10 views

Uploaded by Pinder Dosanjh

- Band Theory of Solids
- TH_3
- Electrical and thermal conductivities of reduced graphene oxidepolystyrene composites.pdf
- adeoti f
- Flomat Eng
- English for electrical engineering.pdf
- adiabatic
- 10
- Article Wattez Duhart Lorente (2)
- 1D Sunsurface Em Fields Excited by Energized Steel Casing
- Info IEC 62305-1
- MWE_Expt1_2017
- The Radiation Poisoning of America
- 986
- SECOND SEMESTER PHYSICS -2 TWO MARKS WITH ANSWERS REGULATION 2013
- Electric Current
- MM5017_Assignment1
- Soil Resistivity
- JNTU Mechanical Engineering (R09) Syllabus Book
- Eg_EJP

You are on page 1of 12

A. Hosseini, R. Harris, Saeid Kamal, P. Dosanjh, J. Preston, Ruixing Liang, W.N. Hardy and D.A. Bonn

Dept. of Physics and Astronomy, University of British Columbia, 6224 Agricultural Rd., Vancouver, BC, V6T 1Z1, Canada

(February 9, 1999)

We present here the microwave surface impedance of a high purity crystal of Y Ba2 Cu3 O6 99 mea-

:

sured at 5 frequencies between 1 and 75 GHz. This data set reveals the main features of the

conductivity spectrum of the thermally excited quasiparticles in the superconducting state. Below

20 K there is a regime of extremely long quasiparticle scattering times, due to both the collapse

of inelastic scattering below T and the very weak impurity scattering in the high purity BaZrO3 -

c

grown crystal used in this study. Above 20 K, the scattering increases dramatically, initially at least

as fast as T 4 .

Valid PACS appear here.

measurements at microwave [2,10{16], far infrared [17]

Over the past few years measurements of electrody- and THz frequencies [8,18,19]. The rapid increase in

namic properties at microwave frequencies have proven quasiparticle scattering time is well established by these

to be a fruitful technique for studying the superconduct- measurements and the very long quasiparticle mean free

ing state of the high temperature superconductors. A paths resulting from this have been corroborated further

key strength of the technique is that measurements of by the thermal Hall eect measurements of Krishana et

the real and imaginary part of the surface impedance al. [20]. However, obtaining a quantitative determination

Zs (!; T ) provide complementary information on two as- of the scattering time and the details of its temperature

pects of the superconducting state; the super uid density dependence has been hampered by the need to use models

and the low energy excitations out of the condensate. to interpret the existing microwave data. The problem

Measurements of the imaginary part of the surface has been that although the step from Rs (T ) and (T )

impedance Xs (T ) provide a direct measure of the pen- to the conductivity 1 (T ) is a matter of straightforward

etration depth (T ), which is determined by the tem- superconductor electrodynamics when in the local limit,

perature dependence of the super uid density. The the extraction of a scattering time from 1 (T ) suered

widespread observation of a linear temperature depen- from a dependence on an assumed model for the shape

dence of (T ) at low T in many of the superconducting of the quasiparticle conductivity spectrum 1 (!).

cuprates [1{5] has been a key piece of evidence suggesting In this paper we present measurements at 5 microwave

nodes in the energy gap in these materials. Near Tc the frequencies, giving enough spectroscopic detail over a

temperature dependence of (T ) has provided evidence wide enough frequency range to produce a rather com-

of 3DXY critical uctuations over a wide temperature plete picture of the evolution of 1 (!; T ) in the super-

range in Y Ba2 Cu3 O7 [6]. conducting state. These results support the early model

Measurements of the real part of the surface impedance based on an ansatz that the thermally excited quasiparti-

Rs (T ), when combined with the measurements of (T ), cles have a Drude-shaped conductivity spectrum and now

can be used to determine the real part of the microwave provide a much clearer measurement of the temperature

conductivity 1 (T ), which is essentially electromagnetic dependence of the quasiparticle scattering rate below Tc.

absorption by quasiparticles excited out of the conden- We nd that this scattering rate becomes extremely small

sate (either thermally excited quasiparticles or excita- and appears to become essentially temperature indepen-

tions created by the absorption of photons). Early mea- dent below about 20 K. At higher temperatures the scat-

surements of Rs (T ) at a few GHz exhibited a broad peak tering rate increases rapidly, initially at least as fast as

below Tc , caused by a very large peak in 1 (T ) [7] at T 4. In the following section we will describe the tech-

these low frequencies. This peak was also observed at niques used to produce this information and in Section

THz frequencies by Nuss et al. [8], and was attributed III we will present the results along with details of the

to a competition between two temperature dependences; extraction of the microwave conductivity from surface

the overall decrease with temperature of the number of impedance measurements. In Section IV the microwave

thermally excited quasiparticles competing with a rapid conductivity spectra will be presented along with the re-

increase below Tc of the transport scattering time of these sults of ts that generate the temperature dependence of

quasiparticles. This rapid increase in scattering time has the quasiparticle scattering rate. In Section V we will

been interpreted as a collapse of the inelastic scattering point out some of the implications of these results and

processes responsible for the large normal state resistiv- in particular compare them to the present literature on

ity of the high temperature superconductors and is an conductivity in a d-wave superconductor.

eect that is observed in thermal conductivity measure-

1

II. EXPERIMENTAL TECHNIQUES weak in the c^-direction, except near Tc [21,22]. The ab-

solute value of Rs (T ) for the c^-direction is also quite low

The property being directly probed in a microwave [22].

measurement on a superconductor is the complex sur- The measurements at 1 GHz were performed in a loop-

face impedance Zs (T ) = Rs (T ) + iXs (T ). One simpli- gap resonator initially designed for measurement of (T )

fying feature of the high temperature superconductors [1]. Like most of the resonators used in this study, the

is that the super
uid response falls in the limit of local loop-gap is plated with a Pb:Sn alloy which is super-

electrodynamics, so that Rs (T ) and Xs (T ) are related to conducting below 7 Kelvin and has very low microwave

the complex conductivity (!; T ) = 1 (!; T ) i2(!; T ) loss at 1.2 Kelvin. In the case of the 1GHz loop-gap,

in a straightforward way. This simple limit arises from the cavity Q can be as high as 4 106 at low tem-

the very small coherence length in these materials, which perature. Another feature common to all of the mea-

guarantees that . A particularly simple regime of surements is that the sample is mounted on a thin sap-

the local limit occurs when 2 1 below Tc and at low phire plate with a tiny amount of silicone grease, with

frequency, in which case one obtains the relations the thermometry and sample heater located at the other

end of the sapphire plate, outside of, and thermally iso-

2

Rs (T ) = 20 !23 (T )1 (!; T ) (2.1) lated from the resonator. In this way the resonator can

be held xed at the regulated 4 He bath temperature

Xs (T ) = 0 !(T ) : while the sample temperature is varied. A unique fea-

A more detailed discussion of the electrodynamics and ture of the 1 GHz loop-gap system is that the sample is

the extraction of 1 (!; T ) from Zs (T ) will be presented held xed in the resonator, with the sapphire plate and

in Section III, but the equations above are useful for quick thermometry stage supported by a thin walled quartz

estimates and for understanding the main features of the tube which sustains the temperature gradient between

microwave properties of these superconductors. the 4 He bath and the sample. This means that the sam-

The expression for Rs (T ) in Eq. 2.1 embodies what ple cannot be removed from the resonator during the

is most dicult about the microwave measurements. It measurements, but we nd this restriction is necessary

contains both 1 and a term of the form !2 3 , and physi- for the high precision measurements of (T ) which rely

cally can be interpreted as the microwave absorption pro- on the sample being held rigidly in a position that does

cesses (1 ) occuring within the rather shallow depth into not vary when the temperature is changed. Without

which the microwaves penetrate (hence the term !2 3 ). this type of construction, motion of the sample and sap-

This screening length set by the super
uid makes Rs ex- phire plate in the elds of the resonator can give rise

tremely small below Tc , such that for small single crys- to experimental artifacts. This is because (T ) is de-

tals, one is forced to employ cavity perturbation in very termined from very small changes in the resonator fre-

high Q microwave resonators. This is most often achieved quency as the sample temperature is changed. This tech-

by the use of microwave cavities made from conventional nique gives highly precise and reliable temperature de-

superconductors cooled to low temperature. This xed pendences relative to the base temperature, but is limited

frequency type of measurement must be performed with to measuring dierences; (T ) = (T ) (1:2 K ) and

several resonators if one is to build up a complete picture Rs (T ) = Rs (T ) Rs (1:2 K ). The value of Rs (1:2 K )

of the microwave conductivity spectrum 1 (!). at 1 GHz is estimated by comparing to separate experi-

The data presented here involve measurements with 5 mental runs where the resonator is loaded with only the

resonators spanning a 1 to 75 GHz range and utilizing a sapphire sample holder. The need to do this in two sep-

number of variations on the basic method of cavity per- arate experimental runs gives the 1 GHz Rs (T ) mea-

turbation. The common feature is that all of the mea- surements a relatively large uncertainty in the form of

surements have been performed on the same sample, a a temperature-independent background value (0:7

),

thin plate of Y Ba2 Cu3 O6:993 oriented such that the mi- although the resolution of the temperature dependence

crowave magnetic eld of each cavity lay in the plane of is much better than this. We do not attempt to ex-

the plate (H~ rf k ^b). This geometry has the advantage tract (1:2 K ) from the microwave measurements, but

that demagnetization factors are small, so the surface instead use values inferred from muon spin rotation mea-

current distributions are fairly uniform and are similar surements [23]. None of the analysis discussed in this

in all of the measurements, making comparison from fre- paper depends sensitively on this choice of (1:2 K ).

quency to frequency quite reliable. The disadvantage is The 2 GHz measurements have been performed in a Nb

that although this geometry mainly measures the surface split-ring resonator that will be described in more detail

impedance for currents running across the crystal face in elsewhere [24]. Measurements at 13.3, 22.7, and 75.1 GHz

the a^ direction, there is some admixture of c^-axis surface have been performed in the axial microwave magnetic

impedance coming from currents running down the thin elds of the TE011 modes of three right-circular cylindri-

edge of the crystal. However, we have previously shown cal cavities. In all of the measurements other than those

that these eects are small for a thin crystal, because the at 1 GHz, the sample can be easily moved in and out of

temperature dependences of Rs (T ) and Xs (T ) are quite the resonator. This freedom to move the sample makes it

dicult to measure (T ) at the higher frequencies, due to

2

problems of controlling motion of the sample as the tem-

perature is changed. However, the sample motion is much

too slight to have any in
uence on the measurements of

Rs (T ). The ability to measure Q0 by pulling the sam- 0

the background uncertainty in these measurements much 1.14 GHz

2.25 GHz

less signicant than it is in the 1 GHz data. The sur- 13.4 GHz

face resistance is determined from Rs (T ) / 1=Qs 1=Q0 22.7 GHz

where Q0 is the Q of the empty cavity and Qs is the Q 10

−2 75.3 GHz

sources of loss must be made by measuring the sapphire

holder and grease without the sample. Then the only re-

Rs(Ω)

maining uncertainty in the background is the in
uence of −4

rections, the estimated uncertainty in the background is

0.7, 0.2, 10, 20, and 360

for the 1.1, 2.2, 13.4, 22.7,

and 75.3 GHz data respectively. The calibration of the 10

−6

measuring a Pb:Sn reference sample whose normal state 0 20 40 60 80

surface resistance is governed by the classical skin eect. T(K)

These calibrations, together with the statistical scatter

in the data amount to a total uncertainty of 10% or FIG. 1. The surface resistance R (T ) for currents running

less at each frequency. s

The sample used for these measurements was a single :

nique using BaZrO3 crucibles [25]. The BaZrO3 , which

does not corrode during crystal growth, yields crystals

of much higher purity [25,26] (better than 99.99%) than

those grown in more commonly used crucibles such as

yttria-stabilized zirconia and alumina. The sample was

detwinned at 250 C under uniaxial stress and then an-

nealed at 350 C for 50 days to produce a sample with 1.14 GHz

nearly lled chain oxygen sites. This gives a slightly 2 2.25 GHz

lower Tc (88.7 K) than the maximum obtained near an 13.4 GHz

oxygen concentration of 6.91 [25], but provides partic- 22.7 GHz

ularly defect-free samples without the oxygen vacancy 75.3 GHz

Ωs )

2

−25

Rs/ω (10

1

performed on smaller pieces cleaved from the original

2

repeated on dierent pieces to ensure that the sample

was uniform.

0 20 40 60 80

Fig. 1 shows the surface resistance of Y Ba2 Cu3 O6:993 T(K)

for currents running in the a^ direction. At all 5 of the

frequencies shown in the gure, the rapid drop in Rs (T ) FIG. 2. The same measurements of surface resistance as

below Tc is due to the onset of screening by the super- shown in Fig. 1, but with the behaviour below T emphasized c

uid, with the overall magnitude of the drop depending by dividing out a frequency-squared dependence associated

strongly on frequency as expected from the term in Rs (T ) with super
uid screening.

that varies as !2 3 (T ).

For easier comparison of the dierent frequencies, it is

3

convenient to plot the low loss data in the superconduct-

ing state as Rs =!2 versus temperature, as shown in Fig. 1.0

2. One feature of these gures is that above 65 K the loss

scales as !2 to within 8%, a scaling that is expected if

the microwave 1 (!) is frequency independent above 65

K. This agreement lies within the estimated uncertainty

in background and calibration constants, and provides a

check of the degree to which one can compare the mea-

λ (0)/λ (T)

surements at dierent frequencies.

2

The broad peak in Rs (T ) was originally attributed to 0.5

2

with decreasing temperature below Tc and competes with

a density of these thermally excited qusiparticles that de-

creases with temperature [7]. For the early measurements

near 2 GHz it was suggested that the quasiparticle scat-

tering time reaches a limiting value near 30 K, possibly

due to impurity scattering, at which point the quasipar- 0.0

ticle density takes over and causes Rs (T ) to fall again 0 20 40 60 80

with further decreases in temperature [29]. The specula- T(K)

[t]

tion that impurities are involved in the turnover at 30 K

was partly checked by studying samples doped with Ni FIG. 3. The temperature dependence of the a^ axis pene-

and Zn [30]. These doping studies showed either a smaller tration depth of Y Ba2 Cu3 O6 95 plotted as 1=2 (T ), which is

:

peak shifted to higher temperature or no peak at all, con- a measure of the super
uid density via n e2 =m = 1=(0 2 ).

s

an impurity limit at higher temperature, even when only

0.15% Zn was added to the sample. This sensitivity to tract 1 (!; T ) from these measurements of Rs (!; T ). At

such low levels of impurities raises a serious concern over the lowest frequency of 1 GHz, where ! 1 and we

these earlier crystals grown in yttria-stabilized zirconia have simultaneous measurements of Rs (T ) and (T ), it

crucibles, because during crystal growth the residual im- is straightforward to extract 1 (T ) with only an assump-

purity level due to uptake of material from the corroding tion that the electrodynamics are local. The 1 GHz mea-

crucible reaches the 0.1% level. The results shown here surements of (T ) used in this analysis are shown in Fig.

on a new higher purity sample conrm the original spec- 3, plotted as 1=2 (T ).

ulation that it is this residual impurity scattering that The screening by the super uid follows the local Lon-

limits the increase in quasiparticle lifetime, even in quite don model if a superconductor is in the limit .

pure crystals. The low frequency surface resistance of Strictly speaking, this local limit is more complicated for

the new crystal rises a factor of four above the minimum the case of a superconductor with nodes in the energy

near 70 K, higher than the factor of two or less observed gap because the coherence length is then k-dependent

in earlier measurements of samples at 2 and 4 GHZ [29]. and becomes large in the node directions. However, the

The changes are consistent with the new samples having consequences of this type of non-locality for the electro-

lower impurity scattering and so reaching a higher quasi- dynamics would only be observable at low temperatures

particle scattering time limit at a lower temperature than and the eect would be small in the measurement geom-

was seen in the yttria-stabilized zirconia grown crystals. etry used here [31]. A much more serious problem for

The frequency dependence of the peak in Rs (T ) pro- the data analysis is that at the higher frequencies where

vides further evidence of the rapid increase in the quasi- ! 1, the thermally excited quasiparticles also con-

particle lifetime. In much higher frequency measure- tribute to the screening of microwave elds and it is then

ments on thin lms, Nuss et al. [8] were the rst to ob- incorrect to use the 1 GHz measurements of (T ) in order

serve a similar broad peak in the THz range that shifted to extract 1 (T ) from Rs (T ). Eectively, the penetration

up in temperature and decreased in size at higher fre- depth becomes frequency dependent, a phenomenon that

quencies. They pointed out that this could be accounted has been observed directly in mm-wave measurements on

for by relaxation eects. If the quasiparticle lifetime in- particularly high quality thin lms [16]. Ideally this prob-

creases suciently that ! 1, then the sample enters a lem can be solved by measuring both Rs (T ) and Xs (T ) at

regime where 1 (T ) falls as continues to increase. So for each measurement frequency, but we have done this only

high frequency measurements the temperature at which at 1 GHz, for reasons discussed in the previous section.

Rs (T ) reaches its peak roughly indicates where ! = 1 It is possible to work around the fact that we have

at each measurement frequency. The fact that we ob- measurements of both the real and imaginary part at

serve these relaxation eects at 13 GHz indicates that only one frequency, as long as there is adequate infor-

the scattering time exceeds 10 ps in the new samples. mation on the frequency dependence of the real part of

To better understand the data it is desireable to ex- the surface impedance. The problem is analogous to the

4

one faced in far infrared spectroscopy of opaque samples, delta-function can be neglected, leaving

where the re
ectance, but not the phase of the re
ected

light, is measured over a wide frequency range. Kramers-

Kronig relations are the usual solution if only one of the

(!; T ) = 1N (!; T ) i 2N (!; T ) + !12 (T ) :

0

optical constants is known, but is known over a wide fre- (3.2)

quency range. In principle, data at the ve microwave

frequencies presented here could be connected to far in- Thus, in general the real part of the conductivity comes

frared measurements of re
ectance in order to perform from the normal
uid. The imaginary part has contribu-

this analysis and extract 1 (!) and 2 (!). However, such tions from both the normal and super
uid, although the

an analysis is dicult because there still exists a substan- super
uid dominates at low frequency.

tial gap in the mm-wave frequency range between our In the local limit the connection between 1 (!; T ) and

highest frequency measurement and the lowest frequency the surface impedance is made via

far infrared measurements on crystals. Some data have

been obtained in the mm-wave region using techniques i ! 12

such as time domain THz measurements [8,18,19] and Zs = Rs + iXs = 0 i : (3.3)

direct infrared absorption [32], but these have all been 1 2

performed on lms rather than untwinned single crys- Thus, at 1 GHz where we have measurements of both Rs

tals. The quasiparticle scattering rate is typically much and Xs , 1 and 2 can be extracted using

higher in lms than it is in single crystals, so data taken

on such dierent samples cannot be analyzed together in

this way. An alternative to a Kramers-Kronig analysis 1 = 20 ! (R2R+s XXs 2 )2 (3.4)

is to t the frequency dependent surface resistance to a X

s

2 R

s

2

model, but this is not a very satisfactory procedure if 2 = 0 ! (R2s+ X 2s)2 :

one only has data at ve microwave frequencies and one s s

doesn't know the shape of the conductivity spectrum a At higher frequencies, where we only have measure-

priori. A further problem with both of these techniques

is that the far infrared data is only available at a couple ments of Rs (T ), it is useful to write 1 in terms of Rs

of temperatures below Tc, so they can not be used to do and 2 in the following way [29]:

a complete analysis of the data presented here. 2" 2 1 =2 # 2 31=2

Our main approach to analyzing the surface resistance

data is to use the Rs (T ) measurements at 1 GHz to arrive 1 = 4 2 4s 2 s

s

22 5 (3.5)

at an estimate of how much screening by the thermally p

excited quasiparticles must be included when extracting with the sign choice + ( ) for 1 > (<) 32

1 (T ) from Rs (T ) at higher frequencies. Although the

procedure involves some assumptions about the model and where s = 2R0 !2 :

for the screening, we will show that the corrections are s

small enough that the eect of uncertainty in the choice of In the normal state, where 1 2 at low frequen-

model does not signicantly aect the conductivities that cies, this expression reduces to the classical skin eect

we extract in the analysis. We begin by writing down a result 1 = 0 !=2Rs2. Eq. 3.5 continues to be valid right

general 2-
uid expression for the microwave conductiv- through the superconducting transition and can be used

ity that includes contributions to the real and imaginary to extract 1 from measurements of Rs provided that one

part from both the super
uid and normal
uid (the con- also has some information on 2 . The extent to which

ductivity due mainly to thermally excited quasiparticles), one can use this expression in the superconducting state

depends upon the relative importance of the normal
uid

(!; T ) = 1S i2S + 1N i2N (3.1) contribution to 2 . In regimes where this contribution is

= nms e (!) ns e2 + small, 2 is simply given by 2S = (0 !2 (T )) 1 which

2

im ! 1N i2N can be calculated from the penetration depth measure-

ments. To clearly illustrate the problem that occurs when

where 1S and 2S are the real and imaginary parts of the the normal
uid contribution to 2 is not small, we ex-

super
uid conductivity and 1N and 2N are the real and amine a particular version of the 2-
uid model where the

imaginary parts of the normal
uid conductivity. The su- normal
uid conductivity is assumed to have a Drude

per
uid contribution consists of a delta-function at ! = 0 frequency dependence:

with an oscillator strength given by the super
uid den-

sity divided by the eective mass (ns =m), and an imag- 2

1N i2N = nmn e 1 + (! )2 i 1 +!(! )2 (3.6)

2

inary part that is the inductive response of the super-

uid at nonzero frequencies. This super
uid response

can be expressed in terms of the penetration depth us- where is the scattering time of the normal
uid and

ing ns e2=m = (0 2 (T )) 1 , and away from ! = 0 the nn =m is the normal
uid density over the eective mass.

5

The ratio of the normal
uid and super
uid contributions

to the eective screening is then 6

2N = nn (! )2 :

1.14 GHz

(3.7)

2.25 GHz

22.7 GHz

75.3 GHz

uid density is small (nn =ns 1, which occurs at low

σ1(10 Ω m )

−1

temperatures). Conversely, diculties arise when ! > 1

−1

and nn =ns is not small, which is likely the case for our

7

data at 13 and 22 GHz in the temperature range from

20{40 K, and for the 75 GHz data from 20{60 K. 2

For the conductivities that we will show below we

take the following approach to estimating the normal

uid contribution to 2 . At 1 GHz 1 is calculated di-

rectly from the simultaneous measurements of Rs (T ) and

Xs (T ). Then we extract an estimate of (T ) using the 0

Drude model above (Eq. 3.6). The normal
uid density 0 20 40 60 80

is calculated from the penetration depth measurements T(K)

by assuming that

FIG. 4. The temperature dependence of the a^-axis mi-

nn e2 (T ) + ns e2 (T ) = ns e2 (T = 0) : (3.8) crowave conductivity of Y Ba2 Cu3 O6 993 extracted from the

m m m

:

which amounts to assuming that all of the low frequency near T is a result of superconducting uctuations and the

c

oscillator strength is being shifted from the normal
uid broad peak at lower temperatures is caused by the increase

to the super
uid as the temperature is decreased. The in the scattering time of thermally excited quasiparticles.

(T ) and nn (T ) derived from the 1 GHz data can then be

used to make an estimate of the normal
uid contribution of Y Ba2 Cu3 O7 crystals have shown the presence of an

to 2 needed to analyze the data at higher frequencies. extra sample-dependent peak in 1 (T ) just below Tc, a

When this analysis is performed, we nd that the normal feature that was discussed by Olson and Koch [34] and

uid screening in
uences the extraction of 1 from Rs (T ) by Glass and Hall [35] who attributed it to having a sam-

only at the level of 20% or less. This can be understood ple with a broadened transition. A similar feature was

if one notices that ! 1 at temperatures of 50 K or also reported recently by Srikanth et al. for BaZrO3 -

less at which point the normal
uid density has already grown crystals [36], but since we see no sign of this in

fallen below 20% of the total oscillator strength. There our new high purity samples, we conclude that such fea-

is some uncertainty associated with assuming a Drude tures are associated with a spread in Tc0 s in the surface

form for 1 (!) (Eq. 3.6) and assuming the redistribution of the sample. The main feature that we do observe in

of oscillator strength implied by the two
uid model (Eq. the conductivity is that 1 (T ) has a large broad peak,

3.8). However, we will show that for temperatures up rising to nearly 25 times the normal state conductivity.

to 45 K, deviations from a Drude spectrum are barely The peak rises a factor of two higher than was seen in

discernible within our experimental uncertainties and the measurements at 2 and 4 GHz on an earlier generation

two
uid model is obeyed at microwave frequencies to of crystals grown in yttria-stabilized zirconia crucibles

within 10%. Thus, the maximum systematic error that [30] and it crests at a lower temperature, 25 K instead

might be introduced by this analysis amounts to 3% at of the 35 K turnover observed in the lower purity crys-

worst at 75.2 GHz, only about 1% at 13 and 27 GHz, and tals. This eect of very low levels of impurities is not

is completely negligible at 1 and 2 GHz. Furthermore, the consistent with the suggestion of Klein et al. [37] that

values of (T ) that we use in the analysis above turn out this feature is the result of BCS-type coherence eects.

to be consistent with the conductivity spectra 1 (!) that A coherence peak, essentially a density of states eect,

will be discussed below, so the correction for screening by is observed near Tc in 1 (T ) of s-wave superconductors

the normal
uid is self-consistent. such as Pb [38]. However, the peak observed here at 1

Fig. 4 shows the conductivities extracted from the GHz is much too large and too low in temperature to be

Rs (T ) data of Fig. 1, using the methods described above. attributed to such an eect. Furthermore, a strong co-

The sharp upturn at Tc marks the presence of super- herence peak has not been seen in NMR measurements

conducting
uctuations, which have been discussed in of T1 in this material [39] nor is it expected in a d-wave

greater detail by Kamal et al. [6] and Anlage et al. [33] superconductor, the now widely accepted pairing state of

and are not the main focus of the work presented here. A Y Ba2 Cu3 O7 . [40,41]

number of previous measurements on earlier generations

6

4K 35 K

10 K 50 K

20 K

4 4

σ1(10 Ω m )

σ1(10 Ω m )

−1

−1

−1

−1

7

7

2 2

0 0

0 10 20 30 40 50 0 10 20 30 40 50

10 −1 10 −1

ω(10 s ) ω(10 s )

[t] [t]

FIG. 5. The conductivity spectrum at 3 selected tempera- FIG. 6. The conductivity spectrum at 2 temperatures

tures between 4 and 20 K, extracted from the 1 (T ) curves above 20 K, extracted from the 1 (T ) curves of Fig. 4. Above

of Fig. 4. In this temperature regime, the conductivity due 20 K, the width of the conductivity peak broadens rapidly,

to thermally excited quasiparticles has a nearly temperature stretching out of the microwave frequency range above 55 K.

independent width of 91 GHz and a nearly temperature in- These spectra continue to be reasonably well t by Drude

dependent shape that is close to a Drude lineshape (the lines lineshapes, as shown by the lines in the gure.

are Drude ts).

IV. CONDUCTIVITY SPECTRA AND

Thus, in the absence of strong coherence eects, we QUASIPARTICLE LIFETIME

have attributed the rise in 1 (T ) below Tc to a rapid in-

crease in the scattering time of thermally excited quasi- The evolution of the conductivity with temperature is

particles, as discussed in the Introduction. The fact that better illustrated in Figs. 5 and 6 where we show the con-

this peak rises higher and turns over at a lower tempera- ductivity spectrum 1 (!) at several representative tem-

ture in the new, higher purity crystals is consistent with peratures. In fact, the central technical achievement of

this interpretation. That is, in the higher purity sample, this work is that we now have measurements at enough

runs into its impurity limit at a somewhat lower tem- frequencies that both the shape of 1 (!) and its tem-

perature than it did in the earlier generations of crystals perature dependence are quite clear. Fig. 5 shows the

and this impurity-limited scattering time is very large in conductivity spectrum at three temperatures below 25

the new BaZrO3 -grown crystals. An estimate of the in- K, the temperature range where we have argued above

crease can be made as follows. The penetration depth that the conductivity is dominated by thermally excited

measurements indicate that more than 90% of the nor- quasiparticles scattered by a low level of impurities. We

mal
uid density is gone at 25 K (see Fig. 3), so the will not concentrate here on the lowest temperature data,

25-fold increase in 1 between Tc and 30 K implies an where the loss becomes very small and dicult to mea-

increase in by at least a factor of 250 over the scatter- sure accurately by most cavity perturbation techniques.

ing time just above Tc. This is actually an underestimate Fig. 5 shows that from 4 to 20 K, the conductivity con-

because not all of the far infrared oscillator strength in sists of a very narrow peak whose width is largely temper-

the normal state ends up condensed into the super
uid ature independent. The lines in the gure are weighted,

at low temperatures. Such a huge increase in lifetime least squares ts to a Lorentzian lineshape (the real part

is consistent with the relaxation eects observed in the of Eq. 3.6), demonstrating that the conductivity spec-

data at 13 GHz and higher. As a rough illustration of trum of the thermally excited quasiparticles is Drude-

this agreement, far infrared measurements indicate that like. The main contributions to the error bars in these

! 1 at about 3000 GHz just above Tc, so a 300-fold spectra are a combination of uncertainty in the individual

increase in below Tc would mean ! 1 at about 10 measurements' calibration constants, plus a substantial

GHz, leading to the considerable frequency dependence uncertainty in the background loss in the 1.1 GHz mea-

in 1 (!) that we observe in the microwave range. surements, and scatter in the 2.2 GHz measurements.

Within these error estimates (mostly sytematic error)

there is very little clear deviation from a Drude lineshape

7

when examining an individual spectrum at a particular

temperature. The most noticeable deviation is in the

spectrum at 4 K, where the data may be taking on a 60 From fits

From 1/λ

2

nearly Lorentzian lineshape largely conrms the ansatz

originally used by Bonn et al. [29] to analyze the early

Rs (T ) measurements.

nne /m (10 Ω m s )

−1 −1

An interesting cross-check of these ts to 1 (!) is

40

−1

conductivity peak, which is given by the t parameter

17

nn e2 =m, to the super
uid density ns e2 =m = (o 2 ) 1

extracted from the penetration depth measurements. If 20

one assumes that all of the oscillator strength ends up

2

in the super
uid -funtion as T!0, then the super
uid

density is related to the normal
uid density via Equa-

tion 3.8. Fig. 7 shows a comparison between the normal

uid density inferred from the ts to the 1 (!) peaks 0

and the normal
uid density inferred from the penetra- 0 10 20 30 40

tion depth via Eq. 3.8. This gure indicates that the T(K)

normal
uid density does nearly track the decline of the

super
uid density with increasing temperature, which in- FIG. 7. A comparison of the normal
uid oscillator

dicates that our use of a two-
uid model to describe the strength determined in two ways; from Drude ts to spec-

screening is a reasonable procedure. The increasingly se- tra like those of Figs. 5 and 6 and from the disappearance of

rious deviation betweeen the curves above 30 K is an oscillator strength in the super
uid response, as measured by

indication that the Drude lineshapes do not completely 1=2 (Fig. 3).

keep track of where all of the oscillator strength is going

as temperature increases. There is also some deviation been obtained in measurements on thin lms by high fre-

at low temperatures, taking the form of a normal
uid quency microwave and THz techniques [8,19]. However,

oscillator strength that is extrapolating linearly towards the much higher level of defects in such samples limits

a non-zero value as T!0. This is an indication of the the temperature range over which the evolution of the

presence of residual conductivity in the low temperature, inelatic scattering rate can be observed. In the high pu-

low frequency limit, which is expected for a d-wave su- rity crystals, the temperature dependent scattering can

perconductor [42]. be tracked all the way down to 20 K. A t to the form

The quality of the ts to 1 (!) and the agreement in 1= (T ) = A + B (T=Tc)y from 4 to 40 K yields an ex-

the oscillator strengths shown in Fig. 7 indicate that ponent y = 4:2 0:1, with coecients A = 5.2(0.4)

the Drude ts do provide a reasonable measure of the 1010 s 1 and B = 4.6(0.9) 1012 s 1 , and is shown

width of the peaks from 4 to 45 K. The temperature as the solid curve in Fig. 8. The uncertainty in the ex-

dependent width coming from these ts, which we in- ponent indicates the maximum range that is consistent

terpret as the scattering rate of the thermally excited with the data to within the estimated errors shown in

quasiparticles, is shown in Fig. 8. One of the key re- Fig. 8.

sults of these measurements is that the width of the nor-

mal
uid peak is very small, 91 GHz, and it is nearly

temperature-independent up to 20 K. The main change in V. DISCUSSION

the spectra in this temperature range is an increase in os-

cillator strength, due to the shift of spectral weight from For the purposes of discussing the data, we have di-

the super
uid response (a -function at !=0) to the mi- vided the conductivity spectra up into the two regimes

crowave conductivity. The narrow width suggests a very discussed in the previous section. In the range below

long quasiparticle scattering time of 1.8(0:2) 10 11 s. about 20 K where the width of the peak in 1 (!) is

One sees in Fig. 6 that above 25 K the conductivity narrow and nearly temperature independent, studies of

peak broadens rapidly and by 60 K the width becomes samples over a wide range of purities indicate that this

much greater than the frequency range of the microwave regime is governed by thermally excited quasiparticles

measurements, so we have no direct measure of the width being scattered by impurities or other defects [30,50].

and shape of 1 (!) above 60 K. The exceptionally low Waldram et al. have pointed out the possibility that

level of defects in the new BaZrO3 grown crystals, cou- non-local eects might come into play in the conductiv-

pled with the measurements at 5 microwave frequencies, ity in this regime, leading to an eective scattering rate

allows us to determine the temperature dependence of the that is not in
uenced by the density of residual impurities

inelastic scattering rate over a fairly wide temperature [43]. However, the considerable narrowing of 1 (!) that

range from 20 to 40 K. Qualitatively similar results have

8

Fermi surface. In particular, it has been pointed out by

2 Hirschfeld et al. that elastic impurity scattering in this

situation should lead to a frequency and temperature de-

pendent scattering rate because of the restricted phase

space into which the quasiparticles at the nodes can scat-

ter [44,46]. So, with this possible con
ict between theory

and the phenomenological model in mind, we will make

some more detailed comparison between the microwave

1/τ(10 s )

11 −1

1 tions.

The transport properties (both microwave conductiv-

ity and thermal conductivity) of a dx2 y2 superconductor

have been the subject of considerable theoretical eort

recently [42,44{48]. This work builds on earlier calcula-

tions of the transport properties of anisotropic supercon-

ductors, aimed primarily at explaining and predicting the

0 properties of heavy fermion superconductors [51,52]. The

0 10 20 30 40 high temperature superconductors now oer an opportu-

T(K) nity to test these calculations in a situation where we

have a relatively simple anisotropic pairing state. Such

FIG. 8. The scattering rate of the thermally excited quasi- comparisons are somewhat complex because the question

particles, as inferred from the width of Drude ts to the con- of transport properties at low temperatures is inherently

ductivity spectra of Figs. 5 and 6. The solid curve is a t to a question of understanding impurity eects. This is es-

a scattering rate that increases as T 4 2 .

:

pecially the case for anisotropic superconductors because

the presence of impurities has a strong impact on the

excitation spectrum near gap nodes, particularly in the

we have observed upon going from YSZ-grown crystals limit of unitary scattering.

to the higher purity BaZrO3 -grown crystals indicates A key eect of impurities in an anisotropic supercon-

that the samples are still in a regime where impurities ductor is to produce a band of impurity states with a

play a role in the low frequency scattering. We have width , thus giving the superconductor a non-zero den-

previously suggested an intuitively appealing way to in- sity of states at the Fermi level. One surprising conse-

terpret the spectra in this regime, based on a specic quence of these states is a universal conductivity limit at

version of the two uid model [29]. In this phenomeno- low frequency as T ! 0, rst pointed out by P.A. Lee

logical picture, the quasiparticles excited near the nodes [42]. This residual conductivity is independent of impu-

in the energy gap have a temperature-independent scat- rity concentration, the result of a cancellation between

tering rate due to elastic scattering by impurities and the density of states induced by the presence of the im-

a conductivity spectrum with a Drude lineshape whose purities and the lifetime associated with those states. A

width is set by this scattering rate 1=i just like impu- version of this universal limit has been observed by Taille-

rity scattering in a normal metal. In the high purity fer et al. in thermal conductivity measurements of pure

samples this 1=i would correspond to a strikingly long and Zn-doped Y Ba2 Cu3 O6:9 below 1 Kelvin [53]. To the

mean free path of 4 m if one takes the Fermi velocity best of our knowledge, this limit has not yet been deni-

to be vF = 2 107cm=s. In this particular two uid tively observed in microwave conductivity measurements,

model, the only source of temperature dependence in the in part due to sensitivity problems in the type of cavity

low temperature microwave conductivity is the density perturbation measurement being discussed in this arti-

of the thermally excited quasiparticles, which increases cle. Instead, our main concern here will be the behaviour

linearly with temperature. This is a straightforward con- of this conductivity as temperature and frequency are

sequence of the linear dispersion of the gap function near increased, which involves conductivities that are sub-

the nodes and is also intimately connected to the linear stantially larger than the T!0 limit and are thus eas-

temperature dependence of the penetration depth (they ily measurable with the methods discussed above. This

are Kramers-Kronig related). microwave conductivity has been the subject of consid-

Parameterizing the normal uid response in this way, erable theoretical eort, including both numerical work

with a temperature dependent density and a scattering and analytical results in certain limits [44{48].

rate, has been partly justied by calculations of the mi- One well studied case involves the electrodynamic

crowave conductivity of a dx2 y2 superconductor [44]. properties at temperatures and frequencies below the im-

However, it is not so obvious that a temperature indepen- purity bandwidth , in the unitary scattering limit (scat-

dent scattering rate is expected for impurity scattering tering phase shift ! =2). In this limit the impurity

of these thermally excited quasiparticles near the nodes, bandwidth is given roughly by ( )1=2 where

since they dier greatly from free carriers at an ungapped is the magnitude of the gap and is the elastic scat-

9

1.14 GHz

tering rate that the impurities would contribute to the 2.25 GHz

normal state resistivity. For !; T <
, where the trans- 13.4 GHz

port properties are dominated by this impurity band, it 4

22.7 GHz

has been shown that both 1 and vary as T 2 [44,45]. 75.3 GHz

σ1(10 Ω m )

−1

This quadratic behaviour has been seen in Zn-doped sam-

ples of Y Ba2 Cu3 O6:95 , where it was found that at a Zn

−1

impurity concentration as low as 0.15 % the crossover

7

energy scale is already
> 4 K [49,30]. However, Zn

substitution for planar Cu's is the only impurity that we 2

have found that clearly gives this unitary scattering be-

haviour. Ni substitution for Cu, Ca substitution for Y,

and the chain oxygen vacancies all have much weaker ef-

fects, even at defect levels of 1% or more [21]. The previ-

ous generation of YSZ-grown crystals showed only slight

curvature in (T ) and 1 (T ) below 4 Kelvin and the new 0

BaZrO3 -grown crystals show no hint of T 2 temperature

dependence down to 1.2 Kelvin. The relative rarity of T 2

behaviour (though it is common in lms for reasons that

remain unclear [54]) leads us to consider the opposite

limit for the strength of the scattering, the Born limit.

For impurity scattering in the Born limit, the crossover 0.4

energy scale is exponentially small, so one does not ex-

pect to see the universal conductivity limit until measure-

ments are performed well below 1 Kelvin. In fact, in the

microwave measurements presented here we are also not

necessarily at low enough or frequency to observe any 0.2

simple limiting behaviour. So, we compare our results

qualitatively to numerical calculations performed in the

Born limit by Hirschfeld et al. [46]. They found that at

very low frequency 1 (T ) rises rapidly from the universal

zero temperature limit to a much larger conductivity that

depends upon the impurity scattering rate. It remains 0.0

0 5 10 15 20

fairly temperature independent until inelastic scattering T(K)

processes become important. At higher frequencies 1 (T ) FIG. 9. This detailed view of the temperature dependence

becomes smaller and moves through a whole range of be- of the microwave conductivity below 20 K shows a gradual

haviours, varying from mostly sub-linear in T at low fre- evolution of the shape of of 1 (T ), from concave up at high fre-

quency, through a quasi-linear temperature dependence quencies to concave down at the lowest frequencies. The quite

at intermediate frequencies, to a faster than linear tem- linear temperature dependence seen here at 13 GHz seems to

perature dependence at high frequencies. Figure 9 shows be an intermediate behaviour.

behaviour in the measured microwave conductivity that

is similar to this Born limit result in some of its qualita- sub-linear as expected in the Born limit. However, one

tive features. The overall conductivity has a magnitude perhaps important dierence from the theoretical calcu-

that varies with purity, from the quite high values seen lations is that the trend does not to continue below 2

here, through to very low,
at conductivities observed GHz. The data stops evolving towards the expected low

in Ni-doped samples [30]. More importantly, here we do frequency behaviour, which is a rapid leap upwards to a

clearly see for the rst time that the linear behaviour constant value. The reason for this is not yet clear, so

of 1 (T ) is an intermediate behaviour, albeit one that we are left for the moment with qualitative features that

survives over a substantial range of frequency and tem- seem only weakly in accord with Born limit scattering.

perature. The evolution in the shape of 1 (T ) at low Other features of the data echo the expectations of a con-

T clearly falls outside of our phenomenological model, ductivity spectrum with a Drude-like lineshape that has

which would have predicted a linear temperature depen- a temperature independent width; namely, the similarity

dence at all of the frequencies shown in Fig. 9. That in the 1 and 2 GHz curves and the relatively large fre-

is, if 1 (!) were really Drude-shaped with a temperature quency and temperature range over which 1 (T ) is nearly

independent width, then 1 (T ) would exhibit the same linear in T. It is the latter aspects of the data that lead

temperature dependence at all frequencies; namely, the to the Drude model being a fairly good description of the

linear temperature dependence of the normal
uid den- conductivity spectra.

sity. Although the foregoing discussion indicates that the

At our lowest frequencies the data does move towards

10

1 (!) spectra cannot be perfectly Drude shaped, there is collapses rapidly and it becomes easily discernible in the

still a characteristic width to the peaks that is well pa- microwave spectral range at temperatures below 55 K.

rameterized by the Drude ts. Thus, the plot of scatter- In the range between 45 K and 20 K we nd that the

ing rates shown in Fig. 8 provides a reasonable measure collapse of the scattering rate varies at least as fast as

of the narrowness of the peak at low temperature and T 4. By 20 K the width becomes extremely narrow and

its rapid broadening above 20 K. Just above 20 K, the nearly temperature independent. This narrow width of

initial onset of this increase in scattering appears to be only 9 GHz corresponds to a mean free path as high as

at least as rapid as T 4 and must rise even more quickly 4 m if we interpret the width as being a direct mea-

at higher temperatures in order to meet the width ob- sure of the elastic scattering rate due to impurities. We

served in the normal state far infrared measurements. A nd that some features of 1 (!; T ) below 20 K are in ac-

rapid temperature dependence of the quasiparticle scat- cord with quasiparticle scattering in the Born limit for a

tering time would be expected in any situation where the dx2 y2 superconductor, in particular, a gradual evolution

inelastic scattering comes from interactions that become of the shape of 1 (T ) from sublinear T dependence at low

gapped below Tc . A number of early calculations tackled !, to quasilinear and then faster at higher !. However,

the problem of the collapse of the scattering rate below there remain discrepancies that might best be settled by

Tc in this way. Early on, Nuss et al. explained the peak a detailed numerical calculation aimed at tting the ob-

in their THz conductivity measurements in this manner servations presented here. Such ts must come to grips

[8]. Littlewood and Varma studied this type of eect with the observation that the behaviour of 1 (!; T ) below

in a marginal Fermi liquid [55], the idea being that be- 20 K is reasonably well described by a model involving

low Tc a gap opens up in the scattering spectrum. Statt quasiparticle scattering with a temperature-independent

and Grin similarly studied the eect of the opening of scattering rate.

a gap in the spectrum of spin
uctuations [56]. All of

this work predated the solid identication of the dx2 y2

pairing state, so isotropic s-wave gaps were assumed in ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

the calculations. Quinlan et al. studied a model in

which quasiparticle lifetimes were associated with spin We are greatly indebted to A.J. Berlinsky and C.

uctuation scattering. They studied the eects of both Kallin for many helpful discussions regarding transport

s wave and d wave gaps opening up in the spin
uc- properties in d-wave superconductors. We wish also to

tuation spectrum [57]. Since we now know that the gap acknowledge helpful conversations with D.J. Scalapino,

in this material has dx2 y2 symmetry, this latter calcula- P.J. Hirschfeld, P. A. Lee and G. Sawatsky, and are grate-

tion is most directly relevant to our measurements here. ful for the opportunity to carry out some of this work at

In particular they found that at temperatures well below the Aspen Center for Physics. We also thank J. Trodahl

Tc, the quasiparticle lifetime increases as T 3 and even for his contribution to the design of the 75 GHz cavity

faster than this as Tc is approached. In a comparable setup. This research was supported by the Natural Sci-

temperature range, the transport scattering rate that we ence and Engineering Research Council of Canada and

extract from the width of 1 (!) is closer to T 4. Thus, the the Canadian Institute for Advanced Research. DAB ac-

temperature dependence of the inelastic scattering rate knowledges support from the Sloan Foundation.

seems to be about one power of T faster than the lifetime

calculations based on a gapping of the spin
uctuation

spectrum. One must note, however, that the quasipar-

ticle lifetime can in principle dier from the electronic

transport scattering time, since charge transport is most

strongly aected by backscattering.

Permanent address Dept. of Physics and Astronomy, Mc-

Master University, 1080 Main St. W, Hamilton, ON, L8S

VI. CONCLUSIONS 4M1, Canada.

[1] W.N. Hardy, D.A. Bonn, D.C. Morgan, Ruixing Liang,

We have presented here the most complete microwave and Kuan Zhang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 3999 (1993).

measurements yet obtained on a crystal of a high tem- [2] D.M. Broun, D.C. Morgan, R.J. Ormeno, S.F. Lee, A.W.

perature superconductor. These spectra reveal a wealth Tyler, A.P. MacKenzie, and J.R. Waldram, Phys. Rev.

of detail regarding the conductivity spectrum 1 (!) of B 56, 11443 (1997).

the thermally excited quaiparticles in the superconduct- [3] L.A. de Vaulchier, J.P. Vieren, Y. Guldner, N. Bontemps,

ing state. We nd that 1 (!) has a Drude-like shape. R. Combescot, Y. Lemaitre, and J.C. Mage, Europhys.

Lett. 33, 153 (1996).

Although in detail there may be deviations from this [4] Shih-Fu Lee et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 735 (1996).

shape, there is nevertheless a well dened characteristic [5] T. Jacobs, S. Sridhar, Qiang Li, G.D. Gu, and N.

width which can be associated with the transport scat- Koshizuka, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 4516 (1995).

tering time of the quasiparticles. Below Tc the width

11

[6] S. Kamal, D.A. Bonn, Nigel Goldenfeld, and P.J. [32] D. Miller, P.L. Richards, S. Etemad, A. Inam, T.

Hirschfeld, Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 1845, (1994). Venkatesan, B. Dutta, and X.D. Wu, Phys. Rev. B 47,

[7] D.A. Bonn, P. Dosanjh, R. Liang, and W.N. Hardy, Phys. 8076 (1993).

Rev. Lett. 68, 2390 (1992). [33] M.S. Pambianchi, S.N. Mao, and S.M. Anlage, Phys.

[8] Martin C. Nuss, P.M. Mankiewich, M.L. O'Malley, E.H. Rev. B 53, 4477 (1995).

Westerwick, and Peter B. Littlewood, Phys. Rev. Lett. [34] H.K. Olson and R.H. Koch, Phys. Rev. Lett. bf 68, 2406

66, 3305 (1991). (1991).

[9] R.C. Yu, M.B. Salamon, J.P. Lu, and W.C. Lee, Phys. [35] N.E. Glass and W.F. Hall, Phys. Rev B 44, 4495 (1991).

Rev. Lett. 69, 1431 (1992). [36] H. Srikanth, B.A. Willemsen, T. Jacobs, S. Sridhar, A.

[10] T. Shibauchi, A. Maeda, H. Kitano, T. Honda, and K. Erb, E. Walker, and R. Flukiger, Phys. Rev. B 55, 14733

Uchimokura, Physica C 203, 315 (1992). (1997).

[11] Jian Mao, D.H. Wu, J.L. Peng, R.L. Greene, and Steven [37] O. Klein, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 1390 (1994).

M. Anlage, Phys. Rev. B 51, 3316 (1995). [38] K. Holczer, O. Klein, and G. Gruner, Sol. St. Comm. 78,

[12] Kuan Zhang, D.A. Bonn, Ruixing Liang, D.J. Baar, 875 (1991).

W.N. Hardy, D. Basov and T. Timusk, Phys. Rev. Lett. [39] P.C. Hammell, M. Takigawa, R.H. Hener, Z. Fisk, and

73, 2484 (1994). K.C. Ott, Phys. Rev. Lett. 63, 1992 (1989).

[13] Steven M. Anlage, Dong-Ho Wu, J. Mao, X.X. Xi, T. [40] D.J. Scalapino, in High Temperature Superconductiv-

Venkatesan, J.L. Peng, and R.L. Greene, Phys. Rev. B ity, edited by K.S. Bedell, D. Coey, D. Meltzer, D.

50, 523 (1994). Pines, and J.R. Schrieer (Addison-Wesley, Reading,

[14] T. Shibauchi, H. Kitano, K. Uchinokura, A. Maeda, T. MA, 1990).

Kimura, and K. Kishio, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 2263 (1994). [41] N. Bulut and D.J. Scalapino, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 706

[15] H. Kitano, T. Shibauchi, K. Uchinokura, A. Maeda, H. (1992).

Asaoka, and H. Takei, Phys. Rev. B 51, 1401 (1995). [42] P.A. Lee, Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 1887 (1993).

[16] U. Dahne, Y. Goncharov, N. Klein, N. Tellmann, G. Ko- [43] J.R. Waldram, P. Theopistou, A. Porch, and H.-M.

zlov, and K. Urban, J. Supercond. 8, 129 (1995). Cheah, Phys. Rev. B 55, 3222 (1997).

[17] D.B. Romero, C.D. Porter, D.B. Tanner, L. Forro, D. [44] P.J. Hirschfeld, W.O. Puttika, and D.J. Scalapino, Phys.

Mandrus, L. Mihaly, G.L. Carr, and G.P. Williams, Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 3705 (1993).

Rev. Lett. 68, 1590 (1992). [45] Peter J. Hirschfeld and Nigel Goldenfeld, Phys. Rev. B

[18] S. Spielman, Beth Parks, J. Orenstein, D.T. Nemeth, 48, 4219 (1993).

John Clarke, Paul Merchant, and D.J. Lew, Phys. Rev. [46] P.J. Hirschfeld, W.O. Puttika, and D.J. Scalapino, Phys.

Lett. 73 1538 (1994). Rev. B 50, 10250 (1994).

[19] A. Pimenov, A. Loidl, G. Jakob, and H. Adrian, preprint. [47] D. Xu, S.K. Yip, and J.A. Sauls, Phys. Rev. B 51, 16233

[20] K. Krishana, J.M. Harris, and N.P. Ong, Phys. Rev. Lett. (1995).

75, 3529 (1995). [48] S. Hensen, G. Muller, C.T. Rieck, and K. Scharnberg,

[21] W.N. Hardy et al., in Proc. of the 10 Anniversary HTS

th

Phys. Rev. B 56, 6237 (1997).

Workshop (World Sci., Singapore, 1996); D.A. Bonn et [49] D. Achkir, M. Poirier, D.A. Bonn, Ruixing Liang, and

al., in Proc. of the 21st Low Temp. Phys. Conf., Czech. W.N. Hardy, Phys. Rev. B 48, 13184 (1993).

J. Phys. 46, 3195 (1996). [50] Kuan Zhang, D.A. Bonn, Ruixing Liang, D.J. Baar, and

[22] A. Hosseini, Saeid Kamal, D.A. Bonn, Ruixing Liang, W.N. Hardy, Appl. Phys. Lett. 62, 3019 (1993).

and W.N. Hardy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 1298 (1998). [51] P.J. Hirschfeld, P. Wol
e, J.A. Sauls, D. Einzel, and

[23] J.L. Tallon, C. Bernhard, U. Binninger, A. Hofer, G.V.M. W.O. Puttika, Phys. Rev. B 40, 6695 (1989).

Williams, E.J. Ansaldo, J.I. Budnick, and Ch. Nieder- [52] R.A. Klemm, K. Scharnberg, D. Walker, and C.T. Rieck,

mayer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 1008 (1995). Z. Phys. 72, 139 (1988).

[24] B. Gowe, P. Dosanjh, and D.A. Bonn, to be published. [53] Louis Taillefer et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 483 (1997).

[25] Ruixing Liang, D.A. Bonn, and W.N. Hardy, Physica C [54] D.A. Bonn and W.N. Hardy, in Physical Properties of

304, 105 (1998). High Temperature Superconductors, Vol. V, ed. by D.M.

[26] A. Erb, E. Walker, and R. Flukiger, Physica C 245, 9 Ginsberg (World Scientic,Singapore, 1996).

(1996). [55] P.B. Littlewood and C.M. Varma, Phys. Rev. B 46, 405

[27] A. Erb, J.Y. Genoud, F. Marti, M. Daumling, E. Walker, (1992).

and R. Flukiger, J. Low Temp. Phys. 105, 1023 (1996). [56] B.W. Statt and A. Grin, Phys. Rev. B 46, 3199 (1992).

[28] S.Kamal, Ruixing Liang, A. Hosseini, D.A. Bonn, and [57] S.M. Quinlan, D.J. Scalapino, and N. Bulut, Phys. Rev.

W.N. Hardy, Phys. Rev. B 58, 8933 (1998). B 49, 1470 (1994).

[29] D.A. Bonn, Kuan Zhang, Ruixing Liang, D.J. Baar, D.C.

Morgan, P. Dosanjh, T.L. Duty, A. MacFarlane, G.D.

Morris, J.H. Brewer, W.N. Hardy, C. Kallin, and A.J.

Berlinsky, Phys. Rev. B 47, 11314 (1993).

[30] D.A. Bonn, S. Kamal, Kuan Zhang, Ruixing Liang, D.J.

Baar, and W.N. Hardy, Phys. Rev. B 50, 4051 (1994).

[31] Ioan Kosztin and Anthony J. Leggett, Phys. Rev. Lett.

79, 135 (1997).

12

- Band Theory of SolidsUploaded byParie Perdana
- TH_3Uploaded byMohamed Ben Mansour
- Electrical and thermal conductivities of reduced graphene oxidepolystyrene composites.pdfUploaded byFamiloni Layo
- adeoti fUploaded byRoland Rawlins Igabor
- Flomat EngUploaded byalex.amaral9292
- English for electrical engineering.pdfUploaded byDharma Wati
- adiabaticUploaded byapi-225932882
- 10Uploaded byArogya Raju Pudhota
- Article Wattez Duhart Lorente (2)Uploaded byThom Watt
- 1D Sunsurface Em Fields Excited by Energized Steel CasingUploaded byyangwei00414312
- Info IEC 62305-1Uploaded bys525497
- MWE_Expt1_2017Uploaded byHRIDAY HARIA
- The Radiation Poisoning of AmericaUploaded byThorsteinn Thorsteinsson
- 986Uploaded byozgurdal
- SECOND SEMESTER PHYSICS -2 TWO MARKS WITH ANSWERS REGULATION 2013Uploaded byPRIYA RAJI
- Electric CurrentUploaded byJohn Johnson
- MM5017_Assignment1Uploaded byArg Sreekar
- Soil ResistivityUploaded byrasheed313
- JNTU Mechanical Engineering (R09) Syllabus BookUploaded byvishnu351
- Eg_EJPUploaded bydesta18
- Soil Resistivity Data Computations Single and Two Layer Soil ResistivitUploaded byChaw Su Lwel
- Kaowool Paper 1260Uploaded bypraveentien
- Lec. 2Uploaded byIhssan Jamall
- coursenotes.pdfUploaded bysindy larasati
- 20140912140912 w 1 IntroductionUploaded byNicholas Ortiz
- Physical Experiment LabUploaded byJhonel Paul Sobrados Quezada
- P436_Lect_08.pdfUploaded byZhenhua Huang
- Temperature Dependence in SC ConductivityUploaded byGowrisankar Rao
- Electrical and Dielectric Characterization of Na0.5Li0.5Zr2(PO4)3Uploaded byUmaru Ahmadu
- The Hall Effect in Polycrystalline and Powdered SemiconductorsUploaded byNassar Al-Essawi

- The Wizard Christ OutlineUploaded byJustice Dubhghaill
- Rules for Topographic ProfilesUploaded byShiirleyLizz
- Up2 V01 I01-FA SmallUploaded bySunway University
- bansigUploaded byMarc Armand Balubal Maruzzo
- Economics Prob Set . 2Uploaded byAditya Jagnani
- 6. 24k in 24hoursUploaded byJoanne Wehle Dailey
- Learning Microsoft Word 2007 - IntroductionUploaded byGuided Computer Tutorials
- The Relationship Between Sufi and Political Elites of Inner AsiaUploaded byAlexandreShah
- The Gujarat Maritime Board Act 1981Uploaded byVibrant Gujarat
- Genesis Investment v Heirs of Ebarasabal Pecuniary DigestUploaded byIcon Montius
- City Solicitor's Memo to Springfield Emmployees on Casino IssueUploaded byThe Republican/MassLive.com
- TM-2201 AVEVA Marine (12.1) Outfitting Foundations Rev 3.0Uploaded byAnonymous 08sVWgFQax
- Constraints to Edu Planning in NigeriaUploaded bypraisepresh
- Biliary Atresia2012.pdfUploaded byvmanthos
- ENGLESKA GRAMATIKAUploaded bymarko
- Pregnancy With Internal Medical DiseasesUploaded bysanjivdas
- Disiplin SekUploaded byMimi Amizah
- Byzantine Garden CultureUploaded bycrabscribd
- Chapter13 Controlling and Troubleshooting the Red Hat Enterprise Linux Boot Process(2)Uploaded byBrent Michel Farmer
- Earth Science sample testUploaded byaronrodriguez
- GRE Word List-IUploaded byTarun Mattaparthy
- Influence of an Outdoor Garden on Mood and Stress in Older PersonsUploaded byKonstantinidis851
- Burns - PrinciplesUploaded bysuperjaxxxon
- 150920 AMN Lanny Sinkin Moscow PresentationUploaded byKingdom of Hawaii (Alii Nui Moi Edmund K. Silva, Jr.)
- How to Write an Article- Preparing a Publishable Manuscript! (3)Uploaded byhgtfrtfyghj
- Americorps Handbook | Season of Service Mountain CorpsUploaded byAccessible Journal Media: Peace Corps Documents
- Oklahoma! (1998 Revival Script)Uploaded byBrian O'Brien
- 2015 Bull Mock CAT 31.pdf_451ce8dd-094f-49f9-b4e9-570665c1cad9Uploaded byPrateek Sarin
- Assertive Communication GuideUploaded byKorporativac Konsaltingić
- Cfm 300 Advanced Taxation (Day Eve)Uploaded byKafonyi John