Geosciences Journal Vol. 7, No. 3, p.

203 208, September 2003 

Study on the exchange reaction of HDTMA with the inorganic cations in reference montmorillonites
Seung Yeop Lee* Soo Jin Kim

} School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, Seoul National University, Seoul 151-747, Korea
spectroscopy, and atomic force microscopy (AFM) have been used to investigate the adsorption of cationic surfactant to the mineral-water interface as a function of surfactant concentrations, with and without added electrolytes, and as a function of pH (Manne and Gaub, 1995; Ducker and Wanless, 1999; Schulz and Warr, 2000; Atkin et al., 2001; Yui et al., 2002). From the effort, it appeared that the adsorption of cationic surfactants onto non-swelling silicates was well rationalized and could be satisfactorily described by theoretical models. In contrast, adsorption onto swelling clay such as montmorillonite was considered to be complicated by the interlayer intercalation of surfactants and the evolution of the aggregation state of the clay sheets upon adsorption of cationic surfactants (Brahimi et al., 1992). Accordingly, the observation for the surfactantmodified swelling clays has received little attention. Although many scientists have performed experiments for the surfactant treated clays, there is not sufficient research on the surface change via intercalated surfactants through scanning electron microscopy (SEM). In this paper, our intention is therefore to lead to an improved characterization for organoclays treated with long alkyl chain surfactants. 2. EXPERIMENTS 2.1. Clay Samples Wyoming Na-montmorillonite (SWy) and Arizona Camontmorillonite (SAz) were obtained from the Source Clay Repository (The Clay Minerals Society, Columbia, MO). The montmorillonite samples were used without further purification. The characteristics of the samples are shown in Table 1. 2.2. HDTMA Adsorption Isotherms Batch equilibration isotherms were determined on 20 mg clay samples weighed into 50 mL centrifuge tubes. To these tubes, 40 mL of solutions containing the quantities of HDTMA bromide (Sigma, St. Louis, MO) equivalent to 0.02 to 1 times the cation exchange capacity (CEC) of clay samples were added. These suspensions were then shaken 7 days on a reciprocating shaker under ambient conditions. The mixture was centrifuged at 8000 rpm for 20 min to yield a clear

ABSTRACT: The adsorption of hexadecyltrimethylammonium (HDTMA) cations on swelling layer silicates (montmorillonites) was studied by adsorption isotherms, X−ray diffraction, and electron microscopy. At low HDTMA concentrations, HDTMA ions started to be adsorbed on interlayer sites of SWy montmorillonite, causing a preferential release of interlayer Na+ compared with Ca2+, while the lateral attraction between adsorbed HDTMA cations at edges or external surfaces highly prevailed in SAz montmorillonite. Montmorillonite clay surfaces appeared as foliated and irregular aggregate structures at high HDTMA loadings. Besides the clay surface charge, the interlayer inorganic cations appeared to have a substantial influence on the expansion behavior of silicate layers as well as the evolution of the surface aggregates as a function of HDTMA surface coverage. Key words: adsorption, hexadecyltrimethylammonium, SWy montmorillonite, SAz montmorillonite

1. INTRODUCTION Organically modified layered silicates have long been used in numerous industrial applications. Understanding cationic surfactant adsorption on layer silicates is of great importance due to the widespread use of those compounds in both household and commercial activities (Theng, 1975; Hackett et al., 1998; Lee and Kim, 2002). In aqueous solutions, surfactants self-assemble into a variety of aggregate shapes including spherical and rod like micelles and planar bilayers (Wanless et al., 1997). In particular, electrostatics and surfactant association at the solid-liquid interface have been established as important interactions in ionic surfactant-charged solid systems (Chandar et al., 1987). Mica has been regarded as a typical hydrophilic substrate and has been implicitly used as a model for clay minerals and even for oxide minerals. Mica has been also employed as a model for clays in swelling studies. Recently, cylindrical aggregates typically observed on mica were not seen on either kaolinite or montmorillonite, where sphere-forming cationic surfactants in solution also formed spherical aggregates at the interface (Warr, 2000; Schulz and Warr, 2000). They found that adsorbed layers of cationic surfactants on mica had decidedly different morphologies from those on other typical clays, kaolinte and montmorillonite. For these kinds of experiments, optical reflectometry,
*Corresponding author:

02 to 1 times the CEC on SWy and SAz.02o 2θ s−1 and the slit set was 1o. 1. 2. UK). while there was not a great release of inorganic cations from SAz (Fig. 1). the HDTMA clay suspensions were centrifuged and washed gently with deionized water. In that case.204 Seung Yeop Lee and Soo Jin Kim Table 1. 2A). The HDTMA bromide was dissolved in warm deionized water and added to clay suspensions. the equilibrium surfactant concentration of SAz was almost the same as that of SWy. 2B). −0. which was Fig. The operating condition of XRD was at 40 kV/30 mA in a step scan mode. Additionally. the cation release curve for SAz was characterized as being linear with HDTMA loading.2 CEC). After mixing for 7 days. inorganic cations (Na+ and Ca2+) existing in the interlayers of the clay were released into water. SWy showed that adsorption amount of HDTMA progressively diminished until about 0. Adsorption Isotherms of HDTMA Adsorption isotherms of HDTMA by SWy and SAz montmorillonites are shown in Figure 1. When the loading amount of HDTMA was more than 0. Tokyo. and then increased as the loading amount increased (Fig. Obtained from Mermut and Lagaly (2001). Additionally.97 Na2O/CaO ratio3 1. Shimadzu. 2. and then a progressive decrease of sorption with the increase of HDTMA loading. 3. Electron Microscopy The clay samples were dried at room temperature and coated with Au under vacuum in an argon atmosphere for scanning electron microscopy (SEM) studies (LEO 1455VP SEM. Japan).02 Obtained from Borden and Giese (2001). the adsorption isotherm by SAz showed a remarkable HDTMA adsorption increase at slight loading levels (≤ 0.5o. Sample designation SWy SAz 1 2 Specimen Low charge SWy-2 montmorillonite High charge SAz-1 montmorillonite Cation exchange capacity (meq/100 g)1 85 123 Layer charge (cmolc/kg)2 0. as HDTMA sorption by montmorillonite proceeded. 3 Obtained from Mermut and Cano (2001). but the cations on SWy were considerably released more again from 0. resulting from the cation exchange reaction (Xu and Boyd.87 0. supernatant solution and the HDTMA concentrations were measured using a total organic carbon analyzer (TOC-5000A. Shimadzu. Tokyo. Meanwhile. Their adsorption isotherm patterns were significantly different at initial surfactant loadings. accompanying Na+ ions released more than Ca2+ ions.3. HDTMA Clay Preparation Organoclays were prepared by adding the amounts of HDTMA bromide equivalent to 0. . the concentration of inorganic cations (Na+ and Ca2+) released from the montmorillonites via the exchange with HDTMA was measured using an inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectrophotometer (ICPQ 1000.15 mm. Japan) with a graphite monochromator. Cambridge. 1995) (Fig. exchangeable inorganic cations on SWy were greatly released at low concentration of loaded HDTMA (Fig. For exchangeable cations.1.6 CEC. Tokyo. 2. Mineralogical properties of the montmorillonite samples used in this study. −0. 2). Adsorbed HDTMA was determined as the difference between the added HDTMA and that remaining in the solution. The d(001) values were recorded using CuKα radiation from an automated X−ray diffractometer (XRD) (Rigaku Geigerflex RAD3-C.4.5. RESULTS 3. Japan). The scanning speed was 0.25 0. Adsorption of HDTMA by SWy and SAz montmorillonites.4 CEC.4 CEC. X−ray Diffraction Analysis Ten grams of organoclay samples were dried at 25oC as oriented aggregates on glass slides.

d-spacings of HDTMA−SWy and SAz montmorillonites as HDTMA loading increased.4 CEC to 1 CEC. which are affected by the internal or external surface cations.4 CEC) (Fig. The layers were relatively flat.5 Å.Study on HDTMA with reference montmorillonites 205 Fig. 1994) (Fig. 3. Moll (2001) also reported that Na-montmorillonite is thin and more flexible than other layer silicates. variations in the exchangeable cation carried by montmorillonites are reflected in their appearance and morphology. micrographs of HDTMA−SWy revealed irregular flake-shaped aggregates which appeared to be stackings of units without regular outlines. 3). .. 4D) when dried after being dispersed in water.3.e. broad undulating sheets) to “cornflake”-like as the HDTMA loading increased (Fig. Ca montmorillonite (SAz) appeared as irregular aggregates which increased in size as the HDTMA added increased (Fig.2. the raw SWy (Na-montmorillonite) was more massive and adhesive (Fig. 2. SEM Observation Figure 4 shows the morphologies of montmorillonites (SWy and SAz) modified with HDTMA and provides a basis for comparison between the two clays. 4A−C). 4F). 3. As shown in Figure 4C. He showed that the differences between raw montmorillonites are due to variations in the attraction between the montmorillonite particles and in the relative strength of the attractive forces at the edges of the particles and on their basal planes. This means that the exchangeable inorganic cations on clay minerals may play a role in the overall appearance or morphology of silicate layers. while those of SAz increased from 14.2 to 18. XRD Measurement The d-spacings of air-dried clays were not nearly changed at low HDTMA loadings (≤ 0. 3). 4D−F).7 Å. The morphology of raw SWy changed from “entrails”like (i. ascribed to an enhanced Ca2+ release. and especially more aggregative at high loadings of HDTMA (Fig. According to Grim (1968). indicating a transition from parallel to vertical orientation of alkyl ammonium (Lagaly. 3. 4A) than the raw SAz (Ca-montmorillonite) (Fig. The release curves of exchangeable inorganic cations (Na and Ca) from (A) SWy and (B) SAz montmorillonites during HDTMA loading. except for a curling of the edges. the dspacings of SWy increased from 14. Characteristically.7 to 23. Fig. presumably because the Na+ interlayer ion was more easily hydrated than was Ca2+. As the HDTMA loading increased from 0.

2A). HDTMA was also adsorbed mostly by cation exchange as indicated by the release of considerable inorganic cations (Fig. (C) 0.1. this preferential release of interlayer Na+ by HDTMA made the distinctive HDTMA adsorption isotherm shape different from that of SAz. which minimized the lateral interactions among the alkyl groups of neighboring adsorbed HDTMA cations. similar to that of HDTMA isotherm on montmorillonite performed by Xu and Boyd (1995). 2001). adsorption occurs via electrostatic interactions between the clay surface and micelle. 1).9 CEC HDTMA−SWy..15 CEC HDTMA−SAz. (D) raw Ca−SAz. and (F) 0. and this active HDTMA access to the interlayer Na+ sites might make its random distribution in the interlayers.206 Seung Yeop Lee and Soo Jin Kim Fig. In addition.9 CEC HDTMA−SAz. 2). In this experiment. (E) 0. 4). showing the HDTMA equilibrium concentration increase with HDTMA loading up to about 0. Many montmorillonite particles can therefore be regarded as aggregates. DISCUSSION 4. the Na+ in the interlayer was easily exchanged with HDTMA (Fig. leading to neutralization of the surface charge (Atkin et al. (A) Raw Na−SWy. Characteristic Desorption of Inorganic Cations by HDTMA Adsorption For ionic surfactants at very low concentrations. the decrease in the equilibrium concentration of . the basal plane surface of clay sheets became hydrophobic and progressively aggregated depending on the degree of surfactant loading (Fig. lamellar aggregate structure was often obvious at high HDTMA loadings. Inasmuch as the HDTMA cations were strongly preferred by the exchange sites over the inorganic cations. a foliated. 4. In SWy montmorillonite. SEM micrographs of montmorillonite particles before and after HDTMA addition. 4.15 CEC HDTMA −SWy. Meanwhile. (B) 0. and indeed.4 CEC (Fig.

. 1) as well as the substantial release of interlayer Ca2+ ions from that point (Fig. P. the active lateral interaction between adsorbed HDTMA cations at external sites played an important role on such a flocculation. Alteration of Montmorillonite Surfaces As previously mentioned. 2001. Hackett. 160−168.). E. V. Manias. 1994. Basal Spacings Change From X−ray diffraction measurements on dry clay it has been shown that stepwise changes in basal spacing between the elementary sheets were obtained when a long-chain cation such as HDTMA was added in increasing amounts to montmorillonite up to the CEC. 15.J. McGraw-Hill. The d-spacings of HDTMA− SWy were different from those of HDTMA−SAz (Fig. Chandar. p. P. Subsequently.. (ed. Layer Charge Characteristics of 2:1 Silicate Clay Minerals.. However. R.Y.2. exchange with initial counterions (inorganic cations) occurs and adsorbed surfactants neutralize the anionic clay sites. It appeared that the different charge densities and inorganic interlayer cation types of the clays have an effect on the evolution of the surface aggregates as a function of HDTMA surface coverage. 8. 1998. New York.0 CEC (18−18. and Giese. REFERENCES Atkin. S. As previously noted. Langmuir. Craig. Borden. In that case.J. Layer charge determination by alkylammonium inos... This was indicated as low aqueous phase HDTMA concentrations of SAz at the initial stage (≤ 0.A. at these low loading levels. 17. R. and Biggs. 1995) and the rare opening of the high charge interlayer space of SAz. 2A). Consequently. It seems that the flocculation process of clay particles therefore depends to a great extent on the adsorbed surfactant position or distribution according to the layer charge densities or interlayer cation types of clay surface. Grim. Clay Mineralogy. As shown in Figure 3..4 CEC. 1968. 3). the d-spacings of HDTMA−SWy began to increase from about 0.F. the interlayer inorganic cations appeared to have a substantial influence on the expansion behavior of silicate layers as well as the evolution of the surface aggregates as a function of HDTMA surface coverage. Clays and Clay Minerals. For example. 2002. 5. Adsorption kinetics and structural arrangements of cetylpyridinium bromide at the silicaaqueous interface. R. the Na+ in the interlayer was easily exchanged with HDTMA. W. 2001. Ducker.E. E. 108. 4. 596 p. in HDTMA−Ca−SAz. 1). Baseline studies of The Clay Minerals Society Source Clays: cation exchange capacity measurements by the ammonia-electrode method. and Kim. D.R.. In: Mermut. 1994). Study of the adsorption of cationic surfactants on aqueous laponite clay suspensions and laponite clay modified electrodes. Lee.J. XRD and SEM. Somasundaran. the lower exchange of interlayer Ca2+ ions by HDTMA probably maximized the binding strength of HDTMA by increasing the degree of the lateral interactions on the external surfaces. and Giannelis.. Langmuir. 6. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science. S. the d-spacings of HDTMA−SWy at 0. Adsorption of naphthalene by HDTMA . which may be related to the gradual increase of HDTMA adsorption shown at the HDTMA adsorption isotherm (Fig. the remaining Ca2+ ions could come out of the interlayer. Vol.. Labbe. 31−46. the internal and external surfaces of montmorillonites with different interlayer inorganic cations were characterized as clay sheets with heterogeneous expansion at initial HDTMA loadings. 1999. HDTMA had a higher affinity for high charged Ca−SAz montmorillonite rather than for low charged Na−SWy montmorillonite. Lagaly.. P. This means that as the opening of the inter-gallery of SWy silicate layers was facilitated by the continuous HDTMA intercalation. restricted access of HDTMA to the interlayer of SAz montmorillonite resulted in significant lateral interactions among alkyl groups at outer surface or edges even at low HDTMA loadings. E. Langmuir. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS: This work was supported by BK21 Project of the Korean Ministry of Education.. Consequently.. In other words. 1−46. 1908−1918. The Clay Minerals Society. 6155−6163. and Wanless. Brahimi. Aurora.2 CEC) (Fig.J. The clay particles were highly flocculated in high charge HDTMA−Ca−SAz montmorillonite rather than in low charge HDTMA−Na−SWy montmorillonite (Fig. due to the lower layer charge of the clay (Lagaly. the neutral and hydrophobic character of the clay particle-water interface makes a flocculation of clay particles as shown in Figure 4. 4. 444−445. 7410−7415.3. 49. upon addition of a cationic surfactant in a quantity less than the CEC. Journal of Chemical Physics. into an aqueous clay suspension. Molecular dynamics simulations of organically modified layered silicates. 1) may result from both the increased lateral interaction of adjacent HDTMA cations on external or edge sites (Xu and Boyd. G.Study on HDTMA with reference montmorillonites 207 HDTMA with HDTMA loading (≤ 0.. S. N.7−1. HDTMA cations are either intercalated between the elementary sheets or adsorb on the external or edge sites of clay. and Reverdy. Fluorescence probe studies on the structure of the adsorbed layer of dodecyl sulfate at the alumina-water interface.P. A. 4). and this active HDTMA access to the interlayer Na+ sites made its random distribution in the interlayers. G. B. E. 117. besides the clay surface charge. and this progressively made clay particles greatly aggregated as HDTMA was added. Adsorption of hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide to mica: nanometer-scale study of binding-site competition effects. 1992. and Turro.S.5 Å) were several angstroms less than that of HDTMA−SAz at the corresponding loadings. 1987.2 CEC) on SAz (Fig. In SWy montmorillonite. CONCLUSION From the observation of adsorption isotherms.

W... B. H. Surface aggregate phase transition.. Warr.J. 22. 343 p. Manuscript received June 4. Molecular organization of surfactants at solid-liquid interfaces. Baseline studies of The Clay Minerals Society Source Clays: geological origin... 18. T. 49. Clays and Clay Minerals. G.G. and Cano. Xu.A.G.W. 374−380. G. Baseline studies of The Clay Minerals Society Source Clays: chemical analyses of major elements.. 13. Yoshida. 1480−1482. and Inoue. A. Langmuir. A. 1997. 2001. 1995. S. Theng.. Clays and Clay Minerals.K. Clays and Clay Minerals. S. Intercalation of polyfluorinated surfactants into clay minerals and the characterization of the hybrid compounds. 2508−2514. Wiley.F. and Ducker.208 Seung Yeop Lee and Soo Jin Kim modified kaolinite and halloysite. Langmuir. 2995−2996. Tachibana. Moll.F. S. 393−397.A. Baseline studies of The Clay Minerals Society Source Clays: layer-charge determination and characteristics of those minerals containing 2:1 layers. G. 891−896. Langmuir. Mermut. 381−386.C. and Warr. Cationic surfactant adsorption by swelling and nonswelling layer silicates. and Lagaly. and Gaub. Adsorbed layer structure of cationic surfactants on clays (mica is not a typical substrate for adsorption studies). 1975. J.. Tryk.G. 2000. Langmuir.. H. Surfactant adsorbed layer structure at solid/solution interfaces: impact and implications of AFM imaging studies. T. Schulz. W. 2001. Wanless. 49. 49. New York.E. 5. 1995. Mermut.. 270. and Boyd. 16. 2002. D.. 2003 Manuscript accepted August 5.R.R. Manne. E. 2001.A. 2003 . 55−63. 88−94. Science. Davey. H. 4223−4228. Applied Clay Science. 11. 2000. H. The Chemistry of Clay-Organic Reactions.. Current Opinion in Colloid and Interface Science. Yui. A...

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful