You are on page 1of 271
‘Ward/ Nielson/ Hahn GDI 2004 CRITICAL IR SHELLS A-L SECURITY/CALCULATIONS INC M-R SURVEILANCE INC S-U SIMULATION INC LINKS 1 - Panopticon 2.3 - Solicinude 4 - Emptiness 5 - Sign Shifting 6 - Politiks Is As 7 = Hobbes 8-15 - Humenitarianism 16 - “We save lives” 17-23 - UN PKOs 24-25 - Representation 26 - Reform 27» Intervention 28 - Globalization 29 - Discourse of Danger a 30-32 - Media ' 33-36 - Morality . 37-46 - State 47-60 - Geopolitics 61 - Doctors Without Borders 62 - Mearsheimer and Morgenthau 63 - Terrorism 64 - Preventative Diplomacy 65 - Demining 66 - Confidence Building Measures 67 - Environment 68 - Cyprus 69 - Georgia 70 - Lebanon 71 - Golan Heights 72- East Timor 73 - Congo 74. Ethiopia/Eritrea 75 - Western Sahara 76 - Sierra Leone 77 - Ivory Coast 78 - IndiaPakistan 79 - Kosovo 80 - Liberia 81 - Standing Army INTERNAL LINKS 82-83 - Calculations 84 - Security Leads to Otherness IMPACTS 85- Extinction 86 - Otherization 87 - Nuclear Weapons/ Use 88 - Statism 89.90 - Simulation 91 - Patriarchy 92.94 - Calculative Thought 95 - Racism 96-98 - Oppression 99-105 - Security Impacts ALTERNATIVES 106-125 - Rethinking IR 126-129 - Genealogy 130 -Deconstruct REALISM BAD 131-137 —Realism Bad OTHER STUFF 138 AT: Nietzche Bad 139-140 - AT: Heidegger Bad 141 - AT: Perm 142-143 - No Objective Threats 144-146 - Kritik Comes First 147-151 - Language Key ONIALISM LINKS 152 - United Nation PKOs 153-154 - Anti Imperialist Protest 155-156 - Western Values 157 - State 158 - Universelism 159 - Identity 160 - Fundamentalism 161 - Kritik of Universal Other 162 - Phycho Analysis 163 - Romanticism 164 - Ethnography ‘Ward/ Nielson/ Hahn GDI 2004 CRITICAL IR 165 - Differentiation 166 - GeoPolitics OTHER STUFF 167 - “The Other” 168-175 - Visions of Islam 176-178 - Humanitarian Benevolence 179-180 - Media 181- 184 - Us vs. Them 185-193 - IR = Iinperialism 194-197 - Indian Slavery 198-201 - Pakistan Slavery IMPACTS 202-205 - Self Fulfilling Prophecy 206-208 - Slavery 209-211 - Must Fight Slavery 212 - Silencing 213 - Exclusion 214 - Destroying Peace ALTERNATIVE 215 - Dielogue 216-218 - Deconstruct a 219-220 - Disjunction , 221-222 ~ Rethink 223 - A2: We Liberate/Include More People 224 - A2: UN Solves Slavery 225-227 - A2: Post Modernist IR 228-230 - A2: Pragmatism 231-232 - A2: Realism 233 - A2: Representations Shape Reality 234 - Our Kritik Comes First 235 - A2: EU Impacts 236-237 = A2: Rorty AFF ANSWERS 238 - Identity Turn 239-240 - Security Expansion Turn 241 —“‘The Other” Tum 242-243 - Campbell Card 244 - Permutation 245 - Impact Turn 246-247 - Realism True In the Case of UN 248 - Realism is not Obsolete 249-250 » Realism Inevitable 25 {252 - Realism Good CREATCAL AR — See ash. S| cales\anions Ade Sapte UN PEACEKEEPING IS A CODE WORD FOR NEW WORLD ORDER- THIS NEW ORDERING OF THE WORLD IS NOT ONLY CARRIED OUT WITH THE SWORD, BUT IS LEGITIMIZED BY THE WAY WE SPEAK ABOUT INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS. BY VOICING SUPPORT FOR UN PKO’S WE BUY IN TO THE RUSE OF SECURITY, AND AUTHORIZE ITS ENDLESS QUEST FOR ORDER ON A GLOBAL SCALE. Debrix- Assistant Professor of Intemational Relations at Florida International University- 1999 Re-Envisioning Peacekeeping The United Nations and the Mobilization of Ideology- PG 52-57 Fixe ontllcondioon of pow-cold wat neratontl rations in bet sucunacned by these two quotations from former Ucited Nations Srcreary-Generl Bowes Boouos-Ghali. Afr the collapse of ea - smaniom, the Fixed ground of cealtincerntionl relation becomes, Jn Bours Ghallt words, an *unseted ground” thar ea hold only the promive (aot the realy) of order and secur. Und such = ‘promi I realized, pose-cold wat itemaional teaions it doomed Te-ncousier he eye of chaotic and unscling phenomena described thera teed by end of tcl et ed beg) ow fo sind evn th, ew dlnce o noe appear 0 mk eran. ‘Ahowgh “anachy” was belived to be 4 seed mares is | spec now seas ough he imag of« proireon of es, Eoteh anaconda some fave slamnngy sed rel 4c ing aarhy™ Order sod march ate no longet acura oust see The old dtcoureof rir elm, elgtonacerain © & ndertanding of Hobbes, is no longer abet oer the “ihe order CZ, ing of mame? reed forthe ew pro. For meron el: = fans ther eh pcb wa er dors not oly nia 0 ose “Hebe: qctont aber ore Rates the cree teresa ‘bebe ey cove of Hotbers uneven berwees {ke leat of ed iter tere ome ens. eesti tw Hobos Srv arpulyeualating thew of ene’ "ie prorpect™ ‘fa eveyone would wats © vay away fom sod “rom mich Wis tl reps on es way ‘Salaun ch ananassae b. 8 7 ‘Them chickens is the UN. Ws went to New York to meet these player haters’. Ali G.-..-