Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kinsuk Maitra, Carole Hall, Terri Kalish, Marita Anderson, Erin Dugan,
Justine Rehak, Verónica Rodrı́guez, Jennifer Tamas, Deborah Zeitlin
KEY WORDS OBJECTIVE. This study was a retrospective chart analysis spanning 5 yr that investigated asso-
activities of daily living ciations between occupational therapy interventions and goal-based positive outcomes in patients
with multiple sclerosis (MS) and related disorders at discharge in an urban inpatient rehabilitation
medical audit
setting.
multiple sclerosis
METHOD. Using descriptive statistics, we examined demographic characteristics in the first analysis phase.
occupational therapy
In the second phase, we performed a series of correlational analyses to identify treatment variables associated
rehabilitation with positive outcomes.
treatment outcome RESULTS. Generally, patients improved in their FIM™ scores at discharge. Increasing occupational
therapy intensity had a positive effect on functional performance in all categories except feeding, with
significant correlations in upper-extremity dressing (r 5 .153, p < .05) and memory (r 5 .204, p < .01).
CONCLUSION. Occupational therapy was associated with positive functional outcomes for patients
with MS. Future treatment protocols should include cognitive skills training, community reintegration,
and self-care, because these treatments were found to be significantly correlated with positive changes
in FIM scores.
Maitra, K., Hall, C., Kalish, T., Anderson, M., Dugan, E., Rehak, J., et al. (2010). Research Scholars Initiative—
Five-year retrospective study of inpatient occupational therapy outcomes for patients with multiple sclerosis.
American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 64, 689–694. doi: 10.5014/ajot.2010.090204
examined the relationship between the number of therapy *Percentages are based on an N of 193, but some data are missing: 7
participants did not disclose race, 9 did not disclose marital status, 8 did
minutes spent in each intervention and the change in FIM not disclose prehospital living setting, and 13 did not provide posthospital
scores for each functional activity. Significant difference living setting.
analysis (Table 4) between occupational therapy intensity areas of ADL performance, including significant negative
(number of days treated/length of stay) and changes in FIM correlations in the categories of lower-extremity dressing
scores. We found that increasing occupational therapy in- (r 5 2.17, p < .05) and tub transfers (r 5 2.21, p < .01).
tensity had a positive effect on FIM scores in all categories It appears that efficiency in self-care may be directly related
except feeding. However, the only significant correlations to practicing self-care activities. The use of therapeutic
were in the categories of upper-extremity dressing (r 5 .15, exercises also showed mixed results on independence in
p < .05) and memory (r 5 .20, p < .01). ADLs, showing a positive impact on upper-extremity
The time spent on cognitive skills training correlated dressing (r 5 .21, p < .01) and a negative impact on tub
with improved independence in all categories of cognition transfers (r 5 2.18, p < .05; Table 5).
(comprehension, expression, social interaction, problem
solving, memory), and significant correlations were found
in the categories of comprehension (r 5 .23, p < .01) and Discussion
expression (r 5 .23, p < .01). Occupational therapy is a part of the rehabilitation team
Training in self-care skills correlated positively with that serves patients with MS during inpatient re-
independence in all ADL categories except tub transfers habilitation stays. The purpose of occupational therapy is
and showed significant results in upper-extremity dressing to facilitate independence and participation in ADLs.
(r 5 .24, p < .01), and toilet transfers (r 5 .15, p < .05). Results from this study suggest that occupational thera-
Patients who spent more time completing therapeutic pists in an inpatient rehabilitation center were able to help
activities demonstrated decreased independence in several achieve this purpose, because patients with MS who
Table 3. Change in Discharge FIM Status Compared With Initial FIM Scores: Paired t Test
Initial FIM Discharge FIM FIM Change Standard Error of
FIM Category M (SD) M (SD) M (SD) FIM Change t (df ) p (2-tailed)
Feeding 5.06 (1.37) 5.84 (1.00) 0.78 (1.14) 0.084 9.272 (184) .000
Grooming 4.61 (1.27) 5.46 (0.98) 0.85 (1.15) 0.085 10.107 (184) .000
Bathing 3.16 (1.39) 4.37 (1.17) 1.21 (1.28) 0.094 12.838 (184) .000
Upper-extremity dressing 4.07 (1.17) 5.12 (0.94) 1.05 (1.10) 0.081 12.969 (184) .000
Lower-extremity dressing 2.83 (1.41) 4.18 (1.47) 1.35 (1.20) 0.088 15.282 (184) .000
Toileting 2.37 (1.71) 4.15 (1.66) 1.78 (1.67) 0.124 14.354 (182) .000
Toilet transfer 2.72 (1.72) 4.36 (1.46) 1.64 (1.36) 0.101 16.278 (183) .000
Tub transfer 0.50 (1.10) 3.42 (1.87) 2.93 (1.90) 0.145 20.202 (182) .000
Comprehension 5.66 (0.94) 5.92 (0.85) 0.25 (0.84) 0.063 3.970 (179) .000
Expression 6.02 (0.98) 6.39 (0.77) 0.36 (0.90) 0.067 5.373 (179) .000
Social interaction 5.95 (0.96) 6.26 (0.75) 0.36 (0.84) 0.066 5.470 (162) .000
Problem solving 5.64 (1.15) 6.08 (0.93) 0.43 (0.94) 0.070 6.069 (179) .000
Memory 5.82 (1.20) 6.20 (1.00) 0.36 (1.12) 0.084 4.316 (179) .000
Note. M 5 mean; SD 5 standard deviation; df 5 degrees of freedom.
Note. Occupational therapy intensity is determined by dividing the number of Note. LE 5 lower extremity; UE 5 upper extremity.
days treated by the length of stay. *Significant at p < .05. **Significant at p < .01.
*p < .05, two-tailed test. **p < .01, two-tailed test.
advised against treating the cognitive aspects of MS
receive occupational therapy services in this setting (Mendoza & Pittenger, 2003). Mendoza and Pittenger
demonstrated an increase in functional independence on (2003) further argued that patients with MS can greatly
discharge, as evidenced by improved mean FIM scores benefit from various cognitive rehabilitation interven-
in all categories (Table 3). These findings are consistent tions. The rehabilitation techniques allow people with
with those reported by Baker and Tickle-Degnen (2001); memory disorders to develop the compensatory strategies
Freeman et al. (1997); and Solari et al. (1999). In the that afford greater functional independence. Additionally,
current study, the largest increases in functional inde- interventions in the areas of community reintegration and
pendence were seen in the categories of tub transfers, self-care skills would be recommended as part of the
toileting, toilet transfers, bathing, and upper-extremity occupational therapy treatment plan because these re-
dressing. sulted in improved independence in ADLs in this study.
Results suggest little or no relationship between As mentioned earlier, the available literature has a dearth
neuromuscular reeducation intervention, group therapy, of quantitative research; therefore, these findings cannot
and change in FIM score. Although it might be beneficial be confirmed as prescriptive for the general population.
to use these types of interventions, results indicated no
clear relationship between neuromuscular reeducation and Limitations
group therapy on functional independence. Additionally, The study was performed at a single major urban medical
results indicate that the use of therapeutic activities and rehabilitation center, and hence the sample does not reflect
therapeutic exercise as interventions did not have a re- the entire population of patients with MS and related dis-
lationship to FIM scores. Because research results from orders. Future studies may consider including samples from
this study did not provide clear evidence for these in- several hospitals and incorporating patients residing in
tervention approaches, our opinion is that more quanti- suburban and rural locations. Most patients in the study,
tative studies focusing on functional outcomes are approximately 76.7%, were female, and the results may
necessary to show the effectiveness of neuromuscular re- not accurately represent typical treatment outcomes for male
education, group therapy, therapeutic activities, and patients. Because of changes in the medical center’s docu-
therapeutic exercises. mentation procedures, on occasion the total number of
One can also conclude from these results that in- units of occupational therapy treatment was difficult to
corporating cognitive skills training into occupational decipher. Units of treatment that were unclear in the doc-
therapy treatment of patients with MS will lead to im- umentation were recorded as one unit, respectively. Addi-
proved cognition for these patients, especially in the areas tionally, each therapist had a slightly different method of
of comprehension and expression. Cognitive retraining chart documentation. Also, it was difficult to differentiate
may be limited, however, because of Medicare and between which activities constituted therapeutic activities
Medicaid reimbursement policies. Low reimbursement and which constituted therapeutic exercises because no
rates create an economic barrier because therapists are specific definitions existed. Because the study was