You are on page 1of 4

Surrogacy(regulation) bill 2016

On 21st November 2016 the 228th report of law commission had recommended prohibition of
commercial surrogacy in India.
Surrogacy(regulation)bill 2016 has been a major decision taken by the bench towards
regulation of surrogacy practices in India. The bill focuses on prevention of commercial
surrogacy, exploitation of surrogate mothers and children born through surrogacy.
Surrogacy means, “a woman who becomes pregnant usually by artificial insemination or
surgical implantation of a fertilized egg for the purpose of carrying the foetus to term for
another woman.” Thus “surrogacy is part of third-party reproduction which can include oocytes
(eggs bought in the baby bazaar), sperm, and embryos.”

Surrogacy in India
India is considered to be the global hub for surrogacy. Infertile parents from different
countries come to India to opt for baby’s birth through surrogacy. Western Gujrat,
Hyderabad and Mumbai are the main surrogacy centres in India.
As per 2009 law commission report the surrogacy industry in India of worth Rs.25000
crores. It is currently estimated a business of 2 dollars billion industry.
Before the ban foreigners accounted for 80% of surrogacy births in our country. In the
year 2002 India became the first country to legalise commercial surrogacy and in the
year 2012 India was named as the surrogacy capital.
Despite this growing prominence of the Indian surrogacy industry in recent years, it is
strange but true that the surrogacy practices in India remain largely unregulated.

The Trigger
The debate began in 2008, a Japanese couple commissioned a baby in a small town of
Gujrat. The surrogate mother gave birth to a healthy baby girl. By then the couple got
divorced and the baby was parentless and stateless caught between the legal system of
both the countries.
In 2012, an Australian couple who had twins by surrogacy, rejected one and took home
the other.
A single mother of two from Chennai decided to become a surrogate mother in the hope
that she will start a shop near her house. Unfortunately, she was paid only 75,000 rupees
by the autorickshaw driver and taking a 50% cut, who served as the middle man in the
surrogacy business.
On January 2014, a 26-year-old Yuma Sherpa died in the aftermath of a surgical
procedure to harvest eggs from her body, as a part of the egg donation programme of a
private clinic in New Delhi.
The Bill
August 2017, Parliamentary Standing Committee submitted its 102nd report on the
Surrogacy(regulation) bill 2016 and it was tabled in Rajya Sabha and in Lok Sabha on
10th August 2017. The report gives the analysis of the nature of the bill.
Surrogacy bill 2016 shall be applicable to whole of the India except Jammu and
Kashmir.
The bill regulates the commercial surrogacy and highlights on altruistic surrogacy in
which no expenses are to be paid other than medical expenditure, and also it protects
the surrogate mother as well as the baby born through surrogacy. The bill has put a
strict prohibition on clinics stating neither getting involved into commercial surrogacy
nor shall offer, conduct, promote and undertake or associate with commercial
surrogacy. All Assisted Reproductive Technology clinics will need to be registered.
It also bans foreigners and homosexual, single parent, live-in and NRI’s from opting
surrogacy.
The bill allows surrogacy for Indian married couples after 5 years of marriage with an
official certificate of a doctor declaring the couple to be medically unfit to give birth to
a child.
Women within the age group of 23 to 50 years and men aged between 26 to 55 years
will be eligible for going through surrogacy.

Altruistic surrogacy
Altruistic surrogacy refers to an arrangement where the surrogate does not receive
money for her service but for the medical expenses. Many of the arrangements are made
within family members or close friends.
The expenses to be paid are-

 Medical expenses, including the embryo transfer or artificial insemination, fertility


injections, and labour and delivery costs
 Donation fees if an egg donor or sperm donor if required.
 Attorney fees
 Counselling expenses
 Additional fees, including maternity clothing and travel costs to transport her to and
from appointments
 Agency fees

Eligibility for surrogacy


 Indian married couple who are medically declared unfit for producing a baby.
 The couple must not have any child, neither adopted nor natural.
 Women of age 23-50 years and Men of age 26-55 years of age.
 Only close relative can be approached for ‘altruistic’ surrogacy.

Penalty
Any intending couple or person or any clinic getting involved into commercial
surrogacy will be charged a heavy fine of 5 lakhs and imprisonment of 5 years and
repeated offenders will have to face a fine of 10 lakhs and imprisonment of 10 years.
Whoever contravenes the act will have to face imprisonment for not less than 3 years,
5 lakhs fine and repeated offenders might be charged with additional 10,000 rupees fine
per day.
Analysis
In India, infertility is generally known to be a sin. The trauma of infertility is best
described and felt by the married infertile couples.
Hence surrogacy is considered as the ultimate option by many of the couples resulting
in win-win situation for both, the couple as well as the surrogate mother.
The Assisted Reproductive Technology has helped millions of infertile couples who
have got medical complications.
But the banning of surrogacy has shattered millions of couple’s dream of becoming
parents.
The bill, rather than safeguarding surrogacy through strict and transparent mechanism,
the government has banned the commercial surrogacy.
The bill does not even define the term ‘close relative’ properly, which might to
exploitation of law by wrongfully using the ‘close relative’ clause.
The value of the so-called surrogacy industry of India is 2 billion dollars, which has
now come down to null.
Besides, if surrogacy is banned, a black market will surely emerge where middle-men
would take away the financial benefits and women would lose both income and
adequate parental care.
Conclusion
However, the Surrogacy Bill will curb unethical practices and protect the exploitation
of surrogates by middlemen and will also keep a check on illegal acts like flesh trade
and many more.

You might also like