Beyond-IR: Remote Controls for Home Entertainment

By: Jim Davis, Senior Product Marketing Engineer, Cypress Semiconductor Corp.

Does your home entertainment system look anything like the below photo? Do you have a TV in your bedroom that you have to reach at odd-angles from your bed to control with your line-of-sight IR remote control? Am I the only one that’s amazed that st we’re in the 21 century and reliant on a near 30-year old, one-way, line-of-sight-limited technology to control our bleeding edge consumer electronics products like our multi-thousand dollar plasma big-screen TVs and other entertainment systems? I don’t think I am—and that’s why you’re still reading.

Figure 1 – Example of a Multi-Component Home Entertainment System

The alternative to infrared remote control technologies is RF-based remote controls. RF-based remote controls overcome three major limitations of infrared technologies: line-of-sight and range; one-way communications; and high power consumption. Let’s take a look at each of these limitations and attempt to better understand why the primary interface to our home entertainment, the remote control, continues to be based on a 1980s era technology and how this will change, especially with the introduction of the RF4CE consortium and standards.

Line-of-Sight and Range
The most apparent limitation we all deal with on a regular basis with our infrared remote controls is the need for a line-of-sight connection. This connection is fragile in that it is broken if the receiver is accidentally pushed back into the entertainment center enough to cover the optical IR receiver. Even if you just want to turn the TV off, you have to walk right up to the receiver with the remote to toggle the power. What happens in these same scenarios when the remote is no longer restricted by line-of-sight? You no longer have to care about where the receiver is or where the remote is in relation to the receiver. Radio frequency technologies for remote controls, unlike Infrared, have physical characteristics that allow these control signals to penetrate line-of-sight obstructions such as walls, blankets, and home entertainment centers. Just as with a WiFi network connection, the beauty is that users are not tethered to a desk and can travel throughout the home while still maintaining a connection to the network. RF remotes work in much the same way. In addition, RF technologies allow for greater range then typical IR remotes (1~5m of range). RF technologies can easily reach 20-to-50m with the same operating characteristics of the IR remote control. And depending on the application, this range can easily be extended with a slight increase in power.
Beyond-IR Remote Controls for Home Entertainment Published in Digital Home DesignLine (http://www.digitalhomedesignline.com/howto/218000081) Page 1 of 3 June 2009

[+] Feedback

Another feature enabled by bi-directional communications – a feature every family needs – is a pager function to locate the remote control. The lower power consumption of RF remote controls. The lower a manufacturer can drive their cost when building millions of a product. The use of a smaller.digitalhomedesignline. Rather than spending searching for a misplaced remote or operating the receiver manually. allowing for better hand-fitting. How many times have you driven away from your garage thinking more about where you’re headed.com/howto/218000081) Page 2 of 3 June 2009 [+] Feedback . The table below compares a typical IR remote control’s power consumption to that of a leading RF technology. IR) RF4CE: The Consortium Bringing Remotes into the 21st Century Why.One-Way Communications The next feature-limiting characteristic of IR remotes that RF technologies easily overcome is one-way communications. The most paranoid among us immediately turn around and return to the house just to realize that as a part of our normal day-to-day routines we have pushed the garage remote button just like we do every day as we backed away from the house. Power Consumption Typical IR remote controls require battery replacement at least once per year. price is king. the less the manufacture has to charge to make a sustainable profit. longer operating life also translates to fewer support calls and RMAs for the home entertainment system manufacturer due to failures in identifying problems with their systems ultimately being a result of failed power sources (i. In addition. And this is just one of the new possibilities and innovations a bi-directional communication link can enable for controlling home entertainment system. Most of us don’t even realize this is a limitation of IR remotes primarily due to the fact that RF remotes are still not very common for home entertainment systems. With a one-way system you must either remember exactly how many next-song button clicks to press from the current song playing or listen to opening of each song before clicking to the next.7 uC 2+ years Infrared 250 mC 8 weeks Figure 2 .e. sleeker form factors. For example. or whether you’re going to be late just to realize that you don’t remember if you shut the garage behind you. on the other hand. Multiplying the number of home entertainment system remotes by the number of batteries in each remote (typically two AA/AAA batteries) and we’re disposing on the order of millions of batteries each year. say you want to find a particular song stored in your audio system. For both the consumer and the manufacturer. Further. Beyond-IR Remote Controls for Home Entertainment Published in Digital Home DesignLine (http://www. which impacts the minimum form factor. In contrast. with all of the benefits that RF has over infrared. 100 press/day) Cypress CyFi Low-Power RF 66.Power Consumption (RF vs. From a manufacturer’s perspective in the consumer electronics market. users could instead have the remote sound off to reveal its location. it serves as a differentiating feature for which many consumers might be willing to upgrade. have we not seen this technology take off? Two reasons are usually cited: cost (including added design complexity) and the fact that IR is an incumbent standard. due to the high power consumption of IR technologies. users will quickly discover a need for the remote to provide feedback regarding the system being controlled. it’s clear to see that a low-power RF technology could easily and significantly increase the lifetime of the batteries in home entertainment remote controls. Ideally. a system with greater battery life such as RF remote controls is a huge win-win. what your first meeting is at work. Once the line-of-sight and range limitation has been addressed. drained batteries). single cell enables removes battery constraints. IR remotes require multiple large batteries. In addition. imagine a remote that could display the status of the garage and whether it is shut or open? With a bi-directional communications feature. Let’s now consider an example apart from the home entertainment system that would also benefit from these same RF remote control features—the garage remote control. In this table. users would prefer to scroll through their music. Feature Energy Per Button Press (Measured in Coulombs) Battery Life (CR2032. can take advantage of smaller batteries such as the CR2032 coin-cell. perhaps selecting the next song from an abbreviated list shown on the remote. this could easily be accomplished.

This Source Code (software and/or firmware) is owned by Cypress Semiconductor Corporation (Cypress) and is protected by and subject to worldwide patent protection (United States and foreign). Cypress does not authorize its products for use as critical components in life-support systems where a malfunction or failure may reasonably be expected to result in significant injury to the user. An entire market of universal remote controls has evolved based on this and many of the same companies that design the core entertainment system devices develop devices for the universal remote control market. relatively cheap. EXPRESS OR IMPLIED. and probably the most logical reason why RF has not taken off in the consumer electronics market is that IR is the de-facto standard for remote control communications. Disclaimer: CYPRESS MAKES NO WARRANTY OF ANY KIND. In this way. All other trademarks or registered trademarks referenced herein are property of the respective corporations. non-transferable license to copy. and everyone except for a small few of consumer electronics manufacturers utilize IR technologies for remote controls. compilation. Any reproduction.In response to this. few features other than compliance to the standard and measures of who can comply more effectively will truly separate the RF component offerings thus leading to the prime discriminator: price. The information contained herein is subject to change without notice. Cypress Semiconductor Corporation assumes no responsibility for the use of any circuitry other than circuitry embodied in a Cypress product.com/howto/218000081) Page 3 of 3 June 2009 [+] Feedback . Cypress reserves the right to make changes without further notice to the materials described herein. translation.digitalhomedesignline. The second. non-exclusive. In March of 2009. will commoditize the electronic components to meet this standard. 2007. The inclusion of Cypress products in life-support systems application implies that the manufacturer assumes all risk of such use and in doing so indemnifies Cypress against all charges. Cypress does not assume any liability arising out of the application or use of any product or circuit described herein. Cypress products are not warranted nor intended to be used for medical. the RF4CE consortium is working to establish a standard RF interface for consumer electronics products which. CA 95134-1709 Phone: 408-943-2600 Fax: 408-943-4730 http://www. critical control or safety applications. create derivative works of. This alone has a spiral-effect of preventing RF from entering the remote control space. Cypress hereby grants to licensee a personal. RF for remote controls will quickly become a simple add-on component thanks to both the ZigBee RF4CE standards development and its supporting manufacturers. and compile the Cypress Source Code and derivative works for the sole purpose of creating custom software and or firmware in support of licensee product to be used only in conjunction with a Cypress integrated circuit as specified in the applicable agreement. Nor does it convey or imply any license under patent or other rights. WITH REGARD TO THIS MATERIAL. Cypress Semiconductor 198 Champion Court San Jose. this changes as a large group of the world’s major consumer electronics manufacturers and their suppliers continue to team together to form the RF4CE consortium to once and for all upgrade the world’s home entertainment centers primary interface. It’s simple. major consumer electronics manufacturers have made a clear statement that RF for remote controls is necessary. life support. use. Furthermore. BUT NOT LIMITED TO. can be standardized to continue minimizing the number of remote controls we have in front of our couches. PSoC Designer™. and PSoC Express™ are trademarks and PSoC® is a registered trademark of Cypress Semiconductor Corp. The inclusion of Cypress’ product in a life-support systems application implies that the manufacturer assumes all risk of such use and in doing so indemnifies Cypress against all charges. However. Cypress does not authorize its products for use as critical components in life-support systems where a malfunction or failure may reasonably be expected to result in significant injury to the user. in turn. or representation of this Source Code except as specified above is prohibited without the express written permission of Cypress. unless pursuant to an express written agreement with Cypress. the ZigBee Alliance and the RF4CE Consortium jointly announced an agreement to deliver a standardized specification for RF-based remote controls—ZigBee RF4CE. THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. and. modify. when it comes to the RF interface itself. Use may be limited by and subject to the applicable Cypress software license agreement. through a public partnership. can be achieved at reasonable cost and effect. modification. INCLUDING. Programmable System-on-Chip™. life saving.com © Cypress Semiconductor Corporation.cypress. This means. the remote control. Beyond-IR Remote Controls for Home Entertainment Published in Digital Home DesignLine (http://www. United States copyright laws and international treaty provisions.