ourt of
Appeals Docket No. 19-04146
In the
UNITED STATES
OURT
OF
APPEALS
for
the TENTH CIRCUIT
CAROL MASTERSON
ppellant
-
Plaintiff
V.
NATIONST AR MORTGAGE LLC;
{
--•
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMP ANY AMERICAS as TRUSTEE for the RESIDENTIAL ACCREDIT LOANS INC. MORTGAGE ASSET-BACKED PASSTHROUGH CERTIFICATES SERIES 2007-QHl; RESIDENTIAL ACCREDIT LOANS INC.; MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATION SYSTEMS INC.; ROES 1-10
and
DOES 1-10 inclusive representing a class
of
unknown persons who claim
or
have the right to claim an interest in certain real property located in Park City Utah.
ppellees
-
Defendants
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR DISTRICT OF UTAH CENTRAL DIVISION The Honorable Judge Robert
J
Shelby Case No.
2:
18-cv-00 196-RJS-DBP
APPELLANT S OPENING BRIEF
Opening Brief Masterson
v
Nationstar Mortgage et al Docket
No
19-04146
Appellate Case: 19-4146 Document: 010110283477 Date Filed: 01/03/2020 Page: 1
T BLE OF CONTENTS
I
CERTIFICATE
OF
INTERESTED PARTIES ........................................................... 3
I
WRISDICTIONAL STATEMENT ............................................................................ 6
II
ISSUES PRESENTED ................................................................................................ 6
III
INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................... 7
IV
STATEMENT
OF
FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS ..................................................... 8
V
STANDARD
OF
REVIEW ....................................................................................... 14
VI
LEGAL ARGUMENT ............................................................................................ 14
VII
CONCLUSION .......................................................................................................
31
Opening
rief
Masterson v. Nationstar Mortgage et al Docket No. 19-04146
Appellate Case: 19-4146 Document: 010110283477 Date Filed: 01/03/2020 Page: 2
I
CERTIFIC TE OF INTERESTED P RTIES
1.
Appellant
is
now, and California at all times relevant to this action, an individual residing in the County
of
Los Angeles, in the State
of
California but was residing in the County
of
Los Angeles, in the State
of
California, Appellant owns the real property commonly known
as
2595 Aspen Springs Drive, Park City, UT 84060.
2.
Appellant is informed and believes, and based on such information and beliefs, asserts that at all relevant times to this Complaint, Defendant Nationstar Mortgage, LLC create is a subsidiary Nationstar Mortgage Holdings, Inc., LLC with corporate headquarters located at 8950 Cypress Waters Boulevard, Coppell, TX 75019.
3.
Appellant
is
informed and believes, and based on such information and beliefs, asserts that at all relevant times to this Complaint, Defendant Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas
as
Trustee (hereinafter DBTCA ) for the Residential Accredit Loans, Inc. Mortgage Asset-Backed Pass-Through Certificates, Series 2007-QH 1 (hereinafter RALi 2007-QH 1 ) is wholly owned subsidiary
of
Deutsche Bank with corporate headquarters located at 60 Wall St, New York, NY 10005.
4.
Appellant
is
informed and believes, and based on such information and beliefs, asserts that at all relevant times to this Complaint, Defendant Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas
as
Trustee (hereinafter DBTCA2 ) for the Residential Accredit Loans, Inc. Mortgage Asset-Backed Pass-Through Certificates, Series 2005-QA13 (hereinafter RALi 2005-QA13 )
is
a New York Corporation with corporate headquarters located at 60 Wall
St
New York, NY 10005.
Opening
rief
Masterson v. Nationstar Mortgage, et al Docket
No.
19-04146
3
Appellate Case: 19-4146 Document: 010110283477 Date Filed: 01/03/2020 Page: 3
