MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐1

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐2

I am curious what happened to your "Jewish husband" that you used to justify your sympathies with
terrorists. I assume if you were still married I would be addressing him because you seem to have
the need to have men front for you (when you aren't backstabbing those very men). that is the
pattern. how many times did I front for you Marta when students were complaining about you? in
fact I do remember some emails way back where you left me in a lurch. I remember apologizing to
you... but I knew I had done nothing wrong. the pattern Marta is you do not believe you are
capable of wrong. how can you live like that? - ג Noah ג David ג Simon ג
©2010 FriendFeed - - About - Tools & Widgets - Blog - API - Help - Privacy - Terms
MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐3

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐4

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐5

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐6


Posted on WADVPRES.ORG and also sent to Governor with my full name.

24 sarah levine simon // Feb 9, 2011 at 6:17 am

Sarah Levine Simon, 109 Hooker Avenue, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601
Phone: 845 485-9829 email: sarah@sarahlevinesimon.com
http://www.sarahlevinesimon.com

February 8, 2011

To: Governor Chris Gregoire: office of the Governor, PO box 98504-4111
And via Fax to 360 753-4111

Dear Governor Grigoire:

I am writing to make you aware that persons working for the Justice system in the State
of Washington issued a restraining order and commenced extradition proceedings from
New York State on Noah David Simon, a resident of Poughkeepsie, New York, and who
is my son, without any investigation into the allegations. His accuser , his former
computer-programming professor at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh, had
papers served on her former student Noah Simon, falsely identifying him as part of a
Carnegie Mellon conspiracy against her.

Accuser is a woman with a history of making accusations against men, and of filing
lawsuits based on those accusations. The accusations made against Noah Simon should
have at the very least raised eyebrows if not hackles. Accuser freely entered into a blog
written by Noah and freely engaged in dialogue with him and others in the blog. She then
took a video and statement out of context to the district attorney and to the news media.
(She has a personal or family relationship with the investigating detective Marik.) With
the restraining order in place Accuser continued to dialogue with Noah on his blog. She
could do this because the restraining order was only binding on Noah, not on her. Hence
he unwittingly became guilty of violating the restraining order.

Refute
There was a 7 month long investigation into the allegations.

I have no personal or family relationship with Det Marik. There is no evidence of
this.

I never entered into dialog with Noah on his blog, or EVER with others on his blog
before he posted the gun video. The only time I entered into dialog with him was on
May 9, 2009, after he had already begun his harassing posting. When there nothing
was being done to stop him by the authorities, and his harassing posts were
escalating I tried this as a last resort. He had said he was posting the comments,
because I blocked him. So I thought if I tried to talk with him he might stop. This
was a very bad idea, and it only made matters worse. He immediately began posting
false statements and then cut and paste them into many accounts to distribute them.
He focused on my epilepsy. He posted that he had “melted the ice queen”. On May
31, 2009, he posted many times though many accounts, that I “broke my own no
contact order” I started to get scared about why he was doing this, as there was no
order in place. I then created an audio reply to address this, and posted it on my
own blog on May 31, 2009. I sounded desperate and stressed out. The reply stated
there was no no-contact order in place. It had this on the face of it as well. I find it
very odd Ms Simon wrote here that there was a restraining order in place, during
the May 9, 2009 interaction. Again, this was the only interaction I had with him
online. I removed the audio reply, as Noah Simon began copying it and pasting it,
through many accounts, I am assuming because it sounded so troubled. He did not
have copyright of this recording, so I was able to get the ISP’s to remove it.

All of this was turned into the police. Torres knew about these interactions, and the
audio reply.

Three clicks of the mouse would have brought the ADA Hugo Torres of the Seattle
District Attorney’s office to Accuser v. Carnegie Mellon University. Three more clicks of
the mouse would have brought Torres to the blog site and the context of the discussion
between Simon, Accuser and others. He would have known immediately that he could
never have convicted Noah for any felony. So the People of the State of Washington paid
to have Noah extradited over three thousand miles away on quasi-arguable misdemeanor
charges.

Something has gone very awry in the justice system that allowed this case to proceed.
Furthermore after more than a month in jail, he was convinced to plead to misdemeanor
charges in order to avoid more expense; bail, jail time, and fear for his safety. Noah is a
Jewish activist and he was incarcerated with skinheads tattooed with swastikas. He was
not given a final tally of her legal fees before agreeing to payment of Accuser’s legal
fees. Upon his plea he was released into the streets of Seattle without identification or a
coat. The jailers lost his personal property.

He was unable to get on an airplane without an ID and rode the Greyhound bus across the
country in one of the worst blizzards in history. His treatment by the State of Washington
has been inhumane throughout these proceedings. Our entire family has suffered the
humiliation and the financial burden of lawyers, long-distance travel, physical and
emotional pain and suffering.

Refute
Later, Ms Simon wrote in an email, that she paid for Noah Simon’s airfare (home,
as the state paid for it to Seattle). Noah Simon used this alleged bus trip as a reason
why he could not get down the posts online, by court ordered deadline of 2/17/2011.

I used to think of Seattle as the place to live, eat well, see great ballet and opera. I will
never visit again.

Respectfully Yours,

Sarah Levine Simon
MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐7

From: "sarah levine simon" <sarah@sarahlevinesimon.com>
Date: March 10, 2011 5:17:38 AM PST
To: april.Bishop@kingcounty.gov
Cc: matthew@flennaughlaw.com
Subject: [Fwd: Re: Marta Lyall] Working towards a settlement of this
matter.
Reply-To: sarah@sarahlevinesimon.com
 
Dear Ms. Bishop: 
 
I am enclosing an email thread between myself and Marta Lyall's lawyer 
Matt Lapin. I am the mother of Noah Simon and was forced to pay for his 
legal fees etc. We were trying to find a way to settle this matter once 
and for all but when the proposal was made to Lyall, she apparently decide 
that Mr. Lapin would no longer represent her. Does the court have any 
mechanisms to help parties settle. This has been a malicious prosecution 
from the beginning. Noah was arrested and extradited on four felony 
counts: stalking, cyberstalking,identity theft (of Lyall's medical records 
and bank accounts)harassment intention to cause harm. It all came to 
naught. The ADA Hugo Torres failed to investigate until he had Noah in 
custody. Noah plead to misdemeanors in order to avoid a costly trial and 
more jail time. Bail was set too high for us to make. Since his 
incarceration many people have come forward: In the past 15 years she has 
made similar accusations about 35 people and we now have the FOIA request 
from the University of Washington where Lyall was employed until she 
started accusing her colleagues; We have a Federal Lawsuit that Lyall 
filed against Carnegie Mellon University in 1998 and continued until 2002, 
we have the results of a subpoena to Wikipedia that shows that Lyall 
herself is a cyberstalker. She is a sick and paranoid woman and once she 
gets into people's lives she is there to stay. 
 
Sincerely, 
Sarah Levine Simon
MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐8

Subject: Fwd: Lyall v. Univ. of Washington, Lyall v. Simon
From: JusƟn Walsh <JusƟn@mallinglaw.com>
Date: Thu, 31 Mar 2011 15:26:23 -0700
To: M Lyall <martalyall2011@comcast.net>
Justin P. Walsh
Law Offices of Karl E. Malling
justin@mallinglaw.com
P: (206) 826-8250
F: (206) 577-3843
http://theamateurlawprofessor.com
The Amateur Law Professor - Washington Legal News
"The fields that need to be plowed are endless. You will never be done plowing the fields.
Just plow what you can, and rest. Don't worry about getting it done, because it's never going
to get done, and I'm all right with that. Most people think that they can't finish the fields, so
they don't even start. By the end of the day, I've done so much more than anybody else that
it's crazy, just because they're fretting about that they can't get it done. I just went out and did
it." - Ian MacKaye
Begin forwarded message:
From: Noah David Simon <noah@sarahlevineimon.com>
Date: March 24, 2011 1:24:24 PM PDT
To: Justin Walsh <Justin@mallinglaw.com>
Cc: "april.bishop@kingcounty.gov" <april.bishop@kingcounty.gov>
Subject: Re: Fwd: Lyall v. Univ. of Washington, Lyall v. Simon
Dear Mr. Walsh,
I will do so and can you explain to me who Susie Wirth is and why she has
made phone calls (I assume on Ms. Lyall's behalf) to parƟes represenƟng
me in New York State? The Google explanaƟon is that she is a partner in a
wine business with your boss Mr. Malling. The short answer is that Marta
Lyall has once again hacked into my computer and is reading private
emails.
Sincerely,
Noah Simon
Fwuǣ Lyall vǤ 0nivǤ of Washingtonǡ Lyall vǤ Simon
ͳ of Ͷ ͶȀʹͺȀʹͲͳͳ ʹǣͲͻ AN
MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit9

Page 1 of 1 King County Superior Court
516 Third Avenue, C-203
Seattle, WA 98104
(206) 296-9105
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF KING
MARTA LYALL,
Petitioner,
v.
NOAH D. SÌMON,
Respondent.
NO. 10-2-04392-6 SEA
ORDER RE: EMAÌL
COMMUNÌCATÌONS
Due to the failure of the parties to this action to adhere to previous Court
requests that substantive information relating to the case not be sent to the Court in
email, and to avoid any potential for ex parte communication, the Court hereby
ORDERS:
Any emails sent to the Court by the parties will not be read or reviewed by the
Court and will be deleted upon receipt. Any communication with the Court should be
submitted in writing pursuant to the local court rules.
DATED this 1
st
day of April, 2011.
_____________________________
Judge Beth M. Andrus
King County Superior Court
Judicial Electronic Signature Page


Case Number: V
Case Title: V V
V V V
Document Title: V
V V V
Signed by Judge:
Date:




Judge














This document is signed in accordance with the provisions in GR 30.
CertiIicate Hash:
CertiIicate eIIective date:
CertiIicate expiry date:
CertiIicate Issued by:
V V V V V V V V V
10-2-04392-6
LYALL VS SIMON
ORDER
4/1/2011 9:26:41 AM
Beth Andrus
Beth Andrus
A31991381293F0EDC27CFFCFECEF2B56EE8FA988
8/11/2010 4:30:02 PM
8/10/2012 4:30:02 PM
CN=Washington State CA B1, OU=State of Washington
CA, O=State of Washington PKI, C=US
Page 2 of 2
MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐A

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐B

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐C

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐D1

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐D2

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐I‐1

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐I‐2

HA! I truly have to agree!
Thanks for that little kernel of wisdom, love.
—————– Original Message —————–
From: Noah David Simon
Date: Jul 9, 2007 1:58 PM
Shows we don’t have to agree to see wisdom in a philosophy… I find myself quoting Jesus all the time.
this one
Behind all their personal vanity, women themselves always have an impersonal contempt for woman.
Friedrich Nietzsche
is especially tantalizing… when you have a girlfriend and mother @ war with each other.
If you think I’m thickheaded…. you should see old ma.
—————– Original Message —————–
From: (uRi0u$
Date: Jul 9, 2007 2:04 PM
Lol, trust me, I have one, too. And an in law. (
—————– Original Message —————–
From: Noah David Simon
Date: Jul 10, 2007 11:18 AM
I never got a reply after I spilled my guts. Well it is more complicated then just some Bisexual I’m with. Please don’t
judge. Her ambivalence stems from the fact that she does love me and is attracted to me, but some where deep inside
is some racism coming from her father who would never accept me. Your talking about civil war people. Oakies and
upstate New York People…. the grandmother lives in Texas… is a Repubican in Houston and voted for Nixon. Their
biggest fear is the family fortune ending in Jewish hands. They were delighted to have my darling son for a grandson…
He looks like a white boy with blue eyes…. but they try to keep me from him. They think I will corrupt him with my
radical anti-christian ideas. Sara and I slugged it off on our own… barely getting by for five and a half years. Neither
my parents or her’s approved of the relationship. She was not always loyal to me though… and I was stupid and
thought having the child would make her love me the way I loved her… It did not. In fact I could not afford to pay the
hospital bill for the pregnancy. I couldn’t even afford the abortion the first time it happened.
So yeah… I’m like a piece of shit to the world. The sister of Sara… the Rich Lesbian I referred to: her name is
“Laura”. Laura doesn’t call me by my real name. She calls me “the sperm doner”. She is married to a columbian guy
in New York who sleeps around with young girls like the mayor of Los Angeles. She keeps him around like a dog on a
leash. To ammuse herself and because she lives in Inwood and needs a man to scare off other men from the Lesbians
going in and out her house. She makes about 100,000 a year, but has recently got cancer of the thyroid. She is a very
bitter women…but she has money and seems to love being with Maxx. I get along with Sara’s straight sister “Liz” and
of course the Autistic brother. Now that I am unemployed I am like a piece of shit.
I would not be in the unemployment situation I am now if my girl had a little trust in me. I helped throw a huge fashion
party in NYC last year and I knew some of the biggest names…. all I had to do was look good… so I brought my girl
(why not we have a child together) ….well she got drunk and humiliated me in front of some of the most important
people in the world because she thought I was hitting on all the fashion models (I wasn’t, it was networking)…. it is a
problem. I love my girl… but she holds me back because she doesn’t honestly believe that I love her I guess. Her sister
and her hate men… and they don’t trust. They have been great with my son… he stays at her parents house, but if I
had been supported by her at that party last year… I would be employed now. She wants me to be a working man like
her father is, but I am a very talented artist and I can not help what I am. I still love her… but she has not been
supportive. When people see a man whose woman doesn’t think highly of him…. well it effects the ability of a man to
market himself. All successful men have a powerful woman behind them propping them up…. My girl just wants to be
mommy… and sees me as a financial failure. But it doesn’t have to be that way. She made it that way. Art is Politics.
MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐E

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐F1

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐F2

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐G
noah-CallCops98-Exhibit-G-1.txt 5/18/2011
Return-path: <ns39+@andrew.cmu.edu>
X-Andrew-Authenticated-as: 31088;andrew.cmu.edu;Noah D Simon
Received: from pcs39.andrew.cmu.edu via trymail
ID </afs/andrew.cmu.edu/usr22/mlyall/Mailbox/Ap=1fee00iWY0=oE40>;
Wed, 8 Apr 1998 20:48:42 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from pcs39.andrew.cmu.edu via qmail
ID </afs/andrew.cmu.edu/usr23/ns39/.Outgoing/QF.Ep=1fdq00iWY0=k1Q0>;
Wed, 8 Apr 1998 20:48:41 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from
mms.4.170.Jun.27.1996.16.34.50.sun4.51.MacMail.5.2.CUILIB.3.45.SNAP.NOT.LINKED
.pcs39.andrew.cmu.edu.sun4m.54
via MS.5.6.pcs39.andrew.cmu.edu.sun4_51;
Wed, 8 Apr 1998 20:48:41 -0400 (EDT)
Message-ID: <op=1fdm00iWY0=k1I0@andrew.cmu.edu>
Date: Wed, 8 Apr 1998 20:48:41 -0400 (EDT)
From: Noah D Simon <ns39+@andrew.cmu.edu>
X-Andrew-Message-Size: 4045+0
Content-Type: X-BE2; 12
If-Type-Unsupported: alter
To: Marta D Lyall <mlyall+@andrew.cmu.edu>
Subject: Re: (fwd)
Cc:
In-Reply-To: <Pine.OSF.3.96.980408203601.21160A-100000@alpha.dickinson.edu>
References: <Pine.OSF.3.96.980408203601.21160A-100000@alpha.dickinson.edu>
\begindata{text, 5022}
\textdsversion{12}
\template{messages}
Excerpts from mail: 8-Apr-98 Re: (fwd) by Diana Steele@dickinson.e
> Date: Wed, 8 Apr 1998 20:39:04 -0400 (EDT)
> From: Diana Steele <steele@dickinson.edu>
> To: Noah D Simon <ns39+@andrew.cmu.edu>
> Subject: Re: (fwd)
> Noah
> > The more my love for you grows, the more
<----------------------------|
> > the danger of intense hatred. you are in deep shit Diana.
|
> >
|
> Diana
|
> and you wonder why i seem distant at times and act fearful of you. my
|
> insticts always tell me not to go see you, and i do anyways. therefore, i
|
> am the stupid, naive girl who places herself in the position of being
|
> harmed. hate me more yet?
|
|
1
noah-CallCops98-Exhibit-G-1.txt 5/18/2011
Go to above statement
again----------------------------------------------------|
By the Way:
I went to a meeting on date assault tonight and they gave out a questionaire.
One of the questions was....
Women claim rape to help their reputations... Myth or Fact?
They said Myth.... I argued with them... They called the cops on me and said I
was disturbing their meeting.
No Joke.... It just happened
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------+
|N()AH +----+ |
|DAVID | | |
|SIMON | | |
| +----+ |
+-------------------------------------------+---------------------------+
| internet homepage... +---------------------------+
| http://qru.com/gallery/noah/main.html +---------------------------+
| Email Address +---------------------------+
| NS39@andrew.cmu.edu +---------------------------+
| Phone Number +---------------------------+
| Pittsburgh Pennsylvania +---------------------------+
| (412)-862-3039 +---------------------------+
| New York City: +---------------------------+
| (212)-543-0275 +---------------------------+
| NYC Address +---------------------------+
| Simon Studio +---------------------------+
| apartment 6D +---------------------------+
| 565 west 169th street +---------------------------+
| NYC 10032 +---------------------------+
+-------------------------------------------+---------------------------+
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
2
noah-CallCops98-Exhibit-G-1.txt 5/18/2011
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
All work and no play makes Jack a very unhappy boy
\enddata{text, 5022}
3
MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐H

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐I‐1

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐I‐2

HA! I truly have to agree!
Thanks for that little kernel of wisdom, love.
—————– Original Message —————–
From: Noah David Simon
Date: Jul 9, 2007 1:58 PM
Shows we don’t have to agree to see wisdom in a philosophy… I find myself quoting Jesus all the time.
this one
Behind all their personal vanity, women themselves always have an impersonal contempt for woman.
Friedrich Nietzsche
is especially tantalizing… when you have a girlfriend and mother @ war with each other.
If you think I’m thickheaded…. you should see old ma.
—————– Original Message —————–
From: (uRi0u$
Date: Jul 9, 2007 2:04 PM
Lol, trust me, I have one, too. And an in law. (
—————– Original Message —————–
From: Noah David Simon
Date: Jul 10, 2007 11:18 AM
I never got a reply after I spilled my guts. Well it is more complicated then just some Bisexual I’m with. Please don’t
judge. Her ambivalence stems from the fact that she does love me and is attracted to me, but some where deep inside
is some racism coming from her father who would never accept me. Your talking about civil war people. Oakies and
upstate New York People…. the grandmother lives in Texas… is a Repubican in Houston and voted for Nixon. Their
biggest fear is the family fortune ending in Jewish hands. They were delighted to have my darling son for a grandson…
He looks like a white boy with blue eyes…. but they try to keep me from him. They think I will corrupt him with my
radical anti-christian ideas. Sara and I slugged it off on our own… barely getting by for five and a half years. Neither
my parents or her’s approved of the relationship. She was not always loyal to me though… and I was stupid and
thought having the child would make her love me the way I loved her… It did not. In fact I could not afford to pay the
hospital bill for the pregnancy. I couldn’t even afford the abortion the first time it happened.
So yeah… I’m like a piece of shit to the world. The sister of Sara… the Rich Lesbian I referred to: her name is
“Laura”. Laura doesn’t call me by my real name. She calls me “the sperm doner”. She is married to a columbian guy
in New York who sleeps around with young girls like the mayor of Los Angeles. She keeps him around like a dog on a
leash. To ammuse herself and because she lives in Inwood and needs a man to scare off other men from the Lesbians
going in and out her house. She makes about 100,000 a year, but has recently got cancer of the thyroid. She is a very
bitter women…but she has money and seems to love being with Maxx. I get along with Sara’s straight sister “Liz” and
of course the Autistic brother. Now that I am unemployed I am like a piece of shit.
I would not be in the unemployment situation I am now if my girl had a little trust in me. I helped throw a huge fashion
party in NYC last year and I knew some of the biggest names…. all I had to do was look good… so I brought my girl
(why not we have a child together) ….well she got drunk and humiliated me in front of some of the most important
people in the world because she thought I was hitting on all the fashion models (I wasn’t, it was networking)…. it is a
problem. I love my girl… but she holds me back because she doesn’t honestly believe that I love her I guess. Her sister
and her hate men… and they don’t trust. They have been great with my son… he stays at her parents house, but if I
had been supported by her at that party last year… I would be employed now. She wants me to be a working man like
her father is, but I am a very talented artist and I can not help what I am. I still love her… but she has not been
supportive. When people see a man whose woman doesn’t think highly of him…. well it effects the ability of a man to
market himself. All successful men have a powerful woman behind them propping them up…. My girl just wants to be
mommy… and sees me as a financial failure. But it doesn’t have to be that way. She made it that way. Art is Politics.
MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐J
noahNo-ReadTil-9Exhibit-J.txt 5/17/2011
Return-path: <ns39+@andrew.cmu.edu>
X-Andrew-Authenticated-as: 31088;andrew.cmu.edu;Noah D Simon
Received: from pcs42.andrew.cmu.edu via trymail
ID </afs/andrew.cmu.edu/usr22/mlyall/Mailbox/gp5nK6G00iWl0:BU40>;
Mon, 23 Mar 1998 23:24:38 -0500 (EST)
Received: from pcs42.andrew.cmu.edu via qmail
ID </afs/andrew.cmu.edu/usr23/ns39/.Outgoing/QF.Yp5nK4200iWl099fI0>;
Mon, 23 Mar 1998 23:24:36 -0500 (EST)
Received: from
mms.4.170.Jun.27.1996.16.34.50.sun4.51.MacMail.5.2.CUILIB.3.45.SNAP.NOT.LINKED
.pcs42.andrew.cmu.edu.sun4m.54
via MS.5.6.pcs42.andrew.cmu.edu.sun4_51;
Mon, 23 Mar 1998 23:24:36 -0500 (EST)
Message-ID: <Ap5nK4200iWl099fA0@andrew.cmu.edu>
Date: Mon, 23 Mar 1998 23:24:36 -0500 (EST)
From: Noah D Simon <ns39+@andrew.cmu.edu>
X-Andrew-Message-Size: 9556+0
To: Marta D Lyall <mlyall+@andrew.cmu.edu>
Subject: popcorn
Cc:
In-Reply-To:
References:
Excerpts from mail: 23-Mar-98 Re: bibilybobilybiblybop by Marta D Lyall
> noah--
>
> they are not "firing" me. who is telling people this?
> You don't know how strong I am, nor what is really going on. They are
> saying I am fired to create an image of me as a victim of their power.
> This is just a myth they are attempting to build because they are
> frightened.
Come now Marta, I saw the reaction John Sturgeon and Brian Rogers had to
your lecture last year. They kept on saying the words, "Flesh Packets"
and laughing histerically. and man did Rogers snap at me when I asked
him about you last semester. "Stay out of it!", he barked at me and
then he went all philosophical telling me that I wouldn't be able to
comprehend the mystical reality of academia. Never mind the little man
behind the curtin. That it was beyond my comprehension.
Yeah Marta, they are terrified of you.... so am I. But I also know your
weaknesses...they do too.
I have been talking a lot about my weaknesses and my classmates
weaknesses, but I have never told you what I see in you.
you are weak
because I think you are pissed off
you have good reason to be.
You hide it,
but it is so obvious.
and then it sends you into convulsions.
I'm terrified your going to pop.
like a raison in the sun
For all my talk of alienation
I'm passive compared to you.
I don't even come close.
please don't pop.
pop pop, fiz fiz, oh what a relief it is!
You are not an easy read at first glance you seem weak in a feminine
way. Like I could push you around because I'm a big Hemmingway guy.
1
noahNo-ReadTil-9Exhibit-J.txt 5/17/2011
When I first saw you at my sophmore review, I thought to myself that
this lady would be an easyer sell then Simon Penny. Simon Penny in my
opinion is a sharp guy, but he is no more difficult then you. you are
like a mirage. you let a guy off the hook with his VRML assignments and
send him on a trip through his own head and the worst part is that I
can't even blame you because I wanted to do it, but you didn't stop me.
I would of been much more content as a VRML drone, but that was not
meant to be. Now somehow I have to find my way back to something
tangible. That system you were talking about.
Bob Moses had a system that he betrayed because to him getting things
done was more important than doing the right thing. That is what I was
doing early on in my college career. I am reading this book it seems
that he actually did a lot of good, and so did I; I look through my
portfolio of art work and there is stuff I like. One might argue maybe
he did mostly good and then made a few mistakes later on. I mean I hate
to overllook a million people, but he made it possible for us to survive
the 20th century. We needed roads and he built them. We needed parks
and he built them. That comes down to is travel and recreation.
The computer industry is at it's best a communication medium. That is
what is important and that is what we have to work on. But who is going
to get hurt by that to get that goal achieved. Which standards people
follow are going to be thrown out? We already have the answers to some
of those questions and what freaks me out is that I am trully one of the
victims of the new standards as are you. As was Robert Moses a victim
for some of the choices he made, but he was smart and when he made a
mistake he was so arrogant that he went and hurt other people and made
them pay for his mistakes. He was angry. So where does that leave us?
Moses never admited a mistake.
I was Drawing stuff because it was stuff I could get done, but I was
really trying to find ways to make something bigger and more important
than just a picture. I thought comic books or animation might be a way
to do that, but I am learning that these mediums are just a way to make
a hot medium that is easyer to sell. and then I am finding that maybe
drawing itself is just another hot medium. That maybe I need to go back
to symbols and text. Where as creative people will we draw the line and
say that is my means of expression. I look at how adept Nathan Jim Glen
and Krier is at all this stuff in Virtual Organisms, but their thinking
is seriously more flawed then mine. No one is our department is working
in a hotter medium then the people in our class and none in our
department is working in a colder medium then me. I am a real hard
sell, and I figure if I am going to be that way then I should start
facing up to that and go to selling school.
Where is my place in all of this. Especially because like Moses my
talents lie in multiple disciplines and no disciplines, how can I
adequately be a positive force in your class? What can I offer since I
am really not terribly adept like Nathan, Glen and Krier at this
programming stuff because I am better at complaining then getting stuff
done. I totally admit that, but I also feel I have taken a fair beating
from people over the years because of that. If I could only show you my
junior high school experiences and the amount of jobs that I have been
fired from for stupid reasons. I couldn't read until i was 9 years old
and I was reading hebrew before I was reading english. The only thing I
can say is that maybe I am not good at the programming end of all this
stuff, but like usual it is going to be a huge learning experience.
What I am going to continue to do is thoroughly read the texts you give
me. The thing is I honestly believe that I could be possibly your best
student if I get things together. It has taken me 6 years so far of
undergraduate to figure out that I am realisticly just a freshman in the
things I want to do. The only reason I want to graduate so badly is
because i don't want to have to pay the price for 6 years of figuring
something out. I trully had no idea what I was doing and I still really
don't and that scares me even more. I am glad that the requirement for
me to graduate is a math or science because I think that is what i am
2
noahNo-ReadTil-9Exhibit-J.txt 5/17/2011
lacking in my programming skills. Not the comprehension but the
artithmatic practice skills
My father spent most of his early life trying to be an actor because
he was a poor history student in college. He went to Yale drama school
with all the most famous names and never made it big like his
contemporaries who you probably wouldn't know because you don't pay any
attention to the media. Now he is a teacher, and there is in my opinion
no better teacher in the world then my father. I look at him and on one
hand i see the biggest loser in history and on the other hand I see a
man who is so damn great at what he does, but it took him until he was
50 years old to get to this point and man did he make mistakes. He was
also a hard sell, but to society I think buying him is invaluable.
Here something that might explain our Finnish classmate Minnie, speaking
of people that are going to pop.
CULT. 9:59 am
THE FINNS: BEST CONNECTED
Publishers of a new almanac of Net statistics say that
Finland is right when it boasts of being most excellently
online. Its Scandinavian neighbors are also well wired.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
http://www.wired.com/news/news/email/other/culture/story/11134.htm
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------+
|N()AH +----+ |
|DAVID | | |
|SIMON | | |
| +----+ |
+-------------------------------------------+---------------------------+
| internet homepage... +---------------------------+
| http://qru.com/gallery/noah/main.html +---------------------------+
| Email Address +---------------------------+
| NS39@andrew.cmu.edu +---------------------------+
| Phone Number +---------------------------+
| Pittsburgh Pennsylvania +---------------------------+
| (412)-862-3039 +---------------------------+
| New York City: +---------------------------+
| (212)-543-0275 +---------------------------+
| NYC Address +---------------------------+
| Simon Studio +---------------------------+
| apartment 6D +---------------------------+
| 565 west 169th street +---------------------------+
| NYC 10032 +---------------------------+
+-------------------------------------------+---------------------------+
"There would thus be a fantastic irony about "matter," and every object
of science, just as there is a fantastic irony about the
masses in their muteness, or in their statistical discourse so
conforming to the questions put to them, akin to the eternal irony of
feminity of which Hegel speaks- the irony of a false fidelity, of an
excessive fidelity to the law, an ultimately impenetrable
simulation of passivity and obedience, and which annuls in return the
law governing them, in accordance with the immortal
example of Soldier Schweik."-Jean Baudrillard
And my ending is despair,
Unless I be relieved by prayer,
which pierces so that it assaults
Mercy itself, and frees all faults
-Shakespeare "The Tempest"
3
MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐K

noah-incestCMUExhibit-K.txt 5/17/2011
[27,2187,8mrOE8y00WB6ELS0BW]
Return-path: <ns39+@andrew.cmu.edu>
X-Andrew-Authenticated-as: 31088;andrew.cmu.edu;Noah D Simon
Received: from pcs34.andrew.cmu.edu via trymail
ID </afs/andrew.cmu.edu/usr22/mlyall/Mailbox/8mrNLlG00iWTQEyk46>;
Wed, 15 Jan 1997 21:44:01 -0500 (EST)
Received: from pcs34.andrew.cmu.edu via qmail
ID </afs/andrew.cmu.edu/usr23/ns39/.Outgoing/QF.kmrNLjW00iWTIEqWAg>;
Wed, 15 Jan 1997 21:43:59 -0500 (EST)
Received: from
mms.4.170.Jun.27.1996.16.34.50.sun4.41.MacMail.5.2.CUILIB.3.45.SNAP.NOT.LINKED
.pcs34.andrew.cmu.edu.sun4m.412
via MS.5.6.pcs34.andrew.cmu.edu.sun4_41;
Wed, 15 Jan 1997 21:43:59 -0500 (EST)
Message-ID: <kmrNLjS00iWTQEqW52@andrew.cmu.edu>
Date: Wed, 15 Jan 1997 21:43:59 -0500 (EST)
From: Noah D Simon <ns39+@andrew.cmu.edu>
X-Andrew-Message-Size: 1180+0
To: Marta D Lyall <mlyall+@andrew.cmu.edu>
Subject: Re: Last-Request
Cc:
In-Reply-To: <Emg4Vo200iWX05A78c@andrew.cmu.edu>
References: <Emg4Vo200iWX05A78c@andrew.cmu.edu>
Marta!
This is great! I love it. I know have a manefesto to follow. Even if
I always failed to meet its standards, but I wish I did.
One Page? In two days! How about saying nothing and doing exactly what
the text says?
I have just started reading. I like the part about incest. I emailed
it to my mother. Won't that be a shock?
N()AH +----+
DAVID | @ @|
SIMON | ~ |
+----+
Address...
5741 Kentucky Ave PGH PA 15232
Netscape Address...
http:/www/andrew.cmu.edu/~ns39
Email Address...
NS39@andrew.cmu.edu
Pittsburgh Phone Number
(412)-361-6758
New York City Phone Number (Simon Studio)
(212)-932-9604
Legal Warning: Anyone sending me unsolicited/commercial email WILL be
charged a $100 proof-reading fee. Do NOT send junk email to me -
consider this an official notice: "By US Code Title 47,
Sec.227(a)(2)(B), a computer/modem/printer meets the definition of a
telephone fax machine. By Sec.227(b)(1)(C), it is unlawful to send any
unsolicited advertisement to such equipment. By Sec.227(b)(3)(C), a
violation of the aforementioned Section is punishable by action to
recover actual monetary loss, or $500, whichever is greater, for each
violation."
[29,2187,8mrOE8y00WB6ELS0BW]
1
MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐L

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐M

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐N

MARTA LYALL DECLARATION

Exhibit‐O