You are on page 1of 11

From: D.

Sperlein

Fax: +1 (415) 404-6616

To:

Fax: +1 (707) 435-6409

Page 1 of 1110/4/2010 12:48

FAX

Date 10/4/2010

Number of pages including cover sheet: 11

To:

From:

D. Sperlein

AT& T I nternet Services

The Law Office of D. Gill Sperlein 584 Castro Street, Suite 879

San Francisco CA

94114

Phone

Phone +1 (415) 404-6615 Fax Phone +1 (415) 404-6616

Fax Phone + 1 (707) 435-6409

114aMt443&iHII~ _

From: D. Sperlein

Fax: +1 (415) 404-6616

To:

Fax: +1 (707) 435-6409

Page 2 of 11 10/4/2010 12:48

THE LAW OFFICE OF D. GILL SPERLEIN 584 Castro Street, Suite 879

San Francisco, California 94114

P 415.404.6615/ f 415.404.6616/ gill(j.iJsperleinlaw.com

October 4.2010

Rhonda K. Compton AT&T Internet Services

Legal Compliance Department

1010 N. St. Mary"s Street Suite 315-A2 San Antonio, Texas 78215

VIA Facsimile 707-435-6409

Re: Service of Subpoena

Dear Ms. Compton:

As I anticipated in my early letter, I have obtained an Order from the Court authorizing me to serve the attached subpoena on AT&T Internet. A hard copy will follow in the U.S. Mail as I understand your policy permits/requires.

If you would like an electronic copy of the attachment so the information can easily be copied, I would be more than happy to provide one.

Please contact me immediately if you foresee any difficulty in complying with the attached subpoena.

Thank you in advance for your cooperation in this matter.

Very truly yours,

D. GILL SPERLEIN

THE LAW OFFICE OF D. GILL SPERLEIN

From: D. Sperlein

Fax: +1 (415) 404·6616

To:

Fax: +1 (707) 435·6409

Page 3 of 11 10/4/2010 12:48

~~AQ8S (Rey 12/06) Suhpgena in a Ciyil Case

Issued by the

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

DIS TRICT OF N.D.:....:. T:....::eo.:..:x""as"-- _

10 GROUP, INC.

V.

DOES 1-244

SUBPOEN A IN A CIVIL CASE

Case Number: I 10-3647 (MEJ) N.D. Cal.

TO: AT&T Internet Services, Inc.

1010 N. St. Mary's Street, Suite 315-A2 San Antonio, Texas 78215

D YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear in the United States District court at the place, date, and time specified below to testify in the above case.

PLACE OF TESTIMONY

DATE AND TIME

COURTROOM

D YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear at the place, date, and time specified below to testify at the taking ofa deposition in the above case.

PLACE OFDEPOSlTION I DATE AND TIME

[if YOU ARE COMM.ANDED to produce and permit inspection and copying of the following documents or objects at the

place, date, and time specified below (1ist documents or objects):

Documents sufficient to identify the names, addresses, telephone numbers, and e-mail addresses of the AT&T Internet Services, Inc. subscribers assigned the ip addresses identified on Attachment A on the corresponding dates at the corresponding times.

PLACE

The Law Office of D. Gill Sperlein, 584 Castro Street, Suite 879, San Francsico, CA

94114 gill@sperleinlaw.com, fax=415-404-6616

DATE AND TIME

12/5/10: 5 p.rn.peT

D YOU ARE COMMANDED to permit inspection of the following premises at the date and time specified below.

PREMISES

I DATE AND TIME

Any organization not a party to this suit that is subpoenaed for the taking of a deposition shall designate one or more officers, directors, or managing agents, OJ other persons who consent to testify on its behalf, and may set forth, for each person designated, the matters on which the pcrson will testify. Federal Rules ofCivil Procedure, 30(b)(6).

ISSUING OFFICER'S SIGN A TURE AND TITLE (INDICATE IF ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF OR DEFENDANT)

P~~ .

DATE October 4,

2010

ISSUING OFFICER'S NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER D. Gill Sperlein, Attorney for Plaintiff 10 Group, Inc.

584 Castro Street, Suite 879, San Francsico, CA 94114 gill@sperleinlaw.com; phone 415-404-6615; fax 415-404-6616

(See Rule 45, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Subdivisions (c), (d), and (e), on next page)

I If action is pend ing in district other than district of issuance, state district under case number.

From: D. Sperlein

Fax: +1 (415) 404-6616

To:

ATTACHMENT A

Doe No. Date IF Address Time (GMT)
1 May 5.2010 99.147.204.85. 17:54:36
2 May 13, 2010 99.13.229.0 04:29:30
3 May 10, 2010 99.72.197.27 06:30:15
4 April 23, 2010 99.l89.l82.234 03:59:05
5 June 7, 2010 99.l60.5.62 02:09:30
6 June 14, 2010 69.l48.l70.11 14:18:39
7 May 9,2010 75.30.92.78 17:42:40
8 June 14, 2010 69.234.42.8 15:02:12
9 May 10, 2010 7l.l56.57.125 03:4 7:01
10 June 8, 2010 69.211.7.l75 02:53 :48
11 June 14,2010 99.169.63.132 13:52:19
12 June 9, 2010 99.l81.l54.83 04:03 :37
13 June 7, 2010 99.62.5 6.l 0 19:29:22
14 May 9,2010 99.23.7.155 03:58:38
15 May 14, 2010 71.136.253.90 09:55 :34
16 June 10,2010 99.38.229.12 22:02:59
17 May31,2010 70.247.116.73 22:42:26
18 May 25,2010 69.l06.l88.l73 12:35 :53
19 April 2, 2010 99.65.9.132 07:11:30
20 April 20, 2010 69.23 l.8l.l 91 09:45 :05
21 April 9, 2010 76.238.5.l06 13:27:36
22 May 14, 2010 68.l26.62.231 21 :59:02
23 May 16, 2010 68.255.254.114 10:55 :33
24 May 19, 2010 70.138.125.116 17:11:34
25 May 20,2010 76.200.l46.36 03:28:24
26 May 24,2010 69.l06.l07.92 21:15:42
27 April 20, 2010 99.l5l.l12.236 06:05 :48
28 May 22,2010 69.232.37.68 22:43 :56
29 May 26,2010 75.6.246.205 23:11:52
30 April 2, 2010 76.200.l59.l84 06:24:17
31 June 6, 2010 69.110.31.162 05:00:30
32 April 27, 2010 75.37.148.26 20:00:16
33 June 8, 2010 99.l44.233.234 09:31 :27
34 June 8, 2010 76.220.40.238 19:22:29
35 June 9, 2010 76.245.99.43 07:38:05
36 June 13, 2010 99.177.146.113 00:52:21
37 April 10, 2010 76.219.170.57 09:11 :47
38 May 22,2010 99.191.36.71 18:16:52
39 June 3, 2010 99.74.180.95 18:34:14
40 April 6, 2010 99.170.53.79 21 :07:41
41 April 1, 2010 69.237.l59.9 08:21:17
42 May 20,2010 99.20.l93.l32 20:25 :31
43 May 30,2010 75.55.22l.l79 02:29:40
44 April 17, 2010 173.19.91.145 08:21 :30
45 June 14,2010 75.25.0.55 13:59:23
46 June 6, 2010 76.212.195.103 06:53 :30
47 June 11, 2010 75.34.l55.l1 21 :20:32
48 June 8, 2010 12.171.62.218 05:40:20
49 June 12,2010 99.l77.184.130 16:57:14
50 June 13, 2010 99.61.83.47 01 :53 :54
51 April 21, 2010 69.l09.24.43 03:54:31
52 May 29,2010 75.26.157.243 02:23 :18
53 June 4, 2010 99.25.235.173 07:29:13
54 June 12,2010 64.252.134.121 06:04:54
55 April 14, 2010 69.228.43.213 09:21 :39
55 April 16, 2010 69.228.43.213 09:24:13
55 April 17, 2010 69.228.43.213 04:25 :30
55 April 17, 2010 69.228.43.213 08:26:30 Fax: +1 (707) 435-6409

Page 4 of 11 10/4/2010 12:48

From: D. Sperlein

Fax: +1 (415) 404-6616

To:

55 April 17, 2010 69.228.43.213 21 :42:41
60 May21,2010 69.228.38.188 00:00:12
61 May31,2010 71.139.172.56 19:39:09
62 June 10,2010 173.20.139.84 17:30:19
63 April 9, 2010 70.138.156.211 03:55:10
64 April 2, 2010 75.l7.228.84 03:38:11
65 May 25,2010 71.l42.76.l50 10:09:05
66 May 20,2010 69.l5 3 .62 .69 11 :50:27
67 May 29,2010 76.247.81.38 15:04:12
68 April 11, 2010 70.138.156.211 01 :48:31
69 June 1,2010 68.76.l45.41 01 :25 :33
70 June 14,2010 99.23.124.230 13:33:15
71 June 1,2010 75.11.52.12 21 :40:04
72 June 10,2010 75.46.73.l82 09:29:50
73 June 13, 2010 76.253.l26.l85 01 :08:51
74 June 12,2010 75.45.64.35 10:57:56
75 June 10,2010 71.138.213.49 19:20:47
76 June 12,2010 99.173.173.185 23:28:00
77 May 4, 2010 71.13 7.242.l45 08:54:56
78 April 11, 2010 173.24.95.68 01:43 :28
79 May 18, 2010 76.255.149.206 20:23 :30
80 May 30,2010 75.42.224.84 17:16:27
81 June 12,2010 99.l79.l83.l42 14:58:06
82 April 6, 2010 75.37.21.202 09:31 :43
83 May21,2010 76.204.101.230 05:43 :52
84 June 8, 2010 76.253.101.93 11 :44:33
84 June 9, 2010 76.253.l01.93 03:02:00
84 June 9, 2010 76.253.l01.93 19:27:58
84 June 12,2010 76.253.l01.93 10:33 :13
88 June 11, 2010 99.189.182.125 23:56:57
89 April 1, 2010 76.254.3l.l54 16:55 :57
90 June 11, 2010 76.221.147.95 06:47:25
91 May 14, 2010 76.193.160.13 01 :35 :29
92 May 26, 2010 68.127.29.115 16:42:57
93 May 27, 2010 99.6.90.l59 21:13:22
94 May 8,2010 75.2.24l.44 12:12:49
95 April 1, 2010 71.139.l73.l72 15:42:05
96 May 30,2010 207.214.11l.l20 17:31 :51
97 May21,2010 99.152.144.200 20:39:40
98 May 3,2010 75.4.193.169 00:14:50
99 April 2, 2010 69.234.182.167 21 :22:23
100 April 27, 2010 70.251.7l.l93 02:33:29
101 June 5, 2010 99.l40.6.l3 16:08:38
102 June 1, 2010 75.25.l4.l21 19:51:49
103 June 12, 2010 75.43.211.222 20:26:09
104 April 26, 2010 99.33.193.11 17:26:13
105 April 7, 2010 7l.l46.137.144 12:00:29
106 June 1, 2010 70.138.l09.73 22:54:28
107 May 6,2010 99.132.235.144 22:29:24
108 June 14, 2010 67.121.126.149 14:22:05
109 May 21, 2010 69.37.91.l18 17:09:04
110 May 27, 2010 99.l63.85.21 14:00:27
III April 16, 2010 75.l6.l17.238 07:48:30
112 June 8, 2010 7l.l58.175.219 16:26:44
113 June 10, 2010 76.234.160.139 23:51:27
114 June 12, 2010 99.135.l66.207 11:38:43
115 June 12, 2010 67.67.22l.4 18:24:19
116 May 9,2010 69.152.l70.81 15:59:47
117 June 14, 2010 69.l08.l00.28 12:22:14 Fax: +1 (707) 435-6409

Page 5 of 11 10/4/2010 12:48

From: D. Sperlein

Fax: +1 (415) 404-6616

To:

118 May 29, 2010 7l.l34.246.32 09:50:54
119 June 12, 2010 99.62.239.19 13:17:59
120 May 27, 2010 76.206.238.136 19:27:35
121 June 9, 2010 70.234.180.126 18:53:21
122 June 14, 2010 70.138.118.253 14:05:35
123 May 11, 2010 69.230.98.98 18:46:01
124 June 12, 2010 69.214.l58.234 09:41:03
125 June 10, 2010 99.l90.36.l69 19:43:11
126 May 27, 2010 68. 78.l.l7 0 15:56:55
127 May 18, 2010 75.5l.l00.140 06:18:14
128 April 17, 2010 75.30.232.l54 05:47:51
129 June 7, 2010 69.209.62.195 13:22:19
130 May 20, 2010 99.3l.l57.251 14:22:17
131 June 1, 2010 173.28.l0.l50 13:24:50
132 June 9, 2010 99.l4.218.241 21:55:21
133 May 31, 2010 69.l51.217.35 05:38:21
134 April 4, 2010 99.145.192.90 09:43:02
135 April 3, 2010 99.24.15l.l36 17:30:56
136 May 11, 2010 69.l09.208.20 04:36:51
137 June 11, 2010 75.57.4.l75 05:08:15
138 May 2,2010 75.l.8l.97 05:41:01
139 April 5, 2010 99.l75.216.223 01:26:03
140 June 2, 2010 99.l82.27.98 09:41:41
141 April 21, 2010 173.24.57.242 16:24:03
142 June 8, 2010 99.32.196.233 12:23:21
143 May 25, 2010 99.186.110.74 07:37:10
144 May 20, 2010 70.133.l44.228 04:16:41
145 April 28, 2010 69.l09.238.l92 03:49:27
146 May 21, 2010 76.234.l60.69 17:41:16
147 June 12, 2010 75.22.94.224 23:53:22
148 May 25, 2010 99.61.63.l94 01:00:11
149 June 12, 2010 75.22.26.25 11:58:14
150 April 4, 2010 99.156.120.197 17:07:11
151 May 12, 2010 99.189.182.125 07:22:58
152 May 20, 2010 12.24.59.l30 05:01:56
153 May 22, 2010 70.238.l18.l98 17:46:11
154 June 8, 2010 75.50.57.l1 12:16:01
155 June 11, 2010 70.130.39.246 07:33:47
156 April 26, 2010 76.253.108.184 09:34:16
157 April 9, 2010 70.243.253.64 03:44:22
158 April 27, 2010 99.68.164.40 09:46:02
159 April 28, 2010 99.68.164.40 08:43:03
160 May 15, 2010 99.89.50.98 23:02:36
161 June 11, 2010 173.30.l39.233 09:05:22
162 April 28, 2010 76.242.l78.7 21:50:23
163 June 8, 2010 76.231.245.123 01:16:34
164 April 10, 2010 99.155.18l.0 15:56:38
165 June 11, 2010 173.28.45.98 03:24:40
166 May 27, 2010 75.5l.l78.220 13:07:42
167 April 23, 2010 70.240.18l.201 18:19:45
168 June 12, 2010 75.9.75.5 07:28:10
169 May 29, 2010 76.208.l54.110 07:30:35
170 May 31, 2010 99.8.23.24 05:11:58
171 June 5, 2010 68.95.157.13 14:09:14
172 June 14, 2010 7l.l36.235.205 15:04:03
173 June 14, 2010 68.251.36.60 12:14:45
174 June 12, 2010 75.9.60.l46 12:22:11
175 April 26, 2010 99.59.235.188 09:41:58
176 June 13, 2010 99.129.l9.42 01:53:30 Fax: +1 (707) 435-6409

Page 6 of 11 10/4/2010 12:48

From: D. Sperlein

Fax: +1 (415) 404-6616

To:

177 April 17, 2010 99.131.42.99 20:05:56
178 May 18, 2010 99.4l.l74.189 17:11:31
179 June 7, 2010 70.247.116.73 21:51:57
180 May 15, 2010 76.194.239.103 05:34:39
181 June 12, 2010 75.25.168.144 19:50:25
182 May 8,2010 99.ll.l86.l13 10:26:13
183 May 9,2010 99.58.245.l48 03:51:24
184 May 25, 2010 7l.l46.27.72 20:59:31
185 April 6, 2010 75.5l.l79.18 09:47:11
186 May 8,2010 75.10.132.152 19:46:15
187 May 17, 2010 70.128.l16.64 20:25:58
188 April 6, 2010 68.9l.94.63 09:56:19
188 April 1, 2010 68.9l.94.63 10:14:30
189 May 16, 2010 76.254.39.l09 22:46:15
190 June 13, 2010 68.89.45.20 01:12:01
192 June 14, 2010 75.l8.50.69 12:20:28
193 April 4, 2010 173.23.200.213 01:21:15
194 April 27, 2010 75.1.210.167 06:57:42
195 May 31, 2010 76.204.6l.96 22:17:47
196 June 12, 2010 70.25l.l30.l74 17:52:44
197 April 16, 2010 69.153.56.196 09:42:23
198 May 23, 2010 76.251.212.95 14:17:10
199 May 2,2010 75.36.43.115 08:55:51
200 May 8,2010 99.60.49.41 12:53:10
201 May 4, 2010 69.151.196.31 15:58:09
202 June 7, 2010 173.28.1l.l31 10:28:27
203 April 15, 2010 99.l.l78.249 05:03:02
204 April 16, 2010 173.l8.86.l73 05:06:30
205 April 27, 2010 69.234.46.32 00:30:02
206 May 10, 2010 76.219.170.57 04:26:15
207 May 25, 2010 69.234.35.89 18:46:06
208 May 25, 2010 99.32.147.126 15:52:40
209 May 28, 2010 75.25.171.57 03:12:28
210 June 2, 2010 75.41.57.55 07:03:44
211 June 12, 2010 76.219.l70.57 08:59:22
212 April 10, 2010 75.l7.56.111 21:00:33
213 April 13, 2010 99.129.210.91 14:38:39
214 April 14, 2010 70.130.186.111 03:54:36
215 April 30, 2010 75.18.224.133 08:09:00
216 May 10, 2010 69.149.74.198 03:27:22
217 May 18, 2010 99.5l.l49.235 15:13:40
218 May 5,2010 76.222.124.254 20:52:32
219 May 29, 2010 76.217.59.l95 07:51:08
220 May 30, 2010 7l.l55.235.l60 23:44:36
221 May 6,2010 99.l7.28.218 21:48:13
222 June 5, 2010 76.237.199.205 20:04:43
223 May 30, 2010 75.17.127.252 18:36:41
224 April 13, 2010 99.61.224.129 09:55:20
225 June 2, 2010 76.200.95.242 02:23:40
226 April 14, 2010 99.94.154.24 06:48:18
227 June 12, 2010 75.36.l76.l4 19:18:40
228 April 28, 2010 76.203.216.71 10:23:33
229 May 8,2010 75.47.l58.4 16:21:47
230 April 20, 2010 99.190.116.78 21:25:12
231 May 17, 2010 69.149.40.100 20:36:30
232 May 31, 2010 70.233.l42.l76 02:25:46
233 April 2, 2010 68.92.62.3 04:52:14
234 April 13, 2010 69.111.192.60 15:55:11
235 April 23, 2010 68.251.32.l6 21:47:23 Fax: +1 (707) 435-6409

Page 7 of 11 10/4/2010 12:48

From: D. Sperlein

Fax: +1 (415) 404-6616

To:

236 May 25, 2010 69.238.178.70 01:04:08
237 June 4, 2010 99.138.88.25 03:22:32
238 May 14, 2010 99.52.245.180 01:51:49
239 April 1, 2010 173.23.173.81 04:01:16
240 April 1, 2010 99.168.94.203 15:52:33
241 April 11, 2010 99.61.95.222 00:29:40
242 April 25, 2010 76.218.82.l11 20:24:45
243 April 26, 2010 75.22.90.l3 09:42:36
244 June 6, 2010 7l.l35.100.185 13:40:43 Fax: +1 (707) 435-6409

Page 8 of 11 10/4/2010 12:48

From: D. Sperlein

Fax: +1 (415) 404·6616

To:

Fax: +1 (707) 435·6409

Page 9 of 11 10/4/2010 12:48

Aoaa (Rey 12iQ6) Subpoena in a Ciyil Case

DATE

PLACE

PROOF OF SERVICE

SERVED

October 4,

2010

1010 N. St. Mary's Street,31S-A2 San Antonio, TX 78215

AT&T c/o/

Internet Services,

Inc.

SERVED ON (PRINT NAME)

Rhonda Compton, Legal Compliance

MANNER OF SERVICE

Facsimile to 707-435-6409

Hard Copy Vla U.S. Mail

TITLE

Plaintiffls Counsel

SERVED BY (PRINT NAME)

D. Gill Sperle in

DECLARATION OF SERVER

J declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that the foregoing information contained in the Proof of Service is tlUe and correct.

Executed on

10/4/2010

DATE

SIGNA TURE OF SERVER

584 Castro Street,

Suite 879

ADDRESS OF SERVER

San Francisco, CA

94114

Rule 45, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Subdivisions (c), (d), and (c), as amended on December I, 2006:

(c) PROTECTION OF PERSONS SUn.lECT TO SunpOENAS.

(1) A party or an attorney respousible for the issuance and service ofa subpoena shall take reasonable steps to avoid imposing undue burden 01" expense 011 a person subject to that subpoena. The court 011 behalf of which the subpoena was issued shall enforce this duty- and impose upon the party 01" attorney in breach of this duty an appropriate sanction, which may include, but is not limited to~ lost earnings and a reasonable attorney's fee.

(2) (A) A person commanded to produce and permit inspection, copying, testing, or sampling of designated electronically stored information, books, papers, documents or tangible things, or inspection of premises need not appear in person at the place of production or inspection unless commanded to appear for deposition, hearing or trial.

(B) Subject to paragraph (d)(2) of this rule. a person commanded to produce and permit inspec.ion, copying, testing, or sampling may, within 14 days after service of the subpoena or before the time specified for compliance if such time is less than 14 days after service, serve upon the party or attorney designated in the subpoena written objection to producing any or all of the designated materials or inspection of the premises- orto producing electronically stored informati on in the f011n or forms requested. If obj ection is made, the party serving the subpoena shall not be entitled to inspect, copy, test, or sample the materials or inspect the premises except pursuant to an order of the court by which the subpoena was issued, If objection hac, been made, the party serving the subpoena may, upon notice to the person commanded to produce, move at any time for an order to compel the production, inspection, copying, testing, or sampling. Such an order to compel shall protect anyperson who is not a party or an officer of'a.party from significant expense resulting from the inspection, copying, testing, or sampling commanded.

(3) (A) On timelymotior., the court bywhich a subpoena was issued shall quas.r or-modify the subpoena if it

(i) fails to allow reasonable time for compliance;

(ii) requires a person who is not a party or an officer of a party to travel to a place more than 100 mil es from the place where that person resides, is employed orregu larly transacts business in person, except that, subject to the provisions of clause (c)(3)(B)(iii) of this rule, such a person may in order to attend trial be commanded to travel from any such place within the state in which the hial is held;

(iii) requires disclosure of'privileged or other protected matter and no exception or waiver applies: or

(iv) subjects a person to undue burden. (B) Tfa subpoena

(1) requires disclosure ofa trade secret or other confidential research, development, or commercial informatinn, 01"

(ii) requires disclosure of an unretained expert's opinion or information not describing specific events or occurrences in dispute and resulting from the expert's study made not at the request of any party, or

(iii) requires a person who is not a party- or an officer of a party to incur substantial expense to travel more than 100 miles to attend trial, the court may, to protect a person subject

to or affected by the subpoena, quas.r or modify the subpoena or, if the party in whose behalf the subpoena is issued shows a substantial need for the testlmony or material that cannot be otherwise met without undue hardship and assures that the person to whom the subpoena is addressed will be reasor.ably compensated, the court may order appearance or production only upon specified conditions.

(d) DUTIES IN RESPOND1N(i TO SunpOENA.

(1) (A) A person responding to a subpoena to produce documents shall produce them as they are kept in the usual course of business or shall organize and label them to correspond with the categori es in the dem and.

(B) Tfa subpoena does not speci fy the f011u or forms for producing el ectronicallystored informu.ion, a person responding to a subpoena must produce the information in a f011n or forms in which the person ordinarily maintains it or in a f01111 or f01111S that are reasonably usable.

(e) A person responding to a subpoena need not produce the same electronically stored information in more than one f01111.

(D) A person responding to a subpoena need not provide discovery of electror.ically stored information from sources that the person identifies as not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or cost. On motion to compel discovery or to quash, the person from whom discovery is sought must show that the information sought is not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or cost If that showing is made, the court may nonetheless order discovery from such sources if the recuesting party shows good cause, considering the Ih111tatiD11s of Rule 2o(b )(2)«("). The court may specify conditions for the discovery.

(2) (A) When information subject to a subpoena is withheld on a claim that it is privileged or subject to protection as trial-preparation materials, the claim shall be made expressly and shall be supported by a description of the nature of the documents, communications, or things not produced that is sufficient to enable the demanding party to contest the claim.

(B) If information is produced in response to a subpoena that is subject to a claim of privilege or of protection as hi al-preparation material, the person making the cl aim maynotify any party that received the information of the claim and the basis for it, After being notified, a party must promptly return, sequester, or destroy the specified information and any copies it has and may not use or disclose the information until the claim is resolved. A receiving party may promptly present the information to the court under seal for a determination of the claim. If the receiving party disclosed the information before being notified, it must take reasonable steps to retrieve it, The person who produced the information must preserve the information until the claim is resolved.

(e) CONTE\-jPT. Failure of any person without adequate excuse to obey a subpoena served upon that person may be deemed a contempt of the court from which the subpoena issued. An adequate cause for failure to obey exists when a subpoena purports to recuire a nonparty to attend or produce at a place not within the Ih111ts provided by clause (11) of subparagraph (c)(3)(A).

From: D. Sperlein

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

II

Fax: +1 (415) 404-6616 To: Fax: +1 (707) 435-6409 Page 100f 1110/4/201012:48

Case3:10-cv-03647-MEJ Document10 Filed1 0104/1 0 Page1 of 2

2

[PROPOSSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF LEAVE TO TAKE EARLY DISCOVERY 10-3647 (MEJ)

3

D. GILL SPERLEIN (172887)

THE LAW OFFICE OF D. GILL SPERLEIN 584 Castro Street, Suite 879

San Francisco, California 94114 Telephone: (415) 404-6615 Facsimile: (415) 404-6616

4

5

6

gill ialsperleinlaw. com

7

Attorney for Plaintiff 10 GROUP, INC.

8

9

10

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

11

12

)

) CASE NO.: 10-3647 (MEJ) ) ) ) ) )

)

)

)

)

)

)

13

10 GROUP, INC. d/b/a TITAN J\AEDIAo a California corporation,

[PROPOSED) ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF LEAVE TO TAKE EARLY

14

15

16

Plaintiff,

DISCOVERY

vs.

17

18

DOES 1-244, individuals,

19

Defendants.

[PROPOgEDJ ORDER

Having considered Plaintiff s Miscellaneous Administrative Request Pursuant to Local Rule 7-11 for Leave to Take Discovery Prior to Rule 26 Conference and finding good cause therefore,

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, that Plaintiff is granted leave to take early discovery.

Plaintiff may immediately serve on AT&T Internet a subpoena or subpoenas to obtain subscriber

information for subscribers assigned IP addresses identified by Media Protector. Plaintiff's

-1-

From: D. Sperlein

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

II

Fax: +1 (415) 404-6616 To: Fax: +1 (707) 435-6409 Page 110f 11 10/4/2010 12:48

Case3:10-cv-03647-MEJ Document10 Filed1 0104/1 0 Page2 of 2

2

[PROPOSSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF LEAVE TO TAKE EARLY DISCOVERY 10-3647 (MEJ)

counsel shall issue the subpoena(s) in substantially in the same form as the example attached as

Exhibit A to Plaintiff's Miscellaneous Administrative Request for Leave to Take Discovery Prior

3

to Rule 26 Conference;

4

5

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, that subpoenas authorized by this order and issued

6

pursuant thereto shall be deemed appropriate court orders under 47 U.S.C. §551;

7

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, that AT&T Internet, Inc. shall have twenty-one (21) days

8

from the date they are served a copy of this order to respond to the subpoena in order that it may

9

10

have sufficient time to provide notice to the subscribers whose subscriber information Plaintiff

11

seeks to obtain thereby; and

12

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, that good faith attempts by AT&T, Internet, Inc. to notify

13

the subscribers shall constitute compliance with this order.

14

15

16

D d October 4, 2010 ate:

17

DGE MARIA-ELENA JAMES,

UNITED STA TES STRICT COURT

18

19

-2-