You are on page 1of 12

BC 501

eBusiness

Assignment: Website Analysis

Lecturer: Ian Knox

Marc Cook: 2553006


On the Web, usability is a necessary condition for survival. If a website is difficult to

use, people leave. If the homepage fails to clearly state what a company offers and

what users can do on the site, people leave. If users get lost on a website, they leave.

If a website's information is hard to read or doesn't answer users' key questions, they

leave (Nielsen 2003).Data show that web users exhibit an extreme form of channel

surfing. They can click through hyperlinks at a scorching pace, leaving only valuable

seconds for the web designer to tempt them to stop, look around, and with token

effort, find what it is they are searching for and make a purchase.

How a site is designed -- typography, color, page layout, site hierarchy, to name just a

few elements -- can have an immediate and lasting impression on visitors. And it can

keep them coming back. According to a study conducted by Forrester Research, three

of four factors most likely to drive repeat visitors to a web site were design related:

ease of use, download time, and freshness. (Rappa 2007). The first law of e-commerce

is that if users cannot find the product, they cannot buy it either (Nielsen 2003).

The area of website analysis is a contentious issue. Web analytics is an ever-growing

tool used in website analysis. Web analytics and metrics are often used

interchangeably. “Metrics are an integral part of all businesses and it can be a major $

expense both directly and indirectly” (Knox, 2007, Week 3).

Usability of a website seems regularly to bring to mind dealings between the site and

the site visitor. A company’s Website may be the first contact that potential customers

have with your business. The conversion of visitors into customers must be a primary

goal for all web based businesses. How?

Commercial and non-profit successful websites usually have these things in common:

• Usefulness of information - (Keep in mind that information is only useful if it

pertains to decisions that need to be made. Therefore, firms should be


judicious about what their information requirements truly are and plan

accordingly (Knox 2007))

• Ease of surfing on the site

• Quick response time

• Excellent product information flow

• Readability and originality

• Friendly layout

• Good listings on major search engines (Website Analyst 2007).

From a business point of view the checklist is very focused on first impressions. This

is understandable because if users don’t like a site they are just a mouse click away

from leaving. If they do stay, what web page features can help and encourage users to

complete a transaction? Some of the most important features are included in the

following checklist:

1. Is the company name and logo on every page? Is it linked to the home page?

2. Does the site have search (if needed) and does it work adequately?

3. Are headlines and page titles clear?

4. Are photos well placed, and a suitable size?

5. Do links work and clearly describe the page they will lead to?

6. Is font size and color easy to read against the background?

7. Is the transaction process simple and secure?

8. Are transactions acknowledged and can shipping be tracked?

9. Does the site have contact information and/or help?

10. Is the purpose of the website clear?

11. Do I TRUST this web site with my information?

12. Can you leave feedback or extend the relationship e.g. newsletter?

(Knox 2007).
The above mentioned checklist will be the basis used for analysis for the following

three websites: Australian Securities Exchange (ASX)

ANZ Bank

Merlo

Australian Securities Exchange (ASX)


A user, at first glance of the ASX website, might be somewhat overcome by the

plethora of information and graphics on offer. However, the site is well designed and

relatively easy to navigate.

There is a company logo on each page; therefore, the user will be aware if they have

‘clicked’ away from the ASX. The website offers a very useful search function that

assists the user to find just about any form of information to do with the ASX or a

listed security. This will save the user time because, as mentioned above, there is an

abundance of information which can be sourced throughout the site. In addition to

the standard search engine, the ASX site gives the ability to a user to search for a
particular securities price by typing the company’s name or code into the search field.

Both of these search functions are available to all users of the site and are located at

the top, right of the home page..

Search ASX

Get price / announcement / info


Codes:
Detailed search Find a code

The website is clear and precise to all users of the stock exchange. It has the

following links which relate to the information or tools required depending on the

capacity of the user.

• First-time investors
• Brokers & participants
• Institutional investors
• Listed companies
• ASX shareholders
• SFE participants
• Supervision

The headlines and titles are obvious with all of the main features and events

highlighted, such as: Listed top companies; Price sensitive announcements; Upcoming

events; Upcoming floats etc. The graphics, fonts and color schemes all seem to work

for this site. It is easily read and there aren’t any parts of the page that look unsightly.

Although the purpose of the website is precise, there are help options such as FAQ’s

“contact us,” site map and glossary links available to the user. One of the better

functions of the ASX website is the ability to register and use their online training

facility. As a potential investor, the ASX can provide you with the basics required in

understanding, analysing, and buying and selling in the market.

The website covers the three most important aspects when it comes to driving repeat

visitors; it is relatively user friendly, it has decent download speeds and it conveys a

sense of security and trust. In a brief study, I encouraged 5 different people to browse

the ASX website. All, after the initial shock from a cluttered homepage, found it to be
relatively simple to navigate, finding information they needed and were in little doubt

about the purpose of the website.

If there was to be a negative for the site, it would be the flashy advertising that catches

your attention occasionally and may force a user to forget what they were looking for

or encourage them to leave the site altogether.

ANZ

The first thought I get when I browse the ANZ website is: why didn’t they use the

whole page? I know it is not favourable to overcrowd a page, but surely you would

use the space provided. As you can see above, when the page is maximized only just

over half of the page is utilised. It may be a personal opinion, but it actually feels like

it is a “pop-up” link rather than a banks homepage, which does little for ones sense of

security.

Once a user is past the initial first feelings, the site is navigated with ease. As

highlighted below there are a number of options for a user depending on their

capacity.
Home Loans Financial Planning Transaction Banking Economics@anz Agribusiness
Credit Cards Super & Retirement Business Finance Cash Management Community
Visa Debit & Giftcard Invest your money Small Business Finance Solutions Rural Managers
Transacting & Saving Life Insurance Merchants/multiPOS Trade Finance Deposits/Investment
Personal & Car loans Private Bank Business Cards Markets Long Term Finance
more... more... more... more... more...

The links and link names are used rather well on this website, which allows for are

more tailored navigating experience for the first time user. There are three different

search options. One is the standard search ANZ function using key words. The other

two, however, are slightly different. One is an “I need” search function and the other

is an “apply” search function. Both options provide scroll-down boxes with provided

links to make searching a little easier.

As with the ASX, the ANZ displays their logo on each page so a user is aware of

when they are viewing an ANZ page.

To test the site I decided that I would try and open an account and link that account

with the internet banking facilities. The results were somewhat mixed. Although it

was easy to find exactly what I was looking for, only part of the actual application is

online the rest needs to be downloaded, printed, filled in and then handed in at a local

branch.

As an existing customer, I am and have been more than impressed with the online

banking facilities that the ANZ offer. Once an existing customer has logged on (which
can accessed from the home page), they have access to all of their ANZ accounts and

the ability to do just about anything they wish.

A menu of the main functions within the internet banking link is located on the left of

the page. Functions such as the ones listed below make banking online a pleasant

experience.

• Balances and transactions


• Pay anyone
• Pay bills
• View bills
• Transfer between my accounts
• Pay Credit card
• Purchase a bank cheque
• Multiple future payment/transfers
• Future payment transfer
• Past payment transfer

In addition to the functions above, an online banker has the ability to view and

download their transaction history of any of their accounts, up to 120 days.

Overall, the ANZ website is easy for users to accomplish basic tasks the first time

they encounter the design, reasonably efficient, memorable, and satisfying. The

graphics, colours and fonts appear to be a high-quality combination and the security is

first-rate. The drawback relates to my first comment; why isn’t the home page fully

utilised?
MERLO

Merlo is a business that stated as a coffee shop in QLD and has now expanded to 5

coffee shops and an efficient coffee and coffee related product distributor. The above

picture is that of the Merlo homepage. It is a no-thrills page with excellent colours set

on a black background. From the homepage there are three options:

• Bar Merlo

• Merlo Coffee

• Merlo Kitchen.

Clicking any of the three links will open up what appears to be the homepage for that

particular section. It is easy to see that Merlo have made a point of not annoying their

visitors with pointless animated graphics or other large unnecessary images. They
have designed their website so that visitors/potential customers can quickly and easily

find the product and/or service they wish.

The functionality and usability of the Merlo site is of a high standard. It is quite easy

to navigate around finding information or adding products to the shopping cart.

However, the site does not have a search function to fast track a visitor to a particular

piece of information or a product.

Shopping on the Merlo site is fairly straightforward. A customer finds the product

they require and adds to their shopping cart. From a consumers perspective shopping

carts evoke the physical analogy of placing products in a container as we shop (Rappa

2007). As each item is added to the cart, it is itemized and a running tally is kept for

those shoppers who are budget conscious. Also after each item the customer is given

options to check out, continue shopping or cancel cart contents.

The one thing I find a little annoying with online shopping, and Merlo is no different,

is that you always have to either log in or register before you can make a purchase. I

understand that there has to be some sort of postage details made available but the rest

can be irritating and time consuming.

Merlo uses icons as navigational devices to give visitors a sense of movement through

a site. The web storefront visually conveys the company's image and its products in a

manner that is synonymous with its business objects (Rappa 2007).


References
ANZ. (2007). ANZ Website. Retrieved: 1 May 2007,

from: http://www.anz.com.au/

Australian Securities Exchange (ASX). (2007). ASX Website. Retrieved: 1 May 2007,

from: http://www.asx.com.au/

Barnes, V. (2007). Web Site Functionality. Retrieved: 1 May 2007,

from: http://www.htmlgoodies.com/introduction/intro/article.php/3473631

Flanders, V. (2006). Biggest Mistakes in Web Design 1995-2015. Retrieved: 1 May


2007, from: http://www.webpagesthatsuck.com/biggest-mistakes-in-
web-design-1995-2015.html

Kapoun, J. (1998). Five criteria for evaluating Web pages. Retrieved: 1 May 2007,

from: http://www.library.cornell.edu/olinuris/ref/research/webcrit.html

Knox, I. (2007). Week 3 Lecture - Web Analytics and Business Models.

Merlo (2007). Merlo Website. Retrieved 1 May 2007,

from: http://www.merlo.com.au/

Neilson, J. (2003). Usability 101: Introduction to Usability. Retrieved: 1 May 2007,

from: http://www.useit.com/alertbox/20030825.html
Rappa, M. (2007). Managing the Digital Enterprise – Digital Design. Retrived: 3

April 2007, from: http://digitalenterprise.org/design/design.html

Website Analyst. (2007). Can your website actually benefit from the Internet?

Retrieved: 1 May 2007, from: http://www.website-analyst.co.il/

Website Analyst. (2007). Tips and Ideas. Retrieved: 1 May 2007,

from: http://www.website-analyst.co.il/tips.html