Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/23235022
CITATIONS READS
33 1,234
4 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
The social relations of general health professionals in the provision of care to people with serious mental illness in general hospital wards: a substantive constructivist
grounded theory View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Scott Brunero on 23 October 2017.
Correspondence: BRUNERO S., SMITH J., BATES E. & FAIRBROTHER G. (2008) Journal of
S. Brunero Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 15, 588–594
Prince of Wales Hospital Health professionals attitudes towards suicide prevention initiatives
NERU
High Street Preventing suicide can depend upon the ability of a range of different health professionals
Randwick
to make accurate suicide risk assessments and treatment plans. The attitudes that clinicians
NSW 2031
hold towards suicide prevention initiatives may influence their suicide risk assessment and
Australia
management skills. This study measures a group of non-mental health professionals’ atti-
Email: scott.brunero@
sesiahs.health.nsw.gov.au
tude towards suicide prevention initiatives. Health professionals that had attended suicide
prevention education showed significantly more positive attitudes towards suicide preven-
tion initiatives. The findings in this study further support the effectiveness of educating
non-mental health professionals in suicide risk awareness and management.
588 © 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Attitudes towards suicide
emergency department nurses’ attitudes towards suicidal positive attitudes? (2) Do Staff with professional experience
behaviour using some items from the ‘Suicide Opinion in working with suicidal patients have more positive atti-
Questionnaire’ (Domino et al. 1982) and new statements tudes? (3) Does personal experience with suicide result in
created by the study authors. Both groups of nurses gener- more positive ATSP initiatives?
ally reported positive attitudes with no statistically signifi-
cant difference found between them. Some differences in Method
attitude were associated with length of experience. Com-
munity mental health nurses with less experience had A cross-sectional survey using the ‘ATSP Scale’ (Herron
significantly more positive attitudes, while there was no et al. 2001), was conducted among a sample of nurses,
difference in attitude among accident and emergency nurses midwives and allied health professionals working at one
in relation to length of experience. Younger community hospital campus of the South Eastern Sydney Illawarra
mental health nurses had marginally more positive atti- Area Health Service. The ATSP Scale was chosen as the
tudes, while accident and emergency nurses showed measure of staff attitude, as it is directly concerned with
no difference in attitude with regard to age ATSP and showed good internal consistency (Cronbach’s
(Anderson 1997). Samuelsson & Asberg (2002) studied alpha = 0.77) and high test–retest reliability in the valida-
psychiatric nurses in Sweden using the ‘Understanding of tion study (Herron et al. 2001). Personal and work-related
Suicide Attempt Scale’. The authors found that attitudes demographic information was also collected, as well as
towards working with suicidal patients were significantly information which indicated prior suicide awareness edu-
improved in the area of understanding and willingness to cation exposure and exposure to suicide in respondents’
work with this patient group, following a 12-session edu- work and personal life. Two hundred and forty (n = 240)
cation programme. Morriss et al. (1999) in the UK, devised healthcare professionals were mailed the survey via the
and evaluated a training package for non-psychiatrically internal hospital network, in February 2006. The South
trained staff to assess suicide risk and to manage the sui- Eastern Sydney Ethics Committee approved the study. All
cidal patient. At 1-month post rating, significant improve- data were entered into spss version 14.0 for analysis.
ments in problem solving, provision of immediate support
and future coping were shown. The ‘Attitudes to Suicide Suicide prevention education
Prevention (ATSP) Scale’ (Herron et al. 2001) was used by Suicide prevention education had recently been in place,
Appleby et al. (2000) in the UK to assess success of staff with attendance on a voluntary basis, between November
training in primary care services, emergency departments 2005 and January 2006 at the study site. Using a problem-
and mental health services. Attitudes improved signifi- based learning framework (Trevena 2007), an educational
cantly only for the emergency department group. Herron package comprising of a 1-h face-to-face group session and
et al. (2001) used the ATSP Scale to show more positive follow-up self-directed material was developed. Groups of
attitudes among mental health professionals than general health professionals, ranging in size from 6 to 15, attended
practitioners (GPs) and emergency department nurses. In the sessions. Using group facilitation skills, sessions began
this study, positive attitude was associated with previous by asking clinicians to think of a clinical case where a
training in suicide risk assessment. patient they had been working had become suicidal. Once
Botega et al. (2005) in Brazil, developed the ‘Suicide a clinical case was identified, the case was then referred to
Behaviour Attitude Questionnaire’ using a sample of 317 throughout the hour discussion. Participant’s attitudes
nurses. These authors found that belief in the right to were then challenged; information on suicide rates, suicide
suicide is stronger among older professionals, those who risk factors, ATSP and management of the suicidal patient
had taken care of suicidal patients, those who had a family were interwoven into the discussion session. A handout
history of suicide, those who were of Protestant religion and information on how to access hospital-wide policies
and those that attended church more frequently. and NSW department of health ‘Suicide risk assessment
and management training’ e-learning package was also
Study aim distributed (Department of Health 2004).
© 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 589
S. Brunero et al.
590 © 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Attitudes towards suicide
Table 2
Individual Attitudes to Suicide Prevention items by prior suicide awareness training (n = 134)
Statement
Previous training No previous training
1 = strongly disagree
2 = disagree Median Median
3 = uncertain Overall 1
(% in agreement) (% in agreement)1
4 = agree median
5 = strongly agree score n = 44 n = 90 P2
1. I resent being asked to do more about suicide 2 2 (0) 2 (8) 0.01*
2. Suicide prevention is not my responsibility 2 2 (2) 2 (12) 0.005*
3. Making more funds available to the appropriate health services would 2 2 (9) 2 (8) 0.49
make no difference to the suicide rate
4. Working with suicidal patients is rewarding 3 3 (19) 3 (6) 0.03*
5. If people are serious about committing suicide they don’t tell anyone 3 2 (18) 3 (22) 0.009*
6. I feel defensive when people offer advice about suicide prevention 2 2 (0) 2 (4) 0.24
7. It is easy for people not involved in clinical practice to make judgements 3 4 (52) 3 (46) 0.34
about suicide prevention
8. If a person survives a suicide attempt then this was a ploy for attention 2 2 (11) 2 (12) 0.03*
9. People have the right to take their own lives 3 3 (23) 3 (21) 0.17
10. As unemployment and poverty are the main causes of suicide, there is 2 2 (2) 2 (4) 0.39
little that an individual can do to prevent it
11. I don’t feel comfortable assessing someone for suicide risk 4 2.5 (39) 4 (57) 0.003*
12. Suicide prevention measures are a draw on resources, which would be 2 2 (2) 2 (6) 0.15
more useful elsewhere
13. There is no way of knowing who is going to commit suicide 3 2 (14) 3 (19) 0.05
14. What proportion of suicides do you consider preventable (none to all) 2 2 (18) 3 (16) 0.34
1
Per cent in agreement calculated by adding 4’s and 5’s on the Likert scale. 2Difference between previously trained staff and non-previously trained
staff (Mann–Whitney U-test).
*P < 0.05.
and non-trained staff in a positive direction for trained reported UK means for GPs and emergency nurses but not
staff. As supported by other studies (Neimeyer & Pfeiffer as low as the mean for community psychiatric nurses, who
1994, Morriss et al. 1999, Appleby et al. 2000, Samuelsson may be considered as an expert group. These results are
& Asberg 2002), targeted training can have an effect on encouraging and set a benchmark for non-mental health
improving attitudes, skills and knowledge. The second professionals in Australia.
study question – whether professional experience with In Table 2, summary of differences between trained and
suicide has an effect on attitude – was not supported in this untrained staff on individual ATSP items yields an encour-
study. This finding runs counter to those of Samuelsson & aging picture with regards the effects of a suicide preven-
Asberg (2002) and Botega et al. (2005) who found that tion programme. The by-item results between trained and
professional experience of treating a suicidal patient was untrained staff are mostly reassuring. For example, there
associated with more positive attitudes (Samuelsson & was little agreement with the idea that ‘suicide prevention
Asberg 2002, Botega et al. 2005). measures are a draw on resources, which would be more
The third question, personal experience with suicide useful elsewhere’ in either group (2.3% trained vs. 5.6%
(family, close friend or others), was shown to be related non-trained). Appleby et al. (2000) surveyed 82 mental
to more positive attitude. Botega et al. (2005) demon- and non-mental health staff in the UK using the ATSP.
strated a positive effect of personal experience on attitudes. This study showed a positive training effect. Five ATSP
Neimeyer et al. (2001) found a negative relationship items showed a significant difference between trained and
between personal history of suicidal behaviour and suicide untrained staff with only one ATSP item concurring with
counselling skills, which was significant in professionally our study finding: ‘If people are serious about committing
trained personnel. suicide they don’t tell anyone’.
Midwives, nurses and allied health professionals showed In Table 3, analysis of individual ATSP items by subject
no statistically significant difference in total ATSP scores. characteristics indicates that time in speciality is a domi-
Herron et al. (2001), using the ATSP in a UK study, nant meditating effect on attitude. Greater time in specialty
reported significant difference on attitude between emer- correlates with higher ATSP scores or more negative atti-
gency nurses mean total (37.9), GPs (37.2), community tudes in six of the 14 items. It is difficult to gauge the
psychiatric nurses (31.9) and psychiatrists (34.4). Overall reasons for this, but the finding is not new. Anderson
mean total score in our study was 35.2 – less than then (1997) located a similar negative association among
© 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 591
S. Brunero et al.
Table 3
Significant relationships between subject characteristics and the 14 individual ATSP items (n = 134)
Subject characteristic(s) significantly associated
ATSP questionnaire item with agreement to item Statistic employed P
1. I resent being asked to do more about suicide Staff category = nursing/midwifery Mann–Whitney test, z = -2.5 0.01
Greater time in specialty Spearman’s rho = 0.19 0.03
Had a patient attempt suicide = No Mann–Whitney test, z = -2.5 0.01
2. Suicide prevention is not my responsibility Greater time in specialty Spearman’s rho = 0.28 0.001
3. Making more funds available to the Staff category = nursing/midwifery Mann–Whitney test, z = -1.9 0.05
appropriate health services would make no
difference to the suicide rate
4. Working with suicidal patients is rewarding Staff category = non-nursing/midwifery Mann–Whitney test, z = -2.2 0.03
5. If people are serious about committing suicide Greater time in specialty Spearman’s rho = 0.19 0.025
they don’t tell anyone Had a patient attempt suicide = No Mann–Whitney test, z = -3.0 0.003
Had close family or friend commit suicide = No Mann–Whitney test, z = -2.7 0.007
Had close family or friend attempt suicide = No Mann–Whitney test, z = -2.0 0.05
6. I feel defensive when people offer advice Greater time in specialty Spearman’s rho = 0.30 <0.0001
about suicide prevention
7. It is easy for people not involved in clinical Have attempted suicide = No Mann–Whitney test, z = -2.3 0.02
practice to make judgements about suicide
prevention
8. If a person survives a suicide attempt then this Had a close family or friend commit Mann–Whitney test, z = -2.1 0.04
was a ploy for attention suicide = No
9. People have the right to take their own lives Had a patient attempt suicide = Yes Mann–Whitney test, z = -2.0 0.04
Had a patient commit suicide = Yes Mann–Whitney test, z = -2.5 0.01
10. As unemployment and poverty are the main No significant associations – –
causes of suicide, there is little that an
individual can do to prevent it
11. I don’t feel comfortable assessing someone for Greater time in specialty Spearman’s rho = 0.35 <0.0001
suicide risk
12. Suicide prevention measures are a draw on Had close family or friend attempt Mann–Whitney test, z = -2.0 0.04
resources, which would be more useful suicide = No
elsewhere
13. There is no way of knowing who is going to Greater time in specialty Spearman’s rho = 0.28 0.001
commit suicide
14. What proportion of suicides do you consider No significant associations – –
preventable (none to all)
ATSP, Attitudes to Suicide Prevention.
community mental health nurses and Botega et al. (2005) depression. Hem et al. (2000) in a cross-sectional survey of
found a correlation between negative attitude and older age physicians found that 3.1% of female physicians (n = 287)
among a sample of nurses. McLaughlin (1994), in a survey had made a suicide attempt. This was significantly greater
of casualty nurses in the UK, found the opposite, with older than the rate among male physicians (0.9%). Suicide death
age and more experience being associated with more posi- rate among healthcare workers compared with all other
tive attitudes. At this point, the key interpretation of these suicides in a study in the UK showed that female nurses
very mixed findings is to ensure that all staff attend training were one and a half times more likely to die from suicide
despite their length of time of employment or within their when compared with the general population (Kelly &
speciality. Bunting 1998). Clearly, nurses and doctors are among the
Personal exposure to attempted suicide and actual highest risk groups for suicide, yet they are also the people
suicide attempt among staff members appears high in our who are assisting in the front line for its prevention, treat-
study, although there are few studies to benchmark this ment and management. Neimeyer et al. (2001) demon-
against. A lifetime attempt at suicide was reported by 4.5% strated that a personal history of suicidality and a belief
of health professionals in our study. The current Australian that suicide is a personal right accounted for modest, but
general population attempted suicide rate is reported at significant negative variance in a measure of suicide pre-
300 per 100 000 for females and 150 per 100 000 for vention skill level, beyond that which was accounted for by
males. Expressed as a percentage, the female rate is 0.3% professional factors. Our finding that more positive atti-
(Andrews et al. 1999). Frank & Dingle (1999) in a study of tudes related to personal exposure differs from that of
US women physicians found that in a sample of 4501, Neimeyer et al. (2001). This issue will need more thorough
1.5% had attempted suicide and 19.5% had a history of research analysis in the future.
592 © 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Attitudes towards suicide
© 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 593
S. Brunero et al.
Neimeyer R. & Pfeiffer A. (1994) Evaluation of suicide interven- Trevena L. (2007) Problem-based learning in the public health
tion effectiveness. Death Studies 18, 131–166. workforce training: a discussion of educational; principles and
Neimeyer R., Fortner B. & Melby D. (2001) Personal and profes- evidence. NSW Public Health Bulletin 18, 3–8.
sional factors and suicide intervention skills. Suicide and Life Valente S. (2002) Overcoming barriers to suicide risk manage-
Threatening Behaviour 31, 71–82. ment. Journal of Psychosocial Nursing and Mental Health
Samuelsson M. & Asberg M. (2002) Training program in suicide Services 40, 22–33.
prevention for psychiatric nursing personnel enhance attitudes Valente S. & Saunders J. (2004) Barriers to suicide risk manage-
to attempted suicide patients. International Journal of Nursing ment in clinical practice: a national survey of oncology nurses.
Studies 39, 115–121. Issues in Mental Health Nursing 25, 629–648.
Suominen K., Isometsa E., Heila H., et al. (2002) General hospital White R., Gribble R. & Corr M., et al. (1995) Jumping from
suicides – a psychological autopsy study in Finland. General a general hospital. General Hospital Psychiatry 17, 208–
Hospital Psychiatry 24, 412–416. 215.
594 © 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd