You are on page 1of 1

People VS Borromeo

Facts:

 On July 3, 1981, the four year old niece of Elias and Susana Borromeo reported to Matilde
Taborada, mother of Susana, that Susana was shouting frantically for help because Elias was killing
her. Thereby, Matilde went and asked for help from her son, Geronimo.
 Upon coming back, Geronimo peeped through the bamboo slats where he saw Susana lying down,
motionless, apprently dead beside her one-month old child who was crying and Elias mumbling
incoherently still with the weapon in his hands.
 The appelant contends that he and Susana were legally and validly married in a church wedding
ceremony and there was no marriage contract executed on the occasion; hence, the accused
could only be liable for homicide, and not parricide.
 The Circuit Criminal Court sentence Elias guilty beyond reasonable doubt of the crime of parricide
and sentencing him the penalty of reclusion perpetua with the accessory penalties of the law.
Hence the appeal.

Issue:

WON there was a valid marriage between the accused-appellant and the deceased-victim?

Ruling:

There is no better proof of marriage than the admission of the accused of the existence of such marriage.
(Tolentino vs. Paras, 122 SCRA 525).

Person living together in apparent matrimony are presumed, in the law, in the absence of any counter
presumption or evidence special to the case, to be in fact married. The reason is that such is the common
order of society, and if the parties were not what they thus hold themselves out as being, they would be
living in constant violation of decency and law. (Son Cui vs. Guepangco, 22 Phil. 216) The presumption in
favor of matrimony is one of the strongest known in law. The law presumes morality, and not immorality;
marriage, and not concubinage: legitimacy, and not bastardy. There is the presumption that persons living
together as husband and wife are married to each other.

And, the mere fact that no record of the marriage exists in the registry of marriage does not invalidate
said marriage, as long as in the celebration thereof, all requisites for its validity are present. Furthermore,
the validity of a marriage resides on the fulfillment or presence of the requisites of the marriage which
are: legal capacity and consent.

17