Haney v. Scientology: Opposition To Motion For Sanctions

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9
 
! # $ % & ' ( ) * !+ !! !# !$ !% !& !' !( !) !* #+ #! ## #$ #% #& #' #( #) ,-./01/2234 5,,54/1/50 15 672706.0143 851/50 259 4.0:1/504
!"#$%& () *+",-."/0 1.2) 34567 89::;<= >?.$@ A) B$$0 1.2) 34567 8<C<;:= *DEFG4E6 HA( EIIJ>140 G)>) K:: AL%-"%& 5"MN$O?%P0 4ML&$ QR: 5M%NL/S?,$0 >A TC:Q: *$N7 3R9:= 9Q;URQQQ V I?W7 3R9:= 9Q;UR:KQ 5%L?/ X) Y$/&0 1.2) 3AP,L&&$P G%" D?Z [LZ$= B?$&?/" X\A/P%$?0 1.2) 3AP,L&&$P G%" D?Z [LZ$= F) 4&$]?%& !@?/0 1.2) 3AP,L&&$P G%" D?Z [LZ$= HAII1^0 5_>>J ` Y16*0 HHG QC;9 (?N/M& 4&%$$&0 4ML&$ K:: G+LN?P$N-+L?0 GA QTQ:8 *$N7 38Q9= ;TTUT899 V I?W7 38Q9= 8CQU<K:: A&&"%/$@. a"% GN?L/&Laa. 4_G1!JE! >E_!* EI >AHJIE!6JA J6 A6X IE! *D1 >E_6*^ EI HE4 A6B1H14 U _6HJFJ*1X >J[JH b_!J4XJ>*JE6
;.-79/7 <.07=
0 GN?L/&Laa0 O) >D_!>D EI 4>J16*EHEB^ J6*1!6A*JE6AHc !1HJBJE_4 *1>D6EHEB^ >16*1!c XA[JX FJ4>A[JB1c ?/P XE14 Q d 890 X$a$/P?/&.) >?.$ 6")7 QT4*>[8Q8Q: eA..LS/$P a"% ?NN -M%-".$. &" D"/) !LZ+?%P b) 5M%PS$0 b%)0 X$-?%&,$/& ;Kf
"#$%&'%(()* +""+*%'%+& '+ ,-(-&,$&'*) .+'%+& (+/ *$&0'%+&*
X?&$7 b?/M?%@ QC0 8:8Q
 
*L,$7 <7;: ?),) X$-&7 ;K !$.) 6"7 Q9RQCC:9:9<Q 
Electronically FILED by Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles on 01/04/2021 01:54 PM Sherri R. Carter, Executive Officer/Clerk of Court, by J. Lara,Deputy Clerk
 
 
!"#$%&$''() +!!+)$&$+% &+ ,-'-%,#%&)( .+&$+% '+/ )#%0&$+%)
"
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1: 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 2: 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
!"
 
!#$%&'()$!&#
#$%&'(&)) *+,*-+$. )&$-/ % 0,(&,' ),+ 1-2,'3&/-+%(&,' ,) (4&3 5,6+(73 +6$&'8 ,' 9-)-'/%'(37 0,(&,'3 (, 5,:*-$ ;+<&(+%(&,' <%3-/ ,' '-= ->&/-'2- *+,>&/-/ %)(-+ (4- +6$&'8 <. &'/-*-'/-'( (4&+/  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
!!"
 
+,-.+ .%-(/,#$ ."
 
012345627 .89 (2:1881249; <931=79 >?15245@@A7 /64562 @68 %936275;9814562 !7 <179; 62 #9: B1347 >=87=124 46 )6;9 6@ )5C5? >8639;=89 7934562 DEEF
9-)-'/%'(3 2,'>-'&-'($. &8',+-I ,+ %((-:*( (, 4&/- &' % ),,(',(-I (4%( #$%&'(&))73 '-= ->&/-'2- =%3  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 *+&,+ (, (4&3 %'/ 2,6$/ ',( (4+,684 +-%3,'%<$- /&$&8-'2- 4%>- ,<(%&'-/ (4- &'),+:%(&,' )+,: 4-+ *+&,+ (, (4- +6$&'8@ 9-)-'/%'(37 ','3-'3&2%$ 2$%&: (4%( #$%&'(&))73 2,6'3-$ ?'-= ,) 03@ O4&()&-$/ <-2%63- (4-. :%. 4%>- 3*,?-' %( (4- 3%:- 2,')-+-'2- /,-3 ',( 24%'8- (4&3 )%2(@ ;'.,'- =4, 4%3 <--' (, % 2,')-+-'2- =,6$/  <- 4%+/ *+-33-/ (, 3%. (4-. ?'-= ->-+.,'- ,+ 3&'2- %((-'/&'8I ?',= ,) ->-+. 3&'8$- *-+3,' &' %((-'/%'2- %( ->-+. 2,')-+-'2- (4-. 4%>- ->-+ %((-'/-/@ R>-' &) (4%( =-+- (4- 2%3-I ',(4&'8 %<,6( E?',=&'8 ,)G 03@ O4&()&-$/ <-2%63- 34- 3*,?- %( % 2,')-+-'2- 2,6$/ +-%3,'%<$. &'/&2%(- (, #$%&'(&))73 2,6'3-$ (4%( 34-  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
 
 
!"#$%&$''() +!!+)$&$+% &+ ,-'-%,#%&)( .+&$+% '+/ )#%0&$+%)
M
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1: 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 2: 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
&'),+:%(&,' )+,: 03@ O4&()&-$/ *+&,+ (, (4- 0,(&,' (, 5,:*-$ ;+<&(+%(&,' +6$&'8I (4-. %((-:*( (, &'3(-%/ 2$%&: (4%( 03@ O4&()&-$/73 ->&/-'2- &3 /6*$&2%(&>- ,) 0+@ 1&'/-+73I %'/ (4%( /6- (, % *6+*,+(-/ E%))&$&%(&,'G =&(4 0+@ 1&'/-+I %$$ ,) 4&3 ?',=$-/8- %<,6( F2&-'(,$,8. =%3 3,:-4,= &:*6(-/ ,'(, #$%&'(&)) %'/ ?',='  *+&,+ (, (4- 0,(&,' (, 5,:*-$ ;+<&(+%(&,' +6$&'8@ 9-)-'/%'(3 *+,>&/- ', $%= ,+ 36**,+( ),+ 3624 % *,3&(&,'@  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 *-+L6+. (4%( 03@ O4&()&-$/ %'/ 0+@ 1&'/-+ 2%:- ),+=%+/ =&(4 (4- '-= ->&/-'2- %)(-+ (4&3 5,6+(73 +6$&'8 %'/ 9-)-'/%'(37 =4,$$. %((-'6%(-/ %'/ 3*-26$%(&>- 2,'L-2(6+- /,-3 ',( 24%'8- ,+ /&3*+,>- (4%(@
<"
 
012345627 .89 (2:1881249; <931=79 >?15245@@ )62;=349; 1 %917621G?9 !2C9745H14562 12; 4I9 /64562 @68 %936275;9814562 J17 #64 B85C6?6=7
EP4- =,+/ Y)+&>,$,637 /,-3 ',( %**-%+ %'.=4-+- &' (4- (-J( ,) (4- 16$-Z +%(4-+I &( &3 % 34,+(4%'/ (4%( (4&3 2,6+( 4%3 63-/ (, /-',(- % )&$&'8 (4%( &3 <,(4 <%3-$-33 %'/ :%/- =&(4,6( % +-%3,'%<$- %'/ 2,:*-(-'( &'A6&+.@G
!"#$%&$' )* +",-.$ /"$%0,12$3 /"45*
 D"[[BH [M[ W@M/ "T\CI "T]M@ ; E)&'/&'8 ,) ', +-%3,'%<$- &'A6&+. &3 (%'(%:,6'( (, % )&'/&'8 ,) )+&>,$,63'-33@G
 6'*
 ; +-%3,'%<$- &'A6&+. :-%'3 E%' &'A6&+. +-%3,'%<$- 6'/-+ Y%$$ 2&+26:3(%'2-3 ,) % 2%3-@7G
 6'*
 %( "T]^ DA6,(&'8
/""1&4 7 8&,, )* +.41-.49 /"45*
 D"[[BH ^[] _@F@ TC^H@ ;3 3624I 2,6+(3 :63( 8&>- :,+- $--=%. +-8%+/&'8 +-$->%'( )%2(3 (4%( %+- &' (4- 2,'(+,$ ,)I ,+ +-$%(- (, (4- ?',=$-/8-I *6+*,3-I ,+ &'(-'( ,)I (4- ,**,3&'8 *%+(.@
 6'*
#$%&'(&)) 2,'/62(-/ ,<L-2(&>-$. +-%3,'%<$- &'>-3(&8%(&,'3 &'(, (4&3 2%3-I (4- 0,(&,'3 (, 5,:*-$ ;+<&(+%(&,'I %'/ +-*-%(-/$. +-A6-3(-/ (4- ,**,+(6'&(. (, 2,'/62( )6+(4-+ &'>-3(&8%(&,'I =4&24 =-+- /-'&-/@ S%3-/ ,' (4- &'),+:%(&,' #$%&'(&)) =%3 %<$- (, +-%3,'%<$. ,<(%&'I =&(4,6( (4- 4-$* ,) (4- /&32,>-+. *+,2-33I #$%&'(&)) ,**,3-/ (4- 0,(&,'3 =&(4 (4- $&:&(-/ &'),+:%(&,' 34- =%3 %<$- (, %22-33@ O4-' (4&+/V*%+(.I ),+:-+ F2&-'(,$,8&3(3 *+,>&/-/ %//&(&,'%$ &'),+:%(&,' %)(-+ (4- 5,6+(73 +6$&'8I 34- )6+(4-+ &'>-3(&8%(-/ (4- '-= ->&/-'2-I )6$)&$$-/ (4- F-2(&,' "BBC +-A6&+-:-'(3I %'/ )&$-/ (4- 0,(&,' ),+ 1-2,'3&/-+%(&,' &' 8,,/ )%&(4 <%3-/ ,' (4- '-= ->&/-'2-@

Reward Your Curiosity

Everything you want to read.
Anytime. Anywhere. Any device.
No Commitment. Cancel anytime.
576648e32a3d8b82ca71961b7a986505