You are on page 1of 64

2004


.
7.5
.
"
" " "" .
.


4
.
4 .........................................................................................................................................
- 4 ...........................................................................................................
6 .....................................................................................................
7 .............................................................................................
10 ....................................................................................................

. -

14

14 ...................................................................................................................................................
14 .........................................................................................................................
- 14 .............................................................................................................
16 ...................................................................................................................
16 ........................................................................................................................................
17 ..........................................................................................................................
21 .......................................................................................................................

23

23 ...................................................................................................................................................
28 ................................................................................................
32 .............................................................................................
35 ...................................................................................................
37 .................................................................................................
38 ...................................................................................................
41 .............................................................................................................
42 ......................................................................................................
47 ...................................................................................
49 ........................................................................................
50 ...................................................................................
51 ..................................................................................................
53 ..............................................................................
55 ..........................................................................................................
56 ................................................................................................................................
, 58 ................................................................................
58 .................................................................................................................
59 ................................................................................................................................
" ) , ( 60........................................................................................
61 .................................................................................................................................

63

' :

65

' : )( "

80


.1

"
" ) ," , .(1

.2

"" . ,
,
. "" ""
.

.3

,
, .

.4

,
. .

.5

:
.


, .

-
.6

.7

4 - :
.

) (.

.8

.9

.1


1202 . .7.5 -
) (
306.1033 -

" , ,
.

) ( 80 -
.6.3 1957 ,
, .7

.
, .
, .

,
" )
"
" "( . ,
) , , ,

, '(.

,
: , , .

: ,
.
) , (
. .

seismic moment :
) ,(MO .(MW) moment magnitude-
. ,
, .
) (Intensity MMI
) .(Modified Mercalli Intensity 26 ' .18

.10

:
, , .

.
, .
,
:

.11

,
.

,
. ""

.

,
/ . ,
,
.

, .

.

: , ,
, , ) ,
'(.


.12

)
( . ,
" " ) (.
, ,
.

.13

" ,
, ,
, , , ,
.

.14

,
"" ) ( . ,
, .2 ,
, . ,

, .
".


.15


. :
.

, .
, ,
" " , ,
. ,
,

; , , )
( ,
.

, -

, : ,
,
, . ,
,
.

"" , .
"" ,
.

.16

:
) (
, ,
" " , ,
.

, :
.

(.1

,
,
) , ( . :
) ,
(
.
: ,

) ,
( . ,
) (
10,000 ,
20-30 ) (,

.0.2-0.3%

(.2

, ,
,

. ,


"".

(.3

,
, ,-
,
"" ,
) ,
(.

, )
( -
, .
,
) (
.

, " " ,
.
, :

(.1


" "
. , 100 )
( ,
) 20-30 , (
!! 18%-26% -
, .

.17

(.2

,
, .

(.3

"" , :
.


)
( , ,
. "
, ," ,
" " .


,
,
. ,
,

.

10


.18

, :
.

"" ) (;

- , -;

"".

.19

: "" )
, ( "-
" ) , (.

.20

"" "-"
,
. , "
" ,
,
) ,
, , ""
, :
(.

.21

:
, .
.

.22

:
.

) (;

) (;

) ;( After Shocks.

.23


- .
.

.24

- .
) (
" . ""

11

, .
" , :
.

;3

(.1

(.2

(.3

(.4

(.5

(.6

(.7

(.8

:; ;
; .

.25

- , , .
) (
. ,
,
); ( , "" .
.4

.26

,
) (intensity . , ,Mercalli

"" ) ,(Refugees
. "" ,
"" . "
" ,
) (.
" ' 1 "" """ :
" ) .(2

12

, .
"".5

.27

""
, .intensity - , intensity - 3% ,10
, 10% - ) 80% ,(6 18% -
) 45%( , 26% - ) 20%
( , .

.28

) ( ""
. , 1% ,80%
4% , 30% , ,
)
"" ; ,
, ,
,"(.

.29

.
" " ) "(
- . ,
,
, ,
, , ,
,
, .

.30

, .
,
.

"" ,
. ,
, .
" , .damage factor
, ) (Dollar loss
) (replacement value . 80% 80%
. ,
.

13

.31


, ,
".

14

.1

.
" " , .

.2

-
.


.3

,
.
, 3 , 3 - ,
"" . :
.

; .7-7.5

; .7-7.5

. .6-6.5

.4

"" .

.5

" , ""
, .

-
.6

1 .

.

.7

)
' :(27
.

,
.


) Serious injuries were defined as ,27
.("those requiring hospitalization ,

15

) ( 5%- -
10% .
.

,27
,
.
, , ,
.7

- X% " ,
.damage factor ,
) (Dollar loss )(replacement value
. :

DollarLoss
Re placementValue

= ) DamageFactor( DF

, 80% 80%
.
.

"" - 8
) (
.
100% ,80%
,45% 10% - .20%

,
.
32% 60% 26% - 95% . ,
" ,
. 10,000 - .
, "" ) ,(Refugees
. "" ,
"" .

16

:1

7-7.5

7-7.5

6-6.5

7,500-16,000

1,500-10,500

3,000-10,000

5,000-10,000

2,500-6,000

800-4,000

1,200-4,000

11,000-22,000

37,000-83,000

8,000-53,000

17,000-53,000

170,000-377,000

37,000-240,000

84,000-243,000

115,000-230,000

5,000-10,000

1,000-5,000

2,000-5,000

3,700-7,800

10,000-20,000

2,000-10,000

3,000-11,000

47,000-104,000

10,000-56,000

19,000-49,000

11,000-28,000

.8

.9

:
.

6
"" .
;1:3 , ) (10%
. , ""
. ""
"" ,
) ,
.(5%-10% -

, ,
. ""
"" " : "
; " ) "80%
""( " " , ,
; " "20%-45%
" " ,
.

, , . 0.5
2 , .

17

.10

:
.

, .

" , , , ,
, , ,' . ,
.


/ .


.11

7.5 "
. , ,
, )
, ( . ,
7.5 ,
) (.

.12

:
.

7.5 .

) (aftershocks
, .9

.13

, ,
. ,
,
.

.14

- .
) (intensity - .

, 6-8.

18

.15

' :2

7.5

16,000

6,000

83,000

377,000

10,000

20,000

104,000

.16

, ""
) , , ,"( .
"" ,
.

.17

: .
" " ,
" ) , ( .
, '.

.18


, - 6.5 .

19

,7.5
) 16,000 -(

20

,6.5
) 10,000 -(

21

, .
,
,
. 3,600 -

.19

:
. , ,
,
, .


.20


. :
/ , )
, , ,'(
/.

.21

, . 5% -
, ,10 5% -
) 11 ( ,
,
. ,
) ( ,
.

.22

3 " .
'.

10
11

, 5% .
, 15% - .

22

' :3
7.5

7.5

6.5

, -
5%

37

12

5% -

339

30

86

"

37

11

5% ,
5,000 )
25,000(

0
0

5
)(2

24
)(9

.23

.24

:
.

, 5% -
, 5% -.

" 15%-30% , 5,000,


5%-10% - 25,000.

25,000 - "
: , , , , ,
, , , , , , , ,
, , , .
, 7.5 5000-.

,
, ) " "
(:
.

.
.

23

.1


":
.

, , .

,
,


.

.2

- .
; , , ,

, .

.3

.4

:1985

12

8.1 . 350" .

) ( 10,000 - , 30,000 -.

100,000 - . 2,000,000 -
.

10 - .12

, .
, .

24

' :4 -1985 ,

3 , 281
) ( .

28% ) 5,000 (17,870.


137 , 301 .

14 ) (5% , 46 ) (16%.

117 , 2,800
.
45% .

40% .

70% , 95% - ".

10% .

40% - .

.5

:1988
.

6.9 , .

25,000 - , 30,000 -.

530,000 - . 1,100,000 -
.

20 - .

25

' :5 1988 ,

21,000 ) (54% , 41%

84 .

83 88 - .

, .

13

,
.

, .

" .
.
60% - 16; 80% - ;
100% - 25.

, . 3
.

, .
19.

13

] 250,000[ .

26

.6

:1995
7.2 . Kobe .Hyogo
.
.

5,500 - , 40,000 - , 317,000 -.

300,000 - . 1,500,000 -
.

130 - .

.
' :6 1995 ,

14

] 55,000 450,000 -"[ .


15

) 4 180 ( . 4 .
, 50% - 1,810 - .

440 ) (.
180 7 , 8-14.

16

950,000 Hyogo ) 2,280,000(.


20% , 6 . 2,600,000 , .
70 , 7.
25 - " , " .
850,000 Hyogo .

226,000 6.

500' . 9-11.

, / .

, , 9-16
.
16% )
(.

9 .

240 ) , 6 - ( . 500 -
135 - . .

146

14
15
16

, 1,400,000 -.
] Kobe Municipal West Civic Hospital 7[ .
" 2,836 - , 12,700.
64 21 - ; 20 10 - .
. . ,
, 50 112 - .

27

.7

:1999
.

7.7 .

2,350 - , 9,000 - . ,4,500 -


.

82,000 - , 600,000 -
.

14 - .

' :7 / 1999 ,


5,000 , 8,000 - , 70,000
.
2,000 - ,
.

4,375 165 -.
. :"
10% - .
) (.

.
,
. .
.

45" + . 400 -"


.
.

10% , .
.

28


.8

, :

.9

4 - "
. 4 ""
, ".

)
, ,(.

17

" RADIUS
.

.10

)
( , ,
. ,
, .

.11

,
:

17


, , ,' . ,
)
( , )
( ,'.

, ,

) ,
, , ,'(.

RADIUS - Risk Assessment Tools for Diagnosis of Urban Areas Against Seismic Disasters
1997 140 - " , International ) IDNDR
.(Decade For Natural Disaster Reduction
50 - ,
, .

29

.12

,
,
, .

.13

:
.

10
.

,
.


, .

.14

,
.
) ( ,
. ,
.

.15


) ( , , .

.16

, , .
, ,
, . ,
, , ,,
, .

.17

, , "" .
.

.18

:
.

,
. , ,

.

30

.19


. ,
) , (
.

) (intensity - .18
"" . 8
, "".
' :8

%
VIII

IX

XI

30%

14%

3%

1%

0.5

40%

30%

10%

3%

16%

24%

30%

10%

20

8%

16%

26%

30%

45

3%

10%

18%

30%

80

2%

4%

10%

18%

100

1%

2%

3%

8%

6%

16%

31%

56%

.20

18


"" ) 6% ,16% ,31% ,56% ,8 ,9 ,10 ,11( .
,

) ,MMI (Modified Mercalli Intensity .1-12


4 . :
:MMI=8 . .
. ,
. . . .
. . ,
. .
:MMI=9 . .
, . ,
. . . .
. . .
:MMI=10 .
. . .
, . . .

31

"" ) 14% ,32% ,57% ,86% ,8 ,9 ,10 ,11


(.

.21

RADIUS
.
, 15%-50% ,8%-25% ,4%-15% ,1%-8%
) (intensities 10 ,9 ,8 ,7.

.22

" .

.23

,
,19
RADIUS .
, 12 ,4 ,1 ,0.5 "
) (intensities 10 ,9 ,8 ,7 .
" ".

.24

,
. .

"

.25

19


. :
.

) (.

,
.

, .

, ,
.

3 "" " ,
.
) (.

32

.26

, , 25%
50" , 5% .
, , " .

.27

,
.

.28

, " "",
.

.29

,
. :
.

/ ;

/ ;


.30

.31

:
.

) , ,
, ,( ,
.

) ( ,
,
.

, .

, .

, ) (intensity -
"" . ,
7.5 ,

33

) 6.5 ,
(:
.

.(8) 11

.(6) 10

.(11) 8

.(9) 10

.(8) 8

.(7) 8

: ,
"" .8

.32

,
"" ,20
21.

.33

, ,
, ,
, ," . ,
8 75% , .
, :,
, . .

.34

, :

20

3 , 28%
. . 84
)" " (.

) 1984 - ,5.2 (
.

, , ,
. ""
, ,
. ,
, ,
.

34

.35

21

, ,
, ,
.

, :21
.

75% , 70% - .

70% , 50% - .

20% , 45%
, 40% .

, 20% ,
30% , 30% .

25% , 20% - .

)( ,
10%-20% , 10% - .

, ) ,
, , '(
.

25% ,
. , " .

,
, , ) ( ' .
, , , ,'.

35


.36

:
.

) ( , ,
, .

.22

,
, . ,
,
.

, .

,

.

, .

.37

, .

.38

, RADIUS 12 ,4 ,1 ,0.5
" ) (intensities 10 ,9 ,8 ,7.

.39

200 :" ) 100 -" 100 -


" ( 10;
500" ,9 2,500"
) 8
, ( . ,
7.5 7,000 - .

.40

22

,
:


, .

36

.41

117 ,-
2,800 , 25%
. 45% - .

,
.
.

950,000 , Hyogo ) 2.3 -


( . 2,000 - ,
" . 370,000 -
9 - ,
.

, :
.

40 ) 15 -"
9-10( , 20
) 40 -" , , .(8-9

, .

500 , )
10(.

500 --
) .(9

150 " )
.(8-9

200 )
,(8 20 .

6 , , ,,
10 , , 10 ,
.

40 -- ) -
100 (.

10 ) 30 -
"(.

37

12 , .

, 25% ,
. , "
.

:
(.1 , 50% , 20% -
-
,
, .
(.2 5% - -
, - .
.
(.3

(.4 10 -"
, .


.42

.43

.44

:
.

) , , '(.

) , ,( .

:
.

) , ,'(.

"
, ) 20(.

38

.45

.46

:
.

137 , .301

83 88 - .

440 ) (.

:
.

80% , ,
10" .

30% , .

35% ,
-- ) (.

15% ,
- .

25% , 10% -
.


.47

,
20 -" .
. , ,
.

.48

250 -".
:

.49

, , ;

, ) ( 100 -":
.

39

.50

.51

.52

" .

:
.

, ,
, , ,
.

:
.

" , .

, "".

:
.

, ,
, .

, .

) ( ,
.

"
, ,
, ,.

.53

.54


) , ,
( . .

40

.55

, ,,
10 " RADIUS ) RADIUS ,0.5
12 ,4 ,1 " 10 ,9 ,8 ,7(.

.56

, ,
. .

.57

:
.

20 " .

60 " .

20 , 20 -
.

20 " )" " , 10"-(,


".

10 .

7 ".

2 : 4 , 5 ,
1 , .

6 4 , 6 ,
, 4 - , .

6 ,
.

3 - " .

10% - , 40%
"".

10% "" -
.

41

25% , ,

, 10%.

:
(.1
.
(.2 " ,
, , )
(.
(.3 20% -
.
(.4

(.5

, .

(.6

(.7 10% , 25%


.


.58

, )"( .
) (.

.59

, ) (
,
. ,
.

.60

) ,(2003
. -
. , .

42

.61

" : ) - ,
( , ) ,
/ ( . .

.62

, ) ( ,
) 8
,6 .(9
.

.63

, .8-9
, , )
( . , ) (
" . , .

.64

,
. , . ,
)"
( , .

.65

. ,
) ,
(.

.66

, , . ,
, " , .

.67

, " , "
.


.68

) ( ,
)" "( , ) ,400 (
) (.

.69

, 20 -" .
, ,
, .

43

.70

, , .
, ,
.

.71

.
, ) (intensity ,8
, .23 ,
, .

.72

,
.8 .
/ ,
) (.

.73

, .9
, , .

.74

" " :
.

5"/" ) , , , , ( .
10.

30 -"/" ,
.9

50 -"/" - ,
.8

.75

"/" "/"
, , , ,
.

.76

400 - .
)" ( , " )' 40 -
" ( ." 400 - .

23

.
, .
, , ,
.

44

.77

, : "
) 160"( , 100 -" 10 , "
.

.78

, ,
) ( ,
.

.79

:
.

)
( .
. ,
.

) ,,
'( . ,
, .

.80

. ,
)
" ( . ,
,
,
.

.81

, :
.

, 40% -
.

, ,
. , 80% -
;
) (.

, 2.6 -
. 12,700 - 9,000 - . 64
21 - , 20 10 - . ,
50% - , 30%
24 . )
( .

45

.82

,
," .
.

,
. ,
,
7.5 .

46

.83

:
.

.

.
.
,
.
4 400 " 2 , 400
" , 2 400 .
"/" , , ,
) ( .
3 -" ) , (
, 6" 6 -"
.

10 10 ,
, 5 - ,
.
30 , , ,,
, , 50 , , 50 - 25 -
.
50 ".
,
) ( ,
, , .
25%
10% - ,
10%.
":
(.1 ) ( 4.
, ,
. , , , ,
, 4 - , , 2 - ,10% -

) , (.
(.2 8
) (.

.
.
.
.
.
.

.
.

47


.84

, .
, .

.85

, . ,
.

.86

,
,
.

.87

. , -
25 , .
) , , ,
( , .

.88

) ( .
,
.

.89

.
.

.90

,
,
. . , ,
. .

.91

.92

:
.

40% - .

.
, ,
.

500 )
( 9 . . ,

48

,/ .
, .
.

.93

.94

45" , 400"
) ( .
) 10% - (
) , (.

:
.

,
. ,
, ,.

) ( )
( 10-30 .

,
10-30 .

, , 20
, 20
.

50 - , 20 -
, 20 - , 10 - .

" ,
" .
. .

20% , , .

,
. , ,
, ,
, .

49

)
( ,
, .

.95

,
, ,
; ; ;
.

.96

:
.

20 - ,
, 10-100 .

2 - ,.


) ( .
.


.97

, .
, 2 : , ,
, . .

.98

.
, .

.99

900 - ) ( , 1,600 -
) ( , 600 - ) ( , 300 -
) ( .

.100


. ,
, .

.101

: .
" .

50

.102

, .8 ,
, ) (intensity .10-11
, 20% 20% - . ,
.

.103

, 240 ,
, 8 - .

.104

:
.

50 4 : ,
6 3 , ,
.

" ,
.

, .

, , .

" , 50% -
.


.105

,
. .

.106

.
,"
, .
, .

.107

,
)" , ,( .
" .

.108

, " ,
.

51

.109

:
.

30/
. ,
. ,
.

, 15% - .


. .
, " " .


.110

:
)( .
, )"( ,
-.
, ,
.
) , ,"(
, , ,'.
, - ,
.
: , , ,
'.

.111

:
" ,
.
,
.
.

52

,
, .

) ( .
.
, .
, ,
.

.112


.
. ,
, .

.113

)"( , "
.

.114

,
- , .
,
- .

.115


:
,
, .
,
) ( . ,

.
,
:
, , ,
, .
, """ ," ,
" " ,
"" " ".

53

.116

, :
70% , 95% - ".
, .
226,000 .

.117

,
, ) (
, .

.118

:
.

25% - , 25%
, , , , ,
, 25 .

5% - 3%
".

1% - 1%
.

30 , , ,,
, , 50 , , 50 - 25 -
, ) , ,'(.

50 " ,
5% - , , .

25% - ,
.

25%
. 15% , .

":
(.1 " )
( 8 . ,
" , .
, , , , 3 , , ,

54

2 10% -
" .
(.2

" , " .

(.3 " 8
) (.
(.4
36 ,
25% - ) (.
, .
(.5

) ( ".

(.6


.119

: ,
, )(.

.120

, ,
, . ,
, ,
, .

.121

, ,
, .
.

.122

.123

, , .
.
, .
) (.

.124

, ,
.

55

.125

:
.

250 , ) 25 -"
10(.

250 --
) .(9

90 " )
.(8-9

90 )
,(8 30 .

15% - " , .

15 - , 8 - 8 -
" , .

4 .


.126

: , .

.127

) ( . ,
.
.

.128

, .

.129

, . ,
.

.130

, ,
/ .
, .

56

.131

:
.

/ 20% .

/ 20% ,
, 10%
" - .


.132

. )
, ( .
)"( , .

.133

" )
( . : ,
" " , ,
, .

.134

" :
.

"
, " .

" ,
" .

/ ".

.135

" ,
. " ,
, ,
) , ,
, (.

.136

, , :
; "
; '.

57

.137

, " "
. "
) : " ;
" ( . " ),
( .

.138

:
.

" ) , ,
( .

" " .
, "
) ,
, ,
(.

.139

, 25 - " ,
" .

.140

: " ,
, . .
,
, .

.141

:
.

" .

":
(.1 . , 500 -
72 - .
(.2

(.3

" .

58

,
.142

,
. : )
, ( , , ,
) , ,( , , ,.

.143

, , .
" . ,
.

.144

.145

:
.

/ 20% ,
--.

--
30% - - .

3,000 .

/ 2%
- .

20% ) ,
, " , ,( ,
," .


.146

, .
:
.

, ,
. ,
.

, , , ,
) , , , , (.

59

.147

, .

:
.

80% 50% ,
-- , 20% -
.
.

15% -
.


.148

, ,
, , . .

.149

.150

, ,
.

, , .

) , ,'(.

10 50 - . 80 -
,9
.8

60

.151

:
.

3,000 9,000 - 3,000 15,000 -


.

70 - 60 - ,
, . 20 .

30%
//.

" ) , (
.152

:
.

,
.

,
.

, ,
,
, ) , ,'(,
, .
, )
( .
, ,
" .

61

.153

":
.

, 14,000 - . 9,000 .
100-200.

, .

30,000 - ,
.

" 400,000 ) ( . :
(.1

150,000 .24

(.2

150,000 , ) (.

100,000 (.3 , )
50% , ( ,
. .
.

) ( 25,000 ,
) 20,000 5,000 - (
.

50,000 , " ,
, , .

10%
. .


.154

..
24

" , , 63,000 - .
, ," 3 ,
" ) , , , ,,
,"( , 2 "
) ( , 1.5 "
) (.
" 15,000 - ) , ( ,
20,000 ) , , ( , 40,000 )
, , , ( , " 15,000 , 35,000
, 25,000 ) , , (.

62

"
.155

.
" , ".

.156

,
, ,
, , , ," . ,
.

.157

,
.

.158

:
.

" ) ,
(.


) , "

, ;
, ,

(.

.159

" '.

.160

"" 15%
30%"" , 4,500 : 350 , 42,000 ,
.


.161

:
.

15,000 .

4,000 , .

63

.1

" " ," , .2002

.2

" " , " ,


.2003

.3

.4

" " , , .2002 ,

.5

" " , .2000

.6

" " " , .2000

.7

" " ,
" , .2001

.8

" " , .1998

.9

."Seismic Vulnerability Assessment, prepared for Mekorot, March 1998

.10

, , .2002

.11

" " , , .1995

.12

investigation of lifeline system damages,


http://921.ncree.gov.tw/eng_report/lifeline/lifeline.html

earthquake

Chi-Chi

.13

The 1999 Taiwan earthquake damage to critical facilities", Tsu T. Soong and
George C. Yao

.14

The 1999 Taiwan earthquake Lifeline damage: Electric power Systems",


Masanobu Shinozuka, Gee-Yu Liu and Chin_Hsiung Loh

.15

The 1999 Taiwan earthquake Bridge damage", Ian G. Buckle, Kuo-Chun


Chang and Jenn-Shin Hwang

.16

" " ," , .2000

.17

" " ," " ,


"" , .2001

64

Earthquake facts and statistics", US Geological Survey, January 2003,


.http://neic.usgs.gov/neis/eqlists/eqstats.html

.18

Understanding urban seismic risk around the world a final report on the
comparative study", A project of the United Nations RADIUS Initiative,
December 1999.

.19

.A simplified tool for earthquake damag estimation", Oyo Group, Japan, 8/2000

.20

Final report from BRGM for the Region Africa/the Middle East/Eastern Europe
(Addis Ababa, Izmir and Skopje)", International Decade for Natural Disasters
Reduction (IDNDR), RADIUS Project, 15 September 1999.

.21

Guidelines for the implementation of earthquake risk management project",


Geohazards International, Palo Alto, California, December 1999.

.22

.Final Report for Izmir", RADIUS Project

.23

Earthquake
effects
in
Kobe,
Japan",
http://www.seismo.unr.edu/ftp/pub/louie/class/100/effects-kobe.html

.24

The Spitak-88 Earthquake the performance of lifelines", A. J. Schiff.

.25

Quantitative Risks Assessment Study in the Haifa District", Interim Report,


TNO Institute of Environmental Sciences, July 1997.

.26

ATC-13, Earthquake damage evaluation data for California", Federal Emergency


Management Agency, 1985.

.27