Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dr. Alles
Hinduism
11/24/10
Sinister Yogis
David White’s book Sinister Yogis is an alternative look at the practice of yoga
and the instructors. His book illustrates the ability of capitalism to corrupt the truth and
reality of any practice. White discusses thoroughly how yoga has changed from past to
present and how the people who teach it are not necessarily fit into the classic mold of a
yogi.
One thing White’s book depicts is how people defected from the ancient practices
of yoga to an easier and less demanding life, that yoga is much different now than it was.
Even the yoga instructors lost their drive to teach meaningfully, instead turning to a more
profitable path. If you look at the quoted passage on page 247, “To a disappointed young
Iyengar, yoga seemed something he could pursue with the ‘mercenary’ intent of making a
living”. This quote points to one of the issues White is trying to not so subtly allude to,
that capitalism is an infectious disease that has brought about laziness and skewed our
perceptions of what yoga is truly about. In fact, much of our world consists of
misinformation and skewed perceptions. The idea that these teachers would abandon the
values of what we thought was traditional yoga for monetary gain is something that
should bother us, but it doesn’t. We are accustomed to this happening; it is the
“American dream,” to come here and make a fortune by swindling others and abandoning
ironic to find that the yoga most people here know of is actually a bad copy. It is another
story in India though. He writes that the Nāth Yogīs have made a return based on
patronage from wealthy benefactors. Part of the reason that many have lost sight of the
historical yogi practices is the world economy does not support people with no income,
and for them donations were hard to get. It seems more that White is speaking of the
American or Western yoga industry instead of the Indian practices although both have
been altered from tradition to some extent. Not to make excuses for it, but some changes
to the culture have been necessary in order for it to remain part of society.
Another point White is trying to make is about the yogis themselves. He stated on
page 37 that none of the yogis fit the stereotypical description of a cross-legged man
praying for enlightenment. He asks why all the yogis that narrate don’t fit the classical
definition of yoga, but we know that the classical definition isn’t completely realistic.
That too is skewed by media and interpretation so we see an idealized version. We see
what we want to see, not reality. White discusses the reason we have these inaccurate
perception on page 244 in the second to last paragraph. He states that “in the latter half
of the nineteenth century the British in India began to romanticize the yogis whose
lifestyles and livelihoods their policies had largely contributed to wiping out”. He
specifically refers to the urban middle class, saying that they got the image of a yogi
completely turned about. People continued to misunderstand the yogis and yoga; both
experienced a great deal of reinvention during the early twentieth century. White takes
care to analyze the yogis throughout the book, providing insight into the original
practices and how it has changed. He includes passages that are meant to reveal exactly
how much we have wrong about the yogi. In India things are very different from the past
despite some benefactors trying to support the culture, yet American yogis and yoga are
completely unrecognizable.
Life for the yogis has changed in the past two centuries; they no longer have the
free and almost carefree life that they led. They are forced to depend less and less on
patrons which has caused their numbers to dwindle considerably. With the lack of people
to remember the history and remain true to it, yoga changed and along with it the yogis.
So although White makes good points about the yogis changing both yoga and their
lifestyles it is understandable why such a change occurred. If you lack the people to
support it or the records to remember it then of course it will evolve over time.