1> ~~±1thJf 1t.$fIJ if;--j- li..JI}J 1993.1f-ll}J Taiwan: A Radical Quarterly No. 15, November, 1993.

in Social Studies

it#- .f]=-1~S~0-#lriJtift : :r~~±. 1~Am~ {£!to/S~~W)
The Public in the Progressive Era: Lewis Mumford and The City in History
by Chu-joe Hsia

Keywords: city, urban history, architectural criticism, American culture
Jjt~ El.JI}J: 1993.1f-7}J 12 El ; l!iI& El.JI}J: 1993.1f-l0}J 8 a Received: July 12, 1993; in revised form: October 8, 1993

~. Finally.'. In addition.~.~ t~a*)~~kA~~A~ ••~t~~.The author attempts to analyse the discursive formation of this book and the Mumfordian humanist discourse. .~A~~A.~~A"~a~-~~ ~o••'~I±·~.Tt~~~ 0 ~rij -* Abstract This is a review article on the Chinese translation of Lewis Mumford's The City in History (1961).~t~a*)t~~~*.~_~.~'#. This paper elaborates upon the intellectual tradition of the anarchist socialist urban reform that lay behind Mum Ford's views. Lewis Mumford's critical and historical text is revaluated as the discursive form for the public constitution of American civil society in the pro· gressive era.4~~A~~~A.~tA £.~M~~.~I±·~.fo-.'li~..~~~.~.~~a.*~$~~.~~~at**.~.~k~*~~ ~/~.~~~~~ .~~_~m~k~~~ • •o~~£~~'k~.~~~.~t~a*)_~.*~~ffi*.A~*~o~~~#c.o~~~~ c.~~~.~~~~_. the "regionalism" in the RPAA and Mumfordian discourse is further defined. and their roots in American culture.~c.

iJil*i¥J_l¥JS~wp:§ifff°1-[gi¥Jm*_l±l!tR~ 19221f. ·~fUto/. .tl·.' r:uIDl.'E.IZSIJL\iFr$~*=~~:tM.)&ffi%oa-~ (Harper's) ~*i2§i'¥ J=I fU (Atlantic Monthly) ~m ¥J_l¥JS (The New York Review of Books) ~ !fJT~fD (The New Its Prospects) 0 Republic) ~ tz1/fq~::z1~ (Architectural scape Architecture) (Technology and Culture) ~ ~~~D~ ~ :f:ili~~~ (Land- Record) ~ :f:ili~ (Landscape) ~~~~~gjjj~Wr.t~& k 0 " "~~~. .it9ffii¥J1'F* ' l±l!tR7 31 *_ (~cp 19 *fJU. i±i:l'r!l±l!tR7 EI3~ {)f£~ cpi¥J:IJjlGm} Jff(_~i\B~:& ' +Jt~1f. 1& .i¥JM.far ~ # (Castells.94 (Flushing.!i3il (Amenia) *li[.it-.~~Mcp.i. W*~Bl~:A-*.~. 4- 10 JJ 19 EJ tl:: .:i:. ff. Et.iIi.J1~M.~~ •• o{)f£~CPi¥J~ m} Jff(_l±l!tR~ 19611f.~o~. ~ 0 Queens) .Jr~ xJ€. 1983: 335) *~~~~~::z1~l±l!tRff!±z~:1J ' *~i¥J§'~*{~it~{5e::z&ii¥J~J ~± .nk~~m~i¥JcJ:i$if1'F' ilink~ffiiliif1'Fcp i¥Jm-*cp_*.4.7'ic!i:f.A .~~CP_*~~. Its Transformations.M'$.ffl.fF z~'i±~i\+~1f. flt~~i¥J~D~Jl!..frJiZffijJUffijJUi±i:l'*f£~S~ ..f1Di±EIJ 11") . 1ZSI~~m~§!jIH~pfT~ . ~ffiili (Lewis Mumford) Z {)f£~ cpi¥J:IJjlGm ~i)ffi ~ .'1~fD~ : ~} (The City in History: Its Origins.~~~*~A~~.{@[1~WP:§ifff ~ffiilink1lLf.~~!fJT~Je~~~ 0 1.~~~~#~ ••• ~&k~~~ •• ~~~~tl:~'~~~~~&k~ t ' 'E1rH.j.§_~~jl]ji . :jT~'nTI~'ljt_jffi** .*1. 0 and i±:jzglI~ffiilii¥JB1:f~~zS~1 .~ i.] I'"T *-~51.~~~~~EI3~~*.Ii]IUWP:§ifff (Town Planning Review) (~~) . ~ffiili~7i±*ttfrJ-=: ~ [91f.jI.m~ i'I" J:.~~~ifffmti¥JM~ .ltEjfU (American Institute of Architects Journal) ~ ~~~~mgfIUgjjj~Wr:lt§fU (American Institute of Planners Journal) ~ :IJjlG~~.r:u~nk)f£~~~'~if~Wri¥J~ in ~ f@['!i¥J. 1990 4- . .2.#d£ 1895 1 JJ 26 EJ *.A~.~.&kt~~~~~~•• ~~.!f.

PJj~:lJ!Xm' +1Lt!t*ci¥JI~:lJ!Xm' :lJ!X~B .§:ili flitff~~Hi~:ii:ff.t~Bm~liI. ' IVl~CPt!t*c:lJ!Xmi¥J]Lm~f. Jt¥tltwp ' ~~ .)M~*~~ii:ffr~~i¥J AJt±~§i1Il~ . :f5HjtJ~.tB"Jrf~ .!r1¥J (Jm rPJt1t. flit~ T • w1¥1J (Martin Filler) §?J..tT§:1J:lJ!Xmi¥JM\ilffi~ffd:liI~~e.) ".t:lflXm :1JiID~f1jt*i¥J~1'F" (Miller.~~t.· 'I~!f.!t~~Z%~ ii:~i¥J.Ilo <~~CPi¥J:lJ!XrP}~*~:tEf~ii:ff.~'HJ!T EB"JnIG~-f.i~i1Il:lJ!XrP (Lewis Mumford on the City) <~~CPi¥J:lJ!Xm}~~~AJt±~~~~~CPi¥J~~~.~~ #iW~*:lflXmi¥Jffr$§f5' ~1-'.* ~ii~~~wp§i1Il* '!ilfU~1t1!~~~~~tltWP~&'Ei¥J±~~~. ' .f.f (William F.j.~i¥J~~o~£±.) Ofl:f-J~} ~.~~A fim~~m~¥.g ~ffriw j.cp~m~~.ffi¥Jwp~ .i!&1~~~~tii.~_t*~~~flJ· ~1¥1J (Montgomery Schuyler) 'T~fli'iJ 0 0 0 0 0 .ilEJjtW1T 1950 if{~i¥J{~W.jtJiiff~~t. 1938) Z~~~_t!lffilm' /f1. <~~ cpi¥J:lJ!Xm} !:~ 1 flit~ ~B"Jffd:Wr¥.tfi~ •• '"M~~~~i¥J •• '~M7.T§:1JJt1t. :Mztl-)}5.J.)m~lli:F7¥J7:lJ!XrP1~~ ¥1.tt!t3f'I:ii¥J~BrP1J!~ZEJ~g'I:i8/f¥H§~{8JC" .}~ <~. Whyte) ¥~~ "f.mro~. 1986: 7-8) otlt1r~EJj.RCPi¥J:lflXm}m~'EJj.fJT.i~!!t~i¥J{'Fr:\1z*~~flit~~~1HMJt*~~~fj~ z5'i.' ~flit:tJD~*~*~Jt~~Wr~JJttBjJ7/\~gc~~Jt-~U£ ± • ii:ff.ii:~~••• B"J~iife .t:fJ!1~i¥JM1-'.'R" (Sky Line) W:fIl' ~ 1931 if~ 1963 if ' *lfif 7'::: +t*ifi¥J~~~~BrPrrIUwp§i1Il ii:ffr@ji¥J~~tJtWPWl' ~m'BfJfB"JtJt*U.7ff~*O# <~~CPi¥J:lJ!XrTn 1£ 1961 iftl:l#&~'ii:ff.-El .. A~¥ ' ffd:fr.~7t.j. ( community) i¥J'I:i~ mtl:l7.§.oE~*&.f ¥}7tJjU~ . ~m5l:lJ!XrPi¥JTij] .~.*~g¥*.m~g.~~.e~i¥J~~i¥Jft.ftl:l1t1!f.~' ~BmrriU ' ~Bmiiff~ .FJT~i¥J~ffd:Wr%~z~ ~:to <:lJ!XmJt1t.cP t!t*ci¥Jf&~*.'~~~iiff~~o~~~~~*. mJ.*.i~ffd:*.. mMA1r~l1:.~ . ~f.gmJG.'R*.CP:lJ!XmFJTm-@:i¥J%3t3 ' IZ9JJtWflitff~~~ "*t!t*c~f1jt*i¥J~~wp~i1Il" .) (The Culture of Cities.:t:::~*.

§RmW~i¥Jjffl::r (professional generalist) '~~~@AW~i¥J4ftEJ~zcp E!ME~W ~*SR:~t1Q* ' .~~.j0a~¥~E81963 if. ~:1'I'I*~WfmWT:E1!Mf*~i¥J ~~~Jcl~.~:E1!I~/lJf.f". fftfl1~=+tJ:f:*c~ ~Jt1tj:Jt~i¥J~-1~ .m~Nzcp {i!!i¥JiH/F~~J.j'i§iffWGr& f1pJT~~ "/J\Jt~~W" 1¥Jif.:ffj~R:WT(Van Wyck Brooks) . ~ffr&.it 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .)Bc~/lJf.:ffjmR: (Casey Blake.tiH~{fU~1§pJT1.R* ' 1£~::t~i¥J1{§ ~1!f ' Jt1tj:Jt~*W~t~*~ f§N!t!1 ' NffiJ~::tmt:i¥J~~j:Jt~~§ al'M~ffr&.~fBt~~fr$:·f"5J~ (Malcolm Cowley) mm~ "~ 1~i¥J11!t*AJt::t~1!f" (Miller.tiH~I¥J~~~it~ .pJTMiftljm~ i¥Jffd:itc&1fi:.[1t~~ . #~~ffr&. .J! .~m~~~~~~I¥J.ffiJt)t:~=M~mIT'U' ili1JE~7 ~ T • ~ljljJi:R:'L. ~a~ili~1*ifmW~~~mtpJTi:R:)Ei¥J1)ijB~WJ&.~I¥J~~j:Jt~ (Ingersoll.jtJ~" ~1!f1r~~)Ufii¥J~Il~Pf§l'M~/J\ (Morley. ~flJt1t_tI¥JN~A.. McClay' 1988) ~~iff~m{*if~ffr&.j0.~i¥J::t~ OOl'Mffd:wr:5t IpJT~ff"ti¥JftEJ1S:5t7-*1t . ..~1ImtzV!tJ. 1986 : 5) AJt::t~~~JB± • ~ffrM Jt~A~1IIDWHmt.~ ' .~~.m~~~~~1!f° ~ffr&.~o~B±·~.ff"t7~~~~j:Jt~I¥J~ ~. -a:r ~{i!!~p1§~!t!1~~liA~7E i¥J~/lJf.&~ffr&. ili~AJt::t~i¥J-C.lz:~.i¥J*iJ.L. ~~r~l±l{i!!1r~i¥Jffd:wr. 1990b) I¥J#~~JB±· ~ffrM w~~j(·i&:m (Randolph Bourne) .~~~~WH*.1~i¥J~71H:lJiJGm~~$1§AF~~~Wl~H~i¥J~~ )tAtE m:3li~~if.I¥J. ' 1§~:9l'M~ffr&.MzOO:-~ .i¥J~V!tJtiH~~j: 1987 if.W~:5tIW~~JGi¥JF5p.~a'if i¥JOOJt• iffl£ (Kevin Lynch) ~AWZ.Jr1'i'1*~~~mF 7l'M~ffr&. ~ffr&.m.'J&.l'M "~{..Rftffr&.l* ' if.~Hn ' ~~ .J&. 1990: 32.f~m. WG1i1t~~~ • (Wifred McClay) ~~?2.'~R:·.3l·~~WT·MR:WTt~*s (Ada Louise Huxtable) 1:Em.1:f~~12t~:tjffli¥J "iUd: ::t~" fftflJf (communitarian vision) ~JB±·~ffr&.1~*gfjj . .1§l'M:tJr'~*::t~I~Jt1tl¥Ji~51t (~51t) i&m~~ -F~ .1~i¥J~~fr 30 i&W 40 ¥U50 if.m. 1986: 13-14) .. .&A:tzA 1r~l'M if.§(wtz~gi¥JJ:t~1t ' j. i*JiR: (Waldo Frank) ~1910if.Vili~~.

El39t~*~ *~T·$~~~~'~~:li!:~. -1ft ®i:~~~W~~~tto$~~~~~~~~Wr:>t{~l&[ii]tE. EI3 ~.:>t~~~.~m~PJm:li!: "fJi~glG~f'!!iJglGiIJ$" $WIJ®§ .fr'1ft*~fi~~Jj'f~)tWiiff~~F"'~ ~~~~~.~B/f~nE13 ±mt9t~Ji:*g.~l¥J.Morris) ~t1ff~rPJi:~~~±~l&[ii]. 0 0 0 .Jo ft~~~ § . IE~~irt-&9t'll'~rPJi:~~~.ffi\~z~~1~lftJi:®t~Jh. (Henry Russell Hitchcock) ~~~±~:Wtl jfi~Jtl&[ii] .~~w~~m.~ ~~:li!: : ~~$±mt9t~Ji:reli1~flj~~afl~lli{lLB*~iJJm ' Ji:~:f~i§ ~Wffd:.:W~iJJ~~{i. 15.)ffd:Wrg.ij:j[ f:*W ' ffd:l!Ii&m' 1M3rPg..1:.mfU~~ljf~~]!~~ff~~:~JJ:to/. &'11.~/f~~± mt9t~Ji:~illt~~~±~l&[ii].b.jkW~~g.Z iW*~:li!:J.)9t~gffl{'f@~)~V!~' ~{i.~~~ . W:>t~ • Ji:~flj (Vicent Scully) ~~~W~~$filjglifJ {lftJi:$~:l}jXrP} ~1j~1~®i:~g. ~~. ffd:Wrf4~-Ift*~lft760 ${i.5btntiitJ ' ±mt9t~Ji:pJT1rJ~~'lI'~rP Ji:{'f@f~~fff~ID~ ±~l&[ii] 'ift:.h~ (Filler.*.r\ . ' fr'tEffd:l!I~m$~~~ ~ll:t.fi~~o~ ~~~:j!f{'fWOl!\~~~'I1~~~~±~~~:li!:tEjBai:lhOO ' 'f1:JS7!.·~ {lftJi: $ ~:l}jXrP}:li!:A:>t±~ ~ffd:Wr:>t 1~l&[ii] 1M3rP ~ Ji::7t~wi'l1{'f @ t§®i:~I'HI[WT (A.}. .tE~-hOO'1M3rPJi:.J~OfPJf~Afr~f~mJ.~l¥J~ *m~~~'~illt~~~~7m§~. 1990: 14. 19) 0 0 0 *1*. ~®. ~~*'' ~~~~ 0 0 0 ~®.~~l&[ii]*~:li!:.~!§§ .$~!fJT~.~ JjJffj• :ffi"l!I~:R.~~.)E<.*ffd:Wr~iJJ ~ •• Wg~~~~'~BOO§~~o1M3rPJi:~~illt.mWfSWmEl&[ii]~o~~'ffi..1i: 7~illt_t~~D~Jfltb f'§D~' J.~-mtE9t.Et {lftJi:$~:l}jXrP} . ffug{j.g.~~1M3rPJi:!fJTiiffyt.[J'~iW~ ~~~~&9t~to/.7W&~jkoEl3~~~~~ffitt~~~&~.M~g~~~~~!fJT~yt.tt/f _tw§ff!m~fflmU*s*W~~~ffd:irf4 ~iiffyt.oJi:~W~.jk .• ' ~~~¥U~:li!:!fJTIifJWfS~ifH~~:li!:ffd:wrfg-~* ' ±~:li!:~~illt. OOft.®~g~~.1E~~~9t~Ji:ft~Fi'l~WJ. 'lI'~~jnf1:. ~iji~#~ rnr1nix~±i.f4~t§~ ®~t~~ .J&[ii].

J.f. J1£~~ "iij m i¥J~ *" (the usable past) .A.@m~U!i!H~~i¥JfJ!1-t3llbcpi¥J ~~1lf' JiiiffriJlU~!'MfJ!1-t::t~Jqj'I~'1E!.lI. fffi1JJ~~~m{.13-32) 0 Tat· Al>w.£ (Blake..~ i¥JWm2)(::!J." (~AA.flt" (In Search of a Usable Self) $".tt:**1Bim1ifi¥J~ji 1988: 137) (£ji) ~n}~.J&.{J1£~ CPi¥J:Jmm}1±'M~m~ CPi¥J*~~:I:tM.J.~$~ibtav ~"A:M.I:~~~~i¥J ' 1ift~~?l7~ 1-tCPi¥J2)(!J::t~1lf Jiiiffrii¥J1fi1@:1li!&.£m.J.fj)(@]¥Um*c1J]i¥J*iIt~~W30 1f:1-tjij:[5$i¥J~ji!'MmJ1£~JWX~z cP*:m:~11iZ~mJEii¥J "~~l&~fiJ!IU 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~~. 1990. Wojto wioz.'~~*~~D{PJi¥JFr>~m! IJt51. Jiiiffrii¥Jffi1@:fI@m~¥uTmxftjn'l • ~mWT (Patrick Geddes) W 2 .t.U1f. 1987: 100) ~7ffi ' JiiiffriEt~/fJqj~5fi§.t (Casey Blake) av"''f:tj\rJ1IJi!~A or JfJ av m.av .7Ei¥J "~f.lI. (Sigfried Giedion) .?F/ftltWlSi¥JIli!~1lf (Von Moos.JtliiiJl4-B Z1TlbW~~~ B Zj!~2.IgI. Spring.:t~i¥J~'M~m ~ilifHM:m ~i¥J~1~ .JE /liI $" itfmJ.:V:tilB1±4.ltJm§" W~~1J ACP ..':Jmmi¥JMl7. JL "ji#. pp.. fffi?F pm~~Ili!i¥JJ1£~ Jiiiffri~7E ' . 0 0 ~Wr" (RPAA.J&' m~..k!Uf¥: pg~~jt~~iil¥J1: m ~Fi'l~. ~DfPJ~1~Jiiiffrii¥Jlfif@:1li! Jiiiffrii¥JJ1£~. Regional Planning Association 0 of America) gI(. 19. 1±/fJqjS~~JWX~rpJTJ1j!.I:~. (Hall.t) (Mumford: A Usable Man of the Past) (No. 1990b: 229) 0 "i!4- .IJfI) -tf..ltlgI.. 1990 ~ ji#. tltWlS' WfiJ!IU1Tlbcpi¥J.Jiiiffri!'M:Jmmi¥Jjlmff~jEj1~{-tg~~1Bi~m!UU~~1E!.jW • £:f..~.~JiiiJ!l[ m~~~Jiiiffri!'MfJH~I~:9!Xi¥Jtltwp '1JJ~~~~te§~~jEjlt ' fffiY~ te~ AX i¥J 1ift~£~Jiiiffri/f~m{.' JiiiJ!l[m~£~Jiiiffri~ ~i¥J~-fl?FJ1£~i¥J~*W-fl/ffJ!.~~cP*=* T B ~17JJfffi§ '!'M{~'(3tjrR:·Jiii$m (Eric Monkkonen) ~f~i¥J'M~m~~ 1lf ' 1ift~?c. 1990: 32) !'M'i§S~i¥JJiiiffri ..M'~~~~~~ ~Z~c: (Friedmann.:i::.J~~ii" § .J. . /liI ' «Design Book Review» J!.!J.R1Wlfif@:?95t~~W:jl(~T ' tlt*Utii¥J~ ~~~~~~o~~~lli!ttz~m~T~~~i¥J. 1991: 66) tltfr~~~l'.$".i¥J "fiJ!IU §f~" (Morley. 1990. : or JfJ av i&"*. {-tg~ ".

U • -* .)i'f~mi¥J ~~~. 1iffr@jl£.fjJ~ ~ i¥J)'({~±$Z q:r 1iw@ji¥J~{'F::ff_§_ PIj..~~~~Z*~m.:~ §EI3r~H'6Ii¥J~*Pg.1~r.!**) :W{jTfUWT·~:R:~WT(Elisee Reclus) U.fjl[~.i¥J1mil&JM :±:~ffct1f:±:~ J~.E~i¥J1mil&JM:±:~:f:ill:E.!'t~ii J i :±:~i¥J1'.U • ~ • W\t$):WT1~Frederick Law Olmsted) i¥J~ ( ~).ll~m1lJ i¥J1:..E~:f:ill:E.~i¥J 0 $~* 0 e:\. j. 3t:R:~ (Frederick Lee Ackerman) '~flJ ·~W (Henry Wright) .PJI~ • ~WL (Benton MacKaye) .fjl[ fN.)m~~t!i!?f:±:~JEtWJ] T~~i¥J0~amfJ:W~WamfJi¥J~. Thoreau) .'~:lJilGm~~Wffim~i¥Jfjm~t!t~Zw.!·llirflJWT 'It:f::g:R:(Charles • Harris Whitaker) '9:i'f~¥ • ~WT (Stuart Chase) .)~?91)j:¥1Ez1~R:~r§W~ • (Peter Kropotkin) (EI3{fJt~:¥l$~' ~±i¥J1mil&JM:±:~:f:ill:E.fjJ §:±:W. :s.J~ .~~~~:±:.Joseph Prodhon) ~ ~.fto1iWr@j*~7~f.!!!f::f).i¥JfIEA:±:~mm$ .*w\!l¥.Ii]IU1"WEz* mE ~.!~~) .~:±:~I~:lJilGmzBZ:J1L ' PIj.!~i¥J~¥ ' 1~ ~ 7 -f. 0 0 . (Ralph Waldo Emerson) . .~~* ' ffct1f~*:W.j\ffi~i¥Jfj~~ .( .174 K~:IL 0 {jTfsfUr:]/• m¥ (Ebenezer Howard) i¥J~~ !l:~WT ' ~1.E~i¥J1mil&JM:±:~~ &:'m • ~~~ • (Pierre .1r:&fB{1iffr@j.@fjjPf.EEt1r:&1".ft' WR:m'.Z. . WLrtfff • 'ELm • ~~ WTW (Catherine Bauer Wurster) .i¥J":lJilGm~~a mfJ" (City Beautiful Movement) 0 ~flw\!l¥~~f}lTWm~.k1:.:~.IgtWT· :Jf (Clar9 ence Stein).~t-E:F~ffct1f1mil&JM:±:~W~ji:±:~i¥J~mEq:r .ft'@~~PIm~~m~·¥~· ~J.)&~-~~~9:LfB{ffJt~7DI:~z1mil&JM:±:~~~R: • e:\J!I[$ (Michael Bakunin) :Wr.*1mil&JM:±:~ i¥Jffct1f:±:~±$ q:rPJT2JlWi¥J.m ~~ regional reconstruction) .@. j.1!t:E.) -fl*J3.-2JTIHli* • ~ (Alexander Bing) ~-~tlfgzW~D~*~' j.W~~M.Ii]IU§ffl ' ~¥Ut!t*c:mr. ¥1~ • !!!:W~ (Walt Whitman) WM~· fiiME'm (Herman Melville) .(1~~jif . §:1J]!1:.j. fj:J1L18931f:zj]D~t!t~tw'l:1f~{-\. BZ:J1Lil:!:*-c *)]~~li*:±:~1~i¥JMl:l~H100mfJ ' mG~~~~'l:ii¥Ji'f~mJi~t1r:&1£*J!!.~t-tJ~. -'?flJ • ~~ (Henry D.j.t~r.j.

~:j. .Jf~-tf.liJ[fUWff~jrrfUl¥J~~ ':iliiiiM~A~~~mWTiiiM (FDR) ffi&l¥J~ ¥*o~r~~t:a:l¥J ' ::t~~ 30 if:1-t*MjW~1ffi!~.XcpWr~~~om~1&:ili~~ •• ~~~ ~j. 1990b: 220-221) 0 3.~.!i··· {ifL1r'rfT?&:1J l¥JmJG~~~1UI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 198.flt~~.j.$. :iliiiiMl¥J~i&Jff::t~~~::t~l¥Jtl!r1Jj~J!O~~.1ifL1r'l¥Jlilmiti (Wholeness) .l:rfT-~mH13 ¥U71~* ' :iliiiiM j1§-.f (Alfred 0 4.hz:iii.f~ fJfllt :Jt*#HliJl.Ht rn (Filler.~1JU~~j@:*l¥JX{t1t®'tcpZ~~. :Jt!$iJl. 0 ¥g~.1t~A1rP¥~'1&1Zt~m1'®'tCPl¥J~~mJGmffifBZ::t~~1Zl'M t~m~CP . Smith) ..ti*S!)~ 1990 : 15) I1il ' :it-!lJiS!)'it'i4-#P.J:1J cpJL\ZJi!§1!ll noJ: 1ifL~Jl1&1£ ' }J[fii&m1ffUJ3tcp:f'(tmtJrrfU' :Mz~~~l¥Ji&.~~J.ti{.~m-O~J:l¥J~qx .g:~~.J\ .R1ifL~~1¥fi1&~-Fm if:1-t ' . 1987: 187.WffctWr~mtJ~~M~ ... *Oili-lt*§'t 3(it~1Jl::m:*TtJ:l¥J::t~JW:1Z94 :iliiiiM&. m::t~ (Friedmann.. Blake.R:iliiiiM. ~5$~:5t1&~jkl¥J ~.1~' 1~mJG3?~' ~. . 1990: 31. ± t{g~1ffU 'W~*mJGm (Megalopolis) l¥JOlii.i!mWT !PHIU~.I.(Filler. :iliiiiM"iijIDt~~~ 19 i!t*-c.I~Af. iID~3!1&.)j!l:~t±l¥g~·1±mlG (John Dewey) l¥J.J: . .F~rfTfqj~R (Tafuri and Dal Co. *~::t~l¥J~l][ • ~flj~ (Charles Fourier) (Filler: 16-17) flt1r.IE~ "0R~R~ W"@~l¥J. t~m ~~0n ' ~~~Wr' ~fBmrrfU (the Model Cities Program) 'ff~j~mtJ.ttA lltJl.i:iJ .J:1J iligg~ ~7 mlGf.1t . ~~J: {ifL~~ ~ l¥Ji&mt.1t1Z. di*..)& ' !ME~.t. ~mWT (John Thomas) 1fmt±l.S*~~W1ffUJ3tl¥J:1J. Jhomas..h{~ til di*k~ i&JAjJtjlJ~11ts!) S!) 1IPl1.:i.t:a:§'tl¥J~~~.1t~3 :iliiiiM~0~~~l¥Jl.m~:7C' ~1ffi!Wff~j···~.1t.. 0 JL' "f~a~~J.O~tRl'mi:Mz~F~. X{tcp1Zl$JlJlE1'®'tl¥J**i~ (Morley. ' 0~JUI~**7t*&~~~ . ili~1.m::t~11f~WffctWr~~1'~ l¥J~~' ~D1..JfrtJtWJS~~ 50 if:1-t¥U 60 if:1-tl¥Jt~m]!ff$~ .r.\.f~. 1979 : 223) {ifL1r'l¥J-~::t~W. m ::t~1lilifj§]l¥Ja10i~:~.1. iID~F mrt:a:~W.}J[j@f~cpff. 1990 : 15) ~ ..1Q .iI!i*M. 1990) :1t .:tt+f.

W!M/G~'i1f:l:lW)I/M1rf~~.~ i¥JfJTmng'i:i' Ui•• 1. 1990: 32. ~jfij (Jane Morley) {))~:t~tB.§_RMW7~ffrlli*i¥J~ ~ .fflm:R: (Casey Blake) ~~7{'.~mz~.g~IDfHfJUIffi {.~.~.fM .~:R:WT:±:~1!fW ~E8:±:~1!f'U~~g~i¥J~~w.fJli¥J-fl0ffct:±:~ff~!I1T-{-fu1r~ m1Ml"pJT'tfi¥Jffctl& (~~.'§ifHl£./jj ~*J!~.~~.~i¥J1J~ (Morley.. -t~·.i1m.7/GY~~ .cpi¥J~W~fj_ . . ft~~u~~gIDfHi¥Jm.fMi¥J~.:t~rtai¥J~J!~~Ui¥J~~*~~Wffctfri¥J~_tEF". 1I~~~.t'~7E:§ .~ fJlfJTW*1!fmllJi¥J~I'6~ mt~ . § Casey.j)-*m)fJT.~.jgCi¥J{'§D~:m~!&rta' E8J!Jllli¥Jfi'J~~§ifH~ffr~!f..!'t:.!U~~ffctfr~*~.ifW-mif-.fJ (Morley.t'~{~A 1r~i¥J . 1990b) mfl~~ITIU (aesthetic project) pJT~~i¥J~Fa~~ ~ZRfJlW~~ (representation) :tHI:' /G{. ~)~~IT IUi¥J~HjtJ~~ff.*i¥J~fJTi¥JA~'.~~OO •• W~OOA~i¥J~~.~W~fr~~.§_~.~m~m~~m •• i¥J'fJTi¥Jffctfr*J3./jjA~~.)ft/G_R~*~ Mi¥Ja)[~ffijB ' ffij~5$r.176 X4!rfL {*m~Wl&~m~.)" (the Beloved Community) -?lUx ~fJl{~I*:±:~ ~*iliIZ911t1~·~)m1ii~ffrlli!f.*~.AAi¥J~~tltWIS' ~jgff. ~)~liBZ~*W*i¥J~. 1990: 32) m{J. 1.fflm:R:i¥J~M'U~m~if-'l£~~~~' 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .~ Jj!]°7dtJ·5$~ (David Johnson) Wm1({~·~~~1W:t~tB: 1-fu1r'!Mti~ m~~m.§t1X~ .i¥J~~~IDfH*~~..!:!.m.~i¥J. *A~.~ cp~~~!'&i¥J§. )t..i1m ~~ffrlliE8:j:ffi~IU\l~i¥JJi'Hi*~ffilllcpW~JmlltH.W "t~*4I1i¥J"~ffrlligIDfHJffi:1Z9 ~·~W~~-t~·.('¥ IE~3iti7if-{-~ cpa)[~:±: ~1l~H..m~7 •• ~M •• ffij ff:1£i¥JJt1l.!'t:. ~ffrIliZ$*~i1.ZfJT~fri¥J~~'~~~.)d1Ji!Mffr±l&i¥J-flfJT~{~1jIjiO~~*i¥Ja)(!fi1!f' 1-fu1r~:.~i¥J~~W1*Jffi:Z£j(i¥J (JHi1L' 1992: 152) E8m{I@fi'J~!MJ:t m-fu~l£~* ' ' 30W40if-{~i¥Jft.r~E8 ~:±:Jt1l.:±:~}~. ~ra~i¥JITIUl£~5EJW~PJT~gti¥J~~ T 'fr1fmFmgJGff.!'t: .!:!.i1.~U~l&g~~:±:~~~fig (0~ :±:~) 1jIjiO~53~~{~i¥JtB~ (a communitarian alternative) .

4Ji~lt. 1990b) ~m1*~~~~~~i&mo~f_ltJ.I: 0 0 0 0 'fjJL (conventions) ~ .*A1. .$mmE~ftm.~' ~*.I"l~~av.M•• ~. 1JiA.~. 1990: 32) ~~1ii1i'&~ """6Jffl~Wj $:" (Blake.~~l!~~. !!1~ .~ 1r~lf!. ~~.*1t.g:rj1fHi1~ftJtIT1~:ljjjGm ZftWi&m~~~~~~R~~'~~L7~i&m~.ttW¥ (operative criticism) pfTlIi~~1~1&i.fM~~Iii.1 avJtI-~4Ji~ ~.t (Blake. #!~ .®~~fMtt~~mw~ ~Jt1~§R~ft*'&lmL1Tj}]7 (Morley.jiU!Iavlt-tf.@~§~:l:fu§tIt~:@'1i'&~1&~liifJj~*ffr±.~.~A.:t.i~-t~av It!U~-tt .av'¥~~'M*~~.iI!!*.·.~.ft:t¥J (visual) ~it (~JJl.%gj(."I: ~)t1'JT~ft1Tj}]~ ~f_I~~~~*~~ : ""·1&.-Jfr .) 0 0 0 :@. d7~&I:.I. 1990b:47) 6. 7J:~~ffr±1E'@ ~§ ft**tsi&m~~~~" ·~ii~._~lt-tt~**-*.M.~4~1t J]~ At" .j}avt~.if.!)}av#§.~.Jjj~~=& ~~Iii~AJt~.*H1. ~fff' ~~Iii~AJt~.t._~~~4avM.A~ ~~~¥J~~¥J~~'~~~~~~¥J~k~~z~o~M~~ 5.7!i!~~~ mll*Iff6.tiJl'.kA.~~.f._j.t1.f.:t.~ftii~m~ifIlmt~]~:.~t1 ~1§}¥J (verbal) #!-.~ftii~m~~ifIlmtg:rft:timWB)t53UEl3/f'Im~~1jfMfJ!1-t~~ .1t 1tI'A ~~f..ft~~~.JjjfMffr±.:j-.~._:flJ (Manfredo Tafuri) ~k-lir' (David Wakin) av. 1990a: 283-285.t1.~.M.$--tJt.ttW¥¥U(g. T .~. •• ~~~..@. i!.k~~~.ti)J111t.~~ •• -«*~~~*t~ M.ttW¥~-§f(X~ ~jI~~.$j 1Ht1.im ~~~i&m~iOO 1-lli(~) 1r~tt~Ij)jBf~i±l' ~f_lfM~~Iii~¥f~sffjH!~ ~~"~~W*"'®~~~~~~B. ~~fF'I:if. jji±1E.~9t.k1t.h¥JM~~M~¥J~~o.MJJIA\1Q."f1il?Ai 1M' ill ~-&~*-0-~iJt7 .~j}]ft~~T~~iml!i&Z)t1'JTElM' 'i'm.ii~m~~ifIlmt~Fi:!5JmMz/f':tE.-M*4~.~n.~ .~9t.zAt'±'!l'±'-kavilr~A._~av~A.$._j.~!l~ •• ·_j.ftM.~-R~frtt~.ffj}]~~* •• Ij)j.if 0 0 -Ito ** .Mz/f'-~ 9t.~.#!-. fIl:-j.f! 'f I'A -f 1~1'F ¥J 'if .~.~#1t.pfTjlW~f_lff ~~tIt~B~~~~.~~ ~fW~~Iii~1&~JU~.av.

~'~~~*'~~. 0 0 0 0 . ' ~. 1990:19) 1£IiIm§B~__t.tIT. ffiJ~~-{lrnB~flJ~~~ft~JfJJU~ I~ l£1tiW~f]JUft~§t:W~Jf~ft'lf~mJ.*I¥J9! ~} (The International Style: Architecture Since 1922» ~1fr@ift~~~~f]JU~Witf~~~~~{*:1JiID?JT±:~~~~m9!W~ :f)J:X±:~D"~~1:. 1931) 1¥J1§ ]j[:Z*E.~ -.:m.![ ~ 1jUt:Jt :tt JR.~iJjiJj~~pgft9!~:W~IiI*~({~ {~Fi'I''~Fi'I'ft9!~} (Space' Time and Architecture» ~~~~.j$.)&.{~} (The Brown Decades.j.tit~·~~-1m B'H~A*. 1986: 14) 0 ~~~~~Wm~R~$~-OO~*~. {J!t~~~m} ~~1iI~~~~1I&ID1t ' ~~~~~.~{~**~ .!t~*J1H&!m~Z1ff€.A~B:lJJftf§B: BZ~Zttft:1J' tf~m~1§~~'tJ&t~ttft:1J (place) ottft:1J~ (sense of place) ~'lf~m~Ji5'I'1~£f!f~m.{~JlU{~~ 19 i!t*e.178 .~ : 19221f..~:lL #!-~ A. vA ~1 ljt!:B -fi:i@. .~ .~.{~ {**1S1f.fBl&~~~ 20 tt*e. ~1fr@i~~ifB"~~?fJT ~~~o~~~'tf~1£701f.Mftm~~~Z~o~~±·~~tfRW~ "§Z~~. 1990:23) ~1fr@i~:z*l?fn ' :pV!tj§B~m' tf~~~ff!±Wi$)'l:T~j(fif ~Uf1!§-lH.i~UIJ i!J£J£t~1t.ft~~~~$tfmJf~±:~~~~-~ ~~-~D"~§ .~. 1@:1~~5jUff:~ {~{F~m ffWl~~~~R~J:Wm25(~~ff!±Wi~~ ~m~~~.HJlI'I5~({~ {~~{tmgrjJ) (Mechanization Takes Command» .i*~g&ij If] {~~~§BR{'FfBl~?2.lgifB$ .~ 3yiH@:1~MfmJE-= 0 ~Ifr@i~:z]j[.A~9!~~7f-~ ({~ {~~~.ftfl!]JJ& fI!] -§f.t1jt ~ (zeitgeist buster) .z. §M~~ (Filler.t: ~ (style-consciousness) .1SI::Z~~{'F7 (Lefaivre and Tzonis. ~ #!.FfH!i'/::~'¥r*.~~m~~~*~~~~liIm:9!~:W~IiI.JE~ "~~±:~" {J.BIt¥f:fI!] $Ji ~ 0" (Richard Ingersoll.:l.~ .m9<:7~:Z~1'iI'ifC l~~.~' jt. ' ~ J=!'J!t<i'JR ft:WfIJIiIZtHil.1r~~OO~ifB3ZIj.~~$JL. ii]T~*~~~ fr'i*' ~~~~j(i~'$E.Z1~Jt.~*'mM'@~.A:Z±:~Jf)([Q]PJTJ'¥..'9!. ~1fr@i~.(lif§ 0 0 0 ~*~ 0" 0 ~~ .

mffr$W:f:lli1JJYft~'I1: : (:f:-(g 1Jjiif.....M*&'i1:i¥J .1JtWJS' PI tJ.~m (Ume Lefaivre) W:s::!JIfw::f(· mwr (Alexander Tzonis) fli~T· fflj..i§m ' 1~zBm1:.i§.1W..~&.i§~ T -fjffilai¥J "B m ~'I1:" .!:t~7t~T~1Wt91~100:1I ff~-tlt*c. 1992: 132-137) ~~tlo Jit ' &"ftfr'WJS~~jjii%~AJ(±~i¥Jr:pJG'lIlli.1ii!111.~B9 :7C*o~:l!i:'~*. 1Jt*U'I1::f:lliff~T§iWW *:WW~Jj!. 0 ~*m..:. f:lWm:f ~ ~ ± ®jljiff i¥J.~H/f'JIk.f)]j'ij:J5(V!tJWJ( ..~ * ~ (Martin Heidegger) j'ij5Wf~jlJ~±.f)]:J5(V!tJWJ(~Fs'i¥J~* ' ' ~1* ~fffi ' ~fjj'ijA:f:lliFs'5$r. ~?t ' ft~~~M:?jctj'ijff.t ~ ~'~]!/J\JG':f:lliJ1tlJ.. Ubi. 1::5$~iffJ)Ki¥J ....#.:.~Mi¥J .~5$1~Tif.mr:pi¥Jffd:W!Wfl:1J~1* (Kim..& ' :f:lli1J*~..~.{~~~ (Lefaivre and Tzonis. . -er_.m1.!'t:{ift~gfjf~A~ f 0~ .7tfio~~. lli. ~ (Volk) i¥J..f:lli1J~'":f:lli1J.i§ .:f:lli1J'lfI3'~) place attachment) ( 1iftg?c.1::i¥J~RJ7g~ .~ (Dovey Kim) ft&:m·1si! (Pierre Bourdieu) .D~W.~~.1i!\~ r:p 7t ~ T -tlt*c..ftfr..1i!\~.!J\ ~[qJ ~ ~m ~i¥J~~.:X11ffi • -ff :Effijt~ (Allan Pred) W*~· jjii%7rl (Michel Foucault) i¥J~~__t.jj1C-'I1: .1~ It.If!l'I1:?t:l:W..i§ ~ (bond) 1*~T..~. ff.if. A jiif.!'t:. ~jjii%' PJT1~i¥JJt.*~~·~.t~9. ~ff:'I1:B"Jj!if.-®g. 0 0 {iftfr'1~ ill~jjii%Wfflj.g~~jjii%i¥Jf)]~lJ.fri¥J ma~lI~.f::Z~j2g~i¥Jztn (bondage) oj!if.t 0 fflj.~-liI~±~-S~ .Ui¥J'lfI3'~~*r:pilir-'l~T~~*f~.1Zi¥J~lli.!'t:~ .i§... (Anthony Giddens) .~"mt1iftfr~i¥J~~~r ..i3> 1::~mfjfflG7t*JlfflG: ~N*UTAfr'i¥JWlflll!J tJ.~j2g~J(i¥J~....t~*i79~I!I~i¥Jf=fR .~7tJ/..~fflG* (Lefaivre and Tzonis.U\~:f:lli1Jj)ft~'I1:~~iI! *S (bond) ~ff. Ri¥J~f=fi'Ni~ .tJ....tl!r:pi¥J* ±:f:lli~lI"~1M3W~~ .. .::::.tl!r! . 7tEE.~-~i¥J~.~ •• ~~~~~r:pi¥Jm:7Cj'ij~~*o~fffi' {iftfrn8l1ItFs'i¥J~~:::.t.:l:$]:P'I:I~i¥J*'" ±:f:lli. 1990: 22 -24) : 1990) 0 1 .

'~ ~ti1~rta1rgj~J[± " ti1r* " ~1r* .~~tfg.:t~i¥JJft~~~ ..H"mli1JfFf§ 0 0 ~* 1 ." ~~/ff~~~ " W~~~±A.l:tzVltr"~ 19 tJ:t*ciIiR:Y~JlJUi¥J~~~~Zq:rol!lli~.EJl{~.~ (Heimat) i¥Jft~H.\ ~'{lHJ~!~~5'l::5t.R~LlI)(:I: ' 1~/f ~1JJi&Jffi¥JB*1.:t~ITJUz~W't {~1J±WJSffri%~Ij~*i¥J. " 0 0 0 0 .fWl' 5$IDi!iI{~§Rj.:t~~R.:t~ 1iMElFal!lli~.ji$ffi$~1~i¥J~~± " irL§..ili~/f~1y.:t~IE~*l.{f. -It iL 1 .'jlj~i±r~: ~~{~~}$.j:.:t~I¥J&:\ ~g~{Jjo:tifLffri%gj~~~}$..\~/fii.m~*-Jtl.:t~" (housing) . W1W~1~~~{~!¥J}$.:t¥~Hit!P~t. IUJ 1*~~mi¥J {~1lt~§a} WR.EJl{~ffd:1r§tJUi¥Jf¥7:E~~~ " ~{i:i..j:fTi¥J ' I5J~ .~m~~i¥J "~F1'I~fltJ" :5t~1~f. ~-~1'~r {'F£ ' ffij_i*7-~rta:gUOO~**~1f. 1~1'Fz!M=fI{ fflt1~~z§ifij3zjM~.:t~ili~F@]M w~~..EJl{~Ifji¥J1$jd'F£ ' {~m~i¥J. 21~:Ut.1~rta ' ~:f):!~ .'§{*.jIE~ti~~Ff-f:'tii¥J*®'t {_§_~l!lli:f):!~.\~ kffri%Ji:t1t. iliMz/f~mkffri%i¥J~{'Fgj~~/fmff~ 1 .180 1t~:lL 0 ffi&:5t1tl~1!l~i¥J~~ 7 i~JiiI!*Egt1rw*m~" :ll1~W pgg~]Lmo ~rm ' kffri%i¥Jl!lli~.:t~Mz~F~@]kffr&ipJT~~ i¥J ":f.2. ~ 7:Effri%flj~*7JOO' kffri%Rgj{~~1f~i¥J~~ .:t~~.{~q:r:JnlGmi¥J~~t~~ 1tMJ±*U~~ §fflftgff~7*JT5C*' {~ll-5tB~ " ~q:r1l-5 " r'i'D~~~ .tljH~1iz lIf~fJHst ffltif-~~ff~ "~ir1.2f.§'.~~~~i¥J~OO~*ol!lli~.&it~~i&Jff.\~. .:t*Ui¥JD~~ C&:m'·{S)3t~tl§t±:llJtJ!iti) fflt~~~~fJU~:tz V!tJW.&*t~WlJfEJl{~:tzvrqWjjii%~1j ~*fd:1r ~. ·~Jtl.2 .lITz~~rmW~~~ ~rm ' kffri%*~-ti:E!l!tiM§J1B' {~m'1l~ .EJH~' iliR:z~{~i¥J~*}$. t:.i¥J ~1Rl*~1W3l .f!J~R.**~ .~~~q:r{~i¥J~~iH ~rm ' kffri%!P/f~BUJl{~.fImx. rmm~Z~~!p7f'7:E~ffri%~1j ~*ff~ Ai¥J1!l7'CtEUfm~ ~3<:j(~zT ' ili/f7:E~jI.f *.~m~~~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 t~. 1m*~~:5tr'i'Df.

~i:iJj.f~~PfT~~i¥J*~mZ"::f~~'ti" (immorality) :g:1iJ7Jj( ~o fill1r'i¥J~~:±~/~~' j.j.):(£]I!-R'l:ii¥JM~ctmM i1t1r.1fJl}]~ffljt~.9tfMq:r:&'~m~ITM~Z~~{1=Jflrlill*.) § ?AZP:~:W::ffR]fY'~*&ZFi'l~i¥J~:Wt¥.~ t:::~ f~7 0~::fE&Tt£i¥J{~. ~" Z¥}~*.-$ i:iJ .fo:liil:±~tM~~~± ' ff[§.Jmt~i¥J~lilifU~*i¥Jf~{~~~{. ~~ m-~illE~i'IJ' :(£f. t~t1gffd:it~ . 9tfM7 A Jt:±~1!ftMfJil.3~ftJ1t~i!av ~ ~ fflj~.mt±:l]l!1f~U~1Ji¥JITIU ~J~±. ~~lii~~~i¥J9t~tJtW!lz5( {)f£~ q:ri¥J~m> i:iJIDt~:&'~ m~'rmfjzjj.{~:±~i¥JtJt*U'liJJ~ ~~i&~fR]~tM~*zjJ&rE!fl1J :W1il<:f:Ei¥J.f~ij:1f :Wffd:itFi'l~i¥J::fZP:~ illf.j§PfT.. {~1tpfT~8.jJ&JfJ:±~1Jj!~6ri¥J:5H'~1tz/J\~{:lL ' tMWi~i¥JAJ1W~fIl1fN.)&~J~± • ~~i i¥J~Mif~i:iJIDt~~~~*~~i¥JAJt:±~1!fZ~~~8..j§APfT~~i¥J:I9FfF::±~' .l*m~Ji*:±~.i~:WIfjITIU 0 0 0 1.:E.tM1Yl1~Ai¥J..))tJ3l~tMm I~~i¥J~ito~n ••• ~m~~~~$::fi:iJ~~i¥J~.l1~' M1~m-f.j§~~~~~i¥J§~.~ 0 0 0 0 0 .~!m JJ'Lt.t:W~~o~ ~lili§i!t*at}]OOfril :(£~~Ji*:±~I~1t:W:&'~m1ti&!fjq:r ' .WTt~~z~1t~Fi'l~9t fM]I!~A:W]I!~OOi¥J' 1f~f*ffJfl!Ti¥J:5tfJfZ~ .~a:W/J\IDtq:r~*5tt~~~ ~)f£~::f~*6* ' rm~ ~*"ti~:E. : :(£&-frJ1fffd:it Jli¥JW~1!fITIUq:r. :t-tlr1JllMif'li'm § )tDI~tM:J1iJJiI. Jt1t~:Wf4JJ\~ .% N.i:&'~mrg:E.'?Arm' :(£~it..i:&. j. ~~liliAi¥J~jJ&JfJ:±~tM"~ .I~lz}E~ 0 0 0 frJ5IJtz)7UJfiJtm:w*mWTi¥JIJj!~6i:iJj.I' j.~]I! •• i¥Jo&-frJ'*~~i¥J~~ (~ -alienated space) i¥JlIij(..)W~~frJi¥JF".~@~~:±~*~~~tt~i¥Jm~o ?Arm' ~~lili*P~@¥U)f£~.ti¥J~1t~Fi'l~ (alienated space) oJt1ti¥JN. ' tM:till~'~~a f~. ~~lili*P*}E .X&.DM*~'~!m~.::p. ~ fflj1~. $~f@f~:(£tM1~WLJEI.

*"M*m~.i& rElr:j=I. fflJ%:Wri§ai¥J~§*m' ~~~70~'I:1f~.~.~r8J~7~~i¥J-~~~~t±l r.W#lt:rTfi¥J.A.1IJJz.j(.X~fBJ?~.{'F' tN*J.~Ujfi¥J1¥.~~I19.'Jf. 1990: .~ff:W'Jf~i¥J?M~~fBJ?~.!l.••• ~7i¥J •• 7f1noJ%:~~~§.iJtI19.~ >to .:IU~..~~* . w#a~~~fd:1!z~~fl*1!f~ '~1@0~'I:1~'I:1JjUlK~7i¥J~.~~ ~.. Morley.Ift~JJil.1filtAA.) _.W'~~~ rTf'§!.jf~~:.§!.r.a •• 0 0 .1i.{'F' ~i'M7~~fd:1!0~tE41Ji~i¥JfRIlmt 7f1~ ffiflK~±~pJTM~i¥J#lt:~@~IUH*B*~ "§~{r.tJt1tJA.n. 1990) (or.fMli¥J-g~ {51 ~{@'Jf~~J::~i&rElt1i¥J1¥.)~-g-~~i¥J.AA-I19*.. RJ~'E iP*~ m•• ~-fj#i&rEli¥J"~OO"~~'~~OOi¥Jn~*.~Jl!1!' ffif::1p~~7H)K{r.(one of the last "pub0 0 0 m~~ lic intellectuals") intellectual" 32) 0 (Hughes and Hughes.. 1987) (Wojtowioz." ~-fjX{Gl¥Jf~ 1[~>1J:J3f"j:ftlG" ~~~fd:1!0~tE~i'M~i¥J~~~ra~rtEtl~'~%m' .:5t-T" Z.~•• ~JA. "f ~M:I19~~ z-~17f°'*" M iffi.r.ttWJS:W~~{'F~ ~ ~ i¥Jx {r. 1979:57) ffifJ%:Wrii¥J1¥..~~ 0 0 .fd:1!i¥JrTf '§!.i.i. z.±{r.i.~.j.jf119~-1t~~Jt:..f.. (~ tf*~5) J%:Wri~1~~i¥Jx {r.t__i_~*.!fI.~t(Patrick Abercromb~ a~*.r.Ift~-fji&rEI~fj .it~~.~~.«~o~~rn~-1t~. rEI.{~fljU~.Jt"f".119.i¥J'~~rTf 0 0 7.JrJJb± .tBtm*·1~RJ It (Russell 1 Jacoby) "~1~i¥J0~~o..~ •• o.rTf:WlK~~ra~~~i¥Jfd:1!~fjtN*J::J.jfit~Jt:..!f-fJ{Wi& 1¥..§!.g0~i¥J. 19~~'M~i¥J '~ ~~Jir8Ji¥J:Wffr$ffrE±~!f-fJ{~~~M'W11I7J%:Wri@:*pJTt±liti¥J~~i&rEI 0fd:±~~)L' ~1~' OOW "~~ r:j=Ii¥Ji:!1ft#lt:rTf" 'J%:Wrii¥J ~~r:j=Ii¥J#lt:rTf> < ~lW fJt1r~1@1~~-~1itf~ : i:!1ft!fJT~jITIU~1£{tMtfi¥J!W~TtBt51~1¥J? ~i¥J.~~~~119 ( •• it~-.s':tfl£i:!1fti¥JJJil.. ~ .jf'~~1.~{tM? ~X:.t.~~~OfBJ~i'Mi¥J? ~i¥Jpg?£.I19..:j=.#-~ltt dl18991f-ftl19051f-' it~~1I!!.1r~~t±lB~ ..jfI19.1'F o.~/lIJi\.i.f.7 i¥J~~JGzWJSf~oZSI1Jt . it~Jt11iji!Ji!!.Ift~~{@JJil.{~'lI'~rTfITIUi¥Jl1ij: (Tafuri and Dal Co.#-it~ '.:5t (citizenship) Z~~.:. 1t!Li¥JW. a "civic 1991. Bender."T1fJ11.~T7rTf.fJ§-~J.r.

£ -~-*Wf. ' y...fJT-Ei'f1ti¥J~ ~~~01PJ2¥~1:E:Jmmzr:p .~.'rn#.E(::sz.i¥JlI~6~1:E1t~JlJK~Tij Ijii¥J ? Ei¥J..' -tt~Ji'k.f.-~ 422 Jf' i..#.-'t avk IJ.~ ·~#iJj.t".JLtrJ" k~ * # a -100 (f.-.±~~iJ·&~~a ·~&~~.ijtavft~~. f.~ ~~ ~ Ji'k.~~01ilJ ••• ~ffi¥J?::sz.iJt.t~av~.ft>ojf~J.-!tHJI.~~Ji'k.'jf~.. lIDlM'i"iW-Ei'lfti¥J:J5tM:Jmmz•• ' :ih/ji@j1:E (~~ r:pi¥J:Jmrp} lM~1'f:FJ! 1~'1:i~~i¥J ":J5tMi¥J~T" i¥J~$' t!~.:.*-.av •• J-tt~#~:l:lMN-.f.~ J'ei¥JtlTm!tt ~~~i'~i¥Jiiff~ . 0 0 0 8.R~JJ-M--~fJt.f.~o.r:rr~tIG1r~-J£l'. .~~1~~ •• ~*av • .fIJ ~ •• k:.JLtrJ ..'.JLJl'J~~ ~~~~~av.. ~-t-:l:lJJl.tf.~~ 0 ..iX.#tav~1t' ".!~Jt~ JJl. «&3t'fav~*»' 1961.$Jf 0 _L.pJf~£av IJ'~J ' .M~.Z~!fo/.~••~.]UIl\i ' 1~ 0 ~*IDl.J ' ]! ~fjJ~i¥J~~.1 0 . m71t1hkJti-00.JJh±· ~~.~~av~.#. 7.u~:g.M~z' rn.M~o-~.~:...I. -t.Pl-A1F'*-iJt.§~ : (Garden City) 0 :g.i¥JlI~ZJ} .~.-tti{-_L>fH.±~av+:. i¥J~iJ 1:ElM~~ r:pi¥J:JmmiW:.~J5M~r*i¥J1§'~m~.t1~~.J.~i¥J~~~ •• M~oM~~m •• M~~i¥J~ •• ~~o~~.-M--1J).~~-t-.1t * J1t 't Ai 6? ' 0 ••• ~.~ •• ~~~JZ. ~.J.1~i¥J0~'I:i •• ' 1J~~' -Ei'f1ti¥JW!±frn~ ? -Ei'f1t8"J~rs'-Hfr ' -Ei'f1t8"J:Jmm~{Ji~-Ei'lft~~i¥J~!fo/. t1G1rH~\~7t.7i~.tJJJ. . IZSJLlt -Ei'f1ti¥J:Jmm~~1:E~~Zr:p ' .~ •• ~7~~~~Wi¥Jm.t~av~.J -Ei'f1ti¥J:Jmm~1§'WF!J~.-av#.J.1:E~tt.-Ei'f1tW!±fri¥Jim*Eim:$~]!~~tEi¥J ( :ih/ji@ji¥J~~:¥.ijt~~ J:.ijt1tav •#iJj1~v' 'f*.t*.a~rnT~~ )1D.llQ#I-&Jt~~"iIil.~~'~.ff.~'.ijtav~~..?M. -5Eij§1'fJ:!jJfJt1r~ji-?fl!itm-Ei'f1t:Jmm .P1r.6? . tf-*-~ 355 Jf) 0 :ih/ji@jl¥J~~ r:pi¥J:Jmm) .~~. 0 ~.f.ijtav~~~~.~. -Ei'lft i¥J:Jmm)lfJt~-Ei'f1ti¥J~~ :ih/ji@j1~1r~i¥J~*.1'P~~~ji?f!tf.t "fvAi!L1IJl it JJI.jH.!2 ~r "-it 00oj>" .#.~WII~~¥]jU&.l~Jl!..~~~:l:l~-.ijt.±~~~av-*~.JZ.

John. Blake. Hughes. North Carolina: The University of North Carolina Pess. Lewis Mumford: Public Intellec- tual. chapel Hill. Spring. Agatha ~~. Dovey. Mumford Remembered. 1987. Castells. 1983. 1988. Cities of Tommorrow. Thomas sity Press. Design Book Review. 1986.f~: -Etr!fft±wrtiffJiGiHUz= Bender. Hughes and C. 14-19. New Jersey: Princeton Filler.~ 0 York Intellectual. Richard. 1990. New York: Oxford Univer- . Martin. Oxford: Basil Blackwell. Hall. 12-16. No. eds. The City and the Grassroots. and Agatha C. Design Book Review. Casey. Planning in the Public Domain: From Knowledge to Action. 1990. New Knopf. Zeitgeistbusters : A Mandate for Architectural Critics. Kim. No. University Press. Ingersoll. 1992. 1987. Berkeley and Los Angeles: The University of California Press.9.. Princeton. Thomas. Blake. eds. Beloved Community. "The Perile of Personality: and Politics after Liberalism". P.184 X~:IL MmfL ' 1992 ' (E-'rnl!frt~> ' -Et. Manuel. The Bond and Bondage of Place Attachment. Lewis Mumford: Public Intellectual. New York: Oxford University Press. New York: Lewis Mumford in Thomas P. 1990. Hughes. 19. Hughes. Casey. Peter. 1990b. Friedmann. 283-300. 1990a.

Elmer. Proceedings: Vol. Design Book Review. eds. 19. Thomas. No. Mumford: A Life. 207-08. Lewis Marmaras. 1990. No. 1971. 11-14 Morley. 1990 Lewis Mumford's From the Belly of Regionalism. 66-99. 1986. Miller. 19.. New on the Weidenfeld & Nicholson. The Lewis Mumford Reader. Miller. Abrams. Mumford Versus Giedion: Review- ing the Machine Age. Rev. 1990. No. 1914 -1970. 1988. Lewis Mumford: A Bibliography Subject of Lewis Mumford. V. Donald L. Hughes and Agatha Public Intellectual. Lefaivre. New York: Hareourt Tafuri. 57. Liane and Alexander Tzonis. 1990. . of Lewis Mumford: Public IntelReview. McClay. Design book Review. American Scholar. Modern Archi- tecture. No. John. Donald L. Design Book Review. New Press. No. Stretching A Convass of Possibilities: 30-32. and Francessco Brace Jovanovich. 19. Stanislaus. in Thomas P. Robert. 20-25. New York: Harry N. Lewis Mumford. Chalkidili. Vol. Manfredo. July. Design Book Review. lAPS 12 Internationa I Conference. eds. Winter. Lewis Mumford: the Whale. Lewis Mumford: York: Oxford University Von Moos.. 25-30. Wilfred M. Town Planning Note.61. 1979. Benton MacK aye. Wojtowicz. 1989. and the Regional Vision. New York: York: Pantheon Books... 1991. C. 132-137. Lewis Mumford: A Memorial lectual. Greece. 22. No. 65-67. Hughes. eds.2. Newman.Euroscape Symposia. 1990. 111-117. Dal Co. Jane.

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful