This action might not be possible to undo. Are you sure you want to continue?
Domination, Language and Popular Resistance in Egypt: A critical reflection on the current revolution
By Danny Jacobs Independent Study John Raines Religion Department Temple University March 29, 2011
In the past few months, the world has witnessed a string of revolutions in North Africa and the Middle East that has shattered both Western misconceptions of the region s values and spread a feeling of revolutionary possibility that has reverberated around the world. At the time of this writing, popular uprisings in Tunisia and Egypt have led to increasingly escalating protests in Yemen, Libya, Bahrain and Gabon. To many in the West, these events have seemed either unexpected because the ruling hegemony appeared stable by Western norms1or purposely instigated by radical, religious sects to establish an authoritarian theocracy.2 What we have missed in our assumptions has been the hidden transcripts of those who have been oppressed. Behind the public formalities of the subordinate class has been a buried dialogue of resistance and organization. What we are witnessing now has been rehearsed in the minds and private dialogue of the oppressed for quite some time.3 For the people of these countries, these protests aren t new or inspired by a political elite but the public expression of the aggregate of individual struggles and stories. To analyze this exciting time, I am calling on the theories of sociologist Pierre Bourdieu and political theorist James Scott to explain both the processes of acquiescence & restraint as well as domination & resistance. Each concludes that no matter how objective and impenetrable an image of power presents of itself, the ability to overcome prevails because the ultimate source of power presides in us. This does not imply that structural constraints don t play a role in limiting or influencing agency. Instead, both scholars seek to transcend the traditional structure vs. agency debate, towards a more fluid concept where a
Mazel, Zvi. Tunisia First Popular Uprising in Arab World. Jerusalem Post. 17 January 2011. Web. 18 February 2011. <http://www.jpost.com/>. 2 Wheeler, Scott. One Nation Under Islam. Big Peace. 19 February 2011. Web. 20 February 2011. <http://bigpeace.com>.
Scott, James C. Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1990. Print. 8
structure exists but is voluntarily indoctrinated; Bourdieu calls this the internalization of externality.
I will begin by detailing their schemas of human interaction and then apply them to the modern history of Egypt, going back as far as Napoleon s colonization of Egypt. The goal of this paper is to achieve more than simply post-hoc analysis of the current wave of revolutions in the Middle-East but to try to answer or at least improve our comprehension of much broader questions: Why do revolutions take place? What social and linguistic structures create the authority needed to rule? Can these be resisted? And finally, why did the Western world specifically bureaucrats in Washington - miss the revolutionary atmosphere boiling in the region? My approach is to synthesize both these methods, incomplete by themselves, to provide a fuller understanding of why and where domination happens and, how constraints are imposed that appear invisible to the eye of the outside spectator. I conclude that it is the marginalization of people in more than one space economic, political, cultural, etc that allows power to create a hyperbolized image of its strength and authenticity to hide its true dependency on subordination. Finally, I explore the way in which a popular democracy could be used to both to break free from self-oppression and to establish a new identity.
Bourdieu and Markets How can years of small, daily resistance infrapolitics
so effectively avoid
sending the signals of impending revolution? World focus on other issues (the Recession) could be argued to have drawn attention away from the case at hand but even had someone observed the Middle-East for several months leading up to the revolution, it would be very possible that this could still go unnoticed. A country
Bourdieu, Pierre. The Logic of Practice. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1990. Print. 45 Scott. Domination and the Arts of Resistance. 19
assessment report by from September 2010 stated that despite tension over who would succeed Mubarak, there was no threat present that could seriously destabilize the regime and that the ruling party would continue to hold power in face of what was considered legitimate oppostion.6 Credit for this veil does not lie entirely in the ability Egypt s leaders to control their subordinates but also in the subordinates tendency to censor themselves. It is here that Pierre Bourdieu s analysis can explain this phenomenon. Bourdieu s system of language and interaction is analogous to that of an economic market. As we interact, we produce ideas, using our stock of social/cultural capital and then sell them on the market of dialogue for profit. In the same way that markets set prices by the forces of supply and demand, the situation and audience present during our speech sets the value of our spoken word. Speech that is favored in those conditions because of its social value, its correct use of dialect and/or the prestige that it carries, is valued highly on the market. That which steps outside of its bounds, tries too hard or violates any of the standards of the market is chastised, the producer being disciplined by suffering a symbolic loss one of respect in the eyes of others. The totality of these effects creates the habitus7 of a speaker, a sort of feeling and understanding of the market that guides what we say and how we say it, shaped by both past experiences and anticipated profit. 8 Thus, we learn when we can speak up and when we must restrain ourselves. Those whose habitus most accurately aligns with the market possess a power because they can more freely express themselves. In the eyes of those who
Economist Intelligence Unit. "Outlook for 2010-11: Political outlook." Country Report. Egypt (2010): 4-5. Business Source Premier. Web. 27 March 2011. 7 Bourdieu, Pierre. Language and Symbolic Power. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1991. Print. 123 8 Ibid. 76. For an analogy, think how an experienced investor buys stock they appear to possess a sixth sense that guides their choices.
struggle in the field, this appears inherent.9 The effect of this is exponential; those with lots of cultural capital speak/act in a way that is more valued and therefore, accumulate reputation or symbolic capital amongst the public.10 Yet, because they gain more respect, their words hold more validity, so they can make even more profit in the field. This new factor symbolic capital - acts as a multiplier on the effectiveness
of the language used. The problem is that those who lack prestige such as the lower-class population- often experience a negative multiplier effect when they attempt to use more advanced language, barring them from the ability to move themselves up in the social hierarchy. Bourdieu terms those who step outside of their social place as petit bourgeois and describes their appearance as hypercorrective and anxious.11 The consequence of this is that those who do not possess the appropriate grasp of the dominant way of speaking can be minimized or even shut off from certain markets (silenced), and stripped of their ability to participate in a democracy.12 As one can now infer, control over the market trends is a locus for an exploration into what institutes domination. For Bourdieu, this control involves more than what is just said but also what is not said. Boundaries are situated not just by what positively confirms an identity but also what negates the same thing something that is unnameable in the sense that it isn t spoken of in a formal setting but is still tacitly recognized in the absence of its voice.13 The act of speaking about circumcision embodies this concept. Circumcisions do not divide groups between males that have had one and males that have yet to go through the procedure so much as they divide males as a sex from
Ibid. 94 Bourdieu. Language and Symbolic Power. 14 11 Bourdieu. Language and Symbolic Power 24 12 Ibid. 97 13 McCumber, John. Philosophy and Freedom: Derrida, Rorty, Habermas, Foucault. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2000. Print. 38
Print. they still define the form of the new proposal through familiar language. we may ask how do these markets arise? It is here where James Scott s brilliant concepts of power can be utilized.14 However. Eds. which does include a neutral word for lesbian. Bristol. Otherwise. 66 16 Khayatt.16 This is in stark contrast with Didi s meeting with a group of women from the upper-class of Egypt who spoke classical Arabic (and many spoke English or French). Schecter. Philosophy and Freedom. something that is felt but suppressed through the enunciation of the act because it does not characterize their identity. who only speak colloquial Arabic. 2003. Didi.17 By having a word which could explain their feelings as an identity. we will most likely confuse our audience and possibly look insane. Even when someone introduces new meanings for old vocabulary like a Richard Rorty ironist. What she finds is that there is a significant difference in behavior between lesbians from the upper class and lower classes. Language and Symbolic Power. Terms of Desire: Are there any Lesbians in Egypt? Language and Socialization in Bilingual and Multilingual Societies.18 Still.15 Didi Khayatt has written about her experience searching for a lesbian in Egypt. Bourdieu. We can only signify something else if the other concept has a way of being located in the lexicon of the market. UK: Multilingual Matters. because of their access to certain language. 223 18 Ibid. Robert Bayley and Sandra R. 228 15 14 . mussahaqah. there doesn t exist a word for lesbian (at least not as a value-free identity she mentions that there is a derogatory word similar to faggot that is used). 118 McCumber. Amongst the lower classes. the women felt that they belonged to the same group and felt permitted to openly engage in intimate behaviors. the development of this sexual identity and the confidence to have this sexuality has been subdued as perverted in this lower-class.Jacobs 6 women. and thus. I believe Bourdieu leaves something out. 218-219 17 Ibid.
Scott specifically mentions how both those who hold power and those who are subordinate must act or perform in public essentially. the more burdensome the public transcript has become on their lives. Borrowing once again from economic terminology. in a way. 19 20 Scott. we can say that the discursive black market is indicative of the level of repression. can be a quantitative measure of oppression. Often that which is said by people of similar ranking holds more candor than more heterogeneous spaces of interaction. Scott s contribution shows how the markets are created. the image of a perfectly in-tuned habitus might be a façade. As Scott shows. 20 the spectrum of open communication can still be applied to this analysis. Thus. much of the elite choreograph their performances in public and in doing so. The more those dominated have to hide. leaving them to plan retaliation in their hidden transcripts.19 While Scott s description of interaction might seem conflicting at first because of its claim that sociological relations are divided only between the hidden vs public transcript as opposed to markets.Jacobs 7 Scott and Resistance James Scott analysis of domination and resistance focuses on the gap between what is said and done in public (hegemonic) settings versus what actors say while in settings that allow them to speak their mind more freely (private). even the most powerful are dominated by the nature of their relations. The best way of adapting his system to Bourdieu s is to view it as the difference between markets inhabited by hegemonic powers and those by the underclass. correct or euphemize. Domination and the Arts of Resistance. impose speech markets in favor of their behavior and accent. In fact. 5 . The difference in openness between these two transcripts. Contrary to Bourdieu s. which force them to uphold an image of finesse. 12 Ibid.
if they succeed. meaning that the elite class owns the material basis of production [And] the means of symbolic production.23 Violent revolution can still happen within the dominant ideology. power blinds itself by its own myth. the first sign of an uprising comes in the tendency for rebels to test the limits of public sphere.24 Still this begs the question is amelioration of material and political conditions enough to set one free? In his critique of Nietzsche s concept of freedom. it remains narrow in its scope. 78 24 Ibid. use of strategic naivety basically pretending to be a fool who couldn t possibly be planning something more sinister to deflect attention is often utilized. It is possible that one of the determining factors for why the revolutions in the Maghreb were so successful was because it was commonly believed that such uprisings would never happen in that region and thus. Heidegger claims that Nietzsche fails to really go anywhere because he is trapped in Ibid. however. act as de facto proof that such actions are acceptable and an escalation of tests soon begins. if any of these actions appears suspicious. Scott mentions the peasant s of the French revolution never expressed a wish to abolish the Monarchy but simply their wish for reforms within the system. Domination and the Arts of Resistance.22 These public statements.Jacobs 8 One of Scott s most useful contributions is his explanation of how revolutions come about. Acts that are seen as dangerous to the hierarchy are immediately attacked and made an example of to the public. 192 Ibid. Furthermore. if hegemony existed. then it becomes impossible for a revolution from below to happen without any external tremor.21 Such actions can include things such as making a back-handed compliment. Usually. For Scott. signs that could have been taken as warning signs were disregarded. grumbling under one s breath or using symbolism in arts to make political statements. Scott s system differs from Bourdieu s also in his rejection of hegemony. 197 23 Scott. 77 21 22 .
Echoing the importance of controlling the dominant style of speech. Print. Syracuse. The New Mamluks: Egyptian Society and Modern Feudalism. NC: Duke University Press. A local cleric.Jacobs 9 the inheritances of his German language ultimately. 39 27 Cole. 2000. they continued to oppress themselves with traces of colonial thought even when they control the means of cultural and symbolic production. his thoughts as well. The judiciary soon adopted Napoleonic code as well as French legal thought. Napoleon s Egypt: Invading the Middle East. Philosophy and Freedom. Juan. Egypt s history too displays this trap. The upper-educated elite of Egypt McCumber. Abd al-Rahman al-Jabarti. 32. he handed out pamphlets declaring that he was a servant of God and an admirer of the prophet Mohammed. Liberalism without Democracy. Print. 2006. Egypt: Desire for the Other Through Mimicry and Language When Napoleon first colonized Egypt in the 18th century.29 The judicial system also became characterized as possessing a large amount of French lawyers. Print. the French did manage to establish a prominent influence on Egypt. 2007. Maghraoui. 6. his plan embarrassingly backfired. Abdeslam M. 26 25 Sonbol. 26 While clearly trying to win over the people of Cairo so that they should accept him as a liberator who freed them from the Ottomans. Despite eventually reaching physical independence. 69 29 . we see here how even those with physical power can fall victim to linguistic pitfalls.25 One may change their position in the field but remain confined by the same fence. New York: Syracuse University Press. Durham. Amira El Azhary. New York.28 Despite their quick expulsion.27 The pamphlets were dismissed as cartoonish and Napoleon became enraged. It is here that we begin to see the creation of Egypt s elite class and the lingering effect of Western thought on Egypt. NY: Palgrave Macmillan. his ideas must conform to hegemonic tools of expression and thus. mocked the pamphlet for his poor grammar and obvious lack of stylistic norms.
32 Maghraoui. 31 30 .32 The reason behind this was articulated as removing leftover Turkish influence but it is quite clear that they wished to be recognized and praised by Europe as a modern country. now under British rule. The New Mamluks. The Transformation of the Egyptian Elite: Prelude to the Urabi Revolt. 21. This is taken from Rodenbeck quoting E. Paul and Janet Starkey. 94. 91 36 Brown. The Conspiracy of Silence and the Atomistic Political Activity of the Egyptian Peasantry. the march of European innovation [Had] become a gallop. Eds.36 Still. cattle poisoning and murder existed prior to the revolt but because they were done by individual peasants.30 Peasants were uprooted and their communal land privatized. NY: M. Lane wrote about the reforms.Jacobs 10 went to France (and later England) to study law and were highly influenced European Classical liberalism.E. 84.35 The peasant support for this revolution did not come out of nowhere. 34 Rodenbeck. In 1879. Print. incidents of vandalism. Dressing Native Unfolding the Orient :Travellers in Egypt and the Near East. Vol. 35 Sonbol. the government repeatedly pushed through reforms that mimicked the structure of European countries.31 while religious institutions were centralized and purged of their traditional behavior. as E. the atmosphere created by these escalating acts had the ability to effectively unite those 34 Maghraoui. Liberalism without Democracy. 1989. Nathan. especially under Muhammad Ali (1805-1848) and Khedive Ismail (1863-1879).W. Liberalism without Democracy.Ed. The New Mamluks. 43 Sonbol. Sharpe. 1882-1952. they lacked both the legitimacy of elite resistance and enough organization to scare those on top. Reading: Ithaca. During the 19th century. This change happened without any foreign. Print. Colburn. 93.. 2001. 1997: 328. Ibrahim. Armonk.W Lane. The Middle East Journal. No. 3. 19 February 2011. we begin to see one of the first public expressions of peasant resistance to this foreign imperialism during what came to be known as the Urabi Revolt (named after the soldier Urabi Pasha who led the resistance). aggressive pressure. Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance. Forest D.33 The European influence was also exhibited by the new rulers in their dress a change to the frock-coats characteristic of Western European rulers. Web. John. 42 33 Abu-Lughoud.
38 In an article by the experience with this phenomenon during the Urabi Revolt: We may be justified in denying to the passions of the multitude the name of patriotism but a multitude of facts have made plain to us that neither the peasants of Egypt nor the Bedouins regard our presence in the country with great complacency. 28 March 2011. 91-92 41 Maghraoui.41 Despite 37 38 Scott. 40 Sonbol. Domination and the Arts of Resistance. 54 anchester Times from 1882. Manchester Times 1288 (September 16. Web. 222 Ibid. made up of officers in the Egyptian army. The use of a tactical smile has become the preferred method of deference by many of the soon-to-revolt population hoping to calm the nerves of their ever anxious superiors. the poison of the asps in their hearts. were more concerned with receiving equal pay and privilege as the foreign members in the same service. Nearly four decades later. Under pressure by Saad Zaghul and members of the nationalist Wafd party. 19th Century British Library Newspapers. 1882): 4.39 Despite popular support for Urabi Pasha. another revolt breaks out in 1919. They may smile approvingly with festivities with which we celebrate our victories in Alexandria or Cairo but although their words may be softer than butter.40 This would not be the first time that the peasant class is betrayed by a bourgeois revolution. an unknown journalist illuminates their . 3 39 Summary of the Week.37 What is particularly interesting is how the rise in the feeling of resentment that a colonizer feels is often balanced by an increase in displays of complacency by the subordination. which included peasants giving what little money they had to the rebels. The revolting elite. the leaders of the Urabi revolt held remarkably different views than that of the peasants. the British granted independence to Egypt but only under the condition that British help write the constitution and that the Zaghul and his followers not gain power.Jacobs 11 who were previously independent of one another.
Nearness does not literally mean which is physically near to but that which is near to our true character. suppressed other non-Western narratives of identity and development. The binary of West/Orient. incest taboo) and be accepted into the social order or. . acts simply acts by 42 McCumber. New York. this is the definition of a sociopath. Comparing Egypt to an infant. Print.43 the false dilemma created by the intellectuals of the time concerning what Egypt can and cannot be.42 the Egyptian intelligentsia sought to establish themselves as closer to the Europeans than to that of the ArabOriental character. 1980.). 2007.Jacobs 12 claiming sovereignty. embraced by the Egyptian elite. 45 Maghraoui. Liberalism without Democracy. Thus. as an infant develops its identity. Everyday Economic Practices: The Hidden Transcripts of Egyptian Voices. the Egyptians. Print. New York. The Interpretation of Dreams. Savvina A. Much like how Martin Heidegger favored nearness as the requirement for authenticity. 34. where a boy infant seeks to be with his mother and kill his father (For more. According to Lacan. sought to purge themselves of their Orient image and create a new one that was much closer to the Europeans. by using revisionist science and history. Of course. see Sigmund Freud.e. NY: Routledge Press. 43 Chowdhury. imprisoned them in the narratives of Europe and in doing so. tried to prove that the European or Greek heritage was closer to their true being than the Arab character. Philosophy and Freedom.44 It is here that the child can to do one of two things: either they can accept their Father s presence and the law that comes with it (i. they can reject the father (and the norms) due to its desire to be with the Mother and fail to assimilate into society. NY: Avon publishing. 20. Abdeslam Maghraoui reads this situation through the lens of Jacques Lacan. the new khassa (the ruling class who promoted Egypt s new European liberalism).45 For Lacan. 5 44 This is the classic Oedipal Drama. meaning one who cannot understand social norms by themselves and instead. still unable to disconnect its body from that of its Mother. they only ended up conforming themselves to Western norms. it comes to a stage of tension between it and its Father. blocked any chance to establish an original identity. while striving for this individuality and demarcation from the Arab world.
The revival of Ancient Egyptian culture worked not just because it linked Egypt to Europe but because it distanced them from the Arab/Islamic culture at the time. 69 46 . 47 Maghraoui. its former Mother.48 Relics of Ancient Egypt were also re-examined to determine their true nature by the Western-influenced elite to prove that Egyptians were in fact. Ancient Egyptians were considered Greek and were also not Muslim. For example. Salama Musa published an archeological report claiming to prove that that ancient Egyptians and ancient British shared similar bone structure and thus. this scientific proof was widely accepted and further encouraged by those on top. 75 51 Ibid.47 Their denial of their inability to ever become fully European only pushed the elite of Egypt to the point that they tried to destroy any trace of their true self. Empty Gestures and Performatives: Lacan Confronts the CIA Plot. NY: W & W Norton. Slavoj.50 The intellectuals of the time continued their conquering of the Egyptian identity. both by denouncing local activities antagonistic to European culture. this revival appears to be a celebration of Egypt s rich cultural history but upon further inspection. indigenous Egyptian culture) in favor of becoming part of Europe. 78 49 Ibid. such as mawalids or traditional celebrations. 80 50 Ibid.Jacobs 13 logical calculation. 98 52 Ibid. the late 19th century and early 20th century is known as the period of the Pharaonic revival movement in Egypt. European. Print. declaring the historical boundaries of Egypt. the meaning becomes clear. Maghraoui contends that Egyptians wanted to be European so badly that they rejected the Father (in this case. Far from being rejected as ludicrous. In 1928. 2007. 36 48 Ibid. shared the same ancestry.46 To use the extended metaphor. New York. as social illness 51 or. How to Read Lacan. Liberalism without Democracy.49 At first. so as to homogenize all the ethnic groups found within the borders as Egyptian.52 Zizek.
The New Mamluks 217 McCumber. Nasser s period in time is interesting because it appears to break itself from European influence. Feminist Studies Vol 36. 55 The cultural hierarchy was transformed only in image and language but retained its same values. Philosophy and Freedom.54 Still. 54 Maghraoui. he spoke using fusha or classical Arabic. knew its true essence. No. Print. When President Nasser spoke to the elite-intellectual crowd. he changed his dialect to ammiya or the colloquial slang used by the working class. 2010: 404-432. public intellectuals began to refer to themselves as Eastern.53 Like the revolutions prior.57 What the privileged leaders of Egypt did in this era was seek to validate their view of the Being of Egypt to the point that they. When he would speak to the amma. the khassa. Laura. different from American and European citizens.56 The divisions had not only remained but where further deepened. This is based on Aristotle s theory of being.Jacobs 14 In 1952. for example. Gamal Nasser comes to power under a coup d etat promising change. popular support for the revolution came from the anti-colonial protests that had preceded Nasser s insurgency. above the lower classes. all in the name of creating modern citizenry. The same backwardness that was criticized by earlier intellectuals was attacked by Nasser s regime. this new feeling of Pan-Arabism inspired only a superficial demarcation and really signified the Soviet Union s temporary influence. 7-8. Citizenship and the Regulation of Reproduction in Postwar Egypt. They set the boundaries of the country (territory both physical and Bier.2. Liberalism without Democracy. during a streak of economic crisis and political instability. disposition (control over its boundary). and initiative (who and what is legitimate). . What we see in the 20th century is the elite class of Egyptians seeking to claim three characteristics over Egypt s Being its physical boundaries. 406 56 57 Sonbol. 415-416 55 53 Ibid. from peasants that were once again rejecting what they saw as the unfair imposition of an outside influence. The Family is a Factory : Gender.
the amma made it clear that they were not dominant. that which is signified through the use of a specific dialect can be used to neutralize resistance and retain hegemony. This third factor was determined by the structures of Egyptian language.59Arabic was seen as a coarse and crude language only used by the underclass. This divergence can and has been exploited to maintain hegemony. Egyptians could receive higher-education. 61 When the common press lauded Mubarak s use of these popular idioms. established the law (disposition) and determined who voices counted (initiative). excluded those who did not have the privilege to attain such ability. the recently ousted President Hosani Mubarak was praised by many of the working class for his grasp of the peasant language.Jacobs 15 cultural). which was favored by universities and entrepreneurs. one can say that this requirement to speak acceptable French/English was a barrier to entry into the dominant market and thus.60 This skill wasn t something mastered by Mubarak to show his cultural knowledge it is instead an approach to reification that Bourdieu calls the strategies of condescension. Yet access to this education was only available to a few. 90 60 Ibid. Language and Symbolic Power. 216 Ibid. make military connections or grasp the arts and culture of the Western world. 218 61 Bourdieu. Borrowing from economics à la Bourdieu. the language spoken by the elites of Egypt was either French. By mastering these foreign languages. Egypt s class structure has been reinforced by its use of language. The New Mamluks. a fact that he flaunted. 68 58 59 . because the Sonbol. which they considered the language of prestige and sophistication 58 or English. Like most former colonies. Indeed. Up until Nasser. they didn t just end up praising Mubarak but also tacitly recognized their position in the country s hierarchy. By acknowledging that Mubarak was using their common dialect.
Even more so. they would most likely be chastised as a petit bourgeois or tryhard because they lack the years of training that the khassa posses. Power.62 If a member of the lower class attempted to speak classical Arabic.relationships of power do not necessarily open up the avenue for the lower-class. 202 66 Ibid. a group endows the person with a symbolic Skeptron. People who submit to power do so because they believe it exists. 192 63 62 . however. he argues. Instead. Formal and informal education.63 Fear of this sanction alone limits many attempts to learn the dominant dialect. It is important to realize that the praise for knowledge of the dialect of the underclass would not have been given had a peasant worker got on TV and made a speech in ammiya they would be ridiculed for lack of sophistication or just ignored. by pretending to negate the hierarchy through the use of common language a symbolic negation Mubarak actually got the public to acquiesce to the structure of relations. 64 Ibid . Mubarak is symbolically speaking down to them.66 By delegating one individual to the position of authority. isn t one party dominating the other but is in fact a product of a constant circular relationship one is dominated by both an authority and themselves. allowing the whole A peasant speaking fusha might appear as superficial.Jacobs 16 dominant dialect did not appear. In effect. This distinction between those who can speak freely and those who are silent becomes so great that the dominant s ability to make returns on the market seems to be based on the qualities of the person alone. a reversal of this class privilege would not be possible. 72 65 Ibid. 62. the expected loss of misspeaking outweighs the expected profit. 64 Control over who gets credit is powerful and Bourdieu expands upon this by introducing the idea of Political Fetishism 65. Bourdieu. Language and Symbolic Power. rather than the underlying social relations. leaders only exist because of a group treating them as dominant figures.
cultural and symbolic barriers do not just show themselves in antagonistic situations. Mubarak referred to himself as the father whose children wanted to become orphans in other words. <http://www. This relationship becomes full-circle when we realize that it is in this act. and ergo. that launches them to the a celebrity-like standing in front of the group and gives them credit for great outcomes. positions of power are explained by features that appear internal to the dominator i. exploits itself for its own symbolic profit. during the recent uprisings. Since individuals fail to recognize their role in creating a power. Ibid.69 Unfortunately. What I don t see at the Revolution. 11 March 2011. Specifically. sharp wit. 68 67 .Web.vanityfair. a former military man. The New Mamluks. in 2004 there was the start of the Kefeya Movement in Egypt (means enough ). The performance of power one individual representing the feelings of an amount of people that would be physically impossible. a group made up of radical socialists and Nasserites basically university intellectuals who come from middle-class backgrounds. 68 meaning guardian. Looking at recent history we see that there have been several attempts to revolt in Egypt in the last 7 years alone. One of the biggest criticisms of the movement was its inability to connect with those outside of its own circle. In this case.Jacobs 17 group to be legitimized and heard in political or formal situations. it appears to them as objective and external. that the group is named and created. the group produces its own symbolic capital and. the act of speaking for a group.67 Essentially. Interestingly. March 2011. unless granted gives the Skeptron a magical property. Any attribute can be hyperbolized to justify the relationship. Mubarak. Christopher. Slate. 190 69 Hitchens. the revolutionaries are misbehaving and should listen to their moral but compassionate superior. 207 Sonbol. etc.e they possess great enthusiasm. maintained the nickname holder of the wilaya. it was his military background that was used as defense of his role. but in mutual ones as well.com/>.
digging out of the poverty of the past. What we are witnessing now is a cumulative representation of the hidden angst held by the Egyptian people over the last century and a half. 12 July 2006. 70 The lack of connection is the result of a huge cultural chasm between the classes the use of intellectual. xxiii 72 Ibid. pressure from the bottom still has the ability to chip away at those norms under the noses of the elites.net/>. <http://www. even though it shared a similar objective. Domination and the Arts of Resistance. This group essentially isolated itself off from lower classes with lower cultural capital. In fact. 71 Scott. whereas rural peasants tend to resort to saying turath [or] adat or heritage and customs. To rule Egypt is to rule against the background of these expectations and disappointments Egyptians are not blind to what has befallen their country.72 While it is unwise to point to specific events as being the final catalysts for a revolution.The 70 Osman. Egypt s Phantom Messiah. something one could call the safety-valve breaking.71 While those with resources have an advantage. They can see the booming lands in Asia.Jacobs 18 leading critics to label it as a group of intellectuals screaming and shouting in public forums and magazines. the intellectual crowd has been known to use the word thaqafa or high culture. Web. Egypt in particular has had a history of being dominated by multiple colonizers but also a history of resistance.opendemocracy.. 178 . One of these circumstances can be a general feeling of frustration. Tarek. we can point to conditions that tend to incentivize action.. 18 March 2011. Marxist language like class consciousness and commodity fetishism simply does not spark interest in the minds of rural peasants. Open Democracy. as Fouad Ajami points out: Dreams of national power and deliverance visited Egypt no less than four times in its recent history and they all ended in frustration This is part of the country s self-image. there is a difference in their word for culture. countries that were once poorer than Egypt.
The force at which a group of people can strike back with is extraordinary when they are pushed to their emotional edge. For one. Extraneous direct oppression is not only futile but often counter-productive to establishing dominant hegemony. Fouad. the hopes for revolution from above. 74 Maghraoui. Theda Skocpol influential theory from her seminal piece State and Revolution states that the prerequisites for a successful revolution are internal economic inequality and 73 Ajami. 5 . 74. imprisonment) has the ability to force an objective truth upon the subordinate. but in reality. kicked out foreign rule. Foreign Affairs. 74 In an optimistic sense.Jacobs 19 dreams of liberal reform. one does not feel this emotion when encountering the failures of those we see as oppressors but instead. While the Egyptians. 83-84.73 Take heed of Ajami s use of the word disappointment. No. 1995: 72-88. they often failed to realize that their own fiascos were the result of their tendency to [embrace] colonial culture and subject themselves to the norms of the West. One might argue that coercive action (violence. the subordinate must still come to the conclusion by themselves. The Sorrows of Egypt. This is something of which is aggressively concealed as knowledge of this can prove hostile to dominant hegemony. Vol. the implication for all of this is that domination is just as much a product of the slave as it is the master. Liberalism without Democracy. 18 March 2011. something felt when one sees the letdowns of those we identify with ourselves. Pg. From Mimicry to Revolution Several theories behind what causes the start of revolutions exist and their still is probably plenty missing if we were to combine all of them. 5. the socialist bid of Nasser [have] all withered away. Web.
Web. do not take these events as final causes in their own but more as cases of larger antagonisms showing themselves. populations will often acquiesce to political repression in order to maintain their living standards. any rebellion can easily be put down with help from outside military forces. 7. then wouldn t one would expect revolutions in many other countries outside of the immediate region?77 Skocpol s argument is strong but incomplete. Theda.org/>. I am sure we will learn of more events that changed the momentum and do not want to limit the scope. if international bonds remain strong. Instead. Egypt. XI 75 . 7 March 2011. see Carl Robinson. 13 March 2011. State and Revolution. Informed Comment. Kusha: Iran vs. this is reminiscent of Egypt. as I argue. On the other hand. but also an attempt to restore autonomy and dignity. <http://www.) 78 Scott. if this was the case. 78 The problem is many times this second objective is only acquired by those who gain power. Why Vietnam Won t Fall. As the days of the revolution continue. Yet. <http://www. Revolt is not the product of simply material domination. Vol.juancole. (For an example. 77 Egypt s economic condition is comparable to other countries. Web.com/>. leading to the despondency that has plagued Egypt. it is also resisted and overthrown along multiple avenues. Theory and Society. No. 1 March 2011. 1979: 7-95. 76 Sefat. 8.Jacobs 20 external pressure from stronger countries. 11 March 2011. Domination and the Arts of Resistance. Skocpol.worldpolicy. we must add our insights from both Bourdieu and Scott to understand. Kusha. World Policy Blog. I will support my theory that certain conditions strongly influenced the outbreak of this revolt through various examples. For Kusha Sefat. However. that because domination happens along multiple spaces.76 Sefat argues that the recent recession in the United States limited its ability to step in and control the uprising and that this only irritated the social chasm. Web. that also are facing international pressure. as discussed.2. 15 March 2011. possesses both a defined class gap and a large dependency on foreign influence. Egypt: Qualitative Differences in Capabilities.75 Without economic problems. like Vietnam.
On its own. 79 . it is perhaps not enough because if one accepts a system. 1998: 91-112. today. In the past few decades.79 Yet. Economic Reform. a relic of the Pharaohs who named that area after the direction in which The Nile flowed as well as a way of distinguishing their hierarchical order. as one can just choose to not participate and live tolerably. Dominant figures who denigrate often do so in a manner that situates them but still convinces them their interests lie in maintaining the hierarchy. the villages surrounding the historical sites of Ancient Egypt have become booming tourism industries. 14 March 2011. Since the liberalization of the tourist industry under Sadat. this area is called Upper Egypt. rather than provoke a pronounced responses. 34. Matthew. but it is a tactic that is used only to distract the population. tourism is the largest source of foreign income in Egypt and an economic heavyweight for Egypt.Jacobs 21 Humiliation A general feeling of cynicism amongst populations has been subtly encouraged by those seeking to retain status-quo throughout history. a very recent example of state-instituted degradation illuminates the view of the recently ousted Egyptian government on its own people. Humiliation. which has played an important role in most histories of authoritarian oppression. Surprisingly. Middle Eastern Studies Vol. Web. While examples of Egyptian intellectuals belittling the poor and rural of Egypt have already been mentioned. No. then they will shift the blame to themselves. It is not enough merely to evoke distrust. In fact. beneath this gain Gray. Privatization and Tourism in Egypt. 2. the Southern part of Egypt has developed an extensive tourism industry. What set s something off is the instance an individual decides they are willing to die to maintain their dignity. is the ingredient which is often combined with this misery to produce open displays of struggle. it is home to some of the poorest population of Egypt.
82 Bryce. ed. 7. has relocated the people living around the historical landmarks of Ancient Egypt from their houses so that the industry could expand. Egyptian authorities claimed that the residents of the area were destroying valuable artifacts that did not belong to them. the indigenous residents have received very little of the gains. 89 Abu-Laghoud. Tourist Studies Vol. they have become dominated not only by lacking a voice or presence in the political and economic realms but by being treated like animals. As the economy has boomed in the area. what remains a legitimate object of culture is what appeals to Western desires and tastes. Television and The Virtues of Education: Upper Egyptian Encounters with State Culture Directions of Change in Rural Egypt. the tourism industry of Egypt. Everyday Economic Practices. 162. Cairo: The American University Press. by creating separate transportation pathways everything from bus routes to walkways for the tourists to protect them from the indigenous masses. Such a factor.82 Even after all this modernization. golden pyramids and rich treasures rather than of the amma culture that surrounds the pyramids in towns like Luxor. Modern Egyptian resorts and tour packages repeatedly stress Pharoanic imagery in their advertising. but to world heritage. when tourists visit the local towns.83 For the people of these communities. more so than even Chowdhury. under the guidance of the World Bank. He is quoting a brochure from Sovereign Holidays. 81 The tourism industry of Egypt has also emphasized Western-influenced narratives and silenced others. they are often approached by beggars looking to receive something of what had been excluded from them. Hopkins.Jacobs 22 has been a policy of resentment towards the local people. Derek. 83 Chowdhury. 175. to the extent that they treat them almost like animals. The tourism industry has responded to this. No. Repacking Orientalism: Discourse in Egypt and Turkey on British outbound tourism.80 In a narrative similar to that taken by the liberals of the early 20th century. Nicholas S. Lila.2: 165-191. Print. For years. 112 81 80 . emphasizing Egypt as the land of royal tombs. with help from the Mubarak regime. Due to this. Print. Everyday Economic Practices.
a former slave. After being stripped of ownership of everything in their life. the members of the community have created an informal tourism sector. nobody can! Technological and Generational Change Besides the factor of humiliation. Dina. where they offer tours of their local houses and neighborhoods. 18 January 2011.Jacobs 23 conditions of economic depression. even if it means hurting themselves. Within several days of Mohammed Bouzazi selfimmolation in Tunisia. 11 March 2011. several individuals from Egypt followed suit. specifically in the form of self-immolation or selfmutilation.com/>. 86 . the self-harming protestor seeks to reaffirm themselves as the final causes of their existence. <http://www. became famous for mutilating himself with a knife in public to protest his slave-owner. things that can happen independently of outside pressure or rampant inequality.85 Cornish did not do this because he wanted a higher wage. in contrast to the artificial tour routes that are set-up by the resorts. Skocpol and other material theories miss the influence of both generational and technological change. Massachusetts: University of Massachusetts Press. he did this because he didn t want to be treated as property.reuters. 85 84 Zayed.84 Probably the most accurate indicator of wide-spread denigration is the presence of public suicide. To resist this. creates the circumstances for opposition. Egyptians set themselves ablaze after Tunisia unrest. Festivals of Freedom: Memory and Meaning in African American Emancipation Celebrations 1808-1905. Amherst. Mitch. 107. 118 Kachun. Print. It is well known in the field of economics that the power of adopting a new productive technology gives an Ibid. Reuters. Web. Sandy Cornish. 2006.86 The burning of one s body signaled the ultimate defiance of authority if I can t own my body. Self-harm protests domination because it expresses a sense of control.
2008. 24.87 the same holds true for technology in opening opportunities for revolutions. Egypt After Mubarak: Liberalism. For the leaders of the Middle-East. have the ability to overstep their reality and fall into catastrophe but their arrogance to realize they have lost their base often proves fatal. these can consist of anything from a military challenge to power. When Orwell finally confronts the elephant.89 It is not clear whether or not Orwell's audience. Oppressive regimes often encounter a series of critical junctures 88 during their reigns. The Parallax View. to a technological change. Scott borrows from George Orwell's essay Shooting an Elephant to explain this phenomenon. Print. would have behaved differently if he did not kill the elephant but their presence alone is enough to check his behavior. In the essay. 2006. he realizes that he not only has to kill the frightening elephant to avoid ridicule. Windows 98 in 1997: Is it wrong to borrow ideas? Bad Samaritans: The Secret History of Capitalism. 2007.90 Leaders too. Anything that gives the impression of weakness or naivety cracks the image of complete domination and invites largescale resistance. Cambridge. the Burmese villagers. UK: Bloomsbury Press. Slavoj.Jacobs 24 entrepreneur a head-start until the innovation diffuses throughout the market. 236. it was their failure to control the Chang. whether that is one of infallibility or omnipresence. Princeton. Print. 87 . Orwell relates an experience from his time as a colonizer in Burma. London. it is only once the cartoon looks down and realizes that it is walking on air that it falls down. but that he must play the role of power that he projects upon his subordinates. 88 Rutherford. Philosopher Slavoj Zizek metaphor for powers ability to fall describes a cartoon character walking off a cliff. Ha-Joon. 89 Scott. Print. 11 90 Zizek. MA: MIT Press. Bruce K. Islam and Democracy in the Arab World. A ruler s image and policy is put under public scrutiny during such a trialby-fire and it is up to them to prove that they still possess their mythical being. during which the local Burmese asked him to shoot an elephant that had killed several members of the tribe. he must live up to his own name. NJ: Princeton University Press.
Web. 72 93 Jay. such an event would appear insignificant but it energized the Egyptian youth so much. Kefaya helped to bring the hidden transcript to the public transcript.youtube. In itself. that they decided to Beaumont.guardian. 91 Mubarak.uk/>. The new technology opened the door for the hidden transcript but it did so. 29 January 2011. 91 . Following this step foward. While it was mentioned earlier as a failed movement.93 In early 2008. The Guardian. eventually leading to an estimated 800 labor strikes alone in the period of 20082009. Facebook and the uprisings in the Arab world. A declared refusal to comply is one of the key turning points in overthrow of a power relationship. something that exploited their word against them. Peter. Roots of the Revolutionary Egyptian Moment.com/>. Kefaya is an example of something that Mubarak would later regret. because it trapped the dictators under their own words.co. Both Mubarak in Egypt and Ben Ali in Tunisia attempted to block social networking but eventually backed off because they thought that banning it would cause more problems. Paul. Real News. as well as other dictators in the region. <http://www. 2007 and 2008 over wages in its industrial cities. <http://www. The Truth about Twitter. stressed during their reign that they were for liberalizing their countries both politically and economically but their promises ended up biting back.Jacobs 25 explosion of social networking. textile workers in El-Mahalla el-Kubra began striking in protest of the working conditions in the city. 11 March 2011. Everyday Economic Practices. 11 March 2011. 25 February 2011. Web. Egypt faced a series of labor strikes in 2006.92 Despite power knowing that it is in the position of dominance. because it dispels the myth of underclass fear of authority and becomes the first instance which alerts many outsiders. it will often try to dilute its public image of oppression so as to convince the general public that they have more freedom than they have in reality. 92 Chowdhury. Kefaya was not the only group to do so but part of a larger instance of Egyptians testing the public transcript.
the event disclosed that challenging this authority and winning reform was possible. 2008. <http://challengemag. 2008. 7 February 2011. Big Bang: Origin of the Universe. On April 6. In science. and thus. Challenge Magazine.96 much of their life has been met with escalating success. members of the future Egyptian Youth Movement created a Facebook page calling for all workers of Egypt to skip work for the day. Print. Egypt: The distance between democracy and social justice. Web. generational change often coincides with paradigm shifts because older scientists tend to have a more realist or conservative approach to new theories. 328. 95 Singh. NY: Fourth Estate. Time itself is often the enemy of power. Walter. as it continues it exposes more and more holes in the phantom of power s objectivity.cbsnews. 11 March 2011. Web. Yacov Ben. An individual s attitude towards power can play a partial but important role in its existence and as they come in contact with these gaps or exposures to freedom. They have seen new ideas come and go. New York. 17 March 2011. 96 . Simon. <http://www. Subordination is essentially a learned characteristic but one 94 Efrat. the memory of past failures has haunted the older demographic of Egypt but for the younger generation. Power relies on the people it dominates to hold it up. To sum it up. Laquer. in support of the striking workers in El-Mahalla el-Kubra. What blooms from this and other incidences is another important factor in influencing revolutions: generational change.com/>. as Simon Singh argues. Will Egypt s Youth Meet History s Challenge? CBSNews. are perhaps more cynical of so called revolutionary ideas.94 The immediate result was an increase in the minimum wage but more importantly.Jacobs 26 participate in solidarity with the workers.95 In a similar vein. 18 March 2011. they become hungry.com/>. of which make up around 65% of the population in the Middle-East. like pillars to the roof of a building.
Written by Himself: A New Critical Edition.Jacobs 27 that works the best when we feel that we are hardly secondary. Davis. instead of increasing my contentment.com/news/>.that whenever my condition was improved. . Print. Web. and Angela Y. scarcely. but my life. March 11.97 98 Douglass. Frederick. Bil. and in thinking of my life I almost forgot my liberty. 99. and set me thinking of my plans to gain my freedom. 98 Schorr. 2010. I have observed this in my experience of slavery. <http://cagle. an American Slave. 97 . San Francisco: City Lights Books. 2011. using his own experience as an example: I was kept in a perpetual wind of excitement. I could think of nothing. it only increased my desire to be free. 11 March 2011. Cagle Cartoons. Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass. 12 March 2011. Frederick Douglass described the power of this effect.
rather than put the blame on an individual. 18 March 2011. The EBA was concerned with creating an attractive market for foreign investment and competition. 99 The marginalization of the majority of citizens in Egypt has not just been the result of actions by the ruling government but the behavior of the opposition as well. despite pushing for various political reforms. which both marginalized a large portion of the population and deepened the tension between the classes. The colonial influence clearly remains today. The three strongest oppositions to Mubarak s the Judge s Club. The most recent events at the time of writing confirm the urge to reform all aspects of life. Both the Judge s Club and the EBA have been supporters of neo-liberal reform. Egypt s Cauldron of Revolt. the same ones who went on strike for a rise in wages in 2008. have now replaced the former statesponsored unions that existed at their factories. for different reasons. These protests weren t just responses to the authoritarian political rule but to the neo-liberal reforms that began in the. not just the removal of one person.100 whereas the Judge s Club is a relic of early 20th century elite liberalism. the Egyptian Businessmen s Association and the Muslim Brotherhood have expressed anti-popular politics for some time now. 32 . 100 101 Rutherford. 101 They have accepted the Western model of development as the only viable form of economy. <http://www. The workers in El-Mahalla el-Kubra. it is important that the people of the Middle-East achieve their goals. Domination and the Arts of Resistance.com/>. As one Egyptian worker put it.foreignpolicy. 210 Scott . James Scott calls this the Mark of Oppression. one of which I believe is the creation of democracy in both the political and economic realms. Web. we want an overthrow of this whole system. Foreign Policy Magazine. Anand.Jacobs 28 What can be done? For this to be a successful revolution. 16 February 2011. The protesters clearly see the structural flaws that oppress them. 99 Gopal.
agribusinesses. privatization of public services. 106 Chowdhury. they are for general public participation in elections but this is simply because it is their best route for attaining power. and Ruccio. 176. deregulation and floating of the country s currency. In reality. As the Structural Adjustment Plan. the Egyptian government had created the conditions for mass resistance and it was here that the Muslim Brotherhood. The program recommends many free-market reforms such as balancing the state budget. the MB has criticized democratic means as possessing the ability to quickly cause mass disorder amongst the public and hold the potential of disobeying the ethical precepts of Islam. (See Ha-Joon Chang. Bad Samaritans: The Myth of Free Trade and the Secret History of Capital. especially because they often criticize Western culture and claim some sort of populism. 235 105 This is a neo-liberal economic development program strongly recommended by the IMF/World Bank as a condition of receiving a short or long term loan. we see that it is the symptom of state policy.Jacobs 29 even when they claim opposition to the West and in the process.102 The Muslim Brotherhood is an even better example of this contradiction. if we look at why the MB and some of its militant followers have become generally popular. D. seeing 102 Gibson-Graham.106 One of the outcomes of these policies was the creation of large. 104 Ibid. Everyday Economic Practices. 2008). 127 107 Ibid. Eds. discredit alternative forms of development.107 In effect. 104 The position they take has become one where democracy is good if it elects their leaders but mob rule if it elects the opposition. In fact. their political values are more in line with the ruling NDP than that of the public. 2001. Print. 103 Rutherford 2008.K Graham-Gibson. a wave of mass migrations into the urban cities of Egypt sprung up as small-farmers lost various social expenditures and common land (shared by multiple farmers) was bought up by larger. UK: Bloomsbury Press. London. Durham.103 Despite their vocal support for participatory politics. NC: Duke University Press. 126. J. For strategic motives. dense Sh abi quarters or neighborhood slums of extreme poverty within cities like Cairo.105 was introduced under Mubarak. . J. After Development: Re-imagining Economy and Class Re/Presenting Class: Essays in Postmodern Marxism. Stephen Resnick and Richard Wolff.K.
Domination and the Arts of Resistance. 1995. 110 I basically agree with Hitchens. This will not only mobilize the marginalized citizens of Egypt but might be the best hope for preventing another authoritarian State government. Frankly. The MB quickly offered social services through local mosques to fill the gaps that were created during the liberalization period. 108 The problem with this is that it backfired and made the Muslim Brotherhood and its followers more militant. What I don t see at the Revolution. Christopher. Once again. Ed. Thomas.109 What I believe is needed in Egypt is not simply a new leader but a change in social relations towards something of a local. "Party Realignment and American Industrial Structure: The Investment Theory of Political Parties in Historical Perspective. 111 Ferguson. they cracked down on mosques and replaced the Imams with statesanctioned clerics. Greenwich. As the Egyptian state saw the MB gain popular support. 37 110 Hitchens."Research in Political Economy. Paul Zarembka. the Jasmine Revolution is important as it stands as a 108 109 Ibid. CT: JAI Press. it tends to push the oppressed to the point that they are willing to lose their life.111 In contrast to this. to us in the West there doesn t appear to be a genuine opposition leader but that is because we are considering only that which fits our norms of legitimate. participatory democracy. 84 Scott. Ferguson s research shows how the issues that make up the discourse of elections are usually the result of differences and/or splits in the business sector. when power expresses derisive oppression.Jacobs 30 the opportunity to gain support. it is very rare for changes in history to be caused by the people rather than by a change in the composition of the elite but this is perhaps an expression of our beliefs of what is suitable. Christopher Hitchens recently wrote that he didn t believe Egypt had the chance of truly overcoming a tyrannical government because Egypt has yet to have anything that resembles a genuine opposition leader and those groups that claim to represent the opposition are nothing but emancipated hulks. Print. stepped into these neighborhoods. Slate. .
than it should be true that the resources necessary to effectively govern do not need a hierarchical figure. 1980. Jurgen. However.113 As John Plamenatz explains. the average individual has the ability to give answers that are deemed rational and reasonable if they possessed the means (whether knowledge. The Theory of Democratic Elitism. Cambridge. verbal or economic) necessary to produce these credible statements. or one of perfect equality. language and symbolic capital needed to engage with one s neighbor. that a hierarchy is not essential to governance. Joseph. 115 Schwartz. 1990. D. NY: Routledge Publishing.C: University Press of America.Jacobs 31 strong expression of popular opinion (both positively and negatively). one may ask is that even necessary for a successful revolution? Should the Egyptian people need to put their future in the hands of one person? If Bourdieu is right. that what makes a choice reasonable is not because the actor can give a satisfactory explanation for why they made it but because if [he/she] could give an explanation. 86. This does not imply that only under a Habermasian ideal speech situation.115 112 Bourdieu. New York. the very creation of these markets that exclude. it would be satisfactory 114 In sum. Print. The Future of Democratic Equality: Rebuilding Social Solidarity in a Fragmented America. can be argued but only under conditions in which resource disparities do not hinder the attainment of the symbolic or cultural capital needed for every individual s opinion to be accepted as meaningful. However. Language and Symbolic Power. Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action. Washington.112 This hypothesis. can this be achieved but that people should not be effectively silenced by structural or economic constraints that have prevented them from being able to establish themselves in their communities. Print. 55. came about not in a democratic manner but as the result of stratification of access to the necessary cultural.: MIT Press. that power ultimately resides in the persons who elevate a selected individual to something that transcends the common mortal. Mass. 114 Bachrach. 1997. Print. 202 113Habermas. . Peter.
) 119 .119 For more on this view see either Plato The Republic or Joseph Schumpeter s Capitalism. gladly showed itself ungoverned in passion. simply because they could not control their violent human nature. The Western Illusion of Human Nature. human nature. 118 Champion.Jacobs 32 Of course. and was instead replaced by irrational mobs of citizens who carried out violence. (See Thucydides.´ Pew Research Center. and the enemy of all superiority. 12 March 2011 <http://online. IL: University of Chicago Press. Great thinkers from Plato to Joseph Schumpeter have argued that democracy is inherently unstable and will most likely end in an invasion on individual rights. 13 March 2011. had it not been for the fatal power of envy. and Democracy. and gain above justice. ³The Fall of Mubarak and the Media. is to establish an elite class who can maintain order and subdue the irrationality of the masses. that a direct democracy will devolve into mob rule. New York: Harper. 2011. Jurkowitz. <http://www. Richard Winn Livingstone. Book 3. 2008. Cumberlege. The Pew Research center also published a report at the beginning of the uprising.82-85. UK: G. The History of the Peloponnesian War. London. Coptic Christians Worried About Future Without Mubarak. The only solution. some might argue that without a dominant power. since revenge would not have been set above religion. Print/ 116 117 Sahlins.journalism. comes from an account of another revolt relayed by Greek historian Thucydides. 1946. echoing this realist viewpoint. Thucydides remarks how order dissolved upon the Corycians war breaking out.). instead of allowing them to subsist against the day of danger when their aid may be required.com/ >.118 Following the outbreak of riots in Cairo. Marshall. Socialism. news media almost immediately expressed concern over predicted ethnic conflict in the region in a similar manner.117 In his History of the Peloponnesian War. there is no order or. Web. Print. 7 February 2011. showing that the use of words like theocracy or extremism were often used more frequently than other words like democracy (Also see Marc. Trans. 2011. 1950.wsj. Thucydides writes ³In the confusion into which life was now thrown in the cities. always rebelling against the law and now its master. above respect for justice. Chicago. Indeed men too often take upon themselves in the prosecution of their revenge to set the example of doing away with those general laws to which all alike can look for salvation in adversity. Web.org/>. and Richard Crawley. The Revolution that is alluded to is the Corcyra Revolt. Print. they argue.116 What is interesting is the basis for most of this political thought or political realism. February 1. Marc. Wall Street Journal.
Al-Masry-Al-Youm.123 In fact. In Atfeeh. 13 March 2011. cooperation between groups that have been conventionally thought as permanently hostile towards one another (Muslims and Coptic Christians) has become a feature that has defined this revolution. sensible discourse. Stories of Copts protecting praying Muslims and vice-versa flooded the blogs during the beginning of the revolution but were ignored in many mainstream news outlets. as they contain the marks of instigation by Mubarak loyalists.121 This mutual aid shouldn t come as a surprise but the idea that cultural diversity leads to conflict has become so ingrained in modern thought that it dominates our assumptions.com>. it regularly shifts between different ethnicities holding power with no dissolution of the State. many of the incidences of sectarian conflict in Egypt are being examined. Print. 103 123 . India: The Most Dangerous Decades. sectarian clashes might be a conspiracy. Web. <http://www. 13 March 2011. In fact. New Delhi: Oxord Press. <http://www. 122 Harrison. contrary to the expectations of political 120 Cole. 121 Afify. The Theory of Democratic Elitism. Juan. Muslims One Hand in Egypt s Youth Revolution. appears to contradict this theory. a country much more diverse than Egypt and with a similar colonial past.120 In fact.juancole. 338-339. 2011. Christians.122 Instead. but against prejudices of the West. Bachrach. perhaps as a way to break up the unity of the revolutionary forces. Selig. Images of this new unity such as the pictures of Imam s and Priests rallying together to chant We are one hand have defined this revolution as not just revolting against an authoritarian government. Web. 1960.com>.almasryalyoum.Jacobs 33 The current revolution. India. 10 March 2011. Informed Comment. Democracy has the ability to push individuals to collaborate and encourage non-violent. was predicted to devolve into totalitarianism upon the introduction of popular democracy because of the belief that competing ethnicities would seek to destroy the opposition. Heba. February 7. What many political theorists fail to realize is that instead of reducing to irrational mob rule. at least in Egypt.
124 Returning to the factors that influence revolutions. Ethnicity. Larry Diamond. Print. Democracy appears to have acted as a pacifier for ethnic conflict by allowing groups to mobilize from within a system rather than attacking it from the outside. rather than during cases where one has a voice but perhaps does not get along with others. Boulder. Juan J. CO: Lynne Rienner Publishing.2. one can deduce that ethnic conflicts are often the result of situations where one lacks a voice. Empirical evidence also appears to support the idea that Democracy reduces the chance of a terrorist attack within a country (see Quan Li Does Democracy Promote or Reduce Transnational Terrorist Incidents? Journal of Conflict Resolution Vol. 48. Lintz and Seymour Lipset. Print. 124 Das Gupta. No. Democracy and Development in India: Assam in a General Perspective Democracy in Developing Countries: Asia. 1989.Jacobs 34 theorists about India at the time. 2005:278-297.) . Jyotirindra. Eds. 167.
Web. but introduces a whole series of variables that are usually not considered as a 125 Zyglis. Egypt has a history of hidden resistance that not only challenges this view.buffalonews. they might still harbor the view that hierarchy is still needed in order to run something efficiently. Adam. It is definitely wise to rely on those with expert skill to complete a task but talents can be developed in many different situations. February 12. 14 March 2011. The Buffalo News. 2011.Jacobs 35 125 Even if one doesn t accept the belief that diversity will lead to conflict. . <http://blogs. Many might hold semi-technocratic views.com/adam-zyglis/>. insisting that complicated tasks like finance or engineering remain in the hands of those who hold university degrees in order to maximize success. 12 February 2011.
have tried to answer this question of language and semiotic hegemony. Ibid. 63. Thus. 127 126 . Derrida suggest the hierarchy between the words be flipped and then synthesized in a new word. 47. especially when it comes to the question of breaking free from cultural domination. 130 Bourdieu. It is empowerment which should be stressed. Everyday Economic Practices. they provide formerly excluded resources. Language and Symbolic Power. Instead of following the development path already forged out. For Egyptian women. 128 McCumber. They build trust. In this manner.129 Bourdieu mentions that there is a tendency for language that meant one thing amongst the old rule to become transformed into something with a new meaning during revolutions but he doesn t explain how.Jacobs 36 traditional economic indicator. Philosophy and Freedom 23.126 Despite never receiving formal training by banking institutions. they invest in that which is valuable to the locales they become tools for the construction of identities. Their conclusions often range from resisting the traditional ranking of the word128 to simply the creation of a new vocabulary and meanings. often circulating large amounts of money around at extremely low transaction costs while still possessing a very high repayment percentage!127 A superficial reading of this outcome would praise only the economic effectiveness of the gam iyas but the real victory is the autonomy and meaning given to these associations. our final question: how can the Egyptians find their own identity in language and rid themselves of their colonial past? Several philosophers. Egyptians of the ammiya could reject the cultural binary between thaqafa and turath or the difference in the words used for culture by the different classes in Egypt. 129 Ibid. it is one of the several informal credit associations or gam iya that allows them to maintain valuable family occasions (like weddings or funerals) and keep money within communities. 21 & 124. they become the force of their own creation. such as Richard Rorty or Jacques Derrida. 127-129. many of these community credit organizations operate extremely effectively.130 It is due to this that I reject these Chowdhury.
Gareth Griffiths. No matter how many words are reinvented. Can the Subaltern Speak? The Post-Colonial Studies Reader. Domination and the Arts of Resistance. unequal relationships will continue to establish material and social inequality amongst populations. What constitutes their distinctness should ultimately be a product of their own will. Spivak. Gayatri C. One of the great critiques of modern postcolonial theory. The hidden transcript never becomes a language apart but retains mutual intelligibility with that of the dominant transcript. While these tools may be useful in overcoming language barriers as a group. (See Khayatt.Jacobs 37 options as solutions on their own because they approach the problem as one that can be solved simply through exit mechanisms rather than through one s which empower the voice of Egyptians. This is even more apparent when we consider the symbolic and cultural capital gap between a Western scholar and a baladi peasant.131 There is no doubt that the hidden transcript is important in both providing a platform for airing of anger and establishing group cohesion but simply choosing to drop out of dominant transcripts and create new meanings for traditional words fails to overcome the power structures propagate the transcript. Pensively. Bill Ashcroft. 2006.133 Instead. as long as the dominant lingual markets exist. London. New York: Routledge. 132 Our predisposition towards truth often causes us to speak for individuals and suppress them in the same manner that colonialism originally functioned. individually they self-censor. by Gayatri Spivak. as if it was itself a former colony of the public transcript. Terms of Desire: Are there Lesbians in Egypt? 219). I approach this question with apprehension. 24. 135. we must 131 132 Scott. . 133 Baladi means local. and Helen Tiffin. As Scott says. Eds. Print. Often attempts to help give voice or create identities lead to the same homogenization that one was trying to prevent I am not Egyptian and do not know their individual experiences. is the tendency for outside intellectuals to imply complete comprehension of the subaltern s experience or the persistent constitution of the Other as the Self s shadow.
Jacobs 38 speak to the people of Egypt. The best starting point for overcoming this. cultural or symbolic factor. etc). "Party Realignment and American Industrial Structure: The Investment Theory of Political Parties in Historical Perspective. where individual s voices hold equal weight and are not significantly constrained by any economic.135 it would be only fair that Egyptians be given the right to greater democratic control over their jobs. power. even if it is still incomplete. one can adopt what already appears to be happening (for example. political. Since corporate institutions already play a big role in a citizen s life both through economic control and social authority. The very act of establishing a more direct democracy will decentralize power but this does not imply a fall into anarchy or dissolution similar to Yugoslavia. What is needed is an organization where voices are felt equally. the democratization of the factories in El-Mahalla El-Kubra) and apply it to a new. This could be anything from something as radical as worker cooperatives to simply a vote in which candidate their place of work supports during an election. where people do not feel they need to possess any sort of cultural or capital to participate and are free from any kind of intimidation (intellectual.134 as well as possess perhaps the biggest influence on the outcome of elections. 134 . Instead. they confront individuals to operate cooperatively in the solution of concrete problems affecting [themselves] instead of weakly through representations created by stronger interests (or not at all). one need not fear that this will 135 Bachrach. The Theory of Democratic Elitism. either through finance or endorsement."). free from the restrictions of the markets or suppressive transcripts. would again be the creation of a more inclusive form of democracy (rather than just a liberal democracy). so that we may listen to them and show that their voices are valued. 69 For more see (Ferguson. more inclusive form of governance through the use of democracy in the workplace. When direct democracies exist. Regardless of this more popular approach.
137 Either way. Conclusion In conclusion. such a process reveres the innovation of new conceptions. Foley. what is not seen or even hides itself plays equally an important role as that which flaunts itself on the public stage. than a direct democracy could not only work but flourish in the region. Philosophy and Freedom. Domination works on multiple spectrums to project an image greater than itself. a goal of which our vocabularies play a role in creating. Perhaps the biggest finding I learned from this series of event is that power is a two-way street and that relationships of power are never Bachrach. Ultimately.Jacobs 39 undoubtedly lead to homogenization of opinion. our role should not be to sit back and analyze the situation through our scholarly lens but to respond and support Egypt as members our world s family. often as a deterrent from its real weaknesses. it is under these conditions of open debate and cooperation.136 I strongly believe that as discourse happens. It is our responsibility to avoid jumping to hasty generalizations. Under general equality. a unity of solidarity and pluralism. It is now clear why a democracy can serve as a means of breaking free from past-language constructions. each individual becomes a possible producer of legitimate language but still retains a need for camaraderie with others. investigation into further evidence of their position. (See Thomas Jefferson and John P. especially now that we understand there that we me consider a whole multitude of transcripts that we do not see. 1967. that linguistic and semiotic freedom can be sought as expressed by the previously mentioned poststructuralism thinkers. Print.138 Thus. The Jeffersonian Cyclopedia.) 138 McCumber. 103 Difference of opinion leads to enquiry and enquiry to truth Thomas Jefferson. The Theory of Democratic Elitism. 660. 71 137 136 . demarcated from the barriers to entry. differences will naturally occur and inspire reevaluation of one s position or perhaps. New York: Russell & Russell. I cannot claim to know what Egyptians want but if their history is any indication.
Such revelation is not only optimistic but also empowering if the protests in Yemen and Bahrian (and soon to be transitioning Libya) are any indication. it is that the actions by just ordinary people in one country can change the world. .Jacobs 40 permanently set. The Jasmine Revolution should provide motivation to the world s oppressed that their ability to overcome is not something fictional but a very real and a very possible now.
Web. Abu-Laghoud. Fouad. Nicholas S. 19 February 2011. Vol. Hopkins. Web. 74. ³The Transformation of the Egyptian Elite: Prelude to the Urabi Revolt. sectarian clashes might be a conspiracy. No. Negar. ³In Atfeeh. Heba.´ The Middle East Journal.´ Foreign Affairs. ³The Sorrows of Egypt.opendemocracy.net/>. Cairo: The American University Press. Ibrahim. Azimi. ³Egypt¶s Youth have had Enough. <http://www. Web.´ Open Democracy. 21. 3.´ Directions of Change in Rural Egypt. 2011. Print. 21 February 2011. 13 March 2011.almasryalyoum. ³Television and The Virtues of Education: Upper Egyptian Encounters with State Culture. Vol. No.com>. Afify. August 31 2005. 1997: 325-344. March 10. .´ Al-Masry-Al-Youm. 5.Jacobs 41 Bibliography Abu-Lughoud. Ajami. 1995: 72-88. Lila. <http://www. Ed. 4 March 2011. Web.
D. 1980. Web. No. Facebook and the uprisings in the Arab world. 1991. Washington. Cambridge. Mass.: Harvard University Press. February 25.C.Jacobs 42 Bachrach.´ The Guardian. Laura. Bourdieu. <http://www. 2011. The Theory of Democratic Elitism: A Critique. 17 March 2011. Print. Pierre.guardian. Peter.2.uk/>.´ Feminist Studies Vol 36. 2010: 404-432. Citizenship and the Regulation of Reproduction in Postwar Egypt.: University Press of America. Bier. Beaumont. Print. ³The Truth about Twitter.co. Print. . Peter. Language and Symbolic Power. ³¶The Family is a Factory¶: Gender.
Ha-Joon. Marc. 1990.´ Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance. ³Coptic Christians Worried About Future Without Mubarak.E. Print. NY: M. The Logic of Practice. New York: Bloomsbury Press. Armonk. 2011. February 1.´ Tourist Studies Vol.´Wall Street Journal. Print. ³The Conspiracy of Silence and the Atomistic Political Activity of the Egyptian Peasantry. 7. Calif. Derek. ³Repacking Orientalism: Discourse in Egypt and Turkey on British Outbound tourism. Web. Brown. Chang. Colburn. Print.Jacobs 43 _____________. Print. 12 March 2011 <http://online. Forest D. 2008.: Stanford University Press. Bryce. 1989. 1 US ed. ed. Stanford. Nathan.2: 165-191.wsj. 1882-1952. Bad Samaritans: The Myth of Free Trade and the Secret History of Capitalism. Champion. Sharpe.com/>. . No.
February 7. 13 March 2011 <http://www. Democracy and Development in India: Assam in a General Perspective´ Democracy in Developing Countries: Asia. Juan. Everyday Economic Practices: The "Hidden Transcripts" of Egyptian Voices. Savvina A. Davis. Print. 2007. 2010. 2011. Juan J. Print. San Francisco: City Lights Books. Larry Diamond. New York: Routledge. 1989. Cole.Jacobs 44 Chowdhury. Written by Himself :A New Critical Edition. 2007. New York. Muslims µOne Hand¶ in Egypt¶s Youth Revolution. and Angela Y. __________.juancole. NY: Palgrave Macmillan. ³Ethnicity. Das Gupta. an American Slave. Print. Jyotirindra.com/>. Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass. Boulder.´ Informed Comment. Douglass. Eds. Web. ³Christians. Frederick. CO: Lynne Rienner Publishing. . Napoleon¶s Egypt: Invading the Middle East. Print. Lintz and Seymour Lipset.
NC: Duke University Press. and Ruccio. ³Egypt: The distance between democracy and social justice. 2011. Stephen Resnick and Richard Wolff. Gibson-Graham. .Jacobs 45 Efrat. Ferguson. 1995. The Interpretation of Dreams. Print. CT: JAI Press. 2001. Thomas.´ Challenge Magazine."Research in Political Economy. Retrieved 8 March 2011. Eds. Paul Zarembka. New York. ³After Development: Re-imagining Economy and Class´ Re/Presenting Class: Essays in Postmodern Marxism. Durham. 1980. Yacov Ben. Sigmund. Print.K GrahamGibson. February 7. "Party Realignment and American Industrial Structure: The Investment Theory of Political Parties in Historical Perspective.com/>. Freud. Ed. <http://challengemag. J. J. NY: Avon publishing. Greenwich. Web. D. Print.K.
New Delhi: Oxord Press. 2. Web. 1960. 14 March 2011. Matthew. March 2011.´ Slate. No. Web. 13 March 2011. Selig.Jacobs 46 Gopal.vanityfair. February 16. India: The Most Dangerous Decades. Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action. Habermas. Christopher. 1998:91-112. 2011. 34. Print. Harrison. Cambridge. <http://www. Hitchens. Privatization and Tourism in Egypt. ³Egypt¶s Cauldron of Revolt. Mass. .foreignpolicy. ³Economic Reform.´ Middle Eastern Studies Vol. <http://www.com/>. 18 March 2011. Gray.: MIT Press.com/>. ³What I don¶t see at the Revolution. Jurgen.´ Foreign Policy Magazine. 1990. Print. Anand. Web.
journalism. Mitch. Didi. Buffalo: Multilingual Matters. March 2011.´ Pew Research Center. Walter. <http://www. Festivals of Freedom: Memory and Meaning in African American Emancipation Celebrations 1808-1905. 18 March 2011. Marc. Web. . 2011. Mass. Thomas. Foley. 1967. Print. <http://www. New York: Russell & Russell. 2003. Amherst. February 7. Khayatt.: University of Massachusetts Press.cbsnews. ³Terms of Desire: Are there any Lesbians in Egypt?´ In Language and Socialization in Bilingual and Multilingual Societies.com/>.Jacobs 47 Jurkowitz. Print. and John P. 2006. 13 March 2011. The Jeffersonian Cyclopedia. ³The Fall of Mubarak and the Media. Eds. Robert Bayley and Sandra R.org/>. Web. 39 Vol. Print. Jefferson. ³Will Egypt¶s Youth Meet History¶s Challenge?´ CBSNews. Schecter. Clevedon. Kachun. Laquer.
<http://www. Print. . Foucault. 2011. Mazel. Zvi. Durham: Duke University Press. Liberalism without Democracy: Nationhood and Citizenship in Egypt. Quan. Web. 2000. January 17. 2006.´ Open Democracy. Web. John. 17 February 2011.jpost.com/>. 2005:278-297. Habermas. Osman. Print. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. ³Egypt¶s Phantom Messiah. ³Does Democracy Promote or Reduce Transnational Terrorist Incidents?´ Journal of Conflict Resolution Vol. Rorty. Tarek.opendemocracy. 1922-1936. July 12.net/>. Print.´ Jerusalem Post. 2006. Abdeslam.Jacobs 48 Li. Maghraoui. No. McCumber. 18 March 2011. Philosophy and Freedom: Derrida.2. 48. ³Tunisia ± First Popular Uprising in Arab World. <http://www.
³Dressing Native. Reading: Ithaca. Print. Print. ³Why Vietnam Won¶t Fall. <http://www. Carl.: Prickly Paradigm. Egypt After Mubarak: Liberalism. Marshall David. 17 March 2011. and Democracy in the Arab World.Jacobs 49 Plato. The Western Illusion of Human Nature.´ World Policy Blog.worldpolicy. John. Benjamin Jowell. Robinson. Trans. Islam. Sahlins. Print. 1944. 2008. Web. Princeton: Princeton University Press. March 7.´ Unfolding the Orient :Travellers in Egypt and the Near East. 2008. Ill. Eds. Rodenbeck. 2011. Chicago. . Bruce K. Rutherford. The Republic.org/>. Print. 2001. Paul and Janet Starkey. New York: The Limited Editions Club.
Sefat. Print. Joseph M.Jacobs 50 Schwartz. New Haven: Yale University Press. Big Bang: The Origin of the Universe. 11 March 2011. Joseph Alois.´ Informed Comment. The Future of Democratic Equality: Rebuilding Social Solidarity in a Fragmented America. 1950. March 1. New York: Fourth Estate. . Simon. 2008. Kusha. ³Kusha: Iran vs. Singh. 2004. Scott. Web. Egypt: Qualitative Differences in Capabilities. 1990. Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts. Socialism. <http://www. Capitalism. Print. 2011.com/>. Print. and Democracy. James C. Print. New York: Harper. Schumpeter.juancole. New York: Routledge.
Syracuse. Spivak. UK: G. 15 March 2011. 7. Print. Thucydides. Print. The History of the Peloponnesian War. Vol. Scott. Wheeler. 2000. Cumberlege. ³Can the Subaltern Speak?´ In The Post-Colonial Studies Reader. ³State and Revolution. London.´ Theory and Society. 20 February 2011. and Helen Tiffin. Bill Ashcroft. February 19th. Eds. No. Theda.2. Gareth Griffiths. Gayatri C. The New Mamluks: Egyptian Society and Modern Feudalism. <http://bigpeace. ³One Nation Under Islam. Amira El Azhary. Sonbol.com/>.Jacobs 51 Skocpol.´ Big Peace. 2011. 1979: 7-95. New York: Routledge. 2006. London. Richard Winn Livingstone and Richard Crawley. Trans. Web. New York: Syracuse University Press. . Print. Web. 1946.
Web. Paul. 12 March 2011. January 18th. 2011.´ Cagle Cartoons.Jacobs 52 Zayed. 2011.´ Reuters. Slavoj. March 11. 18 March 2011. <http://www. ³Egyptians set themselves ablaze after Tunisia unrest. Print. How to Read Lacan. Web.W. __________. ³Roots of the Revolutionary Egyptian Moment. Bil. January 29. 17 March 2011. Web. Cambridge.youtube.´ Real News. Print. 2011.com>. 2006. Media Jay. New York: W.reuters.com/news/>. Dina. 2011. 2007. Zizek. Norton & Co. <http://www. .. <http://cagle.com/> Schorr. MA: MIT Press. ³March 11. The Parallax View.
28 March 2011. 2011. Primary Sources Economist Intelligence Unit. Web. Web. Adam.Jacobs 53 Zyglis. 27 March 2011. ³February 12.´ The Buffalo News.com/adam-zyglis/>.´ Manchester Times Iss. 19th Century British Library Newspapers. British Library. 1288 (September 16. 2011. <http://blogs. February 12. Egypt (2010): 4-5. Web.buffalonews. "Outlook for 2010-11: Political outlook. Business Source Premier. . 18 March 2011. 1882): 4. ³Summary of the Week." Country Report.
This action might not be possible to undo. Are you sure you want to continue?
We've moved you to where you read on your other device.
Get the full title to continue reading from where you left off, or restart the preview.