11 views

Uploaded by Vortices3443

save

- Pitch Roof of Triangle Cross Section
- Continuum
- Finite Wing- Vortex Lattice Methods
- Why Do Vortices Generate Sound-Alan Powell
- Official NASA Communication 90-056
- Blackshear 1956 NACA the Growth of Disturbances in a Flame Generated Shear Region
- balde aerodymanics
- Experimental and Numerical Investigation of the Flow Analysis of the Water Saving Safety Valve
- 11
- Instability an Unsteady in Aircraft Wake Vortex
- ye.pdf
- NASA: 90-056
- Updrafts, Tornadoes and Hailstones
- 62CFD NonNewt Flow Rudman 2013
- Tablas de Vapor
- National Science Foundation: CTScov
- Aerodynamics of Wind Turbines
- Classification of Lubricants
- Genero RadiAtive
- Emms
- Untitled.pdf
- Mechanical Properties of Fluids
- P530_01_121_english
- tut04
- Lab 9 - Fluid Properties (Viscosity)
- CFDNotes Introducion Course CFX Bueno
- Fontbona_J on Navier Stocks Equations
- Batchelor vs Stewartson Flow Structures in a Rotor Statotr Cavity
- ssrjuly2006
- PV Newslette June 2015
- K. Bajer, H.K. Moffatt and Francis H. Nex- Steady Confined Stokes Flows with Chaotic Streamlines
- H.K. Moffatt- On the behaviour of a suspension of conducting particles subjected to a time-periodic magnetic field
- H.K. Moffatt- Fixed Points of Turbulent Dynamical Systems and Suppresion of Nonlinearity
- S. Childress, P. Collet, U. Frisch, A.D. Gilbert and H.K. Moffatt- Report on Workshop on Small-Diffusivity Dynamos and Dynamical Systems
- H.K. Moffatt- The Topological (as opposed to the analytical) Approach to Fluid and Plasma Flow Problems
- H.K. Moffatt- Liquid Metal MHD and the Geodynamo
- H. Branover, H.K. Moffatt, M. Mond, E.S. Pierson, P.S. Sulem and A. Yakhot- Magnetohydrodynamic Flow and Turbulence : a report on the Fifth Beer-Sheva Seminar
- H.K. Moffatt- KAM-Theory
- K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt- Current-Sheet Formation in Relaxing Plasmas Inhibiting Action of alpha-Effect
- H.K. Moffatt- Stretch, Twist and Fold
- H.K. Moffatt- On the Existence, Structure and Stability of MHD Equilibrium States
- H.K. Moffatt- The energy spectrum of knots and links
- J. Etay, A.J. Mestel and H.K. Moffatt- Deflection of a Stream of Liquid Metal by Means of an Alternating Magnetic Field
- J. Etay, A.J. Mestel and H.K. Moffatt- Deflection of a stream of liquid metal by means of an alternating magnetic field
- K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt- On a class of steady confined Stokes flows with chaotic streamlines
- H.K. Moffatt- Helicity in Laminar and Turbulent Flow
- FL Bolcato, J. Etay, Y. Fautrelle and H.K. Moffatt- Electromagnetic Billiards
- Jae-Tack Jeong and H.K. Moffatt- Free-surface cusps associated with flow at low Reynolds number
- A.Y.K. Chui and H.K. Moffatt- A Thermally Driven Disc Dynamo
- H.K. Moffatt- Relaxation Under Topological Constraints
- A.Y.K. Chui and H.K. Moffatt- Minimum Energy Magnetic Fields with Toroidal Topology
- H.K. Moffatt- Fluid Mechanics, Topology, Cusp Singularities, and Related Matters
- H.K. Moffatt- The Earth's Magnetism: Past Achievements and Future Challenges
- H.K. Moffatt- Electromagnetic Stirring
- K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt- Chaos Associated with Fluid Inertia
- H.K. Moffatt, S.Kida and K. Ohkitani- Stretched vortices - the sinews of turbulence; large-Reynolds-number asymptotics
- David E. Loper and H.K. Moffatt- Small-Scale Hydromagnetic Flow in the Earth's Core: Rise of a Vertical Buoyant Plume
- H.K. Moffatt- Cosmic Dynamos: From Alpha to Omega
- H.K. Moffatt- Spiral structures in turbulent flow
- H.K. Moffatt- Structure and stability of solutions of the Euler equations : a lagrangian approach

tc

FORMATION AND DISRUPTION OF CONCENTRATED VORTICES IN TURBULENCE

H.K. MOFFATT

**Isaac Newton Institute for Mathematical Sciences 20 Clarkson Road Cambridge CB3 OEH, UK
**

The Burgers vortex (Burgers 1948) is described by an exact solution of the Navier-Stokes equations in which the effects of uniform axisymmetric stretching are in equilibrium with viscous diffusion. Burgers introduced this vortex as ‘a mathematical model illustrating the theory of turbulence’, and he noted particularly that the vortex had the property that the rate of viscous dissipation per unit length of vortex was independent of viscosity in the limit of vanishing viscosity (i.e. high Reynolds number). This is of course an attractive feature in the light of Kolmogorov’s theory of turbulence, in which the rate of dissipation of energy per unit volume E and the kinematic viscosity U are regarded as independent variables. The idea that the small-scale structures of turbulence might be representable in terms of a random distribution of vortex sheets or tubes was taken up by Townsend (1951). Townsend showed that a random distribution of vortex sheets would give rise to an energy spectrum proportional to k-2 (multiplied by an exponential viscous cut-off factor) this power-law reflecting the fact that on any straight line through the field of turbulence, intersecting a finite number of vortex sheets, there will be (in the limit of vanishing viscosiby) a finite number of discontinuities of velocity per unit length. A random distribution of vortex tubes gave rise to a power-law k-’ (again modified by an exponential cut-off), this slower fall-off with k being associated with the more singular behaviour in physical space associated with a line vortex. The Kolmogorov spectrum k - 5 / 3 lies tantalisingly between k - l and k-2, suggesting that the typical (or generic) structures in x-space which may be responsible for such a spectrum should involve some compromise between tubes and sheets, for example spiral structures (Lundgren 1982, Gilbert 1988), these possibly arising through the interaction of tubes and sheets (Krasny 1986, Moffatt 1993).

321 U. Frisch (ed.),Advances in Turbulence VII, 321-330. @ 1998 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.

328

H.K. MOFFATT

During the last fifteen years, evidence from direct numerical simulation (DNS) of turbulence has accumulated indicating the presence of concentrated tube-like structures in the vorticity field (Siggia 1981, Kerr 1985, Yamamoto & Hosokawa 1988, Vincent & Meneguzzi 1991, and others). This has led to a great revival of interest in the primitive theories of Burgers and Townsend, and a re-evaluation of possible models of turbulence in terms of simple vortex structures. It was noticed by Kida & Ohkitani (1992) that the dissipation structure in the concentrated vortices of 3D turbulence exhibit two maxima, off-set from the centre of the vortex, and they suggested that this might be explained in terms of the action of non-axisymmetric strain acting on the vortex. This suggestion was taken up by Moffatt, Kida & Ohkitani (1994) who developed a high Reynolds number asymptotic theory of a vortex subjected to non-axisymmetric strain. Determination of the dissipation structure involved pursuing the analysis to third order in the small parameter Re-', and this analysis did indeed reveal the two peaks in the dissipation structure, arising from a symmetry-breaking splitting of the circle of maximum dissipation that occurs for the Burgers vortex. Remarkably, at leading order in the asymptotic analysis, the axisymmetric Burgers vortex emerges in spite of the non-axisymmetric character of the strain. This is because, at high vortex Reynolds number, the vortex spins rapidly in the strain field, and experiences the &averaged strain, which is axisymmetric. A similar behaviour had been previously recognised by Ting & Tung (1965), and by Neu (1984). Even more remarkably, the solution of Moffatt, Kida & Ohkitani indicates that the vortex can survive for an exponentially long time even when one of the rates of strain in the plane of cross-section of the vortex is positive. Again, this is because it is only the &averaged strain that is relevant at leading order. The characteristic dissipation structures identified by Moffatt, Kida & Ohkitani are present also, although for rather different reasons, in twodimensional freely decaying turbulence, at the stage when identifiable vortices emerge from a random initial state (McWilliams 1984, 1990, Jimknez, Moffatt & Vasco 1996). Each vortex in such a field moves with the local velocity induced by all the other vortices, and is also subject to the two-dimensional strain field associated with the presence of all the other vortices. At high Reynolds number, the effect of this strain field is to distort each vortex cross-section to slightly elliptical form; the associated dissipation field has precisely the same structure as that determined in the earlier work of Moffatt, Kida & Ohkitani. This remarkable result is a consequence of the analogy between steady stretched three-dimensional vortices and unsteady unstretched two-dimensional vortices, as described by Lundgren (1982).

FORMATION AND DISRUPTION OF VORTICES IN TURBULENCE 329

The elliptic deformation of vortices in both two- and three-dimensional turbulence makes them prone to the type of three-dimensional resonant instability identified by Bayly (1986) and Pierrehumbert (1986). As shown, however, by Le Dizks, Rossi & Moffatt (1996), stretching carries the wavenumber of sinusoidal perturbations through the unstable wave-number band in a finite time, so that infinitesimal disturbances are always asymptotically stable. This mechanism is not present for two-dimensional (unstretched) vortices, and one may reasonably conjecture that 2D turbulence is always unstable to 3D disturbances (in the absence of stabilising mechanisms such as stratification or magnetic field). A serious limitation of the Burgers model in the context of threedimensional turbulence lies in the assumption of the uniformity of the strain field, and the associated infinite length of the stretched vortices. In fact, the region of concentration is of finite length, the vortex lines diverging more or less rapidly at the ends of these regions of concentration. This finite length is apparent also in experiments (Douady, Couder & Brachet 1991) designed to detect intense vortex filaments in turbulent flow of liquids seeded with small gas bubbles. Variation of the strain field arises through the non-uniform action of the ‘other vortices’ near to the parent vortex whose structure is considered. In so far as these other vortices may be treated as point vortices, the nonuniform strain field acting on the parent vortex is a strain field associated with a non-uniform potential flow. In this lecture, a simple model will be developed involving the action of distributed vortices on a two-dimensional stretched vortex sheet (of Burgers type). The problem is treated by using the potential 6 and stream function ?J of the non-uniform straining flow as independent coordinates. The advection-diffusion equation for the parent vortex sheet has universal form in terms of these coordinates, and a wide family of exact solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations is thus generated. A variety of solutions will be described, which provide a good indication of the manner in which such vortex sheets may disrupt in regions of strong non-uniformity of strain. A similar technique runs into difficulties for the analogous axisymmetric problem, because in this case the advection-diffusion equation, expressed in terms of the relevant 4 and $J,is not universal. Nevertheless, the approach does indicate one mechanism by which vortex disruption can occur. References

Bayly, B. (1986) Three-dimensional instability of elliptical flow, Phys. Rev. Lett. 5 7 , p. 2160. Burgers, J.M. (1948) A mathematical model illustrating the theory of turbulence, Adv. A p p l . Mech. 1,pp. 171-199.

330

H.K. MOFFATT

Douady, S., Couder, Y. & Brachet, M.E. (1991) Direct observation of the intermittency of intense vorticity filaments in turbulence, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67,983-986. (1988) Spiral structures and spectra in two-dimensional turbulence, J. Fluid Gilbert, A.D. Mech. 193,pp. 475-497. JimCnez, J., Moffatt, H.K. and Vasco, C. (1996) The structure of the vortices in freely decaying two-dimensional turbulence, J. Fluid Mech. 313,pp. 209-222. Kerr, R.M. (1985) Higher-order derivative correlations and the alignment of small-scale structures in isotropic numerical turbulence, J. Fluid Mech. 153,pp. 31-58. Kida, S. and Ohkitani, K. (1992) Spatio-temporal intermittency and instability of a forced turbulence, Phys. Fluids A4, pp. 1018-1027. Krasny, R. (1986) Desingularisation of periodic vortex sheet roll-up, J . Computational Physics 65,pp. 292-313. Le DizBs, S . , Rossi, M. & Moffatt, H.K. (1996) On the three-dimensional instability of elliptical vortex subjected to stretching, Phys. Fluids 8(8), pp. 2084-2090. Lundgren, T. (1982) Strained spiral vortex model for turbulent fine structure, Phys. Fluids 25,pp. 2193-2203. McWilliams, J.C. (1984) The emergence of isolated coherent vortices in turbulent flow, J . Fluid Mech. 146,pp. 21-43. McWilliams, J.C. (1990) The vortices of two-dimensional turbulence, J. Fluid Mech. 219, pp. 361-385. Moffatt, H.K. (1993) Spiral structures in turbulent flow, New Approaches and Concepts in Turbulence, Monte Veritd, Birkhauser Verlag Basel, pp. 121-129. Moffatt, H.K., Kida, S . and Ohkitani, K. (1994) Stretched vortices - the sinews of turbulence; large-Reynolds-number asymptotics, J . Fluid Mech. 259,pp. 241-264. Neu, J.C. (1984) The dynamics of stretched vortices, J. Fluid Mech. 143,pp. 253-276. Pierrehumbert, R . T . (1986) Universal short-wave instability of two-dimensional eddies in an inviscid fluid, Phys. Rev. Lett. 57,p. 2157. Siggia, E.D. (1981) Numerical study of small scale intermittency in three-dimensional turbulence, J. Fluid Mech. 107,pp. 375-406. Ting, L. and Tung, C. (1965) Motion and decay of a vortex in a nonuniform stream, Phys. Fluids 8, pp. 1039-1051. Townsend, A.A.(1951) On the fine scale structure of turbulence, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 208,pp. 534-542. Vincent, A. and Meneguzzi, M. (1991) The spatial structure and statistical properties of homogeneous turbulence, J . Fluid Mech. 225, pp. 1-25. Yamamoto, K. and Hosokawa, I. (1988) A decaying isotropic turbulence pursued by the spectral method, J . Phys. Soc. Japan 57,pp. 1532-1535.

- Pitch Roof of Triangle Cross SectionUploaded byKrishnamoorthy Chandramouli
- ContinuumUploaded byMohammad Khasawneh
- Finite Wing- Vortex Lattice MethodsUploaded bySumit Malik
- Why Do Vortices Generate Sound-Alan PowellUploaded byila_368684492
- Official NASA Communication 90-056Uploaded byNASAdocuments
- Blackshear 1956 NACA the Growth of Disturbances in a Flame Generated Shear RegionUploaded byPrem Chand
- balde aerodymanicsUploaded byArvin Raj
- Experimental and Numerical Investigation of the Flow Analysis of the Water Saving Safety ValveUploaded byIJSTR Research Publication
- 11Uploaded byDaniel Hastay
- Instability an Unsteady in Aircraft Wake VortexUploaded bysreetejlakkam
- ye.pdfUploaded byChristophe Stevenin
- NASA: 90-056Uploaded byNASAdocuments
- Updrafts, Tornadoes and HailstonesUploaded byvcarmonaelizalde
- 62CFD NonNewt Flow Rudman 2013Uploaded byIrfan Shaikh
- Tablas de VaporUploaded byRemmy Torres Vega
- National Science Foundation: CTScovUploaded byNSF
- Aerodynamics of Wind TurbinesUploaded byIoanna Kalo
- Classification of LubricantsUploaded byaqibazizkhan
- Genero RadiAtiveUploaded byhks82
- EmmsUploaded bydr_m_azhar
- Untitled.pdfUploaded byJonathan Dixon
- Mechanical Properties of FluidsUploaded byHussain
- P530_01_121_englishUploaded bypsychoo4702
- tut04Uploaded byCatalin
- Lab 9 - Fluid Properties (Viscosity)Uploaded byAmanda Amani
- CFDNotes Introducion Course CFX BuenoUploaded bymatteo_1234
- Fontbona_J on Navier Stocks EquationsUploaded bybj3
- Batchelor vs Stewartson Flow Structures in a Rotor Statotr CavityUploaded bykoolwaveoceanic
- ssrjuly2006Uploaded byandres
- PV Newslette June 2015Uploaded bysklatake

- K. Bajer, H.K. Moffatt and Francis H. Nex- Steady Confined Stokes Flows with Chaotic StreamlinesUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- On the behaviour of a suspension of conducting particles subjected to a time-periodic magnetic fieldUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- Fixed Points of Turbulent Dynamical Systems and Suppresion of NonlinearityUploaded byVortices3443
- S. Childress, P. Collet, U. Frisch, A.D. Gilbert and H.K. Moffatt- Report on Workshop on Small-Diffusivity Dynamos and Dynamical SystemsUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- The Topological (as opposed to the analytical) Approach to Fluid and Plasma Flow ProblemsUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- Liquid Metal MHD and the GeodynamoUploaded byVortices3443
- H. Branover, H.K. Moffatt, M. Mond, E.S. Pierson, P.S. Sulem and A. Yakhot- Magnetohydrodynamic Flow and Turbulence : a report on the Fifth Beer-Sheva SeminarUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- KAM-TheoryUploaded byVortices3443
- K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt- Current-Sheet Formation in Relaxing Plasmas Inhibiting Action of alpha-EffectUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- Stretch, Twist and FoldUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- On the Existence, Structure and Stability of MHD Equilibrium StatesUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- The energy spectrum of knots and linksUploaded byVortices3443
- J. Etay, A.J. Mestel and H.K. Moffatt- Deflection of a Stream of Liquid Metal by Means of an Alternating Magnetic FieldUploaded byVortices3443
- J. Etay, A.J. Mestel and H.K. Moffatt- Deflection of a stream of liquid metal by means of an alternating magnetic fieldUploaded byVortices3443
- K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt- On a class of steady confined Stokes flows with chaotic streamlinesUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- Helicity in Laminar and Turbulent FlowUploaded byVortices3443
- FL Bolcato, J. Etay, Y. Fautrelle and H.K. Moffatt- Electromagnetic BilliardsUploaded byVortices3443
- Jae-Tack Jeong and H.K. Moffatt- Free-surface cusps associated with flow at low Reynolds numberUploaded byVortices3443
- A.Y.K. Chui and H.K. Moffatt- A Thermally Driven Disc DynamoUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- Relaxation Under Topological ConstraintsUploaded byVortices3443
- A.Y.K. Chui and H.K. Moffatt- Minimum Energy Magnetic Fields with Toroidal TopologyUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- Fluid Mechanics, Topology, Cusp Singularities, and Related MattersUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- The Earth's Magnetism: Past Achievements and Future ChallengesUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- Electromagnetic StirringUploaded byVortices3443
- K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt- Chaos Associated with Fluid InertiaUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt, S.Kida and K. Ohkitani- Stretched vortices - the sinews of turbulence; large-Reynolds-number asymptoticsUploaded byVortices3443
- David E. Loper and H.K. Moffatt- Small-Scale Hydromagnetic Flow in the Earth's Core: Rise of a Vertical Buoyant PlumeUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- Cosmic Dynamos: From Alpha to OmegaUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- Spiral structures in turbulent flowUploaded byVortices3443
- H.K. Moffatt- Structure and stability of solutions of the Euler equations : a lagrangian approachUploaded byVortices3443