Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bu©rahan Bekir Ya©cı*, Kerem Ural†, Naci appeared as whitish, verrucous, hyperkeratotic papules
Öcal* and Ali Evren Haydardedeo©lu‡ 1–2.7 mm in size. The cases were randomly assigned
to azithromycin (n = 10) and placebo treatment groups
*Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, (n = 7). Both owners and investigators were blinded to
Kirikkale University, Kirikkale, Turkey the allocation to the groups. Azithromycin (10 mg/kg)
†Republic of Turkey, The Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, was administered per os every 24 h for 10 days. Clinical
Board of High Stewards, Ankara, Turkey
evaluations were done by the same investigator
‡Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine,
Ankara University, Ankara, Turkey
throughout the trial. Azithromycin treatment signifi-
Correspondence: Dr Kerem Ural, Birlik Mahallesi 5, Cadde No: 3-6 cantly decreased clinical scores (P < 0.001), whereas
Erkan Apartmani, 06420 Cankaya, Ankara, Turkey. there was no change seen in the placebo group. In the
E-mail: uralkerem@gmail.com [correction made after online azithromycin treatment group, skin lesions disappeared
publication 20 May 2008: corresponding author details updated] in 10–15 days. One case in the placebo had spontane-
ous regression of its papillomas by day 41, but
lesions were still evident at day 50 in the remaining
What is known about the topic of this paper six cases. There was no recurrence of papillomatosis
• Azithromycin, an azalide, is a subclass macrolide antibiotic, in the azithromycin treated dogs (follow up 8 months).
effective, well-tolerated and safe therapeutic alternative
No adverse effects were seen in either group. In con-
for papillomatosis therapy in human.
• Papillomaviruses induce severe, nonregressing and clusion, azithromycin appears to be a safe and effective
recurrent infections in animal and human hosts, and are treatment for canine papillomatosis.
responsible for affecting the oral mucous membranes
Accepted 20 March 2008
and skin of young dogs and older dogs, respectively.
• The purpose of the present prospective, randomized,
double-blinded, placebo-controlled clinical trial was to
investigate the clinical efficacy of azithromycin on oral
and cutaneous papilloma in dogs.
What this paper adds to the field of veterinary This study is self-funded.
dermatology No conflicts of interest have been declared.
• The beneficial effect of azithromycin in this study is in
keeping with the therapeutic inflammatory potential effect
of azithromycin reported on human papillomatosis.
• In the present study in all treated cases, the lesions Introduction
disappeared contemporary with the classical signs of Papillomaviruses induce severe, nonregressing and
cutaneous papilloma in response to an azithromycin therapy, recurrent infections in animal and human hosts.1 Papillomas
suggesting that azithromycin therapy may be useful
affect the oral mucous membranes and skin of young and
therapy choice in most of the cases.
• Perhaps azithromycin eradicates an unknown organism older dogs, respectively.2 Although the underlying mechanisms
involved in predisposition to papillomatosis or an alternative are not completely understood,1 papillomavirus is implicated
explanation may be that it could help to suppress an as an aetiological factor in canine oral papillomatosis,1,3–5
autoimmune phenomenon leading to formation of but there is a less consistent association between cutaneous
papillomatosis. papillomas and papillomavirus in older dogs.2 Reports also
indicate that dogs with immunosuppressive disorders are
predisposed to developing canine papillomatosis.2
To the authors’ knowledge vaccination is the most
Abstract commonly used traditional treatment option in dogs with
Azithromycin, an azalide subclass macrolide antibiotic, papillomatosis. However, the lack of a commercially and
is an effective, well-tolerated and safe therapeutic readily available papillomavirus vaccine is a disadvantage.
option for treatment of papillomatosis in humans. This Individually prepared vaccines are labour intensive, which
study reports the clinical and histopathological results is not cost-effective, and cause various side-effects.
from a prospective, randomized, double-blinded, Azithromycin, an azalide subclass macrolide antibiotic,
placebo-controlled trial of 17 dogs of various breeds has been extensively tested and is licensed for the treatment
with diagnosis of oral (n = 12) and cutaneous papillo- of various clinical infections in humans and animals. It has
matosis (n = 5) treated with azithromycin. Papillomas been shown to be effective against human papillomatosis.6–10
194 © 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 ESVD and ACVD. 19; 194–198
Azithromycin therapy of canine papillomatosis
In dogs, azithromycin is administered as a tablet, suspension group) or cutaneous papillomas (n = 5; three in the azithro-
or injection formulation for the treatment of pyodermas,11 mycin group and two in the placebo group). These con-
babesiosis12 and bartonellosis.13 Given the efficacy of sisted of small round growths with a rough surface located
azithromycin in human papillomatosis, and experience of on the lips (n = 7), tongue (n = 5), nipple (n = 1), vulva-
safe use in dogs, it was hypothesized that azithromycin vaginal junction (n = 1), ventral abdomen (n = 1) and the
would also be effective and well tolerated in dogs with eyelids (n = 2). They appeared as whitish, verrucose, 1- to
papillomatosis. The purpose of this prospective, randomized, 2.7-mm papules. Results of the complete blood counts
double-blinded, placebo-controlled clinical trial was to available in nine dogs and serum chemistry panels available
investigate the clinical efficacy of azithromycin in treating in seven dogs were within normal limits.
oral and cutaneous papillomatosis in dogs. Papillomatosis was confirmed in all cases by the
histopathological examination. There was parakeratotic
hyperkeratosis, and marked acanthosis with the affected
Materials and methods epidermis three to four times thicker than neighbouring
normal epidermis and exhibiting finger-like projections into
Study design
the dermis (Fig. 1). The superficial keratinocytes were
Prospective, randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blinded clinical trial.
characterized by pycnosis and numerous keratohyalin
Animals granules, and perinuclear vacuoles that completely encir-
The dogs enrolled in this study comprised 17 breeds: Golden retriever cled the nucleus in some cases. No inclusion bodies were
(n = 4), boxer (n = 2), Beagle (n = 1), Siberian Husky (n = 3), German noticed in the keratinocytes. One case was diagnosed
shepherd dog (n = 1), Labrador retriever (n = 1), French bulldog (n = 1) with pigmented papilloma, which was characterized by
and cross-breed dogs (n = 4). presence of melanin deposition in the basal layer of the
epidermis in addition to above findings (Fig. 2).
Evaluation of lesions and laboratory work-up Treatment with azithromycin for 10 days resulted in
Physical examination was performed for all dogs. Complete blood complete healing of all skin lesions in all 10 dogs. Complete
count and serum chemistry panels were available for nine and seven dogs,
clinical remission was seen in 10–15 days. One case in the
respectively. A tentative diagnosis of oral or cutaneous papillomatosis
was made based on the history and physical examination. All dogs
placebo group showed spontaneous regression of
were anaesthetized, and biopsies of the oral and cutaneous lesions papillomas by day 41. In the remaining six cases treated
were taken for histopathological examination. Tissue samples were with placebo, papillomas were still evident by day 50. The
fixed in 10% buffered formalin, processed routinely and embedded in azithromycin treated cases were followed for 8 months,
paraffin. Four- to five-micrometre paraffin sections were stained with during which time no recurrences of papillomas were
haematoxylin and eosin. observed.
Allocation to treatment group and owners’ evaluation Investigator’s clinical scores (Fig. 3)
Dogs were randomized into the two treatment groups by tossing a
The azithromycin-treated group showed significant
coin to determine treatment group for the first case. The remaining
dogs were enrolled in alternating treatment groups. Both owners and improvement in scores at all time points from day 5
investigators were blinded regarding the allocation to groups. One (P < 0.05) to day 45 (P < 0.001) compared to baseline.
group, consisting of 10 dogs, received azithromycin suspension There were no significant changes in clinical score in the
(Zithromax®, Pfizer, New York, NY, USA) at a dosage of 10 mg/kg per
os every 24 h for 10 days, while the placebo group consisted of seven
dogs. The ingredients of the placebo included purified water.
Statistical analysis
Differences in the clinical score between the two groups on
the examination days were assessed using Mann–Whitney U-tests. The
clinical success rates of each treatment group were compared on the
examination days by using Wilcoxon tests (Windows version of SPSS
13.0, SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). Significance was defined as P < 0.05.
Results
Figure 1. Papillomatosis showing severe acanthosis, with the affected
Physical examination of the present dogs revealed no epidermis three to four times thicker than neighbouring normal
dermatological abnormalities, other than the oral (n = 12; epidermis, and finger-like projections into the dermis. Haematoxylin
seven in the azithromycin group and five in the placebo and eosin, ×120.
© 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 ESVD and ACVD. 195
Ya©cı et al.
196 © 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 ESVD and ACVD.
Azithromycin therapy of canine papillomatosis
Résumé L’azithromycine, un antibiotique azalide de la sous classe des macrolides, est efficace, bien
toléré et sûr pour le traitement de la papillomatose de l’homme. Cette étude rapporte les résultats cliniques
et histopathologiques d’une étude randomisée, prospective, en double aveugle contrôlée par placebo, de
17 chiens de races variées souffrant de papillomatose orale (n = 12) ou cutanée (n = 5) traitée avec l’azithromycine.
Les papillomes apparaissaient comme des papules blanchâtres, verruqueusesn hyperkératosiques, d’une
taille de 1–2.7 mm. les chiens ont été traités soit par l’azithromycine (n = 10) ou par le placebo (n = 7).
Les propriétaires comme le vétérinaire ne savaient pas le traitement administré. L’azithromycine (10 mg/kg)
a été administrée par voie orale tous les jours pendant 10 jours. Les évaluations cliniques étaient réalisées
par le même investigateur pendant toute l’étude. Le traitement avec l’azithromycine a permis une diminution
significative des scores cliniques (P < 0.001), alors qu’aucune modification n’a été observée dans le groupe
placebo. Dans le groupe azithromycine les lésions ont disparu en 10–15 jours. Un cas du groupe placebo
a présenté une régression spontanée des lésions à J41, mais des lésions étaient toujours évidentes à J50
pour les 6 autres cas. Aucune récurrence n’a été observée dans le groupe azithromycine après un suivi de
8 mois. aucun effet secondaire n’a été observé. En conclusion, l’azithromycine apparait comme un
traitement efficace et sûr de la papillomatose canine.
© 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 ESVD and ACVD. 197
Ya©cı et al.
Resumen La azitromicina, un antibiótico macrólido en la subclase de las azalidas, es una terapia efectiva,
bien tolerada y segura para el tratamiento de la papilomatosis en seres humanos. Este estudio presenta los
resultados clínicos e histopatológicos de un estudio prospectivo, al azar, doble ciego y controlado por
placebo en 17 perros de varias razas con diagnóstico previo de papilomatosis oral (n = 12) y cutánea (n = 5)
tratados con azitromicina. Los papilomas se presentaban en forma de pápulas hiperqueratóticas blanquecinas y
verrugosas de 1–2.7 mm de tamaño. Los casos se asignaron al azar al grupo de tratamiento con azitromicina
(n = 10) o al grupo placebo (n = 7). Tanto los dueños como los investigadores desconocían la distribución
de los animales en los grupos. La azitromicina (10 mg/kg) se administró por vía oral cada 24 horas durante
10 días. La evaluación clínica fue hecha por el mismo investigador durante la prueba. El tratamiento
con azitromicina redujo de forma significativa los valores clínicos (P < 0.001), mientras que no hubo cambios
en el grupo placebo. En el grupo tratado con azitromicina las lesiones desaparecieron en 10–15 días. Un
caso placebo presentó regresión espontánea de los papilomas en el día 41, pero las lesiones eran aun
evidentes en los seis perros restantes en el día 50. No hubo recurrencia de la papilomatosis en los animales
tratados con azitromicina (seguimiento durante 8 meses). No se observaron efectos adversos en
ninguno de los grupos. En resumen, concluimos que la azitromicina parece ser un tratamiento seguro y
efectivo frente a la papilomatosis canina.
198 © 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 ESVD and ACVD.