You are on page 1of 472

^^

f
ht^
^^'c^'^
'
C ATEN^
GR^CORUM PATRUM
IN

NOVUM TESTAMENTUM.

EDIDIT

J. A. CRAMER, S.T.P.
AUL-a: NOVI HOSPITII PIIINCIPALIS,
NECNON

HISTORI^ MODERN^ PROFESSOR REGIUS.

TOMUS II.

IN EVANGELIA S. LUC^ ET S. JOANNIS.

OXONII,
E TYPOGRAPHEO ACADEMICO.
M.DCCC.XLIV.
C A T E N iE

IN

EVANGELIA

S. LUC^ ET S. JOANNIS,

AD FIDEM CODD. MSS.

EDIDIT

J. A. CRAMER, S. T. P.

AULiE NOVI HOSPITII PRINCIPALIS,


NECNON

ACADEMIvE ORATOR PUBLICUS.

OXONII,
E TYPOGRAPHEO ACADEMICO.
M.DCCC.XLI.
s^-'
<^^

\l
MONITUM LECTORI.

Cv ATENAS in Evangelia S. Lucae et S. Joannis hac-

tenus ineditas ex eodem Codice Coisl. vulgavimus, quo


in edendis Commentariis in duos priores Evangelistas
usi sumus. Catena in S. Lucam longe diversa est illa

quam Latine tautum edidit Corderius Antverpiae An.


1627. in fol. Nostrae fundus est, ut in Praef ad Cat.
in S. Matth. jam monui, Commentarius vulgo Tito Bo-
strensi Episcopo attributus, de quo fuse egit Fabricius,
de Commentariis in Nov. Testain. disserens Bibl. Gr.
t. VII. p.778. Est revera autem Epitome tantum Com-
mentarii, ex illo antiquo Scriptore praecipue contexti, ab
^odem anon}Tiio Auctore, qui Catenas in S. Matthseum
et S. Joannem e Chrysostomi Operibus confecit. Et
annotarunt quidem Combefisius et alii, plures exstare
reliquias integri Commentarii Episcopi Bostrensis in
Cateuis Regiis MSS. (ap. Fabr. p. 779.) Hujus gene-
ris est nostra, quse multas Symbolas affert ex Tito,
pluresque insuper ex Origene, Chrysostomo, Cyrillo et
aliis Patribus. Si fides autem adhibenda est veteri

cuidam Catalogo MS. videtur Titum Bostrensem in


omnes Evangelistas commentarios edidisse sub hoc ti-

tulo, T/tou 'Eirta-KOTTOv Boctt/scSv epfjiyjviia €/$• Toiig ^ Evayy€'


Ki<Jrag ^.

Et ssepe quidem laudatur a Macario Chrysocephalo


in Catena ejus ad Ev. S. Matthsei Cod. Barocc. 166.
a Anecd. Paris. 1. p.
1. 393,
a 2
iv MONITUM LECTORI.
semel vero tantum laudatur iii Catena a nobis edita
in Ev. S. Marci, nunquam autem in iis quse ad Ev. S.
Joannis explicandum concinnatae sunt ; unde patet Com-
mentarios ejus in duos hos Evangelistas ante ceteros
sevo absumptos esse.

Nostra in S. Joannem Catena, prorsus dissimilis est,

ut bene monuit Montfaucon. in Bibl. Coisl. p. 68. illa

quam vulgavit Corderius Grsece et Latine Antverpiae an.


1630. fol. Cum Corderiana maxime quadrat illa quam
continet Liber Baroccianus 225. membr. form. in 4to.
Saec. XII, optime exaratus, sed initio et fine mutilus,

et multis in locis humore corruptus. Hunc quidem


Codicem utilissimum judicarem ad corrigendum et am-
pUandum Commentarium a Corderio editum. Nostri
autem Commentarii prsecipua pars Chrysostomo debetur,
et ab eadem proculdubio manu ex ejus Patris homiliis
compilata est, qua; Commentarios in S. Matthseum et
S. Lucam confecit. Additse sunt prseterea multae cita-
tiones ex Apollinari, Cyrillo, Origene, Severo, Theodoro
Heracleensi et Theodoro Mopsuesteno ; sed ante omnes
frequentissime laudatur Ammonius Alexandrinse Ec-
clesiae Presbyter, cujus multa adducta sunt Scholia in
Catena ad Acta SS. Apostolorum a nobis vulgata. Hic
Scriptor, non confundendus cum antiquiore ejusdem
nominis Monotessari Evang. Auctore, quem memorat
Euseb. Hist. Eccl. VI. 19, floruisse videtur circa finem
V Sseculi ; nam subscripsit an. 458. Epistolse Episco-
porum jEgypti ad Leonem Imp. pro defensione Conc.
Chalcedonensis (ap. Fabr. Bibl. Gr. t. IV. p. 179.)

De hoc Ammonio non gravabor qusedam testimonia


adducere ex Anastasii Sinaitse Hodego, quoniam minus
accurate exstant vulgata in Gretseri Ed. p. 278. Nos
MONITUM LECTORI.
ex optimo Codice Bodl. Roe 22. 'O Tre/?/ Travra zoXwci-

poTaroi rav e^vjyvjTav 'A/x/Acov/of o Akt^av^pev^f toi/toj tso rpoito^

rov ' AXiKapvaaea yeipcocroifjievo^y eOavaTCoaev. AvaXapav yap


Kcu TTpoairoiyjo-dfJi.evof) ro rov HafJioaarecoi Tipoaca-nov, oig eioe rov

'lovXiavov elg ^OKvjaiv Kai (pavTaa-iav Tp€7rofx.€vov' Kai avco Kai

Karo} BecoQeiaav Kai e^ofxoictiSeiaav rvjv ayiav adpKa rov ^pKxrov,


coaavet '^ianpiofxevog Kai ^iaTrX.yjKri^ofxevos eni r^ dOer-^aei rvji

dXvj6eia(, 6 Upog Afufxaviog


' <f>i^ai irpog rov \ov\iavoV " Ort fjiev

" ©€0f dXvjffrji 6 'K.piaTOi 6 Tlog rov Qeov, Kai Seiov ovrcoi avrov
" TO ayiov acofxa ryj Secoaei, Kai ev avr^ KaroiKei irav ro TrX-^^pcofxa

" T^f QeoTVjTog, TtavTi Tiov '^Y}Xov' yap fxvj ovrco (fypov^v, ^evog koi

" dkXoTpiOi eart r^g dyiag BeorriTog avrov' Ofxcog ^ia t^v iroXXriV

" Kat <ptXoviiKov vfxcov ^i/yofxay^iav, rcov apvovfxevcov rvjv dvSpcontvt^v

" (pvaiv rov Kptarov, iSov otKetovfxai Kai dvaXafxPdvca Trpoacoirov

" 'S.afi.oaarecog, yj fxaXXov diitaTov lov^aiov, ^iXcovog rov <f)tXoaO'

" </>oy." Kai oiiTog yap itpog Mvdaova rov aTtoaroXiKOv fxaQyiryjv,

dvTippy)aiv rore Ttept r^g 'Kptarov itotovfxevog BeoTyjrog, ^iyipcora

(Edd. absurdo sensu ItKpxra) rov Mvao-ova Xeycov, Ttg koi

Ttoia Koi TtoBev yj dTio^et^ig. k. r. e.

Paulo infra Anastasius citat ]\fxfxcovtov ttpea^vrepov

'AXe^avtpeiag eK rov Ttpog rdg aipeaetg EuTuj^ovf Kat AtoaKopov

Xoyov te ^. ubi Ammonius ipse inducitur disputans cum


Colutho Juda30. " Ka/ yovv itore fxoi Kard ryjv ' AvrtvoTtoXiv

" Ttpog KoXovQov (Ed. AkoXov6ov) rov aocptaryjv, rdg ^iaXe^etg


*'
Troioi/jaevsi), lovoarov Kat avrov rvyydvovra, dvTt6evTog Kat a^Tou

" rolg rov Kptarov Bavfxaat rag ^coaecog Bavfxarovpyiag' eira efxov

" etpyjKOTog, ort Mwa^f fxev cag Ttpocp-^Tyjg cov, ^ta Ttpoaevyrjg e^e-
" reXet repdareia, 6 Se XptaTog cog Qeog, avroKeXevarcog rd 6av~
" ^aTa Videndum an
^<€3r/JaTTeT0 S/p^a Tfjoaevyyjg.'^ k. t. X.

hic Coluthus, cum quo disputavit Ammonius, idem sit


ac Lycopolitanus Sophista, qui poema de Raptu Helenae

^ Haec in Ed. desunt.


vi MONITUM LECTORI.
conscripsit, licet hunc Anastasio imperante vixisse tra-

dat Suidas. Alius est Collutlius hsereticus presbyter


Alexandrinus, de quo Athanas. Apol. c. Arian. t. I.

p. 134. Ed. Ben. et alius junior quem laudat Anony-


mus Auctor Dogmaticus in Cod. olim Claromontano,
postea Meermanno, nunc Bodleiano. Auct. T. 1. 6. KoX-
XovOov Tov aipeTiKov eic r^«' vtto Seo^oaiov aTioXoyiag. Hoc
opus dogmaticum, quod quibusdam Jo. Damasceno
attributum est, idem esse conjicerem ac illud de quo
Anastasius loquitur in Hodego p. 192. quem tomum
dogmaticum vocat, et quem se composuisse testatur
sub nomine Flaviani Episcopi Constantinop.^
Citatur rursus ab Anastasio in Hodego Ammonii
opus contra Julianum Halicarnassensem p. 9,QQ. et

p. 278. KaTo. MovocpvaiTwv. Et hsec quidem de Ammonio,


qui tam frequenter et in nostra et in Corderiana Catena
citatur, ut facile cernatur illum continuum Commenta-
rium in S. Joannis Evang. scripsisse.

Jam adnotatum est a viris Criticis veteres Commen-


tatores in Catenis ad S. Joann. Ev. concinnatis, nullam
interpretationem attulisse ad pericopam de adultera
coram Salvatore nostro adducta, sed omnes eam quasi
silentio prseteriisse, unde non leve argumentum deduci
videretur contra authentiam ejus pericopae. Cum au-
tem omnes, ut mihi videtur, Catense, ad S. Chrysostomi

interpretationem accommodatae sunt ut earum basin,


•id argumentum non ultra illius Patris silentium, licet

hoc grave sit, extendere, aequum esse videtur. Magis


ex re foret, Scholiastarum anonymorum, qui notata ex-

c Multa ex hoc opere vulgavit Ang. Maius e Codice Vaticano


t. VII. p. 173. sed praestantiora et integriora ea exhibenda essent
e Cod. Claromontano, qui nunc Bibl. ornat Bodleianam.
MONITUM LECTORI. vU

scripsemnt in marginibus plurimorum exemplarium


Ev. S. Joannis, de hac pericopa sententias recensere.
Hujus generis est Scholion, quod invenitur in Antiquo
Cod. Coll. Lincolniensis num. 16. Codex ipse ut mihi

videtur, ad decimum Sseculum assignandus est, Scholia-


stse manus aliquanto recentior videtur. Textus quidem
Codicis a Millio et Scholzio collatus est (Scholz.

N°. 95. Prolegom. p. Iviii.), sed marginis ut opinor, nulla


adhibita fait ratio ; quapropter, Scholion ad prsedictum
locum, exscribere non inutile esse judicavi.
TavTa /xera Kai tov K€(f>aXaicv TYji fxoiyaXi^o^ ev Tiai tZv

avTiypdtpcov w^eXiaTar " Kai aTi^XOev eKaaTOS eig tov oIkov


"**
eavTox). Kdi Ivjaovs eiiopevQyj eig to opog twv eXaim. opSpov

**
&€ 7raA;v /3a6(og ijXGev o 'li^aovi eU to lepovy kou 'nag o c/Xog
" YjpyeTo Tcpog avTOv, Kai KaQiaai e^i^acrKev auTovg '.'—[ajyovaiv

" 01 ypa[X[j.aTeig Kat oi ^apiaaiot yvvalKa eTii fi.of^eta KaTei-


" X-t^fXfxevvjVy Kat aT-^aavTcg avTvjv ev tw jW,e<7co, e/Vov a^To?, ti^d-

" ffKaXe, TavTTjv evpofxev en avTocpwpco fxoiyevofKevfjv. ev Se tc3

*'
vo/Aco McyCT^f eveTe;AaTo yjft.iv Taf TotavTag XtSd^etv' av ovv ti
**
Xeyeii vepi avTvjg', tovto Se eXeyov Tietpd^ovTeg avTOv, iva
** ej^cccTiv KaTvjyoptav KaT avTOV. o ^e ]7)aovg KaTaKw\^ag, tc3
**
QaKTvXif eypa(f)ev eU t*?v y-^v. wg ^e eTreft.eivov eTrepcoTiovTeg

** afTOv, avaPXe\pa$ eiiiev avToTi' 6 dvaf/.dpTyjTog vfKwv TrpSoTOi

** Xi6ov PaXeTCo eir avTrjv. Kai TtdXiv KaTco Kvipag eypacpev elg
**
T>?v yrjv evo$ eKaaTOV avTxv Ta<; dfxapTtag. oi &e dKOvaavTeg,
** e^Yjp^j^pvTo eU Ko-6 eif, dp^dfievot dTro tcSv irpeajSvTepcov ecos

** Twv ea-^^aTcoV Kai KaTeXet(f)6y] 'Irjaovg ftovos Kai yj yvvyj ev

**
fi.eacp ovaa. dvaKVijjag ^e 6 ^lvjaovg ei^ev ayT^v Kai e/Vev,

**
yvvat, irov etaiv oi KaTrjyopot acv ; ov^etg ae KaTeKptvev ; yj §e
** e<7rev, ov^etg Kvpte. ehe Se avTyj o ^lyjaovg, ov te eyco ae KaTa-
** Kptvw. •nopevov, KUt dno tov vvv fxi^KeTt dfxdpTave'' —
Insignis profecto est in hac pericopa lectionis varie-
viii MONITUM LECTORI.
tas, multoque major quam in quacunque Novi Testa-
menti parte ; quod non aliunde credo oriri potuit, quam
ex minus diligenti et constanti ejus publico usu in

quarundam Ecclesiarum sacris Officiis; quo quidem


potissimum divinae scripturse integritas atque uniformi-
tas servari et sustentari valuit.
Praeter Cod. Coisl. adhibuimus in duobus Catenis
Cod. Bodl. (B), quo jam usi sumus in Cat. ad Evang.
S. Matthsei, et in nonnuUis etiam locis Cat. in S. Lucam
Cod. Laudianum (L), qui ssepe adhibitus fuit in Cat.

in Ev. S. Marci. Horum Supplementa et lectionis

varietas ad calcem voluminis relegantur. Sed perti-

nent tantum ad Epitomen Comment. in S. Lucam, qui


vulgo Tito Bostrensi tribuitur, et ei parti Commentarii
in S. Joannem, quse Chrysostomo debetur. His autem
corrigendis utilia invenientur, sarciendisque iis quae
omissa sunt aut mendose scripta, oscitantia, sive veteris
librarii Coisliniani, sive illius cujus opera ad transcri-
bendum Codicem, lectu non facilem, Parisiis usi sumus.
C A T E N A
IN

EVANGELIUM S. hVCM
E CODD. BODL. ET PARIS.
KE^AAAIA»
TOT KATA AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.

a . rieg) T^f airoypa^T^s,

|3'. ITs^) Tcuv aypavXovvTcov irojjtAevav,

y. Uep) "S.viLeoav.

S', Tlep) "Avvjjf TYis vpofr}Ti8os.

t . Usp) Tov yevoftevou p^[Ji.aTog Tcpos 'looavvriv,

r . Uep) Toov eitepuiTy^^ravTcav tov 'lcouvvriv,

^. Ylep) Tov nreipacTfj.otJ toO "^wrrripos.

1)'. ITg^J ToD e)(OVTOs wevfx.a doufMViov.


$'. Uep) TT^s irsvQspas HsTpov.
I . Hep) Toov la&evToov ano TrotxiA^v vovw,
ia . Yiep) TT^s aypas twv l^$6oov.

1/3'. Hep) ToO XsTrpov.

ly. Ylep) Tov vapaXvTixov.


18'. ritp) Aeu» Tou TeXaovou.
is'. Tlep) Tou ^r)pav e^ovTOs
X^'§"'
«r'. Tlsp) TT^s '«Jv ' A.TToaToXuiv IxAoy^f.

i^. Yiep) Toov [jiax,api(j-iJuJov,

iij'. Ylep) Tou 6xaTOvr«p;^ou.

16'. Ylep) Tov vlov TT^S %^P«f •


X . Yleg) Toov aTro<rTa\evToov irapa 'Icoavvj).

xa . Ylep) T^f a\si^aar}S tov Kupiov [Jivpoo.

x/3 . Ylep) Trjs vapa^oKYis tou airelpovTOs.

xy'. Ilgp) Tr^s 67r»r»/x,^o-6fli)f toow uSaTcov.

xS'. Ylep) Tou Ksyemvos.


xs'. Ylep) Tris dvyaTpos tov ap^i(rvvayooyou.

xg-'. Yleg) tyis a\[i.oppov<rris.

x^'. Ilep) Tr^s «TrocToX^f t»v »|3'.

xr\ . Ylep) Toov e apTOOV xa» tmv /3' l^6voov.

x9'. Ilgp) T^5 Tou Kvpiov eiregooT^<ysoos.

a Hsec Capita dedi e Cod. Bodl. L.

B 2
KE4)AAAIA TOT KATA

X'. Tlepi T^f iieTai/.op(pu)(recos.

Koi. rispi ToO (r6X)jv<«^oju,evou.

A/3'. rispi T60V 8<aXoyi^OjU,gvcov tij jas/^cov

Xy'. ITs^) Tou eTTiTpeirofji.evou «xoXoySsTv.

A8'. riepl Twv avaSsjp^flsvTcov o'.

Xs'. ris^» ToD sTrspcoT^o-avTOj yojw,*xou.

Ag-'. ITsp) Tou lj«.7rso-o'vToj eJj touj XjjaTaj.

X^. Uep) MapQas xa» Map/aj,


Ai)'. ITe^i frpoa-ev^ris.

Xff. Uep) Too e^QVTOg 8a»ju.o'viov xco^ov.

^'. Hep) T% Ix ToD o;^Xoo eirapaaYjS (pcov^v.

J«,a'. Ilsg) TC«V aJTOUVTCOV o")jjw.s7ov.

|w,/3'. ITsp) ToD ^apKralov toD xaXeo-avTOf tov 'Iijo-oDv.*

/xy'. Tlep) ToD TaXavicrju,oD tcov voju-ixcov.

ju.S'. Ilegi T^f ?wju.>jj Tcov ^apKTaluiv.

l/,e'. riep) ToD fleAovTOj fiepi<j-a(rQai Tijv xXYjpovo[x.lav,

fjLg-'. Ylep) ToD ou riv(popr}(rev yj yuipa ttAouciou.

ft^'* ITegl Tcov raX»Xa«cov xa» tcov Iv tw lE»Acoa/«,.

ju,)j'. ITe^) Tijs ep^ooo-ijf itveviuu a<r$sveias.

IJL^'. Ilep» Tcov •napa^oXcov.

v . ITeg» ToD STrspcoT^cravTOj si oX»'yo» o» (rco}^o[ji,evoi.

va'. ITegi Tcov el7ro'vTcov ToJ 'I)jo"ou 8ici 'HpcoS)jv.

v/3'. riepi ToD u8pco7r»xoD.

vy. Uep) ToD ju,:^ ayavav Tas 9rpcoTOxX»(7»aj.

v8'. ITepl Tcov xaXoujaevcov Iv toj 8s»'7rvco.

ve'. ITep» o»xo8oju,^j Tcvpyou Trapa^oXtj.

Vf'. ITep» ToD avo'SyiiJ:.r}(TavTOS elg %copav /u-axpav.


v^. riep» ToD o»xovo'ju,oo t^j «8ix»'a^.
v)j'. ITe/j» ToD TrXoucr/ou xa» toD Aa^apou.
v6'. TTep» Twv »'
Xewpcov,

^'. ITepl ToD xpiTOu TYis ahxias.

^ot . Tlep) TOii 4*apKTaiov xai tou tsXcovou.

^/3'. ITsp» ToD evepcoTrjcravTOS tov 'Irjaouv wAooo-iov.

^y'. ITep» ToD TufXoo.

^8^. ITe/ji Tou Zax;^«/ou.


0e'. Ilefi) Tou TropeuSe^VTOj A«/3eTv eaoToJ /3a(riXe/«v.

^r • ITep» Tcov Aa/3o'vTcov Ta^ ju,vaj.

^^. rTep» Tou TrcoAou.

0)j'. ITsp» Twv 67r6pcoT)jo-avTcov Tov Kup»ov app^»6p6cov.


^6'. Ilep» Tou «ju,7reAcovoj.
AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
o'. Hep) Tcov eyKaQsToov 8»« tov xijvcrov.

0«'. rie^i Tcwv 2a88ooxa»«>v.

0/3'. risp» T^5 Toy Kuploo eTrspooTY}<reoos wpoj touj ^oipKyaiov§.


oy'. ri?p) T^j Ta /3' AsTTTa.

08'. riep» T^j (TOVTsAs/af.

os'. Ile^» Tou Vla(T^ot.


05-'. Ile^» Twv (p»Xove<x>j<ravT«;v t»'; |u,e»'^«jv.

O^. rig^l T^f h^aiTY}(T8C0S TOU "SoiTuvoi.


0)j'. Ilep» To5v xoTTTO/xevcov yuvaixoov.

06'. 'E^oo9ev)]0"»j 'HpcoSou.

w'. Ile^i Tou j[x.eTavo:^<ravTOj A)j<rTou.

Tra'. IIsp» T)jj alTri<recos tou <rc«/AaTOj tou Ku^/ou.

^r/S'. Ilep» Tou KAeo'7ra.


EPMHNEIA
TOY KATA AOYKAN EYAFrEAIOY.

ToT ArioT laANNOT TOT XpTSosTOMOT. EvayyeXiov Ka-


Xoir av, ovk eTrnVi^ I3e(3aia Kai aKivyjTa fxovov eariv ayaBa Kai

vnep TVjv a^iav tyjv vjixerepav, aAA oti Kat jtACT evKoXiag airdcrvji 5
rjft.iv e^oGrj' ov^e yap irov^aavTe^ Kai i^pcoaavTeSf aAA' dyaTtti-

BevTes vno rcy ^eov [xovoVf eXd^ofxev airep eXd^ofxev. Kvayye-


Xiov ^e eaTi Xoyog Trepie-^^oov eicayyeXlav itpayfkdTm KaTa to

FivayyeXiov, ^ia to wcpeXeh ev(f)paivuv tov aKOvovTa, eirav irapa-

^e^YITai To enayyeXXofxevov. 10

AovKoii fxaKdpiog, laTpo^ fxev y]v r^v rej^v^v, yeyove ^e Kai


xpv^^cov laTpo^, dvafBag dito rov eXaTTOvog eiri to KpeiTTov. KaTO-
XeXonre yap yjfuv rwv 'I>?<roy Xoym re Kai QavfxdTCOv tvjv fxv^fJLvjv

eyypa(f)ov. fLovos te tSov dXXwv KvayyeXiaTciov aKpi/Scci eitoiyjaaTO

Tvjv Tov KvayyeXiov ypa(f)Yjv, Kat iroXXa twv Tollg aXXot$ aeaia-i^

7T'^fj.evm, ovTog direfi.vvjfi.ovevae xe Kai ^ie^^i^XOev dKpijSSif, oto Kat

TO irpooifxtov Tyj<; YiVayyeXtKrjg ypa<pYjg aKptj3eiav eicayyeXXeTat.

^YiireLBrjTrep iroXkol hre^^^eiprjaav dvaTci^aaOai SLr)yrj-

aLv Trepl rav TreTrXypo^oprjpeucov ev rjpXv TrpayfiaTcov.

ToT EN Ariors Titot EnisKonoT Bo2TPnN, kai Opi-20


TENOTS. To *'
eiteyeipfjaav^ evTavQa avTt OTt xooptg yaptafia-
Tog yjXBov eig tyjv dvaypa<pyjy rwv KvayyeXtm Tiveg, jqj^ voeh.

y\.aTBahg yap ovk eTte^^^etprjaev dXX eypaxpev aito dytov irveu-

fJMTog, Ofxotoog Kat MdpKog Kat ladvvyjg, irapaTtXvjatoog he Kat

AovKag, to fxevToi eTttyeypafXfxevov KaT AtyvitTtovg KvayyeXtov, 25


Ka) TO eitiyeypafXfj.evov xwv i0 EivayyeXtov, 01 avyypdi^iavTeg

eiteyetpfjaav. rtoXXa §e Kat etepa (J^epovrat, «AAa ra reaaapa


I. 5. EPMHNEIA T. K. AOTKAN EYArrEAIOT. 7

Tov Kpiarov ^EKKXrjarta vpoa^eyjerat.


" 7r€n\v}po(popif][Ji.€Vuv^
ixova rj

§€ Xeyeif «$• oy% aTrAaJf tw Xoya vapa^e^ofxevuvj ov^e 4^^^^ t^


viarfi irap€iXi^[Ji[J-evwv, aWa vept wv ev itXripo^opta. yeyovev avTOii

TrapvjKoXovSrjKWf To7i epyots' avTOHTai Se Kat vTtvjpeTag KaXei tov^

aytovq k.TtodToKovq. -

'EyeVero kv rajis r)fi4paL9 'HpcoBov tov ^axnXiws T7J9

'lovBaia^.

'Es ANEnirPA*oT. AafJLJSdvei nrpwTOV tov yjpovov, iva fJLr] ^ta-

<j)vyri Twv 'apayfj.d.Twv o Katpo?, Kat cf>y)crtf (3aai\evi Tvji 'lovSa/af,

«re/S^ Ta Ttapa 'lov^aiot^ eS/^a^e, avv^dws to/V Ttpo^YjTatg tqv io

^aatkewg twv 'lov^aiav <f>epei tov yjpovoVy Kat ovrwq aTvjpi^ei T^g

itapovfftag tov lyjcxov t>;v yvwatv.

'l€p€V9 Tis ovojJLaTL Zaxaplas, i^ i(j)r]ix€pLas 'AjSta.

Ea ANEnirPA*OT. ELaTepa Se ladvvov ovo[jt.d^et, tva tov


Ttpo^po[i,ov ap^vjTat Ti^g EvayyeXtKVjg l<JToptag, Kat ovTwg eig tov 15

'Ivja^ovv TtapayevvjTat' Oio Kat tvjv yevvvjatv avTov irpwTVjv Kvay-


yeXtaTvis e^vjye7Tatf 6av[j.aT0vpy^[xa ovaav 0eov, oitep Ka\ avTO

Ttpo^aatv etye vtaTewg dyaO^g.

Oti Ttep "hvo vjaav iepe7g Ik '^to^oyvjg t^v ketrovpyiav itoi'

ovvTeg, AI3ia ovtw Xeyo[J.evog, kou 'Layapiag. htei ovv tepd- 20

Tevaev ev t^ XetTovpyia o APia, [t,eTa tv}v eKetvov e(f>i^[j.epiav

eXeiTOvpyei 6 Zayapiag. e^vj[i.epiav ^e ypv] voe7v ov to Ttpog v}[j.e-

pav Ttapa[j.eveiv Kat XeiTovpyeTv ev tw lepwy aAAa to itpog e0^o-

fjL^a' ^ei^at Se 6eXwv oti eKaTepw6ev vo[xt[j.ws eTvyyavev iepevg


Zayaptag, (f>v}at, " Kai v} yvvvj avTOv eK twv 6vyaTepwv ^Aapwv." 25

6 'Hcrai/ 5e SiKaLOL afi({)6T€poL ivayjTLOv tov Q€0V.

To etvai te ^tKatoi evwitiov tov 0eoi5, eiratvog eaTt TeXeiog'


avTog yap htiaTaTat [xovog Tag twv dvBpwitwv Kap^tag. Kat yap
ev^^eyeTat KaTa [j.ev to <f>atvo[J.evov ^tKaiov etvat Ttva evwittov twv

avSpwTtwv, KaTo. te tq KpvTrrov T^f ^iavoiagy [nrj eivai Totoirtov, ^.o

e[j.<f>wkevovTag KeKTV}[t.evov Koyta[x,ovg irowipovg.

Tivof ^e eveAcev irpoaKetTai Ta7g evToka7g Kat To7g ^tKatw[Laai

Tow Kvptov TO d[j.e[i.iTTovi evet^'^ itep ev tw awei^oTi pxntov Kevo-

^o^tag, V} dvBpwTtapeaKeiagy v) hepQV Tivog toiovtov ovk etyov.


» EPMHNEIA TOT KATA I. ii.

BovAojM.evoj' §€ ^eT^at OTt ^ tov Kv/j/ou yevea-if tj Tiapd^o^off

aKXrjv irpo eayr^ Karea-Kevaae yeveatv, Ka\ oti T^g (f^viiedof

e<TTi ^ifjfxtovpyoi o hri^Yi^taVy eTrviyaye Keym' " Koi ovk ^v avTo^s

TeKVoVf Kai Ta e^vjs.

II Q.^0r) Se avTco "AyyeXo^ Kvplov. 5

Kai eiret^v) ov iraat (patveTat 0eof, Pj 01 "AyyeKoi avTOVy


ei fjir] Totg KaQapav eyova-i t^v Kap^iav, ^v ^e Za^^apia^ ro/oi/TOf,

^ta TovTO ctxpSvj avTW AyyeXos Kvpiov.


**
Tou OvaiacrTYjpiov §e tou 6v[xiay.aT0i*' e«rev, eTre;^»; "rjv Kai

^Tepov OvaiaaT-^ptov y^aXKOvv to tuv 6\oKap7rcoy.aTav. "'ETa-io


** payOy] Se Za^^apiaqy^ Kat to. e^^f . ttOTt ^evi^ovaa oipt$ avSpavca

(f>atvof/.evif] ovK eaTtv vTrofxovi^T'^' aAA Ojawf eTriaTpecpet airo TVjg

Tapayv]'; tov Tjayfaptav A-yyeAof, eiTrm «utw, " fi^ (fto^ov Za-
" yapia^^ Kat avaKTaTat avTov.

ToT Xptsostomot. Yloia ^e avTr] aKoXovBia^ oti virep tov 15

Aaoi) irapaKaXovvTog toi) Tjayaptov^ Kat vn\p afjLapTv^ixaTcov Seo-

fxevov, Koi avyyviofxfiv atTOvvTog to/V avv^^ovXotg, elireh irpog av-

TQV Tov AyyeXoVf " fi.y] (f}o(3Qv, etay]Kova6r] yap v] ^et^aig aoVf^ Kat

Tov aKQvaOyjvai aTrodet^tv Troienat, to Te^^^ByjaeaOat avToci iraHta

Tov ^lcocxwyjv ; Kat fxaXa eiKOTcog' eiret^y] yap vnep tcov dfxapTV]- 20

fxaTcav Toi) Kaov TrapeKaXet, efxeXKe ^e TtKTetv tov viov /SooovTa,


£<V5>''^
*de / afjivos
~£:v~fV
tov Kyeov atpcov
NrafxapTiav,
Tijv
/}»
kai
\\f(-~
Ta e^iyf, eiKO-
»/

Tcog <py]aiv y]Kova6y] yj ^ey]at( aov, Kat Te^v] vtov.

MeyeSoi efi.<patvet T^g lcodvvov x^y%^?, Kai fxeye6oi jSXeTrofJievov

vTro Qeov. eaTt yap fj.eye6o(; y^vyjqg KaTo, dpeTy]v, Kat eaTi Ttg 25
afxtKpoTy]? "t^^vyyjg, eyco ovTcog aKOvca tov ev tSo KvayyeXtco, "
^^
" KaTa<f>povy]ar]Te evog twv afJ.tKpm tZv ev t^ FiKKXy]ata'^' fxtKpov

yap €Kei tov evavTiov tg5 fj.eydXcp Xeyet' oTt 6 tv^^wv 6 fxtKpog
**
eaTtf S^Aov €K tov og av aKav^aXtar] eva tcov afitKpcav tovtcov'^*

fJieyag yap ov aKav^aXt^eTat, dXX 6 fxeyag iravTog aKavhdXov ^o

KpetTTCOv eaTi.

I c EoTat yap ixeyas ipcoTriov tov Ku/otbu.

*l^ov Kat evTav6a **


evcwnov Kvptov^' Xeyet, caairep Kat irepi twv

TeKovTcov avTOV e^prjTat.


1. 18. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOY. 9

"EiiKepa ^e fo-ri ttocv to fJiiQvjv {xev ironTv Suvap,€Vov, ovk ov oe e|

afJLveXov.

'EtA^o-^ij &€ UvevfJiaTos 'Ayiov ev Tyj KoiXia t^? fJi-yjTpog avTov


wrapyjav o laavvfig, yjviKa iXBovarj<; t^? fMjTpo^ tov Kvpiov Trpog

Tfiv EA/crajSer, ((XKipTifjaev ev ajaXXidcrd. 5


Kax fxiv Iwdvvrj^f iroWovs twv vlwv €7reaTpeip€ itpog Kvptov

Tov 0eov •^fi.Zv KaTo. ttjv roy Ytvayyekiov cfxav^v' 6 Se Kvpio^

vjfji.av lyjaovf o \pi(TTO^, wavTa? €(f)WTi<T€V eig tyjv eiriyvoxjiv TV}i

aXvjBeiag' tovto yap avTov to epyov eaTi.

17 To &e *'
TTpoeXevaeTai ev irvevfj.aTi Kai 'tvvdfj.ei 'HX^oy," toutoio
ecTT/V HX/aj t^^ ^evTepaq tov Kvpiov Ttapovaiag laTi •jrpo-
^pofJLOff KaBwg, (f>y]aiVf 6 vpocp-^Tifjg elire' " TiefJi^pco vfi.7v HXiav tov
" SealSiTfjVf irpiv eXdeTv Tr)v yjfxepav Kvpiov tvjv fJi.€ydXv]v Kai
" €Tri(f)avrj." ovTCog ovv Kai lctidvvvjg r^f TrpcoTVjg yeyove Tipo-

%pofJ.og' Kai ev Trvevfj.aTi fxev, oti ooaTrep vjv eiri tov HX/av vj tov ^5

Ylavayiov Y\v€Vfj.aTog ydpig, ovTtng Kai liri tov •jrpo^pofi.ov. ev ^vo

Se ^ia TO f/.€y€6og T^g irXripovff.ivvig irap avTcov ^iaKovtag.

T/ eaTi TO eiriaTpexpai Kap^tag iraTepm eiri T€Kva ; Teoa tou

lovSaicov Aaoy ol ayioi ^ATroaToXoi vTrrjpyov' e^ ayTaJv yap KaTrf-


yovTO Kara t^v tov aifuaTog avyyeveiav. TOiavTvj ovv eaTai^ (f)Vjaiv, 20

vj Tov lcodvvov ^taKovia, cog hriaTpexpat Taf toJv lov^^aicov Kap^iag

etg TVjv Twv ArroaToXcov ^i^aaKaXiav' yap "nepi ^piaTOv toi~


avTa fj-apTvp-^aag, avvetarfyaye Tvj TOiavTrj fi.apTvpia Kat Tovg

'K.ptaTov ft.a6vjTagf Kat ro d^toTriaTov avToig €k tovtov KaT€-

aKCvaae. 25
To Se **
dvetOeTg ev (f)povv}a€t ^iKaicav^ ^rjXor, OTt airetdeTg fxev

ef dpyvig vTrrjpypv 01 'lou^aro;, (ppovvjaig ^e ^iKaicov, v) ev TOiV

ATroaToXotg ovaa r]v.

To Se **
€TOtfj.daat Ku/j/oj," Kat toc e^^f, dvTt tov irpocvTpe-

iriaat tco 'K.piaT^ eiprjTat' irpo tov (f)av€pS>aai cavTOv €ft.Trapa- ^o


aK€vov Kat TrpoKaT€aK€vaafj.€vov Xaov' TroXXa yap davfj.aaTa

•npoetTrm irept tov Kvptov 6 7rpotpofj.og, Trjv €tg avTOV irtaTtv tov

Xaov TrpoevTpeirtaev.
18 Ka) eiret^tr^ep diriaT-^aag Zayaptag, " KaTa rt yvcoaofJMi
" TOVTo/* (f)r]atVf evtTtfJ.a.Tat KOi(f>OTr]Ta Kat d(f)Coviav, coaavei Toi/35
^' c
10 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA 1.22.

A^yylAou \iyovroi ravra irpo^ avToV eTre*^^ aTTKrrtif ^AyyeXa


Trapea-TyjKOTi Seoo, kou ov TriaTeveis tw aiTOCTTeiXavTi avTOv, oii^e

Koiyi^yi T^v Tov Ae-yovxof ^vvafniVf aXXa t^v tov Trpdyfi.aTos «ou-

vafAiaVf "^ta tvjv aTTKJTOv aov TavTVjV (pcovvjv, dcpaipeBvjo-vj TVjg (fxov^g'

eojf av Tov 'npdyixaTog TikripwBtVTog, yvwg Kai to <jov anKSTov Kai 5


TO ^wvaTOv ToD Seov.

*H Tiayapiov Koxpeva-ii, ovk e/fwX^^e/ yeyovtv wg evo^/craf* ev

«rwej^e/a yap 6€0(f>aveiag Kai dyyekiKvis oirTaaiag r^v 6 lepevg

KaBapSig To7g [j.vaTif]pioig ^iaKOvovfxevog' dXXd tw Ti/Tro) T^g eKei-


vov aiyvjs Kai a-Teipwaeag Kat yrjpovg Tey^yivai tvjv (fxov/jv, tovto lo

olfJiat ^yjXovv tq ck tov 7ra\aia6evTog Kat KaTayvjpdaavTog Kat

aTetpaj^evTog t^ dvviKoia rwv ^e^afAevm vofxov tov ypaitTOv rag


Ttept 'KptaTov irpoppi^aetg itpoek^eh, Kai tyjv aiiTOv fxyjrepa eK

TOVTov '7rpo€\6eiv.

22 A<a ^e Tov (3ovkea6at fj.a6elv tvjv aiTiav T^g atam^g tov Xaov, 15
TayT>jv ^ia vevfxaTog 6 Tiayaptag e^i^Aov, Kat tovto eartv tawg,
*'
OTt Kat avTog y]v ^iavevav avTOig Kat tte.fj.etve KoxfyogJ'^

T/ ^e Kat ^tevevev avToTg ; to ^tavevetv Itafxevovra Ka}(f>ov,

TotovTOv eartv. ai yjcptg Xoyov iipd^etg, ov^ev ^tacfyepovat vevaeav,

ai ^e jtACTa Koyov Trpd^etg, ovk eiat vevaetg, KoafiovvTat ydp vtto 20

Toy Xoyov' eav ovv t^^yjg lovtat<cv tvjv iioXtTetav dXoyov, ccg fi.yj

^vvaa6at avTovg ^t^ovat Xoyov itept m TtpdTTOvat, ^Xeite tov

TVTtov Twv yeyevyjfj.evwv eTtt TAayapiov 'hiafi.evovTog Kacf)ov kou ^ta-

vevovTog avToTg. eart yap vvv Kwcffog 6 Xaog Kat aXaXog. vag yap
ovK yjfAcXXev aXaXog Kat dXoyog eivat, eKJSaXcbv tov Xoyov d(f> 25
eavTov, Ka). fj.yj
tvvdfj.evog itep) fi.y}^evog Xoyov dTto^ovvat vofJ.iKOv

vj TtpocpvjTiKOv Xoyov.

24 Ai^en-a; ^e oy ^EXtadjSer ^ta to ev yvjpet avXXaBetv, aa^pcov


yap vjv yj yvvv}.

OpirENOTS. E/cpyjTTev eavTVjV eiti ft.yjvag Ttevre, ecog Kat M.apta$o

avXXd(Byi, ore yap Mapta avveXa/3e Kat vjXde Ttpog avTVjv, Kai
OTe eyevero aa7taafj.og avTVjg eig ra uTa avrvjg, eaKtpTVjaev

ev dyaXXidaet to (3pe(pog ev Tvj KotXia TVjg ^EXtad^er, kat Ik

YlvevfJ.aTog dyiov eXdXvjae rd dvayeypafxfj.eva, Kai eXaXvi^vj ev tvj

opetv^ TtavTa ra pvjfi.aTa ravra. XaXvj^evTCOv ovv avTcHv cag itept^^


1.33. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 11

Qetag avXXi^eujs Kai wg Trepi tt^o^^toi; /x.eAAovTO<' yewaaOai cv

Tw Aaoj, ovK €Ti €avTip irepieKpvl^ev, aAA' ei Se? ovTa^ eiTreTv,

Kai evappyja-taaaTOy oti apa yevvyjfJia eti^ avTrjg o irpo^poixos rov

KvptOV ^fXXV I»J<70V XjO;0"TOt).

Ovet^oi ^e ev avQpwTroig tovto Xeyet, oirep ev toT^ yjpovot^ ^

eKeivotf vTiyjpyeVy TovTeaTtv yj aT€Kvta, yjyovv to eivat orTeTpav,

(oavep enatvog Kat evkoyia yj iroXvTeKvta, Mijva eKTov Xeyei


Tov Tyjg a-vW-^rpecoi laavvov.

E/7re oe 6 KvayyeXtaTyjg Trepi TVji itavayiaq 'heaitoivy\q yi\Km


SeoiOKoVf OTt yjv ixeiJivyjaTevfx.evyj dv^pl e| q^kov Aa/3i§ Ka} itaTptag, lo

oetl^ai PovXofxevog, OTt Kat avTy] yj 7ravd[xa}[Jiof eK yevovg ^v tov


AaPih. oBev Kat 6 jUv^o-Teuo-a^evof avT^v 'lcoa^cf}' ozJSe yap yjv

^vvaTOV KaTa tov vo[jlov diio cf)vX^g eTepag dpfJ.o^ea6at yvvcuKa.

**
38 Eirei^y/ te eli:ev Seog t^ Eva, ev Xviratg re^i^ Te/cva*" Aue^

T>jv Ay^v TavT>jv ^ X^pa ^v 6 AyyeXos ^'^at, " Xa^p^ Key^apt- 15


" Ta)[j.evy] Kvptog fJ.€Ta aov.'*

To ^c **
^^eAoy^^eTo TroTawoj 6«; daitaa^j.og ovtos" tovto
efj.(f>aivet, waavet eXeye itpog eavTyfv, fj.y]
dpd Ttg aTOjro?, wf c^
dv^pog vpog Kopyjv ; yj QeJog' eTret^y] kou Qeov [J-v^fJ^y] avveaTt too

**
da7raa[j.ca, to 6 Kvpiog fxeTo. aovr 20
30 A/a Se TO jtx^ etvat ^yvaTOv, Bopv^ovfJ.evr]v Kat (j)o(3ovft.evi^

dKpt^iog dKovetv to, XeyQyjaofievaf Ita tovto kvet TtpwTov avTyfg

Tov (f)ol3ov 6 AyyeXog eiTtoiVy ** fLy] (pojSov M.aptaf/.,^^ tva ev ara-


pa^ia. yevofj.€vyj, ^e^i^Tou Ty]v Qetav dTtoKpiaiv.

To fj!ev ovv eivelv tov AyyeXov itpog avT>?v, **


evpeg ydptv'^ 25

KOtvov y]v' evpov yap yaptv itpo avTVjg Kat akXat, ro ^e eiTteiv

**
avXXi^xpyjf^ ovK€Tt Kotvcv y]v, dXX i^^td^ov etg e-aayyeXiav.

E/we ^c TovTo, tva Sc^Itj tov Kvptov e^ avTVjg T-rjg itapQevtKyfg

w^vog KOi eK ryjg y]fJ.€T€pag ovaiag Xa^ovTa Ty]v adpKa.


32 AiKaiwg ^e €kX^6v] ^li^aovg 6 eitt acoTyfpia tov y]fj.eTepov yevovg ^o
eXQav' TO yap ovofna tovto eig t>?v 'EAAo^a yXiaaaav fj^era^aX-
XofJ.€voVf Qeov XeyeTai acoTy]pia Ka\ 'iaatg.

To Sc *'
eaTat /xeyaf," wj ^ecTTroTi^f Kat ^y]fj,tovpyog ^y]XoT, Kat

oy% o}g i(aavvY]g' to yap €TtayofJ.€vov OTt * Ytog Yi\/taTOV kXi^o^-


** *'
crcTai" TOVTO e[J.(patV€t. YlSig ^e (f)y)atv Xiog 'Txptarov kXi^-^^
C 2
12 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA 1. 34.

ov](7€Tai ; ebei yap fAaAAov emeiVj iiog lipta-Tov vnapyei^ (0$

Trpo Tuv aiavav €K tov YlaTpog yewvjSevTos avTov. aW epov^eV


OTi hxjirep wv <pva-ei d^yj&vig Qeog 6 Tlog, eAa/3ev ev ^copeag [^epei

^ia TO avdpcoTTtvov to ovofi.a to vnep Trav ovo[xa, TovTecTi TO


KaXe^crBat Qeog' Kat acmep av Kvpiog 7rdcv]g Tvjg KTicrecogf wg ^

^vjfjLtovpyog Kat notviTvjg, €K Qcopeag XafxlSdvei TtaTptKVjg eig K\vjpo-

vofxiav Ta eOvvi ^ia to avOpantvov. " atTviaai^ ydp (f^vjai


" irap^

** Kat ^aaco
e/xov, crot eBvv] tvjv Kkvjpovo[J.tav aovJ" ovTag av (pvaei

Kat dXYi&ag Tiog, Kat eK TVjg ovatag eKXdfxxpag tov UaTpog icpo

'*
TrdvTOiV Tuv atmwv, Ttog YxpiaTOv" KaXenat, §;a to dv6pa7rtvov. 10
Kat TO
xvcc^,/ ' bwaet
»5,v~> 'f
Oe tv; otKovofxia apfxoTTet.
/

Spovov Se ovK aiaQYjTOv Xeyet, dkXa tov fLVj^ev Svvjtov Kat

eiriKVjpov eyovTa, tov Ka6 o\v]g Ty^g oiKovfLevvig (fxoTog ^ikviv eKXdf*.-

TTOVTa, Kai ^v^ag voepag KaTavyd^ovTa, '^ta TVjg evBeov tt^taaKaXtag.

Ka/ otKOV Se laKafB^ f/^ to \ovtai(i)V eSvog fLOvov vofj.ia(Ofj.ev, 15

dXXa Kai itdvTag Tovg tta T^g KXviaecog tov HcoT^pog vjft.aVf e^

dndvTav twv e6vav etg tv^v toov dytcov vioSeaiav etairotovfi.evovg.

RaatXeiav ^e TeXog ovk eyovaav ov^evog eaTi tov (3aa-iXevetVy

€t fJiV] fj.ovov ToD tvjfj.tovpyov Kat "heaTiOTov tS>v oXm 0eov. wcrTe

avToV ecTTt l3aatXevg aloovtog, ^ta tv^v vjfxeTepav a-aTVjpiav 20

dvOpwirog yeveaBat KaTO^e^dfJ.evog.

34 Ovy^ wg airtaT^aaaa v] Travayta irap&evog to " Trwg eaTat


**
TovTO, €7re/ avtpa ov ytvwaKoo" Xeyet, dXX wg ao(f>v] tov Tpoirov

eirt^vjTovaa fiaSeiv tov vpayfj.aTog tov Xeyofievov. ov^e yap


yeyove irpoTepov Tt TOtovTov, ov^e fJ.eTd TavTa yev-^aeTaf Xeyw 25
Vri TO TrapSevov TeKeh, o6ev Kai avyyivwaKet 6 AyyeXog, Kat tov
**
Tpoirov epfJ.v]vevci}V Xeyet, Y]vevfj.a Aytov e^eXevaeTat eirt ae, Kai
**
tvvafj.tg 'TxpiaTOv^ Kat Ta e^^<'. " ^ptaTog Se Seov '^vvafj.ig

**
Kou Qeov ao(f)ta," cog hi^daKet ^AiroaToXog. Kat irag fj.ev

eireXevaeTat ; ovk o\\m to eirep')(pfj.evov, evepyvjaei Ve 'hvifj.tovp- 30


yiKwg fJ.v] (f>aivQfx.evov.

35 T/ &€ eo-TiV **
eaiaKidaei aot ;" 7rept(3aXei ae Kai ev^^vav] ae
Ka\ irepf/apaKwaet ae, Kai kvkXco aov eaTat.
^pv) ^e aKoirv]aai irwg oX^v avTV]v tv]v iravaytav Kat ^coQTroiOV

Tptd^a e^e<f)v]vev e/srwv, Flvey^a 'Aytov Kai ^vvafxtv, Kat TxptaTOV. 35


1. 41. AOYKAN ETArrEAIOY. . 13

Ov <7vyyiva)(XK€t le tw Zay^apia o "Ayye^^os aTria-T^aavTi ^iKaiai,

^iOTi ityev Ikuvo^ €iV vTrotuy(j.a Kai aKXag (TTeipaf irpo avTov

y€vof*.€va$ Kai T€KOvaag, ag al SeTat ypa(f>ai '^i^<x.aKOv<n,

0^5^ (xirXctii te TO y^vaixivov <^ri<xi itpog ttiv irapSevov 6 Ayye-


Acf, iva fxy] e^coQev €Trei(rayo(JL€vov avTy (7wi/.a vofXKJ-Q^, ak\ 5
«TTiyyaye Kat to " eK croi)," tva e^ avT^i (pvaei to yevcc[ji.evcv

eivat TTt^TTevOyj,

'Aytov Se KXyjOi^^rofJLtvoy ovy^ wg evotKOv e^ovTa tov Tiov tov

Seovy Kat eK fj.eToyyjq (xyiaa-6r]ao[j.evov, <xX\ wf cvra K(XTa <pv(7ty

aytov, TOJ Tov avTOV Tiov vnap^^eiv Qeov Kai eva eivai. 10
^vyyev^ Se t^? Ylavaytag itapBevov Trjv EX«ra)SfT eiTtev

Ayyekog^ etre ag e^ kvog iipoTr(XTopog tov laKwP vitap^^ov^xag, etTe

^ia TO Tipo TTjg vofJ.o6e(7ia$^ Xa(3eiv tov Aapav eK Trjg tov Aevi

<j>v\yjg ovza yvvalKa ttjv EX/c7a/3eT, BvyaTepa ovaav tov A/A/va-

Sa^, T*?v a^(\(l>vjy Aaaawv, Ik T^f ^lovta <f>vk^g virapyovTog. 15

Kot yap evTavSa avv^<f>6i^ vj ^aaiKiKr} tov 'lov^a <f>vkrj, €^ rjg

vitrjpyev EiktadPeT. ^to Kat irapo^o^cag rj irdvao^pog tov itavaytov

WvevfLaTog (£KOV0fj.riae yjxptg, Kat TavTVjv tvjv Za^^^aptov yvva^Ka

'EAio-a/JfT TTpoaayopeveaBai, leaiiep Kat Trp tov Aapwv, oii(og '^ta

Tou ovofJiaTog evapyccg /*a5wjM,ev, ag e| eKetwjg Tvjg Kktaa^^T ao


iraapyei yj avyyeveta,

38 Ktirovaa ^e rj Ylavayta TrapSevog, " /^ot» yj ^ovXyj Kyp/ou" Kat


Ta e^^g, tovto eS^Awo-e, Tnva^ ejjU./, <f>y]at, ypa(f>ofj.evog^ j3ovXeTai

ypa<f>evg ypa<f>eT(a, -KotetTO) SeXet tov itavTog Kvptog.


Ae^a/xevof Se o "AyyeXog Ti^g itavayiag itap6evov tvjv ofj.okoyiav 25
rrjg itiaTectig, aTtyjXSev ait avTrjg.

ETtopevdrj Ce r} itavayia itapSevog elg t^v opeiwjv itpog tt/v

EXtaoiPeT, eitet^y] eKei (CKet Zayapiag, yvmat j3ovXo[J.€vi^ to


Ttepag av etitev 6 AyyeAof itpog ain^v.

Ovep oe ov^evt twv itpo<f>y]Twv vTirjp^e, tovto elg 'lceavviyv^o

yeyovev, Ota to TtXriatd.Xetv axnov Tr] ^piaTOv itapovaict K<ti Ttpo-

Tpey^etv avT^g. ho ov^e itpoTepov tov Ayiov Ylvevfj.aTog eitX.-^a^ri,

ea>f ov eveaTfj avToi yj Kvo<f>opovaa tov teaTtOTriv \ptaTov.

41 ToTC &e '7t\v]a6eig UvevfiLaTog 'Ayiov, ea^ipTa Kal t^ fJLvprpi

fxere^i^ov Tv^g yaptTog, Kat ave^oa Ttpo(f>r]TtKa vj 'KXtadjSeT ^$


14 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA 1. 42.

p^jaara, ^ia 10 Kvii(j)opov[Jie.vov €V avryj (3p€(f>o$, " tvXoyvj[j.€vy] <jv

" ev yvvai^i^ keyovaa " Kai evXoyrjfxevoi^ Kai to, e|^f. ov^^efxia

yap roiavryjg yapirog Koivmog, ovre yeyovev, ovre yeveaOai

^vvarat.

42 " K.ap7T0v ^e KoiXiag" eliie, Kara t*?v TiaXaiav rov 0eoi) npog 5

Tov Aa(3i^ eirayyektav rvjv Xeyovjav, " Ik Kapitov rvjg KOiXtaf


" awdvjcrofxat eirt rov Qpovov aov" KaXag ^e Kapirov KOi\iag r^^g

Ttavayiag iiapOevov y] ^EXtaa^er uvofjiaa-e, ^ia ro [Jir] e| av^tpog

eivatf «AX eK [j.ovy]g r^g navayiag QeoroKov Mapiagf Ylvev[J.arog


'Aytov evotKy](Tavrog ev avryj, Kat r^g rov 'TipicrTov tvv(X[J.ewg 10

eiit^yKtadacrYjg avryj. ot yap eK rwv Ttarepm t*;v (nropav eyovreg,

eKeivm etat Kapnot, Kadag Kat rw Aa(3i'^ eppeQy], eK Kapitov ryjg

KOtXtag, rovreartv ot Tcpoyovot ry]g Ttavaytag 6eoroKOV, Kat avrot

eK (ynopag av^pm yevvy]6evreg.

YiV[j.(f)ma te rm [/.ekXovrm vtto loodwov \eye(76at, yj [J.y]r'f]p 15

avrov aTre(f)6eyyero' axnrep yap eKeHvog ava^tov eavrov ry]g irap-

ovatag t% Tiap^evou 6eoroKov, aaavei Xeyovaa, rt yap [t.ot rY]Xt-

Kovrov TieTtpaKrai aya6ov, iva yj ["-"^rY^p rov Kvpiov [x.ov eXBy] irpog

[j.e. KaXel ^e avry]V [j.y]repa rr]V ert Kvo(f)opovaav, Trpo^py^riKa

Xoyco 7rpo(f)6<xvovaa ry]v Kvy]atv. 20

MaKapii^et ^e avryjv wg vj^y] Trtarevaaaav, " ort earat reXeto}-


" aig ro7g XeXa\y][i.evotg avrv] napa Kvpiov."
46 KiTTovaa ^e " [j.eya\vvet v] xpvyv] [xov rov Kvptov" rj Tcavayta

Ttap^evog, etet^ev eavryjv Kapitov "^o^oXoytag Ttpoacftepovaav. oaov

yap, <f)y]atv, v'nY]perov[j.at /xe-yaAco 6av[/.ari, roaovrov 0(f)eiX(a ^o^<x- 25


^etv rov ev e[/.ot evepyovvra •napo^o^a. "hto Kat y^yakkt<xaaro ro

TrvevfiLa [t.ov, rovreartv eTep<f)6y] Kai y]^vv6y] eitt rw ©eco tc5

Y.(t)T'^pt [J.OV. '2ci}ry]p [kov ydp eart Kai Qeog' acory^ptav ru) KoafLco

^t e[j.ov 'yapt'^o[j.evog. itvev^j.a te Kat '^vyr]V ro avro keyet.

48 Kat eTte/SXexpe Se', (pyjatv, eii e[j.e, ov^e yap eyo) TtpoaetoKiqaa 30
TOyTO, raTtetVT] ovaa Kat ava^ta, Kat vvv etg ovpavov dito yy]g

[i.era(3atvci}) appy]TOV otKovo[i.tav eKitky]povaa' Kat ovyi av [kovy] 07

FiXiadfSer, aXXa Kat itdvrm rm Tttarevovrm [/.aKaptovat [j.e

Ttdaat at yeveat, Kat yap [KeyaXeia eitoiy^ae [t,ot 6 ^vvarog, ort

itap6evog ovaa avveXa^ov, vTtep(3daa t>;v <f)vaiv ^ovXyj^jmti avrov,ZS


$

1. 54- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOY. 15

Kat. KaTa^iovfJL€vv] avev avtpog, ovy^ awAcSf e/va* /Ai^T^yp, aAAa tou
fxovoyevovs Tlov tov Seov Kai Qeov. Aia ^e to [jl^ airicT^a^ai

Tiva Tw TOiovTQ} fxvaTyjpio}, eiirev 6 ^yvaTOf, coaavei eAeyev, oti

^waTOg 6 TovTo evepyyjaai Qeog.

Ayiov Se e/7re to ovojaa ayTov, ^YjXovaa OTt ovhev Trapay^jpat-

V€Taif etg yvvalKa (rv\\a[xl3avo[xevo$ 6 Tav dndvTav ^r/fxtovpyoi.


* iva/ TO eAeo^- de «yTOv etg yeveag Kai Ta e$iyf. e3re/0>; Qta to

eXe^aai Ta? yeveaf tov yevewv aweX-^cf)^!^.


**
YlpoireSi^Ke Sc tois <f)o^ov[Jievotg ayTOV," ot< ot TrdvTyj avaJ^toty

Kai ev Tri dirta-Tta ^tafJievovTes ovk eXeovvTat, aAA' 01 ^i httyviO-10

aeoog •npog TriaTtv Kat fj.eTdvoiav fj.eTaTpeTrofj.evot.

51 *' Exo/jjcre &e KpaTog^ kcu to. e^^f. ene^ t% ovtov yeipog
ovK dvSpomov to epyov. Kai yap (Bpayiajv tov YlaTpog Ttog,

KaTa TO " eXvTpQXTco ev (Bpay^iovi aov tov Xaov crov." tt avTov ovv
vtKr^v etpydaaTOf Kai Tponaiov e<nri<Te, KaTa twv itdXat Tvpav- 15
**
vovvTwv vorfTxv eyPpav. AteaKopirtae" ^e Kat Tag tovtcov

avTvv Kap^tag, twv t^ ttavoia imeprj^pdvccv, TovTecrTt Tag (3ovXag


avTwv Tag KaQ v]fi.tt>v aTrpaKT^aat not-^aag. Toinovg ^e avTOvg
Kai ^vvdaTag Kake"!, ovg KaGeXwv vxpatTe Tovg TaTretvaxxavTag

eavTOvg vao KpaTaiav **


Trjv yeipa, &eSwAca)S' avTolg e^ovatav 20
**
iraTeiv endvca o<j>ea)v Kat aKopTiim, Ka) evi Ttaaav t*;v tvvafj.tv

**
Toy (y(Bpov^^

Ka; '*
TreivwvTaf" fxev Toiig e| e^vwv \tfJ.wTTOVTag Oetwv Xoym
KOi ^t^aa-KaXiag, eveitXrjaev dyaBu)v, twv Tijg veag ^taB^^Krjg. Tovg

Se TW vofJ.a} TtXovTovvTag ^lov^aiovg, Kai TO^ig Ttpo^rjTaig itiaivo-i^

fxevovs, Kevovg e^aTtecTeiXe, fj^ ttpoa^e^afj.evovg tov VTto tov vofxov

Kat tZv 7tpo<f)r/Tu>v 7tpo6ea7rt^Oft.evov "KptaTOv tov Qeov v]ft.wv.

54 To §€ *'
dvTeXdPeTO 'lapaviX Ttat^^og avTotJ," ^uvaTa* jtxev Kat

itpog Tov KaTO. adpKa ^lapa^X tovto dpfJ.oaat' itoXXat yap e^


avTav f/.vptdteg tttaTevaaaat tS) Kvpif eacoBrjaav. ^vvaTat Oe Kat 30

Ttpog Tov vo»yTOV Io-^a>;A tov ev tco voi opcivTa Qeov' tovto yap
laparjX epfi.r}veveTat, otTtveg etatv 01 eK twv eOvav ittaTevaavTeg. \

**
¥ifj.vria6ri Ve tou eXeovg avTov KaBwg eXdXvjae" Kat Ta e^rjg,

eig Ttepag dyaym, ottep rpt elirw» itpog avTOv, ort " evevXoyrjB'^-

" aovrat ev t» airepfLaTi aov Ttaaat at (f^vXai Tvjg 7^?." 35


16 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA I.56.

^6 " EfjL€iV€ 8e Maptafx. aiiv avT^^^ Kai to. c^^f. SiyAor oti ewf

ov TiKTCtv e/AcAAev ^ 'EA;<ra/3€T. e/ "ya^j ra e«rraj jtxijv/ t^^ o-yA-


Aiyx^ecuf avT^f aveaTaX^ 6 A-yyeAof wpos' t^v itavayiav irapBevov.

aireXOovaa ^e efxetve crvv avTyj [x^vaf Tpe?5", Trpo^vjXov oti TtXripcO'

BevTOi Tov y^ovov T^f cruAA^il/eojf t^^ EA;cra)9eT, €/$ tov oikovS

avTYji vireaTpeipev y} Ttavayia TrapBevoif ^ta to /xeAAov (yvvetaep-

yeaOai irXyjQog elg tov oIkov Tioyaptov, ev Trj TVjg EiXtaa/SeT

yevvyjcfei' tjv yap al^cog ev tyj itavayta TtapQevta TrapdevtKyj.

Tivog ^e yapiv efx,etvev ; 'laccg Kat toD Trapa^o^ov Beccpvjo-at t»jv

eKJ3a(7tv, Kai eirt Tolg KaO eavTvjv aitopovad Te Kat eKTtXyjTTO- 1 o


[J^ewij Kat Ti ^e-^aet yeveaGai ^ovXevofAevrj.

YlapaTfjpriaadBat Se^ ev oAtj ttJ vakata ^taB-^KY} Kat Tyj Katvy

ypacfi^f etTTOv eaTtv ent dfxapTCoXov yeveceasg etpi^fxevov to, " eirX'^-

*'
aOy] yjfovoq Toy TeKeiv^ otfi.at Be OTt ovk dv Tt$ eypot, ei fxy}

fjLOvov OTTov avofi.a<7Tat OTt "biKaiog eaTiv 6 yevvctift.evog. 15


AtaTt fj.eTa t^v •TreptTOfi.^v, to ovofna eKaaTov Ttattog TtBeaBat

vofiog TtpoaeTaTTev ; eTteiV/j tovto KaXov yjv TtpcoTOv Trjv Ik Seov


TtpocjTayPelcrav kaj3eiv <T(f)payida, TOVTeaTt t^v TteptTOfJ^qv, Kat eig

Xaov Seov yjpyifiMTta-at, Kat Tore to avdpooittvov '^e^aadat ovofka.

Ovy^ ditXag Se yj ^EtXiad^eTf 'la)avv>?v eiVe KXyjByjvat tov "Ttpo- 20


opofit.ov, aXX wg itpocpi^Ttg ovaa vito T\vevfj.aTog 'Ayiov Ktvovfj.evr].

ovOe yap eyivccaKev to. ypyjfj.aTtaSevTa tw Zayapia' Ttwg yap av


avTYi aityjyyetXev fj.y}
XaXav ;

03 ** Anyjaag ^e TtivaKt^tov^ 6 Zayapiag eypaxpe to ovofia,

eTtetoy] ota vevfj.aTog ovk yjtvvaTO tovto ^t^Xaaat. Ttcog ydp ; 25


**
E^ayjaaaav TtdvTeg," eTtettyjitep ofiLocpoovvjaav ot€ Zayapiag
Kai yj KXtadjSeT Ttept tov ovoft.aTog IwavvTjv eiitovTeg, Katitep

levov bv, etg Trjv avyyevetav ayTwv. 'EpfLfjveveTat ^e \cadvvyjg

0eoy ydptg, ^to Kat fj.eTa. to ypdxpat avTOv to ovofna, evQecag Tyj

Tov @eov yaptTi, avecayOfi avrov to aTOfua, Kat eXaXet evXoyav 30

Tov 0eov, Kat Ttpo(j>yiTevcav Ta avayeypafj.fj.eva, TtpaTOv fxev Ta


' itapa Tov ^ptaTov, cog yj^yj €'7ti'^v]f/.yjaavTog tcS ^ica, vaTepov ^e
Kat Ttept Tov lctidvvov.

05 l^taTt oe eyevero eTtt Ttavrag <popog; tva coaTtep eitt tv] atcoity]

Zayaptov e^earv] 6 Xaog, ovtco Kat ev rw XaX^aat avrov, oitcag 35


1.74- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 17

dia rm tva tovtwv QavfXMTm Xoy i^ovTai TrdvTegy Trepi t&v Tep^Scv-

Tos "Jiai^og' Tavra Se itdvTa TipoKaTeaKevd^ovTo TioppuOev, waTe


a^ioiriaTov eivat tov tw ^piaTa ^apTVpyjaai fxeWovTa.
KvXoyav Tov Seov 6 Tta^^^apiag eTtioKOTtrjv Xeyei yeyovevai irap

avTov irpoq tov Xaov avTOv, Xeycov ovTcog, " evXoyfiTog Kvpiog 6 5
xyeog tov laparjA oti Kai Ta eg-^g. oiTiveg eiaiv 01 tco XpiaTia

TTiaTevaavTeg' ovtoi yap Trjg eTiiaKOTtyig aJ^ioi yeyovaaiv, evepyov

eig eavTovg t^v Qeiav emaKOTi^v dno^ei^avTeg.


09 Hiog Qe vjyeipe Kepag aaifjpiag -^[xiv Kai Ta eg^^g ; to Kepag

y] dvTi l3aaiXeiag, 17 dvTi ^vvdixea^g TiapeiXyjTiTai t^ 6eia ypatpyj. i o


d[x,<poTepa Se 6 ^ptaTog eaTiv 6 Ik Tifjg iiaTpidg tov Aa(3i^ dva-

TeiXag' avTog ydp eaTiv ^aaiXevg twv /BaatXevovTaVf Kai 7]

dKaTafAdyvjTog ^vva[j.ti tov YlaTpog, vj ndvTag Tovg eyQpovg rjfjJhv

TpOTiioaafxevt}, Kora t>jv tc!jv dyi(av avTov 7ipo(f)Y)TU)v npoaayopevatV


Tidai yap Totg Jipo(pr}Taig to Tiepi tov \piaTov KaTriyyeXTai 15
fJivaTvjpiov, Kai pvaafxevrj rjfxdg eK tcov eyQpm rjijiav, Kat eK

%etpos TidvTeav tcov fj.iaovvTm ^fndg' eyBpm te ovk ataQrjim,


aXXa vorfTm.

72 To " notrjaai te eXeog jW,€Ta twv naTepm y]fj.m" ovTag 5^^


voeiv, OTi TO eig ^fxdg yevofj.evov eXeog, Kai npog Tovg naTepag 20

^fjMV avaTpeyei, Tovg vepi tov APpadf/.. eTiataQofKevot ydp Tvjg

etg yjfxdg evepyeaiag, KOtvmot yivovTat T-i^g ev(f)poavvr]g.

Ylept lavTrjg ^e Xeyei fj.vria6rjvai ^taB-^Krjg dyiag avTOv, iiept

rjg Tipog tov ^A^padfJ. tteBeTO Xeym, " Kai evevXoyrjQrjaovTai ev

Tco aTiepfj.aTt aov ndvTa Ta eQvrj Kat iidaai at <f)vXai Trjg yrjg." 25
« "r\
*
^vixv
yjpKov Qe ov a)fj.oae
^'a/5^
npog AppaafJ. tov naTepa
^ ' «~j>~'
tovtov
yjfJMV,

<f)y}atv, OTt etTiev avT^ 6 Seog' " evXoym evXoy^av ae, Kat tiXij-
'*
6vvm 7iXy}6vv(o <re." e7iXY/6vv6y} yap to avepf/.a ^A^paafj., eig

aiiepf/.a Kat Tm e6vm Xoyta6evTm avToi.

Kat €7re/^»; TioXXdKtg pvovTai riveg eK %€/^of e/6pm, f/.eTa^o

'j/\.<j>o^ov ^e, tid TOVTO <f>y]ai,


" tov ^ovvat y]f/.Tv d(f>ol3ci>g eK yetpog^

Kat Ta e^yfg. Kat ydp v] HptaTov hitty}fj.ia, 7ieTioiy)Kev y]fj.dg

a(f>oP'j}g eK yetpog eydpm pva6^vat, ov yap y}a6av6Yifj.ev ryjg

ent^ovXYig twv ey6pm, dXX^ at(f>vt^tov y}p7iaaev Yjfidg fxeTaaT-^aag

dv eKeivm (ti) tov KXyjpov kou t^v fj.epi^a avrov. '^to kou yjfxeigSS
D
18 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA 1. 76.

0(f>ii\ofi€v ^arpeveiv avrw ev oo-iotvjti kui ^iKaiocrvvrjf onep ov

yiverat ^ta rtva Katpov, a\ka ita^jai raf y]fj.€pai T^f ^«^f
VJfAltiV.

76 Ti ^^TTOTe Se »? irpog aKQvovToi (f^vjat'


" Kai cv '^at^iov •npo-
" (f>r]Ty]s TxpKTTOv kXyjOvjO''/] ;" Kat yap TrepiTTOv vjv ravra Xeyctv 5
T« fJLVj voovvTt TiatVioci. yjnr] ovv VTToKa^eTvf ort [xrjTroTe apa oirep

Trapa^o^ov yevvrjatv eayev lctidvvvj^, are ApyayyeKov ravrrjv

Kvjpv^avTO^, are avrov aKipTyjtjavTog ev tv] Kot\ta rvjg fj.YiTpog

VTrep (f>vatv eirt rr] Tiapovata. rvji itavayiag -Trapdevov t^JJ Trpog T>yv

'KKt(Td(3eT, ovro} Kai yevvyjSevrt, irapdto^ov '^ty] Kat rrjv itapa-io


KoXov$Y]<rtv 60"%e ryjg ataOvjaewg.
**
Tdy^iov ^e avT'2 itapovTt Ttpoe<pY]rev(Tev TtaTYjp Aeywv, 'Ttpo-

" 7topev(Ty] yap itpo 7tpo(7007tov K.vpiov erotfxdaat o^ovg avrov'^^

e7tet^y]Ttep y]tet wg Ttpo^-rjryjg, ort fxer oXiyov ov fieWet eyetv


avrov Ttap eavrw rpe(f)Ofxevov' (f)V](jt yap F,vayye\tcrTV]g, ort 15

**
i]v ro itatttov ev ra7g ep'f]fJ.otg, e(ag r]ff.epag dva^et^ecog avrov

" Ttpog Tov l^jpa-^K."

" Tvwcrtv ^e (rcoTVjpiag^^ <py]crt ^ovvat ro7g dvOpooTtots rvjv rov

\pt(Trov' y]Ttg yvactg (TC0TV]pta ecrrai avroTg rolg OeXvjcraatv eitt-

yvavat rr]v acori^ptaVf lov^aiotg re Kat ' KXkY^at. 20


Aeyet Se Kai 'Jtoog earat yj rov ©eov yvcoatg acorvjpia, ort (f)V]atv

" ev d(f)eaet dfj.aprt(ov" earat, ovrcog eXe-^aavrog rov Seov rovg e^ni

yY]g, Kai yap cog dkY]6ag '^ta aitXdyyya ekeovg %eov '^f/.cov y]Xe'^-

6v]fi.ev' oy^e ydp ^td t» epya d eitof^aafj.ev YjfJ.e7g.

70 Ev olg rov itarpog aitXdyyyoig e^TteaKexparo Y]fJ.dg e^ vi^ovg 25

Kat e| ovpavov dvaretXag Yjfj.h Y]Xiog '^iKaioavvY]g, fxovoyevyjg

Tiog rov Qeov Kat Qeog Y]fi.m.

Ka; " aKorog fxev Xeyet rv]v dyvcoatav. " aKtdv ^e Savdrov' rv]v

dft.apTiav, ^ta ro fLv] eivat aiaOvjrov Gdvarov, dXX^ aicovtov, eiKOva

oe ej^e^v Bavdrov. coaitep ydp aiaGvjTog Bdvarog ycoptafj.ov e/et ^o


i/^yj^iyj", ovrcog vj dfJ.apTia yjxiptafj.ov YlvevfxaTog 'Aytov.

To §e " eig o^ov elp-^vvjg" "^v^XoT, tva, (f)Y]a}, rd rov (3tov vjfj.wv

^ta^'f]fj.ara KarevGvvY], Kat o^Yjy^aY] etg ry]v ^t^aaKaXiav t*;v eav-


rov ILptarog Kat ro KY]pvyfj.a' rovro ydp eartv o^og etpY]VY]g.

KTteioY] oe Kard tyjv dvaXoyiav rv]g yjXtKiag •7tvevfi.artKY]g 35


II. I. AOYKAN ETArrEAIOT. 19

vj^iovro yapiTOi o Trpo^pof/.o^f ^ia, tovto (pvjaiv o KvayyeXiaTtji


" TO ^e TtaiYiov vjv^ave Kai eKparatovTO TrvevfxaTi"

Lita TovTO Qe '


cv Tats €p7]fJioi$ yjv ecog avaoeiqeas Kat ra
e|%. tva Tov vTrepKoafxtov fxvjvvcov ^piaTOVf e^ci) TVjg ev avQpa)~

TTO/i" KaKiai yiy Kai ottco^ ai^tOTTKJTog fxapTvg (pavyj, [xapTvpaiv too 5

"KpiaTWj Kat Trjv KaKiav eXeyyjov jaera Trappriatag.

KE^. A.
Ilcpt rfjs d7roypa(f)TJs.

1 Ka; eTret^Yjftep KaSoXtKyj '/aptg eKXa[j.7reiv efxeWev eU Ttaaav


TVjv yyjv, yiveTat ev irpoaTayfj.a Ka& oXvjg Tvfg oiKOVft.evy]s,Hoi}T^pog 10
evof Ka6 oXyj r^ oiKOVft.evyi yevvcofJLevov' <f>i^(Tt yap 6 Kvayye-
KtaTyjg, " eyeveTo Se ev Ta7g yjfxepaig eKetvaig, e^yjXBe toyfxct^ Kat

Ta e^yjg. Ka) ^ia tovto ^e ytverat tovto, eTrei^yj yj a7roypa(f>Yi

avTYi y£yiatft.ct>g tvjv "navayiav TrapOevov e^eTrefLirev etg ByjOXeeft.

reKeiv, tva Trkyjpcody] yj Xeyovaa Tipo(f>y)Teta " Kat av BijfiAee/x, 15


**
oiKog rov K(f>pa6a, fny} oXiyoarog ei * rov eivat ev y^tXtaatv
**
lof^a, el 01» yap fxot e^eXevaerai roy eivat eig apxovra ev

**
rco lapayjX.^^

^varyjpiov rt fx^ya ^ovXerai 6 Xoyog Trapaar^aat, ort etg

rvfv rvji oiKovfxevvjg oXvjg avaypa(j)VjV e&e/ avaypa(f>y}vat \ptarov 20


li^aovv, tva avvavaypa(f>eig roTg ev tv] oiKovfxevv], aytaay] rv]V

otKovfxev^v, Kat fxera6r] rviv a7roypa(f>v]v ravrvjv eig Pi(3Xov ^covrcov,

tva ra ovofxara rcov avyypacpevrcov avrco Kat Trtarevovrcov avrco,

eyypaipy] ev To7g ovpavoig.

I21ACPOT IlHAOTSiaTOT. A7r€ypa(f>v) 6 K.vptog Kat Kvjvaov 25

ereAecre Kaiaapi, toj Kpdrei vofxo6ercav vTrordaaea6ai, orav fxvj^ev

iiapa^XdTtry] itpog rvjv evae^etav.

Atart einev RvayyeXtari^g **


tov vtov avrvjg rov TrpcororoKov'^^

ovoe yap aXXov eay^ev viov vj •navayia 6eoroKog Kai detTrap6evog ;

eveiOvi Qeog vndpyet dXy]6tvog e^ ainvjg aapKco6eig Kvptog vjfJiMV^o

Ivjaovg ^ptarog. yeyovev y]fi.cov '^ta rvjv adpKcoaiv d^(X(f>og, rovrov

yaptv c>>vofxda6r] TtpcaroroKog, cog irpcorevcov ev Ttdatv avrog.

Ev ryj (f>drvvi Se KaraKXtverai, Koi %ta ro fxvj vndpyetv fxev

a li Cod.
20 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA II. lo.

avTOis TOTTog ev tco KaTakv[i.aTi, KaOwg yeypamai, €ti ^e iva

v}fj.ag Tvjg aXoyiag eXevOepcoa'!^, tov KTYjvoTrpe'^^ fxeTa[xei\pavTas

PioVf Kai Tfjv avBpaiToii Trpeirovcxav avaKT^a-afxevovs avveaiv.

KE<>. B.
Ilfpi tS)V aypavkovvrav iroifievcov. t

E7r€/^^ ^e Kai itpoTepov ev tyi TraXaioi irvevfxaTiKoTg TTOifxecri

TQig 7rpo(f)-^Taig Ta irapa Qeov ^ieiropOfji.eveTo py}fJ.aTaf ^ia tovtq

Kai vvv ^ia Twv ai(76v)Tav TroifJ.evav to avTO yiveTai. Kai yap o

acrcofJiaTOt; aapKa TrpocXalSofi.evog, ^t avTvjg upa6ri tco yevet twv

avdpooTrav. eTi Se Kat ^ia to airXaaTovg avTOvg elvat' e^YjXovv i o


yap TVjv iraXaiav iroXiTeiav, Trotfj.aivovTeg wairep ot iraTptapyat

Kat avTOg MwyV^f.


lo T(9 ^e **
^Ttg ecTTat TravT/ tco Aao?" tco t»v avOpairm '^vjXoif

ov fj.ovov Toj Twv loi/^a/cwv.

14 Oirep ^e to TrXrjQog Ti^g ovpaviov aTpaTiag atvovvTeg eXeyov, 15


* ooi;a ev vxptaTotg Weou Kai eirt yrjg etprjvvj, Kai Ta eqvjg, tovto

afjfj.atvei, OTt "to^a Tca ev v^iptaTotg ovTt Qeca Kat eirt yyjg etpvjVYf

yevofJ.evcc. Kai yap ayeXvjv a7re(f)V]ve fJ.taVf Tovg Te ev ovpavZ, Kat

Tovg eirt yYjg, yevofJ.evog ^fxTv elpyjvv} Kat ev^oKta. 01 fj.ev yap
AyyeXot Kat Traa-a vj ev ovpavo7g '^vvaft.tg, TrXvjv twv aTrtaTOvvTav, 20

ev elpvjvvi fj,efj.evvjKaat irpog tov Seov, Ta avTOv TrXvjpovvTeg OeXv}-

fj.aTa, vjfnag ^e vj afuapTta ^'^(GpoTroivjae irpog tov Qeov. eiretoi^

ovv eXvae tv^v e^/Bpav Kvptog vjfj,m Kai Qeog Ivjaovg X.ptaTOg,

aiiOKaTaXXa^ag vjfj.ag Trpog tov iraTepa, Kora tov XeyovTa kiro-


aToXoV avTog ydp eaTtv vj etpvjvvi vjfxm' etKOTCog oogoXoyovatv 25

01 AyyeXot avTOv, tqv eirt TVfg y^? etp-^vvf yevQfj.evov "KptaTOV tqv

Qeov vifj.m.

'HpirENors. T/ So^TroTe AyyeXog ovk aTri^XOev eig lepoao-

Xvfxa ; ovK e^vjTviae t&v? ypafkfj.aTe'ig Kat Tovg ^aptaaiovg ; ovk

eiavjXGev elg TVfv twv lou^a/wv avvayccy^v, dXXa •notfj.evag ebpev^o


dypavXovvTag Kat (f>vXdaaovTag Tag (fjvXaKag TVjg vvKTOg e^rt tvjv

•jroifj.vviv avTwv, KdKeivovg evi^yyeXiaaTO ; OTt eKeivot fj.ev vjaav

^te(f)6apft.evot, Ka) to5 (f>6ovu> v]fj.eXXov ^ta7rpiea6at' oiiTot ^e airXa-


II. ai. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 21

ffTOt ^(TaVf rrjv TraXaiav TroXiniav ^yyAovvTef twv TrarpiapywVf Kai

avTOv Mojyacw?* voifjifvei yap Yjo-av Kai oxiroi.

0€<a ^o^Tj Kai ovpavia irepiaaTpacf^QevTei ot ?ro/jU,€V6? Kai ayye-

A//f^f aTparta^ SeaaoifJievoi, Kai vfxvokoyovayjg aKovaavTeq, eirt-

t,fiTovat SepfxSig t>jv By^flAeCjU,, ^Tig olKog apTOV fxedepixvjveverai. 5


*'
diek6a}fxev ^rj eaog eig Bv]6ke€fJ." AeyovTef, tov^ t^? eKKXyiatag

irpoTVTTovvTeg irotfj.evag tc Kat tepeT^:, olg epyov eart tov ovpaviov

apTOV eirt^-YjTeTv, tov afj.vov tov 0eoi), tov aipovra ttjv afJMpTiav tov

KoafMov, Kat fi.vaTtKa)f Ka6 eKoiaTyjv iepovpyovfj.evoVf KaTcc to fxeya

ekeog avrov. 10

19 'H 5e M.apLaiJL Traura cruveT-qpeL tol prj/xaTa TavTa.

TloTa ^e " avveTYjpet TravTa^ tj iravayta QeoTOKog ; oaa Te


etpyjKet avTrj AyyeXog, oaa re 01 •jrotp.eveg eiirov, avfxjStPd^ovaa
ev TYf eavTrjg Kaphia, TovTeaTt tovt:o eKCivo avjKptvovaa Ta pri-

fj-aTa, evog Trpdyfj.aTog avfj,(f>aviav, ag OTt irep Seog VTrdpyei KaTa 15


aXrjQetav e^ avTrjg yevvrjOetg ev aapKt.

Ktpiaaot Aaesanapeias. OTav t^rjg $pe(f)og eaTrapyava-

fj.evov, fxrj fJ-eyjptg fii.oyrjg T^g Kara adpKa yevvrjaeoig avTov Trjv

eavTov ^idvoiav aT-^arjg' dvairri^riaov ^e elg Secopiav Trjg Beoirpe-

irovg ^o^rjg avTov. dvd(5ri6i tov ovpavov, ovTOog avTOV ev TOtg dvoo- 20

TaTW Bewp-^aetg vxpa}ft,aat Trjv vTrepTdTrjv eyovra to^av, oipet KaB-ff-

fxevov eirt Bpovov vxprjXov Kat eirripft.evov' aKovaetg twv Y^epacpeifj.

vfLvoXoyovvTWV avTOv' 'TrXrjprj XeyovTiiv tov ovpavov Kat Trjv yrp

T^f "^o^rig avTov' yeyove %\ tovto Kat hrt Tr^g yrjg' ^o^a yap
Qeov Trepf^aTpaxpe Tovg Trotfj.evag, Kai TrX-S^Bog rjv aTpaTtag ovpa- 25
vtov ^o^okoyovvrav "KptaTOv — Kat fxeT oXiya. ovkovv fj.r} ug /Spe-

<f>og t^rjg dirXwg tov ev (fydrvrj Ketfkevov, dXX ev TrTar/eta Tr\ KaB
rjixdg Tov irXovatov wf Oeov, Kat ^ta tovto ho^oXoyovfi,evov Kat irap

avTwv Twv dyiav AyyeXcov.

KE4>. r. 30

Ilept 2vn(a)u,

21 YlepieTft.-^6r] §e Kvptog rjfj.m ^lriaovg HptaTog, eTrei^rj

yeyovev vrro vofxov, Ka6<ag (ftrjatv 6 ^AiroaToXog, " yewojfxevov (k


22 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA II. 22.

**
yvvaiKOff yevofjievov vvo vojxovj^ yeyove ^e tovto ^vo icpayiKa.-
Twv eve«€)/, Tco re e^ayopaaai ^ia T^g '^Xi^pao-eag tov vofJLov Tovg

VTrevSvvovg TVjg Trapa^aaecog tov vofKov, kou tS> "hia TYig irpog

TiaVTa VTraKoyjgf tvjv tov A^afx. e^iacraaOai TrapaKOViv, wg Xeyei 6

AiroaToXog. oti " waicep yap ^ia T^f TrapaKOYjg tov evog dv6p(anov 5
*'
dfxapTcoXoi KaTeaTaSyjaav 01 icoXXot, ovtq} Kai ^ia Tvjg vTcaKorjg
" Tou evof, '^iKaioi KaTaaTaS-^aovTai 01 ttoAAo/," TOVTeaTiv 01

vioTevaavTeg tco KpiaTw Kai ©ecw. Tiys' ovv BeoirvevaTov ypa(f)^g

Xeyovavjg Kaxa aXrfieiav 7repiTfi,yjSYjvat tov 'KpiaTOVy Tig eaTiv

6 ToXfJMV Xeyeiv, ag ovy(^ viiefx.eive t\v TcepiTOfJi^v, oirep dpvetaSai 10

l3ovXovTai fi.eTa tcSv aXXm 01 t^v <f)avTaaiav iTpeaj^evovTeg' vjfJieig

§e Toy? Trepi tov TrepiTf/iyjOevTog avTov fLoptov, Xeyx '^r] TVjg d^po-

/SvaTtag, iroXvTrpayfLovovvTag to t/ eyiveTo, wg Ta dvefpiKTa Kat


a^rjXa iroXvTrpayfJ.ovovvTag diroKpovauft.eQa' ov^e yap yeypairTO.t

Tt irept TOVTOv. ei ^e Kat eiirotfj.ev OTt ODairep to ayjpavTov avTov 15

aifJ.01, f/.€Ta Tov v^aTog ev toj Katpoo tov aTavpov vjytaae tv]v yr^v

a-To^av ev avTrj, ovtq) Kai rj 7reptTf/.rj6eiaa dKpo^vaTta Trjg yvjg

^avaaaa, TavTrjv rjytaaeVf ovk dv dft.dpTotfii.ev. TrdvTO^g he Kat oig

oi^e Xoyotg eKovatwg rreptTfJ.rfieig e(f)vXa^e to TreptTfLrjQev' oirwg

Kai KaTa tov Kaipov Trjg dvaaTaaeoog avTov, Kai KaTo, tovto 20

aveXXetnitig ej^wv «yTO avac7T^ TrXrjprjg viro KptaTov, Kat acpSapTog


oXix Tco a(»fj.aTt' Kat yap v^fJ.eHg ev ty] dvaaTaaet to aafj.a to

v)fj.eTepov irXrjpeg airoX^i^xpoft.eSa.

Ev Tco enre7v tov KvayyeXtaTvjv, **


Kai eKX-^Svj to ovofxa avTov
" Iriaovg" oirep eaxt acoTrjpta Xaov, " to KXrjSev viro tov \yye- 25
" Xov irpo Tov avXXv](f)d^vat avTOv ev Tvj KotXtaJ^ Trwg ToXfj.aat

Xeyetv Ttv\g, OTt evSecog avv tc5 eiTreiv tov AyyeXov " X^^^P^
" Ke')(aptTiOfj.evri^^ avveXrj(f)Srj, SavfjA^etv yjprj.

22 " Ka/ ore errXrjaSriaav ai rjfi.epat tov KaSaptafxov ayT^f."


**
KaXag eTrrjyaye KaTo, tov vofLov'" KaTa yap Trjv dXrjSetav ovk 30
etyev dvdyKriv y) iravayta SeoTOKog irepifj.evetv rjfxepag KaSaptafxov,

atTtveg rjaav TeaaapaKOVTa eirt apaevt TeySevTi' etprjTai yap ev

Tco vofxo) " yvvvjf^ <f)r)atv, " ^Ttg eav aTrepfxaTtaS^, Kat TCKet dp-
" crev,
fj.
vjfxepag eaTat dKdSapTog^ vj ^e TravdfJMfxog SeoTOKog

ov aTrepfj.aTtaSeXaa, dXX eK Ylvevfj.aTog 'Ayiov avXXaj3ovaasS


11.34- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 23

€^e(f)vy€ Tov eivai, Kai KaT avTov tov vo/aov, Kai ttjv KeKpvfJiixivfjv

avTov (7Y][xaa-iav, Kai aKaBapTO^.

25 To Se irefi rov Svjuewv elpyifJievov oti ^v " irpoo-^e%o/xevof


**
vapaKXvjaiv tov la^a^A," tovto ecTT/ •jroTe &<a tou X|3<c7tov

vapaKXviaiv evpot laparjX, ^/a T^f e/V avTOv TriaTewi eXevde-^

plav €vpiaK(ov €K t^? twv 'Pioixaiuv ^ioiK^^aeaSf Kai \k t% vtco

aXko(f)vXov ^aatXeias 'Hpa^ov.

ToT ArioT Ktpiaaot Aaebanapeias. Fiia€(f)ep€TO ev tw


/e^w Xp/o"TOf, Pp€(f>oi cov €Ti ^pay^v t€ Kai vTrofJM^iov. ^e

•ye }j.aK(xpioi "Lvfxeav Trpo^pvjTiKy} '/apiTi T€Tifxv][j.€voi, ^ej^eTa/ ju.ev 10


€is ayK/xXas avTOv, Bvfj.vj^ias Se TVjg avwTaTW TrtixTrXdfi.evoi vjvXo-

yvjae Beov Ae-ywv, " vvv airoXvetg tov ^ovXov aov, MairoTa,** Kai

Ta e^^s" irpovjToift.aaTo yap to tov 'KptaTOv fj.vaTV}ptov, Kai trpo

avTvi<; TV](; tov Koafxov KaTajSoX^g.

29 T; toSto Se **
vyv airoXvetg tov "hovXov aov, ^ecTTroTa;" irepi Tvjg 15

ev ca^Ac; ^wiyf efne. * IvaTa de to pv}fJ.a aov ev etp-^vvj, bta

Tov "^QivjafJiov ov eiXvj^pag vjv. ETre^S^ Se ev aKOTCo Kat ayvQiaia

VTr^p^X^e Ta eSvvj ^aift.oai XaTpevovTu, (pag ^e avroig 6 \ptaTOi

yeyovev, aTroKaXvxpag tov ovTcog aXr/Qvj ©eov eavTov t€ Kat tov

YlaTepa Kai to 'Ayiov Yiv€vfi.a, ^ta tovto (pvjai " (pcos etg aTroKo,- ao
" Xw\/iv e^vsSv."

re^yove Se Kat " ^o^a tov lapavjX^^ HptaTbg, Kai kut avTO

fxev TO e^ avTwv avaTeTXat to KaTa aapKa, e^o^aae 0€ Kat iroX-

Xovg e| avT^v &/a Tv^g €ig avTov TriaTeag.


Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias. Teyove (pZg TOig ev aKOT€i Kat^^

7r€TrXaw]fi€voig, kou vTro '//ipa. ireaovai ^ta^oXiKv^v, KCKXvjTai yap


irapa tov %€ov Kat WaTpoq irpog eirtyvuiatv tov 'Xtov, og eaTi (f>ag

TO aX-^Qtvov, aXXa Ka\ elg ^o^av tov lapavjX' €i yap Kai yeyo-
vaai Ttveg vfSptaTat e| avTwv Kai aTretdcTg Kat aavveaiag e/u,7rAew

T^v ^iavotav e)(ovT€g, aAA' ovv aeaaaTai to KaTdX€tfj.fj.a, Kai SeSo- 30


^ajTTai "tia XpiaTov.

34 To ^e **
€ig TrTaatv Kat dvdaTaatv etvai tov Kv^/ov TroAAcSv ev
" ToS Icrpa>;A" ^yovfxai, ovk dXXoov irtTrTOVTOsv, Kat aXXwv dvt-

aTafxevav, ov^e yap ToTg /xev tov TrtTrretv d(f>opfi.dg irapeyet, To7g

Se Tou dviaTaaOat' ot ydp iriirTovreg diro t^? aTdaeag cv


fj
iroT€ 35
24 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA II. SS-

ijaav KaTairiTTTovai trjkovoTi' ovheTtoTe Vk eldTVjKH 6 aTiiaTog,

aei %o.\i.ai (rvpQf/Levog, aW ovTcog '^^vj voeiv, oti o ev t^ a^apTia.


i<7TafX€V0i '^ia TYig fj.eTavoiag '^nrTei Kai aTtoBvfjaKei e| avTyjg' Kai

XoiTTOV ^ Ty] ^iKaiocrvvYj Kai aviaTaTai Tri eig 'KpiaTOV "TriaTet'

TrnrTeTO} yap ra yeipova, iva avaaTri xa (SeXTiova' eav yap fxr} 5


Trearj v] Tropeza, 07 acc^ppoavvv] ovk aviaTaTai' eav fji.r] yj akoyia
avvTpi^% TO XoyiKOv to ev yjfuv ovk avS-^aei' ovTwg ovv eaTi to
" eig TTTioatv Kai avdaTaatv ttoAAwv."
" Etig ^e avjfj.ehv dvTtXeyofnevov." Kvptoog ay]fxe7ov eyvcofj.ev

irapa t^ Beta ypatp^ tqv ^aoTrotov aTavpov. e6v]Ke y^p^ <pWh 10

Mcova^f Tov o(f)tv eiTt av]f/.etoVf TOVTeaTtv eitt aTavpov. enet ovv

ov TravovTai \^vyofLayovvTeg Tiept TVjg evavdpctiTrv^aecog tov Kvptov'

01 fnev dvetkyj(pevat avTOV aafna, 01 ^e (pavTaaia Ttvt t\v S/a Toy

acofxaTog otKovofxiav TrXvjpovv, Kat dXXot yotKOVf dXXot ^e eirov-

pdvtov aafji.a, Kat ot fxev Trpoatccvtov ty]v vTtap^tv, ot Se aTro TY]g 15

TtapOevov Kat dypdvTOv Maptag tv]v dpyvjv eayv^Kevat, tta tovxo

etg av]fieiov avTtXeyofj.evov. " Pof>.(patav" ^e Ae^ye; tov Ao^yov tov

TtetpaaTtKOv twv evavfiiy^aectiv.

Aaacs. " Vofi.(patav" Se (pY]at ty]v eitt tSi aTavpcp BXtxptv Tvjg

itavaytag BeOTOKov, oioff.evYiV fj,Y] ^eiv avTOV TotavTa TtdayetV tq 20

yap avdtg avaaTV]aea6at avTOv, cog vitepoyKov Tecog v]TttaTeTTo.

Aaaos. Ylpoipi^Tevet 6 'Zvft.eav Kat ttept avtv^g Tvjg dytag


itapBevov 'M.aptag, oti itapeaTcaaa toj aTavpcf, Kai (SXeitovaa Ta
ytvofi.eva, Kat dKovovaa tcSv (pcovoov tcHv (povevTiiv, fJ.eTa ty]v tov

Ta(3piv]X fKapTvpiav, fxeTa t'*?^ ditoppY^TOV yvaatv T^g Qeiag avX-2^


Xv]\pea}g, fi.eTa ty]v fj.eydXY]v tcov Bavfj.dTcov eTti^et^iv, yevv]aeTat Ttg

Ttept TV]v aY]v y^^vyY^v adXog.

SS To ^e **
OTtcog av dnoKaXv^pQcoatv eK TtoXXm Kap^tcov ^taXo-
" yiafiLQt,^* aivtTTeTat oti fj.eTa tov aKav^aXtafj.ov tqv eiti tc5

aTavpoo Tov KpiaT.ov yevofj.evov TOig fj.a6viTa7g, Kat avTV] tv] itava- 30
yt(X 7tap6evca Tayeia Ttg taatg htaKoXovSel itapa tov Kvpiov.
^e^atovaa avTcov tv]v Kapttav etg ty]v eii avTOV TtiaTiv. ovTCog

yap et^ofxev Kat YleTpov t^? eig "KptaTOv ittaTecag dvTtayofxevov,

To avQpcoTttvov ovv aadpov ^iyjXeyySv], tva to layypov tov Kvptov

^^^X^' - 35
11.39- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 25

Aaaqs. To ^€ " OTTUs a7[0Ka\vcf>6a(riv ck tioXXwv Kap^im


" oiaXoyiafj.oi'^ tovto e<7Tiv, iva Travrwv ol ttaXoyi(rfj.oi t^Xoi koi
catpiis Toig avOpayiroii yivavTai' Tig /xev o ayaTtav axnov, Ka\

^ej^ij; QavaTov t^v e/V avrov ayaTtr^v ev^eiKVvfJievog' t/V ^e o liti-

TtXaaTOV e^^wv tijv tig avTOv TriaTiv, aKav^aXov nXrip^aBeig ^ia tovS
CTavpoV Tig Te o irpo^i^ovg Kai e7rifi.evci}v tco tc cravpcp Kai tw
OavaTw avTov.
i

KE^. A.
Htpi "Avvtjs t^s 7rpo(j>riTi8os,

36 'H le Trpo<f>vjTig Awa 4j TocravTfjg a^ia}6e7a-a fxapTvpiag vtto

Tov KvayyeXtaToVj avSojfxoXoyeiTO too Sew, Toxrreariv fivyaptaTet 10

Tiyv acoTyjpiav opwaa, tov tc Koaf/.ov, toD t€ lapo^X eirtaTaaav.


tjXaXet Oe iiept avTOv, OTt avTOg etvj XvTpcoTijf, avTog eiyj

6 YiWTfjp, ovTOf rjfkiv elg yapav •jrepiTpexpei tv}V KaT-^<f)etav.

39 " 'TireaTpeipav Se eig tvjv TaXtXaiav, etg t^v TtoXtv eavTwv


'*
Na^apeT," eiietVfi ei Kat rj ^yjdXeefJi. r)v avTwv itoXtg, aXXa Kat 15

t»;v Na^apeT iroXtv eavTiiv eireypacpovTOf ws eKei t^v o'tKr)atv av-

TWV "TIVJ^dfLeVOt.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaesanapeias. ASpet &17 fJi.ot t^j- oiKovofxia$ to

jSdSoi, dvSpomtvov vnof/.evet tokoV Kat TOt to avapyov ev yj>ov(p

BeiKag eyjav Aoyoi' ev av^-^aet acofjiaTog, 6 navTeXetog ag Qeog, 20

ev d^poTYjTt fLeXav dawfj.aTog' irXvipovTai ao(f>tag avTog oov vj

vaaa aQ(f>ia. Kcti vpog tovtq <pafj.ev, opa tta toutwv tov ev fJi.op(f>yj

Tov UaTpog, ev Ofx.ot(£iaet t^ Trpog y}fj.a<,, tov TrXovatov, ev itTayeia,

ev Tairetvccaet tov vxpyjXov, tov to irX^peg eyovTa QeiKchg ev tw


XeyeaOat XafSeiv, qvtq) KeKevxKev eavTOv Qeog u>v 6 Aoyog' Ta 25

yap dvBpcoTrtvwg irepi avrov yeypafj.fx.eva tov Trjg Kevaaecag "hto^et-

Kvvai Tpoirov. ov ydp eaTt t«v ev^^eyofj.evccv etg ttiav (pvaiv viro-

aTVjvat Tt TOtovTov eK tov Seov Tlarpog (pvvTa Aoyov. Teyove


Se aap^, yjyovv dvBpccTrog Ka6 yjfi.ag' TiKTerat eK yvvatKog KaTa
(xdpKa Ta av6p'j}irtva v7rofi.efi.evyjKci)g. yjv fxev ydp iKavog Seog cov 30
6 Aoyog, eig fj.eTpov dvtpog TeXeiov Koit €K fJt-yjTpog avTrjg t>jv

tttav dvaj3tl3daag adpKa. aXX ovk vjv fj.aKpov TepaTOTroi-^aag to

E
26 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA II. 44.

^pafj.(.vov. Errei §e ovk aaapKog akXa a-€(yapKa}[J.evog tlcxayaym


Tov ©eov Aoyog, FiVayyeXiaTyj^ e^oy, " rjv^ave Kai cKpaTaiovTo"
Kai Ta e^rj^. ^ia tovto Trepi tov KaTO, adpKa yjiri voeh TavTa'
<T(ap.aT iK(jOi yap vjv^ave Kat eKpaTaiovTO, twv [xeXav avva^pvvo-
fxevav T^ av^i^crei. EirXyjpovTo §e ao^iag kou yapnogt ovk ev^
To5 '7rpoXafxl3aveiv' aei yap tq irX^pef eiyev a>g ©eof, aXXa tov

@€ov Aoyov T^ Tov (jaiJ.aTog yjXiKia o^vveKTeivovTo KaTa ^po.yv


T^f co(f)iag Kai TVjg yapiToq ty(v eKcpavaiv. 'ETrfjSCOTa ^e Tovg

^i^a(7KdXovg Kvpios Ta tov vofxov iidvTcos, Kou to, vofxiKa ira-

payyeXfxaTa. Kai yj^e/ /xev yj itavayia QeoTOKos fxy] TeKVov avTOV 10

eivai Tov Itacrt^^jy, aXXa ^ia tvjv v'ffo4'i<x,v toov ^lov^awv vofxi^ovTav
eK TTopveiag avTOv yeyev^a$at, (^rjai Trpog avTOV, oti " i^ov TiaT^p
" aov Kayo) o^vv(Ofxevot e^yjTovfxev ae."

ToT ATiOT Ktpiaaot j^^aebanapeias. E<Vct)v 6 EvayyeXt-


aTVjf, OTt " irpoeKOTtTe ao^pta, Kai ydptTi trapd t€ Oew Kai dvQpd)- 15
" TTOtg," ^etKvvai Tov eavTov Xoyov dXyjO^. 'ATC0(f>epei yap axnov
ei<; 'YepovaaXfjfXy afxa t^ dyt(x. irapGevw, eopTi^g etg tovto KaXov-

cnjf, e/Va (pvjatv, dirofxehat fxev avTOV, eyKaTaXeicpS^vat ^e fxeTa

TavTa ev tc5 lep^ fxeTa^v twv '^ttaaKdXaov KaBrjixevov, epooTcovTa

^e Kat diioKptvofxevov, 'tvjXov te OTt Ta itdXat tw vofxto ^iyjyopev- 20


jaeva* eiTa Qavfxa^^ofxevog vito TrdvToov eTri Ta7$ epuTrjaeai Kat Talg

aTtoXoytatg. 'OpSii ev ao(pi(X Kai ydptTi TrpoKOitTOVTa, S/a toi/

ytvxaKeaOai TtoXXoTg, OTt TOtovTog eaTi.


OpirENOTS. O fnaKdptoi; AovKai oaa (pSog yjfi.iv TrapaaT-^aaf

OTt TiapQevov vlog 6 ScoT^p yjv, ovk e^ dvtpog. Ylpog ti ovv iraTepa 25

eiTre tov fxyj aTreipavTa fxyj^e atTtov avTf yevofxevov TVjg yeveaecog ;

'AirXovaTepov fxev XeyoiTo dv, oti ei €Tift.yjaev avTOv to rivevjOta to


Aytov T^ Tov TraTpog Trpoayfyoptri, hrett-fprep dveSpetpaTo avTOv*

€1 Se ^ei Tt eiirerv Kat [3aQvTepov, epovfxev, etret yj yeveaXoyia


eyeveaXoyriae tov l(oay](f) diro Aa^i'^' edo^e ^e TreptTTy} eivat 1J30
yeveaXoyia epyofxevyf eirt tov l^oarjcf) fxy} yevvyjaavTa tov llcoT^pa.

iva yj yeveaXoyta Xoyov eyyj e^rtT-^^etov, iraTyjp dvyjyopevGyj ^lway)(f)

Kvptov yjfjMV \yjaov 'KpiaTov.

44 'Apa ^e oTt dyroXdoXev (og iraTg, KOxe^^yjTOVv, vj oti veTrXdvi^Tat ;


5

III. I. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 87

aitaye. ovre yap T^f 7rav(TO(pov deoTOKOV Mapta^ ^v tovto, TYjg

fj.vpiag '^i^afj.iv^g irepi avTov Beiag anoKaX.vxl^eii, ov^e tou 'Iw«7^^*


akk coavep eav Tif ^i^TJj ypa(prjVf Q^vvwf/.eva}i avTVjv ^yjTct, oyp^

coavep nKavqfj.evqv ovVe cuf ecrcpaXfxevi^v, aX^ wg eyovcrav fxev

Tov a\y]9ij Kat fxvaTiKOv Xoyov, fi,Y}ir<ag ^e TrecfiavepccfKevvjv, ovtcc 5


KaKehoi e^yjTOvv tov Kvptov yjfxwv ^ly^aovv 'K.ptaTOV, fx^oog ane-
aTV) ait avTa>v, fi.'^<ag KaTaXeXomev avTovg' te Kvptog yjfxwv

Kat Qeog a(petg avQpwTrtvy]v ^ovvai aTtoKptcriv, Qeiag onrTeTat aito-

Kptcrewg, vapefAcpatvcov OTt Qeog eiy\ aea-apKcoft.evog. 'Eire/^r? yap


y] irapSevog Kai SeoTOKog tov eTrtKXyjOema avTOv iraTepa ^IoKjyjcp 10
eXeyev avTov iraTepa, avTog <f>y]crtv, OTt efj.og iraTyjp, av'/^ 'lcc(yy](f>,

aXX Seog, OTt tov vaov ^ecTroTi^g' elg tov vaov yap tov Seov
cov, e^y]f " ovK rj^etTe, oti ev TOig tov UaTpog fJLOv '^eT eivai fxe ;"

ov (xvvyjKav ^e to py]fJ.a ot irep) ty]v ayiav deoTOKov, eX<x\y](T€v

avTotg Kvptog, eiret^yj ovk ^v (xv6pa>Trivy]g ^tavoiag to ovtoo 1

Ae^TOv cTvvt^eiv fj.v(7Tyjptov.

51 A;a toDto ^e " y]v vmTaaaofj,evog avToTg," •Jrapa^etyfxa ^i^ovg


iraaiv vtoig, tva Ttfj.(!>ai Tovg eavToiv yove7g Kat vTroToiaaeaSai av-
TOtg. ^teTyjpet ^e yj fJ-yjTyjp avTov yj iravayia irapBevog Ka\ SeoTO-
Kog, irota py]fi.aTa ; oaa AyyeXog eiTrev, oaa 01 Trotfxeveg, oaa 20
Si/^fwv Kat y] Avva, Kat oaa vvv avTog irpog avTOvg' ei yap Kat
ft.y] TeXetcag eyvcaaav Ta etpy]fj.eva irap avTOv, irXyiv avvrjKev yj

travayta BeoTOKog, oti Qeta vir^py^pv Kat virep avjav. ovte yap ag

TratQtov yjKovae ^a^eKaeTovg, aW eT-^pei to. py]fJ.aTa wg TeXeiov.


UaKiv Trpog Ty]v av^y]atv tov a<afj.aTog TrpoKoiry^v Keyei ^vayye- 25
KiaTYjg, TovTeaTt OTt Kat 6 ly]aovg irpoeKoirTev, aairep •noXXoig

ev yvcoaet KaTa 'upoaByjKy^v yevofj.evog TYjg irept avTOv QeoTrpeTrovg

woXy]xpecog, yjv avv ev^oKta tov YlaTpog eve^etKvvTo, avfj.-npoaovTcov

T«y yjfovca» Tyjg vjkiKtag, tyjv eXkafxxpiv Ty]g 6eoTy]Tog.

KE*. E.

Hepi Tou yevoiifpov pi)fiaTOS npos 'iwai/vr/v.

I MefLVYjTat ^e ttKatcag tov '/jpovov Kot tcSv ap^^ovTcav Xey<av

^vayye\taTy]g '*
tv eT€* •nevTeKa^eKa.Tca Tijg yjyefxoviag Tt^epiov
E 2
28 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA III. 2.

" Kaia-apoif" kui to, e^^f, iva yvcofxev ort ev TO?f t^? (.vavBpaynvi-

aewg •)(^povQi(; tov Kvpiov iJ/awv Kai Qeov 'Ivjaov yipi(7T0v, €K\€\oi7r(i
KaGoKov apyjnv Kai vjyovfxevog c^ 'louWwv. aXXo(f>vXoi Se "iipy^pv,

'Pafxaiav jaei/, oi Se Xonro) 'H^w^ov v/o/, ' A(TKa\caviTV]g to yevog,


" ijkOe yap ar/v/ to apyiiv aiiOKeiTai^' tovt€(tti XjOiO"To5 tco ©ew 5

oy/Awv. E^eA/TTov ^e o/ 'lov^a/cov apyovTeg KaTa Tovq Xoyovg


laKa}(3 Tov iraTpiapyov.

Q, To Se e/7re?v " eyevero p^i^^a Seov ein ^latxvvqv" leiKVvcriv oti

ovK a(j> eavTov vjXOeVf aXXa Trapa Seov ano^JTaXeig, o&ev Kat

ToaavTa irep) tov 'iwavvrjv e^ O^PXV^ aoKovoix-^Sy] ^ia TavTVjV tv]V io


^iaKoviav. Eitei yap koi tov Ttpo^pofJiov tov KptaTOv a^Kxyaarov
eivat. Aia t/ ^e eyeveTO p^jxa Qeov 'Jrpog 'lcodvvrjv ev t^ f/"?/*w >

^td Ttva [xvaTtKTjv 6eccpiav. 'ETre/^^ yap efxeXXe TroAXa Ta TeKva


avTyji epvjfxcoBetayj^ [xaWov eivat ri irep) t^c eyovav]? rov avopa,
Tovrov ydptv rovro yeyove. E/ yap [xv] rovro y]v, eKTtepiaa^ag eitotei \$

KVjpva-accv ev t-^ epvjfxca. KKVjpvaa^e ^e (3dTrrta[xa [Leravoiai; etq

a(f)eaiv dfxaprtwv. To jtAev yap ©ew f^dTirta^xa reketcog e^yei

d(f)€atv dfiaprtav e^ avrov rov ^aTtrt^eaBaty ro te lcodvvov eU


avro [X€v e/j^ev dcpea-tv d^xaprtZVf ^ta [xeravoiag ^e, dre)^; yap
^v, e/ Kat Tav 'lov^aiVccSv ^a-nrta^xdrcov reXetorepov VTrfipyeV 20
€Ttotet yap avrovg eTttri^^etovg [xerdvota, Kat ^eKrtKovg aiir^g

yeveaBat irapeaKeva^e roiig ^airrt^^o^xevovg.

4 E7re/^»? ^e 'lcodvvi^g irpo^po^xog yjv rov ^ptarov^ (f^covyj 'yjv 6

koyog, Ttpo(hpa[xev yj (f^ctivy] rov Koyov. '^ta rovro kou wg ovita

Ttapovrog rov KvpioVy *'


€Tot[xdaaref' (f>v]at, " rvjv o^^ov avrov, 25
Tovreart, evrpeittaOyire Ttpog Ttapo^oyrjv a)V dv /3ovXotro vofKoSereiVf
Twv Tov vojaof aKtxv d(f)taTd[xevot. YivQetag te mtei rdg TpijSovg
Tov Qeov ^ta ^iKatoavvy]g avry]v odevav aKoXtd ydp oy Ka^ia.
To ^e " Tracra (pdpay^ TtXyjpctiOyjaerat" Kat rd e^^f, wg itpog

dvrtBeatv eart' Kai otovet d[t.(f>tl3dkXovrog rtvog yj 7tpo(f)y]T€ia 3^


ditoKptverat. Kitet'^)] ydp elitev, " erot[xdaare r^v otov Kvpiov,
*'
evSetag Ttoteire rag rpt^ovg avroVf' dvdvryjg ^e Kot rpayeia
ri dpery] Kat ^va^td^arog, Kat €[xno^i^o[xevy]f itpcarov [xev dito

Twv Ttovyjpav TtvevfxdrcoVy eitetra Se Kat dito rm (pvatKav Kat

e^coBev itaSccv, ag Xeyovrog rtvog t» itpotp^Ti^ itxg evteyerat 35


III. 6. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 29

KaTopdoixyai apeT-rjVf to(7ovtwv ovtcov /fwAvjtAaTWV, avTO^ aTtoKpiQai

Ae-ye/, oti vav to irpog tov t^$ aptTrig '^pofi.ov I^tco^i^ov '^iopOcoO-^-

aerai vno tov ^piaTov' Kav (pdpay^ Tig ei^, Kai '^ia tovto

vTrap^xet '^va^aTog, iik^puiQ-^cTiTai Tipog ^e^iws-iV Kav hpog r/f

uyi Kai ^owog, Kai ^ia. tovto eaTi ^vaTiopevTOSj TanetvwQ-^aeTai ^

elg ohov ei6etaVf Kat itaVTa eaTat evQeta,

Aaaos. ^apayyag Se Kat opi^ Kat (3ovvovg to. itaQri KaXe7,

Kai Tag Tm ^atfji.ova}v avTta-Taaetg. ""O ^e Xeyet TotovTOV eaTtv,

OTi Tiavra oaa t»?v apeTvjv Kat t^« tov Qeov o^ov '^va(3aT0V

wo/er, KaTapyvjOyjaeTat vtto ^ptaTov, wg yeveadat Xeia itarra lo


Tolg o^eveiv ^ov\o[t.evotg' Xela ^e yeyovev ovTCog, eTiet^Yiiiep tov fxev

^aTavav KaT-^pyvjaev 6 ^ptaTog, Kat inro Toiig Ttc^ag tZv ^ovXwv

avTov TeQetKe, Ta Se T^g aapKog TtdOv] ev eavT^ KaTevvaae Kcti

KaT-^pyvjae.

6 Aei^ai ^e BeXm, OTt ovKeTt lov^^a^oi ovTe itpoaYjXvTOi fJLOVov, 15


dXXa Kai itaaa ^ t£v dvSpooTrcov (ftvatg TVjg ^iXav6pcoTtiag aTto-

Xavaet tov Qeov, <f)r]at " Kat oxpeTat itaaa aap^ to acoT-^ptov
*'
Tov Qeov, '
TOVTeaTtv, OTt Ttpog ra TtepaTa TVjg yyjg Ki^pv^Byj-

aeTai twv EyayyeA/oJV tovtojv yj ^vvafxtg kou yj yvaatg, «Tro Qyjptw-

'bovg TpoTtov Kai aKXy]poTdTy]g yvwfJLVig eig '^fJi.epoTyjTa TtoXXyjv Kai 20


•TtpaOTi^Ta fJieTa(3aXXovaa to twv avOpooTtoov yevog. Kat yap ^ta

Tcov aKoXicov TtdvTa tov 'hte^Bapfj.evov jSiov yjvt^aTO, TovTeaTt,

TeXmag, Kai itopvag Kai XyjaTag Kai fndyovg, oiTiveg ovreg '^te-

aTpafj.fxevot itpoTepov, TVfv opQvjv varepov e^d^taav o^oV oitep ovv

avTog eXeye ToTg lov^atoig, " oti TeXcovai Kat itopvat ttpodyovaiv 25
" vfxag eig tvjv PaatXetav twv ovpavcov.''*

10 eXeyev ovv rotg eK7topevoff.evotg o^Xotg ecog ' Kat eig Ttvp
" jSaAAeTa;," Ttpotypdcpvi eig to KaTa MaT^aibv.

KE^. S".

n.(pi rav fir(pa>n](rdpTav rov *Ia>dvvr}v. 30

EpcoTVjdeig Se 'Iwavv>jf Ttapa tcov oj^Aojv to t/ TtotvjaofJiev ;

avTog KaBaitep Tig eittaTvifjMV tarpog eKdarco ro itpoatpopov reSetKC

PovjQvjfiia, To7g fxev oyXotg <fnXaXX-^Xcc <f>povyjfj.aTt Keyjp-i^aBai Ace-


30 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA III. 1 8.

Aevojj/, xeAwvaif Se rrjv eU aKaQcKTovf nXeove^iag aTroKXeicov o^ov,

Toif ye iJ.fjv a-TpaTiiorai( ro fxyj^eva ^taaeteiv 7rav<7o<j)coi eTci^aviov'

ov^eva yap aiio(3d\keTat 0eof, op6(io$ Koi ^iKaicog TroXtrevo^evov


ovTto Se ^v [xeyas xat d^idyaarog wg elg lirovoiag eXBeh roiig tc5v

lovoatav OrjiAovgy [xr] dpdye avrog eif\ o Xp;<7T0f, o viio Trpoipyjrcov ^


dyiav TrpoKeKVjpvyfxevog. avrog ^e t^v roiavryjv avrav vnoxpiav
airoKOiTT(ov eXeyev eyco fAev voart paTrriga vfAas, Kai ra
e^ijs-, ecag " KaraKavaet Ttvpt da^eara.^^ 7rpoeypd(f)V} eig ro Kara
MarOaiov.
OpirENors. Tpia rdyfxara eia-^yayey TivvGavofj.evov rov lo

Iwavvov, ev /xev, (ovofi.aaev o^Kovg eKTTopevofj.evovg eiii ro pdirrtaf/M,

aX\o ^e avofiaae reXmagy rptrov ^e mofKaae arpariwTag.


ToT ATTOT. FevOjaevof eyca Kara rov tottov toiJtov, eirrjrovVf

€1 avry} yj evroX"^, oaov eiri rcov pvjrwv rw op^Aoo, dpff.o^ei' " o ej^eov

**
ovo yjroivag, fi.era^orco tw fny] ej^ovTi'" ort ydp roTg AwocttoAo/? 15

dpff.Q^etf ^^Aov eK rav dvaypa^ovrm^ wg vno rov YiCoryjpog irpog

avrovg *'
elpYifxevov, ev olg eXeyev avrotgf ft.yj^€ ^vo y^trmag elg

" o^ov dpaif aAA' opa, ei rd eipYjfxeva iiepi evtvfxarog ev tw


Aoyco To5 Tiept r-qg yvfxvoryjrog ^vvaaai 7rapaXa(3etv eig to "
** ej^wv Suo "^firmag fxero^orca rx fxyj ep^ovT/." QeXet ydp yjfxdg cof 20
jOtTjSe tvo ')(irmag eyeiv, Kat ev^e^vaQai, tt^ fuv ro TraXaiov, tt^ Se

TO veoV aXX eKOvaaa-dai fxev ro erepov, ro Oe erepov eyetv. afxa

Se e^-^rovv ro " fxero^orco rw fxy} eypvri. Tig ^e eariv 6 fMj

ev^vfxa eycov nepi rov yj^cora Kat fn.y} evaKeiraafxevQV coare avrco

fxera^i^ovai ; ov rovro Xeyco, ori ov ^vvarat Kat KaGi' vTrep/SoXt^v 25

Tovro irporpeirrtKov etvat Trpog ro ^eh evhvetv rovg irevyjrag Kat f*.y]

afxeXeh ry}g evroXyjg.

18 E/Trwv Se ori TroXXd fxev oiiv Kat erepa TrapaKaXm evy^yyeXt-

^ero rov Xaov, etei^ev ori rov Xoyov rov EtvayyeXtov ^i^daKmy
TToXXd acoTYipta evayyeXi^erai ^i^dyfxara. 3°
To ^e hrayofxevoVf ori " 'Wpcotrjg rerpdpyy^g eXeyyofxevog xm

ayTon Kat Ta eg^^g eag ev ty} (pvXaKY} irpoeypacpy} etg ro

Kara MaTdarov. ofxoicog %e Kat irepi rov (Sairriafxov.

19 O Se HfxoSrjs 6 T€Tpap)(T]9f €\€y\ofjLeuo9 vtt avTov.


ilpirENOTS. OvTog irapavofi.cog eyy^fie t>;v yvvaiKa rov a&eA-35
III. 23- AOYKAN ETArrEAIOT. 31

<j>Qv avTOv Ttafa. rov MwyVewf vofxov' aXX' o aKaTa-nXfiKTog laav-

vi^$ /xij^evof TrpoauTTOv kafx^avoov, ov (f)ol3rj6eif Tyjv ^aaiXiKfiv

e^ovaiav, ov^e ^ttov TrXvjpwv npo^pyjTiKviv TrappvjcriaVf rj^ey^e tov

'Hpci^r] eTn tt] Trapavofxca tqv yafxov, Kai KaTeKXeiaOy} eig (pvka-

KTjv, Kai [xr] fJLepi[xvS)v QavaTov, e{xepiiji.va Tiepi '^piQTOv. 5

33 Kai avTOs tjv 6 ^lrjcrov^ aycrel iroov TpLaKovra ap^o-


pL^vos.

TpiaKQVTaeTYig ^e eiti to ^dTma[j.a 'TiapeyeveTO, eire/^*; [xefxap-

rvprjfjiev^ eaTiv rj rjXiKia avTYj, loaTe fxeya ovaa, afka ^e Kai iva

^ei^vjf OTi TeXeiovs av^pag ditoTiKTei KaTo, r^v vorjTrjv ^KiKiav 1710

Ttvevfux.TiKYi av ovTQ} yap Kai TrpwTog avBpamog TeXeiog

e7i\da6rjf Kai evBe(ag ev t£ Trapa^eiau) TeGei<;, ccg TeXeiog evTo?o]v

Kai vofKov eXa/3e, Kai eTteTpeTieTO tov Trapa^etaov t»jv epyaaiav


Kai (pvXaK-^v.

Ylepi rrjv KaTO. adpKa yevv^aiv rov ^eaTtOTOv ^fnav Irjaov 15

XptaTov, ro Tov fKev MaT^arov ajro "EokofJioovrog avrov yeveaXoyeiVf

Kat tpSdveiv eig rov MaT^arov Kai laKwfS Kat lcoarj^p, Kat afi.(f)i-

(3o\<i}g eKaarov avrSov, erepov ^e Kat eri KaraXeyetv yevog' Kat


'toKei Twv d^vvdrav eivai rov ^lcoarjcf» rov vofxtaBevra dv^pd rrjg

Ttavaytag BeoroKov Kai dei TiapBevQV ^aptag, rov re \aK<h(3 Kai 20


Tov 'HA< eayrjKevai Ttarepa' d\Xa Karavorjaag fxev rrjv Xvatv rrjg

^oKOvarjg ^tacpcoviag. rpirog dito TeAovf Kara rr^v rov ^arBatov

yeveaXoyiav earlv M.aT8a7og, itefXTtrog te dito reXQvg, Kard rrjv

rov AovKa MeAj^/* rovrctiv roov "^vo Kara Ota(popGvg yj)Ovovg, ya-
ft-err] yeyovev rj KaBdv' rov yap MaT^av 'TtpoetXrjcporog avrrjv Kat 25

7ra<&07ro<iyaavTOf c^ avrrjg rov laifwjS, Kat TeXevT-^aavTog, yripav

avT\v QvaaVf eK rr)g avrrjg wv (pvXrjg, dXXrjg ^e avyyevetag, rjyd-

•ycTo MeAj^/, Kat eitat^oitoirjaev e^ avrrjg rov HX/. te laKca^

rotyapovv Kat HA/ ofj.ofj.riTptQt rvyydvovatv d^eX(f)ot eK r^g Eaflav.


etg 'Eo-^av*' ^e tou 'HA/ yvvaTKa Kat dreKvov reXevr-^aavTQg, ^o
Kard Tov vofLOV elarjXBe itpog avrriv 'laff«/3, wg d^eX(f)og Ttat^o-
Ttof^aag rw reXevr^^aavri d^eX(f)w tw 'HA/* €7ra/&07roii70'ev oiiv rov

c (l<r6av Cod.
32 EPMHNETA TOT KATA III. 43.

^lcoayjcf), Kai yjvpeGi^ 6 laayj^, vioi fxh wv t^ cf^vaei tov la/^oj/?,

vo/Aoo ^e Toy HA/, /<fa< to «yevoc ol9ev 'laKOi^ KaToiyeTai. o^e ye

AovKoig Tov KaTa vofxov Xeym naTepa tov la)ar](f> tov HXi KaTa-
yeTai' <npocxfiKOVT0og te 6 fxev tov KaTa (fyvaiv, 6 ^e tqv KaTa
vo^ov TtaTpo^ [xefjt.w]Tai' iva ^ei^aatv, oti ef a[Ji(f)OTepcov tcov 5

iraTpwVf Tov Te KaTa tov vofxov, tov t€ KaTa t>jv (f)vaiv, eig

Tov Aa^i^ avaTpeyei to yevog' o6ev t»v ^vo naTepm elg tov

AajSi^ avaTpeyovTioVf Kai 'lof^a/cov Kai 'EAAiyvcyv iraai TiepieipvjTai

afji.(f>i(T/3'^TV](Tig Kai anav (TKavtaXov.


Tox ArioT Ktpiaaot. HaTiTi^eTai ^e 6 li^^Tovg, evkoyoov Ta 10
ti^aTa Kai KaBaipoov avTa virep yjfxav. Ayiog yap e(XTiv Ayicov

Movo-yev^f tov 0eoy Aoyog, Kai ovk av avTog e^eYjdvj tov ayiov

^aTtTKjfxaTog, ovh\ (x^peaeug afxapTiSov Tvy^eh, (naTtep yjfxeHg Kep-

taivofxev ^i avTOV.

'Avoiyet Tovg ovpavovg, ovg cKXetaev TrpSoTog 'A^aja, ^tjXcijv 15

cog rj Tov (3a7rTiafji.aT0g 'hvvafx.ig avotog eaTiv elg tov ovpavov' rjfjuv

yap aitavTa eitpaTTev ovpcLVtog tov aytaafkov Kai T^f TjfJieTepag

XvTpaaecog aTtapyofji.evog . ovtco Kat to IlveDjaa S< yjfxag KaTetaiv

eig avToV Uvevfia Se oy)^ ev tc5v XeiTovpyiKcov 'Ttvevft.txTcov, aXXa


TO avTOv Tov 0eoy, to ofxoovatov Kai avfx^aatXevov avTco Kat tco 20

YlaTpt.

E< oe (f)yjat, Ttvevfxa KaTa^ahov coaet TtepiaTepav, tva ^etyGet'^

aa(f)cog cog eig eaTiv TYjg itaXatag Kat KaiVYjg ^taByjKYji Qeog' Ka)
€ig VTtofXvyjaiv ayayfi tov eiti Nwe KaTaKXvafxov. "Q.aitep yap
tot€ TteptaTepa tyjv KaTanavatv evyjyyeXiaaTo T^g opyyjg toD 25
0€oy, oyTO» Kai vvv iteptaTepav eitov, ft.yjvvet tov T-^g (XfxapTtag

KaTaKXvafxov Kai tijv tow Koafxov ^iaXXay-^v.

O ev yjfxiv TtpcoTOTOKog yeyovev ev ttoXXo^ig a^eX<po7g, KaSelg


eavTOv etg Kevooatv, ^eyeTat ttpcoTog to Ylvevfxa' KaiToi tov ITvey-

fxaTog ^OTYip VTtap^^^cov avTog, tva Kcti eig yjfxag epyj^Tat tt avTov^^o
TO a^tcofxa, Kat T^f "Ttpog to Aytov Ilvevft.a Kotvooviag yj yaptg,
TOiovTov Ti Kai 6 UavXog ^tt(iiaKei yjfxag Xeycov, ttepi Te avTov
Kai yjfxctiv' " Te yap dyta^cov Kai 01 dyia^ofxevot e^ evog itdvTeg,
" 01 ^v ovK eitatayyveTat d^eX(f>ovg avTovg KaXeiv, Xeycov, ditay-
" 'yeAw TO ovofxd aov To^ig d^eX(f>oig fxov." 35
IV. u AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 33

KE«i». Z.

Jlfpi Tov TTfipacrfiov tov ^arnjpos.

1 ^lrja-ous Se Hu€viJ.aT09 'Ayiov TrXrjpTjs VTrearpeyp^eu

OTTO Tov *lop8ai/ov. KCLL rjyeTO 4v r^ IlvevfxaTi ety ttjv


eprjfxov rjfxepas TecraapaKOVTa. 5

1 OT ATTOT. 1 1 ovv apa xo '


riycvo ; ear/v ov to a-recpepero

fj.aX\ov, a\k OTi ^i^^ye Kai eTroXirevero. KarriBKyp.eBa yap Ttag Kat

r]p.e7i avroi iiffi icavroi rovro ev eTrieiKeia Xeyetv, ^eiva rvyeiv^

KaXSis eavrov ayei. eirokirevero toivvv ev r^ iprjfxca ev nvevixart,

T0vre<7Ti TTvevfxartKiog' vevYjarevKe yap, ov^ev itavreXwi rrf rov 10

cafxarog %/5e/a ^/^ovj" elg rpocf^YjV' ovk avrog vyjareKXg Trpoa^eo-

fxevog, akka rvirov yjfuv ra KaQ eavrov etg v7r0ypafi.fi.vjv avart6eti,

Kai etKOva irotovfi.evog rrjg irap vjf/.iv e^aiperov Kai reBavfxacfj.ev^i

^(orjg. ro ^e ev rrf ep^fLco ^tairaaBat avayKoiov Kat '^(prjatfi.ov

eartv. airo^f^otrmreg yap rm etKaiav rov Trapovrog j3t0Vf rrept- 15

aTraafxm Kai KVfjJxrm Kat ^akrjg aTr^WayfxeSa, Ka) rrjv rj^ovi^v

airoveKpovvreif Kpeirroveg rov rretpa^ovrog Harava eaofxeOa.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias. 'EvratJfia fxot PXerre t^v rov


avBpamov <f>vaiv, Kai ev carapyr\ rw l^ptarw r^ rov Aytov YJvev-

fxarog ya.ptri KaraKeyjptaft.evriVy Koi ralg avoordro) rtfxaTg eare- 20

^avoj/xevijV irdXat fuev yap vrrtayyeno ra>v o\av Qeog, XeyaVy


**
orri earai ev ratg rju.epatg eKeivatg eKyefh arro rov Ylvevfxarog
*'
fxov eiri iraaav adpKa." vevXrjparat Se eig rjfxag ag ev irpcorai

"Xpovo} ro errrfyyeXfxevoVf Kat rrepi fxev rav dpyatorepm aKaOeKTwg


€KKeKktKorav eig (f>tXoaapKtav e((>rj rrov HpiaTog, " ov fxri Kara' 25
" fxetv-fj ro Ylvevfxa ev rolg dvBpwTrotg rovrotg ^ta ro eivai avrovg

adpKag." EiTrettr] ^e vrdvra yeyovev ev Xptarco Kaiva, Kat t*/v §/a

rivey^arof xe Kat v^^arog dvayevvrjatv rreTrXovrriKafj.ev, yiprifxart-

^ofxev "he ovKeri aapKog Kat oufxarog reKva, rrarepa ^e fxdXXov

KaXovfiev rov Seov' ravrrj rot Kai f>.dXa elKoru^g, ware (og TeTt- 30
fxrffMevoi Xoiirov Kai ro Xafxrrpov eyovreg rrjg vioOeaiag Kavyr]fx.a,

Betag (f^vaeag yeyovafj-ev Koivavoif ^ta fxeroyrjg rov 'Aytov Hvei;-

^ Leg. fors. rvxoy.


34 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA IV. 3.

y.aTo<;' 6 h ev vjfMv TrpojroroKo^y ore yeyovev ev TtoXXoHi a^ek<f>o7i,

Ka$ei( eavrov eli Kevooaiv, ^e-^^erai irparov ro Ilvev/xa, Kai roi rov

Uvevfxarog ^or^p VTtdpyaiv avrog, iva Kai elg yjfia$ epy^^rai ti

avrov ro a^tcof/.a, Kai rrjg irpog ro 'Ayiov Ylvevfxa Koivooviag 7]

Xapig. ^oiovrov ri Kai 6 YiavXog ^tldaKei yifj.ag Xeym Trepi re ^


avrov Kai •^(xaV " re yap dytd^cov Kot dyia^o[Ji.evoi c| evog
" vdvres' ot vjv ovk eTiata^^vverat dheX(f>ovg aiirovg KaXuv, Xiyav,
" aiiayyeXvi ro ovofkd aov ro^ig dteXtfioHg fxov. E^6;^^ yap oXcag

cvK eitato^^vverat KaXwv y)fj.dg dteX^povg, "htd rot ro vneXBeh T»yv

irpog Tffiag Ofxctwaiv, ^ia rovro rvjv vjfJMV eig eavrov Trrayeiav 10

[ji.€rart$€tg, dytd^erai fneS vjfxwv, Kairoi rvjv Krtaiv d-naaav


dyta^cov avrog, tva ft>j (paivvjrat ro r^g avdpcoiTorvjrog irapatrov-

fj.evog fj.erpov, 6 rvjg dndvrm acorvjptag Kai ^avjg avOpccTtog yeveaSai

fj.yj
(f)vyctiv. Kat " ev 6fJ.otccaet ryj Trpog yjfj.dg yevoft,evog t^ Kard
" irdv ori ovv, ttya fiovyjg dfj.aprtag.^^ 15

3 JflANNOT TOT XpT202T0M0T. " Ka/ avvreXeaBetawv avrwv


" eTreivaaev," ov^e ydp wjarevovrt dXXd Treivavrt itpoaepyerai, tva

av fi.d$yjg, yjXtKov vyjareta KaXov, Ka\ iiag oitXov eart Kard rov

itajSoXov fj.eytarov, Kat ort fxeya Xovrpov, ov rpv(f)yj Kat fj.e$yi Kat

rpaTie^y] 7rXyj$ovay], aXXa vyjareta irpoae^yj^tv ^e?. A/a ydp rovro 20


Kat avrog ev^arevaev, ovk avrog ravryjg 'teofj.evog, dXX^ yjfJ-dg

irat^evccv.

OpirENOTS. Udvra Ttetpaafj.ov ov efj.eXXov 0/ dvSpcoiroi Tteipd-

^eaSai, irparov eiretpdaSy] Kard ro dvSpwTitvov' ^e Xeyco, rotovrov

eartV eav t^yjg rovg «tto rav aipeaecov eaStovrag cog dprov tov 25
Xoyov rov xpev^^, 'taSt ori eKehog Xoyog 6 Xi$og earlv, ov 6

^tdjSoXog "^etKVvatv, evet TToiog ^v Tretpaafxog rov Xi$ov yeveaSai

aprov, Kat rov ^ioryjpa (f)ayeiv ;

4 At^daKet &e htd T^f Xe!^ecog, ori ovrog fiev, ov pyjfj-a Seov, ro
Oe rpe<f)ov pvjfj.a Kai ro ^cooTtotovv' eir eKetvco ydp rco p^^fxart ^^ 30
avSpcoTrog' afj.a Se rvjpet, ori ravra Xeyet Kard ro dvSpdoTrtvov, ov

KaSo Seog yjv. Q,g ydp irept dvSpcoirov dnoKptverat Kat Xeyet,
" yeypairrat, ort ovk hr dprca fj.ova> ^yfaerai dvSpcoirog,^^ ^yjXcov

ort cog avSpcoirog eart iretpa^ofj.evog.

5 Eizrwv Se 6 EivayyeXtaryjg, oti " e^et^ev avrw irdaag rd(35


;

IV. 14- AOTKAN ETATTEAIOT. 85

" PaaiKeiaf T^f oiKovfxivrji cv (JTiyfJiyj "^q^ovov" olvti tov ^ieypaxpe


Tco koya TVjv oiKov[ji.€vi^Vf <i>fl^h '^«' wa-7rep Tponov Tiva €v t^
^tavoia avTov mre^eiKVvev a^ coeTO. ov^ev y]yvo'ei 6 ndvTa Troi^aa^,

€1 yap fxvj TOVTO cctt/, irwf y^^vvaTO avTovs tov^ TOitovg e/f kva
TOTTov vpog Seccpiav acofxaTiKrjv ayayeTv, oiov, (pepe elneTv, Trjv^

YIep(T(ov yjyefJioviav, yj tvjv 'Iv^av

ToT ATioT rpHropiOT Nt22H2. 'O KaTo. TTavTa Koiva>vy](Tag

yjljJiv 'Xjiapig afj.apTiag, Kai avfj.fJ.eTaa')(a}v yjfi.Tv twv avTwv 7raSyjfJ.d-

Twv, TYiv Trehav ovk eKpivev dfxapTiav, ov^e dncoaaTo T^f eavTOv

ireipag to ««t avT-^g vdSof, aX\ e'i^aTO t^v opeKTiKyjv T^fio


(f)vae(i}$ opfxi^v, t>jv e^ri Tyj Tpo(f>^ yivofj.evy]v, diroanog yap Tea-
aapdKovTa ^fi.epoiv ^iaft.eivag, vaTepov eTreivaaev. 'E^w/ce yap ore
ePovXeTO Tyj (pvaei Kaipov to. eavTVfg evepyyjaai.

13 Kai avPTcXeo-a^ irdvTa Treipaa-fiou 6 Sict^oAoy, Acai

ra e^rjs. 15

TouTovf TQvs Tpei$ Treipaafj.ovg eKTeXeaag tidjSoXog dveyi>'

pi^a-e. Tiveg ovv eiaiv 01 Tpeig ; yj yaaTpifxapyia, yj (piXapyvpia,

vj KevoOo^ia, aWovg irapa toitou? iretpaa^ft.ovg ovk e^xjet. irpcaTog

Aoafj. hia KotXiag 'ireipd^eTai, eTret^v} ov-/^ ei^/e irXeove^iav, ov^e

Kevo^o^tav, irdvTWv Kvptog (ov, Kat fi.y}^evog eTepov ovTog' ov irpoadyet 20

avT(f! ^tdj3o\og opy^v, oy^ev yap e/j^ev 00 opytaQy]' diro ryjg

yaaTptfJMpytag totc ^p^aTO, Kat vvv eKeiBev yjp^aTO.


T/ Se €<rT/ to " ecog Katpov ;" e^e^ej^CTO yap t^v iovhaiccv

irovyjptav. ^ptaTog ^c ^ta tovto irapeyeveTOy tva irXyjpwai^ T^f


otKovfjiev^g tov aKOTrov. 25
14 To ^e *'
virea-Tpeipev 6 lyjaovg ev Tyj '^vvdfj.ei tou Y\vevfj.aTog
" elg T>?v TaXtXatav^ '^ta Tag Beoavifj.eiag (pyjalv, (aairep eTreTeXet

T^ tvvdfxet Tov Ylavaytov YlvevfLaTog, ovk e^(o6ev Kot Tre-Troptafj.e'-

vy}v TYjv Tov YlvevfiMTog '/dpiv Xa^av, KaOa Kat tZv dyKov yopog,
dXK ojg (ov (f>vaet Te dXrftxg Tiog tov Seov, wg i^ia ^vvdfxet Kai 3°

evepyeta. yjtoifj.evog TVf tov Ylavaytov Kat ofJioovaiov YIvevfxaTog,


TavTag eipyd^eTO.
flpirENOTS. Fiiret^v] efxeXXev dBXeh irpog tov ^tdPoXov ev tw
iretpaafxx, ^ig oVofJ.d^eTat to Ylvevfxa yjap^g ndavjg TrpoaByjKrfg' OTi
F a
5

S8 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA IV. i6.

Se aymi(Tafj.€vos eviKvjae Tovi Tpe^g avayeypafxfxevov^; 7reipacr(xov^,

Ttpoaayeg ttJ aKpi(3eia TVjg ypacpy^g ti Trepi tov Tlvev[Ji.aTog (f)Vj(Tiv,

" OTi 'lyjaovg viiecrTpexpev ev Tyj '^vvdfjiei tqv Y\veviJ.aTog ; Kai Trpo(T-

iB-^Kev " ev ttJ ^vvdixei^' ^ia tov dBXiqTYiv tov veviKi^KOTa.

'QpirENOTS. " Ba(7iXeiag KO(rfji.ov" (pyjci, tov ko(T[j.ik(iov avQpco- 5

wwv, Tiva Tponov 01 ^acriXevovTai viro 'novvjpiag, 01 ^e ^aaiXevovTai

viro (piXapyvpiag, 01 ^e vito Kevo^^o^iag' ov yap e^eiKvvev avTcp

Tag ^aaiXetag tov Kocrfjiov, Tiva TpoTiov layyei ^amXevei,v, iv

avTOV "jrpOTpexpyjTai TTOiYjdai, b evof/.i^e TtoiYiaai, nepiyevridecrQai tov

X.ptaTov. €1 GeXetgy (f^yjcrt, ^acrtXevcrai tovtuv, Kai €7r< tovtccio

eXrjXvGag tov dyctiVKjacrOai Kai aTro^TTyj^rat Tovg ^acrtXevofxevovg

VTT eft.ov, fj.yi


dyavt^ov, ev d^ta, Treawv TrpoaKvvyjcrov fx,e, Ka)
TiapdXa^e iraaav tyjv (3a(TtXeiav tvjv vtt efie. aXX 6 "EaTy^p

PaatXevaai ft.ev OeXet Kat viioTd^at ndvTa to, eSvy], iva "^ovXa

yevyjTat ^iKaioavvyjg Kat dXyfietag Kat irdayig dpeT^g' jSaatXevaat 1

^e oi) fJ.eTa dfiapTiagy ov^e (BovXeTat dKfj.yiTt vnoTd^ag avTOv


eKeivco eaTe^pavccaSat, ov^e «ac/xtjt/ Xa^eh tidaag Tag ^aatXetag

Tov Koafj.ov, Kat t>;v to^^av avTm vTioyetptov. Aio <f>y}at Tipog

avTOv, " yeypanTat, Kvpiov tov Seov aov TipoaKVV^aeig, Kat «utoo
*'
fLOvca XaTpevaetg.^^ 20
16 ^Kft,(pai^ h€,(f)y}aiv, eavTOv Kai KaraaTyjaai ef atfj.aTog lapayjX

^ovXofj.evog, Kai OTt Keyp^aOat Tiapa tov Seov Kat YiaTpog etg

acoTYjptav TVjg vti ovpavov, 7iavao(j)ctig Kat tovto otKovofJ.eH npo y^


Twv aXXwv Tolg €k Na^apeT, oig avveTpd(f)Yi, Ka^d ye ty^v adpKa,
<py]fi.i, TOVTo yapi^of/.evog. " yjXSe" yap, (f>y]atv, " etg Na^apeT, ov 25
" y]v dvaTe6pafj.fj.evog,'' Kai Ta e^y}g. Avayvovg ^e to. ev too Tipo-

^•^TY] Haata dvayeypafj.fj.kva, " oti Ilvevfj.a Kvptov eii efj.€,

*'
ov eveKev eyptae fj.e evayyeXtaaaOat TiTcoyoTg," Kat toc e^Yjg.

EivapyeaTaTa ^ta tovtcov e^etKVve TOig aKovovatv, oti avTog


y]v, TOTe ^ta tov TipocpyjTov XaXav, OTt Kat evavSpcon^aet Kat 30

d(f)t^eTat ^taacoacov ttjv vti ovpavoV Keyp^aOat ydp ovy eTepcog

(f)afj.ev Tov Tiov, 7iXy]v oTt KaTa adpKa, yevofj.evov ^yjXovoTt KaQ'

y}fj.dg Kat evav6pco7iY}aavTa.


ai E/Ve Se, " OTt aY}fj.epov TteTiXy^pcoTai y} ypa(py] avTV},^^ Kat toc

k^Yig, kavTOV (pavepcog TiapiaTag ev Toinotg tov ^td t^^ 7ipo(p^Teiag35


IV. 23- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 37

•7rpor}yop€V[Ji.evov' avTO^ yap evyjyyeXio-aTO ryjv roov ovpavZv Pa<Ti~

Xeiav ToTg aiTO twv lOvZv' avTOt yap y)(Tav vToyxotj /xijSev ej^ovre?,

/x^ Siov €v yvaaet, [J.yj vofxov, /x»? Trpo^ijTa^, Kai anaat toJV ttAov-

Tov ovK e)(ov7t TTvevfxaTtKOv avTOs at')Qji.aA'jiTovg ovTag eppvaaTO,

Tov aTro(7Ta,TYjv Tvpavvov KaQeXliv, TovreaTt tov Y^aTavav' avTog^


€v^<TTpa\p€ TO vovjTOV Kai Beiov Kat ovpavtov (pwg ToHg eaKOTta-fjLfvvjv

eyovat T^v Kuptiav, KaBwg avTOq (f>y)ai,


" OTt eyw (pag etg tov

** twv
Koaf/.ov TOVTCV IkrjXvOa'^' avTOg aTrekvae ^eafJLiov, '^yjXovoTt

fig afLapTiav, Toiig avvTeSpavaft.evyjv eyovTag Kap^iaV avTOg eK'^-

pv^ev evtavTOv K.vpiov ^eKTOv, ov 6 iravao^pog YlavKog ft.vy]f/.ovevet lo


**
XeycoVf /^ov, vDv Kaipog evTrpoa^eKTog, t^ov vvv y]fi.epa acoTyjpiag.^'

22 TavTa ^e aKovovTeg Kat 6avfjt,d^ovTeg *'


eirt ToTg Xoyotg Trjg
" •yaptTog ToTg eKiiopevofi,evotg eK tov aTOfiaTog avTov," KaiTot
**
afx.iKpoXoyeTv avTOv ovk aireaTyjaaV eXe-yov yap, (f^rjatv, ov^^t

^^ viog eaTtv ^lcoayjcj) ovTog ;" oOev apfxotiov etiteTv eir avToTgi^
**
rovTO' ttov Xaog fJLCopog Kat aKap^iog' 0(p6aXfL0i avToTg, Kai ov
**
^Xeirovaiv, WTa avToTg, Kat ovk aKovovatv."

33 Kat €hre irpos avTOv^, HauTcos epeiTe fXOL ttjv irapa-

^oXqv TavTTjv/laTpe, Oepairevaov aeavTov.


Kotvog Xoyog vapa ^lov^^atotg ^v, aaTraafj.ov '/aptv e^yivpy]fi.evos' 20
*'
ToTg yap appaaTovat tSv lUTpwv eTre(pavovv Ttveg, laTpe, Oepd-
" Tcevaov aeavTOv" xaavet ovv tovto irporetvag avToTg to pyjTOVy

^piaTog eXeyev, ort iroXXa ^ovXeaSe irap efKov yiveaBat ay]fi.eTaf

irap vfj.Tv fj.aXtaTa, irap oig Kat eTpcx^pyjv. AaA' oiOa to Kotvov

Kai airaat avfx^aTvov iraQog, ort KaTa(f>povovvTat irov aet Kai Ta 25


e^atpeTa t5v TrpayfLaTxv, orav fj.yj
airavi^y] "Trapix Ttatv, aXX
eyaatv eir a^eiag avTa. 'ETrei ovv Kat eir avBpwTi'x tovto avfj.-

Paivet Qavfj.aaTlag, yap avv^Si^g Kat iraphv aet airoaTepeTTat

iroXXaKtg Tyjg o<f)etXof>.evy]g avTca Ttfj.y]g irapa t»v e^OTOiv avTOV

Ota TOVTo **
Xeyj} vfj.Tv, OTt ovtetg irpocp^Ti^g ^eKTOg eaTtv ev lyj^o
t( 's^
» ~ >»
iraTpiot avTov.

npirENOTS. YlaTptg tuv irpo^py^Twv, eK ireptTOft.y]g Xaog^

Trap oU ovK etat teKJOt' y]fJ.eTg Se ot aXXoTptot t'2v ^ta9rjK'2v Kai

^evoi Toav eirayyeXfZv, ete^aifj.eQa Tovg irpocf^yJTag oXy} tpv)(yj irpo-

Ky]pv^avTag ^piaTOv j]Trep eKeTvot, wairep Kat rj ev "LapecpSav Ti^g 3$


Tit^uvtag yy^pot tov 'Hxiav Xtfxov yevofj.evov ev rca 'lapay]X, tov
36 EPMHNEIA TQT KATA IV. 30.

aKcivaai Xoyav Kvpiov. Trepi TavTVjg t^? yyjpag Trpocf^^TVji (pYjaiv,

" OTi TioWa Ta TeKVa T^g ep^rjfxov [xaXXov 7] Tvji e^^ovarjg tgv
* avbpa, Kai TraXiv, oti cTepa ypacpij, (Jieipa eTCKev eirTa, Kat

" Yi TToXXy} ev TeKVoig y]a$evrjaeJ'

'KTrei^rj ^e Tag irept avTov "Tipocf^i^Tetag elg TeXog ^p^^a/ tte(3e-S

l3aiovvTO Toov lov^^aim Ttveg, ^ e7[i Ttai Tav irap avTolg fie(3aat~

XevKOTCoVf Yj eitt Trpocf^^^Tatg dytotg, airocfyepet •yjpyjat^xuig avrovg


TYjg ToiavTYjg vTrovoiag, eXey^^cov avTovg ag airtaTovvTag, Kai fxyj

TriaTevovTag oti [xaXXov etg avTOV ai TOiavTat 7rpo<f>yjTeiat dp[Ao-

^ovat, irpog [xiav aTreaTaXOat XYjpav YlXiav etirwv, Katirep iroXXav 10

ovacov ev tcS 'lapayjX Tore, Kat eva Bepairevaai Xenpov tov irpo-

<f>v]Tyiv Kktaaaiov Na/e/Aav tgv Hvpov, Kai eK tovtccv TrkeiaTCiov

OVTCOV ev TW lapavjX, eTret^v] eK iraaav tcov '/vipcav eKetvvj [i.ovvj

evpeOyj TriaTvj, 6[».oici)g Kai eK TrdvTCCv tcov XeTrpcov ovTog.

ToT ArioT Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias. T; to kcoXvov avTOViS

eivat aeirrov tc Kat d^idyaaTOV, et Kai viog evo[/.i^eTo \coavj(f> ;

ovy^ opag Tag Beoavj^xeiag ; TreaovTa Tov '^aTavav, veviKV][/.evag Tag

Tcov ^at[t,ovcov dyeXag, ^ta(f)opcov voavj[udTcov eXevQepovg yeyovoTag

TroXXovg ; eiraive^g tvjv y^dptv tvjv evovaav avTov Ta7g ^t^aaKaXiatg ;

cha a[LtKpoXoye7g ^lov^^aiKwg, OTt iraTepa tov 'Jcoavjcf) e7reypd(f>eTo ; 20


D, TroXXvjg d(3ovXiag, dXvjQeg eir avTovg eiTreiv, " i^ov Xaog [/.copog

*'
Kat dKapttog, 0(f>6aX[t.ot avToHg, Ka) ov ^Xeirovaiv, coTa, Kai ovk

aKovovai.

30 A<a Tt eKJBaXXovTcav avTWV " waTe KaTaKpvjfxviaat avTOv, avTog


** ;"
^teXGm S;a [neaov avTcov enopeveTO ov to TraSeiv (f>evycov, ^ta 25

ToyTO yap Kai eXvjXvdev, dXXa Katpov dvafxevcov entT-^^eiov etg

TovTo. dpyri yap vjv vvv tov Kvjpvy[i.aTog' tovto de avTO virdp^/ei

TeKft.-^ptov, OTt Ka) OTe eiraOev, eKovatcog ireTrovSe, Kat ovk av ovhe

T0T6 eiraSev, et [uj eavTOV eTretcoKev.

ToT ATTOT. Ovf ov [KeBtaTvjat Xoyog vrpog to elbevat aa(f>cog 3°


Tig (f>vaei Kat dXvjBwg eaTai Seog Kat Kvpiog, TovTovg aayyj-

vevei Trpog to evvjvtov vj tcov avj[t.eicov eirt^et^ig. ')(j)vjat[*.cog oiiv Kat


dvayKaicog TspoaeTcdyet iroXXdKtg Talg [x.vaTaycayiaig Tag [xeya-

Xovpytag' aTrtaTOt [j.ev ydp ot Tvjg lov^aiag otK^^Topeg, Kat Tovg

tSov KaXovvTcov eig acoTYjptav dTt[t.d^ovTeg Xoyovg, [/.dXtaTa Se35


TravTCOv ot airo Tvjg Kanepvaovft..
IV. 34- AOTKAN ETArrEAlOT. 30

KE4>. H.
Hepl Tov e)(ovTos irvevyM baiiioviov.

^;^ Kat eV ttj avuaycoyfj rjv oivdpcdiros e^oiv Trvevfia

Sai/xovLOV aKaOdpTov.

¥t7[€iVfi ^e 01 lov^ahi ovh\v €T€pov evofJii^ov tlvai rov X|9i<7TOV, 5

itXriv OTi Ka6 eva rm ayim, Kai ev Ta^et Trpocpi^rcov 7iapeXde7v

elg fxeaov. Aia, rovro im fji,€i^ova r^^v Trepi avrov ^o^av Kai
v-novoiav eyiodif ro '7rpo(p'rjTiKOv ava^aivei [Ji.erpov' ov^e yap eipfiKe

vore rd^e koyiKug % aXX' loare voix.iKSog ra vvep vo/jlov eAaAe/,

Kai [xer e^ovaiag T^f QeoTrpeTtoix; ro7f aKaSdprois eTrerifxa Tivev- 10

[JM(71V.

34 FiV<f)'^fi.et ^e ayTOv ro iivevfka ro dKaSaprov Xeyov, " oi^d cre,

" rtg e/, aytog rov 'Ia-pa>;A," virovowv ^ta r^$ TOtavrvjg ev<f)V)-

fJitag ro Kevovv ^o^^rjg avrov epaarrjv diroreXeiv, Kai dTroa^^^eaOat


-TrapaaKevd^et rov eirtirXrirTeiv avrco re Kai roig ofj.ototg avrov, 15

olov avrt ydptrog ^itovra ydptV aAA ovk hrtrev^erat ^oXtog

Qyjpag, Seog yap ov ft,vKTyjpt^eTai, dirocf^pdrret ^e fj.aK\ov ryfv

aKaGaprov avrov yXwrrav Kvptog, Kat Trpoa-rdccrei rov €-)(ovrog

avTOV airocpotrav.

TiTOT BosTPflN. AjOa ^ta ri eppiypev avTOV ; ^ta rt Se o 20


Kvptog avveyjapyjaev ; eireiVrj yap eXdXei wg vyjcfyoov Kat ecffOeyyero

(og KaOearYjKug, ^ta ro ra p'^fj.ara eivat rov ^atfj.ovog, v] Se yXiorra

rov avBpamov, Kai €vofj.t^ov 01 avBpavot ort ov^^^ a>g ev tatfj.ovt(i)

irovfipia e^pQeyyero, aXX €K r^g Kap^^tag avrov eXdXet, avveyoi-


pvjaev avT^ pixl^ai rov dvtpa, iva "^rjXov yevyjrat, ort ro '^atfj.ovtov 25
€C7Ti ro XaXyjaav.

Es ANEnirPA*oT. ^EK^dXXovatv avrov, KaB eavrcov fKaXXov

rrfv OtKfiv opt^ovreg, Kat fSe^atovvreg ro viro rov 'E(or^pog etpyj-

fj.€Vov' eKTreirrwKaai yap avrot ri^g dva TroXeoog TVjg lirovpavtov,

rov y^ptarov fj.yj


oe^dft,evot.
'
\va §e fKovov eXey^y] 'tvaae^vjaavrag ^o

fJ-^^^^jptg eTrf^etpyjfJMTUiv, avyKeyap-^^Ke "JrpoaeXBeh ra Ka& eavrov


roXfj.yffj.aTa. Ate^iet yap ha fj.eaov avTwv, ov^ev oaov elireiv

rtva 6efj.€vog r^g eTrt^ovXrjg avrav.


* "KvyeiKuq Cod.
5

40 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA IV. 38.

KE$. 0.

Tlfp\ TJ7? nepdepas Uhpov.

38 ^ Avacrras 8e e/c TrJ9 avvaywyrj^, dcrrjXOev U9 rrjv

OlKLaV ^ifXODVOS.

Ktpiaaot Aaesanapeias. Qfaaai ttw^ KareXvaev Ttap ev/

Twv fxaQYjTwv, av6p(i}7rw TrevvjTt Kai a.a^[X(i) KaTo, tov jSioVf 6 tvjv

€KQva-iov ^i yj[j.ag vTro[Jt.eiva$ TiTwy^eiav, tv V][xe7$ Tyj eKcivov itTd}-

yeta TrXoyr^o-cy/xev, Kat fxd6a}[xev toI^ raTieivoHg cyvveTidjeaBai Kai

[xri KaTercapecBai rav ev ev^eia Kai BXppei. VTro^e^O[JieSa Totvvv

Kat r][xe7g tov Ivjo-ovv. orav yap eiaPdXr] Kat ev rj[juv eyctift.ev 10
avTOv eig vovv Kai Kap^^tav, TOTe tSov eKTOirm yj^ovwv tvjv •jrvpcoatv

amcrPeaei. eyeipet ^e Kat evppcoaTovg aTrocpaivet, Trvev[xaTiKa>g

OVjXovoTt, ooare Kat vnrjpeTeh avTWf TOVTeaTi, to, avTW toKovvra


TrXvjpovv.

ToT Anor Titot Bostpan. OvKeTi yap ^ twv laBevToov diio 15

voiKtXccv aadeveiav, Kat drco iTvev[j.dTm aKaddpTcov, Kai irept UeTpov


Kai Av^pea Kat IukcoP koi ""lcodvvov. To **
vTiYjpypv dXteig," Koi

To " vjKoXovQovv Tw 'KptaTcf Tipoeypd(f>ri.

Ylepi te Trjg dypag rcov lyPvcov Xeyei aytog KvptXXog


AXe^av^peiag —Aid tu>v dXtevTiKcov avTov hrtTritev[j.dT(ov, dXtevei 20
Tovg [JiaQrjTag, oircog [xdQcoaiv eK tovtov OTt navaBeveg eyet to

BeXri[x.a, Kat roHg BeoTrpeneaTdTotg avTov vevfiaatv rj KTtatg vnr]-

perei' Kat iva ^id Tipdyfj.aTog evapyovg, Kat wg eK tvttov Kat


etKovog Tov iiapc^o^wg TeTeXea[i.evov '7TXr]po(f)oprjdcoatv, OTt ovk
a[f.taBog 6 iiovog avTotg, ovt^e aKaprtog r] airovVr] earat avroTg, ^v 25

av irof^aaiVTo, Tr]g evayyeXtK^g [f.vaTaycoyiag to ^tKTVov diTXdo-

aavTeg, aXX ev avTco TiaVTr] re Kat TrdvTCog Tag tHov eQvwv dyeXag
avXXe^coatv.

KE*. I.

Hfpl rS>v ladfvrav dirb noiiiiXciv voaav. 30

Ktpiaaot Aaebanapeias. ABpet le [xoi rrdXtv, oar]v ey^et

TV]V w<peXetav v] T^g dyiag avTov aapKog erra^r], eXavvet ydp Kat
^ Multa hic omissa esse videntur et leg. mepi tuv 1x6.
V. 5- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 41

votKt\a$ vocrovg Kai Sa/^ov/wv ^Aov, Koi t^v tov ^ia^okov Svva-

fjLtv KoracrTpeipei.

K.aiTOt yap Xoya KOt v€vfi.aTi vXyjpovv ^vvafxevog rag repa-


TOVpyias, iva t£v avayKaiav ^i^a^r], Kai rag %e<J9aj €7rt(f>epei TOis

oixriv ev dppaaTiais. E^ci yap, e^ei [xa6e7v ^/Aaf, oti tvj^ tovS
Xoyov ^vvdfJiewf tvjv evepyetav -TrecpopifjKev oj dyia aap^f ^v i^iav

evof^cTaro, BeoirpeTiri t^v tvvafxiv efx^vTevcag avT^ij. ovkovv aTrreo-fico

Kat vjfJMVf fndWov ^e ^fi.eTi avTov ^ia Tv}g fKV(TT iK-fji evkoyiag,

iva Kai vjfJMg eXevBepwcf] xpv)(^iKa>v appuKjTi^fJidTm Kat T^i' twv


^aifxovictiv e(potov Kat TiXecve^lag. lo

Tor Anor Tixor. ^vyo^evet voa-^fJLOTa, aa-ejSetav e^eXavvetf

^atf/.ovas d-TroaojSeT, irdvTa to, KaKa eK^dXXet^ eladyet te eU t^v


otKovfJievyjv tyjv dXyjQetaVy e^ovaiav Seoirpe^vrj.

KE4>. [A.

Uepi TTJs aypas riov lxBv<ov. I<

2 Ktpiaaot Aaeeanapeias. SavfJM(XQ}fji.ev Tyjg oiKovofxtas to

evTCj^vov, TO eirt t^ ye Gyjpa tojv TeOvjpi^KOTwv t*jv vtt' ovpavoV

(fyrift^t tvj t«v dytwv AmaTokwv, oi Kat dXtevetv e/^oTej, vtto

\pt(TTOv yeyova(7t Xhov^ tva Kat avTot t^v twv evayyeXiKwv

KfipvyfJMTWV aayrjviqv y^aXdaavreg, TrpoaKOfxtaaatv avTW Tovg Kara 20


Ttdaav Tviv yvjv. Ka\ yovv e(f>'*] irov ^i evog twv dyiav irpo^pvjTwVf

**
/Sou eyw diroaTeXXo) dXieig iroXXovg^ Xeyet ILvpiog, Kat dXtev-
**
acoaiv avTovii Koi fxeTa TovTa, dvoaTeXw TroXXovg Srjpevrdg,
**
Koi Brjpevaaatv avTovgT Kat Tovg fxev dXieTg Tovg dyiovg Atto-

QToXovq (f)V]a], Or^pevTag Se Tcyf Kard Katpovg twv dyiav eKKXrj-^^


atwv. rjyovfLevovg tc Kat fxvaTaywyovg. EweiS»; ydp dpKovvTwg
ToTg oyXotg ^tetXeKTat, TpeireTat irdXtv irpog t^v avv^dr] fxeya-

XovpyiaVf Kat &/a twv dXtevTiKwv htiTr^evft.dTav dXtevet Tovg

fxaQr]Tdg.

5 TiTOT Eni2KonoT BosTPON. ^rjaiv ^tfxwVf " hrtaTdTa ti 30


** vpo-
oXr]g T^? vvKTog KoirtdaavTeg, ovtev eXdfSofxev." iroXXot

(fyilTat ^XOoVf Koti efjietvev drrtaTog 6 Koafxog. Aia tovto eXeyev


G
42 , EPMHNEIA TOT KATA V. 12.

UavXos, " ^ vi)^ 'TrpoeKo^pev, vj ^e vjfJiepa *fff)iKev' co$ ev iqff-epa.

" eva'/viiJ.ovQ}g TrepiTaT^accfJ.ev"^^ TtoXXa eKa^ov 01 TTpo^rirai, Kai

^Yovtatoi €[Ji€ivav airiaTOi. Ti av Tig enroi irepi twv aXXcov eOvccv ;


Aia TovTO eXeyev 'EcoTyip, " aWoi KeKoiiiaKaai, Kai v[j.e7$ eit,
" Tov KOTTov avTwv ei(7€XyjXv6aTe." 5

Ktpiaaot 'Aaesanapeias. UpoaeTo^e yap To7g irepi E</x.cova,

^payy r^i- yyji ano^epeaQai, Kai KaQehai irpog aypav to oiktvov.

01 ^e ti' oXYiq jxev ecpaaKov KOTiiaaai vvktoi;, Xa^eiv Se [/.vj^ev'

itXyiv ev ovofmTi 'KpiaTOv Kad^Kav to Xivov, Kai [/.eaTOv el^/pv

ev^vg Tav TeSrjpevfLevav, iva '^ia itpay^J.aTo? evapyovg Kai cog eK io

Timov Kai etKovog tov irapato^wg TeTeXea[i.evov, TrXi^pocpopYjBaaiv,

OTi ovK a[t.ia9og Tiovog avTU)v, ovre aKapnog 7] aTrovQv], 7]v av


•TTOirjaaivTO, TYjg evayyeXiKrjg [j.vaTay(t>yiag Xivov anXccaavTeg, aXX
ev avTco TravTyj re Kai itdvTOog Tag Tav eQvav ayeXag avXXe^coai.

TrXvjV €Kem a6pei, ov yap la^^^yaav dveXKvaai to X7vov ^i[t.cov re 15

Kal 01 avv avTW' Karevevadv, (f>y]ai, To7g [xeToypig, ^^Aov ^e oti

^ta Twv dXievTiKwv eTtny^ev^JMTCtiV, caare avXXa(3ea6ai avTOig Kai

avv^^iaacoaai tvjv dypav. YloXXoi ydp To7g twv dyicov ATToaToXcov

avvfjpavTO Kai avvaipovTai iTOVoig, Kai irpo ye rwv aXXcav 01 Tag


lepdg v}[juv rwv dyicav EivayyeXiaTaiv dvepevvavTeg ypacpag, Kai 20
jxer' eKeivovg CTepoi TroifJ.eveg Kai "^t^daKaXoi Kai Xaav yjyovfxevoi,

Kcti Tcov TYjg dXyjQeiag TrpayfLaTcov e'niaTyi[t.oveg. Ava(pepeTat yap

€Tt TO X7vov, TTXyjpovvTog avTO Tov ^ptaTov, Kat KaXovvTog eig

€7TiaTpo(l>y^v Ti^g ev l3vQo7g 6aXdaayjg Kara to y€ypa[j.[>.evov, tovt-

eaTt Tov ev ^dXyj Kat KV[J.aatv, ev To7g KoafxtKO^g. 25


Ylept Tov XeTTpov Kat eiTi tov iTapaXvTtKov Kai TTept tov reXwvov

€cog TTept TftJv daKcov rcov TTaXaicov Kat twv vecov, itpoeypacjjyi.

KE4». IB.

ILepi Tov \eiTpov.

1% Kai iyeuero iu Tcp eiuat avTOU iv ixlSl twv TroXecoVfSo

KOLL iSov dvrjp irXrjfyqs Xiirpas.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaebanapeias. 'ETra/vov iTavTog a^ta tov iTpoa-


V. 12. AOTKAN EYArrEAIOY. 43

eXBovTog yj TiiffTig' [/.efxapTvpvjKe yap to TiavTa tvvaaBai KaTopdovv


rSo ^E>[Xfxavov)}K, Kai '^ia vevfJLaToov BeoirpeTim eXevBepovaBai ^rjTei'

KaiTOi To TrdOog ovk id(Tifji.ov' ov yap otbev vj Xenpa ralg tccv

laTpm efxireipiaig iiapayitipel.v^ aKKa. TeBeafKai^ (pYiatv, eXavvo-

fKevovg ev e^ovaia BeoirpeTrei tov^ aKaBdprovi "^aifxovag voarjfxdTcov 5

sroAAoJv d7raK\aTTOfJ.evovg, Kai avv^Ka cog Beia tivi Kai afKa"^

yeipi ra TOiavTa ylvecrBai. opSo ^e Ttpoi tovto yjpfi^TOv ovTa Kai

eToifxoTaTa KaToiKTeipovTa Tovg irpoaiovTaq avTW. T/ toivvv to

KcoXvov eXeeiaBai Kdfxe ; Kai ti Trpog TavTa ^piaTog ; el3e/3aiov

ev avTW TYjv iriaTiv, Kat tyjv ez avToo §>; tovt^ TiXvjpocpopiav epyd- 10
^eTai. Se^^era/ yap Trjv anvjatv, Kai OfKoXoyel to ^uvaaBai, Kai

<f>y]<nf
" BeXco KaBapiaBYjTi'^^ yapt^eTat ^e avTca Kat dcprjv r^g
dytag avrov Kat TravaBeveardrrjg yetpog^ Kai evBeag air-iqXBev dir

avTOv vj Xenpa, Kat ro irdBog rpf Ik iro^wv.

ToT ATTOT. T/ ^^7roT€ tva fJidBcoatv evrevBev 01 rvjv roov lafud- 15

rm ydptv Trapa Seov ^eyofxevoi ; f>.r] rag Ttapa txv Bepairevoft.evm


ev(prifx.iag atreh, fx-^Te ft.v}v rov irapd rivoov eiraivov, iva fjji^ eig

vTrepoiptav eKireaotev, ro Trdvrm rcov KaKxv ataytarov irdBog, Kat

KaB erepov ^e rpoirov, Kai aiooTroovTog rov Xeirpov vjpKet Kat avrvj

rov Trpdyfiarog vj (pcovvj, irpog ro airayyelXai irdai roig eihoaiv 20

avTOV TV}V rov Bepairevaavrog ^vvafxiv.

ToT ATTOT. OlKOVOfxiKwg (pvjat Trpoadyetv ro "^oopov tcio Xeirpoo

Kara tov Mcovaeoog vofxov ro7g lepevaiV vjBeXe fxev OfxoXoyovfxevoog

fxeraaTrjaai rrjv aKtav Kat fxeTaTrXdaai rovg rinrovg etg Trvevfka-

TtKriv Xarpeiav' dXX^ eiretOr] fxvjnci} Triarevaavreg irpog avrov 25

^hv^aTot irpoaeKetvTo raTg Mooijaeoog evroXaTg, dog ert roov dpyaioov

eBvSov layvovTOov, eTrtrpeiret rca XeirpZ tovto iroteiv etg fxaprvptav

avTotg. Ka< fxer oXtya —Ka/ e^ afTov Ve rov BepaTrevaai rov

Xeirpov e^eariv i^eiv Kat fxdXa aa^oog ev dirapaKX-^rotg VTrepoyaig

•npog Tov Moovaecog vofxov, ovra 'Kptarov' eXeirpaBvf fxev ydp v)


2,0

Maptdfx, d^eXcpvj ^e M.oovaeoog avrv]' KareXdXrjae ydp avTov, Kat


Kare^dKvero fxev yap Xtav eiri rov Mcoijaeoog, eiretov] Civk vjv iKavog

dnoar-Siaat tov yvvatov rr]v voaov, Trpoaeirnrre rco Oew Xeyoov,

Kyeog heofxai aov, taaat avTvp».

G 2
5

44 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA V. 17.

Iljjoaaj^ej' toivvv aKpiPa^' alrriat? y^v hKei &;a Trpoaeityj^g, t^?

avadev y]fjt.epoTy]Tog vj^iov TV)(eiv' ^e ye twv o\cov SwTiyp (xeT

e^ovaiag ecpy] t^^ OeonpeTrovg, " 6eXo) KaOapiaGvjTi'" ovkovv fxap-


Tvpiov y]V To7i lepevaiv vj TVjg kenpag am^oXy], Kai y]V evTevQev

ei^evai Tovg t*?v KpeiTTOva ^py^cpov amvefXovTag t<b MoJvVer, oti 5

T^g aXy]6eiag e^oo l3adiovaiv. E&e/ yap, e^et MwyVea 6av[xd^etv

/xcv cog vo[xov ^iaKovov Kat yaptTog VTcovpyov, \a\y]6etai^g ^/

^yyeXccv, vnep6av[xd^€tv ^e tov ^E,[t.[xavovyj}\. Ka\ ^o^oXoyeTv avTOv

u>g Tiov d}i.y]6y] tov Qeov Kat YlaTpog.

ToT ArioT TiTOT BosTPflN. " Eig [xaprvptov avroTg," eig 10


[xaprvptov ro 6epa7revea6at, tva itXi^pixTy] rov vo(xov' ov yap '^^Xde

KaraXvcrat rov vofxov Kat rovg Trpo(f)yjrag, aAXa TtXr^paaai. aipe-

pertKo) ro " elg fxaprvpiov" eig v(3ptv Kara tov vo[xov Xa[x(3dvova-tv,

ov avvievreg 01 dvor]Tot ori ro " elg [xaprvptov^ etg diiotet^tv

Xeyerat' oiiov yap [xaprvpia, irpocpaatg eartv d[K<pt^aXKo[xevov 1

npdy[xarog.

KE4>. ir.

Ilept Tov irapaXvTiKov.

17 Kat eyevero eV ixia twv rjfJLepcov kou avTos rjv dida-

(TKcov, Kol rjaav KadrjfievoL ^apiaaloi kcu vofwbiZa- 20


(TKaXoL.

ToT ArioT Ktpiaaot 'Aaebanapeias. 'E7re;^»j ^e y]v dvay-


Katov, ovK evapt6[i.y]rov TrXy^^vog rav ypa[X[xare(ov Kat ^apiaatcav
avveiXey[xevy]g, yevea6at rav ert fxdXtara ^eoTrpeTreardrwv etg ovv]-

aiv avTov, [xtKpa yap e(f)povovv iiept avrov' WKOvo[xy]6y] rt iiaXtv 25

rwv Te6av[xaa[xevav' epptTiro [xev ydp eiit KXtvy]g itapdXvrog oivi^p,

dvidrw voax KeKpaTy][xevog. Etiret ^e daBevovat iipog ro avfxfSdv,

}] Twv larpwv r^Xeyyero re^^Qty], Tipog rov dv(i}6ev Kat e^ ovpavZv

larpov irapd twv oiKetcov eTieKOfxtl^eTo. 'ETrei&^ te y]v ev oxpet

XotTiov rov QepaTievetv la^^^yovrog , teKrr] fxev avrov yeyovev 0730

Tiiartg. ort Se eariv dfxapriag dvatpertKr], tto^etKVvatv ev6vg

Kptarog, eTiicfxtiveT ydp tw Ketfxevo) Xeywv, " dv^pane, ouf^ewvrai


V. 17- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 45

" (Toi ai afxapriai crov'" aXk cag ye oifnai, iipog TOVTOig epu rig

evQvg aTraXXay-^vat ryjg vocrov k^ovkero' Kai itwg acpecriv r-^g

aikapTiag avrSi Hpiarog eiiyjyyeXXiTo ; iva fxAOYjg ort a-ectyy]-

/xevwf Kat a\po<f)VjTt Qeog KaraaKaTrreTat ra avSpooTitva, Kat

etpopa, r^g eKaa^rov ^oi^g ttjv o^^ov' ovtco Kai yeypairrat' " evcoTrtov ^
**
yap tiai rm rov Qeov 0(()$a\fJiSiv o^ot av^^pog' eig Traaag rag
" rpoy^iag avrov aKOvevei." hrei^vj Se eartv ayaOog, Kat Travrag

avBpooTrovg Beket aw&^vat^ ^taafA-^y^et TroWaKig e| afxaprtav rovg

evetki^fj.fi.evovg, appwariav efi^aXwv rw a-wfjiart' ovro} ydp irov

(pviat ^ta (pcovijg 'lepef/itov, " irovto Kai (xda-Ttyt Trai^evB-^av] 'lepov- lo
**
(TaXvifJi..^^ E(f>vi ^e vov Kat 6 Tlapotfxtaar-^g' " y/e, /x^ oXtyapei
**
nat^eiag Kvptov, fi.v}^e eKkvov vir avrov eXeyyofkevog' %v yap
" ayaira Yjjptog^ irat^evei, fi.aartyoH te irdvra viov ov Trapa-
" "^eyerair KaXag ovv dpa 'Kptarog rvjv rov voaeiv d^popfxi^v,

KOA oiov rov irddoug r^v pi^av, Tovreari, rv)v dfxaprtaVf Trpoarro- 15

Keipetv eTrayyeXXerat. E^atpe6etav]g yap ravTiqg, dt ^v Kai ro

TrdSogj e^et irdvrwg avrvjv avvavatpeOvjvai rvjv voaoV fnev ovv rav
oXwv ^wrvjp Kat Kvptog, QeoirpeTreardTvjv ep^wv rvjv e^ovatav, rv[v

Twv dfA.apTtcav d(f>eaiv hrviyyeXXero. Bopv^el ^e vrdXiv Xoyog ro


tv^TiretBeg Koti /SdaKavov rwv ^Paptaaicov epyaar-^ptov. 20
TiTOT TOT BosTPflN. Qavfj.daat eari rovg KOfJita-avrag rav

TrapdXvroVf Trwg fjJri ^vvvjQevreg ^ta r^f Svpag eia-eX6e7vf dveKOft.icrav

avrov eiri ro oiofLa, wg yap ^evw Kai Kaiv2 eTrf/etpvjaat 'Trpdyft.ari'

avaairaaavreg yap rov Kepafkov, fi.ereKtvv]a-av rv]v d'7roKeift.evv]v

vXv]v. Kat ofJMg rovrwv yevofJievav, Kai ^{vjaovg efJ.aKpoBvfj.eiy kou 25


01 irapovreg eatamwv, rvjv eK^aatv ^ovXofj.evot Oeccpi^aaty Kat i^eiv

ri XaXet Kat rt TroteT. Avaa^rofi.waavTeg roivvv ro Sa;/xaTiov,

yaXMCTi Tov Kpd^^arov, Ka) <pepovat fneaov rov irapaXeXvfj.evov.


U Oe l\.vptog, <pv]atVf towv ri]v Triartv ai/Toiv, ov rv]v Triartv rov

TrapaXeXvfj.evov, aXXa rv]v irtartv rav KaXwg (ptXoTtfi.i^a-dvT(i>v, 30


ojCTTe aXXov Qt dXXoov iriartv Bepaireverat. E/7roi V dv rtg inrai-
6pov eivai roirov, eig ov Ota riov KepdfJ.<ov Kare^i^aaav tv]v KXiwjv
rov irapaXvrov, fj.v]^ev iravreXwg ri^g areyi^g dvarpexpavreg.

Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias. " T/f ovTOf," (f>v]a-}v,


" og XaXeT
5

46 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA V. 27.

** av ^apiaale, tovti
^Xaa^fiYi^iav ;" aXX' ovk e<prj^, cD iiepi

avTOVf el Ta<; Beiag (iriaTaao ypa(f)ag' eha Trpoff^rjTiKcov efxefxvvjcro

KoyaVf el to (leitTOV Kai ^era TVjg evavSpcoTr^^a^eag avvi^Kag (xvaTr}-

piov. ^Xa(T(l)y}fJiia$ ^e eyKk-^fJiaTt nepi^ixKXovai, tvjv ea-^^aTyjv

avTccv Ka6opi^ovTeg '^iktjv, Kai BavaTOv KaTa\pYj(f)i^o[Jievoi. Tov 5

yap etTTOVTa '^va<pi^[J.iav KaTa tov ©eoy, OavaTov vTrofJieveiv Trpocc-

TaTTe vofj.og, eneiV^ Ve tovto TeToXft.YjKaaif '^ia^eiKVvaiv evdvg oti

Seog eaTiv, 7va •naXtv ov (f^opvjTwg '^vaae^ovvTag eXey^rj. " Ti


" yap" <l>yja}f
" ^taXoyi^eade ev Talg Kap^iatg vfxav ;" ovkqvv

OTav Xeyvjg, w ^apiaaTe, " Ttg 'hvvaTat afj.apTiag a(f)tevat, ei fx)) eig 10
" ©eog ;" epoi) aoi KayiOf Tig ^vvaTai Kap^tav ei^evatf Kat Tovg

ev Toj (3aBei TYjg ^iavoiag Xoyiafj.ovg Ka6opav, el f*,7}


fj.ovog 6 ©eog ;

AiiTog yap itov (f^vjai ^ta (f)0ov^g '7rpo(f)VjTwv, " oti eyci) Kvptog
*' €T(x^(ov Kaptiav Ka) 'hoKtfj.a^fov ve(f)povg'" e<f)yi ^e ttov Kat Aa(3t^

irepi T€ avTOV Kai yjfxm, " TtKaaag KaTa fxovag Tag Kap^iag 1

" ayTwv" ovKovv 6 ei^iog Kap^^iav Kat ve(f)povg (og ©eog, ovTog

a(f)iyjat Kai afxapTtav ug ©eog.

KE*. lA.

Ilept Tov Aevi.

27 Kai fiera ravra e^rjXOe^ kcu eOedcraTO TeXcovrjv, 6v6- 20

jxaTL \evLv.

ToT ATTOT. TeAwvTjf ^v Aet;)^, avyjp aitXyiaTog etg (f)t\o-

Keptiav, ayaktvog eig irXeove^iav, twv ov^ev TrpoayjKOVTCov avTw


a^iKog epaaTYjg' tovto yap To7g TeXwvatg to eTrtTyjOevfi.a' aXX cg

avTuv yjpTid^eTO twv T^f d^tKiag epyaaTY/ptwv, Kat aeacoaTat itapa- 25

"bo^ctig, KeKXvjKOTog avTOv tqv irdvTCtiv Yjfj.(hv ^coT^pog yiptaTov' e(py)

yap aiiTW, " dKQXov6ei ff.ot."^ 6 ^e irdvTa d(f)eig yjKoXovdvjaev avTW.

'Opdg cog dXYjQevei Xeycov ao^coTaTog JJavXog, " oti ^ptaTog


" YiXBev elg tov KoafLov, dff.apTCoXovg aaaati'^ opag cog aapKco6etg

fxovoyevYig tov ©eov Aoyog to, aKevyj tov hafSoXov fxeTeaTi^aev €ig 30

^ Xevia-ov Cod.
5

V. 37. AOTKAN ETArrEAlOT. 47

kavTOV ; kou a-effuaTat [xh 6 Aevi *', vj[Ji7v le to Trpayfxa '^prja-Ta^

evoiifjae Tot? (Xfrita^' oti yap aoo^ei to fxcTavoe^v, e^ avTov tov

yeyovoTog '^e^i^dyixeSa' inaTevaeTai ^e avTog 6 twv okm oeaiio-

T^g Seog hia (pwvyji Trpocpi^Tov Xeycov^, " e-^iaTpdcprjTe Trpog fJie

" Kai aieB-fjaeaQe, oi dit eayjxTov tyj^ yYjs. AAA. eiai Tive$ oi 5

T^f Belai yaXi^voTYjTOi eTiiyeipovvreg anoaTepeh Tovg Ta7g dfiap-


riaig eveikv]ft.iJ.evovg' ov ydp iiapo^e^yovTai fj.eTdvoiav, aX\ olov

e-TnTifMoai rSi awi^ovrif ^tjtovvti ra eavrov Kai vavTayoQev av\-


Xeyovri ro eaKopTTiafuevov, Kai ovk aKovovai Ae^y&VTOj' rov ^cor-ijpogf

**
ov yjieiav eyovaiv oi vyiaivovreg larpov, aXX oi KaKag e^/pvreg. lo

" oiiK rjXOov Kakeaai ^iKaiovg, d\\d du.apT(i)\ovg eig f/.eTavoiav."

ToT ATTOT. 'O ydp rSiv oXoov ScoT^p, dre ^y] larpog vndpyjnv

TTvevfJidruv, ovk dmtpotra roov '^eoft.evxv avrov, Kdi oog ^taaft.r)l^ai


^vvdf/.evog To7g ovttw K€Ka6apfi.evotg oiKovou.tKxg avvvjvXt^ero' toio-

fj.ev Se, w ^aptaaHe, rov aov (ppovrjft.arog tijv drpoTitav, oirotaov 1

aot yeyovev atTtafi.dTcov irpo^evog vj Kard rav ev dfjLapriatg otppvg'

avTOv Kd(3(6fJ.ev e^i^yi^rrjv, rov itdvra eltora ^ptarov. K(j)yj yap


ovrct)' " dvQpwTTOt ^vo dvel3vjaav etg ro tepov Tipoaev^aaBai, eig

" ^apiaalog, Kat eTepog reXoovYjg' aXX' 6 fiev ^aptaahg arag


" TtpoaYivyero keyxv, 'O Seog, evyapiaroo aot," Kat rd e^^g. 20

Ylept Se rov elireXv rov KvayyeXtarYiv ev aaj3pdr:a ^evrepo-

Trpwrw, ayiog 'lai^^apog Yli^XovatcorYjg ovroo keyet, " ort oev-

" repdirpwrov e'tpYjrat, eTrei'^^ '^evrepov fi.ev yjv tov Yldaya, irpaTov
**
^e Twv d^vf/.cov." Kt ^e ad(3j3aTov etpYjrat, fi.Y} Bavf^daYjg, ad^-
fiarovydp itdaav eopryjv KaXovai, Kat ^ta rovro eipyfrai ad(3l3aTa^S
aa^^drcov.
Ktpiaaot 'Aaekanapeias. Tavra Tteitpaycog Aa^i'^ itapd
ye ro to5 vo/aco toKovv, rov itavrog itap vfxh d^tovrat Bavf^arog,
opBwg Kat ^tKatcoi' Kat ydp ^v d\y]Bcog ayiog Kat itpoipYjTiqg'

**
oiiKovv rov tta y[covaeag vofj.ov (pdaKovrog evapycog, KpifiMS'^
** '* Kptaet, itag
^tKatov Kptvere^^ KOi ov k-^xpYj itpoacoTiov ev

rovg efJ.ovg KaraKptvere f/.aBi^rdg ; Kat eig hevpo Bavfj.d1^ovreg

c Xewo-aj Cod. ^ eXeyev Cocl.


48 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA VI. 9.

wf ayiov Kai w^o0o^t>jv tov [xaitdpiov Aavih' Kairoi Tr]v M.avaew$


evroXvjv ov TeTyjpi^KaTe.

TiTOT EnisKonoT BosTPCN. Qv^eii KaXeTrai vloi dvSpoiTToVf

d\X Irjaovg fAOvov eavTOv ovtoo KaXeH' enei^v} Tio^ m Qeovy

napa^o^coi KaTtfj^iaaev vio$ dvBp'jynov ^i dvQpairovg KkrjQvjvai' 5


eavTOv ovv Kai Kvpiov tov aa/^^aTOVf wf ^i^fxtovpyov Kai Troiyjrvjv

Kat vofxoOeTrjv tov aa/S/SaTou eKaXeaev.

KE4>. lE.

Tlepi Tov ^Tjpav exovTos t^v X"P°'

9 ^KTTepcoTT^aco vfids tl e^eaTi tols crd^^axTLv, dyaOo- lo

TTOLTJcraL ^ KaKOTTOLrjaaL ;

TiTOT EnisKonoT BosTPON. YiOcfxaTaTq ktav vj iievais, Ttpe-

TTOvaa TaHi eKetvm d^eXTfiptatg v) TTpoTaaii' el fxev yap e^eartv


dyaOoTtotelv ev aa^^aTdi Kat to kccXvov ov^ev ekeetaOai iiapa

%eov Tovg KdfUovTai, iravaai avKXeym Tocf Kara 'KpiaTOv \S

avKocpavTiaSf Taf d(f>opfi.as, Kat t^ aavTov Ke^aXyj KaTa^^m


t\v ^tKVjv, ^v hrYipTyjaev FlaT^p To7g dTtfud^ovat tov ^li/jaovv'

rjKOvaag XeyovTog irepi avTov '^ta (pm^g Toy Aa^t'^, " Kat
" avyKQxpci} Tovg e^xPpovg avrov ano Ttpoaitniov avTOv, Kai Tovg
" fj.taovvTag avTOv T^OTrctJco/xev.'* E/ ^e ovk 'e^eariv ev iroteiv 20

ev aaPfSdTO), KeKcoXvKev vof/iog aa^eaGat il^v^^v* yeyove tov

vofxoBeTov KaT-^yopog, dtaPe^XvjKev evToXyjv, €(f>


y} Kai TeOav-
ff.aaTat vj ^ta M-coiJaeag ^taKovia. dXX^ oii'^ eavTco, (pvjatv, rm
oXm Qeog tov eirt tw aajS/SdTa) reBetKe vofLoV vjfniv ^e fLaXXov

To7g VTreyovatv avToi tov avyeva' KaXwg ecp^^g eiratvm Tovg 25


Xoyovg' ovkovv avdyKVjg Kat voff.ov to Oehv eXevOepov Ttcog ovv

atTta Kat ev aa(3(3dTW ^piarov eXee7v eOeXovra Kat evepyerovvTa

i^yj^o^v ; OTav Se Kat tov eTti tco aa(3j3dTCi) reQetKe vofioVf ttoXv-

Ttpayft.oveh fi.eXXofi.ev, eXevjf(.oavv)^g eveKa itapa Qeov dicopiaff.evov

evpvjacofi.€v. 'EKeXevae yap dpyeXv ev a-ayS/JaTCU, Kai fi.v]^€vog 3^


To avfJiTtav avtreaBat itovov, dvteaQat te f/.aXXov Kat avTo^tg of/.ov
VI. 20. AOYKAN EYArrEATOY. 49

Tor? aXoyotg tZv ^cowv. Ecftv} yap, " iva avoTravtryjTat o italg cov

Kat yj irat^^iaKf} aov, 6 ^ovi (tov Kai to imo^vytov <rou Kat vav

KT^voi a-ov** 6 §€ /Souv fXeSv, Kat toc €T€pa twv /fT»jvc5i

KE^. ir.

Hepi Tjjs T©i> 'ATTooToXajv tKkoyrjs. 5

12 E<7rwv Eua-yyeXtaT*;? " ot/ eyeveTO ev TotJV yjfJ^po-i? TavTai^,

" f^^XOev I^o-ov? •Trpoa-ev^aaBat etg to opog^^ Kat to. e^^f.

E^e/^e S/a tovtov^ KaSai 6 aytoq KvpiXXof (pyjatVf OTt izaana

vpos oiKo^ofjJi]v ^fjL€TepaVf Kat eU ovi^atv twv TTtaTevovTm etg

avTOv €ipya^€TO o Xp/crro?, Kat Trveu/xaT/AciJ? TroXtTeiag Tpoirovio

Ttva TO Ka^ eavTOv avaQei?^ aXvjQivvjV vjfleAev aTto^aivetv vpoa-

KvvriTtKYiVy Kat OTt Ta? Trpog Seov iK€Teiag kaSpa Kat KeKpv[Jifi.evat;,

Kat ov^evog opavTog irpoarjKet iroteTv. Tovto yap ^viXoi to etg opoi

Koxa fjiovai Kai ag ev crj^oX'^ irpoaevyeaQat tov K.vpiov rjfjJav

yyiaow, KaBwg Kai ed/da^ev ^jtxa^, e;7rcDV, ' av de, otov Trpoaevyr], \
^
" eiaeXBe etg to Tafj.teHov aov^^ Kat Ta e^^f. Ka< yap acpiXo-

ho^cci Kat oaiovg eiraipovTag ye^ipag irpoaevyeaSat ^ei, (aaitep eig to

T^f BevoTtag v\\>og omoTryi^SovTog tov vov, Kai airocpoiTZvTog (xev

Qopv^ov TtavTog, aTtoTpeyovTog te Ka) fji.epifj.vyig Koafj.iiaig. Se? Sc

toSto ^^av, ovK a^tKOpag Kai o^pavyj eyovTag oXtyo4>vyiav, eirrO' 20


vcof Sc fnaXXov koi ev airov^^, Kat ovk aBavfLaaTOV eyovrag t>jv

vTrofMinjv, Kai ev ^evTepo) Tag ev yepatv epyaatag TtB€ft.evovg,

' AKy]KoafJi.€V yap, OTt ov yaXeitoig yivyeTO 6 \ptaTog, aXk ori

^tevvKTcpeve tovto ^pav. Uept TVjg tZv AitoaToXm eKXoyyjg, Kat


Ttepi TcSv fJMKaptafj.m 7tpoeypa(f>y] eig to Kara MaTSalbv. 25

KE4>. IZ.
Ilepi tS>v ixaKapi(TfiS)P.

20 Ylpoaitocfyfivag itavTog aya6ov t^v ^ta ©eoD 7rTcw^e<av ytvo-

fj.€vy}v, Ka) TO Tteiv^v Kat KXatetv ovk a[J.ta6ov eaeaBai TO^ig aytoig

einwv, fxeQiaTyjat tov Xoyov eirt Ta evavTtoog eypvTa Tovrotg, <f>yjai 30


H
60 EPMHNEIA TOY KATA VI. 20.

yap, " ovai vfuv to/V TrXovaioi^, ort «irej^eTe ttjv TrapaKXvjcriv v/awv,

" ovou 01 €fJt.'7r€7rXv}(rfx.€V0t ort Tt€tvac€T€. ovai vfji.iv 01 "yeAwvTef vuv,

" OTt it€vQyi<T€T€ Kot KXava€T€' ovai OTav KaXcog vfxa^ €i7rcoat 7ravT€$

01 av9/?w7roi*" ^€iKvvai ^e TavTa KoXaa-ecc^; ovTa Kai Iik-:^s ^fXTroiyj-

TtKcCf Iva Tw <f)ol3a T^f €7rYipTi^fX€VVjs KoXaa-€wg (p^vycoat fX€V toS

irXovTcTv, Kou to ev Tpv(f)a7g €lvat Kai -yeAwT/, TouTecTT/v, ev T€p\p€cri

KOCTfJLtKaTg, t^ ^e twv (TT€<pava3V €7riQvfx.ia, cov KXyjpovofxoi y€vrj<70VTai

ot fji.aKapt<jB€VT€g, (jayYiV€vovTat irpog Tovg irovovg, Kai t>;v 'hia 0eov

aip€7a6at 7rTCiy)(€iav (xirovhaa-coat. Ka/ yap Tovg fit.€v KXi^povofxovg

eacaBai T^f t«v ovpavcav ^aatX^tag (f)y}<7i' Tovg Se eorj^aTa/f Trcpt- 10

•7r€T€7a6at avfji.(l>opa7g'
" oenl-^^Te yap, (f>ij<7i,
" t>jv TrapaKXvjatv.

*' Kai Tovg viro


vfJicov." Acyet ^e Ka) tvjv ofxolav Tifx,<opiav virofJ.^^vai

vavTuv avBpcoTroov €7ratv€ia6at 6€XovTag.

ToT ArioT KTpiAAor 'Aaesanapeias. Wig KaivoTvjTa ^coi^g

ivayycXtKyjg, fJi.€Ta tvjv y€tpoToviav KaTapvBfjn^cov Tovg eavTOvJS


fJiadvjTag 6 ^ccTvjp, TavTa (f^vjat' Tr^pi ttohov ^e apa TrTCoyjcv Tairra

X€y€i avayKctiov /&erv. Ev jm,6V y\p to5 KaTa MaT^arov ff.aKapiovg

€a€a6at (ffvjat Tovg irTCoyovg tc3 Trv€vfj.aTt, Kai avTwv €ivat t»/v

l3aatX€iav twv ovpavcov, tva vow^ev '^TCoyovg tco iiv€Vfj.aTi, tov

fj.€TptO(f>pova Kou avv€aTaXfX€vov caair^p ^yovra vovv' (x^to^^^XcoTOg 20

^e to^oDtos" Kat ©eco yvQ}pifj.og' Ka) yovv e^iy ^t cvog tcSv aytcov

vpofpvjTcov, " Kat €7rt Ttva l3X€\pco, <xXX vj hirt TaTretvov Kat vjav-

" 5^/ov KOti Tp€fj.ovTa fJLOv Tovg Xoyovg ;" E(f)vi ^e Kat 7rpo(f>-^Tvig

Aal3i^, " OTt Kap^^iav avvT€Tpift.fj.€vv}v Kat T6Ta7re;vco^ev>jv

" 060$- ovK e^ov^evcocre/." Kat fxcv avTOg 6 ^coTvjp, " fj.a6€T€ air 25
'
e/xov, (f>v]atv, " ot; Trpavg €tfj.i Kat Tavriivog tv} Kapbta ev fie

To^f 7rpoK€tfj.€votg vjfxtv avayvcaafj.aat fJ.aKaptovg ka^aBat (pvjat Tovg

TiTCoyovg, ov 7rpoaK€ifJ.€vovg tw irv€vfj.aTt, ovk aXXvjXotg havTtov-

[X€VOt, aXXa fX€pt^ofX€VOi iroXXaKtg Ta ^tvjy^fxuTa, Kat TOTe fX€V

^ta Twv avTav l3a^i^ovat K€(f>aXatcov, TroTe ^e tw kvi 7rapaX€i(f>6€V, S^


€T€pog Taig t^taig €VTi6viat avyypa(f>a7g, iva fxvj^ev tcov avayKaicov

€ig ov^atv Xa6€iv ^vvv]6^ Tovg TrtarevovTag €ig JiptaTQv, ¥ioiK€

Toivvv irTCoyovg ovofxat,€tv ev TOVTOtg Tovg a(f>tXo7TXovTOvg Ka\


<ptXoK€p^iag KpetTTOvag Kat tov Tpovov eypvTag a(f>tXapyvpov' kou
VI. 27- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOY. 51

"yc ouv 6 ao(f>WTaTOi Tlavkoi apKrrcov ^fxTv fJiaQ^iJ.dTVV €i<T-r]yrpr7}<;

av€^€iKVVTO XiyaVf " d(pi?Jipyvpos o Tpoiro^f dpKovfxcvoi toT$ irap-


** *' xat
oucr/." Trpo<T€Ti6ei §e TovToii, oti fj^ovTCf liaTpo<f>ai
** K^ei to
aK€Ttd(TfxaTa^ TOVTOig dpK€a6v]ao[Ji.€6a/^ yap^ €^€i

craTYjpiov Kai evayyeXiKOv jaeAAovra? avTOvg ^iayyeWeiv KrjpvyfJM^

Tots ditavTayo<J€., dcpikoTrXovTov €y(€tv to (ppovrjfxaf Kai eucj^oXov

eai Toc Kp€iTTQ} Tr]v €7ri6v[xiav. Ov TrdvTwv ^e twv ev evTropia

ovTwv koyog Ka6dnT€T0iif {xovav ^e €K€tv<ov Ttcv irepi to. j^^juaTa


tov •Troflov K€KTr][X€va}v. Tiv€g Se €iaiv ovTot ; oi fxev t^s tov
Kvpiov (pavrjs dKovovT€i X€yov<Ti, " fvi^ 6v]aavpi^€T€ vfuv 6i^aav- 1 o
" povs €Wt Trji yyjif ovov <r^s Kai ^pwats d(f>avi^€i, Kat oirov

'*
KX€7rrat ^iopvaaov<Ti Kai KkeirTOvai' 6rjaavpi^€T€ Se vfxTv fxa\-
" Aov 6yjaavpovs ev ovpavw. Ottov yap €aTiv o 6r]aavpos <7ov,

" €K€i eaTat Kai i] Kapoia aov.

"Otl 8vpafxi9 irap avTOv e^rjp-^^ero, kou laro TravTa^. 15

ToT Anor Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias. Ov yap \ayyv e^avei-


^eTO T^v irap erepov A.piaTOSy aAA avTOs cov <pva€i tJeof, ei Kai

y€yov€ aap^, t^v €7r; Torj- Kdfxvovaiv eKTrlfXTrav ^vvafxiv laTO

irdvTas.

A/ ^i^aaKaXiai ai €(/>€|^f eypd(f)OVTo €is to KaTa ^aT^aTov, 20


€(os " Kai cylveTo to prjyfxa tvjs oiKias €K€ivy]g fxeya' ofxoKog Kai
irept Tov €KaTOVTdpyov 7rpo€ypd(f)r].

Aeyet ^e "KpvaoaTOfxos eis to KaTa MaT^arov, epfxi^vevccv Ta


irep) Tov eKaTovTdp^xov, tov avTOv etvat tov etg tov AovKav, tov ^c

eii Tov loidvvTjv €T€pov. 25


ToT APioT TiTOT BosTPON. OTav aKow^s tZv KvaryyeXtwv
XeyovTCov, fivj ^apYjO^g t>;v ^tdvotav, dXXa irpo^vfxy^^iqTi tv^v irpo-

atpeaiv' ov yap aTovos, ov^e Trpog to, evKoXa cvTovof* Oc irpo-

6vfxos Kou irpQs Ta ^^va^/epv] ^vvaTog, " Aa/SeTC," (f^f^ai, " tov
" ^vyov fxov, Kai /'^eTC oti eXa^ppov eaTt to (popTiov fxov" cav3o

yap oXcag avTOv l3aaTd^yjs, to ^okovv etvat aot ^apv, €vptaK€Tai


Kov(pOTaTov irpos tvjv ireTpav.

37 Ktpiaaot 'Aaesanapeias. ^AXri^evet Xeycav fxaKdpios Ylav-

Xos, OTi " €? Tts ev "KptaTco Kaiw] KTiats'^^ irdvTa yap yeyovev

€V avToo T€ Ka) h^ avTov Katvd' Kai ^ia6^Ki^ Kai vofxos Kai 7roA<-3S
H 2
5

figl EPMHNEIA TOT KATA VI. 31.

rei^. "AOpei Se oWf TrpeTrwSeo-TaTi} Xiav ecrri Tpr? dyiQis ixvaTa-

y^iqatg ^ Toid^e TroKneia Kai ^a^. efxeXkov to7s ditavTayo^je

y^g TO (T(aTyjpiov e^ayyeXXeiv K-^pvy[x(x, Kai vjv evTevSev Trpoa^oK^v,

OVK evaptOfji.-^TOvs e^recrQai tov$ ^iooKovTai avTovg, Kat TcoXvrpoTioog

tmjSovXevovTaf. dX\ el (xvve^fj rcuq ToiavTatg XvTtatg d^^^QecrOyi-

vat Tovg fuSYiTag, eha OeXetv dfxvveadat Tovg XeXvn7jK0Ta$, e(xi-

y-^aav dv, Kat 7rape^pa[xov avTOvg, ovKeTt to 6e7ov avTo7g irapaTi-

SevTeg Krjpvyixa, ov KaXovvTeg eig eTriyvcoatv dXyjQeiag. e^ei toivvv

Toig ovTQ} ae^TTTaig ave^iKaKiaig tov tSov dytm [xvaTay(6yov ava-

yatTtaai^ vovv, tva TrdvTa yevvaiatg (f>ep(i)at Ta aufx^aivovTa, Kav 10


vjSpi^diat Tiveg, Kav dvoaia>g eirtjSovXevcoat. IleTrpaj^e ^e tovto

Kat irpo ye tcov dXXcev avTog eig vTroTVTrojatv r^ixeTepav. eTt yap

dirvjpTtafxevog tov tijxiov aTavpov, KatTot Tvjg lov^aioiv TrXyjOvog

€TrtyeXaav]g avTfi Tag irpog ©eov Kat Ylarepa XtTag virep avTwv
hrote^TO Aeywv, *'
«^ef avTO<V, OTt ovk oi^^aai t/ Tiotovat" Na^ 15
ju,»/v Ka\ fxaKdptog "^Tecf^avog Kat TOt l3aXXo[xevog XtQoig, 6etg

Ta yovaTa Trpoavjv^aTO Xeyiov, " Kvpte, {xy) aT^arjg avTo7g tv]V

" dfxapTiav TavT>?v/' Ka; fxaKdpiog he UavXog, " evXoyov-


*'
[xevot evXoyovfxeVf 'tva^[xov[xevot 7rapaKaXov[xev. ovkovv avay-

Koia [xev 73 Totd^e irapaiveatg To7g dyioig AiroaToXotg, yjp^ff^^

c/jw.WTaT^ ^e Kat ri[x7v ai)To7g etg Te to y^y\vat ^tovv op6ag

Kcti TeGav[xaa[xev(Oi' [xeaTyj ydp eart Trdayig <f)tXoao(f)iag. ^vaKa-


TopQoiTov ^e awoTeAoycr^v avT^v Ta^f ^[xeTepatg tiavotatg TrpoXyj-

ipetg ovK dya6at, Kai tcov ev yi[x7v ovtcov ira^av yj ^vaKaTay(ovtaTog

Tvpavvtg. 25

31 Kat KaOods OeXere tva iroLcocnv vfuv, oi avOpcoTroi, kcu

VfJL€LS 7rOL€lT€ aVTOLS OfXOLCOS.

ToT ATTOT. AXX 7JV €tKog Tovg dyiovg AiroaToXovg oiyi6yivat

Tdyjx irov ^vaKaTopScoTa eivou Ta etpy}[xeva' toivvv Ta TravTa


el^(bgj Tov Tyjg ev ^fx7v (ptXavTtag vo[xov '^ey^eTat jSpajSevTyjv, 30
wv dv ^ovXotTO Ttg irep CTepov Tuj^erv. rcvoy yap TotovTog,

(f)y]a)v, etg CTepovg avTog, oirotovg irep dv BeXrfg elvat Trept

ae' ei fxev aKXyjpovg Kat davfX7ra6e7g, 6paae7g Kai opytXovg,

" Cod. av«;{€T/(Ta*.


VI. 41- AOYKAN ETArrEAIOY. 53

U.V^CriKM(OVi KOl TtOVtipOVif i<TQ KOU MITOi TOlOVTOi' ^l 0€ TOV-

voarrlov, 5^>j(TT0Vf Kcu afMn^a-iKaKovi, fx)] oupoprjTov rjyov roi-

ovTOV eivai ce* Kat Tay^a iiov ^6?? ovto) haKetfJieyoii TiepiTTOg o

voiAOSs eyypoi(f>ovTos Qeov Ta7^ Kap^taii vjfjucv tyjv tov i^iov SeX"^

fAaTos yvaaiV " 'Ev yap Ta7g vjfxepats eKetvaig" (pri^Jt, " \eyei 5
*' ^iSov? vofkovg elg t»?v ^tdvoiav aiiTav, Kat eitt
Kvpios, fj.ov

" T^v KapYtav avTwv eTriypdxpa) avTovg^

ToT ATTOT. ApttJTOV Kai TOVTO XP^f^°'' '^^' ^^? 6vft.ape<7TaT0Vf

Kou oaiais xpv^^aTs tovto fxdXtcxTa TrpeitoV OTt ^e TrXovatccTepa

yeipt \y]xp0f/.e6a tvjv avTeKTiatv •napa tov ndvTa Tikova ta>g vefJ.ov- lo

TOf Qeov ToiV dyanw<7tv avrov, avTog irewXi^po(f)opy)KeVj etTruv,

*'
OTi fueTpov KoXov TremeafxevoVf vTiepeKyyvofi.evov ^wacoatv etg

" Tov Kokttov ^jU-alv."

41 Tt 5e /SAeTretS" to Kap(f)09 to iv r^ 6(f)da\fiS tov

d8€X(j)ov (Tov ; 15

ToT ATTOT. riav yaXeTTOV airoKetpet vd9og tZv y]fx.eTep<av

^tavotav, VTiepoiptag apy^vjv Kai yeveatv. Kat Tot yap ^eov Ttvai

eavTovg KaraaKeTTTeaQai Kat KaTa Seov TroXtTeveaQat' tovto fuev

ov ^paat, nokvTrpayfxovovai Se to. erepooVf Kav daQevovvrai idcoat

Ttva$, ccaTtep et$ Xi^drjv epyofxevot toSv t^^tm app<i}aTVjfi.dTiov, (f)t\o- 20

xpoytag vitoQeatv itotovvTat to yj)-fjfj.a, Kat KaTaXaKiag a(f)opfJi.v]V'

KaTarpv](f)t^ovTat yap avTcov, ovk ei^OTes OTt Ta taa voaovvTes


To7i TTap avTcav ^taf^ejSkvjf/ievotg eavTOvg KaraKptvovaiv' ovtco

vov Kat 6 aw(f>a}TaTo$ ypd(pet Uavkos' " ev « yap Kptvetg tov


" erepov, eavTov KaTaKptveig' t» yap avTa irpdTTetg Kpivcov.' 25
KatTot fJMkkov eyjpvp aaBevovvrag ekeeh ag ralg rm TraBwv

€<f)0^otg vTrearpwfi.evovg, Kat To7g Tvjg dfxapriag jSpoyotg d(f)VKTWs

eveihfifjLfji.evovg, Kat vTrepevyeaSat tmv TotovTcov, Kat irapaKaXeiv

avTovg Kai ^teyetpetv eig v^tv, kou iretpdaBai ff.v] Torg" taotg

ireptveaeTv aiTtdfiMatV " yap Kpivcov tov a^eA^ov," KaSd (f>v]atv^o


6 Tov HptaTOv fJi.a6v]TV]g, " KaTaXaXei vofuov Kat Kptvet vofji.ovJ'^

etg eartv voft.oQeriffg kou Kptr^g, avca yap ^ei T^f dfxapTa-
vovavjg (pvaecog eivat tov Tavrvjg KptTVfv' av ^e fJkVf Totovrog oov, ri
Kpiveig Tov TrXvjatov ; d-noXoyvfaeTat t^ KptTvj dfxaprdvcav. ei ^e
54 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA VI. 41.

ToKfJLai KaraKpivuv, Kai toi tovtov [x.y] ey^jav tv}v e^ovaiav, KaTa-

KpiQrjCfi fjt.aXkov avTog, ag ovk ecSvTOf tov vo[ji.QV to Kptveiv eTcpovg.

Tor ATTOT. 'E^ avayKaiav ^[xas avaTreiOei Xoyia^fJLiav aiio-

cyeaQai jOtev tov Pov\ea6ai Kpiveiv eTepovg' t^v eavTwv te [xaXkov

Kap^iav 7repiepyd^ea6ai, Kai twv evovTav avTa^ig iraSav aTraXXaT-S

TeaSai ^vjTeTv, alpovvTag tovto itapa %eov, AvTog ydp ecTtv


iw[j.evog Toi/g avvTeTpi[j.[j.evovg Tri Kap^ia, Kai xpv^^^tKcov •^[nag

vo(Jifi[xdT(tiv eXevOepwv. T/ ya^, et voaS>v avTog Ta cti [t,et^(0

Kai "/aXeitfaTepa t£v ovtwv cv eTepotg dcpetg Ta KaTa aeavTOV,


eKeivoig eittTt^xag', ovkovv aitaai jotev Tolg eOeXovatv evaejSag dvay- 10

Kaia eig ovyjatv vj evToX>;, [xdktaTa te Tolg to ^i^^daKetv eTepovg


eyKeyeipta[ii.evotg' et p,ev yap eiev ayaQoi Kat vi^<j)d\tot, KaQ(xnep

etKOg, ^ctii^g evayovg Ta Kad eavTOvg avaaTTjaovTeg To7g [jlvj toc taa
tpav eXo[j.evotg, evTrpoawirctig e'7rtTi[i.'^a(tiatv, OTt [/.yj Tovg TYjg evovarjg

avToig eTTtetKeiag dve[i.d^avTo TpoTtovg. E< ^e pdBv[j.ot Ttveg eiev 'S

Kai Ta7g etg to (pavAov vj^ovaig evdX(tiTOt, Trag av eTepotg to. 'iaa

voaovatv eTrtTt[J.Yjaeiav ;

OpirENOTS. Aev^pov dya6ov to TIvev[i.a to 'Aytov, ^ev^^pov

Trov/ipov ^id(3oXog Kat 01 tovtov vnYipeTat. ey((tiv to Ylvev[j.a to

Ay tov^ Tovg tovtov Kapirovg eii^eiKVVTatf ovg d'7rapt6[t.e7Tat 020


dnoaToXog TlavXog. 6 ^e ^vva[i.tv dvTtKet^nevvjv ej^ctjv, T^g dTt[/.iag

Ta irdSYi aKav6ag Kat Tpt{3oXovg dvaTeXXeTat.


TiTOT BosTPON. Aia(f>vy(ti[i.ev tyjv <f)6opav t^^ d[xapTtag, Kat
**
OTav XeyYj 6 Sct)T>?p Kat Kvpiog iJ/acSv, ovk eaTi Mv^pov dyaSov
*'
'TTOtovv Kapirov aairpov^^ [kyj Xd^Y^g avyyv(ti[j.Yiv eavT(a TYjg pa6v- 25

[niag' TO [i.ev yap Mv^pov (f)vaet KtveiTai, av ^e irpoatpeaet TroXt-

TeiiYi' Kat Trdv 'bev^pov [).v] (f>epov Kapirov, etg dXXyjv '^(jpetav KaTe-
aKevda6Y], av ^e etg epyaatav dpeT^g dve^^eiyPYjg.

Miy Ttg Totvvv aipeTtKYjv dKOYjv irapeta^epctiv KaKag voetTO)

TavTa. Kt yap (f)vaet KaKog Tvy^^dvetg, t/ [J.av6dvetg ; elg T/30


tt^^daKYj ; TO yap (f>vaet ov d[xeTdl3Xi^Tov irpdy^j.a' ei ^e yj [xeTa-

(3oXy] '^t^^daKet Kat Xoyog evTpeTret Ka) yj irapaiveatg [xeTarroteT,

Kai Yj ^i^aaKaXia [xeTa^dXXet tyjv ^tdvotav, yj [j.ev VTroy\>ta TYjg

avdyKY\g CK^dXXeTat, to ^e ^oy^xa TYjg irpoatpeaecog o[J.oXoye7Tai.

Ata TOVTO Kat KXYjatg, '^ta tovto Ka\ tt^^aaKaXia, ^<a toutoSS
VII. 2. AOYKAN ETArrEAIOY. 55

Kal "KptaTOS Trapeyevero. E/ yap ^v afxeTaPXvjTa <f>va€i tu


irpayfJiaTa, /aar^v TavTa eyiv€TO' vvv §e opa [xoi t>jv |U,eTajSoA>;v,

Kai voet [Mt TV}v TrpoaipecrtV ov^eig aiTtaTai Ta aXoya ^aa <f)vaet

Ktvovfxeva, aXKa tov<; Ttpo^ t^v OfxoiOTpoTrtav tc5v aXoym avT e^ov-

ctag eKKXivovTag avQpanovg. 5


'Eh ANEnirPA*oT. IloAAa Ta TrpoTtoXeiLovvTa, Kai Trpog iroK-

Xovg aywv avQpairotg ^aiiMovai, TraSy] ^vx^^i oSi/va? awfxaTav


Kai 6Xi\p€t$ "TrpayfxaTiov. ttA^v ei TavTa e-jreXSvj, (Se^atovat tov ev

To7s Tov Kvpiov TrapayyeXfkaat 'hta T^f Ka^ €Ka(XTV]v vjfxepav

aaK^aewiy tva fxvj KaOdvep /Staicov v^aTav efi^oXy) irpoeXSovaa, \ o


caBpa To. ev vjfMV ^oyfiaTa '^taaKe^daei, dXX ev ev^oKif/.-^aet ToTi

evavTtovfA.evotg irpdyfxactv aKaTdXvTos ovaa vj apeTvj, Kai fxv} r»


TrToofxaTt Treptcf^aveig dXXa Tvj vikvj yevccfxeSa' TrepKpaves yap Kat

To irrwfxa twv fxeydXa 'te^ttayfxevav, OTav fxeydXm airoirtTrTaat.

Yieptcftavvig ^e Ka) vj to^a Tav ev "aiaTet ^e^atuv, OTt eirt fxeyd- 15

Ae/f aT^pi^ovTai.

KE^. IH.

Uepi Tov 'EKaTOvrdpxov.

I 'ETTCt de hrXrjpuHTe iravTa tcl prjfiara avrov els ra?


iaKoa? Tov Xaov, elarjXOev ely KaTrepvaovfJL. 'E/caroi/-

rdp^ov de tlvos hovXos KaKws e^cov efieXXe TeXevrdu. 20

Av-^p Ttg e^TreiKVjg Kat Ty twv vjQm ypvjaTOTi^Tt '^taTrpeTrm, Kai

aTpaTtcoTwv vjyovfxevog ToTg oiKovat tvjv J^airapvaovfx, avveaTiog

^V TovTov avve/Si^ Ttva twv ywjatcov otKerwv dppccaTia ireptTreaeTv^

Kat cag ev eayaTatg opaaQai Xotirov eKirvoaTg. Kai vjKovae, <f>vjaiy

Ta irept tov l-^aov' eha irefxiret irpog avTOv, ccg irapa Qeov 25

'^viXovort Ta virep dvSpamov <pvatv tc Kat "^vvafxtv e^atTm' vj^tov

yap Twv T6U OavdTOv ^eafxwv aTraXXdTTeaQat tov eayaTV] voaa>

KaTeiXvjfXfxemv.

AvjXciiaavTog ^e tov KvayyeXiaTov irept twv direaTaXfxevccv irpog

TOV Kvp/ov v3ro Tou eKOTOVTdpyov, ovk apyag Kat ccg CTi^e X/"?3o
aKOTreTv vjfxag Kat ev TovTca tv]v tov K.vpiov SavfxaTOvpyiav, eXey-

5^ovTOf T^ T»v lov^atcav dyvcofxoavwjv, ^ta t«v 'Iov§a/a>v auTwv


56 EPMHNETA TOT KATA VII. 2.

Xiym " TrapayevOjU-evo/" ya.p, 4*^<ti, " Trpo^ tov Iiyo-ovv, iiapfKa-
" Xovv avTOV (TTrQv^^amg Xeyovre^, ori a^iog e(7Tiv, w Trapc^ei

" TovTco. ' o/ yap t^v €/V afTOV TricrTiv "Trapairovfi.evoi irapeKaXow

avrov ev^^eiKVvaSai Tolq maT€vov<Tiv eQviKo7;, oti Qeo^ eaTiv a\rj~


Oa^. Ttvog yap eaTtv aXkov to pveaOat Ik BavaTov ; oQev eiKOTwg 5

e^dxyd^aav joiev ovtoi ot ayvifxoveg' ei eKX-^Qvj ^e Kat TtpoaeteyPri

Ta e6vv), eTOtfXOTepav eayriKOTa t^v Kaptiav elg to 7rta-T€vetv eirt

Tov KvptoV Kav To, [xaXtaTa TtpoTepov yjaav ev dixapTtati iroXXaTg,


*'
^ia Tvjv Tov Seov dyvcoaiav, KaTa ro eirXvjSvvBvjaav at aaSevetai

" avT(5v," Ka) To, e^^f. UdXtv tt/v eTOtfmatav t^s Kap%tagio
avTwv irpoaeaye to ovaaov^.

KE*. 10.

Jlepi Tov viov t^s Xrjpas.

Tivog eveKev [x.eTa to IdaaaBai tov '^ovXov tov eKarovTdpyov,

fxv] KaXovfxevog viro tivo^; eirt veKpov dvdaraatv iropeveTat o irdvTaiS


f/Swf, Kat ^coT^i Kat Bavdrov t^v e^ovo-iav dveywv, " Kai*^ ydp
^atv, " eiropeveTo eU TroXtv KaXovfxevrjv Na)v," koi to, e|^?*

evy txTrXois dXX olKovofxiKWTaTa tpav, tva fM] Xeyaai rtveg oti

ov 'TravTeXug efueXXe TeXevTav o tov eKaTOVTdpyov iraHg' Kav ei

TovTO yeypa(p€v o FivayyeXiaTvjg, to, Trpog ydptv fKoXXov fi to. 20


irpog dXviOetav a(f)Vjyovfi.€Vog, ^ovXofxevog Tvpt aKoXaaTOV rZv
Toiovrav diro(ppdJ^at yXarrav. Ata rovro vir-^vrviae \ptaTOg 6

©eof vjftMV Tw eKKCf/.i^of/i.evu) reQvecort, Kai TrpoaeXGm 7ji|/aT0 r^g


<7opov, Kat rov veaviaKov avtarvjatv 6 Travro^vvafJiog Xoy(a re Kat

dcf^yj. Ata rt §c ov Xoy(a fLovo) eTrXvjpov ro Bavfm, dXXa Kai 25

^yparo rvjg aopov ; iva fii.d6cofn.ev ori ro a^afxa HLpiarov rov ©eou
o^/xwv, aSifxa ^aivjg ec-rt, Kat crap^ rov irdvra layvovrog Aoyov.

^EtTrei^^ yap i^ta yeyove rov Xoyov vj aap^ rov irdvra ^myovovv-
Tog, ^ia rovro ^(aoirotog eart Kai avrvj, Kat Bavdrov Kxi (pBopag

dvatperiKVj. 30
" AveKdBtae'^ yap, (f^vjatv, " 6 veKpog Kai ^p^aro XaXe^v" iva

fjiv] Kara <f)avTaaiav ^o^Y/ riatv eyi^epBat' Ka) yap dXvjBovg dva-
e Sic,
VII. 20. AOYKAN ETArrEAIOT. 57

cTTao-ew? viryjp^/fjv ravra <jy}[j.e.'ia' ay\'Xjypv yap aoiixa ovre dvaKa-


Oiaai ovre XaXrjaai "^vvarai' oOev " Kai e^ooKev avrov^^ 4*Wh '*Tyj

[Jt.y}rpi avrov.

i6 Kat iSo^a^ov tov Qeop Xeyovre^, Ori Trpotp^rrjf

/xeyas iyrjyepraL iv r/fXLV. 5


ToT ArioT Ktpiaaot ifVAEHANAPEiAs. Meya ^e rovro •napd

ye dvaiaO-^rx Kai dyapi<jr(a Xoyto^ [xiKpov yap varepov ov^e yap


irpo(f>-^ry]Vf ov^e elf dyaQov tgv Xaov TrecfiyjvoTa vo(xi^ov(Tiv avrovy

dXXa rov rov Oavdrov KaraXvryjv davdra) iiapa^i^oaaiVy ovK el-

^OTff ori rore ^^, tot€ Karekve Sdvarov, yjviKa e<f) eavrov t^vio
dvdcrraaiv eitoi^aaro.

Km. K.

Ilfpt rStv airocrrdKivTav irapa 'lcadvvij.

20 E7r€/^^ ^e ro irapo^o^ov rov OavfxaTOi eii <f>ol3ov yjyayev airav-

ra^ rovg rore Trapovrag^ ^ieXaX-^Svj re Kai ev oXyj ryj lov^aia, koi 15

ai/To5 ^e Tc5 dyico (SaTrTiaTyj diffffyeiXdv riveq rav fxaSi^Twv'


'^
•npoaKaXeadixevog ovv enefxxpev avrovg Ttpog rov K.vpioVf XeyaVy
" av ;^
ei epyofxevogf yj erepov irpoa^oK^fxev

Aia ri ^e aiirovg diieareiXey Trpoeypd^f^ero elg to Kara MaT-


** rav reKvxv ayT^f."
Baiov, ecyf Kai e^iKaiiodyj /] ao<f>ia diro 20
Ktpiaaot 'Aaeeanapeias. Ovk yjyvorjaev [xaKdpiog ^aiTTi-

aryjg rov evavSpamyjaavra rov TlaTpog Xoyov' ^iy rovro viroXd^Yig'

yj^ei yap Kai fxdka aa^paSf ori avrog eartv 6 epypfxevog' elpyd-
t^ero Se rt ao<pov Kai evfxyfyavov^ Kai OTtep y)v eiKog, ov fxerpiag

ovivyjai Tovg int avrov fxa6y]Tevofxevovg' 01 fxev yap ovn^a X-piaTOv 25

ei^oregy yjroi rvjv io^av avrov Kai t>;v KaTa ^ravTwv VTrepoyyjv,

Yfpefxa 7i(og Kai VTre^dKVovTOf Bavfxarovpyovvrog avrov, Kai raTg rav

^pcofxevav vnep^oXaHg viKavrog rov (SaTrriar^v.


Kai fxer oXiya' ri ovv apa fSovXerai voeiv epcorav Kat *'
Xeywv,
" av ei epypfxevogf yj erepov npoa^oKWfi.ev ;" e(f>av rotvvv ori ^AaT-30
T€Ta/ T>jv dyvoiav oiKovofxiK'2gf ovy^ iva fxdBoi fxaXXov avrog'

y^ei yap wg Ttpotpoixog ro fxvaryipioVf dXX iva TtXyipo^opyiBaaiv 01

avTov fxaBi^rat, oayj rtg eariv yj rov SwT^pof i/nepoyy], Kat ori
I
58 EPMHNEIA TOY KATA VII. 24.

T^f OveoTrvevffTOV ypacjyfjg Xoyo^, tov f/.ev ag ©eov Ka.i Kvpiov

jj^ovTa 'Trpof^efAyjVVKeV 01 ^e aXXoi 'iravTeg •^crav oiKeTai 'npoaice-

TaA/xevo/, teQTtOTOV eTOifxd^ovTeg t^v o^ov Kvpiov, Ka&a yeypa-

•TtTai' eKkyjSi^ toivvv ^ia twv irpocpifjTav 6 ep^x^Ofxevos, 6 twv oAwv

HiOTrip Kai Kvpiof. 5

ToT ATTOT. E/^Wf (O^ ©COf l^pKTTOg TVjV OlKOVOf/.taV ToD

irpdyfiaTOi Kai tyjs tcov lcodvvov fiaOvjTuv acf)i^ecog ttjv aiTiaVf

KaT eKeTvQ '^vj fkdXi(7Ta tov Kaipov TroXXaTrkacriag t«v ^^i^ yeyevvj-

fjievctiv elpyd^eTO 6eo(JVjfji.eiag' yeyovoTeg ovv apa T^g evovavjg avTcio

fKeyaXoTtpeireiag eitoTiTai Kai Beccpoif Kai tioKv to QavfLa TYjg evov- lo

(Tojf avTCti '^vvdfxectig Te Kai evepyeiag ev eavjotg (xvKke^avTeg,

"Tipoadyovcn t^v epctiTYjcnv ctig e^ lctidvvov XeyovTeg, ei avTog ecTTiv

ep')(OfJ,evog *, evTOvGd fxoi /3ke7re TYjg tov EcoT^po? oiKovofJiiag to

evTeyyeg' ov yap aTrXoog e(f)y] to ^ dX?C diiocffepei fi.aXkov avTOvg


eig Tvjv ^i avTCtiv tcov TtpayfKaTCtiV TrXyjpocpopiav, iv eva(f)opfJLCtig t^vi^
eig avTovg itiaTiv Ttapa^e^dfievot, vTtovodT-^acticri Ttpog tov aTtodTei-

XavTa avTovg' " 'TtopevdevTeg" yap, (pyjcri, " ditayyetKaTe lctidvv^,

" a i^eTe^ Kat yjKova-aTe' TV(f)Xoi dva(3Xe7tovai, yjjoXot Ttepnta-


" Toya/," Kai Ta e|%. TayTa iravTa 'itpoaityiyyeXKaatv cag eao-

fj,eva ^/ efj^ov KaTo. Kaipovg ol fj.aKdpioi 7tpo(piJTai. Ki ^e eych 20


yeyova tSov itdXai 7tpoetpyjfj.evctiv aTtoTeXeTvjg, Kai tovtcov avToi

yeyovaTe Becopot, fxaKdptog Totvvv og edv ft.y} aKav^^aXiaQ^ ev

efLot.

34 T/ e^eXrjXvOaTe els ttjv ep7j/xou OeaaaaOai ;

ToT AnoT TiTOT Bo2Tpi2N. No/x;^€Te OTi lcodvvi^g fneTa- 25


(pepeTai u^e KdKeT ctig vito 7tvevf/.dTCov aaXevofi.evog, coaTe ttotc

fj.ev ff.apTvpeh, oti avTog etfm 6 'KptaTOg' dXXoTe he epcoTciov, el

avTog eyco elfj.i ', oi^a a 7toteT' efJ.ov to ttvevfj.a, efi)fj yj ydptg, efj^

•yj eKeivov otKovofj.ia. Ti toivvv e^-^XdeTe eig t^v epyjfxov, t^v ju.»j§ev

e^^oucrav Tep7tvov; iv oog ^id tvjv eKeivov 6eav e^tevai 7tpo(f)aai-^o

^yja6e. A^Xov toivvv, ctig ^/ ov^ev eTepov KaTaXeixpavTeg Tag


TtoXeig T>jv epyifj.ov KaTeXd^eTe, et fiyj ctig dvTntoiovfj.evoi tov
dv^tpog Kat tov d^ictifJ.aTog. epcoTO. fj.e ovk dyvocov, dXX^ oi^a rt
TtoteT' ov ydp vvv fj.ev Oi^e, eTepca ^e dXXoTe fxeTa^aivet.
f Sic. g Sic.
VII. 31. AOTKAN EYArrEAIOT. 69

M^ (T/ijfxa tyfi TrepifSXeTrrov ; fjJy] (3a<xiXiK0V a^ici}fjt,a ; fxi^

Paa-tXtKOv e/j^ev evToA^v ; fi.y] ypafXfj.aTa Kat '^oyfmra Kat vofi.ovg

€Tr€(ftep€To ^actXtKovg ; fxrj avTtiroii^aofJi.tvoi rjv Kara to <f>atvo-

fji.€vov ; ov-^^^t TpiyjLvov ifxaTtov ecpopet ; ov-)(^i avTOfryi^iov eiye t»/v

Tpo<py]v ; /A^/ TotovTov vfMig TrpoeTpiiparo eKei aTieXdeiv ; 5


E/ wf €/f "Trpoipi^TYjV yjpyi<Tif/.a}g ain^AfleTf, Kat Xeyot vfjuv, Kat

irepttjaoTepov "TrpocpYiTOv' o fj.ev yap iTpo<p^Tif]g TipoKeyet, ovTog ^e

ov fxovov Yj^ovTa TrpofJ.efJ.yjvvKeVf aXXa Kat vTre^et^ev eiiribv, ** T^e o

afjivog Tov Qeov, 6 " atp<av tvjv afJMpTiav tov KOfTf/iov." AyyeXov
oe Tov l<i3<x.vw]v KaXeTy owj^ oti i^v AyyeXog, avSpaivog yap yjv t^v io
^v<TtVy aXX OTi ayyeXov epyov eiroteti ayyeXXcov rov 'KptaTov rrjv

irapovaiav' ovTog P<x7rTtaf/M eKYipv^e fj.eTavotag, tva TrpoXa^Y] y]

ft.eTavota tyjv a(f)eatv' avev yap fi.eTavoiag a(peatg ov ^t^oTat.

Es ANEnirpA*OT. Opa t^v aKpi/Seiav, f».et^<i}v ev yevvY]ToTg

yvvatKav Xeyet, tva e^eXi^ tyjv irapBevoV eyevvYjBY] fj.ev yap €k i^


yvvatKog, Kat KaTi^^iaae a<afj.a eK tov Y]f».eTepov <pvp<xfj.aTog Xa-
^eiv, tva TQ oXov ayiaaBr] ^ta TY]g air apyY]g. VevvYjToiv §e (f)Y]at

yvvaiKxv twv Kara (f>vatv TtKTOvam, iva i^^ta Orj t^v Trapa (f>vaiv

Trapdeviav.

Aaaos. Oiov fji.eya etyev ot^ia>fJi.a 6 ^Jcooiw^g koi (f>o^epog ^v 20


Tiyv evaTaaiVy Kat aefcvog t>jv oxptVf Kat aytog tyjv Trpoatpeaiv, Kai
aveirtXYjTrTog tov fSiov, Kat KaBapog ty]v ttavotav, Kat Trvevft.aTO-

(popog TY]v yaptv, Kat ^vvaTOg ev iraat, Kat €vyevY]g KaTo. irdvra.

tov yap ap5^;eoea?f vlog y]v, Kat (poPepog tw Xaw, <TvyKptv6fj.evog

te irpog Tovg y]^y] irpog Seov €i^r,fj.-fjaavTag, Kav fj.eyag eaT/v, aAA' 25

OfJMg eTt ev /3/ou avaaTpe<peTat, Kat ov^eirco aireXa^e ty]v Trpoato-

KCtifJievYjv eXni^a' 6 fniKpoTepog toivvv ev tyj ^aaiXeM tSov ovpavwv,

fj.et^<t3v avTov eaTtV ot^ oti Kat lioaw^g ovk airoX^^eTat, «AAa
avyKpivci}fi.ev to evTavQa a^i<ofj.a, eKeivy tyj Trpoa^oKCOfj.evY] yaptTi.

31 ^LVi ovv o/JLOico(rco T0V9 avOpayjTovs Trjs yeveoiy TOVTrjs 2,0

Kcu TLVL eicTLV ofJuoLOL ; ofiOLOL euTL iraL^LOL^ Tols iv ayopa.


KaOrjixevoLS.

ToT AnoT Ktpiaaot. YivtKa irov iratyviov Ttg TpoTrog irapa

Torf lovhauav trouatv ovrcog ey<ov, eig fiepYj ^vo nXYiBvg 'vat^icov
I 2
60 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA VII. 3

eT€[Jt.V€TO, a Koi TTjv Tov ^lov yeXZvTa Tvp(3vjVf Kai twv ev avToo

TT/ja^jaaTwv to dvaifxaXoVf Kcu t^v eTepco^ elg cTepa 0€ivv}v Kai

dBpoav fXfTa^oXvjV, to. fxev yjvXovVy to. ^e eOpyjVovv' aXX ovt€ To7g

avXovai Kai yaipovaiv 01 BprivovvT€? (tvvyj^ovto' ovre fxev Toig

KKaiovaiv 01 tov avXov cj^ovTff ayveTrAaTTOVTO* eh aXXvjXoi^ S

evcKaXovv Tpoitov to davixTraQe? rffovv o^idBeTov. toiovtov ti wewov-

Bevat Tov$ twv lov^aioov ^Yjfj.ovg ofxov TO?f irpoeaTfjKotnv iiyypi-

^€T0 "KpKTTO^.

KE^. KA.
Hfpl Trjs akeiyjrdiTrjS top Kvpiov fivpa. lO

36 'H/)£ora bi T19 avrov t(dv ^apiaaLcov, tva (j^ayr) /Lter

avTOv.

Kpyj yivoo(TKeiv oti ovTog ^apiaalog KeKXYjKcog tov Ki/^/ov

vj[j.Siv Koi ©eov 'ivjaovv KpicrTOV, ^oXepas viroKpiaecos ovk diTYiX-

XaKTo, ov^e TVjg efMcjxoXevovavjs diiiaTiag avTw, oQev €(f>v)f


" el v}V j^
'*
Trpo^p-^Tvjg,^^ Kai To. 'e^vjg, 'O ^e K.vpiog Kamep eltwg avTOv toiov-
*'
Tov ovTa, eiaeXQccv elg tov oIkov avTov KaT€KXt6vj, Kat <^oy,"

<f>v)atf
*'
yvvvj ^Ttg vjv ev t^ vtoXet dfJiapTaXog, einyvovaa oti KaTa-

KetTat €V TV) oiKta tov ^apiaaiov' Kai Ta e^vjg.

OiiK eaTi ^e avTV) ovt€ vj vtapa t<3 MaT^a/o!, ovt€ vj iiapa tco 20

Ma^Koo, ovTC VI Ttapa t» ^lwdvvvj fKWifxovevOfxevi^, dXX eTepa Ttg.

Karavowv toivvv eyco koi Kare^eTd^av eTiifj.eXoog tvjv tt^vjaiv Kai

twv evayyeXtKwv pVffxdTwv evaTevi^av tS> dKpt(3€i, TpeHg eivat Tag


yvva^Kag Xoyt^ofJi.at' Koi €K T^g twv Ttpoavmwv irotOTVjTog, Kat

e^ avTOv Toy Tpovrov TVjg Trpd^ecog, Kat €K T^g ^tacpopag tov 25

Katpov. 'O jU.ev yap ^lccdvvi^g irept T^g M.apiag TVjg d^eXtpvjg

Aa^dpov Kat Mdp6ag eTratvovfJi.evvjg acpo^pa Kat BeoaefBovg, Kai

ev Toig fk.a6viTtwaaig XeXoytafxevvjg tw ^Iv]aov tovto <f>v]atVf d>^€

voog ttviyovfJ.€Vog, " ovv, ^lvjaovg, vrpo e^ ^fJiepwv tov Yldaya


" YlX6€V €ig Bvj6aviaVf ovrov vjv Ad^apog, ov vjyetpev €K veKpm.^o
" 'EiTToivjaav ovv avTw €KeT ^erTrvov. 'H ^e Mdp6a ^tvjKOvet, 6

" Se Ad^apog elg ^v tcov avvavaKeifJLevtov avTf' vj ovv Mapta


VII. 36. AOTKAN EYArrEAIOT. 61

" Xa^oixra Xirpav [xvpov vdp^ov,*' Kai to. e^^f. yjXeixpe rovg

TTOOaf rov 'I^oroy* l^ov vpo ef ^fJiepSov rov Yldfy/a' Kara rrjv

OiKiav Mapiag Kat Aa^dpov Kai MdpOaf rovro yeyovevai cracf^fag

taroprjaev o EvayyeXia-r-^^' ag Kai dvwrepw ro avro lovro e^eT-

Ttev. " 'Hv &e Ma/j/a t, dXeixpaaa rov Kvpiov fJivpx Kat cKixd-S
" ^aaa,^^ Kat ra e^^f, **
^? o d^eX.(f>o$ Ad^apo^ ^a^ever" Kat /a^

6avfid(rvjg ei Kora Ttpoava(f)wvriaev eppeGfi' Kat yap vepi rov lov^a

(ftvjcrtv 'M.dpKo^; ra ovofxara rSov ip 'ATroaroXoov dirapiBfj.ovfJ.evO(;,

**
Kat \ovtag laKapixrrj^ bf Kat •nape^ooKev avrov.^^ Kairot ye
ov^eitca Ttapa^ovg ^v avrov, dXXd ro fx.eKXov, wf ^^17 yevofJievov 10

eypaxpev 6 M ye 'M.arOaTog eTtdyet Xeywv, " Kat eyevero ore


*'
ereAecrei' li^crovf •ndvra^; rovg Xoyov^ rovrovg, eiTre to<V fi-o.-

**
6ijTa<V auTOy, o^^aTe ort ft.erd tvo yjfLepai ro Ylda^^^a ytverat,"

Kat rd *'
e^yj^. Tov te 'I>j(7oi5 yevofj.evov ev ByjOavia ev oiKta
*'
S/jtxajvof Tou keTrpov, irpoayjXSev avrw 'yyvij eyov^a dxd^aarpov 15
*'
fxvpov iToXvrifj.ov, Kat Kareyeev eitt ryjg Ke(paX^( avrov dvaKet-
fj.evov. z^KOTtet ovv ori etpyjKoroi rov lyjaov, otbare ort
*'
fj.erd ^vo yjfj.epai ro Tidaya yiverai'" ovrco^ taropyjcrev avrov
KvayyeXtarrjg yevoft.evov Kard t>jv ayT>jv Byjdaviav ev ryj oiKta

Titfj.wvo^ rov Xevpov, Kat vito ryjg yvvaiKO$ rifnyjQevra rw fJLvpw, 20


fty} Twv TToSwv dXet^ofxevxv, dXX.d rov dXaPdarpov Kara^xeofxevov
ryjg Kecf^aXijs. ware Kat vito rov Icoavvou ypacfiev, ev toj oiKa>

Maptag Kat Mdp6a$, Kai aTto rov rpottov rvjg itpd^ewg, eKeT fxev

yap Touf Tto^ag ^Xetipe koi ditefxoc^e ralg 6pt^t r^g t^iag Ke(f)a-

X.ijg aXetxpaaa, evravda te Kareyeev htt rijg rov lyjaov Ke^paXyjg' 25


Kat aito yjpovov ttpo fuev yap e| yjf/.epuv €(f>yj lcodvvyjg rov Yldaya
yevea6at ro ^eTitvov eKeivo, MaT^arof ^e vpo yjfxepxv ^vo Kat

fxovos' AovKag **
§e itep) toc fxeaa rov ¥.vayyeXiov y} Koi ert npo
'*
rovrov. i^ov ydp yvvr] ev ryj itoXei ^rig yjv dfxaprwXoi, eitt-

**
yvovaa ort avd^etrat ev rjj oiKia rov ^aptaatov, Kofxiaaaa^o
" aXafSaarpov fxvpov, Kat ardaa itapd rovg Tto^ag avrov OTtiaa
" KXatovaa," Kat rd e^^g. " 'l^wv ^e ^apiaahg KaX.e-
'*
aag avrov, eivev ev eavr^ Xeym, ovrog ei '^v itpo^pT^ryjg, evi-

^ MdpKOi Cod.
S

62 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA VII. 43.

**
vaa-Kev av ns koci itoxaTrri^'' Kai to. €^y]$. vpo^vjXoTaTa yovv ck
rov Kaipov M^eiKTai fJivj ttjv avTTjv Tat$ aXKaig yvvai^) Ta7g itefi

Tov Katpov Tov TtaBovg TifJLyjaaa-aig tov ScoT^^a toj fxvpti)' fu^iv
te vo[xi^eTCi} Ota to Kat tovtov tov ^aptaaTov rov KeKkyjKOTa avTOv

Yitfxava TipoayopiveaGatfTOv avTOv eivat Yitfxwva toS Xenpco' <patve-

Tai yap eKehog TeBepaTievixevog vtto tov Ivjaov, Kat •^aptcxTYjptov

(oaiiep anoTtvvvg avxSi tvjv etg tvjv otKtav aitotoyyiv. ov yap av el

fxy] Te6epa7revT0, irap avTco KaTeKvev.

K.aTe<f)t\€t he avTti ovk apywg, a\Xa, t&j fxvpa aXei(f>ov<ra Toiig

"Tro^ag, rvjv TroXXyjv aTopyvjv eK tovtov ^etKvvovaa. 10


'O ^e Kvpiog 6 fxv] ^ta pvjfxdTav fxovov olkovwv, aXXa Kai Tag

IvBvfxviaetg KaTaXafj.^dvm, ag Kat tuv 'TTpocfyvjTav ^eaTroTvjg vTrdp-

yjnv, airayyeKKei Tovg Xoytafxovg tov ^aptaatov Xeyoov' " ^tfxcov,

e)^w aot Tt etiretv, Kai Ta eg^^g.

43 Kha eiTTOVTog eKetvov, co to TtXeov ^'^(aptaaTO, avTog (f)V]ai itpogie,

avTov' t/ Totvvv av TotavTa evedvfL^^Svjg ; ov^e yap av dvafkdp-


rvjTOg' ei yap eXdrTd} yjpeaiaTelg, aXX ov fKevrot anvjXXayf/.evog

Tvyyavetg dfxapTVjfxaxxv' Kat iroXXdKig fxev ytyverai rov TtoXXa

eirratKOTa, ^t e^ofxoXoy-^aeag rm dfx.apTi^fj.dT(av aTtaXXayv]vat' rov

t\ oXtya v]ft.apTviHOTa, tt vnepvjipaviav fnv] TtpoeXSeiv t» <papft.dK(a 20


TV]g e^ofi.oXoy^a€cog, Kat vitoKeHaQat rvj KoXdaei' ov^e yap ^ta to
fLV] eyetv TtoXXa Tijf Kptaecog aTtaXXaTTerat rtg, aXX Ofkotcog Kai

eitl To7g oXiyoig KaraKptverat, fLVj rvjv "TtpoavjKovaav Kai vitep

avTWv TtpoaevejKag e^ofi.oXoyvjatv Kat fxerdvotav. (og yap dfxap-


rcoXog d^nappvjataarog evpeQ-^aeraif eiti rov cf)opepov ^vjfxarog, 25

Kat av fj.ev, <pv]at, ro7g erotfKotg ovk ey^yjaa)' vd(op ydp fxoi eitt

Tovg Tto^ag ovk e^coKag' evKoXog yap rwv v^drcov v] ypvjatg' avriq

^e Toc dverotfxa e^eKevaae, roig ^aKpvaiv avrvjg Ppeyovad fj.ov rovg

Tto^ag' ov te yap evKoXog v] twv ^aKpvxv eKyvatg, Kat ralg Qpt^tv

e^efJ.a^ev, tva "ti wv iB-^pevae itpog dff.apriav veorvjra, "^ta Tovrcov^o

dytoavvv]v evpeQvj Bvjpevovaa' ert oe Kat Karecppovvjadg fxoV <f>t-

Xvjfxa ydp fnot ovk e^wKag, oy^e eXata> tv]V KecpaX-fjv fxov vjXetxpag'

avrr^ ^e fj.eTd itavrog 7to6ov Kara(f>tXovad fx.01 rovg itotag, fj.vpQ>

rovTOvg ^Xetxpe' Kat en€t'^v] ehag ev aeavrca " ovrog el vjv "TtpocftvjTvjg,

" eyiv(oaK€v av, rig Kat itoraitv] v] yvvv] avrv] vjrig airreTai aurov, 35
VIII. I. AOYKAN EYArrEAIOT. 63

** Kav vvv €K TOfTou oti ovk


OTi diJiapTaXoi 60"t/" yvaBi tffvoovVy oti

Kat Touf (Tovi ^iaXoyiCTfJLovs htlaTa^ai Kai Tag ajxapTiai TavTvjg


yivwa-KwV ^io Kai ae /u,€V co$ irdvTa e/^Wf iXiyya^ Kai tov oyKOV

Tuv dfx.apTrifx.dTm TavTvjg (HKTTdfXivog Xeya) aot " oti acfyewvTat


**
avTyjg at dfxapTtai" Kai Ta e^vjg. 5
E^o^e ^f Kvayye\t<7TVjg, OTt Kat eTepot yjaav a-vvavaKetfj.evot,

ovg Kai e^evKxev XenpoSf OTt oy)^ ag irpocp-^TOv ^v, dw ux; ^e-

airoTOV TO YtKatov dTrovefxovTog' t/ ^e ^v to ^iKaiov ; -^ e^of/.oXo-

yrjcrtg TYjg yvvaiKog Kat to ^dKpvov Kat vj TifJLVj, Kat yj icapa Tovg

Tio^ag cTaatg. 10
/Tre de avTvi ApiaTog rj iriaTtg aov aeawKe ae. ilta to

TTtaTevaat ai;T»;v OTt e^ovatav e^/ei acf^tevat dfxapTtag.

To &e **
Ttopevov eig eip-^vrjv" tovjo eaTt to fj.riKe.Tt dfj.apTdveiv.

KEa>. KB.

Ilepl TTjs •napa^oKrjs tov (nreipavTos. 15

[ YlOll eyivero iu tco Kade^rj? kcu ovtos 8l(o8€V€ Kara


TToXlV KCLL KCOjJLTJVf KTJpvaaWV KCLi €Vayy€\L^O/JL€VOS' T7]V

^acTLX^iav tov GeoO.

Ato^evwv ^e KaTo, noketg Kat KWfxag Kat Kvjpvaacov Kai evay-

yeXi^Ofi.evog tvjv (3aatXeiav tov Seov ovpavoOev ytvoft.evog ^t^d- 20

aKakog etg t>;v yrjVf Tovg eTCt yrjg etg t>jv {SaatXeiav e^dXet twv
ovpavwV eaTt yap Kat rj yrj avTr] ^rif>.iovpyv]fjia, OTrcag 01 ^ia itkd-

vvjv aiToaTdvTeg Trjg ovpaviov KaTaaTdaeccg twv eTrtyetcav KaTa-


(ppovrjacoaiy.

O/ ^e ^oo^eKa r;aav avv avTco ovk evayyeXi^ofj.evot^ dXka fi.a9rj- 25


Tevofxevot Kai 7rai^aycoyovft.evot irpog to Kvayyektov.

AivjKovovv Se avToTg ai avvaKoXovBovaat yvvaTKeg eK t«v vrrap-

y^vzm avToig' ov yap acofnaTiKrjv avdiravatv rrapeyovatv avToTg,

aXX' evayyeXiKVjg acoTrjpiag avTnrotovfj.evat Kai irpoaavaXtaKOvaat


Ta vndpyovTa etg tvjv twv "heofxevm eTrt^oaiv, tva KTVjavjTai t^v^o
evaej3eiav. Ylept t^? Trapa^oXrig tov airopov Kat aKoXovQcog, irept

Tov airTeiv Xvyyov, Kat f/.r] KaXvTrTetv avTOv aKevet, Kat tovto
64 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA VIII. i.

TrpoTepcof ^e, Kai 'nep\ Trjg fJLyjTpo^ avTOv Kai twv a^€\(j>Zv avTOVt
ort yjQeXov avTOV i^^e^v, Kai Trepi Trjg eT:iTiijJ}cre(ag tuiv vhaToov Kat

Trepi Tov ej^ovTCf tov Aeyewva, Kai irepi rav J epyearjvav, Kat irept

Trjg dvyarpog tov apy^iavvayayoVf Kai Trepi Trjg aifj.oppoovdfig, Kai

Tiepi TYjg aiiocrToXrig tcov ^coSeAca, Kat Trepi 'hlpa^ov, Kai irept tcSv5

TievTe apTOov, Kat iiept Trjg tSov fxaSrjTwv eTreparrjaeag, ort Tiva fji€

Xeyovatv oi o^^Xot elvat ; Kat iiept Trjg fji.eTafJ.op(f)Q)ae(ug Kai Tiept

Tov creXrjvta^ofxevQVf Kai nept tuv ^taXoyt^ofxevoov Ttg fxet^tcv etTT/v,

OTrep eaTt Ke<pdXaiov. Klg to. fxiKpa, eig tov ayiov Xoyov, eag ca^e,

<7ipovypd(f)ri etg tov ayiov MaT^arov. lo


ToT Anor Titot Bostpan. 'O ovpavoBev •napayevofj.evog ^t-

^daKaXog eig Trjv yr^ Tovg hit Tr^g yr)g t»;v ^aatXeiav tcov ovpa-
vav evayyeXi^erat, tva Trfv yrjv TiQf^arj ovpavov' rjv yap xat rj
y^
avTov Orjfii.tovpyrifKa. ETre/^T^ yap tia TiXdvrjv diieaTYi Trjg ovpavtov

KaraaTdaecog' ^Afie ^e Kat t*;v y^v KajopGooaat eig evaejSetav, koii^


avvdipat to avvafx<poT€pov tta fxovriv cptXavGpaTiiav. Ttg Se Krjpva-

aeiv efxeXXe PaatXetav Qeov, vj 6 viog tov ©eov, ov vj PaatXeta ;

ov yap ot AcaTW Ta avco KrjpvTTOfxeVy dXX 6 dvcoSev Ta dvco dnay-


yeXXet. Teyomatv ovv iioXXoi Tipo^p^Tai, dXX ovk eKrjpv^av ov-

pavav PaatXeiav' cov ydp fxr] rjaav BeaTai, tov Xoyov tovtoov Ticog 20
e^i^ovv. Aid T0V70 eXeyev 'lcodvvi^g, 6 cov ck Toy^ y^g, eK t^j
yrjg XaXeT, ^e dvcodev epyofxevog eTidvco TidvTcov eaTi, Kai

€copaK€ fxapTvpei' CKrjpv^e Toivvv t^v jSaaiXeiav tov Qeov Tolg


diitaTotg fxri (patvofxevriv, t>jv iiap ^AyyeXotg 'JioXtTevofxevyjv t€ Kai

KpaTovaav, tva ot aKOvovTeg (SaatXeiav tqv Qeov tcov eiityetcav 25


AfaTa(/>pov^crcy(7/v.

Ov a<jifxaTtKr\v avdiiavaiv fneTe^icoKov, dXX evayyeXtK^g acoTrj-

piag avTeTioieirOf TipoavrjXtaKov ovv rd VTidp^^ovTay tva Krrjacovrat

rrjv evae/Setav.

ToT AriOT Ktpiaaot. KtaK€KOfiiiK€ Tov Kvpov fiaKdptog 50

xpaXfxoo^og Aa/3;^ Xeyovra, " dvoi^oo ev 7iapaj3oXa7g to ardfxa


" fxov.^^ ASpei hrj ovv eg Tiepag eK/SelSrjKog tq nap avrov ^tr/yo-

pevfxevQV' TiXetarr} fxev ydp TiXrjSvg avveyriyepro iiept avrov e^


aTidarjg rrjg lov^aiag. YlpoaeXdXet ^e avroTg ev TiapafSoXaigf

aXX cKetvotg fxev qvk ovatv d^iotg rov fxaSeh ra fxvarrfpia T^f35
. ^

VIII. 5- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 65

Twv ovpavav ^aa/Ae/af, a<TV[Ji.<f)aw]i vjv 6 Xoyoi' Xoyov yap yj^iovv

ovoevof to y^ifj(T6ai t*;v e/V «^tov Trpoa-^KaaSai iriffTiv, avriirpaT-

Tov oe avoaias to7^ ^i ayTov KyjpvyfLatriv, kou yovv (ireTifJMv toT^

eQeXovcTi vpoae^peveiv avToo, Kai t^v irap avToTi ^ixpucri fxvaTa-


yayyiaVf ZvaaePovvTe^ tc Kai AeyovTCf, ^aifumov eyei Kai fxaive-

Tai, Ti aKoveTe avTov ; ovkovv ovk eKUVoig ^e^oTa/ yvS)vai Ta


fjLvaTyjpia t^? PaaiXetag twv ovpavm^ ijfiAv ^e fxaXXov Tolg Itoi-

fMTipoig e/f incrT^v* ^ehtaKe yap yjfxiv avTog to ^vvaaQai fxovoV


irapa^o^$ ^e, <rACOTe<vov Xoyov, p-^aei^ t€ ao(f>av Ka) aiviyfxaTa'
eiKoveg yap eiai^ (oaitep ai Tiapa^oKai itpayfi.aTm ovy^ opaim^ lo
voi^raJv T€ fMiXkov Kai wevfjLaTiKwV 6 yap 7^/0?* ovk eveaTi toTs

Tov awfjMTOi o<pQaXfj.o7<;' tovto teiKvvaiv vj irapa^okyj To7g TYjg

OiavQiag 0f/.fuxai ^ia tcHv ev aiaS-^aeif Kai olov airo tojv Trpayf/.aTccv

OiafA,op(f)ovaa KaXas tvjv vovjtwv layyoTfiTa. thxf/.ev toivvv OTioiav

rjfj.iv e^v(f)aivei tyjv voyjatv tov SwT^pof o Xoyog, " 'E|^A6e," <f>i^- 15
aiVf " aveipcov tov a^ireTpai" Kai to. e|^f

5 Tor AnoT Tixor. " 'E^^Adev" ^v yap ev Toig KoXiroi? tov Yla-
Tpog, Kai irpo TravTog atwvog avvai^ioi tov HaTpog Aoyog. Ov
yap OTt ayreipeif TOTe earat fi.ovov, o^S' ot€ ck Mapiag yevvaTat,
^^ ev tS)
Kai Koafj.oci yjv, Kat Koafj.o<; avTOv ovk eyva." 'E|^X5ev 20
aiietpm tov aireTpat tov t^^tov airopov. A/a Tt tov t^^tov; ov yap
Zavet^eTat Xoyov, Aoyog Seov vTrfxp^/oov t>jv <f>vatv. ovKeTi tttog

airopog IlayAoi', oy^e lcixxvvoVf ov^e aXkov Ttvog twv AiroaToXcav yj

vpo<pvjTaVf aXXa ayropog fj.ev ^v* ovk yjv Se ayTwv tttog, aXXa
XapovTeg eyovat' XpiaTog be totov eyei airopov, eK r^^- totag2^

<f)vae<ag tvjv ^t^aaKaXtav '7rpoa<f)epci}v. Eav yap Ae-yv; IlayAof,


**
eyo) e<f)VTevaa, 'AttoAAwc eiroTtae," ti^coai jtxev toj Swt^^/ to
anetpetv, eauTw Be to <f)VTevaat. yap <f>vTev(av aXXoBev Xafn-
/Sav»v, aXXay(ov f/.eTaTiSy]atv, 6 ^e airetpm <pvTevei, aXX* eK tcov

ihicov TafAievm Xafj.(3(xvm aKopTri^et. a<f)Qovci)g y^etp) airetpm 030


nauAos- eAeyeV " el ^0Ktft.y]v ^yjTelTe tov cv e/x.o/ AaAoDvTOf
*'
\ptaTov'" &e Sct)T»?p " ft.y} KaXeayjTe ^t^^cxaKaXov e-nt TVjg y-l^g'

" eig yap eaTtv vfJMV ^t^<xaKaXog ev ToTg ovpavoTg." Ilorof ^t^cxaKa-

Xog ; ^i-xa tov fj.aQeTv ^taXeyofj.evog. tta tovto eXeyov 01 ^loi^aToi,

a sic.

K
66 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA VIII. 5.

" irw( ypafJi.fji.aTa ovTog oi^e fjiy] fJi€fjLa9r]Kc^$ ;" A;a tovto eiTre tov

lOtov aTTopov, iva f/.ddy]s oti avTov r^g (pvaecog 6 (ntopog' Kai <yap

av.TO<; eaTiv iravTOg dyaBov cxiropevi, Kai rjfj.iig yeapyot avTov,


Kai Ot avTOv T€ Kat iiap avTov Kap7to(f>opia irdaa '^vevft.aTiKrjf

Kai TovTo ^fj.S)v tt^^duKei Xeycov, " X<»>ph €fxov ov hvvaa-Oe TToieivS
OVO€V.

Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias. Ka/ Troia Tig €<rTtv yj 7rpo(f>aa-tg

Ot vjv dp7rd^€T€ Ta ev Taig o^oTg ; i^a)fj.€v Teag, ag Iv iray^eat

irpayfj.aat to ^vjTovfjievov. aKXvipa Kat dv-^poTog irdad ircos eaTtv

o^og ota TO t^v aTrdvTWv vTroKelaQat iroat' Ka\ oiihev avTaTg €y)(w- 10
vvvTat TCtiv (7Tr€pfj.dT(av' Kenat ^e fJidkXov hrnroXaicoi, Kat Tolg
eOeXovat twv TrTTjviav €TotfJ.a elg ^iapiray^v. ovkovv oaot tov vovv

eyovatv ev eavTotg (XKXvjpov Kat oiov 'neTrtXrjfj.evov, ovTOt tov Beiov

ov Trapo^e^/pvTai airopov. ovk €ia^v€Tat ydp ev avTo7g 6e7ov re Kat

lepov vovG€TfjfJ.a, ^t ov 'hvvavTat Kapirocpopeiv xa eig dpeTV]v av- 15


yYifj.aTa' ovTot Tolig aKaBdpToig 7rv€vfi.aat, Kat avTW ^e to5

SaTava TreTraTvjfj.evot yeyovaatv o^og, ^v ovk 'eveaTt TroTe Kap-


TTcav dyioov eyyeveaQat TpocpivjVf aTeTpav Kat eKyovov^ ej^co» ti^v

Kap^tav.

IflANNOT Xpt202Tomot. TavTa Xeycov elg dKptjSeiav dyet 20

l3iov, Trai^evcov evaycoviovg elvai, ag vTro Toig aTravToov 0(f>9aXf(.o7g

KeifJ.€voVf Kat €v fieaco tov TVjg oiKOVfj.€vy}g aycovt^ofievovg OedTpw.

M»/ ydp ^vj TovTO 'i^^Te, (fjt^atv, OTt evTavQa KaS-^fneBa vvv^ Kai

(V fj.iKpS) ycoviag €afj.ev fj^epet' yev^aeaSe ydp Trdat KaTdtvjXoi.


B1KTCP02 nPE2BTTEPOT. '
Orav ydp ToaavTV] vj dpeTVj d^v- 25
vaTov avT-i^v XaQeiV ey^cov ydp airov^^atav irpoaipeatv, X-^xpeTai

irvevft.aTog ydpiv Kat ao(f>iag Kat yvcoaecogf Kai a^iav tZv Trovccv

TVjv afi.ot^vjv.

ToT ATTOT. Ta yap eK (f)vaecog vjft.iv evovTa v} S<a ydptTOg

^o^evTa, edv fnvj '^id T^g avveyovg irpoaoyvig Kai airov^bvjg (ptXoirovov ^o
(pvXd^cofiev, TavTa ^vjfiicoBvjaofueda, ov fj.ovov fxvjVev 7rpoXaf/.{3d-

vovTeg^ dXXd Kai 7rpoaa7roXXvvT€g Kai d eyeiv €^o^afi.ev.

TlTOT Bo2TPaN. Kk TOVTOV S^AoV OTt OVK VjV 6 'ZcOTVjp fJ.€Ta

Tcov KaTa adoKa eiiyevm' KaTaXnrcbv yap TovTovg a-yoXd^ei Tvj

" Cod. tyovov.


VIII. 22. AOYKAN ETArrEAIOT. 67

varptK^ ^i^affKaXia. Eirei^rj ^e itoGi^tos y}v ^ia tyjv airo\€i\l/iv,

Kou hriBvixfiTog tU Beav ^ta t^v yjioviav avay^jap-^^nv, TiapayiviTai

rj [A^^Ti^p avTOv Koi ol a^eXcpoi, ol itpoyovoi tov lw(TV]<f> oi K\y]SevT€i

a^eX(f)ot' ovK eaTi ^e (XTefJiTV] (sic) tov Kvpiov vj (jvyyeveia, ovOe

ev oXiyco 7Fepiyp(X(f>€Tai avTOv vj Tipog avQpwTrovg (fiiXia. 'HAde^


yap caravTa tov KO^rfxov eU a^eX^pOTVjTa KaXeaai a^flovov, Kai

7rpoXa/3o}v eXeye ev vpocf^-^Taii tx TlaTp;, " aTrayyeXco to ovofXM


** Xeycov^
(Tov Toti ateX(f>o7g fxov'^^ iroloig <x^eX(f>o7g epfxvivevei

•*
ev f/.ea(p eKKXvjaiag vfxvfi(T(o o-e*" oirov toivvv eKKXfiaia ^pi-
aToVf eKei a^eX(f)OTYig 'KpicrTOv. lo
12 ToT ATTOT. *0 Xoyog tov Qeov, Xoyog y]v avTov, TlaTpog yap

KOi Tiov ft.ia ^i^a(7KaXia ev Trpo^f^v^Taig Kai ev KvayyeXi(7Ta7g Oia

T^f evepyiag Ty]v tov 'Ayiov n.vevfJiaTog. Xeyei ^e tov Aoyov tou

SeoVf iva t^v Tifi-t^v avaTrefxxpyj irpog tov TlaTepa. 'Q.g yap eirpeTre

Tw YlaTpi yevv-S^aat T/ov, ovtco irpeirei yeyevvyffxevx Ttfxav tov i


5

yevvY](TavTa, M^Tijp fxevTot Kai a^eX(f>oi ovroi elaiv 01 tov Xoyov

tou Seov aKOvovTeg Kat 'iroiovvTeg' "^^jpeiav yap eyei aKor] ep-

yaaiag.

KE^. Kr.
Ilept TTJs emTinTjirtcas rciv v8dra>v. 20

22 Ktpiaaot i^AESANAPEiAS. AieirXei ofxov Toig ayioig Airo-

(TToXotg "KpKTTog T^v Ti^eptd^a 6aXa(7(Tav, y]Tot XifLvyjV eyyf


yepToi Se icaTa tou (jKoui^ovg a^OKi^Tog T€ Kai airy]vy]g yeifxwvj Kat

Taig Twv avefJMV efJ.^oXaig vi\)ov to KvfjiM KvpTovfLevov Kai to tov

OavaTov ^eog eveTiQet Tatg ft,a9y]Ta7g' T€6opvj3y]VTat yap ov ju,e- 25


Tptag, KaiToi to 6aXacr(xovpye7v el^OTeg, Kat KXv^aivog ovk ovTog

aireipaTot. eTreiVif] ^e Xonrov tov kiv^^vvov to fj.ey€6og Trpog a(f>opy]Tov

avTovg eKoXei ^etXiav, ag eTepav ovk e)(ovTeg toD aa^e(x6ai t^v


cAw/Sa, irXyjv oti fxovov avTOv tov TaJv ^wafxecev KvpioV S^Aov Se

OTt yiptaTOv ^taviaToiai XeyovTeg, **


eirtaTaTa, auiTov, airoXXvfj.e^a. 30
KOii KaSev^yjaai yap avTOv KiiayyeXtaT-^g (f>y]atv. oiKOvofi.tKU}TaTa

8e fji/>t Kai TovTO Xtav TreTrpayPai toKel, iva fxv] evQiig (xp^afievov

Tov KXvOmog eTrnry^av Toi aKd(f>€tf t*;v irap' auTou ^i^TOvaiv eiri-

KovpiaVy aXX olov aKfi.daavTog y]^"!^ tov KaKov, efJi,(f>av€aTepa 'yev»;-

K 2
68 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA VIII. 25.

Ta< TVj^ QeoTTpeTTOvs €^ov(Tiai V} ^vva[ji.iif fJiaivofi.(VV}v KaBicrTaoa


QaXacaav Kai fJ.€6i(JTaaa npog yaXyjvyjv.
ToT ATTOT. KvTovGa {jt.01 jSAcTTe jtA6Ta via-Teag oXiyoiri<TTiav.

TTiaTevovai [xev yap oti aaaai "^vvaTai, co^ ^e oXiyoTTiaToi Xeyovai


TO " accaoVf aTroWvfxeBa'^^ ov yap ecpiKTOv amXeiaOai rroTe avv- 5

ovTog avToTs tov irdvTa layyovTOi. d\?C ey^epTai vapayji^fJia


^piaTO^ 6 TrdvTcov eycov tvjv e^ovaiav, Kai KaQiaTvjai [xev evBvg tov
Kkv^cova, avveaTeiXe ^e Tag Tav 'irvevftMTCOv opfJidg' Kat tov Sopv-

l3ov enavae, Kai &; avTccv e^ei^e twv TrpayfxdTCCVf oti Seog eaTi.
XeyeaGci} roivvv Ttap y)[x,ciov to ev j3il3\oo tpa\[t,m' " av ^eaTro^eii i o
" Tov KpdTOvg Tyjg QaXdaafjif Kai tov aoKov rwv KVfJiMTcay avTrjg

" av KaTa^TTpavveigJ'

ToT ATTOT. Q^aiiep 6 y^vaog ev itvpt ^oKifxd^eTai, ovtco Kai v}

TTiaTig ev ttetpaafj.inq' 7rA»;v daQev^g 6 dvBpamv voyc, ^e^Tai &c

TtdvTcog TTjg avcoBev %eipog eig to ^ieveyKeTv dv^peicog rd iiape^x- \


5
irnTTOVTa. Kai tovto y}[J.ag YiCOTyjp eti^aaKev, e/Vwv, " X(»>pig
'^
efJ.ov ov ^vvaa6e Troieh oy^ev*" coft,oXoyei ^e tovto Kai ao(f>co-

TaTog TlavKog XeycoVf " ori itdvTa layvco ev rw ev^vvafj.ovvTi /Ae

XpiaToo.

25 'A^' ovv ag ovk ei^OTeg to " Tig ovTog earif*' Trapyjyopevov aA-ao
X^Ao/f ; eha iicog ovk aitiOavov TravTeXcog to '^Qiyjfj.d eariv ; rj^eaav

ydp ovTa 0eov, Kai Tiov Qeov rov 'li^aovv* KaTaTiXy^TTOfJ.evoi ^e

TVjg Ivovayjg avTW ^vvdft.ecog ryjv virepPoXyjv, Kai t^v T^i^g BeoTi^Tog

'bo^av, KaiTOi Ka6 yifJ.ag ovti t€ Kat opcofxevco KaTo. t^v adpKa,

Xeyovai to " Tig ovTog eartv" avTi tov iroaog Kai olog, Kai ev oayj 25

'tvvdft.ei Kat e^ovaia, " oti Kai avTOig eTtndaaei ToTg v^aai Kai To7g
" avefxoig, Kat vitaKovovaiv avTa'" eitiTaKTtKOV yap yjv to epyov,

^eaTtoTtKy] y] itpoaTa^tg Kat ovk d^icog otKi^TtK'^' fj.eya Kai tovtq

Ttpog Gavfxa Kat ovyjatv TOig aKpocofi.evotg' vitaKovet yap yj KTtatg,

olg av eTttrdrTetv /BovXeTat 'K.ptaTog. dfxeXet Kat tov Ty}g eitt-^o

Tift.y]g TpoTtov ev e^ovaia 6eo7tp€7tei yevea6ai (pt^aiv 6 MaT-


6aiog' ecpyi yap etiteiv Ty 6aXdaayj tov Kvptov, " atcoTta, Ttecpi-

" fxooao" Kai afxa t^ Xoyco yjKoXovdyjae to TtpdyfJ.a, Kat yj 6d-


Xaaaa yivcoaKei tov ditapyyjg avTyjv avvayayovTa, itpoaTayfj.aTt

Tov 6efj.evov dfj.fj.ov opiov avT^, o ov^ vnep^yjaeTat. 35


VIII. 31. AOTKAN EYArrEAIOY. 69

KE*. KA.
Tlfpi Tov Afyfwvos.

27 'E^eA^OKTt 5e aim^ €7n rrjv yrju v7rr}VTr](T€v avrcp avrjp

TLS €K Trj9 TToXecof, 0? ei;(€ SaifJLOVLa €K ^ovcov LKavatv.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeia2. ^EvTavSd [xoi jSXeVe Bpdaei iroAAw 5

Koi «Trovo/a (TvixTreTrXifjyfxevrjv ^eiXiav' ^e7y[xa fi.ev yap airovoiai

^y]XcoTiKOV TO Tokfxrjaat XeyeiVf " t< efxoi Kai aoif Irjaov T/e Toy
*'
Seov Tov vipiaTOv ;" el yap oilaf oXai ovra avTOv Tiov tov
'Ti///c7T0u Seov, 6[MXoye7s oti Seog eaTiv ovpavov t€ Kat yrjg koi

TMV ev avTo7g' eha irag to. [xi] aa, fj.dXXov Oe Ta avTOv ttap-nd- 10

"Cfetq^ eha Xeyetg, " Tt e/Aci Kat aot ;" Kat Ttg dve^erai tSov eiii

Tifji ^aatXeiag fxeypt "navTog dve7vai ^ap^dp^ Tovg VTto aKvptTpa

KetfJievovgf Tag avTcii Se rrpeitovaag epevyeaOaf cpoovdg. avrai M


eiai TO *'
'teofx.at aov fxrj [xe (Saaaviavjg'" itapyiyyetXe yap," e0>;,
" TO} TTvevfjLaTt e^eX$e7v dito tov dvBpwiiovr AOpei ^e fxoi irdXtv 15

Tvjv aTrapd^XYiTov to^av tov ndvTa layyoVTog, <f>r][Jii ^rj 'K.piaTOv

Tvjv dKaToyavtaTOV layvv^ avvTpi^ei tov SaTavav, eSeXyjaag fxovov

TovTO 7raSe7v avTOV rtvp avTW Kai (pXoyeg etat t» tou Kptarov

poJjtAaTa. AXvjQeg ovv OTt, KaSd (pvjatv 6 [laKdpiog xpaXfi.a)^og " Ta


" opvj erdKvjaav aaei Kvjpog arro Trpoawnov tov ©eoi)*" opeai yap 20
Tag vy^niXdg kcu virept^tpdvovg irapeiKd^^et ^vvdft.etg, rrovYiptag '^yj'

XovoTt, TrXvjv wg irvp) irpoa^aXXovaag t^ tov "^wTvjpog vjfXiov tvvd-

fxet T€ Kat e^ovataf KaTaT-^KovTai KVjpov ^ikvjv.

31 ToT ArioT TiTOT BosTPCN. 'Qcave/ eAe^ye, fxvj drroTrefxy^g

rjfJMg, fxvjte elg ro CKOTog to e^ooTepov to vfrotfxaafxevov ra ^ia- 25

jSoAco Kat Totg 'AyyeXotg avTOv' erret TOtvvv othaaiVf gti iroTe

Trefxc^YjaovTat, dveaiv irpog Katpov ahovatVf ofxoXoyovvTeg oviXaQvi

aa<f>S>g OTt eav eirtTd^rjf aTreXevacovTat. ware K.vptog to fxev

eirtrd^at avTo7g ovk eiaaev, avveyapviae Se avTOvg eivat ev Tvj


y^
TavTvi kcog orre Kai tov ^tdjSoXov, rrpog yvfxvaatav twv dvSpamaV 30

rov ydp dvTiirdXov vj drrovaia tou vtKvjTov d<patpe7Tat tov aTe-

<f>avov. AvTot fxev ydp irovvjpevovTatf 6 ^e dyuvoQeTv^g aTe(f>avov

TrpoTtde7 To7g vtKwat. irapeKdXovv 01 ^atfxoveg tov Kvpiov. ei KaTa


70 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA VIII. 41.

Tovg alpiTiKovg ap^/ou vjcrav ^vo, ovk av 01 ^atfxoves irapeKdXovv

Tov Kvpiov, e/ fx)} Yj(Tav '^vjfjitovpyi^fJi.a [xev tov 0eoy, ag Se d[xap-

T^^aavTig d7rof3€PXy]fx.evoi. /SAeVe TOtvvv tvjv oiKCtOTi^Ta tvjs ^vjfAt'

ovpyiag Kat T^g dfjiapTia^; tov eXeyyov, y^fxag yap ovjfxtovpyta viro

Tov '^ea-TTOTvjVf 01 ^e dfi/xpTavovTeg vtto tov KptTVjv itapaKaKoixyi Kat 5

ofxoXoyova-t t^v e^ova-iav.

ToT ATTOT. Kadapa ^ KaBapa^tg, dvavTtppyjTog r} BepaTteta, ovtci)

yap evvjxpev 6 iida^/jijv coaTe eiityvmat tov HaTvipa Kai a^tovv av-

Tov, iva 17 avv avTco' Tdy^a Se Kat evXa^ovfxevog t>;v v7roaTpo<pvjv

TCtiv ^atfxovoov. ^e Kvptog tva fj^q


^o^v} "^ta TVjg itapova-tag <pvKaT- 10

re^v, Tiapm yap Kat ditwv <f)v\daaet ovg ^ovKeTat, aiieXvaev av-
Tov, eiTrav, " v7roaTpe(f>e eig tov oikov" Kat fxvi^fxoveve Tvjg evepyeiag,

ttvjyov TO Gavfxa, tva ^efBataa^ffg t^v ydptv, " '^tvjyov oaa aoi
''
eTroivjaev 6 0eo?*" ov ^eyet, eya Tvirog vfxh Ta7retvo<ppoavvv]g

yevofxevog, dW dvaTtefXTtet eig UaTepa, ov avTog Ttotei to Qavfxa. 15


BiKTOPos nPESBTTEPOT. 0eov dpa vj^ei tov Ivjo-oDv, Kat tZv

tatfxovm a7taWayetg KVjpvaacov oaa e^totvjaev avTW Ivjaovg,

ei7twv avTW, *'


'^tvjyov oaa aot e7toiv]aev 6 Qeog'^' dWcog Se ov Ttapa-

(3atvei Tov vofxov, b yap evepyei Tiog, evepyei 6 TlaT^^p.

KE4>. KE. 20

Ilept T^f dvyaTpos tov dpxKTVvayayyov.

4^ Kai iSov rjXOev dvr/p (p ovojjlol 'Ideipo^.

Toi ArioT TiTOT BosTPON. To ovofLa Kehai ha Tovg lov»

taiovg Tovg ei^oTag ro yeyovog, tva yevvjTai to ovofxa a^toQet^tg

TOv QavfxaTog, Kat ovTog dpyav TVjg avvaywyvjg tcSv lov^^atm, oy/c 25

viXBe Ttg Twv evTeXwv, ov^e twv TV/pvTWV' e'i6e fxev ovv Ttpovka^e,

Kat §;a TtiaTtv Ttpoaeneae, kou tt evyvoifxoavv^v hteyvw, fxvi tta

y^etav TtapeyeveTo. 'H yap y^eia ^ta(3d\\et tvjv TtapdKXvjatv,

Ofxug OXtxptg eaS OTe KaTa^td^eTat Ttpog to eXeaBat tpav Ta avTta

'^vjatfxa Kat avfX(f>epovTa. TavTVj TOt Kai fxaKdptog e(f>v} Aa^t'^, 30


" ev Kvjfx^ Kat xaXtv'2 Tag atayovag avTwv dy^etg, twv fxvj eyyi-

^ovTCiJV Ttpog ae.


VIII. 43- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 71

KE$. Kr.
Uepi TTJs aifjioppov(rT]i.

45 'Eh 'ANEnirPA*OT. Upoa-eia-i yvvv} KaXSog Kat olKtiaog r^v

[J1.0VYJV iKavriv d(f>op[J.7}v eig to laSvjvai iiapaaKivaaaaa t>jv Triariv.

" Ylpoa-eXQovaa^ y"-?* (p^^^iv,


" ontadev, vjxpaTo tov KpaaTie^ov tov 5
**
ifxaTiov avTOVf^ ^i^Xa^Yj ireTrta-TevKvTa fxeyd^ai, ovTcog ag Kat
^ta T^f (Traiprig TTiaTevaat tyjv laatv. Aeyet ^e avTcP Kat ^tvj-

yeiTat MdpKog KvayyeXia-T-^g' *'


eXeye yap, (pvjatVf " OTt Kav
" Twv t(MaTi(i}v avTov arpoofJLat, a-aO-^a-ofxati Kat Trapay^jpyjfxa eaTYj
*'
vj pvatg Tov at[xaTog avT^i^g. Q.airep yap ei Ttpoaaydyot Ttg 10

0(f)GaX[AOV (pcoTt XdfiTrovTt vj irvpt (f)XeyovTt tvjv iie^f^vKvtav vXvjv

e^dTrrea^at, afxa t6 iipoaYiyaye, Kat to T^g evepyeiag TreTrk-rjpctiTai,

0(fiGaXfJ,6g Te yap, afka to itpog (f)cog aTrt^eTv e(f>c>}Tta6y}, Kat to

Tre(f>vKog viro^eyeaGat Trpog evepyetav afxa to TrXvjaiaaai (f)XeyeTai,

ovTcag 7} TrtaTCog ecftaxpafJievv} tov KpaaTre^ov tov lfJ.aTiov avTov, t^s" 15

idaecog eTv^ev, ovk rfpoyfif} t\ to Trapdoo^ov.

'Eh ANEnirPA*oT. OvK y]v to5 Kvpio) irXi^ataaat Kat e(f)d-

ipaa6ai avTov acofi.aTtKcog vXyjatd^ovTa Kai e(f)aTrTOfj.evov, et ft.v]

Trvevfj.ariKcog tovto Trotyj' eTfj^e Totvvv ovirep eyjpyit^ev y] yvvyj. Ato


Kat ^yjTei rovg vno tov l^vpiov, Kai eg otptv KaXeirat tcov ft.a6y}Twv 20
ovK ei^OTiov TO ^y}Tovfj.evov, dXX dirX-^v Ttva Ty}v eiracpy^v otofJ.€vci)v

Xeyetv tov Kvpiov, Kat ToiavTy}v oiav 01 Xotiroi iravTeg e(f)y}TrT0VT0.

'^toirep Kvptog ^iaaTeXXcov " y]\paTO fJ.ov t/?," (f)y}atv, coanep

KOt eXeyev, 6 e-)(cov coTa aKovetv, aKoveTCO, KatTOt TrdvTcov Ty}v aco-

[xaTtK^v TavTy}v eypvTCov aKO-^V Kat [J-eyjpt ^e r\>tXy}g T-^g tcov Xoycov 25

aKpodaecog aKovovTCov dirdvTcav, aXX ovTe aKovetv y}V tw [xy] avv-

erw, ovTe airTeaBai tw [j.y} TrtaTCfi. T< ovv ; elg oxptv avTi^v KaXei,

Kat Tovg lepovg o(f>6aXfi.ovg eiraipei ireptaKoncov ty^v yvvouKa, OTt

Oeag d^ia Ttapa t<S Kvpia' d^ia ^e Kat T^g etg Tovg irapovTag

eTrtbei^tcog, OTt irapd^etyfj.a irtaTecog irdatv y]fi.eXXev eaeadat Kat 30

irapaKXyjaig eir) TriaTtv, S/a tov "^oBy^aofxevov avTvj ^tKaicog eiratvov.

'Eh ANEnirPA*oT. YlpoTepov fxev ovk eToXfxa ^t evXd^etav


dvTtKpvg diravrav, Ka) 'irep) Sepaireiag d^iovv, ^v]TovfJ.evy} ^e

^ Sic. Leg. Tot/To.


72 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA VIII. 49.

KTtavTa TtpiTTovrag, €[ji(f)c^os re Kai evXa0^g Kat to aePat; ap-


jtxoTTcv 7rpoa<pepov(ra' Kai tvjv OfXoXoyiav T^f ida-eoog ng e[X(f)av€S

TtatTi noienai, ov tSi iidvra ei^orif aWa To7g ayvoovcriv, aiad-^aet

T>jv laaiv eTreyvcoKvia. Aeyei yap Kat rovro 'M.dpKog " ort eyvio
*' ra (Tcofxarif ort tarai «Tro T^f ^dartyog.^^ ^v t Ik rvjg eTia^fy/jg 5

eXaf3e BepanetaVf ravryjv Kai ^/a Toy Xoyov e^e^at(aaev Sa)T>y/>

efTrccv, " TTopevov ev elp-fjvri, Kat 'laQt vytyjg diio ri^g [xd(XTtyog croy,"

Kat vytatve •nparov ryj "Trtaret rvjv tpv^^^^v' eira ^e Kat ro a^fxa.

49 Ktl avTOv XaXovuTOS ep^^Tai tl9 irapa tov ap^^^Lavv-

aycoyov. 10

TiTOT BosTPfiN. Iva yap [J.y] etTtri Kat avrog, eTitayegi ov


yj^eiav (xov ej^w, Kvp/e, ri^ri yeyove ro irepagf aTteOaveVf ^v irpoae-

OOKWfxev vyiaivetv aTrtarog yap yjv, 'lovSai/cov e)(cov (ppovyjfxa, <p6d'

vei Kvptog Kat (pYjat, }j.ri <pol3ov, Travaov r^t^g aTitartag ra p-fj-

[xara, eTcta-yeg rrjv y\Sorrav, [xovov Tttareve Kara rvjv yvva^Ka, ^v 15

yap avrvj KaSdvep •jrpootti.tov ryjg [xekkovavjg Bav[xaTOvpyiag.

Eb ANEnirPA*oT. ABopvjSag irept t>jv ryjXtKavryjv Trdpeart

^vvafxiv, ovK oj^Aov eirapo^xevog, aAA' oaov otov re tov o^/kov d<pt-

arag' rav [xev [xaByirav [xovovg rpeig av^xiiapaXa^hv, rao Se oj^Aco

7rpo(paatv ava^^cop-^aewg TrpoPdXXoov, ro [xrj reOvdvat (pdvat t»/v 20


Kopyjv, aXXa KaQev^etv. 7rpoaKaXead[*.evog ^e fxovovg Ik Trdvrcov roiig

yoveig, ovrta t^v Kopi^v KaBdnep KaGev^ovaav dvtaryjatv, dXi^6eg rij

6av[xarovpyta Trot^aag ro Ka6ev^etv avrriv' oitep avev rvjg dvor-

ardaecog ovk dv '^v dXyj6eg. AiOTrep 01 [xev t>jv avdaraatv ov


TTpoa^oKSovreg KareyeXoov, Ka6ev^eiv aKovovreg t*;v r(6vyjKviav' av- 25
TOf ^e Kard t^v a:;Tov ^vva[xtv dXi^6eg ro elprj[xevov aTre^et^ev.

51 Ort rwv aXXcov ovrot yjaav VTtepeypvveg, Kai [xev IleT^oj" eK

rov a(po^pa (ptXetv avrov e^yjXov rrjv vnepoy^-^v' ^e lcodvvyjg Ik

rov a(po^pa (ptXeTa6at, Kat ^ldKoo/Sog Se aTro ryjg aTtoKpiaeoog, yj

aTreKpivaro Xeycov, ^vvd[xe6a irteTv ro TtoT^ptov' ovk dno ryjg diro- ^o

Kpiaewg ^e [xovov, dXXd Kat diio rav epyoov, rcov re dXXcov Kai d(p

cov ewXyjpcoaev, aTiep eliiev. Ovroo ydp rjv a(pohpog Kat ^apvg
'lov^atotg, cag Ka) rov 'Hpco^i^ ravryjv ^copeav [xeyiary^v vo[xtaat

yapiaaa^at ro7g ^lov^^aiotg, ei eKe7vov dveXot^.

c Haec Chrys. siint. Cf. Cat. ad S. Matth. p. 134.


IX. I. AOTKAN EYArrEAIOT. 73

KE^. KZ.

I ^vYKaXeaa/ievos^ Se tovs ScoBeKa fiaOryras avrov,


eScoKeu avTOLS Bvva^Lv koll e^ovalav hri iravTa tol

SaL/jLovLa kou voaovs OepajreveLV. 5

KtpiAaot 'Aaehanapeias. 'AXrjQe^ eiTre^v ori Ttovm arfabm


Ka^Ttoq ^vKX^r^q' Toli yap roi t>jv Tcdvayvov Kai ajSe/SijXov, Kard
ye ro dvQpccTroig eyya>povv, KaropQovv eSeXovrag ?a'^i', ro7i irap eav-

rov yapiafiaai Karatpai^pvvei X.pi(Trog, Kai nXovaiav <ivro7g dyi-

vjrpeirSoi yapi^erai t^j» dvreKr-qaiv, Kai ^o^i^s avrov Tijf /§/«$• 10


KaOiarrja-i Koivcovovg. ^e^^ow rov irpdyfjiarog dTro^et^iv cacpyj re
Koi evepy^ rovg dyiovg ATroaroXovg' opa yeyovorag eKirpeTreard-

rovg, Kai ryj virep dvQpwTrov ^o^vj KarearefXfxevovg, [/.evovrog avroTg

faera toov dXXuv Kai rovro yipiarov. Ae^uKe yap avroTg, (f^i/jo-i,

" ^vvafAiv Kat e^ovaiav eiri Trdvra ra taifj.ovta Kat voaovg 6epa- ic
**
irevetVf^ aAX' opa irdKiv rov evavSpooir^aavra rov Qeov Aoyov, ro
ryjg dvSpwTrorvjTog vTreprpeyovra fxerpov, Kat roTg r^g BeOrYjrog
d^icofLaat '^iaTrpeirovra' eTreKeiva yap rwv r^g avdpaTrorrjrog ft.e-

rpcov ro h^ovat Kard Trvevfkdrm dKaOdprav, oig av ^ov\y]rat tvjv

€^ov(Tiav' Kat fJir]V Kai ro ^vvaaOat voavjfJidrav ekevdepovv rovg 20

€vet\y]fi.fi.evovg Kat fLovov Qeov. H yap ri^g avararco (f>vaecog

VTrepoy^-^ re koI "^t^aaKaXta Kat ^o^yj ovOevt rav ovrav eveart

<f>vatKag, Trkyjv ort avrw re Kat fkovw. a^ta rotvvv 6avfi.arog 07

Tor^ dytotg Airoarokotg eKvefi.yj6e7aa %dptg, eireKetva Se eTratvov

Kat 6avfuarog y} rov vefj.ovrog a(f)6ovta' ryjv eavrov yap, cof e(f>i^v, 25
eyapi^ero ^o^av dv6pxirog e^ovaiav Kard Trvevfxdrcov ^e^xerai

TTovyjpcov, Kai ryjv ovrcog xmepoTrrov o(f>pvv t>jv toD ^taj3o\ov (p^fifiviv

Karaarpe(f>et, Kai rot Xeyovra irore " t»;v eiKovfJievi^v o\y]v kara-
" X-^Ofjiou r^ %€//?/ «f voaaiav, Kat wg KaraXeXetfj.fj.eva wd dpco,

" Kai ovK eartv og Ota(pev^erat fj.e, r} avrenry} fnot. ea^paXXero ^o

^e ryjg dXyj6eiag Kat hy]fi.dpry]Ke r^g eXirt^og aojSapog Kat 6pa-

avg, Kat ryfg dirdvTCov da6evetag KaraKavycofj.evog. Avrtrd^erai


ydp avrS) rovg roov lepcov KyjpvyftMrcov lepovpyovg, rcov ^wdfJiecov

I.
74 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA IX. 12.

Kvpto^f Koi rovTQ ^v apa ro ^/ evo^ xm ayim 7rpo<f>v)T<ov vpoKe-

Kvjpvyfxevov, itepi re. tov Sarava Kai t«v ayiav ixvaTayayyZv, ort
" e^ai(f)vy]s a.vadTVjcrovrai 01 ^aKvovTef avTOV' Kai cKv^xpovaiv 01

" €Tri(3ovkoi (ToVy Kai eavj elg ^iapnayyjv avrolg'^^ fxovov yap ovyi
KaT^i^oKaai t)>v 'ZaTavav, liri^ovXevovTig avTOv tyj ^o^v], Kai 5

oiapvd^ovTei avTov to, aKevyj, kou npoaKOfxi^ovTeg too Xp^CTW Qia

itKTTiwg TVji eif avrov.

KE^. KH.
Hepi rSiv t aprav Koi roiv j3' i\Qva>v.

12 TipoaeXOovres Se ol SooSeKa ehrov avrcp, airoXvaov 10


Tov o-)(Xov.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaebanapeias. Ka) t/ to " aTtoXvaov^ eaTiv, e^e-

Taaeoixev aKpijSooi. 01 /xev, cag e(f>i^v, tSov evofJievav avTf itovvjpm

"TrvevfxaTav avve^^ovTm avrovg anakXdTTeaBai TcapeKdXovv, 01 Se

Kai eTepcov dppoi3aTV][j.dTccv e^^^Tovv dno&eaiv. atg ovv el^OTcg 0/15

[j.a6vjTai QTi KaTavevaag fxovcv aTiOTiepaivei ToHg Kdfxvovai ro ttq-

Bovfxevov, TO " dvokvaov avrovg" <j)aai, Kat cvk avroi fxakkov aKti-

Otmreg ig TtapaKfxdaavrog rov Katpov, dWa ryjg eig rovg oj^Aovf


aydiryjg eypfxevoi, Kat oiov fxeXeroovreg ^§»7 T»yv TrotfxeviKyjv eTrtaryj-

fXYiv Kat rov KVj^eaGat Aa»v dpypfxevot. 20


ToT ATTOT. " ^araKXlvare avrovg'^^ tva ^e Kat eni fxei^o) etg

vrpog To irpayfxa rpeyyf, Ka\ %eog oov <f>vaei ^ta Tponov vavrog

eirtyivioaKyjrat, TroXvTrXaatd^et ro ^payfy. BAeTre/ t€ etg ovpavov,

oiov ryjv dvcodev evXoyiav aiTm. e^pa ^e koi tovto ^t vjfxdg oikovo-

fXtKwg. earoo fxev yap avrog itdvra TrXyjpwv, y) avooBev Kat itapa 25

W.arpog evkoyta' iva ^e fxdOoofKev y][xe7g, ort rpane^yjg dpypfxevoi

Kat fxehXovreg dprovg ^iaKXav, 0e» itpoadyeiv o(f>eiXofxev vitrtatg

(oanep evQevreg '/epat, Kat t*^v dvco6ev evXoytav eit avrov Kara-

<f>epetv, dpyyj Kat rvitog Kat o^og rov Ttpdyfxarog yeyovev yjfx7v

otKovofxtKcog. eira OTtot nore itpoe^y] ro Bavfxa' KareKopea6vj TtXyj- 30

6vg dv^^pm qvk oXiym, eig Ttevre ydp e^eretvero ytXid^ag yapig
yvvatKm Kai itathm' rovro yap erepog rtg rm EvayyeXtarm
rotf eavTOv itpocryivtyKe Xoyotg' Kai ov fJ-^yjpi rovrov ro Ttapd^o^ov,
IX. i8. AOYKAN EYArrEAIOY. 75

aWa yap kou KO(f>tvoi avveXeyi^aav KXaa-fxaTwv SwJeAca* Kai ti to

evT€v6ev; ir\rjpo(f>opia aa(f>vii, oti T^f <pt\o^eviag to XPVf^ irXoV'

ciav eyet Ttapa Qeov t^v avTeKTif]<xtv. K^eaTi Se Kat i^eiv to7s

apy^aioTepotg Gav[ma-i toc vea avf^^atvovja, Kai fAtSii ovra Kai Tfji

avT-Tjg ^vvafAeas evepy^fxaTa. ej3pe^ev ev ep^^fxca tq [xavva Toig e?5

lapayjX' apTov ovpavov e^ccKev avToH?, apTov AyyeXm ecpayev av-

Spayiroi KaTa to cv il^aKfx.olg vix,vov[JLevov' aAX' i^ov ^rj TiaXtv ev

epyifJi.(o Tolg ev ev^eia Tpocf^i^g Ke^j^wpyjy^Kev acf^Bovwgf olov e| ovpavov

Kadietg avT-^V to yap TroXvnXaatdaat to ^payy, Kai olov eK tov

fjLrj^evog t^v ovtco noWyjv aTroOpexpai irXviSvv, ovk aiteotKog av eivj lo


Toi) TrpaTco arifxeta}.

KE<E>. KB.
nept TTjs Tov Kvpiov eTrepoDTTjatm.

i8 Kat iyeuero iv r^ iivaL avrov Trpoaevxofievov Kara-


fwvas, arvvrjcrav avra ol fiaOrjTcu, kcll iTrepooTrjcrev av- 15

TOVS>

ToT ATTOT. 'Opag to Trjg irevaeag evTeyyeg ; ovk evOvg etirev,

Vfxe7g Tiva fxe XeyeTe eivai ; d7ro<f>epet te fxaWov eTri tov tZv

e^wdev BpvXkov, tv eK^akav avTOv Kai d^oKtfxov dirocf^-^vagf fxeTa-

aofS-^arj Xotirov elg ^o^av dXrj6ivr]v, ^rj Kai ireTrpaKTat. eiTrovTWV 20

yap Twv fxaBriTav, 01 fi.ev ladvvriv tov ^airTiaT^Vy dXXoi ^e HA/av,


akkot &e OTt 7rpo(f)vfrri(; Ttg twv dpyaim dveaTrif etirev avToTg,
'*
vft,etg Oe Ttva fxe XeyeTe eivai ; wairep eqatpeTov to vfxeig eqo)

Ttdrjatv avTovg twv aAXwv, iva Kai Tag eKeivwv <f>vya>atv virovoiag,

Kat fxrj fxtKpav e^coat irept aiiTOv Tr^v ^o^aV vfxe7g, (f>r]aiv, 01 €^-25
etXeyfxevotf ot ^''^'P^ "''^ e/xoy KeKXrjfnevoi irpog aTroaToXrp^ 01
""^P
T(ov efxav TepaTovpyrjfxaTcov fxdpTvpeg, Tiva fxe eivat (f>aTe ; Trpo-

Tryj^S. §c vdXtv twv dXXm TleTpog, Kai TravTog Toy xopov yiverat

aTOfxa, Kai Tovg (piXoOeovg epevyeTat ^' av-


(fmvrjv dKpt^rf Se Trjg etg

Tov triaTecog tvjv ofxoXoyiav eK(pepet Xeycov " tov "KptaTOV tov Seov." ^o
aa(f>aXrjg 6 fxaSvjTrjgf ov ydp toi (prjatv dirXcog X.ptaTOV avTOV

eivou Tov Qeov, tov 'KpiaTov ^e fxdXXov. YlXe7aT0t fxev yap ol w$

^ Leg. vid. Koi T)]v (piXiOeov ip. «puvriv, iucf.


76 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA IX. 26.

ama •vav KiyifilaBai '^


Trapa Seov KaTo. tiacpopovi rpoTtovg wvofxa-

cfJievoi ^(jpiaroi' ol [Aev yap ey^^iaOvjaav elg ^aaiXeai, 01 ^e eig

vpotfyi^Tag, 01 ^e Kai T»?y S*' avrov irdvrcov "^ixaiv "Earvjpos 'KpiaTov

XaPovres Xvrpaaiv, rovTeariv yjfJi.eTs, Kai tm 'Ay/w TIvevjJLari

KaTaKey£iafj.evoif rrjv rov ^piarov KX^aiv eayj^Kafxev. oikovv 5

"TrXetaroi [xev 01 y^piarot' KeKki^vrai ^e ovrag d-no rov irpdyfxaros.


eli ^e Kai [xovog 6 rov Seov Kcti YiarpoSf oyp^ ag "yjfxav [xev ovrcov

y(j>taTwv Kai ov &eov [xaXkov, akk erepov rivog, dX\ wg avrov


Kai [xovov i^iov e-)(ovrog Ylarepa rov ev ro7g ovpavoTg. AvjXov ovv

eari rrji erepm itXrjGvog vcpe^aipoiv avrov, irpovevefxvjKe rx Tiarpi 10


wg ovra [xovov avrov. ©eof yap m <f>vaetf Kat Ik &eov Ylarpog

dva\d[xxpag dTropp^^Toog, 6 [xovoyevrjg avrov " Aoyog yeyove aap^^^


Kara ro yeypafxfxevov,

2,6 O9 yap av liraicryyvOrf /Lte kcli tovs ifiovy Xoyov^,


rovTov 6 vlo9 avOpmrov iiraLa-)(yvOr]a€TaL.

Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias. rioAAa Kara ravrov epyd^erat


yjpyjatfxd re Kat dvayKoia "^ta rovrm rm Xoycov. TrpSorov fxev

^etKVvaiv ort Trdvry] re Kat Trdvroog experat ro7g ala^Qjvofxevotg av-

rov Kat rovg aiirov Xoyovg ro rav 'laav rvyeiv. T/ ^' av yevotro
Tovrco ro laoararovv etg tvvafxtv eii6vft.iag ; el yap htatayvverat 20
T^vof l Kptrvjg, (cg eirocpeiXav avroig rov rrjg evJretOeiag fxiaOov,

Kat rvjg etg avrov ayditvig ra epya, Kat rov r^g ewoiag arecpavov,
vSig ovK eartv dvafi.(f)tXoycog enreTv, ort Tidvrrj re Kat iidvTag ev

areXevT^rotg eaovrat rtfxaig re Kat ^o^atg 01 rm ovroo Xafxitpm


rervyyiKoreg dyaBm ; etra irpog rovrotg (f)O0ov avroig evrtKret, 25

Kara^yjaeaBat Xeym e^ ovpavov, ovk ev afxtKpoTipe-neia rri Trpcorv]

Kat v(f)eaet ryjg Kaff yjfxdg, dXX ev ^o^rj ryj rov YlaTpog, ^opvcpo-

povvrm ^AyyeXm. ovkovv icayydXeTtov kou oXeSpov fxearov^ ro


KarayvcoaS^vat fxev eiit tetXta re Kai d(f>tXepyta, Kara^otT-^aavrog

avcoSev rov Kptrov Kat dyyeXiKwv rayfxdrm TteptearyjKOTCOv. fxeyao^o

^e Koi Tiavrog Oavfxarog d^iov Kai ryjg eig X^^iv ev^fxepiag irpo^e-

vov, TO evt roTg rl^y} TtpoTteTio^yifxevotg yaipetv avrovg, Kai ro vpoa-

doKJiv rm t^pcorm rag dfxoi^dg' enaiveOyjaovrat yap ot roiovrot,

c Ktxi>^<T6»i Cod. ^ Cod. oXe%jt*£(rTov.


IX. a;. AOTKAN ETAITEAIOT. 77

Xj9/<7Toi) AeyovTOf , " ^evTe oi evXoyyjfxevoi tov YlaTpog fxov, K\r]-


**
povoixvjaaTe TVjv v]TOi[xa<T[ji.€v/jv vfxiv ^acnkeiav aiio AcaTa/SoA^
" KoniKov.

KE4>. A.
Ilfpi T^s fjLeraiiofXpaxreays.
5

27 ToT ATTOT. Oi/7ra> T^v c| w^ou? ^vvafxiv ec^x^^KOTag Toi/f

fiaOrjTaSf eiKog rjv Taya itov Kai avSpioiTivaig TrepnreaeTv aaOe-

veiaig^ Kai ti toiovtov irepi avTOvg evvevoy}KOTag emeiv, Tiwg

apv^aeTai Tig eavTOv, yj Trag airoXeaag tvjv eayTov ipv^yjv evpriaei

TiaXiv avTVjV ; t/ ^e Tor^ toDto TraBovTi to laoaTaTovv eaTai 10

yepagy 17 Kai itoim eaTai yapiTfi.aTm fxeToypg ; \va toivvv Tm


ToiovTm avTOvg airoa-T-^ayj Xoyi(T[j.m, Kat otov fxeTayaXKevayi
irpog evav^ptav t^<,- ecro[xevyjg avToTg evKXetag eTTtdvfi.tav evTeKm,
*' **
Ae^yft) ^e v[/.iv" cf)yjatv, eiat Ttveg twv avTov eaTyjKOTm, ot ov
" [x-y} yevamrat QavaTov, eag av t^coai t>;v ^aatXetav tov ©eoD." 15
^aatXetav te Qeov (pyjatv avTvjv t^v 6eav Tyjg ^o^yjg, ev 17 Kat

avTog o(f)GyjaeTat Kar eKeho tov Katpov, Ka6 ov av e7rtXa[i.ily] ToTg

eiit Tyjg yyjg. yj^et yap ev ^o^yj tov Seov Kat UaTpog, Kat ovk
ev ye [laXXov a[KtKpoTrpeTieta ty] KaB yi[/.ag. Trwg ovv apa Seapovg
eTToieiTO Tov Bav[mTog rovg Xa^ovrag tvjv viioay^eatv ; aveiaiv eiri 20
to opogt Tpeig ai: avrm rovg airoXeKTOvg ep^wv, eha [KeTaitXaT-

rerat irpog e^atperov riva Kat BeoTrpeTiyj Xa[XTrpoTy)ra, uiare Kai


rov i[karia[t.ov avrov Tyj rov (poiTog Tipoa^oXyi^^taXafJ.xpat, Kat

oaov aTTaarpdxpat hoKeiV eira Moji/V^? Kat }rlXtag TrepiearyjKoreg


**
Tov Irjaovv •npoaeXdXovv dXX-^Xotg t>/v e^otov avTov ^v e[x,eXXe 25
**
irXrjpovv" (f^yjatv^
**
ev lepovaaXyjf/.,'^ rovreaTt r^g [/.era aapKog
otKovo[i.tag ro [Lvar-^ptov Kat ro awrriptov irdBog ro eTit ye, (f>y][Jii,

rw Tt[/.rj) aravpw. Kat yap eartv dXyjBeg ort KOf 6 ^ta MsouVecof

vo[i.og Kai Tcov aytm irpo(pyjrm Xoyog ro Kptarov [t.vaTy]ptov

Trpoavetei^av, [xev ev rinrotg Ka) aKtalg, [kovovov-^i KaBdirep ev^o


irtvaKt KaTaypd(pci}v avro' 01 he TroXvrpoTrag irpoyjyopevKoreg, wg

Kat o(f)Byjaerat Kara Kaipovg ev ettet r^g KaB "^ftMg, Kat ort rvjg

diravrm eveKa acoTTjptag Kat ^w^f ov irapair-^aerai ro TraBeh rov


eirt ^vXov Bdvarov. ovkovv yj ^wvaewg Kat 'Ha/ov Trapdaraatg
te EPMHNEIA TOT KATA IX. 37.

Koi TO TrpoXa^eTv aWrjKoii avTov$, otKovoixia rtg ^v, ew fJLaka


Kara^ciKVvova-a ^opv(f)of>ovfJievov jotev viro vofAov Kai vpo(f)i^Twv rov

K.vpiov v]fii.wv ^lyjaovv ^piarov, ax; Kai vofi.ov Kai TrpocpvjTCOv ^eaTto-

rvjV 'Jtpo^ei')(PevTa ^e iiap avrav ti o)V aXX-qXoig avvwta TrpoeK"^-

pv^av. aW 01 fnev fxaKoipioi fKa6r)Tai Ppayy nag aTrovvcrrd^ovatv S

wg rij irpoaev^^rj ayoXd^ovTog rov yipiaTOv. 'ETrAi^poyv yap


oiKovoft.iKZg Ta dvBpoontva' eira ^iaypyjyopovvregf Oecopoi yeyovaai

ryjg ovr^a aeirrYig kui irapo^o^ov fi.eTa(BoXyjg. oivjQetg ^e 'tacog

Seaireaiog Ylerpog ort Tdya trov evearfiKev Katpog TYjg Paatkeiag

rov Seovy diroteyeTat fj.ev rag ev tw opet ^tarpt^ag, aKvjvag Se 10

rpetg ^e? yeveaSat, (f^vjat, tw ILptar^ fuev fxtav, rag erepag ^e


MciJvo-^ Ka) HA/a* dW ovk "j^^et, (pyjaiv, Xeyet, ov yap rjv Kat-

pog TYjg avvreXeiag rov aiSovog, ovre fj.y)v rov y^ovov Xa^elv rovg

dyiovg ryjg eTr^yyeXft.evyjg avroHg eX^rt^og tvjv ft.e6€^tv. '£lg yap


JJavXog (pyjat, ft.eTaa')(y]fi^aTiaet ro afafia ryjg raTretvaaeag yjf/LZvi^

avfJifJioptpov r(p aafxart ryjg ^o^vjg avTov Kvpiovg ^yjkovort. ovayjg

ovv ev dpy^aig ert ryjg ciKovofJ.tag Kat ovTro) TreTrepaaft.evyig, Trwg ^v

etKog KaraXyj^at 'Kptarov ryfg etg rov KoafJLov aydiryjg, airo(f)OtTYi-

aavra rov TraSeiv vTrep avrov ; aeaccKe yap t^v vTrovpdvtov, Kai

avrov v7rofj.eivag rov Kara adpKa Sdvarov, Kai ^ta T^f eK veKpav 20
dvaardaecog Karapy-^aag avrov. qvk vj^et rotyapovv Tlerpog

onep e^pyj.

KE4>. AA.

Ilfpt Tov (reKr]Via^ofievov.

37 'EyeVero Se eV rrj e^s rjfLepa, KareXOoiJTcov avrcov 25

aTTO Tov opov9, CTVJjrjuTTjaeu avTco byXos iroXvs.


ToT ATTOT. A/a T>;v aYjV airtartav ovk evvjpyyjKev yj yaptg' ort

yap y£Yi fJ.eTa irtaTeag irpoatevat 'KpiarS) Kai rotg irap avrov
T^v Tov BepaTrevetv tvvaaBat KaTairXovr^^aaat ydptv, avrog YjfJ.ag

e^tta^e iravrayov rvjv irtartv airav irapa rcov Trpoatovrcov avrw, 30

ravTYig eveKa r-i^g atrtag Karevovjae ^iKaicog avrov "Kptarog Xeycov,


" co yevea aTrtarog Kat '^tearpa.ft.ft.evv], ecog rtvog eaofxat Trpog vfxag
" Kat dve^ofJMt y^wv." airtarov ^e yeveav eKeivov irov "Trdvrcog Kat
IX. 46. AOYKAN ETArrEAIOY. 79

TOVf 6[/.oyvo!)fJicvai (iKOiag aveKakei, koi ^i€(TTpa[X[M€vov, Kai Kar

ovhkva TpoTTOv opBotto^ih €i^0Ta. Trepi tcov toiovtxv (pyjai to ypaf/.-

ftxt TO UpoVf **
m al TpifSoi aKokiai Kai KafXTivKai al Tpoyjai
" avrZv." Kai fx,€T oXiya — E^e/ fxXv ovv tov tov ^atfxovSivTog

•naTpoq kv7TOvft.€Vov aireXBeh, Kai ov T€TV)(YjK0Ta T^f (f)i\oTtfXia$' 5

«AA tva fxri Ttg ot€Tat Kai avTOv aTOV^cat Xj9«7tov Trpog tyjv tou

vapa^o^ov KaT0p6a)(XtVy €'7r€Tifi.vj(T€ rco aKaQapTip TTvevfi.aTif Kai

irapa^x^^fi.a tc/u vo(T€7v dirrjWdTT^TO, Kat diro^c^ooK^v avrov tco

vaTpt avTov' ov yap yjv €Tt tov irarpog, aXXa tov KparovvTog Ttv€v-

fxaTog. Eire/^^ §e «Treae/craTo rriv irXeove^tav, yeyove TtaKtv touio


loiov vaTpo^f Kpt(TTOv Oe to Occpov.

KE<^. AB.

Hepi tS)v BidKoyi^ofiivav Tis fiei^av.

46 KtPIAAOT AaEBANAPEIAS. YldOog &*/ OVV ^taKCVOV ^O^VJS €t(7-

^c^pdfxyjKe Tiva tc5v dytwv ATrocTToAcyV to yap oXoog 'ttaXoyi^eaBat 15


TO T/f aV €ty] fXet^COV aVTOOV, <p€tX0V€tKGVVT0g T0VT€(7TI Kat to

Ttpo€(TTavat Twv dWcov cTrtSvfx-^aavTog' aAX' Tot Ttdvra €it(bg "Kpt-

arog 6 ©eof ly^wv, tov ev t'^ tov fxa9v}Tov "^tavoM "^taXoytafxov,

(oairep Ttva TttKptav avo (f>vovaav Kara ro yeypafXfxevoVj irptv €tg

vrpog ap^vat, iipiv a^pvv6i^vatf €K pt^vjg avrijg dvaj3adp€V€t ro 20

KaKoV dpypfL€va ydp ev vjfxh rd TtdQvj vtKa p(^t(ag, d^pvvSevra

Se ^vaavoPkvjrd eart. Ucog ovv dpa ro (f)tXo^o^ov iidQog diro-

K€tp€t irvevfxdroov larpog ; eireAa/SeTO to Tiat^lov Kat eaTVjaev

avro irap eavrw. w(f>€\€tag Se 'Xjxptv €7rot€7ro ro ypi^fxa, Kat avTo7g

ro7g dyiotg AiroaroXotg, Kat vjfxTv ^e roTg fX€T cKeivovg. Tlapa- 25


/3oaK€Tat yap vj rotd^€ voaog, wg eirtirav Trdvrag dvdpooTrovg, €nr€p

av €i€V €V VTrepoyv] t^ Kard rtvoov. Ttvog ovv dpa rvirov Kai


€iKova ro irapevey&kv €Trot€7To Trat^^iov ; dirovvjpov t€ Kat d(ptXo^o^ov
^(tivjg' aKaTr-^X€vrov ydp ^yet rviv yva>fi.viv, dva>6€VT0v tvjv Kap^tav,

Kat eaTtv ev dirXorvjTt ttaXoytafxm' ov (fyiKoto^iag epa, ovk o/Scv 30

VTT€poyQ^g rpoirov. Wtrd (pvjatv, " ort og av ^e^vjrat ro TraiYtov


" TOVTO €Trt rw ovofxart fxov" Kat rd e^vjg, tovto eariv, 6 fxtKpo-
80 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA IX. 49.

repog ev 7ia,aiv v/jliv vitapy^av, ovTog earai /xe^ya^, tov ixdTpio^ppova

Xeycov Kat ov^ev vxpi^Xov 7tep\ avTOv Xoyi^Ofxevov ^i evXa^eiaV


yeypaTTTai yap " oti itag vipav eavTOV TaireivtaByjaeTaiy Kai 6
" Taneivav eavTOv vxpood-^aeTai.^^

KE$. Ar. 5

Uepl Tov fir} fTTiTpenofievov aKoXovBetv.

49 E^zrwv Se KvayyeXtaTTji nepi ^ladvvov tov dteX(f>ov 'la/ccu-

/3ov, OTi TTpog Tov }^vpiov eiTiev " eiiiaTdTa, ei^o[i.ev Ttva eni to5
** aov eK/SdXXovTa ^atfxovta Kai eKwXvaafxev awTOv," ov/^
ovofJiaTt

wg (pGovi^advTCOv tc5v Attoo-toAwv tovto (prjaiv, dXX ag a^tovvTcov 10

fjLaSeTv. E/ ^e eTepoig e^eaTt tovtc ^pav, '^to koi avTog ^todaKUV

avTovg dvTaireKpiBvj, fx^ KooXveTe tov avvTpt^ovTa tov SaTavav ev

TcS ovofxaTi fJiov, ov ydp eaTt Kaff vfiav, tpyjaiv, TOiovTog. oaTig Qe

ovK eaTi KaS vft.a>v, viiep vfxav eaTi tuv ayaTrcovTcov fj.e, oiTtveg ra
eig ^o^av fj.ov TiXi^povv BeXovat, Tvj itap efKov '/dpiTi aTe(f>avovfJ.evot. 15

T/ eVT;v onep (pyjaiv, OTt " eyeveTo ev tw avfj.TrXripovaBai Tag


^I
" y]fj.epag Trjg dvaX-^xpeag avTov ;' OTt evaTdvTog tov Katpov Ka9

bv edet XotTTOv to awT-^ptov vnep vjfMV vTrofA.etvavTa iidSog, ava/3^vai

f*.ev etg tov ovpavov, avve^^pevaai ^e tw Qew Kat YlaTpi, eKpivev

dveXBeh elg 'lepoaoXvfna,, ovKeTt w^e KaKeiae iiepiepyofJ.evog, ovhe 20


Tiepio^evwv KWff.ag Kat iioXeig. tovto yap ^YiXo^i to " eaTYjpt^e to
**
Tipoawnov avTov.^^ KKnefKTiei dno itpoawTiov avTov Tovg fj.a6vjTag,

ovK dyvowv wg cvk eaovTai ^eKTOt napa twv YiafuxpetTwv, irpoKa-


TayyeXXovTeg avTOv ent tw KaTaXvaat nap avTolg, dXX tva

KaKetvotg ndaav d(popfj.riv Jipocpdaewg eKKOipvj, Kat To7g f/.a6viTaig 25

w(f)eXeiag yevrjTat iipo^evog. YiTteiVfi ydp dve(3atvev eig 'lepoao-

XvfiM, Tov TOv TidBovg Kaipov Yj^^vj cj^cov yetTova, Kat efxeXXe T^g

loyb^a/wv dveyeaBai napoivtag, tva fj)f\ aKav^aXtaBwatv ot av Tia-


OovTa t^^watv, dve^tKaKct ^e fj.dXXov Kai ainoi yevwvTat, Kav v^pt-

^wat Ttveg rj aitoQtwKovaty Tipoyvfj.vaafj.a tcv •npdyfj.aTog t^v €^^30

TcSv JlafxapetTwv v^ptv eTiotvjaaTO, waavet Xeywv avToHg' el yap


Kat ovK e^e^avTO vfj.dg, vfj.eHg ToHg efJiXiTg tov ^ecriroTou fxyeatv
IX. 51. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 81

(^aKdXovBrjaavrig, ^iaKapTep^^aare dyioirpeTragf odiv fcai elitovToov

€K rav [xadv^raVf " Kvpiff QeXtig etinofxev irvp Kara^vjvat airo rov
" ovpavov Kai avaXwaai avrovg ;" eirerifxyicTev avroigf irepKrreXXaov

6eoTtpe'7t(ag rrjv o^vQvfxiav, Kai neiQcav ave^iKaKeh, ov fjiovov rore,

akXa Kai eig ra }j.era ravra, yjviKa rrjv wr ovpavov ^iepypfievot, 5

efneWov avoaioig riai "jrepiTrnrreiv av^pa<7iv, ovk avey^ofKevcov rov


Beiov KvjpvyfuiTog. ei^evai yap 'Xjpyj,
011 wg fXYjTiQ) rvjg veag KeKpa-

n^Koreg yapirog, aX\ eri t^c Trporepag e-ypfi.evot (rvvyjBeiag, rovro


€tirov ", rov HXiav acpopavreg rov irvpt KaracpXe^avra ^ig rovg

TtevTriKovra Kat rovf yjyovfJievovg avrwv. lo


Ylept rov fJLvj eirtrpeTrofxevov aKoXovOeiv TtpoeypatpYi eig ro Kara
Mar6a7ov.
O oe etTrciv, " aKoXov6r}cr(a <Joi, Kvpte," vpwrov te eirtTperpov fioi

aTrord^aaQai lovg ev tc5 otKca fxov, d^to^riXarov fxev viroayeaiv

eve^ei^aro, Kara iravrog eiraivov fxearYjV' ro te ye ^vjreiv dirord-it


^aaQat Tor? etg rov oIkov avrov, ^ta^etKvvatv ori fxefxeptarat irag

Trj havota' ro yap oXccg irpoaavaKatvovaSat BeXetv rotg Kara


yevog oiKetotg roHg fxvj diro^e^afxevotg, ea& ore rov eirt rovrco rco

Trpdyfxart aKoireiv, ov /3e^vjKorog eari Xoytafxov' ^to Kui (f^Y/ai

irpog avrov, " ovtetg eirilSaXm tyjv


X^^P^ ^'^ dporpov Kat arpacpetg 20
**
etg ra oirtaco, evOerog eartv eig rv]v jSaatXetav rov Qeov." Q.airep

yap yyjiTovog r^g ^ia rm aporpcov dvaroft.Yig dp^dfxevog, orav

OKVvjavj Ttpog lo Xentov tod Ttavrt irovca, ovy^ oxperat rotg aarayy-
atv KOfxwaav tijv yvjv, TrpoaocpX^^aet Se ro7g opcaat Kai yeXcara,

ovrcog ei rig eX.otro fxev dKoXovSvjaat \ptaTw to) Sew, ovk drro- 25

rdaaerat %\ rotg ev to5 Koafxc^ Trpdyfxaai, Kat roig Kara adpKa


otKeiotg, Kat fi.dXtara rolg ft.Y] rov aKonov diro^^eyjtfxevotg avrov,

ov^^afkac ovrog KaropBwaet ro7g e<p airaat ° rolig eiraivovfxevotg

dyaBvjv evroXfxtav, ovhe evOerog earat eig rvjv rov Seov /SaatXeiav.
eirt^dXXei fxev aporpco rvfv y^e^pa, ttort irpoBvfLog eartv eiraKo- 30

Xov6etv, oiriaco Se ^Xenet, ^tort fxeXX^aecog koi dva^oXvjg irotelrat

Ttpocpaatv Tv]v irpog rovg otKetovg ^tdX.e^tV dXX ov roiovrovg ovrag

evpvjaetg rovg dyiovg AiroaroXovg. Afxa ydp vjKovaav toi) ^eaird-

n fhuv Cod. o itjiuitaTi Cod.


M
82 EPMHNEIA TOT KATa X. i.

**
Tov X.pi<rTOv XeyovTO^ Ttpog avTovg^ SevTf OTtiad) /otov," evQecog

a(f>€VT€i TO Ttkohv Kai Tov iraTepa avxwi/, yjKokovdyjaav avTw.


TOiovTOv; ovv TTpo(7y}K€i Tvyyaveiv Tovg aKoXovBeiv eQekyiaavTag tc5

0ew. f

KE*. AA. 5

Ti.epX tS)v dva8eix0evTCi)V o.

I Mera 5e Tavra avlbei^ev 6 KuyOioy Ka\ irepovs 6/35o-

firjKovTa.

TiTOT BosTPttN. TovTov TVTtog ev ToHg MwvVeojf eypdcpeTo


Xoyoig' Qeov yap TrpoirTaTTOVTog, e/S^oix-^KOVTa 63reAe|aT0, CTny- i o

<f>i€i Se To7g e^eiXeyiJ.evoig to rTvey/xa ©eow' Kai Kaff eTepov §e

TpoTTOV, Tovg T€ ^vo Kai ^eKa fxaQYiTag Kai avTovg b'e Tovg e/3^o-

fXYjKovTa, ^ia T^f Tou vofAOV (TKiag aYj[xaivofJ.evovg evpvjaofi.ev'

*'
yeypanTai yap ovTcog ev t'^ e^o^co irepi twv u/a5v lcrpayjk' riX-

" fiov," (pi^aiVf " eig AiXafx" Ipfii^veveTai ^e eig avdj^aaiv, vjyovvi^

elg av^yjaiVf " Ka) "^aav e/ce?," (pvjaiv, " '^clo^^eKa v^^aToov Trvjya/,

'*
Kai e(3^ofi.'^KovTa aTeXeX"] (f^oiviKCDV.^^ dva^aivovTeg yap eig

TcXeioTepav avveaiv, Kai eig av^Yjaiv avaTpe-)(0VTeg tvjv Trvevfna-

TiKYjv Tag ^voKai^eKa TTYjyag evp-^aofi.ev, TovreaTi, Tovg dyiovg

'AiroaToXovg, Kai toc eptoff.^^KovTa tZv (f)oiviKOov aTekeyvj Tovg 20

dvo^eiy^pevTag ^vjkovoTi iiapa 'KptaTov' apvofxevoi yap wg eK

•nviym dyim eK twv tov 'EaT^pog rjfMov fxaBfjTm iiavTog ei^vjaiv

ayaGov.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias. Kai eiret^y] nokkyj Ttg efxekkev

eaeaBat tcov eig avTOV TitaTevovTCtiv yj iikyjBvg, eaayyjveveTO ya-p ov 25

fnovov 6 lapavjk, dkka yap Kai ai tS>v e$vcov ayekat' Ota tovto

dve^ei'/6y]aav itapa \piaTov tov Qeov yjft.ci>v Tipog Toltg ^vo Kai

^eKa Kai erepoi e/SSo/x^/fOVTa. T« dKokovBa tovtcdv oiov " fnev

" 6eptafi.og Tiokvg^^ Kat Ta e^vjg. Kai " fLy] f>.eTal3aiveT€ e^ otKiag

" eig oiKiav" mep peff.l3aaft.ov '^yjko^, Kot fLtaQov aiTovvTcov Kat ^/a-30

^okvjg eaTt TeKfiyjptov. Ylpo€ypd(f>€TO eig to KaToc MaTOaiov. Eti


^e Kat To. TOVTcov dKokovda ecog w^e' " Ve efif aSeTcov aSeTei tov
'*
aTToaTetkavTd fne."
;

X. 7. AOTKAN ETArrEAlOT. 88

2 ""EXcyeu ovv Trpos avrovSi 6 fieu Oepur/JLO^ TToAuy, ol


Se ipyaraL oXlyot.
TiTOT BosTPON. "ClcTTtip jap aypoi KOfxa>VT€i TtXovamg
evpeTg re Kai fxaKpo) iroWovi i^rjTovai tov^ 6epi(7Tai, ovt<c( vj

(TV{j.'na<ja yvjf tjtoi twv p.f.\KovT(ov Trt(7T€veiv (i^ Xp/crTov yj 7JA17-5

6vif iroAX^ Ti^ ovaa kai avaplG^rjTogi ovk oXiym i^dno ^uo-Ta-
y(tyyav. ePd^i^ov ovv ava ^vo TiefJi.TrOfxevoi KaTa TioXeig Kai Kaix.ag,
**
p.ovovovy\ (3oavT€g to Sioc T^f 'laavvov ^ojv^f, €ToiixaaaT€ o^ov
**
Kvpiov.'^ "TrXyjv €K€ivo aQpei' e/Vwv yap to " ^e-^Oi^Te tov Kvpiov
'*
ToD depiafxov, onag eK^dkrj epyaTag €ig tov SepKXfJiov avTov" 10
toDto 'n€iipay€V avTOg Kanoi tov Qepiafxov Kvpiog, tovt€(xti twv

hti T^g yra' Tiq av €»7 Trapa tov (f)v(7€i Kai aXyjQag ovTa Oeov
" ayTOu yap rj av[xi:a(Ta yr] Kai to TrX-^pafxa avTrjg" KaBa y€-

ypaiTTai' eha Tr<Jo<; fxovwg TtpeiiovTog tc5 €tii TravTcov ©eaj tov

€K^aX€7v Toiig IpytxTag TovTovg dvf^ei^ev X.pKTTog' avTOg dpa 15

e<TT/v Toy Bepiafxov ^eaTtOTrjg, Kai '^t avTov t€ Ka\ avv avTa Ka^dp-
y€t tS)v oXoov Seog Kat YlaT-^p. t^ta ^e TtdvTa eaTtv avTov, Kai

cyOev e<TT/v ccv av ej^e/v llaTYip XeyoiTO, a fxrj €aTi Kat tou Iiov.

ToT ATTOT. TIpoXey€i he avTolg Kat tov ^icoyfxov, tva eveyKcoat

Trj "TTfipa Tag avvB-^Kag, fnrj j3aaTdl^€T€ ^aXdvTtov, fxr} /BapeiTe 20


dpyvpto) TOv wfxoV dpxeT yap vfi.iv ^e^aprjaSat TJj (ppovTi^i tov

Xoyov Tr}v ^tdvotav' fxrj ev tco ^aXavTica t*/v eXTtita tov dpfov

€y€T€, dXX ev t» TrefxxpavTt TiBeaSe tt^v <f>povTtda' fxrj^eva KaTo,

T^v o^ov dairdai^aOe, fxrj tovto €fi.itottov tov KrjovyfxaTog yevrfcat

OfxtXiag ev fxeaca vapaTTtTiTovarjg koi ^pa^vTrjTOg irpocpdaei, fxrj- 25


'hffxta Ttg ^ta/3oXtKr] KaKovpyta vfiMg aTroairdar}' ov yap KaT
dvoKX-^pctiatv ^a}a€T€ Tr^v irpoarjyoptav, aAX' vfi.(7g fxev tov Aoyov

OaaeTe, oirov Oe 17 a^/ov eiravairavaeTat to irpayfxa. \^i 6e fxr],

€<f> vfxdg avaKdfxt^ft' ov yap dirX^g pnrT€Tat, dXXd Kpiaet Trj €fxy

PdXXeTat. 30
n M77 iJL€Ta^aip€T€ i^ olKiaf ety olKiav.

TouTo yap p€fx^ofxev(i)v Kai fxiaQov atTovvTCCv, Kat aaTaatag


tpyov, Kat "tia^oX-^g TeKfxrjpiov ^e^rjKOTeg ^e yiveaOe «ai dfX€Ta-

KlVrjTOl TOV vovv.

M 2
84 EPMHNEIA TOY KATA X. ii.

11 Kal Tou KovLopTov Tov KoXXrjOevTa iQfuv Ik ttjs tto-

Aeo)? v/icov airoixaaaofxeda vfuv.

OpirENOTS. Tfflv yap dfxapT^i^fxdTcov vixav o KovtopTO<; tiKaioog

av e/f vixdg eTraveXQr]. Trapar-^pet ort ai [xv} iiapo^e^/oixevai tov$

ATioaToXovg Kai t>?v vytrj ^thaaKaXiav irokeig, eyovat TrkaTeiag $


avdXoyoV to " 7rXaTe7a Kat evpvyoopoq yj o^og rj ayovaa ets tv}V

" aTraXeiav, Kai iroXXoi elaiv ot "^iep^ofxevoi ^t avTvii.^^

1 2 Aeyo) de vfxlv otl ^obojxoLS iv Trj rjfxepa eKeivrj aveKTo-


Tepov ecTTaL.

TiTOT BosTPCN. 'E7re<S>7 eU '^o^ofxa ovk aTreaTaXYjaav Atto-io

aToXot, edv Totvvv [Xfi ^e^uvTai vfxdg Tovg hiioaToXovg, yeipovg

eaovTat ovTOt eKetvm.

^3 Ovai (TOL X.opa0v, ovai (tol BrjdaaLda, otl el iv Tvpcp

Kcu ^lBcovl iyevovTO, Kal r. e.

OvToi 01 TOTTOt ^lovtaiKo) eTvy^avov, Tvpog Be Kat Yt^wv 'EA-15

XyjviKoi. Hvifxaivei Toivvv 6 Kvpiog, OTt ei ev TOig eGveatv eyevovTO

ai '^vvdfxeig, paov dv eirtaTevov vjiiep vfxelg' eXey/et toivvv Tag

^iov^aiKdg TroX.etg, Koi dvTtTrapaTtBYjai twv 'KXXvjvtKccv iroXeav


Tag yeipovg. Kat ydp ovTCcg ex^h 'r« ^^^V po.t^'^? (TrtaTevaaV

\ovta7oi Ve efxetvav aTriaTot, KatTrep TroXXvjv eayv}KOTeg tov Xoyov 20

TVjV eTrtfxeXetav. M^ Xv7re7a6e OTav dTretOaaiv vfj.Hv, fxvj^e XeyeTe


Tt virdyofxev v^ptaBvjvat ; ov^^etg vjfxoov dvex^Tat' 6 aKovccv vfLiv

efxov dKovet, ovTe dv irtaTevafi Tig, vfxelg eaTe '^vaonTrovvTeg, ovTe

edv dvTtXeyaatv, vfieig ecrre 01 evedpevovTeg, j^/JiyaaTe fxoi tv}v

yXSoTTav, ey<j} irapeyja tv}v ydptv, a6eTZv vfxdg, efne aSeTei' etg 25
efji.e ydp dvaTpeyei v} vfxeTepa v^pig.

Upoetpv}Tai OTt direaTetKe Tovg e0^ofxv}KovTa' ^to vvv Xeyet

OTi vireaTpetpav fxeTa yapdg, ag e7raKoXovBv}adav}g rcS Xoyca TVfg

Beoae^eiag' ekeyov yap, " Kvpte, Kat Ta ^aifJLOvia viroTdaaeTat


" y}fuv ev T(p ovofnaTt aovJ^ ovy^ ovrco Se yatpovTeg OTt p.dXX.ov ^o
yeyovaai tov Qetov KV}pvyfxaTog ^tdKovot, tovto eiirov, Kat OTt

v}^tavTat yepcov AiroaToXiKiov, «AA' otI avifxeicov yeyovaatv diroTe-

Aecrra/. Oirep Se, <pv}atv 6 XpiaTog Trpog avToi/g, " oti eOewpovv
X. 13- AOYKAN ETArrEAIOT. 85

**
Tov Saravav, wg aorpaTnjv neaovTa eK tov ovpavov" tovto

^y]ko7j OTt €1 apycov avTwv KaTeireaeVf o\ ^ovKoi. ti TrpoaQoKaai

^vvacrdai '^paaaf Xeyet Se ecopoKeyaif cirei^Yj aXXog ov '^vvaTai

l^67v Yj KpiTVj^ 6 aopaTog' wg daTpaTrvjv ^e e*7r€v, oti XafXTrpog

v]v Trjv <f>v<Tiv^ €1 Kai aKOToei^yjg yeyove tvjv irpoaipeaiv' b yapi,

eTroirjaev 6 Seog, tovto KaXov. Aio [xy] fiay/x,a^eTe, <f)y}ai, /xij^e

fjLeya (f^poveTTe' eyu yap ^e^ccKa vimTv t>jv e^ovatav.

KaTt Se Kat ovtw ka^eh irept tovtov KaTa tov aytov KvptX-

Aov, OTt wg daTpaTtYjV Ik tov ovpavov et^e ireaovTa tov tid^oXov,

TovTeaTtVf e| vxpovg etg yvjv KaTevyjveyfxevoVf ck "^o^yjg eig dTtfxtav, lo

e^ ta^/vog itokXvjg etg ecr^^aTvjv daBevetav. Ylpo fxev yap T^g tov

^ptaTov Koi Seov Kat ^ccTi^pog y^fxm eTit^yjft^iag KUTeKpaTyjae T^f

vff ovpavoV TTpoaeKvv^drj ay^e^ov Tcapa ndvTm' vaoi TravToy^ov

Kat ^(OfKot Kai Bvatat. eTret^y] ^e KaTaite^pony^Kev e^ ovpavm o

fi.ovoyevy]g Tew ©eoS Xoyog, TreirrctiKev eKeivog ag aaTpaiiy]^ o Trav-i^

Tag e^yjtiv irpoaKvvrjTag Tovf "^evkavyjfiLevovg, viro irodag TeQetTat tcSv

TrpoaKvvovvTcov avTOV.

Kat 0(f>etg ^e Kat aKopiriovg avTO tovto ^y]ko7 ag Trept avTov


Te Tov ^ta{3okov elpr]fxevov Kat tcHv ^atf/.ovxv avTov, otTiveg avv
avTio KaTairaTovvTat vtto twv ^ovAwv 'KptaTOV tov Seov ly^Sv, t^v 20

TO/ai;T>jv e^ovaiav Kafx.^dvovTeg vir avTov.

To ^e, *'
fj.ri yaipeTe OTt Ta itvevfi.aTa vfuv vnoTaaaeTai^^
TovTO ayjfiLatvety tva ft,^ Kevo^o^iav eK tovtov KTriaovTat. Kat yap
aXkot eia}, <py]atv, 01 €K tovtov evepyeTovfKevot, ot t% tdaecog

SijAovoT/ KaTaJ^tovfi.evot' dkka fi.akkov ev tovtco yaipeTe, OTt to. 25


ovofiaTa vfxwv yeypairrat ev To7g ovpavoTg, ov %ta fxekavog, dkkd
ttd fjLvy]fi.yjg Ka) ydptTog Kat %o^y]i Seov. Kai 6 aev %id(3okog
avcodev KaTaTrtnTei, ot ^e dvSpooTTot KdTO> ovTeg ava ypd(povTai.

avTV] Toivvv eo"T*v 17 aA>j5;v^ %*/'*> "^^ ^^^ ypd(f>ea6at. ypd(f>eTat

Se eKaaTog oaov edv Kafiyj tw Te d^icjoft.aTi, Ka\ ty] t^s" evepyeiag ^o


XdpiTt.

Ta aKokovSa TOfTO) olov, " avTyj t-Jj copa v^yakkiaaaTO tco

**
7ivevfj.aTt \r]aovg. '
Kat " fx.aKdptot ot o(f)6akfiot 01 /3ke-

TFOVTeg d /SXeTreTf." Kat irep) tov eTrepuTrjaavTog vofxtKov, ecag


86 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA X. 25.

" KUt rov TrXyjaiov aov co^ eayrov*" vpoeypacpr] c/f to Kara
M.arSaTov.

OpirENOTS. Ov fxaKpav to **
TidvTa fJioi Trape^^oQy] viro tov
" YlaTpo; fxov^ 6a"Ti, Kai ro " €^o6v] [xoi naaa e^ova-ia ev ovpavca
n Kai eTTi
' ' ^ ~ )> ^ 5> * ~
Kai Oia tovto avTo) OiOoTai Traaa
> ~ ^ /'^ ~ 'e
egovcria,
' "
iva$
^
yyjg.

eip^^voTioffjo-yi "bia tov uTavpov avTOv' eiTe ra eiri TTjg yyjg, €iT€

Ta ev TOig ovpavo7g. ov^eTtco /xev ovv ra itdvTa eipyjvoTroiyjcyev, cog

'^yjXov eaTt eK tov tov dito Tyjg KaKiag viiapyeXv '7roXe[xov' eaTai
^c TrdvTccg yj reXeia elpyjvyj. ^iKatoraTa ^e Tidvra Trapa^e^iiKev
avTco Ylar-fjp' eirei Kai avrog 6 Tiog irape^oBiq VTtep TtdvTCCv, og 10
eari Ylaryip irdvTcov dvSpooTrcov, fxdkicrra inaTm, Kai *'
iXacTfkog

" ecjTt "nepi rcov dfj.apTia)V ^/xwi'," ov Tcept rwv yjfLerepcov he fLovov,

aXXa Kai Ttepi oXov rov KoafLOV. vape^^oSy] ^e KaOo yeyovev av6pcc-

TTog, ** iva ev rco Qvoft.aTi {.yjorov Tidv yovv Kafnxpyj eitovpavicov Kai
" eniyeicov Kai KaraySovicov, Kai Tidcja yXcocrcra e^oft.oXoy^cterai 15
**
ori K.vpiog lyjcTovg 'K.pKrrog, elg to^av ©eou naT^os-, aft.y]v^^

TiTOT BosTPftN. ATTOKdXvxpig ecxTi fieTd^oaig yvcocrecog irpog

ro fxerpov rvjg eKdarov (pvcrecog re Kai ^vvdff.ecogf Kai onov fxev

OfjiOia <pvc7ig, eKel yvcocng dvev '^i^aaKaXlag' evravOa ^e ef dno-


KaXvxpecog fi.d6y]<xig. eTtnr^pei roivvv, itcog evravda fLev eK ydpirog, 20

eKel Ve €k (pvaecog.

KE4). AE.
Hepi Tov eTrepcoTTjaavTOS vofUKOv.

25 Kat Ibov vofXLKos TLs dpeaTTj, ^Kireipd^cov avrov.


KitaiveSeig VTto rov 'Ecor^pog 6 vofKiKog, ttjv dXa^oveiav e^eppyj-

^ev, ov^eva eivai 7tXy]cnov avrov riSe^evog, wg ovhevog ovrog avrov 25


Kara ryjv ^iKaiocJvvYjV ecpafXiXXov. Toi/to ydp e^^eiKvvro Et/ay-

yeXiaryjg elnuv, " ^e SeXcov tiKaicocrai avrov Ttpog rov ly]<70vv

*'
e/Ve, rig eari fxov itXy^aiov ;" vofxiKog -nXy^aiov fxovov evofxi-

^ev elvai rov tiKaiov t» ^iKaico, rov vipyjXov t® v\py]X^, Kar


dperyjv, (j>y]fxi. ov ydp rv] ovaia fxta. ovayj ro vxpy]Xov eAfp/vev, 30
«AA' ^ ro7g d^tiofiaaiv, ^ raig itpd^eaf '^to BeXcov avrov OiKatco-

aat, rovreart ^iKaiov dno^e^^aif ug vxpi^Xog etrj Kara Tiyv ap€TY]v,


X. 30. AOTKAN EYArrEAIOT. 87

jtxeyaf Kara to ^i^aaKaXov eivat, (pvjai " Kai rig eari [xov
^
TTA.vja-iov; oei^ov ff.ot rov ovra fxeyav o Oe l^Qir-ifip are Or]

voivjrYig, f/.iKpov yap Kai fj.eyav avrog e3roii^o"€V, ov raHg iipaJ^eaiv

Of^e rcn^ a^iwfxaaiv, aXka T17 <f>vaet (opiaaro rov TtXvjatov, fxovov-

ov)() Xeyccv, oviroi aot reag keyet ort ov^ev r<av aXKm tievrjVoyeVf 5

iva fKvi 01 ovroog <f>tXaperoi vofLtaaat ft.v] y£eo)are7v rofg ireXag rrfV

ayaitvjv, ^oyfjLa rov aov eXey^fov vofxiaavreg eivat, aXXa Kat ei

ovrwg e^xet' ^e^oaSd) yap aTtov^ag rov deofnevov yeveadai irXvjatoVf

ov roo ToVco fnovoVf aXXa Kai rvj '^iaBeaet, Kat t'^ e/f avrov eirtjxe-

Xeia' ^ta yap rovro Kat rov Yaff.apeiri^v aot eyapaKrviptaa' ro yap 10
vXvjaiov ryj <f)vaet Kptverat ov r"^ aperri, ov r^ ovata, ov too

a^tafxari, aXXa rv} avfXTraBeia Kai tw rpova t^? Qepaiieiag'

eKnvov ow vfyov fxdXtara iiXvjatov etvat rov ^eofxevov, Kat avre-

vdyyeXrog ent t^v Po-^Seiav ^d^t^e.

KE4>. Af. 15

Hepl Tov ffiireaovros els Toiis Xpords.

30 " AvdpioTTog rig Karef3aive aTco 'lepovaaXvjfL,^^ rvjv dvjoQev KaQo-

Qov rov avSpwTTOv atvtrrojxevog rovro <f)V]atv, vjrtg ^ta rvjg rov

AoafX "jrapal^daecog diro rvjg inpvjX^g Kot daraatdarov Koi Qeiag


rov TrapaOeiaov ^iarptj3vjg, 'lepovaaXvjfL evKaipwg ovofxaaSeiavjgy 20
OTrep eipvjvvjv P avjfxatvei Qeov, irpog rvjv leptyw r^v KOtXvjv Kai

yQafi.aXvjv, Kat ra Kavfxart Trvtyvjpav KarcoXiadvjae. tvjXoi Se

rvjv efXTraSvj rovte rov Koafxov ^ct>>;v ywpi^ovaav Qeov' Xvjarag

Se Ae-ye; to twv dypioiv ^aifJiovxv avarrifxa, otrtveg rav r^g dpervjg

ifxarim, dv^piav (f>vjfi.i, Kai aa^ppoavvvjv Kat rd Ofxoia, eK^^vaavreg 25


afTOv, ra rvjg dfxaprtag rpavfxara KaraXnrovreg ev avroo, dirvjXSov

Oevreg YifxiQavvi' Kat yap ovk eart rovrotg oXcog evyepeia rov
TtXrprretv, et fi.v] irpoXa^ovreg avXi^aaat rd rav dperav irepi^O'
Xaia, oQev fxera rovro iiXvjrrovatv d(f>ei^wg Kai fxey^pt Bavdrov.

ov yap rv]v dpervjv eKOvaai airov^^al^wat fxovov, dxXd Kat r^g ^o


vjfi.erepag epaatv dvcoXetag, E,7retdv] ^e t^$" AevirtK^g tepcoavwjg

P flfnifjUyov Cod.

i
88 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA X. S5-

ovoixaTog eartv (lavjyYjTrig, ^ia tov lepia^ Kai tov Aei/iTov Tr(v

avci}(peXy^ TQv vojxov a-y][xaiv€t Trapo^oV ov^^e yap Ta$ TtXvfyaq tov
"^
TrapaTienTCtiKOTOt; eig Tovg XvjaTag eOepdirevaeV a^vvaTOv yap
'*
aifxa Tavpm Kat Tpdyoov d(f)eXeh diJ.apTiag" Kai eTrer^e fxev,

riTOVfjae Se, Kai irpog TeXeiav SepaTreiav ovk vjpKeaev, ovTe Ketfxevov S

dveaTrjae' to yap " dvTnrapyjkBe'^ ^yjXoT OTt ov Trapahevae KaTa-


Xeixpag dQeaTov, dXX eaTr} Kai eBedaaTo^ Kai QepaTievaat ^tevorjBvj

Kol ecp-^xpaTO' irpog ^e t^v Qepaiteiav d^vvaT-^aag, t-^ twv TrXvjyZv


rjToi Twv TraSitiv eTriKpaTeta viKrj6eig, etg Toviriaa TidXtv dTretpajxe'

TOVTQ yap TO " dvTtiraprjXBev^ ev^^etKvvTat. lo

'AAA' nrdaav Tr^v dvSpcoirivvjv (pvaiv ^id Trjg dirapyrig tov

^vpdixaTog TreptGefxevog, ev jj
navTog vjv eSvovg to fnepog, hv^atov
Te Kai 'ZafxapeiTOv Kai '
EiXXvjvog, Kat irdvTm aira^ avOpwirm,

TOVTOv fxeTa tqv aaixaTog, oirep eaTtv vTro^vytov, tco totto) TVjg

Tov dvSp<07rov KaKaaeag e-ntaTag, twv TpavfxdTm eSepdirevae. Kat 15

ydp '^tevaev dXyjSwg, ov irapa^tevaeV avTO tovto irpocpaatv 'o^ov

Trotrjadfxevog to vjfxdg eirtaKerpaaSat, Ot ovg Kat KarvjXSev eiri

T^f y^f, ^; ovg Kat KaTeXvaeV ov yap cocpSvj fxovov, dXXd Kai

avvaveaTpd(j)ri ToTg avSpwirotg, KaTa aXvjSetav "XJ^ptg TpoTrvjg Kat

(pavTaatag yevofxevog avSpwirog' tovto yap t^iov tuTpm yvv]aiwv20


Kai (ptXoaTopym to avvavaaTpe^peaSat ToHg appwaTOvai, Kat fi.vj

a(f)taTaaSat irpiv dv vytaivxaiv. oSev Kai olvov Tolg 'eXKeatv eirav-

TXm Tov ^i^aaKaXtKOV Xoyov Kat eTrtaTV(f>ovTa, eXaica tovtov eKe-

paaeV ov yap oiov tc yjv aKpaTOV avTOV eveyKeh' ov ydp vTreft.eive

T^v v7rep(3dXXovaav aTvxptv to Tm TpavfxdT(av yaXeirov Kat avta- 25

Tov* oSev ^td TovTO dft.apTCi}Xoig Kat TeXwvatg avvaveKXtveTO. eirt

TO ;^;ov ^e vno^vytov dve(3t(3aaev' ev eavTW ydp vjft.dg (pepet, oti

eafKev fxeXv} tov a(/)ft.aTog avTOv' elg vrav^^o^y^ehv te dirriyaye,

TovTeaTiv etg Trjv EiKKXvjaiav tvjv irdvTm yevoft.evvjv ^eKTtKvjv Kai

y^apvjTtKVjv' ovKeTt yap KaTa to arevov T^g vofxtKrjg aKidg Kai TVjg 30
cv TVTTOig XaTpeiag aKovaofxev, ovk elaeXevaeTai AfJ.fj.wvtTV]g Kai

M.a!a(3tTV]g etg eKKXvjatav Kvpiov, dXXd tovto dKOvaof>.ev, **


Tropev-

" SevTeg f».aSvjTevaaTe irdvTa Ta eSvr\^ Kat Ta e^^g, Ka) OTt **


ev TravTt

** eSvet 6 (po(3ovft.evog avTOv Kat epya^ofi.evog ^iKatoavvt^v ^eKTog avTa


" eaTt. '
Hag ^e dirayaym fiei^ovag e7rtft.eXeiag vj^twaev eirei^^
;
35
X. 38. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 89

T^f KKKX-^aias crvXXeyeiavjg Ik twv ttJ TroXvSeia veveKpoifxevaiv

eOv(t>v, avrog yjv 6 \pia-Tog ev avTyj, Kara ro yeypafifxevov, oiKccv


Kai TrepnraTiov Kai Tracrav 7rvevu.aTiKVjv "tu^povfxevog yapiv.

^Tieyovai oe Tov Tiavhoyov tvtiov ol AiroaToXoi Kai oi ff.eT

avrovg Ttoifxeveg Kai ^i^daKaXoif olg etg ovpavovg dvi^v etiOKev 6 5


0€(7noTr]g ^piarog ovo Ovjvdpta, Trpovoeiv e7rif/.e\oog rov YjppcoaTVj-

KOTog eyKeXevadfxevog, Kai TcpoaQeig *'


ag edv rt Trpoa-^^aTrav^crvjg,

" eya ev tw eTiavepyeaOai fj.e dTro^w<x(t) aof" ^vo ^e ^vjvdpia rag


ovo oiadvjKag (pvjai, Trakaiav Kat Katvvjv, dfxcporepag ovaag rov
Seov, Kai fi.tav eiKOva rov dvio Kat evog PaatXecng cpepovaag, ag rd lo
ovjvdpia, Kai rov avrov (Saa-tXiKOv yapaKryipa raig Kapttaig vjfxcav

^id Twv lepm Xoyim eva-(f)payi(^ofit.evag Kat evTvnovfJ.evag. a V^


Xa^ovreg oi rav dyicoraroiv eKKXvjatxv Troifxeveg, Kat fKerd ttovxv

Kai i^parcov Ta7g '^i'^aa-Ka\iatg TrXarvvavTeg, Ka\ oiKoBev irpoa-

OaTiav^aavreg' toiovtov yap vndpyet to vorftov dpyvpiov, eitavep- 15

ypfi.ev(a toS teairorri Kara rvjv reXevraiav yjfj.epav epovaiv eKaa-rog,

K.vpt€, ^vo OyjvdpiaO ehaKdg fioi' toov TrpoadaTrav^aag o'tKoOev,

akXa 'hvo eKep^Yjaa' kou ydp to Troifivtov vjv^vjaa. oig dnoKptBe^g

epei ev, OovXe ayabe Ka.t Triare, Kai ra eqvjg.

EiVa epcoT-^aavTog rov ^eanorov ^ptarov rov vofxiKov, *'


riva 20
**
Tovrcov Toov rptm TrXyja^iov ^oKei aoi yeyovevai rov efuieaovrog
^' eig Tovg Xyiardg ;" **
KaKeivov diioKptOevrog, ori irof^a-ag ro
*'
eXeog fxer avrolJ," dnoKptSetg eiTie, " itopevov Kai av Kat •noiei

*'
Off.otcog,''^ loaavei ekeyev avrw' avovvjTov yap TVjg tepcoavvvjg

d^tcofiia roig Xayov^riv avro, Kat roTg ^oKovaiv eivai vou.ofx.aQea-t, 25


to uvofidaSat vofJ.oft.aOelg, et f>.v] ti avrav ev^oKiuovai rav epycov'

i^ov ydp TrapaTreTTkeKrai r-i^g dydTrvjg arecpavog rx tov vXt^aiov,

KE<t>. AZ.

Tlfpl MapSas Ka\ Mapiay.

38 M.eya fj.ev ro ry^g (piXo^eviag KaTopdcoft.a, oirep vj y\.apBa eyovaa 3°


rov Kvpiov vTre^^e^aro, v\py]Xorepov OTiep v] Map/a TreTroiv^Kff KaSag
6 Kvptog y]Ui.(ov Kat Seog Iv^aovg ^ptarog efj.apTvpv]ae. "napaKaOe-

^ovaa yap irpog rovg TtoOag avrov, Kat tcov Xoycov avrov aKovova^a
N
90 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XI. 5.

aintiyBYi fXH^omg wrep tyjv MapSav. irpo^ fKeivyjv fxev ydp <j>y](7t,

" Map$a, Map6a, [xepifxvoii" Kai ra e^^?. Oiite yap ^;a rovro
Trap€tTft.eVf iva Trepi ro7^ I5pwf/.a<7i ttjv KotXiav OpexpiCfJLev' Kai Oi

okiycov yap 07 %/?€/« yiverat' itept te ravrvjg ecpifjt " Mapia yap
" rv]v aya^v fxept^a e^eXe^aro, r^rtg ovk acpaipeB-rjaerat an 5
" avrrjgr Tii ^e ^v v} [xepig ; aKoy] Xoyav akrfietag, Kat Beaptag
[XvcTT^piooVj Kat rvjv /xev ovk airearpe^pev, a(f> m enotet, t^v ^e

Trpocete^aro, e(f> olg 'TrpoaeTy^e. CKOTfijCag [xev rotvvv rag ^vo


[xepi^ag ^ta rm ^vo yvvaiKm, eladyofxev, r^v [uv <7a[t.artKa)repav

^taKoviav eXdrrw' yjii^at^xaTdrri ydp Kat avrv)' ryjv Se dvajSe^vj- i o

Kviav Kat TTvevfxartKanepav' Kai eKaarog yj^xwv 6e\et eKXe^erat. 6

/3ovXo[xevog ^taKoveiv roig nroiyoig Kat 6epa7revetv voaovvrag, ^td

Mdp6ag rov Kavova rovrov XajSeh' ydp dv irofrjavi rtg elg '^ovkov

"Kpiarov, eig Xptarov dvarpeyet ro ytvofxevov' ^e ^eXwv r^v


Maptav ^YjXSoaat rvjv KaraXeXotTrvtav rov aw[xarog r^v htaKOviav,!^

dvaj3daav ^e eig rvjv 6eaptav rwv itvevfxariKm [xa6y}[xdr(tiv, yvv]-

atwg [xereX6erw ro rrpdy[xa. ovtvvjat ^e Kat rovg eavrov [xa6v]rdg

6 Kvptog '^td rovrwv ov [xerptwg, tv ei^eTev hnwg re Kat riva

rpoTTOv ra7g rav ^eyo^xevcov avrovg otKiatg ev^tatraadat "xjtv],

vjViKa TV]v vTt ovpavov TteptepyovTat, ro 6eiov Kvjpvy^xa Karay- 20


'ycAXovTes".

rie^^ TTpoaev^g Kat Ttepi rov " Ttarep vjfxwv^ Ttpoeypd^jyv] etg ro

Kard MaT6atov.

KE$. AH.
Hepl Trpoa-evxfjs. 25

Aeyei ^e ro *' xat Ttopevaerat itpog


5 T/f e^ vfxwv e^ei (piXov

" avrov [xeaovvKTtov^ Kai ra e^vjg, wg ev rpoitca itapa/SoX^g, iva

[xv] dxptKopwg rv]v Ttpoaevyvjv 7totw[xe6a, >j Kat wg [xv] aKovadevreg


€K 7tpwrv]g evyvjg Kat ^evrepag, dvaKOitrw^xev rag iKereiag, wg
ovoev e^/ovaag ro reXovv eig ovv]atv' davverwg rovro Ka6 eavrovg ^o
Xoyt^ofnevoi, ort 7tpoa^X6ov TtoXXaKtg, e^aKpvaa, eSe^6>jv Kat ov

Ttpoae^e^xdvjv' ov yap eKJ3el5v]Ke rt Ttpog Ttepag rwv aiTV]6evTwv

Ttap e[xov. yjpri %\ [xaXXov eKeHvo Xoyt^ea6at vj(xdg, ort oi^e rd


Ka6 vj[xdg rwv oXwv ^ea7toTV]g' Ka) Ttdvreg eneKetva rwv v](xeTepwv
XI. II. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 91

ixerpm aiTOvfXiv. Tavra ovv koi to, tovtoi^ ofjioia ev6vfJi.ovfji.evot,

efj.fj.evafi.ev TTpoaKapTepovvTe^ tyj itpocrevy^' Kai yap Ta avt^pcoTi

TtopiaBevTa Kai e^ eToifxov Aiy^flevTa KaTa^ppoveTaOat <j>iXei. enribv

yap " ^yjTeTTe" to Troveiv eTttTaTTet^ ttovo) yap aet ittog evpi<TKeTai

TQ ^vjTovfn.evov. Kpovccv TTj yeipi TTpoaapaTTet tyjv Svpav^ tva tvjv twv 5
Kpov(Tfj.aTav o-x^krjatv ovk eveyKm T^<r eo-Tiag SeaTroT^S", avoi^if] Kat

ovx^ eKcoV fj.a6wfj.ev toivvv eK twv Ka6 vjfx^g irpayfj.aTav tov yjpfl-

atfxov T>/i/ d-^pav, Kat Kpov(T(afj.ev Kai o^xK-^accfxev ^yjTovvTe^, Kat

eTrtTvycofj.ev.

To Se " TTopevcreTai fnecrovvKTtoog'^ irept tS>v elg Ta ecyyaTa tov ro


^iov Ttpog (xvvaia6i^(7tv ep')(Oft.ev(i>v twv oiKetoov afJ.apTrifj.<i.T(av Kai

Tyj "ffiaTet 7tpo(TTpe'/ov<Tt, tovto (fjficrtv 6 (f)tXav6p(aTtO';' 6 ^e (fnKoi

6 T^f otKiaq Kvpiog, o 0eof ^jtxwv Kat Yj(OTYip lyyaovf, o itdvTag

<f)iXav, Kat TOVi fj.vi itoog 7te7tt(TTevK0Tag avToo, Kat ^/i^wv t^^v

awTi^piav avTicv' Tpelg §e apTovg avofxaae, t^v eig YlaTepa, Kat 15

T/ov, Kai 'Aytov Ylvevfxa, ittaTtv alvtTTOfxevog, ^ Tig eaT^v ofXO'

Xoyid Tyjg itavarytov Kat ofxoovatov, Kai ^(oowotov Tptd^og. 6 &e

<f>tXog Ttapayevofxevog el o^ov Ka) eTtt^ev(a6eig avToo, voy]6eiy] av


eiKOTdig AyyeXog, vjyovv 01 AyyeXot 01 Ttapayevofxevot •npog t>jv

ecrj^aT^v Toy ^tov copav itapaXa^e^v yjfxag' (ptXovat yap y^fxag Kat 20

avTot, T^v YjfxeTepav acoTyjpiav ev<f>poavvriv Ttoiovfxevoi, wg Kvptog


<py]aiv, *'
oTi yapa ytveTai ev ovpavcp Kai toc e?^$-. Ta oe itatQia

Ta eitt TY]g KXivy]g avaitavofxeva Tovg Tpa(f>evTag (og Ta itai^ta Kat

TtapaiteittaTevKOTag ev d^TtXyj Kap^hia tw Y,vayyeXt(i> TtapiaTf^ai, Kat

y]^t(Ofi.evovg too Kvptco avvavaitavea^at, cog Kat vept tovtov avTog 25

ScwT^p Xeyet, " oti itoXXot aito dvaToXcov Kai ^vaft.(ov y]^ovat

**
Ka) dvaKXt6y]aovTat fxeTa 'AjSpaafJi.'* Kai to. e^^?. " 'Ava<&e/av"
evTayfia Xeyet ttjv fxed eitifxovi^g eTtiTeTaft.evi^v itpoaev/y^v.

5 de, Tig e? vfxcov tov TtaTepa, eav aiTy]ay] apTov, Kai Ta


e^yjg, Kai itept tov e/ovTog ^atfiovtov K(0(f)ov, Kai itept t«v AcyovTouv 30
**
OT^ ev BeeX^e/JoyX eKJSdXXet toc tatfJ.ovta, Kat OTav to dKd6apTov
**
itvevfxa e^eX6y] dito tov dvdp^oTtov," Kai Ta e^y]g, ecog *' Kat eaovTat

eayara tou dv6pxTtov eKetvov yetpova tcov itpcoTCov," Ttpoeypdtpvj

elg To KaTo. yiaT^aliov.

N 2
9^ EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XI. 14.

KE*. A0.
Ilepl Tov tx^^'''^^ baifxoviov koxJ)6v.

14 TiTOT BosTPiiN. K.a}(f)Ov KaKeT^ lo KncfyoT^Ta ({xmiovv it^og

TO [xr] aKOvaSrjvai Xoyov Qeov' ^aifxoveg •yap TtovyjpoTaTOi Trepi-

eXovTeg to evvjKOov t^c twv avOpcoTraiv Trpoatpeaeag, eTTi^pcoaav yjfxwv ^


TYjv aKorjv TYji -i^JvyYjg' 'hi.a tovto 'KpiCTog TrapeyeveTo, iva eK(Bdkri

To ^aifJ.oviov TO KCticpov, Kai dnovcrwixev Xoyov dXrj6eiag' ovOe yap


€Ke7vos yjv 6 ^atfjiovi^ofxevog Kwcj^og, dky. etg eTvyyave oeiyfjia

TcSv irdvTaV tov ^e eva BepaTtevety iva KaSoktKOv yevf^a Trapaayvi


T^g oiKovfxeviKYjg acoTvjpiaif Kat OTav eU (K yeveT^g TV(f)Xos o-oj-to

fxaTiKccg evepyeTehai, irdvTeg iivevfxaTiKwg evayyeXt^l^ofxeBa' Kai


OTav eig TrapaXvTiKog ^a^tay], eig fJilv ^ta tio^wv irap e\7rida

Tpe^/ei, Se Kocrfxog dfna tco evt, ^ia too TVji 7it<TTeag alviy-

fiaTt Tpeyei tov ^pof*.ov TYjg dXyjSeiag, dXX 01 iTOV^poi fi.eTe6vjKav

TVjv evepyeatag elg yor^Tetav, t^c l^iag vTTOxpiag ovTeg avTOt 15

f>.a6rjTat.

Ktfiaaot 14ae3anapeia2. KceJ^ov ev TOVTotg Tov d(pa>vov

wvofJ.da6at (paff.ev' tovtov Ka6apta6evTog, Kai TeXea6evTog tov

6avfj.aTog, KaTeKpoTet fxev yj Tvkridvg TaXg ev(f)Yjfi.iatg avTOV, Kai

^o^v] SeoTipeTielt aTe^avovv vjTielyeTO rov 6avfj.aTovpyov' Ttveg Se, 20


(fjvjatv, e^ avTwv, ovtoi Te vjaav ypafXfxaTelg Te Kat ^aptaaioi,

diiovota Kai (f>6ovw fxe6vQVTeg ty^v Kap^iav, 7rpoa6i^Ki^v tyj voao) to

6avfJ.a TreTrotvjVTat, a(ptaTavTeg yap avTov Ta 6eoTrpe7rwg eipyaa-

fxeva, Tw tta^oXw 7rpoaveveft.vjKav to ° TrdvTa ^vvaa6at KaTop6ovv,

^i avTOv ydp avTOV eK(BdXXeiv ecpaaav tcc hatfLovta. 25


Akta. ° laTvjai juev ydp j3aaiXeiag twv v7ro yelpa to
yvvjatov, laTVjai he oiKovg, to KaTa fxvi^eva TpOTrov dvTt(f>epea6ai

Tivag dXkviKoig twv ev avTw. eaTi^ae ^ dv Kai t^v tov BeeX^e-


/SovX (3aaiXetav, to fxv] avTOV kavTW ^pav e6eXeiv toc evavTia.

IlaJf ovv iK^dXXei Y^aTavdg tov "EaTavdv ; ovkovv ov')^^ eKOVTa tcSvSo
av6pw7rwv eKTrefxirovTai toc ^aifxovia, ov yap fxdyeTai, (pvjatv, 6

YiaTavSig eavTW, ovk eTrtTrXviTTei To^ig eavTov ^opv(f)opoig. 'Evy-

n rS Cod. o 'AkvK. Cod. Nonien vid. esse corruptum ; fors.


repon. 'AwoX. i. e. 'AmXtvaplov.
XI. 34- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 93

KpoTiT ^e fJLoiWcv T»;v eavTov PaaikeiaV XuireTai toivvv ivvoeiVf

OTi 'hvvafj.ig 6eia avvTpi^ei tov 'EaTavav.

TiTOT BosTPaN. ^lov^^aTot Kai e^ lov^aioov KaTa tjapKa yeyo-


vaaiv 01 [xaKapioi fiaSi^Tai' ovTot Trjv KaTa TTvevixaTm aKaddpTccv
k^ovJiav (.(jy^-^Kaa tv Tiapa ^piaTOV, Kai ovj Kai airvjkXaTTOV Tovf 5

Iviayyiix^vovg, eTrKpuvovvTe^ avToTs to "cv ovoixaTi Ivj(tov X/Jifrroi)."


'
Ore Toivvv, <f)i^aiv, ot e| vfxav yeyovoTeg vioi Iv ovofxaTi fxov tov

BeeA^e/SoyA BpiafK^evovaiv^, eTnTrXyjTTovTeg avTov Tovg hopvcpopovg,


Kai df/.eXXvjTt twv eyovToov avTovg eKTrefHTrovTeg, irxg ovk evapyvjg

^va-(f)iqfKta, TroXv to afkaQeg eyovaa avfXTreTrXeyfnevov tw Xeyeiv,\o


tfxe ^avei^eadat 'bvvafKtv, rr/v TrapdKXi/jatv re tov BeeX^e^ovX.

KaTaKptBvjaeaOe toivvv, (f)Y/aiv, viro Tvjg viaTecog twv e^ lfj.wv

yeyovoTwv vtxv, enrep avTot fxev tvjv irap efxov Xaj3ovTeg e^ovaiav

Kat hvvaft.tv, TrapaXvovat tov "EaTavdv, Kai ovk eKovTeg toov

e)(pvT(t}v avTov eKirefHTrovTeg' vfxeTii ^^ Xeye^e TaTg eKetvov dvvd-iS

fi.eai Keyjpvift.evov evepyeTv €f/.e Tag Beoaiqfxetag. KTretVrj te tovto

fxev ovK dXvj6eg, exXov ^e fmXXov eaTt Kai KaTtxpevafJievov Kat


avKotpavTiag ey^ov ypacpy^v, 'npo^vjXov OTt ev ^aKTvXx Seov eKpdXXco
Ta ^atfkovta' ^d^TvXov Qeov to'Ay tov ITvevaa <f)V]ai.

Ktpiaaot Aaesanapeias. 'E-yw fiev yap eire^^-^fxvjaa, (f>v]ai, 20


tva TrdvTag e^eX<i)fj.ev rwv tov "^ta^oXov yeipav, tva ai')(^(j.aXaTovg

ovTag eXevBepctiaw, Kat (ficcTtao) eaKOTtafi.evovg, Kat TreaovTag dva~

aTVjaci), Kat avvTedpavafnevovg tdau}fi.at, tva ra TeKva tov Qeov tcc

tteaKopTrtafj.eva irap eKetvov ^vjXovoTt, avvaydyco eig ^co-^v. ^e' ye


^aTavdg fj.vi oav fj.eT efJ.ov eTriyetpeT aKopiri^etv d avvvf^a Kai 25

eacoaa. Tixg ovv fj.a^xpft.evog TaTg efj.aTg oiKovofiiiatg ^t^coai ft.01

Ovvafii.tv KaQ eavTov ; dp ovk evvjOeg xo oleaQat ye TotovTov Tt


yeyevvjaBat ; iroQev ovv apa avfi.l3ePvjKe ToTg lov^^atcov tvjfj.otg to
KaToXtaBeTv etg ToaavTag evvoiag irept ^iptaToVf avTog diead(pvjaev
eiirm, otx " OTav to aKdBapTov irvevfj.a e^eXBv] diro Toi) dvBpctiirov,^^ ^o
Kai Ta et;-^g.

24 QpirENOTS. T< eaTt to ^tepyeaBat to Trvevfi.a to irowipov " Sx

**
avv^pctiv TOirm ^vitovv dvdvavatv Kat fj.v] evptaKcov ;" dnxjtpot tottoi

01 cf eBvav TO irpoTepcv, vwi Se ireTrX-^pccTai v^aTog Betov, KOt

P Tp/jSowiw*» Cod.
94 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XI. 37.

QVK€Tt '7rape-)^6vaav avdnava-tv avToTg' TroieiTat toivvv eTTtCTTpo^fnjv

irpog TO TTpOTCpov avTov ooy^eiov tov eg lapayjA, Kat wg evpev


avTOvg ovK€Tt 6eiov eyovTag ev avTo^g ovteVy aXX^ ep-^fJLOvg ovTag
Kat (jyoXa^ovTaq avTth irpog evoiKVjaiv, KaTWK-^aaTO ^^Aa^^ fJieTa

Tid.ayig avTov TYjg ^vvdfxecog. Tovto yap (f)aiveTat '^tjXovv, " eiTTa 5

Xeyoov eTepa TrvevfJiaTa fJLCT avTOv^^ KaQdnep eiaSev eirt TiXyjBovg

ovof/.d^etv 7] 6eia ypa(prj tov too-ovtov dptOfix, eTrei^av Xeyvj, " oti
*'
aTetpa ere/cev eTiTa, Kat yj TroXXr] ev TeKvotg vjaOevi^aevJ'^ ov^e

yap TO TrvevfJ.a to a^d^apTov qttoiov eayov ev AtyvnTd}, TotovTOV

eyovatv ot etg tov Ttov fj.ov dTricrTrjo-avTeg' TreTiXyjpwTat Kat 10

akXm TiovYipm, Kat yeyovev avTolg Ta eayaTa yeipova tSov Trpo)-

Tm' yeipova yap t»v ev AiyvTTTca vvv itdayovGtv, eTreitypiep eig

Ivjaovv \pt(7T0v ov TreTTtaTevKaa-tv, aXka tov dpyYjyov T-fjg ^ccvjg

dveKTetvav, o6ev ea-Tep-^Oyjaav TVjg ^(ovjg' Kat ovKCTt keyet ev avTOig

irpocfjyjTyjg, Td^e Xeyei Kvptog, ovk eaTi ay]fj.e7ov ev avToig, ovKeTt 15

vepag, ovKeTt ay]fii.eTov eirtcfjavetag Kat irapovaiag tov Qeov. fJieTa-

0el3y}Ke yap Ta dyaSd e<f> y]fJt.ag Tovg e^ evSSiv, tovtov^ 'li^aov


*'
Koyov elpyiKOTog, dpO-^aeTai dir avTwv yj j3aatXeia rov Seov, koi
*'
^oO^atTat eQvet frotovvTt Tovg Kaprrovg avT^gJ'^

KE4>. M. 20

Ilfpl Tfjs e/c Tov o\\ov iirapda-Tfs (fxovrjv.

27 A;a Tt Ti^g yuvatKog etirovayjg, " fj.aKapta y] KOtXia yj j3aaTd-

.
'*
aaad ae," Kai Ta e^yjg, avTOg "KptaTOg ^ea^iroTyjg eiire, " ft.e-

" vovvye fj.aKdptot ot aKovovTeg tov Xoyov Toy Qeov Kat <f)vXda~
** aovreg avTOV ;" dpfno^ta^g Trpog tov Katpov tovto (fjvfatv' eTret^^yj
25
ydp 01 TCtiv 6ei(cv koyav dv^Kooi Tovg vnyjKOovg tovtcov KoreKptvav,
avTOg TO evavTiov irotm, fLokXov fLaKapi^et TovTovg' Xonrov Ve Kai
'
^td Tov ia6evTa Kuitftov, tva Kai avTog aKovaag fnddyj, Kai fna^iiv

TrtaTfvay], Kat irtaTevaag epydarjTat, Kat epyaafxevog aTe(f)avcii6Yi

Ka\ do^aa^y] f/^eTa irdvTcav twv (pvXaaaovTCOv Tag ^eairoTtKag evToXdg. 30

avep etirev heairoTyjg 'KptaTog, " oti yj yeved avTV] 7rovy]pd eaTtv,"

ecag '*
eo"Ta< (f)xjeivov okov^ 7rpoeypd(f>y] eig to KaTa MaT^arov.
H Tov Tot/ Cod»
XI. 37- AOYKAN ETArrEAIOT. 95

KE$. MA.
Ilepl Tciv aiTovvTav OTjfifiov.

33 OvBeiS' Se Xv\vov a-^as ciy KpvTrrov TLdrjcnv, ov8e wro


TOV flodlOV K. T. €.

Avyyov ep^ovTe^' ev avToHi; ol avBpaitoi t^v voepav ^vvafj.iv, ovkS


(ig ro €jX(pav€; ayovai TavTrjv, a\k €ig to a^av€g KpvTTTovci ro

fJLrj ^i^T€iv ry^v €KXa[x\piv Toy vov, aXXa t^v e|a?56v Kai fxaTaiav

XaixTipoTi^Ta. avrv) yap yiverai ir^pt rov vovv crKorog, €ig Tiovripiav

avTOv €KKaXovfj.€vrj, ola trj Kai vj irepi Tovf ^apicaiovg ^o^a irapa
Tw "TrXvjOet (f)6ov€px Kai KaKOYjBiog Kara rov rtft.wfi.€Vov TiapaaKeva- lo
^ovaa, Kai Trpoadyeiv ^ia aTOfnaTos Xoyovq dae^eii Kai avKocpav-

TtKOvg, ovToc yap cvdoBev Kat dito Kap^laq €pyoft.€Vov ro aKorog,

oXov TO aicfj.a irXi^po7, ov fxovov ro arofxa Xoywv cfJ.-fftirXctiaa rwv

fxrj ^iKalm, dXXa Koi "Xj^tpag eirt fxiai<f)Qviav eyeipovaa' 'o ^vj Kat

irpdrrovai fxiKpov varepoVy diro tov <p6ovov irpog rov (f>ovov eyetpo- 15

fX€vot. e^ov ovv vfxh, (f>y]at, Ka6apov KaraaKevd^etv rov vovv, Kai

^ta rovrov KaraXafxirpvveiv eai/Twv rovg re Xoyovg Kat rag


irpd^etff vfxe^ig Se rovvavriov, o6€V y^rj irpodyetv (f>oog, €vr€v6€V

irpodyerai aKorog.

KE^. MB. 20

UtpX Tov ^apuraiov tov KcikeaavTOS t6v *Irj<rovv.

37 T/vof €V€Ktv irovifjpav Kai (Be^vjXwv ovrwv rwv ^aptaaiwv Kai

PaaKdvav Kai dXa^ovcov, KXiq^eig irap kvog e^ avrm \ptaTOS


Qeog yjfxav ov TraprjTVjaaro, dXX €ia€X6a)v av€KXi6vj ; ovy^ ag
dyvoav t>jv Ivovaav avroHg aKator-fjra 6 irdvTa €ihwg rovro irevoi- 25

yjKev, dXXa vov^er^aai rovrovg eireiyofxevog, fxvarayayiag vpo-

(paaiv ro irpayfxa iroiovfxevog.

^lEaKav^aXia6v] ^e ^apiaahg, ort ov irpo rov dptarov e/SaTrri-

a6rj, aavverwg a<po^pa, rovro yap eiroiovv eKehoi, pvirov 'Travrog

eavrovg, wg evofxt^ov, diraXXdrrovregf ovep ovtafxov irpoaeraJ^e ^o

Mwiiy^f toDto iroieiv.


96 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XI. 42.

M.ovYj yap ^ia tZv v^aTWV anovixpig y^peioo^eaTaTyj Xiav eaii,

ToHg pvTtaai aw^aTiKiO';, aKaOapaiav Se t^v elg vovv Kai Kap^iav

aTraXXd^ai ov ^vvaTai. Ta tovtcov aKo\ov6a, otov ecTTtv, eiTtev

Kvpto^y " vfxeTi; ci ^apiaaioi to e^wSev tov iioTrjpiov^^ ewf " to


" yap "Ay lov rivevjtAa ^/^afe< vfjia^" Trpoeypdipy] elg to KaTa 5
M.aT6aTov.

Ktpiaaot i\AEaANAPEiA2. 'E^^v |W,ev jap Kai eTepot? Xoyoig

yj)rjaaG6ai tov K.vpioy, vovdeTeTv eSekovTa tov aavveTOv ^apicraTov,

em^paTTeTat Kat tov Katpov Kai oiov eK twv ovtcov ev ^(epiJtv e^v-

(patvei TVjV fXvcTTaywyiav' wg yap ev Katpw Tpocf)^]^ Kat Tpane^vjg j o


evapyeg VTro^etyfxa ^e^^eTat to TtoT^fjptov Kat tov ittvaKa, Kat ^ta-

^eiKvvatv OTi KaGapovg Kai eKvevtfxixevovg elvat y^pri Tovg elXiKptvwg

XarpevovTag tw Sew, Kat ov ^'^tiov [xovrig e^ aKaGapa-tag a(ti[xaTt-

Kr]g' dXXa yap Kai Trjg eig vovv eaco KeKpvtxfJievi^g, Ka6d7rep afxeXei

Kat Ta Totg Tpaire^atg e^vTrvipeTovvTa tHov aKevoiv Kat twv e^ccBev 15

eXevdepovaQai pvTtoov, ev av ey(ot, Kai itpoaeTt tovto Tm eaco. O


yap Tiotrjaag to e^coQev (prjai, Kai ra dvcoOev eTtotrjae, TOVTeariv

TO aiofxa KTtaag, Kat ^v^^r^v eipyaaaTO. yjpri Totyapovv ev oaoi ra

TTOtrjfxaTa tou (ptXapeTov Seov avvtpofxov eyet ttjv ditoKdSapatv^f

dXX rjv dXrj6eg tovto ToTg ypafXfxaTevat Te Kat ^aptaaiotg' f^e^^^^pt 20


ydp fxovov tov 'hoKeTv elvat Ka6apovg avTovg itdvra ^pav eairov^a^ov,
'*
Td(f)otg KeKoviafxevotg "TrpoaeotKOTeg^' Kara Tr\v avTov tov HcoTripog
(pcovrjv, " e^'jo6ev fi,ev wpaToi, eaw6ev ^e yefxovTeg oareiov veKpoov koi
'* Trdarjg aKadapatag.''^ ''AXX ov ToiovTovg rjfxdg eivat (3ovXeTat

'KpiaTOg' dyiovg t\ Kat afxwfxovg ^vyr\^ re Kat awfxaTi. 25

43 '^A ydp e^e/ fxdXtara KaTop6ovv, Tavra irapevTeg wg ewXa,


TOVTeart Trjv Kpiatv Kai rrjV aydrtriv tov %eov, fxovag eKetvag

aKptjSwg eTrjpovv rag evToXag, rjyovv Tr]peTa6at irpoaeTaTTOV Ttapa

rov vito %^Tpa Xaov, di irXetarag avToTg XrjfXfxaTWV o^ot rjaav Kai

d(popff.at, waTe f*.rite Ta tS>v Xaydvwv XeitTa Kai ov^evog d^ta^o


Xoyov TtapaTpeyeiv avTovg' epyov ^e dyditrig Trjg etg Qeov, to

KUTa fxri^eva Tpoitov itpoaKpovetv avToo, "he^tevat ^e tov itavTog

vofxov Ttapdpaaiv, Kptaeoog ^e rj ttKatOKpiaia Kat to (ppovTthog

larjg a^iovv Ta Te^eaittafxeva, Kat fx^ pa6vfxeTv fxev tSov dvayKaiay'

^ Leg. vid. ex,(iv sed alia manca sunt. ^ xpvxnv Cod.


XI. 50. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 97

fxovoii Se To7i emK€pM(7iv axpiPas opav, «AXa vpoaK^tv^ tioi-

€i(T6ai Trjv \pri(f)ov rrpi


€(f)
e/faCTTO? irpayfxaTt' to yap a^iKa
Kpiv€iv ovK ayaTrrjV t^v e/V a^€k(f>ovs TripovvTOJV €(TTt' to, toivvv

avayKaTa Kai (TvveKTiKa ixr] TrjpovvTe^ tov vofxoVf Ta^ 'htKo.Tag

Xafj.l3(xv€iv ea-TTov^a^ov Kai tcSv CfTfAeaTaTWV. 5


To yap aaTraajaou? ^'ijTerv napa iiavTCiiv tuv ev ayopa, Kai to
7rpo(T€^p€V€iv €v (TvXkoyoig irepi iroXXoy irotel^TBat (xirov^a^ovTeff

[j.vriix<xTm o^rjX(t>v ov^ev ha(f>epov(7i' a ^tairpeiret /txev to/V e^coSev

KO(Tfj.otg^ [j.e(TTa le €i(Tt vdarjg aKaOapcriai. evTovQd, fJiot /3Ae7re

ltaf3€P\r][j.evrjv eo^aTcws t^v inroKptatv to Trpog ape(TKeiav avOpct)- lo


irwv airavTa ^taTrpdTTeaOai. Aia tovto (f)rjatv o [J.aK(xpiog Ylav-

Aof, " €1 avQpanrotg vjpeaKov, "Kptarov ^ouAos' ovk av r][j.r]v"

KE4». Mr.
Uepi Tov TdXavKTfiov twv vofUKmv,

46 Ava(f)opr]Tov [/.ev aet irasg eaTtv avBpwTrta iravTi to ekeyxea^at, i


S
7rkr]v ovK avovr]Tov ToHg eirteiKeai, fj.e6iaTr]ai yap avTovg eiri to

a[t.€tvov. a6pei tovto Tretrov^OTag Tovg irapa ye Tolg Iou^a;o;j

(ovofxaafj,€vovg vofitKovg. [i.€V yap tSov oXcov Y^oiTr^p eTreTifia To7g

^apiaatoig, wg c|« rpe-^^ovat Tr]g evdeiag o^ov' irpog TavTa Oe to

TCtJv avoaixv vof/.tKav e^^^aXeTratve aTi(pog. eavTovg yap viro(f>€povai 20

ToiV eyKXrjfJMai^ Kai Ka6 eavTav eiprja6ai vofi.i^ovaiv, a irpog

€K€ivovg e(f>r] 'KptaTog' aXX ^v ^'^irov KpehTOV, ayair^aat fj.€V

Tov eXeyyovy atTrfaai ^e t«v app(caTr]fj.(XTCov t^v Xvatv, Kat [i,rj

v/3piv a[J.a6(hg tov eXeyyov ovo[i.<x,'^€iv, eir^o^eXr] ovTa Kat yjp-f^at^xov.

Ti oyv Trpog TavTa KptaTog ; eirtTeivet tov eXeyyov Kat t^v eiKaiav 25
anTwv o(f>pvv KaTa(f>€p€t Xeytov, " Kat v[xTv ToTg vo[J.tKoTg ovat."

^o Ylept Se Tov ZayapioVj ov etrrev Kvptog ort [uera^v rov


Bvataarrjptov rov vaov ea^fxiiyr], aytog Vpr^yoptog "^vaar^g (pr^atv,

OTt iraTr^p eart tov irpo^po[j.ov' Kat e7re/&>; ovK aireyjaptae rrjv

iravayiav 6eoTOKov Mapiav, kou /otCTa tov a(f>6opov tokqv, tov raTg 3*^

irap6€voig a7roK€KXr]p(0[t.evov rovov ev roo vaoo, ^v Se ovTOf

roirog [j.€TaJ^v rov vaov Kat rov dvataarr^ptov, e[xapTvp€t Se Kai

fSaaiXea rrjg KTiaeag etvat rov eig yewr^atv av6pomivy]v oiKovofj.tKag

o
98 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XI. 52.

el avr^f Kara ak-^Seiav Trpoa-eXQovTaf <j)oj3(ja rov [j.r] yeveadai

^aciXei vitoyeipiovg^ tia rovro rov lepea fjiera^v rov vaov Kai

rov 6v(xia(7rvjpiov Kareaipa^av.

52 Oval vfjuu TOLS uofiLKOLSf OTL rjpaTe TTjV KXelba rqs


yvuicrecos. 5

Ktpiaaot Aaebanapeias. **
KAer^a yvxa-ewg*' Ka\ avrov
€ivai (pafxev rov vofnov Kai ri^v ev ^piaroo ^iKamciVf '^ia iiKJreug

t\ ^yjKovori ryjg eU avrov. ^v jU,ev yap vofxog ev aKia Kai rvTro),

Trkvjv ol rvnoi ^iafi.op(f)Ovai r^v akyjQeiav Kat ypacpovaiv ai aKiai

voXvrpoTTWi ^f^h ro \piarov fj-var-^piov. fA.ovog ea^pa^ero Karaio


rov rov Moova-eag vofxov' vjadiov twv Kpewv avrov, Kat eyjttov t»
aifii.ari rag (f)Xiag, Kat veviK-^Kaai rov oXoQpevryjv, aXX' alft.a

TrpoPdrov koivov ovk av tayyaev avarpe^ai Qdvarov. efuop(povro

Vifi ovv wf ev dfj.V(p ^ptarog, t^v VTrep rvjg rov Koivov ^(cvjg vtto-

ff.eva}v a-(j>ayv]Vf Kai aw^m atfj.art tw tht(a rovi fi.ereyovrag avrov. 15

TtXe^iara S' dv rtg 'npog rovro Keyotro, §/ wv evec7T;v lte7v ro

X-pta^rov fj.varvjptov ttd r^/jg rov vofj.ov aKtdg ypa^pofnevoV eipYj

Se TTOV Ka\ avrog ro7g lovQaioig TrpoXaXooVf ort " Karviyopav


" vfnoiv M.ci}va^g, eig ov vfieig yiKittKare' ei yap eiitarevere Mwi»'-
" ae7, eTTtarevere dv efxoi' Tcept ydp efj.ov eKetvog eypaxpe.^' Kat 20

ndXtv, " epevvdre rdg ypa(f)dg, ori cv avra7g ^0Ke7re vfxe7g ^a^v
" aiaviov ej^e^v, Kat avrai etatv at fj.aprvpovaai nept efJ.ov." Kat
" ov OeXere eX9e7v irpog jtxe'" a^Trag ydp 6 Xoyog ryjg QeoTrvevarov

ypa(f)yjg eig avrov opa, Kai eir avrw avvreiverai.


KTietVlfi ovv rovg KaXovfj.evovg vofj.tKOvg, dre ^yj rov Mcovaeag 25

7roKvirpayfj.ovovvrag vofJ.ov, Kat rag rav dyim irpotpyirwv ovk Yiyvoyj-

Korag (pcDvdg, dvotyet rpoTrov rtvd roig ^lov^alaiv '^yjij.otg rdg ryjg

yvcoaeag 6vpag. irat^^aycayei ydp 6 vofxog eiri ^piarov, diro^pepei

§e elg hrtyvcaatv avrov Kat rd rm dytm irpo^ffrm evae^yf

Ky}pvyfJ.ara. dXXd rovro fiev ov TreTrpdyaatv 01 KaXovfxevoi vof/.iKoi,3'^

€K ^e Twv evavrtav ijpav t>?v KXe^i^a ryjg yvaae^og, tva t»/v ^id

vofiov yetpaycaytav evvo^g yjroi t^v Trtariv, ^yjXov h ort t*;v etg

'Kptarov, irpoaytverat ydp "ttd ry]g Triareag ryjg dXyjSetag yj yvaatg'

Kai yovv 6 Trpo^pyjryii, 'Wadiag ovrw ttov (pyjat' " Kat eav iriarevyiref
XII. 4- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 99

" oi5S' ov fxyj crvv^T€," %wpif yap Tilaiecoi a^vvarov evap€<7Ti/j<rai

voT€. ^pav Toivvv Tr]v K\e7^a t^? yvcoaecos o/ KaXovfJHVoi vofJi.iKoi'

ov yap etcov irKXTivcrai Tivag eig tov tcov oXm 'EcoT^pa Xj3/<7tov, e/

Kai Te6av[j.aT0vpyr}Ke TTOkvTpoTrcci' ol ^e Kairoi Oavfxdaai ^eov, eiri

TOVToig avTOv ^ieavpov Ta? Qeoa-yjfjjeiag Koi Toy? vtio yetpa XaovgS
(TKav^^aXi^ovTes ecpaaKov, " ovTOf ovk €K/3d\Xet to. tai[Ji.ovta el yi)fi

" ev BeeA^ejSoyA apyovit tcov 'baifj.ovicavr

Opag ev TOVToig t5;v KXe7^a TVji yvcocrecog atpovTag' e^^i^aaKev

ev Ta7g a-vvayccyatg, (pavepov KaGeaTrj TOtg dKpoct)[J.evotg to BeXfifJM

Tov Geov Kai WaTpog ro dyaOov koi TeXetov Ka) evdpeaToV oi ^e lo

TavTag avTov Ta$ fivaTayciyyiai ovk dfxcofx-^TOvg dcpevTeg dXtaKOV-

Tat. vpoae(f)covovv yap ToTg oy^Xotg, ^atfiovtov ej^ez Kat fJ.atveTatf

Ti aKoveTe avTov ; yfpav ovv KaTa to dXYj^eg tvjv KXeT^a t^?


yvccaeccg, avTot ^e ovk elai^XGov, KCKcoXvKaat Be Ka) eTepovg.

KE<^. MA. 15

Ilfpt T^f C^i^-li T<op ^apKTaiiov.

Ktpiaaot Aaesanapeias. 'Aiiag yap yjtxoiv Xoyog Kat irav


epyov €V yifJ.epa Kptaecog eaTai (pavepov, TreptTTV] Totyapovv yj vtto-

Kpiatg, 0€i Qyj dXyjBtvovg y]fJ.ag opaaBat •npoaKvvyiTag.

4 ToT attot. E/f Trvevfi.aTiKyjv evavtpiav dXet(pet Tovg dya- 20


vSivTag avTov Xeyco yap vfx.h, (pyjai, Toig (f>tXoig fJ.ov, ov/^ airaaiv

airXcjig irpeiroi av, cag eotKev, irept tovtcov Xoyog, eKetvoig ^e fj.aX-
Aov oig av evvTrapyccv opwTO to e^ oXyjg Kaphtag dyairav avTOV,

olg Kat apfLo^et Xeyetv, " Ttg yjft.ag yjaptaet diro t^^ dydirfig tou
** ^piaTOv BXii^tg
; yj aTevoyjapia, y] Xtf/.og, >; '^icnyyfj.og, yj yvfi.voTyjg, 25
**
yj fxayatpa ; 01 yap fxyj Totovxot, evirapaKOfj.taToi Xtav eiai,
Kai irpog aTroaTaaiav eTotfxorepot.

Kat fj.€T oXtya — Ylpoa€v6vfj.eTa6at he TovTotg KdKeTvo irpoa-

yjKei' evptaKOVTat yap ^ta Trovcov ol aTe(f><xvot, Kat dv6pci)Troi fCev

f^eyjpi actifxaTog eKTeivovai Tag opyag, Kat irepag avToig Trjg Ka6 30
rifxag eiriBovXyjg TYjg aapKOg 6dvaTog, 0eoD ^e KoXd^ovTog ov

fj-eyjpt fj-ovyjg aapKog yj ^yjfxia aT-^aeTat, dXXa Kat avTr] avvwo-


O 2
100 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XII. 13.

<f>€p€Tat ralg oiKeiaig tj a6\ia ^vy^^^' ovkovv €i<rir(o [xaWov 6 [ler

evKXeiag Bdvaro^f elg o^px^^ VH-oii ava(f>ep<ov areXevri^rov ^«^f.


ToT ATTor. 'Ooocf oavjv TtoieHrai rriv irpovoiav rav ayaTToovrcov

avroV €1 yap fJ-ey^i rav ovra) evreKeardrav eKreiverai, Kai olov

KareKTiv eTii ra irdvriov [xiKporara ru>v fcocyv, Troif av eTriXddoiro 5


rav dyairwvrav avrov ; ovye roaavrvjv avrav TroieHrai iipovoiaVf

ag eKaara rwv Kar avroiig ei^evat AewTwj', Kai olov yjpiOfxvjixevas

e)(eiv avrav rag rpi^ag ; rj yap ovk edaet TrecreTv eig Treipaafjiov,

^ yovv otKovofJitKcogy tva TcaBovreg evhoKtfi.vjaoifi.ev, elg '^rayiha Treaetv

eirtrp^/agf yoprfyriaet irdvras Kat ro ^vvaaBat '^ieveyKeTv. 10

KE4>. ME.
Ilfpi Tov 6fXopTos [ifpicraa-dai Tfju KKijpovofiiap.

13 A/a ri Trpog rov elitovra avrSo, " ^t^daKaXe, eiTre tco a^e\(f>co

" fjLOVf fj.eptaaaGat fJLer efxov rvjv KXvjpovoft.iaVf^ aTTOKptde^g eivev,

" av6pa)7re, rig fj.e Kareari^aev apyovra yj fj.eptarYjv ((f) vfj.ag;" 1$

eirettYiitep eKemg KaraXtirav avrov ra xp-riatfj.a Kat irpog aiory]"

ptav '4'V')(/li avvretvovra, itept yyiivm re Kat itpoaKatpiov TtpayfJM-

Tcyv, e^-^ret f/.€ptarvjv avrov yeveaSatf rovrov ydptv (og oyXYjpov Kai

ovoev ebeXovra fj.au€tv cov eyjp-^v eihevat, itpacog aitoTtefj.Tterat, Kat

ug afxtKporpvxog Ttept r^v airvjatv yevofxevog rvjg avrov fj.tKpo' 20


•Ttpeiteiag' TteiOm ^ta rovrcov avrov re Kat rovg rore koi vvv

aKOvovrag, itavrog fj.€v dito<f>otrav yvjtvov re Kat TtpoaKatpov

TtpdyfJ-arog, fiy] (ptXovetKovvrag d^eX^poTg, etKovrag fKaXXov avroTg,


*'
Kav ei 0ovX<ovTat TtXeoveKreTv' aito yap rov aipovrog,^^ ^P^^^h

" Toc aa fj.vj aTtairet'^' ^vjreTre ^e fxaXXov ra oaaitep eart %pi7- 25

ertfJ.a Koi dvayKaTa itpog acorvjptav xpvx^g' ho Kat eTtvjfyaye Xeycov,

" opdre Ka\ (f>vXdaa€a6e, diro vdai^g TrXeove^ta^^' Kat ra k^vjg'

cog l3o6pov rivd ^taf^oXiKov irapatviov vjft.Tv ravrvjv diroipevyetv, Kat

^^ Kai e^coXoXarptav 6 ao(f>og ovofj.d^^et YlavXog, <og fiovcog rdya


irov •npeirovaav roTg ovk eitoat ©eov, v\ Kat iaoard6fj.Q)g e^ovaav 50

€ig /Se^^^Xcoaiv ro Xarpevetv rivdg ^vXoig re Kat Xt6oig.


. .

XII. 17- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 101

KE$. Mr.
Hepi Tov ov riv(f)6pr](rfv f]
x^P^ liKovalov

lo iJwf d€ oy/<: e<7T/ ev tco irepiaaeveiv tivi ij ^wy} avrov €k rwv


** x/jtap^/ovroov afToD," Sia to irXovrx avveKrciveadai ro T^f ?»^f
/1,17

fxerpov, KaBag y](xiv aatpcog re Kai evapya^ vire^ei^ev avro$ 05


Secr^OTTj? ^piaroii t^" to?? TtpoeiprjiJ.evoig avve^evyfjievrjv Trapa-

fioX^ eii [xdXiara avvreSeiKev. " Avdpamov yap Tivof," (pi^aif


" TrXovaiov evcpopfjaev vj •^oopa,^^ Kai Ta e^^f

17 XjO»? Se aKOTt-fjaai rjfJiag aKpij3ai ro rov Xoyov evre^^^yov, ori

ov^ ev vjfjLiv ev(f)opi^aav elae^ei^e ycopiov, dX\ oXvjv, e(f>if], yjJjpav 10


evKapnov yeveaOai rca KeKryjfxevx, iva fji.d6cofji.ev tov "TteiBovg ro

Padog' Kai yap orav ovtw woAXoJV Trepiyeofj.evog dya^ol'; arevo-

yjnpelrai 7r€(f>povTtKa}g, " ri ydp Troi-^aoo ;" (f^vjat, ^to Kai eaKeTtrero

fiovos aitoKavetv rav itpoaovrwv aurx, ovy^ opwv Ttpog ro fi.eKXov,

ovK avafSXeitoov itpog rov Qeov, ovK epav (f>iXoitTO)yj.ag, Kat rav 15

cvTfu^ev avyrifji.drm e(j)tefj.evog, dXXd Kat ro ert rovrov itapaXo-

yoorepov, eavrw fj.y}Kog opt^et ^oovjg, ooaTtep ck «y^f Kat rovro 6epi-
aag' **
epoo yap," (f^vjat, " t'^ ^vyy fJiov, ^vyv], eyetg TtoXXd
*'
dyaQa Ketfueva etg ervj itoXXd' (f>dye, itte, eixfypatvoV ^to Kat
**
0€Of €/7rev afToo, a(f>poov, ravrrj r^ vvKrt riqv i^vj^iyv aov ditat- 20
* rovatv aito aov, a he ijrotfjiMaag, rtvt earat ; aXvjOeg ovv, ort
'*
ovK ev Tci) Tteptaaevetv rtvt earat vj ^oovj avrov eK twv vitapyovrxv
« ayTco.
~ »
> ^ N V >
Qto ro eitayofj.evov ort
/ '' ii "
ovrag
' /1
arjaavpigoov
V '
eavrw Kat
~ ^ V
fxyj

*'
elg Qeov ttAoutwv," (f>ol3i^6evT€g, fj-i^^e etg evvotav rov TtXovreh

eX6oofx.ev' Tptafj.aKdptog ydp Kat ev eXittat Xafj.7tpa'ig 6 Kardi^


©eov TtXoVTOOV.

A(f>poov ^e ^tKaicog eKX'^6v], eitet^-i^ vtdg d(f>poov rotovrog Kat


**
fj-dratog, Ka6o}g Kat 6 ^paXfLw^og <f>i^(Tt, itXijv fj.drv]V itdg dv6poo-
" "Ttog 6y]aavpt^€t, Kat ov ytvooaKei rivi avvd^et avrdJ'^

Ta dKoXov6a rovroov, oiov **


fj.r] fj.eptfj.vdre rv] ^vyr] vfJMV^^ 30
vpo€ypd(f>Y] etg ro Kard MaT^arov, eoog " Kat ravra itdvra itpoa-
" re6-^aerat vfj.7v"

KrpiAAOT 'Aaebanapeiaz. 'O? d-ao ye roov itrrjvoov Kat tc5v

€v aypoTg dv6oov i^pvfj.evy]v Kat dKardaetarov epya^erat aoi ittartv,

evootd^etv ^e oX<ag ovk e(f>iy]aiv y]fJ.dg, ori itdvry] re Kat Jtdvroog r^v 35
5

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XII. 35.

Tca^ avTOv ya^iC^exai </)e/Sw, to avei/&€ef e^' aTraai ^ioovg' " Kara-
" vo^^aare" Xiyoov " ra Kpiva, iroos av^dvei" Kai ra e^yj^,

'AATjSef ^e toSto* to. yap tc3v yjpvji/.drm avBri iroiKiXa re ovra

Koi iroXvei^v} ev Kpivoig [xev Kat ev eTepoi$ Tiai tSov (f)vo[x,evccv ev

dypoi$ d^io6av(jiacrTOV eaTi tyjv copav' irpog ^e [AifJiyjaiv tvjv avToov 5

VTTO^aXXoiJievov to Teyyovpyovi/.evov XenreTai 'TidvTCcs CKeivcov, Kai

[xoXig ep^/eTai 'ttcc^ TVjg dXrfieiaq eyyvg. E< toivvv tovB ovTCog

e^x^ei, Trwf oiiK dXrjBeg oti ov^e Y.oXo[xm, KaiToi (piXoTi[i.oi ovtco

yeyovag, ev oXvj tyi SoIij avrov vepiepdXeTO cog ev tovtwv. Airoy^^v}

TOiyapovv To7g ao(f)o7g to %f3e/af eveKa Kai [i.ovrig eva')(r][ji.ova Kai 10

evnopiaTov e^/eiv tvjv 0"toA>;v, Kai anicav XiTOTrjra [J.r} vnepaipov-

aav TO dpKovV dpKeaei ^e Tolq dyioig 17 ev 'KpiaTco Tpocprjy rj

'jTvev[iaTiKr] ^rjXovoTi Koi Beia Kol vorjTrj, Kai 17 [LeTa Tavra Qo^a.

32 *«
M>; (f)ol3ov TO [AiKpov 7roi[J.viov" dvri rov [t^ d-niarrjarig eipvj-

rai, [J.iKpov Ve ttoi[i.viov ovo[J.d^ei, rj eTrei^r} irapaKeirai [xiKporrjg ev 1

Tco Koa[i(a Tovrco roig eKovaicog aKT-f^^Koai Kai dy^rnxdroig, r} 'hia

TO r^rrdaBai rr}g rwv \yyeXcov irXrjBvog d^xerp^^rov ovar}g, Kat

davyKptrcog iiXeoveKTOvar}g ra KaB r}[j.dg. etnciov yap ev r^ roov

eKarov TrpojSdrcov irapa^oXrj, ort '/atpei eiri rw evi [jmXXov tco

TtXav^BevTi koi evpeBevri ^ eTTi rolg evvevrjKovraevvea roig [xr} 20


7r€'7rXavr}[f.evotg, e^et^ev ort cog ev ev To7g eKarov, ro eirt yr}g eari

itoi^xvtov Ttpog rdg d[j.eTpr}Tovg rcov avco Ttvev[i.dTCov ayeXag. aXX


et Kai ovrco [LiKpov eart, (ftrjatv, r} rov 0eoy ayaBorr^g 07* itavTa

Xoyov VTrepeKretvovaa, Se^cuice Kat avrw rcov virepKei^xevcov irvev-

[xdrcov rov KXr}pov, rovreart t*jv twv ovpavm PaaiXetav' ovv ra 25


ovrco [xeydXa Kat e^atpera ^t^ovg, ircog OKvf}aet irXovaicog ra eiri

yr}i iraper/etv ^[liv dyaBd' Trpohr^Xcag eKirXr^povvrcov r}[j.cov ro eira-


'*
yo[t.evov' (f>r]ai ydp, 'jrcoX^r^aare t» vTrdp^/ovra vfJMV Kai ^ore
" eXer^ixoavv^v" Kat rd e^r}g' a^nep irpoeypd^^r} eig ro Kard
MaTflaZbv, ecog ** eKe7 Kat r} Kaptta v[j.cov earat." 30
^S tjtircov ori earcoaav at oa(pveg v[j.cov 7repteycoa[Levat, ov ti^v

Tov aco[j.arog oa(f>vv ^ie^coa^ievi^v r}[xdg e^e/v irapaKeXeverat, aXXa


TO Ty}g ^tavotag erot^xov eig (f)tXepytav To7g e<p airaai tr^^kovori

To7g eTratvov^xevotg.

a «; Cod.
XII. 39- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 108

O/ &€ Xiyy<ii t>jv rov vov eyp-^yopffiv kou (f)aitpoTV]Ta vovjtvjv

€iritv]\ovaiv, iva apervjv a(TKovvTtg, Kai tov irpocpopi^TtKOv Kat tov

ev^idQeTOV Xoyov 'hia vavToq ddTpaTiTovTa ev t6 Tvj i^i^^, ev t€ t^


yXuTTVj ej^ovTe?, ^/ d[JL(poT€pcov €Kkd[x.TTCi}[j.€V. fX€V yap cvOov

yjft.dg (f>coTi^€if 6 ^e e^o> Tovg dWovg' ^ton€p 6 ^t^a(TKa\tKog $

Kvyyog \\ivyov(TS(o Kat dp^€V€CTQ(ti Kai Tp€(f)€a6(iD vao T^f TrpaKTtK^i

dp€TVjg, iva [xv] cKOTHVOq v] Kai aXafJ.nvig.

37 Vd[Mvg %€ ovQ[j.d^€t, ^ta t'o [j.v]^€v oXojg KaTV](p€g v] Xwi^pov

VTtdp^/ytv Ttapa tv] 6€i(X Kat aKV]pdTca (j>v(T€t, tva eA^ovTOf, <f>v](Tt,

'^Y]Xov Se OTi €v Tvj ^cvTcpa, avTov irapovataj dSpooog Kat dooK-^TCog lo

KaSdmp ddipcDg t«v vvktwv e0;crTa/x6Vo?, oircp cv][JMtV€t to a^ij-

Aov T^f vapov(Ttag «yToy, ov? av Ttap€(JK€va(7[i.€vovg €vpY] Kai

€TOl[liOVg, €IT€ 6V T^ ^€VT€pa, 6;T€ eV T^ TptTV] (ftvkaKVJ T^f VVKTOg^


rv]V Trapov(7tav avrov dva[ji.€vovTagy Kat "^td rovro Trdaav ap€Tv]v

€pya^o[jt.€vovgf " [j.aKdptoi €i(7t, (f>v]<Ttv, oi ^ovkoi €K€7vot, Trept^o}- 15


" o-€Ta/ ydp Kat ttaK0VY]a€i avroigJ'^ rovrccTTtv ori rolg t(rotg v][JMg

avTa[i.€f4'€Tai Kat oiov KdfnvovTag avaKTV]a€Tat, Tpv(f>ag v}[t.h irapa-

6€)g rdg Trv^vfj.artKag, Koi iroAi/TeA.eaTaTvjv, ^axptXy^, TroiKtkv]Vj

d[Ji.(f>tXa(f>v] Twv eavToy '^apta-[tMTCOv dirXoia^i rpaTr€^av. Nofnt-

<Ta[t.€v Se rovg /w,ev riqg vpwTv^g (f>vXaKV]g rovg €Trt[X€X€ar€pov 20

^tovvrag, Ka) irapd Toy? dXXovg dypvTrvwg '^taK€t[>.€vovg 7r€pt rvpt

rm dyaBS)V Ipyaatav, Kat '^ta tovto irpcarv^g To^ea»^ €Tr€tXv][/.[/.€-

vovg' rovg ^e T^f ^euTC^af, Toyf VTro^€^v]KOTag' rovg Se T^f


rpir^g, rovg rovrcov Kara^€€aT€povg.

39 Ttveg §6 7rpwTV]v Koti ^^vripav (f)vXaKv]v Kat rpirv^v ro ^td(f)opov 25

Tftiv v]XtKtwv €^Y]yv]aavTo, irpcoTv^v jaev, Kaff vjv 7ra7^€g €a[j.€v dvv]-

{3ot, ^€VT€pav te, Ka& ^v veaviat, Kat TpiTV]v, Kaff v]V 7rp€aj3vrat'

TO Oe, €t vjO€i otK00€a7roTV]g, Kat ra eq^i^g, €Ci}g [i€ra rcov

dTrtarwv B-^a€t, 7rpo€ypd(f>v] €ig ro Kara MaT^arov. Kig ra


[LtKpa €tg T>jv €p[i.v]V€tav rov ay(oKiov. 3°
'OpirENOTS. Kartv vvrvog Kat ^ypvjfyopatg^ axrwep litt rov e|«w

dvQpcoTrov Kai €7rt tov €aw' dTrairovfi^Oa rotvvv €ypv]yop€vat, KoSd


<f>v]aiv 6 Hcor-^p' " ypv]yop€iT€ Kai 7rpoa€vy(€aB€, tva [j.v] €ta€\6v]r€
*'
€ig 7r€tpaa[j.ovr Ka^ [Jk€r oXiya — IlA^v Ta voXXa v] Kara
Trdvra ev toS (Btoi toutco dypvirvv^TCov €art, irv} /xev ^ta ro €06- 35
104 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XII. 46.

opeveiv Tovf TroXefxiovg ovrag, " oyj^ ciuii.a Ka\ adpKa, aAA* €^ov(Tia$
" Kai Koa-fxoKpdTopas tov Koafxov tovtov, Kot "TrvevfiaTiKa ^ T^f
*'
TTOwipiai" IV eK Tov eypyjyopevai o-w^afAeBa, coaTrep ^opKai Ik

jBpoyctiVf Kai waTrep opveov eK Tiayi^^og, Kai " iva Tag oa(f>vai
" "Trept^iccrafjievoi Kai rov^ Xv)(yovg dvaiirofxevovg eyovreg, Ofi.oia 5
*'
yeviOf/Le6a dv6pa7roig Ttpoa-^eypfJ.evoig tov Kvptov eavrcov, iva
" eX6ovTog Kai Kpova-avrog ev6e(i)g dvoi^wfkev ayToo."

Eb ANEnirPA*oT. ^tyoTOfi.iav (pi^at tov KaKov ^ovXov to

^iatpe^Yjvat to e7rtavfi.j3e(3yiK0g avrw, Kat ^taKOTii^vai di: ayrou


jU.eTa fxeydXav Kat ccpo^pav dXyy^ovm' aTeA^f yap evpe^^^aerat 10
ToioyTOf, avev 6eiov Ylvevf/.aTogf aap^ Sov Kai ov TivevfLa. eTiei

TOT6 eafnev ev irvevfnart Kara tov ^noaToXov, orav Ilveyjaa Qeov

eartv ev yjfuv. fxepog ^e dreXeg diioXetcp^eig earat fMera rav


aTriaraVf ccg dv ov^ev tiJs' Titarewg anoXavaag etg acoTVjpiav, aXXa
avv Tco dTriarco KoafLO) KaTaKpi6eig, Kai roaovrco ye f/i.ei^6ov ly 15

KoXaatg, oaco 7rXe7ov vj ydptg.

46 EAflojv ovv Kvptog tov toiovtov 'ttyoTOfJ.Yirov^ tZ ^mrt eavrov


Xoyco Kat evepyeT vTrep iraaav fj.dyatpav ^iarofuov, oog ft.Yj yevo-

fkevovg oXoKKyipovg Tivevft.art Kat "^v/y] Kat acoft.aTty OTroiot etatv

01 dyta^ofxevoi oXoreXeTg, wv oXoKXvjpov ro nvevfj.a Kat yj ^vyy], 20

Kat TO aS)fi.a dfi.eft.Tircog ev tyi Ttapovaia TYjpelrat tov Kvpiov

Yjfj.ciov \y]aov ^ptarov' tva ^e aacpearepov t^Yjg, iipoaeye iicog dv

voYiBetYj eK rov ^t't'Kve7a6at rov ^covra tou Qeov Xoyov eTitfji.eptafJLOV

T^yp^ijf Kat irveyjtxaTOf, ovrtva e7itfJ.eptafj.ov ^l^vy^g Kat Ttvevfj.arog

01 fj.ev ovv tiyorofj.ovfj.evoi Tietaovrai, 01 Ve iitarot Kat <f)povtfj.ot 25


oiKovofJ.ot ov Tietaovrat. Xoyog yap ev avrolg TiotYjaag ra afj.(f)o-

repa ev, Kat ro fneaorotyov rov (j)payfj.ov Xvaag, rovg "hvo eKrtaev

€tg eva Katvov dv6pco7iov, Tiotcov eip^^vyjv, Kat aTioKaraXXd^ag avrovg


rSo 0eco.

A/a Tiotav airiav " Kvptov 30


SouAoc fj^ yvovg ro 6eXY]ft.a tov
" avTov, Kat 7ioffiaag d^ia 7iXi^ycov," vTieyet Xoyov; '^tori fXY} Y}6eXY]aev

elMvat, 'hvvdfj.evog fJM^eh' ei ^e fj^ yvovg


oXog ovk dfxotpog opy^g

earat, ort fi.Y] ei^wg KarYifxeXYjae tov fxa^eh, ^iolog d^iaXXd^et Xoyog

rov yp^vat TioXXdg xmoft.ehat ^iXYjydg, rov ei^ora Kat paBvfXYiaavra.

^ wvtr/xaT* Kou Cod. c Leg. fors. hyfirofMiVit, sed excidere plura.


XII. 49- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 105

EiiiFwv §e OTi " TTavTt <a e^o$v] TroAy, iro\v ^rjTrjO-^aeTai irap

**
avTOv^^ eScilev oti <f)opTiK60Tepov tHv ^t^aaKOVTUv to Kpifxa.

Tloia &€ Tavrd eariv a ^y]TVj6v}(T€Tai irap avToiv ; to ev tti-

CT€i opOoVf to dirXaveg elg iivoTayayyiag, to jSefSi^Kog ev eATrio/,

TO aKaTaa-eKTTOv ev inrofJLOvyjf to dBpavdTov ev lcryyi tt} TrvevfxaTiK^, 5


TO e/V Tav OTiovv twv dpiaTCOV dv^payadi^fjidTwv 'irpoSvfJi.ov t€ Kat

eycrfleves", oxTTe /fa< eTtpotg vTroTVTrcoatv eivai iroXtTetag ayyeXtKrig.

To **
irvp vjX6ov ^aXeh hrt Trjv "yijv" irpoeypa(f)y] etg to KaTa
**
."
MaT^arov ecog Kat to ecrp^aTov Aeirrov airo^oif

'Eh ANEnirpA*oT. TowTo TO Trvp eyovTeg oi Trept KAewTrav cv lo

*'
eavTorj" eAeyov, ov^t yj Kap^ia yjfx.(tiv Katofnevrj ^v ev yjfAiv ev Tyj

" oha, Kat wg eXdXyjaev ^fnTv, Kat ig '^ffjvotyev yjfiTv Tag ypauftdg,**

49 ToT Xptsostomot. **
Tlvp yjXSov (3aXeiv eirt tvjv 717V," ovk eirt

TVjV y^v tvjv V(f> vf/.eTepotg iroat 7raT0Vf/.evy]Vf «AA eiri Tvpf yv]v tv]v

v(f> efLaTg y^pat TreirXaafi.ew^Vf eiret^-^irep ^tdjSoXog Taig Tav 15


dvBpconcov Kap^tatg dKdvBag Kai Tpt^oXovg eveaTretpev dfLapTV]-
fjidToov' " Trvp v]X6ov hrt^aXeh hrt tv]v 'y^v, Kai r/ 6eAw el v]tv]

av^(pOv] ; Oet yap fLe Kaaaptaat tvjv €fJLV]v yv]v oet fkeTa tov

^ta(3okov TrtKpo(f>opa Kat ^Xa^oirotd ^XaaTV]fJi,aTa irvpt e^avaXa-

aaif tva Ka6ap<a tv] tpv^^vj Ka6apov tov ovpdvtov airopov ev ovpavca. 20
**
OvK y]X6ov yap fSaXeh etp-^vy]v, aXXa fjMyatpav^^ eav fj.v] ya-
XAaa Tw cyPpco vfjJav fidy^atpav, vfn.7v ovk ea^at etpv]VV].

Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias. KaiToi 'K.ptaTog eaTiv yj etp-^vv]

y]fj.cov KaTo. Tag ypa<f>dg. Ilwf ovv, €(f>v], ovk ^X6ov eipv]vy]v ^ovvat

€iri T^f 'y^f ; OTt 'X£V]fj.a fj.€v vj €lpv]Vf] KaXov Kat ovTcag dyaOov, 25

aAA ov Trdaa iravTcog etpvjvv] to dKaTd\\^eKTov ^yet, aXX eaTtv

e-jrtacf^aXvjg iroXXdKtg Kat T^g eig Qeov dydirv^g diroKOfJ.tXovaa.

XAva/TeA^f ydp v] Trpog Toi/g eT€po(f)povag €ipv]vv]f Ka^dye to tu


laa (fjpovetv eKeivotg. Ata tovto ydp Kat tcov eirt y^f (ptXTpcov ot

viaTot a(f>taTavTat Kat avyyeveTg dyvoovai^ Kat TraTvjp vtov <f>tXtav 30


dvatveTat *, Kat viog iraTpog Ttfj.v]v dyvoel, Kat fJ-^^TVjp 6vyaTpog
<f>tXTpov dsrcoaaTo.

' avlyfrai Cod.


106 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XIII. i.

KE^. MZ.
Hepl Tcop ra\ikai(op Ka\ tS)p ip r& ^ikaayi.

Tlipi Twv TaXiX.aiav wv dir-^yeiXav tw ^piajia ori to alfxa

avTccv II/AaTOf efii^e [xeTa twv Svaiav, yj)^ yivuaKtiv oti ovTOi

€i(Ttv 01 Toi^ ^oyy.aaiv e^aKoXovS-^aavTtg 'lov^a tov TaXiXaiov,^

ov Kai AovKag ev TaHg Tlpa^eai tuv AiioaToKwv f/.efi.v:^Tai. v}V

Oe To ^oyfJLa xov 'lov^a, ^g kcu o 'laat^Tmog ev ToHg TeKevTaioig

TYji iov^taiKVjg ApyaioXoylag e^ei^e, (pavTaaiav e^ayyekkm ttoA-

Xfjv irpofpaaiv S^flev evaejSelag. Kvptov yap f>.y]^e />t€%/" aTOfiMTog,

ecpaaKCi fJLrj teiv Ttva keyeiVf fi.i^^e KaTa Tiva Ttfivjv Kai (f)t\o<ppo- lo

avvrjv' oi/TOJ Se /a^tc tov jBaaiXevovTa. o6ev Kai ttoXXoi ye avTuv


irepi Tov fKYi eiTteh Kataapa Kvptov, '^(aXeTiaTaTatg atKiatg we-
^aWovTO, 01 Kat etitaaKov fxyjVev napa to. ttaTeTayfxeva ev tc5

^wvaeug vofioSeaiag dva<f)epea6at tco ©eoj. Atoirep Kat eKaXvov

Tag vTto T^f yepovatag tov Xaov Trapa^e^ofJievag yiyveaQat Trep) 15


T^^ amvjptag tov ^aatXewg Kat tov 'Va}f/.ata}v eSvovg Qvaiag.

etKog ovv eirt TOVTOtg ayavaKTOvvra irpog TaXtXxx.tovg tov TitXaTOV

KeXevaat itap avTatg atg e^oKovv KaTo, tov vofj.ov irpoa^epetv

Ovaiaig avTovg avatpedrjvat, ooaTe avaft.tyPy}vat Ta7g irpoacpepo-

ft.evatg Qvatatg to alfxa twv irpoacpepovTOov. TovTa ovv eiretTrep 20


e^OKet vTrep evae/Seiag yiveaSai, aTr-^yyeXov tco SwT^pi, j3ovXo-
fxevot TO eTrt TOVTotg dpeaKov avTw fxaBeh' Kai yap evofj.t^ov Ttveg

diro Tov Xaov ^tKatOTaTa KaTo, Tag dfiapTiag avTwv TavTa Treirov-

Oevat Tovg avaipeBevTag, «Te aTaatv KtvyjaavTag Tag tco Xaw, Kai
ent TO fj.taeh epeBiaavTag Tovg dpyovTag KaTa twv vTryjKOWV' ^to 25
avTOg TO fnev elvat avTOvg dfj.apT(oXovg Tt6rjatVf ov /x^v (pvjai

TavTa avTOvg Treirov^evai, ag twv fi.Yj ireTrovBojav yeipovag.

EiVa eirt TovTOtg (prjaiVy oaov eiri tc3 p-^fj.aTt, airoTpeTrm T^f

efJ.(f>vXiov aTaaecog irpocpaaet evae/3etag dvaTrTOfJ.evovg Tovg airo

Tov XaoVf TO " edv fj.r] fii.eTavo^avjT€,*' TovTeaTtv, eav fj.rj [xeTa-^o
l3dXv]Te Tov aTaatd^etv Kai av6taTaa6at ToTg dpyovaiv, oirep ov

KaTa l3ovXvjfj.a irotei tov Qeov, TrdvTeg OfJ.ot<i}g diroXeiade, Kai to

vfj.eTepov alfj.a dvafj.iyp-^aeTat vfj.eTepati Ovatatg.


^

XIII. II. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 107

4 'O TTVpyoi mawv cv tco 2/Aoa/x ovx «f afxapTuXoTepovs irav-

Tcov ovTas TOVi ^€Ka Kai OKTW Kare^^^aaeVf Ka6(i)g Kat avTog (f>rjaiv

6 Kvpiog, aAAa ^i oXiyav v7roh€iyiJ.a To7g oIkqxxti Tfjv l.€pov-

aaXyjfx, yiyove. Kai 6 }j.€v €lg Ttvpyog TrapajSdWeTai oXyj t^ iroX^i,

iva TO fxipog €K<f)ol3-^avj tq oXov, oi ^eKa Kai oktu tw Xa^ t^?S


TtoXewg' odev eTienrep TOvg otKTjTopag ra ti}c dirtaTiag €V€fjt.€iv€,

Kai avTOi avv avT^ fKtKpov vffTCpov To7g avToTg ir^pieTreaav oig irep

6 irvpyog Kai oi ^€Ka kui oVt», ot€ Trjv 'UpovaaXvjfJL 6 TiTog KaT€-
crTp€\li€V Kai TToXvv Kaov eBavdTCoae.
o 'H T^g avKVjg Trapa/SoXvj tyjv dKapiriav eXeyxjei t^j 'lepovaakvjfJi, lo

^ia Mcot/Vews-, ^ia tcov irpocpvjToov, "^i eavTOv.

IsiAiiPOT IlHAOTSiaTOT. 'H KvayyeXiKVj avKVj vj dvBpamoTfjg

eaTif 6 ^e oiKo^eairoTvjg 6 Qeog Kai YlaTvjp, 6 Se dfXTreXovpyog o

Tiog Tov 0601/, (j^iXoTrovyjaai Kat €KKa$apai tov dfj.Tr€kv)va rjfJMV

ev^rjfx-^aagf CKKOTrrjvai Se irapa tov oiKO^€airoTov K€X€va6eiaav j

Tr}v avKrjv wg oKapTrov, e^ avrrjv (fyrjai Kat tovto to €T€pov' €i ^ia

vofJ.ov Kat irpoiprjToov ovk elSeXTiaOrjaav Kat fLCTavoiag Kapirovg

ovK dire^nKaVf \jca\'\ To7g €fi.o7g dp^€v$iiat ^oyfnaat Kat iraQyjfj.aat'

Kav fuv "Trof^awat Kapirov eviretBetag' ei §e ft.rjyef eig to fxeXXov

€KKO\j)rjg avTrjVf €ig tov aXXov aicova Tvjg twv ttKatav fxept 'hog, %o
€KT€fJMV avTovg' caTt Se rj TrpaTr} dOeTi^atg Trjg IvToX-^g, rj irapa-

I3aatg rj diro tov ^vXov, tov €V fj.€aw tov Trapa^etaov TrpoaTaT-

Tovaa fJLTj y€V€aQat' rj Se ^euTe^a, oj ev too vof/ico ^vaaejSeta rj irpog

Tov fj.oayov' r} Se TptTi^ aae^eta rj ev Trj yapiTt Tvyydvet Trapai-

Trjaig, " ovk €yofj.€v ^aatXea, €i fj.r] Kaiaapa" Kat tov Kvptov T^f 25

^G^rjg aTrapvovfj.€V(jov.

8 Konpta Se Xeyet to, ^aKpva, Kat Tovg aTevayfxovgf Kai Tag

yafj.€vviag, Kat Tag dypvnviag, Kat TVj^tv ^vy^g Kat aci}f).aTog, t>jv

^i €^ayop€va€Ci}g Kat dTtfxoTepag dycoy^g eiravopBcaatVy cag OeoXo-

yog Xeyei Tprjyopiog.

Km. MH. 30

Utpi Trfs ^xovoTjs irvfvfia aaOtveias.

II 'H avyKinrTovaa yvvr} tovto Xeyerai iraBe^v e| aypiOTrjTog

^ia^oXiKrfg, KaQclog <f)r)aiv ^taTroTrjg, " rjv etrfaev Y^aTavag, €Tr}

P 1
108 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XIII. 17.

" ^€Ka Kat o/cTW," Jtrwf 7rapec»pafj.€vii]v itapa ©eov "ti oiKeTa 11x01,1-

afiara' Trapaniof yap roig avBpuirivoig (j(6fj.aai rov vo^xeh aki-

r^^piog yeyove "Earavag, BeoTrpiTtiaraTri Se Xtav (fxov^ Kai e^ovcriag

yefJiovaYj Tvjg avccTaTCCf Tfjg yvvaiKog ravTrfg rvjv voaov eXavvei

TTpoac^iTidvjai §e Kai y/ipag avryj, iva fxddccfxev, ori t>jv tov &eov ^
"Koyov ^vvafuiv re Kai evepyeiav yj ayla iie^^opr^Ke (Jap%' iQia yap
vjv avTQV Kai ovy^ erepov rtvog Ttap avrov ovrog Tiov KaTafJ.ovag

Kai l^iKiog, Kara ye ro rtaiv avocmoraTov '^okovv. nept m etitev

^e(nroT7]g 'Kptarog itpog rov apyjavv(xy(oyov irepi rov aa^^arov^


TrpoeypdtpYj etg ro Kara M.ar6a7ov. 10

17 Ft^xaipe ^e Xaog eitt itaai roHg evto^otg rolg ytvofi.evoig vn


avrov, eTtett^r^ ra iiapa^o^a epya ekve Ttaaav ^"^rrjaiv itapa ye

Tolg ft^ KaKO-^Oetav ^vjrovatv, onep ot ap^^^ovreg eTtparrov, eitt Ttpo-

(paatv vofj.Qv tov SwT^pa KaKag vjSpt^ovreg.

KE4>. M0. 15

Ilept rStv Trapa^oXav,

IQ ToT ArioT ElPHNAIOT EHISKOnOT AoTrAONOS. 1^6 KOKKOV

atvditecog ^ta Ttapa^oXvjg ^etKvvfxevov, Kat Xoyov eitovpdvtov aitep-

fj.arog '^tKYjv ev Koafj.(a ag ev dypw a7teipof/.evoVf eyovrog ev eavrio

TO TtvppaKeg Kai ro avarripov T^f 'tvvafj.e(og. Kptrrjg yap rov itav- 20


Tog Koafkov eKrjpvaaero, ovrog ev rrj Kap^tcf. rrjg yr^g ev yafj/x.Ti

Kpv^etg Kat Tptrjfi.ep(ag fj.eyiaTOV ^ev^pov yevvrjSeig, e^eietve rovg

eavrov KXa^ovg eig ra itepara rrjg yrjg. Ik tovtov TtpoKvtpavreg

ot ^co^eKa AitoaToXot KXd^oi (opahi Kat ev6a\eig yevrjQevreg, aKeTtrj

eyev^Qriaav ro^tg edveatv wg 'Tteretvoig ovpavov, v(f> wv kX(x,0(cv aKe- 25


Ttaadevreg 01 itavreg wg opvea vito KaXtav avveXOovra, fxereXajSov

rrjg e^ avrav 7tpoep-)(Of/^evi^g e^oo^^ifxov Kat eitovpavtov Tpo<f>^g,

21 QpirENHS rrjv y.ev yvva^Ka Xafnj^dvet etg rrjv eKKXrjatav,

rr^v Se ^y/XTjv elg ro Ylvevfj.a ro 'Aytov, adra t\ rpta, aa)fj.a,

Ttvevfj.a, i^fvyriv, dytd^erai Se TavTa t'^ ^vfLr] rov dytov TlvevfJLa- ^o

Tog, eSf yeveaSat itpog to 'Kytov ITvevjaa, ev (pvpafxa.

Ta Se CTepa tovtwv itepi tc tow kokkov r^g atvdiiefog Kai irept


$

XIII. 26. AOTKAN ETArrEATOT. 109

*'
T^f ^v[Ji.y]g ea)f Kai eiatv -^pZTOi oi eaovTai ea-yaroi,^^ '^poeypa^rj

€/$ TO KaTa MaT6a7ov.

KE^. N.
UepX Tov eirepcyrTj(TavTOs el oXiyot ol (ra>^o/xevo{.

25 'Q.$ yap €Trt Tivog oiKoheaiioTOv iroWovg tZv iTriTYj^eioDV awe-^


yvjyepKOTOs elf eaTiav Kai Tpave^av, eha TrpoeicrPe/SyjKOTOs fx-eff

uv e^et TOVTO ^pav, avoKXeiaavTos t€ t^v Qvpav, tov<; fJieTa tovto

Kpovovrag aKOvaeaSai <j>v]aiv, OTt " ovk oi^a vfiai voSev eaTe, airo-
" aTVjTe air efxov TravTe^ epyaTat attKtag'^^ ov^efxia yap Kotvmia
<f>coTt irpog aKOTog. rtveg S av vovjQeiev ot XeyovTcg, to5 ^ptaToo to 10
**
€(f>dyofi,ev Kat eTriofi.ev evwirtov aovy Kat ev TaHg irXaTetatg y]fi.wv

" ett^^a^ag f^ dpfnoaetev av ToiovTog te Koyog, fidkiaTa To7g e^

lapay]Xf oig S*^ Kat e(f>y] ^ptaTog, " OTt oxpeaOe A(3paafx Kat laaaK,
** Kai laKaP, Kat irdvTag rovg irpo(fyf]Tag^^ Kat ra e^rig.

26 Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias. n«f ovv yja&tov Kai eirtvov evco- J

vtov Tov Seov ; t^^v vofj.tKY]v TeXovvTeg XaTpetav, TrpoaKOfxt^orreg

yap tcc SeHo rag ^/ aifx.aTog Svatag y^aStov Kai yjixppatvovTO,

y]Kpo(tiVTO ^e Kat ev raTg avvaytayaig tcSv Mwi/Vewf (StPXtav, ov


Ta eavTov yeypacpoTog fxaWoVf epfJ.y]vevovTog ^e to. irapa tov Seov'
**
irpoaveTiSet yap de) Tav eavTOv (fxovav to TaSe Ae-yez K.vptogJ'^ 20
'A\)C ovk dpKei irpog ^tKaiaaiv y] ^i aifux,T(ov XaTpetay ovQ

av dirov^xpeTO Ttg fi.o\vafi.ovg, aKpoary^g fx.ev TOiv Setoov yevofJievog

vofJMVf Treirpoc/jog Se ovtev tS>v KeKe\evafj.evQ}V, Kat eTepwg Se t^v

VKTTiv ov Trpoay^Kdfj.evot t^v ^iKatovaav tov evae^r], Kat t');^ evay-


yeXiKy]v, 6eaniafi.aatv dKoXovS^aavTeg, tt wv y]v ^vvaaSai tvjv 25
ev(pva Kat e^etXeyfj.evy]v e^aaK^^aat ^wyjVf Trag av et eXdaetev eig

t^v PaatXeiav tov Seov eiraptBfx-^aetg To7g avofxaafj.evotg, Kat

erepovg rtvag ^vvafj.evovg eiveiv, eaff ore ruv Trdvrccv KptTy^g,

**
e(f>dyofuev Kat eiriofJ.ev evamov aov, Kat ev TaTg irXaTetatg yjfJMV

**
e^/^a^af." Kat rtveg av eiev ovTot irdXtv ; iroXJXot TreTriarevKa- ^o
aiv eig rov Xpo"TOV, Kat rag dytag eir «vtoS reXovaiv eoprag.

(fjotTwvTeg ^e Kai ev eKKXyfata twv evcvyyeXtKm aKpowvTat irai-

^evjxdnov, diroTiOevTai Se c/V vovv rSv yeypafj.fj.evwv ov^ev, dxXa,


110 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XIII. ^^.

Kai Ttviv^ariKyji epyaaiag yvixvyjv e/pvai Trjv \l/vy(y]v. KXavaovTat


Kcu ovTOi TTiKpag Kai ^pv^ovdi Tovi o^ovTa^' apv^aeTat yap Kat

avTov^ Kvptoi. €^^7 ovv OTt " ov Traf o Xeycov fxoi, Kvpte, Kvpief
" etaeXeva-eTat eis t>jv jSaatXeiav rov Seov, «AX 6 ttoiuv to
" 6eXy][xa tov TiaTpog fxov tov ev To7g ovpavoli^ 5

KE*. NA.
Ilfpt rSiV (Ittoptcov r<p 'Irjorov 8ia 'tlpadrjv.

31 To " €^eX9e Kat iropevov evTevOeVf^ (pOovca (pepofxevot 01 ^api-


aaHot eXeyov ^eaTroTyj XptcTTw' ovte yap yj6eXov Ttvag <ptXe7a6at

VTT avTOv, ovTe Taig 6eoav]ff.iatg, ovt€ Ta7s vnep vofJiov fi.vaTaya>- i o
ytatg. Oitep yap ehov, " oti 'Hpw^yjg 6eXei de a.TcoKTel.vai^''

vpo(f)aai^ofLevot eXeyov, o6ev avTog a>i eTa^wv vecfypovg Kat

Kap^iagf tovto e/^«f, Tipdwg tc Kat eTre<7Ktaafj.evag, Ka6(ag e6og


*'
avToo, dvTaitOKpt^eig e/Ve, e<7raTe ty] dXaTreKi Tavrrj.^^ Kat ^oKeT

fxev TTCog TeTpd(f>6at Kat ^Xeiretv t^v rov koyov ^vvaft.tv etg ro '5

'Hpio^ov "TrpoacoTTOV, wg rtveg evofKtaav, epyerat ^e fxdWov Kara


TVjg ^aptaatav a-Katoryjrog. ov yap eine r^ aXcoireKt eKeivv], aXXa
**
ravTf]^^ ev(f)vearara fx.eay] rtvt '^wfx.evog (pavyj, aa^piag hetKWcev

eyyvg ovrag r^ dXwTceKt rovg ^apiaaiovg ryj iravovpyia' Kat yap

TToog cog det itavovpyov eart Kat ^varponov to ^wov, ovtoo Kat ot 20

^apiaa7ot' o6ev Kat wg TrpoatoKavreg Karoppcio^-^aetv avrov t>;v

'Hpwtov 'Xeipa, ravra eXeyov, Kat rot rwv ^vvdfi.ecov ovra Kvptov.

Oirep ^e i^^et XvTreiv ro rcov ^aptaaicov ar7(pog, diioTtXy^povv eitay-


**
yeXXerat Xeycov, i^of, eK(3dXXci} ^aifJLOvia, Kat idaetg eTTtreXuJ'*

D>g ydp irpoeipy]Tat ^ta rovro e^icoKov avrov, tva ft.y] rr] rav Ttapa- 25
to^cov eitt^^et^et •xjicofjievog, aayyjvevyj •jroXXoiig etg ro Tiiareveiv

avrco.
<

Atd ^e rov eiveTv " reXetovfxat,^^ e^et^ev, ort eKwv vTrofLevet

ro eTTt tcS (xravpco Ttd6og, Kat rore vitepyerat ye rov acoaai Ty]v

VTT ovpavov. 30
S3 E/ttwv Se ort " ^el jotc" ovk dvdyKi^v d^tacpvXaKrov e^^y^pry)-

ft.evy]v cecTtep eavrco e^-^Xceaev, aXX ori fJiaXXov cv e^ovata rav

avrov 6eXy]fj.dr(ev dvetfj.evcog re Kat dvwroTtrcog, oitotTtep av edeXot,


XIV. I. AOYKAN ETArrEAIOY. 111

Pa^iUTaif Ka) irepivoaT^a-y} t>)v 'lovJaiav, ov^evo^ (TiiovTOi yj eiri-

/SofAevovTOf, a.y£i<; av avTog KaTa^e^yjTai ttjv ^ia tov tijmiov

tTTavpov TeXiiaaiv. To ^e " a-^fxepov Kai avpiov,^^ TcXeiovag "^fJ^e-

pag ^yjXoi.

Ktiroiv Se oti " ovk ev^ej^eTa/ Trpo<py}Tyiv aTroXeadai e^co 'Jepov- 5


'*
aak-i^fji" eS^Awczev oti koi tovto, (pyjaiv, aTtoKiiTai avTyj, to Kai
e/xe avTOv tov twv vpocpyjTcov Kvptov ev avT^ iraBth.
To Se '* ovK ev^e'j^eTa/' fxyj^eig vofJii^eTa} /Siav avayKaaTiKyjv

'louSa/o^f lTrayoit.evr,v eU to ToiayTa ^^av elpy^aGai, aWa KaTa


Trjv T^i aXyjBeiag ^iayvuaiv e| uv eirpaTTOv [xiai(f)ovov KeKTi^fJievoi 10
irpoaipeaiv. To " lepovaaXyjfi., \epovaaXy}fi." kccs, " ev ovofji.aTi

*'
KvpioVf Trpoeypa<l>yf eU to Ka;ra MaT^arov."

KE^. NB.
Ilfpt TOV vdpaTTlKOV,

I KX>;l9ei$ §e waA/v vwo ^aptaaiov ev aapPaTco ^ea^^oTyjg i^

^piaTog' y]v Se ovTog t<cv irap avrolq '^iaTrpeTreaTaTcoVf fx.aXtaTa

Oia TO ^vaTpoirov ayToJv a^^XSe, fxaXXov ^e &;a t*?v tovtwv oi^e-

Xetav avveaTtoi yevofxevog TovTotg, oircog Becopot yevof/.evot t^s uirep

av$pcc7Tov la^jfvog t€ Qfi.ov Te Kat ^ofiyf avTov, Taj^a irag Kav ovTcag
irtaTevacaaiv OTt ©eof eaTi, Kai T/of 0eov t>;v Tr^bj- y]fxag Ofiotcaaiv 20
wreAfliv, oy/<c airoaTaq tov e/va< b i^V irapeTfipovvTO ^e avTOV, /m.^

a^a 7ra)f KaTa-jretppovyjKe Tyjg elg tov vofjt,ov a/^oSf, t/ twv car-fffo-

p€Vft,evci}v epya^Ofnevog ev ^ft-epa aa(3l3dT'x. 6 te Kvpiog ovy^ oircog

ckkXiv^ Tvjv a<ppova f/.ef/.\piv, aXX oirag evepyeTyjafi Ttvag irdvTa

^taTrpaTTeTai, o9ev Kat tyjv dcppoavvyjv eXey)(^et twv atTtaaBat jueA- 25

AovTwv afTOv eirt aa^^aTtKa^ig evepyeaiaig, Xeycov,"€^eaTt tco aa/S-

**)SaTaj BepaTrevaat y} ov ;" Kat yap y}v, (pyjatv, avBpcoTrog Ttg v^poirt-

Kog efiirpoaBev avTov. eiret^r} Be '^vaTpoircag aeatyyjKaat, irapaXvei

KpiaTOg Tyjv dSpavaTOV avTcov dvaiayyvTiav, Xoytafj.oHg avayKatotg


eig TovTo y(jpcofj.evog, Kat coaavet Xeycov avToTg, et KeKcoXvKev vofx.os ^o
eXeeh ev aa/^^dTca, Trcog eirotKTetpetg avTog tov etg <f>peap KaTa-
Treaovxa ; fj^ (ppovTiaiqg viov
Ktv^tvevovrog ev aa^^dTcc, fjiyj^e Tt
112 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XIV. ii.

Tav ToiovTCOv liaTrpd^i^ ; Toiyapovv yaipnv eiTrav Ta7g ^apKxdiKaXi

Pa<7Kaviaif, dnakXdTTei tov voaeTv tov v^epca KeKpaTVj^tvov.

KE*. Nr.
Hfpi Tov firi ayairav tcls irpa)roK\i(Tias.

7 Oirep ^e enre, tov$ KeKXvjixevovs " eitiayjtiv Trai Tag TrpaTOKXi- ^


" (Xiag e^eAeyovTo," ^0Ke7 [xev Tia-tv 'lawg [xiKpd itag eivai Taura,
Kat ov TroAA^? d^ta (ppovTttog' OTav ^e Ttg avTo7i tov tyj^ "hiavoiag

0(j>6a\ixov evepetay], TOTvjvtKa^e ixaByjaeTat, onoiov fxev dnaXkdT-


T€t fAcofAOv Tov avdpuTToVf offov Sc TO KOCfxtov avTOv epyd^eTui'

TO yap TtfJLag ov iravT&jf yjff.Tv o^petXofxevag Ttpoyetpiag eir t^l^viT eh lo


d(7vveTov<; diro^patvet. Tiocrifjg yap atcxyvvvjg to itpdyfx.a fuefxe<7T(o~

Tai, OTav evTtfxooTepov eX6ovTOf, 6 dfX(j)OTepovg KaXeaag epei, **


^og
*'
ToyTco TOTTOV ;" (xaippctiv te Koi d^to6avfJLa(7TOS 6 ^vvaTOg (ov to7s

•npcoTots KaTa(refJiVvv€a6at, Kai tovtov fxev ovk e^iefJi.evoi, itapa^/a-

pSiv te eTepotg vito ye tov fi.^ ^oKeiv vjTTa(76at <f>tko^o^ta' ^tonep 6 15


**
TOtovTos (og 0(f)XvjfLa Xi^xpeTai ttjv TtfiivjV, to 7tpo(7avd^vi6t^ dKovav.

fxeya Totvvv Kat e^atpeTov dya6ov to fj.eTptov <ppovv]fj.a.


Ktpiaaot 'Aaebanapeias. E/ yap ToTg hepotg TtpoaTdT-
T€(j6at ^vjreT, Kep^^aiveTQ) tovto ^ta t^? av(o6ev xp-^^pov, Kai (TTe^pa-

vov(76(o TtfiaTg Talg itapa 0€ou, vtKdTOO itoWovg tvj twv apeTcov 20
XafXTtpoTi^Tt, Tvi Ta7tetvo(f>po(7vv^' v\pvjXov yap itapd ©eoj to <tvv-

e(7TaXfj.evov <f)povv}fxa. fxtfivjTvjg yiveTat tov ^ptaTOv tov elvtov-


*'
Tog, fxd6eT€ avt efxov oti Ttpavg etfxt Kat Taitetvog tvj Kap-
*'
S;a." TauTa ^e Ae-ywv ovKCTt eittitXvjTTet ^apeag, dXXd TtapatveT

'^VjUTag. 25
1 i To ^e, " itag vrpiov eavTOV Ta7t€tv(o6vj(7€Tai, Kat Taitetvm eav-
*'
Tov v\p(o6-^aeTai," TVjg 6etag vjpTvjTat Kptcxecog, ov TtdvTOog ydp KaTo,
Tvpj Tav dv6pwTt(ov eTttTeXeiTat (tvv^^etav, eTre^S^ Kai TtoXXot Ttfx^g

opeypivTeg, eneTvy^ov T^g evTeXovg TavTvjg Ttixvjg.


5

XIV. i6. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 113

KE4>. NA.

Ilept tHv KoKoviievoiV iv ra deiirvm.

12 'TTTofiejxevo? Trepi ryjg (xuT^^piov raTreivo^f^pocvvvji Qeiov Trapdy-

ye\fxa KaXov Kai itpog rovq KaXovvraq enKpepei to ^i^^ayfxa^ Kat


fjieyav etadyei rvj^ Trpog dvBpWTTOvg ^e^Ktiaeag tov aKonov Kai tovS

Kapnov d^ioiJTtov^haarov, el Kai [xvj irapayjiYjfxa tvjv dvTaiio^oo-iv

KeKTV)Tai. 01 yap fxiKpo\pv)(oi (f>iXovg KaXovvTeg Kai d^e\(f)Ovg


Kai avyyeve7g Kai yenovag, ^;a to evOeag dvTiKXYjQ^vai itap avrm
TovTO TTOiovaiv' 01 ^e fxeyaXo^^vyoi to vitep^akkovTCiii; KakXiov
Kai fj.eyaXoTipeiTeaTepov epyai^ovTai, oirep vTte^^ei^ev o K.vpiog' to lo

Tovi teofi.evovg Kai da$eveig Kai \eXx/3y]f>.evov$ <f)iXav9pa7ievecr6ai,


Trap wv ovK eariv avTanoboa-tg' aAA o Kyeos o avTaTrooioovg tv}^

(f>t\av$p(t}TTiag tvjv Ttfii^v ent t^^ f/.eX\ovav]g ^co^g' tovto ^e ov^

tva Tijf Trpog Tovg i^tovg dTreip^vj Ttft.^i ^tefiapTvpaTO, d\X tva

^t^d^v} fxrj TTtTTpdiTKetv Tag (f)iXoff)poavvas tS)V taav avTaTro^coo-ewc, 1

dW a)(f>eXtf/.ovg TroieTaOat Tavrag eTii fj.eydXatg dvTam^^aaeat


TOig Ttapa %eov.

O etttav " fxaKapios og Ttg <f)dyerat dptaTov ev r^ ^aaiXeta


*'
rxv ovpavaVf^ ovirto fxev ^v TrvevfLartKog, rpv^^^tKog Se ft.a\XoVf

Kai dveirtrvj^etag eycov irpog avveatv dKpt^vj rav XaXovfJLevcov Ttept 20


'^piarov, wviQv} yap aoofj.aTiKag eaeadat riiov dyictiv rag afjiot^dg.

^toirep e^vcpaivet "KpiaTog 6 Qeog v]fi.xv itapa^oXvfv rolg rore


Ttapovatv' dTtoyjpe(iiVT(iig eyovaav etg Ttapd^et^tv r^g eiti Ttavrt tw
Koafico yevofnevvjg oiKovofJ.iag, i^rtg eartv avrvj.

16 *'
Av9poo7tog rtg," (f^vjatv^ " eTtoivjae leTitvov fxeya,'^ Kat 025
fnev avGpccjtog vovjQetvj avQpcoTtog Kat Ttarvjp' at yap eiKOveg TrAaT-

Tovrat Ttpog ro dXvjSeg, ovk avrat ^e Ttdvnog eiaiv vj dXviBeia'

ovro} ^v} ovv rwv oXwv tvifj.tovpyogf Ylarvip T^i" 'ho^vig fj.eya

TteitotviKe SetTTVov, TouTeo-Tiv, ciKovft.evtKV]v etpydaaro itav^yvpiv'


b^^Xov Oe ort tv]V e^tt Kptarto oetTtvov Oe avro KaXei Kat 01/5^*30

dptaroVf ort ev eaydrotg Katpolg rov atwvog, Kat oiov eitt tvafxalg

rov Ka& v]u.ag alwvog e7te(f)dvv] vjfnTv Tiog, ore Kat rov ^t v]fi.ag vite-

aTV] BdvaTov, Kai ^e^ooKev ^fj.Hv rv]v eavTOu adpKa (payeh, e^dXeae
114 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XIV. i8.

^e iroXXovs, ra 7rX^6v] ^vjXovoti twv 'lov^aiccv. r/f ^e ^" o aire-

(TTak^tvog, ov Vifj Kai '^ovXov eivai (f)Yjaiv ; avzog o "KpKTTog'

ocTig Seog oov (f)va€i, Kai Tlog aXi^Sivog, " [xopcpvjv ^ovXov kavTOV
" Kevuiaag aveAa/5e." IloJa ^e vjv a yjToifxacre To7g KeKXvjfxevoig ;

afxapTiiiv aTioSeaiVf IIvey/AaTOf 'Ayiov fxeSe^iVf vU6(.(Tiag Xaixirpo- 5

T^Ta, I3acrik€iav ovpavxiv' liti TavTa KeKXyjKC Kvpiog 6 Seog '^ia

Toov evayyeXtKm Be<JTii(Xix.aT(av itpo ye twv aAA.ct)V tov IcrpaoyX.

To ^e *'
^p^avTo ano [xiag itavTeg '7rapaiTe7a6ai" tovto eaTiv,

OTi wg e^ evog avvQvifxaTog oiiheva Xoyov eTroivjaavTO T^f KX^^aeag,

To7g yecoteaTepoig aavveTccg npoavevevKOTeg, aypm Te Kai yeuipyiag lo

Kai Tiai^oTroiiag eveKa.

i8 Tiveg Be av vovjSeiev oi TrapaiTVjadfxevoi ; vj faya ttov TVjg \ov-

^aiccv avvaycoyvjg ol TrpoeaTvjKOTeg, av^tpeg a^poi Ta ^aXXavTia Kai


(piXoKep^^la YjTTrifj.evot, koj. icaaav elg tovto "^aTravcavTeg airov^-^v'

^ta TracTTjf yap eirog ei7re7v Trjg QeoTtvevaTov ypa^pvjg eit avTo7g 0>? 1$

TOVTOii '^iaj3el3Xi^f/i.evovg eveaTiv i^e7v TovTovg. ^io Kai e^co ff.eft.evri-

Kaat TYig eopTrjg, Ta7g ovtco aKXvjpa7g aneiBetatg to fxeya ^e7TTV(tV

7repivl3ptaavTeg.

21 KeKXy}VTai ^e dvT eKeivcov oi eig Tag -nXaTetag Kat Tag pvfxag,


ol eK Tojf lov^aiW^f itXriBvog daQevri tc Kai dyevvri t^^v oidvoiav 20
ecog Tivog eyovTeg Ka) d(f>eyyy} Kat yaXevovaav, vyie7g Oe Kai

evppcoaToi ^ta Tvjg etg X^/crrov yevofnevvjg iriaTecog' e^t^d^^^Bvjaav

yap opOoTio^e^v, Ka] to 6e7ov eig vovv ehe^avTO (f)a>g' oti Oe Treirt-

aTevKaai tu>v lovdaicov ovk evapi6ft.v]Toif '^iafxdBoi Ttg av Ta7g tcov

dyicov ATToaToXcov Hpcx^eatv evTuj^wv. 25


23 'Aya6og wv (jivaei Qeog Kot (piXdv6pco7Tog Kat eig Tocg ohoiig

Kai eig Tovg (f>payfj.ovg e^aTtoaTeXXet tov ^etTrvoKX-^Topa, oirep

d7ro(patv€i tvjv tcov e6vm KXvjaiv, fxeTdye To7g e^ atfxaTog lapavjX

elaeveveyfxevovg 'hta TYjg TriaTecog' Kai ydp " eii TO^rog eo-T;/' (fjvjatv'

v^r^^pyov ^e ol e^ eBvav dypoiKoi Tdg (ppevag Kai aTrvjyptcofxevoi TOV30


vovv, Kat olov e^co TroXecog ^tdyovTeg, ^td to fxvj ^vjv ev evvoff.ia,

KTYpiOTrpeTrwg te fxdXXov, Kat avv dXoyia. TroXX^.

Oyj^ aTrXiog Be fiTre TovTOvg KaXeaat, dXXa Kai avayKdaai,


KatToi TrpoaipeTiKOV d^raai to TriaTeveiv eaTi, Kat ^eKTOv tovto

irapd Oeco, Kat Tav Trap avTov ')(aptafx.dTCOV ava7rifX7rXdfJ.e6a. Trcog


35
XIV. 28. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 115

oio» e/Vev avayKafTai ; KaT oiKovofxiav riva' ("Tieitv} yap Tavra ev

acpop-^Ta ^ovXeia r^f itXdvrig KaTeiyovTOt VTre^^vyfJieva tw ^ia-

I3o\oo Kcu ovK el^OTa' tia tovto (7VVT0[xa}T€pag «Aoycrecyf eberjOvja-av

fjii[xov[xevy}g dvdyKvjg yjpeiav, iva kolv ovTag la^/yGOifJiv avajSkeipat

Tipog ©eov, Kai t»v iep<hv yevaacyOai [xadrjiJidTCtiv, a7ro(poiTV}<TavTa S

Tiqg dpy^aiaq dTtdirigy Kat aTroTivj^-^aavTa TpOTTov Ttva TVjg tov Oia-

^okov xeipog.
E/Vwv 6 ^eairoTrji 'KptaTog Kat (j)tXdv$pa7rog, " et Tig epyeTai

" irpog jote, Kai ov [XiaeT tov ira.Tepa eavTov" Kat toc €^%, oyTe
dyvorjaat Tvpf <f>vaiv, ovTe ^ovXevaat t^ <f>vaet TrpoaTdaaet \pt- lo

(TTOf, dXXa yjprjaBai t-^ cpvaei irpog to d[xetvov Kai acoT-^ptoV Kat

yap TO Tt[JMv yoveag Kat avTW tcJ; Ky/J^w So^er, Kai tq eKTpe<petv

Ta T€Kva Kat Ta TOtavTa, Tor^ yovevatv vnaKovttv, Kat to ayaita.v

Ta? eavTm yvvaiKag Toi/g dv^pag, Kai to Tag yvvaiKag Tovg eav-

Twv dv^pag (po^eiadat, 6 6e7og A.iioaToXog elar^y^aaTO. ov yapz^


QiKetovg ye ovTag t^ irtaTet, Tovg otKetovg [xtarjTeov, aXXa tovto
eaTiv, oitep (f>rjatv, ort Toiig irpog t^v eig Seov maTtv e[XTio^t^ovTag

Kat Ttpog aocTvjpiav xpv^^^^g KooXvovTag, TovTovg TiapatTr^Teov, Kat

[xr]la[t.ag eve/cev dydif^g aapKtKrjg, Trjg eig KpiaTOV dyditrjg

icaTa<f>pQV€Tv.

KE*. NE. 2o

Hfpi olKodofirjs nvpyov irapa^oXr).

28 To Se eK Trig tov vvpyov QtKo^o[xrjg r][x7v eTtt^ri\ov[xevov, tovto

eaTtv, iva ol t»;v evKXea Kat a[XQ)[i.rjTOv ^ariv KaTopBovv eXo^xevot,

Tr^v dpKovaav ev tovto} 7tpoBv[xtav, tw eayTwv eyKOTaBe^xevot vot,

oviwg e-zovTat Tr)g TotavTVjg [xaKapiag itoXuetag, [ke[xvrja6at t€ 25

Tov XeyovTog " tIkvov, el itpoaep-xrj ^ovXevetv Kvpica, eToi[xaaov Trpj


*'
'>\'vyYiv aov eig Ttetpaa^xov, ev6vvov t>^v Kap^tav aov Kat KapTepvj-
" <rov" €1 Se Trapa Ttatv ovk eaTt 7tpo6v[/.ta TOtavTYi, ovTot itwg av

la^/yaetav tov TtpoaTedetKOTa avTOtg itepatwaai aKottov ;

ToT ArioT Mahimot sxoaion. ^tg rj TtapalSoXr] tov wu/J-30

yov ; Ttvpyog ar\[xatvet Trjv tSiv dpeTwv TeXetwaiv [X€Ta yvuaecog

QiKo^o[i^rj6eTaav. oaTig ovv itpdrTet Trjv KaTa itpd^tv ditd^etav,

eyet eittTr^etoTriTa itpog eitiKTi^aiv <f>vaiK«ov Kai QfwpvjTtKwv Kat

Q. 2
116 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XIV. 31.

GeGKoyiKiiv Xoyuv, ^i m aTta^Ti^^eTai 7} TeXeia yvwaig' ovto^

reXeioi t>;v oiKO^^Ofjiyjv tov irvpyov, 6 ^e eWeiTrvj^ rovTcov fxv} ^vv/j-

6eii elg Ttepa^ ayayetv tyjv oiKo^ojJiVjVf efXTrai^eTai Trapa t£v iiapa-

T:opevofi.evav, ene avQpw-nwv ene ^atfxovuv.

31 To ^e " e'i Tig ^aatXev^ itopevofj.evog erepfX) ^aatXeH avfx^a-^


'*
Keh eis TroAe^ov," Kai ra e^rj^, rovro avjft.aivei, ori irpog rag
evavTiag ^vvdfj.eig eariv yjfj.h dyav, KaSwg ^itoaroXog <pif}aiv,

*'
ovK ecTTiv yjfi.Tv yj TrdXvj yrpog alfj.a Kai adpKa^^ Kai to, e^vjg. Et/
^e Kat Tipog to <f)povv]fj.a rvjg aapKog, ev roTg f/.eXeaiv vjfnav

dyptatvwv vofKog, ra TioXvTpoTra TrdSv], Tipog ravTa vjfj.h vj TraXTy, 10


avTVj Tuv e^^Bpav vj aypia TiXyjBvc,' Ttag ovv apa rovrav irepteao-

f).e6a ; orav 7n(7T€va(Cfj.ev ort ev tco 0ew Trotvj<TOfJ.ev tvvafj.tv, Kai

ort avTOg e^ovdevwaet Trdvrag rovg BXifoovrag vjfJ.dg, Ka6ibg eav-

rov Ttg rav dyiav TipocfyvjToov ^taBetg e<pvj, " /^oy, Kvptog ^ori^eT fj.ot,

" Ka) rig KaKaaet f^e ;" Kat iidXiv 6 ^eaTieaiog Aa^t'^' " Kvpte, 15
" cf)Q}Ttaft.og fJ.ov Kat SwT^p /xoy," Kat Ta e^vjg' avrog yap •^ft.icv
7] \ayvg eari. ^io avrov eyovreg I3ovj6ov, fxv]^afi.ag Tiept etpvjv^g

rovg e-^^Ppovg v]fj.oov '^aifj.ovag epoor-^awfjiev, oiiep eart ^ovX(i)6v]vai

roHg 7id6eatv, dXXd fxdXXov dvrtarafxev avro7g, rov Kparatov Qeov

v]fn.av eig dvTtXvj\ptv oXoxpvj^ccg Kat d^taXetnTag eTitKaXovft.evot. 20

34 KaAoj/ To akas' iau Se to aXas fJLCopau6fj eV tljji

apTvO-qaeTai ;

Ktpiaaot. EcrTOJcrav ovv ev v]ft.h 01 aXeg, Tovreartv, ot 6e7ot

re Kat aooT^ptot Xoyot, wv edv KaTa(f)povvjao>fj.ev, eaofj.e6a fLcopoi

Kai davverot, Kat a^^elot TiavreXag. 25

'Eh ANEnirPA*or. Ovroo ^v] Kat ro aXag eivai ndvrag av-

aTVjaerat rovg fxev npcDroog, rovg Se ^evrepoog' Tipooroog fxev yap 01

'ATioaroXot, 01 tm Koafxx itavTt yeyovaatv dXeg, Kat oaoi fxer

eKeivovg rotovrot dpTvovreg eig aooTV]ptav dv6pw7iovg, Oevrepov Se

01 rdg eKKXv]atag iiXvjpovvTeg, Xaot yjp-^aifxot Tipog oo(f)eXetav ro7g ^o


TiXvjaid^ovat Ka6taTdft.€vot, " KaXov ovv," (f)Yjat,
" to aXag, eav
" ^e TO dXag fxoopav6^, ev rtvi aprv^-^aerat, ovre etg y^v, ovre eig
**
KOTipiav ev6erov eartv' e^oo ^aXXovatv avro. 'O eyav ura aKovetv
" dKoveTOoJ^ yjpviaifxovg vfxdg (f>v]atv, 6 iiap efxov Xoyog anaatv
dv6p(io7ioig KaraaKevd^et, Kat Tidatv eiii acoTvjpta iiapafxtyvvat, 35
XV. II. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 117

rotovTOvg aTTo^eiKvvs oiov^ Trpoeipi^Ka' (i ^e irapacpQeipe.i ttjv Ttpotr-

•^Kovfrav tiavoiav, oxne a<p vfxav ocpeXos ov^ev), ovt€ vfx^v €T€p(0-

Btv acpeXeia aTroAeAreTa/, o6ev ovTe elg y^v, oWe eii' Konpiav

ev8eT0i eaeaQe' y^ [J.ev yap to wcpeXovfxevoVy KOitpog to wcpeXovv'

VLLeTg ^e Ttpog to uxpeXeh Koafiw airavTa Keifxevot, ei fi.y}Te wcpe- 5

Amo; fkevoiTe, fxrjTe w(peXeia6ai ^vvaa6e' aTroKXyjTOi Kai eig ovoev

eaecBe. "Evfia Vq Kai avveaecog ecpYj teh To7g aKovovatv, (oare


vapa^oXtKOv ovTa tov Xoyov avvievat. Ta aKoXov6a ewg t^$ iiapa-
^oXYjg Twv p TTpo^aTWV TrpoeypafpT] etg to Kaia y\.aT6a7ov.

8 Ylept T^f 'tpa')(jx.'^g (pvjatv 6 aytog Tprjyoptog 6 BeoXoyog, OTt 10

Xxr/yov rj\l>ev X.piaTog Kat Qeog, ^t^XovoTt tvjv eavTOv aapKa, Kai

TViv oiKtav eadpwae t^? dfxapTiag, tov Koafxov diioKa^dpag, Kat


TYiv ^pa^^Qxvjv e^-fjTYiae, tyiv /SaatXiKYjv etKova avyKeywafxevYjv To7g

7rd6eai, Kat avyKaXenat Tag (ptXag avTW Jivvdfxetg eiit ty] TVjg

^pa-^QXYjg evpeaet, Kai KOivwvovg Ttotehat TYJg eixppoavvYig, ag Kat 15


TYjg oiKovofi.iag fxvaTt^ag eneTtoiYiro.

'Eb ANEnirPA*OT. \vyyov fxev ditTOfxevov eivat Tiy^" tttaaKa-


Xiag Tov Xoyov, adpwatv Ve ty]V twv dfKapTiwv aitOKd^apaiv, Kat
Twv TtovYjpwv ^atfi.ovwv Tov ywptafxov Kai ttjv ditaXXoTpiwaiv. TOVTa

yap otovet y£Yift.aTa tyj etKOvt eTttitpoaBovvTa ov avvey^wpet eit 20

o^eatv opaa6ai Qeov' o6ev tovtwv ditwa^evTWV, evpe6yj yj aitoXw-

Xvla ^pa^^fXY], vito TY)g yvvatKog, y^v elg t^v eitovpdvtov eiXYjcpev

'lepovaaXYjfx.
KE*. Nr.
HepX Tov diTo8i]firj<TavTos tls ;^«pai» fiaKpdv.

1 1 E/TTWV oeaTtOTYig \ptaTog gti " dv6pwitog Ttg ^vo ei^/ev viovg,^^

Ttept ToD avdpwTttvov yevovg (f>Y]aiv, qti eig ^vo ^f^pYjTat TayfMiTa, 25
etg ^iKaiovg Kai dfnapTwXovg, etg ^e itaTYjp TYjg dv6pw7tOTYjTog, 6

(f>iXdv6pwitog ©€0f. YlpoaYjX^e Se, (pYjatv, 6 vewTepog, ov ^td tov

yjpovov vewTcpog dXXd ^td to evov TVjg dtavotag Kat ti;v yvwfXY^v

aaTaTOv KeKTVja6at dv^Xt^ vitdpywv Kat Xeyet tw itaTpi, " ^Of


" fxot TO etti^dXXov fxepog TVjg ofcr/ac," TovTeaTtv, ov BeXw ^oy-30
Xevetv avdyKYj, avTe^ovatog ydp eifxt, eav 6eXw, aw(f>povw, edv ov

6eXw, ovK dvayKo^ofxat' etwKev ovv TtaTYjp d(f)6ovwg dnaaav ttji/

KTiaiv, eiteaiYiaev avTw tov eayToD vofxov tov (f>vaiKOV Ka) ypaitTOv,
118 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XV. 13.

iva ev TOVTCO TTai^aycoyovixevos irXrjpcca'/] tov vofxoGeTov to jSov-

kyjjxa, GeXei yap yjfxag eKova-icc^ ^ovXeveiv avTco' eha, (pyjaiVf

a7re^^/x>;(7e ttov, Kai «Treo-TTj 0eo$ air avTOv' ov fSia^eTai yap

oii^eva ^vj PovXofxevov ^ovXeveiv avTw.

13 ATTO^yjfx-^aag toivvv e^yjaev aacoTco^, Kai avyjXcoae tvjv ova-tav, 5

TovTeaTt Tov efXcpVTOv Xoyiafxov, t>jv acocppoavvyjVj tvjv yvcoatv t^$


aXyjOeia^, tvjv fxv^fxyjv tov Qeov' o$ev Kai yeyovev avTco Kifxog

layypogf ov kifxo^ apTOV ovoe 'hi^lia v^^aTog, aXXa Xifxog tov aKov-
aai Xoyov K.vpiov' eiteTat yap Trf ocnccXeia tS)v itpoeipyjfxevcov

*'
apeTcov TOiovTOf Xifxog. Aio Kai irapevfivg eKoXXyjQYj evi tcov 10
" TToXiTCOv T^S^g 'X}*>po'-i eKeivyjg'" evBanep eiaiv 01 fxev "noXnai avTVjg

^aifi.ovegi 6 ^e Xifxog tcov dyaOcov acpodpog' ^/0 Kai eirefx^ev avrov

eig Tovg aypovg avTOv (3oaKeiv yoipovg' ovtco yap Tifxcoaiv 01

^aif>.oveg Tovg TifxavTag avTovg, ToiavTag ^copeag yapi^l^ovTai Totg

TteiBofxevoig avTOig. Kai yap eKTtnrTCov Tig diio 0eov, Kai ^/a t£v 15

ly^ovwv Tolg taifxoai itpoaKoXXiifxevogi yoipatyjg Te yevofxevog tog

eig yyjv vevevKcog, Kai tw (3opl3opcp tcov t^$" aTifxiag TtaBwv eyKvXiv-

tovfxevog, eiKOTCog yolpog vofxtadyjaeTar y^poviil^cov ^e Tor^ KaKoli

Kat aXXotg Tvitog aitcoXeiag evpiaKeTat, Tpoitov Ttva ^oaKCov av-

Tovg Kai Tpe(f>cov Toig T-rjg dacoTiag di^dyfi.aat. to ^e " eiteBvfxei 20


" 'XPpTaaByjvai Ik twv KepaTicov wv YjaBtov ot yolpot, Kai ovtetg l&<-

" tov avTM'" TOVTo eaTtv, OTt Tcov KaKcov ovK eXdfx[3ave KopoV itapa,-

PdXXeTat ^e Toig KepaTtotg yj dfi.apTia, OTt coaitep yj to^twv yevatg


yXvKeld eaTi, kut avTO ^e Kat Tpayeta, ovtco Kat yj t^? dfxaprtag

(f)vatg evcppatvet fxiKpa Kat KoXd^et f/.eydXa, Tepitet itpoaKaipa 25

Ka) fxaaTi^et atcovta. eig eavTOV eXdcbv, TOVTeaTt Xoytadfxevog tvjv

TtpoTepav fLaKaptOTyjTa Kat tvjv ^evTepav dSXtOTyjTa, Kat Ttg fxev

yjv oVe yjv fxeTo, tov Qeov Kat HaTpog, Tig ^e yeyovev oVe yjv vTto-

TeTayfxevog Totg talfxoatv, eiite, " itoaoi fxtaStoi rov YlaTpog jw.ov,"

TOVTeaTi KaTviyovfxevot, Kat yap fxtaBovTat aet (f)iXdv6pco7tog ^o


Seog, Kat nept Tpnyjv copav Kat e(f)e^y^g, cog yeypaitTat, " iteptaaev-
" ovTa< a^TWv," twv fie<wv evTpv(pcovT€g ypa(f>cov, *' eycb he tco Xtfx^

" TovTCov avveyofxatr " Avao-Taf ttopevaofxat ttpog tov itaTepa fxov^^

vTtoaTpexpco KaXcbg o6ev e^i^X9ov KaKcbg, Kai epa avrw, " itaTep,

" yjfKapTov eig tov ovpavov Kat evcoitiov aov," apKei fxot ttpog 35
XV. 20. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 119

awTvjpiav TovTa ra pi^fjiaTa' ol^a tov Seov fA.ov t^v ayaBQTriTa,

olta Tov TiaTpos [aov t^v •^fj.epoTyjTaf TrpofT^e^eTai fxeTavoovvTa,

ov ovK eKoXaaev afxapTavovTa.


30 *' Kai ava<7Tag vjXQe irpo^ tov rtaTepa avTOv'"'^ zodev avaaTag ;

eK T^? KaGetpag Trji ^^ov^f, eK tov Trjg afxapTiag iiTWfxaTog' ^

Trpoo^eOvjKe yap t^ KaX^ (Sovky Kai tvjv Trpa^iV ^ei yap yjft.ag ov

fjLQVov jSovXeveaQai Ta (f)i\a 0ew, «AXa Kai Tag ayadag opfxag

eititeiKvveiv Talg Ttpa^eaiV " eTi Se ayTov fnaKpav aiieyovTog^^ Trwg

fjMKpdv ; ot; 7rpoeXa(3ev vj evepyeaia Triv fieTdvoiaV " eioev avTOV

" 6 iraTVjo avTOv, Kai evaTrXay^^viadrj'" TiaTrjp yap e<XTt t^ %/"?~ 10


**
aTOTVjTi, el Ka\ &eog VTtdpyei Tvj <f>vaei, Kat. tpafiMV eireaev

" eTii Tov Tpay^riXov avTOv Kai KaTe(f)iXv]aev avTOV ov yap


avefLeive tov TrpoaKCKpovKOTa TrXvjaiov eXQeiv, aXX avTOg avT^
TtpoaairrjVTvjaeV e$og yap to) (piXavdpconw 0eo5 tovto noieh' to

TiepnrXeKeaBai tvi ff.eTavoovav] ^l^v^iy, Kai daTid^eaSai avTr^g tvjv 15


vTTOTay^v. " €<Ve Se afTw 6 vlog avTOv, ndTep, vjft.apTov etg tov

" ovpavov," (f)o^ovfj.ai tov aTepecofi^aTog tv]v fxop(f)Vjv, wg KaTVj-


yopov (pcov^v, *'
Kai evwntov aov'^^ "^io Kat evXaf^ovfxat t» (f^coTt

Tvjg avjg QeiOTVjTog evaTeviaat, pvnapovg ej^wv Toy^ ent tov awfxa-

Tog Kat T^f ^t»%^5" ocpSaXfiQvg, fi.eTa yap TravTcov fxov twv KaKxv 20

Kai ai lintQ^^pofj.iai KaTr^yopovat fj.ov' to %\, " itoiv]aou fj.e ccg eva
" Toiv fKta6i(i}v aov," tovto eaTtv, OTt fxvjTe TVjg avXvjg aiteXdavjg

fne, "^eaitoTa, tva fi.v] TtdXiv TtoXefitog evpwv /xe itXavwfievov, wg


ai^xjJidXcoTOV dvaydyvj, fnvjTe TiXriaiov eXKvarfg Tv^g fj.vaTtKrjg

Tpane^vjg Kat (f^oPepag, ov ToXfj.w yap o(f)9aXfxo7g evayeatv opav 25

TcSv dyiwv Ta ayta. " €<Ve Oe 6 itaTrjp itpog Tovg QovXovg avToii,"

TOVTeaTt Ttpog Toy^ tepeag, " eveyKaTe Trjv aToXvjv itpwTVjv," tovt-

eaTtv, v]v aTtwXeae tov itaTpog avaywprjaag, tv]v itiaTtv, tv]v yvwatv
TV]g dXr]Beiag, Kai ev^vaaTe avTov tov eavTOV dno^^vaavTa, Kat

SoTC ^aKTvXiov eig tv]v xeTpa avTov, t^v a(f>payi^a Tr]g itiaTewg ^o

T>jv AfaTa Tov ota^oXov, Kat vTto^rjfLaTa elg Tovg itooag avTov,

iva TOVTOvg vTtotr]adfj.evog ev eTotfj.aaia tou ^vayyeXiov Tr]g etpr]-

vr]g KaraitaTr] rovg 0(f)etg Kai TOvg aKopittovg, Tag avTiKetft.evag

'^vvdfj.etg. Kai eveyKare tov fj.oayov tqv atTevTOv tov Tv6evTa vnep

Tr]g oiKovfJievrfg, Tov Toig f/.eTavoovat ft.eTa^iOofxevov, t^v ft.eTdXeifpiv ^^


120 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XV. 24.

**
Twv Oeictiv fiv(TTV]picov, Kai (jiayovreg ev(ppavO!i)iJ.€v, hri ovto^
" viog fxov veKpog •yjv Kai ave^vjaev, aTiokuiXwg vjv, Kai evpe6v]."

24 *' Kai rjp^avro ev(ppaivea6ai'^^


X^P^'' 7'^/' y^^^^^^h ^^ {J^ovov ev

ovpavo7$ eTTi evi afxaprcoXco ixeravoovvri, aXXa ev ry] y^ Travrcov

ev(ppaivoiJ.evuv rwv ^iKaiwv. ra yap ecpe^^^g rvjg iiapa^oXrjg ravrvjg 5

eipt^fxeva, olov eariv 6 viog avrov iipea^vrepog, epwr-fjdag Kat

\ka6wv ryig eopr-tjg r^v vTroQecnv, vjyavaKryjae Kai ovk rj$eXvjaev

eiaeXSeTv, Kai ra rovrwv aKoXovSa, ov y^r^ cog (pQovrjaavrog v)

eyKaXeaavrog ravra yjfxag Xoyi^ea6ai, ^iori TtapafSo)^ ro Xeyo-

[xevov eari, ra te ev 7rapa/3oXaTg Xeyofxeva ov teH Trdvra Kara o 1

Xe^iv Trepiepyd^eaSai, Kadcog (pvjaiv 6 'KpvaoarofJi.Qg eig rvjv epiXYi-

veiav rov Kara M.ar6a7ov, rrjv Trapa^oXrjv epfj.r}vevwv rwv fj.ia6ov-

fxevoov epyarwv, dXXa rov aKoirov fj.a6ovrag ^; wv avvere6rjaav,

rovrov ^penea^ai ft.ovov, Kat fLrj^^ev Tcepatrepco ^rjreh rj ttoXv-

Tcpayft.oveh. Kai yap ovk eariv ov^^etg rwv dyiwv roiavra ^iKaio-i^

Xoyovfhevog, wg (p6ovov Kai /SaaKavtag vndpyovreg Ka6apoi. E<


yap Kat rag y\jvyag avrwv vnep rwv dft.apTcoXwv ^t^oaat, jroXAiu

f/.aXXov opavreg avrovg aco^off.evovg yatpovat Kai otKeHa vofj.i^ovat

ra etg avrovg yivofj.eva aya6d.


Ttvog ovv eveKev ovraig avyeTe6r] r) Trapa^oXrj avrr] ; Kai rt 20

KaraaKevdaat ^ovXerat ; rr^v virep^dXXovaav efj.(paivet (piXav-

GpcoTTtav rov Qeov, ort roaavrr] eart irpog rovg eTitarpe(povrag eig
avrov Kai yvr^aiwg fKeravoovvrag, caare Kat (p6ovov reKeiv erepotg

'hvvafj.evovg' onep Ka) vjfj.elg iroXXdKtg Tiotovfj.ev, evepyerr]aavTeg

Tiva, Xeyovreg avrw, ort 6 ^eivd fj.01


eveKdXeaev, ort ae rotavrr^g 25

rtft.rig rj^twaa, ovTe eyKXrj6evTeg Ttapa rov eKeivov ^ta{3aXeiv e6e-

Xovrog, dXX ev rovrcp de7^at (3ovXofJ.evot ro fxeyeSog rrjg '^copeag

Yjg a7TY]Xavaev, oficog ^e Kat 7rpoaa(paXt^erat ^ia rov vno^^etyft.arog

rov TrpeajSvrepov viov, roiig dfj.eft.TTrcog iToXirevofj.evovg fj.rj^eTTore

Oe^aa6ai Xoyia\j.ov (p6ovov riKrovTa Itt). acorrjpia fj.eravoovvTwv '^o

df/.apTwXwv, VTTO rov f/.iaav6pw7Tov 'htajBoXov vTTO^aXXoft.evov, aXXa


fj.aXXov TTapavra rovrov aTToarpe^pea^at, ev(ppatvofJ.evovg Kat yai-
povrag eiTt ryj awrr]pta avrwv.

'X.pr] ^e Kat tovtq ytvwaKetv, ori toKeT riat ^ta rr^g rwv vlwv

hvvdfiewg rovg re dytovg 'AyyeXovg KaTaar]fj.atvea6ai, Kai r]fi.ag^$


XVI. I. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 121

Tovf ovra? ent t^c 7^f, Kai ro /tx6v toD Trpea/SvTepov Trpoffomov to
T»v ay/ojv A-yyeAcuv Ta.yfj.a ^ijAoyv, to ^e toiJ a<7cyToy fca/ vew-

Te/?oy TO yivo? to avBpxitmV Kai aXkoi Se Ttakiv vo\i.iC^(jvai, %ia


jw,€V Tou TipfcT^vTepov TOv KaTa (japKa \(7p(vfiK ^vjkovaBat, ^ia &e

Tov vecoTfpov Ta eSvrj. **


airoxpvjcffog ^e'," «/^jt/v, o ayiof Kv/?/AAof, 5
** Tar? irep/ ToyTcev ^o^at^ €i[JLt fjih €ya>, ^oKifxa^iTCt) ^e Kai
**
<l>tXo(x.aBri<; to aXvjSeif ovtc «ya^ irep/ twv ayiav AyyeXwv
" irpeTTov e<7Ti Xoyi^ea-9at, OTt ovk eTreyivaaKov tov aaaTov [xeTa-
" voiav Kat Tvjv eiit tovtoi TeXovff.evyjv eopTTjVy aAA ag ayvoovvTe^
**
yip'j}T(i}v' ovre naXiv •yjpri avvaive7v ^fii.ag ag ev l3e(3iiOKOTa$ twv 10
c? laparjXf onov ye tovtov; oia iiaayji, (og eTrof emeiv, Tvjg
** 5eo7rveyc7Tou ypacp^g, ^ia^ePXyjfxevovg eartv l^eTv wg aTtoaTaTag
/fa; aireideig.

KE*. NH.
tlfpi Toi; olKovofjiov TTJs dSiKias. 15

I Aeye/ ^e /fa/ Trep} r«v Tra^a/SoAwv ay^oc Ky/J/AAos", oWe^ />fa/

XpvaGaTOft.og <f)y]atv, oti itXayiwg Kai aavfj.(f)av<ag .yjfniv avrai


Tipayfj.aTcav ov:^at(popav ^-^Xcoaiv eiaKOfJ.i^ovaiv, orav avTOV ev

^payeH Kai avveaTaXfxevtag tov vovv KaTaG-^aci)ft.ev' ov yap aiiavTa


<f>i^ai, Ty]g Tiapa^oXrjg to. fJ.epyj noXvTtpayfj.ovetaBai yj)Yi' XenTcog ^e 20

Kat e^yjTaafi.evag, iva ft.yjTe "npog toc Trepa fj.eTpov ^a^i^cov Xoyog
KaTaXvnyjay] tw TieptTTw Tovg (f)tXaKpoafj.ovag, fJ.^^Te fxev aSoAe-
o"X/a? oj^Aov epyaayiTai Ttatv, olov Kai ea) r^g iiapa^oXyjg eart

ryjg Xeyovayjg, " AvQpcoTiog rig y]v TiXovatog bf eiyev otKovofi.ov*


Kat ra e|^^' ei yap fi.y] ^ovXoito Ttg tiarpavovv, rig ff.ev av ely] 25
avdpcoTiog 6 rov ^ia(3e^Xy]fi.evov eycov otKOvofjiov, yj Kat rig av ely]

Tvycov ^ia^ejSXi^Kcbg avrov, rtveg Se Ka) 01 roTg o(f>Xi^fxaatv

evoyxii Kai rag rav 0(f)Xy]ft.aiTCOv tioiovvTeg aTioKOiiag, Kat &/a Tioiav

aiTiav fj.ev eXaiov, Se o-nrov eiiocf^X^^aat Xeyovrai, aKOTetvov

aft,a Kat nepiTTOV anoTeXeaet tov Xoyov. ovkovv ov •ndvTy] re Kat 30


TiavTcog atiavra r-qg tiapa^oXy^g ra fJ.epy] ry\ rtov ^y]Xovfi.evcov eia)

Becopta y£y]aifiM, eig eiKOva ^e Xy](f>6eiev av dvayKaiov TipdyfJMTog

afxvOpwg VTiefj.(f>aivovaa to reXovv eig ov^aiv rolg dKpocofxevotg.

EcTT/ TOtvvv TVjg TipoKetfji.evy^g Tiapa^oX^g roiovTog 6 vovf' /Sot/-

R
122 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XVI. lo.

Aera^ 7]f/iag 6 twv oXcov ^ea^iroTy]^ Seog oXoTpoircog Toig eig apeTYjV

avaKiHaOai (77rov^da[xao-iVf aiiahXaLTTOVTaq kavTovq toov tov irapov-

Tog l3iov Tre piaa-Traa-ixwVf iv evTrape^pag Kat aTcepiairacrTwg vTrrjpt-

Tw/Aev avT^f KaOwg '^ia tov Aa^i ^ (pvjai, " ay^oXdaaTe Kai yvare

OTi eycti eifxi o Kyeog Kai TiaXiv Oi eavTov, ^xAyjaaTe ra vnap-^


" j^ovra Kai ^ot€ eXeyjixoavvvjv" Kai ij /Aev evToA>/ auT^^piog, da6ev7]g

^e Xiav 6 dvQpwTiov vovg, Kot dei iriog TrpoaTreTryjye To7g yeco^eaTe-

poig' o6ev ^vjXa^^vj irpocpaaiv acoTVjpiag 'rjfxiv vTredei^ev o yipiaTOg

^ia T^g TrpoKeiixevyjg irapa/SoXijg, fkovovy^i Xeycov, ornrep ei fiyj

^ovXoiVTO Trjv Twv '^(^pvjfxdTcov Trepiovaiav KaraXnreh Kat Toyvio

vx}^vjXy]v TroXiTeiav da7rdaaa6ai, 7rXy]v Ka^d ye tov vTro^ejBy^KOTa

TpoTTov, Kav oiKovofxoi yeveadcoaav^ t<3v irTcoyevovTCtiv av[X[MeptaTag

Tuv virapyovTCCv TovTovg Trotovfxevoi, oirctig <piXovg KTyjaafxevot TroX-

Xovg, Kat fxdpTvpag t^? evairXayyyiag Tovg ev 7re7rov6oTag eyovTeg,

OTav avTovg y] eirtyetog eKXenroi ^w^, TV/aat tottov Tivog ev Ta7g 15

eKe76ev aKy]va7g' ei ^e fj)r] (BovXoivro to f^yj^e tovto ^ta7rpd^aa6ai,

dXXa Ta 7rapd tov ^ea^roTov ^o6evTa avTcc, fLovatg Taig eavTcHv

^a7ravcoai Tpo(f)aig, y] Kat 7rpoa-Katpovg movvTai Tifxag, afkvyjfxo-

vovvTeg tov XeyovTog Qeov, " dvotycnv avot^etg Ta aTrXayyya tc5

" d^eX<pa aov," Kat oaa dXXa yj 6eia ^t^^daKei ypacpy] rrepi Ty]g etg 20

Toiig teofxevovg avfj,7ra6eiag, dTroTreaovvTat TrdvTCog T^g oiKovofxiag,


eTrtTr^^^SovTog avToTg tov ^avdrov, Kai twv t^$" Treptovatag avTccv

7rpayft.dTCi}v e^eXKOVTog, koli ^/a t>jv d7rdv6pcti7rov avTctiv 7rpoaipeaiv,

dvTi Tctiv aictivictiv aKy]vm tco aicavtcti Kat aawfxdTc^ Trvpt Trapa-

oo6Y]aovTat. 25
jo T/V ea-Tiv " 7rtaTog ev eXayiaTCti,"6 KaXcag ei^cbg jStovv Kai t>jv

elg TO fLeXXov eX^rt^a ^e^t^pt^Kccg, Kai d^rocpepoov ft.ev twv e^riyetcav

Tov vovv, (ppovctiv ^e fkdXXov to. dvco, Kai ^id tovto tov eTrtyeiov
7rXovTOV eig Tovg ev^eeTg KaXag taTravcav. eXdytaTov Se tov eirtyeiov

TrXovTOv e^dXeaev, ov ^y] Kat d^tKOV f/.aft.fKCtivdv cpvjatv. 6 ToiovTog ^o


ovv ev Tco eAaj^/<7Ta) TrtaTog evpiaKOfhevog, Kat ev TroXXca TrtaTog

ea-Tt, TovTeaTiv ev Tolg 7rv(VfJLaTiKoig Kat 6eioig yapiafj.aaiv 6 Se

ev TCti 7rXovTCti Tovrcti dtiKog yevofievog, etg eavrov fx.ovov avvryjpav

avTOV tyjXovoTt, Ka\ ev Tolg 6etoig yapiafKaatv d^tKog evpe^-^aeTat.


a Sic.
XVI. 19. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 123

^AWorpiov §€ T*;v Twv yjfyjfJLdTccv Treptov^Ttav avofxaa^evy eiretorj

ov yeytVYjfj.eQa fieTa vkovTOv, yvfxvot ^e fxakXoVf Kat ag aXi^6cof

€<m yeypafji.fji.evov, " OTt ov^ev elaeveyKafLev etg tov Koafxov, ov^he

**
e^eveyKeh Tt ^vvafKeQa'^^ aXKoTpiov toivvv avBpwitov TiavTog cf)vat-

Kwg TO irXovTeh' e^x6ev yap eva Kat tov avTOv ft.ept^€a6at Tvpos 5

Toi evavTia, Ka) aKaTa^peKTOog ^vvaadat l3tovv, '^etKVvatv 6 oea^iro-


**
Trji ^ptaTog XeywVf ov^etg ^vvaTat ^vat Kvptotg ^ovXevetv" Kat
Ta e^vig.

14 'Enet^v} Se r^ voaca Ti^g <f)tXapyvpiag avvey(pfJ.evot e^fjfLVKTyjpt^ov

avTOv 01 ^apiaaht KaiTiep '^ia ft.aKpSov Xoym TOVTOvg 6epaTievaai 1 o

/3ovXy}6evTogf rpeireTat Xofnov eirt ro ^ptfKv twv eXeyyjaVf Katpov

KaXovvTog elg rovro, koi a7ro(f)aivet "^o^yjg avrovg ovrag epaarag


Tijg Toig ttKaiotg re Ka) aya6o7g Trpe^novavjg av^tpaatv, avTovg oe
ov fJL-rjv ovrag rovro Kara aX^6etav' (prjat yap, " vfj.elg eare ot

" tiKatovvreg eavrovg evdoTriov rav av6paTrm' 6 te Seog ytvaaKet 15


** Tag Kap^iag vfjJSiv, ort ro ev av6pco7rotg vxj/i^Xov /3^eXvyft.a evcoTrtov

" Tov Qeov'" rovro Kat eTepnBev irov irpog avTovg evpiaKerai Xeyav,
" Ttoog ^vvaaBe Trtareveiv^ ^o^av itapa av6p6iTrcov Xaft.(3dvovTeg, rvjv ^e
" ^o^av Tvjv Ttapa rov fxovov ov ^vjre^Te ;" rovg ft.ev yap dXi^^lag ovrag

dya6ovg ro7g eig ^tKatoavvvjv eiiatvoig rwv oXxv arecpavoT Qeog, 20


01 ye ft,v]v dcptXdperot Koci viioKptrat rdya raig eavrav \p-^(f)otg ro

^OKeTv eivat aeTrrol itapa^XeTiovatv, aXX' ovheig, w (^eXrtarot,


**
(f)aivj rtg av avroig eavrov are(pavo7. Teypaitrat yap, eyKco-

fj.ta^erci) ae 6 TteXagy Kai fi.v] ro aov arofua, dXXorptog Kat f>.v} ra


" ad yetXf}. ydp Seog ytvcoaKet rdg Kaphiag vfj.mt Kat rtft.a fj.ev 25
** ^iKaiov rov aXvj6tvov' aKopTtt^et Se ra tS>v dvBpcaitapeaKcov oardy
av6p'j}TiapeaKta yap pi^a Kat dpyvj Kat yeveaig rvjg fj.efj.iav]fi.evv]g

itapa Tw Sew Kat dv^pcottotg vtrepoxptag. itept m eiitev 6 Kvpiog


" vofxog Kat 01 itpo(^ratf^ ecog " fj.of/evei^^ 7tpoeypd(f)v} eig ro

KaTa Mar^aiov. 3°

KE$. NH.
Hfpi Tov TrXouflriov Koi tov Aa^dpov.

19 Ttjv TtpoKetfj.evviv 7tapaj3oXv]v rv]v tou itXovatov Kat rov \a)^apov

dpiara ttaiJ.op(poi Kat ^taTtXdrret yiptarog 6 Qeog v]fiMV, cuare

R 2
124 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XVI. 19.

To7i' elg ayaGovpytav av^/rjixa^xiv eTieiyeaQai ^tairpeTreiv yjfxag'

BeXei yap fivai <f)i\a\X-^Kovg Kai koivuvikovs Kai evfxeTO^OTOvg

Kou (ptXoTTTwy^tai e7ri[j.eXy]Taii Ka) tZv elg tovto crTrov^aTixaTav

eyedQai veavtKag. E/ttwv ^e OTt " avGpairog Ttg vjv -TrXovatog" ag


a(j)tXotKTtpfx,ova tovtov avci}vvfji.cog eavjfj.avei KaQag ^ta tov Trpocpi^TOV 5

Trept Twv [x)^ <pol3ovixev(i}v avTOV (pYjaiv Qeog, " oti ov ixvj [xvvjadco

" Ttt)v ovofJLaTCOv avTav ^ta yetXeav fxovy^ fxvy]fi.ovevet Se tov irevyjTog

ovofxaaTt, eTtett-^irep ev yXaaay] ©eou o< TOtovTot eiatv. eyet te

KOLt koyov u)g yj tSov 'E/Spatav irapa^oatg (pyjai^ Ad^apov eivai

Ttva KaT eKeho tov Kaipov ev lepoaoXvff.Qig, eayaTtiv iiotovvTa 10

TiTCiy/eiav Kat dppcoaTiav, ov fJLvyifi.ovevaat tov Kvptov, cag etg napa-


^oX^v XafSovTa avTOV eig efncpaveaTepav tov Xeyofxevov tvvafj.tv.

'M.iq^etg ^e vofui^eTCt) twv TovTa dKovovrcov, OTt yeyove Ttatv


dvTairotoatg yj Trowjpav epycov yj ayaBciov' eaTt yap 7rapa(3oXyj to

etpyjfj.evov aaTetcog itapa "KptaTOv tov Qeov y}fj.cov eayy}fj.aTtafJ.evyi, 15

tv e't^otev 01 Tov eK yy)g eyovTeg itXovtov, cog et


fj.yj
l3ovXy]6eiev

etvat ypi^aTot Kai evft.eTd^0T0t Kai KoivcoviKot, Kat TaTg tcov Trevyj-

Tcov dvdyKatg entKOvpeiv eXotVTO, ^etvyj Kat d(f)vXdKTcp Treptneaovv-

Tat "^iKf]. I^ctJjaev toivvv tov TiXovatov tyjv ctt ov^^evi twv avay-

Kaicov yjpfji.evy]v otppvv. " Kveh^vaKeTo,^^ (^'^'^h


*'
iropcpvpav Kai /Sva- 20
" crov," TovTeaTtv evetfiaTeiv" eanov^a^e, Kai y]v ev eaS^Ti ttoXv-

TeXeardT'^ Kai dKaTaXeinTotg TpvcpaTg. Touto yap efj.(patvet to

ev(ppaiveaSat Ka^ ^fLepav. TrpoaKetTat ^e " XafJ.7Tpcog," TOVTeaTiv,

dacoTCog.

'O ^e Ad^apog voacc Kat Trevia ire7re^y]ft.evog e^e^Xy]To, (py]ai, 25


Trpoi, Tov TTvXwva avTOv dTy]f/.eXcog epptfj.fj.evog., oiihevog d^tovfxevog

Xoyov, (pet^ovg Kat (ppovTi^og dfj.oipog cov* ^y^TcHv Trpog Kopov TVjg

Tov irXovatov Tpa7re^y]g Ta irapoXtaOatvovTd T€ Kai dy^y]aTOTepoC

eKoXaC,eTO %\ Kat CTepcog voaca yaXeirciiTdTy], dXXa Kat 01 Kvveg,

(pvjatv, eXetyov to. eXKy] avTov, ovk d^tKovvTeg dXX olov avvaX- 30
yovvTeg Kat BepaTrevovTeg t^ yXcoTT"/], Kai to Xvttovv d^ro^eovTeg,

Kat (piXo(ppovcog 7reptaXei(povTeg, 07rc»g Kat ev tovtc£ '^etyBi]

TrXovatog Kai 6y]pS>v diry^veaTepog, a>g aavvaXyy]g Kat d(ptXQtKTipfj.cov

Kat fj.eaTOg 7rday]g aTravSpcoTrtag. vTrdpywv he 6 Trevyfg ev TotovTOtg

^ «u/xaTcrv Cod.
XVI. 25- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 125

^eivoTg^ ovre aTre^vcxayTryjaev, ovre e^Xa<T(f>^[xv](7eVf ovre yfyavaKTfi-

aev, otnre Kareyoyyvae rov ttXovcj-iov. itoOev ^e rovro ^^Aov ; e^ wv

aiiyfffayov avrov o/ AyyeXoi topvc^opovvreg^ Ka\ etg rov koXttov

rov \/3f/aaiJ. aTreKarearvjaav.

32 ** Aire6ave ^e Kai o irXovcyiog Kai era.(f>yj'^^ {jivj aTrXag iiapa- 5

^pa[Ji'j}fxev ro eipyi[J.evov ori fj.era ro aiioQave^v rov TrXovaiov Trpo^T-

Keirai ro " erd^py}." eneiViri yap Kai ^m, Ka^direp ev iJ.vy}fxari Karop-
pvyfievyj vnyjp-^ev avrov yj ^v/ji^, ra(f)ov 7rept(f)epov<7a ryjv adpKa'
Oia rovro 7rpo(Tere6y] ro " erd(f>yj" aTiaXXayetg Se rov a<i)f/.arog

aveiaiv eK rpv(f)yjg eig rov a^yjv' iva ^e fxei^ovtcg Kararpvy^rai^ 10


hpa, (f)yi<7tv, rov Ad^apov ev KoXiroig ovra rov A^paafj., axnrep yap
rov A^afj. eKJSaXoiv rov iiapo^eicrov Kar avrtKpv rovrov KaraiKiaev

avrov Seog, iva yj avve-^^g oxpig dvaveoixxa ro Tid6og aKpt^eare-

pav avrw Tiapd^jyyi ryjg eKTrroxrecog tcSv aya6m ryjv ai<76yiaiVy

ovrw ^yj Kai rovrov Karevavrt rov Aa^dpov KaraKyjcre. 15


Tivog te eveKe ov^i nap erepw ^iKatoog rov Ad^apov, aXX' ev roTg

KoXnctg rov ^APpaafj. eidev ; eTiet^^y] (f>iXo^evog yjv A^padfx. \v

ovv eXey/og avrov yevyjrai ryjg fxtao^evtag, '^ta rovro avrov fxer

eKetvov l3X.eiret. eKeivog Kat rovg irapiovrag eByjpeve Kat eig t^v

otKtav eiXKev eiaco rvjv eavrov' ovrog Kai rov eao) Ketfxevov 20
vape^apa.

34 Aia t/ te ov iipog rov Ad^apov rov Xoyov ditereivev, aAXa


Tipog rov AfSpadf/. (pyjaif *'
Tidrep A(3paaf/., eXeyjaov /xe," Kai ra
e^^j- ; EiTiet^y) yiayyv6ri Kai vjpv6piaaev eK rav Kar avrov Tipay-

fJMTav, Kat evofxtaev avrov fn.vyjaiKaK-^aetv Tidvrag. E/ yap eyca, 25

<f)y]atf roaavryjg dnoXavoov eviioptag, Kat ov^ev yjOiKy]ft.evog, vitep-

er^ov ev roaovrotg ovra rov dv^p^aiiov KaKo7g, Kai ov^e xpf^^^tcov

fxere%(OKa, iioXXco fxaXXov avrog ovrcog v7iepo(f)6etg ovk eiiivevaei

rvi ydptri ravrf]. Tavra Xeyofxev^ ovyi rov Aa^apov Kaivpfo-


povvreg, ov yap S^ ovrccg '^teKetro eKe7vog, dXX ori obrog ravraso
he^oiKoog ovK eKoXeaev eKt7vov, dXXa rov A^padfx e(f)Q)vy]aev' evo-

fxt^^e ydp avrov dyvoe7v Ta yeyevy]fxeva.

25 T/ ovv eKe7vog ;
**
reKvov fLv^adyjri ori drreXafSeg ra aya6d aov
*' ovk ftnevj
ev r-^ ^ayj aov." YiKo-n^awfxev (f)iXoao(f>tav ^iKaiov'

d'jidv6p<t}'jie Ka) wfxe Kat 7iafXTiovY]pe, roaavra KaKa ^ia6eig tov35


126 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XVI. 26.

avBpco^nov, (piXavdpairia^ [xefJLVVjaai vvv Kai ekeov^ Kat avfX7ra6etas

Kai avyyvccfxyjg' ovk atayyvrj ovfk epvSpta^, ov^e eyKaXvTTTVj; aWa


ri ;
" reKVOv" (f^vjatv, " aiteka^e? ra ayaOa aov ev rrj ^®'^ aov'^^

i^v^^riv yap reraTreivoofji.evYjV ff.r] TrpoaTapd^yj^, (f>yjat' dpKet ra


rvji rifji.wpiag avrx, ft.fi TrpoaeTrefxf^atvcofjiev avrov rai$ avfJL^popai^f 5

reKvov, ov Kvptog elfLi, fi.eratttwfxi aot, ro d evrevGev dneXBeh


eKeli, ovK eartv vjfJi.erepov Xotitov. Ata rt ovk eiire, eXa^eg ra
dyaQd aov, aXX " dneXa(3eg ;" ocpetXifjv ydp riva ev^hetKvvfj.evov

Kat tYiXovvroi eariv' dnoXaff.lSdvet ydp rtg rd o<peiXofi.eva.

T/ oiiv evrevOev fj.avBdvoft.ev ; ort Kav ft.tapoi riveg wat, Kav etg 10

ea-^^arov KaKtag eXvjXaKoreg, TtoXXdKtg ev rt Kat tvo Kat rpia

etpydaavTO ayaOd' KatTcep ovv Kai ovrog TrXovaiog, oBev ^td rvjg

ev/ifj.epiag rvjg ev rw^e rw (Btw dTroXa/Sav avrd, ^KOvaev ori


" aneXa^eg ra ayaSd aov ev rvj ^ayj aov, Kat Aa^apog OfJ.oi(ag

ra KaKa. laceg yap Kai ovrog ev v) Kai ovo vj Kat rpia vjft.ap- 15

rvjKag, evrevBev ^td rvjg o^^vvvjg vjg vTrefj.etvev, direXa^e ravra.


Aio (pvjaiv, ** o^e TrapaKaXeTrai, av Ve o^vvdaaf" v) ydp Kptatg
avvjXeog roo ft.v] TrotvjaavTt, eXeye.

2,6 Ti ^e avjfxatvet OTrep eliiev 'A/^paa/x., **


ori yrdafka fj.eya earvf-

" piKrai, '


Kai ra e^vjg ; rojv rav ^iKatoov ^ta(f)opdv iTpog rovg 20
Ttratovrag' waTrep yap evavriai ai TipoBeaetg, ovrctig dft.tyv]g vj

fj^erdaaatg, rwv ft.ev rvjv dveatv, rcov ^e rvjv KoXaatv '^e-yofj.evav.

dirorvy^v ^e toJv KaB eavrov, vTrep erepm Xotirov irotenai rviv

iKervjptav. Opa irag (ptXavBpamog Kat vjfi.€pog yeyovev viro rvjg

KoXaaecog' yap rov Aa^apov Karacfypovav irapovrog, erepoov a-nov- 25

rav (ppovTi^et, Kai napaKaXei 7refj.(f>B^vai rov Ad^apov eig rov

oiKov rov Trarpog, Kat ov^e aTrXwg irapeKdXeaev dvaar^vai riva

Ik rm veKpav, dXXd rov Ad^apov, oirag, (f)Vja]v, i^ovreg avrov


arecpavaBevra, ov e^Xeirov ft.vptoig KaKoXg dyavti^oft.evov, 01 yevoft.evot

ft.dprvpeg r^g Treviag avrov rov Xtfj.ov Kai rav o^yvaJv, avrot Kaiso

rvjg fj.eTa(3oXvig Kat r^g 'ho^vig avrov yevofnevoi fidprvpeg, eKare-


pxBev re irat^evBevreg, Kat fj.aBovreg ori ov f-^XP^ "^^^ irapovrog

^tov ra vjfj.eTepa ar-^aerat Trpdyft.ara, K'dv ovrci) TrapaaKevaacov-

rai wg ^yv>j5^va< ravrvjv ^tacpvyeiv rvjv KoXaaiv.


29 T/ ovv \^padfj. ;
" eyovat Moxrea Kai rovg irpo^yiTag, aKov- 35
XVII. 5- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 127

" a-draxjav avTwv." Oi/j^ ovtq} ya^pt <I>V'^'» <^^ Kvj^yj twv a^eA0a5v,
o5f 6 TTOf^aas avTovg 0eof* [xvpiovg •yap avTotg €7i€aTr,<7e ^i^a-

aKoiXov^.

Tivo^ ^e €V€K€V avTanoKpiQeii 6 TrXovcrios e<f>'rj,


" ovy^i, iraTep
" A^paajx, aXX edv ti^ eK veKpiiov iiopevS^ Ttpog aitTOvg, jueTavo^-5
** aovo"/v;" hieiVrj avTog ovTog tSov Seioov ypacptov aKovm KaTe<ppovei,

Kai [xvSovg evofii^ev etvai ra Xeyofxeva, e^ wv avTog vTtevoei, Kai

Trep) Tav d^eXcpxv ovToog vnoTtTevovatv (txjnep Kayw, oti " Ttg vjX6ev

" eKei6ev ;" Ttg eK veKpav dveaTVj ; Tig eiTre to. ev tw a^Ty ; '^ia

TOVTQ edv Tig aito twv veKp^v diieX^vi, ovk dTiKJTyjaovatv avTW, lo
aAAa [MaXXov To7g Xeyofxevoig irpoo-e^ova-iv. " e/7re Se," (pi^at, " "^pog
" anTov, et M.(oae(i}g Kat toov Trpocf^vjTav ovk dKovovatv, ovSe edv Tig
*'
eK veKpwv dvaaTri, 7teta6-fiaovTat.^^ OTt ^e tovto ovTnog eaTiv

dXrj6eg, Kai o txv ypa^pSov ovk dKovxv, ov^e veKpm avtaTafj.eva}v

dKovaerai, e^et^av oi ^iov^^aloi. ot eTret^rj Mooaecog ovk yjKovaavi^

Kai twv irpo<pr]Tiov, ov^e veKpovi i^ovTeg dvaardvTag eTrtarevaav,

dXXa vvv fi.ev dveXe7v tov Ad^apov eire^/etpovv, vvv ^e Tor$- 'Atto-

aToXoig eiieTf^ttav, KatTOi tioXXwv dvaardvTcov ev to? Katpoo tov

aravpov»
ILoX-novg ^e tov APpaaft, Koi tov ^JaaaK, Koi tov 'laKw/S ao
TOfrof^ eivai 6 aytog Atowatog o ApewTiaytTrig Tag ^etoTaTag

Kat fJiaKapicoTdTag X-^^etg, Tag vTro^^e^xofnevag iidvTag Tovg ^tKaiovg,

etg TTjV ev avTa7g ay^pa Kat fnaKaptcoTaTVjv reXetaaiv.

I Ylept Twv aKav^dX(ov XaXoov €(og " d^pyjaeig ayToo," TTpoeypd^py]

etg TO KOTa MaT^arov. 25


5 Ylept Txv dpyatoTepoov dytccv (pvjatv 6 AnoaToXog, OTt ev tvj

Titaret efJiapTvp-^dvjaav 01 Tipea^vTepoi, tovtwv ovv ^vjXooTai yeve-

a6at ^ovX6fj.evoi ot aytoi AitoaToXoi, "iip6a6eg vjfu7v TiiaTtv" eXeyov

tw oecriroT-yj \piaT(0, ovk aiTovat ^e ntaTtv dnXag, tva fiv]

diitaTOvg avTovg vofxtavj Ttg, dXXa Tipoa^vjKVjv ntaTecog, TovreaTt 30


TV)V etg TovTQ /3el3ai(oaiv. napaaKevdaai te avTovg ^ovXofxevog
teKTiKovg yevea6at Tvjg TotavTV]g ydptTog, <f)V]atv, " el ej^eTC niartv
*'
cog KOKKov atvdnecog, eXeyere av tjj avKafxtvca ravTV], eKpi^io6v]Ti'*

Kat ra e^vjg. Et yap to Tienvjyog ovrco Ka) Kara yvjg eppi^co-

fxevov fxeraKtvfjaetev av v] r^g iitaTexg "^vvafxtg, Ka6oXov (paivj rig^S


128 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XVII. ii.

av, [xyjhev ovTcag aKivyjTOV eivai o [xv] aaXivaeiev rj itkttis' ii<e.m

fxevToi "TrpoaeKTeov aacjyaXSoi, cooTe jU.17 Tiva \oyov Xoyii^eadai Kara

Kfv^v eKTiXyi^iv elneiv tovtq tw ^taTroTi^ Xp;crToi), Trpog wcpeXeiav

Se fxaWov Kai actiTyjpiav rjfJLWVy Kai yap iravTa layvei yj ryjg Oeiag

^vvd[xea)g e^ovaia. Tlepi yap kokkov aivdiredig Tipoeypd(f)Vj eig S

TO KaTO, Tov lS/[aT6a7ov.

7 FiTrei^^Yj 7re(f)VKe Trag dei 6 avBpwrtivog vovg KaTacpepeaQai eig

<f)i\o^o^iav, d<f>op[J.Yj ^e tov 7rd6ovg yiverai TiroXXdKig, to eiii riai

tS)v dpiaTCtiv dv'hpaya6Yj[i.drm evooKi[j.yjaai itapa 0eaj, TiayydXettov

^e TOVTO Kai ©eco KareaTvy^[J.evov, KaTa(f)epei eig tovto yvcc^JiVjgio

dpyeKaKog ^pdKoov, (og oieaBat Taya itov Kai 0(f)eXeiv tov Seov
Tag dvccTdTCo Ti[mg, orav evKkea Kai ev^oKifxov eycoai tyjv ^cavjv.

A<a TovTO Twv 7tpoKei[xev'jiV dvayvcaafKdTCov tyjV owafKiv 6 ^eaTtoTYjg

Ttoienat "KpiaTOg, Xeycov, " rig e^ v[xwv ^ovXov eycov dporpiavra


" Y] Ttoi^iaivovTa," Kai to, e^Yjg. Ai^daKet yap htd tovtcov ort 1
5

T^f ^eaTioTtK^g e^ovaiag yj ^vvafLig, cog o<^A^/xa Ttavrayov itapd.

Tcov oiKercov ^yjt€7 tyjv vTtoTayvjv. ov yap ydptv, e(f>Yj, ofnoXoyyjaet

Tco oiKerYj, Kav ei yevoiro Ttap avrov itav oitep e^et yeveaBat Kard
ye TO TYjg tovXetag itpeitov, aXXa [/.yj TtXi^povvTog [xev to 0(f)€tXd-

[jievov Kiv^vvog eTterat, TtXvjpovvTog ^e ydptg ovh\ [Kia, Kav et 20


^eaitOTYig \piaTOg vitapyjav ayadog Kat (f>tXoTt[j.og Kai (f>tXdv-

QpcoTtog ov [xovov iao^vva[i.a yepa roig Kd[K.vovatv eitayyeXXerat,


aXXa Kat itoXXco itXeov rovg irovovg VTtepfSatvovra, KaOcog (f>Yjatv

Ttavao^f^ogTlavXog, " ort ovk a^ta ra TtaS-^^iara tov vvv Katpov,


" Ttpog TV]v [xeXXovaav "to^av ditoKaXv^f^Byjvat eig yj[i.ag.'^ 25

KE4>. NO.

Hepl Ta>v i XfTTpmv.

i j Tvjv eavrov ^o^av ^ta Tyjg [xeyaXoitpeTtovg Oavfiarovpytag e^-


(pavvj KaQiarvjaiv '^coTYjp. epyerat aayvivevcov elg itiartv tov

dKdpotov lapavjX, aXX vjv Kat ovrco aKXvjpog re Kat ditetBrjg, ^v^o
^e 7] ditohet^tg aa(f>Y]g, av e(f)Y}v dpricog, yj twv XeTtpwv ttaKdBapatg'
ovrot yap TtoXecov t€ Kai kco[i.wv aTteXavvofnevot cog aKdQaproi
Kara rov ^coiJaecog vofnov, VTtavrviaavreg ra Hcor^pi, eXtitdpovv
XVII. 22. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 129

avaWaTTedOai toi) KaKov, Kai eTr^oraT^jv wvo/^a^cv, tovt((7ti

oiQaaKaXov. o §e <f)iXdv6pa)Tios <ov, e^vj, " virdyeTej ^ei^aT€ cavTovf

To/^- lepcvai.

Aia t/ ju*; [xakXov %<l>ri) 5e'Aa>, KaBapiiByjTi, KaBa Kai e(f>

(Tepov Xeirpov, TrpoaTeTaye ^e [xaXXQV, eavTov^ eiri^ei^aTe toT^ 5

iepev(7i ; vojtxof eKdXei Ttpog tovto irdkiv Tovg T^f Xeirpag aTiyjX-

Xayfxevovg. ^EKeXeve yap wg ^&>j TeSepaTrevfxevovi Pa^i^eiVf Kai

Toiig Twv 'lou^a/cwv KaB-ifyyjTag, '^r]XovoTi tov$ lepeTg, ^iafxapTv-

pacrSai, oti itap eXTri^a Kai Tiapa^o^cog aiiyjXXdyyjaav toi) KaKOv,

Tov \picrTQv TOvTo KaTavevaavTog. Kai o^ ev too avTovg vndyeiv lo


Ka^apoi yivovTai, Kai oi [xev evvea aTe iov^aioi ovTeg, eig dya-
pia-TOV XvjByjv efxTreaovTeg, ovy^ vTreaTpeipav tovvai '^o^av tx OeoJ,

o$ev aKXripoKdphiov Koi dfxvi^fxova iravTeXccg ^eiKvvei tov iapayiA,

he dxXoyevyjg, TOVTeaTiv o YjafxapeiTyigy ^ia to ef Aaavpiav


Kaidyeiv to yevog dXXoyevy}g' ov yap [xdTy}v Xeyet, ev [xeaa TVjg 15
**
"Zafxapeiag Kat TaXtXaiag Kat lov^aiag, vireaTpexl/e [xeTa (pxvyjg

" [xeydXrig ^o|a^i»v tov Seov." AeiKvvei ovv oti 01 'Ea[xapetTai

evyvai[xoveg, lov^^atoi ^e evepyeTov[xevoi ayaptaTOvaiv.

20 ETrei^^ y)t.p twv oyXuiv YuiTrjp ev T&rs" irpog airavTag Xoyoig

^ie[xe[xvyiTO navTayov T^g j3aaiXeiag tov Qeov, ^ia tovto KaTa- 20


[xei^ittivTeg 0/ TaA,av€$, 07 Ta^^a Ttov elg vovv e^ovTej OTi tov eiti

^vXov ddvarov vno^xevel TaHg avTav ^vaTpovtiatg aeaayyjvevoft.evog^


eig TOVTo KareipoovevovTeg, Kai (paat, " ttotc epyeTai rj PaatXeia
" Tou Qeov," avTi tqv, itpo Ty^g itapa aov XaXov^xevyjg ^aatXetag,

aTavpog ae Kai SdvaTog X-^xpeTai. Ti ow ttpog TovTa HpiaTog; 2^


*•'
yj ^aaiXeia tqv Seov evTog v[xm eaTi^^ TovTeaTiv ev Ta7g vfi.e-

Tepatg Ttpoatpeaeai, Kai ev e^ovaia Kenai tov Xa/Seiv avTyjv.

E^ecTT/ yap dvQpaitoi TtavTt t*jv elg HptaTQv ^tKaiooatv, t>jv Oia

TVjg TttaTetag Oe StjAovot/ /icaTaTrAovT^aavT/, Kat ^ia Trdavjg dpeTyjg

eKXeXaft.Ttpvaft.evx, Trjg txv ovpavxv jSaaiXeiag eTttTV)(eiv. 30


22 'KTOtfi.ovg Se eivat ^QvXofxevog Tovg dytovg avTOv fxaQi^Tag
Ttpog Ttav OTtovv twv avidv Ttecj^vKOTWV, Kat TtpoevTpeiti^eaBat ttpog

vTtofxovyjv, iva eutoKtfLoi yevofxevot ^vv^^Sxatv etaeXQeiv etg tijv toD

0eou PaaiXetav, (fytjat itpog avTOvg' " eXevaovTat y^txepat OTe


" eTttBvfxyjaeTe fnav txv yjfxepxv tov vtov tov avQpcoTtov ihe7v, Kat 35
130 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XVII. 33.

**
ovK OipeaOe" TovreaTiv iiii yYig (jvv^iayayYjg avrov, Kanoi Kai
T0T€ avv avToi ovref, 6Xi\liiv v7ro[J.evovTe$, aXXa Trpoi avTmapd-
6eatv Twv v7repKei,[J.evm KaKav alpeTa Tro)? riaav to. eXaTTOva.
Me/^ovwv yap fxeTa tvjv ovtov dvdXv)xpiv 6Xi4iecov eTreipddi^aav.

Yiepi TYjg ^evTepag avTov Tiapovaiag, Kai oti " w^ daTpaTrri 5

ovTwg eaTai, cwf /x^ €7riaTpexpaTco eig ra oiriaa^ Trpoeypacpv]

eig TQ KOTa Mar^a/bv.


Ktpiaaot AaehanapeiA2. Aia[/.e fx-^vvKe Xeym, wg daTpa-
irvjv eaea6ai ttjv eavTOv irapovaiav. eyevyjdv) fjiev Kara aapKa Kai
eK yvvaiKOs, rrjv e(f vjfJi.iv TrXyjpdoaav oiKovofuiav' KeKevooTai ^ia 10

TOVTO Kai TeTaireivooKev eavTOV, Kai ovk ev ^o^yj OeOTVjTog efJ.(f)av(iog'

eKdXei yap Kaipog eig tovto, Kai r^g oiKovofJ.iag yj 'Xjpeia' ft.eTa

te Trjv CK veKpSov dvdaTaaiv dvaTrTag elg ovpavov, Kai avvetpevaag


tS) Qew Kai Ylarpt, KaTajSrjaeTat irdXtv, cvk ev vcpeaet So|i7f,

ofTe fj.Yiv ev av6pco7rivYj afj.iKpoirpe7reia, dXX ev tyJ toi) ITaTpoc 15


vTrepoy^'^, 7rXvj6vog AyyeXcov dopvcpopovavjg avTOv, Kai TraptaTafxevYjg
cog Qeco Kat K.vptai tSov oXcov. H|ei Totvvv cog aaTpaTrv} Kat
'*
XeXriBoTag, Kat ovhevt TrtaTevTeov XeyovTt, i^ov whe v} eKeiJ*'

^^ ^epet ^e etg v7ro'^etyfj.a tyjv yvvalKa tov Aojt, ty\v fj.eTd to

e^eXdeiv aTro Ho^^Ofncov aTpa<peiaav eig toc OTriaco, Kat ttd tovto 20

yevofj.evviv aTYjXYjv dXog, TOVTeaTtv, a7roXt6co6eiaav, 07rag eKaaTog

TYjg 7rvevfj.aTiK^g epyaatag, dv^petwg dvTe^xvjTat. Ato Kat tov


AwT efJ.vY}fj.ovevae Ka) toov ev llo'^ofj.otg, 6eiov Trvpog epyov Kai

Tpo(pYj yevofxevotg.

Tlcog d^roXXvat Ttg tvjv eavTOv ^^^X^iv, tva avTvjv ^taacoavi ; v) 2^


Kat Ttva TpoTrov ^taacoaat vofxiaag d^roXXvatv avTYjv ; 6e7og

A^ioaToXog Trept tovtcov (pvjaiv, " 0/ §e tov \ptaTov ^li^aov adpKU


*'
earavpcoaav, avv TO^ig 7ra6-fjfj,aai Kat Tatg e7rt6vfuaig," irovoig

tviXovoTt Kat Toig etg evae/Setav dywat, KaTaveKpovvTeg to TVjg


*'
aapKog (f)povY}fj.a, Ka6ag (pYjatv, veKpcoaare Ta fneXY) Ta eTrt TY}g 30
" "yijf, TTopi/eiav, aKa6apatav, 7ra6og, e7ti6vfj.tav KaKY}v Kai tyjv

" TrXeove^iav'^^ oaot ovv tovtcov eveKa veKpovvTai, ovtoi aeawKaai


TYjV eavrcov ^v/^v, ot ye fJ.Y}v (ptXv}tovov aipovfj.evot /Stov Kat

oiovTai '^
Tyyv eavTcov ^vyv}V KTda6ai, d^roXXvovat TrdvTcog avTvjv

•> orovTt Cod.


.

XVIII. 1. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 131

**
yap o-TTf/pcov," (prjaiVf " e<V ttjv (rdpKa, deptaet (f>6opdv.'' iari

§€ Kai erepco^ aTroAetravTa Tiva ti^v (avTov \pvyjl^v tiaTaaai, o

Kai 01 ixaKdpioi TteTtpdya^Ji [xdpTvpe^f TOVf y-^XP^ ^^X'?^ '^^^

aifxaTo<; '^itveyKovTeg dywva<;, rrjg eig yipiaTOv aydiri^g eveKa, Kai

(TTecfiavov TaT^ eavToov KetpaXai^ dvYixpav. ol e| dvdv^pov ^e t|/i/j^^f 5


Kai yvafivji tov napavTiKa Tyj^ aapKO^: ^iacpvyovTe^ OdvaTov, ovTot

<f)ovevTat T^f eawT^v yey ovaat ifvj^^f* KaToiK-^aovTat yap etg

<^ov TYj<; KaKoav^peia<: v^e^ovref ^iKa^.

EotK€ ^ta TOVTCov Tovg ev iiTuiyeia. Kat irovot^ ovTa$ vito^rikovv'

01 jotev yap ro t^j- irrayeiag (poprtKOv yevvafjog cpepovre^, acD(f>pQ- lo

vo}^ re Kai evteiKai Ptovvres, ovrot TrapaXeKpQYjaovraif dtKatot

^y]\ovoTt rvyydvovreq' oi ^e [xyj Totovroi, dXXa KaKovpyoi Ka\


vd<ryji <f>av\oTy]TO<; eTrtTfi^evTai, dtfteB-^a-ovrat r^ ^ta iivpog imo-

Ketaotj.evot ^iKyj. d^TroareKei yap, <f>y}ai, rovg 'Ayyekovg avrov


Kat eKXe^uiatv eK t«v dixaprcoKiov rovs ^tKaiovg, Kat Ttpoaotaovatv 15

aiiTco.
I

36 To ^e " o^rov to awfj.a,** Kat ra e^^f, tovto ^yjkoT, aairep ovv

acofjiarog Ketfievov veKpov ra aapKo^opa rav ttttjvwv Itt avra


awrpeyet, ovrag orav viog tov dvOpcoirov -^apayevyjratf rore Vq

vdvreg ot aerot, rovreartv 01 vxl^yjXa Trerofxevot koi dvco rwv eirt- 20


yeiwv KoafitKciov avevyfyft.evoi 'npayfx.drcov, eir avrov dvo^pafJ.ovvTat*^
NvKra ovofndi^et rov ryjg Kptaecog Katpov tia ro d(f>aveg Kat

dfffpoa^OKyprov ryjg Trapovaiag avrovt Kkivyjv ^e ryjv dvdiravatv.

KE*. 5.
Ufpi Tov KpiTOv Trjs ddiKias. 2^

1 A<a t^? irpoKetfxevyig TrapajSoXyjg t% Xeyovayjg " Kptryjg rtg


**
yjv," Kat ra e^^g, dttaXenrrcag yjfndg irpoaevyeaOat TrporpeTrerat

Hptarog 6 Seoc y}fji.cov, Kat fji.y] cKKaKeiv ev raTg ^(^aeatv. E<


yap Tov a^tKOv Kptrvjv, rov fn^^re Seov <f>ol3ovfj.evov ff.^^re ft,^

avBpcoTrovg evrpeTroft.evov, ^e^vacoTryjKe r^g X^P^^^ ^ 0"^''€%V Trpoao^^og, 3°


coare Kai aKovra Trotyjaat ryjv eK^iKyjaiv avryjg, Trcog o <f>tXotKTip-

fJiMV Kat ixiaovovyjpog, 6 rotg dyaircoatv avrov xe7pa vefJMV det t^v

c Hoc Scholium Cyrillo tribuit Cod. Meerman. Vid. Suppl. ad


Cat. in S. Matth.
S 2
133 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XVIII. 8.

erco^ovaav, ov Trpoaoe^eTai fxev roy? itpotJiovTag avTa Kai ev ^jU-epa

Kai iv vvKTtf iroi-^^rei ^e ry^v eK^^iKrjaiv avTaVf wg eKXeKTav avTov ;

Kai TavTa fxev 6 ayiog KvpiXXog. o Se 'KpvcroaTOfj.og Kai avTog

elg '^iacpopovg Xoyovg avTOv Trepi tov Kpnov Trjg a^iKiag Xeyei,

OTi irovripog Tig rjv Kai '7tapavo[J.og, Kai avTO de to ayiov tjvay- 5

yeKiov TovTO ^eiKvvaiv ev t'2 Xeyeiv tov *' aKOvaaTe


Kvpiov, ti

" 6 Kpnrjg TVjg a^iKiag keyei' 'he Qeog ov fjivj TroiYjafi t^iv

*'
eK^iKVj(7iv Twv eKXeKTfhv ayTot)*" -TiapeaTi^a-e yap '^ia tovtcov^

aXXov eivai tov KpiTfjv TVjg dhiKiag, Kai akXov tov Qeov. Yltog

ovv fj^era TOiavrag efj.(f>ave7g dnohei^eigf ov <f>piTTOvcn riveg oXoog, 10

Kav eig evvoiav XafK^dveiv, fxrj ti ye Kat Trapprjcta XaXeTv, avTOV


Tov Seov eivai KptTrjv Trjg dttKtag, eKTtXrjTTeaBat y^r].

8 OvK dyvo^v heairoTrjg X.piaT0g, Trwg yap 6 irdvTa etowg ;

(fiYiai,
" Tikriv vtog tov avSpccTTOv eXGcov apa evprjaet Trjv ittaTtv

" eirt T^j" yrjg ;" akX vTreKcpatvcov OTt diroopafxovvTat Ttveg ev 15

eayaTOtg Katpolg T^f opSrig TrtaTtcog Kat dhia^X-^Tov, TtpoaeypVTeg

Trvevfxaat nXdvrjg Kat ipevhvjyoptatg hteaTpafXfj.eviov dvBpooircov.

KE<I>. SA.
Ilepi Tov ^apia-aiov Ka\ tov Te\a>vov.

JO Ata Trjg tov ^aptaatov Kat rov reXcovov irapajSoXyjg ht^hda-Kei 20

"^fxdg <f>tXdv&pcoTTog Kvptog Kai Qeog li^aovg 6 ^ptarog, riva

^p>j rpoTrov rdg irpog avrov iroteHaOai herjaeig, tva [xr] dfxtaSov

evpeBYi rotg y^pcofxevoig ro irpdyfxa, fxrj^^e ht wv oo(f>eXe7a6at rig

vofxi^ot, htd rovrcov avrov Traporpvvet Ka6 eavrov rov rwv dvcoSev

y^apta-fxdrcov torrjpa Qeov. Teypatrrat ydp, ori " eari '^iKatog 25


*'
diroXXvfxevog ev dtKatoo"- avrov'^^ oQev Kat ^aptaalog evravBa htd
rovro KaraKeKptrai, ort fxr} entcrTrjfxovcog eTroteiro rrjv Trpoaevy^^v.

rioAXa ydp Kar avrov ra eyKXrifxara' Kat yap cog dvovg ov

fi.ovov redavfxaKev avxog eavrov, aXXa Kat iroXXovg erepovg avv

TW reXcovr] KareKptvev' 6 he KaraKptSetg vir avrov reXoovrig ovo 30


oaov eiTreiv dvareivat roXfxav eig vxpog rovg o(f>9aXfxovg, aXXa
TreptaretXag tv]v irapprjaiav dog ovk ej^wv avrrjv, roig airo rov

^ i>t^iKat'j.'i Cod.
XVIII. 12. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOY. 133

avvei^OTog Ix^y^oig irXyjTTOfxevo^; ecpo/SeiTO Kai fxovov 0(f)dy^vai

0fa5, wg oXiya (ppovriaa^ tS>v uvtov vofxctiv. Tvtttcov ovv to

«TT^flof Q}fJLQ'Aoy€t xa eyKX-^fxaTUf Kai ^eiKvv^ cog larpw t>jv vocrov,

eXefjByjvai irapfKaXet, ^io Kai " KaT€l3vj" (f^Yjo-lv o "^iKaiog KpiTyji,

" ovTog ^e^tKaiwfkevog eig tov oikov avTOv" Trap eKeivov. TavTa toi- 5

yapovv aK0V0VT€i efx.(f)pova}i Tocg apeTag KaTopQcaacofxev, Kat fxyj^eig

TOVTOV "xaptv VTTfpoxptav voaeiTCi}, jU,e/xv^o-flaj ^e fxakXov tov Kvpiov

enTOvrog Tolg ayiotg A7roaTo\oig, " OTav ravTa itdvra TiotvjcyYjTe'"

^vjXov Sc ort ra 'hiaTeraytj.eva avroTg, " Xeyere ort "^ovkot dyjpeloi

" €aft.ev, Kat w(f>eiXof>.ev iioti^aat TteTTOf^Kafxev.^^ " zra^ yap," 10

(ftrjatf
" Ixpav eavTOV raTretvcoS^^aerat, 6 Se raTietvm eavrov
*'
vypccB-^aerat.^^

'I21A12POT IIhaotsictot EniSTOAH. 0avfxd^etv e(f>yig Kat

(.KTiXyiTTeaBai, -ttSos fxev ^apicrahg fxeyaXoppyjfxovYjaag Trpoe-

Kpovaev. ^e I«;S irXeiova Kat ft.ei^ova elpviKwg ev^oKtfxi^aev. 15

Akov€ rotvvv avvrofxctis. 6 fxev fxi^^evog itapaKivovvroi fxyj^e epe-

Bt^ovros fxeyaXy\yop^Vi Kai ry]q otKovfxevyfc, aTtdayjg (fypovcov fxei^ovcag

6 ^aptaahg, eiKorcog iipoaKpovet' v7T€pyj(f>aviav yap voaei. 6 he ev

fxev rx ev^oKtfxeiv KpvTrrcov rd oiKeia TrXeoveKryjfxara, ev ^e tw


KaKyiyopeHaBat (f)pd^cov Ttpog ro diro^^vaxaOat ra e7rt(f)€pofxeva 20
eyKXyjfxara, ccaitep dot^^ifxog ireTrotYiKev 'Iw/3, Tidayjg airtag e^ca

KaS€ary)K(v eig rovg ov ^eovrcog KaKvjyopiag r^g atrtag aTryjX-

Xayfxevovg.

Ylep) Twv f3p€(f)it)V Ka) Ttep) rov elitovrog ^i^aaKdXov ecog

" Kai r^ Tptryj y]fxep(i dvaary\a€rat^ Ttpoeypdcf^yj eig ro Kara 25


^arBam.
12 Sethpot ek TH2 nP02 Mafnan. 'Karcag ev fxeaca Toy lepov

fxeyaXocpavccg yjret re Kai Ttpoay\vy€rOi Kat aog d^iog av wv j^ret

rvyeh, rag oiKeiag itpd^etg dityjptBfxe^ro Kai eXeye, " vyjarevQ} ^tg

" rov aa{3^drov'^ Kai ra e^y^g, Ka) oaca itoXXd KareXeye, roaovrov 30
TtXeov ryjv Betav dite^vev dKoy^v, Kai 6 rm pyjfxdrcav oyKog Kevog
Ttepi ra X^iXyj Kareppet, Ka\ etg d(f)pov ^ieXvero, KaBd^tep TtacpXd-

^ovra KVfxaTa. reXcovy^g ^e rig fxaKpdv earag Kat rov veca ryjv

eay^dryjv vTto^vg yccvtav, ro arvjGog eitate, t*;v 4'V%'»?v coaitep vito-

fxtfxvyjaKcov ^id rovrov rm avryj iteTtXyifxfxeXyjfxevccv Kai eigSB


X34 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XVIII. 17.

oiaQvjcriv '^ieyetpoiiv KaOev^ovaav, Kai fxyj^e Tvj^ ev ttJ Trpoaevyyj

aTafTtdDq avTOv vjyov^evog a^ioV tovto [xovov eToX(xa Xeyeiv,

Seog, iXaaSrjTi fxoi tw aff.apTw\w' Kai to fXoXig e^iov tov aTOfna-

TOi PYiff^a, TTTepv^iv vxprjXa7g eii^fipero, 7rpo$ ovpavov avecpepeTO, Kai

Kpovcov TVjv Bvpav, e'ia(o Trjg Beiag aKOVjg 7rapeTref».7reT0, Kat eOiKaiov 5

Tov irpoaev^aft.evov. 6 yap oiofj.evog eavTOV a^iov elvai tov eig Ta


o^vTa .TtapaKVTiTeiv tov lepov, Kai -nXvjaiov tivai tov &eov, noppca
fKeTa T(5v ^e^YjXdov aiioppKpYjaeTai' ^e Kai Tag $vpag xpavaat

(ppiTTCOv, Kai avTav twv Taft.ieim tov (SaaiXeccg KaTaTpvcpvjaei,


KaTo, Tvjv ev rao aafKaTi vvff.(pivjv tyjv Xeyovaav, " eiavjveyKe |xe 10
**
(SaaiXevg eig to Tafxieiov afToiJ."

17 ToT XpTSosTOMor. Ai^daKccv Tovg ff.a9v]Tag 6 ^ptaTog fi.e-

Tpid^eiv Kai Tvcpov KaTairaTeiv Koafi.iKOv, Toig TOtovTOig tvjv (3aai-

Xeiav eTiayyeXXerat (pdaKcnv, " dft.vjv, Xeyx vfii.iv, og eav fivj ^e^vjTui

" TV]v (3aaiXeiav tov Seov wg Trat^tov, ov fi.vi etaeXBvi etg avTVjV. 15
0'vTog yap (piXoaocptag opog, to ft.eTa avveaeccg aitXaaTov eivat.

KE<I>. EB.
Uepi Tov eTTepaTTiiravTos toj' ^lrjorovv TrXovcrlov,

18 ToT ATTOT. ^T/vcf ^ta(3dXXovat tov veaviaKov tovtov cog vttov-

Xov Ttva Kai irovvjpov, Kai ft.eTa Ttetpag tco Ivjaov irpoaeXBovTa, 20

eych ^c (piXdpyvpov avTOv Kat '/^pvift.dTOiv ^TTOva, ovk dv TTapatTYj-

aatfxvjv eiTrelv. 'E7r€;^>^ ^e 'KptaTog TotovTov avTOV vjXey^ev,

vmvXov §e ovtafjJjog, ^ta to fivj dacpaXwg twv d^-^Xwv KaTaToXfxav,


Kat fxdXtaTa ev eyKXvjfkaat, Kat tov M.dpKOv TavTVjv dvYipvjKevat tvjv

vTTorptav Kai ydp (pvjatv, *'


OTi Tipoatpafj.av Kai yovvTreTciov irape- 25
" KaXet avTOv, Kat oti ef>.(3Xexl>ag avTco 6 Ivjaovg vjydTrvjaev avTOV,"

^ta Ti ovv ovTcog 6 KptaTog vpog avTOV direKpivaTo Xeycov, " ov^etg
" ayaQog ;" eiret^vj cog dvdpcoirco TrpoavjXSe ^tXw, Kai evi twv iroXXm,
Kat '^itaaKdXcii 'Iot/^ai>ca)' ^/a toDto wg dvBpairog avTco "^taXeyeTai.

Kat yap TroXXa^/ov irpog Tag virovoiag tcov Trpoaep^/pft.evm airo-^h^

KptveTat. OTav ovv eiTrVj, " ovhetg dyaQog" ov^ eavTOV eKpdXXm tov

dyaBog eivat tovto Xeyet, diraye. ov yap Xeyet, t/ fxe Xeyeig

' e Cf. Cat. ad S. Matth. p. et seq. et Cat. in S. Marc.


i
54 p. 376
et seq.
XVIII. i8. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 135

ayaOov ; ovk eifiii a-yafioj-, aAX ov^ei$ ayaSo^, tovTeaTiv, ov^etg

avBpwTiwVf Kai avrog ^e OTav ^eyvj, ovte Toii^ avdpanovi dnoarepiov

dyadoTVjTog tovto Aeyf/, dXXa Trpo^ dvTi^^taaToXvjV ttjc tou Qeov


1/)/
ayamTtiToq.
a\
L\io
\>/
Kai eiarfyayev,
4t'^f'£i'"
ei^
ei yyeo^.
[xr) o
^'
Kai ovk

fiirev, ei fji.vj o TlaTi^p [xov, iva [xdGrjs oti ovk e^eKaXvxpev eavTOv tco 5

veavKJKco, Kai OTav ^eyvj, **


/u,>/ KaXeavjTe ^i^daKaXov em tvj^ y^i"
•Kpoc; avTiS/ao-roA^v avTov tovto (f>v]ai, Kai iva fxd6a)a-i Tig vj TrpccTV]

tqvtcov ("'PXV}. Ka^ jU,eT oXiya — AiTrapa vjv vj y^, d\ka toJv

aKavSicv to TrXvjBog tov airopov avveTTViyev. E/ ^e iteipa^iov Tipoa-

^\6ev, eh-^Xuaev av Vjfxh 6 FivayyeXiaTVjg, loaTrep Ka\ eTn Tm 10


oAAcov Tioiel, Kai ei Treipd^av irpoavjKOev, ovK av aiivjXSe kvnov-
[A,evog €<f> olg vjKovae. Tovto yovv ov^eig enaOe TcoTe twv ^api-
aaiwv, aAA vjypiaivov eiriaTOfi.i^ofi.evoi, ovTog ^e aTreiat KaTYi(f)V)g,

(mep ov [xtKpov avjixeiov T&y a>; [/.era Tiov^pdg yv^ixvjg avTOv

vpoaeX6eh, aAA' daSeveaTepag, Kai e-ntSv^xeh [xev tvji; ^(ovjg, Kar- 15


eyea6ai §6 erkp!^ TrdSei yaXeTrcordTop.

ToT ArioT TiTOT BosTPflN. 'Oo"T6 Qeov epyov ro aa6^vai

vi[i.dg, aAA' vj[j.av ro ^eXvjaai, 0eoy te ro toop-^aaaSat.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaesanapeias. E^eo-T; ydp avToTg, ei [xvj etg

ditav eXoivro rwv ovruv diroXta^eTv, erepag ev^0Ki[t.etv, " Troivjaai 20


*'
(piXovg eK Tov d^iKov [f.a[t.[t.wvd, tv orav eKXetiraat, ^e^avTai
**
avrovg etg rdg atavtovg aKVjvag."
ToT attot. Tipoaendyei Se toDto MaTflarof to **
rt apa
" earat v][Ji.7v ;" Trpog rovro epeT rig, ri ydp oXcog d<j)YiKav 01

[t.a6vjTai, vj rtvoov avreKTiatv atrovai irapa ^ptarov ; T< ovv 25

irpog ravra (f)a[uev ;


[xdXtara [t.\v ravrvjg eveKa t^^ atrtag avay-

Katordrvjv hrotovvro t>?v irevatv. ag ydp ov^ev KeKTVj^xevot ttA^v

ort [xtKpd Kat evreXvj, j3ovXovTat [uaSeh rtva rpoirov aixef^erai

Seog Kai rovg oXiyoard KaraXeXonrorag tid ye t^v /SaatXeiav


rov Seov, rovreari ^id ro e(f)iea6at rvyeiv rvjg rav ovpavav ^o
{3aatXeiag, S<a r^g eig avrov aydnvjg. dpaporug /xev ydp irXov-

aiog Kara^fypovvja ag iroXXav, irpoa^oK^aet Tag d[J.ot(5dg. ^e ye


jj.iKpd KeKTVjfcevog, elra rovrocv airoarag, ev iroiaig eXTriaiv earat,

noig ovK etet [xa6e7v ; eira irpog rovroig KdKeho elireh dvayKahv,

ro ydp rot ttoAAwv vj oXiywv diroXiadeh taov roig ira.Seaiv etvj av, 35
136 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XVIII.35.

KaTo. ye rov t^j- opSoTvjTog XoyoV ovkovv to ye ^kov eig vizaKOfjV

Kai TtpoOeaiv ev lavj ra^ei KaTaKoyKjQeHtv av Tolq itoWa KeKTfi-

[j.evoi^f 01 fxy^ KaT avTovg fxevovTeg' eha TaHg laaig TcpoBvixiaig

'^af/.evoi, Kai toov evovTCOv tvjv aTrefx/SoXvjv eKovatov VTrofxevovTeg.

Aia TOVTO ^e 01 ATiodTokoi **


ovhev tovtccv (xvvvjKav, aX\ "^v to 5
" p^fJ.a TOVTo KeKpvfXfJievov ait ayrwv, Kai ovk eyivcaaKov Ta keyo-
" fneva" eTrei^Y] ovteTtce vj^eicrav aKpipwg to, itapa twv ayim -npo-

(pvjToiv irpoKeKvjpvyf/.eva.

KE4>. Hr.

JJfpl TOV TVCfiXov. 10

ct:i Tlpo(TYjX9e fxev TvcpXog wg Sew tS Travra kj^/vovti, ovofxd^ei

^e avTOv viov Aa/Si^f e^Treihr] reQpafKfxevog ev \ov'hai(7fx.a ovk y]yvo-

Y/ae ra ^ia tov vofLov Kai rwv TrpocpyjTuiv irepi avrov Trpovjyopev-

fxevaf ori eK yevovg vnyjpye tov AafSi^ ro Kcnra odpKa' ovkovv cog

vj^v] 7re7ri(7revKibg ori Qeog cov Aoyog V7reff.eiv€ tvjv Kara aapKa^S
yevvriGiv, rrjv aTto ye rvjg navayiag 7rap6evov (py]fJ.i, 7rpo<7eiTiv ccg

06c5 \eycov, " e\ev](70v fxe, vie A«/3/^." ori yap ovrca tiarideig

7ip0(7eK0fj.i(je TY]v iKerY^piav, e7TifJ.apTvp-^aei. KeyoiV avrw 'KpKrrog,


" Yj Tricrrig (xov cre(7Ci}Ke o"e." Bavfxdcroofxev te avrov Kai tyjv evcTra^Tiv

T^f OfxoXoyiag, oti rivZv eTiiTLfxcfSvrcov avrS), avrog ovk aviei' Oio 20

Kat TeTtf/.Yjrat eiKorcog ttapa HpKTrov rov Qeov' KeKXvjTat yap


Ttap avTov, Kat eyyvg yevea6ai TrpocTTeraKTat.
41 OvK dyvoxv ^e i^pcoTYjaev avrov Trdvra eiowg, " ri 6eXetg
*'
7toiYj(T(a aot ;" «AA iva ft.d6otev 01 7tapeaTY]Koreg, Y]yovv 01 avfx-

/Sa^i^ovreg, ccg ov y^pY]fxara alreTv avrov, «AA evepyetav 6eiKYjv, 25

iog 7tapa Qeov. E7r€/^>; ^e rov rYjg atTY^aecog evecpdvtae rpoTtov,

rore Vf] rore rvjg lov^a/cov dirtartag eXey/og y]v to etpvjfLevov

7tapa 'Kptarov' ecpY] yap fxer e^ovaiag TYjg avcorarco, " ava^XeipoV

Ttg yap rSov dyicov TtpocpY^rciov el^te rt roiovrov, Y]yovv ev roaavTY)

XeXdXr]Kev e^ovaia ; o6ev Kat >pcog tc5 Kdfxvovrt yeyovev yj (pcov^' 3°


(poorog yap y]v Xoyog rov dXY]6tvov' d^raXXayetg ^e rvjg voaov, ov

KaTY]fji.eXi^ae rov eivat (ptXo-^^^ptarog, Y]KoXov6€t yap, (pY]aiv, avrSi,

TY]v '^o^av dva^refJLTicov wg Qea' yeyove ^e Kai erepoig 7rpo(paatg


XIX. 5- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 18T

Tou ^o^oi^eiv avTOV, avas yap, <f>yi<riv, 6 Xaog c^coaccv ouvov rf


<

KE^. SA.
Ilfpt rov ZoKxaiov.

A 'Apy^neXoivi^i r/V o Zaicxaio$, ew eiriTdcrei ^e iroXXy "aap avT^S


TO (f>t\dpyvpoVf Kai t% TrXeove^ias 6 a-KOTro^y tovto yap Tot(

tcXwvati TO eTriT-^^evfJM' dW ov fx.eii.evriKev ev tovtoi? o ZaK-


j^arof* yi^kjoBvj ^e (fyeitovi t^s Trapa tov Xp/aToiJ* avTO^ ydp
e<TTtv KaXwv eyyvg Tovg fxaKpaVj Kai (f)!OTi^iov Tovg e<JKOTi(Tfi.e-

vovg. entBv^Yi<7avTog yap eKetvov tov Kvptov lv}<xovv 6ea<ra<r8atf i o

Kai ^ta TovTo hrt <jvKOfj.opeav dveXBovTog, €/3Xd<7Ty]<Tev ev eavT^

(TvepfJM crcoTyiptag' ovTrep /^wv o \pi<TTOg Totg Trjg deoTvjTog o<f)BaX'

[J^oTg, 6 iravrag avQpairovg SeXcov <Ta}6^vai' TrpoTetvet t»/v yjfJiepoTVjTa

**
Xeycov, ZaK^aie, aTrevaag KaTa(3i^6i" Kat Ta e^^g' eytvoxTKe

yap wg TrpoyvaxTTi^g Seog to €<TO[Ji.evov. et^ev dvdpcoTrov ^v^v^S


eTOtfj-OTaTa ^iavevovcrav etg ye to eXeaBat ^tovv dyi(og, Kat fJieTe-

6etKev eig ev<Te(3etav' Kat ydp vire^e^aTO tov 'lyjcrovv yatpooVf o6ev

Kat yeyovev evSvg eXerjfJiCtiv Kat (f^tXoirTco^^^eiag epa<TTyig, Kat To7g

vjOtKy)fj.evotg vTre^ryeTO TeTpairXovv direp Yj^tKy]<Tev diro^ovvat, Kard


Tov vofj.ov Ta Te<Taapa TrpofSaTa avTt evog eKTtaetv KeXevovra. 20
Ato <f>y]ai \ptaTOg Qeog vifj.wv,
'*
a-yjfj.fpov a<OTY,pta tw otKca tovtco

" yeyove, Ka6oTt Kat avTog viog eaTtv A^padfj..*^ ev6a ydp eiaPdXXyj

A.ptaTogf eKet iravTcag eaTt Kat acoTyjpta. t$0€t oe Kat Tovg lov-

^ouovg yaipetv eTr) ZaKyaica aea-caafxeva Trapa^o^cagf oti Kat avTog


eig viovg eTeXei tov 'A(3padfx, oig tvjv '^td "KptaTov XvTpcoatv ^id 25

irpocfyriTav dytwv eiryjyyeiXaTO Seog.

5 ToT AnoT TiTor Boztpcn. UapaSappvvag avTOv Xeyet,


" airevaag KaTd^Y^6t^^ aov y^etav ej^cu, fj.€ya <tov to eXKog, fxeyd-
Xijv e7ri^eiKvvfJ.t Tyjv ^epaTreiav, ev to; oIikq) <tov Se? fj.e fj.elvat, ov

ToaovTOv ev tw e^w, o<7ov ev tcS t^j ttavoiag. Ka\ VTrete^aTO avTQV^o


yaipoiV erv/e yap wv fj^tf irpoae^OKa. ^RTrayyeXXcTat Se to»

Sftrr^p/ Ta vjfj.ta-y] twv VTrapyovraVf oiiy^ tva eavTW Ta Xonrd irapa-


Koraay^yjf aXX tva TeTpairXaatova diroTtayj ToHg 7rXeoveKTvj6e7atv.

evt TOVTOtg Ivjaovg ev(f>paiveTat Kat (pvjat, " ayjfi.epov ccoTVjpia

T
138 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XIX. 12.

*'
yiyovi Tw o^Ku> tovtw." vptitrraro yap ro oXoKKvjpov rov /A€Ta-

VQ-^a-avTOSf reTpaTrXaa-iova ^e aTrc^ ttooai To7i a^iKVjBeiat, vo[x.i[i.ov

voiovfxevos rrjv eKri<Tiv.

KE«I». HE.
HepX Tov iTopfvdePTos Xa^ew iavra ^aviKeiav. 5

11 'O (TKOvos r^^ •npoKeiiA.evrig TtapaPoX-f)? oXriv wf h ^payeai


irapKxrS. rvis e(f> y]ix7v yevoiJ.evfji olKovo^uiag rov Qeov Aoyov rrjv

^vva/xiVy Kai rov Kar avrov fxvarvjpiov Ta aT[apyy)i fJ-ey^i rekovg.

yeyove fJiev yap avSpcoTios Qeog wv Aoyo^, Keyjpfi^ariKe ^e ^ia


rovro Kai tovXos, aXX' ^v Kai ea-riv evyev^i, Kard ye rvjv €K^°
Ylarpog appyjrov yevvyja-iv. aTtoTTepdvag ^e ryjg [xera aapKO^ oikovo-

fxiai ro [/.var^^piov, eif ry]v evova^av avrco Kara ^vatv avaire^poi-

ri^Ke ^o^av, Kai olov aTto^e^yjii.YiKev eU %'^po-'^ [/.aKpdv' yo^pa yap

erepa vapa rvpt yyjv ovpavog. Ai/e/3>7 &e Xa^eh eavrS) (3aai-

Xeiav. iiwg §e rm oXwv paa-iXevcov [/.eTa rov Tlarpog aveta-i iS

npog avroVf \y)xlJO[i.evoi ^aatXetav ; ^yjkovori evavQpfaitYiaavri toj

T/oS Kat rovro ^t^aatv Ylaryjp. Ava(j)otTy}aag yap etg ovpa-

vov, KeKdBtKev ev ^e^ta r^$ fJieyaXoavvvjs ev vxpi^Xoig, ro Xotirov

eK^eyo^xevos (l(t)( ov reSSoa-tv 01 eyQpot avrov viro rovg •notag


avrov.

14 Ttveg te eiatv ot •noXhai avrov ot [t.iaovvTeg avrov ; 01 lov-

^aiotj Tiept wv (f)y]atv, " ort Kat eupdKaai Kai [j.e[i.tayjKacn Kat e[i.e

" Kai rov Ylarepa [J.ov^^ Kat ovk y]6eXy]aav avrov eir avrovg j3aat-
Xevaat. ^to Kai eXeyov iipoi YliXdrov dpvov[j.evot t»?v ^aatXeiav
avroVf " ovK eyo^j.ev ^aatXea ei [t.v] Kaiaapa" Katrot ZaKyapiov 25

Tou 7ipo(f>v]Tov ^omrog, **


X^^-^p^
a^o^^pa, Qvyarep 2/wv, oti i^ov

" ^aatXevg aov epyerat aot ^tKatog Kat aco^av'" Ojao/wf Kai

'Haaiov, " i^ov ^)] ^aaiXevg ttKatog ^aaiXevaei, Kat dpyovreg


" [j.era Kptaewg dp^ovatv" ert ^e Kat rov Trpo^v]TOV Aa^t^ itepi

avTov rov 'Kpiarov Xeyovrog' " eyw &e Kareard6v]v fiaaiXevs^o


XIX. 22. AOTKAN ETArrEAlOT. 139

KE*. Ef.
Ufpi t5>v XafiovTap ras fipas.

13 Uotovi Se '^ovkovg KaXktrag rovroif ^teveifxe Ta^ ^e/ca [xvas ;

Tovs T€\tiov$ Tvjv e|/v, 01$ av irpeTry nat vj aTipea Tpo(f>yjf TOi/f

fxva-TayciyyeTv ei^orag opBZg, Kat irpog iraaav aperrjv eavrovi re S

Kat erepovi aTrevQvvovrag. ovrot yap vovQerovvrag rovg vtto %e/pa


Xaovg Trpoa^epyd^ovTat rotg ^oBeTcxtj Kat rov roTg ayiotg Trpeirovra

Kephaivovat KX^pov. vTToarpe\pavTog yap ix.era ro Ka^eh r\v (3aa-i-'

ketav rov avOpamov rov evyevovg, ^JyXov Se ori Xp/cTTcv tou Qeov

^f/MV' ev ^evrepa avrov Ttapovaia rev^ovrat Kai eTraivav, Kat raTg lo

avaraTa} Tt[MaTg evrpvcp^^aua-t. ^eKaTrXaatdaavreg yap Kat Trav-


ravXaatdaavreg ra '^oBevra ^ta rov Kep^avat voXXovg, eirdvco

^eKa TToXeav yj Trevre yev^aovrat, rovreartv dp^ovat TrdXtv, ovy^

m ^p^av irpo rovrov [i-ovm, dXXa yap Kat erepm ert ttoAAcSv.

ATtfMta ^e earat roTg okvw veviKvjiJi.evoig' o ydp rot KaraKpvrpag f$


aov^^apio} rvjv [xvav, virev^veKrat ryj rota^e ^iKy].

Tavr-tp §e t^v Trapa^oXvjv eiirev, eiret'^)) eXeyev, ^yiKev ^


(3aatXeia rov Oeoy, Kat Beaadfxevot avrov eig 'lepovaaXy][x dvtovra

w-^Ovjaav ^ta rovro dvtevat, tva ^v) dpyriv SaJ rri PaatXeia rov
Qeov. ravra /a€V ovv eKeTvot evofntl^oVf ov [uifjv eXeyov, aXX' ev raig 20

havoiatg avrwv eKvXtov rriv irpoa^^oKiav. 'O Se TrXdaag t>?v Kap-


dtav Kai rovg Xoyovg eTrtard[jLevog, yj^et ravryjv avrcov t*/v irpoa-

toKtaVj Kat ttopBovrat ro a<f>dX[Mt, tta Trapa^oXyji' evKaracppovyjTos

yap Traaa yvy.voTy]g Xoyov.

32 JCi' yo-p avaryjpog et[At, (priai, Sept^cov oirov ovk eairetpa, ota 25
Ti [xy] ry}v ^oOeiadv aot ydptv, rovro ydp eartv yj [uva, '^etcoKag roTg

rpaTre^tratg, rovreart, "npovOyjKag etg airoXavatv roTg ev et^oai

^0Kt[xd^etv Ta Trapa aov. 'E-yw yap eXQoDv eirpa^a aV rovreartv,

dTrffcyiaa ro e[LOv avv tokoo' twv [i.ev yap tttaaKdXwv eart ro


KaraaTreipeiv roTg aKpo<i)[/.evotg rov eTratpeXrj Kat aarriptov Xoyov, 30
roTg dKpoo)[i.evotg Se ov (Jlovov ra KaTa(3Xy]6evra ryjpetv dfJieiarra,

dXXa Kat vaaav dperyjv irpoaepydaaaBat. Atonep /xev oKVfipog

T %
140 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XIX. 39.

oiK€ry]( yvfxvos Koi rov SoflevTo? ecrrai yapia-ixaTo^f 01 Sc Trjv

afJLiiVQ} Pa^i^ovTeg o^ov, ev TrpoaQ^K-j^ Beiiov '^apKXii.aTm yev^crovTai*

€Tt ^e Koi Twv almiav ayaQoov aTioXavawaiv' 01 ^e fxyj fieAoyo-avTff

^lov^^aToi eir avToiig ^aaiXevaai tov avSpcoTTOv tov evyevvj, KaTe-

a^pdyrjaav efJ.7rpoa6ev avTov, (^fiai. Ka< yap eiradov Kai vvv tovto ^

Tiveg e^ avTwv eirt t^ tccv 'lepoao\vft.wv aXwaet' ev te tvj tevTepa

vappovaia \ptaTov tov a\7j6ivov Seov •rjfxaVy itavTeg ovtqi (aairep

hf a(f)ay^ t^ aTeAeyT^TO) KoXaaei ^oO-^aovTat.

r- ToiV yap KaTaKovaaai TtpoQvfxag tqov avTOV Xoym Tor? fia$y}-

Ta7g Xeya Kat To7g e| eSvm TreTttaTevKoaty Kat KaTeyovaiv ev r^io


htavoia Tov Tvjg tt^aaKaXiag BefxeXmy Kai etoOy} Kai eTieptaaevQrj

Ta TVjg Getag yv^fxrjg KaTa t^v toD IIvey/AaTOf '^(cpeav. lovoatm


^e ft)ifj KaTaayovTm tov avTov koyov^ Kat etoKovv ej^e/v a(f)yjpe6i^'

TOVTO Se eaTtv tj KaTa rov MaoiJaeag vofxov Xarpetaf Kat Ta vpo-


^TiKa Kai QeoTTvevaTa ypdft.fi.aTaf to, TtpoayopevovTa Trjv wapoy- 15

aiav Tov Kvptov Kat Qeov Kat "^coTiljpog \piaT0Vf Kai avTO ro tov
lapavjX ^talSovjTov ovofxa.

Km. sz.

Hfpi Tov TraXov.

29 Kat kyiv^TO m yjyyuTev m ^rj(f>6ayT) koI BrfOaviav 20


7rpo9 To opos To KaXovfjL€vov 'EAatajv.

OpirENOTS. 'H jU,€V BvjQavia epfXYjveveTat oiKog viiaKoyjgf rj

Se Bi^6(pay^ atayovegf lepaTtKog Tig m Toitog' Kat yap aiayoveg


Totg lepevai eS/SovTO, wg ev tc5 vofi(p dvayeypa-nTat' oirov ovv

vzraKoyjf kui tepog TOitog, eKei ditoaTeXXet Kvpiog rovg Attoctto- 25


Xovg XvaovTag " irwXov ^e^^ef/.evoVf ev 00 ov^^eig itaiTtoTe dvBpwTtm
*'
eKd6taev" avti tov ov^eitOTe av6paitog Xoy-.^og eiteKd^taeVf 17

MftjyVewf Xoyog^ yj 'Hcraiov, ov^e dXXov Ttvog im TtpocprjTm. ot€

&e ^Aflev 'KptaTog, etTte Tolg fj.a^rftatgf iva diteX^ovTeg Xvacoat tov
**
TtaXov. EiTte &e awTorf, edv Ttg vfj.dg epcoTdf Tt Xvere tov arwAov, 30
" epeiT(f OTi 6 Kvptog avTov '/jpeiav ej^e^." itoXXot yap yjaav ot

Kvptot Tov ovov itpo Tov Kvptev6y)vai vito tov SwT^pof* lafLei/ Se
XIX. 35- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOY. 141

OTi 6 Tov Kvpiov aTTO^ yevoiJ.€voif ov ^vvaTat TioWovg Kvpiov$

e)(€i)>' OTav Tyj KaKia. tovXivti t;j", woAAcSv •traBwv SovXof e<XTiv 6

avQpaTrog.

35 Ktpiaaot 'Aaesanapeias. AyeTai o TrwAof, ^vo jM,aS>jTcSv

aTreaTaXfJiivccv irapa "K.piuTov' VTrrjpeTovai yap itpoq tovto avTO 5

Suo TayfJMTa, irpocf^^Tai ^e outoz kui ATroaToAo/, ^i av (xayyivev-

ovTai e/f TTiaTiv to. eQvrj. AyeTat Totvvv airo Tivog Ka[ji.v]g, tva S/

ayTou Trjv aypoiKOV twv eBva)v ^et^y] (f)peva' ovk ev vofJ.(a TeQpafi,-

fj.eva}Vf l^vjadvTCOV ^e /aaAAov aT^jW.eActJf Kat dpTtag Kat dyptwq^

irXvjv fj.eTe(JT'q htt to vifxepov' yeyove yap vtto 'KpiaTw tc5 iidvTa 10

^^ddKOVTt. eTepoq ye fj.r}v t»v dyicov YivayyeXi(TT(sv Kat war&af

e(f)yj ^aia (potviKCcv avaTetvovTaq TipoTpeyetv avTov, Kat OfJ.ov TOtg

ftM6yjTa7$ avvTiSevat tvjv ^o^oKoytav, tva Kat '^t avTav tov veov

Kat e^ eBvm, loaTtep ev TtivaKt yeypafj.fj.evov, t ^(i}fj.€V Kaov. Teypa-


•mat yap, " Kat Xaog 6 KTt^ofxevog alveaei tov Kvptov.*' 15
ToT AnoT TiTOT. 'O Kvptoi T/f, dvoXeXvfj.evov to ovofJM, e^ov-

ataaTtKVj Se v) iipoayfyoptay PaaiXevcov yjBeXe <f>atvea6at tw TrXyjQei*

taoKe(f>aXoi ^e yjv yj 6ea' /xeTaaTeAAcTa/ ttoAAoJv, tva Ka6ta6evTa


t^ccatv 01 iroAAo/* irpoeXa^e to irXyi6og Kat /Soa " ev\oyyjf*.evog 6

**
ep^xpfj.evog ev ovofJMTt Kvptovy* " ^o^a ev vxptaTotg QeS, Kai eat 20
" 7^f elpyjvyf, ev dv6poyiroti ev^oKia.'^ Ata t; ; dv6p(tmot yap fj.eT

A-y^eActJv' yap avo) ^aaiXevg Kare^yj /taTCt), Kai 'ireTroiyjKe fxtav

viraKoyiv. 'Ey}fj.e7ov to yivoff.evov. ov yap airo tov opovq twv EAa<wv

ets 'lepovaaXyifj. eiatovTt tw Kvpi(p xpeta Ttg eir' ovov Ka6e^ea6ai,

Gi eif Tvjv \ov^aiav Kat TaXtXaiav airaaav ^t-^et fre^oif dXXa to 25

fTTO^^ov «yTOV eTTi Tov iraXov 6eoope7a6atf ^vjXoT to eirt tov veov

Xaov Ka6e^ea6ai tov ovpdvtov Yjyefj.ova Kat fSaatXea Tvji '\tpov~

aaXyjfj.. To yap veov Tijf KX-^aecog eS^Acwaev ircoAof, aAAa Kat


TO irdXat fj.yj
Ka6dpov twv vvv KaXovfi.ev(i3v. dKpt^earara te 6
M.aT6aiog tvjv viroTVTrooaiv rwv irpayf/.dTCOv yeyevy]fj.evyjv e^ei^ev, 30
ov fLovov Tov iraXov fJ.vyjfJ.ovev(i)v, dXXa Kat Toyf ovov, oti Kat 6
lapayjX varepov dKoXov^yjaet tc5 veoj Aaw, Ka6d irore yj fJ^rjryjp tS
vwXw' OTi yap eirt tco vwXca eKa6ea6yj '^yjXovatv 01 Xotirot, 01 kol

fxovov tou traXov ft.vy][xovevovTe( dyofxevov vpof rov lyjaovv. Se


142 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XIX. 42.

M.aT6a7og eiTroiv Kai ttjv ovov a^^Qeiaav Kai eirdvw avTa KaSeaSevTa
Tov KvpioVf ov O^^nov avvoopi^a yevof/.ev>]v tov re ttcoXov Kat t^s

fJiViTpog Xeyei, Trw? ydp ; «AX eTroixevriv t^v ovov. AeSe^evoj Se


TraXog Kai vj ovog Tovg 7rpo<J^e^e[j.evovg ToTg dvBpicnmig 'npdyfJM.aiv
f^e/^e Xaovg, Kai fx^ dveTOvg ovTag elg to ^e^aaQai t^v eni/3aaiv ^

TQv Kvpiov, dviefxevovg ^e ^ia to 6e7ov eTriTayfJia tov Kvpiov jOtoy-

^evog ditOKdoXvaai ^vvvjOevTog, Kai el (SovXovTai KCcXveiv Ttveg, wg


avTot ^eaTTOTat, dXX edv Ttg vfi,Tv eiiirii t/ (pyjaiv ;
'*
epe^Te oti
*'
6 Kvptog avTov '^eiav ej^e;." 6eia %\ KXy^atg ev tovtw ^eSiy-

XccTat. 10

42 K^dKpvae §e eirt tvjv 'lepovaaXTjfx 6 Kvptog, <f)tXdv9pa}irog cev,

tva ^ia TovTQV fj.d6(0fj.ev OTt XeXvTrrjTat irept avT^i^g, e'i7rep oXoog

y^ri Tt TOiovTO etirelv irept tou irdvTdiv eireKetva ©eoy. WSig yap
-aXXoog eyvcofi.ev av rjfJ.eTg OTt KaKovg ovTag rjXeet, el fxy] ^ta

TrpayfxaTog avQpwTrtvov, tovto KaTeaTrjaev evepyeg, oQev Kat fj.eTa 15

TptaKovTa irevTe eTr} TTjg dvaXi^xpeoog rj aXcoatg avT^g yeyovev,

avaPoXrjv Troiovfj.evov tov <ptXav6p(airov ©eou T^g Ttfj.copiag ev

ToaovToig eTeat, Kat fj,aKpo6vfj.ovvTog Trpog to emaTperpat Tovg


ireTrXavrifj.evovg tta Trjg twv dyiav ^AiroaToXcov tt^^aaKaXiag, eig Trjv

Tojf TrtaTeag aXr}6tvr]v evtyvwatv, Kai diroXXayrpat Tr^g fj,eXXovar]g 20

opy^g epyea^ai eiri Tovg viovg T^g diret^etag' tto Kat ot Treta6ev-

reg eppvadrjaav, '*


fj.ev ot te diret^-^aavTeg dirwXovTO, to yap, el

" eyvcog Kat av Ta irpog eiprjvriv^^ tovto eaTtv, oti ra '/^rjatfj.a

Kai avayKoia irpog ro etpr]vevaat ©eo5 ei eireyviag aTtvd eaTtv, rj

irtaTtg, Kat r] etg Kvptov VTraKor], Kat to aireyea6at twv TVTrwvi^

Kat Tr]g ev vofJ.ca XaTpeiag, ovk av TotavTat ae 6Xi4ietg 7reptefj.evov,

dXX eKpv(3r]f (pr^atv, diro o^6aXfxccv aov eKovatcog yap ovk r]6eXr]-

aev eltevat, r^yovv avvtevai Tocf 6eomievaTovg ypa(f>ag Tag ^r]Xovaag

TO Trept efj.ov fj.vaTi^ptov.

Katpbv te Xeyet T^g hrtaKoirr^g aov, r]v avTog emf^aaTO, 30


KaTeX6wv eirtaKe^pdfj.evog avTr]v, Kai 6e7a 'bi^dyfj.aTa 'titdJ^^ag ev

avT^, Kai irXetaTag 6avfj.aTovpyiag epyaadfj.evog.


XX. 2. AOTKAN ETArrEAlOT. 143

KE^. SH.
Tlfpi tS>v iirepaTrjo-avTav tov Kvptov apxifpiav,

2 IflANNOT TOT XpTSOSTOMOT. 'lcTeoV ^f, OTl KUt IwaVVrn


TOVTO (f>y](7iv, aAA* eKem^ ju,ev ev apyyj tov EivayyeXiov, ovTOf Se

vpos Tw reAe/, olJev eiKOi ^evTCpov yeyev^cr6ai Kai KaTa ^iacf)opovf 5

Katpovf. KaKiT fxh Keyova-iv, t/ aYi[xe7ov eTri^eiKvveig yj[J.7v ; ev-

Tav6a l3oaaif KaiToiye e7z-<T//xijflevTef '^ia to ^^vj 6av{xd^ea6at

avTOV Trapa Traai. tovto ^e KaTyjyopia fxei^uv lov^aioov, oti Kai

aira^ Kai §/f to avTO tovto TroiyjaavTO^, efxevov eirt t^ KaTiriKeia,

Kai avTt6eov avTOv eivat ekeyov' ^eov KavTev6ev avTOv /xaflen/ ti;v 10

Ttpoi Tov YlaTepa TtfJLyjv Kat tyjv oiKetav \ayyv. Kat yap e6av[ka-

Tovpyyjae, Kat eapav to7s Xoyoig toc epya (7Vft.^aivovTa, dXk ovSe

oi/TCUf hrei^ovTOy aAX' yjyavdKToW ^toirep Kai avTOi tov Hcaiav


avTo7g eTttTef/^t^ei KaTyjyopov XeyaVf " oIko^ fxov oiKOi iipoaevyyji
" KKyj^^^aeTat." 15
ToT ArioT Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias. *0 vo/ao? (f>y]aiv

tta Mcavaewj', fJLovovg eKeXevae tuv lepav airTea^at aTrov^aafJidTav


Toyf ef aifxaTOi Aevi'' avTOt ^taTdTTOvat Ta ev tco 6eta} vo^ou,

avToif ^e^oTat to fxvaTaywye7v, Kat yj tZv lepZv irept^okuv e^ov-


ata' av Se 7r»f e^ eTepa^ vTrdpyvv <f)vXy]i, yeyovaq yap eg 20
loy^a, Taf ev yjfJL^v eKvefxyi^eiaag e^apird^etg Ttfxd^ ;
" T/? aoi
" ^e^coAce T^ e^ovatav Tavryjv ;" cxAA' ei Ta$ 6eoTrvevaTovg yj^ets

ypa<f)ag, co davveTe ^aptaa7e, Kat tocj twv dyiwv irpotpyjTZv cf^ccva^,

€[xv^a6y]( av Ae-yovTOf tov fxaKapiov 7rpo(f>-^TOv Aa^i^, Trpog tov


*'
TcSv oAcov crcuT^^a Xj3;aT0v, Hfxoae Kvptos, kou ov fxeTafxeky]- 25
**
6yiaeTat, av tepevg eig tov aiwva KaTa ty]v Td^tv MeAp^/cre^e/f."

<f>pd^e ^y] ovv, t/j €k tcSv ypafxfxaTeav yj ^aptaaioov keXetTovp-

yy]Ke to) 0ew ^aTa t^v tcc^/v MeAj^/o-eSe/c, oi evXoyy]ae tc Kat

OeOeKdTcoKe tov ^APpadfx' ag Se 7rdvao(f>o<; ypd(f>et IlayAof,


*'
ywpig Trday]g dvTtXoytag to eAaTTov vtto tow KpeiTTOvog evXoye^-^o
" rai," oviicoyv 17 pi^a &e ^ dirapyy] T^g yeveaeag twv e^ lapay]\,
TOVTeaTtv, TTpoTrdTcop A^pouifx viro tyjs tov MeAj^/cre^eAC lepof^

avvy]g i^v\oyy]Tat, Tvirog le ^v MeAj^iO^e^eAC Kat yj KaT avTOV


144 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XX. 9.

Upcoavwi Tov itavrm "EiWTVjpos Xp/CTov, 0$ yeyovev r]iJi.iov a/jj^^e-

pev^ Kai 'ATrocTToXoi, npoaaycov rSt 0€oo Kai YlaTpi tov$ ireTci'

(TTevKOTag elg avrov, "^ia t^s virep vofxov Xarpiiag TeXti(hv eig

ayiaaixov. T; roivvv aayaXKeig, ^apKraTe, twv lepav 7r€pi/3o\ci)v

eKTrefXTrofJ.evwv, oia Talg Kara vofxov Svaiaig tjv ')(jpy}aiix,ay KaXovvrog 5

€ig ryjv hteKeiia tvttcov ^(oyjv, Kai elg akffiy\ tiKaKaaiv r^g oia

TTia-reag, ^YiXovort r^g elg "Kptarov, Kai TiapaTtSevrog r^g evayye-*

XiKi^S TtoXneiag t^v o^ov, eyKaXe^ig, etire [xot, tc3 vofxoOerrj rov

vofxov TVjv Xvatv, Kai ori [xy] raig t^tatg yjKoXovQyjaev evrokaigf

aWa vofxov Travrog eiieKetva Qeov ; ov yap rovg vofxovg of^ 1 o


eavTf fxakXov, aAX' ^fxiv opiadfxevog fxeSiari^ai Kara Katpovg,
e^ OTrep av eXoiro ra ^tarerayfxeva, Kat avacpepav etg (BeXrtova ;

Hv ovv Katpog rov TravaaaBai toc ev rinrotg, avo^eiyPyjvai ^e ra


'*
Kpetrrova, Ka/ yovv f<py] irov Qeog ^ia (fxov^g 'Haaiov, Kat
**
d(f)avia6^aerai vofxtfxa Xaov fxov" Yjpyyiaav yap rvjg veag evro- 15

Xyjg dva^e^etyfLevi^g, ^v ^i eavrov KeXaKyjKev yjfxh Tiog.

KE4>. se.

Ilept Tov dfiTTeXavos.

9 Tor ArioT loANNor ror XprsosroMor. Atto t^j "napa-

PoK^g ravryjg irokXa aivirrerat' rov Qeov tyiv irpovotav, t>Jv etg 20
avrovg yeyevyjfxevyiv dvwOev, ro e^ dpyyjg avrcov (povtKOv, ro fxyj^ev

irapaketcpQyjvat rwv y^Kovrcov eig eTrtfxeketav, ro Kai rwv irpocpyirciov

acpayevrwv, fxyf dvoXetcpO^vai avroiig, dXXa Kat tov viov Tref/.xpat,

Kai ryjg iraXaiag Kai veag eva Kat rov avrov eivat Qeov, ro fxeydka
avrov Tov Odvarov KaropOaaetv, ro Ty]v ea-)(drvjv dtKy]v rov arav- 25
pov Kai Tov rtfxyffxarog avrov virofxevetv, rav eOvcov t^v KXyjaiv,
Tcov \ov^ai(ov r^v eKTrrcoatV rvjv ^e diroty^ixiav, r^v irokXy^v avrov

fxaKpoQvfxiav <f)y]aiv.

Tor Arior KrpiAAor 'Aaeeanapeias. '


OAiyv evpyjaei rtg

Ty]v eirt ye roHg vtoig lapay]\ laropiav ev rovrotg, ag ev (Spay^eiso

avvevy]veyft.evy]v. 'AfxireXcov ydp 'lapay]X, (f>yjatv 6 xpaXfxui^og'


**
kfxirekov e^ Aiyvirrov fxery]pag," Kat rd e^yjg. Kat 6 'Haafag
** **
afxiteXm eyev^Qy}," (f>y]at, tc5 yjyairyifxevo}." Eari roivvv tovtov
XX. i6. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 145

<f)VT€va-a^ Qeo^' ovto^ aTre^-^ixrja-e yjiovovs iKavovgy Kalroi irhfipoH

ra Jravra, a'Jio\i[Ji.7raveTai &e twv ovrav ov^evog. Ilwf ovv aTre^v)-

fxyja-e ; /xeTa to ava\r](f)6^vai cv e/ ^ei vvpog KaTa^Se^rjKa^ eir/ to

opoi TO Siva, Afa^ t»?v appyjTOv fxopcfyrjv efjicpavi^ ^e^^i^XuKev avTolq'

aW 0)$- «aTa «ye tov tvhov tSov avBpwTtivoov TtpayfxaTm eoiKe v(ag S

aTrotyilxia fxaKpa to yeyevrjf/ievoVf ttX^v opaTai Tre<ppovTiKOt)i tov

'X<api0Vf Kat e/f vovv ej^wv afTo. Ov^etg yap yeyove &/a fxeaov
Katpoff Kaff ov ovK awecTeAXovTo Trapa tov ©eou trpoKJyfjTai tc

/fa/ ^iKaioi vovQeTovvTeif ot ^e yeyovaatv a7rei6eT$f Kai a.Ttft.aa-aV'-

Tes Tovg aTteaTaXfxevovi e^airea-TeiXav Kevovs' TOVTeaTiv, ov^ev lo

ej^ovTa? etTretv vnep avTtav ayaBov tco TTeirofxcpoTt ©et», Kat (prjaiv
**
'lepefxia^f i^ov to /J^/x-a tou Ki/j9/ou eyev^Brj avToHq eis ovet^iafxoVf
" ov fLVjv PovXvjQcoatv avTov *^
aKOvaatP
13 ToT AriOT IflANNOT TOT XPTSOSTOMOT. T/ eCTT^ TO " iVo-f
**
hnpaifriaovTat ;" oy)^ w^ ayvoovvTOif a\>^ QeXovTog ^et^ai to 15

afxapTyifxa fxeya Kat aiiokoyiag irdayjg eaTepyjfi.evoVf eiret avTog


e/dcof, OT/ avaipyjaovaiv eirefxypef Xeyet oe evTpairiiaovrai ro
yeveaGat 0(f)e7\ov aTrayyeXXwVf ort ^ei avrovg evTpair^vat^ eitet

Kat dXXar/pv (pyjaiVf


**
eav dpa aKOvaaaiv" ov^e €Ke7 dyvoS)v, dXX
iva fuiff Xeywat riveg twv dyvccfxovcoVf ort y] Trpoyvooatg avrov yeyo- 20
vev dvayKaariKy} rijg TrapaKOVjg, S/a ToyTO ovrco ayyjfxari^ei rag

Xe^eig. E/ yap Kot Ttept rovg tovXovg dyvwfxoveg eyevovrOf rov

vtov ro d^KOfxa ai^eaBvjvai ep(/3^v. Kat fxev AovKag (pyjaiVf ort

avrog dtre^pvp/aTOf ori TraQeh e%ei rovrovgf KaKeivot eiirav, " fxvj

" yevotrOf* Kai t»;v fxaprvptav eiryfyayev, ^e MaTfiarof ori avrot 25

T^v xp^(f)OV e^yjveyKav.

16 MeToc te ro dKovaai avrovg rviv toD dfxireXmog Trapa(3o}^v,


^ta rovro eliroVf ** fLrj yevoirOf^ eiretVlf] avvtevreg rm alviyfxdrav

ro /3d$ogf airoaetovrat ro iraBeh, he^otKoreg ro eaofxevov. AXX ovk


eart rovro evavrtoXoyiag' Kai yap dfxtporepa yeyove, Kai rrjv^o

iln^(f)Ov avTot e^yjvey Kav KaB^ eavroov, Kai irdXiv aiaOofxevoi rav
'*
eipyffxevaVf etnav fxyf yevotro" Kairot Kai rov irpo^f^yjTyjv eireretyt-

aev avroTg, vetOoov auTovf ort irdvrwg earat touto, dXX ofxwg ouS'

d oMT^ Ood.

u
146 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XX. 20.

ovrag ra edvyj aacpooi aTreKaKvrl/cVf wa^Te fxvj^efxiav avToTf Trapa-


a-)(€7v Xa0v)v, dkX rpi^aTO uitm, " Swo-ez tov dfATteXava aXXois.*'

17 A160V kavTOv KaXei, Kai oiKo^^ofxovg Toiig ^i^aaKaXovs twv


lov^^aicov, Kai, Je^e^iiyX (pvjaiv, " 01 oiKo^^OfJiovvTeg tov roTyov Kai
" d\€i(f>ovT€$ dvapTVTWi" Ilwf ^e dne^^oKifuaaav ; 0) Aeyovref, S

ovTog ovK ea-Tiv €K tov Qeov, ovTog iiXavS. Tovg oyXovg^ Kai oaa

ToiavTa' tvo Se ^vjaiv d^Trcckeiag IvTavBa twv lovBa/wv, fuiav fiev,

Ty]v dito Tov 7rpoaKO\pai Kai aKav^aXiaQvjvaif tovto yap ctt; rov

X160V rovTov, erepav ^e t>jv «Tro ryjg dXcoaeoog avrav Kai rvjg avfn.-

<J)opag Kai 'itavoKe^plag, ^v aa(f)cog e^^Acixrev eiTrav, " kiKfx^aei 10


**
avTovV Aia rovrcov Kat r^v dvdaraaiv i^vi^aro rvjv eavrov.

Ktpiaaot. 'EKav^a\ia6evT€g yap eiri Kpiarw Kai Trpoairrai-

aavreg avr^, rwv lov^^atcov 01 ^^ft,ot avverptlSifjaav. Ov yap Yj6eXov

aKovaat r^g 'Haaiov *'


cfycov^g Keyovavig, K.vptov avrov dyidaare,
" Kat avTog earai aot <f)oPog, Kai ovy wg \i6ov •jrpoaKOfJ.fJ.art 15
** avvavTYjaeae avrWf ofSe irerpag 7rTcofji.aTe."

ToT ATTOT. ¥i^eKav6v] irdXiv etg dyaXtvovg opyag ro rcov

^aptaaicov epyaarvjptov, Kat diroKreTvat jSovkevovrat rov eirt Xvaet

^avdrov y€vofji.evov dv6pco7rov, dXXa "^ieKoipev avrcov ro dvoaiov

ey/eipyjfj.a Xaov (fio(3og. Oii yap r^g €ig Seov evae^etag ^v2o
avrotg Xoyog, ov^e yeyovev avrotg yakivog v} ^ta yicoijaecog evroXv}

XeyovaUy *'
d6mv Kat ^iKatov ovk diroKrevetg'" Trportfj.coat oe fJMk-

Xov Tvjg eig Qeov ai^ovg rov dv^pcovrtvov <f>oPov.

ToT ATTOT. KaiTOt ircbg ov fxaXXov eyp^v fX€fJ.a6'^K0Tag ro

eaofxevov e^co (f)epea6at rov KaKOv, Kat Ttfxvjaat rvj Triaret tov 25

Kaiovvra rov dae^vj, Kat dfj.vv)atKdKco ydpirt ttaac)iC,ovTa rovg raig

dfJ.apTiaig eviayvjfxevovg ; dXX^ ov^ev rcov rotovrcov vmXeXoytafJ.evotf

avKO(f>avTtag rvjg Kar avrov avXXeyovatv a^opfxag.

K.m. o.

Tltpi t5>v eyicaOerav 8ia rov ktjvctov. oq

20 ^g av6pcoTrcp Trpoatevrai KOtvSa rco "jrdvTcov "^cor^pt ^ptarVy >

aXX i^v dfxetvov evvoeiVj ort yeyove fxev ev ofj.otcoa€t rvj irpog

vjfj.ag Qeog wv 6 Aoyog. 'Atto M ye rvjg virep Xoyov 6eoav]fX€tag


5

XX. 37- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 147

Kcu ajToSe/fefWf r^f OeoTrpeTrovi ovk avdpcovos wv [xovov ^ieQeiKvvro,


aXXot Kou Qeof. HOeke /u,€y yap 6 rZv oXwv 6eo? avdpamivvjs
tvvaoTeiag eXevSepov eivat tov ^lcxpa-^X. Ejre/^»; te rovf Oeiov^

TreTiarYjKaai vofjt.ov^f yeyovaaiv \mo y/ipoi- tcov ri^viKa^e KeKparyj-

Korav, Kai '^eafxovs e7re6r]Kav avroTf. e^^^rovv roivvv, <f>vja-i, Ttapa-^


tovvai avrov rvj apyri rov ^efxovos. Tlpoae^^OKfjaav yap ori

vdvryj re Ka) itdvrug aKovffovrat Xeyovrogy ovk e^ecrt dovvat

(popovs Kai<7api' «AA' " e^jr/Se/^are /jio/," ^^jo"/, " ^vjvdpiovJ'^ Eirt-

tetypevroq de, itaXiv eipero^ '


rtvoi eyei eiKova Kai eTrtypa^pyjV ; oi

te Kaia-apogf <paa)v, Kai ri Trpoq ravra \ptarof ;


** diro^ore raio
" Kataapog Kaiaapi, Koi ra rov Qeov tco 0€o5," 'xpyifx.drav fjt.ev

yap ^eafxovg hrtppiirrovat ro7i vTre^evyiM.voig, oi rvjv Kar avrwv


Xaypvrei dpyyjv, ^yjreT ^c rirap' 7}[j.cov Kat dydirvjVf Kat ryjv ef

epyav dyaBav evKoafxiav. Ovkovv re6avft.aKa fxev rvjv diroXoytav

avroVf Kat rovro eTr) Travrog rov \aov, oi ^e Kat rovrwv eig k^Si^v 1

evrjveyfJi.evotf UtXdrw Trpoa-tjyov rov li^aovv (pdaKovreg, " rovrov


**
ivpafxev ^taarpe(f>ovra rov \aov Kat KooXvovra <popovg ^i^ovai
**
KaiaaptJ'^ Kat ofxag Qavfmaavreg r^v diroXoyiav dir^Xdov

Karriayyfj.fj.evot.

OpirENOTS. Kyevero ev dpyyj dvBpaiTrog, wg ev ryj Teveaet 20

yeypairrat, Kar eiKova 0eov, varepov ^e irapa t^v afTov irapa-

Koyjv aveka^e Kat yotKyjv' wavrep yap ro vofi.tafj.a etKOva eyet rov

/SaatXevQvrog twv eflvoJv, ovrcog ^ irotav ra epya rov Koafj.oKpdro-

pos ryjfv etKova avrov (popet, yjv •jrapatveT 6 "Eiooryip dTro^i^ovat Kat
airortOeaBat Kai (popeiv t^v e^ dpyyjg yevofi-evyjv etKova Ka6 6[j.ot- 25
(oatv rS) 0€o5. AKoXovQag rovrotg Kat 6 YlavXog (pyjatv, " cog

" e<f>opeaafj.ev t^v eiKova rov yoiKov, ovra (popea<ofj.ev Kat ryjv

" etKova rov eirovpavtovJ^ Tovto ovv '^yjXoT " airo^ore ra Kataa-
" pos Kataaptf KCti ra rov 0€ou tw Oeci5."

KE$. OA. 30

ITcpt tS)V 'SabdtyvKolav.

zy Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias. Ylpoaiaat "^o^tovKaht toj wavTOJv

yjfjJav Yidiryjpt 'Kpiarw, og eari ^onj Kai dvdaraatgf kou dvatpeh

d o2to? Cod.

u %
^

148 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XX. 37.


ireipmTai tvjv avacTTaaiv. 'T/3pi(XTai Se ovt€$ Kat airicTTot ithaT-

Tovcri Ti (xeaTOV a[Ji.aQia$. l^ufjiev ^e airep e(f)yj avToT^ ^pi<TTog,


**
O/ jtAev <yap vioi, '
^^c;, " tov aiavos tovtov yafxovai kou yafJii-

govTaif Kai Ta e^rjg.

TOT ATTOT. Oi VlOt TOV VVfJI.(f)aVOij T0VTe(7TtV, 01 TOV KO^TfJit-

Kov Kai €v<Tco[JLaTOV Kai <f)tXo<ro(f>tag yifxovTa ^ta^civTes Piov, TeKvo-


yoviag eveKa yafj.ovcrt Kat yafxi^ovTat' ot ye (/.tjv tv)v evKXea kou
ayaGov fj.eaTrjv KaTopBaaavTeg ^«^v, eha KaTa^tQ}6evTe$ iv^eTv

T^f evTtfxov avaaTaaecog, avco irov navTcag eaovTat T^g ev rco^e tc5

K0(rfi.ca ^oi^g. Aia^tcoaovTat yap cog av aytotg irpeTT'/] Kat eyyvg lo


'i^O'/] yeyovaat %eov' t(7ayyeXot yap eia) Kat viot Seov, tvjv ayiotg

TtpeTTOvcrav TeXovvTeg XaTpetav. Ylapyjyaye te avToTg Kat Mwi/Vea


ev et^OTa (ja(pwg twv veKpSiv t^v avd(XTa(7tv. 'Ev yap Trj jSaToo,

^y <f)v]atVf el(TKeKOfx.tKe XeyovTa SeoV " eya elfxt o Seog 'A/Spaaju.

" Kai 'laaaK Kat 6 @eos 'IaAfa)/3'" t/vwv Se Qeog, ei ju.^ ^vjaov- 15

Tat KaT eKetvovg; dXX eoTt ^«VTcyv Seog. Ovkovv TrdvTYj tc Kat

irdvTcog dva^toiaovxaty Trjg iravaQeveaTdTTjg ^e^tag dirocf^epovaifjg etg

TOVTO aTravTag Tovg eK T^g y^g.

Qyj^/ Twv ovK ovTcav KaOaTra^ d(pavta6evTCov, Kat ovk€ti dva-

^rjaofj.evcov eivat (f^rjai Qeov tov ©eov, ov yap rjf/i^^v, aW €ifj.t 20

Twv ovTCov Kat ^mxcov. Q.aTrep yap 6 'A^aft., ei Kat 'e^r] t^ "^fJi-^p^ j]

'€(f)ayev diro tov ^vAou, dire6av€ Trj airo^fidaety ovtco Kat ovTOt, et

Kat €T€6v^KeaaVf 'e^oov TJj viroayeaet Trjg dvaaxdaecog. Ucog ovv

(f)y]aiv akXayovy " tva Kat veKpcov Kat ^covjcov Kvptevarj ; aXX ovK

'eaxt TovTO 'iaov, eK veKpcov yap €VTav6a (prjat tc5v Kat avTcov ^r]-^^

aea6at fi.€XXovTcov.

OpirENHS Se <f)r]atv, AvaytvcoaKovTeg Ttveg Ta 7rpo(f)r]TtKa

TrXavmxat irept tov vovv T^g ypa(f)yjg, <f>ep€ etTreTv €K tov llaatov,
" 'eKXeKTot fj.ov ov TeKvoiroi-^aovatv etg KaTapav^ Kat ev tw Aev-
Tepovofk.i(o
*'
ev TaTg evXoyiatg evXoyrjfxeva Ta eKyova Tr]g KotXtag 30
" crou," vTroXaf>.(3dvovTeg ev Tr] avaaTdaet twv veKpcov eaea^at

TavTa, fj.y]
voovvTeg Tag irvevfi.aTtKag evXoytag. Ata tovto, acofJ.a-

TtKag eK^eyofj.evotg ToTg Ik twv Yov^atcov YiO^^ovKaiotg, eXeyev

YicaTTjp, " TrXavaa6e fxr] et^OTeg Tag ypa^pdgT


XXI. I. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 149

KE^. OB.
Hfpi TTJs rov Kvpiov firepuyrTjcrfas irpog Toiis 9api(raiovs.

46 ToT Arior Titot Bostpcn. Tayra roTs fxa6y]Ta7i ekeye,

yoe/av evova^t r^f TOiavTVji Trapaiveaecog. EiireiO'/) yap OiOaaKa-


Xot r^i oiKovfJi€vy]i irpoeyetpi^ovTO, ^i^da-Kei avTovg^ fxrj ixifJLfTaOai
^
Toyf Tra^a 'lou^a/o/f ^i^^a^TKakovg. KKeTvoi yap KaTeaBiovci rag
oiKiag Tww y^p^fi ^i^daKovTeg vvjaTeveiv Kat ^eiKVvovrei yaa-Tpt-

[jioipyiav, ov 'jrpoTaTdfxevot yripuiv, dkXa Ta tovtuv ava\i(7K0VTeg'

" ovTOi X-^ovTat, <f>yj<Tt, irepta-aoTepov Kpifxa," ort §>? ^/^a«7/fa-

^.tKOv eyovTeg ayvjfJM, itpoayfoyot Tvyydvovatv etq KaKiav. 10

KE*. or.
tlfpi TTjs Ta /3' XeTTTa.

I Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias. E0>? irov 6 SwTiyp, " fxaKaptot ol

** TovTOvg enovrevet irpoacpepov-


eXe-^fxoveg, OTt avTot eXeyjSvjaovTatj'^

Tug ra ^Sopa avrwv etg ro ya^o(f>v\dKtov, aXX wg eK vXovrov woAAov 15

voXXa fJLev yjaav eiKog ra irap eKaarov Kapiio<f>opovfxeva' o\tya


Se 'sdXtv Kat T^f rwv TrpoaKOfxi^ovraiv dva^ia %etpog' elra fxer

eKetvovg yvvatov Ttrtayeta 'hetirj] Kar tayyifxevov ei(Te6vi ® c| epdvov

fjioXtg Kat aiiv i^poort (XvXXeyov evrekeardTyjv Kat airoyjiSiaav

^*
yjfJiepa ttarpocf^^v eira Svo •npo^ryjyev o{3oXovg, (oairep airoAO"»- 20

fxevyj rov /Stov. O irapa^o^ov irpdyfxarog' yi rov irap erepov ekeov

^yjTovaa ^ti^veKag, avryj ^avei^et Sew, KapTTOcpopov avrSi Kat avryjv

d-nocf^aivovaa rvjv itToyyyiv' vtKa rotyapovv rovg akkovg, Kat hKata


il^cfxo are<f>avovTat Ttapa Oeaj.

T/vo? &>eKev yj %evtyjpa yjipa rovg irXovatovg evtKVjae, rovg 2^

ra ^apa avrZv eig ro ya^o(f>v\dKtov irpoa^pepovrag, Kat ^tKattx

4^(f>!p
are^pavovrat 'irapa rov Qeov ; ^ta ro rovg fxev €K 'TrXovrov

TToWov oXiya jrpoaKOfxi^etv Kat dvd^ta r^g eavrav yetpog, et Kat

•JToXXa ^v eiKog avrovg wg irXovaiovg Trpoa<f>epetv kcu Kap-Tro^f^o-

peTv, T^v Se OTrep e^ epdvov fxoXtg Kat ^piorog evTcXef aw^aye, ^o


* €«< €6(t Cod. ' hta Tfatprfyi Cod.
150 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XXI. 5.

TovT€(TTi Ovo o^okov<,f TovTO TipotTayayfi' Kai yap coaTrep aTroKTto-


[X€vr} Tov Piov oKov eavT^^, fJLeyaXo^pv^xcos navTa Trpodrjjaye.

KE*. OA.
Hepi TTjs orvvreXeias.

c EiTre^eiKvvov Tiveg tc3 X.pK7TS Tas ev tw vaw fjieyakovpyias 5

Kai Tov Tuv avaG7j[j.aTC0v ko(TIJlov' wrjdyjaav yap^ oti Bavfxdaet cyvv

avToTi Ta opcoixeva, KaiToi 0eof av Kai Opovov €')(cov tov ovpavov.

'O ^e d(f)iv]ai [j.€V tov irepi avTcav koyoVf Trpofxefj^-^vvKe ^e oti ck

/3d6pcov irecTehai KaTa Kaipovg, KaTaKOfj.i^ovaYif eU tovto avTO

T^S 'Poofxaicov (TTpaTeiag, Kai airacxav tvjv 'lepovcraXyjfx tvjv t^j-io


KvpioKTOViag ^iKag e^aiTOvav]^ tov lapav]\, fieTo, ydpTot tov tov

"EcoTy^pos CTavpov TavTa avve(3v] TiaBeh avTovg' 01 ^e ov awi"


aTavTo Tcov opcofievcov tvjv ^vvafj.iVf avjdvjaav fj.aXXov Tovg "ffept

TVfi aveTeXetag tov alcovos Koyovg e^v(f>aivetv avTOv. ^'tpovTO S»;

ovv ivoTe TovTa eaovTat, Kat Tt to avjfj.ehv OTav fj.e\Xv] ytveaQat. 15

T/ ovv yiptaTog ; e7reTa< tco aKonw tcov irpoaayovTCov tv^v Trev-

atv, Koi (f>v]at ff-ev Tecog tov$ iiept TV]g dXcoaecog tcov 'lepoaoXvfj.cav

Xoyovg, ^taTpavoi ^e Tovg itepi t^$ avvTeXetag tov napovTog


atcovog. Ylpiv yap tv]v e^ ovpavov yeveaQat KdBo^ov tov TtdvTCov

v]fJ.cov "ZcoT^pog HptaTOVf Trpo^pofJiot Tiveg ava(f)atvovTat xpev^o-^^pt- 20


aTOt Kat xpevdo7Tpo(f>^Tai, to avTov TtpoacoTiov eavToTg TreptirXdT'

TOVT€f, dXXd fM] dKoKovBYjav]Te, <f>v]atv, avTOtg.

ToT ArioT TiTOT BosTPCN. ** Otav ^e dKovavjTe" wg ydp


<f)rjat YcoavjTntog, irpoeXa^ov •noXefJ.toi, avTapavTog tov €$vovg, kou

fi.v] '^i'^ovTog Tovg avvv]6etg (f>opovg Pcofj.aiotg, Kai fj.eTpicog aeo(ppo- 25

vtaOevTeg, Kat dveaecog TVXovTeg, TidXiv evecoTept^ov, kou ndXtv

eyiyveTO iroXefxog, Kat ovteiiOTe vjavyjav y]avaaavTo' TeXevTaiov

Oeaadfj.evot Vcofiaht ty]v tovtcov aiiovotav, KaTeXvaav t^v iroXiv.

ToT ATTOT. Teypair-rat ev Talg Tlpd^eatv, OTt fj.eTd tv]v dvd-


aTaatv eyeveTO Xtfj.og fJ.eyoi.g e-at KXavVtov Kaiaapog, kcu a€ta[j.ot3°
iroXXot eyevoVTO.

9 Ktpiaaot 'Aaesanapeias. Aidcoai avjfj.e7a aacfjvj Te kcu


evapyv] T^f crvvTeAe/af tov Koafj.ov' 7rdXe[J.oi ydp eaovTat, e^fyf].
XXI. 9- AOTKAN EYArrEAIOT. 151

Kai aKara(na(Tiaiy Kai ra el^f . Kai €Tepo$ ^yjcriv Eva-yyeA/o-r^f,

•JTavTa ra acjrpa 'Trca-eTraii elXfxP-^crerai 6 ovpavos c5f /3il3\iov

Kat ra f|^?. Ata fjieaov ^e ri$^(7i Kat vept rrji rwv 'lepoaoXv-

[jLcov aXuxyetag. ^^Kepaae yap rov koyov rovrov KaKeivcp to/V ^tyj-

y^fji.a(Tt. Ylpo yap rovrcov Trdvrcov (pi^a^tv " e7ril3a\ov(Ti e(f> vfxasS
**
Tocf yeipas avrcov, Kat ^/w^ovo"/" Kai ra e^y}?' vpo yap raiv rvjg

cwreXeiag Kaipcov ^Xo) ^aev rj rav lov^aiwv X(>}pa, KaraQpa[ji.ovai^s

avryjv rvjs 'Pccfxaiccv (rrparetag, efJiTieTrpvjarat Se o «ewf, Kare-

(TeiaQyj Ta •aap' avroTg ^aaiXetay ireTravrat ryjg Kara vofxov

Xarpeiag oy tvvafjt.tg' iip^v ^e TayTa (xvfx^yivai e^ici}-)(6y]aav itap lO

ayTwv oi fxaKoipiot fxaB-^rat, '^eafj.carat yeyovacrt, yiy^Qyjcjav eit

ap^^ovras, e7reft.(f>6yicrav eirt I3aatkeag' aire^xrdXy] yovv 6 TlavXog

etg P«jU.>jv Ttpog Kaicrapa' ttAi^v yeyovev avroig etg fxaprvptov,

rovreartv eig fj.aprvpiov ^o^av ra eirevyiveyfj.eva' 'ttapeyyva Se ort


" fj)fi Ttpofj.eXerare fj.eXKovreg aitoXoyelcy^at, X-^xpe^rQe yap Trap efxov 15

" <ro<f)tav yj yXZa^rav,'^ ov ^vv^crovrat avrtaryjvat yjavretTre7v,aTiavreg


**
01 avrtKetfj.evot vfj.h^^ aiioKetpcov ^e t^? avOpciyTrtvyjg fji.tKpo\pv')(^tag

rag d(f)opfxag, '7rapci^oByj(TecrGat, (f>y](Tiv, avrovg viro d^eX(f>m Kat

<f)i\ci)v Kat rav eK yevovg, 7rAr?v ort irdvryj re Kat irdvrcag crajfl^-

(Tovrai irap avrov' 6pt^ yap eK r^g Ke<f)a\^g vfAccv ovk azoXeirat, 20

(fyi/jai' <Ta(f)earepav ^e t>;v Ttpoayopevatv irotcov, " OTav, t^yjre, (f^yjai,

" KVKXovfxevyp viro arparoiretcav ryjv lepovaakyjfj.' rore yvcHre ort


« riyyiKev yj ep-^fxcoatg avr^g" Ktra fxe&taryjat irdktv rovg Xoyovg

evt rov r^g avvreXeiag Katpov.

ToT ATTOT. "A yap ecapdKare hr efxot ytvofxeva, '7rpoa^oK'^aare 25


Kat e(f) vfxTv eaeaBat.

TiTor. Ylotov Se fxaprvptov ; ort ro t^tov vpjt^aro KaropOcofxa

rov KyjpCyfxarog' orav ydp rtg ^tafxaprvpyjrat ro (3eXrtov, Kat ro

Kaff eavTOv irotyiayi irappyjataadfxevog, aTro^-^ayjrai vfxh etg fxap-

rvptov, ori ryjv evae^etav aTryjyyetXare. 3°


Ta Se cTejja toutwv "Trept re Toy lepov Kat Trept ryjg avvreXetag,

ecog " ot de Xoyot ov fxrf TrapeXQaat,^* irpoeypd^py] eig ro Kara

"MarQaiov, Kat eKei ^"^ret.

Ktpiaaot Aaesanapeias. Ap^^^pfxevrig yap ooairep r^g Kpi"


aecog evaXdrreaOat, avvoyyj rig earat tetvlq, Kat a^Troxpv^tg etgSS
152 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XXI. 29.

Bavarov. To yap tcov hrepypiKivm a(f)op7)Tov ^eTyfxa iroXXoii ap-

K€a-€i 'npog oXeSpov' ov AeAvjfioTCijf, aXX wg 0€O? Kat Kvpios cv

^o^vj OeoTtpeTrei, Ka) itavTa jOteTao-Tija-e; npo^; to a(Ji.€ivov.

'Ava/StuaovTai yap ot veKpot Kat aiiotvcxovTai ti]v (f)6opaVf to

€K yy\q TovTO Koi evaXcoTov a^fxa, evtvaovTai ^ Oe ttjv a<p6ap<7taVy 5


l^pta-Tov ve/xovTOf avTvjVf Kai a-vfjL[ji.op(f)ov$ tov awiJ.aTOS t^s Qo^ifjs

avTOv Tovf €/f avTOv TttaTeva^avTag airo^a/voyTOC.


E/Vwv ^e Tyjg avK^i tvjv 7rapaj3oXy]v, eiir\yayev oti eyyvg eaTtv

2917 (3aaiXeia tou OeotJ, oiiep MaT^aro^ " yivaa-KeTe oti


^""l^^h

eyyvg eCTiv eirt 6vpatg. lo de TotovTO otbaaKet, OTt ovira} Tipog 10

TO eo^aTov TeAof fiKei Ta irpayixaTa tovtccv ytvofJLevcov, aXA'

o^evei irpog to tcAo? ^^17, KaQaTrep ent twv Kapitav^ o^evet vj avKrj

Toi/f Kka^ovg, a^naXwofJt.evv} Kat eK<f>vovaa Ta (f>vXXa. Ovtco yap


hv] Kai 7] Tov Kvptov TTapovata, KaTapyovaa iraaav apyviv Kat e^ov-

ciav, vapaaKevai^et tjj /SaatXeia tov Seov. 15

Feveaj', (f^rjo-tv ov Tovf tot€ dvSpcoTrovg, aXXa Tovg ofJiOtovg tw


Tpoir^. Ol^e yap kou ovtcos KaXeTv yeveav, ug to " avTV] yevea
*'
^r}TovvT(ov Tov Kvpiov."

TovTO Kai Tvjv Tcov aTotyeiccv avvTeXeiav ^^v} Tvpoayopevet afux

€» To5 Xiyeiv, oti d^vvaTOv Tovg Xoyovg fi.ov itapeXQeh, KatTot Kai 20

T«v a^TOiyetcov 'napepypfj.evctiv.

E/TTWV irepi T^f avvTeXeiag, koi OTt nd.VTCog vj^et vj rjfJt.epa, Kat

OTi TOVTa yev^aeTat, koi ovk ey/capel fxyj yeveaOat aTtep etTte,

itpoaBeig e<f>i^,
" itpoaey^Te eavTolq fi.y] itoTe ^apyfi^aiv vff.ctiv 01

**
0(f)6aXfJi.ot,*' oyp^ 01 a-cofj.aTtKot, dXX 01 T^f ^tavotag. Meptfxva yap 25
f3tcoTiKav Kai KpatitdXyi Kat fj.e6yj e^opt^ei fx.ev ttjv avveaiv'

a(f)opi^et ^e Kat tvjv TttaTtv, efJ.j3dXXet Se elg Xyj6yjv tSov avfuf>e-

povTCov. Ato "TtoXXyjg dypvitviaq ^(jpeia, fji.vyjfj.Yig Te Kat evXa^eiag


Kai a^vveaeag, iva npoaevypfj.evoi tta TtavTog, Tag Ttpeitovaa^; vyj-

(TTetag •npoa^fjepcafj.ev tw 0ew. 30


Li oe y]v aitep eotbaaKev ev tco tepco ; itavTCog ttov Ta imep
^y vofJLiKVjv XaTpetav fj;,e6iaTcav fj.eT e^ova-iag Ta ev TVTtco Key^jpy^afxco-

^y]fj.eva Ttpog t*;v dXy]6etav. Aionep Kai 6avfj.d^cov Xaog, oti ev


e^ovaia y]v Xoyog avTov, yj^ta-Ta tovtov y]KpoaTo. E/f to o^of he
S evSvVijTa* Cod.
5

XXII. 7. AOYKAN ETAITEAIOY. 153

TcSv €\ouuv y]vKi^€TO Tovf ev rjj vo\€t Oopv^ovg vapaiTovfMvoff

tva Kat ev tovto) tvttos rjfxTv yevyjTai,

llep/ Tyji €opTr)g Tav agvfxcov oti yfyy^b^i '^^' ^"^^ e^-^ovv oi

ap^^f^iepeTg aveXeiv avTOV, Kat OTt eia^XGev 6 Saravaf eig tov

lov^av, Kai OTt crvv€(f)iovyj(T€ tov •napo^ovvat avTOv, KOt OTt e^iyre/ 5
€Trt TovTo €VKatpiav, eag " Kat 01 ^u^eKa AitoctoXoi cxiiv ayrco,"

vpoeypa^fyy] etg to KaTa MaT^arov,

KE$. OE.
Ilfpi Tov Ild<rxa.

7 TiTOT BosTpaN. ^iayj\$€ toivvv "EaTavag €ig avTOv, ovTa ovk 10


€K Tftjv tp aW €K Tov apt6[xov, dpt6fj.ov dveTrX^^pov, ovk diroaToXtKOv

d^taixa €K€KTy}TO. 'HA^e Se ^ yjfxcpa tcov d^vfnov, ^i


€^€t 6v€(x6at

TO Hda^xaf <pdaKa 6 Tyjg hpTvjg Katpog wvojaa^eTO* ^i^XoT ^e ^td-


(3aatg. Clairep yap r^g AlyvnTiav ^ovXeiag 6 'lapayiX dTryjk-

AaTTCTO €ig t^v Tyjg eirayyeXtag ep^ofxevog y^v, ^ta 6aXdaay]g 1

fjieayjg I3a^i^a)v d^poyja ttoS/, oyTco Kat y]ft.ag ^eT Ka6d7rep t»;v

fiaAaTTav ^iaTrepaiova6at veavtKag tov eiKaTov tov •napovTog ^iov

ireptaTraaft.ov' '^ta^aivoft.ev ye fx.ev €k (f)tXoaapKiag etg eyKpoTetav,

cf ayvwatag Tojf irdXat etg 6eoyv(oaiav T^yv TrdXat aA>j5^, €K

6avdTov etg d(f>6apaiav. Ep^o^aev Totvvv Ttff.S)aav evt Tovg rvirovg 20

T^v aXy]6€tav. eX^ovayjg yap <f>y]at, T^g yjfnepag, Ka6 ^v e^e^

6vea6at to Tldaya, ^vo Ttvag dTroXey^yjv tcov dytav 'A^TroaToXoov,

vfaav ^e WeTpog Kat lcodvv^g, Trenof/.^pev ev t^ iroXet, einm ai/Totg

Ta yeypafx.fk.eva' KatTOt Tt tyftroTe ov tov dv6pomov evapyxg /caTO-


fji.€fj.y]vvK€ To7g dveaTaXfi.evotg ; Ov ydp ecpyj irpog tov ^e^va tv^^ov, 25
aAAa ay]fj.e7ov OeoaKev dv6p(iyirov dirXSog K€pdf*.a) v^arog 7re<pop-
TtafLevov. T/ ovv irpog tovto <f)afj.€v ; ijJ^ To7g lov^^atotg vno-
aypfj.evog yjv Trpo^OTyjg irapo^iaetv avTov. ' Iva rotvw fj.y]
fi.d6r]

Tov av6pi}-7rov, Kai ^paficbv dirayyeiXy] To7g f).ia6(aaafj.€voig, tidcoai

ay]fj.e7ov. Et/ yap virerrXaTTeTO T^yv ft.a6y]Ta7g evvotav eyetv, ft.tai- ^o


<f)oviav u)^ivav. " wravT-^aet ydp vfj.7v,^^ ^'?o-'> " dv6pwTrog KepdfAtov
*'
v^^aTog /3a(7Ta^cyv." ^ Td-)(a irov kou fj.vaTtKov Tt Kai dvayKOLiov

ota rovTov ^yjXiiv' €v6a ydp av elaeX^v] ro v^wp, tyjXov Se ort to tou

X
154 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XXII. 14.

ayioy fSaTrTKXfJiaTo^, (kci KaTakvei HpKTTog. Ylavxog yap vjfj^ag

aTraXXaTTei pvTrou, Kai vaov v]fJi.oi$ ayiov yevea-Qai ©eov, Kai T^f

Bfiag avTOv (ftvaecos lioivmovg, tia ^/.fToyrjg tov Ayiov YlvevfJiaTog'

ovK av tf. a[j.apTOi Tig TaXrfiovg, Kai avayKoiov elvat keym tvjv

TravTog dyiov ^v^^t/V. KavyaaQa yap, fpV^h ^ a^e\(f)og Tairei-S

vlg ev TcS vypei avrov. eToifndaaai ^e to YLdaya To7g ixaQyiTaig

14 avveiaTiaTO li.piaTogf dve^iKaKoig too irpo^oTV} (f>daKoov, " €Tn6vfj.ia

" e7reSv[xaaa tovto tq Ylday^a (payeh fj.e6 vfj.S)v." Ti ^r) apa (f)vjaiv

6 EwT^p ; ovKovv ag tjSt; irpoetTTOv, Kaipov e^-^Tei t^? Tipo^oaiag 6

ipiXdpyvpog fxaSvjT-^g' iva ^e fxv] irpo t^j- toD dyiov Ylda^^^a Totg 10

<f)ovovaiv avTOV Trapa^x, ov '^iafJ.eft.YjVVKev Ec(?T>?p, vj tov oIkov yj

Tov avOpcoTioVf Tiap co to Yidaya TTeTTXvjpooKev. Anotibovg TOiya-


povv TV]v aiTiav tov fxvj OeXvjaai aa(f>ag enreiv tov •nap w KaTe-
Xvaev, '*
e7n6vff.ia,^^ (f>vjaiv,
'^
e7re6vff.vjaa tovto to Tldaya cf>ayeh
" ft.e& vfX(ov" ofkotov waei Xeyoi, naaav edefxvjv airov^^vjv, oirccg av 15
layvaa Ka6eh tvjv tov Ttpoka^ovTog dvoatOTVjTa, tva fxvj Trpoapov

VTTOfxetvct) TQ Ttd^og. TTkvjv ov fiL^ (f)dy!t) TO Tldaya tovto, e(og ov

7tXvjpo}6ri ev t^ PaatXeta tov Qeov. K6og he avT^ f3aatXetav


ovpavav ovofxdi^etv Trjv ev TttaTei ^tKatwatVy tvjv ^ta tov dytov

f3avTtau.aTog KX^atv, Kat Trjv tov dyiov ^aiiTtafxaTog fxe6e^tv, 20

Kat Tvjg ev iivevfxaTt XaTpetag tyiv tvvafxtv ovkovv ovk oxpofi.aty

(prjatv TotovTov Yldaya, tow tta 'M.coaecog trjXovoTi '^rjXovft.evov

TVTiiKag, etag ov TrXrjpxSy] ev tyj l3aatXeta Toy Seov' TOVTeaTtv,

dva^ety6evTog tov Katpov, Ka& ov rj fSaatXeia tcov ovpavSov efx(f>a-

vt^eTai' irXvjpovTai yap ev rjfi.h Totg Trjv vnep vofLov Ttfnooat ^td- 25

Paaiv rJacrj^a to aXv]6tvQv' Kat ovk e^ dyeXrjg dfxvog dytd^ei


Tovg ev ^ptaTw' avTog Ve fxdXXov dytcag lepovpyovfxevog ^id Trjg

fxvaTiKr}g evXoytag, Ka6 rjv evXoyovfxeda Kai ^coo7rotovfxe6a. Ve-


yove ydp vjfxh dpTog ^wv e^ ovpavov KaTa^dg, Kat ^(arjv tt^^ovg

To5 Koafxw. 30
Tox Xptsostomot. KavTCvflev ^^Aov, OTt ovk riv avToo oiKia.

Eycb §€ oifxai, fx^^e Toi/g fxadrjTag avTOv eyetV rj ydp aiiTOV

eKei •napeKdXeaav eX6eiv. Ttvog ^e ev(Ka to Yldaya heXet ; "^id

navTcov OetKvvg fJ-iyjpt Trjg eayaTrjg rjfxepag, oti ovk eaTtv evavTiog
T» vo|aou. Kat t/ ^^Ta Tipog dyvioTa TrefXTrei dv6pa)'jrov ; AetKvvg3S
XXII. i6. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 155

Kavrevdiv oti rjdvvaro fjivi iraGeTv. 'O yap tyjv ^tdvoiav tovtov

"TTeiaai, aore avTov^ vTro^e^aaBai^ ti ovk av elpydaaTO (v toT^;

(TTavpoxx^iv avTOVf ei ye e(3ovkeTo /x.*? iiaOeTv ; Kit enei^y^ yjyvoeiy

Kai aif]fJieTov avToT^ ^i^aaiv, oiov eiri tov Sai/A o 'tpo<priTrig Xeyei'

"**
evprjaeig Tiva dvaPaivovTa Kai aoKov eyovTa,^^ Kai evTavBa, 5

Kepafxicv (SaoTTd^ovTa' 7rpoaTi$^ai ^e " {xeTa Ta;v f/.aGYjTa)v ixov"

fxeTa TO dpKovaav yeveadai t>jv iiapaaKevvjVf Kat eKeivov fxv] vofxt'

aai KpvvTeaOai avTOV. Tlug Se el to Tlda^^a YjaOtov, irapavoft.aig

^a$tov ; ov yap dvaKetfxevovg ^ei" (payetv, Ti ovv eaTiv efnreiv ;

ciTi fxeTa TO (payeh aveKeivTo kofnov eaTicofievoi. to

15 E/Vwv OTi **
eTttBvfLia e7re6vft.vjaa tovto to Wdaya (payeTv
** ^ia tovtov, oti ovk
fxeS vfiav TTpo tov fxe iraBeHv^^ earjfxave

aKwv Ttapayeyovev em to TrdBog, aWa fxeTa TroAX^f eiri6vff.iag

oocTe Traflen/ v^o tov Koafxov' ovk eaBiei oe avTO fxeTa twv lov-

^atcov, aAAa aeToc twv fKaSi^T^v avTov fxov'j>v, eiiett-^Tiep eKeivoi 15

dvd^ioi v]aav tovtov ha tvjv eTrifXovov dTtiaTiav. Ylepi tov eiiretv

avTOV OTi ovKeTi ov ft-rj (payco e? avTov, ea>$" ovai tx avOpwTrx


eKeivx Oi ov TrapaOtOOTat, Kat oti (piXoveiKia eyeveTO ev avTotg

TO Tti at/TaJv ^OKei eivai f«.et^'j}v eooi *' ^tdKovo^;,^^ Trpoeypdcpyj.

loANNor TOT Xptsostomot. E<f TO eTitBvfLta eTreQvfxvjaay 20


TOVTeaTi irapa^ovvat vfxTv to. Katva irpdyfxaTaf Kat Yldaya ^oyva;
Kaff '0
/xeAAco TrvevfxaTiKovg iroteh.

\6 Ktpiaaot Aaesanapeias. 'Ev t^ eU to KaTo. MaTfiarov


'*
EvayyeKiov ovTca KeiTaif ov fxvj tt/iw dirdpTi Ik tovtov tov
**
yevrjfxaTog irjg dfxnekov ecog T^f vffxepai eKeivri;, otov avTO irico 25
**
fxeff vfxSov Katvov ev t^ 0aat\eia tov UaTpoi fxov^
Ylpog TavTa airoKpiveTat '^evrjpog eirtaKoirog AvTtoyetag Ttpog

AeovTtov Ttpea^vTepov ypdcpcov ovtw. '*


ToiJto ^/ttA^v t>jv dirotoatv
**
ey^ei Kat tvjv e^vjyrjatv. O ^ev yap dytmaTog Tr]g Kwv(7TavT/voy-
** 'iroXecog eTttaKOTtog \'jodvvr]g eKeivvjv Katvv]v itoaiv tov iroTvjptov 30
'*
(f>vjaiv, vjv fxera tv]v eK veKpoiy dvdaTaatv eiriev fxeta tojv fxa9r]T(ov
**
aiiTov, TOv vaov toD awfxaTog toD dvaaTavTog 7rtaTovfi.evcg, Kat to
*'
T^g (ptXo^o^iag dvoatov e^oaTpaKi^cov ^o^dpiov. 'laToprjTat yap
" BeoTreaiog YXeTpog ev TaTg Yipd^eat twv ATroiTToAajv Ttpog Kopv^-
**
Xtov etirav, **
oiTiveg avve(f)dyofxev Kat avve^niofxev avTM fxeTa to 35
X a
156 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XXII, 27.

** ava<TT^vai avrov Ik veAf^wv." /AevToi «ye QeoXoyog Tpi^yopiog


" ev TW eis TO Ylaaya Xoyca (f)vjai' kuivov TTOTYjpiov ^oaiv eivai

T>jv ev T>j fj.eXXovcrvj Kai irpoahoKWfx.evy] iSaaiXeia twv ovpava>v twv

Oeiccv voyjfxaTCOv e7ri^yyeXy.evm TjfxTv aTroKoiXvrpiv' ore XveTai fiev

Ta eaoTtTpa Kai ra cdviyfkaTa^ (pavepovTai ^e :j irpocroiTrov Trpog $

TrpoawTTOv 6ea, KaBa cf>^aiv 6e7oi AnoaToXof.


SeTHPOT EK TOT nPOS 'IoTAIANON STNTArMATOS KE*A-
AAiOT. Eva yap apTov evavGpwTiyjaag tov Seov Aoyog cv tw
fLvaTiKoa ^e/TTVco t^j- lepovpyia^; tov fxeyaKov fxvaTi^piov, TrpaTOi
avTog a'7rap')(0ft.evo$ Kai to7^ ATroaTokoi^ tovto Trapa^ovSf Aa/3wvio

vjvXoyyjae, Kai ^eScy/cev els ovofua tov i^iov SavaTov Kai t^«" ava-
aTaaeooi, eiTrwv, ^^tovto f/.ov eaTi to aoifxa to virep vfxwv '^i^ofxevov

**
eig a(f>eaiv df/.apTim" Kai eaQiofnev Kai dTra$e$ Kai aOdvaTOV,

Kai acpBapaiag TrXvjpeg, Kai dvairifXTrXa rjf/.ag TYjg avTVjg evXoytag

Kat dOavaaiag, (uairep Tivog Tvjg fxeXXovarfg vjfxtv eyyiyveaOai 15

Betag yaptTog Kai '^vvdft.ewg T^g dvaaTdaeag,

ToT Xptsostomot. TavTa TrdXtv Kat avaKTafnevog Tovg fia-

6v)Tag eXeyev, tva ft.v} vofxtataaiv aa6eveiag eivat tq Trpayfxa, Kat

Tov Trpo^OTVjv hop6ovfJievog.

KE*. Of. 20

Ilfpi Tuv (f>i\oveiKr](rdvT(ov Tis fifi^av,

37 lov deeTTroTot/ XptaTOv etirovrog qti eyu be etfxi ev fi.ea<a vfxwv


*'
ag ^taKovav^^ Ttg ovTCog eaTiv dirvjvvjg, wg fnvj iraaav airoTTTvaai

(f)tXoto^iav ; 'O yap viro Trdavjg XoyiKVjg KTiaecog «a< dyiag §/a-

Kovovfxevog, avvBpovog Kai avfx^aatXevcov tcS 0eca Kai YlaTpt, 25

^taKovov Td^iv eire^/wv, evtxl^e Tovg iro^^ag twv fi.a6v]Tav' Kai Kad

eTepov ^e Tpoirov htaKovtag ej^e* to^iv, TovTeaTt KaTa tov TVjg

fj.eTa aapKog otKcvoff.iag Xoyov.

30 To ^e " tva eadtvjTe Kai TrtvvjTe ent ivjg Tpaire^vjg fxov ev tyi

*'
jBaatXeta fxov^ (fyvjatv, oti ovk ev e^eafi.dTcov pQse/a eaofxe6a Kat 30

Tpaire^vjg, dXX eK twv Ka6 vjfxdg irpayft.dTCOv vno^et^at Ta Trvev-

fxaTiKa ^ovXofxat, qti '(aairep ot irapa tcov eirt yvjg ^aatXecov Tag

TrpaTag e-xpvTeg Ttfxdg, avveaTtot tc elatv avToXg Kat ofxoTifxot,


XXII. 33- AOTKAN EYAITEAIOY. 157

ovTQ}^ (V raii vpaTevovaat^ Ti[/.a7i efrovrai "Trapa tw aBavoToo

^a<7iXti, 01 ayioi Kai 7ravev^>j^oi A-TroaToXoi, wg ^taixefxevifjKQTei

jM,€T avTov €v ToTi n€ipaaixo7i, To ^e " Ka6t<7ea$€ eir) t0 Bpovovg'^

Kat Ta e^rji, Trpoeypdcpri.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias. Q,ieTo [xev taag ^tal3o\iK^g ano-^


voiag eiTiixeaTog wv 6 lov^agf ^vvaaOat kaSelv tov ovTa X^/aTOV,

aW viXeyyeTo Ttdvv 'Trovvjpog wv, Katroi rpam^rig d^tovu.evogf Kat

T^f Beiag yjfxepoTi^Tog [^fyj^t iravTog airoXavaag, o ^yj [xdXtaTa


<f)opTtKa}Tepov avTa Tfjv Kokaatv aiteipya^eTO. Ovai Totvvv avrSa

KaTa TVjv TOv 'S.VT^pog (pcovyjv. O [xev yap KaT ev^oKiav tov io
Beow Kat YlaTpog te^coKev eavTOv v/rep v][xav, tva iravTog vj^xag

e^eXriTai KaKov'^ o §e tov twv oXav ^(OTYjpa Kat XvTparyjv TaTg

Twv <f>ovevovTa}v y^pat •aapa^ovg, tvjv tta^oX(a irpe^Trco^eaTdTyjV

€KkvjpOVO[JI.V](Je ^IKV}V.

KE4). OZ. 15

Hepl TTJs f^aiTTjCfas tov Sarava.

Ata Tt Tovg aXkovg a(f>eig Ttpog tov YleTpov [xovov elpvjKey

" 'Lt[Ji.av, S</xa>v, i^ov o llaTavag e^vjT-^aaTO v[j.dg atvtdaat wg


**
Tov crrTOV ;" tva irat^evavi avTOVf [jlv] eavTW Bappetv, dxXa TOtg
vap avTov yaptaixaat ae[j.vvvea6ai. T; ^e f<TT< '*
atvtdaai ;" 20

OopvP^aat, Tapd^ai, vietpdaat' e6og ydp tc5 Sarava, Tor^ evtoKt-


[xovatv eTrtTrvj^av, ooairep Koi tS) 'Iw^.

32 Ev T» €tTre7v, OTt " eyo) e^e-^Qi^v irept aov, tva [xv] eKKtirv] vj

" vtaTtg aoVy^ e^e/^ev oti wg dvSpmrog irdXiv ^taXeyeTat, Kanot


Seog (ov TV] (f>va€i, et Kat yeyove adp^, hevjQy^vat ydp KaTa to 25
avBpoTrivov, (f^vjatV V7r€[jupatvet ^e ^id tovtccv ag etirep eK^oBeivj

irpog TreTpav tc5 SaTava, airiaTog yevvjaeTat iravTeXag, oirwg ye


Kat [xvj eK^oOe^g vjaQevvjae TJj iriaTet dpw]ad[j.€Vog.

33 E-Trdyet ^e to " e-jrtaTperpag arvjpi^ov Tovg dteX^fjovg aov^^ tva


[JLV] etg aTroyvaatv e^j.ireav], [xdXkov ^e dya&v}v eXiri^^a KT-^aeTat. 30
To yap *'
eirtaTpeipag aTvjpt^ov Tovg d^e\(f)Ovg aov," tovto eaTi'

yevov aT-^pty[JM Kai tt^tdaKaXog twv &;a TrtaTetog irpoatovTWv e^uoi.

ov yap Vf] diroaTepviGviav], <f>viaiv, dpvv]ad[J.evog toI/ airoaToA/Afou

yapia^JMTog, imep rijg Qeiag eaTi yaXv]voTi^Tog Kat TV]g d^fjdrov


158 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XXII. 37.

(j)iXav9pco'7riai virdpyet TCKfA^^piov. Hepi wv yap eiTrev Ylijpog,

GTt €TOtfJiog etfj.t vTiep (70V aiioGaveh, Kat uv vjKovae ^ta tov
TOTiapyov^ Ttpoeypd^fl.

ToT Xptsostomot. EvTevfley f/.av6dvo[J.ev ^oyfxa [xeya, wg


ovK apKei iipo6v{j.ia av^pooTrov, av [xyj Trjg avco dTToKavt] pcTiyj?i Kat 5

TiaKtv ovhev Kep^avovfxev ano TYjg dvwdev poTr^g, 7rpo6vfxiag ovk

ovaYjg' Kai TavTa dfutpoTepa ^etKvvat lov^ag Kat YleTpog. ovk


evavTia eavT^ vofJ.o6eTav ^ptaTog (f)rjai' itpoTepov fxev eXeye,
" fji.vj KT^(7vja6e TT^pav," Kai to. e^^g. Nvv ^e (f)V]aiv " eywv
" /SaWavTtov, dpdTco Of».oia>g Kat itYjpav, Kai fJ.Yj ejav irwXrjadTO) 10
**
TO tfxaTtov avTOv Kat dyopaadTca fj.djaipav'" kot apyag fj.ev

yap eKeha iipoaeTaaae, oirccg 7re7pav Kai dTro^et^iv T^g avTcov


Ovvdfiecog XajSovTeg, ev tw fi,Yi^evog avToiig vaTepe7a6at fj.eTa. 6dp^

aovg Kat 'npo6vft.iag elg tyjv oiKovff.ev)^v e^eX^caatv aiiaaav' Tipog ^e

TYjv avfj.TikYipoiatv TYjg otKoyofitag epy^pfxevog, TavTa TiapeKeXeveTo 15


iva fJ.Vj "tta TeXovg dpyot fj.evctiai, iievtag ^e Kat neivag Kat yvft.vo-

TYjTog TieTpav Xa^ovTeg, ev TovTotg tyjv oiKeiav (piXoao(f>tav ev^ei-

^ovTai, Kat fLY] xaTiep ^t d^^v^/^ccv opydvcov evepyeia6at toc kkt


avTovg vofxitcoatV eTt ^c Kat tva fiY] fj.eTd TavTa Ttveg ^'^(uat

Xeyeiv, OTt ov^ev iiap avTolg etaYfveyKav eKehot, dXXd to iidv TYjg 20

Tov Seov poTiYjg eyeveTo, 'Tipog Se TovToig tva Kai ft.eTptd^etv

fj.d6coat, TovTo Tiote7, Kat oncog f>.Yi ft.ei^ova ^ KaTa dv6pco7iov Xd^coai
Co^av. Ata OYj TOVTa Kat tioXXco nXeiova tovtcov, dcpetg avTOvg
TioXXoig Twv d^oK^^TCov TieptniiiTeiv, ovK Yj/^ovX-^di^ vno ty]v aKpi-

/3etav T^g vofxo6eaiag TYjg TipoTepag avToi/g d<pehat, dXX e^xdXaae 25


Kai avYjKe TYjg (piXoao(j>tag tov tovov eKetvotg, coaTe fXYj /Sapvv Ttva

Kai d(f>opYjTOV avToTg yevea6at tov ^tov, iioXXa^^^ov eyKaTaXtfj.na-

vofxevotg Kai tov aKpt/SYJ vofxov eKehov dvayKa^ofxevotg TYfpeiv.

37 Ayopdaat ^e ft.d')(atpav, (f^Yja), ty]v ecf^o^Sov tcov lov^aicov tvjv

KaT avTov yvcoptaat avTolg PovXofnevog, Ka) OTt fxeXXovatv avTOV^^o

avXXafK/Savetv, Kat tovto (pavepcog fxev ovk ^6eXYjaev elneh, coaTe

fj.Y] 6opvl3')^aat ndXtv avTovg' 'tt aiviyfj.aTOi fj.evTOt TYjg fi.a')(aipag

TYjv eveaTcoaav atvtTTtTat eTitl3ovXY]v, Kat OTt fj^eXXet iidayeiv

Tiapd Tcov lov^^aicov anep ena^e, Kat tovto eK tcov e^Yjg '^yjXov.

E/TTWV yap ^^"


ayopaadTCO fj.d^yaipav^^ e^TiYjyayev, " ot^ 'he'i Ta ye-ZS
XXII. 44- AOTKAN ETArTEAIOT. 159

" ypafJLfMva nepi ef/iov TcAeo-fi^va/, oti fJi.€Ta avofxav €Koyi<79yj' ovt€

ovv TeXe/»? irapeaiami^a-eVf iva fM) Tyj a6poa, e^poO'^ Tapa-^^Oaaiv,

ovT€ TTaXtv TeAewf eyvccptaev, tva fxrj ^eiXia Ttvi KaTaaye^xatv.

38 E/VovTwv ^e Tm ^ATToaToXxv, " Kvpie, i^oZ fj.d')(aipai w^e %vo^


Kou TO keyP^v fiv] avvievTccVf avTO^ (f)V]atv, " iKavov ec7T/," KaiTOt^

ye ovK vjv 'iKavov. E/ fj.\v yap dvQpaTrivvji ^oiqBeiag Ke^j^jprjaOat,

avTovg e^ovXeTo, ovhe el cKaTOv "yjaav fxd^atpat, iKavat ijaav' ei

Se fjJij TouTO, Kat Svo TteptTTaf Kat ofj.(og ovk diKKdXv^e to


aivtyfj.a. Kai yap itoXXayov (f>aiv€Tat tovto Tiotm, eTtettav fj.ri

vo-^aaai to XeyOeVf "JiapaTpey^et tovto Kat dcpirjatf t^ tuv irpayfxd- 1 o


Twv eK^daet Tav fxeTo. TovTa t>?v KaTavoYjatv txv eipvjfxevajv evi-

Tpewcov XotiroVf aairep Kat ot€ e/ire, " XvaaTe tov vaov tovtov"

Kai Ta e^^f. Tlepi tov Ttpoaev^aaBat avTOV irpo tov irdBov^

7rpoeypd(f)y] eif tq KaTa MaTSaTov.


Iva Se ^ei^yjf OTt dXi^9tvos vjv avfl/JWTrof, Kat ovk dico to}^ 15

BeoTyjTOi ^ dywvia 'yeyovev, t^^pwae, Kot eyeveTO avTOv 6 ^pwg ooaei

Bpofx^ot atfiaTOi, oirep fxvaTYjpiov Tivog laTi TeKfXYfptov. Qvte


yap et acpo^pa "hetXoTaTog eaTi Kat dyevvvjg, aifxaTog efxeXXe

voTiaiv e^ dymiaq fxovviq wairep tKfndat ihpiOTog irapa <f)vatv

vypaiveaSaif dXX ev^oKvjae tovto yeveaOat ev eavTco, oircog Tvjg 20


vjfjieTepas (f^vaeag coairep dva^t^pdvv] Kai e^otKiavi tv]v TV]g ^etXiag

trvffv^v.

43 Q.<p6v] ^e avTa AyyeXog e^ ovpavov evia^^^vccv avTOv, oi/y^ OTt

TV]g tayyog tov AyyeXov hreteeTO, v7ro Trdavjg vrrovpavtov ^vvd-

fxecag <po/3a} Kat Tpofxco TrpoaKvvovfxevcg Kai ^o^a^ofxevog, dXX iva 25

wXvjpcoSyj TO ev Tvj fxeydXv] cjntri viro tov M.o)vaeci}g eipvjfxevov, " Kai
**
evtayyadrcoaav avTOv TrdvTeg viot Qeov," TOVTeaTt ^ta tv]v

vnep(3oXv]v t^? $avft.aaioTV]Tog ^o^oXoyxv avTov 6 AyyeXog eXeye


irpog Kvpiov S17 ecTTiV vj tayyg, teanoTa, av ydp tayyaag KaTa
BavdTov Kat KaTo, toD a^ov kou KaTa tou ha(3oXov, eXevBepcoaag ^o
TO yevog tZv avGpcoircov e^ avTcov.

44 4>a>v^ Trapoifxiag XeyeTat eirt tcov a<f)o^pa XvTrovfxevcov Kat


**
aycovtcovTcov, atfxaTi t ^pco" coairep Kat eiri tcov TriKpxg o^vpofkevcov,
**
atfxaTi KXaietr ei fxev ouv KaTO. tovtov Ttg ireTrapcotvjaOat vofxia»t

Tov TpovoVf ov^€ ydp T«v TOtovTcov fxa6v]fxdTCov 6 dvv]p dvvjKoog, 01)35
160 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XXII. 50.

yap &pofJij5ovs t^pa^ «Tre^^vaTO aifAarog' ov yap Ka^ ofxoioTvjTa

TovTcov eipyjKe yeveaSai tov$ l^pcoTag' tovto yap (xa(f)So$ ^vjXovori


" waei Bpofx^or irapiaTVjdi. BeXav ^e fJLoiXXov ^v]XSi<Tai, wg ovy)
XeTtraHg riai voriai Kai olov ev^ei^ecos yapiv e7rt(paivofx.evai$, aXX'

(og akYjQiHg ahpav aiayovav ^iki^v oXov To7g i^pSoat •nepieaTa.^ero.^ ^


** Tovg Twv aifi,ar(iv Qpofx.^ovg wae) Kopov t6v yeyevrjfievov irapet-
XYj(j>evat' e^vj\ov Oe apa (oairep Kai ^ta ryjg evT€Taft,evvjg Ttpoaevyvigf

Kat TYjg TcoXKvjg ay<avtag Kat r-i^g rav i^pcioraiv Tcayvrrirogy wf


<f>vaet Kat aXvjQcog, aX\ ovK eirt^^et^ei Kat (pavraaia avOpconog re

eyipvjft.artaev 6 'ZwTVjp, Kat roTg (f>vatKo7g Kot o^ta^XvjTotg viivipe- 10

rvjaaro iraBeai, Ylepi rov avaarvjvat avrov €k r^g irpoaevyvjgf

Kai ort e^ftiXvjaev avrov lov^^ag, Kat ra e^^g, ecog vffayov avrov

•npog WtXarov, irpoeypa^pvj etg ro Kara MaT^arov.


TiTOT BosTPflN. To '*
fLVj €tae\6e7v etg iretpaafxov^ ov ro

fkvj TretpaaBvjvat, aXXa ro fx,v] eaco yeveaGat rwv Treipaafxm Kai 15


KvptevQ^vat,

AnoAiNAPioT. Yv]fi.e7ov ro (f>iXv]f».a ^e^iOKev Trpo^t^ovg, ^ia

ro Kat fxakXov TrXvjataaat ^vvaaQai Kara rv]v avvv]Qetav, Kai 6

K.vptog (f>tkovvra fKev avrov ovk aTrearp<x(f)V], rr] re avvv]6ei irpao-

Ti^rt Kat irpoaeXeyyoov, E^e/^e te avrw, iva fxv] vofjit^'^ XavBdvetv, 20

ori ovK eirt Tovrca avrov heyerat, oirep ayv^fiart^erai ^ia rov

<f)tXv]fxaTog, aXX eir eKeho, e(f> oirep r]Ket KOit (BovXerat rov
eTrireXeaai.

^o ToT Xptsostomot. A^tov ^v]TV]aai rtvog eveKev fj.ayaipag

e^aaraaav, Kat iroQev v]aav eKei fj.ayatpat ; airo tetirvov vjaav Kai 25

rpaTre^v]g e^eXi^XvQoreg' eiKog ovv Kai fnayaipag eivat eKei ^ta

ro apvtov' rovrovg Se aKovaavrag ort v]^ovat rtveg eir avrov


XafSeTv eig l3ov]6eiav cag iroXefj.v^aovrag virep rov ^t^aaK<x,Xov, ryjg

eK€tvv]g yvcoaecog v]v fxovov. Aio Kai eTrirtfj.arat Ylerpog avrv]

ypvjaoifLevog /xeTa a(f>otpag TV]g aTreiXy^g' Kai ovk a(f>v]Kev rtva^o


f3X<x^v]v yeveaSat \ptarog' taaaro yap avrov, Kat 6avfj.a eire-

^ei^aro, iKavov Kot rv]v eirtetKetav avrov Kat rv]v tvvafj.tv efj.(f>v)vatj

Kat TV]v Tov fJia6v]T0v (ptXoaropytav re Kai 7rpaorv]ra. Kat yap


€K€ivo (f>iXoaropyci)g Kat tovtq 7rei6v]vta}g. AKovaag yap "/SaAe
& Qusedatn excidisse videntur.
XXII. 6t. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 161

T^v ixay^aipav €is ttjv B-^Krjv avryjij ev6eci}( €V€t(T6v}f Kat jM,eTa

Tavra ov^afMiv tovto voteT.

AnoAiNAPioT. TovTO lcTTiv OTt cvy^wp-^aews Katpo$ KOt yj


»1. / ~ /
i^OV(Tia TOV CKOTOVS.

TiTOT Bo2TPflN. Ot€ BiXw KpaTovf/Mty (pi^aiv, eya yap vvv S

fleXw, ayToj eaTtv vfJMV yj wpa, Kat vj l^ovaia Trji afJuxpTias vfxwv.

6l TOT XpT202TOMOT. lo-Teo» OTt OVT€ 1/]a6€T0 TOV TrTUfXaTOg

IleTpof, Kat TovTO ^vjkSiv 6 AovKas (pviatv, OTt evejSAei^cv e/f

avTOV
>Nf-\r ^^
XpiaTOf, betKvvi
\ e/
oti ov
^ /
fxovov
»/
yjpvrjaaTO,
>«^>
aAA ovoe
>^v >
ctt-

€[Jiv^a6T^ oiKo6€v, Kat Tavra tov aXcKTpvovos (pccv^aavTOS' «AA lo

€^€^6^ TtaXtv Tvjs Tov ht^aaKoikov VTro[Ji.v^a€a)(, Kai ro /SAe/Ajxa

avTw yeyove avTt (pcovrjg, ovitfa irepi^evig vjv. o 8e MapKog cp^atv,

0T€ fxev ava^ vjpvTjaaTO, tot€ "npxTOv e<f>covv}aev 6 aXeKTpva>v, ore

§e TpiTov Kat reXevTaTov, aKpi^eaTepov e^vjyovfxevog tov [Ji.a6i^Tov

TVjv aa6€V€tav, Kat to a(f>o^pa avTOv a7roTe6vv}Kevat tco ^eet, kou 15

TaSra "aap avTov tou "ht^^aaKaXov fm6av eypaxpe' Kat yap (potTvj-

T^f ^v IleTpov. avfX(p(i)va Se Ta Ttapa tov MaTfla/ov Koii ^AoipKov,

€1 Kat ^oKeT evavTta eivat. E7re/^>7 yap Ka& eKaaTTjV aycoyvjv

KOi TptTov Kat T€TapTov (pcoveiv €'tci}6ev dXeKTpvcov, ^vjXcov

^(xpKos OTt ov^e V] (pcovfj avTOv eTrea^^e Kat eU f/.v^fJi.v}v vf^aye, 20

TowTO (pv}aiv' 0}aT€ afupoTepa aXv}6i^. yrptv v} yap t^^v TptTV}v dyoi-

yi}v aTtapTiaat tov dXeKTopa, TpiTov ^pvvjaaTO, fxovov te vtto tov


Kptarov Tvjs dfxapTtag dvafi.vv}a6etg, ot/^e KXavaat eToXfxa (pave-
pwff dXX e^eXBcov e^co, cKXavae vtKpcog.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias. Ho-5ev>20^e KaTa t^v vpoppv]atv 25

Tou \ptaTov fxaKapioi TleTpog, Kat v]pvv}aaTO tov twv oXcov S»-
T^/ja 'KptaTov, Ka\ ovy^ a-Tra^, dXXa Tpig, Kai evcofxoTov eTroteiTO

TV}v dpw}atv. "E^pv] yap MaTfia/bf, " OTt vjp^aTO KaTava6efxaTi^etv


" Kai ofxvvetv, OTt ovk oT^a tov dv6pa)vov." YletpoovTai fxev ovv Tiveg,

OfX(OfxoK€vai KaTO. Tov MaTfiaTov, ovk oi^ev dv6pcoTrov yeyovoTa TOV30


lv}aovv, TovTO Se airtaTov. IlcSf yap ovtov ovk vjpvvjaaTo TV}g fxera

aapKog oiKOVOfxiag dvarpeTrcov to fxvaTvipiov' vj^et yap KaO v}fxag

yeyovoTa, TovTeaTtv av6pcoTrov tov fxovoyevf} tov Oeov Ao^yov* Kai

yovv wfLoXoyyjaev evapycog, " oti av et HptaTog Ttog tov OeoS

"tou ^avTo^," Kat ovy^ a>g eva tcov Ka& v}fJMg Tiov avTOV etvat SeovSS
Y
5

162 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XXII. 66.

^iaj3el3aiovix€vog to, Toid^e (pyjcriv' aWa Kai To7g TVjg avBfiiOTto-

TiqTog fj.€Tpotg (yvfx/SelSvjKOTa Seapav, tov eTreKeiva itavTog ytvvfiTOv,

Kai €K TTjg Toy ©eoy Kai HaTpog oixxiav avaXoifxrpavTa Koyov, ovk
aiiicxTi^ Tov eivai Kai 0[xoXoye7v, wg ea-Tiv avTog Tiog tov Seov

Tov ^wvTog. Kai ov^rjTroi (f)a[xeVf oti yeyovev apvvjaig, iva [xv] \pav-

ayjTat ^ptaTog, aX\ oti to eaofxevov ovk yjyvoi^jKo^g, TtpoaTiyfyyetKe

Tco fji.aSvjT7J' OTt yap avBpomtVYji fxtKpoipvy^iag, wg e(f)i^v, yeyove to

KaKOv, Kat ToTg tov avvei^OTog ekeyyotg fiaQvjTrjg KaT€Kptv€TOf

h^d^etev av evOiig koi avTOg 6 SpT^vog, Kai to ent Tyj fKeTayvaa^ei

^aKpvoV e^eXOuv yap e^w, (pyjaiVf " eKXavae TrtKpoog,^^ Trpoaea^/yf-io

KOTog avTa Tov ^ptaTov, Kai tov npog avTOV yeyovoTog Koyov

KaXeaavTog elg dvdfxv^atv. ETrtaTpexpag ^e ov ^trjfJLapTe tov

a-Komv, fxefxevYjKe yap oirep rjv, yv^aiog fi.a6vjTVjg, TteTrkovTVjKe

yap T^g acf^eaewg tov TTXfift.fi.eKyifi.aTog.

66 ToT ATTOT. Ylpenoi av etTteiv oirep e(f)Vj Ttg twv dytav Tipofpvj- 15

Twv, " e^eaTfj 6 ovpavog evt toSto, Kat €(f)pt^ev eiii TrXeTov a(po^pa
**
Aeye; K.vptog." 6 yvjg t€ Kat ovpavov Kvptog, Tav oXm yeveaiovp-

yog Kat Te^^^ytTVjg, 6 ^aatXevg twv ^aatXevovTm, Kat Kvptog twv


KvpievovTcov, wg eig e^ Yjfxav dTtfxd^eTat, Kat ^taKapTepeT tvttto-

ft.€Vog, Kai Tov €K twv dae^wv v7rofJ.€vet yeXma, tvtiov v^fuv TVjg 20
elg aKpov dve^tKaKiag eavTOv TiapaTiOeig. 'O yap €Td^(ov Kapttag

Kai ve(f)povg, Tipo^f^vjTetag TidaYjg toTvip, Tiag dv i^yvovjae, Tig eaTtv

Tiataag avTOv ; ^Aviayova^vig v}fii.epag to ^vaaej^eg Kat vdavjg

dvofxtag fxeaTOV avvvjjepTai PovXevT-^ptov, Kai etg fjieaov 6 Ma)i/-

aeag Koi 7ipo(f>v)T(ov ^eaTiOTYjg dSeafJicog €^vPpt^ofii.€vog rnapeKOfi.t- 25


^eTO eimvc/avovTO Oe et avTog eaTiv XptaTog aXX etnot Ttg av
Tipog avTOVi, ei /xev dyvowv epooTag, ovk edei cre nptv to aXi^Oeg

fxaBeTv, TVTiTeiv Kat v/Spi^eiv avTOv, fi-^TicDg Qew TipoaKpovavjg' ei

8e VTioTiXdTTetg t^v dyvotav, ev ei^iog avTOV ovTa ^piaTOV,

aKovaetg ovv tov lepov ypdfi.fj.aTog, " ©co^ ov fj.vKTVjpti^€Tat" ^to 30


Kat \ptaTog npog avTovg' " eav vfxTv e<7ra>" Kat Ta e^^vjg' tiov yap
dKovaavTeg entaTevaaTe ; tiov ^e epcaTWfxevot eaty^aaTe ;

^XeyyovTog ^v avTovg to eipvjfjievov, oti ov itavTeXag htaXeXv]-

Bev avTovg to itpdyft.a §<« t*^v e« tc5v aYifketm eiityvwaiv. Ilo^ev

ydp TO Xeyetv tovtov fxovov ^ptaTOv, oitep €(f>


cTepoo ovk elp-^-^S
; 5

XXII. 66. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 163

Ka<Jiv ; ^Eiiri(f)ep€i ^e to T^f Kpia-ecog, aTreiXav ori oxpoviai avrov

ev T^ij ovpavicD ^o^yj (paivofxevoVj aW Ofxwg aKovcravTe^ ovk enXr^av^

ovt\ ecpvka^avTO, aWa ^Xaa^fJiuag eiTrav eivai rov Xoyov. Ovrcci

ovK eig u)(j)e\eiav toi<; dvrjKOoi^ ai Ttav fxvJTfipKov aTroKaXvrpet^,

dW eU KaTaKpKJiv. 5
Ktpiaaot !A.aehanapeia2. Air-^yayov TiiXaTw tov lyi^rovV

Trape^edrjaav Kai avTOi TaT( twv 'Pcofxaicov aTpaTia7i, Kai iieTtXYj-

puTai Ta ^ia tZv dyicov irpocpvjTcov eir avTotg jrpoe^nvjyyeXfji.eva,

**
ovai Tcc dvofxai, TrovYjpa Kara t» epya tHov yeipcav avTOv avfi.l3y]-

" aeTai avTcio'^' 6 ^e, " KaGoos eiioivjaai, ovTcag earat aoi ro dvra- lo
*'
Tio^^ofM. (Tov, dvrairo^oO-^cyeTat (xot eU Ke(f>aXriv aov." Tf Se S^

Kat YliXdrca, (paai, rag Kara rov Tiavrcov EcoT^pof yifj.av ^ptarov^
**
(TvvrtBevreg avKo^pavriag ; tovtov evpofLev '^iaarpe^povra ro eOvog
*'
yjficcv, Ka\ KccXvovra (popovg ^t^ovai KaiaapiJ'^ Tlov KeKcaXvKe

<f>opovg '^t^ovat Kaiaapt ; Kairot Tre^TrofKpare irpoi ovtqv e| eav- 1

T«v Ttvag jotCTa tcSv KaXovfievccv 'Hpco^tavciiv Tietpd^ovrdg re Kat

Xeyovraf, " li^da-KaXe, e^eari (popovg ^i^ovat Kaiaapt, vj ov ;" etra

•npog ravra "Kptaroi' eTrt^ei^are fxoi, (pv]ai, vofxtafj.a rov Kevaov,

etpero re, rivos ^xet eiKOvog eTriypa(pvjv ro Ttpoaota&ev "^vjvdpiov

ctig §e Kataapog e(paaKov, dno^ore, (pvjai, '* ra Kaiaapog Kaiaapt 20


**
Kot ra rov Seov r^ ©eaj." Y]ov roiyapovv KeKaXvKe (popovg

^t^ovat Kaiaapt ; aAX' eiavjv avroTg aKOTTOg ro Karayayeh eig

Qdvarov rov dva(pepovra irpog ^c>ylqv, ^tXtjv vjXeyyovro Kat dv^pog

tt^coXoXdrpov yeyovoreg ^vaaejSearepot. O fjiev yap UtXdrog


vavrog alrtdfxarog «ir^AAaTTe tov Iviaovv, Kat rovro ovy^ aira^, 25

«AAa rpig' 01 ^e eTrla^^QJov Xeyovreg, dvaaetet tov kaov, avKocpav-

rtav erepag avWeyovreg d(popfJ.dg' kat ort fx,ev e^t^aaKe, (paatv,

aeatyriKaai ^e rvjg 'tt^aaKaXiag rov rpoirov, te^^toreg wov /a^ apa

vwg Kou avTog n*AaTO? evpeOy roTg irtarevovatv evapi6fj.tov,

irXvjv Kat ravra a Xeyovaiv, e7reTifj.a YltXdrog, aTroXoyovfxevog re^o


Kat Xeycov, '^
ovtefxiav airtav evpvjKa ev avrSi," Kai ra e|^«".

KaTiyyoperTO jtxev vno twv lov^atcov 6 Kptarog' vjv §e airtarog

VI Karvjyopia, rov irpdyfxarog (pcovvjv evavrtav roTg Karvjyopoig

d(ptevTog' ovtc ydp (popov eKccXvae Kataapt ^t^^ovat irore, fj.aXXov

fxev ovv Kou eTTerpexpe Xeycav, " dirodore ra Kaiaapog KaiaaptfSS


Y 2
"

164 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XXIII. 7.


" Kdi ra Tov Qeov too 0f»." ovtc PaaiXeiag lyyeipyjatg ^v h>

avTco' ak\a yap eTrtovToov avT^ tZv oj^Awv oooTe (SaatXea TtoiYjaaty

KaTaXtTim avTovs etg xo opo^ avey^apvjae, Tlotav ^e aTpaTtcorcov

Tiapaa Kevfjv opav ev avTa ot avofxot, ei^ tovto KaTvjyopovv avToo ;

Tt ^e aXa^oviKOv ; ov^^^t Koofxa^ Kai iioXetq o^onropuv Toii TroaiVf evt 5

OepaTreiatg avBpwnav e<paiv€TO ; Atonep Kat avTca tw n/Aara)


antBavog vavTeXwg rj KaTVjyopta Kat eaoXog a(f)6r], o6ev Kat eTTVj-

pasTa, otovet ^tay^Xeval^wv Tovg KaTvjyopovvTag, Xeyoov, " av ei c

** j3aatXevg twv [ov^^aim ;" e; KcCt Kvptog to ovTcog eivat ^aat-


Xevg ovK apveiTat. 10
KE4). OH.
'E^ovdfVTjiTis 'HpwSov.

7 ¥iK'neii.(f>6etg te Tipog 'H^co^iyv vtio YltXaTOv, ovk aiteKpiBvj too

tipcoorj epiaTWfxevog vit avTOv, eTietOv] ovk eoet irpog avapamov


avoKptvea6at fxvjtev a^iov aTTOKpiaecag eyovTa' aXXcog t€ ^e ov^e 15

^t^^aaKaXiag v]v Katpog, ovfe eTii^^eiKVva^at avjixeioov ^vvafxtv

•npeitov vjv to5 Tipog TepaaTtcov orptv <f)tXo6ed[xovi fxaXXov vj av]fjt,eTa

^vudfJiecDs 6eia i^eiv ^ovXofuevcf o6ev atamvjg i^av tov Kaipov

eatcana.

XXeua^e/ fxevTot tov aefjjvov Kat Tifj.tov avata6v]Tog, fj.apTvpet 20

Oe tit cov "x^Xevaget OTt fj.y]Oev aOiKov eirpaqev 2i.ptaTog ov yap


ea6^Tog ^ e^ei XafniTpag ent tov KaKOv Tt ^e^^paKOTog v] elpv^KQ-

Tog, o6ev lov^aTot Kai ovtci) KaTatayyvovTai €K tov ^iKaaTv^ptov


Kai rv]g KaTV]yoptag avTWv. aTctovTog rov KaTV]yopovfi.evov fxeTo,

XafJ.Trpag €a6v]Tog^f ei Kat ^tairai^wv 'Hpoo^v^g eirotei tovto, ovk2$


av Se toSto tteTcpd^avTO, eiTrep v]v opy^g Katpog. 'MapTvpei Se

Kat II;AaTOf, ot; xpi^(f>og v]v avTV) tou Hpw^ou ft.v] v]^tKV]Kevai

Tov KvptoVf e| cov <f>^at irpog Tovg dpyiepeig Kat Toi/g apyovTag,

OTt " 7rpoav]veyKaT€ fj.ot tov avdpconov tovtov cag airoaTpecpovTa tov
'^
Xaov, Kat i^ov, eyo) evwirtov vfxwv dvaKpivco, ov^^ev evpov ev TC030
**
dv6pci}7rca TovTca aniov cav KaTv^yopeiTe avTov, dXX ov^e 'H/JW^oyj

Kat Ta eqv]g.

'Eb ANEnirPA*oT. KaTi^-yo/jerTO vTro ypafj.fJMT€cov, Kat v]v

dvtaTog v] KaTv^yopta, tov TrpdyfxaTog <pcavr]v evavTiav roig Karvj'

* a*V6^T05 Cod.
XXIII. 7- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 165

yopoig a.(f)ievTog. Tig yap yj T^f (3aa-t\€iag €Y)(€ipyj(rtg %apa


Xo^aToy, bf Kai eiriovTav avTa xaiv oyXajv co(TTe ^aaikea KaB-
ta-Tavaif KaTaXnrav avTovg eig opog aveywpYi<je ; evQa fAr] ^ei

Xiyeiv /xij^e aTroKpiveaBaif (Jtomrjv ayet ^ptaTog. Tt yap e^ei

Ttpog avQpcoTTOV airoKpiveaOat, fxvj^ev a^tov aiioKptaewg fyovra ; 5

A^a t/ te etyov avayKy\v a-nokvaat eva KaKovpyov KaTO, nf/v

kopTVjv ; eiKog apTt vitoa-jrov^av yevofxevwv 'Pwfuitav kou lovtauav,

ovep •jroTptov ^v avToTs itapeyetv rtva x» Aaaj, '^teTvipovv oi

*Pa)[Jia7ot TOVTO, KaSag Kat oaa 6 SaovA avveycopyja-e ^ia tov Xaov
Tov ^lwvaSav. Ylept tov BapaPl3a, Kai oTt rjyy dpevaav ^ifAwva lo
Tov }i.vpi^vaiov, vpoeypd(f)Yj etg to kutu M.aT6a7ov.

Ktpiaaot Aaebanapeias. Tou Kptvetv XayovTog eXevOepovv-


Tog avTOVf OavaTov tp^^ov VTtoaTyjvat TtapaKaXovat tov irdavjg

evae^eiag KaSvjyrjTyjv Kat ^ttda-Kakov, tva ert (f^opTtKanepav vno-

fxetvaat KoXaatV dveKpayov yap '^afXTrXrjQet XeyovTeg " aipe tou-i^


*' **
Tov, dnoXve ^e yjfJLiv rov Bapa(5^av^^ thov Vtf aa(f>'2g tov
** aytov Kat htKaiov rjpv^aavro, Kat yjT^^aavTO dv^^pa (povea yo^p^-
**
a^vat avToig, tva t^? CKeivov fi.epi^og eaovTai Kotvoovot^^ o Sr/

Kat avv€(3r] iraQeTv avTovg' ^e^ovrai yap eig oXeQpov Kai a(payrpt.
^' aTavpaaov auTOv," 20
€ve<f)av^aav yapf (pi^atv, XeyovTeg^ a'pe> «^pf j

TauT>jv auTwv T>yv dvoatav KaraPoy^v vjTtaTO Xeyojv Kvpiog ita


** dfp^Ka
<f>a)v^g lepefJi.tov' eyKaTaXeXotira tov otKov fxov, Trjv

**
KXrjpovofxiav fxov, ^e^tcKa t^v rjyairrjfjievrjv rpvy-^ fj.ov etg yeTpas
**
eyOpicv avrrjg' eyev^Qrj rj KXi^povofi.ta fiov efj.ot ag Xewv ev tpvfjJa,

ehwKev eit
€fj.€
rrjv (pcovrjv avr^g Ota rovro efxtarja-e. 25
ToT ATTOT. Ei(f>r] Trov irept r^f rwv lov^^atm dvoatorrjTcg

6 irpo^f^yjrYig 'Yiaoiiag, **
ova) avrolg ort direTrvi^yjaav dv efnov'

* oetXaiot etatv ort yjaepyjaav etg eft-e, eya> be eXvTpa)aafi.yjv


**
auTouf, avroi ^e KareXdXvjaav Kar efJLOv x|/eiiS^"— —/fa/ iraXtv,

" veaovvrai ev pof/.(pata 01 dpypvreg avrwv '^t airat^evatav •yXwo"- 30


** ai^g avrwv." " eveKptve to/vuv," (prjatv, ** YltXdrog yeveaOai
**
TO atryjfLa avrm" Kai vtKVjv vevtKyjKaat oXeOpov fxy^repa' Kai

ayerai /u,€v SwT^p evt ro atoryjptov TrdAog' ^tfxcovt Se, (fyrjat,

Kvpyjvatu} eireQrjKav tov (Travpov aurou. erepog Se t£v dyivv


^vayyeXt^rrm Kot avrov epr} xov hjoroint ^aardaai ro ^vAov. 35
166 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XXIII. 27.

'AA>?56f Se TrdvTUf tovto KaKHVo' ^veyK^ [mv yap rov (rravpov

6 YiWTYjp' KaTa fx.ecri^v oe i<7C0s tvjv o^ov vTravT-^aavra rov Kvpvj-

vaTov Karea^^^YjKao-i Kai [/.ereSvjKav eir avrco ro ^vkov. Avay-


Kaiov ^e TTCO^ e^^ei Xoyov ro Kai avrov rov o\m 'Ecoryjpa l^piarov

e^tK0[J.iaacy6ai tov aravpov' eipyjrai yap Tiepi avrov '^ia <l)cavyj<; S


**
'Haaiby ori Ttattiov eyev^dv] ^imiv, vio$ Kat €^o6v] y}(xTv, ov vj

" ap^Yj eTTt rov coixov ayTov*" «^5^17 yap yeyovev avTov aravpog,
**
'^i ov (Be^aatXevKe roTg vtt ovpavov, e't7cep eartv aXy]6eg ori
^*
yeyovev vTr-^Koog fJ^-^Xpi tov Bavdrov, Bavdrov ^e aravpov. Ato
**
Kat 6 Qeog avrov virepvipcoae Kai eyaptaaro avrco ovofjia ro 1 o
*'
vTrep Ttav ovofxa, iva ev r^ ovof/iari lyjaov Xpiarov Trav yovv
**
KdfA,\l/i^ eTTOvpavicov Kat eTityeicov Kat KaTa'^ovtc>iv, Kai iraaa
**
yXcaaaa e^Oft.oXoy^aerat ori Kvpiog Ivjaovg "Kptarog etg ^o^av
**
Qeov Ilarpog} ajtA^v."

KE*. 00. 15

Hepi tS>v KOTTTOfievap yvvaiKav.

27 A< rjv atrtav Opvjvovaag rag yvvaiKag ore eirt rov aravpov cog

rpoTratovyog aTTYjet yiptarog, ov f/.ovov ovk dne^e^aTO, aXka Kai


eTrerifnyjae ; ^ta ro eKovatcog irdayetv avrov' too fCev yap aKovrt
'ttday^ovri ^ avfi.irdOeta TrapdKk-rjatv (pepet, rw he CKOvrt vPptv. 20

'Ettc/ ovv eKeTvai, rov ev^Yjft.eTaGat Kat KporeTaBat hiKatov ovra, cog

rov Odvarov a^eaavia Kai rov ^td^okov eKvevpiaavra, eQpyjvQW

KOTrTOfj.evai, tia rovro eirerifXYjae re avraig, Kat ra fxeXkovra

avfiP-^aeaSat irpoefXYivvev, aitep KaraaKYjxpavrog rov iroXefLov rcov

'Poofi,aiQ}v TYJ %wpa rcov lov^aicov irepag eXafBe. 25

31 SvAov vypov eavTOV Xeyet, 'hta tyjv ev too awfJ.aTt avrov QeTav
^ooYjV TYjv dfudpavrov Kat aKardXvTOV, Kat '^ta ro eyKapirov Kai

evSaXeg' Kapirot yap "^aav avrov ai ^coottoioi fji.varaycoyiat Kat

irapatveaetg. roivvv Xeyet, rotovrov eartv, et ovv efxe, (pyjai,

rov rotovrov ^etvaTg irept^e^XYjKaatv drtfi.tatg 01 'Pcofi.aicov arpa- 30


rtcorat, Kat 6 rovrcov arparYjyog UiXdTog, rt tpdaovai vfuv rco

^Yipf Kat aKdpircfi ^vXw, tw Xaw rcov Jov^^atwv, TrpoairoXefxovvra

ra rcov 'Vcofi.at6ov arpaTevfiara, f/.Yj^€V ctt avra tc3 Xa^ rav


lov^atcov ^YjXovort rov re6avfji.aafxevov kou Kapirov ttKaioavv^g
XXIII. 43- AOYKAN ETArrEAlOY. 167

e/ovrm PXenovreff ecp ol^ y}v eiKog <f>et^ovs Kai Tifxvjs a^ioo-

Gyjvai T^f irap ainm' fuaXXov ^e KaraKavaovaiv vfnai (cairep

^vXov ^yjpoVf Yjyovv iroXtopK-^o-ovcxt Kat a/j^aXaTou? X-^ovrat Kai

avoKTevovtn, ti^XovoTt t^? eig avTOv rov EcoT^pa ^v(X(T€(3etai eveKa.

Ylepi Tov aTavpcoS^vai tov ^eaTroTyjv 'Kpiarov eoo^ " -^v ^65
** ^atJikevg twv lou^awv,"
Kat vj eTttypa(f)Yj eir avroOf iipoe-

ypd(f)y} eii to KaTo. MaT^arov.

KE*. n.
Titpi Tov fi(Tavor]<TavTOS XpoTou.

33 'O fjiev ovv MaT^arof Kat MdpKOs eTreiyo[xevoi irpoi cTepa, 10

etirovTei ea>? ov avet^t^ov avTOv 01 Aijo-Ta/, Ta koiva Tijf i<noptag

ra 'irept tov aTavpov irapeXtTrov. AovKag ^e dcpefxevoi tc3v irpoTepwv,

ag napa Torf aWotg etprifxevm^ Ta 7rapaKet(f)QevTa eKetvotg, tovt-

etjTt Tov evog XriaTov tvjv eTrtyvcoatv icxTopeT, diro T^f (puv^g
ap^dixevog rjv Kvptog eiire' " IlaTe/?, d(j)eg avTotg, ovk o^laat T/15
" Ttotovcrtv" a(f> ijg etKog i^v, KaQdirep etpYirat, tov erepov twv

kfldTav e^^deiv eig KaTdvv^tv.

riaif MaT^arof ju,ev Kai MdpKog Tovg ^vo Xeyovai Xy]<j-Tag

oveiOt(7ai Tov i\.vptov, AovKag Oe tov eva ; ev apy(yj ^aev ot Ovo

kyjo-Tat TrapaTrXyjdta ToHg \ovtaioig e(f)6eyyovTO, ydptTt ryj irpog 20


avTovg' t(Tug rtva irap avToiv ^orjQeiav evTevQev irpocrtoKavTeg eig

a(pe(7tv. CATretOy} Oe aitep irpocreQOKdiv irapa tojv louda^wv yjpyy}-

(rav, Bdrepog Tav Atjcttwv, avTog t€ avevrjxpey Kat tov akXov eig

rovTO TtpoeTpeireTO.
Ilol^ev Se eKehog dvevy}\peVf cvTro} yap ^v Ta KaTo, tov (Travpov 25
Sea^xdfxevog 6av[J.aTa ; Ik rav X6y(tiv laag wv itep Kvptog 'ly}(Tovg

7rappy}ai(X ttpog tov Qeov, ag ttpog Ylarepaf e(f)6ey^aT0 XeynVy


llaTep, a(peg avToig ov yap otoaat ti itotovcrtv (cg yap laog
**
ta(o ^iaXeyo[Ji.evos Kai varepa eKdXet, Ka), ouf^eg^^ avv TtoXXyj
irappy}aia eXeyev. Ov yap etire, Kvpte, TrapaKaXa ae, axryyw- 30

p-qaov avTolg, teiKVvg OTt to. etg avTOv e(f> vjSpet XeyofJieva, eig

f3Xaa(f)y]fiiav tov YlaTpog dvarpe-^^ovai, &/a ro T^f 6eoTV}Tos

OfMOvatov.

43 Ilwf &e Yj "^eairoTov ^fnwv Seov TrenX-^pxTat vvoayeaig, yj


168 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XXIII. 43.

vpo^ Tov Xyja-T^v, eipyjKOTOt; irpog avTOV, " avjfxipov fxeT e(xov eay}

** Tco vapa^eia-(a ;" vXrjpcov TidvTa GeoTVjTi, Kai ev


€V to, t-^ to)

CTavpic ^v tia tyjv adpKa, Ka\ Iv tc3 ovpavSa '^ia tyjv QeiOTVjTag

Kai TrdXiv KaTa(3a<; airo tov rjTavpov, Kai \v too «^17 VTtyjpyev,

Kai Tov XvjaTViv eig tov Tiapd^eiaov elaYjyaye t^i irapovaia. Trjg 5
BeoTVjTOs' Tdya Oe irpaTOv tov XvjaTYjv tov eli avTOV iriaTevaavTa.

ToT Anor Titot BosTPaN. Si^/xepov TtoXXdKii ^v Ty^ ypa<f>y]j

Kat eiri oXov TrapaTeivei tov eaTyjKOTa aiavaf waTrep Kai ev tco
** Xoyog ovTog irapa
ecpyjfxiaGyj 6 \ov^aioi(; /otep^p/ t^^- a-^fxepov

" yjfxepag,^^ Kai " qvto^ iraTyjp Mcya/3;Tc5v ect?? T^g ayjixepov ^[xepagJ^ 10

TrapyjyyeWeTQ ovv tco a^iwaavTi [xvyjaSyjvai avTOv ev t^ jSaaikeia,

Tov Seov, TO €v Tco eveaTyjKOTi aimi Trpo tov [xeXXovTos Troiyjaai

avTOv yeveaOai ev t^ j3aaiXeia, tov Qeov.

Sethpot AnoAor.^ T^ve^ cpaat, irajg av e^irotfxev etaeX.y}kV'

Bevai Tov XyjaTVjv etg tov Trapd^etaov, tov AiroaTokov Ylavkov Tovg 15

av atwvog aTraptdfxyjadixevog ttKaiovg ev Tri irpog KI3patovi eTri-

aTok^, OtKatooQevTag ^ta Trjg TriaTedog, Kai eTrayayovTog^ " Kat


" oiiToi TrdvTeg fxapTvpyjQevTeg ^ia Tyjg TrtaTecog, ovk eKOfxiadVTO
" T>jv eirayyektav^ tov %eov Trept yjfxav KpeiTTOV Tt 'Trpo/^kexjya-

" fxevov, iva fxyj yoiptg yjfiwv TeketcoGwat ;" Kat Ttveg keyovat wg 20
ATToaTokog ovk ev otg airyjpiBfxyjaaTO Kat tov kvjaTyjv avvYiptBfxy}-

aev, akk eatcoiryjaev avTOV^ wg tSov eirrjiyyekfxevm >j^^ Tvj^ovTa,

Kat tta TovTO ovK eiirev aTrkSig Kat dirpoa^topiaTOog, '^irdvTeg 01

" fxapTvpyjQevTeg ^ta Trjg TrtaTewg ovk eKOfxtaavTO Tag eirayyekiag^^

dkk eiire, " Kat ovtoi iravTeg irpog Tovg airyjptBfxi^ft.evovg ^eiKTt- 25

Kwg avatpepmv tqv koyov, olg kyjaTi^g ov avvyiptBfnyjTO. eTepoi

Se e(f>aaav, /ix>jSe Trcog tov ky]aTv]v TeTvyviKevat t^j ev tco irapa-

tetaoci. AvTog yap eiirev^ ** o ovpavog Kat vj yvj TrapekevaeTat,


" ol &€ koyot fxov ov fxv) 'TrapekBooatv'" eaTt yap Ka) Te;ouT6V

ei^og, (f^vjaiv, ev ToTg tov Kvpiov p-^fxaatv, ev otg irept tc5v eaeaBai 30
fxekkovTcov wg ^^vj yeyevvjfxevoov ^te^etatv, cog otov keyyj, " ^e /x.^

" TrtaTevm, vitvi KeKptTat'" Kat irdkiVf " dfxyjv, keyw vfi.iv, oti

" Tov koyov fXQv aKovcov koi TriaTevoov tw TrefxxpavTt fxe, eyet ^oovjv,

" Kai eig Kptatv ovk epyeTat, dkkd fxeTa^e(3v]Kev ck tov BavdTov

fe
Leg., credo, "Ano AOr. Numerua Sennonis excidit.
.

XXIII. 43- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 169

**
e<V T^v ^anjv." aXXoi &e irpo^ tovtoi^ t^v (Evvoiav Kai to pyjTOv

€Kfxd^ovTat '^'
Xeyovat yap ^eTv vvotTTi^ovTag avayiV(aaK€iv, " a/xr^v

Acy» cro; (xyjfXipoVf ii& ovtus e^Kpepetv to " joter e/ixov ea'»;

" ev Too TrapatetaUf^ ws ilg tov fji.iXXovTcx, yj^ovov ^oKitv a<f)opav

TYjv VTiocyyjEatv. dXXa Tairra /xev oi/TO/. 5


lo Oe aAyjaei Tijg e^yy-y^aewf, touto ecrT/. Ta iirifyyeAfxeva

rjfuv ayaBa ^acrtXita h<TTtv ovpavm, ovyji 17 e/V tov Trapd^eia-ov

e/coSof ^ ^7 htdvotog' oBev Kai TipoaevyeaQat Kcti Xeyetv Trpocr-

eTo^ev 6 l^vptof, " IXBeTta rj /SaaiXeia aov" ov^ y^ toD Ttapo^eidov

OtaTptl3y]. a\k tacof epet Ttg a)$ TavTOV eaTtv tj j3ao-tkeia twv 10
ovpavwv Koi wapd^etaoff ^vo irpoa^yoptav ovacov irept ev TtpdyfUf.
TO vTtoKetfJievov. dXX yj twv lepSiv ypafj.fxdTav ^ttaaKaXia ^etKVv-
atv, a)f ov TavTov eaTtv, aAX' eKaTepov ttoXv to ^tdcftopov. Ta
fJiev yap ev tvJ ^aatXeia tSov ovpavav yjTOtft.aafji.eva TOii dyaTraat

Tov K.vptov ayaQa, " ovre 0(f)BaXfi.og e/^e, ovtc ovg vjKOve, ov^e eitt 15
" Kap^tav dvQpcoTtov ave/3>7," /«^Ba Kat BeaTteaiog ypd^et ITatJAof

Tov Se Ttapd^etaov Kat o(p6a\ft.og ei^e tov ^A^aft., Kat oi/s ^KOvev'

TjKovae yap " aTro TravTOf ^vXov ev tso itapa^etaa /3pcoaet ^a-yi^,"
et Kat Tov evog ^vkov t>;v /xev 6eav elyjE, Tyjv ^e ^pcoatv ovk ene-
TiTpaTtTO. Kai eitt Kap^hiav dvBpcottov dve^yj, itpoaeTdTTeTo yap 20

epyd^eaBai tov itapd^etaoV yj Se epyaata tov itapo^eiaov /Sdvav-


aos Ttg ovK yjv, a\k ei^yjE. XoytKyjv ev(j)poavvy]V avafi.eft.tyft.evyiv Kai

evvoiav Betcov aitokavatV atcoTtcov yap Tyjv dpvayyjv y] yjpTtayy]

YlavXos eKeiaeVf eitetitep avTOg eivev, " etTe ev acofj^aTt, etre

" €KTOS Tov acofJMTog, ovK oita.^^ 25


'
QiOTe \y]aTy]g tov f/.ev itapa^etaov TeTvyyjKeV d^ev^yjg yap
eiTtuv, " ayjfuepov fj.eT efxov eayj ev toj Ttapa^eiaco'^^ to, Se cv

ekittat Tyjg ^aaiXetag tcov ovpavcov dyada fJieTa toIv air atcovog

^iKaicov ovK eKOfJiiaaTO, tov Seov itepi yjfiMV KpetTTOv Tt itpo-

/3ketpafi.evov, tva fj.y]


yjopU y]fj.cov TeXetcoBioat' OTt yap Ta a-ya^a 30
Ta cv eTtayyeXtaig yjfncov d'7toKetfj.eva ovhev eTepov eaTtv y] (3aat-

Xeia Tav ovpavwv, ttoWaypBev fiev eaTiv avvi^eTv, ftM\taTa oe eK


Tav pYifJMTcov eKetvcov, wvnep Kvptog cv ts!) KaTa AovKoiv Eva-y-
yekico dvayeypaitTat Xeycov ToTg eavTov fj.aBriTalg, " vfueTg Se'

^ Leg. iK^toi^ovtai.

z
170 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XXIII. 43.

" eCTTC 01 ^ia[X€fJl,€VVjKOTeS €V ToTi '7I€ipa<TfJI,o7$ fX€T €[XOV, Ktxyii}

" 'hiaTiSvjfi.i vfuv, KaBwg ^ieO^TO fxoi YlaTYjp fxov [3aaiX€iav, iva
" eaSiYjTe Kai tiivyit€ eni TVjg TpaTre^rji fxov €v t>5 PaaiXeia fxovT
^tyofKev ^e iipog t^ lif^yyeXfxevyi ^aaiXela Ka\ tov Trapd^eiaov,
OdTig '^iopig^ laTi TcvevfxaTiKrji avaTravaewf' Gavfxdaai ovv ecrTi S

Tov Kvpiov Tag 7Tavao(f)Ovg oiKovofxiag, wv fX€Tpmg Tivag efx^f^aaeig

^e^eiyfxeOa, tov en avTatg etiieiv TeXeiwg Xoyov ovk eyovTeg' tov


yap XyjaTov TOiavTVjV TriaTiv €Tti^€i^afX€voVf Kai tov fxev aXXovg
Tuv rjXoov KaTacftpovvjaavTog, npoaTreTrepovi^TO yap Ta ^vX^ X^^Tpag

Kai iro^^ag, Kai Ta ev noah aiiavTa vz€p(3dvTog, Tipog ^e Tafio


fxeXXovaag dvaiTTepooBevTog eXnttag, Kai Kpd^avTog tvjv e^aiaiov

Kai vTrep avBpaiiov €K€ivy]v (pavvjv " ft.v^aSyjTi fxov, Kvpte, otuv
" eX^-fjg €V Tri (3aaiXeia aov," 6 toJv yjfxeTepm ^iavotwv e^eTaaTyjg

aKpiPyjg, TVjg iriaT^cog avTOv Bavfxdaag to fxeyaXoTrpeiieg t€ Kat

vxpyjXov, €K Tav avTtKa fxdXa eaofxevccv Trpog t^v eXTti^a Tav fxeX- 15

XovTCtiv avTOV e/3f/3a/»<r€v eiTroov, " ayjfxepov fxeT efxov ear] ev toj

" Trapa^etaa." Oi fxev yap dXXoi, (f^yjatv, 01 irtaTevaavTeg eig

€fX€, afjfxetav Ka) ^i^^aaKaXiag dTtYjXavaav, Kat ^ia tovtoov tov

Ttept (SaatXeiag Xoyov e^e^avTO' ovTog Se fxyj^ev aKovaag toov efxav

rj Beaadfxevog, el fiiy] tov aTtfxtoiTaTov BdvaTOV tov aTavpov, to 20

yevvahv eKeho prjfxa erpOey^aTO, " fXv^aBi^Ti fxov, Kvpie, OTav


" eXBrig ev Trj ^aatXeia aov^ T/ ovv ; eyeTca Tecog Trjv ev tw
TTapa^^eiaoo Tpv(f)rjv T^g otKeiag eveyvpov TiiaTecog' Tev^eTai yap

Kat TYjg (BaaiXeiag eig vaTepov, ev


y yeveaBai avTov fxvrjfxrjg

rjl^tooae' Kat ooanep vtK-^<popov elaeXavvoov etg noXtv t» Xafxiipa twv 25

Xa(f>vpoov €TiiKOfxi^€Tai, nepKpaveaTepav ^id tovtoov ttjv v;^i;v irotoov,

Kai avaKrjpvTTCov to Tponaiov ovTca Kat i\.vptog eiaeXavvccv eig

T^v dpy^aiav tov dvOpdoiiov TiaaTa^a, tov Tiapdoetaov Xeyoo, tov


XrjaTYjv €7i€(p€p€T0, TiavoTiXiag dtidarig aefxvQTepov Xa(f)vpov, Kat

tSov tov ^ta^oXov aKvXoov, to KpdTiaTov epyco ^rjXm, ccaTiep eXeyev, 30


**
ag '^•^aag tov la^/ypov to. aKevi^ avTov Trjg oiKtag Of^pTiaaev.'^

"OTt Se ^v copa eKTrj Kat aKOTog eyeveTo, eceg e^envevae, npo-

eypdcprj etg to KaTa MaT^arov.


OTiep eiTiev 6 ^eaTiOTYjg 'K.piaTog, OTt *'
OTav vxpccQoo, navTag
^ Leg. xupioy.
XXIV. 13- AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 171

**
ekKvaoo Ttpo^ €[Ji.avrov,^^ epyois tovto Tre-akrjpaiTai. Hp^aTo
yap aayi^veveiv TroXXovg eis eTriyvaaiv akrfieiaq ev tw <TTavp£
virapyaiv, oGiv Kai o' kKarovTapypg t^cov tcc yevofxeva, (.^o^a^e rov

Qeov' eTVTTTOv ^e Kai to, (XTrfiti tSv lov^aiav Tiveg KaravvTTO-


fjievoi iiavTwg Kat tois tyjs ^iavoiai 0[/.{Jt.a<7tv avajSkeTTOVTe^ "^P^i
S
eTtiyvwfTiv T»;v 6/V Xp/(TTOV, Taya itov t^? Kar avTOV tov '^ea-TtOTVjv

^vaaePeiag «TraAAaTTO/xevo/, t^s tSov aTavpQxrdvTCov roXfXifjg Kara-


PowvTe$, et Kat fjirj efjicftavai ^ia Tr]v twv y]yovfji.evQ}v avoaiOTvjTa.

KE4». nA.
Uepl TTJs alTT)<Te<ji>s tov (TafiaTos tov Kvpiov. lO

50 Uep} Tov 'l(o<Ty](f>, iras edaipe to (TWfxa tov Kvpiov •rjft.cov kui

Qeoi) Kat YiWTrjpog \yi<tov ^ptaToVj Kat irepi Tav f/.vpo(popa)v yvvat-

Koiv, Kai irep) t^^ ava<TTd<Teag rov ^e<ntOTOV, Ttpoeypdtpvj etg to

KaTa ^aTQatov.
KE^. nB. 15
Hepi Tov KXeoTTa,

^3 'Eitei^-^Ttep 01 eig tvjv KWfxvjv 'Efji.fi.aovg fjiaOvjTat itopevofj.evoi, (og

ovKeTi ^yjv Tov ^piarov Ttpo^T^oKCtiVTeg, Ttepi avTov itpog akXfjXovg

dviufJievot ^te\eyovTo' tovto yap ^yjXoT, (mep eiTtov, OTt " y)fJ.e'ig ^e
**
yjkitt^Ofiev," ^ta TOVTO avTOg e^TttaTag avToig, avovjTovg Kat Ppa- 20
^eig Tyj Kap^^iix, KaXe7, e^eyetpcov avTovg tta tovtov KaTa ^po.yy
Ttpog T^v Tr^g dva<TTdae<ag itKTTtv. Et yap Kat tvjv (pyjfJiVjv TVjg

dva(TTd<Te<og eiitov eKeivot t*;v ^ia tov UeTpov Kai lcodvvov, dkX
**
oyj^ «f Ttt(TTevovTeg tovto eXeyov. A<o Kat (pv]<Ttv, OTt e^e<TTy]<Tav

**
y]fi.dg at yvvaiKeg," ovk evayyeXtctfjiOv aXv]6etag Kai (j)coTt<TfJi.ov 25
TOVTO vofn-i^ovTeg, dw' a>g eK Tapa^^g Tivog Kat (pavTacTiag elitov-

(Twv avTuv Ta itepi rvjg dva(TTd<T€cog, Kat tvjv avTOv ye tov rieT^ou
fJLapTvptav Kat tov 'lcodvvov, to, oQovta fJ.ova eitt tov fJLV^fiuiTog

ecopaKOTcov, ovk d\i^6ovg dva<TTd<Tecog TeKfuvjptov vitekdfx^avov tovto,

ort ff.y] avTOv t^eiv eXeyov " Kai' ydp (f>v]<Ttv,


" dTtv]X6ov Tiveg 30
**
Twv (Tvv vjfJ.h eitt TO fj.vr]fj.e'iov, Kat evpov ovtco, Kadcog Kat at
**
yvvaiKeg eiitov, avTOV te ovk eJ^ov." avTog ^e Tvjg TotavTVjg

d-TttiTTtag Te\eicog avToi/g e\ev6epco<Tat l3ov\ofJt.evog, dvefj.ifj.vv^TKe

Twv TtaXaicov Ttpoppvfaecov, itapdycov eig fi.apTvpiav Mwcrca Te Kat


z %
172 EPMHNEIA TOT KATA XXIV. 36.
Toiis Trpo^Yirag^ epixi^vevcov ra eTriKeKpvfJifxeva, Kai ra 7rpo$ rov^

ava^iovi a<7a(j)ri roHq a^ioi^ a-a<py}vi^(cv. 'Einei^v) ^e reco^ " oi

" 0(f)6aX[A0i avjm eKparovvro rov [xrj cTriyvavai avrov" (ag (f>vj(riv

Et^ayyeA^cTT^f, ewg ov 6 Xoyo^ rvjg rov Har^pog ^i^aaKaXiaf

eiaeXdav elg ras Kaptia^ avrcov, evTrapateKrov r^v itiariv eipya^S

craro, ore Xoiirov eiticrrevdav roHg Koyoig avrov, rore Kai riqv

oxpiv e/Ji(pavyj Ka6i(rrv)aiv avro7g' ov [Ji.vjv (j-vixTrapaixevei' " Kai


avro^ yap ^vjatv, a(pavrog eyevero air avrcov ovKeri yap
fxera rv]v avaara(7iv ra rov J^vpiov itpog rovg fxaQvjrai rotavra

oia ra Ttporepov, oircos eK rovrov irXetovcos rov Ttodov eTtav^vj^rcoaiv. 10


" Avaaravrei ^e avrvj rv] copa VTtearpetpav elg 'lepov(7a\v]fx," Kai

ra e^vjg' rovreartv, ev avrvj [xev rvj copa ev vi a(pavrog ait avrav

eyevero "heaTtori^g Xp/o-rof, vitearpexpav [mvj fiXexpavrei. ovk


avrvj &€ T^ copa evpov avwiQpotafxevovs rovg ev^heKa, Kai aitYjyyei-

Aav Ta AfaTa rov Kvptov Ivjaovv, aWa fj.era rtvag copag, oaagi^
eiKog -^v avrovg Ttoivjaat ro 'ttdarvjfKa rwv e^vjKovra^ ara^icov
j3a^ii^ovrag, ev aig itd.vrcog Kat ^eaitorvjg co<p6vj rco ^tft.covtf

*'
avroi ^e e^vjyovvro ra ev rvj o^Z, Kai cag eyvcoaSv] avroig ev ryj

KAaaei rov aprov.


36 " TavTa Se," (pvjai, " XaXovvrcov avrcoVy avrog earvi ev fAeaco 20
" avTCov,^' Kai ra e^vjg, ovKert Kparovfxevcov rwv 0(f>6aXfxm avrwv

ettecpatvero avrotg, ov^e cog Ttepi erepov ^taXeyerai, aXX^ eavrov

eft.(pavv] '^i^coat, Ka\ Sappetv ttapaKeXeverai. 01 ^e ovrcog vjaav

aff.(ptl3oXoi Kat ^e^toreg, cog vofxi^etv ovk avrov /SXeTteiv, (pav-

raafxa ^e rt Kat aKtav. Avrog ^e Kat eK rcov rotovrcov Xoytafxcov 25

Karevvd^ctiv avrovg ro evrpt(3eg avroig Kat ovk avfieg aTte^pQeyyero

pvjfxa, eiTtcbv, " elp-^vv} vfitv'^' tva Be ^ejBaicog Kat ev^oiaafxov ^/%a
Tttarevacoatv, avrov cKetvov eivai rov TteitovBora, tta^eiKvvatv evGiig,

ort Seog m (pvaet, ytvaaKet ra KpvTtra rvjg Kapoiag, rov ev avroig

rcov evvotcov ovk vjyvoet Bopv^ov. ^vjai yap " ri rerapayfxevoi 30


<t ' ^ " ^ ^ '}:~
€<XTe, Kat ra egvjg.

39 AeiKvvat ^e rag '/etpag Kai rovg ito^ag Kat rag ^iarpvjaetg


rcov vjXcov, Koi xpvjXacpav eittrpeTtet, Kai vXvjpo^popetadat ^ta rpoitov

rivog," ort ro TteitovBog eyvjyepro aa>fxa. Ato fi(.v]^etg avKO^pav-

^ fKctTov efijKOJ-Ta Cod.


5

XXIV. 51. AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT. 173

TeiTOO Trjv Koivrjv yi}uv}v ava,<7TaaiVf akXa "Jrepi tov avOpocTrivov

crwfjiaTOi aKovcDV, " OTi (TireipeTai (7a[j.a xpv^^iKov, lyeiptTai (xSifJM

" TrvfvfxaTiKQVf^ fAvj ajrapvyjcrriTai twv avSpaTrivwv aafJuxTav t^v


eif a<p6apaiav ava^pofx-^v' (eanep yap xpv^iKOV €(7Ti to Ta7$ t/^u^^-

Kaii, Yjyow (TapKiKatg eTriOvff.iaig aKoXovBovv, ovtco Kai TrvevfJia-^

TiKOv TO ToTf Tov 'Ayiov Ilvef/txaTO? QeXvjfJiaaiv vTroKeifxevov. McTa


yap Tvjv €K veKpSov ava(TTa(nv qvk €(ttiv ert (f>iko<TapKia$ Kaipog,

aXXa iravTeXiog a.7rpaKT-^(T€i Tvji afxapTiag to KevTpov. Avto


IxevToi TO KaTeveyBev eU t^v -y^v TY}i a(f)Bapaiag ev^^vaeTai.

42 Xp^ §e aKOTT^aai ^ia iroaoiv Tovg Itiovg /xafli^Taf irepl t^? 10


avTOv avaaTaa€(ag ^eairoTyjg 'Kpiarog eTriaTcoaaTO' "TrpSoTOV fj.€V

**
^ia Tov eiveiVj xf^vjXacf^-^aaTe /oie, Kat i^eTe oti irvevfj.a aapKa
Kai oaTea ovk eyet, Kauoog efj.€ oecopeiTe e^ovTa OevTepov ota

to v7ro^e7^at avToTg Tag %e7pag Kat Tovg Tro^ag, TpiTov, ^/a to

eTrt^YiTYjaat l3pcoatfi.ov ti Kat ^ayeiv evcoTrtov avTcov, vj Kai ^t oiihev 1

€T€pov Tt TovTO TreTroft^Kev, yj tva &e/|'>j aa(f>cog, ag avTog eaTt 6

avaaTag eK veKpav, og irpo tov aTavpov Kai irapa Travra tov


Katpov Tr^g oiKOVOf/.iag avvea$icov Kai avfj.Trtvm avToltg, Kat avvava-

aTpe<f)Ofj.evog avQpcoitivcog' ov^e yapi wg ^ecfxevrjg cti Tpo(f>ijg T^g


aapKog avTOv, etfjaye fj.eTa t>jv avaaTaatv. ao
45 E/Ta ttavoi^ag avTcov tqu vovv tov avvtevat Tag trept avTov
Xeyovaag ypa<pag, OTt ^ei^ TravTa TrXrjpcoWfjvat Kat Ki^pv)(6^vat eirt

Tco ovofxaTt aiiTov fj.€Tavotav Kat a(f>€atv <xfj.apTtcoVf " KaOtaaTe"


**
irpoaTa^ag avToTg, ev Trf iroXet 'lepovaaKrjfj., ecog ov IvtvariaBe
**
tvvafj.tv e^ vxpovgy" e^ayayav avTovg ecog Trpog B>j5aviav, eirapag 25
Tag yeTpag, evXoyrjaev avTOvg. tovto Se 5^>? voeiv rjfJMg ev t^

fj.
rjfJ-epa. t^ fneTa Trjv avaaTaatv yeyovevat, Kara tq ev Ta7g

Ylpa^eatv iaTopr]fj.€vov. "^A yap eiriTefJ.QVTeg 01 KiiayyeXtaTat


€tprfKaat, TavTa to) TrXaTet TVjg laTopiag e^aTrXovrai Kat aacfjrf-

vt^erat. 30
51 YiiiXoyriaag Se avTovg, Kai ^payy irpoeXBwv, av€(f>€peTO eig tov

ovpavov, tva avve^pog etrj tw YlaTpt, Kat fj.€Ta Trjg evcoOeiarjg avTW
aapKog Kat TavTrjv •^fj.iv eveKatvtae tvjv o^qv ev avQpcoTreta f>.op<fy^

yeyovcag Aoyog. tiQet de, rjqet KaTa Katpovg ev t-j^ ooqr} tov

b ^ Cod.
174 EPMHNEIA T. K. AOTKAN ETArrEATOT.
YlaTpoi [xeTo, TMV dytav AyyeKav, kui TrapaK-^xpeTat ^[xas /xefl'

eavTOV.

Ao^oKoy^fTCOfxev Totvvv avTOv tov havBpdm-rj^xavTa 'hi yjfxa^ Qeov


Aoyov, Tov eKOvatcog itaBovTa aapKt, Kat avaiTavTa ck veKpwv, Kat
XvaavTa t\v (pdopaV tov ava\y](f)6evTa, Kai fxeTa tovto vj^ovTaS

[X€Ta ^o^rji TTokXvji eni to Kphat ^avTas Kat veKpovg, Kat ano-

Zovvai €KaaTW KaTa Ta epya avTov' ht ov Kat fxeG^ ov, tw Oew


Ka) TlaTpt 7} "^o^a Kat to KpaTog, avv tw Uavayiw YlvevfxaTi,

€1$ Toi/i alicvag tuv atuvm. Afx-^v.

^^TtX^qpaQYj yj epixrjveta tov Kora AovKav ayiov EivayyekioV lo

Ofxov Ketpakata SN.


C A T E N A
IN

EVANGELIUM S. JOANNIS,
E CODD. PARIS. ET BODL.
TOT KATA rOANNHN ETAITEAIOT
TA KE^AAAIA^

OL. rTegi ToD Iv Kava yaix,ov.

/3'. Usp) TWV lx/3A>jSevTc«v Ix ToO lipou.

y'. Hsp) Njxo8i5jM,ou.

S'. Z.fiTri<ris TTsp) xa$apt(j-[j.ov.

e . Ylsp) T>jc Saju.a^EiT/8oj.

S"'. riep» Tou /Sao-»X»xou.

^. rispi TOU X)]' £T)J ^OVTOJ Iv Tp ao"06vs»'a.

1} . Ils^i ToJv e' apTcov xa) rcSv ^' l^66aov,

Q'. YIsp) Tou Iv daX«<r(rp •nspitca.TOv.

i'. riepi Tou Ix yeveT^f to^Xou.

»«'. Ilepi Aa^apou.


»/3'. Ilepi Tijj aXei\f/ao-)jj tov Kupiov /xupo).

»y'. Ilep» eSv elwev 'louSaj.

»S'. Ilep» toO ovou.

»e'. risp» Toov 7rpo<re\$6vTCttv 'EXXijvwv.

If'. Ilep» T05 ViTTTT^pOS.

i^. Ilep Tou irapax.\riTov.

Dj'. Ilep» ah^a-eoos too K.vpiaHOU <raj«,aTOf.

»S . Ilepi T% «v«(rTaa"e«>j.

& Hsec e Cod. L. sumpta sunt.

Aa
EPMHNEIA
EI2 TO KATA IQANNHN EYArrEAION.

ToT AnOT lOANNOT TOT XpTSOSTOMOT EPMHNEIA EI2 TO


KATA IflANNHN ETArrEAION. E/ fX€V 'iwdvVVjf YJlMV €fI.€W€
^taXeyeaBai Kai to, avTov epcTv, avayKaiov vjv koi yevoi, avTOv
Kai TraTpi ^a eiircTv Kai avaTpocp-^v. eirei'^-)^ ^e ovp^ ovTog, «AX o 5

0€Of di avTov (pGeyyeTaif irepiTTOV eaTi TOVTa dvai^ifjTeTv. caTt

^e TtaTpihog jtxev yiTot Kaixvjt; evTeXovs' cmo ^rfiQai^a royf Vaki-

Kata^' TiaTpog ^e dXieiog Kai TrevTjTOf* Trai^^eiag Se T^g (s^aSev


ofS ot;ovv avToo /x.eT^v* Kat yovv [xapTvpe7 AovKag OTt ov fxovov

t^tcoTVji vjv, d\Xa Kat dypdiKiJ.aTog. OvTOt; 6 aAzeyj- o diio lo


Bij6a"ai'§a TVjg TaXtXaiag, 6 TraTpog dXieccgf 6 t^txTVjg idtcoTiav tvjv

eayaTviv, o ypdfKfxaTa fKVj [xa9(hvj [xvjTe TipoTepov fAVjB vaTepov,

fj.€Ta To avyyeveaBai Xpiorct?, TavTVjv cpBeyyeTat tvjv (jvyypa(j)rjv.

'ETre/^Tj yap fxeTa tov tov ^aTVjpog vjft.av aTavpov Kai tvjv etg

ovpavovg dvo^ov, ipev^^o^i^^daKaXot Ttveg ecpaaav tov dittov roS 15

0eov Aoyov Tore "npwiov KeKXvjaOat TiaTpog vnap^tv, ot€ Kat dv-
Spoonog ^id TVjg dyiag eTey(6v] TrapSevoV avvaySevTeg twv TitaTev-

advTCov 01 vovvey^eaTepot, Ttpog tov tov HccTv/pog dcpiKovTO ff.a6v]TV]v

lcodvvvjv Tov Tov Zie(3e^aiov, Kai tv]v TotavTV]v a7rv]yyeXXov voaoV

og TovTO dKovaag, evQewg eTTi tv]v tov irapovTog e^paf^e avyypa(pv]v, 20

dvaTpeTKOV tvjv t»v ^pev^^o^^i^^aaKdXcov tpev^^o^o^iav.

'Epothsis. Tivog eve.va tcSv dXXwv KvayyeXtarSov dno TVjg

oiKovoft.iag dp^afxevxv, tovto fxev ev (Spay^e^ f/LeTa TovTa vjvi^aTO

etTTCOv, Kai Aoyog aapg eyeveTo, Ta 6e aAAa TravTa irapa-

^pafi.u)v, TV]v avXXv]xptv, tov tokov, tv]v dvaTpo(f)v]v, tv]v av^v]atv, 25

evQecog Tiept t^? at^iov yevv^aecog v]fi.7v ^taXeyeTat ;

AnoKPisis. 'ETre/^^ 0/ aAAo; Eya-yyeA^o-Ta/ to TrAeTov ev Tor«-

AfaToc adpKa 'BiaTpixpavTeg Xoyotg, ^eog vjv TioXXovg yaft.atTieTe7g


1. 1. EPMHN. EIS TO KATA mANNHN ETAF, 179

ovTa?, fxy]^€V inl/i]XoT€pov twv avSpwTroi^ irpoaovTmv hvoyjcrai Trepi

rov fj.ovoyevovi T/ou tou ©eoD* tia touto c/fe/va irapa^paixibv airo

T^f VTiap^eag tv)(; aihiov Ttounai TrjV ^i-^yi^aiv. ^py} ^e. Kai tovto

yivwaKeiv' oti ovt€ ouTOf irpoi tov vxpYjXoTepov cavTOv Xoyov a(f)€i$

Trjg oiKovofxiag ^/x.eAT^ce, ouTe €K€ivoi Trepi t^v TauT*;^ €(77rov^a-$

KOT€f h-^vjaiv, T^v TTpo aiwvwv liriyr^aav vTrap^iV Kai fxdXa €iko-

Tus' €V yap vjv Ilvey^a to kivovv Ta? anrdvTWV ^^vyag.


i 'Ez/ oLp-^^rj Tjv 6 Aoyos".
IwdvvYjg TOv y€V€aXoyovfJi€Vov aiWTrwVf avo tov ay^veaXoyr]-

Tcu apy€Tai. Ttpkii^i yap tov 6€oXoyovfX€vov Tlov tou @€ov io


jtxiyTe y€V€aXoy€7<76aif " Trjv yap y€V€av avTOv Tig tirjyrja^Tai ;"

fj.riT€ TT^ipd^^a^Oar 0eov yap tid^oXog 7r€ipd^€iv ov ^vvaTai.

TovTo ^e <f>afii€v ov Xvovt€$ tov ^]y]aovv diro tov X.piaT0Vf ^€i-

KvvvT€S ^e Ta €Trivoovfx.€va irpdyfJ.aTa kiri Yrj^xov X.piaTOv. tov

hc vovv Tov yipoK^ifxkvov E,vayy€XiO'j ov^€i<; ^vvaTai Xa{3€iv, f*.y]


i^

avaireawv ctt/ to tov lijaou <7t^9o^ Kai Xa^wv t>?v liqaov fxr]-

T€pa M^apiav aito rov Xr^oov fj.r]T€pay Ka6wq ^Xwdvvr^g. T<


or(noT€ Q€ Tov YiaT€pa d(f)€i<; 7r€p) tou T/ou ^taXeyeTai ; eTre/^»?

€K€7vog fA€v l^Xoi rjv airaaiv, e/ Kai fi.y] wg riaT^p, dXX w$ ©eo^.
6 0€ fJ.ovoy€vy]g yjyvo€tTC' €ikotw$ toivvv tvjv Trep) tovtov yvwdiv 2o
€v6€wg €K irpootfnioiv eaweucTe S^ivai ToTg ovk el^ocriv avTOV, dXX.

waT€ oiO€ Tovg dvBpwTrovg to Trp€<7^vT€pov Ka) irpwTov fj.dXiaTa

TtfJMVTag Kai Tt6€fj.(vovs ©eov, Kal '^ta tovto evTeufiev apy^^Tai'


ovQ€ Tov TlaTcpa ev tovtois dTr^atwTryjacv' **
ofj.(i}g fv apj^^ y]v 6

" Aoyo«-." 25
laov ovvaTai tov ev dpyyj to y]v' et yap ev dp^xyj y]v, sroTe ovk

y]V, Kai Qta tovto de <py](7iv Aoyog Kai ovy^ Tiog, tva fj.r] T17

7tpoay]yopta tov Ttov €t<7€X6r] aoi y] tov Trd6ovg cvvota, €7r€i^y] to.

Trap y]fj.iv y^vvavTa yjpovw y€vva kou €fj.7ra6wg, 7rpo^top6ovft.€vo$ Ta?


a7rp€7r€7g VTroXy]y\/€i(; ovtw (f)yjai. Aoyog ^e CKX-^^r], iva ^€1^(6^ OTt 30
€K Tov vov ^rpor^y^r], Kat oti d7ra6cag €y€vvr]6rj.

" Ev apyri rjv 6 Aoyos" €i^€g Trapprjaiav Kai €^ovaiav 7roXX^v ;

TrZi ov^€v afufjif^dXXwv ov^e €iKd^av, dXXd irdvTa d7ro(f>aivoff.€Vog

<f>6€yy€Tai. To " ev apyjf] y]v" €Trt(Jvvy]fj.fj.€vov 7rpoaK€ifj.€Vov T€ cv-


^€vog €T€pov, dnoXvTov Tiva Kat d7r€ptQpi(7Tov '^€tKVvat TYjv dpyyfv.
^^
Aa 2
180 EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA I. 4-

10 0€ yjv ovhev erepov ta-Tiv «aa yj tov eivai an OYjAdTiKov

KOLi aTreipcog eivai. Aoyov ^e avTOV eKoiXeaev, iva [jlv] TiaSyjTvjv avTov
rvjv yeveatv viro\aj3a}{X€v' eri ^e Kai ^ia to aTrayyeiXai YjfMV ra tou

X\v€vu.aTog. ovy^ dirXiog ^e avTOv Aoyov iKaXiatv, dXXa fxera t^?

rov dpdpov TTpocrdYjKi^i, oirag rSov Xonrav avrov Xoycov Kai ev rovra)^

Xoopiay]. TToXXo) ydp oi Toy Seov Xoyot, dXX ov^etg eKetvav rwv
Xoy(ov Qeog' dXX eKe7voi ^Kev aitavreq Ttpo^^qrelat Kat tt^oo"-

rdy^ara, ovrog ^e o Aoyog ovaia rtg evvirodTarog e^ avrov


TipoeXBovaa diiraOioi tou Ylarpog. e/Vwv ovv ort Kai " ©eoj- rpt o

" Aoyof," ovK efxcf^aivet ri [xeaov r^g Beorvjrog ravTrji, eTcet^yjio

ovx ^TTov @eo$ 6 Tiog' einev ovv ro yvooptartKOv rrjg yvrjata^

avTov deorv)TO$ Kai ro aibtov, bta rov ev apyri w '^^ ^^ (Tvvai-

^tov eve(pi^vev yjiuv ^td rov " ouTOf i^v ev dpyri Tpof tov 0eov."

Tovreart [xrj voixtarjg Tipea^vrepav eivai, <f)V]a], rrjv viiap^tv Toy

Ylarpog' ov ydp riv eprifxog irore rov AoyoV el te Xeyct rtg, Kat 15

•nag eartv Tiov ovra [xy] vearepov eivat rov Ylarpog' ro ydp (k

rtvog ov avayKrj Ttdv varepov eivat rov e^ ov eartv ; eKeivo epov"

fxeVf dpa ro dTravyaafxa rov r/Xiov e^ avrrjg eKTiri^av rrjg rov


rjXiov (f>vaea}g, [xr} varepov eivat (paivjfxev rrjg rjXiaK-l^g aKrmg ;

ov^afxwg' dvdyKrj ydp ofxoXoyvjaat rovro Kai rov rag ataSvj- 20

aetg TieTiripuixevov' ov^e yap X^optg aTravydafxarog r^Xtog e(f)avr}

TTore' t^ov Kat e^ avrov Kai ov^ varepov avrov' ovra Kai em
rov Warpog Kat rov T/ou vo-^accfxeVf [xdXXov ^e Kat [xei^ovitig Kat

BeoTrpeTrSog' ^td ydp rovro Kai 6 TlavXog avrov ovrag eKaXeatv.


ETrei^vj 6 M.ci}varjg eAaj^/crTov [/.epog rvjv Kriaeag «TroAa/Swv, 25
ov^ev ri[xh rrep) rm dopdrm 'hteX(y6ri '^vvdfi.em, eiKorcog Evay-
yeXiarrig ev) ^payet pr}[xart oXa irepiXa/Bm (f>v]ai' " TravTa ^t

avTov eyeverOj nai yjapig avrov eyevero ovbe ev, yeyovey

rovreart, rm yevv]Tm, Kav oparov r], Kav vor^rov, ovtev yjaptg rrjg

rov ^ptarov ^vvd[t,(Q}g eig ro eivai Trap-^yQi^' ^^ y^P ^^ TIJV30

reXeiav aTty[xr]V etg ro " oi/^e ev" e-^tB-^aufnev Kard rovg atpert-
Kovg' eKeivot ydp ovrci} (f>aaiv, " b yeyovev ev avrio ^<w^ ^v," /3ot/-

Xo[xevot TO Y\vev[xa ro 'Aytov Krta[xa Xeyeiv.

4 '¥iv avTW ^(orf rjv, kcu t) ^(ot} rjv to 00)$' twp av-
OpCOTTWV. 35
1. 6. mANNHN ETArrEAION. 181

E/wwv vept T^f ^yifxtovpyiai^ lirayit Kai tov vept t^^ vpovoia^
Xoyov. tva yap /xyj^e/V airi(7Tyj, Trccs to, ToaavTa Kat TrjXiKavTa
**
S/ avTOv yeyovev, eirvjyayev, OTt ev avTw ^ccy] tjv" TOVTeaTiv,

OTt ev avTa ^yj ra Travra, Kat ev avTa TrpovoeiTaif Kat OTrep Trep) tov

Ilarpof e'ipifjTatf Kat itept avTov Kvpico$ av XeyotTO, " OTt ev avTco 5
**
^iofxev, Kat KivovfJLeQa, Kai eafJLevJ'^

To ^e eTtayofxevov, " Kat yj ^ayfi yjV to (f)(o$ twv avQpUTravJ'* ov


TOtovTov aiaGrjTOv <p(ag ^v, aXXa votjtov, ttjv xpvy^v (f^aTii^av avT-^v.

Kat ovK etTte, to (pais twv lov^aiccv, aXAa KaQokov *'


tc5v av$pco-

" ircov" oi/^e yap lou^aro; [j.ovov, a\Xa Kat EAAiyve? Trpos TavTi^v lo
lyAdov Tvyv yvaa-tv.

5 Kai To (f)(09
eV Tjj arKoria ^alvei.

^aivet ^e to ipag to voyjTOv tovto ev t^ aKOTia' (TKOTiav Xeyei

yj Tov BavoTOV vj Tfjv TrXdvyjV to yap KyjpvyfJia fieTO^v tvjs iiXdvyig

eXaiJi,\pe, Kat cv tw BavdTcp Se yevdfxevos avTOi, ovtw? ayTOy itepi- 15

e-yevcTO, ag Kat tov^ ^^»j irpoKaTeyofi.evovg dvayayelv.

Kai 7] (TKOTia avTO ov KaTeXa^ev.

H (TKOTta &e avTO ov KaTeXafBev, cTre;^^ oyTe SdvaTo^ avTov


TiepteyeveTo, ovTe yj TrXdvy]' eaTt yap aKaTaywvKXTOV. ovk ef/.(f)t-

Xoyjtjpel Oe Talq fjcr^ ^ovXofkevatg (f)60Ti<j6yjvat xpv/aTg' ov^e yap 20


avayKVj Kat I3ia, dXXa ^ovX-^aet Kat yvafjiy] itpoadyeTat yjfxTv 6

Beof.

6 'Eyei/ero avOpmros arrecrTaXfievof irapa Geou.

AiaXeyOetq yjfMv (yvfXfi.eTpa( Ttept tov Qeov Adyov, oSco koi


Taget TrpoPatvcov eitt tov tov Aoyov K^pvKa tov 'lcodvvvjv epy^eTat. 25
A/fOvovTe? te OTt irapa Seov diteaTdXy], fxyj^ev Xotitov dvQpd^Tttvov

vofxtaaofxev eivat twv Xeyofxevm' ov yap to. avTov, dXXa tov


jtefKxpavTog a-TtavTa (f)6eyyeTat, ^to Kat dyyeXog itpoa-^ydpevTat'
ayyeXov Se a^€T>; to fxyj^ev 'i^tov eltteh' to te " eyeveTo" evTav6a
ov TVji etg TO eivat itapotov ^yjXcoTiKOv, dXXa TVjg aTrocrToA^f 30
eo"T/v avTiqi' TO yap " eyevcTo diteaTaXfxevoi^ dvri tov diteaTdXy^
etpyjTai.

Iva pLapTvprjarf irepi tov ^cotos.


To Oe *'
tva fxapTvpyfayf Ttept tov (f>coTog,** ovy^ w( dJ^tditiaTov
182 EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA 1.6.

rov Tlov Tov 0€oy t^v (pvaiv Tro/^crwv, vj iva tw QeaTiQryi '7rpc<76vj

e/f a^ia<; Xoyov, aXXa '^ta to eTrayofXfvov, iva TrdvTfg TrtaTevacoct

^i avTov, T0VTe(7Ti 01 0[J.O(pv\ot, avToq yap Qeog cov Kai Qeov

yvfjcriog Tlog, Kai T^f ovalag Tyjg aKyjpaTOV Kai fxaKaptag, ov oeT-

Tai^ Tov [xapTvpyiaovTog' eneiVfi Ve TVjg acoTyjptag avrw fxeXei T^g ^

Twv TToWaVf TovTov yapiv etg tovto Karepy) raTreivoTy^Togf (og Kai

dvdpxTTcp TVjv fj.apTvpiav eTrnpexpai tvjv eavTov.

Ata Ti eiTTtv " oiiK yjv eKelvog to (f^ag, dXX iva (xaprvpyjay
" Trepi Tov (fxtiTog ;" ag t» mkXa Ta p^^fxaTa, ixet^aiv o [xapTvpwv

Tov fxapTvpovfi.evoVf iva fxyj Tig Kai eiit tov ladvvou tovto voft-KJy}, lo

T>;v irovyipav TavryjV VTToxpiav avaipm tovto (pyjat.

Ktpiaaot. OvTog o eK Qeov dneaTaXfxevog 6 Ttaaav eiKOTCog

KaTairXyj^ag tvjv lov^atav, t-^ tc tov (3iov aef».V0TrjTt Kat Ta7g

eig aaKyjatv vTrepjSoXaigf 6 ^td (poov^g dyiag TrpoffyyjTav TrpoKyjpvT-

TOfxevog. 15

i^MMaNior nPESBTTEPOT. Atd TovTO fxei^av Twv dXXm itpo-

^•^Tm lctidvvyjg, oti eKemt fxev eKVjpv^av tov Trpoa^^oKoof/.evoVf

ovTog ^e eapaKwg avTOv, Kat iretaSetg '^td ayifxetuv OTt ovTog ^yj

y]Xde, fxapTvpm e^ m yiKovae kou et^ev.

iipirENOTS. '
Oaov e(f> eavTW ^tjAovot;, e*' Koi fxyj irdvTeg ent- 20

aTevaav' ovt\ ydp et fxyi irdvTeg tov irapd tov yjXiov teyotVTO

(pcoTtafxov, yj^yj Kai tov vjXtov (paiyj Ttg av fxy} em tovto dvareX-

XetVf e(f> wTe irdvTag (pxTt^ea6at' y] ydp TrpoGeatg tov 7Teft.\pavT0g

avTov ^v irtaTevaat irdvTag.


Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias. ^A-TreaTdXGat (f^yja} Trapd Qeov' 25

e^ei yap ovk avrofxoXov irpog ryjv virep tov 'EcoT^pog yjfxm fxap-

Tvptag tovra oetKvvetv tov aytov [3airTtaTyiv, dXXd To7g tov


Ylarpog vTryjpeTOvvra GeXrjfxaat' ^OKeT ^e fxot Xiav y]a(f)aXtafxevog
ev TovTOig EivayyeXtaryjg, ofj^ dirXag, ort yeyovev, etTreiVf dXXa
Kat ^ta Tov TrpoaQeTvat, Kat *'
dvSpooTrog," d^ovXordTm Ttvm ava-30
Tpeirm virovotav twv XeyovTm, fxy) dvQpcairov ovTccg VTrdpyetv tov

f3airTtaTr}V, aXXa rm tov Ylarpog Kat Tiov viri^peTOvvTa GeXyj-

fxaatv^ ag eK rm ovpavm eva Ttva tS>v dytm ayyeXm Trapa-

yevofxevov avQpaiTrtvca '^(jiYiatfxov accfxart, Kat irpog to KyjpvTTetv


^ oii^e Tii Cod.
1.9. mANNHN ETArrEAION. 183

aviaTa\(xivov irapa SeoZ' onroacpdXXovTeg Se T^f dXvjGeias oi

Mppoveg' TO yap dyyeXog ovofMa Xenovpyiag fJiaXXov ecTiv yj trepi-

ovaiag (Ti^fJiavTtKOv' axmep Kai oi eiit tov Iw^ ayyeXoi, aXkog


etr dXXx Tpey^ovci, toc KoXinpoTta KfjpvTTovTeg nddi^. Ovkovv ay-
yeXog o fxaKdpiog (3aTiTi(iT)}g S;a TYjg tov '^eciroTOv KaTCOvofJiaaTat 5

(pav^g, ovK avTog KaTo. (pvaiv AyyeX.og wv, «AX ug etg to ayyeX-
Xeiv aTieaTaX.ixevog, Kai " t>jv otov eTotfud(xaTe Kvpiov" Pouv.

9 'Hj/ to <p(09 ro dXrjOLVov.


Avdycov ^e TrdXiv tvjv evvoiav vjfiMV irpog tvjv eTieKeiva iraa-vjg

apyvjg vnap^iVf tvjv ov^afxov X.yp/ov(xav ovt\ njTafxevviv, e(f)Vj'


" -^^v 1 o
" TO (pZg TO dXv]9tvov, (pccTi^et itdvTa dvBpoonov epyoixevov eig

" rov KO(Tfxov'^^ Kat et itdvTa avQpxnov (piOTi^et, TrSog a(pci)TtaTOt

[xefJiev^Ka(Xi ToaovTot' to fJiev etg avrov vjkov TtdvTag vjXQe (pcoTt-

(rat, ei ^e Tiveg ^KovTeg Tovg o(pGaXfj.ovg T^f ^tavotag fxvaavTeg,

ovK vjOeXvjaav irapaM^aaSat tov (piOTOg Tag aKTivag, ov iiapa tvjv i


5
rov (pcoTog (pvatg vj aKOTi^atg eKeivvj, dXXa vapa tvjv KaKovpyiav
Tav eKovTt d-noaTepovvTOiV eavrovg TVjg acoTVjpiag.

Ktpiaaot. 'TireiXvjTrTO ydp irapd rtat 'htd Ta Trpoaovra avToov

'TrXeoveKT-^fxara, uig aiiTog e'ivi \ptaTog, ^td tovto (pvjaiv, tv

oXoppt^ov dveXTj tv]v rotavTi^v TrXdvvjv, ^i^XovoTt (pag ^e Kat avTog 20


Kara fxeToyvjv, (og Kat irdvTeg ot ayiot.

Ammhniot. E< Kai (pag Iwdvvvjg Kat 01 aytot, aXX ovk


eKelvot TO OeoXoyovfxevov, og eaTt \piaTog, (pvaei (pcog' ot yap
aytot ydptTt eayov tov (pooTtafxoV ^io irept tov ILptaTOV (Pvjaiv,

c^v TO <p'jog TO aXvjdtvov. 25


Ktpiaaot. 'EiKdaTcov tcov elg tovto eivai KaXovfxevcov ao(ptag

riTot Beoyvcoatag evTtQvjat Kai pi^av efi.(pVTevet avveaecog' XoytKOV

t€ ovTog diroTeXei to ^wov t^^ oiKetag (pvaecog fxeTO-^^pv diro^et-

Kvvcov, Kat TVjg d(ppdaTov XafXTrpoTvjTog ooairep Ttvdg dTfxovg

(pcoToetOeig evtetg to5 vw, Kaff ov avTog oi^e Tporrov re Kai AoyoV 30
(pooTt^et Totyapovv tvifxtovpyiKwg fxev Tlog, «Te Vri ro (pcog virdp-

yjov avTog to aXvj6ivov, KaTa fxeroyv\v Se 17 KTtatg' Kai KaXenat


tta TOVTO Kat ytverat <pSog, etg rd virep (pvatv dvaKatovaa ^td

rvjv Tot; ^o^daavTog %ap*v ovrcog ot AyycAo/ (pxra, Kat irdvTeg 01

aytoi, KaTa fxeToyvjv "^viXovoTt. 35


184 EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA I. lo.

AMMflNior nPESBTTEPor. 'O Kvpios To, XoyiKa avTov kti-


afxaTa aito ^va^iKwv evvotSiv cfxoTi^ei €1$ to TreiaB^vai oti ((tti

@€0$' aToya^o^ivovg ck Trj^ Tav KTiafxaTm avTov /caAAov^f Kai


iVTa^iag to vTiiipaveyov t^^' aiiTov ^vva[j.eag.

©EOAflPOT. EfTTWV " Tov ep')(pfx.evov elg tov ko<Tf/.ov^ Trepi tov ^

^eairoTov ^piaTov,