"

'E' N·- .. o· ... s···· .

... _-\ ···\1: \ .

" " .

. .

, . ., . 1 I •......... '.... . .

Copyrighted material

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'Ch~stine: :KDIisgaard, hat 'heome ijn~ of tD,e leading: ,mttllJn1tlrefS, of Kan'~~lS mOdI, :pb'ilGsQ.'b.,. S'he is. bjlen,'tiJied 'With ,I ,smaU POll, 'D'f :phUoso,h'e'J',s, 'who ,are :P:f.I)(hl~lnl; D, \I!YtrsiOfi 0:1 :Kantl':s :m~l'td, :,billosoph,' 't'~iiiIi,t~ Is ,a;t, O1l,Ce sen:s:iJtl've 'LqD :U", :hist:orJ!c:.al

'h ~'~ 'I·· . 'I'~ ~ "

:~s 'W,~, II e rev,e!a IUlg 1,'t\S, pa'r~Jlc'W!la_r :r:eleV'an;oe~ 'tiit!il iCfillitcmpo~

.~ -~,-~~'Il.;;1[,- _,Ii!!' CiL;iI; ,~~ ';~''''''''Ii' ,,,jk.a f;'i!'~":I.::,j.;j'Ii"!iI'i'i,,,,'l- ,~ ... t<i1i'~Tci!i; ""~"ru"'ii'Ii,,,jie ;a,lI!jIkJraJf, p:~nllll~e!J£_I_'iJhil ~[(~ lre."IC~.;:" 'II_~;t_1!Jr.~ :'-.Ij.Wl~t1u-.~I_"~ ,~tl~-~~Ii ~ u-.Il; .1\iI_1~~~ ;~.[~-~~~=

;~,CS' alS, ,I ~Jd, ",",WS:io;A.I!lt: '~Ihe :mo.ifd lliife 'w,bi~h, 1e'~~raSi~$ dl~lt,y ,art '~'[h~; '!!_'l~ns;~ 'o:f h),v~ Ind, V,ailliu.~. 'Ra;~~t Kmlt~"s, 'W\Qllc" :~s' :S~dD !1lS,

'"~·.ifr''':o1i,1Il·'I!IOI": ""I ' .. a""~'1'o;~;g f"o' C "I" !,.,~..ll_~';'''''"''mg.' "1'-' n;f>t" , ,n"'I~""~.' qc'll~'''''''''~.mo~if' ;:i;~'7Fj;~'iio

I. ,~· .. lJ..U- ·iIJ_~· .IS ,IJL~UU~,~!Ii:r.' .... Ij, d.-tJl_W}!I.:r.'iJI!iaI_ . . . lIoL-U, I y. .. _~lI" J L. u1!11:ii-a.!Ir.~IUUa~_~_~1 '~~'UI,,"

[ e ~ _ " ~ ~ ·~·~-~.'I. ". ~ ~ __ ~ _'_ ~ ~ ~ _ •• ~ ~ ~ • ~. _.'_.' ~. _ .•. ' ~ I. ~ w - w - w • w w •

'~h~ mt~U!phys.ic~ of :rnGl':ds,w bu,'~ alse pr:JQt1ca:~, 'Q,UestiQIDS 3jOOU:~ ~fs.~n;lil, re'~iltj~DJSw :poUtii~sw ,aDd e:v,erJ~~,' hLlilm~, imlt~'r;iJ¢;ljjni~J,,,

Thi.'9 ,c.)Jleet~,(In eJ UDi1een ,eSSilYS ~s' dii,vid,ed :~n:tl~ n",o :paRs\;. :p~,rnt: One 10'1k~1l8 an 'e.li~ll:tGfi :wnd, b~,t~q.n:emdQn of: 't'~e :Ul,OI:al :,hiIoso-pilY1' ~fid, muldi ,sefV\e ,iii'S ,9 COR:.tEen:ta:ry on ft)~ G1:0U11,"=

u~I .. ;j'·, ry"] ·,,;ii;.dI' ,i\~'~:;ji'.tii!n;~1l!''c~'",",\<'1 nf':' ,iIi,iI'£iI'"'i!I'i!~''' 'i" ..... I-· ""'r'""',n, ,"'.\~'I"I!jIlno<i'Iii';'i!! ... ,.,;,;AI "'-~.~.J [~I ['-::I~g '~"ll~~-~~·~)!· ~-~~~ ~., ~y~~~.~,lgI~!1 .I"~-~ '" ~ '¥r.'~ ~-.U~. ,~ r~.'~~ ~1:IIi..IJ~1~1 ~.

[OOD;tra~~s, ,~Jti!'~, :p'hil!.tI~ph,y wltb, I~th~~' :~nI.'U~lllti;:d, :m~I,;d, :ph~,,,, '~ii'!i~""'~b(~"'011'_ 'ill. ",,":,j!o'li:-, 'h~,~,I't~~,..,.,-'1 [~Ari~,.O'dlilli"- ,tC;1~''''\,;~i ... 'I.. M~I'f!i;~ ,i''IIitjil;d! I~J~-ov.rt __ '}I!;Q~ L~!Ir_IJI!. ==--",,~I~Vi_'_]~~ ~=~=~;'--'-~~i' iJI~~~Jl""l~-~---lIl =. =~_jI'~~ ~~_

:HJU'm~~1 ,I'mi, 'oon'tJem~ranr '~WiU~:amsw N~g~~t >and, iPal',fi)t~J", TWo :p.adit;uLIli.' j'oea:l :~i'm,t~ ,of: het'in,te,tpmt':a!tioo, 9ire KSlim,tlls 't'~e.fity' [~f~ 'y,due ,aiil.d :his, 'w,idemy' :mis;und:e,rn,9tood d,Qctnme uf the if.'[\,WO ;s~afidpQ;in'ts.,·1;. 'When, '~b,e-'Se; ideas ,arre hrlU,y e:x:plaiImedJ ,ac'Co:rdI~n,g '~O :ICiQlrSgaaid, :_any of: the 'tr~JHtio;flliiIJ'~, pH)bte:m~ w,~,t'h, ,.d pllZi~

'''~;~[~--l ,. -;Ii..,=;-; ~-r-,iIc,~', V,7" ;o1i:-;-lf;-Ii'~1 a,-, '" il'1-.'·h" ii' c-,;" ,d·:-';IDJ~imn," ~~~ a,- ),'tiiiii' __ ,,",w,es iilil.!JU'U ... ,A-iIII1aiJ" ;;]! ~ll ,1,C;;]!_Ii3a:,t."ct"~iII'-:li'-

Thi~ oO:i]!CC~tl'oll ,oO:ll!liaI~fiS snmle, lOof tlbJe :G;~es,t: wlmk, being: [du~,e O[1i.i, :KooJt:-'s, ,et'ih'tC5, and wiU ,rom_mmd the: aIt,telltjJOll, o:f ,aU '~'ilft.,os~ ,m.VQ]v~, :~n '~~~mng ,~nd, :s,,"ud,y,in;g ,mcrJ',a'~, ~Jb~oIJ,

l~

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Copy rig hted m ateri al

"f'~lU"t' in TmmiB M~d~aE,!/-,al

'·$',F-~-·'I __ . ,. - -~"- .. ---- ...

,;Ii, ,if';iI'ii,'I\"i;I;n.jj!';j~~'" .r,"''i7-h.~' ,{"' •. 1".iI!..~"~ ,~_l'. , •. : .. , .... , • ..,..~.iI'\i':li..,.:.,i<', I(~'"",' ",;1,.." :Di"c~"'~".!I;. ," .1i~k,,,, .. u-'I\' l~ ~:~~~Q_;!P.I 1l~!I.i-~1J ~~ IViI] .. _l~~I1~ [l~ [_iJI! ~i:r.~-,-~_l'_IiIIl~:":'- j.·~'!I.iI .• ::._II. L_flD .U-J:,~;[,:_~'..,.J~! LILI. IUifll:'_[';I~

,U~r~, ~ C~~&' 'C~~l1rCi9!___mg.,m .. hbli~,d:Q'n f}a~ i~ ,~¥~,lilli',~1'6 lSRN' O~,~,~4$l644-<6 b~db'4~k,

:I:S:B:N' O',,~,! ~ ~4(9)!:62'~1 'p.a:PGl'bEk

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Copy rig hted m ateri al

l~'~~ 'f ~ ~ d' ~ ~ ~ 'l'" ~ ~~

'_- .- "." '\.' - ,"_, 1

a, . m .' i~'C 'I,~l'].

[ AID m'tro(tu[;~iQn ti~ dl~~ e~'hicl1Jt "!lJ,u,Uc;rut, .!tf:lJd i\e:~i@,(gU;5 d~,(J~p:t c.j' :K~n:t

'i K.a[l'itt"',S :FOImUm.o1 'U'n'~,~tttw.s.~I, I4,w 71'7

.4, l;ain'~"':s formula 'Ot :H:u'mum~:t,. ]:,06,

s: The d.'~ '~O l'rn;e:: :K!iln'~ ~n d!eo:~imte:: i!,\;v,~tl~ ie~n :1; 31

6, :MQf~H.ty ,aIS, :&r:eeed!(Xm ~~ 5:'9

7' Cpa,'~ ,th~ :rljngdo:~ O[ End~,; :R~(ii'prod.ty' ,a'l'iJ;d

re:S1'l)n~~b.ni~,V' in '~~~f;Sani8Jm. :~lrl:t~ilLms ]' ~,S

EO Tlb~ ~'s'~,ns ~!: ~an sbi ... ~e:"A.fjjl ~1t~ c;~~' on ~Jn~ d~!S!th:lCltiOilmi ·b~,tW'ee.n, ,gm~~t'lln't~,~;~ :aJM,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

D~; lPef;OODl ~ 'I :~d~l!!iiltii~,,, :!il'fid '~be; un:w,ty [~f agew,cy;: l4. ~~i~, :~~sp@nfS!~ t~l ,iP,gIJt:

Copy rig hted m ateri al

In ..... odu c-' ct ~ "l'~' IO~ In~~ .

.... ..Ii,!" U, - = -. I ",' ,I I I

i'1fi,,""{,ftI; th"~"'e~:if"e~:"" 40--: ii:"'~iftl;oi'ii[.,e- ""'ir'e~' l"ni-..i:iI!FFiI"'I~j:O"";o'iI.'iii~ofii'fi; ~f:'" U"i!i;f"ilI~' "L'~'i--~, ... ;.it- I"C' nU'e-:p ~i;n

ll. W'u I . - lUi- A::J! ~ .. ..:"_Udlt-.L:l:_iIIi'l:.- 'U~~ . ~.Hll~--:;""[rr\lo'!J.ii~!Ii._~r'U,_-.Ij_"1 u , .A_g.dl~JIIi ·nJlrU..-_:IlI, I' ~1l~1 "1 l"_~_"l

~ese ~8acV8 Ll'ile~ ,Irst is the them"", [i}f~ v,a'hlce~ dtat I ,alss~-ilite w~th

.. - c .. - ... . . - ,- I,.·.. .. ,. . , ., . . . .. , . ... . .i&l, J;' .. .. .. .-. - - . 1. I, - .- .. .. - ... . j •••

K.atl't"',s, :P(1tliiiUta [1J1 Hiu.:m.ai:D.'ty" Kain:t dlii£f-e'lis ,b:10im, :rea'rnists and empiri·, eisas net N1eJie'ly :m t'h,e lilbl;ects, 't;o ·wh!~.ch he ,ass~~ V,dJUle~, I~r' m. 't'b,e w:ay be CiBl)te-Fn~es, dliHeI1em!t :l~mds of 'val~eJ' 'but. in the lS:~O:r:y he ~ens

.. i. ..... ra .. ~. "C Ii"h~ '"C- .'~." ~._ ",~ "~- -Ii.. - .~'!i.' _. - ~ ~ -c- "l~-m ~ L~'!i. - ..,.~~ ~'il.:il A~"" - ~ ~~, --- . ~

a'OOUlt w.' =Y tnere :1!9i suen a 'itlli~ng SiS vQllire m tine; wcr,UIi. ""Comu..1Hg '~~

IF ,"",_ , ' . ,-: ... ',," "Ii'. '!!j,I!" ,]: I"" " .. - ":11..··, '. "~h'''''' ':',"':', .' .. _t. .',' , --.' "." 'i~:3 .. ~, ... .'~ eh ._. '-r' ,.' '.' [ H" "",

A4-IUt,f we ca~,er·_·a_.lie on ~_u,e i(~,~,eets al our r3,t1!!IIl!!a!II, enoices, ... 1 J~

!U'gu:~~ mQilt tl!!.~. (!on~~,t~.on of Qm;s~~,v;~~ as ~"'~~ds~lin,.,"·Q'Yl~h!!~S/,i is a ,Prfisu,.posi'r"i~, 'M ',3!~-i[oo;d ~ho;j,~e. To[ (,;'hQGse som.et'hi'rng i:$ to t'aik:e~ :it WI be 'wartll nlitS'Uimg'''' and 'when 'we [moose. th:i:"liIl~ bocause ,t'he:v' a,le

."".. . _. . Ii". '.' 1'" , . .... ... _ , , .. --a.' ""'.' ... 1 ..

im:Pfl1fta-n.t ;1'0 til:5i' w,e are~ lin [eft«-t taking QUls,e;lv[EM; ,to 'be im:portam.a:.

1'X

Copy rig hted m ateri al

llle8etll,fin on. 't't-.U5· .il'ac::t [oommits[ ·us[ lu[ '~he~ o@fioop.~lGfi of a.UT' human·,,·

·~ftt ,;ij;;:;,;ij; }".~i':ii*,folt!' l"t1 'i'~'iii':~~:i'''''' ~·ji;i!!o[ l'\a' ·~'~M' b~"'Ii[ifii~;i!:i[ "~ 'U' e'"iiir"t· o!';i!j '~~"fllil~ "Ii i;"iit

.111,,.[, ~~~ ~J ~-VlU_..i!lYl!e.'J' ~J iJ!I·, .. _t~}Ul.' JI"lI1_IL(I! ,'.01 tII_~ILlt1l..J .-a:alll_1il !V.I. l~J~:Jl". Qi l~U. ~_.~.U __ 1& v-II

Hru~t,t';I' ·t·he :,mclp,Le ·of treiiiJli"llg aU hL~mIH, beings as ends~:~n·"· ·t·h~.v'e~ ..

Fn ·o~~ W~.)T· dus atco~~n;t f:eS'e:mb~e:SI ei.ITi!p:~ndst the~rl,es[ [G£ 'V.slue ..

The [(),bi~t.s o-f: vahle: ,.e ji~5t the 't~gs. ·~'ha,t aile :~m~~lt3iH!t eo us, ·~·~'lte; ~bi ~~~s' iiilf n;l~trc;Il':~l :~~ru'~. b~:t'e'.fre~t~,,, .But: 't'~,e tC$u;~.ting ·V'aluLes· aIC~ :iilQ.lt:

";e .. '1'.1'1:..,:""' ill.'7,.",jljl· ;iflil[' g.I,.c"',"~.iII!.iI'Ii' .. .;I: '.'"""'! .... j.1.' 'y. L,. ,;j;'~o· "''''" 1!"ln';j.,;e.;;e~'i>;;j[.j[i ·'(j"'I··ji'ilO:> a.p.,~rmg.,~·;[.~c .~ . .::. '.::....~;ijI;m"C"·

~uJlUI.I~ IJ,yG ~_ r' ... ·~Il [WlJ.~'~l:J." D. '. LilHI,· '~!IY! ,I l.uiJ:. '~iJ.I.a!\IJ ¥M~ 'J ........ ' ,Ii]!, -.1. -, I ',fI! 1l~.['U"~ -. ,

.---~.~---- '--.~~---- ~~----~~;. -,,' -----~ - ~~ ~~-- -- ~ ~,". '.'_',

·t·h~ a~t ,of r;a;tiQna]i. ~1LO'ioe. Owr ctfimm·l;tmen't. t:o' the value [fif~ :b!u:man."·

~.ty (iQlls:tr~ms, (ml own. chDi,CeS!~ b,· ~lrnLUillg: 'W_s' tu pimswj;~s, 'whicb, ali:; [d:OOe.ldalbile .flUiD me stmldPJ:w.t Gf othCiM.1 aDd. ecXten,G.rlDg. alar oan'cem~ '~.:. ·~"i-~i '~~"\":':~: c..;:,:cL.~ ,'14 [;;*1f;i:li~[ cheese, Thri~: 'f';"t~:AmiiiS 'C'he ibafSllC .mJtlli-"

",0 !i.ill:e !I:.~llnp Wn~Cu ~!I.~LiIi"-' .. ,,,,, ~!I""'vV'..,,",~ ~~ ~'!;;I\~~~~ ~~~ ~ _~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~

···t, :\ ..... rn~ ·1L"';1....· "d·~ ·~~I!I·~;;i!i'" 'if·h·~¥,iII"""S' ""f·" , .... al . 'Irili~' .~'L:~", ',"iIi~"'" oi"'i'''IiIi!l;J'., '!I:"""lU!"" 'i·1ijli,c!it' "'''IV:·· !l. _l/v.,~JJ~ 1llC.:.I~I_~~I::.·. 1~1~"'_"::~_1Qi~ 1,_:: .-~'&llr\r.l. I ~-.l "'. _~~"""''t~ l!l!lJIa~ '" ~ ~-~~, lLo "~:__.~_~ ~ ~~, ~~ [~~',~

·dl.lIiIl!JL and '~hat them. atR: thii'l1l.S 'wh~,ch W'e :m1J5t~ vi4ue. lu,t~ 't'hese :wqub:emeH,t;s ate net de;d'ved .&om. ·metaph'.yi'icl'I. .facl's. 'Wha'~ bri'ngS[ ~"jo'bje:c-dvl:t:yi'j to ·t·be; .realm of' vable~ is D;(!Jt 'r]~IJt; 'CH~:a.m. ·tb.bIlSS' nave; ;;'Ik' ~~;::':'~~; ~""·~flr.~ ·[k~::·'il~t··: :-'i"Ii.II;'jif;i!ll_"" t·,'4I"'1ii~: ·!!fb[·. ~~!t'[~~ ~ir-;· [ .... ;o'l'li'i.']·t::r:"Ilm"i'~· ,on. 'r~,tj[~na·~. c;[!!re~!li.I.v.... Vw.U1l.'~ I[!!'IioiIL. &JIIU·iii b.oJ, . ~Lilill1l!'Ii. !!OJ _ ;"'\1,'" ;Q_~,..... """""~"""""~""_["'~ ~ ~ ~ _ ~~ ~ ~_~

~hD:i,Qe"

~ie~ '';'':'~~TI-d" ,;j,·~.;;.~m·~'':;'· .rii;niff"r.':>:~!"" 'U:;j[fj.:,;j;"';.:i! ta~lilr"tjI,!jj'i,a'~ HT '1~"'I~"'~A"IIIi!Ci ,.;I·~J+~-I:'ji}n~ ,1I,D~ ~-!U'!WU':I.r~ .. !I.~J:I,.._ 'I"" WUi.l.I • .w ...... IUI:.I_~ 1~_iR __ l~ ~ ~I __ i_I::11I!..!IJM'Q!,. VII] . .; .. _:~dll~~IJ_:_'JV.I~~,~l y-~'~~~_~

01: 't~e~ t~'fi 5!EilRd.po:i:n,ts:; and the heanng of that Q~ ·mOO',alJ. phn~p:~.y~

'fi,.., j,.4~ r:,--: :--,~ - ~;-[4"'.Ii'ii\Oi--.:J:. .~t: .~:~~ ,~jJiiI'''oi'Ii~'':~'~]'''''''''''~j[I· ~". :N,A'i;i'"i;iI!'.i"!I[~~[!" V"'''illri;!iI-' i'Ii'''mii1io:liil!i ,,,'I!.. ,;0)).' a' llill_-l rne 1~;rQ.un:u Irr.l~CA ~1 ,Ll-J]Iit." ,.l:JV\~~"l~lNJ~tfl~, ~UI~~~~ IV.J Lli'f"II;Y'lt,yj1!ili!' a-~~ I~~I~_~~I ~~~~" I_'

.--,- ~1ii['J --,- "C' 1 ~;~ ·1f-:·~lin'i7 '~!flif:'!i[~, ·":W,.·.IIi"ii] :i[!ill'"'Iiln~L~."i'Art]i:i ·From. ~~ihi[m. he [caD oO'nsifi.e1[' ,~iI",l(lniil!iI, ~,I •• "e ,~~IG!o "'. ~ ~ ",,,,,~~;\.lI!.t?' ..... ~,!I.~ ~~ ~ ~ .. ~~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~- ~~

brhnscU: and. reoognize '~l~ie ~1a:W5 [Gf the [~mpl~,.mmlt~ 01 :hi;s :porw·, H:S , ..• ." [~G tll} .. 'We ;ean mmidef' <c)urseJves,w m dle liil.1'i;gJJiII(ie ;of '~hc; Crl':tl'~uesjl' ·15 .noum;ena [ij;I' a;s; .J.it,hl~n;omtnil'l. 'I,bris ,,~ew' :is nGt" .aJS. lSiO m:aJl!.y ma.vle :su!p'~d~, ·am. ·on.tDt~c:al [ill]" me~tap~h',':5'li~.!Bl d~,e~ a¢.cum.,,·

]j"n,p' .0· ·w···'1l...1";r-o'Ii..· '!U1IO\tI; ,,""~'li2:ii!o' '~~m~c·~u~;~.","·;t;;t\I.'1'iii:i'·~v· ~iiil"i; · .. urn ~~"..i!i''''_Ij.· .~'I.tii;_T·lld·"·[ifi' i~ ""''I!'i~l ~. 'I!!_., ·,_,,_:,~:~,~j~~l '!'[!I"~ ~~I~1 ~~" II .lIl,!WI.&~,wuY.:~JI'l" ~~_ .. " "''"!H'!"ul W_II_l~~~"'i&'--£'_~J!j., ·"'""'!UIlln.L -_="I '!IA~_"J!Ir."1

mm,eh~w :mo:r.,e :r.,eal1'llJii:m. the ewer. A·s :~: 1Ufide~l(.a:md it.ji 'i,t goes· Uk'e~ 'th.is\: :m. one senle the W1GE~.d. is, liven W[ UiS)! . .l:t. a~,~a1JS w[ UlS., .. ar~cl. we ae pass.lIe :in 'me .~ate oJ it, 'We mlus't ,t'her-eiale miniik, [t:\1~ 'dl,e; wOI':td u gelleJ',adll'!,g 'the i,~anoes~ as p.V:blJ t·tJ,em. to ·iI!.IS,. 'ne~ wl)l'~~d. :insafar as it ,Itpears t~ 'IIJlS is p.hC'll~m,ena1i the .ur:~d i'r~so:f.ai' ,as· :i.t lefi,eraites ,tlte ,w,pellr'anoe~ is, :Il,OumenaJL, We; [can €lmy ,kn{)w the we;tldJ a_5 "he'" nmmenaili!' ,t'b;a:t ,lSI .lnsofar ,as! .il is gi,v~n, ·t·D sense:r 'buIJt: we [tan ~·lli~:t.i'i Q~ :iJt U nOIIUEi,enal, So 'dl,ere ale fiot '~~'twu' 'wlldds\, i~' but :f3;me:r;' 'Olle 'wcu:ld w:mc·h. m.ust; 'rbe c:oJ1cei~ed. :m. ·t.W'OI d.tfieren,t w,a,1:;" ,And au' '(l1f 'd'iJ9ie pnbt!,ts a,pply' ;a,bgrv1e all t-c[ (f~~i1ves. 'WhJ!fl, 'we; 'view' O'!!u.e~lVre~ M

n'ik"',",nil'fn~l,iil ·W\i!iI· ji".,ti.i~I"'~ e~U'~·Ij.'l;·n!i!li· "II L""i'~t··· ...... 11Ii~,i!ili1;I'.,._ 1-1iiIi ... ']oi'II..l,:i!i"i[D' i'flInA'II!" rl]t1ir."'iIo_~.JIi_"t~"_II:~~ '.~-~:'!i.I" ~]!!ir.~_-;&v., .," - :y."'Ii.li"I' ... _IHI_ -_Ii_~ell [~Lru~I!J. V~~"]I~ill_lL"LI!r.~liQii ~'!r-~~.~~L~ ~_~. ,_~,

appeaTi3im,ces[ such. ,as ·t·ho:ugh.tsl 3ifiid. [cho:i.oes,p. 318· pans of tile :~a!JtU'ul

Copy rig hted m ateri al

xi

'worl~ and dnl,~refo:re ,a5 Ii}~~med. 'by' .i.'t"5J :~8i,ws. BUil~ m~o:f'ar ~~, 'W~ ialW :qdion~l! 'we also Eep'[r~l·~fS.tlves ·a'S Qcti:~~ ki'FlIS~· wl~o ar~ t-h~ iiij~,,", 't'b,{JrSi [0£ O.UJ thllUp,ts ,aJlld 'C:~luJ.i,cGs\;; 'We; do :Ii1Ot. .wg:a;ld our ·ttboughrts. and, [cl1:o:'~~~19, m~t.[~ly ~S' '(bi'l1;p, 't'~~lt .hi~.p!p,~n tl1:i' '~rs~: r3.th~J't. t'b!in'king aiM. [cih~itn;g ~e ,t'ibt~ 'th~lt~ W~ do •. ToQ[ ~;bi5i ~~tl~n~~, 'w'e :~U!~t 'v:i~w' (;l~r" :s~I.Y~s, ·~S, .n~~m)~~, And, f'r:orn d~is, sit3nd.~i~.t~ W~ r~()pi:z~ l;J!W's, '~hat gpv'~m (1!ll'f m~Dt!ai·~. :~Wt~r.s,:m [;l d.n*'~Ii'[~tltt way '~han ,th~ m:a.w:~ ~.:..; :mall~ure d,Qi: :la,W's, 1b:1!' the emrl?:~.oym~n't.!' :w:r ·~'b~ :~[$;~ ~f ·th~ :PQ';W~g;.~: :~ra,w\s '~i-.Utt ::fi~.ow us how' t"ltinklD.!g: and cih.OO:S:~IJ.g .ni;iUilSIt: be ~'Qn)~,

The.re :m.ay 'be pmble.u8 'Yri.~'~, tiids[ ''W\d!.y {if;: :tookim:g at the :h,um.s'1]] :s~1\~ati(llil1l bue i'~. dQes.1i£O'~ [oommil; us eo ,a!.·lbf'li~f 'in.a! ml"st~r.ijoU!s. £(nu~ of: :$~.pe~ns~,o..us elt.[:stc~~~~,. 1;t d~i5~1 '1iruQ"w'ttv~;r~, b;l!,¥~ :~m.POl'~ili~.t i'm,~i."" cat~,Qn~ :kJ;r.· '~h~ wary 'that 'W~ ~f,rnad~. mOI:~'I. pllitlUQs~hy~ Th~ '~i~ 'lask (Jf :mm~ .. pb.i'I,(JsQ:,hi~[ .hl :lan't" :is, t~[ ,gS;W~[ th~ ,.~es'ti(;Ul. l~'W1h~.t rS'hO'~ld I: d!(1;~ ~J Tbi~[ m~k. ~ 00:£ :L1il[ us b,· our pra~lt4~1." ~r~Jti.C1Ul!3il na'iue} w.h'i~h 'bdn,gs 'wbh i~: ~tb. th~ [~!~tcj.t;Y' .W[ ~nd. '~h~ n~(;~ss.i'ty ~f l(ib~~a..g (lUI.' ,;t~lb)n'S.. [CbQi[~ is, [Olllf .,UPit'j ,00Utf ti:~(is~p·ai·b]t'. :f~lt~~l ,iIi~ ~~,t=i{D.l;JJ'[ 'hl,b];gs, T,b:.~ .pB)je.~)t [0£ cr1ti,c;d~ D1_m~l p'hi_~loso,h'", is U)[ de~e~ milD.~ 'wb~lt :~sa~(;i~ ·we. ,~m. :bdl fin. r~aS(l~. :£'()~' ~h!!ifilg the :pmb]e;f!fl w:mdll. :rea:som. :i.'taelf has s-ejt~ :mr us, Sm.oe 'W'e ,alle looling: .Wl' :~~.W1S .l~r t'he. em~lo;y.memt 0.1' [GUl :polw;el:5 oJ [clliO'iloe an,~, .a~t~.omt ·we. d~[ :I.ot~, :in

'I!.. - ~ .•. .•. .-..Ai ..... 1 1 1· ·!L.Ai -..:.II

[tll~j;S :lfiI.vc~tl:g.a'ti{[f:.i" I~.i~. [mU!n~ves, ,3i~ n3'twta.~ C!IIiJ1!iisa[~.y· web!tffillm,eu

bei11igs. - as tii.e [ob~~c:ts[ of .sciiell!tU~jc;; urmdln,st3!iiid)~ng. 'we fepr;d. nUll""; iR{tVles as £re:e:", a'S me: ,aJu,t]rrtm;s, of [O:U!I: ac[ticm!s". Tibi;s ii&1 ·~,O..t: because thc.~'e is any l';e~n to, dletll, ·tm:t:a!it 'W~ are :filalttlLmli' caJ~~aU., deteJ;,fjIti~ledJ behlp", 'b'Ullt l~~'mIUJg~ f-()I" th~ :lin;lJ·0CiP0~ ,;)1 hi3L~.t tha.t [C1~n(;~tit}n [of ~U'I!';'" R1l,,~ :is ,bTfil~VQ~:£:. MQ.ral ph/~'L@~p'1x.y p;roo~eds, from 'w:hat l' cain the stil'n.dL~icAt (Jf nf;ae,t~£a] ·(·'tla·SQll

• ,,' .••• 1 o:-ct.' 1 L , ct'.,' _ ,,_, , ' -' .. I •• ~.,

'Th~~ ~.WQ m~m~ eeme to,g~t'h~'r in t'h~ ~ss~.y from. 'wiijcCb I hav'~ dm'v~d. '~h~ t~tk: .~ tb~ v,'Olhl'l'i.iU,~~ ,;)!Ild in 'whr~(!'h I d~$CI'~j~ th~ a~~O'!!mt 0.1:' ~b!Umalil, r~~31ltiO:lils-h~PS.~, both. :pe;ts(1)l};aJl ood. mm,~dli' ~b,at :~ltO'~, ~m ~ntjl:s :Filirl[()sopm" n'u'thl(g~ [~dlrteR as ends!"'.ffin~the:jjJ]s:e.J)v~ :is, nlJ't a nu.t~te[[ ~d: dll~'v,t~,i 81, m'~ltap:!b,~i~ .£~e't iI'OO!).d~ ,t'h~m. = dl:a·t th~y [UG b:~e rand, :rliitio:~~~ [a-mdl so .lba,Vit 'vra'll,!!l,e --=. and. then .. actin:~: .a~rdi'n,gl,y;. Wlhen. yn\ol respect~ t'lle h.il!~lDim];t,y· of ·ot·be1ls 'J1G,ll ·dol :m,ot leprId, ·~lte1D. ,3;B! !i;'~l';> t:'"'~~t\iil n~ ·j\o-~~fw'::·'I~..:.IIii'ji, =",[,;,0 -n1~l""!iii""':m·.~·;~,:"'~~[.,,", =. ,,,,t. '''·L·~ I':i:jliii2[,,",;iio,,4i.·1i,.nu~~ '~!i,j:~(~1

'U:~~ UIJ.!J~-"' .. [1 1U.1J: IKIII.£--"U .. r~IL~-U-:o"" M~ ,F~lj]u?-.I_~-W"t _ ~ GiIl_"~Ui !III}'] !IUI_ .In! I _IIH.~ 'j ..... ru. ,. u. I .II.~~~_IIJU

them . .as act·ive ibeJn:g8)!, ,a~· the ,auJthO-IlS '0£ the~r ,t·~OW.gi11,t;8 .31m,d ,c:l~O:lees~,

,;i:j;;Ci ·""\ofi"~~""ii'i.'" ',-;~ '"ie~ }iiii:\P" .... ' n.,t..i>!~ 1;i1C,. e~:iff'Ajl~~iiT:if\i, .. ~jk~fiiIIi;e..;>l· ~~;Ci .~,,:;, 'i<ijI; f--i[,e~''''''iii'

!IiI_1iJ!1 ,~_~u.",,_';IJIII:_~DJI~iIlUI. .l.lu rlJ,'LJ.rr--'-'W"J Ul.J~I"'II.a ,dI[J. _iIHd~~_a 1~_III_"1 1 .. _II]:!l.r,I;_II_II_Iil-~-' L~I ~D.J .~_a !lrf1U'l '.::JJIII!!Ir!

them. 3$ .ie~lllw iJnhtiill>iit",SiutS.1l)j: the s!t'.8ndpo:~n.t: [lllf pI.a~ti.e~d. :t1easo:n. :I:t~ 1'8

Copy rig hted m ateri al

1H .I ,atrrn ri-""~I~: alhO'IlII: thl;~" 'Kanlt ,afifiroaches 'm,ol'al 'I"i:hii~"h:v b~ ,~ V~",,'

~ ~ .- -WJI!" ... c .... " ... , .... ', ... " ',t'"'Ir'" ,. . .' ,. ". 1"""' '-'- -',frL ",T ---' -.' " -'"'T

djif~-I\~rnit W,al~' tbarn the 'Irit;;S:i1i E;:~--:-~--;~ :;':-,ts,-'- d tnr"11 C '~~"", ':': 1 'th,

-- -~ -~- ""~l-'" '.. ,,' l, mpU1IiClS . an, " e:J!1 '" ~il~ ,m_~_e

,il11h';}1~ti~ ~l'amti(¥llJ, do" 'ne 'ba~j.c nm'blem- ,set: b~~ the -c;l~:~"",t::-(;' ,C-It')~, ,'ld

-"---"-T--- -~-----~~~- --" ='"-'"1 -~,~",,,\_-,,,,, .y}CP~i&I'" CLm IO::Q ,

s:i,p'-"',,",,'li!' 1:'''' 11':~,,'Ut"b·;,;·,jj. ",,'L.A.""'~'..iIi J' ,l._'tH~' '''r'l-;;:;, .. 'f'i'lfi,..... .. , .. ·L ,:t~ ..... n, --.-,'~.- ,".".- -';i;.'.- -'II

,~~iiI .... :;~, ....;i!!" ..... ,_,,~!,I. i;;I-Ui~~~~, '- ,~,~: ,IJ,.I]!"" '~.t"r-";u~il!.?U: ,~a''''V ra~'iI!e ,p;mC~l!caJi,

,q:uesUo.rn$1 >as ,they al!e ,fa~~d 'by' t}.i,e ~f\I~c,~i'v~; moral ,age-nt ItCfJself., Mc!l'u], rnhiJl~n~,~' is, th~ '~xticmsion and :re£lin~ment 'M 'Qoolina~--:-;-c - ~ ,ti~,

" 1""""" ,<r"-" (I' ,,- -~- - - "" " ----- ,,-- -~- ~ - ,,~,,- =- .. "';$ prac ,

'ca'J, de~iber;atil1nl 'thee ~'f.ch, :kJr p"fa~t1(liJJ~, r~n!il*S<, 1'1ris, ~majkes, Kar~,t;!'fs eDitetpu5e very dif-ftr~D't ,f'm~ tJMt ,cd ,p:~ib,)s@p.h~l'\s 'w,ht) udk: aoow,{ :mnralitJ and the :m(}l';aJ, aI~n't :fm~, ,t'!h~ '~'U'~sid~~, ihni'r:d"'peI';Soo'Q]'UK, as n"b;c-nnmen3i ,tlha,'t 8P.€ in need oJ ~xnhjm!JIltio.n, ,K~lt;~'S, ,aIq:nllm~"Il'tS,---:i-::i

it" . " .. -""" . -" " " "- --- --- - -" - - ---,f"~-~.- -~~~" ~~- .. ".~=- .. ,C:. ,. are

,-·-.·-·,t" ;L.~" ¥'I ,", .,L ... , .. ,,- .... ,. ,.~:.lI,.." .' j' ..l '"''''''I'''

n~. 1~~'O:~!!.1 iIll5;1 '~;J:!i~Y ar~ au:W'~s~u ,w iIllS,

',a;~hu"e ,tQ ,gTas<pl t'ibis, di.fl~r~.c~ 0']' '~~ g~~spl .tits d~p't'b and .si:gnUj,C3ffJ,ce ha'5 'kdt;vU~d 'tfu~: bg~i~b'~Si,pwlng wlQ:ddJ;!'~ rl~p~ij~lllo:f ,Kantt;. Wb.~r~ t:h£, ~:oa!l Is BC}:t 12m ,~xnla/inn ibll,t eo adldr~~~:- '~ilb--' v-"~~ ,-Ib.-(;...:iil'"'"",;,j,-, .~ ~

. ,,-!C!' .. " "" -"" " ,,~ - - ,,¥~- --~ ~ - - - - - - -~,.,,-\!' '!j._~e "e;ry ~,,3!llU!ilI:Ui5 ali:

s'llc'CeSS De dIffCRDIi", :Firs't~:n~rsomal f1fU~Sit~nfilS, 'reo'U!~'fie £i~,st:"-C;-O-,~:l-'I

. " "" "" ~---",r-------~''!:I,-''-''''----'' =".,.- .. ,_1".pcr .. 'IIJa,

,am~w'eu, ,M~Sgll"lrd,e.d ~_Iu'~a)tio:m, oJ sc4enc~ Uil.~s, be~~, ,;l ~~u;_mfilg 5Cf!!iII«i fi;l~ cQl'lIws.l:nll in 't'~e iii'hi]oso"h"~ of' 't~e medem 'world.. O,',"d;jii;il;li

._ .. __ l ..........• .;._, c_ ._,,_ ~ .. I.,_-_,I:"_- II' ",co ,_ .. c_ ._~_-_"~ __ '==r __ ._=~_-!l · .. ·\IJ~~

m3!nU~rit3l,ti~, lfi.f ,t'~'.ds, is mat, :So Tlna-m,y ,p~U,OSI)Iih~l'.s ~;gf'e'J!' &om, an

'Illni~,m'~'-';r::-:j-:-: 'f;.-:-:'-'-141-:-:;-,~:,:"c. (~-c~-~, ,,";~'ji .:ik"ll··~'·-·:":·i·,'Lr:'i·;,c" II ,":')'''":1/'':'' '" "'II ,~:/. : .... ~ ... 1llllfec,[.di,teUvc IOICI1I,u;e.I1ICY ~D ,pose au Polll. oso,p.U~,CI.1I, quecS~I~:5i l~, ~'lS:t~

mO:loo;~'cal te~uns", "H~rji\\' dtJ, ¥ile 11luw '~]]1l't ,mvthm~' has, v.tr~- "11jji;.J1

~- ... -O,.Io .. - - ... _. 1__ . !II • I r. ... . I. • ••••• , - - 1_. .• . .. J _' IT ,_-_-_----..,1J.1 '_- __ -_ _ --~-'-·lr. [~~-U.

'wb:w.cJh th]'iir<~s, '~~'Vle U'~ This, w"ii/ij ,of FMkin'ijI' ~I't ~ .. ,L.'i.c1iJJ1 'r:rwf.ohJ~:m~' C'UI)" ..

__ I~ ._~l .- __ '::LLII.Ci,-' [1 __ " .,11[11 "I,.~- ..... , 'I' .... , r.:_.:_, .~~.~.~I._~ .__:..IUJ, _ __:. __ I~,~~,._,,_~~...:__~ ~:.~

,uc-'.sts, '&61111 the s'ta'R' HIJi't. ,t'~~m' solwtiorn will tum OtU 'tim 00 '~n ,,," b road

~~ _ •. ' •. l • '. -. -_ 1_ 1 I : - _ . I. _ . I.l 1 I _- . I_ 1. .. I_I ,:_ I, ~ .. ~. "_ ,_~ .: 1~, '.'_. ,:__ ~,:__ ~l ~-_ '__:o~~, ._!., ....:.__r._:, ._-_!" ~"':__'jl .1_- ' P-, __ -_~g- .. _~

;sefiSe" ;t~bnQl.;o~~'cal'" ,iil miilttU' Ot fhtdim:IiI" some '"i,~oo ;of." k!ll!·"",w'ru~~I~;IO

.... - - -. jl .•. - - __ ..••. ~;I, .. _.II _ •.. ;] I., •.. c _- .. ~.~ __ - ._ • .If~.- .. -.-- _-~ =-__j~._ .. _.~-u~~

'w'~'~c'if..i 'Wle 'ean them ii/nnlv 11.1'[ 't'ih.;erre' is no n~~dI 'I':iG aCCin'Ii'!ii"Ii;ll!, ",;,L .. ,., '_;'Ii,,,,

'~'"l _-:: I. __ - 1 . '. .. _-',. 1_- - ~ . ._r, l ,r.r.'r~ 'J'lll -.1~ l.· ._.' __:.:' l.__:.. '_. ,_~,~, L _ __:.-__:.-._ ~._!., _~-~~~~~ IU::_llRl~. l~_]"-a[

:~j]/:5 ,~idlanoe (If: :Pf;3iCtii.OO :mU$,t :~,Q~k Uk~: t.h~t" ,[,t 'mary' lie~ iLnsctead :if:],

u, ~ ~ £" 'j,.i!' 'III 1 "",'IL.

t~~e I)t101'1;SU}Jl QIi: :nn;Il,C..jnJies o~: 'jl"i:r~c:dtaJJ, lie,aso,n ...... , PI.ri'rnc4'r:"I,,~ willt: ;m'I',\\f''''

= ~'lfP ,If' .If ti.-~

C!im. Icho~,ce 'in the s'ame w,av '~'hat ,the: 'n!l'iillc4'm]e.s Of 'rnn~~c '~'V~

-- =-_ .. -.==.c ..•.•. " l __ l .--" .... --- .• ". 'l'" --- II - .. l~ , ... ,r'-~"~' ~-_" _~~I_ Q'~'_'_._'=

'mo!a:gb't :rn, i''c;I'ii,era:1 .and, t!b,c: :,lindp~,es, cOf' dIe unde:r.standi~g go:'v~m

m·,·.,l':"c;"",""",:tj··'cl·'--:',j:-~r:-::'Ir,:"-,t~.:-/~ ,-,L::-'II-':~:'-(~'J"':"-: !!i:"'":'Ii'~;~:: ;.(:-"L1 .""·'I'~C":· ,1.~" li > _~e cd.l~a .10.1), UL (]oDiE:' ~1.~,eliS ;auoUt, 118i~Ul1e, otl~~e 5U~ ,iPfUilIi(;!tpl~i l1!ire

im, illiie f.hst: iitlS~anee~ 'ldJ,h"e8s·ed to l1'~- ,the p":·hi~oso1"'ihi.c1J1 f1Iu~s'tio:rn

_-_ ~-=-." ~~ .... ~I".". t .... _I._.·. __ .-- ••••.• --JI! _., .. j •... , ·~.·.-·r _ .. _.~, '~,~_,_-_~._-_c_.=

a'oo-ut, '~~'m ,i:i:!~ 'i"'I'~;F ~;o"i; Rffi;,~,~·;.;;It, h-'ii"IIO!w .. Ii' ~I;ji; 1~,"","£r;,~ fik,""'"i'ifi' "',,;; 'w~"h.~' 'nT'""! have ~I

~_. _ _ ~ ~ _ _~~ =-"- ~~~ ~ !aVo l._IBllM!-~tJI:' _ u~.. ·n·... A];_l1io.l!"·~!r.· 1._llt1lli_...allI1 I~IL~ . J' .~ ~ ,lIl-a'". _ '---'Y

oo:.'O'.nm to ,tih~m. O,i[ r;a'dlef", fMse twim nruesU,l1n8 'k'Co:me on~'. '1m

~ _. - .~_=._~ l _._.~,-=-,.-.l,~ _.- " .. l . ·~_I. "_ •.. _ -" .~ _c. __ " ._._

;:ifn~·~'~m" "'0' t"-,'~,,,,,, 'iI!'''''i"lJnH'd" 'W".',Ol; '!I!i!i"'II] ;'Ii1'.'"C'-,~,.:.I''''''''~.--.':'c:.-: ,--,-.-,-,,,",,,-C"'~'d;" .;.,'L..,-, .:e, ".Iio' '1IlII01i~~n~'-~ _--"--:~ w~ '!l!I!!oI",",l!oIr~_"" """ .~ III_, ,~"i£e"",u.y lila,Vle ans ""ere DiliC nP.h ..

T~.e: :.'iSUjm,dl@lrs:ta: ... ndJ~nl!llS ,or 'K,m't:r.,S, ide'as, "'~,;'Iii')cll b.:a~: - i":.~ - :-'-Ih-ed 00 ~;.

"" ,,- - -- "-,, ---"'"-"0'" ".~ ~.-.- , W,.I " ;ve [csu '" ' . "In,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Ii .......... ,.:1 ··t-·'··'· nil·~mU:l,!llC lo:n

.... l··.,,;-!jIRiit'riIi<'it' .. I'"'!"t·;.,-.-"'"""· o: .. :r. ·~I .. l! •. "" 'ni~f"'"~"iI' 11- ...... "'"',~ b·· .Q;o:I!, ...... , ;o'l' ..... ·'I.I~.i<'·~'1!·.l' :.~"L1. "".""'iIi.'II!'-<!!!' ...... ·.,. DI1t'ljjo· ~,",~~~ .. ~~~~~~.~~~~~I~-L~ :__:_~: .~lFIl~J ¥,-~y.~J~~~ D~·,,·~ [_:.~~~_~ l~,~~~~~ ,I.]. ~AJI!.- ... ~~~,~~!J Q~l'l

mi'S gr~~ra~ .~~nn [I)'J: gi'S~nderstgdJ~ng :is· (lC3'~:rm~l'iIi. m :F1bi~~p:&y., I

b '~. Ita - h ~'l b·'~· b b . d

I :el '~e¥~ ·tl ,t ntullSJI: p ;11 ,00S!):Pi]{;;tI" ViJJ~;W;S' t ;liilt .. ,aVie [1J'~.n~i'· .y' t~I,lrelil,G'

in th~ tl'adit-i[IjJmi. ~t;h~' are I~~uit~~n, :,:~.arj1jjs;i'b]~ ,UF.' (;~. ib~ road~ !S~[ by ,ill u.tt]~ g~D!e'r.'O'~s, :iW~Oliiu~ltm¢t~n~it" 'V:i~ws too,'t havie bee:n. he~d ~nd. d~l)'\e~~' a,ped, 'by :hiilt:eUli~iU: :pcople [Q,ve!f m,omg :penoos· of: ltime .arre unHk:e~~r t:D be iuec.t-ed ·10, ~,o,gi£.al e:mOI,S ,a;~d [elem,emt.ary· mi'stakes~, at ttJI be re .. ,

t:..~i;,,:",~. \I~ ·11~'<Ii·11 r~~,p' ~fl~m:l~_~t;.,i!i'. ·UI: ·~!i!';'i'i.",·i~'Iif t-'iff-a ,t~:i!ii~i"Iiliffii.;lI"'·~ ~·bj-··.~:~i'·Ji'~';fj"""I~.Jj' ·~it..·~ t-

I;U,!II.1!Oi'!ilI li1i '1 ,L~I. ia,l. . .. _ e.iliil,!II.;!!I~ .. !oJ!I.YIo.I.I,.1 . _liI,'!;p "'_.I'_iII,UJiI;.liu iU . C'!IoC"II!.lI'.U'il! ,~n_a ..

_' '-~ _'

i:"iiif'ie .. ' ~",'iil...~,]~ ~C(: 'fi~;if'.:'<'Ii,g·. '1...I~. ·~',if'IIi!.Ii' '''p - ·l'i1i1S[i: ''!ijii?r;ti1..~;'C :"I~I ,q'_ -'Ilr.'O!!<.!:iiift iI'iL'i'i.,.,'I1..:""~:;f·~I· ~ '~nl

"";11'1, .. !iI!'!io!Ui""!'!U!I., iU.I; !lj._iill£!',~ . U"" .iI,!I;1U,"',,",~ ,g _I,u,. 'II. ""'-ili'IID,~_nilioo;ll iQ_![.... ._""",,,!!O-J1U-IU j~ ... 1'_'1, ,I,u

_' l""'i .~ _ __:.. ""_:'J

...I ...•. _ .. ···~~I d-~··' - ? .. ~I 'W'·~'· .L. t_·.,· 0. th .'~~ .-._- - .. ,.--~.~ - ".~ .. D:~· _-. I' ,L, ~]1i\ ,

uee,p ,anY! I .·.~_s,gu_~seu..~,~a,ylli·" ,lin, ;LaCt. it.;ey c"(;eSO~tP'.PoSie "~_ile iI~_mt ,IC,I~~OOl, ,Ii

., , ..... - .~,: ·11,,·I~"'-·. -.- - -·ik~·~·-- IP-h··;]- ~.'. ~-~;L._.~_~- ~-,~ .. ~.- .. ,",.'b .. ~-~~ jk-l_.~~_ ... __ . r--r.~.~~ -.:b.~. w,ay 0.1; ,d)G~U:l(g, ;iI,'t. 'lili111ilg5, •.... :II08(),PJ..-,i!:e1 ,aTe a!'t IUle.l[[ l~t W.ilill,cU, tne

if;;o'Ii'i!i;~ l~:';:'. [i.'Ir,,,," ~niiP'~"I~ :~""'~lii;'~I""pn1I<i:infiii ,ijri: ,<11 ·n.·::t..j~·IIO-:'i::i\On·~I~i"';'];]- nfia:c~"~i .... ifi' ]:~·"':iltf\lj'iil ,;ojl

~"'.l .Iil! 1,"_[]Ij~ .lI_~_liJ.:W-""'!IJ_"_lIiII_~l U"'-'L~L ~~'L'U" _., __ rv.-JI~IJ~ ..tJ.: Mil lrJ]~-III-1 ''-~~'[~_lIr'!Iir.!R_ 1 lIf"V~",,"_IIr'U..H., _IJ_III:'~ IIIo!

llbUisilr~;I,e· .and s,YSil~ml,t.ic, 1'1~w) ·the Cfl~]l~~ism. fif; a:~, o~PfilJlef:.i,'E.~[8 posi."

't-··'\c:---· .~,-. -c-.c· c-,.- .. -·illl- -- .ii;·jk.~, ·iiiilii -- - ii.,~·~rio' .--.-., 'ii; .-t· ~ ·-'·b-c ~·il·C'-~.·~--<L..';'-:-r-·l .C',- ...... ,Ik. ·n·~~--c .~,Qf], .~5 Dtlm-uI,1! Y IIj.lIi1-<:'!f!I'-eilli~esc" .pah 0.1: .31 .P .. I.llllSO.p'nl,'C'a. WUtl.,l'ij. •.. ue.e:.iP

dl's~e_Rle:m.t'5 ,amon.:g; 1.OOd :,h·~L~ph,el'S, sp:ri'm.g; .f-:ilnm. latf\I~-sc'l.111e dif., f,l!fef:.ilteS fit: ,a;';Pl'lJ:.iclll, anl(!1. [QUdlOO\k:;: '~iicse arR· ·wha.t .ale realty 3,'t Sitiil!:te..

'~·il;<; [;Fi;.r[I.n·"";i:iiFflif,~iof>';'-;; It[l.J~ ,f,l;;.!.:I! ;<;-u~·It:;.:.t<:1t .i'[If:>,i'l;1 ",\i;iI';;, 1~"",;i"ot:ifill]t.ijfIi];'iifI;~. ~:t.. ... ["'h, ..... ii ... .:I!

111_]_IL~ ~-~JI::.'w~lr !Ir_III~"::ll ~,I !li!_IHIL.. ~. _ '~!J!!W'''I'''' 1.::III:.I_IR_~~Wi W~,~- it .L~_ -1J-II.ClI 1'~[I[1I.!I ~,Ii~-~II~~

. 'It(~ h"1 . . 'hltb dUm l Kl

a_mOll!g [ilppos~ng. :p"J.lnsap .tuJ, pos~;tu)njSI";~c, matle 1'c.:;(~!C~UI"t ,iIl!l;;~

N,ore ti.'liiiil~Jl~Slicn.g" The :pbUiJ:S:C.p~!i:iJca1 '~rad~.fiO:Il = amuij! bill. :Dl'Y' 'ViIW,. the eOIl.'L'e'Blpo:ruy :phnos~pb'i,cll. ·Si;;lelle =. ,rel~u~~:mJt~ '~5, 'w.i.dl. ;3, tme [ie'm'barras:sme;nt of· :o,ooeEL We ·a,'l:e 01 sbou'rnd] be peq;:~,eXie<ll, ·3't beim,g: tOm.'·'

"· ....... n'."itIi~ 'W-' .-li.,'L. fC'''l''i1 'm, ;:i!Ii'!I;V' 11:!~~,,,,,,'i,",,,,,",'l'\1' [~.~n'ilfll"~I'r!U' ';O!;II'Ii,~ 'nil;lj'"·'I;t!;~'b·l;a, ·!l7..I~W' ,\fo, '0- 11.'"'" I_~~IJ_~,~~-U .- ·~J,u, ~ ,_:_~-~-~,:! ~-~-~~~-~PJ' ~~-_.!I!;-~~-~$' ~~~~J Jf\~'~~-~-~' l~~. ~',~~.' .~. '.:_:'." .:~.

- .. -- -.I .. -.·;j!o -- . 'L - .. --, .-. ,;j; - ..ll- - _ - ,. . ,iii-. -. ,. 'Ii,.. . . .. , .. - .. ; -h - .. • - -. -. - ,",,'L .. '. ,.,'Ii,.. -. '"'"'" ._.-

"r,);'CXlilj.~y ·Ue,gD1I5, !!liD u~§I.pa'l!le W.Il~.eIil. W'C iit .... me 1100 see wl!li;. !Iollili£ .!PlIi.v.,o""

n- ~n.\fo! [..,..~1fI'::,:ff···~r~n'iIi' 'iIji;""'n!I'ol!; ,l'il"";" 'r;Oli'i,~'i'lI!I;iIl!" 'O"II~·~ :t'h-·_~I'\,,·:d(""'I!\~ ,o:iI'~itr~~'r;'ni. ~iI'r;.'_';'"," =~Ii~)'_~ ~~: ~U~~-~,~-_~,~, ~.~t"~r·,,",,·~ ~~,~ -'~'~~~-~Ol ~~,~t~, l'~~_ ~~L~-~Ii.·~ '~IIH.~IL".~, .,~~=. ~~~~_~t~'

Wm.:aJt ,d)if~erle:liu 'qj!liles,tin&s" Wi! wU1 [lml~y' knmw ·w'ha·£ t:U d1i'lmJki kO'W"~'

= -

e;V,!!j"~ wl~ln 'W~· 'ca .. flind. enee alpin. ·~·he: [oommon hi~mlm :pJligb~, [CitE

WO'J'ry' 'tlft.a,t D1ot:iya,'~IS me'ln t'Ol as:k th~ djJfeir.'eil.~~ ,q'~estJicns,. ''llu~ corre-lCot ·".iiew is net ,~~.I '~o be t;'he 'one, l~ft di~tmd.hl!g w'heB. the OOon~ra." diictloDlSl ,and. a'bs1l!r.:d)i.'t~,(!iSl of :al'~ d~e, o.~·h:e.!.l';s h:a.'\)!\~ .n'lmiiliUV ·~n 'e'x~~,,,

~--- - ~.- - ~.- --_"~ _ ~~ ~ _ ~~"_ ~ _ ~" __ - _- __ "_"_ ~"_-_ _ - _"~ ~-~ ~ _-_"~~ - - _"~-_"~-~¥ _ - --_"~ ~="--r _ - - _-

I·.' 'l'.;a; ;t1!'f'Iom~'·. liI:Ii' • ..... 1 be .'h·· t. ~ ci1"!ift.;a, .... IIf-.. ,~~, .~·n·liI!;~~1l'.i!Ii~O:!: 'L~"'l~' ~~I ~,.'L~ 'L. ··fIIliii '--. - ··'''''·n· "l" .... 'I;'!Io .. '!""'".m· - ·-.iI!l '_'l l_-~I .~~~-~'~~ l,~ --=-,~ l,-:-~, __ ~ ~~~ !I!;~~t'l ~~~ __ )~ Hi ~_~l~ ~l~l ,~ 1,~U~ ,~}~,~,~~_~ ~-~~_~~-~_ :__"~ ~

W~ .: i),. .. !l" ;t;:'L,., ·n'iI'Aiii.l"~i.:o!iI"':' ,t.·.L .. .;0. !i!;,i·U- .-~~. [tjIi~ 'iI1I;'L,.f~lil'ilo~'OI'ri.TIi·2i,.. V' ·~.n.-· ,[j;,' ....... ~ :e'.iI!)Ii;,+' n~ •. ';o!;""'itIi

,IHI j~I-~, ,LulI._'Y'!I!-~ '¥'gl~~ !\oIHI~ ~i',,: ~11' ~J' ,~1.lIJ~.~j~1If'~:~' ~ ,1111" _ '"~:~~ ,Q~~'~l ltr,~~~-~.,

~' ~'FHr~l.:.1, t,!l"l·I'"'.e~ '~~. ·ii·~·i;:'f"'I"" ·t,o·~,;'];tf· ~"1r!~,Ci' t" .... i;\'Iiilj"e:-Ii'lif,~i~~ ,;j';wi: 'IiiL,p. if!;'iI'ib-:f~~;j; '~if!1 ]t:~ll-.'ir~Iif!i'"

ill ~ U"".:IJUl [1 __ t\;-, l"~ .. _i) __ ~_~J.a, .. _~~J_"'1"1 !Ir_l~i_~:a '!tr.~iII_"r'w., ';r'~-~r'U."-~l v-.L 1 .. _lI~b..,. :iJ!'Wl Wllilfllli!lil ,II~ _~_ 'l1li_"

·-·_···_···_···d·'1 ~ -~ "". ,,;.~.~.~~" .~"~~~ 'L,~ .. ·L .. ~ ·~·~~'·d-I ,--. ~l·. - - ,.-~-- "'1"b - ,.-~~.

t~ate\r I~'en ]!iI; Jimpel~llectl,yj [!I!)i' i[lu,e seCQliilL [set I~I; 1e:J.~,yS\;, Ji.,MieSe ~"s·

rare loomnaJ[~ti'Yle -. ,I~d theiT :ItPTfl'eraii ,a.'~m 1,' tu, s·btvw- dTaia!It: die· mQfe

. __ .• ,.~t __ ~. __ l. 1._ll'.J __ I., • __ • _ ~~.~III .. __ 1 I lI' . ," __ I. ~ , •• • l __ ."l, •

... Ii.c:\!' , ~ '". d·-l"· .. ~ ... ~, ... , ~ ... ..._---c-~~ ~~ 1'1' .. ~ -J ... ~~* ~~-~ ~~..JI .. ~~~ ~ ~:i! .-.t._~ ~~ ~ ~.- ~ ~~-~

~~~:U~UiS, [.:IS!pa_n~rcs· 5't wee ZiI, ...... ilH.t:S 'v,~ew aJ~.u ~s..ume nlU tue. JEiDf;e ~cW",

iiIIi...lr:".··1 'j'iltb~.f~'·I_;f!i;lfoifiii'il 'l..;~,.., ... ]~ ''!iI_]~·j>_iifi!~.'"Ii,t.,- \!',"'_if, if" .... ~ ·~ ... I liIlli'!i!:li'i'ii. ·~I''!i!rT!i·;a.~. '~i" '~~~I!i!', .;'i;~ Id' ~~31'ii;i!ii~' '!Ii!~;111~1J1 lro' - JI_ljv~vl~lj::t_~~g_l !9_ 1~111::YI _11 ~ ~"~ '!Ir.!9JIUl ~ ~i~l~W-I9-I~I::"~~ ,t_I~ll ~e:~II~I::I~ ~.Il; . _i'\r.~~~f_.

dif'fge~ces :in ~1i\~l';oa~-.b aInd ~n;Jdoo·k- Of ();n::~u:e 'f also '~·~il1lk ·t;b:at unce

.. 1. ,"l 'J'. __ I. ,-. -.,' __ , • -'-rrt, . - _ I. ," _ 1 • J". _) • ,'. _'. _ I ,". ~- _'I' '. ~'. 1 •• , ••.•• __ 1 ,'., [ 1 • __ I., ., •• I., • ~ , '. "l __ •• '.,

... 'L.lli1i!~;iIiI ~liii'~'.iI!'\i:!it'iil"iM~: <lili!'~ ..... ;r,r- ... :i·l~'D '~·~jn~ii!i.'_t;.,~.,.,..J 'ft"'!iii'fi(t;- i'a: ,,,,,," ~Wl!; '::;'-·iY<m:~. l"Iitl!; lUJ1~~~!!r" U_'::L1I}~"';~._"JI"~~!Qi 18_1!,~ !!iiIUI~,'!Ir-'!ii-I,,:: ':I ~1::lrUWl~I~~-f l~_"jILl.l. ~ l~·lje ·w·w Igi '!ir-tII~I:: .. ~ .. ~~e ~g'

me :mmie loompe11i;ag;,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

The. firrS't t'h"ree [e~S!ary$ at\e: Hn.ked bry ti1, CBntoem. 'wi'~fi, iSSi'ues m. 'v;aliille tb~((}'~, I [~~miP;JIre :KanJt. ·wi:tIb. phn~p:~e:~, 'W~lO:~, 8iJt :Ie~~t~ 08$ l;al" aJ~, 'v,d1u~ tlf~~o:[.J· .~s ~()F),~~Tn~d~ .iOO.\pt~Sen:t '~e .'ra!tiO'na~~ist. It r,adi:ti,(ln.:· .M$tot:te, G. :1;" M,oQJie, rand, 1hfim~5· :Nagel. '[~,ere lane. i'n :~.aot im,po:n";~1'11't ;si'mUwri;tlle:S bet~ee:FI, KI'Il.t;i'S :licooU·n.t: uf yalue and. '~ne ,a'C~o.~ni~S· glVle;m.

·1t1V' .;jf.·jl",.""b. ,j,'I!;o'T-Ji,p, ·n·IJr.]'·~oj1;c;nm4.;a~ '~'i'iiiii' ·i;·Iik"":r~· .~.c;: i"Ii;~;i!i\Ji"i;1 b~ ,~i"Iiil'.L ;I'i:"~I~'" :"'i;ifi "~j::ii::i""n·" w I' l!I._lI]il~!='JW !I;._l[I~ll~ ,~~I~JI_, ~1~!Il!ULrt[I~~~J O~~, !!P_~"""-!II1~ .!II_Qi [~-~_:~.Ji' ~ ~-@"~~.l ~~~~j. ~~ !!P.-~:~~-~

·~tam dtff:e[fl'I,(;~~, n;e 'w'lIr'k: of Ie'aen [~SiSla,' iSi ee brio'S o.~,t~ 'die simrilari't:y ,~rtui '~hm ·to :5'tt.,a·w' w:bere the dift~l)e:n~e lie~i am.d. w:b,,· irr~ maJue:r.s", Atili~·ode's .id~1 of a, 1'000, tnarc. is #flna'~, 'wit'hcou:t [quaWiiea:ti,Q.ll,r fl ,Moore~'s, id~a, of an f-"iD.t~dnsj,c·~\f ,B:OO~ .amd :Na:I;e~.J·s, .idea of an '~'{ .• mJtl~ :Il~u:t.[alu '~!"al:!le ,are aU d~s]gn~d ·to do 'w"(!rJ'.k. 'w'hich i'n. K~n!t;"'5, tnwry is Id'~rTie'" .~.~,~. ,''!il ·i':'\'!iII"·h·.·iil!iI:' [d'-·ilrl: .. "",~.HI~· 'W'''',~,J: b·.·.}1":' t:·.'h~ i,...:I~/~I. 'lI"h'~i't: .inu·' :l;'I'"Iii!lim'I~'Fy" is the

. ~-.::It Ill] ~ ,~}!Rl'_ _ ~IJ . __ ILI~t!ll:~11KI::~I,," __ !AI! . .' . _ ~\r.; ~u.~Q ~, __ i5;!I!l' ~ . _~lIJrQ ~". =~ _ :lIP.

:. -e- '.'

'\i1~,- .~~.~ ~."j '.;1;.1: ~ ~."",,j .~ .. ~ ~~.:.I[~t~··~··~·~· rj .... :i!' ,'li;1~'~1 "'i\~l~'~iill~ WiIl.;iIi!n j!1~. ~"'.~~ ~.iIj;T'; f!IiF '~n .·h;Q;

~ Ull£QIiI.uJ,.:;I}GnC'IiJ~ OQnU!~, JUJiI, "",,:Ii, "'_ c~. v(t'!!!!!e,., '·~·~"~""v,,,~ 1~2..:_;~ :oil":MiII~JL'1 .~, . 1 ~.'!;,;i

'm~~o~ ~~~ .. ~~~ ,"h ~ ~I- -- ~-t ,~, b-~[""'l..,~~, ':'~' .. ' f ", 1 W"'" '~h liii ···:k , :.lilOUUm. 0;. Ii'.es.e 'Oiltloe:p'Si Hi u m'U~I, '. l.IilJOO' . '!leIlS" .. ~ .. e, INn l·~. as~.,

~il;,.~ ... Jt.. .e-,1;:Oii";ii""'iI!ic~I;::,. ~;i:!O!i!'I'" ,"Ii·fr. t<ltlill) tob, .0: .it i·iIi'r" 'f;.·lf·~ ",;i'oili[!'il!i I~ i"'.LJ~ ~i!::i[!,;i'oi''Il!I' Oliii It rls-

~ I]JIU""-~]l !il'i!lPl!~f1iIP.~'!Iii UIi] IU"-!iJ!'!lu R'Ir! . _J_~~ ~f~ •• ~ _ l~" l~'~ "_,_:_~,,.... ~g~~j ~L IU--=--li~J L~"_"~J' _ -.co-!"!] ~ ~~-~

tc:tl~~ ·~~~-:'IlI,~r~~' I s·I1~~r.··~d. sa.~~ 'OOIt ~a-;' US·~. '0.1' '~he~c :I. 0';1;00 ·dle: ~thi,eal

0' _ le,p. ,per, ~ ap5i ., . _ . J~JU. . .. _'1 r ir ~~. ~L.. ~. ..'~.. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~.~ ~ ~ ~ ~.~ ~ ~~

.<1.~.~(.~~~-cc.,'C,~: .f;..-; ..... l~ i"Ii'i!~,'-'ii"" ,d··~·i,;(':I:~~~!i1i'i"\iI; ',·.n t· "h' '.i'j; ' __ ;il!i'''',~n·Ii..!Wil!;~iii''''!iI]· 'JjP.~iIIi~\itl·dl!' 'n .... ;r!;;I!;rL.:1,1I'!! [1I.I_l_~];el-enc-e ~o. ~. l iR-_I,~;e'~J ."_ ::~_~~IJCI;Ll!ir.il::I!~-~' [_~::Il . ~~ ~~~rD", ,~-~~p-~ ." ~~,.~.~~ r-~~~-~~""~

:~n dlt~; m~~ien:t ,and :mooem w~J'~I.dSl"

..........,.~ ~:"'io~o'" ",.1.,.."_.;:1; ""~~ .. a· voc '-I~'iIl~ h ·~f~"'''i. ,,,,, .... ;oo;rll!ll'l; ... "'1'!Ii!Io ,;i'j'Ii~ ,.;L.··I,e·m. '.iI'!' 'b···l~'.' ~,., ~~ .. ~ 'l.~'.~·.le ,Ln~ ~_~~~ UlI~,~-~ ~-~-I;;I~ '/1iJ1 ~!~!y!j _,~l~¥·~ ~I ~·'4!',.H.,.u~~.V: ...... , ~m _I. - ~I - 'UJlll ,~,ll ,~~ dJ l .1IJ!l.I.- J,

:mCile dif.ne.u~:t tl~ .lrti,OJu'II;:il;e;" 'tbe~e essa'.ys eoo!tcI,SSft :K.ari:t's 'v,~,ew:s ·w,i.t"h. ·t'hose of pbil~pher$ ·who.".· api'mil, :$;1) fUrf." as t'be iss~,es, und,er d,isc;msi'" :si,on [ale eoneerned ....... re'J)esem,t~ ,em:pi:ri.tci.sJt: cStrains i:rrn.. mO:f;al pb]l~,., :pby': D,inridl :Humt and, Bernard. WlUiamsw Henry sidlgwi;oC:.k; ,3.'md :Derek Pa'f,Dt. These :,hUoso.phel'S! ·a'r\Pt.~· ~n V.BirlIO:\i'S 'w.3iYS", d;l1ar~: the ~"On'b~n,t: of 'the. pd.nc~p·les of :p'J':atn¢!al reaSOil :~$ :ritl.a,ed, and. ·ofin;tr-oUed b, f.ac~s. a,bD'lW,t~ ~b~ 'world. Biu:me: and 'WiJUia:m$ ,sr,gue tJta:t dl~: possj.hle iCCU'1'~~Iil)t: of ra,tional :p:r.i'mci,p'l~s :~s. :U'm'~.td. by owr :[M,Q,tciv,a:tio:m~l [capac;i.'U,es" Si,dgw:~ck a'~pes, that r,s:tinm:a'l p~in,ci:p:tes :m:ust em:ploJ' OQti;,eepts w:hic'~, 'Can be I."lie-il, '~@i D3itJul'.al cJbjeots wl:t'hoult: v,aguem,ess, ·0(" ,3i'mbi-· gui't~, ,and tDaJt~ only ihe. ,",iDdrp~,e: [of u!t'Hil;1 m,eets, ~his, ,cri:betlO.n. ,And :Parfi'~:5' .ia'moDs, ilu;acks ,on, ·some. f'l'Qlinbtt' di¢'ta;~e" fijf :,;r-:a(;ti,ca:D, reason de,,end .nDt: al'lly Oli. his UDii.'liSUiii'l 'views, a:oowlt~ tbe: :RlCt.a(p!h,s;iICS oi personal. identity, 'b.u;t .. al~ on. b~s ;as )UilJ'},:p1tiom. tb:a:t ,the COltt;e'Iiit. 'Q~ 1;3:U,(H].a·~. p\l:~I'i!C~.iPJJe~$ depen,ds. om, :such. m,et3p,~.y;si,cal :tac~'S,. I 3iqlUe 'dla:t ,these :p:hu'oso.,hem miscD:Gloei"'fe 't·t:Je [-elation, ·betwe.eFii, 'pmcdt'cid :rea"'"

-.~ ~~d"h~ ~.~~ ~'Ml 'p_~~~~L ~.~ ~~ ~ ~~ L ~ ~~h-d b~r. 'h~ r-'~~'-'1d bo~

~n. an , 't',if: 'W~'l;', ."; ".~.aCtlic:a: '. ire:a_SQfiI, liS! not ~81. 'iil:pe.~ ':, t~'e W(lf:c ;:~. c.!.!!iII

-:: .... ,fr·~.-.,-:: :~;Ij;-'~0;1i;lEl {,t-. 'I;:.J"ii.!i' ",,'L;ifi[W'I'-:-:-: 'Ii'iJ~ '~"",W' 'w""· ·m.·i~liti;C:tc i~·lti"lij~, ;.'1Ii' . It [il'I-''li;1'liii!i!!,t' fg,~lilll!loo\l' ~Iilap"""" 1'''.1 ~ 1 DliU .. ,liI'Ig ~!i.1' ,~_!I""", ~ ~ . _ ~ ~. "'!!"l~. ,"",JJ!~.I""" ;I."", ;Il~~~"" ..

M:'~me' ,~l1d. 'W:illi~ms :1: ,aJtJU,e; ~hat ",(be :,rind.pJes, of p.racdcaJ. :!t:~iliS.~J' if there ~re :s.:~.u::·:h 'I'riir.func:~p,]e~~ ·~i"v~ us' mativ:es,,, .a,n\~i'nls)t 8·id~i'Ck 11~1~

~ .,.~ •• ,~.I":l ••• ,.~ •. = ~'_,~ .. ~~~ .. ~l' ~ ... ~ ~.~_ ~.~." ~._ .... a,~ ........... ~II!"lIl!"l~~· .... ~ ~ .~.~~~-

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'1:-''1~~'1Ii''i"'',t .. '.1' "'}'I:"II.: , .l!l~,U,"""~,UI"" .. U.L.L

:xv

Pbiil~s::"hv"'s] ,I [OOo.fi!W!lJ';il't~;"Ve [tnte.n)r.ise-, 'H~rw' OO'!Jhl, '~,t be oth~rwls.~:~·

, O.O,p '" I.. , . ",r-- ,I,.. .,. ".'it' "" ... _ ",I.... __ ._1_~. -- .. - .. ~. --~ .. --

'h{~ ~- .:: - --: hi; eal ,---;tn'iil'','':- I :-,~,-t91 ,ca'-jl, sueeeed 'M]'\!" i~ 'd'ilejcf' aJl'I!ldJ~~n~ can :iIr.'tliCii),DI..

,.[1080,p.I,., .. ala_melll, .. H, -""""-"=l'=~~----~~ --'~----iI;iIi

[--";i--.>:-. ·Jf':-::-ID:-.l'---:::-,-,_ tJt':-"'r ,~"I~~~lii'. the hnman [~'-'fi'!'"1Ii''f~Ai'fi" in the 'W"'t'!lJ!' ~,'Im!"Iilt mze 'U~e_mlil!e yes\!' ,IHlteU PW.L,6IoIIIJ"-1 . H'!r ,lil;~ .. ~,u 1i;,;<I!.!'~,~_.!i.!Ji~,,", __ VJIL'-;!1 ~ '1,J..Ji'!o< .. ~,r ~~_

these ,-j~l'Ii1T:i]-,-,;-~t-s ,-j7:- 'rc:-.se--;;-too· '¥e~t 'e'Ve.~' 'iI;"iie~~sQoI1;!':S! "[ffnd, has a, set of

. OSie iiIi ... "'-... .... WL iil!re ,iP-re fiL ,,", " , .. - . \I" ~__~ .. =_~_ __ _ __

Ila:tllr:al" alm,Cjstt prll.m.ithre biases: ,1t00w~rdJs th~ big, :,ictilU"~ '~r m~ :in~,d,caee detiiliU~, tl@WaI.mS, :91~mUari)t,., and ;S'y~{g~~ ,~I' ms.tiru;:,tia~, and dUf-er~ enlce-\!, ~OW,aLros, m,e c;u::tmOi ;CO[ilS~~Jti'Qn ,l"i it~n,i.t'Q,ry' ,;;'d~-a:dJy :rm~iPptd aut and W'ODJI o:r. '~'h~ ,radli~.al dha11e.ng,e to received w,o,ys, ,~f' com,cel.vh-a:,g; mtm,@l,5,. Th,es~: 'b:~ases, aJle :nOit: 'had, :~n 'the:m'se:~,V\es, 'W~: le-£iii: uneODe:ct~~, me:!f tbr~a,t~n, t~, 'twm, 'OUI :i.n.di,vidual \iY@]Oe :~.n,~o a :melieID" id]l~yn;~

. '.'" . - 'Th", - .'. - - -.'. -.- ' .. '-h'-';'l' - - - -lh---- -t_ .'. - '-I-e ------ -- -". --1-

,~ .. 1-1"1- [', . ,._. - -'.~' ","': .. '. I,' •• ". -,;" .. - -' • r ,-' -I -"1 . I: '-1 - 1-' -11"..', 'II>' '(:' . I" '-.'.,1' -_ r- ,.'';',.- ~IIL': .

~rau,~ ~n~., ,'-, '- ~e w,ay C~ ,g,er om, ,[0 pl. ,~, J~,p , Y ,W!5, to ,eot your na,{'(WTcl,

men't!d. ,pr-ocl:iJ,vi:U,es dlo their u~"mOSt and then, (leaH. :i11 ycruril' ~:es:C:!TIte.rs 3!nd ,h:imdl~ ,~nd, s,t~dem,tiS ,and ,c:d:t~,(}S, 'tlO' oO'ttec~~ the :meg~i.'U,v,e ,efla,'ti5 ,@j~ 'y~ii.U:' 'b' I~:"';I"'''''''': 'I' ~-~o:I; f--:. ~"'I'I lu ... 'kv' ~'nl 'i"lf"'"'~ ·t"",'a.,,;;'~'i"'"'''' :"""~ f'orI;to;n,JiC'] ';;'r"l'"-fi ,Pti-u' ,fio:>.'f:>'ii:'"" ,oiiI'"3"d']

_ !I!~~.~. _' ,~~." .... II!l'!;ii ..... .L~, '_ '!ilI'!I,,'. '-'l'~ ,IIHL.L" i .... ,,....!li1. .... .L~ <lIIJloL'IiJ, ,llluli", .. 'JloL'U.'<lI o~u,lIi.iI, .:JIll. jU,_.~JI,~.::I! ..... ~ ..

erieles and 'it is 'o.o.t, '~ssi'b]e het.1e to 'memiiii(itJi ,tbe. 'm~r-J'iJ.' neO:'file w'ho

'. 11,,,,_,_)1, _.' ... "" .. ~,," "'",t.-'~ .','.' ,,'. '" , .... ,',,] ,1j.1, .. ",.,,,,,,". "'11 ~ "'Jr'" ',',.'".'.

have :h-el:ped, :m.C 'tJ~ 'wn,be the eSSi8r.)trS! th3it :foUow. :But w,e 'oWe a, .S;I).1'et:ia'n Idnd ~f' ,debt ~o' the 'DP'on:~e 'w,lth 'Wb~1E, we~ j\e~fly d.iscllss, «~[ ph~L~

lr--' lr ,_. '_ ~

SOc ht eaI"':;~ec':,s" and, 'to- ttose 'w'O:l'k"'fJI;~ en the same n-~bt~~:s- who ~~,v,~

... ,p.ll . "in" w:.,.. I , --., "l~_, __ ~ r~----~-~ ,,~_,~~,_

'W ~jl'ftdmc~ 'Wh~A, th~y' .qm~ and s,~r ill'S t~, :tu;~th~~' '~l~~rt~ 'w'h~n th~" ,uonilt 'I 'ba'\)!\~ '~: u ~;n~fJjt~d in ,th~s~'''W\aV,s il\~ d-ruf: 'Work and 'OOflVer,S,a-

~~._C_'7 " __ -_-_ ~-~"_ ~,_.~~ .. _ .. ~. _-.~_~. ._)~I~-~ '.~ _' _ .. ~ .. ~. "_" ._ 1$ ~ .. _ .!III' •. _ ... , _ ..... _ _ J. - .. J _ I. -, I

tiOfll, ,m Cl~.adot.t~ B~Qw~ Cb~irtes Crit,lJtn;den.. 'T~.m, IGould1, :Ba'r.llai~,iil

H· " '"T'i" "" H' i'·'~111 'n ." H-""- '1' ". C""'" 'li',:; -, ;ii; ... ,~-" " 'iU'e":ttl ~t.. n", ~"" " _3:~;Emn~f ~'DIQ -,,-J.~"Ii!' ,!ri~tel c,'.Y'.to:~~, ..;:iI~O'tt~ ,rum~, nlbillllf.' ,n.UiUl·~A" v,rnof."al

'Q"",n;.T ·~'~Ilil A.,_,.lI!...1' n", .. ,'l;.. 1i'· .. , ;I[!,,,,",'l;.'~," ,Ore .-,'"'", ("(",..ll .-p-"-'-'In"", >E'.",",t.,,"~ ~,"e:c, 'ij,.lii~:c . . :___' "'''!II!elJj!.·~ ,nJ.lJ,uy A~,O~,,· J.ay O'\ill!I,eusene:r;, I!IInl,\.iIi 1,,a;mHf ~!j,i[fap(lro,''I'I!,iIilO

h-~l:ped, ~,~ t1Q ,prepalR, 'tms, Q6~tect~~n. :1 w'Oi\l~~d also Hkie '~@1 takle 't~l:s!

, ...... ',_' " ,". ',",.', ,_ ',' '_' j I ' . ,",f.' '~";",' ,.' , r- ' '(-"J." " ..:I., , "'" .' .",'1;." , , .e,C 1 e'~lln ' ("j ,,41 '-, ~ ".-',:-,'"',, er.,~'

Q~gF!l, t'O ~XPI~SS m,~ U.ee,[p lI'atn~U!e, l!(itr1-ue relU,iIJ~I .~mu gene1'Orus

'f.: ,.,_'1, " 'I ' . " .' .,' .. _.lI l ," .' ';h 1 ~,'.. M'" ~,_J .. , ~ .. " , . j" - .' ;iii ~,.:I .£!I, ." ~'il". C'I ,,-, .",,, -I: '1Id;'1 ,n~,p ,c_, :r;~~,Vl~ ,~fQ:~ tc~J1l: ,~~e '_, ,!:U~,ey ,11uom,p,5'OD • ..n.ll'U, nl]ii3i11i,,. .. WO';lIJl! ..

U.k~ t~ th~nk, :~y t~~he~~ Job J..a,W:~~l",

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Abbreviatio __ ···n-·'·s·-· LO"'-'['I '11'1 r: '._' __ ', t's W"'" '-0" "--[':k~'o, __ ,~ t~:rre,Vla ~1'~1 -. i.:" ,Ii~_ ._, :~ AW.lIl,II-_- [0>:" I.~ ~11,c:O

lte~@mn,oe-s 'to ,rand, C_~tado:ns (If 'Kan~:s, 'wQ:d{~ ~ gir~~ ~w,e;ttlca!L'ly ~.~ dl~ U:~ft '~smg tle [;iIi'bbfi$'viiJj:tt.rns 'ooLo~1 ,aned mr .mM't wmb[ [~lit:j;ni tit ~ n:um~be_ris 0:( ,tbJ:! uJ,evmlt: 'v,glUm~ gf K'~:~~ ,~~ml1l~'l:J~ S'collififten [~,ubH~b~d rD[-:' 'm~ PE--'~.si~:c'l;'"iG.h~ Akad[e'm~& ,d'e!l 'W1i5lS'el1UihtQiifIIi'!i[- 'Bm\U~;;1 whim Iin'f'lii!"~Ii' ilm,

,Y, ,e" :e:U"l.'S_ ... ,', _. - I, ~.,,' ~ " - ... ~ _1'1"" -,' .. J, --" -,Fr--~-

tIle mairglns o:l~ m:ost 'un~ti~. ne: 'ViQ~,~'me: :OJ~h~ ~ :I$teil, at; tIb:~ ~d ~ 'i2h~~-m~~, belUw' The ,Q]~!t-.t''''U6i'~ P~f~' RS'a-5all: 'MW~,Ye:f', '~S d~~d, i~ ,~t!!ii __ ' ,_~ eliIL,~:es ~"~. ' __ , ,n ';Ii UJ', ... "~,, j' ,,', .. , ,-,

;o'Ii[~ :;!Ij,''''O!Io1i~~, '~\i'IIil.!' "" .. i""~;a; 'l'U'IJilU~: 'II;Um;L,,",~, [DI~ 'htmttln me :H:I1iI:'i!: 'A'i and ,~d, If[B~[

w. 'P.lI!'U, il'!Io'IIIi.IillUlliliU "-,it L'I-, iIlfl,~ ~ = __ ~~,!;'! _ ~ __ ,~ ,~~ _~ __ I~_ ~ __ , _ ~ ,.. ~_ ~

~t~S!, De ,l.oot~m~ [~' i;~'/J~ :n,~ ~~.t~, ~mi~y '~y iIi'bc :pa,g:c ~J;lm'be:f.' of du; t~J.Q:9i.~tit)Il,,, 'T.h~ ~~ran$ibrtiol :rm:m, 'w'biclr.: I hilV'C quowd ,~:'_~e li;s;,t-ed ~elofw.

;t''''-II!:iI.~'U.U

"iu_~nliI:iJ,

G

ID

Copy rig hted m ateri al

x.viU.

A ~

,. . , ',='" '_ I" •• ,.

..8 B.B. 1\ i' ,I .. A.T ,I. 0 N s

:D'~ ,E, W~lnl'd. ~~ .Kani~·; S~JlWteiJ.17~·Cd:tl'cal Wdt:t11g~ ,midi (i,aue.' d- ' .. ' ""·f~ & 'k 'M",l, ~"" M '·h . tl 'U"'-" -.":~-.,~ '.'&f'O~).~C':e M; " I i",', .C .'" , •. liilnc; '. ,e--5('.~:r., ,",an,t~.· .es, ~I:' -·.r:ii~vcr~ilt.~., :iClH9Ji!,

,and :New'l'O<J:lk;: :B~, ,&, :[NIQ~Rel j ~:6·8,!, ~D~

.i,tht~ :10.1' ,3. Uim:~,¢:riSal, HiCS1Gty :mo:m. :I e-:os:m.o.po]~bn. :~.t of 'Yt~w'~" [~11S4~'I' 'tt~81, ~wi~ Wb,~oo leek. :~g K'~:t C)_~: :Ri~,tOl.v;. 'c~J~ed, ,;:)00v~" I[VlDI

r., .... :~~~ .. "OIi.,· "",,,,,:I!!\'''''1,.:.'P~ ~ '1'.,."." 1'.=,'I','JI.,iD .... J"'~ iD;."]i~ ~"''''Ii''''" '~''I;;-, .... ~~ .... c·j.°il'lI'P! ' .... etes [ .... f·

1L!!;;I"~~.I~ M.I_l:_"lJ ~!I-_{/~IIJIIrQi ~ III II' f ~ II_j ~J ~~.~ • _ 'lll~ 'ALII.:.!. ~~ .. ;V.'--IId_I~.1 IUHL'I!.I ~"'_'!ir.o!l.L!IdI_~'!ir L.~.M-'-'!I.!i- v.. 1

neOOo~' friedrim. Brnj'il~:e:r~ GQtd~eJb, Ki~t.2:n~ ,arnd. 'Ohr~ ~Nhl']~~ ~lQ''V"iQ'I,l~ 'by '~I,d. M:~~r in, .I[9',;JJ.h tc~$\" tQ'oi~, Wdd" lndil~a'(i"

'~l· iLl' '~\...- 'n..';~b'~" _.1...', .~.

ns: ~,:,,_I;CIM;:U: ,iiu. _Jl)~iI~_~ 'I~·8o.;.

'n~ Gelt~.rai1 b1t~rOO~~~~ng 'tgl ~rhti ,M'~~~pbJ'~i~' of .MiwY~'l~ i.:~:191}~, 'lIi1tmS. ~~mi2:S E~~~npoo, ~r:ii ,rmmJam~'ei1:' ,Ka'l:r:~ Btm'c'Qi Pbiloaapn,Y; 'lndig~~lis:: Hic'k'ett hblii.~~ 1:98~. The t.WOI miiliin. :~a!l!:~Si m dlr; W'l):rJe ,aK :liS'l~d s~pagit~'I.f _L~" fVII

~'fhe,: MS[·"'I:n.k't!'iiji"'.?I'1: ,'I'l'iru:-i:;:;;.le&· .-,.f JIJ\Sitioi"!~ 'lI""7\tii'f~", ~rmSi_ 'Jtri'lf--, :ladd.,

~ ~~ ~.~- ~-~S~l"'~~-~ ~ ~~_--jf'l__._ ~ ~l 1-Jt~~ ~~7"-~ ~~.f'·~f I .. ~-~~--- -~.~~~ ~~-~~-.

l.ibr.anr of: Liberal Arts 'I'~' C' , ~ViI"i

I _ _ ; _~'~ _,. _ 1 . _. I I . - ., • 1"Z. ~ ~ ~ ••• J

Dti U~~~iVb-sj)~~' .!Pt.mdp1~' 0/ 'V11t~~' I~ 1'7'97'1 U;arns. ~m~s, El~_hll~r. ton :~~ .l:.mti'~~~· g~~:t~' ,Htb~'c'd ;Rhjl1~~pllMo [~~~~di. !1!OO,v,(t u rVII

{l,M O:Wd, Question Itais~d, A.BliB~: Is, !tbe ,B1J:m_ :la,c.e C"O&t:ilifi.dy n.,.~trT~"'JGi~Ii1''''':~~.i' *~~'" 'Eo'L""ri" ,A, ...... :bo:r, tn K'''!iiD;~' [Fii..,1 ,I::I':~li:t~$~ ""·I'''·7'~;

C.L~-Y~'I!P~~-eJ~ ,~~~-~ ~~~ ,. ~tc.=-_-_ ~ _ ~~-_ ~ Ut"~ ~--..J-y~~:1'l ~ l~

, ... ~,~..-~\iIi. (Uilii~ d!~¥'!IY ... ,}!I',I!I!~I

m.a,·~~:i'~ ~""'n:;f'\tlt"""'ij.li'tl'· :;",~ F'!il-"'lri[~'U'"'f!i~ [M~ Pr"ll""i:n'l~~ [i!I~ N~"'~"'[J!':""',I:' .~i.., ....... Ji~

~!Ijj ~-~3' II-.i~~-~~~I ~~ ~,_~J!J ~J' ~. ~-=~ - =~--~-~Ir.""~-~- -"'I ~ _ P-I' ~ ~ = J_:_"-~.c

():~f 'GZId ,i!;~·1tii~ [tIht: iSQFcain~d. J~Pmt',; :EJ.l5a,y~jI,' :[['l~j,}w t~~,,, 01. Hi,. K.ede;rd ad, ,B" ~E. W;a:Wfo!d :i'n, K~n:~: ,S'i'.;;eoted' ,1h:e~(;_"1;Uicrd' W~,i;~ .. ,i~g-'$. ,~ld C()l'~[~~d~c~ W:i;~! lh~'CK. IC~J~~~ ~jkJ","l~, '~DJ

~~:~""",flim,,;, ;""~,;'I I~''-' .":~iU' .:~,~i·I~C"':~"" ,:JIjjij· ... '~~n~'Il!'.,'~~;[< ,~:" 7;iZi:'~1' iii'i',S' 0IIi;" 1(JI 1i"'i\"'C"i'i~I;r;· ,J;"",~,!U.ilill>'~iV\ .. l[l.IIlil"lUI iIoJOJ .nH~ C'~![,il'II~ 0 .l;g:~!I;1Ii1.'t"l\l'~.!l"!OJo_ili!l.-"" i &., !l'!;;J ~~ ·.iIOoU.'il!. C:" !!;,_;-'IU.lllilO<l'~.

!f)ev.iH~, byle{wls. ',\illdrtt :Ie~k;. :L~bf;irr:y of: L'i'befli1Jl A~~. ~9 5[~' UV~I ,~r;p~~~:~~d h!1~~ (~~:'?'fiS}~1 ~[~" :~w:il$. 'WhII~ :~k, m. ,~'~a~' On: lii~'.r ~)Q'r~, cited aloo,v·e..·I'Vln~1

J~/j'giM 'M'[~:i'Q d~ limit$' [(Jj ,~'~~M A.l~~~ ft7:9'31~, tI.~S. theo,.·

[~I1""":"" [lii.1, I("\ .. ,,...,..";i"i>;, I .. ft~ 'Ury,'Iil''I' "8:'" I' '1::f""~"4+11i1 f,_,. ;j:'·_;ijile, n.~'i:j'"i""i'-~;i"'" ~Tjil

~, .. ~ ~ll'i_il U~l"'-""_L'_'''' "'~.Ii1 ,lJIIu., 'II. .• ,.. I["'].W~_I::II'U:"_IJ. ~ ~IJI~~Ii_~_IlL'II.J.!'JHi~['J ~~I.;r'.IUI,

'Cgu~ :~~'14'!· ,R:p~, N'ew 'Ymk~ ~l Th:ec'h~b~ '1,,60+ (VU

,It-On. :I ,8l!1~ 1U,~'t 'to :Lic :n:om, AJ),t[U~.srti,c Motiv~;u {:I'91~~. '~i1D!. 'Lewis White IecJk in .lmrnli!J~Il_E ,l\'a'D~t Qri[~ciqu~ ,oJ' ,P.:rillCiti:~· [0t:111 ,I:a~,s(m ~,d Oth~.r 'Wl'ii!:1n.-g,s: JiLt MOr.~' P~iJ;r;,s~hy. Cbi~~:

Uoive:.(;si:ty· m 'Ch~~ :Pre.S6 .... , :~;t.i9o :Rpt .. :i'l'I. :New Y~r}:: Gfuilnd" '~'iM:"'6 ~VD~:11

"~lr- .111 ~ - ~

i.!li"L....- " t··'I'il:-·.. C"i.:;o,wlm. ~ !i!"""U,'~I:rri; 1'lliII!' ,co, ~''T'I...,',~. "I~'''' ',iJ<~"~': .. , ... ,: 'jill;: _""~ ......... , '"",' '-1'"' """< '",L""I" "1 '~I '"" C,·i"ij' 'b··~.~~, I~,'i"

U-.llj .i.liL'~ "i;,.,; .lOin .. 1!.l!'.liIi ;Ji ... , _~.. J. .. U_;iI! Ji.",l",,!' ,~ .l.J.1U... UiIJ .I .. iI!l""'l1l~ 1 U... !l,

Does :n.nt ATlin]v :~n 'Pl';" ..... ·'I· ci!!l"'!;!" ~f ~ 'Ij·7.·1EIi'i2' !I- IIfr.!"D';c" '-H· '~. N~I~I;c,;i.~t, ·~i.i'i"'. "1

___ -_ _ _ ~ I"""l ~.r~.J.' _ _ =~:l!i;I~ j~1!.r ~ ["':.. 7J [I! \1. Or. [I" III lOll . ~_01E. I .~~LIJ

,Ka~t.'~i ,Pajtt~IC"id ~'tm",s', mf .. :t~IIau, :Ie:tss. camlbri;~e~~ Ctm'~ hiidge U'mhrieni'ly PreSSj• li:sr?lO. (Y11IIlll

ffWiba,t: ls, :inU.~ell1mmlt.:~'I~ '~1·7,84f.l, 't:I::as" ~Le;wis· White :Reel':. :'11 RQ~t O'n! Hj~'~~·. ¢iikid.,~llkrvle. [~Ymj

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'P':A".~',"'" 'R-; ITI-- :0"",=: I'N' :::,,' "E-J

. • • , . I l r 1 ••.• 1 • • 1 " •• ...::_ • ~ , , "., l ,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Copy rig hted m ateri al

I An inrroducnon tOI the ethical, political, and religious thought ot Kant

'~ ....... ·~"""""""',di''''r,.~,-,'I 'iI' -,.,.,t-' •• '1..,." ,AI"'_';'iI"iL ""ii: seeenl '1"""'-1·'''''-':> ''''''''''''''''''p'h' .'U'''''~ """,. ''"1n·Ai ,.'L..,. ,~y,~, 'U~~_~~'~/~~ .~~),~ l,~~ u.;~~g I~.( ~,If-~-~~ ,~_~l~-:- !Ii~ .• j_lI~t~~'," '~ 1·~~J~ ~IIJ_~,U. ~I]],~

bl·'· ... h ~f' ,iI"~""" :rI[I"'I'~'t·.", ~iif'·, ' ...... "" .. , ,,'i'l',oI;>'''I'''" , ... [..,.~ '~"'~~IIl'IiP!n,~.o;on't· e', ~'I\q .... \~ ''''i:~v~t'h'<;I!,,"

_ :__.~.l,-:-_____j ~_~ ~_~~~ ~~P"'~-~ ~L. ,~,~~.J '"",~~,~ ,~~,y~ ~~U~-~-;' u~-_· ',_' .. _I·"'L~~IJ_lI)l_~. JL[U~~ -:-. ~J~.

m .' .. '. .'. .'. hi I'" . f' '. hi' ':In'~'" p' L ~ , ' " , - .-. d' "bi .'. ~ 'hI- ~ .'.

-_, -,. ri rc -'1_ . . -~, ~ , 1- " I I_:' I - '," 'J '. - _~-' I" '01 I, = _ " I" [.", I I - '," J I - ,.' - ; - I ' - - '[1 I '. _ -', ( ," 'I " I' ','[ . , l: . -," I 1- '; I

~~~e, oon'SU~J\lt~ L,~ r~,~,"o:~,~· t~·_"I,l,lllt~,.enr ,_.eL,.ce 3"Ut

'the. KOpe [a:~d!, :,ow(e:r of. :~ea'S'Q-n. :I'n 'dl,e CrjU!q~.:u~: of Pillre: ,~ed'S~jj~ :Kant sho-ws, mIlt 'theore)tica'~, :reason is· 'tlnable '~Oi 8!il!Swer t~he qr.u,esitcioms, 'QE spee.~]~lJti¥e :metar'D.y&~,CS': 'whether' 'Ood, e;x~st~1i! 't~,e SCfWJ, lSI bn;mO:lt:ii~ Md, 'Ih~ 'wiU, is. :fr_, B~,'t tb~51 ~~n¢~J;~sion :p~~parts, d~e 'wa,y' l~t, ,81m, e:x,t:enS:i,on ,m, ,tbe po·wtT' [of Plf,I,ot.iJcd, ieason. I: :P:raet!l'c;al ,reasom. dJbec'[s, ,th:a:Jt~ eVlery' :&iUIm4D. 'beag ,3.;S 3 .. f:[lee and. ,3[ut:OlllimO.lJS: beirng ilDl'ist 'be I~gaDtled. ,as 'i,[I'nc,"G:fidiUnn3J'U., y,alw'ble. m. :Ms et't~I!C':al w,ri:t;jta(gs :K.ailrt

:-:1..~ ~ -':~I 1..~ ~ ':' "'.1f"'~1 ,d'~I:~i-':,~ ;:(}~:,~ '8~:; ;:;'(.:1":':-1 ,~ 'r~:'~'~-::-~ ~l ~ r-~':'-::--~[~':~}"~ ~ll ~'~ ,--: 'r' ;; -:;~IV'-r~. SJ;Lm'WS J;LmwUilll~~I-a n.ve ,P;~1.w;;8 ;3. ,~iiI!iI!UJna . ,~nunua![.IQl.'ai. Inr ,~10\1;3 ].rYi'

n-,:l~'h-:-~s,. '~'C'd :~ f-!.(1i:--:\nJ ,-,:f 'mt1kf~'m f:a"lth~ Brtn!j))~if:.i'if f;e\a!SOlll to the 'Wt();l'ld, lifO 1 . C,," ;an . ta. ". Y.I]. 0 .... .. ,L I. , ,,[11_ ,~~·ft ,~... . ..... _.. ,~ .. "

beommc,s the ef:.i:~e~ri;s.e of :mtc!I.:aJi:ry :mttbJer than melil(,lry:s;ics), aI~d tbe

WIi"fl.T'lt~ [nID, 'jlO'f.;;oiII]~ ."'iIiDI .. '~a '~~ __ ; ("~ husn CI<1i1ij'i;]"'rrV:

._ .. _. IiUl"tlol.l!A~ 'n.''lir.i.~_ I ~ 1r_IHI:!ir.' jll]~lr'~ !U.)l; l _ .~"L ~"_il_ Ji~." e

lmmarilU~~ Ka;~~: WaB bGm ':iiO 'Im;~i Q"s'OOi)\ Pms-sta. an LI.;:' A~ri~ 'I"?! 2\4" ',~

______ .. _fill. -" , .. , J . __ 1. ~,_, , .• ,=, L~ __ , , __ ,c __ '~" ~, ""~ _ ••. _., ... _~l _ ~ ., ~ I"l, !I:"~~= = I' =. '"

b~,t\@ ~, d~;v'()~.t P,~.~t~t f~[~,y; ~"f3t1~~r 'w'a~1 a h~'mJc~issl"'.m3'k;~!r ,gd '~~ l~InUy W,~~ n~l W~U, I~f. :But :Kan!~.J\'~ m.{J.tbe;r ~~ogn,I~~d her ~~,~I~, i~lt~-lI~~t~,1 ,giEtSJJ [aL~d th~ paJt~~~n.~ of' ,ltb~ fa:~Uy p'!1st'Or :F:r~ Al'K',n SclWiU]jI~ I~ :r6g',i=<J!,'i5'311, a IPi[e-tiJ&t ,th~(llQgy pt'(l£~!S~r and, :p:l\ea(hef~ eni'i':b'~@dJ Lm;t to a;U~nfl 'llf:1e c()n~O"~U'm Pl'hieri[maili![ulm and 'nJl~narr~ for.'

~~ _ ___:,,_ ",=,-.~_, ~!__~_~.____:.__: ~._.' [_ u :l~,,,,=,_-:____,,_,:,~ .• ~__!:_l"'=' '.___:__:_: __ . ...=.~~j:: ,_II,_ ~ ~l,I~I~ __ ~ __ I,·~.~~~ __ __!_U...: _ _:~I~, .~_-~~.::_J ,~£_.~'y I~, --=.. :___ :_: ~I.

'll. 3>

Copy rig hted m ateri al

·t'inte u.m.v'e:~i~;y; B:e ~,'tl;Wdt~,ed ,ar~, 'Ihe 'iUII'~.V'e'~:si'ty of' litl~;g:s:be;[g: :tt'f);m, :r''J',ijj~·,.t,,''''', Iies~stm"" n':r~l1Wre en ehoose o.lil,~ of ehe ~.ae.'u:ntI~es and '~'~Ik;',·,:,~

.("t'~ ~n ~ ~ ~ .. ·,0'.1:"· ~~ ~ ~.~ ~ ~~ ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~-~ ~= ~~~ ~~ ~ ,~'" ;t:tll, :alling

!(t~fllf:5e:s, ec],e~t~,~:aUy' b~~"t~d.,~ :H~ 'W'~~, ,infl~.eneed b, h~ teacher :Mar'rr. tin. IUl'IlW,I"Se.rru. [~~ 7'Tj,~S; T II~, a 'W~lf&n .r;a.d'O'udist; 'whQI taUg'blt: phl]j~soph.f and pll'y)s:~.c8" and 'who took. a!n :~uteres,t~ :~iII '~be: d)ev'¢l,opm~~.t;s ,~f .Bdt~~ :phiJj~p:b,Y' and seience, :Kn;~,iMn bltJlOOJ1!,lC~d Kmit; Ito th~ Wi~:d(s, I~f New'~OI'iiLh

'~iifo"-:"~m-:c-' 'Ij''7A1,,'=e·!t' ~, ... ft'tr 'Ui'.rf>'ii"'i~,..:.d' !"",,",];ii; nnC"'~I'\"'t'''''', 't· ... '.I~lI"Io'lII" 1""'1 ,~,L." hom "'Ji", ",,"'f",· £,"IV'i _. ::. [Ij,! ~ 1-' .)1 ~ l~_-Llo .. 'IIr on UoIl,it\;.., I ~IL~ ~l ~",. Yo OJ. ~ ~~IIj,,~IJ, 'I.~, I'D~ _~~~~,_~~ ~_=

·;Pi"li(r~If{LIjj'iiID ';['~'~';-'-:""]~':I ~~ '~~,~ ,,..it"I~~'~';~';- ~b'c"~", ~,' ", ad ", 'Ii ,~,'" ,~'~I ",:"', ,. ",,j.,'.' ~"".. " "", ,.,' ,t", '.' 1'1 "",,,,,IlIIU!'YI::I' ,I:aml ,~leSI ,neal ,n!ILl!'n~;gsl '. eir& an "iPl;Wir$Ueu .~ui5! ,~n~~!re5i,.,5, m ,W}~I JJr~~

scJ e:mce liil I~'~"~ be ·WS'S n"iilrl'tioo die ril""·I14.'t' ,to '~eDtm,e as it Pri'!ll1'tanzmlt

"'.- .. -.1. -_ I. ," .• '. -,I_I •. 'I' _;'1:;1 . ~,I J _' ~ •• .1 _: I. •. I. ,I,. t. &.oI\~J,.~. - , ,::.- _ of::' ',.:. '_ ~'~. '~_' .. ~, .~, _,I_., __ ,~ :".~_",:"_~",:",,, __ ,=[~

{,arn. u;~8a13!n.ed i.ect;Ult!r w:h.o ,is p~id 'by l~(:~iIIU\~ I'~~~l :aiJt: Km.D'ils'bug. :nn older: t:o earn, ,3 .li!.V,~l'I\g: Kan,t~ lectiUJ'too, O~, lm.~n,. ,s:li,l.bj:~~ts jnCJ.udiJi;g ]I~P(';" metap:~"s1C'Si~ e:thic-5, g-e.o,gf'alph.y~ ,3ff![tnropolO,§il :mad1iem~~iCi~j the f(rU!Ii;~ ,cLl,'tioEi'$ '0£ fii'3JtUJroal scienee 31~.d .. p:h,)f;s:~,e:s\. We hav,~ t~stimOJ]!i.rus, to the C~iW~f' of Kan~:is, '~eQmre81 '~:h;f:r:n'~I""~(Jwt lus, 'Hfe: his, audieaees w,e-r.~ lrar~)A·

,I: ..... ~" .. '" ~ ~, .... " .... , " '" , ..... ""'I~.I, .. }" "", ., ''', '" " ,.~', ~ ~'~'~' ,',"~~"~ ~_,",~"'"j'

and bris etml}c'5 lectures aee Ilfparted to :~a!.v'e '~n e$p~ciaUy ,ntQvi'~1-,3 Tn c~' 7~''70 'Kan~' 'wars nnaUv arr-nawnted t:o a 'r.epl'~lilaI nf.O'f~s:sorsh'in the

l."_~J II. ,.. It _,_-~11 :_'_- .. - __ .~ -':'11' '[r~·.·.··I.~.- 11_._ . I ,I,~~~r._ .. ~,J:..:.~~...=.,--·:..:.~,--.__:___.J'~lr. ~~~.:_.

~ha'~r O[ ·~o~c and 'metan'hvs:j es a;t KO:n~ tJ·""l"!ii1!TP Hie 1~C!tU'r.:~d '~h~'I1~ U!ndl

.:1:_ .; •• __ -. ",."L' I $'-.l~.-r. ~ [ _, ,. .. _ . " '_' .. ~~ I: ',7.; ~ J. " . , "'.' lIi~~.IZI!.··,-,- -~. I, .. ...:_.', ::_-...=. ._!1 . .: .~I, • ...::. •. :._. 1~__!_,...::._~I .... :.: .. ...:._~, ~~6

'il i',,'~. '~~, ~l~,--:~ ';~~I ~, q~\I'~ "1'1,,:::-:' '~'I~'-:' .~ 19'1-" '!UJe Yl_~"e!;.!l!. 01] IZ j;',euruary I !iYQ4",

E:'i!n'·-·-:-v:~ -:: left ,-,t;.I~: V:,:;·'c.\-::,~'~~, ,:~ .. n ~,' ,'I 'b"·~1. ,', ,":h"~'" , .. I, ,,' , ' , ,',,", ' , , "",.i: 'LI"" ,

~",=-~,-,.J: ne ~ eJ' "el" me ,~onlg,8lD!e:~g, :all-eaiwillJ,t ~" "ere ;,t.re reports O'J: mllSi

-!Jr;lj' "~~~'''i':-''~ ,'i-;'~'~l':""';cC: ",,',;: ',:,:,:~;i' '~r-:~'r,;-::;,~, '-: ~'~I ""'~,:, ·l,."~';~'·~1 ,,:~,jf ',",. ',"(.> .. ' , ,. r'.; ,,".,' I, /, ,

e:~~,,"l"a~lr'l41f'i4lry ;a!L!l~. u:y !L!Oi ~,~srUa.wlZ!el am. ene nasJ.rS! iQ,I w.n.u.en ~fj(?fjkU~,tsli'

,Ia;c-,s, and i~h~~ I.~' 'iIrc~; had 'j:""':;~"-;~'iI.'i!J '""'1'1 ~] t·:; :i~",:,:~,~ ,"~'I ,;i.;~, ' ',,', ::~"., ',' ~

,p~_c~~ m_ tt~~ll!gS ne U!ia:. ,flIiec:"\I'ieJ' seen, m a .!Ii.{K)~not:e Iii[!! U~e ,[p:~!(j~(le o~:

,A.n:r:hr:i@i~QlO1;f.Jr !:r.nm ~~ ';raiQ";~'dtic ,Pdn~' (),f Vl:"e:w~ Ka'f~t' CO;iiFl:nta~endv

~~, ~.~~~ ~.F"~ ~ ~o,;" '. ~ ~ -= ,.~ ~ ~ ,~'¢!r"-"""'_".,." .. -" ... ') ~"" ~ l , .. ~ ... ,,,,' ,t'" ... " . T

remarks:

.A cit"'" such as, ROniil7sbfi:a on 'the lUve.'[' PreioliP.'l- a ]:a'~ c:'t:~', dij;~ '~?{'!IIt~"C .:;~,~

, ~~<! ~ ~,~= ~~ ~~~~-IO~' '~i!!!' ~- ~. ~'''~, ,,,,,,.~-, ." "\~-' l"l~ , ., ~. ,n,., r i[j!. a,

cst'.1,'t:~!, th£ ~~ of tmfi;~ gfo.Wi~wJn~~t;l!.5 :p:~~c·jil c(]~rn.dJIS~ ~he site of a 'M~y,e~'_ ,s(i,'t:}!" ~:£:o;r ~Dltiv~,ttiGn. [~J djj;,t; ,S.¢i,~ne~s,~~ ,a, ,SUfiir:~ln [~mm.e~~~dI ibv' :ri'ver'-S, 'w~lth ,the

.. J It''-_,· ';"

:illtmQr: 'of 't~e :OOt'i~,1(~, so tlait iJt:s IDocaitffi.on ,fa,vots, naffi,c 'with th.e r.,eSit~ 'fd: ttt~

>!"-'fii"'il;'rilili'O:'!Il j'cS' '~~~1;:;,1"'] ."10[;, '!i;i!.fi . .,'L iifi'~iii!~loiiIlj.I'b"-:--.!lIi'g ,;fIi"i' :remo~·;i;,.:. I"..;tn~i'!'ft~n·~, "h""~"'"'''''!Il!' ,.;I'I~~ ;"i'~P'..;;>i"'~ '!Ir.'"!O.!I .... ~lO,1:-,~ if'.... 'n ~ , id.<:I '!IT,~t.lJ. '''''''''''\!!9'ilJUU,l~J!I!t'!>l< ",,~. , ~. , .~,!!ii"" ",,,,,,~~,~= ~""~ ._. "'''!<~!tl< 'i;II_"'~ .·'!O;,.,'!.,-",.i'"

lang:ua;g;es and. eusmms - is 3; stll.t3rb;]~ place fur b:fWd~~it,g: 'o:moel'$ .kn.g·w"1.e of l"tlafi, and, ti;e 'world,. fu is;~Cb, ,a CIli't,y~ ~~'i;5' kno-wled"e caill. H al·fl[~~~,~d. ,~v,~~

.. 0 '-~l

,w·,..'i. •. ,~"~·~ ,~.~ ~~~~,1'- _ !I'''''t;;,'~' ~ ~ ~,~ ~

.~ Ai,.;nMJJ,iliitt tt[3.V~Jlng" ~tN,'" ,~, ,n: ,[::2100,1-

Copy rig hted m ateri al

I'll, c!E\nlidl;ti~~m~n'~ [G~rman,. ilih~: :~nJteU,ec~ju.al 'Wi0,11d w,as d:~mina,too, b, 00 [~n,~m~ :w~, of r:a:U'cm~:aUsm, camled, the LeU:~ni:z='Wti~f8~, :p'hjc~ ~tosoph'~~, Chr,~~ 'W~JU [~II .i;79~ 1:'7 S;'4'~ is, geHeral~" coosid.ered ,(ID;~ of

u, iI!=..l1 ~1' 'II!.. G' - A' I';' .. ~!:' -W'·'_' '-lu ,.ill I h"

tlJri,e, 'twc[ :IJIUunuefJ:s, [~A' 't~~_;_'enn~ml" 'ti~l~mm1:'l~'.""O'\ '~I: cnms,truotew ,. I~~

p:hiloa.opby :iliom th~ ii~ of. Lci'b-n'~7:~ ,and "l'llo:m~stie, i~c~hola!sti'c~s,njt" :Ue t-oot: :m~uiib~,t'~es, as a l'node~,~, ,~f:U~ '~lielj.loo, tJ~a~, 'plililosop\by :81~,tr[[Jld be. ,ia! '~Ul!_~J~!'~ d~dJ~vtj"v~ ~'Y'-5ltemJ' 'wit'h, ever,. Q@fiC~.uS:~fi~, deI'ul,v''ed 'by' ;syn~-sis,tjc ~s-opim;g ,from :m,eCe!!83!ry :P([iCllltSes., Like Le,JM_~~ WoHI: based bi~, ,s,yc&tem, en the 'prindples, ,~f: cQ:GJt'I,adic~tjj,Qm, and :~~,fi '"' d.en't :1)~:iiSO:r~",~ 'WeUf also believe-d, '~ha.t the pdSil~ip~e: of s'ufl(}i~nlt :~'(1rrru, ~o;u]d 'be ,defil,ve.d &txff:], ehe pl',ind(p.J~ o-j [~:ono~di-~d~~ fQ!r.' 'mer-e wu~ld 'be a, co:n:t['iidi~c;d,O:ml, ifli, the insr::~mt\~,(;n;d, d~t~4',~n~d, ,exi~:t;en~-e [[1yf: ;s, [fi,er-eiy p08sibJje tb];l](g~:~ W!~.dle hl~man ib~i~, :~eed ltD use emp~rl~' ,~:I, liiile;m,ods in, O!r!J;r' ;sea'~, £01" the r.''ti~n;s [of ~birllP~' in, ,prindp-le :I,t :sihcfl!.i],d 'be :~5:~,ble to case the scienees :In ,I ~orn:ple~e'l.Y' ,~;led)~,cd'v-e :~ottif!l,. "E1l,e c~;st:efijCC~ o'f ~ CaL~ 00 prory\~, by 'Qin-~(1'logi!t;i3'ru~, ~oS'm~]O-gI!,~, lea] and tei~JeoIQgj~, af~m~~,tsli and be;P.d1;lise: 'we l(~ow' '~t-..a:t GIDd ex:18liS Wc~ :know' 't'ihat '~is, :~lS, t'he Best iOf' AU, P05S'~,ble: 'WIDILds. 'ne :~U~, ~~ ;si.mpJ.,e; ,arM, hnrmQnaL and, si.n~e i1I.c~i,(1tns 'Ilthier than t!b08e aile ~peI"" ~wn_~;s a_R: ~ii)\p~ly ~s:d'bleJl the 'w,IU, is, :&-ee;)' 'WCJll?:s e~'ltb::s, is, bssed '~, th~ ,id~a 'tjha't Hle w,trul :~!S lit'e-oCes8aDly mDti~alt~d by 'e'~e ,g"ood '= '~'!ha.t ,is~ bf' ,th~ ~r~ptjo:~, of a, :peri:eotllJfi ,ajc-h'wev,able by' ~c~i,'mn" 'Whiff 'tlhllU,gDt it oon'tradi~~~ry til' perceive .3, :pedectljCJfi 3iflld net de-si:re :~,t" so ,in, :K;lDd_ it~l',mi5 'we :ma,,, 83!y dlat he beUev~d t'liruiil!~: '~n~ 'm~t',d :pif,~[IJ~i~' '1!'Ii:~,e: is ,;ulQ11""t~,¢," 8, .seekt~,p' nerfecti'Oifi wiU, briJ):~ 'UiS bil;~nin~~i ,MldJ th~

,If II' .-~ lrr b ~~ ~

:~!~ti'on ,of ~a,cb :petson, ihal:,~D~Jl;W~es, w,~,th the: ,.eJ:fec~ion '0'1 ~~~ry

,o~hel'. :lm.itnol.ld, [oonduc:t is '('be les,ult ,of oom~~:iim ~Ioou;t W:h8iit: is ,snOO., :Mofal ,goodn.~ss, :i~ t~l '00 ,~chi,¢v'ed t'h-IIOn,gD 'we. (:-ladlta:t~,o:n, ,3!Il,d c~ctiJJ[t of Q\1l})" :~d)~il!~"

[~ in-n'~~n~ (Jf ,thi~, ~r:'5t~m, O'f d!a.glic~iiiJ~]C; :lEet.ap:~",s.ilts OJ)~ the thI)U,p..t of' ,Airltk'1ii:~ Ge~~fi'ililn,,' CaD, :hs_tdly be o,V\e-;tl~s;ttma.t'el(t. It'" ~~~ he t'a.uP,t~ :in 't~e u:m1,ver:siJtJ~ :~,ectiu'f:ecd, i:~~ Ce4.'liii'Wl" ,md w,r.:ote in, ~~, ,as, 'w~U as, Ji.,a,Un.r 'WaoUf :ha:d m,(lre dh':ec:t :1~lfl:lle:noe1 thm Lei'b= ,ni~, ~i:ms~U:" WoHf 'waS, ~be nrlst. :p\h'wLI}8;(1jpil,er: ~o prnduce ,I f!al[."lIledg~d,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

fS,S1t1em jn.l"he (~el]'n:aI1llanpq:e;l' ~nd :h.e ,m,v:'C-n~ed, t:h.e teC:~nic~.I, pmlo,..

;i;j~~p':Sk ~,.,."':~ \.,~\M;.".;'ti:k,'il~",iI'V '!iii.. 'i't- ~".ni!:i. r. ~;i!j.i:i.ll '~~ b~ ':; D ;i!j:-r."C,;C' ~ ;i!;iD""~~,~. ]j@ li~":~ :il'_ljt~ ,'jJ ..... ,~ .. ~. ~," 1II11.!!;;oAiill" '~'u!!;;oI1l!l}w;l~,: J ~ln .... " ~·a..z!i W""'!wU, LPT 'e ,liiI!' "",Ui~eiil!~m. ""iGIIU: 5, l!~a8

'Wlirii~ ,;'ti;~;i!i'Jj'i] 'ifri'.: -"""S;i!liojl!'i""""~ {~I 'ii':Wi'i:IN.:·'i~~;]~ <II'":,' "-"""'IIIU 'ii"'" '~'1"'ii"ii'~~!i!:', ""Ii'I"~'~*'~'~~1 #,~~., i"':1..,~: 1-.:c, •• '. '_ !!;;;!Ii.'!w !III'_'JoO!!U ct."'~!!;P .. !!;'(",_~.!.i~, leu, r'V,~I!1;10- .Q1i. ,1;Vl, e - .. liu. iIlJUVli&'ii;_'il! WIlI',!Io"C:n ,iliDl' ILUe .11

dies_iJ ,i'liiICl :S'~wned, t'liie SOC~e-iUeS, o.t: the '~~e~:ds, 1M T';:[~'tl~ ~':'ih;s:-·

.. - L ... J -- . ,.. ·,r- ,...... '-. ,. ... Wi .. _.. .. . . '-. ..EJLn. _. . ,,[ill .... ~, w, )It.e

memibeu, pledged, D...nl: 'l?O acce,t '01" :rej e,(.;t lx~ll,ef;s e1C::oept :1'0:1:' siuf8cJ!CfiJt: re:ason. ~ ~ Kant was edL!:1clt~d ]jill tile 'W:O~ftG!llil. s"stcem;, and, ,lung ai~e[ ,h~ :b...a.d, r.lei:~t~d it he G!esC'J'ibed WiJllH as, jjtl~e ,~iiJ[lte~i't: of atU 'dtu: dQg'~' ma.tic· :phi'~osophfiJ:'S,~;r !~C::~; :0 DX¥ij. WaJl[f~,s :8'~ud!elil.its talughiJ: :in: umi.V1!-I'~ 5id!~s au' 'O"V'ef' G,Cl',ma'lil.y and, 'wm,t:e m.any cl' the te~~Jboo:ks, ,t~_a1.t: (jet'"

'I'Ii!I;'''I]'n' '1!!W1i\A"\i!Ii~S;i'"li"I:!' '~iI''ii!:Ii-_' ' .. ~n'il'''~-~ ~..-.;, '!I'iil:!"" l"'M ... Ch'i'!!~'r oII'.<"i11'i'l'·iI!'~j[!1 o··:·-:~··~"" ,ii"iif' t·"I:..;Ijo ~.~~.~ ,~~L~I~_~_~~.~ yy.~_,~~. ~i~~,~~, l,~ l~[~, ~~~, ~-~L l¥yl~[!1!1~~ '.-_'~'J""" v.~ :_IHb .. ,

most :~nij'lu!~nt-id, 1m: d:.~m, ~ Alexander' C;6n'U~ll :Oaiumgarrtell r r7 ~1:'4.- 6,20 II = wrote the '~eKt'k;o:ks, Karll.t~ '~, :in :bis, oour~ om, metap'h:;rsi,es ,lila, ,~~hi.cs",

rCJj: c.:om:se 't'bis ~x,tl.e'm~ ,ra,tio:mal'ism, did nO'~ 10 'uncihIUel1&'ed. Tbte. ,foUowt:rs of du~: ,other' iu;under of '~'be A,u/iliml1l!~' 'ChdS'~ian, 'T.bnm4'''' Sj,U5, 1,J:'6 S j:= I','2i,8 ~1' a'ttack~d 'tl!t.,e '~~l'I!~,ti'on of :phOGm;pmy' ~mibOOioo, m the: :Lejbn~:z:~'WDUfim, s,y,stmn" Some 'were Inti,~me;tapih'5:icaJi' ,aLtull 'waD'ted .pln.iloso"tw.,· 'bD ,P:~I,Y I, :ml!OJlIe .PQP~laI:t :mO:llJl,~~,ca.d~i~ rcll~, Mimi,@) ,im,po:r.t'tnJt; ~Dl '~be s'tliJdel1,t of ethl.~ is ,t'be ,fa.ot; tba;t ThQm:asj:~s, :hbn,s~Jt

O!'iIIFft,d! l,l':Iiiii'Ii;.,;;",,~ '!ID:I-.,iI"!!; ~n~ . ..ll '~:~~'I,;i!e_'~l IPO!'I;toi,nn· ;:Il~l's':m':' 'u.1\~~ '1!I]l!i;co;;r!i;;ro·il'~liF..,...:I;I' 'UI"I"'i'iL 1111.&.11 !U!!IiI._IlII~_.&r.J! ~ J;L~ v.-1t"I~--.~-~-a, L"¥~J.Il~Ui.I ... ~. ,~,~II-:-.lJ"-!"i ' __ dill· -_~_I ~ - II- !'FT'~~,~ '~~~-!I#-¥~_~} ... ~-g ," .. ~g

pj!et~srm" :P:ied'&m\!, tbe I1eli,gio:m, ,fif :K.a;D:t'::!!l QIWTI ,fmil,r~ e:m:,ha;S:~2ed ,mner' rel~giio-u5 ,ex.perien,cc,\!, seU"'e.'X'amlm:altlfifi ,atOid :mrol.sUy' IGOd wimtksl; ,armd :P'iJetjl.~, thefJcfo3ia_iI'IJ9! 'belirewd :l_o. ,iI :I'~rol!ill ofifi'fii,ec~ijO:fi bet.wle;en :m~l,a]il:t.y and J;'e~l.igi..O:fl,. 'WIlen W}jUf Wa!8, ,ap,poi'lll.te.d, :riecl1Gtf' ~.t: '~[be 'U·fil.lr1CFSi'ty IQ~ HlaUe:i.' ,I p]jeti;si!t ce:n.tler~ bWi inaiugLl!if-ail :~ec~uI-e was ll,On dIe :Pl'a,eti.cal PbUoso,;hy' [~f '~'be Cb.in,ese.i~' Wo:U~ cJaimed '~ha:t me :mfital p:~il~so:phy of Co*c~.U!s SbOW5, tbaJt: e~t'h~Ci8 :iJS ,srecessible 'tm nartJUI;am reISO~, mel,

l·'fIi'i;~';'-Ii:'I!e:-.I'fI;..lI~P;iI,t·, ~.t 't..o;.!jtl',b~!;!J;"'Ir:"'~. A·.'~ ,;j] '1II".I;!I!;C!>iU 'II to: '~:.~~,l~"l';i!, 'P".l",;tI'.:~I~,t: ;a'PI;;!1'~'il~~, ~II'\..'

l _1II_,I_lrU_''?I.Ilr' . "_II~U;-~Il_",. I '!I.i-l .~J'!I.P.IIP,' IIIIr..I_tyll!'dll}!I.~WIH.III •• _~ dI ,1I.!llr.I;J!:W_IJJ.,W ''''r1!U'' ,1.1 tWi!, !I..It""_~~,," ""_-.I."_III.r:IJJI.I.IJ~~ ,~-~.

s.uaded, Pfed~;[i,~k, W:Uheibn. 1: 'to 'banish. WoU.t

A. :~alt~· ,ch3JU.eng-e: t~1 the Le:lilbmJ:lj·,Wol.f.'Han. philosophy ,ealn:e: 'wneA GejjHiIn~ 'began 'to' s,t'ad,. dle l:ri;ti\5h. !01l.pi:ri,c-ists,w es.pe~4a'~1'y :Kwm,e, u ,IB, kf.U_fl afu;:-r d~1:; 'middle o;f. the [Cle~tiltoury ,~ :IIlOrY1e:rmen:t, ealled j~':po.p!liil8ir p!hi.I.~QPi:jI'Jt~' fl'@'urisl~ed, '~nd.(!l1" tlli~~ :~n;fh;~~nce 1M ,fl',ed~dcik 'ttine; G;fe!3it,~l

""'!i"'''''i'''','''p,n;lnG' '~'D ies , ........ mh ""I"'!"'h,iln 'W .. , ·'1' ... ,L ,.'jIl--'!'!. 1) ... ,..'111"'''' :;11; .. ~""'-'W!' "'i~'I1.<~.,!"."" ~?"'.:Iu:y,·~.lI~ ,,~,~~,~,,~w' I ~~~I ~~~,~-~~=~"~~.~-w~~,t.t :: _,ry} ~~~,~~~~-~"t1J-.~_._~c~I~~lI.1.JJ '¥¥'D1\;;i.l~ ,r.ItI.~

eri(;:k: ,had. :reV,i.'tiU~~d, :Bom grC'UpS' 'W~I~ ,infeHs,t-e.d, ,in the.: P'~!dlosO'pbi,'"' C~~, tt~dli.t~.o:ns QJ :Ff,m~~ ,and Ilitai'~~. ,and ,th~ 'w'O'J'.iks, (If Loe'k.e'i· :Befk-eil.eyi' SIri:irteS1bwTiQ', H-mltm@iI!;~n, Hume, :Rf!;id'·.~ ''i~',.I, '1!"Jj;i'!i;.·~I~S",,;'tiI.I~, '~!!\iIo1!iil:'li~ .~""",,,,,,j[j;~,"'*,"':.fi.

_ ~-w-w" ~ _w-~~',~ ~ ~_w_ ~-~~~~~~ ~=~~l' ~ W~-~'_'1 ~~~ L~rV~~. '!r~~ ,!!'·I'Iir.""i.Il~" l!blb~~I',,-I_iAl~~'li

,MOI;"';I, sense ,.ih;j:lo .... ~ 'W''iil!il 't'ilrii'i'.'i'";~:, ~.:M]~'ili"'~~I. '~j"e' U',JO'i1ir;l;: '~~m.··.· .... i'iI(-~' (J .t-'~'ii:!iJ·C'~' r.t..'i'~r~ ,. ~ ~~.~.~ ~IS~!O'I"" ~'!;;IM"''.f ~~ lR..:l! ,U'I.~,,",I!~ gYL'_le._IiI .... U.r ~.!!'. AiI-_.eil!. lA _. V\~'1~, ~!I._l:il,,-"_IiS, ,il"n;!IOIi5~,

:ra,t.ilo:~_rukfn. i'D. etbl~s; W,1lI81 tJ"posed 'ooth by' d~e ;s,ppeDl tDI :w1lli,Oil ,3iodJ

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'the ,appeal 'to :moml :feeling: ,and :bii(wblteS;5I. ,Mt~r '~,e tmiddle ,af: the c~~,tUfY :r.a.tiomaHsl :metarph,y,sw'c81 '~OO [~~: :~lliC1:I~'S'Lngly undet ~Jt;tacik~,

,And ~ ~, :Ft[6,3 df),e :lel:~];m, ,A~ademy o;ff;e;red. ,3) pd~~ fO:I!' dl~ 'oos.'t ,essay' [O~, the to.p~,e ~)'Wh,e-;thef; m,eltapl~j,y;5i~al '~rU'th$ pnet,al1YF and lin :pa1tieu]. me, :rufidameflta'~, :pnncwples of :na.turilll thootGD' and m,Qr"" ,!JJh~ a:F'~ :1!lI,ot oeap'lible: oJ Plioo:f;8 as di.s,trnc.t as these ().f' IOOni~t;lJ'~ [and :~f: they rare n(1lt,~, w:ha,t is, '~hc~ tnii,e :nar~iUI"e o:~ me:_b: C~rt3i:~;ty; t~[ 'what dl~~ ~, '~'ms, [oonah'~,ty 'K: [de;\iYelo~,~, and. :~8[ '~Ibi.al ~~e \SU!ffi[Qj~nt I:o:_f.' CQnvi[~~-ioo, ~of: tbeb cmt'h~l~~!i[[ One oi the ,oom~pet'j,t-o::r:Si 'was :KanJt~[ alth~up, h~ dhJ, J];C)'t 'wlrn ,t'h~~ pure, w:~ijcih, 'W~fi'~ 'to ,M[~~, M~!I'I;" d~hS:(!ii:hrn [~::J:12i;9,....,86). En his [escsay K:a.rn.t denies, 'that :~.!~,ta;ph,"Si~s llilas, 'me: same lnC't'hoo, ,8J5, m:adle:mal]I~' The dUll(;!\i~,ty' is that ,th~ ~on~~ts, of' me,taphysi,cs catmot 'be e'i9[tablhhed s)m!lth~ti,~!1:u.y. the w,ay 'it'h.e [eRn·' a,pls of :ma!tb~tilel ean, lin m.rarth~~U~ m.e oonce.pts ,create' t'ihelr (J:bi:e~tts,~, ,amd, we lean, be ~6rt:ain tha:t 't'b~1' ~Q~,tdn 'wns;t, we hacft~ pu~: ilu;to ,them .. :Pbiloson~h,y~ on ~~ 'CJt'hef' h~dj has '~O and,~;~J(:: ~o:nc.e:~t:s,

~ _'. ~,~ .~'

w:h1,c'h_ ate gi:VeIl, to :i,( ()§eUIuly [pr! ~7[6=1'8J ,2.l$[lff.'I", Yet~ 'IDetBlphr,yr5'~,C:S[

is :~tin seen t-o 'ki po9aUij~e, and ~,ilabl[e [0'1; !1, ~e!rt"aj;~,ty suf-Stien.t :lllf OOf:.rnc:tltOf!i:i w,e lliJUSlt dl:a!w' lQiu!I :~nf(~J~n[~$! oFlllly' frO'Im, '~b,ose predl~c~lt~s of ii, mnoept of: 'WbllCh 'wle are; ,cettai.Di, rutd, n~t 'il~m, t~ the (lo:rncJl'U~ltan

. 'II.... . 'l.. "I .]11 . 'I ·,;11 iri: ," '" ~n~ ~ 'U' 'I

't!lUl:t W't: .£ilBi,¥'e 81D,Ve.U at 1], ,oomp~l-etle g;S~~liIi!ttton ii'"r~ ~91.F-"9 j". e.3irn,t:'s

[et'hi,cal 'v,i,e,w;s 1m, t'bis essa,),' dl~sp,b,. ~, ~Jlj;ll',i()~s, (iOfnbbl~,t:iOO, of in£J,u~, ences :&:o:m 'WtlU:f ,aJ'liidJ, Hu~~lu~so:rn." The PI,of.l ~nDJoi,plle~ ~re <~he 'We\l~'3!I1I, ;1 do the mest perl~(';t poS'si,bJ[1l'.: 'by' 'I)U~ [and. {'I do :nut de 'diat 'which, w(ju~,d, :b.iind~-J: 'dlM!; ,g«a,t'e8t :~slSible p~rf:ecth):n t:ea~w,bte

.. '1...-- -, , "ftiJ" , . '" I t~[ ~"nil:!'· ... ! "!ur,"" h .,,' ., .''', '1'" "" "'"C -, - ~,,'ih ' t~ ~C'-" 'It ." ~ ~ ,,-" ullrom:~~ Y;OI1: " ~l,r~, ,~i91~1. ~~t t-_Jese prUilI;ilpl 11::5. I.'Ire ,mc~el!,y IIa:tl!uall ana ;:$0

,·m·····ff'W"U' '11'IIHf~n OW""" KmO'W 'wiba;t, i:s 'Il'ierl~ct' fat' th~s 'flcarscn et'~] c's ,ra.Hi! '~n

~ 1_ ~~r~,l ~1'~ '~-~' ~ ~...:_l__I_. _',_, .~- ':_~_~~'.~ .' __ ~. ,~'~ _'. I, _,- ~.- -;. ,'.1' l ~ :' _ I [' - _.' - .; 1 [ ~ _ J _- J. - . 1-" __ OI.' ~-v.

'have the :~li\msj;~~ ~~rtaiD:tou:. Fo:1':" ICan,t~ $a,~.S~, s, jO:nrn,ci.n,le c£ Cibltgatiun

~, .1" ~ ~ '.' lJf' Jf" _;.

kl'1:s us 't1hat W~ [o-u,gh:t 'bo .(to $omedlirog." :Eidl,er: 'we; ,ou_gbt: tn, do :Si~m,e'"

.. ,L u . .l' 'II!..-'i 'il., '-b • . 'III

'wIng: :aSI 3 :m.e:.s, ,to ,din, enu\f itn. W,~ri'CIIri, C~5e 'we~ ~n, p!fO¥ei '~ic ie; PmlCl:pJeJ,

'b~,t :it is not; a ~~ '(It ,moral CJb:Iig:a:tlofl,} oil 'w-e~ 'OU1p,t bl' do, ;sometbitl(g,

_.oJ coo L,~, b 'Ii!.,"",'~ ,', 'Ll 'I"l I

~~, ,~, ~~,1' lin, wliUdrl elise. 't~le :p;tlnc~iPJle :~Si 'un:l~:f;lo.'V,~..,,",,e.,, i\(Jrt)una'~~jl'~,

:HuJtiili.e~om, na8, ShOWtlIiSI dla,t '~'b,e; :S:l:dxuxJi.uLlte 'p;~jb'JJ~ipl'!s '~ha,t ,g~,v,e

'= ~ ~.

:t'm':"'''~ :C""'b""it '''"i'':c'~ .. k;-::t-'--:C'i'iII;I;'i"'~ k-',";i"'iiw'l-~~iJ")I; b II'lit ..... f. 'unmill'!ltl':ZIiJ;~'I-

~. _- ~ ~o:nem" :are iO,IJJec;S DUIlO, w; "., .. ilv·~~' I~~~ _""", _:: 1I;,o!'_, ,__.__'----~~_ ~~iJ'---- ,_e

I' 'III" fnimi "" 'I 'Ii' - ." " "" "- 1....... .l ..... - - ~,,-- ~ ~ .... .Ji r- '11.." -t... '" 'ib" , - "I, ' " ,

~~lJl'm;g 'i,!I""J~ ~99"", .It 15, yet~ ~nl ~: [w;it-enn~!I1!~, wlUet[~e:r; ,t~ e ,;r,lm.aIl'

:p __ d~,l.es, 'M [Qblip,ltb)n ,He, b'ased om, '~he~ :la,o\1:I[",' 0% kn@wm_jedg,~ O~ [of: 'MHng I~n 30()),,~'~ :KanIt.'~'8, cO'f~elJJsio[l'rlll ar:c In, QR,e sense the I~V~-1',S~ af: those he 'wiD, u[tbna'~~hr' reach: it 15, spec.llb,tl,\fle 'me~d{ph~ics, w~hjJch

"'1'1 'Ii..,~, 'II ,J.' .,~_,ii:_ .;!'--..1 . ..1 - • ~ .'l.,l:l- 'b.. b * t, ~'III-] 't.. ...

W,~.I, !PC ,lied: '~:u,un.u~<~[ anti. pfat'UC"~!I, :PiUJ I~PI]l,J 'Wn'~,cilli WII, _; ~set, Oil,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

C ,:if!!'iCccc, h ~1~~'~1 v.~'" "I~ I'i,.( ,~~~\,; '~, ,_:",,,,,,, 'w,' , ,"~_, 1't"''-(' ",_,-, ,t',,[', '1tIj'I:' <'Ii:t, 'iIr'~, a ,ufJIliI, u35U!i, ,I,!!i:.;t In bilic ,pr:wze essay" e see A-al!t, S~t I!~~ .LiLlillSieli_~, rne

qUeSC];(ltlS, thl,t: wUl lead '~O hts maltm:e ',j.i!iW'S,; dle ,qll~s,ti'On ;of 't'ib,e: ;SCa1:t:u.S, ut pill!re 'ClOOOt!,tJii, i'l :m~~arp.htysicsj' ana, d~e Iquestl,on 'of :r}8J~i'ood,

l."""l = . ,_. '_"' ~'

d ~te(n~:\.ma'bHh\l!' .of ends and im~,il't~ll!'~·S, '~n emies-

,e" ,'cl",""c,.'" ,',' .. c',-,,, _c,',_ ~-,it?""''"''-'''~-'''''l!''-' ,,_~_~,,' __ "

S(l)J ,mQ~.rr.1,i ,rii1:ll(18;OphYi m ,~s :mu~h aa :~it ~U',p:p:lles 'the firtt ,pdnc'ipi~ ,of cd,i:iC'dl i'Q'd~~m~~~, .151 oo~.y CQ.~~dJ ~' ,ttu.~ lPl!)!fe inl~e~~,e:c-t ,and i!t~U' bd~gs to '1l~1e;

ih'l 'h - d 'hi 'b di d· .. h ~ J

Pl~: OSO'p .; ,y:, ,An'~ tIt_ :,e man "'N, 'In IeJUlOe_, ~ts. entena 'to Le sense oj P'~e:a!Si~I~e. 'OI

paltit '~pt~,i)I'rusJ is, v~ry fi:gh.t~ly' bla:m~~ ~o,g,~tbtrr with. c~ai~, :fi'uiiifle:nJlJs, wlt~ ha,'vt; :folliO'ww, hbtllJ, eo mm.e ejUe~~ ,f~O'm .~;, is'~ch Me"n liS, 8Wt'C~bW1f atnd, hj~ ~Uf:Jn~~!t&. UD l;161~

'We. ,al~ have the: L~~~~u':r.~ I~~: ,;e~'ll'.~'c~ .. :~o~,~s '~~k~n '~J' Km~'s, ,stiu-d~n'~Si, in his ,~thiciS, courses sQm~~,bn.l~ :~n ~.b~: '~QS I:77')~80, and, the vi~s. in '~'h~~~ ,~ ~los~ t-:Q' Ita.ru,"',s, ~J',hi~~'~, v.i'~W5" ,An:.d 'W~ ,ba,v'~ Kq;t~I'i5, OrW:rn, t-~'t"'m':-;f~~ I~'JI a f':alln£nt 'wdt,t~liI! 'lIn tt:h~~ r7'~'- of: the proFound hd·lJ]u", e:Sl_OI]JYt U!I!, ~'-[[!.-- .... ~-~~~~~= _~- ~ ---I' -~ -- ~c~-""--~- =-

~Il!OO [~nt',d~d, Q:~ his 'mo:~~~, '~i'~WS, b, R~\tSis~.u~ 'wlb,o;s~ 'W~.ifks ,h~ 'W,ilIS, I',~ad_bii!g, i:4!

Alt'bougb K_aJlt.r~ moral '~i,~w~, W~-1"~ d~~~l~,,.~lJ&. t-h~r !a!rd~!uliilrdll}n,

h ;o'II'd,- ,~ .. 1-1,::-.-~.C"lt~' th -~ ,w·;·",--c'I"{'i1iI!!!i' ""'~I~I.-t-' ,lfiI,f: his ",~rn;i"E;ll'I[;c,~"i"in~ ,"Ii 1.. "",liil'li': ',:,'b;A ;e;,tc"li'lIf~I'Ii~ ~:

iII/,." !I:.''V :alW.U, , '''' __ Ie ~Jur,I'io.I'lcl(ll',;I' 'V!!;'J!" """,.., ~I!"" ""V~"~~iO.'!I~'!i.!I~Q< ~IAJ"",,,'!I, !!P~'!W' '"' ,!I'I;"'''''~ 'II..!I'.-I,

m~t~:phi~j~~," 'I',h~ fIDr;SlIi: ,~d~, ;of t'b~ C'd':!j;~~l1l~ oj P~;r~ ,!R€~I~Q~ ,aP'"' pei]r~d i'll, 1:'7':Eh. :I:t~ co:rrucJ,us.i~nSi ove:Td~rew ehe Ido,piatic nleta,phySiLC-ii of: tbe Lcl'i\);miz'· WoUfiii3:!ii :philloso.pb.y; ,Mie4tde-1~SO:];ilil, :r:e:£'elnoo, '~~ :U.'S ,:i:W,~' thor ,as "the al1;,d!est;f.-Oif,l~g: Kr.a.r!lU, ji:I:$ l~ :£aCtt,~, K_ar~u;!'iS ,aJm, w,a;s :[t~t '~D' d~!Hr,(1'Y; 'b~lt '~O Cir.clD:mV'en't ehe sk~p~i~~~m, o..f. Hj~me!, In the ,P._t~lieg~·

,:~D1l1~' ;'\ofi; A:nl'~' :10oi;~;I,~,:tir~i'~~'D;':~:"h'!\I',id[""'1" ~ Karn-: rl~o~iCi,;, ;I!~~L~!O.oI! !,.-u ~=.r rU~!I;!!;;I!"'" c.jjiYt~,"",~'Il"'-¥~J'~~t ~=~ ~",!,_~I!i,.:!~

i[~.o.fi" ," '"' n,

I ~_ '_ ,'" ~'."'.', ,t.:":"~1 '.,"',~IIi,i1;.~·,;"h""(" 'L:f""'''''''I .. j,,,,, ;-0, '~J."'"""" ,,·'"t'I·~ enu ,1.:i ''''0:''',,' 'i,.,~", 'n.lI'j;o;,~ 'j, .... tC, .... ,,'I,"" !i)j!!-fi,";;:';,--c-,] ~. ~ _ _ ~iII_'J~' . _'J~ ~ ~_.i_!lP __ I'!ir."""';.ll lnl~'-=-II_II!~ rjJ! !\).Ilia ~-'_ _ ~"LI_" I!IP.-~~_ rWl ll:.1 'Ii! ~ ~c!fll.ll!lll ,L_I~.l. -IU! .1 ,~_ .• u • ..um ,

,~D:rm., jffid ,~n, fi;)Um.-di ~hart; the 'co-ntlt'l,pt ,o.f dt~ CQ~.ecti~g of ~ruS'e ,~l~dJ ,~ff~t

Copy rig hted m ateri al

iJi; '~J

.......1.. ~i .. 'b,.". 'h" ~h '~~ ~-~dJ~-~' ~ruli- ~"ltmk t1~~

W,8S ~t :n.0 lmJ:I1D_8 'biCi ~D_~~" t~oe:"t ~]!' 'W,_,___IIiC~. til_~ lI~,-e(,~~__;~:_~~ ~~~~~~~i!1I,,~~~

~ec:)tien. of' tIIw~.,9, d "jri'Onl, illu,{ mith1if.' t'lhat Eetaph,YS'~L~ 'COlll'51Sli1S· ,a'~~o~ [~m.m IOf Sl1l'e'h [COIitQ~li'JIt~, I' :SO!J'i"I':ht· 'to; iScmaim dte-il[' ·l!l!um"ber· and 'wIllen 'I ffiladl

iDl'""~ ~-- -- -'~ ~~ ._. ---~ ~"-',t'",~ _ '!' " '- '-"~ ,&!'JlJ .,,_-~ "_'~" ... - - . .. . . .. - I- . I ,". ,. -- ,,- ..

i!ll8!tisiactulily :s~~l1~~d in ~'h;~~, !by' rstaning, f~, ~, i,i~e prnn'C~p~.cj, :~: pm" ~~d-=-d ~:['fh- dEdu~d'omJ 0f: t~~~ c~c:~ms ''Wi~i~ITII''w:as Im.o'W'[o@f.itaim Well\e'Do,t

____ Irj,tl,_(i .. ,Cil , __ ...... ". , '!I:'-~,~,~,, l,~ ,,~_ ,,,,, .. l_~_,,,,_,, ...

krlved £iiIOm e~rle~oel' ,a8! HUmeJ had, ,a[tt~mpt.td. ito [~n,w di~H\ '~d,t; Sfpr..m,g

L--~~, ,..:l;'iiiI~ nt~~, '.'."'-:I"'<i' .. ,t~, .. ~-:I~iIi"i:Ii· [~1JitlM~~' "':If"iI\O,~[ In;JJIIII. UII~ l~·--~.'IIY- !W_~J.lJiI_ .. _~.I:li. _d,;,IlI_g_III_~_~}I ~Ji'"'J[=1 ,~ .. lI_g'l,;.l~

H'III_e .nd, ltarrn,t: $gttce tha:t m,et".ap:~,)is]tal pdi1lclp']JC's siucb its 'Me~e~'

[D!'<~:''r, [l-",i!il .~l .:: ~~TD;,r! '~'ili!Ili ,.".."..~: '~ii'i<li'II\!f,',;,o;:_ 'rii" 1 ,<lilijli;,~,~''''''t·:el"'''' 'W,,~.:Mliltli'rl'll~,~, t··.'IIt,;il!o

'"''' ... _HI:. illiL'a ill C:aJUJS!Iol iI ..... , ,1i1,V"," alcl_I_YIlO.,,,,,,. ,Iu u !I!IJ_IiI ....... _I'I', _!!;;o ~1"""U!-.I!!!' .. _uj"'.,U[~ ,_'_ili!!;;o

ptmi:eate; :is[ [oofiltiJ_b~,ed in, t:bJC COcl!ce"t Of ,the ;srmibj~'Cjt., A judgIrtel!!tt tha'~

'~i:- I~~ -'~~~n'~~~[~"\~ 'r'.-, :-~-:;-c (:~-~ ,~>\~ '~'~.' '~--,- c.iL.,.c .'~ "e;_] ,~ ":'i:,'~j'~l : :','1" [- -" '·I~b· ·~t"1

rs flat an3il,ytlc ,IS ~Jntililetlc., ,Iii; ,l1lot:.tap,U,slcal! c'I',~_nc~,,~es, ,L!l ,syn""J '-'"ie. ':_~JCw

'\"'re~;-:\~:c':ll:~IlC: '~'he;m [dffMl ,IS [deliin~t~nnS1 and ~ed'''''e ~dliS 'h[t}tm t'ibem,

W.caDDO ,311 .. ", .. " __ ", __ ",._.1",1", __ ,' , ,_","~~" ,_, __ ",~,," __ .,,""--""", ,~_

'b, the princi!ple of: e.om,t.mdlcl:iloo., Ther :mf!JlSit be demoinstfa:~9. :Out 'Ht~:~: .~. Sh ~w~,dJ, ,t'hat I~',cr~ ,event, 'bas· ,II t3I~se,r.i' oO'o'l,d, not be d~ri'vi!d,

, UimIl_e '. DC, L, ,Y'-..." ,,' " "'_" __ , __ ,,' , __ ",,' '" n, ~ ",_

:b'om [expeD.en,e_e~. Alt'hough :110t: alialytl~'t the :iilldgu~e:o~'t :m'~9[t H; a

n"";""'(p,;!' = "'"''f'-r--f~w'-:-;iil411-le~: ~~c;v 'ifti1iUr-'.i;:i, '~''''15~n-ijl, Tiijji; ~1..e~' ~:r;i'iI'~n01iii;d' .i"if:-': ~ri'iii"--" ,imii;il'~""'~~ ,:f"""~'4'-iIl,'" - l'iiJj1!UI ' .. " ,..,1) ID,t ,!If.!IiiI- ''!Ioi' ,11,"'& """'~iIO,;, .11011, [~I], , 'Iiui_iln.J'biI:"';t'W;!;il' u.: ~ .. [Wcl,[!Iil' ,iIj'!;,!IOi!l;l!!Li!;U:'c1ir.

'K3(~~ '"C-"~~~;d~~-'~ ~ .-~. ~ded de~~~~ -c,~' e c '-, 'i~dd' .' .,'- .c!'.!ief m" , ·.'Hit ,p.mVljes, '1:", e ,Ilee-', [_ .m.CU18{tE~itl!Gll- [o-.l"_e~lltbQn - 0.,;, [_-~e

;s,ynlm..eitic [til: p~~t)ll ,rinlm,ples[ 01 the U!nd.e'f5)t'andim8~' " H'idlrr.fQ[ :~,t ha, 'Me·n autJD1ed. thli1lt~ ,aU, ow' kmoW'le.d,s.~ :m,ust iCo_ml,m ~Df ij'bj:e~t'S" tl :msta(l" 'w1e :mlut, S!1l!p:pose mit i(J:D:joot'& 'mil)lS,t [c@morm t;Q.[ Qur' knowl,·

... .4,_, 'E!rl"Nil!" ',!!'Ui!O\O:>, .... ,""ft' '~I.. .... .nIll\U' .,. ~n''';'I ...... n' .... .c' 'iI<'~l"'nDC:: olli'!l,lv W" .'I,..',;:j,., 'Dr",", .... 1;~'II!'-,j!;.:-.;~""b;C! [~~!i ~~, ."~ ~~~ .~:~h~~j"""· ~ r'~~~~'~ ~-I. !L';.~._:~_~.~l :__:1J_LIl· 1" · .... ·,I:~.,l~l 'H'~ !U!,~~.~:~~,'IP.'~~'

:,u[t~ .mJt~1 '.mu 1., (C:I' 1~,v:i,=k,v,iii~l. :I:u't :K:aD'~~:S dedJuetion [Q:n[y' ]ieenS!es. [our use oi fb,e prinei:p:les, ,of !pure um.dtrs,t\Sndb~g :fnr clbjects [e'~' 'we.

dV'r:I;D, .. ,tlll'~"",,AI :~,:L.i':lil'I!'M[ ;;.'L"""., ~'l!1 ,;!,!;iC! l~'I'!i,L""n·~~oiI;'n\o!'i; 1~[ ~'.' [ .... ~~;C! 'RnliIi' 'ni~ii~~dliti! U-'-;i:!; 1~~.~~.!Ii~~~" ~)~~_~'jI! l~.nh:~)'l ~jI! ~:~l rJl-~- -~v."""'~~-~~:. .lJJLl g,.~~1 ,.H.~10- r'olo~'PI!J,III'U~ . _~

'With A jU'IHl!CI~ciG.n, for ,i(pplytmg ,them, to' ,t'hmg~, ,as 't'11ey lIe :m

,~Ik"'~'liilb'~Ue~';a =, ,;j.-n ,!"~'nn-~'iI'n'ii;"'_ri;iil "

LJII_llc'1.r.L-_~_'.I.'il!-!W_IIJ, "1I!'1 . ~1iJI!' ~ ~'U' ~:"r'U '!IiI_"'_~_~~~~I;Ar.

:kt this w,a;, KQl,t 11~cues tD,e m,ejtap.~b;fSJJcal b • .ils, oj' '[,),Q,tU!f.al setenee ,~~ 'K' -:__'j -""m·.-·I;iIi!i'1iiil:'r" !i!''I .. ~~t'!I,t~-''i'''~!ifiili'ri''l' _ 'O-n.'1Ii" 'iL ~ [d'~ ~!C, ii[!'io); ,""t 1l.·;~"'lt [oos,t 'to, il!;nGC;Ii~il:01it~_y.~

L~~Il:~Ii_i:ll ., l'-' ~'!ii!-~IL~1 ~A~r. ]~-IIA~,.L':_"~ ~_~ -~~ ~~~, ,~~-~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ,.-@I! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~-~ ~-~ • ~

',m[ .. '.iI<,-t<, "'i~'~u,ciW~;_ifi[ ~ ~:"''Ii'' ",'~ .. , 'ilfi""o1;d' ~+:~i_A'-::~:o1;l' '~-:"W"iin,.',.,cl;c, iifi~,' G,,', -, "',_'[.- . .;1 ,.- ',irm-: '-m; , '-"",.[ "1"", ;,,",~'ill";1if' : ... ; ... _ '-d ',~"")I!i""'i,",

__ .~~~;~t_:_tl-1 ~-lt~QlJ! ~f~~1 'Y_, __ ,,... ~~~, _~J,"~~~i9~ ,lw~~I~ ~J: ~ ~ ~~ ~_~~~~~~_bl~'I: ~=~ ~-~~

dom, ,aCR, t.uu:JeuniDoo~ :K.:aj'[t ba 'n,ot~ s'!bo,wn thl'~ ~hf!ille i~ ,rt~[ Goo~[ ~~~i~ii;"i"";'Ii;~~i~C'\.f' ,""11:' '~'iIi~.iI'"i""m.'_ C~n~: '~~i"1;..\"ii' i"',L1 ... illi', i'JI,.~'!Ii' thr~n''''!Qi :"Ii:r':I'!: [L"'~nd, iI:-h~

If_:I::I_~_Io_IBI..--v-tllIra_I~II!l.I~· U-.ll ll~I}~~- ;I!] WU~ I.H}U.:I,... .. IgJl~~ I~Jr~~ ~~ ~~, iYe" 'I!;:!I-~~ ~~-~

limi:ts, [of '~lbmretjea.'l 'lIode.n.t4'n:.diinl, Y~;t t'hf~.I~Ml~d, ~~}SWl!", in :i'ts :s~'h for '!ih~ U'noon.dJj;~iQn~, ,....;, f:o:r ~be [OOm:f:~~)t~n,~~ l@J ,i,'t!S! ,I'Cle(;n;rnJt~ ~f' '~hi. - ,o!lm,~ls 'M '~n 01, 'wh~t}le[ th~S!~ 'tbi'ng_s ,;u'le! I[~a1., H~ ~elsafii~, the ,open'~_ng :1 bles., ,or the ,Cduq~~l€i of P,ti1:-e R:e~!Slon t~n '~i\i' is! [en~,_Ju,~U~d, by' :ii'ts, :~t.~ t~[ ,~'k, 'Qiue~tj~n~, :~,t i~ unalbl,~ ~;o an$'w~r.,

Th~s~ ~~.c1~si~s, s~t 'lh~ pn;Jb:l,e:ms, ,(fir :K.an;t~~ :'li-..(:tic~1. phillG$¢lI'" ,h,. :F,irat,~, ,the ~ota] :rn:a,w it~H mitis-t, he; ,Ii :s-yn'd~.e)tcic a prl'Dd iPrili.-~~,:ple I~G, 4'W~l, I'fiJ;i as ,KaHil had, a:ireadly e:tDp:h;as,~~M, ];1), d~,e 'pn.~ essa,!:~, "The

Copy rig hted m ateri al

~"fII.¥ffI"II'.'~ll'''l"'''' 'W"L,.,~:'L,.I .,;'~Il """bili':'liI:!'~iIi''',~n ,iii" ,~n~"'~.:.d' 1"'~'" One .ti;UIP."}r,··~ ,;j"ifri; ,d; 'Ilil ,~k'~I;i2 ,~",,~~~~_~ ._:~_~. _ "_' ~~~[JJ, [~,~._: ~,__:-u.~~-:-.I.l!l..;.~1i .IHZIIJ !I..rA,~,",~i3.Iil!W J' _alii __:." _ Jw w~r~~ L Iri-~ iU IIj.JJ1IL'il!]

,i"'ii.' t: ,'I,.I;i'!lI~' "'I'ril;l:I' ]"",".";U\i:I; ,.:1:-- .. ,:,; ..... ,h~ ."".".h' ;:;",""".";41 '!"!\.:;,;;,~~ift.i!, .... il~ "'~t"" IP..¥ ~ :iP" ~;Fo:i~Q"".t:i~i'o ,oj; n~'~ ,;c;.r,p.:;.,:;,i'I~V v~, .' J~~JLl [~_' I 'cg .~~'~ ~ ~:~,~ ~'L-:-_-~ ~~, ,~iIJ,~U. ~!Wi ~_~ l' u~p'''J. J !W.IDI..i:' LI,~Iil~~_1.1.1 OJ ' - ~~~IJ}.l)j

,of tl~~ ~~ti(l~,~~' P?I. :i'l~8)" I:'i!l"t; ,a;lii. ow.P,'t :S~a!b~m,ei1l.t ~'ali;mfitr. '00 derivoo,

1.~"1'i"1>m..·' ;::I;'.~'.t'V'!!'"~;::I;.''''' "'''''J"'' 'W.' r 'L.~'f":.:L .', 'm. ';""jI!I;h.r ,;j.\;CI;II.I'.""", 'U~'."" L."£rcilU t-"4. '.~.np;",~ '''r;r."~''';' ."'.rifl,d:~;i2 'iffli. nit ,WJl,~\~~ ~:A,~-~~'~~"~~l . .'-.,O",~, ,II, I~'".I.~W.$' !I.'~iJ, r.:J! . LJI ~rlu'"' ,j]JIII~!~-a OJ.ll~~J M;I!O"~l ~IiJI!J lli.lIk!'!'II.,

n'.,"""li"l" ..:I"" ",;L,,,," 'I'\~U'~' .. A..lI 'n ;I:Ii""',,"C;;""~';j;,U' '~',;j;, 'm' c IfI;;',."j;, t"~,,:,,,,,,,,",.eiF>;Fo:i' b 'e~' '1 .. , ..... nUtfn ""I jj;F/I;i"fllr;ii' ,11'~:~'~·~1U.~1 ~~ ~I~~~ ,,~.L~Ul ,~-"~-~-~~~\I.!II.,i. ,~,~, ,I J ... _a.".~ .1~1"';'1IJ .... _Il}u;~J~W -.' 1IU:~~·~JI.L.ll W F-~:[iIl~"IIl:.j~lil

:Du~ thee: moral i!fi.ugrut; ,cmotd; 'be es~ailll~iS:hed ,I'D_ailydcal1y" The ,i1!tgnil:" :mtm,t &{rft th~$~ :~D the Secfjjltl8ec~jj~n ,of t'b,e G:liQ;undW:Ql,~; af m6 M6:tGl"r. .1ihF$:jt,~ of M(i(t:i(d~ I:Iy~,s'I~, :ptc'ts, UPI 'where the IlD'!e essa.y h~;& oM ~,2. 'Y~·;a:J;s '~j'~l\e" H:yp(J.tbetjjtal :~mpe[3!tive8' ~ p.rl;lt~d,p']ie:i wbieh :~_D_$truct 'Q~ t;~) d,Q ~ertar~n acHfims, :~f Wit 'WatU, certain, eads ~ aTe ,a'(~l'alfti"t. 'WhiUe

I;h"; "r' .. Ii'" ,: .. :, ;,~,. 'Ji l,cI~1 "'";"~'I"IC""' C'.'~ "'~C'i~;'" f.'~'~::~I~C' ,'1 '~k'rw ,-:,'~ "{·;71. -,'.': i~::-,l~I~'I""'~' ".'1'1': ,,;,'jk:,"'" :"1

It' 0 e:~:r Imliili.l~(~~ , c.{)(Ilte.nt cames !I;WIiII, Eli, ,ilia, e-e- 0:1; n_I~IUle tte',l.~cl_w,g us ~u~a,!I;, a,

certtain. ~~tcil).n, ,is a, :meaniij· 'to ~, ,~ert3iifi ejld~ d~e neooMilt,,' e-xpiyessed IJl" t'he. ~~'(J!ll!;ltt/.i!' lCflrn,e;s, ,i~rO:[f1 a, p:r:iDc~,:pI,e dl:lu: b~ an,a'i1tli~' ~~;f; dle will:::

'Whoeve][' w,~rurns d1.e ~n~ :SO' f~f ,as :rt:!;j9iG~ he, ~l:!li.V~ :influ.efioC~ un hils ,a~t~on.. Wjn~, .also ftt~ :fu~~Js,~s'abl')" :l1ecessa~ :m,eans to. ~~ 'tha!t, tie ,in. 'ih.is, ,~g.we.:r, 'Tfu:is, :PW:PJS~t~o~, i~ 'W~a!t. ~~~e~· ~he w,~ml~, :i~, ~a~.'V~l~al; ~T~ ~~ w,~.mi.~g ,a~ Qlbj;~~lt

~·.~I "~c~'C .-=t,£~'",j~ '-cC'~~ 1·"···~I,····'I.!i,"c:'.' ..... "',' "":'~C'';I''"'" ." ,., .... ,~ .. '~''ir .. 1:11"" ,·,··r "i'b~' ',' '.' ,"': ,",

,a~ ,my Ci~~~~j'tl ,m,1 ~aj~siilut:~ as all, ,3 GUin!G, C3,I)I~j' ,1"'!Cl:, tu:!I!i iU!i5e 0:, !!Leo ,m~,iI!Il~ ,Hil,

,aWr.'~ad,y' dlO'u:pit", and, dle i'm,e~:aJt~ve ,dei~:h!"ie~ dIe loo,ace~t of ~ecesw't.lf ,ac;tiCliti, t'O dd;s, :e.nd. ,f~r~m iI1be ~~~.Q~<t' 0I'f: 'w:i]lin,g ,thi~ ~iJ'fi;~. Ire· ,4]7)

'wnUn:g ,sCIme~ll'iJ'l:g b; d!e~ei[miDi~;s yo~rileU so be the CaJuse of:: 'miJt: ~11;~ng, w:bilc;h, m-eans d~t~.;r,tn:~lliing Y'O.:U'f,Se.U ,to 'use die a,Y,aUaible Cl'iUW, ,c.-nnnecJt;i(1f;iS - '~hei ~mea'i"IJS· ~ tel ~!t;, iWW:~Uins 'the 'el'ltdjN :i5, !ibudy ,posi!t:edi IJiI!l ii-he 'h1il'itVrfl:ltul~sis and 'W~ need onlv an.alvz;e it tOI iiI[iri~e at· wUU;n,p

[_.~ 1~.___:___. . ..2" ,~,,·,ltr-~'~~~-:_"":'-~_~_~l .~_~:_J~_' _. ... ::_ '~_._ .. _ .. J ,._1. '[1' . - __ ~'1"[-,., .". IJo' , _I, ..... , •. I.I ""':':~_._~

th··.,~ 'M'@".a'l'iJlS.If. If.'O'U w~U 't'O be a'b~e '~O nJ:s~' die nj;an<G" then 'V'~;U ~l~eadv'

_- .~' , ._'_.",,:,,'J -'7.' , ,._ J • ,-.~·-11· . __ J" ~.---- ·W"-- - ~· .. "-J.--- •• - .. "-lt'·

'win ,iIt~ 'I'liil'l!ctice: ,as ,t'hat is ,t'be ~!I"'~ndisfr\Pn8abJ'V 'ne.cesslnl!' me~,nlSI '~U' 'it,if.!'

_-_-_, _'_ ,~'_[_ '_"_- !._-'_I- .. [, , . __ ,. . __ . _ .,~-'i_ - ... l:!' _ r •••....... __ ~,,. [ __ .... ". [.J

t-~.:L~'ii> "l .. ~I:' '\ c. '~:I:;~'~"C 'nn';:-'~~"~:'" l\~" p~r.~: 'f,'~:- '"i'r"H~~I] 'o-fI!~'~!D!'h~: 'iiC, not "'lIl1'!lmiC'i:liJllid, !hu' ,::1

li:u.~'!I.'a!,e ,~n your ,r .... weL UUI~ "'~~'J:e. ,U1!,'!;,!''''',~~ ""Mo:..g~'''' ~.~ .I:"'~ __ ~ ~,I' ~

,~~",,·:,rt'~:!fl:-~ ";1 '~~~I~-c;:--cc~t~~-:-~, ,ou:~ cl!,u,des, h~ld ftlr us 1\G:~\~rdlGiSls I@f' 'wha't

,WO'. e~,C!a! , ,~m,pera,.~, . e, _I:" . ~ ... ~.... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '"' ~.~ ~ ~l#' ~~L ~ ~ ~ ~ "" ~~~ ~

'W~ 'Wa.nt., ,I\, m~~aj :m1Je does nj)~, ;~~'y.' l~dQ tbis H 'Y(l1)l, 'W'an't d~~Jt~or, bu:t - ;"nC' ') ~':'~ 'tll"do 'tb'19,~ ~7 It, 'WiS, ,ex"'\oofied in a cil't~"ericd 'im,'l'i'liEJ';3!dv-e.. F'C),JI'

sun,1,] Y ..' ... ~~, ,.,. '.. ,t",~~, = ·~~~~~e~~ ~~~~' '-,w."~~'~ .~~ . ~. ~'.~

r";I~t~"~"C) ~ 'dF' 'me; ~?~I!'[ '~a::-'"~ ;SIC~:S: '~bat '''f"O'·U 'lnuS't r,~"'~CIt: du~ ,ri~'~,t's oj: ,ID5.anoeJ' e , utI. 'W1 ._- ~ .. J ~ =~ _~I" ~ ~ ~ ~~~ _~~!L~ --

1·,iIi>'!Ii,.···"1 N,·.:·:·,-,·i.;t.]'",c]'~, .;'~I '"'~''''l~:~·A,:,'c '-C;:"-·";i!.·:-"d'~ 'ji\i;~'I.~]"iI"h~ . Iii"""'"". '1Ii"~iUin be "Ii'it'l"Ii'm'U'c"I~~" ~'~I D'",~~,ef;SL, " ~:h,[ililmg IS ,au:eau,f ,pOSJ,,,,e I nul!'"", ...,..u ~n'!;r, ' .. i!r '""u_(lI.~'''' ,,",~o, ,il-JJI!.

'he :r.cl',j~:e es!sa,' Ka!l'l't ,had, thDU(p,t~ dl Ii t: this meillll,t ,t'~~Jt t'h.e :mQt:al

'1N1II'~'nl""~n,l,;J:lo ;I'!j?'I'~ll'~ ~i'[I)n:iit: Le~' ,iI!j;~lClit";"j;L~l';i2:t..t:iIA" T;;.'Jf~lIiW '~;ti! iAl'}'i'i ... ;~liti,~,~ii:i.~, l~''i'ri'!i),+''''.PcII~I, ii:l..,"Ii'IIi', ,~"~~~~-~~'Jf- ~ ~!YI~- u[ "_lIIcU~ [IJI . '-r.~:._ ... ~Ull _1iJI_J);\.i'WI'll ~."'!I;!U,." 1_1r,- ~~l-_ .. ~w'~U"-!iJ! [_lUI_'_" ~~g_r~ ,J~IR~

!'iiL;!;!, .... ,0'Ii'.\~P'Ii'!i!F.il .... ,~ll1'.m".~.~i";t>-if~I~"i''ii!\e~' ~,~ e~~Itii'L~~+~I"" ,.ii' ;":f'~'i'1i'iI!';i" and re i1Il~ld,ii:'I'i'~, ,"Ii jV:,d'~~\"

l~~:t:~ ~-ig['-j~-D'~!.I.,IJ~~- , __ ,~.!l.LIJ.UlII_ Y·i. &;~ ~l/·~_ .. I .. _lI)}!lr.I'=-IIIr'!ir.' W ~"'j, .. J~-.IIi,"iil[ A _ Y J.'!Ir.-~.t,,",_"_~l'!i.-~ Ai ._.'-~

..!I ." U 1,:.'k 'L. - .Ai - d "~ ~ .".' ~ ~ ,i.,i.." .". ~ ........ b~-'I"h"· ~.Ai tt.·~ -~~~- .*.'1 ~ .. /.' t'l!..

'!UUC~'H)'n/~ ,Ulie tne ~e ,uctl!il):D IUl1a;t. eSI~, \I;~S ea tne 'pctl],]OJ"lh,es. o,,;',I!Jie

:pure 'iLiilde:rs,t'and~ng' :£01' the :f:eamm. oj~ 'eL~perien.Ci~,

The ;seo~:rtd 1'1~~~1~: ,~f '~b~: Cl.itdi~~e; 1r!Jj' Pu~ ,!R~~:Slon d1~.~~ '~al'$ om, ,-::~~h\:-S'IOOI'il~mi$; tth~ ,i!S.'SiIIl~S, oi s~nla.t:j!.~te :m@:'t3:"h.~8i,ClS::: Goo., ,fr.eed£lm.

i!;;](_ Ie,. .c_ ... -=" -- ~,,- -~ - -- _,!!?,"O''''''. -~- ~ .. ~ ~ ~~.t'" iJ - .. - . 1

Copy rig hted m ateri al

II

and, immfi[ii;"a'lit,y~ As, ,I!beiil(ly' :llIot:edl" KaJ~,t CQi.ilJcluded, 't'~a)t these ~uuld '1:01; be (~~~~~m of 'ii'benre"t1eai 'knOfl!vi~edJg!e~. If) ia:c:t ~:he~u~~I:::-c;t to deeer-

,n ,Ie uJl'L , .. , ,L" .. ". " . ".jI,1 aemJJi ue r

m:hle ,,,i~,emejr 't'IJi,C:J' ,WR: :reaUtles, ,~,i,vies :O[5e in arf1i,tiJn~mi,~s;: [ap,piil'R.[i,d,;t eq,waU,}7' good. ,a;~meDt$[ iOn beth :5:~,d!es '01 the lllUiestj,01J", 'Ih'C :mQS,t~ i'iDitlipltt"8/n:t o:~ ,tihres.e", [c~nc~img ,f~me(lomi wUl se:nrlf; as ,am, as.'rn:pte., PreedfiUJ" as Ka'1l1~ 1]fiidef;$unds lt~, ]LS[ a ~pe(ia_l kind, of' caJ~sal~,ty ~ :G;n't fir :i1,PJntaneous calu~ali~,'j wncondj:ti,ul1ed, !by ,atil., "tiar eause. [OnIC nla,y' argue dr..a.t there earn 'be no :RfSt C3:!Jse,1 on the [~nn,~f:.ids[ tl~:a!t: :w,t WGu'ld cfiti~at.e the rule '~'ha.t e\]!i~ '~Y'ent 'has. ,~ cause. On d.'-, [J~'b ~.-:

. .. I .. " ., .. , .. ".... .. ~ ,.. ". i.. ...., . . """':I .. ~ ., ~, , .. ~ _. iii, . ,u. .. . ~,~ I .. ~ ,ie 0' ~ . CI

hand" tU"U~; m_:a!.y. argue t'balll: tbetf.''el :IDUS~: 'be a Ir:S't ca[1JJ.iS'e~ ;s:~n}~i ehe s,u!fl\h~:L~ent eanse (1f. ,3,'~.yt'hi'n:g M'!J)St ~l~d~ all the ~aiUJ~$ 'tlha.t: 'hoa.v.tei 100, up '~O ~tt' and. (b~re c~n he ~() :8ilW~Ic:j~wrIt iCJaluse if th~rg is an ~i_ttG'liidte r~p~5'S [~A...4f4'=5:~Lm4.'7~1=8o[J" Cb.:d5,ti~.n ,Au,ps,t CmS(bl!lS ,I I ]",1: 5 =1'5 i~[ 3, 'i~tii9,t cri.ti(;. [(1rf 'W~Ul: 'w~,om, :Kant ~,dmi'l\OO~, bad. 'w:r.it,t~lll aib{1t:U)!t ,th~ ~Wl;til1ijJ~iS';!' ap,p~ilU'ng '~~ ,tb,~m as, ~vid~~~e 'elf tl~~ .Hmi:taJ,ti(1ion~ [~f Ih'~,,,, Dl~n r~~ and. ,th~ :~~~d, f(1f,F.' lIiJi~nQ~ CL~, £'aJi't'b, and ,~1'1ij~lt,i.lJJ]j,.~f~ KI1i~.'t n~w li~~l,VI~ t'be atl!d'~(imi~~ 'lttf' a,,~al ~o' hi~ difStbt.cti~.n 'It~~t:Wi~~~, ,no.u'~~~!1, ,;J~.d, "b~no:m~n~, '1'b,~ ,a1l,ilitino.mi,{lis[ sh(JiW' hi]iw :im~n_.t~ milS d~5:tin~tio:~, i;s~, £o:r.' w:~,thO'~lt it ,~;))SQ:~, mrus:t b~ ,s~~n as gi'viIg;g nse hll[ oontradic,t~i~s and :sik~,pti(iis:tm, 'wiU b~ ju~dO~d" I'~, ~m~ (;!1S~S,~, th~ ,ai~tbto:rnY' is ,s::eli!U,~J.a;~ed, by 3, ~orct of ~qrlJlhroca;ti,Qn =. ph~nQm~na ~re tJlea'~ed ~:5, U~ t'b~J' 'w~re :~Q'~;m~naf. and ooth o:f 'th~ [;J]'pmel,il,t's ,iJir~ £i1I~ ~:,A50'~=fVBS3.]=j4J" :tn o~b~-l" '(iilS:~j! :~.t 'trc,U,~:5, a~lt tl~.~lt Qlil,~ oj 'L~~ ~rlU'''' :ttI;t:nts, :5$ trnue of ,p:be:n(lmeoo~[ 'wbile the Qtb~;r ~()'~ld 'be tm~ = ,al't'~fl,'U:gb. 'we: do mot ,kn~w' tli.a:t :it is -. '1)1' :ll(Jlilme~i'I,,, The an;tirt~~y' [O'f Heeoom, ,t'lkc.s the laue4" ,f>Ottrl:i,. :10, ~'h,e :pibreThG1tmenal wor:ld, 'beCil~se it ,IJ8 '~emptl[4:1 ,I'fiid, [t.a'Il!SIU.ty :~;s te{mpo:rai~, ,Sl:1Jl.ccessl,~nl, aoootdlm.g: 'be ,a lUlle ... ,C'V'e~1'J [e'\ife~Dlt: :hIS, j;l, esuse, ,Ilid '~:be]Ye Ca'" be :~,o :b!eedo:m,. Jut ·t,!be

-, ~~~-'" ~ ~ ") "'"Ii' ~~ld !ill - -" ~~ -~, ~~,~I~,," ;~ ~; ~~ - ~"~ d ~ -~ ~ ~~,~ ~"~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~~~ - ~1·"~C"

:l1InU'm1eH!3!" WQr J .. ' DeS 'nut ex]:st Hai. U'me ,iiU1L. a, Sipu:nU'in,elUliI8[ !C:aius;a :d.y

'1;8 possiiJ111,eJ, ·~Jh"C}ug'ili, 'not :kF!i,~waib~,e~, :in ~t [~AS 3,6J=4~lBS ~14,=69[~1.

This 'Iew~ea 'lOOm ffir beHef In t'lle f'medom of ,t'he wUl Wihl,dlli 'IS[ ·t~e

[ _, . [ ,- ". -. , . • ."' .\, - . I. _ " . " , .. , _, ,". I. __ ,. , __ ,. ". __ J .. '" . __ 1 1_. __ "_'

:i.OUll,dlalLfifi. of mltf'i.H:t:y fAs 41=51/1[5 70=16 ~,;, As, Wit 'w:iU. rse.'C1, :fmedo\lD, 'fif: me 'wiU is hn,pO:rt.a.:fi!t: tD[ :K3iGi.t: fiot merely ~O;t" 'dlle ,latmiU3iif :lessCln, 'dlat 'we 'cl'mnot be held loo(tuwJtaJble ~~f 'we ,il'l'le lUl!f ire,:,; k~,t beeause :it: pll~Yidtl's 'oock 'tne~ O]fUent [ill: mn~a]jty' aM, i"~s, mu~:i'~"'e., KiiI!~lt: uiU ask jinaw' wll1llld ,3, b'lte 'wiU wi,m :IilDithing ~Or.is;U;'31h .. !ffing or gIl'h:iiing,~.t dete.{(,~ :mine i,ts, :aeUon:s:~~' and :Ile w:ill. [a'rgu~ ~ha'~ th~ ,mSW'ef :~~, i'j~blY' the ,mO:I',I'~, br,w!J' {Cl 149'1", Tbjs selves ~[he :p:.l'tQib[le:m. ·$e~ b, ~he ,lft~~inQmJ'~' ahh~ugh,

"""'-~I'y,·, f,"."'zym.· ,i§ "' .. 1II'';!I' ..... 1·[''"':~'111 pi'!ii!II.D'" ;i"'illi: '~'·1·[,gi~ Ei .... y '~~,~lo:!~n' l!I.;'l;,~·.jI!i ''''iL.'''i!ltt-. ,.,'Il. ... ,"'i_, 'ffiI!I;.'U" l!i'l\' uf..Dlll.·, .il.U"' II, d Ir,.,la1_~!I,I;" ~IJ, ,¥~I !I,I; y-,f. '¥ ~''l'T0i .Cu.& ,lJl~" ,a-_d· '1;1] !loW.lIllLl !lo1lJl~_~,'W> ,LIHI, _ ~~ll.l.l

- ---." -- - -- - , , - - -- ~ - - '-~ --- - - . - - - - - - - - - - - -- - --." ~ -- ~- ~ ~ -- - - - --- -- - -

Copy rig hted m ateri al

be an 'iJn~:used [Cc.s,iJse :~n 't'tJe ,tlQ'Um,f'cna1, 'wnrld ,If ,m, un.co.mdi:th:ma1 ,~xptan~,tio:n, ,of: Ute p!henomena. cln '00 ,~,~en", U:nle~s 'there :is, sueh a,

,iI'!:o!i,~liIi;':!"'" ,;j.'lloe~' w1il'!lipL~ is n·;rjIi;j. 'LiV' :i';~.e. ~!i!o\i!lln,1I'o:!Ilr~liC!' [;r;;.;~ h'·''I'!fm'OIII111'I .-.;oc"!;~"""1I!I; in liI",,:,:I~'ililll!i,~ .... _Ol!lllll_~-~~J ,=IiIII.. . ... u\llo· Ul , ._~I •• ;U!Ii..~ W;J I • .I~ ,~l-'~~&-W_al_1 ,\i_I;;)! ..t", ,~, i:WJII, £~~~~~-~1.J I _ .,1 ,1 .. ~_lI~~

'b:Je,,, $peculative tnOOJlet"icaJ ~~1l.r. :htJwe~erl' !Cannot tell. '~5, w,hat '~Jl'~S ,ca,lliIse: 'WO'l1!iild 'be. Ptllc~1ical :reaSOill~, i"m., pril)iVid)~ng '~S, w,j:th, 'tne In,oral ~a,w:r [ms,wer:s[ dus, q,iIl.i,esti~n. This,. a~co:r:d)~ng '~O :KanJ'tl :p'llovid,es, U'S 'with ,;9. ~~'cle:de~i'tiaJ:~~' :ffir be:~iev1Jng iE, the lIooUty oJ: the m,O:tallarw~ and, 50,:in '~'he :h:eeil,om, of' O~f ,own 'wins, ItC:!; ,4,s}. [Once Kant [disoovers 't'ha:t~ ~hae ~s ,3. mor .. l 'basis :t:fi:r 'beU~f b~, tie ,f'reednm ,of 'me 'win~, ,he: uses t'ne :sa'me met'b,odj, tn i'~],OW dii,t t;bere :is ii, :mG't;a'~, 'Ilmsis far 'hU,<d: :in GOO, and ~mnul(['tll:i.t;y:"

The 'V,~,ew,s sklet:cb.ed, ajoo\!'~ ,Sl're not Wio-t.k,ed ou't ~n;tH lCa.n,t: w,ri,'t-es dIe

C:~r;i:"~n~j"", ..... ~:n:r; ... \ ... ~~ ... ,~I':Q:Q""'n{fL'~' tI" 1,.,~,~!'i iD~U~'ii, Afir ..... r:!ii ~'~iiif!;t.," fiI(i",~:4~i~"'~d'· .0!1 'r:!!'ir':o:~~"

. iI."i~_;&'iUJU U~J ,C·,oI.'IIiI'li.HUIIrlWi_i!Il. ft!~WLJl!~1l_". ~. u- D~}:I ,~ .. !II. I=W_ ra .. A_ .... H.,. J [~'oIo1lNI ... ~IIIr.- . g] ~tl ~,.J

bOO:k, desctiileiJ to 'become ehe main t-e:x,t: iG:t: '~b;e s["rt~dy of: hts ethr~c.s! me [G:rQ~ndwot:k' of :fhe ,M8ta:pll'8jj~ af ,M:ol;alics I~:~ 7'S S ll. 'T~e p;ij'!pOse cf' ,tb.is 'W~I;k: is, ,~~'the seaeeh lUI ;and es'tabUsbrme~t: o~f' ,th,e s,u:plleme prin(i·, n,l, e [ryi, ~~;:1i(l'a·.'~ll"~Vc~~' ~[G~', ".i!!itI!~'iI"~1 'H'_·I'~'~ 'n'~I,o:'If~ ~,\olIliC!' ~'h:.t:I!"'1 t"~[ ~~,iit;!:l! ;:!II M:' [';i';io~~i~.:"'~.~'~"""!i "",.f. r· U~· iIo~"tU'olo._IJ IlII.lt ~. _ J!,;, .... ~. , ,01/~ ,~\WIi:ili~lb .. 'I!1'P.' ~_~ l", - !I.r.ldll, _~ ·n·,~";I.~1U [~, . ~ )~~~.~\'[J'J' ~-~~ ~l

,Matil3/:S" rn, XOiot's t~mn:~,()gy1' !ii, ~~'critique" i'n,~,esti,ga,'t)e~ the I,egid·, njih;j;jio'\of' ~ a'''nn'l~'n'p' 'nl·,C·il~I·''''' r·ciiI'it-iill'!iri;!j;'ij n(l"iln·");fo~n'~I":"Q, ~1i'fI\d:: ~~I:e~·~r· "'"0:" n,r,",.,.·~;j;if' to ;f'I;'b-'·,

iIo_I.!_II_IIiIIJ'?ir.l T '!IoiJ; 'It'lIf'' 'If ... -.-~ f''IIII_- !w . ·iMJ!Ii_~tU;"""':.1 It''';&,~r - !Ii.'".Lr..JlJt'?lIniil! ·0.;&.111 • 'U~~ _LII·· ~-. lJ_ilt~""Jt;~·""a "",. 'Ul _.

~ectsw 'whUe~ ta, #:me~.~p:h:'SJI~Si;i se1$ ta:[th dlioge pri"~c.ipJ.es and d],ei'r

j-i· r[,l''"',''/'·[ -\, Tfrr·' 'Tb"N .$'-:"'( .. -[·1 ,.·f '~'~ .. G:~"~·",:-:,,m·'~:-::'i [;C'" -:-"C:'t~'-CC"[ ," de-

~m'\I,C;Il\JIOctl~t, ",c"e ,,,L .. , . e.Ct1M 0\, Le-~lQ,Il_IL~I" oonta:~ns ae

d\JI.'''''','':~'':···['' ,· .. ·f tl~f··· c.:[ ..... , ..... ~.:.'~ l· w : 'c-. d ', ..... ' 1:. [:' [i:'-,t. C~'.[III."-·' [·"f~ : ... ,--c"." . .'j":.',,- .. al 'iC·.·"T·'-:jl. '·'i""

~lU~'LO~ 0; .... e ,m,~l'a, . ,3'" atli~ so ~S a, c;l'U_~q,~ 0., l!u~aC1uca , ,r;ea:sUfi.. at,

",L;iIi! io' _ili!, LiJi! ,w·" .,. .... ilfiCi! tb ... e '1i;~\Jl'iIii"Il,., 'jIi..u, , .. ;Il.'ii"iii;~ ... 'ikt· 'j;iL "'t j;'h~· "'t '-'·"""Y ~1" d~" 'I,.;,.. '-ii'i'~

L~_[~~ "il~I~~_I~ [11l'~ .~. ':II:U~c'_; ',_l~wl~ L""'~Ij;I~;~ ~I~ "_I_li~~~_ill" 1~_~]_(iII;.· l~:' ~ _-AI;,' WuiUJ_- J ". ~ S;y._L"~IIr.'

tlent:, later; be saw '~;ha't '~'be~ mfifal1aw 'Cie-tl~cl, be validatte.d in a diffe.fi~

'l!:5!lt W,"''V- ,"'nd 'iI-'[i1 ... , .c-;,;ry:t·~[n~:3\ti! ..... i:- P.t·'.i"ii"".f~"".i"i';~' ,jry~\;I!ji~~n[ 'iilU,i!'iI,il!! ,""1..'ii:>; Tj;ii"il!!j'~I~'ii. :~,y iD'i'~I!'"

.~= ~ ..... ~:''1 ~--~ ~~ .~. ~~ ~~ ~ l~~ v): l.""'l I""'l K~4_"f~H_~; InIlfr.iH~;~L____.' '!!!T-" W~ ,,"_[LI!r.1 1.11!r.e.~ll~-~1 Ullilf.l~,

we m.1ls,t; "rlliim, t:iD[ the Gj'JO:i1~d'W"fit:k' Sind, ~he ,Me;~'~\phy8ic~ of ,M:Oi:t3'1s' tlO! ,I,tt the :s:ubsltanoe of :KD,t~~s eth.i,C$,.t ,~:Ol" b~, the second! Gliti:q~ule; dle: :pli(i"!!'I)lem, of V'IU.d.ilti_ tlhe :morallaw and, mow,mg, ho[w ,it H,ts hlit'C[ ms ;syrs:tem, !Su,,'~3i:n.'ts Ka:t'cs :~n;tereS,t in its fOlmJ,r.da'tion, and, a:,pH,y,tioll,

:Kanlt~~[S, ,method ,m, ,the Pi.f;st Secti,Oll, of the; [GrO'und'~lk lil an.alytii~;~ :h.e, 'utes, examp:Wes[ :~D [O'fdm' tDI :a.niI!,y-ze: ClU" o:~[dinary' iCOJ1ce:Pt~Dn [o.f: ,I, good 'w,~U and ItD[ amive a:t~ a ,f~n~lJJ~a,t~on, of' 'the prin,clp[te [0',0, 'wbioo :~~cb ,I 'w,in aets, A. [good, 'win is, elisll,y' dis,tl!fl:gti'JJsbed ,h:tlnl ene tba't aets :&~;n;l an indirect: iFii,cHna'~iiil)n\li dC[ilg 'dle :.t: th'~ng merel, as, [it :means, to ~m,e U~;tle:ri(lT' endj, ,il 11!~t6sh. p~5e~l,iJ' The diUlcul:t t'h"mg: :is, te clliJI:~i'D;gr(IJ8h ,I good w,Ul ttt;m, ra, 'wiU, tha;t has ,a ~~'dl~I\ec~t :1.ncJim3i·'

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'li,QD!l '!'#(1J do, so.m~jt'h~Dg: 'tM,t :is, his, :i,'t ~~,f~ns~l ... ~.,t ~G~ ~"7ff, ~'!' JQ:{' :insctmlJOOj (hfiR: are P~QP~~ il~Q' ,s,y,mp'aJlt-h~t~j,¢~.nf ~QFilsdJwt~d (h~lt w:~,tlm:,-,

,c 'iii; '." ,- "ii;hr' ,t, 'V ' .'iIi' ,or '~'1:C' '~ -,~ -, ."Im; ~ nn..al an iiml '-- '1:' [~, ,;j;o'~, f-,

OU!,\, ,IJiity ,mJ)'!J,6'~'~' -(b_:;lrn_,~!!.\y Q= S~~!IL.a;S~d't~ ~~fl'y !IJ!!IW,_~ ~~, ,sa,,,,,lSu1Q-,,,'

'ttCD b~, s.piiuiJ'ing jny" ,:iimd ,rejo:~,ce i'm, 'dl,e; ~~il,tJenttmGmJt: !OJ ,o:dt~ts 'w-b~,eJh ,t'h~y' h8ive :made :poSSn):~,e':!!~' l[G, 3[98'1.., Ha,\1',mg: iiil :naltUitai, :~lI!cl'mart-iJ@n 't{J[ do w:lul't [c.g.inc4dtes with !Clbl'ty is[ :fitat~ tl1e is3ime mmg as aotrm.lt; :hom, dut;'l :SD far cJla:mI:ty '~e m.1l'St. conu'asl tIhl,s, case wl,d~, one w:~,el:te the [d,'tu" :~s[

,.j - -'~ - ~ 1-· ii- - r' 'T .... :~~ h-' .;il r"

ufime W.U:I,iIOU,'1! :ns,twf:s, mO.ll'niltl,om,;, ·,iidJKJii: soml,eome 'W ~.08e mIlia :~S[

1/ clouded, 'by a, soufi-w oi' his CrW;m, 'w,hi.c'~, er<tln,gu-lrShe~:lll1U s,y,mp-a,tb, wi't'h 'dle~ lot. of: othe[s:~~' ~i" ene 'wko is, ''''by tCDiper-a:mem,t: CQ~,d ud

,ji'f],.jil~'~itir~;i::iI'ftfii<' .jii'il; ii'h~ c,~ p~-,U"'r.":h'ilIP,s'" .-.~ ["", .. ;i-.,~,"" i.~, lr- '::i! iIJIl;i!iI'-, ~,t [C;'ii"U"';I-., ,;j; n~r,c."fIin 'ii"" l~_ : ;~: _1l1}~_ ·'!ir."'&-_IUIl.· ~-u l,_- -_ ~ !iJ!iUII]~ILMI_"'_~-ci v.,Il: O!lr_[~~~lo.l ~IU.' ~li Q til U ~~~_L]II. !iii] Ir".JI1~~~ll l~_~

G~vmrheleS8 1be:Il,elJ£.~f:J:ti it: :miUllst be from :ai, ~, wUl. 'Whlillt :i'S t-he prlneliPlt~~ [QIiiJ~ 'wh~~h he or ;s·~~ ,;tcts:l' We see, 'G:f:S,t~ 'tiha,t sueh ,3], pe~n does his or her d)\uy '~I~~,'t '~rtts:~ 'it is b'ffi~, [001" !h,~r dur11,y, :FUtth~J.ntO'J'[~ri' 'we see dLat 'wbar~: maik:e~ Ildm 'O:~' l~br do it - ,ar~d ::90 'wha't makes :it: hr~~ Oil' :liIer duty' - is, not sbn:ply ~~ts ,utr.p~, :F'm' the~ :1l!~a'l!Jur:all:~' ~s:"mpa'" 1d!r.t~tic, pe,1S.on, ,iIIlld. 'dl,e '~M~PiJ;~~!betic, hut b~,~~ac~lljt: ~~-l',snn OO~'[I~ ba!v-e; rhe :sl:me :putrpose,j :heJlpi'wg 'otbe,'[':s", ,although one has ~itdsr P;Uf'" P()S~ ~G~lU!~ o.f a, [dlir~:¢,t biu;;:Un;lti~ft ,mdi, '~'~~ [~th~f' hiiJS :iJt; :&.[~~, [dl~lty~ ,I~dl aire: e:Q~t__qst~, 'with dl(~: sd...lib, m~n w'h~ d~~, th~ I,ilb:t ,thins for' ~n '~lt~dor p~j' sueh ,35 ,f~r (J.f.' pu~i:sibroe:~,t~ il)l heJpe [(1rl r~w,a!~d.

D:u,t;y.~, th.ell~, is :oolt :3, :ma:tiier r©.f' ,h~lv,ing, oerttiibl putpm:ses. If 'we :r.e-

----:-,:- ;:-C:l- ,~U '----:-~-'-,C-;:-;;:~--" -, ,= ,<rn1 '~,,:-,~-:-:-,/,~'I = h-; ~'1-:--'h-:-: -;c ,:,~'U. '::---:-h,~(;- 'k-l-::f[-, ~;-r, '-'h::-' m{JV1C a ,.' pU~8 Ii,· ,mate:113 , .; .0:(1] t. e w,~ .. 'I w, .; at, ~5 , C .il, 18 Ii:,.e

f:~.nl~ai_l, prln~liP:_[e: ,o;f tk~ 'will. The ~Qo~, 'I'~ne--i:p]~ ;of d~:ty' :ilS h!)$.r't Lh!1lt it: ~jS dluty' - tbaJli: It: Is ];a:W'~, The~ 'ess~~ttira_l ebMa~,t't.-1" 0] la:w is '~ll~vle:rsaJ,,, it' Tmif[ ' .. '~h",· w'b"t: b II dill!' li~)tr~nlk t, the 'ii c·i'\\!i..::r"", ,--,[,y,", ere ,me" '.It; pelrKlm, __ "~JJ ,iile:S, ,AlIiiO,_[lJJ, .. y ~~~~_:O , ~ .. ~ ~n_~_ ~

saUty (If :ms/h.er :IYJin.c[pt~, He [01" she [!lnl'y' ,a~,t~ i);1'ilJ, ,;I m~'m th~lt; he [~[ she [ootitd, 'win '00 be a u1]!i:Y'emal ~iifW' [G, 4<O~\ll" In ,t'hi~ 'w,i);'y' Ka;liWit ma~~s[ &o:m the: ~~,d.el, 'miJIt: ,31 goed w,j]l, is, ,O:I];~ ,It'h-at irets &om diu-tty to a, p~liici;'" :plei thalt can be '~s.ed '~O '~eU us 'what [0U!f; dOrt]j~91 af.-e.'i:l!l

In ehe 8ecMd Se_~tio:f-J; :Kil~:~ reaches t:lle ,Sarfit'lt'eJ P();~_Ol 'by a_~!uItJ~ef; ro.U'~e:; the i'1,["v,~sltipltion of ,ralti~[lJ~I, ,a;~ti~n. !~IVI~[f~biQI tn :n::a:t~re 'w-or:ksr ;fJ'¢cQ:"m.g ·tn ,la,W:8,,, [a,m" ;s, ~a;ti~nal 'k±rn,g; :bras, tbe cl,a!~it;f' o:f

- w h ", f ] m' ~"

,a:ct~lnl ,aoofijF' IDg t'O t, ~'e c.o:~c.e"n~)jt O:':8,W,5,j I~" ~a't :IS~, ~lcctf,;rlf:.il t~[

,t\'~'i'!il;i!'rieinl ... ~,j~' [~f;"'!, A 'iii' '"Ii. ~- ~,_ i'iTi'H';';~'ilrii11.,. t,·'Il..;o'Iir~' 'Vf;Y!lI'Ii ~---*.J'i!i; "1i;"io '!IlJ!\i"iiIIIliii'i[j\O,"li:II~ ~,'I..,"",i; ''''\iN~;~1 ,~'J!II~"_'_r.,..-llrlt~'~l ~u' ~ L'J ~.~~ ~IIJ_~~ r~l~~__!,_J'~.!'lrt_'~ ·_lJll~l!l!' 0' ~I~, l~~'''' ~ L~l ~. !Y'!~.~[~~ I~LI4I~ ;.J ~~,

... ,i"~, .... M 'iti'" ,""'''''' f" ""'31- :II: '[illr ;i'Ii, [ti'_,~''Ii!'i:,;t,¥I; il '~:n.1i'I(r' ~'''iiy"!ji~1 Kl!i;U' ,l!jil' ,;i"!\"",,,"j~"r~'n ''U'~'lil'II' '_,"II~;o'!iiM; ,~_~~. y_~ ~__Jl" ~. ~·lI,,,, [~ ~lI~~·"-I_HIII.I. ~ I}~~ ~~~_~, ~) _:_~~~ ~~~l~i_d~_. J ,,. ~-~ .~~~~y.~_~,

,fel' ,ac~ion:; ~~,t ,mu!St sa,)!' 'w'hlt Y'DIl. ,ar..w Imog, '~D do" ,and 'w.bsr-;. :~'f y,our marx!JN. i5, '0'J1~: (h.;illt; i"~: is :~alti[O'J:1)I'~, to atilt; Qn~, ,i:t :.ee,t'i "nl~n 'test5~, [c~d!s ,rtf. IIUSon exp're~, i'~, hn.pera,thv1e'S. Yi:inl,r actcioD :mU!s!t be ,I

Copy rig hted m ateri al

me~n'S t-.o yo.~u:[ end, s:r.td, [~U:mllc88 ])t: :~s :moTaJl, f:~,u:~[-ed) 'YioU'f:' end :Ri~Sit

'l..:;. pnn. ·;i!:"I~.!i!'t'''''':Fi'!i' 'Utii~1'·fr·.i4 'vif!l'i'i'ii'l 1.. "'"n'fi:W"·'C:'. ·~i!i'1iiJ 'y .. b. ·"'!i!'e~· ii."",,f,Ci, ",:lie·· e~·im;. ·'~~"'J!;I.:;.d··1 .;]].. ..'1- ... , ~IJ~ ~V,I.LlI~ -1ij!~.:~;u]J.1 '!'J.1f',' '!II.~I ;;r.:u ... ;JJ • .J1iII1F,r; - - ~~aalli ,', ,ILlI/ .... iIil!· 1.,.ni:;l!I.:SI llIiUJ.. I. ~I.L~~~~ ~- ... ,lI' I l-.Jl~

IlWu' kind'S! of' :hyplJd~etical :impeiil,t"JJ.ViCS,. ·tn(Jse of rfikiU. and, :pnid~~e. B~Jt ,t'h~e j;$i also [~. i'm~;a;t-ive ,th~Jt 'beIJ15 ·~s[ Yi~~Jt we :~~lj~S,'t (tQ" .. r~prd.·, leti$· [(iI.f [I)U[ :p:riv:a't·e p.u~s,. This :is, die .mD];a]J. [O't.' ~aJt;eg(lrical :iQri.,e:ta.·· t~~.Vte, and b~}:cl.1"\lse it~ is :kt~pe:m,d!eIlJt on aU .ma'~eria1J' w,~ :b.(I'W 'tl~:a.t~ '~~'dl~l~ .is :~,oith~ng: :mm8!m~l: :m. U ~oe't 't'~e ·Ufiri¥;e~U,. (If: :Ia.w as, 5:UcH. '~(J. 'wib'i~h ,£'h,e: .mii':rlm. '0] the a.ct:i();D shnu·~d. ~om'~Jn]JLQ {'G· .41 ~,. I~

~·m·:i:jFi. ~;4.:. ·~tDlii't1' ·~~~,nl ,;fjo' ,d; i:',;jI'i-";>;iHr~!;f!,,,,·li [l'·il"frif:ii.:>',T''''t:l~.·1i~~~ W.·. :je~' [..,.."'ril .~~·jl'i] ~;h: 'S·iiil".'iIi ;<;r;:;'I"\7'';'''' ,I~ ,.~.\III.J.U 1ll]~!Ii.r Y.·i~'r/' ,IIiIW~ ... ~_J:!IiiIl ~111~.,.~'1111~~_JJ., _L~II_;&Jf'IIIPr.ll!liilf .. '!r.'~ .. "_ ~_LIi '1-III.r_II_I.L II. .. _ ~. ~ ~~'rr~[.J

,f,~,A("t [finly 'ilc.onillli;:ng: to t'lul'i;, :marxim. 'by 'wh~,c'h, 'tOU [cat] ~l't ·the ~e tiv:~le ·c.·riH th3lIt:'-t: ,s·h~~~·ld. Mcume ·~.lWli~~v'e:na·lla",:,",rt [~G·2,1· [C:~ 1~·~ .

.. m, 'W\ .. , ], r'lJU , a_~, , " .. w ~ .. 4 ' ,' .n'

'Iii! t, '~Il '.... tho iIi...~ ""1['] •

,uut: n;O'W' ean "'Oil. ~el. W,tie,c' .eJ' you .. I_m i~hi~e to 'W.H , YO,UI' ·m_I'Xlm. ss Q,

'Ull!~venml ] aw'~ Olll 'Kan't':s 'neW' (t '~iS[ a. :ma'tl:er -of: whl·~. ~ou car~ ·c.·riH

. Il~. 1.- lI_.~~ll .. l_ll l •..• l. __ j1,ll.l~_. .·.~ .... -l ._. ~_l ." ~ .. _'.l ••.• __ O]Wl __ ,

MtiU~it aunirraJdlJot~i\[~Jt.i~i This. :~s :i.mpOItaf:.tt.r llOlf II fi.e:l,ps. '~O seCllIr-e 'ilhe~ ,car!J:,gnn!c;a'n c·tlal',aellcJ; of diU~ :r;es'ulta ,-, ,any a:~ln!t: 'who l};):pUe:s the IOOn,'~ ·t0ad~[t(~ltlD ·c,e.Sit· sherr-;Id. ,,")i!if~. ·dlie ,S3i'me reSiui~t· ·re~.timless[ lC}j: b':8.lhe-: ·nC'; .. ~

1[ .. 1 .1 , JUl. ell""· , ~ .,,~~,. ., ,I. "I ~n

'v-a'~e .b~.t~"~,tS. ~'O [.;recer.m,m.e wA.edte~· 'yf~U can .: w:~n. '(f'~r :~.ax.i'm. .!i'lt~ the S8I;Ple 'tUDe ·as IJt'S[ ·~m.vl:enaUzatil)n ·wlDtnnu't. cumltcra~]ctl,(J"", yU~, ,eml1.isio:n, 'tqi'faig teo w,nl·y0.ur~ :mdioDl in. ,31 'wCtr:1d im, w:hi!ch 'ni;e~ :maxi'ltJ, :15,

. ~~ "'~-. ~- .. ·Ii·~ "", __ .J "... ~. ~h- . ~.",.t.. ~...' ~ 1- ~~-r. j' -- -I:' Yo.~ .. ~~ .'. _. j~' A ,-.~~ ·U:ll'ii,Ve.m:at_l'~. - u}~ ·w,.· ~li~'U :~.t lS a .. !ilW· '0',.;' na·!t'!ltA:!;o.:, ~O'U lire ·to ···,l1)iltil'ii;,

'y'O.mseJ~ w:liethe~r. if d~e ·action which. ',ou propose .slf~O'tlld kk!e PilaU;

'Il:-',[.' ,~ '1Io'!IIW.:·: [Ai' ft.;i!I·lIfn'~~ ["",,IE: ~'ilJ...l· ~'Ii,.. 'U\';'!i,'1'I] ''U'~m'· iI:!'~IJ:; ·T.II'~.'I".iI!!' ,.;:I; n,""-' V;,NI11] ;i"!j"",,I·~]I··.,.1

~.:: ~J ,~~,._,,_. ~I: ~~l~~J~.L~ ~I: ·Hj~,~:_j~_~~ •. 1 ~~ .7.'~-.:. '__:I~~_~~ 'H~_~~, ~, r-~,I'1Ji JJ!'!I#~ ~~~~~J

:re,prd. i)t~ ,is .po$sHJle tnwl.p ·y((.ur: 'WiU:1~' I:C:l [69[~\, c.o:n)tl:s~l!e.tion :may

."'!Iii'Ii.~;tIi ·mi"·,;1 '''''~''o~,·Uj,a·:':t~·: 1!·lf·,~Le··' ·iii"OllI<iti·!iiiI'iII.t'OllI'~!ir'J;...,;;,t-~ ~lil"'e::-:ijfI. [L.:;ii; [o!"<.iI'fII.,lt'\£i'J'~~~4i'~ .!iI,.:l] . .!iI, ·~''''w~·: fry' ..... ,&_~~, -,!\II R. 'n' II' ~~ ,I; 'II._1I_J.!. IIHU.M.A.o&IIJ.I.oIJ IIIrU.a U.oIt'U 1.1 ~'!I!' .HI. llJ.!I.r ~1Il_~lli.'~ ,'!II' !lW'-U; IIIr.!l! IIiiII .1."1 .. ~-L

:miJwre: ·W:I.thDl:U~ Cfifttt~.m,otlfi:~~, :~.t is· [cnntf-sq' to !Strict. or' perte~t d)l.l,t.y~:

U; iJ.t~ ·ean. be c'Onc,et'vt6il:l but: IC0u'td .ntlt '00 miSJ,'ed wldlfi'.ui.t: ,ofil1i.U",a,d!i,e~t~,o~, :~.t :ils, co:nlt.r;'1ry· to 'bI!oo,d. [a.' :im.ped'et't <hl,'ty (G 42:4).

The be5,t~ e:xlm:pl~ of' 'tae :n'rst~ $ort~ ru ,oon;tramctiOn. :eo.m,ee;ms a .. mm. 'w:hose :mlllim. is t.tl[ make a :false .PIlOmiSe. i'D. o:rom' ~D' ,s;et SOJD"e :mmte,~, w:hicIh he blaws, :be: 'w:Ul be unabt-e '~D Rpary" To, :see wkedl!I' '~~i5' .CI'I!1~ 'be ·w:iUed. ,as a ·~m.v)enilla,w~[ 'we i'~n,e: a Wt'Q']ld. :~n wl~itib. ·tbis· .is" 50 'IU) ~,eik~, the s,tandar.(i, p~edule for.' .i:e~tin:g rea,d).y :m.Qne}'· .... ie,.is ·1 .Ia,w oj: :na,'t~re ·that an"oil,e, w:h,g· ne.e.dJs [fi,Q;DleY ,toes to [ie-t .I,'t. m~8[ W.S·Y,h Then. 'w:- .. ~'.I!rI'i.::I·a:iine 'dle 3iL7Pf:it '~~:im~ tl~ '\\lr~H 'l~O act Q~ b~ii max~:[;'. "~r: th~lt

.~e 1 .... --oLi .. "O"-·"-·.1~~ ~ .... == ..... ~ .... = .. ~. ..un In.iiI!

'W;hil:"]~J _ '1.iI"''''~Ij;: +.·~1·~, i1i'ij~ i"":t..,i'1iillt: ;iI;'~lic Qiiv·~c. ~]C;iD ttii!'i<[ .i'1iI. ",,;-r..."'I~ii":,,~I~ ... ;tc~];f\'~ because

__ v.t']' tY_ l~]~~ ~~~_,~ '~~ l~~~\\; ·Y_~_._A~ [~. !!r~ !:L"-~~ 1V1J.! ~ !!r.I~I_::I'!r_'liAY_~,"_.IU..l_& ,~'Ir.'A~!iJI!~

... [. 'b. ".- ·c· , ., - . ·1"" c-"I' . W . , ]~ . ,·'1., . j'j'",'L· ,. . . i'· ,'I .. }1' ··.:II";\, . , ... ·dc c.

:s.~C.~" !In.~'VIe:fSaUD.tICUiij, \.)QU,",1iJ. :ma~ew~ .'Lrr'(!LniLS~ .~;ltseil~;· ,!ill!nY.'IL!.Ile en • U)

be ',"!ii"\""?'''i'ri'',..,..l!~:iI!;litiill!~1 .~~, 1··~: tiift'j~Co;;'I;~'~~" 'ni']ii ot'!lliil'i: w~~'lldJ b·· .. el J",'V"'l: W'~'~iii: ~1i"',i'1i,ifi[ ~ ~~"'~IJ~riJJ_f_A~.!_~~U ~,. ~ ,l!f. f.JI~r-~~~I~~,~ =~ ~-~tl~ ~. yi-~" ~ ~. '!r.--. _I~ ~ ~ .. [lJjl!~J" .," II-_:QI

n~;mrl~'s;ilod'-: *'i']ii h·;~im·II·· ~;'I'lit··, 'WI')_'1'~I~d,' ..... nlv l.-'1'IIO"h. i":It: i"'t'fi'.'U" ;e;,'Ii'I, .. ,t..r ,"';i!;iifi~';""T'li1 ."Ii;j!j '!Iti'1ii:::i'i ,l,"'iI,","._._-" '!;;'.~ .. "'" c_~ ••. " IIJ.!'iId- .. ~ '!U!''!;''I!I.~ M~:! ~""~_ ~'" _!'!" ... ~Q.I! ~1i!'~il""_"!'!U!'tu """" "'III-'lu,

... , .. ~ ··1 . ~)~' I.~, .'1 c '.' 'I ~, .. i : ... ··1 [-,1ft j II'" , 'I) ·n·· . i J ~. 'I;h~' ti , ~. ··1 .~ i' II' w·i'f- .. ·[;Iit,·Iit,~\[ ~" .. ,

p:oo,t-e'D_se !IU, .4\:lc~,.,. d _S lm.PJ.- ~_J; rc aenoe ~_e sense ~Iiiii,._ .~ .. lCI~ tl~ll liS

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'if'S"

.~. _'.1

a 'totliUam,ct"·M-, 'lantis, vietW'- ,IS we sa.W' lea:rl",e:r,', '~s; d'uu 'b~~tbeti,c;a.'~

._'.l ~ -_ - •••• __ ••. 1. _~ II . ~ "'--1 •. _... . .. ,_. __ .. _1~1 .. 11. _ •• ,- •• 1_'J)·.~·¥· __ ... _l •• -_

i'm~m,ti'Ve8 a;-;-e ,3ifii:altTf;lC-- beesuse 'dlev '9~pre.S& a Ie]at\o~ of: 001l0-nr.

, ,1:"'- I,. - '" ,f., -- '1 "'- ",'" . "... ... ,.,,"' . '., ,,,'" . ._ -,. _Wi., .. , "". "C,t"

tlal CO(l,tDnme:m,t" The: ne,p;tlofi [Ill: an ~:alytie stiilit-emmlt: :is[ ,3, [C--ODtri:r. dilc~tiofi Th~; 'RUlin 'In die [~mn'le derj;~es his 'maxim &:o:m a 'hvnt1i.~,

• : • • - I. _ II I ,. r. ,.,.". I . , . ,. • _, , . '.~~ t.. . _j- - I ••• ', I,. - " . - " "..1, . , , '1.r-¥

the.Uc.al i!mt1er'i:it"jt'l:e';' '~~U '11:-011 W,Dt stlme 'I't4bil1v' mamev' 'vou o.u,P',::h ::t 'to-

.,' _. _' __ ,_, , ,~. ~_, I. " •• _ III , I~""'. _ " •• _ I, _ r. 1,'· .,. - . t •• ,..." ,,.. ". •• ~'_I I~ _

ma,ke ii, false promiSe. II ThiS im:"i'a:t~,v,e .m dled~ed .ff.am ,I 'c8J'Usal ,t~'.lawJ,~' ......, tha~, ,false ~ro:m;i5'j,DI is a me IRS, t~[ I~ttm~; :r,ud,' :mant;J'~' Oamllintd, with -tile: anall.ytic pr.ilnc4:ple ~'ha:t 'w,hoev~l' wills cbe end 'w:iUs dle :me.SI. Tt1e ,C3,usail, ~~lii,W;l'! :~n ':I[!ileS'tiO:D.~ bo.w\fl;¥£[, turns o~,t

~ ~. ~

to be na la(W a:t ,aU", 'be:eii'u!Se: f~s.e: promising QC)u~d. :no;t, be 'the W1'i'~,W'=

1- tit' Dd 1':' d Th' 'fl.' f 1

,·:1:·.- 1----=-:-'·-:.]-·;::-,·-:-;:,·,--: ,.-:-;:_r~ ---<;'-_~I-,-=-'I-:-." '-~-::-'~ ~,--: ,-:_-_.--:,_~,.-~.~. ----::-,.-, ~_.'~.'L, .. , __ :-,:-_:-,-., -:::.,; .:- . :-,-_11,-.-,-: '-,- .1-:- -,~,"L\-l·-'

,~a m,e. ',_, , D '. I,CI!Jung ,rea, fy ,money.. ,," e e" ',' ,caey 0: '. ,3J_Ylmg pr-omml

depends [00, the .tact thiU. it; 1;9 [cx.'Ce,pt"ie:na1", :fnt pemple: bei]i,eve promiSes ,ol'lly be.c.aJil8'C1 'dl~~" ,ate: :n(lnnaUy- ,made .m ,~OO, :f1Jit~ in.d, :~,end, mane·y 'om, dl.e~ basis, o:f: ,t'fiem, on]," 'beca'Juse: 't~e:y 'RUe,v·e ,t'hem., In '.tUm,l: ~'he 'Ufii,""e-'I;~aliz3itlGfi, fif :h1s[ :mu.i:m.r t!be; de~ei:tiul :pl{iml'se:i" w,~Us[ a 'w'Odd 'io, w:hic:h. promises, of: 'this :kind, ,ilK ,n,ot~ IliIlr:m;aU,,' in. ,aood :raith ,and the:reiO~e 'wiU nat. 'h ;8at~tedL Thls[ m,e;an$ 'thl~, the~ will :no.t 'be a

~. l~·

'm'---:-'·;ti;_ilijil'fl;S', :io'Ji' !p\~iii' •• iii1p r--':'_;!iI,'fiIv' '~~n;iil,v' '~:n,iI 'iii'~, .. t-, .. : ..... itI! h':'U1i'Iit'liii!-':u.I;J;.i,"'_-'~I·;'Nin~"O!I!."~7.~ , ~ - ~lIiiII.IJiIL~ ~ [!:lI~"'~~ . ,1~~,:I' .liIll;l.-~_"iIf~$"1 ~~~I ~.llrQ.1lI_' ·UI~ . - 'll·lr~!Ij.~'~~l'~~_~, .~~~~~~,~)W,"'·~

:&---o.m 'which the d!ocel.t-&d 'pmmlse-1 deo'Y-es his O'WJi :maxi'm 'wiU be :falsil.edJ. This :is wheR 'W'C; get: the 'Cfit1itr1ld!~,Ctinm:; ·t'~e; lyimg :Pi'Qmi5e:t 'w'ho alt'lQem:-,ts, '~O' wUl dle '~wV\er:sallza;tiiofi, of :his maJtim, 'wills, ·the: ,m:-nial. of the ana1~;ica] ~flm,c-ifile an. 'wbi,~-h :b,e; himseU ~mi"l!lilses[ '~O

l' ,.. r lr ,~. lr'~

,act.-; and. 'd~e~ d.emal [@f !Q1l anlly;ticarn. pri~.ci,pJje~ :'S[ ;ill, camu'-adtcti,on. !!:5![

'if~"'l."""'i!!' ;If'"~,t. ~,;:;i£!;: ... 1"'":~ftji; ti,'i'i\""'iii 'i~j~~e~-ffiiI;'i'[IlI;'n~' "\-,t!! oiilP,;t!';!iI~~V' :Ifi;"" 'ftii'A'iifri'~I;C!~jC!, ',iiC! ,t':Ii"';~'tr'

,~I~'.I., ~'illceIIIl, .lIi'!I.iQ. ,.._iilll_-iU.lIl 1 •. Jla!ll· M_II'''~ _ I - . ~ ~.dl: ~"'''Cll !Ir_r.~t'_ '!Ir.?"~~;&1IiiIMi1lli ~ ~J; ,~ill,U\IJ.~:.L"L""-'llr..~ ,111~ u~IIJ.LLJ

,a c'On:tradtetiofi. :~f promises, ,aft 't·b.ems.elves, :necessliry; But· .lCant~~'s, ~)t in t'l),e: 'e~ple ~s .mnre :moclest: 'than. 'dl(i.t:;: it is, :i1O't :inten,ed, to esta'bUs'h mart: :'J.'Qm~s-es ,are' :necessary. P:mmises ,are itece~ :fOl 'the :man. :lrn me e-&mple~ beciil!u$e 11, ptopoHS, ,to 'use [I :p.:~onDse as, ,tIb,e 'me oms 'U;) b"'iS; O~- --cd ~o 1'11(-''-s ~ "C'~C'c It/--ct-,-~c--, tb..a'E hi' 'C' "'I-ct' "~on

c' .. :' , .•. ' ,'. '.' •. ~ •.• "'~~ •. en." ,.18 l! W,':y ,an .. 5!11iy,~ I " .', .. ' :. e [cann,o, , WI . ,

h~[iII[ 'm-'i''''Ii¥'-- "'Ii,...;·.;I1 '\i!i!i 'iitCC'I~'I:J!"'_''''l't--.--c,-'~""",,[ '"',', ".1., -, ''';::-C-,.di' +"1:-:;--- 'iji:iU' ... .--'c -C'C'-""'-'_'~I ~_ " '~llli_u __ lilY! l!!Ii!Oi!< '!O'I!n_~,,,,, '!w.iI,i;!jR_ lza'''-IV\J_il. H[I,. "';u!~ ',-JiD_nJ ... , ~_l.m[e, '"' u;e.nev-c:: ..... 'fU'lo'li

In~nAiil!'lD '~if!i, '"!!,,~i"':'1'" ,"'Ii'1!'r" :i'!l1 ... ~t''lWi1 'w;h.~~; .iIIi,.::~[""''''IiIi'.~, ,d'ii!lin~Ii'ri'A!c :'fiIl1'. ,j[iiii!i .i!!i_V,""M.r. F-i!~.rY-!il~ ~-w ,~\L'JV ... [t_I_'" ~UJ ~-,..I~~lU"lI~1 ~~, _ ~ '!IJ"~~:_I~-!F~I;\iI!,,· ._i'li.:r~iIJJI{Y'" U _ 1 lli'~ '!ir-a~""lr'

'ti,ona), ~'h:af.~~~t, 'Q'~, ,I~~; ,~ ,oon'U:'ad)~ot1O:11. [(1fl '~bis, ,killd.,

The iO,theJ lOind Qf co:n:tra-wc--ti()'D, .a:ri~.s whe~, 'y'Qu a,~~tre[n.plt~ t~[ 'Win

,..,'l...;;., 'iiii'l'ilr~"';t~_"l"""'li;za:iii'iI~n n~' !f'n-m- -.;g inA'~I~,f!:V '!Ui.,'L':I~'iIlo. '!Ui'""".Ii'iL~ ~1~[ .. ,1i,g-1·''''"'"· 'lIi"jI!,..;g;, ~ .• n)~. ~1~,'''~~. - .'~ '~.CL'V .; 'IbIIc~ ~~_·~'~c~ lr!Y"~~~~· '"~~~A, !ft!1IbII~~.fQ, ~~~~_II§_~~~:_;~,~~ ~~,~

, , "!"lll- 01',[ _",,£.0 c-' ,,'-' -' - --"",'~'I'" 'E' _., "-r - ,.-' .~[;t;, ,--' .. , -.- '" "'~Il ,- " .... - ..

W,I~ .. ~' ~!II~-ac:r ,mOl!e ge!l1:a',!W.!J.y. ,{'Of mSitan~ .u- y-O·U, tc,ty ~;ol Wl~_; a u:nilv~r'~

sal 'n.nH~v [1J1·n~"'1 ecti'rng t'.timts and 'ncrw-e:ts 'VtClll oontfamct' '~-O'i'l'r.' 'w-HI

._ ~~''_;. !f-~~~'''=:-'I .~~, .~~..=.~._ .. ~ . ._;~~=-.: 1.:~~._.____:___.IJ':_J ~~~~"' ~.~ _':'..=..-~ _., ,I·:__'·~-_' .~.,__:_~~.~~'~I~c,,:_'J~..:.I._;. ".~.-~ .. _-~.~-

b~cl~se. t1f:l~H: S'e'J'V;e '~~u for '~~',!ilU. sorts ~f '~5sibl~ '~~~~~sP ,I [G· ~I~.~['~e, :~'f

". It~ 1f'~',It-¥~. ~;J .~

'~t'O~, '~~ft!" te 'wUI ,I 'wiv-e:ral. n~Ci~' of' ,not: 'h~~ilftiftla' ,adlel':S!, 'JlU;u, 'OOIU'--:: - '"'

,,..- .. ~ '"~J' ... w.'_'_l.~ . 1~ .'.l·-·~r·· .. J.." .. '~~. "=-"~-~~I' . __ I.'.l .. , " ... _ .... _1_r.a1

dilet 'V(J,U[' wiD '~2US.~ VOU, 'vQmse.rnf:, as, ,3, fim,t'e ,ra,tion;Jii '~~ln.~"'. ,a.-r'e

w.~~~ ;J;.'~-~~ ".~ ~ .... "~~'.~-. J.~" .. ~ I"~-~~-~-'l~ ~~' .. ~ ~'-'~-~ .. ~w~. ~~'.~'~ l!::.",, __ il ._, .•

- -

Copy rig hted m ateri al

[il'jiit"\iII!'D 1·'1i"Ii need 0·11[' """""'~"::""i'''f''l''''''''' ~~~, 17',"'1 .... ,.' ;iI": '1!!I;;A"i" .oliZt~ori''''lgI' ''''In' ""1I'fl'~I""iIlc~"I'" '.'",,!"'S""'"

~Jl,~_-:__~I, ~'~~ .~_~~-~-.~_ ~ of. [~~_~c~~~~~~!J ~~~,~ .~~ ,~lI~'I!.l ~_;fl;~~'~'~LOI ~~ __ [~~~~~~~~ ,~,~_~_~~~,

,;i!...IfI;Ic ["".n· ,;!i;';:;'.'II:iIi.iil.1 :a'~'~:i"!rI!iIi.' . "j,,".T> "IIIiii' '14.""'1"'"' 'rr'~'~Pi'I'1I.'f (iln . IIiiii" 'V[.rnf~III')C:o.:.,l,i.': 'tn'" '1 "" ,~""" 'II..lI1 w, ·~,.,'I).."""'ljlt·",

I~ 0: _ ' ~~:.r.J!li.lliaiJ. .~ L~'-~~"I ,Inl .... _ !W"II ,UlI.lI.IIiI.~,.1.-..LCiI 7. ~_II.~ll: ,I" ,[a ·H·~ lq ' .. ,1I,gnl~~I~~

,a'S'$i$ta:n~ :i$ !'ii, ,t'h(Jught; ~~ll!t 'tfi ~letemu'~,(t; w:~eth~' ',UkU, Ga'n ,~'~'111 ',,:,:,A'i'I>.I· ',,",<ifviTmC'~1 ,;!i;",. a 'iJiilllinYe~:""""''';~ '~',;!i;~ ~l c·;a,Ju~~'tY·;~:'"l'.i;'~~~··..;.."l·~""".'~I~" .... :t-,'i.~"'""', L~l..ll,,,", - iJ1Ii ~lIJj I. uu- ,1Ju:aI.A..Ii[", -.a. ' . ' ,T.· _1J,&:IalI. ,lIc6l1lU·I .. ,1l"lI]) ..... U, '.' UI ,lIl.~ , [.\Iolll"" u· -:-ll"L.IJ11::J! ,nv.-1_~

~ ~ " - - -- ~ -- ~ ~~- ~ - _ - - ~- ~ ~ - - ~ ~ ~ - ~ - ~- - - - - - ~ - ~- - [. ~ ~ ~ ~ - -. , ---. . - ~- ~ ~ - - - ~ - ~ ~--

·~9~~-~· ,",Ii!, ," C'·. d:!'-" "·,,·t' :" ~ ,i'",c·;j; '~~'iio, '~'"r" .. ".~:~:.",~.;j; .. ", .. , .. -. L~, " .. ,' , ...... "~"" '.

[even u: y-ou, (]I! ,H~,., ,Qll.!li!I;C!Ii. iC'.' .any ,3:SS1S!II.am,QC ,[[I'~m. ,3JIl',Y1QDe 'iCJIi~w or

'1:..." ',iifiit"'" ,;!i;.n~ry real 'iIjo. ..... pe~ .~, ,;j;,'Ilo.,;;.., 'y.;ijnl'il ;w,i'U'

IIHIOI y. ...... !1M, . ~L.. "iIl]~ .'. !I. III a).1 '. UWI !'J.1I',~" '.1

- .. ti - - . ,", ~ ... .'

At dlis ~[Dt 'Kalil '~as, lon'[~' ,told 'USI 'wha't tl1iE: ~3}t~Pfinc:.allrml~a:a·,

II, ... __ lrr·~·-.l[-.- 1-_- ... -~. , .. 1.1 -- ... -- .... _-1 ••• ,.-,'O'~,.,.- I, -,~' }

tti,ve I;S :~f: ,tJh,ele :~,SI fille 11(;i, 4~.s~i Bert: 'j!!iiSlt aSI me laws, of: 'dle Wifi~l:leu'ta;md·,

"~ ~ 'b. ~.l:" ~ 'l.. ... ~ ... ' . 'I!.JI,'"'Ik ~.:.II 'I!....,., .. .l'.d~~ ~ ~; ~ ~~ .'~ .,~. ,~~ ~ ·~b ~ '"'11. ~~~ ~~ ~:l~~ ~ :IIDg ,lWaU 'to ee IC':Slt3iL!lIlIBliI.e~ llI'T ,ill 'u,1aiIiU.c~tl,i!J1'~, S~.Iniwl;l1l;g il:tlliil'lt 'iI!lIiJ,c,'1' ,3{P'iP,J,Y t'o

,.'lkp, ~t""'ift~ ;01: a;~"-riI.aniFi"'~~ r"'1..';i:ii; ,;fi'iiI~'ij',IiIi;UfFi",jI"'i"Ii:~ l~'~,fiI~c~;i:j;~Iij\e~i 'rc:n:-Ur.'i!>,i' [ke~' [~U!~"'"'~~

1;._lnl~ 'n' UOiIlL."t\l1 u-l 1W_"'-.l~·-~.,\.i-"~IJ"lilAP.t IU_L~ ~. '~-"-:e')U~I.",,.."J~, _~_~_;ljl~!W_J.!IPII!Ir_I,·!r.·:. III_II: .... _"'''':.1 llJ.! lliiia'll.!m_U

:Il[~h,ed brJ(' is~,cr'Wl!ng mIt: :i.t a..cmally a;"Ues, 't,o the wwm., will. ,~~cn,e

~~.~,<'t..,~'iI·~I~ [~t '~1~'~'~'~"C'1 .. 1!.,~.~.~, 'd'~'~'~'~"C'~f~'"C'f~"."C' ~.' ."C,~ "C'·fI~~·~* ,~~r.lI·;bri' ,~ .. ~CC r.o 'k.~ .. ;,~~c~[~.~,;j;,,;

pOSS.l,(Jlll''''1 ~ll reamn ,,1l1)\I.8! '1Ioi!lo!e:In1IUIILg 'oOU'W1UC;!I. ,HlW_'il!!I. ,IlOW ne lm,veS~;l·'

g;a!Wd:11' I:(j, '411J. 'Wiliie; ,tilis, p@~~ijbUlt, [caD~,ot, ~e [esml\,,:ii;sud 'Wf.i.'tU me c.Dbcll ;iJ;i:'IP:;nj~'~ met1lt' of' tine Thhd ,seotrool '~"h~~ I\esi of the Se~fimd SeCit1tfim

. _ I,. _ . _ l -.l~t-- . .. _ J I . _ _. II , " ~ _ ~ ~ _ ,... _, .. _ .. ~ - " . _ _.,.,

~~~ni'iI~Q, 1"";1;-'0:> .,.w"il1fi'V' ~~",~~-IIiiII_II,!Wi!iJ! 1t1~~~ .. !lM1$'.

u .... ~· [b~~L~~ L~~~ 'i!...'~"i!..~~L ·.'ik~,~ ~~~ ~'~'"'~~CC ~ ~~.~ ~ ~;·~b. ~"~~~ ~~~AI '"~

,~nt IUe,pns J;iI~m, ,11115 '1iIlilJ!!S;1;S tliiaHt: one ,iaJiI,W,iilYS, ,iiK':,ts 'w,lilu mme lel'l,u, [111,

view. Ends ma,""" Hlllrvj.de 'IlS, 'wl,tib 'J;e!a1sons, nos~th!\el\f· ,U 'n'ur~Gsel WI be

-"' -~. -- .. --. 1----.,J-· Jr-.I .. "._ _ ~~ 1 __ 11 _ .. ·-,--·r···i.- "'.I~I - .. ,~.-_~I~ ".- .

iiicihie:¥~~ M' n;:;'Oia~i''Y\iI!1'v "Ii~, tli1imo-s· 'Wti ml1'S!t' 'fiiOri aet a~~'~nSri :u tthi¥~ is

__ -=. __ . J_:..:.. )~~111 [.~_~ ~_~~.-----f!\\!~.~.IIjr.I __ I',~, I~ ~~~._, [_II~ .... _._ • ._:' ~..:._'_.L_:' ,__!_~_:..:.._._..:. ~~ -.~_I. _ ~~"_:!I!I ~ l_~~~.~ ~._I

:a ~at~II'n\['.iLciJil ~'~'n.i"ira'''iv~ there D.i~'II[!ot be a'm A'I:...:~cil:iv¢ end .... n.~ ~..eil::er·

"_~_f~":__l:j~;~/'__~-":' __ ~"~~Jf-~--:__'~_'~[" ~-'J! I~-'-~_',:. II;~., :,,¥'_"'['¥~J:.-~.l_-:-' ".:__. '.~ _'_~l ~I.:__._ ._)_-,_:__~

mimed b, reason iJtseU' ,.and, :&~ ,iiit)t~d.bu,tied, to every :mJtciGna], wiU~ 'when, 'we 8;C~: [on 'th..e c3ite,llnn.oCal :impemli'V'e'l' dlls W,IU be, dle. e4l!d, 'we bave iti.

'-~'I ~c-,,~ ~IG[-::: .' ~,~, ,~,iO. M·: 1'~jIl·i~.~' ::- Q!~~ '~W:~·~ii,.,,·':i-~ ,~,,~~.~~'ild'i 't·'ii..·:\~,~."C'qo1 '~ .. ,:2' ~l"c"i~,.~ 'i·:,·".J1 ,~l: v,~,e,w 1~~1 4,l.;r=1,\Q; .'".[![" '" ,3[Qij_,r •. ··.,iIllli1.lil .. , WQUJi' .ld5 e.nu,~. ,1 ,!IUS, ,Alll',\l !Q'1

,iI'bmlu,'~e value lcan~lot~ 'be ,(Gumd in, the [mb~ects, 00.1' (f~f dl:~i;recS.r :fo:r t'ht:~' ,Itl d~ei'r v,ah:we ,j'ro:m ehe ia~t 'tbat we desire: t'ilem., :Nol (HI. :~:t 'R: toumd, ,m, 'CPaI" [dtllSiires ~Ihemselyres.!! [mE' 1m, th~ various ,objects, aro~\md us ,1'Ylail-

" 'L'I: " liZ' .. , "'" .. , , , .. , .. , 'n,· I~L,.. 'U", . it"'" " ~~, ' ,,,. , . ..lI., . . '1 . . . .,

,3;lil'Jiie ,~~llJlse: as m(!i~ms., ,!J"I;;I~p(!il'~, .fi!;,lnJ~, U'Sw" ,mant/ mu\l' m,lenera"J ~:Vf:ry

,,,.~,~ •. ~ ""1 'k ..... , , ~, ~. ".~"", . ~ ,." 'd ,', hi' ,,' .', 'U·"~' iF" ." iilIil

,[IIJUDma ~lllg eXlls,tcs [as an en .. In, ,,,~~m5e,,~"" ~~ 4~~.p.,

"Tci'l.f~'C!' ~~n" ii"!:'llriil,i!J~;:;;n L oi,'pl.,,,,: '~ ...... .,/I~ ,;j.;~ ",;~."", ,~'~I'''''l·'~ ~~,":,'L. 'W' .'L ~~h" 'Iii"'L"";i"'"'!l":'ffn:I'''''''.,.:Ii,,, Jl J;_IL~r.JI ~ ~ jwiIJJw":~J.I'U_· , ndllJ.~ DiII.A !L!!IL:I.! U1~ ~JIJ .. ~ .1llLI. '!'("!'P.',1I,U[!J, . '-.' DlIt'!t.i_ -, !li.1l_Ll,'II.r. !l.r~'LI,U\U_.lh.JU.

'wor:k c-nens' ,the onJ)v' ,t"h:i'IrIi[P' 'wm!ll:;b baiS Ui~oo:ndiJdmill 'va]ue is a go,oodj

.'" '.'," •• - '; ~ .. _[_._,I. '~'. "-"'.1' ._~lr.,.J~ ·-·_.[1":' __ 1 ~~l_~ .:: __ :[ _ _:_.:..:.~,~ __ ,_J~. __ :..:. [1,_1, .. ' __ ")_.~ ·-~ .. _II!cf.:__r-~.-_

'~lL A, '~J-};lng :bas omldii,d,(ulal ~,aU.ue D :~,ts 'valI~e ~~leopends [mn, 'wh~the.:r' I~t:a;m. (lilliiid!i.'tl~n:iI!' :bA1.Jo• ~,""1'ir" '~n. ·.iI!~l'1iT~""""'., '~'h~ . .i!l!~ ,,,,l'Ii;~"U~: :'I'i'f' ,~'iIl..~, ·m·[[·'ii![~(n.··;Ci ~;iI!i""

~ _-~ ~ _~-_ _ _._..,-~ ~_ ~~~~~ ~y~Jt~ ~ ~t. l~ _ ,g~!9JII:J~~~ l~ __ f'lr. ''I!' ililJJII~-'IIr."1 v- I ~_~Ii_t'!lr. __ ~g __ ];I \II,..

n~nd8, nn t'liiu~. 'valiu@;of. *'il:J"", ,~Ii1-1I, :~+ ii!i.i!Ii"_''''!i!',. :"'-d·.~ ~,t.. .. V,l'Iilil'i'!'i~~ i('iIl.: :,,~, ~~,b'e~,t: A~

r - . "'- - - ~~- - - _~ _ - ~- ~---==r~ ~ ~~ 1Q!'Ir.;:. ~"I.-~, i5H~~._ iU~l~ ~ ~_ilIM~"1 ~-JJ P--I~ ~- .. J~-.'¥ W~I

desi'm d.e:l"i~nds Oli'ii 'wh~~1..- [j[j,,,',"iiii""'"'''~i'i'HI!" "'')..;iI; ~"iIIiiii ... ». ·w"··_.'l~'~1 '_'''I]'Ii". Ii'AIi1~b~'= ' . .;.'_'.~I,..:. ._ '..:.r_:_-~~/.;~._I .:..:.-J~, r r ~.~~~.___A~ 1~~f_~,7~~-~~~ 1~[I!!r U~_~~IlLI!ir.' .... L' __ WI fJ'!Irg~~" ~_~~~~~~_'.r-"

U~:e 'itO 'fm,e :~rr$.~n,~:$ hil'ppi'~~SSl' :I,ve~ 'hap"mess 'iii :~it: '~ab;~~W~ in, ,all C:3S~S and SQ, is, ~nndi:tion-;t A ''"'liiiin;tp.~ 1.. -[-~ '~llIiiH~'ii"i1l',4~'~tA'4i"i:"'l 'v,,,,mJU.p~ ,~,t: itt, has

... ~l ~ .. ~ _ • ~ ~_~-~~.~~'~~~'~.:.I~ ~ ~I~~ l~:: ... ~ ... ~rU~'IIIj;_IIJV!IJ_;!,iA~, . ~.______f~=--~ ~~ ~.~

its, \f,al,ue ~in it~f' and ~, :ba i.t '!!nder ,Ill oondi,tlo,rJs. Ubbna;t,~~,y' .]1 \\"!',3ihr@ :mjUst snri'fii;~ htlm ,~ ,SCniJiKe ~'~h~m '~S' u':I.co::diidi "C'l~;U"'~ ~l3hlaib:lfIi~"

~ ~ ~.~~.~~ ~,r~~~~= .~ .. ~ , .. W.II ,I .. n. iIl.i OOiill.y ~_, ''''1"

,'Gr' :as, ,~D.n[" ,a;s we [c;_ ~ueS'ti'on t'h~ ~:~b:-: ,::-f: i~:~H:-~th;;n;i7~ ~:':\e ha~,e '[CIt

~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ "'--'""Q; ~ "., ""I,li e va tile 0:, .. mLe 1'"'"'Of w, ;v ,n.o .

•• iI,h ..... iL -,.-1 ,;i.,'L" iiIIi,t"I.d· .Af·: J","e .... ii"iiii'rii,A"'..,* .m.'~,~, cu ..... ~ ;j;,<i~, ,~~~.~ ~.~ ,".~ ... 1... ~j., . ~· ... 1'-~ .~ good~'~ .. : ~,".~';'1'~~ "'''''''iCI,,","nEU UTI) ~ .,.eLI!' 'I/o! I ~"'-' ,,"U.liiL.wil .. IiU.H'd· ,iI'io.iID'Ir:S ne.w IS,u:liil",; Chu V ;a' ;.'. 'l WlJiil

_ ~ __ -~~ _. _' . •• • "-....;:_ , ._' •• -.~ 1· ••• · •• -. , _ • __ _ r. - _- _ • I _ .. ~ ., .• It, •••. I _ • . ' .. I". - . - '1/' • I I '.' - "-. I .,. [ .' _ I

Copy rig hted m ateri al

has, UIfJ],cOfidit:IJO'1"!;al vraliue; of 'dds :I!dnd, Since :~,t :is 'dTItt';, o'~ec't~ !Of [Oi!JJf OWD, moi(;J!:s w:bic~b 'Wl';: ~.e to, '00 ,g~1 and, thi4J~: o':bj~~ do, :~,Qt; h~'!!'~: 'v\al~,ei ,bri, tllems.el'Yes,. the souree [of value :m~s't: be som.eddng t:bia!lt es{ta in us. ,It; ~$ 'n~t O'~ :n~ds, and d~RS~, fQ:!r '~b,Qse ar~ ,!EUlt ,a'~ways, good, :I~t lmJUsti tMI'~Q~j' 'ib~ ():~[ hi1JlllitanjJt;1I;~ '~U'r' r3t~Q~1 :~!1Jt;'u'~ and, ~pa.ci;t,y ,lw' ra:tiio:rud, eheiee, 'This is ,n~t dile]'~~,t fr~m, ~ying: .it is, a, pd 'wi'U, :'101" :mJtil.Qliiial :tla)it.UL~ '~n it~ !p~doot IS'tilite;1' is, !!ii, ,g,ood 'win [~(:; ,42.8;-.219; [C2. ~'7,-67; [~7')·,

Ka:lt: [-'~-::'=S 'u'bS:l; th-, 'iiI\~)Ic:~'~k~ ill':,~,ttO:llal 'iDlatUIre eJr\s,t8 ,itS ,ilill ~nd, filii

.. 0,_ ::my_ _ e ,lrDruI"t," e raIl ,I , .. 1._ ,.'" ..~,

:i,tse:IJi is, a su'bje:c:"d:y'e ,prin,c.;i:pJe of :h,U!mm, ~lcti(}fi5!i' 'kllll: 'that S[I'li,ce every' :raitlou], oo~8 bolds, :~,t.r :i:t Im,tit be 'tal'en, '~O 'K: ~bi;e£tir.~le ,as, ¥lIeU [~c' '41,~il~ :~fUse $a.M, [of 'us bolds, :bislh'tr.' [I)w:m, ends t(J.' llC ,good,~, [each, of: U'$, ,-'e,g:atrdls, hisJhe:JJ' o.wn, b~manj_t;y 8!S ,iI rBo~r.e't of vmU6~, :ID, ItO-fisis!", 'iDeiiey~ w·ei m,USt~ ;a,ttnilmi,t'e: 't'~e" 8I.Qirle kirnd, ,0£ 'v,a'nuc~ til[ the :I:iUmafill:ty of

~1;'b.- -- .Tt.. - a' - - - - - ~ .JI- - ~ t- , - - ~ i(l.:Cii; ~'I!..ll*[Ci;l... 1.;0 ~ ,",,"'~in~ ... ~~ ~ ~ ii?Tb' oi]li n.b~· !'*"i"~V''V~Lw'e:m. ,iL,n;C",e canslucm:10Da' [ ... """,3!~\ .. IJ.i"iI!, ,._;_~!!J,hli~~Q!~iIi~~.b;,y' lEI"" ''''"_~".,; [",jr\~,",,~"L/e

~.d :ne-ed~d ,~' rt:he det~i.lmtnatllio:~ of'th.e 'win 'by' a rea.t~pri[c:al im~a''" 'ttiv'e. It is, ,iii, ll~pjti:v~ end,~, [!m~ thilrt ,jJ5 net t~, b~ a~t.oo, ,aga1'lmJs:'t :raith~~'

1~ be c:h''' d Tb' l ds Ka m 'I'

t~ an 11 :P!lu:pilse; 'i(':O' ~ ...•. .ae JU~~\!''6L, ',; ms =fiilL: _~~nit 'f!) a :R6W' ~':.ImJU':aJttOI1

of tb~ :lim.~r3't~,v~I' th~ :F~r.~ul~ oJ :Hi~ani,ty'~ j\I,AQt so '~ba.t ,Oll, tr'M't. hL~ht.Yi 'w'h~,th"~x :m y'OU]" ~W~, :~i5cm ~[ ,in, '~ait of. 'iI1i~ot'h~~, ,d,Wia,YSI as an e:n.d ,IlFld neVlc{(' ,as ,;I] means o:n~~,'~~ ~~'G, 4(;);19)",I:)J

'K'~ 'b j c~ h d r l~ .

,ant: ,t II en Q'caitsl ,t~ ne :8aclll,:e~ :s~lt 0: ~ [e:x~~mpi .~S' ~ c~ 'USG_ ear _J;!!~ ;6, "~OW:Ulg

h(!Jw' th~ irmm.oral malxi:ms, :1D!,V'O'l'V:6 [il v,W,oj]atjQ~, [~f '~m~ '~n~.ndhiQm1l, v~due -(l~ :h'~moo'~ty;, 'Viola't.i~nB of pm'OO't, dlu:t.y o~~U![ 'whe:l1I!, ,th~ ,p~'w,~r ~f 1'3'tiQIl! •. ,c'b,(di~ d~fl:miit-i'V~ ~f' blJUlilj!'Hrlt;y' is ~.ad~ subo:~dlina;~~ t~,

:'f> .. ; .... 'e-·II" :nri''''-'l!\o':l!'~'!U' [;f!;tji.TI'~':I!i'.I!·IO:": "11"'""1. :170"";~;<;, A·: \ "".U,jl""'~~oI;>i, :'"-ryot' ,jr:n'''''iii'''''"'l''''''';'' t·IjI-.:>:""'iii'';;, :~'l.·''''/

uU_1 _'11J! ~ •• .IH.I"_;J..'!I.P_~,~ W-U'--.Il,"~W}. .,1J_1I_&_ !Ctf~lM_1iJ I] ,. !iJ!. _1J~'\il'.I~I~.JI ~U'iIJ, l.LII_ .. a~_"_LLIIi.w.-"'l . _1J.'~1~.:J! ~[~_ r.::II_~'

her [aw,iil :~,U!marfJ]itJ' .as mmet'ihlifig :~,elshe can, mw,w' ,a'W,3i" ,ltJif t'iliC saike:

,m,-l: t.1~:c;,.JL~if [ifilijl.7't .... ~ fG' _:, '4- ,"'" i'iil'. ~AI·r'-v~' 4·~ "" ,;o;,'r="i ~ ~IA'"lF"'vl-if!..Ti";ji, ~'~",. ~ur.,a';ji,a'~;i:i;fi;Pfi.;.

u.1 J;1_~a_l ,lI_lt~lI, w-!lil~~n/~,IJ ~ ~ '. - J [ ~ :-'17 ~J • .tTJJ.._l£" '. [_ :.&!..J5I ... .;}.' J. .j;~l.lHII[t U~_"!IIP 'nJ[IHI~ . .a ... a ~rW-W--lr

t~,v'e oil' 'oOOlclve, :me~ilodJs W[ U!Dde~;fijiHe the ,f;medfiw. 0'- choioe Sind, i&u::uom, ex:e4'(;.;llsed, 'by omem also, 'v,~,O:J;a,t~ perfect, d'u,t,}!'~, The lying: :,i:om:r. isel uses t'llei lender as a me.J'-e mltafiS beCaf!l!lse" :bei tEtt.ks :him :in,bJ'

efi'!<~iiFHr ,,,,,~w-r.:<'Iirv ~l',i!j; '-m~ -~ o~,n .. 'e~v' '"'a~I~'jkPT' 'iii"I'k.''''-n· fil~'~.if'ii,m""i'.iifiiP '~'l"-m. ~ 'iii<ijI; ",",ii.,~",.ai ,.~Ii'j\-~l;·~'e~·I"'C ,rLr.'I.i.",,& !MJ., . .'liI[Illt 1-1,0',' - - \IH. :-,,.' .JJI l .. lIl~. !lllll .. " .. ~ ,1~fl'[IlIll"a Jlrl~ ~ -, !lJ~ IIYI..rJI~~1r.i 'R,~]~fU-1 _':_

Of :n,ot t.'O dn SO\;, H,e. 'd\.i,U!s, 'ltre31,tsi :h18 nal!'l;llg: 'd~e :mnf:.i,e{,~ ,a ooi!tdli;t~fin;al o:"OOd- IS, "'f. 'ilt 'W'Cil'~~ m,of;e 'rm¥l1lwt 1!'i'lian the, [t)the.[~s 'bumm~ffl-, 'Cl-::'~

IICJ .... ·_.,'ill ._ ... 1_ [ .. ~~. -. , [ __ I ,-.J., ll_ --".IfIl!lJ.ll-' ... J .• J . __ ., ." __ ., J. [_ 1. ~JIIr!).'!11 • J[Je-r

~t~'i"oi, ~-"""""irif~'T, 4;i1': 'n-~~i6"'ii: ,~,""'~~i!i'~1 i"Iil~-i,~;Cio;o;'ill:H;i';;I","'" ,""";d,i ·U' 'i"oir''ii'[Ji!';'i';[£i,'!i;'b~'~~, 'II:, "",\li\ ... ",I," ~'!I."A:!;;!l!;p.t"1IO. ".~ ,r,II,U'!lo","'!;o'!I; ,iI,,~iI;!.i"'~ I'I' .... II-Y! '!ilI'!;pl!;;l ... ,t"!I..Iv\I'~, 11,1 ""', ... nllllill'_a!l..IJUi.g, ..il,... ,WD

maj(~e.f; 'w:bat enid. '~:lIiiey' ,seW,tel' :MI a go 00. e~ld, I;S ,an ,o'b~ect: o:i e.;\!,Ier, ratlianaJ, 'wnl-'j and, reasen is tijuS'~, '~'ihe~ '¥f!J'mct oJ U'f\e Ci~j_DlliS~j {C1 6\:l,~, tr'I' A' ". 7"~[ill~'A,n.i"D'.,[~_,,~ ~'1

~,~, -,~,: 37- ~-~,g,: g., ~~ ,

A:~I""~"",.lr'i""'''''' hn '1!"'I;'Ol;'~'l',iIi'U ]j"IiC!i !1!'I;;',,;<Io' ''''I '~'1'lrilimn.I::!~' ~\i!'Io, '~,~, ;i'I ":'L'~""!J:,.,,,!,;I 'W" ,\iI!i' ;i"!!"fl'!U ",,;"'I,ll' ,~'I'Ii ,~,'U1h~-~.~ .I.1IJ':~'~~~·~~'.l ~~I ,~~t'I!bP."l ~"tfi!!~~IIIII!',lr~ ,~ ~ ,~~~~.,,~u.r- _,_.~ ~~~,~, ~~~ ,_UI;

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'I--C"i,;1i1 'it' .a.. 'N~'Ti ~, ;IiiA' 0f'i;'IR: ." ~L ljV~1i' 'I' n ~ n,'~''i\i'''W'

.. 10 lRn] _ [' !ill! l~1"t"V.l,.l~ .. liliJ[~"l.Jiii!~Li]I~.Ij·[ •• "ltIII.

(:,A'TE .. G ():Rill:m S, o P DUTY': TH.I M .. lE TA' R:Y':S:~:(::S, Ol" .M,O!lLl,[,S,

'f,',... ,;j;'ji!-c ... , r» ... !nc..:ii..J!r~~!I!',l .. , ,;!J; "oo-,-,c·t~-n:l'rii"iI;I; ,;j;i!'lio ",'L:-\~ e,~., ·fi~'I:!;l'O'I'I,;t!;s:~~n ...,:ii: ,..:L . .,., f·;.....,I:~ .. HI !I.~-l~l ~~·v~~:(J,·r.rt.'~~l\J • I.:_.-:..,~~ __ ~~~ !IJ.~ u~-~ '~~~~"l !IJ.~~~~~~-_,_ ~cf. ~_~ __:~~

"'¥,--'oiiIim~:-~·m'~".;Co. '!UiJ\;!i;,m..:'! ,ii;'Ii,.,.,.. 'I'Iit:>O!I;,.:Ie--r ,·;iIi,.~t-, 'jU'~/~ ._. jii; ''IlU.I!''ll'~11 'l'II!I;'i!'Ill~ , b~.c!· ~w-n·~I:::u~'I:I!III;"'Ii,·1I!I; . 0""

~~IIiIII. - Ir\~t~~ 'Rd- ... II~I !l.IJI~ i&L~U['_~, Ul.:illl, JI'iiiJ.UL-I· -n' ·W, ~ ~ ._.~f~~ ~ ... : _~I ~,,~,~~~, __:_~

dJu:ties w.hen. :he w:ri'tes, t'he Metdpiyuc& of ,Mora15'" He se;,Yi tl~l,t~ he has ,adopted the dt.v:i$l!M, :ttot:D11l:llly' ,m, use by 'the, Sc'hODIs,w 'wilth [mile dlU'cren<l'C: :he~ mifi.ks ,tha,t~ 'th,ere Ire. :in:mer liS weU ,is [Guter :pm-eet

~~I'it;~oI!O'C! 1,(,"- Al"'i 'ii"ji"i;~I_ '~i1r!ti'~ ·iI!· I.' [~,ii,d'- 'nu~~;i!:--'il,~; .. ;17 't-·~~~~,D,"·;>i!n,:l:.:ltCi!,~'''''''.:i ifiI."":~Ii'n;J!OAI,iJiJij'

U"Yj!lrJ.~~ ~I~ ~1iiQ 1"',II."I~ r. "·,[~""'''.''l 1 IHiu W 'lr. Ll.J.£_U"I .. _1:1,,_ ,J,'Y.JLe1'"w~I.l:J. il'.li!lwl~ ~1 ,iIl~1..,...Ii .... f@.

I 'I"~~"'f~ 'be; 'IIn:trodmced ,iii 'mMe 'ocfi ,3il1ld [oomn'~lca'bed c-1.a:5'5~8~atifi'm ,m

~ll J 'I '7" r/: ~ [ " I.. ["" _ ... , "... ., • " ,', ,I."" " , t.. ".,"" ,~i" • ,. ". I . . "" _"" r. " '" ."' _ '

dLII~j+iiiil!!li!i\" B-:i!ii~~; 'm"-iI"!l'llr:'''''g.·~, i\li"!'ll t~t. [n'll'~\_IfO~'[il'\LTi. iI"!lf:: '~rrw Tt'~([~t-· :~_.,!f,:~'b~~:l~-(~I1..~-,~\ ~,t.;~; ~"""'!Iio_'_"'" ,_l!r._~Q.\.... ,,_.v,. h._iIi '.' !I.i~ ,_JJli'!r. "t. ~'!wIil'[",l'!o.!l"U v, ,1.I.u _ _ l'!io.iiI!_H ... eiill'!l.iiil .I_sues [ •• u,C

_- ~

'\\!',"';~i<:'':'ci.t!Q' ill'iJ t":L. 'mli"ii~I]~ '~'~'II~~~ '~\ w~il~'~. ~ ... iIt;o;,~1..~ tl ... ,. ii!i1iji!D!i\i!!i,~\ "'~~j~ ~t;~;i.i!i_~ I t;'ir, ~IJe: _ ~-W~l "!o!'~ 'y"''!r. ~u,,,,,!PI!,, ~_Q'~.!',Ii __ ,1'- _~ '!iih,.,"",,",",I\~ IU]}"", r.:i!'l"'-!I.''!I.--....'' v.,f, \!IU,!r_t\.s !r_liliilli,.

K"'I'n* sees .... Ii~,* '.'r'i b·.I~;r;: l"'l.iltiillit" Wiil']l,l"J11~ _,~4 ~-=--~~ !;JI~~~ M~ ~ [I~' ~_~--Q! l _g~~-IIJ . '" I!.J!'I!!::~~

Copy rig hted m ateri al

[exberns:lo~s, of' (un' :~nndlte ri~,t '~O freedom.,

~,~ ,M> "~ri'~'iFli:l.:'i7, ':jj1o,~'.t","",~ P'-~':"'Iof'i';o,~~'''' i0~J, ~:t;'~'i'Ni 1~"'i"Iill!i!i 'w~'~lb~.' '~,"n;i:i[r~IU"Fri~;i!i:

II [[I.... ,. JDl .... iiIr~IIT rLI!;& ... w_:J. . .•. ~_ili_",""JI~t~~!3I v.1 l!t' tilL.; ~w.oY U!tIiP~'J'" ~ ~ tI!"" __ I ~._~-~ '141 __ !\i.~"I!i!-~f.

,.!i:TI"-~'~:~, ,~i' '~~~i~~~--:i- '~" ;~'Ii'ir~,\~ .... ~ 'i~'~~iji'lIi! ,'.:I!ilf'?c~,i!i: '~~'m.,', ii;"i'l['i;;iI'I;, nf '"ii'~I~iii,;o;'i!!i in, iI!i~'V',o>;'r,a'~,

u."Uh .... es 0.1; v,~~r",ue. ,n, u,!I.nY """,I, 'NI_~"""I,I!;,; u_liu",if", ,~c" .... ,_~ V~_M,;;- _~ JI!;.iI!""'~"""I!;,.' ~ !iI! ~ _

'wa,y-s,. :iPlet, a, !~.lU1t:~,. of. 'v,inue mvolv~s t'he free adapti[OD 01 :som,e end 'w'hiJclI P1D'l, pla(,twcaI rlumn dJ~rl~'ts, DuJt-i[e5j of 'virtue ar.ilse from, dle:

S'Ur,p:em,e P,f;\I.nd,ple 01: the Doct_ri'fiiC ,of 'Vir.Ule: i)',hCit ,aooomin,g, 'bm a, 'maxim, 'w:huse ,ends :aI'e IU.CIirJ~ '~b4t i"it [em be a, 'tlnir'Y1H:S~, la,w tllalt~ ,~::-:~" r:::-:'" :-, :til, ~~~,~' 'th! ~s~, ---:" ---:-' dil'" ~MPV ~,ii'i]'~ )-' - a:s 'Un'lflCie; ,die U'1lih!"l~mal'Prin€i",

eVC'F;YIIne, .a:ve .. c c en, ~ ,-, " _ ,;J'~ ~ ," , ,' ,',', , __ ,_, " , , __ ,,~ ',~, ,. ~ __ ,~~ ,_

:pJ,e~ of' JU8.t:iJe:el mis: :,nnc~iP:te :~s s,n:t'ibetlc:; ;s:~n,a; :il ~h'etts tbe ,adc",twnn, [of ,eillds, ,81ild, :8.0 cfim£emS, our 'm~tlrvle8- h, must he; esta.'bUshed t-ba't'it

., _ _ ,I. . _" '. _- " .. _ . _ .... _, l __ .• __ " - I- 1 l __ 1 .• - •. _' .•• -.' ,- •. l __ .• _ •..• _l ". l .•

,ai\\,-fiH~s 'I'D ,thei h:-~m:afi, will ,I,t ,IS d,educed &riRl, the 'l'¥"ssi,'b[U.l.~' 'M '~lJire;

~~~ ~.~ ",~

'c '·~---:f,~a'~c~~3!SI :;-1- 'It, -:'[;1 ,31 'llt'atUife Qf. hlilm_ b~~n~ md n~x:'babl'w' all ,p;EaC1C _, :Ie - on" ,. I "" ,- , ,'_~ _ -~ ~ --"'~~~ ~ .t'~~ -~ ~ -l~-~

,Ir;d,t-e 'fatlona], bei-n;p ~-hat W~ :ai'W,Ji,y\i aClt, fal' an el1d, (ll '1il,=I:D.4 TP

"';"T-;(\'n.' _,ClI"''Ii'Io~-1 _A_ ..... ,;l1 i7;!!;~'Ii!I;~;iI!; :l!~I;!!;~'~_'loI'!o l·'M"'J~I'I"Ii'!li'''-;IO:' 1I!!I;rC! '~'!Ii'!lll" '~'il;tlil~'I'\"';ro, .. D";C!; 'iIi'n ~l f 71__}_______ .1;J!~~~~~'!i .nJ,;~Ul~ ~~-~~-~ ~~~~~J.r~ ~~"t~ ,~&.L¥!\o~t:' -.J"~I ,III~;)' ,IIJLu~~~"'L""~,," . -~ ~~

,ens, [the mau~r of cho:i.ce) wl~j[tih, :may' 'be: ,co:n't[;QIty' ~o dJu;ty~ le.gis:la-, live I!EISO'J'lt, ClnnO'~, ,iilJ.DQ ap.m$,t~ d~.eu' :mfll)uenrce: odl,el' 'than..r tm, 'tum ... 'by :m-ea;ms, of in [Gp'PGSi~ng' :mDta'~, end, w:hidl, merel-ot-e, :il!Uli8~: be ,g],,,1:0, ,ti, ,;ri'()'l~' mdependen,tliy Qf' i'm£-Una:ticn" ~,MPV ,3,8:1 );, biac~i,tall\easoj], is ,3,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

:fao't.d.t.y o£: ends, 8~) .if there is '~le p,f~c~lcal :reason. ,['hele m.illst 'I[;e :Ileoess~ff' Iw,ds", Tb.~s: :nle'.alls ,t'~:a.t dtere ~IYe d~,tles, '~O :h.41~!Ye ,th,ese ends,

.-!i~U~'iii~J~c;, ~i,: "~iF'~il~<:iI' ~'M~,~TJi~~' :j O"j;f J'

~i I!IL-:-,I;!~ ~J: ¥·~.~!l.U!\.r ~t'.~ ,LC 'w.- J.7J Oil

Th'fl; ends 'd')~.t~ ft~n set$; :are :huJuanii'ty :in, (In,~'~, I(!\W:~, :~T,sG':n :and,

,~,'I!.··I·' .!: ... , ""'~'., "..ll ,j;"~lll" .,", '."f'" .. II!.,_", .. ,i' .. '.' v ., ... if: ...•...

';;II!I',~, 01 every 'O't~1el'1' ,~:c;,w.i! :fo.~ .i(:i!Wln,g, ~rom, '~~],~d,.!' o:~e. 'S oOiwn, p~rJ,'~C~lJ@-n =

' ...... 0··' ral ""', .... ,,1 ·n""iI".I'II''''-'~ ""I<i'']' 'iI"'~;a;, L ~'nn~·n·""''''''i .-.f··:: ..... ""'L.""~ 'M····· i'P~il" ~ iii! ~ OI'ii!I'~ V···: :'i"r~ ~~t:_'~~~ ~~~g, ,~,~.~!~P~~ __ . = ~~Lg ~g,iw§, .gar,r~,~!1;--~-~ [~c_ [~il{~~~,~1 ~f~':'~- V' .3IQjJ~_Jg![~I" .. :~'-

tue also mco~"a'Sses, the dJ.!,(I,tj~s, 0.1. :iusdlCie.;; f~dlts ,u:e sacred eo I, iI'i@[Son 'who 'V1all!!l@s, bllnlilam.t~' ,DrlJ acts of '~US,tiCl~ ,g'~ '~1"ans.mrm,~d :into

lI?'" ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~~. ~ ~ ~~~~~~.~ <1:,1 ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~I~. ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~.~~.~~ .. ~ ~~ ..

~('ilt~ Qf 'v:irMl~ w,b.i~~, d'@n~ for thi~ :~~S:~D" TiOl ,~mi,~l'~ vi'~tu~ 'W'e ,m'~iS:t ::J:d!;:-r;,,,,'" 't'Ii'!U;1i8~ ends f'mteilv W't"li' C31Ii!Iinot' be !CiA~rGed tn, a.diA'n't t'~~m 'in two

.. -_ ¥J?"-~l .~~J~,...=.-~-...=. ...=._~~.~-_J ,I~,~, .->"'='_-:__'J:~I' ..... ._=.' . ...=._~.l~~~~ ~ . ._!l .__: .. ._:- .. ,:,-~.,:::--~, ._=..::<' '~,.....:. .. ~ ",:.~,V··~~ .~~J~-"'='-~'~~j! ,_~~ ~~.~- ... :",:, .

. ~ ~". ~r~' ~" ... ,... ,".~ ",' -., .- ... ~.~ "~'~II '. ,'" '. t·, - .~ .. ' ,..... of.·. '.' -.' ..... '., ". '.' . '. ,'" .~ .. ..:I., - ,'. .. . .~, ·dl ' ,-:I

sense:~", .It l5 .il.mpOSiS\lr;J,~e ,~D . act ti~ ,!liiQ1['~ ,S(lVIUeo:me,. ~Oi ,a'\l,Q,'~ :8!11ll;l:m :.,. ,_~,

,.,., ,,' fe. '11] . .:1 ,. '. ., ... ,. c.", ', .. '1:;.- ... , ," l'~I ... ~ .,.,", ." ',;j,,.', ,.,:, .(1'. ..' -. 'M·····', ' .. ~II .. u ·'k·' .. , ,. I .' ",",~.-:I

lille won iIiJ, In la;oi" ease iIlJII;, ,I !I,e.81III Q"WI,lle !liO '.' ,0 ,SO."'~' ,~IP~J.mg :Ii, ,g~,

. I:' < '1 ..:I,:, I ." ''''t''", . ." ,',' . 'Iio, 'jIl-.~,- .. ;1II· ".'-' " t; -.;I... . 'b'" ,., ." .. ], i ',' "'I'!iJi:>~.. . -,

[Dor.a" Ii;QSPOS:L-~~n 'cgJt,@", ,~~u:elJ }1i(:\l,.U ,~r.,e~Qm~ ~u~ 'onLY mI,Y ~,I;Q!rm,~

mG~:', 'WIi~ng' I~I' ,aC'(loD'~ [~MPV' l~·I:&lI: ...... ,S''l~ll.

l I' ~ '. I.' • ~ 'w .Ii!: ~ , . w. W ...

. - . - .

:[lu'~i'e, I~f 'virtwe ,2!re of '~[;)']~''Oad, 'a'bHI~!t'lla'.nJ whj~e d.u't~,e:s, of '~rus,t;tce a:e

'(!ff $ttd~~ o'~~~:igB~~il@n" :DUI~ir~ !@f :ju~ltl~~ :~'~qYiffiIr~ p~nicJ~l~r !I~~cloos 'o:r

.. d h ·bl· . . lerb ~ 'iIi..~ A· 'L d' 'l'iIi:

l~ml.SSj-~Sli' ane 't.~e; O\.I~~pU!J;D, lSi sn:Jlct ... eeause ,~t ean ee ~'-l;~Clj~l~tg.e_" ,liw:

'~'(JU '~ri~t',m !1, ~uS!~: acnon,~ 'it '~~ :~Q~: credi-eahle· 'Ilnl!~, .eu~~, 'w'ilitallt: '~U~, CiWie!-

;J' ~ -- ,~~~ .. ~~.~ J ~' ,_'_ ~~ l."""l •• l."""l' - _ •• , •• ~.~. --'~'-'-~~"JI! -- .~.- J-- ~_ "' .. ~ w

~'f' "'UIlI do 'noit, '~0'1!1 'h~v~ dQ~fll ~m~tth,~ft,D' 'bad lMPV' '~8fi_n; AI" hut ~; R.

'--' /._ '-.' ~ -' '----.-~ iI' -' ~-' '- ~" .. -. ~---~-'- .-._.--.-. ~--"'-"'Q! -'~~' [~- .. __ .. ~ .. ;:,' :l;"'1I'~1 - ~'_' '_'-'.~ ~.

2.,~n~,l3:~,~I ... Du'~i'~S! oOf vicn:u~" 'by' ~~t1!tra~;~ t-eU, 'Y~U ~Q' ~d.oprt 3!~d, pms'1!l,~ ~],~:3ihili ~d;s iCUCill,. a d"~ltv' catWlno,t si'm'nl~' be ,diS""~1:;s,"'D',~AI 'wr 'tdb~ ends

[~.-~_~L_~':________'_~' '~.____:__..~~.o: .;;:;Ii.~~-~-~~ I~' .~.~1~1J.' . ._:~_'~- ~.'~' ,~_~~_II. 'r"~~' ~.~ ·~.--~~~~,t ,~~~~ .~-~~ ~-.____:__.~

• . .. I .' ,... . .. .., . '1;.._. .,. .'1.·' ~'., .. ~L,:, ". ·,!II ,E" . 'h·'Ll'· >. ..., h - .. , ..

JJn q),iIll~s~u~n ~anno~; ~ IQ~mp~~~e!l,y a~QIev:-e.;w., I~D ~~ .. ;~ Ol;i!t~plt:to:n, ~Fer-e 1iiS,

'brr~a.dL T-o, d~e. ~,t'emlt tha,'[ 'ylO'u :ptwl$ue ehe ,e~d~ ,9J$ 8irl end di,c,t:a,t~, b,

''''IIir.;.' ·~!"'W:" 'Vt'fiL'i'~1 , ~h· '~e~;;·oie~· 'I"i:1"fil~''''l ~iilflifri.Tiii'jI!-.. Cn '~..ifIiT 1~\;;'I'm' ~ln'~lofI; t';I-;'e- n~~n"'J 'P'.,.l1f-.n,

"..illli!Ooo .!I'IIII, .... '" ,if uy 'l1li ' ·ilL .. ,..,. &n,U;!illc' ',",'!U!"& lIioili],. av.r ,~.'v& "'_lIIo'lOli·· ,it"tili,~~, . _[iii IF·!I.\IJ,'Zl!U>L".I, '!I!'!I!',iIi]..i ....

'ft:'a'H;SPl;eSSes, 'the :~.oT;~I,ts (,I omen, is bad, 't'i~lIe, qersOH. wluJ SJ;m'flIl"w,CJGn·,

~. ~,~,~ • l~' [r" II:

f1JlfllS, 'VOl ,t'be~ :li3!w :merely does w:h::u :I.S, ((wea\l' 'but ehe perm'!], w.ih~1

c.oilf,O:u:usl 't1J 't'!},e, liil'w' Ib,~ca;u'$,e he 101' s:he, has m;a,d)e the :righJtsl of: k~ms!fl'· ity' :bis, or :bie1" end :~Sl moraU)" I~,ood [~:Ml)V ,,90=9':1 l"

'file Id'lsrtbtct·l!o.il be~,ween S'frJ!c;t 81if-Jd, broad, ~:h~ip"t~O:fJ;S is :sD:ttieum,es, c~t!i!ise.d, 'widlJ 'dle: di,~tifi,DtiO:[l 'be~twee:m, :pe.dect: iI!~d iITh~iPe:lic.e-it dut~,es\ .. K3int htliJ1$eilf does n~t use the i'Ourf temll.$ m, a pe:t:$,\pi(,~ll'~ w,a;y: .. :l6 P'enect: du;ti,es, r.,enuire defim,te ,a£;'t~,o:ms, ,or 100.issil~n®1 'w:h'ne ,in 'we

"':L _

ease o~' im'FiIif"Ttect d)w,ti,esl :~ndb~:ado:n is ;aU,owed t;o' ola,,,,"' a :r.1Qle i'r]i, det:e4t•

lr'- . r ~ .

'~nJ'i~I~' lexa£t'~v' 'l",'lliJt :.'Did 'How' IDJu;e-h WIt: w~U d)~ t;o, IC8'I'""ii"V mem !();ut

,_. I_.. ,~.IIIiIOI .• _ •.•. ~ ,:.01.,. '7 .... '}1 '. I .. ,~., I. "' ,-, .. ~ '.~ _' ...... ~. 1.", •. '" ..•. ': .~ ••• ~~=-i',1 .~- ' ,._, .. '_.'. ,."""11

:D,ut.iJes: '01 ~iI!l:sct'\ilc.e :aJie aU perlec~~, but tbeJ\e 8Jle bo:t'h, im:pedec~; ~nd,

"-' {:"'- ",..:1 .•.. I .,j(, .", .' :. ":i[~' 'L .. ,.... . . .,."" .__(' ... ' ..:I .... ,. !; .• ,. . - !'I!.. ....

,~.I:I'~c.t u;uttl!es: 0-1 v,~.rtIue~. Y¥ie li1iaVe~ ,;lin unpeu,ect IIjJ,U;!I!.y 01: YU1:;l!f: w,!n.¢;n

't'h,etle l's i;1, nOSltl,\!'e end t::o '~mmO't;el but 'we L1W' doesl nnt ~::3!~ ,euC,tlJ.V

r ,~. _ IT ,,.

i.~~1i'. 'qiiJI.'"" .1"i;j;s~,"a~'tjll"';Ci; .. 'V~1I'il ,mi~l"ii~'~ ~:o:: ...:i:~ • ...,,].rji:i:'li 'v)l"!i,~u~'ii' 1ft000.l)~I;i[.Q, ,d;n,<iI n'Jli;;'l.je~·~ [kC~I~"

,[~'V _co, r'U'tl,LC.I_ .lI.; .. ~!,;,;- .... ~ ,i' 'Uy "",,-,!!;;u,," 11., .. ILl,.,. 'I'!I;r_ iVif,'" ". 'V. ,IJ, 1~_iQi """ .... OIJI~_ ... !iII~&\J, iF·!U' n' ~,"W 10, .... ,'"

,U;]l, :may e-hoose ,t'h{Jse~ thilt: arc: :sui'taible ~D 'your IOCQupi1lt"io-n ,wmd ttaSit!e8

Copy rig hted m ateri al

1'."C·~"P· ::II n"', ~ ''U'~1I'I' ~n ..,'1.,;,., ."'"1 'n!"if1imlo'" 'i~ ''i'IIl...;;o. 'L''''II!\'nm'', ',o:.i!o'" ..-.~' .... iIi'Jh''''',.,.,,;, :L'Ii>~' V{Ii"l'il ~~¥j_~'~ ~'7-l~~,~ ~~~ ~~WJ'l l,~ .If"'l~ 1,1 ,'_' ll!o~ !tlJj]t~ .lr[J~;~r··· ~~I:;I! ~1l: v11i:._, ~ra, [1J!~1"1 ~ Uy

ma.,' coneentraee y;our ~ffom OFl. m~ h3p'P~·PJess of ·,~U'r' :f-Jiends, (.M·P'V" 3,901,. :Pe:ri;~ct d'Utlle8 1M vl'f,ilJUe ,a;ri:se HCafljSe. 'W~ must refrain. f'rom .p~m~.u]j:ar .aet~~nrs 1~~in\St' humanity m. our I~W:rn. :permn er tna:t I~f another .. Surilcidl~, p~!lysican'y' Id~t_nletiVie halbi.ts,,. ~nd. ,t'b~ .1'aU.u'~'es I~f aeJf"f,apecit ~ib:j;~ed 'in ~U~d~.p~i~n and ~~nrUUy v.i~b;~e ~d~ct dllJjtie~s ·tn '(f!L!II\se:m,v,es. (iM'Pry' ·42. ~~-·4-4-:~'· :PoaH.w,e:s of: :re~~-e,t.! ~,U!~, .;I!~ ,cd ... u~rr,~~', m;ckeoti'V and inr;l~"'" "riO:~~lte '~mct: .dll!~i~$ tm others 'M'PV'

,_,iii", ,,' {J - . '\.,- - -'_ .ir ,- j~, ~ ,_c - -, .t.' ... ~= " -, -, - -~~~ ~ ~ ~ -- -~~ !t- ~~ ,

4':l,-68j a .A:F:Jd. ·~'be I~m.efal 111ll.t,,' to ~d~pt .moxaU'y' ,~ood ~~dJs ~ t'h~ (h,u~y oi moral ped~oti,~. - is p~d~~t, Ado,iPtmg ~ ~~d! is, ,;I defim:i:f~. tho~ :iJn'~~miIJ~, ,a~ti~n. :!8u!t, :ma'km,g: sottIJ:e.~hi'ng yOWl end and, m:.1·k.,~

l·omg" 'iIi'L_,~"'" ""i,iI'Ii-"~ rh '_~ mu ..... 'i~~~ 0' ~ "'-~~'1'III" "'l ndu .... 'iii' 1',"' ,,","..,..t' ,,;tiii<m:I"i'".iL'~·I,n:g-": a' '~,-U''''''','''-'''--'''- ,'I

.11. !ll;DaI. 'lW..L1._tl I - _l1li. ,I. u!t.\;~·'I! ~. ~I . u.rl.&.li. ~u ~.ur.II..r.~, . -IJ! ,1IL--'U I ra"U' .. Ll .. ~I. . [I '~]l. :IHI.J..:.iII.,;.&MW,

~--'-' --- - ---- -~- - - ~- - -- - - - ,,' - - - - - - - - - - - - - .... -

\w;mg ean simply ,de,dd'~ ~n at O'~~~ t'O" do. 10m' .m.(1ft~:~e!i t·O'l' ~be "QUit,'~ w,i1Jm. ,~Cits, 'W~ dQ f'ur' ·tb~ ends, :may 'be: :nEXlOO, 'wi't'h .tton'·.tttG:.::a]]. m~· 't~.vles~, ,;t]lIrll. ''Y''''e: ·c_n(ift be cettw~n dl31Jt: the,' al'!e .pure r·Mpv .3 9·,l;~91'., 4f'I"""4)~ S~~ alse R. 19i";''3'Q~. :f(lf ~!I1$'tamQeJ' "O,1!], IM3,:Y :resO:~.V{el 'when 'c~~pt~ :n~t t(1i! ~Qmi~ll'i.t ~uidd.¢: .nQ,t~ ·lJm.y- because you. value h"wm:arn .. • lltlt bl. YO;U[' 'crwn :peLSl)l1 'Duit because yO:U, alC~ mBlI,dJ; ~([ ,'(f.uiif 'ben,el1 .. " cenee ,[OSl" ·re.qru;~Ie '~]le ;slUp,rntt (Ii: YO:lnI :DIB.tuml, ;S')!1Eipa·li~i}es,. So' :ian.'t g"SI lof ·dle du:ty ·of :m~l,a], peIfec:tl~n, that it: :~'.SI .... in '(l'ua11:lry s.tri~.t ~d.

Hidio...l,;'i"O;Ii'· ~J,.;i"'ii~liIi""C'" .~'i'Ii, .;l1iloilfT'iiIo. '~it" '~i;Q_ b read and im ·lne.,.1'~Ji"I, .. ,~J· ,~'M' "1~iiH AI.iih.t'i L"'fli.."" r!!ir:i;I~·~~,~, L~L_W,u~'~:Jl 1~11_.1::1 U~t~f.l~ l~l. 1~_Qi .. !lVAc.·_' P--I~.-_ ~,~'I!P.I-D~-~~, ~~"'d-If '" ~~gJI!. ~.~~

int~~. ,ilct~i~ns. dlat aile r~-q).m~d ar~ d~.'~e;!' bu~, ~h¢:1' De n()t~ dl~s· dlaq~;)jble,!, V~rlting !b:umi!l!~i·c., in. ~h~ .proper ·W'a., MUSIi 'be wtu:ked a,t~:· iit ~s an ffin~em;Jil labO'f w.~.th. whdoo W:~ I;t[\'e :~e·v:-er· siulply done, SOl t't~e (I:bUIJ·t:i,QDS, ,of ·V'.inue are ~lw.a".s broa:d.

I~ th~re ·arre :~m' l~te~ri&S· of' df~.tJes, ~f' v.~rtue: (I ~ :perfectt: dU:iics in, Qn~L t'O" p;rlese'J"Yi~ amd. :f.1~S~:c;t the .h.U'~.t~y 1JWl. iQne~'5, Oiwn. pe~rJ.; ~~, :bmp~r:f:~ct; d,ut~,~ '~~ !@n~\!' til)l d~'V~liil)p l(itn~~'S, ihumanj.'tYi' :~nitenec~u,'· ally .arnt1. :pb.y$tcalfly·; 1~3') diU:t~,CcSl ,o1loIV'C .'fell· othe-u;. tn P'ltJwote 'c:b,ej;z:' ha,pm.es&~: and i:4l1 d.md.es o~ .respect f~f:' othe~;s;l' ifiC::~lU.dii1\g: respec~: :fot m@'lf' r.l~h;ts\" 'The d.eg:ree of one's v.i;rtJ.te :~5, m.e3?sure.d 'by' me e:€Jteut tD' '!I\i",·~ei, ... ·~ .... ifi"~; ~"~''''\'''''''~~I ~;'ifi" ~I;O:;:"ii?)tf ."';~l~· :~1: ·"t·h- ',;;;.,iC'_;iII!. "d- ueies ~~~'ii'i" t :It:;i;!! 'n,,'Ii'I·ro;;. moral -",,-,111111;,0_1111. 'UI!I.... a;!I,n .. ~~a 1111, Uu'lilO~ib 111'_11: __ v .. , !!O, _ 111.;"'.... ,_ !.II!1"-li .... Q! !lc'l'~'u.I'_:u~ _U('!;"P.t' ~""" ~,~_·~i ..... ~ ~

D'iU"lti:V\e of r'~g:a£d. for :ib.urmmi:t.y;, ·~.mpJ~t~ 'vittue is, '~Itta;~nab~e (in. this m~~,~ ·so om' dUlty' to a~m~Vte it .is itself lo:J~ broa.d ·obUp.ti(JA:: it is .31. d~,ty t'O :~ro,p~ss, t~w,;udJs iit (MIlV'· '409"~; C2. 8·.l;~:8,6i ·~r.P .J;8\4,~1 s:~.

Kaint ~p1!1i'FlSi ,aU. ~J ~:u;f.' dlNl:ties· :!In. t'tltiJl$ 100f freedom", D~,H,es· cf Jus:tioo $,(.m@l: .from. the 'very idea, o~ exU:rnaJ .. lr.,eooow::: ;3, wo-r~~.d :m ·wmioo. ~~~ryIQllh~lS' :r.~;.gb:t~, are :r.es~t~, i~ aJ 'world :irn w:btcn. co:mptcet.e e~t:~m;ll :fJ)~edo:m. is, ~hi~v'ex:t Virt~ue :~s 't·h.e .a.Qhi·evem.e~.t~ lof imnet

Copy rig hted m ateri al

~'!O "i. ·K·. A" ". "":'Ii·T,."!D: ~. ["-"1 H." A' .... '~'.". '!I'['!:!!' 'I' '~. O. [- .. f' [;i'"'i;J 'I!i;'~'~'~'

~~ '_ ~,_,'_ ,~,~j '_' g! ,~1t\" y,~ ~ ,_,~ .~ ,g,& ~ .__:_ l~ U If ,g ~

:&eedfimt :£Of the vi~O'Wls· :pe-;tSOil 8,C,tS £tom £[ee,ly ·cllosen. [ends radr~,el' ·dlaIl be~ng: .gtf:v~med 'by :Wfi!dl~iuiJ@fis aind. d!es~I~-'S!. :1' ·~rth. fif: ·t't-le5e 1];~dJ8. 001: d)ll'ti,e"S we:m·e u'Iiii',e-r~saUy :p:r3o'c:tlced,. :mumsn, ·~imp. w·ould 'K: in ecvery' ~en'$'e tt-ee'.

Th·~ 'n~t sttiilli1'Jl. in 'r!~, ~r.~r~[n~WI'ro1:'if~ :~r'Q1'I.'fi'ri'II~'itf'f ",~ tiii"i;, ,-c~,l!'1i'iI';ii.1i; tt,J..jli; 'i'f,~iiii'Ji"il1 ~ _~ ~~-~ ~ _ ~I----'¥~ ~-_-= __ ~ Y;=~i!r.ol~_=-W, .. ~~~..l ~,~~~'_"J~~~"~ 1~ '~ I:~~R\\;~ l~~1;t1!r ~ '~!I! ~

f,'o:m:uuJas, :aib,ead,' ,~.v~n tQ o:~e ,mo~'b~I and, :Pl'OO~C~ [a '(hh~d,

Obje~tiv:e~y t111e W"~~d of ,~I, pr~¢ti~!I~.legillsl~tioo, lies I~rdi~; m the ,~!ltS!t. pl'iim~~,.I,¢1 :~p 'th~ r~aiL~ ,_dJ :m t,,!t~ :f;u~. of '~~,'V'~[r:~;U'ty; whim, :~'k~ :it ~pa!bl~:

W: M~i'llg ~ :Lac.W' , '. ,;, :SJubje:ctlvely~ ~Jt 1ies in du~ end. B:uit, ·th~ sl!l~jwt o~ ,aU ~n~8 is ~~ :far~i~aL b~~~;,~ ~ e~~ :~g :i't$e'lf: (by the ~~on4 :~Jindple~l~ b- 'Wls.. tlit~fl~ :t~umjJCw~, ,th~ du;rd ,pI;aClt~cat ,mfi~~pli\i: [~.f t"~~ W.~m~, ,as We 5U.P(;~m,~ ~diF t~omJ nf its· '~a!~Dulu,[.y' with ~fiI'i,vefiSal fJuc'ltic31 :mammlr V~;Z:~", dl!J ~de;a, ~ th& wHW '01: ~~r:y lEa)tio:_~, :ooing ,as .~king u~~v1~~$al ,~a.'"t ~G 43 :~: I

llil,ti[CWi!l1 'H;'~np are: dte; de)t'G,m'~fU~-;ES oJ: :ends; - 'the. eaes w:l!io set: ''l!'\a_l~e. 'iln, mi'mlgs" So Iii, r[a'tiou'~, be~n.I: 'nli)UI't VaJillll,C r,a'tional :~a,u.u'e as, an '(!(iiid, In

~''';C!;eu~- dlft,.!ll .'.. is 'W' ·'l"·.'b· "'h' 'II co .,..n,ll 1"'Il''10 '''!I'-~;iIIi,W'' ,;j;'IL-,~,;t, W" iI'o r:!;;o'!i;t, ~'ll'W. n.ft m' axims ~,~_~ ._111"1 [ __ ~,dJI~ ,~~ .. _~ . _. ,IL-:- ! I~J _~~l ~J.LIiUl ,.hl, '"",~~'..,' ~~!~l ', ... _:1~ ~~'l ~:W"~' [~~~ ,~,~ _I~~:_._!~'

''iili·' .... '~.t"~ ..... , ,;to\i\ji.'il'i~.~ ~e~' 'i,'iiI_n·~.A."e~:II'Q,;j;l. '~,;!IiW:~'~,io! P,m"";i'!;e~' '~a ,o!i'lfe- '.'~;I!Ii' ;tr;.'I'i!ce·~C!' '~'~.r"I;, '~,a·~~'"

nJ~IJ_II,,..J;1l ~!W·JI~I:O U_~,"!P,' ~,~D_ ,1I_GI ,J!;;f. O! _ ,'Ii;i, lJ'!I'''''' II,;,IJ,,_, !llill:rl.~ ~-.L" ~ 'P."P.',l.lrl~ ,~£r.& __ ~~

'['a,tional naitJUt:e OUI' efid~, W'e ;are ,t'b,e, ones 'who gi:ve [~'U'[8eilv,es, 'this law~,

'WIiiJ ,;oiI-'" ;oi'ii'iI:ti'~'liifj;iFi;m- -'nlliiiii!.

' -e :'0.1"," iRc .1 .. ; HMJ~V.,~;I~( ~ :',-V'!OiP.!iil<.

~"~:r~, i"iI,~ 'tr'UJo'liFil1 'Uil'i!ifU\~ n" ~""m;'~;I~' m-~;,niii'l"'ifl!'iI~\tid"1 i"iI,'i'~~~~o::m",~-,iI'jL'i'i~~V' ,;jJn.'" '~,~~,_

I.ll_~:..r_~I~ 11IiiIi_1I.!Iirl !ll.nu 'P."P."OI,Tr~ uil, ~_- -"_ ;01 '_" ,U'I.I._- 'l'1iII1.i'w.'- , ,mY,l.iV.o-.ll_oIt," [,' '!I;I."l!l.li_~lIl'E !CiI_-il.l.-UI '-W~I"l

;b.-n .... m"~ --.", .. iI'~IQl~ 'U 1iiIiJ'i..,.:>n Vt\il ~ ac 'i!'.\tI; 'i'n;n!il' 'iiiil\;o'i;""",,-'fi ;!Ii~iI'ii;,"ilin-t'!Iim'C c 'OCii~ iC'!t". v,iI":IIi'~1 ,;!j; ..... ' ifti..TiI, ,;:'II [~IJ,Uili_~'u'~ I, - ~Y_a!' ")/111 "li~ .. _~, J. '" .... I!WII l'i,J,1IIr. ... lllItUl.~ "'Y.'IIIIiII""~-~1 ~f""'~-IL7."""~ ~ [I t"_' u~~-.Lrt~1 ~(U~' ~~'Ll [~-.LIl, .:ii,

~:a,w t"hat YO.ui, giJ,vye tn, y1ourrs.eH:;: 'whem, yiou ,a.ct. :he;J:~GllCmo~sl"1' ehe :is,w

'~IiC! ,jln'il;itlin~;t.I;~ 1""'"1 'Vt""'i'jl b'-,it m ~'e~:an" ;1;1i'! 1fI;~ a" ,C!',;:i'i'fIl ... ~l"~n·· ' ..... vrv,jiii! are p·,!I' ...... ~7..ld: l,,",,~ W,·ji,t·'!Il.· ,;!lin

,111~ ,1I_"'"IHIl.t"WlaW~1 !Io.7.-.&_IJ, ,;.- !IJ!!!I.III I ",~ ,I,," . , -" _~I v~:]: I "['a:o. •• dll~I .. _- i~" II' ~-UI 1I:iiI~ ~, : I£v 'Y',IJ _t;UI '.", ,~"Inl, 1I:iiI~

~~n,'t'eites,'t :~fi ,actblg: 'an, j,'t" L'Ili.'k,e ,s. ;S:imp.,le e-xa'm,ple~: YO:]!i, migb~, abe;,' ,snm.e pos_];ti,v~~ IS/w =. :wr iMtil'flCel: 'JO:U mlp.t pB'y ,u~r 'ta;x:,es .= '~aiuse ya~, are :afraid lot ibe:ing puni's[l,ed :if 'Y'O'~, dO! fJ!Olt:. Thts :is neiieI1()fionl,Y; ylf~I

'i;i':"it· "'i"~~lt··· ·~'itl i"!i;,'!I",~i:;;Il~:nIj)" l.,.,...,:I'~i~' !D'L~.u.,'" ~~:Jn· .. ~:",: '\11 ..... 1"1. ~\Il"il "'h- 'OI! ·~:"'."i\i;". ~I ~:I,.,~ I~t'~ii!i:

L'~~::II ,-~II~·~., ,I~I::I 'H "'ll!.1.~.~~_.:ae Ir"!Id_~_'J_l_ ... _I_lJ._ltll!tr.lI::ll\:. li!at _ 1~ /' U~ l~V. !Ir_ ... ,1_iIiII'~'lr. V'tL_W, ;U;I .. n y, _iilJ_JJ,.._1

b~~d,; ,uu. migil,t Pal., '1:f~f; taxes, '~~n, H 'Y-ou 'ooiij~e 'tliiait ·,o:u c(f~ld ;a,v1o:id "i:~,~ ,e:i,dl,e,J; becaese Y-;'(fU), tb:in'k, eve·{t'Jlll'ile Shiould pay di.ei;f:' ,s:halc~i Of; b~c~!J~e; you d~d'filk m:a!il: ~()pl.e: :9h.0'~1d. ,~bei'" la,~1 made; 'bY' popu-ruar le.g'~laJJtin·J:t, TbeM; 'wo:~ld be, ~~n ,an '~;l1dl(lat_f;f' sense, ,e.;xamrples, uti ~lu'tJo:nam'y' - [o:f givtlllg: the m~,w' ttl, ''''O'YI~lf 'l!!iecl,use .of SJJme COW1'm'w,t" m,en'~ '~:Q :h~ iiiU· b~:U,ef :fD :i~; ~S' ~, ,b,w.

,'~[l)'m wh~Jt; :~ ba(V1~ s~id, :s:@1 f~r.~ :~,t looks, a~, :~i 'JQU ,cl@'uJd ,;td~.P.'~. P'Y"

n.,...'.". ..... 'n·'1 a ,""~'1' .. .,.. ... ''''''m·..,.'1,,'.,.l,u , .. , ... ,,Ji "",'L,." ,;:.)1.,.... "",i:: ''''f''~''''_'''_''''''''-'U'' ..l .... .,.;r!; ......... ' d· '.,.,_,.., .

~'~'~_~~:"',~J.If~ ~J~~-~~~~~,~!Yr.~I?!Ii'~J.:~' ~~-l~' U1Iic~ ,~tY"§~ !bI". ~jy.~~\M;lY~~,,;" IY.:Y~~ bI~~'~l ~~~~-~~' .. '

Copy rig hted m ateri al

.- -' -. ··It - - - .... - .' - '~- - h - - .- .' - -'" '-1' - .- ha' - -'. "- - - - '. - .- - -- - - - - -I' - - d" - - . - d'-' c--S'- -.-

... " .. '.' , ... ' ' .. ' " ... '. , ' .. ', .. ' . . , ... ' . . . " .. " ' ... " II" , .. '. I" ... '. • I : ."" "'1 "., .', co .. '1 .• I .'

Imine !t- . .e ~nce:rnt 0: I. t, .Ie .Pf"lECI:P' e tJ.· ,t.lS iIIHI!],l;cnomou!5 ,1 i~L op;t:e su . ,Jut,

:Kanl~~ ,dli'ln.'S, $ lit: .ih docs! and t'lna:t the 1c;a:~eprl~ .. l bD.:~j'a,'t~.vIE IS 1m. ;3, [spe~id 'w:ay' Wti :prinC~ll[e 'm aiU·~Gnomy;. ·H....:elt;ewno:mG-US, mmtivati.o:n ~ 1~.Iy be lIi5i50C~:a,t~, 'wUh h.ypot·het~,ciin. b'[nperait~ilV:~1 fQl-' 'lt~l~ h, .. po.thesls ,exptC&ses tlIDe mlt~est dl!a:t binds< yo~, '~~ dle la·w:. The mai'lil.

-.--h ... ~ --c- - -;;i..t.. -c - -.~ -"!i).,;- -'il ~'L.,---';'.'- LJ--·- p'---" ,- ~t..-' ,;.,'l.--- 'l..---p([Ule~m, 'W!UI! m.os:t: [eliliIlllcal. bleUll'Sits 1~-il'Olre Aant ];8 t;ua't "ley J.:iI1ii1!ve

~'liI;i·II • .A1 [I''oi;''i[ see ... ·Iit,,~ii- ~~,":,.,'Il ~,,...;j'r<'\!,I"!iiI~'1i'Wfi1 j'O;'Ii~""oj'i;;i: be '~:iiIi~:-:- ~i?nii?'ili'i"'-'al_. 'tr'iiti'itV "l~, ~L.QI.I""U '1oiU _""" '-.lil.a,,, ,1I1~iljJ\Ila_l. ,U;IIo,'!;.;!O !I:. I, _ a'!I...""""u. ";;"11'.1.1111"""" . ""' ,I'iIi'!wI"C:II,!U.II'J,v,III'J.LUU"" ,Ii..!!'IY"",f ,I.a

:S'~~sed. W[ ~jh~iG)il!1\~ 'US '!JJinooliiidJit~nfiianu, A-n'tii' '~h~oftt' ,that 'uies, toO[

···-·;~r·'!UIJI···· .. _- .. - ... l",_ ~r-"" • 1 ... >_'-' 1 _ I •• I,?~ .'Jl __ 'J?' .. -._t .... -.]1' .... - ]1 •. -_ ..•.

u~'i;~ain o·b:UQ-alticm. 'b",,' ,oH:~r.in~· 'UJS, ~1iiI iliil.t~l'~t 0.£ ~m~ 'kind !'D doiD'~

---"'T--= --",~,------~ _.'" -------~~~, .- ... = ~--------- .. -= ----~., ,--- l_"_\ __ ~

om' d~,'t~ nrov.jdeSI us 'yi~.tb aJ. 'nrindin]~~ t'hii:iJlt eemmands 'b!.~t·\he"t'~C3i-n\lt-

-----1~, -,,--- "'_-.~--;t"-I-_----~~.~.- '-1.t""'" . ------·1'1'

Dllt calt;e'goricaiUy, 'Whm. t'b~,e tm~rat~.Vt~ Is hiypo-di&tica~~"" we .a]wa~,s, ha!'fei 3JD ,~d,on~: [elt'her .~l:'lD ·t·!b,e ,action Of; ~i've 'iUJTi, ·dlie ·'iifJ·tge:r:eSit Ttl[

-- . ... . .. -, "".t'.,_ ,... ." -- ,,_ ,. ',~-;L,Ii"""., .. - . ... .... , ... , - 1 ... , ~~ . .. . -it' - , ... ,I , ,.. L ..... • ...

it-O["":~ail1l, o'hl~O'~tim'l[t 'we; need all ~m~em~j:'Y'e rtha:t h[flidle; \:WS, iLlfirondi-~i_ .. ·

~ ~ 'II.£-.L~~ If

alil,y .. Il!iI:t t.1i8 me.-aw malt: m:unral mr,Uw1Ul)1\ [f :i)t: [ex;i;sts~, miUst: be aU1~Ollo:mtfws· The[-e~ 'C3.'11 on~v' be o~,e: ]"~n 'w'n"" k.u.mlim bc~-n[g.Ijj;, m'UcSt

• I. " I •• : ,_ .•• -ell II _ r. _ .. _." ... _ '~- . _ ,_. [ " .. _ I ~. _;!' . _ . I .. /..a;;a_II\~~ . _._ ..

;n'~~ .1"'.1.. ... ~i;"iii'.,11 .~,>11.~~ ,;'Iiii!i"41. ·'T·Iit,~)i· ci;ifi' t'~I;'Iij~: 'w- ,i!ri"iNII!; '~l,",:"I;t- :I ......... ~ 'i:::..,.,. [<'i'L'II'i!~":':.tY~~1 ~IQ ""',~, U.LI!;;> JiU,v\UI .. 1! .hl 'n, A'lil,u 1Ii-.IiI.a'!I.. lA.lI .. U.~"" _ ~ '!w ~ ~ """ ","_U.a,_. I.A ~'I!' IliiV ""!I.U,a iC.!, _ "'"0 ~ 'lid"

I~

4-;3·~-')J,~,

'1h~ :brU(~i1D. wUl'mMt be :S~~. as, U!Firi'Y'e~'l.y' l~.gisla.tjv'e, EiIi.eh ():( tl!S,

L-""':'~'l (. L _(. . '~'- .. 1 ~ . .. I!.... ,. ·_._'Il:ii; ... ,:,1[ I;. . .... '. .. ... ;(". " .. " .~' ., . ... .

~ a W.g~ tDiilt .maIlKes, laWS, .!fQl' .~Jt~;n as, u: !lJ0'1' ~¥-e.Fy.Qn~, ~Jn,~~ .~J\l~.

be- '" - - - .'. - - - ,~., L - 1-" -1- ,'. - th' ~ - -- - '1 La' . 1"- . . . 1

--I .. 1" ,I ... , .' . ! .. ,. ,.' ,. ~ . . . : 1 I· . ,I 'I L _. . ..•.... , .: " :. . . .' 'l _". . . '.' '1 I' . I:. I . , ......• : I I· -_ .. ,-,. '., 'I' I.,

m,g~ cog<,l:,_ II,~ . ~ps '8.le .·.·c mora· .. ,W" we . (UM] ii. m.o:ra" oonnrnlU·

DI~' iii KJjiil,vflom [~f~ ·!Ends· Lne ·lt~fi·p:~D:m of: !onds is .all ·I.d!eal n~ is ~~',ii

_ : l!lr.~. 1 1 _ .• ~. I. , •• , ..• _ ••• [ . I •• , _ '~:~'. .,.. .., ~. _ • , _. , ·...!l1 [ ,I •

ii!lJC---, ~ii-·.ijti~·"'t'C~.t<:~ 'U- -"'fI11\i'fI.,fil ~~ 4f~~~-I:ifii:'ii~ ·;Ffii,~'oF.-i'f'l']j;~ '~""~~':i:":iigs--:-. ·~·~r-.'~'i'ighO: I ~"""m',::- iW',:-.- ';ffI.'"1

!ili . o.~~-LL-.iiIIJ.IAiiIl, .1I:!1i.i . ..: .. 111 'U1I::1I u.Jl; U..:II.IIr1i..i.., ..... LLII}.1 IIl!liiil ~ .. IIkI.'-iL-.III.gJII ~'-.Ljll.''''." 'II.~il. 'U"-w. . i!Ii.i~. ., IU'-L"

_. -.' .-.

laiWs .~j a '[cn,ubUe 1M a1Jl rB;tlfiul beifi,P\~ '[t ia: ,31 commUlmitv In w·hlich.

[ .. __ .. ..,. . I, .. ~ I . I.. • I.. ,., _ I. ... • .~:~ .. , I. . , _ •. ... ~. . .. l. .. _ I'; ." [ ...

&eedom 'IS '~eriect'lv' reaUzcd· lfit i'ES chizem ,arYe '&iee 'bo,th 'm tile

1 .' .' ,. . ,_ " ,~'. __ . ' .•. I~ , __ . ' .. ;~I , .. ".' .. l •... _. . ". .'. ... '" ..• "

scn'se ,tIb.a:t, they nillive m.ade Iill!cr[ OrWD ia,W\s and lJ~, ,the ,s¢rnS-e that the lawsl '~'bre,¥' b3iR~ mae aft; 1;'be la'w.s. of. &eednm - the "iu)l::'d',c~d laIw~,;-f'

.. __ .~_ _ .J.,' . , L .. , __ ~ , , · .. 1_ __ J-D} _1. _" .0,

;iliV'ji;iiIIi_I"';~ '~eed""m··:1 '~i"'iil, "'\.' ;g,,",LI~iil"'~]' ~''''~\iI''';ifl .~;t t'iI:'Ii*,I[li"~I;'Ii;~ 'If-."''::iiI.,;Illi'i'm~:II .. ',.,...~; If}'~·.i?.··,g·~'"

!!J.dIr.!I.\!~.l~::RlJJll [I.J- V. : _ III!I.-J;U "_I:I~ !!t.P.'L[I.~;1IP."_ 1 l.Rl·n [g ul ["_~ .• l~'\r.-Lll[l' . .aI_iIiIIdll [L.I;!I;~~'V _ . ~I'! II. J[J~ 18i.]; .

,Jl~ j('iLl: 'E7l~'d'-lifi"~:ifi' ,;'Ii;~lifi~ f~,'!I1 W\' .... ·~;iIi .... ~ ·i:''''i~''iI''iH, ll·~I·:.~'iiil!'i;!i:n:!.~'·1 :"I;!i!', i!i~~!i!'.(~1 i"'.Lemli!i~llt~l-_:_i!i'

U"""' ..... ,I, vJ~ ........ iIo, .. !iI' ,UlI ""'.iII-"'V !!!Ii, _ ... ,11,\.;1\111"" v,t: ,IIJA!"'-.liUU 1 [1lJC,liIO."'~ ;gO '!;,;;uUo bill. 'LU .... _,I,,·C'.,

aJS, W'en. al 01: the ·~a'n:ic:mhu:' ends, wl~jch ,eam 'ma'Q' !Set; 'fol: b-"Imself,'i~' ,3,

-_. -- ... _ ,_', ... ~ .. ,_ .. ,F·~···~···-'~··~ ... ~-. --~.-._ .... _ ... _ L"~'._" , .. _. [_ .. ",!1 , __ 1., __ ... "-'f -"

S'V·iI!;,.\illiiftl!!; ,;n>!~ ",l'~1 G',-'7~1 ends iI"G··,:,,;iI'~ :lI'~1 ~~;i"iL ,;"'I'~i.c"~~~' .,..;a:~l~~.l!i hl'll,b: ,;n>!!U!I'ii'i .~",",= _1,,.'~i,,~,,,,~~I~I. ~J: ~:__~, I~i~' ~:_~ .l··-~ '~31,;3.~~ ,~,~~~, ~~,w,~~~,~, ~~~~~~ ~ 'Y!.~~ ,~~[I~~

uan, and ·the ha!p,~ne§ ,of o,metJ'5. as, aD ,md ,md n"liU:1S [e'~'CfY' ,otiher ,liS

~~ .

am ~nd m i'tSei·]f 'h '~S a: 'CDm:1munj'[V ~rN;I'~""@d in ,th.e: ib:armnn.ious mdJ

__ ~.~ ',,:,, __ .~. ~_J~, C,_._,":'.~~o':!i ,_,_ , __ I __ ', ,~",,:_ _~~_;·~~'~_·_;~~"_',I ·":'!!!!~L~f~"~-· ~_;~, , __ ~,,:, ,~~_~_,~_~~_":_''':_~ [_. I_..:_

c~eraD¥e ""'U1HJmt ef 'tlle "rOOd

'-~,1f"'-- _I_ ""- r- '_ - ' '_- '_ "-·a· ._", •

Tme: liingdob], of Ind, ,rov-tdes '~$ 'with .8: 'Wa,?' 'Ot iie:Pte&en't-ins: the sense. in w'hi.ch mot .. 1 'lawlS mie 13iWS 'of amtnmomv ·Sup· '~. ",,'n 'ir.10!ll.,

. __ 1_"., ". _., .. 1,-_.!iIII-I,~ I",,_" ,_-.,._ ~ L'. I ...• [ , I,··I.I .. 1,1··J.'.l '.:.:..-~I.:;IF-~~-"" '~., ,_,~,

timnail 'ki:"I~ were' 'maU" 'to 'fnm~ Ii Kl'nlP'do:m [of; '!Ends and he1!d a

I ~ J, .... _ .. ~._._ ., •. ~ , ... __ - t-: ' ,I, _ ,_ . ," ·[1 ,_' .r. ,I, _. . - .. , _ •. __ ,~, [:: 1_. ,-_ .r .. ,._ -_~l . '," i. , ". ::. _._. 1_'

,"'~TilID,~'t-"i'iiI~l\t!ri'!Ilnll: t:'I;i'!ri'fll~l~liicl'j~1 'iii';FfI: m::-I,n;~~.:i! ,il[l'ji!j! l'-''''W~'C:la,- ':j'j;~,;nl~. 'il ,!'iIi i1f'...c!1 '~;'1~1,.J1 ''i",It:~:

~·U---.L- .• Uil!:W r.YlI. U'--.Idlllll. ~U---.&.III,L!I!· ' ..... dl.J •. 1U!l--.&~ u·u, .iIIiI.~i'W! [~.L~ _;Ql, , 'a!l n·,w.iIIiI'II. [1.111 n ~ ¥J! UIIIiI_ U 1"J.''W

.c:-;I!. .. ~ .. - -,.-::~ E',-,c:::~ ~ .. iI!. --,-I -:c r.,~--1.~ 'b':· .. -: -,-:'-,-'c ,iit~ ''C'--'-'---::-~i-: t.';.,- ~", ·ii).,,-'c .~ :.". '. ,,', '-"-' •.

[Crl,oo;se,. , ... aC:~I, 0,1: us WOU.lUe ea:gel:' 110'0 pleSen'e ;ui~S 0;[ ,ilil,er own ,~ree

dom,~, so we: w,~ld :ha,vye tID' cJhoose 1a:W,5. that presef¥yed, 'dl,e, freedOm, fif:

Copy rig hted m ateri al

,~;i'Ii""'""~1 :''I;''';t"O,;i''!ii4i''~I~nIO'' [1'.... :'~I, D" :'iiii""v\lliliii'~iI::>"'Ii'~i l i'1i;w; ~'~'iIj'i;"';Qo 'W~~ ,~,i"jk1i".;'~1 fl, 'W'ill'~1 ,"1;, ~\i~1ij''i''''11.f1, t'iJil _~_~ ;g'!l.!,!;;!UI'U_Wu;~, I!I.'V Gi , __ 111:1 _ ... ~ "'11'1-_11 , !III! _ _ _ "'i .. _ilil}!Io!'!!;,P __ "'" '''' 1!.lI'!;>I',iIi.!.!l! __ ,I _iii, iR '!I'!I"''-1, .. ,Il,W l.u,

w'hitdl the a.ssjs,ttaJ~Ce. an ethers ~_nd, ,t'be resources o:~ h'urmarFii, W.,e.~/t8

'W~-:,~' ''''(l~~';I]-"'''b--'';l-,~ Atoi"rii" ~'-I~;e;, '~~I the '"ff".QI_'~ii"i;ii!i 1"1'-"~ ,~.;t'O_~C-il"iLT'i_ 'W" '"'~~liI'f'ii'i'~41, ~.iI~;I]-'~ ';;'~,-t:

__ ... 'I"-e a:ViU"R. _ e 1''VoI. UO'!;r- GiO JliliV ."II"'-""_UO I!.!I'J; Gi'!;;!~lil!o)l".u.... __ '!w' Wi'-!l'y._~unJ .Iii, ",_II_a",

eaeh pe:m:on eonmbure SIODle,thing eo 't'~e o;bU-pt~rY' ,endis, 'ne :~a,w8 'W~ 'w'O'!!d,d eheose tu be 1J)nd~~ if it WIe'I.'6 ours to ,C:boos~I' WQ;uJd, be mIg;t~'I. ,la'w,s,. Whg. 'W~ ~lQ' ~;b~¥ :ro.G-r:iIJ. :~!1,ws;!' '.~n.!' 'W~ la;r,~ raru'l2on(1rmQ~ ,~d, .f'~~!,~lt 1it~ .i~ ~nJ),y' b~ca'~s~ w'e. are :inrlped'ootm.}f J;atii([nal~ ,~d, :suJb:ioot to 'tb,e hnpo:nlWm,tjl}~, ,~f~ desire, 'th!lJt; :mo-rali'ty ,a(p-pe~, '~O us as 'oon$t"lai'nt ,.,..0; !1l$, dllt,y [~G, ,:M~'lt']l.

Th'U. givd KaU't aIliot'ht<t 'wa,;f' I~:f f:o:uD)'i!.ila;tm,g: the cC$;tegoncal :i.IOJi'e:~·' 'tiv~!, 'W~ ~ ,aj.W3YS -to ,~ct, as if 'w~ 'W~~ me,~~tcm,g: ,€~1t ,t'h~ Kin.gd~~ cf' Ends rlG~ -4"3'4~" [Of' ~OU!~l this .id.ed, is, not aertu;lUy brough,t ~ioout'roy 'Lhe: itndi:vjdool"':s li~iliill u~ 'to i~,!, 'n~ aG~tid~~,tsJ IO'J: nat~~;f i!U1d ,t"[h~: 3~tiO~5, of. othef :poo.p:[e~ ,mary d~Si~O'lt ,tbe ,re~i'ld,t'$; of mo:r,'aiUy ~, Icnn·, du~t~ ,~d, :~~a:d t;Q' t'h,~ oob3ppm.~!'j, of. dl~ :m'Q:fil !1,~;e'~lt I~' ,O't'h~rs. Jut sin~~ ,th~ moral, 13'w' ~o~~;m;dls 'c.a'be..goricdly, 'W'e .mius:t :~e;vy~ttJhiE~ss,

'II • 'II • - 'Ill.. 'iU,~, ,,dI A[: E1 d' A. 'III '1.. 'ili,filil, 'l..'" 'it:.l .. ,

aot ,ar~ ~~g_~:aitlQifrS til, 'b],e ,~ng.\lIOfD 10'_1" .'rn· '5. ,rult]l!(ri~1; b:I!~$ ~eem:s .u~e; a

t>iFIi'ii'Q,t-'or-&m"' ,11.' 'W~'~'':''"i'" 'ii:"~.:., :o[le-""'('il'iii'c. '~l"~ll" [L::;:. '~,...~, :i: .... I"""'''"' ,~.:; ,a- Q.:I(if"Q~; 'ill'l'li 'ii"'ii .... ,il ... j~ ·iii'~~~

~1L!"i.HI_'i:l. _1I,g_ ,J.I .. J']IJ~IJ_~, !II.~]""~, .fI!Y_ JII.-D.i ~ _w_ lU!w [l[IiIrU.JI ·.ll.!I.i'..I. .... .III_Oi . iIil!~_IJ_~_~... IIJ_III_"1 ft .11_luwJltJI !II~1'-r.

a.g;em.'tl'si;medow, iSI higbUgi.:l!oo, in, :s~[tc~,;a, ease, ne~ ,3:gef),t .1:8 :HDiU: OOn'· StO;Bibl.e.d 'by' c-'Xit'e-m:al ,ffilite8 'bJ ,ac~, a.gawnst: the '[-aJtL.fifia-rn. ideal that is, i'he Illljec't: af: h~~l.ha' will.,

u: ther.e; '~I~, ,il cltte,~1ld eal .'!'m~-l'~a;t~v'e a, ,I la,w ,of n'Wlre l'~n ,1'I'N'Ifii'hri'tliJi), 'to

~. _OI. -.l .. [~-. _ •. - _ •..• ~ ..• } J .. - _. l_·r-II!IP.--· ~.~ ~ ... p.._ ._ - - .. ~ .r·~· ~ .. _ ... --~ ·-r,~~"~~~1 .. -

"b·" 'w~'~'11 ,,'1.,;,'1.,;, . eth .,. ". "," ,.,,~ '.' "'~Il' .. w'h ',. i" is '!!Ii I H' , ••••.•• ~'" ' ••••. " '.

~l cl~ __ lu.t men tnese tliree·l!iiOr,m:UJI'u ~et!li~ mS,_,.,J._iilit. ~t ~'S" ,~'1ll,t: 1101Il.R:!DiUJ_mi,'"

,&'U'at,e '~hat ehe 1c:a'~~i)'Arica] 'im~erati'v'e Is l'ieal :Katlt :needl eo m~

_ .. -~.~... ..-~-.~ .... -~ .... _.~ .... '~'}!.!IJ~~.~_. __ !"!l ~._=._._-!"!l ~ _ ~-_ ~ _,._,p. =.I_ •• __ • ._ •• -_ •• -~ _

,;r!,n:--"",":"I!...··'l·'II'Ii,O' ,;!:!;'III~"" = 'iI".L"i!Io~' "-,1.,_"",, h' '~"im''''!1i!I; ''U!I!~'~lll ~"Ijl!!l; 'L..", 'm- ,~.-.i,~~,"!; .. "'.~ 'btu, ~,,, O·:-··:.;i'""-""i~~ '~!I4r,~~~~~._~~ ~~I;I-~ ~~~I" iUl-~ __ ~I. _~~, ,",,11 ~,~~, ~ . II_t~"~¥·~'''~1 -'2.' '~~iI' '.:___. '"~~~.

'wile :mQ'I','dil~Y' is ,;1 "mere: ,p:nan'~O'_ of 'tne :m'mdn' I~C ,44LS; ~I~ I, d,ggml of

'--.'. oj;"'-" ,'~,"-;io. - -,.", :Ii!.,--' -r- ,,' .... ·""':L .. ~ -,- - ,. - Ii; ,-- - ,'i4.tl' oj; - .,1..,- "iI\li1\ l~ ""11'1 .... - -'t-' 'L.

,r:ah,llD'nl~lS, .. ,me .. ap::~:'SI'C'S WJ:~ll~~, eoes ,n.ollj;, apPI.::,o IIliO 1~-(I;e~O:I__Jg. ,.~, es _ a~

:U'sb. d~e .mn.:iJ~, 13l,~, 'we ,need, a ~-r~.ti~e ,mf; 'Iaetkail, .reaSQfl"

The c.uJelorical, i'm:peta:Uve, is s,ym,meti!i:;. ,MoraH:t:y, is :n'llt~ oCtl1!ltimed

",~ .J"'e' ,c-,c--:',c_,-_--'t-, ..... t"; - 'r--';j.''j-·c- "'-'1,- ,.-.'"'111 '1j;1:fL..1'----, - 'c -; c -: c -,"';";i .c--c' :'i- '-,-- - ",,1;.,,-, .. '\:_ ,',.,-,

.lu. ' .. Iii.' c'Oncep'!I., ...,,1: ,a ·,a,!Io~.o:na· W,Il .• nl~em, ,8 ,p:r:opOS!I.!Iolo:m, ,~s ,synl .. Ue!l.~'c), 11 .. 5

,;';rn...-.; iii':e: -db'C!' 'n'Ii~'~IQt-" ..... .,. 1 "I .... 'I+,:e~~ ,r~"iii[k ... o: !i 'il ",'I\:.I 'iii'~"'i"~ ~'~in~n:n. W: : !I." ,;j;'i!lo. ;lI, ,;;,'Il,., l"~1 "I~ !Ir. 'H U lII.. _- u ._ . ~ ,IJU!I.iII_Iii:::II!\1 IJ!IWT ,UI~ ,Ul ~_!J~W . .!~~, .. ~Irl--'w.- ,II, y~uJ...,... .... IJ, .... , !\-JllI, ,g !I;.IHI,· ,f.U ~LII.&

"!.I"hi,c'h boc'h, e-1: them U"e t;o, 'be found ~~'c;, U' mJust 'be dedu,eed I~G, ii A ""~

.•.• ,_ •. __ ._1, . : ... _ .•• ' I ..• 11_., I,~. II.· - •.• "'." _-'. 1 [II ·,j·l .-. _. ~.- ... , ..• J I._-_. ~ .. _:__I '~'I"-I.

,Kan:l1/;s 'vlew ;~8 't'ha:t '~lU5' mud 't,effii.1:8 plf-D,y,ildeiJ, 'by the posj:ti,,\!ve oon~,p·,

t"-n ~,~ ,.,L.~, .~~;D.l.,..-~ .... f ,.,'h-·>Ii ~ """'11]- g"'ii!i ,-, ... -ift'ii-'~-- i' ; ~ ';ji.';l.",,* ~I'~ ~ - '--~i~~ -- -'~_~Uli_', CI; lYle ,~Ii:e,,",~~m, v.,lI! ~ .• ;11.' Wh '" ,1:.&1_"", a .. ~ ..... menr 15 I':;IHI,~ I~,i[ ~ a UJW!GDiilill,

w,~U m,\l'st: 'be r-egarded, ,as ,a, ;&e.~ wn~! ,and (:2i,~1 a free wUl is, ;a, 'wiD, under m,ctral m~,w, Thetef.ofe~ aJ, ~altj.o.:lllal[ win blJ ,a w,iH. 'mde-r m,o.:mllarw:;,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

111 ~~ ~~ -'~d - --- ,. ~ L ---'dj S-~ Th 'W~'iU L'h ···l" - "f .

,. 'toe, 8eQO~l' '. plie:mlISe ,119: pm'Ved : ;f;'Si,t. ,,," 'e .. ,L" ~JS t ,,-.e ;Coalu...Sa~ty 0:' ,3.

";"'Ii:~~iI"i'i'i;o1i11 'L •• liii'i'if. i',~ ,~.LD,; oW. ··jl~'~I,ii'iCi, /~·;O;'iIf~o<'ii~;~: _ "i>iiifi: ,;i"';~;i'!ii~i;iO'i;i,1!iCi, :","H,;I. [-;l"'; .... tjiC>il;i'!ii'i'i"iCi _ ,~'I"[~ ,L iII!!li.I,U,Uill!ll. iIl1C<l .. '"C!" iU: U;L,.;, ., ,~. _iii, "" !I'I;!o<!Il-.liUU;i:!' ,~~_ !!w_iIi!l~u •• '!iii!i."!l ,g.u,l\iiI. 1!.U:","\I).UY~iII_ii:!< _..."

det~·nmnoo, ~,> 'me :~a,w:s (IE fiA'.re! :IJt :~s nG~ I ,hlOO wiU. ,SU{ppo,se ,~Jh.a,t raIl. YD'U£ clh~ioeSl, o~ld be tltaoed, to a, ps<,(C:hn~Jogit';a:~, ll!.'W of' :~~UXI.Tr:e~ :SafY:i> "a ~-l\S.fitl/;S w;U ';191 ,a'h"'l,a~'S de~ll~[~tl~n", ,~, th~ S,bJt;:filQ1th ,'C'f 'b~~/h~:r

',r- .... ..l __ , ,~.. _, '/'.. ._ ...... , __ .I __ , ... _~? ._ .... , -""~~" Q. ,-_ .... - .. ~

d~si;~SI"t'I.' ,AlJthO'~p~ 'Y~' 'WQ~ld alw;a.y;s 00, 'what y;:(1f~, t"W,'ai~jt ~os.t.;"j~1

'\I';'i"iil'lliill'" 'W'_ ,111' .,~ '''ii''oi!'''~~'lld" In"""1"I' [1--' '.~ ~ ~;:I! A' ". L..:-;:I! w" li]'~ '~;I': ,,..,. ... '~ ... ,L ",",I' 't·,.,; ·n·~;ll@'~@",""","I~'''''''d: ~. ~~l& _.~. ~ ~'!V-UJ-_, ~-u~ lue. ~-~, ,:__,~, ~-~ '_"_' ,~~~ .~~ ~~-~ Ull-~!13 ~_~I .__: __ ~'" g_~~_~_~,~~~,~~._.

b:y' _,,' ~-X.t~-;lll~l m~e1.l ~Vi~:f~ yoor: awn [df;r9iR~:!, Lnis :i~ 't'h~ n~p.ti.Vl~

;i'iOii"ii\;'iHi(".n;'i" ~ Alii: '~~;i'!iiilfjl'li .. '~.u. ·.t·: ' .... '1!\iIIi' :~ 1,;c,"l' '"i',"'nf~'li~"':""i'"," nn~I'liFjf"!I\~ ~"?""i'i";;o,;;iQ~iI\~;rIIH Ofiof"· ~.:I_I~ri!l._1r-U"jl~' ",",.1; n ..... -_-~~"'~, D __ ~.~ w:~~ ~'~~~'§ ~ 1f~~J4.l~,""l~ ~~~-~;~.!1.3,~~-~ ~-.!.l

keed!o;m" 'The wUl is, ,al [Ciai'tS;l;~ilYr- ,.d '~'I!ii~ [oong_,~ IOf ,;J Cai~~Utr' ,~ ..

;f;;o1i,Ri]' ,." ]·,;o1ic ... ·L'j •. "7~.~., '"", e j'~In.;r;'""Ii;11R,Iftl.~c ·.~ , ...... 'b~.·· .,",ii""~ t..~F. ·i'"'.Fr~ ofi.· 'if'i." ~~. r,\"Ii;n'd'" i;'\I·m·. }ti,'"' -'"iii' a [,,"Ii:"i.',' n. 'f.i[\"Ii.' ~;'pi,.,,;j;.~,i')o'i'i.·, I ..

~_I _iiI! _iII!'~D<. ill! ","iA!'~.I], ,?~· . _I,,,,,,_ilil, ~1JI,!I!,n!o<lIl-.l/Uu_C!< f iA'_U . ~'1!JI .. __ ~;~. b" Ai II;,;-lUI,H,".I,a,U_~}! .. "ll!.ll\u.

Th, '""ut tt :~[ln1fb,t.[ 'W~~· ,t'ibe; w~'11 'i~ 't\J',a<:t~i£ai'l '~1~aJ8iOn- and 'w'e C3!mnot .. D !tc .. 1 a" ... 'U' .. L .. ,r . .L", ., . . . .... . .'. . . .. . .

OO,riai've a pl';a;cli~ ~;aso:!i'il th~lt ehooses ,!a!fild aers ro.r no li~Jl, S~n~~ r~s,·are deri.Vi~, &om. :'_riln.cipl~~i rhe 'WiU :!tn:~!it h;lV~ ,;I :prind;,j~ ,A h~ win -UJs,t~ 'tb.~~m~: h~,v~ :i,t~ 'fjJW.~, :~~,w' [~l'; ,rin~~p:~~~, ·whj,~h. :~,t ,gj,v~ ,to iJ,t~lf:", :[,t :[Q!!\l$t be d. ,alWltnn.(n:n(JIIlS, 'wUt :Btiit iI:'he :_(J.llal :~a,w :is, rrb.e l~,w o~ an 8jU'~Qrn.om.iJ'Us· 'will :l.ant ,oof:lc-lwdes 't'hat: 'l~:a, :kce 'wiU and ,ill wU[

n_.l14l":" '~~I~ li;o1i"iii!~~ 1"I;'i'~; ~\.;I."Tllj~;; eal" 1~~~.4:'~J" j!1Ii 'II.II.I!I,UII;.;I. ,1U,'u.I,a:iI, fa: n "'" a ... '!io l1u!!lrudJ!i.o'!iIII. ~u 4"" t ..

Rea:dem, ,HIre of;'bem. :r.r~zczled, '~" 111&5, i:'jilgu_en:t., I~ 'th,e ·wiU. ,is free. ,to ¢JaOOse" ,t'ts, (IrWfi. :pmlDciplet wm.,' is'~.o~ld it: be under 't'~e mJ)J3l1arw'~' L,"[:b see w:Ih~, eo:mide.r ,t'he 'l"~blelD, :ft~m> ,t'h~ pem;pect~.~e 'fi~ a :bee :[altit)mal.

'W .. ,Iil'~ 'rm'~~""j"";<1~ l"'iii' 'II~ ..,;, ·,.. ... t· .i,O· .''''''''111 'W.·' "1' ~"III 1" 'iii" ' ...... '1'·1"'·' '1i..1""j""iIIi' "'" '1!!W"~iI'Ii'i!":i;Imi'~I~, D''":':'~'-in;l'"''i' ';t:.'_"_"~ ,,~. ,~-~~. '~l ,~,~l [~~~I~~~ ~.LlI~ll -_' _'-U#.I' ''1;., '~_~~_~:~"1 ,1TIIi~!W'~' [~,Ir~,~~~~_IJF~~'!1 ~)~l ,~--=

• L" ",",'i!., b.:::' '" 1. t: • ]f" N-' 'It., ...l •

15, :tfElet i:t: :must '~iloose tDilS ,p~U1U~'I[p\le ,[0'.[' ]iil:se r, .•..•. O't~Jil'm.8 U,elt'enmnes

i'",'4I~'.:>J "",l.oJIi.L~e:-:'· 'l'~' '~""~ "'O~'fil'ilfi'1l;'ile-~:e~ Iv ,,,,"Ii:Iiii'rIl·:,[ji.;o'iIri'''''-l','ilii'''''., C"~ilricii''';;; ',i~'",~ 'ifin··'o:"'o""~lnll,,", [.:I\i!iI'it-,;i:io"iIo,

IU~lJ.oi:]! '!Ii.i_I;I~-.aAir. .. 11 II u ,"_0 ~-. "IELlJirr.\I 11:. •. _ ,. a.lmr.·~ _ 1~""'-IU!!W?a. ~"JI_"J!i.i-"-Ir. ,~}'_'i]Ii ,~, 11l-.~"rl"_' Lb.r. !Ui'!W.IJ,

mim~81 w:llraJt ijl: C(Jl!!i:iliES, :is· ,:I :rea:soot :nnt'h:iiog 'yet t:Cf.u.n:ts as a, :r.eamn, l'IlT' i'~:, I'~,t "i~f. ~~nfl1ij}ng ,,~~t oour~itSi ,~S ,ai. 1'e1as.o:~ :fm' i'~\" it rii(ppeiILl:$, t.o ha!~'e no. b;Jis!Is m[ ~hoosml ,i'£s, :prinC'~ple!, 11t~[,~ ][S, :n~1 ,OOll!S't.ralmt ,~n. :i.'ts [m~,i~~",

"",,~"'(!,~t" '";'~: .. t··' .;,;j; ,""'!'L ........ .,c@ .. '11'''i~ '~' 'n'iii' ..... ;ij'Iot"i, ... "", ' .. ;Il...·""iili" ~,h,;,Ii" ~'S', [u ''''iIi'' ,~ ..... ;bl""'11' ·;h·~

~~_~'~~ ~~I~~ ,~,~ ~_~~ [~ ,~~,P'I!" ,g---=-~l ,~_~~,..!~~~ lJl:~~I~, l~-:- _ __;,~_~J ,~~ .• ,,:,_.~~, """.~.~~ l,~=~

P,1JJ';~D~mla [mf 'Unlve-ttUJl La.w :says!;, In,e ()'nil,¥, ,oon;Strain~, tha:t :i.t: :im~51

nn l?i:~I.r" ""j'k.,-.:I .......... "" ,I ..... th ... · ,j; ,[ji.'i!.., '''''':: ~. -, ~ ''!U,~ ,;i,'i!.·e·· f"o:~ -.", "fIi~ II' ,,,~ ·j"""f·.,-.t'h' :~.ng""~' 'I!X' f"o"i'-i'j';,~ ... ""

UIHI. l.!l-~ . !Iir_IJ._vW!l..r.~ JJIil!J ll:.~i!lr. !ll.IEI ..... , lIJ.iII,· .. ·1Ii.r. [llI_ .... l.LlI_U uJl: ,1_81·O'. ,1IJ:~u. -:-; 1 .. 1 .. " -.\IJ,'!W!'!·"'oI,;!U~.-::I1

- ~ - t': - . ,', ~ ~

,iiilii""V 1"'"£fI.ftl~.:;!!n'iii' ,f ..... , .. ,.:I-·,'"'"Iiii' '~I'''iW~'·-:-., aC '~11' "·;~I';;'j~· ,;ij,[ji. t.., .... , ... ! ,,,,~ 'It'"':'", '~Iii' a' 1, .... W~ ;' 'TI-l!...Oii! 'fiiiAtifor","'"l' 11 .... 10:;.. '~ .. lr !lir.V-.UJII!-"'_~"~' I.u;IL l .. ll\iIJ!II. JIL~. '.' j!1 . .~ .. UW:~JI;.-:t ,lI.," J~ lrUi ~, ,~_~J [ • J;il1..... . ,IJ:[I~ ,IJ~,~ ,~~_. 1_~!Ift!

"~--l~ ~"';'be~ &- - _~'"L.~ -f' . f'~ ~ ~ "1'1 'wn- . t1h~ ~'lli'~ ~'h~L~.

S[m~ [.Y· , .•.• '·n, cS, ." ,,'f; :POS(l't!l.flD o' ,3, :r-ee ·WI., ' . ..;, .. : ·.en .' .• e: W;I .. ,,'!5, C: ["O:U:~:S,

;o1ii~, • .;fI.]",~",;j;~..:fi, ik;v' ~·ih~.·,1ii.! '~'"'i"if"Ii'~1 'll;o1i'W. ~'iif. q.~Y'fiI(i'i~"';Ci\liil·.:>J '~i;joiCi! ,iliTil(fifi"Jri;;o'i;n: _lli'~t 'Tc't.·e-: 'm~: '?ii'i"iI.'~1

!IIBa'!llr. ~ __ II~'_'''~-U II) IT l!i._ _ ~ ,~_-l_"'U-..lJilld~J IIL~ ~ ~ ,~I ~~ ~-._:"lr':l. ~~ 1ZJ1ir.~ [",!La IDllr-~.IJ,~I!WI __ {~.UjJIIJ 1.'-" I, I.I ,_ _ ~IJ [udaL

law' is, me la,w' ,~e. a;cpo:n,tafiC~ty" The wiU d]"a.t :~s, gcrv'emed. try mD:r-ality-

'~''''' t- ... P, ,iI' .... IlI""".'!i."

[0-1 'i'Jh-~ [-,~·l.r i" 'b, ,d· c';~ t'b', ~'-fIH ,]1'1."-:-' '~i-rl [··bc,·~,;:.-~·, ,~(," be d)~i,-~_,'-'---:d '~ ... . -ll! t '. e til! .. ,er , .aill.~, 1, .. eo w,~. , a .. ,OIW8 ,~.W c .. G.lreS .0 .... .~f.-ct:)U:L .. !III,

,~ 'u~~rniJ;1 .t:.u~j. i't~ ,s:~l1Id~, :i.'ts k~d~" :~'n R!!dii"!~:n: Wl;tldn Ulei l.1:mJit\S' o~ ,R~M'~: AlIon~'., :Kmlt !Climpi~s~ ,t'Ih~It: tbiiJ$ :~~, ra, ''aU, ~rv'~rne

:f II',. ~. ~~

,.d, ~"liGabl~ [It J4,-3,j:j1 4J:-,44" '7i8-'7\9-]\,' Sm~e 'lth~ 'fr[~ 'w~l'l ~, not

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'~KC' .;1. '~'ii'T i ~ 'f'i,":' o:iQ .ii.. ~L ,.,.,g"li ~I. ;I"li; ,Ii!' O'~ 'jfI,'DI'Y'

I _ • .l'li.J..., ., ~l li''J1.I ~ ,8.~, " [I:' ~.i[I.,"" .. \;.:IP!ilI' . '.' ,Ii' lr.iJ ;1.,

ml{Irv{ed by' des:ir~ urness,.it [c'ho~s ,t1Qi bet!' th.e w,ill:l'~ surrender of ~ijts fm~dm:liiD ,Catmno:t .~ [evnlairnt1d bv 'r'htl pm~!SU'r.:es of 'ti{l:'m.nta¥~ali'ili S·:\~I';Ci ... ;g;,n",

• ,_I '.::__ :. . .:..I,I_II " . ...=. I,~ ~ _ .~.'.~~ ~~'._.::. ~~:_ ,_I_,_....:_ __ • ....:.~, ._ I, ...=.' r : __ • ...=._ .:..~J _,1,. .• :_:~, .~.::._~~~'~_~_.:..: _ __!'Lr!J . __ .~:~_~

,t~bUitli.!" ton, lt1:gint'atiom is 'i'tlli\eWf ,t'h~ 'l!"o'lI00U£l' of the 'wilP~ 'ni=li~~;<I;,

.. _,--=._(,,_1_11 l_;~ 1_,::.- _,Iltrl_-- __ ,_~_:..:.J_, '_,_. ,_,_~~ . ...:.-_'_ . 1,_1....:. ,ir,,_,,·.:..-_)_,.:.il._!l . .....:___!. _~_~c.._-=-' '_L_'~':____'."":",,. r!I!P.I-~·!!I·~~~~

~'h - .. - ... - . Jll ~ ~ ~ .' . ~ ~ .. i~~ ~ ~ ~ '1:' • . ~ ·Ii'· .. ".. .. 19b' . 1 .

. I ' - 'J', I' .... , Ii'·· ':. "I":' I -' '".'", '-, ,-. ' ... ~. .. - .. ' - .. "_' -' .'_.[ il .. - I" "1', -: I ". ". . ti _. . I. 'I' ." .' .. ' r . ',_-"" ', ••

~~. ~10e to ;a . ,QW ,I!Il!~Jt 'leiS 0: I. l~C"'· IWI,Unm, eo outwe.~~~ ,m,Q;ra~ ,~Dr~Ili .

"~'~C'·~:s· ~'-p." C' '!:i< ''iI,.' 'Ii,~. _~[£~ 't.i!",~ !l.1.v'e, i,1I"!;. ·:l.,J'=""\4i .~e\l' J"'~;;:il ,r t-

But, wil]u' ;s'hmUl!d we 'beJ:ievle. ·t'~at the h~[i:iD8irn 'wiD is ~'me't '[m dre:

• •• J ••• _ Ii' _, f.. _ • .. • .... I. . .. . . _ . _ fl.. . _ . _ . _. .. . " __ ~ ~.~, _,-. ~. • '_ ~ _ .~ ._.~ _

G' ~ ~ d: ~ It" X" ." - .. _ '00" " "' ~" tb· ~ '", ~ ." ~ 'f' th . bl bssrvi

[ J". 0 • I'. : t . . I.) .' ' l:'. r - . I - ~ - I -', I _ ' • [ I L":' f _ I • J' -. • l . " • '. • • -. - ' t.· . .. ! -.' ,'. ,- .' . - . . . - .' .. .'. ,- ~ , .' I

~ ~Q~r",:waf· '~l~,~~~n .:'~~.S, 1~-~~I!IJSi pm 10-" tne arlU~mt, __: f O~~~lng

th~lt, as ~:aitiQll;~l 'hi'ngs 'W~ :m:~s,t !ifjt; '~nder ti~e id~. [~f f~Red~m"" W!hen W~ ~~ r:a'tj~nill. [C:boi~~s ,ilJrndl de~iis:blns,~, Wr~ mast thin'lk, [0£ eurs elves, as, :rnl1i<~,. ,A. "'~.in;~~ wh i~"'rh··. lliliillifi'''l, 'l\Oli!Q""Ii_T,d·~. :"'tC;i]j;~.(:"';Ci, ,t-.,~; '~"Ii;~1,"",::~:~, "t'"'r,~;c:iii;;';-,~l'~~"~' _~ _ ... ~~ ~ ~ ~.~~ ~~ ~_""""'.~ ~ _"''''' ='!o?~~~ h"''!o?L!U ""'" ,I/:I'!;. ..... 1,!!;,o,wUY uti p\faC!Il-1C81,Y

,ff;6~,tr ,;uld, SO 'ooU'fiid 'b:~' d1ie la;ws, of. freedam f(jAI~;8i[i I!t'rljt Ka,-::'t. dF')'

-, ..... _--,._ .. " ... ._-, ... '1' ._.,,,,, .. ~" ,," _L, .... -- •. ," "!!r·4'''1 •. I!!I., .D. _ ~,

Oo:ID'nl;J!lnS, tbaJtr. thi:s ,afm;~mef:it '~~, 'itsei~f 'WS[ c*'fclllla.t '~f';-££e;-~d~:~' '~:[

.. . ,t'u.- - .. - .'. ...., -- [!:!:Ii- .., 1iII', ",' , . I. ._, ,~, 0 ,[1: ,a5l;an

iiOOOUIwrlt (.:1: hJ.QW' W'e~ C3JD 'be mar:'al~.u' m,oti'va.ted~, A :lji~:='~il':'7 :,~,tt,:'~l ~':]]J1 _ .. ~~=~~,=~~~ ~~ ... _" ~ .. _~~_" '_""~~_""''''rfU_II~,yralt'!llll:a W.

,is jl~s,t [;I 'wiU, Uim.d~r. mora.l ,Ia,w~~ btu 'W~: ~re nee pUl',ei~y :mltional, MGl',a'I,,,

~,iity ..... ..:11 ... .,.,... .. "'., 'n. ·d;l", w·'··r'e· ""u·:'t.7-~m·' ·.''''''I.~' 'f'.U'''' h,d'P'P:;IID'''''''''''': '''i' ..... , .... 1I'~rr f .. ·.'I"oiII! ... ;I~m·.' 'til:riL,~t: ~'iII'

,1I1!i.l.,· U!liZlllu.oa.Illi li:!I! .... !i!lJ_ ~~, -, 'dI~l,I", U 'IL, ,ai -. ·.-lIJ' , ~ lli-.u !Lr.UI', ""'~-IIa-n'u 110" ¥V,LJa ~ .I.r~

ti ~ - ~ - - ~ - - - - ~ - ~ ~ - - - - - ~ - ~ . , , , ~ ~ ~ ~ - - - - - - - - - - - ~- - ~ - _.- - _ ••

'1'I'";:II"'!'d: I,":,,~ '~l"" .. "''1'11, o:i!Y'I'iI!l"""""".';,on """if h;r-r;.~, '''_J!!;' ...... 1""" b .~ ·m:'fIi;i..I.~"'ii.~~ .'0 .~I .... , .. 'Lt",c, ""j"L'~[iII' ,II!~~-~- __ ~l ,~~ ~, ~~_~\I:~~lur-~ ~~, ~I): ,~ __ ~.~ ~ ~ ~~~.~ __:.~ ,.I.r_~I"~'''·[~~~1 ,,--ul u-~ ~~_,~~, ~ ~~

,~1amalUOfi. :js p\I(JrV.i,ded b, 'trn,e, :id,ea ~f' 't'~,e :b].tei)]illible 'world,

:E',ve:ryone" :K.anJt: cliii~ms\! iistin:pi:Sh.es 'be:twee:m, t'h'~ngs as t'be:y. 3p~ :;eBf' .and, thm,g~, ,a$ 'tm,e, are iE, ~h-ems~lves,", And, [e:V~JJ''il~~ ~ ~",ly

,~t..'r~ ·fI':,~ ~ .. ;,_~ .. ,~ .. ;;: ;:"C' .. ~.:c. 4":.~c.~~,1,ii!. .~,~"~ : ~:I'~ .~~, < .. c·~)k.~,. ,..,1.,;,",,,..,, 'Hi', , I ,,' ... 1I·~1'~".":··.·· .'

!l:.ulS[ UJis:t1nc,t~{[n ito JllIDSCu: a'S WC.:.lI, as t,o oltu.C"l' ~lJullIi~,. '_C Ult, ,~!Il [a~~,t~Q~

'b.~~:C".~CC""~'~'~ 'k~",-c .. -~ t..'·~fC"C"·- ,"~~.,~.:~ :C··C· ~. ,C'!\.,,", .. ,.:!I).. ,"> ,A.·,~:iio.", c,.~"·".·,-:I).. ··..iI1 if .. " " ",,:L"! '

,liIJuman. uc;;m,g~, l'~iiIi·V1e ,rea6Q~[ W,!luil,<ll. ,IS, uli5i, .. -m,iSXU5.iJj~.eUi ,!["~(1r.m [~V~'l'YiUlfmg,

else :m. ,t·h.a,t :it is, ,a purc SPO~ltaileou.:s oactivU~}f; 'nerttt~Je1i' ,iii, hi~m~!Il beclllg :ij[U!ri8;,t OOWJt~ ,bimseJt ,a$ belonging ~o 'the in;~en~t~;ible wlg.l',ld,~, as w'eu' as to the 'wfiIldl of: :semse (0 '4,S[~) 3,~ [eI ,A:),.8 - 411B,s 6[6=4$'9)., 'The ~ln;~eUigilble world is the :liiollnl~nal wlo:[ld~, :reprded ,3:S [wMis.tllng of pUT:t agencies, 'w,nieih ,gc~,erate 'the 'world ilhat 3(ppeliU, 'bl) '~$. We b,Qw' nntt:li'fii:g fif: meese agencies .. [cx':ce.pt: '~h,a,t W't: m!Ust ,thmk 'ot '~bem, ,alS, 'm~

.. "".' ~ ~ ill: ,",,1.. ~ ~-- ,. ~.~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ .. L ~ ~c~ ~_~'b.';' ~':b ~~~"~ t., ..... ~ ~ ~rl ~AI ~ ~ .,' ~ - - " ~_ ,..l

:IOU'l:oe 01; IL.Ui!: :apptUI:BnOeS .n:011l 'W'ui~CJ;i, I~U[ Nil:OW,ae'li:l(G.e :rus [oo:n!~tIUJct~u.

Di,lliit: [i"io'i'iil'" ~"CCn iI"oitn"lrC'·;·'f,C'C" ,~-:: .'C~~,";~ ... ~ .. ~*.'",";.'jc~, .~::II.~"C"'~:~' '-"Ir~ "~·:·~·~I: "c.,c,' .... ,'i.. .... ". ~'.i' '. '.",

__._""" ",,,,,,.I' vW,liil, -l:""",CI,!l.Y ,luI PUK atO .. l VII •. " lll8:0l:'S us :a;mo:n,~, iL.Ue:ml •• W~

ar~ :'i'~;ifII'·U:r *'~;<I; l·,~~~I:]~c.liCP)iII!~"""S·. ";i;~~; :'!il~; ~.~ :"'Ti'~ Sj(!W\"iTi:tr~'~,~'~~:-'~I~, .. ~. c'd', :~",C'[ _~"." ~4'~V~_~ "_liil"" . _~_I}"\.,1i -I\O'!;;o,'I"''!;p.~, n '!Io; QII.'!Io; iUi:Cl"" ;gu.U',If!U_u!liiW:eOUS~ an. !5'0

Imun~ 'IOu' mora.H'tu

[.>:.!. . ~J • ...:..J. ~. II "':":"'_~_'~'':',,''~

T,_, .. :L,~ ~i'.'~f~U'.'.D rfjli !Jl!i;, ... i11 ... ;t'~"'Aj1 'ri[,d(A,!:'AH ifL..iI! ''!i'-,~"i'!iffl;.a'i'i';j;, .-.~ ~.~ .. ,'i...~. ~·.h"·~ . ,U~, [UJ-~ ~-,.~ '~l~'~~ vJ.J ~~'~'~)~~1~-----' ~ .. ~~g~V~~ l!f._l1_"~ RI~~._~:I~"'~ll~ [g-.oe-Sl 1'_.J~le Ol"~: 'C[

'wav.·:10~ The rWi'IiY" [O'f moral ob'I'iD'~,tflon 'is 'ba,wn. 't'lJu,IWi'.[O"O"1". w'iI.,,~,~, '~""''''''j"

.i .•. J~'[.J .... - I.~ .... ~ __ .. -'_'[',' .:._. " !~ .. _ .. ,~~._, ·_.1.....:.' .~,_._,. __ ~,_, , I ,~_",:~,~ .....:. .. _-~.~ l_~"~~_~' '_"_'L'_I_ii.l!l.1 1~_I'II.,

e~Us[ [a t~'a£,t of: JLei1son:~~' (Cl. 3 j[ }.,T.hiS ,f,,et~ ,is 'OUf [oozm:ciOUS~Si 0:1: dl,e

:m'}""iI:"~] ~ "Ii'!U!i" :"",..;,:d·· ~ '~I*'i!io "''''''I:'iit:ili;'"J't~v' t.Ji'll 'r,t:ji;""'.'l'.''i~;!i'i-.JjI; 'i'~HC!, w: :'I!re~ :~41''il!'I~'''' ~\n'"",' I".~'l"ilill'il+im' 'i'O'f[ ~ __ -UI1~_ I ~A R g_il~". , lllll~'" ~"'[r-~'.Io ,$' I~ [....:i.L-'U... '!f.·iIIiIJ~1I.r !I.III."" '" ,In. ~ _~~~'1!' ~~, .," ~ ~L.IJq.!\\!~. _~~,

,iH"iI"li'~'!I~;i!i.~ i~r\i!i ,"Iiiii'\lll' ........ i;ji;~ ... 3ri'jl.!jj'illii! .... ~ '""1r)~ '~I,n~w.: 'H: 'tIL. ... "l"'';'.'II" ~;II" ,.';L:-,iI;Io 'lI!'iI;I(l'Iil;C!;~ ,"tiL:~.tc "it: ~._:J~Ig_~."~_I.~_~r. .,y~ ~JI1~ ~V.ill.II_~'.IoU~1iJ! ..J.f. 'U~~ ,~IL"I" .!L:l-!I. u;[u,[~ ~~,iIO ~~ ~~~~~ ~~ .. ,~ "

;iiilli,1'.~[i!i) ·in.[ (i!i" W. ,·~'L..""."'I;i· ;i\t"i;[ (1.', ~n, b'C'11'i'f, l"n 'iii'ik~, 'l!;e~:niC'e: ''i'~. ,,~., 'ULii";' 'I ........... ,ul~, 'iu!Jo0:li ","!'n!1!"i .~n, ~"'~.··,o'!.,t·. ,iii". 1!I._'!Ir.;&I:_1Qi 1!'dO , " . llIliIiIIl.l 1."-11 . "-II J' - 'lIIIi!l. . ·IJLlJ ~lIl;J.~, I~, _IJLlIilI ~ !~Jnlll!ll~'l '" ~ ~-~~ '" '",~, !bi~~ u~ '"'I~_I_gJ .. ,Il~

'teJ'l! 'US; '~lO' mauer '~~U}rW s,t:1D;n[i1I" t'he o:nnO'smlli" 'motjV'~: ~C<~ ,::I!, .... ~ 'T-1k;i!i,

I. - •• - -_ :_.' '. _ ., ,_. I. - '~- ... I I ,-' ,I. i ' •• '.".- __ '":,,,~, I ~~ __ ,:_:_ 'Jf.lIf'-'---~ ~:_)~ ,~~ ~,'_~ _' ~1Qi _ ..... 't~ ~W~ii I.llnlI~

Copy rig hted m ateri al

·2.1''':

~ .

Copy rig hted m ateri al

~ 'S-'

l'!, ,',

2[.'

K~~ .'~' 'l;.'i"'I"i'iii, 'iljij'0'Q ·;;',L"C·" 'n''q''ii'ii'"iif'i;'I!',ln,p,~'iti'v

WiIi"1lli~ ,II ra £'!IalJ ~ ,D.,EJ.. . .1:" H,.~ .... ~ ra. u ... ,1;-]1. 10

"i'1I."\~'''' 'UiIO'oI;!L 'm' 0lI1~~';::I!' .. ;L ~,I:!' ..... '1 'I 'II!" ;IIIIft,.:I, 'L'~lrt, 1", .. 'o:!"'"""i'~;I:! ..... , '~o:Ii 'l)m'IN"rIIQ;o:!'I;~~"'m;i:li ,fl,;o"!i; a';i~.,;iII--'.,iIi!"if.ili; 11!;~!Iii '"~ L:__~l~,~~ iUll~ ~,~ ~,~_~ ~U.,l'l ,:__~ ~~~:~l l .. ~ ~,~ ~~_,~~~~jlU-j~, ~_y . __ ~.Il_4_:K,..."'Jil!ir.'!!

'ODmpl~~e 'v:ircue ~o;t; be :n~aUz~d :in 'thi~ ~iH1' ,md vb'il~ll~ 'W"rimJd :hl,Vt~ 'to' be :&(!lcessarUy looflDecled '~O ba.,pi'fiJless, iQl" '~e H~ilh9t 'Good '~o 'be. :re"IH:z:ed,,~ :Bult; no :s!ll~h [oonnecthm ID:btablS~l :tOf; 'vi:R,ue does :n,ct :~nl!vi,talbjh.f' lead tol :h~t'i'~~ness~ nM' morall~' a:ood ~ntfll~~o:;S '~O ~~,~ofr~, ~~~~ ~~~~~i1 ~~~~ ~~ -~I"".~~~~'" ~~~ ~~~~-,!! ~~-~- 1~!_,lin Cc. ,g,Y!U!l;ll

'1I!'[""".l!i'~~'IIt-'iI!' 'In" . 1~, ... 1It· an. " ' [i'I!iW¥Iim"'lll'[il'llD'" "'''!II]' [i"'O"Iilt~liI!i''!l ,;1'I;;"1IiHf~;i=Io"'~I·IiloH, ''''''~''''''I~'ll.:l[ 'L~, '~Tii'i,ififnl~~ ... i~ia,"'C '1<'

~,~~~::Wl~!I! ,_- I ,1~~~1.J _~ ~~J~~ ~~~~P-b ~~"'_--IJ.ld ·-~.~~{~Jj~iI~1l IT"U.WUJ tIC-. ll:l::I~~ul::~1}1W.~}~D",

to solve the prc(blem" :~l' it, wtO'mld. hl,Vf~ 'to, be 'bet,ween ,good ilict~tOO$, altd :bariPP~n!ecS8,r ',et, ,g;ooo, iIiI,C·tionS, ma,y 'be dfiille w,~,mfi1iWt: ,a, I~, wnll~IC,j. 1::1,;,-,19:1" Thll ,a"all'e:liIl!t lm;possibi'lity gj:'te~8, :~ise W' an :Sif:],tififim,,; W~ ~u::w '[him::~gh, the P,3it:~t, of. I.eamn 'tha,t ,th,c~ :m,otal la,w' cO'~dls

"''''!i"j;~Q'l'i~I~i''Iilil''["",," B"!lIilt~· ~~t~ :'I""'"~""'~: '~, ".~I~j:!i;O;i'iri'fiil"'~I]]I\C· ~;:"~·c:l["'~~ ,~r:;,..Jl. .. ·.-;fi ~. ~.~ ~:J": ,~ .~. _ ~~"""lIHI!!!"!Io1I'_Ui,,!!. . ""'. ,n I!;p i!io<!AlI,IiIiI!V!Il. ~ !!;,oah'~~,u'''',I!!io;a: ~~,J i:umma_l1'u,i;'I!III, [~Q KeA an

eind 'La i' ~ '.' ·.·~'Ii..;ll <1'. ~ 'f'" .. ·.-;:1 .. ';"V . jnj[ ·th··~· ~ ~ L"~ ~ ,'i... ~ 'b~ .. iii;. ~ ~ "

C,'_'__: ':__, Y_L.t :ilI UllpOSS.lLiPtL!i~: ,~JOJ" mi to 41i.;.\[(~e o,e, ,iI;L~ [' ;~rel,\!iI1:), 'Lne ,11I.~,esJt

,1:000, :is :iJm,ossilbl[e aecoming: to practical, :m.les,\i' d!ien, the mOl)]l ]:a,w which, commands '~'hat.il"~ be rutrtnewd :nl'l(llS,t 'be £a.rlii,W't~tC'j dJ~l\~eed, to ,@Jm~tu :ima~j-m:a~' [ends" [and CODi'et1li!l,h~fl'C'I~' '~nl'rrer;ellthl' '£aJ:s;eti ~[C,1 ~ T' ""I~[~

--~-,r-'-,$' --_'~"~~--'~;J' ->=- -.-,~ -- _.. . .. -~".- --~.~J' ~_ .. - I. -_!l - !l1' l .. -- I.... ~., . .I11:4.1~.

:h las; ~.mOO, t'O enJDcs, tha't ,Ka'l'IDlt: hre-Ile\ f'(YJSI I!:es, the 'pu.n.ty 'of his, :PJS.it~1Cil!l, 'The :ma:ral, :I_ra!w' :is, iCau~,godcal 4!nd, :IiIO!: oo:ndl.tio:~,e.d b,' ,o~ns!i:5'·' '~~ne,' 'wl;~h 'bappiness", Thill cD;t]!r;~s,m, ;~s, ii, :m~8;uEdteEsbjndim,g bO't'h IGf 'what, :Ka:nt: ,asserted ,e3.fi:1ier 8if.i,d, w:haJt 'he cla'~ms, here" ,As Ki3i~,t: :mm5~lf

'i'iI.Ii"ii,j-ifri;t~ji!i' ..... r~,t·~· ~'i':il "i\Ai'fI;"'v,? ~<fi;, j'O~l .. i;rl"';Qjm~'~:'1ii' '!I);..;"l'"~,:j~, [C·-:k~"",;j;~';o];n":. [t;",,,,'Fii"'" 11:--~.;j1';;....-..[iiJ;~~,~1 ''7~, r-~~~f. -!ill u~.. ~ILI;_III. l. ~~tl,,.. l'~ "-'''1[11.''_11,'''- rfJ. _ _D lU.l· .~]~.~IIii_a!l._II_"_ - U~_~"!'J.'''' ~I .~, ~_..!M 7'Q. f\r Q~

1lI,eV1ef.' asserted, and 'ricmm,g he 'sacfS i"m;,Jiies ... that :happl'il,ess, 1:5 ttO't Qf

''''iJi..~, '~I'Ii,t'C'm;T:iTi[!j~: '~i~i':i"",",*i"Ii:iJiPi"~ [~IT"'P "':tt"~_jO:iI'iIl~1 ~'Ii:!i! 'ii'ir~:~ ".:.ilfi.HI~","'"'l ~'~,.~,:·>~.,c~iioj~:"["' :"f: l!;._iILb ... "'" ~ _ .. l!o.i!'''''''' ,Hilil,,,,,v'iII, ~liIi)!"l!;p ~.. ,if,"' ,,," lOCI,. ~. Jl,,uA;p Wo'l1iIOONUJI,wDJ"ai1illi , Cuar.a)(l l,er 0

mOf,a1li'!t.,' 'mear~JS 't'oot ,the deslR :Wf; yeu'!: 'OWml, 'li"PPlri'leS8i :n-i,UlSt: D;ilt ;ili:'f.~1 'U',.,~I'!~, ~i~m:":\ ,d'~i~ji"'~ ~'.Lj'1if,~t~· ~IS, '~.nillr-Jt~·", '~t""'''';D;i!i' j'i'if[I,* '~m':.iij;o];n":~, ' .. ~I[;;;,j.' m.~~.l ..... ~'"II'i.'~lil.t ~,,;,

~~~.~ 1- U~ 1~llU __ . . _ .-~._i_;l_itI! 'n'l.HI_Gl ..... _ . Jll~_I .. ,~l .111 •. ~~"'1iJ ~_.u!IP. . __ ~-!M_ !Ir~lr~_J.J _ .u,lIIlalUJll}' ,~

t'he [om., g'Otld, ,and, b;n,pnnarAlt: t'i~g~, :Ul(p;p1ness :w'8, Oondil,t.i;IlUSJU.y' V'alllll,aIbl-e~ but 'w:b,en, :W,ts ,ooo'dI~,tiJ,o:n, IS, me"!j i"t: is ,a [1=.nr)uID.e, ~" 'J',he ,moral II'w' etlmmi"ts '~i 'to the :reaUZaliUnn, fif: ,t'he go 00, mmg:Si ~jiuu~ :r!1Jtlo,na[ be~Di.S phl!te v,a'~,ue 'OJ1" A w(;u:ld. ~~_fi 'wh-~,ch [good ptfipW,e are :fttisai8;hle :~$ mo.IaJl,. derec;ti,Vlt"

Tae t'!htl\mt :~, by 'the; impomU)Jlw,tJ of. lilcJlli~ving the :Hl[ghes,t~ 'Good :~51 'bes,'t 'u.im;slooo b,' ,oonsidmD.g the W,ai" til,.: :mfit:a'n :mo.ttve~ :f:u~l,etinn£" Yeru, v,i;@;w' '~D'UJr.S~l1f as, 3], ~m~mber of, the~'~t~~n-\~I''bt~, ~~{:;"ld

~ ~"~ ~~" ~~"" ,r~~~~~~ ~~ .~ _.~-~ .. ~ .~c ..•. ~ ..• l.,~,.lgll, Ie wo:r.,

,aDd SiC, as Ii, 'I'!iiiilssiib:~~: IC&:l~,"jS1.a;tM' 1't1, , ... , :rv~i~)~lr:o.~ I~ Ei~),.j,~," '-U:';:~c ,"',""~:

~ ~ "" ~ ~" .If ..... ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~ ~ ~,., _ ~ !t'Ui_~_"~'!;,iI,l!o)I"t~iIi'" """I , .... u,u;s. ,il-iOU are

[aDtGq: the, w'ilr:ld-~'s :ifJ.rRt Ciil~S, I,.u'£. thee .arm other' !ll\st C.iil!J1!JS-ec8:' (l,tner' 'I'!i.e;1';SmDS\ and w'bart?tv'el' else ])8 [eS~fJjljJb:rne tim' tk~ '~'.~~":' ,t'~'"llic .. ~, . [",.:-:':' I"'

Jt ... ~~~~~.,~, ._ - "'_d ~, .d •• ., ',t'''''' ", . e wa" ." ~,~ ap,p~

,~"" D" iI!i "Ii,~.~ IJ","" ,..Jt ""L,,. 'i'!n"li*.iI<~",'.I[ "'\i"!I:~ l<iCi-'" .~i: ,j.Jb~ 1 ... ~ ~~, <t "~in"."~ 'jI"'_ . ;io'I!.. ... ~-.y, .: _l~, [_I:U~U. ~",.1!J.f. v.-~ IU~~~~ 1._~:._A·~-~I;.i&_1 [~D~-,__fJ;~ D.,"~ 1~_.J=1e.~ .LLiI:w,s. O~l nal,,~re.. .U-IJ I~e

phmamemial ~wtldd me rcS':'~lts, ,of. oUr' ac"t.I:~s, De d!e~enDm~d :n~t 'rl~st by eU'f' 'BW,D, [U,teniuoms\!' 'ht~ by ,t'he ,~J)~tJf$ I)] :mait;W"e and. th~ aeeiens of c:rther, pe~I\Sun~L O11'r aU~m,pt8 b), I.leaJiz.e ,the ,Iood ,~re. o.f't~n div~J~~d lb,'

Copy rig hted m ateri al

:"'~ [a, :dptc.eou-f), ,~J d.~~re~,:o.o ad,v.~~~.e: t~ ,h(i;m$eill~: :f!f()m, .fornm.Q'lW~ing hk~ :mwail Jlw'l:r ei'ther :tn 'tbbi 'Qf. in ,ano.tneir' 'Wm~d~ he, wi;sle~w :r;a!;b,e:~, di5ro,t~mt~ [ed~" w [estJa'bllsh 'dte.I:O~ ~o -whi.c:h t~a1t ~oJy ilia,w [dii'oocts, 3!U !brj;s powers,> Btu'.

his ,,:,,1'1.;.,: ," '·"1 '~:,-,y.;j,:,.;j, "'."~~' '.',[~ '.["]1' ,,:, ,J~,"lnl~, 'b::' M>,:("~"~;;~, 'h:~· ~ [';,11, , . IS !CHon IS 1m1!~nYI~., ;lnu, !li,WIn ,na,tl'!LI!rel :lbj't~ll1lf~.i!SJI'~ ne ~a;y. eqlect .ere !allJ!u

,there ~ w,DJtiq,e~t ~o:r~ce\!, he c_ fi~ve4' ~t~ ,a, :r..egula:r h~Q:D·Y ••. " ,~~.::"t'!hl Ill:: 'niii~~ wb:i ~,b he '~i' f~~]s h~'lnsi~f o;b~~~ ;i!lld hn,,,,,t!]]~ to ;i;~~O\nl~

WI , ~ ,l'~~.~",," . e t I,e, 1-'" , - , . , -]- . -. -. . ..",~"-'!;I" - - , -. ,,~ . , .. , , , .. ,

'"il~s;h" Dece-'i't, V;i,o],el'l~- !Sind e:ouv' w:i~rn iiJlw,~,v'l :s]llLttCimd. hr5Int~ iill;moU'",,'b, he.

,r-'-_.' __ 'I ~ ." •• 'J ~J ,[I :r, • .-=J"."~ -=--=---=-,~ " •. =I"!'J.' .~~-~ '~·~'-.T~ ,~~ ~-~ ~ ~- . ~ ~~~~51~ ~~

:hirn~e1f H hone~t~, ~c:~'bL~ .. aad kindly~ and ith~ ri..[~ns m~~ w,~~b

", -,:~"'~ : -_. 'L..-,' i ,,,', :'~:". : ',:,/'~I'li ", ;'!W~ '~" ; 'i" ,~l., ." .' ,'i.,,~, , W"[ 'iir'i'n- n •. ~~ '~b'l ',' [,'i[ ".,'.:' ,: be "'-';"1;' W~iL:illm, ne meets W,III, not, ~ U~i,'5;t!il_~l!I!!lng bd!..(1[ ,~~cfit_~J.~e8S \)I'~ =iI',~~~e;ss1 ~ rei!!.

'liiii~'I!.-]'_;b"'" ~-'v n""t"'l'lii'''' '''w~I'lhI:, .. 1Il-1 'iii""" 1ii..:il,=-1 ",I 'n""~ t",lh:I",1 tii'O-:-' ",,1'] ,;.;"f' .... , ;iii!iji";;]i<' ii'j;~ ji~--""'i"ii;i;, .~l!!'ii~_''iJi:;iii!, JI3I.11_tI! ~-!I,;'!i;lLI. lm.~ .. ~aJ ill.lll_IJJb.ll L •• ·lIHlJI.i!l.;.i~1J .IIJJ~lr.-:1:LI_1.l! ... ,~- .... lJHIJI,;_I3.~J lll.-'.- ,aJl·. !l_l_l1~~ ...... !I'i~, a ..... _1 ·n· ...... !lJ! ~~I.l .... iI1_I.l......_~J

,a.,.jil 'Illfn'~~m' ,;;II,]~1l' ["iD!a~il!:ol 'i,llC!t '~I"l'i~\i;I! ~;L"" ~",:,l1;~.\~, .,,:,~ :'i'h.", [iD!,l1;~;L, __ ' 'jIj'I'i;.,;a;, n"l~i~'" ~'L~n"_"

"_II_L-~ v __ 1"-_;1 ~ I~ 1II!IiIri"I._~_~p. lp.l"'~_. l __ 1IN1!Ir 1~_I~IJ'!irI ~~~~ W L!r __ I"" II!Iri!HL~.L!r_I~lrI ~ ~ r. tW. ~1_~'IIIt ¥'!Wi_iIi.J..!'~~j. 1!r_IJ~ --Il

'ii:Ji.,1hI;,,,,'Ih ,.,1!.."l'''' 'ii:Ji."~"I'l~'~inl~--D"~""iOI,;ii..j iiliIP"'~ 11'- .. .,1 "","",fill O-"~u~.,.'k .. "'0-' ~i-fV"" '!..",l'O-'""" 1Ih"l'-mc' "l' .... 'b,~!E, ·~·.~-~~c~~:~ l~~~~~ ·~~r~,__;'I"":.~~~~~~~.~~.II4r~_~c~W '. ~~_~j~~. lIEll~_~. ~lIrc~ l._ .• : ~~!~, 11!J._ .. Wl~·!P.'~ g~IJ.:..~IJ}~.lIIl,··, .. ,ioL .11 .. ~

:PtQtlit IQ'.f mow ,~3,WiS~, 'ht'. Inn~'t ctrrtatnl,y' l81iv~ ~p as ~liIl!po:SSli'bl~. [~Cl 4$..1,1

Th,e: :Modv\iUiing t'hou,p,t '01 :mc-taUty :18 ~he ·t'~O;l!lgh;t th3i~: yfi'."tiiI, t;~Hl

[""".iI"1tft'4i'·rlib·.I~'iIi'~ 'iI' ..... maktn gI' 'iIi'L~, '~\u"-.i!1iIP"I~1 ,;l; 'U'i'nlad' ;i"I;.m .... ll:' ~-,n.~ll:" '0,'1"[.' ~,f. 'V~.I~'[' ~ .... ~1~~~,~_~.1~~~ ~~ ,~~~J~ ~g,~, llnIP~~~~U ~J A~~,_ ~" 1 u_I .Ei~_~U~., p~I"l .~I· l/'~'~'~'

""iI'.~!ftIiIoft;t\iI!l "'1:_' ,~"'W""'~~~ ·,.ll·'.~iI!i!l'iI',"'d' 'll.i!IiI" n.)L"", .. ,,:iL ......... ~~ .,'L,OI'.' ."L,nic'l'.' .... ' ... ,,.., 'i,~ ,O"!,~ W"0"!1lP!;'.' [~~!L.-~~I~~ [~'!P.II aI _·_.~IJ!·~I ~.~".~,~~_~.:__. ~;J' Yll~~l~_~ ,w.~~-~~~J l,n~~ l'll~~_~J'l ,~_~~, ~_~I ~~~~,,,,

rsa!~ falSi@; and fm'tastic.

--,.}· .... I ~---- - -~-- ~---~--- -~-~

The :sO:W,U!~i[D'n, 'tD' ~;h:~51 :as, tD' 'e'vm ,_,tiJnom:y is '£'0 a:,peal '~D th~ n()lam~n'!i'~l'nh@n,omi¥inal dbiitincHt:.km. :!m Itt-he wcQ'J':I.d, a~ :smse ,ilth,~[\~ ,~iS, :11l0

-- - -,~- --~~- ,t"'~--- -~ -~-~ ---- -~- - -- -~- ~- ---- -, - -- -, - - - ---- -~ --- - - - -- ---

fC!aU!sal 'Cim!niC1l;eth~n 'betweeiD, a vb:tUGUS disposition, a111.d, :ba,,~1'D,e5s\t bu,'t 'lhelle ~c)1;dd be a ItQm!U~cJtion, betwt:en one's nG'u'mena;~, di:s:,osi'tiO'Il and [Gne~,s, haNmes5, :in 't'be wi(Y.nld, of sense. lu,t~ 't'iniS, OGnn,ect=inll1 'wQu]d 'be ,~Ddii~ect:: i'~~ 'wou'ld 'be :mooia't~d by ,a;l]j, ,A,uthQI' [D'J~ :Na,t~ure 'wIh,o, :hlld de.signed l'be la,w:s [M :na'ture 50, 'tba,'t 'tile [t~Im;eetl~D balds ~C1, :[[ 1:,4;, .... ' ]: 5 J. :[n, oriel" tDI plily tbe role 'en,v,isaged, tnis, A"u:tbnr W'fi:UlI]d, nave ,to 'be omui;poil:tn;t [~'eo d!eail111 dle :~a,w:s of: :i'ia,turel; [o;lmn~s.c4em!t~ 1,'t'D loo:k :1!ltt'D dle. :heans, [Gf :mtlo:nlil Ibeillgs and :bJofyy' the {lit :mol.:al dj:S,posj,'tlon:S!~[f [sttd ped:ect~y goodJ. The Autho{t, oJ :NliU,Uire 'w(flllld. :h:a,¥le 'tIle [a,'tUiib.ui,tiC~

t- -";!i;d' l~'''~n .. ;o:i '~Il'v ,;!j;;Co.r..~i'b,;t;; 'd' I ,Jj.~ .......... ~I ~'C'-';i'iI, 'Ii' 4' n [i T,1t 'iii.:'!.. ""IFe-' ''Uii!',tI,.. .... , '~I r ..... .jI ';j;'~.tiIifl'C" .: ... t'> .~.~I~-~-~,"'~t~-~~-·,i Ig~~,~, __ _>~-.~ ,,~~~ .. ~,~, ..J".~_~IJ. u: ~_lI~~~·.~ .!r-!f~~~'~ ~~~J ~~:I,~ __ ,._.,. l .. -:-J;I!~

H'ignesJt Good, WCJtilld 'k~ PD5sibte~ ;and, fiiinr-sH,ty wfiuldJ :1'I,ot dh:ec~t: 'U~ '~O imposs.i,bte [emds\;, S:jnce w'e :m1!!lst c:be'y dle 'mG,t;a'~ law;; a_D,d, tbe;f;ei'~te mus,t: [ado,pt~ ,t'he :H'ip,eslt~ [Gooo, as ~u'r efid~, 'we~ need, tiOl beU'e~e 'fIlSl!t; end.

1';;:. finlCl;Co~'If·;~I.", ~II"I;I ~'e.-' ne ..... fi 'iii" ke-}Il',e-iiille-' 'm~··~ w:-;c:\[,nl~' 'iilIj~'l~]~ 'ii:7Ii"i'3~;ti; l\i'r fini!i'IDi~b~-"'l~IP ~1~,i:jI

-_~I .t"~~~1.I.~).UI~i'?i!!;'1'1 lo.~ ·mJ _' •. l-!lr~J ,.~'U [0 JIL·· '!f.'i .. ,' -. ,.,. II.-W:IIiiIIIII.. 'f1'II!·,III~ u 1 .IIUU.:_&_I'!i.,.. .. ,., .r.v-al~'J.IJ -.'!IJ.!. I, ,~~_&;~

is, :n,ot ri, 'OQD,tiintell!t: need1, 'based, {!tn an aIbi~r:aIJ" desire~, 'bu:t ~'j' a, need of: ,pUlie tetson." 'IllUs, pro·"Id!es ,3 :pure :pl;acticral I:e~fi :fnr: 'be:~ie.f Ill, GOd ~C:1\ :[1'41/1\=;43;1."

,A, SI'mUtn' upm,en't es,tabUshes ~he pl,acd,Ciiii~, ra;t~fim:aH:t,. of: belief:

Copy rig hted m ateri al

•• - 1" -,~ 'I :i oj: ~ '~t,.

Ul :~mm~na'~,ty" ,It lIlJe mmlfiS., :.a,w oGm.m~n~S, l1"OU tu see_~, Y'O'lWir (TwU

mOif.a], :~ri\ectt~n::: tl"~e b6~iI~lesS o:f: "fGUi~ 'w-tIL Th~S! C3iFlifi'Oit be a,ch'wevted in ehe QOUIiSe ot vn~.n:' UllE 'oor: 1]0 [Gne 'Ylfh'b ,a 'Sie-fiSililO'Ulg; as wen as a

, . - . - . -" -" - --.. ." - . ' ,,--.,,' :' .. " ,'. , :' - - - " - - , - , , , "- -- - ,,, - - , - - .. - - - , ,- - , ,

,."'.'\-" .. '~ '-, ,Iio!', , _: 'LI,[·:, '_,",' .-'I[[,l"j,' ".-·-,_i:'_·'-clif [~!-~-,:.,:,"-,.~:".[-,-,.- ':w::":i1."~I~~ '-I ,:----:--'.~,j;,'11,---,

f,II!i,;tQnl1 na~m,e .IlI!!1i!S, ,!:Ii mC(f~c.y ,p;:n'e~j~, w~~\l.I~'l~n.. ,~~:aI;~, :aJ !I;;:'f~",~le

W~b,OI ~!('i~t~s ,in, '~im.~" [Si~lbj~~t ,to ~~illlwity ~.d, :S~ to :~m~iib:Hi~~y, c~n, a~~~~ :~i pr(}8]'~~~ t!~'w,~rdS! btin'!Jl~sS' [of 'wiU. M e~df~,~s'5[ :p:~ope~~, :~s ''''~iiIIi' ,iI!["Ii'·m··';:;, t,itI'i; ,t;lb' i!!- [i'iiV)lliji.:!' ,~,~ roo :~;[l: ith~ 3.rb;h-i~vte'li'iI1rmitt' cf ffiloHn~ss "The

1Ir_~_I~-. l~gl_:I_~,...f. 'X"J ~_j~, ~,I~1i!! 'lQi U·.;.;~w ~ l_~~_~ I~J~ __ ~~,~ -a- -:_.-J~~ _ _!l~, ._-~. '~:_.:..-'.... ... )~;""::'-.";'.";'!I .. ~",~~"~.

'I';-:-'~hf'~e ,k~n,a~ to wbo;m '~'he t~mpiJXa:~, ,ii.}il'nmJtiO'n rus, noithi'n,Q"- seesin

, D __ ,1 .. , ,,_ -'01 c c - .. = ,~.~, c_" ~~~, - ~~ ~ ~.~.~~ .~ ~~~ ~~ ~.~ - .~~~"'_"'eJ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~-

,t'~'~, j:!jiilli'i'i1il!ij:!j,. w'~~,i""'h is '~lj'iil' "~liC, '\,.rirL,L'i}tl!Jt @ndi, ,:3. w:!bn~,e iCillilite;p,mahl~ t\Ol th~

_1Il_ll!iJ! g'!ir.ll"'!i.ri"'j.J __ lJ_l'-l~~ ~-~ ~~~ ~~ ~~ l""lllJ~~ ~ - --=-"------1.~ ~ -_~~~ -~~~ __ ~'~ ~-~_

-r: -::4'1] ]~ ~'W'i'j [~'C:':! 'I':l'lll'li lJi

~11~\l,~~ ,"~'-.- ~": -"-- ""':__.:J,,~,

A f~i;~h 'ffin Goo, and :~n i'm'mGt~~UJt;~t of '~b~ :S1il)U'~, tm~lS 'ba5~d ,on. pr~~t-i·' ~aJ :rea:Stlll, - 'p:lt!te ",f.'a!c~icd ,birth ~"is n@it j~!S't w:~5hfum th'inl~in!l'~ be-

~ '-' " _-

~;::'~~"IS-:- 't ;Slf"ri'i'fiJil'S, '~m ,!it 'radom'tal d~md. As, :K.an't s,tri'ki'D~~~' 'p. uts i'~:~

!li:a~u e l,.t.'t"iI,~, ,=c, c~,' ~ ~_~~_~ c~cc c ~~ ~~~~. ~ .~~~~ ,EiI!'"''' '_, . __ ~ ~.

G:r~nt~ ~bart the '''_ntt :m!t1-rail ~3,W' ~intexlil};rabJ:~' hinds every' :m3~ !3.S ,3, !Cn:miJ.marn,d

lIT'" t _

~n,Q't as a :nle o:f :~mden.~~~, ~he :~;~tOOU.iS1 '~, may' i~a,)r~ I 'w~11 tb~~, dl~r~ '~e i!1 GMj. 't{ha,t; to" [~rdst-efi-O~ in, th~s 'wlillrld. ~ [almS() an, [al'sU~~~~ in, a :p1.J;I~ wo:rld o:f t1he; '1J~d;Ir.slatndi'll'''' .d, 'l1'n:alhl ~'haJt m'~ ,dut.'4tio~ k endless ~e'1 '!IJ'o'q[il

._, _ • -, _, ., r. _ ~._~~J. __ ._. l J~" • " , __ I~ ._ •• _1._ ••••• -.~ ••••••• _-.I .. - .- .... ~. = 1:"'l~.JI11

fillS does, 'DJot mean 'dta:t.. £~i'dl is ,oom~m~n~~d. 'Tlh~ ,motam la~w de-

_:"iT'll,..;I,;r;, ,t'~:""'t: .1O"",i'!O 'iIo'iI!--'l·';t<O'i~, t· :L..;g; L ~, .... 1,,~ .. ,~. ,0Ti .... c1 'I'!iCiO'; .. ~'~J[;g. ~. "'I'~I40, tit· ;L,,,!! ' ...... ! ...... ' ... ""'r "In ~'_i5Y~'Il~~ .-~_!_iP-'" n"~ ~.~~I iIJ-LH;; ~~ ,P._!~~~~~l~, Q~!y!g ,It~-~~~~~~ 11l1~J~, ..::111~ ,~~~~-~-~~-_ ,~,"~.~I

w~b'iC:b we aee t~1 think ~f it~ ,~~ :PQssibl~ :i~, ,S'~.bj;~~t 'tl~ O'~r iQ"W1J_ ~-lu:~iceh' since [~~~f.:e~so~~ ,c:m~t: obJecth!''el" dfl~id~ wh~jt-h~Ji.' i'~, :~s' by U~'~C:l-'U'~] ] aws, ~f: 'riatwe 'w-"'~'b~lut ,I 'wise.: It uiihoil' nresi dbil!o~ O've![' '1ilJ~,'"

~lliV1e:, .. a, __ " .. ,.,~. __ l,i~.~ __ ~, =~~~,~ !I?""~ ,Ij.-~ '_'.',_ =~

'~1U~e! [m' wheth~~ QJ1~y on, th~ ,~Si~~m,IP~:k~\D, I@f S'~~h an Au;~b@OCii (C~

'I'~'~l 'jD"~I",o;~h' ,,- _.~L[I·~· ~"--'I :1 need ,,.,.:1.: ~,L,~ '-'-[',,-' ,djj",. ii~f,['" : nd '[1' "[I' 'II!-:1 f5, ~, ,iI;·~U~,., 'Sll;rn~Igs, !I.rom ~, ~ee~, VI IYIie! m~l'iY-,-~S,~b~=O:tl ,HL ,~ ,S!JCJu

:i8, ''ViO'ltuntary. Salv,atIJ@lll Id~e:llitd!S on, m(ll;l C:b_afac:t~4:'j' not O~~ 'wb~t

H'i'i,~ b .. ' ii!i l.:I.-:;.,..t,i:!O_~,_,l!:iI!

'!'.!' •• .,.... ,,'!;.\1_~~''Il" '!;,;!iII,

Om' 'beIiJ~~, i'~, Goo~, :hn.1n@-1'~~n~.y' ,~d fiOO~d-Qm, - tha'~ :~~ '~N."i~,t~~~ :iI't ran b:u,~e.Uig~bl~ watf.'ld. =' a:r[~ '~1J.I'Qs,tula.'b~~ of. :'J',:;)!~ti,~.aJl r~'.1!Son, I;}' A, :PQ~~' 't!.\:'l~;J!~e 'O'.f pra~tJ~il J~;JJS(;L~, :is t:h~O:f.~~-iI~ :bt fnmn." a5~I'~mB; ~m~ltllinB:

· ... b:"""·(~t'; '.~''''7I';;'I·' ,ilif', ,~Le-~' ease 'itie~ 1-' ~'t-, P._,;:i'i'f"r-'f>:(-' '~7'. ""h'-lii"i'Ij'''lf'3'l "';l.;fI;iijL-"'e-~lcii"_,;ii;l~~' ~""'" ~':'e~,_ !I;;I'!I!!!I'_ '!!'I'.J~~!~, ,.H§\I !!!oU!. ~~'I sv» '~'" !I,,;~n.LV." ~;;;I. 'I;l!'n.L~,[;U~ ..... .L'_ !I;.~i""~ ~'1 '~-I'<;I! IU_

.,.,i.;L'~r' ,;j;.·ru',I.g or '~.~'llliIl'':'; DI'I~'.' ~"",~, '~:";"'--'!I",'g 'i'I!_ m'!' !ii'\I:i!iI!"-J;i;c.,., ~p' :ri'II!!II~·.'mg':' ' .. "" .. ...,- 41']1.,,,,, , .... IAgd,! , ..... ' 'II;;I .... lli.::n~IIi:r_ , l!. "- ~ '1..01" ,~W:.::::l~," .Eli1""1'- "!n'!'l!1.:r ,1IlIaJ·"'!IiIr 1tIIi1l.l. ,I IJIj,,~_~~,all..:;]." ,~,~~I"I" I· '_ [liIJ:Lu,HI£ 11.\;1I:1~ , .. _~~-~-. :a!

~-~ ~-~- ~ - --- ~_ - - ~ -~_~-- _ ~ _ ~ ~ _-~-~ ~ ~_ ~-~ ~~- __ - ~ ~ - _ ~, , ~ - ~- 1.1'"r-'~--.'_.' ~-~ - ----~ ----~ ~ _-- - ~ _ -~

o.f m~fdi't.y' :in b~l'~,~vi'~:g i~~,n S(i;n~e pOC'a~ti~!J)~ ,reaJ~illilJ, lSUppo.__~li lb~~ief :~n

,t'L,.,.. '~t<·I~'li'''I.'''!i''''! ,j,lIi'l'" n .... 1I",i'l\~r .;o!<,: ' .... GO,'""'! ~ .... ]4''''''-, .. ,~,..'g t· ,"L, ... ,.... "i',L.~,t, .... iI! ·;I.,'L,;g,ifri ...... ,..-;;:,1"',_1 "~~IIlI~ ,~-~~~iW~j~~-~J ~~~J ,r-~·" ~~, ,~~ ~~~~,~ [~,l~-'I§_~=~~,~,." ~ ~~,~~,~,~ l~jDa.-= y,;Il: l~n_~~~l~~~,~

f~,3}SQnJ,!' ]'Q ~s'tlb]i$'hing ~be :PlS;~la'~~s~ :'r,~c~ci~ 1\~5O'n t~k'es, '~1P the m~t~ph:ysi,~ ta;sib, '~ltat ,~'h(!i:Q~,t~~11 ~~n ha,d, t~l rili~dQ.n., Fo:r' ,H: t'lileJ'e ~i a Go~ 'wbo m4de the w'Olld :~n I@irder to aeJr.d.eve; dle IU_Iest

i'""i:_~A ,iit'L_, ,;j;,L,;;;, '~Iil'''''''''l~[d'- .;;Il~iI!l 1,.-,~~.,.;, ""~I ,.'.I .... "" .......... ·-1]~,,.~ii"ii'i:'i:""I~·~'!IJ' D'1j'i"1"J 'n'I'~IH'ii;i"ioi[;lil;:Ii;' Ui~j.' L!ED~~, l~~~ ."" y,~ "~. g:-~~ L~·'r-·~ [~ ~~~y,~,~,~~~~,~~J: o~-~ ,~·~,~I1~-~~E' A

'~~~,~olQli,c~~, ~t}~Olln;~, [0'£ ~'he sort th~i~, '~h~ ,m~~atph'ysi~ian i~:eks '= [on~

Copy rig hted m ateri al

,a· ·ii'!\;Fi'ii".;r.,A~,,":i'i' t~: ·t .. ~1..I~iI"!:"'1 ~~~3i·"i!ji~'bI~f'iIi)i· ~,!D, 'if"",-rfla f~oi"iil:" 'II:"~ •. '~~~i' ·~'-n. I 'it·ltD.· a'~~i: ,ij>'t~J~ w-~""}U..lLllb. lut-f ft' l]t .. }~_J_IL iW'" !w_l. , 1'"-1~I_"_;L----e.1 ~_g .1LI_oUII~'_ ~~I. IIl.jIHI~ DCa:~ ,MI __ , 1i._IlJI .. ,... JLJIIir-I.'l!:1. u.-I rft...lJ_LlI

'Possii'ble: 'Woilds ,"""", Wt).liild be 'true ~Cjj, :[ 3.2.-41: I\.

1:t~U~'iii .jU, ...... ~ ..... ·c·t', m',·c . .,.,j;a,.\I:" ,io" .... ''"lt"' ·1i\',.;O<i· ... iit~mI ,t~I~';i;,'1!.. ''''lllilknu.sb r--:a·~t·~o:c",.,;;,;l I..:I.,-..=.., 'n ..... iii ',iln'" U,~~,~, ,~~)~~ c~~~J~~~ ,"~-~~J~~ ,tf~,~-~!Ij.~-~~~-__:, 1~~,U-~111 ~~J'~lv-~~~ '-~J ~:_'.~~~ ~~,~~"", U~~J I~~cy~, ,~,~:_,

,am""" 'W8V ,extem.d OWl' In:()wl:'''I~'iLlI'e We, cannm ·~s@. m@ t:e:n.C-lts l~l·p:r.actl·'

'i! 1 ,f' " . "~- - ., ,,_. _, ~i,:;)-'. - ". -." ._ 1,,' '-' .

,eal :faith. to ~J.aiD the 'w"a,y' '~'hirngs -e~. ·o;f' tQI:' any 'tb,ecmetlcol. pur:~s. This :s·n.o<w;s. thdit crwr' ftc;alties aife ·W'll'ae:l.,· ,.p~ed 'til {fu~' voca·, '-':"J --: I" '1Ei' ;:--: . "C'If. ~. ·~i,--:.· ~ 'il 'r: ~F,-:-=-·,' --:-, .- '1-: ,';'I!r ~. jD~-"c c~ ,A:~'li 'r -,. c'~It.·ii -~ ·~W·~~·C" --_:'lld: -I·, '\-, :":t-- -: tlon~, ,11;'01 tfl.e: .uual. ,pDq.K}se (} rille ~st 01; mu .i£lns5:111J.iI'c , .. '01',1.8 ,16 rue

,amieve.eDit: of' :moqil g~ess· 'by brwmaf:l beiIDg5 1~IC3, .4411 ~'4'l').· ,And,

.~t. ._, ~: ." ~.J ·m~.~ ;.;t;!I.:!!ii'l'ii·L'V"iii.,i ....... ;1i 1.,.,= .. 'fii<Iji'l-,'"'":iI~p,. ,U' TJ!~' ~U.l~1 ~l~llT~-~~-~~' ~:~Y!'f!l"~~l~~rII

- - God] iiUld. ~wmit.v' 'rn ·tb@:i'r ,a.w[uW 'ml~'e~t."· wouWd stlind. D"nceash'~~1'", bidtO:R

~ r. <11 • I.". _ _ "_ ..... _ l __ 1 •• f " _ _ _ _ r. _ .•. __ • l ~I. _- ••• .,. • ~ •• ". __ ••• _ _ _ __: _ I. - •• I_~l.' . _ I .. ..: .

IO\IJC qe5h •. , , , 'n_spe8-SjOH of 't.be~ Jaw 'wowlld mdee~l h .~ned!,j' ,~j tbe I~gmtnalnd~ wQo~ld. M :peri"Q~~.I~t; '~ca'~~ 'tb~l dJij.pg~tig.n :fr:Q-m. 'whi~'b a~doo~ :~oul~ be dom.~ ~Qt 'M msdfl.ed, by' ·:HI,Y loom'man~ md b~Q~J~

".'11' ~ - ... ~ '11.1' ',1;,.' '~t_ 'f! - ~.. Ai . 'I; ~

t .£~ :S"Mlf.' Ito II'Ctmn 'Wl}.UI~. ln, t:Wlililili ease 1M;: ;iI/ways :,r,e8mJt _iolIi. e-'XJll~mal;, ressen

w-o~l!d. have ~o' ~ 'to 'e~~a,,!'-:nf:' tOt gaJtht=J' it~ ~~re~ tal :~~~i~t th~ mcJma'" 'ti,oo bV,1 Vlivid :iel of '~Jw d~i~it..v af~ d'U~ law Thus most .a.ct!ion\St ~lomTrnill'

• I,"_l "(/"" l. ], ., -, _, I.·.· _.', __ ~~:._ .,.. ,.il :_" _ .,_Il I .• _.,.:,.,- .•... _', ...... , ._.~

,t~ t'b.~: la~' W'(UI~ld 'bc' be .~Hl! fw~, few· wo.d rbe: Idone: from bO,pe~ li,~~

'iE:..r."lf·m.· ;I "'''i w' '~"'" l"!';'loO'"i'",;11 ·,_,~''rt .'"1''' ''''>!,,''-'~n';a,- 0'" ~'Ll·""'1r- ,1'~OI!'''" ,.}'r.;p;, '","-,!'O'Ji-Hi"b~_' o·~ ~'I,.,,!! ll~IJU __ I !U;MI!lr.Ttr. JJ..t.1.1JiII. , .. Jlt.u,IJ •. IL U'UJ.lli._I:1l W. _~!Ir_L1i.I..: __ iriJ.--J.! ULLll L~ll::l_ ,\i;.I_~. _IAJI.ltL~ U.lv. U'U:.I.'I:._ I _IL lli._l_l~

PC;~g l!1iruil, '~. 'af tQ wlod'd ~& biI. '~e ~';OJ ~~~:m.e 'Wi~m~, would :nm. exist.,at all. I~C:l' 14111

larlle, 'W'aS ,g ,a!fd~~t ·cha~."ion lei 'di..~ Amu~d~. and IFT~'tuib. :R~:y~.Ur-· nom .. :8'i.s support .fill' 'dle :IQJt~eit Wlln. mw I. ~ep,u't8ltion as, II J~eo'bi'D.t and :aJt Qn.e1 p)mJt 'rililI~re W·8:S ,I w.id~s.pread rumGf' ·t'ha't h~ 'W'!1S, ,ggilng t'Ol 'ads, as lb. !1d:vi.sox '~O '~'he: .new· ,S,Gl'~ml .. enLI)~~· :Jaebmil'liU'iI wd;t~s, ,of Kant."':'s, .~patb!lnce for .n-ews, .&nm f..rtnc¢jt .• iIl his o'~ssjO.ID. ·wilm. 'me su'~at 'liD. IOOniVHS3itimn .. U· H'ts ~nnrh.usmm .£·ml' ,th~ 1.·e;Vtf:JhlJuom. 'W,"5I;D'

- --,~J. - - ~ ~ - -'-~ ~ ----- -.----.-'~ - ---- --~--'- ---'--~~'- --- ---- -.-.~- - ""- - --- ~-'--~ ~~ ~

.nut as id!ea'li:ztng; as 'd18it of many 'Ql.!l,ts· a.(lm;[fet8~t and :he ,dliid. nnt, 't-Utlii). iI,pm&t .ti,t: wlheD. 00 :i!Dd'.Y·lot"h.e:rS Idliid., .Aoo([mhlg: tt) lOilie repo:rt~ i!'the .s3fhl.

-0"1'-1 tD"~'- - ·~tl- --- -- ,;.~~ =f.\r: ~ ~ - - ---- -- -~~ ;~-- ~ - --. ~ ~ .". - - ~~ - ~ -edc~ ---,·th-- .".,~~-

I'~_I I·-I··.·. I:I··:~-~:.-~I"I:' 'I~:I I:~.-~·~'·~:·~ ···"·.~'I"· -n'~~I':III·I~---··~II, (~-'I~-:-lj'··:·I-.'·I· '.-"J-ll~1 ["11',:

a ., . . e ,. JOlIm,s In. , . an.cc W-e:H: Ulllm:pID:rtallt romp.aT! . . W]J t .. iIi:

tIf'·b-:l)o.l'if'I'" ,.'I~~11 "l''" Id-'~~~,"~'Ii!I~ &(t~l Ct"~h~.I~OI"~1..1 ·~1ji"o1i!i(li)""d.! ·1it~;l1 ;"'~i"~.;Y:d".J '~'"'~ ,i;'~~. """_ .. , .... 111;;0 ""''1!J1I. !!al; .'!I;riQ.,t'"",.Y".UI.I, ., .. n~. 'n .1",,1:1 .I''',IiID_I>'',I;;l!l;r ,II_aU! IJi'lIiUJ;\I,'!Io!lll, GlI,.L-!ilI, "lfl.e

JaO()b'iM w'tr-e ·n.h)babl\~ ~~b·t. :·~O all dle:v 'W'e:fie do:~i~·Ht"·;-i)ei5 Ghr-:---=- t'h:-: . . .,1 ... .. .. iIr' , . . ,f J"1I!6I1o ,I "." ",.1 • .00' . , .. en e

bii;~1..t val'uei he n]ao~ on '&~o:m and hllllDWIli .~:.~i~rt~" it 'iiS fiO'~. :S~~DS;r.

-1(!5iUi ... ....' ,t'.. , .... ,..... . .... .. , .. .,. . .. .., .lI'Ji,5liil. ·1 . - -'.. . ..ar'··

i'm~ ·dlat.lle, 'R,O'l:llniJs a ·ref1ahllc. ,itS the' deal fonn of: d:o-vemm,ell~" B'wt ,~,~ .

• "iC! .. -.. . •.. ,,, ~- , ..... ":1:'" •.... . 11..... . .. . ., . Dc .. . . . .. - - ,... . . .1"

Copy rig hted m ateri al

')'.' .. ''i'Ii. 'R.· ': '!i<1i'T i ;:1. [kif ~'R-' ," '~'. 'i"<'~"~ '~' 0" ~ ,'1" 'l!i!'U' W'

.J!~ , ~A.!L:"!II ... iilI' "'~J.V .,m.Ji.o .iIf,~,.I:,iLo' .- .. ,"''!;JI',I'" H I;

is, ~M'pdSh1:1 t~ :qd. th.i5! '~mI.thil1Jl$i!i$m .. (1)1' :i.'ts .!l'u:t·M~s e$!taib.~'.iJ$)h'-ent: i'm. a. man, w:liito, belie:'¥,~d thHlj~; W~ :m~s,t .ai[w,aiY~' ,;t~t ~S' ,c~.~e:m~, :m. ti~@.

'li":""~f1i,''''''' ,-,",.il: '~"l'",r!I:- '.I~"'i ... ·~ml .. iI""'" "I""·f: ... ..., .. ,.,.,gn:o'l·,g ... "","",,,, (l1"'i"d·l 1'1).''''1,.",,,,", ,ii.-;"'';'iii'·L "'n:' rl~~ :D-1J~~~_~~.HuJ tw .~~~l ~,~~,l~~I!J~ y~ ~~~I~~~'M~~~~j! [~~~." .Ir~~,'¥·~ ,~-~'.I.!I!-lI~ ~". ~~I

tn ~~ 'li'hiJn,~ , ... · ... '1l..1t 'W'ha:t 'n]:lk:es. U ~v,efl 'iml11i:e sl:limn;smg' is· ·th.a:t ·Iant·

J¥ ~~, ~~~_:_~ ~~~~~~~ L~ .... ~~'.~ ,~~~I~~_~._ ,~ .. ~~ .~ -e . __ ~I~, ,~~_;~~~ J.~ .. ._:..'~.,r_or~~)~. __ 1 :. -_~. I" ' .. ". '.~ -).1

~' ·w~t.e· tIIilt: :re¥(.\lu,'U~fi :is [aJ).w':a".s .: ~& and ·t·!fia,t 1~1:t :~s ,t'lIe, ~~l~.llS1 [d~lt' t'O ~nd)ure~ ~~~. ,the m(Js;t iot{.l]e:ml'Je ,ahuse o:t:: :S'~,preme IJU'thol'.i·~;1" [~MP.J 3,~I\·~7

K.a1n:e~ 'nn;1i'tic:d 'theon' ~i!ke his ethics ~upfiel'aUv- oWfes a nP~:t· ,deal

:____.'-~- _I .~.~. ,F~·.:",· .. - ! . ...:...-_.-, .~-:I _-:':"_~',$"'" _ . ._; c.l ,.r .. - .• m---' . ':'-', ~ _- 'l"~' .- I. ~~ .. ", .-. -,

to .Out$N~" :I't .W [;I lSooJ!d. ~o~.tq:et dleo:rr~ m. 'wh~,QJh :poople; Uilli't:e: ,~ ........... ~.JlinlOi· *'u '" r-_'~r:_1 Win T hav:@ ~·xn'l ilmoo aoov@· h'o-w' nm~n:v'

p-~~-'wdl~Y_[ -~~l ~-v [P-o ~~~~~ -e- e- :_,~,~, :_. ,~~~~. w"~' ·~-.~,tf~_.I___:___'w'w-w.1 'w;-=''':_; .. ~' w' < .... d. r" .>,~.~.I,I."T

i .·i~'b,:,"_!i!', ~~i!i!'~; ,~ .. iI!fi"Ii' ,J:)L",": 'ri~"I:'iii~:=""-'·1 'I!i''''''Sf;~~;~>1II.iiD' ""f. Pr,"!iet~~al R~aSilI'!L ThGS@.

n.--.&~~ iIIi_~.I_o.'!ir. 1~~I;UIII_1.::1 U:_I~ JrIH_II.~~~ Cwo 1~'~~I~ ~ .... ~ ~P-<~ ~-~~ ~ .. ~~-~ _ ~-~. ~ ~ _

~ ~l..'''i!O ili!V~,II!j* ~'H ~ ·eit,o'I;ifo\iDJ , .... ' 'II:'!II,"!!;H'I,_. 'b'Ii'L't· 'rI.~U' ::1!m ;i',jinmlV'lsioD.al! ,~~' ~iinQe 3

n.5I~IJ~~1 [~M~~~ lli.I:_"l !m!, 1~I~J~ Vill L,_~,~~,~n~J!l!i-lf. _,~-~,_, ~ ~,T ~~.~ ~~.__: ... , __ -~.,_:_,-~~'~'~ .~-~:.. ~.~ .. e- w.1

~ p" - ;O;·!L.· ~ • ..:I. t; ..l~ 'L.!

~'i-: c t :'lSi ,~ :-U!~I,~z;aIt.'i,()~. t-O QS~ ,~rmOD [3Div:one ma.'U'· lueiimui mS

0.:,,1. ,l., ai_.,,,,, - to,,~ "~" -~ -~"-----C, ~~~r~ ~~ ~~., '" ~~~ ~~ .. ~.~~-

rilh:t. ,aljl.inst ano:mu;, DiIP,t1;~~ 'wi'O. .me.viltlbly· .Iri"e~ and tbe:re~ .ii;~ :~, 'wa:y to '~;t~l~ ~~ [e"~'t 'by' ·woJenee:. lao t'bis, ·w-s,y· w,e, :,iies:enJt .:11,

,""L _,"!!;;t, t; ..... ] iiI'II"~ .. ,"!'"..-. ... 'L,,g:r ',i'" ... ,L,g !f! .... ,iio.;g. ..... If '"'i"""lio"~""",, ~~". t·~""".:i.Ti;'fi\iiijCJ 'ii;;;''''' ·~A. iii["',"! lu_IL'J'!iI!:"':," l~ ~_~~ '~~Y.~,II§_ ,~ ig'I,,§ ~!~~-~ ~ .~)~)w:~-., I. ,~ru~ Jl1~J~ l ... _a. l~:u l ..... 1:Rr

.... ~iii~ft, ::IiJIt'~iASiili' Aft'@~ft"F"'IihM to [@:St.1Jb:!li·s·h :i 1·mid~eWl state of; afwrs -.=

~~I.J!w;"'¥I::_~ ~~~~~, l~~,-=. ~,~.~ ~_~ w _.' .~._-~~._._: _~~~~~. '_, L!.lw -1.1 w - l.w .. -', w .. _~' .. ' l .. _ ..• -', ... I;.~

.a:. l~aJte~ :in. 'which nih'S, ale gug'l~t~d.l'.a'm~'r mIlD. pro.,v:iSil)1lJ:tt .so, we

.jL:-'!':p, .... "" ' ..... "ni'lI..t, · .... ,..;MI ,., .... ,fI .. ~_,]I ... ·~u' 'tv , .. ~ """"_"-Ij-,,-,,';" o('Iiio'h-J;!io,pji:i; ;in. [",!lIjoio..:il;i' ';·l'[Oit.'ifro 'ntjo'I:~'iii~,;, ,t_:liit,L!!~ IP-, ,~~~~~ ~~,~~ ~..JlI;I..~_II!r.I-"l~ ~ ~)~.·~I" ~v ~~,l!li#~ ~,~-:- - ~1a!1 II.,U ~")l~'" ~.~."~.!U!I .~.IId_J_~!ljd"

,~'I ~~~t.u wi'. us [~.Mp:l' ~c:,~=~]j:'~'i",

_."= ~L~ -'. .. ~ __ ~ ww~ ~w ~ I." ~,;}.l,;}. .;JI - 3,~·

TIi. 'Il!iiifli'l'!lt -of. '~1ti.,tcina1 rsooi~tv' is '~~ 'n~teet r~~':~,ts and freedom The

~L'~~I I?--~-~~~ .~J. ,F-~'~'~·--:-~~·~·~' ~ .. :_..~.__!c~J~l,T ~ __ l .~.~. ,If~'~'w'w"w'w ", ;~~' .. ~"w . I ': ' ...• - '.' I r -_ •.. ,' .

. id~l :Sit!1lltce: = m:d~", '.~ [~~'[I)ne and o:~y legitj·m.a'~e cO:lIs't~.m)tiom."~' rIMP,' ·~AiJ()=;iII.:1~. 'pp ~,4' ;t1!""'iI1;'~" ,"",",. is· ,a :Z!e~u'b:I~c ~MP~' ~.AIO~\" :Bu,t ,as ·t·!il~:f:i)~

'1- -~,. 3~ ~ T-~ l!- ~ - ~ 'wl'i'-: J: ~~ -. ,r' - ~ - ,I ~~ ~ - - - - .. ~~

. d - . .". 'It! ~ ·tII" ~ ~ - _.;, - .... " ~ ~ - - ~ - - ~ ~ -~ - ~ ~_.- -. ~ - - ~ ~ - ~ - ~ .. eh - ~ . - ~ _ ... ~ .. C']

.:-~.: ',',- '.··'.··l· ,'1·~lll-:[ .,\ 111,_', I' "'[-I-"['}' -'1"" --it"l-:,~,_[,l·"I"'J-,'-' ,- ,'-'(l~-l"" ~:II' .

·s'tanc_ W~ muS!~, la,~"~" ~~,~ e~~m,~"G~rmnenJt. t-o fep((es>ent .. '.' e genera,

·wiD. gf dle peop]t;, .~~. [~n~uemd:" :mi'ii.!Is-t ~bey l!Jt;. Odd!i,y~ wfe :m'~s,t dQ 'this, [e·v~. if' me ~t;jm,8; gOrVe-mment 1;S the result (If: ,3: reOOD:~ :mv1Iltlutbm .. The ~ljlV~niJm~~.t :i.tcseU hiS [1Ji d,u't.y to :p:.rom.~t~ its, (fWD ,p~d!~~\al ~v~~JUtlQn t~, a lrle-,uibJirum .. I:Onn. Arld, there should 'rbe I~XH:M,'r,ri.]et~; ketdo:m of :s~~~'r:',l.l~. SQ· mIt: th,e ci'li~n:S1 'CUll, (lli~n'Ss these :miit,-

rtf"' I". 1_ •••• _J". __ I." 1 ",,~_1J1P. .... _~.~ ... =-=r" •• -~_~."-~-~ ~._~ w.~-_ ~~-~~ w~~~~~ _-~-~_

'~~~!_ 'ri'i;~"Jli'!I; ~""~lt"lii!l""H -"·S. '~'""I a '11.,~,~~'ti'rI"",';';g;; nOil!!)~+;iIOI'!i '~n {'Ori"'~ ,;i;'I!rt=li. 'trms~tliii'rn.

~-~-I&~. D~l~ I~Lv. ~I}. _1_iIiI''!ir_II_.l 1. ,1_"_11 B 1~}!I';~l~_'~~.a@1Ir,!1!r ~~ ~~~= l~~ ~~~!!r.I~ Y!r __ ~~~~= ~~

~ ~

[~'M- i'Q;f ~ 'II'O_,~~I .• ,~, r lii"'O_'''''i!I;. :Ti ;~' ~'O"'-"''''~'~~\_ ~ l·.·l r·.~ ,;;II oil [JI ~,rll'" ';'ll_!' v e liA!,. I, II'" 1~71 ~'bI~ ~-=

The ,aI~m9!t ,t'bat :s'bD'~ 'dita.t indhidUld!! m!:!tlJild. ,~t'er m'~~ juDd:i.~

~._'.I '_IC' ""ilfc.o,BH'iI!i ,,. .... ~ • .I!-"'ri, •. [~,iIII! .~t'!I'...,":'.iII.,.iiI!i"" :~11 .. ..,. :-IL, .... ,.u .... ·""'IL.-,., D;'IiIi'.~'''''' , .. I'L.."....ii'~'~ :.:Il~ [~, ,~~ __ :~~~~l~, n·J),-,._1 !b!IM,'!r ~_. I,'Y!~W aJ.~·!IJII ~,.yr.·rr'~ '"~~ '~'_~!I!--:-~~~ ~:~I~'l~~1 U~'!I

Copy rig hted m ateri al

':F,~: "l'P' 310.7 ...... :1:],);, :fmJQ~lt ,among: these 'wiU. be larw:s, far' the oonduct: of: 'WUJ, .f~Gt 'wars, mould be 'Ol1nduct,ed atto~'ilng t-e laws, that: 'win, .. "k~ "'"o'f~' ~ '~v~· ·,tual'~'lf~ ~~ ··~~~·~t mE .-~-~-- 1m dl- M>tlrllr~£I male paSSl" ~e I, c "e e~"en _1'_ ,Ie "1evemen,: ','.,. peace. ~' 1I~~e ,~,."'!fL__:_'P:'_,--:,:__ ~:"

CIiJ' h:m'DipJes ollu'st:ice ~MPll 343, ..... '::1) and, ill ,~;tulal ,Peac'e· [IP" 343~6o:1 :K.t a'tt;em:~ns tlO ,s.pe'~l {Ul't, :in detail. 'w.\ha,'~ 't'i),ese ls,ws mould, 001, and ,expresses ii, .~pe 't'h;a,t :ru"~,elm vriU aUJend '~O 'wbat he Mys! Irpp 3'8,.....6':1,,~8

'uee is, ~~pottm~t; :m,Qt oni~", beea~se ~.t :is ~ihe~ ,e:~d ,@l vl(:l.len,ce Qfid,

iDjustjce~, P'DeI wUl brmg 'wit'b it, 't'he ,tnltire I,QJmevem,en't of'the KirngdODl of !Dds, on e-m", ]It; lC!es, hand, m. h.d 'wim the ,S(3)t~ Imf

~ljit'''Ii'Ilr'D 'IrD' 'ti£J"L'II","'IL iiIU.1''QIi!rU' ,~,'!I;to-.i,I"ii~ '~;13: ,'!II '_n-'1f~'Ii.'II':l" r" 'W' ,: 'L'iI'!ill!ill ,A'L~ '~n't;il;, 'fti ...... r .. 'Il., ... , iUjl.A_~_·:~ ll_1 ~ I '~JI_'_:I~_g !!iI!!~t~~,I: liJ~@l~l_V~'~~' ~~F.~lUn[~!!! 'L_"~:~~ lJD_~ ,F.-~¥,~~~l ~~_y~, flIlJ_1 ; ~

'II!'Ii~ 11"~: ,.:Il"i"i.i~" 'u~;h' ,.~..JIL;a;!II' 'iI!'i"i; 'i:N'i, '1Ii',i"i; ~"'Ii'''' 'w" ""Ii'.' ~:'Ill iii'!i"Ii~~ .\0 "i~ ,~~i.:ll ,l';r"riil" ''''iL;I!i' ~'U_'-~.l!Qj. U~~IU.-,... ,"or =-.~~_,,_~ ~v ~~ ~_~ ."[~ ~,_,~, ·~.UL~ ~_,.,,~lJu~ b-'V [~ ~~~ ~~ ~t~

peo,ple; wUI :001 ,go to, 'W:QJ[ ~m' ttl:\l,Y'iQ], l'eaO:ll!S [P' ss I: ~l" 'men, 'dl,c:re :iLs, less waf~, ;sMial blsdmu01llS, 'will bUPIll'OV''e;p :m.1 a~s, WIlliS ~ncC'W' stm~ 'dl,cJ' are mosd.y· dujlDH, 101' the slk~ of 'W'H" :Puboc ,&mds, w,Ul 'be

~,Lli"lil""'ii'liili:'~'lliilid'~1 :"~'Fi':O ... ~lll~",,'!i;iCl-·""~ ·~iJ"''L~.,., t"~"iifi"ll 'wl~ip,;Ml~b· ,.jiIIl~ ii'oi:~,;M1 ...,,'I:",1"~)n'I:""" W. '.~1'~ 'LI<~ c" 1ti.i-I-_~_iIIiI_l:iI_L_.~I_IAIi!- .. l~_;ll!IP.-U ~U~J'-'QI!IP_ VIi.I] ,1I1"IU~I_~1I1 . _Ial_"_~_:_"l ~ ~ ~ u~ ... ~!p !lWHlrU. !\o!!~'liil~,~ jl j til_I] lue

'=IiFiii"n~r'q',,"",J 1f:1jiJ f~' ,~~,~ i!i; !D,," .c··.,n~il1!' '~' "'"",'''' L 'IB'·ii'i'~I~1:"'w.· :- ..... (,j;"iIiji;~":Ii'i·t. _ ,-,~"t.. .. ; ;i!'iiii!'1>i;liid' l~t>~iM~

lll_II::II_II.r!dlllV·!I!'!CU ~llllu[nl l"-!iU,. l~g~ '. _Dn_nl ~l~LoI!l!!' '_~::"_~_IiJ.-""'-1I_W_"_II~-!II~J." ~['~, !!ii!-W,IJJlr._lIIl _lIrV~~l

'~iii"i, ·w'·:,'~" ... 'L. 'p .• eop .... ' :-- ... 1 iii! *'~'~'ilffiil\., ;l'~iI:' ,1It·~"~;i!i.,'I'V\i1t,;i!i: (,W~ .3-:' S", I~l ,- ~i1ilr~ ·iJ."':i ~~".iU(:"".;I '~Y":'

lit .. :: .... ,"lll_I_1-IIiiI_ll1 . - .. W- ... 1i-_IHI:l_ltll_A lUi .. ~_:IBI""1I::ILII_~=.I1 _ !!iiP.-~ ~ ~ l~ I I '~·lll_.lall LUG tltvgf~~~.gu IU! ..

[ 1 • ~ ,_I • ~" ~.

k-eedo:m. Imf s:pe.eccll, and, dli~Uission. And,r' :lnaUy~ :m.oI;a]ily l'tH·If. 'wiU

be~ ,B.cl1iC1!'ed.~, as 'IDe ·~:d.tilmaile; :ptoouct ,m: cu'l,rllli[f; and le:nllp,t-enrme:nlt. :Po.l' ,a, tll"pW ,oo:m5,tl.tu,d;om. is, :fi.O't t~, be e:-Xpeot;ed :!bfitH, m(tr.alb:.y~, bw,t~ ~ -~~- -- -'1= - ~ood -c- ~ -'1 - ~-d;'L ~ "f - - -~'I]~ "' ... ~.~ lr~~--tcd -nJJ-~ ~nl!'C"li5:e ,'~ iii, 1,' .. 1.· .. mara: colli Tbon '0: ': a poop,c ss 'tD • e e.xpe:G: --,O··-.'yr

Uillld,e:r !Ii, I~' loons,ti:l-Ulifitl,'~-; (fP' :)16~, ... oa~ SJ\!~,~l,

A!t~ ,the ,ei'l,d, of the ,M~tap\l.!,r&i!CQ,1:' ,Pnttcif11tl8, of 1:'ti~ti!Ce ,th,ef.-e~ :~8, a, IIlI,g~sti:rrmi, tAiU; 'we· 'mal" l.ia,Vlf:) ,an, ~ftiis:to,dcal ,fm,th :i~D, tile plssfbi:Ul,y' lof

:' .. ':''c' ". '-, '.'' '''C~''_'' ',' j.', '" ~, 'j ,', ",~,~,,,,'I' _- 'I' I ' , ' ',"': 'j~'-'" :.- ';1 j" ~1:\ ",'1" , " • ,;t,' i"i"~' 'IN', ,.it.. ... j~.', .... ;~

peace" on Y'Je, S3l1llle.· .mJ~ .. as pracil1c~ R...:.I!I1O'IlS I~U_'J' .. J) ~iIl_!le.o,rejUClll'~

'Il" .... ,'II·dl .. .," .. 'Ii...~ .. ··tt;"', ... ..:II .. ., 'wh' , ... L, " "',-',- " "', ,'. , , ',-' ,,"'11..'1, ."," "F '~" , .11[fW,lIel:e e.an~ we: a ,,,,,aUleu as ,,'0 .. ,. 'eUler. peiClC 15, "oSSlli1J!C or no!.\" ,~n

Iuch [3, ,case 'WI:; --allY mM~de_r 'w'hed'.u~-I we have an l'lliiite-l'8'lt ~lill !ii,ccept,., brrtg 'me ,oarrect)uR- t'hart .i~t :is,. :[i;' me m~e.craf is basal. on, mar:a]I;t:1' - :if

tl..'iiIi ;i'O;i"W:'!ii!iiilOi"'rln·_ '~'ifil AM·.iIi; ... 'L',~i' ~U' il!dlj;, 'II.,,,, t-i'li'oi;a; ,~c. '_O:"i 'i'-"Ii 1-' ~,ii'Ii'.:I"" li!ii~~ !in 1.. ...

_1J_lr'!i.!: 1~-U.._I~~-~:"fY_I~~ 1~ll_lQ UL_.~ ·ULI_Gj. "_I_I}.: :g~, ~~ . :~I;!W-""~ ,iii ll_~~-U-.a~iIiII_- 1t...y_~ l._"~ [Wi ~~

!~u:'!hievled ~ ,tho, we~ :may a'coe"t :i.t. ijE',ve~fi :U tl~e 11edli~,tl,Om, of 't'MS, iI:N\;J;1 1M :aboUml'nI'!' W,lf 'W',e:ft~ idwa~ji.fS, 'ltD '-;-em:a'n "U,!st: a '--; ,~:oos' 7'. ~~ m ~ .. ~,-~ ,Itt......" . ."-e' .., ... "1 . r L. J ' ,~I~ W,~_, T we

sUI 'wo-uJd, nm be df(!(d'WLng owselvl'ls, 'by' aCfop,ti'(l!g the :rna'll'lll ,of wm'ki:tliiO: fDt" iit w.'iiti m1re;lend"lD! ~rHV,:er2u:c:tj' I~'M~' ~ ,e .. ·'I~_ lHlcOO '~"~-::i

- - __ =.I_~~ __ ~ ~ ~ _~ .''--=_'·~_·_~~I r-~-!"!l···_ - ... ~.~._.- ~lj ~~~·l.1 .J'-,f.l;- . __ r. __ .... _J we

ba _,I" . .I' hi d A,L "'''' ~.~ . .:Ii 'L._:I ". •

,;__;~·ve a UIU'ty '~o ~O' '~_' I~~ aD:..., ems ,I1V'C!j nse ,~,o a D~, to UCldeV,t ~~.t

,pG55ible-., The !S.EmctJUH: of 'lm.e .pmeD1! is, exited" '~'h_alt O'j 'the ,aqu'" m~n'~: WI belief' in. GOO, and immO'mlit~:, Kan't a.lli :~tual :~ the ~~hilbes\t ,potirlticail. ,pod,;u

~':IS~ '''i!Ii.,;:''J1.., ;,~ 'o:-'Ii..""", '1'!ii9i;t!;iC'!l·'ll:-ii,I'~itv ~f: 'nP~;r;~ is b' .rlli~iI!'_l!;iI!i;il!o..:l1 '.:n , .. ',1,..,"", 'L~'i!!'rI1' .... Fi ,;0;,,,'.1 ',~ __ I :lr~!I!;g .~~. !U~~ Jt~~~-~~~g;~7-' ~_ ,r-~' _~~Jl__:.~I,"~_~'~:~~~:!I!P.IgJ. ~ I~'~ J1l1!'~~-WitJ.j~1

Copy rig hted m ateri al

3- 14'1 U';I; !iii.lTT' iifi '~jj';if'!II'IR' ~ ij' '!mI"B'ii""ij' ;if'!i;,iE'[O-"'P--;'iUV

,l'II..a,.ll"!l " ,<:I!I L~'" '!I....!", ,~,Ji,; ,~EIII,,:L Ji,;,'!LI' c.:iI' ",I ',i£!I. ,J.

e'

wri,'liimil:'~" blU!"~, t~h~QJ~,c:a'~ irn~ei~Rtadml-o;f b~'!~~lWlt r'n 'Wh~f'\h '~'-tW,~-ei

"~~~~~O'""l! --" ,~ ~-,~- --~""~,, ~ ~-,,,,,c .. ",t?'" , ,,,,,,,,-,_. --" ,_1-- .""'Ii,I ,1_- " _1,,,,_ "al,_["

is [~,v,I;ilI'ian"!'iA, as w'Ark"~ill'liJI" "~,"'f-~lc ,~;'~, 'm' ·.i~lw:,,";~ .... i"!WIid~\i~,~1 [iI"!I-"~ 'iii"jk~1 '~-~~:l-n .. ~ ~~~, ~~ ~ ~ .... ~ ~!io1' .... '!;,!'~, ,~'I'-"'"'b I!o!."""~,, ""'_.;u'" "'JIi_I~ , __ .'!<l!\IiB_W, '!;;I .... ,IcI', !Ih ..... """.u ........ ; ",ililJ"", ,u:u_mall,

,!I':-1i iii"A , iiII!,¥<lliitl' 'lilliS,;i'itI'.g·'. '~\'1i~ ""l1k.:l1 ,~'L~ :Silli;'~tZIi~!LiIil"iifi~~, 'fi~' '1t~'Ii~-'i'i: '~I-""'ii;-:~' ,-n-I 1..,-:~ ~"'''''''-''''''l!' "'". """1'_', '!Oil! , ,,10111 __c. n' "'_II, g.,uYi ",illCi .... ll11_"",,lhll!!;,;iiJ!!iJ! """iii; ,I!I"Y_I!~ .. au ,UiQiI!I,U_1e as nei['

tooll, :E,ve.f'/' r-eginn, of the ,g\lc':be su,p,p:rnie8 :m3i~erials1 dli1.liil; humans ,cam, !Uei 'to, a!daJi\\t WI '~iie; 't'h~1',e, ,and 'w.al' '~as, dle wficdon of' I(UlSI1.iDn~' tbai!'

,--", •• ," ,-",_. 'l~' ...... l __ .... _.r •• ,. -- •••• - ,-- -" ._.r •• -_ ••. f ••• _, _--'_ ~·LO _.'~_l_J

'!lU!marll beim~l e,~,enruDv do Sfilesd!, ,eve"fifWl1em~, 'TIl is, 'brin~s ,a'ooll!t,

l_I. -.:_1 "---L~'" __ I •• -- -'$' .... 'ri ... r. • ·· ... ,1·tI'tr. _I,_,,11 "_~. _,\-. 'LC.J-' ~_-_._.",:,_._

'~'be [c~lti'~a,don and de¥elo.p.:memlt~ of: hWIIDI$D, pow{ers, and, 'l'l1mlts. ,As, '~be ,popula,ti,oM of: the ,ari~s, :re._ons mcms~1 these !f0UpSI ,are ::I'V!il~n'C-, 'inevitablv' 'bliO'i'llro':l-;.,[ 'back in'tiD con'tae'[ wi'tll 'OJ!lJ;e,. DO't1hu' Di-ff'eir~

I~_-_ •• ,.[I_I,." ... 1 - '1'1- ~.I, ... '~~J, .. -. [~~_. I, .... :... .... __ ._I,~-~ _:'i~ •••. _.,I,.~-_II,:__·~_~.[~~·~_~~:..:..~·~....:.-·[!l._·.·_:_,.____:_...=._~

Itnces, ~f' :lieli1gion and :~angu.iI,e ,k~ep th~m ,1£, w,.' foJ' a, '~-i'ml~\! but;

'fi-'iiijjli~i!i~'iI'l!igii!; ,j ..... , g~~u!loi,.'~~liIl!iL, ~1I1t"lg cto ...... m ,I"" ''-.~m-'' ,j;LJI!' n',,:,,~~1 ,f ..... , .. ""~~m' ';II!;ipJi'!l.ii'!i' 'E';!I:I't'j:lit:'ill", Jf~~I;;I!I~,'~ ,,-~ [~II!o~lUU~_g ~-~~~ ~ __ . ~ ,~v~~, ILg;~ ~~, ~V~ ~~""~IJI~I - ~~~~,~ -_ 'Pf~ILlil

'tiuaUy t"biilS fo:tt:esl them '~m es,t;a,b.Ush jUddieal P.e:~iitio:nS!, 'w~i-~b OB,e ,_,~ ot'het, Wild wiD Itead '~O 'I!'IiP<Q,ee and l'U'Sti,oo ;a]jl 100Vier the 'world nl Th~'S

•. __ t. _ l,~ _ _ • 1 '" ., ,_.,. _ ,If-~[' ~ _.. _ _ ~. _ . _. _. . ~ i. _ .~ _. ~ • ~ .... _ -_' ~ ~ -_- _' •. _ _ - __ - __ II!! _' ~._._

:lnrtel1Ofe.m'tiOfi ,(}f 1Ds-~o:ry is o S'e«:di' :Il,ot lSI some-tbt~Q!: !m(1iW,a'b]ei lad

.or I.~' ~~~.

not. ISiS a r.eaoon, for ,moNI q,uie$cen.oe~ bw"t lSI ,8 w,ay tbme :moJ',aM,

.;:o;~,"",imj'''., ... ~ '~o~. 'pea-,~;-,·-.t'!,ii' ~ e-:iii"'ij!i'~'Coj~~1i1" n.- itit'iii'ilji .... ""',1'reo ~~P':~ .. ;!I;,j:~I.rili1l:Jl1 'w:,·II'Ii.;LI ~iL'~'ir:"·

'!I.iu_ .... LII_ j1i.J!IIrl1;Ul U-. _... i'W'W . . _~~,·IP.',~II~~~, __ Ui!lli.----'11.11.01.~ fai 'Ii.i-~ ~~"IU.v· •• HI, .... ,~)U1J, Iln~1II

,,- ~ - ~ - - - ~ - ~., - - ~- ~ ~ - ~ - .. - ~ -- ~~- - -~

,",'iii:... .'~ ~ Ii

el~,ij\Its, !lrP' 3,6:8 r·

ThiiSi 'nicit UfU' of' h'ls'1:)rwv a'II2' Iud m !CI!' l'Ol il'liN~' 'iii!! ;!:]t[i.'~I'l'm""l:l'U, dil!Oti'li~l·'l:"IIt,S=

'~': __ } ....:.... ,~L ....:.l...!l....:._~·....:.· . __ ~ ,_ .. __ I_~~,. [_~~ -:__"-" ~~ll~ _' lr . ....:.-_J..=_ • ....:.J ~,~l I@d15_,,_·_' 11ft). ,_~.__!_~~~~:_~_y.~'-

't~,e. In it the :moJ','d, 'd.~$posi'!!ion is :seen, as ,miu'l.t~.ng .f.1'O'm ~-ht Rlpub1.i~m ~o:m£i't)u,'ti,Qn'S ,lIld, C'Qndi'tion'~ ,of enJighltenm,en't t~hat :nalt;u:___re :p:r:OOU!tel, Nit;wr-e :ii seen aSI 'workim:l: '~roulh, {tme mecIL.anism, of h!mman :pas.'" Mfimst,r [~'iP" 'i1,68}' thiroUJb [mmmetilion tbe lfIr¥e M '~nTil'inr and 'war·, as

• • 1.1 __ ,' ~"" ~J .:.:'.'.:. !,!I!l • _1. ... .:..- '-_', __ , .~ •. .:._ -~I_I,~'" __ I_. _ • .:._,,~ 1_._._'._ ... :.."".~ ~,_~, '~'~~~,#,~l ~_ ~.~ __ I . _. ~-~l~1 ' __ '

US~fiIP' met'boos mat' 'wtru]d 'wn;r'k OIl {!i'a IBlc;C: [m: lev-nSf! ~p:p' ~6;C'i 'h, is,

"- · ... ·~I . - f. ,. __ r_ _ . __ -_ I_I •• ~' _ - , ••• ,,' • - - • 1 1_ -. _,._ .~- -.~, _-_-_ ~_, ,_ J' _·"'1., ,_,_ ~-_

,from. a, p.rac~tl,C'a1 standJi'Omlt 'that 'we lee: our,se'~,,,es, is ,fRe~ 'CD 'tL]n~: tn:eD'" ,Dzm,g; :mln~ lev-erytmng ,i;S exp]i¢aJble In t~'S of 'ClllSeS", While th~ ,re~1i.cll :r-eiso:n e~,p:taini", pra.c,tical, rumn is, 'wholly' :nOIma,tl,v\'e~: ,aclt-ua~, lexamp~es, of' moral c:on(Jluct uooot be idmtifioo, w.i't'b ar~i'iD!t.yj :eO! ,are 'they' necessary' t-O iStJ,pport the moul, :~a,wi!'~, [ciIJ~ 'on 'us {IG· 407 iI,

And ~,:et: KafU: believ':es, ,that hii~OJlt hitliS' 'nTnvi~,ded 'us w~th one 'ft~:\ec:e,

e., . _ ... ~'.. - ,- ., , ., - " . ,. , .. - '" _. -, , " ',. ,- ",1;"""" I" , .... - .1.. .. , ,. iIf'~'·, ..

M m~c~ t"ha· it ... 'L,~ 'Ii'nf'!ir~'II~~'cN'1ii.:lc~,t· -ej.;i"1iit'!i1 1- S ''''I11!"'-'Ii'~ ,iiiH, ;..'~, .. h "II~'m'" i"Iiil:'ill '~'5i;i!li. ''iillri'~ [.~_:_. L-=,.~._}_-=--~~_~ . .:..:, .~~)_~ I~,... ~v_ .. ill, W!~,~~¥it_,l. ~,_~,,~, ."~"' l~~_:_~l ll:I~1l 'UjL~ .; ~~_l _ ' __ ~11Il lllg-~-~;. "_~_;J:~l

:may 'yet ,p:rev:aL 'This, pioo~ oJ '~'i,dmce :lS, the 'e'fiiitbusilS'M 1M me

-'-,·-c-,·'·,-(·,,·- c.if .. ,'L.-,'II]' . ,,'!L-H·"·'·'I·"I' "T"L,.'E' ",.jLD ·-1,""·'''' .,,', .. , .,,",

:sre&ta.to:n, OJ( we ,!rTmc~, ~eV<lI~~ltI!~" ,!I;, Ole I7JRliU.~~ ~evo,--U!tlml! alms at

:- ,--;'---::-'il~I'~'II,' ...... 'n , ..... - ;1-,j''':i"o''I,j', ,,' 'I lj'," , .. 'II.., ' "",'.,,,',' " ".', , " :'.- 'Iii. """ 'iIi''':'',,,,,, "~ If<)! 'iii' iL .. " '~',," "..:1':'_

a fepr!Wi~J.l!~~, "",Dn=hl"~,!I;iIi)~lom·" ,~, J' u~e!(CiJlO-lle :alm51,,,, ~us",u:!e~, ally. !!!one ,conw,~

'tl;fifi 'wheRby Wlit (tile $O.ulJlCie of' all levU and, co:~ptio:n, o:~' MtJrtis}:m d,etlened,'~i' [~OQ ,B6j; The [mlthl!iisiasm, of' ,t'h,e ,s~~ta'bGr.S :Rlus't: ibe ex:-' plained: ~Y' the [exJ;!u;enoe of; 1ft mor:il,dis,po$i)t1GD--J fot t~pDume [mlt1u!~si-'"

;!IoiCili!!l!iio _,;,~~\aVIi!; !I'I!iiln"".1ii1 .......... ,l,u '"A'uiJ!l~-~''' 'U1J!'iI!..'o':Ii:io' iii;!:], '~i·.::Il~~'II,o':Ii!l'li:..1 l·'I:':Io·.::Il~~,A +n 'ti!J!'!Ii..'-1it·· (tilll ~ .'"'~,:;..;~ ~~p~ ~ [~_IU:~J ~~_~.".~ '"'.~~".~ ,~~_~, ~_: ~l" ~'~U-eeQif. 1r.-1I.!I: ·":I~_I:_g_;.: Ill"-

nm,el~' :moral SUi""\I, ."ill!: ith; :'~ iii"~t1.c"';i""~, ;;rIif: :rll""":~t:- "j~d, 'ii~; [;'!OH"Hr~ ..... I\" '~:", 'lH:'\i'Ii:iif--~~

r _- J' - __ -~ ~ _~ ~__j ~ .. ~~ '!P.I!IiP.P= _ !I!P.I,~!\\! v~ l~~___jI." ~~J_ !II' ~::_'_I_~_JV.~ ~ o.IIiIg;_tli~l

on"';'" ;!I .. C·I~,~,"jii"'i,i;.iliii'\ilii!i*jj f,~ 10£)' co~, ,'t!"'"",~t;i' .... ?'"'.c-'~~r-,.j .... ;i!;"

_~~v _~_I; IiU,fIl!f!o;;,_'I,'!;p-!;!!II; ~I~ GP,.;' t!ai[J ;I'WIII)!Io. ",",f!olI\lo~,C_I,UUl:1!iJ!I;

Copy rig hted m ateri al

~·tb .. ~:. '1.1" eal ·.l 'Inn. ,·,,-:·:1-'.11" tl-~ """'1.1' ~ '~.Ql].1Imo'li'~.·;c t-;.1..I, ''f'i/U' !"'"'.1l.. -~. '~' .CI... ."'-' 1- ,:f.!":~ .... I .. JL!\.?aJr IIJ~ ' .... ~.-t - -!I.IILo. . l_ltu. - 15l_J.1~

3S

n~ re:V~l.lI!tl;Q:Q iQf' j .!h:ed :,eQ_p.ID.~ wbiGb, 'we ,~~e :s~:e4i, ·~£gJ.diQig: :m g1llif MY may sueeeed 01" mlsc:aNY'~ :i~, :ma,'~' 'b@; :O.~h~d, wliJth M'~ry' ,md ,~Jtf~~tE~~ itil' the

'iiiV11!ni;t. ~'Il.,""'iii ,"ii, ;;:,pnliijil..J- m-- 'If"i"'" 'Mf""·_' 'I:;..,. 1J!.:.",.;~I.-!l~IV' t- ... L ... tu> ~"" ""·'V ...... -~,.IIi\·e· '"I'.' .;a' .. ;u ...... _-.L~~1~'\I!' ,~~-~-J\3 l~ta!~ ~ ~~~'dIJ!=-~ ~ ~_I.~r. ... ~J ~~~ L~_l~, L~"~-W_lV.,.· . .cvl ~~-vr-~ l~cV ~cA,~_'!iI?-!Wi~- . [l!lr. "~-u~-,..-,..!iJI!HUJI~ J~:

idltc ~nd, t·im~~, W'O]jJ~~ :n~~f :~QbYe: ~o :ma;k~ tl~ ~~riln~i:I ,a~ :~iJ(l~h ~~ - It'i:':i!5 rie:V!J]!udon~, I ~~, nom;cth~l,c:s:s Inds i.D. 'thll: :t.urts 01:' all tb~ !$!~clt~itiOI',I' Iw'liiJ- .- --~. 'Ii ....... ·~""'IiI,.;,~1 'i'O .'11'-1" ~ .~ .-, .. ' .,'ii-. - ..... ~1", .'"! ., 'wi ,1.,:[. t ',' , ~""-'"I '- .,"" .. " '.'h~ ... ~. ~, __ ,_~ !il!_1e ='!;.!I'~, 'e:L~1""" ""= 1!'~_!I!I!S ,gam,e~ 1",_U€'msel,·_, e8~' ,:I1i, __ ·~~S.1l11i1Ul!. p.af'l~.clpd~ ..... :8,11:

'~-=f~~i"li:i r~;ftUi""ruv' rnn _~'''''i'ilIi:iJ; ;oj;Ii:j;'m-:-' ;j;'I..;g; 'VP'il"V .;;iirn_",Iij"IIfL-'I'iIi ;tj;!; 'iu'L~"'i'L ;;;ojJ l"'n'li ... '1..,., '1"""I;jo'L ~ _ __!I!I~_~J~ [I!i!-~-~-J,l' ~~ ~ .. _~L!I-_I_L!lo!I!~"'IR!~ _ _:-.~' !\i._[I~, '~''Iir.~,.' L!lr.r_"r-ill~[JI!~ t'U~I_lI val' ~·ll]_il .. ,..~_W. ~_liJIllnIUIIIJ~::II" "p-Jl J~_Ul

d:a~rj it'~~S S"nlparmy; t'h~~~lU!)t; can, lurve nn, m'h~~' ~U~e than iii! mQ:f;a~, 'mred~8'l"Iin'ltitijJliiJ in the h~m2in 'rat1e'-, ~~ 8 ~ I~

,r .. ----.~-}-. - l __ •. __ .l_}. ---- __ lll ••.•.. -!11 ~~-~ .J.!~

IC3in,t kiD, :fuis ~,i,ti~l W:,@I':~, a5; ~h~ t~ An",~st:r.,~y~~,'Oj '~~ppUnl ,t'be ,ewfl~ of: ,the ILei'bn~·'W~:tffi~, pbi1osO:p'hy~ ralq 'wi'~h ~,ts ,optUmism ma:t God :liars ch:~, ,everytni'm,g; :fQ'1 .:he be~~~ h'~, ~b~ ~~. m: ,AU, :P~~I,'~

'i.,;I] lii:li: 'il.,jl 'if,,",,, - ~ .'il 'L - i:" .. ,L.." h" f".l. ~,'L.

lilJ,e;'"o:tl~5", ,lUi ~t$ 'J*ce ne Pll'~ ~, ,tr.aJ:u~ m, ~~Unl~, ~~~g,~.ml' ,~S, 'm~,

S- fiiii>.r-~~~' .".If' ,"'Iiili"o:l!,lv "a~ 'iii."';fI; ........ ·:ill m- ~ifiL' .. ri;~l" .'.:1" .;00''''..]' , .. ,'t;.I~ ,ir'!."""m· Do .. ,.,..""",... .. ""!, , .... ii:: ;00 ,-",,!,,\;o;nh~""~· IU!IIII ,~, u_1 Jr'I.I'.IJ,IIIr-- 'J: .... '!I!-~v.nw, " - ~..JJf~lI .. l"l~ d.o.Io .. U U~IL~ ~ '. ~1J.~I~-'~"hl,~ ~~ I~ ~~~'~;~IJf~~~~' ~r

ii~ of: :prt(}ti,c$il ,rea~n" ''Dds, fr~:e'om i;$1 .not~ em, o'ib,j~~lt~ ,0'11~l1ow'1.J'

'i!...'"it~· fi~ ,0 ''''''''t-,iii-nn",,'i] ,.",Ii;i:\'i'lr-C"",;joiiinn-c'; ,1i:i\ .... _.", ... ,'L,m"'-~,iO" ,;e:o:~ Ii!" 'i!.'~"-'''"n-· ~'-.~- 'i:n,a~ I • ...,. ,;-i ... ,'L,jj;oi,ua ID.!Ul I u:l: !ill] la.iUl. _~!u.I,.I.G:J. ,1I:I!-I;I!IEf,IJ: ·al!l.~~_· '.1 '~~..IJ~,£,~;[JiIII .. " ,b I. ': Ii. ,1l:~J~; .. ~~!~~, l~~~~ ~~l [~~I~_~~'!Ii'~~1

,iill,dj ,t'bef\@by' '~O reat~ ~ih-e id~!11'S of. ,~!15o:m, :~n ~:he wo:dd., 'Th~ Qm~rks ,OeD, the F~cb :lt~Qb;~ltiOD, ,,~~t~d, !aJ'~'¥-e ,i[~ fm~ dl!~ '~~5i~l" ~)'On dt~

[0"":"11" ~ Q. 1.~"I'iI~':;'iii';;:"I'>:D- co, I-'1iiJ 'iii'~e~' t..'j"'~lm- ~ ;]I,..... 11< ,;-i,"'cg, C.l.'~';"""''''.\''''''';j;,~v' 'jI'Ii"""itI'iF":I!iI',,'i'''''[I:~i'P:' 1~' 'J'I'!'" .:L,;g, '.'~'." Ju. :_~.IU~~!I!-~~' 1III ' .. ~ ~_~:~,~ ,n",-~·· l~,~, ~~~ .:..:..~""~.;I!I"~~~~lI,l ,r~'~mI~,!I§'~~iI!Ii~!iI!l~' .I!1i-:I l~~~

:';r.e:meh llevlo~~,u.t]O'.n :Kmlt~ ,l~und ev,ide:n~~, df~llt~ ,~l'!eedom is :ElMW, :~n h'~,~

'~.;iI'n, ''''":''"t- 'i~ .. if> : ..... ,~ ,...., ... 'U" 'v"",,'" '~."",lI"!j",,""I'"",,,,' .)IIi''''!' "in ,;j;,'~iiI!i '.\Il~""rt..] ,.J.~,~_~, .~~I~~'~~I ~~g. ~~-~~'? ,'~;~ P.f§-~~~~~~I ~~~ . ._; ,~,,___:__; ~,p~ "'~"~~Yl!i

:~: w{Quld 1i'k~ tlo t'~alilk 'Tld. C~~eOt ~n1e~ 'n~~p~~ ~d. tbe ~@liturs ~f c8i'Id'c,s in th~ Hj~'~tli,lY' of' 'We~~~r.n ,P:n.j;~'ril\i:-apiy':i'o.[ comm,iiM.iJts '0Ii, !ilill. I~:a[~iel' [dlr~'~ of: 'wis, di~]Jt'ft.

,I Jr~~ ~9, :~~~$Qn :p.f:~~i'~9, :p:npcipl~~, '~a.t: d~t~rmj~~ wh~,t~ ,gi,'V~~ G~f' (;iK;U." ,stances:.. we o~.Jt: t'0 ~1iel!le" i.~, can pmvide ,'i,~I'I,GiplC'S1 ~'ut d,e;t:e:I.mwme i''''!;~~iU ,~m OUr ~i'rcumstJ81t.t~S, 'we ~.t 't'(]; dn. 'nloe :l~tt>e:~' is ~':pj':ac<ti:cal :re~ [S09,'~' SQ.~ [~f: the 'Imr~i!~h :e.fl~~(:]~(1,g, ,alf],pg!f t~ ,hv~ '~U~~~~ d~alt pta~d .. [~~, :ra'Salill, is., m,e:cnJ:y ,ap'p~ied d'i.~ret]u~, e~n,~ fur inS'tmc~, :~Mtm.~mrtal

Copy rig hted m ateri al

:p:ra~t~~'d :f~a~Q:i1in,g i$, '~IU~t l~atplt~dlJ'J' l~n;I!sal f~~omng.,~ £OJ" I~a_p])e).

'~1I'i]i~."'.;i. H~~. "~'"'I'i'ri'''' .~.' I FJ"o...,,".' ""'''i'I'C~,oI1''''; ;i"1i~ ,i·.i' ':":,,""".' ','."'""",; N~, .. ··0;i1~.'":.,,:"", ·iMlf,iI. ~I.'~,,' :3i.· .. =''''I .. ,iJ;·.; ·liiJ.~'if;1.c,' ·,··I,,"<\". ,~jll.'··I~I'" ,.'- .. ,lb'.o;I,'!I'·,I,u "MI~iIOiIO"'"'I' .n, j: J:i&.Ii4.l_j:a~ ~. ,iIiJ:!IliI,"Jln:.l~I~:. ,UliU.;liill ",~. ,iF,lf". ,~.~. Ii! .00 . .o", l!¥ ~!lid)'" ~l~~~ i!I~

~~lmlt ]~:aI.vieli ,gut .~~ 'tb~t:i1f I aim .~@ ,iiI.C;t: O~. ~'he .b:aw·l.e:dge 'th_~,t M[mJ~tib~~I: ~s ,8, :m~lltS, tOI m.Y' ~d.~ J _llUi,t ~ttUrn._.¥'~,a di!$t~nct-iveJy,p!-a'G:ti~'l: r~tJ,Mal ~~!> it,': ~·~Sllt. of 'ibelj'llg m(Jff\\"i~~~d'w ta:ke th~ m;ems 'tit) m,'~' lends, 'Th;i~, di!5I~~n;~dlf ~gcticiUy toa'tiUTIiilJ ~pa.c,j,'t;y ·m~.y· ~lm .move us ~o gOVf(m. OUi[' raetLo:ns by p:rl~c.j,J~$, o.f .p~;,tr6 pl'3cti~.~. reasen wlll!r~ch ·a~ PDt a!ppliJ~a,tiofl!s, :bt!ll~ ana-

].:,'" ':"',. ',. -'f i~ [h" -', "t~ ':.' ;1'" ,.': ... _c", 'l ;. ,~ P':" ,·d'"'- ".i> I, '.' ': ':' . ';'"i'-f "'h:, ,~. '--""1"(: ,'.' .... , fi;.··- : '---,

~~€..s 0 ~ __ em)'e,~eiS! ". P,I!'ctIlCI.pes," O~ .. I!SC'll!I:5Sw:ntS 0" I .~s PO(l~t I5G¢ , .. o.m.a:s.

N'i!geiL The PQ\9.s'i~mtl 0/ J:Utmis~ ,c'Uptf'-lB. 'V' dlIl,d, "~"Ibl ,and M." ~5k~~:ti· eis_ . .:Jj'hqu)t; :~3'ci:i~l. :R~:ISUfi~,~J' Cl!ta;ptcf I I in t~i~, 'v,filume~

l. E,'mst Cass:irer Ktl'[i:t"s' .u~e: ~~d' 'ThiO'~~'~:"'r' 'nl'll liO=·;2 '[

• _Il__ •. __ .- _>_l. l,W! j.I __ ~ •• _,1 l._l, _[ '~Q)j:jltl! ,~,lrr. -. .l.

31 P~u~. S~h~lf;P~· .Kd'ni~·'s .'t~Cf:i;~iQ~l' !tb~a.'S'i· ~~. I~c,. See iI~o 'llh.e f~rew:o:rd ~oteot~!J"~ a~ .~;t:hi~~ w:h~r~ :tew.~~ Whit~ BeCk . .qjUQ,1Pe3 o:ne of ~11!~'~ frlend:s .as saying:

:HA:itw oft"e.n he ·g;o.,~ed. us ,t'O te:sif;5\< how' gf~eg ib:e 'iIlgit~ne:d. [O'lJit' h~trt'S,r. :bnw 'Qll1i~m he :~~~~, O~f' 'm:ind[iili arnd .[~l·irQ:g5, :fuio:m. ~'he fetle.;g ~f seJ]_6s'b ,e;u_e:mor1ii:sm :to ~_he h~ ~o:nsci~~mess· [of :freedolt11, ·t~ '~n.cGltd)itioDat l~b~~~9C:~ ,[JIJ ·dt~ .~a,w 'o~ ~5Qm~ t:.o tlle ~alt~ti()!~ I()I '~~I~sh d~~1 Tb,;e

. . 'I b~] 'b d . 'be' 'rOO .~'~ II1J mll

:Ilmm.o:rtl., ru~ ~op"ef seeme_. t'1!li '!!a'S[ to ne :I'IlSP],;> I 'WIt] II 3, . 'mVl~:-;-1 y

pow\~r;. ~d he .~~5;,l:redJ ·Ill!S~. '~~Q .U~~en~ t~ him. in ·wtmdle:r.; .. His '~eal~Is ,eer,taiBb' neve:_r; left: ,a. si~e ~ec;tj1!:f.e :i:m. his ,ed'liCiS, w,h:'h,O"~,t :ha,'\?jn,g NCQ;i]lt 'bet;t~f ._~~. l~t'!E .~xJ

4, C'~iS!Si-r~F~, ,Kall~"'~ .1;;1#8 a~d:' T.h,~tl;gb;~:~ ,p. '4·~.

~: 1'h_~,'t :i:5j the p:rmciip_We ,tib)_~u;. ,a_~y~hin.g th.a!t eKl'5JtS 01 !KCU~s, 'MU'~ 'be [e~,"" pJ.~~n(lidi. ib<y ,Q_ :r~as(lQ. -w-]ld£!h. is'h~s 'W·~1 ~be It'hing :m;~s<t e:.ltis:t ~j' oocU'r ,~md C311m,01 ~ Grh~~1;s~ than. as ~)t Is,

-6. 'Lew-irs[ 'White Bec,k I~rly·.· Ge:.rWQ~1 'hiJmow.;h'~'· KJtl'n!t tJ:nla Hi"'E. :P_,C€;j(j'-:'c· -._

,. ~ " ~ ~ .. .'.,.. . . .. . L.... . '..lY.J!'. .. . .• . . .. l' . .fi~~ ,~C;~

~onj .~[;, 1;,4,

7 B~~~ .!fiad,' G;eFm~ln .P&,i:t~~phy; .:K;·!\l[IM' ~lilld .f/:'i$ P't~d~'Ot~'~(HS, p, .~\14"i' :8 See '~]~Wj :P.P, '~1= re,

9 8·u~ .. A. 'B~a(:ikill.i' T:h~ .~~:~:rg¢'n(~ uf G~.r~,a!il a'~ ~ .U:~~t~· L~lig;u.jlI'le;j' I 1',oo=·r15l~ :pp, ~6=4iai,

]l.OI .B.~ckjl .!l:l'~tl.v GMl'mlt'i't! ,P:~il~'~pny: .Ka1!lit ~~d .n:i$. .Prtd~t~~~'(!f;$~ :p,. l.i5ei

:11 ~lec~", Ea~~y G'~r.ma_~~ 'p'~[ji~~~~p&r~' K~_~~ .a~)d .H:l~ ,P.uJ\glie'8,s'Cl~~, !P.P-.

44l-4~·

:Ui '1;1::, is semetimes ,asserted dl3it .i~ h~s ~I\~~crl.tlcal ~enod. ~& w.ar~, a m~I;ill ~nC!e: ~·~o:rigr' .. ""'r iC';;'~l!:iio:R,;,;rrtllllltl:!!r'. b-~~I~' rlll'Ci. , • ..,. ... , i'!;iir~Vf"'~~~"'"j"if;;I!'~~ .;f'~'n.cfij''', h .. ~, 8'!'1!r.~~ ~.~.~'I!r."'~~l""l~ ~~ ~ 1iIJI'r·~~~"J!r.:=~~-~~~l ~,-~'!r. @iiil! ~_lII-¥ .. ~ w'!lr y_"_';p'!Ir.'~Di_li~!,-Jlcii • ..::I_l_~!U·u.i;Jl=,J ,~

'w~, ,a-~ 'k5t: ,an .:J·mlbiv~'t~mlt; 'on~- 1~S:ee ,aID~ .~bilPJ~· A';'ei'lt's' ,P~CJ:,i:~]CtrJ[ .~:t'h~~~ C~:iIi"t~r ·m.) Kant 'Wa:5, .a, :f;a~io:nili~,t. by t!r;~i.~irng: ~nd. :perbaps by '~~M:pe!riame~~" 1)\!lI1!.. ~'he!ll\e' i_s ~n0 do-~ht: he ad.~~I'@d, F.~lmets, HUJ~cmu~_.~~ I~ '-&94- I·7·'4·6[~ and. Adam, S:mitJ~ (:i['j",~ 3;-5)0'1. ~rt~'~ ,ailOl'irf'llti<m, or Hu~~n:e~ :is

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Ethical· 'no'~'itl cal reli o1lO'US dl(}U",,':1-.lt

n ,. .,1 I ''. '."if' I:' " - , . I. ., ,t " ,~, '. "I." L, , ,05111,1 .. '

'1,'7' .;.,'

[c~e~ f~om ~he :f'![.;e~,uoe:J]t ('t'hg~'h ~rid~W,) dlis·~~s~o:n$ 'of Hi~Jcl1e'sgn in hi~ 'W'()I'k F~OI:'K_~ts,adM'~;i~-aiD/lo-n [ofS:m'tl!Eru:~'[)[ '0 'lain'ha-=l arod A l., M~--::TI-=~'-[

., ,-...,., . I. . , .. ~. I. ~.' ,. '~ 1.,. - ,''',.,' _ ,f,"'-" I;;,,~. ". '. ., ~, ;1(: ~-. ~ ~

:m.trooJl!f.cdon ito 8:mi:tij-at's 'rne: tll~01:.r [oj ,MOi"itd &t.,D~ri.ei/;ij~ti.' !p\., ], I. :fn. this pefiod 3!m~ng ~he :Bri~.~8ib ,M,o~;a~~sts:;; ~be sentimeol,t!.liJli;s,t!< were imcom.:p;I'r:a'bly beH~f MOfaj~. :pb.uO'Sop:tj~~ than :fiUwaliiStS, :su~b. ,as Sa.ueil C~a~~e [~I 67' _5-"""I 7':1:9i' and. ~~s :fril:low--er.s. (lne. ~,ar see Rall.t: as· tt~ng ttl[ .~ltS:pGn~ 'till

t. b !I..: 'L.: 'hi !1 'I r. M d' 'b ~

'tw·Q· 01 't_~e :m9!ltl O:!5.r;:ec,d.oDi5, wuic.;i l¢.~e ~t~me[tt1lllirs:t$lei{1e·~_~e_. ~t et ;~k\iil

:f3lti~a;U!~"" F]~~ '{lIe seD.t!lgcnrtaiUi!!,t~ had. iIIJ ~n.ctl.o~~. a~OOl;b!llt ~ 'w~alt

'I".;;>_"''''~ ,;:"". ~1.· .. t.:·I'~if. ,"","" .. ii!:-\~]"".:I.~;L;;>!m:' .t\il"i; [J"'!P;O'!U' .~;i..,,.;,,, '"""'""""';"fi'1" ~,,,;,,,, I~h~-.i!> iO';~iI'''''' ti'O'>I'.:o· n.,.;~ .. e [ll~IIJI_~IJ.I, ,1i~~J oft .ll.l.l_ [!IIP_ltll ~.~I_IiIJ~ ~-Ui !IP_I::I;-'W. __ I ~u 11.1'-"_1':'113 'll!_1~hill~ .1'!lrIRt~-~-.II_IJ ~&_I~I 1C'1·1'I!·~ ll.llLiinIP "!II-v. !I.!I! ~L.~U •. "

lOOjl~Pt~, is;~cb ~ the: f~U,Q,jiJali~u· '~Ueved. J~n.~~~ ,a'nd ~g~''i ~Q' ~e.. Tb,~ e3~~ty' :rlltio:n:alists ~:Y' I~OIl.tmst ~3~ no Ci);m,elt~~. 3,o~0'1l~t; 01: whart; ~le3Sotl. :~s 'tbalt: 'mey' eeuld 'use '('0 :8;~PPO-J1t· t~e~~' :~o$iid,o.~, Ottl.,· wi~h Richard. :rrice: [~17'~'~-91 ~I I~ 'W~ find;!i! Bd'tis~ radQ~~~ilt ,al1!~~ting tb~~ :p(~b~em. beadi"o~, :~~oi'i.d~, d'i.~ 1~2lf m)t~Qfiai~~:Jt$ :~itSm$,t~, d!~~ iUSQn ~, d~f;t:eJt~,r' de)te~ll_l;LQe 't.'h,Ci 'wil~1 'b,1!Iit~ tib:ey' dtd mot: :hJaY\e ,al1. iUX01Ul!t~ of Ju)w':it dees sa, Wilth ~i;i5. :r;h.1·b :.i~OG,U'n.t: m w·ilI • .a;t :reamn ffis .in. ban~~, Kafillt ~ue:m,ts. ~o[il:lontSlru~t.3, [3do..ll::ail~st ~tlli~·~. t"hegry' Whl,d). ·w.in .~J.v-e ·tihe~e. ,mlllc!D~'!.

~: 1 :$G uU~ ·h~~.a:Il~ it 'W,as :p.:I.'blteWy· d~~d~d ull: tl:u'!i: looeasloo. mf. .Kam,t;",:;, arPPGinlt.e~~ to' d~e (:lh;a~r of PrQi~SQ-:r oi .[.()'g.i(; ,~n;d .M.e~t~~~lY'S~C8 !!l't :l«img~lh."

:~4~ m. tbe~ :m.iJdJ~ :r:r6 O:S;, Ksin.t: W![io:t'e:

Jy in~li'n3,tioo. I .301 3:0. inq_iI!lIl'r,ef. :~ t~t 3, l~finmJ_5Ing thil'$'t; :ffif' .b;lnvru~g~l

",'~ ... '.'.,..,.i';I ... .,f~' '.~·i..'I·"'!·i,. 1in"iii"'---3:i, ·,.~~.;t~~1;1 ·t'h".'~' ":ii ..... 'I·:""'" ';'''1': iMlt;'i('i;,,,,~~""[ '"'"1" "i~'~ ."''''''..:1 i<'l"j~~''''~,'''',",i;.'''t'' ... '~IIi_l'1l;" "',"'.I~:'Iir';)!I, '~.u. 1110<1]. i!:I''''.-~ "".L 'i!li .. """ 1i.I....,,;), .• ,'!W ~1!<l!1 !t'''''U~.I''''''',;) ,Ul •.. I!~\, IIiII~LY. ~~, •. <l~ .. iC:._l'!u,., •.

at: every adv~ in it." 'l"he~ w:a~ ~ time whe~ I 'be:~ieved. t'his looni!itit'Ultied. ~1!t~ hllltm o~ h'UMillflIiIt¥j, and i d~:$(ptsed ·th~: ·~ficpl~t. ·w.ffit~ ~11Q1W' :net:t~it,g. ItDU:Sse~U. [~nDeCtied. me :i!n dil1leh .. u .• , :~. IDea'm;edl 't(][ ·lI.,o.;mo:r :m:em\J. ,amd.l 'wn~td. ti~d m.y"'S~m~ :IDQ~ '~S~~l~9~ itbll the ,oQ:m:mo:n.labQ:r.~f :irf I ldiid .n(!)t beliJev~ I!!'t.a:t dur~Sl "lew [oJ :mtl1'_~ 'C:3B. :gi\!\~ ,a w!!lIfitln t.o ,a]i~ ~tIh;~ts, .~o, ~st~bU~liiiwq. f~~

~.~ii!' I~I: htlm~iit.y~

1'~. :f~nd~fi'ng. t'~~5 ,~~,e :1: bave d!t";'Q',wn. 'OD. dt(li titanfsrua,ti(l!$ts, by l.-il~,'",d;s, "\ifJliJte Be.£k. ~m the :injtll'oouct~ol!l. to .f.mmilr;u~e:l .I'a,n:t·: Cdriq~~ of ,l~f.~\C~'~ca,l' R;e'Q~an tffld' IO:tJj'~f' ·Wri!t.ing~ .in MiQ1:lti'l: .Pli:I,[~~,:pn'l· :p. 1,~ arod. ~y P'd,U~ Sciillii'IDnl'li' in. ,r~ln~"& P~iCltlljJC:6J:' j1!h.i~·. 'I'll •. '"',18,

~~ .r ~

t S :h~~ 1'~rJy (~!e~~'.i1 .p:lln[f}~v:p:k:r~· .:K;~ii:~· ~.11d RiB h~d€'C~~~rsj :1', 331.

16 .c't, liraJlfl.,' (;;:6~,afl P.~i"'(),$~ty: R';·an:t· ~'Dd .f1:is f1,f:-8lJ~'[,~'t~Qr~" :p. 400\.

I" IL.ewj_8 'White Be(h~ ,A. Co:mmenrbJ'ZY (rjNl .K'jl1'rJ:es· Cd:t;i\qUil fllj.P-rac;tlctd itSd'" ~9 l>P', ~,-,IS. 'f:~r mrtber: ~f~~mmit ~see :~p. ~.6-,~;7 ,and 'n'ii)tf~ j.l of t1l1'j'sl

... L.'''''I\''''-''''''' [~([.~~!I.~IJH'

:1 iIjI, :Hii·'rn"'~ ,in. '''.'r.,.~ ·I'Jrp'-"":H..., ..... I(N:l;' :(j":.~:WI""' ... ~Ii!:J;""I~H''''''''. h~. 'I~',:I. ''''~fl~! ... d ~;L .. ,'t: 1J"I' .... itF1.I1-,:I ~\i"1i'" ~.~"" =1iJ __ ~~I ~ U~~ =~!5r'HIl-.II~~~P.' v." lr~lJ~ .. -=iUfl_:_~ Jj·¥!I-!IJI.W_~Pr~ __ tIU g._ll~~~-._. I!&i-_I~I_~ IlLl!.l.o--I.U ~ILv.l., '! • ._~ib"l

'v.i;rtue (11 [~~~[ a~~~~n.~1 ~TI~oOt 'be l~t"h-e f-Jrst vif:itoo~s, .oti'¥~, ·w.h~ch be~ :S:1;O'W8 iLl Hlieri~ ~ IiIl.Y· actfo:n.;,{)" p:o~~ 'n}e says[;

Copy rig hted m ateri al

:kfUfe 'We Clin, '~a,y,c s:u~h.,a :Rpr:d.t tllt~ a~tlM :m:ust h :~)eall,· ·v.ittl!lO~B!1 .d. '~. ·v.lrtue :mJust he [d:e_Ei!v~'d. £roM 80m~ 'v.lrt)uO'l,J~ :mm~.v'~ .ADd ~K'~ [~1;I~Jtjl.y- the ''Yi!frtlQo~8' :m{)uve Jttl!i!S:t. be d~lmr€,ll,t (rom m.pm. 'W ·~b.~ 'v.~fttl~

,', ··f i~'~'" '~""'··I~ In '" '7·'0'1 O. 1 tt_ll_II~ 1iI~!I.: ~I.h' !!~'IJ ~J , [D}

This 'W'.1tS.~ art f~~ t~m~1 a ~,fI~H!tia'l~v lJot\.W~rM. AAb'l,'t. QP'lA:j'ost bis l'8}t~.oH·~L~~t~

• 0; ,~~ ll' E-~' ~"!II'!' ~

~~~enr~". BecaliJ_fJe tb&y' a~~~. ttlHe tile seD~~ • dut~y' w,il~ the i,!'fJg:t~" :mat~'Yt [0£ morail. '~Q~U!1oC)t~ :"~iiRe~'S! ,~men~ !f-o:d~i~, 'them ~o gy ·tbilit~ :~~, mo.t;iv·e bil' w;hl!t :maike8 ,an ,S.ctiGlI ,3, da't~1:. :h: :~·~S' l~m tQ[ il~e ._ .~nrt.u.= it=it:mi~t vie~Ij" ribQ~~ tbe Cfml~e:n,t of Mo:r:aUty;" R'lWt~ K::QJ ~'V:er:oog;~~ Hume:~181 ~bj~¢Cot~jJl)lJ by dli;9;t~SW~; tib~ krJ.~~. ~dJ 'thJ!~ mal1el',iJa·~. ,~lC'mu~nr1S, of. m;od-V'i,t])On. If th,¢ '"Gmt 'ViRW>lIiSi .mutlve~~ ,dl~, 01: :b~v~ Ito ~ ,Ii~¥f"m. -aJte~iI1y~ t'h:e ,objection, ·does nDt :bc·mAll. N'e;\!',:e:tt.he:ms$~, I. ~m:tgt; siimriJ.. iM ~o' :H:'ilm~I's :i!!1I1 '~ed 'by W;. )), l!~iIl~ '~11~i'I'l'St Oll]i' ·t'broxy 'wltidh :hul&. duit :m.'Jttb\'t:~ ,of ·.Y· :kl'md :is i~_eJ)J~.:ni~dJ m. th~ '~()QJt~lt of dA1li~~'~' .b1rt~fi;t~,,·b~ 'Q~' u~~ 'die .~~m1t :in ~ii.~nl 'ld aIMri\]l1Iii~, sjfll.'OO h~ ,tb~mlks '~'hat: n:it 'w'Guld 'k ."arad,€OOcail ·~O, bold Wt l~iye: ,o.~it ~Q ij~~ :"lIum, se:mc m'h:CI" :m;~td.ve b~n nevu' 'Ol(Jlbt: to acct .(mom, ,3. sense; of. dutYI' 'w\h~~ll :i1~ .~ :biKbg;t :mMi.~/" ;~~ T~~ RJ8'h~' ~d' d~ ~d~l :'l''' ~=6\, Fol" :f~l1heir.' discw;$fi€m. see Cbapter j, In 'this ·v·offiJ1!Iime.

I'~[ fte: ttaodllng m t~e, [oo:nr'til',adi.ctj~ ·t~t w:bicb. :~. _'i'\~ hcr:e :~~ '~Qt ~", oontf:o·v,ef;"ii~ .. 'ne~'e~ il~ di~e~nu:em!t !both :iOOUit Kmti's hlj[~ililioill:91 ,Dld lib!lYi!llt 'w-halt; .mrm. the 'Qi)~lJ:'ldj~ti~. '~9Jt; :~t'un tge :~n ~er t~ w,oik ... :i~I .9, de.F~~e: loj: ,this inll1e.l'~tatt:i{kn, ,~ga.limst the ~ala,o:~ '~lt~~ti~, s~~ 'my "~KaifiJt'~, l\Qnnm!iIJ ~ Ui~i~eI;sal, :w.W:~ 1/' tCUipte'r 3 ~n '.ils ·'¥til)'Ullnl~, .M, :~: :PO:~FiIt

,"""r~lil' .i.;i. . .,;_, 'iliRV _''Ii~~ii'ioa; d"~' n~,,,,,,,'Wco~ci"I""£=I""i"'''''c",,,''",,,,, ..... ,'b ... .,., ""''''''''m·m:]"," .~il ~'il..;, .. "",,"No. ~-._r!ll: W_;J9.&~~J ,lJu;t ~i~ __ ~' ,_,_~-~, .~'.:,_~=~, ,~U-_, .~~" ~; ~~, ~'[~~~-!lJ_j ~~_: 1 __ ,¥-;. ~ ~. 1'_~ILIJ_.~ ~IL'1

~~ oO!llitradi}ct_~o:n~, d-:'8it 1M ;I ma~ who ,eol1$if:l!tQ, ~'.~~de: a:s< ~ ,~~pe: f.~~ NtW'C :mtsm-y: I [~ m;:;.1: ~. '~h!3t ~~ 'W,ils right. :in ,sU;ppoosiq: It'b:3t: t'llilc dAliit"y :mQ.t ee 'CGn'!IJm'ft s1a!~c"!'bl@~ OO'lli.d H d~dv·~d, .&1)'01 *~ :~~;~t; ~tr1!i.dl¢:d~. ~~iSit;, .~:r idi~ 'lm~.~ma~~l4ftion. [of: ::tUricid~ il$ ,iI. :m.etbod m esc'4_pin,g misery' 15· :g~t: $elf~~~~;i'tinl-' :nM m:o, 1: see 1'M£ :It i'$' ~n. ,any w~, lSelf.~I~I'a:dliC<~Q$, N~ ~d~q: tb3!t; [ know [~Ic :!!!;~o~w~ly' deds wffilt'b, aU ~j :Kanlt.!i"S ~Dmr:l.~<!, 'bu,t t'b'Jis ne:ed :nm Metm i['l\irat: t·~c. '~fJ~t; ·cam;t~t; be ,oo:m..s,~~~~d,. I[t~ M3:.,' .m~g

. .,'1.. ''"{'' 'II"-n,t' .. 1'L ....... "'" ·iL,;,., "' ...... _'n·i1 .... , ·L._ . ...ii1". W_:_@'l '~_:~_iI!~ I~H-IUI~ ,iH::L~1 [!Ii!~_~IL~_~¥",I!Ii?o tqI_I •• nJ~·.

lQ :~t;.jI;1 '~~:;U'm, 'mat bis ~tr.11)ictio:n, test Icm. seNe liS! J. criile~CIi1 :fo~' .t~~ wb~t: QW' s,pecmc dUitieslire has ge:l"l.H3!tetl Iii. 'Y~'t; :~~Jti!i[~,t~ !Of cdticis:m, md ,ddm~ 'n~ [~[))~lC~S1l!l :[ 'm,mtiog ker.e1; one of' !the :m.ost :mf].u~Jti!~L 'W.~ ~m_atfe :by' :H:0j~~ md, me id~:ts (rie~. £~j' ·~l'i!iIl:tan~eir.

= = 1~ iiiJiL :I' ,:;. 1i.C'i • •.• Ji; 'I~' iicA'~~II:i ·.iIi ~.~U'~I

,He, •. ~ .~~:jJ'no:ml~Q~IQY· Qi' ~!pJ':m[~:r' 'tJ,~iS .•. n,v;., ,1,ilL'~~iI~J'J' p. 2.61~\ .,1i.iI. P;l~~~'Q·

iIJBy' "I ll~:tj it~_s., y:, ,Pd, Km.t)'~, p,,, 9~, I~~~t~ ~!!!QI ~·WaiMed. 'citll1:. d-:'eJ :t:(l:$t :fQ:~bi~~ t:OOl m1Jlllih~ ~BmdleYi' :l'OIl' :il'ls~n.~ m flDllIity .ffir :Dlwty':8 ~'k~lJ' lQ .!'th'i~'l· &t!l.di;e~" ~\i' :1::;' :i~, daim$ 'Walt: t~~ 'ws:t mrl~'k.~. [C~~rl'~Y' immo:r~:lr.

Copy rig hted m ateri al

• • '-I 'b - lt 'Id u - - . ..··t -Ih" .\':; iD',~.~ i!i.' - -.' - -

!!1mce It!ll'lfIV~I_. eM],', ·Y' 'W"Oll~:__, e{J'rnu'\l!aJ,"~ l' .8, (lio,_i_I~~', ~ ---"_I O,~jle:e~1'Ofli!!i

[il,y,er~oot (he!: 'mffiJ:l: ,of: 'me q1!l'l!tr\5, :~n!tmitfOI!l$ arid, :~n.l~es :i;n, pnerjii,tirq; d:.,c to(lnltlldicti~J'l. The ,ih7St: ~e;[JOO:k8, the :taclt: "thai!' ,the ,:a:p,t :inlte:nm[ ,t'O ,;:'i,v,B.il :h.imse:JJ of 'tibe iilJ~titJU!tiWil 'w~~diij the 'oo~v.ef;S~li:zaJtiog gf ~~~ :~~m w~1d1 [e~iwilna,te~ :~Q-I" hiI~, gIiY~[i, hl~ iR,t~l!i,tjDn~"" tJu~ :~n9t~,tlll:t"j~ ,~~ :n~c~.~" ,Dt'e HCQnd ovcl:looks 'dn~ fa~t t'blit: ,the ,a:gwlJtis :(UJIpOS¢ :iIn. ,sr.a~[ ,aQt~ ([)of d:iaTIi.t;~ '~~d, '~ li;Jt~m~ in. j wmld. 'w,h~~~ ~1;1~b w~ :n~ :W.Q~,f!!r (!!,;lU~d :~::r. P:o~' ,a, 'c~i, ,de~~ ~l :~It~$ 'vi~w' :&:o:rn, tJbe~ ~b$~~,,' tiOilS, see ,MllfCUS ;Si'nge:~~ ,G:eJi~ritdlz~[dn:G in ,!dltt~J' :pp, J;'71~~'J[S;,. :~e ,~m~ Chapter 3, in. d}l~3 'v,i)I)i[lmCi"

:S'J; '~r';t, ~I!uitpml dJi'5Clu53mn 01' :KOlt!fS ;acoo!WmJt 00:1 't\b'~s -d~t~J' see :B.~a_!I'ia, li:e_(\" :~~, ~rMIIlt;llal ,Aid! iilind :R,~9'pect :FQf ~~(iI'UiJ ~I in, TIl'e ,P:ra~~1c~ ,o.f ,Mim[~1:' /(tul,g,mMit:, [cJha,p~@r.' ~'"

~~ For'!I m~ ,d~t-aa~ ~i~ilJt~o:g 'of '~, i!1!rgu-~tt'l~. see 'm,' fj:K.ail'lt:'I!i, ~." 'M'loIU ,of: H~~m_i,ty~.i~ 'Oha,~eiI' 4, in, tJh~s '\!',ol'llm~~,

~j[ [Qn :Klin}t~8, ~tricl)1lIim8 [lp'j'msrt: [eoo:~c:tnn, and ~e,lio;liI'l see m" ~'fh@ R:iPt t~ :Lie;: ~~ en DeaUng 'with. Evit Jj Cha___pt:e~ .5 ~n ,th~i!!i ~b:~m~j ~d Og~ra OfN~'IL ~~ktw~~ C-~~,ti~: Ad)u.i~~,~ I~' ~, Cd~tm~rciQM~ 6f ,Re-~~;' ,~~Jn"""i!i""''''''I.!il' till; ~1.\i'","!I!'Ii";',"l ,~:r!",\i"'tc.",·",,'l p+~',iii;l'1lo"'.n-I'JiI!",,'_ "'!'h"'-~""!I'~-

~~-.b~!I! w. ~~~~ .. _:_ '_'I nHl~;!I!· 1!l!1 ~ _ ~~_;f!~~ - l_l_"~~v~r.~b-V tr ~@,lr,"~_~ __ ' ~!"!'

~4 The! Met~;$i~' ,(jlMora1~ baS! gg'ty ~It~r' r~hi"ed, mJli:C'l], !alt!~emrHM, m

.& ,.,. .. iI."._,A,: -",'m, ,'''-~'''C''fn' ,~'I'iii"~"C.I;f'iIl';'Ol ~nr, ~i''1't'''a- ''''''lH'''-I'I_ -t' 'i!" ."'f~ ~'I..'I·I", '·"'·;o-r,'I.,. ,'''''1'1_ -d·'-, , "''''1' .. ,'1'1_ "t"!,,, .~~

,;lTiUliI,l!!ilI-- , " , ""~, .. -- -, .. JI, .. !, ........ 'il! ........ ,lICu ' .... ,!Ii; J .. i ... !L~ __ ,.!iI! !!.lNi. 'I:,U __ 'il! '"' . ,I!!;, Il1O _ ,. , -'!w'!<O!'-~ __ L 'il! UJi.

'the; di¥Jligg Q-f' dfl~~h:!!J,. :!i!~ M~~' Gr~g(u:, L1'~' [Qt' F.:r-e~~'; A, ~tgdy' (ff ,r~fl:~ .. 5' M~thod 'fiJI' ApP$1i:n'I' th~ l(j'al'l!lori'Gal 1.;per:iCi~'i'II'6 ,in 1'lm Mt::flii1';; "bss~1;.: iJ~' ,S'i~t'~,~ O,Mla, N'e-ll ~OIN~UI!~1 ,A"i(::ting ~~ ,;p:tilic'li'Pl~ ,A!!l B~j~y [on ,K$flit1~ ~Wl'i'C$'f ,~fiodJ :IM~~ AIW1ie~, KlH;U'$ TI]~ty' W M:fi1!'a:l~.

~:s ~In, 't'b,e ~rtru'ndWqJr.I: Kant [claims 't'b'S1t: :b~, ~akb~g :mo"a'~ decIi:siol1l!Sj. 'tJ!te; 'bc~t: ~ma. '~O' U5~ is 'mat: [gf 'Upj¥l~~ la,\W ([~ 4,lJ,6-:1'i'J, b1r~f~:s,ti~Yi lim ,th.e~ .Me:!l(Jjll;rs\h::s- of' .Micn:~'d:S' I!I~ d.imct U&!! :1'5, male o;f' ,the; '~o:r:tn',!I'tl, oJ U;l!Iibrel\uJ U,W': 'the 'Umri:ve.rsal 'Pnn~~pb:i of' Jll8t:iYce g,dj, d .. e 8:u.'!lem;~ :P,rj'f;I,~tP:f.¢ [of 'V:~nu~ ,~ 'Qed :~~t~d., 'Th(t~ ~ ~WO[ ~~il~'~ '~~i!lI~~ lor tld~.

n ..... ~~ [0':';0_ '."-.' ~ '1":0>" , .. 1..";1--: 'ifJ":"'ll"'I-': "',-"b,~"Wrii,·iP~_" 'h- _ ds -, .Iiii.,. ... ,~,- 'I..-it"~r ' ..... ,,- ~"'. ';r;- -"'_-_- ,t;'!il "',\., "',-,-'I.. .. i"" '., ih-.c ,~,

'\-I.I.LI~ .... _IL !IIr.- " ...... ~IIr.J l _~ UJ:.l.· ,D;iI: _ 1 .. "-__;IU.,~Ul i iIil! ~}"_"_":LL.r\I_ll ,nl 1J1a .... !I.~ 1 llJ~.Ij_" ~_iIiJI iJI._l_I_ .. ~ 'Ii_ ~

:IltOW :p-nnclp~tes ,n~: ml:, ,Mcta:ljJlt¥SilCS' oj ,MOrll1~ ,b~ It: Ii ,gener,aJ lwt:lJ. atd. :Karl1ft: may [Still iDltad it'hla:i: ME iSh,Du'f~ ut'; th~ '.aF.ii:¥,~:r;al FI.w ~ld:3itiun. iilit ~hc lev~. (d; :Pttrt_~c)at_M' ~cl8jJ~S,," 'The Illllt)t.e:r' view has ,j,l. ~rt~n, phii.iSfhi'~~ i'tJ~, £Or th~ :~fDi'iIU~~, [of lllll~\t~[~, U::'w :~:sJ .,t~nd~, as iii! ded~iQn 'p.~~dli1~. l't: :is Dot iii, :rule '01' ri 'way o:f' ,gen.eud'_: gem:-nd, :m~~esJo b"Uit s, w:a,y' of: :mli]dng d~i:$i~$! :~QJ OOD~t~ iSi,t~(iions. TbJJs, ,~9! why' :hn,t; ,nQ]ds d"le; 'v,ie;w~, :S*~!f.~ ttlin:g to- :m:aB,,' o:f his :readers", It'bat: ~'be:re !CIiD, be nn ,g,uUfi'lle. [~on'O'i:cts oJ d1!Jity I[MM J.~4J" The.re Is m'O :roo~ :fot ~Aic;;t: 'w~ei'l de:ei!5ioM, ,~~e :m;td:e

i"II'H.:i-;'"' , ... 'L;o;, 'Il'~.,.;il~ ,o.·~ U~'-'"'"I~~~, ... ~1 f ' ... ~' ".""0; ,",J1:-~ ~~";l'll!Q' ~'i,;:;,:~, ... .,.;i, ~=~·it.,.- ... , [ ... (: l!IIU.L.I~1 UJJAi'lI~~_Jb~J.I:II}UJ.\iIl .IL [l~1 1'1'l·"~~_~, ~.!'J.Jl;~ ItUIJ .. _1I_~ .. ~_III_~ll. __ Il,· ... ~I~~ __ I.LI- .. l lI~~IIP.!W_~:lIIi?'a ul;

:t'he ~ ,aR :l'nlillld,ed, :In, y~ur.' B1l1i'm", and, dfte ml!ltilM, :simp]:y pi;JSes or ~.1!nS t'h¢ ~iU'i:illdi;otl(jn 't~!9,t~" 'y:~ 'th:~II~ ,~m ()~~ cOuf$~ ,tb:ings tn S;a!y ~himrt

Copy rig hted m ateri al

rcs [f;)! ,M'Gx~~ 'GO'V~~"

~\')'r. :I ,~, .a:eeil1;m,t, of ~ltis, distiil1~tion, ~~ 'OnfiF-i Nl~~, [O"N'~~nJ!' .A.;;li~g

""'... ,r.J;.",,~III'I';;-'-l:':!n'~"'" m:i-'II'i 4' :iI!= if ;Ill, '!.!I:_~'~l ,r,-,r"u,u, •. ur~"'.!' ~1W\;' : ,.JI' ~ 0,

ne; :~de4 of k'giJSi!altion in, ,;I, ,Ki!~~, [of E'nds pw,v:id'e:s m~ mQ8it ,a~c~~i~ ble mink 'het.WOOrl, .Kanit~:S OW.A 'Wri!lt~mg~[ md thm~ m his ,~on!~;e.mlPOl','Ir)r .;',!iii':l'~~,t_r,aClt~!~;amjse)· :i1!l:ec.esmIS", ,f'OJ' heee w-e :Hnd. ~:'I ... e: .~Q~t dva,t 'we: mil,Y' 'be 3IuJto-n~c'llW:JJ 'knnd, by tl~ lai.w~ W~ ~1!:fl!lWd. [~boo~ urn~ ~de~ dWUM" s~l!l~es; ~O]r ,the :mosl: ~(nilb[e [exa~1(ple see Jo:b.n .b.wj~ ,tt Tfa~~' ,o/'

~' • , ..... "" 'b.." A,.... M' 'Ic]j'lIll'U' ~ "'iIiIii... '~

~gJS:~1~ ~:~mtln~~i ,~ .• iQSi,; Ha~,af'~ l~g~,Vg~~'l:Y' !t'~e~" '[I;[~;fl'I'

1Ii8 'Th~s id.ea dllilt .R:cdom,~ 3)U)mn.o:mr!( .:i1~~ .Mm.allity are th.e wm,e .i~ S'u,l~ ,~l1ed ib;y' :ritG,~ss.eil,il!I, iH 'fhe: $odil_l e:rmtilr[~'Ct.'" lInusseau. ·wrot~e.~ ;!'!''!!b,the .,~\~~edli.'ng ~~~,~ilti~~, t~m~d, be ~H~~ 'tll~' ,a~q.m~iltigg in, ,th~ [ci,¥liJ, ,st'ii~ m ~Qf"'~, Ulbe:tWl' 'w~id~ ,aloae :m.tk:es, Min tnity *e :~ste-1: oi ~j;iti!S.elf, :f,or ~o- R [~r:i:~e:rI, 'b.,,' ,a,~tj}te .s:~Url,e ~8 ,sill!~e~. ,and obedt~n,e'C ~o ,the. ~s.w we M~ :pr-e5m.bed :~Q~' 'o:ne:seH :i!8 :~~'Il)enyi\!' [~~~ :~:~; :r.j. h:i~ib1y it '~s this ~l1l~.si'" d.Qfl, t'bJalt pf(l~~ :~t wim, the ~lIlJtiD~ itn[ [~. pro;b~~mJ. he; :hdl wO'tk~d [~ill :nea~:ID'Y aiU m :his[ :I_~je ~ dfte :p.~ro'bl!em of W~b_I;t :&eedom 'is;

~, Tb.ert: :~$ [~riltti~il ~On~\iYe~;S<J QrVet' 'wbe)ti1.er itlhi~Sl !ii~8i'ih:ed. &0. ci [~ru-mge :~n Kamit:i<s ·vie.ws. :Ka'nt [~id, :1l.Q,t, sa", [ex'p:U;c~t~,. t~a,t it: [diicd." ~,1l1!t: .~n idl~ tCi;r.auld" ~ri: b~ 'f:efc;~, at(~ ·the ead [t:lf .1Ffir~~ ,~~~~~t t~ ",~~~ d~ru~:tj~ml~' [~GI ~U;4~ 'Wbe.~[~3iS' :irn, tl~ C;rI;u'q!U;e [oj ,PI,-a;aiicQ.J' Re~:5'(J:rl~ ih~ ~a"s dlat~ ,udl,c [Q'ttt)" of

~.'L, ~ll ~ll I:...,~ d' b. i;'Hi.''_' ,11!,11 " fl I F" ~~, _j 11! . • iii

'me .OJ'ai~, .~a.w ~ ~ :P1'Q-W:" ~~. :~~ '~eg~tI~' ' t';:;j ,>1}.'1 I' ,~tl~_ru.,

[~~~~'l '~v1dml~ :is ~v~d~d, by 01~ f~~t tbt: 'W~b!q, t'h~: [C~t'£q~~ fJl cPrx'dC'tlccd . .te'i1l'~nJ!li 'wai[ !I iiib __ I'e of PilD. iilm Ka~t:~'s ]>11'[1:'., [~ke BecJ~ ,A, Cain" .mmitazy' [i!ln Ka~t~~ Cd~qp';i!): oj rr['a~til~~l' ,R~[~(ijj'I' pp." :~:l - .J S,.ll POt' [~.e

'P.iIl,. 'i!!j'I~ill:ij"i' d ·i'~~_~j~I;ro>l:!;~\n.,~, [~,. ,.,'i.~iI!l i'I,', ~[~,' ';l!icof.'I" "i'iJI!I; iC!i!'i;l:l! u·""f.'I-:fj;'m.;O;I(.-ik- ··CO: l~CU",~,'I!Ii~;f)a; ry;!>~I'I"'f"!~

,"~~-~-III_III!ljJ y __ 'iJI! .. : .... W'iJ_III:.ut-.J_ .. ':il! ~Il UJJ.'IL"il! ·~'li!ln-.r."'!Ir- j!lL,IJ.ljI ~!Ir. ~n.._ l l.n :":lllI_ _~~l ll'iii.illl_;lJ.lJII. ~ J-ir!lr.-!l.lli-!IiII~!l.1-~_~,

.."..r·, .~,·"I''''';I:I!_d:_o-_w ,""I["'~I U,'.',, :_"'-_I!'_.' .. ,~I~.,'II.!': 1J. 'iI!\,I!!i,c_ !I;;'::I .. = '''''IiI_,1j'-[ , ,,",,7.;1, I'\"."L" ""'., ;"",'_"1" 'U';I:I!I["'..-i,.,,1,. _ ~jin:I'. i;l:l! '.fii--, ,_-_..:I :-'~i>ru..,r.

~~ ~~~I!P" __ ~ ~~U !,"\liy_ ~~~!liil·' .~,F _ ;J.lJi (" ~~ _ .. Ii_LU __ y~~~~~ ft-I!P-~~~~ _ LIIl-~ ~~~

t'lnn, de;SJ :&itt~~t~;;, Ok~' dl(i GllD:d,~ d~ :[):liLj!llki~J~h~~N ~ :~~,tzJtf;~

,A,iilt~~,;i:.'n~;il'i;';' ''!l)!'ii'' 'itl""'D'i')II' [n.[I!~[""l';;I,Q""I:~!P!' ""'I'~[~' j;"'l'Df~~n:~ii'!"J';~~~["'''~' ~.':~~''''iIi!I' ~, [nJ~-~lll:: .; _oIIJ!l.l!l._~ ·_'v.-.'_::Il l~_ .; l!l.-~ 1kj''lII. ~._::. UJ!J~~I~_IU. '_'!rIJ_.i liflgj-~~If.iI!.~l~I~· ~- _f'i.J U?!mt-li §}-.:ilJ~!I;J~.::. r.

3,0 lt~ :~s :m.~t [eaSj 10, m'idmund w.e, :lan,t: ho'L~s, tha~ ·it ~t 01 bQ'~,)!, wil, UnfJlot 'be a'C:hieved, :i'll, ,this, :I'iif:el' e~i:the:r.' loom Whllt ~Ka'IlJt. :lh1,:YS heir.[e 01' :ft:£KI!I], 't~e' ~el1igj'W1f 'w'h~ :he darir_miS[ 'rih~u; [rffite~e itS, JJ~di.cal ,evil 'lD, :tu.!Jma:m, 'H'UlLj!fl~1.'j' :~'~ t'Fte: ,R~,'ffiQ"~ Kant: ~~, t'k~, W~19eD~ q( ml'wi'llh ~gltooo-y' :by' shnwtng hoW' :an, c:v'il "d·~~. [can. be tb.OQlpJn [tlf a'S, d:',c msult; 'Of [i)'l;If [O'W.n ~g~~, 'ne ~n~e~tive$ mshi8: i'fom, 'Ouf ,seomb'le: D:a,rt,M('i do not: [~nmpd us m, _,;Y' 'W3!f: 'W''C: !1~t; Q-n ·tib~. :~~9Gfar ,as W~ :waJk~ j,t [our ~m t;QI d(J :801" Iu,t ·this, makes i,t :um ~o' lmd.m:1Stmd, 'w:b,y- ,m, :im~t 'w.wU ,~b:(n;,1ld, b~ .i~:~vJ~'abl;~ :fQ:T: ,a, :I~~~~ [~~i~tJm·t in di,~ wadd Q~ MiP~ ~t ~i~ Wiil!t ~

~.\~'!'~ ~'ii..~'ii' '!ILi~r,.""~U!!'I' ~A~.!~~l- ~iH~~~lihl!~, ~~,;:o;, :0!1;/R 'l'In.·. ~~.=~ :0'1;,.,..:1 '~liijil ,;o'iii!ji(i!<f' .w:.I'!IiiII. llil_lltiIIll H''_ ,1{lIllJ"!I'!':U ~_~U_IJ_IJ lliUrV-.IIilil_ I ,1II_LLL'!Ir.!Ir_IJ_IJ!I._ ... ·!I"l· .. iI! "ill! .... , ... [ .. ~~~~!I.:&-~-"UI, ~'''U,I! ,1II.1J.1.i ~.~!-'

~~ ~ .he ~It~ [g~U~, tl'i,~ :fa~t; 'wQuld :Iii~t be i.~,g;tiilbl~ [~ll ~:S}," :Fb:!' a

Copy rig hted m ateri al

di$~'IlIiss~.ofIJ m ·chi.i5, ~i~1n, md [Oof Kanti's ~'b.~' of moral fawJt'i!I, [pn:~~;3iU,y~ see ,AUen 'W;, 'WoOOl,t ,rDnt:~S1 ,Mor:cd R~I:rl"in~,

1]' It: ~s nQ~ c~ea:f: 'W~QJt, e:~ac,t_W¥' we I~e :5up~dJ t.o' :be.ili~e wbe:m w'e 'believe in, bnDlnrta~i,t,?: [Gl'C:a,t; dillc.u'lties :M:~ b.e1Jc,,, :~l: 'Wie ,:ure; sdU, f;Ol mst ~n t~me,.J t'h~ [Qt'h,eo.,r 'lirfe~ seeDJS j~,t: ~Q' 'be' ,~, coorunluliltb:m of t.!llis[ 'on~ ~~p~[ 'with ditc ,Sillm~ 'tm1:JI!din,g cGUid01l8,i' u: 'W~ .am n~t~, the; :nml,Qli'IJ ~ PJ'QII:~$~, ~em!i! ou!t: g.f p]a~e.;, It, MS·(1i[ ~ems 't.b11!t i!t. i!!l! ,i;n 'thi~ [otbe!r.' Ute ,t'ht1!t ~h,e v,irtl1Loo~ i!IIr~ '~ ~ m~d~ :~~" In, ,fa~t ~~ dl~ ~al':U~es:t: 'v,e~i~, [~f: fk~

.. :t.... . ~ . It'l.· ... ''''F'''' ... II[ . f'm . ;i'"!i ',~~ . ';f :n..,. R . .;i,., , • .'~

g~O'I'Yi' L~ [.'L~ ~""'_'iimOg . (C1= '~e '~ll~q,!lI!e: 0i .t~ ~:g'SMi 'Ulli_~! :1;SI!l-_~j;e 'fteamn,

,f:or '~~~~f in, :~ .• m~a1i'ty ~C'l ASIQ-:[f:[[ :DS'38-l9~!!' ~ts js ~w,iJ~~ of: dl,c

d·~f.Cci!!'I;Ir-l"'I·;a;;t':. ,~~~I ,., ... :I~~, 1'i;Ij..~m.' 'r~fft 'l"ft ,{!~;a; '~~~I ;'l"1".1I11 'Thr "l"D0,41,i ,;iJi ~~I ,l"Hi"~ 1'i"1;-"",

" __ 1I_Dl.-1Ir.V_ !l-_ J!lu:Ii'1 W_N ~_~~ IIr_l~L'w 1 L~,1r I _L-_I] [Ii ~_l~ ,iiiJ_'1WII m [n_lI.l. I" c:r-r." .~_III_IJ 1:"!IiiIIIlitp. IIl._Drw.

~e, mYstlliiites &~tl'~ ~l~~is~ e.iXp~~:ined, 'below, t'b~,t.: 'the, pl5ltul;!t'e-si o:f :(\l~;acit~~'~, m-~llIt [~nm: '~ til~~g t~ [e~t~fid. 00[[:' ~ll~i~ bJQ'wledg~ h1J ,my' Wa',Y' l~e'NDl J 3 3=34:1. If 'we; 'try' 't~ tb~'l(, of' dl'¢ ofh~j' U£~ w;~ :[l~~~;" :ib' ,think W: ;romeJfbl'Dg: ~e:m~al~ whe:l!l! w;e: ttY' ito l~i'D.k 'O[ !i:it~miJty~, W~ :Ind, O1.1~,~ii~~$ '.in'king of m~~ ,a~ ~crif-ir~;d~[ oOf: :m~Q.~nOll~ (END ~34,~ ~~! This is :a [oond"'l:"0.Il of: ,th~ Wa\~ <=>",~ tJ!tru:lmX

.J!'"iI.'~" " .. .".' l.l!. '. ' .. ~ .. ,r w ... ~ ...

3~ :[0 Idi8:j'~ Wt:'tb~iflii dlel ,[ill~j'it~ [oj ,Rlill'e8M Al(JI:~~.!' :KI!nJt, s:~~~s [O'u,t; :in, !CMe 'RtaU, wbat~ ,I, mllgil)[l, '~a~~ on, :mD:nal :~ii.j;i'h w~md be, ~nd. 'o£f~~, :~'~lwt~r~ Ju'emi1_iOl'ifS, oj 8Ctii,tUife ,and 'lradi,'ti,(it!Gi~, Cbristian. dootrlil"le.s, in 't>e:r,ms of it. Thl~, w,orlc got Kanl :wmrm 'ooubl~ ·w,ith, tt'11~ ,a'n'tbori't"i~!!!, f~f: 'tIh~ (t!~~" d'm,e :(0, his :twm(. l1tc U:'be:ra'l f.~ri1lik tt~JJ [Gl:le3j~ dl~~ :i;n. :r 7'86", ,lmdJ h~iS :m~ M'h~ :8'ucc~~~ N~(;ik, 'WUh~1nl1i, II ~~j~t~ JQ!~~M, Cbfis.;;

' •. ' ,~,nc'~ ~~~'ij~IH",!,;!I,' ,a;[i:. ~i>i;<li~ ""~ iFl"~"" ,,;r;.~~~~ ,-;j1!;!it'ia.iirFm.·,·;iJin,·~Il'.·" .. ~ .. ,...~, ,,_J~~~··C'~)b"1 .T",.·dI ~~'b.~.,;1:~,

!!;,V,u. "~'UI!~III,1r.~ "..,., iliI!Iil.Y, '!o.toli, '~iI!L'_ il!IO'IIIIJIOI!Iii- !III~ct"IIII~,~' _. "":In, W ... Ji~umJiIi, an,,,,, ~.I'I!Iol!'I.l!JS.

'w~nnerJ' ~ k'n0Wli 'OPPlI'u;:g,t ~f ,the B'liligb1ie~men~ .. began ill 'craMpalpa: 'tn iSrta'm;p[ [~ll,t: :~,~Up'Qu~ ~~,t~mn~nt~ and t~ '~M~~ dl~ aruJthoo.ty' [0'£ iQrthodoK :Pl(}test:.l'n,t: doot!rio,¢. :Knitis pre~t~p: iP,llo~~e~e~ :biBl :I'i[om, Itlh:~ :~P;ft':g$i!v,~: ,C!ff~S! f~r iii ti'm~[ 'b11!t' 'We: ,R~l~g~~n :p:r(}vok:edi WiUW~e:~'!, :K4n!t 'W,'IS miliddd,em, to, 'Wt.IJli@. mijj UicigtOll~ sllihj~cts, by' ~ ,d~~I~Cjt cm~~ ~nt ~'b~ :Kitl&. ~wi!llly 'wri!t,~eg 'by 'Wilmer', :t\h)t-'Olig;ru~,y~ 1{Ji1n!t ,oom:plledJ ~"I.",as Y'GU'(" :MiidEst~t"S most ~ari;t:hfiuli~ ,:s,~'bjC!ct~ n' arnd toot dw~s iPhrra:.se ,as :Uili~9ige 'm :p,l~~ib:lbih. :hlls 'v~e.wcS[ ,al~o~l't: ,~d~ginn, enee ,again, ,af'~e:r :F:.:ed.erlck 'Wll:" h.~Dn:~s ~!th. ~ '[hcik-,i' ,lady 'G'~an .r!bilQ$:~,by~' K:~'n~' ~~<d R'S Pted'~)u ~Si'Jrs;~, ',t" ,4],$.

33 'Ihc: ~~t ~' ~,Y' i~ ~lm e~~bUged, by ~ ~~uJ~t~, m~ J'l1iridii~~l 'nstri:Jlail£ of. Pi'a~t~£.I11 :itea'SoD.. ''Wh~dil, ~a:y.s tbll,t; [(il{,t-smal ,o'bj~:ct~ ~, h tro.l)e~ft,y· (M'PJ' l,~6'1, I~e CQir1 see ,the s~m'iWa_rity; l't, hi, ,meOJlerttc.al £nl ,~"'n:.m~, meta,b,y;si~, in, oon!~ent [~K_t 'caf:eMrnly dj5.tin,.i9k~~ '"I'pmpe rty I!' ~ .. , e:r:ly s:,eilk.hl,g :f:mm, :ttU:ife [e:mlpi'lic:aiW ,o8Ses~i([(!Ill; .and. ihe~d, 'l!',:illid Ma1IlSt. it is :n~Rd, :fQf tffit~ 'ta~,k8' '0£ pra~ti!~;iIi.~, :fea~. Sl~ i'hoe arriU~~n't ,~Q~' ,the ,lQssi1bniity m i;e'i-l'iev.iiq, w,orld pea'Ce hss the ,.m.e S'tm~tu~l:e; [IS 'is ,:aQU'~

Copy rig hted m ateri al

me:-n1t:9< :fcor (~od. .~ immOn\iiJlirt~, ~'P:-ei;Qe CM, be ach~e~ve:d:'j is ,&i~~ II plistu·, lart~ gf pr:a{;;Jt~cal ~~n .. :s~ klJ~w~, '~,l\'-\o :3 3-]14'"

'),'".~ .. , .(;;,:;' '~'G~~J1;, ~""C".Ii"i"',,"iI!"!Iilli!' i!lin ~l ,,,,,~ ... , :~"-"",""'i"',:ij., ~ ...... ,,':-,:"~,,;.:i;o:i'1i"iI1 'nn ~"'''''~'':I!''':I!'

~~ .:__I •• ~. '.~ ~_~~ U~~,iIl~_~~:~,I' [~~j_,~1 [~.lIl!l~ r,j;Jl·~~~~,~fl.ft~~W:"[~_~!I#-I:~'1 ~rill ~~. ~ s s>

35 ~h1' Ge,r.m'ti;n,:v' a\r1ld rah~ ,"f;I~'liiC.I:i' ,:R~\\'lwul~clo:n'~, ~\;, ~64'" l~' ~,~n'u;r~' d~)d lb.ti ,~;ench' ,~1~!'~I';ol~[i:iiCIJ'~1 fl" ~'Si,.

'.[!',''li,.. II!""'_ i .. ~I"'''f'i', ,;,~"i.., ~, ""',',...i!!i.' :·,.·'h· ,"":'I,.,.",,l'''''n·, ',~"'.ii::': 'iiTII""II',.' [~,' ,OC., tl.'IO:.: 0:0, ,.iL"'!, it'"!.';'~_'""'I'IA"'I', '~'''''Il!.,-':, irri;, 1':0 u •• ,i'>'Ti"'"L1 . "'~' 'f'" 'ii'""i, -,', ,,""I'U,-,:

;~ of' OJ iIi~ ~n .... '!;,;'!U . 1iilfWl_'il!ilU . , m: ,if."._~ I, ,[ ul . . ... ~ ~J1J..., "i;,.,;uln,u'~ ... .u~~ .::!iII" l~."O'" - ,II, n~!i) ,~.U."'l·

iH: tn.!u! in Tbmry' bUlt it dM.c5, !not ~,,~,~'" in P,r..lWt_i~et! ~ ,'1 whe;llc :Ka'fi'rJt ([:GE@S g,'i;I!t~ ~~fP,gl" I!P-~n'~t .~v~J\1Jtion ~, till th~ .r~~I~f1' ~~.g t~ 'C~h I[G~ .. ,m:i1n', a~d itIliBi ,,:r6'RikJrf: ,Il'i~mu;[lall~, p u 269~~, !Of. .mtlll,,' 'o:( Kanri:.rs ildml~!r:~r;,s wbQI ~:" ehen ~ed, t'h,e ftm_£Jb Blev,oJujt_~Qg, ft):.r disc!WisiJD:liS 0;1' the .~a[[ado~~.ca;l ciha.ta,¢t~ IO'f: K:Q~I'~ ,an~tluJ~ U;ll tfu.~ ,f,~cJh. &ev~~j~ti~, ~~.~ ~1$ Whi,t~ ~.~, ;'1.'K_r. Jlndl 'tD£ :Rip!'!:, ~o B~.vohl,t~n9J/.!' ~n bi~ ,~~S"~"'7'$ [un'

:Pf Jill""" ,~n .. ~' ,~'11'.,"",l~ .... ',.,..0];1I!!i4i', .. "I" T'I~'" ;];I'll'.~ '~0];1'i.1U;[ 'I"j "",c;l";c': f. ifo!!' -'1'1"" ''';m'·~1 ,t~·.. ti ~ .. i~r!lt ..,.(~

niW~._"'~ !Iif.IIJIHIJW; 1fJ1'W=I_-..I.tI~l' ~J_I_"~'~-"'-~l & 'I.!'!~I ·!uUIL~~ IlrJ~_ ... _~_:~ lP!ir'!l€:_"_'il!~II' [~_ :: f'· IM_WJLa . _~IUI.!I!i' a_iI\~_~~ u. I

Bi<>:!~:""~Ui an."

..r.,.,i!J,?!!;;~_~_

3ilBJ Th~ L~p~ 1m' Co:l1.!gre~SJ or :N:altiall'$, i;s[ ooiy " ,u:n~.it~,v,~ ~.a.ft'Q,p,t~:~t 0'1' ,;I, :rCcsrn, WtU':ll~ R .. ,~hl~t". ,and 'thei l:arw,1 M W,3f' ,ia1r~ :tl'l, 3 iS~n~ G:ni~y' [ill n • .at~v,e '-'I!fiI-c-~c~ca··-' ':c'l t~-· 'Ia~ c-"f"iIi' ,- 'w--;jj]d--~u'I";~rc ~,p[ ,::~,;:'~ T .... -i --~cf" 'C·'--i-':··-~']·' -- .. --:, ,S!_no,g~jtie il!:L _-,,--e ,__;_,W!S. w a , __ .[L_..:__, :mp_!J~..c' I~,-- "" :n,11"" M~J!u~"a_l(l ~,peLln:g

'IlS 'm ac,t, :p;:a,G'C'i'ultyir. iUltC'y mmpcl, ~s eo '~O:ll,d)act w[;s~l~, .i!ll Ii 'WilY' th.a!t; 'w~il1 :m,O't: :m~b ,~aCie !IIn,d, :iJn,1:e.maJ"d)a[l:al irus:tiee iM[Wss:ihle ~;M.PJI 3c4 7'~l u

ji.'5)1 The-se; rernarrks :S;l!Wm;filJiI!m~: ldli!i"'l~' ~t :8ap 'mii~out: ~ls b~stmiOi'~ 'wtit~.,S; u Sill~ ~~C!~'rn~,,::: ld'8iJ ~ril'!liil U~1:v~~'i3J:[ ,Hi5t..Qtl' fmm: a' IC\i1.~rm:opo1~~ ("~~ ,PQ£:r1t. (}f 'V£~W1'CMi~ct~(tI1 ,1'~Jgining Ifljl H!~'m~n HI~(nzy~ liltd ,F,:e,~t;" ud J:lC~'a~1 :fll'st S:'up,lemmlt:, .1~Otl~ 'd~~ 'C'iWigH;1~ mI Pt:~Wal Pt~a~.'~~

Copy rig hted m ateri al

ry ,I~ t: ~. ~,L. -: .ofl ~'~-,,. ., •• ~ " '.~ II~' 'I~ :'~(. ~l'~:~"k-; :;'iI..=~. :~::~'~l:;,Ci(-, ,.,'~~ ;fl[~S:"

Yn~ ()¥. ,~:;n;e l,J!:e~,,,,,e5 01: .f.eOern.' .. , ,m'O([a [pJillIOSOp:n:y CUHOe.m_a "'"-~_:t...,"!iI,-"'"'-

tiJo:m 'w:b~th~1' m~I'~, '~)~,d,pne~,t'$ ex.'l:e~s ,jim,ilema:~.~~' [fir' f,jlex:~emal'~' reasons ~ A~nli'nili" 't1m '~D!t:tmid];sts ii: immeone knOiWl~ 'ot· ,a'C~e;n.ts a,

_._-~ ... _.~ l"""i":___'_'-_'-_' __ ._'_~ ._"_ '_- ' - __ - -_. _-_~l '_"' . - - I .• - .• - , ..•• ..1 _,- .... r····· -

H:'II;;i<'i",_1, '.111[11'.:111 .......... ,""' ..... ' "',' .... ""'''l'" ;eh, .... m'u,';'iii 'L'''I~~'''''' ''''I 'm;'C"· ..... l"',. ... .tiI' '~~r-c "'"' .. ';j;~nlv """'" ·~t~, '~iIiI" "A~'_]~ , ~cY(l!_lJlLIJ~~'Lo ~~_~ ~_:_______.~ ,_,I J.: ~II;;, J~~,y..~. ~ ,_. __ r_,~, .. ~_.y.~ ,IlJv . [~-""!Ii._&;&~~1 !u'~_"l ."l .. ~' lll.~_I~

M,oth!'te; :18 pew. o.i ,~'h~ iCo:~,tm)t: of 'tfu~ 'i~dgm,ent::: me :rea£S~fi w.~", the

~ . .

ac,tiO:f), :WI :ri:gbJt :i~ ,I :R;I)SQll ,,(!Jl' ,do~'QI i:t. ACOO!ldm,g, '~:O ,e:xt-e.miBlUsitis,r.

d~',s,'i-, '~::t' 'liit!cessadl'u so:' ,t'ibec.l',t; 'C/llliWdJ be .a. ~a5~ :in 'which, :1: under. ... ,

..I . 1LS ,lllO , , - H . T . ._ ~ .. ~.. ...~ - __ - - ~~ - ~_ - _ _'__ _ __

:8taif:Jd, berh ,tbiJ1~: and 'wby' :i~t :~JlS :righ~: fl):~ :mt~. t~l do .sG:m,etb~n& and yet have; no motiv'e /0,1 eloi'lll' i:~, S:ime~ :m(1rSt (JJ U'S beUev'e tba,t: an, aedOll'1 'being: ript is a. reason ,l~[ ,d.o.mg, i·t~ .inht.e~ismi :seems :ml1IlC p'll'~silije, l'~ 'c;lipt~r~ Qn~: d~m,~n'r, ,of: 'I)U'F :sernse 'tha}i~ mural, 'judg;" 'me;nlts have lJ~f1111i'Jtt~~ i~,c~~' th~y' af\~: ,mo~jva~i.DI'", :!B:u:t SOme: I"b'i.~, 'llnsA'n;L, .... ii"ID \ .... l~~ .... "_'L~,., 'irn'''~maH ~'m if mrr~t' wmu'rnd also, bnno~e iii

11"\;1-. Ur.iJ~I-~~l!.2- lJel~t~'''''-"' ·U_ta)ll. ~,,~~,~_~u~~ '_:-_' [-=-._c_,~I __ >..:. ~ ..... :.!.._:-I~, '_ '-~'<.-'" .. 1_1. 'Jf" -.-" [.

'f.,-,:I!!Ci't_'Pi;:"""tlon 01111 'mD'f,ail 'RaiSOnS,. U' maul] tea8.fin'Si arre 'tfi 'B'O:ttva'ilc ,t'be.'!"'

=,~~:Y·~'I!if.~ _ ________. ._~ '_C_~ "~ _-_-_-_-_-_-_'" ' __ ~ __ - __ I~_,_, '_' _'_ ~ .. ~.~ __ ~. __ , _ • , •• ,_ • _. _. 1 •• ,. - _to )1'

43

Copy rig hted m ateri al

MalIf' ~f: dl,e; :moves ,I'D, 'd~e IWll't,e:m:por.aq' Ide!bate welle ~rdl!(:4:pa:~ed,

1", ..... : iii".h":·'e~ '~'e"'i!._ .. 'iit'e:' b'';'i-~.f(';'';''",".' 'ii',1..,;m, ;ii';ii;'j.;'i'>' n ~(""'~:l",~[~,iif.[i:i; ,,,"n,~ ,iit-'~~"""ii:iI!I'i,;il;',;;;n·en.'.,""l".~[if',.,ii!1 At iii'ih"';ti; ~~_~, llb-~~.~. ~ __ .-~~-.~. ~.~l~,·"""~-!lbr_~H., ll!-~Jl:~ la.~I~~t~J~~lI!-~!I¥€I! ~~~l ~~-~,~, ~~~,l~~"·~NJ.~ ~J~-.,~.,~~~~ ~~, l~~~~_~

eiP-,t;e~nJth [ce,:t;ury;, ,At, the oen:ter Ot 't't~elh' ,d~S[Plil,1~ Wa5 the :rtQtil)a, of:

..-.iLl:~[":"<.o'i,j,;t""j'" ,,.. • ..:._ ,;i;,'~""i~' 'I1~",ad' I 'I'rii"~m- ·, .... 0·1'\11, "'..". ,1'i'01:..:. ... ,j,.."., .,L .... ' .. ~~I""';jiJ;:'n'j,![l!' .... 1( !1~tU~~J~~~[~-:-~~.~,. ~, l~~~,~y ~-~,~$ r ~:~-~ Jt~,~,.~._!~-~-.'~.,. j..J l~~' ,~.'~-~~'I§i~ ~~ l~-:-U-~ ,~:~~~~~J~~~[~~'~~J" '~~:

..l1.I~t: ''if T'-h,g '"';go-, !!W"",'~'~ll· " .... ,iIi'~'I'fi .. lj! ~! ... , "'" "A'.'~I""""'i' ""iii: , ... .,c-i'IO'II' ... "I...... 'b'a,","''II'~I'''''i '~~'","'fI"Io g~l~~I-JI!1 .~,~,_c~ ~~~~~, !IbI!;~~~tI!.~~~y~ ,~~,~ ~y~-~~-~ 'IbIIc;Jl ~~~- I,;~~c~~c~ ,~.~~-~~~~ I~

cdidi ,,~<,tion,d\~' ts ~m,etim~s, 'lIIstliclJ hliOs@l'f' as s.,'lm!~UIin ,for tl a, d!\1,t"," 1~' ~,

".~~ .... ~ .. ~ ~ ..... ~~ .. ~ .~=-=-~.-~. ~-- -~. ~- .... --~J' ~-.~ .. ,,~~-~~,,= ~. ~ .~ ~.- '..I~ ._.

r~'l1I.-IIi'i'ii"'"",.iI, ,"" e f(~Ii']Iii'!iI_, 'l:illii'i,t··, '~i[i"'i;~t~!i:t'.'.~' ,t"~IA~~;r 'li!'1iili!f""irifi: 'iIi".rit: ~;i"!i; ·m,'",'i1i'iil"J .. , +'Ji"jI, '~h~"~' ,"""':~~'.:'iIT'i ,"!iili!', ~~_,I~I!_"~ ~~~]j~"JI~-_ u~.. uUIl_II~. I~~_". .Ii!!r.:.~-~~ ~JllV. ~u .:__J~~~1 ~~ ~J _J'\i:I A-~~.:lt~-tl~1i R!!iII!

W, dil,c tlli'l~!1f,r[~dtl~~ ,o;f diile ,;ctiml~, 'I/O 'iJtJs; 'n~a!tiv:e 'noun - 'W~ ~~' dH~t

••.••• __ I ••• J. '~. 1 ••• __ •• ,-, ,-, ••••• __ r •• _,", •• -, ••• -'_;p. .. ~~ .. l_ ••• l __ ,~ _ l~. L~' III ~ ••••.• _~~' • •

'we ;~e'el !!j'bl'l~lIid- 0.--= arm ~"nd~t, an (":bl-":o;~;t~ol'i~ ttl[ [e.1xnr;ess, [OU" sec-rae mIlt:

- . JL , ].I~ \' . il' , D [ . . . _ _ ",1i~.. _'I '" . . ., ,!If' ....if. _.in .. ... _ ..

• ,1..,-:-: ::--IC" o'II;~Tiifi'ci!i ,....,f. ~.:'iIii';",,'IIJi,~:o,-.' I~P~; :~:IIi"!ij~~;iIIl ,A~ :~:~[~ ~'IiIi;:' ~.liiIi!"'l, .,l..'''''ii', ii'iffi'iMi~~I~ ,;r;'''''T'lid~1i'i''''~: ',,".ue C .g,~J,liI,>Z!' VlL ,.Ui'l!.!'{L .... I],"'"!}, """if'!!.; ,..,1"",I,J,iI,IAOl' v.·~; !O"'!oQ[, ~~,!iI;,., JIIIiI!'!Ii'!I'I! ·,-u, .... ,.. ,I,liil"""'~,""',~, '!;;I'!U'",u .~'!wllO,

h!l QDli,il~'limn 'H~,e tl~~ idea miiJt nu):ral J·'Qd[~~DtSJ [9~RS5, i'rrrwte~mra1

-..- •••• L _~ .- •• -..!:i,Ii- ~.--=-=<<:il ••• ~ •• li._- -,_ __~ .. ~_~L~:.l~ •. '~-~~L'-~'.l .- •••• -_-, r.~L'·'~· ~ •••• lL __

~;ii;;C!ii'if:i'1ii' _ ]";ICJ l·'~,i;,i>!ffi..Jl;i:i;d'~ ti'~, .t"1"lin~i~U'ii\D! ~b' ;f:\'t;jk ~illlili!ii\'i.I"~i':Ilifji!i l!!'iLl ."1..~ 'rnAnli!lI~!"':."ijjl*'W' 1l'lLt:

tll'!Ii.:-!H_~"~._~IP. . rlil I _l1I~.I!li!-I!ir..Ii_~M~- .. l!l.~ '!Ir.H;~'~-' __ 1I!!ir ... v. ... JIj]] ~,I!!ir-~_ .. ::I~-; .. _III,I~ I!..f"; !l-_[L-I!r.' II::I~ II ilRl!lr_1i '1'l'IIllI~) v~;

mor-alh:y;: its poiWie~I' 'oo-th, t-e miotiva,'~e ,aRd '~O bi~d; ,And, dle ej!D'h~l!ell'~'b"c~m't!a~' 'mOJa'Hs,ts.~ 'In~!e ,olln'~emf¥ll1!21ftf' hill~-m~US;tll~ 'f:'I~

•. ~.- ••• ,-- __ I •• ,_ 1" _ _:.:1 [-_.-, .. ---.- ,-, t 1 __ I •••••• _ ••••• -._-i_!Ir"·'!I.I'!'-I!IrNII· [--} ...•• ------ .. - J! Ii __ J

~--;-lt~1 ,a: Wf;tl c~lt,1kf 'wh~ the~' tried, to [o~mb~ne ~dlese tW'01 [ei~,tme.~ts~,

l]iaiJ, , . .. 1. - '!J' - - ,.". , ,,~ ,,' '" ,.. "" \ ..• """ .,. ,,, .. ,, . -. ., <" ... , , .• , ,', ,

'n:";i7I~''''Il': ,"';~'~:i' 'i'Iiffi.ri --=, ~'.I 'iii"ii'~:"~iifi;i!O;i"!i;j:':'I;h~.,;iIi,-~[ , ... ii'ii,~~ ~,',~~J ti"h~,~~i;c t:mLTii~';ilififfii;t;,i!i~ rti,\I!i:" Tfi'"'1i,tr ,iI'!HI!'Ir,li~tJ]""_I,l!iJ!!I. ,.~iliv.l'a,iIi, ,lr'lid,II!O.!''''-'''''',r't _"",,iI,!iJ! '!w.iI,,.,'!O-iI!'"'I .... ~ '110, _ .... ,lif "",r'lr''I.l!\U'!;r.liil}'''ao Il'!.l!cl, u'""" ...

'oo'I'i'd' ,~l'de to ,ex.i'iill~~n how we ,If:e ~~d '~O d.~, O:~r d[a]~:t'l;;. .s:amue~

".<,1,'0"'"'' .,," ~\ .. -,I,~ , .... _"" ,_,'" .,I.1_L~." ~". ,<~,' ,~~<,,~'_ ''' },." ..

C~~I '!\., l' '~, ,,~ '. '.' ~':V ;]. ·~··h·"!·· ' . 1'~-n' '~n' , .'11., ~. L,·· .. ,-'.~ ~. '.'

·.·.,Waf,IS;(!:,j, ,.;a~ :~nsit.:a-ttlice;i' .~_,e._-e.!I ttJtt Otlmp[mllb.:-;t ~ga-~'s-~, '."c!'_:a!!t: ne I~es: tlOl

'L,,""",, ;i'h' ',;lj; ~;o",~~'i'" "ffl'f: H' ..... 'i.:-b'· "'ill';' ;i,L ._,'" '-'fIo"'~ 1 l' ";'10"':0:" ,,,"'f'"!!' '1Ii'~"'" " ..... lI';;;:,,..~~1';;:I! l' ,,"'111"')1" 'l'"f," [0'1; ~ l~;_~ .",~'§." y~ ~,,·':~D,~.~~l!i l~~~~ :llI~V.~aI .__:~·"~I ~:....~ ~n~ Jf~~cll,~~,L!p.'~ :....~·"~I Vc~ ~,

:s.a'l'~4'I~~1ifl [~PQssi'Iti~,y' 'Gad~ 'wI~u)[ :hatS; m~ :P'O"iw~r' 'fg@! ~nfo:r~~ ,~'h,(!im,!, :E",.j;~het, 'W~ ,:me D;bUa\~d t,1O o'b~:'Il!" it,'he mV\E:ir@ii'lI'nl rruair'k@; 'iIll:G')I!i~, in w'hich fC'.3~

'~-~'._ .~.~.~ .~ .. ~ _~~~.~. l~r~J '~-'_:_"~.1 ~~--=. .. ~.~". ,~-~, ~-~~~ ~_~~~-!-_:." 1~~~~j1! ,~I I ,J~.~-c:::::;~, L...=....~:....:..._...=....

obJ'~!a\~,t-ion :is! 'lNder' t'Ol "os;i'~i"U~ 'larw', -or' tloruere 'is, n~1 'II~'~ Q~'H~(~'tjM ,I~;

~ • __ ~_:r.~='.l ",~ ~ •• _.~ r~ -~ .. -~w •• l."""l·.~wwJ. ~'-= .~._~ •. ~ •• ~.~ ~-~ l."""l ••• _ •• ~l~ •• _=r~~ •• _ ••

,!i'Ii,11II_,'~'~"""'A-~r::~;i!Io~ '[1\"'" '~I,01;,+'i3ifIl:'' 'iIfr"!iliiiiY~I!i'lilllpDI+'ifi[~ ~iiI"in:lli'im~i"Ii;iIi''''I~i:iCm··.I, '~!D[ ;iI!i,'I!liIL'l;ilj;,,"'" 'iI;i~ *'~' .• ' ~lIJ_J_ n_r~'!i.IJ~,l~~~~~ l~-M LlIJ_iA!~-I!ir.i_IIJ_.j [I!.~I~_~IJ_~-@!~"-~·~~J! ~:-__..~~~-~~:~~~-. __ ~ -=-~ ~~IU.~I!!r~~ ~~ ~J£IJ""

'V~~ ;s~m~ o'~~~t'b)n~ TIti~ iSienti'mmitaHs't Ft:J'nd., 'H,\u,~cbesQn fOol" ,ex""

w '~:I .... _ -_ ... -~:~, •. " ... - .~.~ ~l_OI." .... -.~ ... ~_ ... ,_ ..... ~-~ .... ~l."""l._:.==r ••• L'~ ••• ~ •••• ~." .• "_ =.J!ll!1."-.~ .. _l

,atMTr\'Ie.", 'heU[etV'e$ 't'itc'U G,oo, ,hai Tli~-(;lv,ided us 'with ,a 'Ii'iOOl'W se~e w'~r',c:~

~-'Lt?"t"',1! ." ..• _ •. "u •• · •• _-_._ ••• ~ •• ~.~._."~~."_.~~.~ .~ •• wwl •. __ •. ~l.' __ 'J .. ~. __ ~ ... "·._ .•••• 1.'_1. _l

caases ~S' 'IQO ,lp'l'o:~e be~ev·O:~enia; and deem I,'~ 'ViTtUIllO-::lUs,. B\~Jt :m~iJGfia'I,~ 'mSi~S, al'~l~e ,tba't 'nf;Ov'~d~'~~ UlS, w~'~'h ,I sense 'w'b",ci en-du~ [Cim~I')1 M,(j,.,

,~ ". . . ~i""" . . H iIr' . ,Ll .. e; ... - ,I, . . .. .. ..... _,. 1.. .,.,} .... ." .ID, , ...

·~A .. ~~ - ~"~;m ~ -~ - - ~~ - r. "I"~'~~ ;,. Lr.' ,~. ~ ;O\"C"' ~~ f-~" G~ ~. - ~ -- . -. - --_. -~'I"~'~~ b~C"

'~I,Ve.iS 'Wlk' ~ a, :mD'j:a_~ [q~!a!r ;It, li$, ]IYS't ,iii! W,iilJ : ;OJ'[--:.'~, t~1 U1ea.'liei :mr..tm .1 it,,' .1

,~i!le',~e','V~; '~TiciC~':ti:M'lltiiHi'[iI. t.J'ilili.·t"t.., ..... i!!'~1 ,"!'.:.~~!jlijifi' ,!i'Ii[ifil '~'i'~l;i·.;~' ~~"" ~'iii; li!'J'IIi!U:ifi[ 'i*,J..,"'iIf ",,,,,,,,,-\1[!!.-_1_ "" l,u_,",,[!Io,I'!I.;~[LMIC~J' n,,,",, !I.~.J;'!r.,",,'V~ "YJ_, ... ·u!_ ~'" ,,,,-,,_l',,,",,,'!w,L'.l1, iii!''''''', ,'.ili'!r. !iJ!""'" '" [~iII~"" ...

'GM '~~!Jld. h!1,Vi~ [d,.~n '~5: a ma1i~",!I".W'Vjn_1 m~ral ,~~Iil~ had, HIe 50,

~ =~~.

,mose:m., :[,~ :is n~t '~~~)u:se be:nev<o'l~f!I~~ :is, [Dhl'~.~O'ry' m, ,i,ts~H~ bu't

'OOC~[iU:S€ ,Ged is bGme1li"i()'~ent ,amd ,illIl:"trimrY~n'" 'bentl;VtDlemc@ is ~rood ((itl'

....... "~_~ ... " .~ ' ... ~. ".--,,'"'".-, .--.~ ." ··I'Jf'r .~ ... ,.~~~ ~'~-.'~'~"'~'. ~- ... j--- ~-~. [or~·~·-·~ '-'--~

U5w 't'~a,'t Coo, :Ilas, [~aus~d u"' tl~ ,a!,PM¥-e ,i;t. ~ :Uiu't 'tfue :Ii';a:~i~m11iJst ti(di~~, fdee ~Q:m"l:aiWl' th~!t tb~$ ,m*~$, :mGl',a]ji'~y ~, kind. cf: iU~tSiQ~.!, W~ may' :ind.eedi n;r,Vle mQ:rallllpeI¢~j~io~5/j!' b~t~ 'unl~ss, 'W'hl;~ W~ 1P~~~i"~ ~~![ ,I

- ~' , =

'riJ .. ,l..':Cn·~1: m;': ,.,; i,~,_'II~'".' < .. ' ,,·:litl'~': L' "".,'.' ":'~"~' '1,<';:\', -", ,~[[",,'~" ,'j' l~'~".' ,-'pl',ii'lb.,"c

~,~~_~t~~ss ~-~It 15, r~~~" J~n u_~e iitOUOl'l\j tJ~e ,1C;~10,n, IS, ,1l!Jt, real,' Q~ ... tll'

'~""-d' iiI!~ 'n'-;-,;,fo '_-o1;]'~I'!IiI" ;i"j;'L'ljiii'iIIl'.!'Ii;f;\i'"n'U' ""t...il?i!!' !i'li11i1 '~,iI'i..a, i!j"'fij~- ,,,;I!.'''',;i' -~-~- ~'iI~ ~ - ~ ~~, ~-= ... '~_: ~ ,:: ,-~~ '1;~~i9_ ::Wl~: [~Utl_I~~".;~-~~·I-:r. 1~I:Ll'lr.';Ii: [~IHlli 1~'IIJlt~~ IiJ!~JS ·~_i~I_IIiIlI.J .01'_013.1, sentl!-e

dru~nn!'" '~mn1-~e~ '(~"\'fba,t t'I],tJ;ei 'Hlnjif 'I'i~.nhinlj)j i"~mfisi~aH~' nf.cne:r. lat'f im~'

~~~'~~.l' ~~_;'~L.~ =1 ., _ .. I, - I" ~ • =:_"::--o _I ••• _-- -"=-01[- .1._ \ -_ .. - I ••• __ .. J~ tl"" I. 'r" .. "l .... ,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'ft~c-~r:~'ust Ot· 'iUn'llI~'t,,, '~'be-l'~; 'is, notbi'li1'" ,obliC!"'iUl~lu, ..... ,M~ The r,j!ftih,~~,

,!r,-,m,r.'"1 J.... ·--II .... ~ --, ..... ,.,~ ,- ... ----,~, ... "-~~~.~~J.... .."~L ~,_~.u ..

'1tess ;of ,I~ ,!3]cfon 'C~Ulillo-t be !5G:m,eth'~n,!t' e-x~ri:llli'c to i'~~ ~mJ·e:cte-d 100nto

_ .. ,. __ l •• -.,_lJ'"l_' , J .• "' .". __ I •• ~.~_O' .. --.,-ll---l..: ••• "'~'1P.~.1 ••••••• _'.l t_.",

i't~, like ,~, isee-oodla:~ muaJi;(~~, 'b" 't'b.e '~ll1.tlntl, 6f:;3, sease, The ;ac;,tiGD

'I' »» ~l J.l~. 'lWf'ttt.'!W1

fdillst: 'he 1'ntd'n:siwl$y 'Qbllp1t'{Jty :H u~ :is, obUpltory ,at ,a]t

:RUit; :sentimefiiltallsts,w in, 'W'iB" cnltlolzed ra,t~ooaU5,ts :kkr: :IlDt be~ng: ,a'b~e: 't,o e~,p:lai'n, :hOrw 'w-e Ire~ mJ():t1'v:a'M~d '~O ,do, OU(' dIU,ty" Aot.-fitdmg to :rt,UonaJ.i$ItS, :~,tn.e9S, i,· I, ;,W, p.roperty' of an ,ac.tl,on Gl:' '0'1 'the re-lati(ltn ,of an, aCDon, 'bl) its SitJua'tiOn.r <lIisoemed by I19son. B'LWit: ,t'h,e, ih.e IttS,P ,m i, :raluonal, 'tm;t·b ~ms ~D' bi,V(: ,rt(J' :m.oti!va,'tional po-wer. 'Hume

(O!I;'I!M;""",1I'I}t!;'V ........ ·m'n'~'''!;l·'I!'IiS~ • ,~~~,~~~~J"7; ~~:__.~ ,r.~~~~~'~iII_111

., . ,:m;~ti! ~.g. of~~n ~~tQ.1d b,Y' W~'f d)~~ii~i9~, ~nd ,iJtrl~ d~i;.~ld f-rg,j1fi ~i)m.~ a~ti~n5! 'h.y dl:~ GPD~nn at: :tnjllst~C~J' ad. im~~U~dJ ~o Gdl~r5 ~Y' t§t .of G\Miptton.

~·/;;.I . ",', ",' I I ~"'I: :' ;11· ,_ .. ;~ ,~ . ,)1:'1'--", _ '~b'l' 'V-f.: : I _. ··!I'I~rl i _',-: _ .... ;_'", : :'1- 'I' ti ;~'. l," . :~ '-~ -,- I' -, ti ~ : ' • .-!i I" .~, I ',~' =11"1: _ ': " .~I ;1 ""UlCC ,m,orI!I:Sw t.1.eKI!\!A~ .. :i1!. e .In, ln~~uen.cc: OD tue iilCI(UlM 3DM ii1i1i~;e.enon8.!' ~t

:fo~l()w,6\< t·~a,t. 'tb~,· IC~t: be dm,v~dJ from f:Ca~~ ,and ·thalt, '~Ul5e: :r~~~

",,~ .... 'tI!i,.,;, OI;e .~ ... 'i.· ... ~I ... , ""ii_c,.;d·' v w~I.~AI ...... , ... T'!; .... ~ .... i" , ... ,0'1;"",,", .. Hfll:!' ,iI'!.~~,;o;'''' A ... ,ii,"I,~,~ ... 'W!i;;O;'~' .,' '1iI_1~_~!lr.jI ''':Ii;P.' 'ft'!W, Jldl'!l'!· .. ' [ .. _1I~, ... [, II" 11f,1o!?i;l!'!I'!' [~ ~:I, ,"I['IiI·'I!·~_:" ,l~I_.J·~·'IiI ,"_iILIJ~' ~_"'~_llL ,~_IJU~L!WAi~_~_'lr.-~'J

Copy rig hted m ateri al

: ..... ,'£1 K-;Ii;'N'"Tt;j:}., M if'Io'RAL l\!,'H'~'E.O;; :j:}.O',I~lt'!I"~'

.... "i!lI ~,A= '_ '= i;!I _ ,= ..... =_' __ ~ = _=~ ~ , . ",_ " iF cn, ~

":d~:e: :!$S~,yJ:$ di:s'c~mo:~, m:: ~lthi,~s 'md~ inQ@<n~~j~j:V\e:J).y~ :Kan'~, sa,ys~1

t~. " " "I).: ',Il;,,,,,,i"', ',~i,., :cl· ~'I!, ~'? '~-,cl:, .. ,.." .. ~n:, ;I'.~, _-D, .,~.~, 1','."., ,o.:'I!:-."'" ~ fi,ir:',I!' .• ,"', '1I!'ii'~[''!Ii."" .. ""'. """,-'h. "Ai.iI;'~iilliii" '.,; i'l--iiIIj, ,t;"'Ji'Ii',III'l'., ;',u' ~ I ~ ~l~. w~~ ~~~-u I~y ~ ~_~~-~'~!I§_~~g ~.n. ~~ ~~~ .~JIL~~~ n'._ ,1Ir ... _~_:_t~-~l ~_~_~J~ I~~~~-~,~,..

'lJ,f :b,owl~d,s~ or :~~inl . " ",~xdrui']VI~~Y' de-dd~s '~h~ prim~ry',pd:~~ipte.s of :'Ll~cti,c.al p~.i~,~p:h,¥"~' [~:PE, 300'"

I:,· ~)t~'s, ~lddcd perioo, t'hj, UTmtea:sy aI~ian"oe 'between, ra'~i'olla1i's:m land ,serttimmwjlim ~~i CiV·e~ and l',a'~,on4HaM, li1;.ia!S, WOifl, the lda,,~ The 'I'!iif~b' .~~ .of o.b·,1igi""~i'~I, '1[;ii'I~"", :~"I'V' 'fi"ii'~li'II""'iI!'o-n'i~·I·li'O"':~[, '~rJi"ilo.b~'~-"~. 'iffi"i'M.~I!i!';i' 'I!,. ... ,

~~ ~ -~-~~,~ ~-~ !I!.I, ~ e~~-~~~" Lt_~~ ~., ,r-l~ l-u~v.~,~:_t ,~-~ Ft v .JIJ!Ir.'iL-_I_"~l .I_"_-.l.U_'iJ!:!l.1 ~

l5.~]VI~ in tWr~ :Sta~s:, Sm~~ th~ loon~,1PIS, of morallt),' ar.-e; ~o:~~e.:P~s, of; pilD:~ Ma91i)~ Wt~ mus,t: staru: 'with Q, :me~ai,hY}lica;l, ,aOOOUIli~. :s'hnrwirng

'L. ..... !I".' 'H(I'I,- '_!"!IICAiI!!i !O\~~iiRit",~fo..iI!l ... :L· ..... ·S ... il'ii"iil!!i .... iiIi"·iI'-C , .... i'Ii.A ifi\li'i '!lii!i'h',- .... ,L. -~~ [~ ---. ..... ,'11--.,; . ~~cy.L,". ~'~;~ L,;!!W~I~-UL'_'_] er~'-~J~-~;~;~~Q! l~(_~~ ~ ~-V{_'~~'_I ~I,,~~ !R_I~r~' i~l 'g·1 1_· _a;~ U~Ley ~aIDll,'~l'·'

~U"-f"1 IClmlJtai:fiI- 'B"U1~, m~ iCliiliim m!l11~, ,il oonO~rt O[ 'cTI'.-' '"'~,-SI:1 :-~nl' -:-~-I 't;:; -~=i! i ~." -. ~-, ,-" ,--". ~ ."._ =--, .~ _, - '""1""" pure. ua .(00] ap,plles . I~

dbfl; w'odd. 'is, a.'nW'a~5 is:~f~'!be,de.· 'KraAt lcaDllOl· li'ke le~if;I-~le;:' ,"' -t:'I(f:a'~~;sts

,--~. .., _,", i.~ ,_. _ . "iI'" '1"U"" -" .• , , "., . , .. ,',. ". ~'". 'd .. ,", ,I" .r ,m 1, .n .. 1 . '. 'I

ilimp-ly ~in!si~u tbat: ta, :r;atilonal :m,o.t:;a] ur:del:' IJS :in~lUit;e.d h'il the :maUtRi loj f;1t~'i!fii~_ 'D':i'\IigH~:a-"'~it'!' '1m. :;-I;i;:ili!"'n'~~i]";fi\a- 11.,0::115-, 'rnA; '~~l-~' 'iii";~['iil""';ii; :~r~ aj.'h-:'~"';C!, ~;b. o!i'lI'fIi ~'I"iI1

~_lLlI_+_II_"'~w ~,v _. l~J.~ __ 1!Ir~~~\~.I["1.,;I!, }'WI~ ,II_IH, , III_IIJ'!WI!I II_~_"~- l!!lr. ,~~~ILUlIW'" 011_111)111 ~. lIIf~!'il! I. J~li •• J_1I1 ,u"IJ,

dr~eQmticail philQ',SiGp:h:r~, So 'we :m'W_s't tum, t'illl ,3, ¢ri)tlca'~ :Sy-DJthesIS, tD' mow' ,tb:a'~, '~'be OQ;~,oec,~s, 1M :m~t,aJi't" apply tID' dlilt: pan: !fir: the 'wndd, toO w:h.ic'h, d:we,' pUQ)On. tm IIl('PP1,; t(jl us.' '17'hJ~' :6I)~t S<1iep,~, and, the ,ae I ,lim. co;~~emed 'with hi'~, thhi) '~a~:r, :sh,ow!! 'w-ha,t obto;"'"~~~nn "IS" w,t '~\~ ,~, '-I-~~.

"c_,,' -_. ...,rt.""l"""\p'-- .. - ,1'D_..,1,,,~l! lOlsa~,

w'h~lt: th~ lOOttCieprt of o:bli&"I~io:n ¢i(u'itta;iDll!. 'l1te ;se'.ooniil.]l ;0([ s._w.m}th.eUcal,~,

. :'-"-;'1 ,";Ilr-:-'y,r" ,--'h·-.--:, ''-b'-" --,'.;'-.'.;:_---'','-', hr"'" ,"'-;:--.-1- ',',"'j-'"'", 'C'I '~·ib'-'" ~I" 'i'h,-'-" .,.'r.,--' 'ih.a~.-,--,

SI't'Cp ,I., 0 __ 1 ~. ;at t__ 1:; COI'i~Pt, ,.a1S acpp~,c~uo:n.r rtat ,liS" It '.allt we , .- ,ve

,o'blig.a:tWllS. ;1",

'~'nl ' ....... ii"Aiiiil'~I~'Uii'i'\:r~.. ~l; 'lI!","'~'ii .!'i1filM·!"j;j"ifi' ,h--,; 'iiL'lrii'i'IL,.. ~,t.liii~ ]\a- 'ifji;iftIi d'- ~~'~riliil-'''v' ct,I." ~,I:''''W,;liJ)l;tJ '~I!"!O.!'""H~ ,I. ,~, ,1\..:,111.11",· RJir',r""ililiI.'''' I!I,'.'!U!' l,iI].~II.I.1'ii.. 'U~L!lr.IIl''!r ',~ ... 11;..., I, ,~iI~ilil! ........ · ,,.,~.

,a11~l.ut: snahJ;zing; ,the ,mfite~pt: !fif lob1i.pt:iloo. An ~bUI~t;iafi ~(f~ld, be

'~iie-:iCJr~~'~,,":'TfI '~':" ,Il; t",!II~;i;:ilj~"t\~!ta1 ~'i:fI:'iifili!ll';o'i;"~''q',iii! ,~r~-4I, 'a- 'i'fI''''';~V'7'~nIP' ""-r',!Iltl' ,~qfI~,;'i1 '~[..;o_l'l·d' Ia-

Irill, ,-iIil!-~III~~l llJ! II' !IiI1 1Iir. ... 1."W\~~III,... _ . , .1I_1I_1II_ ... r·_... .. lu'·!I!' .... , 1iII_III_ilrU [ -"_111_ ... _1'11_11_"_~, ·~.Inl_MI _1 '~~I'Iir.~ ,Wt~-~ _ ~

'~Sl i'mmed!ia,tle:~.y' to ,the PI).'hDwla of: U:nl:vet-w, Law. Kaimlt: 51',,6:::

_ ,~ .... '~I~'I'I '~i"'".~, ~.'o;oO~II·'i""" '~ii!:-'''''l;:-·If.''!!r. :11"+,,"' 1""",'''"r,\lI; :"'''''~~~n:~' 10" t~ "" ''-':'''''''~O'l1I~i.-.: ... ]- '1;-11I'i0!!-~'

~ 11 11 "L~ 0"1 __ 1 ,1_~_~,I:]i!11I "_.L.,.U_IJ_IJ~ "~_l"IIP_Ur'W. "_11'( ..... 1.:"_"£.0 ~-v.l_ilj!l.r.:~~lll! .. I. !IP..i"-!lrt~.U""IiI_ , I -.;I~.I'\r-~'OI.I.'

t.if~~ ~, n.g~, aJ'~~ :~mim m~ ,i:O-Ru]a 'cQn't~n~ng: dl~ :t~o.~itlQ:n 'w'-~i:cb ,a~m1e ca-ml be;3l C8!t'e,goricru im(pe~a!tJiVre, e " +

s ra •• ' u: :1: tJhiirn'k. m ,I, ~OOgortw :i'~J".atti,v~~, J ,i.R~'w' j'mm~di~:I'el, 'wh'd:!' it lOO.ilit'il.tlif~. ~Fm sm~ ,time :wmpe:1'2tlv~ OOll!tain'S, Ms~d_G5 t'h~ bw ~li'-~Y' t'b~ n~'

,'s-';:~v,' .. "",;!. ,.''1;111, 'l"I'!;c;irill"-[·,'m':' ":b; nl!l;i,-i1 ,;j;,.-..-.\if!w-..:i ~""~I,..,'h' '~:'i~;GJ ~,'i~~ W' ":h:!Ii"'~l""~ '"i'''~~ r-l.o!IIU,' .' ,'I'!i'l"li""iIi'",;~~I!o, 'PIi"'1i;

__ ~LI:'jJ:L ·Y_[I_@l!il' !Ii_g-~ ._ .. ~~ ~----=:rV"~ '~ ~-~jg, '~,~l!r~ ED_~.~ lII_@'1"f~l .'~= r'!r.' ~[[J_.-'!r.' ~,-H'-nr '!I.iI-~~_J~!RI_fI_~_if_9- •• ~I,-'!i.i!'

~oItdi,tiQ~ tOI wlli'C'b. :it ~s ~~s.m~t~ tIhe~~ i~ :rn~Hljj]g remainiq; h1J ~11! ,e~~.t: tjh~ ~i.~r~a1ity m 1!1Fw' ,a~ ~~~b ~Ol w:b:i~b dl~ ~mm ~f: t~ a~ti~, ;~o.IDd

~'OI'M III III II •

Therr.,c is· tllil-e~lf:o.I~· oo~'" ome ut-eofll"tcal inwrmr:ad~ ftt'itS· AC't on~,,' ,a.ccorcl~,

I l , ,- . , ,_ J! . - - - - , - . ,-,. jl1 ..• - - 1:,.' . I. ., •• ,- ~- 3 - • - 1 [ - - - ;f!' .... - . _, ~ . J. I - .• • ,.,. ,. - - .:., . - ..• 1 1

g. :fia~t:, -dl.e ,.ilysi.S, ,gi,ven b~, 'ili:bese oIJp[i,c :,assages, is ,ailI'm.Qs,t: id.eD'~i'· cal 'tlm dle ,3irli.une-mlt: of ,GmlW'JlaWfitt I.

Copy rig hted m ateri al

:iIn. ·~Im.$ :P8;peI" :my aim i.s. to, isbcrw' :I"iu;,w' lta:mes, ,a:liiiailysi;s of a'blip'"

.'.,A''''' .-.;n .... ' .. 'i·ii'j;, ... ;fi 'm'" ~ I !iii ... "" .,.. ""i.i1:~lm' .~ c I;<>-nt"· .,..:i!.' .t""'I';i'o"'i;;;j'i'iiV~'~WU"il:ii'j'_' ~' n..-rcU: .:I""'i:> '~I Oi,.·;;II~'i- 1'~~~'1 [~YA~)'--~'~~~I L·~,~, l,iU~ ~~,,;~~ __ .. ~_1J_1I1.. ~Jl: [~~v.~~_ .. }~J;,._.'·V--,.K, Jl;. ,lY~'u'~'~u~~~ g. [1]!~IJJyL'P.

tiOD, ~X) ,t~be :pm'bJem, oj: O!b'isaU[(}fi tha~: emerged .Mm the CODIt"liOiJ

'~,~"I'l"',-.t!" :b~!i'a~'!.:O~"if'o 'or""li'l·Jn:;(o:JIlI".l·~Iri"'m~'C" '''''.n',c·d:~ ,lij;e:"ii't",i'm'.~.~I';>'iif!;,jj; ... 'II~,Iii;if1"~ '~'ji"iI ~"'"-"''it~-i,o:-: i:'f' z. if ,~,r.

T !Iii',~,~ 1 '. 'lY"1!o''''''''''!IO'~~' .~,dOJI!o .\1>11_ ~ • ." ... 1M. . iii! ~~~ ... ~ ....... ~'~,!I.4II.IiIl""~II .. ,. ,111,1, O.'!Ir..'!Ir. .. IJ .. ,.,11. "".r .I, i!;.<ii!I;,

:P:lai'~ In m~re [d.~tad, how' '~'!ne 've.q Ic;on-te,pt: of:' [Qbl.pdoo. ,gemera,t-a a

..l1r::'II"'"m. I~'''' 'U'l"It,.'~I~'k ,~,,: p~;n~l.r;",'11 t"""-'I t"~I:r<iIti" ii"- .... 'ii"t"ifi]L'ii'.-O;>';i'rC!r'ii:f· 'P1.,,·e-""ii"iWl1ii-l"'!iI'ii'i- [<jOt

gU~-_ ~ _lLIJ"~, ·",,~U~_ll ,~~ ~. ~ ... _ ;MI. ;'4J! . _111.011.1 !\Ir.~~_lIl. _",U'!''I'l !lirJI,~ ~-. I. 1~1. __ "~i Ll~l~I""_"_"I~ ~[

GrolJl1ld'~~J'"i:' I' w'hidh I' '(eOQ:ilstg,o!' in Sec:~tifin i:" shews 'd\:ie: 'wa'ii" 'OUi;t

-' '~ .. ~ ,~""'...... ~., '.' ; .. ", .. ;.'~,... .. ..; .. ~~"/!i ..

... ~ i""tc.fi"'~emi\""i"II '~I~,J ':!:~I ~oij'il d.'· ~ ;i!'i;*T'Ii!i:rt' i"'Lijii~!"",iC '~'If:'5iJi' ~;;y."..: 'i"i""'~ '1Ii"~t''i:';'': ,""(Iii" u~: IU!lila ul!l!.. 1Ju.~ Gliili:L-'IlI, .~!U !i!!'U . ,vl ... o;,e, ~.UU"'I"I!'!il! 'I"I!'.iliiJ.Q'" !il!"""~.I' Ucl "".iI!_!tU·~itI; D~JJII~

("b~i,g:att'Gn. :m:lS'1 be,

Th~: ,-II'I~r-'mellt '0£ 'Gh(f~'~lt:dwo:~ t '\9, an ,au-emll'l:~ eo oh!'·:e 'wh;u I: :s'haU,

.. ~e iiIi·ilF·· .L •. , . ~.l .. U.,I .. ~, .. ,f'L,' ,~ .. ,~ .- .... ~.~<t"' .. -.~ '~"'~- ~~~.-~ - -~---

~U a, '!'i:mnti:Ya,t1nnal ,1'Giail:,sbit of tbe fmlce,t of a. "right: actilll1{r. l~ omer eo discO'~e"\l" 'w:llalt 'dll;t. CCUlCe:,t a,ppli:es '~O,r. 'du:t ,is~ 'w.hidl a~thiJD_S are n.glu'Ol:i:I Ii, :mQti:va,tio:~a1 anallysli il nIle 'eba,t: d-eAnes 01 :~JdeJ1t_I_B,e1 night ac,tioo8 in, teul1s[ ,of: tll;c :mot~,¥'es :h-,fim~ whic'h the., 3_1Ci d!ml~ b, ,a DiiUI:4H., ,good, :~SOIiii.,i;~ The :staLrting poin,t of ItID,tti ar.D_ai'Y'Ij5, is, t!na't a,

mloi"i'F·='·ll'~ ,j)',:",~,,:il i'ti;o;''1~iI'iL'i'lil '~;:i!i: ~ili;1I""""';i!Ii; t~~~1 'f'lb;e, ~1"",l+t\!,\iI!i ,~f d)1lI1·:~', !ii}l':, 'W~

I __ ~-..iIJJ_ . 7' ~1.KJUj A-IIiiI!Ii._lf".~!II::1 II;'" V"~I!-~ UU!ll_"~ I~'J ~~,-'_:_~::I 1"_ ~~ ~_,_ .. v.!\-~ ~ ~ ~ __ II!- 1'['- __ ,~ ~ ~ _

TcIiI"i'~lroil;"t. g=; .. ,- ~'i'rklt, ,a~'t"·;:;:· ':~:8 UHe; 'dla.t 'il doOne '~r' a, 'm,oraU~' ~1Xd, nC:_~SOIi1

'"'~.LI\!!;iI'" . ·f~ 3, ,I,~~ ,C.lon I; ; , ~ ' ~ L !Ii.i!'}' , __ ;, . '1 ,~. - - lit·· u .• _"

[lih~cjJ:u\8e .Iit ,1/8 ,rigb,t, 1'1;' 'thie~ analysi!Si wfir:k;8!, :KarH,til ac'blle've,mJe_o;t :~_i 'i?O afm,\lo:-; £[[1::;' dl~'S' f~~I,t.urre. uf.Ii~1-:;lt, a(;,t~\ccn91 't,o a ;s~bSlrantiv,e 'mM:a'~, "'dod",

.. ~_;e . ,om ... 1 ,if: ... , .... , ~~., ... wn. ~. ... .., ... _,. ~ .. __ t',,~;-

p~e 'w'b'i,c-h iden:tlfle8 w'hicJb. a~!t.iO:I1i51 are n.gfi,t, :nn, omel' U>, ,a:ppmcia:~e ,th,e~ impcu:bfiCie 'D;t tbis a:c'h]e:::V\~.l'Hen:t\r. we m!u'alt, 'oMs~dt:4: i'~, :i"~, Ugh'l1. .o;~ :-1:1 '~~~,:" -":It: [-;f H'u'm-:/~ 'w'h~dll n.u'~ns '~O slu)Jw' ma't e-xacd~' '~!tdiS'

an arpuu:n G '" 1 e .. ,Il,. ,t< .. ,t''"''''., .'. ...; ~ ~____~!' _

allili'iJl)t: be dlUii,e:, TbiHS, al'l,~·m~~t gr~·Vles rise ·~o 'w'hat .1 ;shan. can. tiH'l1me~'8[ Diilemm_a.,'t~

In, O'lM'li"isl;~icm 'to the 't'ii1esis 'd~ralt th~ sen:s:e ,of dlu't~ is the O'Jll~ :mGl,i~,

~r~ " II'

'mi;"l.-4'iiuJ'!! ·H·" 'l'~(m' ',;ill! :'t'f·,D'l'll ... .-S· "",L';i'lll\' ,t~""i')L~ '~'_if.' 'lir'l·'tt· 'nn.'1'llt!i 'm·~.·~'JJ\-.:!o '!tLI'II!--'i,~'L ib" oI;I'l'!;.""'IH1''S. ~ ~ :_'V"_:~J!If ¥I' ,~,~ lW~_.~ p~«,-~-""" l~~~ II!!D~ ,~~~~, ,,~~, ~~ --=--~~.~ ,-:_________.~,,~,''''~J! ·",~l.~~~, __: '~!L-~'p.__:.

,"'Ii 'ii"ti'!il·---'·t·, i"iTi'ii .... iii'i'\.l!' ;o'lhi· •• e'oi"ri'Iil ;i!','tH iHI~(;~~t' 'L,_ "", _;i:I!:!l~..:l! if."\n '''''h~ '!I:"l·'-I'~'''' ;n;f" ... ,'L'<i!,.' g 1~1i_~e.=I[I;.·" !V.1.il1 ,g]IL11t" [A~~l'~ .• ':~j!' 1l!i!1;Y= .. ~~~~.",'~ ~ [~ ~~-r-~' .,,~ ~~~ .,,"~.~~.~~ ~-~ iUJ~J'l

''''Ii';'';*~~T'i ~ \,t'lil~:' 'm: "1""118*' '~:-. ;!;~m·. ··I<II! , n ~'h··; ii!Ii~"'" '''li''Iii~)U. 'I:',,..;~ ·ml ;:" .... :~'¥Ji!!i' ;r.r nt"i'l!1""j,",'I,,,,,,_ II n H~

!IM.iJ!I;.-II~-.;I, ~y 1 [ _ 1Y. .~~ ~ au; __ 0'''- U!li- __ ~~. [I~III_~I!I.. _I ",_11 [ __ V'W ~ ~ ~-!l r"l~~-!"!l.r~~~ ~ ~~

paiDJts 'OIllJt '~ihat w:llen 'W~ praise an ,aCi~io~ [and :t:.:egaId :i,t ,acs 'v~rul,o.U5\!, 'wie dOl :80 'lbeCil!Ia8e 'W'C ;S'UP,pose ,t'iila,t i;t ~~_as, a 'virtmalls, :m.ot_i.¥.I!. ,A:lld:~

Ti!ll!! !1mip~~, Idl!3t it'b,e :m,er;e ~e.p.'m, tn t'lI,e 'v,iLnue~ m 'the actiu" m;a,,' ~e t1he 6Dt

,-..._t~·'''-~·-' ,-" ~!b' .. =,'b, ,- -= . ..JL_ - ~'.dIi .,'b.-, '" -.,' -'n ...... d :rend' "",","" . ..1 ;'t~·, ' ... '; .... ;,c .. ; ..... '.;o; ~"'" ' ........ -''''"'"'0.''0 .j,... ",. ,~.~,ve:j' W\!iI~A;i.lJ.i,.p:r)~IlC 'l1li, I~lli(li '!II~~~Q~"\!, ,d.I!~ ,:~. I.· ",'.Ii: !IJ, lIl'I'.l!li~, ... !U!W:;;I'''' ~1iIi'''~ ~;-.., . .-, ,U~,.,

e:irr,~~~" BemM 'we [cm ihav;e; swill, ;I ir,e,ptd,j ,the: acdoJ], mJu,!,t,.lmie R.a'~h'· ·vinuQ.~!5i~ ~d t'he V,~fme m~~t: 'be [deQ!,v"'d, ,f-a:;m. ~fim~ v:il!tl1l"S m~U~; Andl con~~

;fI"~'''''!:it'', ,'il"" "'I'iit· .. , Y""I·'rt,· ;o~i"Ii';'[", 'm .. ¥c:w •• " ...... ' 1'i'rii'"~"!D)t '~"':'. ~[:·'\I;."11..,."!"f.' ',~'I'I'~.m.' , .. ,"t"", ,...,. .. -,"1IIm," , , .. , _'''''',:'' t, i'h~ '<ii, '"",'.-,:;"I' •. ~ri;.", ~!IolI!I!O;~II"'_~,,' !l..iliiL' ... ''I!', ~ . )!IolI!'Io.!IWI'iI! , .. l!<lI'''I,~',,", ~~~.I,~!L!I . l~ 'U!1lbIi"',aij"'~1b ~\I!o!'.= ~.JI,,", ~""':O"""~ _ ~jII "'"~""" "~I!;,~"",

of ,tib~ ,~tioo.!. A 'vift~~~ mo,t~.¥,~ :~~ fC'q,~~~i~ tOI :~Ild~r ,m ~ti.o. 'v:i!Iil:JOla!$. An

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Tb:.' "11\: :' -j 'r' '~:; I: '- -;-' II <' ~ :'~': r II" '~_~ I 11:- :.l.·"(~ ;" ir.II·, I.';' I; 'I~: ".- ':~ 'IL:':!~~~:' (I I: ,',:, ~ ~l_ ~L fl'j .' I.·':I-'··~' _. • :r~,:. 'Ij-;' ."

=.~U! a_r,gn_meL~;t caclil, ~ ,11''eCllSt. ~w" ~e'Lrms (b. ~.Iw_",~_n,ess, o.!ap.pase tlilalt a

d.~: [am-j,on is ~~ti3ny~ Qf 'lttJ' d~fljmt4W\ '!m~ :'''[Q'JnPt~d by' ,a :mm"'·

_'II~~, iIiI! ..... '""".~ ....... A;Io'i,."',g. 'T" ...... , ·~"-'~1i.O~ "' .... ·'h·,.I .... iIl:-- , ... '""".,i[~.iI!; .OO; ... [~ ·r.i~·:1..' .. '11'''"''''' '~'I:~I!'!!;iI;· 'I·,-lif!i,' ..... ' ~~;J' b~~' ~.uJLI~.~.'¥L"§!I ·~·Y .~~L"r ".~~~-~. ~~~~~~M'~ ~~ ._;~fJI~~ ·n!lr.r .~,_ ... ~~~~ ~~~"

- ~

w"h'i""~ ~~~·~.v""~, are Q',""M".JI_. '[Bn·Pc i'~ ·,:'~iiD enlv 'i:7t'i. : ..... ~. m ..... ~i''''''!11· :"";[![ ,~iL~ ii!!:il!;'i'lil~" ,~;t

.. =~.j !'_f_.ff~~·~ _ ~~ ~~ I!r.' ~~_ = -~~ ~Ii, ~_'JI~ y~. 7. ti¥~ ~~~= ~ II!r" J_A;!I t1;J[I;'iir.~ ~I!r.il:;lg~ uJ

_. _ .. ~.

~,hlt\~- ,the-,ll 'Wl! do i~ 001 Diet tL'b~ 'ldnd [of ¢~'f;Cle; 'Bl'IlUllf; des¢~eibe':~ 'he,) -:-

"_ .. _~ '~i' - -, .,- ,~ .. "_:I •••••• __ l .,- .. o. , . __ I. 1 - - _~ •• -.l .. ]_ l. _ f •• [ll . I •••• - ••••. n , _ I" .:Ie-.

I ~-.·~··'-[i-· '--·'1..;1-"1 w -h ..... 'C ,~\., ',.'""'i'If.,:-:. :··,-:-··d·1 :1,11 .. ·C~'[1 w'l,.((: ·:-bl:··(·:·' .. [ '~'-, .. -.- .-r ... ·~·I·,---:-,·-·,;, ~\~h,--

W,ilBtt. ~u y,;(;,~, ,at liS: .n~iI,t ,an .. ,iaSiil1i;, yOU... uiiliit t .. ia~. U:;. ~iIi,CU ~.~, , me,;, Ilfjout.

,lcltinfilS ,;u~e m@sed'cne ]'[us1t: becar~s.e they a.l'~; rj[tf'b.,'t. :UCfW earn, ~I d!C1iv'ei

~ ~:I

aiDY I~Uj]itent .from th];s:~' fi;e o:b~c.c~ion :m.a, be taklm tIDl be ,ijJJ 'y,clSi;Cfi [D'f the '~'·em~t.v· fiO:fffialilsm it o'~e:cdQIi,- fio,T' tbe; 'nrific~~~'~e ~~dC]1 dlie d~kit

"- - . ,- - - ir' l' .1 ~, - - - - • - 1 " • U-I· .... - .. , - .~l •. - - . ,rt 1 __ • , .~l •• , -"." - - I.. , -6'~1J

tbi'i'iil~' ·be.:eause :lit -is[ the ri,"'kl~: th5fiif:ii ,1~nea'f;S· 'l(:O be an elBi'i\rv f:O:UflijJJ'l-

" &-_III,~1 .. , .... l .. _ ,. . 1 .. __ " 16-1:1 . ~' -'LfI"r. _ I.~ '" ••• " l., __ ;~'.'.' ll ..• ~ 1

h~:m-. A~(_om:"'''fi;~ t~[ H"lJime. 'I nee-d. 'nUln: biif!lt'm.adon a'iooU't 'wbich acts

=r. __ ,~ [J I"..... l. _ -J-IUl,e . .. I l. _ _ _ _ • [~l _ j •••• -"F. ... 1 1 }. , 1 _ _ _, _ •••• _ 1 • _.. • •• _,., w w [ __ f .• '. _, • , .• .- ,

~r;e 'vjl'it)UQUS OJ'' 'fidj·lfr;.t befrcfl~ Lean do 'dl,em 'wi'tb reO'~iro. '~O diei'[' 'Y-"'fitlle

._l" .1_ •• _,- •• _ ••.••••• ~_& .. " .. f .• l ... , .. __ , "_ ... __ I -._, w~.l"_ l ~_l._. ".-. : "-._'J ~l_l.,'_.-.

,i'l"":" 'ori .... ·.,ltf'i'li· .. C!i!\_ '-T"~i.e ~·1t'i'!i.':W~l ~L,~ ii'i~a:,A1 ~:~, ';~I ''i'ri''ioll'ir; l: sense. 'W-b··,il ... r;. 'tiiill'il]-'~1

~I [ll~t;.I:~LW:Il-'_gg r. [l lJjll_~~ I~(~V w w!Q l!r_l[l~, ~IL"f~-~Y ~;\J!~ !A. L'_'_"J¥~~ ~-""~Il~'J! w w • __ 1~-~IL.l ~ llL _Wl

, .. iffii· ... b-il~l iIi'litl '''I..... n-" ·~l. ,;i'\il;~:i- "'~:" 'Iir·.'i""I'llii'!iiI'~IS. 'iIi'ri?iI"!It- "'~~_;j!;! ·w.-,h-t;ro·'L., ~,~1 ... , ,;;ti·ii'".'iit'\iI'\I: ,i!i'

I!;,;1I11_Gl_ .,iII""", '!IoI-'1iJ! 'IOU ,t,'\Ii -iI!ii., U!IilIiJ"UiIi'!;'; "I'll, !l.MU''-'I! . ,lIi1i1i!U. 1 '1'."io;.OZl' .. .Ii!l.:"u "'1I11_QA\" A!Ir",IJuDa

righ,t. ,And ·tbe :~jOlal ~se must ,app,m'Y'e moti,,,'es· nt'be-t 'dla~l 'd1e

'-C---,--,ji{V'lIiiI· ,.~~ ,.J1Tf"V ·~·--l -;-,~.","C' ,f\;-. '-.-_*' -.--: -C-C'.-, ~·'-:-I;i;--::-·,f, ,'-n"-· [i·h--·,--: ii!I::-~--[i'-'--:-C'1 "lj"1..'j;[i!i[ ,mlG'l-il.: '!;,r Oil: Yi~·"\f.r .~n Olw;-'I ~e ,ge:I". sOrrJ,C" OD.l][,Cfl" ,~iI .. ,~D [,. e !iI!''f,s,.-em,;, JI"L'II"

·~'-'_·;!j;~e::i:i;. 'ii~;c!: 'w~':il*'i7 ,a- ~!l"~I"'_-m--)'m--; ,;jl_ ~~. Ujj~ r.-'-~~*a--'I[n-C'. ~'h-:J~ ~J"~i!ii~iC! ~'i..:,",;j. ].,,~: ,i1iC![ '~J;ffIiii;h]ij3is-[

JI~"l·lP.'· A~ !IIII_~ .. ,ill, ,,"_III, ,~_ JI~t~ _, __ g.ll u: 'H"'" ~ "'-' ~II_ _ l. _ !I.i"l Yl ... "_III_,;r. 1._J:.LiIII!IIr. .lll. III_'IJ! ,IIIJ.I.oI.l!lY!'!!IIi._lIl·'P.' IIir. .

,tb.a"t [e5!sen'tiallly m_ak'e ·iCt'lC-DS :ri.gh.t~, i~. ippi1lr-en't·~.l\'· ttliJU$,t be :tm,o·t-iV:es

""",,",'Il., -. .'L., . , -- -··c--, -d'i "'"",, -. ,..-i .... .:." "- - -.-,.-, ."----. -.1,1[ ·0---:·· c -;h. - .- ,-.'ii.. .: -- -. 'i.. -. c .041 ,t· ,-. ,-, - --'. --

I~et ~nm, 3, ,r.e:,gB _ ,1JU'1 ,!t~:t!-ne5S nseu,,, .'_.0 11: __ e 100bd~_r nana, ~I: we are

,to· ittSli'm. the dl;esis· di8,'[ ,the primarlJ' :~(Jtive 'of 'vi;n;UD'il8 a~dfin, :~s the 'm@!tiv'e of: du,t"" 'Wt@: 'mU5[t' halVe some 'Wi/V of '~d!ent±~"i~l'IliLl' [illY' d,eniI1il'i'iIP'

, - , ._ •. _-, _' _ •. ) I. ,~~l ". _ ,_ , - _" I - - . ,_. - _ _. I~ • ., t.- . J - .I.J·, ·i&l-~Cl •. • I. , ,- - - -"---01

'~'""~I.· ,;j;~:i"I':""'ioJIoiC'!, -W":·lIi;-l'·t!:·~' d)·I~iC! nl;rjL"~iCiI"~'d:' ~~ ~;~'~~f::' ft:ji.iIj'ii~l;'iii':fi''"',

,1J,~~~la", ~~L. '_U,d._~ ... ,iIHI, 1Iir_IHI, ~ iI"L!\.:t!l.1 U,~.!I.r.Io1I ,Vail_oil IUI~1II iIolI_lIt'?lJ.l111._ 'J! ~ r.

Sen;ti.mmta.Usts[ o~tred :w:r the :m'O<dV',a'~i~na1 ,a.ifi1al'fsi;sj but ,at ,I eoS[te

.r' ~

On "~me ,atlld. H'U'ttch,eso:n;"sl \riew~, w:bat 'ren,de~[ ,actions 'ritt~o.:~s, ·i.S 'Q!J'_[

a-P.pw,v,.d of '~'l'te na'tru':Ia'I, d~-'CtioM wilt!ih m1J~tj.v,!J;~e '~he-l1l, ,;:I;l1d '~h~ ale· ac ~MdJ~'i'iIj)'·tl~.- t'be r,pm~SIt: 'v-"rt!aO'~S[ 'mOrd¥es - i~ 'lin 'ltl'ume!'s[ 'nbfa!Se.-. III

. -, tJ! c., .'L, -~-"~-e)ll'l .-- -- ~]_J. ._ .. _ ... , __ .. _l,.· ," l __ l.lll. f····[rt __ l._ ... " ......

mt)lf"dly :righlt: atti;on. Th.i·s leads[ t-o two :p1'obJitm:s:\! of)e tQ~c.eming ,tIbe faet of [oblipti,on, and t~he IGdler' ooJ1(eming: the S'e41se [Gf~ o'b]lp,tlolJj, or mot~i,v~ 1D'1: d!1l.tJ~. :1: halve .11'f[e:ady· ,mee.!clo:ned !:he pr(lble:m, [oon<;:~m[n,g; 'tlhe

f\i!lh"~ ~oii:' n'~l·~,.,~t· '~""n Th- ... ,g. .IH''';'''~'I"1I1ft ~s !1:!'I'!In'I'!iO·~~~ ,,,~ he ·n",'''',., because '~""',

~:~_~II!!, ~_I [~g~,~~~~,~t~ =!! • ._:,~~ I~~~~t~~~ .~_I ~~.tt-.~ ::_-~~I ,,~ ___:.~ '~'~iI'~)'l 'I.J~~- __ ,~-~ ~_. L",",'~,

.. " - .. ". ,·.P., .-.-i!'", . '8··' "', ." -., ""n:""'" had .'. he -- -", --.' .-. d,·li,(-:t·-, ---c, •. '11: ...

a P,l.'O'Y'e: Jh.-S .mO!!-lil ve;, .l__UI~, W~ m~~;1!.",~ ~ JIlQ, W'f!,' --,eel]:, ,g.vell. a __ ~, _ ~)CJe.eI~:..J!.y

~ ..... t"i;;i.'!i'''~·''''!I'!;'''''"':;.:I ·m-··IIi"i~~l ;r!_,;r!;;i;!, L'~'~'\iI:Ii' a'l'!ift~.'\il:li11 '~~C:'U'~"';!:!oI!'!;.' m· .... i!i';'JjO\i:!j '''!;'ft-~ iC!iO"'~ ~-~c~~_~~l~,~~ ~I .1 v_!t~,~ i~~~~~,~, 1tiI·" ~ I_'.F.~~''Y' ".~-~ ~, u.~~~.~-~r~"l I~ ~ __ II#-~~,''I' ~ ~Lg, ~.: ~I

~.::,u~"\j:I;n·!Il' ,1Ii[ ... !I\"i[ .... H; iC'.n , ... '~~ ,i'!Il .... ,il .... ~ ~,[!, 'li!I;;i"O!Ii" 'n DlI"!,",,'Cl,cj~;,o~'f,~, ,.,;[ .... 1..iii' ·1D,.,.,i!i' .;h·,D'''''1 '[''<iii' ,~iC!, ~U_~I~~!I!Ii!i_--= l~ ~-~{~~-¥.t_IIi~-!' ~.~ u-~ @~{L~'bI'~, ~~ ,~_~~~. ~:_;~-~~_~~:~'~I!.,~ ,~,~I!'~'!i ,ut~~, I,~_,~ ~_.dll, ,I~ ~l ,~~

'L~'~I '·l •• ·.--<: 'If;- ... :.".~ ~-_' I 'L .... (.L,,·:,-\-I.,-,:.'A'~I.~·iIf--'~li·--';':' ::-:;-C~;j;;'"~'i'" ':~-[""'i'fI'il!i! ,[j;·Ii;o'.-llt--· ,'"!-, n.-af.'U !I.,O see ,liI'oW b. can 1m- OiUJ1;gIJ.0irf •. n.l~, Ol(lI1p,~nl"J lac "l{[,IiI, ,~s ~ .. ~ "Iilil. .IS

b-:l"'li1'r.;ll'i'l'liIP'.""" A'1Ii""'!, '."Iit,;!Ilj, ,it-, ~,C!! '1[fI;"'_~e:~;C!iC'!,;!!J"' t-~[ -41tj!; D'ii~I,j, ,V ~;'i..-,,!~ .;!i"'1':~.il~iifIi ~;ICJ '~n;i': n--~l"\ti'iaJ;;.

1J-IIIU_lIL~~Ci' UIJ_~!Iir. !I..nla}", ,II,. I ,~~ ,1J_~['Iir.-~- .1:l!1il!!M_.I~' . {U ~u. lU~lilrl 111.1; lli._J~L1Ir. ~~I"'_Ii-~II_lIl llA" III_-Jb-V1" 1 _ ~,~~

iC!';!i;O-'"111-yc- n- -"'Iib- -jii;. 'i..:O--ijjji' r~'ln ~,ii; t., .... 'njlr,;tiIiC!iC!,all~--' ,;t,n, .JI ..... ~ r'i'n:n- 'ii;ii:ii-'lpo· -'i"!i;1'J~~ 'ill~II';t,Di_ ",,·III;j·i!!i;i;~ !il!W~ :'1 JJ. " ::- i 'l: '" l]li'~ ''FJi' '~"'IH. 1I ~ ~ IH.~-'lir.Illr.D!g& -'., ~u U-oI:' Y!IJ!'l: ,"~~u I.:_ .~ .. ~ ~'. " ~ : ~~'_;I.~LAI;..:"I.gl

. ,..;' , .. ".. .~I . i . _,.. •• , , t.. ,- .- ... _ l~: -. •• r. " •• _ -. _ 1'" J. _ ~,' 1 _ 1 • - _ _ _ - ••

Copy rig hted m ateri al

49'

.' I

, ... "

:malk:e~ ,s. similar lobjectl1oo. to e-x)t~maUsm .. Ii ,~'h,e mo;ml :mrot'irve :is ;5im;ld.,

.i'1iI.·iI"i':"' .... ,,:',··:I] ,i'1ii~ ... [.i\ ... ilri' j!!j~r.lil'"'~' ,i'1i,i!1 ·~~~! .... ·~~;nil"·"'~L w~; "'i'1iIiffi' :~i'1iI~·II1l!' 1..1 ... ''''' ... ··~ii''i; .;:-.b~·~"I~l"ti,.'" iIIIi ,IIG,,,,tlIfw iIIIi1i];.'!:":U:U.1I. !il!Uvlil 8_" ~,ul ... ,,.., U~~"'IJli"""'1' ~ ~ ... '!w !PI'_I I. 1.'!ir!Pl'_U" cUlii ~ """ ,IIV 0: .1lI_~;:,~

tions. "o:r how' C(fO ,the~e 'k~ an ohUg~t;iGfi 'to :hl.ve; dle :f:Jlllld,vie \wni.eJh .,v'es UlS, ID'hli,galt]!:imS,~ And, hO'w' e!ilJ~, we 'he~ o.:bUgf.'d, eo 'peR{J(Uln 'dle ac-

';i~ i":W:'!i;i!O. 'i'i1in:~iIiIi<!iiifil ~ •• :~'i!' .... 'L.'I]:',d\ .... ~ '1i1' ... 'I.. ... '!Ie ..... ' 'i"Il., •. '_~+".~.iI; ,",1... "1i'i; n._,.;!iIi'i'''_' ti'h-'.-':~' 'Ii~ ly-Ui .. JI:_ ..... i ~~IBI~-~ '~'I!' ~ ilYl~ wUIj.~~, ~-w ;[~.~ !\r' ,,_~J!_~J ~,~~-~~ '¥ I!r." I~~~, lr"~~u~-~~ .~ __ )!rILt~1l ~ [J_'~

'i,t :iJllllot: :n~S&l.'~ '~@ ha'\''C the mOiti'v~- i'~, '~!l not reaH~' 'fii,eoessa""· '~Q

J •• r. [_r •• _r •• " ••• - •• - - __ 1i01 ... _ .. _.~ ... _ ... ~ " .. ~ "''if' .j. ~_ •• _f" ••••••.• _ .• _~,.. [_r" ••••• ·•· •.• __ ._],,, •.• ~

c~onn ,dIe aotioAI-~5 :Be.bhld ibM_b, ,ob1eCi~iollJ$ is 'd~e ,~.d)~a t'l1~IIlJt: the!

,~-.I~i}.t f ••• _." ••••• _.r. ••• -. __ - __ ••• _ "._.~ •••• _ •• -~.~ .•• ~ .••• __ =. [:.-~ ~ . ~ _ .

'~~'~t:lless ;of an ,a,e'tion ,camnot be e.oXtdns;icaUu c.ufJf·e~d1-, 'U: i,t. :":8 ~I'C~S-

[&~_IJ. __ j.""., ._ . __ J • _f. _ .- r ••••• _ .J •• j". ":_1...1 ·.·_:J.·Jl" •• _.·~,..:l 1.lr [_ .

1~1Q'ry .f;fiI:'·W eo ,hav'e~ 8, befj,e~v.,Q~,enf.e~"'ta,piPmri~g mnml :SeilSe '0:1': 'hene'Yl]"" :len!t: :mDt!iVe.S~ dDSI :Hi;.uist 'be '~D,'U~ 'henevU:I,e,fi't. a.ctliJfi ifs :intnns:I,caU.y ,o\ll'Ip.'bl)t}t If: benev,olentt: ,acti,ofi IS :mnt :mtnnslca'Hy oblig:.iUD1Y, dler-l :neither an, u'b:~,tr;trily :~mp.bD.ted mo:ml ,semse fiOJ1" dliSo;penSilible n3itrul'isl ,aHeetio:m.s, oau 'mll~e :i,t .1"

,As 'I'h.ese iSl1IUimen.'ts. S:l!iIa:eSit~ dl!e ide,s, dl1tt ,~Ye are: iil, ,fa,ct: cJb:Hacd. :15 :na,turally IIISOt~a,t~. wit'h, ~bc~ :Id.ea that w·e 5h~utd act fmm tne mo·, tive: lof: 'Db]~'litii"tiofi. 1:'0 be ol';liliail. '~D t'b,e '~.rlo.:f.mamc:e of: 1m a,ctiom, is, '~m

~ ~ I~ .~

'il._"".11." ••• " - .... 'I!.., :.' ,"t' ,'.- . , ......... 'ii..t·, ." ..• ,' .- .: .J] , • .-. ,e, ..... d' ,~- ,i)!,. '.'", 1:"' \ --" ,'I~,:,.,;I _ ~

~!leve U1IIJ., If) , 1!i!j!, lSi ,iI,~iI" aO.J!om, ,amu eo IUl , llZ i',[J\(i1IL l'iaGL, ,;iii, ..unu, 0:1l:

:m~thiaJtlQn.aI.lleoeS!si't.y:: ,tb-e ,actimn.iS: ,caUed fOI" or ~eman.decl 'Illy' 'ltl.e ,sl,'Dlad,oJl.r ,in;,~l tba't :is t;he m,oti've ,1'0([' d:Oi'nig it:. ,And t;his, t):dngs us '~O

'iii:Lcto. ;c'!,;a,;i!!Glift,.J 'n ...... 'I!.·'II.:.-m '~'-" , .. 'Le·, ;!'~,ii!:!:,~t "I!I'~r'-"~I'Inu: ,eo. m- ...... ~""\tI;tl ~~' ,-'1; , ,000''''' __ '~·I .. ~LiI;a,

!I!!~l~ ~_~-UJ ,r'!!!!,'!Y!~~~-_·_:·~'!J ,~ ~~t'~ ,~",~- oil ~,~ •• ~I~~, ~ ~~ .~ .,_l~\I._~.''I' ~~' ~ .-W:PJJ-~.~!g~/~

,--,,·-·i"il'ii "-:1' - - ' •. - .... ,- ,;.,'I!..'-" ,.,'t. ... ," -- ..... " .. --- -. """,~ ..,.' ... .1.iii,g-.cdli-" .... - ,''-'. '(Ii" "~".-: ,.' .-.,., ' ... - .... -.' .-,

,nl,I~,~r-a_1 .m !!!.'lV€!S... u~en !I,~~e· mJ;;l'!!ion!'·e 1!;!!.1 ' ..... Iiil'J;~,'~'l'Iin. ,mUi~h., .'.~I,Y I,,,, ~i~h, iie

:sec"O'n~"""I""'l' llD'~.e:

~ .. ~,-.~,-._. ~' __ ~'I)'j _ ,,_, _--.11

H'i'ii'tcihemn ,aCiOOl\~ir~Ji'I'l,v dis:nn:~sses, 'mm,t' of' 'w'ha't is. said 'O!Jj'l.1'rUt

[, ~_ ,_-,~-, ~-._.-.~-. I- -.~,.~.-.~. !I,II"-ll"" .. ~ .. -_'~ _.-,_. , . r ••• _ '1-1 .~. J ". .. .~. _. - t._ J ~!UW,~ _~

o:b:H:v~tJom as '~~',cO:~5ed,.~' and ,~w'D'bsoln~e. rId; 'W'hem 'We: sav' ,mm..eon..e

... _ . ..-r_. _ . J ._ ., •• ,',. ,- •.. _~ J •• _. e _' ., •• ,,' - - _, •• j. ,~., 1:J,! _ ..•• _. f.~ f.~,

:1$ ,mQtoaU,' ,obliged to· an a,c{U.Qm, 'we :mem onJJ.y' dlit: t~h..e :mDJ';t'~, :selse an~¥~ tie' iWt5..of::i': dlalt tihe:re 15 iii '~~·s;U:Si."j.'J:1,t7 'l1:~fi tikI it'_~'1> We

. r~i . ... .. - r.. .-". _ r. _ 111 ••• _ _. •• ~. _ •.• _ JJ¥. _ .. ~~ [ ,_. _ ,. J • Jr. ••• ,

ale 'not t'8Fki!n~. about eK.iCi~~'"'i7- or moti'Vat1rD'p! rea,j;!nns The. ,tw-n:

, ~'" .• ~ .. ~.::..J._, I_~~~~., __ -_~ I __ -; . .:.,1_ J,_ I_::.-_-t_'::,,-~.!I'O .:: ' ... llt::.,_~·.·. J,~_,_:~ •.• ~._~~_,._.~ .• , .•. ~,~I"_, ._ •..•.. ¥.

P-llrts 'of the 'RO:i"J]gt~Vi't.v of' 'Moral'ltv ·~,t;s "ower tn 'bj'mA] or '~1IIJ5ti'''"''

_',~_ . .:.:. .. J l~-_: __ ,~I,~_.:. __ .. ~. __ ~~_J.~~_, .,I_,,_.,. '.::._~'. ,~·~:__.:.--.~_~~·-.~\I·:l ,I,._~, Jf:__ .... ~ __ , I_-f__:" __:..,_:~~~ ._-_ ~l~-_·,~~-~",7~

and .1'IS, ,ow. '~O ,motl\tl,te" ID'I" e;.'lticl.t~ :hive ,s~pariie't-e :SD'UfOe5,,, Dut~,

H·I'~I'I'ii..iI"'"'I!.;::.;fC!.....-n oii'"_~'ftI!I!n'~' ~o!I;'i.p!;~. ',:' )~J~~~~~~ __ ' ~-~~.r'~~~.~i!J

'ne :pI-Oi,~ect m die plea&~ of ,~Lf;ilP,p~~'bat~, :l~, :~Iit~ g~eg i!lJ mg.~~.\!Ye itol ,cJn:oos¢ ~~: ~th:rll. f!l!t~h~if rth~, anOtih~I'JI 'I!Jlalt; tt'~, ,$:I:1,"~~S th~ .mal :sm~t~ 01.' de-t~l'mmadD 't'o ,a.,nI'O'Y'e nt'IiGI' 1.0 du:e; e:le:otton ~9

• - , • r. ,r. . _ _ f. _ f. • _ , • r. • • ;t.\t~i . . . ~J ~"'H.{. • '" , _ _ _ • ..-, • _ _ II

Copy rig hted m ateri al

I~t~ m~'1 M1. ~'he .l~~;]llie m :m~I~a1jty' nt ,diut;y' :proo~~e; ~, !!I~th4tIru,f w:ithg~t alQ.,' mh~~' :m~ftVG;~ 1 ;i/ru)W~~1 It; mil,Y::: Illit; du.!5, WSi no' obj~~t-].Gn t~ ,the. ~Pf~it,

;1.;- Ojioi"!. !it,". 'iI\'lI''', , 'u .. :~n...~ ".ft '~_'!I'I'.' 'H.,iI;.~,'Pii'.I!I"I"''; .. ~: 'iI!, 'ftII;~." .1~~1.... ""',',.'!. il\l'llil .. '~iIi'ri'oI"~t:rc!i~!';>;' 'i;.':;eo;, ,;"!;ry~fM1o~1 ~I~ 'L.~I~I~,o'!;fH; Yr"Pi.l'-'!i.'1..::Ilol .l ILIllIIii.1 "" ll}J~-.IIJ", "'~.l" '!!" "~I.L.~!IiI_'a! l"LL~I,U~_ L!I'!""" V·Jb Y',"ll:III.III!Ir.-III,r.lj..,. ,,_iii! "'-IU,"_I11:~_"_I::L-'~'lnl 1II.lIllI] .I::IJ~_III_LL""I~"J

ga!t~ffili' a :f'e~~ wb.o ~Is. tis, ,hoean dev~ld, of 't~'1! primc~p~.et. :Ina,' :baite hWM~'U '~:pwl, ~ht ,3c:C~1i1In1~, ,iim.d: llla:y ~~ri"nrm, th~ ,:ict~(in w,lth(t!lII!t~ tl~ :rumt~,vel' hom.3! CE:I1'a!i'll, sense o:f d11!lit;Yi, in Mdcl' tOI aOq)lI'i'w by :p;rKti~el' that V;i;f;lJlI1:0IlS pf:tiftci,~le.. Ot :art~ le!a!t.. tOI ~~s.e ,t~ him~lt d, Much, illS :PJssibte;, b~s '~t ,0£ it;.~~

In 'both a(}cO'~o;tS\il 't'h~ mJ(Jd¥~ ,0£ ;O:bUg.:a-80n is riooru~dJ to a. d~s:bre; :((If

~.;iIIi:llf"I~Jr'n'lfii'1ii\!!\~l_, ~"" ic ,o1l~!C~ifri; "I'.,.dr1'1'i." .... .f.I. 'tiO; ,011, ;£!oiII\ en rn.Jl~,r·'Ii'''io1i; 'mll:iif!i.-"'·· .. II m ..•. .,."i'~~\i(jo, ..... ~iF~~ifi'i'li

_ ~-J--= P-,~rt_" v ~ P-. ~~ lll~ ~-~ ~_~r~ [I ~ _ ~~~ _I!.!" P- ~~~~~U ~P-~~ l __ .vlI1D.:1 .~~_~l _ ~~ _~~l-u, .. _ .. J

from rs:po:n;t;l:'l1ii,ea~$ natural aH~cda~, is nlK:lW aiU'dlJe.nt~~aU" v,b:tUt}U8.,.i.iil 'This,.is [OOD1U';~liY 'fill th~ 'widfi]'11,~&ha]l~d i~, ~hat ('bHO'.a'~i~ll is een-

~',., " ~

-\"Ii;~ ""~ Hj'ji;"!'i t':"Ii 'II [iII!'¥'rut.,..ip.}ri~<IIi~_ ,"'('ii"1i, ,,..'Ih·. at 'F'~;iIIoj~-" "Iiil':'l'l! ,i"Iii"i'. '~;iIIi.~Ii:'lii: some ·";i!Ii.t·C'j!ii'i.-~~ 1'-_lillil_l] Ir.U ll~IJI~"l~_I, ~~'!'IIr.-IIII~~IU}~"'f D_I_IIU !Li- __ .al.. ,"_IHI~-II!W "_~I~ 1IiI~ ll~Qa:!I. ~v.> __ ~ !II~. _IIV..I_I_ii:f.

wb~~ OU'iT~,t to 'be '~':-eriO-lll'1!ed ,from t'be sense 'that t-h~' ate o:bl'~Iitl'i:'ilit:())TV:

.. -:. - - •. ". ~~.. r.. -. If' l.. l - - I l - - - I • - : r ..... - - _. - - - l., - - -~,,.. . - ., . • .> - .... 0- - ._1 -t •

Nt.rw' :in [OOf: own '!re1lUl!f.Y· :~.t bas beem, ,1Ii[j;Ued, 'that W\e Sihould. ,a'bafidnm, these ~deacS .abomt ,["b:~ili:3itlOfi 'Ill her -[amoos. 'IQ~',Hi nail1liP-;t ,,-;'Mode.m

. --"- .. l -. - - .. -.' .. I. • .,~, • - • - • • " - _. l, - - _. _. , 7"J.I". r-· ,r-~- ,~ .... - -_-."_

MGfial. PhUosopbly/l' !Jicabeltb. Anseom'be argued 't'M,t ~ht :mGJ:,aj, 1~~.,tlJ' md, ,tl~·,obl'~don.'1 ,Ht :spet4'nedly modem, :motiOM ,tD~'U~ cJassi'· ,ea·l. ",~noson11,eis Ilt,,e Ads'fJmtle did ve~' we:~l W.~,t'hDUlt. ,Msot.\mbe

r-i lr-i - _It -

,claIms, 'tlha:t 't'~e-Se' irdeBs, ,illire :ma1tJutaJ]y aS8oC:~ilU~d w,i:t'~. ,a, dl~,V,lfi.e law'

.c:-.;- -.- .. c:-.-.-.'.,*.- -:- -'1';: '-;"~'"~l ,-.-:-.;111 .;,-~, .. ;.,1..,~ l":I~ '.--:-,.' '.- .. - .. ··l ,-,:t •. "'-.' c:-.----::-.c:-.--:-,.-:'; - -:- '-l·~·c:-:-~L

'oonoe,'~I{Jn 0., e,tilill!CS,~, anu, 1m, me aUlJISmOe Oili; t[iliil!l [oont;'eptlim1(~ ,a;CiI\,

;Se.~~· :i~. S."mt'I;;1' (;har~s, bave ~. 'made mare 'reo~l}d\f b-~' liemaJm,

... . __ " II [ .. __~\~..... . __ . . -' , __ . _..~ _ 'L '" .. ~' , __ . L.

'W~~_IUa_m_s, tn 'e'bJe [a'st [ch~jn~' [Oof h~!S beek .!l'1u[~s and: dll~ Lim:i~~' ,of

:rcJtt:.'~~l:"'; ',1.,1<. ;~.~ 'n, "'F ,A ... ;'-, , .. ,iii,. ,·,-11 ·1'F'Ii.Iil.,.i:1I.. ,t ." l~; '.' '~,' .' :.iIi'_. "iF •. '11,

,:j!r.,uJ'1_ 1000'0P:\Ii.'," . ,W!UI!. nrl~tlm_lU~ ~.t !a!~~jJ_'J'~,~_oII~~i) ,iiJ! .,",~ eX~eIJjh,,-.!i ,IIISO

'W"III'laJms,· wre an '\mnaRafllt: assumndo:n ,~!,r'~tb du~~ir 8le-Dt~'m~lltal~at

. . ,I .11 '1' . . .. . .. , ,I .. r· .. ,. . .. . . ',r·· , .. , .. - . _ , .. -- _I. . . .. .. . . ~. ..

p\fedeoesSO'f15.j1 [or ibot'h 'belildJ ,t'o ,t'himk '~'ba,t dl~.e :pamary .~JOif1Qe, of: S;a,yin,g;

.. ;Ii!..... ,~, 'bL'~II' ,..:,j A 'Ii!..~. 'Iik.", -. '1I1i 'L .. , ~ ..:Illi'Ii' ; ... .J ' 'iL!.. .JII

'~~,t .I. am, Ou,~lg,ei;t tD ~() iso.met~uJiI;g .['S! 'l[~Ui!t I wl~~. !IjiC '~r~t~~~, :pURtS~lieu~,

'L'111~..:I ~'Ilil 'Ll' __ .'illt 'Iii 'Ii· d . '~,:. .L~ • " _.'1..

g;ljaim.~ or w:u_ ~J.~me :my~~, 1J[ ~. ' • ~ n(lt. u, ,It -S, ,em1pria;S:~s 1;$ [~3irac'i"

'tierisil:ic of. 's@filtim@nti3H~'1'lII'Ii vthic'b co:~st[Wots 'm.(m~d-itu f'rom the

._._:_-_.:__.~j_J~..:. ~cJ ( . ..:.-_~_~~._:~~--_j__:_,~_~~,~ .. L~_._-J~, ',,:,-:,,:,__!~_'_~J.~.,..:.-.:-~, ,__;-'-__:_c----:-}~.·-~ll' , __ )~.__:_._:_:J l_~__;_c"::,,

Sil!aiMnnjnt Of 'I!Jhe rs~t3;tDr' Of ]"udae t;akin'" 'tliJ6 ml'ecfll(m§l,m :an~l!m'v\i!lJl

[-,,_:-__:___.--,r~-L~·__: .,:__:~, .J_-.:=. _.,}--='--=' . .:_'.__!-..:..: __:, .:__:~. .: .. ----.G-~I l.:_.~ _ _:_~~ .--__!~ ~ -.~:_: _,-._L_-:-~._:__ .. _:__-__:. -F,t,__!··:.!. .. ~'I;!I!!:_:

and diSa1,prov,'II. as m~ ~(1Iu.re~ ,~f Q,ur :fnoot hlndame:~,tiIJ :mQT'.al, 'OOJli~p~ 'u.()Jl.l~., For ,~, ~s~~t~:nlll(!!1l!,taU5!t, dl~ ideca: ~f oblt~~a;t-i~n C~~, 'G'.nl~' ,a;ri'5e b~

~ ~ ,. "

,', II' .- ,,', .. -.' ,..:1"1 -, . ". c ,: ... '11 .,(-.- '''i,' .-c··;. th .. - :- .. -:[~ ~I.."i! 'E.-;. ; ,-' 'I'-'~(",·-: .-, -;~I' ~: '~ .. = . .-, ''-'~'. '·i:' ,'. ·;h·:

N~l.Q u~~.p,p:m¥~. ,~'St. t, . e 5e"'.l!ii:. . J::'fir:a, ,li1!UODilliw15t., ,fil.owe:verj t .. e

IOOlWS, on 'rnhUga:tlon eomes m:flm, aiD ,agefit~ccfi'~ered or d.eUbe:rad.\lye ~mfiecdvle· no.t: '&om 'tba'l\ !OJ ,the mora:] ~u.;l, ....... ·, The nnmQlftf' [W:J.-ibefij ..

r-- 1 r ,- , - ... -I . . 1 - ••.• - L - . I., . _.. - - I ••• I. - I rI· iUfi-~ . - lr" l - - - _"I"· .... _ I . _ . I

dr\j!"iC f:Oree oJ sa:yl;m,g fi! arm o':blil~d 'tc~ do ,t'i1iist,·r :~s :1l.CJt: "I w:iU 'blarlne m"seU if I de :m.o.t:U but #m:r '~dpJle:Il,t w,t it: is Elpt: :i:m;pcls, :me; ,to do

Copy rig hted m ateri al

mj8 •. :i.}~6. And, dIiis, is at leaset: Iell!~:ed! to an l@lder' '~'ilutu!lg)b:t:1t wlWe'h, ,IS ,loUiild, :m, the c]asslc.al ,p:h'ilos~phe:r.s", Ms,M-de;Jii5 pemo:[i, ,O'f 'la,(~~i,C'Sil 'wisdom, does, the 'V,m-!U~lU'S QCdOll, for ~itl ,own, sa'k,e and. ff)'r the 8,d'lir,6 of dl;g ,DiilbJ18 [rW m'lmll.~&!' He !is :m~d rt{J' act: by' ,arm, ethi,c:.al'C)jtwaUJt;,~ ,3 mOf'fll 'ibearl!iiitJ and :FifJ'i);lli.'~, 'wbi,ch :~e sp,I1enemd.\s .m the ,a~U,o.m~ H:e docs :~mt :([I)crely aret 'Qn, some 5 ponr,t'3if1t!UIiJis' na:tlurw, IiiHeeUCitu 'w'bi~h s~delim<e 'ir~Jul!,es applaud. ~iI, .ADd i'his elemcoJt 'Gf: :rmflloil ra.ctl~n,"""· this .1§'t.riI1c of how :I:t, ~,OQts, :&GlD, the agent's PD:i'fi,t Of 'v,~,ew ~ essenJiiaUy dfO,pBi out: ,ol: S-ent-rmPJi".ali8m.

'n.ls, bad a greart: d,ea'[ ·t'Q dfJ,~, I l\)el'l/ti~,e" ·wj;~h. :k,eep[rng ,a'hical t,8iilOna1.-,

~,Jtiim~C-I ;ilill- 'i~,,,,, ~Tci' ""~iI5!' iI5!~ liii'~~""":.i'i"I~'I;" lif!iP,ftf~!·U--TV 0;:-:" 'n m--:;-'''llii'"'ti'' '~~'iffIJ"':;: U'i!~.\I1"~'Lp.Iii~n- "", ... ,.ll I.;-~ ,_, - [11.' ~~,.,,~ ,.J..IJ"1 'url~ ~W_I:~.~]I ~;&"/'I!- _ ;a;.ITIr. :__.lIHI.· ~ ~ -~~-~'1' .r=~~~) .. _a.,. Jj:-:-~~} .. ~_]lt~-~·~· [~~u

Fiumte:'!s, attlQ,c.g om, Iml, l;a£;10ml1sm 'weclic ,e.Ke(o;ti,Yie! ,aDd .Lttler.' ta:ti,o,,' .f:J.a]I:StS~ 9iuc'l), as J~hn, 'Ia]p,y' ,WId Rj,cJfia'rd. P:ricJC:), :paniJcul:ar!~,Y' ,admi"ted H:ujbi:hes.l)tl,,~9 .But: dl,e ideQ, ,of: ollJiga"t~,oil, ~Dd, ,i:ts ,ooMcctiou, '~O m,gUvs:hon, 'was ,captured. ~£jter' D:Y' 'CJa-rkets, ¢tn:i,(al :sys;,~em. '~an, iby ~i'lh~:r.'

.. t:i!~ .. t;..~-.' - c.' 1.\ ... 'II.~,",,~ .... (. 'H-'ID":;'~'L~Q~"""'.' I '~'i.;o,~"" 1i1'n' ,1I;O:i;Q""o"'Il;';·I""."g: ri'lr"!'llo-t··, , .. .,..t· ,~ .......... i<" !""i<': '~l!'C:t:,

!il!~_~_"!li.U_Ui~I!i!I~ ,~)~Jl~~, !U.; . U '_ ~ "',IJ~I!;II-~,~, '1!·,~,~L"·~. IIJ~·~· U~~~L ,~,,,,~~,~~ .': ~ '~~~I ~~ ~~ ~~~~~_~~J ~_~ g. ~~

to' 'be ,donli~ 'I} ~~':r4,sonable;!' t~ ,and !~proplltio~,t't! ~~ Cla!l'ke 'tri~ '~O ~1Pi!" ture tile ~fise mat: nlht actions ,arfC caUed. 1'0:,' 'I)'" d~mand~d b,' tb~i:r :sl'tl:d,tiOM" ml8iJt: th~y !I1ave. ,a k~nd ,14i :F~lti'oo;d, :~~c~s:~~,tJ' 'ro~"g~'b]~, '~(11 ,tbe neC0Ssl't;,' ,of: dem.GnSllable 'tm'llfll,,~~ :He ,~es, tb3'~ ~1fme ~rismll

0- ,,!,.l, :.'l·'.,iiiI', .... ,;h.{\;;'j, ....... , n.1; ,,";.~1:I' .~,,,,! 'iii'if.. J;iI' .;.io~m: - .",:'~I ,iI'lJ!,"",",,;f\of'Ii'"".- I ,..,1: T-- -L., .liinliP'""/J! l!~ ,,"1.,,,,,,,11 •. 1..,-,'1' ''I'iL"", U. - 'CfW.U/U;~ll.o., ~-1 [gIl • • III .~;a !LI.1l])',-.. ~1 .. ,'IIr.- .. . IlliW, ,A~LI;;;I~~.I_ .. , Ul " I:~l.....~~ ~~~~, 1,~JUI~ !l!in~

:mllI3il, m(J'fI,v{e :~g th,e seese om thIs ( .. b:~iga:ti,o.n,:

:fQr '.~ '~'~Cm1t~ ,and CWKb:n~e, ~f iii! ,M8i1i,~[8, O;~, .Mi~d.t OODJieilD_iing 'tlle ~Ramnaibl~ll~$ ,and F1;tlm~SS, ~ t''!a¢ t:hl~ dn!at hi~ ,A.cti,Q:n.!:I, ~'bgw.d '~ ~.'" Ktnned 'W SRh. M swill, Ii :R!ui~e 01' LaiW'~; '~S ,tb~ tN~st: ,and! fOnnIU.csc O,&lfgia .. :~jbnj[ ~, mQfl~ :p~~ly cand, ~~n~dy !SQ~ t~g ~,Y' lorJn;·g~ wh~;t~~f' m ,the ,AJ1!I)thmiJt.y' ,of the {~i\'Cr ·of ,ii, :u:w" 0:1." ,-,;r R.e-pCi, :h~ m:ay ba,~: 'tl1l .~Its hli1~tiw, by' 'kWlii'rds rind :hin'i;s·b'mmJts.~~'

l'nc~t;ears_inJl,~ 8Si the elgb,teendl ce:m,m-r,' pf~gRsSeSj' wye ind :p~hUoso-

n'iL~, .i;"L'i'i1 lib~iIi;'b" ,Ji!;iit~";i!!j .,.._l·tl!;-i:Ii ~ii:iiI'It. .... ~ 'iiH,.'Aii'1.i"ii'n,v: ,~itfIo ,;t'i\t'i;m-:-:- :b--~:Ti~ 'Iio'h- :- .... ' '~""~iC!,t-, '~n--IiF~'~""iiii"",

r-"-l~i .. !g V-.~I ... ~~ __ 1 !iII_+.~-Di vI; . _r~,._ !u!~Will~"Ir.' -~-V'.l~_.~-a III-U ...u .. 1II_1L-1I."l I •. _ ;'!fIr.! ~"'" • ,II __ c!II~'II_'"

of il.~Jtime.[l'~ali!im, w'i,'d], ~, :Mfile ~a'tlona]i;stloC~ ,Iooount: ,of ,o'b~ipJti)o:n;,~~ .Bl1lt :raltlomal~M ·too 'b:a:s, ·ra, OOS,'-, so- lOf:li;iO~ IS, H'ume/!J afMlfltle:-;t '''is,

~~~ ~~_~~~~-~.~~ __ ~_" ~_ •••• _" '"'~"",~ .~. lI"~~~ ._",. ,.ll •••• --I!t.~---. II},. [1_

:aeQel't~d., :Por H;UDi·(~/S u~me:nt mikl~ ~It~ ap.,ea:r 'tn!il!t: m~ :lde.a fb~lt: tne. :mD'tlve Q;f duty' .i5 the ,pri~ :rQJQti,v'-e t~, :dght !1~ti,!mt ~a, 'M: m:ain:tDned, onil,' ;It ,th~ eX"ll'Se Qf ,.he id~al, thl;~ :ngh,t; ~cti'~s, ,~

~e-Pi:n,~1fi .e~: .. Q~'n-'iii',li.· .. ~ll-,v i'n .'iii!!~'Iii: n.! iO!""_'"":'~ ,_.~,~i'i;rg;';': :r,_,,,.~,.,)I[1 ,",:L~~ 'r"""'''iii'II-:-'I'iiit!:iIi' u. j[JMI;I.o't;U1 e- Ii;I!I.1!I-~ .~.!lj.J.P.W. 'IT . ·IIJ~, l~;'I§~,~~.~ ~~ ,m.~, ,~~y~.",~!! ,g~~:~~-~gJ. ig];-~ ~~~~¥-L~J.h2!~

-Ui-'IiF,.' h-c,,,,,,'iI.41 ... ;i.;"i,~ ""I~i.liiin--~Q'''': '~iiC' 1·'~ ";,,'L,,," '''''''I.-~~'~ ,.;.,;£: ,"JL"", , .. ,"" .......... ,iI!l '.,'i:lifl'l'I'~"'~~ ,;;t,e UUI .. J;I!il.l .. ~.l.iI iLIll~~l ~,IJ,~~~,~~ ~_~ ~'l:I!~ ~c~ ~~~)~l~!!li.'~ W g}.~ ~-~IfYM~ ~'''Ir.I-~~lI-IJ.~= .n~

Pri~ .PU:t9, ,i.'t;

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'" . . ,aU ,aot~,g~~~, iijin~b~~d~y~ bav~ ,~, n-~~~:f;e:\" '~t; :~'~w rome: ~~~~i~tef' 'Q~r_'" tai:mru.y' 'belofllit; ,t~ i[lltc~, and, so:m,¢'!t!idil3lt~ th.eil\@; is tn he 'JlHJ,~' ,8iflnllted ,of ,th(lm.

''''I!''iil." l.o~ .. ,i", . ,~;ii; . 'L.. .. ...!t..' . • jL . . ~ 'D .....t, .. ,1!.. •

-,lIluiI!S .ma.y' [~ 'uw:lJ't :some v..; It .. i~m, ,aile. !Il~~tJ O'ULeI1'S, 'Wl"~, ,~liIit ~~' 'm~8 ,~~ :1101.

ill~n"'!"1~d~, if: ,mo !i~~lQ:M' ,iJ~~ ,£~ tl~'m'~~'v~~ ~Hihe~' r-i;g'hlt m' 'WHIIl!&, n, Co • ~Jt ~o'~~

~Ii'io,,!,",,li!:, ,,:-'i...,0'I;11F; :ii? '1F""i:'~,~l;""~;~[!lit;o!i,f'l. '1F;"L'~\iI' ,0'1;,.,...., ',.;]~l- ':;liiI'idi1f""iIIl~;t'I;'i' u

!!i'Y!~''''~ ~I~"I' U~, ~liI"":W'''~~'¥'!l>io;l'\I' ~JJi_""" ~"'" a. ,hI:, ~iIO,~_U!lo_"

S:~n{;~ tlf~~.t is, 'una;Q~~pt3'bl~J! WI~ In',nst: [C'ODJdude d~ar,t t~·:ri:.8hl and w:mmg ~ w~al ~h;u'a'~t~~~ of' (liC~j\Q',n~!S/JJ,j [Thi$J~ of [C1@i.~e~ RmOv~ '.". dHfl:· c~dt,Y' ,;jlooU!t, dain;g a(;t40~l$, 'with :Iltgbn t'{Jl tl.b.~t 'r~Kh,tn.ess., I th~ :rilblt,1.. :n~S$ is hi!), ,t'h~ ,;lc:ti~n-J 'we: ~. Qe'rtai'nt', d.o[ :it, £0:11' the ,~!'ike: of tbt

':r:".,'l4.t' 'n. ';';i:i'':; '~-;I'~I.' ;ri,ifri.-'U'r' .,'1. .... r·a-'iii~;f!iril.,,·~·]'-Il:"~iii' ,~", ",''"!d; fI.l'"'":fI ,~.".L 't-;~,-,,! 'ii~,~, iiio·.L"'iii ,",~~,~-::~-lI!~~~\. ,D~J"l lu._~'!JT l .. ll~ 'oJ_ '!II.~I~.I£'O' ~~~l '1IL~1 .-;;I!1I2I -u- J~l 'H·£I .. J11 . J;~~ .~~~~ Iltill-ilJ!i!-

:rig&.t.ness is, ~t~ iSp.e.lc; ana(hrom~it1edlyl ~ :noo,·{n.tiUI,a'~, Pnrpefty~ m,·' :~~~Il!rt; ti:~, ,tb~ a~tin~\!I ~.~d, :~n!ltftd,t~d. by' :~~;J~D. :[n, 'thi~ W;;JY;, r.a;t~i~nd,~

•• ,j~m s~~m~, '~(1j [~riI,ta1I1I_~ '~s :in a ,m~t'a,p~,y:si,~'al ilDJ ... ·J:aJ!. tleali5'~ as 'w~ll, ,ar~ ,an, ~pi~~.~mO:b),gi~ i'Qudti():Jli~~ 'whiM ,m '~th ·~n-P'8Jb't~bl~, Tili$

'w·n ,"i' , '.' rtt~'i .. , II" , be " . ''b''i. ·t~· , .. "Kan't ........•... b'i.' [ fJ···· '1):. d I

"~.~l ,~n ,Fa;; '1}C;llar' ,00, [O~6ClliOD [M ,'_[_c.\" is\I._~G~[~S P'ro,l~c, ,1!GI\Ii~:5i

'tt.,e urn,e-,rl:ti,eal 3_a:S;ULmptiofl ~'oot n~es~' pri"liiit;lip[le61 :ma;lY' be ~OU!Ii'i.I~r' 1;111' r;s:t~o:naI, in:t!iliti~;!, te[ hold :in the :~aJ~)Ulre [01: minp, A'nd,~, ,aJlt:h.O'~gh,

,~'~., ''''''r~.'I,niJi;,o1il.l-'~i~J''s· 'i'e)./~ ... ,*,,,,,;~ t:'~ .. "H"p~i'i'~i ... t:iC't t:b-·,·,;;;o,QfYr"-:.':' ;irIIf: 'iI''''D,01i[~i']ioHl ~rW'jlft;ii;i 'w'L',i''';b':

!Il-_ilib" ,~,III'I~lUc"iI_iI!I' __ 1_Q.!Ii! . & .. !!I.;'!i.! !Li~, . _111,,,-," !!;,. ... .l.iI .,:U,~I!i.!·iI.""!j,. ,_ .• "-' , '!i.!I , ,iI,'!;.oGOIU'U:. ,1,1,1!;lI',~~'J, ~ ~ u_~"" . ,

• 1 ~.

iit: :fOUOiWI81 ,that. r~~n CiI!IilIU)t :moti,v,~'t~,r '~'b~;, :b_ad :0;0 a:C'CO'!!lo:t [of cbi()iW'

'W\~ ,~, '~ m~t~,v'~Jt~;d 'by' :ra,tin~l tmt'iITI.~, to' put :in its, :p']a~~. 1"h~

' .... ,ilfc~~'ft,"":~·,i,"",.\iCl liCl"'~' ",L ... ,1Ii' "·':~l'~p.; ·~'i, ........ ;!"', ~"'l'y.: '~'.r-,,,,,,,;,'i:IIl-.'llloI::I! ,i'n , ....... .,. ~r .. ly.·. ,~L",!,

.Il!dJ!Ii;~U'--.l.!}..JlI.Il~!-l;-a ~'!IlIi i[;.D.1a.!II;, !IJ,r.-IJ.\ ·lII" ,ll-",liU,IHI. ,ro. u.ilHI" . - .1i:I&:I\&m\lJ~ . .II u.",lIi~ "rJT,d,J ... II_JJ1..\:;n

-- _"_ -_._._._._ ~'- -- - - ~-'- ~ - - ---'. ~- ~'- - _. __ ._ - -'~--[': ,~~ - - ~ - - - --'~ - _._ - . -r', ~ _'--

n':O-_"'!!,n.,i ........... 1···' ... ,L,~ ~~··~n'~I:'n[Pn~"'''" .".:il: 'iii"~,"",' ";;i[n!l.,iI" , ... 't\:;a;.~'I">'n ''''';';~rlli;.;,t' '~-':""' W. · .... !.·''"I~'

~_~_~~~~l'~c~~_~. ~_~ iUl~ l~~_,jw-~~,~_~~~ ~f. !I!;~I~' ~,~~p~~ ~c~~-:-~~_,~ '~~~~-~l oe ... _.,~~,1'1

mtl,V1~' us, :But i'~s:~~d ~f '~QbJgiJll :bow' thils :is; p05$i.bl~~ ,th~, Is:imply imsitoo. O;I,t it i;~.,

m, hglili~d tb~ng.s l.at 'W'Q_~ mstead. [(itt;: 'OOlth~r, In a~r own, '~m,t;UlrJ~ W~ :0[,;, :1059, de~mded. :in:tw;~ijooi~m, by' ,ailill, arrgu_m,ent si:mU3(r to Hmm.e'l's\;, [n 'f'he ,open~n,g: pa,g.es of. Thle lUght ,a't:a!d1 dJ6 GO()i:~, I..(JSS ~lt,ta>Cik5' m.e possi'blU;r, (),l; a, :mMiv,aitiOOil~. ,i11I1ii:aily-sis of: f;,~,gb:i;~,eSS1' 'WhCIl, 'we ,sa--,' maht: a~. 8,c,l 'prooeeds :&om, a good :motJ~V\e1r wye ,dire s.a,)!,lng: t"h3!t ]t~ liS m.O:f1l11,,' good. Sol 'iDa SI!.y ·d13,'t; righ:tll.es8[ ildm~,t;s o:r: 3, :lIiiOt~.v,a'tlonal, ,Qlfiial,sril i~ 'teo Sa:y tthat '~~"rip,t~j 1I1teanS {.!i:ln,(jraII", ,!OOd, lj.~6 ,B'l]J,t :1.(1SS[ ~,'1i[ t-haJt:,h~ [~, ~jh~w' th;l~: tlrriis :is WWn& Q.~ as he stM't'H~gly' !P~.ts! ~t~ i)"thLa!t, :n~.thrinHg dil!1it [QU,g,b.'t tl~ 'be d()li1Ii~ is, ~"~'\'e~' mQ\ml'~.,· ,good. f,!'l!i" O]l~ oj his

~iili'"ltml'm~IlI;"\"i II'~"'" '''i'iI!..,:,1'' ~\i'lI'U' 'j"'IL~,,!!, ~'i'!. .... , t~'L'..-r<'II~1 ,.;~,-,t:, onm' , -' (;111' '1Ii''ll!' ,~~, '''';"!i; .. ;ro.t':

l~t!l;f.~J!_:_.~~J~~ ~~-~ ~~~J '~'~','[!l ,~g_v~ '~.~~ "c~.lfU ~~'~l ~'':~'~. U-=-'l~~,,. ,~iQ.! ~!YI [~'¥.~

:bam a, i,)~rntiD m,~tir~1\~jIJ 'US~!1U,J' held thiJit, '~lf}e :moti,Vt~ i~, qU!gti~n is, 'dt@ ~S6 ,~f d)~,ty:!, ~!B[ut,~

Copy rig hted m ateri al

,Again~ [$I!Ir~~ malt :~: sa,~' t>lil 'VOU, "'it :1.:8, 'VOM d.w[;v' b), [diD a~t ,,.4 ,R:om 'the. ,.n~

~ - ... ~"-----------J! •. ~J1"rr~- ~~~ - -'~i'" ~ - ~. ~ ~ ~~ ~-- ,r.' - ~~ - ~ ~,' w_ ~'- ~'- w _i"""'l _ ~~ w' ._.-=--=-= ...

Of di1!mt!t' .. dUJt: ,m~n'! 'I:~)t. :~$ 'Y0Uf.' d;li1Jt,~ to dQ[ ,act; ,A, f'mm t'bCi se:os@: 'tha,'i: lit 1$ '~f.'

d.i"'-U ,t""" de "" ..... ' A ~' c"T"ii.~ .. 'I' ,.JI"'lii-'· ,.,'1..[-., ~~ i'''' 'vnUJ,~I,,~lttv 't"'" ,.,; ... '.' ~iI\Ai.m [0.; ... -.,.[o.;'"n

'--=-~~7-1 ~ .. -_ .. l @~" ,,;.=~ ~L'_'~~ ~l U1J_' [_~ ~~, .~l~. ~~ Il'~-=-~ QlJ!)__:.·II· ...:~ ,@~" !IJ_lI_,i~-~ !AI ~~"1_.I'~'~"_:________'

~tlIv~~ ht I ~UM~~t wt ]tQIIII ~b~~ld! ~t urndCl' 'tib~ ;s'~~i;tl~, th~it: :it j$ '~Q.wf d~t!ll 1:'0 [do, Ii ~rtliiD d.u'PliiIJ i'm!!s~Cttilv,e;o:f Motive, i e. l!IInde<1:' ,8 's.'1W~i-

.,. • _ r •• ,,_. • •• .•. -, _ ,__ _ _ I _ _il_"'~J _ [I .•• ~.~. , _ •. , .•• I __ . ,_ Il . ~J •••• 1 .. _ . [ I "l I I I '~'¥.'¥~

tlQg 'which, :1' ~~9it 't:hin~k faJse ~.~H.~ it ~~Jl!t~;iJdict8 :my own",

'Th.c only' C()li.tcJ}us:L~, thi!l!t em, 'M dr,;ajwn ,~s '['hl,t GUIr [dJLllit.y !I$J ~o dQ ciClUaifilJ

~. ~.

~'Illfitgjj)! :nQ~ ~o dQ' 'th@D, fro.m, tl~ aeMe; of di!!lit~~~

It :~8 :n(tt ',",e: ca~ dlait :1 [~_, by [cilG:i¢t :prooil,Q~ :a, ~n~. Motive hYiAeth~!:' [tffitrils

L~ ,S"'" :".....,;r,:,.,. ... '"'!!, [~iI!ild,"I'~ [ii"f, '.\'" !II""f[l'i"''' [ot ~'i.U'''''''~'''''[I''i ,i,.,. 'm .. ''U'G'il!;~I:t ""iii: ""1 -:o",,,,,,,,~,,,,',[j;.r) .. , ~1!11 !!1l£W~'~I11~',,,, !I,!I""""IJIJ,., v, ,H!IOl ~ _'ilI!Iil • I 'V,U~,.iIO-_U." '1 ,L:lU, , l!~WI ,"'Ii. .... ,U~U,"'I!"'!iji.I'''L, ;;I

:llQti~f ;&un I~$ ~h~ 1 'C~, art ,a, :Ql~m'~~t~'s :ootie::e ~'k~ :~!~ .~~~~,\!\~ g, i5~lm:tdiii;t: .. :i'ng m@: 'to ,Ic;t,,~[

Tb"u"o;~, Boss[ lOOn:ci~ludes· ';I){: ,~~ot be 'dlle ease t'hart: ~,c:l-a:'~ltt: l :~·ugbt, 'tlj'

=_ ",~,""'jI j, ",~,,~ _, .. ,aue, W,3L ,. iO _ j U

do ira H,t from, cer&aJn :mio-tivles"

liU~.e eal':~iier;' :ra;tj!ol1:idist'S~ :Il09S ;cxu'iJ£h,ules that :righ,mess :f:Jl'MlilSlt ,Sl;ml'" nl'", be a nmpe:ft~' 0:£ ,cmaifii ,ac~tinf:Ja;~ 'But '!Ross, 'has a mT;-~h:,;'~:,~' r ~ . , ,It"", l' , . " ".,,',' ,.,"',' ,,' ,,~.c, lllQre

.;iI~'~.il"",'II~''e, i:cj;"'Ii'ii!!!~ ~;n'iI'''Ii~i~'iii''i'O' 'iIi'ikii!!!; 'i1i~~""'fi'jt,;'iiIi '~~'.i!Ii' I;"i~ .-;-'. ,'iTbl~""~)Ci,Ci: 'ii:'~[~I:1 'if"~, U_iI_IiHi!i;,;iy_iI,!I:i"_Uliili!lo -it',;lCUiI:diue; !Il-ilili!lo uu.I.,liu,lu_I,,!f .... ,iliu'Ii!I.i"II.o ul: ,[iJ&I'Ii"Ue~ I:.niBiI1 ms

predeoessors. F.OJ' CI.ar:Ic~, :Pric.ei and 'Ra]p,y' 'w'cre [aIl1 w:~.a!t: 'WIC shnuiid, no-w' [can :ifi)t:cmiiUst8.:4~ The, beli;eved ~ha"t 'diE :pc'",Ption oJ an aD-

4;~",..". ;rti:D, ~,~bl;i' ctjI.T'. Uj:k ..... "i:' ""\1.;0\7 t-\lfliO:C:'~~ 'iii", he ,o.,'~':e~' ii"!i'lim--:-,Cl:e~' ""'i7I~nIP' , ••• :17,1,~1~1.I1.""",' :Jij! ,;:il

,,_~,,'U."J.l1 [iEI_g ~ '''b.':II''~1 iU-i&~1 !'f!'J.' il1.:ll!li. ·U;]IJ~,i!' ~. lli.l !II.-U -!I.! ·L:.Ii~ ~J - - _. ·U:W~~ 1l#l1.;l_~~Jl-!U;"1 ~-~ ,iIlIrJIJ ,~.

m,Oh'Vle lin [dn :I,'t" So the. pl'~J;b:~em, R.(J:!!HS[ notlc~S, :Ifi t'bls :~ast: ,~'mleiii~, mart: 'we C8!Rfiot, m1r!SitlCf' 'dle ~ense cf cJb:iiga,dom, [art 3, :mGmen:t's; n\1Uce""

..jl~~ 'i'Ij''''iif: ,;rtii~;"iiO! '~l--: j;'lf'iIii!ii'"I.:'iO: ~ i!"i\li:i, p'''',V"lfil~

Ul!.l!!!Ircao , .... UII:. IIII'_I,JA,I!IIO; ,I,U , ".fl!!;r_iI"'I~, ,ft_a; ,11",1011 __ o;HII" """,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'W'h~m, w~ ~ [~fiD.!SQiu.'l!IDs! "t'h::lit: an, :aaI:Qti, is, f1t 'tl1 ~ W:m.~t~ iiilT,' dl~t~ :I't [ofllilrt ~o 'be [dO:ITI~, :it Is ,nnt c1moe:i,v.bl~ 'th~lt 'We, eM ~(em!il_ln Dr][.intl[il'~li~'ed~ [01 'WM~ I! ,m!~ni¥~ UJ' a.~~ion. It 'wo~'l~ ~ t~l Urul€ mr~~ ,t~ [~~iU~ :mucJb, wi,tJh a ~i~Ul~, 'Who 'wnid. cl¢:n.,' t\hiis,~ Of' 'w:a~ 'w'QDl~ :m:a:i'nJta~n 't'j'uu:, tlhe ~mitllli;ea~ '01' !l(e~s:'On;~bl~n~S'$ g.f ,~~ ,~tioo, ii~, :n.Q[ :re'l!SQ[I, 1m' ,do:~arg, ~tt:, Qd, ~h~ imm~rl1Ji:~,. g::['

~-.--~"""'~.-'''''-.~ ~iIb.'I'","'i"i"",~U' ,~£ '-"".', ..... ,.ll. _ ' ... ..,. '_;o,;>;;-;,.,. ..,'''".-\.,...'.''''" ... ';0;;1;' .I1~ii'niP' ,'-., An'-" . -,Iii:ii:.':"';...,'j.-l~- ;-09' ~1!I!ir, ... a~l!InQ:t:.PJ:~ni~a! !;!!J, ,a~OI! '''''''~JII(:.P.lilf u,'I,l!i ,';~U_I!~ ["'~W!l:':~::;IJI; [~~~ ,I!~" ,,,' :. [Wli ........ ~ /Iii!'.liI, !l;;'oIO,

,wn€'~~~3Jt-~on tmO r.octi:triilde [can-n,0t, k ~rl!too, :lmm, du:~ view o:f :i:t'.:~

'Wlu~~:as lto:tiI~'1 ,fo@lb~iW:iDg, h·~,~h;mt :is, an [~xt~!1!1i$,t~,'U :L·~ki~ ,S:c:!f_~ :in'~~!r\o' :na1.~~~5\il l\OSiS! ,.d, :Ptidhud, ,~'hirik thar~, a ~, p~rso~, d~ "tIl~ :rilhlt~

",jLf~ni!L'i' il>b-~"';i'I;'I:Ji~ 'l"'~' t,~, i""1,.~ '~"'!""'I!'"' ii;Iir'~n[Qi' t:t B""ii'i" n[,'9'"""[~"'~ ~j[':L-""d' ... !'I,.link··. ""f IU~I_I~.~~J . !!ir.~~v.Q!'IIr l,I!I.. lloJ;J 1~[I~ lIJ._6'_II~. ,"_IJ_!_'_::"_~;l' ',~ ~l~. ~ ~~IfY ~·~LlI~LLiYf.~ '~IJl~- ~ w=

the m,e:ti,¥e [mf dUlt.)', as :smlle~dd'ng li'ke a desire! thilt '~!ai:k~s., :righlt: ,ac::ltirGll ,f~it, i;t$[ [obje.ct~ :0,0:1:: ,as oomethiing: t'h~)t::iS! 'in:::volv~d i.N,1('hie veI:J',p:'a.&p of'the :f:a~"t d~:a,t: dle ,acot}.o;n, is :Il:gh~:. So Uke :Ku't~ch,e;sml,r' RIMS 1.11 effect: :s~p.:a,'"' :!E'!i;,.~ifi[ ~,1,..,"'l: ~~III'i[j[j:iIt"~~~'n~: 'i!)~"'[iI!'n.H[ - ~'''''j~ ,f"',lI't·: m""" th.;:;, ,~"'~i[i1WIil"iil![ ri~':~t ,= :ffl~m, ,t'~.,;,

~~~~~ IU~I'!r.' 1,'~~_f._IJ~-------.bL"~~-~~tI~ l~~!!r =-~~ _~-~~ ~_'!r !l!ll!YI~~~ ~-~ ~~'f!r.IJ~~ ~ ~~ _~~

~ ~ ~

mO~i'\fa,tj_:og liie.~SM - the des.ire '~O d\!i! ·what is, :ri.gh~ .. , .And, ;sln~ this

;i';~,1Iii;lij:!;t _,~1 ,_,~[ .. 'L.;If' i[!;~'_'Ii'!ii'll~ f"'[~"1 ,111' .... ~- 'n""~""!in' II' I" 4j;, ... ! ... .." ... _"\' '~-'""' ~'~'II'.' r!Ii~'II'..-v ...... , ,""'I"";io,

~-~-IfI~~~ ,~IHI-~lJilllJl'~I~, ~-~,~~,~,If.,.r. ~~u' ~~ ~ .vJ~~_~~~1 ~.l~l [~~~i~l ~ g~, ~)~~II l~~ ~~-~

,f~~m :i!t, ,An 'W~ ~ say' :~$ thl(~ ,ittms; fr-om i!t is mO'r'il'~,y' ~. Tb~

m- "@&~' "':~·!i'!li.' J!'ifriI'" 'jI'I!,~""." .h-·g. ,l'O];_~oll' t·-:'~,- .. , i<''''''' ..... ,;g.'III''!L,:, ... ;I;I!, ,iii<' '''';;'''''''''1111' ~""'~'!I:!'. b" '",""'~':';i'" ""[ ,I~. rc~_~ ~ ~l~j~, .~~~ ,~~~tf. l~-:-~~_~ .I~~~ ._,:~j~ ~~~~~~~~~~ ,~_~l ,~.~l1!-1 [~~,..1 ~.~-~~~,~-~J I~

:m~s.()n flor [~'(if.l'Q;n:~ i~~ m~ ~se [af a m.o~-iv~1' w:h~n th~ d!~ir~ ~'O[ dOl 'w-bat is! right hlppens se be Qn, me! :s.~~~ 'to m'~~R9:t~ lW in i'~'" :F~"h~.ml~[~,~ :RJMS! dm.ies[ ,t'ihat a, ~rigbt [il~'lon ~n,~edJ. b~ ttl any' w,~)" good. ~foJ'~ ~le, argues,,,

'~'ir' :i!:'ii')Ii--;-~,~--:-~~",,~,~, ,i"Iil '~"i'i"I,I;i;' ,~ .... ,ii,i'M'!i[ '~[i"i'-'t'ti'ri' i"Iil. b--·~'.d'- ii"ii'"" '~iii"'..1~I~.ji'\i:i:i!'i'':" -ii('i:t."''V\i!li'_ ~L'''''i17 ];1; Q!'!.l!\m'\r!lo.'!"ne '!I,I"",e!il! !PI! ,['iIWJIi}!I. ",-,.,:Y""",.iIi, ,1.1 ""'",UII,!PI! !PI! , .. '!;Ail, olIiuWiIi.L'!;r;OI,'!;r_OIiol,1O, ,.111"""'], ~ '!Io\!, [~I~Iii;I;~

[-c:'~--;-[ ~l't: be.s[t be t'l:' [~tmme(taU~ ~""'~~ _,,"4 n'U::-l\e! ~[! RO' ~t!ilC-C---:- ftee tba;t "t' w--''U

caD, .,. .. Jill" n,.." [~,!JI!.lI'!!o!I!, " , .. 1. . 'ie!i_faD ,L)., ~_l

[e\!'''e.fi be thaJ,t~ :t.g,T' t'rilgh,t# ne:l.t:her m,ealns. ct~:P!Ioo~ctt~e~ of: lood C();I]iSC,'"

[i!1'i1~'d.!i!'i' I_~~[tj [~[[ifi"iii'ill!",i!i; [(;!I~:~k[~:tj "i;D[ 'il~i~''''inli''li;~\'.f~i''Ii'b--: 'l~I;iI;~1 'iffii"l"l:' h~:li"lioi!:[ ."iit: .~i!\'~'c' ~-~I ii!j)l..Ii"!l',i\ii!'i'fi' ,~", "\I,!I.'l'l;;;iliJ£;'!Oo!il! ~iOZl\lul"""'" ,1,11;61.1[' ,1_ .... !liil-'U_ ..... __ I.;l',,;;;,.a \ ... ~ ,111"""'1, , . !IIi'" .1,,," "'""" C[ lI}"'1.'"\IoI, ",_:l'I!U":n!',IiIl, !IiI'Ioi!'

be ~fi[II,cJde-ifit: 'w,~.d~, maJlt: ~mlf¥"-i",~;~,ji So a, '~~'~[.t acdon :~s nor fiece~9a'ril'v

r- ,r,"'_". "Jl~~_i ,.

:~t'I!sttru.Dlel1!li~_l~"Y' ,I~w and aiCcaming: '~O R..cSS\i' it ,basi no :f_ti,titnsllc; 'vab~e., 'Wk~!t: hai ~,due" ~,)'s' ,l\~" [f'~~~_,i the d~ml ~f' d~!e right a(:;~: beCI~~ ~,t iiS :riP,~~. fl,~~, :B1J'~ r,~sb't~~S's b,' :i,tJs.df ~)"is Ittl~ a. ,iC:-Im oj 'vat'~~ ,a't all, tj,~ I:y :~,t~~lf~, '(~~'DJ r,~sh'~n.~SI~ ha;~ n~ :~,Qr.l1'! .. arY,V\~ ~QI'~~~, This[ mak,~ i,t. d~arf.' 'w~l1iI,y :I\'M$ :mitW~: ~ an ~lt~~rrtJ3iiliJ5't~. Si'n,~~ r,~Iht..n~s5' is :na-t: a, V,~b;l;~" ,tiJe dlil'iS!b'e '~!l d~ 'wJha'~ is, r:~~()u, i:'j, n~ ,aJ, ~pa.mse w[ ~, v,ac~ue:. NOli' d.~es, i;t seem,r' '~'h~J'1e'fore~ ee 'H; ran e:speciiU", :[a~'ti(Ina:l m\Otl,~;, l;~k~ 'me 'f:Ja.Nrm af~«,-

"dii;:-iHfil![ '~~Vlili''':';i'Io.:l~ b!·· IV' [ifi~[.r~lm·"'iiIi!·t"II"f,,,;~I.",iD;t,;r;~_ :~'fI, "I;i!il 'm·.··.ii!ifil:\\il!'~~'.i"Ii ;::;[niii':'~~ ~:r.,~ 1..1 ~"·F~:r ,~:: "'_'IIJ""~","" ,1:!9~ ~ '!o.!'\1,'!r.'U -v • _LU!!I.._I __ . ,'!;r;II.I,!Il!g_wl""!Ioi1il'1 1,'10, '~';!! ..• "'ilii'! .. ,I'l a m,'!w!'",J,v'e we llia,t";pe_I"I, ",a

h~ve. So dib,t~,e9i 'b~' :i,\ise:lf ne;l,tb.~r :mct~:v,a;~es nOI' 'b:iln.ds~, 11o:r ,arre, "t!iiYe oo!iU1d ~Q[ 'd1e d.e~ire to do 'whl~: is, D!gh'll. tr, ,3;1);, 'tie 'M I:-e~n, [01' cliA!!i,tym Thus it 'turns [iJirUlt '''t'~,~t "1"'r'~ e e~ _ ,~:LiIi w'ltrA'~~' 'ii'iii('ilh~,'!i;,;j;~"i!\ -:i t,'-r.."~~ .;:; j: '~'Iii'''''fi'",

~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ "'" ~ ~ y~ ~~ ~~~ ~'"""''i!' 'bU,,", . ~ ,1i.t~'J"'" UIV H _ . _iA!'!I.._1 ",'iC l'!w!lI:OC 001; ,I,~I!"

ru~:~s, :Sfrin.P' fI\~m. dt~ lSi~,~sedJ mtrinsiic ',\a]~e O,f Ict'i.ngJlnm ,~, oeRaiin :mo1ti,v'l'l1' 'whi~h 'W~ sbn:p]y h!a!ppen toO bav;e.

Copy rig hted m ateri al

In t:'be :P.r.e£ace to 'the Gro;u'lj1d1WiO"lrki :K.iuit. S'~J;S ,th.:a.t~ his :rm,efh;~. i'Fi. th~ fhs,t :p,ar.~; Qf' the book 'wiU 'be {;!1,t-C1 proceed. !I~aJ,~caiUy :&IGln ~o:~'mo:~.l~;;no.wmedl,e til' tI~e let'e~~D~in~t]fifi 'o:( i;ts, iSUi,pl;lel1ii,e pr:bu::i.:Fle~j (G~ 3'9.~:1,. S"~ifi(j~UY.i Gr.~ti'nd'W\QI:R l' .seeiCs ·th,e pn~lc-i:ple ·be-nln-d. "eommen :ra.tional :kn'C)'wled!g·,e ~£ :mo!tuls·# [~G 3,9';$;);· liee.arllse he :~s arud.y.~q: Go:mmOfl!:. :km<)i""d·edg~, Ka~l't starts from ,att idea. w:hit'cb be e.xpec:ts. ·t·b,e reader ... on~:e he F.eoogD.'i~·~~ :it~ ·to ~QteP.it d'ruat, :rnot'hi;Dg :is ~r-C'I :-·o·,:-,d'·tl !l1l!aiUv' 'v(duabt~ re:J(3!~lf!':t ,ill ~ood 'wnl. WhCli!lleVer Wt!e: beUeVie

umcfLI.!\ ..... " ~.~ .. ~ .... ~.~,~~~ __ .~~.~_ .~.~~ .. _

~.:~ 'Ijr, :-r:-c:.- 'oti!i':~.'1~~~ifi ;-I .t"<.'l..Q; a~,Q;".,.;iCi~' ;Nf :iI11llii"'1h ::JJ wjU 'Wllli 't'mi'll1Iik 'we :h:i'.l'ie

we .1!1.a:,VC "'" 1.!li.IJi!lo""IlJIItU 'L.UI!;,; !!I.,;!Ii,'!;.-~ """~"'.... v~ !JI_ .... ~ _ _ _ ~~ .., ~. ~.~ .. ~. .

'Ci'~'-':;I '~'j~. " "'"''i:';Il'i';T'i1 [i'b~:li'"li!~' b~. ,"'lilifi' a Cil;"ii~:ji'"li;~I. kmd of. \!,\"II~'I'I~;': Vii.'li'~U~ ,t:'halt: is .inde.l•

oren. :an a"'lIi.lu\I.1! ,'"- .111;1,"- .. ..,."" III! 0!Y .............. ""'.w ,_ .~_1iJ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ _ _ ~ _ ~ ~~_. ~. ~. ...

p~nden·t 'of ;!\~what. :~,t ef'f,ec,ts Of; .iIi~mp]iih~s.1 11 ,ail]ld 5Q:1' U'rn~oodi.·' ,~:\:-:- al [~G· \'.i!~' 'I .. 'Ft'i '-;I;d~' b) ;t:US.OOV1~f.' 1dlru.~ '~~irtc~l~l(li; ~r. .m'Gra1i't~ Of of

I,ona., ~ .. ..;J'~4,~. , .. , 0; •...... -~ - .. ~ .-~ .. ~~~~.*"~ ~ ~~ ~~. ~~ _.' ·.N ~ .

'ur_r:U:.Qllditj,~alIy· ,I~· a~t:i·ont W~ Di~. t~) dl~stov~r w:~alt p.rl~lc4:ple ,a good wiU ,acte, om,

The 1to~lon o:~ dU!~:f' ir:u:J'llI,ilfes that of. a .good '~U]-li' since ·the n~tion ,~f duty' ia1 th,e~ :i'totiuD, o:~ !li!.,Iood 'willI ope;r,ilt~ng: ~~d~' i"l c:~f't:ab~. sub~ ~~UV~ ·c~.~ltn;:-t~;:-IliS ,iaifld]. 'h"in,df;atl!~S;;'j ~1-G, '~'('I11' .~.,. 'Th~r.~mm, Kan~; n~:O"OSf1iS tn-

,ITeS ,ell" ... ,. ,.1,.,._. !l' ,JI':l' ~- ~=~""~=I ~~-~~. ~~~.If~~~~ ~~

.~ ;:::'k ,·'t.:,~s~-! ·F'!I ~c:'h',c'h we should s~'U' tbat a ·~e._1',Sml ~Cri.rJd l-iimom .

. ,00. ,,8, cac.-s.nl W .. I 1 ., it." .. \_~~~_ ~=~~

dutlr~~' :~n ,g],dcr bJ' d'~M{jI¥Ie:r: tbe pdinlci:ple of: ,iu~t~glii, ·wbr.~_,Ch. characteriR.S a, good 'wltt He proceedl to dlis,tlngu:~~h t)~e: .ki'~dls ;of' :~,Qti'v~,'~ ·tllllll,. One ma.}!f' ac,t &om duty (dOl ·t'~'ltif!~ 'right: ·tibi~;g '~cai~s~ :h~ b~ tl~~ :riglb,t thm,g~\, .&om. db-ect ilnclimartiQD r:~Q:r.m. ~Fl. a~tiO:rnJ. beca,1,l's'e one 'P~oy'i itll· Qt' .fro.m. ind.h:~~,t :~nclJi'~~lt-i'mll (!pe'F.W.~. 1m. :a(it1~!] as, a me~~S 'ttl ra, :fur!J'fhe:.t' e:~~.J" Th@ :6r~t. 01' K~.t:~'s .~·@';m· e-:ump:~es, 'OO[J!Cems :fl, m.ef:~ ,c.bant 'whl) :Ileh:dn~ from. ,o'v~~ha:rling .bapl,~siS e~s,t~meJS, 'becau~e: i'I. good r"epu.tatiion h.dps, 'oo.si'~~SSI' This is, a;~. '~nmp:le ,~f' i'",[ill:e'~t :in.cb.,· :~a.t_ioj]" 'We are u1dlk~~.y' to co:nfus~ sueh an 3,citj'(YJ]). with. an a~tiorn. :&.om, duttyi' K~nl :SaIY:S,.

'~iiIIi. ii"i!,.·J,.·iIIioii" ":'~r'~ ~¥i'"Iiim··-:IIi"ii. '~Ia!i!i, ,;'I;i"':Jl!; ~ •. ~ii1"" ~ ..... nh'~I~Jt;_T!,"'Ii''''~ ,,,;I!rotil!l 'nA~ntt:; 'in :earih. ~l lIJJI~ ~'U~L~1I1 ~'I_ l~~ ~tA_~ __ .,~t~~-!Q p_~~ L"_~ILfj~~'~"l~ l~~ =~~'W P--~!!r ~_:IJ_lII---=r!ii!! .~~~~ _ ~ ~~ ~-~ _-_~

o:f~ d.f:le.m· 'W'e I~sider: ,g. aet~on t·h.a:.t lone OU~''''llt ·to do f'rom. d)1UI.t~:. 'ibut~

~-~ .~ ~ ~ ~~'.~-~~ ."-~ .~ ._ .. ~._ ~= ~._._.~ ~ ~~ .. - '-I~'~ ~ _~ ~ _ ~-~ _ ~ ~. _. ~~'I~ _ •• ~

'li!·h:l'[ or!u,~ 'maru also 'L ... , na'tIllIall'U' mcHn~d 'tQm d!~ F'CiI' i'nstanc~ Kmt'

I_-_~_~' . ..::: . .__:. j_-"c"=_' '~~-~.,T .~',______:_.:___,. ~ .. ~~.~~._~::_,.~~,~:_,~. ,:__________,~c,,=_ __ o,_:~_~,~, .~_~ .. ..:. • ..:_ •. ,~ ,______:,._'._ :_.~,~,_l.;~-_~.~ . ..=.~ ":.~.' t. j~1

SaiVIS 'l~n~@ are 1'!ierSODS

- ~''.l '--~ .~ __ ~-"~' ._. _ ... r .-~ -"~' ~ ~ _.

Copy rig hted m ateri al

.Aet~,Qn$ done Qn ,tbis, b~sis; ,;n~e 't'~dU'~ifW ,a;~d amiaihlejj ,a:nd ~~desetVe~ prtDis.e and enoG'U![:ag;em~n;~,~'~ yt~~: they d~ ,not: e.;v~n~; the maral 'woRh <Jf ,the a(ti,on d!Gne ,from, drt1;~y ~'G, 398,jl, To ~tlttd 'ciie e;~4];oe [of d!lI!l:ty .and 't'~,e ,I~· 'WiU,11 'W~ ,mj~~ :f:I:ndl, '~'he. 'iOli9Aisl ,fin. w:ffillC:h. 'we disUn,lUish ~'hese .3¢:ti<xP$ fmm, thos~ dene from d:ut.".

It :181 e$seD~'i$l :~(Jt~ ~'O, [oomiu'S~ m~ p~mt oj' 'dil,ese e-Xiilim:p]es wid~. ,t'ha,t: i!lJl ~be :honeS'~, nll~'fc'han'~~. 'who ,ac;~s· ~':nej;~_hec_l" :Ho:m, dJu'tf :fifi:j~ .tmm direct: i'r-u::-Jm9JJti:nn~, lnw.t~ onJ!·r' ,f~r :ai. $~Ulsl~, ,p~ijJo:setl ~IG ;l91'il• Acrur-ding: ,to D, £a-U:.t'Uis'f:' lUl,t :tti;~SJguri~il~d :wl:mng of. d~~5~ P~~UI~s:;, :Kan~. 'boJ,ds ;s, cmdei~, .he~,o:msJtie d],e.OI)" $joout~ all, :m'Qtir'!l"t~ ,~m~;r 'tib~ :mo:t',J'~, ene'S!;: he t:hinks that. ,:a!UJ ,3;c~,t()n5' 'e'Xtt~lt; motJI. Olles, ,ge deae :f\C[ the :sa'k,e 'Gf~ 'o:mets ,own pl~i'5Ime~ gd] iI@ are aU eq'U!aUy :se18s'!t.l. and, ·"r-i:tho1.u. :r-tuJJ;al 'wordi., ,Sol '~lIid~~.sIQod\i' .K_I'IiU m.eans, 'UJ em.ph:asJze ~;be: iSim.i1:'al1f;t;v 101 ,~~~iQns dor:.,e. ,b·om dhect :~ntJi:liuiJtioo 't-a 't'b,ose. done ,from i'~d~Il~c.l ~n~~inadnn~ the;i.t' pu~~, .like; ehe h!Q<J1est :_eillch_,t~~'Sf. ,Ws .iwndamen,'" 'f;1!ny ~l_as.h, :!BiU;~: w:ba:t K~n:t cl!~:a.rly' emp.:mIo1Si%es 'ere. is, ,th~ dill~'l['f~ce '~tweoo dlce:lec~: ,3il!ld, :~nd'if.-ec,t [Zlcli.naticD.r IimdJ he u,ys, le~,Uc~,d.y' dtat

'iI!;'iIl-,;a;, ..:;1trm"n"".ii~'h-" iliilli't ... , ct'fioiliii',~;i'"W'!i[ "',i!il ;{ojl'ii!Ui,;j;'~n'il~t', an- -~ IV 'il'inJi'l;t' ·.IJ"f'ii\;EI, ;:"!if. ... ;j:"~II'!;'i[.-\\I" , .... I!" 'iI!l"",~,a'iI!;""", ~w~ ~/:~' - II ~~l!t..____: .~!\L_tl[~ ~-~"1I'IiJI!UiIi_i.J l~g ft ~l!I.I_~]1U'''l .. I _. ['I [LLu..~- ~ '1!.1~ ~, ¥ ~~J'l7; ~ [~~~lIn;",~.

nes~i~' (G: .3 9,S:I., H.~ praises, I~ei, ,lt~iiCfi5 ,as amIable and lev:en lld)lll:tifiW'~'1' (pt71clrtm;~'pi!ili' .and (;~~.,,~S' t-h~m '~~ acd,oo.S ansing: .tttun dl,e, ,incH-, na:tiiOD. tlQ :i],an1il([i' 'w,hi~h :b~ [~~s~w~ere descr;Utt~es ,a8,~ ~~. SJ;lf.i,UhU:-m!iIif~~' ,of: m,a!"ali:ty [IDff :!\61,.,i!l;' En ,f.a~t, ,If we iuppose t'ba,t :Iarrlt holds D, :h,edDmtt.ic theaFf' at ,th,e P:p;jlqlW'q. ~f 10 ~.ctjO'JlS, d(W;~ :&om, b1,cHna'tiAllJ::i\l' ne:~,ther the dist'[lJi'C~ti,([n hetwtee.m. [mre~,t ~d, indh'~Cit in,cUn~dfin;r :llQ(' [~as, :1. ,wnw, shcrw :liIl a, mo:me:m:tll th~ S:~D~r.'~I, ~r'ent of [Grou,nd'worb:: .1~ :m*es, '~IMI1,eh :s.e~s.e, b)s'teai Kalil 'eliOCv,~s:iuws, me 1,C.;t ~f 'tile s,rmpIJthet~c pef~ ,som, la, [o-ne dom,e .WlI' its, 'o-w,n S{iil_ke~, The ,d!euUIre til 5,ymp'iJt"netiic :pe;rsOJ], 't!ik"flls i'n .h~pirl!g: :iSI :D,ot ~~, 'Uhte.,rinf; :PUIr;p~I' '~Uit :1$, :r.adl!eI' dlf; :r,'HSon,

'''''''lb' ''\1' 'L,;:>. ' ..... ""~[~;QC h~'~ It'ltiii'Mfi7. 'jL,; ~ n'il'ii~iDi!i, :Jl1:!1 'p- '~""l"'i[tlu' '1'1"" oil,!!, ft;n,;iIo' '''''jL;a;, nUl' '~~;iI!i, i:"'iI~: "!J.'!I", _~ J: .~~ ,~.JlI.L~~~!r.I1 ~~'-;J!-FJ,~.::~~ l~l.i~' ~.ly-.Llr~~·,J ' . ~ . ,W~au~l ~ ..Ii,'~ ,~ JI .... ~I'l ~~t~, F'-=-·~~·~~~ ~,iJ;

his ~cti;@~ b\1;~. '~he gt'lllu:nd, 1M the ad~puaj], [Qt· DiS pr\llPCse",

And ,the ,person 'w'hi) :he~p:s oth!'!(~ &om cl!Jl!I,ty [,rlso doos, :50' :wr :~,t:s orwn, $31ke:" Lr.~,~ d!~t~' ,m. [q,lleSUm1", as, Ka:mJt~ maikes, ,c"~,ea.r ,elmw:bere'i :is the. d.u~;,' '~O mak!~ the harppi~~eS$ 'of emers, {(nie:~'s, 'e'nd [~G 430,~ Mrv .3 IB,) ,; 38,S}", :I't is '~~,us~ ,~1: thi:~ :sLmila.riLr, fi~ p:u~se· '~ha:t '~he i,m.pI'" tbe~ic per~D!,s a,c'tiOQ !1lre ,1ili~raetfl1'i~ed ,15 t~d~tifuil,~\!' ~e5p:~:tie: the~r'

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'~,;j; ... ~1~ .... ,~ m-::--, .... ~l~ ~W' ~i"[I.~';1..I~ '1'~~~ n:1i'c'liiV' ~ . .,,~: ~'1'l","'if '~'Iif,""'i'II.,J I" ;o"II'i'liI~'_ ,i;·~"~I;j;· ~.'U'~iIff"'f'iI~'""1..fV ,iIi_u,,_A '!<AI; . - - ,'V.lI,""-· " i!d1i~U;I •. ""I,. ,1U11""·.l -';7', I=~"-U'O ~iI" u, .. _II.-y, !I\;!IY-....!!"II' "~~-!,-"",,. g., .'_U,t"g.'W:-~.f

':;i~, 1- ,D~;·ifT'i'ililil:;o"II .... ~'Ii'iIjfi"Il .,..j~ 'iIfiI'i,"jL'i''''Ii'31~'~,'U',li ~~,.;o"IIIIiI~~~ ,~,"f ·il~, ,"IiDI ·.im:;IItWI:~I]-;c~ ~·r;ro~n:~'ijl-:';~ '-roe"",, ~r~ ,~_>;!I< at ",_1 I'.u ..... 1 A 11;;0_1. 'Y_I U. u.l ,lloIiU\IoJD_IiJ,!Ii..iI" ~'!;""I:!IilI!.r.l!'!I.; 1,IIl, ,I);!! Il10_ _ ,1_ ~ _ .r."~' ,,,,,"' ,1_11"":1:"'1,1 ~ I!J! I' 1,lUi ... ,

'Ii..~~,-~ -, ~,~ .. ;(;_~-~. ~. ,~, ~,'-,'1.."--:_--,-,- .·L:~:_;1It ,-,- ·-~C'.';---C',;:.'''C .'." c· .' '-\'-"-' I"]'''''''_~''IC'_''_'I 'c;-t. .--"c" '''-'-'''':l'~i--;:c-: be-

,1!~JI,unaDU,1 .m. O:hl£:f'5w ~iU5,"· .ilS uIJnC(f ,IS, :a, S(lmfw ,a;C~luHln. (1[' lllo.l'.IiiiU;Y ", e

couse :ii't :is a .nlo~i·V\e t-o ·ob~~y· aJ't.ain ~tnct :~iI!.w'S of 'OOOdUiC:~ :£01 '~h~II : ~7"~, -1- Wee ~:I: Sio ,t'h ~, (ttH'-:-:ren ee bet~'::e en ·~·b,e 8l~m·fr!iath.ef ca'n~" h -'~I--:-fol O'WD,_ "Ol_. e e:, ~,l we? ,r-' 11.:"1 C l'L,

pel"SOO. and the dJiIl"toolly he'lp,wl :pe-itson. doos, not [-est ];~ 'tllteb' pur'·' c-:;. ::-:-0 b ~~I~t" 'I-::(;;I-i;- 'l-,,-:-:~-,l~ -:-,~.::1,..-:~:-" 'n' sleads ~ -::- Ii; ti"::-: .~" -. ,ff:-,- ;::.;-::-~ . "C'~~--;;-- r.· p(Jse:), lI;J~l" .mD!S~ I,e C'..lseWnere,,, .il.uIS _us ,D;;an!. 1 .. 0 .nUI! l!I!ei:Ufi-'lll .iPm.p1~\l

'.~nn ;1 . .".,"'- .... :llv· ,It A· .... 1 "''''"'';j;~iF>n ·n;lii.4'n,iliil .... .;fi ,Lfi_1 Id'- -u'-'.v ..JI;ftU:iI;c; ·,.,.ni, ·1!,.,auI"" l~;i.,., ~&-U_~ ,~UII_ ... ~-~_,._\I"i,. ,iirIiJJJ _1I.~!1._~,.: •• ,~_ .. 1 ,lIr...:.IlJIj;U-,·, ,_I _- ~,-u, [1l~[U-il~L_~. " .. ~!Il.·i u.-~~ ,~~.I~'''J ,IHI_1(iiI1'!I!' ... "ll._;IJ!1

·iil"n.T:a~ '~I .~--,,'~ ·ii", the '~'~;nl"'a'~ ·W~·:t.I~""~1-., ]';a, ~ ..... , be /1i· " .... I~e-~{-":".,J ·i;·~r-:-.,.rr.,'i'i'iTl.l ~.~ b~''i'Ii'i: 1;'ii1"

,1_Ui'U-\& JIL 'FJ! Ual "JllIl, 1~_Ml_-'& 11._ _ Ir---rUI3I", -. J]J_Mlj~~ll A:lJ I'~ . '-., A- I]J_Mlt ).'" ~ ~JIl]_ 'UYf.f.I~1 111'1:., . -y~ _"_Ml,

,t'h,c~ ma.xlm by' 'wbii}ch :~t is, de.;iqlUIHIn;.edtJ ~lG 319'~5

T!ll' S;ijv i'halt ·t·lle w1)fth of. an !3,Lcti 0-:11 docs 'n~t' 'Ih~' 'f~ 'its nU'i'FiiAse 'bult

.. '- .•. _. 11"' • ' __ I " •. 1_ .; t" '~-~' . ."."L 1. __ I •. "."L, __ ~" . _:_."' .. 1.-. i ... ~. "."_._ .'.~ .. ' . .; r. _.' .. ' ~.-. t."~ I~!l I •• _ •. ' ~1. '_.J,~-~ .. "." j" ~ '. "_ .. '

in ~irt:s :mui"lni,r' :1.1 m SillY tDalt: i~s, 'wnnh lies im ·the ,gr.a~nds,,~ 'w:ibiclt.~ '~; ,action. aJ).O'~g 'with lieu;, p.~~~ has '~~~. ,Ch.o:s:~ .. ·U:~.rt~na,'t~~~.y, ,il·t

.",'~.'~, 'I'H:l:'~'" '~T'lil i"'\'" '~iIi"mlm; ·.~'ii"t··.· :iU''''T'fiI~: ·~:iIi"II·t.r~-l'Ii.'I'~~iIIl th ~~ 'ild·I.,.,"Ii ~ ~I. "",;>tiI'!ViliH'i"" ,~.~.'rc~ ,,_iliJll_'iI! ,r'"",]J.li!. ,II:,U lY_ili'!w "'-1'0-- . _ ,I!;;;J_ill.' iI'!I.a_"_ili.'~ ,II;U, _il;UU~,,",1!;;'oO!' l!l._ ~i'" ,,-, __ 'I!..!I'J, a: 'cJ_:II_""'_.·U_il-_I!_'~ !!i" iI,lIl-~t_!J~

no 'Ar:e~cmf,on w·i1ia.tever - he :t'ID'n\,u :S!!Il'''''S" i-o raJ. footnote eh,ul1~S~ I",,'

, . ,t-", ,r-' ,],' ,'. ~.,. ,., ,I,t'\.'-l.~' ~- ... iOI.,. ,., ~"., .. ,,~l_'I'

:,j;~\~'iL_1I i-:" ,~,,, . ·:Oi~'ilt.. l'·I.~: i".t·'!I'F: ~ll:,,~LI'lll :' il'l:, ;Il.J""''V' '~~C')'i~'l ,-f: a"taeilIJta!I. it(j .biS· UiIi;IIl-JH usagev. lUIla:"", ,!it ]}'iJ_axUlii ))91 3. ~UIill'Jec,u,_ 'e '1'InC;~.p!l}e, 0:.

VO:Ultio:~,'! (G ~IJ., :[1), £act~, the idea o&..a :maxJ;m is le'sse!mltlal '~O :ltanr)t:~'SI a.uluilDn of the p.fcJb:I.em, 'mf [()bUPlt~nil,,,

Acoo:Hlng: iu Kam.t: l't io:~ll)ws f'mm 'tfi,e tact, ,t'~Iii)t: ,8, :raltiro:nal 'being

·",p""ilil .1'jlili'ind'·~I--- ~·jb.al ·:I:,,.iI'-;o"II1 -f'~· t......,-.j\Jl'i._,..r~, [fO"C c. - ~ 16i"~ t~L;o"II,'j;. ifi:L- ....... ;i;~ .. ;i!~- >Ii --.a~"I;~ --~ .... -

iII"-'''''' - - [WI ·cr '!lin""; .I;!ilI,eilli. {} • liI;l!;eUu\llIi~, ~< ~ 44,01- ·.UiII!':;. duJC ;g~,i;!!< .ili;uI ,II; f'!l.;Q.oo.rI, 'u.[

'~, '--:- ,"I .--: ~"·--:I'-~"C'-"l~,·. 7'~~'~~.-'~ .. '~-. ',''-1,' '-'--~I,.-...ii .. ~ '.~ ... 'Vi;l~'FI'-'-~' ,;··ir~·.j--'i-.iI '"Ij"If;-

On ai. ,p,nnJCI,pe W,lillCIiI, sue, :~rU.!li9lt repl;u. M ~,;O!I,U!nta[!l~y .!auo.pl(eu. ,Ii"til,e.

n-:;~nt: Ih~:ti'C has ·to dQ w~'·t·~ ehe w,a"'~ ,!it t',~;t:"onal bej·lru(;f.· ~u~t ·~h-'i~·d( :;-1' n-:-.ic ,t"UL- e: ,_ .,., .. " ~_ I, __ ,_ _ _~y .. , =JL~ _ _~_~, =,,_~t_., U, ~c(_1r

a,e.OOnB wh~n :s:...[f},e is 'mRoo. m. [~:U.~raltjfjJ.D. ,m.d eheiee, 'W:b~~. you ~~ a. chmc~1' yt'O'~. dQ nm ·v.i~w ',o-urs~H I~ sbnp'l'Y .iNiP~UOO, :in·~.Q i:t by' .is'~g: or im.,~ls~., 'I'ns.t~il~ i~: is as :11' ·th~:re W\~~I~ :s:o-m~tb~ng (J'V.i~J!' Mld [!JJ'bo,v'~ ,~u. !Qf ',QUi[ d~si'ms~, so:m~tibi.n:g 'd~alt :is, y-g~I' ,~~d1. ma;t d~~~d.~s w:ildc:.h :~f: aD,Y' of ,'OIJr desires t)() gr,'Ildfy, 'Ya~. mary:of course c:hooga to act '((Iii ,iI! d.es~·m· but t'tii31Jt does, no-t me3111i 'diJ31t: vou ,iliR ."·m~~UedJ. hv F·t '. It

,-- --, .. ,' ,,-- -- , _ 1. .~' .. .., ,~. _ ... , _ .. , " ~ .. --, ,~ . " ,- _ , ~ -- ,I'''''' , - 1. 1. - ~ ,1'''''' _ -- _ '.f I, ,.

m,ean;8 you take. ·th·is desbe a8 a. 'r;e3lsQ:fii'i' o-ri :~ill, :Kan,'t':8 :~anguaPf you make it '~Wl" maXIm, WI :s.a·ti~lY· thl~ d~s~t-.e~, "b.~. may 'e'V:C::",", c'ilOD!Ri to'

'~ .... i~ l"1riji1 ~~'Ii,",,' ~lt'~i[ji;~~;4" d .. ·~I-:-ifii~'"'id;. '~'Ii'lil~: :ifi'iif~'II]- th ;o"IIj~: does :i[ji;"",,~: 'W~}"'ii"i ·F""a, ~·;j;--;-:-.in ..... J..1

g,.,:, "'""Ie:&: ~ "",'w.J, ,;]!. _1,V,liI,iI>-,;]!·!. .,e~u, ""'o!' 1l!I'!.II!!I:. ", .. I_Ii, 'Ad'" 1!ilI1!.A.cli!' II,'V,,", ,11I:,1",.a.:,U ,I,,,., o'!I.~Ie.n~l,"u

is ·~n,;;;n;ili'l·~~·~,g-: ~,'O":W':t;, "I't': ~~i'II'i'Ii-ilil ·1i:'·iI:--:~t··· ~,'II. ,;o"II'"I'~ t :;o1i·I\.'~nlif ~.t'~Ijji;"""·'b, ..... £' ;0"111 '~-:-:-,a'"i'-Til -, ,~,ul1t"'!;.',I_I'''_II:'1 _:_ .. iI" U~Ol , ,., , .. II:IJ"""'_'U·"" ~_ili_I~;gJ" 1"""'-' @.I!I!;,' ,1I:JI._l\l.c"O "" _'- '!;.<~!I,~!L.U ga< a: ,feiW.,u,u

',Q:r cfb_oosi'Iiri'~: ti@ :sartis~'" one desj:re ·r:a.t'b~f; 'C'b31fii anotb~(- makin-If 'it: '!li!'Our'

~ .. "L .. ~-- .... -._IJ-.b···· ···_·-···:IJ_jl' .. ~. - .. - .. -._ ... l. OI •• -.1. l -···-~··'-'¥'---·"L,----D'·· :1 ... --"

, , -"I, . . ~"" 'i- ..' ,'. I " '..- .. ".' ,,]i, " " 'W'.'" ' "_. ,;o,;Il..,." .. - " " ,

P.1i~m.I.,"O ,;J;~i!i;: l~. yom iSd1'lmg.~:Sl~, u .. ~~:, ~a~r m~m. ·Wlu.:s ~Xp:rl~SiS:~S:

'wb~jt 'fUU t~.e t~1 be ra. F:e:a~ .fQr ,;l;{iiti'Qn~; si'n,¢e r~gn5 1a;f,1~ ·d~r,iiv~d .hn:F!n pl'.inC'~plM~ or l;lIw'5'~ .it l~p:resses, 'yQ1U' 'oonetpti~n ~J a. l,a,w,

:K8i~.t '~li,~l!'~s, m;llt; au' h1JlDl!1'D :at'it.io:n. :is, ~~~oS'i.V\~~ and. so ·tba,t

,~ ~~ ~

I'~-~'" i " ., '", I' ,-''i-, I"'"'''' "',c.,jl' . ',' -',:' ',;j..' ,c'; ",., "'. " 1 ,,;I !,jf!i", 'G."'··,·_.· c ,'~ ·M···· 'ft'J1' .•. iiI!., ~ .' Q .'

~V:~J:'Y .m~m. w a,(;,~o,m, loon",,;I~ns: ,!I!~. ~u [~I.;:!I~~ _:':_' '4~7~' ~'-I'" .'!!. 31;!:!111~ J.g4-~

815:~: Il ,41, A. Dl~'m of. a~M,on. 'wiU tb.emwre US~3UJ·.ha,vc'e tb~ f'Q~.m. ij'I

Copy rig hted m ateri al

[O',n ~-ha'~ :mmm, i'f f'GU, ,;i'~~[ ,ma~e :~.t 7'QUr mmm, l'l't@1 ,;:~l~i~~ pu~\~'!,Jlj' Sbl~e ~hi;s :m.uhn ~OO[ mllWt 00 ad!O'p:t~d ,tor a, re:ason ~he-;f'~ aIJ~ reasens for' haivi'~!s :piU'~5\t w:bi~,h, ue ,lpin [~~r~5iSd, :lJn. ml'x'ims\;, Alt:~lougb K_ar~Jt does :n~t if!Jll'p;haJsi:zie t'ird;s,r. :it: :is, :p~f~bajps, ,elsi;", ,es~, tra ,t'ldn;k. of :mo)'ms, ss liiera_f;~h'icaJU\y [@(f;pn;iled.~' ,t~~: wUI, tilo,

,;i\, .t""~~n'~'r. ,j\. ';j;,n ,;!i .... t.'~"'Vle-. 'jfl~1TTriliMiIi!>ii!i!~,jQ\r,~' ~ Ii!> '''i~lnfi;h!li.J1 ..... jjii; ,tr'~.i!i' t.~li!>i ICJ A~ ,t~'~ ''ilU-{~]-1

IftJ!Ir.'!Ir_"~ .; ,a ~-u !II~"'[Il_~fPiI!I·~J " IrLM-.lllr~~!!ir,ll"· Iii" !A!UUrl'~-u. U,II_~1 ~Jlll-\':!- I]Hg,1.If~ ~j; 1& fll._~-

,ICib/~'e Pu,~},,'pi~ ,~Hll~s, ,a; reLetviant bllmO'dlet~,Ci1'~ '~lm~r,a:t~'Y'eJ'. ,i'~'i'

h" __ 11. ",' .--."r-~"l ~Jf"ll_"." _. 1. , .. ~. l .. _l;!r ... _- .. J1. __ l~ ;tf'lr.l. ._Il~.,. 11

'wiU ,a;c:me'~'e ~~\,,'~'j is, m tum ad@;p~~dl 0;11, 'tb,e ba:siJs oj ,I fUL~d1Je[ :m~xim dt~,'t "'I 'wi~[ m~k~ i'~ :m'~' :';UI~ '~O hav~ d"iu~. 'dr.b~IS' 'dta't E d~ij1"e~'j [or.' 'w'h~~~~er.' ,i,'t :n1'~rs:b~ '~,

"'j"L."".!"ii:li;ii: Olr['O:!; ,~, ... jL ""'-, 1't' ""'''''iI'' ;t",,,,ViI>; '4\'L,~ ,t, ,jIO'jL "'" ,d' "I cfl"''I'.iI:Ii .... ;ro ... , '~:.' <!!'..-!l"'\i:Ii""',,", i",'L.,g. [""V'-_,""

~g-~~~!I!r.--~~~~.P ',"",~t~_~~ ·A·~,~,I~l ~I~ ~ IlklliJ..~~ ~_~~~ .~.~{g;'I§_~~_~~~ 1~~~~!I§-!I§~, ~~ I~,'j~~

'n,t'Ii*,'L'~ii·i ... 'lI'iiI'i'I'C';""-II"i' '''''''''11 ~'h'-"'" '~'""""-~f"'·I~": 'n.i!!i'I';"'if'''n '''~''-lIi'c ';1"', ,.,'L,,,,,,~, .. , ..... , ... , ... ~, ..... ! .. , ,.,'t.'A

11-~'~~'~~~!!r ,~-~~l~~_~' I~~~' l~,~~ gl~I~LiW ,f!-~_~I~~.___:__. ~l~_~~~ ,~-~~ glb~-'u ~_~~~·lL.~HII, . ....".__:_..t_i! ~[[ill~,

[ ... \ifiln··'''i',.. .... ;i.'!i4i' '11.,"", 'jL,~;t" 1·'''' 'm-' [1·, ... ...]1 ,iii'" ,,",L~;t". ""'~I!",'L"""lI,.ID'b[ ,,..'jL.,.;, "''Ufm.'n .. ,''tjL.i:Ii'''~'''' '1'Iiiil'i1'"j;!'''''''' ~.___:___:~_~~~ ~~ ,~~ ~,IJLI, .~- .. 1 :~IJLlg ,~~I l~nr~~~ 1~~,:g}"4r.~~. ~WI~ ~,' ~:~j~~I11§;~~,~ ,~-~-'_;I~~M

and ,t'be d,u.df'~.d 'pe;f.Sfi~~ '~fh lli:unrteJ 't'~e '~nwq:ul.s:e.; ~n he.~lp-~Dg QtheJts.~, 'ttJe:y' :ha,~e :il:dio.,t~d, thiS! pu~se [Bn dilere.[[i,t grounds, ,,(,be s,y:mpa,-

,;j;'~~:tJ~i'" 'npT:f;\tjiL-nl ,Il!lif>,p'i!jj 'jk,:":lln~in,i7 ,;ii,jjo iC!~m:c[~~':l..'iiji'i;'D' nll")~;!iIii!'t ... ftiiii ,!;ii~4. t"~l;iil~' ,il!D, '"'1!IN'.:'~u' !IiJIl:lt~'!'dIUIi.i!I Ir-'!r.'iIo~IIoZ"_1J ra~~.al .lI;J_g,~ill-"=--e &I_a ~ _ . ~1 .. _I~l_II_IIi_"~ i._~ !I.F.M_~_;I=1J'II.4I!1 &I_III, .. ;\i . _"~~_IIiIII" lll~ "'~)ll"

he makle:s: it hl'~ ,e.mA:it The :mo:t-a'Wl, wo:rtb:" pe:f;SfiH, !Sees, helping' ,diS fSO'me.:t11mg caUed ffi~~ IDl' ne~8aI1f ,amd dliB! :15, wbart, :mad~:a;ttes :him ,to ma:kie :i.t: hi'S! etitd,.l~

,A, common. cfim,:~atlli,t: :~s ,t'ba,t: ,t'his, s,ugges(tis d'l.a,t ,a ~pe.J:)sun, w'boO[ b,e:~ps, '~~lr.'ct~nd~ aInd, with it ~t~f~ U~1'ier; rl~ cis, 'mo.t;a11'~' 'be,tter tt'hm one w'llo,

,fe .u, - -" _:.., ,- - ,,' ~ ~, , _ .. ,-~ - .. ,t"1t'. ,,_lit<', - - _ .. t. - - 'I' " ..... , ,- _. - _. ,,_.. - -' ,_ ...

d~es, ;!itu, ,ghu.ily ,a'liid :&lrull, i:9Jpo.l1,mll!e~UiS 'Hne,.,'Ojert~e:; ,iitlild '~b_a,t ,t'bis, is! both uni;~t:U!i:ti,,,e and '~naUf;ajet_hVte" Tbl~ [oo~!p~aio,t~ h~w~'V'I~t is ba-ed ~ a: 11 ... ~s:r.:~[i~euta'nd~;ii'i.D' o:~ Kall1t~S, no;m[l't .. , 'Dl,e-;l'e; ,I~ tbooe 'imnm; .. ,

'" _5, , .. ,. ,,' . __ ~_ ,u_n"" " ... __ "_~'U'~" , .,._. L ',r" .,~-_ .. , • "-,,,' "-, ,-_. L ... ,--- r ,,'

'tiliilt mi;m.gs, '~U ItememlK4':;, IIlu,t} Ka'~.t: 'ma'k',es, :It: C::leiii[ ,tha't t~,e fea~fi he co:m.tr;as1ts cases of :na,mralliffec1tlfifi 'with [C~:5 'w:he4\c ,t'be~ met~,~e of dttu:y 0:, Clates, j'm, ·t~e ,a'b&enoe of: n:a.t:USlal Biff.'ec;cioIJ, is: t'tiiaJt ,the [oper,s,'·' 'ti,Oil, (r.f' the ,mnthre oJ Id,tlity :is especi,aU" 'obvio,us in, d~.e :la,'tter ltind oJ use;" De5"~,t-e t~be :mis'~ndefS'tDdl~ngs 'to 'wb;~CJb dd's s,t=lia'~egy gives n~ ,the ,eS5efi'tbd dit-fer;en;tc~ betw'ee:m, d'le nt10 people omnLt[:as~H, does, n~t :resit i'r~, 'W'betitoeT d~.e :~.elpbii,g; [acti,fin, :~s ,e:Gif:G,-ed. It r'C-$tB! i'n, 'whetb,ec<t one he:~;p51 finly 'bec'8,Urse 'of tbls enJ:Crf.meo!t: air b«::aJute hemp :~$ perce:tved as, ,so:met'bi'rrg :~,t :is :necesS8iIf' t',O[ live", N~1h~l: :plleven'ts, an acdo:m, :h1o:m, being: don,e, :&om, the mD'tl,~e of: dI~,tf, by- s-om,eone in w:h,om, s;y.mrpa't'ib,y' is ~lsD ,;rem1!t;. ,Attl1!i1aU,,~ w,e m,Uist. d~$tinplm, ~;W'O

~;j[Q"")C!, 'i71.ti!7.J:i1' ~..;or""~' '~[~:iTl.l~' 1.."", ,;'Ii p-:b_'i'"'" '~in'- ,~l.nm'-.-l iE"~im-!:i,";l.f1t ;f!iI!!!n:l\Qif'; ,;!i;iIl!, .nI, '!ir.1IiII_ .... ~-iJ! ,1l1~_J"'!\r.. .I. ,Inb .. _ 'W ,1II~LlH.~1J1111J UC; !Ill .. ~~_UJ ,111_ _ '" U-y , ~ 1- -1r.r.-JUi',l ~-\I=_~ ·!P.'L~~ ~.~ I~

S!1l,p,p,]}emellitary ,fir ~-go;peta'ting: m,oti've 'th:ait~ :p:r.,ovides, needed SiUi"OR

'iJl.-y, ... :'r.ii:i; m-c ,'''';;;'ii-p\;iO; of du -'~V', ~1~[C!f 'f!IjP"i",taJ;f[I,ft[',g. 'm~,~:- fi'il!i-Jii~l"'c!j ,a- 'i:¥" i.'iif"i.n,U"" 'iii"'" '~In'- ~'h:;tI;

ItUiIo '!L(~~ _ ~l"_. '!I'l"'Ir,I ..t-J UJ. ''''",r, I, L_IJ_II_a. 1~·~'.10 a!l.l'-.Io_1J l~ . _ ~Y.·!I!J ~1I,'1Iir. iLlJlli&JFiIJ,'!I.Itr ,111_, l. !IwI

Copy rig hted m ateri al

,A'-,al··-·'Il!'~l~'i:l' [n;f'~ 0,-: ·b--,~,~·"~'t-'I\A'n

.AJJJ_. _ ,,.. ~~ID.! llU"i" 1 - .J .. ~. _ tU~ ~l

·t· CIi ~17

iStmSe; de;v:e] nn ed, in ReJi'Qi'aIl: 'W~':th:in :the,; Umrii§' 0'" itea',s'-tiil' Alon~, and.

--", .. - .. ~ .. -}~~ ... _ .. __ l.l.f .. ,_.~_. -=-= ._l"""'l~~~~ ~~~ =~.~-~-~.~~.~ ~1 ~~--~.~~'-=-~~==~~.~-,~ ~~~

1!..., , ...... .,..,t'I;~ -iI. i"'I'~* _, """ 'l:'I;;['i,.: :_1;W\~V,C" ,d' ~, th~ b.~ln.inG" ,aC'tl~n w'h.~m r~ui~d. ,m

lli_l,.. '!I!!I!'~M;JIW 1::.V'"l. L~~ L"_"JW'~ ~ ~ ~ "'_j,' ~l~ ._l¥ _~-~ ~~~~~, ~ ~ ~-~~= .. =~~-~ ~'~, ~~-~~ ~ ~

:i!iFYH.I'-::-~P_'-j'j;fo;'ty· ,"l~,-iI 'i'Ii'i,!,4\, ;i!i."i'!II!>iII!~ :i'liii!i~ ,"1 '~:'~,op, -,[ ""~~in·iIf.y, i II:~' "Ii4il-'_ Tb' I' .~;i!I: ,~AiQ~;J",: ... t"~;o1i~"lIil

IiJ! __ l!ll}!Ir_l~I,. UJ_I.-U [L-_._U~ ~;J. ~'!Ir. R9- ~ ... - . !li:V itI.lIl~~ ~ ~_ j~ • l~_'~ ~~_ ~~-tll~-!9_~

~''____: •• l"""i' ~ ,_.'. lJ

.• ~ penon'ls mm.M w<m'h, :B'U'!t; ~theI' ~~n i'I~, 'wb~ S",ml~thy ~s' trl'.-l'esent m'li~ht 'H; nuui'v:atle:d. ·e~tind)v- ,~, ,at 'I~ast: .s,Id'ficien!d'!lf'. bv '~'be:

lr"O .. _J •• l .... :... .. l ..... __ r ••• - •• w._~ ••. "._ .... =~ ... ~,,~ _. ~~ l."""! ••. ~ •••• '"'~~-~"-~'-~'~I'l~ "." ._I.

~mmi,,,e [of duty.:; so' 'thralt s.he wo,ulldJ do ~h~ :h~lpinl a~t~Q:~ '~~In if. isnmna.dlv' 'w-e.;m not ·"'Rs.en.t. 'This ·~~son. has meral word]., ~;~lt: 'her

"0' -lr!-·· 1., .... "l.:~ •• ~~ • ,~ ••••• -~~w~ =-=~- ,If~~'--~~ ~-~~ _~~~~~ .. ~~~-~ ~._ ... I:_~-:"":.l

:nlii.1irv~ :~rrn----p;imy wnl'OOnI~rib-ult~ lQ' :h~:r ~njQy:m,~n't 01: d!l,~ ·lc~hJn,

'H' l'II"'ii· .. ·'jIlIi!l]',~1I' "", ilJi@~-"'."'"'e-i1 'nn'm"', '-iii" "I!'" ,-'';:!in '-,n:II'~ ,"'."..o;n"",p.''''n--''' jIT ... , ..... , 'Ii~ '1ii', ... ,~'IL,m" ,-'01'

~ ~y. n ~~ ~~~ ~. ~c~g, F_~l~. ~l ,~~I ~ ¥ ~_~ ,~rM'Y~}~ ~~,~!IJr~,t!.~~.:_. ~!!, ~J~l ,~ ~~LKL-~~

'hlim aoout ·th@ cnnundJs '1m 'whi~~ a 'n,ni~' is .3.don'Ii~~ and h,£l)d W~

'_. __ -~ _ .~~.·~.·L~ ~~ l_~c_. [~"~·L~~~_~.~. '~-_'~' . ~,~_,,~-. [_ Jff'~',r·~·~-~ ~._. __ -._ ,~,~ .. ~~l ~ ~._ ~_I _~ _-~-_ Ii!!' ~ -e- _

'!liWtI.IIIi;c'toJ':,~*,i'n;IJ'I;I~,(!;'h 'L~iiiow~~n 'tDe; l!m.ntitliUiiC 'f~fliHn'~ _d (lesues w'bit"!'h

'~_H~~' ~~~'"_~~~~~~~ ~~, ",~,~,~~ ~_ II ~ [·~-~~~-~~~-.:.:.~u[ ,~,~-~-'~b~". '~J~-~ '~--=..~-._"J._:,._ ._,_,,~I I~:~

'J1'nmpt '!.!IS, to ,j:fdn,t ,a p,l.UJI'QS~ ,.d ilft.Qs~ '~:aJt: ,r~~;ldir~ from: -(h~ ,adQP'"

=' ~ '_" ~ =' '_'

.• ~ -, .... 1( ",. ·jIfi,1i'.'im'ili'\iiifr.ili 0,' '.It''Iiil"iiIII' '1iI\1'1ii.i~ ·jL:-v... adfiftt@d a nu't'N'is~ _d 'L ....... ii"iiRl"" wJ~_.J. Vii; R r-~lllJ,~~_~~' ' .. ~~-~ 1" ~~, ~~~. ~ I~-,_:_-~,r'---="''':_' ~. lrl_:_~F-~~ ~ ,~~-~ ~_"Ir.I_y~[1 '~

isenled. 'in j·ts, ·tM'11B1liltl-, Ceft;rlD '!!.lmo:tbJnl .!iI!nd f:~li:~or~ 'wnl :na.m[aU~'

. ._ .... [ __ I I ... lr'~ I .. __ I .. J . ,. I., l .. -~_,- .. :.=r. _ •• _~.~ ~ •••• , __ ----,~ __ = ~ ... ~·~I·_·~/·

:re~ult., 1m. :parti;cutallj .i~, oIdi;~arlY (:,l[Cjum!S'mrIlJ~eS the; ~dva'Il'cell1;eltt ,o.j ,ac:iiecveMeDilt: [nf 1fhe~ ~u~~ wUI lllake; ,()~. hpn:~, r~iD'~'rd]l~ss 0:1

lr' -IIiI.lF~ ~ ~rr[1!r. ~e--

whethcf;' YDU ao"ted i;t ,oj'j!glfiJaU, :&om, :rtalfllml ~i'~'c:Hna,'tiiQIl, ,U :&om,

dLllr"'''': So a dAatifu] '~-;l','timl_, 1!'iho, af~e.r; aU 'RaiU~ dIMS, 'value d'le: bl~ii·'"

,. _.L!l.11~1 , ••. , ._ •• _'J. __ • __ , tF~, W!W'i:.~~p. _ [_ r •• __ , •••• 1 • 1 [1 •• -. ,:/ .~- ••• , •• ~ ._.1 _ •••• - - r., [- --'~r.'

'&e:SI'M odl~rt- 'wiU :dl!!'l~~~e t.ak~ t'fIol@.aJSl1Im 'in 'maJdnlD: ,oth~n ha!~,w,n,

=. - -~ ~ .. - J •• -.'J"1J! ~~~, _~ .. ~ .. :JIV~ --~-~., F'~~~-~-~_ =~~~~-~~' - -~ ~.~ ~~,~'F,'~

This :~s; ~, :~iQ.'t '~'Q,t K:a~n :~es ~pU'dd).)r h~. :hi5! l~ter ,~~'hi.Gll. 'wlitmD'Ji:j., For :~nstanc@ ,m ':rb,e ,Me:!'anhu~'csJ .h~rtejnl'~ o'~ 'Virtue

- ~ ~ ~~ ~~. ~ ~ ~ ~ - ~~ - _. ~ ~ ~ -'I ~ -~ -.~ ~ . ~ - - . J?"'" ,J'" - -" ' - ,li.'" . - ~ t '_. -"

'whem lun:t is Cl:'xn'll:aimi'(!iQ' dIe dl!ltu m 'oo.nefiooni"!;e 'he s_viS'"

_-~':_'_c __ ~~, ~e.__:~~..::: t-~· .~~.__;;~,~~~,:_:J~,,__!~1;f. L ~.~ ~_-~ I~~J<' ::. J L~· •. ~_';.~c~_1 " t~.-.~_._;. cv..~,. "~. ,._ ~ ~_',' ~.l.1

Copy rig hted m ateri al

C:Js~s,:in. 'w'hi~"~1 th.;!I! 'm"';i!'IItclfV\~ ,'1"~:~ln*",~ ;ifi;~'~'ijila.e. ,r'Ii''''\iI'"\i;''i~~''i'liI--;' tin, i:T',~r'I,i; 'i.~:-:- :.':0:':, ~ _ ~ .... _ ~_ _. ~_g-.J! _~""' ,~'I!.!'. ,Id . ""' ~L u,~"y ~~illu,~..,.r A II;;I!I,;,-U11illl",,",g, I ....... Aa:m,,-lI' ~C:;lj'I!II5e

m~ a;.d)\rianCeme:fii!t of the :ha"p:~necSS: lfif: ,ot'beJ";5: :is, HI' c1.d,y' ,cGnedvled, :as,

."""'\if';D"~jCi'<II1:'V 'rtir.i,,",'\);CIJi' ';i;'If'oD:, m ,a~'l,v n,L·J;!:>. ... ~'iii 'Pu" 'iii, ,~"l!:I,,4i'L.;.;p, lii"'!:""'~, ''''l'IIO:D'~~'iIi'"', r:'~I"'I~' ~1~'!Ir.~-~,-m_"'J '~IQfU~'__lIl !Ii.:Ill]~Q_ , ~III!Iir_ l'; r !I..r.tIiI_. ~II.U.~ ,~_'_:'&~I:l~.& ~ ~~~~_~ iUJ~l~l

1m [Oi::dl~fia:~' looJ'.ulitJQE.s, :QJ, dJU~jluil, ,ptrsOIl1), 'wiU :~ot :b~,Y\~ th.~ ~nlUl,t"iiMS, ~~,OJ;;l~iaJly [wfisequ,en,'[ upon, ,t'he~ :adCJptti,om, of ,s. :p~!rpD:~;!' :indJudm,l: ~n~ -j;o,m,e[u [0£ its, s;u£~e~m.l~, :puI;S'Uitji and jm]l' in, ,j,'ts :reiiU~a;ti,iOn.

[On!~ t'ilI!8 is, ,~lcapt~dt the in,'tud:t:1,on 'b:JDnd. ,t'h,e ~(lmmo~, ~(JlIl]i." 'n.,l·1ili'l'fiI~: ;Ci'~'R'iilli~ld··~ ~":"ij'm:"'n~iiIi! ,;ot,'"'Iild.'~1 t,,~~~, ,~_ the 'iii'~~'FI '"I:':~(,;;; .'iii "'II:i" ;:;.'\';;' ~. ~ .t'~!ILJ~I!, ~I~h."'''''''.~ .. ""''U',1i1i;grO~.; 11'11:&:. .ulS ,~s ene "ililll;U ,lm~r!l<i3im",.. ,p,O'Jn!l;., .Jj,ntl:

1~m:p[laiDt: is It;a!se-d, OIl 'diJ,e; 'U.!S'~3il misf;ea:dl~DI of: the eum,:~,esw m, 'w:hic_b; tb,e peJ":SM 'W·~·U)I aces UQm, Id;lliy' is envisIoned .as someo:n~ 'whQ does not J:ieaUy have~ the :h~f:pi~e~~[ of: ,@t'h,ers :as, :hls lend. LThis, .is ~:dm,1y ::!, :mj:st~k)i:. DJj,it;f' :is filO't a, ,m"el~nt P'lUJI'Osel, bU'~ a IWH,_t grn'iJim.d, :f~J 't'he. ,adop~joll, lat~ [;I pU'~~!, .so :[K:an't"':9 id~, :heJfe; li9 ca,u~u"ed !bet~t'tF.' ''>" ,S~'Y'~DI, d~~lt th~ S'Jm,pl!~1h~:t~~, ~~~n~[$ ,mO't~,v,~ Is s&6JloWQ' tbMl, th~ morally wormy FI';S~";s:~ bo~ 'want tl)' be{t,P;. 'hu!!: d~,e[~ :IS :;,V[!1'~ll;b~~ ,~j. I'Uf,tlJef.l' s~tmt~h of 11iHltivatlng, t'h@Dgb.t :eMU!: ii,el:pl:ng wbicih, t'b~~ 'me;td~' rs:~mn31Jthetj~, ~f;~Il bas 0:-11' le"nlif:"-:~cd, :;'·)I,.~~ ThiJ~[

.. _~_ .. ~ ~-" =,'" , '~''r",,1. ,r-" .... " . Jc,,"'"'Oage .!lm." ,,5

~rdl~r srretch of tha~,gb~t eoncems ehe SO:K of w'mld, w:~i'ch, ,t'Ms, 'w1ilU'~.d, be .if no [O',m.e ,hd~,~, =', QI 'kue'[.j if :!mO [OO~ Pflr(i~j;Y'ed '(he n.eed f,rif; ffileJlp ,as, a red~on :t~ ~elp~[ O.l' 3 daicR1. [@on ,hd,. S~(;b ,;I 'world. 'w,(!'Illlltl, be 'iI!lna(H,}eptabl~ '~:u'S~ W~ r~prd, 'O'~r Q'lwn needs as, ,reaso;~s, w:b:, ~W~ sh(Ju'~d, b@'. he'~lned [~(;;, ,A.:1).~·; MPV ,.4I,~ "t :Re;"'~lmhl°;' 'mu '~eeds ,a~'" ::-Hll'~-

... ~ ~~ .. _ ~ ~~~~,!y_~ .•.. '"t~~,~ ~ == . "t'.JJ~~~'~"-JI:!I"'"'' ,:mIO, .. 8,

UV~ ,W!I' !l~b~ISll' !Or], as Ka![);t ,p~,ts itt. :makJng 'myiSe{~f, aID, [end ,101' c()tbe.;t9i~, 1: ~'~s:~ r~pl\'d 'me needs ~d' lot;'liiiers ,iliS! ~fii,oUUaJJti::y'e f'O;f:' me (,M:P'V l'9[3[:~J'~' ,And ,tJb.is, is eo say ·dlat ehe needs of: others, ,are a :~8!W' to m,e", ~[ the m-O:l',aUy 'W~ft'~,y pe~fi :tu~J:ps 'bearllse ,she; beli,eves] 'thalt: 'di,~ n~$[ 01' cth.em 1D3iki!:; ,3, claim, on :het' ~fid, ~[ ,t'h~lt: '~,eile :i$, a, n()~miltci'v~ d~m~d1' ;i!'iJ' r'lil, '~:",'W'~ ,ti'h~[;o'I'~, ;It:;~~; IIfiI:U~"In;'i!:o,i; ~~ '~e:-~l'n,. "'II':~~;." cj~'.;.rCjOj;.r<:;.\i!iI;r~""\"'I··l·j"'1i'''' ~~' r,L~ n"l"IID'1Ii' ,!",f",' 'I!.!I~ !Ill! 'W'''''~''''~';I' I'. ,8;'1:. D.iliil,.. U'. i!!lril'," '"u ,iIi!l, . ,r' 11, I1!1oD .. ~]jI ~1!I,i ,,~,~)~ !I;!I'~~, y.~ m..,. ,IFc!l;ll',~-~ '" y_

d},e 19'am,pte brings us t~ ,lC~~UU~I'lS, ,t'hird, prop'@Si'Ui@~ 'w'hidh i~ m~lt: '~)'Dut,Y':I:3 ,t'ihe~ ne~~~h:y of: ::iill a,c.tJio:(ru, [ex~Q~,t~, h@m, :~spe~t fer.f illa,w"'l ~'G': ~""""~l

k,-:: 4]JV~·

Niowa,t this :po!i:rnt :~.'t 1:5 e$se:n"t~~llt:o "m~ID'~1' '~'ha,t 'W:ihitt fltMJt is, dlllng is .3, ,mQti'v!a;tiO,1il~' ()Jjjaly~'i:~ of' the nQtio~, [~f d~,ty [~' :d:s1bc·ne.~, Kai_f:l't i~ ;ana'~,y,zm.g: ,t'he ,good, 'wiU~, ,cih.tc~:e!l'i~~ ,I~ [~n~ th;li~: does, 'Wblt

~;ifil ,,,,,: ... ;I!:.t;. '~":JjO'ouc ise '~'" ~,1fIJ ,~...,'Ii]..~ m',·", ... ~lg"l' ~~, [.:I':Ii<''''i?:'''.'''r ,..;''ci::l! '1M'~1,..,,.'iiili"ii'~liiIIj. A~ '.'ii1r" .... ""'~'"' =-~ Jll~_ill~ ~'!ir.gf. _0. .. "I!Ii. lI.'i;I! .~,~~j~~~, ~;[U~~, l~~ w-~~-~·,,~-~. ~c~ ,~~,~~ .. -IJ~,~~_r.llr' ~i_t, ~~_'~ViIUll

,(Ut~oHa.ll,y good, a£~ti,Qn.~~' The :a$SuDlpt~on, !bmind ~~Hlcib, ,atm, ~.al'91i:a] is, t;1hait d~e tSIQ}son why ,a' ,good,,:wt11ied ,P~1:'~O'~1 ,dQe~ ~' ~~tliaa. [i!lnld :rD~ re'l1.\9on 'w.f.!" :t.&e ac;ti:on i;s' n:gibt,~ tite ;th"e ,\Sl~'I~. Th~ HOOd··;willed :pe!fson dQ~s, d1ie dgbt: 'dling becllwse: it: :~s 't'~,e, ript 't'b.in&, so ,U: 'W~ ~ dis,..

Copy rig hted m ateri al

~,::,~c:,-,,"~ :'I-l~:: '~h~; g;""r"i"'.;II,,.,~:,:r~led '~-;t:mll dOOI, '~t~ 'w,@ 'w:iU :harve: i~f;liia ~~~~:al !Ij;lOV,(::J w, y, e e.,u!!lAI! Wil~ .I!"--~ _~~~~, "~ "~~ ~~- , ~ '"*"'~ ~ r~~ ~ ~ ~

di;SQ~V~IOO, 'w'hi, :U is the ri,p:t thm,g~, Wbar~: 'I.:'ll«:: :af:.ialJi~is, :r'e'veals bii tb31t. du~; reasan w:h,' 't'~,e~ ,~0Od~iW[UOO petSOTII d~ the act=io'11J is, :~ot: :me:Jelly L-;t'Oi"Iiil~l1ilifi" iit' iD~l'V';lI!~ ~hii.:s or maIl!: '1!!i!1Ii~' 'hut 'becill!iiSe U is neceS<83.'i:V ,=

11JG_~gl~ ~l'l ~!Ijr.I_~ ~ II!P.I:~ ~~~_. _'_' _ ~ __ ._ [~' _""~.~-~--.,,. .. l ..• -. _ ..• , •. J "_" ••• - _ •• ,

'~:~a.t iJS, ])1; is, a la'w' = '~O :~.d(J:I'Jll, $ucih, ,3111. iiic~]Gn IGr' '~D hai¥'C 8'uc~b, ,iii! p.,~~" The m.axbtl ~J '~,e ,8;tti~:n.. o:f; 't'b,Ci 'marx1m (;:I: '~'ile J;nl'~~ :ha81

~ JI: .. ~t·'· ,[, ' .. ·l..··,l'~11 ~·,l~'~11 ~ ,1i'~II~,~·~l <b,~ --~~j,~~"'J,~ ';i','Ik~'··~·t_·, .ili!; ,"iii, "iIi] 'i:liJJi"i.-_l!'!ilj;·~',col\illi ~,1Ii' 'ilkliil .. , .... '!i!i W,lfla_, '~ i:U.~!1 .. w, Cai.w, Iii, ~',w,ep •. l!i:oJ;iliiillfiliCI.;:er--. ,..na, lA,",1 ,II" ];0 ,~_~"v.~;!I'J.J_""'J~""-lr- ~!!i" ~~

,;j;'Ilo..~, C'/i'~ "C:"l't~j i·c' (~~" ..~""Q;~' ,~ ,;.:i .... "'i1ii(i;, .. ii'i~i 'iI!li""~~i!Ii' oT"oi "I'i~ ~C.iinli'ii!I;, '''i''jL~, '~lIIi;iJ'~] '11.. "'I!''".

Iic~~,e C3i,p,aC~'~,f l~lO' ~r....as :ii, ~-'IoIliI"'~~U, ,lIiuiiRI"", 'U'U 'WoO', ,""I'_. , .... '!Ior I~JIi_b ••. Ii".~" !U-'~~

",.,..,;j;,~r' o:~ ,~'~.a, ~':a-'iit:~'ifri, '~iii' ~W:'lik,i'i* '~,,",~Jiiij,;o'Ii'fc;<>_i!:i, '~'il..'!i!i ~,":'i"~~1~'W;~1(]~~ '~,'i',I'ilWil~ C~lJf' is,

.~~~, __:_i: !I!-_~I~ ~.HI __ ~_.1U .• L~ ,.,.J']_"l~ 11J_1II:.IJ~ur,"_II·"·A~-"!iJI! 1!!lI_~]t1llP. ,~~ '_'_L~_:IJ_i~-IIia!I, ,r~--jJ .. ~~p. L"l!l!, [Ii- ..

,tlflat ~1md 'notDi'rng ,else d'iiit" m.akle:c5 't~e action fir' 't'~e 'rw~·l!IiFiVlse '~'i~j~lt'~

.~,,__!:____'-'-~J [~-~-- ,__'__j-·---._->~:_'__!t~ ----~ .. ~'J ._~JI-_}J ,~)-_~ .. _ . __ r .. " .l_-t-.~' .-.' . __ 'r. r' --iIIlr'!i.i!"- . 11,~_~ •. iP.

'Kmt'~s amalvsls'iden:tiles Hte ,~,~'lJr.me8s, o~ 'fhe actl:um n&~~nlrl:aU~ wit'h

,_- ._)~l ~.[ __ -_·~_._,l.-c--~"'-I- ~-~._._._~-~.~~. __ ,1.~~_1I, .. , . ,- .. 1 __ . ""- .. _r ••• _] .••.••• _l._J_--".,:f.' ~~ 1 __ ,

'iI"L;iI!; If!!gI~;~" ;ii"!;L -'.'",,,,,,II'\iIIII' .""J:: "i';·", ,,,.. "' .... ~'m' , !I<_I·n~ J~~'_j vU\i:lJJF~-v'~-~ ~ ,~,~~ ,~~II: I •.

:Nr .... w ,comes, t'IITJ_,e ~ri.ti~ S.t-ePI. lit; foUows, ,tD!'it; 't!lrle maxim, :mU91f:: :rnot: 'iIJ,4i1' 'Ililifi] l·I~Di"';'1 ,,",'L,'I;ir:~~1':i~r.' ,L."-'m am ..... 'h~'m~· !Ou,tslde fit '~tcseU 'P'OI if 't'hCi'lC

8.?Iir.'l~ lll!lr.:~ . -~~,RJ_I, [~IJ._,,~g.~J_~~ HU_, I, --.______j7 ~,1_~-~1I!1 '_.1 __ J._~_)_1 . _' I, ,, "._ ,I .... ' ' .. jIl' '-', . ~ -' c. ';'- '.

were arn 'O'~ftls.id~ :sg-U!w~ of le.'n ,chaJracte1~ thClal ,t'ha,t~ 1SD-Uiroe,j' ,r.aith.er 'ftlhan '~-~\!I;I ,cl1aJ'a[ih~!I' 'Its:~U: w(: .. u'~d be w'ffi'lat' ma:k,es die at.t'ifiil '[]:";li.lt'

.~_ ~~~ ._. _ I. __ .• = '_'_-_ .. _- __ (j.] ...... _. ' _ .. _. . "_" __ t ~ ,. __ . __ ,_ ... , I_ .. _. _ I. _, I ~ ~.I ,Po

~!'!Il;S,t~,lti,~, '~'ihe m_a~xhn~~ l~pl ~h;n:~c;ter :~u~t; .~ :iDilril'il$ic::: ,i:t m,U'5t, b_ar,V'~ 'wb;Jjjt; ]: s!hdl'l;iiaJll a (~I~,w'UU(:e :t~rm,. 1~' Tbis :~$, wby le\ga'~, cinar:a<:~te:r;.. or' un'~'l\!'>rj'~;s'tdl'f~'. '"li'ust, be Iiirod)crS:iJood as, 'hlw~ike 'lonlii., ~h:a,t '~s., ,3;81 liI

._~, _~' '~ _ ~- .. ~_._'~l[J'J.. ~.~.~ •. ~_.~. _~ _ .~. "_ .. ' _-' _" ,.. .. -_" ,- I.", __ ,_. ,f .. 11 __ ~l I .. I _ .~J .- • I

RQj!ld~Ulmienr~: of, ~l1iv·~;rr.s'QJJi~~bili:t;y", Karn't dr;a,w:$, this cOll,elwslofi tntra 'W'a,lt~

,ShlC~ :1, :ba~'C m\!~d. dl,c w,i'~I, 01' ,a'WW, :~m:p\!JW8ies -wffi]ricJn C(itW_~~, Qi1l1le ~o i,t: f~\am o'Mdi@Ace to raillY' liiW~ not'lti__ng ie __ aims tt]l ~'L~ ~:!3' ~ p;rj.~.c~,~~ ~i t'~ 'wiU I~~~t: 'ooivmal. leo:m:~j)t;r' of irt., ,a(:;UQD to,larw 11!l StlW,,, 'niit; :~.$~, I sho:~.tdJ ;~vcr' .3~t h]J ~sucb, ,ii, W\l~ 'th:aLt. I c:(},1!'md ~n,ot ,a~so 'wim_l, ~hrttt: MY mrll~im :s!hauld R ~

~'I £ 1 '~. ~

'MI,vemal, ,:Q!,W;, :rMb~re oon:;Dm1!i~ '~ mrw' ,!:I~ :~u.ci__ [I:wi)t~~oo~ ,a~lII!mi~; ,a-"y parr'"

'ti~l!lilaf :IDiI,W ~p:-p~~.~'aib1~ t~ ~r.tiari!n. a,€ti~sl :~rv~ as it'h~ prlBcl!'p~£ o~~ t'b,@i wiL~r and it; ;m,u~t~ sc;-rvc IS, !!KIl, ,ra, principle ~_f duty' is '1JWt: 'm 'be a 'v,~m d~'~ti~Olil ,an~ '1;:17liiImedcaJ e~~.GQ1:!, ~G 4Q'~l[

~. -;-, ".~c 'i::{~: rl~' .···-iI"'l~,~:,~~,_;, '-'['" 'II "·ii""~1..: : ":,r I.', ".~, ' " '~'] i' i':,L1i;, rlL .:

Ji,ne ,pmnt .IS ,s, u.e~,c:a,t-e nne, ron ,fn~~u,t s.m,pose,j at ,l!ll'stlt ILUiil!t me

'k---:;-l~. <t.n::~:"'i·~r' b'.··~( ~'~~Ci):<~1 ''f'~.;:i, g' ~~ ... ;oI~';i;!.-";~'·I;i(Od'~1 'n~~1i'jrt1i1 ,~, HlriIii"iil~"V\'5ii'\ll!~, ;r; .... 11~'li-l:

,Ile_ga iC;uaJf8iJl:ieI1 W,IIIICI!iIi, 111.111"", ' .. uuu.~ lu,-, . !t--1!;.-,l!il!l!.lI\liIi ,UJ "11i1iV.I~_I, ~ iAI"" 1iiI ",",'!;.!'!'ilILIU

.~.~ _~~.~. 1:-- ~,-~ ~.~_ ~'t·.'~~]··~'iii"i;,i:I!' '-'"'b~'''''"''' t'·1!..';o'IiTi"j; '~~'~~'i!I;'l~jL-~ '~, ,tA_I nf'" t·~'i!.., .... 'Hi'iI;,'5i -iIi,....... ~·~r

lrome ,Imm. iml;iI;"Cilil1ili;"O O~I ;""-'IIiL~iII1l1iil, lig,'","".lI1il!i;,w "U.,;"_:j_,, "'-'. ,n.,.... ~'~:""~A~' ~~,':IJ~II~" ,!I"'li.!!";

:ms:t'8;nee, }7''I)U, :m~ght: :S':'~p.~ ~'ba1! tll~e iEiCld"om, is P[-e~.;rilbe,d. &y rs:ome larw 'whos.e gro~n.ds are, tmd:epeD!d~n:tr.,o:l eV\CJ'1t'~img; Ka~t h3;Z) sarid, :be~tle" and 't'bat ,tlI~ muim, e:o..u]d be l!'~lepl It :in the sease 't'~a,t~ :~t 'Ci~fijfoulls to mil

'm:·i·~enen~"'n·.' '~!"'~' L"I"'t!._,: i<" ,iiiif' '~~"'" '1iMf1i""'"".l"It'"'~""'I.V w' ,'!ll,.:,,,,:'I)..,, 'p .... ·~·.n~'-liii' '""'. ~ . .;>_,;jj.~. I':;, i ..... L.~n"',ii' .. ,jl.n-:, ~_-YJ~Jf-~_~U~- _ _!l'l .~~I·"""!! .I. ,~~J ,~~l ~~J,~ ~~~~t ~_.aJU)llr .. '. JIIUIIir_IIlI. ,ft.iI;I- - !Ii. ~_IJ_lI"'-II:iII~_ .. _a Il.r'UI U.Ju~ .~I ..

,the ,;ioo¥~ 'll!~()t'a,tj,OD 'w,hen he addis the 'wards '~~'wi'~'h.o.u,t ,8;sSiIilnd'ng an;y pru:ti,cmar :Ia,w' I:ppUca'ble in IOtr.tarm, l3~tlo:ms" i~' ,8i~d iit :~s :~mpnt~tB!n:t to see

Copy rig hted m ateri al

~, ,,'~'-, ~- ". ,', _..II •. - ~ '1111' . ,~, _,J: €!'" ., ... , . .,'f!.. ... ~. t'iil.···, ~,. ..,-r." ~~ ~"~ ~ t, " 'II]" ~ . ~'. .". • f-I '. ..

W,n", ,~." ,~$ ,U!~~ [D-'w'eu. ,.;j[u,ppose ~Qaf, '~~ecre w'~![e ~;UIl:~I;W a ,1!1i,Wi, :p:re5C,if.I~,,,~:ns:,

. ~ • 'I' ·1'~11 ~,~'llll ,,-,L ,', h 'E' 'I, 'Ii' .. .11; ,",".l

terttun, a,c,uollls. ,~, 'W~L~, I~~ wi 'tbe~ ,I ~x~,emal ,.L4_,w. ,jj'iiiu, :SW!~~$16 WI~ S~U

,~~~ '~ ,~

"1:.. ~h . . 1 i lI'l!I; 'III 'L. ~ ~ L ~. - - '. . 1_ 11"'1.,

t"J!wdit'I' ::e mmum gets ltt'i ~~~ ;C;nl'ra1C!I!er :nut :~,I,-Cm, :w,tS tmU,ln~]iC:; UJ,Wl(~.~

t, 'I!., i.' 'L. •• t, t, ~h .. "'L .... ..2l11 'L, h

II~nn~, ~u~~ ,!lfom, ~'~e [rKtD'nSl,C :.;'3,01: b_~alt rne aC,lt'M :~s[ Iprescn~:a &1' t~,e

Bx,t~al :Lilw. Then 'W'e 'wiD. :ba,V'f; to ast, wh,' the E1:Jt:em:allLa,w is a ~~.W'

'~""'!''''''',.-i:Ii''U1IO\iiO,'Il;'''Ii~t'Q [':oI'!iIl'~III!"!;'~ ~LJoI!O'il'.il!iI"l;l r~a' ~.,..¥o '.;i!"~'!pJJ"'TjIl..u, .~ii"'t~>:I"'~ ,'-,-""',,,.,k:;jf ~ ,;j. '.','ii'), ~[Uil,,,,", "' '!O.,- ,w .. ,'" "'"' l ... "",,~ ... ~, '''nI~ ,~ ...... ~~ ~l ... _~~ 'n'!01 "'"~""' ,iit~, ~~.v,Il, ,ILS ,[iJf!.oI,I![~,,, ,1 na,1. IS ~O!

.531YI' 'We win have 'bo ,ask 'wb" '~be. :ax;~~malla,w' is :~n ~u[~e~, w:~,,· it, lS, :il,Qt.di:a,'t~,V-e" :Betl'iu'Se obv:iO'~sl'yj the; mere lifam'm'[a:r.lc'cd :fc{Jtilii, oft 'uni,~elr·

. '~. . . ~II. ",,'L ,', '"I -] ~ be '" A ~ ~

rSa~l~;J cannot ,ma_[(~ ,!I!_O"iw,illng, I, "aw'; ;eI, .a:W :w[Usit; ee n(:j<D1ta,'t~rve. ~;,~ .~W

.l;n,.,.~ ft,,,,,,, .. !II!VI;.",~I. ;i;Ii, ,,,. ~'I ;i'Ii'~'m' i:"iI:i'Ii m--' u; 'ili'i ~ ~~'-~[~ '~~t, .. -" .... f;,;I!;, ~;i. i-.l..J' . "JII .. .

1!lJ'~!Ii<~ ~~~!!; :~~~~ ~, Q~JU' , ;ou '[ , •• ...; :':ill!e:ne~.)l" 1~:ajU:~ lll~ " .i5! [auur~:l\ii5~i;Ii 'IIliQ 11U~.j. Qr

'~n ,sOJn[e; gW!aP' tbart: irnic~fude5, m,e", :~:-t :mlU5t~ get it~, Kri:, ~\r h.Q:~d on ,m~" ~.tiS ,ca,plci:ry 'to' bbitd 'm,e;I' l;rom seme ,m)t-eUig~jbh~ SQ:m''Ci~, B~,t 'tiJK41 ehe i'@1Ul'oe of dlle ~E;x)telB:c11 U,W"iS i1Inrnl!aJ~ivi~;1" :r'8ilth~f.' t'b~n ,l~,~l ,cihai_f3,Ote-if

l, 'Ii. ~ ~'III]~ L..... t, -, L ,-_-I ·'1111- . .l .,.-.(j..

OlL 't1L~e maKimll' W,b, ee 'WJ;I1ii1't_ :WO(l,v,at;es, t'Jlie 1~,~Wl.~~~, :~J';SWl",~·I,ile

re~if1 wb", 'd!J£ Exu:-iw:al L;a,w is in, :£fi:[-c:e,~, ra,'l,'hi,er ,th:an, 't!be f'a'~~, tb_iJjJt: ,t'ht~ marxhn has, le,~,11,c1]afacte~~, w,~ll be du;: ,eod,'~'wiUed ~~rt's. DitQtivrev ~~l' ~,'t 'win. be the mal :reaSfif(l, w:b,y '~'b,e 3iCUO-Ji i~, ,ri~t, ,Amd 'this, iJ~ ocrnln','ar~ to :K~n,it's; ana~~t~i!s ;of 't'l.-' ~[I~~f~?~ ': f du~.\.

~ ~~ ~~~-''''7 ~ ~ ~~- ~~ ~ _~_?o .. , ... ,e; mu ],'\I'e 0: , Y

,An, exarm:~e wiU m_:ikoe~ '~'~i5' PO:WTIt dealer::: S'up:po:5e tb~];t rigih,t ,il!~ do!'lJlS, 'w~re: mase commanded In la'ws, :W~J;d, ~J)wn 'by' Goo", ,A,~oordi~g ~.o' Kan,,~l:s :arn,~.al,sisj '~he good;;'w:H~ed, :petSGl1 [does these 3:ctiQ:~~, because ~t :is, ,I :~a/,w_' 'tta do so, :Bli.t 'w:lmi,y IS :~)t; ,lil la;w' '~O d!~ so:~ n,~ ,il'~,W\erJ:' ~,; 'bG€riilU:S'~ 'God, so ounlmall.dis., :Nfiw~ w:hl!m [01; these ,two, ,~-aSO'IlliS, is, the r.[:eI'Sr.U!~ why 't'~ie 1~~"wl:U,ed, :pel1S(rjIIJ does ,tlirue !1~ti[(ID!" 'which ~~, alse the fC'asG:n why d~e a}c~t~,on is :r,ipU :1": d~e. ~~tio:~, :~s, :right becaase (jod cQmmalnid~ itir it :i!S not ;r.igbJt; 'b~~,u5e it'S, m~ro is, :~n'~d~ai,caUy ]le;ga'l; and, 't~b.e :reaSum, w:i}],y' d~,e ,i~-'wi~led, pe~o:~, dloo-s, :it; 'w'~U 1l!Clt, 00 gr,~sp (1! :its, :~~g~'I. 'cha[ac,'~e:r~ l~ut jC$pGn:51~ to d'~,v~~n~ [oommi3!~,dL. ''l,itds ];8 Qmfi·, U',alfF ~D' K3IilI:t;J!iS ,miii,ys.j;~t Th,e: ma'~m, of m~ ~~tion m'~s[t: be :~egal, :in, i;~selfi and, dlii:s ~an [Gn~,Y' '~: because :~t has !1, :~i3f.w'lik,~ fmm., file reiii~' ,gjws mO(falts~: may W[atl)t: to, :re,p:~.y ,tbaitt: '(h,e :mari'mi.'~ l~.gal ,~'ba[a~te;1j ,ad, ,th~ ~iu::,dfit;i,i'~ bel1t1Jg: div,lneJy' ~Qr-nm3Dded~, ~~ th~ ~e '~hl!ng • .But ~'~s 'ClQ;n~fil,m;hy 't:o di"v,i.D!e liilw' carn, O:~'Y m~k.~ a :~a~im, (t_~~~51'caU~, :tlO~, :~fii[d~nslt'~3.uYJ' :ie,g:at S~t 't'be dUemIm8l. l'\:eim;~d'~~,~ U the l~r;s~n is :mov-ed hy' dl V,W[u:; ;commS!nd~, ,then legal charaetea :~s' :~.JJtt, d:te :muti:v~, and 'tlhei mo~i,'"e of dDt,,' ];8 :not: ;3,t 'wtlrk. Sinoe d~e l~~l ~M'il;~t,er (jf a

. ~

matm arDtl t'I])e .dJ~,vb~e ocun;~ndednc:&s oJ [an ,ac:ti~n M[~ n~t ,a:~_3i_I,yH'"'

calh~' d'JJt: ;sit'me t'bhl,~, ri~:~il,ess :OOl~S·t [e~seJ]JJtJ~n¥ :H[~ in one 0' 'd'u~,m, or tbe 'f}.t:be.ti, 3IIlId~, ,3i~c~[di'~i til' 't'he ,arn~hr~s~, iJt miiIiJlS:t 'be '~:be :I~pl [:harr:~'

Copy rig hted m ateri al

ac·t;e;I" o.t· the N:axi'm. Am;. fS1i1)1 ,tIbi.s. :must: 'k: :~n~ i~ltf,i[l;s:i,~. :1~w1i~ki~ jmm'. lids ,arrrJU:mern,t~ wUI, ,8I;pplly t'Ol an, ,a:~temptt '~O dU:brt'e the legal ih3'f, ... ' act~r of ,31 :ma(xim, ,f'rom anyt'h~g; omc!r ~MD it'S, i'rnltJ',in;s,~,~. ,la,wU.k~ ilIun': oJji~.,· ]!ega;~. cihar,3ict,er d!nd I,a,wlike fO\ulfl, ;a'[\e; lllDtdyUc(]'lly or essenti:ally me same 't~.iDg,'~'"

N~w that ]1J;S't argum~l'lt m.aTy make iJt clear why -dl~Je :1!f!iP] cih,aI,3!C~te[ (Xi, a maxim, C3!F;i;fl;Ot come :bio:m, an E-X,te,ma!l La.liY:" B'Il~: dl~,e coraLclusJ,ilfi ...,,_ waJt it must tbJ!relfll''e loom,e :&om, lavUklc '~JU]1Il11' as, S,peeJfied by 'l"'he U1'i!i,~l!.;f;~aUz3Jl\IU!:ty 'be~t: =, :ma,lt ,seem, milllcll :~,ess, o'biJi~,o.;l!.is. 'WhiJ;.. 'he~w d\oes :~.t~ 'c~ncludt: '~'ha:i~ ,3 :W8!x1W. ,M:S i'Jj~trin8:~C :~,eplltha;~~crer (ll,iny .if iI:t. has 'W"liJ8i¢ the 'uD.I,v'Crsal.wbfHt,,' 'test iden:~jn~$ ,as l~wUkie fOHn ~'s.~ L~'O 'unlie:q,tand t'his! 'W'e :rm,U5:t :keep, :~n. mind 'lW'Q' p~fnt\Sl. The 8.tSl r :ha,ve a'~read'1' nO'~1Iced" In,'l)xdex tll' be a :~~w;, it :is, :rno£ ~n~uIh 'd~ralt~ ,~

'n~'i'flI"'~1'1I!'l,;Cj; be grj'''''~mmll:-',-_c,:-·"".~.t"!\;!j;I]v' ~U'-i""'l",. .. ersal I~' '-~u--"'4i ,,'It;JtjI; '1-;- 'n-iI'i'."""3-'iit~"~ ,if'.,.., Ir~.LI~.d"~~I[~\'!I..r. llJ _' ,r~;" _. - ,_I. _"I!I!-_lI,~~~ .r II' . -ILl.,- ·'¥~.I.r~_ ;~III .. l~ .... ILl •.. '_I;;I!~ ~~ -~~ ~ [. !I;j."~,~_~...,_ I~_~"!I'~ ;J}y,~,

the :PC-{f~SO:fii, w:b,o is t-o f6m!ow it; 'dle-t-c~ :m,Ust: be ,same bl.t~ll~gj,'bJle :FeaSG:n 'why i~. bi:~J)s, d1,~;t p~80~" The second p(fJint otmoe;m_s, '~bie 'WH,", tile 'tlni.'v\Qr:-,-'lliz;o'li;I.:-U~t" r~Ji'Ii'li'I(~I'~ml;n1iI[i: fi'iif:lJc:~t.mnn'ifi:, Th,,., 'f"'!i"-~'-':I-~-:-'1---:-'tr ~.:-]~'~I;:;I C:"~I _~~ ~ ... =t!'iY!-~"Jtk..=-1' ~""":I.Mi.Ll!;.'I!!YI~'-'!I, ="""~c __ ~~ __ de ~cq.u~_r-e:mell."" I"eilia us

,tha:t WI~ :m"'ll~~ !1(jlt :~n ,S~~ ,~ W'a,Y' thilt W~ I~ ,il't thl~ :~a.:_~,~ tim~ w~iU ear :mil,oms.it~ urni'v~s!iJjl, '~:a,w~, :If a. :~hll. ~pa~~~$1 '(bi~ ~~~,t~ t'h.e aic~ion is :righit~ :in ,th~ brood, s~n!H - :~.t is au. r.~gihtt' ~-l'm'issib:l,e.:" not '~rn['ig, 1:'t l~ only i_f ,;1, m_~_xbn, fails ~boe~ test: ,t'bat Iwe ,g~t: a, <holly ~ the dwty' (If d(J~~g:

r~c .. i···· . f 'w'jL. .. the ~"~l-io..l .-". '"-~.-" ...... ~.. - _, -.~:- -- - ~~ -';. ~]~=c- ~ t' '-'-!I!_:t~~ oppos='te er __ !li._a.t me JjiU_ .'C:y, 'm,aXl~m aa,1's,/ u~.!' more 'ilne[~~8e ,~, Oili;

'do ,t-'fiI" th~ ..... " , '. it~, ,--£ cw'htt 'dtF 'II "';'-.'::-~ I ,~c I,w S cc· .~. i-:-~I'1i;l-:--:-'lf ,a~,-,pl __ I.c~ o.ppos~,e 0: ,~_. ~.iL_oe ,~Axun sa.y,~ aS,a, __ ,,0 a, ffia)Lm 0 ,

,duty :~81 not mle;rel, O;~,C' '~hat y1J~, cti'li: will as umi."')M.sall5~, btu I~ne 'dJli1t ,U:~, ,W'U'8t. wUl as, u~llvlcrs'alla,w. ,A.nd ~;h;is, :m!ean~ t"ha;t 'd'alei m~xbD. :is a ,Ia:w t~ 'W'hrl,~-h ',Q,ur. O',wn ·win. ~o:m~ld:t~ 'y~u, B~t a m,gj~ to cw'hjcih ,,(1m' gtW.D. will ,('iQIin'ml'~.t~ 'yo-u is ,inowmatj~l~ lox ,Yi'Q;~~" And dli~" to return '~C1J 't'b~ If-Sit: ,P(1rj!ll'tl :i~, 'wh!Jt:,~ p\(,in~i:,~~ :mus:t h irru '~:rder t~) bea la;w:ro'l

vn'I'i ..... , 'I'.' '..,... .. "'1:~.;t;", '~.,:" !~ni.m.·' ,.,..,;jI'.'Ii:""·~""IAII!' 'Il"i"1i"'"

J.' ~l"'J ,III.," ,IH .... !I!JII~I~ ~ .. ;~~iIl.. 0' ,~[w: ,.,.[~ I' ~'4 $"' ~~'!l

A,p.i'[l an ~xa;~:,:ne w:~U ,c'~~ri&' tl~~ ,porin.t. :1: w:~U ,t~k~ Ka!~.e~ ~'~i~slt: e.X'8lmr,le,. d~~lt (It' ,the :~,,~n,g, pmmis~ [~G ,~t-~l,~l. ,A man :hl :fi'l1!aI_lrrtciaJ dJ~f8", ~uh~,~s o():ms:ide:~, ,g.et1ti!ll{g ,re-~dLy :m~~y I~ ehe Sih'I~Jllgitih of a lyi~g

nlP.lf>,"",~,;e;,.;. iI!o.L,"""iIi' 'iU;..;;., 'w'~I~ "''''''I'li'''"'v 'l.1I":'i<' m .. ,. .... ,im· "Iii' (~'~. 'w" -;r~ll , ..... , ... 'I.,\@, ""I '11'U'~t'Ii D nm"·· 'm· "",

r'l&u{uJ_lI~.h::J!-b lll.;[ta!lj,. ,iI]Ib .. , .'-.·,111 ,_lI. "'L!Ik..'¥~'I~. C;U~J .1., l~ u I ,IIJ_~J ,IL, - ~o~ __ , ~IJ_~,~A~ ,~. ,il.l'~-~o~ ~~ :_:.-u~-~

ise, in. ,order b)1 ,get some tte.adly m,(lne:y; !~' :H:e ,i'i$k$1 h~:rm.seH wb~t-h~r ,b,~: ~O\1!dd 'win. ,h:~s mm'~ '~O be ra:t ,tbe Si'ime "tjtlt~ a UtdV~~;l.~ l,a,w, Th'is,

'""''''"''".'"'"'' ,.'if. ':a·~-t-" h e l".iiin .. ~. ag,IJl.n,."" iii 'W',;ft;,?'iiI41 1·' n ·'1 W'·~I·,;f!;''''. I ";'.i\!'I;e.l'J1"'''''~''"' ,~!1l..-'~1 needs

~.H."!II :I~I:I! !liIEt 1. I ,~~Jt. . ,.Ll.... ' . 1I.JJ!kr.a ,l1li ·"·i\:o.I!"l&,~U "I...lII. . " . JUl· !II..r_I:l~ ~"... b' ".Jh.ll.I..III.;.t· ~ lUlu ~~J

',' ~ • ~ - ~ • ,.J _. - ~ - - - - - - --

m~~~"""~.~' ,"",.,:-.",;!j;.l""e~)ii; a~ ltf]i"nliP" 'H<Jioitil<ft1I;.c.'l";C!.;i! oi:.'"".-'d:1 he ,~""",.-,,,;;,,,l.n--e·.o;l 'iIi'iU--.",.."" ''''I'''' .;L_~ sam ,-,,,,,!,

~1II_"t_'.I- .J;_II_II~ .. J\} .. D. [ . [W.~, ;a~CiI ,r~.'Ut"_iIH.' ·a-'IiP. , .. IH.· 1:1 ,11"1.aJ_lIc~Ofl""~ !Ij;~:~IP'''1f! ~)'l .. ll~~ [~~~~_~~~l

~" '~' - ci[' -'~-~' 1.1 ·'11'" b'" . H·'-· .•

tIme), ,~je 15 pan (:Vi ,t !Iil IS, 'wnr lUI!' 'WI __ Iml .1!tS IQI!JJl'(~m" d.'...'~5, 'q!U!~snl~Q :liS,

w:~,e-ithel be c~il, wUl this, w:bu~,e .s:ta;te lot rdf'alb';~., :NQ~' h~s, maxim is, .

Copy rig hted m ateri al

i.er:i:'led, f~rnm. ;8, :h'.Y.PQt:netclC'~d. :impH:lui.'v-e~ flU 'yOU. W:~n to get ,SU~Je I~ad.y Hlio:n.e" dten, makle B, ~.y:~ng promise, ~1' 'This h!ypa~hGticral im:p'9,'ai~' ti!V1ej ,in 'rl!Jm,~, is, deDvYe~l :n&m. ,t'b,e tB'tj,\GnaJ p:ri'fl,c,;j,pl[~ tha't whoe-v~r 'wiU,S! ~D~ eM, 'wiUs[ '~be ·n,«e.sSflIY :me.a.n'Sj tD,g·ethe-t' 'wi!th the l!'~[cau511!! l.a'W' '~'hat ill.yiJlf;: plf@Jllisesl ,at!re ,a, m,ed!mSI '~U,~ fir: 'win caJu$e:, '~he :pcsKu.iom, '01 r.e~d,., :money ('G l\1Il7l HCiWie"V'el'" im. die 'wodrd, ~n 'w'hicb th~s :mmm,

if ' 'iIlU1hr~'II-' ... ~_ ,-.'~", I~"lc:'~l- it :i.-., c: .ll-;;~~l -c.-;-~ Ibe,,''tll~ '~'C;' [-, ,",~ :' :,': '- -,-,;'[" '[l _' ,", II' ._51 ~. _ .emal!lZl~--..!.billSC;I~sa...iliI.W"005nD.~ . .c!lJ.. ji,-(lr. 1.1: eveillr0me ,m,

'W<'i'ii'i'ii-.~' r--'-"J!ili'll~.V' :t",~iC!:"" '_~j .... fi 'iit't'lo '"if';,;!J;l~\i!iI: ..:iI, I, 'Irl,'iifI;jO!' niF~m: I~J~""'" 'rrr~r:iI'[ ;C!'~'\I'iI!i ,~~.~ .... , ;iO'i~~

~ ~ ~:Ij_I~lllir. v.J; i'!lr.-MNI,. ", .. _~1.I~L !lr-:1J,i&~1 'leU ".H._Cil_A~ [~. J.·,~IJ_~.~ Jf'~,~- _~-~1- .~,I;!\3 ~'l ~l ~-~y v~_,..

WQ!llld 'beUe:ve. w:h~t~ W,'i$, :pr.orn'~sed to bim 'bU:t 'wuldd, o~ly ~lraft1l1gb ,I't

!"iI."IV 'C!'ii~""Jh'-' :;!iI'C!lC!J;t;,-""'ilnn.- ,;jliCi ''q'~:~ln' nrl!'eili'oI;>l!'iI; .. ~~,n' I~riil ~''''~l ''j''L"", 'm""i!'n l"iI:'N; '"'.t...~ ".!IW'-,'IIi.'i-iiili"Ii."-·'~, "-.I-'-'1tl' ra ... r'?ir_!· iM_a~!V.IJ.I~~,_u,H., aI~1 '1!J[~~. _~l ~""'~'~~_~_~~-~' ~u ,~,~~~~~ JI,U~ ~- I ~ ~,~ IU~'~ .... ~_aHln.~1

pte SDtJ,ot~ a,t~ ,the same ~i'me~ rat~,on;any' 'wiU both, alc,tif(l;g: 'on :his :maxim ,Sind, a, slate of aff;a:~rs 'w'hic'h urmn:i!iitnliTlii'i;i:!' i'i;1..~ iI":'~ii'i,~,-'~1 ],-.-'w· ,-,"::,-,;:-,

_. __ ~ _ _ _ ~ ~ ~ __ ~~ __ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ __ ~~~"'"~ ~u""''''' [~_ni~ ... aJ~5a_li. Jl ~ _ ,iI:wm

w:mdll. ,;he. :r,ado:mIH:ty 'm ,ICti't1;g [001 h~s mardm :l$, de.1i,~'ed, ,1\ malD, 'whn w.uls tio '~lse the ims;,ti,'t~iH,o:n, [~f prom.i$'~n;g ~n PUfSlid'~ of. Ihis, end ~M:~_Sit

'~,",i-",~ .. ~]'-I]- t-'~,"'i;,t-- t--'Ifi-;j3 '~T[lIS~ ~i:~i'il.'-·l'liiii'[l, ,~'Ifr"",ifii;ljd' ''IlU\,'.:;n;,',-, 'l'k."it,~JI I' "', . [~;:-U:>l!i, ''''i"'iiil'[ '~,~,,;,_il .. '!llli~_ }l~~;jfj'

-""III _ 1 J~_il_g. J • _.HI-'_' 1I_;&_I11_ ,1!I._1J1!l.iy1li. Il0:l.'\10.111 raIHI,u!llil_ I ¥1!"U_ , . ,., nJIJ_LlU ILl U~ ~~Y'!\\i ·,"",~~Jf~. 1~-=--1Ii_1I,...-~

tpmmlises ,a'r:~ [1e:rneral1,' mlildie in, ,Iood t'~d:m" So he ,h'iw1cse-lf ,lLS OO'm1'm'1:~,t-~, ted, t:@, 'w,HUng me :~~,w dl81t people: shoulJd make th~~r' pm~s bl, ,g1>OO, :faith ... so' lOrlg: ,as he wUls 't:lds pa;nictwlu' :m:a:~dm, "Ther.e~ci1'le:j !be carnnGlt :1',atio:naU,r w,iU 'b~ a.c~, [on 't'nis maxbn, [~l~ dle ~m,e ,time IS he wi1ls it as, a, la;w:,,~'~

Th,e' j;m;~narn:t thr~:ng: to, see :~e[le: is ~bt~ :~,t :i5, t'he :man tli O'W;)!l, w;H~,

'''i'I..''Ii'it ifi',;rr.-iffi'i'-'~it-·i!; h-e'llm-c:-, t_..,., '_'i!.,;t;; 1 .... 1Mi, .,1..;:ifii; 'iIl'lt,il'iliI!'iiil;I·il!e·'·;ii; ;C!;1L-;n;.'~l'..:1 be 'm,.,.;-;M,._, 1"~ [DTii~'~ l!.i-_~]a~ 1W-~ILI_"'_~_I_'ildll'. ,a , -' -_IJ_I - J , I~ ,.111:,.. ,J.ilJ'~ [l-:-Llla~ ,~i,iJ.U""'~' -_~ ,::,~ '~_~:~~1~~ U _'.!Iqr ,I~,. l~~~ ~ b-'VllU,

~ta~i~;b. :iif 't'beif' ,31R tD' 'k: made ;a:t a11. 'ne ,ar.:[]!1~n'~ :~5 nc,t~ thai It: :p"''O.m.l~ ~fi\l ];5 gette:mU" ;,1 useful :ms,U)t;ili~ciQn o:r' 'ml~; 't'~,e; r,~Ih:~ness, o-J: k't-Jep.i.n,g: p1f-u:m:ises, :~s 'w,E\I,'tt:en in:t-o 'the: :ni.t~u.re of' ~Jh'~iIlIs, The 'm_ is, com_m'l:t~~d 'liD the imU-tju:ti~n O:~ :p:r.O:M'~5'lng 'by' his ,own :maim 'boo-a!Uise: :be wUls to eDplo~Y' ,i:c ,as a means 'to his end, :[t ~.s' Ibis IOW])1, wiU,i and :Hoth'~ng: else, t:hat ml1ik~s &t ,impossible :Eor ,[bim to, wiU ehe u(W_i:v~f;sa]ity 0-£ :l'j,~n.g, :p:llomiHs. :~'D ~b~5i 'w'a,I,y ~-he 'm.n!~,Vle:.tsaU-:zabiUt'1 test ;S!1D'CW5 Us' w:haJt~ pnt-J,tiples our OrW:D, :mm.Dms, 'OO:n1'Dllj~: 'us to' 'wiUing as, .la,Wr~t, As, ,ltamlt~ S;a,ysw :if ~be man does, 'wiU the :1!rulX[mtf 'he 'c-~~·t: ~, 'be. 'wiUi~g :~,t as lI), :~iilW~, b.u:t ra:t'h,er :mu:st be :RiprdiUI: :bims~H ,IS an ~~OepltjOH, ~G ,4l;4]1. ~

Let m,e digress ,II m,ome~,t~, :U~ is ,I~; 'this ,PD(hu~ :wn tbe ,apm~n:t thlt: me tlibj:e_,c;tiofi :K.anl :~,e{V\el,ed api'Il.S,t 'W~Uf~ =. th~ #[Imptf fO!~XiaU8m,iV ,obJect.ito:m, =, eTIl!terl$ d},e :p:ief;u're as an o'bjGC~j[GD a:pins,t: Kanji; :ibbnseU. ,AiC'CIDJldi'llg tDI dlie. [ob~ec~ci[~n~ dl,e FlOnDula, 0.1 Universal :Larw- la~~ks, IC'CJllen:t sinee ~h~P.c:e a:r.,e: :no :r.,:esU',i"'tj'iY~IS: [ijWi, w14,",t- ,",~,~ ... ~;,-[;, ,')1,,~ (":~, ,n

,~ ~ . _ _ _ ~~_. ~ __ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ _~ ~""" _~"""-~JIL. !!o.!'.II.~ ~ ~ iIi.u, we w:adl'i1 W.~!I, :as Ia1

UDlI'Wlersal :~ilW~ ,Ind, ~he.f.,ewre ,niOI :h,]1iPlicard~[Gns abolllt: 'what we m'u,~~t. so' wiU, NO'w' '[ ·h.(}"e t'~ihlt tthe ~am'l;lIi'te -c'll;:U'I' '~avl~~ "'illS'!' ;;i\r.l~'·;-' 7' ~i'~]-".,--:.~ ~-,t

.. , . . " , "-'!If~ -~~--'- ~~~~ ~~~- ,t"'" -~'" ,t: .1" gII.ven. W.I, i!:iI'U~gg.~_

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'ii'lir,-t-e .,;If:',D, :J,b-i'-:-"',;i;J\~ ,i:~: m /;0i'f'""k-'_.;i'II1. :~~..fi, '~'~:~It·' ii,L'~r'lI!i "~I~' :I:~,'W;c, *'Jfil 'wlh'i ... '!h 'i"iitail'"

II:. Ii l:a, , !I. III 1,., 01 . Jel!;;o'l.lu.I':I. :ato; ,_ . 1",,,_,,,,_ ,.ilj,;,I,'1, ",_uU ~.I!JL",. '"".eIi •• ", '!;." ~""'" ~"" .. '" "'-'Ii.! ~""'= """'_~

OiWll, ~fnls, do ,co:ml1tdt '~~, B~,t it ~is, alse :im~l't;li~Jt '~~ :~: W:halt :is, '!I!~T'i.'il!' '~O!':','~'lh' •. ~'l'liil! '1i'fi;.'''I'Iii"1ii~S'''I~ ,t:i"'ii"" iC'i"i;'~IV~niiD'.,' 'iI\'~;iI!!' ;QmlN.':"~n!l;!'~IC' '1'!iiI'eJL.I~'"ii", snme'I'I!',II.U.~ ''I'I!' hi.. uu • .., ,rtl,""'".t"""" .G.iI, :1,,,,",,1, !LI!'V<III. ~ ,II. - '0' ~_~Jtor... "'"'~;I?"IIi;~'!.nio1'!i.1' ,t"'~ ~ ,u~ _~~ ~ ~ ~""'"

't..DI,es :madte 'by 'dl'{)se.; wCIJrJ,Q,~ li'b Kepi", ,a:p,p:-f:O'V~ K~nt~!S a~~Q'oot of. '-~;- __ ;- -_:c .... '!] '~,~:,...,iif'L_:'I .. "";IAn '~ilil<lt"' ,~oh,-,~'i'II,'~l_,: 't'I);.:""Ii-~ 'lIi"iIr-'!'!, 'p. ~;;:v":"ft'irjn];o'Ij1 o~ 'UI::rn.i''V~''';:CI;o'lj'~, :L;i'liiW' is ,moJ',w, ,WUII:.I,l"g,!I..I}UI'J, iL!J!!IilI!. " .. iliU~. .IHI.g', "'-_Ui .... , ,!VcI,;U_!!~'!;I!~g: ~W .. ~ ~ ... ~"'~ _g: ~~ =!o'!

~,pty~, This 'I;)roPMid, is 'mat :~me ~JtemaJ'~ la,,",, 0'1:' n(ll",Rlaliv~ ~~n!S'i.d,,,, -,,:; -If:"J n I . ~ ~ be: :i'm~n:ed ~iilltim 't'!be s,,,,,sltf:~m tl)l sO:~v,e: t'it~,C s;un~~d, 1~1in'l'liti ..

cralQ:D!. C " .. 1. ,1:" , ,I . , ,.. '·'··1 .. , . , c . ._-,. • ~t"Ii'"""""""- . c __ ,.t" ~

ness, 'pwltli,em, ,3ind, ,~,ve 'O(l1l!ten:t to our d)util-e\91'~''I:

~i~'''' "w'~","Jijj 'U"""D:-I~:'"'" ;n,=w.::~ ,Ci,,",l-''il~,t·e~i ..... if'" ,jl," '~'~b··~~ ·P.··ri, ..... '<I!i -"'''''''":''','W: where [i\h~ "Ji'i'~l.,;ll~,,,

,1. II.~.'i]I ., i&I.;:]! a;tI. _ 11:., .:l! 'U', ,~ .. , """-,, , ..... .I1']!;'i!',I'.II, ,1'-,",1, '!j._. I.... , II, ,~."' ... , ~ "" ~ ~ ,_ I ..... ~.... '",!Ul ... , ....,.~

~metl'jm of 'the ~m([f:al ~S~, 'W~it bWi~,h-t ,in '~~ gi'v'e ~~rnlt~n'~ to dt~: o:blipti!()~ ,(xf w'hh:m itr..~ pr,ind:p:l~ ~l d~ ~ha:t wbh;;~ .i;s ,pe'~~trl :is, ,t[b,~ :£n':iU_~o. ,A, 'V!;!lcri3n!it; of :lant.":s, '~w,n, ,~rp11l],~nt. ,~n ,Gro~nd'wQ:r.ik: ,f sbows, wbY' ,t'!lfJis, ~Qi])U:tlQD liS ,dJ~iS\a'II(Jw{1:d", E'i,t'ltcr the ,acti,fitJ, na.'5 l:t8, 'ped.¢~tifim,

'"ID.·, 'l·,,,,..,,"!!:llf,'. 0,:"1 u~;fI; ,;jjJ~, '1"'I'i"" ..;.IlryiiiO'~ ~,;j, ~n',: ;i;i'!J;i'!i'>U-~fiiii' lifL-t ,ill'''', 'nP.!~.':e:- ... ,iil'!rynl, iL1liif" ~i:'i; ,~L-= J~-~~-l ~._ ... ·L~ ~.~~ .~"'~'''l U~Ii_~~ ,~,!I. u.. IOi-W"-U. _~_ .. J.J ul-.l [IJJ._'iZI .r--~I]L .. !Wi:. UL_IIJ! lOu],] !U.;iI!J.ll

a~~:Olllllt o.i' 'w,ha:t gti,ves, i't; :i:ts, :pericc,tiJorn, =, i'fl, tb~$ case", ,t'h,e~ a.PP([fi¥,3·~, fi~ ,th~ ln~J'i~d, sense, 'lihe :~'"f.a'S0'n. 'w'hy d~e. !1Cti(1lD, :i$ periec~t, :and, 'd),e, ,r.C~SQD, 'why' ,!i, I:~' :~;ES(1l~, d~5' j,t~, :mlust; 'be exa:~t'l.y' 'U~,e ,Slime. T~e a~th:u~,~'s,

,. L_ '",. _.~'IIII of' ..:.II] ''_ -'il.. 1 'L,",'

P~fl'eC'UO'Jl cannot; ]~ l~tr.JnS:liGiU~Y' ~o:~iI;en:-eu 1)1' ,t~J.~: 1m,fira .- :s..e:mS~1' ~Uit

m'~s!t be frntrili1_sjc, 'Illo the !1~ti'(1m, i't~~,. CO:~lt~n't m'Q'~,p,t; ,~n ,b~ll'[I, '~xte'~"" nail, n~iJjJti'v~ IS'Q"UOO~~, 'v:iola,t~S! :Kan;t"':s ,anai~,y,sis i~, tbe 'w,ay' 'W~ ,have

~"

W'."::,~ """'D ''''''' ..... w'·,' ,~.-- .. '''''''l·'h·,o;!o'",' !<"i' 'n,lO;!O,p 'W," :."'1C!" ,il'iliiC m' ;:i:~ll-m·" !P' 'iliil4..;., '""r'l1ml' ..... .",i ... '~

,._.~ ~~_o~' ,~~y .'._' ~~~ [~ ,~,~j'-:-~_c~~, ~~IJ,~ ,If~i~~, .'.'~J).' ~J;. 1~, .. ~.lK;, "I.~l !II;.II..~, ~. ,~~IJ.lI~~ . .JJ __ l

agai'fl5:t ,th~ Dlt~i!~d Law; l'I.Ipp;u~e-~, a,pint tna-t. 't'~.-e :Ext!emalla,w' is, ~.n, :f:owe 'k-es!1.iSe ~it: ,i5 d~e la,w of: ,God'\Si 'wIlt Tfii!5i ];8 s}up.p~:d, '~a 'be W:IlI,t

'iiin ",'i\;.:e~Q ,ilrt. 'nnT"iiiri ",,;j;,iiI'i.iip, ~I\iliilt'" '!ikfi-W<~ ~ t""'" ... .l],"'" ,w.-..jl]-'I] ,iii!> fiJ]~ 'I~ 'ii'in~:"'iii,V\ ... ,L-..'j' 'ji:ii"i .... ~,t ,1Ii~,_'__I'ii.' CD' ,~,I~ ,1Ii·JiU,",;~~;u.,,,~,'I""" ' '. ~;. , ,i!i]!!&L ,.:'. uou. ''''''~,J',I' ,I, ,I,,']!, ~. ~ ,I:,: !I~liu.~Llliil.ul,"-oi .:' .. i ,W.: .iiil~l;"'; ~,L

"It "S, 't'tn law' a:f m¥;-jW~ 'win tc~ ,"lbev G,odJi':s w-'!Il. Tit'is, :~5, ,m. eld ,Il ];, .. .e .< ~~ .J' "~ co ,~ ~~ ~.~~~ ~ .. " .. ~~ ~ .~ l~~ ~ ~~ ~.~ ~~~ ~~~

:H:()boosiIW, tbo:u;gn,t - t'hra/it: Bot'hin,g: ean 00 ,j). lalw' ,foOl me '!In'less, ,I: am" befoLl '~O (.bee, :~t .. iDd, :I1O'tb~n,g can, blnd me to o be,' :~,t 'IlD]ess 1, :It.ia,Vle\ a, :mod,ve ~O;f:' ( .. ~,il1ig i.t;. till. I'w.t :Kall!t: goes ai. step, .fuu;ller; tbailll, H:OIbH!. NO!'Jj1ing' e~CC<P-t :m,,' ,CfWn 'wtU, can, :ma'k_e ,!ii, b,w' 'iI,oIn~a!Hrve~ for ,m"", E;v'el1i, ,t'he~ ~miPOsl;tl,ofi ,of: ,3, ;8a.ri'J~t~fim, caooot ~ypas5' m,,,' w1U~ ~fjI .3, :rewBrd, 01 punis'hmC-fiit: 'Qfii'ly bwiJ!s :~J 'W,IU if.:1 wUI, to ,g,et, 't~e :re.w:3.rd of: ,aVlli,d 'd)Ci :I.ftrtnishmen,t ,= mall: :i8,. ,H I make :h m:f' :Wloi.'M, tbat :ml,Y ;wnteres,t 01 pI-e~,a'~I,fin Slh«~ld 'be; ,it law to :1Ite:, '0'01, those :ma'lt~'s. sbown bjl be necesslf;f 'by dile~ ntl!i:ye.Jmdl'z:a,b~lil,y 'tes~: - 0111,' tlu:~se to w'hi,~~b :M,Y own, 'wi;U ~:omm.l;ts 'me - ,are ilittr:il~si:,c.ally ru.}l,lua't~,Vte. ,And '~his~, as '~!be 1''it~iiGn_aiUs,ts hid argued all, 11on& :~i, W'hl~, all, cdJ:diga.tiuli'it, m:as't be, Autotiiomy is, -dte Ol1'~y possibl,e; SOilJlrlee~ 'm: :~n'~rl-~si'~ IlJo:rtnadvj,t,~, and,

. ·f'~r," . 10 'O~, Q!lJ~_lg:aUcm"

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Q.De result: ,o;f dli~:S is, ,th.a,'~ iit s;haw8 d1.t:at: the B:ri;ti~h. :f,3itliGlnaUsts t!ll iso:me~ cx!t:en;t: :m~8~:om:k ~hie4Jf' target" fiey opposed HCibbe~iJlms;m~, m;~fra'~. sense ,t'hw~, ,Ind dl!V,~fie ~o:mmmd dl.eoJJ'~, .a~H en dle. plOUin,ds,~,

i"il;C!! ;j'h' - e.-v ;i.·h-c,tfI,l'ili'""'IIf,;,;j;, i'b-'-'a-:iii ,;j;,'~.,..;C!.;., 7'''i:I'~e-' 'm'e- ·~:-tiI'~l· iitlt' ;il ~,;ilil'l;il!l'" ..,.," 'l'!iol"l;~l'·'iit~jji,~ I' ;:i1U[J!' iM~ l.~. --'ll' 1,-:-. !Y!'!~~,J.!II.jI! l .. ~ '_ . _ ~J ",,~~:I~~-~ J;~__ ,I ~ - ~IJJ~W· ·JI!IJ.1 ,~ ~ ... I.J .. [~. ~,Il: .r~~~ .!I!;~,'" ~ . _~~!JT-~

111ll,'t Kan:t~,s md,,-,,sis sho-ws, mit: PQ.s'l'tlivity is :~,,);t~ 'me prclbJem." ,A law :in die :11l3,Wre o~' thj'm.IS~, U :i,t~ is, 'Elde:ri'boodl ;5, ,I tne(1r,fldical or meilla,~ physicil, :pr.incipte '~ha,'t i.:s. ,e;l'ttlem.al tn, It'ne 'win", gir,Vles :r.ise '~o I~Qctl,y

, .. ,'Ii;.~ ~,;i!lm' '-~'~ 'ii\'~n'~'I',e:~'m" ~ik,~'iii ,-:-Il·'i~.I!·ln,;fI, L",iuiJ!' 1-:iI;o'1;';'~iI!; ltii~l '~' ~';mjL'!; '~in' ''':L:--~ 'n,1i,~,~iI'I!',~ ..-.;.1:'

U:~i~ ~~~_,,_~ ,~\~,"!Y'~'.~_I'~'J ~~J~]~ u~ '''''~~~~. la'I'T ~~~.~.] ,~rp.1'P.'~ '~'~.~' U~~ '_.~_~!I!J~~ ~-J,

d~.i'ngs ,em 'omly :mak.e. our' :mlxims, extdmsicaJjly~, :not, b~,u:in5i!callly~, n~JmIU,'ti!:. TI1.e. :pRI!blem, w.i'lb 'lll,ese, t~hood.es, Is :l'W't ~Jha'~, ~'he'ir laws

,0!I;'I!'i!!!; n~~~'.{~'lIiI'\IfJi' '~!II'.II'i'" I"h·,"'iit: 'iiiili,. ... ,i,[' ~,~w· ',fj,o!II'~~ i"~t', 'W,', :'1·.1.'11.,.,iI ,ri'iI~I'Il'~;i'j'!;,m" '~.r~iC!:I.,v .0'1;' ... .:1: ;ClQ.: I !!II_"'~ lrv~~'~_~"'I!~~] ~Ullil I,_ ,_.~ ~~:I~-.IJ_ , .lQlb.,. ~ ~ ... ,'~ ,~,~~,] ". _ ,IJ~-!Ul ~ll!il]. I!IpI!~,£,v. . !t4~-~~lr~1 ~.~Q~. ,

ate not :~n~-d!ll'sic;all:y' ,nQiIHI.a:tl,ve,,, :B&,I"t dl,e, ,Ka.fitian, :ia,ws iQf a!U~t.oEl!,o:my ale POSl,'t],ve la;W51: :mQ~ai. ~3iWS eeXist 'ooe3!~se WJ; legisia,te them.

ci"m,IDd'lcr mistta;~e~, till'If:,tJ ,tl~i5 ,ti;mJe! ttl Bl.I;~b:~," :maud, '~hUoso.pb,

'iTiiiJiFIi .... , !p;pnoI!iI'i'i"iI'il1- v '~;C! i"'t..·e~ '!!iI"I"ll;~v"'i'i;I!.,il~'~tiV' ;Ifill' m-:- C];I"'''''I]- ;!'iInnl;ti;e-t1I;"'~ ~.t'!tI ........ ·d:-I dl.::I1_~~.I~ cr-_I.U.I/PIir_.llM_IJ: 'j..~] l~~ IU_I" !III_'J::~JIJII·~·IIIlWlll_I::II,t~llll'·· 'UI-.I; I -_ :_I r'Pi.!", .... !IiII_- I '!ir.-U.Io_II,w ;1~i~.;J!iI 11r·.I,ll!lr.-~ 1&.L:1II·.

Mm,t?ehesom, 13:_p,ee dliilJt; :mo(;al :id,eas ale ,fundJ3imcnmU,. 't':&imp.me~ ~~' and, carn amIy be defined triviaUy by s,pom",mS.,'6:t 'This, :idea, is eohoed I'll G,. :!~" MooJ1e's 'QD'BOem 'wirt'h ,t'!tu:: j~',na,'t:~riSUtSU,c; ta:Uai;~,J~'::: because l~:ptea-

;£!iln,~~"'j! .;l;, •• : ... ,:l1 !l!',vn .... ~ tl ~~r' jijn'oll!;4i";!U''!;;r'!,>il!I' "';:,O!IIfn!ll'li;nitt' 'L.,:, iIi"O!Ill~\iIIi'n' 'iif..-:;. 'm'''''!''''ID ,.:L.~ ,i[!l"' __ ,~ ~;~.l~ ~_~U D'Y'Y'g] ~l .~~~. '~:__J~II!o~i11I~1- ~~~_~¥"l ~ 10~'_~~_' !I#~ ,~~I t~~~'~' l.r"_~ [~~~.~n~~.J~

.·bf;nlil' M:':"~~~ oi'!jol'!ill!!l;",;:l'·i~~lOl:!oil!i ;;.,'Il:-I,O!II.· (;!', ........ ~#' .,i[!l "'1 ~'i'~'I'!i;'1 0I:!0 ~,tI;I:>"'1 1!I'5· n, ~~: ,£"'_iI'll;o'!i/ut~l·'Ii!I;>i:II' 1,~.~,~~~J. ,I, .. _!_~~L~ ~_~~_~~_._:~u-~-~ ~'~!'l ~, ,~~,~ ~~~M;VllJ~ ~~~~'!] n1-~\t- ,w-u-~ Tr- ~'~~GiI

,Moore", mak:es ai, ,sbnUl'ir 'c~aim aJbou~; rldib:t. rJ'~, The 'tm'tl~, :~n tlu~se ,3irgiU:mem!t$ .is ,:0[:5::: IC~ii'ms iltm'u~-~, .,y;; :ptea:surt:/, or' 'whwt maxim'ze;

'ii'I;'~I';';!!IiC'!nflfli!' ~'I'\'" 1I'Ii~" l·'~''''I!''i'~;Cl'i·''''_;:i;~ll~'U' ·:ft;:-t!P'l"ll!l;!o'I;'.oii,~it> oIi'L;IjI, '!ID\av' ,!,!'I'~':'lm' ~ I· :L~~r~'" ",'Il:-,oI'Ii Ir .. ~~~:~~~IJ.~J!1 ~~~l~ ,LI""~!I. '·,IIJ_~,W.J.,~_~~_~~_~W' II' ,1I&~L'oI." • .ln.~F',f.J,·!P.'L~-I- ll!oD-~ 'rI! ~'II ~_.L;IlJ_1 __ I_~I I ·UU~I," ~_~

,..-i ... 'Ii;.,., ,;i!ln,..l .L1···(j:J. iI:II.r-- ..... Ai ~,~..,. ~..., '~'o:·rm· .,a.OI,~ .. ilil.~'.n;:f oi!Ifi!fl; ;ilfil"Il. .• , .... ,_'11 ~""'I!"-"',;,-nil' ;!!;.i"!;ift'I!!I; ...... ,I.-~_~:" ~~~~] IL~~ I~~' ~'~i!! .~,~~l.~~-:__:-~,:_~~)'~·,..·~';1/ ~I [~~_~. [~~~,~~. ~_~~~~_~~.~, ~~,~LIJ' 1~ly~

'11:0":,,, ..JI"""iIi'l·"U\i"'!c1!i i('~iI'!iil!'!li'!; ,;l;'n(u 'n~P!i,_"",.,'Ii,.·'I'iI"!: .. ,'!1 ,oI"!j;r:;.- .... iI"!\~I'!i., ~n 'n·..-:;. ""-.'bfilol"!j'i'lI~ J'!jol"!lil!!l;oI"!jol:!iM' ~Ii"!;n b'··01:!0 ~ g_~~,:_ ~'~~],~,~,'!YI'\~_~~ ~,l :______.~A~ ~l"~_~'~~_~~' ~!YI'"~~_~~Jfl"1f! ,~!YI :__.~~ ~,~_,~,~~~~, ~_~~_~~~,~~ ~_._: __:,~

IClOim,pll:l~~ely' ,anal~d, :in t;(!!fmS of a ~altural 1(1rJ" ,faetuail, one. An of these

'n'L;'IIi"!iiil!i .... n'L;!:!o1!')[! ... ....-I!'II~'I,~I~·~;:O .'h·,oili!~ !I!'!;'i"1i-_,i§'..-~~;~ 1.ro,\iI"1iIl'li~-.il'!intii~ ''''r!I'A 'i1i~'P!i,oili'I!!I; ... I~~ ... ;I!,..'~I""! .A·r: ,VU-~,~~~Y',VD~~,~I ~_~~~t~l~~_~ 1'~_.~.~!I!o'.~~~~.~,~~"'~,·!P.'~ ~~~~_~Wil!ol;ll ~_~~ 1~~I~_~~'~;J"~~_~\~~!I'~

oili '!P.i"!iiC!f.'.I1.iIi' "','~-""i:U ""~-~'l'i'ilk··' 'iIi'-i~~'iI' 'I"~I~'r"'I~'P!i·..:I"'i'~iI!)lIi"O!Iill!!lo'iIi:i'r'!lIiC!"'''''~ , .. 'Ii...":1!- 'n·~~,i§'''-;'IJ,'oI'Ii "'i;"!iiI!ll;~~n'iI'

l~] '~'~-~~_~I~J ~~[r 1'~_~,i&III ~Jp,.a~ ~~:. u£~U~~~!I!o-_~~_-.Ja, ~-I' U1I~, ~~,IJ,~&a]"'!Ii,·!P.'~ ~-~Ii_Ii-~~;~'~

~"fIi-;O~iC!i 'P!i';!'JIli!i' ","lI'Iio':l'L.'IiI'! us ."i""l n.,ii"!~'!~ O'-'.r~t" '~''''E!; ,rn'~ifI;oI'!:tii.t! '0!II1~-41 .,'L1""iii ''ID.''''' '1'H11' ,iI!;lIi" , .. 'I!. . .tIf!l"~':..r.-'W!\~ [~~~I "'~_'Y"!Ij.- ~_~~~Jt~ I ~ l,~ lrr~~~ .. , ~l ~ ,~,!Lo_~ ~~~~-~ .. :~W '~iIB.tU.II~~1.-- 'n!'~ ..Il~~, . .: ~"'l UlI~-~~~~~.'~

:have :reoourse~ ttll,a leiS€:: '0[' '10 a fatuHy ,of ,mltiU~.tio.m, 'tba,t mneti,om U~e ,3, sense",

:Bi~,t~ Kan,'tlc5 ana'~,rsis does ]'l;{1jit r-edu,Ce 't'tl.e n'Onna,'t~.\tl:e oon.oe:,t: iI:~1 ;tI, :mOrJ:-

'n: 't;"lni!,;jI·'.1!"~:fie .... ~;;.,~ '1In'dL!JiitJ;l,;!!,,il1 l.".'iit: '~d:\'i~iI"!\ifI;JiJ n.-·"'i'ir'iif'r'ii ..... ,iit·~!jiii~ :'i"-....-~."'"'"Iiii ,iii<,,":,: ~"I'\i~,;!i;I;j;,.i'l.J\~

[ _ ~ '" .~. _ _1~;11IJ' ~'.~, U.1.J_~i~J ,IJ_ ._~~~_~_~ ~ ,~;~._ ilW-~-~_1;;I! . ~~IJ~~ ... ,·~~ ~U~_~!I~J~~"!., !ltWU .~..,_-v~,L~]W,""L~

'~\I'!ii~, ~iIi!lli\._~,iIi' ,",,'~,.;:I! ,i'I;lI'Ii~'I:~iI!i~,i[!: 'vilol:li~-:lrC! 'i,~ .'If. ... ,~. rl ... ;:1I.... ~.ro.~~'l:'!lirC! ,o'I;'I"~ ,iI"L ..... iI!!ii'I! '!u",'h·'iI'1i.:i[!~ 1y.~~1I~.a;·~ I,~] L¥V.ga~ iUJ~ '~~~,,[~_~~ .f'~~-iI~~1 .~_~I ~.~~l~l ~,~p~" [~_~~~~,~I ~~ !\\o~y~~ "'~-\1P.~

maxhns !ha've law]]ite f:omJ", 'whJch ,ti's '~he IOJm ,of nCIIRla.tj,v,ji't,' ~i~ljjf. :P,m'v:i~~d '~'ha,t ,the a,t~_gorica.l impe-<r:;utv'e proeedUlw can 'K made to

W\~;i:;;L:. '1.I!"~ii'i''T'~;iI!' i"1i1ii1",.!i;l-.c~Ii'~I~: :iI~Ii' ~"'i'lil;o'li;~111i!i! '.'~I!i!ll ti-:,"' ,fc:io', ... k···. 'ii":W'~I~: (I :'h-" ~b'~.;""tfil ~: ·~;I1..~i

_ _ UII.'1 lDi_iAiJI::II~ ~ g_IBI_GI_. J.' ~aJIL~ U_,-~1lI ~,I::ll_iglr~l~ ~!iJl! l!lrV ~I ~_ . I UW.I!I. -~ Vl .l'\r."1IiP.~" ~J; !WIi]J\P.

C-O;IiiCe:pt~, '~lla;f lSt :i;t et1!aihW,t.s, 'ms 001 :i,de_IiIJt~fy 'ml'f duties. 'We aiMrJrr,e:r 't~le C(lw.t-entt I~f mOf;,alj;ty by ;I:u~e~n,g wbleJh 'm_aims ba¥e 'D,onna,rt,Vlt ,lCltln.

Copy rig hted m ateri al

B;';I~'" fie",'t.·,anli; 'iiil",1ii; _~+ ,£.·,....Jl,-,=.a,n,ii\n.l~ 'ii"fo"i;';,Qii, ... l'i'\i:i; .... II!. ""L,D Bln-C" 'ii 1".,,'iIk. m-:-c'fiiFc .... l·,. U~I~ v-~~-g~,:r~' 1~_;U:~ ,~~L~·~!1!0 ll~Ull:~UlilIJHU~,~ .. _~· ,~,lILuJ_~!ldm.~ u~: !Ir_Il~~ U , .1 .. ~~1;11_~:~, I~-._} ''''~,~:_.

'.1.,,~ .. 1 ,...,.:i! '~,...,",,'I!.. t, :'L,,!, "'!'. ~:"" ... _ ..... ,'L ''''fll''",fi t,' -J'iI',,-"'!!mt·'i"!.'b· oI"!j~Ii'!I;~U~' -0-" ~o;l '~'''''iI' iL~~... 'iIi"~iI:!i' ~~i~~ y.J: ~I1-D, ~~~~ ~pli~~~~J"Ull, ~~~~I ~~·'I'!'Ii~~~.~~~,~1~~_.,_1 ~_~~~_~:"I. __ " J~~ JI.T'~~:~1 ~~_~_~. ~,~~,

a,e~ep,tanQe O:f. :HIUme;~iS dilmntna,. :Fo:r M'~me;'-:s dlile:IrI'll'Ul :I,eaives US, w,j,t'l), :an '~n)un~lt-:e: ch~~~~, I' tl.~ 'virt!il~ lof: ,~, ,!lC!ti,(ln is loo;rif'~rrl~, 'Itr", i'u., ~'I'i:*~"'" _, t·· '''.·~n· '1"','i..,"';II\: c~~+~V\1IIi! """'fili"fl"i"!l;+ '~ t'hlill! mA~h"j@' li"il' [~bH"'.\!III·,~J~I_, ''I[ .'1;-.-, ,IiU,V!I;._I,'!I!''Vo_ _lil~ _, IU;ta:!!l; ,1i~"'_V"~~. "'"' '!;,;og_!iiII_~," ~ ~ ..... ='I;,,!!.,"~. ~ 'I!.!I= !;i,l'_~~'~I!o'M-_'-. ".~_!li!iiO

. (1/ . "I :~'·i.' ;', ,~~ '. :,"~l <~'I, "\"'" :"1 ,'Ii:,,'II,,~ ~"- i~ '~"'_f" 'j: I e i t : ..... ~ I, [' I "1 i~'~ ,II:' :t: .. UU:ma.llsts ,IiU.un.U ~ldS oUJect_UM}J_I~,U!:" lU\lJt~Jt l~aUs:e U: S~Ii'~l8! as n !ail

I.~s!t some a~do:g R;Jiny, a~Ih'~ t~1 be ,d~Jl~ ,tr.,(1rJD ,th~ motive [of QCblip'" 'tiDD, and beC31Ms£ '~k£ :fact 'M {"hUI!'!I'~ion :s@ems '~O 'Ibe d~~,"d~nrt, am, 'diI,~

~~~~~ --~- - - ---~ - --- -- - ~ -- ~ ~ -~~~- ~-- - - ---- - - ~ - ~""':I"-"""'~- --- - -- ----

·'I!..,:lt'" l 'h . T'1l.. • -~'III' d 'L'I,~ • b 'II!..

p1)SSI~!L'fy OJ( t~J~ mOIJ'V~ .: J ,~~ r.3ittQ-~J;st; r&aV~:_. Q~II,~!PUO:~~, l_:,~,t ,~t '~~,~

>!'!.;-;; .. t-1"£. '~In"'dl·l"'mli:i' m- ~.fi",,",l,~,t"U m"'-' toi'k"", m~,;,:,.''''n'~'UGl·,'I''!''''l nro-~c~~l"""''''' '0-£' ' .... """.·.1 ..... ..,."" ~~l~~ U!" ,~~~~J,cc._:~~ t~~~,aJ~,~1' .~.~I~, 1 .. ~J1~ ' _ __:-~ .. -~,r~-~'~·~-'- ~~_: [lfl. ·:..,~_~Il,l~cc~j~ ':_'cI, ~,V'cc~Y.~-~~~1

r,ldt~.f' '~, ,m, me :fttotiv:a,tio~al p~,m4~ Qf' p~op~e.

The a1irpme.m't. [~ IGliO~~dw.arik' l' ,s!b.o'w:~ '~S' wlld;o, n~t ~~,V~ 'C~ a~~~p~, HU1n~~iS dil~Iin'ma. For Katmt :s'h.Q:ws, th;lt~ the p:mnli~ of H'~N~1'S, ar,pm,~nl: ~~ 'Iha't d~j]q y~,ur dU!~:~r ,fj){1!Jm[ ,t'b.~ m,o.ti'v~: (If' di'u(" .b~ ,m ~pty ,i~m8!Usn1I c= is taJs~" Am l~bU;~,tio:_~,,-, O:~' an ::l(ilti'(1rn d(m;.~ from '.e DlQ.ti,,;e: of ChllYr :~_S ,CJJiiC ,tba,t dre a;S~Ii1,t he-l';s~~f mJ;t!s~: 'win :a;s a, 'Im.!il,,\e~ law. r~; ,is,,- :in U$ v·~ry :tl!~tro.:f:~ and ~S:9(1;n~~ ,~, ,a~ciQn ~I~J~OOO'"

'1 ""~1 d '11 I"'h . d" 'h "ll' 'b'l'

I .'[',-,' .,'; ',':: ·.~Ji· _',- "-1 ,'.~_'J ,,'[,"_ "'_:, ',' "_'_' , .... -,' -"._ ,'I (I,"'n .; .···I-I~·: '1,',"1] [.- ...... ",·:'·'r ...

,m(}.us:_y W,LJ~-,-·. U) ~(1lmp ~~~ ~~_~ argum~~lt\r ~!r}j~_, S-".,O'W tJ0;l!~, o.c',",~:ga,~

'ti~ns ~[,' ~~ist~ K:rm~ n~ds, ()~ry '~~ :~l~ow' thl~: b~m_, b~~ng~ ,Ire e.a,~a'bk !1)f: ,aJw.t"Qnom~U5 :m(1lti.V'aJltion:; m~lt is, ,t'ba,t W~ ~ be m()li'~'

~ l~

~\alt~, by' these laws, '(bait 'we, mru~~, 'wllt [f WI~ al\~ [~IP~bll~ ,~f ,gi'yi'~l,g

'II 'Wi I " ",~,I,,'VI': I 10,'11. w- 'I:..: fV'l~'~.'II:""'i'n: :

c,_3, .. 'S: ~o ouml)· _ es" U_!l.en ' .. (!l, ,I!_!lil _ e: o!J.:J,I!Igat~~nl.s.

1 W[fuld U'ke tOI '~l'imlk Cinlal~oiii:t~ If;QWD ;and ,Maj~i!~y' ThomPSOil. :f01' ,t'hdf v\ll'llrlble iI'5S'stm,ce with ,this :pa,el'"

1]: 'n~ ~~e-po:[~f:Y d~ba~~ be.~, 'WilLh W~ :I[)-, :F,'ilk/~ ., 'Uught~' ,a~d Madv,a;,;; don:" :~Iit his OU,\p:t, ,R;e.a:1SHt;g'&', d'Rd'MlTll'aJ:t:t,y: 'lfle; [O'ol:l!sCRt,Bd' ,'>IiI~pef:~ f)J W,

D 'P!ii[p., 'L._ ;Ii; iL.· .;Ml·· "·U"

,', ;.,~"~""j. ICIlWI.pt'C.f' I. ,l,im;Qo!g:: !(n~ei[' ~m:~J:t_t ~ic'~SSlons ,ue".~·:t,._.;_!I)iI1m

It...,.,,~it --- H~ 'I~O.·. Ibl'l ~ ~tlD ,ad ,M.o.t;W:am:fiD, ]1-, 'Rr~Oil!:~t :Mfiral :Pillii;lfis.o--;b::t~ in,

_",_~}e~...!' ., __ ~ ~ ~ . m _ . ~ ,~ __ y ~

ji--., .... ~ ... , ,ilt..;t.' }llt1i'i1 ... ~.·f-~"'."'i~' :'""~:~~Ii'1i,":'r,o:I:!~*'I[!I,':i:i'..,·""ofIi'~e~' ~(j ~':t~;i,ii'!i"i~""m·.,· ;u~.Ii"~,j~\Ii];.,..... 1~~, ... fn' .. liI!! .. .0::0-

lI_I~1:l! J.~~ '~!F~"- ,LJ!"'!ID."a ~_iIi ~"'IIJU.lliII_~~~"'.,.·. ~a .... ~ 0 U'J' ilt'l~_~Jl_ili!lilll J In.. EII!H_in~_~_~.I,"!llF.jI !ir-~-I-"r!l.i~-" IQ.~I

'IlIi 'n"-"i!. "'1"1.. N' '1.1' "!I!I!i..:1':5< ':L ·:k' /( A:~ • 'ID\ ... .-.21 'W"'I~II'

c~,'i'_rt, I W ·"11~g, ~.iilge-J!S ~,~~ ~;"'~~:rj!ti1'ty OJ' i.i~:tm'~IS~~1 iI:,l~m__idiy._~::IJ:~~.~.~ ..

,tilDlt~rna'~, ,~d, :b~mal, :~~S~~ in, :Iiirs, ,Mo-.r-a'l LUti'k,1 cih.fi~~' ,8", ;;mil, S~ti.-

iIl!i!~'.;U;';1 '~;)IIPUiJ!-...;~iI ,!rIm, ,. i~; •• io\'l,,!ii ;D!',£I' .... '}('.~I1'_ 11 1~\·I';E; e. '~~iI!'5, ili'h"'" ~1.'Iii:J~ii'!i1l\' ,'I'n Ii'lii::"~"'':''n't''llii'!iii~m,' ~Ji_~_IIr:'''_ii11 .U" ... ·"[IIiII~J:It!1 ,ill: _. ;1"~_il,I".iliW_lJ ,n!lr.'itil~!I;I.', :,"11 .1 ~_ ~H:iJt, 'Ir_::!!IiI ~'WI;U~f1lr-Wi~ [~: 1 O~.~': f~_iiII_~: _ 1

A}Q!!iit :PJ:1ii;¢t:lci! ~J:ng~,~1 C~prer 1'[[ i~ d~i91 'Y~lu.~,

~ ~ for i~~t~~ P.~~'kMa~ jOfO'ItJ.~~gatl~n ,arl:r.jl ,Mu,t~Y'IJtl£fn, 1n 1't~c~nJt :Mo:riiW, :rhi'W,Q5l!l}:ph:,jj !lind. 'W'ilHarm!5,~ ~]nte;marn I1nJd. :E.X!iiemal lieasQ]·ts.~·

) See ,!fer ~m_B~m~e: N~,eJl~ Th~ P1l's,fillilJty ,of'.tUttttism' aid m,f' 'fJ'Sl~,ptiJ~~sm, raibGutt :P!Jcti~~iirn, :Re.3SiOE .. ,~~'

Copy rig hted m ateri al

4, Sa1DI~\'1i~, C~~~~ ,It Di~~u_.j~ (:Qn~ni~'8' tb~ U~~'lt~f.~bJ,'~ Obli'~'afJ'QH~ rtf N~t;ul'al Re:l:11gii'lll! ~ind' the: nlu'h 1€iI'ud' .ce:l~:~;l1n:~,ll" 01 :t~~ CJ];rj~t1ldil R6'~ld~',., ~Q,B!; ~~h~ ,l!h~j!'Jii€: ,l.etil;~I~~ .:r 7'Q j: :~n T.-&~ MH:iji' fJlj S~m~~ CJ[lJirAj~ W .. ~i!l9~

<-.-. s· ~JI.~,~···' ~.-.~ L~~, ,.,'b .. ~ n.-~ .. '~l.- '~' "" -~- ':-:""C' ~'.= ~ 1~ - . ..:I ,'.- '19; '1]" 'jI1i[ -'b_ ~'~I

l'il;llI.,.,;i:l~l;;lU~ U~.Uil!i, ''"'~~ pOj!'J!,~ ,~~[m~~ 'C~, l~ ~~u ,lin ,v. ,_C" ,~pua~~

ed, T:l~ ,8r.,f:~'i&'h Mfl!fill',J,~e5J~'S ,r:16j"o.=-,~·800 'V~l I;: dl,~ ,r.aS5l~s, dwdJ ,3~~ ail: 11P, I '4-96. :H:~f:e.;ip*~ tihis wor.k 'will be (:it~d ~, ~~C]a~~b~ with, pag~ :llU~

H; f 'b C 1 d 001" mIl ~ b b f h I. h 'ru '~

1'~lS : !Inm, ,It • '.@ 111:[,;1'0 , e ·1:£1.0n, ;;,; .; ow!:::;. ,y t,.o~ : :mm, lJ Ie I :3,p .. :acl S'(l!' ee-

~io:~, w:ltefe i!i",,;ali.W!!iI~le,

.5 Pi"fi~~S! Hu~c'h~S\W:i" ,11l\uIS;~Mti~n' on' i'h~ M'QlfaJ' S,:nf'~, 'Thi!s, wmk liS th~ ,~O:l!Id pan of;~ ,A.i'I' ,~;SSQ;' an :f;n:e N~:tl1,r.,e' ,lInd IC'ond'uc[" r1f :dle: fl1S&f,~ll1'& ilinld AJfeecti<J1f1;s" 'With l'~l:~~r~tic:m's ,on' :tjl~ Mo:r~l S~'Se:., 1-ib,~~etllraft'e'J:' 't~~'~ w'Urk 'w111 h 'cIJtcil, [!iIi~ ,rj~Hiu~~·~lu~:go.n~'~ .J:~'l~~t~I"!\w;l~,,,·'I,'

6 R.'~lcJbaHfll~~c~ A. R~'Wi:e,'~~'[of' '~'~'e; P~n(Ji:nn'l OU'e~tJ'o_n;:iSl fc~' Mcrca~'l, cd D D

.'.' .. 1],1:.. .. •. ~"., , .. . j.", .. , [ .. ) , , ,t]' '- ,]f" .... , "'"' .... l... , .. , ., .. 1'" ~,~ . " . • . •

'bp:hiel],. ~t. 49, LThe R~""i~w W,Qi9i the :fi;r;5!!!; "llm)'i)liske@J in Lo:ndmx ~n I1S; 'llm~~iI' ,th,e t],t1~ A ,R~~8W 'r?J1' the ~nC'j!JUI'l (;!lU;~~1u:n'&' ,alld ,D,'iflii&~I,[>i~ ,m MaE:dls" bp:bae~Ij''8 [edildo~ 'wble:b, ~: 'M,~e [e~~e~.;. is ~~p;rim~ed :£~m, ~~b,e tbim, ~~~lun '01' 1:781" ,kID~ctioo5 ff,i;lDl, the ,R~¥l~w ~ 'be :t:irll~d! :~Q D. D. :~

, ... 1.,,01;"';"1 "",41. ~;i:I! :fi; .. I'j~,~,:Ii"n'''',;?Ij''''~I~I1' ;11,0£ 'r,oI'!i~:~!tI'1i'V'i; 'l:l!'ni111. '[I: imi'l!!1.. 'I;':J;, T,=iI];iC',,, I'i'i,.~

IN-''_93~; ~ ~~-~j! ~ ,l=-~~~ dal~.if_,"_iI3~~~~ l.;"lLv.-.; !H_liF.h.li1Wli l.i V J.l Iir.I'! ~ Q~ ~ '"-~~, l -1l'J! ~,~~ lli ~ III 7~~1 l!r_[br

~S$@ge cit~dI is, ,all. :p. 1.47', iWereLQdter ~h~ 'w'Ofk, 'Will ~e 'cit~d ,~~ ff~'IJI 'w,~,di1, ~,~ :~l);mIH~ f'l'~m, Rapn:!u,=d:':$ ~:djtio~ of tb~ '~:k. ,~o~m.owEd, '~ th~~

"'''''''''m' " ,.,1., .. , sele ..... ;n .... 'eo "1'0' !fj\ri"I;i;~',~j" ;liI;il'J'jI, .. "'"'~';ii,L7tl~ 1~II!li!t ~~. !lrJlhr ~jlJr.;'-~!i._lII;-v.-!fJ_ .. ~J [~~ I ,UiliL~J~.J:tJI_-u ~1K1Ilv.'--- .. ilW~[._,-~!4.~_I!o'l

'i Da,v,~d, :Hj\l!.~ ,A, ~n1e~t~e.: of ntj.;~n ,N~:tU'~~" :p.. 4,; r. "~-ifid)b~t ,ollted ,a~ ,I,~ H'Il.m.e!:S n:eiltt~iil§l'ei. iJ

IS :F(lII' dii8C;U~!iiQ~ see ~,m SCI~~~p'p~ ,:rGt':~ P:rt-'C,ri~cw !i'tlJic.'!i!; Ic'fI. 3+ ,K~[filit; t~~~iSi Hl'liltcb~on l~, d~~ :Nm I~,y {i:;~ ~Ih.i!lwl, ~d, :i'D, :~a:w~![ w~rk:; 'U:''ealts H1Utciheml!l,c~, view !itS, r,'epl'escl'llt'Sl'tive m aiU~m:ptsi '10' l'ase. :mKJKr.ali:ty ~~ f:~f:ili'!lg. :~'~ hj~ :liil't1(li~hil.~~~Oil, ~g, ,Ad~ Stmiithl.'$J ~h~~lY' Qj M'o:r,~} ,smi~i,m;es.Mit~~, :1)", D. b,hael [d!eSCirihe.s, ,3, ,~.et)tieir.' of :117' 1: WM ,M3tdb.lls Hem, to ~rl!; in. w:h'ich He..~ ~ef'e'~ 'tgl 8;mi,I~'h ~S !!'y,auir.' krv~~tJei" f;p, ::1 ;ii;).

P 'f~SQ"~ed,I' 'be,~aJil~'~ ilt. W.a81 'wrl,t)lie~ mi" a. :p~e ~f-f~~.oo :~~ 17"(ki by we ,l8ed~n Ac.~ulC:ill,Y\'" 1:.,'[ did, :i'i,Qot; aC~lJaUy 'wii~ th~ ~~:Z~I' w'hich, '~~i'i;t 'to M~~es :Me:mdeJlsmhn., See LewJis Wb~~e :Bee\~~ Ba~:r..l~' ,G'e.:r.;ma~~ ,f{b,tlmQ~il'}\',~

,;~'''''i!I",,:r' "":,,,;,~ ,q~, .... ;~i~·~'"''''oii''''"'''''iI'.\''' iIi1Il'1ic . .4; JlI 'jIi' ~' "II

~~:~,~ I~~:~~ ,rJ:~~1 ~;"",!I:~~~~~~I~~' ,~,F~ ,~~~,~~~,,,

~H~I 'ft~ t;'WQ' :~t~, ,d!~~~b~di I~Qnei!!,[!]Qnd QP~,ooWnatt.J,y U;i the :m~~pby~~~a~, ,an~, 'l[iioJSCeiDde~bm, ded1!lCllo:os, [o;( the Cl!tQ'~ri.es :irlil, dll~ Grlrtiquei at P'lJ;r~ .I~'a\S:oQn~ ~il~([Io~ '~'be reli,tiO:!l 'bet;w~,en ~ me.t~,b:1fflicil de:duothnl ~j m ~

!n'l',j;~'l;~ ""'''''11''''''''1'1110' '''!n.·.:1 ~Iiii';r;: "';,'O'[i18·:1\r:<'i';oo: ~"'I 1'1"'."...' ,~;,i';>;"'iii'~['V "",'I)~)",i'i" T~ :"i"''IJ' ,"'!31"'I!! 'i;l!;,~,

F.I ii, V, til. ~~ _ ~r'lil :cUI ,~J .. ~ !IiII_oIJII __ I", Q.~_I:'-'i ,~!<3i ,~_L~!l.1 ,~_IU}!Ir.-!I.1="_w..,.· ,,-=_:IJ!.riliIU~"'1 .11:1, ~_LII" !ir. _~_ !l.lllLIir.

,~ru,ysl:!i' ~ ~'be 'C:Q~~~~lt Qf ~~Ug~ti'{):D~, 'wilth 'wlliJ~h.:[ ,~~n I~oticemed. ~e~e"" 'w~ill :s!b;O'w' t'b3it it :15, :to~caU'Y puss~lirl~e,.... 'thait, th,~ ~dca, COnttaill5 :I1n '!DQnrU';ad:.i,et~oD, - whUe t)ht is,yn;t)h.esis, wUl :*ow· ,~W :~~ is, ,~~y ~sil~l~if :bnw it CSlI'I, 3ippl:~' [t.o us.' ~For.' ,th.e~ ,dwstitm~t~on MtW'C:tm. :lopc::d, ad :F~ pm~iL.:~~iltyj; sec ICI A'~4\;l~,~1B'310':['9'J~, :i1i1i'l.d"As;~~~lcB6l\4.n .. The aeOOIlJRJt of

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Analv,s;ies of ob'~'i'''\!Idon

<~ ..... ' .... t __ ~_t .. _J

:t:¢al :po~lj'blliIty In, t'b~~ p!I$$a8,~ :~.$ p,v~n l~ ~c~,ms of l'h~ poss~J!JiU,ty of [e:x~)den,ce .and tkelJefme~ doos; 1l00t I!Pfly' ,t~ eJd];i~~, IOQn~ptt hurt 'theile ~CClU$t, '-It,ill '!JeTe- [~-:-a:J.O'--- oP~ £M-:tllica~ [iOIl;r;,~ts "'f. dO·~'!::irf ;--ca'i"',~'~Im~, ,S~I _' !i;1!IIl m_,_~p~ '_~ ,~'.~,~ _ 'e':_:_:~ :C __ , I~~~_ ......... i:-',~' ll",,~.! ...... ~-IJ~ f;_,~'lQllIl!!L~'

~S'm ~, ~fb]~, i~ 'b;i! be 2,'t'\ru*~.

[I P~or.' 'tbl!:i 'MOS.t :Pi,lirtj. 'I' w~11 use !!lI':rlxht~j iind ~""o'bliPitQ'rycil,l' to deno~e' ,arny' ,ii)(itiOl!l, 'hit :~~ :mo-raJly caiII~td :fOi'" ,)[h~ t~nn ,tlf!i,_~tt:i~' ma,y' 'M, 'Ui$~d :m~ 'h.IiDad!l,::-~ fOI :i.rn.elub ~rmjsi!itlhl~ :a,ct-iO&, :and ,Kamt~s aa~,\I'S'h;, ,:dS(]ii [@Xl'ii'~ffi,~

- - " -l'~ _ _ -~~ ~_ ,,_ _ I I _, ~.w , , , ,_ . ~ ~ , . " , . . '. ,f . . . . ,If"

,cate.s dds, BotiO:O;r 'b,1lI!t :ml'~ :~'oow, w;i'~~ 'R <m ~e~,U'i'[ftl aet.io;m_s. 10th HI!~tlJ! ,~d, ~1,g'.li~t~tY1~ ~, ~~I iDe: ~~ mo~re· ;8:Jedfi¢a~I,y; ~Q' :r~Je!li' ~clt~on~

.jUtl i' I ib" .. "ltd ~'I" ' ,d j ,~. ' [ I "~n ",,,. '}fJ In· /{ t, u I

(:.a. ~. i : Of ., so a.. c:, '~l"I.\U,_t Utle5:1' 0:1' stl., ,mnle 8,pcCI. ca. y ~o ,iilC bOlles

mUed, W1' 'h·y· 'ilusti~e,. So~ :f"bUo~QP'b~Ji fm ~gm,l~ :Ij'um.e ~d B~roa'fd, 'WU~j3ms,~ [bcli;c,;v;~ tt'b:at '"riiglhrtcr,r and, Ij'riblita~rl :s'~{):a~d, [01]i1.y' 'be llse~ 1m

QH,e m~ 'tibeR 19u.er tw~ cl~:i~$ [of iii~tioo~" ~d, ~t 'v~Fi~~ ~~Dt~ w;~idd find, in, dills 'd~w' gmn:llds, toz" obi~Citin,g eo ,the [I'r,gu:m.c:n)t;, of ,this PPC:[", I dkJ :~ot try' lo' d\ea11, Wi~, d'w! i~Ye~ 'burt: :1: IIg 't'ry' t~ ~Qti~ 'm~ :pgi'Jlit' wh~ U: ,co-m$· iIl,p" ,See: :U.I jill' .1]:1:1, :lind ,1\3",

~:j; RigbtneS8, ,~~s :Sitrncdy' speal:in:s: a p.~ny of a,~t'i~ gd, ,a:m;y giw.J], act en be dog~. :~m ,a. 'v:mc;ty Ill' :mm~,lt~~>!' ,~j bad, IOf md~lm~t. :8Ult. :~t; a~~, CIiJl be. !KIng 01' iduJdfl,cd :ifll '~I',ms of :m.o,t:ijve~, ~ve:11, if d,,e~' are n'Ot

~iI","'.nViIIJ ,~I'7'n'" '£~m .iil.,,",C''', m'o;·.·;~·~.AC', •• LA\1 ~, ... , ... f'~',,,- , .l .. ,c-'''d'- ""iii. ,,.,1.., .. , ,·0· ... '""'" "" 'W~I!(!I!,,"'~ ~'=-=c~-. ~~= 1~~_1~~ ~--·~-~-~~~tr l~gJ!r.li'; ~~L., l~ y-~m:~-~---=-, I~~ ~~~~ ._"~~I ,~,

:~~, wiI,t1b, ~ ~ot~'vM 'W'OA1Iildi ,lin ... ill:' I~n~~ du!t~ [goOO m{)t],V~5 w~!'lld :PIlUm,:pt" Th.@i st;rriu.(\:~ 15 thOQgb~ to he cJ __ f:a~te!rl8!tlc; 0.£ Vb:tU,e-Cie:IlII't:€lrN [~t'~fCaJ th~orieSi\i' :bu[t ~,I 'will :9lb(!!rW :~t is a];SQ' Ka~~~'Sl,

I;), Blum@/)s, n&iill1,s~, 'PI., ,;,\\,',8,. This al!:gJlm.ent [OOC1!I!fS 3,t: 'th~ N,gi!Bm.ring uf.' ,tb~

1ii_;j,:'O~'m, '~ri 'ii:>.,'b,~, ... iL.1 iiiji..:;;j;,~I"'_ [1'<11 ,; .1_"':I~ .. ,1I ... ra, """"1 [ .. ,_liE ... ". ,"Iii ""'-irib. ,"fll~'.;i :1"' ,~,,,, '~{~c:__~~ ~,~, '",,'1J:~~c~~:~ ~~-~~~~ ~-i;!! ~U-~~~i~~,~-~~UI I~i;!! ,~,~ ~,l~~~-'~_~~~ ""~~,l~g.~ir ~~o=-UI ~l~ ,I!!,,,I

'jmpnrtJil'llt; to. pl~blJt. O'IlJt ,t!hIJt: :iIes, [OtTll.elusion, Will, iii, ,O'~mjjn Wfl.~' on!I:~' a~p~i.¢(:i' ~O' me; :U'Ww Vlifltues" The '':if,9t :met~y~ l<!Jo 'i~sd(!e '~~, 01;l[t te, be H~i"" WA'te(e~t ~'A!'~:2'f' oAIJf1i;[~~. burt tbis "':S,'I'I¢U:}u::.f,:an ~iIi'U!c/aUv 'Yli1'tIllOO'5, nt,tJ'~ ~~~,'M;2,·

, .. , ... ). "~I""lT' ~'''''f;l'',," l'" ,.. .. :1...... ..., . iF"'" .] .. :/' , .. , .. _ .. 0 " , ~,4J1" ~

:nor :is ,it 'the~ m(Jtive i!JjJ8!'WiUy ,~~ 'W'Oiik '~m ,Qge~t;i, ~riQ~,mjng j~'5it !!ictiOllS. lPaIlli~u;]i!llf ~c;u ;Of: 'i'U5'tl"' Nhn ~e'l!I1taJt~ly ,~ mot n~~n~y ,WH ~[' ~nte.~eSit: ~:,4)"{'~" Wt~ ,~p,pflave of iiu8ti~e: bCCli1iJiR sy~pam~y' mak:.:s 'Us ~ .. }ve' 'WbaJtg,~ is, hl me! oone~)ii,ve i~t~t-es;'t ~4'99- 5 001 it 'we :~dorrn, j.U$:t; ~;l(~ti.Gn~~, <Of. :R:sn:l.m. Ol!l:rse~,¥'ClS, :from, iU!inVll!!I!t~ (m:esl.' '~IJS@: "!tI'e ,appMV'e: of: 'i~sti~:; lihit ii~, OOC3JU~ j!lliidJce ilil 'ri~nuG!llii~ :ilfnd. 'we 'v,aiu'e !Ql!I~' own dhM,acter ~:s,oo-=a:l,~ se~ ,;iI~OI 'm~ .Hnql.l·ir, Chfili~mflll' t;h~ hj1n~~pJ~~' !(JJ,M:'miiJ'Js:, ett :Le .. A, k1I.'f~Di.Ue ,~. :p~ ~L N'id'di'tt;o i:'Odofd~ Cb~dm ~eS9j; 1,t"rS:Jj p;p .. :i,el~-6l'~!" 11tiJe, :~, Qfie: ~n'$~~ in, wh~cb, 'iiUS!ti~ ~S! ~n ,HaN~6.ci.al N.' 'Vilt)u:~., Th~~ :POiOit: 'becomes :i'mfO[tarolt :Ila~e!r' :I<1l die :::lIrgumJe:o,t; see '0;1 :[ "

:[,4 :Hi\Wm.e"rs, 'n~l~i.;~~ P', ,4,1',8\,

:IS Seei :10:1' ,in'S!ta,t~ N!a,pl~, 'The ,Prm&:tb\fl~:~lV' (if Al;r'mi3.m~ P;PI. 4;=5. ,16 :Hi~t~'heSQD'iS, Inti~trdtiQR'S'i' :p, 130:,

'1'":11' 'UZ'""i", -'L.- ;r; ......... ,l.- :J~:"~,~,,,,,,-,,,,o;li~'",,,,,;:;, 'n'p' \~, .... = 'I' ':ri''''

&; ,"!Ur!l,.~U,~;;IU'Ji!li,!5i .lUU~'~'E~!!.IlI:~.!IiJ;I!,~ ,';', •• ,w,,;r;I'1 ,a)u.

Copy rig hted m ateri al

:18 fbl)tipll~stm,":!!J, ,nlu,¥tj'~,ti'W71~~" '\., l' !M~-

t P Hl!rlti(i'!h:~mn.jis, 111U~~'I~;dan~~, :,. I,4],Q. ~ee. ,aasa iHi'!Wll::lte:so.n:I;5; l~qJl"~~ COniC"~n~

... ,I. T"i;'" • _ jl f' ~ " ..!Ii ,I '!IJ!" ~ j' iii ~~ ..;j' Co 't~ 1ft;; ifi 'L. 'ill

,lilS;' ~li~ 0,r~g~~~ ,(ii' [~i~~' ig:€~~ oi' '~jirt:~e: (lij" ,ili~~qE:6,i:' ~(!hj~, :~n, ,v" ,~~ il;\.3.Pila,~~,

[;d. Tke: ,lib',~tll)sh M€ftaZ:istJiil' .!: 6JQ=f\8'~~' vl)~" l~ :p" ~93,.

:1ro, H'~r~im·. ''''!'lG' '~..l!I'i<I:~:~'I::>;:O'. 'I'll. ~1.,\iThl ~ ~ ~ d~ _ J ... ~ ~,iIi'~!H ~lIj~!ii':;' ,f!'~ l~ 'f J r.

~:J :H:o,ww-er;t ,~~ :1: pomJt ,o.~t: in lU3'1 the nunive Gf d:b~iptinn, ,f~ d~le ~$'.~' :mod,v'e ,3il; 'WO'lll:, :tll '~b~ 'casr; of. jIJ'5it ,actl,Q]1;~, ~,an~, 'w'h~n 'W~ ,~~e ~e.ptedJ-i [~b~te:rnltiO_fiJS,t ,and tbrjs is 8!lt '~_po;nB~t iPOllllit: ~.~ H'lI.~IS fa!mr. [Q.1lIIf hUef that o'bU!,ga,t"lmEJ $ihQ\W~d H 'we mod,ve of: j~a!tt aC;Liensl is m[u'C~h :11',m~[ '£!han, i,i}U!r' heHd 'that h~ ~h.ould 'be t'ke MOt--"~ .of t'~m~' ::t~·f:: ':-1 :-c ~.',e-:·,--,-, m:,: ie

_~ '. . .. ~."...,.......... . l.. . E: Il::l'OJ}S ~lJI!ng.lng, ,~~,rgm

wlla!t~ HUm~ '~bi [~;:'in ~'be ~al1!Ut~l 'vru~~e8i 'Wtrl~h, we :m~y t.re,prd. ,3S 'm~rit~rli1!,'Il1'S mdulr dyo 'ir.@tlIfu:l;rOOj ~:s~ '~'~Hl'[~ it 's~;:~C"rud i~"" [c'k.-.~ '-::::,-d ~h [ I~"I

, .. ,,"',,' ... ! , .. , ... "J .. ~ .•. ~_ ,n",~. ,,[_ .. ou ... ~o~erv~_,'~~!1_ nl!

tJk.~ :pa$i~,@ i~ 'wllW~eJ~ be ~o:mp]9ii'n8 'm_alt: '!r;wtlmwaUs.ts aJnn'Ot~ ;I;~~otlmin :fUf' mo~a:H,t,yj1S, powa itOI :.~tiv~~ U$]f. 'w.~~~'IJi, I ~\l\~ q:UQ~edJ O~ p,. :\:Il: ~ i Uu-e is ~rcel~l ~;OO~t fb:i51~ be :5fellks :s~ilca11, a'bo1il1tt 'jiust a:edmiiSi" 'nll~ :Hi'ij!m.~ oou~iI. ,a;I;pe~ aJg.a!i~st the PQi~Jt I am m,~~g be-;[~l 'tb~lt. :b'h~ :1i;"S't~:m, :r:a¥01;S tnc o,pe~a)t-b.u"il of th,c :mntiv~ of. d)U/ell In. [~xaetly ~bDse ,~a.~$, in, 'wWc~ 'we :f~~~ gg~~~ ,au~ 'm:a,t: it sboil.i!'ldJ o:petiU1e.

1:1 1i.~dmIf:.cd in, nGI'" Edli~', R'~I~gi(U:i~, ;i1\!1,d ,Paliti~,: CfJll"tftd ,''hil(i)~(}1Jblic'id

~l<'Iill'l""ir.\~ "ii,~' ,i".~_;~, M~'/~_·AII,!"'}[\""~'1":I:..",,, 1:{""~'iIi'lm' .... ..., ,iii',l~' 'nn 'I "::~A""

~ Y.-J!!"~J~I v.:1 u~ iIJi. lj",~ ~ liirnLiI~I~!Ir.-U"~IEilJ~11 ·"l~d!!I.:.I __ ,j~ .~I~J:jI ~[If· • .oiiII-!i). ~'~II'

~3 WnUil~8J 'WaQI~~ us ~Q' :~e~Q~~z~i 'tihalt, 'Obli,galt~.QI'IS, !,r~~OI',m. ~ust [o;ne 't:~ of 'et'h'i~al consi}tfeir:in~~fillll~~' [[;po :[ 9~l\" ,Smne: ,a,Cti.o.~s, ,am :n~t: [D'bl~)'o~ W~ :mof;t ur I~~s dl;a~ 'Qb~i~tcOtY~ ad .. h;a'~~7 o:r ~~~o:l~ O[ s:i'm,iPJy' what ,a, persrrn Of I~ [~ltt~[.act~r '~bl dQ ~'I" J]'19IJ. Wi(~ma~s'~~, 'v~ew is, ~i'mnlM' t~ l'.b.!)Me/sl 'dew' ,tn_ait: ,the m..ot~,~,e m ~mrlil,gadO:Il, is ,3,~,Pir@p;1iI1;tfl: :ku" G]l~ ,kind, 'Q~ ~Q~im, OOi'i~!iJd~'m,tlOj1], [[lbart m iru~U~e:j hIt '~O't~ ~l I~ nl:[[~ 'iI~~, ,:I}:I'); W~~liil'm5' :rep~d8 ~ttem1,plS ee t-Ir.·ea,t: ::d~ ct'WcaJ. '¢lm:a~.5' as, ~~, gof 'oblig;I~ioi] [~~:¥' :me~~ 'af stiCh, dervices ~S' ROSj,~:s, p,l,i'mtl lacJ.e o'b'ljptims~, 01' im~ei! ilUlt.t0s" 0.1.' g,~ne.f!aJ'~, [dJn,t!i~'j 'O:~' du,~L~~ ~o ~n~:!!e-Jfl 8i~1 fun.da_mell;tli.lI:y m~s'oo guidallPi'+ I7"~=9:l'~\;, 'Th;e ,pl~fljl; oJ Sillcib a,t11lempls", r M]~£v~~, :i~ :R~t; :wC!rcily tel:w-:po~ an, ,::I~~IJ,~l!!iru, Q:~d~flht~ss! ~ 'th~ :m~i~J, 't'¢tt.1iLi'n;l' ~o:[ eo license ~l!lifni'inl iPe.~le w:bn iJp.o:r.[e [eefi"lifIJ ~tn~.ca1 eb.r.i;ms,l bUll; t~ 'iii~,pmai[\l, b~lw ttJ)~ [~~aitQlS ,~,li"!~ mOIDnart-ive fQJ~ "fur the .1l)1/:8 'who 3,ct: an '~h~aL wnm~am!S [~OM ~Cl;e tba,t; t~li~:!I' I~ :~~t Qf: 'fh;~ :m,Qot~,ve ,fQ~' t'he~ idea m i~ll,era'l o:r ~mred~t: or P:l,im'~~ f~C'i~ [obHpitiomfS,~ bll~ thinb, tlJt :~t ~.~ ,iI~ ,~n:{Jl ,t'O S'tiJfrII~os:e '.i3lt ,a!n, 'n:r;aClie-li~ 'I'Ifoossit\1P' 01' 'rlOr.m.ard'Wl: ~ ~S!li'ilc:':,--, f~;----

- ,It'"',V-- ~ -~~- - -~ ,F-~~ =, ... .!Jil .. d ", •. •. "~~~'r]]jQii!l, !r:om

[Ob~~gait.iDS ,I,,, I 96~!!, B~ jf :b.e ,~~ :rlgb:t~ ;~g:_~ ,~OCD,lmilllt of dll!e :ll~aJti(v;e; :fQ~~e~ of these claims W5 ,n~cd~d,~ as lta.~ Wffiu'ffilW a~. ~ :Q~Ji!$\.

~4 ,AllI~o:m'be says t'hlit: the ~~r:m;s, '~'~S:h,G,~'L~~j' ,alld, ~~01:ll,ght~~ ~~hav,~ nQW' a~~~ .a Sipe~ial se-ealled .'~.Q~~.'I :!!Im~ - i~e.~1 ~ :ie~s.e, in which '~'he.Y' :i'miP1y smne aibwlul~e' vemi:et [~U'ke one of. !i:fuiltUfOM' ~iii"l~it~:' [~: ,~ ::-,-,~[ c; ',;1 '~'~ffiru -',if!: ,:" d'~

-- --~~~~ • ,-, H ~l" ... c, ',r'" ~-~ I Y on, ::I, m~J Qo~ W~~!!Ii~ ,~S _e

iScn[~, In, it'h,e 'i,ongh.'i~ :seir:tt!l!lcti,;l;:~es/' ~'UM"".:I""Pi'i1I' ~~:O'''I'",;~i '~~II"i!o\'io;r;;)'MI'''''!Ii!',li',i' iiIfI Cl,;fj;. ,b"~

- . ,." - ~ -~~ ~ ~. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~J""vc~=~ ,!!rilli .. lv;:]!u,rU,~ irl" ':?-!' ~~

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'1"[

" ,

,. I'

, .. ;~l;o"'i" 'l1l'i :1:'''1 ~', W~~:::~]'l·~, ... ~·;r;: ,"':"'V"';" U ,;iJI-m'""'iO>; ~[ '''''m' " nl'll'~~1i [li'h .... oh~~!lT1iI'·;.~'I[1i[ '.i5.r'~"'A t." ''''(iJi

.... ~.".... iF\" ..... ,"''"'~ ~ ~ ~. ~ L"~OIJOIJ~ ~jl'·1". .."' '!o!.! _!!;,(!O., !QI __ . , ~~iIojl,l,'!W I ''""~''"' __ ~~~~'J'!o!.I"'_"' .. ",~_iI; .... ,.,.',,", ="" c.~_

C-scs.P:~riII: :i.t~, and, the fact: 'thalt. ~ ,gir.'Y\eo~ ,iiige'llit WQurud '~~ef~:r ~ot t:Q'~ ~~ ,tbiIS, :-i:-:-;ii:-~~'-'- 1"iii'L:: ',-,;,-,' I;-;~I~~,~:' :-"}ijt"~,,::-'I.~ -c' ~:rFiI.'~ ~ift'i!:, reles wiU not '~~(i!l1l!S~ him, B}1h,,,,ml "",ne mor:aJ~_~!~y 6Y", ~'" 0'1 LJ\it,l.m _ ~! ~ ~.!i! ~ _~ _ _ _ ~ _ ~ _ ~.~ ~ _ _ _~ __ ~ _ ~~I!'

:oGf: wiJ'll, ~bmjil:g him, to' h bas~d, ,Oil ,a :mis~nde~s)ta~dling", B:1Dme ,is! t'b~ [ci!Ql'scteri'5:ri:c r:m~t~Q,1'J. of' tlit; mOl['tll'~ty,,s1,,~:tem~' 1;1~'.b!i'~~~ ~!f'Id' ,'b[~~ LLrnit$ (Jl ,Pbi$~S!~phy~, p, :n"?',~ m,,' 'e~plta:$j~I'", l'i:i!s ~!i_!ii, t~ _t". W,~&i the: :mnr,~i~iJ~f :s;,,,t,cm W:~il'i~m~, '~rlOOs ~.~ me t'e':It.t is dlstinotb' r'8itiOEdbdi~ 'hurt: ittb~ [em:pbasi_s C~ ~.~a:mt:~, and, O~, ~'be 8e~e:f;j~. idellis, of mEnt,an~ ,d!em~n;t~, ~s 'O'lNCi [~'1lla~3c,tMiStlc of smtt~m@flit1l'l~st t'iitoori'e5 '~o:r 'l'ea'SOllOS, J mentiu i~ 't'he te1l:it~,

' .. ~,~- -~ .-. ~~, ,- ,I~.), .,,~ ... , .... , .. I" ~ ,., ~.~,,~'" '" _I.~,_.l __ , -_., .. ,j"

~mrt Ji)g~iC.e-i' me w,~,y,~ ttlfi dliIttii!1i5! m: :~~$~t r-e~tn~r; ()!~r :p]";aclt~c~ ~ :bl~!nl'"'

":~'i:t·, 'b·· i"''''''i::I',;o'1 tii""':~cF [{~'tii"~~ :-,tli.,...,.a·;-;;1; ... .i· 'V~'"'!~ [""'I'f'f''';~ "'I',""'Y' ... .,.' ~·I~" .. "'."i' '"1L,'I'i~' ii'li'[ ~m,-

.~"~III I ~,}' I:J! l .. ll~!l.1 1 .. 0,,. ~1'-'1rtllU ,-;l_lI, UJ. ~ .~Ar.~ ~ r. + ll}.I_~/~:~ ~_~- ... ~ '~~ [IJ-~.I~:~ 'Y'",~~ _~~ ~

p~lete~ 'COO!l\emp~ or dlen,y dIe w:roI](doo~' aU mct;a~ 'W''O.fm, ~ecaUR Oft t~~

..,.., I~. :; ~1Il;-,~ -"-, '1. ..... ::: [~ .... , '",'[til ,-e, "'~J'.iIO,--,-;, 'I..~ ','1-, :,-,·'110 ......... ,,·,·,·,. ~,,"'i_ • .:1 '""',-l',''"'~,;:Ij~~,= ,"'n-'. t'i'~'l"", "."i<" .,~,i""i!!\ofiom~ -~ iIi"ijlj'i"I~'Ii.·'I"" ,Qi!',iI?' .... ~H!I!!l~l:i1 n(l: ~yU 'Iili ,n~,"''I.:i!r ~ ,~~iIJ~,t"~u'!n.U ""'hl.l'.l~~, ,. __ ,U, '1:.8 r.l! JI!iI! ~OIJ~""'''-!', .. ~ .. ,~_.U!!Oil

'wi,d(t, it'Jh~ i~, uf :~~, who as u '", • ,3 m.or,arn Mafili.g Ci.a'n, :n.e:v'e;,[' Ieseall p~ed~s:~· ,sidon, to ,goOO:~j ItM'l~1V' -t}(i'll. :1 diso1a'58 ~'bi8, iiui!tl'!ilde ~o '~~ii1.e' in ~M~·n.iil~itty ,~S

iI:!!' d'" I~ ..-..L z· iIl..' '-I

.I,-,meomtj" '~lj8!pt:e;f !j lD tJiJilfJS 'Vli1l'U_:me~"

~S This, :~9J :m;os't; eJqJ~~(;U;:tn th,e; dltOJY 'of .Ada- Sm:i,tb~ w:~u) has, mOi!~ ~o sai~

,,,,'~~"'J'" 'm: -. "'1<",,,.]~ ·m.: , .... ,~)t!l.,',,,.;4.c ... '?O;'I ,.11.'1' i'i'ri, 'H" """""'1'\"'" ,A':" 'H" ;",,,, ... ii!:-''''''''''''''_·:I· " [ ''''I'Il''~1 ~ .. 'tb·"". ,: :iIl!~i",·A .. :'" '''", '''M'[ ...... ~~~e· .. _i(H]YII [ __ .w-.l1ii1_ I __ :.u!·"_~'1!'iiI}'_~,.'V:~_~ -'_D __ ~JI~ l J l ~_~J.I_~ U; .. [ [,~~-~~IQ~~ ~~~ no _W ~-~-~-!;JI ~ ~y_~l.,

pJS\i:tive it:(l)OQ,~t 'oj' ,tih~ :rillle of: 'the :m,~li,v~ of du,t}'; Smitb ~,y;8': .. ,rWl~n [OUl' :pa~5i,u ~~lin,~ u~ I1Jb~n(l1St al:w,a,ys se 8G\rd~d and, s.e:l:iS:b,1 h'Ow comes

., . 'Ii.. . ••• 'II . '~ M f' . ~~. . . . dJ - c "C

~lt bi:at 0'1l;[ !I'C:t:lj~!re. :pr,[D.CI1'ples :S1i_i"OU~ -'-, 0: ,~eg I~ ~ :gelle"iID~S, ~"-. :IID[ ~m"

h~~'~' ,It i'IS ':Dt th-, 5:~'t 'i'iiO'w@l' iOf. h~marnit,~' h: "~, nut' 'th3~, fe:eblf: :s~~nlk of'

, IE: ,", ,", '" ,_ ,iI! ,,[lJ ~ , . ~ .~o. ,t". .. .. ~ , , -) - ~ - - - - .. ,'~ " ,1- ~ ~,' '- - _.. " .. ~... ~,!f" _ ,]. ~,'

lx~_mev;O:ID@nc~ which, N';a,ttu'e has lighted ~ m ,t_he :ltuJ~m i&;e~!r.t ~h~t ~s t'h'U~ ~pal~l~ of ~~~~!r;ilclti. the stm~!~5!t~ ~~pld$~5! of. ~'I~~~Drv~" 1't~ i~ ~ s1"m~ '(f'W~f~ 11 .O~le' ;~'pr~ihl~ :liDmi.v~j' 'which 'e:l\i.~fts, iItseU ~po:n, ::5~cJb [0 C'ctI:sius; , I:'t: ]llii' RHone ~~~n:C~p'~e1; '~Q:M~~~n~et 'tile i.bi't:.!i1nrt gf thee 'br~as~ ;~'&~ ,~~ 'Mwin., 'al~ 8re~;~' i~;d;g~ '~l1[d' ~'f~Jt~f' 'OJ O:~' oQndi7ct"~ l 'f~lB

~"'oi'1i'~' ~ ... ~ M'~-C""'~_"',~ ~''''''H;~;il,[~,,," ... ,.,o.:< 'p_ ]'" 7':" 'm'!L!" ""'m .• ·~'I"''''I·,,,,,t Tl-o>;, ;!\!', .... ,", .. 'MJ.ii!:-·l·,' .... iJ:

l~ .l({DU.JrJ!' ~J 'I _ ~'tL.m.IiFJIl !iJ.!D_'E~J~~iI::iI_:'_.:Q'".('_1 ~.~JI! ,~. ~ lid 1- l __ I,.,J '!W. __ ~ll:_~_iR!~ OI~J ~ ·11 u~ L.::I~____!::_'_j ,,~lIJ_lIJ_ ~.~I

Sndt'h:i:'s :i'mp'[d_~J :i~t:at.i{JJ~ d.e"vdQp$ by a pm~~s~ ~f l~t~m:i:iU~It:lQn. '~~~lt 'be,gifi~ 'wi'th, ~~' 'i~d,glI~i~~t~ of' 'th~ Ci"multltt m O'tIfJ;~i':S\" ,S~,aJtlli.i!hi'i~; '~i.t~

, .... i;"L~ .... , 'II!i"L."1'1 ,i .... , 1", , .. 'I·' ..... ,· '1,'I"Ji'i" '~'io\"'V' f.,'.,.;iilJ'j;l; "'lii'" '."~m, ~ 'I'" ,oU'f r"';i~;e:,,"j·;I·"""l" 'in "f"~!r.' ''''WI''Ji[ UilOQ","~ 'l' ,",I1'u ,iI," .:00 il\ _L"'~_ ""OIJ, 'n "'T ~"'.Y.I!;I!_' Y!iIi ,)""_ ~ __ 'iI! V _, "";""101 ,~o. ,_ I!.;!',~_~ "" _ '!..I!""'~ V _ ~ ~_'"

,onlliiiIDll,et~, :lmd. by: ~'hi:s, ptOOCe.cSs 'We~ ,~~e l~~ ~O dt~ 'de~, of ,ainl :m.'te:ma~, rs:pecLti!l:" ~O':' '~-"'h-~ "flldpn~~ :'S dl.~ MOt"!r7<l; Ot d~t~ '~~'rbti TJUi:O'ffi' ,@/i M!or,~~ ,~fttl'r"i"

[~_f w ~.Q __ I ~ ~ _!IiI1 C ..... l~ ~,. I. ':/ ~ .. r .. ,,~, ,'~ ,,. .~ .. _

,nllB.'lI'I'S", PP'. Ie9i=1'a,~",

~6 c'f'o' 'he ,'~ W:~~U~ms, ,~J~ diS~\!li$$~S: dlJiffiS ~i;d~: ,of t;h~ idea, ~f Qhm~pti~nJ 1m

'Ti..--::..-,i.. ';o'Ijili.t~:;--:, [""~ii;o;d' :"c .... , d' ~ ... , "[ ;r~'n... _,' :-:'''lij!;F,'loj'!;'''~ 'N~.·.'.--_~·J30 . ',;0" :." j;J["'v~t ';'Il' 'h~ 'I~i",. ".~jlil''f'.,' ... ~,.:;~~. "~~ , • ...,.:r'" u.~ !I,;:.u~ -e.:r ... !liIL_"" ,;dUo "OI!IJ~ c;I ...... ~,h .. dl" .... ~~iI;,jl' ,OIJ _ , • __ '.il! ,I:!l:J:!u".[wj. £01;1;'100;1'1;,.

~1' See m[ :i'n8tal!l:~e Ni\Qo,m'~mM~ Ed~~c~ W.7 1 I '!t5;1}1 1-:[.4~, :!rn~+:~:,1 :rll,b~:$; W::I :~ :~::~oa1!'l; :1"'5)' :~: :~'719,bJo[; ,and :x..S' :~: 1l::8Qalil=S.

c .... ,iili,"~, '~'.ii·\i!'!;o!O~~I;rj;il!; ,t~'jilfl:l;r;, ,j,[-..;, "I "m,~; ~' ,tiA.'·~ '·.iIi'iI_;"liI!i'......,,-·'!i.,;, '1"'" 'C .... ,f t·~ iH"'-!"~"1i'llri1 ,"'"fIt'Ii·,;I1 'iii,~il'· ... 'I~''''''_'t.,iII!~_jJ f';,;.' :_;::1, ""C5'1!!j"' .. :_ .... "I·o!'Il~I~!v, ~l1i ~,w]~IIJii~IIII_~l.lnll_~_1:li .iIJ_IJ_1J •.. ],.. ,_III=III_~";V!Il::Ij-" ~~I, ll:"I~_.I~l}!iI·!I.~L~~~~ "_iJ_.r~ l"l =l1·!II~I!r.~ .;JI"'!r.' ~~s-!!Wi~";e_lIJ~~,,

~6~=12" The :PG~~~ is, relO!t;ed 'tn, i!!'b.e fact 't'hait ~~!, '!' , 'i~ :~s' :H~t :~~-Ji~~y ~be ·$ct~t~ :m a~~ol'~_~~ 'w:~m, dl~ :rtght 'm1~tl bO,t; ~b~ Sii'llt~ dij,3itt :I'mfi~t~, ~1tI.e ,jllu.ma of~ tIt'be :rigbt m1ce~ ~'~t; is vi'rti~e# I~Ni~ama(;;M~~~' Ethi~ 'V,I. 13,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

"'J'''Ij' t"lIiil,!1

~ :~~4j~ 7). LThel'\e iss ~ 8e~'5e in 'wiffi'rufucib ,A_ristode/~. 'Vir.11~OUS ~4,Si()U'" ,3CtS imml the tight: :rliib; aJl't'bQ~ ~!t. i~ :!Il~t~ the: ~a-~ sense ~'!7i\ii!t 'tie !I)'"illt~OJlaU:st:s :b:ad :i!n.:mintt

~~~l :OO.t·1!I1 :~icei's ,~:-e.\\",~e:w r3ll'td, '[iObn B:alguyl~ T~;e ,Eb;~il~;:~i;a:liiQAl [01 M(;lfu,I:' Good:'" ;n~~B\~ [Ol' ,~ "~tth't1r ln~~i~' .t~t~ dJ~ ,Or:igi~~' of O~'.r ld~~' oj 'Vk:t~'8 we_te '~rr~i~t~1l [~~irn:l~cd~C' '~:n '!r:tl;SiN)iji;~ tmO, Hlltmc'h.e_SOFl!~s th-c; ~~

-"._I!, .. _-, .. ~ ... r .y.1 "',IT''''~~'-~' . !_~_._ ~.l OOIY.

3~ CIHk~. JP', J96=97'~· l~k~'8.=IJI~;~\1\=\~9.· l]l: Clarke~, :iP~1o 6 I.4l~.o,~."

3·1· Cru_uke~. :'P', 614J!Q!·. nese ·,a8~s[ ,SIre ·~.umed. W;il'th, ;3!WIg.v,a_~. by ftw.ce (:~ :~,al[ ~d. :fr~~_. [~"'O:bUp~i.on ~nd, .MQtiFv~tl~~ t~ p. ~;9).

'~ .. ·'\.'I .. ·::. 0'" ·i)'h··..,. [0.'"1""" i<"~:~0!!' 'g~Jo!'i~' ,! ..... t'~.,."'~ ~ H~~'.I.~""~'r·..,,;oo~.,.,~\r;: I:~"''' ~.,.,.J:'.~ 'n;< . .,--;;,..~[ 00;-=--';-"'"",

oJ; oJ; \1eI.~.!Iii, _~L'" 'l""'~~' r·.~,U'!IOj. ,l!u~~'.!r~_~"','IOi !IlI. ....JIOI!Ir_~l~_.lJ~ " .~_IIlI_ ..... , i!lJ-J. iii, ,1'U;u_:r· •. ~. [;;I(i~~

i!Q~a· hjs niltiba~t tkeoty· (iset'; P,r.i~e", :pp. s;f={68fJ;4.!8.....,~:l'" OlD, 'llhe O'th~l' ~hl~ Adam. Smith. d~v~l~ ap. ·a~tlit: of 'fih~ ~.~~j;SI ,of ,th~ .• ~tive gf: d!!Wt:,.r aIll.iIl [ga:v~ it .3, :p.fo:-mtn~'n!t~ ro~~~, in. aI !s'cil!IiI,Umt!:nrt':3lliis,t 1~!fiDilir:x)[ {;~ ![!ii:i,j", ,j~ve~. And ~'o~ :luld.e~ ·w.~~~e ,~~p"'ing ~_~.:k!e ,the' ,Senjt~Hlmtiln!S:ts ~o '~N'~!lifi, .D~Ult;¥ ~~ 'i~Illl$ of Il1ull:m_. palt)~~\. ,.,~~[ tNt; ~~~~n~ :lS ~~tr,i'l'IS'icall:y ,a]ln;h.of.~UJt~v:e: a~d :n.QJ .S\I!n.ot~.oIi1J is :ri.e.e~~ lot o·hi!:}.!:~q; :i·~. S.e~ '[~effi B~~t~~, .fjl¥[~ ,S:~m~~ .P:r~cliedl ~;~. ;r·~e. RJQth ~~.ve1~ 'h,e;,re.:inUte'-'l ,~i:ted as '(·~Bud.t!l:~~ ~t pcp. :w.:I~. 4.],.

"- """-'" '.- . '1'~"'="lg: ·l[·.·l~~:·t'·

'4 ,f,',u-€e", .Pp· ·41.'7 .4iJo,r ~~,4!~ 4,7 ..

• ':;:'1 'Pri ~ ~ ~.~ :;;"] ~ ~ ., .

. l5 .:~:~.; :p'p •. ~. j; v : ~, lJ."

],6 'W: :[l. :RGSis~, 'The ,Rlfb~: idJlitid d]e Good~, ". 3, l~h,crei'n3f.t;el' :re'e~,rOO ~o· aJ5, !~ .R,J()SSll~,+ I: :run~e illr~dy n1:e~tiooed 'rilIDalt iii m.g,u;v,Sl~10Jid ,a:rul;l:li;!ili~ does not :~q)Ul~ tl!h~~; ;!~:r:igbt a:et;;!j ~n, ~tia!ni am .act; that; iii, .,~~. w.~It'Iil, a ~rtai'n .~

£ t' ·~l..fi A ~~;ik 40 • C']. t· ~'b-' ~ 11.. ~. ..:i-=_.

O'~ Hl.O'~live ·WQ.llIi~li.iI, ·~o~ 'W~I~~i.0iL!li'~ ,a~lf :I'm, 'l.ca!ltmJ l~ .111: fo¥e:ry' sue .. ~ ,3C"1' ,~s ~J:.iit

if-@m d~~it Mot~\tle ,a~dJ ;so' .~~ m.ot;-aWhr,~ l[~ n.:t~, ~k,v;e~-l~uJt Itlhi .. doos, :001:: ~iect :I.ms~'s .::u:pNm~(:I;t; iiinrl. :so ~s 11.01:. tto. tbe :po:irn!t tit~~ :Not~~~ t'h,C :~Ml~I'~ u~e lof the ~e~ ·~v.~~uo~s;' 'in. the '~ri__gW_'~ :s{t;a~~meJ1Jt. 0:1 d~;e. [d)i·r. :I:emm~ "M~ [caRY' ·~o.t'h, t!hili impW~t.altiGn [of ~\dP~i.' and of' j·.tlf~·!~Y ,g1Jod~'",

2\"'1' :~$\i' p., 4,· l'S, :l~s.!l p\" 5·

31~' :R,ossJ.' PiP\;· $ ~6 •. ,~o :R_~!St ~* 5,

4~: :See tl:e q,~.o.ta)t~ofi &oM IC~arke on :lP:* ):1; _~ !the ·One &cum. Price ~el~Wj, ~t. ~,4,·

·Oil_OOgu., §f\S, ~'WM~ :i;s· ·t;he ilteamll. eXle;it~l'I.g a ,Man to the; C~1u:o:iI~@: [o:f ~ V'iIittl!l'@~~ .j\~it~o-g~ I ~W~ h~~ ~~~ A:,.prO:ha.ti~ 'of ~~, . + ,~~. Balgu.r;. ~I;, 45! ~ see tlolmSU :pp. $,6,. ,5·~.

4:~ P.ri~ie-i; .~.P'·; 18.6~~1; ·!['~14.\,

4a S~:e :f.t .. A .. P,I:i!~b:afd!~, ;(j:DIw~ ~nd. I'H!tl@~~~tj'~ ~nl hiiS .Mo.r~J O~lf8~f.i~· ~~d'

:Fio - ...l~' - - :_,., d [' :i. ~ ~. .a ~.. iI:.. ...l = ·1'liI.J

vf;!I~1' !l~ly: .~ni~'~r~it:; ~j'S~'~ a~__:~: ~~e:t~i~_~ (if H+ A. F]I!',~ii,i;\I'il\6_X"':. ,E':.II";:S

.pa~f' ~~ ~o"ghj'e ,and. Motl:~'~ttU:D~ U' which ~~u'odu~ dn;~ ~~~nJla:li!5.~1

Copy rig hted m ateri al

13

eJ(;t~_31ism di;S<tln£\t~.Qn... ~s addtr.I~s:se:d ·t~ PdGhalldi ;;lind :I.MS 10:-11. j~st; ·t:hls Pli~t"

.... ··· .. 4-. Rms· 'm~c 'l'1:i!~~~-

~ l ,' ..... ·fl ,r,r~' l.J11 ~1.;JJ1~

4,5 Itoss~, '.p\,. 7'='1 I ralIltl 14f=3'~\" 4.6 R.oss~. :~\, I ~:1'll.

4·" RQ$'s~. :p\, l.~~ ..

4:8 Ku!'tt m,U'SIt :m~n, that 'th~l"@; :iJs :fOO. fDI' c'Onflq;,tual loonrusioo. in ~h1i. case: (if ~ili"~~ot :m~Unaltim'i •. ~'f: yQ\!l. p!-Wi"m. ,~. d'il,u:t'ful ,iI~)t. tht ii!!: .!a.~," 1m ~o-e ~~I(;~ p]~a5'imt; In i·fi.$tlf~ w~ caR'n~t; tdl 'W'h~th~j" rOlli, a;ctl~d :~'lQm, diUJt;y 'Of' gO'ly' ifmn]i~ .~l(l!~8<lt~e~. :Iurt gO' one ,Iiv-e~· C'O'Rec;t: e~h!l1~;e iiust: :(01" ·the.: ,1.easl.l~e of: jlt ~ ~~.fe 'we kti~w ~~ dloe ~_;ti~ W,il8; ,~~!t'her :i'~(:):m [~UJt'· ~1: :seHr. ini~:r:uf," H'IlilIt ith.~ffl ]1$, [S'1Wni'L~ nu 'WTY toO '~~illl ,:aJb@Il1Jt :an aciJUl:am hoo,es,t .a.ctiun. t'ut ba~lls to M :irm ,~f!O_O.e.iS :i'1l1tie:t''est: d~,lit: S'b~ d:~d .fi~ :[mm.ln:t~ms:t mill~~' t~ao ~hwty!,

49 I'n the: 'ilSi~fl'i ,cil.tt.ml ilt3mit: S:OlJnds :11.ti'~ :.1hu1!iit :~u:n~nl'j h~: S3,y~ ,th:att ~~D~ :ideal ~ :m(}raHt, ~l0np to C!~W!'!!u:re~ its l1lH £Or ~me si'l!nulacfta of: :m.~faJ·~M:y· tn t'b~ ]~v£ ,of: hanOI ,and, lout;W.wOO, Id:~~om!mJ ~sU.t)l!1It--e8, :Ql~~~

• "'1'" " Ii d 'i. ~~'E1 t, " ,~~.:I L" t, -. d- '-"IL

Cc],V;hL[Dil,oJl . ;1[11 .. 'tlia,t,~v·erytulmg :g~ 'tn3Jt. :IS 'mot u.'S~ •. iill'm. :I m~r.aI!Y

,good, dis,PO:9~,ti<m. '" '" . i9, morning ~l!Ilt; 'pm~e]1)g~ pel g:~iijJtfl~r.irDg _~.~~/~ :O'il.iJ~ in anothe~[ .'Hsage :K_~ iSopeall;;s more 1,ellliJemt'ly of hOIlM;, He ~s d'isC'1a'SS~n:g, tllt~ (l~estiQfi. w.ffil~tbC'-l 'we ,RC,v'l:~.~~ b~ ·tb~ :n8bt to' f~tdl~ib ·tw,~ klnds ,ol~ DUI'.~f~:' '~ll~ 'Om,c~fiS, who ikt~n in 1d!Il.ei'IS.~ and iUafnMaml~dJ :m.m'h~f:s 'who, ~\;;iU """"':":['1" ~h"I'-1 ,;iLI!'''''fn I'I'n ,;!jIVli!)"I'~1 'd:-]"'I:! !Ilit,l':!;;to.,.. !I!!i' ..... I'C'boll"I' QTIi:r:"'ft..i,Ci~II!!I,ll!il)'I'1'. '1I:';";1Ii'iI1il!'

.... ~-~ ~~-~ '!r_~J.~~ ~_t~ll~ 1~_1!J.! ~ ~ ~,-,t~ _ ~!)"i'~-'!r.-~~ ~" __ :.r'!r.-~' !iI!!~-~.r~!ll~~~-~-~,I·'" [l'iii_@_~~~'lil

~b..in.ks th~~,~ :~s fe·a~Qg ~Q' d~'bt ~ilurUwef 't'h~Mi m.'!I.rrd~"~ ga.}'· 'be P~mF ws:b.OOl~, :mr' :b.~. g,;ys t'bart; hoom '(~is no- 1~~U~~o.(tIl in 'th~sti. [c_:a~s,~ .:am:iJ t~:a!t f~~@.glsl3!tblIll, :~t(5@U .. '" ". is· :msplo'5iilblc fo.l" tt~~ 1.a~I: ldll'lit: ffin~e~jti:v¢s, 0:£ h.oo.OJ: ,~Od8; ·the :pee~~e dOl :OOi :ac~ul. [~SiliI.bie~ti'~fJ)y~1 'wi!tli: dte st41l'ld~~ ~'~~t 3ir.'@; .ro'b~ooti:v~·ID\JiJII ,;) ... rr~:ait:c to tlteir t'iilJiIi"I'iiIiR@:'i.!' ~M~' ~·l·'· 6~'~''''! ·Kan~. ~s:

[ .. ~,.. ·.r .. . - " -r-. ' ~ . .I(~t"~""'¥"""- L. .. .•. :t" •. .f'=~' ~ - ,~; ~ ~.'.. .:J' ,~". . - J iii.

"""",'11 ~ .J ~ .. '- - d - - -

,ge~e:r'!II-I~" 'cJ.'.'_i!i!r'~.u:~t·e;ri_ile~. :as. 1~.;I'ie'V~~ng i!!hii'i!t ~.0uJt:r ~dI .~!n(l·~~matiQIl. :lJfre the

[0:-01'1 'tWOI kimttffis, ()d' :m.~t"l.Y.1iti~" 'truif; both (d 'the~ :p~a,~ ~ug~~'t: t~t; b.~ :f~pm8 hcnu[ I.S :somedl1i'llg in 'be"t;weOD = II ~rt. m :pl\o:t;o-{mol:i_~ :mmi,v!t 'th~n: pr~~~d~. tih;.e; ~Ju~n~ .oHv-e Of d~tl' itt ,th~' e:d~~a,don of ')hg. hl!rumar.tt :s~i~!" I rs~IlJ~t~ tbrt: :ilt:ill!t :m~as tru.:t; th~ _o.il,'V-1t ef h.mtij.f ~I[Plm'xl.~ :rtlJait:e~ dl~ :l'IIDtive m m~fa'l 4!y.tgm,~.}!" :iIn:~o.1'~' ~Sl the :per;s~~ ~~~ed 'by :~t f;Qti~OCW~.1 blr tits ~W.O ~h.. ,ii, 5tnct law of CQl[d.UJ;;t; 'w!hri;c~ ~,,'~~f;its l!JIll :iti~al of ChiIU::4Ct~Ii", '¥e't: :moti!v,:es of: h@IlDf' :f~~~ cSlto:rt; oJ dlt .fulll·~lledpdJ Jll()IoTil .Q~~Vl~ '~ca~~ ~'m.~ lal\HS W .h~o;r ~ Do,t d~mvt~d frog a'J1!W(.W.O.y :i;~I'L ,Sec: n5 r 1 ·M),ow,.

SO ~~ A~~.ew8 RJ'~~~bt ,!,j'H~ujsm ,~gd :":ete--iOO.n~m.y;;!P

:s :~: ,Ka/nt; cal'~~SJ 'fb.e liy.m:partbmi£ :"i'iSQR a 't~.M:en'~(.1ob:i!~l:l/:rtl'll,~ldeiJu (;. lI9~~'~ a, friend ~o' &NHr1rtii_n'it". A:l'Jd :~m,ti.e.I\lit!ii1i;st mo;;a]J phj~ooo,lef,sl 'thought. m

""V~m-ffi2Oi'h.· v i"";i" '" ·.....-Iii:nt1""'S-;iil ...... _ ~t:-·iilr .. ,It_.". 'lk.'U-ii'i'iI·O:iI-n 'l.."":~fri;~" ;O>;1ii·-U- .. I'I1. il'ft_ lil .... ,~ ·It.""" ;ail.,.. I_' 1.;[If'!!"'"''I!.~, I' ~I a, '''~i;lF~-~-~~_~ !I'!I!-~ lIU,~:!I11~ !L-~ 1~1J _IIJ ..... ·, ~1IJ_~.j;:l1 I_I;;I! .~ _~_lIJ_1J ~;L.~-L I~l:~~~ ~~

Copy rig hted m ateri al

.t:bost to wJbn. l\Iirte ,ar~e pa_n~(.;uii!ltlY' ,au'.at'bed) ~.~ viRue [~:d dlce ~rriv~~ill :b,'~.i3i~ cij]3tr'3,ct~ris,dcs w'h~c!m ~ke th,e,. s.rbnilarr ,t~ ~1!lfrs~l.v~s. "fbiljl;5, ;SI,MpaJt'by :rJ'Iailr£esl ~ ,e~~ 101 b~m~n'it" ~~ ~o ~e~, as ;a :s_'Ul:~u:,~_m[m [or rbe f'(J;rHlula of. Hiumanri'tf '~illst; ,as! 'hUDDl: ~~[\fl~5[ [iJj$ ,8, is'~m'Ula~[1jim '0£ d~~ :f'01r.:njU~,~:~iIl, o:f U:lliv'e(salla:w,

S::iIi ,Afl~f lu,'tl~r w,r<,}tt!; ~~$ ~amDU5, ,kfi1l~]jJJ Xl '00, ~h~ c'OE!sj$~n(iy' '(If lHJn~Vg,.· le~~e: w~t'b, ~U~W@,ve;. :ilt 'W.:I,S, :n~t ~11(~mmO:D~ ~~l' eip~ee~jdl·ce:mJtU'r:jt-' ,~i.. :tQ~J'~[$ ~Q' tre~t dlt'i pn_n,~i~Je ,of ;!:ie-lf:"l~v{:; ~~ ~~)(fv,idJi.ng ,~, :met~oo ,o:f [clil~~mJ,g; ,a_on.g, 'Y[:2i~,tO'llIS, ,~n~\! :I'i'~ [oJ '\iiidli1ih. ,3f~ '\r,=dJ11i~~ :fm: tb~i;f' ~W-Il,

eC!,~['j"","~iIIl '9,'Ii~~'~'e.~J.' [1I.'l!icnl~~. ,·,1,.;";1. tIi"~e' 'iI!!i~iI:I_'1I'c!~il!""" '\!Il,!\;<I! g.o;>'t '(:P.iji'Wll;'ll[ iC!:O!II!."I,I!;iL"'!i.!'~[Mi,;:r ,t'I;,!I~jC!J'I!lll"," ~~r'!r.-~EI L~-~l!r._~ .. -~ ~.OQ~~-~ ~'_@l!h- I!l-Jtt.. .1!1'~-'!Wi~,~til!!-~.I'!r. '.'~ I!r." ,~~. ~'!IJI""l'_~~~ ~!Ir_ ~~-,I· ~-.~~J p-. ~1!r.-:iJl-Il.i_iIl'~

:pre~!'i@p~s~~, :rart'be:r '~a;~ elt,pl;I~~s~, ,th~ d~~l~~~ ~It .~ . 'be~aYl~e 'W'e have [the ~.R i[lb3~ 'w@: [~~O'!o'l' 3~l1fl~\!,IDiIj'!iii:!i' 'its ci~J~C<t :I'~llWi:t~ir' illiii'ii,~!~t,.....,~ _'~ Th-=' 'fi~~cl'"

. ,,_,~],~, .. _ J ,. . _. ,I ',f [ . _ ... , .. ~", _ ..• L!"~,_.. ~f' , .. _ ~ iIr',If'"' ,~_, ,i!'4'~"",E: ,1f',,,,~U!~, ,

:pl!~ [o'f ~IL£ .. lnv'e seleees !a'm.ong: ,tbinp~, ,aU of: cW'hr~cJ~1 'W1~ [ti:r;:~\im £01' t'h.e:i'f; -urwin is'~e~ 0~ the basis. [01 h(jJ<w mflll:c'b, ple~s;1Wfoe 'we 'Will ~et fr~. ,~~:hite'V~~: t~.r=m 'hili' ,gjrf'I'ii!::i'f~ll'l!tl"'l' d"',dl not 'f~ad '1IIIit~e~' 'bll~ l~IU:~~~iI'!.'·[ 'fi';(.i!ii:ll~=:!f: tt!lin.:t .... t!. . ~ ,.n." . ,t,',r;- .. . 'I .Il , ,. . ,~ ". . .. ~, . , ,.. .,. ~ ,t,',1! , .!rtll (11. . ...

~~a!do:n O~' self~'ruQ¥e w:~s ~d~~ed, 00,,::,11 by "~~e 'im tib.e ~Qq~'izy G'(fll~ ~H]'iOS t'liC: ,P:l:i~,Giple8 of M'j]~~l~ 1~'P,P, ,:1~ I~S~,~ lQI =cU-llk, ,and t()i[ . QJ'OIE

;;o:""'""'""'n"'1"': [i.fV' '~"I'·'·""h"'- ~","A'n" "l'Il' '~'~':~"'",:II!: ... ",,:~,:i~1!'!I';r. IO'U'~!r!""":' :f',~,,,, ,~.;i1"fO'''§I,ii' ;r' .. ,,,,,,,,,,,,,[ ru'''f~jF' ~I~)"-~"'. ~_inl~"~ _ I. Ill~: llllla'~ _ r'!!l(!iJ!U _ I , __ I l~.LiIl_!'W_~J"_iIj !IiIj~_'JIU"LI~._iI.1I .. 'rlU'"L1.!.1 5oJr~~r~ JI-~J .. ~-Jj 1iI~~ al:r\..~.UU;ll In.G_L'_1 !III lllllo!_~

't~e pJ"inGipJe ,oi $eJf~,h;(Vi~ i~ ~'t1j:s, $:~n;9~ - ,as [o-o~ 'w'~Y' of cJkoosi~; ,~-o:ng, 'tl~~~,5 w~ ,dl~Sli;fi~ :ti'o:r thit:ir:' o~ ~iki~s = ~'I1I!t; ~~t}s, th~ ,nn~~p:t~ [uf [d.UJity U,[ as rival ~(J, it - ,~8, ~'!!hu 'W~lf 'of cll.oos.ing [OU[f' ~U'~S;eSl.

$ J l,t :maf ~~~ro, ~5' if :~' atn, ,guUrl,Y' [ilf [a, cQ .. m~pli1i.c~ ~r :11], n!!iak~ng th.ill$i~ :f~~ :miiub: C:O:I1f.,uSli'ng ~J~so~:e: 'wi!th s3Itis.ia:edo:n, [0:17 gr.\I,ti8~~'ilo:n" an.c:~ [~i!i!Ie :made 'u, my' iID~~~ 't~ 00 ~1' a~~~ve s.om~th~H!& I: =i~ ,of ,ca~e ,~ft~.f:i~ 't~ S~~ :iHt do~:~. :BUJ[, [ft3!'t po$iI1I!~: ,3.'P~~~:S: ev~m, ito 3,cti,onSi un"rtjJk(l!~1 fot,tt'b,e Btl!;'! I"~fle~y' :iU,'5'tntIHflllllta1. ~e~O:Jl$ji ,i!I(:~ti.o:m;51 th!li!t. ,ilf~~ ~n;~r means ~o other f'JlIds, ':mite ~i;Dlt I [aim _akiIl'iI, 'lti~f,~ liS 11, dJUlt~Dt; [ufi~, :bv.lTI8 'tl@ 1'0 'W~Jt~, w,b~ :~~ meu_iU~ ~\O SI1.,,' iIt'b;art yo.~ ~a,\!',@; ~made so:m,et;bi-Ol, ,nUll!: :pU'r,oS€:, ,M'y di!~m, is t~ti if. y~u, ~~mht i~:~~~~edl :it'l, ma'k~~; ~m.~l;llUng 'Q~f plm~ei ~d 15.0 ''illu~ :~Jt a~, am, ~fid~, '~l!ID 'win ~~m;~ tQ[ tu~ ~~~5'Wr~ ~.~ :~U' I~lf.lo~~~f~l ~U'f!~U'it;, 1: [~xpillain, thi.s h~t.h.~1:' in, ttM.otality' as :F-{RW,OMJ iJ Clr.~,tltf; ,6, ill, ,tIllils 'v~l'IJ~~

~;4 'ne :smne ~iQ~ is, 'ma:'~ ~J' ~tke~; r~'t-~;di n:. Pri~ d~&t~p1i'S~es ~"alt~o:nal ~. iQstmcti,v~ '~~~uIDt'lm~~~ [afid~, ,ruihe th:i~~, cilaI~m~ dlat :in~tj:__Q~;ti.'j.te :oo~ n~""Fru~~c~ "~S 10'v~b~~ oot '~3J'1~, ~ibJ}rt of VWrflJIt; f~C= p-n ~if'lji'ii~C['Ii' ='.' ~""""I':'ii~

, ... ~ u. .. . ,I. c I . .. .. ..". . .. ..,., - ., ... L • ~I' ~I.' ,fi""' ,[ 7~ ~ ,!Ii,~, ,I, S1.. ~:f ~,

hW~1-iIlkie;!!; ,ill, is~~~laj' ~oInpat_rlsOJl [~Ba~~y~, ,p. ~~={6@[lL :Inss YyiSJI liThe c-Ofillsc.ienrtlO'lltS ,altit~Jt<u:d~ ~~ on~ 'winr~ci~ ,~~~VfilMg'iS tb~ t"hnol)ltt (d.dt~~'{,lf ,good, Qf ()U :pL~i!lsYre ~~1 ,~Jlle one e:~s~, 1b.1Wt i!t;, :~s' [~ ~OXel re'f1;~~t~~~ (J:~ti~:~'d[e: 't~~a~l dttSlt: ~.~ whl,cb w~ ,i3i~ml, di~dy ,3Jt t1l1~:'f~ucthl!:m of ~m~ g,Qud ~r ;50~~'~~~~~'r~ f-ot arn~lh~:r:;. :si~oe ' • , ",Ire :~:~op ~Q' ~'hink wbe:thcef 'i~ aU ~be [c:ii[CJ~m!S~al1~~ It'be bIl[n.Plilg oJ ,tiha!t: :s@ Of-' pl~a'S~rG i~,t-t) '~N~Simee :rns 'w~!t itS ~Uy ~m~'liiiT.dJie'-J1ft.lI,~Q~ ~~, ' ••• cf}' I:~s~, P~'" t,6/R~1"""<6';lr :m,' [em,p.b)_aS(iiSl)"

Copy rig hted m ateri al

SS' N'3:p'1 [~.p:lo,ys 3, S"~mi"~al' ,8f,I1m!mmJt In The Pf:JS"&lllfcil;t.,,' 'l!Jj Ailt'ml&m~ :pp. :81-84.;,

s;;t;, I sa t!hru~ :hl s,pilte ~f: ~e,~~t: tha~ 10 t111~ "thiNI.,~tiWl,[of me IGr~u~ldW(JtI4 hni't, U'ys tMiU 't'b.¢ pritmcoii,J,¢ t~at I~iin, ,alboo:l:glt~ly' [good 'wi.ru~, ,~s eae 'w:ttm~ maim, ~ ~w):jYS, :~~d~4~ :i!ts.eJf tii~] !ii, ~i1:lvC'-L~al, ~:ii,Wn' ii9, s<~~e;lie; k:C3Iuse ,u~" ~H'~Y'8!i;s, tlJ the; lOOllmpt oJ :l'n. ~'b5.JdJIWt;dty ,good! wUl tila,t; ,m~N' of rdl~' mar_x~m ~no,t be f{!t~lld:1j [~G: '4-4}.'7'~' n 'I~Ue~!"ie [tih,a,t ~hi;s is a ~iss.~a1tie" m~~t~ [O~' art; ,W~a1t a ,~f' way 'Ot ,'lttJ.fi-.E 'me :~t, 'WM¥ is! 5iffij'tb,(itl~ is t'Mit t'ke ,morsiW, ]oQiW' hofd~[ Ir[J.I lt8 '= ttlfl~t 'W''Ci !I're Clipi'ble oJ 111!¥:I'ng: ~b50"

'I ,. 1'1. ~~AI ·'It,.~ .. .'L.. ...........AI ·ii']· u, ••

;I;Ultle'J,y' ij~ "WIlI-'Sl;, ,1,~Il1:e stla1t:emmt ~I.iat.a [~'WI~., :I;§[ iilnf: w!li~ose :muumli ss

~ii1tlve~sil;i:i!!a!ble is; ;Jynrt~~~ic, onl" iii ~)'lgOOn' i~ '~ing '~sed run a. ,~~m.Y' :oo~~ tl'Ve ~5~:~' 'tu s_iJ,p~ry' iii d~fid[ [on 'lis,

5:1 J: :form:ulilite.d ,a, ead~e,1' 've:r5ion oi~ ,th~s. ,a~,IU'I'I1,e;m~ in I, I~om.me~t: <0:11, :David, CWimnid_t(Re:y"'S :pa.,e:r ~K_Mt;I'$ ltef.'!!J!tittiM [of C~seque~tial~8\m,iJ al't t~e AJ!il!~ncan :PJw~~,~;~pld~'1 AS'iQ~i~,ti.Q~ ~€~t~~, tn ,Al'.ti], ~9:88i ,and ~' w'OuJd :~hiklCli to thInk Cll'mnw~~k.Gy' :(o;[ :p,['oln,dq, nu~ ~o. do so.

S;:B P~tl7btPi :i't is 'WOft,,~ .y,~q, ,a, 'W,ord ,iJj'OOUt, whalt ill, me_a 'tel da~m ~'blt ,3, mgjm, ha~ aJ 'i'i,f:Q~, j\r. Tb.~ t~f~:M 'of aJ lm~,g l1:i, QFd~~rily 'w.g~t: ~1JI ~i;~ 'n ~he. ~l;i!ti!o:ns, ,am.om.:g '~t_s p;arrts~ :and, 'lth:¢ patns [oJ ,ii, m3~~ml 01' ,a.et:~Dn [~t:C[ ita~e: dIe silnp'l~!t ~8e1 ate t~e :<i~tmn ~o 'be pedQ1ID.ed. m;dJ the PJl.V_rpi;nC ~'O< 'h ~'~~zM. 'ft~ p~3ig~~'h~rui,t;;y' 0.£ KIID,t~'s dunllg'bt thatt; t'!hli: I:w_m~5 of a :PlrrtC~cula.t' a~t-ion m5'1:S :irn, t~t! :l'Ofitl, of :i:t'S :mm'ln, aif[ 'h~ ~il, ij'd;ll.Ui:~~l'l( 'ru,¥' oottsided_~; '~e ~{{l~_Wolwj_ng ,trl;l~s, of m;g:~g,:

~Al

:~ 'win .kP~k. A~e~ dClN~ :~n ower ~Q' :r~m~~ h~m :[(J~m. ~h.~ pa!~ 'of g

[A'n"'oii'ii.,...;~n!ll' 'L··'~'I'I';a;~ ~_~"'_""'_I!I!0!lil __ }!Iiit-"J.

'Ii , . ,,' .~ •. ~' '1\0,_, ~ .. - 11,. A, ~l " ",~I·, . I .. ' ,', '" .,....:1. ,'_"", :-l·····, , .. ' ,,_. ,",

,~ W,~~!I, ~OC!lli, ~_j}Je~ !IlI.;j))W,~, I~, (iftl'ye:r ~n ,(-e~~eve: .Ill" ~eimpe~.

:n wlJl~, fi1n nCJ:hi III 'ntl···un(::hJ~ijI:~: Ib~~[ in !()l'd~j' 'lUll m1:iI~~ m,J t(!mN!1 ~:iE"

llf"- ,If~ .. ~ ~ ~ .IJ~

~A_· r. ~ 'Ii ·'-I'il '.:I'. , AI iii... • iiO.. 'iii.. • ~I· ,..:i

~_ I ,~·WJ~.I :a~IjJ, V;I;§lllllR,g :my ,pj8R!ilI1mHt~i.er :1'11, t!liii:e ~i"1llS.PWhillJ :I;D, i01'utliiJ.' to.

~,vloi;~ a ~t3gt<m tOI wl'rbih ~I' ~Un, e:sJecDlb" 8'u8(le~dbte~

I~B~1 I will ,Q,V(:i<ld, v:i'Sl,t~ .,r ,~~d)~t~~r :in, 'I'ftt ,~w.p.~U~~ :in, a~cf ~O' !S,a;l~ :mIYse,U IIJlinplca_nltm,e.ss.

[~Cll I 'WjJ~1 avoid 'W~Jtcjh~_OJi: :p])'im;e~t~me ~erue"vi&iO:Il~, jn mrle!r' ~o is.~;aJre :m,,,,

lSeU' WlniPlea~it~~~",

'I'll' ,";iloi!'!'ii. i<Y>~ ~lo'1;'!ir~i'i'f'i'"~' .. :ii... ~, 'D, i(!\~"''''!.;o:;:- ,.ii. . .,. ,"'''"~ -::. ,;'iof'ij' ''i'...,.' :"f'~j~l"""~r, -:, '!i:f"",i;

,I! _, "",,.,,,,,,_D] !inO>'IO,r. ~.~ ... ~~~~ .. ~ .n. ,.~ ,D ""'U ••• ,I;;!I,i;",.'~, !loB,..; [;]!Q~~iI.~ "''''',,", .... 1 "-,!"JOOIJIJ~"",,jli.uI]'I[ 1I"'!Io,

~d~pti;l1I, :maxim, A. :~~ '~~~.~~il~le Q:t [e~e!l ~ wbile '0 i~ Wiron:t. B~t 'th~8, 'itS, ,",01:' :5\i'mili'ri~'ii!' b~ca[lls¢ Of 'tb-::.' '~1iIirfit'\'5~ :il!l mr'm '8 :fu:--c 'ma'F':m C

----. ,- .. -, ... , "---it' 'f ... ,' .... -. . --II:.: ,t'·'"'.r"""·· ~_,_Jll_, .~, '". it .-- _X:l __ , .

tiO;n:t~'Il~ it'be ;~e pu.~OSe1J. 'Yie~ :it,!' onee 'i'gaj~~ is :~mrls~;ble, Wh~J', is 'w~o:q, 'Wl.tb, dl~ a~tlO:D, wh()$@. mu~m ~~ :Iw th~~~ d~~ 'fi(,rt; r:e~t [~)t'h~f :in, ,the; ,ac~tinm thai!' is :por.fol'.m,a tU' :i'll, the pu~e; :(O[ 'w~ti:c'h, i~ is, fCim-'Gmlie.r.

Copy rig hted m ateri al

b,'i@t :i1Iit ,tbe r:ehtion. ~hveeg the t..w'O", chdJ 'tie '~e~a,tioml 't!e:tw1eem the two ~.:;J of. th~ ,~~. j~, it~, f~"

~,9' J~ e:xplll'iJl!'Il :my' "lliews aI~it b.o,w' tl~ :~['[Mu.li1 of Ulliv~itsa'~ :l.t;w rsl'flu;ld '~c ~p"J~ :~~ :Mty' iQ !"~~e1S' Fg~u~~, gf U'n~ve~ :L~w~!fl Cb.1~ j LQ thi~s, '~lu~~"

,it ~ ~",' ~ ~ - ~ - - j.' 'il "". - ~,- - - L • d~ toiL,.'" iIi,L L.;i,...~ 'iii. ,...'i. - - iii

!Q(!i' '~i~' is e..ss;e:O;l.ll!l; 1",0 lIO'eep' ~n :m'l'o; , i'iIi~'!' mese 'com'SiI!ue:iI';~b;mn'.S, iIii'Y 1~I.i,;e;m5e~:,es

[dQ' fi~t ~QJw' wli" tl-e ,aoti~~ i:5, im:a~lQ:n~L ,AU tjh~t 'dl~~ :iJlgu.m~~~ ~tl~;~ is 'w~,r' tbe :lllsi'i11 §M.Qt 'H wiUed, ,IS ,ii, la,V{ ~ n~t wby ii, :~;at~uu'~ be~~; :m!us~ IQn"1 -will ~~~m_8< 'that eftm. be 'w;ijle~ ,as ll!ws;, For tb_mt: ,f-I[d oi~ thee ,a'~~m.~fJt l\iYe 'm~ed, ~o 'Nk~ 'the ~~ef ~t~ d~~ri!'kd, :irm, t~e, 'GQ:H,~mU$~Q:g 1!)f

,~;Ll~"" iIi"io:lIii~r. ,..._o.'il! it:--,y- •

6 '11].".' - -- - - .. __ z· • '. d _.ii:!.Itl] • 'K "'1- .• £'L. .

• ~.I ,~_~[ mst;!__IlRJi ilY;t:et' pl_a'I'S\l~ ,~,- w:_' _w~'l'll~ ~:-_~it is! ooncrc,tJOll (]I;!!' it_~i.e !a1.il['oo,'"

rom" (if tb~ w,iU :H~g.e~ sary;s, il.' ••• iSd~~" 'to d~r.;~ ~Q' th:t,; [~~chj$iv'elj :m~l'!Il, ~iJdO:Elii w;iJth~,~t :mll~'i:ng d~,e 't[la~_s:i;ti,on" !!o ttihe [~o:n~pti~ 0:( ethj,os'ii :is, 'to mdu~ dd:~i liiifii U'I :iIifi ~mJtJ' !6g:rma~l~m .. '!' [0:1: ~:G1W~~j :m:a'te~~ ~I,f' ~e b~t :iln :f~Olll, t"fi~ f'llI:tshl~ ,lind :p;i'rttCtll.af -d~Jt~i~s, ~y be ,:lni;~dJ <lit I;~OGldiq1.,;, . . " Ii ':rbe J~ib,ilm~phy' of ,~\j'glll~i 'tI'3!DS" T~ ,M. :E{[n.o:~ HI" ,9.,~~g:o, I gfW~ dl~ K!~f)~H.~~ 'W :D~~~J. :lmdD~!,

,£ "!il '~,,",'" .....,~cl.::i'~]~,"'~'-, .. ~;'": ~[~":~."""'[ "~I<;jif'i" '~' "':~I 11'- 01.... r;;H:i'~ ~,It""" _ _ iIi!l,}!, ,~iWj~,L!/,~\u~, "I:~~~, ,~,' .... Will. ,[]]"i~a,

'~'3 I'his ,8a,,' k e-spee:ially :ham, lto see, beca!use dl,e i!rgJJme~tlS, tttlr.'I!t: :Brldsh f.3JtJonalis,ts ~se to[ :sk.ow' 'ma,t :m,(l-fai ~:aw,s, ,afe iQdeed, 1arw,llo£ r:ea90fi ,art sim'W:a.t to 'tbose 'f'bilit: Kain,t: 'iU.~s, itO' ,show' ttllttit: :m.m:am lra:w;sl ;I're la,liN!; 'w-e: rn~st mti<maU, w~rnl Su1cl!;'bF ~pe~ikimt :r~tiM!:iili~tJs, ~bQil1dl :Dn~ ~ve !iiqu,~, m.e~tSi if)l:' :m~JlIl :~,wl$,~ ,-inc¢ il;'~¢¥" 'mtink dij;~~ 1cw1'- a[~ :~~\!'~dti~t._ :B:UJt C~u~ej !in pJ!_ni(:g~ Lrles t-o iimpfe:s:s dl1:$1 :seU.-ey,i~e.nCie '~~. hi'S al~~j~ ~.c:e lrl a:~~, '~O ~fl'lm~m,t~ &:om tt.i:t jlflGtkidtn Ri'I!:lJ'lE-JlI~ _d ;arlQm~~L~!S, iI,om this prin_cJjple are s:~m:i~af.' t~ thOR £100. d~,e ci3!teg,o:r,i,e:a~ :i'mJp€ratj;~~. fo:r.' i'lii8!1!a~oe;,. C~~~e ~.!iiyl!i' that i~ 'W~ we~ mot: G~~,t f"l~ W-@l1i[d. be ss i_po5Snt~J£ t~a)t [a, ,Ma,~ ~URli;r~y ~o tIfj;~ I~itl~mal R~sO:D, oJ th~~~, ~·h:'(fuld des:~~e 't.'O ,pro, oome s:ma'~1 profl:t: t'O ,H':i'mselt 'by dOlq, vii!J;lence ,aniJ! dam,ilge ea b'i~s ~Neilb'bo;r.; ,as th_:i1i't he S:b,0,1LIl_ldJ 'be 'WiJHng 'to ~ dep;ri,ve.d of :1fi.~~~~~riJ~1 ,~~mr~1tt ~Q' ~;n~dY fk~' u~r~~~a~~€: C~V~JtDtl~i'l~ii!S ~r Am'hl'"

~.~.;"'io":" [oi"io~ '''r:-:-i'i.iI..~.'i'jJ! [r'C.~"II ... i'i''1~1i!i' '~ 1"",'~';[i~"~'1",,,,,,jl'~

llr_~-U.~IJ ul! __ II~!I._lI_J"~-.II1 L 1_IiIJldlli..-~i,!I Jf'~'l ~ II!. 7' l __ ..... ~J .... v!'.J~. •

64 PtiiCtJi po,; 4Ill,~'li HUjt(!b;eMm~ lnql1il1' (~\'ono~:r:r]ijn;g dJe; Or/giI:ud t1j" OiW"

ir.J.,..,,,,l'l'; At. r:!ii'''~'~,,;o;, = .. ii..r...,. ........ !11 ..... -\n;o(fo.,;ll' n ::I!,~[~' .iIl[fJ:~_a! ~J 'If .J:J_oIll~~JDJ 'l£-.Il .i!__._t'JU'llI.il:l_iIl u~a~1 ~i'l J.!I.I! J. •

6s «~r" iE. M.OOfJ~ Pl:in~,~~ lj'tb.i~~~, po;p", S=:I "I'.

££! rn.............. 'l'iri; '7'-',,,,,,'1'" ""

gg M_Ul~t'p. .If'J:I.'. .~. -.iII.,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

3'

_

,

-

K' ant's Pormul a-I of

.a..lI. .; .I, I , ,", ,._',,"""",,_- --_-- ... "_~"_ :>"----',

·U~ '~m' _ Iversal 'L" .a 'W\":~

"-".,,c_,_. tl _. ',_, '_ :L'O,,_,----, ,,_. ',_'_' ',:',:

l{acnlti;S I~s~: .f:o;rnl!rlll~Jtjjn~, Q.f ,t'b~ CaJt~i(JJic.al :im:~r,artlve~, the FmUlfiiIiJ'La ,O'j UmirV~X:S!11 :L!1',w~ ,rn~5:

,A~,t IQrnJ., ,~~td!iB,g ~Q thi:"':: m:lx'iim 'b~ which, -y-ou. 'C'_ ,a,t; the ._me 'Ij!mu~ 'will tat J,t: :mO'u1d 'lbeoon(u~: ,iii, u_n:~v,e~~ ~arw; ~G ,4\~,~:J

A. :t-ew ~mcsi la~ef;" ,KWllt iSla,S 1d1lalt: ilJi:s :~s eQltll'va1m1t; t~l IC~i'Il,g ,as th{)ugb, '\,:,C: ~;"I:' 'ifi"''''''''~rii'i'lil '::-'~e:r:e. 'Ik,~ ~iill!ii" 'w"~ll ~ .... , '~'"::'l''!''m' '.);i:Ii a :~''''w' of n"iili:)UI',@;:and.he:'usn

YOliiIir,lIiU.'G.i1'U,UiIi.'W' .,.D~ ,'U ... _"" __ lJI-I!I!l.V~~_~~!I'@" -~~~----J ~~ __ , _

milS .lauecJ:' MUIUllili~lio:n :111 ,bis, ecXQIm,les 1m: ,holW' fhe .i'mpera,ti,vc :~S, 'to be I~J]edi E.lse;w:h,c~l'-ei l:a,1; S!t'iec~liU mat: '~'h.e '~es.c, is, w:~ethe-[ ~OW, 'CJQ-u~d,

,Flr· ~ ~ [I'

.- ,~~·.ll.~ ~'~.' - '~~.--. ','~~ - ~'~.<i'lI'lii~;ii"iin.·. ~'iI' ,"Ii ~C~Sif.'I'H; O"Iif'" ';!I!I,'~~'''- t~""'f: 'l!M'1l..·1" ~':h 'Ufl'li~ Vni.-'I''lif W,I~IJ IIj.JIl]e.~ UD~IV\.illgli_i,l::liIiiG}':_ILv..I_~1 1]o~I;· iP-, Q!l:~:~ .'l~---)I~':_'_J M~ ,_~Jld~"yJ~~ ~ __ , '~',~~[~__:_~, :t' .. ~-~ ~ 1~~_~:~

--til ,-.----- -- -- j~' rc L.!~.J1 ,L __ ~ ·11 ...... ' .. ih' '. ·'h l'i' "u~l'iz s "h ' N(lIi-'li is-C-4Ii: WeJ:'e :a, p,a:rt;-- f,ll !!8ii9'~I,;; iifDN.lI, ,~nl Q,n.t. pW.£e ,C 'C:_'l_aLaCI__:,.':c..:,~e_, t_ll__e ~'-'-4Y,

:a.gef:.U;. ,al51 asking: it!iw:~at :SM: ,of woilJd. be 'wO'~ld CU;'!1lte: 'und'el" 'tile ptd:~ ,-,:,~. -, ,~f: '7--ctJ,-ai[ masol],- .- - . ,a 'w'Odd -huml w:h,i,ellrjJ, manUirV'@[, he; 'wul!!lldJ

anceo ". p,ra ,c -J' ,"'_ .. __ .'H, __ ",. ,----~~I~------,'~- ------

"~la-·'-, h;'!-~-'-<H '-:- .. -, 'i=--'~.0-:-;DeC·~' 1~'I.:~I- 'But, how do ~n:u d!~~eltmlne ,'tiibe:t'her

.P "C'e tm.~e ,illS ,1IIi..mem .'. r ~" j ~" -,., '", ', , il-' ._ .. ~ .. ,.. __ ... __ '_ i -"

,-:c", I-C,'1ii :~ ~- -I :::'-'--1 '::-'~"IJ'I'~ ,- ,--::;'~~--::-,;-~-:-c~nrI' ;'Iil~ ;'IiI 'Ij;'li]!l .... , ~,ii'Ii:"iFlrro~.~ ~'~ll ..... .j'/j' ~'~;iI!i ''!;;iI''·l"~'11 ~'iI!'

o:r nD'!IO. yuu can. Wli!u, Ii, ,P:V ... _u m_GlXILUiL !IIi!il!1 ,""", ,1:_iA!.~· ut, U,@I!0;""'I,~'" Q~ _-_ !!JilIv ,"'~y, ~!0"!1

'n;r,,,oj'!t"~o1",ii;1: ",,ji;i'il~ liIi<iFiJ E;li'iil"iI1'\;iii ,li!iiU~~~;iIi, m,I" 'i'~I'Sii' ;i'Ii;~''V'rA' ;i'Ii'iI'[ "'C'~"'" ;jfj'~'m;il;l!-liI"<r'!In,.;li!u' ',"' .~IIJ";1Iii- _ ~II,...:J. ~.~-.l.11I~~J 1I.1L:.1I£ 'iIIJI_~_~_I~-~ ~!If \'p'-.l1'U-;I_I}!l.if [ __ l~. ~'1 [R!_II~lb.1 e- ~ [R~· ~~jIlJ_""" ~~~ ~~IW,-'- .-_.

SIfi:f:i51 :m, :matten, of dIu't,~ :~,t ciWmnot. be the case mat 'w~h_:ai!t; 'you IU~ railb'~,e '~O ::- c:-:;~:il~ :'-,- I--I>~t-i<-:"I)'c'--;- :~') :,-;~ ~"",;i!',,"--;;_ 1--; ---;'~-'J,Oli;ii"'Vie'·"'~""'~l1'i'lir,jli""'di'vidua;1 d;iElistus,.

W,IJ!:I, HI ,3, .miiiii!lle_1' 0'.1 percSimD3il, I ..... a;!l;if!i~ OJ' :re.liA'!l.li , .. ,,"v ? _ ~ ,'_iI~_~ _ ~ __ ~ _ .... _~~ _

R.ath~:,-: tit: c-w ~"-,t:;!;:': I)~ ~'c:~,~:t, :~C-",il CIH wUlls, 3], ,i1imesJtir(:m ,m W;h3lIt: V'tlll], ,. i :er~, e q), .eS.lfln ~ W,:IIL, y!O!~" "- ~ '" - - "'Ii _ _ --~ -~ "~- I}' -

Cf!1D win. MithlJ~;t. mjj:l'r~dff:cti:on,;,

Ac:-:---;~l~iFilDi' ,1[.-:;- 'jL!"'''',"",j~', 'i,:"fii]C'~.'!:~~ '~I'liii"oij~v""'~'''Iil~i!!!!\Ad'l 'K:1',,~..,.j'm!iI!: '11i1:ai,U :ai''V'~ ris~ t'o ,n,Qom!Ui_I .. ~, !I:IU .iI'i;;,il[!iI.", 'Ii"!' ,II _ililue; I!I;I,I.I'_I, _ !!;';II,~ _iI_~·"'._ ,UJII~~!i!' ~ i! ~ , _ ~~ _ _ __

... ·~'-·t-· ~,'lii.jI'1 ~'i;'"'.;:"i'i'i,;r;, '~ii'Ii, 'E:t;i;iI\iI'io W' ';i'lii\J!'i!i'

"",0(1, -['GlUlI£"I!u.~[1iIi ,Iii !I:"n'U'.,II;!,!.l!i'

Some iicdo~~ ,iI~ m ~udi. ~ ,~m~ tih.iI!t; dt~~f ~:a'X~m 'C3!1iiiI'U'JiI ~V'¢l1. h t!hOI(!gbt as ,a umrll.~!\~~'~ 13W 'nf :~t~ w:~tbO"~t ~ftf;Jd~cJt'foll~, ;fsr 110m, :i:t: lbeing ,po;ss~bIDe dtalt I~ntc 'C01lllld 'win ,lth:l't: it *ould be SUJ~:h,;, :In Q,t~er:s, tbiiS· i~te:[Ua~. im:posti'b:iillJ, .. it.,' IS· :Mt: fmiia4 dlwlh· it, i~ :sdU i:m,fO~~'J~ to' mU fh~ ,thEir Maiim ~ih(!j!liIbl

'!Ii;-=,~ -r= ... ~1 '~::, ~;if .. li'i ... ,~~-:.,,;rt~"i.!!'~i'"Ji· ,'" ]' """'--"" "'1<-~ '''':a·.'rlf~ be '''''-''''''''~.i''''''' i"!.~~~l ,"". w"I'li~1 'W"'1i:"'~I~...i, I~, IID~ 1,,0 I~~"~ iIIli~u'lI!'~IJ~~"'l' ~u. d,'!II'D u.l!. ,u 1")IOIi~"'" IL!nii_!I;I_~ ~!I;I .. ~iIi OI! __ ,_1111 __ '!<l!'~_Uil

~ltl!':adi.ct: :i'~df" We Ui!l!ily' aee ,thSlt, 't'he ffJJm;~t 'm.i"in, ~~~i~t~ 'wilt~ ,th~

'77

Copy rig hted m ateri al

The ms't sort (d: [OOIl!tr:'t(iiJttio-n is 'us[1.udl,' [caned, [a, co:olUadieti,on i'n~, o(mljce,t-io~ and 't'b.e: seoold I, Gom,u,adictJlou :lU the 'wn!.

:[:n, 't'ms, pa.per l ,~nn oo:oee:moo, 'widi, :Idemdfyimg ,the S-eiiJSie :~n 'wh!i~h ~br_n~ Is a, '~'cO'.DltJ',adic~iD'm,~~' in w;iiJJing me umiv'ells.aJi'7ca,uol!i}, ,of ,a, im.'~ mOf'all m.axim~, and e~S1pec4aJly 'W;I,t'b ,the: :stl]jse· :~n w:hi(n 'dle 'Ini:Vte,r.s;a:1l· ,ba,t~on af such ,I, :mmm, ean 'be: slid, to have [8, oOD!'tl'adic;ti,gn ,in :i.t~ '"""", dl8!t ,is"" 'wi~jh ,die idu 01' [8 oon'tradi~,0ti\On, ,m, [t~n;t~pitci[~D. Thrr.'£ ,I'f£ tbtme dif"~mn't ,mtJeJPl!et'l;uoms, ~J the mn-d, of: Ic'On:t"dJ.ctj[~Jl ,Kanlt~ hat I,I~J" oulh1t '~o hl,V'C~1 ill, mind, foud Ln, 'Ihe U,t"el';i't'1jJJf;. ~ 'liI,ey ae:::

:U The Log,ic:rai 'CoD't-ra.<UttioD :I'n'~eq\retalt:,b,.n, IOn 'tSis :mtelP,ret'a,'· ~'io,l(~, d'te'£:e is, :so:me~mDl Uke ,I, logical :impm&ilb:Hi:ty ,m, 'title 'Uimhte:rsd,'· ,im,t~on [of the maxbu~ 01" :in the s,jrStem, [of na'tlljIe in w:~i6h, the :mW'l'iD Is aJ, 'I'!Ilrlltural :~a,w::: ,H tIne. 1m aixi m, 'Were: '~m,Viel'fSiiliI~e.{I, ,t'he: ,3;cti,on [Of'

___ ~-_._ ~ __ -!"'!l_- __ ~_ •• _-~ _-_- ~-~. __ ~~_._._._ _-~ ~ __ .~.~~ ~. _.~_. __ ._ ~ _ ~l ~-~.~ _ __ ~ _- _. _ ~

:rcl'i,cy- ~bat, l't :p!oposes, 'w(nl~d, 'be ,i'nc()nrei,vab~e.

iiJ The TeJjeoi,o:gilca1 [CDD,'tr,adj~tjo:m, lm,!t'elp'JletaUon. [On ·t'b:is[ :~nte:r.-' :"l!et.aluCn!~f it 'wCltuld, 'be C:OD'tr-ad)~,ctDIJ' t(l[ 'wiU Y<J:l!ll" .aDm, is, [i J.w,w '~I'

o'l;. ;f!~ii\;o!;!im"., [ryiL': :n!o!I;'~il"''''i'''' ,;j;l;!";~""'.r;'Ioili~(IIifi\"!,O!I;'II~~ ,""";r:I.-TiHI"i;i:il'.i'q\~'fiI' ... ril~i'I;""",2"'· ,\!,nli~, ,,o:i(~ ,,o:i,;I'tiii'l:ng'

[~ ~;},~~_~ , ~-I' ,II,~J~"!JI_;&~ !L!~li~-~l~~1W8J_llf.· ~!LT.""_.!lill!WIIJ,lI!'L~l. ~-.lJI._H-~. If.·U!IIII MUI.'" IIII!W!II. __ .,_,1

[apl:nst rsome nl!!t,utal[p:uiJ(isew [fil' ,trlWI :maixim could net be ;3, 'te),co:i,Q~,ea1, :~a,w~ 'n,e :mmm, :ffis ,moo.nsi~t~m,'t with ,iii, ,s.ystte:matic :hili~fi\lO:fj," [00: :,lHposes,!!, or 'w:i:tJl, ~b~ pri:nmp:~e 'tba,'t any' [~tpn,! in:5'!:irntt.r [G.' act:ion,·,

'iIf~' h·,.,t!; ,"I; 'iI'l;_"';'ilfiIJ~'III'~'~1 n'll'miimiifl~ ";!'Nilii" '!UI;'h-f~""h-' ,ilto, 'I!'!II!I;U' ;C!;,.' b ... ~' 'oIi"L"", ;i'j'lift~, ~:'''':;~iii'' ifl·u·-'~i'.\,,:,,~ ~,' F-~ -=----.1~h~1 ~, ,~~I~I~. ltfl~,r-~~ .~!bI'~ !JT-, __ ~~ __ ,~JLl ,~,~,: l~i'l l~ l~n~, ~~~t~' l~~l~ ~- ~ '~,'''~=!I

:iU,I' 'r~e P,f'a'c1ticii, COl1l.tf;amctiO'Dl :mteqlmt'a,tiOD," O,n tbiis l'm:C'CIIPlltCI,·' '~blnt' tlJJe ,o(mltr:amcd'O]J! e tha'~ ,O-U maxim, 'W'tO'uld, be. eJ;_j..d~f~l[tin!g :iJf: u.D'i1Vte_nalized: Y-OU__I acdriEl, w,o-uild, Ib~oome. .ti.'nelecllwl wr (he ac:bi[~,,'e~ 'm~t:;-;f: '~~'--;!UJjC' n"~'~~ "If:: [e;v'tfF~-i''OEi~ Ittrilid '~Q~l use it fail' that '~Iilmose-~,

~.,_u Q'~ Y!J'_l il;<u_.",I:"' ,~~ .. -"'"'; -- - ~-~-- - --l --- -- --- -~-- ,r-,",jf---·

,e.~'IIN;;iO";A '!IlT~""~ 'n'm····~' , U" :Si'l! ",;L ... ,oI\' .~'I"'.'il""~ ,c;,... .. ' ,..,'L"o'I[.' 'n'lil'li'mii'ilol!;~ ,o'Iltt, .'h·~' ~"!m' '-;!:I;

~~_~~_!I!r.r 1'~-~ ¥~",-·,t-¥.¥~ l~~ ,-_~._~ ~~l~l ~~,"~~-~,~, ~y~, ~~~'l F'~',tr-~~~ ~,l'l l~_~~l .~~_I. -~

'time [IS 'J0U, .P:[O~: 'to 'iIlmi,veHa1iQ: ~me, :mwm4, you in efifoot 'w,iU ~he

'i1i;~~Ol;II""4':;ln,'" .;n;.·(f· 'V r "",.-,: -~'I'II" [;ry.~.'. '."IIl'I'. n'I'I'~_·,· ·Ci_e:. " !Ii;_DIL!VP.'I~HI,L'II~, ~_ 11·~L.....aJ. ~·'I!'l'P.',III_"'lrl"'''',r--''' II

In, t:1)1':iq 'tiD dle~;ed'[d!l'l!e 'w:hi!tb. of,t'hese \i'lieW,B! :is, lOOft:ec:~t" it :~5[ :I'lD;P0t,-.., 'taiIU~ IDI :ret'RClE,ber: thl,t :~:t ];8 fiat Just: 'beC31Alil5.e [~f d),e ~~!l;t[adkil:iDfi ];n, the D:nl!y,er$alizedJ :max:bn, thiillt, ,bnmiOI.:a], ,atdfi!lJ, l;S :in3ititlnal" Kan:t is fic<t clai:min:g: 'tDt1Jt~ ,bn:mG:r[a'~, 'Ol1llduc:t: is [Wj];tr.e:d!~,otDlJ' _,,_.it :h.e w~r:e, tb-e :mmr-,aJ, ,taw' 'w'iju'~d, 'be: anaJj"t-l[c I;adle-T' d'ii'I, s,ym,t"hetllco;. :b1,DY' ,eVlent~, [8

"i'!""'n·,,,.,,,,,il;~;iIi';~n' "In' 'iI"~;I!i' ~'I'~l·"u'-,jI!I;"i!,;:.'~I'i~;:,.'Iii~""'-n....-t v;.n,'I'111II" m· "dl'V'~m-' '~'''''''I''ll~ 'n·;i'j'Ii·' nm'" ,~I!'..iII!!' ~_~~:_.~~~_~~~~~y_~ ,~_~ ~g,~ L~~I~I. ~.~:~~~~~_~~_~ ~~: ,F ~~~, ,~_l~~~. "'~~,~U,,~t~"l r~':_''''~1

tJla!t: there :is ,ii, [oon~-ramc;~-iQn in ','OWl' mWnl1, £al' th~ ,!U~ dUlemnt.,

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful