You are on page 1of 18

NEW WEBSITE: www.ephesians-511.

net AUGUST 2006

ENNEAGRAM PRACTITIONER MINISTERS AT MAJOR CATHOLIC RETREAT CENTRE


Please see http://ephesians-511.net/documents/ENNEAGRAMS_SUMMARY.doc for information on Enneagrams which is a New Age personality-typing system. Lalith Perera, a preacher of ENNEAGRAM seminars and retreats who lives in Colombo, Sri Lanka, ministered at POWER 2006, the first International Youth Conference at the Divine Retreat Centre, Muringoor, Kerala, India from 30 July to 4 August, 2006, despite the Director of the Centre, Rev. Fr. Augustine Vallooran V.C. being informed in advance of Pereras involvement in the practice of this New Age tool. International renowned Catholic preachers from India and overseas also ministered there. The email invitation from Divine Youth, the Centres youth ministry read, and Lalith Perera from Sri Lanka will be our resource persons from outside the country. Youth around the globe have saved up on their vacation and leave to be clothed with the Holy Spirit (Luke 24: 49). Teams from Europe and America, Australia and the Gulf have already confirmed their coming. Three hundred participants from Sri Lanka have already chartered a flight. Since Fr. Augustine is a member of the National Service Team [NST] of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal [CCR], the Chairman of the NST, Mr. Cyril John, was also duly informed. Despite this, Perera was permitted to minister at this important charismatic event. The Centres Director was satisfied that Perera brought 400 Sri Lankans with him to attend the Youth Conference. Thirty pieces of silver? The Centre was not the only one to sell out. The information was circulated to many people who are closely associated with the Centre or have a special place for it in their hearts. These persons, who would normally respond to other reports, tactfully avoided an acknowledgement of this one, because this ministry has touched yet another sacred cow!

MY CORRESPONDENCE WITH CYRIL JOHN, CHAIRMAN, NATIONAL SERVICE TEAM, CCR:


From: prabhu To: cyriljohn@vsnl.net; nco Sent: Monday, July 10, 2006 4:06 AM Subject: POWER RETREAT 2006 Dear Bro. Cyril John, I have been furnished with printed evidence that shows that one of the leading preachers slated to speak at the forthcoming programme to be hosted by Divine Retreat Centre is also a preacher of ENNEAGRAM retreats which cover from 3 to 5 days. My article on ENNEAGRAMS is attached herewith for your perusal. The CATHOLIC evidence that ENNEAGRAM is occult and NEW AGE is overwhelming. I have written to the concerned preacher, and submitted to him my write-up, but with no response. I am trying to contact him again, but have been unsuccessful so far. May I have your personal telephone number so that I can talk to you, in case you do not want me to use his name by email? Alternatively, I can give you his name on hearing from you in reply. At your service in Jesus' Name, Michael BELOW, AN EXTRACT FROM MY WRITE-UP: THE VATICAN SPEAKS ON THE ENNEAGRAM IN THE DOCUMENT "JESUS CHRIST THE BEARER OF THE WATER OF LIFE- A CHRISTIAN REFLECTION ON THE 'NEW AGE' "

According to the Document, Enneagram [from the Greek ennea= nine + gramma= sign] refers to a diagram composed of a circle with nine points on its circumference, connected within the circle by a triangle and a hexangle. It was originally used for divination, but has become known as the symbol for a system of personality typology consisting of nine standard character types. It became popular after the publication of Helen Palmers [1989] book The Enneagram, but she recognizes her indebtedness to the Russian esoteric thinker and practitioner G. I. Gurdjieff, the Chilean psychologist Claudio Naranjo and author Oscar Ichazo, founder of Arica. The origin of the enneagram remains shrouded in mystery, but some maintain that it comes from Sufi mysticism [Glossary]. Under the caption The New Age and the Catholic Faith, the Document explains: On the one hand, new forms of psychological affirmation have become very popular among Catholics, even in retreat-houses, seminaries, and institutes of formation for religious. At the same time, there is increasing nostalgia and curiosity for the wisdom and ritual of long ago, which is one of the reasons for the remarkable growth in the popularity of esotericism and gnosticism

John Paul II [in Crossing the Threshold of Hope] warns with regard to the return of ancient gnostic ideas under the guise of the so-called New Age. We cannot delude ourselves that this will lead to a renewal of religion. It is only a new way of practising gnosticism- that attitude of the spirit that, in the name of a profound knowledge of God, results in distorting His Word and replacing it with purely human words in distinct, if not declared conflict with all that is essentially Christian. An example of this can be seen in the enneagram, the nine-type tool for character analysis, which when used as a means of spiritual growth produces an ambiguity in the doctrine and the life of the Christian faith [n 1.4]. The Document could hardly be more explicit than that. The enneagram is New Age, has its roots in esotericism and pagan mysticism, is a modern form of gnosticism and its use as a spiritual tool is, as we shall see, a distortion of the Word of God which is the basis of all Christian faith and living. The Vatican Document provides a list of major New Age influencers that includes founder Ichazo, and, naming it as a key New Age place has this to say about Esalen which played a major role in establishing the popularity of the enneagram: A community founded in Big Sur, California in 1962 by Michael Murphy and Richard Price, whose main aim was to arrive at a self-realization of being through nudism and visions... It has become one of the most important centres of the Human Potential Movement, and has spread ideas about holistic medicine... This has been done through courses in comparative religion, mythology, mysticism, meditation, psychotherapy, expansion of consciousness and so on. Along with Findhorn, it is seen as a key place in the growth of Aquarian (New Age) consciousness." [n 7.3]. REMINDER ON 15 JULY 2006: From: prabhu To: cyriljohn@vsnl.net ; nco Sent: Saturday, July 15, 2006 9:19 AM Subject: Fw: POWER RETREAT 2006 From: cyriljohn@vsnl.net To: prabhu Sent: Saturday, July 15, 2006 11:52 AM Subject: Re: Fw: POWER RETREAT 2006 Dear Michael, Thanks for the mail. I have forwarded your mail to Fr Augustine Vallooran so that he could look into the matter. With loving regards and prayers, Cyril John

MY RESPONSE TO CYRIL JOHN, 16 JULY 2006:


Dear Brother Cyril, Thank you. I had sent similar letters to Father as the host of the programme and venue, and to you as Chairman of the CCR. Father has written. Here is the correspondence. Michael

MY CORRESPONDENCE WITH FR. AUGUSTINE VALLOORAN, VC., DIRECTOR, DIVINE RETREAT CENTRE:

From: prabhu To: Divine Retreat Centre Sent: Monday, July 10, 2006 4:01 AM Subject: POWER RETREAT 2006 Dear Fr. Augustine, I have been furnished with printed evidence that shows that one of the leading preachers slated to speak at the forthcoming programme to be hosted by Divine Retreat Centre is also a preacher of ENNEAGRAM retreats which cover from 3 to 5 days. My article on ENNEAGRAMS is attached herewith for your perusal. The CATHOLIC evidence that ENNEAGRAM is occult and NEW AGE is overwhelming. I have written to the concerned preacher, and submitted to him my write-up, but with no response. I am trying to contact him again, but have been unsuccessful so far. May I have your personal telephone number so that I can talk to you, in case you do not want me to use his name by email? Alternatively, I can give you his name on hearing from you in reply. At your service in Jesus' Name, Michael

BELOW- AN EXTRACT FROM MY WRITE-UP: .etc. as above From: prabhu To: Divine Retreat Centre Sent: Tuesday, July 11, 2006 8:46 AM Subject: Fw: POWER RETREAT 2006 From: "Divine Retreat Centre" <augustine@sancharnet.in> To: "prabhu" <michaelprabhu@vsnl.net> Sent: Friday, July 14, 2006 10:09 AM Subject: Re: POWER RETREAT 2006 Dear Prabhu, Greetings from the Divine Retreat Centre! Thank you for the mail and all the information provided. Please do let me know which one of the preachers slated to preach here for POWER 2006 is a preacher of Enneagram retreats. You may revert back on this email ID to disclose the information with whatever evidence you have. Yours in Jesus, Fr Augustine Vallooran VC From: "prabhu" <michaelprabhu@vsnl.net> To: "Divine Retreat Centre" <augustine@sancharnet.in> Sent: Saturday, July 15, 2006 10:34 AM Subject: REPLY REGARDING ENNEAGRAMS / POWER RETREAT 2006 Dear Fr. Augustine, I thank you for your kind reply, for your confidence in me, and your openness to my ministry to expose New Age errors. The preacher concerned is BRO. LALITH PERERA of 73/15 Saranakara Road, Wellawatte, Colombo, Sri Lanka whom you know well and who has hosted you on your visit there. I have in my hardcopy files the printed information [10 photocopied pages] distributed by him during his "A RETREAT ON THE ENNEAGRAM" held on 1 - 5 MAY, 2004 at 'TABOR', #7, 4th floor, Lucky Plaza, Colombo3, Tel. Nos. 2577768, 2503510, 2716489, by the "COMMUNITY OF THE RISEN LORD, MEMBER OF THE LIFE IN THE SPIRIT COMMUNITIES OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH". It was attended by Bro. Antony Mahendran, a part-time Catholic lay preacher from Cochin, who is now in Seoul, Korea. Antony Mahendran's email address is antony_avemaria@yahoo.co.in. It was also confirmed to me by other Sri Lankans like Rev. Sr. Cinthia A.C., etc. who keep in touch with me.

They inform me that Bro. Lalith is known for his "innovations", and they have spoken to him about Enneagrams etc. but he ignores their concerns. On 25.11.2005, I wrote to Bro. Lalith explaining to him the New Age errors of Enneagrams, and including a hardcopy of my write-up on The Enneagram. I suggested to him that he may be unaware of the occult/esoteric background of the enneagram personality typing, suggested he read the Vatican Provisional Report on the New Age [of February 3, 2003] and requested him to discontinue giving such retreats. Regrettably, Bro. Lalith neither responded nor terminated his Enneagram programmes. Bro. Perera's last major retreat for people in the Sri Lankan Charismatic Renewal was attended by 2,000 people according to Duthika Perera, Lalith Perera's son whom I spoke to on the telephone [00 94 11 2716489]. According to Duthika Perera, Bro. Lalith has given Enneagram seminars for several NGOs in Sri Lanka, like LAWYERS FOR HUMAN RIGHTS, etc., the latest being one for an NGO named SAVE THE CHILDREN, as recently as a week ago. You will agree with me that it is a matter of great regret that the leading Sri Lankan charismatic preacher, who is bringing a large group of people for the programme at your Divine Retreat Centre at the end of this month, is not only not giving his full contribution to Catholic ministry, but has also exposed thousands of people already to a practice that has been condemned in a Vatican Document. Preaching at Divine Retreat Centre will only strengthen his credibility and increase his influence. Dear Father Augustine, you will appreciate that as my ministry serves, among other things, to warn Catholics of those who promote New Age in the Church and in the Renewal, I will be obliged to include the latest information on Bro. Lalith Perera in my update of August 2006. Kindly acknowledge receipt of this letter from me. Yours in Jesus' Name, Michael From: "Divine Retreat Centre" <augustine@sancharnet.in> To: <michaelprabhu@vsnl.net> Sent: Wednesday, July 19, 2006 12:51 PM Subject: Re: Lalith Perera Dear Prabhu, Greetings from the Divine Retreat Centre! Thank you for your mail. This is to clarify that Lalith Perera is coming here not to preach or talk on Enneagrams but will be leading Praise and Worship with his team during POWER 2006. I have received the copy of the mail you sent Cyril John stating that Lalith is a leading preacher slated to speak at POWER 2006. I do not know who gave you this information. To my knowledge he is not a leading preacher. Please check with me before you send out any wrong information about us. Yours in Jesus, Fr Augustine Vallooran VC From: prabhu To: Divine Retreat Centre Sent: Friday, July 21, 2006 1:16 AM Subject: Lalith Perera Bcc to Cyril John Dear Fr. Augustine, I thank you for your reply. I stand corrected by you that Bro. Lalith Perera is not going to preach at POWER 2006, but to lead Praise and Worship. The source of my information was people from Sri Lanka as well as the Divine Youth message reproduced [in part] below*.

Still, Praise and Worship is an important ministry that calls for the same anointing as preaching. It has never crossed my mind that Bro. Lalith was going to preach on Enneagrams at Divine Retreat Centre. Bro. Lalith is not only involved in propagating an acknowledged occult personality typing tool through Enneagram retreats, but he is either unaware of or has ignored the contents of the Vatican Provisional Report on the New Age. I also greatly suspect the nature of the various psychological counseling courses that Bro. Lalith attended at Manila and other places. Today, one of my friends, a Redemptorist charismatic priest, has flown to Colombo with a personal letter from me to Bro. Lalith. I look forward to a response from Bro. Lalith that he has abjured the conducting of Enneagram retreats and will communicate the contents of the Holy See's Document to those whom he has exposed to Enneagrams/New Age. With love and prayers, Michael Prabhu *Greetings of joy from the Divine Youth! Preparations are in full swing as we approach POWER 2006, our first International Youth Conference at the Divine Retreat Center (30 July to 4 August). The entire English section campus is being totally geared to host the POWER 2006 participants... International renowned Catholic preachers and music ministers have confirmed their participation. The retreat will be led by Fr Augustine Vallooran and Fr Mathew Naikomparambil. The team will include our Divine preachers and singers. Fritz, Colin and Vinay from ICPE & the Rex Band will also be here. Stefan Attard from Germany, Sal Solo from USA, John White from Canada, and Lalith Perera from Sri Lanka will be our resource persons from outside the country. Youth around the globe have saved up on their vacation and leave to be clothed with the Holy Spirit (Luke 24: 49). Teams from Europe and America, Australia and the Gulf have already confirmed their coming. Three hundred participants from Sri Lanka have already chartered a flight. Truly we know it is going to be the MIGHTY PENTECOST OF OUR AGE... Yours in Christ, DIVINE YOUTH

NO FURTHER RESPONSE FROM THE DIRECTOR OF DIVINE RETREAT CENTRE

CORRESPONDENCE OF MR. ANTONY MAHENDRAN WITH FR. AUGUSTINE VALLOORAN, VC.:


From: prabhu To: cyriljohn@vsnl.net Sent: Friday, July 21, 2006 1:14 AM Subject: Fw: Fr. Augustine -- Thanks For your reply Dear Cyril, It is after 1:00 am. For your information. I just received this. As you can see, it is quite independent of my letter[s] to Father Augustine. Love, Michael From: antony mahendran To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Sent: Thursday, July 20, 2006 9:51 PM Subject: Fwd: Very Important: Dear Fr. Augustine

From: antony mahendran <antony_avemaria@yahoo.co.in> To: augustine@sancharnet.in Sent: Tue, 18 Jul 2006 17:55:47 +0100 (BST) Subject: Very Important: Dear Fr. Augustine Dear Fr. Augustine Greetings to you in the name of Our Lord Jesus Christ. I am really thankful to the Almighty for guiding you to unite the Youths all around the globe under the divine roof to mould them and set them on fire. But in the meantime I am also very sad to know that Bro. Lalith Pereira of COMMUNITY OF THE RISEN LORD from Srilanka is been invited to the Retreat to preach. Bro. Lalith Pereira is an Enneagram retreat preacher and i myself had attended the enneagram retreat conducted by his team at the Peters College chapel, Bamplapitiya, Colombo during 1-5 May 2004. Many of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal Leaders and laities in Srilanka are aware of him conducting the enneagram retreats which is condemned by the encyclicals of Pope John Paul II. (I am sure that yourself might be aware of this). Do investigate on this regard thoroughly and please do discern with care, allowing New Age supporters to preach in a Spirit Filled retreat does not sound nice and is also a serious Sin against the Holy Spirit. With Fraternal Love Antony Mahendran From: antony mahendran To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Sent: Thursday, July 20, 2006 9:52 PM Subject: Re: Lalith Perera Dear Bro. Michael this is the reply i have received from Fr. Augustine. I have not replied yet. Divine Retreat Centre <augustine@sancharnet.in> wrote: Dear Mr Antony Mahendran, Greetings from the Divine Retreat Centre! I have gone through your mail. This is to clarify that Lalith Perera is coming here not to preach or talk on Enneagrams but will be leading Praise and Worship with his team during POWER 2006. Yours in Jesus, Fr Augustine Vallooran VC From: antony mahendran To: Divine Retreat ; divine retreat ; MICHEL PRABHU ; stanisdevot@yahoo.co.in ; tri_sea2000@yahoo.co.in Sent: Thursday, July 20, 2006 10:20 PM Subject: IMPORTANT: Lalith Perera and Enneagram Six Seconds' EQ Network: Certified Associates EQ Experts > Certified Associates > Lalith Perera

A complete range of development with a broad range of training experience and qualifications in education, training, EQ, and enneagram. Specialties: Personality Development and Transformation. Building up of Executives through Transformational Learning Methods that ultimately Transform their Organisations and optimise performance. Executive Coaching / Conflict Resolution / Groundwork for Effecting changes in Organisations Services Available: Seminars on Emotional Intelligence -- 1, 2 & 3 day Programmes (Based on the 6 Seconds model) Adaptation of the 7 Habits of Highly Effective People -- 2 day Programme The Enneagram -- A Programme of Self Discovery and Life Transformation in use for almost 2000 years -adapted to todays corporate and personal environment. (See enneagram.com for more details) -- 2 Day Programme First Things First -- A Principle Centred Time Management Programme First Discover what is really important in life -- then put it first -- 1 Day Role Negotiation -- Facilitating a dialogue between various members of staff to enable each one to realise what one must do and must not do to enable the other to work better. Subsequently, to help those engaged in the process to come to agreements on what to change and adjust to work together more effectively. Mentoring / Executive Development: Enabling Executives to consolidate their strengths and build up weak areas. Types of Clients: Corporate Clients Banks / Sri Lankan Airlines / World Bank Funded Projects of UNDP / Schools / Overview: Company Name: Omega Point Services / Web Site / Based In: Colombo Sri Lanka / Available In: Asia, Sri Lanka, SE Asia, Mid East Biography: Consultant in Human Resource Development (Training) with Sri Lankan Airlines (The National Airline of Sri Lanka) / Trellerborg Lanka (Subsidiary of Trellerborg International -- Sweden) / McLarens GROUP of Companies ( Sri Lankan agents for Mobil Oil, GAC Shipping, GE USA -- Heavy Equipment ) Qualified in the Inductive Method of enabling and facilitating learning in adults East Asian Pastoral Institute -Manila Philippines, 1983 Certified as a Teacher Trainer in the method of Inductive Study E. A. P. I. Atheneo University, Manila Philippines, 1985 Certified in Public Speaking and Course Material designing -- E. A. P. I. Atheneo University, Manila Philippines, 1987 Diploma in Psychological Counselling -- FROM the Family Services Institute, 1986 Trained in the Lumko method of facilitating adult learning, using small GROUP techniques and Team building principles -- E. A. P. I. Atheneo University Manila Philippines, 1992 Trained in Psychological Counselling methods* I function as a facilitator for conflict resolution and a resource person for human development. Certification in Emotional Intelligence FROM the 6 Seconds Institute of the USA, 2002. Source: http://www.6seconds.org/cert/show.php?ID=36 *see my articles on New Age psychology and Counseling techniques- Michael

Insight is a training institute with a difference. It is the brainchild of a few individuals who were inspired by a vision of a new era in learning. A method of training that would bring about a transformation and a change in the participants. The kernel of this concept had already borne fruit in the E.A.B.T. (Eco Adventure Based Training) programs of the Wild Holidays. It has revolutionized training by akin it out of the classroom and into the 'wilderness' to enable participants to discover nature, wildlife, the harmony of the environment and in and through it a harmony with ones won self and with others. Wild Holidays dreamed of extending his 'experiential training' from the wilderness into the classroom and boardrooms of the corporate world, hence the birth of 'Insight.' Insight deals with the development and transformation of people, who ultimately decide the success or failure of any organization. It conducts programs and courses that enable people to change and sustain the positive changes that take place in their lives. It deals with intrinsic motivation by which people become committed and dedicated because they see it as a part of Principle centered Right Living. This results in a lasting sense of Self Worth and an inner joy that makes them feel good about themselves as they do the right things even when no one is looking. Insight also deals with programs that develop Emotional Intelligence. Participants are led to self-awareness i.e. to realize what they are doing and how they are relating to others and to their jobs. They realize perhaps even for the first time about their unconscious thought and actions that have brought them and others so much pain and problems and how it has made them unproductive. Insight then goes onto help participants to take charge of and use emotions in a productive and positive manner that enhances not only the person but his or her contribution to ones work and organization.

We would like to be partners with you on this 'adventure of discovery' that extends from the wilderness into your classroom and the boardroom. 1. The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People A Program that will change your life Created by Stephen R. Corvey and taught to most managers and university graduates all over the world. Proven to change lives from within with a revolutionary 'inside out' approach. An introduction to a character based, 'right living' way of life that guarantees peace of mind and effective results - long term. Seminar/workshop conducted by Lalith Perera, with over 10 years experience with the material. A facilitator trained in the methods of enabling others to change from within and to attain transformational living. Seminars conducted over 2-3 days

2. The Enneagram - A Journey into Self Discovery

Discover the mystery of your inner being by a 2000 year old system. A program that helps you to discover the way your subconscious thinks and what it really wants. A program that gives you the knowledge to not only understand what is happening inside you but gives you the tools to harness it's power to live in a powerfully effective manner. With its origins shrouded in the mist of the past, some trace it back to the time of the Ancient Egyptian Dynasties over 2000 years ago. Known and used by Sufi Masters to attain inner perfection in their mystical life, it has finally filtered down to the western world in the last 75 years Now it is being used all over the world and extensively in the United States to help people towards self realization and how to work effectively with other people by discovering how their inner being operates Over the last 10 years the Enneagram has been adopted to work and the modern business environment It enables people to see how they could work effectively with others and how customers and clients could be dealt with at a deeper manner by recognizing and meeting their unconscious and unarticulated expectations

Conducted by Lalith Perera with over 15 years experience in teaching the Enneagram to varied groups and audiences including airlines & theological institutes. Seminar

conducted over 2-3 days 3. Motivation through Character A program that motivates people to do the right things for the right reasons. Speaks of the 'character ethic' that was the base of all stable civilizations over the past 2000 years. It leads participants to realize that there is no long term happiness or real success with adhering to the principles of 'right living'. It presents a simple technique on how to find happiness and be more effective by using activities that build trust in both the work and the home environment. Finally participants are taught the 'Empathic' method of listening. A technique of scientific listening that enables the listener to enter the very heart of the speaker and effect change. It teaches how to discuss difficult and volatile issues without reacting or fighting In fact it shows how different opinions can actually enrich us rather than threaten or destroy. This program is conducted in both Sinhala & English, with varied audiences ranging from senior executives to regular office personnel with powerful results. Conducted by Lalith Perera. Duration - 1 day 4. Role Negotiations People who work together become less effective when personalities and opinions clash. In fact they tend to resist each other rather than cooperate. Role negotiations introduces the participants to the merits and techniques of working together Participants are then led to share what changes they think should happen in the other for them to work more effectively Then the consultant facilitates negotiation of their work roles, until both parties come to an agreement on what changes they would effect in their own work to enable the other to work better. Many such workshops have been carried out with very positive results. Individual support and mentoring can also be provided in complex and complicated situations Conducted by Lalith Perera. Introductory session - 1 day Actual 'role negotiation' time depends on the complexities of the situations

5. Individual Mentoring & Support Modern managers are given comprehensive knowledge on how to manage business institutions. Few are given the skills and knowledge to manage themselves and their inner lives for full productivity. Individual support to discover oneself and how to deal with one's weaknesses and drives can be provided This service is already being provided to executives of reputed companies with very effective results. Source: http://www.wildernesslanka.com/insight/insight.htm From: antony mahendran To: Divine Retreat ; divine retreat Sent: Thursday, July 20, 2006 11:20 PM [Bcc to this writer] Subject: Fr. Augustine -- Thanks For your reply

[PHOTOGRAPH] In Picture: Lalith Perera presenting Talk on Enneagram


Dear Fr. Augustine

Thanks for your reply and it is very sad to know that you are allowing an Enneagram preacher Mr. Lalith Perera to lead the Praise and Worship sessions in POWER 2006 International Youth Retreat even after aware that he is a New Age promoter. Is there any scarcity for Praise and Worship Leaders in India or rest of the globe? Please do not compromise and justify the faults. Please do listen to His Voice and act accordingly. Here below I have attached some texts about Mr. Lalith Perera to let you know that he is a well known Enneagram preacher in Asia and worldwide. Allowing him to conduct Praise and worship in a Catholic Retreat Campus even after aware of his New Age activities gives an impression as if your are indirectly appreciating him and his work. With Fraternal Love and Prayers, In Christ with Mary, Antony Mahendran From: antony mahendran To: prabhu Sent: Friday, July 21, 2006 9:29 PM Subject: Re: Lalith Perera Dear Bro. Michael Fr. Augustine seems to be going out of the track (by writing to you): I have received the copy of the mail you sent Cyril John stating that Lalith is a leading preacher slated to speak at POWER 2006. I do not know who gave you this information. He is compromising and justifying a lot. Antony From: antony mahendran To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Sent: Tuesday, July 25, 2006 8:11 PM Subject: Fwd: RE: EQ Inquiry from 6seconds.org Dear Bro. Michael I wrote to Bro. Lalith Perera (through the email column given in the 6seconds.org website which I had forwarded to you earlier) inviting him to present a talk on enneagram for Spice Jet airlines staff and he has responded to my query. This is his email id: focus@eureka.lk. With Regards Antony Mahendran From: antony mahendran To: focus@eureka.lk Sent: 20/07/06 22:30 Subject: EQ Inquiry from 6seconds.org Dear Mr. Lalith I have attended your retreats on enneagram in Colombo. I would like to invite you personally to Present a Talk on Enneagram for Spice Jet Airlines, India Staff. Awaiting for your reply. With Regards Antony Mahendran

From: Lalith Perera <focus@eureka.lk> To: Antony Mahendran <antony_avemaria@yahoo.co.in> Sent: Tue, 25 Jul 2006 16:44:49 +0530 Subject: RE: EQ Inquiry from 6seconds.org Dear Anthony, I would be delighted. Pl. Send me more details. Lalith

LETTER TO LALITH PERERA, COPY TO FR. AUGUSTINE VALLOORAN, VC., AND CYRIL JOHN:
From: prabhu To: focus@eureka.lk Cc: Divine Retreat Centre ; cyriljohn@vsnl.net ; nco Sent: Wednesday, July 26, 2006 3:48 PM Subject: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Bro. Lalith Perera, My name is Michael Prabhu. I am a full-time lay evangelist from Chennai, India. I am sending you this email because I have, only today, been able to source your email address. You are already in receipt of two letters from me, one dated 25.11.2005, and the other dated 21.07.2006. In each of my letters I apprised you about the New Age nature of Enneagrams, and I enclosed a hardcopy of my write-up on Enneagrams, since you are a leading charismatic preacher who is also conducting Enneagram Retreats in Sri Lanka which have been attended by many hundreds of Catholic charismatics. On the 15th of this month, I spoke to Duthika, your son, [since you were not at home] over the telephone, and he confirmed to me about several of your Enneagram retreats. Regrettably, you have not responded to both my letters. This ministry has been informed that you are to lead the Praise and Worship at Divine Retreat Centre at Power 2006 later this week. It is a matter of great regret that you have not abjured the practice and propagation of Enneagrams before you minister at the Divine Retreat Centre. I will be very happy to hear from you, by return, about your final position with regard to Enneagrams before I will be obliged to convey this information to other Catholic preachers and National Service Team members, as well as post this correspondence on my website, the details of which you have in my letters as also in the articles that I have sent to you. Yours in Jesus' Name, Michael Copies to: Rev. Fr. Augustine Vallooran V.C. Director-Divine Retreat Centre, Member-National Service Team, CCR; Mr. Cyril John, Chairman, National Service Team of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal

THE ISSUE IS FINALLY PUBLICISED BY EMAIL LETTERS FROM THIS MINISTRY AFTER NO REASSURANCE WAS RECEIVED FROM THE AUTHORITIES CONCERNED:
From: prabhu To: Michael Prabhu Cc: focus@eureka.lk Bcc: XXXXXXXXXX Sent: Thursday, July 27, 2006 6:42 PM Subject: ENNEAGRAMS

Dear friends, With great regret I am obliged to bring to your notice the following: The Vatican's Provisional Report [3rd February 2003] on the New Age explicitly warns Catholics about a device called the Enneagram. Lalith Perera is a leading charismatic preacher from Colombo, Sri Lanka, who also preaches regular 'Enneagram retreats'. Several hundred Sri Lankan charismatics, among others, have attended such 'retreats' preached by him. I have documentary [printed] evidence of the same, as well as information downloaded from the internet. His son Duthika has confirmed to me all of the above when I called Colombo a few days ago to talk to Bro. Lalith. I have written to Bro. Lalith thrice during the last eight months, sending him my report on Enneagrams, and seeking a response from him, which I have not received till today. Just a couple of days ago, Lalith has accepted an invitation to give another such programme, and I have a copy of the concerned correspondence. Having received information that Bro. Lalith is to minister during POWER 2006, leading Praise and Worship at Divine Retreat Centre this weekend, I have also shared my findings with the highest authority at Divine Retreat Centre as well as in the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. My letters to them have also included information on Enneagrams. However, the responses that I received have not been encouraging. This shows not only the extent to which New Age has infiltrated into the Renewal, but also the compromise that accompanies it. Please visit this ministry's website [www.ephesians511.net http://ephesians511.net] for information on Enneagrams. Complete details of the subject of this email will be uploaded after mid-August. The updating from August 2006 will include exposes of other Church and Renewal leaders who are involved in the practice and propagation of New Age practices, alternative therapies and eastern meditation systems, or who have not been cautioned even after this ministry has brought the issues to the notice of the concerned authorities. As a matter of fact, such communications from this ministry usually do not even elicit a response. NOT TO OPPOSE ERROR IS TO APPROVE IT, AND NOT TO DEFEND TRUTH IS TO SUPPRESS IT. AND INDEED TO NEGLECT TO CONFOUND EVIL ... WHEN WE CAN DO IT IS NO LESS A SIN THAN TO ENCOURAGE THEM- POPE ST. FELIX III Michael Prabhu COPY TO: BRO. LALITH PERERA

FINALLY, A RESPONSE FROM LALITH PERERA:


From: Lalith Perera To: 'prabhu' Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 7:05 AM Subject: RE: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Bro. Prabhu, Greetings in the name of the Lord. I have no time to respond in detail as I will out in the next two weeks. But will respond when I get back. I have not done the Enneagram Retreat since the last time you wrote to me. That was sometime last year. But I will explain in detail in about two weeks time about what we are doing here in Sri Lanka and speak to you later. Yours in Christ Lalith Perera From: prabhu To: focus@eureka.lk Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 10:43 AM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Bcc: augustine@sancharnet.in; cyriljohn@vsnl.net ; nco ; and others Dear Bro. Lalith, I thank you for your response, which I received just a short while ago. I look forward to your contacting me, as per your assurance, after your return from India two weeks hence. But I would meanwhile like to point out to you the following: 1. After waiting till last night to hear from you, I sent several hundred mails to leaders in the Renewal across India and globally. A copy of the letter[s] was marked to you. However, your letter to me [below] is in response to my email of the previous day. Before making this response to you, I have once again checked my mail, but I find that you have not replied to the letter in question. Had I heard from you earlier, I could have avoided writing to all those who are connected with this ministry. 2. When I spoke to your son Duthika on the telephone two weeks ago, enquiring about your Enneagram retreats, he informed me about programmes that you had conducted in the weeks just previously, and I have noted their details. Moreover, information on your ministry that I sourced from the internet confirms that you continue to give Enneagram retreats. 3. I am relieved to read your assurance that you discontinued giving Enneagram retreats since the 'last time' that I wrote to you; and that it was 'sometime last year'. I had written to you the first time in November 2005 year. If you had responded to my letter at that time, or even to my next letter, I would not have had to write to you again, or bring the matter to the attention of the Renewal and Divine Retreat Centre leadership. 4. In response to my letter[s] [of last night] circulated to leaders in the Renewal, I have already received a few dozen emails, including from a few priests and several leaders in ministry [from overseas too], greatly regretting that you are going to minister at Divine Retreat Centre without abjuring the propagation of Enneagrams. I am marking a copy of this letter to all of them.

5. I would like you to know that I have nothing personal against you, or the Charismatic Renewal, or the Divine Retreat Centre. As a founder-member of the Delhi Service Team [1982], I have also spent more than 18 weeks in many visits to Divine Retreat Centre from 1995 -2000, and both the Renewal and the Potta ministries are very dear to my heart. This ministry to expose New Age error is absolutely impartial. I do not seek to win friends by silence or compromise when I find that error is being either propagated or tolerated by leaders in the Church and in the Charismatic Renewal. I can assure you that I am having to pay a heavy price for choosing to speak out, even though I always write in love, humility and brotherhood to those who often ignorantly and innocently are involved [either directly or by association] in New Age, and those in immediate authority in/over the situations. It is only when my communications are ignored, or met with rejection, and sometimes even hostility, that this ministry is obliged to make the issues public, which is what has most regrettably happened in this case. [A couple of youth were prepared to reach pamphlets against Enneagrams to the delegates at Power 2006 but your letter has made that unnecessary.] 6. In respect of your statement that you have discontinued giving Enneagram retreats, please read the following correspondence, which precedes your letter of today to me by just three days, between yourself and Mr. Antony Mahendran of Seoul, Korea, wherein you have expressed your 'delight' in being invited to give a talk on Enneagrams: [see above] NO RESPONSE WAS RECEIVED

SELECTED RESPONSES FROM PRIESTS:

From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Thursday, July 27, 2006 9:45 PM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Michael, This is quite sad but we cannot do anything about it. The Sri Lankans Charismatics do not come under the National Charismatic movement of India. About Potta also nothing can be done because the Vincentians are independent. Let us pray such things may not happen again. With best wishes, Father XXXXX From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 2:53 AM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Michael, I pray that Divine may not allow him to do some mission there. I am [overseas] now for one month. I will be back to India on . Father XXXXX From: XXXXX To: <michaelprabhu@vsnl.net> Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 1:02 PM Subject: RE: ENNEAGRAMS My Dear Michael, First of all, let me commend your commitment to the cause of exposing falsehood of the so called new age - It could be better called the "New age of Satan" Between you and me, you may be surprised to know that in St Pius {the Mumbai Seminary} The new seminarians are first made to go through the exercise of finding out their enneagrams. As a result, you can expect a lot of Mumbai priests to be hooked on to the enneagram. If you have the specific papal document, it will be good to send a copy to the Bombay bishop with copy to the rector St Pius college, Station Road, Goregaon East Mumbai 400 063 I am very busy in this parish of over 5000 poorer people. Hoping and praying that all is well with you and the family Bye and God Bless Father XXXXX From: XXXXX To: <michaelprabhu@vsnl.net> Sent: Saturday, July 29, 2006 12:34 PM Subject: RE: Fw: ENNEAGRAMS My Dear Michael, Though I am very busy as it is the weekend, I felt that I should send you an article that i got from the internet under the ID "enneagrams a catholic view" I am sending the same to you and u can also follow the link given in it. Bye, With Blessings and Prayers Father XXXXX From: XXXXX To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Sent: Thursday, August 31, 2006 5:47 AM Subject: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Michael, As regards Enneagrams, I personally know that it is widely practised by Catholic RELIGIOUS in the North. At least one (Jesuit) priest that I know uses Enneagrams as part of the Retreats he gives to the lady religious. You have written that the Vatican's Provisional Report warns us Catholics in this regard. As I had written about 'New Age,' and Pranic Healing: WHY DOES THE CATHOLIC CHURCH NOT DECLARE THESE THINGS FROM THE PULPITS, AND REPEATEDLY? Our good Sisters, I mean the Nuns, suffer a lot by these things. As most of their Input comes from Priests, when they do not hear anything to the contrary from the Pulpit in the form of Encyclicals,

they and the laity just accept what the priests teach them during courses, seminars and retreats. In union of prayers Father XXXXX

SELECTED RESPONSES FROM LAY PERSONS INCLUDING LEADERS IN CHARISMATIC MINISTRY:


From: XXXXX To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Sent: Tuesday, August 01, 2006 9:58 AM Subject: RE: ENNEAGRAMS Hello Micheal, Saddened to hear about the problems in the church and now even in the renewal. I guess with every passing day we are looking to please people more than God. But then the gospel needs to come true as this is something which Jesus himself spoke of, i.e corruption and problems in the last days. God bless you for what you do and may his love and grace always be with you. God bless n love [Prayer-group leader, AUSTRALIA] From: allanpanozza* To: prabhu Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 6:29 AM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS *ICCRS President Dear Michael, Many thanks for your information about the Enneagram. I have found that one of the best books dealing with this subject is "A closer look at the Enneagram", written some years ago by Dorothy Ranaghan. It has helped me to discuss and explain the truth about this subject many times. Kevin Ranaghan was Deputy President of ICCRS during my early years on the Council. Blessings, ALLAN [AUSTRALIA] From: XXXXX To: YYYYY Cc: prabhu Sent: Thursday, July 27, 2006 9:58 PM Subject: FW: ENNEAGRAMS Dear all, Read this article and also go through the site mentioned... a rich resource of information on all new age practices - catholic teachings against it. I think, we, as leaders should educate ourselves on this. Hope you will forward this to all. [Jesus Youth leader, Delhi] From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Thursday, July 27, 2006 10:12 PM Subject: RE: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Mr. Michael, Thanks a lot for the mail...your website is really a rich source of information for all leaders. I have forwarded this to many... hope all will read it. May God bless you and your ministry abundantly. [Jesus Youth] From: XXXXX To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Sent: Sunday, July 30, 2006 7:18 PM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Micheal, I appreciate your concern for the renewal. I shall see what can be done about it after verifying the facts. Thanks XXXXX [Senior charismatic renewal leader] From: XXXXX To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Sent: Sunday, July 30, 2006 5:12 PM Subject: RE: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Br. Michael Prabhu, Thanks for your email and the ministry that you are doing with diligence it is not a popular one but stick on with it. You will get rewarded by the Lord Himself on that Day (sorry that there may be very few rewards on earth here at best, it may be such emails from well wishers like me!!) I have had some recent experiences with new age medicine and have not had very good experiences specially with homeopathy and acupuncture-related magnet therapy treatment I will write a detailed email or letter on this personal experience of mine (from my personal email id) and maybe it will be used of the Lord to open the eyes of many good brothers who are subtly being deceived (by the way, today there is high-level deception happening and it is the pride of man not to submit to the authoritative teaching authority in the Church magisterium - which alone is qualified enough to see to some of these deep subtleties and bring them to light) that is principally causing this to happen. [BANGALORE] From: dawsongomes To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 10:23 AM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Mike, Praise Jesus... I too will be writing to Divine Retreat Center with a copy of Fr Mitch Pacwas article on Enneagram. God Bless Dawson Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 3:42 PM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Mike, Praise Jesus Send me e-mail addresses of Fr Augustine Vallooran. God Bless Dawson Sent: Friday, August 04, 2006 11:48 AM Subject: Letter sent to Cyril John Dear Mike this is the letter sent to Cyril John and a similar type sent to Fr Augustine. God Bless Dawson Dear Cyril, Praise Jesus, Glory to the Lord for His mighty work in your midst. I am enclosing an article by Fr Mitch Pacwa, a former new age practitioner, who now is very much part of EWTN. He has written books on New Age and it dangers. I read his testimony, in the New Covenant many years back, of how the Holy Spirit was being blocked when he came into the renewal. He cited that it was his earlier practice of yoga and how he had to renounce it and only when he did that he was set free and the

power of the Holy Spirit was able to flow freely. I am sure you know Fr Mitch Pacwa. I am enclosing an article on Enneagram where he speaks strongly against it I pray that you could use it in the Charisindia magazine and also make people aware of it. Many people who call themselves renewed know nothing about it and even leaders are ignorant about its consequences, some even practice it. The Lord says for lack of knowledge my people perish as you know that what's the Lord says in the Book of Hosea, even Paul warns Timothy about the last days how many will turn to theses false teachers. As you know there are many in the church specially our very own priests who teach it, are we going to keep silent or be the watchmen we are call to be and also as Charisindia exhorts us to be. I would like to remind you of the promise that you gave us at the Exposing New Age, the seminar held in Bandra that you would see that Charisindia carries articles exposing the same and you even said that those who spoke it would be a good idea if their articles were printed as you really felt that their exposure was very good. I am still waiting and so are many of us, the days are evil and we can only do good by exposing the evil in our midst. Praying that the Lord would use you as the Heavenly Father used Jesus in the temple to cleanse it and make it a house of prayer. Praying for you. God Bless Dawson Gomes MUMBAI

Sent: Friday, August 04, 2006 4:25 PM Subject: Cyril's Response Dear Mike, Cyril's response for your info. God Bless, Dawson [Leader, Burning Bush Intercession Ministry] Dear Dawson, Thanks for your mail. I have forwarded it to the Assistant Editor of Charisindia who selects the articles and plans the issue. Thanks for your keen interest in the subject. As promised, a few articles were published which are connected with wrong practices/new age. In July issue itself there was an article by Fr Joseph Aymanathil. The editorial board is committed to publishing good articles on new age. Thanks for your prayers and support. With loving regards and prayers, Cyril John Sent: Wednesday, August 16, 2006 2:04 PM Subject: Fr. Augustine Valloorans Response Dear Mike, Praise Jesus, This is the mail I received from Fr Augustine. I am attaching it for you to read, it took some time for him to write, but I only attribute it to the power of prayer. Thanks for your prayers for our outreach, it was an awesome experience in intercession. All glory to Jesus. God Bless, Dawson Dear Dawson, Greetings in the Holy name of Jesus! Thank you for all the mail and the article attached. Mr Lalith Perera was here as leader of a group of 400 Sri Lankans who came to participate in the POWER 2006 retreat. He conducted only praise and worship sessions while he was here. He will be getting his ministry certified by the Bishops in Sri Lanka to avoid further issues on this matter. Thank you for sharing your concern with me. Yours in Jesus, Fr Augustine Vallooran VC From: dominicdixon To: prabhu Sent: Thursday, July 27, 2006 10:49 PM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Prabhu, Good work, great courage. The problem with some centers who call these people as resource people dont really care if they are involved into the NAM. [MORELOVE ministries, BANGALORE] From: dominicdixon To: prabhu Sent: Monday, August 14, 2006 10:02 AM Dear Mike, excellent work. Just want to bring to your notice that during the 2006 Youth power conference held at Potta, they had invited a minister Mr. Joseph who had showed up drunk and sang two secular love songs while Maria Sangeeta and Fr. Augustine watched. Besides this, a lot of other stupid things had happened. The source of my information is from reliable people and from watching the video of the event. The CD is out and suggest you watch it. From: dominicdixon To: prabhu Sent: Monday, August 14, 2006 3:55 PM Subject: Info Dear Mike, There were only 68 people from Sri Lanka. Sal Solo www.salsolo.com had rebuked Maria for her attitude and behavior. Joseph is a minister of some sort. I will mail you the CD if you cannot get it from Chennai From: dominicdixon To: prabhu Sent: Wednesday, August 16, 2006 10:27 PM Subject: Re: POWER 2006 Dear Prabhu, I was not there but I have seen the video and was happy I had not gone. I just confirmed by a youth leader that there were only 68 people, I will reconfirm it with another source and get back to you. Maria had invited some people from Bangalore who had toiled for her, these youth were in the dance and skits when she told them not to do it, so Sal, said that as long as he's performing, they will do it and that she should have no objection. If you see that minister and the way he acted, you will be ashamed of Potta. I'm trying to arrange a copy of the CD for you. From: erikagibello To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Sent: Saturday, July 29, 2006 12:46 AM Subject: Re:
ENNEAGRAM

Dear Michael, I am attaching for your use my Enneagram article. Love Erika PS. Send my article about the Enneagram to Potta. Mainly the problem with it is that it is a personality divination as is Astrologie! Apart from that the two men who invented it (taken from Sufi source) were famous occultists. Father Vallooran knows me well and will accept my opinion. EG [LONDON] Sent: Wednesday, August 16, 2006 1:39 PM Subject: Fwd: Enneagram

From: "Divine Retreat Centre" <augustine@sancharnet.in> To: <ERIKAGIB@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, August 15, 2006 1:12 PM Subject: Re: Fwd: Enneagram Dear Erika, Greetings in the Holy name of Jesus! Thank you for your email. Regarding the issue about Lalith Perera giving enneagram retreats, allow me to clarify something. Lalith Perera was here as leader of a group of 400 Sri Lankans who came to participate in the POWER 2006 retreat. He conducted only praise and worship sessions while he was here. Thank you for sharing your concern with me. Yours in Jesus, Fr Augustine Vallooran VC Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2006 6:28 PM Subject: Re: Enneagram I will ask Fr. Rufus to forward my article on the Enneagram to the Bishop of Sri Lanka. I think he studied with Fr. Rufus and is called Fernando. I will pray for your Press conference. EG Sent: Sunday, August 20, 2006 2:41 PM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS / BRO. LALITH PERERA I will try to talk to Fr. Rufus, either to ask him to send my article on or to let me have the name of this Archbishop or Bishop. In Christ Erika [ERIKA IS SECRETARY, INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF EXORCISTS] From: fritzmascarenhas To: prabhu Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 7:30 PM Subject: Re: Thanks Michael Dear Michael, Thanks for your email regarding Enneagram and also about Lalith. If I have a chance I will talk to him. May the Lord strengthen and encourage you to warn the flock of the dangers creeping in. In His love and prayers, Fritz Mascarenhas [Director, International Catholic Programme or Evangelization (ICPE), BANGALORE. Fritz was one of the preachers at the same programme]

From: javierlopeztorres To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Sent: Thursday, July 27, 2006 11:29 PM Subject: Enneagram Praise the Lord! Dear Michael, It's a pity, the enneagram issue. In the Encyclical letter "Jesus Christ The Bearer Of The Water Of Life - A Christian reflection on the New Age" -enneagram is mentioned a lot of times! They are many good links on the net: http://catholiculture.com/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=4634 http://www.ourladyswarriors.org//dissent/enneagram.htm In Christ+ Javier [Internet ministry, SPAIN] From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Saturday, July 29, 2006 10:03 AM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Mike, Thank you so much for this mail. I checked out your website. It is extremely good. However, the pages on yoga are going too far to the right, which makes reading them difficult. From: To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Sent: Friday, August 11, 2006 12:25 PM Subject: News snippet in Deccan Herald Dear Michael, Thanks for your mail on Enneagrams. From a friend, I heard about the retreat at Divine. The only thing that disturbs is the performance by the ex-Rock stars of Christian music. The Spirit of God who hovered over the chaos in the beginning will bring order and beauty out of today's confusion too. We have that promise! Hope all well at home. With prayers, From: marialaurapio To: prabhu Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 12:59 PM Subject: RE: ENNEAGRAMS Very dear Michael, I just wanted to thank you again for the excellent work you are doing of informing about New Age ideas and techniques infiltrating our Church, and for all the efforts in order to inform those leaders who are actively promoting them, as this recent case of Bro. Lalith. You have done all you can, and I am sure that your mail will help other people realize the problem, and some of them will certainly try to contact Bro Lalith about this matter. The Holy Spirit needs you, so keep up the excellent work!!! Very warmly in Christ, Maria Laura [Catholic apologetics internet ministry, SWITZERLAND] From: marialaurapio To: prabhu Sent: Monday, July 31, 2006 12:22 PM Subject: RE: ENNEAGRAMS Very dear Michael, The New Age infiltrations you are denouncing do a very profound harm in the Church. The Holy Spirit has found in you a person that is willing to do something about it. As Jesus says, we cannot pretend to be treated by men better than He was when we do God's Will. Persecution in this case is a sign that you are on the right track. Hold hard! My husband and I will keep you very specially in our prayers and I offer to the Lord my small everyday sacrifices for you. You have a strong faith, and Jesus is next to you every step you take. I find it very encouraging to see that several persons have written to support you and I am sure that several others, even though not writing to you, will have taken some type of action. In the end, what counts, is that you do what you have to do. The result is in God's hands. Very warmly in Christ, Maria Laura From: marinorestrepo To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 2:24 PM Subject: RE: ENNEAGRAMS.

Greetings from London. Dear Michael: Thank you very much for your letter on the enneagram and the retreats that the brother is giving back where you are. I'm 100% with you in this battle and praise the Lord right now for your apostolate. Please be so kind to give me that brothers e-mail so that I can send him my words on his ministry and I'll do the same with different catholic groups and communities around the world, to get them to write to him exhorting him to wake up into the truth. In Christ Jesus, Marino Restrepo, Pilgrims of Love www.marinorestrepo.com [Catholic ministry, LONDON] From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 6:18 PM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Thank You, dear Michael for the information on ENNEAGRAMS. In fact we do not know much about bro. Lalith. However, we pray that the Lord may give you strength and courage to pursue this matter. Love [MANGALORE] From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Wednesday, August 02, 2006 8:07 AM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Michael, Thanks for your e-mail with the details. Thank God for all the encouragement and the response received, which has helped you, in this your single handed battle. Even though I can do nothing much in this respect I shall definitely pray for you and I know you will succeed one day. [MANGALORE] From: pamelamathias To: 'prabhu' Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 8:54 AM Subject: RE: ENNEAGRAMS Hi Michael, Thanks for your message. In short how are they not good for us. There was a priest sometime ago who held Enneagram seminars in the parish. I am getting better and in fact I am thinking of making a trip to India on my frequent flyer points thru Qantas Airlines Thinking about beginning Sept 06. Look forward to your reply. Love & Blessings Pam [Trained counselor, AUSTRALIA] From: rappainedumpara To: prabhu Sent: Tuesday, August 08, 2006 10:15 AM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Michael: I could write to DRC only today. If I get a response I will let you know. Meanwhile, let me know where you live. Rappai Nedumpara [CANADA]

From: "Family Prayer Mission" <familyprayer@sympatico.ca> To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Cc: rappainedumpara Sent: Sunday, August 13, 2006 12:05 AM Subject: Enneagram Retreat Dear Michael: I have received a reply from Fr. Augustine, DRC, a few days ago. As I had promised to you, here is the relevant portion for your information: Dear Mr Rappai, Thank you for all the mails. As for the issue about Lalith Perera giving enneagram retreats, allow me to clarify something. Lalith Perera was here as leader of a group of 400 Sri Lankans who came to participate in the POWER 2006 retreat. He conducted only praise and worship sessions while he was here. Thank you for sharing your concern with me. Yours in Jesus, Fr Augustine Vallooran VC From: richardmascarenhas To: prabhu Sent: Friday, July 28, 2006 2:11 PM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Br. Prabhu, Thank you for the detailed article on the Enneagram. The following paragraph is taken from the article that you posted. It refers to the article written by Fr. Pacwa, is it available online for downloading. "When his parish was about to sponsor an enneagram workshop, he distributed the articles to parish council members so they could rethink the issue in the light of more information. The seminars were not held, wrote Fr. Pacwa, When the New Age comes to your Parish, New Covenant, March 1992. Committed Catholics everywhere can effectively do the same whether it may be the case of enneagram workshops to be conducted in their parishes or enneagram titles on the shelves of their local Catholic bookstore". Thanks, In Christ, Richard Mascarenhas [ABU DHABI] From: richardmascarenhas To: prabhu Sent: Saturday, July 29, 2006 9:58 AM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Prabhu, It is really sad to know, that inspite of providing sufficient details to prove that the New Age methods are evangelisation are harmful to the Catholic Spirit of worship. It is surprising, that knowledgeable (?) people within the Church and lay ministers ignore such revelations made available to them. Knowing what they are doing is not good, they still continue. Have they lost the fear of God? Their personal agenda's seems to give take precedence over their desire to preach Christ. I feel greatly distressed when I hear and see such things happening in the Catholic Churches and Retreat Centres. I was thinking of you yesterday when during the course of the Konkani Prayer Meeting, (we had the Adoration of Blessed Sacrament, held last week of every month and conducted by the Priest, by force so to say as it was earlier done by the lay people) he began with chanting "OM Shanti Shanti". Earlier too he had recited during his homily in one of the Konkani Mass. I am sure he must be chanting it daily in his prayers. I couldnt concentrate the entire hour. The literature on OM that I had requested from you was to forward it to you. But since the article is not precisely on OM I havent done it. If you could give me some sources from where to get, I will post it to him along with a cassette of Fr, Jerry. Meeting him personally is out of question as he is extremely short

tempered and has no hesitation in raising his voice and using language which you and I would hesitate. And so anything that u can help me with, before he starts to go all out with OM, seeing there is no opposition to its use. Prabhu, I thank you for sharing all the details with me, and i assure you of my prayers so that the truth will prevail sooner and save many a souls. With best wishes, In Christ Richard M From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2006 11:27 PM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Prabhu, Thank you very much for the replay... I had downloaded what you said in www.ephesians511.net if the 45 page write-up is something different please forward to me. I can rush through it and read it later. Hope you are doing well with your family and hope that your ministry is going well. These days I am little busy with my theology lessens and assignments. I am keeping fine. Wish you all the best... With love and prayer, Br. XXXXX From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Sunday, August 20, 2006 8:44 PM Subject: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Prabhu, Thank you very much for the attachment. I down loaded it and just rush through it. It is very valuable. Thank you very much. May the Lord bless you.. Love, Br. From: saratfernandes To: prabhu Cc: reslfernandes Sent: Sunday, July 30, 2006 12:29 PM Subject: RE:
ENNEAGRAMS

Dear Michael Thank you for your timely warning .My daughter has just gone to Potta for the world youth conference but had already left before I received this. Never mind -- something to discus on her return. When I was doing a course in marketing management in the early 70s one of my professors explained the JoHari Window. I am sure you have come across this. I found that useful to a point but in the area where it says unknown I substituted the fact that God knows everything about us which is a comforting thought. I wanted to know what your views were on this interpretation of Jo Hari window. I certainly do not wish to give any more credence to humanistic ideas. So grateful for your advice on the above as well as where psychology plays a useful role or not. Every blessing in Jesus [LONDON] From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Saturday, July 29, 2006 11:15 AM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Prabhu, I informed the official Charismatic Leader of the Renewal in SL. Lalith is a breakaway group. To my surprise, he too is using Enneagram in his programs. He even forwarded an article by an American priest who promotes it. I am therefore giving the e mail address of this leader. You can forward everything that you sent me without any acknowledgment to me Already the Charismatic Renewal is fragmented write to the Archbishop [Oswald Gomes] archbishop@sltnet.lk. Dr. Deryne Wanigaratne who is one of the top leaders of the official renewal delrymon@yahoo.co.uk [Charismatic Renewal preacher, SRI LANKA]

From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Tuesday, August 08, 2006 12:11 AM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS God bless you Mike... You may not see the fruits but you will carry the battle, just for the love of the Lord. Keep me posted and send me the new link as soon as it is up for your website. Love and prayers. From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Tuesday, August 08, 2006 7:53 PM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Hi Michael, PRAISE THE LORD JESUS CHRIST! I am really glad that you oppose the works of darkness and I do support you in prayer and also I am interceding for the church. This is my way of opposing the works of darkness. My love to Angey and self, love and prayers

MY LETTERS TO THE ARCHBISHOP AND TO THE CCR LEADER, COLOMBO, SRI LANKA:
From: prabhu To: archbishop@sltnet.lk Cc: Divine Retreat Centre ; focus@eureka.lk Sent: Friday, August 18, 2006 9:06 AM Subject: ENNEAGRAMS / BRO. LALITH PERERA : LETTER FROM INDIA

KIND ATTENTION: ARCHBISHOP MOST REV. OSWALD GOMIS, SRI LANKA


Your Grace, With great regret I am obliged to bring to your notice the following about Br. Lalith Perera: Please visit this ministry's new website: www.ephesians-511.net ] for information on Enneagrams. Complete details of the subject of this email will be uploaded on the websites shortly. The information that is yet to be uploaded on the websites, as well as all information about Bro Lalith Perera can be sent to you immediately on receipt of your request for the same. The updating from August 2006 will include exposes of other Church and Renewal leaders who are involved in the practice and propagation of Enneagrams and other New Age practices, alternative therapies and

eastern meditation systems, or who have not been cautioned even after this ministry has brought the issues to the notice of the concerned Church and Renewal authorities. Several Catholics have written to Fr. Augustine Vallooran VC asking that Lalith Perera not be allowed to minister at the Convention. He has informed them that Lalith Perera has brought 400 persons from Sri Lanka to Divine Retreat Centre, Muringoor for POWER 2006, that Lalith Perera has led just one session of Praise and Worship, and also that "He will be getting his ministry certified by the Bishops in Sri Lanka to avoid further issues on this matter." The purpose of this letter is therefore to inform your Grace that Lalith Perera is expected to contact you or other Sri Lankan bishops for certification, and for you to ascertain whether he has abjured preaching Enneagrams or not. COPY TO: BRO. LALITH PERERA: Dear Brother, You have failed to keep your promise to write to me after 2 weeks. Cc: augustine@sancharnet.in ; focus@eureka.lk Bcc: cyriljohn@vsnl.net ; antony_avemaria@yahoo.co.in etc. From: prabhu To: delrymon@yahoo.co.uk Cc: Divine Retreat Centre ; focus@eureka.lk Sent: Friday, August 18, 2006 9:05 AM Subject: ENNEAGRAMS / BRO. LALITH PERERA : LETTER FROM INDIA

KIND ATTENTION: DR. DERYNE WANIGARATNE, CATHOLIC CHARISMATIC RENEWAL, SRI LANKA
Dear Dr. Deryne Wanigaratne NOTE: The above two letters are almost identical to the ones sent to the Renewal leaders/ Divine Retreat Centre in India, and so are not reproduced completely here. All the necessary correspondence on the subject was included.

NO RESPONSE WAS RECEIVED FROM BOTH, DESPITE A REMINDER.

Using and teaching ENNEAGRAMS is not the only issue with Lalith Perera. Despite being recognized as a resource person for Catholic ministry, he is an astute businessman. His website gives details of the many courses he has done to qualify himself in programmes to change peoples lives- different types of psychological counseling*, 'right living' way of life that guarantees peace of mind, transformational living, dealing with ones weaknesses, etc. How is a person who finds little use for Biblical counseling and the charisms of the Holy Spirit so popular in charismatic circles in Sri Lanka and even in India? Lalith Perera continues to be minister at Divine Retreat Centre year after year, bringing along with him large numbers of Sri Lankans for the international youth programmes *see my separate articles on the great spiritual dangers in psychological counseling, much of which is New Age. See also my reports on other major problems with Divine Retreat Centre.

LETTER FROM A SUPPORTER OF LALITH PERERA


From: Paul John paul_pcj@yahoo.com To: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net Cc: focus@eureka.lk ; cyriljohn@vsnl.net ; antony_avemaria@yahoo.co.in ; augustine@sancharnet.in ; tabor@sltnet.lk Sent: Wednesday, February 21, 2007 11:41 AM Subject: Enneagram Dear Brother Michael I read your article concern enneagram criticizing Bro. Lalith and thought of writing a note to you. Stop Criticizing Servants of God. You and no one has the right to Judge and Criticizing except The Righteousness one has the all right and the Power to do and he will do in His time. If you see a problem Start Praying to God instead criticizing. I believe that you will not disbelieve that Lord can Change People. I have been attending Lalith Prayer Meeting on Wednesday, I give Glory to the Lord the way His spirit is moving, I have seen and witness lifes been changed, life's been transformed. It not because of any ability of Lalith (I guess lalith will agree with me) it all to do with the Manifestation of His Holy Spirit. I thank God the way He uses Lalith in Sri Lanka. In Country like us and India life's of Millions of people need to be saved. Every days Millions of people dying and perishing not knowing JESUS. Lets stop criticizing and finding fault, and we will see how HIS great commission could be fulfilled.

Time is precious and it belong to God Lets use it to Bless, Edify end encourage each others. May the Anointing of the Lord be with Lalith Thatha and his team and May the Lord use Him Mightily. I pray that Lalith and His team will always be covered by the Precious Protective Redemptive and Authoritative Blood of Jesus. God Bless Every one and I pray Bro. Michael will experience the Love of God. Yours in Christ, Paul Note: I don't except a reply from Bro. Michael From: prabhu To: paul_pcj@yahoo.com ; focus@eureka.lk ; cyriljohn@vsnl.net ; antony mahendran ; Divine Retreat Centre ; tabor@sltnet.lk Sent: Wednesday, February 21, 2007 7:08 PM Subject: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Brother Paul John, Thank you for your great concern for truth as perceived by your goodself, and your advice to me. It is only the fourth or fifth such letter that this ministry has received in all these years, and it helps one to understand the extent of deception and compromise within the Catholic Charismatic Renewal itself. If you did not "except" a reply from me, then you should have limited addressing your letter to me alone. Since you have marked copies to Bro. Lalith, to Mr. Cyril John, and to Fr. Augustine, I am obliged to respond. 1. My article does not "criticize Br. Lalith". Or anyone else. My writings are meant to bring awareness of New Age error in the Catholic Church irrespective of who is the person involved. I do not seek to gain favour, recognition or platform from any person, or any organisation. Both Mr. Cyril John and Fr. Augustine can vouch for my impartiality from their many years of knowing me. Almost 7 or 8 years ago, I had even brought to the notice of Fr. Augustine that three senior lay persons ministering at Divine Retreat Centre were Master Reiki or Pranic healers. 2. My articles are posted only after sufficient investigation, documentation, and correspondence. And when error is justified, defended, ignored, or left uncorrected. You may ask Br. Lalith why he did not write to me on his return from India, as assured by him to me. I had first written to him long before the event in question, but he did not respond. 3. My article concerns "Enneagrams". I believe that the Vatican Document of February 3, 2003 on the New Age speaks more about it than any other particular or specific New Age practice. Unlike most Catholics, I am unable and unwilling to remain a passive spectator when error, New Age or any other is propagated. I find it rather odd that you did not attempt to deny that Bro. Lalith teaches Enneagrams. One or two persons have denied that fact or claimed [falsely] that he stopped before coming to India. Still one or two others - who were aware of the warnings in the said Document] - felt that it was not a big issue. 4. I would have expected that some of the concerned people would have appreciated- instead of condemning- me for my alertness and my burden for the Church. Fr. Augustine, in February of 1995, confirmed my ministry with Jeremiah 1: 4, 5 when I met him as an unknown person for the very first time. He confirmed it to me at subsequent meetings. Mr. Cyril John has met with me on two occasions since 2003, once in Mumbai, and earlier in Vijayawada. Both the times, he has publicly [in the presence of other senior leaders of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal] stated- among other things- that my ministry needs to be encouraged at the national level and that any of my material does not need to be checked or verified because it is authentically Catholic. I trust that nothing has changed since then, except the increase in compromise and the unwillingness of more leaders to hear the truth when error is discovered among their associates and in their own organisations. 5. If you believe that my ministry is "critcizing and finding fault", maybe you would like to see the thousands of supportive letters that I have received since 2003 alone from CBCI Commissions, Cardinals, Archbishops and Bishops, superiors of religious orders, priests and seminarians and lay leaders in the Catholic Charismatic Renewal [including members of the ICCRS] from all over the world, and most major retreat centres and ministries in India. You might also like to read the Acts of the Apostles where the disciples of Jesus Christ not only propagated the Gospel, but also defended the Church from error. Peter and Paul also identified by name those in the early Church who would lead Christians astray by deceitful teachings and practices.

A number of persons in recognized charismatic ministry and leadership from all over the world wrote to Fr. Augustine, whom they and I deeply respect, under copy to me. Were they too "critcizing and finding fault"? 6. Bro. Lalith Perera must abjure the practice and propagation of Enneagrams, if he is to be recognized as Catholic [because currently he is in defiance of Church teaching], leave alone the leader of a huge charismatic ministry, and he must also undo the damage done to thousands of lay Catholics in Sri Lanka through his Enneagram seminars by admitting his error and reading them the truth from the Vatican Document, or from Fr. Mitch Pacwa SJ's book "Catholics and the New Age", chapters "Tell Me Who I Am, O Enneagram" and "Occult Roots of the Enneagram". Fr. Mitch was in the New Age and in practice and teaching of Enneagrams, and was Christian enough to publicly confess his error and make amends for it by writing the book, and several others like it. In the book, he NAMES those involved in promoting Enneagrams, including eminent priests. So does one of the cofounders of the Renewal, prophet and author of many books on errors within the Church. Are Bro. Lalith and the others connected with this episode Christian and humble enough to emulate Fr. Mitch?

Those who defend Bro. Lalith, or who remain silent and non-committal, share the guiltiness of Bro. Lalith. 7. You pray that I will "experience the Love of God" but do not want me to reply, meaning that you have closed the door on me. Is that what Bro. Lalith has taught you through his prayer meetings and Enneagram retreats? I do not give up on anyone, brother Paul John. Lalith can become a leading warrior to preach the error of Enneagrams, and he may be invited by the National Service Team and by Divine Retreat Centre to give his testimony like Fr. Mitch Pacwa is now doing. I, too, pray with you, that Lalith may be covered and protected by the Blood of Jesus. I do not wish to see the name of anyone maligned, or the soul of anyone lost, through the unnecessary propagation of New Age error along with charismatic ministry. Bro. Lalith is not alone. There are even senior priests in the Renewal in India who promote other New Age practices, but who have their defenders in the national and regional leadership. That indeed we live in the last times [in the words of the said Document] is confirmed by the fact that those in the Renewal who promote error are felicitated and used to teach and minister to others, while the ministries of those who expose and combat error are maligned and isolated. God save the Renewal!!!!! Yours, Michael Prabhu Bcc to all those who responded to the original article. PS. My 50-page article on ENNEAGRAMS has been taken off the website for updating and will be re-installed shortly. From: vijay To: paul_pcj@yahoo.com Cc: michaelprabhu@vsnl.net ; focus@eureka.lk ; cyriljohn@vsnl.net ; antony_avemaria@yahoo.co.in ; augustine@sancharnet.in ; tabor@sltnet.lk Sent: Thursday, February 22, 2007 12:52 PM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS - Abstain from every form of evil Abstain from every form of evil. (1 Thessalonians 5:22) Dear Bro. Paul John, I read your letter, which you wrote to Bro. Michael regarding Enneagram & Bro. Lalith. I like to say something to you. Bro. Paul John, What will you do if one for you son or daughter became a drug addict and started to spread the same habit to the other Members for your family? Will you warn others of your family to be careful with [abstain from] him or not? What the Word of God Instructs:Jesus Says: "If another member of the church sins against you, go and point out the fault when the two of you are alone. If the member listens to you, you have regained that one. But if you are not listened to, take one or two others along with you, so that every word may be confirmed by the evidence of two or three witnesses. If the member refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church; and if the offender refuses to listen even to the church, let such a one be to you as a gentile and a tax collector. Truly I tell you, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven. (Matthew 18:15-18) NRSV Our Forerunners of faith have taught us by giving an exemplary life. St. Athanasius fought against the Arian heresy, even when he was only a deacon, he condemned the Bishops who promoted the Heresy. So there is nothing wrong in criticizing the Heretics, even if they are Bishops or Cardinals. The Papal Preacher says to raise your voice against the scars of the Church:There is the risk that someone might do exactly what Saint-Exupery is condemning here. It would be the case of someone leaving the Church and then going from university to university, from newspaper to newspaper, from congress to congress, giving voice to his bitter accusations against the 'institutional' Church, as if this were a completely different thing to his ideal of the Church, thinking he can save his own honour by presenting the Church in a bad light. We know that the world thinks wonders of those who leave the Church. Speaking of those who abandon the Church for some heretical sect which immediately confers honour and rank on them, Tertullian said, ' How easy promotion is when you pass over to the enemy's side!' (Against Heretics, 41, 9). It is often the case that one hides one's total loss of faith behind a thick cloud of accusations against the Church. Should everyone always keep silent then in the Church? No. Once you have 'returned home', once you have wept for the Church, once you have humbled yourself beneath her feet, God may command you, as he did with others in the past, to raise your voice against the 'scars of the Church'. But not before then, and not without this risky mission causing you some form of death. The saints have applied to the Church what Job said to God: 'Should he kill me, I will continue hoping in him'(Job 13:15 - Vulgate Translation) [The Power of the Cross by Fr. Raniero Cantalamessa p144-145] Note: The note at the end of your letter, ' I don't except a reply from Bro. Michael', sounds a Nazi style. Please don't write like a Nazi.

From: antony mahendran To: Paul John Cc: focus@eureka.lk ; cyriljohn@vsnl.net ; antony_avemaria@yahoo.co.in ; augustine@sancharnet.in ; tabor@sltnet.lk ; MICHEL PRABHU Sent: Thursday, February 22, 2007 7:18 PM Subject: Re: Enneagram Dear Bro. Paul John

Thanks a lot for your concern towards Bro. Lalith. I had been there in Colombo for a year during 2003-2004 and I have attended several prayer meetings of him. Yes I agree with you, thousands of people attend his prayer meetings. But the danger begins here, now Lalith is becoming popular as an Enneagram preacher all over and he had conducted Enneagram Retreats for the same crowd who attend his regular prayer meetings. This is how the evil spirit deceives everyone. I have already written more about Bro. Lalith and my experience in his enneagram retreats. Also my younger brother Antony Vijayendran had replied you with a good answer. Remembering you and Bro. Lalith in my prayers With Fraternal Love Antony Mahendran Bangalore, India From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Tuesday, February 27, 2007 10:56 PM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Mike, Each time I read you, I cannot help admiring the gift of tenacity the Lord has blessed you with. God Bless and with much love. From: XXXXX To: prabhu Sent: Friday, February 23, 2007 8:51 AM Subject: Re: ENNEAGRAMS Dear Michael, Just a note to tell you I am praying for you and your ministry. I am happy to note you are not getting discouraged by criticism. I will write more at length in a few days. Love to Angela.