Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THROUGH
ENERGY EFFICIENCY
PROJECT ASSIGNMENT
SUBJECT: ENVIRONMENTAL LAW
SUBMITTED BY
R.L. BHUTIANI
I.D. NO.EL/702/07-08
C/O ENGINEERS INDIA LIMITED
BANGALORE – 21
DECLARATION
Certified that this Project Work is my original work and that I have
not taken or borrowed any material from other’s work nor have I
presented this partly or fully to any other institution / College /
University. I have complied with all the formalities prescribed in
this regard.
The global primary energy consumption at the end of 2002 was equivalent to 9405
million tonnes of oil equivalent (Mtoe). The Figure 1.3 shows in what proportions the
sources mentioned above contributed to this global figure.
The primary energy consumption for few of the developed and developing countries is
shown in Table 1.1. It may be seen that India’s absolute
th th th
primary energy consumption is only 1/29 of the world, 1/7 of USA, 1/1.6 time of
Japan but 1.1, 2.9, 1.3, 1.5 times of Canada, Australia, France and U.K respectively.
Table 1.1 Primary Energy Consumption by fuel (2002) in Million
Tonnes Oil Equivalent (Mtoe)
Although 80 percent of the world’s population lies in the developing countries (a fourfold
population increase in the past 25 years, their energy consumption amounts to only 40
percent of the world total energy consumption. The high standards of living in the
developed countries are attributable to high-energy consumption levels. Also, the rapid
population growth in the developing countries has kept the per capita energy consumption
low compared with that of highly industrialized developed countries.
The world average energy consumption per person is equivalent to 2.2 tonnes of coal. In
industrialized countries, people use four to five times more than the world average, and
nine times more than the average for the developing countries. An American uses 32
times more commercial energy than an Indian.
Coal Supply
India has huge coal reserves, at least 84,396 Million tonnes of proven recoverable
reserves (at the end of 2002). This amounts to almost 8.6% of the world reserves and it
may last for about 235 years at the current Reserve to Production (R/P) ratio. In contrast,
the world’s proven coal reserves are expected to last only for 204 years at the current R/P
ratio. India is the fourth largest producer of coal and lignite in the world. Coal production
is concentrated in these states (Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra,
Orissa, Jharkhand, West Bengal).
Oil Supply
Oil accounts for about 33 % of India's total energy consumption. While India has invested
considerable resources in this sector, the crude oil production has stagnated at around 32-
33 million metric tonnes per year over the past decade. The majority of India's roughly
5.4 billion barrels in oil reserves are located in the Bombay High, upper Assam, Cambay,
Krishna-Godavari, and Cauvery basins. India's average oil production level for 2002 was
793,000 barrels per day. The consumption continues to outstrip production and. about
70% of the total petroleum product demand is met by imports imposing a heavy burden
on foreign exchange. India had net oil imports of over 1.2 million barrels per day in 2002.
India’s annual current oil import bill is around Rs.80,000 crores. In terms of sector wise
petroleum product consumption, transport accounts for 53% followed by domestic and
industry with 18% and 17% respectively.
Table 1.2 Demand for Commercial Energy for Final Consumption (BAU
Scenario)
Source Units 1994-95 2001-02 2006-07 2011-12
Electricity Billion 289.36 480.08 712.67 1067.88
Units
Coal Million 76.67 109.01 134.99 173.47
Tonnes
Lignite Million 4.85 11.69 16.02 19.70
Tonnes
Natural Gas Million 9880 15730 18291 20853
Cubic
Meters
Oil Products Million 63.55 99.89 139.95 196.47
Tonnes
Source: Planning Commission BAU:_Business As Usual
Sector wise Energy Consumption in India
The major commercial energy consuming sectors in the country are classified as shown in
the Figure 1.5. As seen from the figure, industry remains the biggest consumer of
commercial energy and its share in the overall consumption is 49%. (Reference year:
1999/2000)
Economic growth is desirable for developing countries, and energy is essential for
economic growth. However, the relationship between economic growth and increased
energy demand is not always a straightforward linear one. For example, under present
conditions, a 6% increase in India's Gross Domestic Product (GDP) would impose an
increased demand of 9 % on its energy sector.
In this context, the ratio of energy demand to GDP is a useful indicator. A high ratio
reflects energy dependence and a strong influence of energy on GDP growth. It is
worthwhile to note that developed countries − by focusing on energy efficiency and lower
energy-intensive routes − maintain their energy to GDP ratios at values of less than 1. The
ratios for developing countries tend to be much higher.
Coal
Coal is the primary energy source for power production in India, generating
approximately 70% of total domestic electricity. Energy demand in India is expected to
increase over the next 10-15 years; although new oil and gas plants are planned, coal is
expected to remain the dominant fuel for power generation. Despite significant increases
in total installed capacity during the last decade, the gap between electricity supply and
demand continues to increase. The resulting shortfall has had a negative impact on
industrial output and economic growth. However, to meet expected future demand,
indigenous coal production will need to be greatly expanded. Production currently stands
at around 290 Million tonnes per year, but coal demand is expected to more than double
by 2010. Indian coal is typically of poor quality; Coal imports will also need to increase
dramatically to satisfy industrial and power generation requirements.
Oil
India's demand for petroleum products is likely to rise from 97.7 million tonnes in 2001-
02 to around 139.95 million tonnes in 2006-07, according to projections of the Tenth
Five-Year Plan. The plan document puts compound annual growth rate (CAGR) at 3.6 %
during the plan period. Domestic crude oil production is likely to rise marginally from
th
32.03 million tonnes in 2001-02 to 33.97 million tonnes by the end of the 10 plan period
(2006-07). As shown in the figure 1.8, around 92% of India’s total oil demand by 2020
has to be met by imports.
Figure 1.8 India’s Oil Balance
Natural Gas
India's natural gas production is likely to rise from 86.56 million cmpd in 2002-03 to
103.08 million cmpd in 2006-07. It is mainly based on the strength of a more than
doubling of production by private operators to 38.25 mm cmpd.
Electricity
India currently has a peak demand shortage of around 14% and an energy deficit of 8.4%.
Keeping this in view and to maintain a GDP (gross domestic product) growth of 8% to
10%, the Government of India has very prudently set a target of 215,804 MW power
generation capacity by March 2012 from the level of 100,010 MW as on March 2001,
that is a capacity addition of 115,794 MW in the next 11 years (Table 1.3).
In the area of nuclear power the objective is to achieve 20,000 MW of nuclear generation
capacity by the year 2020.
Table 1.3 India’s Perspective Plan For Power For Zero Deficit Power By 2011/12
(Source Tenth And Eleventh Five-Year Plan Projections)
Thermal (Coal) Gas / LNG /
Nuclear (MW) Hydro (MW) Total(MW)
(MW) Diesel (MW)
Installed
Gas: 10,153
capacity as on 61,157 2720 25,116 100,010
Diesel: 864
March 2001
Additional
capacity 53,333 20,408 9380 32,673 115,794
(2001-2012)
Total capacity
114,490 31,425 57,789
as on March 12,100 (5.6%) 215,804
(53.0%) (14.6%) (26.8%)
2012
Building stockpiles
Demand restraint,
Energy efficiency
Sustainable development
Although all these options are feasible, their implementation will take time. Also, for
countries like India, reliance on stockpiles would tend to be slow because of resource
constraints. Besides, the market is not sophisticated enough or the monitoring agencies
experienced enough to predict the supply situation in time to take necessary action.
Insufficient storage capacity is another cause for worry and needs to be augmented, if
India has to increase its energy stockpile.
However, out of all these options, the simplest and the most easily attainable is reducing
demand through persistent energy conservation efforts.
Figure 1.15
Energy efficiency is often viewed as a resource option like coal, oil or natural gas. It
provides additional economic value by preserving the resource base and reducing
pollution. For example, replacing traditional light bulbs with Compact Fluorescent Lamps
(CFLs) means you will use only 1/4th of the energy to light a room. Pollution levels also
reduce by the same amount. Nature sets some basic limits on how efficiently energy can
be used, but in most cases our products and manufacturing processes are still a long way
from operating at this theoretical limit. Very simply, energy efficiency means using less
energy to perform the same function.
Although, energy efficiency has been in practice ever since the first oil crisis in 1973, it
has today assumed even more importance because of being the most cost-effective and
reliable means of mitigating the global climatic change. Recognition of that potential has
led to high expectations for the control of future CO2 emissions through even more energy
efficiency improvements than have occurred in the past. The industrial sector accounts for
some 41 per cent of global primary energy demand and approximately the same share of
CO2 emissions.
In this paper terms Energy Conservation & Energy Efficiency are used
interchangeably.
The benefits of Energy conservation for various players are given below
Nation - Reduced energy imports, Avoided costs can be used for poverty
reduction, Conservation of limited resources, Improved energy security
Air Pollution
carbons (CFC) emissions from refrigerants use, etc. In chemical and fertilizers industries,
toxic gases are released. Cement plants and power plants spew out particulate matter.
Sources of major pollutants in air and average composition of pollutants are given in
Table 1.4 and Table 1.5 respectively.
been in balance during the centuries with carbon dioxide being absorbed by terrestrial
vegetation and the oceans.
The key greenhouse gases driving global warming are shown in Figure 1.12. Carbon
dioxide (54%), whose increase is largely produced by the burning of fossil fuels, is the
primary global warming gas. CFC's (21%), even though they exist in very small
quantities, are significant contributors to global warming. And, (while not shown in
Figure 1.12), perfluorocarbons (PFC's), sulfur hexafluoride (SF6) and hydro
fluorocarbons (HFC's) are other growing contributors.
Carbondioxide, one of the most prevalent greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, has two
major anthropogenic (human-caused) sources: the combustion of fossil fuels and changes
in land use (see figure:1.13). Net releases of carbon dioxide from these two sources are
believed to be contributing to the rapid rise in atmospheric concentrations since pre-
industrial times.
Acid Rain
Acid rain is caused by release of SOX and NOX from combustion of fossil fuels, which
then mix with water vapour in atmosphere to form sulphuric and nitric acids respectively.
The effects of acid rain are as follows:
Many options for limiting emissions are available in the short- and medium-term
Policymakers can encourage energy efficiency and other climate-friendly trends in both
the supply and consumption of energy. Key consumers of energy include industries,
homes, offices, vehicles, and agriculture. Efficiency can be improved in large part by
providing an appropriate economic and regulatory framework for consumers and
investors. This framework should promote cost-effective actions, the best current and
future technologies, and innovative solutions that make economic and environmental
sense irrespective of climate change. Taxes, regulatory standards, tradable emissions
permits, information programmes, voluntary programmes, and the phase-out of
counterproductive subsidies can all play a role. Changes in practices and lifestyles, from
better urban transport planning to personal habits such as turning out the lights, are also
important.
The international response to climate change took shape with the development of the
United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). Agreed to in
1992, the UNFCCC set out a framework for action to control or cut greenhouse gas
emissions. The UNFCC was signed by most nations, including a voluntary pledge that the
developed countries would reduce their emissions to 1990 levels by the year 2000. With
scientific evidence pointing towards increasing destructive contribution of human
activity, It became clear that most countries would be unable to uphold their promises. All
the nations, who initially ratified the UNFCC, reconvened in form of Conference of
Parties (COP) at Berlin in 1995 with a goal of entering into negotiations on a protocol to
establish legally binding limitations or reductions in emissions. The event was called
COP-1 and was the first session of what became an annual meeting to analyse the
efficacy of climatic change program, review scientific data and monitor the emission
commitments declared by certain countries.
Since the UNFCCC entered into force in 1994, five meetings of the Conference of the
Parties have taken place, as well as numerous workshops and meetings of the UNFCCC's
subsidiary bodies. A Protocol to the Convention was adopted in 1997 at the Third
Conference of the Parties, held in Kyoto. Although it has yet to enter into force, the
UNFCCC's Kyoto Protocol commits industrialized countries to achieve quantified targets
for decreasing their emissions of greenhouse gases.
Emissions Reductions
The United States would be obligated under the Protocol to a cumulative reduction in its
greenhouse gas emissions of 7% below 1990 levels for three greenhouse gases (including
carbon dioxide), and below 1995 levels for the three man-made gases, averaged over the
commitment period 2008 to 2012.
The Protocol states that “developed countries are committed, individually or jointly, to
ensuring that their aggregate anthropogenic carbon dioxide equivalent emissions of
greenhouse gases do not exceed amounts assigned to each country” in Annex A to the
Protocol, "with a view to reducing their overall emissions of such gases by at least 5%
below 1990 levels in the commitment period 2008 to 2012.
39 nations have signed the protocol, including the United States, the European Union plus
the individual EU nations, Japan, and many of the former Communist nations. The
amounts for each country are listed as percentages of the base year, 1990 and range from
92% (a reduction of 8%) for most European countries--to 110% (an increase of 10%) for
Iceland.
Developing Country Responsibilities
Another problematic area is that the treaty is ambiguous regarding the extent to which
developing nations will participate in the effort to limit global emissions. The original
1992 climate treaty made it clear that, while the developed nations most responsible for
the current buildup of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere should take the lead in
combating climate change, developing nations also have a role to play in protecting the
global climate. Per Capita CO2 emissions are small in developing countries and developed
nations have altered the atmosphere the most as shown in the figures 9.2 & 9.3.
The Kyoto Protocol does call on all Parties--developed and developing--to take a number
of steps to formulate national and regional programs to improve "local emission factors,"
activity data, models, and national inventories of greenhouse gas emissions and sinks that
remove these gases from the atmosphere. All Parties are also committed to formulate,
publish, and update climate change mitigation and adaptation measures, and to cooperate
in promotion and transfer of environmentally sound technologies and in scientific and
technical research on the climate system.
India has ratified the contentious Kyoto Protocol in August 2002. However, the Kyoto
Protocol does not set any binding limits on developing nation emissions, nor does it
establish a mechanism or timetable for these countries to take on such limits voluntarily.
On the other hand, the Protocol does establish a so-called Clean Development
Mechanism, which allows developed countries to invest in projects in developing
countries that reduce greenhouse gas emissions and receive credit for the reductions. The
intent is to help developing nations minimize their emissions even as they develop their
energy sectors and expand their economies.
below the world average of 3.87t per annum. Fossil fuel emissions in India continue
to result largely from coal burning. India is highly vulnerable to climate change as
its economy is heavily reliant on climate sensitive sectors like agriculture and
forestry. The vast low-lying and densely populated coastline is susceptible to rise in
sea level.
The energy sector is the largest contributor of carbon dioxide emissions in India. The
national inventory of greenhouse gases under ALGAS (Asia-Least Cost Greenhouse Gas
Abatement Strategy) project (funded by the Asian Development Bank, Global
Environment Facility and United Nations Development Program) indicates that 55% of
the total national emissions come from energy sector. These include emissions from road
transport, burning of traditional bio-mass fuels, coal mining, and fugitive emissions from
oil and natural gas. Agriculture sector constitutes the next major contributor, accounting
for nearly 34%. The emissions under this sector include those from enteric fermentation
in domestic animals, manure management, rice cultivation, and burning of agriculture
residues. Emissions from Industrial sector mainly came from cement production. India is
the fourth largest producer of cement after China, Japan and the United States. The
ALGAS study presents the latest set of projections of greenhouse gas emissions from
India.
The CDM will be supervised by an executive board, and a share of the proceeds from
project activities will be used to assist developing countries in meeting the costs of
adaptation to climate change.
The National Environment Policy, 2006, provides the basis for the integration of
environmental considerations in the policies of various sectors. The Policy Statement for
Abatement of Pollution, 1992, stresses the prevention of pollution at the source based on
the “polluter pays” principle.
The Forest Policy, 1988, highlights environmental protection through preservation and
restoration of the ecological balance. The policy seeks to substantially increase the forest
cover in the country through afforestation programs.
The Ministry of New & Renewable Energy, the Bureau of Energy Efficiency, and the
Technology Information Forecasting & Assessment Council, have specific mandates to
promote clean energy technologies.
The statutory framework for the environment and energy efficiency includes the Indian
Forests Act, 1927, the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974, the Air
(Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981, the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, and
the Environment Protection) Act, 1986. Other enactments include the Public Liability
Insurance Act, 1991, the National Environment Tribunal Act, 1995, the National
Environment Appellate Authority Act, 1997, the Energy Conservation Act, 2001, and the
Electricity Act, 2003. The courts have also elaborated on the concepts relating to
sustainable development, and the ‘polluter pays’ and ‘precautionary’ principles. In India,
matters of public
interest, particularly pertaining to the environment, are articulated effectively through a
vigilant media, an active NGO community, and through the judicial process which has
recognized the citizen’s right to a clean environment as a component of the right to life
and liberty.
Addressing climate change mitigation and adaptation involves many stakeholders, cuts
across short and long timeframes, and requires that all development projects be assessed
for their sensitivity to climate concerns. This integration of climate concerns in the
development process
has been mainstreamed in India through high-level multi stake holder committees.
The National Committee to Assess the Impacts of Climate Change is chaired by the
Principal Scientific Advisor to the Prime Minister, and includes meteorologists, climate
modelers, hydrologists, energy economists, as well as representatives of key Ministries.
The Committee is evaluating the impact of climate change on key development activities,
and assessing options to mitigate climate risks.
Climate change is integrated into the national development planning process, and
overseen by the Prime Minister’s Council on Climate change, which includes
representation of key Ministries, as well as experts, and representatives of industry and of
media. The Council provides overall strategic guidance on mainstreaming climate change
in development, identifies key intervention priorities, and monitors the implementation of
these interventions.
Chapter 2
Energy Security & Environment
India faces formidable challenges in meeting its energy needs and providing adequate
energy of desired quality in various forms to users in a sustainable manner and at
reasonable costs. India needs to sustain a 8% to 10% economic growth to eradicate
poverty and meet its economic & human development goals. Such economic growth
would call for increased demand for energy and ensuring access to clean, convenient and
reliable energy for all to address human evelopment. To deliver a sustained growth of 8%
through 2031, India would, in the very least, need to grow its primary energy supply by 3
to 4 times and electricity supply by 5 to 7 times of today's consumption. Along with
quantity the quality of energy supply has to also improve. The energy challenge is of
fundamental importance to India's economic growth imperatives.
The energy strategy for the future could be classified into immediate, medium- and long-
term strategy. The various components of these strategies are listed below:
Immediate-term strategy:
• Promoting R&D, transfer and use of technologies and practices for environmentally
sound energy systems, including new and renewable energy sources.
Medium-term strategy:
• There is need to move away from non-renewable to renewable energy sources viz.
solar, wind, biomass energy, etc.
Long-term strategy:
1.3.1 Hydro
India is duly concerned about climate change and efforts are on to promote
benign sources of energy. Hydro Power is one such source and is to be accorded priority
also from the consideration of energy security. Irrespective of size and nature of hydro
projects, whether ROR or Storage projects, these are all renewable technologies.
However, execution of hydro projects requires thorough Survey and Investigation,
preparation of DPR, development of infrastructure, EIA and other preparatory works,
which are time consuming and require two to three years for their preparation. It would
take about 5 years to execute a hydro project after the work is awarded for construction.
Thus in order to achieve completion of a hydro project during 11th plan, the project
should either be already under construction or execution should start at the beginning of
the plan. The broad criteria adopted for selection of hydro projects for 11th plan are as
under:
• Those hydro projects whose concurrence has been issued by CEA and
order for main civil works is likely to be placed by March 2007.
• Apart from the above, a few hydro projects of smaller capacity which are
ROR type having surface power houses and where gestation period is
expected to be less than 5 years have also been included. These projects
would need to be rigorously followed up for completion during the 11th
Plan.
Keeping in view the preparedness of various hydro projects, a capacity addition
of 15, 585 MW is envisaged for 11th Plan.
1.3.2 Nuclear
Nuclear is environmentally benign source of energy and over a period of time, its
proportion in total capacity should increase. Keeping in view the availability of fuel, a
moderate capacity addition of 3,160 MW nuclear plants has been programmed during the
11th Plan by the Nuclear Power Corporation. All projects are presently under
construction. However, in view of the recent developments in the Nuclear Sector,
capacity addition in nuclear plants during 12th Plan is expected to be much higher.
1.3.3 Thermal
Gas
Although gas is relatively a clean fuel, at present there is uncertainty about
the availability, period of availability and price of gas. Only 2,114 MW gas
based capacity has been planned for 11th Plan where gas supply has already
been tied up. This does not include NTPC’s gas based projects at Kawas and
Gandhar, totalling to 2,600 MW, for which NTPC says that it has the gas
supply contract but the matter is sub-judice. However more gas based
projects could be taken up for construction as and when there is more clarity
about availability and price of gas.
Coal & Lignite based Thermal plants
Coal is expected to be main stay of power generation in the years to come.
The following criteria have been adopted for identifying the coal and lignite
based projects for inclusion in the 11th plan.
• Such projects as have already been taken up for execution in the 10th Plan period itself
and are due for commissioning in the 11th Plan period.
• Those thermal projects whose LOA has already been placed by the State and Central
Public Sector Corporations, other inputs also being in place.
• Those thermal projects whose LOA has already been placed and the financial closure
achieved by private developers.
• Those thermal projects whose LOA is expected to be placed by 30th Sept, 2008 and
commissioning is expected during the 11th Plan keeping in view the normal gestation
period, the size of the plant & the type(green field/expansion).
After discussion with the various State Government and Central Generating
Companies, thermal projects with total capacity of 46,635 MW of coal based and
1375 MW lignite based capacity have been identified for capacity addition during
11th plan.
There are no projections world-wide that show a lowering of dependence on fossil fuels
by 2031-32. Oil and gas are forecast to remain in a tight demand-supply balance and the
likelihood is that most new oil and gas will come from a politically uncertain middle-east.
Such a global backdrop as resulted in high price volatility for oil & gas. Further, energy
security concerns are driving key consumers such as the US, China and Japan (that
together account for some 40% of the world's primary energy consumption) to seek coal -
the world's most abundant fossil fuel. This has also led to a push world-wide for clean
coal technologies, carbon sequestration coal to liquids and the zero emission initiative.
Coal shall remain India's most important energy source till 2031-32 and possibly beyond.
India will need to take a lead in seeking clean coal technologies and, given its growing
demand, new coal extraction technologies such as in-situ gasification to tap its vast coal
reserves that are difficult to extract economically using conventional technologies.
The broad vision behind the energy policy is to reliably meet the demand for energy
services of all sectors including the lifeline energy needs of vulnerable households, in all
parts of the country, with safe and convenient energy at the least cost in a technically
efficient, economically viable and sustainable manner.
Meeting this vision would require that India pursues all available fuel options and forms
of energy, both conventional and non-conventional, as well as new and emerging
technologies and energy sources.
Some key recommendations by the Committee on Draft Integrated Energy Policy are
summarised below:
(i) Coal Shall Remain India's Primary Energy Source till 2031-32, Current shortages are a
oncern. Coal accounts for over 50% of India's commercial energy consumption and some
78% of domestic coal production is dedicated to power generation.
(iii) Power Sector Reforms must focus on control over Aggregate Technical and
Commercial (AT&C) losses of state power utilities. To control AT&C losses the
Committee recommends that the existing Accelerated Power Development and Reform
Programme (APDRP) be restructured to ensure energy flow auditing at the distribution
transformer level through automated meter reading, geographical information system
(GIS) mapping of the network and consumers and separation of feeders for agricultural
pumps. This will fix accountability and provide a baseline which is an essential
prerequisite to privatisation.
The Committee feels that it is essential to separate the cost of the pure wires business
(carriage) from the energy business (content) in both transmission & distribution.
Electricity Act 2003 recognises such separation for the transmission
(iv) Reduce Cost of Power: In terms of purchasing power parity, power tariffs in India for
industry, commerce & large households are among the highest in the world.
(v) Rationalise Fuel Prices: Relative prices play the most important role in choice of fuel
and energy form. They are thus the most vital aspect of Integrated Energy Policy that
promotes efficient fuel choices and facilitates appropriate substitution. In a competitive
set up, the marginal use value of different fuels, which are substitutes, is equal at a given
place and time and the prices of different fuels at different places do not differ by more
than the cost of transporting the fuels. Then the resulting inter-fuel choices would be
economically efficient.
(vi) Central and State taxes on commercial energy supplies need to be rationalized to
yield optimal fuel choices and investment decisions. Relative prices of fuels can be
distorted if taxes and subsidies are not equivalent across fuels. The equivalence should be
in term of effective calorie. In other words they should be such that producer and
consumer choices as to which fuel and which technology to use are not affected by the
taxes and subsidies.
Environmental taxes and subsidies, however, are levied to affect choices. Differential
taxes can be justified here if they appropriately reflect environmental externalities. A
consistent application of polluter pays principle or consumer pays principle should be
made to attain environmental objectives at least cost.
(vii) Energy Efficiency and Demand Side Management: Lowering energy intensity of
GDP growth through higher energy efficiency is key to meeting India's energy challenge
& ensuring its energy security.
Over the past decade, gains in both poverty reduction and economic growth have been
significant, and supported by energy growth, which has been significantly lower than the
economic growth. This reduced energy intensity of the economy, in the period since
2004, has been marked by an economic growth rate of over 9% per annum, which has
been achieved with an energy growth of less than 4% per annum.
These policies have been driven by the imperatives of sustainable development, and have,
as a co-benefit, led to a decline in the intensity of energy use and carbon dioxide
emissions as well.
Figure 2(a) illustrates the declining trend in energy use and CO2 emissions intensities,
and Figure 2 (b) highlights that the energy intensity of the Indian economy compares
favourably with those of other major economies.
Fig. 2(a): Emissions and Energy Intensity Trends in India
Fig. 2(b): Total Primary Energy Intensities of the Major Economies
Thus, clearly there is room to improve and energy intensity can be brought down
significantly in India with current commercially available technologies. India would need
to and must succeed in achieving much lower energy intensity compared to its current
level. Lowering energy intensity through higher efficiency is like creating a virtual source
of untapped domestic energy. It may be noted that a unit of energy saved by a user is
greater than a unit produced, as it saves on production losses, as well as transport,
transmission and distribution losses. Thus a "Megawatt", produced by reducing energy
need saves more than a Megawatt generated. The Committee feels that upto 25 percent
reduction in India's energy intensity is possible overn current levels.
This reduced energy intensity, at the relatively low level of India’s per-capita GDP, has
been made possible by a range of factors, including India’s historically sustainable
patterns of consumption, enhanced competitiveness, proactive policies to promote energy
efficiency, and more recently, the use of the Clean Development Mechanism to accelerate
the adoption of clean energy technologies.
Fig. 3: CO2 Emissions from the Food Sector – from field (Production) to
Table (processed food), excluding cooking
The high ratio of recycling in India, compared to that of other major economies in Figure
4, has also limited the growth in energy use, and GHG emissions, because of the lower
demand for virgin material such as steel, aluminum and copper.
Fig. 4: Recycling Ratios in Major Economies
Figure 5(b): Trends in specific energy consumption in the Indian iron &
steel sector
Integrated Energy Policy (IEP) laid out a vision of providing energy security to all
citizens. IEP emphasizes energy efficiency & demand side management as essential
components of the natural energy strategy.
Street lighting and municipal water pumping put excessive pressure on electric utilities.
Quite a few of studies/projects have been successfully demonstrated in some states. In the
11th Plan, such projects will be identified, documented and disseminated nation wide.
Further, to promote such projects in various states, SDAs in association with State
utilities will initiate pilot energy conservation projects in selected municipal water
pumping systems and street lighting to provide basis for designing state level
programmes.
(f) Agriculture Sector
Increasing energy consumption trend is being seen in irrigation systems in the sector. Due
to low power tariff for the sector in majority of the States, it is not in the farmers’
financial interest to buy efficient pumps, but it may be in the utility’s interest to promote
their use.
In the 11th Plan, SDAs will collect, document and disseminate information on successful
projects implemented by some states, launch awareness campaign in all regional
languages in print and electronic media and follow up work in initiating state level
programmes along with utilities.
SDAs with assistance of concerned institutions will also develop suitable energy
conservation models which will take into consideration measures like introduction of
subsidy in replacement of inefficient pump sets with efficient ones, power factor
improvement by installation of capacitor banks, rebate for optimum usage of pumps,
energy efficiency labeling of pumps, etc. These models will be subsequently promoted
through the electricity utilities/distribution companies and SDAs with
involvement of State Regulatory Commissions.
(g) Transport Sector
The sector is mainly dependent on the petroleum products. In the 11th Five-Year Plan,
SDAs will develop linkages with State Road Transport Undertakings and private
enterprises owning large fleet of trucks/buses to establish the status of energy
consumption and conservation in the sector. SDAs with assistance of concerned
institutions/agencies will conduct diagnostic studies to support urban bodies and transport
research organizations in adopting multi modal public transport system which shall shift
demand from personalized to public transport. SDAs will develop linkages with the state
transport undertakings to establish the status of energy consumption and conservation
potential and support studies to promote public transportation systems. BEE will also set
up norms for specific fuel consumption for a few automobile and Transport models
(Services/ Public transport).
4.3.6 Demand Side Management Programmes
DSM programmes driven by State Utilities has made a beginning in India, though these
are yet to pick up momentum. In the 11th Plan, BEE in association with SDAs will
facilitate State Utilities to pursue DSM options more intensely by focusing on the
following:
• Orientation workshops for awareness building on DSM amongst the State Electricity
Regulatory Commissions (SERCs) and the chief executives and senior engineers of
utilities/ DISCOMs.
• Setting up of DSM cells in utilities to conceive and implement DSM programs.
• Support load research and studies to rationalize the tariff structures to encourage options
such as time-of-use rates or interruptible rates to capture the needs and opportunities of
different market segments.
• Initiation of DSM programmes especially in the sectors (such as residential, agricultural
pumping, municipal water works & street lighting) where customers are paying tariff far
below the marginal cost of power
• Utilization of private sector energy service providers to market DSM program to
consumers to maximize uptake, participation and Implementation of DSM programmes
through ESCO route
• Development of pilot tariff based incentive schemes to reward utilities/DISCOMs
through Megawatt (Watts saved) through Ministry of Power for Megawatt savings
implemented (actual realized after implementation & verification by SERCs).
• Utilities that have established appropriate DSM cells would be rewarded by state
electricity regulators for initiatives involved in DSM bidding, load research studies,
impact monitoring while fixing tariffs. • For supplementing DSM programs, supply side
initiatives such as segregation of feeders, high voltage distribution system (HVDS), etc
will be taken up with
support under the state funding and other programs such as Accelerated
Power Development and Reform Program (APDRP) on a case-to-case basis.
ESCO route for implementing the programs. Details are
furnished in Cl.4.5
Recommendations of Two-Day All India Seminar on "Save Energy for Global Energy
Security" 11th and 12th November 2006
Conclusions:
As a pleasant coincidence, Shri R.V. Shahi, Secretary, Ministry of Power, Govt. of India
delivered Dr. Narla Tata Rao Endowment lecture on, "Technology Solutions to Power
Sector Problems" on the first day of the seminar from the same platform. The following
observations made by him corroborate the sentiments of the seminar participants.
"While on one hand we need to expand our generation capacity base from about 1,28,000
MW (as in year 2006) to about 8,00,000 MW in the next 25 years, indigenous resources
are not unlimited - hydroelectric potential -1,50,000MW, coal based capacity can be
much larger, but coal reserves - particularly, exploitable reserves - do put question mark.
Support from petroleum fuel like gas could be only marginal. Nuclear is a good option,
but even for present about 3,000MW capacity fuel is an issue".
"Solar energy could also be a great potential. But so far, technological advancements have
not reached a stage that the capital cost is anywhere near the affordable range. Indian
Climatic conditions are highly favorable to harnessing this huge potential. We have to go
beyond photovoltaic systems and harness this energy in a bigger way".
"It must be recognized that while India faces about 11% of peaking shortages, it is also
the ground reality that the consumption of electricity in the country is one of the most
inefficient. Approximately 23% of electricity is wasted because of inefficient methods of
consumption".
Recommendations:
General :
Task forces should be constituted by the Central and State Governments under the
respective Power Ministries to prevent the impending disaster of extinguishing
conventional energy resources and ensure lasting Energy Security.
For sustained Energy Security, the desired energy mix of the total estimated requirement
of 800,000MW of power for India by 2030 is approximately 25% each of conventional
energy, energy efficiency, solar energy and other renewable energies.
Planning Commission should include items of Renewable Energy & Energy Efficiency in
exclusive slots in 5 Year Plans and meticulously monitor them for compliance. A 5%
addition in each 5-year Plan could achieve the desired 25% by 2030.
Renewable Energy:
Globally, solar energy generating stations should be set up. Simultaneously, R&D activity
should be intensified to bring down the cost of solar installations to affordable levels.
USAID, World Energy Council and other International Energy Agencies should
undertake this responsibility.
World Energy Council and other Internal Energy Agencies should also hasten up the
R&D to develop fuel cell and other promising renewable energies, post haste. Results of
R&D should be shared with all countries, world over.
Deserts and other best locations with abundance of solar insolation should be identified
by the world energy bodies and assistance should be rendered to the countries concerned
to set up massive solar thermal installations.
Being abundantly blessed with solar energy free, India should assume leadership in Solar
Power Generation and avail it as a business opportunity as in the IT field.
High cost of solar power generation is a mind-set. Cost will come down with R&D and
volumes, as in the case of electronics. Government should break the vicious circle of
costs and volumes by determination and will to take the first stride to the goal of Energy
Security.
To begin with, one unit of an existing thermal power plant should be hybridized with
backup integration of solar steam generating equipment. With power generating
equipment and all other infrastructure already in place, the additional solar equipment and
its integration should be affordable. 20-25% saving in coal during solar-mode operation
of the power plant in the daytime could justify the investment.
A competent consulting organization such as TERI should be immediately commissioned
to prepare a feasibility report for a Power plant owned by NTPC or any other Utility.
TERI could immediately send a questionnaire to all major power plants to identify the
best suitable site.
NTPC, State Utilities and all major players in power generation Industry should add solar
thermal power plants to the tune of 5% of the capacity of their installations. Taking the
advantage of 100% depreciation in the first year on Solar Power Plants the incremental
cost of average generation (the difference between increase in fixed cost and decrease in
variable cost) would be nominal. Soft loans could decrease the burden of investment
available for such installations; Carbon credit could further slash the cost down to
affordable level. Reduction in the cost of pollution control (e.g. Electrostatic
precipitation, ash disposal etc.) is also a favourable factor of economy for Solar Thermal
Power Plants.
Govt. should forth-with establish an R&D center for Solar Energy Research
independently or in the fold of CSIR. IIT's could be utilized as satellite facilities for this
center.
Big industrial houses like Tata, Reliance, Suzlon, ITC etc. should focus on measurable
R&D work of Renewable energy sources viz. Solar, Wind and Bio-fuels on a time-bound
basis.
According to Economic Times - Nov 2, 2006, "a quarter of fresh global research
investments is flowing into India and the country is now favourite R&D hub for
multinationals". This situation could be exploited to setup a Global R&D center for Solar
Energy in India funded by multinationals / NRI's.
Fuel cell is recognized as a promising renewable energy resource. BHEL is presently
conducting research in this area. This needs to be intensified with time-bound targets.
56% of Rural India is still far from electricity. Distributed generation by bio-gas / bio-
fuels and Solar-Wind Hybrid Plants is the best answer to electrify Rural India.
Demonstration Plants should be installed in every State through Center-State
collaboration. Private parties can also be encouraged to set up Distributed Power
Generation Plants.
Energy Efficiency:
The US-India Energy Efficiency Technology Conference organized by the Ministry of
Power, Govt. of India, in May 2006 proposed the establishment of 6 Nos. Regional
Energy Efficiency Centers in the country. Bangalore having been chosen for one of the
two centers proposed for southern region, Hyderabad merits the choice for the second
center. Energy Conservation Mission, an integral wing of The Institution of Engineers
(India) AP State Center, is already working as a voluntary center for energy efficiency
and can provide the basic infrastructure for REEC at Hyderabad.
23% of energy saving potential equivalent to twice the quantum, as deemed generation,
should be treated as a regular Power-House and operated for sustained energy security.
This generation is possible at much less cost and time. Intensified DSM measures should
be implemented by all Utilities.
Energy Smartness is more than energy efficiency. Energy Smart Labeling of Industry /
Commercial Establishment, analogous to Labeling of products can motivate them to
embrace energy efficiency and beyond. Energy Smart Standard-2006 drafted by ECM
was presented to the seminar and is expected to be released during the Energy
Conservation Week in December 2006. Center and States should recognize star
performers certified by the ESS-2006 for incentives and concessions.
The Energy conservation Act must be implemented in letter and spirit, Standards for
priority items already identified for S&L programme must be finalized immediately.
Notification for enforcement of the act effective March 1, 2007, as envisaged under the
act, must be issued forthwith.
The present level of consumption of 15% for lighting should be brought down to 10%.
Budget concession for CFL & LED lights and other energy saving items should be taken
up with Finance Ministry for incorporation in the ensuing Budget.
All Utilities should have exclusive energy Conservation cell with specific targets for
reduction of T&D losses by 5% every year and implement DSM measures to reduce
Agricultural consumption by 5% every year.
Chapter 3
Electric Power
Working Group on Power for 11th Plan
Chapter 4
Industry
Energy Intensive Industries
Gazette of India Notification Extraordinary Part II – Section 3 – Sub-section –(ii) No. 288 Dated March 19,
2007
In exercise of powers conferred under section (e) & (f) of the Section 14 of The Energy
Conservation act, 2001 the Central Government in consultation with Bureau of Energy
Efficiency hereby alters the list of Energy Intensive Industries and theother
establishments specified in the schedule of the said Act, namely
Chapter 5
Oil & Gas, Transport
Some very informative statistics regarding status of Indian Economy & Petroleum &
Natural Gas have been furnished by Ministry of Petroleum & Natural Gas in their official
web-site http://petroleum.nic.in/petstat.pdf visited on 10 April, 2008. Same are reproducd
as pdf document in attached sheets. On analysis, following observations may be noted.
Despite the discovery of new sources of unconventional energy, petroleum remains the
primary energy source in India, and even more so, all over the world. The consumption of
petroleum in the world, which started as a few tonnes a year around 140 years ago, has
touched almost 4000 Million metric tonnes (MMT) per year! Even in India, it is
increasing at a very steep rate from 3.5 MMT in 1950-51 to 150 MMT in 2006-2007.
Out of the known reserves, only a part may be technically economically feasible to
explore. This fact, coupled with the present and expected consumption rates implies that
these reserves may not last beyond the next 30 years. For India, the situation could be
even more difficult. Given our limited reserves, our present known stocks may not last
even 10 years at the current consumption rate. Our present indigenous production has
levelled to about 33 -34 MMT and is less than 50% of our annual requirement.
As a result of situation in the Middle East, weakening of US Dollar and uncertainties over
demand & supply, international price of crude has risen to exhorbiant level of over 100
US Dollars per barrel. Total value of imports of crude crude oil during 2007 –08 may
have exceeded Rs. 2500 Billions which is over one third of India’s total exports. Needless
to say that this is putting tremendous strain on Indian economy.
In order to to reduce ever increasing gap between demand for and indigenous supply of
crude oil and petroleum products, very high priority is required for the conservation of
petroleum products by its judicious use, substituting it by other resources wherever
feasible and restricting its use only to the essential needs.
Oil and gas conservation means their better and more efficient use with regard to
economic, social or environmental costs and benefits, resulting in attainment of higher
energy use efficiencies, minimization of wasteful practices and wastage and protection of
the environment.
Following specific activities are taken up from time to time.
C) Action Plan is implemented to produce and sell high grade lubricants to the extent of
about 2.5 lakh tonnes per year to replace the lubricants of lower efficiency, in a phased
manner and constantly upgrade lubricants in line with the international developments
meeting Euro Standards. Multi-grade railroad engine oils with diesel saving potential
have been developed for introduction in Indian Railways.
D) Although transport losses are inevitable while moving the petroleum products by
import tankers and coastal tankers over sea routes and at ports of unloading, a number of
steps taken by the Ministry to keep the loss down to the lowest level have led to a
progressive reduction.
As a part of the Government’s response to the oil crisis of early seventies, the PCRA was
set up in 1976 to undertake studies to identify the potential and to make recommendations
for achieving conservation of petroleum products in various sectors of the economy.
It’s Mission Statement is “Efficient energy utilisation and environment protection
leading to improvement in quality of life”
Main objectives of PCRA are given below:-
To formulate strategy and promote measures for accelerating conservation of
petroleum products leading to environment protection, energy security and
sustainable development.
To create awareness among masses about the importance, benefits and methods of
conserving petroleum products and clean environment by enhancing information
and capacity building.
To promote research, development and deployment efforts aimed at petroleum
conservation & environment protection, support and facilitate efforts for adoption
& dissemination of energy efficient technologies and substitution of petroleum
products with alternate fuels and renewables.
To establish synergistic institutional linkages at the national & internatiopnal level
in the area of petroleum conservation and environment protection.
To provide training and technical advisory services, designed to use economy &
efficiency in use of petroleum products for cleaner environment.
To function as Think Tank to The Govt. Of India for proposing policies and
strategies on petroleum conservation and environemnt protection aimed at
reducing excessive dependence on oil.
It sponsors R&D activities for the development of fuel-efficient equipment / devices and
organizes multi-media campaigns for creating mass awareness for the conservation of
petroleum products. Fuel oil utilization studies, energy audits, boiler modernization
scheme, introduction of equipment bank concept, use of energy vans, development of oil
consumption norms, model depot projects, driver training programs, demonstration
clinics/ workshops/ exhibitions, consumer meets, education films/TV spots, hoarding/
electronic display, distribution of printed literature, R&D projects are other activities.
In addition to the activities of PCRA detailed above, sectoral conservation steps taken by
it are as follows:
TRANSPORT SECTOR
Adoption of practices conducive to increased fuel-efficiency
Training programmes
INDUSTRIAL SECTOR
Replacement of old and inefficient boilers, furnaces and other oil-operated equipment
with efficient ones
Promotion of fuel-efficient practices and equipment.
AGRICULTURAL SECTOR
Standardization of fuel-efficient irrigation pumpsets
Rectification of existing pumpsets to make them more energy efficient
HOUSEHOLD SECTOR
Development as well as promotion of the use of fuel-efficient equipment and appliances
like kerosene and LPG stoves
Action Group meetings and adoption of States has been introduced to give further
impetus to the oil conservation movement and for focussed attention at the State level.
R&D PROJECTS
Indian Oil R&D's " Rashmi Nutan " A fuel efficient lamp
Indian Oil R&D's "Nutan"
An experimental programme to use CNG as fuel in transport sector in the country was
initiated by GAIL in 1992, whereby CNG was made available in Delhi, Mumbai and
Baroda. The supply of CNG in Mumbai and Delhi are managed by two joint ventures viz.
Mahanagar Gas Nigam Ltd. and Indraprastha Gas Limited respectively. The average cost
of converting a petrol car to CNG is about Rs.35,000.
Judiciary has been very pro-active in this area. On the insisitence of Supreme Court of
india, DTC buses were converted to CNG. Similarly High Court of Mumbai forced all
Taxies and Auto Rickshawas to be converted to clean fuels i.e. CNG.
2. The Central Government may, suo motu, or on a reference made to it, after due
consideration of facts, by an order, modify the areas, and the percentage of ethanol in the
ethanol blended petrol that may be supplied, and specify the period for the same.
[F.No. P-45018/28/2000-CC]
CPCB have laid out following Standards for Auto Fuel Quality and Air Exhaust. Same
may be viewed from CPCB web-site (visited on 11 April, 2008).
http://www.cpcb.nic.in/Environmental%20Standards/Vehicular_Exhaust.html
BIO – DIESELS
Government has decided to permit of mixing of 10% bio-fuel with diesel. This has opened up new
opportunities for employment and wealth generation. We have nearly 63 million hectares of wasteland
available in the country, out of which 33 million hectares of wasteland have been allotted for tree
plantation. Certain multi-purpose trees such as Jatropha can grow well in wasteland with very little input.
Once grown the crop has a fifty years of life. Fruiting can take place in this plant in less than two years. It
yields oil seeds up to five tonnes per hectares per year and produces two tonnes of bio-diesel. Presently, the
cost of bio-diesel through the plant is approximately Rs. 17 to Rs. 19 per liter which can be substantially
reduced through choice of right size of the plant and using high yield variety plantation. Bio-diesel plants
grown in 11 million hectares of land can yield a revenue of approximately Rs. 20,000 crore a year and
provide employment to over 12 million people both for plantation and running of the extraction plants. This
is a sustainable development process leading to large scale employment of rural manpower. Also, it will
reduce the foreign exchange outflow paid for importing crude oil, the cost of which is continuously rising in
the international market. Moreover, use of Bio-diesel is CO2 emission free. This oil can also be used for
soap and candle industries. De-oiled cake is a raw material for composting. Also Jatropha plantation
provides a good environment for honey production. We should absorb best of the technologies available
worldwide and start commercial operation soon, instead of staying at pilot plant levels.
1.Technical Feasibility
2.Sources of Bio-diesel
All Tree Bearing Oil (TBO) seeds - edible and non edible.
Edible: Soya-bean, Sun-flower, Mustard Oil etc. Edible seeds can't be used for bio-diesel
production in our country, as its indigenous production does not meet our current
demand.
Non-edible: Jatropha Curcas, Pongemia Pinnata, Neem etc. Among non-edible TBO,
Jatropha Curcas has been identified as the most suitable seed for India.
3.Advantages of Jatropha
Jatropha Curcas is a widely occurring variety of TBO
It grows practically all over India under a variety of agro climatic conditions.
Can be grown in arid zones (20 cm rainfall) as well as in higher rainfall zones and even
on the land with thin soil cover.
Its plantation can be taken up as a quick yielding plant even in adverse land situations viz.
degraded and barren lands under forest and non-forest use, dry and drought prone areas,
marginal lands, even on alkaline soils and as agro-forestry crops.
It grows as a tree up to the height of 3 - 5 mt.
It is a good plantation for Eco-restoration in all types wasteland.
Andhra Pradesh 44
Bihar 10
Chhatisgarh 190
Gujarat 240
Haryana 140
Karnataka 80
Maharashtra 150
Mizoram 20
Rajasthan 275
Tamil Nadu 60
Uttaranchal 50
Likely demand of petro diesel by 2006-07 will be 52 MMT and by 2011-12 it will
increase to 67 MMT.
5% blend of Bio-diesel with petro diesel will require 2.6 MMT of Bio-diesel in 2006-07
By 2011-12, for 20% blend with Petro-diesel, the likely demand will be 13.4 MMT.
To meet the requirement of 2.6 MMT of bio-diesel, plantation of Jatropha should be done
on 2.2 - 2.6 million ha area.
11.2 - 13.4 million ha of land should be covered by 2011 - 12 for 20% bio-diesel blending
Operation of BD
Year No. of jobs in plantation In maintenance
units
As a first step, the alkaline catalyst is mixed with methanol and the mixture is stirred for
half an hour for its homogenization. This mixture is mixed with vegetable oil and the
resultant mixture is made to pass through reflux condensation at 65oC. The mixture at the
end is allowed to settle. The lower layer will be of glycerin and it is drain off. The upper
layer of bio-diesel (a methyl ester) is washed to remove entrained glycerin. The excess
methanol recycled by distillation. This reaction works well with high quality oil. If the oil
contains 1% Free Fatty Acid (FFA), then difficulty arises because of soap formation. If
FFA content is more than 2% the reaction becomes unworkable. Methanol is inflammable
and Potassium Hydroxide is caustic, hence proper and safe handling of these chemicals
are must.
Uttranchal: Uttaranchal Bio-fuel Board (UBB) has been constituted as a nodal agency for
bio-diesel promotion in the state. It has undertaken Jatropha plantation in an area of 1
lakh hectare. UBB has established Jatropha Gene Bank to preserve high yielding seed
varieties. UBB has ambitious plan to produce 100 million liters of bio-diesel.
Andhra Pradesh: Govt. of AP (GoAP) to encourage Jatropha plantation in 10 rain shadow
districts of AP. Task force for it has been constituted at district and state level. GoAP
proposed Jatropha cultivation in 15 lakh acres in next 4 years. Irrigation to be dovetailed
with Jatropha cultivation. 90% drip subsidy is proposed. Jatropha cultivation to be taken
up only in cultivable lands with existing farmers. Crop and yield insurance is proposed.
Chhattisgarh: 6 lakh saplings of Jatropha have been planted with the involvement of
State's Forest, Agriculture, Panchayat and Rural Development Departments. As per the
Deputy Chairman, State Planning Board, the state has the target to cover 1 million ha of
land under Jatropha plantation. Ten reputed bio-diesel companies, including the UK-
based D1 Oils, have offered to set up Jatropha oil-extraction units or to buy the produce
from farmers in Chhattisgarh. Companies like Indian Oil, Indian Railways and Hindustan
Petroleum have each deposited Rs 10 lakh as security for future MoUs with the state
government.
10. Current usages of bio-diesel / Trials & testing of bio-diesel: Usages of bio-diesel
are similar to that of petro-diesel.
1) Shatabadi Express was run on 5% blend of bio-diesel from Delhi to Amritsar on
31st Dec. 2002 in association with IOC.
2) Field trials of 10% bio-diesel blend were also done on Lucknow-Allahabad Jan
Shatabdi Express also through association with IOC.
3) HPCL is also carrying out field trials in association with BEST.
4) Bio-Diesel blend from IOC (R&D) is being used in buses in Mumbai as well as in
Rewari, in Haryana on trial basis .
5) CSIR and Daimler Chrysler have jointly undertaken a successful 5000 km trial run
of Mercedes cars using bio-diesel as fuel.
6) NOVOD has initiated test run by blending 10% bio diesel in collaboration with
IIT, Delhi in Tata Sumo & Swaraj Mazda vehicles.
Chapter 6
Buildings
ENERGY EFFICIENT BUILDINGS
Buildings, as they are often designed and built today, contribute to serious environmental
problems. This is because energy-intensive methods are used to construct a building and
meet its demands for heating, cooling, ventilation, and lighting. These methods lead to
severe depletion of the precious environmental resources. However, buildings can be
designed in such a way that they meet the occupants’ needs for thermal and visual
comfort at reduced levels of energy and resources consumption. Adopting an integrated
approach to building design can bring about energy efficiency in new constructions.
The primary steps in this approach are listed below.
1) Incorporate solar passive techniques in building design to minimize load on
conventional systems (heating, cooling, ventilation, and lighting).
2) Design energy-efficient lighting and HVAC (heating, ventilation, and air-
conditioning) systems.
3) Use renewable energy systems (solar photovoltaic systems/solar water heating
systems) to meet a part of the building load.
4) Use low energy materials and methods of construction.
In brief, an energy-efficient building balances all aspects of energy use in a building –
lighting, space-conditioning, and ventilation – by providing an optimized mix of passive
solar design strategies, energy-efficient equipment, and renewable sources of energy.
Climate and architecture : India is divided into six climatic zones based on different
climatic conditions. Knowledge of climate at a given location can help in the design of
solar passive buildings that eliminate the adverse effects of climate, yet simultaneously
take advantage of effects that are beneficial. For instance, in a place like Mumbai, a
building can be designed in such a way that appropriate shading prevents solar radiation
and adequate ventilation reduces humidity. In a place like Shimla, where the climate is
cold and cloudy, a building can be designed to make maximum use of sunlight, and
thereby keep its interiors as warm as possible. The various climatic factors that affect the
solar passive design are listed below:
1) Wind velocity
2) Ambient temperature
3) Relative humidity
4) Solar radiation
Solar passive techniques: Various concepts and techniques are used to design energy-
efficient buildings. Some of these are described below.
Direct heat gain: The direct heat gain technique is generally used in cold climates. The
basic principle is that sunlight is admitted into the living spaces directly through openings
or glazed windows to heat walls, floors, and inside air. The glazed windows are generally
located facing south to receive maximum sunlight during winter. They are usually
double-glazed, with insulating curtains to reduce heat loss during the night. During the
day, heat is stored in walls and floors; it is released during the night to warm the interior.
Thermal storage walls: In this approach, a thermal storage wall is placed between the
living space and the glazing. This prevents solar radiation from directly entering the
living space. The radiation is absorbed by the storage wall, and then transferred into the
living space. Thermal storage walls include: Trombe walls, water walls, transwalls, etc.
Evaporative cooling: Evaporative cooling is a passive cooling technique, generally
employed in hot and dry climates. It works on the principle that when warm air is used to
evaporate water, the air itself becomes cool, and in turn cools the living space of a
building.
Passive desiccant cooling: Passive desiccant cooling method is effective in a warm and
humid climate. Natural cooling of the human body through sweating does not occur in
highly humid conditions. To decrease the humidity level of the surroundings, desiccant
salts or mechanical de-humidifiers are used.
Induced ventilation: Passive cooling by induced ventilation can be most effective in hot
and humid climates as well as in hot and dry climates. This method involves the heating
of air in a restricted area through solar radiation, thus creating a temperature difference
and causing air movements or drafts. The drafts cause hot air to rise and escape from the
interior, drawing in cooler air and thereby effecting cooling.
Earth berming: Earth-berming technique is used for both passive cooling and heating of
buildings. It is based on the fact that the earth acts like a massive heat sink. Thus,
underground or partially sunk buildings would provide both cooling in summer and
heating in winter to the living spaces within.
In addition to the above concepts, there are many other solar passive techniques such as
wind towers, earth air tunnels, curved roofs, and air vents, which can be incorporated
according to the requirements of the buildings. There are design features that enable
maximum use of daylight inside the building.
Advantages of solar passive buildings: With the incorporation of solar passive concepts
into a building, a large quantity of energy can be saved. Furthermore, these concepts help
in providing comfortable living conditions to the inhabitants in an eco-friendly manner.
However, they cannot totally eliminate the use of conventional energy for modern
facilities such as air conditioning.
Initially, implementation of the codes will be voluntary but will be made mandatory soon
under the Energy Conservation Act 2001 for the buildings having connected load of 500
kw or more. The implementation of the codes will reduce energy consumption from 25%
to 40% and will yield annual saving of about 1.7 billion kwh units.
The codes sets a minimum efficiency standards for external wall, roof, glass structure,
lighting, heating, ventilation and air conditioning of the commercial buildings in all the
five climatic zones in the country. The State Government will have the flexibility to
amend these codes to suit local or regional needs and notify them accordingly.
Salient features of ECBC – 2007 are given below:-
Energy Conservation Building Code – 2007
1. PURPOSE. Purpose1. Purpose
The purpose of this code is to provide minimum requirements for the energy-efficient
design
and construction of buildings.
2. SCOPE
The code is mandatory for commercial buildings or building complexes that have a
connected load of 500 kW or greater or a contract demand of 600 kVA or greater. The
code is also applicable to all buildings with a conditioned floor area of 1,000 m2 or
greater.
The code applies to new constructions and additions to old buildings with above
parameters.
2.1 Applicable Building Systems
The provisions of this code apply to:
(a) Building envelopes, except for unconditioned storage spaces or warehouses,
(b) Mechanical systems and equipment, including heating, ventilating, and air
conditioning,
(c) Service hot water heating,
(d) Interior and exterior lighting, and
(e) Electrical power and motors.
2.2 Exemptions
The provisions of this code do not apply to:
(a) Buildings that do not use either electricity or fossil fuel,
(b) Equipment and portions of building systems that use energy primarily for
manufacturing processes, and
(c) Multi-family buildings of three or fewer stories above grade, and single-family
buildings.
2.3 Safety, Health and Environmental Codes Take Precedence
Where this code is found to conflict with safety, health, or environmental codes, the
safety,
health, or environmental codes shall take precedence.
3. ADMINISTRATION & ENFORCEMENT
Compliance with the requirements of this energy code shall be mandatory for all
applicable
Buildings.
3.1.2 New Buildings
New buildings shall comply with either the provisions of this code or the Energy Budget
Method.
3.1.3 Additions to Existing Buildings
Where the addition plus the existing building exceeds the conditioned floor area threshold
of
Clause 2 above, additions shall comply with the provisions.
4. BUILDING ENVELOPE
Fenestration : Mandatory requirements area specified for
U-Factors
Solar Heat Gain Coefficient (SHGC)
Air Leakage
Opaque Construction
Building Envelope Sealing
The following areas of the enclosed building envelope shall be sealed, caulked, gasketed,
or
weather-stripped to minimize air leakage:
(a) Joints around fenestration and door frames,
(b) Openings between walls and foundations and between walls and roof and wall panels,
(c) Openings at penetrations of utility services through, roofs, walls, and floors
(d) Site-built fenestration and doors,
(e) Building assemblies used as ducts or plenums, and
(f) All other openings in the building envelope.
In addition, there are Prescriptive requirements for. roof, opaque walls, vertical
fenestration, skylight etc. are specified. There is a provision for Building Envelope Trade-
Off Option.
Natural Ventilation
Natural ventilation shall comply with the design guidelines provided for natural
ventilation in the National Building Code of India 2005 Part 8, 5.4.3 and 5.7.1.1
Controls
All mechanical cooling and heating systems shall be controlled by a time clock.
All heating and cooling equipment shall be temperature controlled.
All cooling towers and closed circuit fluid coolers shall have either two speed motors,
pony motors, or variable speed drives controlling the fans.
System Balancing
Both Air System and Hydraulic Systems shall be balanced in a manner to first minimize
throttling losses.
Condensers
Care shall be exercised in locating the condensers in such a manner that heat sink is free
of
interference from heat discharge by devices located in adjoining spaces and also does not
interfere with such other systems installed nearby.
All high-rise buildings using centralized cooling water system shall use soft water for the
condenser and chilled water system
Suitable Air / Water Economizers and Variable Flow Hydraulic Systems are also
prescribed.
Equipment Efficiency
Service water heating equipment shall meet or exceed the minimum efficiency
requirements as specified.
Piping Insulation
The entire hot water system including the storage tanks, pipelines shall be insulated
conforming to the relevant IS standards on materials and applications.
Heat Traps
Vertical pipe risers serving storage water heaters and storage tanks not having integral
heat
traps and serving a non-recirculating system shall have heat traps on both the inlet and
outlet piping as close as practical to the storage tank.
Swimming Pools
Heated pools shall be provided with a vapor retardant pool cover on or at the water
surface.
7. LIGHTING
Lighting Control
Mandatory requirements are specified as below:-
Space Control
Each space enclosed by ceiling-height partitions shall have at least one control device to
independently control the general lighting within the space. Each control device shall be
activated either manually by an occupant or automatically by sensing an occupant.
Exit Signs
Internally-illuminated exit signs shall not exceed 5 W per face.
8. ELECTRIC POWER
Transformers
Power transformers of the proper ratings and design must be selected to satisfy the
minimum
acceptable efficiency at their full load rating. In addition, the transformer must be selected
such that it minimizes the total of its initial cost in addition to the present value of the cost
of
its total lost energy while serving its estimated loads during its respective life span.
Transformers used in buildings shall be constructed with high quality grain oriented low
loss
silicon steel and virgin electrolytic grade copper and the manufacturer’s certificate to this
effect shall be obtained.
Energy Efficient Motors
Motors shall comply with the following:
(a) All permanently wired polyphase motors of 0.375 kW or more serving the building
shall have a minimum acceptable nominal full load motor efficiency not less than that
specified in relevant BIS for energy efficient motors.
(b) Motor horsepower ratings shall not exceed 200% of the calculated maximum load
being served.
(c) Motor nameplates shall list the nominal full-load motor efficiencies and the full-load
power factor.
Power Factor Correction
All electricity supplies exceeding 100 A, 3 phase shall maintain their power factor
between
0.98 lag and unity at the point of connection.
Karnataka state government issued a notification on November 13, 2007 for efficient use of energy
and it’s conservation. The notificationhas made use of solar water heating systems mandatory for
industries, hospitals, nursing homes, including government hospitals, hotels, guest houses, jails,
cnteens, housing complexes / establishment by group housing societies, / boards residential buildings
on 600 sq. ft. loor area or site area of 1200 sq. ft. That comes within the limits of municipal committes
/ corporations, all government buildings, residential schools, universities, community centres,
marriage halls.
The departments of Urban Development, Public Works, Housing, Health & Family Welfare,
Agriculture & Horticulture have also been directed to amend their rules / by-laws within two months
and make the use of solar water heating systems mandatory.
The departments will have to designate a district and a state –level nodal officer to monitor and
report the progress of the enforcement to Karnataka Renewable Energy Development Ltd. (KREDL)
on a quarterly basis.
The notification has also made use of (Compact Fluoroscent lamps) CFL mandatory in the new
government buildings, government aided institutions /boards / corporations. In the existing buildings,
defective incandescent lamps should be replaced only by CFLs. The power utilities shall affect
necessary modficationsin the load demand notices within two months to promote the use of CFLs
instead of conventional bulbs while releasing / sanctioninf new connections / loads.
Even the use of ISI marked motor pumpsets, power capactors, foot / reflux valves in the agriculture
sector has been made mandatory. All the electricity supply companies and Karnataka Power
transmission Corporation Ltd. has been directed to make the amendments in the load demand
notices for tube well connections within two months.
In a move to promote energy efficient building design, all the buildings to be constructed in
government and govt. aided sector will have to incorporate energy efficient design concepts including
renewable energy technologies.
The Department of Public Works has been directed to examine the new buiding plans / drawings and
designate a nodal officer for co-ordinating and monitoring these measures.
(Excerpted from HINDU, Friday November 23, 2007)
This is very progressive step, indeed!!!
ENERGY EFFICIENT BUILDINGS
Buildings, as they are often designed and built today, contribute to serious environmental
problems. This is because energy-intensive methods are used to construct a building and
meet its demands for heating, cooling, ventilation, and lighting. These methods lead to
severe depletion of the precious environmental resources. However, buildings can be
designed in such a way that they meet the occupants’ needs for thermal and visual
comfort at reduced levels of energy and resources consumption. Adopting an integrated
approach to building design can bring about energy efficiency in new constructions.
The primary steps in this approach are listed below.
5) Incorporate solar passive techniques in building design to minimize load on
conventional systems (heating, cooling, ventilation, and lighting).
6) Design energy-efficient lighting and HVAC (heating, ventilation, and air-
conditioning) systems.
7) Use renewable energy systems (solar photovoltaic systems/solar water heating
systems) to meet a part of the building load.
8) Use low energy materials and methods of construction.
In brief, an energy-efficient building balances all aspects of energy use in a building –
lighting, space-conditioning, and ventilation – by providing an optimized mix of passive
solar design strategies, energy-efficient equipment, and renewable sources of energy.
Climate and architecture : India is divided into six climatic zones based on different
climatic conditions. Knowledge of climate at a given location can help in the design of
solar passive buildings that eliminate the adverse effects of climate, yet simultaneously
take advantage of effects that are beneficial. For instance, in a place like Mumbai, a
building can be designed in such a way that appropriate shading prevents solar radiation
and adequate ventilation reduces humidity. In a place like Shimla, where the climate is
cold and cloudy, a building can be designed to make maximum use of sunlight, and
thereby keep its interiors as warm as possible. The various climatic factors that affect the
solar passive design are listed below:
5) Wind velocity
6) Ambient temperature
7) Relative humidity
8) Solar radiation
Solar passive techniques: Various concepts and techniques are used to design energy-
efficient buildings. Some of these are described below.
Direct heat gain: The direct heat gain technique is generally used in cold climates. The
basic principle is that sunlight is admitted into the living spaces directly through openings
or glazed windows to heat walls, floors, and inside air. The glazed windows are generally
located facing south to receive maximum sunlight during winter. They are usually
double-glazed, with insulating curtains to reduce heat loss during the night. During the
day, heat is stored in walls and floors; it is released during the night to warm the interior.
Thermal storage walls: In this approach, a thermal storage wall is placed between the
living space and the glazing. This prevents solar radiation from directly entering the
living space. The radiation is absorbed by the storage wall, and then transferred into the
living space. Thermal storage walls include: Trombe walls, water walls, transwalls, etc.
Evaporative cooling: Evaporative cooling is a passive cooling technique, generally
employed in hot and dry climates. It works on the principle that when warm air is used to
evaporate water, the air itself becomes cool, and in turn cools the living space of a
building.
Passive desiccant cooling: Passive desiccant cooling method is effective in a warm and
humid climate. Natural cooling of the human body through sweating does not occur in
highly humid conditions. To decrease the humidity level of the surroundings, desiccant
salts or mechanical de-humidifiers are used.
Induced ventilation: Passive cooling by induced ventilation can be most effective in hot
and humid climates as well as in hot and dry climates. This method involves the heating
of air in a restricted area through solar radiation, thus creating a temperature difference
and causing air movements or drafts. The drafts cause hot air to rise and escape from the
interior, drawing in cooler air and thereby effecting cooling.
Earth berming: Earth-berming technique is used for both passive cooling and heating of
buildings. It is based on the fact that the earth acts like a massive heat sink. Thus,
underground or partially sunk buildings would provide both cooling in summer and
heating in winter to the living spaces within.
In addition to the above concepts, there are many other solar passive techniques such as
wind towers, earth air tunnels, curved roofs, and air vents, which can be incorporated
according to the requirements of the buildings. There are design features that enable
maximum use of daylight inside the building.
Advantages of solar passive buildings: With the incorporation of solar passive concepts
into a building, a large quantity of energy can be saved. Furthermore, these concepts help
in providing comfortable living conditions to the inhabitants in an eco-friendly manner.
However, they cannot totally eliminate the use of conventional energy for modern
facilities such as air conditioning.
Initially, implementation of the codes will be voluntary but will be made mandatory soon
under the Energy Conservation Act 2001 for the buildings having connected load of 500
kw or more. The implementation of the codes will reduce energy consumption from 25%
to 40% and will yield annual saving of about 1.7 billion kwh units.
The codes sets a minimum efficiency standards for external wall, roof, glass structure,
lighting, heating, ventilation and air conditioning of the commercial buildings in all the
five climatic zones in the country. The State Government will have the flexibility to
amend these codes to suit local or regional needs and notify them accordingly.
Salient features of ECBC – 2007 are given below:-
Energy Conservation Building Code – 2007
1. PURPOSE. Purpose1. Purpose
The purpose of this code is to provide minimum requirements for the energy-efficient
design
and construction of buildings.
2. SCOPE
The code is mandatory for commercial buildings or building complexes that have a
connected load of 500 kW or greater or a contract demand of 600 kVA or greater. The
code is also applicable to all buildings with a conditioned floor area of 1,000 m2 or
greater.
The code applies to new constructions and additions to old buildings with above
parameters.
2.1 Applicable Building Systems
The provisions of this code apply to:
(a) Building envelopes, except for unconditioned storage spaces or warehouses,
(b) Mechanical systems and equipment, including heating, ventilating, and air
conditioning,
(c) Service hot water heating,
(d) Interior and exterior lighting, and
(e) Electrical power and motors.
2.2 Exemptions
The provisions of this code do not apply to:
(a) Buildings that do not use either electricity or fossil fuel,
(b) Equipment and portions of building systems that use energy primarily for
manufacturing processes, and
(c) Multi-family buildings of three or fewer stories above grade, and single-family
buildings.
2.3 Safety, Health and Environmental Codes Take Precedence
Where this code is found to conflict with safety, health, or environmental codes, the
safety,
health, or environmental codes shall take precedence.
3. ADMINISTRATION & ENFORCEMENT
Compliance with the requirements of this energy code shall be mandatory for all
applicable
Buildings.
3.1.2 New Buildings
New buildings shall comply with either the provisions of this code or the Energy Budget
Method.
3.1.3 Additions to Existing Buildings
Where the addition plus the existing building exceeds the conditioned floor area threshold
of
Clause 2 above, additions shall comply with the provisions.
4. BUILDING ENVELOPE
Fenestration : Mandatory requirements area specified for
U-Factors
Solar Heat Gain Coefficient (SHGC)
Air Leakage
Opaque Construction
Building Envelope Sealing
The following areas of the enclosed building envelope shall be sealed, caulked, gasketed,
or
weather-stripped to minimize air leakage:
(a) Joints around fenestration and door frames,
(b) Openings between walls and foundations and between walls and roof and wall panels,
(c) Openings at penetrations of utility services through, roofs, walls, and floors
(d) Site-built fenestration and doors,
(e) Building assemblies used as ducts or plenums, and
(f) All other openings in the building envelope.
In addition, there are Prescriptive requirements for. roof, opaque walls, vertical
fenestration, skylight etc. are specified. There is a provision for Building Envelope Trade-
Off Option.
Controls
All mechanical cooling and heating systems shall be controlled by a time clock.
All heating and cooling equipment shall be temperature controlled.
All cooling towers and closed circuit fluid coolers shall have either two speed motors,
pony motors, or variable speed drives controlling the fans.
System Balancing
Both Air System and Hydraulic Systems shall be balanced in a manner to first minimize
throttling losses.
Condensers
Care shall be exercised in locating the condensers in such a manner that heat sink is free
of
interference from heat discharge by devices located in adjoining spaces and also does not
interfere with such other systems installed nearby.
All high-rise buildings using centralized cooling water system shall use soft water for the
condenser and chilled water system
Suitable Air / Water Economizers and Variable Flow Hydraulic Systems are also
prescribed.
6. SERVICE, HOT WATER & PUMPING
Equipment Efficiency
Service water heating equipment shall meet or exceed the minimum efficiency
requirements as specified.
Piping Insulation
The entire hot water system including the storage tanks, pipelines shall be insulated
conforming to the relevant IS standards on materials and applications.
Heat Traps
Vertical pipe risers serving storage water heaters and storage tanks not having integral
heat
traps and serving a non-recirculating system shall have heat traps on both the inlet and
outlet piping as close as practical to the storage tank.
Swimming Pools
Heated pools shall be provided with a vapor retardant pool cover on or at the water
surface.
7. LIGHTING
Lighting Control
Mandatory requirements are specified as below:-
Space Control
Each space enclosed by ceiling-height partitions shall have at least one control device to
independently control the general lighting within the space. Each control device shall be
activated either manually by an occupant or automatically by sensing an occupant.
Exit Signs
Internally-illuminated exit signs shall not exceed 5 W per face.
8. ELECTRIC POWER
Transformers
Power transformers of the proper ratings and design must be selected to satisfy the
minimum
acceptable efficiency at their full load rating. In addition, the transformer must be selected
such that it minimizes the total of its initial cost in addition to the present value of the cost
of
its total lost energy while serving its estimated loads during its respective life span.
Transformers used in buildings shall be constructed with high quality grain oriented low
loss
silicon steel and virgin electrolytic grade copper and the manufacturer’s certificate to this
effect shall be obtained.
Energy Efficient Motors
Motors shall comply with the following:
(a) All permanently wired polyphase motors of 0.375 kW or more serving the building
shall have a minimum acceptable nominal full load motor efficiency not less than that
specified in relevant BIS for energy efficient motors.
(b) Motor horsepower ratings shall not exceed 200% of the calculated maximum load
being served.
(c) Motor nameplates shall list the nominal full-load motor efficiencies and the full-load
power factor.
Power Factor Correction
All electricity supplies exceeding 100 A, 3 phase shall maintain their power factor
between
0.98 lag and unity at the point of connection.
IMPACT OF ECBC
Market developments for EE products e.g. building insulations, energy efficient
windows (frames & glass), HVAC equipments, Solar water heaters.
Improved design practices in lighting / day lighting, natural ventilation and
cooling systems
Improved performance and power factor.
Low lfe cycle cost
Karnataka state government issued a notification on November 13, 2007 for efficient use of energy
and it’s conservation. The notificationhas made use of solar water heating systems mandatory for
industries, hospitals, nursing homes, including government hospitals, hotels, guest houses, jails,
cnteens, housing complexes / establishment by group housing societies, / boards residential buildings
on 600 sq. ft. loor area or site area of 1200 sq. ft. That comes within the limits of municipal committes
/ corporations, all government buildings, residential schools, universities, community centres,
marriage halls.
The departments of Urban Development, Public Works, Housing, Health & Family Welfare,
Agriculture & Horticulture have also been directed to amend their rules / by-laws within two months
and make the use of solar water heating systems mandatory.
The departments will have to designate a district and a state –level nodal officer to monitor and
report the progress of the enforcement to Karnataka Renewable Energy Development Ltd. (KREDL)
on a quarterly basis.
The notification has also made use of (Compact Fluoroscent lamps) CFL mandatory in the new
government buildings, government aided institutions /boards / corporations. In the existing buildings,
defective incandescent lamps should be replaced only by CFLs. The power utilities shall affect
necessary modficationsin the load demand notices within two months to promote the use of CFLs
instead of conventional bulbs while releasing / sanctioninf new connections / loads.
Even the use of ISI marked motor pumpsets, power capactors, foot / reflux valves in the agriculture
sector has been made mandatory. All the electricity supply companies and Karnataka Power
transmission Corporation Ltd. has been directed to make the amendments in the load demand
notices for tube well connections within two months.
In a move to promote energy efficient building design, all the buildings to be constructed in
government and govt. aided sector will have to incorporate energy efficient design concepts including
renewable energy technologies.
The Department of Public Works has been directed to examine the new buiding plans / drawings and
designate a nodal officer for co-ordinating and monitoring these measures.
(Excerpted from HINDU, Friday November 23, 2007)
This is very progressive step, indeed!!!
U.S. Treasury and IRS Provide Guidance on Energy Credit To Home Builders
(http://www.irs.gov/newsroom/article/0,,id=154658,00.html)
The Internal Revenue Service of united States has provided guidance regarding the
energy efficient homes credit available under the Energy Policy Act of 2005. Under the
new provision, an eligible contractor who constructs a qualified new energy efficient
home may qualify for a credit of up to $2,000. The credit is available for all new homes,
including manufactured homes constructed in accordance with the Federal Manufactured
Homes Construction and Safety Standards.
The home qualifies for the credit if:
It is located in the United States;
Its construction is substantially completed after August 8, 2005;
It meets the statutory energy saving requirements, and
It is acquired from the eligible contractor after December 31, 2005, and before January 1, 2008, for
use as a residence.
In general, to meet the energy saving requirements, a home must be certified to provide a
level of heating and cooling energy consumption that is at least 30 to 50 percent in the
case of manufactured homes, and 50 percent for other homes below that of a comparable
home constructed in accordance with the standards of the 2004 International Energy
Conservation Code. It must also have building envelope component improvements
providing a level of heating and cooling energy consumption that is at least 10 percent
below that of a comparable home.
Manufactured homes can also qualify for the credit by meeting Energy Star standards.
Site-built homes qualify for a $2,000 credit if they reduce energy consumption by 50
percent relative to the International Energy Conservation Code standard.
Manufactured homes qualify for a $1,000 or $2,000 credit depending on the level of
energy savings achieved. The guidance provides information about the certification
process that a builder must complete to qualify for the credit. The guidance also provides
for a public list of software programs that may be used in calculating energy consumption
for purposes of obtaining a certification.
Related links:
Notice 2006-27 provides guidances for the credit for building energy efficient homes
other than manufactured homes.
Notice 2006-28 provides guidance for the credit for building energy efficient
manufactured homes.
Chapter 7
Renewable Energy
Renewable Energy in India
Energy is a basic requirement for economic development. Every sector of Indian
economy – agriculture, industry, transport, commercial, and domestic – needs inputs of
energy. The economic development plans implemented since independence have
necessarily required increasing amounts of energy. As a result, consumption of energy in
all forms has been steadily rising all over the country.
This growing consumption of energy has also resulted in the country becoming
increasingly dependent on fossil fuels such as coal and oil and gas. Rising prices of oil
and gas and potential shortages in future lead to concerns about the security of energy
supply needed to sustain our economic growth. Increased use of fossil fuels also causes
environmental problems both locally and globally.
Against this background, the country urgently needs to develop a sustainable path of
energy development. Promotion of energy conservation and increased use of renewable
energy sources are the twin planks of a sustainable energy supply.
Fortunately, India is blessed with a variety of renewable energy sources, the main ones being biomass,
biogas, the sun, wind, and small hydro power. (Large hydro power is also renewable in nature, but has been
utilized all over the world for many decades, and is generally not included in the term ‘new and renewable
sources of energy’). Municipal and industrial wastes can also be useful sources of energy, but are basically
different forms of biomass. Advantages of renewable energy are that it is
Perennial
Available locally and does not need elaborate arrangements for transport
Usually modular in nature, i.e. small-scale units and systems can be almost as
economical as large-scale ones
Environment-friendly
Well suited for decentralized applications and use in remote areas.
The Ministry of Non-Conventional Energy Sources has been implementing
comprehensive programmes for the development and utilization of various renewable
energy sources in the country. As a result of efforts made during the past quarter century,
a number of technologies and devices have been developed and have become
commercially available. These include biogas plants, improved wood stoves, solar water
heaters, solar cookers, solar lanterns, street lights, pumps, wind electric generators, water-
pumping wind mills, biomass gasifiers, and small hydro-electric generators. Energy
technologies for the future such as hydrogen, fuel cells, and bio-fuels are being actively
developed.
India is implementing one of the world’s largest programmes in renewable energy. The
country ranks second in the world in biogas utilization and fifth in wind power and
photovoltaic production. Renewable sources already contribute to about 5% of the total
power generating capacity in the country. The major renewable energy sources and
devices in use in India are listed in Table 1 along with their potential and present status in
terms of the number of installations or total capacity.
Table –1
Section 4
Section 4 states that the Central Government shall, after consultation with the state
governments, prepare and notify a national policy, permitting stand-alone systems
(including those based on renewable sources of energy and other non-conventional
sources of energy) for rural areas.
Section 61
Section 61, 61(h) and 61(i) state that the appropriate commission shall, subject to the
provision of this Act, specify the terms and conditions for the determination of tariff, and
in doing so, shall be guided by the following, namely, the promotion of cogeneration and
generation of electricity from renewable sources of energy; and the National Electricity
Policy and Tariff Policy.
Section 86(1)
Section 86(1) and 86(1)(e) state that the state commissions shall discharge the following
functions, namely, promote cogeneration and generation of electricity from renewable
sources of energy by providing, suitable measures for connectivity with the grid and sale
of electricity to any person, and also specify, for purchase of electricity from such
sources, a percentage of the total consumption of electricity in the area of a distribution
license.
‘Today India is one of the few leading countries in the development and utilization of
renewable energy. The country is blessed with various sources of non-conventional
energy and I hope the efforts of Ministry of Non-Conventional Energy Sources will
promote viable technologies that can reach the benefits of such sources to the poorest
people in the far-flung regions of the country.’
Smt. Sonia Gandhi Chairperson, National Advisory Council
1. BIOGAS
Biogas represents an alternative source of energy, derived mainly from organic wastes. In
India, the use of biogas derived from animal waste, primarily cow dung, has been
Promoted for over three decades now.
According to the 1997 Livestock Census, the cattle population in the country is about
290 million. The estimated potential of household biogas plants based on animal waste in
India is 12 million. Till December 2004, under the National Biogas Programme, over 3.7
million biogas plants in the capacity of 1–6 m3 had been installed. Larger units have also
been set up in many villages, farms, and cattle houses. The estimated biogas production
from these plants is over 3.5 million m3 per day, which is equivalent to a daily supply of
about 2.2 million m3 of natural gas.
These plants usually provide gas for cooking and lighting, the latter through specially
designed mantles. By replacing up to 75% of the diesel in dual-fuel engines with biogas,
mechanical and electrical power is also generated. Efforts are now under way to introduce
small capacity engines to efficiently generate electricity from biogas in a decentralized
mode. Standardized models of biogas plants – suitable for individual households and
institutions/communities – are thus available.
Along with development of plants and related infrastructure, a large pool of skilled
manpower has been trained and deployed for plant construction and maintenance. The
technology involved – anaerobic digestion – has been successfully extended to treat
industrial and urban wastes on a large scale. This holds potential as a solution to
numerous environmental problems, including waste and manure handling, water
pollution, and carbon dioxide emission.
Biogas Technology
Biogas is a clean fuel produced through anaerobic digestion of a variety of organic
wastes: animal, agricultural, domestic, and industrial.
Anaerobic digestion comprises three steps.
1) Decomposition (hydrolysis) of plant or animal matter to break down complex
organic materials into simple organic substances
2) Conversion of decomposed matter into organic acids
3) Conversion of acids into methane gas
As the process temperature affects the rate of digestion, it should be maintained in the
mesophilic range (30 °C–40 °C) with an optimum of 35 °C. It is also possible to operate
plants in the thermophilic range (55 °C–65 °C) under controlled conditions. Apart from
temperature, the rate of biogas production also depends on factors such as the carbon :
nitrogen ratio, hydraulic retention time, solid concentration, and types of feedstock.
Biogas consists of methane, carbon dioxide, and traces of other gases such as hydrogen,
carbon monoxide, nitrogen, oxygen, and hydrogen sulphide. The gas mixture is saturated
with water vapor and may contain dust particles. The relative percentages of these gases
depend on the quality of feed material and the process conditions. The percentage of
methane in the gas determines its calorific value as the other constituents do not
contribute to the energy content. The methane content of biogas is appreciably high, at
60%. This provides a calorific value high enough to find use in many energy applications,
including power generation. Table 2 provides a comparison of the calorific values of
various fuels.
Table 2
Comparison of the calorific values of various fuels
Fuel Calorific value (approximate)
Applications: Cooking Biogas can be used for cooking in a specially designed burner. A
biogas plant of 2 m3 capacity is sufficient for providing cooking fuel to a family of four
to five.
Lighting Gas lamps can be fuelled by biogas. To power a 100 candle lamp (60 W),
the biogas required is 0.13 m3 per hour.
Power generation Biogas can be used to operate a dual-fuel engine and can
replace up to 75% of the diesel.
Biogas Digested Slurry: The use of biogas digested slurry as organic manure can
supplement the usage of chemical fertilizers. The effluent manure does not produce
any odour and hence does not create any pollution. The biogas slurry is rich in nitrogen,
the essential nutrient for plant growth. Moreover, this nitrogen is in water-soluble form
and can be easily absorbed by the plants.
The biogas slurry can also be mixed with biomass and composted. The slurry being full of
bacteria (which can break down vegetable matter) makes excellent composting material.
When a large mass of biomass waste with high carbon : nitrogen ratio is available, the
slurry helps stimulate decomposition by acting as a nitrogen primer. Earthworms could
either be cultured in dry sludge or in a compost pit.
Strategy for Promoting the Technology: The MNRE provides central financial
assistance for construction and maintenance of biogas plants, development of skilled
manpower, training for use and maintenance, awareness creation, and support to
implementing agencies and technical centers for implementation of the programme.
2. BIOMASS
Introduction
Biomass has been one of the main energy sources for the mankind ever since the dawn of
civilization, although its importance dwindled after the expansion in use of oil and coal in
the late 19th century. There has been a resurgence of interest in the recent years in
biomass energy in many countries considering the benefits it offers. It is renewable,
widely available, and carbon-neutral and has the potential to provide significant
productive employment in the rural areas.
Biomass is also capable of providing firm energy. Estimates have indicated that 15%–
50% of the world’s primary energy use could come from biomass by the year 2050.
Currently, about 11% of the world’s primary energy is estimated to be met with biomass.
For India, biomass has always been an important energy source. Although the energy
scenario in India today indicates a growing dependence on the conventional forms of
energy, about 32% of the total primary energy use in the country is still derived from
biomass and more than 70% of the country’s population depends upon it for its energy
needs. Biomass power generation in India is an industry that attracts investments of over
Rs 600 crores every year, generating more than 5000 million units of electricity and
yearly employment of more than 10 million man-days in the rural areas. The three main
technologies being promoted by the MNES for productive utilization of biomass are:-
1) Bagasse-based cogeneration in sugar mills,
2) Biomass power generation,
3) Biomass gasification for thermal and electrical applications.
1. Bagasse-based Cogeneration
Technology: In simple terms, cogeneration is the process of using a single fuel to
produce more than one form of energy in sequence. Cogeneration of steam and electricity
can significantly increase the overall efficiencies of fuel utilization in process industries.
A minimum condition for cogeneration is the simultaneous requirement of heat and
electricity in a favourable ratio, which is well fulfilled in the sugar industry. The
thermodynamics of electricity production necessitates the rejection of a large quantity of
heat to a lower temperature sink. In normal electricity generation plants, this heat
rejection takes place in condensers where up to 70% of heat in steam is rejected to the
atmosphere. In cogeneration mode, however, this heat is not wasted and is instead used to
meet process heating requirement. The overall efficiency of fuel utilization can thus be
increased to 60% or even higher in some cases. Capacity of cogeneration projects can
range from a few kilowatts to several megawatts of electricity generation a long with
simultaneous production of heat ranging from less than a hundred kWth (kilowatts
thermal) to many MWth (megawatts thermal).
Cogeneration in sugar industry: The sugar industry across the world has traditionally
used bagasse-based cogeneration for achieving self-sufficiency in steam and electricity as
well as economy in operations. In India, almost all sugar mills have been practising some
form of cogeneration. This is true even for mills that were set up 70–80 years ago.
Technologies are now available for high-temperature/high-pressure steam generation
using bagasse as a fuel. These technologies make it possible for sugar mills to operate at
higher levels of energy efficiency and generate more electricity than what they require.
For example, when steam generation temperature/pressure is increased from 400 ºC/32
bar to 485 ºC/66 bar, more than 80 kWh (kilowatt-hour) of additional electricity can be
generated from each tonne of cane crushed.
Revenues from sale of surplus electricity can go a long way in improving the viability of
sugar mills. It has been estimated that ‘optimum cogeneration’ can result in an additional
net value addition of Rs 70–100 per tonne of cane crushed at current typical electricity
sale prices.
The MNES has been promoting bagasse-based cogeneration in sugar mills through policy
support and financial incentives/subsidies for over a decade now. The capital costs of
installed bagasse-based cogeneration projects in sugar mills are known to range between
Rs 3 crores/MW and Rs 4 crores/MW. It has been seen that for a typical sugar mill having
an average crushing season of 160 days, investments for additional power generation
through cogeneration will turn out to be beneficial in the long term.
The potential for cogeneration projects is estimated at 3500 MW of additional power
generation from the country’s existing functional sugar mills.
Achievements:- India, today, is perhaps the world leader in the implementation of
modern cogeneration projects in sugar mills. The achievements merit attention not only
because of the additional grid-connected power generation capacity but also because of
the large number of sugar mills, which have implemented these projects. This is
noteworthy because of the diverse nature of operating conditions across these mills. An
additional power generation capacity of 447 MW has been commissioned in 58 sugar
mills as of March 2005. A further capacity addition of about 313 MW in 34 sugar mills is
reported to be under implementation.
The technology for bagasse-based cogeneration has become fairly well established in the
country. The main equipment required for these projects comprise high-pressure bagasse-
fired boilers, steam turbines, and grid-inter-phasing system. All these equipment are
manufactured indigenously. An extremely competent and experienced group of technical
professionals capable of providing comprehensive project and operational services has
also been developed in the country to support bagasse-based cogeneration projects.
Financial incentives:- The present levels of interest subsidy offered by the MNES for
various categories of bagasse-based cogeneration projects are detailed in he MNES
website <www.mnes.nic.in>.
Sale of electricity:- Almost all major sugar-producing states have announced policies in
support of cogeneration in sugar mills. Support to these projects by state governments
includes purchase of additional electricity at attractive rates through long-term power
purchase agreements (PPAs), facilities for wheeling and banking in many states, prompt
payments for purchased electricity, etc.
Case study : A progressive sugar mill in Uttar Pradesh, crushing 11 000 tonnes of cane
per day, has deployed state-of-the-art, 87 bar/525 ºC steam configuration to cogenerate
over 18 MW of surplus electricity. The technology used is totally indigenous. Biogas
generated in its distillery is also used as supplementary fuel. In addition, rice husk and
bagasse procured from an adjoining sugar mill are also used to extend the power
generation period. The cost of the project was about Rs 50 crores, and interest subsidy
was provided by the MNES on the term loan provided by ICICI. The project is expected
to supply over 70 million units of electricity to the state grid every year and provide direct
employment to about 70 persons.
2. Biomass-based Power Generation
India produces a huge quantity of biomass material in its agricultural, agro-industrial, and
forestry operations. According to some estimates, over 500 million tonnes of agricultural
and agro-industrial residue alone is generated every year. This quantity, in terms of heat
content, is equivalent to about 175 Mtoe. A portion of these materials is used for fodder
and fuel in the rural economy. However, studies have indicated that at least 150–200
Mtoe of this biomass material does not find much productive use, and can be made
available for alternative uses at an economical cost. These materials include a variety of
husks and straws. This quantity of biomass is sufficient to generate 15 000–25 000 MW
of electrical power at typically prevalent plant load factors. In addition, electricity can
also be generated from biomass grown on wastelands, road and rail trackside plantations,
etc. The quantum of electricity that can be produced from such biomass has been
estimated to be in excess of 70 000 MW. Thus, the total electricity generation potential
from biomass could reach a figure of about 100 000 MW.
The technology for generation of electricity from these biomass materials is similar to the
conventional coal-based thermal power generation. The biomass is burnt in boilers to
generate steam, which drives a turbo alternator for generation of electricity.
Advantages
These projects can be designed to match the electric loads as biomass can be
stored and used according to demand.
Equipment for these projects is similar to that for coal-based thermal power
projects and hence, no new technological developments are required.
Due to their proximity to the rural areas, these projects are likely to improve
quality of electricity supply there.
A variety of biomass materials can be used in the same plant, providing flexibility
of operations.
The technology for use of biomass for power generation is fairly well established in the
country. The equipment required for these projects comprises mainly of boilers, turbines,
and grid inter-phasing systems. Recent innovations include the use of air-cooled
condensers to reduce consumptive use of water. All these items of equipment are
available indigenously. Typical capital costs for biomass power projects range from Rs 3
crores/MW to Rs 4 crores/MW. Costs of generation depend upon the cost of biomass, the
plant load factor, and the efficiencies of conversion.
Achievements:- A power-generation capacity of about 302 MW has been commissioned
through 54 projects, as on March 2005. A further capacity addition of
about 270 MW through 39 projects is reported to be under implementation. The biomass
materials that have been used for power generation in these projects include rice husk,
cotton stalk, mustard stalk, Prosopis juliflora (Vilayati babul), poultry litter, bagasse,
cane trash, etc.
Case study:- A power project in Karnataka utilizes a mix of agricultural wastes such
as rice husk, groundnut shell, coconut fronds/waste cotton stalks, bark and roots of trees,
cane trash, arecanut shells, etc., as fuel to generate about 20 MW electricity and sell it to
the grid. The project has minimized its use of water by resorting to air-cooled condensers.
The loans for the project were financed by the PFC and the State Bank of India. The
project has generated direct employment opportunities for about 70 persons and indirect
employment for over 800 persons.
3. Biomass Gasification for Thermal and Electrical Applications
Biomass gasification is thermo-chemical conversion of solid biomass into a combustible
gas mixture (producer gas) through a partial combustion route with air supply restricted to
less than that theoretically required for full combustion. Typical composition of Producer
Gas is as follows:-
Carbon monoxide - 18%–20%
Hydrogen - 15%–20%
Methane - 1%–5%
Carbon dioxide - 9%–12%
Nitrogen - 45%–55%
Calorific value - 1000–1200 kcal/m3
Case studies:-
1 Ceramics is an industry sector where biomass gasifiers have been very successfully
used. The production of ceramic ware requires that raw items be baked for a pre-specified
period at a temperature of 900–1300 oC. Typically, this is carried out in tunnel kilns,
which operate almost continuously for 365 days a year. Oil or other suitable fuels are
fired into the kilns to raise temperature. Typically, kerosene, diesel or LPG are used as
fuels. These can be replaced by producer gas generated in biomass gasification systems.
The typical oil consumption of ceramic factories is 2000–3000 litres/day. After
installation of biomass gasifiers, oil consumption could be reduced to less than 30%,
resulting in huge money savings to the users. It is estimated that ceramic industry
consumes 0.3–0.5 million tones of oil per year. Seventy per cent savings on this figure
would imply savings of 0.20–0.35 million tonnes of oil. About 100 ceramic factories out
of the estimated 500 are reported to have switched over to biomass gasifiers.
2 An independent power producer has set up the single largest capacity, fixed-bed
biomass gasifier-based electricity generation system of 1 MW in grid-connected mode.
The project is located near Coimbatore in Tamil Nadu and uses coconut shells or other
types of wood for electricity generation. The system uses two gasifiers of 750 kg/h
biomass gasification capacity each and five engines of 250 kW nominal capacity each.
The engines are suitable for 100% producer gas operation. Air-cooled radiators have been
used in the installation to reduce use of water. This 100% producer gas engines are
operating successfully. The project has utilized indigenously developed state-of-the-art
technology with fully automatic controls and auxiliary systems.
3 Odanthurai is a remote village of Block Karamadai in Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, having
135 houses with 540 inhabitants. The electricity supply system of Odanthurai was most
unreliable due to its topographical and isolated location. To provide a reliable drinking
water supply system and provide lighting facilities for community uses, the District Rural
Development Agency, Coimbatore, installed a 9-kWe biomass gasifier project coupled
with 100% producer gas engines. The system selected was most appropriate for operation
by local persons. The project cost was Rs 5.90 lakhs. The biomass requirement of 100%
producer gas engine system is about 1.5–1.6 kg/kWh. If the installed system operates for
12 hours, biomass requirement would be about 150 kg per day. Thus, annually, there
would be a requirement of about 60 tonnes of biomass. As Odanthurai has a large number
of coconut trees and plenty of other biomass, the supply of the required quantity is not a
problem. Every unit of electricity generated is likely to cost about Rs 2.42. It is expected
that revenue generation from water supply and illumination will more than compensate
the power generation cost.
3.0 SOLAR HEATING SYSTEMS
Solar Thermal Energy
India lies in the sunny regions of the world. Most parts of India receive 4–7 kilowatt
hours of solar radiation per square metre per day with 250–300 sunny days in a year. The
highest annual radiation energy is received in western Rajasthan while the north-eastern
region of the country receives the lowest annual radiation.
Solar energy, experienced by us as heat and light, can be used through two routes: the
thermal route uses the heat for water heating, cooking, drying, water purification, power
generation, and other applications; the photovoltaic route converts the light in solar
energy into electricity, which can then be used for a number of purposes such as lighting,
pumping, communications, and power supply in unelectrified areas.
Energy from the sun has many features, which make it an attractive and sustainable
option: global distribution, pollution-free nature, and the virtually inexhaustible supply.
Energy in the form of heat (thermal energy) is required for many purposes in the
domestic, agricultural, industrial, and commercial sectors of the economy. Solar thermal
energy can meet many of these needs in a cost-effective and reliable manner. A solar
thermal system basically absorbs the heat in solar energy and transfers it to a medium
such as water or air. When used for purposes such as heating of water, cooking, drying of
various commodities and products, and distillation of water, solar thermal systems can
partially or fully replace the conventional fuels such as coal, oil, and electricity. Solar
thermal technology has a tremendous potential for saving conventional energy in India.
Solar Cooking
Cooking is a common application of solar energy in India. A variety of solar cookers are available to suit
different requirements. The MNES has been implementing a programme for promoting the use of solar
cooking in the country for over two decades. The programme also supports the development and
demonstration of new types of cooking
systems.
Advantages of solar cooking
Solar cooking involves no recurring expenses on fuel. If used regularly, a solar
cooker can save three or four LPG cylinders per year.
It saves time. You are free to do other things while food cooks in the solar cooker.
There is no fear of scorching the food.
Solar cooking is a slow process, and hence ensures better and more nutritious
cooked food.
It does not pollute the environment, and conserves conventional energy.
Solar cookers are durable and simple to use.
Box solar cooker: A box solar cooker cooks food with the help of solar energy, and
helps save conventional fuels. It supplements cooking fuel but does not replace it totally.
It is an ideal device for domestic cooking during most of the year except on cloudy days.
This cooker can be used for the preparation of rice, dal, kadhi, vegetables, meat and fish
dishes, snacks, soups, sweets, desserts, sauces, jams, pickles, biscuits, cakes, puddings,
etc. However, it cannot be used for frying or for making chapatis. The cost of a box solar
cooker varies from Rs 1200 to Rs 2500 depending on its size and features. A normal-size
box cooker is sufficient for a family of four or five members. It has a life of 10–12 years.
Its payback period is 2–3 years depending upon the extent of use and place of use.
Dish solar cooker: A dish solar cooker uses a parabolic dish to concentrate the incident
solar radiation and is useful for homes and small establishments. The cooker can deliver
power of about 0.6 kW, which can boil two to three liters of water in half-an hour.
The temperature achieved at the bottom of the vessel could reach 350–400 °C, which is
sufficient for roasting, frying, and boiling. This cooker can meet the needs of about 15
people, and can be used for eight to nine hours during the day. The cost of a dish solar
cooker may vary from Rs 4300 to Rs 5000 depending on the type of reflector and
supporting structure.
The dish solar cooker can save up to 10 liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) cylinders per year
upon full use at small establishments. Its payback period ranges from 2–3 years,
depending on the extent of its use and the place of use. The life of this cooker is estimated
at about 20 years for the metallic structure. However, the reflecting sheets may have to be
replaced once in five years due to degradation in their reflectivity. At present, the
MNES provides an incentive of up to 50% of the cost of the cooker to encourage its use.
Community solar cooker for indoor cooking: Like the dish solar cooker, the
community solar cooker too is a parabolic reflector cooker. The unique feature of this
cooker is that it makes possible to cook using solar energy within the kitchen itself. The
cooker has a large reflector ranging from 7 to 12 m2 of aperture area. The cooker is
provided with a mechanical clockwork arrangement that rotates the primary reflector
outside to automatically track the sun This reflector is placed outside the kitchen so that it
reflects solar rays into the kitchen through an opening in its north wall. A secondary
reflector further concentrates the rays on to the bottom of the pot/frying pan (painted
black to absorb maximum heat). The temperature attained is so high (up to 400 °C) that
the food can be cooked quickly. Thus, the community solar cooker works like a
conventional cooking device, with the difference that instead of using a conventional fuel
like gas or firewood, it uses solar energy inside the kitchen. Cooking for about 40–50
persons is possible with this cooker. The cooker works nicely in areas where solar
radiation is good during most part of the year. In such areas, it is possible to cook two
meals a day with this cooker. Due to the high temperature attained with this cooker, it is
suitable for making almost all traditional dishes, including chapatis, purees, dosas, etc.
When not in use for cooking, the cooker can be used to heat/boil water.The community
solar cooker can be useful to schools, institutional kitchens, canteens, religious ashrams,
hotels, hospitals, police and armed forces’ kitchens, etc. The cost of this cooker is about
Rs 50 000. The payback period is 4–5 years.
Solar steam generating system for cooking : It is possible to cook large quantities of
food using the steam generated by solar heat. A solar steam generating system comprises
automatically tracked parabolic concentrators, steam header assemblies with receivers,
steam pipelines, feed water piping, steel structures and civil works, instrumentation like
pressure gauges and temperature indicators, steam separators, steam traps, etc. The
system is generally hooked up with a conventional steam generating system already
available with the user, to make it reliable under all climatic conditions.
The world’s largest solar steam generating system for cooking has been installed by the
Tirumala Tirupathi Devasthanam (TTD), at Tirumala, Andhra Pradesh, under a
demonstration scheme of the MNES. The steam thus generated is used for cooking
purposes in the TTD kitchen. The system can supply enough steam to prepare food for 15
000 people each day. Smaller systems of this type have been installed at Mount Abu,
Shirdi, Hubli, Gurgaon, and other places.
Support from MNES: The MNES provides financial support to users of solar cookers,
as listed below.
Community solar cooker for indoor 50% of eligible capital cost, limited to
cooking Rs 25 000 per cooker
Advantages
Solar dryers are more economical compared to dryers that run on conventional
fuels/electricity.
The drying process is completed in the most hygienic and eco friendly way.
Solar drying systems have low operation and maintenance costs.
Solar dryers last longer. A typical dryer can last 15–20 years with minimum
maintenance.
Limitations
Drying can be performed only during sunny days, unless the system is integrated
with a conventional energy-based system.
Due to limitations in solar energy collection, the solar drying process is slow in
comparison with dryers that use conventional fuels.
Normally, solar dryers can be utilized only for drying at 40–50 ºC.
Cost: The cost of a solar dryer of 50-kg capacity ranges from about Rs 30 000 to Rs
50000. Larger industrial-scale systems may cost between Rs 4 lakhs and Rs 10 lakhs.
Subsidies. The MNES is implementing a national programme on solar thermal energy,
which provides interest subsidy in the form of soft loans available through IREDA and
banks. The MNES also provides capital subsidy of up to 50% of the project cost for a
specific demonstration project that is based on new technology and or is located in a new
area. There are a few manufacturers in India who are capable of supplying solar dryers for
specific purposes and in specific sizes. Larger systems for industrial establishment have
to be designed and installed on a project-by-project basis.
Potential for solar dryers: There is vast potential for solar dryers in the country: for
drying agro products and also for use in the fruit and food processing industries. Solar
drying systems can also be installed for drying a variety of industrial products such as
chemicals, leather, salt, plywood, and textiles.
Success stories
Solar drying systems have been installed in many places in the country.
Listed below are some locations where the systems are being used.
Produce / material being dried Location
Fruits and vegetables Sham Fruits and Vegetable Growers Co-
operative Marketing Society Ltd, Nimoo (30
km from Leh), J & K
Gasification/pyrolysis 8–9
Combustion/incineration 6–7
Financial Support: The scheme for providing financial support for waste-to-energy
projects is presently under review and accelerated programme on energy recovery from
municipal and industrial wastes is being developed for providing a major fillip to this
sector.
Implementation: Waste-to-energy projects can be set up by municipal corporations,
other urban local bodies, government institutions, and private developers having technical
and managerial capabilities for implementing such projects on the basis of Build, Own,
and Operate (BOO); Build, Own, Operate, and Transfer (BOOT); Build, Operate, and
Transfer (BOT); and Build, Operate, Lease, and Transfer (BOLT). The proposals are to
be sent to the MNES after completing all tie-ups for waste procurement, sale and
evacuation of power, pollution control, etc. In cases where debt financing is involved,
IREDA, other financial institutions, and commercial banks are required to forward
proposals along with their Appraisal Note. An advance copy of the proposal may be sent
to the MNES.
Potential: There exists a potential for generating an estimated 1700 MW of power from
the urban and municipal wastes, and about 1000 MW from industrial wastes in the
country. The potential is likely to increase further with economic development.
Achievements: A total of 27 waste-to-energy projects have been completed as on
31 March 2005 in India, with an aggregated installed capacity of 45.50 MW. Four
projects of 4.5-MW capacity are under implementation.
A few completed projects are described below.
Projects based on Urban Waste: Three projects based on MSW have been executed so
far: one of 5 MW at Lucknow, and two of 6 MW each at Hyderabad and Vijayawada.
6-MW MSW-based power project at Hyderabad: This project has been executed by
SELCO International Ltd, Hyderabad, by availing a soft loan from the Technology
Development Board (TDB), the Department of Science and Technology (DST), and the
Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency (IREDA). The plant is based on
combustion technology. MSW is first converted into ‘fluff ’ or into pellets of refuse-
derived fuel (RDF). The MSW fluff and RDF pellets are then directly burnt in the boiler
to generate steam, which, in turn, runs a steam turbine. The calorific value of the RDF
ranges from 3000 to 3500 kcal/kg. The plant is based on indigenous technology, and its
cost is about Rs 40 crores. It was commissioned in November 2003 and has generated 35
million units of electricity till January 2005. The project has been completed in two
phases: one for preparation of pellets from MSW and the other for power generation from
MSW pellets/fluff.
6-MW MSW-based power project at Vijayawada: This project has been executed by
Shriram Energy Systems, Hyderabad, and is based on combustion of MSW in the form of
fluff. It has been supported by the TDB and IREDA in terms of soft loans. The total cost
of the project is about Rs 45 crores, and it was commissioned in December 2003. A total
of 500 tonnes of MSW is being collected each day from Vijayawada and Guntur cities.
The MSW is processed for preparation of fluff at various sites, and then transported to the
plant site at Vijayawada. The plant is reportedly operating at full capacity. It has
generated 28 million units of electricity till January 2005, of which 12.34 million units
were exported to the grid.
5-MW MSW-based power project at Lucknow: This project has been executed by Asia
Bio-energy Pvt. Ltd, Chennai, on BOOM (build, own, operate, and maintenance) basis. It
is based on high-rate biomethanation technology, developed and commercialized by
ENTEC Environment Technology, Austria.
The major components of the plant are (a) segregation system, (b) biomethanation unit,
(c) biogas storage, (d) power generation, and (e) organic fertilizer production unit. It has
been designed to process 500–600 tonnes of MSW per day from Lucknow city. This
MSW is converted into about 115 tonnes of dry volatile solids, which produce 50 000 m3
of biogas per day along with about 75 tonnes of organic fertilizer (from biogas digester
slurry). The biogas produced is fed into five 100% biogas engines to generate 5 MW of
grid-quality power. The plant was commissioned for commercial operation in December
2003, and it reached a maximum limit of 1 MW. The major problem it faced in achieving
its designed capacity of power generation was the non-availability of segregated and
source-collected biodegradable MSW at the plant site. Efforts are being made by the
promoters and the Lucknow Nagar Nigam to provide this. The cost of the project is about
Rs 74 crores.
Demonstration Projects:A few demonstration projects on urban wastes have been taken
up by the MNES under the UNDP/GEF assisted project mentioned earlier.
Three such projects are described below.
1-MW power project based on cattle manure at Haebowal Dairy Complex, Ludhiana: The
Haebowal Dairy Complex in Ludhiana, spread over an area of over 20 hectares, has 1490
dairies with an animal population of 150 000. The complex generates about 2250 tonnes of
animal droppings each day. The project, which has been implemented at a cost of about Rs
13.60 crores, will use about 235 tonnes of animal waste each day to produce about 10 000 m3
of biogas, which, in turn, will be burnt to generate 0.965 MW of electrical energy. The
surplus energy after meeting the in-house power requirement will be fed to the state
electricity grid. Besides electrical energy, the project will also produce about 50 tonnes of
stabilized organic manure per day. The plant has been commissioned in December 2004.
The plant is based on biogas-induced mixing arrangement (BIMA) technology, developed
and commercialized by ENTEC Environment Technology, Austria. The Punjab Energy
Development Agency (PEDA) owns the plant and the Indian Institute of Technology,
Roorkee, monitors the performance of the plant.
0.15-MW power project utilizing vegetable market and slaughterhouse wastes at Vijayawada:
This plant is based on biomethanation of 20 tonnes per day of mixed wastes (that is, 16
tonnes of vegetable market waste and 4 tonnes of slaughterhouse waste) generated by the
Vijayawada Municipal Corporation (VMC). Sewage from the nearby treatment plant too is
being used for dilution of the mixed waste in the plant. The plant is owned by the VMC. It
was commissioned in June 2004, and is expected to generate about 1600 m3 of biogas along
with 5 tonnes of organic manure per day after complete stabilization of operations. The
biogas produced is being used in a 145-kW biogas engine for generation of electricity, which
the VMC proposes to feed into the state electricity grid. The VMC is monitoring the
performance of the plant.
0.5-MW power project based on biogas produced from sewage treatment plant at
Anjana, Surat: The Anjana sewage treatment plant (STP) at Surat has three sludge
digesters with a total capacity of 82.50 million litres per day (MLD) and generate about
2500 m3 of biogas per day from each digester. The biogas is fed into a hydrogen sulphide
(H2S) scrubber system, which removes any H2S in the gas before it is passed into a 100%
biogas engine to convert it into electricity. The electricity thus produced meets the power
requirement of the STP, thus saving electricity worth about Rs 10 lakhs per month. The
plant was commissioned in December 2003.
Projects based on Industrial Wastes Distillery waste: Kanoria Chemicals and
Industries Ltd, Ankleshwar, Gujarat, produces about 21 000 m3 of biogas per day from
biogas plants based on distillery waste water (spent wash). Since 1998–99, the biogas has
been utilized for generation of power required for the company’s captive use. The project
is based on two IC engines, each of 1 MW capacity, fuelled solely by biogas. The waste
heat of the fuel gases from the engines, at atemperature of more than 500 ºC, is utilized to
generate about 1.5 tonnes of steam per hour at about 130 ºC. The steam is used for
meeting process heat requirements of the factory. The project has been performing
satisfactorily for the past five years, and has been generating about 1 million units of
electricity every month amounting to a saving of Rs 40 lakhs per month. The pay-back
period works out to about three years.
Pulp and paper mill black liquor waste: The pulp and paper industry is highly
polluting, and consumes a large amount of energy and water in its various unit operations.
The waste water discharged by the industry is highly heterogeneous: it contains
compounds from wood or other raw materials, process chemicals, as well as compounds
formed during processing. A demonstration plant for biomethanation of bagasse wash
effluent for recovery of energy has been installed at Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers
Ltd, Karur, Tamil Nadu. Presently, about 12 000 m3 of gas is generated everyday. The
gas is being used in the line-mud re-burning kiln. With the current level of gas output
from the plant, 50% of the heat load of the kiln is met, which is approximately equivalent
to 12–13 kilolitres of furnace oil.
The biomethanation plant also yields indirect benefits like savings in electricity and
chemicals that would have been required for the treatment of waste water through the
conventional process.
Starch and glucose industry waste: A 4-MW-capacity power plant based on starch
industry solid waste has been installed at Vensa Biotech Ltd, Samalkot, Andhra Pradesh.
This firm processes about 63 000 tonnes of maize and 30 000 tonnes of tapioca per year
for manufacturing of liquid glucose and starch. The power plant is based on the starch
industry waste such as tapioca fibre, maize husk, and tapioca stems. The waste generated
after extracting starch and other by-products has very high calorific value, and can be
directly burnt in a boiler to generate steam. The steam thus generated is fed into a steam
turbine to generate power. The plant has been functioning satisfactorily since December
2003 and the power generated is being exported to the grid.
Slaughterhouse waste: Biogas plants have been installed for treating both solid and
liquid wastes generated from the slaughterhouse of Alkabeer Exports Ltd at Rudraram
village in Medak district of Andhra Pradesh. While about 1300 m3 of biogas is generated
from liquid wastes each day, about 2500 m3 of biogas is generated from solid wastes.
Adoption of biomethanation technology has resulted in saving of furnace oil as well as
chemicals used for treatment of waste water. Sludge from the anaerobic digester is dried
and marketed as a nutrient-rich soil conditioner. The biogas plants have resulted in a total
saving of Rs 6 lakhs per month.
National Wind Power Programme: The Wind Power Programme in India was initiated
towards the end of the Sixth Plan, in 1983–84. The programme aims at survey and
assessment of wind resources, setting up demonstration projects, and provision of
incentives to make wind electricity competitive. As a result, wind electricity has emerged
as an option for grid-quality power generation. The costs in respect of wind monitoring
stations are shared between the Ministry of Non-Conventional Energy Sources (MNES)
and the state nodal agencies in the ratio of 80:20 (90:10 for north-eastern states).
With 2980 MW of installed wind power capacity, India now ranks fifth in the world after
Germany, USA, Spain, and Denmark. Most of the capacity addition has been achieved
through commercial projects by private investors.
Cost of Wind Power Projects: The cost of wind power generation varies between Rs 4
and 5 crores per MW, depending upon state characteristics. The machines can be
maintained at a cost of Rs 0.25 to 0.60/kWh. The projects are estimated to have a pay-
back period of five to eight years.
Promotional Incentives: Wind power projects have been set up through private
investment. The promotional incentives available are listed below.
80% accelerated depreciation in the first year.
Concessional import duty of 5% on five specified wind turbine components and
their parts.
Favourable tariffs and policies in several states.
Manufacturing Base for Wind Turbine: Wind turbines are produced in the country by
about a dozen manufacturers, mainly through joint ventures or under licensed production
agreements. A few foreign companies have also set up their subsidiaries in India. A few
Indian companies are manufacturing WEGs without any foreign collaboration. Indian-
made wind turbines are also being exported to some countries.
Guidelines for Wind Power Projects: Comprehensive guidelines for wind power
projects have been issued by the MNES from time to time. These guidelines relate to
preparation of detailed project reports (DPRs), micro-siting, selection of wind turbine
equipment, operation and maintenance, performance evaluation, etc. Users of these
guidelines include the state electricity boards (SEBs), state nodal agencies,
manufacturers, developers, and investors. The certification requirement for wind turbines
was reintroduced with a time-bound provision for self-certification. C-WET issues a list
of manufacturers of certified wind turbine machines on a quarterly basis.
Success Stories: A few examples of successful wind farms are briefly described below.
Muppandal–Perungudi (Tamil Nadu): With an aggregate wind power capacity of 450
MW, the Muppandal–Perungudi region near Kanyakumari in Tamil Nadu has the
distinction of having one of the largest clusters of wind turbines. About Rs 2500 crores
has been invested in wind power in this region.
Kavdya Donger, Supa (Maharashtra): A wind farm project has been developed at
Kavdya Donger at Supa, off the Pune–Ahmednagar highway, about 100 km from Pune.
This wind farm has 57 machines of 1-MW capacity each. Annual capacity utilization of
up to 22% has been reported from this site. The farm is connected through V-sat to
project developers as well as promoters for online performance monitoring.
Satara district (Maharashtra): A conducive policy for private investment in wind
power projects has resulted in significant wind power development in Maharashtra,
particularly in the Satara district. Wind power capacity of about 340 MW has been
established at Vankusawade, Thosegarh, and Chalkewadi in Satara district, with an
investment of about Rs 1500 crores.
The agriculture ministry has asked for more incentives to local producers of bio-diesel
and rationalization of the customs duty structure on raw materials for biofuel production
to make such imports domestically and internationally competitive. Addressing the ‘Bio-
energy Tech 2007’ convention, the union agriculture minister Shri Sharad Pawar said the
country had vast potential for producing biofuel from the biomass generated by
agriculture and forests. besides, biofuel can be derived from several crops such as sugar
cane, cassava, sweet sorghum, maize, and sugar beet, and the seeds of tree species such as
jatropha and karanja. Shri Pawar said that the NOVODB (National Oilseeds and
Vegetable Oils Development
Board), under the agriculture ministry, had already begun research, development, and
promotion work on oilseed trees such as jatropha and karanja. The board has set up a
countrywide network for identification and development of elite planting material for
biofuel
producing trees and plants. Nurseries for producing elite planting material of these plants
have been set up on 10 000 hectares in 21 states. NOVODB is offering back-ended,
credit-linked subsidy for encouraging biofuel production. However, more incentives are
required for the purpose. Shri Pawar said that the estimated 5% blending of petrodiesel
with bio-diesel would require about 25 lakh hectares of waste land to be brought under
jatropha and karanja plantation. To promote biofuels on such a scale, it was necessary to
make farmers understand
that these ventures would be profitable, the minister said. The interests of various other
stakeholders would also have to be taken care of, he said. Justifying the need for
encouraging
the use of biofuel, he said that the country’s current annual petroleum products
requirement
was estimated at 124 million tonne. Nearly 72% of this was met through imports from the
Gulf region, one of the most volatile parts of the world. Some of the delegates attending
the convention emphasized the need for increasing the availability of bank loans to
farmers
to encourage them to go in for raising biofuel plantations.
BUSINESS STANDARD, 6 JANUARY 2007
Chapter 7
International Laws on Environment & Energy
INTERNATIONAL DECLARATIONS / AGREEMENTS
Post world war economies of western world grew at a tremendous pace. This started
faster consumption of earth’s resouces and also led to discharge of effluents in the
environment. By sixties degradation of environment has started showing which made
countries aware of the adverse effects of unchecked consuption of vital resources.
The United Nations Conference on Human Environment was held in Stockholm from 5th
June to 16th June, 1972. It was also attended by India’s prime minister Mrs. Indira
Gandhi.
India’s approach to the challenge of the protection of our environment was shaped by the very wise and
perceptive observations of our former Prime Minister, Mrs. Indira Gandhi, who told the United Nations
Conference on the Human Environment in 1972 that "poverty was the worst polluter".
In saying so, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi launched a global debate on the relationship between poverty
alleviation, economic growth, and environmental conservation. In the years since then, an organized
structure of multilateral agreements and institutions for realizing the goal of sustainable development has
been developed.
The United Nations Conference on Human Environment proclaimed:
The protection and improvement of the human environment is a major issue which affects
the well being of peoples and economic development. It was also proclaimed that man is
both creator and molder of the environment, which gives him physical sustainance and
affords him the opportunity for intellectual, moral, social and spiritual growth. Man has
acquired the power to transform his environment in countless ways and on unprecedented
scale.
It was also proclaimed that, since, in the developing countries, most of environment
problems are caused by under development; the developing countries must direct their
efforts to development, bearing in mind their priorities, and the need to safeguard and
improve the environment. For the same purpose, the industrialised countries should make
efforts to reduce the gap between themselves and the developing countries.
The Stockholm conference laid down 26 principles to be followed by the states for the
preservation and improvement of human environment. These include:
The natural resources of earth including the air, water, land flora and fauna must
be safeguarded for the benefit of present and future generations through careful planning
and management.
The capacity of the earth to produce vital renewable resources must be maintained
and wherever practicable, restored or improved.
The non-renewable resources of the earth must be employed in a way as to guard
against the danger of their future exhaustion.
Environmental deficiencies generated by the conditions of under development and
natural disasters must be remedied by accelerated development through the transfer of
substantial quantities of financial and technological assistance.
For the developing countries stability of prices and adequate earnings for primary
commodities and raw materials are essential for environmental management.
After the UN conference on Human Environment, 1972 the United Nations
Environment Program (UNEP) was established. UNEP has played a very important
role in in the evolution of conventions and instruments in the field of environment
protection like 1985 Vienna Convention for the protection of Ozone Layer and the 1987
Montreal protocol and 1992 Convention on Biodiversity.
From 3rd to 14th June, 1992, representatives of over 150 countries assembled in Rio de
Janeiro, Brazil, for the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development
(UNCED) what was popularly known as Earth Summit. The Earth Summit is considered
an important milestone in establishing the linkages between environment and
development and in defining the concept of “Sustainable Development” One of the
objects of RIO conference was to recognize the integral and interdependent nature of our
earth.
Principles proclaimed at UNCED RIO conference include:
The right to development must be fulfilled so as to equitably meet developmental
and environmental needs of present and future generations (doctrine of Intergenerational
Equity).
In order to achieve sustainable development, environment protection shall
constitute an integral part of the developmental process (Doctrine of Sustainable
Development).
All states and all people shall cooperate in the essential task of eradicating poverty
The special situation and needs of developing countries particularly the least
developed and those most environmentally vulnerable, shall be given special priority.
States shall enact effective environmental legislation.
In order to protect the environment the precautionary approach shall be widely
used by the states. Lack of Scientific certainty shall not be used as a reason for
postponing cost effective measures to prevent environment degradation (Precautionary
Principle).
National authorities should endeavor to promote the internalization of
environmental costs taking into account the approach that polluter should bear the cost of
pollution (Polluter Pays principle).
Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) shall be undertaken for proposed activities
that are likely to have adverse impact on the environment.
AGENDA 21 was one of the instruments adopted at UNCED Rio conference. It is a non-
binding instrument that presents a set of strategies and detailed program to halt and
reverse the effects of environmental degradation and to promote environmentally sound
and sustainable development in all countries.
In 1995, several nations agreed that voluntary reductions in GHG emissions were not
effective. Therefore, a conference was held at Kyoto on climate change on December 1,
1997 to review the progress made in five years from Rio 1992 and to formulate plans and
fix strategies and objectives for the future.
The parties to the UNFCCC, in pursuit of the ultimate objective, as stated in Article 2 of
the convention agreed to fulfill the obligations contained in the through the convention
Kyoto Protocol.
Some of the important commitments accepted by the parties for achieving quantified
emissions limitation and reductions. These are included in Annex –I of the UNFCC and
include:-
1. Implement and / or further elaborate policies and measures in accordance with it’s
national circumstances, such as:
a) Enhancement of energy efficiency
b) Protection & enhancement of sinks and reservoirs of GHG emissions not controlled
by the Montreal Protocol, promotion of sustainable forest management practices,
afforestation and reforestation.
c) Promotion of sustainable forms of agriculture in light of climate changes.
d) Promotion, research, development and increased use of new and renewable forms of
energy, of CO2 sequestration and advanced / innovative technologies.
e) Progressive reduction or phasing out of fiscal incentives, tax and duty exemptions and
subsidies in all GHG emissions sectors. Promoting policies and measuresand reforms
to limit and reduce emissions of GHG not controlled by Montreal Protocol including
transport sector.
f) Limitations and reduction of methane through recovery and use in waste management
as well as in production, transport, and distribution of energy.
2. Parties agree to share their experience and exchange information on such policies and
measures of improving their comparability, transparency and effectiveness.
3. Parties included in Annex-I shall pursue limitation or reduction of emissions of GHG
from aviation and marine bunker fuels.
4. Parties included in Annex-I shall try to minimize adverse effects of climate change on
international trade and social, environmental 7 economic impacts on other parties especially
developing countries.
5. Parties included in Annex-I shall individually or jointly ensure that their aggregate
anthropogenic carbon dioxide equivalent emissions of GHG listed in Annex-A do not exceed
their assigned amounts commitments in Annex-B, with a view to reducing overall emissions
of GHG by at least 5% below 1990 levels during period 2008-2012.
The Kyoto protocol is an international and legally binding agreement to reduce greenhouse gas emissions
worldwide. It came into force in February 2005 after being agreed at a 1997 UN conference in Kyoto,
Japan. A total of 174 nations ratified the pact to reduce the greenhouse gases emitted by developed
countries to at least 5% below 1990 levels by 2008-12. However, United States, the world's biggest carbon
emitter, opposed the Kyoto protocol in 2001, saying it would be too expensive and should include targets
for developing nations. Australia's former prime minister, John Howard, whose 11-year term in office was
ended by a Labour victory last month, also strongly opposed ratification of Kyoto, arguing it would unfairly
damage Australia's energy-export based economy and cost jobs. The prime minister elect, Kevin Rudd, ran
a successful campaign on a platform to address climate change, and hopes his new government will ratify
the Kyoto protocol immediately.
With the Kyoto protocol due to expire in 2012, a new international climate change deal must be put in place
in time to ensure that necessary action is undertaken immediately. The UN says that this year's scientific
report from the its Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has "made clear beyond doubt that
climate change is a reality", which poses a serious threat to the future development of the world's
economies, societies and ecosystems. "We cannot go on this way for long," the UN secretary general, Ban
Ki-moon, has said. "We cannot continue with business as usual. The time has come for decisive action on a
global scale."
The main goal of the Bali conference is to get underway negotiations on a new international climate change
agreement. The Bali conference is not expected to deliver a fully negotiated and agreed climate deal, but
instead aims to set the necessary wheels in motion. Parties need to agree on the key areas which the new
climate agreement should cover, such as mitigation (including avoided deforestation, where industrialised
nations pay rainforest-rich nations to protect their forests to offset greenhouse gas emissions), adaptation,
technology and financing. They also need to agree on when the talks and negotiations will conclude so that
the new climate change deal can be ratified by national governments before the end of 2012. Other
important issues under negotiation in Bali, included adaptation to climate change, the launch of a fund for
adaptation, reducing emissions from deforestation, issues relating to the carbon market, and arrangements
for a review of the Kyoto protocol.
Four reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), a G8 summit
in Heiligendamm, a Nobel Peace Prize for Al Gore and a world climate council -- never
before has there been so much talk about reducing greenhouse gases as in 2007.
However, not a single reduction goal for after 2010 is included in the final text, although
such goals have been the topic of discussion for weeks -- even months -- and warnings
from scientists who have been recognized with the very highest prizes can be found in a
one-and-a-half-line footnote
The progress made in Bali was minimal at best, writes DW's Jens Thurau.
But the mandate for a Kyoto successor treaty by 2009 and the isolation of the
US delegation were two lights in the dark.
It's the same old situation that's to blame: The sacred oath that the wealthy states made at
the environment summit in Rio in 1992 to set a good example in cutting emissions hasn't
been kept. The industrialized countries have lost valuable time -- or, like the US and
Russia, simply approach the climate challenge with demonstrative apathy. Practically
every climate conference ends in the same way: the US, with countries like Canada and
Russia on its side, facing off against the developing nations. It was no different this time.
In a certain way, the ambitious European Union also bear some of the guilt. They're
constantly naming the most extensive goals, but only a few EU states -- including
Germany -- will fulfill the aims of the Kyoto Protocol by 2012.
Climate change will hit the poorest and most vulnerable the hardest, according to the IPCC, but it will affect
everyone. With their greater economic and technological resources, industrialised countries are considered
to be equipped to do the most to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Increasingly, developing countries are
also taking steps to cut back on emissions and to adapt to the impacts of climate change. The international
community is identifying resources, tools and approaches to support these efforts. According to the IPCC,
strategies for adaptation should take into account environmental, economic and social concerns of
sustainable development. For obvious reasons, the emerging nations refuse to risk the bit of prosperity
they've finally managed to attain by making commitments to climate protection.
Nevertheless, two aspects make the results of the Bali conference just barely tolerable.
As expected, the mandate was issued to negotiate a successor treaty to Kyoto by 2009.
And, as India proposed a text change at the end of the conference, the US delegation,
which rejected the proposal, had to come to terms with their exaggerated arrogance
toward the Third World. No one, not even eternal allies Canada or Russia, stood by the
Americans, who ultimately gave up their resistance. In the end, the at least symbolic
victory should give the developing countries, which are most burdened by climate
change, more self-confidence.
As talks overran their scheduled close by more than a day, delegates from the EU, US
and G-77/China embarked with UN officials on a series of behind-the-scenes
consultations aiming to break the remaining deadlock. The EU and US agreed to drop
binding targets; then the EU and China agreed to soften language on commitments from
developing countries. A chorus of boos rang out. And a member of Papua New Guinea's
delegation told the US: "If you're not willing to lead, please get out of the way." Shortly
after, the US delegation announced it would support the revised text after all.
Delegates at the UN summit in Bali have agreed a deal on curbing climate change after days of bitter
wrangling. Agreement was reached after a U-turn from the US, which had wanted firmer commitments
from developing countries. Environment groups said they were disappointed by the lack of firm targets for
reducing emissions. The "Bali roadmap" initiates a two-year process of negotiations designed to agree a
new set of emissions targets to replace those in the Kyoto Protocol. The EU had pressed for a commitment
that industrialised nations should commit to cuts of 25-40% by 2020, a bid that was implacably opposed by
a bloc containing the US, Canada and Japan. The final text does not mention specific emissions targets, but
does acknowledge that "deep cuts in global emissions will be required to achieve the ultimate objective" of
avoiding dangerous climate change. It also says that a delay in reducing emissions will make severe
climate impacts more likely.
"This is a real breakthrough, a real opportunity for the international community to
successfully fight climate change," said Indonesian Environment Minister Rachmat
Witoelar, who served as conference president, at the conclusion of the talks. UN
Secretary General Ban Ki-moon said he appreciated "the spirit of flexibility" shown by
key delegations - and was aware that "there is divide of position between and among
countries". "But as this global warming is an issue which affects the whole humanity,
whole planet earth, we must have co-ordinated and concerted efforts to address this
issue," Mr Ban said. In London, UK Prime Minister Gordon Brown declared: "This
agreement is a vital step forward for the whole world. "The Bali roadmap agreed today is
just the first step. Now begins the hardest work, as all nations work towards a deal in
Copenhagen in 2009 to address the defining challenge of our time."
Environmental groups and some delegates have criticised the draft as being weak and a
missed opportunity. "This deal is very disappointing," said Tony Juniper of Friends of the
Earth. "We said we needed a roadmap, but this conference has failed to give us a clear
destination." The document coming out of the meeting, the "Bali roadmap", contains text
on emissions cuts, the transfer of clean technology to developing countries, halting
deforestation and helping poorer nations protect their economies and societies against
impacts of climate change such as rising sea levels and falling crop yields.
The roadmap sets the parameters and aims for a further set of negotiations to be finalised
by the 2009 UN climate conference, to be held in Copenhagen Denmark. By that stage,
parties should have agreed on a comprehensive plan for curbing global warming and
adapting to its impacts.
This will include:
emissions targets for industrialised countries, possibly but not necessarily binding
some softer form of targets or ambitions for major developing countries
mechanisms for leveraging funds from carbon trading to fund adaptation projects
Earlier, consensus was reached on the principle of rewarding poorer countries to protect
their forests. This is widely acknowledged as the cheapest single way of curbing climate
change, and brings benefits in other environmental areas such as biodiversity and fresh
water conservation. Delegates agreed on a framework that could allow richer nations and
companies to earn "carbon credits" by paying for forest protection in developing
countries.
Mr Mitchell said the only feasible source of sufficient funds was a global carbon market.
But many economists believe mandatory emissions targets are needed to create a
meaningful global market.
The second gathering of the Major Economies Meeting on Energy Security and Climate
Change wound up in Honolulu on Thursday without any formally stated outcomes.
However, the meeting behind closed doors has endorsed the “Bali road map”, the 189-
nation undertaking at the UN’s annual climate convention talks last December to strike a
new international deal by the end of 2009.
The Bush Administration last year gave its commitment to the UN climate change
convention being the process through which a new global agreement should be forged. Its
own meeting of 16 of the largest emitting nations from the developing and developed
world is aimed at finding common ground on how a new treaty might include all of them,
the US government says.
"In the Bali road map, we committed to a vision of deep cuts in emissions, and now we
are trying to sort through how we can come up with a common expression of that," said
James Connaughton, the White House’s chief environmental adviser.
The group consists of India, China, Brazil, Indonesia, Mexico, South Africa, Britain,
Germany, France, Italy, separate EU representatives, Russia, Japan, Australia, South
Korea, Canada and the US.
France’s climate change ambassador, Brice Lalonde, said “now we are seeing that the
United States is discussing the matter," Reuters reports. "We welcome this move. Of
course we are waiting for the next step, which would be that the US will also have a goal
in reducing its greenhouse gases, joining in that way all developed countries."
Germany's minister for the environment, Matthias Machnig, expressed concern that there
is not yet enough common ground, saying “we need a clear international agreement,
because we are running out of time."
Also discussed at the meeting was energy efficiency, deforestation and the transfer of
clean technology from the rich world to poorer nations. The US and Japan have recently
committed $2 billion each to new initiatives to help developing nations tackle climate
change, expected to result in a new World Bank fund.
07 April 2008
UN official: The train to Copenhagen has left the station
The first major UN climate change talks since the Bali meeting last December have
wound up in Bangkok with a schedule agreed for how the 189 nations of the UN climate
convention will work towards a new global climate treaty to extend the Kyoto Protocol
beyond 2012.
The primary aim of the Bangkok meeting was process oriented - thrashing out the step-
by-step work program of negotiations in the areas needed for a comprehensive global
climate agreement:
*mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions;
*adaptation to the impacts of climate change;
*development and deployment of clean carbon technology;
*financial market mechanisms.
Yvo de Boer, executive secretary of United Nations Framework Convention on Climate
Change, welcomed the outcome as major step in implementing the Bali roadmap saying
afterwards “the train to Copenhagen has left the station”. The work programme agreed
means these can be addressed in “bite-sized, manageable chunks of work”, de Boer said,
across seven meetings timetabled up to the deadline for the new agreement – at the UN’s
annual meeting in Copenhagen at the end of 2009.
The primary aim of the Bangkok meeting was process oriented - thrashing out the step-
by-step work programme of negotiations in the areas needed for a comprehensive global
climate agreement; the mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions, adaptation to the impacts
of climate change, development and deployment of clean carbon technology and financial
market mechanisms.
Other views of the meeting were not so sanguine as De Boer’s, however. The gathering of
1000 or more delegates from 163 countries was also the first chance to gauge what
movement there has been on the major sticking points of targets and burden-sharing since
the new ‘constructive’ air following Bali and the US-convened major emitters’ meeting in
Hawaii early this year.
“The talks managed to keep the momentum going … but it’s hard to leave Bangkok
confident that the deadline can be met,” said Elliot Diringer, director of international
strategies at the respected Pew Center on Climate Change. Major nations were still
sticking to their old positions on the big questions that have stalemated negotiations up to
now, Diringer said.
The proposal by Japan for emissions reductions in developing countries to be shifted from
an overall national focus to a sector-by-sector approach was put off for discussion late in
the year after finding significant opposition from developing countries. Bloomberg
reports the G77 group of developing nations, including China and India, expressed
concern that rich countries weren’t setting new national emissions reduction targets. The
developing world maintains a view that firm commitments to reduce emissions by
developed countries is a key, first-up requirement in a new global agreement.
On the positive side of the ledger, a significant area of agreement among all nations,
developed and developing, was support for the carbon market mechanisms of Kyoto
being continued under a new agreement. Effectively, the Bangkok meeting has reduced
some of the uncertainty surrounding the future of the primary market mechanism of
Kyoto, the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM).
“This sends an important signal to businesses that the international carbon market
spawned by the Kyoto Protocol will continue beyond 2012,” de Boer said in his closing
statement. “Businesses have been asking for clarity on this issue, and now they have it.”
This Synthesis Report is based on the assessment carried out by the three Working
groups of the IPCC. It provides an integrated view of climate change as the final part of
the IPCC.s Fourth Assessment Report. This report addresses environmental concerns in
totality and suggests a road map for mitigation thereof.
Observational evidence from all continents and most oceans shows that many
natural systems are being affected by regional climate changes, particularly
temperature increases.
Changes in snow, ice and frozen ground have increased the number and size of glacial
lakes, increased ground instability in mountain and other permafrost regions, and led to
changes in some Arctic and Antarctic ecosystems. Some hydrological systems have also
been affected through increased runoff and earlier spring peak discharge in many glacier-
and snow-fed rivers, and effects on thermal structure and water quality of warming rivers
and lakes. In terrestrial ecosystems, earlier timing of spring events and pole-ward and
upward shifts in plant and animal ranges are linked to recent warming. In some marine
and freshwater systems, shifts in ranges and changes in algal, plankton and fish
abundance are associated with rising water temperatures, as well as related changes in ice
cover, salinity, oxygen levels and circulation.
Other effects of regional climate change on natural and human environments are
emerging, although many are difficult to discern due to adaptation and non-climatic
drivers.
Atmospheric concentrations of CO2 (379ppm) and CH4 (1774 ppb) in 2005 exceed by far
the natural range over the last 650,000 years. Global increases in CO2 concentrations are
due primarily to fossil fuel use, with land-use change providing another significant but
smaller contribution. It is very likely that the observed increase in CH4 concentration is
predominantly due to agriculture and fossil fuel use. Methane growth rates have declined
since the early 1990s, consistent with total emission (sum of anthropogenic and natural
sources) being nearly constant during this period. The increase in N2O concentration is
primarily due to agriculture. {2.2}
There is very high confidence that the net effect of human activities since 1750 has been
one of warming.
The IPCC Special Report on Emission Scenarios (SRES, 2000) projects an increase of
global GHG emissions by 25-90% (CO2-eq) between 2000 and 2030 (Figure SPM.5),
with fossil fuels maintaining their dominant position in the global energy mix to 2030 and
beyond.
Continued GHG emissions at or above current rates would cause further warming
and induce many changes in the global climate system during the 21st century that
would very likely be larger than those observed during the 20th century.
For the next two decades a warming of about 0.2°C per decade is projected. Even if the
concentrations of all greenhouse gases and aerosols had been kept constant at year 2000
levels, a further warming of about 0.1oC per decade would be expected.
By mid-century, annual river runoff and water availability are projected to increase at
high latitudes (and in some tropical wet areas) and decrease in some dry regions in the
mid-latitudes and tropics. Also many semi-arid areas (e.g. Mediterranean basin, western
United States, southern Africa and northeast Brazil) will suffer a decrease in water
resources due to climate change.
Examples of some projected regional impacts
Africa
• By 2020, between 75 and 250 million of people are projected to be exposed to increased
water stress due to climate change;
• By 2020, in some countries, yields from rain-fed agriculture could be reduced by up to
50%. Agricultural production, including access to food, in many African countries is
projected to be severely compromised. This would further adversely affect food security
and exacerbate malnutrition;
• Towards the end of the 21st century, projected sea-level rise will affect low-lying
coastal areas with large populations. The cost of adaptation could amount to at least 5-
10% of Gross Domestic Product (GDP);
• By 2080, an increase of 5-8% of arid and semi-arid land in Africa is projected.
Asia
• By the 2050s, freshwater availability in Central, South, East and South-East Asia,
particularly in large river basins, is projected to decrease;
• Coastal areas, especially heavily-populated mega delta regions in South, East and South-
East Asia, will be at greatest risk due to increased flooding from the sea and, in some
mega deltas, flooding from the rivers;
• Climate change is projected to compound the pressures on natural resources and the
environment, associated with rapid urbanization, industrialization and economic
development;
• Endemic morbidity and mortality due to diarrhoeal disease primarily associated with
floods and droughts are expected to rise in East, South and South-East Asia due to
projected changes in the hydrological cycle.
Europe
• Climate change is expected to magnify regional differences in Europe’s natural
resources and assets. Negative impacts will include increased risk of inland flash floods,
and more frequent coastal flooding and increased erosion (due to storminess and sea-level
rise);
• Mountainous areas will face glacier retreat, reduced snow cover and winter tourism, and
extensive species losses (in some areas up to 60% under high emissions scenarios by
2080);
• In Southern Europe, climate change is projected to worsen conditions (high
temperatures and drought) in a region already vulnerable to climate variability, and to
reduce water availability, hydropower potential, summer tourism and, in general, crop
productivity;
• Climate change is also projected to increase the health risks due to heat-waves, and the
frequency of wildfires.
Latin America
• By mid century, increases in temperature and associated decreases in soil water are
projected to lead to gradual replacement of tropical forest by savanna in eastern
Amazonia. Semi-arid vegetation will tend to be replaced by arid-land vegetation.
• There is a risk of significant biodiversity loss through species extinction in many areas
of tropical Latin America;
• Productivity of some important crops is projected to decrease and livestock productivity
to decline, with adverse consequences for food security. In temperate zones soybean
yields are projected to increase. Overall, the number of people at risk of hunger is
projected to increase
• Changes in precipitation patterns and the disappearance of glaciers are projected to
significantly affect water availability for human consumption, agriculture and energy
generation.
North America
• Warming in western mountains is projected to cause decreased snow-pack, more winter
flooding, and reduced summer flows, exacerbating competition for over-allocated water
resources;
• In the early decades of the century, moderate climate change is projected to increase
aggregate yields of rain-fed agriculture by 5-20%, but with important variability among
regions. Major challenges are projected for crops that are near the warm end of their
suitable range or which depend on highly utilized water resources;
• During the course of this century, cities that currently experience heatwaves are
expected to be further challenged by an increased number, intensity and duration of
heatwaves during the course of the century, with potential for adverse health impacts;
• Coastal communities and habitats will be increasingly stressed by climate change
impacts interacting with development and pollution.
Polar Regions
• The main projected biophysical effects are reductions in thickness and extent of glaciers
and ice sheets and sea ice, and changes in natural ecosystems with detrimental effects on
many organisms including migratory birds, mammals and higher predators;
• For human communities in the Arctic, impacts, particularly those resulting from
changing snow and ice conditions are projected to be mixed;
• Detrimental impacts would include those on infrastructure and traditional indigenous
ways of life;
• In both polar regions, specific ecosystems and habitats are projected to be vulnerable, as
climatic barriers to species invasions are lowered.
Small Islands
• Sea-level rise is expected to exacerbate inundation, storm surge, erosion and other
coastal hazards, thus threatening vital infrastructure, settlements and facilities that support
the livelihood of island communities;
• Deterioration in coastal conditions, for example through erosion of beaches and coral
bleaching is expected to affect local resources;
• By mid-century, climate change is expected to reduce water resources in many small
islands, e.g., in the Caribbean and Pacific, to the point where they become insufficient to
meet demand during low-rainfall periods.
• With higher temperatures, increased invasion by non-native species is expected to occur,
particularly on mid- and high-latitude islands.
Some systems, sectors and regions are likely to be especially affected by climate change.
• particular ecosystems:
• terrestrial: tundra, boreal forest and mountain regions because of sensitivity to warming;
mediterranean-type ecosystems because of reduction in rainfall; and tropical rainforests
where precipitation declines
• coastal: mangroves and salt marshes, due to multiple stresses
• marine: coral reefs due to multiple stresses; the sea ice biome because of sensitivity to
warming
• water resources in some dry regions at mid-latitudes and in the dry tropics, due to
changes in rainfall and evapotranspiration, and in areas dependent on snow and ice melt
• agriculture in low-latitudes , due to reduced water availability
• low-lying coastal systems, due to threat of sea level rise and increased risk from extreme
weather events
• human health in populations with low adaptive capacity.
• the Arctic, because of the impacts of high rates of projected warming on natural systems
and human communities
• Africa, because of low adaptive capacity and projected climate change impacts
• small islands, where there is high exposure of population and infrastructure to projected
climate change impacts
• Asian and African mega-deltas, due to large populations and high exposure to sea level
rise, storm surges and river flooding.
Within other areas, even those with high incomes, some people (such as the poor, young
children, and the elderly) can be particularly at risk, and also some areas and some
activities.
Ocean Acidification
The uptake of anthropogenic carbon since 1750 has led to the ocean becoming more
acidic with an average decrease in pH of 0.1 units. Increasing atmospheric CO2
concentrations lead to further acidification. Projections give a reduction in average global
surface ocean pH of between 0.14 and 0.35 units over the 21st century. While the effects
of observed ocean acidification on the marine biosphere are as yet undocumented, the
progressive acidification of oceans is expected to have negative impacts on marine shell
forming
organisms (e.g. corals) and their dependent species.
Altered frequencies and intensities of extreme weather, together with sea level rise,
are expected to have mostly adverse effects on natural and human systems.
Anthropogenic warming and sea level rise would continue for centuries due to the
timescales associated with climate processes and feedbacks, even if GHG
concentrations were to be stabilised.
Current models suggest virtually complete elimination of the Greenland ice sheet and a
resulting contribution to sea level rise of about 7 m if global average warming were
sustained for millennia in excess of 1.9 to 4.6ºC relative to pre-industrial values.
The corresponding future temperatures in Greenland are comparable to those inferred for
the last interglacial period 125,000 years ago, when paleoclimatic information suggests
reductions of polar land ice extent and 4 to 6 m of sea level rise.
Anthropogenic warming could lead to some impacts that are abrupt or irreversible,
depending upon the rate and magnitude of the climate change.
Partial loss of ice sheets on polar land could imply metres of sea level rise, major changes
in coastlines and inundation of low-lying areas, with greatest effects in river deltas and
low-lying islands. Such changes are projected to occur over millennial time scales, but
more rapid sea level rise on century time scales cannot be excluded.
Climate change is likely to lead to some irreversible impacts. Approximately 20-30% of
species assessed so far are likely to be at increased risk of extinction if increases in global
average warming exceed 1.5-2.5 DegC (relative to 1980-1999). As global average
temperature increase exceeds about 3.5 DegC, model projections suggest significant
extinctions (40-70% of species assessed) around the globe.
Both bottom-up and top-down studies indicate that there is high agreement and
much evidence of substantial economic potential for the mitigation of global GHG
emissions over the coming decades that could offset the projected growth of global
emissions or reduce emissions below current levels.
While top-down and bottom-up studies are in line at the global level there are
considerable differences at the sectoral level.
No single technology can provide all of the mitigation potential in any sector. The
economic mitigation potential, which is generally greater than the market mitigation
potential, can only be achieved when adequate policies are in place and barriers removed.
Studies suggest that mitigation opportunities with net negative costs have the potential to
reduce emissions by around 6 GtCO2-eq/yr in 2030, realizing which requires dealing with
implementation barriers.
A wide variety of policies and instruments are available to governments to create the
incentives for mitigation action. Their applicability depends on national
circumstances and sectoral context.
They include integrating climate policies in wider development policies, regulations and
standards, taxes and charges, tradable permits, financial incentives, voluntary agreements,
information instruments, and research, development and demonstration (RD&D).
An effective carbon-price signal could realise significant mitigation potential in all
sectors. Modelling studies show global carbon prices rising to 20-80 US$/tCO2-eq by
2030 are consistent with stabilisation at around 550 ppm CO2-eq by 2100. For the same
stabilisation level, induced technological change may lower these price ranges to 5-65
US$/tCO2-eq in 2030.
There is high agreement and much evidence that mitigation actions can result in near-term
co-benefits (e.g. improved health due to reduced air pollution) that may offset a
substantial fraction of mitigation costs.
There is high agreement and medium evidence that Annex I countries. actions may affect
the global economy and global emissions, although the scale of carbon leakage remains
uncertain.
Fossil fuel exporting nations (in both Annex I and non-Annex I countries) may expect, as
indicated in the TAR, lower demand and prices and lower GDP growth due to mitigation
policies. The extent of this spill over depends strongly on assumptions related to policy
decisions and oil market conditions.
There is also high agreement and medium evidence that changes in lifestyle, behaviour
patterns and management practices can contribute to climate change mitigation across all
sectors.
Many options for reducing global GHG emissions through international cooperation
exist. There is high agreement and much evidence that notable achievements of the
UNFCCC and its Kyoto Protocol are the establishment of a global response to
climate change, stimulation of an array of national policies, and the creation of an
international carbon market and new institutional mechanisms that may provide the
foundation for future mitigation efforts. Progress has also been made in addressing
adaptation within the UNFCCC and additional international initiatives have been
suggested.
Greater cooperative efforts and expansion of market mechanisms will help to reduce
global costs for achieving a given level of mitigation, or will improve environmental
effectiveness. Efforts can include diverse elements such as emissions targets; sectoral,
local, sub-national and regional actions; RD&D programmes; adopting common policies;
implementing development oriented actions; or expanding financing instruments.
In several sectors, climate response options can be implemented to realise synergies
and avoid conflicts with other dimensions of sustainable development. Decisions
about macroeconomic and other non-climate policies can significantly affect
emissions, adaptive capacity and vulnerability.
Making development more sustainable can enhance mitigative and adaptive capacities,
reduce emissions, and reduce vulnerability, but there may be barriers to implementation.
On the other hand, it is very likely that climate change can slow the pace of progress
towards sustainable development. Over the next half-century, climate change could
impede achievement of the Millennium Development Goals.
There is high confidence that neither adaptation nor mitigation alone can avoid all
climate change impacts; however, they can complement each other and together can
significantly reduce the risks of climate change.
There is high agreement and much evidence that all stabilisation levels assessed can
be achieved by deployment of a portfolio of technologies that are either currently
available or expected to be
commercialised in coming decades, assuming appropriate and effective incentives
are in place for their development, acquisition, deployment and diffusion and
addressing related barriers.
All assessed stabilisation scenarios indicate that 60-80% of the reductions would
come from energy supply and use, and industrial processes, with energy efficiency
playing a key role in many scenarios.
Including non-CO2 and CO2 land-use and forestry mitigation options provides greater
flexibility and cost-effectiveness. Low stabilization levels require early investments and
substantially more rapid diffusion and commercialisation of advanced low emissions
technologies. Without substantial investment flows and effective technology transfer, it
may be difficult to achieve emission reduction at a significant scale. Mobilizing financing
of incremental costs of low-carbon technologies is important.
The macro-economic costs of mitigation generally rise with the stringency of the
stabilisation target. For specific countries and sectors, costs vary considerably from
the global average.
In 2050, global average macro-economic costs for mitigation towards stabilisation
between 710 and 445ppm CO2-eq are between a 1% gain and 5.5% decrease of global
GD. This corresponds to slowing average annual global GDP growth by less than 0.12
percentage points.
Responding to climate change involves an iterative risk management process that includes both adaptation
and mitigation and takes into account climate change damages, co-benefits, sustainability, equity, and
attitudes to risk.
Impacts of climate change are very likely to impose net annual costs which will increase
over time as global temperatures increase. Peer-reviewed estimates of the social cost of
carbon in 2005 average US$12 per tonne of CO2, but the range from 100 estimates is
large (-$3 to $95/tCO2). This is due in large part to differences in assumptions regarding
climate sensitivity, response lags, the treatment of risk and equity, economic and non
economic
impacts, the inclusion of potentially catastrophic losses, and discount rates. Aggregate
estimates of costs mask significant differences in impacts across sectors, regions and
populations and very likely underestimate damage costs because they cannot include
many non-quantifiable impacts. Limited and early analytical results from integrated
analyses of the costs and benefits of mitigation indicate that they are broadly comparable
in magnitude, but do not as yet permit an unambiguous determination of an emissions
pathway or stabilisation level where benefits exceed costs. Climate sensitivity is a key
uncertainty for mitigation scenarios for specific temperature levels. Choices about the
scale and timing of GHG mitigation involve balancing the economic costs of more rapid
emission reductions now against the corresponding medium-term and long-term climate
risks of delay.
Chapter 8
Technological Intiatives
Annexures
Abbreviations Used
Bibliography