Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1)
Professor, Geotechnical Centre of Department of Mining Engineering, Technical University of Lisbon,
Av. Rovisco Pais, 1049-001 Lisbon, Portugal
2)
Professor, Nottingham Centre for Geomechanics, School of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering,
University Park, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2RD, UK and Professorial Fellow,
University of Wollongong, Faculty of Engineering, NSW 2522, Australia
Corresponding author‘s e-mail: vntorres@ist.utl.pt, dgama@ist.utl.pt, raghu.singh@nottingham.ac.uk
ABSTRACT
The effect of temperature in underground mines is related to the geothermal gradients of rocks overlying the mining
excavation. This may exceed the standards of comfort for human beings to work in an underground environment thus causing
thermal discomforts and associated risk. In order to evaluate the influence of high ventilation temperatures on mine
workers a mathematical model has been developed based upon the concept of heat transfer from the rock mass to the air flow
in the underground environment. This model has been validated in the Noves Corvo underground copper mine, Portugal.
KEYWORDS: geothermal gradient, rock mass thermal properties, human comfort, underground mining environment
qr L
htcn t2
Q
Thermal neutral zone
h A
B
dx 2
h1, t1 α
Underground
1
opening
For the air flowing in the underground mining Finally the variation of temperature from t1 to t2
openings this equation can be expressed as a function enables to calculate Δt r as follows:
of the air flow Q as follows:
λ P L (h1 − htcn ± L sin α )
qr = 1000 ρ a Ce Q Δt r = 1000 ρ a Ce Q (t2 − t1 ) (5) Δt r = t2 − t1 = (9)
g g (λ P L + 2000 ρ a Ce Q)
where;
In raises or any vertical underground openings,
qr is the heat received by the air from the rock mass
h1=0, and the length which influences the geothermic
(W),
degree is L Sin α - hzn and α +, thus giving:
ρ a the air density (kg/m3),
Ce the specific heat of air (kJ/m.ºC),
λ P ( L sin α − hzn ) 2
Q the air flow (m3/s) and Δtr = t2 − t1 = (10)
Δ tr the variation of temperature from t1 to t2 g g [λ P ( L sin α − htcn ) + 2000 ρ a Ce Q]
influenced by heat of rock mass (Figure 2).
The coefficient of heat transfer λ is calculated
The heat emitted from the rock mass and as function of the thermal conductivity K (W/m.ºC),
received by the ventilation air of the underground the non-dimensional coefficient of Dittus and Boelter
opening can also be given in terms of coefficient of ‘Nud’ and the diameter of section d (m), for horizontal
heat transference λ (Holman, 1983) according to the and inclined underground openings d = (B + A)/2,
equation 6: where B is the width of the section (m) and A its
height (m):
dq= λ P dx(Tp – Tm) (6)
K Nu d
where; λ= (11)
Tp, Tm are the temperatures of rock wall and air d
mixture respectively in the particular position dx (ºC), The relationship of Dittus and Boelter factor Nud
λ is the coefficient of transference of heat of the rock (Holman, 1983) was studied in detail by Petukhov for
mass the air mixture (W/m2 ºC) and P the perimeter of gases (air) who arrived with the following equation:
the underground opening (m).
f
The total heat qr transferred (W) can be calculated Re d Pr
through: Nud = 8 (12)
f
1.07 + 12.7( ) 0.5 (Pr 0.67 − 1)
qr = λ P L (T p − Tm ) average (7) 8
where;
Combining the equation 4 with the parameters Red is the Reynolds number (non-dimensional
illustrated in the Figure 2 results in quantity) given by:
Tp = {t1 + [t1 + (h1 – hzn ± L sin α)/gg]}/2 and
Red = V d/μ,
Tm = (t1 + t2 )/2
Applying the above values to equations 5 and 7, where;
results in equation 8 as follows: V is the average air velocity (m/s),
d is the underground opening diameter (m) and
⎡⎣( λ P L )/ 2⎤⎦ ⎡⎣( h1 − hzn ± L sinα ) / gg + t1 − t2 ⎤⎦ = 103 ρa Ce Q( t2 − t1 )
μ is the kinematic air viscosity(Kg/m.s).
f is the friction coefficient of the underground opening
(8) walls (Kg/m3),
344 V. F. Navarro Torres et al.
Pr is the Prandtl number (a non-dimensional situ measurements and the human metabolism Δth is
quantity) calculated by; neglected because actually it is not important because
normally underground mines are mechanized.
Pr = Ce μ/K.
3. MATHEMATICAL MODEL VALIDATION IN A
The physic-chemical air properties are obtained PORTUGUESE MINE
in thermodynamic tables (Navarro Torres et al., 2005). 3.1. ROCK MASS AND UNDERGROUND OPENINGS
The Neves Corvo mine belongs to the Mining
2.3. MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSIONS OF HEAT
Society of Neves Corvo S.A. (Somincor) and is
TRANSFER OF OTHER SOURCES
a subsidy of the Lundin Mining Corporation.
The mathematical expression for the temperature Neves-Corvo is an operating underground copper and
variation from air auto-compression Δta (ºC) zinc mine in the western part of the Iberian Pyrite Belt
developed (Navarro Torres et al., 2005) resulted in which stretches through southern Spain into Portugal.
equation 13 as follows: The mine uses both bench-and-fill and drift-and fills
Δt ha = 0.0098 L sin α (13) underground stoping methods. The mine has been
a significant producer of copper since 1989. The
where; copper plant has treated a maximum of 2.0 mt per
L and α are the well or shaft length (m) and annum of ore and in 2007 it was upgraded to treat up
inclination (º), respectively (Figure 3). to 2.2 mt of ore per annum.
The ore bodies of the underground Neves Corvo
copper mine shown in Figure 4 are formed between
354 and 354.5 millions years ago in a volcanic-
sedimentary submarine environment possibly linked
t1 with an intercontinental rift and, third order pull apart
basins, not far from the collision zone and located in
Vertical opening geological formations between Volcanic Lavas (V1)
α or shaft and Volcanic Sediments (V2). The V1 is composed of
L dp h black shale/schist and has same silicification but
dh generally less than V2 volcanic. The V2 has
a compact vitreous due the high quantity of silica
t2 (Riolitic) showing schistosity and alteration from
Chlorite (Lobato, 2000).
-3
NEVES COLECTOR
GRAÇA COLECTOR
Ore body
NEVES
SANTA CASTRO RAMP
BÁRBARA RAMP 720 COLECTOR
SHAFT
Transport Level 700
Comminution Level 700 Transport Neves
LEGEND CORVO
Ore body
Ventilation shaft CPV
Fig. 5 Neves Corvo underground principal openings, vertical section A-B 30º northeast
(Navarro Torres et al., 2005).
35 30
a) b)
33 25
31
Dry temperature (ºC)
Dr y temperature (ºC)
29 20
27
15
25
23 10
21
Average exterior dry temperature
Minimum 5 Average local underground mining
19 Maximum
Average
17 0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Months Months
Fig. 6 Temperature variation in local underground mining (a) and compared with exterior temperature (b)
(measured during 1998 to 2000, by (Navarro Torres et al., 2005)).
Air intake
Shaft
CPV3
Depth
28
27
26
25
24
23
22
21
Dry temprature - Air velocity
20
19
18
17
16 Dry temperature (ºC)
15 Air velocity (m/s)
14
13
12
11
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
9
4
:2
:3
:3
:4
:4
:5
:5
:0
:0
:1
:1
:2
:2
:3
:3
:4
:4
:5
:5
:0
:0
:1
:1
:2
:2
:3
:3
:4
:4
:5
:5
:0
:0
:1
:1
:2
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
14
14
14
14
14
14
14
14
14
14
14
14
15
15
15
15
15
Fig. 8 Intake dry temperature and air velocity measuring by Data LOGGER DL20K.
The air in CPV3 shaft is not influenced by diesel Table 2 enabled the calculation of the Reynolds
equipments (Δtd), explosives (Δte), thermal water (Δtw) number (Red) and the Prandtl number (Pr) by simple
and human metabolism (Δth). Therefore, only auto- equations referred to before and applied to equation
compression (Δta) and thermal properties of rock (Δtr) 12 to calculate Nud as 5162.02.
were considered for the validation of the proposed It may be recalled that (Nud) is Dittus and
model. Boelter coefficient. This result leads to the calculation
The physical-geometric parameters of CPV3 of the coefficient of heat transfer ( λ ) by applying
shaft and physico-chemical properties of air shown in equation 12 and resulting in 76.106 W/m2ºC (Table 3).
MATHEMATICAL MODELLING OF THERMAL STATE IN UNDERGROUND MINING 347
Finally using the 30.3 m/ºC of the geothermal rock, 36.5% for blasting and 44.9% for diesel
gradient for the rock mass (gg) for the Neves Corvo equipment respectively and this result is similar to US
mine (Fernández Rubio et al., 1990), 30.0 m depth as underground mines (Hartman et al., 1982).
the depth of thermal neutral zone and using the For mathematical model validation in inclined
developed mathematical model in equation 10, openings collector N0900GV and ramp NRAM02
the influence of thermal properties of rock mass a similar process for previous underground
(Δtr = t2 - t1) is calculated as 2.79 ºC. Applying these environments obtained a measurement values shown
values to equation 13, the temperature increase due to in Figure 10.
air auto-compression can be obtained as 2.44 ºC. Then As neither any diesel equipments nor blasting
the total increase of the air temperature during the air activities were used in the collector N0900GV and
flow for shaft CVP3 results in 5.23 ºC. ramp NRAM02 because the ramp is used for the ore
The average values measurement with Data collection from the stopes or local underground work
LOGGER DL20K of ROTRONIC in the air shaft and the collector is appointed for the ventilation
intake with a thermo/hygrometer Casella in the shaft system.
(Figure 9) was 29.52 ºC in the shaft bottom and
24.61 ºC in the intake, therefore the difference is 4. DISCUSSION ON THE MEASUREMENT AND
4.91 ºC. MATHEMATICAL MODEL VALUES
The comparison the results show a total variation The measured average total dry temperature
of temperature (Δttotal) between the mathematical values were compared with the calculated values by
model and measured temperature is 0.32 ºC or an mathematical model at four underground sites as
error of 1.3%. shown in Figure 8 and Table 4. It can be seen that the
error in the measured and calculated values range
3.3. VALIDATION IN HORIZONTAL AND INCLINED from 10% to 80% and are under 1º Celcius (optimal
OPENINGS error range).
The selected horizontal and inclined openings for Larger average total temperature variation
validation the mathematical model was the access of correspond to the larger opening length, depth or
CO570GA1 stope, Collector N0900GV and Ramp presence or absence of diesel equipment and blasting
NRAM02. The access of CO570GA1stope is a sub- using and less variation corresponding to smaller
horizontal opening of 204.00 m length and with small length, depth or absence of diesel equipment and
0.90 m inclination, 20.96 m of perimeter, 27.56 m2 of blasting (Figure 11) The applicability of the
section and a friction factor 0.0046 kg/m3. In the mathematical model was assessed by the average total
access of CO570GA1 the mineral production was dry temperature ( Δ ttotal) and not only by thermal
6000tones/round (2 rounds/week) with 0.20 kg of properties of rock ( Δ tr). This procedure causes some
ANFO/tonne (Coupers et al., 1998). In this locale the influence, but they had been considered valid.
larger diesel equipment used is one LHD Toro 500D Finally the intake and exit temperatures in
(204 Kw) and the measured airflow was 8 m3/s. The underground openings will change influenced by the
variation of air temperature between the intake and exterior surface temperature as shown in Figure 6.
exhaust of CO570GA1 underground stope was 18.6% This procedure were also applied to San Rafael
higher influenced by the thermal properties of the Peruvian mine (Dinis da Gama et. al., 2002) for
348 V. F. Navarro Torres et al.
Fig. 10 Scheme and measurement average values of collector N0900GV and ramp
NRAM02.
5
Total temperature variation (ºC)
Mathematical model
3 Measure
0
3
A1
02
V
PV
0G
0G
AM
0G
C
0
57
09
09
R
N
O
rN
rN
p
C
am
o
ct
ct
R
le
le
ol
ol
C
assessment of the thermal comfort environmental with Fernández Rubio, R. et al.: 1988, Mining-Hydrological
very good results. characteristics of the Underground Copper Mine of
Neves-Corvo, Portugal. Third International Mine
5. CONCLUSIONS Water Congress. Melbourne, Australia, 49–63.
Gomes de Azevedo, E.: 1995, Termodinâmica aplicada.
The evaluation of human thermal comfort in Lisboa Portugal, 351–386.
underground mines based on dry bulb temperature is Hartman, H.L. et al.: 1982, Mine Ventilation and Air
considered as a most practical approach, although the Conditioning, Ronald Press Company. New York.
thermal comfort depends on various other parameters USA, 559–593.
including mean radiant temperature, air velocity, Holman, J.P.: 1983, Transferência de calor. McGraw Hill
humidity, activity level and the use thermal resistant São Paulo Brasil, 194–203.
clothing’s by the operators. In this paper the PPD Lobato, J.C.: 2000, Evaluation of mining induced stress on
support requirements at Neves Corvo. MSc Thesis
(Predicted Percentage Dissatisfaction) index has been
University of Exeter, UK, 21–31.
used as the function of the operative temperature and Moura, A.: 2005, Fluids from the Neves Corvo massive
a mathematical model has been developed that allows sulphide ores, Iberian Pyrite Belt, Portugal. Chemical
the prediction of air temperature in the underground Geology. Volume 223, Issues 1-3, 22 November 2005,
mining environment influenced by the geothermic 153–169.
gradient of the rock mass surrounding the mining Navarro Torres, V.F. et al.: 2005, Environmental
excavations. This mathematical model has been underground engineering and applications. Roberto C.
validated in the Neves Corvo, Lead and Zinc mine in Villas Bôas (Ed.), CETEM/CNPq/CYTED-XIII, 81–
Portugal. The comparison between the calculated 112.
Olesen, B.W.: 1982, Thermal Comfort. Technical Review
values by the developed mathematical model and the
No. 2, Bruel & Kjaer, 32–37.
measured values, in the field, show very small Petukhov, B.S.: 1970, Heat Transfer and friction in
variations with acceptable values for the real life Turbulent Pipe Flow with Variable Physical
situations. Following the validation of this Properties, in J.P. Hartnett and T.F.Irvine (Eds),
mathematical model in Portugal, this procedure has Advances in Heat Transfer, Academic Press, Inc, New
been used in the San Rafael Mine in Peru to predict York, 504–564.
the thermal environment in the underground workings Vutukuri V.S. et al.: 1986, Environmental Engineering in
with satisfactory results. Mines, Cambridge University Press. Great Britain,
518 pp.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors acknowledge the help given by
Dr A. S. Atkins, Faculty of Computing, Engineering
and Technology, Staffordshire University for his
valuable suggestions to improve the quality of this
paper.
REFERENCES
Coupers, D. et al.: 1998, A aplicação do método de bench
and fill aos minérios fissurais do jazigo de Neves
Norte. IV Simpósio Internacional de Sulfuretos Poli
Metálicos da Faixa Piritosa Ibérica, Lisboa, 235–248.
Dinis da Gama, C. et al.: 2002, Influence of thermal
properties of rocks on the environmental comfort in
underground mining – A case study in Peru, 509–517.