Professional Documents
Culture Documents
240
JWOCN
Volume 27, Number 4 Smith, Boileau, and Buan 241
The Agency for Healthcare Research given verbal instructions about how to
and Quality (AHRQ) (formerly the perform a pelvic muscle contraction were
Agency for Health Care Policy and unable to perform an effective contraction.
Research) found evidence that treating UI One fourth adopted a technique that could
can improve or alleviate urine loss in most make their symptoms worse. The goals of
patients.7 A panel of experts convened by pelvic muscle re-education are to learn the
the AHRQ recommended behavioral ability to produce a voluntary contraction
methods as a first course of treatment for or a trained reflex contraction (for urge
UI. Pelvic muscle exercises (PME) were symptoms) and to keep a contraction dur-
recommended for women with stress ing stress situations to keep the ure-
incontinence, men and women with urge throvesical junction within the abdominal
incontinence, and men after prostate cavity for sufficient pressure transmission
removal. The guideline also supported to the urethra.
PME for older adults. Biofeedback is sometimes discredited
PME as a recommended treatment for and called experimental therapy. However,
UI is not new. In 1948, Dr Arnold Kegel it is widely used and accepted in clinical
proposed progressive resistance exercises medicine. Examples of biofeedback devices
for restoration of the perineal muscles.8 include the sphygmomanometer, the ther-
Once thought to be primarily for women mometer measures temperature, the pul-
with stress incontinence, pelvic muscle someter, scales for measuring weight, and
exercises are now considered treatment the incentive spirometer for measuring
options for men and women with stress, inspired air volume. Biofeedback is also a
urge, and mixed UI.6,9-11 An excellent useful method for pelvic floor muscle re-
review of the literature by Palmer12 points education.28-30 It can be used to instruct the
to the role of pelvic muscle rehabilitation person about correct contractions, to maxi-
as a solo treatment option for UI, a possi- mize the contraction effort by demonstrat-
ble adjunct to surgical intervention, and a ing strength, and to show progress in
proposed method of maintaining conti- strength and endurance of the muscle con-
nence in continent women. The impor- traction long before symptoms improve
tance of the pelvic floor muscles in pro- supporting motivation. Biofeedback is also
ducing occlusive forces on the urethra and effective in treating patients with multiple
assisting in continual continence, as well voiding symptoms.31
as during events of intraabdominal pres- Patient compliance is an issue for many
sure increases, is well documented.13,14 types of prescribed therapies. Researchers
Exercise of the pelvic floor muscles results have reviewed compliance factors with
in an increase in type I and II muscle fiber diabetic schedules, cardiac rehabilitation,
recruitment and an increase in contractile allergen immunotherapy, and daily med-
force of both types.15,16 Contraction of the ications for conditions such as hyperten-
pelvic muscle during or before an acute sion and AIDS in an effort to strengthen
rise in abdominal pressure is a habit that conformity.32-34 Behavioral programs de-
can be learned during repetitive train- pend on compliance for maximal effective-
ing.17,18 Pelvic muscle contractions also ness. Compliance is preceded by awareness
inhibit detrusor activity through the sacral of the problem, education about the solu-
reflex, which can benefit patients with tion, and motivation to succeed. The rising
urge UI.19-23 In a study by Burgio and col- cost of health care and a generation of edu-
leagues21 of 197 women with urge inconti- cated consumers are feeding an increase in
nence, biofeedback-assisted behavioral the use of self-care, behavioral-type pro-
treatment was significantly more effective grams.35 Programs about nutrition, exer-
than drug treatment. cise, rehabilitation, life-style changes, and
Pelvic floor re-education works in 3 substance abuse all have behavioral compo-
ways: (1) it increases muscular strength nents, and compliance is essential to their
and endurance of the pelvic floor muscles; success. Visual and audio aids used with
(2) it increases the reflex action of these behavioral programs have been shown to
muscles through fast-twitch fiber recruit- be effective in encouraging motivation and
ment; and (3) it increases awareness of compliance.17,36-38 The use of diaries and
these muscles.8,24 Two major principles of telephone-linked care may also enhance
strength training are specificity (using the compliance.15,39 Perhaps the strongest moti-
correct muscles) and overload (recruit- vator for compliance is the participant’s
ment of more fibers).25,26 In a study by value of the outcome and ability to perceive
Bump and colleagues,27 50% of women progress toward the therapeutic goal.40
JWOCN
242 Smith, Boileau, and Buan July 2000
The purpose of this study was to evalu- Web site, a toll-free phone support line,
ate the effectiveness of a nonsurgical, self- and a quarterly educational newsletter.
directed home biofeedback treatment for The participants were asked to view the
stress and urge UI. The treatment system video and review the instructions and
included education, awareness, pelvic practice session in the journal. They were
muscle exercises with biofeedback in the also asked to perform 5-minute sessions of
participant’s home, and telephone sup- pelvic muscle exercises 3 times a day for
port. 16 weeks. The Persist Trainer provided 3
resistance levels for increased strength
development (strengths 1, 2, and 3) and a
MATERIALS AND METHODS choice of 5- and 10-second contraction
Procedures time, with a 10-second relax period be-
Project participants were recruited at a tween contraction times. The program
lecture on UI sponsored by a local medical consisted of a 5-minute session for en-
center, at a national incontinence sympo- durance and strength training of long
sium, and through brochures left at an ath- muscle fibers as well as a “winks” session
letic club. An introductory project letter, for quick contractions and training of
an initial assessment form, a 24-hour blad- short muscle fibers. A pneumatic vaginal
der/fluid habit sheet, stress and urge UI sensor was used to measure contraction
severity indices, an informed consent doc- strength. Feedback was provided on a liq-
ument, and a commitment form were uid crystal diode screen that also guided
mailed to the participants. The assessment the user through the session with instruc-
form, bladder habit sheet, and severity tions. The journal described 4 program
indices were reviewed for acceptance by levels (starter, intermediate, advanced,
two nurses. Two patients were excluded and maintenance), provided a calendar of
from participation in the study because suggested protocols for the 16 weeks, and
of a history of cerebral vascular accident included documentation forms that
and Parkinson’s disease. Inclusion criteria allowed daily recording of goals, number
were females with symptoms of urge, of sessions, program level, strength level,
stress, or mixed UI; no history of systemic voids, number of leaks, pads, and fluid
neurologic problems such as CVA, intake. A toll-free phone number was
Parkinson’s disease, or multiple sclerosis; available to all participants Monday
intact cognition; and commitment to do through Friday, 7 AM to 5 PM (Pacific
the 16-week behavioral program. Remuner- Standard Time) for questions.41
ation for completion of the project was
keeping the Persist Treatment System at Data Analysis
no cost to the participant. The Statistical Package for the Social
Each participant was asked to complete Sciences (SPSS, Inc) Base 8.0 software was
a data sheet of her status (by phone, mail, used as an aid to compute and correlate data
or e-mail) every 2 weeks. At the end of related to severity indices, leaks, strength of
weeks 8 and 16, the participants were contraction, and demographics. An inde-
asked to complete their second and third pendent consultant performed statistical
continence assessments, a 24-hour blad- analyses. Unless otherwise indicated, the P
der/fluid sheet, and urge and stress sever- values reported result from either a t test or
ity indices. A final program evaluation analysis of variance (ANOVA). Because of
was completed at week 16. the assumption that a normal distribution
was not achieved in many cases, an alterna-
Instruments tive nonparametric test was performed for
A treatment system was mailed to all each test to confirm results.
participants. The system is a prescription A 30-point urge severity index and a 27-
home biofeedback and behavioral pro- point stress severity index were developed
gram for urinary incontinence. It consists as self-rating scales for the participants to
of an 8-minute educational and motiva- rate the severity of their symptoms. Al-
tional video and a journal for education, though this measurement is subjective, it
instructions, and documentation. The sys- has value in the meaning of the symptoms
tem also provides a personal trainer with a to the participant. The point system was
pneumatic sensor to measure pelvic mus- used to provide a numeric measure of
cle contractions and provide immediate symptom severity for weeks 1 and 16.
feedback, along with software that guides Psychometric evaluation of these indices
the patient through preset protocols, a has not been completed.
JWOCN
Volume 27, Number 4 Smith, Boileau, and Buan 243
Limitations
This study was a pilot project with one
particular treatment system. It was limited
in size, gender, control group, and treat- Figure 3. Improvement in leaks per day and voids per day by age groups.
ment system. A larger, randomized study
to review the role of a comprehensive
behavioral program with the same system
in women and men with stress, urge, and Services, Public Health Service, Agency for Health
mixed UI is warranted from these positive Care Policy and Research. AHCPR Publication No.
results. 96-0682.
8. Kegel A. Progressive resistance exercise in the
functional restoration of the perineal muscles. Am
CONCLUSION J Obstet 1948;56:242-5.
9. Sampselle DM, Miller JM, Herzog AR, Diokno AC.
Pelvic muscle re-education and biofeed- Behavioral modification: group teaching out-
back have shown to be effective for a vari- comes. 1996;16:59-63.
ety of UI symptoms. This pilot project 10. Jackson J, Emerson L, Johnston B, Wilson J,
demonstrated that a self-directed treatment Morales A. Biofeedback: a noninvasive treatment
system using a home biofeedback device, for incontinence after radical prostatectomy.
educational materials, and clinical support 1996;16:50-4.
via telephone successfully improved uri- 11. Reilly NJ. Meeting the challenge of post-
prostatectomy urinary incontinence. 1995;7:18-
nary symptoms in a group of otherwise
22.
healthy community dwelling women with
12. Palmer MH. Pelvic muscle rehabilitation:
symptoms of stress, urge, and mixed UI. Where do we go from here? J WOCN 1997;24:98-
105.
REFERENCES 13. DeLancey JOL, Starr RA. Histology of the con-
1. Resnick N. Clinician’s desk reference: assess- nection between the vagina and levator ani mus-
ment, treatment, and management of inconti- cles. J Reprod Med 1990;35:765-71.
nence. Spartanburg (SC): National Association 14. Leach G, Haab F. Impact of female pelvic
for Continence; 1999. anatomy on stress urinary in continence.
2. Society of Urologic Nurses and Associates. Contemp OB GYN 1998;43:45-57.
Patient access to continence services: protecting 15. Boyington AR, Dougherty MC, Kasper CE.
it under managed care. Pitman (NJ): The Society; Pelvic muscle profile types in response to pelvic
1997. muscle exercise. Int Urogynecol J 1995;6:68-72.
3. Wagner RH, Hu T. Economic costs of urinary 16. Bernstein IT. The pelvic floor muscles: muscle
incontinence in 1995. Urology 1998;51:355-61. thickness in health and urinary incontinent
4. Appell RA. Pathophysiology of urge inconti- women measured by perineal ultrasonography
nence. Contemp Urol 1999;11(Suppl):1-6. with reference to the effect of pelvic floor training.
5. Nygaard IE, Thompson FL, Svengalis SL, Albright Neurourol Urodyn 1997;16:237-75.
JP. Urinary incontinence in elite nulliparous ath- 17. Deindl F, Vodusek DB, Hesse U, Schussler B.
letes. Obstet Gynecol 1994;84:183-7. Activity patterns of pubococcygeal muscles in
6. Sherman RA, Davis GD. Behavioral treatment of nulliparous continent women. Br J Urol 1993;72:46-
exercise-induced urinary incontinence among 51.
female soldiers. Mil Med 1997:162:690-4. 18. Schussler B, Anthuber C, Warrell D. The pelvic
7. Fantl JA, Newman DK, Colling J, DeLancey JOL, floor before and after delivery. In: Schussler B,
Keeys C, Loughery R, et al. Urinary incontinence Laycock J, Norton P, Stanton S, editors. Pelvic floor
in adults: acute and chronic management. re-education. New York: Springer; 1994. p. 105-10.
(Clinical Practice Guideline No. 2, 1996 Update). 19. Norton P. Summary and paramount anatomy
Rockville (MD): US Dept of Health and Human and physiology of the pelvic floor. In: Schussler B,
JWOCN
246 Smith, Boileau, and Buan July 2000
Laycock J, Norton P, Stanton S, editors. Pelvic floor technique for treatment of urinary incontinence.
re-education. New York: Springer; 1994. p. 34-6. Urology 1991;37:432-6.
20. Chancellor MB. Managing the urge inconti- 32. Mendez FJ, Belendez M. Effects of a behavioral
nent bladder. Contemp Urol 1999;11:7-13. intervention on treatment adherence and stress
21. Burgio KL, Locher JL, Goode PS, Hardin JM, management in adolescents with IDDM. Diabetes
McDowell JB, Dombrowski DO, et al. Behavioral vs Care 1997;20:1370-5.
drug treatment for urge urinary incontinence in 33. Tinkelman D, Smith F, Cole WQ, Silk HJ.
older women. JAMA 1998;280:1995-2000. Compliance with an allergen immunotherapy
22. Flynn L, Cell P, Luisi E. Effectiveness of pelvic regime. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol 1995;74:
muscle exercises in reducing urge incontinence 241-6.
among community residing elders. J Gerontol 34. Garrett SS. Deciding between once- and
Nurs 1994;20:23-7. twice-daily dosing. Am J Health Syst Pharm
23. Lightner DJ. Conservative management for uri- 1996;53:730-1.
nary incontinence. AUA Update Series 1999;18): 35. Taylor K, Henderson J. Biofeedback and uri-
114-20. nary stress incontinence in older women. J
24. Norton P. Aims of pelvic floor reeducation. In: Gerontol Nurs 1986;12:25-30.
Schussler B, Laycock J, Norton P, Stanton S, editors. 36. Susset JG, Galea G, Read L. Biofeedback ther-
Pelvic floor re-education. New York: Springer; apy for female incontinence due to low urethral
1994. p. 121-3. resistance. J Urol 1990;143:1205-8.
25. Bo K, Hagen RH, Kvarstein B, Jorgensen J, 37. Gallo ML, Staskin DR. Cues to action: pelvic
Larsen S. Pelvic floor muscle exercise for the treat- floor muscle exercise compliance in women with
ment of female stress urinary incontinence. III. stress urinary incontinence. Neurourol Urodyn
Effects of two different degrees of pelvic floor mus- 1997;16:167-77.
cle exercises. Neurourol Urodyn 1990;9:489-502. 38. Kondo A, Yamada Y, Morishige R, Niijima R. An
26. DiNubile NA. Strength training. Clin Sports Med intensive programme for pelvic floor muscle exer-
1991;10:33-62. cises: short– and long-term effects on those with
27. Bump RC, Hurt WG, Fantl JA, Wyman JF. stress urinary incontinence. Acta Urol Jpn
Assessment of Kegel pelvic muscle exercise per- 1996;42:853-9.
formance after brief verbal instruction. Am J 39. Krissovich M. Suggestions for cost-effective
Obstet Gynecol 1991;165:322-9. continence treatment. In: Society of Urological
28. Laycock J. Biofeedback control. In: Schussler F, Nurses and Associates. Patient access to conti-
Laycock J, Norton P, Stanton S, editors. Pelvic floor nence services: protecting it under managed
re-education. New York: Springer; 1994. p. 153-6. care. Pitman (NJ): SUNA; 1997. p. 19-21.
29. Glavind K, Nohr SB, Walter S. Biofeedback and 40. Morris LS, Schulz RM. Medication compliance:
physiotherapy versus physiotherapy alone in the the patient’s perspective. Clin Ther 1993;15:593-
treatment of genuine stress urinary incontinence. 606.
Int Urogynecol J 1996;7:339-43. 41. American Academy of Ambulatory Care
30. Smith DA, Newman DK. Basic elements of Nursing. Telephone nursing practice administra-
biofeedback therapy for pelvic muscle rehabili- tion and practice standards. Pitman (NJ): The
tation. Urol Nurs 1994;14:130-5. Academy; 1997.
31. O’Donnell RD, Doyle R. Biofeedback therapy
The award is composed of an honorarium in the amount of $500 and a plaque. The check is issued in the name of the cor-
responding author, and the plaque includes the names of all authors. The eligibility requirements are as follows:
Manuscript must be original and not published or submitted for publication elsewhere.
Manuscript must be 2000 words or more.
It is not necessary to be a member of the WOCN or to have graduated from a WOCN Educational Program or
an ET Nursing Education Program to compete for the award.
The manuscript cannot be authored by any member of the Editorial Board.