You are on page 1of 132

SMS Messages (5) Between Councilmember Dennard and then-City Manager Harry Black

_L • These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

[ # I Folder Time I All limeslanps Slalus I Message l Deleted ]


1 lnbox To 3/16/2018 Read: Read Smart move and thank you
+15134 7:58:16 AM(UTC- 3.'16/2018 Source file:
From 4) 7:58:21 AM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/library/SMS/sms.db :
+12027447026 4) 0x8O50403 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry Black* 220631040 bytes)
Direction:
Incoming
2 Sent From 3/16/2018 Sent Hi! Hope you are doing well! Just to give you a
+1513 7:56:40 AM(UTC- heads up, I won't be in attendance of1he special
To 4) session today. None of us will. We are drafting a
+1202i joint statement of our support of you
Harry Black* Source file:
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0x8O50FEC (Table: message, handle, Size:
Outgoing
220631040 bytes)
3 lnbox To 3/14/2018 Read: Read Absolutely! I am going to issue a statement,
+1513' 2:46:50 PM(UTC- 3.'14/2018 reaffirming my commitment to being CM
From 4) 2:54:45 PM(UTC- Source file:
+1202'. 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Harry Black* 0x8O19782 (Table: message, handle, Size:
220631040 bytes)
Direction:
Incoming
4 Sent From 3/14/2018 Sent You are wanted and needed here.
+1513 2:36:01 PM(UTC- Source file:
To 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1202'. 0x8O18805 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry Black* 220631040 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
5 lnbox To 3/13.'2018 Read: Read The mayor's statement, not mine. Did not give
+1513' 5:27:27 PM(UTC- 3.'13.'2018 him green light to say that. Please let the other
From 4) 5:27:43 PM(UTC- know
+1202" 4) Source file:
Harry Black* iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
0x8CF5FE8 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 220631040 bytes)
Incoming

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_ 001


SMS Messages (31 ) Between Councilmember Seelbach and then-City Manager Harry Black
_L • These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

[ # I Folder Time I All limestanps Slalus I Message I Deleted


1 lnbox From 4/4/2018 Read: Read Are you going g to offer an amendment
+1513! 3:07:59 PM(UTC- 4/412018 Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry Black• 4) 3:16:07 PM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 4) 0xC5CC6F6 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Incoming 342745088 bytes)
2 Sent To 3/28/2018 Sent That you don't support a severance
+1513! 2:47:01 PM(UTC- Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry Black• 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
0xC455FEC (Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 342745088 bytes)
Outgoing
3 Sent To 3/28/2018 Sent Hope you're still planning to say something
+1513_____ __ 2:46:42 PM(UTC- Source file: Chris See bath's
Harry Black• 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC454294 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Outgoing 342745088 bytes)
4 lnbox From 3/28/2018 Read: Read On my way
+1513 1:46:41 PM(UTC- 312812018 Source file: Chris See bath's
Harry Black• 4) 1:46:51 PM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
4) 0xC44E86B (Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 342745088 bytes)
Incoming
5 Sent To 3/28/2018 Sent 30+ speakers. Many in support of you
+1513! 1:43:41 PM(UTC- Source file: Chris See bath's
Harry Black• 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC44DOF4 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Outgoing 342745088 bytes)
6 Sent To 3/28/2018 Sent Would be helpful to have you up here for public
+1513 1:43:30 PM(UTC- comment
Harry l:llacK' 4) Source file: Chris See bath's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC44DFEC (Table: message, handle, Size:
Outgoing 342745088 bytes)
7 Sent To 3/18/2018 Sent And yet, ·!he majority you need is not going to vote
+1513!: 4:06:55 PM(UTC- for anything more than 8 months.
Harry Black• 4) Source file: Chris See bath's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC29E786 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Outgoing 342745088 bytes)
8 lnbox From 3/18/2018 Read: Read Based on all that has transpired, could not accept
+1513! 3:52:43 PM(UTC- 3/1812018 this
Harry Black• 4) 4:06:20 PM(UTC- Source file: Chris See bath's
4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC29E97E (Table: message, handle, Size:
Incoming
342745088 bytes)
9 Sent To 3/18/2018 Sent No one is budging on anything more than 8
+1513!: 3:45:38 PM(UTC- months. Which is the contract you agreed to.
Harry BlacK' 4) Source file: Chris See bath's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC29DDB4 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Outgoing 342745088 bytes)
10 lnbox From 3/18/2018 Read: Read Would be detrimental to me and my family.
+1513! 3:45:00 PM(UTC- 3/1812018 Source file: Chris See bath's
Harry Black• 4) 3:45:06 PM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
4) 0xC29C35B (Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 342745088 bytes)
Incoming
11 Sent To 3/18/2018 Sent Understandable. But majority is as solid as could
+1513! 3:44:12 PM(UTC- be on nothing more than 8 months.
Harry Black• 4) Source file: Chris See bach's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction:
Outgoing 0xC29C9AE (Table: message, handle, Size:
342745088 bytes)
12 lnbox From 3/18/2018 Read: Read Family and future. Thank you
+1513! 3:43:32 PM(UTC- 3/18/2018 Source file: Chris See bath's
Harry Black• 4) 3:43:50 PM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 4) 0xC29COF3 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Incoming 342745088 bytes)
13 Sent To 3/18/2018 Sent Wish you had stuck with us
+1513! 3:41:32 PM(UTC- Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry l:llacK' 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
0xC29B249 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 342745088 bytes)
Outgoing

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_002


14 lnbox From 3/15/2018 Read: Read So untrue
+1513! 9:38:38 PM(UTC- 3/ 15/2018 Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry Black' 4) 938:46 PM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
4) 0xC1 F9FE8 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 342745088 bytes)
Incoming
15 Sent To 3/15/2018 Sent I just received this text from Juech
+1513 9:36 28 PM(UTC- "I was invited to the city managers office today. I
Harry l::!lack' 4) received a call during another meeting I was
leading in my office on a matter of city business. I
Direction: did not volunteer anything.
Outgoing
I was told that the solicitor was right to be
concerned about her job. Then I was asked for a
loyalty pledge to the manager and a letter of
support

When I said that I had to think about that - not


even a yes or no - I was told by the manager that
I had "made clear" where I stand.

I want the record to be very clear. I want there to


be no doubt on the facts of what happened today.

I have told my personal, out of state lawyer all the


same. This is all codified with multiple attorneys
and will be public record ."
Source file: Chris See bach's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
0xC1F8FEC (Table: message, handle, Size:
342745088 bytes)
16 Sent To 3/15/2018 Sent Don't respond to Cranlet
+1513 ___ . --- 9:1912 PM(UTC- Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry Black' 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC1F13D2 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Outgoing 342745088 bytes)
17 lnbox From 3/14/2018 Read: Read Nothing has changed
+1513! 12:21:37 PM(UTC- 3/ 14/2018 Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry Black' 4) 12:21:47 iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
PM(UTC-4) 0xC165D7C {Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 342745088 bytes)
Incoming
18 Sent To 3/14/2018 Sent Has anything changed?
+1513 11 :57:49 AM(UTC- Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry Black' 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC16131E (Table: message, handle, Size:
Outgoing 342745088 bytes)
19 Sent To 3/13/2018 Sent We are letting news outlets know that there are
+151, 5:53:33 PM(UTC- not 5 votes to fire or accept 2 year buyout
Harry Black' 4) Source file: Chris See bach's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC1364FD (Table: message, handle, Size:
Outgoing
342745088 bytes)
20 lnbox From 3/13/2018 Read: Read Yes
+1513! 5:52:57 PM(UTC- 3/ 13/2018 Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry Black' 4) 5 53:01 PM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
4) 0xC13687E (Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 342745088 bytes)
Incoming
21 Sent To 3/13/2018 Sent 100%. are you releasing a statement?
+15131 5:52 22 PM(UTC- Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry Black' 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC136DC6 {Table: message, handle, Size:
Outgoing 342745088 bytes)
22 lnbox From 3/13/2018 Read: Read Statement is fake news
+1513 5:48:33 PM(UTC- 3/ 13/2018 Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry Black' 4) 5 52:04 PM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
4) 0xC135666 {Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 342745088 bytes)
Incoming
23 Sent To 3/13/2018 Sent If you leave or agree to settlement with Cranley, it
+151, 5:43:23 PM(UTC- would just be for 8 months severance.
Harry Black' 4) Source file: Chris See bach's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC135FEC {Table: message, handle, Size:
Outgoing
342745088 bytes)
24 lnbox From 3/13/2018 Read: Read Cool!
+1513! 5:43:17 PM(UTC- 3/ 13/2018 Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry Black' 4) 5 43:17 PM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 4) 0xC13433E (Table: message, handle, Size:
Incoming 342745088 bytes)
25 Sent To 3/13/2018 Sent We've talked to Landsman. He does not support
+1513 5:4249 PM(UTC- firing you OR a buyout We have 5 confinned
Harry Black' 4) votes
Source file: Chris See bach's
Direction: iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Outgoing
0xC13458B (Table: message, handle, Size:
342745088 bytes)
26 lnbox From 3/13/2018 Read: Read I will clarify
+1513 5:18 20 PM(UTC- 3/ 13/2018 Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry Black' 4) 518:28 PM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
4) 0xC12ED72 {Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 342745088 bytes)
Incoming
27 Sent To 3/13/2018 Sent Then you might need to clarify you are not
+1513! 5:17:14 PM(UTC- resigning. Every news outlet running that you are
Harry Black' 4) and asking for comments
Source file: Chris See bach's
Direction: iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Outgoing
0xC12D382 (Table message, handle, Size:
- --
I 11-L.L..
, .. --- --
VI 'i LIL. n, v L./"\l-
342745088 bytes)
- '"-'-r-""-
___
,.. ____
--~
2
28 lnbox From 3/13/2018 Read: Read That's his statement, not mine. He wanted me to
+1513 5:16:05 PM(UTC- 3/13/2018 join, but I declined
Harry Black' 4) 516:09 PM(UTC- Source file: Chris See bach's
4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC12D595 (Table message, handle, Size:
Incoming
342745088 bytes)
29 Sent To 3/13/2018 Sent So you have agreed to leave? Cranley just
+1513 5:05:33 PM(UTC- released a statement saying that
Harry Black' 4) Source file: Chris See bach's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0xC12C967 (Table message, handle, Size:
Outgoing
342745088 bytes)
30 lnbox From 3/13/2018 Read: Read Ok, I will reach out
+1513! 2:21 :47 PM(UTC- 3/13/2018 Source file: Chris See bach's
Harry Black' 4) 2:24:09 PM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
4) 0xC11B2AF {Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 342745088 bytes)
Incoming
31 Sent To 3/13/2018 Sent Let's talk this afternoon. If you're considering
+1513 2:09 18 PM(UTC- taking any kind of buyout and not fighting this
Harry Black' 4) through, I need to know that.
Source file: Chris See bach's
Direction: iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Outgoing
0xC11A669 (Table: message, handle, Size:
342745088 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_004


3
SMS Messages (35) Between Councilmember Sittenfeld and then-City Manager Harry Black
_L • These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

[ # j Folder Time I All limeslanps Slalus I Message Deleted


1 Sent From 3/28/2018 Sent Just keep focused on the wor1c to be done and
+1513 5:36:36 PM(UTC- delivering for the people we serve.
P.G.' 4) Source file: P.G.'s
To iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1202 0x771759D (Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry Black• 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
2 Sent From 3/28/2018 Sent As I said to you, and also directly to him, he will
+15133 5:36:16 PM(UTC- do irrevocable harm to himself in the process.
P.G.' 4) Source file: P.G.'s
To iPhone/var/mobile/library/SMS/sms.db :
+1202: 0x77177FA (Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry Black• 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
3 lnbox To 3/28/2018 Read: Read Absolutely! He stated to the press that he will
+151: 5:34:31 PM(UTC- 3/28/2018 pursue the dossier route (smoke and mirrors)
P.G-♦ 4) 5:35:26 PM(UTC- Soun:efile: P.G.'s
From 4) iPhonetvar/mobile/library/SMS/sms.db :
+1202 0x7717M9 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry Black• 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Incoming
4 Sent To 3/19/2018 Sent And don't want the "public trial"
+1202: 10:38:23 AM(UTC- Soun:e file: P.G.'s
Harry Black• 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
0x754EDDD (Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 220762112 bytes)
Outgoing
5 Sent To 3/19/2018 Sent Apparently, Smitherman and Pastor wouldn't vote
+1202 10:38:13 AM(UTC- for termination
Harry Black• 4) Source file: P.G.'s
Direction: iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Outgoing 0x754EFEC (Table: message, handle, Size:
220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_005


6 Sent From 3/16/2018 Sent March 16, 2018
+1513 2:46:51 PM(UTC-
P.G.• 4)
To Dear Mayor Cranley, City Manager Black,
+1202i Members of the Public, and Members of the
Harry Black' Media:
Direction:
Outgoing We have watched this unfortunate saga unfold in
recent days, and feel strongly that it is now on us
- the Council Majority - to bring order and a fair
process to this situation.

To be clear, anyone who wishes to bring forward


concerns or report misconduct must feel safe and
comfortable doing so. We actively want your voice
to be heard.

We also believe strongly in due process. No one's


name or reputation should be tarnished without
there being clear evidence (beyond just "he said,
she said") as well as a fair opportunity for that
individual to respond.

We share the serious concern of organizations


Ike the Urban League, Community Action
Agency, NAACP, Black Agenda, National Action
Network, Black United Front, and others that
present behavior is rolling back the clock on race
relations in Cincinnati; we will not abet the
intentional denigration of another black leader in
our community.

We also do not support forcing the taxpayers to


pay out of their own pockets for what is currently
a broken relationship. We believe there are much
better immediate next steps.

First, this situation clearly must be de-politicized


and taken out of the hands of those most directly
in the fog of war: Therefore, we are calling for the
appointment of an outside Special Counsel
(appointed by a maj ority of City Council), to
collect and investigate the concerns raised by the
Mayor, any and all counter-factuals from the City
Manager, and testimony from city employees or
any other directly involved stakeholders. This
Special Counsel will then write a report to be
submitted to City Council for our review.

At the same time, we are calling for a ceasefire


between the Mayor and City Manager, during
which they both agree to say nothing more on the
subject and to focus on the City's work. During
this ceasefire, Council will bring in a pro bono
mediator to privately help the Mayor and Manager
navigate their relationship and return to getting
things done for the citizens of Cincinnati. Lastly,
during this ceasefire, we call for no personnel
changes.

Council will control this process as it unfolds, and


if the need and desire for what the Mayor has
called a "public trial' remains, then Council will
control the time, date, and location of such a
special meeting. Because of the significant
interest from concerned members of the
community, such a specially-called meeting would
occur in the evening, be held out in the
community, and be posted with at least two
weeks notice to the public.

We look forward to cool heads prevailing, these


issues being properly addressed, and everyone
getting back to work for the city we love.

Sincerely,

Tamaya Dennard

PG. Sittenfeld

Greg Landsman

Wendell Young

Chris Seelbach
Source file: P G.'s
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
0x7498FEC (Table: message, handle, Size:
220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_006


2
7 Sent From 3/16/2018 Sent Letter to media from Council Majority:
+1513 2:4648 PM(UTC- Source file: P G.'s
P.G.• 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
To 0x7497E3B (Table message, handle, Size
+1202i 220762112 bytes)
Harry Black'
Direction:
Outgoing
8 Sent From 3/13/2018 Sent Chambers very I kely completely packed with your
+151:: 6:50:53 PM(UTC- supporters tomorrow
P.G.• 4) Source file: P.G.'s
To iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1202; 0x7384D22 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry Black' 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
9 lnbox To 3/13/2018 Read: Read Ok, the mayor made statement. I was not a part
+151 3: 5:34:44 PM(UTC- 3/13/2018 of it
P.G.• 4) 5 35:09 PM(UTC- Source file: P G.'s
From 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1202 0x73AFFE8 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry Black' 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Incoming
10 Sent From 3/13/2018 Sent The 5 of us remain together
+151 3: 5:3243 PM(UTC- Source file: P.G.'s
P.G.• 4) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
To 0x73AE518 (Table message, handle, Size
+12027 220762112 bytes)
Harry Black'
Direction:
Outgoing
11 Sent From 3/13/2018 Sent We heard from Greg. Doesn't support firing or
+151 3 5:31 :44 PM(UTC- buyout
P.G.• 4) Source file: P.G.'s
To iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1202 0x73AD42C (Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry Black' 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
12 Sent From 3/12/2018 Sent after that, I don't see any way they can run the
+151 33 4:35:45 PM(UTC- tables on you from there with the other 5
P.G.• 4) Source file: P.G.'s
To iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1202 0x7340853 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry l::!lacl<' 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
13 Sent From 3/12/2018 Sent I believe you will have 4 Councilmembers publicly
+151 3: 4:35:23 PM(UTC- supporting you by tomorrow; zero publicly against
P.G.• 4) Source file: P G.'s
To iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1202 0x7340FEC (Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry Black' 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
14 Sent From 3/12/2018 Sent Btw, I just called the Chief directly, and he
+151 3: 10:11:56 AM(UTC- reiterated to me he is in your comer, and believes
P.G.• 4) that if you go, he'll be the next to go
To Source file: P.G.'s
+12027 iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Harry Black' 0x7318562 (Table: message, handle, Size:
220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
15 Sent From 3/12/2018 Sent Thanks for being conciliatory with Seelbach; if we
+151 3: 8:5740 AM(UTC- can get a quick 3rd and 4th person publicly
P.G.• 4) supportive, while only Smitherman is publicly
To against you on the other side, will be in good
+1202; shape
Harry Black' Source file: P G.'s
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Direction: 0x73114B8 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Outgoing 220762112 bytes)
16 Sent From 3/12/2018 Sent presuming you saw this:
+1513: 8:56:32 AM(UTC- http//www.fox1 9.com/story/37701894/vice-
P.G.• 4) mayor-confidential-info-prompted-mayor-to-ask-
To city-manager-to-resign
+1202i Source file: P G.'s
Harry Black' iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
0x7311AC6 (Table: message, handle, Size:
Direction: 220762112 bytes)
Outgoing
17 lnbox To 3/10/2018 Read: Read Absolutely! Thank you
+151 3 2:58 29 AM(UTC- 3/10/2018 Source file: P.G.'s
P.G.• 5) 8 05:45 AM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
From 5) 0x72CB754 (Table: message, handle, Size:
+1202i 220762112 bytes)
Harry Black'
Direction:
Incoming
18 Sent From 3/10/2018 Sent You won the day across the board, no question. A
+151 3 12:25:55 AM(UTC- remarkable feat frankly. Just need to stitch
P.G.• 5) together a few more of these.
To Source file: P G.'s
+1202; iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Harry Black' 0x72C94B6 (Table: message, handle, Size:
220762112 bytes)
FILED ~ RSEAL Respondent_007
3
19 lnbox To 3/9/2018 Read: Read Absolutely
+1513: 7:05:43 PM(UTC- 3/9/2018 Source file: P G.'s
P.G.• 5) 719:09 PM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
From 5) 0x72C1713 {Table: message, handle, Size:
+1202 220762112 bytes)
Harry Black'
Direction:
Incoming
20 Sent From 3/9/2018 Sent That frame from get Go important
+1513< 6:23 02 PM(UTC- Source file: P G.'s
P.G.• 5) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
To 0x72BDE48 (Table: message, handle, Size:
+1202 220762112 bytes)
Harry Black'
Direction:
Outgoing
21 lnbox To 3/9/2018 Read: Read Agree
+1513, 6:22 21 PM(UTC- 3/9/2018 Source file: P.G.'s
P.G.• 5) 6:22:36 PM(UTC- iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
From 5) 0x72BDFE8 {Table: message, handle, Size:
+1202 220762112 bytes)
Harry Black'
Direction:
Incoming
22 Sent From 3/9/2018 Sent If Cranley throws dirt at you through the Enquirer,
+1513: 6:21:18 PM(UTC- having Chief on record being supportive is great,
P.G.• 5) but I think having Rocky supply a quote from a
To community leader or NAACP accusing of attempt
+1202i to slander you as a black leader is also good,
Harry Black' habit of vengefulness etc
Direction: Source file: P G.'s
Outgoing iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
0x72BC472 (Table: message, handle, Size:
220762112 bytes)
23 Sent From 3/9/2018 Sent And a smear campaign will singe him, not you
+1513 3:33:36 PM(UTC- Source file: P.G.'s
P.G.• 5) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
To 0x72B0DD3 {Table: message, handle, Size:
+12027 220762112 bytes)
Harry Black'
Direction:
Outgoing
24 Sent From 3/9/2018 Sent People mobilizing for you big time. John doesn't
+1513: 3:33 20 PM(UTC- have the votes
P.G.• 5) Source file: P.G.'s
To iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1202; 0x72B0FEC {Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry Black' 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
25 Sent From 3/9/2018 Sent The community and a council majority are with
+1513 3:30:56 PM(UTC- you
P.G.• 5) Source file: P.G.'s
To iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1202 0x72AE408 (Table message, handle, Size
Harry Black' 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
26 Sent From 3/9/2018 Sent Do NOT resign. Can call back in a bit. John
+1513: 3:30 37 PM(UTC- attempting a smear campaign will destroy him
P.G.• 5) Source file: P G.'s
To iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1202 0x72AE651 (Table message, handle, Size
Harry Black' 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
27 lnbox To 3/9/2018 Read: Read Met with Mayor at 2:00. Gave ultimatum that I
+1513 2:53:33 PM(UTC- 3/9/2018 resign or he will initiate a smear campaign against
P.G.• 5) 3:29:07 PM(UTC- me
From 5) Source file: P.G.'s
+1202 iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
Harry Black' 0x72ADC02 {Table: message, handle, Size:
220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Incoming
28 lnbox To 3/9/2018 Read: Read Thank you!
+1513, 11 :00:23 AM(UTC- 3/9/2018 Source file: P G.'s
P.G.• 5) 11:17:55 iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
From AM(UTC-5) 0x72A6A42 (Table message, handle, Size
+1513! 220762112 bytes)
Harry Black'
Direction:
Incoming
29 Sent From 3/9/2018 Sent Like i said, you'll come thru this better than you
+1513 10:27:17 AM(UTC- started.
P.G.• 5) Source file: P.G.'s
To iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1513 0x72A6E3F (Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry Black' 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_ 008


4
30 Sent From 3/9/2018 Sent Sentinels now making calls to Council in support
+1513 10:26:57 AM(UTC- of you as well. Everyone springing to action.
P.G.• 5) Source file: P.G.'s
To iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1513 0x72A532B (Table message, handle, Size
Harry l::!lacl<' 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
31 lnbox To 3/9/2018 Read: Read Spoke with him, but not sure where he is
+1513 9:33 28 AM(UTC- 3/9/2018 Source file: P G.'s
P.G.• 5) 10:2622 iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
From AM(UTC-5) 0x729E28E (Table message, handle, Size
+1513 220762112 bytes)
Harry Black'
Direction:
Incoming
32 Sent From 3/9/2018 Sent Any update on Mann?
+1513 9:30 58 AM(UTC- Source file: P.G.'s
P.G.• 5) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
To 0x729E44E (Table message, handle, Size
+1513 220762112 bytes)
Harry Black'
Direction:
Outgoing
33 Sent From 3/9/2018 Sent I think you'll come thru this in a strengthened
+1513 9:3049 AM(UTC- position
P.G.• 5) Source file: P G.'s
To iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1513 0x729E65B (Table message, handle, Size
Harry Black' 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Outgoing
34 Sent From 3/9/2018 Sent Not going to happen
+1513: 9:27 23 AM(UTC- Source file: P G.'s
P.G.• 5) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
To 0x729D531 (Table: message, handle, Size:
+1513 220762112 bytes)
Harry Black'
Direction:
Outgoing
35 lnbox To 3/9/2018 Read: Read Stanley is meeting with Council members. Trying
+1513 9:26 22 AM(UTC- 3/9/2018 to get 5 votes to take me out
P.G.• 5) 9:27:06 AM(UTC- Source file: P.G.'s
From 5) iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
+1513! 0x729CA3C (Table: message, handle, Size:
Harry Black' 220762112 bytes)
Direction:
Incoming

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_009


5
Chats (1) Among Mayor John Cranley, Councilmember Dennard. Councilmember Landsman, and Councilmember Sittenfeld

...L • These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

iMessage: +1513-

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 3/21/201811 :42:03 AM(UTC-4)


+1513 Last Activity: 3/2112018 11:42:03 AM(UTC-4)
Number of attachments: 0
Source: iMessage: +1513•
Source file: iPhone/var/mc,u11",L1u1d1)'/SMS/sms.db:
... +1513
0xBAF2427 (Table: chat, handle, Size: 220631040
bytes)
Body file: chat-1.txt
John Cranley•

... +1513
P.G. Sittenfeld•

... +151,
Greg Landsman•

...
3121/2018 11:42:03 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncom1ng, +1513L _;P.G: Sittenfeld)
Where did we leave things for today - is the buyout going to be held or get a vote?
status: Read
React 3/21/20 18 I 1:43:31 AM(LfTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x8E09834 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_010


Chats (1} Between Mayor John Cranley and Councilmember Landsman

..L • These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

iMessage: +1513 I)

Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 11/29/2017 2:04:35 PM(UTC-5)


+1513( Last Activity: 11/5/2018 12:56:41 PM(UTC-5)
Number of attachments: 1?
Source: iMessage: +1513
Source file: Gregory Landsman's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x2B2B902
(Table: chat, handle, Size: 50020352 bytes)
+151: Body file: chat-1.txt
John Cranley'

3.1231201811:22:07 AM(UTC-4)Diredion:lncoming, +1513 :John Cranley)


FWIW, you may not want to give Harry less money than what tensing is getting.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/23/2018 11:32:51 AM(lJTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0xD34D6E (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3.12312018 1:18:31 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513! .John Cranley)
FYI, I've already signed a positive letter for harry is severance approved.
status.Read
Read: 3/23/2018 1:29:09 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0xD38FE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
416/2018 8:40:58 PM(UTC-4)Diredion:lncoming, +151~ [John Cranley)
FYI, Harry's email of 7:16pm is textbook retaliation--attacking her professionalism for doing her job--btw, the opinion represents the office,
not just her. As a lawyer, their analysis is spot on. Council can give Harry money for his own lawyer if a public purpose (it is not). or can just
give him a bonus (bad idea but legal). Not sure why he's mad--his interests are better served by a personal lawyer that council can give him
money to pay for. I think it's nuts but clear path forward outlined.
status.Read
Read: 4/6/2018 8:41 :06 PM(lJTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhoneivar/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0xE5FFE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_011


Chats (1} Between Mayor John Cranley and Councilmember Sittenfeld
...L • These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

iMessage: +1513 (1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 12/15/2014 12:16:29 PM(UTC-5)


+1513: Last Activity: 11/25/2018 3:53:56 PM(UTC-5)
P.G.' (owner) Number of attachments: 1 •
Source: iMessage: +1513,
Source file: P.G .'s
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0xB9157DD
(Table: chat, handle, Size: 220762112 bytes)
+1513! Body file: chat-1.txt
John Cranley'

3126/2018 1:49:18 PM(lJTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513! (John Cranley)


Mann told me you mentioned to him that you trusted George Vincent as a special counsel. True?
status: Read
DellVered: 3/26/2018 1:50:14 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/26/2018 1 50:"14 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x76B7FDC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3126/2018 1:51:27 PM(lJTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.}
I think very highly of George, but also think he may well start to enmeshed in too many relationships for this particular situation. I suppose.
though, it depends somewhat on who he was partnered with
status. Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobilellibrary/SMS/sms.db: 0x76B7814 (Table: message, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3126/2018 1:55:15 PM(lJTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513: (P.G_)
I'm also somewhat resistant to firms that do direct business with the city.
status. Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x76B74AE (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3126/2018 1:55:45 PM(lJTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513, (P.G.}
What would you think of Blank Rome? (Judge Jones+ Cioffi and/or Curp}
status. Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x76B8FEC (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3126/2018 1:56:01 PM(lJTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (John Cranley)
No connections to curp
status.Read
Dellvered: 3/26/2018 t :56:02 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/26/2018 1 56:02 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x76B8D7E (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3126/20181:56:19 PM(lJTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.}
okay, keep me posted on other possible ideas
status: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x76B8B87 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3126/2018 1:56:50 PM(lJTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513! (John Cranley)
Ok Will do.
status: Read
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/ mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x76B898C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3127/2018 1:12:12 PM(lJTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513! (John Cranley)
Let's talk special counsel
status: Read
Dellvered: 3/27/2018 4:34:58 PM(UTC-4)
React 3/27/2018 4.34:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x76E179D (Table: message, handle, chat, S ize: 220762112 bytes)
3.l30/201811:33:36AM(UTC-4)Diredion:Outgoing, +1513 :P.G.)
Tamaya expressed willingness and inclination to do it, though wants to think on it. David said he understands necessity of them doing it as a
team. David going to reach out directly to Tamaya.
status. Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x774DDBD (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_012


3/30/2018 11 :34:26 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 ;P.G.)
I think them as a team steering the process would give council and the community less heartburn than almost any other option, frankly. we'll
see where they land.
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x774DA35 (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
4/6/2018 7:51 :35 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513l __ . _____John Cranley)
FYI, Harry's email of 7:16pm is textbook retaliation--attacking her professionalism for doing her job--btw, the opinion represents the office,
not just her. As a lawyer, their analysis is spot on. Council can give Harry money for his own lawyer if a public purpose (it is not), or can just
give him a bonus (bad idea but legal). Not sure why he's mad--his interests are better served by a personal lawyer that council can give him
money to pay for. I think it's nuts but clear path forward outlined.
S1atus:Read
Reacl: 4/612018 8:31 08 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7932097 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
4/8/2018 9:09:56 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513: (P.G.)
Understood. You know my natural inclination is always toward collaboration and getting things done. I'm not hesitant to disagree, and tone
matters a lot to me too as you know - but absolutely I'd always rather be part of a team that's making progress.
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 4/8/2018 909 57 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7989FE4 (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
4/9/2018 6:06:35 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 :John Cranley)
Hold off on talking to Harry. Speaking to ethics today. Will report back.
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 4/9/2018 6 58:34 AM(UTC-4)
Read: 4/9/2018 6:58 34 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox798DFDC (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
4/9/2018 6:58:38 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 IP.G.)
got it
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x798DAB4 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_013


2
Chats (1} Among Councilmembers Dennard, Landsman. Seelbach. and Sittenfeld

...L • These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

iMessage: +1513, (1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 12/5/2017 4:53:40 PM{UTC-5)


+1513 Last Activity: 4/25/2018 2:14 :57 PM(UTC-4)
Number of attachments: 7
Source: iMessage: +1513
Source file: iPhone/var/moo11e1uorary/SMS/sms.db :

... +1513
0xBAD876B (Table: chat, handle, Size: 220631040
bytes)
Body file: chat-1.txt
Chris Seelbach'

... +151,
P.G. Sittenfeld'

... +151,
Greg Landsman•

...
419121)18 11:33:02 AM(lJTC-4)0irection:lncoma,g, +1513 :chris Seelbach)
So what's happening with Black and attorney? Is anyone preparing an ordinance to pay for his attorney? Are we just letting Solicitor's memo
stand ... and Black can either hire his own attorney or not?
status· Read
Reacl: 4/9/2018 12 10:57 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x9083FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_014


Among Councilmembers Dennard. Landsman. Seelbach. Sittenfeld, and Young
Chats (1)
...L • These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

iMessage: +1513 ,1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 1/19/2018 12:07:01 PM(UTC-5)


+1513 Last Activity: 3/24/2018 5:16:13 PM(UTC-4)
Number of attachments: 11
Source: iMessage: +1513•
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
OxBAE2F96 (Table: chat, handle, Size: 220631040
bytes)
Body file: chat-1.txt
+1513
Wendell Young•

+1513
Chris Seelbach•

+1513
P.G. Sittenfeld•

+151,
Greg Landsman•

3112/2018 4:01:15 PM(l1TC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)


Had good meeting with Harry this morning.
S1alus: Read
Reac!: 3/12/2018 401:57 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8CAEFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3112/2018 4:02:39 PM(l1TC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513
That's awesome. What did you talk about?
stal\Js. Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8CAE8A1 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3112/2018 4:04:06 PM(l1Tc:4)0irection:lncoming, +1513-. - ---- (Chris Seelbach)
My issues with him. Especially responsible bidder. That I've worked on it for almost 6 years, I've made compromise after compromise when
the other side wouldn't given an inch. Had 1,000 meetings. And then he goes last week and testifies for hours about it will basically bankrupt
the city and prevent all AA people from getting work ....without even talking to me. And also his lack of any kind of leadership on fixing the
streetcar.
stahJs.Read
Reac!: 31·1212018 4 04:07 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8CAFFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3112/2018 4:04:39 PM(l1TC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
But he agreed to specific things on both fronts, in addition to restarting our relationship.
stahJs.Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4 08:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobi le/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8CAF349 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3112/2018 4:04:53 PM(ITTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513_ _ .P.G_ Sittenfeld)
Loved "But he agreed to specific things on both fronts, in addition to restarting our relationship."
status: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4 08:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8CBOF02 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3112/2018 4:04:56 PM(l1TC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513~ (Chris Seelbach)
in exchange for me not voting to fire him!
S1atus: Read
Read:3/12/2018408:31 PM(UTC-4l .
Source file: iPhof J ~ bliJ.tJt!J; & § ? ~ : Ox8CBOC78 (Table: ,,,c:.:.aye , 11drfOle, cnat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
Respondent_015
3/12/2018 4:05:42 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seelbach)
and late night, not sober phone calls. Which I know others have talked to him about as well.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4 08:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB085D (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:07:16 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 [Wendell Young)
This is great! Glad you talked with Harry.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4 08:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB05B9 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:08:04 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513: Chris Seelbach)
He agreed to support responsible bidder with my fixes. And to include, in his budget, signal prioritization and making the streetcar free. And I
have those promises in writing.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4 08:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB03B0 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:08:13 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 ____ __ . (P.G. Sittenfeld)
me too. and a re-set sounds good. we all know this, but some smear job is coming ...
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4 08:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB1 FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:08:49 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513' .Wendell Young)
This is even better news. Go Chris!
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:19:35 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB1 D40 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:10:24 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513' .Wendell Young)
We need to be ready for the smear campaign, which has already begun. You saw Sherri's hit-piece in the paper today.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:19:35 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB1 B45 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:12:24 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513: P.G. Sittenfeld)
Wendell, as you said in your comments, highlighting that there's room for improvement and we'll be expecting it - but also calling out a
smear for what it is, and not indulging it.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:19:35 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB15AD (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:14:15 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513_ _ _,(Wendell Young)
Thanks. Glad we're on the same page. This is going to be a slug fest. We need to stick together.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:19:35 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB2FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:17:12 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513.~ _ _JChris Seelbach)
And I agree with Greg that we need to put goals in place that we can hold him accountable to.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:19:35 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB2D5C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:18:50 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513' (Wendell Young)
We need to convene the Rules Committee to formalize these things.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:19:35 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB2AB6 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:19:13 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
I can't see Greg's comments.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:19:35 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB287E (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:20:26 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
He's in Israel, but when we talked yesterday, he mentioned putting in place specific goals for Harry.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:23:19 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB2691 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:21:08 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
Thanks.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:23:19 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB3FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:22:06 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 [P.G. Sittenfeld)
Wendell, also, I agree with the sentiment that rather than some trial style format where people are called up one by one to smear Harry, any
grievances from John should be submitted as a written document, and Council can then proceed to handle on its own timeline and as it sees
fit. But no more of this crap where due process if thrown out the window .
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:23:19 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB3EOD (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_016


2
3/12/2018 4:22:52 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513' (Wendell Young)
Absolutely!
S1atus: Read
React 3/12/2018 4:23:19 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB3955 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:24:06 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
But how can we control that if he does this through a committee one of you don't chair?
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:28:17 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB378A (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:24:45 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
all of us won't be there in that case
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:28:17 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB34EC {Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:25:21 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513:._ _ __ • jP.G. Sittenfeld)
so I think it'll seem slanted. I'm talking about not using Full Council as a forum for some Soviet style trial
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:28:17 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB4FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:26:54 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513'_ _ _,IWendell Young)
A written document isn't a motion. We handle as we see fit. I agree we don't want to hold Kangaroo Court. I think we attend that committee
meeting and organize dissent that shows what is going on .
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:28:17 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB4D00 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:28:05 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 :Wendell Young)
Meant to say if Cranley's document comes in the form of a motion we attend the committee meeting ......
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:28:17 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB49BC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:28:49 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513' .Wendell Young)
We could also move for immediate consideration at council and vote it down.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:28:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB4738 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:33:38 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 P.G. Sittenfeld)
that's very interesting idea
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:33:38 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB44EC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:34:11 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513~ ,Chris Seelbach)
Need 6 votes for that
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:34:11 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB42C5 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:34:17 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 [P.G. Sittenfeld)
good point
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:34:18 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB5FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 4:35:19 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513. Wendell Young)
If we pull David, we may have six.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/12/2018 4:35:20 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB5DD1 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 5:29:33 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
Just thinking; we have Dennard, Seelbach, Sittenfeld, Landsman, Pastor, and me. Correct?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 5:40:51 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CB5BD8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 6:34:12 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513'
Sounds right to me
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8CB9A18 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631 040 bytes)
3/12/2018 6:37:42 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Cranley told me tonight he has Pastor as long as he's in majority.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 6:37:55 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CBAFD2 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 6:38:06 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513
Wow ...smh
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8CBAA9B (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_017


3
3/12/2018 6:39:25 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 __[Wendell Young)
I don't believe it. Pastor told me last night he is w ith us.
S1atus: Read
React 3/12/2018 6:39:38 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CBBFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size• 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 6:40:36 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513, (Chris Seelbach)
Maybe Cranley is overplaying his hand. But he told me pastor would vote to fire as long as he's in majority. But please don't tell pastor that.
Last thing I want is MORE drama
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 6:42:27 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CBDFD2 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 6:42:50 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 ___ _
I won't say anything
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CBDCBE (Table: message, chat, Size• 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 6:46:14 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
But told me smitherman, Murray and Mann are definite yes to fire
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/12/2018 6 53:48 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CBD8A7 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/12/2018 7:27:41 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 . _ ____(Wendell Young)
I won't say anything either but we know Cranley doesn't mind lying about anything.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/12/2018 7:33:13 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CBFFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 4:01:55 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Greg, just keeping you posted: Chris, Wendell, T, and I do NOT support buyout for Harry.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 4 02:08 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CEB3CF (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 4:03:17 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
And AA community & leadership is outraged at prospect of buyout & force out
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 4 03:35 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CECFD2 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 4:04:17 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513
Just so you know , I spoke with John and he said the buyout was to help with the racial tension. I told him that was insulting
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CEC9FC (Table• message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 4:06:05 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
Harry 100% does not want the buyout. But needs assurance that he has 5 votes not only against firing him. But also against voting for
buyout.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/13/2018 4 06:17 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CEC74C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:11:52 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +15131
What the hell is going on?
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF05F5 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:13:19 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513' Wendell Young)
In an interview with news will get back to you.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 5:13:26 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF2FD2 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:16:00 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: ]Chris Seelbach)
We left meeting with Manager with understanding that he was not resigning. Left meeting with Cranley with understanding that he is doing a
pull court press on our friend Greg Landsman. Told us he has every union, David Pepper, etc reaching out to get him on board with Cranley.
:(
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/13/2018 521:10 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF3FD2 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:23:27 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +15131
Vanessa just said that's not true
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF453A (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:28:24 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Vanessa told me same: Greg doesn't support firing or buyout
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/13/2018 528:40 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF506F (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_018


4
13/13/2018 5:28:57 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513

IMG 5619.PNG
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF5B41 (Table: message, chat, attachment, Size 220631040 bytes)
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/Attachments/33/03/3FF1 F344-03C0-4C3B-A079-2A5105AF19EC/IMG_5619.PNG : (Size: 108146 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:30:36 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +151 (Chris Seelbach)

---
IMG 1912.jpeg
S1atus:Read
React 3/13/2018 5•30:40 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF5936 (Table: message, handle, chat, attachment, Size: 220631040 bytes)
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/Attachments/1e/1 4/1 05E90BC-F608-4C5F-B995-C9C92C3FE78D/IMG_1912.jpeg : (Size 262508 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:30:42 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Liked "Vanessa told me same: Greg doesn't support firing or buyout •
S1atus:Read
React 3/13/2018 5•30:43 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF5623 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size• 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:31:02 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 !Chris Seelbach)
Assuming that's true, we need to let Harry know there are 5 votes against buyout
S1atus: Read
React 3/13/2018 5•31:04 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF53O8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:31:22 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +151: (P.G. Siltenfeld)
I'll tell him
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/13/2018 5•31:23 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF6FD2 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:31:47 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
I'll let Sherri know . 100% certain on Greg?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 5:46:30 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF6C38 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:40:13 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +15131 (Wendell Young)
Harry has not taken the buyout.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 5:46:30 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF63O6 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

IJust got back to hotel and emailed John confirming my position against firing CM or a buyout. Now , because it's almost midnight, I'm signing
3/13/2018 5:40:23 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 ]Greg Landsman)

off and going to bed.


S1atus: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 5:46:30 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF7FD2 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:40:34 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1511 (Chris Seelbach)
thanks Greg. Night.
1
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/13/2018 5:46:30 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF7CD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:41:20 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +151~ (Wendell Young)
Thanks Greg.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 5:46:30 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8CF7AC1 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 6:59:19 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +15131 (P.G. Siltenfeld)
I spoke with Wendell and we're in agreement that we can't just let John commence Kangaroo Court against Harry however he once - but we
obviously also need to give employees who want to share their testimony a way to share it.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/14/2018 7 01:13 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O255A0 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 6:59:53 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +15131 Chris Seelbach)
Any idea how Cranley wants to do this? In a committee?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 7 01:13 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O26FD2 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_019


5
3/14/2018 7:00:18 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Wendell talked about a letter we'd all sign? Anyway, I think we all need to hop on a joint conference call tomorrow or Friday to talk it through,
and an overall strategy
S1atus: Read
React 3/14/2018 7 01:13 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O26OB1 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:00:31 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513i (Chris Seelbach)
Ok
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/14/2018 7 01:13 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O26444 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:07:39 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 __ _ ·-· (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Chris, Wendell, Tamaya - could you all do a call at 3pm tomorrow? or anytime Friday in the afternoon?
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/14/2018 7 07:45 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O27FD2 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:07:54 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +151:; [Chris Seelbach)
I can do either
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 7 08:18 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O273B7 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:08:41 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 P.G. Sittenfeld)
cool. Wendell? T?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 7 08:42 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O28FD2 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:08:55 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513'
I can't do tomorrow but I can do Friday between 1 and 3
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O28DC9 (Table: message, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:09:32 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513.--~ ·~ · (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Thanks. Wendell, could you do a group conference call Friday sometime between 1-3pm?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 7:10:18 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O29FD2 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:26:05 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +151, (Wendell Young)
Yes.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/14/2018 7:26:16 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O293B9 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:31:10 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Great, let's do 1 :30pm. I'll send a calendar invite to your personal emails and circulate a conference line
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 7:31:27 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O2AFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:31:37 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513'
Thank you!
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O2A940 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:32:16 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513' (Wendell Young)
Please send me a text. Having trouble with e-mail.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 7:34:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O2A779 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:32:43 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 ,P.G. Sittenfeld)
Will do Wendell. Everyone bring their ideas for navigating this process. Also, I think better if it's just us - not our aides on the line for this call
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 7:34:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O2A560 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:33:34 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
Agree.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/14/2018 7:34:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O2A23E (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 7:35:15 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513
Got it
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O2BFD6 (Table: message, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/15/2018 5:34:36 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 Greg Landsman)
I could do this (7:30PM my time). BUT, we can't have five people on a call without breaking sunshine rules, no? Just let me know.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/15/2018 5•35:17 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O2CFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_020


6
3/1512018 7:07:18 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513_ _~ (, P.G. Sittenfeld)
Greg, I'll ask John Curp on sunshine and loop back ASAP
S1atus: Read
React 3/15/2018 7:11:02 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O2C94A (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/1512018 10:21:01 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seebach)
FYI. In Cranley's meeting with Enquirer editorial ooara ne attacked PG for "threatening CODE president, suggesting employees not come
forward because Black will remain manager." It's 100% not true. But interesting that Cranley is now coming after us.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/15/2018 10:55 06 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O2F525 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/1512018 10:21:44 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513' - _--'P.G. Sittenfeld)
I spoke with Chris Jenkins from CODE a few minutes ago and he said it's 100% not true. John is resorting to some truly outrageous tactics
here
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/15/2018 10:55 06 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O30FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/1512018 10:22:39 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 :chris Seebach)
Smitherman just called a special meeting of law and public safety tomorrow at 10:30 to take action on a "whistleblower protection
ordinance."
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/15/2018 10:55 06 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O30CC2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/1512018 10:27:46 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seebach)
And a special meeting of Council at 10:45am tomorrow. Which I won't be able to attend.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/15/2018 10:55 06 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O31 FD2 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/1512018 10:45:20 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513i (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Harry going after Unions here a bit w/ the Ed Board, in a way that's not good
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/15/2018 10:55 06 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O31808 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/1512018 12:16:45 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
Explain about Harry please or call me. Thanks.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/15/201812:4904 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O39866 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 11 :55:20 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513_ ____ . (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Just emailed you all first draft of a letter incorporating people's ideas
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 11:5553 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O597A8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 11 :55:33 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +151 ~ (P. G. Sittenfeld)
here is the conference line for 1:30pm today:
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 11:5553 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O5AFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/201811:57:32AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513< (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Dial in number: 563-999-1106
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 11 :58 15 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O5BFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 11 :57:42 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 [P.G. Sittenfeld)
Access code: 819666
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 11 :58 15 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O589CA (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 11 :57:48 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Pin (if needed): 1619
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 11 :58 15 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O58485 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 11 :57:52 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513: (Chris Seebach)
1pm?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 11 :58 15 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O5CFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 11 :57:56 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
1:30pm
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/161201811:5815AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O5CAC0 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size• 220631040 bytes)
3/16/201811:58:11 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seebach)
Ok
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 11 :58 15 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhof i e t ~bl!J.lJl@ili&.1SmAtt> • 0x8O5DFD2 (Table: ~ <aB?tt~khat, Size 220631040 bytes) Respondent_021
7
3/16/2018 12:01:14 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513' (Wendell Young)
Got it. Thanks.
S1atus:Read
React 3/1612018 12:08 07 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O5O89E (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 12:17:33 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (Greg Landsman)
Wendell, are you around for a quick call? Tried your cell but it went to VM. Thanks, friend.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/161201812:2246 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O5EFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 12:17:52 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513' Nendell Young)
Yes. Call now.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/161201812:2246 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O5ED62 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 12:18:01 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +151~ Greg Landsman)
Liked "Yes. Call now."
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/161201812:2246 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O5EB1B (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:28:13 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 [P.G. Sittenfeld)
Here's the call-in info one more time; talk to everyone in 2 minutes
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 1:30:08 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O5E441 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:28:14 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Dial in number: 563-999-1106
Access code: 819666
Pin (if needed): 1619
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 1:30:08 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O5FFD2 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:31:53 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: [P.G. Sittenfeld)
You hopping on, Wendell?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/16120181:43:47 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O5F85F (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:32:19 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513' (Wendell Young)
Not yet. Can't get through. Trying again.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 1:43:47 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O5F644 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:33:38 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 Wendell Young)
No answer. 563-999-1106?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 1:43:47 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O60FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:33:50 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
yes
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 1:43:47 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O60A65 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:33:55 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
yup. that worked for me
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/16120181:43:47 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O60874 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:35:08 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
Trying again.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 1:43:47 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O6065B (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:35:23 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
if it doesn't work, I'll call you Wendell and thread you in
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 1:43:47 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O6048C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:36:01 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +15131_ _ _,(Wendell Young)
Not working. Please call me. Call me at: 961-1176.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 1:43:47 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O61FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:45:17 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 _Chris Seelbach)
Hey Greg. I dropped off the call. I think you need to be on there more than me. Can you please call in ASAP?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 1:49:02 PM(UTC-4)
0x8O61A49 (Table: rn at, Size 220631040 bytes)
Source file: iPhoFILEDb~ /~ ~E'~MSEAL :
Respondent_022
8
3/16/2018 1:48:50 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Greg, able to call-in?
S1atus: Read
React 3/1612018 1:49:02 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O61785 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:49:50 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513! [Chris Seelbach)
he's not getting texts. But just called him and he's calling in
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/16120181 50:18 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O6156E (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:50:09 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513£ (Greg Landsman)
Calling in now ...
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 1 50:18 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O612FC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:09:50 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: [P.G. Sittenfeld)
Will send updated letter in 1O minutes tops
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:11:16 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O6377A (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:10:03 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +15133 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
please hold tight to review quickly, and send feedback or say "Approved"
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:11:16 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O63539 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:10:30 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Ok
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:11:16 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O632B5 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:10:50 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +151~ (Wendell Young)
Ok
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:11:16 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O64FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:13:31 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
How are we releasing to mayor and public?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:14:12 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O64E19 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:13:56 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513L ___ __, (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Tara from Tamaya's office is going to send out from Tara's email account to the normal full press list
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:14:12 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O64C10 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:14:14 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Ok. And we can post to our own social media?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:14:16 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O6494E (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:14:22 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513, (P.G. Sittenfeld)
fine by me ...
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:14:26 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x8O64741 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:14:31 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513
That's a good idea
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O64540 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:19:31 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 [Wendell Young)
This is all good.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:23:23 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O65DA8 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:21:33 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Just sent revised letter. Reply with word changes or with "Approved"
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:23:23 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O65BO1 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:22:51 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +151:; .Wendell Young)
Just got a call from Harry's lawyer and then from Harry regarding their being told by John that I am the fifth vote on a separation package for
Harry. I haven't spoken to that little sucker! He just flat out lied to Garry and his lawyer. Is it too late to insert into the letter something making
it clear that"we" do not support a buy-out for Harry?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:23:23 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O65955 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_023


9
3/16/2018 2:23:19 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: [P.G. Sittenfeld)
that language is in the letter I sent you all
S1atus:Read
React 3/1612018 2:23:23 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox80654E1 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:23:35 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Approved
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:23:36 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox806529C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:23:54 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513
Approved.
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox80flflFOfl /Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:24:00 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Approved.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:24:03 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8066EOF (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:24:15 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
Approved.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:24:20 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8066C10 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:26:43 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +15131 Wendell Young)
Just noticed we didn't include the Black Agenda, NAN, The Black United Front
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:27:00 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8066A49 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:26:51 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +15133 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
will add those in
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:27:00 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox80667FB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:26:53 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513, iP.G. Sittenfeld)
Greg?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:27:00 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox80665EE (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:31:21 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +15131 [P.G. Sittenfeld)
T, once we hear from Greg, I'm sure you've got mis aiready on your media list, but just make sure it goes to all 4 TV stations; Wetterich;
Coolidge; Jason Williams; Mark Curnutte; Jay Hanselman; Paula Christian & Amanda; Nick Swartell; and Kevin Aldridge
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:31:32 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox80663F9 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:31:36 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +15131 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
am I forgetting any other biggest?
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:31:37 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8067FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:31:43 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513! [P.G. Sittenfeld)
•biggees?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:31:43 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8067DA3 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:31:52 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513l [Chris Seelbach)
no answer from Greg's cell
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:31:53 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8067BA6 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:32:54 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513'
In addition to the TV stations, we will include individual reporters as well
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8067987 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:33:04 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)

S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:33:06 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8067739 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:33:56 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
Don't forget Lincoln Ware and the Herald.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:34:03 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8067574 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_024


10
3/16/2018 2:34:14 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Great call!
S1atus: Read
React 3/1612018 2:34: 19 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O68FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:34:32 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513i
Good call! We had the herald but not Lincoln
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O68E0B (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:34:55 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Tamaya, I'll send you FINAL FINAL copy as soon as we hear from Greg
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:39:52 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O68BFE (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:39:08 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Greg Landsman)
Looks good to me.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:39:52 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O68988 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:39:22 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513J (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Bravo everyone!
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:39:52 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O687AF /Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:40:14 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +151J
Awesome. I will give Tara the go ahead.
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8f)fiR!'>AA (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:40:15 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Courage, clarity, firmness, reasonableness!
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:40:36 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O683A7 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:40:26 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513, (P.G. Sittenfeld)
T, I just emailed you both the final content
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:40:36 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O69FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:40:38 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 .Wendell Young)
Good. Mann's office is asking for the "press release." Loi
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:40:48 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O69O8F (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:40:42 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
will send to whole group so people can use on social media too
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:40:48 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O69B65 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:40:50 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +15134 (Wendell Young)
Great!
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:40:53 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O698FD (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:41:05 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513i
Thank you
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O69740 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:41:33 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1511 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
should we all post concurrently on our FB?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:42:20 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O69579 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:42:02 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513, (P.G. Sittenfeld)
let me know ...?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:42:20 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O6933A (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:42:32 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513_ _ _,(Wendell Young)
I think social media posting is fine.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:45:12 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O6AFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:42:41 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513, P.G. Sittenfeld)
Doing so now ...
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 ~ F t-P~(4TFdh
Source file: iPhoheY ~b~ ~ M ~~§~Jio : 0x8O6ADD3 (Table: 111 ,1at, Size: 220631040 bytes)
Respondent_025
11
3/16/2018 2:42:45 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513, P.G. Sittenfeld)
T, you are too?
S1atus:Read
React 3/1612018 2:45:12 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O6ABCA (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:45:18 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513
Absolutely
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O6A5E8 (Table• message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:54:28 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 P.G. Sittenfeld)
Team, I knew there was one thing I meant to bring up that I forgot to on the call. 4 of us at a time need to have a conversation with Harry
about things he needs to do to improve. I've overtly told him I believe he needs to seek some sort of counseling. But he needs to hear it
collectively from us, and to frankly understand that his job depends on correcting certain things.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2 54:46 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O68955 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:54:44 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
should we schedule a meeting with him for next week - with all of us minus Chris, who will be OOT?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2 54:46 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O6846F (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:56:37 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +151: [Wendell Young)
Not now please. I think he would view this as a softening of support. May I suggest we reserve that conversation for after we get through this
process?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2 57:34 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O6CDF3 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:57:50 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 ,P.G. Sittenfeld)
Wendell, I'm okay waiting if the others agree. HOWEVER, it's a conversation that must be had - sooner rather than later. Harry struggles
with some things and needs to know we support him, but also bring certain expectations. I'll defer to the group on timing.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2 59:15 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O6CB09 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 3:00:15 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513' (Wendell Young)
I too will abide by what the group decides. For me there is the recognition that Harry is under an enormous amount of pressure. I worry that
he would view the conversation as us piling on. The timing isn't good.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 3 03:53 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O6C705 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 3:46:14 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513' .P.G. Sittenfeld)
Separate FYI: the #2 at the Sentinels just called me and asked that I pass this along: she and Lou Arnold just had a meeting with John,
where she said John tried to divide and conquer the Sentinels from the other African-American groups, and also intentionally misrepresented
the Manager's position. Not for public consumption, but she asked that you all be notified.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 3:47:00 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O7BD5A (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 3:47:45 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513
Divide and conquer is his thing. He tried to do that to me twice this week
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O78884 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 3:55:17 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513' :Wendell Young)
You saw that on a larger scale during the Respons10Ie i,idder wrangling. He tried to pit the Urban League, Ministers Alliance, CAA, and
others against the NAACP, The Black Agenda, and more. Typical Cranley tactic. Don't forget that he will lie in a heart beat.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 3 56:43 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O7CFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:06:59 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513: [P.G. Sittenfeld)
https://www.cincinnati.com/story/opinion/2018/03/16/opinion-cranley-black-somebody-has-go/429452002/
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 6 09:02 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O8572C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes )
3/16/2018 6:10:29 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513i
I spoke with Joe Mallory a little while ago. He saI0 l,;ramey reached out to him and said I was the one that flipped
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O853E5 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:11:00 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 !Chris Seelbach)
Pastor keeps saying "someone fl ipped"
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/16120186:11 :16 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O86FD2 /Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:12:15 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513'
They also said Wendell was the 5th vote earlier
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O86DD7 (Table: message, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_026


12
3/16/2018 6:12:42 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513
I told Joe they are reaching
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O86BC8 (Table message, chat, Size• 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:12:53 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 jChris Seelbach)
I think we're very strong. Which I've been waiting for. For years.
S1atus: Read
React 3/1612018 6:12:55 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O869DB (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:13:27 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +15133 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Weird of Cranley to say that to Joe. Joe loathes John and is very against any buyout
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 6:13:32 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O8679F (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:14:09 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Chris, this coalition is our wedding gift to you and Craig
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 6:14:11 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O8653F (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:14:35 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +151:
That's what Joe said. He was confused by it. But divide and conquer is John's thing. It's all unfortunate.
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O8630F (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:14:56 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
Liked "Chris, this coalition is our wedding gift to you and Craig "
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 6:16:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O87F02 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:15:51 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513< Nendell Young)
Amen! We're the new "gang of five." I pray we stay strong and continue to trust each other. We have the power to move this forward.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 6:16:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O87CB5 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:16:33 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
I'm currently driving but also got some good insight about the financial piece of appointing special counsel. All feels very doable.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 6:16:44 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O879F5 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:16:48 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
Meant to say; Move the city forward.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 6:16:51 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O8772D (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:17:09 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
I'm game to make it a gang of 7 even! I know mann and Pastor must be lonely over there!
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 6:20:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O87530 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:17:15 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +151:: (Wendell Young)
Good news. Please share when you can.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1612018 6:20:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O872C6 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:18:03 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513' [Wendell Young)
I think maybe Mann more than Pastor.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 6:20:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O88FD2 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:18:43 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513: .Chris Seelbach)
I hate to be cynical. And i hope I'm wrong. But I don't think either of them will cross cranley on big things
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 6:20:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O88DD5 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/16/2018 6:19:36 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
You're not cynical. You're probably right. I'm just keeping hope alive. Loi
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 6:20:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8O88B45 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/17/2018 4:44:13 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Supposedly Harry has accepted an 18 month buyout and may force a vote of Council. Just so everyone know , I am 100% a no against any
buyout.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/17/2018 4:45:17 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DA4A9B (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_027


13
3/17/2018 4:45:31 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
I am also a firm No. I'm not looting the taxpayers because John is threatening a smear campaign. That's holding both Harry and the
taxpayers hostage.
S1atus: Read
React 3/17/2018 4 50:34 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DA4795 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/17/2018 4:46:16 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 P.G. Sittenfeld)
This whole thing disgusts me at many levels.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/17/2018 4 50:34 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DA427F (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/17/2018 4:47:14 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513_ ,__ ___ ,Chris Seelbach)
And I really hope we can stay strong as the majority. If not, they will know who they can pick off the next 4 years.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/17/2018 4 50:34 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DA59ED (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/17/2018 5:06:46 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
I will not vote for a buyout. I'm firm! Harry gets what his contract calls for. Nothing more.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/17/2018 5:32:06 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DA6ADE (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/17/2018 5:07:12 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +151J .Wendell Young)
The police chief is next. Watch.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/17/2018 5:32:06 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DA686E (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 12:58:52 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (Greg Landsman)
Agree. Sorry, was asleep. Israel time. Get back Tuesday evening.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2 01:06 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8OAFn::ir. (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 9:51:38 AM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
We should probably release some kind of statement in response to yesterday's news, reaffirming the majority of Council does not support a
buyout. Everyone agree? PG could you draft something?
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/18/2018 9 51:52 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8OB0672 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 9:56:32 AM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513~ (P.G. Sittenfeld)
If the group wants that, I could draft something later today. Just me know .
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 9 58:05 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DR1 Fn? IT;able: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 11 :33:43 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 Yendell Young)
Ok with me.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 11 :3411 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8OB43FD (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 1:20:54 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513: ;Chris Seelbach)
Is everyone good with this? Or have changes? "If the Manager wishes to move on from his current role, we respect that decision. But the
Council Majority remains firm that we are not signing off on paying someone extra to not do their job. That is neither fair nor responsible to
the taxpayers.

Moreover, it is our understanding that, in fact, the Manager does enjoy his job; he simply doesn't like the idea of serving under the looming
threat of a smear campaign. That, too, is understandable.

But asking the taxpayers to provide significant resources in order to avoid the impact of such a smear campaign would set a dangerous
precedent and enable behavior which we do not approve of.

We reiterate our call for a ceasefire, and we remain committed to the thoughtful, fair, transparent next steps we have previously laid out.

We believe in the City Charter, we believe in honesty, and we believe in collaboration. All are welcome to join us in upholding these pillars."
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 1:21:03 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8OB7FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 1:21:47 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Just respond "agreed" if you're good with it
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 1:33:18 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8OB7672 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 1:21:59 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 P.G. Sittenfeld)
Agreed
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 1:33:18 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8OB7465 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/18/20181:50:00 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513' (Wendell Young)
Agreed.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 1 51:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhoFfl'...ffl~ "N'r,e'pt1~~Af : 0x8OB8C08 (Table ~ ~oo~at, Size: 220631040 bytes) Respondent_028
14
3/18/2018 1:51:47 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513
Agreed
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8OB8A49 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/20181:52:32 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 :;hris Seelbach)
Greg?
S1atus: Read
React 3/18/2018 1 52:46 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8OB888A (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:09:28 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513' Greg Landsman)
Sorry. I am just finishing up.

I don't think we need a statement. And I don't like commenting on what Harry might or might not think or want. Also think some of it is
unnecessary inflammatory. We are trying to bring some maturity to this ridiculous situation. To deescalate.

If we do something, I would suggest something short and simple.

But again, I don't think we need a statement.

Here is what I have personally sent to people and reporters:

"My position hasn't changed and a believe that's true for the majority. I don't support a big buyout. We need all the facts, and that's the point
of the independent counsel. As I've said from the beginning, the issues need to be addressed in the next couple of weeks."
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2 09:46 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8OB9E11 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:21:35 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513i [P.G. Sittenfeld)
Greg, I do think there's value in the 5 of us putting something out
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8OB96AD (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:22:27 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: [P.G. Sittenfeld)
Here's another crack at it, even though this feels watered down to me and doesn't speak to why a buyout is really so offensive.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8OB946B (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:23:18 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 P.G. Sittenfeld)
"Our position has not changed. We do not suppprt an increased buyout or believe that's responsible to the taxpayers.

We reiterate our call for a ceasefire, and we remain committed to the thoughtful, fair, transparent next steps we have previously laid out.
Let's collect the needed facts quickly and calmly.

We believe in the City Charter, we believe in honesty, and we believe in collaboration. All are welcome to join us in upholding these pillars."
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DBAFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:24:08 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Could ppl live with that? Again not my first choice, but I think a collective statement is important
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DBAA7A (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:24:55 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +151 (Greg Landsman)
I fine with the first two paragraphs.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DBA7FA (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:25:24 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513, P.G. Sittenfeld)
Ok, why not 3rd?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DBA5FB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:26:11 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
I think first two paragraphs better than nothing .... (even though again feels too watered down)
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DBA426 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:28:03 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513' (Wendell Young)
I'm ok with this but it is really watered down. If this is what it takes to gain consensus then ok. I think the third paragraph is important in that it
offers a rationale for our statement. Greg I hope you will reconsider your thoughts on the third paragraph.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DBBFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:28:39 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513'. jP.G. Sittenfeld)
3rd paragraph feels like mom and apple pie - who could disagree?!
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DBBC10 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_029


15
3/18/2018 2:29:23 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 '.P.G. Sittenfeld)
Is there version of 3rd graf you can make work, Greg?
S1atus:Read
React 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBB9O8 <Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:36:30 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +15131 Greg Landsman)
"We believe in a collaborative process, and look rorward to working through this with everyone."

The current language feels like petty, "tit for tat" stuff. Again, short and simple seems right, and the first two paragraphs feel sufficient. If
people want to add more flavor, they can do that individually. Loi.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBB7B9 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:38:21 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513, (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Alright, I'll sacrifice my own feelings for consensus. Everyone okay for Harmon to email statement out with first 2 grafs + Greg's 3rd ?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBB38D (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:39:33 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513l (P.G. Sittenfeld)
So final would be:
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBCFD2 {Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:41:14 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 [P.G. Sittenfeld)
"Our position has not changed. We do not suppprt an increased buyout or believe that's responsible to the taxpayers.

We reiterate our call for a ceasefire, and we remain committed to the thoughtful, fair, transparent next steps we have previously laid out.
Let's collect the needed facts quickly and calmly.

We believe in a collaborative process, and look forward to working through this with all stakeholders."
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBCDF7 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:41:39 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 [P.G. Sittenfeld)
Then ppl can individually put their own mustard on it
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBC8EF {Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:41:47 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Ok?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:44:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBC6CE {Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:46:10 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 !Chris Seelbach)
agreed
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 329:21 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBDFD2 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:46:50 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +151< (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Agreed
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/18/2018 329:21 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBDDDB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size• 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:48:31 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: [Chris Seelbach)
Tamaya? Wendell?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 329:21 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBDC18 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:49:19 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513~ P.G. Sittenfeld)
Wendell blessed it (despite feeling same as I do,
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 329:21 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBDA0D (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:49:28 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seelbach)
Cool. Tamaya?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 329:21 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBD7F4 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 3:31:47 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +151<
Agreed. Sorry, I'm out and about and trying to be present
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBD3C3 {Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/18/2018 3:32:24 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513, (P.G. Sittenfeld)

S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 3:44:27 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8DBEFD2 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_030
16
3/19/2018 7:36:59 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513'
What press conference is scheduled for this morning?
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DC38EA (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/19/2018 7:37:29 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513, P.G. Sittenfeld)
Haven't heard of one ...
S1atus: Read
React 3/19/2018 7:37:35 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DC33DA (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/19/2018 7:37:53 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513
Ok thanks
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DC31F7 (Table• message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/19/2018 7:58:01 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513i Wendell Young)
Haven't heard of one.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/19/2018 828:22 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DC4FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/19/2018 6:10:02 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Two things: 1) Kevin Aldridge wants to talk to a few members of the Majority tomorrow at 11 am for our insights on this situation - Wendell or
T, would you want to?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/19/20186:11:35 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DD6FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/19/2018 6:10:58 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 P.G. Sittenfeld)
2) Steve Megerle from Pastor's office came to my office at 4pm today and said, what if 8 months of Harry's salary came from the public (per
the contact), and then another 10 months worth of severance came from a private source (if that were even legal or ethical). My response to
him was:
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/19/2018 6:11:35 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DD7FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/19/2018 6:11:26 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 .P.G. Sittenfeld)
1) I don't know 2) I'd have to confer with the majority 3) it would be contingent on very direct input on who the incoming manager would be 4)
harry would obviously have to want to go that route too
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/19/20186:11:35 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DD76E7 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/19/2018 6:12:03 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
but Megerle/ Pastor seem to already be trying to spread some horseshit rumor that I might flip - so just don't want any of you believing it.
Same crap they tried to pull w/ Tamaya and Wendell, etc.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/19/2018 6:12:19 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DD7361 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 10:19:55 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +151 ~
Cranley has called Iris, my Pastor Lynch, Jr and Lynch Ill to try to flip me.
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DDFFD6 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/201810:21:41 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513'1
Keep that to yourselves please.
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DnFR7::\ (Table: message, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 10:23:35 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513' P.G. Sittenfeld)
why in the world would he call Iris to do that? she loathes him ...
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/20/201810:23 43 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DDF51C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 10:23:58 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +15134
Seems pretty desperate and weird.
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DOF?RO (T;ible: message, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 10:24:03 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513<1
She does
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DEOFD6 (Table: message, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 10:24:10 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
by the way, if it were 8 months of public severance and another 10 months from a private source, would any of you support that? that's what
they're trying to cook up now
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 10:2412 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DEOE13 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 10:25:38 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513
I think I would be fine with that.
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db • Ox8DE1 FD6 (Table: message, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_031


17
3/20/2018 10:26:37 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
financially, it's hard to object to. though I think a lot of the community would be weirded out by a private source stepping in, and wondering
what was trying to be covered up
S1atus: Read
React 3/20/2018 10:26 56 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8[)F17Rn IT:;ible: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 10:27:32 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +151,
That's super weird and the optics are bad. There's something there for sure
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DE2AA5 (Table: message, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 10:27:46 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513
Something Cranley doesn't want us to know
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DE2857 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 10:39:12 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513
Harry has something on Cranley. That non disparagement and confidentiality clause is probably everything
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DE481A (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/201811:12:18AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513- ]Wendell Young)
If Harry gets enough outside money to make leaving palatable, we can't make him stay. I think it's bad precedent and it fixes nothing. The
issues that gave rise to this situation remain in place. I agree there is something Cranley doesn't want to deal with. Cranley is feeling the
heat. Let's hold together. Stay strong!
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/201811:1231 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DEA90A (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 11 :13:50 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513: :P.G. Sittenfeld)
so if I'm hearing you right, if Black got 8 months public severance and 10 months private, it would be hard for you to say No? But if it was 12
months public severance (meaning 4 months above what his contract states) and another 6 months private severance, you would say No to
that? is that correct?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 11:1351 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DEA4D0 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/20/201812:39:12 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 IVendell Young)
No. I'm not okay with a buyout in any form. I'm saying it isn't likely Harry will pass up the money and we can't make him stay.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 12:4127 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF6FD2 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/201812:54:32 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 [P.G. Sittenfeld)
Got it
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 12:54 58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF601E (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/201812:56:25 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seebach)
Has this ever happened in the entire country? That private money pays a public employee to quit? That's what Jason Williams should be
writing about. Someone is so scared of what Harry Black might say, they private money is going to pay him hundreds of thousands of dollars
to leave.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/20/2018 1:16:10 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF6B5B (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 12:57:19 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 [P.G. Sittenfeld)
No idea. Agree, i have discomfort with it
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/20181:16:10 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF676B (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 12:58:45 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +15134 Wendell Young)
I agree with Chris.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 1:16:10 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF6562 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/20181:16:42 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513
Agreed. This is a terrible precedent
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF7B37 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 1:17:44 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Tomorrow's Council meeting will surely be a battle. Cranley will be on the attack. Maybe more than he ever has.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 1:37:09 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF793A (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 2:08:11 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
Then we stand strong and fight back. Cranley is trying to destroy our city manager form of government. We can't allow that to happen.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/20/2018 2:14:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF73B0 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_032


18
3/20/2018 2:09:58 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Emphasized "Then we stand strong and fight back. Cranley is trying to destroy our city manager form of government. We can't allow that to
happen."
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 2:14:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DFBF01 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 2:10:10 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
All for one, one for all!
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/20/2018 2:14:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DFBC1 A (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 2:10:30 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513' (Wendell Young)
Amen!
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/20/2018 2:14:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF89FB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 2:11:32 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
This is an incredibly important moment of the next four years. Can they pick one of us off? If they can't, Cranley will either be forced to
respect us...or he will explode. And I'd say it's 50/50 odds.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 2:14:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF883C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 2:13:36 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513i (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Interestingly David Mann said the same thing to me on Sunday: he said he thought this whole absurd episode is going to cause John to
realize he has to be respectful and collaborative if he wants to get anything done.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 2:14:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF9FD2 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 2:14:09 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Not sure that's humanly possible for him. But would be great if it did.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 2:14:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF98B3 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 2:14:32 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
We hold strong tomorrow , and we'll go from there
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/20/2018 2:14:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DF966D (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 2:14:43 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Liked "We hold strong tomorrow , and we'll go from there"
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/20/2018 2:14:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DFAF08 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 2:25:09 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
From inside City managers office "Cranley thinks he's gonna push Landsman so hard tomorrow that he will get his vote." Stay with us my
friend.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 229:09 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DFA9O8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 2:26:21 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Greg is and has been rock solid! (Greg is also probably on a 12 hour flight as we speak)
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/20/2018 229:09 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DFA407 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/20/2018 2:29:27 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 [Wendell Young)
So we're the "Invincible Five?" Loi
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 2:29:28 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8DFBFD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/21/2018 12:01:44 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513i (Chris Seebach)
Greg. How was meeting with Cranley?
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/21/2018 12:15:13 PM(UTC-4}
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8E0A956 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/21/2018 2:26:37 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Amy Murray: "If you all would just come to my committee, you would understand everything ... because I fix everything just like I fixed the
streetcar during my 4 years charing that committee."
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/21/2018 2:27:51 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8E0F6DF (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/21/2018 3:08:45 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513: (Chris Seelbach)
Great work everyone
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/21/2018 3:14:04 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8E1236C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_033


19
3/21/2018 3:39:18 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 ;Chris Seelbach)
Pastor: We have to work together, collaboratively....invokes Shirley Chisom ....then spends 15 minute attacking us.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/21/2018 4:15:24 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E15BF6 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 11 :29:25 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +15131 (Chris Seebach)
Cranley calling Wendell and me asking if he can give us something in exchange for our vote.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/24/2018 11 :29 31 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E859CE (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 11 :36:18 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +15131 (Greg Landsman)
Same. Meeting with him tomorrow. He claims he's willing to put anything on table. Chris, when do you get back? Also, can a few of us meet
on Monday? We can't all meet, of course. Chris, hope your trip has been great. Pictures look fun.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/24/2018 11:4019 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E86DEC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 11 :36:45 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +15131 (Chris Seebach)
I'm back like 2:30am Monday morning
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/2018 11 :4020 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E87FD2 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 11 :37:13 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +15131 (Greg Landsman)
Would lunch work?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/2018 11 :4020 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E877E1 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 11 :38:00 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +15131 (Chris Seebach)
I have to be to foundation in morning and through lunch. But could do something after 2
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/2018 11 :4020 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E87608 (Table• message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 11 :38:56 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +15131 (Greg Landsman)
3:30?
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/24/2018 11 :4020 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E88FD2 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 11 :38:59 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +15131 (Chris Seebach)
Yes
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/2018 11 :4020 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E88ACC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 11 :39:12 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (Greg Landsman)
Others? Up to four :).
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/24/2018 11 :4020 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E88911 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 12:09:43 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +15131 P.G. Sittenfeld)
sorry to miss some calls & texts. have been at March for Our Lives.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/201812:1006 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E8848A {Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 12:09:47 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
I could do 3:30pm
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/24/201812:1006 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E89FD2 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 12:10:39 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
needless to say, I'm fine with some grand bargain that's actually good - BUT the entire point of this is about how we govern and John
needing to work collaboratively with the Democratic majority, not go running to Smitherman, Murray, Pastor and then see how we can pick
off 2 more
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/201812:1042 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E897D8 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 12:10:52 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513i :P.G. Sittenfeld)
can't emphasize enough the degree to which we need to stay coordinated
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/201812:1052 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8E893B0 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 12:15:23 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513' (Chris Seebach)
100% agree with you P.G.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/201812:3018 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db • 0x8EBAE15 /Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 12:24:48 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (Greg Landsman)
Yep. See you on Monday at 3:30. Where is best?
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/24/201812:3018 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhofiet~bl!J.lJl@ili&.1SmAtt> •0x8EBAC30 {Table: r&~Ji~~ii\at, Size: 220631040 bytes) Respondent_034
20
3/24/2018 12:29:14 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513; [P.G. Sittenfeld)
I'm fine w/ a Council office, though off-site probably better. I could get us the community room above the Coffee Emporium to ourselves
S1atus:Read
React 3/24/201812:3018 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8E8BFD2 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 12:31:31 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +151~
I won't able to be there
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8E8B9B8 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/201812:31:50 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513'
I think CE's community room is under construction
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8E8B7D3 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 12:31:52 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513i (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Wendell, can you? I think best to have 4 of us if able to be coordinated
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/2018 12:31 56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8E8B5B8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 12:32:02 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513; (P.G. Sittenfeld)
T, I mean the room on 2nd floor in the Emery
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/201812:3206 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8E8B33A (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 12:32:13 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513
Oh never mind. You're talking about your
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8EBCFD6 (Table: message, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 12:32:28 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513'
Got it
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8EBCDD1 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 1:10:07 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
I can meet. Just tell me when and where. Going dark now . Back on around 5.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/24/2018 1:35:57 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8E8D34C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 2:00:01 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 P.G. Sittenfeld)
Sounds like we're locked in for 3:30pm this Monday. Do you all want to do Wendell's office at City Hall, or the private community room above
the Coffee Emporium?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/2018 2 03:15 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8E93FD2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 2:02:58 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
City hall is easier for me
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/2018 2 03:15 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8E933EB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 2:03:42 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: (P.G. Sittenfeld)
City Hall fine by me
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/2018 2:18:37 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8E93202 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 2:58:25 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Greg Landsman)
Same.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/24/2018 3 06:19 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8E962FF (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/24/2018 5:16:13 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +15134 (Wendell Young)
Happy to host everyone in my office. See you there.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/24/2018 7 06:28 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/ L brary/SMS/sms.db: Ox8E9778D (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_035


21
Extraction Report
Apple iPhone Logical

Chats ( 1) Among Councilmembers Dennard. Landsman. and Sittenfeld

.J... • These details are cross-referenced from this device's cont.acts

iMessage: +1513 1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 1/3/2018 6:28:24 AM(UTC-5)


+1513' Last Activity: 6/27/201810:46:17 AM(UTC4)
Number of attachments: "
Source: iMessage: +151:
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
OxBADEF96 (Table: chat, handle, Size: 220631040
bytes)
Body file: chat-1 .lxt
+1513
P.G. Sittenfeld•

+1513
Greg Landsman•

3/2912018 8:58:13 AM(UTC-4)0iri!dion:lncoming, +1513 (Greg L..andsmall)


Hey guys. I'll post my statement around 10AM. Among other things, I say the following: "I will be a no vote on any agreement beyond giving
the manager the 8-months that is already in his contract if he decides to leave on his own accord." You can mention that or not.

But I did decide to travel with my family this morning, and if John wants to have a revote on Wednesday, that's on him. My position won't
change.
status: Read
Read: 3/29/2018 9:38:07 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8F28FD3 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/2912018 9:01:54 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Happy to mention in mtg if you desire
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/29/2018 9:38:07 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8F29FD3 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/2912018 7:06·17 M(U"f )Oiredion:lncoming, +1513' iGreg l..andsma
Like your plan on independent review. I think Andrew Garth could work with us on it. So it goes through solicitor's office without bias. Just a
thought.. ..
strtus: Read
Read: 3/29/2018 7:31:03 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8F3047B (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_036


Extraction Report
Apple iPhone Logical

Chats (1) Between Councilmembers Dennard and Pastor

...L • These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

iMessage: + 151 3, (1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 2/17/2017 5:38:47 PM(UTC-5)


+1513l Last Activity: 6/28/2018 4:34:38 PM(UTC-4 )
Number of attachments: 10
Source: iMessage: +1513
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms .db :
0xBAAE624 (Table: chat, handle, Size: 220631040
bytes)
Body file: chat-1.lxt
+1937
Jeff Pastor•

3118/20181:31:46 PM(UTC-4)1)iredion:lncoming, +1937 Jeff Paslor)


Please consider the agreement.
status: Read
Read: 3/1812018 1:33:09 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8D88FE8 (Table : message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3118/2018 1:32:32 PM(UTc:4)0irection:lncoming, +1937! {Jeff Paslor)
We have an opportunity to start fresh.
status: Read
Read: 3/1812018 1:33:09 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/ SMS/sms.db : 0x8DB8E0B (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3118/2018 4:43:00 PM(UTC-4)1)irection:Oulgoing, +1513
Hi! I really appreciate your efforts but I can't support the buyout at this time
status: Sent
Delivered: 3/1812018 4:43:01 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x8DBEB40 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_037


Extraction Report
Apple iPhone Logical

Between Councilmembers Dennard and Seelbach


Chats (1)
...L • These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

iMessage: +151 ~ (1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 6/7/2013 12:08:32 PM(UTC-4)


+1513 Last Activity: 6/27/2018 2:20:46 PM(UTC-4)
Number of attachments: 6:-t
Source: iMessage: +1513
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
0xBA0A6DB (Table chat, handle, Size: 220631040
bytes)
Body file: chat-1.lxt
+1513:
Chris Seelbach•

311312018 5:49:45 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513: ,Chris Seelbach)


Are you cool with me tweeting "I can confirm that there are not 5 vote to either fire City Manager Harry Black or agree to a 2-year buyout."
status:Read
React 3/13/2018 5 54:32 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8CF836B /Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
4/1912018 4:58:03 PM(UTc:4)0ill!dion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Landsman flipped
status: Read
Read: 4/19/2018 4 58:14 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x91D4BE6 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
4/1912018 4:59:04 PM(UTC-4)0ill!dion:Ou1going, +1513
To fire Black? Will there be a severance offerea·t
status: Sent
Delivered: 4/19/2018 4:59:03 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x91D4A23 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
4/1912018..§:00:03 PM(UTC-4)0ill!dion:lncoming, +151~ _ (Chris Seelbach)
Yes. He wants him to resign. But will fire if necessary
status: Read
Read: 4/19/2018 5 00:55 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox91D4820 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
4/1912018 5:03:07 PM(UTC-4)0ill!dion:lncoming, +1513_ ·- ·--- (Chris Seelbach)
The City Manager accuses the Mayor of a felony. And the next day Landsman gives the Mayor exactly what he wants.
status: Read
Read: 4/19/2018 5 03:22 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x91D5FE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_038


Extraction Report
Apple iPhone Logical

Chats ( 1) Among Councilmembers Dennard, Seelbach, Sittenfeld, and Young

...L • These details are cross-referenced from this device's cont.acts

iMessage: +151 3, 1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 1/24/2018 9:54:24 AM(UTC-5)


+1513l Last Activity: 3/14/2018 4:07:55 PM(UTC-4 )
Number of attachments: 1
Source: iMessage: +1513
Source file: iPhone/var/mob1le/Library/SMS/sms.db :

... +1513-
OxBAE4DF7 (Table: chat, handle, Size: 220631040
bytes)
Body file: chat-1.lxt
Wendell Young•

... +1513:
Chris Seelbach•

... +151,
P.G. Sittenfeld•

...
3113/2018 5:42:08 PM(UTC-4)()iredion:lncoming, +1513 [Cfiris Seel6ach)
Taking Greg off this chain so he can sleep. What do you all think about releasing a statement or tweeting that there are 5 confirmed
Councilmembers who do not support firing City Manager Black or a buyout?
status: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 6 03:38 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8CF78F5 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3113/2018 5:43:54 PM(UTc:4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Wendell Young)
Great idea! We should give John hell tomorrow!
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 6 03:38 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8CF8FD3 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3113/2018 5:44:04 PM(UTC-4)()iredion:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
Tamaya and PG, what do you think?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 6 03:38 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8CF8582 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3114/2018 2:29:44 PM(UTC-4)()iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
FYI: Harry just told me he's going to shut down settlement talks and fight this.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 2:33:43 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox80174?7 !Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3114/2018 2:30:08 PM(UTC-4)()iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Obviously a fluid situation, but that's what he just said
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 2:33:43 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8D18FD3 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3114/2018 2:33:57 PM(UTc:4)0irection:Outgoing, +15131
Good!!!!
S1atus: Sent
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8D18DAA (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3114/2018 2:35:09 PM(UTc:4)0irection:lncoming, +1513~ (Cliris Seel6ach)
great news
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 2:35:26 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8D188E8 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_039


3/14/2018 2:35:35 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Lord knows things can change quickly
1
S1atus:Read
React 3/14/2018 2:35:40 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O189EA (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 3:08:52 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +151, Wendell Young)
Said the same to me.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 3:25:08 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O1ABDC (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 3:13:30 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)

.-
IMG 5393.png
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 3:25:08 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O1AA00 (Table: message, handle, chat, attachment, Size 220631040 bytes)
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/Attachments/83/03/C3991FF1-2DCE-4E27-BB85-E489DCB45C47/IMG_5393.png: (Size: 1358042 bytes)
IHe's public with it
3/14/2018 3:13:35 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)

S1atus:Read
Read: 3/14/2018 3:25:08 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O1A7BE (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 3:20:06 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513~ (Chris Seelbach)
Cranley just called 3:30 press conference
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/14/2018 3:25:08 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O1A5DE (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 3:46:08 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenfeld)
Asked by reporter whether John has the other 4 to support firing the Manager, John's answer was, "I haven't asked them yet"
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 3:46:24 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O1 C586 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3/14/2018 4:07:55 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 !Vendell Young)
Mini-Trump is lying again.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/14/2018 4:29:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db: 0x8O1 D2FD (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_040


2
Extraction Report
Apple iPhone Logical

Chats (1) Between Councilmembers Dennard and Sittenfeld

.J... • These details are cross-referenced from this device's cont.acts

iMessage: +151 ~ 1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 4/23/2014 2:20:42 PM(UTC-4)


+151:: Last Activity: 7/8/2018 1:2228 PM(UTC-4)
Number of attachments: 137
Source: iMessage +15134170743
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db :
0xBA3D33A (Table: chat, handle, message, Size:
220631040 bytes)
Body file: chal-1.lxt
+1513
P.G. Sittenfeld•

tamaya_dennard@yahoo.com
Tamaya Dennard• (owner)

3120/2018 4:12:24 PM(UTC-4)()iredion:lncoming, +1513 (P.G. Sittenl'eld)


as a separate matter, I'm not imagining that at last caucus Cranley mentioned Scottie Johnson's name as someone who supports John's
position in this whole mess? Did you hear that too?
status: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 4:12:48 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : Ox8DFDFE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3120/2018 4:13:33 PM(UTc:4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513
I'm pretty sure i heard his name. Did you have lunch with Julie today?
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/20/2018 4:13:33 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x8DFDC90 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3120/2.0 ◄· ~ _lUTC-4)!;:>iredion:lnco ing +1513 (PG. Sittenfeld
yeah, and she was like hell no Scottie doesn't agree with Cranley on this!
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 4:14:21 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x8DFD78C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3120/2018 4:15:23 PM(UTC-4)()iredion·Out~. +151~
He is truly something else. What do you think Harry has on John?
status: Sent
Delivered: 3/20/2018 4:15:20 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x8DFEE38 (Table: message, chat, Size 220631040 bytes)
312072018 4:16:44 PM(UTC-4)()iredion:lncoming, +1513: [P.G. Sittenl'eld)
not sure - but if you made me guess some sort of contracting corruption
status: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 4:26:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x8DFEC18 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3120/2018 4:44:04 PM(UTc:4)()iredion:lncoming, +1513~ if>.G. Sittenl'eld)
alright, Greg said he is going to go, in which case I think good for us to both be there to support him, and be a unified front. that ok?
status: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 5 03:03 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x8DFE982 (Table : message, handle, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)
3120/2018 5:03:37 PM(UTC-4)()iredion:Outgoing, +151~
Works for me
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/20/2018 5:03:29 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: iPhone/var/mobile/L brary/SMS/sms.db : 0x8DFE6C2 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220631040 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_041


Extraction Report
Apple iPhone Logical

Between Councilmembers Landsman and Pastor


Chats (1)
.J... • These details are cross-referenced from this device's cont.acts

iMessage: +151 ~ (1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 1/2/2018 9:15:10 PM(UTC-5)


+15131 Last Activity: 11/22/2018 3:37:28 PM(UTC-5)
Number of attachments: 7
Source: iMessage: +151~
Source file: Gregory Landsman's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x2B38F96
(Table: chat, handle, Size 50020352 bytes)
Body file: chal-1.lxt
+1937
Jelf Pastor•

3/17.12018 12:14:34 PMruTC=4)Direclion:lncoming, +1937! :Jelf Pastor)


Deal will be signed tomorrow
status: Read
Read: 3/17/2018 12:28:01 PM(L/TC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0xC88FE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/17.12018 12:14:49 PM(UTC-4)Direclion:lncoming, +1937 (Jelf Pastor)
FYI.
status: Read
Read: 3/17/2018 12:2801 PM(L/TC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0xC88B17 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 50020352 bytes)
3/181201812:.il-4:07 (U C4)Direclion:lncoming, +~ (Jeff Pastor)

Attachments:

IMG 1780.jpeg
status: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 12:4721 AM(L/TC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0xC8D876 (Table message, handle, chat, attachment, Size: 50020352 bytes)
Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/Attachments/a5/05/EEEB61EE-28E2-4F76-8122-AE00F2EFEDD0/IMG_1780.jpeg : (Size: 1591701 bytes)
3/1812018 12:44:38 AM(UTC4)Direclion:lncoming, +1937! Jelf Pastor)
Let's end this and move on.
status: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 12:4721 AM(L/TC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0xC8D949 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/1812018 12:52:46 AM(UTC-4)Direclion:Outgoing, +1513
My position hasn't changed and a believe that's true for the majority. I don't support a big buyout. We need all the facts, and that's the point
of the independent counsel. As I've said from the beginning, the issues need to be addressed in the next couple of weeks.

I'll be back on Tuesday. See you soon, Jeff!


status: Sent
Delivered: 3/18/20181252:49 AM(L/TC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0xC8FFE4 (Table: message, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/1812018 12:56:11 AM(UTC-4)Direclion:lncoming, +1937! (Jelf Pastor)
No sense in dragging this out for a political spectacle. To suggest this is a big buyout is just offensive. Be safe
status: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 12:56:15 AM(L/TC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0xC90ABB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_042


Extraction Report
Apple iPhone Logical

Between Councilmembers Landsman and Seelbach


Chats (1 )
....L. • These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

iMessage: +1513 :1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 12/4/201712:37:41 PM(UTC-5)


+1513 Last Activity: 1115/2018 2:51 :26 PM(UTC-5)
Number of attachments: 41
Source: iMessage: +1513t
Source file: Gregory Landsman's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox2829F96
(Table: chat, handle, Size 50020352 bytes)
Bodyfile: chal-1.lxt
+1513
Chris Sellbach•

319/2018 4:17:12 PM(UTC-O)Direction:lncoming, +151~ _(Chris Sel l>ach)


So Cranley told Harry at 2pm today to resign or he'd launch a smear campaign against him?
status:Read
Reac!: 3/912018 4:1723 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxBE7FE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
319/2018 4:18:03 PM(UTC-O)Direction:Outgoing, +1513'
Not sure. On work call. Will call after. What a mess.
status: Sent
Delivered: 3/9/2018 4:18 03 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhonelvar/mobile/Library/SMSlsms.db: OxBE78A5 (Table: message, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/11/2018 3:41:23 PM(UTe,.,t)Oiredion:lncoming, +1513 Ch ·s Sel bach)
So you officially are not supporting firing?
status: Read
ReacJ: 3/1112018 3:45:38 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxBFC8F2 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/11/2018 5JL31 PM(UTe-:4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 Chris Sel bach)
Just always remember. City Hall is a mess. And you can pick up kids toys, so you .. .and only you...can solve this problem have a safe flight!
status: Read
Read: 3/1112018 5:17:38 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxC00895 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/13/2018 12:18:.ffi PM(UTC-4)Direclion:lncoming, +1513 ______ (Chris Sellbach)
Are you considering making some kind of public statement saying you do not support firing Harry? PG, Tamaya and Wendell have. PG
trying to get me to as well.
status:Read
Read: 3/13/2018 12:1947 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxC22FE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/13/2018 12:20:39 PM(UTC-4)Diredion:Outgoing, +151~
I've told press folks who've asked.
status: Sent
Delivered: 3/1312018 1220:40 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxC22CDO (Table: message, chat, Size 50020352 bytes)
3/13/2018 12:20:48 e (UTC-4)Direclion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Sellbach)
That you do not support firing?
status: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 12:2137 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : OxC22AEB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/13/2018 12:22:09 PM(UTC-=4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +151:
Correct. Though I add that there are issues that need to be addressed.
status: Sent
Delivered: 3/1312018 1222:10 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : OxC228D4 (Table: message, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/13/2018 3:13:06 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Sel bach)
Would you vote for a buyout for Harry? like a 400k buyout?
status: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 3:29:24 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gr~L,E&~t'.,f@£:>!1'' 8 ~ ~e/Library/SMS/sms.db: ~ ( i (~694ltlessage, handle, chat, Size: 50020~ e 9 ~dent_043
3/14/2018 1:06:13 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513!
Sorry for the delay. I told John and media last night that I was a no vote though. On settlement and firing.
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1412018 1:06:14 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxC31FE4 (Table: message, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/16/2018 1:36:19 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 Chris Sel bach)
Tamaya wants the public lynching in the statement, out I think would settle for something about black leadership being under attack. Would
you agree to that?
S1atus: Read
React 3/1612018 1:49:46 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxC75C6D (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/18/2018 1:51:27 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Sel bach)
Hey, did you see statement just reaffirming our previous statement? Can you respond on group text "agreed"?
S1atus:Read
React 3/18/2018 1 59:34 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxC9E769 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/20/2018 12:57:32 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 Chris Sellbach)
From Rocky "Apparently mayor is meeting with him in the am and confident a deal will be struck."
S1atus: Read
React 3/20/2018 12:57 37 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxCBFF2B (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/20/2018 12:57:38 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Sellbach)
Stick with us
S1atus: Read
React 3/20/2018 12:57 39 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Librarv/SMS/sms.db: OxCBFCCB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/20/2018 12:58:18 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513
I'm not moving. Have a statement I'll put out when I get home.
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/20/2018 1258:20 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxCBFBOE (Table: message, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/20/2018 12:58:30 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Sellbach)

S1atus:Read
React 3/20/2018 12:58 30 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxCBFBFO (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/20/2018 1:01:21 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513i (Chris Sel bach)
John Juech saying you will compromise "if you have a say on next manager. Voicing of support for Isaac and a few other items, commitment
to collaborative refresh."
S1atus: Read
React 3/20/20181 01:26 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxCCOFEB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/20/2018 3:55:37 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513
Just FYI, I'll post my statement in the morning before I leave. Would like to be fully with my kids and Sarah after I land tonight. I've been
gone for nearly ten days. But it's a pretty tough statement. Around 8:30AM, and I'm not moving.
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/20/2018 3:55:38 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxCCAFE4 (Table: message, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/21/2018 2:02:41 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513: jChris Sel bach)
Hang in there. I know he's coming down hard on you.
S1atus: Read
React 3/21/2018 2:19:13 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxCF7D2F (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/21/2018 2:19:48 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513j
I'm good:). Thanks, brother.
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/2112018 2:19:48 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxCF87E2 (Table: message, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/26/2018 10:53:28 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513
We'll see. I'm pushing these larger City Hall and CPD reforms. I think PG's meeting with him went okay. Cranley has calmed down, and
seems to appreciate the fact that his behavior isn't working for us. Time will tell, but I held no punches.
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/26120181053:28AM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxD7A4FF (Table message, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)
3/26/2018 11 :02:56 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513: :chris Sellbach)
Just got this: "Harry said mayor has half the City making phone calls to Landsman."
S1atus: Read
React 3/2612018 11 :03 32 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxD7BD6C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 50020352 bytes)
3/26/2018 11 :05:38 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +15131
Maybe last week:). No one really since Wednesday.
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/2612018 11 05:38 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: Gregory Landsman's iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: OxD7B761 (Table: message, chat, Size: 50020352 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_044


2
Extraction Report
Apple iPhone Logical

Between Councilmembers Landsman and Sittenfeld


Chats (1)
...L • These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

iMessage: + 151 3: (1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 11/2712014 1:03:44 PM(UTC-5)


+1513: Last Activity: 11126/2018 8:49:15 AM(UTC-5)
P.G.* (owner) Number of attachments: 3?
Source: iMessage: +1513:
Source file: P.G.'s
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0xB90A6FE
(Table: chat, handle, Size 220762112 bytes)
Body file: chal-1.lxt
+1513
Greg Landsman•

3115/2018 8:35:29 AM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513 _P.G.)


just venting, but Christ. Jason's gossip column frustrates me
status: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/varlmobile/Library/SMSlsms.db: 0x741A2C8 (Table: message, chat, Size 220762112 bytes)
3115/2018 8:35:47 AM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
it's like they can never let the lens be "what do you think is best for the city?"
status: Sent
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/varlmobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x741 BFEC (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3115/2018 8:37:35 AM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513 P.G.)
it's all fucking angling and politics rather than: what might actually allow us to keep a lid on the damn city so that it's not a racial powder keg
status: Sent
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMSlsms.db : 0x7418B36 (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3115/2018 8:37:53 AM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
and why the hell should we have to pay $600k to settle a personality dispute between 2 grown men!
status: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMSlsms.db: 0x741B64F (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
311672018 8:08:37 AM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +151j :Greg L..andsm~
Wondering what you all think of a cease fire/cooling off period, during which they both agree to say nothing more on the subject and focus
on work. We bring in a pro bono mediator (or two), to help them get through the two weeks or however long it takes for us to put together a
process to address the issues that have emerged. A special committee of my committee perhaps. And we ask Harry for weekly progress
reports to ensure the work is continuing unabated, and a commitment from him that he will not make any personnel decisions (e.g. firing
anyone). lf we get the CBC types and NAACP and others to join us, might work.
status: Read
Delivered: 3/1612018 8:08:43 AM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/16/2018 8 08:43 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMSlsms.db: 0x746BFDC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3116/2018 8:09:40 AM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513: :P.G.)
I personally love it! I'm sure Harry would. I'm dubious John will go for it...
status: Sent
Source file: P .G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x746B637 {Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3116/2018 8:15:20AM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 [Greg Landsman
What would get John there, you think? Anything·r
status: Read
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x746B3C2 (Table : message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3116/2018 8:16:21 AM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +151: :P.G.)
fair question. I offered him another legit reason compromise and he immediately shot it down on two occasions (it was give Harry 6 months
to seek employment elsewhere; no buy-out is necessary; he leave on his own terms so there's no racial inflammation, and council is actively
involved in selection of new manager) - he wasn't having it.
status: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x746CFEC (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_045


3/18/2018 2:16:08 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Greg Landsman)
You and David set to meet today? I think having something to vote on Wednesday as it relates to "independent" counsel (my new word, lol),
is now even more important. Thanks for all you're doing on this. Wish I was there to help more...
S1atus:Read
React 3/1812018 7 50:54 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x7506FE8 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/2512018 8:59:47 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513f Greg Landsman)
Yeah. Let's do that. He'll move on maj or reforms. City Hall and within CPD. Wasn't easy. Need to talk strategy on getting Harry to agree to
12 months. I have some ideas. He wants to hear you out too, and he promised to really listen. Same with Tamaya and others. He does
seemed changed by all of this.
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/2512018 9:05:34 PM(UTC-4)
React 3/2512018 9 05:34 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7698FDC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_046


2
,,nD Verizon ·~ 21:19 4v 77% ( . ~)►

< From Councilmember Mann


with Mayor Cranley and Councilmember
Sittenfeld

2 People >
- - - - - - -- - - - -- - - --····- ··········-········- ....... .
engagement. Should we

release tomorrow? If not, l
I
when? I worry we get blasted
I!
for not letting Public weigh in
before vote. Let me know your
thoughts; 2. David has
suggested to me that you,
Tamaya and Wendell are ok
with Mann/Dennard
investigation. If so, can you
guys introduce by motion today
at Greg's committee. If
agreement, I can shelve special
counsel ordinance. Let me
know. Roughly 24 people want
to come forward and need a
process. I'm still -open to
special counsel if that is
• preferred.

Mon, Apr 16, 12:'18

>
' ·,

FILED U~ R 3- • ,.~Jl., CD j 0 Respondent_047


From Councilmember Mann,
among the Mayor, then-City
Manager and Council
l
10 People>

Te)(t Message
Thu, Mar 8, 18:52
chris seelbach
Ij.
I agree with Vice-Mayor
Smitherman on how this was
handled. Very disappointing
· (D dismissal. ..again. I
I

... ..
,
,·1:
!.

I!

Respondent_048
,Ill Verizon ? 16:27 "r/ 94%( }

< From Councilmember Mann, among


Mayor, then-City Manager Black, and
Council
10 People>
---·---------
the results we have achieved
as a City Government.

Disappointingly, as this has


now morphed into a quasi-
judicial exercise including
sworn, video-tapedtestimony, I
have requested to be provided
the requisite outside legal ·
representation as it relates to
my role as City Manager.
Therefore, this is all I have to

CD say at this time. 11

Wendell Young

This is fine. Thanks for the

- heads-up. Stay strong!


(5'l3) 702-·

Harry thank you for this heads


up and all your championship
of us. T
'"-1

••
•UC9nO'O
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0049 Respondent_049
- - ~ - - - --------~--- ---------. ------------------ --------

,111 Verizon ~ 16:26

<-. From Councilmember Mann with then-City


Manager Black

Harry>

Good point! It is absolutely still


on the table

Sending out a clarification


memo

Thu, Mar 8, ·19:51

Call me when you can

a Cl)
---
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0050 Respondent_050
21:16 "V 78% 0 ■}

< From Councilmember


Mann, among Mayor
Cranley, Councilmember
4 People> Murray, Vice Mayor
- - - - - - --------------------------------·--------- ~~ -----
Smitherman, and
--------·--~~--------------------··-·-· ---

Councilmember Pastor

• 20th floor

Jeff Pastor

Been stuck outside for 10mins

Please have someone let me in

Was on 20th

Wed, Mar 21, 12:35


John Cranley

e Please come to ti my office to


share update. I'm here.
Anw Murrny

• Just got here - you still there?

John Cranley

Yes

Amy Mu!Tay

• Onway

r.t G) 0
---
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0051
80411 Respondent_051
,111 Verizon ~ 16:31 -v 94% ~ )►

< From Councilmember Mann,


among Mayor Cranley,
Councilmember Murray, and
3 People> Vice Mayor Smitherman

e without fear of retaliation.

Wed, Mar 14, 22:19


John Cranley

I'd deeply appreciate it if you 3


would cosponsor with me this
ordinance that will protect city
workers and allow me or city
council to subpoena city
workers to testify without fear
• of retaliation.

Confidential--Chris Jenkins
told me P.G. called him a few
days ago to tell him that his
code members should not
testify because there will never
be 5 votes to fire the manager
and then employees wi'II regret
coming forward. He viewed it
as a threat and wants me to tell
Ed board tomorrow about it to
fl help pass the ordinance.

ID 0) 0
---
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0052
e oa Respondent_052
, ,,,,: Verizon ~ ~ 7 8% (----:}

< From Councilmember


Mann, among Mayor
Cranley,
4 People> Councilmember Murray,
Vice Mayor
-·-·--··-··-······-··-I--c,-rI1-rl\:.c-·-..::,I·I·npo·rTan·c-co-·I1·avea1,-· Smitherman, and
Councilmember Pastor
up or down vote on what the
manager's lawyer negotiated in
good faith with the city. After
that vote I am unsure what our
next step should be to resolve
Cl) this impasse
Jeff Pastor

I would also offer, it seems as if


the "council majority" wants to
engage in what the NAACP
calls, "public lynching" we
should work to prevent this
from happening

I agree VM. Could we have an


up or down vote after we
consider their option and it
fails?

John Cranley

Let's talk in the morning. We


have To have up or down vote
fire-+ nn ~nro.omon+

a O)
• ue
FILED UNDER E L Resp
n 4D'O
ent_0 Respondent_053
,11r Verizon ? 21:12 -v 78% (i!i[)

<
4 People>
-------------cuns1aer-rnen-uplTOnana-1 l
G fails?
Joht1 Cranley

Let's talk in the morning. We


.,
have To have up or down vote
9 first on agreement.

Please don't text between now


• and 7:3Qa_rn

Mon, Mar 19 1 '15:00


Cht·is StTtithern1a11

Can u meet Wed AM with


editorial board
John Cranley

I'm booked 9-11 but again go


without me. And Tuesday
better anyway.
Jeff Pastor

Yes

Rt Cl) 0
•e&n eo
FILED UNDER E L Re ond t_0054 Respondent_054
, Verizon ~ "'f 79%l-}

<
4 People>"
·--------·-----------
I'm in NYC and was there on
Thursday. It's critical to get
there before Wednesday. Go
without me. They have already
f8 heard from me.
Chris Smitherman

I do not know what our next


steps should be IF Landsman
really votes against this deal for
Manager. Should we present a .
second option? If so should be
present second option after 1st
fails showing good faith with
the deal we negotiated w
managers attorney or at same
C9 time on Wednesday?
Jeff Pastor

So their proposed ordinance is


all but DOA. The Mayor would
first need to put it on the
agenda for consideration
(unlikely). Next we would vote

•• 0
•een eo
FILED UNDER E L pond _0055 Respondent_055
1111 Verizon '? 16:38 '9 94% ( --) ►

<
4 People>

Thursday. It's critical to get


there before Wednesday. Go
.without me. They have already
heard from me.
Chris Smithem,an

I do not know what our next


steps should be IF Landsman
really votes against this deal for
Manager. Should we present a
second option? If so shou Id be
present second option after 1st
fails showing good faith with
the deal we negotiated w
managers attorney or at same
time on Wednesday?
Jeff Pastor

So their proposed ordinance is


all but DOA. The Mayor would
first need to put it on the
agenda for consideration
(unlikely). Next we would vote
and it was oass BUT would

lfJ G) 0
• ee
FILED UNDER E L n G'O
Respondent_0056 Respondent_056
I C

.
, .. Venzon ~
-;- 21:11 ,.::; 79%U .J• I

<
4 People>

So their proposed ordinance is


all but DOA. The Mayor would
first need to put it on the
agenda for consideration
(unlikely). Next we would vote
and it was pass BUT would
have to overcome a veto
(Mayor could easily picket veto
as well), this is also unlikely. All
things considered, could we
allow us to take a vote on their
ordinance, once vetoed,
propose our settlement
agreement?

Just an amateur trying to


G strategize
Chris Smithern1an

I think it is important to have an


up or down vote on what the
manager's lawyer negotiated in
good faith with the city. After
+h~+ Hnto I ~m 11nc-11ro \A1h~+ n1 ,r

Rt 0)
., u -
FILED UNDER E L .n
Respondent_0057 Respondent_057
,111 Verizon ~ 16:39

<
4 People>
-----···-··-···-Just an amateur trying t-o-············•.............. _. . . . . . . . . . .

G strategize

Chris Srnitherman

I think it is important to have an


up or down vote on what the
manager's lawyer negotiated in
good faith with the city. After
that vote I am unsure what our
next step should be to resolve
$ this impasse
JHff Pastor

I would also offer, it seems as if


the "council majority" wants to
engage in what the NAACP
calls, "public lynching 11 we
should work to prevent this
from happening

I agree VM. Could we have an


up or down vote after we
consider their option and it
fails?

&t 0); 0
•uen eo
FILED UNDER E L Responde t_0058 Respondent_058
,111 Verizon ~ 16:39

<
4 People>

Jeff Pastor

I would also offer, it seems as if


the 11 council majority 11 wants to
engage in what the NAACP
calls, 11 public lynching 11 we
should work to prevent this
· from happening

I agree VM. Could we have an


up or down vote after we
consider their option and it
G fails?
John Cranley

Let's talk in the morning. We


.,
e have To have up or down vote
first on agreement.

Please don't text between now


and z:30a.m

Mon, Mar 19 1 'J5:0Q

liJ Cl) 0
• ue
FILED UNDER E L n 8"0
Respondent_0059 Respondent_059
From Mayor Cranley with
Councilmember Landsman

< Greg
CD

Fri, Apr 6, 8:40 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0060 Respondent_060


Today 3:41 PM

-. - - ~ -- •.. : -~. ~ . . . ._,. .'

After the:rpgetuag
. -, _ _1 _ _

Delivered

• fJ

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0061 Respondent_061


From Mayor Cranley with
Councilmember Mann

< David

Wed, Apr 4, 12:09 PM

.@dsmann115 says that it was


@PGSittenfeld who persuaded
himself and @tamayaforcincy to be
the two council members who lead
the probe as "mutual listeners," of
anyone who comes forward to
complain about City Manager Harry
Black. @wcpo
4/4/18, 10:53 AM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0062 Respondent_062


1 Retweet 1 Like

(1fi$.~~@l~i lililoti.9..1\1..,still g iMe s MOl:l


• right t6 asl{·: qtu.cestiom$.
• • ,..z.
I t
SeMenal
I • .:• ' . -

may be sharing:ern?1~ ,21a·1


stories that beg add:i!~.QJ~al
questions necessary·fof\¢.Q.4~t"b
to get a full picture. Y?J-r:~.2w __
,,,.
'L.. '


3:52

< David
CD

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0063 Respondent_063


Good re the other 3. P.G.
wanted to talk to tamaya one
more time.

0 ··---··------ 0:00 >))


Raise to listen
i!
~ -- ·~ . .. ,. - =:tt'
,,

· Mann and Murray are in board;.-- ' -~ - -


- :r ..._

Wed, Apr 4, 12:09 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0064 Respondent_064


•.. ~

GI • n

3:52

< David
CD

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0065 Respondent_065


Just talked to Wendell. He will
accept Harry•s lawyer simply
being present to observe but
without any right to question.
That seems acceptable to me.

. ~

Important to be si1enj;-,-z.ffi9~~{ o
chill witnesses. Har~y,·~~r:ttJfleci
to hearing in charter :if:fi~~'tf:
-- .,,L . ; • •
- - ~-. ,e- --

,:. ., tJ~

0 0 an
3:52

< CD
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0066 Respondent_066
David

Pg says Wendell wants Harry's


lawyer to be present at witness
interviews which would really
make them cumbersome. At
PG's suggestion I have put in a
call to Wendell.
Pg suggests motion would still
pass but not una:nimously.
Maybe we add motion to
budget and finance agenda to
see what happens. PG's
alternative is judge jones' firm
which he seems to have a more
economical v·ision of than what
we would think. You and P.G.
have to agree on paid option it
seems to me.

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0067 Respondent_067


-•1 + + - - -, • - -~ ... --

needs to be:firrn.n-o·rne.,o.t~us
know. Let's just pclsi:~ct~~:,;.! .
motion. Let me. know;,5q}J:~G-~ .: 0~~ ..
,-.,--~ .
. -
" ..._-
_

.a.
.
--

• ~
'-.,

3:52 ,Ill LTE f• }

< David
CD
is on his mind.

Mon, Apr 2, 3:00 PM

None.

Mon, Apr 2, 5:37 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0068 Respondent_068


... .
~-,.,.,. _. -------·- -------------
Tue, Apr 3, 2:15 PM

Remember budget and finance


meets tomorrow if we have
path forward in Dennard/mann
or special counsel.

' -

You still in committee?

Just finished up.

an
3:52 ... , LTE • I

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0069 Respondent_069


< David
CD
001n rr1e arTa I ar11aya. r quIc;K1y
drafted this plan. I wanted u to
see it before I share with P and
T.

Sat, Mar 31, 12:43 PM

Got it

Sat, Mar 31, 7:34 PM

Sat, Mar 31, 10:01 PM

See my email

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0070 Respondent_070


i'- :,; - - _.. -~-:- - -·-- -,~-... ~~<4 - T•--,~

properly pa_id.". ar1~:~ft11.~~pJtm<rlemt


special couns~L So ·ct9.r.1~~ ee .a
much different plan th~t~s~~S~~~
come from pg .unless_h~ ·-w.~.gt~· ,
to pay for a counsel. H'ave~tor:~~, .·l
keep the transparency·an.Cl · -.. · t ~
·-. - '·--.<- - •· ':::c..iaj,

""n"\
., h
J I
}-_'./
..~_.....
.

GI e • n

3:52 .... LTE 1• I

< David
CD

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_0071 Respondent_071


I agree re skepticism.

Fri, Mar 30, 1:25 PM

lV

TASKS FOR DENNARD AN ...

Talked to PG and Tamaya. I


guess it does not work without
both me and Tamaya. I quickly
drafted this plan. I wanted u to
see it before I share with P and
T.
- .

I will call you shortly.

• r.
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0072 Respondent_072
3:52 ... LTE .• I

< David
CD
iMessage
Tue, Mar 20, 9:28 AM

Wed, Mar 21, 2:41 PM

With labor

"''-· •. :.i - - - - - ~- . --~-


FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0073 Respondent_073
I '\IUVV II l,;UI 11~::, lU VU l~

Sat, Mar 24, 1: 36 PM

,,, .
-. -----' ·~ . .. . •- ;

( 'Had nice chaf ·witfi.•·.;J[~Jwla~a.


!..;Claims that 1f I can aJf~
9r~~9st
.· of list Greg gives me 1
torry6-fr:2#L
then she understands.she.· h.,....
e{$}:
'.
l\
to support buyout. Says s_ h e~~'.:.· ,
• • . -. . I
. l•~,,..,,I

,,l" ,~

From Mayor Cranley with Councilmember Landsman



3:43 ,Ill LTE ,-7 1

< Greg
CD

Fri, Apr 6, 8:40 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0074 Respondent_074


Today 3 :41 PM
'"f - ---- -

'/ . . . . '"':" • I'~ -.:.II

Aro~n91 ·Harry~
f:~12 a@ d
repnmanded. Le1_g.......~,:;,. ~1[0Acda,~.- - .... ..
:-~ . .__,..
~

After the meeting


Delivered

-
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0075 Respondent_075
• •
From Mayor Cranley to Councilmember Mann

3:53

< David
Fri, Apr 6, 7:37 PM

Mon, Apr 9, 2:56 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0076 Respondent_076


~·eul 9·--!ct~M9h>,~. e. it se@1t Ol!lt
.,.._ _- .- .:_.. ~- . .,'--_- .~

Thursday 1:16 PM
- ·---- ---- -
. - . -- .. --~---------
. .

.· Jeff askecr 'r.ne for ~P-~¼i~J~ty ll


council meeting 4pm .Mo,rn-g fii 1

Ok with you? After yol!,lr'b:ti{:f~~(


meeting. · ~ ·- ,;
- ____. _...AJ
-:.

• •

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0077 Respondent_077


From Mayor Cranley with Councilmember Sittenfeld

3:57 1111 LTE fill ] 1

New iMessage Cancel

To: PG Sittenfeld

Understood. You know my


natural inclination is always
toward collaboration and
getting things done. I'm not
hesitant to disagree, and tone
matters a lot to me too as you
know - but absolutely I'd
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0078 Respondent_078
always rather be part of a team
that's making progress.

Mon, Apr 9, 6:06 AM

got it

Tue, Apr 10, 2:44 PM


--. ;... ..- · . - : , . ~ --. -

. Follow up on FCC. Jefif .says:;, ·. • I

you prefer ordinance thaf ·

3:57 ,Ill LTE i.. I

New iMessage Cancel

To: PG Sittenfeld
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0079 Respondent_079
Understood. You know my
natural inclination is always
toward collaboration and
getting things done. I'm not
hesitant to disagree, and tone
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_ 0080 Respondent_080
matters a lot to me too as you
know - but absolutely I'd
always rather be part of a team
th;:::at'c:: m;:::al<inn nrnnr~c::c::

3:57

New iMessage Cancel

To: PG Sittenfeld

heartburn tha.n almost any


other optio.n, frankly. we'll see
where they land.

~-~ J

Fri, Apr 6, 7:51 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0081 Respondent_081


Sun, Apr 8, 12 :14 PM

3:57 ,II LTE ,. '

New iMessage Cancel


FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0082 Respondent_082
To: PG Sittenfeld

okay, keep me posted on other


possible ideas

Tue, Mar 27, 1:12 PM

Fri, Mar 30, 11 :33 AM

Tamaya expressed willingness


and inclination to do it, though
wants to think on it. David said
he understands necessity of
them doing it as a team. David
going to reach out directly to
Tamaya.

I think th~m ~~ ~ t~~m ~t~~rinn


FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0083 Respondent_083
I I.I I l l 11, I.I 1 - 1 I I -- - ._ _ _ I I t _.., _ _ , I I I ~

the process would give council


and the community less
heartburn than almost any
other option, frankly. we'll see
where they land.

3:57 ,II LTE !IL}

New iMessage Cancel

To: PG Sittenfeld

I think very highly of Ge.orge,


but also think he may well start
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0084 Respondent_084
to enmeshed in too many
relationships for this particular
situation. I suppose, though, it
depends somewhat on who he
was partnered with

I'm also somewhat resistant to


firms that do direct business
with the city.

What would you think of Blank


Rome? (Judge Jones + Cioffi
and/or Curp)
. ~·--- .......... ~ ~

. No ¢,9.pt,e'.§-{foms to cur.p
-- - -~ - ---=- . __ .,! ___ ____

okay, keep me posted on other


possible ideas

3:57 ,ti LTE (il_J,

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0085 Respondent_085


New iMessage Cancel

ro: PG Sittenfeld

I think very highly of George,


but also think he may well start
to enmeshed in too many
relati·onships for this particular
situation. I suppose, though, it
depends somewhat on who he
was partnered with

I'm also somewhat resistant to


firms that do direct business
with the city.

What would you think of Blank


Rnm~? ( II ,rln~ . lnn~c::: -1- rinffi
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0086 Respondent_086
,,_,,, __ \----:::,- --··--' -·-···
and/or Curp)

No connections to curp

okay, keep me posted on other


possible ideas

3:53 ,Ill LTE U 1

< David
CD

Thursday 1:16 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0087 Respondent_087


Sure

Friday 7:34 PM

r,~ ~~h~!~ ~.Y,.91!0 t5 ~er, io@I


ref~pf:ed·;t - ·: • ~
~
'
' •

.· .
- -

.
• • • •

~ .
I

"
< ,• -

_.,.._--.
"
...

Yes. Thanks b

Yesterday 4:25 PM

Wendell is chilling Lelg'~,;~~El?.!r.


should be called out. · .•. i
Delivered


FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0088 Respondent_088
3:57 ,Ill LTE U,

New iMessage Cancel

To: PG Sittenfeld

natural inclination is always


toward collaboration and
getting things done. I'm not
hesitant to disagree, and tone
matters a lot to me too as you
know - but absolutely I'd
always rather be part of a team
that's making progress.

Mon, Apr 9 1 6:06 AM

got it

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0089 Respondent_089


1ue, Apr ·1u, i:44 1-'M

,.:~PltQ~ ug .om ~C@. ~ie'fifi s-a~s


l!iyoy)pi,~f~-~.P.tt§lmamGe ~a~
:,' ·. autho.riz~~.
. '
t j_@)imJstfiatiom to
a_
... - • . . . ?.~·nH
execute:develo·
-. . ,p ~·r;tiem .~.· t . .
... -. ..,~.r~.,""
agreement. ton Si sf&1~f tffi
attached·· MOU bqt- 9.9~?-;Ul~
require additionaF-vqte::~t,i•t ,. (
council. True? _ - -J
. - . ~ .- -~ - -e:... ...... - t
Delivered

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0090 Respondent_090


From Mayor Cranley with Councilmember Mann

< David
CD

Yes. Thanks b

Yesterday 4:2 5 PM

Today 4:13 PM

Today 6:02 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0091 Respondent_091


Delivered


6:05 I

< Christopher
CD

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0092 Respondent_092


Today ·12:12 PM

Today 4:12 PM

Today 6:02 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0093 Respondent_093


From Mayor Cranley with Councilmember Landsman Delivered

• • n

6:05 I

< Greg
CD

Today 3:41 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0094 Respondent_094


Today 6 :01 PM

Delivered

• n

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0095 Respondent_095


From Mayor Cranley with Councilmember Murray

10:08 •• ~ C}

New iMessage Cancel

To: Amy Murray

Tue, Apr 3, 5:03 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0096 Respondent_096


Wed, Apr 4, 2:46 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0097 Respondent_097


From Mayor Cranley with Councilmember Mann

10:02

< David
CD
Yesterday 4:25 PM

Today 4:13 PM

Today 6:02 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0098 Respondent_098


Today 10:02 PM

Epic fail
Delivered

• • n
From Mayor Cranley with Councilmember Landsman

10:02

< Greg
CD

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0099 Respondent_099


Today 3:41 PM

Today 6:01 PM

Today 10 :02 PM

Epic fail

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0100 Respondent_100


Delivered

• n
From Mayor Cranley with Vice Mayor Smitherman

10:02 .• 9 c=J1

< Christopher
CD

Today 4:12 PM

Today 6:02 PM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0101 Respondent_101


Tod ay 10:02 PM

Delivered

,..
• ◄

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0102 Respondent_102


From Mayor Cranley with Councilmember Pastor

New iMessage Cancel

To: Jeff Pastor

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0103 Respondent_103


Wed, Apr 4 1 9:24 AM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0104 Respondent_104


From Mayor Cranley with Vice Mayor Smitherman

< Christopher
CD
I I '-' I I I 'I. I I v VU II I I '-' I I I I I vl t.J''-" v w U I I 'VI

verbally said she was stressed


by the line of questioning the
day before by a council
member.

I am very concerned that the


manager did not follow my
direct instruction in not
engaging in any form of
retaliation against any city
employee who risked coming
to my special hearing of Law &
Public Safety to address the
911 call center crisis. I view the
phone call from the City
.. . . .. ..
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0105 Respondent_105
Mananger as Insubord1natIon.
Also, I think the "gang of 5"
text messages confirm they are
protecting this kind of behavior
over the interest of the city.
I pray Ms. Tami who was
obviously shook up yesterday
by the pho,ne call will have the
courage to take a stand. The
"gang of 5" talk a good game
to the public about how they
care about women at marches
but when it counts they are
- .. - .
,·: ··,
i l ;•:, .

7:14

< Christopher
CD

Mavor
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0106 Respondent_106
· · · -· J - -

1had a good conversation with


Ms. Tami. I first thanked her for
her service and testimony
yesterday. Also, I wanted her to
know that I supported her.
She confirmed a phone call she
receive,d from the City Manager
that noted her testimony at
Law and Public Safety related
to the 911 call center was not
helpful and the City Manager
did not appreciate.
She gave more details but I
think the above sentence
describes the tone.
I shared with her that we had
spoken & Councilman
Landsman but I would keep our
conversation confidential until
she was ready to share her
story. She was very stressed
from the call f ram her boss and
verbally said she was stressed
by the line of questioning the
day before by a council
mPmhPr
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0107 Respondent_107
I I,,.._,, 11"'-"'-'1. •

• •
7:14

< Christopher
CD
- ~

"gang of 5" talk a good game


to the public about how they
care about women at marches
but when it counts they are
nowhere to be found.
I will wait to take action until I
hear back from Ms. Tami.
However, I am really frustrated
and disappointed in the phone
call Mayor. I want the truth
about the 911 call center and
do not want anyone to feel like
they can not talk.
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0108 Respondent_108
Vice Mayor

Q W E R T Y U I O P
A S D F G H J K L

+ ZXCVBNM 0

123 space return


-------- - - - - - - - - --·-- __,,

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_o109 Respondent_109


From Mayor Cranley with Councilmember Sittenfeld

< PG
CD

I will always fight for those I


serve, including our employees.
Anyone can partner with me in
that effort. What staggers me
is how you continue to do
things that make so m.any
peop,le feel you can't be
trusted.

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0110 Respondent_110


Delivered


9:23 ,111 LTE f• Jt

< PG
CD

Today 8:45 AM

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0111 Respondent_111


I will always fight for those I
serve, including our employees.
Anyone can partner with me in
that effort. What staggers me
is how you continue to do
things that make so many
people feel you can't be
trusted.
. -- ~ . ·- - - - - --. - -- - - .---=-
c,":·' _,

:, w .hat stagger$ ,rJie is~:l b)q~¼9U


know Harry i's abus.img}~~d ·,
retaliating against city :_vy,f>~l~~,.
-many of are or were '. f n~~tP~5J~i
of yours-and you are p~,tt1_ 1}g;, !
• . .·
. .,,•
: '· '.'' •
~ ~ • ,~
=· ...··~

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0112 Respondent_112


FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0113 Respondent_113


Between Councilmembers Seelbach and Sittenfeld
Chats (1)
• These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

iMessage: +151~ (1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 12/1/2014 12 01:52 PM(UTC-5)


+1513 Last Activity: 11/25/2018 4:51 :58 PM(UTC-5)
P.G.• (owner) Number of attachments: 21,:;
Source: iMessage: +1513:
Source file: P G 's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0xB90D5D4
(Table: chat, handle, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
Body file: chat-1 .txt
+1513
Chris Seelbach·

3/9/2018 9:29:40 AM(UTC-5)Direction:Outgoing, +151 • ]P.G.)


If John tries to terminate Harry, would you support? As you know , I would not
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/9/2018 929:36 AM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x729EA76 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762 112 bytes)
3/9/2018 2:10:45 PM(UTC-5)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 P.G.)
I'll shut up about it, but I do believe this can ena w1tn Harry treating you better and owing you
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/9/2018 210:45 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72AB54D (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 2:11:19 PM(UTC-5)Direction:lncoming, +151:i Chris Seelbach)
I would need a meeting with him that is honest, meaningful and had actual, specific conclusions.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/9/2018 2:11 :27 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72AB2E6 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762 112 bytes)
3/9/2018 2:11 :36 PM(UTC-5)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
I think it's a great idea
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/9/2018211:36 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox72ACFE4 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 2:11 :57 PM(UTC-5)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 .P.G.)
Want me to have him reach out to you, or Jon, to set it up?
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/9/2018 211 57 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72ACE0A (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762 112 bytes)
3/9/2018 2:12:17 PM(UTC-5)Direction:lncoming, +1513; :::hris Seelbach)
What is going on with it? Landsman told me Cranley told him Harry can't last another 24 hours
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/9/2018 2:1217 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72ACBF5 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/9/2018 2:12:32 PM(UTC-5)Direction:Outgoing, +151< P.G.)
Just not true
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/9/2018 212:32 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72AC95E (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 2:12:50 PM(UTC-5)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 .P.G.)
John wants him gone. But not gonna happen
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/9/2018 212 50 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x72AC7A0 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 2:12:59 PM(UTC-5)Direction:lncoming, +151\ [Chris Seelbach)
But is John gonna propose firing?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/9/2018 2:13 00 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x72AC5AE (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_ 0116 Respondent_114
3/9/2018 2:13:12 PM(UTC--5)Direction:Outgoing, +1513; (P.G.)
No, be doesn't have votes
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/9/2018 213:12 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72AC394 (Table message, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/9/2018 2:14:01 PM(UTC--5)Direction:lncoming, +1513( (Chris Seelbach)
what votes does he have
S1atus:Read
React 3/9/2018 2:28 45 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72ADE04 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/9/2018 3:35:22 PM(UTC--5)Direction:lncoming, +1513 ;Chris Seelbach)
Harry tried called. Not sure I'm ready to talk yet. But will early next week. If you want to really this to him, I'm cool with it. I would need him to
agree my fixes to RB and that it solves the issues. And will get behind it. Among other things. But that's the big one.
S1atus: Read
React 3/9/2018 3:40 53 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72B1 FEB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 3:35:27 PM(UTC--5)Direction:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seelbach)
called = calling
S1atus:Read
React 3/9/2018 3:40 53 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.dh · 0x7?Fl1 BE7 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 3:35:39 PM(UTC--5)Direction:lncoming, +15133 :chris Seelbach)
really = relay
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/9/2018 3:40 53 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x72B19F3 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 3:49:16 PM(UTC--5)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
Got it.
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/9/2018 3 49:16 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72B4FE4 (Table: message, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/9/2018 3:50:30 PM(UTC--5)Direction:Outgoing, +151 i (P.G.)
You know John at 2pm told Harry, resign or I'll launch smear campaign against you
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/9/2018 3 50:24 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72B4E32 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 3:50:36 PM(UTC--5)Direction:lncoming, +1513i (Chris Seelbach)
no. I did not know that.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/9/2018 3:51 41 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72B487E (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 3:51 :19 PM(UTC--5)Direction:lncoming, +1513 _Chris Seelbach)
what was Harry's response?
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/9/2018 3:51 41 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72B467A (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 3:52:14 PM(UTC--5)Direction:Outgoing, +1513: .P.G.)
Not taking it
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/9/2018 3 52 08 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72B446A (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 3:52:24 PM(UTC--5)Direction:Outgoing, +1513: (P.G.)
Our government is not a monarchy for John to discard people as he pleases
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/9/2018 3 52:24 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72B42AC (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 3:52:30 PM(UTC--5)Direction:lncoming, +151:l (Chris Seelbach)
I agree with that 100%
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/9/2018 3:54 03 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72B5FE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/9/2018 4:05:41 PM(UTC--5)Direction:lncoming, +151~ [Chris Seelbach)
And support of no fares for streetcar.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/9/2018 4:25 03 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x72B5419 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/9/2018 4:06:07 PM(UTC--5)Direction:lncoming, +15131 (Chris Seelbach)
Jon is told Mann supports firing. If Cranley has the 3 republicans, Harry needs me.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/9/2018 4:25 03 PM(UTC-5)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72B6FE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/11/201812:52:05 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513i Chris Seelbach)
Cranley calling and texting me. Anything I should know before calling him back?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/11/2018 12:5213 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x72F69D6 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0117 Respondent_11 5


2
3/11/2018 12:54:28 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +151 (P.G.)
That he thinks you're a or the swing vote; that he wants you to allow him to go thru with this; that he's trying to line up the unions to call for
Harry's head
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/11120181254:32 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox72F6795 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/11/2018 12:54:43 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513i [P.G.)
He obviously needs you or wouldn't be calling
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/11120181254:44 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox72F649E (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/11/2018 12:55:02 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513~ P.G.)
Also, he has not called me, so we haven't spoken yet
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/11120181255:03 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox72F629C (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/11/2018 12:55:42 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 _P.G.)
I think this situation is also becoming a racial powder keg
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/11120181255:43 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox72F7FE4 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/11/2018 3:37:27 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
Do you know if there's anyone on council who publicly supports firing?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1112018 3 57:44 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: Ox72FB691 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/11/2018 3:58:14 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
Public yet? Not sure. But Smitherman & murray only totally firm yes votes so far
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1112018 3:58:15 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox72FC9B0 (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/11/2018 3:58:31 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 :P.G.)
Who knows if they'll make that public before John can count to 5
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1112018 3:58:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox72FC76B (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/11/2018 3:58:40 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seelbach)
Sherri says he has 4 votes. Only needs Landsman or me, so I'm assuming he also has Mann and Pastor.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1112018 3 58:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox72FC548 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/11/2018 3:59:15 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513i (P.G.)
Bluntly, I don't think her count is firm
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1112018 3:59:16 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox72FC2A5 (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/11/2018 3:59:21 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513i P.G.)
She said same to me
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1112018 3:59:21 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: Ox72FDFE4 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/11/2018 3:59:42 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
I've spoken to both Pastor & Mann. They seemed more up for grabs
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1112018 3:59:43 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox72FDE1 A (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/11/2018 3:59:50 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513! [Chris Seelbach)
ok cool
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1112018 3 59:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox72FDBF7 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/11/2018 4:00:34 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
Mann seems more likely to go with John. Pastor just wants to be with the majority on this one
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1112018 4:00:34 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: Ox72FDA1 1 (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/11/2018 4:00:46 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +151J Chris Seelbach)
got it. makes sense.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1112018 4 00:46 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox72FD7B6 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/12/2018 11 :24:51 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seelbach)
And he told me everything I needed to hear. Will come on board with Responsible Bidder. Will put signal prioritization and making the
streetcar free in budget.
S1atus:Read
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox7321FEC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_o11a Respondent_11 6


3
3/12/2018 11 :25:22 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +15131 _ JP.G.)
you feel like you two can also set the re-set button and work well together moving forward?
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7321CD9 (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/12/2018 11 :25:54 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +15131 '.C hris Seelbach)
That's the question. My dad said to me last night, "What assurances do you have that you can trust him" And I don't have any. But he filled
me in on just how bad Cranley is
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/12/2018 1125:54 AM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/12/2018 11 :25 54 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7321A42 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/12/2018 11:26:09AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
I just need to have more conversations with my team
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/12/2018 1127:39 AM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/12/2018 11:2739 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x73216F5 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/12/2018 11 :27:41 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
understood
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x73214BF (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/13/2018 12:26:46 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seelbach)
Greg says he has publicly told folks he does not support firing. On radio last weekend and any reporter who has reached out and asked.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 1:21:54 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x738DFE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/13/2018 1:22:04 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +15131 (P.G.)
Did he text you that?
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/13/2018 1:22:02 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x738E9A4 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/13/20181:22:40 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Yes

-
Attachments:

Screen Shot 2018-03-13 at 1.22.28 PM.png


S1atus: Read
Read: 3/13/20181:32:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x738E7DC (Table: message, handle, chat, attachment, Size: 220762112 bytes)
P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/Attachments/cf/15/7C5846A6-9020-4B1F-B562-6E199A60D294/Screen Shot 2018-03-13 at 1.22.28 PM.png : (Size: 93507
bytes)
3/13/20181:23:06 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513l Chris Seelbach)
so there are 4 people who have publicly said they do not support firing
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/13/2018 1:32:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x738E4DE (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/13/2018 1:33:01 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
Yep. You'd make 5
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/13/2018 1:33:01 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x738F9AC (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/13/2018 1:44:55 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513.~ _ _,Chris Seelbach)
I want to see what Cranley presents until I commit.
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/13/2018 1:45:18 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/13/2018 1:45:18 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7390374 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/13/2018 1:45:30 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
what Cranley presents in terms of his smear?
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7391FEC (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/13/20181:46:46 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 iChris Seelbach)
Yes. Understanding that most will be complete BS. But I'm just not ready to announce a completely no to firing.
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/13/2018 1:47:48 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/13/2018 1:47:48 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x7391B79 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/13/20181:47:50 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513: (P.G.)
understood
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x73918C6 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:30:51 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513 _P.G.)
Can you let Sherry know no 5 votes
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/13/2018 5:30:49 PM(UTC-4)
f
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox73AC6C0 (Table: me$sa11e hat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
FILED UNDER E L t<esponaenr_0 11:1 Respondent_11 7
4
3/13/2018 5:30:58 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 P.G.)
I told Wetterich
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1312018 5:30:56 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox73AC4O8 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:31:14 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +15131 (P.G.)
I think John trying to force hand
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1312018 5:31:12 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox73ADD91 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:32:01 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 ;Chris Seelbach)
Yes
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1312018 5:32:11 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x73AEFE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:32:08 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seelbach)
100% certain on Greg?
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1312018 5:32:11 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x73AEE44 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:32:19 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513~ [Chris Seelbach)
If so. We should release some kind of statement
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/1312018 5:32:19 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x73AEAB0 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:32:20 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513: '.G.)
Vanessa just said so
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1312018 5:32:18 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x73AEC78 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:32:31 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513! (P.G.)
Doesn't support buyout or firing
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1312018 5:32:29 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x73AE8B0 (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/13/2018 5:32:36 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
Ok good
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/1312018 1045:06 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/1312018 10:45 06 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x73AE6C0 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/14/2018 11 :38:17 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
Can you call me? I'm being told Harry is cleaning out his desk and leaving.
S1atus:Read
Delivered: 3/1412018 11 39:38 AM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/14/201811:3938AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox73O9FDC (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/15/2018 7:37:11 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Is Tamaya going tomorrow?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/15/2018 7:37:14 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7450929 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/15/2018 7:37:22 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 iP.G.)
No - confirmed it
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/15/2018 7:37:21 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.dh · n" 74<;1)41 E (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/15/2018 7:37:27 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
so they won't have a quorum
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/15/2018 7:37:32 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.dh · 0,c74<;()25C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/15/2018 7:37:38 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +15131 (P.G.)
Correct
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/15/2018 7:37:37 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.dh · Ox 74S1B99 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/15/2018 8:50:24 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +15131 _Chris Seelbach)
Cranley know you're not coming tomorrow? Wendell and I sent our excused absences today. But didn't know about you and T
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/15/2018 8:50:30 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/15/2018 8 50:30 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.dh · 0,c74<;f3FDC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/15/2018 8:50:49 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
not sure when my staff was, and no clue what John knows. no communication with him today
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox745679A (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
FILED UNDER E L Respondent_o120 Respondent_11 8
5
3/1512018 8:52:08 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: _Chris Seelbach)
Did I tell you that Harry called me today to tell me (for what he thought was the first time) about Denver....forgetting (because he was drunk
or high) that he told me every detail Tuesday night at 10:30pm
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/1512018 8:52:14 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/1512018 8 52:14 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox7458FDC {Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/1512018 8:52:23 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513i (Chris Seelbach)
Seriously. He needs help
S1atus: Read
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox74583DC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/1512018 8:53:25 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513 P.G.)
yeah, look, part of our getting organized tomorrow needs to include a plan for collectively telling him what our behavioral expectations of him
are - with close to a zero tolerance policy
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox7459DCB (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/1512018 8:53:53 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1511 [P.G.)
where John has stepped in it, yeah, this looks and feel like a "public lynching" - but that doesn't mean Harry doesn't have work to do
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: Ox745977F (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/1512018 8:53:59 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
He can do whatever he wants on his own time. But he cannot make calls or received calls when drinking
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/1512018 8:54:15 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/1512018 8 54:15 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox745947E (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/1512018 8:54:11 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: Chris Seelbach)
Agreed
S1atus:Read
Delivered: 3/1512018 8:54:15 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/1512018 8 54:15 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox7459209 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/1512018 8:54:51 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513: [P.G.)
if this happens after we make our expectations clear, or refuses to seek the appropriate help, at that point, it'll have to be termination at the
8-months
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox745AFEC {Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/1512018 8:55:12 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 P.G.)
but we need to share that with him collectively, and from a place of trying to support him thru what might be an actual disease
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox745ACDD (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/1512018 8:55:56 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 jChris Seelbach)
Yes I recorded our conversation Tuesday. He was 100% not sober. And he doesn't even remember talking to me. Btw. I have recorded two
conversations in my lifetime. The one with Cranley on Sunday. And Harry on Tuesday.
S1atus: Read
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: Ox745BFEC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/1512018 9:08:48 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513: P.G.)
I haven't text him in his most recent round of texts, but here's what I want to say:
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.dt- · nv7<1"FC45 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/1512018 9:10:19 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513! (P.G.)
Hi Dan, I'm not a father yet, so you'll have to tell me if this analogy holds up: If two of your children are behaving badly, is the approach to
then go to their siblings who are behaving normally and demand that they correct they're badly behaved siblings behavior? My hunch is that
you go the badly behaved children, and you demand better, and you don't enable them. Does that sound right? Would love to see the texts
you're sending to John and Harry!
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox745F9C4 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/1512018 9:10:25 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
but I'm not actually sending him that
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox745F45D (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/1512018 9:11:09 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
Sounds perfect
S1atus:Read
Delivered: 3/1512018 9:13:36 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/1512018 9:13:36 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox745F22F {Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0121 Respondent_11 9


6
3/1512018 9:30:58 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +151:: (Chris Seelbach)
Juech just sent me this "get ahead.
I was invited to the city managers office today. I received a call during another meeting I was leading in my office on a matter of city
business. I did not volunteer anything.
I was told that the solicitor was right to be concerned about her job. Then I was asked for a loyalty pledge to the manager and a letter of
support.
When I said that I had to think about that - not even a yes or no - I was told by the manager that I had "made clear" where I stand.
I want the record to be very clear. I want there to be no doubt on the facts of what happened today.
I have told my personal, out of state lawyer all the same. This is all codified with multiple attorneys and will be public record."
S1atus:Read
React 3/15/2018 9:31:()6 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7461FE8 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/1512018 10:30:31 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513. Chris Seelbach)
Rocky said Pastor has been presenting as if he can change Tamaya's vote
S1atus:Read
React 3/1612018 7:17:57 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7466E30 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/16/2018 7:15:43 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 iP.G.)
He can't
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1612018 7:15:44 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7466FE4 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762 112 bytes)
3/16/2018 7:40:55 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: (Chris Seelbach)
Cool
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/1612018 7:59:36 AM(UTC-4)
React 3/1612018 7 59:36 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7467270 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762 112 bytes)
3/16/2018 9:52:22 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Councilmember Mann Statement on Mayor Cranley and City Manager Black's Dispute

Harry Black and John Cranley are passionate public servants. I admire and respect them both.
With plenty of fault on each side, they obviously can no longer work constructively with each other. Calls for mediations, counseling,
interventions and so on come too late to undo the damage in what is now a dysfunctional relationship.
The true victims are the citizens of this community and the serious and challenging issues we face, not the least of which is a huge budget
shortfall for the fiscal year beginning July 1. Our city manager system (of which I am a strong supporter) assumes a strong collaborative
partnership between the mayor and city manager. When that partnership does not exist, a change is essential.
Harry Black wants to leave his post. He has three possibilities.
(1)He can resign but under the ordinance hiring him, he then would entitled to no severance payments whatever.
(2)He can be terminated with the approval of five members of council. The ordinance hiring him entitles him to eight months' pay.
(3)He can separated under an agreed package, again with the approval of five members of council. (Most recently, I am advised, Mr. Black
would agree to 18 months of pay, not the 24 months he presently asked for.)
My democratic colleagues will not support (2) and (3). Mr. Black could resign at considerable financial sacrifice. Otherwise, the current
dysfunction continues, indefinitely I suppose.

My democratic colleagues hold the keys to unlock this impasse. I implore them to help us move beyond the current deadlock.
S1atus:Read
React 3/1612018 9 56:12 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x7474FE8 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/16/2018 11 :53:33 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
showed it to Landsman too - he thought take last part out for now about time/date/place of public hearing.
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x747BBFF (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/16/2018 11 :53:47 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
I'm fine with that - we can always impose that later John wants to go in that direction
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox74 78958 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:37:45 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513~ (P.G.)
if he bails, do we tweak the language and send it from the 4 of us?
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x748O9D4 (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:37:45 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
he was on phone
S1atus: Read
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x748O77D (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762 112 bytes)

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0122 Respondent_120


7
3/16/2018 2:37:49 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 ;P.G.)
cool!
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x748O58F (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:38:20 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
I think he needs to know we'll send from the 4 of us
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x748EBE1 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:38:56 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +151 ~ (Chris Seelbach)
he's good with it
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:39:01 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x748E47C (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:39:05 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 G.)
Asis
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/1612018 2:39:05 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x748E27E (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/16/2018 2:39:08 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513, iChris Seelbach)
yes
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/1612018 2:39:08 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox748FFE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/17/2018 4:40:03 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +151l (Chris Seelbach)
Harry needs to stop negotiating with the minority. There's a new story coming out today that says he wants to leave with 18 months.
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/17/2018 4:42:00 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x74E9FEB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/17/2018 4:42:26 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513 p.G.)
Situation is endless topsy-tervy clusterfuck; Harry just called, said he's going to sign paperwork for a 1.5 year buyout. Force a vote from
Council. I affirmed for him I'd be a "No" vote; not bilking taxpayers because Cranley has a personality disorder.
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/17/2018 4:42:27 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x74E9A05 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/17/2018 4:42:41 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
Yes, Harry is being almost as sloppy with this as John is
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/17/2018 4:42:42 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox74E9652 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/17/2018 4:42:46 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 iChris Seelbach)
I'm a 100% no
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/17/2018 4:42:46 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x74E943F (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/17/2018 4:42:57 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513i P.G.)
Same
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/17/2018 4:42:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox74E9249 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/17/2018 8:14:38 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 iChris Seelbach)
heard from Tamaya at all? If she's solid, don't think there's anyway Greg flips.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/17/2018 8:14:57 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.dh · 0x74FFD60 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/17/2018 8:15:37 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
Don't repeat, and I think good for you to ask her directly, but she told me she wasn't sure and felt torn
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/17/2018 8:15:37 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x74FFADB (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/17/2018 8:16:28 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
More likely she stays with us
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/17/2018 8:16:28 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x74FF40C (Table: message, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/17/2018 8:16:47 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513 ,P.G.)
But honestly I think Harry got her to feel sympathetic for him
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/17/2018 8:16:47 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x74FF22E (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/17/2018 8:16:58 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
If AA leaders lean on her, that's best bet
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/17/2018 8:16:58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7500FE4 (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0123 Respondent_121


8
3/17/2018 8:19:04 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513: [Chris Seelbach)
You're best to help make that happen
S1atus:Read
React 3/17/2018 8:19:41 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7501752 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/17/2018 8:19:09 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 :hris Seelbach)
Can't believe Harry fucked us
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/17/2018 8:19:41 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7501532 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/17/2018 8:19:45 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
Pretty weak
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/17/2018 8:19:46 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x750131 C (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/17/2018 8:19:52 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +151, (P.G.)
Will do with AA groups
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/17/2018 8:19:52 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7502FE4 (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/18/2018 9:12:36 AM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seelbach)
Now that we have all 5. Again. Are we gonna issue a statement in response to yesterday?
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/18/2018 9:49:08 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x7509FE8 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/18/2018 12:59:39 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513: IP.G.)
If the Manager wishes to move on from his current role, we respect that decision. But the Council Majority remains firm that we are not
signing off on paying someone extra to not do their job. That is neither fair nor responsible to the taxpayers.

Moreover, it is our understanding that, in fact, the Manager does enjoy his job; he simply doesn't like the idea of serving under the looming
threat of a smear campaign. That, too, is understandable.

But asking the taxpayers to provide significant resources in order to avoid the impact of such a smear campaign would set a dangerous
precedent and enable behavior which we do not approve of.

We reiterate our call for a ceasefire, and we remain committed to the thoughtful, fair, transparent next steps we have previously laid out.

We believe in the City Charter, we believe in honesty, and we believe in collaboration. All are welcome to join us in upholding these pillars.
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/18/2018 1259:40 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x751 0FE4 (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/18/2018 1:00:11 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 ;Chris Seelbach)
perfect
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 1 00:16 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x75106F7 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/18/2018 1:54:00 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1511 :P.G.)
Sends a strong signal if the 5 of us hang together on this statement
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/18/2018 1:54:00 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7515DF7 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/18/2018 1:54:31 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +151< Chris Seelbach)
100%. So I guess what is gonna happen is Smitherman's committee will vote for this ordinance with 18 months in committee tomorrow, then
it will tie on Wednesday. and fail.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 1 54:39 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7515A0B (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/18/2018 1:54:49 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513: !P.G.)
Yup
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/18/2018 1:54:50 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.dh · 0x7S1 fiFE4 (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:47:38 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:Outgoing, +1513 :>.G.)
The appearance of hanging together more important than the language
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/18/2018 2:47:38 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.dh · Ox 7S1 l:E29 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/18/2018 2:47:47 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
totally agree
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/18/2018 2:47:47 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x751 EC02 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/19/2018 5:50:39 PM(UTC-4)0ireclion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Just got this from rocky. Any truth? "Harry is hearing P.G. might flip on the settlement vote. You heard anything?"
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/19/2018 5 58:59 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x755E34E (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0124 Respondent_122


9
3/19/2018 5:59:27 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
absolutely fucking not.
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x755FACB (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/19/2018 6:00:00 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
the proposal that was floated to me was what if Harry was offered 8 months of public severance, and 10 months by a private source - would
I support that
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x755F8CD (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/19/2018 6:00:29 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 :hris Seelbach)
private source?
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/1912018 6:00:30 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/19/2018 6 00:30 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x755F27E (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/19/2018 6:00:43 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +15131 [P.G.)
my answer was: 1) I don't know 2) I'd have to confer with the majority 3) it would be contingent on very direct input on who the incoming
manager would be 4) harry would obviously have to want to go that route
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7560FEC (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/19/2018 6:21:01 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513: (P.G.)
I spoke to Harry, cleared it up
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7563D55 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/19/2018 6:21:12 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 P.G.)
honestly, I think Harry is likely to consider settling back into the job
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox756384 7 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/19/2018 6:28:16 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seelbach)
well. he said that before. Not sure I can trust anything he says.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/19/2018 6:30:53 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x756364E (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/20/2018 12:56:54 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +15131 :chris Seelbach)
From Rocky "Apparently mayor is meeting with Landsman in the am and confident a deal will be struck."
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 12:5721 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x757CFE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/20/201812:59:04 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 :P.G.)
But want me to mobilize AA groups reaching out to him?
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/20/2018 1259:05 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x757C5FF (Table: message, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/20/201812:59:19 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513i ,Chris Seelbach)
Landsman just texted me "I'm not moving. Have a statement I'll put out when I get home."
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/20/201812:5919 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x757C3F5 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/20/2018 12:59:24 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513i [Chris Seelbach)
So may not need to
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 12:5924 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x757DFE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/20/20181:01:42 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
From Rocky "According to the mayors thinking Landsman is apparently interested in say on next manager. Voicing of support for Isaac and
a few other items, commitment to collaborative refresh."
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/20/2018 1 01:53 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x757DA4C (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/20/20181:21:57 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1511 (P.G.)
AA mobilization under way
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/20/2018 1:21 :58 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x757EA5D (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/21/2018 12:26:12 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +15131 (P.G.)
some annoying reporter from 19 stuck a mic in my face , and in the course of asking questions, I said today's thing would fail 4-4
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x75D5FEC (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/21/2018 12:26:35 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +151, Chris Seelbach)
That's the truth
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/2112018 1226:35 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/21/2018 12:26 35 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x75D5A05 (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0125 Respondent_123


10
3/21/2018 12:26:38 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 P.G.)
he asked why; I said one of my colleagues is OOT; and he asked who. just want to be clear I in no way proactively brought your name up
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x75D584B (Table message, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/23/2018 8:51:05 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +151: jChris Seelbach)
From Rocky: "I think Harry views Wednesday as D day. If mayor can't get 5, he is strapping the seatbelt on and hitting the pedal."
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/23/2018 8 53:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x766AFE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/23/2018 8:51:39 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seelbach)
However: "Harry met with Landsman today and had a good vibe from it. No commitments from him, but a good vibe"
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/23/2018 8 53:31 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x766A9DE (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/23/2018 8:54:25 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
Meaning Harry wants or doesn't want Landsman to vote for the buyout?
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/23/2018 8:54:22 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox766A463 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/23/2018 8:54:39 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513i (Chris Seelbach)
Wants
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/23/2018 8 55:27 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x766A238 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/23/2018 8:54:57 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +151~ (Chris Seelbach)
Before the Landsman text was, "So what do you think happens Wednesday? Conventional wisdom around City Hall is that "everyone has
had their fun, a separation agreement will be worked out next week."
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/23/2018 8 55:27 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x766BFE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/23/2018 8:55:44 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 . :;hris Seelbach)
But Harry told Rocky if he survives Wednesday, he has "some plans that will be "provocative" and will "show his approach in a "different
light" but would not elaborate ..."
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/23/2018 8 55:44 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x766B912 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/23/2018 8:57:16 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
So Harry thinks Greg might go for the buyout? That's what he meant by a good vibe?
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/23/2018 8:57:13 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x766CFE4 (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/23/2018 8:57:44 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
yes
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/23/2018 8 57:45 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x766CD9D (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/23/2018 8:58:11 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513: [P.G.)
God bless Greg if he's willing
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/23/2018 8:58:09 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x766CBBF (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/23/2018 8:58:22 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513l (Chris Seelbach)
more pressure?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/23/2018 9 00:37 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x766C9DF (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/23/2018 9:00:58 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513i [P.G.)
Will text or email you some thoughts tomorrow
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/23/2018 9:00:55 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x766C7EB (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/26/201811:02:50AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513l (Chris Seelbach)
"Harry said mayor has half the City making phone calls to Landsman."
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/2612018 11 04:09 AM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/2612018 11:0409 AM(UTC-4}
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x769D2F3 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/26/201811:04:51 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513l jP.G.)
I'm sure. We can talk it all through with him at 3:30pm. I'm very dubious Greg flips to vote for the current buyout.
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox769EFEC (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/26/2018 11 :05:32 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
yeah, I think very unlikely Greg flips on current buyout deal
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x769FE08 (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0126 Respondent_124


11
3/26/2018 11 :05:39 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 'P.G.)
if it was down to 12 months, I think Greg would support it
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox769FBBD (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/26/20181:34:23 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Rocky says Harry will not take 1 year
S1atus: Read
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox76B1A03 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/26/2018 1:34:31 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513 iP.G.)
correct
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox76B181 F (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/26/20181:35:13 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
Does landsman know that
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/2612018 1:35:17 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/26120181:35:17 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db · Ox7fiR2DBB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/26/2018 1:35:30 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513, (P.G.)
probably not - or maybe does but thinks he can craft something that gets him there
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox76B2BF3 (Table: message, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/27/2018 4:44:19 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513l _Chris Seelbach)
Have you talked to Greg since he met with harry?
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/2712018 4:53:17 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/2712018 4 53:17 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox76EAFDC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/27/2018 4:53:17 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
no
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox76EA929 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/27/2018 4:53:57 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 P.G.)
he conveyed to me before that meeting that he's voting against the buyout
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox76EBFEC (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/27/2018 4:54:04 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
good
S1atus: Read
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox76EBD83 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/27/2018 4:54:08 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
is Cranley putting it on calendar?
S1atus: Read
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox76EBBAB (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/28/2018 11 :26:52 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
What is this special session about tomorrow that Cranley just called
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/2812018 11 :27 02 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox77066CA (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/28/201811:27:08AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +15131 (P.G.)
The 8 months thing
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/2812018 1127:09 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox7707FE4 (Table message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/28/2018 11 :27:36 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +151, :hris Seelbach)
so if the majority vote for that....what happens? Harry has to accept for it to matter?
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/2812018 11 :28 32 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db · Ox7707E20 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/28/2018 11 :28:38 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
Correct
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/2812018 1128:39 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox7707B99 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/28/2018 11 :28:44 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +15131 [P.G.)
He has total control
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/2812018 1128:44 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox77079E7 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/28/2018 11 :28:47 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
cool
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/281201811:2848AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox770781 F (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_o121 Respondent_125


12
3/28/2018 6:08:14 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 ;Chris Seelbach)
Question. If the 8 month severance passes tomorrow . Lets say Harry finds another job in 2 months, would he still walk away with 8 months
from us
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/28/2018 6 09:26 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x77188O3 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/28/2018 6:09:54 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
Good question. I suspect yes
S1atus: Sent
Delivered: 3/28/2018 6:09:54 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0x77185O7 (Table message, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/28/2018 6:12:56 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
Could we put something in there to prevent that? Maybe he has 2 weeks to either accept our offer or not?
S1atus:Read
Read: 3/28/2018 6:18:46 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x77183FF (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/29/2018 10:38:52 AM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
"So I'm hearing mayor is planning a press conference the week of April 9 where public services, code and others possibly including Juech
Paula and Luke will give statements about harry. I find it hard to believe the latter three would do this.

Harry's not aware of anything specific but who knows what they will say. He's trying to determine a strategy counteract someway.

Again, just speculation but wanted to share before your 11 ."


S1atus:Read
Delivered: 3/2912018 1038:59 AM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/29/2018 10:38 59 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7728FDC {Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/30/2018 2:18:43 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 _Chris Seelbach)
R you commenting on Cranley's release? Getting a ton of requests. Feel like if we're gonna respond, should be as a group
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/30/2018 2:26:42 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/30/2018 2:26:42 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x77675E6 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/30/2018 2:29:16 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
not getting asked; assuming you are because John called out your name
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox7768DEC (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/30/2018 2:29:28 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
going to be challenging if not impossible to issue a joint statement in time
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox7768891 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/30/2018 2:31:24 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 [Chris Seelbach)
My response: "The two individuals involved in this dispute will not be the leaders of it's resolution. The Council Maj ority outlined the plan to a
fair resolution two weeks ago. We're committed to implementing and overseeing that plan."
S1atus: Read
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.dh · 0Y77RR928 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/30/2018 2:31:28 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seelbach)
what do you think
S1atus: Read
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7768568 {Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/30/2018 2:32:35 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +151 :; :P.G.)
I think it's good. you could even add something more direct, like: "John needs to understand that he needs to remove himself from this
process."
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7768379 (Table: message, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/30/2018 2:32:43 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513, (P.G.)
but that might be an unneeded poke in the eye
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7769FEC (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/30/2018 2:33:22 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
if you really wanted to add some mustard, could go for: "The people are looking for answers - not just about one person, but about this whole
situation. I'm glad John is willing to bring in a neutral third party who can look into his behavior, allegations against the Manager, and anyone
else who has contributed to this mess."
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7769DC2 (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/30/2018 2:36:22 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 'Chris Seelbach)
The two individuals involved in this dispute will not be the leaders of its resolution. The Council Maj ority outlined a plan for a fair resolution
two weeks ago. We're committed to implementing and overseeing that plan. People are looking for answers - not just about one person, but
about this whole situation. I'm glad Mayor Cranley is willing to bring in a neutral third party who can look into the behavior, allegations and
responses to not only Manager Black, but all parties involved, including the Mayor himself.
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/30/2018 2:36:27 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/30/2018 2:36:27 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x7769941 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0128 Respondent_126


13
3/30/2018 2:36:24 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
what u think
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/30/2018 2:36:27 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/30/2018 2:36:27 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox7769346 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/30/2018 2:37:29 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
I think it's totally fair. if you go with the part with more zip on the end, the press might use just the last sentence. although frankly, not a huge
deal, be the article already has you saying that, just not in quote form
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox776AFEC (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/30/2018 4:27:02 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513, (Chris Seelbach)
told Harry has enough evidence of pay to play that FBI will be interested in "taking a look."
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 3/30/2018 4:30:27 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/30/2018 4:30:27 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox777BDFB (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
3/30/2018 4:30:48 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513 [P.G.)
he should find a way to get that out, even if not from him
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox777BB68 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/30/2018 4:30:53 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
changes the whole narrative
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P. G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox7778921 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/30/2018 4:31:05 PM(UTC-4)0irection:Outgoing, +1513~ ,P.G.)
especially for why John would be so eager to get rid of him
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox777871 B (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
3/30/2018 4:31:09 PM(UTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
maybe that's why Rocky is telling me?
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/30/2018 5 00:39 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox77784CE (Table: message, handle, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
3/30/2018 4:36:50 PM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513i Chris Seelbach)
ohhhh ... Harry has already talked to Enquirer about it. But I think making them hold story? He's already given story to Sherri and Dan Horn.
S1atus: Read
Read: 3/30/2018 5 00:39 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox777CFE8 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
4/2/2018 3:20:57 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 P.G.)
couple thoughts
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox77DA909 (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
4/2/2018 3:22:22 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513; _P.G.)
1) big picture, John might respond to this email hostilely, directly to you or thru the press - and accuse you of trying to silence people, even
though you're doing the opposite. just know that's a possibility
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox77DA7EB (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
4/2/2018 3:22:32 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
2) Harry himself also might not love it
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox77DM6A (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
4/2/2018 3:22:49 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513; jP.G.)
3) I'd again get a sign off on an legal dimension from Curp
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox77DBFEC (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
4/2/2018 3:23:14 PM(UTC-4)Direction:lncoming, +1513; [Chris Seelbach)
ok. do you think its worth sending at all then? Since I said basically same thing last week during council?
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 4/2/2018 323:15 PM(UTC-4)
Read: 412/2018 3:2315 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox77DBD91 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)
4/2/2018 3:23:50 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513; (P.G.)
4) those things aside, I'd put the first paragraph in present tense not past tense. in the second paragraph, I'd add Council to the list of people
who could be reported. and I'd consider replacing the word "harassment" with more encompassing "misconduct"
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox77DBAEA (Table: message, chat, Size 2207621 12 bytes)
4/2/2018 3:24:46 PM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513 (P.G.)
I can see it either way - you already said it, so not totally convinced you need to repeat. just depends. if you want all city employees to hear
this directly from you, I think you can do it. if it's more a message to someone else, I think you could also pass.
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : Ox77DB402 (Table message, chat, Size: 2207621 12 bytes)

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0129 Respondent_127


14
414/2018 10:16:13 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 _Chris Seelbach)
One question, is Harry's response to the transcripts "under oath"? Will it be considered sworn testimony?
S1atus: Read
Delivered: 4/4/2018 10:16:22 AM(UTC-4)
Read: 4/4/2018 10:16:22 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhonelvarlmobilel libraryl SMS/sms.db: Ox785EFDC (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
414/201810:16:32 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:Outgoing, +1513, (P.G.)
I think it should be, right? to be consistent
S1atus: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhonelvarlmobilel l ibraryl SMS/sms.db : Ox785ED2D (Table: message, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)
414/2018 10:16:37 AM(UTC-4)0iredion:lncoming, +1513 Chris Seelbach)
yes, should be
S1atus: Read
Source file: P.G.'s iPhonelvarlmobilel libraryl SMS/sms.db : Ox785EB01 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0130 Respondent_128


15
Chats (1) Among Councilmembers Seelbach, Sittenfeld, and Young
_:r., • The$e details are cro&e--refen!nce<I from this <levice'i 1;0nlI!ct'a

iMessage: +1513 (1)


, Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 9/B/2015 10:50:56 AM(UTC-4)


+1513: Last Adivity: 3/28/2018 10·2e ·s2 AM (U TC-4)
P G. • (owner) Number of attachments: 0
Source: iMessage + 151,
Source file: P.G.'s
1Phone/var/mobilelllbrary/ SMS/ sms.db OxB9639 FA
(Table chat handle. Size. 220762112 byles)
Body file: chat-1 . lxt
+1513:
Ct'ins Seelbach·

+1513
Wer,dell Young•

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0131 Respondent_129


'[>11',0l~U 10 ... ~.uo r"'M\U I ~JIJll~UJI.VUfUUln9t 1' (:t·1.>.l0:)~41tv,q (,...l..:t.J
Confirmed Tamaya is a ha.rd no on 18 months
Slatus: Sent
Source file: P.G: s iPhoneNar/mobile/Ubrary/SMS/sms.db 0x76C33C3 (Table message cho1f, Size· 220762112 bytes)
l!.'2812018 10:25:28 AM(UTC-4)Dicection:Oulgoing, +15131 '.G.)
Quick thing
Status: Sent
Source file: P.G.'s iPhoneivar/mobile/Ubrary/SMS/sms.db . 0x7701101 (Table: message, chat . Size 220762112 bytes)
3/28/'l018 10:26:07 AM(UTC~)Diredion:Ou~ng, +1513: P.G.)
since we've all agreed that Harry can leave voluntarily anytime he wants, but hes only getting 8 months if does, we have to make that option
real
Status: Sent
Source file: P G.'s iPhonelvar/mobilellibrary/SMS/sms.db 0x7702f'D6 (fable. message, chat. Size· 220762112 bytes)
3/28fl018 10:26:23 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outi1Qing, +1511 (P.G.J
well also completely diffuse anyone's ability to say we·re holding him "hostage"
Status: Seni
Source tile: P.G.'s iPhonelvarlmobile/Library/SMSlsms.db 0x7702CB8 (Table. message, chat, Size 22076211? byles)
3/28/2018 10:26:50 AM(UTC~)Dlrectio11:Outgoing, +'1513 tf'.G.)
T & I are requesting an ordinance saying if he ever wants to leave voluntarily, he gets the 8 months reflected in hls contract
Sllllu~: Sent
Source file: P G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/L1brary/SMSlsms.db : 0X7702A22 (Table ,nessage, chat. S12-e: 220762 112 bytes)
3128/2018 10:27:28 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Oulgolng, +1513 (P.G.)
Harry knows it's happening and said it's rine , and obviously said he just won't sign it• but understands the logic of the option being there
Stahls: Senl
Source file: P G 's 1F1>one/var/mobile/l1brary/SMSlsms.db nv77n?71E (Table. message chat, s,ze: 220762112 bytesi
~28/2018 10:28:52 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Outgoing, +1513: ' .G.)
again, it's nothing different than all of us have already said publicly, we just needed to put it in ordinance form - and Harry still retains all the
control
Status: Sent
Source file; P.G.'s iPr,one/varlmobile/Llbrary/SMSlsms.db 0x770362D (Table: message, chat Size: 220762112 bytesi

FILED UNDER E L Respondent_0132 Respondent_130


Extraction Report
Apple iPhone Logical

Between Councilmembers Seelbach and Smitherman


Chats (1)
.i. •These details are aos~nced from lhis device's contacts

iMessage: +1513: I)

# Deleted

Participants: Starl Time: 10/16/2014 11 :36:35 AM(UTC-4)


+1513: Last Activity: 3/14/2018 11:42:52 AM(UTC-4)
Chris Seelbach• (owner) Number of attachments: 0
Source: iMessage: +1513
Source file: Chris Seelbach's
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x11BD3C73
(Table: chat, handle, Size: 342745088 bytes)
+1513! Body file: chat-1 .txt
Christopher Smilhennan•

3.114/2018 9:13:04 AM(OTC-4)0irection:lncoming, +1513 Christopher Smithennan)


Councilman
I would like to discuss the City Manager and Mayor situation if you are available.
Status· Read
Read.3/14/20 18 9: 19:30AM(UTC-4)
Source file: Chris Seelbach's iPhonefvar/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0xC1544BA (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 342745088 bytes)
311412018 11 :05:43 AM(UTC-4)Direction:Oulgoing, +1513 (Chris Seelbach)
I will be at City Hall around 12:30pm if you'd like to stop by my office.
Status: Seni
Source file: Chris Seelbach's iPhone/varlmobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0xC15ADD3 (Table: message, chat, Size: 342745088 bytes)
3/1412018 11:42:52 AM{UTC-4)Direclion:lnooming, +1513 ;Christopher Smitherman)
Due to my personal life I will not be in council until late. Glad you sent text back. We will connect later.
Status: Read
Delivered: 31 14/2018 11:42:55 AM(UTC-4)
Read: 3/14/20 18 11:42:55 AM(UTC-4)
Source file: Chris Seelbach's iPhonelvar/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db: 0xC15C355 (Table: message, handle, chat, Size: 342745088 bytes)

FILED UNDER SEAL Respondent_01 36 Respondent_131


Chats (1)
Among Mayor Cranley, Councilmember Mann, and Councilmember Sittenfeld
• These details are cross-referenced from this device's contacts

iMessage: +1513 (1)

# Deleted

Participants: Start Time: 12/2/2015 2:44:00 PM(UTC-5)


+15133 Last Activity: 7/31/2018 11 :57:00 AM(UTC-4)
P.G.• (owner) Number of attachments: 1
Source: iMessage: +1513
Source file: P.G.'s
iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0xB972BE3
(Table: chat, handle, Size: 220762112 bytes)
Body file: chat-1 .txt
+1513
John Cranley•

+1513
David Mann•

. 1 n: ncomIng, + , 1 n ran
David and PG, 2 things: 1. Berding says you guys had good meeting. I'm having legislation drafted but obviously better if we all co sponsor.
As you know, they have a hard deadline in 2 weeks and we have to have some kind of public engagement. Should we release tomorrow? If
not, when? I worry we get blasted for not letting Public weigh in before vote. Let me know your thoughts; 2. David has suggested to me that
you, Tamaya and Wendell are ok with Mann/ Dennard investigation. If so, can you guys introduce by motion today at Greg's committee. If
agreement, I can shelve special counsel ordinance. Let me know . Roughly 24 people want to come forward and need a process. I'm still
open to special counsel if that is preferred.
S1atus:Read
Delivered: 4/3/2018 12:32:10 PM(UTC-4)
React 4/312018 12:32:10 PM(UTC-4)
Source file: P.G.'s iPhone/var/mobile/Library/SMS/sms.db : 0x782ADDB (Table message, handle, chat, Size: 220762112 bytes)

Respondent_132

Related Interests