Professional Documents
Culture Documents
From the Departments of *Neurology and †Pediatrics, Medical Communications should be addressed to:
College of Wisconsin and Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin, Dr. Zupanc; Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin; 9000 W. Wisconsin Ave.;
Milwaukee, Wisconsin. CHW CCC Suite C540; Milwaukee, WI 53201.
E-mail: mzupanc@mcw.edu
Received July 20, 2009; accepted February 11, 2010.
396 PEDIATRIC NEUROLOGY Vol. 42 No. 6 Ó 2010 by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.pediatrneurol.2010.02.013 0887-8994/$—see front matter
Felbamate was approved by the FDA in 1993 as mono- The first cases of aplastic anemia were reported in Janu-
therapy and as adjunctive therapy in the treatment of partial ary 1994, and the first case of liver failure was reported in
seizures with and without generalization in adults, and also March 1994. There have now been 34 reported cases of
as adjunctive therapy for partial and generalized seizures as- aplastic anemia in patients treated with felbamate in the
sociated with Lennox-Gastaut syndrome [3]. Felbamate United States; 33 of these cases were reported during the
was the first new major antiepileptic drug approved by first year of marketing. During the same time frame, 18
the FDA since the approval of valproic acid in 1978 [4]. cases of liver failure were reported.
Felbamate is a dicarbamate that is chemically similar to Of the 34 reported cases of felbamate-related aplastic
meprobamate. It entered the U.S. National Institutes of anemia reported in the United States, the majority of pa-
Health (NIH) antiepileptic drug development program in tients (23, or 68%) were women. No patients younger
the early 1980s and was found to be highly effective in ro- than 13 years of age have developed aplastic anemia.
dent seizure models [5]. Felbamate is effective against max- Only 8 of the 34 patients were on felbamate monotherapy;
imal electroshock seizures, which predicts activity against the remaining patients were on polytherapy. The mean time
partial onset and tonic-clonic seizures. It has also exhibits to presentation of aplastic anemia symptoms was 145 days.
protection against pentylenetetrazol-induced seizures, Only 23 of the 34 reported cases met the full diagnostic cri-
which indicates possible efficacy against absence seizures teria for aplastic anemia. Of these 23 cases, 3 were found to
[5]. The exact mechanisms of action of felbamate remain be definitely related to felbamate, and felbamate was deter-
unknown. Probable mechanisms of action include (1) mined to be the most likely etiologic agent in 11 additional
blockade of voltage-gated sodium channels; (2) interfer- cases, for a total of 14 patients. In the 9 remaining cases,
ence with both N-methyl-D-aspartate and non-N-methyl-D- confounding factors existed and felbamate was only one
aspartate subtypes of the glutamate receptor; (3) inhibition of several plausible etiologic agents. For the 34 reported
of voltage-gated calcium currents; and (4) modulation of cases of aplastic anemia, 18 patients recovered, 14 patients
g-aminobutyric acid receptors [6]. Blockage of voltage- died, and 2 patients were lost to follow-up [14].
gated sodium channels decreases excessive excitation and In the general population, the risk of aplastic anemia is
the inhibition of calcium currents probably interferes with 2-6 cases per 1 million [14]. The risk of aplastic anemia
neurotransmitter release. The relatively minor degree of fel- in patients who are taking felbamate is estimated to be be-
bamate effect on g-aminobutyric acid function may explain tween 27 and 209 cases per 1 million [15]. Probable risk
the striking lack of sedative effects and absence of adverse factors for aplastic anemia include (1) female sex, (2) post-
effects on cognition [7]. pubertal status, (3) history of cytopenia, (4) history of auto-
Premarketing clinical trials indicated that felbamate was immune disease, such as systemic lupus erythematosus,
a highly effective antiepileptic drug with few adverse ef- rheumatoid arthritis, Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, panhypo-
fects. Felbamate was the first antiepileptic drug to be eval- gammaglobulinemia, idiopathic thrombocytopenia pur-
uated in a double-blind study in patients undergoing pura, and (5) a positive antinuclear antibody titer. If two
evaluation for epilepsy surgery and was one of the first an- risk factors are present, a patient’s relative risk of develop-
tiepileptic drugs to be included in monotherapy trials. All of ing aplastic anemia quadruples [15]. There have been
these studies demonstrated significant efficacy in the con- approximately 40,000 new exposures to felbamate since
trol of seizures [8-11]. In premarketing experience, 1994 and only 1 new reported case of aplastic anemia,
felbamate was also shown to be an effective treatment for occurring in a 45-year-old woman in 2000.
Lennox-Gastaut syndrome. Among 73 patients treated in Liver failure has been reported in 18 cases, 9 children
a double-blind controlled trial, felbamate and placebo and 9 adults taking felbamate, with a definite female pre-
reduced atonic seizures by 34% and 9%, respectively dominance (4 male, 22%; 14 female, 78%). Felbamate
(P < 0.01) [12]. Additionally, felbamate resulted in a total monotherapy was only reported in 1 case (6%) [15]. The
seizure frequency decrease of 19%, compared with a 4% in- mean time to symptom presentation was 217 days. Of these
crease in seizure frequency among patients in the placebo 18 reported cases of liver failure, 7 cases (39%) were deter-
group (P = 0.002); of the 71 patients who completed the mined likely due to felbamate and 9 cases (50%) were
double-blind phase of the study, 70 continued into an determined unlikely due to felbamate; several of the cases
open-label extension phase. An eventual 50% reduction occurred in the context of status epilepticus. Nine deaths
of atonic seizures frequency was observed in 33 of 50 pa- due to liver failure were reported [15], five of them being
tients (66%) [13]. Most participants in felbamate trials children: one death was deemed likely related to felbamate,
were also receiving valproate. three deaths were deemed unlikely due to felbamate, and
When felbamate was initially released, there was wide- for one death the relation to felbamate was undetermined
spread optimism that it would be a highly effective and [15].
safe antiepileptic drug therapy. The premarketing experi- The risk of felbamate-related liver failure is estimated to
ence involved 1000 patients. After 12 months, approxi- be between 1:6097 and 1:15,625 patients. The risk of death
mately 110,000 patients were prescribed felbamate. due to liver failure related to felbamate use is 1 in 12,345
Unfortunately, serious adverse effects, including aplastic [15]. To place this risk factor in the context of antiepileptic
anemia and liver failure, were reported within the first year. drugs, the risk of death due to liver failure from valproate in
Seizure Types
Case Age Epilepsy Syndrome Etiology (Baseline Seizure Frequency) Seizure Reduction
Seizure Types
Case Age Epilepsy Syndrome Etiology (Baseline Seizure Frequency) Seizure Reduction
18. 4 yr Symptomatic localization ? Focal cortical dysplasia Tonic (3-4/d) and complex >50%
related epilepsy partial with 2 genl
(1-4/wk, often prolonged
requiring diazepam)
19. 7 yr Idiopathic generalized — Myoclonic, astatic, and absence 100%
epilepsy, myoclonic-astatic (in nonconvulsive status
epilepsy of Doose epilepticus for >2 yr)
20. 10 yr Symptomatic generalized — Tonic (1-2/wk), atypical absence >25%
epilepsy, Lennox-Gastaut (multiple times per day), and
syndrome myoclonic ($100/d)
21. 10 yr Symptomatic generalized — Tonic or generalized tonic-clonic >50%
epilepsy, Lennox-Gastaut (1-2/wk, often prolonged) and
syndrome atypical absence (multiple
times per day)
22. 8 yr Symptomatic generalized ? Metabolic disorder Tonic or atonic (2-12/night) and >25%
epilepsy, Lennox-Gastaut atypical absence (multiple
syndrome times per day)
23. 4 yr Idiopathic generalized — Myoclonic (multiple times per 100%
epilepsy, myoclonic-astatic day), astatic (multiple times
epilepsy of Doose per day), and absence (multiple
times per day) (presented in
nonconvulsive status
epilepticus)
24. 8 yr Symptomatic generalized — Myoclonic, astatic, and absence 100%
epilepsy, myoclonic-astatic (multiple times per day in
epilepsy of Doose clusters lasting 15-20 minutes)
25. 10 yr Symptomatic generalized — Myoclonic, astatic, and absence 100%
epilepsy, myoclonic-astatic (multiple times per day, too
epilepsy of Doose numerous to count)
26. 8 yr Symptomatic generalized Metabolic disorder Tonic (12-15/d; can occur in >50%
epilepsy, Lennox-Gastaut clusters) and atypical absence
syndrome (multiple times per day)
27. 1.5 yr Symptomatic localization — Complex partial with 2 genl >75%
related epilepsy (35 to >50/d, often in
clusters)
28. 5 yr Symptomatic generalized ? Focal cortical dysplasia Tonic (1-3/d), atypical absence No change
epilepsy, Lennox-Gastaut (multiple times per day, and
syndrome myoclonic (multiple times
per day)
29. 7 yr Symptomatic generalized Aicardi’s syndrome Tonic (4-10 times per day, >75%
epilepsy, Lennox-Gastaut often in clusters); atypical
syndrome absence seizures, occur
multiple times per day, also
in clusters
30. 11 yr Symptomatic generalized — Tonic (2-3/d), atypical absence >75% (tonic
epilepsy, Lennox-Gastaut (multiple times per day), and seizures: 100%)
syndrome myoclonic (multiple times
per day)
31. 8 yr Symptomatic generalized — Tonic (3-4 times per day, but can >75%
epilepsy, Lennox-Gastaut occur up to 10 times per day),
syndrome myoclonic (multiple times per
day), and atypical absence
(multiple times per day)
32. 12 yr Symptomatic generalized ? Frontal Tonic (clusters 1-2/day; every >50%
epilepsy, Lennox-Gastaut morning)
syndrome
33. 12 yr Symptomatic generalized ? Frontal Tonic (1-5/wk, nocturnal only) >50%
epilepsy, not otherwise
specified
Seizure Types
Case Age Epilepsy Syndrome Etiology (Baseline Seizure Frequency) Seizure Reduction
34. 1 yr Symptomatic localization Focal cortical dysplasia Complex partial with 2 genl and No change
related epilepsy generalized tonic-clonic (30-50
times per day)
35. 1.5 yr Symptomatic localization Mitochondrial disorder Tonic and complex partial with 2 100% (rare seizures)
related epilepsy genl (in convulsive status
epilepticus, with multiple
seizures per day until felbamate
started)
36. 6 yr Symptomatic generalized Aicardi’s syndrome Tonic (1-3/d, but can also have >75%
epilepsy, Lennox-Gastaut clusters of seizures) and
syndrome complex partial with 2 genl
(1-3/d)
37. 12 yr Symptomatic generalized ? Frontal Tonic (0-7 times per night) and >50%
epilepsy, Lennox-Gastaut atypical absence (multiple
syndrome times per day)
38. 17 yr Symptomatic generalized ? Frontal Tonic (1-5 times per day) and >25%
epilepsy, Lennox-Gastaut atypical absence ($30/d) and
syndrome myoclonic (3-4/d)
Abbreviations:
? = Possible etiology
2 genl = Secondary generalization
GTCS = Generalized tonic-clonic seizure
of seizure types and frequency, and the validity of the data is charges, without overt clinical manifestations. Unfortu-
considered good. In addition, the parent’s assessment of sei- nately, no specific clinical response testing was performed
zure frequency was confirmed with follow-up video EEG during these discharges. The EEGs also markedly activated
monitoring data on all of these patients. with drowsiness and sleep. With the initiation of felbamate,
The initial video EEG monitoring in the Lennox-Gastaut not only did the myoclonic-astatic seizures disappear, but
syndrome patients typically evidenced multiple tonic and the prolonged trains of generalized discharges were also
atonic seizures, as well as prolonged trains of generalized significantly reduced. Similar to the patients with Lennox-
slow spike and wave discharges at 1.5-2 Hz, probably rep- Gastaut syndrome, but much more dramatically, the fre-
resenting atypical absence seizures. Many of these patients quency and duration of the epileptiform discharges de-
also had frequent generalized and multifocal, independent creased during all states (wakefulness, drowsiness, and
epileptiform discharges, with marked activation during sleep). With two of these patients, there were only rare in-
drowsiness and sleep. Some of these patients had electrical terictal epileptiform discharges.
status epilepticus of slow wave sleep. Unfortunately, in Adverse effects from felbamate were observed in 9 of the
a retrospective study it was not possible to confirm electri- 38 patients (24%). The adverse effects included insomnia,
cal status epilepticus of slow wave sleep in the saved data anorexia, irritability, and motor or vocal tics. In only one
files. With felbamate treatment, not only did the tonic and patient were the adverse effects significant enough to war-
atonic seizures dramatically decrease, but the prolonged rant discontinuation of felbamate. This patient developed
trains of generalized slow spike and wave discharges also significant vocal and motor tics, which were disruptive to
significantly decreased, both in frequency and duration. his family. There were no cases of aplastic anemia or liver
This occurred during all states (wakefulness, drowsiness, failure.
and sleep).
Of the six patients with myoclonic-astatic epilepsy of Discussion
Doose, four became seizure free and two achieved greater
than 50% reduction. Their initial video EEG monitoring In this retrospective study, felbamate proved to be
evidenced multiple myoclonic-astatic seizures, in most a highly effective antiepileptic medication for its primary
cases more than 200 per day, associated with generalized, indication, the treatment of Lennox-Gastaut syndrome. In
high-amplitude, irregular polyspike, spike and slow wave addition, the six patients with myoclonic-astatic epilepsy
discharges. In addition, their EEGs demonstrated robust of Doose, another generalized, medically refractory syn-
interictal epileptiform discharges with frequent trains of drome, appeared to be exquisitely responsive to felbamate,
generalized irregular polyspike, spike and slow wave dis- with four of the six becoming completely seizure free, on
Epilepsy syndrome Cases, no. Seizure free, no. (%) >50% Reduction, no. (%) #50% Reduction, no. (%)
relatively small doses. Per the FDA indication, felbamate is months and then every other week for the next 2 months.
also approved for patients with medically intractable epi- Subsequently, blood testing is done monthly for the next
lepsy of sufficient severity to warrant the treatment. The pa- 4 months and then every 3-6 months thereafter. There has
tients with myoclonic-astatic epilepsy of Doose were all been close and careful follow-up for this population of
having more than 200 seizures per day and were virtually patients on felbamate, and the blood testing is monitored
incapacitated by their epilepsy. This epilepsy syndrome regularly.
may represent a special subset that is exquisitely responsive Two patients presented unusual circumstances. The first
to felbamate, with patient dosages in this group typically patient had symptomatic localization related epilepsy with
less than 50 mg/kg per day. a history of frequent status epilepticus. She had bilateral
The majority of the patients had Lennox-Gastaut syn- cortical dysplasia and had undergone a palliative left
drome (22/38, or 58%). Most of these patients were having temporal-parietal-occipital resection. After her epilepsy
multiple daily tonic seizures, both daytime and nocturnal, surgery, her seizure burden, particularly the episodes of sta-
that were unpredictable and extremely disruptive to quality tus epilepticus, markedly reduced, but she continued to
of life; many had had significant injury as a result of their have two complex partial seizures per week. She had
tonic seizures, including skull fractures, broken bones, been tried on multiple antiepileptic drugs in the past and
chipped teeth, and concussions. Seizures were greatly re- had severe pancytopenia with phenytoin and thrombocyto-
duced with felbamate, 16 of the 22 patients with Lennox- penia with valproate. The hematologist, an expert in aplas-
Gastaut syndrome having a greater than 50% reduction in tic anemia, suggested harvesting stem cells from the bone
seizures, including 1 who achieved seizure freedom. Over- marrow and preserving them for future use, should an aplas-
all, 30 of the 38 patients (79%) had a greater than 50% re- tic crisis develop. She did have this procedure performed.
duction in seizure frequency, including 6 who achieved Although felbamate did not completely eliminate her sei-
seizure freedom (Table 2). In the majority of patients, felba- zures, she had a 25% reduction in seizure frequency.
mate was well tolerated without significant adverse effects. The second patient had had acute lymphocytic leukemia
There were no cases of aplastic anemia or liver failure in the as a child and then subsequently went on to develop
present cohort. Lennox-Gastaut syndrome with multiple tonic-atonic sei-
With respect to antiepileptic drug combinations, the zures, occurring on a daily basis. He had sustained multiple
patients with myoclonic-astatic epilepsy of Doose were head injuries and chipped teeth because of the seizures. His
on felbamate monotherapy. Patients with symptomatic magnetic resonance imaging scan revealed significant white
generalized epilepsy syndromes, including Lennox- matter changes, thought to be compatible with his history of
Gastaut syndrome, were typically on two antiepileptic methotrexate chemotherapy. He was tried on valproate, top-
drugs. The most favorable combinations included felba- iramate, lamotrigine, and levetiracetam. He was not consid-
mate and lamotrigine; felbamate and valproate; felbamate ered to be a candidate for the ketogenic diet, because of his
and the ketogenic diet. The combination of felbamate and oppositional behaviors. Given his history, the medical team
topiramate was hard for the patients to tolerate and was was reluctant to start him on felbamate. After consultation
avoided, in large part because of appetite suppression and with the hematologist, however, stem cells were harvested
weight loss. from the bone marrow. The patient was excluded from
With respect to adverse effects, there were no cases of this retrospective study, because his case was added to the
aplastic anemia or liver failure in the present patient popu- database only later. Notably, however, he achieved seizure
lation. In the past, when aplastic anemia or liver failure has freedom on felbamate monotherapy, and he has not had any
occurred, it has almost always been reported within the first hematologic abnormalities.
6 months, with only one or two outliers [15]. At the authors’ Although these two cases are rare, they do represent
center, the practice is to monitor hematologic parameters important examples of high-risk patients who were success-
(complete blood count with differential), reticulocyte count, fully started on felbamate. Bone marrow harvest is not
and liver function studies on a weekly basis for the first 2 thereby advocated for all patients who are started on