' FD·302 (Rev. 10.

6·95) •

DATE

09-08-2010

CLASSIFIED
FlEAS ON: 1 4

BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
c

~'[

DECLASSI~1 ON: 09-08-2035 - 1ALL INFOP1'lATIOJoJ CONTAINED
HEPEHI I~: UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT

FEDERAL BUREAU OF JNVES1'IGATION

~JHEPE ZH01!Jl,j OTHEPI.rI ZE
Date of transcription

09/16/2002

l:;7C

~ T~heabove-referenced agents retrieved the photographs froml I at his residence, however, upon review, the photos appeared to be taken around the time of the collapse of the first tower, not prior to the attack. While in the apartment building, the interviewing agents were advised by security to speak to another tenant who might have knowledge of the event. Neither agent is able to recall the name of the woman at present. The interviewing agents spoke with the referenced woman who provided no additional information. After determining that the woman could provide no relevant information, the agents thanked her for her time and proceeded to leave. The woman accompanied the agents to the elevator on her floor. While waiting for the elevator, the agents noticed a drawing, approximately eye level, on the wall near the elevator call buttons. The drawing appeared to depict the World Trade Center towers. This was evident'by the shape of the buildings depicted, with one tower bearing a large antenna at the top. There was no evidence indicating how long the drawing had been there.

Investigation on

09/16/2002

at

Newark, New Jersey

...... '""'i========:::;-...J~-\-C3-""
by

~)-I-

l-,-J1__

Dat: dictated

09/16/2002

~

C
It 1s'melperty

b7
of the FBI and is loaned to your agency;

This document contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of it and its contents are not to be distributed outside your agency.

i'O-44& (Rev. 6-2-97)


FBI FACSIMILE COVER SHEET
AU.1I~ORMAnON

flEREl~ClASSIAED ..I DATE BYfID3~""id/!J~P

CONTAINED

.

0'$

PRECEDENCE

CLASSIFICATION

D Immediate D Priority
IXlRoutine

D Top Secret D Secret D Confidential D Sensitive
IXl Unclassified

Time Transmitted: I "3 c2s Sender's Initials: -=Z;;_tHJ::":"'!:"__.--r- __ Number of Pages: +...,0 ('Z..-) (including cover sheet)

L

To:

s \DC-/C.AT- ~
Attn:L._:-:Name

cr-\l.~e2.
Date: 03/05/2002-

Facsimile Number:

~I======~;I~~~====~ ~ s ?...p~ f6 ....L..._""""""~~----L.
AC> ~..,.
2.. 3....L..__:_-=- __ _

Name oj Office

b7C

Room

Telephone

From: Name of Office Subject:

..:...~_Dt::.....__-_:~:::...D=__'L-=-

_

Special Handling Instructions: ___:c...b~~""-\.~~~~.:.....__L

_J-~' ....}.&f"'FC2~"":....--lCL.:.l,:..!C-~e...!.;-fr-.J-~

_

Originator's Name:

LI

...J-----J

Telephone:

I

Originator's Facsimile Number: Approved: L.FA j.£.R4(J

_A.....:.':\-....:....::~=JI-~.L..!.~Z::..,-1-....!.....:.l....:O::..,3;;J_----------------

7

Brief Description of Communication Faxed:

_---!!:F:....'D.l..!..-"J~O:::.....::z-=___!~~+~.J>~ _ q_!_-__!t:..::~.:.._-....:O=_'"'-_

_

WARNING
Information attached to the cover sheet is U.S. Government Property. If you are not the intended recipient of this information, disclosure, reproduction, distribution, or use of this information is prohibited (18_USC, § 641). Please notify the originator or the local FBI Office immediately to arrange for proper disposition.

DATE:

09-00-2010 ,BY TJC60·322LP./PL.J (c;) ON: 09-08-2035 iCC

Fn-542

(Rtv. 11-02-1999)

CLASSIFII' PEAS ON: DECLASSIF":[


Date: Attn:

ALL INFOPlIATIOJ.l CONTAINED ".' HEPEI1J I;:: TJll'CLAS::::IFIED EXCEPT

T!JHEPE

SH01!Jl,r OTHEIU,JISE

S~T/ORCON/NOFORN

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

Precedence: To: From: Newark

ROUTINE

09/30/2002

Newark C-9 Contact:

SA

~--------------------~

b6 h7

:::::::dB:~'1r[
(S )CaSeumIDuu'#~~IOCfNFtl

-r============L-~

0

(Pending)

(s )(s~m"~joe/NF~lEt-=;;";,;W=IN;;.;.",,,,;;T=O.;.;.;WE=R~1
Synopsis: (U) investigation. Statistical
~do:z.FLOlll.

,
bi

bl

.:';....

accomplishment
~ xtJ.'!'!'"'

report

for captioned

l"')%

Reference:

p-[-----------J-t ~ )
Transfer

~~as5'i-fy=Oxi:

~J

Details: (U) The purpose of this communication statistical accomplishments from the referenced of the above captioned substantive case file. (~/OC/NF)

is to claim serial now apart

{t

evidence

to FBIHQ

for review.

J: 1

S~T/ORCON/NOFORN'

(S)

To: Re:

Newark Fr.r\ID. (-S}GGfNF)-IL-

~E!l'/-ORG0N/NOFORN

Newark


hl

~] 09/30/2002

Accomplishment Information: Number: 8 Type: FIS/TERRORIST ACTIVITY OBSERVED/DETECTED ITU: CONSENSUAL SEARCH ITU: LIAISON WITH OTHER AGENCY ITU: LIAISON WITHIN FBI ITU: SEARCH (NON-CONSENSUAL) Claimed By~: ~ SSN: bo Name: biC Squad~:--C~9~--------------~

I

••

.t t

. ...
,~

'

(
(

'277R::f6of .€C·
~T/ORCON/NOFORN
09-08-2035 ALL INFOPlIATIOlor COlorrAUJED

-,

.tRev. Oi~~28-2000)
DATE ..09-08-2010

CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC PEA:;:OI~; . 4 I: c) 1
DECLASSIF":l mr:

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

HEREm IS UNCLASSIFIED 1jJHEFE SHOl!JJ!1 OTIlEFT;JI:;)E

EXCEPT

'Date:

10/04/2002

~tn:
From:

C-9,

SAL..I

.....
b6 b7C

Drafted

By:

(S)

CaseID

Title:

(S~

,:)1
NFl·
Investigation NF)

(Pending) (Pending)
bl

-...35t/ /6~
-

SynOPSiS~ ('$./ /oc; NF.)",-To document the return of evidence to Newark and translation results, Hebrew to English, of certain pocket litter collected from the

High Fivers on 09/11/2001.

'GAl (~I tee,
Full Field

llec":tas s i fy ell.
(U) Reference: (S/ /OC,

~.
06/26/2002

t

Instituted:

]

bl

'(S)
bl

(S)

I
(S)

Details: ¢OC,NF) requested FBI Newark to ~r the collected pocke 1 er 0 ea. e evt ence was received by the L___jon 09/13/2002, at FBlliQ. The it luded personal notebooks/journals, address books, personal organizers, personal letters, business cards, and assorted documents such as passports, phone cards, maps and other documents associated with the five and the moving business1 seized from the "HiSh Fivers", I !an~ J ~--------------------------~

b b7

~:~!~1~~=~J~~:i!d~~E£: ~::;O~~!/g& rovided the $
ET/ORCON/NOFORN

fsi/oC,NF) Copies of the personal notebooks/journals, address books, personal organizers.personal letters, documents, and books in were made for the

h7e:

bl

Field Office (WFO). The first group of documents was translate , an su seguently retrieved by SAOat WFO, on 09/19/2002. The second group was provided to CLI Jthat day.

bl

:l.'
~ •••

-•
a

:t

~
TRO N(eSw) k ~. a[. e
From·

S~T/ORCON/NOFORN
C]nterint~l~,:~~~dC~
lO/04/20,{),2'._"" '_,
'-b'l b6 b7C

~------------~~

09/20/2002.
(U)

CL I

Itranslated the documents, which were retrieved by SADat

WFO, on

--'ffijIOC,NF). The translated docu'ments indicate the notebooks, journals, and address 'b~~ks\"V~fe'of personal nature. The translations include travel accounts, friends and a associates phone numbers, and family letters. CLI lopined there was nothing of Foreign Intelligence nature in the documents.

( S) -----------------------

~The following pidence is being returned to Newark: 1B25 BC EO~~34, and 1B25 BCE01889039,fromcas~ UB4 E01889578, 1B30, 1BIL~ \ -:::> (U) ------------------------------------~ For Newark, copies of the translated documents, from Hebrew to English, are attached hereto.

b1

~ORCON/NOFORN
2

8-2010 BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC 1

4-

I:

DECLASSIFY

09-08-2035

~T
eLI
OFFICE: FBI Headquarters OFFICIAL: SSAL..I ----'

"_
September

ALL INFOPl'l.ATImr
HEP,Enr IS

Co]ITAINED
EXCEPT

U1JCLASSIFIED

~JHERE SH01!JII OTHEPJnJISE

was~hi-:-" n-gt-:-o-n-F~i:-e1"ld;---___'
17, 2002 REQUESTING REQUESTING

CASE TITLE: National CASE ID:[ LANGUAGE: Hebrew

Security

:1 (s)

bl

WFO JOB#: 6643 Document Name: as02260f.nsd

[LS note: All foreign names and names of obscure towns in India and Nepal are approximated]

Page 29
S~T

~-":.)t

:lr~ .... t

.. ,

I,'

.s.

'.' .. , '-_'-'1~1

~ ~01&8oo~.s ~

T~

SATtHe(_

@'

BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC

.:..-.....;:~ ...;"... ' ',.!~'L ~, ~~~~~.·~.;.:..'-';.....-...:2 ....... .... ...

.'~;- •• :,,_~~::-~d:.~

... .......:.~:t:~t..:..:;

..... :*"-,:.;-:;;;.~;!,,_~~~,,~.!;;-'--,.

,.......

~~~~~~.<~~

~r<i

•.t~_

~

_

_

:"...,

~

<"

~~

.~~

£~

>

;

....

~

~

".,.

->-

~":-.

-

~

~

'

"

d

./.

"

~

.i:,

i
'I!
>

\

\

i

I

'0'

.~

"

).
:

b7A

,~:

. fI'l

I

.
"l/lOO I

:J-Rl"

\31 (JVl')

£Q.c... .

L

b7]\

".' :; p. ~ ~
,
.I ~ ,,

-·1:; .I

'1

{.1

i

~.

'\.

:
,

'·~-""I~

.

,

~
"

..

!

i
\

I

\

\

\,

-'

,

.

.

.

.b7A

\

"
i

'J"
,;

y

I

\,

,

I

!
'I

/

I

\

1""---- -------'1 -,
:ltft3 lfA1iC,1iIDI;

... ~~El

.

e

·

b7A

SEC~

nam~l:I mlJVJ n'?llt~l:ICl1m '1:mn 'J~J tln"Jnl 1'11Nn?m 'tmv ?v
1973-1970 ,n"t'JV N?~

lR.R. Tolkien THE HOBBIT
'~1 n11~ :l11~tll'111 l'i'~)" ~N)~' 1~m 11')~'OV1Uil1'00 /''''~1il"il 'n'~'o Il)NO,1936 l'Il'O~:lI1'l tt{o ,lnlN It{'i'1 nmnil nlO'O n":1~~ ',N ""':llil"il ilt{1 illlWN1~.tI~l)m '~mlC1N"ll ~'O ilt 'O'Tn"~~ tlmll .('lJ~lil il'OlJ~'O llJ1l1n~) illW:J'lO~ 1W~W IlmWil Il'CW~tI',nNil tI'lJll1nil ~:JOm1W""'~'il"il N~N ,'l1~~~)j lW "ln~i')j tll,nlJ N~ )~ tI'N,nN .oJ 1~ 1~ '~'O'1tI"~)jil ,~W~l~elV '~N'V'il "'t{il"~," '0"" ~Wil11Jn .1973-1970 tI'1'Oil1'J ''ili'l'O il"OJ)) N7:JJ 1t n'O),o, 110nl'On'~Nl"j7~"l'N ili'1l0'il ~V il11'VN' il"Clil 'nN~ tI'W1n m1lJ'O:Jll'1:l'il1nNJ .n',i'0 "))lJ:J il11'il , tN ilil'O'O "mNO "JWil "'Nil'~," 0"" ~J'i' ,'J'OJ "~' ~'O ,mmi' "0'0 III il:J' il:J'1:JJ '00 ,n"Jil'n1:i'Nl "))OJ ))~j?lV ll'nll1 tI'J,,, ll"n1 ll1~V"n1V ,l'Jn1 ,no 1~'OtI~lV'l~O~ illJn~O~ '~'V'l1l'lJtm l1lt{j?nO'il~ln1:J'~))J ,ilN~Clil 11V~il 1lnlJl ,ilO'tlj?)jil M7'7))il •1m' i'1'" ll'O ,'lnOil 7V nl'717'0 111N~Om 1''1:l1n))OlWmn))V))VOil 11t{ 'n~ iltl 'OOil nN IN'i'W tl'O""il ~W tll~ 11t{ ", 7)) ''''7nilw '7l 1~,"nil n"J~7 'O'Oil tl1l111m~70 n17'lj?0' tl'7lJ N'~lJil7 l~ Nl~)j7 10'l il~,"n .n))1il'nO'ilJ 'J',nN •rj?71" ~v 0'70il"pnvo71 n1'7l1Nil tI"lJ7 TI"J))J 'Jj?ln '11"''0 tlll1n~ 10n01 il1ilO '~l l1i1'l'n~~Oi1TIN))J'O' tlil"l111 tI''O''''il "0)) 0''01n il))J'N 1'OlJJ •",:J 'O'Oil7'0 il'illnil il'nJ))il .01l1nil ,)) ,til' til' ,111'll1l))'OilOJ ,lllllJWil

o by George Allen and Unwin Ltd.
London
Cl

Hebrew Rights Reserved 1977 by Zmora-Bitan, Publishers P.O.B. 22383, Tel-Aviv Printed in Israel, 2000

Translated into Hebrew by the P.O.w. of the Israeli Air-Porce Pilots and their comrades in Abasya Prison, Cairo, 1970-1973

,0l'11' '~'?vo? ,O?~, ,p'nYo? ,?~:llO' I'N ~1'P' 11("1117 ,Y1'~ 1lN~J jOnN7 'l:l~ 11('~D1N"l11~P'N 'Y~~N ':l~ 1N1'1 ,jl ,m 100Jl1J11J1nolJ1(1nlllp,n '11N1N m iDOl '17'0 '1J1nl X1nllll10 ':l~ 'inOI.l1)]1~'l1J ,7"11J01Jlnjll1l1l'1D1J 1111)]1ll(?1( 7nnl 1101( ~

,j-

.m

111111J1)] n"lYl111'1:11n

?, ©

'1X7 C'I('X11.lj11'l"m1m? , '?YD1Jl nOD1m 111m? ,'11'0 '11(7 O'N'~11J,1"'l"m11J1 l'JI(-?n ,32 lPl1)]J1m 2000 / O"1)]n'N'1)]'l OD1l

11"l'Oil10 'Tnt{.nUltJ J'17 ill'lV))ll ,il))lJj7' ilp"J l'l1l0lJJ nm''Ol ,'l'l 1l'l'1J~7 n'~17l)j ,m1nm 100il10 '1j?J N1'i' il'il tl"'Oj? l~ n1'~J ""))11il 'VNJ .'0''''71 111l'P7'0 ll"l''O~' il,,',nil ,i1l'W ,il:i))'lJ 1'))07 tI'tll11'1l:lil~:J ll'Ol:Jno 1m 11'1j?11 I"~~J V1nl:l 100il Jm1 ill1VN'il il"""ill:l .il'W'Nl T ,'elO nt'll N~Ol'O1V O'Wl""· ilOJ1 ill:l:l1')) 'l~1 mmtllJ1 i1'~J 11m 1COl'O O'J'il tI"'Vil .7:Ji1 11))1 ~V 'llj7lJ il'ilV 7' ilt{7l:l 11l1~'TI'nJ))Jnm))7 lj?"il llmN .ll1l1n~ n1101 .N~:JJlJV'V ll'7N''O'il

..

c

",
~:•. .~ r: ~

,0,. \ \
"0

.I
l

I
1

q)~

fJ)

~~------------------------~

M l~41 QMfJV1 rf'efJ f(O'" b-J af [pJ, .
$

•'

.:'I!;rD;~'\~~i~~fiepll~:~f'~~~I'~I~ill ,:P;t,i):~~i,i),
:,1 • I
t,
f'!~I! I, ', '. '" :' ',' ,

~~lll~?:i~~~~Pf.~~~~~~:~~' t W' .~¥;,: ,i.': ml~?q;~~~,~VJ::~~I~J\~~!f\m~' i,' 'v
,":":';~W~~~~n*~n~~(Q(~l!1jl,l){'~T:ilMI6,r'
: ,;1,,'. ' '1\""' I

,"'.:~~cinll I~I:>I!J m){~D '
.'

.

111111111111111111111111111111

o 00030013239 5
3·13239 i1P~H\i " ': -. !lnT n~li1:no'o~nOI~IX '111~,l~:nf)'o~nll~l~

::r

s

.~:...}

"

,

r" -~'\

t~'\Y"':

.

._~

..

:~."

)

SE~T

c
.J

~

-u:
)

:;

~

~

:J

ts

c:

:::::r
<r

u

8

,m

Vt

.J( aH~ UllG,D -4

n

Michal Shalev

ONE HUNDRED WINTERS
e Hebrew Rights Reserved by
Zmora·Bitan, Publishers P.O.B. 4020 Ganei·Aviv - Lod, 71110 Printed in Israel, 2001
mnN) 1!J1ViD

m 190
,Dl1n7 ,u'7pn7 ,07~? ,p'nyn?

'l'~N)DI'~l NmO-

1011191iliPNI 17017

,?~'I1J? l'N

U'7P? 'K 1'\V? ,Yi'~ 1lK~~ lonK? 'ljO lR 'U~'K ,'l11UP7N 'nON ?'J IN 11' ?'J .m 1~O:l11J10mno Nlnl1Jp7n ?, - 1nK 1N
iIT 1DO:l 71?:m '01n:l Nl~11J10 ?:Jo '1noo 11J'~'11J l

.?"'~~O :lnj:l nl1J1100n111J1JN?N U7nnJ "OK

nmol1J n'1:1Y:l n1'1'lM © 11K? O'K'~'~ ,lm·n1'~T?

11K? O'R'~10 ,In'J·n11~117YOOJ '11:l'Yl 1",0 71293 .n 'lm~ n"K ,11 no~ :17 'm 2001 / N"Ol1Jn7N111J1J O'l O 12345678

FD-542 (Rev. 11-02-1999)

DATE: 09-08-2010 CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PL.J/CC P.EA:: OIJ: .4 c) DECLASSIF'"f ON: 09-08-2035


FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION ROUTINE Date:

ALL INFOPJlIATImr CmrrAINED

HEREIIJ IS UNCLASSIFIED l,JHEP.E SHOUl,! OTHEP.lHSE

EXCEPT

Precedence: To:
Newark

10/04/2002

Approved By: Drafted By: Case ID #:

If

~~=====;::;-_____. (.8') 1 U (Pending)
TWIN TOWERS

~=====.....d.{.!~---,

I

(S)

bl

Title:

(8),

(S)
SynOPSiS~~

~

I
accomplihment.
G-3""'

(J)~
, (0.1
~

Statistical
k!l!i

vcl!!t!lholle •

iiedraSsiiy
l~nterview

On.

x::t per FBIHQ request on 9/10/02.

Details:

conducted

('~-----------n

bl

"",

. '" To: Re: Newafk
(S)I
L _

From·

J

~S~ET-

New~ ::=_~ll0/04/2002

1

Accomplishment

Information:

Number: 1 Type: INTERVIEW OF SUBJECT (CONTACT & ESPIONAGE) ITU: AGENT INTERVIEW Claimed By: SSN: ~I ------------------~ b Name: b7C Squad: C9

2

·e
To: Re:

~~)afLk F_r_Q_m ~_Je_x_aa_r~flO/04/2002 __•__
(Adm)

bl

LEAD (s) :

Set Lead 1:
NEWARK

AT NEWARK

••

~;4'

Read/ clear

~,-

I

~)

(Rev. 08-28-2000)

DATE: 09-08-2010 CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC F:EASDl~; 1. 4 ( ) DECLASSIFY OH: 09-08-2035

FEDERAL B~~

S~l1

~ESTIGATION


Date:

ALL IlilFOF.11ATION CmrrAHIED
HEPEIN IS mrCLASSIFIED (tlHEIlE SHOlJN OTIlER1jJI SE EXCEPT

Precedence: To:

ROUTINE Attn:

10/29/2002

Counterintelligence

CD-2C SSA RoomL...-4,....,0::-6::-6~------'

I

From.:~ ~~ct: Approved BY~(] Drafted By: SA
L.........

~=====-----,

b6 biC

~

(S) (S)
(U)

@caseID~====:::::iiJiit:::b:eng===::...i_.:s~LL) ,___J

(S)

bl

(S)

Title:

~:~;:~t~l1~~i~r~~!d~e~~~~~e~~!teJ J ta... Mercer County Airportonl0130)2001J ~

~1

tgo~fPies of tbrat color his

b

c

(U)

Enclosure(s): (Enclosed for Counterintelli r-=-:=:.=..:=~=~......:; photographs taken from the camera of detention at Mercer County Airport, ~~~~~~~ rO/30/2001]N

(U)

Details: [Jhe photos developed at the FBI laboratory depict highway snots of various locations in NJ. One photo shows the view from Route 1 traveling North crossing the Delaware River fJ::'0rn~:Iln~ylvania New Jersey at Trenton, NJ ....e ~_~otos to T h .... ..... . .... are being submitted for any action deemed appropriate] ~ [gn 10/30/2001 the Mercer County Sheriff's Office contacted the Trenton RA and advised that they an Israeli national in custody, acting suspiciously. This individual was driving a vehicle, a white 1997 MITSUBISH , t red to the Ca.1 I had an Israeli elp s in the vehicle showing that he pal a to I near the FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION CENTER at Pomona, NJ that same day.r----lcould no~de an adequate explanation as to what he was ~that day.~was making deliveries of framed art work which was a direct vlolation of his B1/B2 visa. U.S. Immigration and Naturalization personnel on scene that day refused to take I I into custody for this violation. I Iwas charged with ~J( driving with an invalid drivers license, issued a summons aniJ~

L7C

(U)

CLASS
on

:edcJc%
""TT.><...........

.'.

REASON: 1
30a~MOI.F_C.

SIFYON:_::e'"t'~~acao~~

~I

bl

__

~I

19 ftf7

/

-_______.
released. No ... f ~t~ . (U)thisincideng~

':;nce From: ::;jl0!29!2002

Newark

~t

bl

investigation

has been conducted regarding


LEAD(s) :
Set Lead 1:

bl

COUNTERINTELLIGENCE AT WASHINGTON, DC

Read and clear .

••

3

'.

DATE:09-08-2010., (Re;',Ol-31-2003) CLASSIFIED BY 1]C LP/PL,J iCC PEASOH: 1. 4 (C:I . DECLA3SIF'1 ON: 09-08-2035

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

ALL

INFOR1-1ATIOliJ

CONTADIED

,

HEPEHr IS UUCLASSIFIED ~rHEFE SH01!Jl,j OTHEFIH SE

EXCEPT

,

Precedence: To: From: Newark Newark
TRA

ROUTINE

Date:

04/23/2003
b C

Contact:

SA

Approved By: Drafted By: (S) CaseID Title:
(U)

ding) TWIN TOWERS-

(S)

bl

Synopsis ~.\~ To report on the update of the charges against four Israel~rlationals arrested by the Mt. Holly Police Department on 08/14-15/2001. (U)

, ,,,]X

D'il_;i.¥e~

. CJrt'!III'
J(~,

!leclassifj="'@:e:.

Enc1osure(s): ~ Enclosed in a 1A envelope are four photographs deplcting the four Israeli nationals arrested by the Mt. Holly Police Department on 08/14-15/2001 and a floppy disk containing same. A 1A envelope containing an NCIC printout for the individuals listed below.

(U)

Detailsu;~ On 04/18/20031 Mt. Holly Pol~partmentwas contacted and interviewed regarding the status of the prosecution against four Israeli nationals arrested by his department and previously reported under this file. I !provided arrest photos of these individuals and a floppy disk con aining the photos.

I

b

b7

(U)

~AcCOrding tol lall four subjects ~~charged with possession of stolen property, overdue b6 rental trucks. The charges against I I DOBI I b7C and DOB I !are st1I1 pendlng and bench warrants have been issued by Bur ington County Superior Court for . their arrest. The charges against the other two subjects,1 I
.. ~ .~~. ~T-

bi

To:
Re:

Newark
(8)

I:

From.

1\TO"':""'r

04/23/2003


b b7C

c:
(U)

I DOB I Iandl DOB I Iwere dismissed. I I explained that since they were arrested durlng two separate incidents the cases were assigned to different prosecutors. This would explain why all the cases were not dismissed. A review of attached NCIC printouts for these liI1cl~V"i~ll~l~us~Ojl!_,!hat is an outstanding warrant for only there
,
..

~

This information is being submitted for any action deemed appropriate .

••

.s~
2

ftr?
bl

1·1 (Rev:5-13-99)

DATE: 09-08-2010

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION WASHINGTON, D. C. 20535

LABORATORY

.u_....IL-~

.s~-_,;
~t~j]
ALL HIFOPlIATION COlHAINED HEIlEHl IS UUCLASSIFIED EXCEPT l.:IHERE SHOUN OTHEmJI SE

CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC REASON: 1. C:I DECLASSIF'"l'OIil: 09-1'18-2035
To:

Co un teri ntelli gen ce C~- ?,C R Gam 4066 S

Date:

September 26, 2002

I

b6 Case ID
Lab

NO.~\g)020~9O:-:=:2~40~OO:-:=:3""":'L-;-Vo;-----=r;;
bl

NX _}S)f

Reference:

Communication

dated September 24, 2002

Your No.: Title:

(S) .~ __ -,~

f:§J~

r--

Date specimens received:

September 24, 2002

Specimens: " The items listed below were examined in the Questioned Documents Unit:

~"Y1

~~Ql

Notebook (Your JRJ13Y) Lined sheets bearing handwriting (Your JRJl3Y)

Ql.I-Q1.6

~}

;'\.~Qei iml Pt6iii! 6-3 ~ Declassify Oa..Hi
"-'

Enclosures (9) Page 1 of2

\

I

This Report is Furnished for Official Use Only

----

------------------------------------------~--~~


.

This report contains the results of the questioned document examinations.

R~U~ of Examinations:

The presence of overwriting, the limited nature of the text, and the limited amount of comparable writing prevents a definite reading of the beginning of the text on the bottom of Q1.3 CooM NY). Nor could it be determined whether the same writer(s) prepared the text throughout the QI notebook. However, it should be. noted that one "B" letter formation was found on Q1.5 that appears similar to the indecipherable text on Q1.3. Five (5) printed enlar~ments of this portion of writing are enclosed for your investigative assistance. Indented writing was observed on Q1.2. Two (2) copies of this text are enclosed for your investigative assistance. No indented writing was observed on Q1.3.

~ j,6

~ ';4)

Rem~(s:
~ throug 'Digital images ofQl.3 through Ql.6 have been recorded. Q1.6 are enclosed herewith. Specimens Ql.l

b6

uestioned Documents Unit

b7C

Page 2 of2 020924003 LV

,-

DATE 09-10-2010 FBI 'BIFO. CLA:::''''SIFIED UC60322LP/PLJ/CC BY
1 4 (brc di •

DECLASSIFY

0l>J:09-10-2035


Federal Bureau of Investigation
b1

In Reply, Please Refer to File

Noo[_----t]e: )

Newark,

New Jersey

07101

July 10, 2003

(S)

[
9Ptjrot¥

~ TWIN TO"!ER~

I

~~~

This document is classified unless otherwise marked.

"~T/ORCON/NOFORN" (U)

~

Closing investigative memorandum relative to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), Newark Division, Full b6 Field investigation initiated September 14, 2001, surrounding circumstances indicating that five (5) Israeli Nationals identified asl I I and Ir--------,I~d~e~t~a~i~n~e~d~i~n~c~o~n~J ~u~n~c~t~l~o~n~w,..".l,......".t",.h..... PENTTBOMB, MAJOR CASE 182, investigation, had videotaped the 9/11/01, terrorist attack on the Twin Towers and may have possessed foreknowledge of the same. (Note: Newark's initial investigation of the five Israeli Nationals was conducted under the authority of the PENTTBOM investigation. Captioned investigation was initiated after the criminal investigation indicated a possible/undefined intelligence affiliation with an _Is_r_a:li I:tellige~Ce se~ViC~.I(U)

,

• ~~~

NBWcIrt --rrrvesti gcrtTon~'fuurrd"-n-o--Ta-ctua l··-or--suhs-tarrt-i"ve ._,. ·~·-t;.r ~ circumstantial information to corroborate eyewitness accounts the five (5) Israeli Nationals "videotaped" the attacks on the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center. Investigation did find that still photographs were taken of the attack by these individuals with a 35 mm camera found in their possession.(~

~

Newark investigation found no factual or substantive circumstantial information to indicate the five (5) Israeli Nationals were on top of a parking garage "videotaping" prior to first hijacked aircraft striking tower #2 of the World Trade Center. Numerous circumstantial facts strongly support the five (5) individuals statements they traveled to the roof of the parking garage after learning of the attacks from radio broadcasts and Inte~s. None of the Pictures(Vl)
This document contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of the FBI. it

Fiq rMG'r;6~~ C4pr" ,(If r M bPi) 4, l- \-\~

and

fl

the property ~~ t;_tent'Ir===..;;,...,.;;.,;:........::.:.::........:..::.::....:..__..::...:.......:..::......:.:;;:,,:,.,.::.::....:..=:.....::...:=.......

It is

b1

-

y

S~ORCO~/NOFORN


bl

(5)

I'r----[

__

-----J!

TWIN

TOWER~

~

developed from the film found inside the 35 mm camera the twin towers prior to the attack.(Lt)

depicted

(5 )

Physical evidence found in the possession of the five (5) Israeli Nationals in conjunction with statements made by them during numerous interviews over several months indicates that is

bl

bo
b7C

L...- __

(U)

,

-

in S~t:-a-t:-e-m-e-n-t-:-s---,b:--y~=;;;-..;;;.;.;;.. associates corroborated this fact but also revea eta may have also been stationed in other countries as well. t=Newar s investigation found no factual evidence to sU9gest tnat~ I Iwas operatint in an overt or covert capacity iksrae-the United States for the_ I Furthermore, Newark found no basis to even remo ely suggest I Iwas in the p()sse~sionofprior knowledg~~ting to the attacks on the World Trade Center of 9Ill/{}~
bl

----II was

I

I

(5)
_ However N:§li~J;'k~_ inv~§_tl-_gatioI1J_9un~LILQ~hJI}9_!.o __~_l;t3~~s~ _. I L lacted in such a capacity while in the united Sta es. ~ PhyslcaI evidence as well as I Istatements to Special Ayents of the FBI corroborated Newark1s belief that I Jwas working for the Israeli Government through his employment at the I loffered no information to suggest thatl 10f tasked to perf9rm any overt or covert clandestine functlon in the Untied States •. Newark found no basis to suggestl I was in possession of or had any prior knOWledg~elating to the attacks on the World Trade Center of 9/11/01. -.

b7C

I

lor

\fJ.Xu J

b6 b7C

(5 )

.(ihysical evidence

along with statements

revealed-ah

association

betweenlL..

.JI-------------------------------.OOb

by~I----------~

1

2

(s)

···r--C----____;___-----.I-

S~T/ORCON/NOFORN
TWIN TOWER:}

CS-)

bl

(s)
More specifically, never fully revea e satisfaction of in ervlewlng agents, how hand written telephone numbers found in his personal notebook just happened to be In lite of the seriousness of Newark's investigation, and considering the totality of mounting circumstantial evidence indicating either direct or indirect links between the Five(5) Israeli Nationals
1
b

(s)

(s)

~'------'_--~--------~----JIewark N
I

found no basls to suggestl~__~1 was ln possesslon of or had any prior knowle~e relating to the attacks on the World Trade Center of 9/11/01~~

was at first the least cooperative of the Five (5) individuals, but later gave a full accounting of his travel and activities while in the United States. Information provided by I !corroborated statements made by his associates, further s~rength ning the positlon there was no video camera used on the roof top of parking garage to make recordings just prior or during the attacks on the twin towers of the trade center.(u)

~----~~--~~--~~~~

b b7C

~---.. ---~--. ~ r:A·-not~-p~dbel~~gi~g-to-1 Icont-ainedtwo-sets - bG of numbers. Investigation revealed the overseas telephone number I Iwas coincidentally subscribed to by an individual in South America with authentic ties to Islamic militants in the bl middle-eas~ . I This number was (s) later identlrled as a Iegltlmate bank account belonging to friend ofl Iwho lent him two hundred dollars ($200). The second telephone number once authenticated was accordin to BI New York, associated with an advisedthis phone nu~~e==r-=~e~o~n~g~e~-=~o~a~n~l~n~l~v~l~u~a~~~ed a hashish dealer in the New York metro area. Physical as well as statements byl land the other four (4) individuals conf i rmedj recreational drug use of mostly

':\.x 1~

B

I

l~)(1)

3


(S )[


~T/ORCON/NOFORN
1

k::---------------I!
I I

TWIN TOWERS] ~

marijuana. Newark believes affiliation with individuals found Iwas for the purchase of small quantities of jJJeqal drugs. Newark's investigation ruled out a nexus between I land the individual in South America, along with circumstantial ties to the individuals connected to FBI New York'sl I No articulate facts were found to demonstrate that I I was in possession of or had any prior knowledge relating to the attacks on the World Trade Center of 9!11!01.l~J Newark's inquiry intol ~ concentrated on his travel in the United States, along with his use of a German passport he legally acquired from the German Embassy in Israel. Statements byl Icorroborated information provided by his associates, and further strengthened the facts supporting the position there was no video camera used on the roof top of parking garage to make recordings just prior or during the attacks on the World Trade Center. Newark found no basis to suggestl Iwas in possession of or had any prior knowledg relatlng to the attacks on the World Trade Center of 9/11/01.,,-(..(.)

I

b6 b7C

b b7

r

Background

to

the

investigation:

~OC/NF)

(y.)

On September 11, 2001, numerous complaints received by FBI-NK revealed that several individuals had been observed celebrating following the initial crash of an aircraft into the Twin Towers. T-1, a resident of Union City, NJ, advised that at --"-- .app rox j mat.e.Ly9: _Q D_am_,__ T_~s_n.ej__gbbp_r_, 2_'~Qlleg __T--:T_-::1__ t11e_ on telephone to tell T-1 that T-2 saw smoke coming from the WTC. In order to see the WTC more closely, T-l used 7x33mm (likely 7x35mm) power binoculars to view the scene from the rear window of T-1's apartment. While looking in the direction of the World Trade Center (WTC), T-l observed three (3) males kneeling on the roof of a white van located in the rear parking lot of T-l's apartment complex .. It appeared as though they noticed T-l a~ well. ~OC!NF)

(9)

T-1 described the males as white, mid-twenties, no facial hair, no glasses, "clean-cut," no hats, all wearing short sleeves, with lean bpilds. Other identifying data was also provided. T-1 described the white van as a "box"-style van which 4

(lA)

• ~


S~T/ORCON/NOFORN

(s)

tF ;....._----------.L......lo--...,

-

TWIN

TOWER~

N

bl

had no windows on the si<\_ei company van. ~OCIN.f)~

J

it reminded

T-1 of a telephone

According to T-l, OBe of the males appeared to be taking still photographs and video of the other males with the WTC in the background. All of the males appeared to be jovial in that they smiled, hugged one another, and gave "high fives." (See attached photos). As the vehicle later left that area, T-l recorded the license plate as JRJ-13Y. Later that day when T-1's spouse returned home, T-1 provided the police wit~ the informat,ion pertaining to the males. ~OC/NF)~) Another complaint received by FBI-NK revealed a second eyewitness who reported having observed a white van in the same parking lot as described by T-l. This eyewitness, however, observed the van in the pa~king lot as earll. a, 8:00am on the morning of the explosions at WTC. (e.y'OCj-N:E"}~.J A third complainant later reported having seen, on September 11, 2001 (time not noted), a "big, white, model 2000 Chevrolet van, or possibly panel truck or U-Haul truck, bearing the words "Urban Movers" in black lettering along the side. The vehicle was observed in the Liberty State Park's Marine Terminal in Jersey Cit" NJ, located across the Hudson River from WTC. (..sJOC{NF) ~ ) Pursuant to this information, East Rutherford, NJ police authorities stopped an Urban Moving Systems van at a pre_, __ __p_Q$_i t:i,_Q.I1ed roacll?lQ.c]c_.~._1'h? _ocgupie_d.by Il!.ale~ _"-9_IlL __~j..mila!_._to _ . those described by witnesses, was traveling eastbound along State Route 3 in New Jersey. Following the stop, the police detained five (5) individuals, all believed to be Israeli Nationals, on the grounds that they may have possessed information pertaining to the WTC explosions. The matter was later forwarded to FBI-NK for further investigation. The individuals were detained for questioning and later)held for violations of their immigration status. ~OC/NF) ~ A search of the van and individuals was conducted at the time of the vehicle stop. The vehicle was also searched by a trained bomb-sniffing dog which yielded a positive result for the presence of explosive traces. Swabs of the vehicle's interior ~_)
5


samples were sent to the crime WOCINF)~ ) laboratory

(S)
were taken, for further and those analysis.

Seizure of the individuals' property yielded the following: a 35mm camera, several personal telephone-style notebooks, back packs, airline tickets with immediate travel dates for destinations world-wide, Israeli passports (in some case, expired), a German passport, and thousands of dollars of cash. Student identification cards later believed to be false were also found. Oddly, equipment typically used in a moving company's daily duties was not found, including work gloves, blankets, straps, ropes, boxes, dollies, rollers, etc. Also not found was the video camera that T-1 observed at least one of the males using to film the explosion at WTC. +S-Ioc/Nin, \A ) The five (5) detained Israeli
r--.a....o:...,_------.

b Nationals~ w biC and L...,----:--....,...--...J ~w';::e-;:::r::::e:--::l-;n~t:-;e::-:r:;:';v;;"l~e~w=e'::Ja---;:;s:;-;u~b:-:;J~e::-::c:;-:;t:e 0 f det e rmi nin g whether a video camera had been used, and, if so, where the video camera was to be located now. The results of the individual interviews yielded a wide array of discrepancies with respect to the whereabouts of each of the individuals as it applied to time period of the attack on the WTC. ~OC/N.p)~)

I

>0

-

advised interviewing agents that after having arrlved at hlS workplace, Urban Moving Systems, located at b 3 18th Street, Weehawken, NJ, around 8:00 am, September 11, 2001, b7C he received a telephone call informing him that the first ---_-.explClS ion bad_Qccur.r_eocL.[_bLot_e_:o __ the_Bx_s_t __ e_4_Q:2Lo_s_io_l1__g_Q.tllg,;U,.y_ occurred at 8:45am that morning.] land hisl KNFI) got into a company van and departed the workplace for a Gulf gasoline service station. Then, in the company of his friends, traveled to another locatlon In order to take photographs of the WTC. ~OC/NF)\.)')

I

I

I

I

I

lalso stated that he arrived at work (Urban Moving Systems) around 8:00am. Later, afterl I told labout the explosion at WTc,1 Ilooked on the ~I~n~t-e-r-n-e~t~and to the roof of the bUlldlng to observe the WTC went and take photographs. Then, and friends (NFL) left the office and were caught in heavy traffic. Sometime between 10:00 am and Noon and while attempting to return to their office, lLl)

I

I

I

b6

b7C

6

(S)

[r---. ~

--~I_
I I

~/ORCON/NOFORN


1

TWINTOWE:J~)
at a parking photographs.

land his friends (NFI) stopped L.......:;t:-:o:--:a~n:--:a~p~artment building) to take more

lot (adj~~nt) ~DC/NF",-

U

b7C

stated to one of the police officers after his arrest that the lnitial explosion occurred while he and the others were on the West Side Highway (Route 9A in New York City) traveling northbound toward the entrance of the Lincoln Tunnel. I Ilater informed FBI-NK that be had arrived at work around 8:20 am, and only learned of the crash into the WTC from a coworker. and I Igot into a company van (the one they had used to travel from their residences inl NY to Weehawken, NJ) and traveled to a nearby parking lot to observe the WTC and take photographs. L-....-~~~~ and were at the parking lot for approximately 10 minutes, sometime between 8:30 am and 9:00 am,,) but returned to Urban Moving Systems before 9: 00 am. ~OC/NP)~

I

I

I

Film obtained from the 35rnm camera of one of the detainees was later developed and processed by FBI-NK. The photos depict and I located at an observation point later determlned to be the parking lot adjacent to the Doric Tower apartments located at 100 Manhattan Avenue in Union City, NJ. The three (3) Israelis, sitting together on top of a white van, are visibl~smiling on at least three (3) of the photographs . ~OC/N.F)~ }

I

I

I.

b h7C:

The photographs also revealed that all five (5) Israelis later observed the WTC burning from a location on top of _.thSL_roof Of__QILQ];'QgJLbiQ_y:tng_~y.~j;_E:!!l1.~.Ji~J;~.hou§_e~.12S::Cl_te_g__ c=!9:.j_~cE?nt to the Urban MOY)ing Systems office location described herein. ~;OC/NF)'(Jb At this point, more interviews were conducted to verify the accuracy of their statements, as well as obtain any additional information concerning the video camera that was allegedly used by the Israelis. .one such interviewee, T-3, claimed to have seen I lin the Doric Towers on the afternoon prior to September 11, 20U1. According to T-3, rode the elevator with T-3 and another, unidentified, Spanlsh-speaking male whom T-3 observed exiting the elevator on Floor 3. T-3 observed I lexiting the elevator on Floor 9.

b6

c

I

I

Oddly, I

Ihad identified himself, to the Spanish-speaking 7

(0l)~L-/~F

,

.

(5

I[""'~-------....:::;..._-.;"..._""ILs r ae Li.s.

~ORCON/NOFORN


b6 b7C

TWINTOWEjOO

male, as a "construction worker" working in the building until 7:00 pm that night. [Note: T-3 identified~1 ~Ifrom a photo lineup comf,rised only of the photographs of the five detained,

]~LL)

T-1, the source of the original information pertaining to the Israeli males, was re-interviewed at a later date. T-1 confirmed for interviewing agents that it was a video recording device, rather than a still camera, that the Israelis had used in filming the WTC from atop the van. In fact, T-1 recalled qtlite clearly that the camera was a small, hand-held unit, with a Liquid Crystal Display (LCD) r:;een which folded out and could be used in "panning." ~OC/NF)L!A )

In the early phases of the investigation, several other complaints surfaced concerning trucks and/or vans belonging to Urban Moving Systems that had been sighted in locations of significance with respect to the overall investigation of the hijacked flights on September 11, 2001. For instance, two (2) complaints were received which indicated that Urban Moving Systems vehicles had been spotted in the greater Boston, MA metropolitan area, one in Plymouth, MA and one in Nashua, NH. Additionally, an Urban Moving Systems truck (traveling westbound) had been stopped on September 10, 2001, near Montoursville, PA. At the time of the vehicle stop, the driver and passenge+, I land were identified as Israeli
(U) ~_ _

b b7C

~~~~O~~I~~ :~~~u~~u~~w:~~f(l;e t~: ;:~in~li:a ~~ ~. O~ 09;17/01-"
h
....J1

I

I

,.wwoPa.~s :~l'nsetO~e::r'VS~lP,3\wee~d~Nean~d($O'a 11.' ven

(5 )

·······r------------------r-I~FB~~IP~h~l~·I~a-d~e~l~p~h~i~a--n-o~t-e-d~t~h-a~t~'r---------bl
1
L....-

1

(5)

On 09/21/0T, upon Newark's seizure of documents obtained from the Penske truck in which Iwas driving, a second interview of was conducted. Istatements to Philadelphia agents 1n conjunction with evidence taken from the Penske truck lead agents to believe that he most likely was truthful. rhiJadelphia €onc±uded~~that~~he most likelywa&not~directedL

1

b7C

I

I

t~

~e

()

r,[~

8

."
(5 ) ( 5) ~

..

'


~RET/ORCON/NOFORN - TWIN


I

TOWEj~
bl

~'l)

and did not have any prior

knowledgeof the attacks that occurred on 09/ll/0l.(~
~ ~O~n~09/17/01, a polygraph examination of I Iwas ~ __~ __~ __~I A follow-up interview ofl Ion 09/21/01 was conducted along with a second polygraph which indicated he showed Again, the Philadelphia agents opined thatl I and did not have any prio~/k~wledge that occurred on 09/11/01~)~ of the terrorist attacks
bl b6

biC

(5 )

Based primarily on the inconsistencies found in the statements of the five (5) detained Israelis, and the interviews conducted of T-1 and other tenants of the Doric Towers ~~~~~S,C!BI-NK conducted 01 ra hs of on the issue of

bl
hfi

biC

(5 )
Based upon the aforementioneo facts, FBI-NK then obtained a search warrant for a search of the offices of Urban Moving Systems in Weehawken, NJ. The search, conducted on September 13, 200),.~t with negative results concerning a video camera . ~OC/NF)G\A } At this point in the PENTTBOM investigation, Agents of FBI-NK's Foreign Counterintelligence (FCI) squad were consulted

(5 )

... ~~c::t;~~!! -

~o=~-tb_i~;:=aelis.
~
WTC,

b

aased UPQ~e~~:l~d~nd··.~ c

(5 )
lUI

I

detainees to the eXQ10SiO~

deception over the allege usage of a video camera the Israelis, and the noticeably positive reaction d,a:strated bv the Israelj 70C/NF)

th _~

I

1. Did the Israeli natiotals have foreknowledge of the events atWTC and were they filming the events prior to and in anticipation of the explosion?,%"OC/NF)

······(5)

bl

9

...

"J

(5)

t'l"1---------------.1revealed two referencest r~o~a~I luIe!bjC~f]]J~~c~~~~tifiedl

~/ORCON/NOFORN


~
bl b6 b7C

TWIN TOWE::J

(U)

~ __ bo~r~n~==============~--~ I as an IL.. ....J

~1

(U)

Based on information provided by the Miami Division, Newark initially detained and interviewed four (4) employees of Classic International Movers, a New Jersey-based moving company which was believed by Miami to have been utilized as a mover by one of the nineteen (19) alleged hijackers involved in the terrorist attacks. All four detained employees, were identified as Israeli nationals, who had and recently entered the U.S. from var10US locat10ns 1n South

I

I

America

~OC/NF)

b6 biC

(5)

Of note 1S t at tete aSS1C n erna lona Movers also appeared in one aforementioned notebooks seized from the five (5) Israelis already held in detention by FBI-NK. (~/OC/NF)

....---------------.

FBI-NK then conducted polygraphs of land .-----------~I to determine whether either possessed prio~r~ ~ knowledge of the attack on the WTC. Not surprisingly,L..I ~ who was not even present when the initial photographs were taken from the apartment parking lot,l who wa9 J2resent in the p~dng lot, OC iN F-) -'c.":

I

b
C

It!

r

I

l
bl b b7C

(5 )
~~~~~m~~~~T~~~IeSS

••

the detainees whether

lIiteLv lew S tl~~:~n~~~e~~~e~t~~e~:~~~m!~~~~ themselves and b other independent investigation, and I Icoul~ have been at the int prior to the first explosion

FBI-NK obtained witness statements and a gasoline receipt from the Gulf service station where the Israelis had purchased gasoline on September 11. Investigation determined that the Israelis purchased gasoline at approximately 2:14 pm, 12

lUt)

..

rl

,I

t,

T/ORCON/NOFORN - TWIN


b b7

(S)

TOWER:1~

which was subsequently corroborated by reviewing the photographs taken bX the Israelis (themselves) that day. One such photograph depictsl lusing a squeegee to clean the windows of an Urban Moving Systems vehicle. Because the picture is chronologically one of the last taken that day, the gasoline haq to, ~ave been purchased after the attack on the WTC. tsrGC!NF)'~~ A review of EZ-Pass records provided little by way of determining the exact location of the Israeli's vehicle (white van) during the actual time of the attack. According to EZ-Pass, the Urban Moving Systems van used by the Israelis to travel from Brooklyn, NY (location of their residences) to Weehawken, NJ on the morning of September 11, 2001 passed through the BrOOklY~,~N}Y entrance to the Brooklyn-Battery Tunnel at 7:48 am. ~C/NF,~ FBI-NK obtained the videotape of a local news helicopter crew which provided footage of the explosion beginning just minutes after the initial impact of the aircraft into the North Tower (Tower #1) of the WTC. A comparison of this videotape with the still photographs taken by the Israelis implied that the Israelis photographs were taken closer in time to the explosion of Tower #2 (South Tower) than to the initial impact into Tower #1. This comparison, albeit non-scientific, corroborated the three Israelis' claim that they departed Urban Moving Systems for the parking lot observation point after hearing of the initial explosion.(~) Liaison with the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) ~ _ _;r::::..:E?_§JIJ -NK ob_~~n.ing~_9._ tJ?..<i.i!l XB]: d\lP1Jcat~ r§<;:or~L9_L t_h§___ _ ~.,._ metropolitan New York Air Traffic Control radar traffic records for the morning of September 11, 2001. By way of background, one of the earliest photographs taken by the Israelis from the parking lot observation point shows what is believed to be a local news helicopter hovering over the Hudson River between the parking lot and the WTC (this helicopter appeared in the foreground of the third photograph" taken) . The FAA's radar traffic records identify a helicopter, belonging to a local radio station AM 880, slowly traveling in a southerly direc~ion down the Hudson River and then hovering from 8:50 am until 9:03 am, (the time of the crash into Tower #2), between Union City and the WTC on the morning of September 11. Although the results of this (U) analysis verified that the Israelis VlE:.r:-eCitthE:pa:r)(i,ngl:()t~W: 13

..

P 'I

t

(S)

(---~I-

S~/ORCON/NOFORN


am, it did not provide

TWINTOWERjl?-)
9:03

IUI~b;;~1~o~i~~~n~~~~~~®~nd

According to T-1, it was the call from T-2, who is Tl's neighbor and close friend, which initially prompted T-1 to look out of the window towards the WTC. It was at that time that T-1 had also observed the Israelis atop the white van. Since T-1 believed that T-2's call came immediately after the first explosion at the WTC, FBI-NK attempted to obtain the toll records of T-2's residential telphone with a view toward determining the exact time of T-2's call. Unfortunately, electronic records of local calls such as that are not maintained by the local telephone service provider; thus, no electronic "time stamp" verifying T-~'s observation of the Israelis could be obtained. ~OC/NF')~) , An interview of T-5, r lat Urban Moving Systems, revealed that upon "ciocklng In'' a work at 8:58 am on the morning of Se tember 11, 2001, T-5 had observed I and in the local dis~atch area of the company. he Internet, was also present. n or unately, a second interview of T-5 was not conducted with the intent of verifying T-5's earlier statements. Instead, the interview produced o~y additional background on Urban Moving Systems. ~OC/NF)~

I

I

I

I

I

J

b3

I

I

Ihad advised FBI-NK in a Lnt.e i.ew that he had called rv while traveling from the office location to the parking lot'observation point 100 Manhattan Avenue, Doric Towers), to inform him of their and the others) having left the office. I I authorized ~t~e~l-r--~eparturend noted that he himself was' on his way to the a office and expected to arrive there within a minute. may, thus, corroborate I Istatements with respect to the apprpximate time when they were at the parking lot . .I..s./ OC /N.F) ) ~
t o.t Low -up

I

I

I

I

I

14

-.

.
.

(S)

--------...!.....-----,I(
• •

·e
~T/ORCON/NOFORN
TWIN TOWER:l

(S)

bi

On Wednesday, September 21, 2001, all five (5) of the Isr aelis were re-interviewed by FBI-NK and FBI-NYO agents with

(S)


Two (2) of the five (5) Israelis were polygraphed rior knowled e of the· attack on the WTC. Both who had with

r e sj;

to

I
(ex

bl b6 bie

(Sl/~

b6 b7e

aav up i bra Yor k of

1""1----,1

Follow-up and

I

interviews

by Special Agents from FBI New revealed no new significant facts ~

I

b6 b7e

15

.,


.___

T/ORCON/NOFORN
...J~


bl b7C

(S)

TWIN

TOWER~

relative to the issues under investigation by Newark. Bothr----l andl Istatements were consistent with those ~ in pL..r·o-u-s__,.i-n...,.t-e-r-v ....-v-l -e ... i e...J(a} .... ws. In a letter dated 9/25/01, from Newark Special Agent in Charge tol U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service, 970 Broad Street, Newark, NJ, Newark advised the FBI no longer had any investigative interests in the five (5) detainees. Newark further advised in this letter to INS to proceed with the appropriate immigration proceedings.

I

b

(u.)

On or about 11/20/2001, all five (5) of the Israeli Nationals held in detention under authority of the United States Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) were served a deportation order, then discharged from the INS detention facility in Brooklyn, New York, and escorted by INS personnel to J.F.K. International Airport for a flight to Tel Aviv, Israel. (~J On 07/10/2003 closed. ((;..,) Newark investigation was completed and

(Rev. 01-31-2003) :~~I~~~~l[l-2011]

CLASSIFIED
PEAS01~:
14

BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC (b,c,d)

~T/ORCON/NOFORN


Date: CD-2C

ALL nrFOF'HATION COI>ITAIlofED HEREIN IS mrCLASSIFIED EXCEPT liJHERE ~;Hot!YN OTIlERTJI:.IE

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

DECLASSIFY

Precedence:
To:

ROUTINE
Attn:

07/10/2003

Counterintelligence

ucf.
SSm

---,..... _

____j

10sl

b b7C

New York

Attn:

lSO~---------------~
1- 2 r---------------.

i!A~I:----------------~~ 1-2~
SSA~L--------------~ IRSl SSA
New Haven
Attn:

squa~r~6-----------------J

I

L

I

b6 b7C

Case ID #:

(S)

(S)
Ti tle :

~

sed) osed) osed) osed) osed) osed) (Closed) osed) ~ __ ~nding)

1

"'ts+-

TOWERS;

(S) (S)
bi

S~T/ORCON/:::N~O~F_O_RN

flL_

----------------------l

~----~~

-.
To: Re:

Counterintelligence (S)

liF

~T/ORCON/NOFORN

J

From: Newark 07/10/2003

bl

SynOPSj_S:~ investigation.

To advise CD-2C of final results of ~Mived from. 89 tloacldss:dy Oii. lEila. Instituted: 09/14/2001

cJy(

(U)

Full Field Investigation

Administrative: (U), Upon dissemination of this communication, all outstanding leads set for CD-2C and the Laboratory Division shall be discontinued by Newark in ACS.
~~'ee-lHF}

Memoran~m

For purposes of the enclosed Letterhead (LHM), the following symbols were utilized: is T-2 is'''===================~---' ,T-3 T-5
b6 b7C

~~OC/NF).T-1
~(~bC/NF)'"

~~OC./-NF)'
~ (-.,t:08/-N.F).

is;.I;;;;;;:=======~ is

"'\'S4)C/NF) ,T-4 is

1'r-I

.R_.e_f,,,,,,,erral/ Consul

------r-------_-'''

:]

t

b6 b:C

I

Details: {S/OC/NF) Newark provides the closing investigative memorandU~ relative to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), Newark Division, Full Field investigation initiated September 14, 2001, surrounding circumstances indicatin that five (5) Israeli Nationals identified as L-_.--------. ~ I and detained in conjunction wlth the PENTTBOMB, MAJOR CASE 1 ,lnvestigation, had videotaped the 9/11/01, terrorist attack on the Twin Towers and may have possessed foreknowledge of the same.

b6 b:C

(\$,) (~OC/.N.E-)Newark investigation found no factual or s~stantive circumstantial information to corroborate eyewitness accounts the five (5) Israeli Nationals "videotaped" the attacks on the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center. Investigation did find that still photographs were taken of the attack by these individuals with a 35 mm camera found in their possession.
~~OC/NF) Newark investigation found no f~ctual or s~tantive circumstantial information to indicate the five (5) Israeli Nationals were on top of a parking garage "videotaping" prior to first hijacked aircraft striking tower #2 of the World

l

S~/ORCON/NOFORN
2

..
To:
Re:

r

co~nterintelligenC:Jl From: Newark (8) .1 _ 07/10/2003 C -,


r

S~T/ORCONJNOFORN


bl

Trade Center. Numerous circumstantial five (5) individuals statements they parking garage after learning of the broadcasts and Internet news sites. developed from the film found inside the twin towers prior to the attack.

facts strongly support the traveled to the roof of the attacks from radio None of the pictures the 35 mm camera depicted of the made by I is ovea

llJl.)~OC/NF') Physical evidence found in the possession five (5) Israeli Nationals in conjunction with statements ~hem'durinq numerous interviews indicates that I
ftI S

~----------------------~rbv the 1 I by t he l ladvlsed dur Lnq 'an adda t.Lona I Ln t erv Lew he was sel.ected I to I I lwo r ki.nc ou t si.de the country oT

e

1

lca

I

a ml

e

0

eln

em

1

bl L7e
/

(U)

IStatements by I I associates ~c~o~r~r~O~)b~o=r~a~tle~d~t~h,l-s~=ta~c~t but also revealed th~1 Imay have also been stationed in other countries as well. ~ewarJC s investi:ation found no factual evidence to suggest that I I I Iwas operating in an overt or covert capacity inside the Unlted tates for the "Jewish Agency". Furthermore, Newark found no basis to even remotely suggestl Iwas in the possess,i()l1o~pr~c)r knowledge lating to the attacks on the World Trade Centerof9Il1/0L

I

(

!

I

bl b6 h7e

ormatlon

(S)

,......==..,.?V.I:.:, ...~... ()C/~~) .
,--

~~Y'sic:a.l vidence alongl"'w)/J. ... e ...... _,;s., ..I.i..l.t..l.bL.. f:::..!aa.t.!::.e~m~e~n~t:..:::s~b~YL __ ~ b :J___,j revealed an aSSociationbetweenLI J~ ---I L7 ~T/O~CON/NOFORN 3

1

~/ORCON/NOFORN
bi

~~: ~~\nt:rjnteJJjqenc"'ll~~/~~/2g~;ark
liP
(5 )
I

bi b6 b7C

(5)

More specifically, never fully reveale action of interviewing agents, how hand written telephone ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~n~a~l~n~o~t~e~b~o~o~k~~'ust happened to be In lite of the serlousness 0 s lnves 19a lon, and considering the totality of mounting circumstantial evidence indicating either direct or indirect links between the Five(5) Israeli Nationals

(5)

.

I Newark found no baS1S to suggestl..,__---II __ r-----~Iw~a=s~l=n~p~o~s~s~e-~-~-~-~--IT-CY--J~ knowledge relatlng or had any prior to the attacks on the World Trade Center of 9/11/01.
was at first the least cooperative of the Five (5) individuals, but later gave a full accounting of his travel and activities while in the United States. Information provided byl I corroborated statements made by his associates, further strengthening the position there was no video camera used on the roof top of parking garage to make recordings just prior or during the attacks on the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center.
~~Ot/NF) ~ note pad belonging to I Icontained t sets of numBers. Investigation revealed the ove!seas telephone number I Iwas coincidentally subscribed to by an individual in South Amerlca with authentic ties to Islamic

l;') 4o'il-/ OCLN-F)-.------------,

b6 b7C

'Yslnt!lll~

(5 )

;~t;t~~~~~~n~!~ei:~:~l~d:~~~tled as a legltlmate bank account I belonging to a friend ofl Iwho lent him two hundred dollars ($200) The second telephone number once authenticated was accordin 0 FBI New York, associated with ani ~~ __ ~~ __ ~~~~_~ __ ~;-~~v~i~s~e~d this phone number belonged to an individual named a hashish dealer in the New York metro area. Physical eVl ence as well as statements by I land the other four (4) individuals confirmed I I r:~reational drug use of mostly marijuana. Newark believes 1_ laffiliation with individuals found I Iwas for t e purchase of small quantities of illegal drugs. Newarkfs investigation ruled out a nexus between land the

bi b6 b7C

I

I

S~T/ORCON/NOFORN 4

To: ,counb;rintelliaenc:;JFrom: Newark R~!: (~~ _ _07/10/2003

S~T/ORCON/NOFORN
bl


b6 b7C

~ ldi v.i.duaL n i

( \) ')(~/OC/NF) Newark's inquiry into I concentrated on'nis travel in the United States, along with his use of a German passport he legaQl ac uired from the German Embassy in Israel. Statements by corroborated information provided by his associates, and urt er strengthened the facts supporting the position there was no video camera used on the roof top of parking garage to make recordings just prior or during the attacks on the World Trade Center. Newark found no basis to suggest I I was in possession of or had any prior knowledge relating to the attacks on the World Trade Center of 9/11/01. ~)~OC/NF) interviews by SA's from FBI New York's Squad 1-21 of I revealed no new significant ~ rel lssues unaer lnvestigation by Newark. Both L___jand statements were consistent with those they made ln prevlous ln erviews.

~~ __~~ __~

(S)

In a letter dated 9/25/01, from Newark SAC toe==] ~ ~~ ~~ __~Iu.s. Immigration and Naturalization Service, 970 Broad Street, Newark, NJ, Newark advised the FBI no longer had any investigative interests in the five (5) detainees. Newark further advised in this letter ~o INS (o::oceed with the ]~iate immigration proceedings. _
l

(uO~/OC/NF)

bl b6 b7C

\h~~OC/NF) On or about 11/20/2001, all five (5) of the ~aeli Nationals held in detention under authority of the United States Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) were served a deportation order, then discharged from the INS detention facility in Brooklyn, New York, and escorted by INS personnel to J. F.K~ternational Airport for a flight to Tel Aviv, Israel. t~ ~PC/NF) In April of 2002 an in-depth analytical inquiry ~initiated by personnel from FBIHQ and other members of the U.S. Intelligence Community who physically traveled to Newark to review this case file. Newark was advised the purpose of the inquiry was to determine if a nexus, if any existed between the five (5) Israeli Nationals under investigation by Newark to other S~/ORCON/NOFORN 5

(U)

,

i

,• To:

Re:
/

counterintelliaenc:J From: Newark JS,) 07/10/2003

I

~ORCON/NOFORN

_


bl

(\,j()9~!~aeliationals fitting a similar "profile" some of whom were N ~ also held in INS detention around the time of 9/11/01. The analytical inquiry further attempted to determine if these five (5) individuals were possibly part of clandestine human intelligence collection network. Newark notes that the findings of FBIHQ's analytical inquiry are not complete at t~:::e~ S~ this writin. N w rk s gests FBIHQ's investigatio (/ be the repository for any fu ~ ~l~n~v~e~s~l~g~a~l~v~e~~l~n~l~n~g~s~r~elative to suspicious activities 0 Israeli Nationals not specifically related to Newark's inquiry. (U) Investigation at the Newark is complete.

b1

~T/ORCON/NOFORN 6

~

t

,

To:
Re:

co~t:rj ~S

'. nte]] oen:)
j

·1

~ORCON/NOFORN

From: Newark 07/10/2003

bl

LEAD (s) :

Set Lead 1:

(Info)

ALL RECEIVING OFFICES
appropriate (U) Disseminate information contained individuals within your office . herein to

••

SE~/ORCON/NOFORN 7

(Rev. 01-31-2003)
I DATE: 09-1]9-2010

CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC PEAZON: 1. 4 (c)
DECLASSIF""i ON: 09-09-2035


ROUTINE

~T


Date:

ALL INFOPlIATIOloI
HEREm

COloITAUIED
EXCEPT

I~; UNCLASSIFIED

1jJHEPE SHom,1 OTIlEPT;JISE

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

Precedence: To: From: Newark

02/10/2004
b6 bie

Newark Squad C-9 Conta~t : SA

I

Approved BY~ Drafted By:
IL...

(5 )

Case ID #: Title:

(S)

I

~I"-~=----------~____'__'I
~.___fA7T_N

____.AIL l (Closed)
d

I

W--:..~/
_J~
c_y

~

D-\:A
'5;(;.

'tJ1\l/O'-t

U
,~>A
rl/r

b
'_b7C

(5)

(S)I ~:
SynOPsis:'C~

_I

TO_____.WEBf""'\

bl

1

,f {2,If: LitW

To reopen and reassign

subject

case.

l~;d'
(U) Full Field Investigation Instituted: ~~~~~~~'oned
~u-~~ ~ __

09/14/2001
b6 bi

case needs to be reopened and reassigned ~~o facilitate evidence tracking. SAl I case agent, has been reassigned to HQ.

~T

f/0

hI

S~T
NPW~

To:

Re:

Newa~
(8)

From·

1_------dJ02/10/2004 ....

bl


~----~
b6 b7C

LEAD (s) :

Set Lead 1: NEWARK

(Action)

AT NEWARK,

NJ Reassign case to SAl

(U) Reopen subject case. Close subject case.

••

2

'r'
! -

..

,".

(Rev. 01-31-2003)

CLA:,:)5IFIED BY REA5Q!.J: L 4 I: c: DECL""'"

DATE: 09-09-20,

~322LP/PLJ/CC

ALL HJFOP.MATIDN CDIITlUNED HEFEIM IS UUCLA:,:):,:)IFIED EXCEPT 10lHERE 5HD1,J}J OTHER1JJI5E

ON, 09-09-2035

S~ET/NOFORN

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

precede~
To:

ROUTINE
Attn:

Date:

04/14/2004

~wark Newark Squad

Evidence

Control

Center

From:

Contac

7e

Approved

(5) (5) (5)

Drafted Case ID Title:

By:

bl

.~

SynOPSiS:~~

retention

\...0~

To provide semi-anual justification for of evidence when case is closed. '

.~
"~ll.

Pram.

S 3·' l('i-

Details:

(5 ) (5 )

Julyof03jhoweverFBTHQLs

~ The evidence related to the above-listed investigatiort was determined to be of no value to the PENTTBOMB investigation, but was found to be worthy of a CI investigation. Newarkls~CI in uir TWIN TOWERS was closed in

bl

~ __~I to assist us in determining
evidence retained

is still pending.

is~a~w-a-l~t~l-n-g--a--s-u-m-m-a-r-y--o~~--------~ the final disposi by Newark .

Newark

••

~NOFORN
bl

FIG

DATE: 09-10-2010
FBI
(Rev. 01-31-2003)

CLASSIFIED
1. 4
I:b

mro

UC6

~LP/PLJ/CC

PEA50l>l:

c,d)

DECLASSIFY ON: 09-10-2035

~T


Date: Attn: Attn: Attn: Attn: Attn: Attn: Attn:

ALL

IlIlFOPl!l1!.TIOIiI COIHAIlilED

HERE:IN IS UNCLASSIFIED lJ::'"lEP.E SHOl.)lJ OTHEPlJI SE

EXCEPT

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

Precedence: To:

ROUTINE

04/30/2004 Ii Team

Counterterrorism

os]
New York Philadelphia St. Louis San Francisco From: Newark
GMRA2

ITOS Ii CONUS SSAI

ECAU,

i~

Room

4944

r

3
b6 b7C

SSA IT Pakistan SSA IT Pakistan

Squad

Con tac t·: IA Approved By: Drafted By:

I

L.

----1

b6 b7C

Case ID #:

(t)
()

(S)
(U)

() ()

~315B-NK-C8693~~' 31SN-NK-C98832

(Pending) (Pending) I I ending) 315B-NK-I02595-EL6 (Pending)

D··

bl

Title:
(U)

~

\~~PAKISTAN

I

~

IT UBL/AL

QAED~ DOB: DOB:
b6 b7C

(U)

rL.-

,....:;;..&...::.:;.;::;.a;;.:=::....:....---.~

Threat asses sme;:n::_:t::....:....: ___!ol =======::::;-J ~/SSAN: unknown and ~~ SSAN: Iwww.antiwar.com.

I

I

;;le;!;.;..v..e.~e~

~l"a'S'S'i~y=On-;-n=
(UI

Administrative:~ This document contains information obtained under the authority of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA), 50 U.S.C., Section 1801. Such FISA derived information shall not be used in any criminal proceeding, including grand

----------m) r.r~ ~ Lt
1p---

1

To:
(0) Re:

~~~:r-terrorism From: Newark . ~15B-NK-C86934~4/30/2004

S~

jury proceedings and warrant affidavits, without the express written approval of the Attorney General of the United States. FISA derived infor.mation concerning any U.S. Person may not be disseminated to a foreign government without prior Attorney General approval. (U) Enclosurets)~'¥ There are eleven enclosures attached to this assessment. They are as follows: (1) an untitled Excel spreadsheet, 22 pages, dated 10/03/2001j (2) a copy of a document written in Italian with the 22 page FBI Suspect List, dated OS/22/2002; (3) aLexis Nexis business summary on antiwar.com; (4) five news articles downloaded from Lexis Nexis; (5) three Internet postings. Details:~ An electronic communication from the Counterterror~sm, NTCS/TWWU to all field offices, dated 03/24/2004, advised that the post-9/11 "watch list," "Project Lookout,1Iwas posted on the Internet and may contain the names of individuals of active"investigative interest. Different versions of these lists may be found on the Internet. This assessment was conducted on the findings discovered on www.antiwar.com.
.•.......... ~ While conducting research on the Internet, an untitled spreadsheet, dated 10/03/2001, was discovered on website www.antiwar.comunderantiwar.com/justin/finnlist.pdf.This spreadsheet contained names, DOBs, SSANs, addresses and other columns. The last column labeled as ID contained numbers which
I,

(U)

WI

n ~ssem~nated to all field offices by the Counterterrorism Unit as Priority on Information Control Forms (ICF). The names contained on this untitled Excel spreadsheet I
lUI

b6 b7C b7E

~The antiwar. com website describes itself as a sounding ~ara of interest to all who are concerned about U.S. foreign policy and its implications. It also states that antiwar.com has become the Internet newspaper of records for a growing international movement, the central locus of opposition to a new imperialism that masks its ambitions in the rhetoric of human rights, humanitarianism, freedom from terror and global democracy. It also describes itself as a non-profit group that survives on generous contributions from its readers. The Managing Editor is listed as Eric Garris, and the Editorial Director is listed as Justin Raimondo. ~ET
2

(U)

Re:

To:

counterterrorism ~m' Newark . 9XCf:15B-NK-C86934 04/30/2004
1

~T


b7C

(U)
L~

A__s_e_a_r_c_h I __ __o_f __UN re_v_e_a_l_e_d __ l A search of UNI for www.antiwar.com was negative.

~I
,
"

(U)
(U)

~

...... .'csY A scan of the Electronj c Case Fj ] e CEC~) revealed nume:=rousd6c~ents for nd antJ.war.com.

I

(U)

I

(U)
b7A

File 65T-HQ-1427774 serial 26 dated 04/14/2004 from the Counterintelligence Unit CD-4E/11869 to the Washington Field O~f~f~·~_'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-u.u~~~~_'~eived b the
1 1

)(Q

Referrdll

ult

(U)

To: Re:

Counterterrorism ~~m: Newark )9(e15B-NK-C8693:.J 04/30/2004

~


Referral/Consult Ll

(S)
(U) File 315M-SL-188252 serial 152{ dated 11/17/2003{

(S) (S)

bl

~~ ~ __~~ ~~ __~that he was in posseSSlon of a document which was written in Italian. This document specified that~ Iwas a suspect on an FBI list. The document contained{ Isocial security number, date of birth nd twoJlreyj OJ1S 1d.dreSSess .1 !was listed as _on a list dated OS/22/2002. This document can : e found:at www.antiwar.com!justin!CI-08-02.pdf.

1_

is

File 315N-SL-188252

serial

176

dated

12 27 2003
bl

(S)
This serial also restated ~l-n~o-r-m-a~t-l~o-n---c-o-n~t-a~l-n-e-d~l~n--s--e-r~l-a~1~152 regarding the document on www.antiwar.com.
(U)············································

the found

~ File 1 dated OS/21/2002, i~n~d~i-c-a~t-e~d~t~h-a~t~I.-------------~lw-r-o~t~e--a---p-a-g-e~ b7C length article reporting on the magnltude and value of American military and economic assistance to Israel. I Ireported in detail on all types of assistance to Israel citing one of his source~ of information as www.antiwar.com.

(U)

b7A

]_]_i]_3j2()()~~!~~ed a peaceful protest at the mai~a~:~e of RAF Fairford, UK, on 11/09/2002. The protesters handed out several articles during the protest. One article referred to suspected Israeli spies being held by U.s. authorities since the terrorist attacks in the u.s. The article was from an Internet web page, dated 12/12/2001, entitled "Suspected Israeli Spies Held by U.S." An insert at the bottom of the page provided a website, www.antiwar.com. where more information could be obtained on the suspected Israeli spies.
~ File 100A-PG-67150-302 serial 970, dated 10/03/2002{ indicated that during a Western Regional Conference of the National Alliance Sacramento Unit (NASU), a member

(U)

~T

4

e
(U) To:

¥RET

Re:

C. unt.~rterrorism o ~15B-NK-C8693~04/30/2004

!~:

~e~k

discussed a website, antiwar. com. This individual told NASU members to educate themselves about the Middle East conflict.
(U)

~ File 174A-LA-234485 serial 55, dated 11/10/2003, indicated that on 10/27/2003, a special agent reviewed t~h~e~ _ -, _ com uter hard drives seized durin the investi ation of revlew 0 two ard drives revealed between 07/25/2002 and 06/15/2003. was antiwar. com. visits to many websites One of the websites listed

6

(U)

documented

b

bIP·. biC

(U)

(U)

Newark.

There are four FISA derived references located at are 315B-NK-102595-EL6 serials 65, 71, 72 and 80.

(U)·············································

biC b7E

b biC

D6 b~~' i~

5

s~
(U)

To: Re:

Counterterrorism From: Newark ~~15B-NK-C8693~04/30/2004


b t7C

IU)

I

I
(U)

t7c b7E

)8\1

b6 b7C b7E

(U)

!J(I
.. ~ A search of Dun and Bradstreet (D&B) revealed that

b6 b7C biE b

IU)

(U)···················································

.~ One business summary was located on D&B listed to Antiwww C~/'pO Box 575 Big Sur CA 93920 with no further information available.
1 l 1

(U)

~A search of Lexis Nexis for antiwar. com revealed a California fictitious business name for 'antiwar.com 851 Burlway Rd. #202 Burlingame CA 94010. The filing date was 10/23/2000. The business desc7inti on was J i sted as adverti si no-computer witj a contact name ofl ]
l 1 1 I

J: t7C

(U)

A search of telephone number I I tpe number osted on www.antiwar.comis listed to L-__ ~~ ~~._ ~This telephone number was negatJ.veon
(U)

b bC bE

negative.

):s:( A

search of

L...-

___.I

for

L-I

___.Iwas

b bC bE

To:
(U) Re:

coun~~terrorism From: Newark Xl!.15B-NK-C8693:]04/30/2004


b6 b7 b b7E

(U)

)z(A

search of Lexis Nexis fori Irevealed~I----------~~-------------------r--~

(U)

A DMV (CA) search for~I

~lwas

negative.
b6 b7

(U)
S ('\\~A in Lexi~is

A CCH search fori A D&B search fori A~search ADsearch fori for

Iwas negative. Iwas negative.

I

I was

Iwas negative. negative.

b b bE

search of the News and Business Section located revealed numerous articles regarding I I I land www.antiwar.com. Six articles were selected for ~nclus~on ~n this assessment.

b6 b7C

b6

7

~T

(U)

To: ~~terrorism ~~: Newark Re: ~ t::5B-NK-C8693~_4/30/2004


1: 1:7C

(~~ There are numerous websites that comment on the postin~ found on www.antiwar.com. Many individuals harshly critize Eric Garris and Justin Raimondo for their views. Three postings were selected to be included in this assessment. ~~ On the Pravada website was posted an article by Justin Raimondo, "Did Al Qaeda shoot recently released footage of 9/11 WTC attack or was it someone else?" ~)~ On www.jdl-ny.org, a harsh critizism of www.ant~.com was posted that included photographs of Eric Garris and Justin ~aimondo. ~on www.chroniclesmagazine.org, an article by Justin Raimondo, Chronicles Intelligence Assessment - The Terror Enigma: Israel and the September 11 Connection," outlined the activities of the Mossad. It also included information obtained from a story in the Bergen Record dated 09/12/2002 regarding a group of Israelis detained by FBI, ~rk' for possible involvement in the events of 9/11. (An active investigation was cOIlcluc~~d.0nhe five Israeli Nationa s. For a detatled report t of this investigationuuseel _~ (ANALYST COMMENTS: The rights of individuals to post information and to express personal views on the Internet should be honored and protectedi however, some material that is circulated on the Internet can compromise current active FBI investigations. The discovery of two detailed Excel spreadsheets posted on www.antiwar.com may not be significant by itself since distribution of the information on such lists are wide spread. Many agencies outside of law enforcement have been utilizing this information to screen their employees. Still, it is unclear whether www.antiwar.com may only be posting research material compiled from mutiple sources or if there is material posted that is singular in nature and not suitable for public release. There
~T

hI

8

",

(U)

To: ~~~~rterrorism Re: . ~U15B-NK-C8693..:J

~T

From:

Newark

04/30/2004

are several unanswered questions regarding www.antiwar.com.It describes itself as a non-profit group that survives on generous contributions from its readers. Who are these contributors and what are the funds utilized for?
L.....:-----:------:"---:-----:--:-------....J

on www.antiwar.com . If t.h.i.s is SOl then what is his true name? Two facts have been established by this assessment. Many individuals worldwide do view this website includin individuals who are current 1 under investi ation and

b6

~

9

A

(U)

To: Re:

~~~~terrorism From: Newark ~ \2.15B-NK-C8693~04/30/2004

Set Lead 1:

(Discretionary)

COUNTERTERRORISM AT AT WASHINGTON, DC

(0)

.... It is recommended that ECAU further monitor the ~ postings ~~bsite www.antiwar.com. Set Lead 2: (Action)

SAN FRANCISCO AT AT SAN FRANCISCO, CA.
(U)
b6 biC

if~

It is recommended that a PI be opened to determine ~~~~ __~~~ ~~~~are engaging in, or ln, actlvltles w lC constltute a threat to National on behalf of a foreign power. ~~ (Info)

Set Lead 3:

ALL RECEIVING OFFICES (U) Read and clear.

++

10

(Rev. 01-31-2003)

·.

DATE: 09-'10-2010

FBI BJFO. • CL~:~HFIED, B'~ 2LP/PLJ REA::lmJ: L 4 \b,I~,1 , DECLASSIH 0111: 09-10-21):35

U:.

I

(}-l /cf, "..1 ,(
S?,",,\ET
~'Rl

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

ALL INFOPl'IATImI CONTAINED HEREIIII IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT ~)lIEF.E ZIIOTifllr OTIIERlu)I ~~E

Precedence:
To:

ROUTINE

Date: Attn: Attn: Attn: Attn: Attn: Attn: Attn:

04/30/2004

Counterterrorism

ITOS II CONUS II ~ea: 3 SSA J OS ECA~U~~R~o-o-m--~4~9~4~4--~

I

I

.

b6
b'IC

New York Philadelphia St. Louis San Francisco

SSA IT Pakistan SSA IT Pakistan

iiH

Squad

I

From:

Newark
GMRA2

Contact: Approved By:

IA

bG
biC

Drafted By:

(S)

(U)
b6 b7

(U) ~~!~i~~~a~~~~~;~o~h~~ed~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~;e~~~o~:~!~~l~~~:i~~~ (FISA), 50 U.S.C., Section 1801. Such FISA derived information shall not be used in any criminal proceeding, including grand
~T -..,, __ ~ ~ ~ ... ..w~-.,·- ..... ..,.'I",(.O!f~ ~ ~.
.. ~

"'-

.~Forums - Shock Video: Who Shot Neill I Tapes?

http://engfomm'lvda.m1Showthread.

php3 ?s=&threadi ...

A.

UD"n@ n PR
II
5!1J Forums>
Author

0;

I
r·.:~·1

Login with username

All times are GMT. The time now is 06:57 PM.

(..rrp;;mffi;l [;Iii:wtlgRJ r.Gillill:Iili!?llliiljiit1'fu1i!

I

and password: login!

I

(:;:®Jm,' II (._j:ru1Il:;:El1) (::":!'Wl:i:i:m:.J

News section>

Shock Video: Who Shot New 9/11

Tapes?
<l Last Th read Next Th read I>

Thread Shock Video: Who Shot New 9/11 Tapes?

Registered: Dec 2003 Location: The matrix Posts: 819

SHOCK VIDEO: WHO SHOT NEW 9/11 TAPES? Did AI Qaeda shoot recently released footage of 9/11 WTC attack v or was it someone' else? by Justin Raimondo I shivered, a little, as I watched Lisa Meyers' report on NBC the other night: http://www.msnbc.com/news/l001433.asp?Ocv=CB10 "New and threatening messages have been received from AI Qaeda. There's a videotape aimed at American and Saudi Arabian rulers and another that includes what appears to be well-produced footage of the 9/11 attacks v raising still other questions." This new 9/11 footage sure does raise a lot of other questions, first and foremost: who shot the video? It was posted on what is described as "a known AI-Qaeda website" last Wednesday, although it was taken down after a few days. Aside from the usual militaristic gymnastics by jihadi commandos, Meyers reports: "The tape also contains what U.S. counterterror experts say may be never-before-broadcast video of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks on New York's World Trade Center shot from across the East River in Brooklyn. The FBI says it is familiar with the video, which was provided by a friendly bystander. But that raises the question v how did a tape that was not widely circulated end up on a known AI Qaeda site?" It's sinister to contemplate. Video believed to have been in U.S. government hands somehow pops up on a website alleged to be an AI Qaeda mouthpiece, and U.S. government offlcials hold it up as a reason to cower in fear before the threat of another major terrorist attack on American soil. Meanwhile, the President avers that Iraq is the central arena in his "war on terrorism," and his supporters claim that we're battling them in the streets of Baghdad so we don't have to fight them in the streets of Boise v or whatever alliterative cliche first comes to mind. http://www.weeklystandard.com/Conte ... 03/4?5kcolb .asp The idea that AI Qaeda had additional agents in the area, who knew the attack was coming, would certainly explain the

OAT

AU INFORMATION CONTAINED HER.LAS~I~J.ED __
Y~

;t'l\1 .1 ..
IN!'

.

10f7

4/26/20042:03

PM

· Forums - Shock Video: Who Shot

NWl11
.

Tapes?

http://engforum.Vda.rulshowthread,php3

?s=&threadi...

v'

1

unflinching steadiness of the camera's eye as it recorded the terror of that moment. But instead of inventing additional elements and players, it's always best to stick with what we already know. So who else just happened to be videotaping the World Trade Center attack that day? Hours after the terrorists struck, five people were arrested in New Jersey as they taped the WTC from their vantage point across the Hudson River in New Jersey. A witness identified only as "Maria" by ABC News said she saw: http://www.haaretzdaily.com/hasen/p ...s!D=O&listSrc=Y http://abcnews.go.com/sections/2020 .. ,van 020621. html "Three young men kneeling on the roof of a white van in the parking lot of her apartment building. 'They seemed to be taking a movie,' Maria said. The men were taking video or photos of themselves with the World Trade Center burning in the background, she said. "What struck Maria were the expressions on the men's faces. 'They were like happy, you know - They didn't look shocked to me. I thought it was very strange,' she said." Even stranger v it turned out the five were Israelis. When law enforcement swooped down on this crew, they found them in possession of $4,700 in cash, box cutters, and multiple foreign passports. Police dogs reacted as if the presence of explosives was indicated, and, as the Bergen County Record reported: http://www.forward.com/issues/2002/02.03.15/news2.html "Sources close to the investigation said they found other evidence linking the men to the bombing plot. 'There are maps of the city in the car with certain places highlighted,' the source said. 'It looked like they're hooked in with this. It looked like they knew what was going to happen when they were at Liberty State Park.'" These guys were held for three months, much of the time in solitary confinement, and extensively interrogated. One refused to take a lie detector test for weeks, and then failed it. All five had been in the employ of Urban Moving Systems, of Weehawken, New Jersey, the company name on their van's registration. Police raided the Urban Moving Systems warehouse 48 hours later, and carted away a lot of computer hard drives and other materials. The owner, one Dominik Suter, fled to Israel the next day. A few months later, Suter's name turned up on a list of terrorist suspects circulated by the FBI to European financial institutions. http :Uwww.antiwar.com/iustin/CI -08-02. pdf The apprehended Israelis claimed that they were merely "documenting" the day's events: police confiscated their photographic equipment, and whatever film they had taken. The

20f7

4/26/20042:03

PM

Forums - Shock Video: %0 Shot New 9111 Tapes?
r 'j .

e

http;llengforumlwda.rulshowthread.PhP3

?s=&threadi ...

new film shows the World Trade Center burning from the Brooklyn side of the East River, while the Urban Movers were filming from the vantage point of Liberty State Park, across the Hudson River in New Jersey. But whomever had foreknowledge of the attack on the World Trade Center could have taken that film v and AI Qaeda operatives are not the only possible suspects. I have written at length about the five arrested Israelis in my new book, The Terror Enigma: 9/11 and the Israeli Connection, and I commend the attention of my readers to this modest little volume if they want to know more. I bring this up, not merely to plug my book, but to point out that we can't begin to understand the strange expropriation of this previously unknown footage outside the context provided by The Terror Enigma. http://www.iuniverse.com/bookstore( ...sugdz b6J9gGKNA As I prove in my book, AI Qaeda did not carry out its plans for a major terrorist attack entirely undetected. The Israelis were hot on the trail of the 9/11 hijackers, and must have had some foreknowledge of what happened that fateful day. http:/(iraq-info.laccesshost.com/schrom.html Did they shoot the footage we are just now seeing, or was an AI Qaeda film team at the ready the moment the twin towers were hit? Readers of The Terror Enigma will understand how and why the former scenario is just as likely the latter. As to how, in that case, the video passed into the hands of AI Qaeda's propagandists v it wouldn't be the first time the fruits of Israeli spying operations in the U.S. fell into the hands of America's enemies. http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/fr(576453(posts In any case, how this new 9/11 footage, previously known only to the FBI and a "friendly bystander," wound up in AI Qaeda's possession v or in the hands of a website claiming to represent them v is a mystery that the U.S. government seems quite uninterested in unraveling. NOTESIN THE MARGIN The U.S. is how completely enclosing Iraqi villages in barbed wire. A more appropriate metaphor for the occupation of Iraq couldn't be created by any novelist. Like the Israelis, the American occupiers are requiring an internal passport of all travelers coming into and going out of these villages. And, speaking of Israel, we are now doing to the Iraqis what Ariel Sharon and his ultra-rightist Likud party bloc have been dishing out to the Palestinians: arresting and detaining the relatives of "suspected guerrillas." http://www.nytimes.com(2003/12/07/i ... &partner=GOOGLE http :!(www.amnesty.nl/persberichten/NK -PB0090.shtml I can hear all the weeping and wailing on the part of the "liberal" wing of the War Party, crying out that this is hardly going to win

3 of7

4/26/2004 2:Q3 PM

I. .

Forums - Shock Video: Who Shot New 9/11 Tapes?

e

http://engforuyVda.rulShowthread.PhP3?s=:&threadi

...

"hearts and minds." The point is that it isn't meant to: turning Iraq's villages into concentration camps is designed to humiliate, demean, and ultimately subjugate a proud people who refuse to be conquered. That's the real face of the American "liberation" v flat out ugly. v.lustin Raimondo Find this article at: http://www.antiwar.com!iustin!j120803.html Main English News site URL: http://engforum .pravda. ru!forumdisplay. php3?forumid = 7 Main Discussion Forum URL: http://engforum. pravda .ru!forumdisplay. php3?forumid=2
Report this post to a moderator D 12-08-200307:31 PM lIP: Logged

JohnathanRGalt

Bzzzzzt. Error in story.

Registered: Dec 2003 Location: Cambridge, UK Posts: 821 ,

_"

I§# -r:,

Coalition Forces Member

Compare this statement:

"The tape also contains what U.S. counterterror experts say may be never-beFore-broadcast video of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks on New York's World Trade Center shot from across the East River in Brooklyn. With this statement: "Hours after the terrorists struck, five people were arrested in New Jersey as they taped the WTC from their vantage point across the Hudson River in New Jersey". We need to understand basic geography. Study a map of New York. Brooklyn is to the EASTof Manhatten. New Jersey is to the WEST of Manhatten. Justin Raimondo is to the SOUTHof the planet Uranus.

40f7

4/26/20042:03

PM

I:

F~~s

- ShockVideo: Who ShotNflll

Tapes?

http://engfonlm.Vda.ru/showthread.php3?s=&threadi

...

Last edited by ]ohnathanRGalt

on 12-08-2003

at 07:59 PM lIP: Logged

Report this post to a moderator
[1J

12-08-200307:52

PM

rl) 1~!l§Ufri!J 1~':-';:f@I1 rGLI5ZiDJ @~IIWGm!.i...jTi)
~ 2nd error

NickShow
Junior Member Registered: Location: Posts: 4 Dec 2003

And I've been spreading this word around but no one seems to lister That video wasn't never before broadcast stuff. The professional quality angle has been seen before. I own a copy of it. Why, you as] Because it's on a dvd .... put out by PBS of a Nova special. This one in fact: http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B00006ADG4.01.LZZZZZZZ.it It's from the first ten seconds of the damned program! NBC and CNr and the FBI can't get it right! Yes, it must be a conspiracy! PBS is funded by the US Government via grants! All this means is that AI Queda has access to Best Buy! Dear god someone stop this garbage!
Report this post to a moderator

D 12-09-2003 08: 11 AM NickShow,
Junior Member Registered: Location: Posts: 4 Dec 2003

~

11'-'IWi!ilIl#Jr~\

lIP: 1QQ.9.!

,@ij)j

ggrmv;;bl

@iill!!l:il?l

They also have access to Circuit City, too.
Report this post to a moderator

lIP:

Logged

o 12-09-2003
The Beat

04:38 PM

~

l1'-i[j!ii@l§1llfJjit'::tm:ilII9i~1

@~I

Jonathan

_i
.
,
,
,

re?ident beatnik

Registered: May 2003 Location: Between Mickey's ears Posts: 8774

It's my understanding that this "new" film was taken in Brooklyn . Why they would also mention A TOTALLY SEPARATEACCOUNT that occurred in New Jersey, is puzzling, but the have NOTHING TO DO WITH EACH OTHER. Nick -

So, what do they say is the reason it fell???

o 12-09-2003

.Report this post to a moderator

lIP:

Logged

05:33 PM

JohnathanRGait
Coalition Forces Member

The al-Qaeda videos are available here:

50f7

4/26/20042:03

PM

"

Forums - Shock Video: Who Shot New 9/11 Tapes?

e

http://engfo,aVda.ru!Showthread.PhP3?s=&threadi

...

http://intellnet.org/media/ Anyone with a video camera in West Brooklyn/ East NJ, or South Manhattan would have started recording that event once the news of the first plane hitting the tower became public knowledge. Justin Raimondo is hawking his book "The Terror Enigma: 9/11 and the Israeli Connection". As to the reason why antiwar.com ignores all evidence to the contrary while truth and reality take a back seat -- anti-semitism is an ugly thing.

Registered: Dec 2003 Location: Cambridge, UK Posts: 821

It's from the first ten seconds of the damned program! NBC and CNN and the FBI can't get it right! Neither can the AntiWar.com
Report this post to a moderator lIP: Logged

fil12-09-2003 07:21 PM NickShow
Junior Member Registered: Dec 2003 Location: Posts: 4 Re: Jonathan

Originally posted by The Beat Nick -

So, what do they say is the reason it fell???

Supports COUldn'ttake the strain as the columns were damaged. The dvd itself is more if you want to know the physical aspects as to why they collapsed more than the SOCial/political.
Last edited by NickShow on 12-10-2003 at 02:34 AM Report this post to a moderator lIP: Logged

NickShow
Junior Member Registered: Location: Posts: 4

.
Dec 2003

Finally the info get somewhere that is read often: http://www.thememoryhole.org/911/new-footage/index
Report this post to a moderator

.. tm h
lIP: Logged

o 12-16-2003 08: 19 PM
JohnathanRGa!t
Coalition Forces Member NickShow

Good find!

60f7

4/26/20042:03

PM

-

Forums - Shock Video: Who Shot New 9/11 Tapes?

41

http://engfOrtlIP,aVda.rulShowthread.

php3 ?s=&threadi ...

y'

Report this post to a moderator

lIP:

Logged

Registered: Dec 2003 Location: Cambridge, UK Posts: 821

D 12-16-2003 08:36 PM

~

ift,f'jlAi1Ilbllm:;;r:mr1 IQ.~~I

@@iW@J ®.£t£!lill:1'l1

rrw:~.~1 @t!JTIE'.i.'¥i1

All times are GMT. The time now is 06:57 PM.

~tI€W:~QJ&IwP!:@;"'iJ
<J Last Thread Next Thread I>

~

Show Printable Version

I~

Email this Page

I~

Subscribe

to this Thread

Forum Jump:

II,-"N~ew~s:...::s",-ec=ti:=.:on,,--__ --,-I·""'--,·I ~ Forum Rules: You You You You may may may may not not not not post post post edit new threads replies attachments your posts HTML code is OFF vB code is ON Smilies are ON [IMG) code is OFF Leaders

Mark All Forums Read

I Forum

I Contact

Us

I Forums I How

to improve

PRADVA.Ru's website

3~ ~~~ :1.952

::.<f_~,~!w '1tt~~~~:

Powered by: Pravda.Ru, vBulietin Copyright © 2003 Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.

70f7

4/26/20042:03

PM

.Justin Raimondo explores the Israelis' l'rJl1ection to 9111
v

.~

http://www .chr0lesmagazine.orgiChroniCleSI

August...

.

From the August 2003 issue of Chronicles:

1/

CHRONICLES INTELLIGENCE ASSESSMENT The Terror Enigma: Israel and the September 11 Connection by Justin Raimondo
"Remember 9/11!" is the rallying cry of the War Party; what we are remembering, however, is a half-truth. It is time to draw the curtain on the largely ignored prehistory of September 11. Although Bush-administration officials deny that they had even a hint of what was to come, government agencies were literally awash with warnings from the intelligence services of other nations-including the British, the French, the Germans, the Russians, the Argentines, the Israelis, the Egyptians, the Moroccans, and the Jordanians. The Israelis had warned us in August 2001, when they sent a delegation to Washington, handed over a list of 19 individuals in the United States whom they believed to be planning terrorist activities, and issued a nonspecific warning that a major terrorist attack was afoot. Yet there are indications that the Mossad knew about Muhammad Atta and his gang long before they let U.S. law enforcement in on the secret. In the months before September 11, the Mossadhad launched a major covert operation in the United States, involving hundreds of agents who not only kept a close watch on the terrorists but may have effectively blinded U.S. antiterrorism investigators to the activities of AI Qaeda in the United States. The evidence can be found in the U.S. government's own documents, leaked by its own employees, and in its public pronouncements before the decision was made to quash this story at any cost. In March 2001, the National Counterintelligence Center-whose mandate empowers it to identify and assess possible threats to U.S. national security-posted the following warning on , its website: In the past six weeks, employees in federal office buildings located throughout the United States have reported suspicious activities connected with individuals representing themselves as foreign students selling or delivering artwork. Employees have observed both males and females attempting to bypass facility security and enter federal buildings. If challenged, the individuals state that they are delivering artwork from a studio in Miami, Florida, called Universal Art, Inc, or that they are art students and are looklnq for opinions regarding their work. These individuals have been described as aggressive. They attempt to engage employees in conversation rather than giving a sales pitch. The NCIC warned that "these individuals have also gone to the private residences of senior federal officials under the guise of selling art." How they discovered the home-addresses of these senior officials, the NCIC did not say. At that point, two of the "students" had been arrested for immigration violations: The suspects possessed counterfeit immigration papers and identification. Later, many more would be picked up-nearly 2DD-and summarily deported to their country of origin: Israel. . The NCIC alert was the earliest premonition, some six months before the event, of September 11. It was the first known instance-and possibly the last-in which the "antiterrorism" apparatus set up by the U.S. government actually worked, to some extent. The NCIC ended its warning with what turned out to be an accurate assessment of the threat: Other reporting indicates that there may be two groups involved, and they refer to themselves as "Israeli art students." One group has an apparently legitimate AU. INFORMATION CONTAINED 10f5 1i~~!JNClASSIFIED ~ DATE ~ B'l«i03 .

,I l.i,C1f6 /"~ ..rp

4/26/2004 2:23PM

, Justin Raimondo explores the Israeliwonnection

to 9111

http://www .cYclesmagazine.

org/Chronicles/ August.. .•

money-making goal while the second, perhaps a non-Israeli group, may have ties to a Middle Eastern Islamic fundamentalist group. Federal employees observing any activity similar to that described above should report their observations to appropriate security officials. And report they did. Indeed, so many accounts of Israeli "art student" sightings poured in, from such a wide variety of federal agencies, that they were compiled in a secret government dossier. Their mode of operation was always the same: They would enter a U.S. federal facility, even some that were unmarked, and make their pitch, aggressively seeking entry through back doors and generally acting as if they were casing the joint. Since the nation's frontline Fighters in the "War on Drugs" had, for some reason, attracted the particular attention of these "art students," this document, which only came to light after September 11, seems to have been compiled and written up by the internal security unit of the Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA), in cooperation with the Immigration and Naturalization Service, sometime in summer 2001. (See "Suspicious Activities Involving Israeli Art Students.") The incidents had occurred "since at least the beginning of 2000" and increased in November: After April 2001, "the number of reported incidents ... declined[;] however, the geographic spread of the incidents" was extended "to Wlsconstn, oklahoma, and Los Angeles." In addition to visiting DEA offices, these "art students" also descended on a number of other law-enforcement and Department of Defense facilities across the continental. United States. The majority of recorded incidents, however, seem to have occurred in the southern half of the country, with the epicenter of activity located in southern Florida. Investigators associated with the DEA's Office of Security Programs apparently became convinced that, as the report put it: The nature of the individuals' conduct, combined with intelligence information and historical information regarding past incidents involving Israeli Organized Crime, leads us to believe the incidents may well be an organized intelligence gathering activity. ' These were no ordinary Israeli "tourists," as they claimed when confronted. While all Israelis must serve some time in the military, an unusually high proportion of these "students" were deployed in elite units. The DEA report lists name, rank, and serial number: Itay Simon, Marina Glickman. and Dilka Borenstein are all described as former members of Israeli military intelligence. Zeev Miller is identified as a "combat enqlneer," and Ofir Navron is a "bomb disposal expert." Aran Ofek, the son of a two-star Israeli generalt was apprehended in Dallas. Taken toqether, their credentials are impressive: "intelligence officer," "electronic intercept operator/ "special forces/ "demolition/explosive ordnance expert." A group of Israelis was picked up by the FBI after being spotted in Liberty State Park in Jersey Clty, New Jersey, laughing and high-fiving one another as the World Trade Center burned on the other side of the river. A story by Paulo Lima in the Sergent New Jersey, Record (September 12, 2002) describes how five men-"Israeli tourists"-were picked up eight hours after the WTC attack, "carrying maps linking them to the blasts": [S]ources close to the investigation to the bombing plot. said they found other evidence linking the men

There 'are maps of the city in the car with certain places highlighted/, the source said. "It looked like they're hooked in with this. It looked like they knew what was going to happen when they were at Liberty State Park." Lima reports that the five "tourists" following alert from the FBI: had been picked up after local police received the

20f5

4/26/20042:23

PM

· Justin Raimondo explores the IsraeliWlU1ection to 9/11

http://www. Chr.lesmagazine.orglChroniclesl

August. ..

Vehicle possibly related to New York terrorist attack. White, 2000 Chevrolet van with New Jersey registration with "Urban Moving Systems" sign on back seen at Liberty State Park, Jersey City, NJ, at the time of first impact of jetliner into World Trade Center. Three individuals with van were seen celebrating after initial impact and subsequent explosion. FBI Newark Field Office requests that, if the van is located, hold for prints and detain individuals. These reports attracted little if any notice. Not long after, however, the whole operation began to surface in major media. On November 23, 2001, the Washington Post ran a story by John Mintz detailing how, along with the 1,000 or so Muslim Middle Easterners jailed in the Ashcroft sweep, 60 Israelis had been picked up and held, not just for routine visa violations, but in connection with the September 11 investigation. The Post's subhead read: "Government calls Several Cases 'of Special Interest,' Meaning Related to Post-Attacks Investigation." According to Mintz's account, INS officials in Cleveland and St. Louis testified in court that these Israelis were "of special interest to the government"-putting them in the same category as hundreds of mostly Arab men rounded up by the feds since the attacks. Over the next eight or nine months, the rest of the story would come out, though it would be obscured by denials and submerged by an oddly indifferent media. "It is rather strange," remarked Jane's Defense Intelligence Digest (March 13, 2002), "that the US media seems to be ignoring what may well be the most explosive story since the 11 September attacks-the alleged break-up of a major Israeli espionage operation in the USA." (The Post's story blandly assured readers that the Israeli detainees were "observing a time-honored tradition in their country-touring the world after their mandatory service in the Israeli rnilltary," although Mintz did note that "a number of them had served in counterterrorist units in Israel.") On December 11, 2001, Fox News ran the first in a series of investigative reports that blew the whistle on a vast Israeli spy network operating on American soil-and openly posed the question of whether the Israelis had foreknowledge of September 11. According to Jane's, what is striking about Fox News reporter Carl Cameron's portrait of Israel's spy network in the U.S. is the sheer vastness of his subject. The broad scope of the operation, with its many fronts and activities conducted from coast to coast, had all the aspects of a major military campaign. In the months leading up to 9/11, Cameron claimed, Israel was waging a covert war against its principal ally and benefactor, the United States. Over four nights, Cameron reported the myriad details of Israel's far-flung underground army in the United States. He noted that some of the 60 detainees arrested in the wake of September 11 were active Israeli military officers. Some had failed polygraph tests when they were asked about "surveillance activities against and in the United States." Cameron showed how the Mossad had thoroughly penetrated top-secret communications systems. He cited veteran law-enforcement agents afraid for their jobs if they questioned Israel's role. What really caught the attention of viewers, however, was the following statement from his first broadcast: There is no indication that the Israelis were involved in the 9-11 attacks, but investigators suspect that the Israelis may have gathered intelligence about the attacks in advance, and not shared it. A highly placed investigator said there are-cjuote-"tie-ins." But when asked for details, he flatly refused to describe them, saying-quote-"evidence linking these Israelis to 9-11 is classified. I cannot "tell you about evidence that has been gathered. It's classified information." Cameron's bombshell should have provoked a frenzy of media interest and calls for an official investigation. That no such call was ever made is a story in itself.

30f5

4/26/20042:23

PM

Justin Raimondo explores the Israelilonne~tion

to 9/11

http://IV'vV\v.C~CleSmagazine.org/ChronicleS/AUgUSt.

..

"

In the first part of his report, Cameron focuses on a single aspect of a multilayered Israeli intelligence operation that became increasingly visible in the months preceding September 11: Numerous classified documents obtained by Fox News indicate that even prior to September 11, as many as 140 other Israelis had been detained or arrested in a secretive and sprawling investigation into suspected espionage by Israelis in the United States. Investigators from numerous government agencies are part of a working group that's been compiling evidence since the mid-90s. These documents detail hundreds of incidents in cities and towns across the country that investigators say-quote-"may well be an organized intelligence gathering activity." These documents included a 60-page report compiled by a number of federal agencies. In the gray, matter-of-fact bureaucratese so typical of a government document, the "Israeli Art Student Papers"-Ieaked some months later-confirmed Cameron's contention that a nationwide underground apparatus of Israeli agents, centered in Florida and Texas, carried out extensive operations in the months leading up to September 11. Their targets included the DEA; the INS; the Federal Protective Service; the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms; the Federal Bureau of Investigation; a host of state and federal courthouses and other buildings; and military bases. The leaked document describes in excruciating detail the doggedly' persistent efforts of Israelis claiming to be "art students" to get into the offices and even the homes of federal law-enforcement agents and government officials. A March 5, 2002, article in Le Monde by Sylvain Cypel was more specific: "More than a third of these 'students' claimed residence in Florida," and "at least five were intercepted in Hollywood [Florida], and two in Fort Lauderdale." Cypel points out the proximity of the two cities and reminds us that "at least 10 of the 19 terrorists of 9/11 were residing in Florida." Hollywood, a town of some 25,000 souls, north of Miami, was a major nexus of Israel's spy network and the Muslim terrorist cell responsible for September 11: Four of the five members of the group that diverted American Airlines flight number l1-Mohammed Atta, Abdulazlz Al-Omari, Walid and Warl AI-Shehri, as well as one of the five terrorists of United flight 175, Marwan AI-Shehhi-resided all at various times in ... Hollywood, Florida. As for Ahmed Fayez, Ahmed and Hamza AI-Ghamdi and Mohand AI-Shehri, who took over United flight 75, like Sa'id Al-Gharndl, Ahmed AI-Haznawi and Ahmed Al-Narnl, of United flight 93 which crashed September 11 in Pennsylvania, and Nawaq Al-Harnzl, of AA flight 77 (crashed into the Pentagon), they all at one time resided at Delray Beach, in the north of Fort Lauderdale. The most logical assumption is that the Israelis were engaged in a large-scale intelligence-gathering operation on Islamic terrorist cells in the United States. Another important piece of the puzzle is found in an October 14, 2002, article by Oliver Schrom in the German weekly Die Zeit. Schrom writes: Not until after the attacks of September 11 did the consequences of the spy ring become clear. Apparently the agents were not interested in military or industrial facilities, but were shadowing a number of suspects, who were later involved in the terrorist attacks against the U.S. According to a report of the French intelligence agency that Die Zeit examined, "according to the FBI, Arab terrorists and suspected terror cells lived in Phoenix, Arizona, as well as in Miami and Hollywood,

40f5

4/26/20042:23

PM

• Justin Raimondo explores the,l:telis.nnzCtiOn

to 9/11

http://www.Chr'lesmagazine.orgiChronicleS/AuguSt. ..

'.

Florida from December 2000 to April 2001 in direct proximity to the Israeli spy celis." The Mossadwas particularly interested in Muhammad Atta, the terrorist leader, and Marwan al-Shehi, who lived in Hollywood, Florida. Die Zeit reports that the Mossad was watching the terrorist leader and his chief accomplices very closely: Everything indicates that the terrorists were constantly observed by the Israelis. The chief Israeli agent was staying right near the post office where the terrorists had a mailbox. The Mossadalso had its sights on Atta's accomplice Khalid al-Midhar, with whom the CIA was also familiar, but allowed to run free. The title of the Die Zeit piece-"Next Door to Mohammed Atta"-may overstatement, however. As Schrom writes: be a bit of an

[Muhammad Atta and Marwan al-Shehi] lived in Hamburg before they settled in Hollywood, FloridaLJ in order to plan the attacks. A Massad team was also operating in the same town. The leader, Hanan Serfati, had rented several dwellings. "One of Serfati's apartments was located on the corner of 701st St. and 21st Ave. [sic] in Hollywood, right near the apartment of Atta and al-Shehi," French intelligence reported later. There is just one problem: There is no 701st Street and 21stAvenue in Hollywood, Florida. Serfati's rental was at 701 South 21st Street, about a half-mile from Atta's 1818 Jackson Street address. Serfati rented several apartments in the area, however, and one could easily have been "next door to Mohammed Atta" and his confederates, who moved around quite a bit. In addition, the geographical congruity of the Israeli "art students" and the hijacking conspirators was not limited to South Florida, as John Sugg has painted out in a March 20, 2002, piece for the Weekly Planet: Many of the apparent operatives had set up shop at addresses only stones' throws from Arabs in San Diego, Little Rock, Irving, Texas, and in South Florida. The Planet also has obtained a watch list of mostly Arabs under scrutiny by the U.S. government. The addresses of many correspond to the specific areas where the Israelis established bases. While the Israelis were closely observing Atta and his friends, they did not inform the U.S. goyernment what they were up to until August 2001: Der Spiegel reported (October 1, 2002) that they handed over a list of 19 terrorist suspects, with at least four of the hijackers on it, "a few weeks before" September 11, but the federal government says that the warning was for attacks "outside the United States." The warning was nonspecific, indicating only that these were potential terrorists. And there are other discrepancies thatcloud the picture of Israeli cooperation in this matter. If the Israelis had decided in August to come clean with the information they had, why were federal agents still arresting and detaining our "partners" in the "War on Terrorism" in late November and early December?

Copyright 2003, www. Chronidest-teqezine.

org

BACKTO THE AUGUST2003 ISSUE

50f5

4/2612004 2:23 PM

DATE:

09-09-2010

CLASSIFIED

BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC

REA;::mJ: 1. C:I DECLASSIFY OloJ: 09-09-2035

u.s. Department

ALL INFOP1-1ATImr CONTAINED HEREUJ rs TJNCLAZ::lIFIED EXCEPT ~JHEPE SHO~J:Ir DTIlEIU,JISE

of Justice

Federal Bureau of Investigation

In Reply, Please Refer to
FileNo.

11 Centre Place Newarkr NJ 07102

January 19, 2005

b6 b7C

Brooklyn, NY 11218 Dear

L..I

__,

In September 2001 you were detained by the United States Immigration and Naturalization Service. At the time of your arrestr items found in your possession were seized as part of an ongoing investigation. The Federal Bureau of Investigation no longer requires retention of these items and would like to return them to you. You have 30 days to make arrangements to retrieve the items or theY will be destroyed YOllr P1int of contact is Special Agent_ _ Thank you for your time and attentlon.

Sincerely,

Joseph Billy Jr. Special Agent in Charge

I~

B:'

§j~

~lng Supervlsory Special Agent

I

a..
~)

DATE: 09-09-2010 CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC PEASON: L 4 (I~) DECLASZIF":l OI~: 09-09-2035

ALL HJFORMATIOIII COloITAIHED HEREIN IS U1JCLASSIFIED EXCEPT l.:rHERE ZHo~,m OTHERWISE

U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Investigation

In Reply, Please Refer to FileNo.

11 Centre place Newark, NJ 07102 January 19, 2005

Brooklyn, Dear~I

NY 11218 ~

b6

b:e

In September 2001 you were detained by the United States Immigration and Naturalization Service. At the time of your arrest, items found in your possession were seized as part of an ongoing investigation. The Federal Bureau of Investigation no longer requires retention of these items and would like to return them to you. You have 30 days to make arrangements to retrieve the items or they will be destroyed. Your point of contact is Special Agent Thank you for your time and attent2on.

I

I

Sincerely,

Joseph Billy Jr. Special Agent in Charge

Acting

Supervisory

Special

Agent

bl

~I

DATE 09-09-2010 CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC PEAS I]}J: 1. 4 ) DECLASSIF'l Ol>J: 09-09-203.5

.~1
U.S. Department

.'

ALL HJFOPMATION CI)]ITAINED HEPEHJ IS mrCLA;::SIFIED EXCEPT 1rnEFE ::mm,JN OTIIERlJISE

of Justice

Federal Bureau of Investigation

In Reply, Please Refer to FileNo.

11 Centre Place Newark, NJ 07102 January 19, 2005

Brooklyn, NY 11218 Dear~I ~

In September 2001 you were detained by the United States Immigration and Naturalization Service. At the time of your arrest, items found in your possession were seized as part of an ongoing investigation. ~he Federal Bureau of Investigation no longer requires retention of these items and would like to return them to you. You have 30 days to make arrangements to retrieve the items or they will be destroyed. Your potnt of contact is Special Agentl . Thank you for your time and attent~on.

Sincerely,

Joseph Billy Jr. Special Agent in Charge

By: Acting Supervisory Special Agent

bl

~)

DATE

09-09-2010
I:

CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
PEAS ON: 1 4
DECLAS:HF'":l

mr:

09-09-20:35

U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Investigation

.'

ALL

nrFOF'HATION

CmITAINED

HEREIN IS mrCLASSIFIED lilHERE ~;HOlIJN OTIlER1jJI5E

EXCEPT

In Reply, Please Refer to
FileNo.

11 Centre Place Newark ( NJ 07102 January 19( 2005

Brooklyn, NY 11218 Dear

L.I

----l

In September 2001 you were detained by the United States Immigration and Naturalization Service. At the time of your arrest, items found in your possession were seized as part of an ongoing investigation. The Federal Bureau of Investigation no longer requires retention of these items and would like to return them to you. You have 30 days to make arrangements to retrieve the items or they will be destroyed. Your point of contact is Special Agent I Thank you for your time and attent~on.

06

I

Sincerely,

Joseph Billy Jr. Special Agent in Charge

Special Agent

bl

: 09-09-2010

CLASSIFIED EY tTCI2LP/PLJ/CC
(Rev. 01-31-2003)
REASOlil: 1 4 (c) DECLASSIFY OI~: 09- _ 9-2035

,
~

ALL Il~FOruIATI01'J HEREm

C01ITADJED EXCEPT

IS

UUCLASSIFIED

~JHEPE SH01!Jl,j OTHEPI.:rr SE

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

Precedence: To: From: Newark

ROUTINE

Date:

02/18/2005

Newark Squad CI-1 Contact: SA ~
By: By:
LI

Approved Drafted

I

(S)

caae ID #:~

I::
rI
I

IAt-

~sr

~

b6 b7

J

(Closed)

1

(S)

Title; ~) ~~~=T.;:;.;W~I~N~~T::-::OZ:W~E~R~S~_::-------3 SynOPSiS~~ No response regarding property seized. has been received
g.... Xl.

from

subjects

uN/>

~uem· Beclass±~liiII'

Reference:

(S

,

b1

Details~M On 01/.1912005 the writer sent ont fOllr letters referenced above, tol and regaLr-d-=-J..,....· n-g--p--r-o-p-e-r...,.t-y----,-t-:-h-a-,t--w-a-s---s-e-:-i-z-e-=d the Twin Towers investigation. The letters stated that the individuals had 30 days, from the date on the letter, to respond b6 to FBI Newark in order to retrieve their property or it will be b7C destroyed. The letters were sent to the last known address of the individuals. To date, no response has been made and FBI Newark considers the items abandoned. The items will be destroyed pursuant to FBI guidelines_

I

++

,S~

~/0
~)

FEDER.....b....L BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION FOIPA DELETED PAGE INFORMATION SHEET No Duplication Total Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Deleted 12 - bri, 13 ~ bri, 14 - bri, 15 ~ bri, 16 ~ bri, 17 ~ bri, 18 - bri, 19 ~ b o, 20 ~ bri, 21 ~ bri, 22 - bri, 23 - bri, 24 ~ bri, 25 ~ bri, 26 ~ bri, 27 ~ b o, 28 ~ bri, 29 ~ bri, 30 - bri, 31 - bri, 32 ~ bri, 33 ~ bri, 34 ~ bri, 35 - bri, 36 ~ bri, 37 ~ bri, 38 ~ bri, 39 - bri, 42 ~ bri, 43 ~ bri, 44 ~ bri, 45 - bri, 46 ~ b o, 47 ~ bri, 48 ~ bri, 49 - bri, 50 ~ bri, 51 ~ bri, 52 ~ bri, 53 - bri, 54 ~ b o, 55 ~ bri, 56 ~ bri, 57 - bri, Fees are charged Page(s) b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C - 201 for Deleted Page Info:nnation Sheet(s)_

Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page

58 ~ bri, b7C 59 ~ bri, b7C 60 ~ bri, b7C 61 ~ bri, b7C 62 ~ bri, b7C 63 ~ bri, b7C 64 ~ b o, b7C 65 ~ bri, b7C 66 ~ bri, b7C 67 ~ bri, b7C 68 ~ bri, b7C 69 ~ bri, b7C 71 ~ bri, b7C 72 ~ bri, b7C 73 ~ b o, b7C 74 ~ bri, b7C 75 ~ bri, b7C 76 ~ bri, b7C 77 ~ bri, b7C 78 ~ bri, b7C 79 ~ bri, b7C 80 ~ bri, b7C 81 ~ b o, b7C 82 ~ bri, b7C 83 ~ bri, b7C 84 ~ bri, b7C 85 ~ bri, b7C 86 ~ bri, b7C 87 ~ bri, b7C 88 ~ bri, b7C 89 ~ bri, b7C 90 ~ bri, b7C 91 ~ bri, b7C 92 ~ bri, b7C 93 ~ bri, b7C 94 ~ bri, b7C 95 ~ bri, b7C 96 ~ bri, b7C 97 ~ bri, b7C 98 ~ b o, b7C 99 ~ bri, b7C 100 ~ bri, b7C 101 ~ bri, b7C 103 - bri, b7C 104 - bri, b7C 105 - bri, b7C 106 ~ bri, b7C 107 - b o, b7C 108 - bri, b7C 109 - bri, b7C 110 ~ bri, b7C

Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page

111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, b o, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, b o, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, b o, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, b o, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, bri, b o, bri, bri, bri,

b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C b7C

Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page

163 ~ 164 ~ 165 ~ 166 ~ 167 ~ 168 ~ 169 ~ 170 ~ 171 ~ 172 ~ 173 ~ 174 ~ 175 ~ 176 ~ 177 ~ 178 ~ 179 ~ 180 ~ 18 1 ~ 183 ~ 184 ~ 186 ~ 187 ~ 189 ~ 190 ~ 191 ~ 192 ~ 193 ~ 194 ~ 195 ~ 196 ~ 197 ~ 198 ~ 199 ~ 200 ~ 20 1 ~ 202 ~ 203 ~ 204 ~ 206 ~ 207 ~ 208 ~ 209 ~ 2 10 ~ 211 ~ 212 ~ 2 13 ~ 214 ~ 2 15 ~ 216 ~ 24 9 ~

bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C b o, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C b o, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C b 6. b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C b o, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C b o, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C b 6. b7C bri, b7C bri, b7C b 6. b7C b o, b7C b 6. b7C bri, b7C Duphc ate

Page Page Page Page

250 542 543 544

~ ~ ~ ~

Duplic ate b 1, b6, b7C b6, b7C b6, b7C

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful