IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF OKLAHOMA COUNTY STATE OF OKLAHOMA BLED IN DistRicr courr OKLAHOMA COUNTY: DAVID PRATER, in his Official ) Capacity as DISTRICT ATTORNEY) MAR 14 2021 OF OKLAHOMA COUNTY, j ) "USF ALEN Plaintiff, ) Brrr ) vs. Caso GY. ~ ' ) cw QV- 2021-599 y OKLAHOMA PARDON AND ) PAROLE BOARD, and KEVIN STITT, ) in his Official Capacity as ) GOVERNOR OF THE STATEOF - ) OKLAHOMA. ) ) Defendants. ) Bi iON “Traise up my voice ~ not so 1 can shous, but $0 that those without a voice can be heard.” ~ Malala Yousafeai : Itis a call to service every prosecutor has received —a call to make our communities.” safor for our children, to make victims of erinie whole again, and to speck for those who have no voice to speak for themselves.” It is a call 10 see that justice is done, * Always a noble aim, justice does not endl within the walls of the courthouse. So too the work of a prosecutor must go on. To truly answer tic call to service to keep our communities safe and to be a strong voice for crime victims, the prosecutor's advocacy must continue at every step the laudable goal of justice might be threatened. Here, that threat comes from the deliberate subversion of constitutional and statutory obligations by the Pardon and Parole Board.One need look no further than the headlines of the daily news to see the consequences of the Board’s failure to adhere to legal mandates. By now, everyone is familiar with Lawrence Anderson, an inmate whose sentence was commuted by the Governor after favorable recommendation by the Pardon and Parole Board. Yet within mete weeks of his release from prison, Anderson comunitted a shockingly gruesome triple murder — all to which he has confessed. Anderson admitted he killed his neighbor and cut out her heart before cooking it to serve to his aunt and uncle with whom ho was living. Anderson then killed his uncle, stabbed his aunt in both of her eyes, and killed the couple’s four year old granddaughter. At the time of Anderson’s arrest, Grady County District Attorney Jason Hicks voiced frustration with the methodology by which the Pardon and Parole Board gaye notice to prosecutors that Anderson was being considered for commutation, Ex. 1, News Report, The Board’s failure to follow the law with regard to Anderson’s commutation has now led the Governor to cal! for an investigation into the matter by the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation. Ex. 2, Newspaper Article. Unfortunately, Anderson’s case does not appear to be an isolated instance of procedural irregularity by the Pardon and Parole Board. Despite statutory requirements that the Pardon and Parole Board provide to the District Attorney a copy of an application for commutation within ten business days of its receipt, the Board has failed to provide to Plaintiff any such applications. Nor-has the Board provided to the District Attorney adequate and appropriate notice of applications for commutation at the time the same are first considered for relief by the Board. Such blatant disregard for statutory mandates reflects not only a deliberate course of action by Defendant Board, but also impedes the 2District Attorney from carrying out his duty to serve as a victim’s advocate and to see that Justice is carried out, Unequivocally, the Pardon and Parole Board’s failure to comply with their obligation to give notice to affected persons has proven to have deadly consequences. But even more shocking than the danger caused by the Board’s actions are the nefarious ‘motivations behind the decisions they make — the personal finaacial gain to be received by two Board members themselves. Kelly Doyle was appointed to the Pardon and Parole Board by Governor Stitt on February 26, 2019. That same day, the Governor appointed Adam Luck to be a member as well. Ms, Doyle is the Deputy Executive Director at the Center for Employment Opportunities, an organization thal provides transitional employment opportunities and other services to persons being released from prison. Similarly, Mr, Luck is the Chief Executive Officer of City Care, a non-profit organization which, according to its website “inspires those willing to look social injustice and extreme poverty in the face and empowers them to do whatever it takes to create change.” Ex, 3, Website. City Care not aly solicits “activists” to perform volunteer work but also provides services to “judicially involved” persons, Shortly after their appointment, a change in law resulted in the Pardon and Parole Board considering what one news outlet referred to as a “historic” number of sentence commetations that ultimately resulted in neatly 500 inmates being released from prison in November 2019, Ex. 4, News Report. A week before the Pardon and Parole Board was even scheduled to begin hearing the commutation requests on November 1, » 2019, Mr. Luck 3Publicly proclaimed, “Next Friday Oldahoma will conduct the largest single-day commutation in US history. We'll be releasing over 400 individuals from, Oklahoma prisons who are there for crimes that no longer catry prison sentences after the passage of state question 780.” Ex, 5, Twitter Post 10/24/19. In what smacks of self-dealing and Open Meeting Act violations, he continued, “The legislature made the law retroactive with HB 1269. The pardon and parole board worked with suate agencies, nonprofits, and service providers from across the state to ensure these individuals have the resources they need as they transition back into our communities.” Bx. 5, Twitter Post 10/24/19. By no mere coincidence those nonprofit and service organizations included the Center for Employment Opportunities, Ex. 4, News Report. District Attomoys across the State have sought recusal of Ms. Doyle and Mr. Lick based upon the conflict of interest created by their employment that directly beselits from their actions as members of the Pardon and Parole Board. Even more recently, Mr. Luck hhas_been requested to recuse for personally promoting the work of other high profile activists seeking a sentence commutation in a case currently under review by the Pardon and Parole Board, Bx. 6,Rocusal Request, Yet, despite the efforts of prosecutors to ensure the Pardon and Parole Board conducts its affairs impartially as mandated by the Oklahoma ‘Constitution, the Board has turned a blind eye to all concepts of fairness and. justice, ‘ Ttswould not be th first timo the Pardon and Parole Board skirted its obligations fo give appropriate public notice of its actions tothe desriment of crime victims and those who advocate for them. See Oklahoma Parole Board Members Charged with" Misdemeanors, (March 13, 2013, 5:39pm), _ttps:/www newson6 cometary {Sede ]$9e00960774635284P/lethoma-parole-boand-members-charged-with-misdemeanors 4To protect the sanctity of the criminal process and to guarantee appropriate due process snd fundamental fairness to the victims and those who advocate for them, the District Attorney now seeks injunctive relief barring Defendant Pardon and Parole Board from considering any request for commutation until such time as. statutory notice mandates are followed, barring Defendant Pardon and Parole Board members from ‘voting on any roquest for parole and/or commutation for which they have-a conflict of interest or the appearance:of bias, and further barting Defendant Stitt from granting any recommendation for parole and/or commutation that has been tainted by these improprieties of the Pardon and Parole Board and its members, JURISDICTION L This Court has jurisdiction to consider and grant Plaintifi’s request for declaratory end injunctive relief pursuant to Title 12, Section 138 et seg. and Section 1651 et seq. PARTIES AND VENUE ~ 2. Plaintiff David W. Prater is the duly elected and acting District Attorney for the Seventh Prosecutorial District of Oklahoma County. Plaintiff's principle place of business is in Oklahoma County. 3 Defendant Oklahoma Pardon and Parole Board is a body created by Article VI, Section, 10 of the Oklahoma Constitution and charged with the duty “to make an impartial investigation and study of applicants for commutations, pardons or paroles...” Okla, Const. art. VI, § 10. Defendant's principle place of business is Oklahoma. County.4. Defendant Kevin Stitt is the duly elected and acting Governor of the State of Oklahoma and is named in ais official capacity, Upon a favorable recommendation by Defendant Board, Defendant Stitt is empowered by Article VI, Section 10 of the Oklahoma Constitution to commute the sentence of any offender. Okla, Const, art. VIL § 10, Defendant's principle place of business is in Oklahoma County. STATEMENT OF THE FACTS 5, . Defendant Pardon and Parole Board is made of ‘up five members, Kelly Doyle was appointed to serve as a member of the Board by Defendant Stitt on or about February 26, 2019. Adan Luck was appointed to serve as a member of the Board by Defendant Stitt on or about February 26, 2019, 6 Board member Kelly Doyle is the Deputy Executive Director at the Center for Employment Opportunities, an organization that provides services to persons released" from incarceration. By virtue of her employment, Ms, Doyle has a direct, material financial interest in cases of parole and commutation under her consideration as a Board member. 2. Board member Adam Luck is-the Chief Executive Officer of City Care, a nob-profit organization that provides services to persons released from incarceration, By virtue of his employment, Mr. Luck has a direct, material financial interest in cases of parole and commutation under his consideration as a Board member. 8. Defendant Pardon and Parole Board may only consider an inmate for commutation of sentence upon receipt of an application requesting commutation. 57 O.S.Supp. 2019, § 332.2.9. Defendant Pardon and Parole Boerd considers requests for commutation ia a two-stage process. Olda.Admin.Code § 515:15-11-1. 10, During the first stage of the review process, referred to as “Initial Review” Defendant Board reviews only the inmate's application for commutation. If'a majotity of Defendant Board members vote to give further consideration to the application, the matter is passed to “Stage Two.” Olkla. Admin.Code § 515:15-L1-1. 11.1 During “Stage Two,” Defendant Board considers the application, an investigation conducted by Board employees, and allows personal appearances by the inmate, the inmate’s delegates, the victim or their representative, and “trial officials” to include the'District Attorney. Okla:Admin.Code § 545:15-11-3 — 15-11-5. 12. Ifa majority of Defendant Board vote to recommend an inmate be granted a commutation, the application is forwarded fo Defendant Stitt for consideration, Okla. Const. art. VI, § 10; Okla.Admin.Code § 515:15-11-1. 13, |. By electronic. mail dated February 22, 2021, Defendant Board notified Plaintiff of a number of commutation requesis to be considered for “Initial Review’ beginning March 8, 2021. Ex. 7, Hmail. Attached to the electronic mail is a spreadsheet listing 474 inmates to be considered for commutation. Ex. 8, Spreadsheet. ‘The spreadsheet alone does not provide adequate notice of an inmate's application for comnuutation as is required by Section 332.2 of Title $7 and deprives Plaintiff of « meaningful opportunity to make a decision on whether to make objection to an inmate’s commutation application, 14. The electronic mail dated February 22, 2021, does not comply with the requirement of Section 332.2 of Title 57 that Defendant Board send to Plaintiff any 7application for commutation and be given “twenty (20) business days to provide a written recommendation or protest prior to consideration of the application.” 57 0.8.Supp.2019, § 332.2 (C). 15, Among the commutation roquests to be considered by Defendant Board during the March 2021 Commutation Docket are inmates convicted of egregious and/or violent crimes including: Murder in the First Degree, Robbery, Kidnapping, Rape, Child ‘Abuse, and Trafficking in Iegal Drugs. Ex. 8, Spreadsheet, 16. Prior to the electronic mail notification received on February 22, 2021, Plaintiff did not receive from Defendant Board copies of the applications for commutation withia ten (10) business days of Defendant Board’s receipt thercof as required by Section 332.208) of Title $7. (7. On February 12,2021, applications for commutation to be considered by Defendant Board for “Initial Review” beginning March 8, 2021, were included in the otlline database, Ex. 9, Directory. 18... The applications for commutation to be considered by Defendant Board for Jnitial Review during March 2021, are not segregated by county and appear only-in alphabetical order by inmate name. Ex. 10, Subditectory List. 19. , Bach application for commutation is a minimum of eight (8) pages in length and is made‘on a form created by Defendant Board. Okla.Admin.Code § $15:15-11-1, The form application includes information that is otherwise unavailable to Plaintiff from other sources including an inmate's account of their offense and the grounds they believe warrant sentence commutation. Often inmates include evidence of their accomplishments while 8incarcerated as well. Tn addition, the form requires an inmate to attest to the accuracy of ‘the statements made in the epplication under adverse penalty. Ex. 11, Form Application for Commutation, 20. A total of 474 applications for commutation were set for “Tnitial Review” for March 2021, Of the 474 applications for inmates set for “Initial Review” for March 2021, 114 are applications of inmates convicted in Oklahoma County, which total over 1,500 pages. 21, By undated letter postmarked February 12, 2021, Defendant Pardon and Parole Board notified Plaintiff of a number of commutation requests that had been reviewed as part of “Initial Review” by the Board during the January 2021 Commutation Docket. ‘The letter purports to comply with the notice requirements imposed upon Defendant Board by Section 332,2(C) of Title 57. Attached to the letter is a spreadsheet of cases considered and Defendant Board’s determinations as part of the “Initial Review” as to each inmate for the January 2021 Commutation Docket. Ex. 12, Letter 2/12/21. 22. ; The undated letter postmarked February 12, 2021, purports to advise Plaintiff of his right to object to the consideration of any inmate for commutation at the April 2021 meeting of Defendant Board and states that, “If a written protest or recommendation is not received by April 64, it will be presumed you have no position on the offender's commutation application,” Ex. 12, Letter 2/12/21. 23. . Among the commutation requests purportedly considered by Defendant Board during the January 2021 Commutation Docket are inmates convicted of egregiousand/or violent crimes including: Murder in the First Degree, Robbery, Kidnapping, Rape, Child Abuse, and Trafficking in Megel Drags. Ex, 12, Letter 2/12/21. 24, Prior to the undated letier postmarked Febreary 12, 2021, Plaintiff did not receive from Defendant Board copies of the applications for commutation within ten (10) business days of Defendant Board’s receipt thereof as required by Section 332.2(B) of Title 57. 25. The spreadsheet of cases attached to the undated letter postmarked February 12, 2021, lists a total of 241 inmates and does not identify the county of conviction for each inmate considered by Defendant Board for the January 2021 Commutation Docket; thus, the letter and attached spreadshest provides no adequate notice to Plaintiff of inmates being considered for commutation. Ex. 12, Letter 2/12/21. 26, The undated letter postinarked February 12, 2021, purports to advise that access to an inmate's application for commutation may be accéssed by online database, Ex, 12, Letter 2/12/21. The database, however, does not contain applications considered by Defendant Board for the January 2021 Commutation Docket. Ex. 9, Directory. Thus, the databese does not provide adequate notice to Plaintiff of inmates being considered for commutation and deprives Plaintiff of a meaningful opportunity to make a decision on whether to make objection to an inmate's commutation application, 2 By undated letter postmarked February 26, 2021, Defendant Pardon and Parole Board again notified Plaintiff of a number of commutation requests that had been reviewed by the Board during the January 2021 Commutation Docket, ‘The letter purports to comply with the notice requirements imposed upon Defendant Board by Section 10332.2(C) of Title 57, Attached to the letter is a spreadsheet of cases considered and Defendant Board’s determinations as part of the “Initial Review” as to each inmate for the January 2021 Commutation Docket, Ex. 13, Letter 2/26/21. 28. ‘The undated letter postmarked February 26, 2021, purports to advise Plaintizt of his right to object to the consideration of any inmate for commutation at the April 2021 meeting of Defendant Board and states that “If a written protest or recommendation is not received by April 6M, it will be presumed you have no position on the offender's commutation application.” Ex, 13, Letter 2/26/21. 29, . Among the commutation requests purportedly considered by Defendant Board during the Jaquary 2021 Commutation Docket are inmates convicted of egregious and/or violent crimes including: Murder in the First Degree, Robbery, Kidnapping, Rape, Child Abuse, end Trafficking in Megal Drugs. Ex. 13, Letter 2/26/21. 30, . The spreadsheet of cases attached to the undated letter postmarked February 12, 2021, lists a total of 241 inmates out of which 64 have been convicted in Oklahoma County. Ex. 13, Letter 2/26/21. The spreadsheet alone does not provide adequate notice of an inmate’s application for commutation as is required by Section 332.2 of Title 57 and deprives Plaintiff of a meaningful opportunity to make a decision on whether to make objection to an inmate’s commutation application. 31. ‘The undated letter postmarked February 26, 2021, purports to advise that access to an inmate's application for commutation may be accessed by online database. Ex. 13, Letter 2/26/21, The database, however, does not contain applications considered by Defendant Board for the January 2021 Commutation Docket. Ex. 9, Directory, Thus, authe database does not provide adequate notice to Plaintiff of inmates being considered for commutation and deprives Plaintiff of a meaningful opportunity to make a decision on whether to make objection to an inmate’s commutation application. 32. Upon information and belief, Defendant Stitt has before him for consideration applications for sentence commutation for which Plaintiff was deprived of adequate notice and a meaningful opportunity to object prior to being recommended for commutation by Defendant Board, 33. Upon information and belief, Defendant Stitt has before him for consideration applications for sentence commutation for which Plaintiff was deprived of a fair and impartial hearing prior to being recommended for parole or commutation by Defendant Board. FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION — VIOLATION OF SECTION 332.2 OF TITLE 57 AND DENIAL OF PROCEDURAL DUE PROCESS. 34, ‘The allegations contained in parageaphs 1-33 are adopted and restated herein, 35. ‘ Article IL, Section 7 of the Oklahoma Constitution guarantees the right to due process of law. Okla. Const. art. IL, § 7. This encompasses the right to procedural due process aimed to protect against arbitrary government action. Taylor v. City of Bixby, 415 P.3d 537 (Okla Civ.App. 2018). 36. Recognizing the crucial role prosecutors play in ensuring community safely and protecting victims’ rights, the Legislature requires Defendant Board to provide to the District Attorney adequate notice and an opportunity to respond fo a request for commutation being considered by Defendant Board. 1237. Section 332.2 of Tide 57 provides: “Any consideration for commutation shall be made only afer application is made to the Pardon and Parole Board pursuant to the procedures set forth in this section. ‘The Pardon and Parole Board shall provide a copy of the application to the district attomey, the victim or representative of the victim and the Office of the Attorney General within ten (10) business days of receipt of such application.” $7 0.$,.Supp.2019, § 332.2(B). 38. Section 332.2 of Title 57 provides: “An application for commutation ... muust be sent to the trial officials, who shall have oventy (20) business days to provide a ‘written recommendation or protest prior to consideration of the application, Trial officials shall include, ..the current elected distriet attorney of the jurisdiction where the conviction was had.” 57 O.S.Supp.2019, § 332.2(C). 39. Defendant Board has violated the plain and unequivocal mandates of Section 332.2 of Title 57 by failing to provide to Plaintiff timely copies of applications for commutation upon their receipt and by further failing to provide copies of applications for commutation at least twenty (20) business days prior to their consideration by Defendant Board. 40. Defendant Board's failure t0 provide timely and adequate notice of the applications for commutation to be considered hes deprived Plaintiff of a meaningful opportunity to have notice and an opportunity to respond to commutation requests as is guaranteed to him by statute and the Oklahoma Constitution. 41, Defendant Board’s violation of Plaintiff's statutory and constitutional right to adequate notice and an opportunity to be heard impacts not only those applications under 13Initial Review and Stage Two review by Defeadant Board, but all affected applications currently under review by Defendant Stitt, SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION — VIOLATION OF STATUTES, ETHICS RULES AND DENTAL OF AN IMPARTIAL TRIBUNAL, 42, The allegations contained in paragraphs 1-4 are adopted and restated herein, 43, Article VI, Section 10 of the Oklahoma Constitution directs that, “It shall be the duty of the Board to make an impartial investigation and study of applicants for commnmtations, pardons or paroles...” OklaConst. art. VI, § 10. 44, Section 332.2 of Title 57 provides: “Applications for commntation shall be given impartial review as required by Section 10 of Article VI of the Oklahoma Constitution.” 57 O.8,Supp.2019, § 332.2(H). 45, Oklahome Bthies Rule 4.4 provides in relevant part: “Except as permitted by law or these Rules, a state officer ar employee shall not use his or her State office (1) for his or her own private gain, (2) for the endorsement of any product, service or enterprise, @) for the private gain of a family member or persons with whom the state officer or employee is afftiated in a nongovernmental capacity, including nonprofit organizations af which the state officer or employee is an officer or member, ot (4) for the private gain of persons with whom the state officer or employee seeks employment or business relations.” Rule 4.4, Misuse of Office, Title 74, Ch. 62, Appx. I, (2021). 46. Oklahoma Ethies Rule 4.7 provides in relevant part: “In the event a state officer or employee ... knows that a particular matter involving specific parties is Ukely to have a direct and predictable effect on the material financial interests of the state 14officer or employee or of his or her family member or... deterraines circumstances would cause a reasonable person with knowledge of all the relevant facts to question his or her impartiality in the matter, the state officer or employee shall not participate in the matter unless he or she is required to do so by lav or permitted to do so by these Rules.” Rule 4.7 further defines a “material financial interest” to include, inter alie, “any source of income derived fiom employment, other than compensation pertaining to the office for which the state officer or employee or his or her family member holds, in the amount of Twenty ‘Thousand Dollars ($20,000.00) oF moze by the state officer or employee or his or her family member.” Rule 4.7, State Officer Impartiality, Ville 74, Ch. 62, Appx, 12021) 47. One or more members of Defendant Board have a material Financial interest Jn the eases under their consideration for parole and/or conimutation which require them to reftain from participating in the matters before them, 48, Circumstances cause a reasonable person to question the impartiality of one of moze members of Defendant Board in the eases wader theit consideration for parole and/or commutation which require theta to refrain from participating in the matters before them, 49, Defendant Board has filed to develop appropriate proceduses to heat and determine challenges to a member's impartiality, 50, . Defendant Board has failed to consider and determine one or more challenges toa member's ability to hear and determine issues related to parole and/or commutation, 1551. Despite an awareness of existing conflicts of interest and appearances of impropriety, Defendant Board has allowed one or more members to continue. hearing cases for parole and/or commutation. 52, As a result of impeumissible conflicts of interest and appearances of bias by one or more of its members, Plaintiff has been denied his right to an impartial investigation and consideration of applications for commutation by Defendant Board. RELIEF REQUESTED 53, Declare that Defendant Pardon and Parole Board has violated statute by, failing to provide Plaintiff with adequate notice and a meaningfil opportunity to be heard on applications for commutation, 54, Direct that Defendant Pardon and Parole Board henceforth provide to Plaintiff « copy of each and every application for commutation within tea (10) business days from receipt. 55. - Enjoin Defendant Pardon and Parole Board from giving consideration to any application for commutation which has aot been preceded by proper statutory notice to Plaintiff to include a copy of the application for commutation and a minimum of twenty (20) business days to respond thereto. 56. Direct that Defendant Pardon and Parole Board adopt appropriate procedures to consider and adjudicate a challenge to a member's ability to hear a maiter in a fair and impartial manner.Declare that Defendant Pardon and Parole Board member Kelly Doyle has a 57. material financial interest in the cases of parole and commutation before her for consideration. Declare that Defendant Pardon and Parole Board ember Adam Luck has a material financial interest in the cases of parole and commutation befors him for 58. consideration. 59.» Declare that a reasonable person-knowledgeable of all of the facts and circumstances would believe that one or more members of Defendant Pardon and Parole Board appear to be biased in determining the cases of parole and/or commutation that come before thei. 60, Declare any recommendation for parole or commutation in which members Doyle and/or Luck have participated. to be-invalid and in. violation of the Oklahoma Constitution, statutes, and rules of ethics. 61. 5 Enjoin Defendant Stitt from giving consideration to any application for commutation recommended by Defendant Board which has not been preceded by proper statutory notice to Plaintiff to include a copy of the application for commutation and a minimum of twenty (20) business days to respond thereto, 62. , Enjoin Defendant Stitt from giving consideration to any request for parole or commutation recommended by Defendant Board for which Defendant Board failed to act upon a challenge to a member's ability to hear the matter in a fair and impartial manner,63. Enjoi Defendant Stitt from giving consideration to any request for parole or commutation recommended by Defendant Board in which members Kelly Doyle and/or Adam Luck have voted. 64, _Allother equitable relief to which this Court finds Plaintiff entitled Respectfully submitted, ISTRICT ATTORNEY 320 Robert S. Kerr, Suite 505 Oklahoma City, OK 73102 ‘Telephone: (405) 713-1600 Fax: (405) 235-1567 dprater@oklahomacounty.org CRATERS’ MAR 11 2021 RICK we eRe Ey 1871° WATCH NOW KFOR Afternoon News LOcAL Families of Chickasha triple murder victims ask why suspect was released from prison before allegedly committing murders by: Austin Broasetto Postod: Mar 1, 2024 40:10 PM CST/ Updated: Mar 4, 2021 / 40:20 PM CST CHICKASHA, Okla, (KFOR) - Amid heartbreak and anger, the families of three Chickasha triple murder victims are seeking answers Wednesday after the alleged suspect was released from prison on a commuted sentence just weeks before the murders, Exhibit 1“He ruined everything” said Taranzo Pye, the father of 4-year-old Kaos Yates and son of 67-year-old Leon Pye, who were both murdered, “He ruined my whole life? “(The Oklahoma State Pardon and Parole Board] have failed to do their job in protecting Oklahomans,” Brooke Burris Wofford, the cousin of Andrea Blankenship who was also murdered, said, Parents speak out following death of 4-year-old daughter and 67- year-old grandfather in Chiekasha double-homicide -— 42-year-old Lawrence Paul Anderson was a free man for less than three weeks before he allegedly went to a complete stranger's home. According to court documents, Anderson stabbed Andrea Blankenship and cut her heart out. He allegedly then took the heart to his uncle, Leon Pye's home where he cooked it and tried to feed it to his family. Then, Leon Pye and Kaeos Yates were both stabbed to death, Delsie Pye was also stabbed ia both eyes but survived. The families are nearing one month since the logs of their loved ones, “Everyone's still in shock? said Haylee Blankenship, Andrea Blankenship’s daughter. “For me right now it's just like random bursts of sorrow’ said Tasha Yates, the mother of Kaeos Yates. : Exhibit‘The families said they are also trying to figure out why the state pardon and parole board voted 3-1 to release Anderson on a commuted sentence. ‘The decision was then signed off on by Gov. Kevin Stitt. “As a result of that, unfortunately three innocent people have lost their lives; Burris Wofford said. OSBI investigators helieve suspect killed 67-year-old Chickasha man & granddaughter after killing their neighbor —> Anderson's criminal past is extensive, He wes originally sentenced to prison in 2006 for attacking his girlfriend and pointing a gum at her. He went back to prison in 2012 for selling crack cocaine near an elementary school. Anderson was sentenced again in 2017 for having a gun efter a felony conviction and smuggling drugs into jail. “We have put politics and releasing inmates in front of public safety; Grady County District Attorney Jason Hicks said. “Phe goal that we have set in Oklahoma is to decrease the prison population with no thought of public safety” Hicks blasted the decision Tuesday. He said that Anderson's application for a commutation was put in with 600 other offenders hoping to be released, “It’s too many? Hicks said. “You don't have the time to look through those things and give any meaningful consideration? Blankenship’s family said they have tried to get in touch with the governor and the pardon and parole board, However, they have not had any luck, Gruesome details released: Suspect in Chickasha triple murder facing multiple charges, death penalty ‘absolutely on the table’ — Exhibit 1“Those two individuals have not been helpful? Burris Wofford said. KFOR tried to help. We emailed the governor's office a week ago working to get a statement. We were unable to get one due to the winter weather coming through the state. We emailed again Monday but received no response. We also called and emailed Steve Bickley with the pardon and parole board but his phone went straight to voicemail, We did not receive any response to the text messages. ‘The Pye family’s attorney, Robert Wagner said the family held their funeral services Saturday, He said they also have several questions regarding Anderson's release. Anderson's first appearance was Tuesday, February 23. He is being housed in the Grady County Jail facing 3 counts of murder in the first degree and one count each of maiming and assault and battery with a deadly weapon, Exhibit 1THEOKLAHOMAN Triple murder leads OsBI toparole hoard aes . Ehoor eee =e 2 Set penser Seemann death toll is about tojump posure & |e | MTG BAN ie a e0 ip iiD Sees ou ‘Texas becomes biggest US state to lift mask mandate Sroetince Ehnee Meeteeawoar. Smet Rebs ade Seattle gees ‘MIBOKLAHOMAN — faieasiatiecccieaancN NT cases ee ‘onpian 2sicetimersy Seager Lite Adam Luck Sonneries =e)+ Oklahoma's First Lady Welcomes Commuted Workers ‘To Centennial [louse oo ve on es? Oklahoma's First Lady Welcomes Commuted Workers To Centennial House ‘Thursday, November 1dth 2019, 10:20 pin By: Bonnie Campo. Its been 10 days since Oklahoma's historic commutation. Approved by the Okla Exhibit 4 huips:/www news9.com/story/5e346d3e527dcf4 9dadéd8de/oklahomas-first-lady-weleomes,.. 3/5/2021“Oklahoma's First Lady Welcomes Commuted Workers To Centennial House homa Pardon and Parole Board, nearly 500 inmates were released from the Okla- homa Department of Corrections, With a record, many ex-cons knew it would be hard to find work. But some of ‘those who found the Center for Employment Opportunities (C.E.0), landed in the governor's backyard. Sarah Stitt, Oklahoma's First Lady, welcomed them to the Centennial House the morning of Thursday, November 14. “It’s not just a job. I's an opportunity to have ¢ different life, The ball is ultimately in your court. You're making that choice, and sometimes that choice is the hard- est thing,” said Stitt “I have been praying for everyone that was in that commuta- tion.” ‘The crew rolled up their sleeves and went to work. C.E.0. helps all people, but the company saw a unique opportunity to help those who were recently released. It provides a short-term plan to reach long-term goals. ; Lids : “This is a way to build references, | can say they show up every single day, 7 a.m. and they work harder than anyone | have ever seen,” said Sam Eagleson, Director of the Center for Employment Opportunities. Many of them won't stick with manual labor, but it’s one of the best places to start. . ~ One of the inmates to benefit was Raquel Wilkerson. He said he served 22 months in prison before he was released. “lhad a 9-year suspended sentence because my criminal history was extensive. | did six years on probation, but | caught another charge, which was a petty larceny charge, and they convicted me of that and revoked my whole probation in full, Exhibit 4 htips://www.news9.con/story/Se346d3eS27def4 Mdad6d8de/oklahomas-tirst-lady-welcomes.,. 3/5/2021* Oklahome’s First Lady Welcomes Commuted Workers To Centennial House and | was on probation for possession of marijuana,” said Wilkerson. “I knew bet- ter than what I was doing.” Wilkerson said he picked up his bible and tured away from the mistakes he made over the years, He admits his criminal history is long. But, at 42 years old, he is looking ahead for the first time, and he likes what he sees, “Thanks to C.E.O,, | had a job before | got out of prison. They called my mom and told my mom | had an interview, and she said, ‘My boy coming home?’ Laughing, she was ecstatic. | really don't want to disappoint any of my family," he said. About 25 percent of those released from Oklahoma prisons find themselves back behind bars, according to ODOC. The hope is these programs will bring that down. Read Also: Man Released in Oklahoma's Historic Commutation, Arrested Days Later The Oklahoma Pardon and Parole Board said they are working to better monitor their role in the process. ODOC reports they will be tracking inmates to see their progress concerning re- cidivismn, Exhibit 4 hupsu/wwwrnews9.com/story/Se346d32527def4 Sdad6d8de/oklahomas-firt-lady-weleomes.... 3/5/20214) Adam Luck @AdmLuck Next Friday Oklahoma will conduct the largest single-day commutation in US history, We'll be releasing over 400 individuals from Oklahoma prisons who are there for crimes that no longer carry prison sentences after the passage of state question 780. ‘Largest commutation’ in U.S. history expected in Oklahoma Nov. Exhibit 5‘Largest commutation’ in U.S. history expected in Oklahoma Nov. 1 | readfrontier.org 3:18 PM - 10/24/19 . Twitter Web App 203 Retweets 28 Quote Tweets 606 Likes QO a g a& Adam Luck @AdmLuck- 10/24/19 = Replying to @AdmLuck The legislature made the law retroactive with HB 1269. The pardon and parole board worked with state agencies, nonprofits, and service providers from across the state to ensure these individuals have the resources they need as they transition back into our communities, O4 te © 4Bchibit & é iReplying to @AdrnLuck The legislature made the law retroactive with HB 1269. The pardon and parole board worked with state agencies, nonprofits, and service providers from across the state to ensure these individuals have the resources they need as they transition back into our communities. Oa tis Ow hy Adam Luck @AdmLuck 10/24/19 += This vote will take place next Friday, November ‘st, at 11:30AM at Kate Barnard Correctional Center in Oklahoma City. Our meetings are all open to the public. G2 tle © Senibit shOKLAHOMA COUNTY SEVENTH DISTRICT STATE OF GSLAHON 1200 ROSERT 5, KERR AVE, SUITE 60 ‘ORLAMOMIA CITY, OKLAHOMA 72102 (303) 75-108 aK (452554587 DAVID W. PRATER DISIRICT ATTORNEY JIMMY B, HARMON, [RST ASSSTANY DISTRICT ATTORNEY March 4, 2021 ‘Adam Luck Pardon and Parole Board Member 2915 Classen Blvd., Suite 405 ‘Oklahoma City, OK 73106 Dear Mr. Luck: As District Attomey for Oklahoma County, | write to request that you recuse from consideration of the following case currently scheduled for review by the Oklahoma Pardon and Parole Board on the March 2021 Commutation Docket: Offender Julius Jones, DOC #270147 (Oklahoms County Case No. CF-1999-4373), ‘You have publicly demonstrated your personal bins in rogards to this case. On October 17, 2019—two days after Offender Jones submitted his commutation application to the Board—you used your personal Twitter account, @AdmL.uck, to “retweet" & post by one of Offender Jones's most high-profile advocates, Kim Kardashian West (see Oct. 17, 2019 Tweet, attached; related . ‘Tweeis by Ms. West, attached). You made clear in your tweet that you were speaking as “a board . member.” In Ms, West's message, which you appear to be endorsing, she asks her followers to “{pliease help” by expressing their support for Offender Jones's commutation by contacting “the a Board and @GovStitt.” This same post that you shared with the public also refers the reader to the Twitter account @justicedjulius, which proclaims itself 10 be “The OFFICAL page of Julius Darius Jones, a wrongfully convicted inmate currently awaiting execution on Oklahoma’s Death Row” (see Twitter page, attached), and the website Jasticefordulius.com, a site created to advocate for Offender Jones's release from prison and to solicit donations from supporters for that cause (see Homepage, attached) The laws and regulations of Oklahoma provide clear guidence regarding the conduct expected by the members of the Oklahoma Partion and Parole Board. Impartiality ise fundamental and legal obligation for a Pardon and Parole Member, The Oklahoma Constitution, the Oklahoaa Ethics Rules, and even the Values listed on the home page of the Pardon and Parole Board website, mandate impartiality:CONSTITUTION “It shall be the duty of the Board to make an impartial investigation and study of applicants for commutations, patdons or paroles, and by a majority vote muke its recommendations to the Governor of all persons deemed worthy of clemency.” OKLA. CONST. VI, § 10 OKLAHOMA ETHICS RULE 4,7 “In the event a state officer “dotermines circumstances would eause a reasonable person with knowledge of all the relevant facts to question his or her impartiality jn the matter; the state officer or employee shall not participate in the matter unless he or she is required to do so by law or permitted to so by these Rules.” 74.08. § Rule 4.7 PARDON AND PAROLE BOARD VALUES “The Pardon and Perole Board strongly believes and is committed to the ethical, unbiased, and professional performance of duties and will continually strive for excellence and faimess by makiag decisions that maintain a delicate belance between public safety, victim’s rights, and the successful re-integration of the offender.” hiips:/iwww.ok.govippb/ ‘Your actions unmistakably give rise to the appearance of impropriety, if not outright ity. By publicly endorsing a call for Offender Jones to be rocommended for commutation by the Board upon which you sit, itis evident that neither the murder victim’s family nor the State of Oklahoma ean receive fair consideration by you in this eommutation procoeding. This request for tecusal is made to ensure that al! parties in the justice system are heard and can be afforded an impartial review by the Pardon and Parole Board. Itis my hope that you can tecognize your ethical and legal duties to the citizens of Oklahoma and will make the decision to voluntarily withdraw your consideration in this case, Respectfully, ie David W. Prater Oklehoma County District Attorney Jason Reese, General Counsel to Governor Kevin Stitt ‘Tom Bates, Executive Director of the Oklahoma Pardon and Parole Board Kyle Counts, General Counsel to the Oklahoma Pardon and Parole Board Exhibit 6 ceLutz, Shelly. From: Jennifer Pardo Sent: Monday, February’ 22, 2021 12:24 PM To: Lute, Shelly Subject: FW: March 2024 Attachments: March 2021 Administrative Parole Dockat POSTpd; March. 2021 SIR Parole Docket pat, ‘March 2021 Stage I Commutation docket Post.pat Match 2021 Perdon Docketodi, March 2021 Parole Docket pdf; INVESTIGATIVEREPORT._MERGED-32021,pcf From: Jennifer Pando Sent: Monday, February 22, 2021 9:42 AM To: Matthew Xehoe Subject: FW: March 2021 From: Jennifer Pando Sonts Tuesday, Fabrusry 16, 2022 9:31 AM. ‘To: Timothy. Webstar@dac.state.okus Subjects FW: March 202% Good morning, | have attached the parole dacket and reports for March 2021. ~. Please be advised we must receive DA Protest Letters no later than March 2, 2021, by 5:00°p.1 «Please email ail protest latters to daprotest@ppb.ok.gov. Hf you choose to appear, please notify the © PPB's administrative office of your intention to do so no later than Briday, March 5,202 by 4:00 p.m.. Respectfully, Jermifer Pando ‘Victim Coordinator Okdahoma Pardon and Parole Board 2915 N. Classen Blvd,, Suite 405 Oklahoma City, OK 73106-5436 Offfice: (405) 521-6600 Fax: (405) 602-6437 Website: wwvw.0k.gov/pp> CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization, Do not click links at open attachments unless you have contacted the sender and inow the content is safe and was requested by you, Exhibit 7raha RANORS fons us a ba crestor iat cs wer sor cou fassen a er oct wr sr orc SEW sore wi een Mara HoH asl ec Remerr sear ot Exhibit= ee ot z= = wares osor amma = [See a [= lane ——fowarat rams esi —}— Pitan z fstesy ese soour a} —?— fa Ee a fae err cans gat —t fe - z ist ee ama = epee Iwateaceretnart —t— fier = tags ——fineszoneatanart —t — ft = ‘ipsa sen —T~ [ow = aes fausesceur are] 2 — loi = fit asi crewman —t— len coubrantpesaee| 3 — fot ist orcnraawn —1 fee —| Tarr Se —1— for aca enn, —1— fee rea faa ctno seat —¥— fen at [amo ant ea] —1— sy [ovcu isa el —1— fas Sareve ier —¥ ~ nice renee! —* Jomo fete Be “fete eat wind 3 — fae = se as Sr coarosswn| tere [3 fos sea fer sem Jensen 3 — . eer ase frase rot carers Rt — wate : “4 [ron —esvwriney kale it -Auro Arete 1 over fet mu heuer seed is Peak —— ee as nie [niente elf on bese lester cayrot wing ~ Be - Exhibits,; Prints Peters" ecromoncna —?—Joasc & amiss fu orn) ose = a coe eel ——2— fou eat = = fest eel — 5a s Bae lean] —$ a a fssoreseren| = Sse a Esta anaes ——> Ee (reas fous Tes ora = Fe [ea eer mount —F = a eee es (anvastinincrat —t 2 fae ioe feet ——[ewarncinset —> erate z sibs cour —t fescue favors = fra rapa —t a poussss ~~ recseroar — [ois ——fawamoesicep —P [avers —[swemoccirresp—> fase [rvemncani —p fess ——[aerorceanetig > ensis Ion ott fsa Innate —> cea aoa —t fam arene Exhibit 8‘ifn [a sm —~re stor meer | “Ea 5 oust eviae ji sop aric orn} — 3 — Bihar 2 2a gat [ip tem ra — 1 — a Paes — [user jan fs Ineosveme sat — i — ey “efits sen cc ites Ss eave] tats ae feare face (alfa oR EC, tar poate [ee fs utara one, f—forraa eae fon fest “ea san wae car at —3— fore uy Janet fom hi enya fer orcigeniewnt 1 —- fess —| Ho Daigo Sarl — 1 fe iba i aan ee = Ser — [ewan — fee a fy fous! "——~Totagierinel ip ca fant faust fenpictensumed + — freee i fy fates ——“resres iea tre [te ae fees iacrausor, feeb 35 faut seat —[aisvct Insane > bra fur Sgrnar —jnisvat aco pereer st —> fates infuse = Fears —— =e isis fires faire eal — 1 [foe —feee, [Bstay — pvesnsr Sarasa ‘ef ~lear tes — fetes i we Sof loam [evan parses [earn roel o-oo fen es — fee (oar wc an| TH ens—foseae Fissie [ts ——Jonatiteoonoel frases i a 7 Exhibit 8eee oe TORE 7 Toa 18:5 onsale Saf sie ner ove —1— [Sees Faro a a ror aoc Wal —1—~Iaitans fay — fey fe reconeorual Tens Kner rionslel tains oar oes ed te — fur ireanesTae| —E ater — fra ios resale —T c reery fires recone reer oe te ratiwe onsarTal — = a [sxrreye aomlt —t = Saree pest acer] rae ouged——— note acens| 7 * or fae jeworswesm er = ia cm [parry Tr i Gitomer Poet brorenrorcer sel —r 3 isren pate, fauna rset — a Ns [acsearoceoaied "3 ze cs ste aed [oe = [startet ie se 3 Biba 3 Picts Bs Fee Be vrais ero = esa Faber neuer BE Be [rata fat set Jos pice esr a er [ese — oe Eencaiaeoy-s Roeser esta fase lowing ELLOS 1 fsete oot lwasie isp rasan oreo a fs aot i (Feiner Exhibit 8Se fur erronecsot — feta lees rose tea fe ha isc one tise les (ares inte Wer ines — fa lanier (srr — [anor [ssrocorsswrg—t fender — [ans lasrorenuoswnd —t as onsors| —_T aes fer (ea 8 OFFA (seer Taare easreeeee] 7 Te a Teaver oat ‘Miya eaters ry za ste] 1 "olin ertiea foe tr reba fe poise [ore isrseter tt —T ast Jur aahee at —> pears aco aH] Exhibita ra EEE] ae Sian [sates Tea las ww sort] —1 Jee [eee err Foe fav [ewisousmeonyel = — fev Tease frais Pie fears i wastiine wt 1 uta ar atses egies [pees ssa eouinoartoveal 1 lone presi [vd Noa suai Joupamnei es) | "1 fre penal Porat gd fis angs looted =F leewnownneen| “fee leouesnensow | —1— fase ie i lees] [Sn ee] —4— fot aon We 1 — [os BEAT Wot 3 — [Ten Jeo aovs rst] 3 — Journ feswiaous ree] “1 — Jovan Grams ands — fee] jesuraou acme] fear ssc spe] 1 fea (oe a fesraran ese jd 3 fee ye] “fein roves 9 fee feces euawnl| =~ Jara Pett ae uae] ~~ s—Jors lowttnsie orsan| —z—[oteuges | : cua worenrs rl —F— [eta une weet femtsens [3 feawseorase— [2 feo sear asp|—[ a Fee aaeoutat > jewssotest Pt Exhibit 8Ea peas eee nfo forse Jeon z faa: [caster asuie) Sonata —P fea fee afer TE ORONT fee nis [wena —— Teast aor rr —P rato fea pester roman Sear open besser Tian [ean —Jeourerne sol leit es sass —fersaiss ~~" oor nowt —F Taser je ——~ a [asrorco.oswoR—e tas pam [say — tae [wien vierorane—F fa Seat — fare Tara axon —t les at feet (ouhaces oad a fe iam Pere jaune reneeairnt mr fea Perce ce eu fa fia — pata (aeneryesroN—T Late 3 gla lancet ow Tol = last Totes oem 7 {umsronseo wef 1 fae iagrosveate stout re Tae ngwaxatio—[—T ha (anwar aE —T Exhibits[rst ae lassi pisos [mei {Eanes 54" oras — forte faci — pastes bss apsaram!—i—favnaen | psa? jer fone pss ——faerer aertnd —2 [ee feo ie fans oan af Tee a — [a lewis ral —1— [Sera 57 fps foe fer ararsressnyat —1— [sro ir or aso WM fen ia jar ronet| 2 — cen is To fisroremesrat — feast = et ie [Sen momar —t [ore] 38 ~foimenncta| ease —| = [ss facet eer ey > se [eres —— fast erent — 3 i [ses aare ——Fsouweeste wiak —t ie fests furtacs——— foot 5 — rca iis |eteae—— Eorereererenon| iS [sae [teas ———~ few] i [ane [ens parry = ‘er ise fess aan a Sl 1 ie cass fuatsacoraen eri a — fro = fetes —"—faasa aor ea aoe i fires asa enntineet —s— esa i hes “ass wontatael 1 — fens i (yee etait) soar i il rar [pa aes ten Bxhibit &= Eee fe eae = 2. 22 — pe eee a Lie [astor cross wad“ ea eet ee Bee a = ee ae = — ee Exhibit 8[sa eee [sae ts [sam Fine — faa iat eT [omy — [esse foun antes fete foie jt lant — [an pumas fesse ——hanasucner wet fesasat——fuaaaus ta fas is ot - fea owen —t bara rare at —P feaan peepee —> eee caaouer ed —t Saeeorea —t soornaerirol ra Tae eo fact lnemenane a i Jost cour lostor rao um foster cour fpsror cours ror oH [awe leita are fee Hs oes a RREEER| any Beet EF a Exhibit 8aa aa rT “ese ae Tansreccitrera, — 3 —faraa ae seat ———[pepene ran fase, a sn atsance mea —1— fast iso oa a ee esse tase —_frisrss—~ jeseinrannew fase - Sasa ma oar ag Leura [ans fae fe [nsasar ——esanrajocaar ri lous sent —— fais = Safar Iss ran fae a s_[ sur —[anee pea 1 fai Seta ina ornare Ee Sle let Sasa = [afar Lat SOREN Soe ae aa atta ake Tecate Soca iE set (sss eb clffefafafofraffeletet toll |-fulalafclalsbalafefsfets fale [xan (aca [she ora pest | Then ies ait arora ie bene feat bere aris wl ra “wa iswae Donte Fst Sraar co zs foo ft fe as fre so Kaen ar ene for fase: ——frsesse [nto Su fear 3 jeew pac Daas fesse ——eprorcearcas wl a aap after iterate foto Sika fei Saar soe Ta Sharif [rece bares ese Tae Exhibit 8eae pe reer —T ar [reife fastest ——Tsvonscenr nan |e er sees "leper —| > To; tear ———Je apart —[ 3 fra [exces srs losrorcishoss Wal —3~ Io fates Iueavatnesewsr| —1 fea peter Iasi orere| > [ata petri ari crene] —T— fate [es peso beet cme] [ess ies srerwo| —7 ie fines — fate pte ponirre sweet “fr ae eer eestneseer|—1 “Tea tw Ibe sans Jocervne wes “| —1 [Sa ae he ase lroverieusier ai| —1-— [seen Be te fit see last ord — Ta auf lteny frre a $e [ras fea (ene fea [eames] 3 — [onan Exhibit 8[parce aE [em vee os [Men oRet fom ua, coureuns aL box EST SOMES ass Tlost oresrsw Incosseoe sr Ieocreonc ours tre fis nse ese oECD Wo Ww fewraens rea oF coro IESE P00 alata Laren at rommenscco heh co i or enero ExhibitaR [eae Easton Foiyramsproaet oe coufouth CRT [areata fesse be lazessst [vera ee spate a} ala | fearEius aoa firs ot Prstenajitieis josrercearcas Wel DEeeaces eas leaTaoecntao inne Bainccont roe (awa acces a nSECe PDH LDaRWVEE (asus len [eatieranroic} eee efsteheefeulinfefeljfefshfaef fal tof rfofefefahc helo uff ela ff Exhibitsi eter cara a aera Ea lester cara a Sawa ee [ours a Tua rsoea [ares — fines inane waar pe iso OSS WN fey bossa ce ey isang “purer courosrn re espe conan paar] enn besese eas rs foc psa anon . = Levee rot fewer ferns Levene ree [Siero fewsraecy rea en aoa as tee ee jae rea efor 7 ae Keay fran OF cos fara re Rasa i eee favre oH 3 area (als [uss four 25 [rar fener ee oe feat fe (sty Fs famosa PST ‘31 [eases ——fesen fe ossck ono ‘2_[row Jat (heer fea eer Eahibit 8= oo = a = [Bes ——[ st > a — eet — es a ee ee oe eee | oo eee Le ——paas eat ie beg eee a ee — a oe a a fee jon fs eee aes ine —Baseger am) ae - Exhibitie ene Sree te fer a Lied ae ee on a laasoar eet ca — = = re fie — fens [eter ners = fe —fca —— [eatery a ee eee . = eee —— ae = pee ee Eel sae an a Exhibit 8some ora ese] —s— jean ~~ fauar-sciend Tu jean sare soul is nee peeoer-wcomnod 16 las ne asta | Was | pause leyeuer-gescod ie Tn Posen re seel — 3a res [vairsssowst i [ae [se "——fvarscre e Esc kvomcesirersral 1 Pn, [eoeorsesorep] base [ueskce monet fats losvearwnn stor [ sas fosigox unsere fsisaas Jeoneen ca aro 3 Exhibit 8‘am — ueuatonpaat teehee fan au rasowaton [ier tra femme | > ea ae Tost feet) —| ef cE asst —— 1 ane fe cia ora} | jane — er urease] —1 “ea fies finer fern al —t— aaa fg — fauna its hav sas| ncn [sie ——faranna a Sa pasar ie Para fame Tse Txt — -iesstek aL er Tee Joan creases] i Sion ind fas ga off a fared four curs pret] "Saar fia —Ebtedens ———Tostor rr [ras | Ted [atest Im orcpes iat — feos Rapa Ios wal —1 — Fert fe — Fane teresa i pane [Css Tiss ‘Safer fespeskhesiaah 1 —pecm [fase ose ‘sis — fore facebecamiotor| Tp Sa fees fee Paeicaeatol 1 Paneer or pro et [recreate Sfp ies ances “Fras oxen [2 fos | Sepa — art ise ——areess eno pa] $f = ie ie — bia ee | EI owe — ape (la ——— Jom oer —~P—faea awa — ta eee —femasuer raed ame Sees Steno tat [aor ie fs cer [aren pcos fits [ators ones se Tecan Teint ie Exhibit 8se [es ia OFA We Sree — pas eT eae N ESR arf fe ls csaress wot FECT ewes I cme — Taurine care mer=ef Sauee i Levene eal — Lewes Pace fe awesome rat west“ a eget meat — Bi fare wert —e 2 Jaco “fsa rst ta Svnon reed a fae [ae fare hat 6 ceo a a fares — ae fst fs 70 [espncecet reat iy 3 _Joue Fee Ie Inurcerersroesra] 1 ifs — [re ge s orcnabose aint au fs faa lassie lesreramsrest ot “y 3 fous res isi fe execu —¥ stew? — as fasts se_—Towanzrcu) | s_ [nos ft ings ae son onasctsui (2 orf) —[ Isnoey —poissoe Irene est ns Hie Tas Pos emReg ime ke foe os orcaurnoinaet—r Fxhibit 8ata [ne fnnere et —p 54a sam fnwan com ona —> free ase Tose homey seoowes —P forsale Some eT [sors ——~cogecnenesered— far ait [coo er ts erst Ic 2} — fess [ar rea # eater [arses ——~ orcas —t [Stone fener — fa jure-ras gare Gt tein Tears aurrze fect socou fos] 3 esos frost seoatesocs [smaate pas Sense [arses [eeaat——t —fa tata jastorenrerrwn) —~t— festa - ‘|p leurs rewrel —}— foie aot ty ir ashosmn owe sear bat parce orc) 1 lta fs — [re [i ruben fresco 1 ra - ‘a3 pase —[aeeat ese gan asi meust fea frig fae ana fsa iratheamoee | —1—[oe* sts — [piesa las or enue 1 iiss Tae joven wing fe Exhibits[asa RAT ie [tor casas eye (arene Prnse fora [aE aR ATF [omar —_— Powe foe scan ef ea Hest fs ew bee ——~ [canner eT aera wee! Wave sa FAS fae ets sav a Taeorwawnit oat kor finpaus et —[ ExhibitEee pes ei a-ha — a see ee ee ean aoe 2 eee bee eee ee = Sx — farses ——-feeerrarst —— Hse [fies ae le [eos oo eat — ee ee ee ae oe thee a —— fee fee —— fae dees estes eat a eee Ee a : aes —— peta te [astern — fest si jasc crsbcs: want 2 eae aoe ree a . es an see te eee : jae — copes a eta ees : a a eet Exhibit 8ra ae ie a Pa ee] To tale fe fessor paste | > age Sa [asa ——]sved—— oun Te jae — ami [ee Co ese —uter lesrer feos orroeaess| 1am Fess fetter — saan ~—feamra werent —3— set basse fae fener fern es Ween > — Fee “a — faa Esane——lusnecrrine te > jose “st sss fe Favre ——Lororcamoss wet a — fabs Tat pasta fer fires year gona, —1— lor ee feet foes Fauxiscnmt 1 foo zo ———~ eb sa " - a iubal—Ysteout lene aie 11 fat pessous fossil I fee eae stawae| — pe Hepp loses] 2 fee ieee fee Deer trast ——paver wnrssart| “3 ne sae fete renters cams Wiacead —t— basi sare rae guy paris} ere mudi? — fn - sae Tw (ssn laser Tes tarteme unt 1 tsar [ee Tag Hse Wal 7S Si fine—fge Tatas sea ota tf [oe tisat fates dgractnoes —1 — mia ‘or [eens fins "et purua fname 1 fr Ese — fe at rio sor fas “fife — Ye ohare pieced —?— [ora i fee few |esay os orcas tent niet - sre fe Diet Jaiese————“Trareon eee “2 vers | lee eae “ettaet———Taronettaaa)—? st Exhibit 8FIP root et ocfip.oklahomacounty.org Page 1 of L FTP root at ocftp.cklahomacounty.org To view this FTP site in File Explorer: press Alt, click View, and then oliok Open FLY Site in File Explorer. 91/22/2021 32:00AM Directoxy 1-202 12/16/2020 12:00am Directory o1/a5/2021 12; 008K Dinectory February 2024 Stage 1 Commutation Applications 02/12/2021 08: 34aN Directory March 2031 Commutation Stage 2 Considerations 02/12/2021 08:26an Directory March 202i County 01/28/2021 12:00an Directory Magch 2021 spacial Commutation county 01/18/2021 12; 00m Directory March 2021 Special Stags 1 comutation vations 02/12/2021 98: 42nK Bixectory Marsh 202A Stage 1 Commutation Apstlostione ‘pyfochp oklehornecounty.org/ Exhibit 9 sjs001FIP divectory /Mazch?4202021%205tege%420420Commutation%20Appliontions/ at ooft.. Pago 1 of 9 FTP directory /March%202021%20Stage%201% 20Commutation%20Applications/ at ocftp.oklahomacounty.org To view this FTP site in File Explorer: press Alt, click View, end then click Open FIP Site in File Explorer, Up te higher level directory oa/az/2021 266,305 Abla, Meliaca 830705 (1) pa 92/12/2021 231,038 Abner, Bryan 669383 (al) “pat 02/12/2021 376,701 Raaie, “andes qOS03S “Uh oes 02/12/2025 08:26am 893,090 addtagtans deahas SELSSP Tay spat 02/12/2024 08:30 200,770 Aguirce, Clara 7eilNi (7) pet 02/12/2021 98+30a 259,222 Aquizre, Omar 793308 (TY par 02/12/2021 08:30AM 248, 256 albazado, Margaret 617395. (3) pat o2/iz/z021 808, 205 Rloxander, Grends 701307 (7) pdr 02/12/2021 £10,471 Alexander, Reginald sugoel (6) pas 2/12/2021 “363, 408 Alfred, “Wiieell 117602 G31. 02/12/2021 283, 022 Allen, Bakoderisi 667908 Ci}epade o2/1z/2001 247,090 Kionzo, Antonio 765071 (3). pak 02/12/2021 517/884 Knarel; teene 812153 (2) ape 02/12/2021 284,878 Andrews Sr, Addzhony 644459 (6) par 92/12/2021 291,017 Rrnstrong, Clan 835500 (é).pee 02/12/2021 3,782/877 AsborEy, Shasse-eI9205 | eat 02/12/2021 190, 102 Atkins, Beeiion 50864) G] pat oa/iz/2021 676,981 Rytla, “Tensei 240070 (ZA) pat e2/ig/a0e 2,255) 113 faker, Cathy TLIStE 6 SB) oe 02/12/2021 204, 327 Baker,” Rwanain 701640 () sae o2/12/20a1 $98,112 Raker, Michael 212598 (14) pa? o2/i2/2021 2,016,021 Baker, Tamora 78546 (2 epi o2yia/20at 231, 098 Beldctrome Fase RTE ADOT (7) par 02/2/2021 226,933 Rallard dz, Wiohael 110831 (23) spd? 02/12/2021 190,814 Ballentine, asian 751480 (is) .pae 02/12/2024 (14605 Sevba ve ustier Tage The Beale 02/12/2021 219,042 Barfelz, danse T7566 CH} pir 02/12/2021 3,506,320 Ratnete Til, Jonah 268d" (15) par 02/12/2021 443,480 Batnett, Randet 276289 (0),pdt a/a/a02: 626,43 Bashan, Raber TSN Ca oe 02/12/2021 £19,526 Hatchelor, Gary 735164 (7h pdt 92/12/2023 239,230 Hates. Je, Aipnadas TIST4¢ ols pde 02/12/2021 831,110 Hoaky, Vincent Tested (ay pa 62/12/2021 1,210, 66¢ ellie, Stacy 179650 T/-par 02/12/2021 $46,435 Beltran Juan 719265" (7) pd 02/12/2021 759,299 Bench, Jeremy 399683 _(8)-pat 02/12/2021 989,293 Bennett, Anthony 746341 {s) pat 02/12/2021 276,514 Bennett, Jazanine 634020 6.pa" 02/12/2021 257,078 Benton TEI, Louls O37@18 Gi) par 02/12/2021 316/052 BlackwStl, Wena #33401 (ay -par o2/i2/2024 1,594,202 Bladss Je, Marvin 601124 (14) spat o2/12/2021 957/040 Blair, “Sewel 218971 (7) pat o2/i2y2021 219,037 Blevins, Kayla 352457 (15) 5 oz/i2/2021 268,383 Blocker, Edwar 700346 (4) ple 02/12/2021 242,051 Bobannan, Charles 576035 (6).pat 92/32/2024 708,239 Bosnentaup, Gabeta? 170056 Gh car 02/32/2021 249,011 Bouse, Andtew 553165" (14) .pat 02/22/2021 360,013 Bownan Roy L 39281) 02/12/2021 220,992 Boyking, Antonio 1195).(7) .pae Exhibit 10 Fipilocfip oklahomacounty.org/March”%202021%20Stag0%2019620Comuuutation%s20Appli... 3/5/2021FIP directory /March?4202021220Stage’4201%420Commutation?20Apptications at ov... Page 2 of 9 02/12/2021 92/12/2021 o2/i2/2021 02/42/2021 o2/12/2021 92/12/2021 oayia72021 02/12/2021 02/12/2021 02/22/2021 02/12/2021 02/22/2022 02/12/2021 o2/12/2o21 02/12/2021, 02/12/2023, 0/42/2021 oarie/2021 o2vaz/2021 02/42/2021 o2/az/2021 02/22/2021 02/12/2071 ozsra/2o2t o2/i22021 02/12/2023 02/12/2021 02/12/2021 02/12/2021, 02/12/2021 eayuzsao23 02/12/2021, o2yt2s2024 oa/i2s2021 2/12/2021 02/12/2021 02/22/2021 92/12/2021 02/12/2023 ea/ia/aoz1 02/12/2021 02/12/2021 02/12/2021 02/42/2021 02/12/2021 oa/12/2o2t 02/12/2021 02/12/2021 02/12/2021 02/12/2021, 02/12/2021 02/12/2021, 02/12/2021 02/12/2021 o2/i2/2021, 02/12/2021 92/12/2021 o2/az/2ozt 02/12/2021 02/12/2021, 08: 26m os: 50aN 96:36am 08: 26M 08 : 308m 08: 30am 08:26am, 03: 2684, 08: 30am 08:26am, 08:26AM 08:26AM 08: 30am 08: 26AH 08:30am 08:30AM 08: 30ate 08: 30a 08: 30aN 08: 30RN, 0:26am 8:26am, 0823004 98:30AM 08: 30a 08:30AM 08: 26am 08: 30m 08: 26 08: 26n0e 03: 30a o8:z6am 08:26am, 00:26am 08:30am, 08:26am 08; 30am 08: 268M 08: 26m 08:26nM 08:30am 905,693 Zozwozbh, Steven 774050 (14 520,043 Branson, Johnnie "823750 (25, 235,963 Byasvelly Kennech 757405 {id et 208,180 brevet, Wehaal 0 EE Col cae 266,673 Brokat Briteanl Tee? [To eae 298/198 Brookes ponela 84050" 4] Ate ‘183,341 Brown, Paul 374072 (T).pat 1,036, 248 Brown Fong 2008s Torys 722,46 Brunk, Rattan SoGe ae 623,000 Suoushan dorsy 25700 (Er se 234,641 unten, Sobny ASIETE Ta) oat 657,786 Dupkaolls, ChrIataphar OSeT6 (6) pat 104,430 Surne IIE Sesste Tora aay 606/331 oxy 88090022) Bar 198,657 Buauety canon 72685) “Ry ae 278,198 Buster Ti, Wiaiel THTGT Ty pat 206; 058 Calgwels,“Toest Sue0T Lay cae 322,995 Genalag,“Laonog Tasaet~ (ayaa 495,118 Geanony Seaver SBr61) (Se 2,145,107 Gane, Seovo 1/8390 Thee) ct 591,023 Corday Gezenao BS2000" Cite 245,238 Ghanclon, writes THT ter pat 171 665 Ghavey, Joshua Te 760s Tar 169,070 Ghapaai Mishasl eleTS Cas 11,988, 893 Shaman Saglane,“Zonntfor JRE (7) pak $, 956,105 Chariton Jr., Clarence @7ag7s (7 spat 371,890 Gheadie, “Darryl a1s570 (7) GaLi4o. Chetetnae, Tenty a0agnr TTS) par 226,008 Clazy, Morty SHS) Ga ee 1,290,545 Gluthc Spencer TTT eT aE 670, 601 Cobps" Ges Christan Cer The, pdt 184,595 Coleman, Gwnalick 653996 (27) pat 159,326 Collins, Rob 780705 (7) par 3,248,720 Compollosbes; Gery T8316 (25) .par 7,070 Conpton, Leave 231501 (7,24) pat 830,294 Connywordy, Andve 310787 (5) pat 166,944 Cook, Anthony 173498 Cay. pdt 325,809 Cooper, Mary 469293 (a) par 984,033 Gornolious, Hancal 217273 (19) .pat 264,749 Cortez, Tonge] Oz0170 [10] par 254,076 Cottonhan,” Christopher 77052 202, 653 Greker jr, Steven 380507 (28) 308, 634 Geockelt, Kristina 790807 7. pat 138, 978 Erouge, Jimmy 403008 (ey pa 7,526,150 Grow, Brant 363596 (7) par $75,832 Gras, Christopher 1786090 (29) .pae 1,322,454 Cunmiigs, “Gustin 740459 (12] -paF 846, 627 Comings, Karisce TORE Tea 2,505,974 cumsiiss Brian iase10 iT. ae 704,366 Curiisa, Bon 057534 (7) .pade 731,975 Cusey, “Jezemy 249318 (1) paz sad, 451 Gasucky eres SoO7e The 207,057 Danteisy Melba 541460 (7) pat 665, 404 Davila Christopher 39044 (13) .pat 187, 634 Davie, Anthony 234980 (7) pdt u74, 914 Davis, Dawaiahis 453916 (7) pat 24,920 Davis, Marcellous 663906 [7}.paé 1,117,875 Dawson, Gens 608556 (20 par 448,396 Deaver, brian 574205 (20}-pdt 217, 526 Begase,” Chandon 826159 (27) .pat Exhibitio Aipifocttp oklahomacounty.org/March%202021%208tage%201%20Commutationy<20Appli., 2/3/2001FIP directory /Mareh¥2020211420Siege?s202420Commutationy<20Applicationy at out... Page 3 of 9 02/12/2021 08: 30mm 02/12/2021 08: 30aK 02/12/2021 08:30aM 02/12/2021 08:26am 02/22/2021 093 26R% 02/32/2021 o8 1zénat 02/12/2021 08:26aN 02/12/2021 06:30KM 02/42/2021 OB: 30R 02/2/2021 08: zen 02/12/2021 0B: 26am 02/12/2021 08: 268M 02/12/2021 08:26am 02/52/2021 o8:2eq 02/12/2021 08: 26ai5 02/12/2021, 08:26am 02/12/2021. 08:268M 02/12/2021 08:26AN 02/12/2021 08:26AM 92/12/2021 082260 92/12/2021 oa: 30m 92/42/2021 08: 26m 02/32/2024 .083 308% 02/42/2021 ov 02/12/2021 08 02/32/2021, 99:30n oa/iz/ecat oB:26mM O2/32/2021 08:30AM 02/12/2024 90: S0aK 02/12/2021 08: 26m 92/22/2021 08: 31aKh 92/42/2021 08:26AM 92732/2021 08: 31aN 02/12/2021 08:26am 02/12/2021 08:31am 02/12/2021 ‘be 131aM 02/42/2021 86 20am 02/12/2023 08:31am 02/12/2021 06:26AM 02/12/2021 08: 260M 02/12/2021 08: 21mM o2/i2/z021 08 31M 02/22/2021 G8: 3iam 92/12/2021 00:31AM 92/12/2021 8s SINK 92/12/2021 08: 26uH 92/12/2021 08: 260M az¢ie/20a1 08: 31K 92/32/2022 oas20nm 02/12/2021 08:27AM 02/22/2021 Oe:27mM 02/12/2021 Of: 275M 02/12/2021 08:27AM 02/12/2021 08:27am 02/12/2021 08:2734 02/12/2021 08: 310M 02/12/2021 08:27AM 02/22/2021 00:31AM 02/12/2021 09: 278% 789, 550 78,300 298, 656 1,076,539 1,081, 638 212,129 540, 460 4,176, 658 383,228 127,300 398, 262, 3,819, 446 307, €39 zed, 203, 694, 555, 1,242,253 212,925 1,289,276 347,001, 972,560 341, 636 152,008 862,302 316,831 225,573 138,093, 594, 482 958,547 792, 502, 192, 432 263,779 238,348 976, €39 213,954 815, 587 297) 226 497, 608 865,012, 418,075 198, 386 482, 068, 274, 262 659, 543, 187, 990 2,811,052 233, 656 212,307 396, 600 219,232 321,208 1,758, 144 711, 836 45,221 6,814,543 892,089 2,042,240 176,120 35%, 995 224,128 688, 093, Denny, Robie 650134 (13) pot Dergon, Curtin 463893 (i) par Devino, Joseph 773649 (21) vadt Dickens; Christopher Mf, 417829 (14) .pae Dickey, Ferry 631091 (7), pat Bozal, Tusa 673638" (yapdt Drake Jr, Mickey 799230 (74) pat Drenery, Bonnie 269558 (7) pdr Duford, Hilldan 451237” (24) pat Bye, Henry 787956 OL) ede Bliioct, “Donald 624123 (9) pat Ellie, Mitonio 465034 (14) spade Bagalante, Yvonne 758447 (i) pag Espinosa, Gevoning §11071 (2) -pat Espinoua, Luis Cazlos 745155 (7) ;pat Hypinoza, onaldo 413409 (1) pat Faizclott Kodi 726281 [1a) pat Fifer, Edvard 107685 (27).pde Fiteer, Joe 74003) (3s) .paz Blening, Montze 33425 (14) pat Elores, Joshua To075¢ (7h par Hord, Feenk 434531 (ay sped ord, Michael 203465 @) pag gotnezgill, Brandon 783053 (2,26) .pdz Eoutoh, Danny 165503 (28) par Fraize, Abraiin 709756 (/)epde Francois, Lori 820591 (14) -paF Frazier, Billy 74040810, 35) par Freeman, Feather 776391 1d. pat Briend, Baney 246454 (15).pdr Hulton, bewrin 77a (Ca) spas Gage, Ronnie 182911 (7) pak Gellogly, Littie 697847 (16) .pat Geubie, Tiwothy 200196 (1),pa Greta, fatest €33e¢ saad TH “par Garciavionag, Bryon 773895 (1). Gsxora, Israel 142893 (7) pd? Soul, Denath 725362 (7) pat Elipert Jr, Donnie Tossid (7) pac Gilbert Te, Dennle F954 laud, Rathony #21728 (7) par Goble, “Witlian 239638 (4) pat Goldsn, Sichael 218038 119) .paz Gonzales, Orlando 716979 (2) pdt Gonzalez, Fornando 710935 (20; pdt Gonzalez, “Sandra 723739 (7) pdt Goodwin, Keaaty 746276 (18) Grafton, Jonathan 767051 (71 -pdé Geaga Jey Jay Seles (7)-eae Gray, ‘Pinothy 261097 (23) -pdé Greeny” Glinton 7e3959_ (15) .pae Gress Wicnas T1830 To] oo Grifeis, Lacey Lisd28 (7) -pde Geigaby, Barbara 84005021 Guerad, Saline 022133 (T).pde Guerad, Saline @22123 | Shinn, “Brian 272083 (/12).par Gunter, Garios 181037 -(a).pae Guthrie, Shane 450623 (14).pde Haley, Charles 170691 (3,5, 10,2) .paf Ball, “Deland $84650_ (12) ~par Hall, Michelle 639002 (7]:pdz Exhibit 1 Apdoetipoklahomacountyorg/March942020019%;20Stage?4201%20Commatationt420Ageh AE Aa,