You are on page 1of 11

Skip to main content

0972CV00829 Starkey, H Christopher et al vs. Deutsche Bank National


Trust Company et al

• Case Type
• Contract / Business Cases
• Case Status
• Re-Opened
• File Date
• 11/20/2009
• DCM Track:
• F - Fast Track
• Initiating Action:
• Other Contract Action
• Status Date:
• 01/30/2019
• Case Judge:

• Next Event:
• 07/31/2020

All Information Party Event Tickler Docket Disposition

Party Information
Starkey, H Christopher
- Plaintiff
Alias

Party Attorney
• Attorney
• Russell, Jr., Esq., Glenn F
• Bar Code
• 656914
• Address
• Law Office of Glenn F. Russell, Jr.
38 Rock St
Suite 12
Fall River, MA 02720
• Phone Number
• (508)324-4545
More Party Information

Starkey, Louisa H
- Plaintiff
Alias

Party Attorney
• Attorney
• Russell, Jr., Esq., Glenn F
• Bar Code
• 656914
• Address
• Law Office of Glenn F. Russell, Jr.
38 Rock St
Suite 12
Fall River, MA 02720
• Phone Number
• (508)324-4545
More Party Information
Deutsche Bank National Trust Company
- Defendant
Alias

Party Attorney
• Attorney
• Bresnahan, Esq., Elizabeth Marie
• Bar Code
• 672577
• Address
• Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP
One Federal St
Boston, MA 02110
• Phone Number
• (617)951-8638
• Attorney
• Brown, Esq., Vanessa
• Bar Code
• 697097
• Address
• Morgan Lewis & Bockius
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02110
• Phone Number
• (617)341-7822
• Attorney
• George, Esq., Wayne E
• Bar Code
• 656286
• Address
• Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP
One Federal St
Boston, MA 02110
• Phone Number
• (617)341-7596
• Attorney
• Solomont, Esq., Charles L
• Bar Code
• 557190
• Address
• Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02110
• Phone Number
• (617)951-8996
More Party Information

JP Morgan Chase Bank NA


- Defendant
Alias

Party Attorney
• Attorney
• Bresnahan, Esq., Elizabeth Marie
• Bar Code
• 672577
• Address
• Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP
One Federal St
Boston, MA 02110
• Phone Number
• (617)951-8638
• Attorney
• Brown, Esq., Vanessa
• Bar Code
• 697097
• Address
• Morgan Lewis & Bockius
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02110
• Phone Number
• (617)341-7822
• Attorney
• Solomont, Esq., Charles L
• Bar Code
• 557190
• Address
• Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02110
• Phone Number
• (617)951-8996
More Party Information

Chase Home Finance LLC


- Defendant
Alias

Party Attorney
• Attorney
• Brown, Esq., Vanessa
• Bar Code
• 697097
• Address
• Morgan Lewis & Bockius
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02110
• Phone Number
• (617)341-7822
• Attorney
• George, Esq., Wayne E
• Bar Code
• 656286
• Address
• Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP
One Federal St
Boston, MA 02110
• Phone Number
• (617)341-7596
More Party Information

Washington Mutual Inc


- Defendant
Alias

Party Attorney
More Party Information

Washington Mutual Bank FA


- Defendant
Alias

Party Attorney
More Party Information

Washington Mutual Mortgage Service Corporation


- Defendant
Alias

Party Attorney
• Attorney
• George, Esq., Wayne E
• Bar Code
• 656286
• Address
• Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP
One Federal St
Boston, MA 02110
• Phone Number
• (617)341-7596
More Party Information

Washington Mutual Mortgage Securities Corporation


- Defendant
Alias

Party Attorney
More Party Information

Events
Date Session Location Type Event Judge Result
12/04/2009 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
04/02/2010 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
04/20/2010 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
06/10/2010 02:00 Second Rule 12 Hearing Rescheduled
PM Session
06/22/2010 02:00 Second Rule 12 Hearing Not Held
PM Session
06/24/2010 02:00 Second Rule 12 Hearing Rescheduled
PM Session
08/12/2010 02:00 Second Rule 12 Hearing Not Held
PM Session
10/05/2010 02:00 Second Rule 12 Hearing Not Held
PM Session
01/03/2011 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
02/01/2011 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
04/01/2011 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
05/13/2011 09:00 Second Status Review Canceled
AM Session
06/16/2011 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
01/19/2012 09:00 Second Status Review Canceled
AM Session
06/19/2012 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
07/23/2012 09:00 Second Status Review Canceled
AM Session
08/06/2012 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
02/11/2013 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
03/21/2013 02:00 Second Status Review Held as
PM Session Scheduled
Status Review
Date Session Location Type Event Judge Result
09/18/2013 09:00 Second Held as
AM Session Scheduled
10/30/2013 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
04/30/2014 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
06/16/2014 09:00 Second Status Review Held as
AM Session Scheduled
07/18/2014 10:00 Second Final Pre-Trial Conference Canceled
AM Session
08/19/2014 02:30 Second Rule 12 Hearing Held as
PM Session Scheduled
07/03/2015 10:00 Second Courtroom Rule 56 Hearing Nickerson, Hon. Gary Held as
AM Session 2 A Scheduled
10/16/2015 10:30 Second Courtroom Final Pre-Trial Conference Canceled
AM Session 2
03/08/2019 10:30 Second Courtroom Rule 16 Conference Sullivan, Hon. Susan Held as
AM Session 2 E Scheduled
10/15/2019 02:15 Second Courtroom Hearing for Judgment on Perrino, Hon. Held as
PM Session 2 Pleading Thomas J Scheduled
07/31/2020 10:30 Third Session Courtroom Final Pre-Trial Conference
AM 3

Ticklers
Tickler Start Date Due Date Days Due Completed Date
Service 11/20/2009 02/18/2010 90 12/01/2009
Answer 11/20/2009 03/22/2010 122 12/01/2009
Rule 12/19/20 Served By 11/20/2009 03/19/2010 119 02/17/2016
Rule 12/19/20 Filed By 11/20/2009 04/19/2010 150 02/17/2016
Rule 12/19/20 Heard By 11/20/2009 11/30/2010 375 02/17/2016
Rule 15 Served By 11/20/2009 12/30/2010 405 02/17/2016
Rule 15 Filed By 11/20/2009 04/19/2010 150 02/17/2016
Rule 15 Heard By 11/20/2009 01/14/2011 420 02/17/2016
Discovery 03/08/2019 02/28/2020 357
Rule 56 Served By 11/20/2009 05/14/2015 2001 02/17/2016
Rule 56 Filed By 03/08/2019 05/28/2020 447
Final Pre-Trial Conference 03/08/2019 07/31/2020 511
Judgment 11/20/2009 09/11/2011 660 07/27/2016
Under Advisement 07/03/2015 09/02/2015 61 08/26/2015
Status Review 11/18/2016 12/16/2016 28 11/28/2016
Review Appeals Filed 11/21/2016 01/18/2019 788 02/12/2019

Docket Information
Docket Docket Text File Image
Date Ref Avail.
Nbr.
11/20/2009 COMPLAINT with jury claim & civil action cover sheet filed 1
11/20/2009 Origin 1, Type A99, Track F. (copy to GR 11/24/09)
11/20/2009 Filing fee paid in the amount of $275.00 including $15.00 surcharge
and $20.00 security fee.
11/24/2009 NOTICE of 93A complaint sent to Attorney General with copy of 2
complaint
12/01/2009 MOTION: Plaintiffs' to dismiss, defendant, Washington Mutual, Inc., 3
under Mass. R. Civ. P. 21 (no action taken see #4)
12/04/2009 Notice of voluntary dismissal under 41(a)(1)(i) as to deft., 4
Washington Mutual, Inc., only (Allowed, John S. Dale, First Asst
Clerk)
12/16/2009 Stipulation to extend time for Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, 5
JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., Chase Home Finance, LLC, Washington Mutual
Bank, FA, and Washington Mutual Mortgage Securities Corporation to
file an answer/responsive pleading to the complaint to and including
1/8/2010
01/15/2010 NOTICE: Defendant JP Morgan Chase Bank NA, Chase Home Finance LLC and 6
Washington Mutual Mortgage Service Corporation's, of intent to file
motion to dismiss
01/15/2010 NOTICE: Defendant Deutsche Bank National Trust Company's of intent to 7
file motion to dismiss
03/10/2010 ORDER OF DISMISSAL (SON 1-88) re: Washington Mutual Bank FA and 8
Washington Mutual Mortgage Securities Corporation; service not
complete by deadline
03/11/2010 MOTION by Deft Deutsche Bank National Trust Company to Dismiss, 9
memorandum in support; Plaintiffs' Opposition with supporting
memorandum; 9A affidavit
03/12/2010 MOTION by Defts, Chase Home Finance LLC, Washington Mutual Mortgage 10
Service Corporation and JPMorgan Chase Bank NA to Dismiss 12(b)(6),
memorandum in support; Plaintiffs' Opposition, supporting memorandum
04/09/2010 Notice: Hearing (P#9 & #10) on June 10, 2010, at 2:00 p.m. (cc: GFR &
DJP; 4/9/10)
04/30/2010 JUDGMENT OF DISMISSAL re: Defts, Washington Mutual Bank FA, 11
Washington Mutual Mortgage Securities Corporation; service not
complete by deadline (cc: GFR & DJP; 4/30/10)
05/10/2010 Notice: Rescheduled hearing (P#9 & #10) on June 22, 2010, at 2:00
p.m. (fx: GFG, DJP; 5/10/10)
05/14/2010 Notice: Rescheduled hearing (P#9 & #10) on June 24, 2010, at 2:00
p.m. (fx: DP, GFR; 5/14/10)
06/23/2010 Notice: Rescheduled hearing (P#9 & #10) on August 12, 2010, at 2:00
p.m. (fx: GFR, DJP; 6/23/10)
08/11/2010 P#9, P#10: Notice: Rescheduled hearing on October 5, 2010, at 2:00
p.m. (fx: GFR, DP; 8/11/10)
09/20/2010 MOTION: Plaintiffs' to extend the tracking deadlines for MRCP 12, 19 12
and 20 motions to 11/30/10; Rule 15 motions to 01/15/11; discovery to
5/15/11; Rule 56 to 7/15/11; Pre-trial conference to 10/6/11; SC Rule
9A affidavit
09/23/2010 Motion (P#12) ALLOWED (John S. Dale, , First Asst. Clerk) Notices
mailed 9/23/2010 GFR, DJP
10/05/2010 Motion (P#9 & #10) No action taken at this time; Case stayed three
(3) months; by the Court, Muse, Justice (Nancy N Weir, Assistant
Clerk) fx: GFR, DJP; 10/5/10
Docket Docket Text File Image
Date Ref Avail.
Nbr.
01/03/2011 Case status changed: Case becomes active following 3 month stay by
Muse, J on October 5, 2010
02/01/2011 Case status changed: to needs status review, companion case in land
court still under review (see event for 10/05/10)
05/12/2011 STATUS REVIEW of DOCKET. (cc: DFR, DJP; 5/12/11) 13
06/14/2011 Status review notice returned: Still awaiting Land Court 14
determination of the service members complaint case #09MISC40092
w/Judge Grossman
12/16/2011 ORDER sent for Status Review (copies sent 12/16/11) 15
01/13/2012 RETURNED (STATUS ORDER): Status review notice returned by Plaintiff: 16
Case #09MISC400912 (HMG) is still pending resolution of
servicemember's complaint in the Massachusetts Land Court
06/19/2012 ORDER: STATUS REVIEW of DOCKET. (cc: GFR, DJP) 17
07/06/2012 STATUS REVIEW of DOCKET (revised). Copies faxed 7/6/2012 to both attys 18
08/01/2012 Status review notice returned by plaintiff: Judgment entered on Land 19
Court case #09MISC400912-Notice of Appeal filed on July 20, 2012
02/14/2013 STATUS REVIEW of DOCKET. Copies mailed 2/14/2013 to both attys 20
03/18/2013 Status review notice returned by plaintiff-related appeal of Case 21
#09MISC400912 at Mass Appeals Court docket #12-P-1352- is still
pending resolution
09/20/2013 STATUS REVIEW of DOCKET. Copies mailed 9/20/2013 to both attys 22
10/21/2013 Status review notice returned related appeal of CA. No. 09Misc400912 23
at Mass Appeal's Court (2012-P-1352) is still pending
05/08/2014 STATUS REVIEW of DOCKET. Copies mailed 5/8/2014 to GR and DP 24
06/09/2014 Status review notice returned by plaintiff -needs a pre-trial 25
conference
06/09/2014 Notice sent to appear for pre-trial conference on 7/18/2014 to GR and 26
DP
06/23/2014 APPEARANCE: Atty Wayne E George's notice of appearance for Deutsche 27
Bank National Trust Company, JP Morgan Chase Bank NA, Chase Home
Finance LLC, Washington Mutual Mortgage Service Corporation
06/27/2014 WITHDRAWAL: Atty David J. Pellegrino's withdrawal of appearance filed 28
re: Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, JP Morgan Chase Bank NA,
Chase Home Finance LLC and Washington Mutual Bank FA
07/14/2014 MOTION: Joint to amend tracking order and cancel pre-trial conference 29
07/14/2014 Motion (P#29: Stipulated motion to amend tracking order and cancel
pre-trial conference) Motions to dismiss scheduled for hearing
08/19/14 2 2:30 pm. NO FURTHER NOTICES WILL BE SENT. PTC cancelled
(Scott W. Nickerson, Clerk-Magistrate). Notices mailed 7/14/2014 to
GFR & WEG
09/04/2014 MEMORANDUM OF DECISION AND ORDER: It is hereby ORDERED that JPMorgan 30
Chase Bank, NA's, motion to dismiss be DENIED as to Count V, but the
defendants' motions to dismiss be ALLOWED for all other claims.
(Christopher J. Muse, Justice). Copies mailed GFR and WEG with MRCP
54(b) notice
09/15/2014 9E Notice of intent to file motion of plaintiffs, H Christopher 31
Starkey and Louisa H. Strakey
09/29/2014 MOTION: Plaintiffs' for reconsideration of Court Order dated 32
September 4, 2014 , (P#30)
09/29/2014 Memorandum in support of #P32 32.1
Docket Docket Text File Image
Date Ref Avail.
Nbr.
09/29/2014 Opposition to #32 filed by defendants 32.2
09/29/2014 Motion (P#32) DENIED (Christopher J. Muse, Justice) Notices faxed
9/29/2014 to GR and WG
10/03/2014 ANSWER: JP Morgan Chase Bank NA(Defendant) by Wayne E. George 33
11/17/2014 Notice of docket entry received from Appeals Court 34

The interlocutory appeal of the order dated 09/24/2014 is DENIED, as untimely. By the
Court, (AP), Fecteau, J.
02/19/2015 Plaintiff H Christopher Starkey, Louisa H Starkey's Joint Stipulation to extend time for 35
Service of Rule 56, Filing of Rule 56

to March 17, 2015 and March 27, 2015 respectively.


02/20/2015 Endorsement on Motion to extend time for (#35.0): Rule 56 motions ALLOWED

Rule 56 motions to be served on or before March 17, 2015. Rule 56 motions to be filed in
court on or before March 27, 2015.

Notices mailed on 02/20/2015 to GFR and WEG.


03/10/2015 Defendant JP Morgan Chase Bank NA's Joint Motion to extend tracking deadline(s) 36
Service of Rule 56, Filing of Rule 56
03/13/2015 Endorsement on Motion to extend tracking deadline(s) (#36.0): ALLOWED

Rule 56 motions to be served by April 30, 2015 and filed with the court by May 11, 2015
(copy mailed to GFR, WEG, WMMSC)
05/01/2015 Plaintiff, Defendant H Christopher Starkey, Louisa H Starkey, JP Morgan Chase Bank NA's 37
Stipulation to extend time for Service of Rule 56

to May 14, 2015 and to extend Filing of Rule 56 to May 25, 2015.
05/05/2015 Endorsement on Motion to extend tracking deadline(s) (#37.0): for service of Rule 56
Motions by May 14, 2015 and for filing Rule 56 Motions by May 25, 2015 ALLOWED

Clerk's Notices and Amended Tracking Orders mailed on 05/06/2015 to GFR and WEG.
05/27/2015 Plaintiff H Christopher Starkey, Louisa H Starkey, JP Morgan Chase Bank NA's Joint 38
Motion to extend time for Filing of Rule 56

motions
05/27/2015 Endorsement on Motion to extend time for (#38.0): filing Rule 56 motions ALLOWED

Time for filing Rule 56 motions extended to June 8, 2015 (copies mailed to GFR, WEG,
WMI, WMBNA, WMMSC)
06/05/2015 Defendant JP Morgan Chase Bank NA's Motion for summary judgment, MRCP 56 39
06/05/2015 JP Morgan Chase Bank NA's Memorandum in support of 39.1

#39.0
06/05/2015 JP Morgan Chase Bank NA (Defendant) Concise Statement of Facts. 39.2
06/05/2015 Opposition to paper #39.0 (Defendant, JPMorgan Chase Bank's Motion for Summary 39.3
Judgment) filed by H Christopher Starkey, Louisa H Starkey
06/05/2015 Plaintiffs' Responses to Defendant's Concise Statement of Facts. 39.4
06/08/2015 NOTICE TO APPEAR for Rule 56 Hearing at 2:00 PM on 07/03/2015
Sent On: 06/08/2015 to WEG, GFR
07/03/2015 HEARING (P#39) RULE 56, on 07/03/2015 at 10:00 AM: Held - Under advisement
Appeared: Wayne E. George, Esq.; Glenn F. Russell, Jr., Esq.
Court Reporter: DRD #1
08/26/2015 40 Image
Docket Docket Text File Image
Date Ref Avail.
Nbr.
MEMORANDUM & ORDER:

Endorsement on Motion for summary judgment, MRCP 56 (#39.0): JPMorgan Chase


Bank, N.A.'s motion DENIED
For the reasons stated herein, it is ORDERED that JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.'s Motion
for Summary Judgment be DENIED.
See image for full text.
Attested copies mailed on 08/31/2015 to GFR and WEG.
09/01/2015 Notice to Appear for Final Pre-Trial Conference for 10/16/15 to WG and GR 41
10/14/2015 ORDER of dismissal nisi entered after action was reported settled; Agreement or 42
Stipulation shall be filed in this court by 11/12/2015

Applies To: Russell, Jr., Esq., Glenn F. (Attorney) on behalf of Starkey, H Christopher
(Plaintiff); George, Esq., Wayne E. (Attorney) on behalf of JP Morgan Chase Bank NA
(Defendant)
10/14/2015 Document:
A Order for Entry of Dismissal Nisi was generated and sent to:
Attorney: Glenn F. Russell, Jr., Esq.
Attorney: Wayne E. George, Esq.
11/06/2015 Defendant JP Morgan Chase Bank NA's Joint Motion to extend date of nisi dismissal 43

to December 14, 2015


11/10/2015 Endorsement on Motion to extend date of nisi dismissal (#43.0): ALLOWED
as requested (copy mailed to GFR, WEG 11/12/15)
12/08/2015 Defendant JP Morgan Chase Bank NA's Joint Motion to extend date of nisi dismissal 44
12/08/2015 Endorsement on Motion to extend date of nisi dismissal (#44.0): ALLOWED
Notice to WEG, GFR on 12/9/15
01/27/2016 Plaintiff H Christopher Starkey's Joint Motion to extend date of nisi dismissal 45
to April 4, 2016
01/27/2016 Endorsement on Motion to extend date of nisi dismissal (#45.0): ALLOWED
No further extensions.
Notice to GFR, WEG on 1/27/16
04/26/2016 JUDGMENT of Dismissal: Failure to comply with nisi order. 46 Image

dated 10/14/15 and extended to 04/04/16

Judgment of Dismissal applies to Count 5 of the complaint

Count 5 only applies to JP Morgan Chase as all other counts were dismissed against all
parties by the courts decision at P#30.
05/26/2016 APPEAL: Plaintiffs Notice of appeal filed 47

Applies To: Russell, Jr., Esq., Glenn F. (Attorney) on behalf of Starkey, H Christopher
(Plaintiff)
07/27/2016 JUDGMENT on Defendants, JP Morgan Chase Bank NA 12(b) motion to dismiss against 48 Image
Plaintiff(s) H Christopher Starkey, Louisa H Starkey.
It is ORDERED and ADJUDGED:
that all counts except Count V are hereby dismissed

Applies To: Starkey, H Christopher (Plaintiff); Starkey, Louisa H (Plaintiff); JP Morgan


Chase Bank NA (Defendant); Russell, Jr., Esq., Glenn F. (Attorney) on behalf of Starkey, H
Christopher (Plaintiff); George, Esq., Wayne E. (Attorney) on behalf of JP Morgan Chase
Bank NA (Defendant)
08/23/2016 Notice of appeal filed on paper number 48.0 49
Certificate re Transcript sent to GFR, copy of appeal sent to WEG

Applies To: Starkey, H Christopher (Plaintiff); Starkey, Louisa H (Plaintiff)


09/09/2016 50
Docket Docket Text File Image
Date Ref Avail.
Nbr.
Appeal: Party's Letter received re: no transcript on appeal

Applies To: Russell, Jr., Esq., Glenn F. (Attorney) on behalf of Starkey, H Christopher
(Plaintiff)
11/18/2016 Notice to Clerk of the Appeals Court of Assembly of Record 51
11/18/2016 Appeal: Statement of the Case on Appeal (Cover Sheet). 52
11/30/2016 Appeal entered in Appeals Court on 11/28/2016 docket number Docket # 2016-P-1594 53
12/05/2016 Notice of docket entry received from Appeals Court 54 Image
see scanned entry
12/12/2016 Notice of docket entry received from Appeals Court 55 Image
Please see scanned image.
12/30/2016 Plaintiff H Christopher Starkey, Louisa H Starkey's Joint motion to amend judgment 56
pursuant to M.R.C.P. 60(a)
01/09/2017 Notice of docket entry received from Appeals Court 57 Image
Appellate proceedings STAYED to 02/04/2017. Status report due then as to 60(a) motion.
(See image for full text).
01/19/2017 Endorsement on Motion for relief from Judgment (#56.0): ALLOWED
(copy w/certified copy of docket sheet to GFR, WEG)
02/03/2017 CORRECTED JUDGMENT on Defendants, Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, JP 58 Image
Morgan Chase Bank NA, Washington Mutual Mortgage Service Corporation, Chase Home
Finance LLC 12(b) motion to dismiss against Plaintiff(s) H Christopher Starkey, Louisa H
Starkey.
It is ORDERED and ADJUDGED:
that all counts against the named Defendants be dismissed except as to Count V as it
applies to JP Morgan Chase which was dismissed at P#46
This Judgment corrects the Judgment issued on 07/27/16 @ P#48
02/08/2017 Revised copies of docket entries sent to Appeals Court (e-filed)
01/30/2019 Rescript received from Appeals Court; judgment REVERSED The corrected judgment is 59 Image
reversed and the case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with the opinion of
the Appeals Court.
01/30/2019 Party status: 64
Plaintiff Starkey, H Christopher: Inactive;
02/05/2019 NOTICE TO APPEAR FOR Rule 16 Conference on 03/08/2019 at 10:30 AM, mailed on
02/05/2019 to GFR and WEG.
02/05/2019 ATTORNEY WITHDRAWAL On this date Wayne E George, Esq. dismissed/withdrawn as 60 Image
Private Counsel for Defendant JP Morgan Chase Bank NA
02/05/2019 ATTORNEY APPEARANCE filed by Vanessa Brown, Esq. for JP Morgan Chase Bank NA 61 Image

03/06/2019 APPEARANCE FILED by Charles L. Solomont, Esq., for JP Morgan Chase Bank, N.A. 62 Image
and Deutsche Bank National Trust Company
EFILED
03/07/2019 APPEARANCE FILED by Elizabeth M. Bresnahan, Esq., for JP Morgan Chase Bank, N.A. 63 Image
and Deutsche Bank National Trust
EFILED
03/08/2019 ORDER: After a Rule 16 scheduling conference, IT IS ORDERED; Discovery completed 64 Image
by 2/28/19, Rule 56 & Judgment on the Pleadings Motions filed by 5/29/20, Final Pretrial
conference 7/31/20 @ 10:30 a.m.
03/08/2019 Rule 16 Conference scheduled on 03/08/2019: Held as Scheduled
Comments: 3rd Session Lobby: No record
Appeared: Plaintiff - Glenn F Russell, Jr., Esq.
Defendant - Elizabeth Marie Bresnahan, Esq.
Vanessa Brown, Esq.
03/12/2019 Notice to Appear for Final Pre-Trial Conference 7/31/20 @ 10:30 Sent MB,GR,VB On: 65
03/12/2019
Docket Docket Text File Image
Date Ref Avail.
Nbr.

03/15/2019 Defendants JP Morgan Chase Bank NA, Deutsche Bank National Trust Company's 66 Image
Assented to Motion for
leave to amend answer
03/18/2019 Endorsement on Motion to (#66.0): Amend Answer ALLOWED Image
(See image for endorsement).
Clerk's Notice mailed on 03/21/2019 to GFR, VB and WEG.
03/18/2019 AMENDED ANSWER filed by Elizabeth M. Bresnahan Esq., for Deutsche Bank National 67 Image
Trust Company, and JP Morgan Chase Bank, N.A.
08/13/2019 Rule 9A list of documents filed. 68 Image

08/13/2019 Defendant Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, JP Morgan Chase Bank NA's Motion 68.1 Image
for judgment on the pleadings MRCP 12(c)
08/13/2019 Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, JP Morgan Chase Bank NA's Memorandum in 68.2 Image
support of
motion for judgment on the pleadings
08/13/2019 Opposition to motion for judgment on the pleadings filed by H Christopher Starkey, Louisa 68.3 Image
H Starkey
08/13/2019 Brief filed: Reply 68.4 Image
to plaintiffs opposition to motion for judgment on the pleadings

Applies To: Deutsche Bank National Trust Company (Defendant); JP Morgan Chase Bank
NA (Defendant)
08/13/2019 The following form was generated:

Notice to Appear
Sent On: 08/13/2019 15:40:34
10/15/2019 Hearing for Judgment on Pleading scheduled on 10/15/2019: Held as Scheduled
Comments: 1st Session: FTR (REM)
Appeared: Plaintiff - Glenn F Russell, Jr., Esq.
Defendant - Charles L Solomont, Esq.
10/22/2019 Endorsement on Motion for judgment on the pleadings MRCP 12(c) (#68.1): DENIED Image
After hearing, respectfully Denied, reasons stated on the record.
Clerk's Notice mailed on 10/22/2019 to GFR, WEG and VB.

Case Disposition
Disposition Date Case Judge
Remanded for New Trial after Rescript 01/30/2019