Company: Contractor:

Project No.
REVAMPING OF WASTE WATER TREATMENT FACILITY IN ETHYLENE PLANT AT
QAPCO

COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

WWT-P06-23450-001_A- CRS PIPING GA FOR EQUILIZATION TANK AREA- CRS Rev. A

Sl. No QAPCO Comments Contractor Response QAPCO Reply

GENERAL COMMENTS
1.1 Full size Piping Key Plan drawing shall be provided.
Drawing scale shall be assigned generally for the
drawing. For special view or detail there may be different
1.2
scale that shall be shown on the view. General scale for
piping GA shall not be less than 1:60.
1.3 Please draw line size 8" and larger with double line.
1.4 Please draw piping lines bolder than accessory lines.
Comment incorporated.
Full Size Piping Key Plan Drawing WWT-P06-00450-101-01
submitted for Review and Approval
Comment incorporated.
Submitted Piping GAs are in 1:50 scale meeting QAPCO
requirement. Three sheets are added now to include sections
and details to provide more clarity as required by QAPCO.
This will require major revision on all piping GAs hence
deliverables will be delayed. Will revise the drawing to show
double lines for 12” and above as per normal practice.
Comment incorporated.

1.5 Please show all equipment tag no. Comment incorporated.

Show coordinate of equipment on the CL or a reference
Comment incorporated.
1.6 point. Deviation angle from normal co-ordinate lines
shall be shown.
1.7 Line numbers shall be shown on each edge of the line Comment incorporated.
(or at borderline), when any change in direction and
when interfere with other line. Or whenever needed to

Page 1 of 2 438531254.doc
Company: Contractor:

Project No.
REVAMPING OF WASTE WATER TREATMENT FACILITY IN ETHYLENE PLANT AT
QAPCO

COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

show any unclear portion.

Pipe elevation shall be shown. For flat lines, BOP shall

be shown under the line number. For slope lines, WP Comment incorporated.
1.8
elevation shall be shown on every change in direction or
elevation and branches.
Deviation angle between true and Plant North shall be Comment incorporated.
1.9 shown.
Changemark #02
2.1 Please show properly as per piping drawing standard Comment incorporated.
practice.
Changemark #03 Comment incorporated.
3.1 Detail drawing.
Sections & Details added for giving clarity. Additional Sheets
2 of 3 & 3 of 3
Changemark #04 Comment incorporated.
4.1 Please show properly Sections & Details added for giving clarity. Additional Sheets
2 of 3 & 3 of 3

Page 2 of 2 438531254.doc