Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THE MAGAZINE OF BARNABAS FUND HOPE AND AID FOR THE PERSECUTED CHURCH
According to the United Nations, two years used to fund various kinds started in these cities [i.e. Mosul and Regular readers of Barnabas Aid will • “Our families owe their lives
only 2% of Southern Sudanese have of teacher training. The programme Baghdad, where the families had settled remember a report last year on aid to the relief. We really thank you
completed primary schooling. This included training for pre-school after their village in Kurdistan was for famine victims in the tiny central very much. We are amazed that
reflects the colossal disruption of teachers, primary teachers, and head destroyed in 1961 by the Iraqi army]. African nation of Burundi. Although
you found our village out of all the
normal life which occurred during the teachers, as well as training in how to Terror gangs with religious and sectarian this famine received virtually no
names appeared and started to kill people attention in the media, for its victims villages in the whole world to help
civil war of 1983-2005. make educational resources. One of
As life in the South begins indiscriminately, especially in the last it was all too real. Severe floods in the us in our time of hunger.”
the parts of the programme assisted
slowly to return to normal, and the by Barnabas Fund’s grants was period as the churches were bombed and north-west of the country destroyed – A village elder
infrastructure is rebuilt, education is training 13 teachers to be trainers of Christian families were threatened and the crops, and to make matters
• “I was almost dying. I had
seen as the priority. The population other teachers. our children kidnapped. This forced us worse there had been drought in
the preceding months. People were nothing to eat or plant but God
of the South is mainly Christian, Reference 48-494 to leave our houses and furniture and all
that we had behind us and seek refuge in beginning to die of hunger. Every loved me so much and He gave me
the north as there is security and stability. day they would come to the church something to eat and plant. I have
SUDANESE REFUGEES – FOOD AND SCHOOLING Barnabas Fund has enabled 20 bee-keeping projects
to be established in northern Iraq, which will provide
The time is changed and Kurdistan region
has become secure, so we returned to our
leaders asking for food, but as one
senior leader wrote to Barnabas Fund,
not enough words to thank you.”
– A mother
The school began the current
an income for 60 Christian families villages in the last two months. Other “we have nothing to offer them apart
families, who get the chance, are returning from prayers. I have urged members • “I brought the food home and my
academic year with 468 students. Two recent grants to countries in
Of these, 111 are at the secondary as well. of the church to collect food for family danced and rejoiced because
very different parts of the world have
school, and the rest attend the We appeal to you to offer any sort of those in need but they themselves we had food.”
gone to fund bee-keeping projects to
primary school in two shifts each day. support as all the families are residing are hungry.” Another church leader – A village elder
help persecuted Christians support
Not only the students, but also now in the village’s school building, which wrote to us that many Christians were
themselves. • “We want to say thank you to
many of the teachers are refugees, is the only building left in the village and is tempted to convert to Islam in order
In a certain country of Central half destroyed. We lack blankets, kerosene to get aid from Muslim charities. Barnabas Fund… the relief helped
so there is a high turnover of both as
A grant of £4,000 (US$8,400; Asia “Samir”, a convert from Islam and food. In this situation, Barnabas Fund give seeds for new crops. Six
people leave for Western countries
NZ$10,800; A$8,800; €5,600) to Christianity, has six children to Barnabas Fund is helping to provide was thankful to be able to send hundred and forty-two families in
or return to South Sudan. Despite
is Barnabas Fund’s most recent support. As a convert, he finds it the basic needs of Christians like this, grants totalling £31,955 (US$63,910;
the inevitable disruption, the school the village received seed and maize
contribution to the running costs virtually impossible to get work, but the long-term solution is to enable NZ$86,279; A$76,692; €47,933) which
has achieved good academic results. for food. Please pray for peace
of a Christian school for African because those who have left Islam are them to support themselves. A grant were used by church leaders to buy
Seven students graduated from Grade for Burundi because this is the
refugee children (mainly Sudanese) in so despised in this society. He thought of £9,500 (US$19,950; NZ$25,650; beans, maize and salt to help 4,868
12 in June 2007, and one pupil has
Egypt. The school provides a feeding of going to Russia to look for a job, but A$20,900; €13,300) is being used to set families. The grants were also used foundation of development. Please
transferred to the top international
programme, giving each student and his pastor counselled him to find a way up 20 “bee farms” each employing three to provide seed to enable a new crop also pray that we can come out
school locally. The staff have also
teacher a hot meal each school day. to start his own small business so that people, thus providing support for 60 to be sown. We are reporting this of our hunger. After the drought
been delighted to hear from students
Many of the children are underweight, he would not have to leave his family. families. This sum covers the hives, again in order to share with Barnabas
who have moved with their families there was a flood, and we want to
and this school lunch is probably the Samir has experience in keeping bees other equipment and some training. Fund supporters the encouragement
to the US and Australia that they have come out of dependency and we
only nutritious meal they have in the and already has some equipment. The cost per bee farm is £475 (US$997; of comments recently received from
been able to keep up well in their new don’t want to keep asking for help.”
day. A school doctor visits twice a Therefore a grant from Barnabas Fund NZ$1,282; A$1,045; €665) and the cost some of those who were helped. It is
schools there.
week to care for the many medical of £322 (US$650; NZ$870; A$708; per family is £158 (US$330; NZ$427; due to your generosity that we were – A village chief
Reference 11-439
needs of the children. €450) was all that he needed to repair A$348; €220). able to assist. Reference 67-681
his 25 bee hives and to buy a swarm for Reference 20-689
4 BARNABAS AID JAN / FEB 2008 MARCHJAN
/ APRIL
/ FEB2007
2007 BARNABAS
BARNABASAID
AID 55
Country Profile India Country Profile
elements clash. In such an uncertain
climate, India’s Christian minority Religions of India (approximate percentages) The Hindu Caste System
is being placed under increasing
Hindu 73% Every Hindu is born into a “caste”
pressure.
or level in society. There are 3,000
Muslim 13% castes and 25,000 subcastes, each
Christianity in India Christian 6% of which is related to a specific
Christianity has a long and rich occupation. There are four main
history in India. According to Ethno/tribal categories, called varnas, into
tradition it was the Apostle Thomas religions 4% which all the castes are grouped:
who first brought the Gospel to India Sikh 4% Brahmins, who are priests
as early as 52 AD. He is said to have Kshatryas, who are warriors
established seven congregations, Non-religious 1%
Vaishyas, who are traders and
before dying in Madras. While the Other (Buddhist,
Jain, Bahai, Parsee, craftsmen
visit of Thomas to India is a matter
of debate, there is some evidence Zoroastrian, Chinese Shudras, who are labourers
universist) 1% It is not possible to change your
for its plausibility; he is celebrated
in the poems and oral traditions caste. Your caste will dictate not
of Christians in South India, and only your occupation, but also
in 1293 Marco Polo described his In the Middle Ages Assyrian At first mission usually focussed other areas of life such as what
tomb as a place for pilgrimage. The Christians were active in spreading on the elites in Indian society, but to eat and how to interact with
modern Mar Thoma (Saint Thomas) Christianity to India, and an Assyrian this began to change as Protestant other caste members. Higher
Some of the needy Indian Christian children caste members enjoy greater
who get an education in a Christian Christians in Kerala state in the south community emerged there. From the missionaries realised that there was
environment, with help from Barnabas Fund
believe themselves to be descendants sixteenth century onwards the first a great willingness to hear the Gospel wealth with their status and more
Roman Catholic missionaries arrived amongst rural people and members opportunities. Discrimination
of the original Christian community
in India, and enclaves of Catholics of the lowest castes (see box for more on the basis of caste is prohibited
India
established by the Apostle Thomas.
were established on the coasts, on the caste system). Various “mass by the constitution, but the caste
In the second and third centuries
itself on the world stage, economically, particularly in Goa. conversion movements” occurred system is strongly embedded
there are reports of Assyrian or
militarily and politically. It is the The first Protestant missionary to amongst them. These movements in Indian society and social
Persian missionaries arriving in
largest functioning democracy in arrive in India is thought to have been often began through local initiative, structures.
India and also from other parts of
the world. However, it is riven by the Middle East. By 200 AD the the Dane, Bartholomaeus Ziegenbalg, with low caste people themselves Dalits
internal divisions and sometimes Syriac Chronicle of Edessa described who began to evangelise in 1706. He seeking out the missionaries. An Occupying one of the lowest levels
seems almost bewilderingly diverse. the existence of a “church of the worked among the Tamils in Southern illustration of this is the way many in Indian society are the Dalits
The population comprises hundreds Christians” in India. So, far from India. By 1733 the first Tamil pastor of the Chuhras came to Christ. (also called “scheduled castes”
I
ndia is a vast country which of ethnic groups, over 1500 languages being recently introduced under was working in the area. By the end They were one of the lowest castes and formerly “untouchables”
is home to more than a billion are spoken, and there are numerous of eighteenth century missionary work in the Punjab area in North India or “outcastes”). Their status
colonialism, Christianity is an
people: one in every six people religious affiliations. India frequently began to expand, through such figures (half of which is now Pakistan). is so low that they are outside
authentic part of Indian culture with a
in the world is Indian. Modern witnesses inter-ethnic, inter-religious as the “father of modern missions”, They followed a kind of “islamised the caste system. Dalits, who
long history, and no less “Indian” than
India is heir to a rich and eclectic and political conflict as these diverse William Carey, who translated Hinduism” which included belief comprise about 16-20% of the total
any other religion practised there.
civilisation which spans thousands in a mediator and the offering of population, have the worst jobs,
the Bible into Indian languages
of years and the influence of Indian sacrifices. In 1873 an illiterate elderly such as toilet cleaning or refuse
such as Sanskrit and Bengali, and
culture permeates beyond the Indian collection. The literacy rate among
several other dialects. Throughout Chuhra called Ditt was converted
subcontinent into Asia. Within India’s Dalits is 37%, which compares
the nineteenth century Protestant to Christianity by a young Hindu
borders three of the world’s major with 57% for non-Dalits. A large
missionaries of all denominations convert. Ditt sought out Presbyterian
religions were birthed – Hinduism, proportion of Indian Christians are
preached and founded churches missionaries who baptised him. He
Buddhism and Jainism. Indian Dalits. When becoming Christians,
throughout the subcontinent. returned to his village where he
history has witnessed the rise and Dalits have often been able to
faced ostracism and rejection, but improve their social position,
fall of many dynasties and rulers Left and below: Indian Christians worshipping
he stayed there and before long but even within the Church there
who have sought to dominate it; for
his family became Christians. Ditt are unfortunately often still the
more than 400 years it was under the
preached the Christian message as he remnants of caste prejudices and
foreign rule of the Muslim Mughals
travelled from village to village selling loyalties.
and the British Raj. While foreign
hides, and a Christian presence grew
rulers have been influential, Indian
in the area. Missionaries became In the modern era Christianity in
civilisation has always retained its
more active amongst the Chuhras India has shown continuing growth.
own distinct identity. It gained its
and thousands of them embraced Christian mission continues to make
independence from British rule a huge impact amongst the Dalits
Christianity.
in 1947. (see box on caste) and also has been
Modern India is a country growing very successful amongst tribes who
in confidence and seeking to assert
Continued overleaf
6 BARNABAS AID JAN / FEB 2008 JAN / FEB 2007 BARNABAS AID 7
Country Profile Country Profile
correlating rise in anti-Christian
Which states have the Which states have the What is Hindutva?
violence in the state. Almost all the
most Christians? most persecution? “Hindutva” (literally meaning states with anti-conversion laws
“Hinduness”) was a term coined are governed by the BJP. However
by Hindu nationalist Vinayak Himachal Pradesh state, which
Damodar Savarkar in the 1920s. It introduced its anti-conversion law
is a philosophy which strives for in 2007, is controlled by the Indian
India to be a single, united nation. National Congress, which is the ruling
It has been criticised for its overt party of the federal government and
communalism, traditionalism is usually more inclined towards
and its negative attitude towards secularism. This is a particularly
religions which did not evolve in worrying development as it shows
India, and which are therefore seen acceptance of anti-conversion laws
as being “not compatible with the by those who are not strident Hindu
Indian social ethos”. It has been nationalists. New accommodation for Christian children orphaned in the
2004 tsunami. Barnabas Fund is covering the costs
particularly influential in Indian
politics since the 1980s. Legal discrimination radical Hindu groups. Very often
they are trying to force converts from
Anti-conversion laws against minorities Hinduism to return to their old faith.
Official measures and restrictions Many incidents are attacks on church
The constitution provides for freedom against Christians are sometimes services or other Christian meetings
of worship and freedom of witness more subtle. An example of this is that and events. Typically the building and
have been excluded by the Indian Christianity has contributed amongst the Hindu majority. Hindu for all faiths. But India has a federal
mainstream. For many years most India practises a policy of affirmative furniture will be damaged and the
significantly to modern Indian society. nationalism has been resurgent in political system, so individual Indian
evangelism has been spearheaded action where places are reserved Christians beaten up, with a special
Christian missionaries established India since the 1920s and from this states are allowed to establish their
by Indian Christians themselves in educational establishments for focus on the church minister. Many
hospitals, schools and colleges all have grown many organisations own laws on some issues. Since
spreading the Gospel. The growth Dalits, but currently Christian and attacks occur in rural areas.
over India. In addition the teachings including the Bharatiya Janata Party the 1960s there have been attempts
of the Church in recent years has Muslim Dalits are denied access to The president of the Global
of faith, peace and goodwill have (BJP) which has been a force in to introduce laws which restrict
been rapid, but there is no precise these places. It is hoped that a review Council of Indian Christians has said,
influenced many intellectuals and Indian politics since its formation conversion from one faith to another.
record of how many Christians currently being conducted by the “Christians tend to be soft targets,
philosophers, finding their way in 1980. The BJP, and other Hindu These are rather absurdly called Indian Supreme Court will lead to this
there are in India. The 2001 census because they do not fight back. Hindu
into the Indian consciousness, nationalist groups, strongly tie Indian “Freedom of Religion Acts” and being changed.
put the number at 25 million, but radicals use them for target practice
including Mahatma Gandhi. The nationality to the Hindu religion. popularly known as “anti-conversion before they go after the Muslims.”
most Christians feel this is a serious
underestimate.
compassionate and serving side of
Thus, the implication is that to be laws”. Currently there are seven Reconversion campaigns Dr John Dayal, General Secretary
the Christian faith is reflected in that states with anti-conversion laws in Hindu nationalists have organised
Just as India is a country of huge Indian is to be Hindu. The BJP and of the All India Christian Council,
a disproportionately high number of place (Rajasthan, Gujarat, Arunchal large scale “reconversion campaigns” has also commented on the violence
variety, so the Christians in India are Hindu nationalists have also sought
doctors and nurses are Christians. In Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, Madhya which aim to convert Christian by Hindu militants. “The pattern of
diverse. The most important divide to undermine secularism in India and
fact it is estimated that as many as Pradesh, Chhattisgarh and Orissa) but Dalits and tribal people to Hinduism. violence indicates a design. The anti-
between them is between those in the have stirred up antipathy towards
30% of nurses are Christians. It is the laws are only actually enforced Ironically these campaigns Christian violence is not the sort of
North and those in the South. The religious minorities. While the Indian in the last four listed. An eighth
also generally accepted that Christian sometimes feature intimidation and communal violence recorded between
majority of Indian Christians – 70% people as a whole display a tolerant state, Uttarakhand, is considering
institutions will tend to give a higher inducements, which are methods that other communities. A tiny minority
- live in the South. Christianity in the attitude towards religious minorities, introducing such laws.
quality of medical care and education Hindu nationalists often falsely accuse is the target and it never retaliates.”
South is very much integrated into pressure from Hindu nationalists is
than can be found in government-run The stated aim of these laws is Christian evangelists of using. He also noted the police’s frequent
Indian culture and society. In many making life much more difficult for
hospitals and schools. to prevent forced conversions using unwillingness to take action against
areas in the South, such as amongst
some of the Tamils, Christianity has
Christians. fraudulent methods or inducements. Militant Hindu groups the perpetrators, even when the
strong roots. Figures such as the Religious liberty This Christian centre will provide accommodation
In practice the laws are mostly used
to prevent the legitimate evangelistic
Amongst Hindu nationalists there
are many who are prepared to resort
evidence against them was plentiful.
renowned Tamil poet, Vedanayakam
Sastri, showed that Christianity and in modern India
for destitute Christians, both elderly and orphans.
Barnabas Fund is contributing to the building costs activity of Christians. Often the laws to violence, particularly groups Islamic pressure
are seen as giving a green light to such as Vishwa Hindu Parishad and India is home to the second largest
Indian culture could complement India’s first prime minister after Hindu radicals to attack evangelists Bajrang Dal. A rapid increase in the Muslim population in the world,
each other. There is also a significant independence, Jawaharlal Nehru, and other Christian workers. When number of incidents of violence or numbering around 130 million and
number of Christians living in the was a champion of secularism and the victims of these attacks report the persecution made against Christians growing. This is a legacy of the
north-east part of India bordering envisaged India as being a country incidents to the police, they often find has been evident since the mid-1990s. conquest of much of India by Muslim
Nepal, Bangladesh and Burma, with where religions were equal and where themselves under arrest, rather than Between 1964 and 1996 there were rulers. There has been a spate of
25% of India’s Christians living there. religious liberty was protected. India’s their attackers. only 36 recorded incidents but now attacks on converts from Islam to
However, the situation for constitution has consistently provided Each time a new anti-conversion there are an average of four incidents Christianity in Muslim-majority
Christians in the north-west is quite safeguards for religious freedoms law is put in place, there is a every week, most of which involve Kashmir, including at least one
different. In these highly populated
since it was drafted following India’s
Hindi-speaking areas, there is a very beheading. It is thought that some
independence. However, secularism of these attacks were linked to the
small number of Christians – only A minister in Goa was beaten up on 10 June 2007. A local Hindu became unhappy that
has never been universally accepted
650,000 amongst a population of 350 his wife had begun attending the church, and he approached the Bajrang Dal for help. Continued overleaf
in India, particularly by some
million. The Hindu husband and 25 Hindu extremists attacked the minister at the church.
8 BARNABAS AID JAN / FEB 2008 JAN / FEB 2007 BARNABAS AID 9
This series of pull-out supplements is intended to provide background information for Christians seeking to understand
Country Profile the nature of Islam and its contemporary expression. One aspect of this relates to understanding the reason for the
oppression and persecution of Christians in various Islamic parts of the world, and another to the growing challenge
PULL-OUT SUPPLEMENT
which Islam poses to Western society, culture and Church.
group Lashkar-e-Toiba, a terrorist A house church sometimes met in
organisation fighting for Kashmir to his home.
PULL-OUT SUPPLEMENT
fear of judgement and hell. After her death the love theme behind the letter in which this verse is so often quoted.
Love in Islamic theology became a dominant feature of Sufism, expressing the Sufi’s Veiled threat Other Qur’anic quotations in the letter have a similar
According to Islamic teaching, God’s essence and nature endless search for unity with the divine Beloved. The On the surface the letter looks like a well intentioned message about the unity of God: [emphasis added]
cannot be known. Therefore a statement like “God is yearning for a love relationship with God was expressed by plea for better understanding between Muslims and Yet there are men who take rivals unto God: they love
love” (which appears in the Bible, 1 John 4:8,16) would be Sufis in the language of human love, similar to the Bible’s Christians, so as to avert an apocalyptic war between the them as they should love God. (Q 2:165).
theologically wrong in classical Islam. Song of Songs and some psalms. Sufi poetry described two largest religious blocs in the world.
Islam does teach that God’s attributes can be known, symbolically the relations between God the Divine Lover If Muslims and Christians are not at peace, the world Say: Lo! my worship and my sacrifice and my living and
and these are described in the form of the “99 beautiful and the human person searching for his love. In addition cannot be at peace . . . the very survival of the world itself my dying are for God, Lord of the Worlds. / He hath no
names”. Love is one of these 99, as we have seen above, to the Qur‘anic terms mahabba and wudud, Sufis coined is at stake . . . So let our differences not cause hatred and partner... (Q 6:162-164)
but only one. The names emphasise much more God’s the term ‘ishq for love. ‘Ishq denotes an unquenchable and strife between us. Hadith quotes support the same theme:
omnipotence and omniscience, his mercy and compassion, irresistible desire for union with the Beloved (God). However, the letter goes on to lay the blame for all The best that I have said—myself, and the prophets that
his sovereignty and inscrutable will. While Sufism used to be found in every branch of wars in which Muslims and Christians are involved on the came before me—is: ‘there is no god but God, He Alone,
In Islam God reveals himself mainly through his law traditional Islam, the strict Islamist reform movements actions of Christians. He hath no associate... (Sunan Al-Tirmidhi, Kitab Al-
(shari‘a) which calls for submission and obedience. While which have developed in recent times have rejected much
As Muslims, we say to Christians that we are not against Da’awat, Bab al-Du’a fi Yawm ‘Arafah, Hadith no. 3934).
in Christianity God is personal and establishes personal of Sufism as pagan additions and innovations which
relationships of love with humans, in classical Islam God them and that Islam is not against them – so long as He who says: ‘There is no god but God, He Alone, He
should be purged from Islam. The concept of love is
is seen as totally self-contained and beyond personal they do not wage war against Muslims on account hath no associate, His is the sovereignty and His is the
downplayed by such movements and condemned as a
relationships. In Islam, although God loves certain Muslim of their religion, oppress them and drive them out of praise and He hath power over all things’ one hundred
pagan, Christian or Western notion incompatible with
people of whom he approves, he is not bound to love them their homes. [emphasis added] times in a day... Sahih Al-Bukhari, Kitab Bad’ al-Khalq,
true Islam.
even if they deserve his love. Ultimately God is not obliged This implies that the war against Islamist terrorism Bab Sifat Iblis wa Junudihi; Hadith no. 3329.
to do anything, but acts as he wills, sometimes in an is a global war of Christianity against Islam, and that
entirely capricious manner. Christianity is the aggressor against Islam (which is
Orthodox classical Islam is more concerned with God’s
Case study: the radical Islamist view). There is no sense of sorrow A hidden message for Muslims
greatness and transcendence, with shari‘a law and its for the wrongs inflicted by Muslims on Christians It is unusual to see Islamic scholars basing their
applications, than with God’s love. God is absolutely other, historically, or indeed currently in many Muslim lands. presentation of Islamic doctrines mainly on the Qur’an
unknowable, far beyond what can be known or imagined An open letter from Muslim leaders There is no recognition that in many places things may alone. Usually the scholars also make good use of
(wara’l wara i.e. beyond the beyond). The role of humans be the opposite, with Muslims oppressing Christians
is to submit, fear and obey God and his law. For example, about love, 13th October 2007 and driving them from their homes (e.g in Iraq, Sudan,
the hadith and a number of recognised methods of
interpretation. Yet the open letter cites only three
following the call in March 2005 by a well-known Islamist To mark the end of Ramadan last year “An Open Letter Nigeria, Indonesia and Pakistan). There is no admission quotations from the hadith in its main text (although there
scholar, Tariq Ramadan, for a moratorium on the brutal and Call from Muslim Religious Leaders” was published, that Muslim actions could have played any part in the are several more in the footnotes).
hudud punishments still implemented in some Muslim dated 13th October 2007. The letter was addressed to alienation between Muslims and Christians. Significantly, all the Qur’anic verses chosen for
states (amputation, stoning, flogging etc.), several Islamic Pope Benedict XVI and 26 other named heads of Christian So an apparently moderate appeal for reconciliation quotation in the letter are ones that have hadith comments
scholars opposed the suggestion. Sheikh Muhammad denominations as well as to “Leaders of Christian actually contains a subtext of warning and threat. and other recognised interpretations which would be
al-Shinqiti, director of the Islamic Center of South Plains Churches, everywhere….”. It is ostensibly a presentation well known to most Muslim readers. In most cases these
in Lubbock, Texas, claimed that harshness was part of
shari‘a and any attempt at softening it was giving in to
of Islamic teaching on love for God and love for one’s
neighbour. (The text of the open letter is available at http://
Expression of Islamic mission (da‘wa) comments and interpretations are more aggressive to
Christians, Jews and other non-Muslims than the stance
Western Christian concepts which were incompatible with Although presented as interfaith dialogue, the letter can
www.acommonword.com/lib/downloads/CW-Total-Final-v- taken in the letter. Selectively quoting from the Qur’an in
Islam. Shinqiti stated that a personalised faith, like that equally be viewed as a classical example of Islamic da‘wa
12g-Eng-9-10-07.pdf) this way conveys a message to Muslims that this is not a
of Christians, leads to corruption and immorality. He (mission). It is a call to accept the Muslim concept of
The 138 signatories represent a wide spread of Muslim letter of appeasement but a call to submit to Islam.
preferred the detachment and severity of Islam, citing the the unity of God (tawhid) and therefore to reject the
leadership from 43 nations and from Sunni, Twelver For instance, the fatiha (Q 1) is quoted in the letter and
Qur’anic verse incompatible Christian views of the Trinity and the deity of
Shi‘a, Zaydi, Ibadi and Sufi backgrounds. Amongst the presented as the greatest chapter in the Qur’an, reminding
And let not pity for the twain withhold you from signatories are traditionalists, Islamists and several liberal Christ.
humans of their duty of praise and gratitude to God for his
obedience to Allah, if ye believe in Allah and the Last Day. Muslims. Some of the signatories are known for their In their stress on monotheism and the unity of God,
mercy and goodness. Included are verses 6 and 7:
And let a party of believers witness their punishment.” moderation and peaceful intentions, while others are the Muslim leaders quote verses from the Qur’an which
(Q 24:2, translation not specified) express the Muslim concept of a God with no associates Guide us upon the straight path. The path of those on
known for their Islamist extremist inclinations. whom is Thy Grace, not those who deserve anger nor
In this view, harshness rather than love and mercy are and no partners – verses which are always traditionally
interpreted as a direct attack on the basic Christian those who are astray. [emphasis added]
at the heart of Islam. The inference is that Christianity is
weak and contemptible because it has love and mercy at its Intended audience doctrines of the Trinity and Christ’s deity. For instance,
Q 3:64, quoted numerous times in the letter, calls the
In Muslim interpretations and commentaries on these
verses, it is explained that those who deserve God’s anger
very core. While addressed to a specific group of named Christian
People of the Scripture (Jews and Christians) to agree not are the Jews, while those who are astray are the Christians.
leaders, the fact that it is an open letter widely
to ascribe partners to God and not to take other Lords Most Western readers of the open letter will not realise
disseminated by the world media means that world public
Love in Sufism opinion is another intended audience. Furthermore,
beside him. this, but for Muslims reading the letter, the meaning is
It was left for Islamic mysticism (Sufism) to try to redress Say: O People of the Scripture! Come to a common word clear: a call to Christians and Jews to avoid God’s anger
certain terminology in the letter, as well as the choice
the balance and introduce the theme of love into Islam. between us and you: that we shall worship none but God, and judgement by accepting Islam.
of Qur’anic quotations cited, indicate that the letter is
Sufism offered an escape from the dry and intellectual also intended for the global Muslim audience. Different and that we shall ascribe no partner unto Him, and that
legalism of the orthodox Islamic teachers and scholars.
It focused instead on the human yearning for an authentic
messages are delivered to the different audiences, a
practice which is frequently found in Islamic discourse,
none of us shall take others for lords beside God. (Aal
‘Imran 3:64) 2
Loving God
personal experience of God. Sufism taught that this The letter suggests that Islam has much to say about
and is permitted according to the Islamic doctrine of In the Saudi-sponsored English Qur’an of Hilali and
experience could be had by a spiritual interpretation of loving God. For example, it quotes a hadith of Muhammad
dissimulation (taqiyya). The message for the Christian Khan,3 this verse has a footnote which quotes the letter
the Qur’an aimed at finding its secret meaning, and by the Muhammad sent to the Byzantine Emperor Heraclius, describing God with a string of Qur’anic phrases:
audience and for the general public is that Islam and
disciplines of asceticism, repetition of God’s names, breath calling upon him and his people to embrace Islam “He Alone, He hath no associate, His is the sovereignty
Christianity are basically identical religions, both focussing
control, meditation and trance. and threatening that otherwise there would be severe and His is the praise”. The letter asserts that each phrase
on love to God and neighbour. But, as we shall see there is
Rabi‘a al-Adawiyya (died 801) introduced the theme of consequences. It may be that a similar frame of mind lies describes “a mode of love of God, and devotion to Him”.
a very different message for Muslims.
Divine Love into Sufism. She longed to love God only for
himself, not for hope of any reward in paradise nor out of 2
The open letter did not specify which English translation of the Qur’an was used for the quotations. 3 Interpretation of the Meanings of the Noble Qur’an in the
English Language by Dr. Muhammad Taqi-ud-Din Al-Hilali and Dr. Muhammad Muhsin Khan, 15th edn. (Riyadh: Darussalam Publishers and Distributors, 1996)
ii iii
A similar assertion occurs at the end of the section apostates are to be killed if they do not return to Islam;
Testimony
PULL-OUT SUPPLEMENT
about loving God. Again the statement that God has Islamic sects considered heretical are to be fought and
no “associate” appears, carrying the implication that annihilated. Thus “neighbour” is a very limited concept
Chrisianity strayed from this by making Jesus an associate in Islam.
of God. Furthermore, the word used for “neighbour” in the
we can now perhaps understand the words ‘The best
that I have said—myself, and the prophets that came
before me’ as equating the blessed formula ‘there is no
god but God, He Alone, He hath no associate, His is the
Arabic version of the letter is jar, a term which carries only
a geographical meaning. It is not equivalent to the Biblical
Hebrew word for neighbour, which is re‘a (denoting
kinship, even as close as a brother or sister). Yet there is
The price for seeking peace and joy
sovereignty and His is the praise and He hath power another word for “neighbour” in Arabic which is closer I was born in Amman, the capital of the mosque again and refused to talk threatened to reject me if I converted
over all things’ precisely with the ‘First and Greatest to the meaning of the Hebrew re‘a and which could have Jordan, one of five children in a well about religious things. to Christianity and to tell the whole
Commandment’ to love God, with all one’s heart and been used. This is the word qarib, which is used in Arabic known and affluent Muslim family. Because of my experiences in the family about me. Even though my
soul, as found in various places in the Bible. That is to Bibles and which more closely translates the Biblical In the quiet neighbourhood where we mosque, I grew up denying God. father was very occupied with his
say, in other words, that the Prophet Muhammad PBUH original. This choice of differently nuanced vocabulary for lived there was a church, very near to Yet for many years I continued to work, he noticed that something was
was perhaps, through inspiration, restating and alluding different audiences appears to be another example our house. As a child I found myself search for Him, thinking, reading happening to me. One day he found
to the Bible’s First Commandment. God knows best, of taqiyya. attracted to the church, wanting to books etc. One day I watched the film me reading the Bible. He took it from
but certainly we have seen their effective similarity in know what was inside the building, “The Passion of the Christ” which me and threw it away, and he pulled
meaning. and whenever I went there I felt a made me cry a lot. I wished that I from my neck a cross which I used to
In this part of the letter it is argued that Muhammad’s Search for common ground peace and joy such as I never felt in could have been on the cross instead wear. He said he would not hesitate
emphasis on the unity of God who has “no associate” is a In seeking common ground, the open letter suggests that my own home. I found something in of that decent man. I went straight to do anything to stop me converting,
re-statement of the Bible’s command about loving God with the central Muslim concept of unitarian monotheism the church which I felt I needed, and from seeing the film to the church, to and he cut me to prove his threat was
all your heart, soul and mind. The letter states that these and the central Christian concepts of love to God and I loved the image of the cross, though talk to Christ, and He explained many genuine.
two concepts are similar in meaning, although this is hard love to neighbour are beliefs held in common by both I did not understand why. So I went things to me. I felt very peaceful that I went again to the church near
to derive from a straightforward reading of the two texts. religions. It stresses that the two commandments to love to my mother, who was very religious, night, after I had spoken to Him. our house to talk to the minister. He
Perhaps the authors of the letter hoped that by simply are the basis of what is common to both religions. But and began to ask her about God. At that time there were many welcomed me, but when I told him I
telling Christians that two different statements were really presenting love to God and neighbour as central to Islam is Of course, she told me her beliefs and problems in my family. My parents wanted to become a Christian his face
the same they would be believed in the same way that a misrepresentation of the truth. urged me to go to the mosque and got divorced and so did my sister. changed and he asked me to leave.
history has shown people can be convinced of nonsensical The message is that if Christians will accept Islam’s read the Qur’an. She was very pleased My youngest brother and I were living I tried several other churches and was
assertions if they are presented forcefully enough. concept of the unity of God (thus denying the basic to see me so thirsty for God, especially with my father and I had a job with rebuffed by them all. No one would
Alternatively they could have had in mind the Muslim doctrines of the Trinity and deity of Christ), Muslims will because my father was greatly a big translation company. I started baptise me. This made me think that
belief that Christian and Jewish Scriptures have been accept the Christian values of love for God and neighbour occupied with his business, with to read the Bible and found myself even God didn’t want me.
distorted, so that Muhammad’s statement is correcting the as central to Islam. Thus a radical revolutionary change travelling and other worldly things. praying , calling my Lord by a new Then through the internet I found
falsified Biblical teaching to what it was originally meant to in Christianity is demanded in exchange for a superficial When I went to pray in the name, “Jesus” and also “our Father”. people I could ask about Jesus, people
have been. change of emphasis in Islamic perceptions. mosque, many questions would come I felt very sorry for my mother who did not know my family. One of
into my mind. Why is this because of the divorce, and also them devoted much time to helping
mosque different from the because she was wasting so much me study the Bible and teaching me
Loving your neighbour • For a full version of Barnabas Fund’s response to
the open letter and call from Muslim religious leaders
church? Why can’t I find time and money organising meetings about Jesus and the church. I began to
The letter suggests that loving your neighbour is a concept joy here? Why do I feel to study Islam and going several have peace again, and during that time
to Christian leaders, 13 October 2007, go to
common to both Islam and Christianity. But it ignores the barriers between me and times on pilgrimage to Mecca. I I had many visions. In one of them I
www.barnabasfund.org/responsemuslimletter
fact the Muslim concept of love for your neighbour can God when I am here? I did thought to myself that we are in a free saw Jesus Himself baptising me. After
only operate within the limited scope of shari‘a. Therefore • For further reading on the concept of love in Islam, not like the talk about country and that Jordan is known as a a few months, the minister I knew
in Islam there can be no absolute love for all humans, as see J. Windrow Sweetman, Islam and Christian jihad and fighting peaceful oasis in the Middle East, and through the internet put me in touch
in Christianity. Islam treats specific groups of people in Theology: A Study of the Interpretation of Theological others, because I had I saw Christians and Muslims living with a church in another Arab country
specific ways: Christians and Jews are to be humiliated and Ideas in the Two Religions, Part 1, Vol. 2, London and many Christian friends peacefully together. who were willing to baptise me. So
brought under Islamic dominion as second rate subjects; Redhill: Lutterworth Press, 1947 especially sections B and I loved them. I So I began to talk to my mother about I travelled there and was baptised on
infidels (polytheists, pagans) must accept Islam or be killed; “The grace of God” and B(IV) “The love of God”. kept asking, is it fair for Islam and Christianity and tried to 27th May 2005.
them to go to hell when get her to face many things Two months earlier my father had
© Barnabas Fund, 2008 they are very good and about her religion. But her died, and my mother had returned to
honest people? One day expression changed live in the family home and started
one of the teachers in the and she bringing women to the house to
BARNABAS FUND HOPE AND AID FOR THE PERSECUTED CHURCH mosque tried to rape me,
but I somehow managed to
Continued overleaf
a Christian
“The government of Saudi Arabia
engages in systematic, ongoing, and These other nine can use their freedom to help the one who is persecuted.
egregious violations of the right to But where are they?
freedom of religion or belief.” If you are reading this magazine, you are probably already aware that
your Bible and Christian What does “being a probably be deported but if you are
from a non-Western country you
• April 2005 – A Filipino Christian
service was raided and Bibles were
Ask your national Barnabas Fund office or the UK office for our free
The Other Nine resource pack. (Addresses on the back cover.)
16 BARNABAS AID JAN / FEB 2008 JAN / FEB 2007 BARNABAS AID 17
Please send me ____ copies of the 8-minute DVD
FAITH AND POWER: A HANDBOOK OF Yes, I would like to help the persecuted Church Gift Aid Declaration
I authorise Barnabas Fund, The Old Rectory, River Street, Pewsey, Wiltshire
NEW BRITISH ISLAM By Patrick Sookhdeo Here is my gift of ______________________ SN9 5DB UK , registered charity no. 1092935, to treat all donations I have made
TITLE Normal price £12.99 Special introductory price £7.99 Please use my gift for
since 6 April 2002 and all subsequent donations as Gift Aid donations until I notify
you otherwise.
Wherever the need is greatest (General Fund) Signature _________________________________________ Date _____________
(+ £2.50 postage and packing within the UK) (Applicable to UK tax payers only)
Other ___________________________________________*
Islam believes itself to be a faith and also recognises that it is a political and If you have previously signed a Gift Aid Declaration for Barnabas Fund, you do not
territorial power. How is this going to be expressed in the UK? Will there be I enclose a cheque/voucher payable to “Barnabas Fund”. need to sign again. To qualify for Gift Aid, what you pay in income tax or capital
assimilation or separation? This book has been written to provide an easy-to-use gains tax must at least equal the amount of tax reclaimed on donations to registered
resource to help non-Muslims understand Islam in Britain today and the way in Please debit my Visa Mastercard American Express charities in the tax year. Please inform us if you change your name or address or stop
paying tax.
which it is seeking to transform the country. Introductory chapters look at what Maestro CAF card /other charity card
Muslims in the UK believe and do, what they have in common as well as the wide Name
range of variation and differences amongst them. There is an emphasis on tracing (Mr,Mrs,Miss,Ms,Rev,Dr)
Number
current movements and trends, in particular the more radical movements which Address
are those likely to have the greatest impact on non-Muslim Britons. Later chapters Maestro issue number or issue date /
review influential Muslim figures who have shaped or are shaping Islam in the Postcode Telephone
UK, and give concise information on a wide range of Muslim organisations active in the UK, showing the inter-linkages Email
Expiry date / Signature ______________________________
between them. A final chapter looks at a range of very specific issues and challenges relating to the subject of Islam
Please return this form to Barnabas Fund at your national office or to the UK
in Britain. Dr Sookhdeo asks penetrating questions about the way in which the Muslim communities in the UK may I do not require an acknowledgement of this gift. office. Addresses are on the back cover. Barnabas Fund will not give your address
develop in the future and how British authorities and institutions appear to be yielding to the process of Islamisation. or email to anyone else.
I would like to give regularly through my bank. Please send me Phone 0800 587 4006 or visit our website at www.barnabasfund.org to make a
Hardback, approx. 330 pages Isaac Publishing
the appropriate form. (UK supporters may use the Standing Order credit card donation. From outside UK phone +44 1672 565031.
Publication date, January 2008 Pre-order your copy now. ISBN 0-9787141-3-X 978-0-9787141-3-0 form below.) Registered Charity number 1092935 Company registered in England number 4029536
*We reserve the right to use designated gifts for another project if the one identified is
Alternative Gift Card To make an alternative gift for a loved one, please sufficiently funded.
STEPPING INTO THE SHADOWS By Rosemary Sookhdeo contact your national office.
Mag 01/08
Supporters in Germany: please turn to back cover for how to send gifts to
Barnabas Fund.
Normal price £6.99 Special price £5 (+ 80p postage and packing within the UK)
This book explores the reasons why so many women are converting to Islam and answers STANDING ORDER For UK supporters who would like to give regularly
many questions you may have about the issue of its attraction to women. The author Please use these gifts by Standing Order for
unpacks and analyses the problems faced in circumstances such as conversion by conviction
or by marriage and addresses the long-term implications of such decisions. Essential Wherever the need is greatest (General Fund) Other ____________________________*
reading for every parent, church leader or pastor to enable them to understand and to To: (name and address of your bank)
educate to prevent such situations in the future. _______________________________________________________________________________________
Paperback, 121 pages Isaac Publishing, 2005 ISBN 9-0-9547835-7-0 ___________________________________________________________ Post code: _________________
How to Find Us
You may contact Barnabas Fund at the following addresses: Australia
Postal Suite 107, 236 Hyperdome, Loganholme QLD 4129
UK Telephone (07) 3806 1076 or 1300 365 799 Fax (07) 3806 4076
9-10 Priory Row, Coventry CV1 5EX Email bfaustralia@barnabasfund.org
Telephone 024 7623 1923 Fax 024 7683 4718
From outside the UK
USA
6731 Curran St, McLean, VA 22101
Telephone +44 24 7623 1923 Fax +44 24 7683 4718 Telephone (703) 288-1681 or toll-free 1-866-936-2525
E-mail info@barnabasfund.org Fax (703) 288-1682
Registered charity number 1092935 Email bfusa@barnabasfund.org
Company registered in England number 4029536 Germany
Chairman of the Board of Trustees: Mr Mike Penny German supporters may send gifts for Barnabas Fund via Hilfe für
For a list of all trustees, please contact Barnabas Fund UK at the Coventry Brüder who will provide you with a tax-deductible receipt.
address above. Please mention that the donation is for “SPC 20 Barnabas Fund”.
If you would like your donation to go to a specific project of Barnabas
Jersey Fund, please inform the Barnabas Fund office in Pewsey, UK.
Le Jardin, La Rue A Don, Grouville, Jersey, Channel Islands JE3 9GB Account holder: Hilfe für Brüder e.V. Account number: 415 600
Telephone 700600 Fax 700601 Email bfjersey@barnabasfund.org Bank: Evang. Kreditgenossenschaft Stuttgart Bankcode (BLZ):
600 606 06
New Zealand
14A View Road, Mt Eden, Auckland 1024
Telephone 09 630 6267 Fax 09 630 6267
E-mail office@barnabasfund.org.nz
www.barnabasfund.org
To donate by credit card, please visit the website
or phone 0800 587 4006 (from outside the UK phone +44 1672 565031).
© Barnabas Fund 2008 For permission to reproduce articles from this magazine, please contact the Pewsey UK office address above.