You are on page 1of 472

^^

f

^^'c^'^
C

ht^
'

ATEN^
IN

GR^CORUM PATRUM
NOVUM TESTAMENTUM.

EDIDIT

J.

A.

CRAMER,
NECNON

S.T.P.

AUL-a:

NOVI HOSPITII PIIINCIPALIS,

HISTORI^

MODERN^ PROFESSOR

REGIUS.

TOMUS
IN EVANGELIA
S.

II.

LUC^ ET

S.

JOANNIS.

OXONII,
E TYPOGRAPHEO ACADEMICO.
M.DCCC.XLIV.

C A T E N
IN

iE

EVANGELIA
S.

LUC^ ET

S.

JOANNIS,
MSS.

AD FIDEM CODD.

EDIDIT

J.

A.

CRAMER,
NECNON

S. T. P.

AULiE NOVI HOSPITII PRINCIPALIS,

ACADEMIvE ORATOR PUBLICUS.

OXONII,
E TYPOGRAPHEO ACADEMICO.
M.DCCC.XLI.

<^^

s^-'

V

\l

MONITUM LECTORI.
Cv

ATENAS

in Evangelia S. Lucae et S. Joannis hac-

tenus ineditas ex

eodem Codice
S.

Coisl. vulgavimus,

quo

in edendis Commentariis in duos priores Evangelistas
usi

sumus.

Catena in

Lucam
est,

longe diversa est

illa

quam

Latine tautum edidit Corderius Antverpiae An.
fol.

1627. in

Nostrae fundus

ut in Praef ad Cat.
Tito Bo-

in S. Matth.
strensi

jam monui, Commentarius vulgo

Episcopo attributus, de quo fuse egit Fabricius,

de Commentariis in Nov. Testain. disserens Bibl. Gr.
t.

VII. p.778.

Est revera autem Epitome tantum Comantiquo Scriptore praecipue contexti, ab

mentarii, ex

illo

^odem et S. Joannem
reliquias

anon}Tiio Auctore, qui Catenas in S.

Matthseum

e Chrysostomi Operibus confecit.
alii,

Et

annotarunt quidem Combefisius et
integri

plures exstare

Commentarii Episcopi Bostrensis in
(ap. Fabr. p. 779.)

Cateuis Regiis
ris

MSS.

Hujus geneex Tito,

est nostra, quse

multas Symbolas

affert

pluresque insuper ex Origene, Chrysostomo, Cyrillo et
aliis

Patribus.

Si fides

autem adhibenda

est veteri

cuidam Catalogo MS. videtur Titum Bostrensem in

omnes Evangelistas commentarios
tulo, T/tou 'Eirta-KOTTOv
Ki<Jrag ^.
Boctt/scSv

edidisse sub
€/$•

hoc

ti-

epfjiyjviia

Toiig

^

Evayy€'

Et
in

ssepe

quidem laudatur a Macario Chrysocephalo

Catena ejus ad Ev. S. Matthsei Cod. Barocc. 166.
a

Anecd. Paris.

1.

1. p.

393,

a 2

iv

MONITUM LECTORI.
iii

semel vero tantum laudatur
in Ev. S. Marci,

Catena a nobis edita
in
iis
;

nunquam autem

quse ad Ev. S.

Joannis explicandum concinnatae sunt

unde patet Com-

mentarios ejus in duos hos Evangelistas ante ceteros
sevo

absumptos
in S.

esse.

Nostra

Joannem Catena,

prorsus dissimilis

est,
illa

ut bene monuit Montfaucon. in Bibl. Coisl. p. 68.

quam vulgavit
1630.
fol.

Corderius Grsece et Latine Antverpiae an.

Cum

Corderiana

continet Liber Baroccianus 225.
Saec.

maxime quadrat illa quam membr. form. in 4to.
initio et fine mutilus,

XII, optime exaratus, sed

et multis in locis

humore

corruptus.

Hunc quidem
et

Codicem utilissimum judicarem ad corrigendum

am-

pUandum Commentarium a Corderio editum.
et

Nostri

autem Commentarii prsecipua pars Chrysostomo debetur,
ab eadem proculdubio
est, qua;

manu ex

ejus Patris homiliis
in S.

compilata
S.

Commentarios

Matthseum

et

Lucam

confecit.

Additse sunt prseterea multae cita-

tiones ex Apollinari, Cyrillo, Origene, Severo,

Theodoro

Heracleensi et Theodoro Mopsuesteno
frequentissime
clesiae

;

sed ante

omnes

laudatur

Ammonius

Alexandrinse Ec-

Presbyter, cujus multa adducta sunt Scholia in

Catena ad Acta SS. Apostolorum a nobis vulgata. Hic
Scriptor,

non confundendus cum

antiquiore

ejusdem

nominis Monotessari Evang. Auctore,

quem memorat

Euseb. Hist. Eccl. VI. 19, floruisse videtur circa finem

V

Sseculi

;

nam

subscripsit an. 458. Epistolse Episco-

porum jEgypti ad Leonem Imp. pro defensione Conc.
Chalcedonensis (ap. Fabr. Bibl. Gr.
t.

IV.

p. 179.)

De hoc Ammonio non

gravabor qusedam testimonia

adducere ex Anastasii Sinaitse Hodego, quoniam minus
accurate exstant vulgata in Gretseri Ed. p. 278.

Nos

MONITUM LECTORI.
ex optimo Codice Bodl. Roe 22. 'O
poTaroi rav e^vjyvjTav 'A/x/Acov/of
rov
'

Tre/?/

Travra

zoXwci-

o

Akt^av^pev^f
eOavaTCoaev.

toi/toj tso rpoito^

AXiKapvaaea

yeipcocroifjievo^y

AvaXapav yap
eioe rov
avco

Kcu

TTpoairoiyjo-dfJi.evof)

ro rov HafJioaarecoi

Tipoaca-nov, oig

'lovXiavov elg ^OKvjaiv Kai (pavTaa-iav

Tp€7rofx.€vov'

Kai

Kai

Karo} BecoQeiaav Kai e^ofxoictiSeiaav rvjv ayiav
coaavet '^ianpiofxevog

adpKa rov ^pKxrov,
r^ dOer-^aei
rvji
fjiev

Kai ^iaTrX.yjKri^ofxevos eni
<f>i^ai

dXvj6eia(, 6

Upog Afufxaviog
'

irpog rov

\ov\iavoV

" Ort

" ©€0f dXvjffrji 6 " TO ayiov acofxa
" T^f

'K.piaTOi 6
ryj Secoaei,

Tlog rov Qeov, Kai
Kai ev

Seiov ovrcoi

avrov

avr^ KaroiKei
yap
fxvj

irav ro TrX-^^pcofxa

QeoTVjTog, TtavTi Tiov '^Y}Xov'

ovrco (fypov^v, ^evog koi
Ofxcog

" dkXoTpiOi eart r^g dyiag BeorriTog avrov'

^ia t^v iroXXriV

" Kat " "
"

<ptXoviiKov vfxcov ^i/yofxay^iav, rcov apvovfxevcov rvjv dvSpcontvt^v
otKetovfxai Kai dvaXafxPdvca Trpoacoirov

(pvaiv rov Kptarov, iSov
'S.afi.oaarecog,
</>oy."
yj

fxaXXov diitaTov

lov^aiov, ^iXcovog rov <f)tXoaO'

Kai

oiiTog
Ttept

yap

itpog

Mvdaova

rov aTtoaroXiKOv fxaQyiryjv,
BeoTyjrog, ^iyipcora

dvTippy)aiv

rore

r^g 'Kptarov

itotovfxevog

(Edd. absurdo sensu ItKpxra)
Ttoia Koi TtoBev
yj

rov Mvao-ova Xeycov, Ttg koi

dTio^et^ig.

k. r. e.

Paulo

infra

Anastasius

citat

]\fxfxcovtov

ttpea^vrepov

'AXe^avtpeiag eK rov Ttpog rdg aipeaetg EuTuj^ovf Kat AtoaKopov

Xoyov

te ^.

ubi

Ammonius

ipse inducitur disputans
itore
fxoi

cum

Colutho Juda30.
"
*'

" Ka/ yovv

Kard

ryjv

'

AvrtvoTtoXiv

Ttpog

KoXovQov (Ed. AkoXov6ov) rov aocptaryjv, rdg

^iaXe^etg

Troioi/jaevsi),

lovoarov Kat avrov rvyydvovra, dvTt6evTog Kat a^Tou
efxov

" rolg rov Kptarov Bavfxaat rag ^coaecog Bavfxarovpyiag' eira
"
etpyjKOTog, ort

Mwa^f
6 Se

fxev cag Ttpocp-^Tyjg

cov,

^ta Ttpoaevyrjg e^e-

" reXet repdareia, " ^aTa

XptaTog

cog

Qeog, avroKeXevarcog rd 6av~

Videndum an hic Coluthus, cum quo disputavit Ammonius, idem sit ac Lycopolitanus Sophista, qui poema de Raptu Helenae
^<€3r/JaTTeT0 S/p^a Tfjoaevyyjg.'^ k. t. X.

^ Haec in Ed. desunt.

vi

MONITUM LECTORI.
hunc Anastasio imperante
vixisse tra-

conscripsit, licet

dat Suidas.

Alius est Collutlius hsereticus presbyter
c.

Alexandrinus, de quo Athanas. Apol.
p.

Arian.

t. I.

134. Ed. Ben. et alius junior

quem

laudat

AnonyKoX-

mus Auctor Dogmaticus
XovOov Tov aipeTiKov
eic

in Cod. olim Claromontano,
1. 6.

postea Meermanno, nunc Bodleiano. Auct. T.
r^«'
vtto

Seo^oaiov aTioXoyiag.

Hoc
quo

opus

dogmaticum, quod quibusdam Jo. Damasceno
est,

attributum

idem

esse conjicerem ac illud de

Anastasius loquitur in

dogmaticum

vocat, et

Hodego p. 192. quem tomum quem se composuisse testatur

sub nomine Flaviani Episcopi Constantinop.^
Citatur rursus

ab Anastasio in Hodego Ammonii
Halicarnassensem
p. 9,QQ.

opus contra Julianum
p. 278.
KaTo. MovocpvaiTwv.

et

Et

hsec

quidem de Ammonio,
Catena

qui

tam frequenter
S. Joannis

et in nostra et in Corderiana

citatur, ut facile cernatur illum

continuum Commenta-

rium in

Evang.
est

scripsisse.

Jam adnotatum
interpretationem

a

viris Criticis veteres

Commennullam

tatores in Catenis ad S. Joann. Ev. concinnatis,
attulisse

ad pericopam de adultera

coram Salvatore nostro adducta, sed omnes
silentio prseteriisse,

unde non leve

eam quasi argumentum deduci

videretur contra authentiam ejus pericopae.

Cum

au-

tem omnes, ut mihi
•id

videtur, Catense, ad S. Chrysostomi

interpretationem accommodatae sunt ut earum basin,

argumentum non
sit,

ultra illius Patris silentium, licet

hoc grave
ex re
c
t.

extendere, aequum esse videtur.

Magis

foret,

Scholiastarum anonymorum, qui notata exvulgavit

Multa ex hoc opere
p.

Ang. Maius e Codice Vaticano
exhibenda essent

VII.

173.

sed praestantiora

et integriora ea

e Cod. Claromontano, qui

nunc Bibl. ornat Bodleianam.

MONITUM LECTORI.
scripsemnt in marginibus plurimorum

vU

exemplarium

Ev. S. Joannis, de hac pericopa sententias recensere.

Hujus generis
videtur, ad
stse

est Scholion,

quod invenitur in Antiquo
16.

Cod. Coll. Lincolniensis

num.

Codex

ipse ut mihi
est,

decimum Sseculum assignandus
recentior videtur.
et

Scholia-

manus aliquanto
a Millio

Textus quidem
est

Codicis

Scholzio

collatus

(Scholz.

N°. 95. Prolegom.
adhibita fait ratio
;

p. Iviii.),

sed marginis ut opinor, nulla

quapropter, Scholion ad prsedictum

locum, exscribere non inutile esse judicavi.

TavTa

/xera Kai tov K€(f>aXaicv TYji fxoiyaXi^o^ ev Tiai tZv

avTiypdtpcov
"**

w^eXiaTar

" Kai

aTi^XOev

eKaaTOS

eig

tov

oIkov

eavTox).

Kdi

Ivjaovs eiiopevQyj eig to

opog twv eXaim.
lepovy

opSpov
o

**

&€ 7raA;v /3a6(og ijXGev o 'li^aovi

eU

to

kou 'nag

c/Xog

" "

YjpyeTo Tcpog avTOv, Kai KaQiaai e^i^acrKev auTovg '.'—[ajyovaiv
01

ypa[X[j.aTeig

Kat

oi

^apiaaiot yvvalKa

eTii

fi.of^eta

KaTei-

"

X-t^fXfxevvjVy

Kat aT-^aavTcg avTvjv ev tw
evpofxev

jW,e<7co,

e/Vov a^To?, ti^dev

"
*'

ffKaXe, TavTTjv
vo/Aco

en avTocpwpco
yjft.iv

fxoiyevofKevfjv.

Se tc3

McyCT^f eveTe;AaTo

Taf TotavTag XtSd^etv' av ovv ti
Se

**

Xeyeii vepi avTvjg',
ej^cccTiv

tovto

eXeyov
o

Tietpd^ovTeg
]7)aovg

avTOv, iva

**

KaTvjyoptav

KaT avTOV.

^e

KaTaKw\^ag, tc3
eTrepcoTiovTeg

**

QaKTvXif eypa(f)ev

eU

t*?v

y-^v.

wg ^e
6

eTreft.eivov

**

afTOv, avaPXe\pa$ eiiiev avToTi'
Xi6ov

dvaf/.dpTyjTog

vfKwv

TrpSoTOi

**

PaXeTCo
evo$

eir

avTrjv.

Kai TtdXiv KaTco Kvipag eypacpev elg
Ta<;

**

T>?v yrjv

eKaaTOV avTxv
Ko-6
eif,

dfxapTtag.
dTro
tcSv

oi

&e dKOvaavTeg,
ecos

**

e^Yjp^j^pvTo

eU

dp^dfievot

irpeajSvTepcov

**

Twv ea-^^aTcoV
fi.eacp

Kai

KaTeXet(f)6y]

'Irjaovg

ftovos

Kai

yj

yvvyj

ev

**

ovaa.

dvaKVijjag
oi

^e

6

^lvjaovg
;

ei^ev

ayT^v

Kai
;

e/Vev,
yj

**

yvvat, irov etaiv
e<7rev, ov^etg

KaTrjyopot acv

ov^etg ae KaTeKptvev

§e

**

Kvpte.

ehe

Se avTyj o ^lyjaovg, ov te eyco ae
vvv fxi^KeTt dfxdpTave''

**

Kptvw.

•nopevov, KUt

dno tov

KaTa-

Insignis profecto est in hac pericopa lectionis varie-

viii

MONITUM LECTORI.
multoque major quam
;

tas,

in

quacunque Novi Testaoriri potuit,

menti parte

quod non aliunde credo

quam
in

ex minus

diligenti et constanti ejus publico usu
sacris
Officiis;

quarundam Ecclesiarum
potissimum divinae

quo quidem

scripturse integritas

atque uniformi-

tas servari et sustentari valuit.

Praeter Cod. Coisl. adhibuimus in duobus Catenis

Cod. Bodl. (B), quo jam usi sumus in Cat. ad Evang.
S. Matthsei, et in

nonnuUis etiam

locis Cat. in S.

Lucam

Cod. Laudianum (L), qui
in

ssepe adhibitus fuit in Cat.

Ev. S. Marci.

Horum Supplementa

et

lectionis
perti-

varietas ad calcem voluminis relegantur.

Sed

nent tantum ad Epitomen Comment. in S. Lucam, qui
vulgo Tito Bostrensi tribuitur, et
in S.
ei parti

Commentarii
His autem
iis

Joannem, quse Chrysostomo debetur.
utilia

corrigendis

invenientur, sarciendisque

quae

omissa sunt aut mendose scripta, oscitantia, sive veteris
librarii Coisliniani, sive illius

cujus opera ad transcri-

bendum Codicem,

lectu

non

facilem, Parisiis usi sumus.

C A T E N
IN

A
hVCM

EVANGELIUM

S.

E CODD. BODL. ET PARIS.

KE^AAAIA»
TOT KATA AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.

a

.

rieg) T^f airoypa^T^s,

|3'.

ITs^) Tcuv aypavXovvTcov irojjtAevav,
"S.viLeoav.

y. Uep)
S',

Tlep) "Avvjjf TYis vpofr}Ti8os.

t

.

Usp) Tov yevoftevou

p^[Ji.aTog Tcpos 'looavvriv,

r

.

Uep)

Toov eitepuiTy^^ravTcav tov 'lcouvvriv,
nreipacTfj.otJ

^. Ylep) Tov
1)'.

toO

"^wrrripos.

ITg^J ToD e)(OVTOs wevfx.a doufMViov.

$'.
I

Uep)
Hep)
.

TT^s irsvQspas

HsTpov.

.

Toov la&evToov

ano TrotxiA^v vovw,
l^$6oov.

ia

Yiep) TT^s

aypas twv
XsTrpov.

1/3'.

Hep) ToO

ly. Ylep) Tov vapaXvTixov.
18'.
is'.

ritp)

Aeu» Tou TeXaovou.

Tlep) Tou ^r)pav e^ovTOs X^'§"' Tlsp) TT^s '«Jv ' A.TToaToXuiv IxAoy^f.
[jiax,api(j-iJuJov,

«r'.

i^. Yiep) Toov
iij'.

Ylep) Tou 6xaTOvr«p;^ou. Ylep) Tov vlov TT^S

16'.

%^P«f •
[Jivpoo.

X

.

Yleg) Toov aTro<rTa\evToov irapa 'Icoavvj).
.

xa
x/3

Ylep) T^f a\si^aar}S tov Kupiov

.

Ylep) Trjs vapa^oKYis tou airelpovTOs. Ilgp) Tr^s
67r»r»/x,^o-6fli)f

xy'.

toow uSaTcov.

xS'. Ylep)
xs'.
xg-'.

Tou Ksyemvos.

Ylep) Tris dvyaTpos tov ap^i(rvvayooyou.

Yleg) tyis a\[i.oppov<rris.
Ilep) Tr^s «TrocToX^f
Ylep) Toov
e

x^'.
xr\
.

t»v

»|3'.

apTOOV xa» tmv

/3'

l^6voov.

x9'.

Ilgp) T^5 Tou

Kvpiov

eiregooT^<ysoos.

a Hsec Capita dedi e Cod. Bodl. L.

B 2

KE4)AAAIA TOT KATA
X'.

Tlepi T^f iieTai/.op(pu)(recos.

Koi. rispi ToO (r6X)jv<«^oju,evou.
A/3'.

rispi T60V 8<aXoyi^OjU,gvcov tij jas/^cov
eTTiTpeirofji.evou

Xy'. ITs^) Tou
A8'.
Xs'.
Ag-'.

«xoXoySsTv.
o'.

riepl

Twv

avaSsjp^flsvTcov

ris^» ToD sTrspcoT^o-avTOj yojw,*xou.

ITsp) Tou

lj«.7rso-o'vToj eJj

touj XjjaTaj.

X^. Uep) MapQas xa» Map/aj,
Ai)'.

ITe^i frpoa-ev^ris.

Xff.

Uep) Too e^QVTOg Hep)

8a»ju.o'viov

xco^ov.
(pcov^v.

^'.
J«,a'.

T%

Ix ToD o;^Xoo eirapaaYjS
o")jjw.s7ov.

Ilsg) TC«V aJTOUVTCOV ITsp) ToD

|w,/3'.

^apKralov toD xaXeo-avTOf tov

'Iijo-oDv.*

/xy'.
ju.S'.

Tlep) ToD TaXavicrju,oD tcov voju-ixcov.

Ilegi T^f

?wju.>jj

Tcov ^apKTaluiv.

l/,e'.

riep) ToD fleAovTOj fiepi<j-a(rQai Tijv xXYjpovo[x.lav,

fjLg-'.

Ylep) ToD ou

riv(popr}(rev

yj

yuipa ttAouciou.

ft^'*
ju,)j'.

ITegl Tcov raX»Xa«cov xa» tcov Iv

tw

lE»Acoa/«,.

ITe^) Tijs ep^ooo-ijf itveviuu a<r$sveias. Ilep» Tcov •napa^oXcov.

IJL^'.

v

.

ITeg» ToD STrspcoT^cravTOj ITegi Tcov

si

oX»'yo» o»

(rco}^o[ji,evoi.

va'.
v/3'.

el7ro'vTcov ToJ 'I)jo"ou 8ici 'HpcoS)jv.

riepi ToD u8pco7r»xoD.
ju,:^

vy. Uep) ToD
v8'.
ve'.

ayavav Tas

9rpcoTOxX»(7»aj.
8s»'7rvco.

ITepl Tcov xaXoujaevcov Iv toj

ITep» o»xo8oju,^j Tcvpyou Trapa^oXtj.
ITep» ToD
avo'SyiiJ:.r}(TavTOS elg

Vf'.

%copav /u-axpav.

v^. riep» ToD
v)j'.

o»xovo'ju,oo

t^j «8ix»'a^.

ITe/j»

ToD TrXoucr/ou xa» toD Aa^apou.

v6'.

TTep»

Twv

»'

Xewpcov,

^'.

ITepl ToD xpiTOu TYis ahxias.
.

^ot

Tlep) TOii 4*apKTaiov xai tou tsXcovou. ITsp» ToD evepcoTrjcravTOS tov 'Irjaouv wAooo-iov.

^/3'.

^y'. ITep» ToD TufXoo.
^8^.
0e'.

ITe/ji Ilefi)

Tou Zax;^«/ou.

Tou TropeuSe^VTOj A«/3eTv eaoToJ /3a(riXe/«v.
ju,vaj.

^r

ITep» Tcov Aa/3o'vTcov Ta^
TrcoAou.

^^. rTep» Tou
0)j'.

ITsp»

Twv

67r6pcoT)jo-avTcov Tov

Kup»ov app^»6p6cov.

^6'.

Ilep» Tou «ju,7reAcovoj.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
o'.

Hep)

Tcov eyKaQsToov 8»« tov xijvcrov.

0«'.
0/3'.

rie^i Tcwv 2a88ooxa»«>v. risp» T^5 Toy
ri?p) T^j

Kuploo
/3'

eTrspooTY}<reoos

wpoj touj ^oipKyaiov§.

oy'.
08'. os'.
05-'.

Ta

AsTTTa.

riep» T^j (TOVTsAs/af.
Ile^» Tou Vla(T^ot.

Ile^»

Twv

(p»Xove<x>j<ravT«;v
h^aiTY}(T8C0S

t»'; |u,e»'^«jv.

O^. rig^l T^f
0)j'.

TOU "SoiTuvoi.

Ilep» To5v xoTTTO/xevcov yuvaixoov.
'E^oo9ev)]0"»j 'HpcoSou.

06'.

w'.
Tra'.
^r/S'.

Ile^i Tou j[x.eTavo:^<ravTOj A)j<rTou.
IIsp» T)jj alTri<recos tou <rc«/AaTOj tou Ku^/ou.
Ilep» Tou KAeo'7ra.

EPMHNEIA
TOY KATA AOYKAN EYAFrEAIOY.

ToT ArioT laANNOT TOT XpTSosTOMOT.
vnep
rjft.iv

EvayyeXiov Ka-

Xoir av, ovk eTrnVi^ I3e(3aia Kai aKivyjTa fxovov eariv ayaBa Kai
TVjv

a^iav

tyjv vjixerepav,

aAA

oti Kat jtACT

evKoXiag

airdcrvji

5

e^oGrj'

ov^e

yap irov^aavTe^ Kai ^eov
[xovoVf

i^pcoaavTeSf aAA'

dyaTtti-

BevTes vno rcy
Xiov
^e

eXd^ofxev airep eXd^ofxev.

Kvayye-

eaTi

Xoyog

Trepie-^^oov

eicayyeXlav itpayfkdTm KaTa to

FivayyeXiov, ^ia to wcpeXeh ev(f)paivuv tov aKOvovTa, eirav irapa^e^YITai To enayyeXXofxevov.

10
y]v

AovKoii
xpv^^cov

fxaKdpiog, laTpo^ fxev

r^v rej^v^v, yeyove ^e Kai
eiri

laTpo^, dvafBag dito rov eXaTTOvog
yjfuv

to KpeiTTov.

KaTO-

XeXonre yap
eyypa(f)ov.
Tvjv

rwv

'I>?<roy

Xoym

re Kai QavfxdTCOv

tvjv fxv^fJLvjv

fLovos te tSov

dXXwv KvayyeXiaTciov
Kat iroXXa twv

aKpi/Scci eitoiyjaaTO

Tov KvayyeXiov
ovTog

ypa(f)Yjv,

Tollg

aXXot$ aeaia-i^
Kat

7T'^fj.evm,

direfi.vvjfi.ovevae

xe Kai

^ie^^i^XOev dKpijSSif, oto

TO

irpooifxtov Tyj<;

YiVayyeXtKrjg ypa<pYjg aKptj3eiav eicayyeXXeTat.

^YiireLBrjTrep

iroXkol hre^^^eiprjaav dvaTci^aaOai

SLr)yrj-

aLv

Trepl

rav
To

TreTrXypo^oprjpeucov ev rjpXv TrpayfiaTcov.

ToT EN
TENOTS.
Tog yjXBov eig

Ariors Titot
*'

EnisKonoT Bo2TPnN, kai
OTt

Opi-20

eiteyeipfjaav^ evTavQa avTt

xooptg

yaptafia-

tyjv

dvaypa<pyjy rwv
eTte^^^etprjaev

KvayyeXtm

Tiveg, jqj^ voeh.

y\.aTBahg yap ovk
fJMTog,
Ofxotoog

dXX

eypaxpev aito dytov irveuirapaTtXvjatoog

Kat

MdpKog Kat

ladvvyjg,

he Kat

AovKag, to
Ka)
TO

fxevToi

eTttyeypafXfxevov

KaT AtyvitTtovg KvayyeXtov, 25
01

eitiyeypafXfj.evov

xwv

i0

EivayyeXtov,

avyypdi^iavTeg

eiteyetpfjaav.

rtoXXa §e Kat etepa (J^epovrat,

«AAa ra reaaapa

I. 5.

EPMHNEIA
rj

T. K.

AOTKAN EYArrEAIOT.
"

7

ixova

Tov Kpiarov ^EKKXrjarta vpoa^eyjerat.
«$•

7r€n\v}po(popif][Ji.€Vuv^

§€ Xeyeif

oy%

aTrAaJf

tw Xoya vapa^e^ofxevuvj

ov^e 4^^^^

t^

viarfi

irap€iXi^[Ji[J-evwv,

aWa vept

wv ev itXripo^opta. yeyovev avTOii
vTtvjpeTag

TrapvjKoXovSrjKWf To7i epyots'

avTOHTai Se Kat

KaXei tov^
-

aytovq k.TtodToKovq.

'EyeVero kv
'lovBaia^.

rajis r)fi4paL9

'HpcoBov tov ^axnXiws

T7J9

'Es ANEnirPA*oT.
<j)vyri

AafJLJSdvei nrpwTOV tov yjpovov, iva

fJLr]

^ta-

Twv

'apayfj.d.Twv o Katpo?,

Kat

cf>y)crtf

(3aai\evi Tvji 'lovSa/af,

«re/S^

Ta

Ttapa 'lov^aiot^ eS/^a^e, avv^dws to/V Ttpo^YjTatg tqv io
<f>epei

^aatkewg twv 'lov^aiav
itapovfftag tov

tov yjpovoVy Kat ovrwq aTvjpi^ei T^g

lyjcxov t>;v

yvwatv.

'l€p€V9 Tis ovojJLaTL Zaxaplas, i^ i(j)r]ix€pLas 'AjSta.

Ea

ANEnirPA*OT.

ELaTepa Se

ladvvov

ovo[jt.d^et,

tva

tov

Ttpo^po[i,ov

ap^vjTat Ti^g EvayyeXtKVjg l<JToptag, Kat ovTwg eig tov 15
Oio

'Ivja^ovv TtapayevvjTat'

Kat tvjv yevvvjatv avTov irpwTVjv

Kvay-

yeXtaTvis e^vjye7Tatf 6av[j.aT0vpy^[xa ovaav 0eov, oitep Ka\ avTO

Ttpo^aatv etye vtaTewg dyaO^g.

Oti
ovvTeg,

Ttep

"hvo

vjaav

iepe7g

Ik '^to^oyvjg t^v ketrovpyiav kou 'Layapiag.
[t,eTa
tv}v

itoi'

AI3ia ovtw

Xeyo[J.evog,
o

htei

ovv

tepd- 20

Tevaev ev t^ XetTovpyia
eXeiTOvpyei
6

APia,

eKetvov

e(f>i^[j.epiav
v}[j.e-

Zayapiag.

e^vj[i.epiav ^e ypv] voe7v ov

to Ttpog

pav

Ttapa[j.eveiv

Kat XeiTovpyeTv ev

tw

lepwy

aAAa

to itpog e0^o-

fjL^a'

^ei^at Se 6eXwv oti eKaTepw6ev vo[xt[j.ws
(f>v}at,

eTvyyavev iepevg

Zayaptag,

"

Kai

v}

yvvvj

avTOv eK twv 6vyaTepwv ^Aapwv." 25

6

'Hcrai/ 5e SiKaLOL afi({)6T€poL ivayjTLOv tov Q€0V.

To

etvai

te

^tKatoi

evwitiov

tov 0eoi5, eiratvog eaTt TeXeiog'
Kat

avTog yap htiaTaTat [xovog Tag twv dvBpwitwv Kap^tag.
ev^^eyeTat

yap

KaTa

[j.ev

to

<f>atvo[J.evov

^tKaiov etvat Ttva evwittov twv
[nrj

avSpwTtwv, KaTo.

te

tq KpvTrrov T^f ^iavoiagy

eivai

Totoirtov, ^.o

e[j.<f>wkevovTag KeKTV}[t.evov Koyta[x,ovg irowipovg.

Tivof ^e

eveAcev

irpoaKetTai Ta7g
evet^'^
v)

evToka7g Kat To7g ^tKatw[Laai

Tow Kvptov TO
^o^tag,
V}

d[j.e[i.iTTovi

itep ev

tw awei^oTi

pxntov Kevo-

dvBpwTtapeaKeiagy

hepQV

Tivog toiovtov ovk etyov.

»
BovAojM.evoj' §€

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
^eT^at
OTt

I. ii.

^ tov Kv/j/ou yevea-if

tj

Tiapd^o^off
(f^viiedof

aKXrjv irpo

eayr^

Karea-Kevaae yeveatv, Ka\ oti T^g

e<TTi ^ifjfxtovpyoi o hri^Yi^taVy eTrviyaye

Keym' "

Koi ovk ^v avTo^s

TeKVoVf

Kai Ta

e^vjs.

II

Q.^0r) Se avTco

"AyyeXo^ Kvplov.
(patveTat

5
Pj

Kai
ei
fjir]

eiret^v)

ov iraat

0eof,

01

"AyyeKoi avTOVy
ro/oi/TOf,

Totg KaQapav eyova-i t^v Kap^iav, ^v ^e
ctxpSvj

Za^^apia^

^ta TovTO
**

avTW AyyeXos Kvpiov.
"rjv

Tou

OvaiacrTYjpiov §e tou 6v[xiay.aT0i*' e«rev, eTre;^»;

Kai

^Tepov OvaiaaT-^ptov
**

y^aXKOvv to

tuv 6\oKap7rcoy.aTav.

"'ETa-io

payOy] Se Za^^apiaqy^ Kat to. e^^f .

ttOTt ^evi^ovaa oipt$ avSpavca

(f>atvof/.evif]

ovK eaTtv

vTrofxovi^T'^'

aAA

Ojawf eTriaTpecpet airo TVjg

Tapayv]'; tov Tjayfaptav

A-yyeAof, eiTrm «utw, " fi^ (fto^ov

Za-

" yapia^^ Kat avaKTaTat avTov.

ToT Xptsostomot.
Aaoi)
fxevov,

Yloia ^e avTr] aKoXovBia^ oti virep tov 15
Tjayaptov^ Kat vn\p afjLapTv^ixaTcov Seo-

irapaKaXovvTog

toi)

Koi avyyviofxfiv atTOvvTog to/V avv^^ovXotg, elireh irpog avfi.y]

TQV Tov AyyeXoVf "

(f}o(3Qv,

etay]Kova6r]

yap

v]

^et^aig aoVf^ Kat
avToci

Tov aKQvaOyjvai aTrodet^tv Troienat, to Te^^^ByjaeaOat
Tov ^lcocxwyjv
fxaTcav
*
/ ;

iraHta

Kat fxaXa eiKOTcog'

eiret^y]

yap vnep

tcov

dfxapTV]- 20
/SooovTa,

Toi)

Kaov TrapeKaXet, efxeXKe ^e TtKTetv tov
tov Kyeov
yj

£<V5>''^ de
MeyeSoi
vTro

afjivos

~£:v~fV atpcov

Tijv

Nr /}» afxapTiav,

viov

kai

\\f(-~
Ta

»/

e^iyf, eiKO-

Tcog <py]aiv y]Kova6y]

^ey]at( aov, Kat Te^v] vtov.

efi.<patvet

T^g lcodvvov x^y%^?, Kai fxeye6oi
fj.eye6o(; y^vyjqg

jSXeTrofJievov

Qeov.

eaTt yap
"t^^vyyjg,

KaTo,

dpeTy]v, Kat eaTi Ttg

25

afxtKpoTy]?

eyco

ovTcog aKOvca tov ev tSo KvayyeXtco,
ev

"

^^

"

KaTa<f>povy]ar]Te evog

twv afJ.tKpm tZv

t^

FiKKXy]ata'^' fxtKpov

yap

€Kei

tov evavTiov tg5 fj.eydXcp Xeyet' oTt 6 tv^^wv 6 fxtKpog
**

eaTtf S^Aov €K tov
fJieyag

og av aKav^aXtar] eva tcov afitKpcav tovtcov'^*
6

yap ov aKav^aXt^eTat, dXX

fxeyag iravTog aKavhdXov ^o

KpetTTCOv eaTi.
I c

EoTat yap

ixeyas ipcoTriov tov Ku/otbu.
**

*l^ov Kat evTav6a

evcwnov Kvptov^' Xeyet, caairep Kat irepi twv

TeKovTcov avTOV e^prjTat.

1. 18.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOY.
to
fJiiQvjv

9
ovk ov oe e|

"EiiKepa ^e fo-ri ttocv

{xev ironTv Suvap,€Vov,

afJLveXov.

'EtA^o-^ij &€ UvevfJiaTos 'Ayiov ev Tyj KoiXia t^?

fJi-yjTpog

avTov
Trpog

wrapyjav
Tfiv

o

laavvfig, yjviKa iXBovarj<;

t^? fMjTpo^ tov Kvpiov

EA/crajSer, ((XKipTifjaev ev ajaXXidcrd.
fxiv

5
itpog 6 Se

Kax
Tov 0eov
vjfji.av

Iwdvvrj^f

iroWovs twv vlwv €7reaTpeip€
ttjv

Kvptov

•^fi.Zv

KaTo.

roy

Ytvayyekiov

cfxav^v'
tyjv

Kvpio^

lyjaovf o \pi(TTO^,

wavTa?

€(f)WTi<T€V eig

eiriyvoxjiv TV}i

aXvjBeiag'

tovto yap avTov to epyov eaTi.
*'

17

To
ecTT/V

&e

TTpoeXevaeTai ev irvevfj.aTi Kai

'tvvdfj.ei

'HX^oy," toutoio

^pofJLOff

HX/aj t^^ ^evTepaq tov Kvpiov Ttapovaiag laTi •jrpoKaBwg, (f>y]aiVf 6 vpocp-^Tifjg elire' " TiefJi^pco vfi.7v HXiav tov
irpiv

" "

SealSiTfjVf
€Tri(f)avrj."

eXdeTv

Tr)v

yjfxepav
lctidvvvjg

Kvpiov
r^f

tvjv

fJi.€ydXv]v

Kai
Tipo-

ovTCog ovv

Kai

TrpcoTVjg

yeyove

%pofJ.og'

Kai ev

Trvevfj.aTi

fxev, oti ooaTrep vjv eiri
liri

tov

HX/av

vj

tov ^5

Ylavayiov Y\v€Vfj.aTog ydpig, ovTtng Kai
Se ^ia TO f/.€y€6og T^g irXripovff.ivvig irap

tov

•jrpo^pofi.ov.

ev ^vo

avTcov ^iaKovtag.
eiri

T/

eaTi TO eiriaTpexpai Kap^tag iraTepm

T€Kva

;

Teoa

tou

lovSaicov

Aaoy

ol ayioi ^ATroaToXoi vTrrjpyov'

e^ ayTaJv

yap KaTrf(f)Vjaiv,

yovTO Kara t^v tov aifuaTog avyyeveiav. TOiavTvj ovv eaTai^
vj

20

Tov lcodvvov ^taKovia,

cog

hriaTpexpat Taf toJv

lov^^aicov

Kap^iag

etg TVjv

Twv ArroaToXcov ^i^aaKaXiav'
avvetarfyaye
Tvj

yap

"nepi

^piaTOv toi~
Kat Tovg

avTa

fj-apTvp-^aag,
ft.a6vjTagf

TOiavTrj

fi.apTvpia

'K.ptaTov

Kat

ro

d^toTriaTov

avToig

€k

tovtov KaT€25

aKCvaae.

To

Se

**

dvetOeTg ev
01

(f)povv}a€t

^iKaicav^ ^rjXor, OTt airetdeTg fxev
(ppovvjaig

ef dpyvig

vTrrjpypv

'lou^aro;,

^e

^iKaicov,

v)

ev

TOiV

ATroaToXotg ovaa

r]v.

To
iriaat

Se

**

€TOtfj.daat

Ku/j/oj," Kat
irpo

toc

e^^f, dvTt tov irpocvTpe€ft.Trapa-

tco 'K.piaT^ eiprjTat'

tov (f)av€pS>aai cavTOv
Xaov'

^o

aK€vov

Kat

TrpoKaT€aK€vaafj.€vov

TroXXa yap

davfj.aaTa

•npoetTrm irept

tov Kvptov

6

7rpotpofj.og, Trjv €tg

avTOV irtaTtv tov

Xaov TrpoevTpeirtaev.

18

Ka)

eiret^tr^ep

diriaT-^aag

Zayaptag, " KaTa rt yvcoaofJMi
KOi(f>OTr]Ta

" TOVTo/*

(f)r]atVf evtTtfJ.a.Tat

Kat

d(f)Coviav, coaavei

Toi/35

^'

c

10

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
irpo^

1.22.
aTTKrrtif

A^yylAou \iyovroi ravra

avToV

eTre*^^

^AyyeXa

Trapea-TyjKOTi Seoo, kou ov TriaTeveis
Koiyi^yi

tw

aiTOCTTeiXavTi

avTOv, oii^e

T^v Tov Ae-yovxof ^vvafniVf
"^ta tvjv

aXXa t^v tov

Trpdyfi.aTos «ou-

vafAiaVf
eojf

aTTKJTOv aov TavTVjV

(pcovvjv, dcpaipeBvjo-vj TVjg (fxov^g'

av Tov 'npdyixaTog TikripwBtVTog, yvwg Kai to

<jov

anKSTov Kai 5

TO ^wvaTOv ToD Seov.

*H Tiayapiov
«rwej^e/a

Koxpeva-ii, ovk e/fwX^^e/ yeyovtv

wg evo^/craf*
r^v

ev

yap

6€0(f>aveiag
[j.vaTif]pioig

Kai dyyekiKvis
^iaKOvovfxevog'

oirTaaiag

6

lepevg

KaBapSig To7g

dXXd tw

Ti/Tro)

T^g eKeitovto lo

vov aiyvjs Kai a-Teipwaeag
olfJiat

Kat yrjpovg Tey^yivai

tvjv (fxov/jv,

^yjXovv

tq

ck tov 7ra\aia6evTog Kat KaTayvjpdaavTog Kat
dvviKoia rwv ^e^afAevm vofxov tov ypaitTOv

aTetpaj^evTog
Ttept

t^

rag
eK

'KptaTov

irpoppi^aetg

itpoek^eh,

Kai

tyjv

aiiTOv

fxyjrepa

TOVTov

'7rpo€\6eiv.

22

A<a
TayT>jv
*'

^e Tov (3ovkea6at fj.a6elv tvjv aiTiav T^g

atam^g tov Xaov, 15
tovto eartv tawg,

^ia

vevfxaTog 6 Tiayaptag e^i^Aov, Kat
y]v

OTt Kat

avTog

^iavevav avTOig Kat
;

tte.fj.etve KoxfyogJ'^

T/

^e

Kat ^tevevev avToTg

to

^tavevetv

Itafxevovra

Ka}(f>ov,

TotovTOv eartv.

ai yjcptg Xoyov iipd^etg, ov^ev ^tacfyepovat vevaeav,
eiat

ai ^e jtACTa Koyov Trpd^etg, ovk

vevaetg, KoafiovvTat
tvjv

ydp
ccg

vtto
fi.yj

20

Toy Xoyov'

eav ovv

t^^yjg

lovtat<cv

iioXtTetav dXoyov,

^vvaa6at avTovg
TVTtov

^t^ovat

Xoyov

itept

m

TtpdTTOvat,

^Xeite

tov

Twv

yeyevyjfj.evwv eTtt

TAayapiov

'hiafi.evovTog

Kacf)ov kou ^ta-

vevovTog avToTg.

eart yap vvv Kwcffog 6 Xaog Kat aXaXog.
eivat, eKJSaXcbv

vag yap
d(f>

ovK yjfAcXXev aXaXog Kat dXoyog
eavTov,
vj

tov Xoyov

25

Ka).

fj.yj

tvvdfj.evog

itep)

fi.y}^evog

Xoyov dTto^ovvat

vofJ.iKOv

TtpocpvjTiKOv Xoyov.

24

Ai^en-a; ^e

oy

^EXtadjSer ^ta to

ev yvjpet

avXXaBetv, aa^pcov

yap

vjv yj

yvvv}.

OpirENOTS.
avXXd(Byi, ore
OTe
ev

E/cpyjTTev eavTVjV

eiti ft.yjvag Ttevre, ecog

Kat M.apta$o
avTVjv,

yap Mapta avveXa/3e Kat
aa7taafj.og
(3pe(pog

vjXde

Ttpog

Kai

eyevero

avTVjg
ev
Tvj

eig

ra uTa

avrvjg, eaKtpTVjaev

dyaXXidaet to

KotXia TVjg ^EXtad^er, kat Ik

YlvevfJ.aTog dyiov eXdXvjae

rd

dvayeypafxfj.eva, Kai eXaXvi^vj ev tvj
XaXvj^evTCOv
ovv

opetv^ TtavTa

ra

pvjfi.aTa

ravra.

avTcHv cag itept^^

1.33.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
wg
Trepi

11

Qetag avXXi^eujs Kai

tt^o^^toi; /x.eAAovTO<'
ei

yewaaOai

cv

Tw

Aaoj, ovK

€Ti

€avTip irepieKpvl^ev, aAA'
yevvyjfJia
eti^

Se? ovTa^

eiTreTv,

Kai evappyja-taaaTOy oti apa

avTrjg o irpo^poixos rov

KvptOV ^fXXV
Ovet^oi
eKeivotf

I»J<70V XjO;0"TOt).

^e

ev

avQpwTroig

tovto
yj

Xeyet,

oirep

ev

toT^ yjpovot^ ^
orTeTpav,

vTiyjpyeVy

TovTeaTtv

aT€Kvta, yjyovv to
iroXvTeKvta,

eivat

(oavep

enatvog

Kat

evkoyia
laavvov.

yj

Mijva eKTov Xeyei

Tov Tyjg a-vW-^rpecoi
E/7re
oe
6

KvayyeXtaTyjg

Trepi

TVji

itavayiaq

'heaitoivy\q

yi\Km

SeoiOKoVf OTt
oetl^ai

yjv ixeiJivyjaTevfx.evyj

dv^pl e| q^kov Aa/3i§ Ka} itaTptag, lo
yj

PovXofxevog, OTt
oBev Kat
6

Kat avTy]

7ravd[xa}[Jiof

eK yevovg ^v tov
ozJSe

AaPih.
^vvaTOV

jUv^o-Teuo-a^evof avT^v

'lcoa^cf}'

yap

yjv

KaTa

tov

vo[jlov

diio cf)vX^g eTepag dpfJ.o^ea6at yvvcuKa.
**

38
T>jv

Eirei^y/ te eli:ev

Seog t^ Eva,

ev Xviratg re^i^ Te/cva*" Aue^

Ay^v
^c

TavT>jv ^

X^pa

^v

6

AyyeXos

^'^at,

" Xa^p^

Key^apt- 15

"

Ta)[j.evy]

Kvptog
**

fJ.€Ta aov.'*

To

^^eAoy^^eTo TroTawoj

6«;

daitaa^j.og
fj.y]

ovtos" tovto
aTOjro?,

efj.(f>aivet,

waavet eXeye itpog eavTyfv,
;

dpd Ttg

wf c^
too

dv^pog vpog Kopyjv
da7raa[j.ca,

yj

QeJog'

eTret^y]

kou Qeov

[J-v^fJ^y]

avveaTt

to

**

6

Kvpiog
etvat

fxeTo.

aovr
(j)o(3ovft.evi^

20

30

A/a

Se

TO

jtx^

^yvaTOv, Bopv^ovfJ.evr]v Kat

dKpt^iog dKovetv to, XeyQyjaofievaf Ita tovto kvet TtpwTov avTyfg
Tov
(f)ol3ov

6

AyyeXog

eiTtoiVy ** fLy] (pojSov M.aptaf/.,^^

tva ev

ara-

pa^ia. yevofj.€vyj, ^e^i^Tou Ty]v Qetav dTtoKpiaiv.

To
KOtvov
**

fj!ev
y]v'

ovv evpov

eivelv tov

AyyeXov
itpo

itpog

avT>?v,

**

evpeg ydptv'^ 25
eiTteiv

yap yaptv

avTVjg

Kat akXat, ro ^e
e-aayyeXiav.
T-rjg

avXXi^xpyjf^ ovK€Tt Kotvcv

y]v,

dXX

i^^td^ov etg

E/we

^c TovTo, tva Sc^Itj tov Kvptov e^ avTVjg
ryjg y]fJ.€T€pag

itapQevtKyfg

w^vog KOi eK

ovaiag Xa^ovTa

Ty]v

adpKa.

32

AiKaiwg ^e €kX^6v]

^li^aovg 6 eitt

acoTyfpia tov y]fj.eTepov yevovg

^o

eXQav' TO yap ovofna tovto eig t>?v
XofJ.€voVf

'EAAo^a yXiaaaav fj^era^aX-

Qeov XeyeTai
*'

acoTy]pia Ka\ 'iaatg.
^ecTTroTi^f

To
oy%
**

Sc

eaTat /xeyaf," wj

Kat ^y]fj,tovpyog ^y]XoT, Kat
*

o}g

i(aavvY]g'

to yap €TtayofJ.€vov OTt
YlSig ^e (f)y)atv

Ytog
*'

Yi\/taTOV kXi^o^-

crcTai" TOVTO e[J.(patV€t.

Xiog 'Txptarov kXi^-^^

C 2

12
ov](7€Tai
;

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
ebei

1.

34.
(0$

yap fAaAAov emeiVj iiog

lipta-Tov

vnapyei^

Trpo

Tuv aiavav €K tov YlaTpog yewvjSevTos avTov.

aW

epov^eV

OTi hxjirep wv <pva-ei d^yj&vig

Qeog
to

6

Tlog, eAa/3ev ev ^copeag [^epei

^ia

TO

avdpcoTTtvov

to

ovofi.a

vnep

Trav

ovo[xa,

TovTecTi TO

KaXe^crBat Qeog'
^vjfjLtovpyog

Kat acmep av Kvpiog 7rdcv]g Tvjg KTicrecogf wg ^

Kat notviTvjg, €K Qcopeag XafxlSdvei TtaTptKVjg eig K\vjpoeOvvi

vofxiav
**

Ta

^ia to avOpantvov.

"

atTviaai^

ydp

(f^vjai

"

irap^

e/xov,

Kat ^aaco

crot eBvv] tvjv Kkvjpovo[J.tav

aovJ" ovTag av (pvaei

Kat dXYi&ag Tiog, Kat eK TVjg ovatag eKXdfxxpag tov
TrdvTOiV

UaTpog

icpo

Tuv atmwv,
'

'*

Kat TO

xvcc^,/
Spovov

bwaet
Se

»5,v~> 'f Oe tv; otKovofxia apfxoTTet.
/

Ttog YxpiaTOv" KaXenat, §;a to dv6pa7rtvov. 10

ovK

aiaQYjTOv Xeyet,

dkXa

tov

fLVj^ev

Svvjtov

Kat

eiriKVjpov

eyovTa, tov Ka6 o\v]g Ty^g oiKovfLevvig (fxoTog ^ikviv eKXdf*.-

TTOVTa, Kai

^v^ag
Se

voepag KaTavyd^ovTa,
laKafB^ f/^ to

'^ta TVjg

evBeov tt^taaKaXtag.
vofj.ia(Ofj.ev,
vjft.aVf

Ka/

otKOV

\ovtai(i)V

eSvog fLOvov

15

dXXa

Kai itdvTag Tovg tta T^g KXviaecog tov HcoT^pog

e^

dndvTav twv e6vav

etg tv^v toov dytcov vioSeaiav etairotovfi.evovg.

RaatXeiav ^e TeXog ovk eyovaav ov^evog eaTi tov
€t
fJiV]

(3aa-iXevetVy

fj.ovov

ToD

tvjfj.tovpyov

Kat "heaTiOTov
^ta

tS>v

oXm

0eov.

wcrTe

avToV

ecTTt

l3aatXevg

aloovtog,

tv^v

vjfxeTepav

a-aTVjpiav

20

dvOpwirog yeveaBat KaTO^e^dfJ.evog.

34
**

Ovy^ wg

airtaT^aaaa

v]

Travayta

irap&evog

to

"

Trwg

eaTat

TovTO, €7re/ avtpa ov ytvwaKoo" Xeyet,
fiaSeiv

dXX wg

ao(f>v]

tov Tpoirov
ov^e

eirt^vjTovaa

tov

vpayfj.aTog

tov

Xeyofievov.

yap

yeyove irpoTepov Tt TOtovTov, ov^e
Vri

fJ.eTd

TavTa yev-^aeTaf Xeyw 25
6

TO TrapSevov TeKeh, o6ev Kai
epfJ.v]vevci}V

avyyivwaKet

AyyeXog, Kat tov
eirt

Tpoirov
**
**

Xeyet,

**

Y]vevfj.a

Aytov e^eXevaeTat

ae, Kai
'^vvafj.ig

tvvafj.tg

'TxpiaTOv^ Kat
ao(f)ta," cog
;

Ta

e^^<'.

" ^ptaTog

Se

Seov
Kat
Ve

Kou

Qeov

hi^daKet

^AiroaToXog.
evepyvjaei

irag

fj.ev

eireXevaeTat

ovk o\\m

to

eirep')(pfj.evov,

'hvifj.tovp-

30

yiKwg

fJ.v]

(f>aivQfx.evov.
**

35

T/

&€ eo-TiV

eaiaKidaei aot ;" 7rept(3aXei ae Kai

ev^^vav]

ae

Ka\ irepf/apaKwaet ae, Kai kvkXco aov eaTat.
^pv) ^e aKoirv]aai irwg oX^v avTV]v
tv]v

iravaytav Kat ^coQTroiOV

Tptd^a

e^e<f)v]vev e/srwv,

Flvey^a 'Aytov Kai ^vvafxtv, Kat TxptaTOV. 35

1.

41.
<7vyyiva)(XK€t le

AOYKAN ETArrEAIOY.
tw Zay^apia
o

.

13

Ov

"Ayye^^os aTria-T^aavTi ^iKaiai,

^iOTi

ityev Ikuvo^ €iV vTrotuy(j.a Kai

aKXag

(TTeipaf irpo avTov

y€vof*.€va$ Kai T€KOvaag,

ag al SeTat ypa(f>ai
<^ri<xi

'^i^<x.aKOv<n,

0^5^
Acf,
iva

(xirXctii

te TO y^vaixivov
e^coQev

itpog ttiv

irapSevov 6

Ayye-

fxy]

€Trei(rayo(JL€vov
croi),"

avTy

(7wi/.a

vofXKJ-Q^,

ak\

5

«TTiyyaye

Kat

to " eK

tva

e^

avT^i (pvaei to

yevcc[ji.evcv

eivat TTt^TTevOyj,

'Aytov Se

KXyjOi^^rofJLtvoy

ovy^

wg

evotKOv

e^ovTa tov Tiov tov

Seovy Kat eK

fj.eToyyjq (xyiaa-6r]ao[j.evov, <xX\

wf cvra K(XTa

<pv(7ty

aytov, TOJ Tov avTOV Tiov vnap^^eiv Qeov Kai eva eivai.

10
eiTtev

^vyyev^

Se

t^? Ylavaytag itapBevov
iipoTr(XTopog

Trjv

EX«ra)SfT

Ayyekog^ etre ag e^ kvog
^ia TO
<j>v\yjg

tov
tov

laKwP

vitap^^ov^xag, etTe

Tipo

TTjg

vofJ.o6e(7ia$^ Xa(3eiv

Aapav

eK Trjg tov Aevi

ovza yvvalKa
a^(\(l>vjy

ttjv

EX/c7a/3eT, BvyaTepa ovaav tov A/A/va^lovta
<f>vk^g

Sa^,

T*?v

Aaaawv, Ik T^f
avv^<f>6i^
vj

virapyovTog. 15
<f>vkrj,

Kot yap evTavSa
vitrjpyev

^aaiKiKr}

tov 'lov^a
rj

€^

rjg

EiktadPeT.

^to

Kat irapo^o^cag

irdvao^pog tov itavaytov

WvevfLaTog

(£KOV0fj.riae

yjxptg, Kat

TavTVjv tvjv Za^^^aptov yvva^Ka
oii(og '^ta

'EAio-a/JfT TTpoaayopeveaBai, leaiiep Kat Trp tov Aapwv,

Tou ovofJiaTog
iraapyei
yj

evapyccg /*a5wjM,ev, ag

e|

eKetwjg Tvjg

Kktaa^^T ao

avyyeveta,
rj

38
Ta

Ktirovaa ^e

Ylavayta TrapSevog, "

/^ot»

yj

^ovXyj

Kyp/ou" Kat
j3ovXeTai

e^^g, tovto eS^Awo-e, Tnva^

ejjU./, <f>y]at,

ypa(f>ofj.evog^

ypa<f>evg ypa<f>eT(a, -KotetTO)

SeXet
Ti^g

tov itavTog Kvptog.
tvjv ofj.okoyiav

Ae^a/xevof Se

o

"AyyeXog

itavayiag itap6evov

25

rrjg itiaTectig, aTtyjXSev ait

avTrjg.

ETtopevdrj

Ce

r}

itavayia itapSevog elg t^v
eKei
(CKet

opeiwjv

itpog

tt/v

EXtaoiPeT,

eitet^y]

Zayapiag, yvmat

j3ovXo[J.€vi^

to

Ttepag av etitev 6

AyyeAof
twv

itpog ain^v.
itpo<f>y]Twv
Tr]

Ovep
yeyovev,

oe

ov^evt

vTirjp^e,

tovto

elg

'lceavviyv^o

Ota to TtXriatd.Xetv axnov

^piaTOv
Ayiov

itapovaict K<ti Ttpo-

Tpey^etv avT^g.
ea>f ov

ho

ov^e itpoTepov tov
yj

Ylvevfj.aTog eitX.-^a^ri,

eveaTfj avToi
&e

Kvo<f>opovaa tov teaTtOTriv \ptaTov.

41

ToTC
fxere^i^ov

'7t\v]a6eig

UvevfiLaTog 'Ayiov, ea^ipTa Kal

t^

fJLvprpi

Tv^g

yaptTog,

Kat

ave^oa

Ttpo(f>r]TtKa

vj

'KXtadjSeT ^$

14
p^jaara, ^ia 10

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Kvii(j)opov[Jie.vov €V

1.

42.

avryj (3p€(f>o$,

"

tvXoyvj[j.€vy] <jv

"

ev yvvai^i^

keyovaa "
yapirog

Kai evXoyrjfxevoi^ Kai

to,

e|^f.

ov^^efxia

yap
"

roiavryjg

Koivmog,

ovre

yeyovev,

ovre

yeveaOai

^vvarat.

42

K.ap7T0v ^e KoiXiag" eliie,
rvjv

Kara

t*?v

TiaXaiav rov 0eoi) npog 5
rvjg

Tov Aa(3i^ eirayyektav

Xeyovjav, " Ik Kapitov

KOiXtaf

"

awdvjcrofxat

eirt

rov
y]

Qpovov

aov" KaXag
uvofjiaa-e,

^e Kapirov KOi\iag r^^g

Ttavayiag iiapOevov
eivatf

^EXtaa^er

^ia ro

[Jir]

e| av^tpog

«AX

eK

[j.ovy]g

r^g navayiag QeoroKov Mapiagf Ylvev[J.arog
ev
ot

'Aytov

evotKy](Tavrog

avryj,

Kat

r^g rov 'TipicrTov
t*;v

tvv(X[J.ewg

10

eiit^yKtadacrYjg avryj.

yap eK rwv Ttarepm

(nropav eyovreg,

eKeivm etat Kapnot, Kadag Kat rw Aa(3i'^
KOtXtag, rovreartv
ot

eppeQy], eK

Kapitov ryjg

Tcpoyovot ry]g Ttavaytag 6eoroKOV, Kat avrot

eK (ynopag

av^pm

yevvy]6evreg.

YiV[j.(f)ma te

rm

[/.ekXovrm

vtto

loodwov \eye(76at,

yj

[J.y]r'f]p

15

avrov aTre(f)6eyyero' axnrep yap eKeHvog ava^tov eavrov
ovatag

ry]g irap[t.ot

t%

Tiap^evou 6eoroKov, aaavei Xeyovaa, rt
yj

yap

rY]Xtirpog

Kovrov TieTtpaKrai aya6ov, iva
[j.e.

["-"^rY^p

rov Kvpiov

[x.ov eXBy]

KaXel ^e avry]V

[j.y]repa

rr]V

ert

Kvo(f)opovaav,

Trpo^py^riKa

Xoyco 7rpo(f)6<xvovaa ry]v Kvy]atv.

20
Trtarevaaaav, " ort earat reXeto}-

MaKapii^et ^e avryjv wg

vj^y]

"

aig ro7g XeXa\y][i.evotg avrv]

napa Kvpiov."
xpvyv] [xov rov

46

KiTTovaa ^e

"

[j.eya\vvet

v]

Kvptov"

rj

Tcavayta
oaov

Ttap^evog, etet^ev

eavryjv

Kapitov "^o^oXoytag

Ttpoacftepovaav.

yap,
^etv

<f)y]atv, v'nY]perov[j.at /xe-yaAco 6av[/.ari,

roaovrov

0(f)eiX(a ^o^<x-

25

rov ev

e[/.ot

evepyovvra •napo^o^a.
eTep<f)6y]

"hto

Kat y^yakkt<xaaro ro
eitt

TrvevfiLa

[t.ov,

rovreartv
'2ci}ry]p

Kai

y]^vv6y]

rw ©eco

tc5

Y.(t)T'^pt [J.OV.

[kov

ydp eart Kai Qeog'

acory^ptav ru) KoafLco

^t

e[j.ov 'yapt'^o[j.evog.

itvev^j.a te

Kat '^vyr]V ro avro keyet.
e[j.e,

48

Kat

eTte/SXexpe

Se',

(pyjatv, eii

ov^e
vvv

yap
etg

eyo) TtpoaetoKiqaa

30

TOyTO, raTtetVT]
[i.era(3atvci})

ovaa Kat ava^ta, Kat

ovpavov

dito

yy]g
07

appy]TOV otKovo[i.tav eKitky]povaa'

Kat

ovyi av

[kovy]

FiXiadfSer,

aXXa

Kat

itdvrm

rm

Tttarevovrm [/.aKaptovat
eitoiy^ae
[t,ot

[j.e

Ttdaat

at yeveat, Kat

yap [KeyaXeia

6

^vvarog, ort

itap6evog

ovaa avveXa^ov, vTtep(3daa

t>;v <f)vaiv ^ovXyj^jmti

avrov,ZS

$

1.

54-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOY.

15

Kat.

KaTa^iovfJL€vv] avev avtpog, ovy^ awAcSf e/va* /Ai^T^yp,

aAAa tou
airicT^a^ai

fxovoyevovs Tlov tov

Seov Kai Qeov.
6

Aia

^e to

[jl^

Tiva

Tw
6

TOiovTQ} fxvaTyjpio}, eiirev

^yvaTOf, coaavei

eAeyev, oti

^waTOg

TovTo evepyyjaai Qeog.
e/7re

Ayiov Se
V€Taif etg
*

to ovojaa ayTov, ^YjXovaa OTt ovhev Trapay^jpat6

yvvalKa (rv\\a[xl3avo[xevo$

Tav dndvTav ^r/fxtovpyoi.

iva/ TO eAeo^- de «yTOv etg yeveag

Kai

Ta

e$iyf.

e3re/0>;

Qta to

eXe^aai Ta? yeveaf tov yevewv
YlpoireSi^Ke Sc
**

aweX-^cf)^!^.

tois <f)o^ov[Jievotg ayTOV," ot< ot TrdvTyj avaJ^toty

Kai

ev Tri

dirta-Tta ^tafJievovTes

ovk eXeovvTat, aAA'

01

^i

httyviO-10

aeoog •npog TriaTtv Kat fj.eTdvoiav fj.eTaTpeTrofj.evot.

51

*'

Exo/jjcre &e

KpaTog^ kcu

to.

e^^f.

ene^ t%

ovtov yeipog
Ttog,

ovK dvSpomov to epyov.

Kai yap (Bpayiajv tov YlaTpog
tt

KaTa TO "
vtKr^v

eXvTpQXTco ev (Bpay^iovi aov tov Xaov crov."
e<nri<Te,

avTov ovv
Tvpav- 15
tovtcov

etpydaaTOf Kai Tponaiov
vorfTxv

KaTa twv
^e

itdXat

vovvTwv

eyPpav.

**

AteaKopirtae"

Kat

Tag

avTvv Kap^tag, twv t^ ttavoia avTwv Tag KaQ
Kai
v]fi.tt>v

imeprj^pdvccv, TovTecrTt

Tag (3ovXag

aTrpaKT^aat not-^aag.
ovg

Toinovg ^e avTOvg

^vvdaTag
vao

Kake"!,
Trjv

KaGeXwv
yeipa,

vxpatTe
**

Tovg

TaTretvaxxavTag

eavTOvg
**

KpaTaiav

&eSwAca)S'

avTolg

e^ovatav 20

iraTeiv endvca

o<j>ea)v

Kat aKopTiim, Ka) evi Ttaaav

t*;v tvvafj.tv

**

Toy (y(Bpov^^

Ka;

'*

TreivwvTaf" fxev Toiig e| e^vwv \tfJ.wTTOVTag Oetwv
Tijg

Xoym
Tovg

KOi ^t^aa-KaXiag, eveitXrjaev dyaBu)v, twv
Se

veag ^taB^^Krjg.

TW

vofJ.a}

TtXovTovvTag ^lov^aiovg, Kai

TO^ig

Ttpo^rjTaig itiaivo-i^

fxevovs, Kevovg e^aTtecTeiXe, fj^ ttpoa^e^afj.evovg tov VTto tov vofxov

Kat tZv

7tpo<f)r/Tu>v 7tpo6ea7rt^Oft.evov
*'

"KptaTOv tov Qeov

v]ft.wv.
jtxev

54

To
itpog

§€

dvTeXdPeTO

'lapaviX Ttat^^og avTotJ," ^uvaTa*
dpfJ.oaat'

Kat

Tov KaTO.

adpKa ^lapa^X tovto
tS)

itoXXat

yap e^

avTav
Ttpog

f/.vptdteg tttaTevaaaat

Kvpif

eacoBrjaav.

^vvaTat Oe Kat 30

Tov vo»yTOV Io-^a>;A tov ev tco voi opcivTa Qeov' tovto
01

yap
\

laparjX epfi.r}veveTat, otTtveg etatv
**

eK twv eOvav ittaTevaavTeg.

¥ifj.vria6ri

Ve tou eXeovg avTov
ottep
rpt

KaBwg eXdXvjae" Kat Ta
avTOv, ort

e^rjg,

eig

Ttepag

dyaym,

elirw» itpog

"

evevXoyrjB'^-

" aovrat

ev

airepfLaTi aov Ttaaat at (f^vXai Tvjg 7^?."

35

16

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
"
EfjL€iV€

I.56.
SiyAor oti ewf
jtxijv/

^6

8e Maptafx. aiiv avT^^^ Kai to. c^^f.
e/ "ya^j

ov TiKTCtv e/AcAAev ^ 'EA;<ra/3€T.
Aiyx^ecuf

ra

e«rraj

t^^ o-yA-

avT^f aveaTaX^
efxetve
crvv

6 A-yyeAof wpos' t^v itavayiav irapBevov.

aireXOovaa ^e

avTyj [x^vaf Tpe?5", Trpo^vjXov oti TtXripcO'

BevTOi Tov y^ovov T^f
avTYji vireaTpeipev
y}

cruAA^il/eojf

t^^ EA;cra)9eT,

€/$ tov

oikovS

Ttavayia TrapBevoif ^ta to /xeAAov (yvvetaeptov
oIkov

yeaOai

irXyjQog
tjv

elg

Tioyaptov,

ev

Trj

TVjg

EiXtaa/SeT

yevvyjcfei'

yap

al^cog ev tyj itavayta TtapQevta TrapdevtKyj.
efx,etvev
;

Tivog ^e yapiv
eKJ3a(7tv,
[J^ewij

'laccg

Kat toD Trapa^o^ov

Beccpvjo-at t»jv

Kai

eirt

Tolg

KaO eavTvjv aitopovad Te Kat eKTtXyjTTO- 1 o

Kat Ti ^e-^aet yeveaGai ^ovXevofAevrj.
ttJ

YlapaTfjpriaadBat Se^ ev oAtj

vakata

^taB-^KY}

Kat Tyj Katvy

ypacfi^f etTTOv eaTtv ent dfxapTCoXov yeveceasg etpi^fxevov to,
*'

"

eirX'^ei fxy}

aOy]

yjfovoq Toy TeKeiv^

otfi.at

Be OTt ovk dv Tt$ eypot,
yevvctift.evog.

fjLOvov OTTov avofi.a<7Tat OTt "biKaiog

eaTiv 6

15

AtaTt

fj.eTa

t^v

•TreptTOfi.^v,
;

to ovofna eKaaTov Ttattog TtBeaBat
yjv

vofiog TtpoaeTaTTev

eTteiV/j

tovto KaXov

TtpcoTOv Trjv Ik

Seov

TtpocjTayPelcrav kaj3eiv <T(f)payida, TOVTeaTt t^v TteptTOfJ^qv, Kat eig

Xaov Seov

yjpyifiMTta-at,
yj

Kat Tore to avdpooittvov '^e^aadat ovofka.
'la)avv>?v

Ovy^ ditXag Se
opofit.ov,

^EtXiad^eTf

eiVe KXyjByjvat tov

"Ttpo-

20

aXX wg

itpocpi^Ttg

ovaa

vito

T\vevfj.aTog 'Ayiov Ktvovfj.evr].

ovOe yap eyivccaKev to. ypyjfj.aTtaSevTa
avTYi aityjyyetXev
fj.y}

tw Zayapia'

Ttwg

yap av

XaXav

;

03

**

Anyjaag

^e

TtivaKt^tov^

6

Zayapiag eypaxpe
Ttcog

to

ovofia,
;

eTtetoy]
**

ota vevfj.aTog ovk yjtvvaTO tovto ^t^Xaaat.
eTtettyjitep

ydp

25

E^ayjaaaav TtdvTeg,"
yj

ofiLocpoovvjaav

ot€

Zayapiag
Katitep
\cadvvyjg

Kai
levov

KXtadjSeT
bv,

Ttept

tov ovoft.aTog
ayTwv.

IwavvTjv

eiitovTeg,

etg

Trjv

avyyevetav
fj.eTa.

'EpfLfjveveTat

^e

0eoy ydptg,

^to

Kat

to ypdxpat avTOv to ovofna, evQecag

Tyj

Tov @eov yaptTi, avecayOfi avrov to aTOfua, Kat eXaXet evXoyav 30
Tov
'

0eov, Kat

Ttpo(j>yiTevcav
cog
yj^yj

Ta

avayeypafj.fj.eva,
tcS

TtpaTOv fxev
^ica,

Ta

itapa Tov ^ptaTov,

€'7ti'^v]f/.yjaavTog

vaTepov ^e

Kat

Ttept

Tov

lctidvvov.

05

l^taTt oe

eyevero

eTtt

Ttavrag <popog;
ev

tva coaTtep

eitt tv] atcoity]

Zayaptov

e^earv] 6

Xaog, ovtco Kat

rw XaX^aat

avrov,

oitcag

35

1.74dia Tos

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
tva tovtwv

17

rm

QavfXMTm Xoy i^ovTai

TrdvTegy Trepi t&v Tep^Scv-

"Jiai^og'

Tavra

Se itdvTa TipoKaTeaKevd^ovTo TioppuOev,

waTe

a^ioiriaTov eivat tov

tw ^piaTa ^apTVpyjaai fxeWovTa.

KvXoyav
avTov

Tov Seov 6 Tta^^^apiag eTtioKOTtrjv Xeyei yeyovevai irap

irpoq tov

Xaov avTOv, Xeycov ovTcog, " evXoyfiTog Kvpiog
Kai Ta
Trjg
eg-^g.

6

5

xyeog tov

laparjA oti
ovtoi

oiTiveg eiaiv 01 tco
aJ^ioi

XpiaTia

TTiaTevaavTeg'
eig

yap

eTiiaKOTtyig

yeyovaaiv, evepyov

eavTovg t^v Qeiav emaKOTi^v dno^ei^avTeg.

09
y]

Hiog Qe

vjyeipe

Kepag aaifjpiag
17

-^[xiv

Kai

Ta

eg^^g

;

to Kepag
i

dvTi l3aaiXeiag,
6

dvTi ^vvdixea^g TiapeiXyjTiTai t^ 6eia ypatpyj.
6

o

d[x,<poTepa Se

^ptaTog eaTiv

Ik

Tifjg

iiaTpidg tov Aa(3i^ dva7]

TeiXag'

avTog ydp eaTiv
^vva[j.ti

^aaiXevg twv /BaatXevovTaVf Kai
vj

dKaTafAdyvjTog
TpOTiioaafxevt},

tov YlaTpog,

ndvTag Tovg eyQpovg
7ipo(f)Y)TU)v

rjfjJhv

Kora

t>jv tc!jv dyi(av

avTov

npoaayopevatV

Tidai

yap

Totg

Jipo(pr}Taig

to

Tiepi

tov
tcov

\piaTov KaTriyyeXTai 15

fJivaTvjpiov,

Kai

pvaafxevrj
tcov

rjfxdg

eK

eyQpm
te

rjijiav,

Kat

eK

%etpos TidvTeav

fj.iaovvTm

^fndg'

eyBpm

ovk

ataQrjim,

aXXa
72

vorfTm.
notrjaai te eXeog jW,€Ta twv

To "
voeiv, OTi

naTepm

y]fj.m" ovTag

5^^

TO eig ^fxdg yevofj.evov eXeog, Kai npog Tovg naTepag 20
eTiataQofKevot
ev(f)poavvr]g.

^fjMV avaTpeyei, Tovg vepi tov APpadf/..
etg yjfxdg evepyeaiag, KOtvmot yivovTat
T-i^g

ydp

Tvjg

Ylept lavTrjg ^e Xeyei
rjg

fj.vria6rjvai

^taB-^Krjg

dyiag avTOv,

iiept

Tipog

tov ^A^padfJ. tteBeTO

Xeym, "

Kai evevXoyrjQrjaovTai

ev

Tco aTiepfj.aTt
*

aov ndvTa Ta
a)fj.oae

eQvrj

Kat iidaai at <f)vXai Trjg yrjg."
^
'

^vixv « "r\ yjpKov Qe ov
<f)y}atv,
'*

npog AppaafJ. tov naTepa
Seog'

^'a/5^

yjfJMV,

«~j>~' tovtov
ae, Kat tiXijeig

25

OTt etTiev
7iXy}6vv(o

avT^
<re."

6

" evXoym evXoy^av
yap to
avToi.

6vvm

e7iXY/6vv6y}

avepf/.a ^A^paafj.,

aiiepf/.a

Kat

Tm

e6vm Xoyta6evTm

Kat

€7re/^»;

TioXXdKtg pvovTai riveg eK %€/^of e/6pm, f/.eTa^o
<f>y]ai,

'j/\.<j>o^ov ^e,

tid TOVTO

" tov

^ovvat

y]f/.Tv

d(f>ol3ci>g

eK yetpog^
y]fj.dg

Kat

Ta

e^yfg.

Kat

ydp

v]

HptaTov
pva6^vat,

hitty}fj.ia,

7ieTioiy)Kev

a(f>oP'j}g

eK

yetpog

eydpm

ov

yap

y}a6av6Yifj.ev

ryjg

ent^ovXYig twv ey6pm, dXX^ at(f>vt^tov y}p7iaaev Yjfidg fxeTaaT-^aag

dv eKeivm

(ti)

tov KXyjpov kou t^v fj.epi^a avrov.

'^to

kou yjfxeigSS

D

18
0(f>ii\ofi€v

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
^arpeveiv avrw ev
rtva
Katpov,
oo-iotvjti

1. 76.

kui ^iKaiocrvvrjf onep ov

yiverat
VJfAltiV.

^ta

a\ka

ita^jai

raf

y]fj.€pai

T^f

^«^f

76

Ti

^^TTOTe Se

»?

irpog aKQvovToi

(f^vjat'

"

Kai cv '^at^iov •npovjv

"

(f>r]Ty]s
fJLVj

TxpKTTOv

kXyjOvjO''/]

;"

Kat yap TrepiTTOv

ravra Xeyctv 5
apa
oirep

voovvTt

TiatVioci.

yjnr]

ovv VTToKa^eTvf ort [xrjTroTe
lctidvvvj^,

Trapa^o^ov yevvrjatv eayev
Kvjpv^avTO^,

are
ev
tv]

ApyayyeKov
Kot\ta rvjg
t^JJ

ravrrjv
fj.YiTpog

are avrov

aKipTyjtjavTog

VTrep (f>vatv eirt rr] Tiapovata. rvji itavayiag -Trapdevov

Trpog T>yv

'KKt(Td(3eT, ovro}

Kai yevvyjSevrt, irapdto^ov

'^ty]

Kat

rrjv

itapa-io

KoXov$Y]<rtv 60"%e ryjg ataOvjaewg.

Tdy^iov ^e avT'2 itapovTt Ttpoe<pY]rev(Tev

TtaTYjp

Aeywv,

**

'Ttpo-

"

7topev(Ty]

yap
y]tet

itpo

7tpo(7007tov
Ttpo^-rjryjg,

K.vpiov
ort

erotfxdaat

o^ovg avrov'^^

e7tet^y]Ttep

wg

fxer

oXiyov ov

fieWet eyetv
ort 15

avrov Ttap
**

eavrw

rpe(f)Ofxevov'

(f)V](jt

yap

F,vayye\tcrTV]g,

i]v

ro itatttov ev ra7g
l^jpa-^K."

ep'f]fJ.otg,

e(ag

r]ff.epag

dva^et^ecog avrov

"

Ttpog Tov

"

Tvwcrtv ^e

(rcoTVjpiag^^

<py]crt

^ovvat

ro7g dvOpooTtots

rvjv

rov
eitt-

\pt(Trov' y]Ttg yvactg (TC0TV]pta ecrrai avroTg rolg OeXvjcraatv

yvavat

rr]v acori^ptaVf
'Jtoog

lov^aiotg re Kat

'

KXkY^at.
(f)V]atv
e^ni

20

Aeyet Se Kai

earat

yj

rov ©eov

yvcoatg acorvjpia, ort

"

ev d(f)eaet dfj.aprt(ov" earat, ovrcog eXe-^aavrog

rov Seov rovg
'^f/.cov

yY]g,

Kai yap
oy^e
olg

cog

dkY]6ag

'^ta

aitXdyyya ekeovg %eov
eitof^aafj.ev
YjfJ.e7g.

y]Xe'^-

6v]fi.ev'

ydp ^td t» epya d

70
Kat

Ev

rov itarpog aitXdyyyoig e^TteaKexparo
Yjfj.h

Y]fJ.dg

e^ vi^ovg 25
fxovoyevyjg

e| ovpavov dvaretXag

Y]Xiog

'^iKaioavvY]g,

Tiog rov Qeov Kat Qeog

Y]fi.m.

Ka; " aKorog
dft.apTiav, ^ta ro

fxev
fLv]

Xeyet

rv]v dyvcoatav.

" aKtdv

^e Savdrov' rv]v
aicovtov,

eivat aiaOvjrov Gdvarov,

dXX^

eiKOva

oe ej^e^v Bavdrov.
i/^yj^iyj",

coaitep

ydp

aiaGvjTog

Bdvarog ycoptafj.ov e/et ^o

ovrcog

vj

dfJ.apTia yjxiptafj.ov YlvevfxaTog 'Aytov.
elp-^vvjg" "^v^XoT, tva, (f)Y]a},

To
rov

§e

"

eig o^ov

rd rov

(3tov vjfj.wv
t*;v

^ta^'f]fj.ara KarevGvvY],

Kat o^Yjy^aY] etg
KY]pvyfj.a'
tyjv

ry]v

^t^aaKaXiav

eav-

ILptarog Kat ro
KTteioY]

rovro ydp eartv o^og
rv]g

etpY]VY]g.

oe

Kard

dvaXoyiav

yjXtKiag

•7tvevfi.artKY]g

35

II. I.
vj^iovro

AOYKAN ETArrEAIOT.
yapiTOi
o
Trpo^pof/.o^f ^ia,

19
o

tovto

(pvjaiv

KvayyeXiaTtji

"

TO ^e TtaiYiov vjv^ave Kai eKparatovTO TrvevfxaTi"
Lita TovTO Qe
'

cv

Tats

€p7]fJioi$

yjv

ecog

avaoeiqeas
e^ci)

Kat

ra

e|%.
TTO/i"

tva

Tov vTrepKoafxtov
yiy

fxvjvvcov

^piaTOVf

TVjg ev

avQpa)~

KaKiai

Kai

ottco^

ai^tOTTKJTog fxapTvg (pavyj, [xapTvpaiv too 5

"KpiaTWj Kat

Trjv

KaKiav eXeyyjov jaera Trappriatag.

KE^.
Ka;
TVjv yyjv,

A.

Ilcpt rfjs d7roypa(f)TJs.

1

eTret^Yjftep

KaSoXtKyj '/aptg eKXa[j.7reiv efxeWev

eU Ttaaav
10

yiveTat ev irpoaTayfj.a
oXyj

Ka&

oXvjg Tvfg oiKOVft.evy]s,Hoi}T^pog
<f>i^(Tt

evof

Ka6

r^

oiKOVft.evyi

yevvcofJLevov'

yap

6

Kvayye-

KtaTyjg,

"

eyeveTo Se ev Ta7g yjfxepaig eKetvaig, e^yjXBe toyfxct^ Kat

Ta

e^yjg.

Ka) ^ia tovto ^e ytverat tovto,
tvjv

eTrei^yj

yj

a7roypa(f>Yi

avTYi

y£yiatft.ct>g

"navayiav TrapOevov
yj

e^eTrefLirev

etg

ByjOXeeft.

reKeiv,
**

tva Trkyjpcody]

Xeyovaa
fny}

Tipo(f>y)Teta

"

Kat av BijfiAee/x, 15
ev

oiKog rov

K(f>pa6a,
01»

oXiyoarog

ei *

rov eivat
eivat
eig

y^tXtaatv
ev

**

lof^a,
rco

el

yap

fxot

e^eXevaerai roy

apxovra

**

lapayjX.^^
6

^varyjpiov rt fx^ya ^ovXerai
rvfv rvji

Xoyog Trapaar^aat, ort
e&e/
tv]

etg

oiKovfxevvjg

oXvjg

avaypa(j)VjV

avaypa(f>y}vat
oiKovfxevv],

\ptarov 20

li^aovv,

tva

avvavaypa(f>eig

roTg

ev

aytaay] rv]V

otKovfxev^v, Kat fxera6r] rviv a7roypa(f>v]v ravrvjv eig Pi(3Xov ^covrcov,

tva

ra ovofxara

rcov

avyypacpevrcov avrco Kat Trtarevovrcov avrco,

eyypaipy] ev To7g ovpavoig.

I21ACPOT IlHAOTSiaTOT.

A7r€ypa(f>v)

6

K.vptog Kat

Kvjvaov 25

ereAecre Kaiaapi, toj Kpdrei vofxo6ercav vTrordaaea6ai, orav fxvj^ev

iiapa^XdTtry] itpog rvjv evae^etav.

Atart einev
ovoe

RvayyeXtari^g
eay^ev
viov
vj

**

tov vtov avrvjg rov TrpcororoKov'^^
;

yap aXXov

•navayia 6eoroKog Kai detTrap6evog

eveiOvi

Qeog vndpyet

dXy]6tvog
y]fi.cov

e^ ainvjg aapKco6eig Kvptog vjfJiMV^o
'^ta rvjv

Ivjaovg ^ptarog.

yeyovev

adpKcoaiv d^(X(f>og, rovrov

yaptv

c>>vofxda6r] TtpcaroroKog, cog irpcorevcov ev Ttdatv

avrog.

Ev

ryj

(f>drvvi

Se KaraKXtverai, Koi %ta ro
a
li

fxvj

vndpyetv

fxev

Cod.

20

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
yeypamai,
€ti

II. lo.
^e
iva

avTOis TOTTog ev tco KaTakv[i.aTi, KaOwg
v}fj.ag

Tvjg

aXoyiag

eXevOepcoa'!^,

tov

KTYjvoTrpe'^^

fxeTa[xei\pavTas

PioVf Kai Tfjv avBpaiToii Trpeirovcxav avaKT^a-afxevovs avveaiv.

KE<>. B.
Ilfpi tS)V

aypavkovvrav
tyi

iroifievcov.

t

E7r€/^^

^e

Kai itpoTepov ev

TraXaioi irvevfxaTiKoTg TTOifxecri

TQig 7rpo(f)-^Taig

Ta irapa Qeov

^ieiropOfji.eveTo py}fJ.aTaf

^ia tovtq

Kai vvv ^ia Twv ai(76v)Tav
acrcofJiaTOt;

TroifJ.evav

to avTO yiveTai.
avTvjg upa6ri tco

Kai yap o
yevet twv
e^YjXovv
i

aapKa
eTi

TrpocXalSofi.evog, ^t

avdpooTrav.

Se

Kat ^ia to airXaaTovg avTOvg elvat'
ot

o

yap

TVjv

iraXaiav iroXiTeiav, Trotfj.aivovTeg wairep

iraTptapyat

Kat avTOg

MwyV^f.
**

lo
ov

T(9

^e

^Ttg ecTTat TravT/

tco

Aao?" tco t»v avOpairm

'^vjXoif

fj.ovov Toj

Twv

loi/^a/cwv.

14
*

Oirep ^e to TrXrjQog Ti^g ovpaviov aTpaTiag atvovvTeg eXeyov, 15
ooi;a
ev

vxptaTotg Weou Kai
"to^a Tca
ev

eirt

yrjg etprjvvj,

Kai Ta
eirt

eqvjg,

tovto

afjfj.atvei, OTt

v^iptaTotg

ovTt

Qeca Kat

yyjg etpvjVYf

yevofJ.evcc.

Kai yap ayeXvjv
yYjg, yevofJ.evog

a7re(f)V]ve fJ.taVf
elpyjvv}

Tovg Te ev ovpavZ, Kat
ev^oKta.
01
fj.ev

Tovg

eirt

^fxTv

Kat

yap

AyyeXot Kat
ev
elpvjvvi

Traa-a

vj

ev ovpavo7g '^vvaft.tg, TrXvjv

twv aTrtaTOvvTav, 20
TrXvjpovvTeg OeXv}-

fj,efj.evvjKaat irpog

tov Seov,

Ta avTOv
irpog

fj.aTa, vjfnag

^e

vj

afuapTta

^'^(GpoTroivjae

tov Qeov.

eiretoi^

ovv eXvae tv^v e^/Bpav

Kvptog
Trpog tov
vj

vjfj,m

Kai Qeog Ivjaovg

X.ptaTOg,

aiiOKaTaXXa^ag

vjfj.ag

iraTepa,

Kora tov XeyovTa kiroetKOTCog

aToXoV
01

avTog ydp eaTtv

etpvjvvi

vjfxm'

oogoXoyovatv 25
"KptaTOV tqv

AyyeXot avTOv, tqv
vifj.m.

eirt TVfg

y^?

etp-^vvf yevQfj.evov

Qeov

'HpirENors.
Xvfxa
;

T/

So^TroTe

AyyeXog ovk

aTri^XOev eig

lepoao;

ovK e^vjTviae t&v? ypafkfj.aTe'ig Kat Tovg ^aptaaiovg

ovk

eiavjXGev elg TVfv

twv

lou^a/wv avvayccy^v,

dXXa
TVjg

•notfj.evag

ebpev^o

dypavXovvTag Kat (f>vXdaaovTag Tag (fjvXaKag
•jroifj.vviv

vvKTOg

e^rt tvjv

avTwv, KdKeivovg
Ka) to5

evi^yyeXiaaTO

;

OTt

eKeivot
oiiTot

fj.ev

vjaav

^te(f)6apft.evot,

(f>6ovu> v]fj.eXXov

^ta7rpiea6at'

^e airXa-

II. ai.
ffTOt ^(TaVf rrjv

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.

21

TraXaiav TroXiniav ^yyAovvTef twv TrarpiapywVf Kai
voifjifvei

avTOv Mojyacw?*

yap

Yjo-av

Kai

oxiroi.

0€<a
A//f^f

^o^Tj Kai

ovpavia irepiaaTpacf^QevTei
SeaaoifJievoi,
t>jv

ot ?ro/jU,€V6?

Kai ayyeeirt-

aTparta^
SepfxSig
^rj

Kai vfxvokoyovayjg

aKovaavTeq,

t,fiTovat
*'

By^flAeCjU,,

^Tig olKog apTOV fxedepixvjveverai. 5
AeyovTef, tov^ t^? eKKXyiatag
epyov eart tov ovpaviov
ttjv

diek6a}fxev

eaog eig Bv]6ke€fJ."

irpoTVTTovvTeg irotfj.evag tc Kat tepeT^:, olg

apTOV

eirt^-YjTeTv,

tov

afj.vov

tov 0eoi), tov aipovra

afJMpTiav tov

KoafMov, Kat fi.vaTtKa)f Ka6 eKoiaTyjv iepovpyovfj.evoVf KaTcc to fxeya

ekeog avrov.

10

19

'H

5e M.apLaiJL Traura cruveT-qpeL tol prj/xaTa TavTa.
^e

TloTa

"

avveTYjpet

TravTa^

tj

iravayta QeoTOKog

;

oaa Te

etpyjKet avTrj

AyyeXog, oaa re

01 •jrotp.eveg eiirov,

avfxjStPd^ovaa
pri-

ev TYf eavTrjg Kaphia,
fj-aTa, evog

TovTeaTt tovt:o eKCivo avjKptvovaa Ta

Trpdyfj.aTog avfj,(f>aviav,

ag

OTt irep

Seog VTrdpyei KaTa 15

aXrjQetav

e^ avTrjg yevvrjOetg ev aapKt.

Ktpiaaot Aaesanapeias.
fj.evov,
fxrj

OTav

t^rjg

$pe(f)og

eaTrapyava-

fJ-eyjptg

fii.oyrjg

T^g Kara adpKa

yevvrjaeoig

avTov

Trjv

eavTov ^idvoiav aT-^arjg' dvairri^riaov ^e elg
irovg ^o^rjg avTov.
dvd(5ri6i

Secopiav Trjg

Beoirpe-

tov ovpavov, ovTOog avTOV ev TOtg dvoo- 20

TaTW

Bewp-^aetg vxpa}ft,aat Trjv vTrepTdTrjv eyovra to^av, oipet KaB-ff-

fxevov eirt

Bpovov

vxprjXov

Kat

eirripft.evov'

aKovaetg twv

Y^epacpeifj.
Trjv

vfLvoXoyovvTWV avTOv'

'TrXrjprj

XeyovTiiv

tov ovpavov
Tr^g
rjv

Kat

yrp

T^f

"^o^rig

avTov'

yeyove %\ tovto Kat hrt
Trotfj.evag,

yrjg'

^o^a yap

Qeov Trepf^aTpaxpe Tovg

vtov ^o^okoyovvrav "KptaTOv
<f>og

Kai

TrX-S^Bog

aTpaTtag ovpa- 25
fj.r}

Kat

fxeT oXiya. ovkovv

ug

/Spe-

t^rjg

dirXwg tov

ev (fydrvrj

Ketfkevov,

dXX

ev TrTar/eta Tr\

KaB

rjixdg Tov irXovatov

wf Oeov, Kat ^ta tovto

ho^oXoyovfi,evov Kat irap

avTwv Twv dyiav AyyeXcov.

KE4>. r.
Ilept 2vn(a)u,

30

21

YlepieTft.-^6r]

§e

Kvptog
Ka6<ag

rjfj.m

^lriaovg

HptaTog,

eTrei^rj

yeyovev

vrro

vofxov,

(ftrjatv

6

^AiroaToXog,

"

yewojfxevov

(k

22
**

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA

II. 22.

yvvaiKOff yevofjievov vvo vojxovj^
eve«€)/, Tco

yeyove ^e tovto ^vo icpayiKa.vofJLov

Twv

re e^ayopaaai ^ia T^g '^Xi^pao-eag tov

Tovg
irpog
6

VTrevSvvovg

TVjg

Trapa^aaecog

tov vofKov, kou

tS>

"hia

TYig

TiaVTa VTraKoyjgf tvjv tov A^afx. e^iacraaOai

TrapaKOViv,

wg Xeyei

AiroaToXog. oti " waicep yap ^ia T^f TrapaKOYjg tov evog dv6p(anov 5
*'

dfxapTcoXoi KaTeaTaSyjaav
evof,
'^iKaioi

01 icoXXot,

ovtq} Kai
01

^ia Tvjg vTcaKorjg

" Tou

KaTaaTaS-^aovTai
©ecw.

ttoAAo/,"

TOVTeaTiv

01

vioTevaavTeg
Xeyovavjg

tco

KpiaTw Kai
aXrfieiav

Tiys'

ovv BeoirvevaTov ypa(f)^g

Kaxa

7repiTfi,yjSYjvat

tov

'KpiaTOVy Tig eaTiv

6 ToXfJMV Xeyeiv,

ag

ovy(^

viiefx.eive

t\v

TcepiTOfJi^v, oirep

dpvetaSai 10
vjfJieig

l3ovXovTai fi.eTa tcSv

aXXm

01

t^v <f)avTaaiav iTpeaj^evovTeg'

§e Toy? Trepi tov TrepiTf/iyjOevTog avTov fLoptov,

Xeyx

'^r]

TVjg

d^po-

/SvaTtag, iroXvTrpayfLovovvTag to

t/

eyiveTo, wg

Ta dvefpiKTa Kat
yap
yeypairTO.t

a^rjXa iroXvTrpayfJ.ovovvTag diroKpovauft.eQa'
Tt irept TOVTOv.
aifJ.01,

ov^e

ei

^e Kat

eiirotfj.ev

OTt ODairep

to ayjpavTov avTov 15
tv]v

f/.€Ta

Tov v^aTog ev

toj Katpoo
rj

tov aTavpov vjytaae

yr^v

a-To^av

ev avTrj, ovtq)

Kai

7reptTf/.rj6eiaa

dKpo^vaTta

Trjg

yvjg

^avaaaa,

TavTrjv rjytaaeVf ovk dv

dft.dpTotfii.ev.

TrdvTO^g he Kat oig

oi^e Xoyotg

eKovatwg
tov

rreptTfJ.rfieig

e(f)vXa^e to TreptTfLrjQev'

oirwg

Kai

KaTa

Kaipov Trjg dvaaTaaeoog

avTov, Kai

KaTo,

tovto 20

aveXXetnitig ej^wv «yTO avac7T^ TrXrjprjg viro
oXix
Tco
a(»fj.aTt'

KptaTov, Kat acpSapTog

Kat

yap

v^fJ.eHg

ev

ty]

dvaaTaaet to

aafj.a to

v)fj.eTepov irXrjpeg airoX^i^xpoft.eSa.

Ev

Tco enre7v

tov KvayyeXtaTvjv,

**

Kai

eKX-^Svj

to ovofxa avTov

"

Iriaovg" oirep eaxt acoTrjpta Xaov,
irpo

"

to KXrjSev viro tov
Tvj

\yye- 25

" Xov
Xeyetv

Tov avXXv](f)d^vat avTOv
OTt
evSecog

ev

KotXtaJ^ Trwg ToXfj.aat
tov

Ttv\g,

avv

tc5

eiTreiv

AyyeXov "

X^^^P^

"
22

Ke')(aptTiOfj.evri^^ avveXrj(f)Srj,

SavfjA^etv
ai
rjfi.epat

yjprj.

" Ka/
KaXag

ore

errXrjaSriaav
**

tov KaSaptafxov ayT^f."
Trjv

eTrrjyaye
y)

KaTo, tov vofLov'"

KaTa yap

dXrjSetav ovk

30

etyev dvdyKriv
atTtveg rjaav
Tco vofxo)

iravayta SeoTOKog
eirt

irepifj.evetv rjfxepag

KaSaptafxov,

TeaaapaKOVTa
<f)r)atv,

apaevt TeySevTi'

etprjTai

yap

ev

"

yvvvjf^
vjfxepag

" ^Ttg

eav aTrepfxaTtaS^, Kat TCKet dpvj

"
ov

crev,

fj.

eaTat dKdSapTog^

^e TravdfJMfxog SeoTOKog

aTrepfj.aTtaSeXaa,

dXX

eK

Ylvevfj.aTog

'Ayiov

avXXaj3ovaasS

11.34-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
KaT avTov tov
vo/aov,

23
ttjv KeKpvfJiixivfjv

€^e(f)vy€ Tov eivai, Kai

Kai

avTov

(7Y][xaa-iav,

Kai aKaBapTO^.

25
**

To

Se

irefi

rov

Svjuewv

elpyifJievov

oti

^v

"

irpoo-^e%o/xevof

vapaKXvjaiv tov

la^a^A," tovto
laparjX, ^/a T^f

ecTT/

•jroTe

&<a tou X|3<c7tov

vapaKXviaiv evpot

e/V

avTOv TriaTewi eXevde-^

plav €vpiaK(ov €K t^? twv 'Pioixaiuv ^ioiK^^aeaSf Kai \k

t%
ev

vtco

aXko(f)vXov ^aatXeias 'Hpa^ov.

ToT ArioT Ktpiaaot Aaebanapeias.
/e^w

Fiia€(f)ep€TO
vTrofJM^iov.

tw
^e
ju.ev

Xp/o"TOf, Pp€(f>oi

cov

€Ti

^pay^v t€ Kai

•ye }j.aK(xpioi

"Lvfxeav Trpo^pvjTiKy} '/apiTi T€Tifxv][j.€voi, ^ej^eTa/
Bvfj.vj^ias Se TVjg

10

€is

ayK/xXas avTOv,

avwTaTW

TrtixTrXdfi.evoi vjvXo-

yvjae Beov Ae-ywv,

"

vvv airoXvetg tov ^ovXov

aov, MairoTa,** Kai
fj.vaTV}ptov,

Ta

e^^s"

irpovjToift.aaTo

yap to tov 'KptaTOv

Kai

trpo

avTvi<; TV](;

tov Koafxov KaTajSoX^g.
Se
**

29
ev

T; toSto

vyv airoXvetg tov "hovXov aov, ^ecTTroTa;" irepi Tvjg 15
*

ca^Ac; ^wiyf efne.
"^QivjafJiov

IvaTa de to
vjv.

pv}fJ.a

aov

ev

etp-^vvj,

bta

Tov

ov

eiXvj^pag
^aift.oai

ETre^S^ Se ev aKOTCo Kat ayvQiaia

VTr^p^X^e

Ta

eSvvj

XaTpevovTu, (pag ^e avroig 6 \ptaTOi
tov

yeyovev, aTroKaXvxpag

tov ovTcog aXr/Qvj ©eov eavTov t€ Kat
Yiv€vfi.a, ^ta

YlaTepa Kai to 'Ayiov

tovto

(pvjai

"

(pcos etg aTroKo,-

ao

"

Xw\/iv e^vsSv."

re^yove Se Kat
fxev

" ^o^a tov

lapavjX^^

HptaTbg, Kai kut avTO
0€ Kat iroX-

TO e^ avTwv avaTeTXat to
Tv^g €ig

KaTa aapKa, e^o^aae

Xovg e| avT^v &/a

avTov TriaTeag.

Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias.
7r€TrXaw]fi€voig, kou vTro '//ipa.

Teyove (pZg TOig

ev

aKOT€i Kat^^

ireaovai ^ta^oXiKv^v, KCKXvjTai

yap

irapa tov %€ov Kat

WaTpoq

irpog eirtyvuiatv tov 'Xtov, og eaTi (f>ag

TO aX-^Qtvov,

aXXa

Ka\ elg ^o^av tov

lapavjX'

€i

yap Kai yeyoe/u,7rAew

vaai Ttveg vfSptaTat e| avTwv Kai aTretdcTg Kat aavveaiag

T^v ^iavotav e)(ovT€g, aAA' ovv aeaaaTai to
^ajTTai
"tia
**

KaTdX€tfj.fj.a, Kai SeSo-

30

XpiaTov.
€ig TrTaatv

34
"

To
ToS

^e

Kat dvdaTaatv etvai tov Kv^/ov TroAAcSv ev ovk dXXoov
/xev
irtTrTOVTOsv,

Icrpa>;A"

^yovfxai,

Kat aXXwv dvtirapeyet, To7g
cv
fj

aTafxevav, ov^e

yap ToTg
ot

tov

TrtTrretv d(f>opfi.dg

Se Tou dviaTaaOat'

ydp

iriirTovreg diro

t^? aTdaeag

iroT€

35

24
ijaav

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
KaTairiTTTovai
trjkovoTi'

II. SS6

ovheTtoTe
'^^vj

Vk

eldTVjKH
o

aTiiaTog,

aei %o.\i.ai (rvpQf/Levog,

aW

ovTcog

voeiv, oti

ev

t^ a^apTia.
Kai

i<7TafX€V0i '^ia TYig fj.eTavoiag '^nrTei Kai aTtoBvfjaKei e| avTyjg'
XoiTTOV

^
v]

Ty]

^iKaiocrvvYj

Kai aviaTaTai
iva avaaTri

Tri

eig 'KpiaTOV

"TriaTet'

TrnrTeTO}
Trearj

yap ra yeipova,
Tropeza,
07

xa

(SeXTiova'

eav
yj

yap

fxr}

5

acc^ppoavvv]

ovk aviaTaTai' eav ovk avS-^aei'

fji.r]

akoyia

avvTpi^% TO XoyiKOv to

ev yjfuv

ovTwg ovv eaTi to

"

eig TTTioatv Kai

avdaTaatv ttoAAwv."
dvTtXeyofnevov."

"

Etig

^e

avjfj.ehv

Kvptoog

ay]fxe7ov
e6v]Ke

eyvcofj.ev

irapa t^ Beta ypatp^ tqv ^aoTrotov aTavpov.

y^p^

<pWh

10

Mcova^f Tov

o(f)tv eiTt

av]f/.etoVf

TOVTeaTtv
TVjg

eitt

aTavpov.

enet ovv

ov TravovTai \^vyofLayovvTeg Tiept
01

evavdpctiTrv^aecog

tov Kvptov'

fnev dvetkyj(pevat avTOV aafna, 01 ^e (pavTaaia Ttvt t\v S/a Toy

acofxaTog otKovofxiav TrXvjpovv,
pdvtov
aafji.a,

Kat dXXot yotKOVf dXXot
ty]v

^e

eirovTY]g 15

Kat

ot

fxev

Trpoatccvtov

vTtap^tv, ot

Se

aTro

TtapOevov

Kat dypdvTOv

Maptag
"

tv]v

dpyvjv eayv^Kevat, tta tovxo

etg av]fieiov avTtXeyofj.evov.

Pof>.(patav" ^e Ae^ye; tov Ao^yov tov

TtetpaaTtKOv twv

evavfiiy^aectiv.
eitt

Aaacs. "

Vofi.(patav" Se (pY]at ty]v
oioff.evYiV
fj,Y]

tSi aTavpcp BXtxptv Tvjg

itavaytag BeOTOKov,

^eiv
cog

avTOV TotavTa TtdayetV

tq 20

yap avdtg avaaTV]aea6at avTOv,

vitepoyKov Tecog v]TttaTeTTo.

Aaaos.

Ylpoipi^Tevet

6

'Zvft.eav

Kat

ttept

avtv^g

Tvjg

dytag

itapBevov 'M.aptag, oti itapeaTcaaa toj aTavpcf, Kai
ytvofi.eva,

(SXeitovaa
ty]v

Ta
tov

Kat dKovovaa tcSv

(pcovoov

tcHv

(povevTiiv, fJ.eTa

Ta(3piv]X fKapTvpiav, fxeTa

t'*?^

ditoppY^TOV

yvaatv T^g Qeiag avX-2^
yevv]aeTat Ttg

Xv]\pea}g, fi.eTa ty]v fj.eydXY]v tcov Bavfj.dTcov eTti^et^iv,

Ttept TV]v aY]v y^^vyY^v

adXog.

SS

To

^e

**

OTtcog

av dnoKaXv^pQcoatv eK TtoXXm Kap^tcov ^taXooti
fj.eTa

"

yiafiLQt,^*

aivtTTeTat

tov aKav^aXtafj.ov tqv
fj.a6viTa7g, Kat avTV]

eiti

tc5

aTavpoo Tov KpiaT.ov yevofj.evov TOig
yt(X

tv]

itava-

30

7tap6evca

Tayeia Ttg taatg htaKoXovSel itapa tov Kvpiov.
etg
ty]v

^e^atovaa

avTcov tv]v Kapttav

eii

avTOV

TtiaTiv.

ovTCog

yap

et^ofxev Kat YleTpov

t^?

eig

"KptaTOv ittaTecag dvTtayofxevov,

To avQpcoTttvov ovv aadpov ^iyjXeyySv], tva to layypov tov Kvptov

^^^X^'

-

35

11.39-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
^€

25
tioXXwv

Aaaqs. To

"

OTTUs

a7[0Ka\vcf>6a(riv

ck

Kap^im

"

oiaXoyiafj.oi'^

tovto

e<7Tiv, iva Travrwv ol ttaXoyi(rfj.oi

t^Xoi koi

catpiis Toig avOpayiroii
^ej^ij;

yivavTai'

Tig /xev o ayaTtav axnov, Ka\
ev^eiKVvfJievog'

QavaTov t^v

e/V

avrov ayaTtr^v

t/V ^e o liti-

TtXaaTOV e^^wv

tijv tig

avTOv TriaTiv, aKav^aXov nXrip^aBeig ^ia tovS
e7rifi.evci}v

CTavpoV
i

Tig Te o irpo^i^ovg Kai

tco

tc cravpcp Kai

tw

OavaTw avTov.

KE^. A.
Htpi "Avvtjs t^s
7rpo(j>riTi8os,

36

'H

le

Trpo<f>vjTig

Awa

4j

TocravTfjg
too

a^ia}6e7a-a

fxapTvpiag

vtto

Tov KvayyeXtaToVj avSojfxoXoyeiTO
Tiyv acoTyjpiav

Sew,

Toxrreariv fivyaptaTet 10

opwaa, tov tc
iiept
rjfkiv

Koaf/.ov,

toD t€ lapo^X eirtaTaaav.
etvj

tjXaXet Oe
6 YiWTfjp,

avTOv, OTt avTOg
elg

XvTpcoTijf,

avTog

eiyj

ovTOf

yapav
tvjv
rj

•jrepiTpexpei tv}V KaT-^<f)etav.

39
'*

" 'TireaTpeipav
Na^apeT,"

Se

eig

TaXtXaiav,
r)v

etg

t^v TtoXtv
itoXtg,

eavTwv
Kat 15

eiietVfi ei

Kat

^yjdXeefJi.

avTwv

aXXa

t»;v

Na^apeT
"TIVJ^dfLeVOt.

iroXtv eavTiiv eireypacpovTOf

ws eKei t^v

o'tKr)atv

av-

TWV

Ktpiaaot 'Aaesanapeias.
jSdSoi, dvSpomtvov
vnof/.evet

ASpet

&17

fJi.ot

t^j- oiKovofxia$

to

tokoV

Kat TOt to avapyov ev

yj>ov(p

BeiKag eyjav
ev d^poTYjTt

Aoyoi'
fLeXav
Kcti

ev av^-^aet acofjiaTog, 6

navTeXetog ag Qeog, 20
ao(f>tag

dawfj.aTog'

irXvipovTai

avTog
ev

oov

vj

vaaa

aQ(f>ia.

vpog tovtq

<pafj.ev,

opa tta toutwv tov

fJi.op(f>yj

Tov UaTpog,
ev

ev Ofx.ot(£iaet

t^

Trpog

y}fj.a<,,

tov TrXovatov, ev itTayeia,

Tairetvccaet

tov vxpyjXov, tov to irX^peg eyovTa QeiKchg ev

tw

XeyeaOat

XafSeiv, qvtq)

KeKevxKev eavTOv Qeog

u>v

6

Aoyog' Ta 25

yap

dvBpcoTrtvwg irepi

avrov yeypafj.fx.eva tov
ev^^eyofj.evccv

Trjg Kevaaecag "hto^et-

Kvvai Tpoirov.

ov

ydp eaTt t«v

etg ttiav (pvaiv viro-

aTVjvat Tt TOtovTov eK

tov Seov Tlarpog (pvvTa Aoyov.
yjfi.ag'

Teyove

Se aap^, yjyovv dvBpccTrog Ka6

TiKTerat eK yvvatKog KaTa
yjv

(xdpKa
6

Ta

av6p'j}irtva v7rofi.efi.evyjKci)g.

fxev

ydp iKavog
fJt-yjTpog

Seog
avTrjg

cov

30

Aoyog, eig

fj.eTpov

dvtpog TeXeiov

Koit
vjv

€K

t>jv

tttav dvaj3tl3daag adpKa.

aXX ovk
E

fj.aKpov TepaTOTroi-^aag to

26
^pafj.(.vov.

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Errei §e ovk

II. 44.

aaapKog akXa

a-€(yapKa}[J.evog

tlcxayaym

Tov ©eov Aoyog,

FiVayyeXiaTyj^ e^oy,

"

rjv^ave Kai

cKpaTaiovTo"
voeh TavTa'

Kai

Ta

e^rj^.

^ia tovto Trepi
vjv^ave

tov KaTO,

adpKa

yjiri

<T(ap.aT iK(jOi

yap

Kat

eKpaTaiovTO,
§e

twv [xeXav avva^pvvo-

fxevav

T^

av^i^crei.

EirXyjpovTo
aei

ao^iag kou yapnogt ovk ev^
a>g

To5 '7rpoXafxl3aveiv'

yap tq irX^pef eiyev
(jaiJ.aTog

©eof,

aXXa

tov

@€ov Aoyov T^ Tov
T^f
co(f)iag

yjXiKia
ty(v

o^vveKTeivovTo

KaTa ^po.yv
^e Tovg
ira-

Kai TVjg yapiToq

eKcpavaiv.

'ETrfjSCOTa
to,
fxy]

^i^a(7KdXovg

Kvpios Ta tov vofxov
Kai
yj^e/

iidvTcos, Kou

vofxiKa

payyeXfxaTa.
eivai Tov

/xev

yj

itavayia QeoTOKos
v'ffo4'i<x,v

TeKVov avTOV 10

Itacrt^^jy,

aXXa

^ia tvjv

toov

^lov^awv vofxi^ovTav

eK TTopveiag avTOv yeyev^a$at,

(^rjai Trpog

avTOV, oti

"

i^ov

TiaT^p

" aov

Kayo) o^vv(Ofxevot e^yjTovfxev ae."

ToT
"

ATiOT Ktpiaaot j^^aebanapeias.

E<Vct)v 6

EvayyeXtKai dvQpd)- 15

aTVjf, OTt

"

irpoeKOTtTe ao^pta, Kai ydptTi trapd t€

Oew

TTOtg," ^etKvvai Tov

eavTov Xoyov dXyjO^.

'ATC0(f>epei

yap axnov

ei<;

'YepovaaXfjfXy afxa

t^

dyt(x.

irapGevw, eopTi^g etg tovto KaXov-

cnjf,

e/Va
ev

(pvjatv, dirofxehat fxev

avTOV, eyKaTaXeicpS^vat ^e fxeTa

TavTa

tc5

lep^ fxeTa^v twv '^ttaaKdXaov KaBrjixevov, epooTcovTa
'tvjXov

^e Kat diioKptvofxevov,

te OTt

Ta itdXat tw

vofxto

^iyjyopev-

20

jaeva* eiTa Qavfxa^^ofxevog vito TrdvToov eTri Ta7$ epuTrjaeai Kat Talg

aTtoXoytatg.

'OpSii

ev

ao(pi(X

Kai ydptTi TrpoKOitTOVTa, S/a

toi/

ytvxaKeaOai TtoXXoTg, OTt TOtovTog eaTi.

OpirENOTS.

O

fnaKdptoi;
yjv,

AovKai oaa

(pSog

yjfi.iv

TrapaaT-^aaf

OTt TiapQevov vlog 6 ScoT^p
eiTre

ovk e^ dvtpog.

Ylpog ti ovv iraTepa 25
;

tov

fxyj

aTreipavTa

fxyj^e atTtov

avTf

yevofxevov TVjg yeveaecog

'AirXovaTepov fxev XeyoiTo dv, oti

ei €Tift.yjaev

avTOv to rivevjOta to
dveSpetpaTo avTOv*
etret
yj

Aytov T^ Tov TraTpog
€1

Trpoayfyoptri,

hrett-fprep

Se

^ei

Tt

eiirerv

Kat [3aQvTepov,

epovfxev,

yeveaXoyia
eivat

eyeveaXoyriae tov

l(oay](f)

diro Aa^i'^'
l^oarjcf)
fxy}

edo^e ^e TreptTTy}

1J30

yeveaXoyia
iva
yj

epyofxevyf

eirt

tov

yevvyjaavTa tov llcoT^pa.

yeveaXoyta Xoyov eyyj
yjfjMV

e^rtT-^^etov, iraTyjp dvyjyopevGyj ^lway)(f)

Kvptov

\yjaov 'KpiaTov.
(og

44

'Apa ^e oTt dyroXdoXev

iraTg, KOxe^^yjTOVv,

vj

oti veTrXdvi^Tat

;

5

III.

I.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
ovre yap T^f 7rav(TO(pov deoTOKOV

87
^v tovto, TYjg

aitaye.

Mapta^

fj.vpiag '^i^afj.iv^g irepi

avTov Beiag anoKaX.vxl^eii, ov^e tou 'Iw«7^^*
ypa(prjVf Q^vvwf/.eva}i
ecrcpaXfxevi^v,
fi,Y}ir<ag

akk

coavep

eav Tif

^i^TJj

avTVjv

^yjTct, oyp^

coavep nKavqfj.evqv ovVe

cuf

aX^

wg eyovcrav

fxev

Tov a\y]9ij Kat fxvaTiKOv Xoyov,

^e

TrecfiavepccfKevvjv, ovtcc

5

KaKehoi e^yjTOvv tov Kvptov
aTV) ait
avTa>v, fi.'^<ag

yjfxwv ^ly^aovv

'K.ptaTOV,

fx^oog ane-

KaTaXeXomev avTovg'

te

Kvptog

yjfxwv

Kat Qeog a(petg avQpwTrtvy]v ^ovvai aTtoKptcriv, Qeiag onrTeTat aitoKptcrewg, vapefAcpatvcov
y]

OTt

Qeog

eiy\

aea-apKcoft.evog.

'Eire/^r?

yap
10

irapSevog

Kai SeoTOKog tov eTrtKXyjOema avTOv iraTepa
<f>y]crtv,

^IoKjyjcp
'lcc(yy](f>,

eXeyev avTov iraTepa, avTog

OTt efj.og iraTyjp,

av'/^

aXX
cov,

Seog, OTt

tov vaov ^ecTroTi^g' elg tov vaov yap tov Seov
tov
ty]v

e^y]f

" ovK

rj^etTe, oti ev TOig
py]fJ.a

UaTpog

fJLOv

'^eT

eivai fxe ;"
eX<x\y](T€v

ov (xvvyjKav

^e to

ot

irep)

ayiav deoTOKov,
^tavoiag

avTotg

Kvptog,

eiret^yj

ovk

^v

(xv6pa>Trivy]g

to

ovtoo

1

Ae^TOv

cTvvt^eiv fj.v(7Tyjptov.

51

A;a

toDto ^e

"

y]v

vmTaaaofj,evog avToTg," •Jrapa^etyfxa ^i^ovg
Tovg eavToiv yove7g Kat vTroToiaaeaSai av-

iraaiv vtoig, tva
TOtg.

Ttfj.(!>ai

^teTyjpet ^e
irota py]fi.aTa
y]

yj

fJ-yjTyjp

avTov

yj

iravayia irapBevog Ka\ SeoTOeiTrev,

Kog,

;

oaa

AyyeXog

oaa

01 Trotfxeveg,
ei

oaa 20

Si/^fwv Kat
ft.y]

Avva, Kat oaa vvv avTog irpog avTOvg'

yap Kat
yj

TeXetcag eyvcaaav

Ta

etpy]fj.eva

irap

avTOv,

irXyiv

avvrjKev

travayta BeoTOKog, oti Qeta vir^py^pv Kat virep avjav.
TratQtov yjKovae ^a^eKaeTovg,

ovte yap ag

aW

eT-^pei

to. py]fJ.aTa

wg TeXeiov.

UaKiv

Trpog Ty]v av^y]atv

tov a<afj.aTog

TrpoKoiry^v

Keyei

^vayye- 25
•noXXoig
QeoTrpeTrovg

KiaTYjg, TovTeaTt OTt
ev yvcoaet

Kat 6

ly]aovg irpoeKoirTev, aairep
yevofj.evog
TYjg

KaTa
yjv

'upoaByjKy^v

irept

avTOv

woXy]xpecog,

avv ev^oKta tov YlaTpog eve^etKvvTo,

avfj.-npoaovTcov

T«y

yjfovca» Tyjg vjkiKtag, tyjv eXkafxxpiv Ty]g 6eoTy]Tog.

KE*.
Hepi Tou yevoiifpov
I

E.
npos
'iwai/vr/v.

pi)fiaTOS

MefLVYjTat ^e

ttKatcag

tov

'/jpovov

Kot

tcSv
Tijg

ap^^ovTcav
yjyefxoviag

Xey<av

^vayye\taTy]g

'*

tv eT€* •nevTeKa^eKa.Tca

Tt^epiov

E 2

28
" Kaia-apoif"
aewg
•)(^povQi(;

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
kui
to,

III. 2.

e^^f, iva yvcofxev ort ev TO?f t^? (.vavBpaynviiJ/awv

tov Kvpiov

Kai Qeov 'Ivjaov yipi(7T0v, €K\€\oi7r(i
"iipy^pv,

KaGoKov apyjnv Kai vjyovfxevog c^ 'louWwv. aXXo(f>vXoi Se
'Pafxaiav
jaei/,

oi

Se Xonro)

'H^w^ov

v/o/,

'

A(TKa\caviTV]g to yevog,

"

ijkOe

yap

ar/v/ to apyiiv aiiOKeiTai^' tovt€(tti XjOiO"To5 tco
^e
o/
'lov^a/cov

©ew

5

oy/Awv.

E^eA/TTov

apyovTeg KaTa Tovq Xoyovg

laKa}(3 Tov iraTpiapyov.
Q,

To
ovK

Se e/7re?v

" eyevero
vjXOeVf

p^i^^a

Seov ein
Trapa

^latxvvqv"

leiKVvcriv oti

a(j>

eavTov
irep)

aXXa

Seov ano^JTaXeig,
aoKovoix-^Sy]

o&ev

Kat
tv]V

ToaavTa
^iaKoviav.
eivat.

tov 'iwavvrjv e^ O^PXV^

^ia TavTVjV

io

Eitei

yap koi tov

Ttpo^pofJiov

tov KptaTOv a^Kxyaarov
ev

Aia t/

^e eyeveTO p^jxa

Qeov

'Jrpog 'lcodvvrjv

t^

f/"?/*w

>

^td Ttva [xvaTtKTjv 6eccpiav. 'ETre/^^ yap efxeXXe TroAXa
avTyji epvjfxcoBetayj^

Ta TeKva

[xaWov

eivat

ri

irep)
[xv]

t^c eyovav]? rov avopa,
y]v,

Tovrov ydptv rovro yeyove. E/ yap
KVjpva-accv
a(f)eaiv
d(f)€atv ev
t-^
epvjfxca.

rovro

eKTtepiaa^ag eitotei \$
[Leravoiai;
etq
e^yei

KKVjpvaa^e
jtAev

^e (3dTrrta[xa

dfxaprtwv.

To

yap ©ew

f^dTirta^xa

reketcog
lcodvvov

dfiaprtav e^ avrov rov ^aTtrt^eaBaty ro te

eU
yap
20

avro
^v,

[X€v e/j^ev dcpea-tv d^xaprtZVf
e/

^ta [xeravoiag ^e, dre)^;

Kat

Tav

'lov^aiVccSv

^a-nrta^xdrcov
[xerdvota,

reXetorepov

VTrfipyeV

€Ttotet

yap

avrovg

eTttri^^etovg

Kat

^eKrtKovg

aiir^g

yeveaBat irapeaKeva^e

roiig ^airrt^^o^xevovg.
yjv

4

E7re/^»? ^e

'lcodvvi^g irpo^po^xog
yj
(f^ctivy]

rov ^ptarov^
'^ta
(f>v]at,

(f^covyj

'yjv

6

koyog, Ttpo(hpa[xev

rov Koyov.

rovro kou

wg

ovita

Ttapovrog rov KvpioVy

*'

€Tot[xdaaref'

"

rvjv

o^^ov

avrov,

25

Tovreart, evrpeittaOyire Ttpog Ttapo^oyrjv

a)V

dv /3ovXotro vofKoSereiVf

Twv Tov

vojaof

aKtxv d(f)taTd[xevot.
^iKatoavvy]g
avry]v

YivQetag te

mtei rdg TpijSovg
oy

Tov Qeov

^ta
Tracra

odevav aKoXtd ydp
Kat

Ka^ia.
itpog

To

^e

"

(pdpay^
Kai

TtXyjpctiOyjaerat"

rd
rtvog

e^^f,
yj

wg

dvrtBeatv

eart'

otovet

d[t.(f>tl3dkXovrog
elitev,

7tpo(f)y]T€ia

3^

ditoKptverat.
*'

Kitet'^)]

ydp

"

erot[xdaare r^v otov Kvpiov,

evSetag Ttoteire rag rpt^ovg avroVf' dvdvryjg ^e Kot
dpery]

rpayeia
[xev

ri

Kat ^va^td^arog,
TtvevfxdrcoVy

Kat

€[xno^i^o[xevy]f

itpcarov

dito

Twv

Ttovyjpav

eitetra

Se

Kat

dito

rm

(pvatKav Kat

e^coBev

itaSccv,

ag

Xeyovrog

rtvog

itpotp^Ti^

itxg

evteyerat 35

III. 6.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
vav to

29

KaTopdoixyai apeT-rjVf to(7ovtwv ovtcov /fwAvjtAaTWV, avTO^ aTtoKpiQai
Ae-ye/, oti

irpog tov

t^$ aptTrig

'^pofi.ov

I^tco^i^ov '^iopOcoO-^ei^,

aerai

vno tov ^piaTov'
'^va^aTog,

Kav (pdpay^ Tig
Tipog

Kai

'^ia

tovto

vTrap^xet

iik^puiQ-^cTiTai
^ia.

^e^iws-iV

Kav hpog r/f

uyi

Kai ^owog, Kai

tovto eaTi ^vaTiopevTOSj TanetvwQ-^aeTai ^

elg ohov ei6etaVf Kat itaVTa eaTat evQeta,

Aaaos. ^apayyag
Kai Tag
OTi

Se Kat

opi^

Kat (3ovvovg to.

itaQri

KaXe7,

Tm

^atfji.ova}v

avTta-Taaetg. ""O
apeTvjv
vtto

^e Xeyet TotovTOV eaTtv,

Tiavra

oaa

t»?v

Kat t^«

tov Qeov

o^ov

'^va(3aT0V

wo/er,

KaTapyvjOyjaeTat

^ptaTov,

wg yeveadat Xeia itarra lo

Tolg o^eveiv ^ov\o[t.evotg' Xela ^e yeyovev ovTCog, eTiet^Yiiiep tov fxev

^aTavav

KaT-^pyvjaev 6 ^ptaTog, Kat inro Toiig Ttc^ag tZv ^ovXwv

avTov TeQetKe,
KaT-^pyvjae.

Ta

Se

T^g aapKog

TtdOv]

ev

eavT^ KaTevvaae

Kcti

6

Aei^ai ^e BeXm,

OTt ovKeTt
dvSpooTrcov

lov^^a^oi

ovTe itpoaYjXvTOi
TVjg

fJLOVov,

15

dXXa Kai itaaa ^ t£v
Xavaet tov Qeov,
*'

(ftvatg

^iXav6pcoTtiag aTto-

<f)r]at

" Kat

oxpeTat

itaaa aap^
TVjg

to

acoT-^ptov

Tov Qeov,

'

TOVTeaTtv, OTt Ttpog
yj

ra TtepaTa
yj

yyjg

Ki^pv^Byj-

aeTai twv EyayyeA/oJV tovtojv
'bovg TpoTtov

^vvafxtg kou
eig

yvaatg, «Tro QyjptwTtoXXyjv

Kai aKXy]poTdTy]g

yvwfJLVig

'^fJi.epoTyjTa

Kai 20
^ta

•TtpaOTi^Ta
Tcov

fJieTa(3aXXovaa to twv avOpooTtoov yevog.
TtdvTa
tov
'hte^Bapfj.evov
jSiov

Kat yap

aKoXicov

yjvt^aTO,

TovTeaTt,
'^te-

TeXmag, Kai

itopvag Kai

XyjaTag Kai fndyovg, oiTiveg ovreg varepov e^d^taav o^oV
oitep

aTpafj.fxevot itpoTepov, TVfv opQvjv

ovv

avTog eXeye ToTg

lov^atoig,

"

oti TeXcovai Kat itopvat ttpodyovaiv
ovpavcov.''*

25

"

vfxag eig tvjv PaatXetav twv

10

eXeyev ovv rotg eK7topevoff.evotg o^Xotg
Ttpotypdcpvi eig to

ecog

'

Kat eig Ttvp

" jSaAAeTa;,"

KaTa MaT^aibv.

KE^.
n.(pi

S".

rav

fir(pa>n](rdpTav rov *Ia>dvvr}v.

30
TtotvjaofJiev
;

EpcoTVjdeig Se

'Iwavv>jf Ttapa

tcov

oj^Aojv

to t/

avTog KaBaitep Tig
PovjQvjfiia,

eittaTvifjMV tarpog eKdarco

ro itpoatpopov reSetKC
Keyjp-i^aBai
Ace-

To7g fxev oyXotg <fnXaXX-^Xcc

<f>povyjfj.aTt

30
Aevojj/,

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
xeAwvaif Se
iJ.fjv

III.

1 8.

rrjv

eU aKaQcKTovf

nXeove^iag aTroKXeicov o^ov,
7rav<7o<j)coi eTci^aviov'

Toif ye

a-TpaTiiorai( ro fxyj^eva ^taaeteiv
op6(io$

ov^eva yap aiio(3d\keTat 0eof,
ovTto Se ^v [xeyas xat

Koi ^iKaicog TroXtrevo^evov
elg lirovoiag

d^idyaarog wg

eXBeh

roiig tc5v

lovoatav

OrjiAovgy [xr]

dpdye avrog

eif\ o

Xp;<7T0f,

o viio Trpoipyjrcov

^

dyiav TrpoKeKVjpvyfxevog.
airoKOiTT(ov
e^ijs-,

avrog ^e t^v roiavryjv avrav vnoxpiav
fAev

eXeyev

eyco

voart

paTrriga

vfAas,
eig

Kai
ro

ra

ecag

" KaraKavaet
Tpia

Ttvpt

da^eara.^^

7rpoeypd(f)V}

Kara

MarOaiov.

OpirENors.

rdyfxara

eia-^yayey

TivvGavofj.evov
eiii

rov lo

Iwavvov, ev /xev, (ovofi.aaev o^Kovg eKTTopevofj.evovg

ro pdirrtaf/M,

aX\o

^e avofiaae

reXmagy rptrov
FevOjaevof
eyca

^e

mofKaae arpariwTag.
tottov toiJtov, eirrjrovVf

ToT
€1
**

ATTOT.
yj

Kara rov

avry}

evroX"^, oaov eiri rcov pvjrwv

rw

op^Aoo, dpff.o^ei'

"

o ej^eov

ovo yjroivag, fi.era^orco

tw

fny]

ej^ovTi'"

ort

ydp

roTg AwocttoAo/? 15
YiCoryjpog

dpff.Q^etf

^^Aov eK rav dvaypa^ovrm^ wg vno rov
elpYifxevov, ev

irpog

avrovg

olg

eXeyev avrotgf
ei

*'

ft.yj^€

^vo y^trmag

elg

"

o^ov dpaif

aAA' opa,

rd

eipYjfxeva

iiepi

evtvfxarog

ev

tw

Aoyco To5 Tiept r-qg yvfxvoryjrog ^vvaaai 7rapaXa(3etv eig to
**

"
20

ej^wv Suo "^firmag fxero^orca

rx

fxyj

ep^ovT/."

QeXet

ydp

yjfxdg cof

jOtTjSe

tvo ')(irmag eyeiv, Kat ev^e^vaQai, tt^ fuv ro TraXaiov, tt^ Se

TO veoV
Se

aXX

eKOvaaa-dai fxev ro erepov, ro Oe erepov eyetv. afxa

e^-^rovv

ro

"

fxero^orco

rw

fxy}

eypvri.

Tig

^e

eariv 6 fMj

ev^vfxa eycov nepi rov yj^cora Kat fxera^i^ovai
;

fn.y}

evaKeiraafxevQV coare avrco
KaGi' vTrep/SoXt^v

ov rovro

Xeyco, ori

ov ^vvarat Kat

25

Tovro irporpeirrtKov etvat Trpog ro ^eh evhvetv rovg irevyjrag Kat

f*.y]

afxeXeh

ry}g evroXyjg.
oiiv

18

E/Trwv Se ori TroXXd fxev
^ero rov Xaov, etei^ev ori

Kat erepa TrapaKaXm evy^yyeXt-

rov Xoyov rov EtvayyeXtov

^i^daKmy

TToXXd acoTYipta evayyeXi^erai ^i^dyfxara.


eXeyyofxevog xm
etg

To

^e hrayofxevoVf ori

"

'Wpcotrjg rerpdpyy^g
ev
ty}

ayTon

Kat Ta

eg^^g

eag
Kat

(pvXaKY}

irpoeypacpy}

ro

Kara MaTdarov.
19

ofxoicog %e

irepi

rov (Sairriafxov.

O

Se

HfxoSrjs 6 T€Tpap)(T]9f €\€y\ofjLeuo9 vtt avTov.

ilpirENOTS.

OvTog

irapavofi.cog eyy^fie

t>;v

yvvaiKa rov a&eA-35

III. 23<j>Qv

AOYKAN ETArrEAIOT.
Ttafa. rov

31

avTOv

MwyVewf

vofxov'

aXX'

o

aKaTa-nXfiKTog laav^aaiXiKfiv

vi^$

/xij^evof

TrpoauTTOv kafx^avoov, ov (f)ol3rj6eif Tyjv

e^ovaiav, ov^e ^ttov TrXvjpwv npo^pyjTiKviv TrappvjcriaVf rj^ey^e tov
'Hpci^r] eTn tt] Trapavofxca tqv yafxov, Kai
KTjv,

KaTeKXeiaOy} eig
'^piQTOv.

(pvka5

Kai

[xr]

fJLepi[xvS)v

QavaTov,

e{xepiiji.va Tiepi

33

Kai avTOs
pL^vos.

tjv

6 ^lrjcrov^

aycrel

iroov

TpLaKovra ap^o-

TpiaKQVTaeTYig ^e
rvprjfjiev^

eiti

to ^dTma[j.a 'TiapeyeveTO,

eire/^*;

[xefxap-

eaTiv

rj

rjXiKia avTYj, loaTe fxeya ovaa, afka ^e
vorjTrjv

Kai iva

^ei^vjf OTi

TeXeiovs av^pag ditoTiKTei KaTo, r^v

^KiKiav 1710

Ttvevfux.TiKYi

av
evBe(ag ev

ovTQ}

yap Kai

TrpwTog avBpamog TeXeiog

e7i\da6rjf Kai

Trapa^eiau) TeGei<;, ccg TeXeiog evTo?o]v

Kai vofKov

eXa/3e, Kai

eTteTpeTieTO

tov Trapa^etaov

t»jv

epyaaiav

Kai (pvXaK-^v.
Ylepi
rrjv

KaTO.
fKev

adpKa yevv^aiv rov ^eaTtOTOv ^fnav
MaT^arov
ajro "EokofJioovrog

Irjaov 15

XptaTov, ro Tov

avrov yeveaXoyeiVf
lcoarj^p,

Kat tpSdveiv eig rov
(3o\<i}g

MaT^arov Kai laKwfS Kat

Kat

afi.(f)i-

eKaarov avrSov, erepov ^e Kat eri KaraXeyetv yevog' Kat

'toKei

Twv d^vvdrav

eivai

rov

^lcoarjcf»

rov

vofxtaBevra dv^pd rrjg
\aK<h(3 Kai

Ttavaytag BeoroKov Kai dei TiapBevQV ^aptag, rov re
Tov 'HA< eayrjKevai Ttarepa'
^oKOvarjg ^tacpcoviag.

20

d\Xa

Karavorjaag fxev

rrjv

Xvatv

rrjg

rpirog dito TeAovf

Kara

rr^v

rov ^arBatov
rrjv

yeveaXoyiav earlv
rov AovKa
ft-err]

M.aT8a7og, itefXTtrog te dito reXQvg, Kard
rovrctiv roov "^vo

MeAj^/*
rj

Kara

Ota(popGvg yj)Ovovg,

yaKat 25

yeyovev

KaBdv' rov yap MaT^av
rov

'TtpoetXrjcporog avrrjv

7ra<&07ro<iyaavTOf c^ avrrjg

laifwjS, Kat TeXevT-^aavTog, yripav
(pvXrjg, dXXrjg

avT\v QvaaVf eK
•ycTo

rr)g avrrjg

wv

^e avyyevetag, rjyd-

MeAj^/, Kat

eitat^oitoirjaev e^ avrrjg rov
ofj.ofj.riTptQt

HX/.

te

laKca^

rotyapovv Kat
etg

HA/
^e tou

rvyydvovatv

d^eX(f)ot eK

r^g Eaflav.

'Eo-^av*'

'HA/ yvvaTKa Kat dreKvov reXevr-^aavTQg, ^o
'laff«/3,

Kard Tov
Ttof^aag

vofLOV elarjXBe itpog avrriv

wg d^eX(f)og Ttat^orov

rw reXevr^^aavri

d^eX(f)w

tw 'HA/*

€7ra/&07roii70'ev oiiv

c (l<r6av

Cod.

32
^lcoayjcf),

EPMHNETA TOT KATA
Kai
yjvpeGi^ 6

III. 43.
tov
la/^oj/?,

laayj^, vioi fxh wv t^ cf^vaei

vo/Aoo

^e Toy

HA/,

/<fa<

to «yevoc

ol9ev

'laKOi^ KaToiyeTai.

o^e ye

AovKoig Tov KaTa vofxov
yeTai'
<npocxfiKOVT0og

Xeym naTepa
6

tov

la)ar](f>

tov
6

HXi KaTaKaTa
tcov 5

te

fxev

tov KaTa
^ei^aatv,

(fyvaiv,

^e tqv

vo^ov

TtaTpo^

[xefjt.w]Tai'

iva

oti

ef

a[Ji(f)OTepcov

iraTpwVf Tov Te

KaTa tov
to

vofxov,

tov
o6ev

t€

KaTa

t>jv

(f)vaiv, eig

Tov

Aa^i^ avaTpeyei

yevog'

t»v ^vo

naTepm

elg

tov

AajSi^ avaTpeyovTioVf Kai
afji.(f>i(T/3'^TV](Tig

'lof^a/cov Kai 'EAAiyvcyv iraai TiepieipvjTai

Kai anav (TKavtaXov.
HaTiTi^eTai ^e
yjfxav.

Tox ArioT Ktpiaaot.
ti^aTa Kai KaBaipoov

6

li^^Tovg,

evkoyoov

Ta 10

avTa

virep

Ayiog yap

e(XTiv

Ayicov

Movo-yev^f tov 0eoy Aoyog, Kai ovk av avTog

e^eYjdvj

tov ayiov
yjfxeHg

^aTtTKjfxaTog, ovh\ (x^peaeug afxapTiSov Tvy^eh, (naTtep
taivofxev ^i

Kep-

avTOV.

'Avoiyet
cog
rj

Tovg ovpavovg, ovg cKXetaev

TrpSoTog

'A^aja,

^tjXcijv rjfjuv

15

Tov

(3a7rTiafji.aT0g 'hvvafx.ig avotog eaTiv elg tov ovpavov'

yap aitavTa eitpaTTev

ovpcLVtog

tov aytaafkov Kai T^f
S<
yjfxag

TjfJieTepag

XvTpaaecog aTtapyofji.evog . ovtco Kat to IlveDjaa
eig

KaTetaiv

avToV Uvevfia

Se oy)^ ev tc5v XeiTovpyiKcov

'Ttvevft.txTcov,

aXXa

TO avTOv Tov 0eoy, to ofxoovatov Kai avfx^aatXevov avTco Kat tco 20
YlaTpt.

E<

oe

(f)yjat,

Ttvevfxa

KaTa^ahov

coaet TtepiaTepav, tva ^etyGet'^

aa(f)cog cog eig

eaTiv

TYjg

itaXatag Kat KaiVYjg ^taByjKYji Qeog' Ka)
eiti

€ig

VTtofXvyjaiv

ayayfi tov
tyjv

Nwe

KaTaKXvafxov.

"Q.aitep
opyyjg

yap
toD 25

tot€ TteptaTepa

KaTanavatv evyjyyeXiaaTo T^g
eitov,
ft.yjvvet

0€oy, oyTO» Kai vvv iteptaTepav

tov T-^g (XfxapTtag

KaTaKXvafxov Kai

tijv

tow Koafxov ^iaXXay-^v.
yeyovev ev ttoXXo^ig a^eX<po7g, KaSelg

O
fxaTog

ev

yjfxiv

TtpcoTOTOKog

eavTOv etg Kevooatv, ^eyeTat ttpcoTog to Ylvevfxa' KaiToi tov ITvey^OTYip
VTtap^^^cov

avTog, tva

Kcti

eig yjfxag epyj^Tat tt
yj

avTov^^o
yaptg,

TO a^tcofxa, Kat T^f
TOiovTov Ti

"Ttpog

to Aytov Ilvevft.a Kotvooviag
^tt(iiaKei

Kai 6

UavXog

yjfxag
01

Xeycov, ttepi Te

avTov

Kai

yjfxctiv'

"

Te yap dyta^cov Kai

dyia^ofxevot e^ evog itdvTeg,

"
"

01

^v ovK eitatayyveTat d^eX(f>ovg avTovg KaXeiv, Xeycov, ditayTo^ig d^eX(f>oig

'yeAw TO ovofxd aov

fxov."

35

IV.

u

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.

33

KE«i». Z.
Jlfpi Tov TTfipacrfiov tov ^arnjpos.

1

^lrja-ous

Se Hu€viJ.aT09
KCLL

'Ayiov

TrXrjpTjs

VTrearpeyp^eu

OTTO Tov *lop8ai/ov.
eprjfxov rjfxepas
1

rjyeTO 4v

r^

IlvevfxaTi ety ttjv
5

TecraapaKOVTa.
1
1

OT ATTOT.

ovv

apa xo

'

riycvo

;

ear/v ov to a-recpepero

fj.aX\ov,
r]p.e7i

a\k

OTi ^i^^ye Kai eTroXirevero.

KarriBKyp.eBa

yap

Ttag Kat

avroi

iiffi icavroi

rovro ev eTrieiKeia Xeyetv,

^eiva rvyeiv^
ev nvevixart,

KaXSis eavrov ayei.
T0vre<7Ti

eirokirevero toivvv ev

r^

iprjfxca

TTvevfxartKiog'
^/^ovj"

vevYjarevKe yap, ov^ev itavreXwi rrf rov 10
elg
rpocf^YjV'

cafxarog %/5e/a
fxevog,

ovk avrog vyjareKXg Trpoa^eoetg v7r0ypafi.fi.vjv avart6eti,

akka

rvirov yjfuv

ra KaQ eavrov
vjf/.iv

Kai etKOva
^(orjg.

irotovfi.evog rrjg irap
rrf

e^aiperov Kai reBavfxacfj.ev^i

ro ^e ev

ep^fLco

^tairaaBat

avayKoiov

Kat

'^(prjatfi.ov

eartv.

airo^f^otrmreg

yap

rm

etKaiav rov Trapovrog j3t0Vf rrept- 15
rrjv
rj^ovi^v

aTraafxm Kai KVfjJxrm Kat ^akrjg aTr^WayfxeSa, Ka)
airoveKpovvreif Kpeirroveg rov rretpa^ovrog

Harava
fxot

eaofxeOa.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias.
avBpamov
<f>vaiv,

'EvratJfia

PXerre

t^v

rov

Kai ev carapyr\

rw l^ptarw r^ rov Aytov

YJvev-

fxarog ya.ptri KaraKeyjptaft.evriVy Koi ralg avoordro) rtfxaTg eare- 20
^avoj/xevijV
**
*'

irdXat fuev yap
ev

vrrtayyeno

ra>v

o\av Qeog, XeyaVy

orri

earai

ratg rju.epatg eKeivatg eKyefh arro rov Ylvevfxarog
irpcorai

fxov eiri

iraaav adpKa." vevXrjparat Se eig rjfxag ag ev
rrepi

"Xpovo}

ro errrfyyeXfxevoVf Kat

fxev

rav dpyatorepm aKaOeKTwg

€KKeKktKorav eig (f>tXoaapKtav

e((>rj

rrov

HpiaTog, " ov

fxri

Kara' 25

"

fxetv-fj

ro Ylvevfxa
EiTrettr]

ev

rolg dvBpwTrotg rovrotg ^ta ro eivai avrovg

adpKag."

^e vrdvra yeyovev ev Xptarco Kaiva, Kat t*/v §/a
rreTrXovrriKafj.ev, yiprifxart-

rivey^arof xe Kat v^^arog dvayevvrjatv
^ofxev
"he

ovKeri

aapKog Kat oufxarog

reKva, rrarepa ^e fxdXXov
(og

KaXovfiev rov Seov' ravrrj rot Kai f>.dXa elKoru^g, ware
fxrffMevoi Xoiirov

TeTt-

30

Kai ro Xafxrrpov eyovreg

rrjg

vioOeaiag

Kavyr]fx.a,

Betag (f^vaeag yeyovafj-ev Koivavoif ^ta fxeroyrjg rov 'Aytov Hvei;^

Leg.

fors. rvxoy.

34
y.aTo<;'

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
6 h

IV.

3.

ev vjfMv TrpojroroKo^y ore yeyovev ev TtoXXoHi a^ek<f>o7i,

Ka$ei( eavrov eli Kevooaiv, ^e-^^erai irparov ro Ilvev/xa, Kai roi rov

Uvevfxarog ^or^p VTtdpyaiv avrog, iva Kai

elg

yjfia$

epy^^rai

ti
7]

avrov ro

a^tcof/.a,

Kai rrjg irpog ro 'Ayiov Ylvevfxa Koivooviag
6

Xapig. ^oiovrov ri Kai

YiavXog ^tldaKei

yifj.ag

Xeym

Trepi

re ^
evog

avrov Kai •^(xaV "

re yap dytd^cov Kot

dyia^o[Ji.evoi

c|

" vdvres'

ot

vjv

ovk eTiata^^vverat dheX(f>ovg aiirovg KaXuv, Xiyav,
ro^ig dteXtfioHg fxov.

"

aiiayyeXvi ro ovofkd aov

E^6;^^ yap
ro vneXBeh

oXcag
T»yv

cvK eitato^^vverat KaXwv
irpog
Tffiag

y)fj.dg

dteX^povg,
rvjv

"htd rot

Ofxctwaiv,

^ia rovro
fneS

vjfJMV

eig
rvjv

eavrov Trrayeiav 10
Krtaiv

[ji.€rart$€tg,

dytd^erai
ft>j

vjfxwv,

Kairoi

d-naaav

dyta^cov avrog, tva
fj.evog fj.erpov, 6 rvjg
(f)vyctiv.

(paivvjrat ro

r^g

avdpcoiTorvjrog

irapatrov-

dndvrm
ev

acorvjptag Kai ^avjg avOpccTtog yeveaSai
Trpog yjfj.dg yevoft,evog

fj.yj

Kat

"

6fJ.otccaet ryj

t^ Kard
15

"
3 "

irdv ori ovv,

ttya

fiovyjg dfj.aprtag.^^

JflANNOT TOT XpT202T0M0T.
eTreivaaev," ov^e

" Ka/ avvreXeaBetawv avrwv
Treivavrt itpoaepyerai, tva

ydp wjarevovrt dXXd

av

fi.d$yjg, yjXtKov vyjareta

KaXov, Ka\ iiag oitXov eart Kard rov
rpv(f)yj

itajSoXov fj.eytarov, Kat ort fxeya Xovrpov, ov
rpaTie^y] 7rXyj$ovay],

Kat

fj.e$yi

Kat

aXXa

vyjareta irpoae^yj^tv ^e?.

A/a ydp
dXX^

rovro 20
yjfJ-dg

Kat

avrog ev^arevaev, ovk avrog ravryjg

'teofj.evog,

irat^evccv.

OpirENOTS.

Udvra

Ttetpaafj.ov ov efj.eXXov 0/ dvSpcoiroi Tteipd-

^eaSai, irparov eiretpdaSy]

Kard ro

dvSpwTitvov'

^e Xeyco, rotovrov
cog

eartV eav

t^yjg

rovg «tto rav aipeaecov eaStovrag
'taSt

dprov tov 25
6

Xoyov rov xpev^^,

ori

eKehog

Xoyog

6

Xi$og

earlv, ov

^tdjSoXog "^etKVvatv, evet TToiog ^v Tretpaafxog rov Xi$ov yeveaSai
aprov, Kat rov ^ioryjpa (f)ayeiv
;

4

At^daKet &e htd T^f
Oe rpe<f)ov
avSpcoTrog'
pvjfj.a

Xe!^ecog, ori
eir

ovrog fiev, ov
eKetvco

pyjfj-a

Seov, ro

Kai ro

^cooTtotovv'

ydp

rco

p^^fxart

^^ 30

afj.a Se rvjpet, ori
yjv.

ravra Xeyet Kard ro

dvSpdoTrtvov, ov

KaSo Seog

Q,g ydp

irept

dvSpcoirov dnoKptverat Kat
fj.ova>

Xeyet,
^yjXcov

"

yeypairrat, ort ovk hr dprca

^yfaerai

dvSpcoirog,^^

ort cog avSpcoirog eart iretpa^ofj.evog.

5

Eizrwv Se

6

EivayyeXtaryjg,

oti

"

e^et^ev

avrw irdaag rd(35

;

IV. 14-

AOTKAN ETATTEAIOT.
oiKovfxivrji cv (JTiyfJiyj "^q^ovov" olvti
<i>fl^h
'^«'

85
tov ^ieypaxpe
Tiva
€v

" PaaiKeiaf T^f
Tco

koya

TVjv

oiKov[ji.€vi^Vf

wa-7rep

Tponov

t^

^tavoia avTov mre^eiKVvev a^ coeTO.
€1

ov^ev

y]yvo'ei 6

ndvTa

Troi^aa^,

yap

fxvj

TOVTO

cctt/, irwf y^^vvaTO

avTovs tov^ TOitovg e/f kva
oiov,

TOTTov

vpog

Seccpiav
yj

acofxaTiKrjv
tvjv 'Iv^av

ayayeTv,

(pepe

elneTv,

Trjv^

YIep(T(ov yjyefJioviav,

ToT

ATioT rpHropiOT Nt22H2.

'O KaTo. TTavTa
yjfi.Tv

Koiva>vy](Tag
7raSyjfJ.d-

yjljJiv 'Xjiapig

afj.apTiag, Kai avfj.fJ.eTaa')(a}v

twv avTwv

Twv, TYiv Trehav ovk eKpivev dfxapTiav, ov^e dncoaaTo T^f eavTOv
ireipag
(f)vae(i}$

to

««t

avT-^g
e^ri

vdSof,

aX\

e'i^aTO

t^v

opeKTiKyjv

T^fio

opfxi^v, t>jv

Tyj Tpo(f>^

yivofj.evy]v,

diroanog yap Tea'E^w/ce

aapdKovTa
ePovXeTO
13

^fi.epoiv ^iaft.eivag,

vaTepov eTreivaaev.

yap ore

Tyj

(pvaei Kaipov to. eavTVfg evepyyjaai.

Kai avPTcXeo-a^ irdvTa
ra
e^rjs.

Treipaa-fiou

6 Sict^oAoy,

Acai

15
Treipaafj.ovg
01

TouTovf TQvs Tpei$
pi^a-e.
vj

eKTeXeaag

tidjSoXog dveyi>'
yj

Tiveg ovv eiaiv

Tpeig

;

yj

yaaTpifxapyia,

(piXapyvpia,
irpcaTog

KevoOo^ia,

aWovg

irapa toitou? iretpaa^ft.ovg ovk
eTret^v}
ov-/^

e^xjet.

Aoafj.

hia KotXiag 'ireipd^eTai,
(ov,

ei^/e

irXeove^iav, ov^e

Kevo^o^tav, irdvTWv Kvptog
avT(f!

Kat

fi.y}^evog

eTepov ovTog' ov irpoadyet 20
00

^tdj3o\og opy^v,

oy^ev

yap

e/j^ev

opytaQy]'

diro

ryjg

yaaTptfJMpytag totc ^p^aTO, Kat vvv eKeiBev yjp^aTO.

T/

Se

€<rT/

to

"

ecog

Katpov ;" e^e^ej^CTO yap t^v
tva

iovhaiccv

irovyjptav.

^ptaTog ^c ^ta tovto irapeyeveTOy

irXyjpwai^

T^f
25

otKovfjiev^g tov aKOTrov.

14

To
"
T^

^e

*'

virea-Tpeipev 6
'^ta

lyjaovg ev Tyj

'^vvdfj.ei

tou Y\vevfj.aTog

elg T>?v

TaXtXatav^

Tag

Beoavifj.eiag (pyjalv, (aairep eTreTeXet
Tre-Troptafj.e'-

tvvdfxet Tov Ylavaytov YlvevfLaTog, ovk e^(o6ev Kot

vy}v TYjv

Tov YlvevfiMTog '/dpiv Xa^av, KaOa Kat

tZv dyKov yopog,

dXK

ojg (ov (f>vaet

Te dXrftxg Tiog tov Seov, wg i^ia ^vvdfxet Kai 3°
TVf

evepyeta.

yjtoifj.evog

tov Ylavaytov Kat ofJioovaiov YIvevfxaTog,

TavTag eipyd^eTO.
flpirENOTS.
Fiiret^v]

efxeXXev

dBXeh

irpog tov

^tdPoXov ev

tw
OTi

iretpaafxx, ^ig oVofJ.d^eTat to Ylvevfxa yjap^g ndavjg TrpoaByjKrfg'

F a

5

S8

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA

IV. i6.

Se aymi(Tafj.€vos eviKvjae Tovi Tpe^g avayeypafxfxevov^; 7reipacr(xov^,

Ttpoaayeg

ttJ

aKpi(3eia TVjg ypacpy^g ti Trepi tov Tlvev[Ji.aTog
'^vvdfjiei

(f)Vj(Tiv,

"

OTi 'lyjaovg viiecrTpexpev ev Tyj

tqv Y\veviJ.aTog

;

Kai

Trpo(T-

iB-^Kev

"

ev ttJ ^vvdixei^' ^ia tov dBXiqTYiv tov veviKi^KOTa.
KO(rfji.ov" (pyjci,

'QpirENOTS. " Ba(7iXeiag
wwv, Tiva Tponov
viro
01

tov
01

ko(T[j.ik(iov

avQpco- 5

^acriXevovTai viro 'novvjpiag,
01

^e ^aaiXevovTai

(piXapyvpiag,

^e

vito

Kevo^^o^iag'

ov

yap

e^eiKvvev avTcp
iv

Tag ^aaiXetag tov
avTOV

Kocrfjiov,

Tiva TpoTiov layyei ^amXevei,v,

"jrpOTpexpyjTai TTOiYjdai, b evof/.i^e TtoiYiaai, nepiyevridecrQai
€1

tov

X.ptaTov.

GeXetgy

(f^yjcrt,

^acrtXevcrai tovtuv,

Kai

€7r<

tovtccio

eXrjXvGag tov dyctiVKjacrOai Kai aTro^TTyj^rat Tovg ^acrtXevofxevovg
VTT
eft.ov,
fj.yi

dyavt^ov,
tyjv

ev

d^ta,

Treawv
tvjv
vtt

TrpoaKvvyjcrov
efie.

fx,e,

Ka)

TiapdXa^e iraaav

(3a(TtXeiav

aXX
eSvy],

6

"EaTy^p

PaatXevaai

ft.ev

OeXet

Kat viioTd^at ndvTa

to,

iva

"^ovXa
1

yevyjTat ^iKaioavvyjg Kat dXyfietag Kat irdayig dpeT^g' jSaatXevaat ^e
oi)

fJ.eTa

dfiapTiagy

ov^e

(BovXeTat

dKfj.yiTt

vnoTd^ag avTOv

eKeivco

eaTe^pavccaSat, ov^e «ac/xtjt/
t>;v

Xa^eh

tidaag Tag ^aatXetag

Tov Koafj.ov, Kat
avTOv,
*'

to^^av

avTm

vTioyetptov.

Aio

<f>y}at

Tipog

" yeypanTat, Kvpiov
XaTpevaetg.^^

tov Seov aov TipoaKVV^aeig, Kat «utoo

fLOvca

20
KaraaTyjaai ef atfj.aTog lapayjX
etg

16

^Kft,(pai^ h€,(f)y}aiv, eavTOv Kai

^ovXofj.evog, Kai
acoTYjptav TVjg

OTt

Keyp^aOat Tiapa tov Seov Kat YiaTpog

vti

ovpavov, 7iavao(j)ctig Kat tovto otKovofJ.eH npo
oig avveTpd(f)Yi,

y^

Twv aXXwv Tolg €k Na^apeT,
<py]fi.i,

Ka^d ye

ty^v

adpKa,

TOVTo yapi^of/.evog.

"

yjXSe" yap,
e^y}g.

(f>y]atv,

"

etg

Na^apeT, ov 25

"

y]v

dvaTe6pafj.fj.evog,'' Kai

Ta

Avayvovg
Ilvevfj.a

^e to. ev too Tipo-

^•^TY]
*'

Haata
eveKev

dvayeypafj.fj.kva,
fj.e

"

oti

Kvptov

eii
toc

efj.€,

ov

eyptae
^ta

evayyeXtaaaOat
e^etKVve

TiTcoyoTg," Kat

e^Yjg.

EivapyeaTaTa
y]v,

tovtcov

TOig

aKovovatv,

oti

avTog
Kat 30

TOTe ^ta tov TipocpyjTov XaXav, OTt Kat
^taacoacov
ttjv
vti

evavSpcon^aet

d(f)t^eTat
(f)afj.ev

ovpavoV Keyp^aOat ydp ovy eTepcog

Tov Tiov,

7iXy]v

oTt

KaTa adpKa,

yevofj.evov

^yjXovoTt KaQ'

y}fj.dg

Kat evav6pco7iY}aavTa.
Se,

ai

E/Ve
k^Yig,

"

OTt

aY}fj.epov

TteTiXy^pcoTai

y}

ypa(py]

avTV},^^

Kat

toc

kavTOV (pavepcog TiapiaTag ev Toinotg tov ^td t^^ 7ipo(p^Teiag35

IV. 23•7rpor}yop€V[Ji.evov'

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
avTO^ yap evyjyyeXio-aTO
ryjv roov

37
ovpavZv Pa<Ti~

Xeiav ToTg aiTO
/x^

twv lOvZv' avTOt yap
[J.yj

y)(Tav

vToyxotj /xijSev ej^ovre?,

Siov

€v

yvaaet,

vofxov, /x»? Trpo^ijTa^,

Kai anaat toJV ttAov-

Tov ovK e)(ov7t TTvevfxaTtKOv

avTOs

at')Qji.aA'jiTovg

ovTag eppvaaTO,

Tov aTro(7Ta,TYjv Tvpavvov KaQeXliv, TovreaTt tov Y^aTavav'

avTog^

€v^<TTpa\p€ TO vovjTOV Kai Beiov Kat ovpavtov (pwg ToHg eaKOTta-fjLfvvjv

eyovat T^v Kuptiav, KaBwg avTOq
**

(f>y)ai,

"

OTt

eyw (pag

etg tov

Koaf/.ov

TOVTCV IkrjXvOa'^' avTOg aTrekvae

^eafJLiov, '^yjXovoTt

twv
eK'^-

fig afLapTiav, Toiig avvTeSpavaft.evyjv

eyovTag Kap^iaV avTOg

pv^ev evtavTOv K.vpiov ^eKTOv, ov 6 iravao^pog YlavKog
XeycoVf
**

ft.vy]f/.ovevet

lo

/^ov, vDv Kaipog evTrpoa^eKTog, t^ov vvv y]fi.epa acoTyjpiag.^'

22

TavTa
"
•yaptTog

^e aKovovTeg

Kat

6avfjt,d^ovTeg

*'

eirt

ToTg

Xoyotg Trjg

ToTg eKiiopevofi,evotg

eK

tov

aTOfiaTog avTov," KaiTot

afx.iKpoXoyeTv

avTOv ovk
^lcoayjcj)

aireaTyjaaV
oOev

eXe-yov

yap,

(f^rjatv,

**

ov^^t

^^

viog

eaTtv
**

ovTog ;"

apfxotiov

etiteTv

eir

avToTgi^

rovTO'
**

ttov

Xaog

fJLCopog

Kat aKap^iog'

0(p6aXfL0i avToTg, Kai ov

^Xeirovaiv,

WTa

avToTg, Kat ovk aKovovatv."

33

Kat

€hre irpos avTOv^, HauTcos epeiTe fXOL ttjv irapa-

^oXqv TavTTjv/laTpe, Oepairevaov aeavTov.
Kotvog Xoyog vapa
ToTg
^lov^^atotg ^v, aaTraafj.ov '/aptv e^yivpy]fi.evos'

20

yap appaaTovat tSv lUTpwv
aeavTOv" xaavet
ort iroXXa

eTre(pavovv Ttveg,

*'

laTpe, Oepd-

"

Tcevaov

ovv tovto

irporetvag avToTg to pyjTOVy
efKov yiveaBat ay]fi.eTaf

^piaTog eXeyev,
irap
vfj.Tv

^ovXeaSe irap
eTpcx^pyjv.

fj.aXtaTa, irap

oig Kat

AaA' oiOa to

Kotvov

Kai

airaat avfx^aTvov iraQog, ort KaTa(f>povovvTat irov aet Kai

Ta 25

e^atpeTa

t5v

TrpayfLaTxv, orav
'ETrei

fj.yj

airavi^y]
eir

"Trapix

Ttatv,

aXX

eyaatv

eir

a^eiag avTa.

ovv Kat

avBpwTi'x tovto avfj.-

Paivet Qavfj.aaTlag,

yap

avv^Si^g Kat iraphv

aet

airoaTepeTTat

iroXXaKtg Tyjg
Ota TOVTo
t(
's^

o<f)etXof>.evy]g
vfj.Tv,

avTca

Ttfj.y]g

irapa t»v e^OTOiv avTOV

**
»

Xeyj}
~

OTt

ovtetg irpocp^Ti^g ^eKTOg eaTtv ev lyj^o

iraTpiot avTov.

npirENOTS.
Trap
^evoi

YlaTptg tuv irpo^py^Twv,
y]fJ.eTg

eK

ireptTOft.y]g

Xaog^

oU

ovK etat teKJOt'

Se

ot

aXXoTptot t'2v ^ta9rjK'2v Kai
tpv)(yj

Toav

eirayyeXfZv, ete^aifj.eQa Tovg irpocf^yJTag oXy}
j]Trep eKeTvot,

irpo-

Ky]pv^avTag ^piaTOv

wairep Kat

rj

ev "LapecpSav Ti^g

3$

Tit^uvtag yy^pot tov 'Hxiav Xtfxov yevofj.evov ev rca 'lapay]X, tov

36

EPMHNEIA TQT KATA

IV. 30.
Trpocf^^TVji (pYjaiv,

aKcivaai Xoyav Kvpiov. Trepi TavTVjg t^? yyjpag

"
*

OTi

TioWa Ta TeKVa T^g

ep^rjfxov

[xaXXov

7]

Tvji

e^^ovarjg

tgv

avbpa,
Yi

Kai TraXiv, oti cTepa ypacpij,

(Jieipa eTCKev eirTa, Kat

"

TToXXy} ev TeKVoig y]a$evrjaeJ'

'KTrei^rj ^e

Tag

irept

avTov

"Tipocf^i^Tetag elg
e7[i

TeXog ^p^^a/ tte(3e-S

l3aiovvTO Toov

lov^^aim Ttveg, ^
eitt

Ttai Tav irap avTolg fie(3aat~
•yjpyjat^xuig

XevKOTCoVf
TYjg

Yj

Trpocf^^^Tatg

dytotg, airocfyepet

avrovg
fxyj

ToiavTYjg vTrovoiag, eXey^^cov

avTovg ag airtaTovvTag, Kai
7rpo<f>yjTeiat

TriaTevovTag oti [xaXXov etg avTOV ai TOiavTat
^ovat, irpog [xiav aTreaTaXOat XYjpav
ovacov ev tcS 'lapayjX Tore, Kat
<f>v]Tyiv

dp[Ao-

YlXiav

etirwv, Katirep

iroXXav 10

eva Bepairevaai Xenpov tov irpoTrkeiaTCiov
[i.ovvj

Kktaaaiov Na/e/Aav tgv Hvpov, Kai eK tovtccv
ev

OVTCOV

TW

lapavjX,
6[».oici)g

eTret^v]

eK iraaav

tcov

'/vipcav

eKetvvj

evpeOyj TriaTvj,

Kai eK TrdvTCCv tcov XeTrpcov ovTog.

ToT ArioT Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias. T;
eivat
ovy^
Tcov

to kcoXvov avTOViS
evo[/.i^eTo
\coavj(f> ;

aeirrov tc Kat d^idyaaTOV, et

Kai viog

opag Tag Beoavj^xeiag
^at[t,ovcov
;

;

TreaovTa Tov '^aTavav, veviKV][/.evag Tag
voavj[udTcov

dyeXag,

^ta(f)opcov

eXevQepovg yeyovoTag
;

TroXXovg

eiraive^g tvjv y^dptv tvjv evovaav

avTov Ta7g ^t^aaKaXiatg
'Jcoavjcf)

cha
*'

a[LtKpoXoye7g ^lov^^aiKwg, OTt iraTepa tov
eir

e7reypd(f>eTo

;

20

D, TroXXvjg d(3ovXiag, dXvjQeg

avTovg

eiTreiv,

"

i^ov

Xaog

[/.copog

Kat dKapttog,

0(f>6aX[t.ot

avToHg, Ka) ov ^Xeirovaiv, coTa, Kai ovk

aKovovai.

30
**

A<a

Tt eKJBaXXovTcav

avTWV " waTe KaTaKpvjfxviaat avTOv, avTog
;"

^teXGm S;a [neaov avTcov enopeveTO
eXvjXvdev,
vjv

ov to TraSeiv (f>evycov, ^ta 25
dvafxevcov

ToyTO yap Kai
TovTo.

dXXa

Katpov

entT-^^eiov

etg

dpyri

yap

vvv tov Kvjpvy[i.aTog'

tovto de avTO virdp^/ei
Kat ovk av ovhe

TeKft.-^ptov, OTt

Ka) OTe eiraOev, eKovatcog
[uj eavTOV eTretcoKev.

ireTrovSe,

T0T6 eiraSev,

et

ToT
Tig

ATTOT.

Ovf

ov [KeBtaTvjat Xoyog vrpog to elbevat

aa(f>cog

(f>vaei

Kat dXvjBwg eaTai Seog Kat Kvpiog, TovTovg aayyjvj

vevei Trpog to evvjvtov

tcov avj[t.eicov

eirt^et^ig.

')(j)vjat[*.cog oiiv

Kat

dvayKaicog TspoaeTcdyet iroXXdKtg Talg [x.vaTaycayiaig Tag [xeyaXovpytag' aTrtaTOt
tSov
[j.ev

ydp

ot

Tvjg

lov^aiag otK^^Topeg, Kat Tovg

KaXovvTcov

eig

acoTYjptav

dTt[t.d^ovTeg

Xoyovg, [/.dXtaTa

Se35

TravTCOv ot airo Tvjg Kanepvaovft..

IV. 34-

AOTKAN ETArrEAlOT.
KE4>. H.
Hepl Tov e)(ovTos irvevyM
baiiioviov.

30

^;^

Kat

eV

ttj

avuaycoyfj

rjv

oivdpcdiros

e^oiv Trvevfia

Sai/xovLOV aKaOdpTov.
¥t7[€iVfi

^e 01

lov^ahi ovh\v €T€pov

evofJii^ov tlvai

rov X|9i<7TOV, 5
7iapeXde7v

itXriv

OTi

Ka6 eva

rm

ayim, Kai

ev

Ta^et
r^^v

Trpocpi^rcov

elg

fxeaov.

Aia, rovro

im

fji,€i^ova

Trepi

avrov ^o^av Kai
ov^e

v-novoiav eyiodif ro '7rpo(p'rjTiKOv ava^aivei

[Ji.erpov'

yap

eipfiKe

vore rd^e koyiKug

%

aXX' loare

voix.iKSog

ra vvep

vo/jlov

eAaAe/,
Tivev- 10

Kai [xer e^ovaiag T^f
[JM(71V.

QeoTrpeTtoix; ro7f

aKaSdprois eTrerifxa

34
"

FiV<f)'^fi.et

^e ayTOv ro

iivevfka ro

dKaSaprov Xeyov, " oi^d
TOtavrvjg

cre,

rtg

e/,

aytog rov 'Ia-pa>;A," virovowv ^ta r^$
^o^^rjg

ev<f)V)-

fJitag

ro Kevovv

avrov epaarrjv diroreXeiv, Kai dTroa^^^eaOat
ofj.ototg

-TrapaaKevd^et
olov

rov eirtirXrirTeiv avrco re Kai roig
^itovra
ov

avrov, 15
^oXtog
ryfv

avrt

ydptrog

ydptV

aAA ovk

hrtrev^erat
^e

Qyjpag,

Seog yap

ft,vKTyjpt^eTai,

dirocf^pdrret

fj.aK\ov

aKaGaprov avrov yXwrrav
avTOV airocpotrav.

Kvptog, Kat Trpoa-rdccrei rov

€-)(ovrog

TiTOT BosTPflN.
Kvptog avveyjapyjaev
(og
;

AjOa ^ta ri eppiypev
eireiVrj

avTOV
vyjcfyoov

;

^ta rt Se

o

20

yap eXdXei wg

Kat ecffOeyyero
v]

KaOearYjKug, ^ta ro ra p'^fj.ara eivat rov
€vofj.t^ov
01

^atfj.ovog,
ov^^^

Se yXiorra
ev
tatfj.ovt(i)

rov avBpamov, Kai
irovfipia

avBpavot ort

a>g

e^pQeyyero,
pixl^ai

aXX

€K r^g Kap^^tag avrov
"^rjXov

eXdXet, avveyoi'^atfj.ovtov

pvjaev
€C7Ti

avT^

rov dvtpa, iva

yevyjrat, ort ro

25

ro XaXyjaav.

Es
rrfv
fj.€Vov'

ANEnirPA*oT. ^EK^dXXovatv avrov, KaB
opt^ovreg, Kat

eavrcov fKaXXov
etpyj-

OtKfiv

fSe^atovvreg ro
ri^g

viro

rov 'E(or^pog
TVjg

eKTreirrwKaai
fj.yj

yap avrot
'

dva

TroXeoog

lirovpavtov,

rov y^ptarov
fJ-^^^^jptg

oe^dft,evot.

\va §e fKovov eXey^y] 'tvaae^vjaavrag ^o

eTrf^etpyjfJMTUiv,

avyKeyap-^^Ke "JrpoaeXBeh

ra Ka& eavrov
oaov
elireiv

roXfj.yffj.aTa.

Ate^iet

yap

ha

fj.eaov

avTwv, ov^ev

rtva

6efj.€vog

r^g eTrt^ovXrjg avrav.
* "KvyeiKuq Cod.

5

40

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
KE$.
0.
Uhpov.

IV. 38.

Tlfp\ TJ7? nepdepas

38

^

Avacrras 8e

e/c

TrJ9

avvaywyrj^, dcrrjXOev U9

rrjv

OlKLaV ^ifXODVOS.

Ktpiaaot Aaesanapeias. Qfaaai
Twv fxaQYjTwv,
€KQva-iov
^i

ttw^

KareXvaev Ttap

ev/

av6p(i}7rw

TrevvjTt

Kai

a.a^[X(i)
tv

KaTo, tov jSioVf 6 tvjv
V][xe7$ Tyj

yj[j.ag

vTro[Jt.eiva$

TiTwy^eiav,

eKcivov itTd}-

yeta
[xri

TrXoyr^o-cy/xev, Kat fxd6a}[xev toI^ raTieivoHg cyvveTidjeaBai
VTro^e^O[JieSa
ev
rj[juv

Kai

KaTercapecBai rav ev ev^eia Kai BXppei.
r][xe7g

Totvvv
eyctift.ev

Kat

tov

Ivjo-ovv.

orav yap eiaPdXr] Kat
tSov

10

avTOv

eig vovv

Kai Kap^^tav, TOTe
^e

eKTOirm

yj^ovwv tvjv •jrvpcoatv

amcrPeaei.

eyeipet

Kat

evppcoaTovg aTrocpaivet, Trvev[xaTiKa>g
to,

OVjXovoTt, ooare
TrXvjpovv.

Kat vnrjpeTeh avTWf TOVTeaTi,

avTW toKovvra

ToT Anor Titot Bostpan.
Kai Av^pea Kat IukcoP koi To

OvKeTi yap ^ twv

laBevToov diio 15

voiKtXccv aadeveiav, Kat drco iTvev[j.dTm aKaddpTcov, Kai irept
""lcodvvov.

UeTpov

To

**

vTiYjpypv

dXteig," Koi

"

vjKoXovQovv

Tw 'KptaTcf
dypag
rcov

Tipoeypd(f>ri.

Ylepi

te

AXe^av^peiag
Tovg

—Aid
^id

Trjg

lyPvcov

Xeyei

aytog KvptXXog

tu>v dXtevTiKcov

avTov

hrtTritev[j.dT(ov, dXtevei

20

[JiaQrjTag,

oircog

[xdQcoaiv

eK tovtov OTt navaBeveg eyet
rj

to

BeXri[x.a,

Kat roHg BeoTrpeneaTdTotg avTov vevfiaatv
iva Tipdyfj.aTog

KTtatg vnr]-

perei'
etKovog

Kat

evapyovg, Kat

wg eK tvttov Kat
OTt

Tov

iiapc^o^wg

TeTeXea[i.evov

'7TXr]po(f)oprjdcoatv,
r]

ovk

a[f.taBog 6

iiovog avTotg, ovt^e
Tr]g

aKaprtog

airovVr]

earat avroTg, ^v 25
diTXdo-

av irof^aaiVTo,
aavTeg,

evayyeXtK^g [f.vaTaycoyiag to ^tKTVov

aXX

ev

avTco TiaVTr] re Kat TrdvTCog Tag tHov eQvwv

dyeXag

avXXe^coatv.

KE*.
Hfpl
rS>v

I.

ladfvrav dirb noiiiiXciv voaav.

30
oar]v
ey^et

Ktpiaaot Aaebanapeias.
TV]V

ABpet le

[xoi

rrdXtv,

w<peXetav
^

v]

T^g dyiag avTov aapKog

erra^r], eXavvet

ydp Kat

Multa

hic omissa esse videntur et leg. mepi tuv 1x6.

V. 5-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.

41

votKt\a$ vocrovg Kai Sa/^ov/wv ^Aov, Koi t^v tov ^ia^okov SvvafjLtv

KoracrTpeipei.
K.aiTOt

yap Xoya KOt

v€vfi.aTi

vXyjpovv ^vvafxevog

rag repaTOis

TOVpyias, iva t£v avayKaiav ^i^a^r], Kai rag %e<J9aj
oixriv

€7rt(f>epei

ev

dppaaTiais.
tvjv

E^ci yap, e^ei [xa6e7v ^/Aaf, oti
evepyetav
-TrecpopifjKev
oj

tvj^

tovS

Xoyov ^vvdfJiewf

dyia aap^f ^v

i^iav

evof^cTaro, BeoirpeTiri t^v tvvafxiv efx^vTevcag avT^ij. ovkovv aTrreo-fico

Kat
iva

vjfJMVf

fndWov

^e

^fi.eTi

avTov ^ia

Tv}g

fKV(TT iK-fji

evkoyiag,
T^i'

Kai

vjfJMg

eXevBepwcf]

xpv)(^iKa>v

appuKjTi^fJidTm Kat

twv
lo

^aifxovictiv e(potov Kat TiXecve^lag.

Tor Anor Tixor.
^atf/.ovas d-TroaojSeT,
otKovfJievyjv tyjv dXyjQetaVy

^vyo^evet

voa-^fJLOTa, aa-ejSetav e^eXavvetf

irdvTa to,

KaKa eK^dXXet^ eladyet
Seoirpe^vrj.

te

eU t^v

e^ovaiav

KE4>. [A.
Uepi
TTJs

aypas riov lxBv<ov.
SavfJM(XQ}fji.ev
tojv

I<
Tyjg

2

Ktpiaaot Aaeeanapeias.
evTCj^vov, TO
(fyrift^t

oiKovofxtas
vtt'

to

eirt

t^ ye

Gyjpa

TeOvjpi^KOTwv
oi

t*jv

ovpavoV
vtto

tvj

t«v dytwv AmaTokwv,
yeyova(7t

Kat

dXtevetv

e/^oTej,

\pt(TTOv

Xhov^

tva

Kat

avTot

t^v twv

evayyeXiKwv

KfipvyfJMTWV aayrjviqv y^aXdaavreg, TrpoaKOfxtaaatv

avTW Tovg Kara 20
irpo^pvjTwVf

Ttdaav
**

Tviv yvjv.

Ka\ yovv

e(f>'*]

irov

^i

evog

twv dyiav

/Sou

eyw diroaTeXXo) dXieig iroXXovg^ Xeyet

ILvpiog, Kat dXtev-

**
**

acoaiv avTovii

Koi fxeTa TovTa, dvoaTeXw TroXXovg Srjpevrdg,

Koi Brjpevaaatv avTovgT Kat Tovg fxev dXieTg Tovg dyiovg Atto(f)V]a],

QToXovq
atwv.

Or^pevTag Se Tcyf

Kard Katpovg twv dyiav eKKXrj-^^
EweiS»;

rjyovfLevovg tc

Kat fxvaTaywyovg.

ydp dpKovvTwg

ToTg oyXotg ^tetXeKTat, TpeireTat

irdXtv irpog

t^v avv^dr] fxeyaTovg

XovpyiaVf
fxaQr]Tdg.

Kat

&/a

twv dXtevTiKwv htiTr^evft.dTav dXtevet

5
**

TiTOT Eni2KonoT BosTPON.
oXr]g

^rjaiv

^tfxwVf

" hrtaTdTa
iroXXot

ti

30

T^?
^XOoVf

vvKTog KoirtdaavTeg, ovtev eXdfSofxev."
Koti
efjietvev

vpo-

(fyilTat

drrtaTog 6 Koafxog.

Aia tovto eXeyev

G

42

,

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
vi)^ 'TrpoeKo^pev,
vj

V.

12.

UavXos, " ^
"
eva'/viiJ.ovQ}g

^e

vjfJiepa

*fff)iKev'
01

co$ ev iqff-epa.

TrepiTaT^accfJ.ev"^^

TtoXXa eKa^ov

TTpo^rirai, Kai

^Yovtatoi €[Ji€ivav airiaTOi.

Aia
" Tov

TovTO eXeyev
KOTTov

'EcoTyip,

Ti av Tig enroi irepi twv aXXcov eOvccv ; " aWoi KeKoiiiaKaai, Kai v[j.e7$ eit,
5
To7g irepi E</x.cova,

avTwv ei(7€XyjXv6aTe."

Ktpiaaot 'Aaesanapeias. UpoaeTo^e yap
^payy
01

r^i- yyji
ti'

ano^epeaQai, Kai KaQehai irpog aypav to oiktvov.
jxev

^e

oXYiq

ecpaaKov KOTiiaaai vvktoi;, Xa^eiv Se

[/.vj^ev'

itXyiv

ev

ovofmTi 'KpiaTOv

Kad^Kav to
'^ia

Xivov,

Kai [/.eaTOv el^/pv
cog

ev^vg Tav TeSrjpevfLevav, iva

itpay^J.aTo? evapyovg Kai

eK io

Timov Kai etKovog tov irapato^wg TeTeXea[i.evov,
OTi

TrXi^pocpopYjBaaiv,
7]

ovK

a[t.ia9og

Tiovog

avTU)v, ovre

aKapnog

aTrovQv], 7]v

av

•TTOirjaaivTO, TYjg evayyeXiKrjg [j.vaTay(t>yiag Xivov anXccaavTeg,

aXX

ev avTco TravTyj
TrXvjV

re Kai itdvTOog Tag Tav eQvav ayeXag avXXe^coai.

€Kem

a6pei, ov

yap

la^^^yaav

dveXKvaai to X7vov

^i[t.cov

re 15
oti

Kal

01

avv avTW' Karevevadv,

(f>y]ai,

To7g [xeToypig, ^^Aov ^e

^ta Twv dXievTiKwv eTtny^ev^JMTCtiV, caare avXXa(3ea6ai avTOig Kai
avv^^iaacoaai tvjv dypav.

YloXXoi ydp To7g twv dyicov ATToaToXcov
iTOVoig,

avvfjpavTO Kai avvaipovTai

Kai irpo ye rwv aXXcav

01

Tag

lepdg

v}[juv

rwv dyicav EivayyeXiaTaiv dvepevvavTeg ypacpag, Kai 20
TroifJ.eveg

jxer' eKeivovg CTepoi
Kcti

Kai "^t^daKaXoi Kai Xaav yjyovfxevoi,

Tcov TYjg dXyjQeiag TrpayfLaTcov e'niaTyi[t.oveg.

Ava(pepeTat yap
eig

€Tt

TO X7vov, TTXyjpovvTog
Ti^g ev l3vQo7g

avTO Tov ^ptaTov, Kat KaXovvTog
6aXdaayjg Kara to
y€ypa[j.[>.evov,

€7TiaTpo(l>y^v

tovt-

eaTt Tov ev ^dXyj Kat KV[J.aatv, ev To7g KoafxtKO^g.
Ylept Tov XeTTpov Kat
€cog TTept TftJv
eiTi

25
TTept

tov iTapaXvTtKov Kai

tov reXwvov

daKcov rcov TTaXaicov Kat twv

vecov, itpoeypacjjyi.

KE4». IB.
ILepi

Tov \eiTpov.

1%

Kai iyeuero
KOLL

iu Tcp eiuat avTOU iv

ixlSl

twv

TroXecoVfSo

iSov dvrjp irXrjfyqs Xiirpas.
'ETra/vov iTavTog a^ta tov iTpoa-

Ktpiaaot 'Aaebanapeias.

V. 12.
eXBovTog
yj

AOTKAN EYArrEAIOY.
TiiffTig' [/.efxapTvpvjKe

43

yap to TiavTa tvvaaBai KaTopdovv
eXevBepovaBai
vj

rSo ^E>[Xfxavov)}K, Kai '^ia vevfJLaToov BeoirpeTim

^rjTei'

KaiTOi

To

TrdOog

ovk

id(Tifji.ov'

ov

yap

otbev

Xenpa ralg
(pYiatv,

tccv

laTpm

efxireipiaig

iiapayitipel.v^

aKKa.

TeBeafKai^

eXavvo-

fKevovg ev
sroAAoJv

e^ovaia

BeoirpeTrei

tov^ aKaBdprovi "^aifxovag voarjfxdTcov 5

d7raK\aTTOfJ.evovg, Kai
ylvecrBai.

avv^Ka

cog

Beia

tivi

Kai afKa"^

yeipi

ra TOiavTa

opSo

^e Ttpoi tovto yjpfi^TOv ovTa Kai

eToifxoTaTa KaToiKTeipovTa Tovg irpoaiovTaq avTW.
KcoXvov
ev

T/
;

toivvv

to

eXeeiaBai Kdfxe
TYjv iriaTiv,

;

Kai ti Trpog TavTa ^piaTog
§>;

el3e/3aiov

avTW
"

Kat tyjv ez avToo
Trjv

tovt^

TiXvjpocpopiav

epyd- 10

^eTai.
<f>y]<nf

Se^^era/
BeXco

yap

anvjatv, Kai OfKoXoyel to ^uvaaBai, Kai

KaBapiaBYjTi'^^

yapt^eTat

^e

avTca Kat

dcprjv

r^g
dir

dytag avrov Kat TravaBeveardrrjg yetpog^ Kai evBeag
avTOv
vj

air-iqXBev

Xenpa, Kat ro irdBog ATTOT.

rpf

Ik iro^wv.

ToT

T/

^^7roT€ tva fJidBcoatv evrevBev 01 rvjv roov lafud- 15
;

rm

ydptv Trapa Seov ^eyofxevoi
atreh,
fx-^Te
ft.v}v

f>.r]

rag Ttapa txv Bepairevoft.evm
rivoov

ev(prifx.iag

rov irapd
rcov

eiraivov, iva

fjji^

eig

vTrepoiptav

eKireaotev, ro

Trdvrm

KaKxv ataytarov
rov Xeirpov

irdBog, Kat

KaB erepov ^e

rpoirov, Kai
vj

aiooTroovTog

vjpKet

Kat avrvj

rov Trpdyfiarog
avTOV
TV}V

(pcovvj,

irpog

ro airayyelXai irdai roig eihoaiv 20

rov Bepairevaavrog ^vvafxiv.
OlKOVOfxiKwg
(pvjat

ToT
Kara

ATTOT.

Trpoadyetv ro
vjBeXe fxev

"^oopov tcio Xeirpoo

tov Mcovaeoog vofxov ro7g lepevaiV
rrjv

OfxoXoyovfxevoog

fxeraaTrjaai
TtKriv

aKtav Kat fxeTaTrXdaai rovg rinrovg etg Trvevfka-

Xarpeiav'

dXX^

eiretOr]

fxvjnci}

Triarevaavreg
dog ert

irpog

avrov 25

^hv^aTot irpoaeKetvTo raTg Mooijaeoog evroXaTg,
eBvSov layvovTOov, eTrtrpeiret rca

roov dpyaioov

avTotg.

Ka<

fxer

oXtya

—Ka/
eiri

XeirpZ tovto

iroteiv

etg fxaprvptav

e^ afTov Ve rov BepaTrevaai rov

Xeirpov e^eariv i^eiv Kat fxdXa aa^oog ev dirapaKX-^rotg VTrepoyaig
•npog

Tov Moovaecog

vofxov,

ovra 'Kptarov'

eXeirpaBvf

fxev

ydp

v)

2,0

Maptdfx, d^eXcpvj ^e M.oovaeoog avrv]'
Kare^dKvero
dnoar-Siaat
fxev

KareXdXrjae ydp avTov, Kat
eiretov] Civk vjv

yap Xtav

rov Mcoijaeoog,
voaov,

iKavog
Xeyoov,

tov yvvatov

rr]v

Trpoaeirnrre

rco

Oew

Kyeog heofxai aov, taaat avTvp».

G 2

5

44
Iljjoaaj^ej' toivvv

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
aKpiPa^' alrriat?
TV)(eiv'
y^v

V. 17.

hKei &;a Trpoaeityj^g, t^?
o\cov SwTiyp (xeT

avadev

y]fjt.epoTy]Tog
ecpy]

vj^iov

^e

ye twv

e^ovaiag
Tvpiov
ei^evai
y]V

t^^ OeonpeTrovg, " 6eXo) KaOapiaGvjTi'" ovkovv fxaplepevaiv
vj

To7i

TVjg

kenpag am^oXy], Kai
amvefXovTag
t<b

y]V

evTevQev

Tovg

t*?v

KpeiTTOva

^py^cpov

MoJvVer, oti 5
6av[xd^etv
^/

T^g aXy]6eiag
/xcv
cog

e^oo l3adiovaiv.

E&e/ yap, e^et
yaptTog

MwyVea

vo[xov

^iaKovov

Kat

VTcovpyov,

\a\y]6etai^g

^yyeXccv, vnep6av[xd^€tv ^e tov
u>g

^E,[t.[xavovyj}\.

Ka\ ^o^oXoyeTv avTOv

Tiov

d}i.y]6y]

tov Qeov Kat YlaTpog.

ToT ArioT TiTOT

BosTPflN.

" Eig [xaprvptov avroTg,"
ov

eig

10

[xaprvptov ro 6epa7revea6at, tva itXi^pixTy] rov vo(xov'

yap

'^^Xde

KaraXvcrat rov vofxov Kat rovg
pertKo) ro

Trpo(f)yjrag,

aAXa

TtXr^paaai.

aipe-

"

elg fxaprvpiov" eig v(3ptv
01

Kara tov
elg

vo[xov Xa[x(3dvova-tv,
etg

ov

avvievreg
oiiov

dvor]Tot

ori

ro

"

[xaprvptov^

diiotet^tv
1

Xeyerat'

yap [xaprvpia,

irpocpaatg

eartv

d[K<pt^aXKo[xevov

npdy[xarog.

KE4>. ir.
Ilept

Tov irapaXvTiKov.

17

Kat eyevero
(TKcov,

eV ixia

twv

rjfJLepcov

kou avTos

rjv

dida-

Kol

rjaav

KadrjfievoL

^apiaaloi kcu

vofwbiZa- 20

(TKaXoL.

ToT ArioT Ktpiaaot 'Aaebanapeias.
Katov, ovK
evapt6[i.y]rov

'E7re;^»j ^e y]v

dvay-

TrXy^^vog

rav ypa[X[xare(ov Kat ^apiaatcav
fxdXtara ^eoTrpeTreardrwv
iiept

avveiXey[xevy]g, yevea6at

rav

ert

etg ovv]-

aiv avTov, [xtKpa

yap

e(f)povovv

avrov'
eiit

WKOvo[xy]6y] rt

iiaXtv 25

rwv Te6av[xaa[xevav'

epptTiro [xev

ydp

KXtvy]g itapdXvrog oivi^p,

dvidrw voax KeKpaTy][xevog.
}]

Etiret ^e

daBevovat iipog ro avfxfSdv,
rov
dv(i}6ev

Twv larpwv r^Xeyyero
irapd

re^^Qty],

Tipog

Kat e^ ovpavZv
te
y]v

larpov
XotTiov
Tiiartg.

twv

oiKetcov

eTieKOfxtl^eTo.

'ETrei&^
fxev

ev

oxpet

rov
ort

QepaTievetv Se

la^^^yovrog ,

teKrr]

avrov

yeyovev

0730

eariv dfxapriag dvatpertKr], tto^etKVvatv ev6vg

Kptarog,

eTiicfxtiveT

ydp tw

Ketfxevo)

Xeywv, " dv^pane, ouf^ewvrai

V. 17-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
ai afxapriai crov'"
ryjg

45
epu
rig
r-^g

"

(Toi

aXk
vocrov

cag

ye

oifnai, iipog TOVTOig

evQvg aTraXXay-^vat

k^ovkero'
;

Kai itwg acpecriv
iva fxAOYjg ort

aikapTiag avrSi Hpiarog eiiyjyyeXXiTo
/xevwf
etpopa,
**

a-ectyy]-

Kat

a\po<f)VjTt

Qeog

KaraaKaTrreTat

ra

avSpooTitva,

Kat

r^g eKaa^rov ^oi^g
tiai

ttjv o^^ov'

ovtco Kai yeypairrat'
o^ot av^^pog'
eig

"

evcoTrtov

^

yap

rm
Beket

rov Qeov

0(()$a\fJiSiv

Traaag rag

"

rpoy^iag avrov aKOvevei."

hrei^vj Se

eartv ayaOog, Kat Travrag

avBpooTrovg

aw&^vat^ ^taafA-^y^et TroWaKig e| afxaprtav rovg
a-wfjiart'

evetki^fj.fi.evovg,

appwariav efi^aXwv rw

ovro}

ydp

irov

(pviat
** **

^ta

(pcovijg 'lepef/itov,

"

irovto

Kai (xda-Ttyt Trai^evB-^av] 'lepov- lo

(TaXvifJi..^^

E(f>vi

^e

vov Kat

6 Tlapotfxtaar-^g'
vir

"

y/e, /x^

oXtyapei

nat^eiag Kvptov,

fi.v}^e

eKkvov

avrov eXeyyofkevog' %v yap
irdvra
viov
ov

"

ayaira

Yjjptog^

irat^evei,

fi.aartyoH te

Trapa-

" "^eyerair

KaXag

ovv

dpa 'Kptarog

rvjv

rov voaeiv d^popfxi^v,
dfxaprtaVf Trpoarro- 15

KOA oiov rov irddoug r^v pi^av, Tovreari,
Keipetv

rv)v

eTrayyeXXerat.

E^atpe6etav]g

yap

ravTiqg, dt

^v Kai ro

TrdSogj e^et irdvrwg avrvjv avvavatpeOvjvai rvjv

voaoV
rvjv

fnev ovv

rav

oXwv ^wrvjp Kat Kvptog, QeoirpeTreardTvjv ep^wv

e^ovatav, rv[v

Twv

dfA.apTtcav d(f>eaiv

hrviyyeXXero.

Bopv^el ^e vrdXiv

Xoyog ro

tv^TiretBeg Koti

/SdaKavov rwv ^Paptaaicov epyaar-^ptov.
Qavfj.daat
eari

20

TiTOT TOT BosTPflN.
TrapdXvroVf Trwg
fjJri

rovg KOfJita-avrag rav
eia-eX6e7vf dveKOft.icrav

^vvvjQevreg ^ta

r^f Svpag

avrov

eiri

ro

oiofLa,

wg yap ^evw Kai Kaiv2
Kepafkov,

eTrf/etpvjaat 'Trpdyft.ari'
rv]v
d'7roKeift.evv]v

avaairaaavreg
vXv]v.
01

yap rov

fi.ereKtvv]a-av

Kat ofJMg rovrwv yevofJievav, Kai

^{vjaovg efJ.aKpoBvfj.eiy kou
i^eiv

25

irapovreg eatamwv, rvjv eK^aatv ^ovXofj.evot Oeccpi^aaty Kat

ri

XaXet

Kat

rt

TroteT.

Avaa^rofi.waavTeg roivvv

ro

Sa;/xaTiov,

yaXMCTi Tov Kpd^^arov, Ka) <pepovat fneaov rov irapaXeXvfj.evov.

U

Oe l\.vptog, <pv]atVf

towv ri]v Triartv ai/Toiv,
rv]v

ov rv]v Triartv rov
(ptXoTtfi.i^a-dvT(i>v,

TrapaXeXvfj.evov,
ojCTTe

aXXa

irtartv

rav KaXwg

30

aXXov

Qt

dXXoov iriartv Bepaireverat.

E/7roi

V

dv rtg inraitv]v

6pov eivai roirov, eig ov Ota riov KepdfJ.<ov

Kare^i^aaav

KXiwjv

rov irapaXvrov,

fj.v]^ev

iravreXwg ri^g areyi^g dvarpexpavreg.
ovTOf,"
(f>v]a-}v,

Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias. " T/f

"

og

XaXeT

5

46
**

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
aXX'
ovk

V. 27.
iiepi

^Xaa^fiYi^iav ;"
el Ta<;

av

e<prj^,

cD

^apiaale, tovti

avTOVf

Beiag (iriaTaao ypa(f)ag'

eha

Trpoff^rjTiKcov efxefxvvjcro

KoyaVf
piov.

el

to (leitTOV Kai
^e

^era

TVjg evavSpcoTr^^a^eag avvi^Kag (xvaTr}-

^Xa(T(l)y}fJiia$

eyKk-^fJiaTt

nepi^ixKXovai,

tvjv

ea-^^aTyjv

avTccv

Ka6opi^ovTeg

'^iktjv,

Kai

BavaTOv

KaTa\pYj(f)i^o[Jievoi.
vTrofJieveiv

Tov
Trpocc-

5

yap

etTTOVTa '^va<pi^[J.iav
vofj.og,

KaTa tov ©eoy, OavaTov

TaTTe

eneiV^ Ve tovto TeToXft.YjKaaif '^ia^eiKVvaiv evdvg oti
ov (f^opvjTwg '^vaae^ovvTag eXey^rj.
ev

Seog

eaTiv, 7va •naXtv
<l>yja}f

" Ti
ovkqvv
fx))

" yap"

" ^taXoyi^eade

Talg

Kap^iatg

vfxav ;"

OTav Xeyvjg,

w ^apiaaTe, "
epoi)

Ttg 'hvvaTat afj.apTiag a(f)tevat, ei

eig

10

"

©eog

;"

aoi KayiOf Tig ^vvaTai

Kap^tav ei^evatf Kat Tovg
f*,7}

ev Toj (3aBei TYjg ^iavoiag Xoyiafj.ovg Ka6opav, el

fj.ovog 6
eyci)

©eog

;

AiiTog yap itov
*' €T(x^(ov

(f^vjai

^ta

(f)0ov^g

'7rpo(f)VjTwv,

"

oti

Kvptog

Kaptiav Ka)

'hoKtfj.a^fov ve(f)povg'"

e<f)yi

^e ttov Kat Aa(3t^
1

irepi

T€ avTOV Kai yjfxm,
6

"

TtKaaag KaTa fxovag Tag Kap^iag
Kat
ve(f)povg
(og

" ayTwv" ovKovv
a(f)iyjat

ei^iog

Kap^^iav

©eog, ovTog

Kai afxapTtav ug ©eog.

KE*.

lA.

Ilept Tov Aevi.

27

Kai

fiera

ravra

e^rjXOe^ kcu eOedcraTO TeXcovrjv, 6v6- 20

jxaTL \evLv.

ToT

ATTOT.

TeAwvTjf ^v
eig

Aet;)^, avyjp aitXyiaTog

etg (f)t\o-

Keptiav, ayaktvog

irXeove^iav,

twv

ov^ev

TrpoayjKOVTCov

avTw
cg

a^iKog epaaTYjg' tovto yap To7g TeXwvatg to

eTrtTyjOevfi.a'

aXX

avTuv
"bo^ctig,

yjpTid^eTO

twv T^f d^tKiag epyaaTY/ptwv, Kat aeacoaTat itapa- 25
irdvTCtiv
Yjfj.(hv

KeKXvjKOTog avTOv tqv

^coT^pog yiptaTov'

e(py)

yap

aiiTW,
cog

" dKQXov6ei
dXYjQevei

ff.ot."^

6

^e irdvTa d(f)eig yjKoXovdvjaev avTW.

'Opdg

Xeycov

ao^coTaTog JJavXog, " oti ^ptaTog

"

YiXBev elg tov KoafLov, dff.apTCoXovg aaaati'^ opag cog aapKco6etg

fxovoyevYig tov

©eov Aoyog

to, aKevyj

tov hafSoXov fxeTeaTi^aev €ig 30

^

Xevia-ov

Cod.

5

V. 37.
kavTOV
;

AOTKAN ETArrEAlOT.
kou a-effuaTat [xh 6 Aevi
Tot?
*',

47

vj[Ji7v

le to Trpayfxa '^prja-Ta^

evoiifjae

(Xfrita^'

oti

yap

aoo^ei to fxcTavoe^v, e^
6

avTov tov
oeaiiofJie

yeyovoTog '^e^i^dyixeSa' inaTevaeTai ^e avTog

twv

okm

T^g Seog hia

(pwvyji Trpocpi^Tov Xeycov^,

"

e-^iaTpdcprjTe

Trpog

" Kai

aieB-fjaeaQe, oi

dit

eayjxTov tyj^ yYjs.

AAA. eiai Tive$

oi

5

T^f Belai yaXi^voTYjTOi eTiiyeipovvreg anoaTepeh Tovg Ta7g dfiapriaig
eveikv]ft.iJ.evovg'

ov

ydp iiapo^e^yovTai

fj.eTdvoiav,

aX\

olov

e-TnTifMoai rSi awi^ovrif ^tjtovvti

ra eavrov Kai vavTayoQev av\^cor-ijpogf

Xeyovri ro eaKopTTiafuevov, Kai ovk aKovovai Ae^y&VTOj' rov
**

ov yjieiav eyovaiv
oiiK rjXOov

oi

vyiaivovreg larpov,

aXX

oi

KaKag

e^/pvreg. lo

"

Kakeaai ^iKaiovg, d\\d du.apT(i)\ovg

eig f/.eTavoiav."

ToT

ATTOT.

'O ydp

rSiv

oXoov ScoT^p,
'^eoft.evxv

dre

^y]

larpog vndpyjnv
oog

TTvevfJidruv,

ovk dmtpotra

roov

avrov, Kdi

^taaft.r)l^ai
toio1

^vvdf/.evog To7g ovttw K€Ka6apfi.evotg oiKovou.tKxg avvvjvXt^ero'
fj.ev

Se,

w ^aptaaHe, rov aov

(ppovrjft.arog
vj

tijv

drpoTitav,

oirotaov

aot yeyovev atTtafi.dTcov irpo^evog

Kard rav

ev dfjLapriatg otppvg'
K(j)yj

avTOv
ovrct)'

Kd(3(6fJ.ev e^i^yi^rrjv,

rov itdvra eltora ^ptarov.

yap
eig

"

dvQpwTTOt

^vo

dvel3vjaav etg ro tepov Tipoaev^aaBai,

" ^apiaalog, Kat

eTepog reXoovYjg'

aXX'

6

fiev

^aptaahg arag
rd
e^^g.

" TtpoaYivyero keyxv, 'O Seog, evyapiaroo
Ylept Se rov
elireXv

aot," Kat

20

rov KvayyeXtarYiv ev aaj3pdr:a ^evrepoYli^XovatcorYjg ovroo

Trpwrw,

ayiog 'lai^^apog

keyet,

"

ort oev-

"
**

repdirpwrov

e'tpYjrat, eTrei'^^ '^evrepov fi.ev yjv

tov Yldaya, irpaTov
fi.Y}

^e Twv d^vf/.cov."

Kt

^e ad(3j3aTov etpYjrat,

Bavf^daYjg,

ad^-

fiarovydp itdaav eopryjv KaXovai, Kat ^ta rovro eipyfrai ad(3l3aTa^S
aa^^drcov.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaekanapeias. Tavra
ye ro
to5 vo/aco toKovv,

Tteitpaycog

Aa^i'^ itapd

rov itavrog itap

vfxh d^tovrat Bavf^arog,

opBwg Kat
oiiKovv
**

^tKatcoi'

Kat

ydp

^v

d\y]Bcog

ayiog

Kat

itpoipYjTiqg'
**

rov

tta

y[covaeag

vofj.ov

(pdaKovrog

evapycog,
ev

KpifiMS'^
itag

^tKatov

Kptvere^^

KOi

'*

ov

k-^xpYj
;

itpoacoTiov

Kptaet,

rovg

efJ.ovg

KaraKptvere

f/.aBi^rdg

Kat

eig

hevpo

Bavfj.d1^ovreg

c Xewo-aj

Cod.

^ eXeyev Cocl.

48

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
[xaitdpiov

VI.
Tr]v

9.

wf ayiov Kai w^o0o^t>jv tov
evroXvjv ov TeTyjpi^KaTe.

Aavih' Kairoi

M.avaew$

TiTOT EnisKonoT BosTPCN.

Qv^eii KaXeTrai vloi
KaXeH'
^i

dvSpoiTToVf

d\X

Irjaovg

fAOvov

eavTOv ovtoo
vio$

enei^v}

Tio^

m

Qeovy
5

napa^o^coi

KaTtfj^iaaev

dvBp'jynov

dvQpairovg

KkrjQvjvai'
Troiyjrvjv

eavTOv ovv Kai Kvpiov tov aa/^^aTOVf wf ^i^fxtovpyov Kai
Kat vofxoOeTrjv tov aa/S/SaTou eKaXeaev.

KE4>. lE.
Tlepi

Tov ^Tjpav exovTos t^v X"P°'

9

^KTTepcoTT^aco vfids tl e^eaTi tols crd^^axTLv,
TTOLTJcraL

dyaOo-

lo

^ KaKOTTOLrjaaL

;

TiTOT EnisKonoT BosTPON.
TTOvaa TaHi eKetvm d^eXTfiptatg
dyaOoTtotelv
ev
v)

YiOcfxaTaTq ktav

vj

iievais, Ttpe-

TTpoTaaii'
kccXvov

el

fxev

yap e^eartv
iiapa

aa^^aTdi Kat to
iravaai

ov^ev
Tocf

ekeetaOai

%eov

Tovg

KdfUovTai,

avKXeym

Kara

'KpiaTOv \S

avKocpavTiaSf Taf

d(f>opfi.as,

Kat

t^ aavTov Ke^aXyj KaTa^^m
^li/jaovv'

t\v

^tKVjv,

^v hrYipTyjaev
irepi

FlaT^p To7g dTtfud^ovat tov
avTov
'^ta

rjKOvaag

XeyovTog

(pm^g Toy Aa^t'^,

" Kat

"

avyKQxpci}

Tovg e^xPpovg avrov ano Ttpoaitniov avTOv,

Kai Tovg
ev iroteiv 20

"
ev

fj.taovvTag

avTOv

T^OTrctJco/xev.'*
vof/iog

E/ ^e ovk
aa^eaGat
evToXyjv,
oii'^

'e^eariv

aaPfSdTO),

KeKcoXvKev

il^v^^v*
€(f>
y}

yeyove tov
Kai

vofxoBeTov
ff.aaTat
vj

KaT-^yopog,

dtaPe^XvjKev

TeOav-

^ta M-coiJaeag ^taKovia. dXX^ tov
eirt

eavTco, (pvjatv,
vjfniv

rm
Tovg 25
ovv

oXm Qeog
To7g

tw

aajS/SdTa) reBetKe

vofLoV

^e fLaXXov

VTreyovatv

avToi

tov

avyeva'
voff.ov

KaXwg

ecp^^g

eiratvm
Ttcog

Xoyovg'

ovkovv avdyKVjg Kat

to Oehv eXevOepov

atTta Kat ev aa(3(3dTW ^piarov eXee7v eOeXovra Kat evepyerovvTa
i^yj^o^v
;

OTav Se Kat tov

eTti

tco

aa(3j3dTCi) reQetKe

vofioVf ttoXvdicopiaff.evov

Ttpayft.oveh fi.eXXofi.ev, eXevjf(.oavv)^g eveKa itapa
evpvjacofi.€v.

Qeov

'EKeXevae yap dpyeXv

ev

a-ayS/JaTCU,

Kai

fi.v]^€vog
of/.ov

3^

To

avfJiTtav

avtreaBat itovov, dvteaQat te f/.aXXov Kat avTo^tg

VI. 20.

AOYKAN EYArrEATOY.
Ecftv}

49

Tor? aXoyotg tZv ^cowv.

yap,
(tov

" iva

avoTravtryjTat o italg cov

Kat

yj

irat^^iaKf}

aov, 6

^ovi

Kai to imo^vytov <rou Kat vav
/fT»jvc5i

KT^voi a-ov**

6 §€ /Souv

fXeSv, Kat toc €T€pa twv

KE^.
Hepi
Tjjs T©i>

ir. 5

'ATTooToXajv tKkoyrjs.

12

E<7rwv

Eua-yyeXtaT*;?
I^o-ov?

"

ot/ eyeveTO ev TotJV yjfJ^po-i? TavTai^, etg

"

f^^XOev

•Trpoa-ev^aaBat
6

to opog^^

Kat

to.

e^^f.

E^e/^e S/a tovtov^ KaSai

aytoq KvpiXXof

(pyjatVf

OTt

izaana
etg

vpos

oiKo^ofjJi]v

^fjL€TepaVf
o

Kat

eU

ovi^atv

twv TTtaTevovTm

avTOv €ipya^€TO
Ttva TO Ka^

Xp/crro?,

Kat

Trveu/xaT/AciJ?
vjfleAev

TroXtTeiag Tpoirovio

eavTOv avaQei?^ aXvjQivvjV

aTto^aivetv vpoaKeKpv[Jifi.evat;,

KvvriTtKYiVy Kat OTt

Ta?

Trpog

Seov iK€Teiag kaSpa Kat
iroteTv.

Kat ov^evog opavTog irpoarjKet

Tovto yap

^viXoi

to etg opoi
rjfjJav

Koxa

fjiovai

Kai

ag

ev

crj^oX'^

irpoaevyeaQat
e;7rcDV,
'

tov

K.vpiov

yyiaow, KaBwg Kai ed/da^ev ^jtxa^,

av

de, otov Trpoaevyr],

\

^

"

eiaeXBe etg to Tafj.teHov aov^^ Kat

Ta

e^^f.

Ka< yap

acpiXo-

ho^cci Kat oaiovg eiraipovTag ye^ipag irpoaevyeaSat ^ei, (aaitep eig

to

T^f BevoTtag

v\\>og

omoTryi^SovTog tov

vov,

Kai airocpoiTZvTog (xev
Koafj.iiaig.

Qopv^ov TtavTog, aTtoTpeyovTog te Ka)

fji.epifj.vyig

Se? Sc
eirrO'
t>jv

toSto ^^av, ovK a^tKOpag Kai o^pavyj eyovTag oXtyo4>vyiav,
vcof Sc

20

fnaXXov koi ev airov^^, Kat ovk aBavfLaaTOV eyovrag
Kai ev
^evTepo)

vTrofMinjv,
'

Tag

ev

yepatv epyaatag
6

TtB€ft.evovg,

AKy]KoafJi.€V

yap, OTt ov yaXeitoig yivyeTO

\ptaTog, aXk

ori

^tevvKTcpeve tovto ^pav.
Ttepi TcSv

Uept

TVjg

tZv AitoaToXm eKXoyyjg, Kat

fJMKaptafj.m 7tpoeypa(f>y] eig to

Kara MaTSalbv.

25

KE4>. IZ.
Ilepi tS>v ixaKapi(TfiS)P.

20

Ylpoaitocfyfivag
fj.€vy}v,

itavTog

aya6ov t^v ^ta ©eoD 7rTcw^e<av ytvoTO^ig

Ka) TO Tteiv^v Kat KXatetv ovk a[J.ta6ov eaeaBai
eirt

aytoig
<f>yjai

einwv, fxeQiaTyjat tov Xoyov

Ta

evavTtoog eypvTa Tovrotg,

30

H

60

EPMHNEIA TOY KATA

VI. 20.

yap, " ovai vfuv to/V TrXovaioi^, ort «irej^eTe

ttjv TrapaKXvjcriv v/awv,
vfji.iv

" "
01

ovou

01 €fJt.'7r€7rXv}(rfx.€V0t

ort Tt€tvac€T€. ovai

01

"yeAwvTef vuv,
€i7rcoat

OTt it€vQyi<T€T€ Kot

KXava€T€' ovai OTav KaXcog vfxa^

7ravT€$

av9/?w7roi*" ^€iKvvai ^e TavTa KoXaa-ecc^; ovTa Kai

Iik-:^s ^fXTroiyj-

TtKcCf Iva

Tw

<f)ol3a

T^f

€7rYipTi^fX€VVjs

KoXaa-€wg (p^vycoat fX€V toS

irXovTcTv, Kou to ev Tpv(f)a7g €lvat Kai -yeAwT/, TouTecTT/v, ev T€p\p€cri
KOCTfJLtKaTg,

t^

^e twv (TT€<pava3V €7riQvfx.ia,

cov

KXyjpovofxoi y€vrj<70VTai

ot fji.aKapt<jB€VT€g, (jayYiV€vovTat irpog Tovg irovovg, Kai t>;v 'hia

0eov

aip€7a6at

7rTCiy)(€iav (xirovhaa-coat.

Ka/ yap Tovg
(f)y}<7i'

fit.€v

KXi^povofxovg

eacaBai T^f t«v ovpavcav ^aatX^tag
•7r€T€7a6at
*'

Tovg Se eorj^aTa/f Trcpt- 10
(f>ij<7i,

avfji.(l>opa7g'

" oenl-^^Te yap,

"

t>jv TrapaKXvjatv.

vfJicov."

Acyet ^e Ka)

tvjv ofxolav Tifx,<opiav virofJ.^^vai

Kai Tovg viro

vavTuv

avBpcoTroov €7ratv€ia6at

6€XovTag.

ToT

ArioT KTpiAAor 'Aaesanapeias.
fJi.€Ta

Wig KaivoTvjTa
Tovg

^coi^g

ivayycXtKyjg,

tvjv

y€tpoToviav
(f^vjat'
jm,6V

KaTapvBfjn^cov

eavTOvJS

fJiadvjTag 6 ^ccTvjp,

TavTa

Tr^pi ttohov ^e

apa

TrTCoyjcv Tairra

X€y€i avayKctiov

/&erv.

Ev

y\p

to5

KaTa MaT^arov

ff.aKapiovg

€a€a6at

(ffvjat

Tovg irTCoyovg
tva

tc3

Trv€vfj.aTt,

Kai avTwv €ivat t»/v
tco
iiv€Vfj.aTi,

l3aatX€iav twv ovpavcov,
fj.€TptO(f>pova

vow^ev '^TCoyovg

tov

Kou avv€aTaXfX€vov caair^p ^yovra vovv' (x^to^^^XcoTOg 20 Ka) yovv e^iy
vj

^e

to^oDtos" Kat ©eco yvQ}pifj.og'

^t

cvog tcSv aytcov

vpofpvjTcov,

" Kat

€7rt

Ttva

l3X€\pco, <xXX

hirt

TaTretvov Kat

vjav-

" "
'

5^/ov KOti Tp€fj.ovTa fJLOv

Tovg Xoyovg ;"
avvT€Tpift.fj.€vv}v

E(f)vi ^e Kat

7rpo(f>-^Tvig

Aal3i^,

"

OTt

Kap^^iav

Kat

T6Ta7re;vco^ev>jv

060$- ovK e^ov^evcocre/." Kat fxcv avTOg 6 ^coTvjp,
e/xov,
(f>v]atv,

"

fj.a6€T€ air
ev
fie

25

"

ot; Trpavg

€tfj.i

Kat Tavriivog

tv}

Kapbta

To^f 7rpoK€tfj.€votg

vjfxtv

avayvcaafj.aat fJ.aKaptovg ka^aBat (pvjat Tovg

TiTCoyovg, ov 7rpoaK€ifJ.€vovg
[X€VOt,

tw

irv€vfj.aTt,

ovk aXXvjXotg havTtov-

aXXa

fX€pt^ofX€VOi

iroXXaKtg

Ta

^tvjy^fxuTa, Kat TOTe fX€V

^ta Twv avTav l3a^i^ovat K€(f>aXatcov, TroTe ^e

tw

kvi 7rapaX€i(f>6€V,

S^

€T€pog Taig t^taig €VTi6viat avyypa(f>a7g, iva
€ig ov^atv Xa6€iv ^vvv]6^

fxvj^ev tcov

avayKaicov
¥ioiK€

Tovg TrtarevovTag €ig JiptaTQv,
ev

Toivvv

irTCoyovg

ovofxat,€tv

TOVTOtg

Tovg

a(f>tXo7TXovTOvg

Ka\
kou

<ptXoK€p^iag KpetTTOvag Kat tov Tpovov eypvTag a(f>tXapyvpov'

VI. 27"yc

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOY.
Tlavkoi apKrrcov
^fxTv fJiaQ^iJ.dTVV

51
€i<T-r]yrpr7}<;

ouv 6 ao(f>WTaTOi

av€^€iKVVTO XiyaVf
**
**

"

d(pi?Jipyvpos o Tpoiro^f dpKovfxcvoi toT$ irap§e

oucr/."

Trpo<T€Ti6ei

TovToii,

oti

*'

fj^ovTCf

liaTpo<f>ai

xat

aK€Ttd(TfxaTa^

TOVTOig

dpK€a6v]ao[Ji.€6a/^

K^ei

yap^

€^€i

to

craTYjpiov

Kai evayyeXiKOv jaeAAovra? avTOvg ^iayyeWeiv KrjpvyfJM^
eucj^oXov

Tots ditavTayo<J€., dcpikoTrXovTov €y(€tv to (ppovrjfxaf Kai

eai Toc Kp€iTTQ} Tr]v €7ri6v[xiav.

Ov

TrdvTwv ^e twv ev evTropia

ovTwv
tov

koyog Ka6dnT€T0iif {xovav ^e
K€KTr][X€va}v.

€K€tv<ov Ttcv irepi to.
;

j^^juaTa
t^s tov
1

•Troflov

Tiv€g Se €iaiv ovTot

oi

fxev

Kvpiov

(pavrjs

dKovovT€i X€yov<Ti,

"

fvi^

6v]aavpi^€T€ vfuv 6i^aavd(f>avi^€i,

o

"
'*

povs €Wt Trji yyjif ovov <r^s Kai ^pwats
KX€7rrat ^iopvaaov<Ti Kai KkeirTOvai'

Kat

oirov

6rjaavpi^€T€ Se vfxTv fxa\o

"
"

Aov 6yjaavpovs ev ovpavw.
€K€i eaTat Kai
i]

Ottov yap €aTiv

6r]aavpos

<7ov,

Kapoia aov.
e^rjp-^^ero,

"Otl 8vpafxi9 irap avTOv
^eTO T^v irap erepov A.piaTOSy

kou laro TravTa^.
\ayyv e^aveiei

15

ToT Anor Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias. Ov yap
aAA avTOs
Kdfxvovaiv
cov

<pva€i tJeof,

Kai
laTO

y€yov€
irdvTas.

aap^,

t^v

€7r;

Torj-

eKTrlfXTrav

^vvafxiv

€(os

A/ ^i^aaKaXiai ai €(/>€|^f eypd(f)OVTo €is to KaTa ^aT^aTov, 20 " Kai cylveTo to prjyfxa tvjs oiKias €K€ivy]g fxeya' ofxoKog Kai
Tov €KaTOVTdpyov
7rpo€ypd(f)r].
epfxi^vevccv

irept

Aeyet ^e

"KpvaoaTOfxos eis to KaTa MaT^arov,

Ta

irep) Tov eKaTovTdp^xov, tov avTOv etvat tov etg tov AovKav, tov ^c

eii Tov

loidvvTjv €T€pov.

25

ToT
atpeaiv'
6vfxos

APioT TiTOT BosTPON.
fivj

OTav aKow^s tZv KvaryyeXtwv

XeyovTCov,

^apYjO^g

t>;v

^tdvotav,
Trpog to,

dXXa

irpo^vfxy^^iqTi

tv^v

irpo-

ov

yap aTovos, ov^e

evKoXa cvTovof*

Oc irpo-

Kou irpQs

Ta

^^va^/epv]

^vvaTog,

"

Aa/SeTC,"

(f^f^ai,

"

tov

" ^vyov
yap

fxov, Kai /'^eTC oti eXa^ppov eaTt to (popTiov fxov" cav3o

oXcag avTOv l3aaTd^yjs, to
tvjv ireTpav.

^okovv etvat

aot

^apv, €vptaK€Tai

Kov(pOTaTov irpos

37

Ktpiaaot 'Aaesanapeias.
Xos, OTi
€V avToo

^AXri^evet Xeycav

fxaKdpios Ylav-

"

€? Tts ev "KptaTco

Kaiw] KTiats'^^ irdvTa yap yeyovev

T€ Ka) h^ avTov Katvd' Kai ^ia6^Ki^ Kai vofxos Kai 7roA<-3S

H

2

5

figl

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
"AOpei Se

VI. 31.
ixvaTa-

rei^.

oWf

TrpeTrwSeo-TaTi} Xiav ecrri Tpr? dyiQis

y^iqatg ^ Toid^e TroKneia Kai ^a^.
y^g TO
OVK
(T(aTyjpiov

efxeXkov to7s ditavTayo^je

e^ayyeXXeiv

K-^pvy[x(x,

Kai

vjv

evTevSev Trpoa^oK^v,

evaptOfji.-^TOvs e^recrQai tov$ ^iooKovTai

avTovg, Kat TcoXvrpoTioog
d^^^QecrOyi-

tmjSovXevovTaf.

dX\

el (xvve^fj

rcuq ToiavTatg XvTtatg

vat Tovg fuSYiTag,

eha

OeXetv dfxvveadat Tovg XeXvn7jK0Ta$, e(xi-

y-^aav dv, Kat 7rape^pa[xov avTOvg, ovKeTt to 6e7ov avTo7g irapaTiSevTeg Krjpvyixa, ov KaXovvTeg eig eTriyvcoatv dXyjQeiag.
e^ei toivvv

Toig ovTQ} ae^TTTaig ave^iKaKiaig tov tSov

dytm

[xvaTay(6yov ava-

yatTtaai^
vjSpi^diat

vovv, tva TrdvTa yevvaiatg

(f>ep(i)at

Ta aufx^aivovTa, Kav 10
IleTrpaj^e

Tiveg,

Kav dvoaia>g

eirtjSovXevcoat.

^e tovto

Kat irpo ye tcov dXXcev avTog eig vTroTVTrojatv r^ixeTepav. eTt yap
dirvjpTtafxevog tov tijxiov

aTavpov, KatTot

Tvjg

lov^aioiv

TrXyjOvog

€TrtyeXaav]g avTfi
hrote^TO Aeywv,
ju,»/v

Tag

irpog

©eov Kat Ylarepa XtTag
OTt ovk oi^^aai t/

virep

avTwv

*'

«^ef avTO<V,

Tiotovat"

Na^ 15
6etg
tv]V

Ka\

fxaKdptog "^Tecf^avog Kat TOt
Trpoavjv^aTO Xeyiov,

l3aXXo[xevog XtQoig,
{xy)

Ta yovaTa

" Kvpte,
fxaKdpiog

aT^arjg avTo7g

"
*'

dfxapTiav TavT>?v/'

Ka;

he

UavXog, " evXoyovovkovv avayyjp^ff^^

[xevot evXoyovfxeVf 'tva^[xov[xevot 7rapaKaXov[xev.

Koia

[xev

73

Totd^e irapaiveatg

To7g
etg

dyioig

AiroaToXotg,

c/jw.WTaT^
Kcti

^e

Kat

ri[x7v

ai)To7g

Te to y^y\vat ^tovv op6ag
Trdayig <f)tXoao(f)iag.

TeGav[xaa[xev(Oi' [xeaTyj
^e awoTeAoycr^v

ydp eart

^vaKaTrpoXyj-

TopQoiTov
ipetg

avT^v Ta^f ^[xeTepatg tiavotatg
yj

ovK dya6at, Kai

tcov ev yi[x7v ovtcov ira^av

^vaKaTay(ovtaTog

Tvpavvtg.

25
iroLcocnv vfuv, oi avOpcoTroi, kcu

31

Kat KaOods OeXere tva
VfJL€LS 7rOL€lT€

aVTOLS

OfXOLCOS.
€tKog Tovg dyiovg
etpy}[xeva'

ToT
Tdyjx
el^(bgj

ATTOT.

AXX
ev

7JV

AiroaToXovg
toivvv
'^ey^eTat

oiyi6yivat

irov

^vaKaTopScoTa eivou Ta
Tyjg

Ta TravTa
jSpajSevTyjv,

Tov

^fx7v
irep

(ptXavTtag
CTepov

vo[xov

30

wv

dv ^ovXotTO Ttg
etg
fxev

Tuj^erv.
irep

rcvoy yap TotovTog,

(f)y]a)v,

CTepovg

avTog,

oirotovg

dv

BeXrfg

elvat

Trept

ae'

ei

aKXyjpovg

Kat
"

davfX7ra6e7g,
av«;{€T/(Ta*.

6paae7g

Kai

opytXovg,

Cod.

VI. 41U.V^CriKM(OVi
voarrlov,

AOYKAN ETArrEAIOY.
KOl
TtOVtipOVif
i<TQ

53
^l
0€

KOU MITOi TOlOVTOi'
fx)]

TOVroi-

5^>j(TT0Vf

Kcu

afMn^a-iKaKovi,

oupoprjTov

rjyov

ovTOV eivai ce*
voiAOSs

Kat Tay^a iiov ^6?? ovto) haKetfJieyoii TiepiTTOg o
vjfjucv

eyypoi(f>ovTos Qeov Ta7^ Kap^taii

tyjv

tov i^iov SeX"^
(pri^Jt,

fAaTos yvaaiV
*'

" 'Ev yap Ta7g
fj.ov

vjfxepats

eKetvaig"
^tdvoiav

"

\eyei 5
eitt

Kvpios,

^iSov? vofkovg

elg

t»?v

aiiTav,

Kat

" T^v

KapYtav avTwv eTriypdxpa) avTovg^

ToT

ATTOT.

ApttJTOV Kai TOVTO XP^f^°''

'^^'

^^?

6vft.ape<7TaT0Vf

Kou oaiais xpv^^aTs tovto fxdXtcxTa TrpeitoV
yeipt \y]xp0f/.e6a tvjv avTeKTiatv •napa tov

OTt

^e TrXovatccTepa
vefJ.ov-

ndvTa Tikova ta>g
irewXi^po(f)opy)KeVj

lo

TOf Qeov
*'

ToiV

dyanw<7tv

avrov,

avTog

etTruv,

OTi

fueTpov KoXov TremeafxevoVf vTiepeKyyvofi.evov ^wacoatv
^jU-alv."

etg

"
41

Tov Kokttov

Tt

5e /SAeTretS" to Kap(f)09 to iv
;

r^

6(f)da\fiS tov
15

d8€X(j)ov (Tov

ToT
^tavotav,

ATTOT.

riav

yaXeTTOV

airoKetpet

vd9og

tZv

y]fx.eTep<av

VTiepoiptag

apy^vjv

Kai yeveatv.

Kat Tot yap ^eov Ttvai tovto fuev
idcoat

eavTovg KaraaKeTTTeaQai Kat KaTa Seov TroXtTeveaQat'
ov ^paat, nokvTrpayfxovovai

Se to. erepooVf Kav daQevovvrai

Ttva$, ccaTtep et$ Xi^drjv epyofxevot toSv t^^tm app<i}aTVjfi.dTiov, (f)t\o- 20
xpoytag vitoQeatv itotovvTat
KaTarpv](f)t^ovTat

to

yj)-fjfj.a,

Kat KaTaXaKiag
OTt

a(f)opfJi.v]V'

yap

avTcov,

ovk

ei^OTes

Ta taa voaovvTes
ovtco

To7i

TTap
6

avTcav

^taf^ejSkvjf/ievotg

eavTOvg KaraKptvovaiv'
ev

vov Kat

aw(f>a}TaTo$ ypd(pet

Uavkos' "

« yap

Kptvetg tov
Kpivcov.'

"

erepov, eavTov

KaTaKptveig'
eyjpvp

t» yap avTa irpdTTetg
ekeeh ag
ralg

25

KatTot

fJMkkov

aaBevovvrag

rm

TraBwv

€<f)0^otg vTrearpwfi.evovg,
eveihfifjLfji.evovg,

Kat To7g Tvjg dfxapriag jSpoyotg d(f)VKTWs

Kat vTrepevyeaSat tmv TotovTcov, Kat
eig

irapaKaXeiv
Torg"

avTovg

Kai ^teyetpetv

v^tv, kou iretpdaBai

ff.v]

taotg

ireptveaeTv
6

aiTtdfiMatV "
fJi.a6v]TV]g,

yap

Kpivcov tov

a^eA^ov," KaSd (f>v]atv^o
Kat Kptvet
^ei
fJkVf

Tov HptaTOv
eartv

" KaTaXaXei

vofuov

vofji.ovJ'^

etg

voft.oQeriffg

kou Kptr^g, avca yap

T^f dfxapTaTotovrog
oov,

vovavjg (pvaecog eivat tov Tavrvjg KptTVfv'

av ^e
KptTvj

ri
^e

Kpiveig Tov TrXvjatov

;

d-noXoyvfaeTat

t^

dfxaprdvcav.

ei

54

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
[x.y]

VI. 41.
e^ovaiav, KaTa-

ToKfJLai KaraKpivuv, Kai toi tovtov
KpiQrjCfi fjt.aXkov

ey^jav tv}v
vo[ji.QV

avTog, ag ovk ecSvTOf tov

to Kptveiv eTcpovg.
Xoyia^fJLiav

Tor
cyeaQai

ATTOT.
jOtev

'E^ avayKaiav ^[xas

avaTreiOei

aiio-

tov Pov\ea6ai Kpiveiv eTepovg' t^v eavTwv te [xaXkov

Kap^iav 7repiepyd^ea6ai, Kai twv evovTav avTa^ig iraSav aTraXXaT-S

TeaSai

^vjTeTv,

alpovvTag tovto itapa %eov,

AvTog ydp ecTtv
xpv^^^tKcov

iw[j.evog Toi/g
vo(Jifi[xdT(tiv

avvTeTpi[j.[j.evovg

Tri
et

Kap^ia, Kai
voaS>v

•^[nag
[t,et^(0

eXevOepwv.

T/ ya^,

avTog Ta cti

Kai "/aXeitfaTepa t£v ovtwv cv eTepotg dcpetg Ta
eKeivoig eittTt^xag',

KaTa aeavTOV,

ovkovv aitaai
evToX>;,
et

jotev

Tolg eOeXovatv evaejSag dvay- 10

Kaia

eig ovyjatv

vj

[xdktaTa te Tolg to ^i^^daKetv eTepovg

eyKeyeipta[ii.evotg'

p,ev

yap

eiev

ayaQoi Kat

vi^<j)d\tot,

KaQ(xnep
toc

etKOg,

^ctii^g

evayovg Ta Kad eavTOvg avaaTTjaovTeg To7g
[/.yj

[jlvj

taa

tpav

eXo[j.evotg, evTrpoawirctig e'7rtTi[i.'^a(tiatv, OTt

Tovg TYjg evovarjg

avToig eTTtetKeiag dve[i.d^avTo TpoTtovg.

E< ^e

pdBv[j.ot Ttveg eiev 'S
to. 'iaa

Kai Ta7g etg to (pavAov vj^ovaig evdX(tiTOt, Trag av eTepotg
voaovatv
eTrtTt[J.Yjaeiav
;

OpirENOTS.
Trov/ipov

Aev^pov dya6ov to TIvev[i.a to 'Aytov,
01

^ev^^pov

^id(3oXog Kat

tovtov vnYipeTat.
eii^eiKVVTatf

ey((tiv

to Ylvev[j.a to

Ay tov^
Ta
irdSYi

Tovg

tovtov

Kapirovg
6 ^e

ovg

d'7rapt6[t.e7Tat

020

dnoaToXog TlavXog.

^vva[i.tv dvTtKet^nevvjv

ej^ctjv,

T^g

dTt[/.iag

aKav6ag Kat Tpt{3oXovg dvaTeXXeTat.
Aia(f>vy(ti[i.ev tyjv <f)6opav
iJ/acSv,
**

TiTOT BosTPON.
OTav XeyYj
*'

t^^ d[xapTtag, Kat

6 Sct)T>?p

Kat Kvpiog
[kyj

ovk eaTi Mv^pov dyaSov
eavT(a TYjg pa6v- 25

'TTOtovv

Kapirov aairpov^^
[i.ev

Xd^Y^g

avyyv(ti[j.Yiv

[niag'
TeiiYi'

TO

yap Mv^pov
[).v]

(f)vaet KtveiTai,
(f>epov

av

^e irpoatpeaet TroXt-

Kat Trdv 'bev^pov

Kapirov, etg

dXXyjv

'^(jpetav

KaTe-

aKevda6Y], av ^e etg epyaatav dpeT^g dve^^eiyPYjg.

Miy Ttg Totvvv
TavTa.
tt^^daKYj

aipeTtKYjv

dKOYjv

irapeta^epctiv

KaKag
;

voetTO)

Kt yap
;

(f)vaet

KaKog Tvy^^dvetg, t/

[J.av6dvetg
ei

elg
yj

T/30

TO yap

(f>vaet ov d[xeTdl3Xi^Tov irpdy^j.a'

^e

[xeTa-

(3oXy] '^t^^daKet

Kat

Xoyog

evTpeTret
tyjv

Ka)

yj

irapaiveatg [xeTarroteT,
yj

Kai

Yj

^i^aaKaXia [xeTa^dXXet

^tdvotav,

[j.ev

VTroy\>ta

TYjg

avdyKY\g CK^dXXeTat, to ^e ^oy^xa TYjg irpoatpeaecog o[J.oXoye7Tai.

Ata TOVTO

Kat

KXYjatg,

'^ta

tovto

Ka\

tt^^aaKaXia,

^<a

toutoSS

VII.

2.

AOYKAN ETArrEAIOY.
E/ yap ^v afxeTaPXvjTa
vvv §e opa [xoi
<f>va€i

55
tu

Kal "KptaTOS Trapeyevero.

irpayfJiaTa, /aar^v TavTa eyiv€TO'

t>jv |U,eTajSoA>;v,

Kai voet [Mt
Ktvovfxeva,

TV}v TrpoaipecrtV

ov^eig aiTtaTai

Ta aXoya ^aa
tc5v

<f)vaet

aXKa

tov<; Ttpo^

t^v OfxoiOTpoTrtav

aXoym

avT e^ov5

ctag eKKXivovTag avQpanovg.

'Eh ANEnirPA*oT.
Xovg

IloAAa Ta

TrpoTtoXeiLovvTa, Kai Trpog iroK-

aywv avQpairotg

^aiiMovai, TraSy]
ei

^vx^^i
e-jreXSvj,

oSi/va?

awfxaTav

Kai 6Xi\p€t$ "TrpayfxaTiov. ttA^v
To7s

TavTa
'hta

(Se^atovat tov ev
€Ka(XTV]v
vjfxepav

Tov Kvpiov
fxvj

TrapayyeXfkaat

T^f

Ka^

aaK^aewiy tva

KaOdvep

/Staicov

v^aTav efi^oXy) irpoeXSovaa, \ o

caBpa

To. ev vjfMV

^oyfiaTa '^taaKe^daei,

dXX
vj

ev ev^oKif/.-^aet ToTi

evavTtovfA.evotg irpdyfxactv
TrToofxaTt
Treptcf^aveig

aKaTdXvTos ovaa

apeTvj, Kai

fxv}

dXXa

Tvj vikvj yevccfxeSa'

TrepKpaves yap Kat

To irrwfxa twv fxeydXa 'te^ttayfxevav, OTav fxeydXm airoirtTrTaat.
Yieptcftavvig ^e

Ka)

vj

to^a Tav ev "aiaTet ^e^atuv, OTt

eirt

fxeyd- 15

Ae/f aT^pi^ovTai.

KE^.

IH.

Uepi Tov 'EKaTOvrdpxov.
I

'ETTCt de hrXrjpuHTe iravTa tcl prjfiara

avrov

els

ra?

iaKoa? Tov Xaov, elarjXOev

ely KaTrepvaovfJL.

'E/caroi/-

rdp^ov de tlvos hovXos KaKws e^cov efieXXe TeXevrdu.
Av-^p
Ttg
e^TreiKVjg

20

Kat Ty twv vjQm ypvjaTOTi^Tt '^taTrpeTrm, Kai
tvjv

aTpaTtcoTwv vjyovfxevog ToTg oiKovat

J^airapvaovfx, avveaTiog
ireptTreaeTv^
<f>vjaiy

^V TovTov
Kat
cag ev

avve/Si^ Ttva

twv ywjatcov otKerwv dppccaTia
Xotirov eKirvoaTg.
irefxiret

eayaTatg opaaQai
tov
l-^aov'

Kai

vjKovae,

Ta

irept

eha

irpog

avTOv,
"^vvafxtv

ccg

irapa Qeov 25
vj^tov

'^viXovort

Ta

virep

dvSpamov <pvatv tc Kat

e^atTm'

yap Twv T6U OavdTOv ^eafxwv aTraXXdTTeaQat
KaTeiXvjfXfxemv.

tov eayaTV] voaa>

AvjXciiaavTog ^e tov

KvayyeXiaTov

irept

twv direaTaXfxevccv
ccg

irpog

TOV Kvp/ov v3ro Tou eKOTOVTdpyov, ovk apyag Kat

CTi^e X/"?3o

aKOTreTv vjfxag Kat ev TovTca tv]v tov K.vpiov SavfxaTOvpyiav, eXey-

5^ovTOf

T^

T»v

lov^atcav

dyvcofxoavwjv, ^ta t«v 'Iov§a/a>v auTwv

56

EPMHNETA TOT KATA
Iiyo-ovv,

VII.

2.

Xiym " TrapayevOjU-evo/" ya.p, 4*^<ti, " Trpo^ tov " Xovv avTOV (TTrQv^^amg Xeyovre^, ori a^iog
"
TovTco.
'

iiapfKaTrapc^ei

e(7Tiv,

w

o/

yap t^v

€/V

afTOV

TricrTiv "Trapairovfi.evoi

irapeKaXow

avrov ev^^eiKVvaSai Tolq maT€vov<Tiv eQviKo7;, oti Qeo^ eaTiv a\rj~
Oa^.

Ttvog yap eaTtv aXkov to pveaOat Ik BavaTov
joiev

;

oQev eiKOTwg 5

e^dxyd^aav

ovtoi ot ayvifxoveg'

ei

eKX-^Qvj

^e Kat

TtpoaeteyPri
eirt

Ta

e6vv),

eTOtfXOTepav eayriKOTa t^v Kaptiav elg to 7rta-T€vetv

Tov KvptoV Kav To, [xaXtaTa TtpoTepov yjaav ev dixapTtati iroXXaTg,

^ia

Tvjv

Tov Seov dyvcoaiav, KaTa ro
Ka)
To,

*'

eirXvjSvvBvjaav at aaSevetai

"

avT(5v,"

e^^f.

UdXtv

tt/v

eTOtfmatav t^s Kap%tagio

avTwv irpoaeaye to ovaaov^.

KE*.

10.

Jlepi Tov viov t^s Xrjpas.

Tivog eveKev
fxv]

[x.eTa

to IdaaaBai tov '^ovXov tov eKarovTdpyov,
veKpov dvdaraatv iropeveTat
o

KaXovfxevog viro
^coT^i

tivo^; eirt

irdvTaiS

f/Swf, Kat

Kat Bavdrov t^v e^ovo-iav

dveywv, "
Na)v," koi

Kai*^
to,

ydp
e|^?*

^atv, "
evy

eiropeveTo

eU

TroXtv KaXovfxevrjv

txTrXois

dXX

olKovofxiKWTaTa tpav, tva fM] Xeyaai rtveg oti
o

ov 'TravTeXug efueXXe TeXevTav

tov eKaTOVTdpyov

iraHg'

Kav
fi

ei

TovTO yeypa(p€v
irpog

o

FivayyeXiaTvjg, to, Trpog ydptv fKoXXov ^ovXofxevog
Tvpt

to.

20

dXviOetav

a(f)Vjyovfi.€Vog,

aKoXaaTOV

rZv
6

Toiovrav diro(ppdJ^at yXarrav.

Ata

rovro

vir-^vrviae

\ptaTOg
7ji|/aT0

©eof

vjftMV

Tw

eKKCf/.i^of/i.evu)

reQvecort, Kai
6

TrpoaeXGm

r^g

<7opov,
dcf^yj.

Kat rov veaviaKov avtarvjatv

Travro^vvafJiog

Xoy(a re Kat

Ata

rt

§c ov
;

Xoy(a fLovo)
fii.d6cofn.ev

eTrXvjpov

ro Bavfm,

dXXa

Kai 25

^yparo rvjg aopov
o^/xwv,

iva
ec-rt,

ori ro a^afxa

HLpiarov rov ©eou

aSifxa ^aivjg

Kat crap^ rov irdvra layvovrog Aoyov.
vj

^EtTrei^^

yap

i^ta yeyove rov Xoyov
^(aoirotog

aap^ rov irdvra ^myovovv-

Tog, ^ia rovro

eart Kai avrvj, Kat Bavdrov Kxi (pBopag

dvatperiKVj.

30
(f^vjatv,

" AveKdBtae'^ yap,
fjiv]

"

6 veKpog

Kai ^p^aro XaXe^v" iva Ka) yap dXvjBovg dva-

Kara

<f)avTaaiav ^o^Y/ riatv eyi^epBat'
e Sic,

VII. 20.
cTTao-ew?
viryjp^/fjv

AOYKAN ETArrEAIOT.
ravra
<jy}[j.e.'ia'

57
aoiixa ovre

ay\'Xjypv

yap

dvaKa'*Tyj

Oiaai ovre XaXrjaai "^vvarai' oOev
[Jt.y}rpi

" Kai

e^ooKev avrov^^

4*Wh

avrov.

i6

Kat iSo^a^ov tov Qeop Xeyovre^,
/xeyas iyrjyepraL iv
r/fXLV.

Ori

Trpotp^rrjf

5

ToT

ArioT Ktpiaaot ifVAEHANAPEiAs.
[xiKpov

Meya

^e rovro •napd

ye dvaiaO-^rx Kai dyapi<jr(a Xoyto^
irpo(f>-^ry]Vf

yap varepov ov^e yap
vo(xi^ov(Tiv avrovy

ov^e elf dyaQov tgv Xaov TrecfiyjvoTa

dXXa

rov rov Oavdrov KaraXvryjv davdra) iiapa^i^oaaiVy ovK el-

^OTff ori rore ^^, tot€ Karekve

Sdvarov, yjviKa

e<f)

eavrov t^vio

dvdcrraaiv eitoi^aaro.

Km.
20

K.

Ilfpt rStv airocrrdKivTav irapa 'lcadvvij.

E7r€/^^ ^e ro irapo^o^ov rov OavfxaTOi eii

<f>ol3ov

yjyayev airav-

ra^ rovg rore Trapovrag^
ai/To5

^ieXaX-^Svj re Kai ev oXyj ryj

lov^aia, koi 15

^e

Tc5

dyico

(SaTrTiaTyj

diffffyeiXdv

riveq

rav fxaSi^Twv'
'^

•npoaKaXeadixevog ovv enefxxpev avrovg Ttpog rov K.vpioVf

XeyaVy

" av

ei

epyofxevogf

yj

erepov irpoa^oK^fxev

;^
elg

Aia

ri ^e aiirovg diieareiXey Trpoeypd^f^ero
**

to Kara

MaT20

Baiov, ecyf

Kai e^iKaiiodyj

/]

ao<f>ia diro

rav reKvxv ayT^f."
[xaKdpiog ^aiTTi-

Ktpiaaot 'Aaeeanapeias.

Ovk

yjyvorjaev

aryjg rov evavSpamyjaavra rov TlaTpog Xoyov'
yj^ei

^iy rovro viroXd^Yig'
6 epypfxevog'
y)v

yap Kai fxdka aa^paSf
Se rt
ao<pov
int

ori

avrog eartv

elpyd-

t^ero

Kai evfxyfyavov^ Kai OTtep

eiKog, ov fxerpiag

ovivyjai

Tovg

avrov fxa6y]Tevofxevovg'
io^av avrov Kai
t>;v

01 fxev

yap

ovn^a X-piaTOv 25
VTrepoyyjv,

ei^oregy

yjroi

rvjv

KaTa

^ravTwv

Yfpefxa 7i(og

Kai VTre^dKVovTOf Bavfxarovpyovvrog avrov, Kai raTg rav

^pcofxevav

vnep^oXaHg viKavrog rov (SaTrriar^v.
ri ovv
yj

Kai
" av
T€Ta/
y^ei
ei

fxer oXiya'

apa fSovXerai

voeiv epcorav Kat
e(f>av

*'

Xeywv,

epypfxevogf
T>jv

erepov npoa^oKWfi.ev ;"
ovy^

rotvvv ori

^AaT-30
avrog'

dyvoiav oiKovofxiK'2gf

iva

fxdBoi

fxaXXov

yap wg

Ttpotpoixog ro fxvaryipioVf
oayj

dXX

iva TtXyipo^opyiBaaiv 01

avTov fxaBi^rat,

rtg

eariv

yj

rov SwT^pof i/nepoyy], Kat ori
I

58
T^f

EPMHNEIA TOY KATA
OveoTrvevffTOV ypacjyfjg
01

VII. 24.
Ka.i

Xoyo^, tov

f/.ev

ag ©eov

Kvpiov

jj^ovTa 'Trpof^efAyjVVKeV

^e aXXoi

'iravTeg

•^crav

oiKeTai

'npoaice-

TaA/xevo/,
•TtTai'

teQTtOTOV eTOifxd^ovTeg t^v o^ov
toivvv

Kvpiov, Ka&a yeypa-

eKkyjSi^

^ia twv irpocpifjTav

6 ep^x^Ofxevos, 6

twv oAwv
5

HiOTrip Kai Kvpiof.

ToT
KaT

ATTOT.

E/^Wf

(O^

©COf

l^pKTTOg
fiaOvjTuv

TVjV

OlKOVOf/.taV
ttjv

ToD

irpdyfiaTOi Kai tyjs tcov
eKeTvQ
'^vj

lcodvvov

acf)i^ecog

aiTiaVf

fkdXi(7Ta tov Kaipov TroXXaTrkacriag t«v ^^i^ yeyevvj6eo(JVjfji.eiag'

fjievctiv

elpyd^eTO

yeyovoTeg ovv apa T^g evovavjg

avTcio

fKeyaXoTtpeireiag eitoTiTai Kai Beccpoif Kai tioKv to QavfLa TYjg evov- lo
(Tojf

avTCti

'^vvdfxectig

Te

Kai
ctig

evepyeiag
e^
lctidvvov

ev

eavjotg
ei

(xvKke^avTeg,

"Tipoadyovcn t^v epctiTYjcnv
ep')(OfJ,evog
*,

XeyovTeg,

avTog

ecTTiv

evTOvGd

fxoi /3ke7re TYjg
e(f)y]

tov EcoT^po? oiKovofJiiag to
diiocffepei

evTeyyeg'
eig Tvjv ^i

ov

yap

aTrXoog

to

^

dX?C

fi.aXkov

avTOvg

avTCtiv tcov TtpayfKaTCtiV TrXyjpocpopiav, iv

eva(f)opfJLCtig

t^vi^

eig

avTovg itiaTiv Ttapa^e^dfievot,
'TtopevdevTeg"

vTtovodT-^acticri Ttpog
(pyjcri,

tov aTtodTeilctidvv^,

XavTa avTovg' "

yap,

" ditayyetKaTe

" a i^eTe^ Kat

yjKova-aTe'

TV(f)Xoi

dva(3Xe7tovai, yjjoXot Ttepntacag

" Toya/," Kai Ta e|%.
fj,eva

TayTa

iravTa 'itpoaityiyyeXKaatv
7tpo(piJTai.

eaoeych

^/

efj^ov

KaTo. Kaipovg ol fj.aKdpioi
7tpoetpyjfj.evctiv

Ki

^e

20

yeyova

tSov

itdXai

aTtoTeXeTvjg,

Kai tovtcov

avToi
ev

yeyovaTe
efLot.

Becopot,

fxaKdptog

Totvvv

og

edv

ft.y}

aKav^^aXiaQ^

34

T/ e^eXrjXvOaTe
ToT AnoT TiTOT
(pepeTai u^e KdKeT
fj.ev
ctig

els ttjv ep7j/xou

OeaaaaOai

;

Bo2Tpi2N.
vito

No/x;^€Te OTi

lcodvvi^g

fneTa- 25

7tvevf/.dTCov
6

aaXevofi.evog,

coaTe ttotc
epcoTciov, el

ff.apTvpeh, oti
eyco
elfj.i
',

avTog etfm
7toteT'

'KptaTOg'

dXXoTe
efi)fj

he
yj

avTog
•yj

oi^a a

efJ.ov

to

ttvevfj.a,

ydptg, efj^
ju.»j§ev

eKeivov otKovofj.ia.

Ti
iv

toivvv e^-^XdeTe eig t^v epyjfxov, t^v

e^^oucrav

Tep7tvov;

oog

^id tvjv
^/

eKeivov 6eav

e^tevai

7tpo(f)aai-^o

^yja6e.

A^Xov
T>jv

toivvv,

ctig

ov^ev
et

eTepov
fiyj
ctig

KaTaXeixpavTeg
dvTntoiovfj.evoi

Tag
tov

TtoXeig
dv^tpog
TtoteT'

epyifj.ov

KaTeXd^eTe,
epcoTO.

Kat tov
ov

d^ictifJ.aTog.
fj.ev

fj.e

ovk dyvocov, dXX^ oi^a rt

ydp

vvv

Oi^e, eTepca ^e

dXXoTe fxeTa^aivet.
g
Sic.

f Sic.

VII. 31.

AOTKAN EYArrEAIOT.
tyfi
TrepifSXeTrrov
;
fi.y]

69
a^ici}fjt,a ;

M^

(T/ijfxa

;

fjJy]

(3a<xiXiK0V

fxi^

Paa-tXtKOv e/j^ev evToA^v
€Tr€(ftep€To
fji.€vov ;

ypafXfj.aTa Kat '^oyfmra Kat
rjv

vofi.ovg

^actXtKovg

;

fxrj

avTtiroii^aofJi.tvoi

Kara to

<f>atvo-

ov-^^^t

TpiyjLvov ifxaTtov

ecpopet

;

ov-)(^i

avTOfryi^iov eiye t»/v
;

Tpo<py]v

;

/A^/ TotovTov vfMig TrpoeTpiiparo
€/f
"Trpoipi^TYjV
yjpyi<Tif/.a}g
fj.ev

eKei aTieXdeiv

5

E/ wf

ain^AfleTf, Kat
iTpo<p^Tif]g

Xeyot vfjuv, Kat

irepttjaoTepov "TrpocpYiTOv' o

yap

TipoKeyet, ovTog ^e
eiiribv, **

ov fxovov Yj^ovTa
afjivog

TrpofJ.efJ.yjvvKeVf

aXXa

Kat vTre^et^ev

T^e o

Tov Qeov,
l<i3<x.vw]v

6

"

atp<av tvjv afJMpTiav
i^v

tov

KOfTf/iov."

AyyeXov
yjv

oe Tov
^v<TtVy

KaXeTy owj^ oti

AyyeXog, avSpaivog yap

t^v io
rrjv
y]

aXX

OTi

ayyeXov epyov

eiroteti

ayyeXXcov rov 'KptaTov

irapovaiav'
ft.eTavota

ovTog P<x7rTtaf/M eKYipv^e fj.eTavotag, tva TrpoXa^Y]
a(f)eatv'

tyjv

avev yap fi.eTavoiag a(peatg ov ^t^oTat.

Es ANEnirpA*OT.
yvvatKog, Kat KaTi^^iaae

Opa t^v
tyjv

aKpi/Seiav,

f».et^<i}v

ev

yevvY]ToTg

yvvatKav Xeyet, tva e^eXi^

irapBevoV

eyevvYjBY]

fj.ev

yap €k i^
Xa-

a<afj.a

eK tov

Y]f».eTepov

<pvp<xfj.aTog

^eiv, tva TQ oXov ayiaaBr] ^ta TY]g air apyY]g.

VevvYjToiv §e

(f)Y]at

yvvaiKxv twv Kara
Trapdeviav.

(f>vatv

TtKTOvam, iva

i^^ta Orj

t^v Trapa

(f>vaiv

Aaaos. Oiov
Tiyv

fji.eya

etyev

ot^ia>fJi.a

6 ^Jcooiw^g

koi (f>o^epog ^v 20 Kai

evaTaaiVy Kat aefcvog
tov fSiov,

t>jv oxptVf

Kat aytog
ty]v

tyjv Trpoatpeaiv,

aveirtXYjTrTog

Kat KaBapog

ttavotav, Kat

Trvevft.aTO-

(popog TY]v yaptv, Kat ^vvaTOg ev

iraat, Kat €vyevY]g

KaTo. irdvra.
<TvyKptv6fj.evog

tov yap ap5^;eoea?f vlog
te irpog Tovg
OfJMg eTt ev
KCtifJievYjv

y]v,

Kat (poPepog

tw Xaw,
Kav

y]^y]

irpog

Seov

€i^r,fj.-fjaavTag,

fj.eyag

eaT/v, aAA' 25
ty]v

/3/ou

avaaTpe<peTat, Kat ov^eirco aireXa^e
6 fniKpoTepog toivvv ev tyj

Trpoato-

eXni^a'

^aaiXeM

tSov

ovpavwv,

fj.et^<t3v

avTov eaTtV ot^ oti Kat
to evTavQa
o/JLOico(rco
;

lioaw^g ovk airoX^^eTat,

«AAa

avyKpivci}fi.ev

a^i<ofj.a,

eKeivy tyj Trpoa^oKCOfj.evY] yaptTi.

31

^LVi ovv
Kcu TLVL

T0V9 avOpayjTovs

Trjs yeveoiy TOVTrjs 2,0

eicTLV ofJuoLOL

ofiOLOL euTL iraL^LOL^ Tols iv

ayopa.

KaOrjixevoLS.

ToT AnoT Ktpiaaot.
Torf lovhauav trouatv ovrcog

YivtKa irov iratyviov Ttg TpoTrog irapa
ey<ov, eig
I

fiepYj

^vo

nXYiBvg 'vat^icov

2

60
eT€[Jt.V€TO,

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
a Koi
TTjv

VII. 3

Tov ^lov yeXZvTa Tvp(3vjVf Kai twv ev avToo

TT/ja^jaaTwv to dvaifxaXoVf Kcu

t^v eTepco^

elg

cTepa

0€ivv}v

Kai

dBpoav fXfTa^oXvjV,

to. fxev yjvXovVy to.
01

^e eOpyjVovv'
(tvvyj^ovto'

aXX
ovre

ovt€ To7g
fxev

avXovai Kai yaipovaiv
KKaiovaiv
01

BprivovvT€?

Toig

tov

avXov cj^ovTff

ayveTrAaTTOVTO*

eh

aXXvjXoi^ S

evcKaXovv Tpoitov to davixTraQe? rffovv o^idBeTov. toiovtov ti wewovBevat Tov$ twv
lov^aioov
^Yjfj.ovg

ofxov TO?f irpoeaTfjKotnv

iiyypi-

^€T0

"KpKTTO^.

KE^. KA.
Hfpl
Trjs akeiyjrdiTrjS

top Kvpiov fivpa.
(j^ayr) /Lter

lO

36

'H/)£ora bi T19 avrov t(dv ^apiaaLcov, tva

avTOv.
Kpyj yivoo(TKeiv oti ovTog
vj[j.Siv

^apiaalog

KeKXYjKcog tov Ki/^/ov

Koi ©eov 'ivjaovv KpicrTOV, ^oXepas viroKpiaecos ovk diTYiXTVjg efMcjxoXevovavjs

XaKTo, ov^e
'*

diiiaTiag avTw, oQev
^e K.vpiog

€(f>v)f

"

el v}V

j^

Trpo^p-^Tvjg,^^

Kai To.

'e^vjg,

'O

Kamep

eltwg avTOv toiov*'

Tov ovTa, eiaeXQccv elg tov oIkov avTov KaT€KXt6vj,
<f>v)atf
*'

Kat <^oy,"

yvvvj ^Ttg

vjv

ev

t^

vtoXet dfJiapTaXog,

einyvovaa oti KaTa-

KetTat €V TV) oiKta tov ^apiaaiov'

Kai Ta

e^vjg.
vj

OiiK eaTi ^e avTV) ovt€

vj

vtapa t<3 MaT^a/o!, ovt€

iiapa tco 20
Ttg.

Ma^Koo, ovTC

VI

Ttapa

^lwdvvvj fKWifxovevOfxevi^,
eTiifj.eXoog

dXX eTepa
tvjv

Karavowv

toivvv eyco koi Kare^eTd^av

tt^vjaiv Kai

twv evayyeXtKwv pVffxdTwv evaTevi^av
yvva^Kag
e^
Xoyt^ofJi.at'

tS> dKpt(3€i, TpeHg eivat

Tag
Kat

Koi
TVjg

€K

T^g twv Ttpoavmwv
Kat
€K

irotOTVjTog,

avTOv Toy Tpovrov

Trpd^ecog,
irept

T^g ^tacpopag
TVjg

tov 25

Katpov.

'O

jU.ev

yap

^lccdvvi^g

T^g M.apiag

d^eXtpvjg

Aa^dpov Kat Mdp6ag
ev

eTratvovfJi.evvjg

acpo^pa Kat BeoaefBovg, Kai
<f>v]atVf

Toig fk.a6viTtwaaig XeXoytafxevvjg tw ^Iv]aov tovto
ttviyovfJ.€Vog,

d>^€

voog

"

ovv,
ovrov

^lvjaovg, vrpo
vjv

e^ ^fJiepwv
ov

tov

Yldaya
veKpm.^o
6

"
"

YlX6€V

€ig

Bvj6aviaVf
ovv

Ad^apog,

vjyetpev €K

'EiTToivjaav

avTw €KeT
^v
tcov

^erTrvov.

'H

^e

Mdp6a
vj

^tvjKOvet,

" Se Ad^apog

elg

avvavaKeifJLevtov

avTf'

ovv

Mapta

VII. 36.

AOTKAN EYArrEAIOT.
Xirpav
[xvpov
l^ov
vdp^ov,*'

61
e^^f.
yjXeixpe

" Xa^oixra

Kai

to.

rovg
rrjv

TTOOaf rov 'I^oroy*
OiKiav

vpo

ef

^fJiepSov

rov Yldfy/a' Kara
yeyovevai

Mapiag Kat Aa^dpov Kai MdpOaf rovro

cracf^fag

taroprjaev o EvayyeXia-r-^^'
Ttev.

ag Kai dvwrepw ro avro lovro
fJivpx

e^eT-

" 'Hv

&e Ma/j/a

t,

dXeixpaaa rov Kvpiov

Kat cKixd-S
/a^

"

^aaa,^^ Kat

ra

e^^f,

**

^?

o d^eX.(f>o$

Ad^apo^ ^a^ever" Kat

6avfid(rvjg ei
(ftvjcrtv

Kora

Ttpoava(f)wvriaev eppeGfi'
rSov

Kat yap vepi rov lov^a
dirapiBfj.ovfJ.evO(;,

'M.dpKo^;

ra ovofxara

ip 'ATroaroXoov

**

Kat

\ovtag

laKapixrrj^ bf Kat •nape^ooKev avrov.^^

Kairot

ye

ov^eitca

Ttapa^ovg ^v avrov,
6

dXXd

ro fx.eKXov, wf ^^17 yevofJievov 10

eypaxpev
*'

M

ye 'M.arOaTog eTtdyet Xeywv, " Kat eyevero ore
•ndvra^; rovg

ereAecrei'

li^crovf

Xoyov^ rovrovg,

eiTre

to<V

fi-o.-

**

6ijTa<V auTOy, o^^aTe ort ft.erd tvo yjfLepai ro Ylda^^^a ytverat,"
e^yj^.
*'

Kat rd
*'

Tov

te

'I>j(7oi5

yevofj.evov
'yyvij

ev

ByjOavia ev oiKta

S/jtxajvof

Tou keTrpov, irpoayjXSev avrw

eyov^a dxd^aarpov 15

*'

fxvpov iToXvrifj.ov, Kat Kareyeev
fj.evov.

eitt ryjg

Ke(paX^( avrov dvaKetlyjaov,

z^KOTtet

ovv

ori

etpyjKoroi

rov

otbare ort

*'

fj.erd ^vo yjfj.epai ro

Tidaya yiverai'" ovrco^

taropyjcrev

avrov

KvayyeXtarrjg
Titfj.wvo^
fty}

yevoft.evov

Kard
vito

t>jv

ayT>jv

Byjdaviav ev ryj oiKta
fJLvpw,

rov Xevpov, Kat

ryjg

yvvaiKO$ rifnyjQevra rw

20

Twv TToSwv dXet^ofxevxv, dXX.d rov dXaPdarpov Kara^xeofxevov
Kecf^aXijs.

ryjg

ware Kat

vito

rov

Icoavvou

ypacfiev,

ev toj

oiKa>

Maptag Kat Mdp6a$, Kai
yap Touf
X.ijg

aTto rov rpottov

rvjg itpd^ewg, eKeT fxev

Tto^ag ^Xetipe koi ditefxoc^e ralg 6pt^t r^g t^iag Ke(f)arijg

aXetxpaaa, evravda te Kareyeev htt

rov lyjaov Ke^paXyjg' 25
lcodvvyjg

Kat aito yjpovov ttpo fuev yap e|

yjf/.epuv €(f>yj

rov

Yldaya
^vo

yevea6at
fxovos'

ro

^eTitvov
**

eKeivo,

MaT^arof

^e

vpo

yjfxepxv
y}

Kat

AovKag
'*

§e itep) toc fxeaa rov ¥.vayyeXiov

Koi ert npo
eitt-

rovrov.
**

i^ov
ort

ydp

yvvr]
ev

ev ryj itoXei
rjj

^rig

yjv

dfxaprwXoi,

yvovaa

avd^etrat

oiKia

rov ^aptaatov,

Kofxiaaaa^o
OTtiaa
KaX.e-

" aXafSaarpov

fxvpov, Kat

" KXatovaa,"
'*

Kat rd
ev

e^^g.

ardaa itapd rovg Tto^ag avrov " 'l^wv ^e ^apiaahg
ei
'^v

aag avrov, eivev

eavr^ Xeym, ovrog

itpo^pT^ryjg, evi-

^ MdpKOi Cod.

S

62
**

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
ns
koci itoxaTrri^''
fJivj

VII. 43.

vaa-Kev av

Kai

to. €^y]$.

vpo^vjXoTaTa yovv ck
itefi

rov Kaipov M^eiKTai

ttjv avTTjv

Tat$ aXKaig yvvai^) Ta7g
fxvpti)'

Tov Katpov Tov TtaBovg TifJLyjaaa-aig tov ScoT^^a toj
te
vo[xi^eTCi}

fu^iv

Ota to Kat tovtov tov ^aptaaTov rov KeKkyjKOTa avTOv
<patve-

Yitfxava TipoayopiveaGatfTOv avTOv eivat Yitfxwva toS Xenpco'

Tai yap eKehog TeBepaTievixevog
(oaiiep
fxy]

vtto

tov

Ivjaov, Kat

•^aptcxTYjptov

anoTtvvvg avxSi

tvjv etg tvjv otKtav

aitotoyyiv.

ov

yap av

el

Te6epa7revT0, irap avTco KaTeKvev.
K.aTe<f)t\€t he avTti ovk

apywg, a\Xa,

t&j fxvpa aXei(f>ov<ra Toiig

"Tro^ag, rvjv TroXXyjv

aTopyvjv eK tovtov ^etKvvovaa.
fxv]

10

'O

^e

Kvpiog

6

^ta pvjfxdTav fxovov olkovwv,
'TTpocfyvjTav

aXXa

Kai Tag

IvBvfxviaetg
yjnv,

KaTaXafj.^dvm, ag Kat tuv

^eaTroTvjg vTrdp^tfxcov,

airayyeKKei Tovg Xoytafxovg tov ^aptaatov Xeyoov' "
Kai

e)^w aot Tt etiretv,

Ta
co

eg^^g.
(f)V]ai

43

Kha
avTov'
rvjTOg'

eiTTOVTog eKetvov,

to TtXeov ^'^(aptaaTO, avTog
evedvfL^^Svjg
;

itpogie,

t/ Totvvv av TotavTa
ei

ov^e

yap av dvafkdpanvjXXayf/.evog

yap eXdrTd}

yjpeaiaTelg,

aXX

ov
fxev

fKevrot

Tvyyavetg dfxapTVjfxaxxv' Kat iroXXdKig
eirratKOTa, ^t e^ofxoXoy-^aeag
t\ oXtya
v]ft.apTviHOTa, tt

ytyverai rov TtoXXa
rov

rm dfx.apTi^fj.dT(av aTtaXXayv]vat'
fnv]

vnepvjipaviav
rvj

TtpoeXSeiv

<papft.dK(a

20

TV]g e^ofi.oXoy^a€cog,
fLV]

Kat vitoKeHaQat

KoXdaei'

ov^e

yap ^ta to
Ofkotcog

eyetv TtoXXa Tijf Kptaecog aTtaXXaTTerat rtg,
To7g

aXX

Kai
vitep

eitl

oXiyoig

KaraKptverat,

fLVj

rvjv

"TtpoavjKovaav
(og

Kai

avTWv TtpoaevejKag
rcoXog

e^ofi.oXoyvjatv Kat

fxerdvotav.

yap dfxap^vjfxarog, 25
fxoi
eitt

d^nappvjataarog
fj.ev, <pv]at,

evpeQ-^aeraif
erotfKotg

eiti

rov

cf)opepov

Kat av

ro7g

ovk ey^yjaa)' vd(op ydp
v]

Tovg Tto^ag ovk e^coKag' evKoXog yap rwv v^drcov
^e Toc dverotfxa e^eKevaae, roig ^aKpvaiv avrvjg
Tto^ag'

ypvjatg'
fj.ov

avriq

Ppeyovad

rovg

ov te

yap evKoXog
"ti

v]

twv ^aKpvxv

eKyvatg, Kat ralg Qpt^tv
"^ta

e^efJ.a^ev, tva

wv iB-^pevae itpog dff.apriav veorvjra,
ert

Tovrcov^o
<f>t-

dytoavvv]v evpeQvj Bvjpevovaa'
Xvjfxa

oe Kat

Karecppovvjadg fxoV

ydp

fnot

ovk e^wKag, oy^e eXata>
7to6ov

tv]V KecpaX-fjv fxov vjXetxpag'
fx.01

avrr^ ^e fj.eTd itavrog

Kara(f>tXovad
ev aeavrca
v]

rovg itotag,

fj.vpQ>

rovTOvg ^Xetxpe' Kat

en€t'^v]

ehag

"

ovrog

el vjv "TtpocftvjTvjg,

"

eyiv(oaK€v av, rig Kat itoraitv]

yvvv] avrv] vjrig airreTai aurov,

35

VIII.
**

I.

AOYKAN EYArrEAIOT.
Kav vvv €K TOfTou oti ovk

63
tffvoovVy oti

OTi diJiapTaXoi 60"t/" yvaBi
(Tovi ^iaXoyiCTfJLovs

Kat Touf

htlaTa^ai Kai Tag ajxapTiai TavTvjg
irdvTa e/^Wf iXiyya^ Kai tov oyKOV
oti acfyewvTat

yivwa-KwV

^io

Kai ae

/u,€V

co$

Tuv dfx.apTrifx.dTm TavTvjg (HKTTdfXivog Xeya) aot "
**

avTyjg at dfxapTtai" Kai

Ta

e^vjg.

5

E^o^e ^f

Kvayye\t<7TVjg, OTt Kat eTepot yjaav a-vvavaKetfj.evot,

ovg Kai e^evKxev
airoTOV TO
yrjcrtg

XenpoSf OTt oy)^ ag irpocp-^TOv ^v,

dw
;

ux;

^e-

YtKatov dTrovefxovTog'

t/ ^e ^v to ^iKaiov
vj

-^

e^of/.oXo-

TYjg

yvvaiKog Kat to ^dKpvov Kat

TifJLVj,

Kat

yj

icapa Tovg

Tio^ag cTaatg.
/Tre

10

de avTvi

ApiaTog

rj

iriaTtg

aov aeawKe ae.
dfxapTtag.
fj.riKe.Tt

ilta to

TTtaTevaat ai;T»;v OTt e^ovatav

e^/ei acf^tevat

To

&e

**

Ttopevov eig eip-^vrjv" tovjo eaTt to

dfj.apTdveiv.

KEa>. KB.
Ilepl TTjs •napa^oKrjs tov

(nreipavTos.

15

[

YlOll

eyivero iu tco Kade^rj? kcu ovtos 8l(o8€V€ Kara
KCLL
KCOjJLTJVf

TToXlV

KTJpvaaWV

KCLi

€Vayy€\L^O/JL€VOS' T7]V

^acTLX^iav tov GeoO.
Ato^evwv ^e KaTo, noketg Kat KWfxag Kat Kvjpvaacov Kai evayyeXi^Ofi.evog tvjv (3aatXeiav

tov Seov
eTCt

ovpavoOev ytvoft.evog

^t^d- 20

aKakog

etg

t>;v

yrjVf

Tovg
rj

yrjg etg t>jv {SaatXeiav e^dXet

twv

ovpavwV eaTt yap Kat
vvjv

yrj avTr] ^rif>.iovpyv]fjia, OTrcag 01

^ia itkd-

aiToaTdvTeg

Trjg

ovpaviov KaTaaTdaeccg twv

eTrtyetcav

KaTa-

(ppovrjacoaiy.

O/

^e ^oo^eKa r;aav avv avTco ovk evayyeXi^ofj.evot^

dXka

fi.a9rj-

25

Tevofxevot Kai 7rai^aycoyovft.evot irpog to Kvayyektov.

AivjKovovv Se avToTg ai avvaKoXovBovaat yvvaTKeg eK t«v vrrap-

y^vzm

avToig'

ov

yap

acofnaTiKrjv

avdiravatv rrapeyovatv avToTg,

aXX' evayyeXiKVjg acoTrjpiag avTnrotovfj.evat Kai irpoaavaXtaKOvaat

Ta vndpyovTa
evaej3eiav.

etg

tvjv

twv "heofxevm

eTrt^oaiv, tva

KTVjavjTai

t^v^o

Ylept t^? Trapa^oXrig tov airopov Kat aKoXovQcog, irept
f/.r]

Tov airTeiv Xvyyov, Kat

KaXvTrTetv avTOv aKevet, Kat tovto

64

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Trjg fJLyjTpo^

VIII.

i.

TrpoTepcof ^e, Kai 'nep\

avTOv Kai twv a^€\(j>Zv avTOVt
eT:iTiijJ}cre(ag tuiv

ort yjQeXov
Trepi

avTOV

i^^e^v,

Kai

Trepi

Trjg

vhaToov Kat

Tov ej^ovTCf tov Aeyewva, Kai

irepi

rav

J

epyearjvav, Kat irept
aifj.oppoovdfig,

Trjg
Tiepi

dvyarpog tov apy^iavvayayoVf Kai
TYjg

Trepi Trjg

Kai

aiiocrToXrig tcov ^coSeAca, Kat Trepi 'hlpa^ov, Kai irept tcSv5

TievTe apTOov, Kat iiept Trjg tSov fxaSrjTwv eTreparrjaeag, ort

Tiva

fji€

Xeyovatv

oi

o^^Xot

elvat

;

Kat

iiept

Trjg

fji.eTafJ.op(f)Q)ae(ug

Kai

Tiept

Tov creXrjvta^ofxevQVf Kai nept tuv ^taXoyt^ofxevoov Ttg
OTrep

fxet^tcv etTT/v,
ca^e,

eaTt Ke<pdXaiov.

Klg

to. fxiKpa, eig tov

ayiov Xoyov, eag

<7ipovypd(f)ri etg

tov ayiov MaT^arov.

lo
ovpavoBev •napayevofj.evog ^t-

ToT Anor Titot Bostpan. 'O
^daKaXog
eig Trjv

yr^ Tovg hit

Tr^g yr)g t»;v

^aatXeiav
rjv

tcov

ovparj

vav evayyeXi^erat, tva Trfv yrjv TiQf^arj ovpavov'

yap xat

y^
koii^

avTov

Orjfii.tovpyrifKa.

ETre/^T^

yap tia

TiXdvrjv diieaTYi Trjg ovpavtov
eig evaejSetav,

KaraaTdaecog' ^Afie ^e Kat

t*;v

y^v KajopGooaat

avvdipat to avvafx<poT€pov tta
aeiv efxeXXe PaatXetav Qeov, ov

fxovriv cptXavGpaTiiav.
vj

Ttg Se Krjpvavj

6 viog

tov ©eov, ov
6 dvcoSev

PaatXeta
dvco

;

yap

ot

AcaTW

Ta

avco KrjpvTTOfxeVy

dXX

Ta

dnay-

yeXXet.

Teyomatv
cov

ovv

iioXXoi Tipo^p^Tai,
fxr]

dXX ovk

eKrjpv^av ovTicog

pavav PaatXeiav'
e^i^ovv.
yrjg

ydp

rjaav BeaTai, tov Xoyov tovtoov
'lcodvvi^g, 6
cov

20

Aid

T0V70 eXeyev
^e
dvcodev

ck

Toy^

y^g, eK t^j
eaTi,

XaXeT,

epyofxevog
Toivvv

eTidvco

TidvTcov

Kai

€copaK€

fxapTvpei'
fxri

CKrjpv^e

t^v jSaaiXeiav tov Qeov Tolg
^AyyeXotg
'JioXtTevofxevyjv

diitaTotg

(patvofxevriv, t>jv iiap
ot

t€ Kai

KpaTovaav, tva
AfaTa(/>pov^crcy(7/v.

aKOvovTeg (SaatXeiav tqv Qeov tcov

eiityetcav

25

Ov

a<jifxaTtKr\v

avdiiavaiv fneTe^icoKov,

dXX evayyeXtK^g

acoTrj-

piag avTeTioieirOf TipoavrjXtaKov ovv rd VTidp^^ovTay tva Krrjacovrat
rrjv evae/Setav.

ToT AriOT Ktpiaaot.
xpaXfxoo^og

KtaK€KOfiiiK€ Tov
dvoi^oo
ev

Kvpov

fiaKdptog 50

Aa/3;^ Xeyovra, "
ASpei
hrj

7iapaj3oXa7g

to

ardfxa
^tr/yo-

"

fxov.^^

ovv eg Tiepag eK/SelSrjKog tq
fxev

nap avrov
iiept

pevfxevQV'

TiXetarr}
rrjg

ydp

TiXrjSvg

avveyriyepro

avrov e^

aTidarjg

lov^aiag.

YlpoaeXdXet ^e avroTg

ev

TiapafSoXaigf

aXX

cKetvotg fxev qvk ovatv d^iotg rov fxaSeh

ra

fxvarrfpia

T^f35

.

^

VIII. 5-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
a<TV[Ji.<f)aw]i vjv 6

65

Twv ovpavav ^aa/Ae/af,

Xoyoi' Xoyov yap yj^iovv

ovoevof to y^ifj(T6ai t*;v e/V «^tov Trpoa-^KaaSai iriffTiv, avriirpaT-

Tov oe avoaias to7^ ^i ayTov KyjpvyfLatriv, kou yovv (ireTifJMv toT^
eQeXovcTi vpoae^peveiv avToo, Kai t^v irap

avToTi

^ixpucri

fxvaTa-

yayyiaVf ZvaaePovvTe^ tc Kai AeyovTCf, ^aifumov eyei

Kai fxaive-

Tai, Ti aKoveTe avTov
fjLvaTyjpia

;

ovkovv ovk eKUVoig
ijfiAv

^e^oTa/ yvS)vai

Ta

t^? PaaiXetag twv ovpavm^
yjfxiv

^e fxaXXov Tolg Itoi-

fMTipoig e/f incrT^v* ^ehtaKe yap

avTog to ^vvaaQai fxovoV
t€ ao(f>av Ka) aiviyfxaTa'

irapa^o^$
eiKoveg
voi^raJv

^e, <rACOTe<vov Xoyov, p-^aei^

yap

eiai^ (oaitep

ai Tiapa^oKai itpayfi.aTm ovy^
6

opaim^ lo

T€ fMiXkov Kai wevfjLaTiKwV
o<pQaXfj.o7<;'

yap

7^/0?* ovk eveaTi toTs
vj

Tov awfjMTOi

tovto teiKvvaiv

irapa^okyj To7g TYjg

OiavQiag 0f/.fuxai ^ia tcHv ev aiaS-^aeif Kai olov airo tojv Trpayf/.aTccv
OiafA,op(f)ovaa
rjfj.iv

KaXas

tvjv

vovjtwv layyoTfiTa.

thxf/.ev

toivvv OTioiav
<f>i^-

e^v(f)aivei

tyjv voyjatv

tov SwT^pof

o

Xoyog,

" 'E|^A6e,"

15

aiVf

"

aveipcov tov a^ireTpai" Kai to. e|^f

5

Tor AnoT
yap
Kai

Tixor. " 'E^^Adev" ^v yap

ev Toig KoXiroi? tov

Yla-

Tpog, Kai irpo TravTog atwvog
OTt ayreipeif TOTe
^^ ev tS) Koafj.oci yjv,

avvai^ioi tov
fi.ovov,

HaTpog Aoyog.
Mapiag

Ov
20

earat
Kat

o^S' ot€ ck

yevvaTat,

Koafj.o<;

avTOv ovk eyva." 'E|^X5ev

aiietpm tov aireTpat tov
Zavet^eTat
Xoyov,

t^^tov

airopov.
vTrfxp^/oov

A/a
t>jv

Tt tov t^^tov;
<f>vatv.

ov

yap
tttog
yj

Aoyog Seov
lcixxvvoVf
fj.ev

ovKeTi

airopog IlayAoi', oy^e
vpo<pvjTaVf

ov^e aXkov Ttvog twv AiroaToXcav
^v*

aXXa

ayropog

ovk

yjv

Se

ayTwv

tttog,

aXXa

XapovTeg eyovat'
<f)vae<ag
**

XpiaTog

be

totov

eyei

airopov,

eK r^^- totag2^

tvjv

^t^aaKaXtav

'7rpoa<f)epci}v.

Eav yap
jtxev

Ae-yv;

IlayAof,

eyo)

e<f)VTevaa, 'AttoAAwc

eiroTtae," ti^coai

toj

Swt^^/ to

anetpetv, eauTw

Be

to <f)VTevaat.

yap

<f>vTev(av

aXXoBev Xafn-

/Sav»v, aXXay(ov f/.eTaTiSy]atv, 6 ^e airetpm <pvTevei, aXX* eK tcov
ihicov

TafAievm Xafj.(3(xvm

aKopTri^et.

a<f)Qovci)g

y^etp)
e/x.o/

airetpm 030

nauAos- eAeyeV
*'

"

el

^0Ktft.y]v

^yjTelTe

tov

cv

AaAoDvTOf

\ptaTov'"
eig
;

&e Sct)T»?p

"

ft.y}

KaXeayjTe ^t^^cxaKaXov

e-nt TVjg y-l^g'

"

yap eaTtv
^i-xa tov

vfJMV ^t^<xaKaXog ev ToTg ovpavoTg."
fj.aQeTv

Ilorof ^t^cxaKa01 ^loi^aToi,

Xog

^taXeyofj.evog. tta tovto eXeyov

a sic.

K

66

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
fjiy]

VIII.

5.

"

irw( ypafJi.fji.aTa ovTog oi^e

fJi€fjLa9r]Kc^$

;"

A;a

tovto

eiTre

tov

lOtov aTTopov, iva f/.ddy]s oti
av.TO<;

avTov r^g (pvaecog
cxiropevi,

6 (ntopog'

Kai <yap

eaTiv

iravTOg dyaBov

Kai

rjfj.iig

yeapyot avTov,
'^vevft.aTiKrjf

Kai Kai

Ot

avTOv T€ Kat iiap
^fj.S)v

avTov Kap7to(f>opia irdaa
Xeycov,

TovTo

tt^^duKei

"

X<»>ph €fxov ov hvvaa-Oe TToieivS

OVO€V.

Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias. Ka/
Ot
vjv

Troia

Tig €<rTtv

yj

7rpo(f>aa-tg

dp7rd^€T€

Ta

ev

Taig o^oTg

;

i^a)fj.€v

Teag, ag

Iv

iray^eat

irpayfj.aat

to

^vjTovfjievov.

aKXvipa Kat dv-^poTog irdad
Ka\
oiihev

ircos

eaTtv

o^og ota TO t^v aTrdvTWv vTroKelaQat iroat'

avTaTg €y)(w- 10
Kat Tolg

vvvTat

TCtiv

(7Tr€pfj.dT(av'

Kenat

^e fJidkXov

hrnroXaicoi,

eOeXovat

twv

TrTTjviav €TotfJ.a

elg

^iapiray^v.

ovkovv oaot tov vovv
ovTOt tov Beiov

eyovatv ev eavTotg (XKXvjpov Kat oiov
ov Trapo^e^/pvTai airopov.
lepov
vovG€TfjfJ.a, ^t

'neTrtXrjfj.evov,

ovk €ia^v€Tat ydp ev avTo7g 6e7ov re Kat
'hvvavTat

ov

Kapirocpopeiv
7rv€vfi.aat,

xa

eig dpeTV]v

av- 15
to5

yYifj.aTa'

ovTot

Tolig

aKaBdpToig
yeyovaatv
TpocpivjVf

Kat

avTW

^e

SaTava
TTcav

TreTraTvjfj.evot

o^og,

^v

ovk

'eveaTt

TroTe
ej^co»

Kapti^v

dyioov

eyyeveaQat

aTeTpav Kat eKyovov^

Kap^tav.

IflANNOT Xpt202Tomot.
l3iov, Trai^evcov evaycoviovg
KeifJ.€voVf

TavTa
ag

Xeycov
Toig

elg

dKptjSeiav dyet 20

elvai,

vTro

aTravToov 0(f>9aXf(.o7g

Kat €v fieaco tov TVjg
^vj

oiKOVfj.€vy}g

aycovt^ofievovg

OedTpw.
vvv^

M»/ ydp

TovTO

'i^^Te, (fjt^atv, OTt

evTavQa KaS-^fneBa

Kai

(V fj.iKpS) ycoviag €afj.ev fj^epet'

yev^aeaSe ydp Trdat KaTdtvjXoi.
'

B1KTCP02 nPE2BTTEPOT.
vaTov
avT-i^v

Orav ydp

ToaavTV]

vj

dpeTVj

d^v- 25

XaQeiV

ey^cov

ydp

airov^^atav

irpoaipeatv, X-^xpeTai
Trovccv

irvevft.aTog

ydpiv Kat

ao(f>iag

Kat yvcoaecogf Kai a^iav tZv

TVjv afi.ot^vjv.

ToT

ATTOT.

Ta

yap eK

(f)vaecog

vjft.iv

evovTa

v}

S<a ydptTOg

^o^evTa, edv
(pvXd^cofiev,

fnvj '^id

T^g avveyovg irpoaoyvig Kai
^vjfiicoBvjaofueda,

airov^bvjg (ptXoirovov

^o

TavTa

ov

fj.ovov

fxvjVev

7rpoXaf/.{3d-

vovTeg^

dXXd

Kai 7rpoaa7roXXvvT€g Kai

d

eyeiv €^o^afi.ev.
VjV 6 'ZcOTVjp

TlTOT Bo2TPaN.
Tcov

Kk

TOVTOV S^AoV OTt OVK

fJ.€Ta
Tvj

KaTa adoKa eiiyevm' KaTaXnrcbv yap
"

TovTovg a-yoXd^ei

Cod.

tyovov.

VIII. 22.

AOYKAN ETArrEAIOT.
Eirei^rj

67
^ia tyjv airo\€i\l/iv,

varptK^ ^i^affKaXia.
Kou hriBvixfiTog
rj

^e itoGi^tos

y}v

tU

Beav ^ta t^v yjioviav avay^jap-^^nv, TiapayiviTai
lw(TV]<f> oi
vj

[A^^Ti^p

avTOv Koi ol a^eXcpoi, ol itpoyovoi tov
ovK eaTi ^e
(XTefJiTV]

K\y]SevT€i

a^eX(f)ot'
ev

(sic) tov
vj

Kvpiov

(jvyyeveia, ovOe

oXiyco

7Fepiyp(X(f>€Tai

avTOv

Tipog

avQpwTrovg (fiiXia.

'HAde^

yap caravTa tov
7rpoXa/3o}v
** •*

KO^rfxov

eU

a^eX^pOTVjTa KaXeaai

a^flovov, Kai

eXeye ev vpocf^-^Taii tx TlaTp;, " aTrayyeXco to ovofXM
fxov'^^

(Tov

Toti ateX(f>o7g

iroloig
o-e*"

<x^eX(f>o7g

epfxvivevei

Xeycov^

ev

f/.ea(p

eKKXvjaiag

vfxvfi(T(o

oirov

toivvv eKKXfiaia

^pilo

aToVf eKei a^eX(f)OTYig 'KpicrTOv.

12

ToT

ATTOT. *0 Xoyog tov Qeov, Xoyog
ft.ia

y]v

avTov, TlaTpog yap

KOi Tiov

^i^a(7KaXia ev
Ty]v

Trpo^f^v^Taig

Kai ev KvayyeXi(7Ta7g Oia

T^f evepyiag

tov 'Ayiov n.vevfJiaTog.
avaTrefxxpyj irpog tov

Xeyei

^e tov

Aoyov tou
eirpeTre
i

SeoVf iva t^v

Tifi-t^v

TlaTepa. 'Q.g yap
yeyevvyffxevx
01

Tw YlaTpi
yevvY](TavTa,

yevv-S^aat

T/ov,
fxevTot

ovtco

irpeirei

Ttfxav tov

5

M^Tijp

Kai a^eX(f>oi ovroi elaiv
"^^jpeiav

tov Xoyov
aKor]

tou Seov aKOvovTeg Kat

'iroiovvTeg'

yap eyei

ep-

yaaiag.

KE^. Kr.
Ilept TTJs emTinTjirtcas rciv v8dra>v.

20
ayioig AiroXifLvyjV

22

Ktpiaaot i^AESANAPEiAS.
(TToXotg

AieirXei

ofxov Toig
y]Tot

"KpKTTog T^v Ti^eptd^a 6aXa(7(Tav,
(jKoui^ovg a^OKi^Tog
vi\)ov

eyyf

yepToi Se icaTa tou

T€ Kai

airy]vy]g

yeifxwvj Kat

Taig Twv avefJMV efJ.^oXaig

to KvfjiM KvpTovfLevov Kai to tov
T€6opvj3y]VTat

OavaTov ^eog eveTiQet Tatg
Tptag, KaiToi
aireipaTot.

ft,a9y]Ta7g'

yap

ov

ju,e-

25

to 6aXacr(xovpye7v el^OTeg, Kat

KXv^aivog ovk ovTog

eTreiVif]

^e Xonrov tov kiv^^vvov to fj.ey€6og Trpog a(f>opy]Tov

avTovg eKoXei ^etXiav, ag eTepav ovk e)(ovTeg toD aa^e(x6ai t^v
cAw/Sa,
irXyjv

oti

fxovov

avTOv tov
**

TaJv ^wafxecev

KvpioV

S^Aov Se

OTt yiptaTOv ^taviaToiai XeyovTeg,
KOii

eirtaTaTa, auiTov, airoXXvfj.e^a.
(f>y]atv.
fxv]

30

KaSev^yjaai

yap avTOv

KiiayyeXtaT-^g

oiKOvofi.tKU}TaTa
evQiig

8e

fji/>t

Kai TovTO Xtav TreTrpayPai toKel, iva
Toi

(xp^afievov
eiri-

Tov KXvOmog eTrnry^av
KovpiaVy

aKd(f>€tf t*;v irap'
y]^"!^

auTou ^i^TOvaiv
efJi,(f>av€aTepa

aXX

olov aKfi.daavTog

tov KaKov,

'yev»;-

K 2

68
Ta<
TVj^

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
QeoTTpeTTOvs

VIII. 25.
KaBicrTaoa

€^ov(Tiai

V}

^vva[ji.iif

fJiaivofi.(VV}v

QaXacaav Kai

fJ.€6i(JTaaa

npog yaXyjvyjv.
{jt.01

ToT
TO

ATTOT.

KvTovGa

jSAcTTe jtA6Ta via-Teag oXiyoiri<TTiav.

TTiaTevovai [xev

yap

oti

aaaai

"^vvaTai, co^ ^e oXiyoTTiaToi

Xeyovai
avv- 5

"

accaoVf aTroWvfxeBa'^^ ov

yap

ecpiKTOv

amXeiaOai

rroTe

ovTog

avToTs tov irdvTa layyovTOi.
6 TrdvTcov eycov tvjv e^ovaiav,

d\?C ey^epTai vapayji^fJia
Kai KaQiaTvjai [xev evBvg tov
Kat tov Sopv-

^piaTO^

Kkv^cova, avveaTeiXe
l3ov

^e

Tag Tav

'irvevftMTCOv opfJidg'

enavae, Kai

&;

avTccv e^ei^e twv TrpayfxdTCCVf oti
y)[x,ciov

Seog eaTi.
^eaTro^eii
i

XeyeaGci}

roivvv Ttap
Tyjg

to ev j3il3\oo tpa\[t,m'

" av

o

" Tov KpdTOvg

QaXdaafjif Kai tov aoKov rwv

KVfJiMTcay avTrjg

" av

KaTa^TTpavveigJ'

ToT
TTiaTig
TtdvTcog

ATTOT.

Q^aiiep 6

y^vaog

ev itvpt ^oKifxd^eTai, ovtco
6

Kai

v}

ev ttetpaafj.inq'
TTjg

7rA»;v

daQev^g

dvBpamv

voyc, ^e^Tai

&c
\

avcoBev %eipog

eig

to ^ieveyKeTv dv^peicog
YiCOTyjp

rd

iiape^x-

5

irnTTOVTa.
'^

Kai

tovto

y}[J.ag

eti^aaKev,

e/Vwv,

"

X(»>pig
ao(f>co-

efJ.ov

ov ^vvaa6e Troieh oy^ev*"

coft,oXoyei

^e tovto Kai

TaTog TlavKog XeycoVf
XpiaToo.

"

ori

itdvTa layvco ev

rw

ev^vvafj.ovvTi /Ae

25

'A^' ovv

ag ovk ei^OTeg to " Tig ovTog
iicog

earif*' Trapyjyopevov
'^Qiyjfj.d

aA-ao

X^Ao/f ;

eha

ovk aitiOavov TravTeXcog to
'li^aovv*

eariv

;

rj^eaav
^e

ydp ovTa 0eov, Kai Tiov Qeov rov
TVjg Ivovayjg
'bo^av,

KaTaTiXy^TTOfJ.evoi

avTW
Ka6

^vvdft.ecog ryjv virepPoXyjv,
yifJ.ag

Kai t^v

T^i^g

BeoTi^Tog

KaiTOi

ovti

t€ Kat

opcofxevco

KaTo. t^v adpKa,

Xeyovai to
'tvvdft.ei

"

Tig ovTog eartv" avTi tov iroaog Kai olog, Kai ev oayj 25

Kat e^ovaia, " oti Kai avTOig eTtndaaei ToTg v^aai Kai To7g

"

avefxoig, Kat vitaKovovaiv
y]

avTa'" eitiTaKTtKOV yap
otKi^TtK'^'

yjv

to epyov,

^eaTtoTtKy]

itpoaTa^tg Kat ovk d^icog

fj.eya Kai tovtq

Ttpog Gavfxa olg

Kat ovyjatv TOig

aKpocofi.evotg'

vitaKovet

yap

yj

KTtatg,

av eTttrdrTetv /BovXeTat 'K.ptaTog.
TpoTtov
ecpyi

dfxeXet

Kat tov
(pt^aiv

Ty}g

eitt-^o

Tift.y]g

ev

e^ovaia

6eo7tp€7tei

yevea6ai

6

MaT6d-

6aiog'

yap

etiteiv

Ty 6aXdaayj tov Kvptov, "

atcoTta, Ttecpiyj

"

fxooao" Kai afxa
yivcoaKei

t^

Xoyco yjKoXovdyjae to TtpdyfJ.a, Kat

Xaaaa
Tov

tov ditapyyjg avTyjv avvayayovTa, itpoaTayfj.aTt

6efj.evov dfj.fj.ov opiov

avT^, o ov^ vnep^yjaeTat.

35

VIII. 31.

AOTKAN EYArrEAIOY.
KE*. KA.
Tlfpi

69

Tov Afyfwvos.

27

'E^eA^OKTt 5e aim^ €7n

rrjv yrju v7rr}VTr](T€v avrcp avrjp

TLS €K Trj9 TToXecof, 0? ei;(€ SaifJLOVLa €K

^ovcov

LKavatv.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeia2. ^EvTavSd
Koi «Trovo/a
^y]XcoTiKOV
*'

[xoi

jSXeVe Bpdaei iroAAw 5
fi.ev

(TvixTreTrXifjyfxevrjv

^eiXiav'

^e7y[xa

yap

airovoiai

TO Tokfxrjaat XeyeiVf " t<
;"
el

efxoi

Kai aoif

Irjaov

T/e Toy

Seov Tov vipiaTOv

yap oilaf oXai ovra avTOv Tiov tov
oti

'Ti///c7T0u

Seov, 6[MXoye7s

Seog eaTiv ovpavov t€ Kat

yrjg

koi

TMV

ev avTo7g'

eha

irag to.

[xi]

aa, fj.dXXov Oe Ta avTOv ttap-nd- 10
tSov eiii

"Cfetq^

eha

Xeyetg, " Tt e/Aci Kat aot ;" Kat Ttg dve^erai
VTto

Tifji

^aatXeiag fxeypt "navTog dve7vai ^ap^dp^ Tovg
Tag
avTcii

aKvptTpa

KetfJievovgf

Se rrpeitovaag epevyeaOaf
fxrj [xe

cpoovdg.

avrai

M

eiai

TO

*'

'teofx.at

aov

(Saaaviavjg'" itapyiyyetXe yap," e0>;,

"

TO} TTvevfjLaTt e^eX$e7v dito

tov dvBpwiiovr

AOpei ^e
<f>r][Jii

fxoi irdXtv 15

Tvjv

aTrapd^XYiTov to^av tov ndvTa layyoVTog,

^rj

'K.piaTOv
fxovov

Tvjv

dKaToyavtaTOV layvv^ avvTpi^ei tov SaTavav, eSeXyjaag

TovTO 7raSe7v avTOV rtvp avTW Kai (pXoyeg etat t» tou Kptarov
poJjtAaTa.

AXvjQeg ovv OTt, KaSd (pvjatv 6 [laKdpiog xpaXfi.a)^og
opeai

" Ta
yap 20
'^yj'

"

opvj

erdKvjaav aaei Kvjpog arro Trpoawnov tov ©eoi)*"

Tag

vy^niXdg kcu virept^tpdvovg irapeiKd^^et

^vvdft.etg, rrovYiptag
vjfXiov

XovoTt, TrXvjv
fxet

wg

irvp)

irpoa^aXXovaag t^ tov "^wTvjpog
^ikvjv.

tvvd-

T€ Kat e^ovataf KaTaT-^KovTai KVjpov

31

ToT ArioT TiTOT BosTPCN.
rjfJMg, fxvjte

'Qcave/

eAe^ye,

fxvj

drroTrefxy^g

elg ro CKOTog to

e^ooTepov to vfrotfxaafxevov
erret

ra

^ia- 25
iroTe

jSoAco

Kat

Totg

'AyyeXotg

avTOv'

TOtvvv

othaaiVf

gti

Trefxc^YjaovTat, dveaiv irpog Katpov
aa<f>S>g

ahovatVf ofxoXoyovvTeg

oviXaQvi

OTt

eav eirtTd^rjf aTreXevacovTat.

ware

K.vptog

to fxev

eirtrd^at avTo7g ovk eiaaev, avveyapviae Se

avTOvg eivat

ev Tvj

y^

TavTvi kcog

orre

Kai tov ^tdjSoXov, rrpog yvfxvaatav twv dvSpamaV 30
vj

rov ydp dvTiirdXov
<f>avov.

drrovaia tou vtKvjTov d<patpe7Tat tov aTeirovvjpevovTatf 6 ^e dyuvoQeTv^g
01

AvTot

fxev

ydp

aTe(f>avov
ei

TrpoTtde7 To7g vtKwat.

irapeKdXovv

^atfxoveg tov Kvpiov.

KaTa

70

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
vjcrav ^vo,

VIII. 41.
irapeKdXovv

Tovg alpiTiKovg ap^/ou
Tov Kvpiov, e/

ovk av

01

^atfxoves

fx)} Yj(Tav '^vjfjitovpyi^fJi.a [xev

tov 0eoy, ag Se d[xap^vjfAt'

T^^aavTig d7rof3€PXy]fx.evoi.

/SAeVe TOtvvv tvjv oiKCtOTi^Ta tvjs

ovpyiag Kat T^g dfjiapTia^; tov eXeyyov, y^fxag yap ovjfxtovpyta
Tov
'^ea-TTOTvjVf 01

viro

^e dfi/xpTavovTeg vtto tov KptTVjv itapaKaKoixyi Kat 5

ofxoXoyova-t t^v e^ova-iav.

ToT
yap
Tov, iva
TCtiv

ATTOT. Kadapa ^ KaBapa^tg, dvavTtppyjTog

r}

BepaTteta, ovtci)

evvjxpev 6 iida^/jijv
17

coaTe eiityvmat tov HaTvipa Kai a^tovv avt>;v v7roaTpo<pvjv

avv avTco' Tdy^a Se Kat evXa^ovfxevog
^e Kvptog tva
fj^q

^atfxovoov.

^o^v} "^ta TVjg itapova-tag

<pvKaT- 10

re^v,

Tiapm yap Kat ditwv <f)v\daaet ovg ^ovKeTat, aiieXvaev av-

Tov, eiTrav,
ttvjyov
''

"

v7roaTpe(f>e eig tov oikov" Kat fxvi^fxoveve Tvjg evepyeiag,

TO

Gavfxa,
6

tva ^efBataa^ffg

t^v ydptv, "

'^tvjyov

oaa aoi

eTroivjaev

0eo?*" ov ^eyet, eya Tvirog vfxh Ta7retvo<ppoavvv]g
dvaTtefXTtet eig

yevofxevog, dW

UaTepa,

ov avTog Ttotei to Qavfxa.
vj^ei

15

BiKTOPos nPESBTTEPOT. 0eov dpa
tatfxovm a7taWayetg KVjpvaacov
ei7twv

tov

Ivjo-oDv,

Kat

tZv

oaa

e^totvjaev

avTW

Ivjaovg,

avTW,

*'

'^tvjyov

oaa

aot e7toiv]aev 6 Qeog'^'

dWcog

Se ov Ttapa-

(3atvei Tov vofxov, b

yap evepyei

Tiog, evepyei

6 TlaT^^p.

KE4>. KE.
Ilept T^f

20

dvyaTpos tov dpxKTVvayayyov.

4^

Kai

iSov rjXOev dvr/p

(p

ovojjlol

'Ideipo^.

Toi ArioT TiTOT BosTPON. To
taiovg Tovg ei^oTag ro

ovofLa

Kehai

ha

Tovg

lov»

yeyovog, tva yevvjTai to ovofxa a^toQet^tg
TVjg

TOv QavfxaTog, Kat ovTog dpyav
viXBe Ttg

avvaywyvjg
e'i6e

tcSv

lov^^atm, oy/c 25

Twv evTeXwv, ov^e twv TV/pvTWV'
tt

fxev ovv

Ttpovka^e,
fxvi

Kat §;a TtiaTtv Ttpoaeneae, kou

evyvoifxoavv^v hteyvw,

tta

y^etav TtapeyeveTo.
Ofxug OXtxptg eaS

'H yap y^eia

^ta(3d\\et

tvjv

TtapdKXvjatv,

OTe KaTa^td^eTat Ttpog to eXeaBat tpav

Ta

avTta

'^vjatfxa Kat avfX(f>epovTa.

TavTVj TOt Kai

fxaKdptog

e(f>v}

Aa^t'^, 30

"

ev Kvjfx^

Kat xaXtv'2 Tag atayovag avTwv dy^etg, twv
ae.

fxvj

eyyi-

^ovTCiJV Ttpog

VIII. 43-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
KE$. Kr.
Uepi
TTJs

71

aifjioppov(rT]i.

45

'Eh 'ANEnirPA*OT.
[J1.0VYJV

Upoa-eia-i

yvvv}

KaXSog Kat

olKtiaog
t>jv

r^v

iKavriv d(f>op[J.7}v eig

to laSvjvai iiapaaKivaaaaa

Triariv.

" Ylpoa-eXQovaa^
**

y"-?* (p^^^iv,

"

ontadev, vjxpaTo tov KpaaTie^ov tov 5

ifxaTiov avTOVf^ ^i^Xa^Yj ireTrta-TevKvTa

fxeyd^ai, ovTcog ag Kat
^tvj-

^ta T^f (Traiprig TTiaTevaat tyjv laatv.

Aeyet ^e avTcP Kat
(pvjatVf

yeiTat

MdpKog
t(MaTi(i}v

KvayyeXia-T-^g'

*'

eXeye yap,
Kat
ei

"

OTt

Kav

" Twv
*'
vj

avTov

arpoofJLat, a-aO-^a-ofxati

Trapay^jpyjfxa

eaTYj

pvatg Tov at[xaTog
(pcoTt

avT^i^g.
vj

Q.airep

yap

Ttpoaaydyot Ttg 10
vXvjv

0(f)GaX[AOV

XdfiTrovTt

irvpt (f)XeyovTt

tvjv iie^f^vKvtav

e^dTrrea^at, afxa t6 iipoaYiyaye, Kat to T^g evepyeiag
0(fiGaXfJ,6g

TreTrk-rjpctiTai,

Te

yap, afka to itpog

(f)cog

aTrt^eTv

e(f>c>}Tta6y},

Kat to

Tre(f>vKog

viro^eyeaGat Trpog evepyetav afxa to TrXvjaiaaai (f)XeyeTai,
TrtaTCog ecftaxpafJievv} tov KpaaTre^ov tov lfJ.aTiov avTov, t^s" 15

ovTcag

7}

idaecog eTv^ev, ovk rfpoyfif} t\ to Trapdoo^ov.

'Eh ANEnirPA*oT. OvK
ipaa6ai avTov
Trvevfj.ariKcog
acofi.aTtKcog
Trotyj'

y]v

to5

Kvpio) irXi^ataaat Kat
e(f)aTrTOfj.evov,
y]

e(f)det
ft.v]

vXyjatd^ovTa Kai

tovto

eTfj^e Totvvv ovirep eyjpyit^ev
otptv

yvvyj.

Ato
20

Kat ^yjTei rovg vno tov l^vpiov, Kai eg

KaXeirat
Ty}v

tcov ft.a6y}Twv

ovK ei^OTiov TO

^y}Tovfj.evov,

dXX

dirX-^v
01

Ttva

eiracpy^v otofJ.€vci)v
e(f)y}TrT0VT0.

Xeyetv tov Kvpiov, Kat ToiavTy}v oiav
'^toirep

Xotiroi iravTeg
fJ.ov

Kvptog ^iaaTeXXcov " y]\paTO
e-)(cov

t/?,"

(f)y}atv,

coanep
aco-

KOt eXeyev, 6

coTa aKovetv, aKoveTCO, KatTOt
[J-eyjpt

TrdvTcov Ty}v

[xaTtK^v TavTy}v eypvTCov aKO-^V Kat

^e

r\>tXy}g T-^g tcov
y}V

Xoycov 25

aKpodaecog aKovovTCov dirdvTcav,
erw, ovTe airTeaBai

aXX

ovTe aKovetv

tw

[xy]

avv-

tw

[j.y}

TrtaTCfi.

T<

ovv

;

elg oxptv avTi^v KaXei,

Kat Tovg lepovg
Oeag d^ia Ttapa
eTrtbei^tcog, OTt

o(f>6aXfi.ovg
t<S

eiraipei

ireptaKoncov ty^v yvvouKa, OTt
etg

Kvpia' d^ia ^e Kat T^g
irtaTecog

Tovg irapovTag
Kat 30

irapd^etyfj.a

irdatv y]fi.eXXev eaeadat

irapaKXyjaig

eir) TriaTtv,

S/a tov "^oBy^aofxevov avTvj ^tKaicog eiratvov. YlpoTepov fxev ovk eToXfxa
'irep)

'Eh ANEnirPA*oT.
dvTtKpvg
diravrav,

^t

evXd^etav
^e

Ka)

Sepaireiag

d^iovv,

^v]TovfJ.evy}

^ Sic.

Leg.

Tot/To.

72
KTtavTa TtpiTTovrag,

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
€[ji(f)c^os

VIII. 49.

re Kai evXa0^g Kat to aePat; apOfXoXoyiav T^f ida-eoog

jtxoTTcv 7rpoa<pepov(ra'
TtatTi

Kai

tvjv

ng

e[X(f)av€S

noienai, ov

tSi iidvra ei^orif

aWa

To7g ayvoovcriv, aiad-^aet

T>jv
*'

laaiv eTreyvcoKvia.
(Tcofxarif ort

Aeyei yap Kat rovro

'M.dpKog " ort eyvio
rvjg
eTia^fy/jg

ra

tarai «Tro T^f ^dartyog.^^ ^v t Ik

5

eXaf3e BepanetaVf ravryjv Kai ^/a Toy Xoyov e^e^at(aaev
efTrccv,

Sa)T>y/>

"

TTopevov ev

elp-fjvri,

Kat

'laQt

vytyjg diio ri^g [xd(XTtyog croy,"

Kat vytatve •nparov

ryj "Trtaret rvjv tpv^^^^v'

eira ^e Kat ro a^fxa.

49

Ktl avTOv XaXovuTOS ep^^Tai
aycoyov.

tl9 irapa tov ap^^^Lavv10

TiTOT BosTPfiN.

Iva yap
ri^ri

[J.y]

etTtri

Kat avrog, eTitayegi ov

yj^eiav (xov ej^w, Kvp/e,

yeyove ro irepagf aTteOaveVf ^v irpoaeyjv,

OOKWfxev vyiaivetv aTrtarog
vei

yap

'lovSai/cov e)(cov (ppovyjfxa, <p6d'
r^t^g

Kvptog Kat

(pYjat,

}j.ri

<pol3ov, Travaov

aTitartag
rvjv

ra

p-fj-

[xara, eTcta-yeg rrjv y\Sorrav, [xovov Tttareve

Kara

yvva^Ka, ^v 15

yap

avrvj

KaSdvep

•jrpootti.tov ryjg

[xekkovavjg Bav[xaTOvpyiag.
irept
t>jv

Eb ANEnirPA*oT.
arag' rav

ABopvjSag

ryjXtKavryjv Trdpeart

^vvafxiv, ovK oj^Aov eirapo^xevog,

aAA' oaov

otov

re tov o^/kov d<ptrao Se oj^Aco
t»/v

[xev [xaByirav [xovovg rpeig

av^xiiapaXa^hv,
ro
[xrj

7rpo(paatv ava^^cop-^aewg
Kopyjv,

TrpoPdXXoov,

reOvdvat (pdvat

20

aXXa

KaQev^etv. 7rpoaKaXead[*.evog ^e fxovovg Ik Trdvrcov roiig

yoveig, ovrta t^v Kopi^v

KaBdnep KaGev^ovaav dvtaryjatv, dXi^6eg
oitep
t>jv

rij

6av[xarovpyta Trot^aag ro Ka6ev^etv avrriv'

avev rvjg dvor-

ardaecog ovk dv

'^v

dXyj6eg.

AiOTrep

01

[xev

avdaraatv ov
av- 25

TTpoa^oKSovreg KareyeXoov, Ka6ev^eiv aKovovreg t*;v r(6vyjKviav'

TOf ^e Kard t^v a:;Tov ^vva[xtv dXi^6eg ro
51

elprj[xevov aTre^et^ev.

Ort rwv aXXcov

ovrot

yjaav VTtepeypvveg, Kai
rrjv vnepoy^-^v' ryjg

[xev IleT^oj"

eK Ik
yj

rov a(po^pa (ptXetv avrov e^yjXov

^e

lcodvvyjg

rov a(po^pa (ptXeTa6at, Kat ^ldKoo/Sog Se aTro
aTreKpivaro Xeycov, ^vvd[xe6a
irteTv

aTtoKpiaeoog,

ro TtoT^ptov'

ovk dno ryjg diro- ^o

Kpiaewg ^e
cov

[xovov,

dXXd

Kat diio rav epyoov, rcov re dXXcov Kai d(p

ewXyjpcoaev,
cag

aTiep

eliiev.

Ovroo ydp

rjv

a(pohpog

Kat

^apvg

'lov^atotg,

Ka) rov 'Hpco^i^ ravryjv ^copeav [xeyiary^v vo[xtaat
^lov^^aiotg, ei eKe7vov dveXot^.
siint.

yapiaaa^at ro7g
c

Haec Chrys.

Cf. Cat. ad S.

Matth.

p. 134.

IX.

I.

AOTKAN EYArrEAIOT.
KE^. KZ.

73

I

^vYKaXeaa/ievos^
eScoKeu

Se

tovs
koll

ScoBeKa

fiaOryras

avrov,
tol

avTOLS

Bvva^Lv

e^ovalav

hri

iravTa

SaL/jLovLa kou

voaovs OepajreveLV.
'AXrjQe^
eiTre^v

5
ori

KtpiAaot 'Aaehanapeias.
Ka^Ttoq
^vKX^r^q'

Ttovm arfabm

Toli

yap

roi t>jv Tcdvayvov

Kai ajSe/SijXov,
?a'^i',

Kard

ye ro

dvQpccTroig eyya>povv,

KaropQovv eSeXovrag

ro7i irap eav-

rov yapiafiaai Karatpai^pvvei X.pi(Trog, Kai nXovaiav <ivro7g dyivjrpeirSoi

yapi^erai
Koivcovovg.

t^j»

dvreKr-qaiv, Kai

^o^i^s

avrov

Tijf

/§/«$•

10

KaOiarrja-i

^e^^ow rov

irpdyfjiarog

dTro^et^iv

cacpyj

re

Koi evepy^ rovg dyiovg ATroaroXovg'

opa yeyovorag eKirpeTreard-

rovg, Kai ryj virep dvQpwTrov ^o^vj KarearefXfxevovg, [/.evovrog avroTg

faera toov

dXXuv Kai rovro yipiarov.

Ae^uKe yap avroTg,
taifj.ovta

(f^i/jo-i,

"
**

^vvafAiv Kat e^ovaiav eiri Trdvra
irevetVf^

ra

Kat voaovg 6epa- ic

aAX' opa irdKiv rov evavSpooir^aavra rov Qeov Aoyov, ro
vTreprpeyovra fxerpov, Kat roTg
eTreKeiva

ryjg

dvSpwTrorvjTog

r^g BeOrYjrog
ft.e-

d^icofLaat '^iaTrpeirovra'
rpcov ro

yap rwv r^g

avdpaTrorrjrog

h^ovat Kard Trvevfkdrm dKaOdprav, oig av ^ov\y]rat
Kat
fJir]V

tvjv

€^ov(Tiav'

Kai ro ^vvaaOat voavjfJidrav ekevdepovv rovg 20

€vet\y]fi.fi.evovg

Kat fLovov Qeov.
"^t^aaKaXta
ort

H

yap

ri^g

avararco

(f>vaecog

VTrepoy^-^

re

koI

Kat

^o^yj

ovOevt

rav ovrav

eveart
07

<f>vatKag, Trkyjv

avrw re Kat

fkovw.

a^ta rotvvv 6avfi.arog
Se

Tor^ dytotg Airoarokotg eKvefi.yj6e7aa %dptg, eireKetva

eTratvov
e(f>i^v,

Kat 6avfuarog

y}

rov

vefj.ovrog a(f)6ovta'

ryjv

eavrov yap,
Trvevfxdrcov

cof

25

eyapi^ero
TTovyjpcov,

^o^av

dv6pxirog

e^ovaiav

Kard

^e^xerai
(p^fifiviv

Kai

ryjv ovrcog

xmepoTrrov o(f>pvv t>jv toD ^taj3o\ov

Karaarpe(f>et, Kai rot Xeyovra irore

"

t»;v eiKovfJievi^v o\y]v

karadpco,

" "

X-^Ofjiou

r^

%€//?/

«f voaaiav, Kat wg
fj.e,
r}

KaraXeXetfj.fj.eva

wd

Kai ovK eartv og Ota(pev^erat

avrenry}

fnot.

ea^paXXero ^o

^e ryjg dXyj6eiag Kat hy]fi.dpry]Ke r^g eXirt^og

aojSapog Kat 6pa-

avg, Kat ryfg dirdvTCov da6evetag KaraKavycofj.evog.

Avrtrd^erai
rcov ^wdfJiecov

ydp avrS) rovg

roov lepcov KyjpvyftMrcov lepovpyovg,
I.

74

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
xm ayim

IX.
7rpo<f>v)T<ov

12.

Kvpto^f Koi rovTQ ^v apa ro ^/ evo^
Kvjpvyfxevov, itepi re. tov

vpoKe-

Sarava
01

Kai t«v ayiav ixvaTayayyZv, ort
01

" "

e^ai(f)vy]s

a.vadTVjcrovrai

^aKvovTef avTOV' Kai cKv^xpovaiv
^iapnayyjv avrolg'^^ fxovov
liri^ovXevovTig avTOv
tyj

€Tri(3ovkoi (ToVy Kai eavj
t)>v

elg

yap ovyi
^o^v],

KaT^i^oKaai

'ZaTavav,
to, aKevyj,

Kai 5
Qia

oiapvd^ovTei avTov

kou npoaKOfxi^ovTeg

too

Xp^CTW

itKTTiwg TVji eif avrov.

KE^. KH.
Hepi
rSiv t

aprav Koi

roiv

j3'

i\Qva>v.

12

TipoaeXOovres Se

ol

SooSeKa ehrov avrcp, airoXvaov 10

Tov

o-)(Xov.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaebanapeias. Ka) t/
Taaeoixev aKpijSooi.
"TrvevfxaTav
01

to " aTtoXvaov^ eaTiv, e^eevofJievav

/xev, cag e(f>i^v, tSov

avTf

itovvjpm
01

avve^^ovTm avrovg anakXdTTeaBai TcapeKdXovv,
dppoi3aTV][j.dTccv

Se

Kai eTepcov
[j.a6vjTai

e^^^Tovv

dno&eaiv.

atg

ovv

el^OTcg 0/15

QTi

KaTavevaag

fxovcv aTiOTiepaivei ToHg Kdfxvovai ro ttq<j)aai,

Bovfxevov, TO

" dvokvaov avrovg"

Kat cvk avroi fxakkov aKti-

Otmreg ig TtapaKfxdaavrog rov Katpov,

dWa

ryjg eig

rovg oj^Aovf

aydiryjg eypfxevoi, Kat oiov fxeXeroovreg ^§»7 T»yv TrotfxeviKyjv eTrtaryjfXYiv

Kat rov KVj^eaGat Aa»v dpypfxevot.

20
tva ^e Kat eni fxei^o) etg

ToT

ATTOT.

" ^araKXlvare
rpeyyf, Ka\

avrovg'^^

vrpog To irpayfxa

%eog

oov <f>vaei

^ta Tponov vavrog

eirtyivioaKyjrat, TroXvTrXaatd^et ro ^payfy.
oiov ryjv dvcodev

BAeTre/ t€ etg ovpavov,
^t

evXoyiav aiTm. e^pa ^e koi tovto

vjfxdg oikovo-

fXtKwg.

earoo fxev

yap avrog

itdvra TrXyjpwv,

y)

avooBev Kat itapa 25

W.arpog evkoyta' iva ^e

fxdOoofKev y][xe7g, ort

rpane^yjg dpypfxevoi

Kat fxehXovreg dprovg ^iaKXav,

0e»

itpoadyeiv o(f>eiXofxev vitrtatg
eit

(oanep evQevreg '/epat, Kat t*^v dvco6ev evXoytav
<f>epetv,

avrov Karayjfx7v

dpyyj Kat rvitog Kat

o^og rov

Ttpdyfxarog yeyovev

otKovofxtKcog.

eira

OTtot

nore

itpoe^y]

ro Bavfxa'

KareKopea6vj TtXyj- 30

6vg dv^^pm qvk oXiym, eig Ttevre

ydp e^eretvero ytXid^ag yapig
rtg

yvvatKm Kai itathm' rovro yap erepog
rotf eavTOv itpocryivtyKe Xoyotg' Kai ov

rm EvayyeXtarm
rovrov ro Ttapd^o^ov,

fJ-^yjpi

IX.

i8.

AOYKAN EYArrEAIOY.
KO(f>tvoi

75
Kai ti to
irXoV'

aWa

yap kou

avveXeyi^aav KXaa-fxaTwv SwJeAca*

evT€v6ev;

ir\rjpo(f>opia aa(f>vii, oti

T^f

<pt\o^eviag to

XPVf^

ciav eyet Ttapa Qeov t^v

avTeKTif]<xtv.

K^eaTi Se Kat

i^eiv to7s

apy^aioTepotg Gav[ma-i toc vea avf^^atvovja, Kai fAtSii ovra Kai Tfji
avT-Tjg

^vvafAeas evepy^fxaTa.

ej3pe^ev ev ep^^fxca tq [xavva

Toig e?5

lapayjX'
Spayiroi
epyifJi.(o

apTov ovpavov e^ccKev avToH?, apTov

AyyeXm

ecpayev avTiaXtv ev

KaTa to

cv il^aKfx.olg

vix,vov[JLevov'

aAX' i^ov

^rj

Tolg ev ev^eia Tpocf^i^g Ke^j^wpyjy^Kev acf^Bovwgf olov e| ovpavov

Kadietg avT-^V to
fjLrj^evog
Toi)

yap TroXvnXaatdaat to ^payy, Kai
irXviSvv,

olov

eK tov
eivj

t^v ovtco noWyjv aTroOpexpai

ovk aiteotKog av

lo

TrpaTco arifxeta}.

KE<E>.
nept
TTjs

KB.

Tov Kvpiov eTrepoDTTjatm.

i8

Kat iyeuero

iv

r^

iivaL

avrov Trpoaevxofievov Karakcll

fwvas, arvvrjcrav avra ol fiaOrjTcu,
TOVS>

iTrepooTrjcrev

av-

15

ToT
Vfxe7g

ATTOT. 'Opag to

Trjg
;

irevaeag evTeyyeg
d7ro<f>epet

;

ovk evOvg
eTri

etirev,

Tiva fxe XeyeTe eivai
tv

te

fxaWov

tov tZv

e^wdev BpvXkov,
aofS-^arj

eK^akav avTOv Kai
^o^av
fi.ev

d^oKtfxov dirocf^-^vagf fxeTa-

Xotirov elg

dXrj6ivr]v,

^rj

Kai ireTrpaKTat. eiTrovTWV 20

yap Twv

fxaBriTav, 01

ladvvriv tov ^airTiaT^Vy dXXoi ^e

HA/av,
avToTg,
eqo)

akkot &e OTt
vft,etg

7rpo(f)vfrri(;

Ttg twv
;

dpyaim

dveaTrif

etirev
'*

Oe Ttva fxe XeyeTe eivai

wairep eqatpeTov to

vfxeig

Ttdrjatv

avTovg twv aAXwv, iva Kai Tag eKeivwv
fxtKpav e^coat
irept aiiTOv
"''^

<f>vya>atv virovoiag,

Kat

fxrj

Tr^v

^o^aV

vfxe7g, (f>r]aiv, 01

€^-25

etXeyfxevotf ot ^''^'P^
T(ov

""^P

e/xoy KeKXrjfnevoi irpog aTroaToXrp^ 01
;

efxav TepaTovpyrjfxaTcov fxdpTvpeg, Tiva fxe eivat (f>aTe

Trpo-

Tryj^S.

§c vdXtv twv

dXXm

TleTpog, Kai TravTog Toy xopov yiverat
^'

aTOfxa, Kai Tovg (piXoOeovg epevyeTat

(fmvrjv dKpt^rf Se Trjg etg

av-

Tov triaTecog
aa(f>aXrjg
eivou Tov
6

tvjv

ofxoXoyiav eK(pepet Xeycov
ov

"

tov "KptaTOV tov Seov."
dirXcog

^o

fxaSvjTrjgf

ydp

toi

(prjatv

X.ptaTOV avTOV

Qeov, tov 'KpiaTov ^e fxdXXov.
^ Leg. vid. Koi

YlXe7aT0t fxev yap ol w$

T)]v (piXiOeov ip. «puvriv, iucf.

76
ama
•vav

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
KiyifilaBai
'^

IX.

26.

Trapa

Seov KaTo. tiacpopovi
ey^^iaOvjaav elg

rpoTtovg wvofxa01

cfJievoi

^(jpiaroi'

ol [Aev

yap

^aaiXeai,

^e

eig

vpotfyi^Tag, 01 ^e Kai T»?y S*'

avrov

irdvrcov "^ixaiv "Earvjpos 'KpiaTov

XaPovres Xvrpaaiv, rovTeariv
KaTaKey£iafj.evoif
rrjv

yjfJi.eTs,

Kai

tm 'Ay/w

TIvevjJLari

rov

^piarov

KX^aiv

eayj^Kafxev.

oikovv 5

"TrXetaroi [xev 01 y^piarot' KeKki^vrai ^e

ovrag d-no rov irpdyfxaros.
"yjfxav

eli ^e

Kai [xovog

6

rov Seov

Kcti

YiarpoSf oyp^ ag
rivog,

[xev ovrcov

y(j>taTwv Kai ov

&eov [xaXkov, akk erepov
e-)(ovrog

dX\ wg avrov
AvjXov ovv

Kai [xovov i^iov
eari rrji

Ylarepa rov

ev ro7g

ovpavoTg.

erepm
[xovov

itXrjGvog

vcpe^aipoiv avrov, irpovevefxvjKe

rx Tiarpi 10

wg ovra

avrov.

©eof yap

m

<f>vaetf

Kat Ik &eov Ylarpog

dva\d[xxpag dTropp^^Toog,

6 [xovoyevrjg

avrov " Aoyog yeyove aap^^^

Kara ro
2,6

yeypafxfxevov,

O9 yap

av

liraicryyvOrf

/Lte

kcli

tovs ifiovy Xoyov^,

rovTov 6 vlo9 avOpmrov

iiraLa-)(yvOr]a€TaL.

Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias.
yjpyjatfxd

rioAAa Kara ravrov epyd^erat

re Kat dvayKoia

"^ta

rovrm

rm

Xoycov.

TrpSorov

fxev

^etKVvaiv ort Trdvry] re Kat Trdvroog experat ro7g ala^Qjvofxevotg av-

rov Kat rovg aiirov Xoyovg ro rav 'laav rvyeiv.
Tovrco ro laoararovv etg tvvafxtv eii6vft.iag
T^vof l Kptrvjg,
(cg
;

T/

^'

av yevotro

el

yap htatayvverat 20
evJretOeiag fxiaOov,

eirocpeiXav avroig

rov rrjg

Kat

rvjg etg

avrov ayditvig ra epya, Kat rov r^g ewoiag arecpavov,
Tidvrrj
01

vSig ovK eartv dvafi.(f)tXoycog enreTv, ort

re Kat iidvTag ev

areXevT^rotg eaovrat rtfxaig re Kat ^o^atg
rervyyiKoreg

rm

ovroo

Xafxitpm

dyaBm

;

etra irpog rovrotg (f)O0ov avroig evrtKret, 25
e^ ovpavov, ovk ev afxtKpoTipe-neia
rri
Trpcorv]

Kara^yjaeaBat
Kat

Xeym

v(f)eaet ryjg Kaff yjfxdg,

dXX

ev ^o^rj

ryj

rov YlaTpog, ^opvcpo-

povvrm ^AyyeXm. ovkovv icayydXeTtov kou oXeSpov fxearov^ ro
KarayvcoaS^vat
fxev eiit tetXta

re Kai d(f>tXepyta, Kara^otT-^aavrog
TteptearyjKOTCOv.

avcoSev rov Kptrov Kat

dyyeXiKwv rayfxdrm

fxeyao^o

^e Koi Tiavrog Oavfxarog d^iov Kai ryjg eig X^^iv ev^fxepiag irpo^evov,

TO evt roTg

rl^y} TtpoTteTio^yifxevotg

yaipetv avrovg, Kai ro vpoaot

doKJiv

rm

t^pcorm rag dfxoi^dg' enaiveOyjaovrat yap

roiovrot,

c Ktxi>^<T6»i

Cod.

^ Cod. oXe%jt*£(rTov.

IX.

a;.
AeyovTOf ,

AOTKAN ETAITEAIOT.
" ^evTe
oi

77

Xj9/<7Toi)
**

evXoyyjfxevoi tov YlaTpog fxov, K\r]-

povoixvjaaTe TVjv

v]TOi[xa<T[ji.€v/jv vfxiv

^acnkeiav

aiio

AcaTa/SoA^

"

KoniKov.

KE4>. A.
Ilfpi T^s fjLeraiiofXpaxreays.

5
ec^x^^KOTag
Toi/f

27

ToT
veiaig^

ATTOT.
eiKog
ti

Oi/7ra>
rjv

T^v

c|

w^ou?

^vvafxiv

fiaOrjTaSf

Taya

itov
irepi

Kai avSpioiTivaig TrepnreaeTv aaOe-

Kai

toiovtov
yj

avTOvg

evvevoy}KOTag

emeiv,

Tiwg

apv^aeTai Tig eavTOv,
TiaXiv

Trag airoXeaag tvjv eayTov ipv^yjv evpriaei

avTVjV
17

;

t/

^e

Tor^

toDto

TraBovTi

to laoaTaTovv
;

eaTai 10

yepagy

Kai itoim eaTai yapiTfi.aTm fxeToypg

\va toivvv

Tm

ToiovTm

avTOvg

airoa-T-^ayj
ecro[xevyjg
**

Xoyi(T[j.m,

Kat

otov

fxeTayaXKevayi

irpog evav^ptav
*'

t^<,-

avToTg evKXetag

eTTtdvfi.tav

evTeKm,
ot

Ae^yft)
[x-y}

^e v[/.iv"

cf)yjatv,

eiat Ttveg

twv avTov eaTyjKOTm,
t>;v

ov

"

yevamrat

QavaTov, eag av t^coai
(pyjatv

^aatXetav tov ©eoD." 15
17

^aatXetav te Qeov
avTog
eiit

avTvjv t^v

6eav Tyjg ^o^yjg, ev
ov

Kat
ToTg

o(f)GyjaeTat

Kar eKeho tov Katpov, Ka6 yap
ev
^o^yj
ty]

av

e7rtXa[i.ily]

Tyjg yyjg.

yj^et

tov Seov Kat UaTpog, Kat ovk

ev

ye [laXXov a[KtKpoTrpeTieta

KaB

yi[/.ag.

Trwg ovv
;

apa Seapovg
aveiaiv
eiri

eTToieiTO

Tov Bav[mTog rovg Xa^ovrag

tvjv

viioay^eatv

20

to opogt Tpeig ai:
rerat
irpog

avrm
Tyj

rovg airoXeKTOvg ep^wv,
BeoTrpeTiyj

eha

[KeTaitXaT-

e^atperov riva Kat

Xa[XTrpoTy)ra, uiare

Kai

rov i[karia[t.ov

avrov

rov (poiTog Tipoa^oXyi^^taXafJ.xpat, Kat
eira Moji/V^? Kat }rlXtag TrepiearyjKoreg
**

oaov aTTaarpdxpat hoKeiV

Tov Irjaovv •npoaeXdXovv dXX-^Xotg
**

t>/v

e^otov avTov ^v e[x,eXXe 25
[/.era
eTit

irXrjpovv"

(f^yjatv^

**

ev

lepovaaXyjf/.,'^

rovreaTt r^g

aapKog
(f>y][Jii,

otKovo[i.tag

ro [Lvar-^ptov Kat ro

awrriptov irdBog ro
6

ye,

rw

Tt[/.rj)

aravpw.

Kat yap eartv dXyjBeg ort KOf
irpo(pyjrm
rinrotg
01

^ta MsouVecof
[t.vaTy]ptov

vo[i.og

Kai Tcov

aytm
[xev

Xoyog ro Kptarov

Trpoavetei^av,
irtvaKt

ev

Ka) aKtalg, [kovovov-^i KaBdirep ev^o
he TroXvrpoTrag irpoyjyopevKoreg, wg
"^ftMg,

KaTaypd(pci}v

avro'

Kat o(f)Byjaerat Kara Kaipovg ev ettet r^g KaB

Kat ort rvjg

diravrm eveKa
eirt

acoTTjptag Kat
yj

^w^f ov irapair-^aerai ro TraBeh rov

^vXov Bdvarov. ovkovv

^wvaewg

Kat 'Ha/ov Trapdaraatg

te

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA

IX.

37.

Koi TO TrpoXa^eTv aWrjKoii avTov$, otKovoixia rtg ^v, ew fJLaka
Kara^ciKVvova-a
K.vpiov
v]fii.wv

^opv(f)of>ovfJievov

jotev

viro

vofAov Kai vpo(f)i^Twv rov

^lyjaovv

^piarov,

ax;

Kai
ti

vofi.ov

Kai

TrpocpvjTCOv ^eaTto-

rvjV

'Jtpo^ei')(PevTa ^e iiap

avrav

o)V

aXX-qXoig avvwta TrpoeK"^-

pv^av.

aW

01

fnev fxaKoipioi fKa6r)Tai

Ppayy nag
yipiaTOv.

aTrovvcrrd^ovatv S
'ETrAi^poyv
Oecopoi

wg

rij

irpoaev^^rj

ayoXd^ovTog

rov

yap

oiKovoft.iKZg
ryjg

Ta

dvBpoontva'

eira ^iaypyjyopovvregf

yeyovaai
'tacog

ovr^a

aeirrYig kui

irapo^o^ov fi.eTa(BoXyjg.

oivjQetg

^e

Seaireaiog Ylerpog ort

Tdya
fj.ev

trov evearfiKev

Katpog TYjg Paatkeiag

rov Seovy diroteyeTat
rpetg ^e? yeveaSat,
MciJvo-^ Ka)

rag

ev

tw

opet

^tarpt^ag, aKvjvag Se 10

(f^vjat,

tw ILptar^

fuev fxtav,

rag erepag ^e

HA/a*

dW

ovk

"j^^et, (pyjaiv,

Xeyet, ov

yap

rjv

Kat-

pog TYjg avvreXeiag rov aiSovog, ovre

fj.y)v

rov y^ovov Xa^elv rovg
tvjv ft.e6€^tv.

dyiovg

ryjg eTr^yyeXft.evyjg avroHg eX^rt^og
(pyjat, ft.eTaa')(y]fi^aTiaet

'£lg

yap

JJavXog

ro afafia ryjg raTretvaaeag yjf/LZvi^

avfJifJioptpov

r(p

aafxart

ryjg

^o^vjg

avTov Kvpiovg
ovTro)

^yjkovort.

ovayjg

ovv ev dpy^aig ert ryjg ciKovofJ.tag Kat

TreTrepaaft.evyig, Trwg

^v

etKog KaraXyj^at 'Kptarov ryfg

etg rov
;

KoafJLov

aydiryjg, airo(f)OtTYi-

aavra rov
avrov

TraSeiv vTrep

avrov

aeaccKe yap

t^v vTrovpdvtov, Kai

v7rofj.eivag

rov

Kara adpKa Sdvarov, Kai ^ta T^f eK veKpav 20
avrov.

dvaardaecog
onep
e^pyj.

Karapy-^aag

qvk

vj^et

rotyapovv

Tlerpog

KE4>. AA.
Ilfpt Tov (reKr]Via^ofievov.

37

'EyeVero Se eV

rrj

e^s

rjfLepa,

KareXOoiJTcov avrcov 25

aTTO Tov opov9, CTVJjrjuTTjaeu avTco

byXos iroXvs.
yj

ToT
yap

ATTOT. A/a
fJ.eTa

T>;v aYjV

airtartav ovk evvjpyyjKev

yaptg'

ort

y£Yi

irtaTeag irpoatevat 'KpiarS) Kai rotg irap

avrov
YjfJ.ag

T^v Tov BepaTrevetv tvvaaBat KaTairXovr^^aaat ydptv, avrog

e^tta^e iravrayov rvjv irtartv airav irapa rcov Trpoatovrcov avrw, 30
ravTYig eveKa
r-i^g

atrtag Karevovjae ^iKaicog avrov "Kptarog Xeycov,
'^tearpa.ft.ft.evv], ecog

"

co

yevea aTrtarog Kat

rtvog eaofxat Trpog vfxag

"

Kat dve^ofJMt y^wv."

airtarov ^e yeveav eKeivov irov "Trdvrcog Kat

IX.
TOVf

46.
6[/.oyvo!)fJicvai

AOYKAN ETArrEAIOY.

79

(iKOiag aveKakei, koi ^i€(TTpa[X[M€vov, Kai Kar
Trepi tcov

ovhkva TpoTTOv opBotto^ih €i^0Ta.
ftxt

toiovtxv

(pyjai

to ypaf/.-

TO UpoVf

**

m

al TpifSoi aKokiai Kai KafXTivKai al Tpoyjai

"

avrZv."

Kai

fx,€T

oXiya

E^e/

fxXv ovv

tov tov ^atfxovSivTog

•naTpoq kv7TOvft.€Vov aireXBeh, Kai ov T€TV)(YjK0Ta T^f (f)i\oTtfXia$' 5

«AA

tva

fxri

Ttg ot€Tat Kai avTOv aTOV^cat Xj9«7tov Trpog tyjv tou
€'7r€Tifi.vj(T€

vapa^o^ov
irapa^x^^fi.a

KaT0p6a)(XtVy
tc/u

rco

aKaQapTip

TTvevfi.aTif

Kai
tco

vo(T€7v
yjv

dirrjWdTT^TO, Kat
€Tt tov irarpog,

diro^c^ooK^v

avrov

vaTpt avTov' ov yap
fxaTog.

aXXa

tov KparovvTog Ttv€v-

Eire/^^ §e «Treae/craTo rriv irXeove^tav, yeyove TtaKtv

touio

loiov vaTpo^f Kpt(TTOv Oe to Occpov.

KE<^. AB.
Hepi
tS)v BidKoyi^ofiivav Tis fiei^av.

46

KtPIAAOT AaEBANAPEIAS.
^c^pdfxyjKe Tiva tc5v

YldOog

&*/

OVV ^taKCVOV ^O^VJS €t(7-

dytwv ATrocTToAcyV to yap oXoog 'ttaXoyi^eaBat 15
aVTOOV,

TO T/f aV
Ttpo€(TTavat

€ty]

fXet^COV

<p€tX0V€tKGVVT0g

T0VT€(7TI

Kat to

Twv dWcov
ly^wv, tov

cTrtSvfx-^aavTog' aAX'
ev
t'^

Tot Ttdvra €it(bg "Kpt-

arog

6

©eof

tov fxa9v}Tov "^tavoM

"^taXoytafxov,

(oairep

Ttva TttKptav avo (f>vovaav

Kara ro

yeypafXfxevoVj irptv €tg

vrpog

ap^vat,

iipiv

a^pvv6i^vatf
ev

€K pt^vjg avrijg

dvaj3adp€V€t ro 20

KaKoV dpypfL€va ydp
Se

vjfxh

rd

TtdQvj

vtKa

p(^t(ag, d^pvvSevra

^vaavoPkvjrd eart.

Ucog ovv dpa ro
;

(f)tXo^o^ov

iidQog diro-

K€tp€t

irvevfxdroov larpog

eireAa/SeTO

to

Tiat^lov

Kat eaTVjaev

avro

irap eavrw. w(f>€\€tag Se 'Xjxptv €7rot€7ro ro ypi^fxa, Kat avTo7g
vjfxTv

ro7g dyiotg AiroaroXotg, Kat

^e

roTg fX€T

cKeivovg.

Tlapa- 25

/3oaK€Tat yap

vj

rotd^€ voaog, wg eirtirav Trdvrag dvdpooTrovg, €nr€p

av

€i€V

€V

VTrepoyv]

t^ Kard

rtvoov.
;

Ttvog ovv dpa rvirov Kai
dirovvjpov

€iKova ro irapevey&kv €Trot€7To
^(tivjg'

Trat^^iov

t€ Kat d(ptXo^o^ov

aKaTr-^X€vrov

ydp ^yet

rviv yva>fi.viv,

dva>6€VT0v tvjv Kap^tav,

Kat eaTtv ev dirXorvjTt ttaXoytafxm' ov (fyiKoto^iag epa, ovk o/Scv 30
VTT€poyQ^g
rpoirov.

Wtrd

(pvjatv,

"

ort

og av
e^vjg,

^e^vjrat

ro TraiYtov
6 fxtKpo-

" TOVTO

€Trt

rw

ovofxart fxov" Kat

rd

tovto eariv,

80
repog ev
Xeycov

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
7ia,aiv v/jliv vitapy^av,
7tep\

IX.

49.

ovTog earai /xe^ya^, tov ixdTpio^ppova

Kat ov^ev vxpi^Xov
oti

avTOv
vipav

Xoyi^Ofxevov

^i

evXa^eiaV

yeypaTTTai yap " " Taneivav eavTOv

itag

eavTOV TaireivtaByjaeTaiy Kai 6

vxpood-^aeTai.^^

KE$. Ar.
Uepl Tov
fir}

5

fTTiTpenofievov aKoXovBetv.

49
**

E^zrwv Se
/3ov, OTi TTpog

KvayyeXtaTTji nepi ^ladvvov tov dteX(f>ov
Tov }^vpiov eiTiev

'la/ccu-

"

eiiiaTdTa,

ei^o[i.ev

Ttva eni to5

ovofJiaTt

aov eK/SdXXovTa ^atfxovta Kai eKwXvaafxev awTOv," ov/^
Attoo-toAwv tovto
(prjaiv,
'^to

wg

(pGovi^advTCOv tc5v

dXX ag

a^tovvTcov 10

fjLaSeTv.

E/ ^e eTepoig e^eaTt tovtc ^pav,
fx^ KooXveTe tov

koi avTog ^todaKUV
ev

avTovg dvTaireKpiBvj,
TcS ovofxaTi fJiov, ov

avvTpt^ovTa tov SaTavav
TOiovTog.
fj.e,

ydp eaTt

Kaff vfiav, tpyjaiv,

oaTig Qe

ovK eaTi KaS
eig

vft.a>v,

viiep vfxav eaTi

tuv ayaTrcovTcov

oiTtveg

ra

^o^av

fj.ov TiXi^povv BeXovat, Tvj itap

efKov '/dpiTi aTe(f>avovfJ.evot. 15
ev

^I

T/
"

eVT;v onep (pyjaiv, OTt

" eyeveTo
;'

tw

avfj.TrXripovaBai

Tag

y]fj.epag Trjg dvaX-^xpeag

avTov

OTt

evaTdvTog tov Katpov Ka9

bv edet XotTTOv to awT-^ptov
f*.ev

vnep vjfMV

vTrofA.etvavTa iidSog, ava/3^vai

etg

tov ovpavov, avve^^pevaai ^e
elg 'lepoaoXvfna,, ovKeTt

tw Qew Kat YlaTpi,

eKpivev

dveXBeh

w^e KaKeiae

iiepiepyofJ.evog, ovhe

20

Tiepio^evwv
**

KWff.ag

Kat iioXeig.

tovto yap

^YiXo^i

to " eaTYjpt^e to

Tipoawnov avTov.^^

KKnefKTiei dno itpoawTiov avTov Tovg fj.a6vjTag,

ovK dyvowv wg cvk eaovTai ^eKTOt napa twv YiafuxpetTwv, irpoKa-

TayyeXXovTeg
KaKetvotg

avTOv

ent

tw KaTaXvaat nap
Jipocpdaewg
YiTteiVfi
Yj^^vj

avTolg,

dXX

tva

ndaav

d(popfj.riv

eKKOipvj,

Kat To7g f/.a6viTaig 25
eig 'lepoao-

w(f)eXeiag yevrjTat iipo^evog.

ydp

dve(3atvev

XvfiM, Tov TOv
loyb^a/wv

TidBovg

Kaipov

cj^cov
fj)f\

yetTova, Kat efxeXXe T^g

dveyeaBai napoivtag, tva

aKav^aXtaBwatv ot av Tia-

OovTa t^^watv, dve^tKaKct ^e fj.dXXov Kai ainoi yevwvTat, Kav v^pt-

^wat Ttveg
TcSv

rj

aitoQtwKovaty Tipoyvfj.vaafj.a tcv •npdyfj.aTog

t^v €^^30
el

JlafxapetTwv

v^ptv

eTiotvjaaTO,

waavet Xeywv avToHg'
efJiXiTg

yap

Kat ovK e^e^avTO

vfj.dg, vfj.eHg

ToHg

tov ^ecriroTou fxyeatv

IX.

51.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
fcai

81
elitovToov

(^aKdXovBrjaavrig, ^iaKapTep^^aare dyioirpeTragf odiv
€K rav [xadv^raVf

" Kvpiff

QeXtig etinofxev irvp Kara^vjvat airo rov
eirerifxyicTev

"

ovpavov Kai avaXwaai avrovg ;"
rrjv

avroigf irepKrreXXaov
fjiovov

6eoTtpe'7t(ag

o^vQvfxiav, Kai neiQcav

ave^iKaKeh, ov
rrjv

rore,

akXa

Kai eig ra }j.era ravra, yjviKa

wr ovpavov
ovk

^iepypfievot, 5

efneWov avoaioig riai
Beiov KvjpvyfuiTog.

"jrepiTrnrreiv av^pa<7iv,

avey^ofKevcov
rvjg

rov

ei^evai

yap

'Xjpyj,

011

wg

fXYjTiQ)

veag KeKpa-

n^Koreg yapirog,
€tirov ",

aX\

eri

t^c Trporepag

e-ypfi.evot (rvvyjBeiag,

rovro

rov

HXiav acpopavreg

rov irvpt KaracpXe^avra ^ig rovg

TtevTriKovra Kat rovf yjyovfJievovg avrwv.

lo
TtpoeypatpYi
eig ro

Ylept rov

fJLvj

eirtrpeTrofxevov aKoXovOeiv

Kara

Mar6a7ov.

O

oe

etTrciv,

"

aKoXov6r}cr(a
ev

<Joi,

Kvpte," vpwrov te eirtTperpov
d^to^riXarov
fxev

fioi

aTrord^aaQai
eve^ei^aro,

lovg

tc5

otKca

fxov,

viroayeaiv

Kara
etg

iravrog

eiraivov fxearYjV'

ro te ye ^vjreiv dirord-it

^aaQat Tor?
Trj

rov oIkov avrov, ^ta^etKvvatv ori fxefxeptarat irag

havota'

ro

yap

oXccg

irpoaavaKatvovaSat

BeXetv

rotg

Kara

yevog oiKetotg
Trpdyfxart
irpog
**

roHg

fxvj

diro^e^afxevotg,

ea& ore rov

eirt

rovrco rco

aKoireiv, ov

/3e^vjKorog eari Xoytafxov'
tyjv

^to

Kui

(f^Y/ai

avrov, " ovtetg eirilSaXm

X^^P^

^'^

dporpov Kat arpacpetg 20
Q.airep

etg

ra

oirtaco,

evOerog eartv eig rv]v jSaatXetav rov Qeov."

yap

yyjiTovog

r^g ^ia
Xentov

rm

aporpcov dvaroft.Yig dp^dfxevog, orav

OKVvjavj Ttpog lo

tod

Ttavrt irovca, ovy^ oxperat rotg

aarayy-

atv KOfxwaav tijv yvjv,

TrpoaocpX^^aet

Se ro7g

opcaat
to)

Kai yeXcara,
drro- 25

ovrcog ei rig eX.otro fxev dKoXovSvjaat

\ptaTw

Sew, ovk

rdaaerat

%\

rotg ev to5 Koafxc^ Trpdyfxaai, Kat roig

Kara adpKa
avrov,

otKeiotg, Kat

fi.dXtara rolg

ft.Y]

rov
e<p

aKonov

diro^^eyjtfxevotg
rolig

ov^^afkac ovrog

KaropBwaet

ro7g

airaat °

eiraivovfxevotg

dyaBvjv evroXfxtav, ovhe evOerog earat eig rvjv rov

Seov /SaatXeiav.
eartv eiraKo- 30

eirt^dXXei fxev aporpco rvfv y^e^pa,

ttort

irpoBvfLog

Xov6etv, oiriaco Se ^Xenet, ^tort fxeXX^aecog koi dva^oXvjg irotelrat

Ttpocpaatv Tv]v irpog rovg otKetovg ^tdX.e^tV
evpvjaetg rovg dyiovg AiroaroXovg.

dXX

ov roiovrovg ovrag
toi)

Afxa ydp vjKovaav

^eaird-

n fhuv

Cod.

o itjiuitaTi

Cod.

M

82

EPMHNEIA TOT KATa
**

X.
OTtiad)

i.

Tov X.pi<rTOv XeyovTO^ Ttpog avTovg^
a(f>€VT€i

SevTf

/otov," evQecog

TO Ttkohv Kai
TTpo(7y}K€i

Tov

iraTepa

avxwi/,

yjKokovdyjaav

avTw.
tc5

TOiovTOv; ovv

Tvyyaveiv Tovg aKoXovBeiv eQekyiaavTag

0ew.
f

KE*. AA.
Ti.epX

5

tS)v

dva8eix0evTCi)V o.

I

Mera
firjKovTa.

5e

Tavra avlbei^ev 6 KuyOioy Ka\ irepovs

6/35o-

TiTOT BosTPttN.
Xoyoig'
<f>i€i

TovTov

TVTtog ev ToHg

MwvVeojf eypdcpeTo
63reAe|aT0, CTnyi

Qeov yap TrpoirTaTTOVTog,

e/S^oix-^KOVTa

o

Se To7g e^eiXeyiJ.evoig

to rTvey/xa ©eow'

Kai

Kaff eTepov §e
b'e

TpoTTOV,

Tovg T€ ^vo Kai ^eKa fxaQYiTag Kai avTovg
^ia

Tovg e/3^oevpvjaofi.ev'
*'

fXYjKovTa,

T^f Tou

vofAOV

(TKiag

aYj[xaivofJ.evovg

yeypanTai yap

ovTcog ev t'^ e^o^co irepi

twv

u/a5v

lcrpayjk'

riX-

"

fiov," (pi^aiVf

"

eig

AiXafx"

Ipfii^veveTai ^e eig avdj^aaiv, vjyovvi^
(pvjaiv,

elg
'*

av^yjaiVf

"

Ka) "^aav

e/ce?,"

"

'^clo^^eKa

v^^aToov

Trvjya/,

Kai

e(3^ofi.'^KovTa

aTeXeX"]
eig

(f^oiviKCDV.^^

dva^aivovTeg yap

eig

TcXeioTepav avveaiv, Kai
TiKYjv

av^Yjaiv avaTpe-)(0VTeg tvjv
evp-^aofi.ev,

Trvevfna-

Tag ^voKai^eKa
toc

TTYjyag

TovreaTi, Tovg dyiovg
(f)oiviKOov

'AiroaToXovg, Kai

eptoff.^^KovTa

tZv

aTekeyvj Tovg 20

dvo^eiy^pevTag

^vjkovoTi

iiapa

'KptaTov'
rjfMov

apvofxevoi

yap wg

eK

•nviym

dyim

eK twv tov 'EaT^pog

fxaBfjTm iiavTog ei^vjaiv

ayaGov.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias.
eaeaBat
fnovov 6
tcov eig

Kai
yj

eiret^y]

nokkyj

Ttg efxekkev
ya-p ov 25

avTOV TitaTevovTCtiv

iikyjBvg, eaayyjveveTO
e$vcov
yjft.ci>v

lapavjk,

dkka yap

Kai ai tS>v

ayekat' Ota tovto
Tipog
Toltg

dve^ei'/6y]aav

itapa

\piaTov tov Qeov

^vo Kai

^eKa Kai erepoi e/SSo/x^/fOVTa.

dKokovBa tovtcdv

oiov

"

fnev

" "

6eptafi.og Tiokvg^^ Kat

Ta

e^vjg.

Kai

"

fLy]

f>.eTal3aiveT€ e^ otKiag

eig

oiKiav"

mep

peff.l3aaft.ov '^yjko^,

Kot fLtaQov aiTovvTcov Kat ^/a-30

^okvjg eaTt TeKfiyjptov.
^e Kat To. TOVTcov
'*

Ylpo€ypd(f>€TO eig to KaToc MaTOaiov.
ecog

Eti

dKokovda

w^e'

"

Ve efif aSeTcov aSeTei tov

aTToaTetkavTd fne."

;

X.
2

7.

AOTKAN ETArrEAlOT.

88

""EXcyeu ovv Trpos avrovSi 6 fieu Oepur/JLO^ TToAuy, ol
Se ipyaraL oXlyot.

TiTOT BosTPON.
evpeTg

"ClcTTtip

jap

aypoi

KOfxa>VT€i

TtXovamg
vj

re Kai fxaKpo) iroWovi

i^rjTovai

tov^ 6epi(7Tai, ovt<c(
Xp/crTov
yj

(TV{j.'na<ja yvjf tjtoi

twv

p.f.\KovT(ov

Trt(7T€veiv (i^

7JA17-5

6vif iroAX^ Ti^
y(tyyav.

ovaa kai avaplG^rjTogi ovk oXiym i^dno ^uo-TaTiefJi.TrOfxevoi

ePd^i^ov ovv ava ^vo

KaTa

TioXeig Kai Kaix.ag,
**

p.ovovovy\ (3oavT€g to Sioc T^f 'laavvov
**
'*

^ojv^f,

€ToiixaaaT€

o^ov

Kvpiov.'^

"TrXyjv

€K€ivo aQpei'

e/Vwv yap to "

^e-^Oi^Te

tov Kvpiov

ToD depiafxov, onag eK^dkrj

epyaTag

€ig tov

SepKXfJiov

avTov" 10

toDto 'n€iipay€V avTOg Kanoi tov Qepiafxov Kvpiog, tovt€(xti twv
hti T^g yra' Tiq av €»7

Trapa tov

(f)v(7€i

Kai aXyjQag ovTa Oeov

" ayTOu yap
ypaiTTai'

rj

av[xi:a(Ta yr]
Tr<Jo<;

Kai to TrX-^pafxa avTrjg" KaBa y€TtpeiiovTog
tc5
€tii

eha
Toiig

fxovwg

TravTcov

©eaj tov

€K^aX€7v
e<TT/v

IpytxTag

TovTovg dvf^ei^ev
'^t

X.pKTTog'

avTOg dpa 15

Toy Bepiafxov ^eaTtOTrjg, Kai

avTov t€ Ka\ avv avTa Ka^dp-

y€t tS)v oXoov
cyOev e<TT/v
ccv

Seog Kat
av
ej^e/v

YlaT-^p.

t^ta ^e TtdvTa eaTtv avTov, Kai

llaTYip XeyoiTO,

a

fxrj

€aTi Kat tou Iiov.

ToT
Trj

ATTOT. TIpoXey€i he avTolg Kat tov

^icoyfxov, tva eveyKcoat
fxr}

"TTfipa

Tag avvB-^Kag,

fnrj

j3aaTdl^€T€ ^aXdvTtov,
vfi.iv

/BapeiTe

20

dpyvpto) TOv wfxoV dpxeT

yap

^e^aprjaSat
t*/v

TJj

(ppovTi^i tov

Xoyov
€y€T€,

Tr}v

^tdvotav'
ev

fxrj

ev tco

^aXavTica

eXTtita tov dpfov
fxrj^eva KaTo,

dXX

TrefxxpavTt
fxrj

TiBeaSe

tt^v <f>povTtda'

T^v o^ov dairdai^aOe,
OfxtXiag
'hffxta

tovto

€fi.itottov

tov KrjovyfxaTog yevrfcat
fxrj-

ev

fxeaca

vapaTTtTiTovarjg koi ^pa^vTrjTOg irpocpdaei,

25

Ttg

^ta/3oXtKr]

KaKovpyta vfiMg aTroairdar}'
Tr^v

ov
fxev

yap KaT
tov Aoyov
\^i

dvoKX-^pctiatv ^a}a€T€

irpoarjyoptav,

aAX'

vfi.(7g

OaaeTe, oirov Oe
€<f>

17

a^/ov
ov

eiravairavaeTat to irpayfxa.

6e

fxr],

vfxdg avaKdfxt^ft'

yap dirX^g pnrT€Tat, dXXd Kpiaet

Trj €fxy

PdXXeTat.
n

30

M77

iJL€Ta^aip€T€

i^ olKiaf

ety olKiav.
atTovvTCCv, Kat

TouTo yap

p€fx^ofxev(i)v

Kai fxiaQov

aaTaatag

tpyov, Kat "tia^oX-^g TeKfxrjpiov ^e^rjKOTeg ^e yiveaOe «ai dfX€TaKlVrjTOl TOV vovv.

M

2

84
11

EPMHNEIA TOY KATA
Kal Tou KovLopTov Tov KoXXrjOevTa

X.

ii.

iQfuv Ik ttjs tto-

Aeo)? v/icov airoixaaaofxeda vfuv.

OpirENOTS.
av

Tfflv

yap

dfxapT^i^fxdTcov vixav o KovtopTO<;

tiKaioog

e/f vixdg eTraveXQr].
t>?v

Trapar-^pet ort
vytrj

ai

[xv}

iiapo^e^/oixevai tov$

ATioaToXovg Kai

^thaaKaXiav

irokeig,
yj

eyovat TrkaTeiag $
rj

avdXoyoV to " 7rXaTe7a Kat evpvyoopoq

o^og

ayovaa

ets

tv}V

"
1

aTraXeiav, Kai iroXXoi elaiv

ot "^iep^ofxevoi ^t

avTvii.^^

2

Aeyo) de
Tepov
ecTTaL.

vfxlv otl ^obojxoLS iv Trj rjfxepa eKeivrj

aveKTo-

TiTOT BosTPCN.
aToXot, edv Totvvv

'E7re<S>7

eU

'^o^ofxa ovk aTreaTaXYjaav

Atto-io

[Xfi

^e^uvTai vfxdg Tovg hiioaToXovg, yeipovg

eaovTat ovTOt eKetvm.

^3

Ovai
OvToi
XyjviKoi.

(TOL

X.opa0v, ovai

(tol

BrjdaaLda, otl

el

iv Tvpcp

Kcu ^lBcovl iyevovTO, Kal
01 TOTTOt

r. e.

^lovtaiKo) eTvy^avov, Tvpog Be Kat Yt^wv 'EA-15

Hvifxaivei Toivvv 6 Kvpiog, OTt ei ev TOig eGveatv eyevovTO

ai

'^vvdfxeig,

paov dv eirtaTevov
Koi

vjiiep

vfxelg'

eXey/et toivvv Tag

^iov^aiKdg

TroX.etg,

dvTtTrapaTtBYjai
ovTCcg

twv 'KXXvjvtKccv iroXeav
^^^V po.t^'^?

Tag yeipovg. Kat ydp

ex^h

'r«

(TrtaTevaaV

\ovta7oi Ve efxetvav aTriaTot, KatTrep
TVjV eTrtfxeXetav.

TroXXvjv

eayv}KOTeg tov Xoyov 20
vfj.Hv, fxvj^e

M^

Xv7re7a6e OTav dTretOaaiv
;

XeyeTe

Tt

virdyofxev

v^ptaBvjvat

ov^^etg

vjfxoov

dvex^Tat'

6

aKovccv vfLiv

efxov dKovet, ovTe

dv irtaTevafi
vfieig

Tig, vfxelg
01

eaTe

'^vaonTrovvTeg, ovTe
j^/JiyaaTe
fxoi

edv dvTtXeyaatv,

ecrre

evedpevovTeg,

tv}v

yXSoTTav,
efji.e

ey<j}

irapeyja tv}v ydptv,
v}

a6eTZv vfxdg,

efne aSeTei'

etg

25

ydp dvaTpeyei
OTt

vfxeTepa v^pig.
e0^ofxv}KovTa'
^to

Upoetpv}Tai
OTi

direaTetKe Tovg

vvv

Xeyet

vireaTpetpav fxeTa yapdg, ag e7raKoXovBv}adav}g rcS Xoyca TVfg

Beoae^eiag'

ekeyov yap,

" Kvpte,
ovy^

Kat Ta ^aifJLOvia viroTdaaeTat
ovrco

"

y}fuv ev T(p ovofnaTt

aovJ^

Se yatpovTeg

OTt

p.dXX.ov

^o

yeyovaai
v}^tavTat

tov

Qetov

KV}pvyfxaTog

^tdKovot, tovto

eiirov,

Kat

OTt

yepcov AiroaToXiKiov, «AA' otI avifxeicov yeyovaatv diroTe-

Aecrra/.

Oirep Se, <pv}atv 6 XpiaTog Trpog avToi/g,

"

oti

eOewpovv

X.
**

13-

AOYKAN ETArrEAIOT.
eK

85
ovpavov"
ti

Tov Saravav, wg aorpaTnjv neaovTa

tov

tovto

^y]ko7j OTt €1

apycov avTwv KaTeireaeVf o\ ^ovKoi.

TrpoaQoKaai
'^vvaTai

^vvacrdai
l^67v
v]v
Yj

'^paaaf
KpiTVj^ 6

Xeyet Se ecopoKeyaif
aopaTog'
Kai

cirei^Yj

aXXog ov
e*7r€v, oti

wg daTpaTrvjv ^e
yeyove
tvjv

XafXTrpog
b

Trjv

<f>v<Tiv^ €1

aKOToei^yjg

irpoaipeaiv'

yapi,

eTroirjaev

6

Seog, tovto KaXov.

Aio

[xy]

fiay/x,a^eTe, <f)y}ai, /xij^e

fjLeya (f^poveTTe'

eyu yap

^e^ccKa vimTv t>jv e^ovatav.
irept

KaTt

Se Kat ovtw

ka^eh

tovtov KaTa tov aytov KvptXet^e ireaovTa tov tid^oXov,
"^o^yjg eig

Aov, OTt wg daTpaTtYjV Ik tov ovpavov

TovTeaTtVf e| vxpovg etg yvjv KaTevyjveyfxevoVf ck
e^ ta^/vog itokXvjg etg ecr^^aTvjv daBevetav.

dTtfxtav, lo

Ylpo fxev yap T^g tov

^ptaTov Koi Seov Kat
vff

^ccTi^pog y^fxm eTit^yjft^iag KUTeKpaTyjae T^f

ovpavoV

TTpoaeKvv^drj

ay^e^ov

Tcapa

ndvTm'

vaoi

TravToy^ov

Kat ^(OfKot Kai Bvatat.
fi.ovoyevy]g

eTret^y]

^e KaTaite^pony^Kev

e^

ovpavm
o

o

Tew ©eoS Xoyog,

TreirrctiKev

eKeivog

ag aaTpaiiy]^

Trav-i^

Tag

e^yjtiv

irpoaKvvrjTag Tovf "^evkavyjfiLevovg, viro irodag TeQetTat tcSv

TrpoaKvvovvTcov avTOV.

Kat

0(f>etg

^e Kat aKopiriovg avTO
tcHv

tovto

^y]ko7

ag

Trept

avTov
avv

Te Tov ^ta{3okov elpr]fxevov Kat

^atf/.ovxv

avTov, otTiveg

avTio KaTairaTovvTat vtto twv ^ovAwv 'KptaTOV tov Seov ly^Sv, t^v 20
TO/ai;T>jv

e^ovaiav Kafx.^dvovTeg
*'
fj.ri

vir

avTov.

To
TovTO

^e,

yaipeTe OTt Ta itvevfi.aTa vfuv vnoTaaaeTai^^
Kevo^o^iav eK tovtov KTriaovTat.

ayjfiLatvety tva ft,^

Kat yap
tdaecog
to.

aXkot

eia},

<py]atv, 01

€K tovtov evepyeTovfKevot,

ot

t%

SijAovoT/ KaTaJ^tovfi.evot'

dkka

fi.akkov ev tovtco

yaipeTe, OTt

25

ovofiaTa vfxwv yeypairrat ev To7g ovpavoTg, ov %ta fxekavog,
ttd
fjLvy]fi.yjg

dkkd

Ka) ydptTog Kat
ot

%o^y]i

Seov. Kai
KdTO>

6

aev %id(3okog

avcodev

KaTaTrtnTei,
17

^e

dvSpooTTot
"^^

ovTeg ava ypd(povTai.
ypd(f>eTat

avTV] Toivvv eo"T*v

aA>j5;v^ %*/'*>

^^^ ypd(f>ea6at.
Ka\
ty] t^s"

Se eKaaTog oaov edv Kafiyj

tw Te
"

d^icjoft.aTi,

evepyeiag

^o

XdpiTt.

Ta
**

aKokovSa

TOfTO)
'

olov,

avTyj

t-Jj

copa
ot

v^yakkiaaaTO
o(f)6akfiot
01

tco

7ivevfj.aTt

\r]aovg.

Kat "
irep)

fx.aKdptot

/3keecag

TFOVTeg

d

/SXeTreTf."

Kat

tov

eTrepuTrjaavTog

vofxtKov,

86
" KUt
rov

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
TrXyjaiov

X.
c/f

25.

aov

co^

eayrov*"

vpoeypacpr]

to

Kara

M.arSaTov.

OpirENOTS.

Ov
^

fxaKpav to

**

TidvTa
[xoi

fJioi

Trape^^oQy]

viro

tov

" YlaTpo; n Kai eTTi
'

fxov^ 6a"Ti,
~ )> yyjg.
"bia

Kai ro "
5>

€^o6v]
>

naaa
ra

e^ova-ia ev ovpavca
~

'

^

*

Kai Oia tovto avTo) OiOoTai Traaa

~

~

^

/'^

egovcria,

'e

'

"

iva$

^

eip^^voTioffjo-yi

tov uTavpov avTOv'
ov^eTtco /xev

eiTe

eiri

TTjg yyjg, €iT€

Ta

ev TOig ovpavo7g.

ovv

ra itdvTa

eipyjvoTroiyjcyev, cog

'^yjXov

eaTt eK tov tov dito Tyjg KaKiag viiapyeXv
yj

'7roXe[xov'

eaTai

^c TrdvTccg

reXeia
eirei

elpyjvyj.

^iKatoraTa ^e Tidvra Trapa^e^iiKev
6

avTco

Ylar-fjp'

Kai avrog
dvSpooTrcov,

Tiog

irape^oBiq

VTtep

TtdvTCCv, og
*'

10

eari

Ylaryip

irdvTcov

fxdkicrra

inaTm, Kai
rwv

iXacTfkog

"

ecjTt "nepi rcov dfj.apTia)V ^/xwi'," ov Tcept

yjfLerepcov he fLovov,

aXXa
"
**

Kai

Ttepi

oXov rov KoafLOV. vape^^oSy] ^e KaOo yeyovev av6pcc{.yjorov

TTog, ** iva ev rco Qvoft.aTi

Tidv yovv
Tidcja

Kafnxpyj

eitovpavicov

Kai

eniyeicov Kai
ori K.vpiog

KaraySovicov, Kai

yXcocrcra

e^oft.oXoy^cterai 15
aft.y]v^^

lyjcTovg 'K.pKrrog, elg

to^av ©eou naT^os-,

TiTOT BosTPftN.
ro fxerpov
rvjg

ATTOKdXvxpig ecxTi fieTd^oaig yvcocrecog irpog
(pvcrecog

eKdarov

re Kai

^vvdff.ecogf

Kai onov fxev

OfjiOia <pvc7ig, eKel yvcocng

dvev '^i^aaKaXlag'

evravOa ^e ef dnofLev

KaXvxpecog

fi.d6y]<xig.

eTtnr^pei roivvv, itcog

evravda

eK ydpirog, 20

eKel Ve €k (pvaecog.

KE4). AE.
Hepi Tov eTrepcoTTjaavTOS vofUKOv.

25

Kat

Ibov vofXLKos TLs dpeaTTj, ^Kireipd^cov avrov.

KitaiveSeig VTto rov 'Ecor^pog 6 vofKiKog, ttjv dXa^oveiav e^eppyj^ev, ov^eva eivai 7tXy]cnov

avrov riSe^evog, wg ovhevog ovrog avrov 25
Toi/to

Kara

ryjv

^iKaiocJvvYjV

ecpafXiXXov.

ydp

e^^eiKvvro

Et/ayly]<70vv

yeXiaryjg elnuv,
*'

"

^e SeXcov

tiKaicocrai

avrov Ttpog rov

e/Ve,

rig eari fxov itXy^aiov ;"

vofxiKog

-nXy^aiov fxovov evofxi-

^ev

elvai

rov

tiKaiov
ov

^iKaico,

rov
fxta.

vipyjXov

v\py]X^,

Kar

dperyjv,

(j>y]fxi.

ydp

rv]

ovaia

ovayj
'^to

ro

vxpy]Xov

eAfp/vev,

30

«AA' ^ ro7g d^tiofiaaiv, ^ raig itpd^eaf
aat, rovreart

BeXcov
etrj

avrov OiKatcoTiyv ap€TY]v,

^iKaiov dno^e^^aif ug vxpi^Xog

Kara

X.
^

30.

AOTKAN EYArrEAIOT.
Kara to ^i^aaKaXov
oei^ov
ff.ot

87
[xov
Or]

jtxeyaf

eivat,

(pvjai

" Kai rig eari
o

TTA.vja-iov;

rov ovra
fj.eyav

fxeyav

Oe

l^Qir-ifip

are

voivjrYig, f/.iKpov

yap Kai

avrog

e3roii^o"€V,

ov raHg iipaJ^eaiv

Of^e rcn^ a^iwfxaaiv,
ov)()

aXka

T17 <f>vaet

(opiaaro rov TtXvjatov, fxovov-

Xeyccv, oviroi

aot reag keyet ort ov^ev r<av
ft.v]

aXKm

tievrjVoyeVf 5

iva

fKvi 01

ovroog <f>tXaperoi vofLtaaat

y£eo)are7v rofg ireXag rrfV
eivat,

ayaitvjv, ^oyfjLa

rov aov eXey^fov vofxiaavreg

aXXa

Kat

ei

ovrwg

e^xet'

^e^oaSd)

yap aTtov^ag rov

deofnevov yeveadai irXvjatoVf

ov roo ToVco fnovoVf
Xeia' ^ta

aXXa Kai

rvj '^iaBeaet,

Kat

t'^ e/f

avrov

eirtjxe-

yap rovro Kat rov
ryj

Yaff.apeiri^v aot eyapaKrviptaa' ro

yap 10
too

vXvjaiov

<f)vaet
rv}

Kptverat

ov

r"^

aperri,

ov

r^ ovata,

ov

a^tafxari,

aXXa
vfyov

avfXTraBeia

Kai

tw

rpova t^?

Qepaiieiag'

eKnvov

ow

fxdXtara

iiXvjatov

etvat

rov ^eofxevov, Kat avre-

vdyyeXrog

ent t^v Po-^Seiav ^d^t^e.

KE4>. Af.
Hepl Tov ffiireaovros
els

15
Toiis

Xpords.

30

"

AvdpioTTog rig Karef3aive aTco 'lepovaaXvjfL,^^ rvjv dvjoQev KaQo-

Qov rov

avSpwTTOv

atvtrrojxevog

rovro

<f)V]atv,

vjrtg

^ta

rvjg

rov

AoafX

"jrapal^daecog diro rvjg inpvjX^g

Kot daraatdarov Koi Qeiag

rov TrapaOeiaov ^iarptj3vjg, 'lepovaaXvjfL
OTrep
eipvjvvjv

evKaipwg ovofxaaSeiavjgy 20
leptyw r^v KOtXvjv Kai
KarcoXiadvjae.
tvjXoi

P avjfxatvei Qeov, irpog

rvjv

yQafi.aXvjv,
rvjv
efXTraSvj

Kat

ra Kavfxart

Trvtyvjpav
^ct>>;v

Se

rovte rov Koafxov

ywpi^ovaav

Qeov'

Xvjarag

Se Ae-ye; to twv dypioiv ^aifJiovxv avarrifxa, otrtveg rav r^g dpervjg

ifxarim, dv^piav

(f>vjfi.i,

Kai

aa^ppoavvvjv Kat

rd

Ofxoia, eK^^vaavreg

25

afTOv, ra rvjg dfxaprtag rpavfxara KaraXnrovreg ev avroo, dirvjXSov
Oevreg
YifxiQavvi'
et
fi.v]

Kat

yap ovk eart rovrotg

oXcog

evyepeia rov

TtXrprretv,

irpoXa^ovreg avXi^aaat

rd rav dperav irepi^O'
fxey^pt

Xaia, oQev fxera rovro iiXvjrrovatv d(f>ei^wg Kai
ov

Bavdrov.

yap

rv]v

dpervjv

eKOvaai

airov^^al^wat
E,7retdv]

fxovov,

dxXd

Kat

r^g ^o

vjfi.erepag

epaatv dvcoXetag,

^e t^$" AevirtK^g tepcoavwjg

P

flfnifjUyov

Cod.

i

88
ovoixaTog
avci}(peXy^

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
eartv (lavjyYjTrig, ^ia tov lepia^ Kai

X.
tov Aei/iTov

S5Tr(v

TQv vojxov

a-y][xaiv€t

Trapo^oV

ov^^e

yap Ta$
"^

TtXvfyaq tov

TrapaTienTCtiKOTOt;
'*

eig

Tovg XvjaTag eOepdirevaeV

a^vvaTOv yap
fxev,

aifxa

Tavpm

Kat Tpdyoov d(f)eXeh diJ.apTiag" Kai eTrer^e

riTOVfjae Se,

Kai irpog TeXeiav SepaTreiav ovk vjpKeaev, ovTe Ketfxevov S
to yap

dveaTrjae'

"

dvTnrapyjkBe'^ ^yjXoT OTt ov Trapahevae

KaTa-

Xeixpag dQeaTov,

dXX

eaTr} Kai eBedaaTo^ Kai QepaTievaat ^tevorjBvj

Kol ecp-^xpaTO'
rjToi

irpog ^e

t^v Qepaiteiav d^vvaT-^aag,

t-^

twv TrXvjyZv
dTretpajxe'

Twv

TraSitiv eTriKpaTeta viKrj6eig, etg Toviriaa TidXtv

TOVTQ yap TO " dvTtiraprjXBev^ ev^^etKvvTat.
'AAA'

lo
^id
Trjg

nrdaav

Tr^v

dvSpcoirivvjv
jj

(pvaiv
vjv

dirapyrig

tov

^vpdixaTog

TreptGefxevog, ev
'

navTog

eSvovg to fnepog,

hv^atov
avOpwirm,

Te Kai 'ZafxapeiTOv Kai

EiXXvjvog, Kat
oirep

irdvTm aira^
vTro^vytov,
tco

TOVTOv fxeTa tqv aaixaTog,

eaTtv

totto)

TVjg

Tov dvSp<07rov KaKaaeag e-ntaTag, twv TpavfxdTm eSepdirevae. Kat 15

ydp

'^tevaev dXyjSwg, ov irapa^tevaeV

avTO tovto irpocpaatv
Ot

'o^ov
eiri

Trotrjadfxevog

to vjfxdg

eirtaKerpaaSat,
ov

ovg

Kat

KarvjXSev

T^f y^f,

^;

ovg Kat KaTeXvaeV
ToTg
avSpwirotg,

yap

cocpSvj

fxovov,

dXXd

Kai

avvaveaTpd(j)ri

KaTa

aXvjSetav "XJ^ptg TpoTrvjg Kat

(pavTaatag yevofxevog avSpwirog' tovto yap t^iov tuTpm yvv]aiwv20
Kai (ptXoaTopym to avvavaaTpe^peaSat ToHg appwaTOvai, Kat
a(f)taTaaSat irpiv dv vytaivxaiv.
fi.vj

oSev Kai olvov Tolg 'eXKeatv eiraveTrtaTV(f>ovTa, eXaica

TXm

Tov ^i^aaKaXtKOV Xoyov Kat
ov

tovtov eKevTreft.eive

paaeV

yap

oiov tc

yjv

aKpaTOV avTOV eveyKeh' ov ydp

T^v v7rep(3dXXovaav aTvxptv to
Tov*

Tm

TpavfxdT(av yaXeirov Kat avta- 25

oSev ^td TovTO dft.apTCi}Xoig Kat
;^;ov

TeXwvatg avvaveKXtveTO.
ev

eirt

TO

^e vno^vytov dve(3t(3aaev'

eavTW ydp

vjft.dg (pepet,

oti

eafKev fxeXv}

tov
Trjv

a(/)ft.aTog

avTOv'

elg

vrav^^o^y^ehv

te

dirriyaye,

TovTeaTiv etg
y^apvjTtKVjv'

EiKKXvjaiav tvjv irdvTm yevoft.evvjv ^eKTtKvjv Kai

ovKeTt

yap KaTa to arevov T^g

vofxtKrjg

aKidg Kai

TVjg

30

cv TVTTOig

XaTpeiag aKovaofxev, ovk elaeXevaeTai

AfJ.fj.wvtTV]g
**

Kai

M.a!a(3tTV]g etg eKKXvjatav Kvpiov,

dXXd tovto
Kat

dKOvaof>.ev,
**

Tropev-

"
**

SevTeg f».aSvjTevaaTe irdvTa
eSvet 6 (po(3ovft.evog
'

Ta

eSvr\^

Ta

e^^g, Ka) OTt

ev TravTt

avTOv Kat epya^ofi.evog ^iKatoavvt^v ^eKTog avTa
fiei^ovag e7rtft.eXeiag vj^twaev
;

" eaTt.

Hag

^e

dirayaym

eirei^^

35

X.

38.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
ttJ

89
veveKpoifxevaiv

T^f KKKX-^aias crvXXeyeiavjg Ik twv
eOv(t>v,

TroXvSeia

avrog

yjv

6

\pia-Tog ev avTyj, Kara ro yeypafifxevov, oiKccv
"tu^povfxevog

Kai TrepnraTiov Kai Tracrav 7rvevu.aTiKVjv

yapiv.
oi

^Tieyovai oe Tov Tiavhoyov tvtiov ol AiroaToXoi Kai

ff.eT

avrovg

Ttoifxeveg

Kai ^i^daKaXoif olg etg ovpavovg dvi^v etiOKev
Ovjvdpta, Trpovoeiv e7rif/.e\oog rov
*'

6

5

0€(7noTr]g

^piarog ovo

YjppcoaTVj-

KOTog eyKeXevadfxevog, Kai TcpoaQeig

ag edv

rt

Trpoa-^^aTrav^crvjg,

" eya
ovo

ev

tw

eTiavepyeaOai
(pvjai,

fj.e

dTro^w<x(t)

aof" ^vo

^e

^vjvdpia

rag
rov

oiadvjKag

Trakaiav Kat Katvvjv, dfxcporepag ovaag

Seov, Kai

fi.tav

eiKOva rov dvio Kat evog PaatXecng cpepovaag, ag

rd lo

ovjvdpia, Kai rov

avrov (Saa-tXiKOv yapaKryipa raig Kapttaig
eva-(f)payi(^ofit.evag

vjfxcav

^id Twv lepm Xoyim Xa^ovreg
oi

Kat evTvnovfJ.evag.

a V^

rav dyicoraroiv eKKXvjatxv

Troifxeveg,

Kat fKerd ttovxv
oiKoBev

Kai i^parcov Ta7g '^i'^aa-Ka\iatg TrXarvvavTeg, Ka\

irpoa-

OaTiav^aavreg' toiovtov yap vndpyet to vorftov dpyvpiov, eitavep- 15
ypfi.ev(a toS teairorri

Kara

rvjv

reXevraiav
fioi'

yjfj.epav

epovaiv eKaa-rog,
o'tKoOev,

K.vpt€,

^vo

OyjvdpiaO

ehaKdg

toov

TrpoadaTrav^aag

akXa
epei

'hvo

eKep^Yjaa'

kou ydp to
Ka.t Triare,

Troifivtov vjv^vjaa.

oig dnoKptBe^g

ev, OovXe

ayabe

Kai ra

eqvjg.

EiVa
**

epcoT-^aavTog rov

^eanorov ^ptarov rov
^oKei

vofxiKov,

*'

riva 20

Tovrcov Toov

rptm

TrXyja^iov

aoi yeyovevai

rov efuieaovrog
**

^'
*'

eig Tovg Xyiardg ;"

KaKeivov diioKptOevrog, ori
eiTie,

irof^a-ag

ro

eXeog fxer avrolJ," dnoKptSetg
Off.otcog,''^

" itopevov Kai av Kat

•noiei

*'

loaavei

ekeyev

avrw'

avovvjTov

yap

TVjg

tepcoavvvjg

d^tcofiia roig

Xayov^riv avro, Kat roTg ^oKovaiv eivai
vofJ.oft.aOelg, et
r-i^g
f>.v]

vou.ofx.aQea-t,

25

to uvofidaSat
i^ov

ti

avrav ev^oKiuovai rav
arecpavog

epycov'

ydp

TrapaTreTTkeKrai

dydTrvjg

rx tov

vXt^aiov,

KE<t>.
Tlfpl

AZ.
Ka\

MapSas

Mapiay.

38

M.eya

fj.ev

ro

ry^g (piXo^eviag KaTopdcoft.a, oirep
v]

vj

y\.apBa eyovaa

rov Kvpiov vTre^^e^aro, v\py]Xorepov OTiep
6

Map/a

TreTroiv^Kff

KaSag

Kvptog

y]Ui.(ov

Kat Seog Iv^aovg

^ptarog

efj.apTvpv]ae.

"napaKaOe-

^ovaa yap

irpog rovg TtoOag avrov, Kat tcov Xoycov

avrov aKovova^a

N

90

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
tyjv

XI.
ydp

5.

aintiyBYi fXH^omg wrep

MapSav.

irpo^ fKeivyjv fxev

<j>y](7t,

" Map$a, Map6a,
yap

[xepifxvoii" Kai
I5pwf/.a<7i

ra
ttjv

e^^?.

Oiite

yap ^;a rovro
Kai
Oi

Trap€tTft.eVf iva Trepi ro7^

KotXiav

OpexpiCfJLev'

okiycov

07

%/?€/« yiverat'

itept

te ravrvjg
r^rtg

ecpifjt

" Mapia yap

"

rv]v

aya^v
Kat

fxept^a
v}

e^eXe^aro,
[xepig
;

ovk

acpaipeB-rjaerat

an

5

" avrrjgr
[XvcTT^piooVj

Tii ^e ^v
rvjv

aKoy]

Xoyav akrfietag, Kat Beaptag
a(f>

/xev

ovk airearpe^pev,

m

enotet,

t^v ^e

Trpocete^aro,

e(f>

olg

'TrpoaeTy^e.

CKOTfijCag

[xev

rotvvv

rag ^vo

[xepi^ag ^ta

rm

^vo

yvvaiKm, eladyofxev, r^v [uv

<7a[t.artKa)repav

^taKoviav eXdrrw'

yjii^at^xaTdrri

ydp Kat

avrv)'

ryjv

Se dvajSe^vj-

i

o

Kviav Kat TTvevfxartKanepav' Kai eKaarog
/3ovXo[xevog ^taKoveiv roig nroiyoig

yj^xwv

6e\et eKXe^erat. 6

Kat 6epa7revetv voaovvrag, ^td

Mdp6ag
Maptav

rov Kavova rovrov XajSeh'

ydp dv

irofrjavi

rtg elg '^ovkov

"Kpiarov, eig Xptarov dvarpeyet ro

ytvofxevov'

^e

^eXwv r^v
htaKOviav,!^

^YjXSoaat rvjv KaraXeXotTrvtav rov aw[xarog r^v
eig
rvjv

dvaj3daav ^e

6eaptav rwv itvevfxariKm
ovtvvjat ^e
tv

[xa6y}[xdr(tiv, yvv]-

atwg [xereX6erw ro rrpdy[xa.
6

Kat rovg eavrov [xa6v]rdg

Kvptog

'^td

rovrwv ov [xerptwg,

ei^eTev

hnwg re Kat
ev^tatraadat
Kvjpvy^xa

riva
"xjtv],

rpoTTOv
vjViKa

ra7g
TV]v

rav

^eyo^xevcov

avrovg

otKiatg
6eiov

vTt

ovpavov TteptepyovTat, ro

Karay- 20

'ycAXovTes".

rie^^

TTpoaev^g Kat

Ttepi

rov

"

Ttarep vjfxwv^ Ttpoeypd^jyv] etg ro

Kard MaT6atov.

KE$. AH.
Hepl
Trpoa-evxfjs.

25

5

Aeyei ^e ro

*'

T/f e^

vfxwv

e^ei (piXov

xat Ttopevaerat itpog
rpoitca itapa/SoX^g, iva
[xv]

" avrov
[xv]

[xeaovvKTtov^ Kai

ra

e^vjg,

wg
>j

ev

dxptKopwg rv]v Ttpoaevyvjv 7totw[xe6a,
evyvjg Kat

Kat wg

aKovadevreg
iKereiag,

€K 7tpwrv]g

^evrepag, dvaKOitrw^xev rag

wg

ovoev e^/ovaag ro reXovv eig ovv]atv' davverwg rovro Ka6
Xoyt^ofnevoi,
Ttpoae^e^xdvjv'

eavrovg ^o
Kat
ov

ort

7tpoa^X6ov TtoXXaKtg, e^aKpvaa,

eSe^6>jv

ov

yap

eKJ3el5v]Ke

rt

Ttpog

Ttepag

rwv

aiTV]6evTwv
ort

Ttap

e[xov.
vj[xdg

yjpri

%\ [xaXXov

eKeHvo

Xoyt^ea6at

vj(xdg,

oi^e

rd

Ka6

rwv oXwv

^ea7toTV]g' Ka) Ttdvreg eneKetva

rwv v](xeTepwv

XI.

II.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
Tavra
ovv koi
to,

91

ixerpm

aiTOvfXiv.

tovtoi^

ofjioia ev6vfJi.ovfji.evot,

efj.fj.evafi.ev

TTpoaKapTepovvTe^

tyj itpocrevy^'

Kai yap

Ta

avt^pcoTi
enribv

TtopiaBevTa Kai e^ eToifxov Aiy^flevTa KaTa^ppoveTaOat

<j>iXei.

yap " ^yjTeTTe" to
TQ
^vjTovfn.evov.

Troveiv eTttTaTTet^ ttovo)

yap

aet

ittog

evpi<TKeTai

Kpovccv TTj yeipi TTpoaapaTTet tyjv Svpav^ tva tvjv

twv 5
Kat

Kpov(Tfj.aTav o-x^krjatv ovk
ovx^ eKcoV
fj.a6wfj.ev

eveyKm

T^<r eo-Tiag SeaTroT^S", avoi^if]

toivvv eK twv
Kpov(T(afj.ev

Ka6

vjfx^g irpayfj.aTav

tov

yjpfl-

atfxov

T>/i/

d-^pav,

Kat

Kai o^xK-^accfxev ^yjTovvTe^, Kat

eTrtTvycofj.ev.

To

Se

"

TTopevcreTai fnecrovvKTtoog'^ irept tS>v elg
(xvvaia6i^(7tv
ep')(Oft.ev(i>v

Ta ecyyaTa tov ro
Kai

^iov Ttpog

twv
6

oiKetoov

afJ.apTrifj.<i.T(av

Tyj "ffiaTet 7tpo(TTpe'/ov<Tt,

tovto

(fjficrtv

(f)tXav6p(aTtO';'

6

^e (fnKoi

6

T^f otKiaq Kvpiog,
Kat TOVi
fj.vi

o

0eof

^jtxwv

Kat

Yj(OTYip

lyyaovf, o itdvTag

<f)iXav,

itoog

7te7tt(TTevK0Tag

avToo,

Kat

^/i^wv

t^^v

awTi^piav avTicv' Tpelg §e apTovg avofxaae, t^v eig YlaTepa, Kat 15

T/ov, Kai 'Aytov Ylvevfxa, ittaTtv alvtTTOfxevog, ^ Tig

eaT^v ofXO'
6

Xoyid
<f>tXog

Tyjg

itavarytov Kat

ofxoovatov, Kai

^(oowotov Tptd^og.

&e

Ttapayevofxevog el o^ov

Ka) eTtt^ev(a6eig avToo,
01

voy]6eiy]

av

eiKOTdig

AyyeXog,

vjyovv 01

AyyeXot

Ttapayevofxevot •npog t>jv

ecrj^aT^v Toy ^tov copav itapaXa^e^v yjfxag'

(ptXovat

yap

y^fxag

Kat 20

avTot, T^v YjfxeTepav acoTyjpiav ev<f>poavvriv Ttoiovfxevoi, wg
<py]aiv,
*'

Kvptog
oe itatQia

oTi

yapa

ytveTai ev ovpavcp

Kai

toc e?^$-.

Ta

Ta

eitt TY]g

KXivy]g avaitavofxeva Tovg Tpa(f>evTag (og
d^TtXyj

Ta

itai^ta Kat

TtapaiteittaTevKOTag ev
y]^t(Ofi.evovg too

Kap^hia

tw

Y,vayyeXt(i> TtapiaTf^ai, Kat
cog

Kvptco avvavaitavea^at,

Kat vept tovtov avTog 25
^vaft.(ov

ScwT^p Xeyet,
**

"

oti

itoXXot

aito

dvaToXcov Kai

y]^ovat

Ka) dvaKXt6y]aovTat fxeTa

'AjSpaafJi.'*

Kai

to. e^^?.

" 'Ava<&e/av"

evTayfia Xeyet ttjv fxed
5

eitifxovi^g eTtiTeTaft.evi^v itpoaev/y^v.

de,

Tig e? vfxcov tov TtaTepa, eav aiTy]ay] apTov,
K(0(f)ov,

Kai

Ta

e^yjg,

Kai itept tov e/ovTog ^atfiovtov

Kai
**

itept

t«v AcyovTouv 30

OT^ ev BeeX^e/JoyX eKJSdXXet toc tatfJ.ovta, Kat
**

OTav to dKd6apTov
Kat eaovTat
Ttpoeypdtpvj

itvevfxa e^eX6y] dito tov dvdp^oTtov," Kai

Ta

e^y]g, ecog *'

eayara tou

dv6pxTtov

eKetvov yetpova

tcov itpcoTCov,"

elg To KaTo. yiaT^aliov.

N

2

9^

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
KE*. A0.
Ilepl Tov tx^^'''^^ baifxoviov koxJ)6v.

XI.

14.

14
TO

TiTOT BosTPiiN.
[xr]

K.a}(f)Ov

KaKeT^ lo KncfyoT^Ta ({xmiovv it^og
^aifxoveg
•yap TtovyjpoTaTOi
Trepi-

aKOvaSrjvai

Xoyov Qeov'

eXovTeg to evvjKOov t^c twv
TYjv aKorjv TYji -i^JvyYjg'
'hi.a

avOpcoTraiv Trpoatpeaeag, eTTi^pcoaav yjfxwv

^

tovto 'KpiCTog TrapeyeveTo, iva eK(Bdkri
ovOe

To

^aifJ.oviov
yjv

TO

KCticpov,

Kai dnovcrwixev Xoyov dXrj6eiag'
Kwcj^og,

yap

€Ke7vos
TcSv

6

^atfjiovi^ofxevog

dky.

etg

eTvyyave

oeiyfjia

irdvTaV tov ^e eva BepaTtevety iva KaSoktKOv yevf^a Trapaayvi
oiKovfxeviKYjg acoTvjpiaif Kat OTav

T^g

eU

(K yeveT^g TV(f)Xos

o-oj-to

fxaTiKccg

evepyeTehai, irdvTeg iivevfxaTiKwg evayyeXt^l^ofxeBa' Kai
eig
evt,
fJilv

OTav eig TrapaXvTiKog ^a^tay],
Tpe^/ei,

^ta
too

tio^wv
TVji

irap

e\7rida
alviy-

Se

Kocrfxog

dfna

tco

^ia

7it<TTeag

fiaTt Tpeyei tov ^pof*.ov TYjg
TVjv

dXyjSeiag,

dXX
l^iag

01

iTOV^poi

fi.eTe6vjKav

evepyeatag

elg

yor^Tetav,

t^c

vTTOxpiag

ovTeg

avTOt 15

f>.a6rjTat.

Ktfiaaot 14ae3anapeia2.
wvofJ.da6at
6avfj.aTog,
^o^v]
(paff.ev'

KceJ^ov

ev

TOVTotg Kai

Tov

d(pa>vov

tovtov

Ka6apta6evTog,
yj

TeXea6evTog

tov

KaTeKpoTet fxev

Tvkridvg

TaXg
rov

ev(f)Yjfi.iatg

avTOV, Kai
Ttveg
Se,

SeoTipeTielt

aTe^avovv

vjTielyeTO

6avfj.aTovpyov'

20

(fjvjatv,

e^ avTwv, ovtoi

Te vjaav ypafXfxaTelg Te Kat ^aptaaioi,

diiovota Kai (f>6ovw fxe6vQVTeg ty^v Kap^iav, 7rpoa6i^Ki^v tyj voao)
6avfJ.a TreTrotvjVTat,

to

a(ptaTavTeg yap avTov Ta 6eoTrpe7rwg eipyaa7rpoaveveft.vjKav to

fxeva,
^i

Tw tta^oXw

° TrdvTa ^vvaa6at KaTop6ovv,
tcc hatfLovta.

avTOv ydp avTOV eK(BdXXeiv ecpaaav

25

Akta.

°

laTvjai

juev

ydp

j3aaiXeiag
fxvi^eva

twv

v7ro

yelpa to

yvvjatov, laTVjai

he oiKovg, to
ev

KaTa

TpOTrov

dvTt(f>epea6ai

Tivag dXkviKoig twv
/SovX (3aaiXetav, to
IlaJf ovv

avTw. eaTi^ae ^ dv Kai t^v tov BeeX^eavTOV kavTW ^pav e6eXeiv
;

fxv]

toc

evavTia.

iK^dXXei Y^aTavdg tov "EaTavdv

ovkovv

ov')^^

eKOVTa tcSvSo
(pvjatv,

av6pw7rwv eKTrefxirovTai toc ^aifxovia, ov
YiaTavSig

yap fxdyeTai,

6

eavTW, ovk

eTrtTrXviTTei

To^ig

eavTov

^opv(f)opoig.

'Evyfors.

n rS Cod.
repon. 'AwoX.
i.

o 'AkvK.

Cod.

Nonien

vid. esse

corruptum

;

e. 'AmXtvaplov.

XI.

34-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
T»;v

93
ivvoeiVf

KpoTiT ^e fJLoiWcv

eavTov PaaikeiaV XuireTai toivvv

OTi 'hvvafj.ig 6eia avvTpi^ei tov 'EaTavav.

TiTOT BosTPaN.
vaaiv
01

^lov^^aTot

Kai e^ lov^aioov

KaTa tjapKa yeyo-

[xaKapioi fiaSi^Tai'
(.(jy^-^Kaa tv

ovTot Trjv

KaTa TTvevixaTm aKaddpTccv
ovj

k^ovJiav

Tiapa ^piaTOV, Kai

Kai airvjkXaTTOV Tovf 5

Iviayyiix^vovg, eTrKpuvovvTe^ avToTs to
'

"cv

ovoixaTi Ivj(tov X/Jifrroi)."
vioi

Ore

Toivvv, <f)i^aiv, ot e| vfxav

yeyovoTeg

Iv ovofxaTi

fxov tov

BeeA^e/SoyA BpiafK^evovaiv^, eTnTrXyjTTovTeg avTov Tovg hopvcpopovg,
Kai df/.eXXvjTt twv eyovToov avTovg eKTrefHTrovTeg, irxg ovk evapyvjg
^va-(f)iqfKta,

TroXv

to

afkaQeg eyovaa avfXTreTrXeyfnevov
rr/v

tw Xeyeiv,\o

tfxe

^avei^eadat

'bvvafKtv,

TrapdKXi/jatv
viro

re

tov BeeX^e^ovX.

KaTaKptBvjaeaOe

toivvv,

(f)Y/aiv,

Tvjg

viaTecog
efxov

twv e^

lfj.wv

yeyovoTwv vtxv, enrep avTot
Kat
hvvaft.tv,

fxev tvjv irap

Xaj3ovTeg e^ovaiav

TrapaXvovat

tov

"EaTavdv,
^^

Kai

ovk

eKovTeg

toov

e)(pvT(t}v fi.eai

avTov eKirefHTrovTeg'
evepyeTv
€f/.e

vfxeTii

Xeye^e TaTg eKetvov dvvd-iS
KTretVrj te

Keyjpvift.evov

Tag

Beoaiqfxetag.

tovto

fxev

ovK dXvj6eg, exXov ^e fmXXov eaTt Kai KaTtxpevafJievov Kat
ey^ov ypacpy^v, 'npo^vjXov OTt ev

avKotpavTiag

^aKTvXx Seov eKpdXXco
<f)V]ai.

Ta

^atfkovta'

^d^TvXov Qeov to'Ay tov ITvevaa
'E-yw fiev

Ktpiaaot Aaesanapeias.
tva TrdvTag
e^eX<i)fj.ev

yap

eire^^-^fxvjaa, (f>v]ai,

20

rwv tov "^ta^oXov yeipav, tva
(ficcTtao)

ai')(^(j.aXaTovg

ovTag eXevBepctiaw, Kat
aTVjaci),

eaKOTtafi.evovg, Kat

TreaovTag dva~
tcc

Kat avvTedpavafnevovg

tdau}fi.at, tva

ra TeKva tov Qeov
^co-^v.
^e'

tteaKopTrtafj.eva irap

eKetvov ^vjXovoTt, avvaydyco eig
efJ.ov

ye

^aTavdg
eacoaa.
Ovvafii.tv

fj.vi

oav

fj.eT

eTriyetpeT

aKopiri^etv

d

avvvf^a Kai 25
^t^coai
ft.01

Tixg ovv
KaQ
;

fj.a^xpft.evog
;

TaTg

efj.aTg oiKovofiiiatg

eavTov

dp

ovk evvjOeg xo oleaQat ye TotovTov Tt
avfi.l3ePvjKe
irept

yeyevvjaBat

iroQev ovv

apa

ToTg

lov^^atcov

tvjfj.otg

to

KaToXtaBeTv etg ToaavTag evvoiag
eiirm, otx

^iptaToVf avTog diead(pvjaev

" OTav

to aKdBapTov

irvevfj.a e^eXBv] diro Toi) dvBpctiirov,^^

^o

Kai Ta

et;-^g.

24
**

QpirENOTS. T< eaTt to ^tepyeaBat to
avv^pctiv

Trvevfi.a

to irowipov

"

Sx

TOirm

^vitovv

dvdvavatv Kat

fj.v]

evptaKcov ;" dnxjtpot tottoi

01

cf eBvav TO

irpoTepcv,

vwi Se

ireTrX-^pccTai

v^aTog

Betov,

KOt

P Tp/jSowiw*»

Cod.

94

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
TroieiTat

XI.

37.

QVK€Tt '7rape-)^6vaav avdnava-tv avToTg'
irpog

toivvv eTTtCTTpo^fnjv

TO TTpOTCpov avTov ooy^eiov tov eg
6eiov

lapayjA,

Kat

wg evpev
ovTag

avTOvg ovK€Tt

eyovTag

ev

avTo^g ovteVy aXX^

ep-^fJLOvg

Kat (jyoXa^ovTaq avTth irpog evoiKVjaiv, KaTWK-^aaTO ^^Aa^^ fJieTa
Tid.ayig

avTov

TYjg

^vvdfxecog.
fJLCT

Tovto yap

(f)aiveTat '^tjXovv,
eirt

"

eiTTa 5

Xeyoov eTepa TrvevfJiaTa
ovof/.d^etv
*'
7]

avTOv^^ KaQdnep eiaSev

TiXyjBovg

6eia ypa(prj tov too-ovtov dptOfix, eTrei^av Xeyvj,

"

oti

aTetpa

ere/cev eTiTa,

Kat

yj

TroXXr]
qttoiov

ev

TeKvotg
ev

vjaOevi^aevJ'^

ov^e

yap TO
eyovatv

TrvevfJ.a
ot

to a^d^apTov
tov

eayov

AtyvnTd}, TotovTOV
TreTiXyjpwTat

etg

Ttov

fj.ov

dTricrTrjo-avTeg'

Kat 10

akXm
Tm'

TiovYipm, Kat yeyovev avTolg
ev AiyvTTTca

Ta eayaTa yeipova

tSov Trpo)-

yeipova yap t»v

vvv itdayovGtv, eTreitypiep

eig

Ivjaovv \pt(7T0v ov

TreTTtaTevKaa-tv,

aXka

tov dpyYjyov

T-fjg

^ccvjg

dveKTetvav, o6ev ea-Tep-^Oyjaav TVjg
irpocfjyjTyjg,

^(ovjg'

Kat ovKCTt keyet ev avTOig
ay]fj.e7ov

Td^e Xeyei Kvptog, ovk eaTi
ay]fii.eTov

ev avToig, ovKeTt 15

vepag, ovKeTt
0el3y}Ke

eirtcfjavetag
e<f>

Kat irapovaiag tov Qeov. fJieTa-

yap Ta dyaSd
*'

y]fJt.ag

Tovg e^
yj

evSSiv,

tovtov^ 'li^aov

Koyov elpyiKOTog,
*'

dpO-^aeTai dir avTwv

j3aatXeia rov Seov, koi

^oO^atTat eQvet frotovvTt Tovg Kaprrovg avT^gJ'^

KE4>.
Ilfpl Tfjs
e/c

M.
iirapda-Tfs (fxovrjv.

20

Tov o\\ov

27
'*
.

A;a

Tt

Ti^g

yuvatKog etirovayjg, " fj.aKapta

y]

KOtXia

yj

j3aaTd-

aaad

ae," Kai
fj.aKdptot

Ta
ot

e^yjg,

avTOg "KptaTOg

^ea^iroTyjg eiire,

"

ft.e-

" vovvye
**

aKovovTeg tov Xoyov Toy Qeov Kat
(fjvfatv'

<f)vXda~
eTret^^yj

aovreg avTOV ;" dpfno^ta^g Trpog tov Katpov tovto
01 TCtiv 6ei(cv

25

ydp

koyav dv^Kooi Tovg vnyjKOovg tovtcov KoreKptvav,
Xonrov Ve Kai

avTOg TO evavTiov irotm, fLokXov fLaKapi^et TovTovg'
'

^td Tov ia6evTa

Kuitftov,

tva

Kai

avTog aKovaag

fnddyj,

Kai fna^iiv
aTe(f)avcii6Yi

TrtaTfvay], Kat irtaTevaag epydarjTat, Kat epyaafxevog

Ka\ do^aa^y] f/^eTa irdvTcav twv (pvXaaaovTCOv Tag ^eairoTtKag evToXdg. 30

avep
ecag
'*

etirev

heairoTyjg 'KptaTog,

"

oti

yj

yeved avTV]

7rovy]pd eaTtv,"

eo"Ta< (f)xjeivov okov^ 7rpoeypd(f>y] eig to

KaTa MaT^arov.

H Tov

Tot/

Cod»

XI.

37-

AOYKAN ETArrEAIOT.

95

KE$. MA.
Ilepl Tciv aiTovvTav OTjfifiov.

33

OvBeiS' Se

Xv\vov a-^as

ciy

KpvTrrov TLdrjcnv, ov8e wro

TOV flodlOV
Avyyov

K. T. €.
ev

ep^ovTe^'

avToHi; ol avBpaitoi

t^v voepav

^vvafj.iv,

ovkS

(ig ro €jX(pav€;
fJLrj

ayovai TavTrjv, a\k €ig to a^av€g KpvTTTovci ro
€KXa[x\piv

^i^T€iv ry^v

Toy vov,

aXXa t^v

e|a?56v

Kai fxaTaiav

XaixTipoTi^Ta.

avrv)

yap yiverai
vj

ir^pt

rov vovv crKorog, €ig Tiovripiav

avTOv

€KKaXovfj.€vrj, ola trj Kai

irepi

Tovf ^apicaiovg ^o^a irapa
rtft.wfi.€Vov

Tw

"TrXvjOet (f)6ov€px

Kai KaKOYjBiog Kara rov

TiapaaKeva- lo

^ovaa, Kai Trpoadyeiv ^ia aTOfnaTos Xoyovq dae^eii Kai avKocpavTtKOvg,
ovToc

yap

cvdoBev Kat

dito

Kap^laq

€pyoft.€Vov

ro aKorog,

oXov TO
fxrj

aicfj.a irXi^po7,

ov fxovov ro arofxa Xoywv
"Xj^tpag eirt fxiai<f)Qviav

cfJ.-fftirXctiaa
'o

rwv
Kat

^iKalm, dXXa Koi

eyeipovaa'

^vj

irpdrrovai fxiKpov varepoVy diro tov <p6ovov irpog rov
fX€vot.

(f>ovov

eyetpo- 15

e^ov ovv vfxh,

(f>y]at,

Ka6apov KaraaKevd^etv rov
eai/Twv
o6€V

vovv,

Kai

^ta

rovrov

KaraXafxirpvveiv
Se

rovg
y^rj

re

Xoyovg
(f>oog,

Kat

rag

irpd^etff

vfxe^ig

rovvavriov,

irpodyetv

€vr€v6€V

irpodyerai aKorog.

KE^. MB.
UtpX Tov ^apuraiov tov KcikeaavTOS t6v
*Irj<rovv.

20

37

T/vof €V€Ktv

irovifjpav

Kai (Be^vjXwv ovrwv rwv ^aptaaiwv Kai
KXiq^eig irap
kvog

PaaKdvav Kai
Qeog
dyvoav
yjKev, yjfxav

dXa^ovcov,

e^

avrm \ptaTOS
;

ov

TraprjTVjaaro,

dXX

€ia€X6a)v
6 irdvTa

av€KXi6vj

ovy^

ag

t>jv

Ivovaav avroHg aKator-fjra

€ihwg rovro irevoi- 25

dXXa vov^er^aai

rovrovg eireiyofxevog, fxvarayayiag

vpo-

(paaiv ro irpayfxa iroiovfxevog.
^lEaKav^aXia6v] ^e
a6rj,

^apiaahg,

ort ov irpo rov dptarov e/SaTrrieiroiovv eKehoi, pvirov
'Travrog

aavverwg a<po^pa, rovro yap
evofxt^ov,
iroieiv.

eavrovg, wg

diraXXdrrovregf

ovep ovtafxov irpoaeraJ^e ^o

Mwiiy^f toDto

96
M.ovYj

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
yap ^ia tZv v^aTWV
anovixpig

XI.

42.

y^peioo^eaTaTyj Xiav eaii,

ToHg pvTtaai

aw^aTiKiO';, aKaOapaiav Se t^v elg vovv Kai Kap^iav

aTraXXd^ai ov ^vvaTai.
Kvpto^y "
vfxeTi; ci

Ta

tovtcov aKo\ov6a, otov ecTTtv, eiTtev
iioTrjpiov^^

^apiaaioi to e^wSev tov
^/^afe<

ewf
to

"

to

" yap "Ay lov
M.aT6aTov.

rivevjtAa

vfjia^"

Trpoeypdipy]

elg

KaTa 5

Ktpiaaot i\AEaANAPEiA2. 'E^^v |W,ev jap

Kai eTepot? Xoyoig

yj)rjaaG6ai tov K.vpioy, vovdeTeTv eSekovTa tov aavveTOv ^apicraTov,

em^paTTeTat Kat tov Katpov Kai
(patvei TVjV fXvcTTaywyiav'

oiov eK
ev

twv

ovtcov
Tpocf)^]^

ev

^(epiJtv

e^vj

wg yap

Katpw

Kat Tpane^vjg

o

evapyeg VTro^etyfxa ^e^^eTat to

TtoT^fjptov

Kat tov ittvaKa, Kat ^tay^pri

^eiKvvatv OTi KaGapovg Kai eKvevtfxixevovg elvat

Tovg elXiKptvwg

XarpevovTag tw Sew, Kat ov
Kr]g'

^'^tiov [xovrig

e^ aKaGapa-tag a(ti[xaTt-

dXXa yap
Ta Totg

Kai Trjg eig vovv eaco KeKpvtxfJievi^g, Ka6d7rep afxeXei

Kat

Tpaire^atg e^vTrvipeTovvTa tHov aKevoiv Kat twv e^ccBev 15
pvTtoov, ev

eXevdepovaQai

av

ey(ot,

Kai itpoaeTt tovto

Tm

eaco.

O

yap

Tiotrjaag

to e^coQev

(prjai,

Kai ra dvcoOev
yjpri

eTtotrjae,

TOVTeariv

TO aiofxa KTtaag, Kat ^v^^r^v eipyaaaTO.
TTOtrjfxaTa tou (ptXapeTov

Totyapovv ev oaoi ra
ttjv

Seov avvtpofxov eyet

ditoKdSapatv^f
f^e^^^^pt

dXX
ydp
'*

rjv

dXrj6eg tovto ToTg ypafXfxaTevat Te Kat ^aptaaiotg'

20

fxovov tov 'hoKeTv elvat

Ka6apovg avTovg itdvra ^pav eairov^a^ov,

Td(f)otg KeKoviafxevotg "TrpoaeotKOTeg^'

Kara

Tr\v

avTov tov HcoTripog

(pcovrjv,
'*

"

e^'jo6ev fi,ev

wpaToi, eaw6ev ^e yefxovTeg oareiov veKpoov koi
''AXX

Trdarjg

aKadapatag.''^

ov ToiovTovg rjfxdg eivat (3ovXeTat

'KpiaTOg'

dyiovg t\ Kat afxwfxovg ^vyr\^ re Kat awfxaTi.
e^e/

25

43

'^A

ydp

fxdXtara KaTop6ovv, Tavra irapevTeg
rrjV

wg

ewXa,
eKetvag

TOVTeart

Trjv

Kpiatv Kai

aydrtriv

tov %eov,

fxovag

aKptjSwg eTrjpovv rag

evToXag, rjyovv Tr]peTa6at irpoaeTaTTOV Ttapa

rov vito %^Tpa Xaov, di irXetarag avToTg XrjfXfxaTWV o^ot rjaav Kai
d(popff.at,

waTe

f*.rite

Ta

tS>v

Xaydvwv XeitTa Kai ov^evog d^ta^o
dyditrig
Trjg

Xoyov TtapaTpeyeiv avTovg'

epyov ^e

etg Qeov,

to

KUTa

fxri^eva

Tpoitov

itpoaKpovetv
^e
rj

avToo,

"he^tevat

^e

tov

itavTog

vofxov Ttapdpaaiv,
larjg a^iovv
^

Kptaeoog

ttKatOKpiaia

Kat to

(ppovTthog

Ta

Te^eaittafxeva, Kat fx^ pa6vfxeTv fxev tSov dvayKaiay'

Leg.

vid. ex,(iv

sed alia

manca

sunt.

^

xpvxnv

Cod.

XI.

50.
Se

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
To7i

97
tioi-

fxovoii
€i(T6ai

emK€pM(7iv axpiPas opav, «AXa vpoaK^tv^
rrpi
€(f)

Trjv

\pri(f)ov

e/faCTTO?

irpayfxaTt'

to
€(TTt'

yap a^iKa
to, toivvv

Kpiv€iv

ovK ayaTrrjV t^v e/V a^€k(f>ovs TripovvTOJV
(TvveKTiKa
ixr]

avayKaTa Kai

TrjpovvTe^ tov vofxoVf

Ta^

'htKo.Tag

Xafj.l3(xv€iv ea-TTov^a^ov

Kai tcSv CfTfAeaTaTWV.
^'ijTerv

5

To yap
7rpo(T€^p€V€iv
[j.vriix<xTm

aaTraajaou?
€v

napa

iiavTCiiv

tuv

ev

ayopa, Kai to

(TvXkoyoig irepi iroXXoy irotel^TBat (xirov^a^ovTeff
ov^ev ha(f>epov(7i'
€i(Tt

o^rjX(t>v

a

^tairpeiret

/txev

to/V e^coSev
fJiot

KO(Tfj.otg^ [j.e(TTa

le

vdarjg aKaOapcriai. evTovQd,

/3Ae7re
avOpct)-

ltaf3€P\r][j.evrjv

eo^aTcws t^v inroKptatv to Trpog ape(TKeiav

lo

irwv airavTa ^taTrpdTTeaOai.

Aia

tovto

(f)rjatv o [J.aK(xpiog

Ylav-

Aof,

"

€1

avQpanrotg vjpeaKov, "Kptarov ^ouAos' ovk av

r][j.r]v"

KE4».

Mr.

Uepi Tov TdXavKTfiov twv vofUKmv,

46

Ava(f)opr]Tov
7rkr]v

[/.ev

aet

irasg

eaTtv avBpwTrta iravTi to ekeyxea^at,
fj.e6iaTr]ai

i

S

ovK avovr]Tov ToHg eirteiKeai,
a6pei

yap avTovg
Tolg

eiri

to

a[t.€tvov.

tovto

Tretrov^OTag
[i.€V

Tovg irapa ye
tSov

Iou^a;o;j

(ovofxaafj,€vovg vofitKovg.

yap

oXcov Y^oiTr^p eTreTifia To7g

^apiaatoig, wg c|« rpe-^^ovat Tr]g evdeiag o^ov' irpog TavTa Oe to
TCtJv

avoaixv

vof/.tKav e^^^aXeTratve aTi(pog.

eavTovg yap viro(f>€povai 20
vofi.i^ovaiv,

ToiV

eyKXrjfJMai^
e(f>r]

Kai

Ka6

eavTav
^v

eiprja6ai

a

irpog
fj.€V
[i,rj

€K€ivovg

'KptaTog'

aXX

^'^irov

KpehTOV, ayair^aat

Tov eXeyyovy atTrfaai ^e t«v app(caTr]fj.(XTCov t^v Xvatv, Kat
v/3piv a[J.a6(hg tov

eXeyyov

ovo[i.<x,'^€iv,

eir^o^eXr]

ovTa Kat

yjp-f^at^xov.

Ti

oyv Trpog

TavTa KptaTog

;

eirtTeivet tov

eXeyyov Kat t^v eiKaiav 25

anTwv

o(f>pvv KaTa(f>€p€t Xeytov,

" Kat

v[xTv ToTg vo[J.tKoTg ovat."

^o
OTt

Ylept Se

Tov ZayapioVj ov
ea^fxiiyr],

etrrev

Kvptog ort [uera^v rov
"^vaar^g (pr^atv,
rrjv

Bvataarrjptov rov vaov
iraTr^p eart

aytog Vpr^yoptog
Kat
e7re/&>;

tov

irpo^po[j.ov'

ovK aireyjaptae

iravayiav 6eoTOKov Mapiav, kou /otCTa tov a(f>6opov tokqv, tov raTg 3*^
irap6€voig
a7roK€KXr]p(0[t.evov

rovov

ev

roo

vaoo,

^v

Se

ovTOf

roirog [j.€TaJ^v rov

vaov Kat rov dvataarr^ptov, e[xapTvp€t Se

Kai

fSaaiXea

rrjg

KTiaeag etvat rov eig yewr^atv av6pomivy]v

oiKovofj.tKag

o

98
el avr^f

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Kara
ak-^Seiav Trpoa-eXQovTaf
<j)oj3(ja

XI.
rov
[j.r]

52.

yeveadai

^aciXei

vitoyeipiovg^

tia rovro rov lepea fjiera^v rov vaov Kai

rov 6v(xia(7rvjpiov Kareaipa^av.

52

Oval

vfjuu

TOLS uofiLKOLSf OTL rjpaTe TTjV KXelba rqs
5
**

yvuicrecos.

Ktpiaaot Aaebanapeias.
€ivai (pafxev rov vofnov

KAer^a

yvxa-ewg*' Ka\
'^ia

avrov

Kai ri^v ev ^piaroo ^iKamciVf

iiKJreug
rvTro),

t\ ^yjKovori ryjg
Trkvjv

eU

avrov.

^v

jU,ev

yap

vofxog ev

aKia Kai

ol

rvnoi

^iafi.op(f)Ovai

r^v akyjQeiav Kat ypacpovaiv ai aKiai
fj-var-^piov.
fA.ovog

voXvrpoTTWi ^f^h ro \piarov
rov rov Moova-eag
aifii.ari

ea^pa^ero

Karaio

vofxov'

vjadiov

twv Kpewv avrov, Kat
rov
oXoQpevryjv,

eyjttov

rag

(f)Xiag,

Kat

veviK-^Kaai

aXX'

alft.a

TrpoPdrov koivov ovk av tayyaev avarpe^ai Qdvarov.
Vifi

efuop(povro
^(cvjg

ovv

wf

ev

dfj.V(p

^ptarog, t^v

VTrep rvjg

rov Koivov

vtto-

ff.eva}v a-(j>ayv]Vf

Kai

aw^m
ttd

atfj.art

tw

tht(a

rovi fi.ereyovrag avrov. 15
§/

TtXe^iara

S'

dv rtg 'npog rovro Keyotro,
r^/jg

wv

evec7T;v

lte7v

ro

X-pta^rov fj.varvjptov

rov

vofj.ov

aKtdg ypa^pofnevoV
ort

eipYj

Se TTOV

Ka\

avrog ro7g

lovQaioig

TrpoXaXooVf
ei

"

Karviyopav

" "

vfnoiv M.ci}va^g, eig ov vfieig yiKittKare'

yap

eiitarevere Mwi»'eypaxpe.^' Kat

ae7, eTTtarevere

dv

efxoi'

Tcept

ydp

efj.ov

eKetvog

20

ndXtv,

"

epevvdre rdg ypa(f)dg, ori cv avra7g ^0Ke7re vfxe7g ^a^v
ej^e^v,

" aiaviov

Kat avrai etatv at fj.aprvpovaai nept
jtxe'"

efJ.ov."

Kat

"

ov

OeXere eX9e7v irpog

a^Trag

ydp

6

Xoyog

ryjg QeoTrvevarov

ypa(f)yjg eig
KTietVlfi

avrov opa, Kai
ovv

eir

avrw avvreiverai.
vofj.tKOvg,

rovg KaXovfj.evovg
vofJ.ov,

dre

^yj

rov Mcovaeag 25

7roKvirpayfj.ovovvrag

Kat rag rav

dyim

irpotpyirwv ovk Yiyvoyj'^yjij.otg

Korag

(pcDvdg, dvotyet

rpoTrov rtvd roig ^lov^alaiv
eiri

rdg

ryjg

yvcoaeag 6vpag. irat^^aycayei ydp 6 vofxog
§e
elg

^piarov, diro^pepei
irpo^ffrm
evae^yf

hrtyvcaatv

avrov

Kat

rd

rm dytm

Ky}pvyfJ.ara.

dXXd rovro

fiev ov TreTrpdyaatv 01 KaXovfxevoi vof/.iKoi,3'^
t>?v

€K ^e Twv evavrtav ijpav
vofiov

KXe^i^a ryjg yvaae^og,

tva t»/v
t*;v

^id
etg

yetpaycaytav

evvo^g

yjroi

t^v Trtariv, ^yjXov h ort
Triareag
ryjg

'Kptarov, irpoaytverat

ydp

"ttd ry]g

dXyjSetag

yj

yvaatg'

Kai yovv

6 Trpo^pyjryii,

'Wadiag ovrw

ttov (pyjat'

"

Kat eav iriarevyiref

XII.
"
oi5S'

4-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
fxyj

99
evap€<7Ti/j<rai
vofJi.iKoi'

ov

crvv^T€,"

%wpif yap

Tilaiecoi

a^vvarov

voT€. ^pav Toivvv Tr]v K\e7^a t^? yvcoaecos o/ KaXovfJHVoi
ov

yap

etcov irKXTivcrai

Tivag eig tov tcov

oXm

'EcoT^pa Xj3/<7tov, e/
eiri

Kai Te6av[j.aT0vpyr}Ke TTOkvTpoTrcci' ol ^e Kairoi Oavfxdaai ^eov,
TOVToig avTOv ^ieavpov Ta?
(TKav^^aXi^ovTes ecpaaKov,
Qeoa-yjfjjeiag

Koi Toy?

vtio

yetpa XaovgS
yi)fi

"

ovTOf ovk €K/3d\Xet to.

tai[Ji.ovta el

"

ev

BeeA^ejSoyA apyovit
ev TOVToig t5;v

tcov 'baifj.ovicavr

Opag

KXe7^a

TVji yvcocrecog atpovTag'

e^^i^aaKev

ev Ta7g a-vvayccyatg, (pavepov KaGeaTrj TOtg dKpoct)[J.evotg to BeXfifJM

Tov Geov Kai

WaTpog ro dyaOov koi

TeXetov Ka) evdpeaToV

oi

^e lo

TavTag avTov Ta$ fivaTayciyyiai ovk
Tat.
Ti
vpoae(f)covovv

dfxcofx-^TOvg dcpevTeg dXtaKOV-

yap ToTg
;

oy^Xotg, ^atfiovtov ej^ez

Kat

fJ.atveTatf

aKoveTe avTov

yfpav

ovv

KaTa to

dXYj^eg tvjv

KXeT^a t^?

yvccaeccg, avTot ^e ovk elai^XGov, KCKcoXvKaat Be Ka) eTepovg.

KE<^.

MA.
^apKTaiiov.

15

Ilfpt T^f C^i^-li T<op

Ktpiaaot Aaesanapeias.
epyov €V
yifJ.epa
Qyj

'Aiiag yap

yjtxoiv

Xoyog Kat irav
yj

Kptaecog eaTai (pavepov, TreptTTV] Totyapovv
y]fJ.ag

vtto-

Kpiatg, 0€i

dXyjBtvovg

opaaBat •npoaKvvyiTag.
evavtpiav dXet(pet Tovg

4

ToT

attot.

E/f

Trvevfi.aTiKyjv

dya- 20

vSivTag avTov Xeyco yap vfx.h,
airXcjig irpeiroi

(pyjai, Toig (f>tXoig fJ.ov, ov/^

airaaiv

av,

cag eotKev,

irept tovtcov

Xoyog, eKetvoig ^e fj.aX-

Aov oig av evvTrapyccv opwTO to e^ oXyjg Kaphtag dyairav avTOV,
olg Kat apfLo^et
**

Xeyetv,
yj

"

Ttg

yjft.ag
y]

yjaptaet diro
Xtf/.og,

t^^ dydirfig tou
yvfi.voTyjg,

^piaTOv
yj

;

BXii^tg
;

aTevoyjapia,
fxyj

>; '^icnyyfj.og, yj

25

**

fxayatpa

01

yap

Totovxot, evirapaKOfj.taToi

Xtav eiai,

Kai irpog aTroaTaaiav eTotfxorepot.

Kat
yjKei'

fj.€T

oXtya

Ylpoa€v6vfj.eTa6at
Trovcov

he TovTotg

KdKeTvo irpoadv6pci)Troi

evptaKOVTat yap ^ta
actifxaTog eKTeivovai

ol

aTe(f><xvot,

Kat

fCev

f^eyjpi

Tag opyag, Kat irepag avToig

Trjg

Ka6 30

rifxag
fj-eyjpt

eiriBovXyjg
fj-ovyjg

TYjg
yj

aapKOg 6dvaTog, 0eoD ^e KoXd^ovTog ov
^yjfxia

aapKog

aT-^aeTat,

dXXa

Kat avTr]

avvwo-

O 2

100
<f>€p€Tat

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
ralg oiKeiaig
tj

XII.
[xaWov
6

13.

a6\ia

^vy^^^'

ovkovv

€i<rir(o

[ler

evKXeiag Bdvaro^f elg o^px^^ VH-oii ava(f>ep<ov areXevri^rov ^«^f.

ToT
avroV
KareKTiv

ATTor. 'Ooocf
€1

oavjv TtoieHrai rriv irpovoiav

rav ayaTToovrcov
olov

yap
eTii

fJ-ey^i

rav

ovra)

evreKeardrav eKreiverai, Kai
fcocyv, Troif

ra

irdvriov
;

[xiKporara ru>v

av eTriXddoiro 5

rav dyairwvrav avrov

ovye roaavrvjv avrav TroieHrai iipovoiaVf
ei^evat AewTwj', Kai olov yjpiOfxvjixevas

ag eKaara rwv Kar avroiig
e)(eiv

avrav rag rpi^ag
otKovofJitKcogy tva

;

rj

yap ovk edaet

TrecreTv

eig Treipaafjiov,

^ yovv

TcaBovreg

evhoKtfi.vjaoifi.ev, elg '^rayiha Treaetv

eirtrp^/agf yoprfyriaet irdvras Kat ro ^vvaaBat '^ieveyKeTv.

10

KE4>.

ME.

Ilfpi Tov 6fXopTos [ifpicraa-dai Tfju KKijpovofiiap.

13

A/a

ri Trpog rov elitovra avrSo,

" ^t^daKaXe,

eiTre

tco

a^e\(f>co

"

fjLOVf

fj.eptaaaGat
fj.e

fJLer

efxov

rvjv

KXvjpovoft.iaVf^ aTTOKptde^g eivev,
yj

"

av6pa)7re, rig

Kareari^aev apyovra

fj.eptarYjv

((f)

vfj.ag;" 1$

eirettYiitep

eKemg KaraXtirav avrov ra

xp-riatfj.a

Kat irpog aiory]"

ptav

'4'V')(/li

avvretvovra, itept yyiivm re Kat

itpoaKatpiov TtpayfJM(og

Tcyv, e^-^ret f/.€ptarvjv

avrov yeveaSatf rovrov ydptv
cov

oyXYjpov Kai

ovoev ebeXovra fj.au€tv

eyjp-^v

eihevat, itpacog aitoTtefj.Tterat, Kat
rvjg

ug

afxtKporpvxog Ttept

r^v

airvjatv yevofxevog

avrov

fj.tKpo'

20

•Ttpeiteiag'

TteiOm
itavrog
fiy]

^ta

rovrcov

avrov

re

Kat rovg rore koi vvv re
Kat
TtpoaKatpov

aKOvovrag,
TtpdyfJ-arog,

fj.€v

dito<f>otrav

yvjtvov

(ptXovetKovvrag d^eX^poTg, etKovrag fKaXXov avroTg,
aito

Kav

ei

0ovX<ovTat TtXeoveKreTv'
fj.vj

yap rov

*'

aipovrog,^^ ^P^^^h

"

Toc

aa

aTtairet'^'

^vjreTre

^e fxaXXov

ra

oaaitep eart %pi7- 25
eTtvjfyaye Xeycov,

ertfJ.a

Koi dvayKaTa itpog acorvjptav xpvx^g'
diro

ho

Kat

" opdre Ka\ (f>vXdaa€a6e,
cog

vdai^g TrXeove^ta^^' Kat
vjft.Tv

ra

k^vjg'

l3o6pov rivd ^taf^oXiKov irapatviov
6
ao(f>og

ravrvjv diroipevyetv, Kat

^^ Kai e^coXoXarptav
irov •npeirovaav

ovofj.d^^et
v\

YlavXog,

<og fiovcog

rdya

roTg ovk

eitoat ©eov,

Kat iaoard6fj.Q)g e^ovaav 50

€ig /Se^^^Xcoaiv ro

Xarpevetv rivdg ^vXoig re Kat Xt6oig.

.

.

XII.

17-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
KE$. Mr.
Hepi Tov ov
riv(f)6pr](rfv
f]

101

x^P^

liKovalov
ij

lo

iJwf d€
** x/jtap^/ovroov

oy/<:

e<7T/

ev tco

irepiaaeveiv tivi
/1,17

^wy}

avrov €k rwv

afToD," Sia to
y](xiv

irXovrx avveKrciveadai ro T^f ?»^f
Kai

fxerpov,

KaBag

aatpcog

re

evapya^ vire^ei^ev avro$ 05
avve^evyfjievrjv

Secr^OTTj?

^piaroii t^" to??

TtpoeiprjiJ.evoig

Trapa-

fioX^

eii

[xdXiara avvreSeiKev.
vj

" Avdpamov yap
Kai Ta e^^f

Tivof," (pi^aif

"
17

TrXovaiov evcpopfjaev
XjO»?

•^oopa,^^

Se

aKOTt-fjaai

rjfJiag

aKpij3ai ro rov Xoyov
ycopiov,

evre^^^yov, ori
e(f>if],

ov^

ev

vjfjLiv

ev(f)opi^aav
rca

elae^ei^e

dX\

oXvjv,

yjJjpav

10

evKapnov yeveaOai

KeKryjfxevx,

iva

fji.d6cofji.ev

tov

"TteiBovg

ro

Padog' Kai yap orav ovtw woAXoJV
yjnpelrai 7r€(f>povTtKa}g,
fiovos aitoKavetv

Trepiyeofj.evog dya^ol'; arevo-

"

ri

ydp

Troi-^aoo ;" (f^vjat, ^to

Kai eaKeTtrero

rav itpoaovrwv aurx,

ovy^ opwv Ttpog ro fi.eKXov,
(f>iXoitTO)yj.ag,

ovK avafSXeitoov itpog rov Qeov, ovK epav
cvTfu^ev avyrifji.drm
yoorepov,
e(j)tefj.evog,

Kat rav 15

dXXd Kat

ro ert rovrov itapaXo-

eavrw
epoo

fj.y}Kog

opt^et ^oovjg, ooaTtep ck «y^f Kat

rovro 6epieyetg

aag'
*'
**

**

yap,"

(f^vjat,

"

t'^

^vyy

fJiov,

^vyv],

TtoXXd Kat

dyaQa
0€Of

Ketfueva etg

ervj

itoXXd'

(f>dye,

itte,

eixfypatvoV ^to

€/7rev

afToo, a(f>poov, ravrrj

r^ vvKrt

riqv i^vj^iyv
;

aov ditat- 20

*

rovatv aito aov,

a
/

he ijrotfjiMaag, rtvt earat
vj

aXvjOeg ovv, ort

'*

ovK ev
>

Tci)

Tteptaaevetv rtvt earat
V
>
''

^oovj
'

avrov eK twv vitapyovrxv
arjaavpigoov
/1

~ « ayTco. »
*'

^

N

Qto ro eitayofj.evov ort

ii

ovrag

"

V

eavrw Kat

'

~

^

V

fxyj

elg

Qeov ttAoutwv,"

(f>ol3i^6evT€g, fj-i^^e

etg evvotav rov
Xafj.7tpa'ig

TtXovreh
6

eX6oofx.ev'

Tptafj.aKdptog

ydp Kat

ev

eXittat

Kardi^

©eov

TtXoVTOOV.

A(f>poov

^e

^tKaicog

eKX'^6v],

eitet^-i^

vtdg
**

d(f>poov

rotovrog Kat
itdg dv6poo-

fj-dratog, Ka6o}g

Kat 6 ^paXfLw^og

<f>i^(Tt,

itXijv fj.drv]V

"

"Ttog

6y]aavpt^€t, Kat ov ytvooaKei rivi avvd^et avrdJ'^

Ta

dKoXov6a

rovroov,

oiov

**
fj.r]

fj.eptfj.vdre

rv]

^vyr]

vfJMV^^
itpoa-

30

vpo€ypd(f>Y] etg ro

Kard MaT^arov,

eoog

" Kat ravra itdvra

" re6-^aerat

vfj.7v"

KrpiAAOT 'Aaebanapeiaz.
€v aypoTg dv6oov i^pvfj.evy]v Kat

'O?

d-ao

ye

roov itrrjvoov

Kat tc5v
ittartv,

dKardaetarov epya^erat aoi
y]fJ.dg,

evootd^etv ^e oX<ag ovk e(f>iy]aiv

ori itdvry] re Kat Jtdvroog

r^v 35

5

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Tca^ avTOv ya^iC^exai
</)e/Sw,

XII.

35.

to avei/&€ef e^' aTraai ^ioovg'
iroos

" Kara-

" vo^^aare"

Xiyoov

" ra
to.

Kpiva,

av^dvei" Kai ra

e^yj^,

'AATjSef ^e toSto*

yap

tc3v yjpvji/.drm avBri iroiKiXa

re ovra
ev

Koi iroXvei^v} ev Kpivoig [xev Kat ev eTepoi$ Tiai tSov

(f)vo[x,evccv

dypoi$ d^io6av(jiacrTOV eaTi

tyjv copav'

irpog ^e [AifJiyjaiv tvjv

avToov 5

VTTO^aXXoiJievov to Teyyovpyovi/.evov XenreTai 'TidvTCcs CKeivcov, Kai
[xoXig ep^/eTai
e^x^ei,
'ttcc^

TVjg dXrfieiaq

eyyvg.

E< toivvv tovB

ovTCog

Trwf

oiiK

dXrjBeg oti

ov^e Y.oXo[xm, KaiToi (piXoTi[i.oi ovtco
cog ev

yeyovag, ev

oXvj tyi SoIij
ao(f)o7g

avrov vepiepdXeTO

tovtwv.

Airoy^^v}

TOiyapovv To7g

to %f3e/af eveKa Kai

[i.ovrig

eva')(r][ji.ova
[J.r}

Kai 10

evnopiaTov

e^/eiv tvjv 0"toA>;v,

Kai anicav XiTOTrjra
17

vnepaipovrj

aav TO dpKovV

dpKeaei ^e Tolq dyioig
Koi Beia Kol
vorjTrj,

ev
17

'KpiaTco Tpocprjy

'jTvev[iaTiKr] ^rjXovoTi

Kai

[LeTa Tavra Qo^a.

32

M>;

(f)ol3ov

TO [AiKpov

7roi[J.viov"
rj

dvri rov [t^ d-niarrjarig eipvj-

rai, [J.iKpov Ve
Tco

ttoi[i.viov ovo[J.d^ei,

eTrei^r}

irapaKeirai [xiKporrjg ev

1

Koa[i(a Tovrco roig eKovaicog aKT-f^^Koai Kai

dy^rnxdroig,

r}

'hia

TO

r^rrdaBai rr}g rwv

\yyeXcov

irXrjBvog
r}[j.dg.

d^xerp^^rov
etnciov

ovar}g,
ev

Kat
roov
tco
[xr}

davyKptrcog iiXeoveKTOvar}g ra KaB
eKarov TrpojSdrcov irapa^oXrj,
TtXav^BevTi
ort
eTTi

yap
evi

r^

'/atpei

eiri

rw

[jmXXov
roig

koi

evpeBevri

^

rolg

evvevrjKovraevvea
eirt

20

7r€'7rXavr}[f.evotg,

e^et^ev ort cog ev ev To7g eKarov, ro
d[j.eTpr}Tovg rcov avco
r}

yr}g eari

itoi^xvtov Ttpog
et

rdg

Ttvev[i.dTCov

ayeXag.
07*

aXX
itavTa
irvev-

Kai

ovrco [LiKpov eart, (ftrjatv,
Se^cuice

rov 0eoy ayaBorr^g
rcov

Xoyov VTrepeKretvovaa,

Kat avrw

virepKei^xevcov

[xdrcov rov KXr}pov, rovreart t*jv
ovrco

twv ovpavm PaaiXetav'

ovv

ra 25
eiri

[xeydXa Kat

e^atpera ^t^ovg, ircog OKvf}aet irXovaicog

ra

yr}i iraper/etv ^[liv
yo[t.evov'
(f>r]ai

dyaBd'
'*

Trpohr^Xcag

eKirXr^povvrcov

r}[j.cov

ro eira^ore

ydp,
Kat

'jrcoX^r^aare


a^nep

vTrdp^/ovra
irpoeypd^^r}

vfJMV Kai
eig

"

eXer^ixoavv^v"
ecog **

rd
r}

e^r}g'

ro

Kard
30
ov ti^v

MaTflaZbv,

eKe7 Kat

Kaptta

v[j.cov

earat."
7repteycoa[Levat,

^S

tjtircov

ori

earcoaav at oa(pveg
oa(f>vv

v[j.cov

Tov aco[j.arog

^ie^coa^ievi^v r}[xdg e^e/v

irapaKeXeverat,
e<p

aXXa

TO Ty}g ^tavotag erot^xov eig (f)tXepytav To7g
To7g eTratvov^xevotg.
a
«;

airaai

tr^^kovori

Cod.

XII.
O/

39&€ Xiyy<ii

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
t>jv

108
vovjtvjv

rov vov eyp-^yopffiv kou (f)aitpoTV]Ta

€iritv]\ovaiv, iva

apervjv a(TKovvTtg, Kai
'hia

tov irpocpopi^TtKOv Kat tov
ev

ev^idQeTOV Xoyov

vavToq ddTpaTiTovTa
d[JL(poT€pcov
e^o>

t6

Tvj

i^i^^, ev t€
fX€V 6

t^

yXuTTVj ej^ovTe?, ^/
yjft.dg

€Kkd[x.TTCi}[j.€V.

yap

cvOov

(f>coTi^€if

6

^e

Tovg

dWovg'

^ton€p

^t^a(TKa\tKog $

Kvyyog

\\ivyov(TS(o
[xv]

Kat dp^€V€CTQ(ti Kai
v]

Tp€(f)€a6(iD

vao T^f TrpaKTtK^i

dp€TVjg, iva

cKOTHVOq

Kai aXafJ.nvig.
t'o

37

Vd[Mvg
VTtdp^/ytv
'^Y]Xov

%€ ovQ[j.d^€t, ^ta
tv]
6€i(X

[j.v]^€v

oXojg
(j>v(T€t,

KaTV](p€g

v]

Xwi^pov
<f>v](Tt,

Ttapa

Kat aKV]pdTca

tva eA^ovTOf,

Se OTi €v Tvj ^cvTcpa, avTov irapovataj dSpooog Kat dooK-^TCog lo
ddipcDg

KaSdmp

t«v vvktwv e0;crTa/x6Vo?,
«yToy, ov?

oircp cv][JMtV€t

to a^ij€vpY]

Aov T^f vapov(Ttag
€TOl[liOVg, €IT€ 6V

av

Ttap€(JK€va(7[i.€vovg

Kai

T^ ^€VT€pa,
avrov

6;T€ eV

T^
Kat

TptTV] (ftvkaKVJ
"^td

T^f VVKTOg^

rv]V

Trapov(7tav

dva[ji.€vovTagy
€i(7t,

rovro Trdaav ap€Tv]v
€K€7vot,
Trept^o}-

€pya^o[jt.€vovgf

"

[j.aKdptoi

(f>v]<Ttv,

oi

^ovkoi

15

"

o-€Ta/

ydp Kat

ttaK0VY]a€i avroigJ'^ rovrccTTtv ori rolg t(rotg v][JMg
v}[t.h

avTa[i.€f4'€Tai Kat oiov KdfnvovTag avaKTV]a€Tat, Tpv(f>ag
6€)g

irapa-

rdg

Trv^vfj.artKag,

Koi

iroAi/TeA.eaTaTvjv,

^axptXy^,

TroiKtkv]Vj

d[Ji.(f>tXa(f>v]

Twv eavToy
rovg
/w,ev

'^apta-[tMTCOv

dirXoia^i

rpaTr€^av.

Nofnt-

<Ta[t.€v

Se

riqg

vpwTv^g (f>vXaKV]g rovg

€Trt[X€X€ar€pov 20
7r€pt

^tovvrag, Ka) irapd Toy? dXXovg dypvTrvwg

'^taK€t[>.€vovg

rvpt

rm
vovg'

dyaBS)V Ipyaatav, Kat

'^ta

tovto

irpcarv^g

To^ea»^ €Tr€tXv][/.[/.€-

rovg

^e

T^f ^euTC^af, Toyf VTro^€^v]KOTag' rovg Se T^f

rpir^g, rovg rovrcov Kara^€€aT€povg.

39

Ttveg §6 7rpwTV]v
Tftiv

Koti

^^vripav (f)vXaKv]v Kat rpirv^v ro ^td(f)opov 25
vjv

v]XtKtwv

€^Y]yv]aavTo, irpcoTv^v jaev, Kaff
te,
vjO€i

7ra7^€g €a[j.€v dvv]v]V
€Ci}g

{3ot,

^€VT€pav
€t

Ka&

^v veaviat, Kat TpiTV]v, Kaff

7rp€aj3vrat'

TO Oe,
dTrtarwv

otK00€a7roTV]g,
7rpo€ypd(f>v]

Kat
ro

ra

eq^i^g,

[i€ra rcov

B-^a€t,

€ig

Kara MaT^arov.

Kig ra

[LtKpa €tg T>jv €p[i.v]V€tav rov ay(oKiov.


rov
e|«w

'OpirENOTS.
dvQpcoTrov Kai
<f>v]aiv 6
*'

Kartv

vvrvog Kat ^ypvjfyopatg^ axrwep litt

€7rt

tov €aw'

dTrairovfi^Oa rotvvv €ypv]yop€vat,
[j.v]

KoSd

Hcor-^p'

"

ypv]yop€iT€ Kai 7rpoa€vy(€aB€, tva

€ta€\6v]r€
v]

€ig 7r€tpaa[j.ovr
(Btoi

Ka^

[Jk€r

oXiya

IlA^v Ta voXXa
irv}

Kara

Trdvra ev toS

toutco dypvirvv^TCov

€art,

/xev

^ta ro €06- 35

104

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
"
oyj^
ciuii.a

XII. 46.

opeveiv Tovf TroXefxiovg ovrag,

Ka\ adpKa, aAA* €^ov(Tia$

"
*'

Kai Koa-fxoKpdTopas tov Koafxov tovtov, Kot "TrvevfiaTiKa ^ T^f
TTOwipiai"
IV

eK Tov eypyjyopevai
opveov

o-w^afAeBa,

coaTrep

^opKai

Ik

jBpoyctiVf

Kai waTrep
Kai

eK

Tiayi^^og,

Kai

"

iva

Tag

oa(f>vai
Ofi.oia

"
*'

"Trept^iccrafjievoi

rov^ Xv)(yovg dvaiirofxevovg eyovreg,
Ttpoa-^eypfJ.evoig
ev6e(i)g

5

yeviOf/Le6a

dv6pa7roig

tov

Kvptov

eavrcov,

iva

" eX6ovTog Kai Kpova-avrog

dvoi^wfkev ayToo."

Eb ANEnirPA*oT.
^iatpe^Yjvat
jU.eTa

^tyoTOfi.iav (pi^at

tov KaKov ^ovXov to
^taKOTii^vai

to

e7rtavfi.j3e(3yiK0g

avrw, Kat

di:

ayrou

fxeydXav Kat ccpo^pav dXyy^ovm' aTeA^f yap evpe^^^aerat 10

ToioyTOf, avev 6eiov Ylvevf/.aTogf

aap^

Sov

Kai ov TivevfLa.

eTiei

TOT6 eafnev ev irvevfnart Kara tov ^noaToXov, orav Ilveyjaa Qeov
eartv
ev
yjfuv.
ccg

fxepog

^e

dreXeg diioXetcp^eig earat fMera rav
Titarewg

aTriaraVf

dv ov^ev

tiJs'

anoXavaag

etg acoTVjpiav,

aXXa
ly

avv

Tco

dTriarco

KoafLO)
vj

KaTaKpi6eig, Kai roaovrco ye

f/i.ei^6ov

15

KoXaatg, oaco 7rXe7ov

ydptg.
'ttyoTOfJ.Yirov^

46

EAflojv ovv

Kvptog tov toiovtov

tZ ^mrt eavrov
oog
ft.Yj

Xoyco Kat
fkevovg
01

evepyeT vTrep iraaav fj.dyatpav ^iarofuov,

yevoetatv

oXoKKyipovg Tivevft.art

Kat "^v/y] Kat

acoft.aTty OTroiot
yj

dyta^ofxevoi oXoreXeTg, wv oXoKXvjpov ro nvevfj.a Kat
aS)fi.a
dfi.eft.Tircog

^vyy], 20

Kat TO
Yjfj.ciov

ev

tyi Ttapovaia TYjpelrat tov Kvpiov
t^Yjg,

\y]aov

^ptarov' tva ^e aacpearepov
^t't'Kve7a6at

iipoaeye

iicog

dv

voYiBetYj

eK rov

rov ^covra tou Qeov Xoyov
e7itfJ.eptafj.ov

eTitfji.eptafJLOV

T^yp^ijf
01
fj.ev

Kat irveyjtxaTOf, ovrtva
ovv tiyorofj.ovfj.evoi
ov Tietaovrat.

^l^vy^g Kat Ttvevfj.arog

Tietaovrai, 01

Ve iitarot

Kat

<f)povtfj.ot

25

oiKovofJ.ot

Xoyog yap

ev

avrolg TiotYjaag

ra

afj.(f)o-

repa

ev,

Kat ro fneaorotyov rov

(j)payfj.ov

Xvaag, rovg

"hvo

eKrtaev

€tg eva Katvov dv6pco7iov, Tiotcov eip^^vyjv, Kat
rSo 0eco.

aTioKaraXXd^ag avrovg

A/a
"

Tiotav airiav

"

SouAoc

fj^ yvovg ro 6eXY]ft.a tov

Kvptov 30

avTov, Kat 7ioffiaag d^ia 7iXi^ycov," vTieyet Xoyov;
'hvvdfj.evog
fi.Y]

'^tori fXY} Y}6eXY]aev

elMvat,

fJM^eh'

ei

^e

oXog ovk dfxotpog opy^g fj^ yvovg

earat, ort

ei^wg KarYifxeXYjae tov fxa^eh, ^iolog d^iaXXd^et Xoyog

rov yp^vat TioXXdg xmoft.ehat ^iXYjydg, rov ei^ora Kat paBvfXYiaavra.
^ wvtr/xaT* Kou Cod.
c

Leg.

fors. hyfirofMiVit, sed excidere plura.

XII.

49-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
"
TTavTt
<a

105
irap

EiiiFwv §e OTi
**

e^o$v]

TroAy,

iro\v ^rjTrjO-^aeTai

avTOv^^ eScilev oti <f)opTiK60Tepov tHv ^t^aaKOVTUv to Kpifxa.
Tloia &€ Tavrd eariv a
^y]TVj6v}(T€Tai

irap

avToiv

;

to ev

tti-

CT€i opOoVf to dirXaveg elg iivoTayayyiag, to jSefSi^Kog ev eATrio/,

TO aKaTaa-eKTTOv ev

inrofJLOvyjf

to dBpavdTov ev lcryyi

tt} TrvevfxaTiK^,

5

TO e/V Tav OTiovv twv dpiaTCOV dv^payadi^fjidTwv
eycrfleves",

'irpoSvfJi.ov

t€ Kat

oxTTe /fa< eTtpotg vTroTVTrcoatv eivai iroXtTetag ayyeXtKrig.
vjX6ov
ecog

To

**

irvp

^aXeh
**

hrt

Trjv

"yijv"

irpoeypa(f)y]

etg

to

KaTa

MaT^arov

Kat

to ecrp^aTov Aeirrov airo^oif
Trvp
yjfx.(tiv

."

'Eh ANEnirpA*oT. TowTo TO
eavTorj" eAeyov,
*'

eyovTeg

oi

Trept

KAewTrav

cv lo

ov^t

yj

Kap^ia

Katofnevrj

^v ev

yjfAiv ev Tyj

" 49

oha, Kat

wg eXdXyjaev

^fnTv, Kat ig
**

'^ffjvotyev yjfiTv

Tag

ypauftdg,**

ToT Xptsostomot.
TVjV
v(f>

Tlvp yjXSov (3aXeiv

eirt tvjv

717V,"

ovk

eirt

y^v

tvjv V(f>

vf/.eTepotg iroat 7raT0Vf/.evy]Vf

«AA

eiri Tvpf yv]v tv]v

efLaTg

y^pat

TreirXaafi.ew^Vf

eiret^-^irep

^tdjSoXog

Taig

Tav 15

dvBpconcov
fjidToov'

Kap^tatg dKdvBag

Kai

Tpt^oXovg eveaTretpev dfLapTV]hrt tv]v 'y^v, Kai r/ 6eAw el
tvjv
€fJLV]v

"
;

Trvp

v]X6ov

hrt^aXeh
fLe

v]tv]

av^(pOv]

Oet

yap

Kaaaptaat

yv]v

oet fkeTa

tov

^ta(3okov TrtKpo(f>opa Kat ^Xa^oirotd ^XaaTV]fJi,aTa irvpt e^avaXa-

aaif tva Ka6ap<a
**

tv]

tpv^^vj

Ka6apov tov ovpdvtov airopov
etp-^vy]v,

ev ovpavca.
fj.v]

20

OvK

y]X6ov

yap fSaXeh

aXXa

fjMyatpav^^ eav
etpv]VV].

ya-

XAaa Tw

cyPpco vfjJav fidy^atpav,

vfn.7v

ovk ea^at

Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias.
y]fj.cov

KaiToi 'K.ptaTog eaTiv
ovv,
vj

yj

etp-^vv]

KaTo. Tag ypa<f>dg.
'y^f
;

Ilwf
fj.€v

€(f>v],

ovk ^X6ov

eipv]vy]v

^ovvat

€iri

T^f
ov

OTt 'X£V]fj.a

€lpv]Vf]

KaXov Kat

ovTcag

dyaOov, 25
eaTtv

aAA

Trdaa iravTcog

etpvjvv]

to dKaTd\\^eKTov ^yet,

aXX

e-jrtacf^aXvjg

iroXXdKtg Kat T^g eig Qeov dydirv^g diroKOfJ.tXovaa.
v]

XAva/TeA^f ydp
laa

Trpog

Toi/g

eT€po(f)povag

€ipv]vv]f
eirt

Ka^dye to tu
(ptXTpcov ot
<f>tXtav

(fjpovetv eKeivotg.

Ata tovto ydp

Kat tcov

y^f

viaTot a(f>taTavTat Kat avyyeveTg dyvoovai^ Kat TraTvjp vtov
dvatveTat
*,

30

Kat viog iraTpog

Ttfj.v]v

dyvoel, Kat

fJ-^^TVjp

6vyaTpog

<f>tXTpov dsrcoaaTo.

' avlyfrai

Cod.

106

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA

XIII.

i.

KE^. MZ.
Hepl
Tcop ra\ikai(op Ka\ tS)p ip

r&

^ikaayi.

Tlipi Twv TaXiX.aiav wv dir-^yeiXav
avTccv
€i(Ttv
01

tw ^piajia

ori to alfxa

II/AaTOf

efii^e [xeTa twv Svaiav, yj)^ yivuaKtiv oti ovTOi

Toi^ ^oyy.aaiv e^aKoXovS-^aavTtg

'lov^a tov TaXiXaiov,^
f/.efi.v:^Tai.
v}V

ov Kai

AovKag

ev

TaHg Tlpa^eai tuv AiioaToKwv
kcu
o

Oe To ^oyfJLa xov 'lov^a, ^g
TYji

'laat^Tmog ev ToHg TeKevTaioig

iov^taiKVjg

ApyaioXoylag

e^ei^e, (pavTaaiav

e^ayyekkm

ttoA-

Xfjv irpofpaaiv S^flev evaejSelag.

Kvptov

yap

f>.y]^e />t€%/"

aTOfiMTog,

ecpaaKCi
avvrjv'
irepi

fJLrj

teiv Ttva keyeiVf

fi.i^^e

KaTa Tiva

Ttfivjv

Kai (f)t\o<ppo- lo

oi/TOJ
fKYi

Se /a^tc tov jBaaiXevovTa.

o6ev Kai ttoXXoi

ye avTuv

Tov

eiTteh

Kataapa

Kvptov, '^(aXeTiaTaTatg

atKiatg

wetc5

^aWovTO,

01

Kat etitaaKov

fxyjVev

napa

to.

ttaTeTayfxeva ev

^wvaeug
Tag
T^^
vTto

vofioSeaiag dva<f)epea6at tco

©eoj.

Atoirep Kat eKaXvov
Trep)

T^f yepovatag tov Xaov Trapa^e^ofJievag yiyveaQat
'Va}f/.ata}v

15

amvjptag tov ^aatXewg Kat tov
eirt

eSvovg

Qvaiag.

etKog ovv

TOVTOtg ayavaKTOvvra irpog TaXtXxx.tovg tov TitXaTOV

KeXevaat

itap

avTatg atg e^oKovv KaTo,
ooaTe

tov

vofj.ov

irpoa^epetv
irpoacpepoovv
eiretTrep

Ovaiaig avTovg avatpedrjvat,
ft.evatg

avaft.tyPy}vat

Ta7g

Qvatatg to alfxa twv

irpoacpepovTOov.

TovTa

20

e^OKet vTrep
fxevot

evae/Seiag yiveaSai, aTr-^yyeXov tco

SwT^pi, j3ovXoevofj.t^ov

TO

eTrt

TOVTotg dpeaKov avTw fxaBeh'

Kai yap

Ttveg

diro Tov

Xaov ^tKatOTaTa KaTo, Tag dfiapTiag avTwv TavTa

Treirov-

Oevat Tovg avaipeBevTag,

«Te aTaatv KtvyjaavTag Tag

tco

Xaw, Kai
^to

ent TO fj.taeh epeBiaavTag Tovg dpyovTag

KaTa twv
Tt6rjatVf

vTryjKOWV'

25

avTOg TO fnev

elvat

avTOvg

dfj.apT(oXovg
fi.Yj

ov

/x^v

(pvjai

TavTa avTOvg
EiVa
efJ.(f>vXiov
eirt

Treirov^evai,

ag twv
oaov

ireTrovBojav yeipovag.
tc3 p-^fj.aTt,

TovTOtg

(prjaiVy

eiri

airoTpeTrm T^f
airo

aTaaecog irpocpaaet

evae/3etag dvaTrTOfJ.evovg Tovg

Tov XaoVf TO
l3dXv]Te

"

edv

fj.r]

fii.eTavo^avjT€,*'

TovTeaTtv, eav

fj.rj

[xeTa-^o
ov

Tov aTaatd^etv Kai av6taTaa6at ToTg dpyovaiv,

oirep

KaTa

l3ovXvjfj.a irotei

tov Qeov, TrdvTeg

OfJ.ot<i}g

diroXeiade, Kai to

vfj.eTepov alfj.a dvafj.iyp-^aeTat vfj.eTepati Ovatatg.

^

XIII.

II.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
mawv
^i

107

4
6

'O TTVpyoi
Tcov

cv tco

2/Aoa/x ovx «f afxapTuXoTepovs iravKa6(i)g

ovTas TOVi ^€Ka Kai OKTW Kare^^^aaeVf

Kat avTog
Tfjv

(f>rjaiv

Kvpiog,

aAAa

oXiyav
}j.€v

v7roh€iyiJ.a

To7g

oIkqxxti

l.€pov-

aaXyjfx, yiyove.

Kai 6

€lg Ttvpyog

TrapajSdWeTai

oXyj

t^

iroX^i,

iva

TO fxipog

€K<f)ol3-^avj

tq oXov,

oi

^eKa Kai oktu tw Xa^ t^?S

TtoXewg' odev eTienrep TOvg

otKTjTopag

ra

ti}c

dirtaTiag

€V€fjt.€iv€,

Kai avTOi avv avT^ fKtKpov vffTCpov To7g avToTg ir^pieTreaav oig irep
6 irvpyog
crTp€\li€V

Kai

oi

^€Ka kui oVt», ot€

Trjv 'UpovaaXvjfJL 6

TiTog KaT€-

Kai TToXvv Kaov eBavdTCoae.
avKVjg Trapa/SoXvj tyjv dKapiriav eXeyxjei t^j 'lepovaakvjfJi, lo
irpocpvjToov,
"^i

o

'H T^g

^ia Mcot/Vews-, ^ia tcov

eavTOv.
avKVj
vj

IsiAiiPOT IlHAOTSiaTOT.
eaTif 6
^e
oiKo^eairoTvjg 6

'H KvayyeXiKVj

dvBpamoTfjg

Qeog Kai

YlaTvjp, 6 Se dfXTreXovpyog o
rjfJMV
j

Tiog Tov 0601/,
ev^rjfx-^aagf
Tr}v avKrjv
vofJ.ov

(j^iXoTrovyjaai

Kat €KKa$apai tov dfj.Tr€kv)va
oiKO^€airoTov

CKKOTrrjvai

Se

irapa tov

K€X€va6eiaav
€i

wg oKapTrov, e^ avrrjv
irpoiprjToov
\jca\'\

(fyrjai

Kat tovto to €T€pov'

^ia

Kat

ovk
To7g

elSeXTiaOrjaav

Kat fLCTavoiag Kapirovg

ovK dire^nKaVf

€fi.o7g

dp^€v$iiat ^oyfnaat Kat iraQyjfj.aat'
ei

Kav fuv
€KKO\j)rjg

"Trof^awat

Kapirov eviretBetag'

§e

ft.rjyef eig

to fxeXXov
fxept 'hog,
rj

avTrjVf €ig

tov aXXov aicova Tvjg
rj

twv ttKatav

%o

€KT€fJMV avTovg'

caTt Se

TrpaTr} dOeTi^atg Trjg IvToX-^g,
€V

irapa-

I3aatg

rj

diro

tov ^vXov, tov
rj

fj.€aw
oj

tov Trapa^etaov TrpoaTaTvof/ico

Tovaa

fJLTj

y€V€aQat'
r}

Se ^euTe^a,

ev too
ev Trj

^vaaejSeta

rj

irpog

Tov fj.oayov'
Trjaig,

Se TptTi^

aae^eta
€i

rj

yapiTt Tvyydvet TrapaiKat tov Kvptov T^f 25

" ovk

€yofj.€v

^aatXea,

fj.r]

Kaiaapa"

^G^rjg aTrapvovfj.€V(jov.

8

Konpta

Se

Xeyet to, ^aKpva, Kat Tovg aTevayfxovgf Kai Tag

yafj.€vviag, Kat
^i

Tag dypvnviag, Kat

TVj^tv

^vy^g Kat

aci}f).aTog, t>jv
cag

€^ayop€va€Ci}g Kat dTtfxoTepag dycoy^g eiravopBcaatVy

OeoXo-

yog Xeyei Tprjyopiog.

Km. MH.
Utpi
Trfs

30

^xovoTjs irvfvfia aaOtveias.

II

'H avyKinrTovaa

yvvr}

tovto

Xeyerai iraBe^v

e|

aypiOTrjTog
€Tr}

^ia^oXiKrfg, KaQclog <f)r)aiv

^taTroTrjg,

"

rjv

etrfaev

Y^aTavag,

P 1

108
" ^€Ka Kat

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
o/cTW," Jtrwf 7rapec»pafj.€vii]v itapa

XIII.
"ti

17.

©eov

oiKeTa

11x01,1-

afiara' Trapaniof yap roig avBpuirivoig

(j(6fj.aai

rov vo^xeh

aki-

r^^piog yeyove "Earavag, BeoTrpiTtiaraTri Se Xtav
yefJiovaYj
Tvjg

(fxov^ Kai e^ovcriag
rvjv

avccTaTCCf Tfjg

yvvaiKog ravTrfg

voaov

eXavvei

TTpoac^iTidvjai §e Kai y/ipag avryj, iva fxddccfxev, ori t>jv tov
"Koyov ^vvafuiv
vjv

&eov ^

re Kai evepyeiav
ovy^

yj

ayla

iie^^opr^Ke (Jap%'

iQia

yap

avTQV Kai
l^iKiog,

erepov rtvog Ttap avrov ovrog Tiov KaTafJ.ovag
'^okovv.

Kai

Kara ye ro rtaiv avocmoraTov
'Kptarog
itpog

nept

m

etitev

^e(nroT7]g

rov apyjavv(xy(oyov irepi rov

aa^^arov^
10

TrpoeypdtpYj etg ro

Kara M.ar6a7ov.
eitt

17

Ft^xaipe ^e

Xaog

itaai

roHg

evto^otg rolg

ytvofi.evoig

vn

avrov,

eTtett^r^

ra iiapa^o^a epya ekve Ttaaav
ot ap^^^ovreg

^"^rrjaiv

itapa ye
eitt

Tolg ft^ KaKO-^Oetav ^vjrovatv, onep

eTtparrov,

Ttpo-

(paatv

vofj.Qv

tov

SwT^pa KaKag

vjSpt^ovreg.

KE4>.

M0.

15

Ilept rStv Trapa^oXav,

IQ

ToT

ArioT ElPHNAIOT EHISKOnOT AoTrAONOS.

1^6 KOKKOV

atvditecog

^ta Ttapa^oXvjg ^etKvvfxevov, Kat Xoyov eitovpdvtov aitepev
Koafj.(a

fj.arog '^tKYjv

ag

ev

dypw

a7teipof/.evoVf

eyovrog ev eavrio

TO TtvppaKeg Kai ro avarripov T^f

'tvvafj.e(og.

Kptrrjg
rrjg

yap rov

itav-

20

Tog Koafkov eKrjpvaaero, ovrog ev

rrj

Kap^tcf.

yr^g ev yafj/x.Ti

Kpv^etg Kat

Tptrjfi.ep(ag

fj.eyiaTOV

^ev^pov yevvrjSeig, e^eietve rovg
yrjg.

eavrov KXa^ovg eig ra itepara
ot

rrjg

Ik tovtov TtpoKvtpavreg

^co^eKa AitoaToXot KXd^oi (opahi Kat ev6a\eig yevrjQevreg, aKeTtrj
ro^tg
01

eyev^Qriaav

edveatv wg 'Tteretvoig ovpavov,

v(f>

wv

kX(x,0(cv

aKe- 25

Ttaadevreg
rrjg e^

itavreg wg opvea vito KaXtav
7tpoep-)(Of/^evi^g e^oo^^ifxov

avveXOovra, fxereXajSov

avrav

Kat eitovpavtov Tpo<f>^g,
rrjv

21
rr^v

QpirENHS
Se
^y/XTjv

rrjv

y.ev

yvva^Ka Xafnj^dvet etg

eKKXrjatav,
rpta,
aa)fj.a,

elg

ro Ylvevfj.a ro 'Aytov,

adra

t\

Ttvevfj.a, i^fvyriv,

dytd^erai Se TavTa

t'^ ^vfLr]

rov dytov TlvevfJLa- ^o

Tog,

eSf

yeveaSat itpog to 'Kytov ITvevjaa, ev (pvpafxa.
Se CTepa

Ta

tovtwv

itepi

tc tow kokkov r^g atvdiiefog Kai

irept

$

XIII.
T^f

26.
ea)f

AOTKAN ETArrEATOT.
Kai
*'

109

^v[Ji.y]g

eiatv -^pZTOi oi eaovTai ea-yaroi,^^ '^poeypa^rj

€/$ TO

KaTa MaT6a7ov.

KE^. N.
UepX Tov
eirepcyrTj(TavTOs el oXiyot ol (ra>^o/xevo{.

25

'Q.$

yap

€Trt

Tivog oiKoheaiioTOv

iroWovg tZv

iTriTYj^eioDV

awe-^
fx-eff

yvjyepKOTOs elf eaTiav Kai Tpave^av,

eha

TrpoeicrPe/SyjKOTOs
tov<;
fJieTa

uv e^et TOVTO ^pav, avoKXeiaavTos t€ t^v Qvpav,
Kpovovrag aKOvaeaSai
<j>v]aiv,

tovto

OTt

"

ovk oi^a vfiai voSev eaTe, airoov^efxia

"

aTVjTe air efxov TravTe^ epyaTat attKtag'^^
irpog aKOTog.

yap Kotvmia

<f>coTt
**

rtveg S av vovjQeiev

ot

XeyovTcg, to5 ^ptaToo to 10
ev

€(f>dyofi,ev

Kat

eTriofi.ev

evwirtov aovy Kat

TaHg irXaTetatg

y]fi.wv

"

ett^^a^ag f^ dpfnoaetev av
S*^

ToiovTog te Koyog, fidkiaTa To7g e^
OTt oxpeaOe

lapay]Xf oig
**

Kat

e(f>y]

^ptaTog, "

A(3paafx Kat laaaK,

Kai laKaP, Kat irdvTag rovg

irpo(fyf]Tag^^

Kat

ra

e^rig.
J

26

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias.
vtov Tov Seov
;

n«f

ovv yja&tov Kai eirtvov evco-

t^^v

vofj.tKY]v

TeXovvTeg XaTpetav, TrpoaKOfxt^orreg

yap

tcc

SeHo
^e Kat

rag
ev

^/

aifx.aTog

Svatag y^aStov Kai yjixppatvovTO,
tcSv

y]Kpo(tiVTO

raTg avvaytayaig

Mwi/Vewf (StPXtav, ov
irapa tov Seov'
Ae-yez K.vptogJ'^

Ta eavTov yeypacpoTog fxaWoVf
irpoaveTiSet

epfJ.y]vevovTog ^e to.

yap de) Tav eavTOv
dpKei
irpog

(fxovav
y]

to

**

TaSe

20

'A\)C

ovk

^tKaiaaiv

^i

aifux,T(ov
fx.ev

XaTpetay
Setoov

ovQ

av dirov^xpeTO Ttg

fi.o\vafi.ovg,

aKpoary^g

TOiv

yevofJievog

vofJMVf Treirpoc/jog Se

ovtev tS>v KeKe\evafj.evQ}V, Kat eTepwg Se t^v

VKTTiv ov
yeXiKy]v,

Trpoay^Kdfj.evot

t^v ^iKatovaav tov evae^r], Kat

t');^

evaytvjv

6eaniafi.aatv

dKoXovS^aavTeg,

tt

wv

y]v

^vvaaSai
et

25

ev(pva Kat e^etXeyfj.evy]v e^aaK^^aat ^wyjVf Trag av

eXdaetev eig

t^v PaatXeiav tov
erepovg
**

Seov

eiraptBfx-^aetg

To7g avofxaafj.evotg,

Kat

rtvag

^vvafj.evovg

eiveiv,

eaff

ore

ruv

Trdvrccv

KptTy^g,
yjfJMV

e(f>dyofuev Kat eiriofJ.ev

evamov aov, Kat ev TaTg irXaTetatg
;

**

e^/^a^af." Kat rtveg av eiev ovTot irdXtv
eig rov

iroXJXot

TreTriarevKa-

^o

aiv

Xpo"TOV, Kat rag dytag

eir

«vtoS reXovaiv eoprag.

(fjotTwvTeg

^e

Kai ev eKKXyfata twv evcvyyeXtKm aKpowvTat irai-

^evjxdnov, diroTiOevTai Se c/V vovv rSv yeypafj.fj.evwv ov^ev, dxXa,

110

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Trjv \l/vy(y]v.

XIII.

^^.

Kai Ttviv^ariKyji epyaaiag yvixvyjv e/pvai

KXavaovTat

Kcu ovTOi TTiKpag Kai ^pv^ovdi Tovi o^ovTa^' apv^aeTat yap Kat

avTov^

Kvptoi. €^^7 ovv OTt " ov Traf
eis
t>jv

o

Xeycov

fxoi,

Kvpte, Kvpief
6

"

etaeXeva-eTat

jSaatXeiav

rov Seov,

«AX

ttoiuv

to

"

6eXy][xa tov TiaTpog fxov tov ev To7g ovpavoli^

5

KE*. NA.
Ilfpt rSiV (Ittoptcov r<p 'Irjorov 8ia 'tlpadrjv.

31

To "

€^eX9e Kat iropevov evTevOeVf^ (pOovca (pepofxevot
ovte

01

^api-

aaHot eXeyov ^eaTroTyj XptcTTw'
VTT

yap

yj6eXov

Ttvag <ptXe7a6at
vofJiov

avTOv, ovTe Taig

6eoav]ff.iatg,

ovt€ Ta7s vnep

fi.vaTaya>-

i

o

ytatg.

Oitep yap ehov,
eXeyov,

"

oti

'Hpw^yjg 6eXei
a>i

de

a.TcoKTel.vai^''

vpo(f)aai^ofLevot

o6ev

avTog

eTa^wv

vecfypovg

Kat

Kap^iagf tovto e/^«f, Tipdwg tc Kat eTre<7Ktaafj.evag, Ka6(ag e6og
avToo, dvTaitOKpt^eig e/Ve,
fxev
TTCog
*'

e<7raTe ty] dXaTreKi Tavrrj.^^ Kat ^oKeT

TeTpd(f>6at
"TrpoacoTTOV,

Kat

^Xeiretv

t^v rov koyov
^e

^vvaft.tv etg

ro '5

'Hpio^ov
TVjg
**

wg rtveg evofKtaav, epyerat
ov

fxdWov Kara

^aptaatav

a-Katoryjrog.

yap eine r^

aXcoireKt eKeivv],

aXXa

ravTf]^^ ev(f)vearara

fx.eay] rtvt '^wfx.evog (pavyj, aa^piag hetKWcev

eyyvg ovrag r^ dXwTceKt rovg ^apiaaiovg
TToog

ryj

iravovpyia'

Kat yap

cog

det itavovpyov
o6ev

eart Kat ^varponov to

^wov, ovtoo Kat ot

20

^apiaa7ot'

Kat wg TrpoatoKavreg Karoppcio^-^aetv

avrov

t>;v

'Hpwtov
Oirep ^e

'Xeipa,

ravra eXeyov, Kat
ro
rcov

rot rwv

^vvdfi.ecov

ovra Kvptov.

i^^et XvTreiv

^aptaaicov ar7(pog, diioTtXy^povv eitayidaetg eTTtreXuJ'*
ft.y]

yeXXerat
D>g

Xeycov,

**

i^of, eK(3dXXci} ^aifJLOvia, Kat

ydp

irpoeipy]Tat ^ta

rovro e^icoKov avrov, tva
aayyjvevyj
•jroXXoiig

rr]

rav Ttapa- 25
Tiiareveiv

to^cov

eitt^^et^et

•xjicofjievog,

etg

ro

avrco.
<

Atd
ro
VTT

^e rov

eiveTv

"

reXetovfxat,^^

e^et^ev,

ort

eKwv

vTrofLevet
Ty]v

eTTt tcS

(xravpco Ttd6og, Kat rore vitepyerat ye rov acoaai

ovpavov.

30
ort

S3

E/ttwv Se
ft.evy]v

"

^el

jotc"

ovk dvdyKi^v d^tacpvXaKrov

e^^y^pry)-

cecTtep

eavrco

e^-^Xceaev,

aXX

ori

fJiaXXov

cv

e^ovata rav

avrov

6eXy]fj.dr(ev dvetfj.evcog

re Kat dvwroTtrcog,

oitotTtep

av

edeXot,

XIV.

I.

AOYKAN ETArrEAIOY.
irepivoaT^a-y}
t>)v 'lovJaiav,

111
yj

Pa^iUTaif Ka)
/SofAevovTOf,

ov^evo^ (TiiovTOi
ttjv

eiri-

a.y£i<;

av avTog KaTa^e^yjTai

^ia

tov

tijmiov
"^fJ^e-

tTTavpov TeXiiaaiv.

To

^e

"

a-^fxepov

Kai avpiov,^^ TcXeiovag

pag

^yjXoi.

Ktiroiv Se oti
'*

"

ovk ev^ej^eTa/

Trpo<py}Tyiv

aTroXeadai

e^co 'Jepov-

5

aak-i^fji" eS^Awczev oti

koi tovto,

(pyjaiv, aTtoKiiTai avTyj,

to Kai

e/xe

avTOv tov twv vpocpyjTcov Kvptov
Se
'*

ev

avT^ iraBth.
/Siav avayKaaTiKyjv

To

ovK

ev^e'j^eTa/'

fxyj^eig

vofJii^eTa}

'louSa/o^f lTrayoit.evr,v
Trjv

eU to ToiayTa ^^av

elpy^aGai,

aWa

KaTa
10

T^i aXyjBeiag ^iayvuaiv e| uv eirpaTTOv

[xiai(f)ovov KeKTi^fJievoi
kccs,

irpoaipeaiv.
*'

To "

lepovaaXyjfi.,

\epovaaXy}fi."

"

ev ovofji.aTi

KvpioVf

Trpoeypa<l>yf

eU

to Ka;ra MaT^arov."

KE^. NB.
Ilfpt

TOV vdpaTTlKOV,
ev

I

KX>;l9ei$

§e

waA/v vwo ^aptaaiov

aapPaTco

^ea^^oTyjg i^

^piaTog'

y]v

Se ovTog t<cv irap

avrolq '^iaTrpeTreaTaTcoVf fx.aXtaTa

Oia TO ^vaTpoirov ayToJv a^^XSe, fxaXXov ^e &;a t*?v tovtwv oi^e-

Xetav avveaTtoi yevofxevog TovTotg,
av$pcc7Tov la^jfvog

oircog Becopot yevof/.evot

t^s

uirep

t€

Qfi.ov

Te Kat ^ofiyf avTov, Taj^a irag Kav ovTcag
t>;v Tr^bj- y]fxag Ofiotcaaiv
/m.^

irtaTevacaaiv OTt
wreAfliv,
oy/<c

©eof eaTi, Kai T/of 0eov

20

airoaTaq tov e/va< b i^V irapeTfipovvTO ^e avTOV,
vofjt,ov

a^a

7ra)f

KaTa-jretppovyjKe Tyjg elg tov

a/^oSf, t/ twv car-fffo6 te

p€Vft,evci}v

epya^Ofnevog ev ^ft-epa aa(3l3dT'x.
Tvjv

Kvpiog

ovy^

oircog

ckkXiv^

a<ppova

f/.ef/.\piv,

aXX

oirag

evepyeTyjafi Ttvag irdvTa

^taTrpaTTeTai, o9ev Kat tyjv dcppoavvyjv eXey)(^et twv atTtaaBat jueA- 25

AovTwv afTOv

eirt

aa^^aTtKa^ig evepyeaiaig, Xeycov,"€^eaTt
y}

tco

aa/S-

**)SaTaj BepaTrevaat

ov ;" Kat
eiret^r}

yap

y}v, (pyjatv,

avBpcoTrog Ttg v^poirt-

Kog efiirpoaBev avTov.

Be '^vaTpoircag aeatyyjKaat, irapaXvei

KpiaTOg
eig TovTo

Tyjv

dSpavaTOV avTcov dvaiayyvTiav, Xoytafj.oHg avayKatotg
Kat coaavet Xeycov avToTg,
Trcog et

y(jpcofj.evog,

KeKcoXvKev
<f>peap

vofx.os

^o

eXeeh

ev
;

aa/^^dTca,

eirotKTetpetg

avTog tov etg

KaTaTt

Treaovxa

Ktv^tvevovrog ev fj^ (ppovTiaiqg viov

aa^^dTcc,

fjiyj^e

112
Tav ToiovTCOv

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
liaTrpd^i^
;

XIV.

ii.

Toiyapovv yaipnv eiTrav Ta7g ^apKxdiKaXi

Pa<7Kaviaif, dnakXdTTei tov voaeTv tov v^epca KeKpaTVj^tvov.

KE*. Nr.
Hfpi Tov
firi

ayairav

tcls irpa)roK\i(Tias.

7

Oirep ^e enre, tov$ KeKXvjixevovs "

eitiayjtiv Trai

Tag TrpaTOKXi- ^
Taura,

"

(Xiag e^eAeyovTo," ^0Ke7 [xev Tia-tv 'lawg [xiKpd

itag eivai

Kat ov TroAA^? d^ta (ppovTttog' OTav ^e Ttg avTo7i tov tyj^ "hiavoiag
0(j>6a\ixov
evepetay], TOTvjvtKa^e

ixaByjaeTat, onoiov fxev

dnaXkdTepyd^eTui'
eir t^l^viT

T€t fAcofAOv Tov

avdpuTToVf

offov
yjff.Tv

Sc

TO

KOCfxtov avTOv
Ttpoyetpiag

TO yap

TtfJLag

ov

iravT&jf

o^petXofxevag

eh lo

d(7vveTov<; diro^patvet.

Tiocrifjg

yap

atcxyvvvjg to itpdyfx.a fuefxe<7T(o~

Tai, OTav evTtfxooTepov eX6ovTOf, 6 dfX(j)OTepovg
*'

KaXeaag

epei,
(ov

**

^og

ToyTco TOTTOV ;"

(xaippctiv

te Koi d^to6avfJLa(7TOS 6

^vvaTOg

to7s

•npcoTots KaTa(refJiVvv€a6at,
pSiv te eTepotg vito

Kai tovtov fxev ovk
fi.^

e^iefJi.evoi,

itapa^/a-

ye tov

^oKeiv vjTTa(76at <f>tko^o^ta'

^tonep 6 15

TOtovTos

(og 0(f)XvjfLa Xi^xpeTai ttjv TtfiivjV,

to

**

7tpo(7avd^vi6t^ dKovav.

fxeya Totvvv Kat e^atpeTov dya6ov to fj.eTptov <ppovv]fj.a.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaebanapeias.

E/ yap ToTg hepotg TtpoaTdTt^?
av(o6ev xp-^^pov, Kai (TTe^patvj

T€(j6at ^vjreT, Kep^^aiveTQ) tovto ^ta
vov(76(o

TtfiaTg

Talg itapa 0€ou, vtKdTOO itoWovg
v\pvjXov

twv apeTcov 20
<tvv-

XafXTtpoTi^Tt, Tvi Ta7tetvo(f>po(7vv^'
e(7TaXfj.evov <f)povv}fxa.
fxtfivjTvjg

yap itapd ©eoj to

yiveTat tov ^ptaTOv tov elvtovetfxt

Tog,
*'

*'

fxd6eT€

avt

efxov

oti

Ttpavg

Kat Taitetvog

tvj

Kap-

S;a."

TauTa
"

^e Ae-ywv ovKCTt eittitXvjTTet ^apeag,

dXXd

TtapatveT

'^VjUTag.
1
i

25
itag
vrpiov

To
*'

^e,

eavTOV Ta7t€tv(o6vj(7€Tai, Kat

Taitetvm eav-

Tov v\p(o6-^aeTai," TVjg 6etag vjpTvjTat Kptcxecog, ov TtdvTOog

ydp KaTo,

Tvpj

Tav dv6pwTt(ov eTttTeXeiTat (tvv^^etav,

eTre^S^

Kai TtoXXot Ttfx^g

opeypivTeg, eneTvy^ov T^g evTeXovg TavTvjg

Ttixvjg.

5

XIV.

i6.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.

113

KE4>. NA.
Ilept

tHv KoKoviievoiV
(xuT^^piov

iv

ra

deiirvm.

12

'TTTofiejxevo? Trepi ryjg

raTreivo^f^pocvvvji

Qeiov Trapdy-

ye\fxa KaXov Kai itpog rovq KaXovvraq enKpepei to ^i^^ayfxa^ Kat
fjieyav

etadyei rvj^ Trpog dvBpWTTOvg ^e^Ktiaeag tov aKonov Kai tovS
d^ioiJTtov^haarov, el
01

Kapnov

Kai

[xvj

irapayjiYjfxa

tvjv

dvTaiio^oo-iv

KeKTV)Tai.

yap

fxiKpo\pv)(oi

(f>iXovg

KaXovvTeg Kai d^e\(f)Ovg

Kai avyyeve7g Kai yenovag, ^;a to evOeag dvTiKXYjQ^vai itap

avrm
to lo

TovTO

TTOiovaiv'

01

^e

fxeyaXo^^vyoi

to

vitep^akkovTCiii;

KakXiov

Kai fj.eyaXoTipeiTeaTepov epyai^ovTai, oirep vTte^^ei^ev o

K.vpiog'

Tovi teofi.evovg Kai da$eveig Kai \eXx/3y]f>.evov$ <f)iXav9pa7ievecr6ai,
Trap

wv ovK eariv avTanoboa-tg' aAA
ent

o

Kyeos o avTaTrooioovg tv}^
^co^g'

(f>t\av$p(t}TTiag tvjv Ttfii^v

t^^ f/.eX\ovav]g
Ttft.^i

tovto ^e ov^

tva Tijf
^t^d^v}

Trpog

Tovg i^tovg dTreip^vj

^tefiapTvpaTO,

d\X

tva
1

fxrj

TTtTTpdiTKetv

Tag

(f)iXoff)poavvas tS)V

taav avTaTro^coo-ewc,

dW
O
*'

a)(f>eXtf/.ovg

TroieTaOat

Tavrag

eTii

fj.eydXatg

dvTam^^aaeat

TOig Ttapa %eov.
etttav

"

fxaKapios og Ttg <f)dyerat dptaTov ev r^ ^aaiXeta
ovirto

rxv ovpavaVf^

fxev

^v TrvevfLartKog,

rpv^^^tKog

Se ft.a\XoVf
Ttept

Kai dveirtrvj^etag eycov irpog avveatv dKpt^vj rav XaXovfJLevcov
'^piarov,
^toirep
wviQv}

20

yap

aoofj.aTiKag eaeadat
6

riiov

dyictiv

rag

afjiot^dg.

e^vcpaivet

"KpiaTog

Qeog

v]fi.xv

itapa^oXvfv

rolg

rore

Ttapovatv'

dTtoyjpe(iiVT(iig

eyovaav

etg Ttapd^et^tv

r^g

eiti

Ttavrt

tw

Koafico yevofnevvjg oiKovofJ.iag, i^rtg eartv avrvj.

16

*'

Av9poo7tog

rtg,"

(f^vjatv^

"

eTtoivjae

leTitvov

fxeya,'^

Kat

025

fnev avGpccjtog vovjQetvj

avQpcoTtog Kat Ttarvjp'

at

yap

eiKOveg TrAaTvj

Tovrat
ovro}
^v}

Ttpog

ro

dXvjSeg,

ovk avrat ^e Ttdvnog
tvifj.tovpyogf

eiaiv

dXviBeia'
fj.eya

ovv

rwv oXwv

Ylarvip T^i"

'ho^vig

TteitotviKe

SetTTVov,

TouTeo-Tiv,
e^tt

ciKovft.evtKV]v

etpydaaro itav^yvpiv'
avro KaXei Kat
eitt

b^^Xov Oe

ort

tv]V

Kptarto

oetTtvov

Oe

01/5^*30

dptaroVf ort ev eaydrotg Katpolg rov atwvog, Kat oiov

tvafxalg
vite-

rov

Ka&

v]u.ag

alwvog

e7te(f)dvv] vjfnTv
^fj.Hv

Tiog, ore Kat rov

^t

v]fi.ag

aTV] BdvaTov, Kai ^e^ooKev

rv]v

eavTOu adpKa (payeh, e^dXeae

114
^e iroXXovs,

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
ra
7rX^6v]
Vifj

XIV.

i8.

^vjXovoti
'^ovXov

twv

'lov^aiccv.
(f)Yjaiv
;

r/f ^e ^" o aireo

(TTak^tvog, ov

Kai

eivai

avzog

"KpKTTog'

ocTig Seog

oov

(f)va€i,

Kai Tlog aXi^Sivog, "
IloJa ^e
vjv

[xopcpvjv

^ovXov kavTOV
KeKXvjfxevoig
;

" Kevuiaag aveAa/5e."

a

yjToifxacre

To7g

afxapTiiiv aTioSeaiVf IIvey/AaTOf 'Ayiov fxeSe^iVf vU6(.(Tiag Xaixirpo- 5

T^Ta, I3acrik€iav
Toov

ovpavxiv'

liti

TavTa KeKXyjKC Kvpiog
ye twv
aAA.ct)V

6

Seog

'^ia

evayyeXtKm
^e
*'

Be<JTii(Xix.aT(av itpo

tov IcrpaoyX.

To
OTi

^p^avTo ano [xiag itavTeg '7rapaiTe7a6ai" tovto eaTiv,
oiiheva

wg e^

evog avvQvifxaTog

Xoyov eTroivjaavTO T^f KX^^aeag,

To7g yecoteaTepoig aavveTccg npoavevevKOTeg,

aypm

Te Kai yeuipyiag lo

Kai Tiai^oTroiiag eveKa.

i8

Tiveg Be av

vovjSeiev oi TrapaiTVjadfxevoi

;

vj

faya

ttov TVjg

\ov-

^aiccv avvaycoyvjg ol TrpoeaTvjKOTeg, av^tpeg a^poi

Ta ^aXXavTia Kai

(piXoKep^^la YjTTrifj.evot, koj.

icaaav elg tovto "^aTravcavTeg airov^-^v'
eit

^ta

TracTTjf

yap

eirog ei7re7v Trjg QeoTtvevaTov ypa^pvjg

avTo7g

0>?

1$

TOVTOii

'^iaj3el3Xi^f/i.evovg

eveaTiv i^e7v TovTovg. ^io Kai e^co

ff.eft.evri-

Kaat

TYig eopTrjg,

Ta7g ovtco aKXvjpa7g aneiBetatg to fxeya

^e7TTV(tV

7repivl3ptaavTeg.

21

KeKXy}VTai ^e dvT eKeivcov
ol eK Tojf
ecog

oi eig

Tag -nXaTetag Kat Tag pvfxag,
t^^v oidvoiav

lov^aiW^f itXriBvog daQevri tc Kai dyevvri

20

Tivog

eyovTeg Ka) d(f>eyyy}
Tvjg

Kat yaXevovaav,

vyie7g

Oe

Kai

evppcoaToi ^ta

etg

X^/crrov yevofnevvjg iriaTecog'
eig

e^t^d^^^Bvjaav

yap

opOoTio^e^v, Ka] to 6e7ov
tu>v

vovv

ehe^avTO

(f)a>g'

oti

Oe Treirttcov

aTevKaai

lovdaicov ovk evapi6ft.v]Toif '^iafxdBoi Ttg

av Ta7g

dyicov ATToaToXcov Hpcx^eatv evTuj^wv.

25
Kat eig Tocg ohoiig
oirep

23

'Aya6og wv
Kai
eig

(jivaei

Qeog Kot

(piXdv6pco7Tog

Tovg

(f>payfj.ovg

e^aTtoaTeXXet

tov

^etTrvoKX-^Topa,

d7ro(patv€i

tvjv tcov

e6vm

KXvjaiv, fxeTdye To7g e^ atfxaTog

lapavjX
(fjvjatv'

elaeveveyfxevovg

'hta TYjg

TriaTecog'

Kai ydp " eii TO^rog eo-T;/'

v^r^^pyov ^e ol e^ eBvav dypoiKoi
vovv, Kat olov
e^co

Tdg (ppevag Kai
fxvj

aTrvjyptcofxevoi
^vjv

TOV30

TroXecog

^tdyovTeg, ^td to

ev

evvoff.ia,

KTYpiOTrpeTrwg te fxdXXov, Kat

avv dXoyia. TroXX^.

Oyj^ aTrXiog Be

fiTre

TovTOvg KaXeaat,

dXXa Kai avayKdaai,
^eKTOv tovto
Trcog

KatToi TrpoaipeTiKOV d^raai
irapd Oeco, Kat Tav Trap

to TriaTeveiv eaTi, Kat

avTov

')(aptafx.dTCOV ava7rifX7rXdfJ.e6a.

35

XIV.
oio»

28.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
;

115
yap Tavra
ev

e/Vev avayKafTai

KaT

oiKovofxiav riva'

("Tieitv}

acpop-^Ta ^ovXeia r^f itXdvrig KaTeiyovTOt
I3o\oo Kcu

VTre^^vyfJieva

tw

^ia-

ovK el^OTa' tia tovto (7VVT0[xa}T€pag

«Aoycrecyf eberjOvja-av

fjii[xov[xevy}g

dvdyKvjg yjpeiav, iva kolv ovTag la^/yGOifJiv avajSkeipat

Tipog ©eov, Kai

t»v

iep<hv

yevaacyOai

[xadrjiJidTCtiv,

a7ro(poiTV}<TavTa S

Tiqg dpy^aiaq dTtdirigy Kat aTroTivj^-^aavTa TpOTTov Ttva TVjg tov Oia-

^okov xeipog.

E/Vwv

6 ^eairoTrji

'KptaTog Kat (j)tXdv$pa7rog, "

et

Tig epyeTai

"

irpog

jote,

Kai ov [XiaeT tov ira.Tepa eavTov" Kat

toc

€^%, oyTe

dyvorjaat Tvpf <f>vaiv, ovTe
(TTOf,

^ovXevaat t^

<f>vaet

TrpoaTdaaet \pt- lo
Kat

dXXa

yjprjaBai t-^ cpvaei irpog to d[xetvov Kai acoT-^ptoV

yap TO

Tt[JMv yoveag Kat

avTW

tcJ;

Ky/J^w So^er, Kai tq eKTpe<petv

Ta T€Kva Kat Ta TOtavTa,
Ta? eavTm yvvaiKag
Toi/g
6

Tor^ yovevatv vnaKovttv, Kat to ayaita.v

dv^pag, Kai to Tag yvvaiKag Tovg eav6e7og

Twv dv^pag (po^eiadat,

A.iioaToXog

elar^y^aaTO.

ov

yapz^

QiKetovg ye ovTag t^ irtaTet, Tovg otKetovg [xtarjTeov,

aXXa tovto

eaTiv, oitep

(f>rjatv,

ort Toiig irpog
xpv^^^^g

t^v

eig

Seov maTtv
TovTovg
eig

e[XTio^t^ovTag

Kat Ttpog
[xr]la[t.ag

aocTvjpiav
eve/cev

KooXvovTag,

TiapatTr^Teov,

Kat

dydif^g

aapKtKrjg, Trjg

KpiaTOV

dyditrjg

icaTa<f>pQV€Tv.

KE*. NE.
Hfpi
olKodofirjs

2o

nvpyov irapa^oXr).
r][x7v

28

To

Se eK Trig tov vvpyov QtKo^o[xrjg
a[XQ)[i.rjTOv

eTtt^ri\ov[xevov,

tovto

eaTtv, iva ol t»;v evKXea Kat
Tr^v

^ariv

KaTopBovv eXo^xevot,
vot,

dpKovaav

ev tovto}
Tr)g

7tpoBv[xtav,

tw eayTwv eyKOTaBe^xevot

oviwg e-zovTat

TotavTVjg

[xaKapiag itoXuetag, [ke[xvrja6at t€ 25
^ovXevetv Kvpica, eToi[xaaov Trpj
t>^v

Tov XeyovTog " tIkvov,
*'

el itpoaep-xrj

'>\'vyYiv

aov eig Ttetpaa^xov, ev6vvov
€1

Kap^tav aov Kat KapTepvj-

"

<rov"

Se Trapa Ttatv ovk eaTt 7tpo6v[/.ta TOtavTYi, ovTot itwg av
;

la^/yaetav tov TtpoaTedetKOTa avTOtg itepatwaai aKottov

ToT ArioT Mahimot sxoaion. ^tg
yov
;

rj

TtapalSoXr]

tov wu/J-30

Ttvpyog ar\[xatvet Trjv tSiv dpeTwv TeXetwaiv [X€Ta yvuaecog

QiKo^o[i^rj6eTaav.

oaTig

ovv itpdrTet
eitiKTi^aiv
Q.

Trjv

KaTa

itpd^tv

ditd^etav,

eyet eittTr^etoTriTa itpog

<f>vaiK«ov

Kai QfwpvjTtKwv Kat

2

116
GeGKoyiKiiv

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Xoyuv,
^i

XIV. 31.
ovto^
^vv/j-

m

aTta^Ti^^eTai
6

7}

TeXeia yvwaig'
fxv}

reXeioi t>;v

oiKO^^Ofjiyjv

tov irvpyov,

^e eWeiTrvj^ rovTcov

6eii elg Ttepa^
T:opevofi.evav,

ayayetv

tyjv oiKo^ojJiVjVf efXTrai^eTai

Trapa t£v iiapa-

ene avQpw-nwv ene
Tig

^atfxovuv.

31
'*

To
Keh

^e

"

e'i

^aatXev^

itopevofj.evog erepfX)
e^rj^,

^aatXeH avfx^a-^
rag

eis

TroAe^ov," Kai

ra
yjfj.h

rovro

avjft.aivei, ori irpog

evavTiag ^vvdfj.eig eariv
*'

dyav, KaSwg

^itoaroXog

<pif}aiv,

ovK

ecTTiv

yjfi.Tv yj

TrdXvj yrpog alfj.a Kai
rvjg

adpKa^^ Kai
ev

to, e^vjg.

Et/
vjfnav

^e

Kat

Tipog

to

<f)povv]fj.a

aapKog,

roTg

f/.eXeaiv
vjfj.h
vj

dyptatvwv vofKog, ra TioXvTpoTra
avTVj Tuv e^^Bpav
f).e6a
;

TrdSv], Tipog

ravTa

TraXTy,

10

vj

aypia

TiXyjBvc,'

Ttag
tco

ovv

apa rovrav

irepteao-

orav 7n(7T€va(Cfj.ev ort

ev

0ew
"

Trotvj<TOfJ.ev tvvafj.tv,

Kai

ort

avTOg e^ovdevwaet Trdvrag rovg BXifoovrag
TipocfyvjToov

vjfJ.dg,

Ka6ibg eavfj.ot,

rov Ttg rav dyiav

^taBetg

e<pvj,

/^oy,

Kvptog ^ori^eT

" Ka) rig KaKaaet f^e ;" Kat iidXiv 6 ^eaTieaiog Aa^t'^' " Kvpte, 15 " cf)Q}Ttaft.og fJ.ov Kat SwT^p /xoy," Kat Ta e^vjg' avrog yap •^ft.icv
7]

\ayvg eari.
e-^^Ppovg

^io
v]fj.oov

avrov eyovreg
'^aifj.ovag

I3ovj6ov, fxv]^afi.ag

Tiept

etpvjv^g

rovg

epoor-^awfjiev,

oiiep

eart

^ovX(i)6v]vai

roHg 7id6eatv,
v]fn.av

dXXd fxdXXov

dvrtarafxev avro7g, rov Kparatov Qeov

eig dvTtXvj\ptv oXoxpvj^ccg Kat

d^taXetnTag

eTitKaXovft.evot.

20
tljji

34

KaAoj/ To akas' iau Se to aXas
apTvO-qaeTai
;

fJLCopau6fj

eV

Ktpiaaot.
re

EcrTOJcrav ovv

ev

v]ft.h

01

aXeg, Tovreartv,

ot 6e7ot

Kat

aooT^ptot

Xoyot,

wv edv

KaTa(f)povvjao>fj.ev, eaofj.e6a

fLcopoi

Kai davverot, Kat a^^elot TiavreXag.

25

'Eh ANEnirPA*or.

Ovroo

^v]

Kat ro aXag eivai ndvrag avTipooroog

aTVjaerat rovg fxev npcDroog, rovg Se ^evrepoog'
'ATioaroXot,
01

fxev

yap

01

tm Koafxx

itavTt

yeyovaatv dXeg, Kat oaoi fxer

eKeivovg rotovrot
01

dpTvovreg eig aooTV]ptav dv6pw7iovg, Oevrepov Se
iiXvjpovvTeg, Xaot
yjp-^aifxot

rdg eKKXv]atag

Tipog oo(f)eXetav ro7g

^o

TiXvjaid^ovat

Ka6taTdft.€vot,

" KaXov

ovv,"

(f)Yjat,

" to aXag, eav

"
**

^e TO

dXag

fxoopav6^, ev rtvi aprv^-^aerat, ovre etg y^v, ovre eig

KOTipiav ev6erov eartv' e^oo

^aXXovatv avro. 'O eyav ura aKovetv
(f>v]atv,

"

dKoveTOoJ^ yjpviaifxovg

vfxdg

6

iiap

efxov

Xoyog anaatv
iiapafxtyvvat, 35

dv6p(io7ioig

KaraaKevd^et, Kat Tidatv

eiii

acoTvjpta

XV.

II.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
(i

117

rotovTOvg aTTo^eiKvvs oiov^ Trpoeipi^Ka'
•^Kovfrav tiavoiav, oxne a<p

^e irapacpQeipe.i ttjv Ttpotrov^ev), ovt€
vfx^v
eii'

vfxav ocpeXos

€T€p(0-

Btv acpeXeia aTroAeAreTa/, o6ev

ovTe

elg

y^v,

oWe

Konpiav
wcpeXovv'
wcpe- 5

ev8eT0i eaeaQe'
VLLeTg ^e Ttpog

y^

[J.ev

yap to

wcpeXovfxevoVy KOitpog to
ei

to uxpeXeh Koafiw airavTa Keifxevot,

fi.y}Te

Amo;

fkevoiTe, fxrjTe w(peXeia6ai ^vvaa6e'

aTroKXyjTOi Kai eig ovoev

eaecBe.

"Evfia

Vq Kai avveaecog

ecpYj

teh To7g aKovovatv, (oare

vapa^oXtKOv ovTa tov Xoyov avvievat. Ta aKoXov6a ewg t^$ iiapa^oXYjg Twv p TTpo^aTWV TrpoeypafpT] etg to

Kaia

y\.aT6a7ov.

8

Ylept
Xxr/yov
TViv

T^f

'tpa')(jx.'^g

(pvjatv

6

aytog Tprjyoptog 6 BeoXoyog, OTt 10
tvjv

rj\l>ev

X.piaTog Kat Qeog, ^t^XovoTt

eavTOv aapKa, Kai

oiKtav

eadpwae t^? dfxapTiag, tov Koafxov diioKa^dpag, Kat
/SaatXiKYjv etKova

TYiv ^pa^^Qxvjv e^-fjTYiae, tyiv

avyKeywafxevYjv To7g
Jivvdfxetg
eiit

7rd6eai, Kat
^pa-^QXYjg

avyKaXenat Tag (ptXag avTW

ty] TVjg

evpeaet, Kai

KOivwvovg Ttotehat TYJg eixppoavvYig,

ag Kat 15

TYjg oiKovofi.iag

fxvaTt^ag eneTtoiYiro.
fxev ditTOfxevov eivat
Tiy^"

'Eb ANEnirPA*OT. \vyyov
Xiag Tov Xoyov, adpwatv Ve

tttaaKa-

ty]V

twv dfKapTiwv aitOKd^apaiv, Kat
ttjv

Twv

TtovYjpwv ^atfi.ovwv Tov
otovet

ywptafxov Kai
etKOvt

ditaXXoTpiwaiv. TOVTa
ov
avvey^wpet
yj

yap

y£Yift.aTa

tyj

eTttitpoaBovvTa

eit

20

o^eatv opaa6ai Qeov' o6ev tovtwv ditwa^evTWV, evpe6yj

aitoXweiXYjcpev

Xvla

^pa^^fXY],

vito

TY)g

yvvatKog,

y^v

elg

t^v eitovpdvtov

'lepovaaXYjfx.

KE*. Nr.
HepX Tov
1 1
diTo8i]firj<TavTos tls ;^«pai» fiaKpdv.

E/TTWV
Ttept

oeaTtOTYig

\ptaTog

gti

" dv6pwitog
qti eig ^vo

Ttg ^vo ei^/ev viovg,^^
^f^pYjTat
TYjg

ToD avdpwTttvov yevovg

(f>Y]aiv,

TayfMiTa, 25

etg ^iKaiovg Kai

dfnapTwXovg, etg ^e itaTYjp

dv6pw7tOTYjTog, 6

(f>iXdv6pwitog
yjpovov

©€0f.

YlpoaYjX^e Se, (pYjatv, 6 vewTepog, ov ^td tov

vewTcpog

dXXd

^td to

evov TVjg

dtavotag

Kat

ti;v yvwfXY^v

aaTaTOv KeKTVja6at dv^Xt^ vitdpywv Kat Xeyet tw

itaTpi,

" ^Of

"

fxot

TO etti^dXXov fxepog

TVjg

ofcr/ac," TovTeaTtv, ov
eifxt,

BeXw ^oy-30

Xevetv avdyKYj, avTe^ovatog

ydp

eav 6eXw, aw(f>povw, edv ov
TtaTYjp d(f)6ovwg

6eXw, ovK dvayKo^ofxat' etwKev ovv
KTiaiv, eiteaiYiaev

dnaaav

ttji/

avTw tov eayToD

vofxov tov (f>vaiKOV

Ka) ypaitTOv,

118
iva ev
kyjjxa,

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
TOVTCO
GeXei
TTai^aycoyovixevos
irXrjpcca'/]

XV.

13.

tov vofxoGeTov to jSov-

yap

yjfxag

eKova-icc^

^ovXeveiv avTco'
air

eha,

(pyjaiVf

a7re^^/x>;(7e

ttov,

Kai

«Treo-TTj

0eo$

avTOv' ov fSia^eTai yap

oii^eva ^vj PovXofxevov ^ovXeveiv

avTw.
aacoTco^, Kai

13

ATTO^yjfx-^aag toivvv

e^yjaev

avyjXcoae

tvjv ova-tav, 5

TovTeaTt Tov efXcpVTOv Xoyiafxov,
aXyjOeia^,
tvjv
fxv^fxyjv

t>jv acocppoavvyjVj tvjv yvcoatv

t^$

tov Qeov'
'hi^lia

o$ev

Kai yeyovev avTco

Kifxog

layypogf ov kifxo^ apTOV ovoe

v^^aTog,
Trf

aXXa

Xifxog tov
tS)v

aKov-

aai Xoyov K.vpiov'
apeTcov

eiteTat

yap
*'

ocnccXeia
irapevfivg

itpoeipyjfxevcov

TOiovTOf Xifxog.
T^S^g 'X}*>po'-i

Aio

Kai

eKoXXyjQYj evi

tcov

10

"

TToXiTCOv

eKeivyjg'" evBanep eiaiv 01 fxev

"noXnai avTVjg

^aifi.ovegi 6 ^e Xifxog tcov

dyaOcov acpodpog'

^/0

Kai eirefx^ev avrov

eig

Tovg aypovg avTOv (3oaKeiv yoipovg'

ovtco

yap

Tifxcoaiv

01

^aif>.oveg

Tovg TifxavTag avTovg, ToiavTag ^copeag yapi^l^ovTai Totg
Kai yap eKTtnrTCov Tig diio 0eov, Kai ^/a t£v 15
itpoaKoXXiifxevogi yoipatyjg

TteiBofxevoig avTOig.

ly^ovwv

Tolg

taifxoai

Te yevofxevog

tog

eig yyjv vevevKcog, Kai

tw

(3opl3opcp tcov t^$" aTifxiag TtaBwv
y^poviil^cov

eyKvXiv-

tovfxevog, eiKOTCog

yolpog vofxtadyjaeTar

^e

Tor^ KaKoli

Kat aXXotg Tvitog aitcoXeiag evpiaKeTat, Tpoitov Ttva ^oaKCov av-

Tovg Kai

Tpe(f>cov

Toig

T-rjg

dacoTiag di^dyfi.aat. to
ot

^e

"

eiteBvfxei

20

"

'XPpTaaByjvai Ik twv KepaTicov wv YjaBtov

yolpot, Kai ovtetg l&<-

" tov avTM'" TOVTo

eaTtv, OTt Tcov KaKcov ovK eXdfx[3ave KopoV itapa,yj

PdXXeTat ^e Toig KepaTtotg

dfi.apTia, OTt coaitep
ovtco Kat

yj

to^twv yevatg
t^? dfxaprtag

yXvKeld eaTi, kut avTO ^e Kat Tpayeta,
(f)vatg

yj

evcppatvet

fxiKpa Kat

KoXd^et f/.eydXa, Tepitet itpoaKaipa 25

Ka) fxaaTi^et atcovta.

eig eavTOV eXdcbv,
tvjv

TOVTeaTt Xoytadfxevog

tvjv

TtpoTepav fLaKaptOTyjTa Kat
yjv

^evTepav dSXtOTyjTa, Kat Ttg fxev
yjv

oVe

yjv

fxeTo,

tov Qeov Kat HaTpog, Tig ^e yeyovev oVe
eiite,

vTto-

TeTayfxevog Totg talfxoatv,

"

itoaoi fxtaStoi rov

YlaTpog

jw.ov,"

TOVTeaTi

KaTviyovfxevot,

Kat

yap fxtaBovTat
e(f)e^y^g, cog

aet

(f)iXdv6pco7tog

^o

Seog, Kat nept Tpnyjv copav Kat

yeypaitTat,
*'

"

iteptaaev-

"

ovTa< a^TWv," twv fie<wv evTpv(pcovT€g ypa(f>cov,

eycb he tco Xtfx^

" TovTCov avveyofxatr " Avao-Taf ttopevaofxat
vTtoaTpexpco

ttpog tov itaTepa fxov^^

KaXcbg o6ev
eig

e^i^X9ov KaKcbg, Kai

epa avrw,

"

itaTep,
ttpog

"

yjfKapTov

tov

ovpavov

Kat

evcoitiov

aov," apKei

fxot

35

XV.

20.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
ra
pi^fjiaTa'

119
t^v ayaBQTriTa,
fxeTavoovvTa,

awTvjpiav TovTa

ol^a tov Seov

fA.ov

olta Tov TiaTpos [aov t^v
ov ovK

•^fj.epoTyjTaf

TrpofT^e^eTai

eKoXaaev afxapTavovTa.
vjXQe irpo^ tov rtaTepa avTOv'"'^
Trji

30

*'

Kai ava<7Tag

zodev avaaTag

;

eK T^? KaGetpag
Trpoo^eOvjKe
fjLQVov

^^ov^f,

eK

tov
tvjv

Trjg

afxapTiag iiTWfxaTog' ^
^ei

yap t^ KaX^ (Sovky Kai

Trpa^iV

yap

yjft.ag

ov

jSovXeveaQai

Ta

(f)i\a

0ew, «AXa Kai Tag ayadag
eTi Se

opfxag

eititeiKvveiv Talg Ttpa^eaiV

"

ayTov fnaKpav aiieyovTog^^ Trwg
Triv

fjMKpdv

;

ot; 7rpoeXa(3ev

vj

evepyeaia

fieTdvoiaV

"

eioev avTOV

"

6

iraTVjo avTOv, Kai

evaTrXay^^viadrj'" TiaTrjp
Tvj

yap

e<XTt

t^

%/"?~ 10

aTOTVjTi, el Ka\

&eog VTtdpyei
avTOv

<f>vaei,

**

Kat.

tpafiMV

eireaev

"

eTii

Tov

Tpay^riXov

Kai

KaTe(f)iXv]aev
eXQeiv,

avTOV

ov

yap

avefLeive

tov

TrpoaKCKpovKOTa TrXvjaiov
e$og

aXX

avTOg

avT^
to
tvjv

TtpoaairrjVTvjaeV

yap

to)

(piXavdpconw 0eo5 tovto noieh'

TiepnrXeKeaBai
vTTOTay^v.

tvi

ff.eTavoovav] ^l^v^iy, Kai

daTid^eaSai avTr^g

15

"

€<Ve Se

afTw
tov

6

vlog avTOv, ndTep, vjft.apTov etg tov
tv]v
fxop(f)Vjv,

"

ovpavov," (f)o^ovfj.ai
(pcov^v,
*'

aTepecofi^aTog
"^io

wg KaTVj-

yopov

Kai evwntov aov'^^

Kat

evXaf^ovfxat

(f^coTt

Tvjg avjg QeiOTVjTog

evaTeviaat, pvnapovg ej^wv Toy^ ent tov awfxa-

Tog Kat T^f ^t»%^5" ocpSaXfiQvg, fi.eTa yap TravTcov fxov twv KaKxv 20 Kai ai
lintQ^^pofj.iai

KaTr^yopovat

fj.ov'

to %\,

"

itoiv]aou

fj.e

ccg

eva

"

Toiv fKta6i(i}v

aov," tovto
fi.v]

eaTtv, OTt fxvjTe TVjg avXvjg aiteXdavjg
TtoXefitog evpwv /xe itXavwfievov,
TiXriaiov

fne, "^eaitoTa, tva

TtdXiv
fnvjTe

wg

ai^xjJidXcoTOV

dvaydyvj,

eXKvarfg
o(f)9aXfxo7g

Tv^g

fj.vaTtKrjg

Tpane^vjg Kat (f^oPepag, ov
TcSv

ToXfj.w

yap

evayeatv opav 25

dyiwv Ta ayta. " €<Ve Oe

6 itaTrjp itpog
Trjv

Tovg QovXovg avToii,"

TOVTeaTt Ttpog Toy^ tepeag,
eaTtv,
TV]g
v]v

" eveyKaTe

aToXvjv itpwTVjv," tovttv]v itiaTtv, tv]v

aTtwXeae tov itaTpog avaywprjaag,
Kai

yvwatv

dXr]Beiag,

ev^vaaTe

avTov tov eavTOV dno^^vaavTa, Kat
Tr]g

SoTC ^aKTvXiov eig tv]v xeTpa avTov, t^v a(f>payi^a
T>jv

itiaTewg ^o

AfaTa Tov

ota^oXov, Kat vTto^rjfLaTa elg Tovg itooag avTov,

iva TOVTOvg vTtotr]adfj.evog ev eTotfj.aaia tou
vr]g

^vayyeXiov

Tr]g etpr]-

KaraitaTr] rovg

0(f)etg

Kai

TOvg aKopittovg, Tag avTiKetft.evag

'^vvdfj.etg.

Kai eveyKare tov fj.oayov tqv atTevTOv tov Tv6evTa vnep

Tr]g oiKovfJievrfg, Tov Toig f/.eTavoovat ft.eTa^iOofxevov,

t^v

ft.eTdXeifpiv

^^

120
Twv
Oeictiv

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
fiv(TTV]picov,
•yjv

XV.

24.

**

Kai

(jiayovreg

ev(ppavO!i)iJ.€v, hri
vjv,

ovto^

"

viog fxov veKpog
*'

Kai ave^vjaev, aTiokuiXwg
X^P^''
7'^/'

Kai evpe6v]."
{J^ovov

24

Kai

rjp^avro ev(ppaivea6ai'^^
eTTi

y^^^^^^h ^^
ev
ry]

ev

ovpavo7$

evi

afxaprcoXco ixeravoovvri,

aXXa

y^

Travrcov

ev(ppaivoiJ.evuv
eipt^fxeva, olov

rwv ^iKaiwv. ra yap
eariv
6

ecpe^^^g rvjg

iiapa^oXrjg ravrvjg 5

viog

avrov

iipea^vrepog, epwr-fjdag Kat
vjyavaKryjae Kai
ov
y^r^
cog

\ka6wv ryig
eiaeXSeTv,

eopr-tjg

r^v

vTroQecnv,

ovk rj$eXvjaev
(pQovrjaavrog
v)

Kai

ra rovrwv aKoXovSa,
yjfxag

eyKaXeaavrog ravra
[xevov

Xoyi^ea6ai, ^iori

TtapafSo)^ ro Xeyo-

eari,

ra

te

ev

7rapa/3oXaTg Xeyofxeva ov teH Trdvra
6 'KpvaoarofJi.Qg eig rvjv

Kara o
1

Xe^iv Trepiepyd^eaSai, Kadcog (pvjaiv
veiav rov
fxevoov

epiXYi-

Kara M.ar6a7ov,

rrjv

Trapa^oXrjv epfj.r}vevwv rwv fj.ia6ov^;

epyarwv,

dXXa

rov

aKoirov fj.a6ovrag

wv avvere6rjaav,
^rjreh
rj

rovrov

^penea^ai

ft.ovov,

Kat

fLrj^^ev

Tcepatrepco

ttoXv-

Tcpayft.oveh.

Kai yap ovk eariv

ov^^etg

rwv dyiwv roiavra ^iKaio-i^

Xoyovfhevog, wg (p6ovov

Kai /SaaKavtag vndpyovreg Ka6apoi.

E<

yap Kat rag

y\jvyag

avrwv vnep rwv dft.apTcoXwv ^t^oaat,

jroXAiu

f/.aXXov opavreg avrovg aco^off.evovg yatpovat Kai

otKeHa vofj.i^ovat

ra

etg

avrovg
ovv

yivofj.eva

aya6d.
avyeTe6r]
rr^v
r)

Ttvog

eveKev ovraig
;

Trapa^oXrj avrr]

;

Kai rt 20
(piXav-

KaraaKevdaat ^ovXerat
GpcoTTtav

virep^dXXovaav

efj.(paivet

rov Qeov, ort roaavrr] eart irpog rovg eTitarpe(povrag eig

avrov Kai yvr^aiwg fKeravoovvrag, caare Kat (p6ovov reKeiv erepotg
'hvvafj.evovg'

onep

Ka)

vjfj.elg

iroXXdKtg
fj.01

Tiotovfj.ev,

evepyerr]aavTeg

Tiva, Xeyovreg avrw, ort 6 ^eivd
rtft.rig

eveKdXeaev, ort ae rotavrr^g 25

rj^twaa, ovTe eyKXrj6evTeg Ttapa rov eKeivov ^ta{3aXeiv e6e-

Xovrog,
Yjg

dXX

ev

rovrcp

de7^at

(3ovXofJ.evot

ro fxeyeSog rrjg '^copeag

a7TY]Xavaev, oficog ^e Kat 7rpoaa(paXt^erat ^ia rov vno^^etyft.arog
roiig
dfj.eft.TTrcog

rov TrpeajSvrepov viov,

iToXirevofj.evovg

fj.rj^eTTore

Oe^aa6ai

Xoyia\j.ov

(p6ovov

riKrovTa

Itt).

acorrjpia

fj.eravoovvTwv '^o

df/.apTwXwv, VTTO rov f/.iaav6pw7Tov 'htajBoXov vTTO^aXXoft.evov,
fj.aXXov TTapavra rovrov aTToarpe^pea^at, ev(ppatvofJ.evovg Kat

aXXa
yai-

povrag
'X.pr]

eiTt ryj

awrr]pta avrwv.

^e Kat

tovtq ytvwaKetv, ori toKeT riat ^ta

rr^g

rwv vlwv

hvvdfiewg rovg re dytovg 'AyyeXovg KaTaar]fj.atvea6ai, Kai r]fi.ag^$

XVI.

I.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
/tx6v

121

Tovf ovra? ent t^c 7^f, Kai ro

toD Trpea/SvTepov Trpoffomov to
^e toiJ a<7cyToy fca/ vewvo\i.iC^(jvai,

T»v ay/ojv A-yyeAcuv
Te/?oy TO
jw,€V

Ta.yfj.a

^ijAoyv, to

yivo? to avBpxitmV Kai aXkoi Se Ttakiv
\(7p(vfiK

%ia

Tou TipfcT^vTepov TOv KaTa (japKa
eSvrj.
**

^vjkovaBat, ^ia &e

Tov vecoTfpov Ta
**

airoxpvjcffog ^e'," «/^jt/v, o
€i[JLt

ayiof Kv/?/AAof, 5
^e Kai

Tar?

irep/

ToyTcev ^o^at^

fjih

€ya>,
irep/

^oKifxa^iTCt)

**

<l>tXo(x.aBri<;

to

aXvjSeif

ovtc

«ya^

twv ayiav

AyyeXwv

"
"
**

irpeTTov e<7Ti Xoyi^ea-9at, OTt

ovk eTreyivaaKov tov aaaTov [xeTa-

voiav Kat Tvjv
yip'j}T(i}v'

eiit

tovtoi TeXovff.evyjv eopTTjVy
•yjpri

aAA ag

ayvoovvTe^

ovre naXiv

avvaive7v

^fii.ag

ag ev l3e(3iiOKOTa$ twv 10
(og

c?
**

laparjXf

onov ye tovtov; oia iiaayji,

eTrof

emeiv, Tvjg

5eo7rveyc7Tou ypacp^g, ^ia^ePXyjfxevovg eartv
/fa; aireideig.

l^eTv

wg aTtoaTaTag

KE*. NH.
tlfpi Toi;
olKovofjiov TTJs dSiKias.

15
/>fa/

I

Aeye/ ^e

/fa/ Trep}
<f)y]atv,

r«v Tra^a/SoAwv
oti

ay^oc Ky/J/AAos", oWe^
aavfj.(f)av<ag .yjfniv

XpvaGaTOft.og
Tipayfj.aTcav

itXayiwg Kai

avrai
ev

ov:^at(popav

^-^Xcoaiv

eiaKOfJ.i^ovaiv,

orav
ov

avTOV

^payeH Kai avveaTaXfxevtag tov
<f>i^ai,

vovv KaTaG-^aci)ft.ev'

yap aiiavTa
XenTcog ^e 20

Ty]g

Tiapa^oXrjg

to. fJ.epyj
ft.yjTe

noXvTtpayfj.ovetaBai

yj)Yi'

Kat e^yjTaafi.evag, iva

"npog toc Trepa fj.eTpov ^a^i^cov

Xoyog
aSoAe-

KaTaXvnyjay] tw TieptTTw

Tovg (f)tXaKpoafj.ovag,

fJ.^^Te

fxev

o"X/a? oj^Aov epyaayiTai Ttatv, olov Kai ea) r^g iiapa^oXyjg eart
ryjg

Xeyovayjg,

"
ei

AvQpcoTiog

rig

y]v

TiXovatog

bf eiyev otKovofi.ov*
ff.ev

Kat ra e|^^'

yap

fi.y]

^ovXoito Ttg tiarpavovv, rig
otKOvofjiov,
yj

av

ely]

25

avdpcoTiog 6 rov ^ia(3e^Xy]fi.evov eycov

Kat rig av

ely]

Tvycov
evoyxii

^ia^ejSXi^Kcbg avrov,

rtveg

Se

Ka)

01

roTg o(f>Xi^fxaatv

Kai rag rav
fj.ev

0(f)Xy]ft.aiTCOv

tioiovvTeg aTioKOiiag, Kat &/a Tioiav
eiiocf^X^^aat

aiTiav
aft,a

eXaiov,

Se

o-nrov

Xeyovrai, aKOTetvov

Kat nepiTTOV anoTeXeaet tov Xoyov.

ovkovv ov •ndvTy] re Kat 30
ry\ rtov

TiavTcog atiavra r-qg tiapa^oXy^g

ra

fJ.epy]

^y]Xovfi.evcov

eia)

Becopta y£y]aifiM, eig eiKOva ^e Xy](f>6eiev

av dvayKaiov TipdyfJMTog

afxvOpwg VTiefj.(f>aivovaa to reXovv eig ov^aiv rolg dKpocofxevotg.
EcTT/ TOtvvv TVjg
TipoKetfji.evy^g

Tiapa^oX^g roiovTog

6 vovf'

/Sot/-

R

122
Aera^
7]f/iag 6

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
twv
oXcov
^ea^iroTy]^

XVI.

lo.

Seog

oXoTpoircog Toig eig apeTYjV
toov

avaKiHaOai (77rov^da[xao-iVf aiiahXaLTTOVTaq kavTovq
Tog l3iov
Tre piaa-Traa-ixwVf iv
'^ia

tov irapov-

evTrape^pag Kat aTcepiairacrTwg vTrrjpt-

Tw/Aev avT^f KaOwg
OTi
eycti eifxi

tov

Aa^i ^
Oi

(pvjai,

" ay^oXdaaTe Kai yvare

o Kyeog

Kai TiaXiv

eavTov,
ij

^xAyjaaTe ra vnap-^

"

j^ovra Kai ^ot€ eXeyjixoavvvjv" Kai
6

/Aev evToA>/ auT^^piog, da6ev7]g

^e Xiav
poig'

dvQpwTiov vovg, Kot dei
^vjXa^^vj

iriog TrpoaTreTryjye
'rjfxiv

To7g yeco^eaTe-

o6ev

irpocpaaiv

acoTVjpiag

vTredei^ev o yipiaTOg

^ia

T^g

TrpoKeiixevyjg
Trjv

irapa/SoXijg,
'^(^pvjfxdTcov

fkovovy^i

Xeycov,

ornrep

ei

fiyj

^ovXoiVTO
vx}^vjXy]v

Twv

Trepiovaiav
7rXy]v

KaraXnreh Kat
tov

Toyvio

TroXiTeiav

da7rdaaa6ai,

Ka^d ye

vTro^ejBy^KOTa

TpoTTov,

Kav

oiKovofxoi

yeveadcoaav^

t<3v irTcoyevovTCtiv
oirctig

av[X[MeptaTag

Tuv virapyovTCCv TovTovg

Trotovfxevoi,

<piXovg KTyjaafxevot TroX-

Xovg, Kat fxdpTvpag t^? evairXayyyiag Tovg ev 7re7rov6oTag eyovTeg,

OTav avTovg

y]

eirtyetog eKXenroi ^w^,
ei

TV/aat

tottov Tivog ev Ta7g 15

eKe76ev aKy]va7g'

^e

fj)r]

(BovXoivro to f^yj^e tovto ^ta7rpd^aa6ai,

dXXa Ta
^a7ravcoai

7rapd tov
Tpo(f)aig,
y]

^ea^roTov ^o6evTa avTcc, fLovatg Taig eavTcHv

Kat 7rpoa-Katpovg movvTai Tifxag, afkvyjfxo-

vovvTeg tov XeyovTog

Qeov, " dvotycnv avot^etg Ta aTrXayyya

tc5

"

d^eX<pa aov," Kat oaa

dXXa

yj

6eia ^t^^daKei ypacpy] rrepi Ty]g etg 20

Toiig teofxevovg
eTrtTr^^^SovTog

avfj,7ra6eiag, dTroTreaovvTat TrdvTCog

T^g oiKovofxiag,

avToTg tov ^avdrov, Kai twv t^$" Treptovatag avTccv
e^eXKOVTog,
koli

7rpayft.dTCi}v

^/a
tco

t>jv d7rdv6pcti7rov avTctiv 7rpoaipeaiv,

dvTi

Tctiv

aictivictiv

aKy]vm

aicavtcti

Kat

aawfxdTc^

Trvpt

Trapa-

oo6Y]aovTat.

25

jo

T/V

ea-Tiv

"

7rtaTog ev eXayiaTCti,"6 KaXcag ei^cbg jStovv Kai t>jv
d^rocpepoov
ft.ev

elg TO fLeXXov eX^rt^a ^e^t^pt^Kccg, Kai

twv

e^riyetcav

Tov vovv,

(ppovctiv

^e

fkdXXov

to.

dvco,

Kai

^id

tovto tov eTrtyeiov
eirtyeiov

7rXovTOV eig Tovg ev^eeTg TrXovTOv
ovv
ev

KaXag

taTravcav.

eXdytaTov Se tov
6

e^dXeaev, ov
Tco

^y]

Kat d^tKOV

f/.aft.fKCtivdv cpvjatv.

ToiovTog

^o

eAaj^/<7Ta) TrtaTog

evpiaKOfhevog, Kat ev TroXXca TrtaTog
6

ea-Tt,

TovTeaTiv ev Tolg 7rv(VfJLaTiKoig Kat 6eioig yapiafj.aaiv
7rXovTCti Tovrcti

Se

ev

TCti

dtiKog yevofievog, etg eavrov

fx.ovov

avvryjpav

avTOV tyjXovoTt, Ka\

ev Tolg 6etoig

yapiafKaatv d^tKog evpe^-^aeTat.

a Sic.

XVI.

19.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
§€ T*;v

123

^AWorpiov

Twv

yjfyjfJLdTccv

Treptov^Ttav avofxaa^evy eiretorj

ov yeytVYjfj.eQa fieTa vkovTOv, yvfxvot

^e fxakXoVf Kat

ag

aXi^6cof

€<m
**

yeypafji.fji.evov,

"

OTt

ov^ev elaeveyKafLev

etg tov Koafxov, ov^he
cf)vat-

e^eveyKeh Tt ^vvafKeQa'^^ aXKoTpiov toivvv avBpwitov TiavTog

Kwg TO irXovTeh' e^x6ev yap eva Kat tov avTOv
Toi

ft.ept^€a6at Tvpos 5

evavTia, Ka) aKaTa^peKTOog ^vvaadat l3tovv, '^etKVvatv 6 oea^iro-

Trji

^ptaTog XeywVf
e^vig.

**

ov^etg ^vvaTat ^vat

Kvptotg

^ovXevetv" Kat

Ta 14

'Enet^v} Se

r^

voaca Ti^g <f)tXapyvpiag avvey(pfJ.evot e^fjfLVKTyjpt^ov

avTOv

01

^apiaaht

KaiTiep '^ia ft.aKpSov
eirt

Xoym

TOVTOvg 6epaTievaai

1

o

/3ovXy}6evTogf rpeireTat Xofnov

ro ^ptfKv twv eXeyyjaVf Katpov
"^o^yjg

KaXovvTog elg rovro, koi
Tijg Toig

a7ro(f)aivet

avrovg ovrag epaarag

ttKaiotg re

Ka) aya6o7g Trpe^novavjg av^tpaatv, avTovg oe
(prjat

ov

fJL-rjv

ovrag rovro Kara aX^6etav'
evdoTriov

yap, "
6

vfj.elg

eare

ot

" tiKatovvreg eavrovg
**

rav av6paTrm'

te

Seog ytvaaKet 15

Tag Kap^iag

vfjJSiv,

ort ro ev av6pco7rotg vxj/i^Xov /3^eXvyft.a evcoTrtov

" Tov Qeov'" rovro Kat eTepnBev irov irpog avTovg evpiaKerai Xeyav, " Ttoog ^vvaaBe Trtareveiv^ ^o^av itapa av6p6iTrcov Xaft.(3dvovTeg, rvjv ^e

"

^o^av

Tvjv

Ttapa rov fxovov ov ^vjre^Te ;" rovg
eig ^tKatoavvvjv eiiatvoig
Koci

ft.ev

yap

dXi^^lag ovrag

dya6ovg ro7g
01

rwv oXxv arecpavoT Qeog, 20

ye

ft,v]v

dcptXdperot
aeTrrol

viioKptrat

rdya

raig eavrav
ovheig,

\p-^(f)otg

ro

^OKeTv
(f)aivj

eivat

itapa^XeTiovatv, aXX'

w

(^eXrtarot,
**

rtg av

avroig eavrov are(pavo7.
6

Teypaitrat yap,

eyKcof>.v}

fj.ta^erci)

ae

TteXagy Kai

fi.v]

ro aov arofua, dXXorptog Kat

ra
fj.ev

" ad
**

yetXf}.

ydp Seog

ytvcoaKet rdg Kaphiag vfj.mt Kat rtft.a

25

^iKaiov rov aXvj6tvov' aKopTtt^et Se

ra

tS>v dvBpcaitapeaKcov

oardy

av6p'j}TiapeaKta

yap pi^a Kat dpyvj Kat yeveaig
dv^pcottotg vtrepoxptag.
ecog

rvjg fj.efj.iav]fi.evv]g

itapa

Tw Sew Kat
01

itept

m

eiitev 6

Kvpiog
eig

"

vofxog Kat

itpo(^ratf^

"

fj.of/evei^^ 7tpoeypd(f)v}

ro

KaTa Mar^aiov.

KE$. NH.
Hfpi Tov
TrXouflriov

Koi tov Aa^dpov.

19

Ttjv

TtpoKetfj.evviv 7tapaj3oXv]v rv]v

tou itXovatov Kat rov \a)^apov
yiptarog
6

dpiara

ttaiJ.op(poi Kat

^taTtXdrret

Qeog

v]fiMV,

cuare

R

2

124
To7i'

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
elg

XVI.
^tairpeTreiv

19.

ayaGovpytav
fivai

av^/rjixa^xiv

eTieiyeaQai

yjfxag'

BeXei

yap

<f)i\a\X-^Kovg Kai
e7ri[j.eXy]Taii

koivuvikovs Kai

evfxeTO^OTOvg

Kou (ptXoTTTwy^tai

Ka) tZv elg tovto crTrov^aTixaTav

eyedQai veavtKag.

E/ttwv ^e OTt
avci}vvfji.cog

"

avGpairog Ttg

vjv

-TrXovatog"

ag

a(j)tXotKTtpfx,ova tovtov
Trept

eavjfj.avei

KaQag ^ta tov

Trpocpi^TOV 5
[xvvjadco

Twv

[x)^ <pol3ovixev(i}v

avTOV

(pYjaiv

Qeog, " oti ov

ixvj

"

Ttt)v

ovofJLaTCOv

avTav ^ta yetXeav
ev

fxovy^ fxvy]fi.ovevet Se tov irevyjTog
o<

ovofxaaTt, eTtett-^irep
KOLt

yXaaay] ©eou

TOtovTot eiatv.
(pyjai^

eyet

te

koyov

u)g

yj

tSov

'E/Spatav irapa^oatg
ev

Ad^apov

eivai

Ttva KaT
TiTCiy/eiav

eKeho tov Kaipov
Kat dppcoaTiav, ov

lepoaoXvff.Qig,

eayaTtiv iiotovvTa 10
cag etg

fJLvyifi.ovevaat

tov Kvptov,

napa-

^oX^v XafSovTa avTOV
'M.iq^etg

eig efncpaveaTepav

tov Xeyofxevov

tvvafj.tv.

^e
yj

vofui^eTCt)

twv TovTa dKovovrcov, OTt yeyove Ttatv
epycov
yj

dvTairotoatg
etpyjfj.evov
tv

Trowjpav

ayaBciov'

eaTt yap 7rapa(3oXyj to
y}fj.cov

aaTetcog itapa "KptaTOv tov Qeov
01

eayy}fj.aTtafJ.evyi,
fj.yj

15

e't^otev

Tov

eK yy)g eyovTeg itXovtov,

cog

et

l3ovXy]6eiev

etvat ypi^aTot Kai
Tcov

evft.eTd^0T0t Kai KoivcoviKot, Kat TaTg tcov Trevyj^etvyj

dvdyKatg entKOvpeiv eXotVTO,
"^iKf].

Kat d(f)vXdKTcp Treptneaovvov^^evi

Tat

I^ctJjaev

toivvv tov TiXovatov tyjv ctt

twv avay-

Kaicov

yjpfji.evy]v

otppvv.

"

Kveh^vaKeTo,^^

*'

(^'^'^h

iropcpvpav Kai /Svay]v

20

"

crov,"

TovTeaTtv evetfiaTeiv" eanov^a^e, Kai

ev

eaS^Ti ttoXvefj.(patvet

TeXeardT'^ Kai dKaTaXeinTotg TpvcpaTg.
ev(ppaiveaSat
dacoTCog.

Touto yap

to

Ka^

^fLepav.

TrpoaKetTat ^e " XafJ.7Tpcog," TOVTeaTiv,

'O
Trpoi,

^e

Ad^apog

voacc Kat

Trevia ire7re^y]ft.evog
epptfj.fj.evog.,
cov*

e^e^Xy]To,

(py]ai,

25

Tov TTvXwva avTOv dTy]f/.eXcog

oiihevog d^tovfxevog
Trpog Kopov

Xoyov, (pet^ovg Kat (ppovTi^og

dfj.oipog

^y^TcHv

TVjg

Tov irXovatov Tpa7re^y]g Ta irapoXtaOatvovTd T€ Kai dy^y]aTOTepoC
eKoXaC,eTO %\ Kat
(pvjatv,

CTepcog voaca yaXeirciiTdTy],

dXXa dXX

Kat

01

Kvveg,

eXetyov to. eXKy] avTov, ovk d^tKovvTeg

olov

avvaX- 30

yovvTeg Kat BepaTrevovTeg t^ yXcoTT"/], Kai to Xvttovv d^ro^eovTeg,
Kat
(piXo(ppovcog

7reptaXei(povTeg,

07rc»g

Kat

ev

tovtc£

'^etyBi]

TrXovatog Kai

6y]pS>v diry^veaTepog, a>g

aavvaXyy]g Kat
6

d(ptXQtKTipfj.cov

Kat fj.eaTOg 7rday]g aTravSpcoTrtag. vTrdpywv he
^ «u/xaTcrv Cod.

Trevyfg ev

TotovTOtg

XVI.

25-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.

125

^eivoTg^ ovre aTre^vcxayTryjaev, ovre

e^Xa<T(f>^[xv](7eVf ovre yfyavaKTfi-

aev, otnre

Kareyoyyvae rov
o/

ttXovcj-iov.

itoOev ^e

rovro ^^Aov

;

e^ wv

aiiyfffayov avrov

AyyeXoi

topvc^opovvreg^

Ka\ etg rov koXttov

rov \/3f/aaiJ. aTreKarearvjaav.

32

**

Aire6ave ro

^e

Kai

o

irXovcyiog Kai

era.(f>yj'^^

{jivj

aTrXag iiapa- 5

^pa[Ji'j}fxev

eipyi[J.evov

ori fj.era ro

aiioQave^v rov TrXovaiov Trpo^Tev iJ.vy}fxari

Keirai ro " erd^py}."
pvyfievyj vnyjp-^ev

eneiViri
yj

yap Kai ^m, Ka^direp
^v/ji^, ra(f)ov

Karop-

avrov

7rept(f)epov<7a ryjv

adpKa'

Oia rovro 7rpo(Tere6y] ro " erd(f>yj" aTiaXXayetg Se

rov

a<i)f/.arog

aveiaiv eK
hpa,
(f)yi<7tv,

rpv(f)yjg

eig rov a^yjv'

iva ^e fxei^ovtcg

Kararpvy^rai^ 10

rov Ad^apov ev KoXiroig ovra rov A^paafj., axnrep

yap

rov A^afj. eKJSaXoiv rov iiapo^eicrov Kar avrtKpv rovrov KaraiKiaev

avrov
pav

Seog, iva

yj

avve-^^g oxpig dvaveoixxa ro Tid6og aKpt^eareryjg

avrw
^yj

Tiapd^jyyi

eKTrroxrecog

tcSv

aya6m

ryjv

ai<76yiaiVy

ovrw

Kai rovrov Karevavrt rov Aa^dpov KaraKyjcre.
ev roTg
\v

15

Tivog te eveKe ov^i nap erepw ^iKatoog rov Ad^apov, aXX'

KoXnctg rov ^APpaafj. eidev
ovv

;

eTiet^^y]

(f>iXo^evog

yjv

A^padfx.

eXey/og avrov yevyjrai
l3X.eiret.

ryjg fxtao^evtag, '^ta

rovro avrov fxer

eKetvov
otKtav

eKeivog
eiaco
rvjv

Kat rovg irapiovrag eByjpeve Kat eig t^v
eavrov'

eiXKev

ovrog

Kai

rov

eao)

Ketfxevov

20

vape^apa.

34

Aia t/
Tipog rov
e^^j;

te

ov

iipog

rov Ad^apov rov
*'

Xoyov ditereivev,

aAXa
ra

AfSpadf/. (pyjaif

Tidrep

A(3paaf/., eXeyjaov /xe," Kai

EiTiet^y) yiayyv6ri

Kai vjpv6piaaev eK rav Kar avrov Tipay-

fJMTav, Kat evofxtaev avrov fn.vyjaiKaK-^aetv Tidvrag.
<f)y]atf

E/ yap

eyca,

25

roaavryjg dnoXavoov eviioptag, Kat ov^ev
ev

yjOiKy]ft.evog, vitep-

er^ov

roaovrotg ovra

rov

dv^p^aiiov

KaKo7g, Kai
v7iepo(f)6etg

ov^e

xpf^^^tcov

fxere%(OKa, iioXXco fxaXXov
rvi

avrog ovrcog

ovk eiiivevaei

ydptri ravrf].

Tavra

Xeyofxev^ ovyi rov
eKe7vog,

Aa^apov Kaivpfoori

povvreg, ov

yap S^

ovrccg '^teKetro
eKt7vov,

dXX

obrog

ravraso
evo-

he^oiKoog ovK
fxt^^e

eKoXeaev

dXXa

rov

A^padfx

e(f)Q)vy]aev'

ydp avrov dyvoe7v Ta
ovv eKe7vog
^ayj
**
;

yeyevy]fxeva.

25
*'

T/

reKvov fLv^adyjri ori drreXafSeg

ra aya6d aov
ovk ftnevj
^ia6eig

ev r-^

aov."

YiKo-n^awfxev (f)iXoao(f>tav ^iKaiov'
7iafXTiovY]pe,

d'jidv6p<t}'jie

Ka) wfxe Kat

roaavra KaKa

tov35

126

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Kai

XVI.

26.

avBpco^nov, (piXavdpairia^ [xefJLVVjaai vvv

ekeov^ Kat avfX7ra6etas

Kai avyyvccfxyjg' ovk atayyvrj ovfk epvSpta^, ov^e eyKaXvTTTVj;
ri
;

aWa
ra

" reKVOv"
yap

(f^vjatv,

" aiteka^e? ra ayaOa aov
ff.r]

ev rrj ^®'^ aov'^^

i^v^^riv

reraTreivoofji.evYjV

TrpoaTapd^yj^,

(f>yjat'

dpKet

rvji rifji.wpiag

avrx,

ft.fi

TrpoaeTrefxf^atvcofjiev

avrov rai$
d

avfJL^popai^f 5

reKvov,
eKeli,

ov

Kvptog

elfLi, fi.eratttwfxi

aot,

ro
rt

evrevGev
eiire,

dneXBeh

ovK eartv
aov,

vjfJi.erepov

Xotitov.

Ata
ocpetXifjv

ovk

eXa^eg ra

dyaQd

aXX " dneXa(3eg

;"

ydp riva

ev^hetKvvfj.evov

Kat tYiXovvroi eariv' dnoXaff.lSdvet ydp rtg rd o<peiXofi.eva.

T/

oiiv

evrevOev fj.avBdvoft.ev

;

ort

Kav

ft.tapoi riveg

wat, Kav etg 10

ea-^^arov

KaKtag eXvjXaKoreg, TtoXXdKtg

ev

rt

Kat

tvo

Kat rpia

etpydaavTO ayaOd' KatTcep ovv Kai ovrog
ev/ifj.epiag

TrXovaiog, oBev ^td rvjg

rvjg

ev

rw^e rw

(Btw
ev
rvj

dTroXa/Sav
^ayj
ev
v)

avrd, ^KOvaev

ori

" aneXa^eg ra ayaSd aov

aov, Kat

Aa^apog
Kat rpia

OfJ.oi(ag

ra KaKa.
rvjKag,

laceg

yap Kai ovrog
rvjg
o^^vvvjg

Kai ovo

vj

vjft.ap-

15

evrevBev

^td

vjg

vTrefj.etvev,

direXa^e ravra.
v)

Aio

(pvjaiv, **

o^e TrapaKaXeTrai, av Ve
TrotvjaavTt, eXeye.

o^vvdaaf"

ydp Kptatg

avvjXeog roo
2,6

ft.v]

Ti

^e avjfxatvet OTrep eliiev 'A/^paa/x.,
'

**

ori yrdafka fj.eya earvf^ta(f)opdv
ovrctig

"

piKrai,

Kai

ra

e^vjg

;

rojv

rav
ai

^iKatoov

iTpog

rovg 20
vj

Ttratovrag'

waTrep

yap
rvjv

evavriai

TipoBeaetg,
^e
rvjv

dft.tyv]g

fj^erdaaatg, rwv

ft.ev

dveatv, rcov
vTrep

KoXaatv
Xotirov

'^e-yofj.evav.

dirorvy^v ^e
iKervjptav.

toJv

KaB
irag

eavrov,

erepm

irotenai
viro

rviv

Opa

(ptXavBpamog Kat

vjfi.€pog

yeyovev

rvjg

KoXaaecog'

yap rov Aa^apov
Kai

Karacfypovav irapovrog, erepoov a-nov- 25
7refj.(f>B^vai

rav
oiKov

(ppovTi^et,

napaKaXei

rov

Ad^apov

eig

rov

rov Trarpog, Kat ov^e aTrXwg irapeKdXeaev dvaar^vai riva
veKpav,

Ik

rm

dXXd

rov Ad^apov, oirag,
ft.vptoig

(f)Vja]v,

i^ovreg

avrov

arecpavaBevra, ov e^Xeirov
ft.dprvpeg

KaKoXg
Xtfj.ov

dyavti^oft.evov, 01 yevoft.evot

r^g Treviag avrov rov
Kat r^g
'ho^vig

Kai rav

o^yvaJv,

avrot Kaiso

rvjg fj.eTa(3oXvig

avrov yevofnevoi fidprvpeg, eKare"^^^

pxBev re irat^evBevreg, Kat fj.aBovreg ori ov f-^XP^

irapovrog

^tov ra

vjfj.eTepa

ar-^aerat Trpdyft.ara, K'dv
rvjv

ovrci)

TrapaaKevaacov-

rai wg ^yv>j5^va< ravrvjv ^tacpvyeiv

KoXaaiv.

29

T/

ovv

\^padfj.

;

" eyovat Moxrea Kai rovg irpo^yiTag, aKov- 35

XVII. 5" a-draxjav avTwv."
o5f 6

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
Oi/j^ ovtq} ya^pt <I>V'^'» <^^ Kvj^yj

127
twv a^eA0a5v,
^i^a-

TTOf^aas avTovg 0eof*

[xvpiovg •yap avTotg

€7i€aTr,<7e

aKoiXov^.

Tivo^ ^e €V€K€V avTanoKpiQeii 6 TrXovcrios

e<f>'rj,

"

ovy^i,

iraTep

" A^paajx, aXX
**

edv ti^ eK

veKpiiov

iiopevS^ Ttpog aitTOvg, jueTavo^-5

aovo"/v;" hieiVrj avTog ovTog tSov Seioov ypacptov

aKovm

KaTe<ppovei,

Kai [xvSovg evofii^ev etvai ra Xeyofxeva, e^ wv avTog vTtevoei, Kai
Trep)

Tav d^eXcpxv ovToog vnoTtTevovatv
;"

(txjnep

Kayw,

oti

" Ttg
a^Ty

vjX6ev
;

" eKei6ev

Ttg eK veKpav dveaTVj

;

Tig eiTre to. ev

tw

'^ia

TOVTQ edv Tig aito twv veKp^v diieX^vi, ovk dTiKJTyjaovatv avTW, lo

aAAa [MaXXov To7g Xeyofxevoig irpoo-e^ova-iv. " e/7re Se," (pi^at, " "^pog " anTov, et M.(oae(i}g Kat toov Trpocf^vjTav ovk dKovovatv, ovSe edv Tig
*'

eK

veKpwv
o

dvaaTri, 7teta6-fiaovTat.^^ OTt

^e

tovto

ovTnog

eaTiv

dXrj6eg, Kai

txv ypa^pSov ovk dKovxv, ov^e veKpm
oi

avtaTafj.eva}v

dKovaerai, e^et^av
Kai twv
irpo<pr]Tiov,
fi.ev

^iov^^aloi.

ot

eTret^rj

Mooaecog ovk yjKovaavi^

ov^e veKpovi i^ovTeg dvaardvTag eTrtarevaav,
Tor$-

dXXa

vvv

dveXe7v tov Ad^apov eire^/etpovv, vvv ^e

'Atto-

aToXoig

eiieTf^ttav,

KatTOi tioXXwv dvaardvTcov ev to? Katpoo tov

aravpov»
ILoX-novg

^e tov

APpaaft, Koi
o

tov ^JaaaK,

Koi

tov 'laKw/S ao

TOfrof^ eivai 6 aytog Atowatog Kat fJiaKapicoTdTag X-^^etg, Tag
etg TTjV ev
I

ApewTiaytTrig Tag ^etoTaTag
iidvTag Tovg ^tKaiovg,

vTro^^e^xofnevag

avTa7g ay^pa Kat fnaKaptcoTaTVjv reXetaaiv.
aKav^dX(ov XaXoov
€(og

Ylept Twv
etg TO

"

d^pyjaeig ayToo," TTpoeypd^py]

KOTa MaT^arov.
Txv dpyatoTepoov dytccv
01

25
(pvjatv 6

5

Ylept
Titaret

AnoaToXog,

OTt

ev

tvj

efJiapTvp-^dvjaav
ot

Tipea^vTepoi, tovtwv ovv ^vjXooTai yevevjfu7v

a6at ^ovX6fj.evoi

aytoi AitoaToXoi, "iip6a6eg

TiiaTtv" eXeyov
tva
fiv]

tw

oecriroT-yj

\piaT(0,

ovk

aiTovat

^e

ntaTtv

dnXag,

diitaTOvg avTovg vofxtavj Ttg,
TV)V

dXXa

Tipoa^vjKVjv

ntaTecog, TovreaTt

30

etg

TovTQ /3el3ai(oaiv. napaaKevdaai te

avTovg ^ovXofxevog

teKTiKovg yevea6at Tvjg TotavTV]g ydptTog,
*'

<f)V]atv,

"

el ej^eTC

niartv

cog

KOKKov atvdnecog, eXeyere av
e^vjg.

tjj

avKafxtvca ravTV], eKpi^io6v]Ti'*

Kat ra

Et yap to
av
v]

Tienvjyog ovrco

Ka) Kara yvjg eppi^co-

fxevov fxeraKtvfjaetev

r^g iitaTexg

"^vvafxtg,

Ka6oXov

(paivj

rig^S

128

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
[xv]

XVII.
rj

ii.

av, [xyjhev ovTcag aKivyjTOV eivai o

aaXivaeiev

itkttis'

ii<e.m

fxevToi "TrpoaeKTeov aacjyaXSoi, cooTe

jU.17

Tiva \oyov Xoyii^eadai Kara

Kfv^v eKTiXyi^iv elneiv tovtq
Se

tw

^taTroTi^ Xp;crToi), Trpog wcpeXeiav
yj

fxaWov Kai

actiTyjpiav rjfJLWVy

Kai yap iravTa layvei
aivdiredig

ryjg Oeiag

^vvd[xea)g

e^ovaia.

Tlepi

yap kokkov

Tipoeypd(f)Vj

eig S

TO KaTO, Tov lS/[aT6a7ov.
7
FiTrei^^Yj

7re(f)VKe
d<f>op[J.Yj

Trag dei

6

avBpwrtivog vovg KaTacpepeaQai
eiii

eig

<f)i\o^o^iav,

^e tov 7rd6ovg yiverai TiroXXdKig, to

riai

tS)v dpiaTCtiv dv'hpaya6Yj[i.drm evooKi[j.yjaai

itapa 0eaj, TiayydXettov

^e

TOVTO Kai ©eco KareaTvy^[J.evov, KaTa(f)epei eig tovto yvcc^JiVjgio

dpyeKaKog

^pdKoov, (og oieaBat

Taya

itov

Kai

0(f)eXeiv

tov
tyjv

Seov
^cavjv.

Tag dvccTdTCo Ti[mg, orav evKkea Kai ev^oKifxov eycoai

A<a
"

TovTO Twv

7tpoKei[xev'jiV

dvayvcaafKdTCov tyjV owafKiv 6 ^eaTtoTYjg

Ttoienat
Y]

"KpiaTOg, Xeycov,
to,

"

rig e^
e^Yjg.

v[xwv

^ovXov eycov dporpiavra
ort
1

Ttoi^iaivovTa," Kai

Ai^daKet yap htd tovtcov

5

T^f ^eaTioTtK^g e^ovaiag
Tcov

yj

^vvafLig, cog

o<^A^/xa Ttavrayov itapd.
e(f>Yj,

oiKercov ^yjt€7 tyjv

vTtoTayvjv.

ov

yap ydptv,

ofnoXoyyjaet

Tco oiKerYj,

Kav

ei

yevoiro Ttap
itpeitov,

avrov
[/.yj

itav oitep e^et yeveaBat

Kard

ye

TO TYjg

tovXetag

aXXa

TtXi^povvTog [xev

to 0(f)€tXd-

[jievov

Kiv^vvog

eTterat, TtXvjpovvTog

^e ydptg

ovh\ [Kia,

Kav

et

20

^eaitOTYig
QpcoTtog

\piaTOg
[xovov

vitapyjav

ayadog Kat

(f>tXoTt[j.og

Kai (f>tXdv-

ov

iao^vva[i.a

yepa roig

Kd[K.vovatv

eitayyeXXerat,
(f>Yjatv

aXXa

Kat itoXXco itXeov rovg irovovg VTtepfSatvovra, KaOcog

Ttavao^f^ogTlavXog,

"

ort

ovk a^ta ra TtaS-^^iara tov vvv Katpov,
yj[i.ag.'^

"

Ttpog TV]v

[xeXXovaav "to^av ditoKaXv^f^Byjvat eig

25

KE4>. NO.
Hepl
i j

Ta>v

i XfTTpmv.

Tvjv eavrov ^o^av ^ta
(pavvj

Tyjg

[xeyaXoitpeTtovg Oavfiarovpytag

e^tov

KaQiarvjaiv

'^coTYjp.

epyerat
ovrco

aayvivevcov

elg

itiartv
ditetBrjg,

dKdpotov lapavjX,
^e
7]

aXX

vjv

Kat
e(f)Y}v

aKXvjpog re Kat
yj

^v^o

ditohet^tg aa(f>Y]g, av

dpricog,

twv XeTtpwv ttaKdBapatg'
cog

ovrot

yap
rov

TtoXecov

t€

Kai

kco[i.wv

aTteXavvofnevot

aKdQaproi

Kara

^coiJaecog

vofnov,

VTtavrviaavreg

ra

Hcor^pi, eXtitdpovv

XVII.

22.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
toi)

129
wvo/^a^cv,

avaWaTTedOai
oiQaaKaXov.
To/^-

KaKov,

Kai
<ov,

eTr^oraT^jv
e^vj,

tovt((7ti

o

§e <f)iXdv6pa)Tios

" virdyeTej ^ei^aT€ cavTovf

lepcvai.

Aia

t/

ju*;

[xakXov

%<l>ri)

5e'Aa>,

KaBapiiByjTi,

KaBa Kai

e(f>

(Tepov Xeirpov, TrpoaTeTaye ^e [xaXXQV,
iepev(7i
;

eavTov^ eiri^ei^aTe toT^ 5

vojtxof

eKdXei Ttpog tovto irdkiv Tovg T^f Xeirpag aTiyjX^&>j

Xayfxevovg.
Toiig

^EKeXeve yap wg

TeSepaTrevfxevovi Pa^i^eiVf Kai

Twv

'lou^a/cwv

KaB-ifyyjTag, '^r]XovoTi

tov$

lepeTg,

^iafxapTv-

pacrSai, oti itap

eXTri^a Kai Tiapa^o^cog aiiyjXXdyyjaav toi) KaKOv,
too

Tov \picrTQv TOvTo KaTavevaavTog. Kai o^ ev
Ka^apoi yivovTai, Kai
pia-TOV
XvjByjv
oi

avTovg vndyeiv lo
eig

[xev

evvea

aTe iov^aioi ovTeg,

dyaOeoJ,

efxTreaovTeg, ovy^

vTreaTpeipav tovvai '^o^av

tx

o$ev aKXripoKdphiov Koi

dfxvi^fxova iravTeXccg ^eiKvvei
o

tov

iapayiA,

he

dxXoyevyjg, TOVTeaTiv

YjafxapeiTyigy ^ia
[xdTy}v
**

to ef

Aaavpiav

Kaidyeiv to yevog dXXoyevy}g' ov yap

Xeyet, ev [xeaa TVjg 15

"Zafxapeiag Kat TaXtXaiag Kat lov^aiag,

vireaTpexl/e [xeTa (pxvyjg
01

"

[xeydXrig ^o|a^i»v tov Seov."

AeiKvvei ovv oti

'Ea[xapetTai

evyvai[xoveg, lov^^atoi ^e evepyeTov[xevoi

ayaptaTOvaiv.
T&rs" irpog

20

ETrei^^
^ie[xe[xvyiTO

y)t.p

twv oyXuiv YuiTrjp

ev

airavTag Xoyoig

navTayov T^g j3aaiXeiag tov Qeov, ^ia tovto KaTa- 20
TaA,av€$,
07

[xei^ittivTeg 0/

Ta^^a Ttov elg vovv e^ovTej OTi tov

eiti

^vXov ddvarov vno^xevel TaHg avTav ^vaTpovtiatg aeaayyjvevoft.evog^
eig TOVTo

KareipoovevovTeg, Kai (paat, " ttotc epyeTai

rj

PaatXeia

" Tou Qeov," avTi

tqv, itpo Ty^g itapa aov XaXov^xevyjg ^aatXetag,
X-^xpeTai.

aTavpog ae Kai SdvaTog
*•'

Ti ow

ttpog

TovTa HpiaTog; 2^
ev

yj

^aaiXeia tqv Seov evTog v[xm eaTi^^ TovTeaTiv
Ttpoatpeaeai,

Ta7g

vfi.e-

Tepatg

Kai

ev

e^ovaia

Kenai tov Xa/Seiv

avTyjv.
t>jv

E^ecTT/ yap dvQpaitoi TtavTt t*jv elg HptaTQv ^tKaiooatv,
TVjg TttaTetag Oe

Oia

StjAovot/ /icaTaTrAovT^aavT/, Kat ^ia Trdavjg dpeTyjg

eKXeXaft.Ttpvaft.evx, Trjg

txv ovpavxv jSaaiXeiag
^QvXofxevog

eTttTV)(eiv.

30

22

'KTOtfi.ovg

Se

eivat

Tovg dytovg

avTOv fxaQi^Tag

Ttpog Ttav OTtovv
vTtofxovyjv, iva

twv avidv Ttecj^vKOTWV, Kat TtpoevTpeiti^eaBat ttpog

eutoKtfLoi yevofxevot ^vv^^Sxatv etaeXQeiv etg tijv toD
(fytjat

0eou PaaiXetav,

itpog

avTOvg'

" eXevaovTat

y^txepat

OTe

"

eTttBvfxyjaeTe

fnav txv

yjfxepxv

tov

vtov tov avQpcoTtov ihe7v, Kat

35

130
**

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
iiii

XVII.

33.

ovK OipeaOe" TovreaTiv

yYig (jvv^iayayYjg avrov,
v7ro[J.evovTe$,

Kanoi Kai

T0T€
6eatv

avv avToi ovref,

6Xi\liiv

aXXa

Trpoi
to.

avTmapdeXaTTOva.

Twv

v7repKei,[J.evm
tvjv

KaKav alpeTa
ovtov dvdXv)xpiv

Tro)?

riaav

Me/^ovwv yap fxeTa
Yiepi
TYjg

6Xi4iecov eTreipddi^aav.

^evTepag avTov Tiapovaiag, Kai oti " w^ daTpaTrri 5

ovTwg eaTai,
eig TQ

cwf

/x^ €7riaTpexpaTco eig

ra

oiriaa^

Trpoeypacpv]

KOTa Mar^a/bv.
Aia[/.e fx-^vvKe

Ktpiaaot AaehanapeiA2.
irvjv

Xeym, wg daTpaKara aapKa Kai
KeKevooTai

eaea6ai

ttjv

eavTOv irapovaiav.
vjfJi.iv

eyevyjdv) fjiev

eK yvvaiKOs, rrjv e(f

TrXyjpdoaav

oiKovofuiav'

^ia 10

TOVTO Kai TeTaireivooKev eavTOV, Kai ovk
eKdXei yap

ev ^o^yj OeOTVjTog
yj

efJ.(f)av(iog'

Kaipog eig tovto, Kai r^g oiKovofJ.iag

'Xjpeia' ft.eTa

te Trjv CK veKpSov dvdaTaaiv dvaTrTag elg ovpavov, Kai
tS)

avvetpevaag
So|i7f,

Qew
fj.Yiv

Kai
ev

Ylarpt, KaTajSrjaeTat
av6pco7rivYj

irdXtv,

cvk
ev

ev

vcpeaet
toi)

ofTe

afj.iKpoirpe7reia,

dXX

tyJ

ITaTpoc 15

vTrepoy^'^, 7rXvj6vog
cog

AyyeXcov dopvcpopovavjg avTOv, Kai TraptaTafxevYjg
tSov

Qeco

Kat

K.vptai

oXcov.

H|ei Totvvv
'*

cog

aaTpaTrv} Kat
v}

XeXriBoTag, Kat ovhevt TrtaTevTeov XeyovTt,

i^ov whe

eKeiJ*'

^^

^epet ^e etg
e^eXdeiv aTro
yevofj.evviv

v7ro'^etyfj.a

tyjv

yvvalKa tov Aojt,
toc

ty\v

fj.eTd

to

Ho^^Ofncov

aTpa<peiaav eig

OTriaco,

Kat ttd tovto 20

aTYjXYjv

dXog, TOVTeaTtv, a7roXt6co6eiaav, 07rag eKaaTog

TYjg

7rvevfj.aTiK^g
efJ.vY}fj.ovevae

epyaatag, dv^petwg dvTe^xvjTat.
Ka)
toov

Ato Kat tov
epyov Kai

AwT

ev

llo'^ofj.otg,

6eiov Trvpog

Tpo(pYj yevofxevotg.

Tlcog d^roXXvat Ttg tvjv eavTOv ^^^X^iv, tva avTvjv ^taacoavi

;

v)

2^

Kat Ttva TpoTrov

^taacoaat

vofxiaag d^roXXvatv

avTYjv

;

6e7og

A^ioaToXog
*'

Trept tovtcov (pvjaiv,
TO^ig

"

0/ §e

tov \ptaTov ^li^aov adpKU

earavpcoaav, avv

7ra6-fjfj,aai

Kat

Tatg e7rt6vfuaig," irovoig

tviXovoTt

Kat Toig etg evae/Setav dywat, KaTaveKpovvTeg to TVjg

aapKog

(f)povY}fj.a,

Ka6ag

(pYjatv,

*'

veKpcoaare Ta fneXY) Ta
e7ti6vfj.tav

eTrt

TY}g
tyjv

30

"

"yijf,

TTopi/eiav,

aKa6apatav,

7ra6og,

KaKY}v

Kai

"

TrXeove^iav'^^

oaot ovv tovtcov eveKa veKpovvTai, ovtoi
ot

aeawKaai
/Stov

TYjV

eavrcov
'^

^v/^v,

ye

fJ.Y}v

(ptXv}tovov

aipovfj.evot

Kat

oiovTai

Tyyv

eavTcov ^vyv}V KTda6ai, d^roXXvovat
•>

TrdvTcog avTvjv

orovTt

Cod.

.

XVIII.
**

1.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
"
e<V ttjv

131
(f>6opdv.''

yap

o-TTf/pcov," (prjaiVf

(rdpKa, deptaet

iari
o

§€ Kai

erepco^

aTroAetravTa Tiva ti^v (avTov
TteTtpdya^Ji

\pvyjl^v

tiaTaaai,
^^X'?^

Kai

01

ixaKdpioi

[xdpTvpe^f TOVf

y-^XP^

'^^^

aifxaTo<; '^itveyKovTeg dywva<;, rrjg eig yipiaTOv aydiri^g eveKa, Kai
(TTecfiavov

TaT^ eavToov KetpaXai^ dvYixpav.

ol e|

dvdv^pov ^e

t|/i/j^^f

5

Kai yvafivji tov napavTiKa Tyj^ aapKO^: ^iacpvyovTe^ OdvaTov, ovTot
<f)ovevTat

T^f eawT^v yey ovaat

ifvj^^f*

KaToiK-^aovTat

yap

etg

<^ov

TYj<;

KaKoav^peia<: v^e^ovref ^iKa^.
ev iiTuiyeia.

EotK€ ^ta TOVTCov Tovg
01
jotev

Kat irovot^ ovTa$ vito^rikovv'
acD(f>pQ-

yap ro

t^j-

irrayeiag (poprtKOv yevvafjog cpepovre^,
Ptovvres,
oi

lo

vo}^

re Kai

evteiKai

ovrot

TrapaXeKpQYjaovraif dtKatot

^y]\ovoTt

rvyydvovreq'

^e

[xyj

Totovroi,

dXXa KaKovpyoi Ka\
r^ ^ta
iivpog

vd<ryji <f>av\oTy]TO<; eTrtTfi^evTai, dtfteB-^a-ovrat
Ketaotj.evot
^iKyj.

imo-

d^TroareKei

yap,

<f>y}ai,

rovg 'Ayyekovg

avrov

Kat eKXe^uiatv eK t«v dixaprcoKiov rovs ^tKaiovg, Kat Ttpoaotaovatv 15
aiiTco.
I

36

To

^e

"

o^rov

to

awfj.a,**

Kat ra e^^f, tovto

^yjkoT,

aairep ovv
Itt

acofjiarog

Ketfievov

veKpov

ra aapKo^opa rav

ttttjvwv

avra

awrpeyet, ovrag orav
vdvreg
yeiwv
ot

viog tov dvOpcoirov -^apayevyjratf rore Vq
01

aerot, rovreartv

vxl^yjXa

Trerofxevot koi dvco

rwv

eirt-

20

KoafitKciov avevyfyft.evoi 'npayfx.drcov, eir
ovofndi^et

avrov dvo^pafJ.ovvTat*^
tia ro d(f>aveg Kat

NvKra

rov

ryjg

Kptaecog Katpov

dfffpoa^OKyprov ryjg Trapovaiag avrovt Kkivyjv ^e ryjv dvdiravatv.

KE*.
Ufpi Tov KpiTOv
1
**

5.
Trjs

ddiKias.

2^
Kptryjg rtg

A<a t^?
yjv,"

irpoKetfxevyig

TrapajSoXyjg

t%

Xeyovayjg "

Kat
6

ra

e^^g, dttaXenrrcag yjfndg irpoaevyeaOat TrporpeTrerat
y}fji.cov,

Hptarog

Seoc

Kat
rov

fji.y]

cKKaKeiv ev raTg ^(^aeatv.

E<
ft,^

yap Tov a^tKOv

Kptrvjv,

fn^^re

Seov

<f>ol3ovfj.evov

ff.^^re

avBpcoTrovg evrpeTroft.evov, ^e^vacoTryjKe

r^g X^P^^^ ^ 0"^''€%V

Trpoao^^og,

coare
fJiMV

Kai aKovra Trotyjaat

ryjv

eK^iKyjaiv avryjg, Trcog o <f>tXotKTip-

Kat ixiaovovyjpog, 6 rotg dyaircoatv avrov xe7pa vefJMV det t^v

c

Hoc Scholium

Cyrillo tribuit

Cod. Meerman.
2

Vid. Suppl. ad

Cat. in S. Matth.
S

133

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA

XVIII.

8.

erco^ovaav, ov Trpoaoe^eTai fxev roy? itpotJiovTag

avTa Kai

ev ^jU-epa
;

Kai

iv vvKTtf iroi-^^rei ^e ry^v eK^^iKrjaiv
o

avTaVf wg eKXeKTav avTov

Kai TavTa fxev 6 ayiog KvpiXXog.
elg
'^iacpopovg

Se 'KpvcroaTOfj.og Kai avTog
Trjg

Xoyovg avTOv
rjv

Trepi

tov Kpnov

a^iKiag Xeyei,

OTi

irovripog Tig

Kai

'7tapavo[J.og,

Kai avTO de to ayiov tjvay- 5

yeKiov TovTO ^eiKvvaiv ev t'2 Xeyeiv tov

Kvpiov,
ov

*'

aKOvaaTe
TroiYjafi
'^ia

ti
t^iv

"
*'

6

Kpnrjg

TVjg

a^iKiag keyei'

'he

Qeog

fjivj

eK^iKVj(7iv

Twv eKXeKTfhv ayTot)*"

-TiapeaTi^a-e

yap

tovtcov^
Yltog

aXXov

eivai

tov KpiTfjv TVjg dhiKiag, Kai
efj.(f>ave7g

akXov tov Qeov.

ovv fj^era TOiavrag

dnohei^eigf ov <f>piTTOvcn riveg oXoog, 10
ti

Kav

eig evvoiav XafK^dveiv,

fxrj

ye Kat Trapprjcta XaXeTv, avTOV

Tov Seov eivai KptTrjv Trjg dttKtag, eKTtXrjTTeaBat y^r].

8

OvK dyvo^v
(fiYiai,

heairoTrjg

X.piaT0g, Trwg
eXGcov

yap

6

irdvTa etowg

;

"

Tikriv

vtog tov avSpccTTOv

apa

evprjaet Trjv ittaTtv

"

eirt

T^j"

yrjg ;"

akX

vTreKcpatvcov

OTt

diroopafxovvTat

Ttveg

ev 15

eayaTOtg Katpolg T^f

opSrig TrtaTtcog

Kat dhia^X-^Tov, TtpoaeypVTeg

Trvevfxaat nXdvrjg Kat ipevhvjyoptatg hteaTpafXfj.eviov dvBpooircov.

KE<I>.
Ilepi

SA.

Tov ^apia-aiov Ka\ tov Te\a>vov.

JO

Ata
"^fxdg

Trjg

tov ^aptaatov Kat rov reXcovov irapajSoXyjg ht^hda-Kei 20

<f>tXdv&pcoTTog

Kvptog Kai Qeog li^aovg

6

^ptarog, riva
[xr]

^p>j

rpoTrov

rdg

irpog

avrov iroteHaOai herjaeig, tva
irpdyfxa,
fxrj^^e

dfxtaSov

evpeBYi

rotg y^pcofxevoig ro
rovrcov

ht

wv

oo(f>eXe7a6at

rig

vofxi^ot, htd

avrov Traporpvvet Ka6 eavrov rov rwv dvcoSev

y^apta-fxdrcov
*'

torrjpa Qeov.

Teypatrrat ydp, ori

" eari

'^iKatog

25

diroXXvfxevog ev dtKatoo"- avrov'^^ oQev Kat
fxr}

^aptaalog evravBa htd

rovro KaraKeKptrai, ort

entcrTrjfxovcog eTroteiro rrjv Trpoaevy^^v.

rioAXa ydp Kar avrov ra eyKXrifxara'
fi.ovov

Kat yap

cog

dvovg

ov

redavfxaKev avxog eavrov,
6

aXXa

Kat iroXXovg erepovg
vir

avv

TW
oaov

reXcovr] KareKptvev'
eiTreiv

he

KaraKptSetg
eig

avrov

reXoovrig ovo

30

dvareivat
tv]v

roXfxav
dog

vxpog

rovg o(f>9aXfxovg,
avrrjv,

aXXa
rov

TreptaretXag

irapprjaiav
^

ovk

ej^wv

roig airo

i>t^iKat'j.'i

Cod.

XVIII.

12.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOY.
irXyjTTOfxevo^;
tS>v

133
fxovov
0(f)dy^vai

avvei^OTog
0fa5,

Ix^y^oig

ecpo/SeiTO

Kai

wg

oXiya (ppovriaa^

uvtov

vofxctiv.

Tvtttcov

ovv

to

«TT^flof Q}fJLQ'Aoy€t

xa eyKX-^fxaTUf Kai ^eiKvv^
Kai

cog

larpw
o

t>jv vocrov,

eXefjByjvai irapfKaXet, ^io

"

KaT€l3vj"

(f^Yjo-lv

"^iKaiog KpiTyji,

" ovTog ^e^tKaiwfkevog
yapovv aK0V0VT€i

eig tov oikov

avTOv" Trap

eKeivov.

TavTa

toi- 5

efx.(f)pova}i

Tocg

apeTag KaTopQcaacofxev, Kat

fxyj^eig

TOVTOV "xaptv VTTfpoxptav

voaeiTCi}, jU,e/xv^o-flaj

^e fxakXov tov Kvpiov
TiotvjcyYjTe'"

enTOvrog Tolg ayiotg A7roaTo\oig,
^vjXov Sc ort

"

OTav ravTa itdvra

ra

'hiaTeraytj.eva avroTg,
w(f>eiXof>.ev

" Xeyere

ort "^ovkot dyjpeloi

"

€aft.ev,

Kat
Ixpav

iioti^aat

TteTTOf^Kafxev.^^

"

zra^

yap," 10
eavrov

(ftrjatf
*'

"

eavTOV

raTretvcoS^^aerat,

6

Se

raTietvm

vypccB-^aerat.^^

'I21A12POT
(.KTiXyiTTeaBai,

IIhaotsictot EniSTOAH.
-ttSos

0avfxd^etv

e(f>yig

Kat

fxev

^apicrahg fxeyaXoppyjfxovYjaag
Kat
ft.ei^ova

Trpoe-

Kpovaev.

^e

I«;S

irXeiova
6

elpviKwg

ev^oKtfxi^aev. 15

Akov€ rotvvv

avvrofxctis.

fxev

fxi^^evog

itapaKivovvroi fxyj^e epe(fypovcov fxei^ovcag

Bt^ovros fxeyaXy\yop^Vi Kai ry]q otKovfxevyfc, aTtdayjg
6

^aptaahg,

eiKorcog iipoaKpovet'
KpvTrrcov
Ttpog

v7T€pyj(f>aviav

yap

voaei.

6 he

ev

fxev

rx

ev^oKtfxeiv

rd oiKeia
ro

TrXeoveKryjfxara, ev

^e

tw
20

KaKyiyopeHaBat

(f)pd^cov

diro^^vaxaOat

ra

e7rt(f)€pofxeva

eyKXyjfxara, ccaitep

dot^^ifxog

ireTrotYiKev 'Iw/3, Tidayjg

airtag

e^ca

KaS€ary)K(v
Xayfxevovg.
Ylep)

eig

rovg ov

^eovrcog

KaKvjyopiag r^g atrtag aTryjX-

Twv

f3p€(f)it)V

Ka)

Ttep)

rov

elitovrog

^i^aaKdXov
eig

ecog

"

Kai r^ Tptryj

y]fxep(i

dvaary\a€rat^

Ttpoeypdcf^yj

ro

Kara 25

^arBam.
12

Sethpot ek TH2 nP02 Mafnan.
rvyeh, rag oiKeiag itpd^etg

'Karcag
aog

ev fxeaca

Toy lepov

fxeyaXocpavccg yjret re Kai Ttpoay\vy€rOi Kat
dityjptBfxe^ro

d^iog av wv j^ret

Kai eXeye,

"

vyjarevQ} ^tg

" rov aa{3^drov'^ Kai ra
TtXeov ryjv
Ttepi

e^y^g,

Ka) oaca itoXXd KareXeye, roaovrov 30

Betav dite^vev

dKoy^v,

Kai

6

rm

pyjfxdrcav

oyKog Kevog

ra

X^iXyj Kareppet, Ka\ etg d(f)pov ^ieXvero, KaBd^tep TtacpXdreXcovy^g

^ovra KVfxaTa.

^e

rig fxaKpdv earag Kat

rov

veca

ryjv

eay^dryjv vTto^vg yccvtav, ro
fxtfxvyjaKcov

arvjGog eitate, t*;v 4'V%'»?v coaitep

vito-

^id

rovrov

rm

avryj

iteTtXyifxfxeXyjfxevccv

Kai

eigSB

X34
oiaQvjcriv
'^ieyetpoiiv

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
KaOev^ovaav, Kai
fxyj^e

XVIII.
ev
ttJ

17.

Tvj^

Trpoaevyyj

aTafTtdDq

avTOv vjyov^evog a^ioV
fxoi

tovto [xovov eToX(xa Xeyeiv,
fXoXig e^iov tov aTOfna-

Seog, iXaaSrjTi
TOi
PYiff^a,

tw aff.apTw\w' Kai to

TTTepv^iv vxprjXa7g eii^fipero, 7rpo$ ovpavov avecpepeTO, Kai
e'ia(o Trjg

Kpovcov TVjv Bvpav,

Beiag aKOVjg 7rapeTref».7reT0, Kat eOiKaiov 5
oiofj.evog

Tov irpoaev^aft.evov.

6

yap

eavTOV a^iov elvai tov eig

Ta

o^vTa .TtapaKVTiTeiv tov lepov, Kai -nXvjaiov tivai tov &eov, noppca
fKeTa T(5v ^e^YjXdov aiioppKpYjaeTai'
(ppiTTCOv, Kai

^e

Kai Tag $vpag xpavaat

avTav twv Taft.ieim tov (SaaiXeccg KaTaTpvcpvjaei,
rao

KaTo,
**

Tvjv

ev

aafKaTi

vvff.(pivjv

tyjv

Xeyovaav,

"

eiavjveyKe

|xe

10

(SaaiXevg eig to Tafxieiov afToiJ."

17

ToT XpTSosTOMor.

Ai^daKccv Tovg

ff.a9v]Tag 6

^ptaTog

fi.e-

Tpid^eiv Kai Tvcpov KaTairaTeiv Koafi.iKOv, Toig TOtovTOig tvjv (3aai-

Xeiav eTiayyeXXerat (pdaKcnv, "

dft.vjv,

Xeyx

vfii.iv,

og eav

fivj

^e^vjTui

"

TV]v

(3aaiXeiav tov Seov wg Trat^tov, ov

fi.vi

etaeXBvi

etg avTVjV.

15

0'vTog yap (piXoaocptag opog, to ft.eTa avveaeccg aitXaaTov eivat.

KE<I>.
Uepi Tov eTTepaTTiiravTos

EB.
toj' ^lrjorovv

TrXovcrlov,

18

ToT

ATTOT. ^T/vcf ^ta(3dXXovat tov veaviaKov tovtov
irovvjpov,

cog vttov-

Xov Ttva Kai

Kai ft.eTa Ttetpag tco
'/^pvift.dTOiv

Ivjaov

irpoaeXBovTa, 20

eych ^c (piXdpyvpov

avTOv Kat
^e

^TTOva, ovk dv TTapatTYj-

aatfxvjv

eiTrelv.

'E7r€;^>^

'KptaTog TotovTov avTOV vjXey^ev,

vmvXov

§e ovtafjJjog, ^ta to

fivj

dacpaXwg twv d^-^Xwv KaTaToXfxav,
tvjv

Kat fxdXtaTa ev eyKXvjfkaat, Kat tov M.dpKOv TavTVjv dvYipvjKevat
vTTorptav

Kai ydp

(pvjatv,

*'

OTi Tipoatpafj.av

Kai yovvTreTciov irape- 25

" KaXet

avTOv, Kat oti

ef>.(3Xexl>ag

avTco 6 Ivjaovg vjydTrvjaev avTOV,"

^ta Ti ovv ovTcog 6 KptaTog vpog avTOV direKpivaTo Xeycov,

"

ov^etg

" ayaQog

;" eiret^vj cog dvdpcoirco TrpoavjXSe
'Iot/^ai>ca)'

^tXw, Kai

evi

twv iroXXm,

Kat '^itaaKdXcii

^/a toDto wg dvBpairog avTco "^taXeyeTai.
virovoiag
tcov

Kat yap TroXXa^/ov irpog Tag
KptveTat.

Trpoaep^/pft.evm

airo-^h^

OTav ovv

eiTrVj,

" ovhetg dyaQog" ov^ eavTOV eKpdXXm tov
ov

dyaBog
'

eivat

tovto Xeyet, diraye.
i

yap Xeyet, t/

fxe

Xeyeig
p.

e Cf.

Cat. ad S. Matth. p.

54

et seq. et Cat. in S.

Marc.

376

et seq.

XVIII.
ayaOov
;

i8.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
eifiii

135

ovk

a-yafioj-,

aAX

ov^ei$

ayaSo^, tovTeaTiv, ov^etg

avBpwTiwVf Kai avrog ^e OTav ^eyvj, ovte Toii^ avdpanovi dnoarepiov

dyadoTVjTog tovto Aeyf/,

ayamTtiToq.
fiirev, ei
fji.vj

1/)/

a\
L\io
o

Kai eiarfyayev,

\>/
**

dXXa

Trpo^ dvTi^^taaToXvjV ttjc
ei
[xr)

4t'^f'£i'" ei^ yyeo^.
o

tou Qeov
Kai ovk

^'

TlaTi^p [xov, iva [xdGrjs oti ovk e^eKaXvxpev eavTOv tco 5
/u,>/

veavKJKco, Kai OTav ^eyvj,
•Kpoc;

KaXeavjTe ^i^daKaXov
(f>v]ai,

em
Tig

tvj^
vj

y^i"

avTiS/ao-roA^v avTov tovto
("'PXV}.

tqvtcov

Ka^

jU,eT

oXiya

Kai iva

fxd6a)a-i
vjv
vj

TrpccTV]

AiTrapa

y^,

d\ka

toJv

aKavSicv to TrXvjBog tov airopov avveTTViyev.

E/

^e iteipa^iov Tipoa-

^\6ev,

eh-^Xuaev
Tioiel,

av
ei

Vjfxh

6

FivayyeXiaTVjg, loaTrep Ka\

eTn

Tm 10

oAAcov

Kai

Treipd^av irpoavjKOev, ovK av aiivjXSe

kvnov-

[A,evog €<f>

olg vjKovae.

Tovto yovv ov^eig enaOe

TcoTe

twv ^api-

aaiwv, (mep

aAA

vjypiaivov eiriaTOfi.i^ofi.evoi, ovTog ^e
avjixeiov

aTreiat KaTYi(f)V)g,

ov

[xtKpov

T&y

a>;

[/.era

Tiov^pdg
[xev

yv^ixvjg
tvji;

avTOv

vpoaeX6eh, aAA' daSeveaTepag, Kai e-ntSv^xeh
eyea6ai §6 erkp!^
TrdSei yaXeTrcordTop.

^(ovjg,

Kar- 15

ToT ArioT TiTOT BosTPflN.
vi[i.dg,

'Oo"T6 Qeov epyov ro aa6^vai

aAA'

vj[j.av

ro ^eXvjaai, 0eoy te ro toop-^aaaSat.
E^eo-T; ydp
avToTg,
ei
[xvj

Ktpiaaot 'Aaesanapeias.

etg

ditav eXoivro rwv ovruv diroXta^eTv, erepag ev^0Ki[t.etv,
*'

"

Troivjaai

20

(piXovg

eK Tov d^iKov

[f.a[t.[t.wvd,

tv

orav eKXetiraat, ^e^avTai

**

avrovg etg rdg atavtovg aKVjvag."

ToT
" earat
[t.a6vjTai,

attot.
v][Ji.7v

Tipoaendyei Se toDto
Trpog

MaTflarof to
ri

**

rt

apa
01

;"

rovro

epeT

rig,

ydp

oXcog

d<j)YiKav
;

vj

rtvoov
(f)a[uev
;

avreKTiatv

atrovai
[t.\v

irapa

^ptarov

T<

ovv 25

irpog

ravra

[xdXtara
t>?v

ravrvjg eveKa t^^ atrtag avay-

Katordrvjv
ort [xtKpd

hrotovvro

irevatv.

ag ydp ov^ev

KeKTVj^xevot

ttA^v

Kat

evreXvj, j3ovXovTat [uaSeh

rtva rpoirov aixef^erai

Seog Kai rovg oXiyoard KaraXeXonrorag tid ye t^v /SaatXeiav
rov

Seov, rovreari

^id

ro

e(f)iea6at

rvyeiv

rvjg

rav ovpavav ^o

{3aatXeiag, S<a r^g eig avrov aydnvjg. dpaporug /xev

ydp

irXov^e

aiog Kara^fypovvja ag iroXXav, irpoa^oK^aet Tag d[J.ot(5dg.
jj.iKpd KeKTVjfcevog,

ye

elra rovrocv airoarag,
;

ev iroiaig eXTriaiv

earat,

noig ovK

etet [xa6e7v
vj

eira irpog rovroig KdKeho elireh dvayKahv,

ro ydp rot ttoAAwv

oXiywv diroXiadeh taov roig

ira.Seaiv

etvj

av, 35

136

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA

XVIII.35.

KaTo. ye rov t^j- opSoTvjTog XoyoV ovkovv to ye ^kov eig vizaKOfjV

Kai TtpoOeaiv ev
[j.evoi^f 01
fxy^

lavj

ra^ei KaTaKoyKjQeHtv av Tolq itoWa KeKTfifxevovTeg'

KaT avTovg

eha

TaHg laaig TcpoBvixiaig

'^af/.evoi, Kai toov evovTCOv tvjv aTrefx/SoXvjv eKovatov VTrofxevovTeg.

Aia
"
p^fJ.a

TOVTO ^e

01

ATiodTokoi

**

ovhev tovtccv (xvvvjKav,

aX\

"^v

to 5

TOVTo KeKpvfXfJievov ait ayrwv, Kai ovk eyivcaaKov Ta keyoeTrei^Y] ovteTtce vj^eicrav

" fneva"

aKpipwg

to,

itapa twv

ayim

-npo-

(pvjToiv irpoKeKvjpvyf/.eva.

KE4>. Hr.
JJfpl TOV TVCfiXov.

10

ct:i

Tlpo(TYjX9e fxev

TvcpXog wg
e^Treihr]

Sew tS

Travra kj^/vovti, ovofxd^ei
\ov'hai(7fx.a

^e avTOv viov Aa/Si^f
Y/ae

reQpafKfxevog ev

ovk y]yvo-

ra ^ia tov

vofLov

Kai rwv TrpocpyjTuiv irepi avrov Trpovjyopev-

fxevaf ori eK yevovg vnyjpye tov
vj^v]

AafSi^ ro Kcnra odpKa' ovkovv

cog

7re7ri(7revKibg ori

Qeog
rvjg

cov

Aoyog

V7reff.eiv€

tvjv

Kara aapKa^S
7rpo<7eiTiv ccg

yevvriGiv, rrjv

aTto

ye

navayiag 7rap6evov

(py]fJ.i,

06c5 \eycov,

"

e\ev](70v

fxe, vie

A«/3/^." ori yap ovrca tiarideig
KeyoiV

7ip0(7eK0fj.i(je TY]v iKerY^piav, e7TifJ.apTvp-^aei.

avrw

'KpKrrog,

"

Yj

Tricrrig (xov cre(7Ci}Ke o"e." Bavfxdcroofxev te
eTiiTLfxcfSvrcov

avrov Kai

tyjv evcTra^Tiv

T^f OfxoXoyiag, oti rivZv
Kat
TeTtf/.Yjrat

avrS), avrog ovk aviei'

Oio

20

eiKorcog ttapa

HpKTrov rov Qeov' KeKXvjTat yap

Ttap avTov, Kat

eyyvg yevea6ai TrpocTTeraKTat.
^e
i^pcoTYjaev

41
*'

OvK

dyvoxv
aot ;"

avrov

Trdvra

eiowg,

"

ri

6eXetg

7toiYj(T(a

«AA

iva ft.d6otev 01 7tapeaTY]Koreg, Y]yovv 01 avfx-

/Sa^i^ovreg, ccg ov
iog

y^pY]fxara
E7r€/^>;

alreTv

avrov,

«AA

evepyetav 6eiKYjv, 25

7tapa Qeov.
Vf]

^e rov rYjg atTY^aecog evecpdvtae rpoTtov,

rore

rore

rvjg
ecpY]

lov^a/cov

dirtartag eXey/og

y]v

to

etpvjfLevov

7tapa 'Kptarov'
Ttg

yap

fxer e^ovaiag

TYjg avcorarco,

" ava^XeipoV
ev

yap

rSov

dyicov TtpocpY^rciov el^te
;

rt roiovrov, Y]yovv
tc5

roaavTY)
yj

XeXdXr]Kev e^ovaia
(poorog

o6ev

Kat

>pcog

Kdfxvovrt yeyovev
rvjg

(pcov^'

yap

y]v

Xoyog rov dXY]6tvov' d^raXXayetg ^e
(ptXo-^^^ptarog, Y]KoXov6€t

voaov, ov

KaTY]fji.eXi^ae
TY]v

rov eivat

yap,

(pY]aiv, avrSi,

'^o^av

dva^refJLTicov

wg Qea' yeyove ^e Kai erepoig 7rpo(paatg

XIX. 5-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
<f>yi<riv,

18T
c^coaccv

Tou ^o^oi^eiv avTOV, avas yap,
<

6

Xaog

ouvov

rf

KE^. SA.
Ilfpt

rov ZoKxaiov.

A
TO

'Apy^neXoivi^i
(f>t\dpyvpoVf

r/V o

Zaicxaio$, ew eiriTdcrei ^e iroXXy "aap

avT^S
ZaK-

Kai

t%

TrXeove^ias

6

a-KOTro^y

tovto yap Tot(
tovtoi? o

tcXwvati TO
j^arof*
e<TTtv

eTriT-^^evfJM'

dW

ov

fx.eii.evriKev

ev

yi^kjoBvj

^e

(fyeitovi

t^s Trapa tov

Xp/aToiJ*

avTO^ ydp
e<JKOTi(Tfi.e-

KaXwv eyyvg Tovg fxaKpaVj Kai
entBv^Yi<7avTog

(f)!OTi^iov

Tovg

vovg.

yap

eKetvov tov

Kvptov

lv}<xovv

6ea<ra<r8atf

i

o

Kai ^ta TovTo hrt <jvKOfj.opeav dveXBovTog, €/3Xd<7Ty]<Tev ev eavT^
(TvepfJM crcoTyiptag' ovTrep /^wv o \pi<TTOg Totg Trjg deoTvjTog o<f)BaX'
[J^oTg,

6 iravrag avQpairovg SeXcov
**

<Ta}6^vai'

TrpoTetvet t»/v yjfJiepoTVjTa

Xeycov,

ZaK^aie, aTrevaag KaTa(3i^6i" Kat Ta e^^g'
TrpoyvaxTTi^g

eytvoxTKe

yap wg

Seog to

€<TO[Ji.evov.

et^ev

dvdpcoTrov

^v^v^S

eTOtfj-OTaTa ^iavevovcrav etg ye to eXeaBat ^tovv dyi(og, Kat fJieTe-

6etKev eig ev<Te(3etav'

Kat ydp vire^e^aTO tov
Kat

'lyjcrovv yatpooVf o6ev

Kat yeyovev evSvg
vjOtKy)fj.evotg

eXerjfJiCtiv

(f^tXoirTco^^^eiag

epa<TTyig, Kat To7g

vTre^ryeTO

TeTpairXovv direp
TrpofSaTa
vifj.wv,
'*

Yj^tKy]<Tev diro^ovvat,

Kard

Tov

vofj.ov
<f>y]ai

Ta Te<Taapa
\ptaTOg

avTt

evog

eKTtaetv

KeXevovra. 20
otKca tovtco

Ato

Qeog

a-yjfj.fpov

a<OTY,pta

tw

" yeyove,

Ka6oTt Kat avTog viog eaTtv A^padfj..*^ ev6a ydp eiaPdXXyj
t$0€t oe Kat Tovg

A.ptaTogf eKet iravTcag eaTt Kat acoTyjpta.

lov-

^ouovg yaipetv

eTr)

ZaKyaica aea-caafxeva Trapa^o^cagf oti Kat avTog
'A(3padfx, oig tvjv '^td "KptaTov

eig viovg eTeXei tov
irpocfyriTav

XvTpcoatv ^id 25

dytwv eiryjyyeiXaTO Seog.

5

ToT AnoT TiTor Boztpcn.
"
airevaag KaTd^Y^6t^^ aov y^etav
Tyjv

UapaSappvvag avTOv Xeyet,
ej^cu,

fj.€ya <tov
<tov

to eXKog, fxeydfj.e fj.elvat,

Xijv e7ri^eiKvvfJ.t

^epaTreiav, ev to;

oIikq)

Se?

ov

ToaovTOv
yaipoiV
Sftrr^p/

ev

tw

e^w, o<7ov ev tcS t^j ttavoiag.

Ka\ VTrete^aTO avTQV^o
to»

erv/e yap

wv

fj^tf

irpoae^OKa.
oiiy^

^RTrayyeXXcTat Se

Ta

vjfj.ta-y]

twv VTrapyovraVf

tva

eavTW Ta Xonrd irapa-

Koraay^yjf
evt

aXX

tva TeTpairXaatova diroTtayj ToHg 7rXeoveKTvj6e7atv.
ev(f>paiveTat

TOVTOtg

Ivjaovg

Kat

(pvjat,

"

ayjfi.epov

ccoTVjpia

T

138
*'

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
o^Ku>

XIX.

12.

yiyovi Tw

tovtw." vptitrraro yap ro oXoKKvjpov rov /A€Ta^e aTrc^ ttooai To7i a^iKVjBeiat,
vo[x.i[i.ov

VQ-^a-avTOSf reTpaTrXaa-iova

voiovfxevos rrjv eKri<Tiv.

KE«I».

HE.
5

HepX Tov iTopfvdePTos Xa^ew iavra ^aviKeiav.

11

'O

(TKOvos r^^ •npoKeiiA.evrig TtapaPoX-f)?
e(f>

oXriv

wf

h

^payeai
rrjv

irapKxrS. rvis

y]ix7v yevoiJ.evfji

olKovo^uiag rov

Qeov Aoyov

^vva/xiVy Kai rov

Kar avrov
avSpcoTios

fxvarvjpiov

Ta

aT[apyy)i fJ-ey^i rekovg.

yeyove

fJiev

yap

Qeog wv

Aoyo^, Keyjpfi^ariKe ^e ^ia
evyev^i,

rovro Kai tovXos, aXX' ^v Kai

ea-riv

Kard ye

rvjv

€K^°

Ylarpog

appyjrov yevvyja-iv.

aTtoTTepdvag ^e ryjg [xera aapKO^ oikovoevova^av

fxiai ro [/.var^^piov, eif ry]v
ri^Ke ^o^av, Kai

avrco

Kara ^vatv
[/.aKpdv'

avaire^poi-

olov aTto^e^yjii.YiKev

eU

%'^po-'^

yo^pa yap

erepa vapa
Xeiav.

rvpt yyjv

ovpavog.

Ai/e/3>7

&e

Xa^eh

eavrS) (3aaiaveta-i

iiwg §e

rm

oXwv paa-iXevcov

[/.eTa

rov Tlarpog

iS

npog avroVf
T/oS
vov,

\y)xlJO[i.evoi

^aatXetav
Ylaryjp.

;

^yjkovori

evavQpfaitYiaavri

toj

Kat rovro ^t^aatv

Ava(j)otTy}aag

yap

etg

ovpa-

KeKdBtKev ev ^e^ta r^$ fJieyaXoavvvjs ev vxpi^Xoig, ro Xotirov
(l(t)(

eK^eyo^xevos

ov

reSSoa-tv

01

eyQpot

avrov

viro

rovg •notag

avrov.

14

Ttveg te eiatv
^aiotj Tiept

ot

•noXhai avrov

ot

[t.iaovvTeg

avrov

;

01

love[i.e

wv

(f)y]atv,

"

ort Kat eupdKaai Kai

[j.e[i.tayjKacn
eir

Kat

"

Kai rov Ylarepa
^to

[J.ov^^

Kat ovk y]6eXy]aav avrov

avrovg j3aatt»?v

Xevaat.
avroVf

Kai eXeyov iipoi YliXdrov dpvov[j.evot
eyo^j.ev

^aatXeiav

"

ovK

^aatXea
**

ei

[t.v]

Kaiaapa"

Katrot ZaKyapiov 25
i^ov

Tou

7ipo(f>v]Tov

^omrog,

X^^-^p^

a^o^^pa, Qvyarep 2/wv, oti
Ojao/wf

"

^aatXevg aov epyerat aot ^tKatog Kat aco^av'"
^)]

Kai

'Haaiov, " i^ov

^aaiXevg ttKatog ^aaiXevaei, Kat dpyovreg

"

[j.era

Kptaewg dp^ovatv" ert ^e Kat rov Trpo^v]TOV

Aa^t^

itepi

avTov rov 'Kpiarov Xeyovrog'

" eyw

&e

Kareard6v]v fiaaiXevs^o

XIX.

22.

AOTKAN ETArrEAlOT.

139

KE*. Ef.
Ufpi t5>v XafiovTap ras
fipas.

13

Uotovi Se '^ovkovg KaXktrag rovroif
Tovs T€\tiov$
fxva-TayciyyeTv
Tvjv

^teveifxe
vj

Ta^

^e/ca

[xvas

;

e|/v, 01$

av

irpeTry

nat

aTipea

Tpo(f>yjf TOi/f

ei^orag opBZg, Kat irpog iraaav aperrjv eavrovi re S
vtto

Kat erepovi aTrevQvvovrag. ovrot yap vovQerovvrag rovg

%e/pa

Xaovg Trpoa^epyd^ovTat rotg

^oBeTcxtj

Kat rov roTg ayiotg Trpeirovra

Kephaivovat KX^pov. vTToarpe\pavTog yap ix.era ro

Ka^eh

r\v

(3aa-i-'

ketav rov avOpamov rov evyevovg, ^JyXov Se ori Xp/cTTcv tou Qeov
^f/MV'
ev

^evrepa avrov Ttapovaia rev^ovrat Kai eTraivav, Kat raTg lo

avaraTa} Tt[MaTg evrpvcp^^aua-t.

^eKaTrXaatdaavreg yap Kat Trav^ta

ravXaatdaavreg
^eKa TToXeav
yj

ra
Trevre

'^oBevra

rov Kep^avat

voXXovg,

eirdvco

yev^aovrat, rovreartv dp^ovat TrdXtv, ovy^

m

^p^av

irpo

rovrov [i-ovm,

dXXa yap
veviKvjiJi.evoig'

Kat erepm ert ttoAAcSv.
o

ATtfMta ^e earat roTg okvw

ydp

rot

KaraKpvrpag f$

aov^^apio} rvjv [xvav, virev^veKrat ryj rota^e ^iKy].

Tavr-tp §e t^v Trapa^oXvjv

eiirev,

eiret'^))

eXeyev,

^yiKev ^

(3aatXeia rov Oeoy, Kat Beaadfxevot avrov eig 'lepovaaXy][x dvtovra
w-^Ovjaav

^ta rovro dvtevat,

tva

^v)

dpyriv

SaJ

rri

PaatXeia rov

Qeov. ravra

/a€V ovv eKeTvot evofntl^oVf ov
rriv irpoa^^oKiav.
yj^et

[uifjv

eXeyov, aXX' ev raig 20
t>?v

havoiatg avrwv eKvXtov

'O Se TrXdaag

Kap-

dtav Kai rovg Xoyovg eTrtard[jLevog,

ravryjv avrcov t*/v irpoa-

toKtaVj Kat ttopBovrat ro a<f>dX[Mt, tta Trapa^oXyji'

evKaracppovyjTos

yap Traaa

yvy.voTy]g Xoyov.

32
Ti

JCi'

yo-p
ry}v

avaryjpog

et[At,

(priai,

Sept^cov oirov ovk eairetpa,
yj

ota 25

[xy]

^oOeiadv aot ydptv, rovro ydp eartv
etg

[uva, '^etcoKag roTg

rpaTre^tratg, rovreart, "npovOyjKag
^0Kt[xd^etv

airoXavatv roTg

ev

et^oai

Ta Trapa
e[LOv

aov.

'E-yw

yap

eXQoDv eirpa^a

aV

rovreartv,

dTrffcyiaa ro

avv

tokoo'

twv

[i.ev

yap tttaaKdXwv eart ro

KaraaTreipeiv roTg
roTg dKpoo)[i.evotg

aKpo<i)[/.evotg

rov eTratpeXrj Kat aarriptov Xoyov,

30

Se ov

(Jlovov

ra

KaTa(3Xy]6evra ryjpetv dfJieiarra,

dXXa Kat vaaav

dperyjv irpoaepydaaaBat.

Atonep

/xev oKVfipog

T %

140
oiK€ry](
afJLiiVQ}

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
yvfxvos

XIX.
01

39.

Koi

rov SoflevTo?

ecrrai

yapia-ixaTo^f

Sc Trjv

Pa^i^ovTeg

o^ov, ev TrpoaQ^K-j^ Beiiov '^apKXii.aTm yev^crovTai*
01

€Tt ^e Koi
^lov^^aToi

Twv almiav ayaQoov aTioXavawaiv'
avToiig

^e

fxyj

fieAoyo-avTff

eir

^aaiXevaai tov
avTov,
(^fiai.

avSpcoTTOv

tov evyevvj, KaTe-

a^pdyrjaav
Tiveg e^

efJ.7rpoa6ev
eirt

Ka< yap

eiradov Kai vvv tovto ^
ev te tvj

avTwv

t^

tccv 'lepoao\vft.wv

aXwaet'
•rjfxaVy

tevTepa

vappovaia \ptaTov tov a\7j6ivov Seov
hf a(f)ay^

itavTeg ovtqi (aairep

t^ aTeAeyT^TO) KoXaaei

^oO-^aovTat.
tqov

r- ToiV yap KaTaKovaaai TtpoQvfxag
Ta7g Xeya Kat To7g e| eSvm

avTOV

Xoym

Tor? fia$y}-

TreTttaTevKoaty Kat KaTeyovaiv ev

r^io

htavoia Tov Tvjg tt^aaKaXiag BefxeXmy Kai etoOy} Kai eTieptaaevQrj

Ta
^e

TVjg Getag yv^fxrjg
ft)ifj

KaTa t^v toD IIvey/AaTOf

'^(cpeav.

lovoatm
a(f)yjpe6i^'

KaTaayovTm
tj

tov avTov koyov^ Kat

etoKovv ej^e/v

TOVTO Se eaTtv

KaTa

rov MaoiJaeag vofxov Xarpetaf Kat

Ta vpo-

^TiKa

Kai QeoTTvevaTa ypdft.fi.aTaf to, TtpoayopevovTa Trjv wapoy- 15
"^coTiljpog

aiav Tov Kvptov Kat Qeov Kat
lapavjX ^talSovjTov ovofxa.

\piaT0Vf Kai avTO ro tov

Km.
29

sz.

Hfpi Tov TraXov.

Kat kyiv^TO

m

yjyyuTev

m

^rj(f>6ayT) koI

BrfOaviav 20

7rpo9 To opos To KaXovfjL€vov 'EAatajv.

OpirENOTS. 'H

jU,€V

BvjQavia epfXYjveveTat oiKog viiaKoyjgf

rj

Se Bi^6(pay^ atayovegf lepaTtKog Tig

m Toitog'

Kat yap aiayoveg
oirov

Totg lepevai
vzraKoyjf

eS/SovTO,

wg

ev

tc5

vofi(p

dvayeypa-nTat'

ovv

kui tepog TOitog, eKei ditoaTeXXet

Kvpiog rovg Attoctto- 25
itaiTtoTe

Xovg XvaovTag
*'

"

irwXov

^e^^ef/.evoVf ev

00

ov^^eig

dvBpwTtm
17

eKd6taev" avti tov ov^eitOTe av6paitog Xoy-.^og eiteKd^taeVf
yj

MftjyVewf Xoyog^
&e ^Aflev
TtaXov.

'Hcraiov, ov^e
etTte

dXXov Ttvog

im

TtpocprjTm.

ot€

'KptaTog,

Tolg fj.a^rftatgf iva diteX^ovTeg Xvacoat tov
**

EiTte &e awTorf,

edv Ttg

vfj.dg epcoTdf Tt

Xvere tov arwAov, 30

"

epeiT(f OTi 6

Kvptog avTov

'/jpeiav

ej^e^."
vito

itoXXot

yap

yjaav ot
lafLei/

Kvptot Tov ovov itpo

Tov Kvptev6y)vai

tov SwT^pof*

Se

XIX.
OTi
6

35-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOY.
yevoiJ.€voif ov
t;j",

141

Tov Kvpiov aTTO^ OTav
Tyj

^vvaTat TioWovg Kvpiov$

e)(€i)>'

KaKia.

tovXivti

woAAcSv •traBwv SovXof e<XTiv 6

avQpaTrog.

35

Ktpiaaot 'Aaesanapeias.
aTreaTaXfJiivccv irapa
"K.piuTov'

AyeTai
VTrrjpeTovai

o

TrwAof, ^vo

jM,aS>jTcSv

yap

itpoq tovto

avTO 5

Suo TayfJMTa, irpocf^^Tai ^e outoz kui ATroaToAo/, ^i

av (xayyivevtva S/

ovTai e/f TTiaTiv to.

eQvrj.

AyeTat
eBva)v

Totvvv airo Tivog
(f)peva'

Ka[ji.v]g,
vofJ.(a

ayTou
fj.eva}Vf

Trjv

aypoiKOV twv

^et^y]

ovk

ev

TeQpafi,-

l^vjadvTCOV

^e /aaAAov aT^jW.eActJf

Kat dpTtag Kat dyptwq^
vtto

irXvjv fj.eTe(JT'q

htt to vifxepov'
fj.r}v

yeyove yap

'KpiaTw

tc5

iidvTa 10

^^ddKOVTt. eTepoq ye
e(f)yj

t»v dyicov YivayyeXi(TT(sv Kat war&af
OfJ.ov

^aia

(potviKCcv

avaTetvovTaq TipoTpeyetv avTov, Kat
tvjv

TOtg
veov

ftM6yjTa7$

avvTiSevat

^o^oKoytav, tva Kat

'^t

avTav tov
Kaov.

Kat e^ eBvm, loaTtep ev TtivaKt yeypafj.fj.evov,

t ^(i}fj.€V

Teypa15

•mat yap, " Kat

Xaog

6 KTt^ofxevog alveaei tov Kvptov.*'

ToT AnoT TiTOT. 'O
ataaTtKVj Se
v)

Kvptoi T/f, dvoXeXvfj.evov to

ovofJM, e^ov-

iipoayfyoptay PaaiXevcov yjBeXe <f>atvea6at
yjv
yj

tw

TrXyjQei*

taoKe(f>aXoi ^e

6ea'

/xeTaaTeAAcTa/

ttoAAoJv, tva

Ka6ta6evTa

t^ccatv 01 iroAAo/*
**

irpoeXa^e to irXyi6og Kat /Soa

"

ev\oyyjf*.evog 6

ep^xpfj.evog ev ovofJMTt

Kvptovy* " ^o^a
ev^oKia.'^

ev vxptaTotg

QeS, Kai eat 20

" 7^f

elpyjvyf, ev dv6poyiroti

Ata

t;

;

dv6p(tmot

yap

fj.eT

A-y^eActJv'
viraKoyiv.

yap

avo)

^aaiXevg Kare^yj
yivoff.evov.

/taTCt),

Kai

'ireTroiyjKe

fxtav

'Ey}fj.e7ov

to

ov

yap

airo

tov opovq twv EAa<wv
eir'

ets 'lepovaaXyifj. eiatovTt

tw

Kvpi(p xpeta Ttg

ovov Ka6e^ea6ai,
fre^oif
eirt

Gi eif Tvjv
fTTO^^ov

\ov^aiav Kat TaXtXaiav airaaav
eTTi

^t-^et

dXXa
tov

to 25

«yTOV

Tov iraXov 6eoope7a6atf ^vjXoT to
Yjyefj.ova

veov

Xaov Ka6e^ea6ai tov ovpdvtov
aaXyjfj..

Kat fSaatXea Tvji '\tpov~
ircoAof,

To yap
fj.yj

veov

Tijf

KX-^aecog

eS^Acwaev

aAAa Kat

TO

irdXat

Ka6dpov twv vvv
viroTVTrooaiv

KaXovfi.ev(i3v.

dKpt^earara te 6
e^ei^ev,

M.aT6aiog
ov
fLovov

tvjv

rwv

irpayf/.dTCOv

yeyevy]fj.evyjv

30

Tov iraXov

fJ.vyjfJ.ovev(i)v,

dXXa

Kat Toyf ovov, oti Kat 6
irore
yj

lapayjX varepov dKoXov^yjaet tc5

veoj

Aaw, Ka6d

fJ^rjryjp

tS
kol
Se

vwXw'

OTi

yap

eirt tco

vwXca eKa6ea6yj

'^yjXovatv 01

Xotirot, 01

fxovov tou traXov ft.vy][xovevovTe(

dyofxevov vpof rov

lyjaovv.

142
M.aT6a7og
eiTroiv

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Kai
ttjv ovov

XIX.

42.

a^^Qeiaav Kai eirdvw

avTa KaSeaSevTa

Tov KvpioVf ov O^^nov
fJiViTpog

avvoopi^a yevof/.ev>]v tov re ttcoXov Kat t^s
;

Xeyei, Trw?
vj

ydp

«AX

eTroixevriv

t^v

ovov.

AeSe^evoj Se

TraXog Kai

ovog Tovg 7rpo<J^e^e[j.evovg ToTg

dvBpicnmig 'npdyfJM.aiv

f^e/^e Xaovg, Kai fx^ dveTOvg ovTag elg to ^e^aaQai t^v eni/3aaiv ^

TQv Kvpiov, dviefxevovg ^e ^ia to 6e7ov eTriTayfJia tov Kvpiov
^evog ditOKdoXvaai
^vvvjOevTog, Kai el (SovXovTai

jOtoy-

KCcXveiv Ttveg,
'*
;

wg

avTot ^eaTTOTat,
*'

dXX

edv Ttg

vfi,Tv

eiiirii

t/

(pyjaiv

epe^Te oti

6

Kvptog avTov '^eiav

ej^e;."

6eia %\ KXy^atg ev tovtw ^eSiy-

XccTat.

10
§e
eirt

42
tva

K^dKpvae

tvjv

'lepovaaXTjfx 6 Kvptog, <f)tXdv9pa}irog
OTt

cev,

^ia TovTQV

fj.d6(0fj.ev

XeXvTrrjTat irept avT^i^g,

e'i7rep

oXoog

y^ri Tt TOiovTO

etirelv

irept

tou irdvTdiv eireKetva ©eoy.
OTt

WSig yap
fxy]

-aXXoog

eyvcofi.ev

av

rjfJ.eTg

KaKovg ovTag

rjXeet,

el

^ta

TrpayfxaTog avQpwTrtvov, tovto KaTeaTrjaev evepyeg, oQev Kat fj.eTa 15

TptaKovTa irevTe
avaPoXrjv ToaovToig

eTr}

TTjg

dvaXi^xpeoog
<ptXav6p(airov

rj

aXcoatg avT^g

yeyovev,
ev

Troiovfj.evov

tov

©eou T^g
Trpog

Ttfj.copiag

eTeat,

Kat fj,aKpo6vfj.ovvTog

to

emaTperpat Tovg

ireTrXavrifj.evovg

tta Trjg twv dyiav ^AiroaToXcov tt^^aaKaXiag, eig Trjv

Tojf TrtaTeag aXr}6tvr]v

evtyvwatv, Kai diroXXayrpat Tr^g fj,eXXovar]g 20
ot

opy^g epyea^ai
reg
fj.ev

eiri

Tovg viovg T^g diret^etag' tto Kat
ot

Treta6ev'*

eppvadrjaav,

te diret^-^aavTeg dirwXovTO,

to yap,

el

"

eyvcog

Kat av

Ta

irpog eiprjvriv^^

tovto eaTtv, oti ra
ei

'/^rjatfj.a
rj

Kai avayKoia irpog ro etpr]vevaat ©eo5
irtaTtg, Kat
r]

eireyviag

aTtvd eaTtv,

etg

Kvptov

VTraKor],

Kat to aireyea6at twv TVTrwvi^
7reptefj.evov,

Kat

Tr]g ev

vofJ.ca

XaTpeiag, ovk av TotavTat ae 6Xi4ietg

dXX

eKpv(3r]f (pr^atv, diro o^6aXfxccv

aov

eKovatcog

yap ovk

r]6eXr]-

aev eltevat, r^yovv avvtevai Tocf 6eomievaTovg ypa(f>ag Tag ^r]Xovaag TO
Trept efj.ov fj.vaTi^ptov.

Katpbv te Xeyet

T^g hrtaKoirr^g aov,
avTr]v, Kai

r]v

avTog emf^aaTO, 30
'titdJ^^ag

KaTeX6wv

eirtaKe^pdfj.evog

6e7a

'bi^dyfj.aTa

ev

avT^, Kai irXetaTag 6avfj.aTovpyiag epyaadfj.evog.

XX.

2.

AOTKAN ETArrEAlOT.

143

KE^. SH.
Tlfpi tS>v iirepaTrjo-avTav

tov Kvptov apxifpiav,

2

IflANNOT TOT XpTSOSTOMOT.
TOVTO
(f>y](7iv,

'lcTeoV ^f, OTl

KUt

IwaVVrn

aAA* eKem^
olJev

ju,ev

ev apyyj tov EivayyeXiov, ovTOf Se

vpos Tw reAe/,

eiKOi ^evTCpov yeyev^cr6ai Kai

KaTa

^iacf)opovf 5
yj[J.7v ;

Katpovf. KaKiT fxh Keyova-iv, t/ aYi[xe7ov eTri^eiKvveig

ev-

Tav6a l3oaaif KaiToiye

e7z-<T//xijflevTef

'^ia

to

^^vj

6av{xd^ea6at

avTOV Trapa Traai. tovto ^e KaTyjyopia fxei^uv
aira^ Kai §/f to avTO tovto TroiyjaavTO^, efxevov

lov^aioov, oti
eirt

Kai

t^

KaTiriKeia,
/xaflen/ ti;v

Kai avTt6eov avTOv eivat ekeyov' ^eov KavTev6ev avTOv
Ttpoi Tov

10

YlaTepa

TtfJLyjv

Kat

tyjv oiKetav

\ayyv.

Kat yap e6av[ka-

Tovpyyjae, Kat eapav to7s Xoyoig toc epya (7Vft.^aivovTa,
oi/TCUf hrei^ovTOy

dXk

ovSe

aAX' yjyavdKToW

^toirep

Kai avTOi tov

Hcaiav

avTo7g

eTttTef/^t^ei KaTyjyopov

XeyaVf

"

oIko^ fxov oiKOi iipoaevyyji

"

KKyj^^^aeTat."

15

ToT ArioT Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias.
tta Mcavaewj',
fJLovovg

*0

vo/ao?

(f>y]aiv

eKeXevae tuv lepav airTea^at aTrov^aafJidTav
6eta}

Toyf ef aifxaTOi Aevi'' avTOt ^taTdTTOvat Ta ev tco
avToif ^e^oTat to fxvaTaywye7v, Kat
ata'
yj

vo^ou,

tZv lepZv irept^okuv e^ov<f)vXy]i,

av

Se

7r»f
ev

e^

eTepa^

vTrdpyvv

yeyovaq yap eg 20
;

loy^a, Taf

yjfJL^v

eKvefxyi^eiaag e^apird^etg Ttfxd^
ei

" T/?

aoi

"

^e^coAce

T^
co

e^ovatav Tavryjv ;" cxAA'
tocj

Ta$ 6eoTrvevaTovg

yj^ets

ypa<f)ag,

davveTe ^aptaa7e, Kat

twv dyiwv
7rpo(f>-^TOv

irpotpyjTZv cf^ccva^,

€[xv^a6y](

av Ae-yovTOf tov fxaKapiov
*'

Aa^i^,

Trpog

tov

TcSv oAcov crcuT^^a Xj3;aT0v,
**

Hfxoae Kvptos, kou ov fxeTafxeky]- 25
aiwva KaTa
ty]v
yj

6yiaeTat,
^y]

av tepevg
ovv,

eig tov

Td^tv MeAp^/cre^e/f."

<f>pd^e

t/j €k tcSv ypafxfxaTeav

^aptaaioov keXetTovpevXoyy]ae tc Kat
ypd(f>et

yy]Ke

to)

0ew ^aTa t^v

tcc^/v MeAj^/o-eSe/c, oi

OeOeKdTcoKe tov ^APpadfx'
*'

ag Se

7rdvao(f>o<;

IlayAof,

ywpig Trday]g dvTtXoytag to eAaTTov
oviicoyv
17

vtto

tow KpeiTTOvog evXoye^-^o

" rai,"

pi^a &e ^ dirapyy] T^g yeveaeag twv e^ lapay]\,
A^pouifx
viro tyjs

TOVTeaTtv,
avvy]g

TTpoTrdTcop

tov MeAj^/cre^eAC
yj

lepof^

i^v\oyy]Tat,

Tvirog le ^v

MeAj^iO^e^eAC Kat

KaT avTOV

144

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
"EiWTVjpos

XX.
r]iJi.iov

9.

Upcoavwi Tov itavrm

Xp/CTov, 0$ yeyovev
rSt

a/jj^^eireTci'

pev^ Kai 'ATrocTToXoi, npoaaycov
(TTevKOTag elg
ayiaaixov.
avrov,
"^ia

0€oo Kai YlaTpi tov$
vofxov

t^s

virep

Xarpiiag TeXti(hv

eig

T; roivvv aayaXKeig, ^apKraTe, twv lepav
oia Talg

7r€pi/3o\ci)v

eKTrefXTrofJ.evwv,

Kara

vofxov Svaiaig

tjv ')(jpy}aiix,ay

KaXovvrog 5

€ig

ryjv

hteKeiia tvttcov

^(oyjv,

Kai elg akffiy\ tiKaKaaiv r^g oia

TTia-reag, ^YiXovort

r^g

elg "Kptarov, Kai TiapaTtSevrog
o^ov,

r^g evayye-*
rov

XiKi^S
vofxov

TtoXneiag t^v
TVjv

eyKaXe^ig, etire
[xy]

[xot, tc3

vofxoOerrj

Xvatv, Kai
Travrog

ori

raig t^tatg yjKoXovQyjaev evrokaigf

aWa
e^

vofxov

eiieKetva
^fxiv

Qeov

;

ov

yap rovg

vofxovg

of^ 1 o

eavTf fxakXov, aAX'
OTrep

opiadfxevog fxeSiari^ai

Kara Katpovg,
etg

av eXoiro ra ^tarerayfxeva, Kat avacpepav

(BeXrtova

;

Hv
**

ovv

Katpog rov TravaaaBai toc ev rinrotg, avo^eiyPyjvai ^e ra

Kpetrrova,

Ka/ yovv

f<py]

irov

Qeog ^ia

(fxov^g

'Haaiov,
rvjg

'*

Kat

d(f)avia6^aerai vofxtfxa Xaov fxov" Yjpyyiaav

yap

veag evro- 15

Xyjg dva^e^etyfLevi^g, ^v ^i

eavrov KeXaKyjKev yjfxh

Tiog.

KE4>. se.
Ilept

Tov dfiTTeXavos.

9

Tor ArioT loANNor ror XprsosroMor.
PoK^g ravryjg irokXa aivirrerat' rov Qeov
avrovg
yeyevyjfxevyiv
tyiv

Atto

t^j "napaetg

irpovotav, t>Jv

20

dvwOev, ro e^ dpyyjg avrcov (povtKOv, ro fxyj^ev
y^Kovrcov

irapaketcpQyjvat

rwv

eig

eTrtfxeketav, ro

Kai rwv

irpocpyirciov
Tref/.xpat,

acpayevrwv,

fxyf

dvoXetcpO^vai avroiig,

dXXa

Kat tov viov

Kai ryjg iraXaiag Kai veag eva Kat rov avrov eivat Qeov, ro fxeydka

avrov Tov Odvarov KaropOaaetv, ro

Ty]v ea-)(drvjv

dtKy]v

rov arav- 25

pov Kai Tov rtfxyffxarog avrov virofxevetv, rav
Tcov

eOvcov

t^v KXyjaiv,

\ov^ai(ov

r^v eKTrrcoatV

rvjv

^e diroty^ixiav, r^v irokXy^v avrov

fxaKpoQvfxiav

<f)y]aiv.
'

Tor
Ty]v
eirt

Arior KrpiAAor 'Aaeeanapeias.
ye roHg
vtoig

OAiyv

evpyjaei

rtg

lapay]\ laropiav ev rovrotg, ag ev (Spay^eiso

avvevy]veyft.evy]v.
** **

'AfxireXcov

ydp

'lapay]X,

(f>yjatv

6

xpaXfxui^og'
6

kfxirekov e^ Aiyvirrov fxery]pag," Kat

rd

e^yjg.

Kat

'Haafag
tovtov

afxiteXm eyev^Qy},"

(f>y]at,

**

tc5 yjyairyifxevo}."

Eari

roivvv

XX.
ra

i6.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
ovto^
aTre^-^ixrja-e

145

<f)VT€va-a^ Qeo^'

yjiovovs iKavovgy Kalroi irhfipoH

Jravra, a'Jio\i[Ji.7raveTai &e
;

twv ovrav ov^evog.
e/ ^ei

Ilwf ovv

aTre^v)eir/

fxyja-e

/xeTa to ava\r](f)6^vai cv
Afa^
«ye

vvpog KaTa^Se^rjKa^
efjicpavi^

to

opoi TO Siva,

t»?v

appyjTOv

fxopcfyrjv

^e^^i^XuKev avTolq'

aW

0)$-

«aTa

tov tvhov tSov avBpwTtivoov TtpayfxaTm eoiKe v(ag S
yeyevrjf/ievoVf ttX^v

aTrotyilxia
'X<api0Vf

fxaKpa to

opaTai

Tre<ppovTiKOt)i

tov

Kat e/f vovv ej^wv afTo.

Ov^etg yap yeyove &/a fxeaov

Katpoff Kaff ov ovK awecTeAXovTo Trapa tov
/fa/ ^iKaioi

©eou

trpoKJyfjTai

tc

vovQeTovvTeif

ot

^e yeyovaatv a7rei6eT$f Kai a.Ttft.aa-aV'Kevovs'

Tes Tovg aTteaTaXfxevovi
ej^ovTa?
etTretv
**

e^airea-TeiXav

TOVTeaTiv, ov^ev lo

vnep avTtav ayaBov
/J^/x-a

tco TTeirofxcpoTt ©et»,

Kat (prjaiv

'lepefxia^f

i^ov to

tou Ki/j9/ou eyev^Brj avToHq eis ovet^iafxoVf
*^

"
13
**

ov

fLVjv

PovXvjQcoatv avTov

aKOvaatP

ToT AriOT

IflANNOT TOT XPTSOSTOMOT.

T/

eCTT^

TO

"

iVo-f

hnpaifriaovTat ;" oy)^ w^ ayvoovvTOif

a\>^

QeXovTog ^et^ai to 15
eiret

afxapTyifxa fxeya
e/dcof,

Kat aiiokoyiag irdayjg
eirefxypef

eaTepyjfi.evoVf

avTog
ro
eitet

OT/

avaipyjaovaiv

Xeyet oe
^ei

evTpairiiaovrai

yeveaGat

0(f)e7\ov

aTrayyeXXwVf ort
**

avrovg evTpair^vat^
dyvoS)v,

Kat dXXar/pv
iva
fuiff

(pyjaiVf

eav dpa

aKOvaaaiv" ov^e €Ke7
y]

dXX

Xeywat riveg twv
rijg

dyvccfxovcoVf ort

Trpoyvooatg

avrov yeyo- 20

vev dvayKaariKy}

TrapaKOVjg,
Ttept

S/a ToyTO ovrco ayyjfxari^ei rag

Xe^eig.

E/ yap Kot

rovg tovXovg dyvwfxoveg eyevovrOf rov
ep(/3^v.

vtov ro

d^KOfxa ai^eaBvjvai

Kat

fxev

AovKag

(pyjaiVf ort

avrog

dtre^pvp/aTOf ori

TraQeh e%ei

rovrovgf KaKeivot

eiirav,

"

fxvj

"
16

yevotrOf* Kai t»;v fxaprvptav eiryfyayev,
xp^(f)OV

^e MaTfiarof ori avrot 25

T^v

e^yjveyKav.
rviv

MeToc te ro dKovaai avrovg
^ta rovro
eliroVf ** fLrj

toD dfxireXmog Trapa(3o}^v,
avvtevreg

yevoirOf^

eiretVlf]

rm

alviyfxdrav

ro /3d$ogf airoaetovrat ro iraBeh, he^otKoreg ro eaofxevov. eart

AXX
Kai

ovk
rrjv^o

rovro

evavrtoXoyiag'

Kai yap

dfxtporepa yeyove,
irdXiv

iln^(f)Ov

avTot

e^yjvey Kav KaB^
'*

eavroov, Kai

aiaOofxevoi

rav

eipyffxevaVf

etnav

fxyf

yevotro" Kairot Kai rov

irpo^f^yjTyjv

eireretyt-

aev avroTg, vetOoov auTovf ort irdvrwg earat touto,

dXX

ofxwg ouS'

d oMT^ Ood.

u

146
ovrag ra
a-)(€7v
edvyj

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
aacpooi
aTreKaKvrl/cVf wa^Te
fxvj^efxiav

XX.

20.

avToTf Trapa-

Xa0v)v,

dkX

rpi^aTO uitm,
KaXei,

"

Swo-ez tov dfATteXava aXXois.*'
Toiig

17

A160V kavTOv
lov^^aicov,
Kai,

Kai

oiKo^^ofxovg

^i^aaKaXovs twv
tov roTyov Kai
;

Je^e^iiyX (pvjaiv,

"

01 oiKo^^OfJiovvTeg

"

d\€i(f>ovT€$

dvapTVTWi"

Ilwf ^e dne^^oKifuaaav

0)

Aeyovref, S

ovTog ovK ea-Tiv €K tov Qeov, ovTog iiXavS. Tovg oyXovg^ Kai oaa

ToiavTa' tvo Se ^vjaiv d^Trcckeiag IvTavBa twv lovBa/wv, fuiav
Ty]v dito

fiev,

Tov 7rpoaKO\pai Kai aKav^aXiaQvjvaif tovto yap

ctt;

rov

X160V rovTov, erepav ^e t>jv «Tro ryjg dXcoaeoog avrav Kai rvjg avfn.<J)opag
**

Kai 'itavoKe^plag, ^v

aa(f)cog

e^^Acixrev

eiTrav,

"

kiKfx^aei 10

avTovV

Aia

rovrcov Kat r^v

dvdaraaiv i^vi^aro
eiri

rvjv

eavrov.

Ktpiaaot. 'EKav^a\ia6evT€g yap
aavreg avr^, rwv

Kpiarw

Kai Trpoairrai-

lov^^atcov 01 ^^ft,ot avverptlSifjaav.
cfycov^g

Ov yap

Yj6eXov

aKovaat r^g 'Haaiov

Keyovavig,

*'

K.vptov avrov dyidaare,
•jrpoaKOfJ.fJ.art

"
**

Kat avTog earai

aot

<f)oPog,

Kai ovy wg \i6ov
7rTcofji.aTe."

15

avvavTYjaeae avrWf ofSe irerpag

ToT
^avdrov

ATTOT.

¥i^eKav6v]

irdXiv

etg

dyaXtvovg opyag ro
eirt

rcov

^aptaaicov epyaarvjptov, Kat diroKreTvat jSovkevovrat rov
y€vofji.evov

Xvaet

dv6pco7rov,
(fio(3og.

dXXa
Oii

"^ieKoipev

avrcov

ro

dvoaiov

ey/eipyjfj.a

Xaov

yap r^g

€ig
v}

Seov evae^etag ^v2o
^ta yicoijaecog evroXv}
Trportfj.coat oe

avrotg Xoyog, ov^e yeyovev avrotg yakivog

XeyovaUy

*'

d6mv

Kat ^iKatov ovk diroKrevetg'"
ai^ovg rov dv^pcovrtvov <f>oPov.

fJMk-

Xov Tvjg eig Qeov

ToT
eaofxevov

ATTOT.
e^co

KaiTOt

ircbg

ov fxaXXov eyp^v fX€fJ.a6'^K0Tag ro

(f)epea6at rov KaKOv,

Kat Ttfxvjaat

rvj

Triaret

tov 25

Kaiovvra rov dae^vj, Kat dfj.vv)atKdKco ydpirt

ttaac)iC,ovTa

rovg raig

dfJ.apTiaig eviayvjfxevovg ; dXX^ ov^ev rcov rotovrcov vmXeXoytafJ.evotf

avKO(f>avTtag rvjg

Kar avrov avXXeyovatv a^opfxag.

K.m.

o.
oq
"^cor^pt

Tltpi t5>v eyicaOerav 8ia rov ktjvctov.

20

^g
aXX
vjfj.ag
i^v

av6pcoTrcp

Trpoatevrai
evvoeiVj

KOtvSa

rco

"jrdvTcov

^ptarVy
rvj

>

dfxetvov
6

ort
'Atto

yeyove

fxev rvjg

ev

ofj.otcoa€t

irpog

Qeog wv

Aoyog.

M

ye

virep

Xoyov 6eoav]fX€tag

5

XX.

37-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
HOeke

147

Kcu ajToSe/fefWf r^f OeoTrpeTrovi ovk avdpcovos wv [xovov ^ieQeiKvvro,

aXXot Kou Qeof.

/u,€y

yap

6

rZv oXwv 6eo? avdpamivvjs
Ejre/^»;

tvvaoTeiag eXevSepov eivat tov
TreTiarYjKaai
vofjt.ov^f

^lcxpa-^X.

te rovf

Oeiov^

yeyovaaiv \mo

y/ipoi- tcov ri^viKa^e

KeKparyj-

Korav, Kai '^eafxovs e7re6r]Kav avroTf.
tovvai

e^^^rovv roivvv,

<f>vja-i,

Ttapa-^
ori

avrov
Ka)

rvj

apyri

rov ^efxovos.

Tlpoae^^OKfjaav

yap

vdvryj re

itdvrug aKovffovrat

Xeyovrogy ovk

e^ecrt

dovvat Eirt;

(popovs Kai<7api' «AA'

"

e^jr/Se/^are /jio/," ^^jo"/,
'

"

^vjvdpiovJ'^

tetypevroq de, itaXiv eipero^

rtvoi eyei eiKova Kai eTrtypa^pyjV

oi

te Kaia-apogf <paa)v, Kai ri Trpoq

ravra \ptarof

**
;

diro^ore

raio
fjt.ev

" Kataapog Kaiaapi,
yap ^eafxovg
Xaypvrei

Koi ra rov Qeov tco 0€o5," 'xpyifx.drav
vTre^evyiM.voig, oi rvjv
7}[j.cov

hrtppiirrovat ro7i
^yjreT ^c
rirap'

Kar avrwv
ryjv

dpyyjv,

Kat dydirvjVf Kat
fxev rvjv

ef

epyav dyaBav evKoafxiav.
avroVf Kat rovro
evrjveyfJi.evotf
**

Ovkovv re6avft.aKa

diroXoytav
1

eTr)

Travrog rov \aov, oi ^e Kat rovrwv eig k^Si^v
Trpoa-tjyov

UtXdrw

rov

li^aovv

(pdaKovreg,

"

rovrov

ivpafxev ^taarpe(f>ovra rov

\aov Kat KooXvovra <popovg ^i^ovai
r^v
diroXoyiav
dir^Xdov

**

KaiaaptJ'^

Kat

ofxag

Qavfmaavreg

Karriayyfj.fj.evot.

OpirENOTS.

Kyevero

ev

dpyyj dvBpaiTrog,

wg

ev ryj

Teveaet 20

yeypairrat, Kar eiKova 0eov, varepov ^e irapa t^v afTov irapaKoyjv

aveka^e Kat

yotKyjv'
eflvoJv,

wavrep yap ro
irotav

vofi.tafj.a

etKOva eyet rov
Koafj.oKpdro-

/SaatXevQvrog twv

ovrcog ^
yjv

ra epya rov

pos

ryjfv

etKova avrov (popet,

•jrapatveT 6 "Eiooryip

dTro^i^ovat

Kat

airortOeaBat Kai (popeiv t^v e^ dpyyjg yevofi-evyjv etKova Ka6
(oatv
rS)

6[j.ot-

25

0€o5.

AKoXovQag rovrotg Kat

6

YlavXog

(pyjatv,

"

cog

"

e<f>opeaafj.ev

t^v eiKova rov yoiKov, ovra
eirovpavtovJ^
KCti

(popea<ofj.ev

Kat

ryjv

" etKova rov

Tovto

ovv '^yjXoT
Oeci5."

"

airo^ore

ra Kataa-

"

pos Kataaptf

ra rov 0€ou tw

KE$. OA.
ITcpt tS)V 'SabdtyvKolav.

30

zy

Ktpiaaot Aaehanapeias. Ylpoaiaat "^o^tovKaht
yjfjJav

toj wavTOJv

Yidiryjpt

'Kpiarw, og eari ^onj Kai dvdaraatgf kou dvatpeh
d o2to? Cod.

u %

^

148
ireipmTai
tvjv

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
avacTTaaiv.

XX. 37.
avToT^ ^pi<TTog,
yafJii-

'T/3pi(XTai Se ovt€$ Kat airicTTot ithaTl^ufjiev ^e airep
e(f)yj

Tovcri Ti (xeaTOV a[Ji.aQia$.
**

O/

jtAev

<yap vioi,

'

^^c;, " tov aiavos tovtov yafxovai kou

govTaif

Kai Ta

e^rjg.

TOT

ATTOT.

Oi

VlOt

TOV

VVfJI.(f)aVOij

T0VTe(7TtV, 01

TOV

KO^TfJit-

Kov Kai €v<Tco[JLaTOV Kai

<f)tXo<ro(f>tag

yifxovTa ^ta^civTes Piov, TeKvoot

yoviag eveKa

yafj.ovcrt

Kat yafxi^ovTat'

ye

(/.tjv

tv)v

evKXea kou

ayaGov
T^f

fj.eaTrjv

KaTopBaaavTeg ^«^v,

eha

KaTa^tQ}6evTe$ iv^eTv

evTtfxov avaaTaaecog, avco irov navTcag eaovTat

T^g

ev rco^e tc5

K0(rfi.ca ^oi^g.
'i^O'/]

Aia^tcoaovTat yap

cog

av aytotg
viot

irpeTT'/]

Kat eyyvg lo
tvjv

yeyovaat %eov' t(7ayyeXot yap eia) Kat
TeXovvTeg XaTpetav.

Seov,

ayiotg

TtpeTTOvcrav

Ylapyjyaye te avToTg Kat Mwi/Vea

ev et^OTa (ja(pwg twv veKpSiv t^v avd(XTa(7tv.

'Ev yap
o

Trj jSaToo,

^y

<f)v]atVf el(TKeKOfx.tKe

XeyovTa SeoV " eya
'IaAfa)/3'"

elfxt

Seog
ei

'A/Spaaju.

"

Kai 'laaaK Kat 6 @eos

t/vwv

Se Qeog,

ju.^

^vjaov- 15

Tat KaT eKetvovg;

dXX

eoTt ^«VTcyv Seog.

Ovkovv

TrdvTYj tc Kat

irdvTcog dva^toiaovxaty Trjg iravaQeveaTdTTjg ^e^tag dirocf^epovaifjg etg

TOVTO aTravTag Tovg eK T^g y^g.
Qyj^/ Twv ovK ovTcav KaOaTra^ d(pavta6evTCov, Kat ovk€ti dva^rjaofj.evcov

eivat

(f^rjai

Qeov tov ©eov, ov yap
Q.aTrep

rjf/i^^v,

aW

€ifj.t

20

Twv

ovTCov Kat

^mxcov.

yap

6 'A^aft., ei

Kat

'e^r]

t^

"^fJi-^p^ j]

'€(f)ayev diro

tov ^vAou, dire6av€
'e^oov

Trj

airo^fidaety ovtco

Kat ovTOt,

et

Kat €T€6v^KeaaVf
(f)y]aiv

TJj

viroayeaet Trjg dvaaxdaecog.
;

Ucog ovv

akXayovy "
'iaov,

tva Kat veKpcov Kat ^covjcov Kvptevarj

aXX

ovK

'eaxt

TovTO

eK veKpcov yap

€VTav6a

(prjat tc5v

Kat avTcov ^r]-^^

aea6at

fi.€XXovTcov.

OpirENHS
TrXavmxat
irept
fj.ov

Se

<f)r]atv,

AvaytvcoaKovTeg Ttveg Ta
<f>ep€ etTreTv

7rpo(f)r]TtKa

tov vovv T^g ypa(f)yjg,

€K tov
ev

llaatov,

"
"

'eKXeKTot
*'

ov TeKvoiroi-^aovatv etg

KaTapav^ Kat

tw AevKotXtag 30

Tepovofk.i(o

ev

TaTg evXoyiatg evXoyrjfxeva Ta eKyova
ev
Tr]

Tr]g

crou," vTroXaf>.(3dvovTeg
fj.y]

avaaTdaet twv

veKpcov

eaea^at

TavTa,

voovvTeg Tag irvevfi.aTtKag evXoytag.
Yov^atcov

Ata

tovto, acofJ.a-

TtKag eK^eyofj.evotg ToTg Ik twv
YicaTTjp,

YiO^^ovKaiotg, eXeyev

" TrXavaa6e

fxr]

et^OTeg Tag

ypa^pdgT

XXI.

I.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.

149

KE^. OB.
Hfpi
TTJs

rov Kvpiov

firepuyrTjcrfas irpog Toiis 9api(raiovs.

46

ToT Arior Titot Bostpcn.
yoe/av evova^t r^f TOiavTVji

Tayra

roTs fxa6y]Ta7i ekeye,
EiireiO'/)

Trapaiveaecog.

yap OiOaaKafxrj

Xot r^i oiKovfJi€vy]i irpoeyetpi^ovTO, ^i^da-Kei avTovg^

ixifJLfTaOai

^

Toyf Tra^a 'lou^a/o/f ^i^^a^TKakovg.

KKeTvoi

yap KaTeaBiovci rag

oiKiag Tww y^p^fi ^i^daKovTeg vvjaTeveiv Kat ^eiKVvovrei yaa-Tpt[jioipyiav,

ov

'jrpoTaTdfxevot
<f>yj<Tt,

yripuiv,

dkXa Ta tovtuv
Kpifxa," ort

ava\i(7K0VTeg'
§>?

"

ovTOi

X-^ovTat,

irepta-aoTepov

^/^a«7/fa-

^.tKOv eyovTeg ayvjfJM, itpoayfoyot

Tvyydvovatv

etq KaKiav.

10

KE*. or.
tlfpi TTjs

Ta

/3'

XeTTTa.

I
**

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias.

E0>?

irov 6 SwTiyp,

" fxaKaptot

ol

eXe-^fxoveg, OTt avTot eXeyjSvjaovTatj'^

TovTOvg enovrevet irpoacpepov-

Tug ra

^Sopa
fJLev

avrwv

etg

ro ya^o(f>v\dKtov,

aXX

wg eK vXovrov woAAov 15

voXXa

yjaav

eiKog

ra

irap

eKaarov

Kapiio<f>opovfxeva'

o\tya

Se 'sdXtv Kat T^f rwv TrpoaKOfxi^ovraiv dva^ia %etpog' elra fxer
eKetvovg yvvatov Ttrtayeta
fjioXtg
yjfJiepa
'hetirj]

Kar tayyifxevov

ei(Te6vi ®

c| epdvov

Kat

aiiv

i^poort
^*

(XvXXeyov

evrekeardTyjv

Kat

airoyjiSiaav

ttarpocf^^v

eira Svo •npo^ryjyev o{3oXovg, (oairep airoAO"»- 20
irpdyfxarog'
yi

fxevyj

rov /Stov.

O irapa^o^ov

rov irap erepov ekeov

^yjTovaa ^ti^veKag, avryj ^avei^et
d-nocf^aivovaa rvjv itToyyyiv'
il^cfxo are<f>avovTat

Sew,

KapTTOcpopov avrSi Kat avryjv

vtKa rotyapovv rovg akkovg, Kat

hKata

Ttapa Oeaj.
%evtyjpa yjipa rovg irXovatovg
evtKVjae,

T/vo? &>eKev

yj

rovg 2^

ra ^apa avrZv
4^(f>!p

eig ro

ya^o(f>v\dKtov irpoa^pepovrag, Kat
;

^tKattx

are^pavovrat 'irapa rov Qeov

^ta ro rovg fxev €K 'TrXovrov

TToWov oXiya
•JToXXa ^v
peTv,

jrpoaKOfxi^etv Kat dvd^ta r^g eavrav yetpog, et Kat

eiKog

avrovg wg irXovaiovg

Trpoa<f>epetv

kcu

Kap-Tro^f^o-

T^v Se

OTrep e^

epdvov fxoXtg Kat ^piorog evTcXef
' hta
Tfatprfyi

aw^aye, ^o

* €«< €6(t

Cod.

Cod.

150

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA

XXI.

5.

TovT€(TTi Ovo o^okov<,f TovTO TipotTayayfi'
[X€vr}

Kai yap coaTrep aTroKTto-

Tov Piov oKov eavT^^, fJLeyaXo^pv^xcos

navTa

Trpodrjjaye.

KE*. OA.
Hepi
c
TTjs

orvvreXeias.

EiTre^eiKvvov Tiveg tc3

X.pK7TS Tas
ko(TIJlov'

ev

tw vaw

fjieyakovpyias 5

Kai Tov Tuv avaG7j[j.aTC0v

wrjdyjaav yap^ oti
Opovov
€')(cov

Bavfxdaet cyvv
tov ovpavov.
^e oti ck

avToTi

Ta

opcoixeva, KaiToi
[j.€V

0eof av Kai
avTcav

'O ^e

d(f)iv]ai

tov

irepi

koyoVf

Trpofxefj^-^vvKe

/3d6pcov

irecTehai

KaTa

Kaipovg, KaTaKOfj.i^ovaYif

eU

tovto avTO
tvjv

T^S

'Poofxaicov

(TTpaTeiag, Kai airacxav tvjv 'lepovcraXyjfx

t^j-io

KvpioKTOViag ^iKag e^aiTOvav]^ tov lapav]\, fieTo, ydpTot tov tov
"EcoTy^pos

CTavpov TavTa
Tcov
opcofievcov

avve(3v]

TiaBeh avTovg'
avjdvjaav

01

^e

ov

awi"
"ffept

aTavTo
TVfi

tvjv

^vvafj.iVf

fj.aXXov

Tovg

aveTeXetag tov alcovos Koyovg

e^v(f>aivetv

avTOv.

^'tpovTO

S»;

ovv ivoTe

TovTa eaovTat, Kat
yiptaTog
;

Tt to avjfj.ehv OTav fj.e\Xv] ytveaQat. 15

T/

ovv

e7reTa< tco

aKonw
TV]g

tcov

irpoaayovTCov tv^v Trev-

atv, Koi

(f>v]at ff-ev

Tecog tov$ iiept

dXcoaecog tcov 'lepoaoXvfj.cav

Xoyovg,
atcovog.
v]fJ.cov

^taTpavoi
Ylpiv

^e

Tovg
e^

itepi

t^$ avvTeXetag

tov

napovTog

yap

tv]v

ovpavov yeveaQat KdBo^ov tov TtdvTCov
Tiveg ava(f)atvovTat xpev^o-^^pt-

"ZcoT^pog

HptaTOVf

Trpo^pofJiot

20

aTOt

Kat xpevdo7Tpo(f>^Tai, to avTov TtpoacoTiov

eavToTg TreptirXdT'

TOVT€f,

dXXd

fM] dKoKovBYjav]Te,

<f>v]atv,
**

avTOtg.
^e dKovavjTe" wg

ToT
<f)rjat
fi.v]

ArioT TiTOT BosTPCN.
irpoeXa^ov

Otav

ydp

YcoavjTntog,

•noXefJ.toi,

avTapavTog tov €$vovg, kou
Kai
fj.eTpicog

'^i'^ovTog

Tovg avvv]6etg
dveaecog

(f>opovg

Pcofj.aiotg,

aeo(ppo- 25

vtaOevTeg,

Kat

TVXovTeg,

TidXiv

evecoTept^ov,

kou ndXtv

eyiyveTO iroXefxog, Kat ovteiiOTe vjavyjav y]avaaavTo' TeXevTaiov
Oeaadfj.evot

Vcofiaht ty]v tovtcov aiiovotav, KaTeXvaav t^v iroXiv.
ev

ToT

ATTOT. Teypair-rat

Talg Tlpd^eatv, OTt

fj.eTd tv]v

dvd-

aTaatv eyeveTO

Xtfj.og fJ.eyoi.g e-at

KXavVtov Kaiaapog, kcu a€ta[j.ot3°

iroXXot eyevoVTO.

9

Ktpiaaot 'Aaesanapeias.
evapyv]

Aidcoai

avjfj.e7a

aacfjvj

Te

kcu
e^fyf].

T^f crvvTeAe/af tov

Koafj.ov'

7rdXe[J.oi

ydp eaovTat,

XXI.

9-

AOTKAN EYArrEAIOT.
Kai

151

Kai aKara(na(Tiaiy Kai ra el^f .
•JTavTa

€Tepo$ ^yjcriv Eva-yyeA/o-r^f,
6

ra acjrpa

'Trca-eTraii

elXfxP-^crerai
ri$^(7i Kat

ovpavos

c5f

/3il3\iov

Kat ra f|^?.
[jLcov

Ata

fjieaov ^e

vept rrji rwv 'lepoaoXv^tyj-

aXuxyetag.

^^Kepaae yap rov koyov rovrov KaKeivcp to/V
(pi^a^tv

y^fji.a(Tt.
**

Ylpo yap rovrcov Trdvrcov

"

e7ril3a\ov(Ti

e(f>

vfxasS

Tocf

yeipas avrcov, Kat ^/w^ovo"/" Kai ra
Kaipcov ^Xo) ^aev
'Pccfxaiccv
•aap'
rj

e^y}?'

vpo yap

raiv rvjg

cwreXeiag
avryjv rvjs
(TeiaQyj

rav lov^aiwv

X(>}pa, KaraQpa[ji.ovai^s

(rrparetag,

efJiTieTrpvjarat

Se
ryjg

o

«ewf, Kare-

Ta
oy

avroTg ^aaiXetay ireTravrat
iip^v

Kara

vofxov

Xarpeiag

tvvafjt.tg'

^e

TayTa

(xvfx^yivai

e^ici}-)(6y]aav

itap lO
eit

ayTwv

oi

fxaKoipiot

fxaB-^rat,
eirt

'^eafj.carat

yeyovacrt,

yiy^Qyjcjav

ap^^ovras,
etg

e7reft.(f>6yicrav

I3aatkeag' aire^xrdXy] yovv 6 TlavXog
ttAi^v

P«jU.>jv

Ttpog

Kaicrapa'

yeyovev avroig etg fxaprvptov,
eirevyiveyfj.eva'

rovreartv eig fj.aprvpiov ^o^av ra

'ttapeyyva Se ort

" "
**

fj)fi

Ttpofj.eXerare fj.eXKovreg aitoXoyelcy^at, X-^xpe^rQe
yj

yap

Trap efxov 15

<ro<f)tav

yXZa^rav,'^ ov ^vv^crovrat avrtaryjvat yjavretTre7v,aTiavreg

01 avrtKetfj.evot vfj.h^^ aiioKetpcov ^e

t^?

avOpciyTrtvyjg

fji.tKpo\pv')(^tag

rag

d(f)opfxag, '7rapci^oByj(TecrGat,

(f>y](Tiv,

avrovg

viro

d^eX(f>m Kat
crajfl^-

<f)i\ci)v

Kat rav eK yevovg, avrov'
6pt^

7rAr?v

ort irdvryj

re Kat irdvrcag
vfAccv

(Tovrai irap
(fyi/jai'

yap eK r^g Ke<f)a\^g
irotcov,

ovk azoXeirat, 20
t^yjre, (f^yjai,

<Ta(f)earepav ^e t>;v Ttpoayopevatv

" OTav,

"
«

KVKXovfxevyp viro arparoiretcav ryjv lepovaakyjfj.'
riyyiKev
yj

rore yvcHre ort

ep-^fxcoatg

avr^g" Ktra

fxe&taryjat irdktv rovg Xoyovg

evt rov r^g avvreXeiag Katpov.

ToT
Kat
e(f)

ATTOT. "A yap ecapdKare hr
vfxTv

efxot ytvofxeva, '7rpoa^oK'^aare

25

eaeaBat.
;

TiTor.

Ylotov Se fxaprvptov

ort ro

t^tov

vpjt^aro KaropOcofxa

rov KyjpCyfxarog' orav ydp rtg ^tafxaprvpyjrat ro (3eXrtov, Kat ro
Kaff eavTOv
irotyiayi

irappyjataadfxevog, aTro^-^ayjrai vfxh etg fxap-

rvptov, ori ryjv evae^etav aTryjyyetXare.


Trept ryjg

Ta
ecog

Se cTejja toutwv
ot

"Trept

re Toy lepov Kat
TrapeXQaat,^*

avvreXetag,
eig

"

de Xoyot ov

fxrf

irpoeypd^py]

ro Kara

"MarQaiov, Kat eKei

^"^ret.

Ktpiaaot Aaesanapeias.
aecog

Ap^^^pfxevrig

yap

ooairep

r^g Kpi"
etgSS

evaXdrreaOat, avvoyyj

rig earat

tetvlq,

Kat

a^Troxpv^tg

152
Bavarov.
K€a-€i

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
To yap
tcov

XXI.

29.

hrepypiKivm
ov
AeAvjfioTCijf,

a(f)op7)Tov

^eTyfxa iroXXoii ap-

'npog

oXeSpov'

aXX wg 0€O?
to

Kat Kvpios cv

^o^vj OeoTtpeTrei,

Ka) itavTa
ot

jOteTao-Tija-e; npo^;

a(Ji.€ivov.

'Ava/StuaovTai yap

veKpot

Kat aiiotvcxovTai ti]v (f)6opaVf to
ttjv a<p6ap<7taVy
Qo^ifjs

€K yy\q TovTO Koi evaXcoTov a^fxa, evtvaovTai ^ Oe
l^pta-Tov ve/xovTOf avTvjVf Kai
a-vfjL[ji.op(f)ov$

5

tov awiJ.aTOS t^s

avTOv Tovf

€/f

avTOv TttaTeva^avTag airo^a/voyTOC.

E/Vwv ^e

Tyjg

avK^i

tvjv 7rapaj3oXy]v, eiir\yayev oti

eyyvg eaTtv

2917 (3aaiXeia tou OeotJ,

oiiep

MaT^aro^

^""l^^h

" yivaa-KeTe oti
ovira} Tipog

eyyvg eCTiv
TO

eirt

6vpatg.
fiKei

lo de TotovTO otbaaKet, OTt

10

eo^aTov TeAof
tcAo?

Ta irpayixaTa

tovtccv

ytvofJLevcov,
vj

aXA'
avKrj

o^evei irpog to
Toi/f
hv]

^^17, KaQaTrep ent twv Kapitav^ o^evet

Kka^ovg,
7]

a^naXwofJt.evv}

Kat eK<f>vovaa Ta (f>vXXa.

Ovtco yap

Kai

Tov Kvptov TTapovata, KaTapyovaa iraaav apyviv Kat e^ovtjj

ciav, vapaaKevai^et
Feveaj',
Tpoir^.
*'
(f^rjo-tv

/SaatXeia tov Seov.

15

ov Tovf tot€ dvSpcoTrovg,
ovtcos

aXXa

Tovg

ofJiOtovg

tw

Ol^e yap kou

KaXeTv yeveav, ug to

"

avTV] yevea

^r}TovvT(ov Tov Kvpiov."

TovTO Kai

Tvjv Tcov aTotyeiccv

avvTeXeiav ^^v} Tvpoayopevet afux
fi.ov

€» To5 Xiyeiv, oti d^vvaTOv Tovg

Xoyovg

itapeXQeh, KatTot Kai 20

T«v

a^TOiyetcov 'napepypfj.evctiv.
irepi

E/TTWV
OTi

T^f avvTeXeiag, koi OTt

nd.VTCog vj^et
fxyj

vj

rjfJt.epa,

Kat

TOVTa yev^aeTat, koi ovk ey/capel
e<f>i^,

yeveaOat aTtep

etTte,
01

itpoaBeig
**

"

itpoaey^Te eavTolq

fi.y]

itoTe ^apyfi^aiv

vff.ctiv

0(f)6aXfJi.ot,*'

oyp^ 01 a-cofj.aTtKot,

dXX
fj.e6yj

01

T^f ^tavotag. Meptfxva yap 25
fx.ev

f3tcoTiKav
a(f)opi^et

Kai
^e Kat

KpatitdXyi
tvjv

Kat

e^opt^ei

ttjv

avveaiv'

TttaTtv, efJ.j3dXXet

Se elg Xyj6yjv tSov avfuf>efji.vyjfj.Yig

povTCov.

Ato

"TtoXXyjg

dypvitviaq

^(jpeia,

Te Kat evXa^eiag
vyj-

Kai a^vveaeag, iva npoaevypfj.evoi tta TtavTog, Tag Ttpeitovaa^;
(TTetag •npoa^fjepcafj.ev

tw 0ew.
tepco
;

30
itavTCog
ev

Li oe

y]v

aitep

eotbaaKev ev tco
fj.eT

ttov

Ta imep

^y

vofJLiKVjv

XaTpetav
t*;v

fj;,e6iaTcav

e^ova-iag

Ta

TVTtco Key^jpy^afxco-

^y]fj.eva Ttpog

dXy]6etav.

Aionep Kai

6avfj.d^cov

Xaog, oti ev

e^ovaia

y]v

Xoyog avTov,
S

yj^ta-Ta tovtov y]KpoaTo.
evSvVijTa*

E/f to

o^of he

Cod.

5

XXII.
TcSv

7.

AOYKAN ETAITEAIOY.
rjj

153

€\ouuv y]vKi^€TO Tovf ev
rjfxTv

vo\€t Oopv^ovg vapaiTovfMvoff

tva Kat ev tovto) tvttos

yevyjTai,
yfyy^b^i '^^'
6
^"^^

llep/
ap^^f^iepeTg

Tyji

€opTr)g

Tav

agvfxcov oti

e^-^ovv
eig

oi

aveXeiv avTOV,

Kat

OTt

eia^XGev

Saravaf

tov

lov^av, Kai OTt
€Trt

crvv€(f)iovyj(T€

tov •napo^ovvat avTOv, KOt OTt
01

e^iyre/

5

TovTo €VKatpiav, eag

"

Kat

^u^eKa AitoctoXoi

cxiiv

ayrco,"

vpoeypa^fyy] etg to

KaTa MaT^arov,

KE$. OE.
Ilfpi

Tov Ild<rxa.
toivvv

7
€K

TiTOT BosTpaN. ^iayj\$€
Tftjv

"EaTavag €ig avTOv, ovTa ovk 10

tp

aW

€K Tov apt6[xov, dpt6fj.ov dveTrX^^pov, ovk diroaToXtKOv

d^taixa €K€KTy}TO.

'HA^e
6 Tyjg

Se ^ yjfxcpa tcov d^vfnov,

^i

€^€t

6v€(x6at

TO Hda^xaf <pdaKa
(3aatg. Clairep
€ig

hpTvjg Katpog wvojaa^eTO* ^i^XoT ^e ^td6

yap r^g AlyvnTiav ^ovXeiag
Tyjg

'lapayiX dTryjk1

AaTTCTO
fjieayjg

t^v

eirayyeXtag ep^ofxevog y^v, ^ta 6aXdaay]g
ttoS/,

I3a^i^a)v

d^poyja

oyTco

Kat

y]ft.ag

^eT Ka6d7rep t»;v

fiaAaTTav ^iaTrepaiova6at veavtKag tov eiKaTov tov •napovTog ^iov
ireptaTraaft.ov' '^ta^aivoft.ev

ye
etg

fx.ev

€k (f)tXoaapKiag etg eyKpoTetav,
T^yv

cf ayvwatag

Tojf

irdXat

6eoyv(oaiav

TrdXat

aA>j5^,

€K

6avdTov etg d(f>6apaiav.

Ep^o^aev Totvvv Ttff.S)aav evt Tovg rvirovg 20

T^v aXy]6€tav.

eX^ovayjg

yap

<f>y]at,

T^g

yjfnepag,

Ka6

^v

e^e^

6vea6at to Tldaya, ^vo Ttvag dTroXey^yjv tcov dytav 'A^TroaToXoov,
vfaav ^e

WeTpog Kat

lcodvv^g, Trenof/.^pev ev

t^

iroXet,

einm

ai/Totg

Ta yeypafx.fk.eva' KatTOt
fji.€fj.y]vvK€

Tt tyftroTe ov tov dv6pomov
;

evapyxg /caTO25

To7g dveaTaXfi.evotg

Ov ydp

ecpyj

irpog tov ^e^va tv^^ov,

aAAa

ay]fj.e7ov

OeoaKev

dv6p(iyirov

dirXSog
;

K€pdf*.a)

v^arog 7re<poplov^^atotg
fj.y]

TtafLevov.
aypfj.evog

T/
yjv

ovv irpog tovto

<f)afj.€v

ijJ^
'

To7g

vnofi.d6r]

Trpo^OTyjg irapo^iaetv avTov.

Iva rotvw

Tov

av6pi}-7rov,

Kai ^paficbv dirayyeiXy] To7g f).ia6(aaafj.€voig, tidcoai
T^yv ft.a6y]Ta7g evvotav eyetv, ft.taivfj.7v,^^

ay]fj.e7ov.

Et/ yap virerrXaTTeTO

^o

<f)oviav u)^ivav.
*'

"

wravT-^aet

ydp

^'?o-'>

"

dv6pwTrog KepdfAtov

v^^aTog /3a(7Ta^cyv."
^yjXiiv'

^

Td-)(a irov kou fj.vaTtKov Tt Kai dvayKOLiov

ota rovTov

€v6a ydp av elaeX^v] ro v^wp, tyjXov Se ort to tou

X

154

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA

XXII.
Ylavxog yap

14.

ayioy fSaTrTKXfJiaTo^, (kci KaTakvei HpKTTog.

vjfj^ag

aTraXXaTTei pvTrou, Kai vaov

v]fJi.oi$

ayiov yevea-Qai ©eov, Kai T^f

Bfiag avTOv (ftvaecos lioivmovg, tia ^/.fToyrjg tov

Ayiov

YlvevfJiaTog'

ovK av

tf.

a[j.apTOi

Tig TaXrfiovg, Kai

avayKoiov elvat

keym

tvjv

TravTog dyiov ^v^^t/V.
vlg
ev TcS vypei

KavyaaQa yap, fpV^h
eToifndaaai
^e to

^ a^e\(f)og

Tairei-S

avrov.

YLdaya

To7g ixaQyiTaig

14 avveiaTiaTO

li.piaTogf dve^iKaKoig too irpo^oTV} (f>daKoov,
fj.e6

"

€Tn6vfj.ia
(f)vjaiv

" e7reSv[xaaa tovto tq Ylday^a (payeh
6

vfj.S)v."

Ti

^r)

apa

EwT^p

;

ovKovv ag
fxaSvjT-^g'

tjSt;

irpoetTTOv,
fxv]

Kaipov e^-^Tei t^? Tipo^oaiag 6
t^j-

ipiXdpyvpog
<f)ovovaiv

iva ^e

irpo

toD dyiov Ylda^^^a Totg 10
Ec(?T>?p,
vj

avTOV Trapa^x, ov
co

'^iafJ.eft.YjVVKev

tov oIkov

yj

Tov avOpcoTioVf Tiap

to
fxvj

Yidaya
OeXvjaai
'^

TTeTTXvjpooKev.

Anotibovg TOiya-

povv TV]v aiTiav tov

aa(f>ag

enreiv tov •nap

w KaTecf>ayeh

Xvaev,

'*

e7n6vff.ia,^^ (f>vjaiv,

e7re6vff.vjaa

tovto to
edefxvjv

Tldaya

"

ft.e& vfX(ov" ofkotov waei Xeyoi,

naaav

airov^^vjv, oirccg
fxvj

av 15

layvaa Ka6eh
VTTOfxetvct)

tvjv

tov Ttpoka^ovTog dvoatOTVjTa, tva
TTkvjv ov
fiL^

Trpoapov
e(og

TQ Ttd^og.
ev

(f)dy!t)

TO

Tldaya

tovto,

ov

7tXvjpo}6ri

t^ PaatXeta tov Qeov.
Trjv

K6og he avT^ f3aatXetav
tov dytov

ovpavav

ovofxdi^etv

ev

TttaTei
Trjv

^tKatwatVy tvjv ^ta

f3avTtau.aTog

KX^atv, Kat

tov dyiov ^aiiTtafxaTog fxe6e^tv, 20
tyiv

Kat Tvjg ev iivevfxaTt XaTpetag
(prjatv

tvvafxtv
'M.coaecog

ovkovv ovk
trjXovoTi

oxpofi.aty

TotovTov Yldaya,
TrXrjpxSy]

tow
ev

tta
tyj

'^rjXovft.evov

TVTiiKag, etag ov

l3aatXeta Toy Seov' TOVTeaTtv,
rj

dva^ety6evTog tov Katpov,
vt^eTai'
irXvjpovTai

Ka&

ov

fSaatXeia tcov ovpavSov

efx(f>a-

yap

ev

rjfi.h

Totg Trjv vnep vofLov Ttfnooat ^td- 25

Paaiv rJacrj^a to

aXv]6tvQv'

Kat

ovk e^ dyeXrjg dfxvog dytd^ei

Tovg ev ^ptaTw' avTog Ve fxdXXov dytcag lepovpyovfxevog ^id Trjg
fxvaTiKr}g evXoytag, Ka6
rjv

evXoyovfxeda Kai
e^ ovpavov

^coo7rotovfxe6a.

Ve-

yove ydp vjfxh dpTog ^wv
To5

KaTa^dg, Kat

^(arjv tt^^ovg

Koafxw.

30
KavTCvflev ^^Aov, OTt ovk
fxadrjTag avTOv eyetV
^e
riv
rj

Tox Xptsostomot.
Eycb §€
oifxai,

avToo oiKia.

fx^^e

Toi/g

ydp

aiiTOV
;

eKei •napeKdXeaav eX6eiv.
navTcov OetKvvg
fJ-iyjpt Trjg

Ttvog

ev(Ka to

Yldaya heXet

"^id

eayaTrjg rjfxepag, oti ovk eaTtv evavTiog
Tipog dyvioTa TrefXTrei dv6pa)'jrov
;

vo|aou.

Kat t/ ^^Ta

AetKvvg3S

XXII.

i6.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
fjivi

155
^tdvoiav

Kavrevdiv oti rjdvvaro
"TTeiaai,

iraGeTv.

'O yap
ti

tyjv

tovtov
(v
toT^;

aore avTov^ vTro^e^aaBai^
ei

ovk av elpydaaTO
iiaOeTv
;

(TTavpoxx^iv avTOVf

ye e(3ovkeTo

/x.*?

Kit

enei^y^ yjyvoeiy

Kai
"**

aif]fJieTov

avToT^ ^i^aaiv, oiov
Tiva

eiri

tov Sai/A

o 'tpo<priTrig Xeyei'

evprjaeig

dvaPaivovTa Kai

aoKov eyovTa,^^ Kai

evTavBa, 5

Kepafxicv (SaoTTd^ovTa'

7rpoaTi$^ai ^e

" {xeTa

Ta;v

f/.aGYjTa)v
fxv]

ixov"
vofxt'

fxeTa TO dpKovaav yeveadai

t>jv iiapaaKevvjVf el

Kat eKeivov

aai KpvvTeaOai avTOV.
^a$tov
ciTi
;

Tlug Se

to Tlda^^a
(payetv,

YjaOtov, irapavoft.aig

ov

yap dvaKetfxevovg

^ei"

Ti

ovv eaTiv efnreiv

;

fxeTa TO (payeh aveKeivTo kofnov eaTicofievoi.

to

15
**

E/Vwv
fxeS

OTi

**

eTttBvfLia

e7re6vft.vjaa

tovto

to

Wdaya

(payeTv

vfiav

TTpo

tov

fxe

iraBeHv^^ earjfxave

^ia tovtov, oti ovk
eiri6vff.iag

aKwv Ttapayeyovev

em

to TrdBog,

aWa

fxeTa TroAX^f

oocTe Traflen/ v^o tov Koafxov'
^atcov,

ovk eaBiei oe avTO fxeTa twv lovfxov'j>v,

aAAa

aeToc twv fKaSi^T^v avTov

eiiett-^Tiep

eKeivoi 15

dvd^ioi v]aav tovtov

ha
ft-rj

tvjv

eTrifXovov dTtiaTiav.
ea>$"

Ylepi tov eiiretv
ovai

avTOV OTi
eKeivx
Oi

ovKeTi ov

(payco e? avTov,

tx avOpwTrx

ov TrapaOtOOTat,

Kat oti (piXoveiKia eyeveTO ev avTotg

TO Tti

at/TaJv ^OKei eivai f«.et^'j}v eooi *' ^tdKovo^;,^^ Trpoeypdcpyj.

loANNor TOT Xptsostomot.
TOVTeaTi irapa^ovvat
Kaff
'0

E<f TO

eTitBvfLta

eTreQvfxvjaay

20

vfxTv to.

Katva irpdyfxaTaf Kat Yldaya ^oyva;

/xeAAco TrvevfxaTiKovg iroteh.

\6

Ktpiaaot Aaesanapeias.
EvayyeKiov
**
**

'Ev t^ eU to KaTo. MaTfiarov
fxvj

ovTca

KeiTaif

'*

ov

tt/iw

dirdpTi

Ik

tovtov tov
irico

yevrjfxaTog irjg dfxnekov ecog
fxeff vfxSov

T^f

vffxepai eKeivri;,

otov avTO

25

Katvov ev

t^ 0aat\eia tov UaTpoi fxov^
eirtaKoirog
'*

Ylpog TavTa airoKpiveTat '^evrjpog
AeovTtov Ttpea^vTepov ypdcpcov ovtw.
**

AvTtoyetag

Ttpog

ToiJto ^/ttA^v t>jv dirotoatv

ey^ei

Kat

tvjv e^vjyrjatv.

O ^ev yap dytmaTog Tr]g
eKeivvjv

Kwv(7TavT/voy-

** 'iroXecog
'*

eTttaKOTtog

\'jodvvr]g

Katvv]v

itoaiv

tov

iroTvjptov

30

(f>vjaiv, vjv

fxera

tv]v

eK veKpoiy dvdaTaatv

eiriev

fxeta tojv fxa9r]T(ov

**

aiiTov, TOv vaov toD awfxaTog toD

dvaaTavTog

7rtaTovfi.evcg, Kat

to

*'

T^g (ptXo^o^iag dvoatov e^oaTpaKi^cov ^o^dpiov.
BeoTreaiog YXeTpog ev TaTg Yipd^eat

'laToprjTat
Ttpog

yap

"
**

twv ATroiTToAajv

Kopv^-

Xtov etirav,

**

oiTiveg avve(f)dyofxev Kat avve^niofxev

avTM fxeTa to 35

X a

156
**

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
/AevToi
«ye

XXII,

27.

ava<TT^vai avrov Ik veAf^wv."
ev

QeoXoyog Tpi^yopiog

"

TW

eis TO

Ylaaya

Xoyca

(f)vjai'

kuivov TTOTYjpiov ^oaiv eivai

T>jv

ev T>j fj.eXXovcrvj
voyjfxaTCOv

Kai irpoahoKWfx.evy] iSaaiXeia twv ovpava>v twv
TjfxTv

Oeiccv

e7ri^yyeXy.evm

aTroKoiXvrpiv'
:j

ore XveTai fiev
irpocroiTrov

Ta eaoTtTpa Kai ra
TrpoawTTOv 6ea,

cdviyfkaTa^ (pavepovTai ^e
cf>^aiv

Trpog $

KaBa

6e7oi

AnoaToXof.

SeTHPOT EK TOT nPOS 'IoTAIANON STNTArMATOS KE*AAAiOT.
fLvaTiKoa

Eva yap apTov
^e/TTVco t^j-

evavGpwTiyjaag tov

Seov Aoyog

cv

tw

lepovpyia^; tov

fxeyaKov fxvaTi^piov, TrpaTOi

avTog

a'7rap')(0ft.evo$

Kai to7^ ATroaTokoi^ tovto Trapa^ovSf Aa/3wvio
els ovofua tov
f/.ov

vjvXoyyjae, Kai

^eScy/cev

i^iov

SavaTov Kai

t^«"

ava-

aTaaeooi, eiTrwv, ^^tovto
**

eaTi to aoifxa to virep vfxwv

'^i^ofxevov

eig a(f>eaiv

df/.apTim"

Kai eaQiofnev Kai dTra$e$ Kai aOdvaTOV,
rjf/.ag TYjg

Kai acpBapaiag TrXvjpeg, Kai dvairifXTrXa Kat

avTVjg evXoytag

dOavaaiag,

(uairep

Tivog

Tvjg

fxeXXovarfg

vjfxtv

eyyiyveaOai 15

Betag yaptTog Kai '^vvdft.ewg T^g dvaaTdaeag,

ToT Xptsostomot. TavTa
6v)Tag eXeyev, tva
ft.v}

TrdXtv Kat avaKTafnevog Tovg fia-

vofxtataaiv

aa6eveiag eivat tq Trpayfxa, Kat

Tov Trpo^OTVjv hop6ovfJievog.

KE*. Of.
Ilfpi

20

Tuv

(f>i\oveiKr](rdvT(ov Tis fifi^av,

37
*'

lov

deeTTroTot/

XptaTOv

etirovrog qti

eyu be
wg
fnvj

etfxi ev fi.ea<a

vfxwv

ag

^taKovav^^ Ttg ovTCog eaTiv
;

dirvjvvjg,

iraaav airoTTTvaai

(f)tXoto^iav

'O yap

viro

Trdavjg XoyiKVjg

KTiaecog «a< dyiag §/atcS

Kovovfxevog,

avvBpovog

Kai
evtxl^e

avfx^aatXevcov

0eca Kai YlaTpt, 25

^taKovov Td^iv eire^/wv,
eTepov
fj.eTa

Tovg
ej^e*

iro^^ag

twv

fi.a6v]Tav'

Kai Kad
TVjg

^e

Tpoirov

htaKovtag

to^iv, TovTeaTt

KaTa tov

aapKog
^e

otKcvoff.iag

Xoyov.

30
*'

To

"

tva

eadtvjTe
(fyvjatv,

Kai

TrtvvjTe

ent ivjg Tpaire^vjg fxov ev

tyi

jBaatXeta fxov^

oti ovk ev e^eafi.dTcov pQse/a eaofxe6a Kat 30

Tpaire^vjg,

dXX

eK twv Ka6 vjfxdg irpayft.dTCOv vno^et^at
irapa tcov
eirt

Ta

Trvev-

fxaTiKa
TrpaTag

^ovXofxat, qti '(aairep ot
e-xpvTeg

yvjg

^aatXecov Tag

Ttfxdg, avveaTtot

tc elatv avToXg Kat ofxoTifxot,

XXII. 33ovTQ}^
(V

AOTKAN EYAITEAIOY.
Ti[/.a7i

157
"Trapa

raii vpaTevovaat^
01

efrovrai

tw

aBavoToo

^a<7iXti,
jM,€T

ayioi Kai 7ravev^>j^oi A-TroaToXoi, wg ^taixefxevifjKQTei
€v ToTi n€ipaaixo7i,

avTov

To

^e

"

Ka6t<7ea$€

eir)

t0

Bpovovg'^

Kat Ta

e^rji, Trpoeypdcpri.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias.
voiag eiTiixeaTog wv
6

Q,ieTo [xev taag ^tal3o\iK^g

ano-^

lov^agf ^vvaaOat kaSelv tov ovTa X^/aTOV,
'Trovvjpog

aW

viXeyyeTo Ttdvv

wv, Katroi rpam^rig d^tovu.evogf Kat
iravTog airoXavaag, o
^yj

T^f Beiag

yjfxepoTi^Tog

[^fyj^t

[xdXtaTa

<f)opTtKa}Tepov

avTa

Tfjv

Kokaatv aiteipya^eTO.
(pcovyjv.

Ovai

Totvvv avrSa

KaTa

TVjv

TOv 'S.VT^pog

O

[xev

yap KaT
v][xav,

ev^oKiav
iravTog

tov io

Beow Kat YlaTpog
e^eXriTai

te^coKev

eavTOv v/rep

tva

vj^xag

KaKov'^ o

§e tov twv oXav ^(OTYjpa Kat XvTparyjv TaTg

Twv

<f>ovevovTa}v

y^pat

•aapa^ovg, tvjv

tta^oX(a

irpe^Trco^eaTdTyjV

€KkvjpOVO[JI.V](Je

^IKV}V.

KE4). OZ.
Hepl
TTJs

15

f^aiTTjCfas tov Sarava.

Ata
"
**

Tt

Tovg

aXkovg
i^ov
o

a(f>eig

Ttpog

tov YleTpov
v[j.dg

[xovov

elpvjKey

'Lt[Ji.av,

S</xa>v,

llaTavag

e^vjT-^aaTO
[jlv]

atvtdaat wg

Tov crrTOV ;"

tva

irat^evavi avTOVf

eavTW Bappetv, dxXa TOtg

vap avTov yaptaixaat

ae[j.vvvea6ai.

T;
tc5

^e

f<TT<

'*

atvtdaai ;" 20

OopvP^aat, Tapd^ai, vietpdaat' e6og ydp
[xovatv eTrtTrvj^av, ooairep Koi tS) 'Iw^.

Sarava, Tor^ evtoKt-

32

Ev T»

€tTre7v, OTt

"

eyo)

e^e-^Qi^v

irept

aov, tva

[xv]

eKKtirv]

vj

"

vtaTtg aoVy^ e^e/^ev oti wg dvSpmrog irdXiv ^taXeyeTat, Kanot
(ov

Seog

TV]

(f>va€i, et

Kat yeyove
^e

adp^,

hevjQy^vat

ydp KaTa to 25
eK^oBeivj

avBpoTrivov, (f^vjatV
irpog

V7r€[jupatvet

^id tovtccv ag etirep

TreTpav
[xvj

tc5

SaTava, airiaTog yevvjaeTat iravTeXag, oirwg ye

Kat

eK^oOe^g vjaQevvjae TJj iriaTet dpw]ad[j.€Vog.

33
[JLV]

E-Trdyet ^e to
etg

"

e-jrtaTperpag arvjpi^ov
e^j.ireav],

Tovg dteX^fjovg aov^^ tva

aTroyvaatv
*'

[xdXkov ^e dya&v}v eXiri^^a KT-^aeTat. 30

To yap

eirtaTpeipag aTvjpt^ov Tovg d^e\(f)Ovg aov," tovto eaTi'
e^uoi.

yevov aT-^pty[JM Kai tt^tdaKaXog twv &;a TrtaTetog irpoatovTWv
ov

yap

Vf]

diroaTepviGviav], <f>viaiv,
rijg

dpvv]ad[J.evog toI/

airoaToA/Afou

yapia^JMTog, imep

Qeiag

eaTi yaXv]voTi^Tog

Kat TV]g d^fjdrov

158
(j)iXav9pco'7riai

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
virdpyet TCKfA^^piov.
etfj.t

XXII.
eiTrev

37.

Hepi wv yap
Kat

Ylijpog,
^ta

GTt

€TOtfJiog

vTiep

(70V

aiioGaveh,

uv

vjKovae

tov

TOTiapyov^ Ttpoeypd^fl.

ToT Xptsostomot.
ovK apKei
TiaKtv
ovaYjg'

EvTevfley

f/.av6dvo[J.ev

^oyfxa [xeya,

wg
Kat 5

iipo6v{j.ia av^pooTrov,

av

[xyj

Trjg avco dTToKavt] pcTiyj?i

ovhev

Kep^avovfxev

ano

TYjg

dvwdev poTr^g, 7rpo6vfxiag ovk

Kai TavTa dfutpoTepa ^etKvvat

lov^ag Kat YleTpog.
itpoTepov
^e
fJ.Yj

ovk

evavTia eavT^ vofJ.o6eTav

^ptaTog
to.

(f)rjai'

fxev

eXeye,

"

fji.vj

KT^(7vja6e

TT^pav," Kai
Of».oia>g

e^^g.
itYjpav,

Nvv
Kai

(f)V]aiv

"

eywv

" /SaWavTtov,
**

dpdTco

Kat

ejav irwXrjadTO) 10
fj.ev

TO

tfxaTtov

avTOv Kat dyopaadTca fj.djaipav'" kot apyag
oirccg

yap eKeha iipoaeTaaae,
Ovvdfiecog XajSovTeg, ev

7re7pav

Kai

dTro^et^iv

T^g avTcov
fj.eTa.

tw

fi,Yi^evog

avToiig

vaTepe7a6at

6dp^

aovg Kat
TYjv

'npo6vft.iag elg tyjv oiKovff.ev)^v e^eX^caatv
TYjg

aiiaaav' Tipog ^e

avfj.TikYipoiatv
fJ.Vj

otKoyofitag epy^pfxevog,
fj.evctiai,

TavTa TiapeKeXeveTo 15

iva

"tta

TeXovg dpyot

iievtag ^e

Kat neivag Kat yvft.vo-

TYjTog TieTpav Xa^ovTeg, ev

TovTotg tyjv oiKeiav (piXoao(f>tav ev^eid^^v^/^ccv

^ovTai, Kat

fLY]

xaTiep
eTt

^t

opydvcov
fiY]

evepyeia6at

toc

kkt
^'^(uat

avTovg vofxitcoatV

^c Kat

tva

fj.eTd

TavTa Ttveg

Xeyeiv, OTt ov^ev iiap

avTolg etaYfveyKav eKehot,
'Tipog

dXXd
Kai

to iidv TYjg 20
ft.eTptd^etv

Tov

Seov

poTiYjg

eyeveTo,

Se

TovToig

tva

fj.d6coat,

TovTo

Tiote7,
OYj

Kat oncog

f>.Yi

ft.ei^ova

^ KaTa

dv6pco7iov

Xd^coai

Co^av.

Ata

TOVTa Kat

tioXXco nXeiova tovtcov, dcpetg

avTOvg
aKpi25

TioXXoig Twv d^oK^^TCov TieptniiiTeiv, ovK Yj/^ovX-^di^ vno
/3etav

ty]v

T^g vofxo6eaiag

TYjg TipoTepag avToi/g

d<pehat,

dXX e^xdXaae
fXYj

Kai avYjKe TYjg (piXoao(j>tag tov tovov eKetvotg, coaTe

/Sapvv Ttva

Kai d(f>opYjTOV avToTg yevea6at tov ^tov, iioXXa^^^ov eyKaTaXtfj.navofxevotg Kai tov aKpt/SYJ vofxov

eKehov dvayKa^ofxevotg
ty]v
ecf^o^Sov

TYfpeiv.

37

Ayopdaat
KaT avTov

^e

ft.d')(atpav,

(f^Yja),

tcov

lov^aicov

tvjv

yvcoptaat avTolg PovXofnevog, Ka)

OTt

fxeXXovatv avTOV^^o

avXXafK/Savetv, Kat tovto (pavepcog fxev ovk ^6eXYjaev elneh, coaTe
fj.Y]

6opvl3')^aat

ndXtv avTovg'
atvtTTtTat

'tt

aiviyfj.aTOi fj.evTOt TYjg fi.a')(aipag

TYjv

eveaTcoaav

eTitl3ovXY]v,

Kat

OTt

fj^eXXet
tcov

iidayeiv
'^yjXov.

Tiapd Tcov
E/TTWV

lov^^aicov
^^"

anep ena^e, Kat tovto eK
e^TiYjyayev,

e^Yjg
'he'i

yap

ayopaadTCO fj.d^yaipav^^

" ot^

Ta ye-ZS

XXII. 44"
ypafJLfMva nepi

AOTKAN ETArTEAIOT.
ef/iov

159
ovt€

TcAeo-fi^va/, oti fJi.€Ta avofxav €Koyi<79yj'
e^poO'^

ovv TeXe/»? irapeaiami^a-eVf iva fM) Tyj a6poa,

Tapa-^^Oaaiv,

ovT€ TTaXtv

TeAewf

eyvccptaev, tva

fxrj

^eiXia Ttvi KaTaaye^xatv.
i^oZ fj.d')(aipai w^e

38

E/VovTwv ^e
Kou TO keyP^v

Tm
fiv]

^ATToaToXxv,

" Kvpie,

%vo^

avvievTccVf

avTO^

(f)V]atv,

"

iKavov ec7T/," KaiTOt^

ye ovK

vjv

'iKavov.

E/
el

fj.\v

yap

dvQpaTrivvji ^oiqBeiag Ke^j^jprjaOat,
"yjaav

avTovg e^ovXeTo, ovhe
Se
fjJij

cKaTOv

fxd^atpat, iKavat ijaav'
ofj.(og

ei

TouTO, Kat

Svo

TteptTTaf

Kat

ovk

diKKdXv^e to
fj.ri

aivtyfj.a.

Kai yap itoXXayov (f>aiv€Tat tovto Tiotm, eTtettav

vo-^aaai to XeyOeVf "JiapaTpey^et tovto Kat dcpirjatf t^ tuv irpayfxd-

1

o

Twv eK^daet Tav

fxeTo.

TovTa

t>?v

KaTavoYjatv txv

eipvjfxevajv

evi-

Tpewcov XotiroVf aairep Kat

ot€

e/ire,

" XvaaTe tov vaov tovtov"
irpo

Kai

Ta

e^^f.

Tlepi

tov Ttpoaev^aaBat avTOV

tov irdBov^

7rpoeypd(f)y] eif

tq

KaTa MaTSaTov.
OTt

Iva
BeoTyjTOi

Se

^ei^yjf

dXi^9tvos

vjv

avfl/JWTrof,

Kat

ovk dico
6

to}^ 15

^ dywvia
atfiaTOi,

'yeyovev, t^^pwae, Kot eyeveTO
oirep

avTOv

^pwg

ooaei

Bpofx^ot

fxvaTYjpiov Tivog

laTi TeKfXYfptov.
aifxaTog
irapa

Qvte
efxeXXe
<f)vatv

yap

et

acpo^pa
e^

"hetXoTaTog
fxovviq

eaTi
wairep

Kat

dyevvvjg,

voTiaiv

dymiaq

tKfndat

ihpiOTog

vypaiveaSaif

dXX

ev^oKvjae

tovto yeveaOat ev
Kai e^otKiavi

eavTco, oircog
tv]v TV]g

Tvjg

20

vjfjieTepas (f^vaeag coairep dva^t^pdvv]
trvffv^v.

^etXiag

43
TV]g

Q.<p6v]

^e

avTa AyyeXog

e^ ovpavov
v7ro

evia^^^vccv

avTOv,

oi/y^

OTt

tayyog tov AyyeXov hreteeTO,

Trdavjg vrrovpavtov ^vvd-

fxecag <po/3a}

Kat Tpofxco TrpoaKvvovfxevcg Kai
ev Tvj fxeydXv]
cjntri

^o^a^ofxevog,

dXX

iva 25

wXvjpcoSyj TO
**

viro

tov M.o)vaeci}g

eipvjfxevov,

" Kai
tv]v

evtayyadrcoaav

avTOv

TrdvTeg

viot

Qeov," TOVTeaTt
6

^ta

vnep(3oXv]v
irpog

t^? $avft.aaioTV]Tog ^o^oXoyxv avTov
ecTTiV
vj

AyyeXog eXeye

Kvpiov S17

tayyg, teanoTa, av ydp tayyaag KaTa

BavdTov Kat KaTo, toD a^ov kou KaTa tou ha(3oXov, eXevBepcoaag ^o
TO yevog tZv
avGpcoircov e^ avTcov.

44
**

4>a>v^

Trapoifxiag
**

XeyeTat
t

eirt

tcov

a<f)o^pa
eiri tcov

XvTrovfxevcov

Kat

aycovtcovTcov,

atfxaTi

^pco" coairep Kat

TriKpxg o^vpofkevcov,

atfxaTi KXaietr

ei fxev

ouv KaTO. tovtov Ttg ireTrapcotvjaOat vofxia»t
6

Tov TpovoVf ov^€ ydp T«v TOtovTcov fxa6v]fxdTCov

dvv]p dvvjKoog, 01)35

160
yap
&pofJij5ovs

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
t^pa^ «Tre^^vaTO aifAarog'
l^pcoTag'

XXII.

50.

ov

yap Ka^

ofxoioTvjTa

TovTcov eipyjKe yeveaSai tov$

tovto yap
fJLoiXXov

(xa(f)So$

^vjXovori

"

waei Bpofx^or irapiaTVjdi.

BeXav ^e

^v]XSi<Tai,

wg ovy)

XeTtraHg riai voriai Kai olov ev^ei^ecos yapiv e7rt(paivofx.evai$, aXX'
(og akYjQiHg

ahpav aiayovav

^iki^v

oXov To7g i^pSoat •nepieaTa.^ero.^ ^

**

Tovg Twv

aifi,ar(iv Qpofx.^ovg

wae) Kopov t6v yeyevrjfievov irapet-

XYj(j>evat' e^vj\ov

Oe

apa

(oairep

Kai ^ta ryjg evT€Taft,evvjg Ttpoaevyvigf
r-i^g

Kat

TYjg

TcoXKvjg

ay<avtag Kat

rav

i^pcioraiv

Tcayvrrirogy

wf

<f>vaet

Kat aXvjQcog,

aX\

ovK

eirt^^et^ei

Kat (pavraaia avOpconog re

eyipvjft.artaev 6 'ZwTVjp,

Kat roTg (f>vatKo7g Kot o^ta^XvjTotg viivipe- 10

rvjaaro iraBeai,

Ylepi rov avaarvjvat avrov €k r^g irpoaevyvjgf

Kai ort
•npog

e^ftiXvjaev

avrov

lov^^ag, Kat

ra

e^^g, ecog vffayov avrov

WtXarov,

irpoeypa^pvj etg ro
'*

Kara MaT^arov.
€tae\6e7v
etg

TiTOT BosTPflN. To
fkvj

fLVj

iretpaafxov^ ov ro

TretpaaBvjvat,

aXXa

ro

fx,v]

eaco

yeveaGat rwv Treipaafxm Kai 15

KvptevQ^vat,

AnoAiNAPioT.

Yv]fi.e7ov

ro

(f>iXv]f».a

^e^iOKev
rv]v

Trpo^t^ovg, ^ia avvv]Qetav, Kai
6

ro Kat fxakXov TrXvjataaat ^vvaaQai Kara

K.vptog (f>tkovvra fKev avrov ovk aTrearp<x(f)V], rr] re avvv]6ei irpaoTi^rt Kat irpoaeXeyyoov,

E^e/^e te avrw, iva
heyerat, oirep
e(f>

fxv]

vofjit^'^

XavBdvetv, 20

ori

ovK

eirt

Tovrca

avrov

ayv^fiart^erai
KOit

^ia rov

<f)tXv]fxaTog,

aXX

eir

eKeho,

oirep

r]Ket

(BovXerat

rov

eTrireXeaai.

^o

ToT Xptsostomot.
e^aaraaav, Kat
rpaTre^v]g

A^tov

^v]TV]aai

rtvog
;

eveKev

fj.ayaipag

iroQev v]aav eKei fj.ayatpat

airo tetirvov vjaav Kai 25

e^eXi^XvQoreg'

eiKog

ovv

Kai fnayaipag eivat
ort
v]^ovat

eKei
eir

^ta

ro

apvtov'

rovrovg

Se

aKovaavrag

rtveg

avrov
ryjg

XafSeTv eig l3ov]6eiav
eK€tvv]g

cag iroXefj.v^aovrag virep

rov ^t^aaK<x,Xov,

yvcoaecog

v]v

fxovov.

Aio Kai
TV]g

eTrirtfj.arat

Ylerpog avrv]
a(f>v]Kev

ypvjaoifLevog

/xeTa

a(f>otpag

aTreiXy^g'

Kai

ovk

rtva^o
eire-

f3X<x^v]v yeveaSat

\ptarog'

taaaro yap avrov, Kat

6avfj.a

^ei^aro, iKavov Kot rv]v eirtetKetav avrov Kat rv]v tvvafj.tv

efj.(f>v)vatj

Kat TV]v Tov
€K€ivo

fJia6v]T0v

(ptXoaropytav re Kai 7rpaorv]ra.
7rei6v]vta}g.

Kat yap

(f>iXoaropyci)g

Kat tovtq

AKovaag yap "/SaAe

& Qusedatn excidisse videntur.

XXII.

6t.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
ttjv
B-^Krjv

161
€V€t(T6v}f

T^v ixay^aipav €is

avryjij

ev6eci}(

Kat

jM,eTa

Tavra ov^afMiv tovto

voteT.
lcTTiv

AnoAiNAPioT.
»1.
/

TovTO

OTt

cvy^wp-^aews Katpo$ KOt

yj

~

/

i^OV(Tia TOV CKOTOVS.

TiTOT Bo2TPflN.
fleXw, ayToj eaTtv vfJMV

Ot€ BiXw
yj

KpaTovf/Mty (pi^aiv, eya
vj

yap

vvv S

wpa, Kat

l^ovaia

Trji afJuxpTias vfxwv.

6l

TOT XpT202TOMOT.
IleTpof, Kat

lo-Teo» OTt OVT€ 1/]a6€T0
6
e/

TOV TrTUfXaTOg
evejSAei^cv
e/f
>

avTOV

>Nf-\r

^^ XpiaTOf, betKvvi
\

TovTO

^vjkSiv

AovKas
^

(pviatv,

/

oti

ov

fxovov

yjpvrjaaTO,

»/

OTt

aAA

>«^>

>^v

ovoe

ctt-

€[Jiv^a6T^

oiKo6€v,

Kat

Tavra tov aXcKTpvovos

(pccv^aavTOS'

«AA

lo

€^€^6^ TtaXtv Tvjs Tov ht^aaKoikov

VTro[Ji.v^a€a)(,

Kai ro /SAe/Ajxa

avTw yeyove avTt
0T€ fxev

(pcovrjg, ovitfa

irepi^evig vjv.

o

8e

MapKog

cp^atv,

ava^

vjpvTjaaTO,

tot€ "npxTOv

e<f>covv}aev 6

aXeKTpva>v, ore
[Ji.a6i^Tov

§e TpiTov Kat reXevTaTov, aKpi^eaTepov e^vjyovfxevog tov
TVjv

aa6€V€tav, Kat to
"aap

a(f>o^pa

avTOv a7roTe6vv}Kevat

tco

^eet,

kou 15

TaSra

avTov tou "ht^^aaKaXov fm6av eypaxpe'
avfX(p(i)va Se

Kat yap
Koii

(potTvj-

T^f ^v IleTpov.
€1

Ta Ttapa tov MaTfla/ov
E7re/^>7

^AoipKov,
aycoyvjv
^vjXcov

Kat ^oKeT evavTta
TptTov

eivat.

yap Ka& eKaaTTjV
dXeKTpvcov,

KOi

Kat

T€TapTov
V]

(pcoveiv

€'tci}6ev

^(xpKos OTt ov^e
TowTO
(pv}aiv'

(pcovfj

avTOv eTrea^^e Kat eU
v}

f/.v^fJi.v}v

vf^aye, 20

0}aT€ afupoTepa aXv}6i^. yrptv

yap

t^^v TptTV}v

dyoi-

yi}v aTtapTiaat tov

dXeKTopa, TpiTov ^pvvjaaTO, fxovov te vtto tov
ot/^e

Kptarov
pwff

Tvjs

dfxapTtag dvafi.vv}a6etg,

KXavaat eToXfxa (pave-

dXX

e^eXBcov e^co,

cKXavae

vtKpcog.
Ho-5ev>20^e

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias.

KaTa t^v

vpoppv]atv 25

Tou \ptaTov fxaKapioi TleTpog, Kat v]pvv}aaTO tov twv oXcov
T^/ja 'KptaTov, Ka\
TV}v

S»-

ovy^

a-Tra^,

dXXa

Tpig, Kai

evcofxoTov

eTroteiTO

dpw}atv. "E^pv] yap
ofxvvetv, OTt

MaTfia/bf, " OTt vjp^aTO KaTava6efxaTi^etv

"

Kai

ovk oT^a tov dv6pa)vov." YletpoovTai fxev ovv Tiveg,

OfX(OfxoK€vai KaTO. Tov MaTfiaTov,

ovk oi^ev

dv6pcoTrov

yeyovoTa TOV30

lv}aovv, TovTO Se airtaTov.

IlcSf

yap ovtov ovk
fxvaTvipiov'

vjpvvjaaTo TV}g fxera
vj^et

aapKog oiKOVOfxiag dvarpeTrcov to

yap KaO

v}fxag

yeyovoTa, TovTeaTtv av6pcoTrov tov fxovoyevf} tov Oeov Ao^yov* Kai
yovv wfLoXoyyjaev evapycog,

"

oti

av

et

HptaTog
v}fJMg

Ttog tov OeoS

"tou ^avTo^," Kat

ovy^ a>g eva tcov

Ka&

Tiov avTOV etvat SeovSS

Y

5

162

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Toid^e
(pyjcriv'

XXII.

66.

^iaj3el3aiovix€vog to,

aWa

Kai To7g TVjg

avBfiiOTto-

TiqTog fj.€Tpotg (yvfx/SelSvjKOTa Seapav, tov eTreKeiva itavTog ytvvfiTOv,

Kai €K
aiiicxTi^

TTjg

Toy ©eoy Kai HaTpog oixxiav avaXoifxrpavTa Koyov, ovk

Tov eivai Kai 0[xoXoye7v, wg ea-Tiv avTog Tiog tov Seov
Kai
ov^rjTroi (f)a[xeVf oti

Tov ^wvTog.

yeyovev apvvjaig, iva

[xv]

\pav-

ayjTat ^ptaTog,
Tco
fji.aSvjT7J'

aX\
yap

oti to eaofxevov

ovk

yjyvoi^jKo^g,

TtpoaTiyfyyetKe

OTt

avBpomtVYji fxtKpoipvy^iag, wg

e(f)i^v,

yeyove to

KaKOv, Kat ToTg tov avvei^OTog ekeyyotg

fiaQvjTrjg
Tyj

KaT€Kptv€TOf
fKeTayvaa^ei

h^d^etev av

evOiig

koi avTOg 6 SpT^vog, Kai to ent
(pyjaiVf

^aKpvoV e^eXOuv yap e^w,

" eKXavae

TrtKpoog,^^

Trpoaea^/yf-io

KOTog avTa Tov ^ptaTov, Kai tov npog avTOV yeyovoTog Koyov

KaXeaavTog
a-Komv,

elg

dvdfxv^atv.

ETrtaTpexpag
rjv,

^e

ov

^trjfJLapTe

tov

fxefxevYjKe

yap

oirep

yv^aiog

fi.a6vjTVjg,

TteTrkovTVjKe

yap T^g

acf^eaewg tov

TTXfift.fi.eKyifi.aTog.

66
**

ToT
Twv,

ATTOT. Ylpenoi av

etTteiv

oirep

e(f)Vj

Ttg twv dytav Tipofpvj- 15
eiii

"

e^eaTfj 6 ovpavog evt toSto, Kat €(f)pt^ev
6 yvjg t€ Kat ovpavov Kvptog,

TrXeTov

a(po^pa

Aeye; K.vptog."

Tav

oXm

yeveaiovp-

yog Kat

Te^^^ytTVjg, 6

^aatXevg twv ^aatXevovTm, Kat Kvptog twv
e^ Yjfxav dTtfxd^eTat, Kat ^taKapTepeT tvttto-

KvpievovTcov,
ft.€Vog,

wg

eig

Kai Tov €K twv

dae^wv

v7rofJ.€vet

yeXma,
'O yap
dv

tvtiov v^fuv TVjg

20

elg aKpov

dve^tKaKiag eavTOv TiapaTiOeig.

€Td^(ov

Kapttag

Kai ve(f)povg,

Tipo^f^vjTetag TidaYjg toTvip, Tiag
;

i^yvovjae, Tig eaTtv

Tiataag avTOv

^Aviayova^vig

v}fii.epag

to

^vaaej^eg Kat vdavjg

dvofxtag fxeaTOV avvvjjepTai PovXevT-^ptov, Kai etg fjieaov 6 Ma)i/-

aeag Koi
^eTO

7ipo(f>v)T(ov

^eaTiOTYjg
et

dSeafJicog

€^vPpt^ofii.€vog

rnapeKOfi.t-

25

eimvc/avovTO Oe

avTog eaTiv

XptaTog

aXX
cre

etnot Ttg

av

Tipog avTOVi, ei /xev fxaBeTv, TVTiTeiv

dyvowv epooTag, ovk edei
fi-^TicDg

nptv to aXi^Oeg
TipoaKpovavjg'
ei

Kat v/Spi^eiv avTOv,

Qew
avTOV
ov

8e

VTioTiXdTTetg

t^v

dyvotav,

ev

ei^iog

ovTa

^piaTOV,

aKovaetg ovv tov lepov

ypdfi.fj.aTog,

" ©co^

fj.vKTVjpti^€Tat" ^to

30

Kat \ptaTog npog avTovg'

"

eav vfxTv e<7ra>" Kat

Ta

e^^vjg'

tiov

yap

dKovaavTeg entaTevaaTe

;

tiov ^e epcaTWfxevot
eipvjfjievov,

eaty^aaTe

;

^XeyyovTog ^v avTovg to

oti ov itavTeXag htaXeXv]-

Bev avTovg to itpdyft.a §<« t*^v e« tc5v aYifketm eiityvwaiv.

Ilo^ev

ydp

TO Xeyetv

tovtov fxovov ^ptaTOv, oitep

€(f>

cTepoo

ovk elp-^-^S

;

5

XXII.
Ka<Jiv
ev
T^ij
;

66.

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
^e to

163

^Eiiri(f)ep€i

T^f

Kpia-ecog,

aTreiXav ori oxpoviai avrov

ovpavicD ^o^yj (paivofxevoVj

aW

Ofxwg aKovcravTe^ ovk enXr^av^
eiTrav eivai rov Xoyov.

ovt\ ecpvka^avTO,

aWa ^Xaa^fJiuag
toi<;

Ovrcci

ovK eig

u)(j)e\eiav

dvrjKOoi^

ai Ttav fxvJTfipKov aTroKaXvrpet^,

dW

eU

KaTaKpKJiv.
Air-^yayov TiiXaTw tov
lyi^rovV

5

Ktpiaaot !A.aehanapeia2.

Trape^edrjaav Kai avTOi TaT( twv 'Pcofxaicov aTpaTia7i, Kai iieTtXYj-

puTai Ta ^ia tZv dyicov
**

irpocpvjTcov

eir

avTotg

jrpoe^nvjyyeXfji.eva,

ovai Tcc dvofxai, TrovYjpa
avTcio'^' 6 ^e,

Kara t» epya

tHov yeipcav

avTOv

avfi.l3y]-

" aeTai
*'

"

KaGoos eiioivjaai, ovTcag earat aoi ro dvra- lo

Tio^^ofM. (Tov, dvrairo^oO-^cyeTat (xot

eU

Ke(f>aXriv aov."
yifj.av

Tf

Se S^

Kat YliXdrca, (paai, rag Kara rov Tiavrcov EcoT^pof
(TvvrtBevreg avKo^pavriag
*' **
;

^ptarov^

tovtov evpofLev '^iaarpe^povra ro eOvog

yjficcv,

Ka\ KccXvovra (popovg ^t^ovai KaiaapiJ'^

Tlov KeKcaXvKe
1

<f>opovg '^t^ovat

Kaiaapt
tcSv

;

Kairot Tre^TrofKpare irpoi ovtqv e| eav-

T«v Ttvag

jotCTa

KaXovfievccv 'Hpco^tavciiv Tietpd^ovrdg re
vj

Kat

Xeyovraf, " li^da-KaXe, e^eari (popovg ^i^ovat Kaiaapt,
•npog

ov ;" etra

ravra "Kptaroi'

eTrt^ei^are fxoi, (pv]ai, vofxtafj.a rov Kevaov,

etpero re, rivos ^xet eiKOvog eTriypa(pvjv ro
ctig

Ttpoaota&ev

"^vjvdpiov

§e

Kataapog e(paaKov, dno^ore,

(pvjai, '*

ra Kaiaapog Kaiaapt 20

**

Kot ra rov Seov

r^ ©eaj."
eiavjv

Y]ov roiyapovv KeKaXvKe (popovg
avroTg
^c>ylqv,

^t^ovat

Kaiaapt

;

aAX'

aKOTTOg ro
^tXtjv

Karayayeh

eig

Qdvarov rov dva(pepovra irpog
tt^coXoXdrpov

vjXeyyovro Kat

dv^pog

yeyovoreg ^vaaejSearepot.

O

fjiev

yap UtXdrog

vavrog alrtdfxarog «ir^AAaTTe tov

Iviaovv, Kat

rovro ovy^ aira^, 25

«AAa

rpig'

01

^e eTrla^^QJov Xeyovreg, dvaaetet tov kaov, avKocpavfx,ev

rtav erepag avWeyovreg d(popfJ.dg' kat ort

e^t^aaKe, (paatv,

aeatyriKaai ^e rvjg 'tt^aaKaXiag rov rpoirov, te^^toreg wov /a^ apa

vwg Kou avTog
irXvjv

n*AaTO? evpeOy

roTg

irtarevovatv

evapi6fj.tov,

Kat ravra a Xeyovaiv,
'^

e7reTifj.a

YltXdrog, aTroXoyovfxevog

re^o

Kat Xeycov,

ovtefxiav airtav evpvjKa ev avrSi," Kai
jtxev

ra
vjv

e|^«".

KaTiyyoperTO
VI

vno twv lov^atcov
irpdyfxarog
(popov
(pcovvjv

6

Kptarog'

§e airtarog

Karvjyopia,

rov

evavrtav

roTg

Karvjyopoig

d(ptevTog'
fxev

ovtc

ydp

eKccXvae Kataapt

^t^^ovat irore, fj.aXXov

ovv

Kou

eTTerpexpe

Xeycav,

" dirodore ra Kaiaapog KaiaaptfSS

Y 2

"

164

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
too

XXIII. 7.
h>

" Kdi ra Tov Qeov
avTco'

0f»." ovtc PaaiXeiag lyyeipyjatg ^v

ak\a yap

eTrtovToov

avT^ tZv oj^Awv

oooTe (SaatXea TtoiYjaaty

KaTaXtTim avTovs

etg xo opo^ avey^apvjae,
ot avofxot,

Tlotav ^e aTpaTtcorcov

Tiapaa Kevfjv opav ev avTa
Tt ^e aXa^oviKOv
;

ei^ tovto

KaTvjyopovv avToo

;

ov^^^t

Koofxa^ Kai iioXetq o^onropuv Toii TroaiVf evt 5

OepaTreiatg

avBpwnav
rj

e<paiv€TO

;

Atonep Kat avTca tw n/Aara)
a(f)6r],

antBavog vavTeXwg
pasTa, otovet
**

KaTVjyopta Kat eaoXog

o6ev Kat

eTTVj-

^tay^Xeval^wv Tovg KaTvjyopovvTag, Xeyoov,

" av

ei

c

j3aatXevg twv

[ov^^aim ;" e; KcCt

Kvptog to

ovTcog eivat

^aat10

Xevg ovK apveiTat.

KE4).
'E^ovdfVTjiTis

OH.
'HpwSov.

7

¥iK'neii.(f>6etg

te Tipog 'H^co^iyv vtio YltXaTOv, ovk aiteKpiBvj too
vit

tipcoorj

epiaTWfxevog
fxvjtev
v]v

avTOv,

eTietOv]

ovk

eoet

irpog

avapamov

avoKptvea6at
^t^^aaKaXiag
•npeitov
vjv

a^iov aTTOKpiaecag eyovTa'

aXXcog t€ ^e ov^e 15
avjixeioov

Katpog,

ovfe

eTii^^eiKVva^at

^vvafxtv
av]fjt,eTa

to5

Tipog TepaaTtcov orptv <f)tXo6ed[xovi
i^eiv

fxaXXov

vj

^vudfJiecDs

6eia

^ovXofuevcf

o6ev

atamvjg i^av

tov

Kaipov

eatcana.

XXeua^e/
Oe
tit

fxevTot tov aefjjvov Kat Tifj.tov
fj.y]Oev

avata6v]Tog, fj.apTvpet 20
2i.ptaTog
v]

cov

"x^Xevaget OTt

aOiKov eirpaqev

ov

yap

ea6^Tog ^ e^ei XafniTpag ent tov KaKOv Tt ^e^^paKOTog
Tog, o6ev
lov^aTot

elpv^KQ-

Kai

ovtci)

KaTatayyvovTai €K tov ^iKaaTv^ptov
aTctovTog rov
KaTV]yopovfi.evov
eirotei

Kai rv]g KaTV]yoptag avTWv.
XafJ.Trpag

fxeTo,

€a6v]Tog^f

ei

Kat ^tairai^wv 'Hpoo^v^g
eiTrep v]v
v]v

tovto,

ovk2$

av Se toSto tteTcpd^avTO,
Kat

opy^g

Katpog.

'MapTvpei Se
ft.v]

II;AaTOf, ot;
cov

xpi^(f>og

avTV) tou

Hpw^ou

v]^tKV]Kevai

Tov KvptoVf e|
OTt
'^

<f>^at
fj.ot

irpog Tovg

dpyiepeig Kat Toi/g apyovTag,
cag

"

7rpoav]veyKaT€

tov avdpconov tovtov
evwirtov
cav

airoaTpecpovTa tov
evpov ev TC030

Xaov, Kat
dv6pci}7rca

i^ov, eyo)

vfxwv dvaKpivco, ov^^ev

**

TovTca

aniov

KaTv^yopeiTe avTov,

dXX

ov^e 'H/JW^oyj

Kat Ta

eqv]g.

'Eb ANEnirPA*oT.
dvtaTog
v]

KaTi^-yo/jerTO

vTro

ypafj.fJMT€cov,

Kat

v]v

KaTv^yopta, tov TrpdyfxaTog
* a*V6^T05

<pcavr]v

evavTiav roig Karvj'

Cod.

XXIII.
yopoig

7-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
Tig

165
€Y)(€ipyj(rtg

a.(f)ievTog.

yap

yj

T^f

(3aa-t\€iag

%apa

Xo^aToy, bf Kai eiriovTav avTa
ta-Tavaif

xaiv

oyXajv co(TTe
aveywpYi<je
;

^aaikea KaBevQa
fAr]

KaTaXnrav avTovg

eig

opog

^ei

Xiyeiv

/xij^e

aTroKpiveaBaif (Jtomrjv ayet

^ptaTog.

Tt yap
fyovra
;

e^ei

Ttpog avQpcoTTOV airoKpiveaOat, fxvj^ev a^tov aiioKptaewg

5

A^a t/
kopTVjv
;

te

etyov avayKy\v a-nokvaat

eva KaKovpyov KaTO, nf/v
lovtauav,
oi

eiKog apTt vitoa-jrov^av yevofxevwv 'Pwfuitav kou

ovep

•jroTptov

^v

avToTs

itapeyetv
6

rtva

Aaaj,

'^teTvipovv

*Pa)[Jia7ot

TOVTO,

KaSag Kat oaa
Ylept tov

SaovA

avveycopyja-e ^ia tov
oTt rjyy dpevaav

Xaov

Tov ^lwvaSav.

BapaPl3a, Kai

^ifAwva lo

Tov

}i.vpi^vaiov, vpoeypd(f)Yj etg

to kutu M.aT6a7ov.
Kptvetv

Ktpiaaot Aaebanapeias. Tou
Tog
avTOVf

XayovTog eXevOepovvtov
irdavjg

OavaTov

tp^^ov

VTtoaTyjvat

TtapaKaXovat

evae^eiag
fxetvaat
*' **
**

KaSvjyrjTyjv Kat

^ttda-Kakov, tva ert (f^opTtKanepav vno'^afXTrXrjQet

KoXaatV dveKpayov yap
yjfJLiv

XeyovTeg
Vtf

"

aipe tou-i^
**

Tov,

dnoXve ^e

rov

Bapa(5^av^^ thov

aa(f>'2g

tov

aytov Kat htKaiov rjpv^aavro, Kat yjT^^aavTO dv^^pa (povea yo^p^-

a^vat

avToig, tva

t^? CKeivov

fi.epi^og

eaovTai Kotvoovot^^ o

Sr/

Kat avv€(3r] iraQeTv avTovg' ^e^ovrai yap eig oXeQpov Kai a(payrpt.
€ve<f)av^aav yapf
(pi^atv,

XeyovTeg^

^'

a'pe> «^pf j

aTavpaaov auTOv," 20
Kvpiog ita
dfp^Ka
etg
Trjv

TauT>jv auTwv T>yv dvoatav KaraPoy^v vjTtaTO Xeyojv
<f>a)v^g
**

lepefJi.tov'

**

eyKaTaXeXotira

tov

otKov

fxov,

KXrjpovofxiav fxov, ^e^tcKa t^v rjyairrjfjievrjv rpvy-^

fj.ov

yeTpas

**

eyOpicv avrrjg' eyev^Qrj

rj

KXi^povofi.ta fiov

efj.ot

ag Xewv

ev tpvfjJa,

ehwKev

eit

€fj.€

rrjv (pcovrjv
Ei(f>r]

avr^g
irept

Ota rovro

efxtarja-e.

25

ToT
6
*

ATTOT.

Trov
**

r^f rwv

lov^^atm

dvoatorrjTcg

irpo^f^yjrYig

'Yiaoiiag,
ort

ova)

avrolg ort
etg
eft-e,

direTrvi^yjaav

dv

efnov'

oetXaiot

etatv

yjaepyjaav

eya>

be

eXvTpa)aafi.yjv

**

auTouf, avroi ^e KareXdXvjaav
ev pof/.(pata 01

Kar

efJLOv
'^t

x|/eiiS^"—

—/fa/

iraXtv,

" veaovvrai
** **

dpypvreg avrwv

airat^evatav •yXwo"-

30

ai^g

avrwv." " eveKptve to/vuv,"

(prjatv, **

YltXdrog yeveaOai
oXeOpov fxy^repa' Kai
(fyrjat,

TO atryjfLa
/u,€v

avrm"
SwT^p

Kai
evt

vtKVjv

vevtKyjKaat

ayerai

ro atoryjptov TrdAog' ^tfxcovt Se,
(Travpov
epr} xov

Kvpyjvatu}

eireQrjKav

tov

aurou.
hjoroint

erepog

Se

t£v dyivv
^vAov. 35

^vayyeXt^rrm Kot avrov

^aardaai ro

166
'AA>?56f

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Se TrdvTUf tovto

XXIII.

27.

KaKHVo'
i<7C0s tvjv

^veyK^ [mv yap rov (rravpov
o^ov vTravT-^aavra rov Kvpvjeir

6 YiWTYjp'

KaTa

fx.ecri^v

oe

vaTov

Karea^^^YjKao-i
TTCO^ e^^ei

Kai [/.ereSvjKav

avrco ro ^vkov.

Avay-

Kaiov ^e

Xoyov ro Kai avrov rov
aravpov'
eipyjrai

o\m
Tiepi

'Ecoryjpa l^piarov

e^tK0[J.iaacy6ai tov

yap

avrov
€^o6v]

'^ia
y}(xTv,

<l)cavyj<;

S

'Haaiby

**

ori

Ttattiov
coixov

eyev^dv]

^imiv, vio$

Kat

ov

vj

"
'^i

ap^Yj
ov

eTTt

rov

ayTov*"
vtt

«^5^17

yap yeyovev avTov
e't7cep

aravpog,
**

(Be^aatXevKe roTg
fJ^-^Xpi

ovpavov,

eartv

aXy]6eg

ori

^*

yeyovev vTr-^Koog

tov Bavdrov, Bavdrov ^e aravpov. Kai

Ato
ro
1

** *'

Kat
vTrep

6

Qeog avrov
Ttav

virepvipcoae
ev

eyaptaaro avrco
lyjaov

ovofjia

o

ovofxa, iva

r^

ovof/iari

Xpiarov

Trav

yovv

**
**

KdfA,\l/i^

eTTOvpavicov

Kat

eTityeicov

Kat

KaTa'^ovtc>iv,

Kai
etg

iraaa
^o^av

yXcaaaa e^Oft.oXoy^aerat

ori

Kvpiog Ivjaovg "Kptarog

**

Qeov Ilarpog}

ajtA^v."

KE*. 00.
Hepi
tS>v KOTTTOfievap yvvaiKav.

15

27

A<

rjv

atrtav Opvjvovaag rag yvvaiKag ore
aTTYjet

eirt

rov aravpov

cog

rpoTratovyog
eTrerifnyjae
;

yiptarog, ov

f/.ovov

ovk dne^e^aTO,
too fCev

aXka Kai
yap aKovrt
vPptv. 20

^ta ro

eKovatcog irdayetv avrov'
(pepet,

'ttday^ovri

^ avfi.irdOeta TrapdKk-rjatv

rw

he

CKOvrt

'Ettc/ ovv eKeTvai, rov ev^Yjft.eTaGat Kat KporeTaBat hiKatov ovra, cog

rov Odvarov
KOTrTOfj.evai,

a^eaavia Kai rov ^td^okov eKvevpiaavra,
tia rovro
eirerifXYjae

eQpyjvQW

re avraig, Kat ra fxeXkovra

avfiP-^aeaSat
'Poofi,aiQ}v TYJ

irpoefXYivvev, aitep

KaraaKYjxpavrog rov iroXefLov rcov

%wpa

rcov

lov^aicov irepag eXafBe.
'hta

25
avrov QeTav

31

SvAov vypov eavTOV Xeyet,
^ooYjV

tyjv

ev

too awfJ.aTt
'^ta

TYjv

dfudpavrov Kat aKardXvTOV, Kat

ro eyKapirov Kai
fji.varaycoyiat

evSaXeg' Kapirot
irapatveaetg.

yap
roivvv

"^aav avrov

ai

^coottoioi

Kat

Xeyet, rotovrov eartv,

et

ovv

efxe,

(pyjai,

rov rotovrov ^etvaTg irept^e^XYjKaatv drtfi.tatg
rtcorat, Kat
6

01 'Pcofi.aicov

arpa- 30

rovrcov

arparYjyog UiXdTog, rt tpdaovai vfuv rco
rcov

^Yipf

Kat

aKdpircfi

^vXw, tw Xaw
arpaTevfiara,
rov

Jov^^atwv,
ctt

TrpoairoXefxovvra
tc3

ra

rcov

'Vcofi.at6ov

f/.Yj^€V

avra
Kapirov

Xa^ rav

lov^atcov

^YjXovort

re6avfji.aafxevov

kou

ttKaioavv^g

XXIII.

43-

AOYKAN ETArrEAlOY.
ecp

167
Kai
Tifxvjs

e/ovrm PXenovreff
Gyjvai

ol^

y}v

eiKog

<f>et^ovs

a^ioo(cairep

T^f irap

ainm' fuaXXov
iroXtopK-^o-ovcxt

^e KaraKavaovaiv

vfnai

^vXov

^yjpoVf Yjyovv

Kat a/j^aXaTou? X-^ovrat Kai

avoKTevovtn, ti^XovoTt t^? eig avTOv rov EcoT^pa ^v(X(T€(3etai eveKa.
Ylepi
**

Tov

aTavpcoS^vai
eir

tov

^eaTroTyjv

'Kpiarov

eoo^

"

-^v

^65

Kat

vj

eTttypa(f)Yj

avroOf

^atJikevg twv

lou^awv,"

iipoe-

ypd(f)y} eii to KaTo.

MaT^arov.

KE*. n.
Titpi Tov fi(Tavor]<TavTOS

XpoTou.
eTreiyo[xevoi

33 ra

'O

fjiev

ovv

MaT^arof Kat MdpKOs

irpoi

cTepa, 10

etirovTei ea>? ov avet^t^ov avTOv 01 Aijo-Ta/,
'irept

Ta koiva

Tijf i<noptag

tov aTavpov irapeXtTrov.
etprifxevm^
tvjv
eiire'

AovKag
Ta

^e dcpefxevoi tc3v irpoTepwv,

ag napa Torf aWotg
etjTt

7rapaKet(f)QevTa eKetvotg, tovticxTopeT,

Tov

evog
rjv

XriaTov

eTrtyvcoatv

diro

T^f (puv^g

ap^dixevog

Kvptog
ijg

"
i^v,

IlaTe/?, d(j)eg avTotg, ovk o^laat

T/15

"

Ttotovcrtv" a(f>
e^^deiv eig

etKog

KaQdirep

etpYirat,

tov erepov twv

kfldTav
riaif

KaTdvv^tv.
ju,ev

MaT^arof

Kai

MdpKog Tovg
Oe tov

^vo
;

Xeyovai
apy(yj

Xy]<j-Tag
ot

oveiOt(7ai

Tov i\.vptov,
TrapaTrXyjdta

AovKag
ToHg

eva

ev

^aev

Ovo
irpog

kyjo-Tat

\ovtaioig

e(f)6eyyovTO, ydptTt

ryj

20

avTovg'
a(pe(7tv. (rav,

t(Tug rtva irap
CATretOy}

avToiv ^orjQeiav evTevQev irpocrtoKavTeg eig

Oe aitep irpocreQOKdiv irapa tojv
avevrjxpey

louda^wv yjpyy}-

Bdrepog Tav Atjcttwv, avTog t€

Kat tov akXov eig

rovTO TtpoeTpeireTO.
Ilol^ev

Se

eKehog

dvevy}\peVf cvTro}
;

yap ^v Ta KaTo, tov (Travpov 25
laag wv
itep

Sea^xdfxevog 6av[J.aTa
7rappy}ai(X

Ik rav

X6y(tiv

Kvptog

'ly}(Tovg

ttpog

tov

Qeov, ag ttpog Ylarepaf e(f)6ey^aT0
ov

XeynVy

llaTep, a(peg avToig
ta(o

yap otoaat

ti itotovcrtv
**

(cg

yap laog

^iaXeyo[Ji.evos

Kai varepa eKdXet, Ka),

ouf^eg^^

avv TtoXXyj

irappy}aia
p-qaov

eXeyev.

Ov yap
to.

etire,

Kvpte, TrapaKaXa ae, axryyw- 30

avTolg, teiKVvg OTt

etg

avTOv

e(f>

vjSpet

XeyofJieva, eig

f3Xaa(f)y]fiiav

tov

YlaTpog

dvarpe-^^ovai,

&/a

ro

T^f

6eoTV}Tos

OfMOvatov.

43

Ilwf

&e

Yj

"^eairoTov

^fnwv

Seov TrenX-^pxTat vvoayeaig,

yj

168
vpo^ Tov
**

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Xyja-T^v, eipyjKOTOt; irpog avTOV,

XXIII. 43.
fxeT
e(xov eay}

"

avjfxipov
t-^

€V

Tco

vapa^eia-(a ;"
tyjv

vXrjpcov

to,

TidvTa
tc3

GeoTVjTi, Kai

ev

to)

CTavpic ^v tia

adpKa, Ka\

Iv

ovpavSa '^ia tyjv
too
t^i

QeiOTVjTag
VTtyjpyev,
Trjg

Kai TrdXiv KaTa(3a<; airo tov rjTavpov, Kai \v Kai Tov XvjaTViv eig tov Tiapd^eiaov elaYjyaye
BeoTVjTOs'

«^17

irapovaia.

5

Tdya

Oe irpaTOv tov XvjaTYjv tov eli avTOV iriaTevaavTa.
Si^/xepov TtoXXdKii ^v Ty^ ypa<f>y]j

ToT Anor Titot BosTPaN.
Kat
**

eiri

oXov TrapaTeivei tov eaTyjKOTa aiavaf waTrep
6

Kai ev tco
a-^fxepov

ecpyjfxiaGyj

Xoyog ovTog

irapa

\ov^aioi(;
ect??

/otep^p/

t^^-

"

yjfxepag,^^

Kai " qvto^ iraTyjp Mcya/3;Tc5v
tco

T^g

ayjixepov ^[xepagJ^
ev

10

TrapyjyyeWeTQ ovv
Tov Seov, TO €v

a^iwaavTi

[xvyjaSyjvai

avTOv

t^

jSaaikeia,

Tco

eveaTyjKOTi

aimi

Trpo

tov [xeXXovTos Troiyjaai

avTOv yeveaOai

ev

t^

j3aaiXeia, tov Qeov.

Sethpot AnoAor.^

T^ve^ cpaat,

irajg

av

e^irotfxev

etaeX.y}kV'

Bevai Tov XyjaTVjv etg tov Trapd^etaov, tov AiroaTokov Ylavkov Tovg 15

av
" "

atwvog aTraptdfxyjadixevog ttKaiovg
^ta
Trjg

ev Tri irpog

KI3patovi

eTri-

aTok^, OtKatooQevTag
oiiToi

TriaTedog,

Kai

eTrayayovTog^

"

Kat

TrdvTeg

fxapTvpyjQevTeg

^ia

Tyjg

TrtaTecog,

ovk eKOfxiadVTO
'Trpo/^kexjya-

T>jv

eirayyektav^ tov %eov Trept yjfxav
fxyj

KpeiTTOV Tt

"

fxevov, iva

yoiptg yjfiwv
ev

TeketcoGwat ;" Kat Ttveg keyovat

wg 20

ATToaTokog ovk
aev,

otg airyjpiBfxyjaaTO Kat tov kvjaTyjv avvYiptBfxy}-

akk

eatcoiryjaev

avTOV^ wg
aTrkSig

tSov

eirrjiyyekfxevm

>j^^

Tvj^ovTa,
01

Kat tta TovTO ovK

eiirev

Kat dirpoa^topiaTOog, '^irdvTeg

"

fxapTvpyjQevTeg ^ta Trjg TrtaTewg ovk eKOfxtaavTO Tag eirayyekiag^^
eiire,

dkk

" Kat ovtoi

iravTeg
olg

irpog

Tovg

airyjptBfxi^ft.evovg

^eiKTt- 25
eTepoi

Kwg avatpepmv tqv koyov,
Se e(f>aaav,
tetaoci.
/ix>jSe

kyjaTi^g

ov

avvyiptBfnyjTO.

Trcog

tov ky]aTv]v TeTvyviKevat t^j ev tco irapa-

AvTog yap

eiirev^ ** o
fxv)

ovpavog Kat

vj

yvj

TrapekevaeTat,

"

ol &€

koyot fxov ov
ev ToTg

'TrapekBooatv'"

eaTt yap Ka) Te;ouT6V
irept tc5v

ei^og,

(f^vjaiv,

tov Kvpiov p-^fxaatv, ev otg
cog

eaeaBai 30
^e
/x.^

fxekkovTcov wg ^^vj yeyevvjfxevoov ^te^etatv,

otov keyyj,

"

" TrtaTevm,

vitvi

KeKptTat'" Kat irdkiVf

"

dfxyjv,

keyw

vfi.iv,

oti

"
"

Tov koyov fXQv aKovcov koi TriaTevoov

tw

TrefxxpavTt fxe, eyet ^oovjv,

Kai eig Kptatv ovk epyeTat,
fe

dkkd

fxeTa^e(3v]Kev ck tov BavdTov
excidit.

Leg., credo,

"Ano AOr.

Numerua Sennonis

.

XXIII. 43**

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
(Evvoiav

169
Kai to pyjTOv
a/xr^v
ea'»;

e<V

T^v ^anjv." aXXoi &e irpo^ tovtoi^ t^v
'^'

€Kfxd^ovTat

Xeyovat yap ^eTv vvotTTi^ovTag avayiV(aaK€iv, "
(xyjfXipoVf

Acy»
"
ev
Too

cro;

ii&

ovtus e^Kpepetv to "
fji.iXXovTcx,

joter

e/ixov

TrapatetaUf^ ws ilg tov

yj^ovov ^oKitv a<f)opav

TYjv VTiocyyjEatv.

dXXa
Tijg

Tairra /xev

oi/TO/.

5
ecrT/.
17

lo Oe aAyjaei
rjfuv

e^yy-y^aewf,
h<TTtv

touto
ovyji

Ta

iirifyyeAfxeva
Trapd^eia-ov
Trpocr-

ayaBa ^acrtXita
^7

ovpavm,

e/V tov
Kcti
y^

e/coSof ^

htdvotog'

oBev
rj

Kai TipoaevyeaQat

Xeyetv

eTo^ev

6 l^vptof,

"

IXBeTta
epet

/SaaiXeia
a)$

aov" ov^

toD Ttapo^eidov
j3ao-tkeia

OtaTptl3y].

a\k

tacof

Ttg

TavTOV eaTtv

tj

twv 10

ovpavwv Koi
TO

wapd^etaoff ^vo irpoa^yoptav ovacov irept ev TtpdyfUf.

vTtoKetfJievov.

dXX

yj

twv

lepSiv ypafj.fxdTav

^ttaaKaXia ^etKVv^tdcftopov.

atv, a)f ov
fJiev

TavTov eaTtv, aAX' eKaTepov ttoXv to

Ta
eitt

yap

ev tvJ

^aatXeia

tSov

ovpavav

yjTOtft.aafji.eva

TOii dyaTraat

Tov K.vptov ayaQa, " ovre

0(f)BaXfi.og e/^e,

ovtc ovg vjKOve, ov^e

15

"

Kap^tav dvQpcoTtov ave/3>7," /«^Ba Kat
Se Ttapd^etaov

BeaTteaiog ypd^et ITatJAof
^A^aft.,

Tov

Kat o(p6a\ft.og ei^e tov

Kat

oi/s

^KOvev'

TjKovae yap "
et

aTro TravTOf

^vXov

ev

tso

itapa^etaa /3pcoaet ^a-yi^,"
^e ^pcoatv

Kat Tov evog ^vkov

t>;v /xev

6eav

elyjE, Tyjv

ovk ene-

TiTpaTtTO.

Kai

eitt

Kap^hiav

dvBpcottov
yj

dve^yj,

itpoaeTdTTeTo yap 20

epyd^eaBai tov itapd^etaoV
aos Ttg ovK
evvoiav
yjv,

Se

epyaata tov itapo^eiaov /Sdvav-

a\k

ei^yjE.

XoytKyjv ev(j)poavvy]V avafi.eft.tyft.evyiv Kai
atcoTtcov

Betcov

aitokavatV
eitetitep

yap
eivev,

Tyjv

dpvayyjv
ev

y]

yjpTtayy]

YlavXos

eKeiaeVf

avTOg

"

etTe

acofj^aTt,

etre

"

€KTOS Tov acofJMTog, ovK oita.^^
'

25
d^ev^yjg
to,

QiOTe

\y]aTy]g tov

f/.ev

itapa^etaov TeTvyyjKeV
eayj ev
toj

yap
cv

eiTtuv,

"

ayjfuepov

fj.eT

efxov

Ttapa^eiaco'^^
fJieTa
toIv

Se

ekittat
^iKaicov

Tyjg

^aaiXetag

tcov

ovpavcov

dyada
itepi

air

atcovog

ovK

eKOfJiiaaTO,
fj.y]

tov Seov
y]fj.cov

yjfiMV

KpetTTOv Tt
OTt

itpo-

/3ketpafi.evov, tva

yjopU

TeXetcoBioat'

yap Ta a-ya^a 30
y]

Ta

cv

eTtayyeXtaig

yjfncov

d'7toKetfj.eva

ovhev eTepov eaTtv

(3aat-

Xeia Tav ovpavwv, ttoWaypBev

fiev eaTiv avvi^eTv,

ftM\taTa oe eK

Tav

pYifJMTcov eKetvcov,

wvnep
Xeycov
^

Kvptog
ToTg

cv

ts!)

KaTa AovKoiv Eva-y-

yekico

dvayeypaitTat

eavTov

fj.aBriTalg,

"

vfueTg

Se'

Leg.

iK^toi^ovtai.

z

170
"
eCTTC
01

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
^ia[X€fJl,€VVjKOTeS

XXIII.
fX€T
€[XOV,

43.

€V

ToTi

'7I€ipa<TfJI,o7$

Ktxyii}

"
"

'hiaTiSvjfi.i

vfuv, KaBwg ^ieO^TO fxoi

YlaTYjp fxov [3aaiX€iav, iva

eaSiYjTe Kai tiivyit€ eni TVjg TpaTre^rji fxov €v t>5

PaaiXeia fxovT

^tyofKev ^e iipog

t^

lif^yyeXfxevyi

^aaiXela Ka\ tov Trapd^eiaov,
Gavfxdaai ovv
ecrTi S

OdTig '^iopig^ laTi TcvevfxaTiKrji avaTravaewf'

Tov Kvpiov Tag 7Tavao(f)Ovg oiKovofxiag, wv fX€Tpmg Tivag efx^f^aaeig
^e^eiyfxeOa, tov

en avTatg

etiieiv

TeXeiwg Xoyov ovk eyovTeg' tov

yap XyjaTov
Tuv
Kai
rjXoov

TOiavTVjV TriaTiv €Tti^€i^afX€voVf Kai tov fxev

aXXovg
X^^Tpag

KaTacftpovvjaavTog, npoaTreTrepovi^TO

yap Ta ^vX^

iro^^ag,

Kai

Ta

ev

noah

aiiavTa

vz€p(3dvTog, Tipog ^e
tvjv

Tafio

fxeXXovaag dvaiTTepooBevTog eXnttag, Kai Kpd^avTog
Kai
vTrep

e^aiaiov

avBpaiiov

€K€ivy]v

(pavvjv
6 toJv

"

ft.v^aSyjTi

fxov,

Kvpte, otuv

"

eX^-fjg €V Tri

(3aaiXeia aov,"

yjfxeTepm ^iavotwv e^eTaaTyjg
fxeyaXoTrpeiieg t€ Kat

aKpiPyjg, TVjg iriaT^cog avTOv Bavfxdaag to
vxpyjXov,
XovTCtiv

€K Tav avTtKa fxdXa eaofxevccv Trpog t^v eXTti^a Tav fxeX- 15

avTOV e/3f/3a/»<r€v

eiTroov,

"

ayjfxepov
(f^yjatv,

fxeT
01

efxov

ear]

ev toj

" Trapa^etaa."
€fX€,
Ttept
rj

Oi

fxev

yap dXXoi,

irtaTevaavTeg eig
^ia tovtoov tov
toov efxav

afjfxetav

Ka) ^i^^aaKaXiag dTtYjXavaav, Kat
ovTog Se
fxyj^ev

(SaatXeiag Xoyov e^e^avTO'
fiiy]

aKovaag

Beaadfxevog, el

tov aTtfxtoiTaTov
erpOey^aTO,

BdvaTOV tov aTavpov, to 20
fxov,

yevvahv eKeho

prjfxa

"

fXv^aBi^Ti

Kvpie, OTav

"

eXBrig

ev

Trj

^aatXeia aov^

T/

ovv

;

eyeTca Tecog Trjv ev
TiiaTecog'

tw

TTapa^^eiaoo

Tpv(f)rjv

T^g otKeiag eveyvpov
eig

Tev^eTai yap
fxvrjfxrjg

Kat

TYjg

(BaaiXeiag

vaTepov,

ev

y yeveaBai avTov

rjl^tooae'

Kat ooanep vtK-^<popov elaeXavvoov etg noXtv t» Xafxiipa twv 25

Xa(f>vpoov €TiiKOfxi^€Tai,

nepKpaveaTepav ^id tovtoov
ovTca

ttjv v;^i;v irotoov,

Kai avaKrjpvTTCov to Tponaiov

Kat

i\.vptog eiaeXavvccv eig

T^v dpy^aiav tov dvOpdoiiov TiaaTa^a, tov Tiapdoetaov Xeyoo, tov
XrjaTYjv
tSov
**

€7i€(p€p€T0,

TiavoTiXiag

dtidarig

aefxvQTepov Xa(f)vpov,

Kat

tov ^ta^oXov aKvXoov, to KpdTiaTov epyco ^rjXm, ccaTiep eXeyev, 30
'^•^aag

ag

tov la^/ypov to. aKevi^ avTov Trjg oiKtag Of^pTiaaev.'^
eceg

"OTt Se ^v copa eKTrj Kat aKOTog eyeveTo,
eypdcprj etg to

e^envevae, npo-

KaTa MaT^arov.
6

OTiep

eiTiev

^eaTiOTYjg
^

'K.piaTog, OTt

*'

OTav

vxpccQoo,

navTag

Leg.

xupioy.

XXIV.
**

13-

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
€[Ji.avrov,^^

171 Hp^aTo

ekKvaoo

Ttpo^

epyois

tovto

Tre-akrjpaiTai.
ev

yap

aayi^veveiv

TroXXovg eis

eTriyvaaiv akrfieiaq
t^cov

tw <TTavp£
rov

virapyaiv, oGiv Kai o'

kKarovTapypg
to,
(XTrfiti

tcc yevofxeva, (.^o^a^e

Qeov'
fjievoi

eTVTTTOv ^e

Kai

tSv lov^aiav Tiveg KaravvTTO0[/.{Jt.a<7tv

iiavTwg Kat tois tyjs ^iavoiai

avajSkeTTOVTe^ "^P^i S
'^ea-TtOTVjv

eTtiyvwfTiv T»;v 6/V Xp/(TTOV,

Taya

itov
tSov

t^? Kar avTOV tov
aTavpQxrdvTCov
y]yovfji.evQ}v

^vaaePeiag «TraAAaTTO/xevo/, t^s
PowvTe$,
et

roXfXifjg

Kara-

Kat

fjirj

efjicftavai

^ia Tr]v twv

avoaiOTvjTa.

KE4».
Uepl
TTJs
alTT)<Te<ji>s

nA.
lO
•rjft.cov

tov (TafiaTos tov Kvpiov.

50

Uep} Tov

'l(o<Ty](f>,

iras

edaipe

to (TWfxa tov Kvpiov
irepi

kui

Qeoi) Kat YiWTrjpog \yi<tov
Koiv,

^ptaToVj Kat

Tav

f/.vpo(popa)v

yvvatetg to

Kai

irep)

t^^ ava<TTd<Teag rov ^e<ntOTOV, Ttpoeypdtpvj

KaTa ^aTQatov.

KE^. nB.
Hepi Tov KXeoTTa,

15

^3

'Eitei^-^Ttep 01 eig tvjv KWfxvjv 'Efji.fi.aovg fjiaOvjTat itopevofj.evoi, (og

ovKeTi ^yjv Tov ^piarov Ttpo^T^oKCtiVTeg, Ttepi avTov itpog akXfjXovg
dviufJievot ^te\eyovTo'
**

tovto yap

^yjXoT,

(mep

eiTtov, OTt

"

y)fJ.e'ig

^e

yjkitt^Ofiev," ^ta TOVTO avTOg e^TttaTag avToig, avovjTovg Kat
Kap^^iix,

Ppa- 20

^eig Tyj
Ttpog

KaXe7, e^eyetpcov avTovg tta tovtov

KaTa ^po.yy
(pyjfJiVjv

T^v

Tr^g

dva<TTdae<ag itKTTtv.

Et yap Kat

tvjv

TVjg

dva(TTd<Te<og eiitov eKeivot t*;v ^ia tov
oyj^
**

UeTpov Kai
(pv]<Ttv,

lcodvvov,
**

dkX

«f

Ttt(TTevovTeg tovto eXeyov.

A<o Kat

OTt

e^e<TTy]<Tav
(j)coTt<TfJi.ov

y]fi.dg

at yvvaiKeg," ovk

evayyeXtctfjiOv aXv]6etag

Kai

25

TOVTO
(Twv

vofn-i^ovTeg,

dw'

a>g

eK Tapa^^g Tivog Kat (pavTacTiag elitov-

avTuv Ta
Kat

itepi rvjg dva(TTd<T€cog,

Kat

tvjv

avTOv ye tov rieT^ou
eitt

fJLapTvptav

tov 'lcodvvov,

to,

oQovta fJ.ova

tov

fJLV^fiuiTog

ecopaKOTcov, ovk d\i^6ovg dva<TTd<Tecog TeKfuvjptov vitekdfx^avov tovto,

ort
**

ff.y]

avTOv
(Tvv

t^eiv
eitt

eXeyov " Kai' ydp
TO
fj.vr]fj.e'iov,

(f>v]<Ttv,

"

dTtv]X6ov

Tiveg

30

Twv

vjfJ.h

Kat

evpov

ovtco, Kadcog Kat
Tvjg

at

**

yvvaiKeg

eiitov,

avTOV
avToi/g

te

ovk

eJ^ov."

avTog ^e

TotavTVjg

d-TttiTTtag

Te\eicog

e\ev6epco<Tat

l3ov\ofJt.evog,

dvefj.ifj.vv^TKe

Twv TtaXaicov

Ttpoppvfaecov, itapdycov

eig fi.apTvpiav

Mwcrca Te Kat

z %

172
Toiis

EPMHNEIA TOT KATA
Trpo^Yirag^ epixi^vevcov
a<7a(j)ri

XXIV. 36.
Kai ra 7rpo$ rov^
^e
reco^

ra

eTriKeKpvfJifxeva,
a-a<py}vi^(cv.
[xrj

ava^iovi

roHq

a^ioi^

'Einei^v)

"

oi

"

0(f)6aX[A0i

avjm

eKparovvro rov

cTriyvavai

avrov"

(ag (f>vj(riv

Et^ayyeA^cTT^f, ewg ov 6 Xoyo^ rvjg rov Har^pog ^i^aaKaXiaf

eiaeXdav elg ras Kaptia^ avrcov, evTrapateKrov r^v itiariv eipya^S
craro,
oxpiv

ore

Xoiirov

eiticrrevdav roHg

Koyoig
ov
[Ji.vjv

avrov, rore Kai
(j-vixTrapaixevei'

riqv

e/Ji(pavyj

Ka6i(rrv)aiv

avro7g'

" Kai
yap

avro^
fxera
oia
rv]v

yap

^vjatv,

a(pavrog eyevero air avrcov

ovKeri

avaara(7iv ra rov J^vpiov itpog

rovg fxaQvjrai rotavra
eTtav^vj^rcoaiv.

ra

Ttporepov, oircos eK rovrov irXetovcos rov Ttodov
rv]

10

" Avaaravrei ^e avrvj

copa VTtearpetpav
rvj

elg 'lepov(7a\v]fx," Kai
vi

ra

e^vjg'

rovreartv, ev avrvj [xev
"heaTtori^g

copa ev

a(pavrog ait avrav
fiXexpavrei.

eyevero
avrvj &€

Xp/o-rof,

vitearpexpav

[mvj

ovk

T^

copa evpov avwiQpotafxevovs rovg ev^heKa, Kai
Ivjaovv,

aitYjyyei-

Aav Ta AfaTa rov Kvptov
eiKog
-^v

aWa

fj.era

rtvag copag,

oaagi^

avrovg
ev

Ttoivjaat

ro

'ttdarvjfKa

rwv e^vjKovra^ ara^icov
co<p6vj

j3a^ii^ovrag,
*'

aig

itd.vrcog

Kat
rvj

^eaitorvjg

rco

^tft.covtf

avroi ^e e^vjyovvro ra ev

o^Z, Kai

cag eyvcoaSv]

avroig ev

ryj

KAaaei rov aprov.

36
"

" TavTa
avTCov,^'

Se," (pvjai,

"

XaXovvrcov avrcoVy avrog earvi ev fAeaco 20

Kai

ra

e^vjg,

ovKert Kparovfxevcov rwv 0(f>6aXfxm avrwv
cog

ettecpatvero
eft.(pavv]

avrotg, ov^e

Ttepi

erepov ^taXeyerai, aXX^ eavrov
01

'^i^coat,

Ka\ Sappetv
^e^toreg,
cog

ttapaKeXeverai.
vofxi^etv

^e

ovrcog

vjaav

aff.(ptl3oXoi

Kat

ovk avrov

/SXeTteiv, (pav-

raafxa ^e

rt Kat aKtav.

Avrog

^e Kat eK rcov rotovrcov Xoytafxcov 25

Karevvd^ctiv avrovg ro
pvjfxa, eiTtcbv,

evrpt(3eg avroig Kat ovk avfieg aTte^pQeyyero
tva Be ^ejBaicog Kat ev^oiaafxov

"

elp-^vv} vfitv'^'

^/%a

Tttarevacoatv, avrov cKetvov eivai rov TteitovBora, tta^eiKvvatv evGiig,
ort
rcov
<t
'

Seog
"

m

(pvaet, ytvaaKet

ra KpvTtra

rvjg

Kapoiag, rov ev avroig

evvotcov
^
^

ovk vjyvoet Bopv^ov.
^

^vjai yap

"

ri

rerapayfxevoi 30

€<XTe,

Kat ra

'}:~

egvjg.

39

AeiKvvat ^e rag '/etpag Kai rovg ito^ag Kat rag ^iarpvjaetg
rcov vjXcov, Koi xpvjXacpav eittrpeTtet,

Kai vXvjpo^popetadat ^ta rpoitov

rivog," ort

ro TteitovBog eyvjyepro aa>fxa.
^ fKctTov efijKOJ-Ta

Ato

fi(.v]^etg

avKO^pav-

Cod.

5

XXIV. 51.
TeiTOO
Trjv
Koivrjv

AOTKAN ETArrEAIOT.
yi}uv}v

173
tov
avOpocTrivov
(xSifJM

ava,<7TaaiVf

akXa

"Jrepi

crwfjiaTOi aKovcDV,

"
fAvj

OTi

(TireipeTai (7a[j.a xpv^^iKov, lyeiptTai

"

TrvfvfxaTiKQVf^

ajrapvyjcrriTai

twv avSpaTrivwv aafJuxTav t^v

eif a<p6apaiav ava^pofx-^v'

(eanep yap xpv^iKOV €(7Ti to Ta7$ t/^u^^-

Kaii, Yjyow (TapKiKatg

eTriOvff.iaig

aKoXovBovv, ovtco Kai TrvevfJia-^

TiKOv TO ToTf Tov 'Ayiov Ilvef/txaTO? QeXvjfJiaaiv vTroKeifxevov.

McTa
Avto

yap

Tvjv

€K veKpSov ava(TTa(nv qvk €(ttiv ert (f>iko<TapKia$ Kaipog,
a.7rpaKT-^(T€i Tvji

aXXa

iravTeXiog

afxapTiag

to

KevTpov.

IxevToi TO

KaTeveyBev

eU t^v

-y^v TY}i a(f)Bapaiag ev^^vaeTai.
irepl

42

Xp^

§e

aKOTT^aai ^ia iroaoiv Tovg Itiovg /xafli^Taf
^eairoTyjg 'Kpiarog eTriaTcoaaTO'
/oie,

t^? 10
fj.€V

avTOv avaaTaa€(ag
^ia Tov eiveiVj
**

"TrpSoTOV

xf^vjXacf^-^aaTe

Kat i^eTe oti

irvevfj.a

aapKa

Kai oaTea ovk eyet, Kauoog

efj.€

oecopeiTe

e^ovTa

OevTepov ota

to v7ro^e7^at avToTg Tag %e7pag Kat Tovg Tro^ag, TpiTov, ^/a to
eTrt^YiTYjaat l3pcoatfi.ov ti

Kat ^ayeiv
yj

evcoTrtov

avTcov,

vj

Kai

^t

oiihev 1

€T€pov Tt TovTO TreTroft^Kev,

tva

&e/|'>j

aa(f>cog,

ag avTog eaTt

6

avaaTag

eK

veKpav,

og

irpo

tov

aTavpov Kai irapa Travra tov

Katpov Tr^g oiKOVOf/.iag avvea$icov Kai avfj.Trtvm avToltg, Kat avvavaaTpe<f)Ofj.evog
avQpcoitivcog'

ov^e yapi wg ^ecfxevrjg cti

Tpo(f>ijg

T^g

aapKog avTOv,

etfjaye fj.eTa t>jv

avaaTaatv.
avvtevat

ao
Tag
trept

45

E/Ta

ttavoi^ag avTcov tqu vovv tov
OTt

avTov
eirt

Xeyovaag ypa<pag,
Tco

^ei^ TravTa

TrXrjpcoWfjvat

Kat Ki^pv)(6^vat

ovofxaTt

aiiTov fj.€Tavotav Kat
**

a(f>€atv <xfj.apTtcoVf

" KaOtaaTe"
ov

irpoaTa^ag avToTg,
**

ev

Trf iroXet 'lepovaaKrjfj., ecog

IvtvariaBe

tvvafj.tv e^ vxpovgy"

e^ayayav avTovg

ecog Trpog B>j5aviav, eirapag rjfJMg

25

Tag yeTpag, evXoyrjaev avTOvg.
fj.

tovto Se 5^>? voeiv

ev

t^

rjfJ-epa.

t^ fneTa

Trjv

avaaTaatv yeyovevat, Kara tq
"^A

ev

Ta7g

Ylpa^eatv
€tprfKaat,

iaTopr]fj.€vov.

yap

eiriTefJ.QVTeg

01

KiiayyeXtaTat

TavTa

to)

TrXaTet TVjg laTopiag e^aTrXovrai Kat aacfjrf-

vt^erat.

30

51

YiiiXoyriaag Se avTovg, Kai

^payy

irpoeXBwv, av€(f>€peTO eig tov
fj.€Ta Trjg evcoOeiarjg

ovpavov, tva avve^pog

etrj

tw YlaTpt, Kat

avTW

aapKog Kat TavTrjv
yeyovcag

•^fj.iv

eveKatvtae tvjv o^qv ev

avQpcoTreta
ev
t-j^

f>.op<fy^

Aoyog.

tiQet de, rjqet

KaTa Katpovg

ooqr}

tov

b

^

Cod.

174
YlaTpoi
eavTOV.

EPMHNEIA
[xeTo,

T. K.

AOTKAN ETArrEATOT.
/xefl'

TMV dytav AyyeKav, kui TrapaK-^xpeTat ^[xas

Ao^oKoy^fTCOfxev Totvvv avTOv tov havBpdm-rj^xavTa

'hi

yjfxa^

Qeov

Aoyov, Tov eKOvatcog itaBovTa aapKt, Kat avaiTavTa ck veKpwv, Kat

XvaavTa t\v (pdopaV tov

ava\y](f)6evTa, Kai fxeTa

tovto vj^ovTaS

[X€Ta ^o^rji TTokXvji eni to Kphat ^avTas Kat veKpovg, Kat anoZovvai

€KaaTW KaTa Ta epya avTov'
7}

ht

ov Kat fxeG^ ov,

tw Oew

Ka) TlaTpt

"^o^a

Kat to

KpaTog, avv tw
Afx-^v.

Uavayiw

YlvevfxaTi,

€1$ Toi/i alicvag

tuv atuvm.

^^TtX^qpaQYj
Ofxov

yj

epixrjveta

tov Kora AovKav ayiov EivayyekioV lo

Ketpakata

SN.

C A T E N A
IN

EVANGELIUM

S.

JOANNIS,

E CODD. PARIS. ET BODL.

TOT KATA rOANNHN ETAITEAIOT TA KE^AAAIA^

OL.
/3'.

rTegi ToD Iv

Kava

yaix,ov.

Usp) TWV
Hsp)

lx/3A>jSevTc«v Ix

ToO lipou.

y'.
S'.

Njxo8i5jM,ou.

Z.fiTri<ris TTsp) xa$apt(j-[j.ov.

e

.

Ylsp) T>jc Saju.a^EiT/8oj.

S"'.

riep» Tou /Sao-»X»xou.
X)]' £T)J
e'

^. rispi TOU
1}
.

^OVTOJ

Iv

Tp

ao"06vs»'a.

Ils^i ToJv

apTcov xa) rcSv ^' l^66aov,

Q'.

YIsp) Tou Iv daX«<r(rp •nspitca.TOv.
riepi Tou Ix yeveT^f to^Xou.

i'.

»«'.

Ilepi

Aa^apou.

»/3'.

Ilepi Tijj aXei\f/ao-)jj tov Kupiov /xupo).

»y'.
»S'.

Ilep» eSv elwev 'louSaj.
Ilep» toO ovou.
risp» Toov 7rpo<re\$6vTCttv 'EXXijvwv.

»e'.

If'.

Ilep» T05 ViTTTT^pOS.

i^.
Dj'. »S

Ilep Tou

irapax.\riTov.

Ilep» ah^a-eoos too K.vpiaHOU <raj«,aTOf.
Ilepi

.

T%

«v«(rTaa"e«>j.

& Hsec e Cod. L.

sumpta sunt.

Aa

EPMHNEIA
EI2

TO KATA IQANNHN EYArrEAION.

ToT AnOT lOANNOT TOT XpTSOSTOMOT EPMHNEIA
KATA
IflANNHN ETArrEAION.
to,

EI2 TO
€fI.€W€

E/

fX€V

'iwdvVVjf
vjv

YJlMV

^taXeyeaBai Kai
Kai TraTpi ^a

avTov

epcTv,

avayKaiov
eirei'^-)^

koi yevoi, avTOv

eiircTv

Kai avaTpocp-^v.

^e ovp^ ovTog,
dvai^ifjTeTv.

«AX

o 5

0€Of

di

avTov (pGeyyeTaif irepiTTOV eaTi TOVTa
jtxev

caTt

^e TtaTpihog

yiTot

Kaixvjt;

evTeXovs' cmo ^rfiQai^a royf VakiTrevTjTOf*

Kata^' TiaTpog ^e dXieiog Kai
ofS ot;ovv
t^tcoTVji
vjv,

Trai^^eiag

Se

T^g (s^aSev

avToo /x.eT^v*

Kat yovv [xapTvpe7 AovKag OTt ov fxovov
dypdiKiJ.aTog.

d\Xa

Kat

OvTOt;

6

aAzeyj-

o

diio

lo

Bij6a"ai'§a TVjg

TaXtXaiag,

6 TraTpog dXieccgf 6 t^txTVjg idtcoTiav tvjv [xa9(hvj
[xvjTe

eayaTviv,
fj.€Ta

o

ypdfKfxaTa

fKVj

TipoTepov

fAVjB

vaTepov,

To avyyeveaBai Xpiorct?, TavTVjv cpBeyyeTat

tvjv (jvyypa(j)rjv. tvjv etg

'ETre/^Tj

yap fxeTa tov tov ^aTVjpog
dvo^ov,
ipev^^o^i^^daKaXot

vjft.av

aTavpov Kai
tov

ovpavovg

Ttveg ecpaaav

dittov

roS 15

0eov Aoyov Tore "npwiov KeKXvjaOat TiaTpog vnap^tv, ot€ Kat dvSpoonog ^id TVjg dyiag
eTey(6v]

TrapSevoV

avvaySevTeg twv TitaTevdcpiKovTO
ff.a6v]TV]v

advTCov
lcodvvvjv

01

vovvey^eaTepot, Ttpog tov tov HccTv/pog

Tov Tov Zie(3e^aiov, Kai tv]v TotavTV]v a7rv]yyeXXov voaoV
eTTi tv]v

og TovTO dKovaag, evQewg

tov irapovTog e^paf^e avyypa(pv]v, 20

dvaTpeTKOV

tvjv

t»v

^pev^^o^^i^^aaKdXcov tpev^^o^o^iav.

'Epothsis.

Tivog

eve.va

tcSv

dXXwv KvayyeXtarSov dno
TovTa

TVjg

oiKovoft.iag dp^afxevxv, tovto fxev ev (Spay^e^ f/LeTa
etTTCOv,

vjvi^aTO

Kai

Aoyog aapg eyeveTo,
tov tokov, tv]v
v]fi.7v

Ta

6e

aAAa

TravTa irapatv]v

^pafi.u)v,

TV]v avXXv]xptv,

dvaTpo(f)v]v,

av^v]atv, 25

evQecog Tiept

t^? at^iov yevv^aecog

^taXeyeTat

;

AnoKPisis.
AfaToc

'ETre/^^ 0/ aAAo; Eya-yyeA^o-Ta/ to TrAeTov ev

Tor«-

adpKa

'BiaTpixpavTeg

Xoyotg, ^eog

vjv

TioXXovg yaft.atTieTe7g

1. 1.

EPMHN. EIS TO KATA
fxy]^€V

mANNHN

ETAF,

179
Trepi

ovTa?,

inl/i]XoT€pov

twv avSpwTroi^ irpoaovTmv hvoyjcrai

rov fj.ovoyevovi T/ou tou ©eoD* tia touto c/fe/va irapa^paixibv airo

T^f VTiap^eag
yivwaKeiv'

tv)(;

aihiov Ttounai TrjV ^i-^yi^aiv.

^py}

^e.

Kai tovto
a(f)€i$

oti ovt€ ouTOf irpoi tov vxpYjXoTepov cavTOv
^/x.eAT^ce,
TTpo

Xoyov

Trjg oiKovofxiag

ouTe €K€ivoi Trepi t^v TauT*;^ €(77rov^a-$

KOT€f h-^vjaiv, T^v
Tus'
i

aiwvwv liriyr^aav vTrap^iV Kai fxdXa €iko-

€V

yap

vjv

Ilvey^a to kivovv Ta? anrdvTWV ^^vyag.
Tjv

'Ez/

oLp-^^rj

6 Aoyos".
ay^veaXoyr]-

IwdvvYjg

TOv y€V€aXoyovfJi€Vov aiWTrwVf avo tov
Ttpkii^i

Tcu apy€Tai.
jtxiyTe

yap

tov

6€oXoyovfX€vov

Tlov
Tig

tou

@€ov io

y€V€aXoy€7<76aif
TT^ipd^^a^Oar
<f>afii€v

"

Trjv

yap y€V€av avTOv

tirjyrja^Tai ;"

fj.riT€

0eov yap tid^oXog
Xvovt€$ tov ^]y]aovv
irpdyfJ.aTa

7r€ipd^€iv
diro

ov

^vvaTai.

TovTo ^e
KvvvT€S
hc

ov

tov X.piaT0Vf ^€iX.piaTOv.

^e

Ta

€Trivoovfx.€va

kiri

Yrj^xov

tov
f*.y]

vovv Tov

yipoK^ifxkvov

E,vayy€XiO'j ov^€i<;
<7t^9o^

^vvaTai Xa{3€iv,
t>?v

i^

avaireawv

ctt/

to tov

lijaou

Kai

Xa^wv
Ka6wq

liqaov fxr]-

T€pa

M^apiav aito
Q€ Tov

rov

Xr^oov

fj.r]T€pay

^Xwdvvr^g.
;

T<

or(noT€

YiaT€pa
rjv

d(f)€i<; 7r€p)

tou T/ou ^taXeyeTai
fi.y]

eTre/^»?

€K€7vog fA€v l^Xoi
6 0€ fJ.ovoy€vy]g

airaaiv, e/ Kai

wg riaT^p, dXX w$ ©eo^.
tvjv Trep)

yjyvo€tTC'

€ikotw$ toivvv

tovtov yvwdiv 2o

€v6€wg €K

irpootfnioiv

eaweucTe S^ivai ToTg ovk el^ocriv avTOV, dXX.

waT€

oiO€ Tovg dvBpwTrovg

to Trp€<7^vT€pov Ka) irpwTov fj.dXiaTa
'^ta

TtfJMVTag Kai Tt6€fj.(vovs ©eov, Kal
ofj.(i}g

tovto evTeufiev apy^^Tai'
**

ovQ€ Tov TlaTcpa ev tovtois dTr^atwTryjacv'

fv apj^^

y]v

6

" Aoyo«-."
laov ovvaTai tov ev dpyyj to
y]V,
y]v'

25
et

yap

ev dp^xyj

y]v,

sroTe ovk
fj.r]

Kai Qta tovto de

<py](7iv

Aoyog Kai
aoi
y]

ovy^

Tiog, tva

T17

7tpoay]yopta tov
Trap
y]fj.iv

Ttov

€t<7€X6r]

tov Trd6ovg cvvota,

€7r€i^y] to.

y^vvavTa yjpovw y€vva kou
VTroXy]y\/€i(;

€fj.7ra6wg, 7rpo^top6ovft.€vo$

Ta?

a7rp€7r€7g

ovtw

(f)yjai.

Aoyog

^e CKX-^^r], iva ^€1^(6^ OTt

30

€K Tov vov

^rpor^y^r],
rjv 6

Kat oti d7ra6cag

€y€vvr]6rj.
;

" Ev

apyri

Aoyos"

€i^€g Trapprjaiav Kai €^ovaiav 7roXX^v

TrZi ov^€v afufjif^dXXwv ov^e €iKd^av,
<f>6€yy€Tai.

dXXd

irdvTa d7ro(f>aivoff.€Vog

To "

ev apyjf] y]v" €Trt(Jvvy]fj.fj.€vov 7rpoaK€ifj.€Vov

T€ cv-

^€vog €T€pov, dnoXvTov Tiva Kat d7r€ptQpi(7Tov '^€tKVvat TYjv dpyyfv.

^^

Aa

2

180
10 0€
yjv

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
ovhev erepov ta-Tiv

I. 4-

«aa

yj

tov eivai
iva
[jlv]

an

OYjAdTiKov

KOLi aTreipcog eivai.

Aoyov ^e avTOV eKoiXeaev,

TiaSyjTvjv

avTov

rvjv

yeveatv viro\aj3a}{X€v' eri ^e Kai ^ia to aTrayyeiXai YjfMV ra tou
ovy^ dirXiog ^e

X\v€vu.aTog.

avTOv Aoyov iKaXiatv,
rSov

dXXa

fxera t^?
ev

rov dpdpov
Xoopiay].

TTpocrdYjKi^i, oirag

Xonrav avrov Xoycov Kai

rovra)^

TToXXo)

ydp

oi

Toy Seov Xoyot,
^Kev

dXX

ov^etg eKetvav

rwv

Xoy(ov

Qeog'

dXX
^e

eKe7voi
o

aitavreq Ttpo^^qrelat

Kat

tt^oo"-

rdy^ara, ovrog
TipoeXBovaa

Aoyog ovaia rtg evvirodTarog e^ avrov
e/Vwv ovv ort Kai " ©eojrpt

diiraOioi

tou Ylarpog.
ri

o

" Aoyof," ovK
ovx ^TTov @eo$

efxcf^aivet

[xeaov

r^g

Beorvjrog

ravTrji, eTcet^yjio

6

Tiog'

einev ovv

ro yvooptartKOv rrjg yvrjata^
ev apyri
i^v

avTov deorv)TO$ Kai ro aibtov, bta rov
^tov
eve(pi^vev
[xrj

w

'^^

^^ (Tvvai-

yjiuv

^td

rov "

ouTOf

ev

dpyri Tpof tov 0eov."
viiap^tv Toy

Tovreart

voixtarjg
riv

Tipea^vrepav
irore

eivai, <f)V]a], rrjv

Ylarpog' ov ydp

eprifxog
[xy]

rov

AoyoV

el te

Xeyct rtg, Kat 15

•nag eartv Tiov ovra

vearepov eivat rov Ylarpog'
;

ro ydp (k
eKeivo epov"
rrjg

rtvog ov avayKrj
fxeVf

Ttdv

varepov eivat rov e^ ov eartv
r/Xiov

dpa ro dTravyaafxa rov
[xr}

e^ avrrjg
rrjg

eKTiri^av
rjXiaK-l^g

rov
;

rjXiov (f>vaea}g,

varepov eivat

(paivjfxev

aKrmg

ov^afxwg'

dvdyKrj

ydp
ov^e

ofxoXoyvjaat

rovro

Kai

rov rag
r^Xtog

ataSvj- 20
e(f)avr}

aetg TieTiripuixevov'
TTore'

yap

X^optg aTravydafxarog

t^ov

Kat e^ avrov Kai

ov^ varepov avrov' ovra Kai
[xdXXov ^e Kat
[xei^ovitig

em
Kat

rov

Warpog Kat rov T/ou
^td

vo-^accfxeVf
6

BeoTrpeTrSog'

ydp rovro Kai

TlavXog avrov ovrag eKaXeatv.
rvjv

ETrei^vj 6

M.ci}varjg

eAaj^/crTov [/.epog

Kriaeag «TroAa/Swv, 25

ov^ev ri[xh rrep)

rm

dopdrm

'hteX(y6ri '^vvdfi.em, eiKorcog

Evay^t

yeXiarrig

ev)

^payet

pr}[xart

oXa irepiXa/Bm

(f>v]ai'

" TravTa

avTov eyeverOj nai yjapig avrov eyevero ovbe
rovreart,

ev,

yeyovey

rm

yevv]Tm, Kav oparov
^vvd[t,(Q}g

r],

Kav

vor^rov, ovtev yjaptg rrjg

rov ^ptarov

eig

ro
oi/^e

eivai

Trap-^yQi^'

reXeiav aTty[xr]V etg ro
Kovg'
eKeivot

"

ev" e-^tB-^aufnev

^^ y^P ^^ TIJV30 Kard rovg atpert^<w^ ^v," /3ot/-

ydp

ovrci} (f>aaiv,

"

b yeyovev ev avrio

Xo[xevot TO Y\vev[xa ro 'Aytov Krta[xa Xeyeiv.

4

'¥iv

avTW

^(orf

rjv,

kcu

t)

^(ot}

rjv

to

00)$'

twp av35

OpCOTTWV.

1. 6.

mANNHN
tva

ETArrEAION.

181
t^^ vpovoia^

E/wwv vept T^f
Xoyov.
S/

^yifxtovpyiai^ lirayit Kai tov vept
to,

yap

/xyj^e/V airi(7Tyj, Trccs
**

ToaavTa Kat TrjXiKavTa
^ccy]

avTOv yeyovev, eirvjyayev,

OTt

ev

avTw

tjv" TOVTeaTiv,

OTt ev

avTa

^yj

ra

Travra, Kat ev

avTa

TrpovoeiTaif Kat OTrep Trep) tov
ev avTco 5

Ilarpof
**

e'ipifjTatf

Kat

itept

avTov Kvpico$ av XeyotTO, " OTt
eafJLevJ'^
yj

^iofxev,

Kat KivovfJLeQa, Kai
eTtayofxevov,

To

^e

"

Kat

^ayfi yjV

to

(f)(o$

twv avQpUTravJ'* ov
(f^aTii^av avT-^v.
*'

TOtovTov aiaGrjTOv <p(ag ^v,

aXXa

votjtov, ttjv

xpvy^v

Kat ovK

etTte,

to

(pais

twv

lov^aiccv,
[j.ovov,

aXAa KaQokov

tc5v av$pco-

"

ircov"

oi/^e

yap

lou^aro;

a\Xa Kat EAAiyve?

Trpos TavTi^v

lo

lyAdov Tvyv yvaa-tv.

5

Kai To

(f)(09

eV

Tjj

arKoria ^alvei.

^aivet ^e to ipag to voyjTOv tovto ev t^ aKOTia' (TKOTiav Xeyei
yj

Tov BavoTOV

vj

Tfjv TrXdvyjV

to yap KyjpvyfJia fieTO^v tvjs iiXdvyig

eXaiJi,\pe,

Kat cv tw BavdTcp Se yevdfxevos avTOi, ovtw? ayTOy itepi- 15

e-yevcTO,

ag Kat tov^
7]

^^»j irpoKaTeyofi.evovg

dvayayelv.

Kai

(TKOTia avTO ov KaTeXa^ev.
SdvaTo^ avTov
ovk
ef/.(f)t-

H

(TKOTta &e avTO ov KaTeXafBev, cTre;^^ oyTe
yj

TiepteyeveTo, ovTe
Xoyjtjpel Oe Talq

TrXdvy]'

eaTt yap aKaTaywvKXTOV.
(f)60Ti<j6yjvat

fjcr^

^ovXofkevatg

xpv/aTg'

ov^e

yap 20

avayKVj Kat I3ia,

dXXa

^ovX-^aet Kat

yvafjiy]

itpoadyeTat

yjfxTv 6

Beof.

6

'Eyei/ero

avOpmros
yjfMv
eitt

arrecrTaXfievof irapa Geou.
Ttept

AiaXeyOetq

(yvfXfi.eTpa(

tov Qeov Adyov,

oSco

koi

Taget TrpoPatvcov

tov tov

Aoyov K^pvKa tov

'lcodvvvjv epy^eTat.

25

A/fOvovTe? te OTt irapa Seov diteaTdXy], fxyj^ev Xotitov dvQpd^Tttvov
vofxtaaofxev

eivat

twv Xeyofxevm'
(f)6eyyeTat,
'i^tov

ov
^to

yap
Kat

to.

avTov,

dXXa tov

jtefKxpavTog

a-TtavTa

dyyeXog itpoa-^ydpevTat'
to te " eyeveTo" evTav6a

ayyeXov Se
ov TVji
etg

a^€T>; to fxyj^ev

eltteh'

TO eivat TO yap

itapotov

^yjXcoTiKOv,

dXXa

TVjg

aTrocrToA^f

30

eo"T/v avTiqi'

" eyevcTo diteaTaXfxevoi^ dvri tov diteaTdXy^

etpyjTai.

Iva pLapTvprjarf

irepi

tov ^cotos.
tov
(f>coTog,** ovy^

To

Oe

*'

tva fxapTvpyfayf Ttept

w(

dJ^tditiaTov

182

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
vj

1.6.
QeaTiQryi

rov Tlov Tov 0€oy t^v (pvaiv Tro/^crwv,
e/f a^ia<; Xoyov,
^i

iva

tw

'7rpc<76vj

aXXa
01

'^ta

to eTrayofXfvov, iva TrdvTfg TrtaTevacoct

avTov, T0VTe(7Ti

0[J.O(pv\ot,

avToq yap Qeog

cov

Kai Qeov

yvfjcriog Tlog, Kai T^f ovalag Tyjg aKyjpaTOV Kai fxaKaptag, ov oeT-

Tai^ Tov [xapTvpyiaovTog'

eneiVfi Ve TVjg acoTyjptag

avrw

fxeXei
(og

T^g ^
Kai

Twv TToWaVf TovTov yapiv etg tovto Karepy) raTreivoTy^Togf
dvdpxTTcp TVjv fj.apTvpiav eTrnpexpai tvjv eavTov.

Ata
"

Ti

eiTTtv

"

oiiK

yjv

eKelvog to

(f^ag,

dXX

iva

(xaprvpyjay

Trepi Tov (fxtiTog ;"

ag t»
fxyj

mkXa
Tig Kai

Ta

p^^fxaTa, ixet^aiv o [xapTvpwv

Tov fxapTvpovfi.evoVf iva

eiit

tov ladvvou tovto
(pyjat.

voft-KJy},

lo

T>;v irovyipav TavryjV VTToxpiav

avaipm tovto

Ktpiaaot.
KaTairXyj^ag
eig

OvTog

o

eK Qeov dneaTaXfxevog 6 Ttaaav eiKOTCog
t-^

tvjv

lov^atav,

tc

tov (3iov

aef».V0TrjTt

Kat Ta7g

aaKyjatv vTrepjSoXaigf 6 ^td (poov^g dyiag TrpoffyyjTav TrpoKyjpvT15

TOfxevog.

i^MMaNior nPESBTTEPOT.
^•^Tm
ovTog ^e
y]Xde,
lctidvvyjg,

Atd TovTO
fxev

fxei^av Twv

dXXm

itpo-

oti

eKemt

eKVjpv^av
'^td

tov

Trpoa^^oKoof/.evoVf

eapaKwg avTOv, Kat

iretaSetg

ayifxetuv OTt ovTog ^yj

fxapTvpm e^
'

m yiKovae
e(f>

kou et^ev.
^tjAovot;,
e*'

iipirENOTS.

Oaov
et

eavTW
irdvTeg

Koi

fxyj

irdvTeg ent- 20

aTevaav' ovt\ ydp
(pcoTtafxov,
yj^yj

fxyi

tov irapd
Ttg av

tov yjXiov teyotVTO

Kai tov vjXtov

(paiyj
y]

fxy}

em

tovto dvareX-

XetVf

e(f>

wTe irdvTag (pxTt^ea6at'

ydp

TrpoGeatg tov 7Teft.\pavT0g

avTov ^v irtaTevaat irdvTag.

Ktpiaaot 'Aaehanapeias.
e^ei

^A-TreaTdXGat
ryjv

(f^yja}

Trapd Qeov' 25

yap ovk avrofxoXov
tovra
oetKvvetv

irpog

virep

tov 'EcoT^pog yjfxm fxap-

Tvptag

tov

aytov

[3airTtaTyiv,
fxot

dXXd

To7g

tov

Ylarpog vTryjpeTOvvra GeXrjfxaat'
ev TovTOig

^OKeT ^e

Xiav y]a(f)aXtafxevog
etTreiVf

EivayyeXtaryjg, ofj^ dirXag, ort yeyovev,
*'

dXXa

Kat ^ta Tov TrpoaQeTvat, Kat

dvSpooTrog,"
fxy)

d^ovXordTm Ttvm ava-30
ovTccg VTrdpyetv tov

Tpeirm

virovotav

twv XeyovTm,

dvQpcairov

f3airTtaTr}V,

aXXa
eK

rm

tov Ylarpog Kat Tiov viri^peTOvvTa GeXyjtS>v

fxaatv^ ag
yevofxevov

rm

ovpavm eva Ttva
'^(jiYiatfxov

dytm ayyeXm

Trapa-

avQpaiTrtvca

accfxart,
Tii

Kat irpog to KyjpvTTetv

^

oii^e

Cod.

1.9.
aviaTa\(xivov

mANNHN
irapa

ETArrEAION.
Se

183
T^f dXvjGeias
yj

SeoZ' onroacpdXXovTeg

oi

Mppoveg' TO yap dyyeXog ovofMa Xenovpyiag fJiaXXov ecTiv

trepi-

ovaiag
etr

(Ti^fJiavTtKOv'

axmep Kai

oi

eiit

tov

Iw^ ayyeXoi, aXkog
Ovkovv ay-

dXXx
o

Tpey^ovci, toc KoXinpoTta KfjpvTTovTeg nddi^.

yeXog

fxaKdpiog (3aTiTi(iT)}g S;a TYjg tov '^eciroTOv KaTCOvofJiaaTat 5

(pav^g, ovK avTog KaTo. (pvaiv AyyeX.og wv,

«AX ug

etg to

ayyeX-

Xeiv aTieaTaX.ixevog, Kai " t>jv otov eTotfud(xaTe Kvpiov" Pouv.

9

'Hj/ to <p(09 ro dXrjOLVov.
Avdycov ^e TrdXiv
tvjv

evvoiav vjfiMV irpog

tvjv

eTieKeiva iraa-vjg
e(f)Vj'

apyvjg vnap^iVf tvjv ov^afxov X.yp/ov(xav ovt\ njTafxevviv,

"

-^^v 1

o

"

TO (pZg TO dXv]9tvov,
rov
KO(Tfxov'^^

(pccTi^et

itdvTa

dvBpoonov
(piOTi^et,

epyoixevov

eig

"

Kat

et

itdvTa
to
fJiev

avQpxnov
etg

TrSog

a(pci)TtaTOt

[xefJiev^Ka(Xi

ToaovTot'

avrov

vjkov

TtdvTag vjXQe (pcoTt-

(rat, ei ^e Tiveg

^KovTeg Tovg o(pGaXfj.ovg T^f ^tavotag fxvaavTeg,
tvjv
i

ovK vjOeXvjaav irapaM^aaSat tov (piOTOg Tag aKTivag, ov iiapa rov (pcoTog (pvatg
vj

5

aKOTi^atg

eKeivvj,

dXXa vapa

tvjv

KaKovpyiav

Tav eKovTt d-noaTepovvTOiV eavrovg

TVjg acoTVjpiag.
'htd

Ktpiaaot.
'TrXeoveKT-^fxara,

'TireiXvjTrTO
uig

ydp irapd rtat
e'ivi

Ta Trpoaovra

avToov

aiiTog

\ptaTog, ^td tovto

(pvjaiv, tv

oXoppt^ov dveXTj tv]v rotavTi^v TrXdvvjv, ^i^XovoTt (pag ^e Kat avTog

20

Kara

fxeToyvjv, (og Kat irdvTeg ot ayiot.

Ammhniot. E<
eKelvot

Kai (pag

Iwdvvvjg

Kat

01

aytot,

aXX ovk
ot

TO OeoXoyovfxevov, og eaTt \piaTog,

(pvaei (pcog'

yap

aytot ydptTt
c^v

eayov tov (pooTtafxoV
TO aXvjdtvov.

^io

irept

tov ILptaTOV

(Pvjaiv,

TO

<p'jog

25
KaXovfxevcov ao(ptag

Ktpiaaot.
riTot

'EiKdaTcov tcov elg tovto eivai

Beoyvcoatag evTtQvjat Kai pi^av efi.(pVTevet avveaecog'

XoytKOV

t€ ovTog diroTeXei to ^wov t^^ oiKetag (pvaecog
Kvvcov,

fxeTO-^^pv diro^et-

Kat

TVjg

d(ppdaTov

XafXTrpoTvjTog

ooairep

Ttvdg

dTfxovg

(pcoToetOeig
(pooTt^et

evtetg to5 vw, Kaff ov

avTog oi^e Tporrov re Kai AoyoV 30
Vri

Totyapovv tvifxtovpyiKwg fxev Tlog, «Te

ro

(pcog virdp-

yjov avTog

to aXvj6ivov,

KaTa
<pSog,

fxeroyv\v Se
etg

17

KTtatg'

Kai

KaXenat

tta TOVTO Kat ytverat
rvjv Tot;

rd
ot

virep

(pvatv dvaKatovaa ^td
irdvTeg 01

^o^daavTog %ap*v ovrcog
fxeToyvjv "^viXovoTt.

AyycAo/ (pxra, Kat

aytoi,

KaTa

35

184

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
To,

I.

lo.

AMMflNior nPESBTTEPor. 'O Kvpios
afxaTa aito ^va^iKwv
evvotSiv

XoyiKa avTov kti((tti

cfxoTi^ei

€1$

to TreiaB^vai oti

@€0$' aToya^o^ivovg ck
iVTa^iag to vTiiipaveyov

Trj^

Tav KTiafxaTm avTov /caAAov^f Kai

t^^' aiiTov ^vva[j.eag.

©EOAflPOT.

EfTTWV

" Tov

ep')(pfx.evov

elg tov ko<Tf/.ov^

Trepi
:^v,"

tov ^

^eairoTov ^piaTov,
^el^ai OTi TO

Kaku>g enyjyaye to " ev tw Koafxo)
repog
tvjv

waTe

"

ep^xofJLevov"
<f>yjai

^ia aapKog
ijv

elite (f^avepaaiv'

T^ yap vTioaTaaei
TCVTOVf Kat
ctig

Kai Tyj (pvaei

ev

tco

KoafAU Kai

trpo
o
tjv

Kat tovtov fxtKpov Ttvog ovTog enriyaye^ " Kai
ei

"
ev

KoafAog &;

avTOv eyeveTO,^ TovTeaTt, Ka\ t/ 6avfxaaT0v
ovk av
vjVf

lo

Tw

Koafx.Q}, og

et fxyj

eKe7vog e^ovX-^QYj

;

" Ev

Tco

Koafxa ^v," oyp^
*'

cog

tov Koafxov avy^^^povog'
"^t

^ta

yap

TQvTO eTTVjyaye,

Kai

6

Koafxog

avTov e^yevero*" TrdvTag yap

eKWV Kat aKcov avayKaaQvjaeTat irag avOpuTrog, kuv voXefi.iog T^f
^o^vjg Tov

Qeov eaTi,

iipo

twv epycav OfKoXoyvjaat tov
ijv

TiotvjT^^v.

15

Ammoniot.

Of Qeog

ev too Koafxw, ov Ka-v

ovaiav^ dXXa,

KaTO. TO TipOVOVlTtKOV.

ToT
eivat

ATTOT. YldXtv avaaetpd^ei

tvjv

aipeaiv Toiv XeyovTuv,
to, Xotird.

fxvf

KTiafxaTa tov Seov Tovg dvSpcoTrovg Kat
&€

10

To

"

Koafxog avTOv ovk eyva)," Koafxog evTavda to

ovjfxSi-

20

'^eg irXvjGog (pvjat,

tov
to.

yy^ahv Kai

Tapayui^Yi Xaov, tov
ot

tw
Toi)

Koafxca

TrpoaviXnfxevov
<f>iXoi

Kat

tov Koafxov (f>povovvTa.
fxeTo.
TVfV ev

yap

Qeov
fxovviv

irdvTeg avTOV eyvccaaVf ov

aapKi avTov

TrapovaiaVf

dXXd Kai

irpo

TavTvjg,
01

ug

6 'AfSpaafx

Kai 6 M.ci)va^g
7rpo<f>^Tat, coj

Kat

Aa/3<&, Kai TrdvTeg
<f>v]ai.

«Tro

tov "ZafxovvjX

25

IleTpog

'ICANNOT TOT XpTSOSTOMOT.
^ta TovTO ae ndXtv

AvT/ TOU TOV eKeiVOV

^eaTrOTYjV,

dvdym

hrt tvjv irpoaimtov vTrap^tv fxovoyevovg'
Trav, olog

ydp aKQvaag

oti epyov

avTov TO^e to

av

elfvj ;

TrdvTcog

yap €Km Kat
Tov TroivjT^^V

aKm

avayKaaSv]aeTat

Trpo

twv epym ofxoXoyvjaai 3°

oSev fxot

Kat Bavfxa^etv eiretatv det t^v IlavAoy tov
Trpog TVfV

"EiafxoaaTectig fxavtav, Troog

ovtco <f>avepav

aXvjOetav avTt-

^Xeipat eToXfxvjae.

'AMMflNioT.

'Q^e Koafxov

fxovovg

Toiig

dvBpcairovg Xeyet^ airo

fxepovg ovofi.d^m tov KoafxoVf vjTot tov?

ra tov Koafxov

<f>povovvTag s 5

I. 9-

mANNHN

ETArrEAION.
dia,

185

Kot avTco Trpo^TVjkoDfxivov^f OTt Tivef
TtaQitav ovT€ oXoig iyvdotrav avTOV'
TcSv TiaO^v ^ovXot.

t^v irpog tu y^iva TtpoToi

olot

y]<rav

cidcoXoXdTpat Kai

To
yj

Se,

''

e/V

Ta T^ja

i^A^e,

Kai
co^

oi

t^toi

avTOV
Trept-

"

ov irapiXaBov^^
yj

irept

twv

lovtaioov Xlyct
vtt

Xaov ovTa

ovatov,

Kat

Trepi

tSov
6

avOpomav twv
fxev

avTov yeyevrjixevwv' 5

(f)ikdv$p<oiros

yap av

©eof, ^ia

ov^eva, 7r€t6oi ^e irdvTai
ot fxev

€AK€i "apoi avTOV

Oio Kat

ehbovTa avTOV,

eAapov,

ot

Oe ovk

eka^ov. e/V Ta t^ta vjXOev ov t^$ avTov yjpeiag eveKev, avev^eej"

yap TO
yjXSev 6

OeToVf

dXXa

Tvjg

tcSv

t^/cov

evepyeaiag ydptv.
;

X\o$ev

Se

Ta irdvTa
irdvTa

TrXvjpav
;

Kat

iravTayov napav
jtxev

Trotov

Kevcaaag \o

TOTtov
rrj

6

crvveyav

tottov

ov^^eva

^fxetrpe,

irwg

ydp

;

Se vpof

rjfi.ag yjfxiv,

(rvyKaTafSdcret
tvjv

tgvto

elpydaaTO, Kai eavTOv
<rdpKa.
ei

€(f)avepaiaev

y^fLeTepav

imo^hvi

Trjv (f^aveptaaiv
lov^atot avTOV
r^

ovv TavTVjv Kat

KaTdl3a<7iv eXevaiv KaXeT,

Kai

irapaXa/Seiv irdvTeg ovk e6eXy}<Tav.

!f\MMaNioT nPESBTTEPOT.
KaBo
i^

AeyeTat

e/V

Ta iha

eXvjXvSevat,

<rapK<t}6eig eyvccpiadyj toT^

avTOv 6eaaafiLevots
ot

0(f)daXft,o(f)avas'

OTi Trpo^
el; <tiv

Tovg iQiovg "^Xoev,

eboKovv avTov

lOiot

etvai,

KaTa

TO

AptaTog to KaTa fjapKa.

lo de

o<Tot

eXapov avTOv,

TOvrecTTt,

Kav ^ovXot, Kav eXev6epot, Kav' KXXyjveg, Kav ^dp/3apot, 20 Kav
<TO(f)oi,

Kav

dao(f)Ot,

Kav yvvaTKeg,
Kav

kocv

dv^peg,
kocv
y]

Kav TraiOeg,
kocv
yj

Kav irpecT^vTai,
t^^tccTat,

kchv

vXovatot,

TrevyjTeg,
TifJ.yis'

apyovTeg,
TricTTtg

irdvTeg Tyjg avT^g

d^tovvTat
Koafi,tict\v

yap

Kat

Tov YlvevfJMTog ydpig t^v
fKiav aTtavTag eirXacTe

dvnfxaXiav irepieXovcTa, €tg

fAop(f)y}v,

Kat eig eva direTVTraae yapaKTVf- 25

pa, Tov ^aatXtKOV.

OpirENOTS.
yap
e^ avTciv

Eire<

ff.yi

TrdvTeg d7re<Trpd(f)y}<Tav avTOv,

iroXXot

irpocTYjKavTO

avTOv,
**

Kat
^e

fndXicrTa

ot

AttoctoAo/,

e7rt(f)epet

KvayyeXiaTYjg,

oaot

€Xaj3ov avTOv, eayov e^ovyevyjaofjievoi
Tyj

" aiav TCKva Seov yevea^at^
T^v e^ovatav elXyj<paatv, ot
TTtaTei.
^l^ag

tot€

tovto, ov Ttwf
dpeTyj Kat

30

dv TeXei^icaiv ev

t^

Tig

Se

yj

airia,

"^i ijv

eayov

t>jv

e^ovaiav, Oi^XoT ypd-

^etoa^ai avT^v

"

ToHg vtffTevaaaiv eig ro ovofJM avTov," tov

(fxDTOg ^TjAoVOT/.

OuK

eive ^e, OTt eiroii^aev avToi/g reKva

Seov,

dXX

,

"

e^coKev

^^

Bb

186

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA

I. 9.

airoig e^ovaiaVf^ '^eiKvv^ ori ttoXX^s ^et r^s airovOyj^ coare
ev Tco

ttjv

^anrKT^ari

t^j- vloQiaiag

yj^h

€yrv7r(i)6ei<xav

etKOva oKoKXr^-

pov

yjfxiv

^iarvjp^aat Kat ave7ra(f)0v.

Ktpiaaot.

O/

^ia Trtarews^ <f>W» "^^^ ^'? "^ptarov vioBeaiag
(f)vaecc$
rYjv

KeKXri^evot Seov, rvj^ [xev oiKeias

evreXeiav a7re^v-S
rjj

aavrOy KarvjyXaiafxevoi Se coaTrep

a[J.(pta)

XafXTrpw

rov rt[JMvrog

yaptrt iipoq ro

vitep (pvaiv avaKatovfytv a^tcofiia'

ov

yap

eri xpi^-

fxari^ovai reKva aapKog, ©eov ^e [xakXov <yevv^[xara.

T/

ovv

apa

ro irXehv epeH rt^ rvypiv,
elg

vj

rt ro e^aiperov
eTre;

ev

ro7g Tttarevovatv

X.ptarov ttapa rov 'Icpay^A,
'*

Kai avroq yeyevriabat Xeye- 10

rat Tiapa %eov Kara ro
**
jtxe

viov^ eyevvvjaa Kat vxpaaa'
epov[i.ev, ort

avrot ^e
ovo[t.aro$

vjSeryjaav ;"

Trpos

rovro

aKtav eyjov

ToJv [neXXovxccv

aya^av, ovk avry^v

rrjv

eiKova
e^

rm

Ttpay^t.ardiv, ovte

rovro
Tinrco

Kara
Kat

aX^^Setav

e^^tv eti^ov rolg
ev

laparjX,
oixpi

dXX w$

ev

a')(yj[j.ari

ypa(po[).evov
ov

avro7s,

Katpov otop6oo- 15

aeco$,
ot

Ka6a yeypaTtrai, Ka&

e[t.eXXov

dvo^ef/PYiaea^at Xoittov,

ivpeiTw^earepov ye Kat
'tta

aXyi6earepov aiTOKaXovvreg
Y\vev[Ka

Ylarepa rov
01

Qeov

ro
**

evotKyjaat avro7g
7tvev[J.a

rov

[xovoyevovg.

[xev

yap

ei)(ov

tovXeiag eig

</>ojSov," 01

§e

'*

7rvev[f.a

vtoSe-

"

atag

elg

eXev6eptav, ev

®

Kpdi^ovaiv, dj3j3a

Ttar-rjpr

ovkovv

20

^ta 7ttarecog rrjg etg 'Kpiarov ava(3yjaea6ai

[i.eXXcov eig vto6eatav,

Ka6d7tep ev aKta7g, ev eKetvco 7tpoKareypd(f>ero' coa7tep ovv d[f.eXei

Kat

rri ev 7tvev[t.ari

voov[LevY]

7teptro[t.^, ev
eiTtetv,

ryj

eKetvcov 7tdXat Ttpoyjv

ervTtovro aapKi, Kat avXXvj^^yiv
vj[/.erepa rv7ttKcog.

7tdvra

ev

eKetvoig

ra
35

Ave[t.vyjae he

rav aapKtKcov

attvcov, ei7tav,

**

01

ovk

e| ai[*.dreov,"

Kai rd e^^g, tva avyKpivavreg ro evreXeg Kat ra7tetvov rov 7tporepov, Yjyovv ro

aapKtKov roKov, 7tpog ro vi^^Aov Kai evyeveg rov
p^ajOiTOf,
OTrep

hevrepov

tov ^id ryjg

ear]v Ik

©eoD
ryjg

yevvyj6y^vat,

[KeydXyjv rtvd evvotav Ttepi

avrov Xd^co[Kev, koi
rvjv

rov yeyevvvj-^o

Korog ocopedg d^taV
rt[jJqg

^to

Kai
6

airiav rvjg

d(f)pdarov ravrvjg

rt6i^at Xeycov,
tyjv

" Kai

Xoyog adp^ eyevero," rovreart, Itd
rvjv

ravrvjv

v7to6eatv

rov yevea6ai adpKa rov Xoyov, Kai
^ea^torvjv,

rov

oovXov

[j.op(f>Yiv

Xa^eiv rov

reKva Seov yeyova[j.ev.
rvjg

" Feyove

Oe

Aoyog adp^"

ov

ovaiag avrov [j.eTaTnco- ^^

5

I. 14-

mANNHN
e/f

ETArrEAlON.

187

crewf

aapKa, ro yap hvoeh
ixevovaa oirep eariv.

rovro rvjg eay^drvi^ dae/3ftai
Oi/tco
t>?v

eariv,

d\Xa
**

rov ^ouXov

fj.op(pYjy

eAa/3ev*

e^evcTo" Se, e/Ve,

ra tSv

aiperiKiav

efxcf^pdrrav

aro-

fxara^ rZv Xeyovrwv ori (pavraata
d\vj6tv^i dvdXvjipii.

ns

tjv iy oiKOvofJi.iaf

ov aapKO^;

5
aKfivovv

Ti eari
eiti

to,

''

eaK-^vwaev ev yjfuv ;" ro
erepov ev erepco
yjvaQrj

ov

ravrov av
6

T'^

aKyjvyj,

dXX

aKi^voTy

rovreariv,

Qeog

Aoyo^ eaapKaGiq Kat
fj.eV

aapKi'

erepov
eij-

^e

Kar

ovatav (pa-

T^ yap evaaei koi
yj

ryj

avva(f>eta

eartv 6 @eo$ Aoyog
d(f>aviaft.ov

Kai

adp^' ov avyyyaeax; yevofkevy\q, ov^\
evaaecof rivog app-qrov

rav

ovatoov,

lo

aX\

Kai

d(f>pdaroVf Kai

^v

fj.ovoi

oi^ev

avrog.

14

Kat
Ata

lO^acraixeBa ttju So^au avrov.
rov avvrpo(f}ov a(off.arog
yjfJitv

^yjXovori.

E/ yap ro irpoa1

wttov MojyVecBf ovy^ vitefketvav 01
l^eiVf iroog 6eory]ra
yvfj.vy]V
01

Kar
(f>oog

CKeTvov

rov Katpov ^o^aaBev

Kat

dnpoairov kou avralg raXg
yy]yeve7g
^vvyjBy}fj.ev

avo}

^vvdf/.eaiv,

yjfxelg

iryjXtvoi

Kai

av

eveyKeiv.

Kai

eTre;^^

iroXXoi

rSov

7rpo(f>y]rm

e^^o^daQyjaav, wv

elg

ovrog
av6poo-

ax/rog eari ^oivayjg' e6avff.da6yjaav ^e Kat

AyyeXot irapa ra
Yiepa(f>e)fJ.

20

voig

(f)avevr6g,

Kat
ci}(f)6y}

ra
to5

Hepov^etft.
7rpo(f>-^ry]'

^e

Kat

fxera
yjfnaig

iroXXyjg
6

oo^yig

Trdvroov

rovrcov
y)fj.dg

dTrdyxv

KvayyeXtaryjg, irpog avryjv rav aya6oov
**

taryjat Kopv(py]v,

XeyooVf

^o^av wg fj.ovoyevovg irapa X\arp\g

TrXyjpyig

ydpirog kou

"

aXrjfle/af."

avT^v ^Yiai rov ^aaiXeoog, rov yvyjaiov fxovoyevovg 25
rvjv

Ylai^og
aafj.e6a.

rov Ylarpog, avrov rov Trdvrwv Kvptov

^o^av e6ea-

To
aXXa

oe

" «$" evrav6a

ovy^

ofxoiaaewg eariv, ovhe irapaPoXyjg,
eXeyev,

^e(3atooaeci}g,

Kat avau.(f>ta^yjrov tiopiafnov, coaavet

e6eaadfj.e6a

^o^av, otav eirpeire

Ka) eiKog ^v eyeiv fj.ovoyev^ Kat 30

yvyjatov ovra Tlov rov irafj.^aatXeoog Seov.

Tig

Be ^v ai;T>?

>;

^o^a

;

ori fj.er

e^ovatag jSaaiXeT Kat ^eairoryj Trpeirovayjg irdvra
oog

e-notet,

Kai ovy Kai
yZv.

AyyeXoi Kat
virdpyoov

7rpo(p^rat

irpoararrofj.evot,

avroydptg
xopyj-

aXyfieta

ireTrXyipoofxevyj,

Kat

aXXoig

ravryjv

35 B b 2

188
15
T/vof
eve/tev

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
mWaKis
Kai
aitkxg,
eiy^ov
6

I. 15.

KvayyeXKJTyj^
(pi^aiVf

tt/v

lcodvvov

Trepicpepei
Tcepi

fxapTvpiaVf ucnrep
*'

evTavQa

"

lcodvvi^g

fxapTvpeT
eTrei^vj
01

avTOv

;''

ovy^

d\Xa Ka)

(7(f)o^pa

avveToos'

yap

TToXXo)
a)0"T€

TO

Savtxa

tov dv^^pog tovtov

TrdvTeg

lovOaTot,

Kai Tov

'licarjTrov

^ia ttjv tovtov TeAeuTi^v Toyv twv lovoaioov 5

TToXiv

d^^aviaSyjvat
eyKcofxiccv

iroXefxca

Xoyi^eaQaif Kai fJMKpovg

iiepi

avTov
\ov-

Koyovg

Tioie^adai'

tovtov

'Xjdpiv

dit

avTOv Tovg
dvafXifxvfjcyKei

taiovg evTpexpai

(3ovXofxevogf

avve^xccg

avTovg

T^f

Tov
(xai

Tipo^pofj.ov fxapTvpiag'

ov

tov

^eairoTTjv diro tov ^ovXov TroirjTVjg

d^ioTTiaTOV

(mev^coVf

dXka

twv vijTr/a^ovTwv

IouSa/a»vio

daQeveiag avyKaTa^aivcov.

To
"Xccpig

^e,

" KeKpaye^ Xeyei,
d^Trdcxyjg

TYfV itappyfaiav

avTov
tov

^77X0?,

Kai OTi

VTtoaToKrjg

tvjv

Trapovaiav

Tiov tov 0eou

eK-^pvTTe.

Aia

te Tov etTrehf oti

*'

ovTog eaTiv ov eiTrov" ^eiKvvaiVf oti Kai 15
eirolei iva

7rp}v (fiavvjvai

tov ^piaTOV, dveKVjpv^ev avTOv' tovto te
vjfniv

evTrapd^eKTOv

yevYjTai.
ep')(pfJi.evog" ayjy.aivei,

To
Tccv,

Se
ovy^

"

OTriacc fxov

fj.eT

eft.e

KfjpvT-

/xeT

efj.e

yevofj.evog.

To "

efj.7rpoa6ev

fiov

-yeyove,"
fxov
i^v,"

TOVTeaTi, XafJ.TrpoTepog, evTi[xOTepog.
OTi ovK
(EK

To

Se

**

TrpccTog

20

Tivog TtpoKOTryjg irpwTov fxev ovra, oiriaca TreTroiyjKev eivai,
y]V,

dXX^ de) TrpwTog

el

KOi vaTepog irapayiveTai.
yjfxetg

"

'E/f Toy ttAtj-

"

pccfxaTog
Tvjv

^e

avTov

irdvTeg

eXdPofxev,^'

oti ov jU,e0eACT^v

ej^e/

'^ccpedv,

dXX
Kai

avTOTryjyyj

Kai avTopi^a irdvTCCv eaTi twv
avTOaXyjSeia'

dyaQav, avTo^ccy]
avve-/ocv

avTOcpSig

Kai

ovk

ev

eavTW 25
virep-

tov irXovTov,

aXXa

Kai eig

Tovg aXXovg airavTag

kXv^oov avTOv, Kai fxeTa to virepKXvaai fkevccv TrXyjpyjg.
3 6

'Avt/ Troiag
Tyfv Kaivyfv'

ydpiTog

iroiav

ydpiv eXdPofxev

;

avTi

T^r^g

irdXai
ccg

Kai ydp ydptTt Kai ^lov^ahi "npoa^eyPyiaav TOTe,
^id to
TroXvTrXyjOe^g
vfjidg,

yeypairTai, oti " ov

dXXd

^id Tovg 30
eaccSyjfxev,

"

iraTepag

vfxccv

e^eXe^dft.y]v." Kai yjfxeig irdXiv

ydpiTi

aXX' ovy

Ofxoiccg,

dXXd

fxei^ovccg ^id

t^^v

tov TlvevfnaTog ^ccpedv,
K.at to
vofxog ^ia

Koi ^id Tvjv «Tro T^f KaTaXXayy\g yevofxevy^v Trappyjaiav.
XajSeiv Se tov vofxov, ydptTog
y]v^

KaOag
Tvirog

eTrdyei, oti
y]v

"

"

MctiiJaeoog

e^odyj"

ei

ydp Kat

vofxog eKeivog,

aXX 35

I. i8.

mANNHN
e[ji<paiv€t

ETArrEAlON.
oiKTipfxovi, oti
(f)Yjaiv o

189
"
eyvcopiae

ovv
**

eXeyjfj.offwyjv

Seov kui

Ta? o^ov( avTov
^ X«/"f
'^^'

tco

MwuVer,"

KaOcc^
lyjo-ov

Aa/3/^.

Ot/

Se

^ aXyptia bia
vjULiv

XpiaTOv eyiveTo,
[xev

Kat OTt

TOVTO txti^ova
peTYig
Tvjg

eKOfXKjev

ayaSa, S^AoV (KeTvo^
'^ta.Kovog'

yap

vtiyj-

av TaTretvoTepav yeyove irpayfxaTav

ovTog te ^eaTro- 5

Kat ^aatXevg Kat jSaatXewg Ttog,
(jvvhv dei

Ta

ttoXX'2 KpetTTOva rf^ayev

Yift.lv,

t2 YlaTpt.
ecopaKe TrwiroTe"
etTiov
eTit

'

" Seov
Xiccrev

oii^etg

einhv
01

KvayyeXt aTyjg,

eb"^-

yj[J.Tv,

ori

TrdvTa oaa
Ka6yjfji.evov

Ttpo^pyjTat, oiov

Haaiag,
eirt

OTi

ti^e

Tov

Kvptov

6povov,

Ka) 'le^eKtyjX

twvio

"KepovPeiui,

Kat AavtyjX

em

Bpovov,

Kat eTepoi Ttveg cf avTwv
^v, ovk
t>jv

vepi T^g 6ewpiag avTov, Trdvra

eKeha avyKara^aaeag

avT^g
<f)v(Jtv,

T-^g

ovaiag yvjxvyjg opaBeici^g.
^ia(f)op(i}g

Kt yap

avTVjv ecopcov
e<TTi

ovK av

avTyjv e6edaavTo'

dirX^ ydp Tig

Kat

dayyiixdrtaTog Kai davv6eTog Kat dnepiypa^og, Kat ovVe Kd6y}Tai 15
ov^e
eaTi^Ke.

TavTa yap
"

•ndvTa

a^fxdTm

eaT/,

Kat
Tt

ov%\

Tav

AyyeXm
Ttuv.

Ttg avTOv opa, oy^e twv
etpy}[xevov

dpyayyeXm,

[xvi

ye dv6pu-

To yap

OTt 01

AyyeXot avTwv tta TravTog l3Xe-

" vovat

TO TrpoaooTrov tov TraTpog [xov tov ev ToTg ovpavoig/^ tovto

^yjXoi, OTi

8/a t^v Ka6apav avTwv Kat dypvnvov (pvatv, ov^ev CTe- 20
aet tov

pov

dXX

yj

Qeov (pavTd^ovTai, waTrep Kat

ot

Ka6apot

TJj

Kap^^ia, TYi
Trept

KaTa

ttdvotav oxpet tyi dv6poo7roig dvvaTyj, Kat TJj evvoia
ej^e/

t^

Qeov'

ovre yap TrpoacoTrov
1 oyTo oe avTO,
irotyjaat

Qeog,

aXX

ovTe ev ovpavoig

•jteptyeypaitTat.

oti fc»eov ovbetg eccpaKe TroJTroTe,

d^tovtaTov TQV Xoyov
Ttog
cov

^ovXo[xevQg, (pyjat,

"

6 [novoyevyjg

25

etg

tov koXttov
[i.y]^ev

tov liaTpog, eKetvog eq-^yyjaaTO.
TavTvjv

Akovoov Se koXttov,
dv6pci)7rivyjv

VTroTrtaTevayjg Tanetvov'

yap

tvjv

pyjatv eiire, to

dyaptaTov Kai avvaittov avTov to
Kat
oti

irpog

TOv Tlarepa ^ei^at
dveXXeiirtog

^ovXo[xevog,

irdvTa
[xovov,

Ta tqv YlaTpog

e-jriaTaTai, ovk ^lovhatolg

^e

dXXa Kat Trday^o

T^

otKQV[t.evy) e^yjyijaaTO.

Tivog eveKev
'Iwavv^v

rovg el 'iepoaoXv[xwv lepeig Kat
;

AeuiTaf
eTretVri

Trpog

e^aireaTetXe
^lcodvvYiv

cog

evTt[xoTepovg

tZv

Xoiircov,

Kai

avTOv Tov

evTt[XQV

Kai
ttl

[xeyav

eiycV

o6ev

avTOV avTOv

Kat
epco-SS

It^daKaXov eXetv e^ovXovTo'

Kai

KoXaKevTiKcog

5

190
raxTiv,

EPMHNEIA
ware avrou €K tovtov
'

EI2

TO KATA
€i$ to
vjyvoovv,

1.

27.

€TriC7ra<xaa6ai

eai/TOV o/ao-

koyi^crai eivat rov "Kpia-rov.

Ori yap ovk

^^Xov

vjv

CK

r^i yeveaeas avrov' Kai yap eAfyov ToVe •noKKoi, " ri apa ro

"

Trai^icv

earai rovro ;" ^ia rovro ovv Kai avrog

irpo^;

ov^efLiav

eparrjaiv
ev6eia<;
yjv

avrav
eiTreV

Trpocrifjv
'*

re

Kai

^evrepav
ev

eirrev
tt}

evGecog, o-nep

e^5

eych

(pccvvj

Poavros

ep^jaco,"

«AA

oirep

vno^nrevov eKehoi,
Ylepi he rov
e^OKCov

"

ori ovk

eifJii

\piaros."
{xyj

'HA;a eparaai,

ri

avrog eariv,

eTrei^v)

irpoa-

avrov

yj^eiv,

Kai Keyei, ovk

eifJii.

Aia

ri

ovk

eiirov, ort

Trpocfyyjrrii ei

av, yjapig rov apBpoVf

aXka
**

fKera t^s' ro

" 0" apSpov 10
EiTret^vj
vfjiiv

TrpoaOvjKyjgf

"

6 Trpocp-^rrji; ei

av

;"

Kai rovro Travovpyag.
ort
Trpocp-^rvjv
vfJicoVf cag

yap rjKovaav rov
**

y^cavaecog

enrovrog,

avaovros

arvjaei Kvptog
yjv

Qeog eK twv
^ta rovro

a^eX^pcov

e|W.e,"

^e

6 "KpiaTog'

ovrco<;

avrov

epctirwatv, iva
rvjv

Kav rovro
1

Treiacoaiv

avrov avvSeaQat. avrog ^e yvovs
KTrtjJievovrctiv

iravovpyiav avrav
(fiifjatVf

e;irev, oiiK elfii.
**

^e avrcov
eprifj.(f."

r^

epcor^aei, rore

ort

eyco

(pcovYi

(Boavrog ev
rov

T-iJ

eiri

rov Trpocp^^rvjv Kare6

(pvyev
(f)Yjat.
**

a^toirtarov

Xoyov

Trotav'

Kai
ri

yap

'Haaiag rovro
et

To

^e

enreh avroo
;"

iraKtv'

"
vjv

ovv

^airri^eti,

av ovk

ei

\piarog

avayKa^ovrcov

ofj.o\oy^aai

eavrov eivat rov 20
(f)V]atv,

"Kptarov' fj.eaov ^e
eTrei^^Yj

(SaTrrtar^g elpYjKevat

avrm

rov X.ptarov
cog

eiKog

vjv

avrov Kat

avaft,efj.i')(6ai toS

Xaw,

eva rcov iroX-

Xcov ovra,

iravrayov ro arvcpov Kat
ov
vfj.etg

a.KOfj.iraarov eTrt^teiKVVfj.evov.

ta rovro be enrev,
ei^Yjaiv irepi

ovk oibare,

ota ro rvjv aXvjQy]

avrov

fi.Y]

yjvcoaKeiv avrovg, olov rig eart kou TroSev.
epy^ofLevog" avve^^^cog
riSviat,
^>;Aft5v

25

27

To

^e

"

OTTtaco

f/.ov

ori

ovyj, reXetov

eart ro avrov ^airrtaft.a,
cog

dXXa aKia
dXYjQeiav

Kat eiKcov Kat
eirtQYjaovrog.

Trpoo^oTrotvjatg,

aXXov

fj.er

avrov

rvjv

To

^e

**

efxirpoaSev fiov

yeyove," rovreart, rtfj.tanepog,

war

efxe

ft.Yj^e

ev

roig

ea^^droig

rwv rovrov ^iaKOVcov
rvjg ev

dpi6ft.Yj6^vat

a^toV 30

TO

yap ro

VTroOi^f/.a

Xvaat

ea)(dri^g

tiaKoviag

eari.
e^vjg

Ttvog
',

eveKe

(f)Yiaiv,

ort

" TavTa

B^5av/a eyevero," koi ra

Iva

.

T>jv Trappvjaiav ^ei^vj

rov fJ.eyaXo<pcovov KVjpvKog, ort ovk
epvjfjiia,

ev oiKia,

ov^e

ev

ycovia, ov^e ev

dXXa

rov 'lop^^dvvjv KaraXa(3cov, ev

fj.eau TrXY]6ovg

roaovrov ra

irept

X,ptarov iraatv dveK^^pvrre.

KpY] 35

\
1.30.
Se yivctiaKCtv, oti
•)(€r
7]

mANNHN
yap BrjSavia
ov)()

ETArrEAION.

191

t» aKpi^r] iwv avTiypdcpav
itepav

ev hvjBafSapa irepie-

tov ^lop^dvov,
%/?>? /aij

aXX eyyvg
fjiev

"nov
itepi

Twv 'Upo(ToXvfJLm.
Tov (3aTrTia-fxaTo$
Tov
'ladvvvjv

Ka) tovto B^

dyvoeTv, oti to.

MaTfia/bf ^ivjyerra/, Kai

Tot/f Tcpivi 'teiyfi-^vai

yj^ovovq

eTtiTe^iMV, eiteiyeTai Ttpoq

Tovq

e^ri^.

'O §€5
KdSo^ov

^ladvvvig TOVTOii
Tvjv aTTO

fxdXiaTa ev^iaTpi(3ei, Kai
yevofJi.evr]v '^i-yjyenai.

to. fJi.eTa

tvjv

Tov opovq

29

'O te

l^aTrTKTTyji

to

"

't^e 6

dfKvoq tov
d[ji.vov

©eoi)" Xeyet, tta to

TtoWovg TioXXdKig

eTri^vjTeTv

avTOv.

te KakeT avTOv, Tvjg T€

vpo(f)v]Teiag dvafxifMvvjaKcov tov

Haaiov, Kat T^f aKiag t^? AcaTa 10

rov Mcoi/Vea, iva
dXviBeia.

dno

tov tvtiov fxdXXov avTovg itpoaayayviTai Tvj
df».apTiav tov Koafxov, (pi^atv, OTt eKeivog dfj.apTtav eAa/Sev, oiiTOg te ditdaag

atpovTa §e

Tvpj

fx,ev 6 dfj,vo<; ov^evog

Ka& dira^

TVjg oiKovfjievvjg d-ndavjg'

Ktvtvvevovaav yap avTvjv dTToXeaQat Ta15

yedjg tteacoaev.

30

To
aai
fiiev

^e

"

efj.ttpoaBev fjiov

yeyovev," evTavSd

(pvjat

^ta to ^aitTtvj

ev T[vevft.aTt 'Aytoo, '^ta

to Tag dfxapTiag Xa(3e7v tqv KoafJ.ov.
itXeov ov^ev eyet
>]

yap

efxv)

itapovaia,

<f>v)ai,

v]

tov KVjpv^at tov

KOtvov

TVjg

otKovfxevvjg

evepyeTvjv'

^e tov

Kvpiov t&u KaBdpat

itdvTag dvdpoiTtovg, Kai yaptaaaQat tov itapaKXv^TOV tvjv evepyetav. 20

jfVMMaNioT ripESBTTEPOT.
TeyBeig to Kora adpKa,
TV]g Ttov VTtdpyjav'
v] vj

'Avv]p ^e

KaXenat

a>g

eK yvvatKog

OTt

TeXetog ^v ev vjXiKta, TptaKOVTaevjv

OTt

TeXetog
Ttdav^g

ev itdavi

apeTvj itpaKTtKV] t6

Kat

6ect}pv]TtKvj'

V]

OTt

t%

XoytKvjg (pvaetag,

eaTt T^f

^iKKXy^atag,
TtpoaccTtov,

vvf*.(f)tog

eaTtv.
dvv]p

ag t^j

KKKXv]atag yvvatKog eyova-qg 25

^ptaTog

KaXehrat, ig vvfi.(pevofxevog Tag tuv

TtiaTav "^vydg.
la

Tt

TO

Kayv)

ovK

v\Qetv

avTOv,
cag

Xeyet

;

awnoitTov
dvQpoovivvjg

tv]v
<f>i-

fiLapTvptav

epydaaadai

(3ovXof/ievog,

ovk dit
teiKvvai

Xtag

vjv

avTV],

dXX

e|

dTtoKaXv^eoog'

Sc
iva
Tvj

Kat ^v eiy^ev ^o
<f)avepci)6v}

aiTiav

TO

t^tov

avTov
ecTTi

^dTtTtafxa.
B/a

*'

Aaa'

tw

" Ic^av^A," TovT
TttaTei Totg
Xotitolg

to Ttpoo^toTtotvjaat
*'

tov

\ptaTov

avaat'

^id tovto v]X6ov Kayca (^aitTt^ciiV ev
tv]v

"

i/JaT;."

B&vAo/u,evof ^e
avTV]v

d^ioittaTOTepav
tov

eavTov fxapTvpiav

notv]aat, avdyet

ent

narepa, Kat ent to Yivevfxa to 35

192
'AyicVy ovTOog

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
iiTrav,

1.

35.

"

ori

TeGeafxai to 7rv€Vfj.a

KaTajSaTvov (aaei

" TrepiaTepav" Kat Ta

e^^^.

iyve^^wf 6e Acyei to

Kayco ovk
*'

yjbetv

avTOv,

OioTt
cf)v]ai,

avyyevvj^
Trpog ttjv
%01.p1-

avTov

i]V

KaTa adpKa.
**

I^of,"

<j>Yi<jiv,

AyyeXog.,
tva ovv
o6ev

'Mapiav,

EA/cra/3eT
tvjv

yj

(xvyyev^g

aov"

fj.Yi

"ho^r,

5

^eaSai
yjpovov

'^ta

avyyevetav, tovto

(f>yjatv'
ep^^fxci)

Kat tov anavTa

KaT

otKovofxtav

©eov

ev tyj

^teTptPe.
yjfjiwv

KaTvjXSe ^e to Ylvevfxa To'Aytov
lyj(Tovv 'K.ptaTOV, ovy^ OTt

eirt

tov Kvptov

Kat Seov

y^eiav avTov elye, KaQag Kai

'^/J.eig,

aX\

vnep Tov Kyjpv^at avTOv
CTT^f, OTt

fnovov, cog Kat irept
[xe

tovtov

(py}(rtv

(BaitTt- 10
fxot eiTrev,

"
av

%efv\jag
t^yji

j^aTTTi^et

ev

v^aTt, eKeivog
fxevov ctt

"
"

e<f>

ov

to Trvevfxa

KaTa^ahov Kat

avTOV, oiiTOg

eo-T<v

/SaTTT/^aJV ev Tlvevfi.aTt Ay/oj."
yiv(i)(7Ketv OTt

X/3^ Se

ovyt fxovoq

lcooivvyji

ei^e to Ilvev/xa to
01

Ayiov

ev

eidet

Tiept^TTepag,
fj.yi

aXka

Kat

TrdvTes
to,

totc irapovTes 15
ov fxovov

eKei(;e, et

Kat

TidvTeg

eTri(TTev(7av'

yap TOiavTa
TOfTwv
Tyjg

Tcav (70iij.aTiKm ocpSaXfiwv ieiTat,

dXXa

irpo

KaTa otd-

votav

oipeitig, co(7Te fxy}

(pavTa^xtav TreptTTyjv to Ttpdyfj.a

vofJ.t(jai.

IflANNOT TOT Xpt202t6mot.
**

E/

yvcoptfKog
yjXOov

vjv,

ovK dv

eiTTev,

iva

(ffav^

TW

lapayjX,

^ta tovto

^aTTTt^cov.^'

evTevQev 20
e(JTiv,

^yjXovoTt,

a

(pacrt TiatbtKa

tov HcoT^pog, xpev^og Kat 7rXdafJ.aTa

E/ yap €K
lctidvvvjg

TrpcoTyjg ap^df/ievog y^XtKtag €davft.aTovpyet,

ovk dv avTOv
^t^a^r^dXov

i^yvoyjcrev,

ovt dv to Xotirov TrXyjOog

e^e^^dvj

Tov (pavepcoaavTog avTOv.

35
"

li

ivog €veK€v €fi(3X€xpag tco

\y]aov TreptiraTovvTt etirev

iooavvyjg,

25

t^e 6 dfxvog tov
(pcovyjg,

©eov

;" tva
ecag

ttTTag Kai ^id

tS)v

0(f>SaXfii.av

Kat

Oia Toy^

Tovg

fj.y}

totc 'TrpoaeayvjKOTag

ota to iroXv

Tov virvov TVjg Trcopceaecog,
eTttyvcoatv.

d(f>v7rvtayj XotTrov irpog tvjv

toS 'EcoT^pog
lcodv-

HKoXov6y]aav ^c

tcS

I^jo-ov 0/

^vo fnaSvjTat tov

vov,

ov

Tov

^i^aaKdXov KaTa(f>pov^aavTeg,

dXXd

ttj

fii.apTvpta

30

avTQv ff.dXXov TretaOevTeg.
Tov lyjaovv,
Tcov ditXcag
Tcov,

Ovk

evSecog Se

npoaeXQovTeg yjpcoTVjaav

dXX
Kat
cog

yjKoXovSrjaav OTt irep ov dy]u.oata TrapovTCov dirdv-

eTvyev

VTtep dvayKatcev

Kat ft.eytaT<ov irpayfj.d-

dXX

tOta otaXeyByjvat eairovta^^ov.
;

'KpcoTO. ^e avToiig, ti 6eXeT€

ov%

tva

f».d$y],

irw?

ydp

ei^cog

S5

I.40.

IX2ANNHN ETArrEAION.
tcSv

193
[xaXXov

ras Kap^iai
avTOvs

avBpftmm
xat

;

aW

iva ^ia

rrji

e^anr^o-f wf

olKetcoa-yjTat

•ttXeiovog

/xeTa^oS

t^? irappYiatas' eiKO^

yap ^v avTovg IpvBptav Kai

^e^otKevat
Ttepi

ayvaTag t€ ovTaf avrS,
avTov fxapTvpovvTog aKrjeve-S

Kat TotavTa "napa tov 'h^arTKokov

KooTag. avTo} Se ov ^ta TYig aKoXovSvjaeai fxovov tov iroBov
<f)y]vaVy

a.kXa Kai ^ta tov ^i^aaKaXov avTOV ovofxaaai, tovto yap

epfJii^veveTai

" pa^^t'"

Kaiirep on^ev ov^e iriog ft.a6ovT€i Ttepi ovtov,

ovOe aKovaavTeg.

40

To

^e

"

Ttov fuevetg ;"

eiitov

ck TroXX^g Kai

cruvecrecof, /AeToc

yap

yiavyjaq
t\BeyM».

ettielv

t/

Ttpoq

avTOv^

aKOvaat Tiap

avTov •navTa 10

Ov

Xeyei Sc tov toitov, ovte
OTrojf

Ta

ay]ft.e7a

t^^ oiKtag, aXA',
"npog tv]v

ep^/eoBe

Kai oxpeaBe,

TrXeov

avTovq

eiitaTraayjTat

aKoXovBrjatv.

Ata
wf

ti

KvayyeXtaTTj^; earjfKave tov Katpovy etTrav
;

TO

copa

ijv

oeKaTif]

OTrwf t:^v
viro

aTrovbyjVf

vjv

etyov iieoi t*/v

aKpoaaiVf evi^ei^i^Tai, oti ov^e

yap €Tvye

\V

T^f wpa^ irepteTpdTryjaau' kou 15
CTt Oe Kat

itpog

^5.

Vff/,

Ovafjiov

yjXtog wv

^.'/5,\

\»~~5, avTov tov OeaTrof

Tov tptXavBpwmav, OTt ov^e avTog e^Vev, aKatpov eaTt

vvv,

aKov-

aeaBe avptov

ei

ti PovXeaBe,
yjpovov,

aXX wg

Ttpog (piXovg Kai itoXvv
el

avTw
lcpav

avyyeyovoTag
fiev (f>YiatVy
**

ovtw ^taXeyeTat.

^e

Kai

dXXayov

"

6 ^e viog
fi.yj^ev

tov avBpwitov ovk eyet ttov t^v Ke(paXy]v 20

KXhat^ Tov
fnyj

t^tov

KaTaywytov KCKT^aBat ^rjXwTtKOv eaTiv,
Kai yap Kat
yj

ov Tov

fkevetv ev otKta'

itapal^oXyj twv aXwite-

Kwv Kat Twv

TteTrjvwv

tovto /SovXeTai.

Eethpot AnoA.
fj.a

E^

wv,

(f>i^atv,

eBeaadfJLriv fjiehav

to ITveu-

BetKwg ev Tiw, KaTeXa(3ov fxiag elvai tov TlaTepa Kat TOV25

T;ov ovaiag Te Kat BeoTYjTog, Kat fLefJMpTvpyjTat OTt ovTog eaTiv

Tiog Tov Qeov
<f)tXoTifi.etaBat

jSaTtTi^wv ev Tlvevy.aTt
f>.y]

Aytw' ovk av tovtq
ovatag ^v

tvvdfi.evog, ei

t^iov

Kai T^g avTi^g

avTO TO

YlvevfJia to Aytov'

yap eK ^wpeag

Tig Xafi(3dv€i, tovto
oii

€T€potg wg e| oiKeiov TtpoawTtov ^wpYjaaaBai
Tor^-

tvvaTat'

avTog ^c30
"tto

fJiaByjTaig

evecpvae Xeywv, " Xd^eTe

Yivevft.a

'Ay tov.^

Kai

YlavXog

'Pwft.aiotg

eittaTeXXwv

<f)yjatv,

"

el &e Ttg Ylvevfj.a X.pt'

" aTov

ovK eyetf ovTog ovk

cctt/v at/ToS.'*
Y]fji.epa,

AiwMaNior. TpiTY]

avTY] evptaKeTat

a(f>

ov eirot-^aavTo

c c

5

194
01

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
rr]V irpog

I.

38.

^apKxaioi

loodvvrjv (Tvvrvy^iav, ev

17

eirvvQavoVTO

avrov

T/V eo-T/v.

ToT Xptsostomot.
<f>6eyyo[Ji.€voVj [xvj

OTav

aKovavjt; tov
[xi^^^e

^aitTKTTOV ra avra
TrepiTTOV Tiva elvat voeiTTchv

(pXvapiav KaTayvZg,
[jl€V

fxiai^i
eTrei

Ka) (popTiKOV. 'K^ovXeTO

yap KaBaTia^

aKovaQrjvat' 5

^e ol tioXXo) ToHg

Xeyo[i,evoii ov Tipoaelyov e^ apyvji Oia tov
(fxcvv].

TToXvv vTTVoVf Kai ^evTcpa TrdXiv avTovg dtpvTtvi^ei

38

^rpacf^elf 8e 6 *It](tov9 kcu

Omaafxevos avrov9

«aco-

XovOovvras.
lAMMflNioT.
^EiTceiVri 01

dKo\ov6ovvT€i KpiaTW ov ^vvavTat av-

1

o

Tov (J>6d(Tai,a-vyKaTaPaTtKoo$ <7Tpe(f)eTat "npo? avTOvi, ^eiKvvg avTotg

TO eavTov TrpocaTTOv, tva yvooaiv, OTt avTog eaTtv
vo/xov, Kat ^i^da-Kwv

irXvjpav

tov

Ta

ev avTca.

"IBe

afxvos rov Oeov.
ATTOT.

ToT

Ata

TO

pd6v[J.ov

Twv aKpoaTav, To7g

avTolq

1

Key^viTat Koyoti' dpeTVj tt^a(7KdXov Tor? avTo7i
e^ji.nayyjvat

Ke^j^jpriadat •Trpog

to

tov? Koyovg ev Ta<V twv aKpoaTUiv xpv^^aig.

41

^Hv *Av8pea9
To
Se tov
[J.OVOV, ttOTt,

6 d8e\(j)09 ^Lp.(iivos lierpov.
ovo[j.a,

eTepov ovk eyvaptaev
log

dkXa

to tov Avopea

Ttveg (fiaaiv,

avrov virdp^/etv tov TOtavTa ypa- 20

ipavra tov 7jKoXov6y]KOTa. Ttveg ^e itdXtv ov Ota tovto,
eKeivog ov tuv
eTTta-^^j.oov vjv,

aXX

oti

Kat ovk

'yjv

ti

Kep^^og

ano Toy

(xa6eiv

avTov TQ
e7riaYj[j.ov,
'2i[j.oovt

ovo[i.a'

tov Ve 'Av^^pea
tv]v

[i.€[iiVv]Tai

Kat

'^td

ro eivat avTOv

koi ^id to

dpyvjv t^$- TriaTeag irpoKaTafSaXea^at

T(o

eavTov d^€X(f>^' o6ev Kat ^id tovto evdeoog aKovaag 25

"

OTt vof^ao} v[J.dg dXteHg dv^pwTtoov,''' ovk ^Ttopvjae iipog tv]V irapor-

to^ov

Inoa^/eaiVj
elg

dXXd

7teta6e)g vjKoXov6v]aev

Y.i[J.tov.

tv]Xov
[i.vj

Se

OT^ tovto

tov Yii[J.ma

Av^peag elpydaaro, eK tov

KaTa-

ayen/ nap

eavToa tov

t^j OiOaaKaXtag tqv HooT^pog 6v]aavpov,

dXXd
A2

Ta^xeoog Bpa/xen» Kai toiJtov [xera^ovvat

tw

a^eX(fi'2.

30
og epfxv]irept

T/
"

lv]XoT TO etTreiv avTOv,

"

evp-^Kafxev tov
tvjv

Meaatav,
ayToy

veveTat

HptaTog

;" tv]v

a^ivovaav

i/>v%*?v

tov

\ptaTOv Trapovaiav, Kat

OTt itep) ttjv d(f>i^tv

avTov npoae^OKa ^td

1.46.
iravTO^, oBev

mANNHN
ho
"tov

ETArrEAION.

195
ro itpoa-

Kai TKpiyaprig yeyove ^ia to avnPvjvai

^oKUfxevov'
Xiccv.

Kai lituyeTai xat eTepoig fjitTa^ovvai twv evayye-

Ov^x^ aTrXag ^e

Meaa-iav XeyeL, aXXa fxeTa T^f tov apQpov

7Tpoa6YjKyis

Mecra-iav,^^

wi eva ^piaTOv

irpoc^OKiovTe?, ovtev koi-

vov irpog Tovg

akXovg y^iaTovg eyovTa.

Wyaye
'^ia

te avTOV Ttpog tov 5
6epfi.ov

^lviaovv evBeag wg exmeiG^ Kai eyiyvwv, Kai

to

avTOV Kai
ovk c|

ev^^^XwTOv, oTtep e^

«PX^? ovTog avTog

UeTpog

eKeKTrjTo'
fMyj

evKoXiag he ov^e a-nXwg Kai wg erv^ev eite^pafuev^
vvoTTvevaf]
itepi

tovto Ttg

aiiTov^

aXXa TtoWa

i^y]Triaag

Kat tov d^e\(pov
ot

avaKpivag,

ovrto

tov

Xoyov vape^^e^aTo'

dXX

KvayyeXiaTai lo

TOUTO

eTttTefi.vovai,
TctJv

0pay(vXoytag
arjfi.etiov

eTttfneXovfJLevoi.

43

'E7rf<^>; ^e

ov/^ ijTTOv at

itpo^pyjTe^ai TtpoaayoYtat,
Trjg 6eoTy]Tog,

apyeTai
fjLtKpov

Xotitov evTev6ev ditoKaXvTtTetv

Ta

Kat KaTa

avTTiv Ttapavotyetv aito t«v Ttpoppyjaecov.
(pyjat'
** aii

KfnlSXe^pag

yap

avTW

ei 'Eifi.ccv

vlog 'Icovo," aTto
t'o

tov TtapovTog Kai j^
^yjXovoTt

TO fLeXXov
fxeXXov

TttaTovTai'

yap
fxer

ovofLa
yj

eiitccv,

Kai to
^e

Ttporl^et,
i^v,

Kat

eyKcofxiov
ft.eXXov

"Ttpoppyjaig'
**

tovto

ov

KoXaKevovTog
*

dXXa

to

itpoXeyovTog,

av

KXrfiyjari
fi.€T-

Kyjcpag,

epft.^^veveTai
ortep

VieTpog.
yjv

ovk ente Of, oti eyco ae

ovofxdaag,

fxet^ovog

e^ovaiag,

ha

to

fj)fj

l3ovXea6ai e^ 20
T€Oi)g

dpyrig to. Trig av6evTeiag htt^tetKVva^ai aitavTa,
voTepov (f)6eyyeTat.

aXXa

Tavei-

Ttvog
'laKcoPov

Se

eveKev

tovtov
;

fxev

YleTpov
OTt

mofj.aae, Tovg ^e

vepi

vloiig

/SpovT^g

iva

^et^vj

Kai

Trjv

itaXatav avTog

eaTtv

6

'^e^coKwg,

o^

to,

ovofiaTa

coa-Ttep

Kai tot€ Kai vvv fj.eTa- 25

pv6fj.i^ci)v'

Tov yap
fj.ev

AySpa/A 'AjSpaafj,

eKaXeae,

Kai

tijv

Edpav

'Edppav.

^vhpeag d^ovaag itapa tqv

itpi^pofJ.ov rjKoXov6yjae
6

Tw \ptaTco,
Ttap
Ttpog

KOii 6

Herpog itapa tov Av^pea'
oy^ev,

Se ^tXiitTtog oBev

;

ovtevog fi.a6wv

dXXa tovto
fj.01,

ft,ev

eiitovTog

tov \ptaTOv

avTOV,

'*

dKoXovBei
Krjpv^

"€Tteia6v]

t€ evBecog, Kat ovk dve- 30

46 X*^/"?^^"» «AXa
Na6avar]X,
**

eTepotg ytyveTai.
**

Apafiav yap

eitt

tov

"

ov eypaxl/e" (prja)
fi.€v

Moova^g Koi

01 -TtpocpiiTat, evp-fj-

KafJ.ev."

UpioTov

^ta to

Trjv (fxavrjv

tov Kvptov €pydaaa6ai
^tdvotav eyetv,

Tt ev avTco'

eitetTa te

Kai ^ta to

fx€fj.eptfj.vy]fji€vrpi

a?«Cod.
c c t

196

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
ra.

I.49.
tv}v

KOi o-vvej^wf (xeXeToiv
avTOv. Kai yap to

Mcavacwf, Kai Trpoa^oKav

irapovaiav

"

evp-^Kafxev" ^•^^tovvtuv eaTiv aei.
Kco[/.r]v

Aeyei ^e Kai

tvjv

tov ^iXittitov

EyayyeX/crT»;^, iva
oti diro TVjg ov^eva

[xdOafxev KavTevQev ttjv tov X/?;aTov '^vmfxiv
<pepov(rvjg

KapTTOV tov$ twv ixaSvjTuiv

ejKpnovg e^eXe^aTO.
tov Naflavai^A

Ett/ 5

Se

Tov

MwvVca
iva

Kai tovs

itpocf^-^Tag
iroi-^ar]

^iXiwog
Kai

TrapeTrefJAlieVf

d^ioTriaTov

to

Krjpvyfxa'

yap

tjv

dKpi^Yjg Koi Tidvia ^ie(7Ke[xixevog

NaSavayjX fxeTa dXrfieiav,
epyov etetgev.

a>g

Kai
^e

KptaTOg efxapTvpyjaev
Tov 'Iwa^(/)"

ayraj, Kat to

i tov

"

eiTrev, eTrei^y]

tovtov Tecog eivat "naHg evofxi^eTo. 10
ti

Aeyet ^e " €K Na^apeT ^vvarai
avTOV eK
ToJv

dyaBov

etvat ;" ^/a to dKoxxrat

ypacpav OTt eK BvjSXeefL ^e7 eXSeTv tov \ptaTOV.
i'^e" <^>?o";v 6 4>iAi7r7ros",

To

^e

"

epy^ov koi

ei^ag ovk dTroaTVjaO'

fxevov

XomoVf dv

tcSv

pyjfxaTCov

yevavjTat

Kat T^f hi^aaKaktag

XjO/<7Tov.
dXvjScig
irpog

ETratverTa/ ^e irapa tov ^piaTOVf Kat Oavfxd^eTat «f 15
e^/cov, eiret^y]

lapayjXiTi^g '^oXov ovK

ovSev Trpog ydpiv ovt\
yjv

aireySetav e(f)6ey^aT0'

ov

yap airtaTovvTog

ra

pi^fxaTay
yvoifxriv

dXXa d^eKaaTOv

Kpiaecoi, o6ev Kai ^v e^ dpyrig irept

avTOv

etyeVf OTt ovk eartv eK

Na^apeT, TavT>jv
KaXovatv
;

efxetve
a^Jro

^taTyjpwv.

Hcog
Kat 20

avTOV Na^copa7ov
'

01

TrpocpriTat

Trjg dvaTpo(f)^g

T^g eKei

'tiaycoyrjg.

To

Se etireh,

"

Troflev fxe

ytvcioaKetg" '^eiKvv-

atv avTOif av6pcoTrov evaTady^ Kat (Se^rjKora, OTt irep ovk ey^avvcnSri
Tors- eiraivotg,

ovhe

Tollg eyKcofxiotg eire^pafKev,

dXX
Tt

eirtfxevei

^rjTav
aa<f>e-

Kat

dKpt^eaTepov

^iepevvcofxevogf

^ovXofxevog

fxa6eTv

CTepov.

25
ayjfxaivet tq '^

49
**

T/

npo tov ae ^tXtirirov

(fxovyjaat,

ovTa
ev

viro

t^v

avKrjv

ei^ov

ae ;" to Kar

avT^v

Trjv

copav,

OTe

Trj

avKyj,

ov^evog TrapovTog, fxovog

^lXtirirog

t« NaBava^iX kot

lOtav irepi

Tov ^piaTov ^teXeyeTO.
**

Ylpo tov TrXrfatdaat ^e eiVev,
fxrj

"

tte dvy]p

laparjXtTrjg, ev

w ioXog ovk eaTt'" coare

vTroirTOV
tc5

yevea6ai 30

t^v fxapTvpiav, wg tov ^iXtnTrov irpo^^taXeyPevTog
irept

"KptaTw

Te T^f avK^g,

Trepi

m t€

eXdXriaev' o9ev eKeivog

ano tc tov

Katpov, diro re tov tovov, diro t€ tov ^ev^pov, diro tc tou t>;v
yvcofKrjv

avTOv e^erdaat fxera aKpt^etag, avvt^m rtg eartv, diro-

Kpt6e\g

eme'

'^

pa^^), av

et

6

Tiog rov Seov,

aii

et

^aatXeiigSS

II.
**

I.

I12ANNHN EYArrEAION.
Tavra
Se otto iroXk^i
6

197

Tou 'Icrpa^X."
(7v
ety

X«pa? e<p6ey^aT0' tovt
6
^vjTovfxevos,

€<TTty

<f)y]a-lv,

eKcTvos

irpoa^oKafMevo^f

Kai

vpo T^f ^i^aaKaXia^.
"A^iov
vayjXf

te

Kat ^rjTi^aaty Tivog evtKev Tiov Qeov eiirm o "NaSairpo

Kat
;

twv

aYjfj.eta>Vf

ovk

efxaKapiaBfi,

KaQa-nep
to.

Kat

o

$

YleTpo^

OTi

ov

fneTa

tyjs

avTyjg

^tavotag

eKaTepog

avTa
tov

e(f)6ey^aTo prjfj.aTa.

'O

fxev

yap YleTpog

wfJioXoyi^aev

Tiov

Qeov, wg 0ecv

aXyjQyj^ o

te

Naflava^A wi avSpanov
*'

xptXov'

Kat

Tovro ^yjKov eK tov enreiv avTOv,
6

av

et o

(3aatXevi; tov
fx.ovov

lapaiqX..

^e

Tov Seov Tlo;, ov tov laparik eaTt

^aatKevg^ akXa lo

Kat Tyfi oiKOVfxevyji aTrdayji.

Ata

he

tov eiireh tov ^ptaTOv,
Kat Ta
egi^i, airo

airapTt oxpeaoe tov ovpavov aveayyoTa,

"

avTOv KaTa fKiKpov avdyet^ Kat
av6p!i}7rov

Trotei

fxrjKeTt

<f>avTd^ea6ai avTOV
OfXoXo-'

dTrXwg,

dkXa

Kat twv AyyeXccv ^ea^roTyjv avTOv
'^taKovovat, Kat
e(f>

yyjaat.

w*^

yap AyyeXoi

ov

AyyeXoi avapat- 15
eiy}

vovat Kat KaTaj3atvovatf irag dv6pco7rog ovTog av

rptXoi

;

TavTa

^e Ta

Trep]

tuv ^AyyeXwv, €Kl3yjaea6at ey-eXXev

eirt

tov

(TTavpov Kat Tyjg dvaX-^eug.

KE4>. A.
Hfpi Tov iv Kara
I
yd/jLOV.

20
l^ovTeg,

KaXovatv

elg tov ydfLcv tov Kvptov, oyp^ cog 6avfj.aTa
cog yvtj)pifj.ov'

ovQe ug ft.eyav^ T<va, dXX! aTrXag

o6ev tovto ayjfj.ai-

vwv
**

^vayyeXtaTvig (pyjaf
avTov
Tov
eKei'"

*'

yjv

^e

17

(«•^t^JO

tov

I^ctoD

Kat

ot

aoeX<pot

wavep

ovv

eKetvyjv

Kai

Toiig

d^eX^povg,
eirettyf

oi/TW

Kat
etg

I>;o-oDv

eKaXeaav'
t>jv

avTog Ve irapaytyveTat,

25

ovK
xypi

T>jv

a^iav ecopa

eawToy,

aXAa

"irpog

tvjv

evepyeatav

yifj.eTepav.

'O ydp

fMj

dira^tco^Tag

yeveaBai

'^ovXog,

iroXka

fjJaXXov ovK av dirrj^ifoae
fJ.i^Tpt

etg ydfj.ov eX6etv.
Trep)

Elo^fv ew^Afle le
oivov

t^

avTov fxeydXa Xoytaaa6at
fxev
yj

avTov "
t>;v

ovk eyovat ;"
yevofj.eva^o
ayjfieiov

irpaTov

avXXyjxpig,

Kat

toc

vept

avXXyjrpiv
y}

avavTa
evotyjaev,

ovoe

yap vatg wv eQavfj.aTovpyyjaev,

Kav

ev

e?re;S*?

H
eiretTa
*>

5>\

oe xat ota to aKVjKoevat avryjv, OTt

^5,\\»
Cod.

eft.eXXev

av iravTayov direX6e7v ^ dKoyj avTOv.
/

>\

r/

t

ir

>

^
ot

1

i

\

iccavvyjg

avTOv

Est

lac. in

c «?

Cod.

d iMyeiXa Cod.

198
"^jkQe,

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
Kai OTi

II. 5.

avrm

eixaprvp-^a-e, Kai ori fJiadi^TYiV co"5^f, ^ia tovto
eKeivrjv

XoiTTOV 6appov<Ta

iTapaKaKu' €(3ov\€to yap Kai

KaTaBeaSai

"^apiv, Kai
**

eavTfjv Xa^irpoTepav zro/^cra/ '^ia tov irai^og.

To

Se

T^

efxoi
fj.fj

Kat

<70t yvvai ;"

TavTfjg evcKev Trjg Trpocfidaewg eXeyev,

(oare

vTroTrTevQ^vat ro yivofj.evov 6avfji.a.

Kai yap ov iiapa

t^^^
ydp
roTg

fxyjTpog

TrapaKXfjQ-iqvai
oiKeicov

e^p^v,

dkka

Tiapd

rm

teoixevav'

tj

Ttapa

TcSv

ytvofJ.evv]

TiapdKX^^cng

aKdvdaXov TtKrei
01

opxai, Kav fxeydka

jf

ra

yevofJi.evaf

or dv ^e

xpeiav eypvreg
Kat

avToi

^ewvr aif

dvvTiozTOV

ro

•npdyfj.a

ytverat^

Ka6apog
10

enaivog.

5

To
vog,

Se

*'

ovTid}

yj

wpa

fxov tjKet,^^ ovk avdyKf]

Katpav vnoKetfJieTictyjryjg

oiite

lopag

Tiapa-iyjpovfxevog,

nag ydp
;

rwv Katpm
ort

Kat yjpdvm Kat

almav

tyip.tovpyog

dkk

iidvra fxera rov

Katpov rov iipoayjKovrog epyd^erat, Of)^ 6 fnev iiavra noiccVf enet

avyyyaig rtg efxekkev
roig TiokkoTg, Kai ovte
Tiept
*

eivat

Kai dra^ia.

K^iet

ovv

a^yjkov yjvi^

ov^te

rav fj.a6^Twv rov yopov Tiavra eiyev, akk
;

01

ev

rw

ydfnco avrov y^eaav

^ ydp av avrot TipoayjkQov Kai
(pyjaiv,
rj

rov

o"tvov

napeKdkovv
vj

ev

%p€'a KaTaardvTeg^ Ota rovro
1 tvog

ovTioi

vjKei

wpa

fiov.

be eveKev
;

etiicov,

ovtico yjKei

*'

copa

fxov" Kai iiapatryiadfj.evog, eiipa^e
ryjv

'^etKvvg

fxev

rov

fxyi

20

cjopa

avrov vnoKeTaSat, enetra Ve Kat

fxyiTepa rtfLcov, tva
avryjv,
vj

fj.y]

^o^y]

eTimokv

dvrikeyetv

Kat

Karaiayyveiv

Kat
/A^Tijp

tva

fXYf

daSeveiag kd^ri VTiovoiav.
'*

ToTg ^e tiaKOvoig einev

avrov,

ri

dv keyyj

vfj.Tv,

iioiriaare^^ coa-re nketova yeveaGat ryjv aiTrfori

civ.

AeT ydp
ft.y]

et^evai

ovk daQevetag

ijv

yj

Tiapatryjatg,

akka 25

rov

'^o^at entppiiiretv

eavrov roTg 6avf/.aTovpyoTg.

6
iva

^^X
fj.yj

dnkcog Se
rtveg

e<7re

" Kaid rov Ka6aptafj.ov

rm

lov^hatm^^

dkk

rm

dTnarcov vnoTirevacoaiv ort rpvyia rig

eva7iofj.et-

vaaa, etra rov v^^arog eiit{3krj6evrQg Kat KpaOevrog, olvog keTtro-

rarog yeyove,
enetVt}

'^eiKvvatv OTt
r]v r]

ov^enore eKeTva yeyovev
yjv

o'tvov

'hoyeTa'

30

ydp

dvv^tpog

Ylakatartvy], Kat ovk
rvjv

nokkaypv
fJt.y]

Kpy]V^v

evptaKetv, enk-^povv dei
Tiorafj.ovg,
ei

vtptav v^^arog, coare

rpeyeiv eig
eyetv

Ttore

dKdSaprot yevoivro,

dkk eyyv6ev

rov

Ka6apfj.ov Tov
Tipivt

rponov.
Tr]v

ovk enoti^ae §e ro rovrov -Tiapo^o^orepov
v^piav

yefj.ta6y]vat

v^arog, e^ ovk ovxog olvov

tr]fj.iovp-

^S

II. lo.

mANNHN
oiitDi

ETAITEAION.

199
Aux, tovto

y^aas,

evnapd^eKTCtv fxakXov. lo Bavfxa yevrjrai.

To/vuv (V aTTa<Ti Tav BavfxdTav "TreptKoirTei to fjicyedo^ €KO)v.

Ov

vap-^aye
TOVTO

^e

avTog to
tva

v^copf

dkXa

Toii

^iaKOVois

avveyapyicre

TT0ivi(7atf

avTOvg [xdpTvpai
fieTpYjTVjg
TTotei

c^^tj

tov ytvofxevov.
TrevT-^KOVTa. $
6

'AMMflNioT.

'O

^eaTag CKaTov

A/a

Be T6i)
ij

fnYi

etiteh Ttvag, oti fieSvovTCtiv avQpuTToov
^te(f>6apu.evv]
'^ta

cvXkoyog
ttaKphai

^v, Koi

ala^trig avTccv

Kat

ovy^

iKavrj

voTCpov vta>p ^ oivog eivat to tiotov,
TpiKXtvoi ^oQrivat
«r/o-Taafle,
KO(Tfji.oa

tovto KeXevet tco dpy^ioi

tc5

vy)(f>ovTt'

Kat yap

ToiavTyjv
oi

^taKovtav,

a)g

TteTnaTevfxevot,

fxdktaTa eiaiv

vyj(f>ovT€Sf

iore

ev

lo

Kai To^et irdvTa "htaTtQeaQiu avTOvg.
o

10

Ttvog eveKev tov vvfx^piov etpavyjaev
^iaKOvovg
vofJLiav
;

dpyjiTptKXtvog,
e^€Kakv(p9-)^.

ov Tovg
oiKO-

ovtco

yap av Kat tq
y}peft.a

6avfi.a

KaT

Ttva yeyove tovto.

yap Kat KaTa

fxtKpov 6 X.piaTog
eXe-^^dvif

e^ovXeTO yvxaBrivat to
01

(jyjfj.eliov.

E^ yap totc

ovk av 15

^tdKovot ^tyjyovfkevot

TovTa

eTttaTevByjo-av,

aXX

eto^av av fxat-

veadat, dvSpwira xptXio eivat ^oKovvTt TOtavTa fLapTvpovvTeg.

AvTOt
eTepovg

fnev

yap

01

^tdKovoi ^ia T^g itetpag to

aa(f>€g

eyvaaav,
oii^e
e/7rov*

^e

ittaTovaOai,

ovk

yiaav

iKavot

tot€'

^id tovto

avTog e^eKdXmpev aitaai
fL€Ta

7tapayjpy]fji.a,

ovTe

eKehoi totc

20

yap t^v twv
oSev Kat

ay]fjt.et(i}v

evi^et^tv,
"^id

Kai tovto

efxeXXev eivat
t>^v

TttaTov.

fSaaiXtKog
'hia

tovto avTOv itpog

tov itai^og
TteTtotrjKevai
**

vyietav itpoaeKaXeaaTO,

to fj.aBeh tovto

avTOV

to ayifxehv'
**

OTtep

Kai itapd^yjXov
oivov.^^
oii'^

¥!tvayy€XtaT^g eXeyev
eTtoty^ae,

ottou oivov

eitotyiae

to v^ap

ditXag ^e oivov

dXX

25

KaXXtOTOv.

TotavTa yap tov "KptaTOv Ta BavfxaTa, TtoXXiov Tav

^ta TVjg (fjvaewg TeXovfxevoov apaiOTepa yiveTai Kat ^eXTto}.
/xev

Tou

ovv TO

v^oop oivov Ttotyjaat

Tovg ^taKovovg fxdpTvpag eiye, to
vvfj.(f>tov'

Se KaXov yeveaOat, tov dpy^tTptKXivov Ka\ tov

aitep aa(f>€-

aTepa yeyove tov
TcSv

'^jiovov

TtpoiovTog,

KaBdvep Ka\ eTepa itXelaTa^o

ayjfLeiav

ag itpoTepov dfj.vtpoT€pag ^ef^BevTa. OTt ^e eiVev
eTtoti^ae tvjv
eiitov

^vayyeXtaTyjV, "TavTVjv

apyy^v twv ayifxetwv
Ttpayjv, oti Tiveg

\yiaovg

"

ev

Kava

T-ijg

TaXtXaiag,^^
ei

Kai

Kat dpyyiv
'E-yo)

TavTyfv
vTtep

eivai

(paatv,
fi.€v

Kat itpoaKetTat to ev Kava.

^e

TovTov

ov^ev dKptPoXoyyjaatfjLyjVy

dXX

OTt

fiev

fxeTa

T035

200
/3dTrTta[Jia

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
twv
aYjfxeiav vjp^aTOf Kat

II. 13.
e^T^kaaafj.eV e/re

efXTrpoaSev

&e TovTOf etT€ €T€/3ov avjfxehv eyeveTO TrpoTepoVf ov acpo^^pa ^tia^^^v-

pt^ea9at dvayKa7ov etvat
Tla>s ^e
et-yov
*'

[xot ^OKet.

ecpavepcoae t^v ^o^av avTov ;" ov^e
yeyevv7]fji,evw^f ei
fjiyj

yap

iroXXot irpoa-

T0T€

TCtf

01

^td^ovot Kat

dpy^iTpiKXtvog $

Kat
6avft.a

vvfj.(f)ios.

«AX

el

Kai

fj.vi

totc,

«AA vaTepov efneWov

tq

aKOvaeaSat aiiavTeg, o6ev Kat f^^y^t tov vvv a^eTat Kat ov

^teXaOev.

Tlwg ^e "Kat

ot fi.a6')^Tat

afToy eTTiaTevaav eU avTOV^
OTi irep tot€ •7ipoa6yjKyiv

ot

Kat irpo

TovTOv 6avfj.d^ovT€g avTOV

',

e^e^avTO Ttvaio

T^g

etg

avTOV

TitaTedig.

Ata

t/

KaTejSYj

elg

KaTrepvaovfii.
;

\piaTog

fj.€Ta Tvjg fJ.if]Tpog

avTov Kai twv d^ek(f)wv

^ia ttjv eig

fji.YjT€pa TtfKviv, 07r(cg

airoKaTaaTVjav] avTVjv Kat Toi/g d^eX(f>ovg, tva

fj.vi

iravTayov avrovg t€ Kat avTvjv eTrtavpvjTatf koi ovTcog irdXiv

€7rtXdl3v}Tat

twv OavfndTWV. Kat yap ^ta tovto (p^aiv,
l€poaoXvfj.a.
'hta

oti ov fj.€Ta 15

TroKXag

vjfj.€pag ave(Bvi etg

J2
eK

rio^ev ^e toDto §^Aov, OTt

tovto KaTe^v] eig KairepvaovfJ.;
ev avTV]^ ov
'^td

Tov

/ATj^e
01

ev

6avft.a

€pydaaa6ai
eKetvvjv

ydp

vytSog irpog

avTOV

e/j^ov

tvjv

noXtv

otKovvTeg,

tq a(po^pa virdp-

5^€/v ayToy^' tt€(j>6apfj.evovg'

Kai tovto e^-^Xcoaev 6 ^ptaTog etiraVf 20

" Kat av Kairepvaovfj.

v]

ecog

twv ovpavSov

v\pco6e7aaf'^ k. t. e.

KE4>. B.
Ilepl tS>v eK^XrjdfVTiov ck tov iepov.

13
'*

Atd

he

Tov

etTreiv

tov

FivayyeXtaTV]v to
vjfuv

** v]v

^e

eyyvg to
25

Ylda^^^a Tcov

lov^atcov/^ ^etKvvatv

OTt ov irpo iroXXav Trdvv

vjfxepuiv

Tov

Yldaya e^airTtaaTO.
iroXX^i^g

AveXdcov ^e etg
(f>v]at

Ta
yap

lepoaoXvfj.a

voteT irpdyfLa
XtaTV]g, OTt

av6evT€iag yefiov'

^vayye-

"

evpev ev

tw tepw Tovg
fj.ev

iroiXovvTag j3ovg Kai 7rpo(3aTCk^
(pv]atVj OTt

Kat Ta

e^vjg.

Kat ovTog

YAvayyeXtaTVjg

eK^dXXcov

Tovg Ka7rv]Xovg Kat eKetvovg Kat Tovg eKeT ^taTpij3ovTag, eXeye irpog 30
avTovg,

"

fj.v]

TroteiTe tov oikov
*'

tov YlaTpog

fj.ov

oIkov efj.7ropiov'*^ eVe^vjtvjtcov ei

pog ^e KvayyeXtaT-i^g

a^r-^Xatov

Xv]aTav" o6ev

KaTa tov

aSic.

II.

1

8.

liiANNHN ETArrEAION.
a(j.(f)OT€pa

201
€K€i
fx€v

avTOv Kaipov
•7rpo$

yeyovcv, aAA'
7roi€i'

ovk
Oio

ea-Tiv.

yap

avTO TQ TrdSoi cXSwv tovto
'^aix€vog "
(ov

Kai

(T<j)oopoT€pov toT(

\oyot<;

a-nyjKaiov

\yjaToov"

eKoikcacv'

hravQa

^e

ev

7rpooifJi.iots

Twv

ar][X€ia)Vf v(p€ifJi€va}i

t^

€'iiiTifJ.yia€i

K^^/jt^rjTai'

oQev €iKOf ^€VT€pov TovTo y€y€VYjaSai.

S
;

Kk^Hvo ^e
eire;^*;

od^iov

^rjT^aat, tivo^ €V€K€v avTO^ tovtq Tr€iioiriK€V

ejtxeAAev cv

o-a/3/3aTa) fle/jaTreue^v, Kai iioXXa €T€pa Ttoi^iv^
fjiv}

a

€^0K€t Tuv vofXdiV •napd.(3a(Xti €ivat, iva
ra) TlaTpi,
Trjv

^o^y

<ag

avTi6€0$ Ti^

Kai e^ €vavTiai yjKav
TVj^ vTTovoiag iToi^tTat
€'nt^€i^dfi.€vog

TOVTa
ov

TrouiVf €VT€v6€v t^j- Totav-

diopQioaiv'

yap av
o'ikov

6

ToaovTov

^Aovio

virep

Toy

o'ikov,

tov tov

^^airoTrjv

^fleT>jo"€*

Kat ov^€

aTtXiag

efe^SaAev,

aAAa

'7rapaK€Ktv'^vv€Vfi.€voi)i'

Koi yap
6

raf TpaTTC^ag dv€Tp€xp€f Kai to dpyvpiov e^e^yaev* ovk av ovv
€ig Kiv^vvovg

ptnTm

cavTOV vncp

Trjg

€VKoafi.tag

tov oikov, tov

^caTTOTOv Tov oiKov KaT^cppovrja^' Kai ovt\ e/7rev aTrXwg tov oikov 15
Tov aytoVf

aXXa "

tov oIkov

TotJ

YlaTpog

f/iov."

18

To
"

^e

€iv€iv avTovg,
Trjv
rjv,

" t/

arjfxeTov

^eiKvvetg rjfuv, oti
€ft.(f)aiv€t.

TOVTa
cttj-

7Tot€7g ;"

€aydTriv avoiav avToig

iioiov

yap

ft.€iov

y^€ta

waT€ Ta KaKoig
aia-^^vvvjg
;

y€voff.€va

navaai, Kai tov oikov
to

anaKkd^at ToaavTrjg
€K^aXX€tv
Kai
€1 fX€v

AfTO yap

ToaovTov

Xaov 20

VTt€p

Tov oiKov Tov Oeoy, fj.€ytaTov

ai^fi.€tov rjv

ap€Trjg'

€vyv<afi.ovag ^t€K€tVTO, a>g 01 ft.a6rjTat, ^vSiag

av cfiv^-

6r]aav to

"

^Ao$- tov oIkov aov KaTa(f>dy€Tai /a€'" wf &e T^g
eTrt^o^Toyv*

aXri6€iag

aft.€Toyot, ar]fi.€iov

odev (prjat

irpog

avTovgy

" \vaaT€

TQv vaov toDtov" Kat

Ta

e^^f.
ev

^5
yvfaaii

Ktpiaaot.
01

Kpavt^ovTat Koxa (^pay^v to

TeAe^ov

fxadi^Tai, Kai

Ta7g twv TtpayfkdTm CK^da^ai Ta y€ypafXfji.€va
rj^Yj

avf>.(3dX\ovT€g, TroXXrjv

hciKvvovat t>?v

e7r;
€t

to

ft.€7^ov lirt^oatv.

AMMflNIOT nPESBTTEPOT.

AvTt TOV,
r]fj.ag

Wg TlOg WV TOV &€0V
ar]fL€iov

Ta aapKiKa €K^dXX€ig,
€Tr€fJ.(f)6rjg.

ir^laov
OTt

tta

OTt

€K

S€ov3°

Aia tqvto

€tiT€v

" XvaaT€

tov vaov tovtov," 7va

^€i^r] OTt TrpoytvaaK^t

Ta
€tr]

jtxeTa

TaDTa
01

€aofj.€va.

E< ydp Kai tot€

fj.h r^Tropovv

to Tt av

tovto,

Se dfJ.(f)€^aXXov, aAA' vaTcpov

€ir€yvu)aav fJ.€Ta t»;v dvdaTaatv.

Ktpiaaot.

Ov

7rpoTp€7r€i

avTovg

eig

fj.tai(f)oviav,

" XvaaTC 35

Dd

;

202
*'

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
«AA
eirenrep
i^hei

II. 20.

Tov vaov TouTov," (iTTav,

tpaaovrag dvuTrep-

6eTCi)$

avTO, to avfxpvjaoixevov vitaivuTeTai,
f^^

20

YiniovTeg
Oou.y)6ri

eKe7voi

oti

*'

ev

TecraapaKovTa Kai e^ eTeaiv wkooiKo^oixyjv

vaog

oiiTog" Ty^v
eTccv

varepav

eOYjXcoaaV

yj

<yap

TipaTiq eig e'iKoa-1

dnyjpTiad^ yjpovov.

MeTa
yjv

Ve to eyepOyjvai 5

avTOV eK veKpxv

efxv^aQyjaav 01 fxaBrjTa) avTov, oti nepi tov vaov
eTrei^v]

tov aw[J.aTog avTov ekeyev,

tot6 ^vo

avTOtg ra Trpot-

aTafxeva Tecog, ev [xev to t^? dvaaTaaecog, eTepov Oe to tovtov
[ji.e7^ov,

el

Seog

rjv

6

evoiKoov'

aitep

diJ.<pOT€pa

i^vi^aTo

enrwv,

" Xvaare Kai eyepw."
Tivag Keyei TOvTOvg Tovg TttaTevaavTag
OTe
ev
To^ig

10
eig to

ovofna

avTOv,

'lepoao\vixoi$

ev

tw Tidaya

'fjv ;

tov^ npog oktyov
Kat
TJj

dvTeyofxevovg Tore t^ dXyjQeia, Kat TidXtv avTYjg eKTtfnTOVTag.

ydp Tav

dvSpooTrav

twv totc

01

fJiev

ToiovTot

vTivjpyov, ot

oe

TrAavTj Tipoaelyov'
vot

OTt ydp ovtoo yvriatag iitaTevadvTav vjaav eKei- 15
(pT^at

tetKvvatv

vj

eTraycoy^'

ydp,

*'

avrog ^e 6
'O^g

Ivjaovg

ovk

" efitaTevev eavTov avTolg^^ Kai Ta
Ta7g Kap^iaig,
t»jv

e^vjg.

yap efx^aTevwv

-npoaKatpov avrav BepfxoTfiTa el^ag aacpSig, ovk

eBdppet avTolg, ovte evey^etpii^e iidvTa
yevofjievotg.

Ta '^oyfxaTa ig

vj^y]

TitaTolg

20

KE$.

r.

Ilepi 'NiK.obrifiov.

I

Tig eaTtv ovTog
(patvofxevog virep tov

NtKody}fi.og

;

Kat ev

fjieaco

tw tov KvayyeXtov
vofxog yjfxav

\ptaTOv XaXwv ovTwg, "
Kat

Kptvet

" ovOeva,
7roAA>;v

dv

fxy]

TipoTepov dKovaf].^^
TVjg

fxeTa

tov

aravpov

oe 25

t>;v

eiitfj.eXetav

tov

'^eanoTiKov

awfxaTog <f)atv€Tat

Ky]^etav rnoiovfxevog.
oog eyjpyjv.

^teKeiTO fxev ovv iiept tov \ptaT0v,

aAA

Ofj^

eTt

ydp

Ty]g ^Xov^diKvig

etyeTO daOeveiag' tta tovto Kai

vvKTog yjXSe ^e^^otKwg ev Yjfxepa tovto iiotyjaat.

aAA

(ptXdvSpomog

\ptaTog ov^e
eXyjXvQe
Tipog Tov

ovTtog avTOv

diiwaaTO, ovt\ einovTt ojt aiio 0eoy 30

^i^daKaXog, ^t^Xey^ev avTOV Xeywv, rt ovv vvKTwp (pyyj

Ta Tov Qeov Xeyovra, Kai
^e

eKelBev vjKovra
ov^^eig

AetKvvat

Koi

€K tov

elneh tov NiKO^yjfxov, " OTt
Tioteiv,

"

'^vvaTai

Ta

ayjfxeia

TOVTa

d

av noteig, edv

fxvj

Qeog

III. 7**
v}

mANNHN
avTov"
^iaXeyeTai.
jaoy

ETArrEAION.
avTov
tvjv ^idvoiav
c/j^c,

203
Kat

ix€T

OTi avSpwirivifjv Trepi

a>i irepi irpocpYjTOv

3

T/
tid

60-Tiv

"

eav

ti$ yevvvjOy] dvco^ev, ov
;"

^vvaTai l^eTv

ttjv

" (3aai\€iav
KovTpov
TVjv

toi)

Qeov

edv

fXT]

ix.eTacryyi

Ilvev/xaTof 'Ayiov tov
Trepi

T^f

-naXiyyevealaq^ ov

^vvarai

efxov,

(pyjci, 5

^o^av

Trpoa-^Kovaav

Xa(Beh.

''Hv

yap

vvv e^^eig

'^o^av Trept

eixov, ov

irvevfJiaTiK'^

ecTiv,
rj

dWd

\pvy(^iKV],

Kai ov fxovog av,

akXa

Kav oaTig ovv eTepog
\etag eaTi.
eve«ev
e/Ve,
**

TotavTa

Trepi

efxov

^o^d^av, e^w rrjg /3aai6v]Xoi.

To
Traig

^e

"

dvcoQev^ eK

tov ovpavov ov

Tivog
i

^vvaTat yevvvjQYjvat avQpooTioi yepav uv ;" dno
7]

o

iroAA^f eKTtkYj^eagf aKovwv fxet^ova

itapd dvQpoynov.

To

Se Troig

TovTO

;

Twv

p,^ a(f>o^pa ntaTevovTCOv

eaTiV o$ev Kat KaTayekaaTa

Ta

p-^fxaTa (f)aivovTat.
etg

ov^e

yap

evevofjae yevv/iatv TrvevfjiaTiK-i^v,

aW

t^v aafxaTiKVjv yaaTepa KaSetXKvae T^g aapKog to fxeya
viIyjXov, elirav,
et^vjg.
^^

toyfxa Kat
Tpog,

fji^

^vvaTat eig

tvjv

KotXiav TVjg

fxvj-

15

Kat Ta

Avo
^

&€ ^v Toc 6opv(3ovvTa Kai airopovvTa avTOV,
v]

vi

Te yevvrjatg

TrvevfxaTtKvi,

Te /SaatXeoig'

ov^e

yap

ovofxa
Tiepi

(3aatXeT ovpaviov

vjKovaOv] TTOTe Trapd ^lov^^aiotg,

dXka

Ttvag

to icpoTepov taTa-

Tat,

b

fii.d\taTa

avTov

tv]v

^tdvotav
vvv

KaTeaetae.

Aio

Kat

20

^piaTog

aa(f)eaT€pov
Ttg

anoKaXvnTet
e^

T^f

yevvvjaecog Tpoirov etTim,
e^vjg.

"

edv

fjivi

yevvvjB^
<f>y]at,

v^aTog Kat •nvevfxaTog^^ Kat Ta
^eaiioTtKOv

'O ydp
Bavdrov

fxv]T:(ti,

Kafiwv to

avfx^oKov, to

tov

<f>opei

ev^^vfxa,

to t^? KaTdpag, to TVjg <f>6opdg.
6eia ev
^apv]'

E< yap
Td(f>ov

Kat v^ap vTtOKenat,

dkXa

avTa TeXeiTai avfx[3oXa
Kat

25

veKpwatg kat avdaTaatg Kai
evt
Tikelov

Tavra

oixov ytveTat aitavTa.
(f>v]at,

oe

avTOv

andym Tm
adp^

ata6v]Tm
to
^e

" to

yeyevv]-

"
**

fxevov

eK

t^^ aapKog

eaTt,

yeyevvjfxevov

eK Toy

TivevfxaTog nvevfxd c(7t/," tout
tv]v

eaTi TivevfxaTiKOV eari' yevvi^atv

ydp evTavQa
7

KaTa

Ttfxv^v

Kat '/dptv Xeyet.
Oavfxaav]g
;

30

i^ta Tt

etTiev

avTco,

fxv]

ota to toeiv avTOv eTt

Bopv/^ovfxevov,

^to

Kat eii aia6v]T0v dyet iiapd^etyfxa tov Xoyov
^vj

fxeaov aafxaTog t€ Kat daaifxdTaiv, Xeya)

tov dvefxov

tv]V (f)opdv,

etvwv,

"

TO Tivevfxa otiov 6eXet nveT." tovto Se

<f>vjaiv oyj^

ag

irpo-

atpeatv Ttva tov dvefxov eyovrog,

dXXa

tv\v

dno

(f>vaeo)g

(popav, 35

D d 2

204
Tvjv

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
aKCoXvTov Kai fxeT

III. ii.
tvjv (pwvy^v

e^ovaias

yivofxevrjv.

" Kai

avTov

" "

aKoveigy

TovTcaTi tov iiaTayov.

Lo Oe " ovk

oioe, TroOev epyeavefjLOVf

Tai Kai TTov vTiayei," to aKaOeKTov ^TjXor tov

Kai oti

"^iayjeiTai itavTayov,

Kai 6

KCtiXvcov ov^^ei^ Tyj^e

KaKeTae

(f)epea$ai.

Aia
"

^e Tov

elTreh,

" ovTwg

I^tI irag 6 yeyevv][xevo$ eK tov $
aitav ed^^Xcoaev.

7rvev[xaTog" to

av{j.TTepa<7fxa

E/ yap tovtov

(pYjai
Tyj

Tov

'TivevfxaTog,

TOVTeaTi tov ave^kov, ov t^v aia^r^aiv teyy\
•jrwi

aKorif Trjv opfxrjv

epixyjvevaai ovk oT^ag, ov^e tyjv o^ov,
Trepiepyoi^yj
7] ;

t*;v

ano Tov Qeiov YlvevfxaTog evepyeiav
ovTog
ov
6

Kai

ei

oitov Bekei

avefxoi TiveT, Ttoaa ixaXXov

tov Ayiov TlvevfxaTog Xoipig lo
aoofxaTiKrjg

Ovv/jaeTai
;

vofxa

(ftvaeas KaTaayeB^i^vai, ovte opoig

yevv^aecog

el

toivvv tov avffxov ovk

aayaXKeig,

(f)YjaiVf

qti

[xvj

opag, ov^e aTnaTeig ^ia tovto, t;
'Ayiov

'^vjTroTe Tiep)

tov Tivevf*.aTog tov
;

aKovm

iKiyyiag, kui ToaavTag aiianelg evQvvag

Aia

^e 15

rov eiTieh tov NiKo^yjft.ov,
Bavofxev

"

-Tiug

^vvaTai TavTa yeveadat ;"

fi.av-

em

Tyjg

lovSaiW^f evreXeiag avTOV eTi efxfnevovTa TavTa
eiiieTv

Xeyeiv.

Aia tov

tov \ptaTOV,

" av

ei 6

^i^aaKaXog tov
a(\>e-

"

^laparjX, Kai

TavTa

ov ytvaaKeig ;" ^eiKvvaiv avTOV atio

Xelag TavTa ^Qey^afxevov.
•jiaXata

E/ yap

avafi.vyja6yjg, (])rjat,

Ta

ev tyj

napa^o^a GavfnaTa yevofxeva, anQ tc tov npwTov avQpwTiov 20
€K Trjg iiXevpag avTOv
ev
(ov
rj

JTWf eTiXaaOri, Kat

yvvrj,

Ta

ev

AtyvnTW,
eTeKov, Kat

Kat

ev Tyj

epvGpa, Ka)
Ofxota,
cog

tyj

epyifxw, Kat

nag aTetpat
lapayjX,

Ta TOVTOig
Tiep)

^t^ixaKaXog

tov

ovh^

av Kat

&v Xeya vvv antaT^^ayjg.
^e,

11

To
ovK

"0

o*itafxev XaXovfxev,
efx(f>rjvat

Kat

eooptxKafxev fxapTvpovfiev," 2c,
(f)Vjatv,

otpiv

aiaQriTyjv

povXofxevog tovto
ot^af/.ev" rjTot
fxovov.

aXXa

tv}v

aKpt^rj

yevvyjatv.

to

^e

"

nepi

avTov Kat

tov

YlaTpog Xeyet, ^ nept eavTov

Kai

ov^e ovtw,

«j^^o"',

"

t»/v

fxaprvpiav rifxav Xafx^dveTe" to
Tipoava(f>ava>v,

avfx^yjaofnevov, riyovv
*'

Trjv

omtaTtav avTwv

"

et

Ta 30

e-niyeta ehov vfx7v," TOvreaTt Tiept tov (SaiiTtafxaTog, Kat t^? Kora yaptv yevv^aexg, " Kat ovk eTitaTevaare, nag eav eni'j) " vfxh To. eTiovpdvta," TOVTeaTt, iiept Trjg anopp-^Tov Kai a(f)dTov

yevvrjaeoog

ntaTevaeTe

;

12

To

^e

"

eiiiyeiQv" evTavQa, rtveg

fxev

(f)aat

iiept

tov avefxovSS

III. 14.

mANNHN

ETAITEAION.
t«v

205
^e^coKa, Kat
;

elpijaGatt tcvt€(ttiv, ei

vtro^eiyfxa «tto

Iniydm

ov^€ ovTa)( htetaSyjTf, iras ^vv^aeaGe to. avwTepa fi.aBeh

el

^e

TO ^aTtTtafxa httyetov evTavda KaXet, ^ta to ev
irpog a.ytaa[t.ov
II)

ttj

yyj TieXeiadai

tuv

eirt yy]<;

ovtoov

avBpwTim.

Kirtyetog KaketTat

Tov XovTpov yevvvjatgf irpog avyKptatv T^g yevv-^aea>g tqv
Trjg

Irjaov^

T^f €K
**

ovaiaq tov Ylarpog yevofxevyjs.

"

ov^e]^ dvaPePyjKev

6i$

tov ovpavov^^ Kat to. e^rjii tva tov NiKo'^YifJ.ov ^topOaayjTat.
eiiiev

Evet yap
TOVTOV
Tovg

eKe^vog,
(pyjatv,

oti
oti

aTto
fxyj

%eov

eXy\Kvbe
fxe

t^daKaXog^

ydptv TovTO

vofxt^eTe

^t^daKaXov ag
ovpavoii

iroXXovg

twv w^o^ijtcSv

aito

y^g ovTagy e|

yap lo

TTapetfxi vvv.

14

T/ov Se dvBpamov evTavBa ov t^v adpKa

eKdXeaev, aAA* dvo

T^f eXaTTOvof ovatag eavTOv,
avofxaae vvV
6eoTy]Tog,

tv

ovTCog

etiro},

T^f dvQpanoTi^Tog

Kai yap tovto e6og avTco iioKXdKtg fxev d^no Tyjg
dito
Trig

noXXdKtg Ve

dvSpaTroTvjTog
e^tt

to

iidv

KaXeiv. 15

OvK
"

etite Oe, oV; fjLeXXco

aTavpova6at, dXX'
etitcbv,

tov itaXatov Tintov

Ttapeitefxy^e

Tovg aKpoarag
ev

"

Kai

Ka6(ag

MoJvV^f

vi\j'j3ae

Tov

0(f>tv

T^

epiy/xcc." irpaiTOV

fxev

tva fxd6a}fxev, oti avyyevyj

Ta TtaXata

Tolg Katvolg, Kat

ovk aXXoTpta tovtcov eKetva' eitetTa
to itdBog
ep^^^erat'

tva yvwfxev, OTt

ovk aKwv

eitt

itpog TovTotg te

20

tva Xoyt^cofxeda tovto

a-navTeg, oti el itpog etKova '/aXKrjv o(pe(Dg

PXeitovTeg

lov^aiot

Ote(pevyov

6dvaTov,

itoXXoo

fxdXXov

elg

tov

aTavpcofxevov ittaTevovTeg, fxei^ovog KaTa^tovfxe6a aooTyjpiag.
etTtav

Ylpo-

Toivvv

ryjv

fxeytaTVjv

etg

avBpwTtovg yeyevyjfxev^v

'^td

tov
tvjv

j3anTtafxaTog

evepyeatav,

eityfyaye

Kat t^v TavT-^g aiTiav,

25

Ota Tov aTavpov.

AifflMaNiOT nPESBTTEPOT.
aafxa, Ttddeat yap
vitOKetTat,

OvK

eaTtv ovpdvtov TO Tov Kyp/ow
eig
cov

wg Ve

Ka\

fxeTa

aapKog,

XeyeTai vtog

dv^pcaiiov.

ToT
coa-Jtep

attot.

Atto T^f eXdTTovog ovaiag oXov eavTOv ovofxd^ei,^o

Kat aito Trjg 6eoTy}Tog oXov eavTOv KaXe7.

ToT
aXX
fxev

ATTOT.

Q.anep

"x^aXKovg

o(f)ig
yj

ovk

y]v

to /o/SoAov

6i^ptov,

Ofxotwfxa
viv

tov to(3oXov, ovtco Kat
aX-^6etav,

aap^ tov Kvptov, adp^
Ofxotcofxa

Kora

ov

fxyjv

adp^ dfxapTiag, dXX^

aapKog dfxapTiag.

35

S

206

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
ATTOT.

III. 16.
Kai eniayjfjiov

ToT
16

To

vxpooG^vai

^i^Xoi

ro

e{Jicf)aw^vat

yeveadai tov HpiaTOV.

OvTco yap

7]ya7rr)a€v 6 Geos"

tou

KOcrfJLOi/,

SaTe tov

Ylov avTOv Tov
AnoAiNAPioT.
[xekXco

fxovoyevrj iScoKev.
"^O Xeyei, roioinov eari' iva
jt*>;

6avfxda-v]^ el

eyw

vxpovaSai,

aad^^re

vfxelg'

Kai yap to5 Ylarpl rovro
virep rcov

^OKei, Kai

ovrcog vfj.ai vjydiTVjaev,

wg

^ovKccv ^ovvai

rov

Tlov, Kai

tovXm

dyvccixovoov% Kairoi ovk dv rtg ov^e

vTrep (piXov

rovro

TToiyjaetev.

'OpirJENOTS.

IlapaKkr/9eti

6

Seog, v^coOi^vai rov eavrov Xlov 10

evhoKvjaev, iva iidvreg 01 ^ia Trtarecog elg avrov opcavreg,

diraWdraicovtov

rxvrat
eyjoat'

rrjg

rav

irvevfJ.ariKwv
alcovtog

O(f>ecov
>}

(SxdfSrjg,

Kat

^covjv

^»^ ^e

ovk eartv

Kotvvj,

^rtg Kat erepotg ^cootg

VTcapyet,

aW
*'

eK irtarecag Kat rr^g KotTirig apervjg eyyiyvofj.evv].
iiiarevcov
etg

To

^e

iva irdg

avrov

[xi^

aTroXvjrat,^^ Kai
01

ra 15
rov rov

e^vjg, ^v]\o7 rvjv

eK rov

aravpov
ocpiv,
ot

acorvjpiav, ort

[xev

Tipog

rvTTov,

vjyovv

rov

yaXKOvv

rore
Ve

^keitovreg

iov^halot,

TipoaKaipov hiecpevyov Bdvarov,

Tipog

r^v aXrfietav, rovreari

Tov aravpov vvv opoovreg iiiaroi, rov aicovtov oia(pevycofj.ev Sdvarov'

Kat rore
vvv

f>.ev

^vjyfxara

o<f>ecov

idro

6 KpefJ.dfj.evog ocpig,

evravSa ^e 20
ntarcov

Tov

vovjrov

tpdKovrog Bepaitevet rdg nXrfyag eK

rcov

aravpoiSttg

^piarog.

To " ovrcog vjydTirjaev^^ eliicbv, tioXXvjv ^etKvvat rvjv entraatv' Kat ro " 6 Seog rov Koafnovj'^ noXv ro fxeaov rvjg ^tacpopdg ^vjfxtovpyov Kat
Tioivjfxarog.

25
TidXiv KotvoTioieT ro Tidv, ovk el^ag ycoptaft.ov

^MMnNioT. 'O^e
fxerd
^covjg,

rviv

evcoaiv'
'^oSeiavjg

rvjg

ydp aapKog

reQeiavjg vnep r-^g rov Koafxov

Kat

eig ddvarov,

Tiog Xeyerai '^e^oaSai etg rov
rvjg

6dvarov, Kainep
arjg

dna^g
O/

fxeivag

ag Qeog,

avrov fxov^g riaayov-

rd

'ihia

aapKog, ore avveycopet Kat

vjBeXev.

30

ToT
Tiog

ATTOT.

Apeiavot Xeyovaiv, ort ^td rovro KaXe7rat
fxovog

fxovoyevrig, ori

Ik Seov yeyove' npog ovg XcKreov,
fxovoyevrj,

ort Kai rov ^Xtov riveg

Xeyovai

Ka6o

vjXiog fxovog

eartV

dXX^ ovKert Ka\ Tiog eartv.
*
ivyvccfA.,

Cod.

III. i8.

mANNHN
tvjv TVji

ETArrEAION.

207

Ka)
ovK

TO TiporjQe.hai rov Tiov avrov tov aovoyevvi Kai ov ^ovkov,
ayaTiYig
v7repl3oXr]v
TrapiaTyjcriv.

AyyeXoVf
**

Kivwv

Se OTt

e^ooKe" (xwe^JKiaa-fxevag to irdOog vjvi^aTo.
diro Tov irdSovi Kep^os (7a(f>e(XTepov Troiav eir-^yaye XeycDV,
6
TricrTevaiv

'O ^e
**

iva

irag

eig

avrov
ei(nv

fxr)

aTrokfjrai,

a\k

e-)(Yi

^(tivjv

$

aKeviov.
yeyevy)[j.evr},
*'

Kai

eTreih^
yj

hvo

ai

A.picrTov Trapovaiai,

rj

ypy)

kou

fji.e\\ov(Ta, irept

T^g irpoTepag vvv Xeyei, oti
iva Kpivr]

ovK aTre^TTeiXev

o

@eo$ tov Tlov avroy,
ev

tov Koa-fxov,
7rapovai(x.

" d\X
evi

iva a-aa-y] tov Koa-[xov.^^

yap

Trj

^eyrepa avrov
eKdaTio

ro

Kphai irapayiyveTai,

Kai

dirotovvai

Kara

ra lo

epya avrov.

KxpiAAor.
Kpivcov rrjv
Tvjv

OvK

direareiXe,

<py)(yi,

Kara Mcoo-ea

vOjaco

KaTa-

oiKovfJievyjV,

ovhe irpog eAe-yj^ev ryjg dfxapria^; eiacpepct}
'7roiov[J.ai

evToX^V ov^e oiKeriKyjv

r^v ^iaKoviav,

dXXd

^eaTroryj

irpeirovcrav tyiv <f>iXav6pcoirtav eia-(pep(o'

eXevQepv ro tovXov (cgTiogx^
rov

Kai

KXyjpovofXog

rov

Ylarpog,

fitTaa-Kevd^x

Kara^iKd^ovra

vofJLOv elg

^iKaiova^av ydpiv.

AMMftNioT.

E/

eiri

ro KpHvai rov Koa-fxov eXyjXvdei
TrpoYjyovfxevcag

o

'Kpiarog,

irdvrag KareKpivev'
Koafxov.
Kpivei

dXXa

yjXQev

eiri

ro

aaaai rov

te

Kara ro
vofxog

avf/.l3e(3yjKog

rovg

aTriaryjaavrag. 20

oy^

(tig

Is/liovaeccg

y]X6e

KaraKpivai rov Koafxov,

aXXa

awaai.

18

1*

eariv,
l3iov

marevjjv
e-yy]
y]

eig rov Tiov ov Kpiverai

;

ri

ovv, eav
fxev

aKdBaprov

Trpd^eig ovk

dyaSdg

;

fndXiara
**

rovg

roiovTOvg, ov^e yvr,atovg eivat iriarovg 6 YlavXog 4>y]ai,
**

Seov yap 25
evravda
fxev

OfxoXoyovaiv ei^evai, roTg te epyotg dpvovvrai'"
(f)y]atv,

TrXv]v

fKeivo

oti

Kar

avro rovro
^waei

ov

Kpiverai,

aXXa rav

irovyjpm epyvv yaXeTrcoTepav

^iKy]v,

dTrtartag Se eveKev ov

KoXd^erat ^ta ro Triarevaai aira^.

Ktpiaaot.
KaXeiadat
irpog

YlpoTi6y]fi.i

roivvv
Se

nx

iriarevovTi

yepag ro
etg tyjv

fny]

30

Kpiaiv, tc3

d7ret6ovvTi KoXaatv'

avrrjv

K at
ry]V

fxiav ^i

dfX(poh dvacf^epoov o^ov, Kat rovi /xev e(f>eaei
<f>o^(o

ryj irepi

ydpiv, rovg te

rov iraBeTv,

em

ro iriareveiv etvai irpo-

Bvfxag avyKaXJov.

'Ammcniot.

^yjfiieKoreov

ort

KaBoXiKwg Trag

fxy}

irtarevuvSS

;

208
6/V

EPMHNEIA
Tov

EIS

TO KATA
ryj

III. 19.
amoodvjaofJ.€vos'
ovrco

XpiCTTOV

KaraKpirog eari

KoXdcrei
vj^r]

ovKOvv ovT€ ouyovrai ovroi elg Kpiaiv a^

KaraKpiOevreg'

Kai

eiri

rov ^ia^oXov vovjreov, ori

6

ap^/wv rov KoafJLOv rovrov

K€Kpirat,

o^ fjiovov

ori avrog ovk

iTria-revaev,

dXka

Kai eveipaae

rov

Kvpiov, Koi

elg
[xy]

tov ^lov^av daYjX$ev, \va Tiapo^Si avrov eig 5
Trtareviov
^^vj

Qdvarov.
aTTtareiv

"

Ve

KeKpirai.'^
elvai
yj

Ttwg

;

ori

avro ro

KoXaaig eart' ro yap eKrog
ej^e;

Toy (parog, Kat

Kara

rovro

fMeyiarrjv
6

ttjv

rtf^wpiav'
f(.Yj

ro fueXXov iipoavat^mel'

KaSdirep yap
^iKaaSyj, ryj

(povevaag, Kav

r^ ^"^(p^ tov Kpivovrog Kara-

rov 'Trpdyff.arog Kara^^e^iKaarat <pvaet, ovrco koi
Aoafji Oe
ij

010

aittarog,

Kai
e^yj,

YjfJ-epa

ecpayev aito rov qvXov, aTiemve,

Kai rotye
redvyjKag
etireTv,
*'

aXXa

ryj

aTtocpaaet Kai ryj rov Tipayfi.arog <f)vaei
'tta

yjv.

ATToarepeT ^e avrovg Kat aitoXoytag "ndayjg

rov

"

ort yjXde ro (f>ag eig rov Koafji.ov, Kai yjydiryjaav ot av6pa-

7101

fx,aXXov TQ aKorog."
(f)(ort

Ttg

ovv rov

fjiyj

^ovXofji.evov

dno aKO-

15

Tovg

7rpoaeX&e7v eXerjaetev dv
eXy}Xv6ei
etg
ot

19

E^

fj^,y]

rov Koafxov to
fj.yj

</>»f,

e/p^ov

ayvotav

rm

KaXm

airtdaaaSai,

Ttpd^avreg avrd'

wg av rag KaKiag
f/.i^

evepyovvreg, ronov aitoXoyiag elyov, (jydaKovreg,

eyvwKevat avra
Koaf*,ov, Ttdafjg

ovra KaKd.

dXX

enet

ro

(f)wg

eX^XvQev eig rov

20

TteTtXaafxev^g ditoXoytag (pvya^evofj-evotg, Kpiaig earat e^eraariKyj
Tftjv

TtpaKrewv Kat toD (f)pov^ft.arog e^ CKdarov aTio^eyPyivat' Kai
(f)wg,

^aaiXeiag Seov rvyeh rovg dyaTtyjaavrag ro
TTpog

wg eK t^?

avro ayairyjg (pwg Kat avrovg
<f)povyjfxarog
yj

yeyevi^ff.evovg ^i

epywv dyaSwv
€£7t/i;,

Kat

aXyfiovg fj.tayjaai ro

aKorog, rovro ^e

^25

KaKia Kai

evae(3eta'

rovg &e dTtoarpa(pevrag t^v dperyjv kou

rov ravryjg Ttdpoyov Qeov KoXdaewv aiwviwv TtetpaaQyjaeaBat' eiteiTtep

aitov^^d^ovreg ej^eiv

epya

Ttovyjpd, ef/.tay]aav

ro (pwg ^td (pave-

pwaewg eXey^^wv avrwv rd (pavXa.
'

\va ^e

fj.y]

rtg

etity],

ort

ov^^etg

av ro aKorog
yjg

irportfjLyjaete

toi;3°
y]v

(pwrog, rt6y]ai

Kat

Toyv

atrtav,
itovyjpa

a(p

rovro eitaQov, Xeyet
e^yjg.

'*

" ydp
yap
6

ayToJv," <py]ai,

"

ra epya^ Kai rd
ryjg

^ETtet^yj

\ptartavtaft.og

fj.erd

twv

'^oyfj.drwv

opQorvjroc,

Ka\

TtoXiretav
"^elaGat

vytatvovaav aitatret, avroi Se /3ovXovrat det eyKaXtvdfj.apriag ^op/3dpx, ^td rovro

rw t^^

ovk y]6eXY/aav

01

rdsS

III. 22.

mANNHN
Koi
To^ig
vofi.oiff

EYArrEAION.

209

<f>avka irpda-aovTe^ fji.€ra$€a6ai irpog
viafji.ovy
<f>vj(x)vf

ro (ra<f>pov^ rov \pi<7Tta'Torf
Ift.oii.

VTrojSaXuv

X^r^

§6

(TKOTTYiaaif itiag

airo^Trepet

avrovg vda-rj^ airoXoyiag ro «^wf,
Trpo^Je^^pafxov avrSi,

eXBav irpoi avTovg^ Kai ovhe ovrto

aW

eKehoi

"

irotwv ryjv aX-^detav

epyerai irpog ro
iva
<f>avepa}6^

<f>ag" o toS Xpt<XTtavt<rfXW

5

"Kpoar peywv ^rjXovort,
**

"

avrov ra epya, ort

ev

tw

06W

eartv etpya(7fji.eva." Kat
op&rjv
;

yap

6 toiovtos fxera

rov irt(XTeveiv

opBSii

Kat TtoXtretav

KaropBol.

l(7a)g

epel rtg, rt ovv

ovk eiat Kat Xptartavot <f>avXa irptxa<f>iXocro(f>i(x.

(70VTeg

Kat

EAAijvef ev
e/cr/v,

^wvreg
ei

;

'Kptariavoi
'

ft.ev

OTt \o

<pav\a vpaaaovTeg
f3tovvTegf rovro
etiryjg eTrteiKeig

oi^a Kaytbf
(xa(f)iOi.

te Koi
fiot

EAAiyvec op6cig
diro
<f>va-e<i)g

ovK oToa

My] ydp

Tag

Kat KoafKiovg, ov yap eart tovtq dperri.

aAA

etire

voXXtjv VTrofcevovra dito rov ira^elv ^tav Kat <f>tXo(TO(f>ovvTa,

aXX

ovK av exotgKoi
aAA>j

E/ yap ^aaiXetag eirayyeXia Kat
fJLoXig

yeevvrjg direiX^, 15
dperrj,

eTrtfkeXeta,

Kareyet

rovg dv^ptomvg ev
ireTretafi.evot

aypXf)
aperriv'

ye
ei

av

01

wepi

fjLVj^evog

tovtwv

ft.eT'fjXv6ov

riveg

viroKptvovrat

%o^rjg eveKev
e^yj,

rovro TrotovaiV

Se

Oo^rjg

eveKa rovro Troim orav
eTri6vfj.iaig

ov (petaerai tou

yaptaaa^ai
20

ratg

raTg

irovrjpaTg.

KE^. A.
ZriTT]<ris

Tvtpi

Kadapurfiov.

22
'*

Ata

Tov

eiTreiv

ort

"

fji.era

ravra e^^X^ev
ev fxev

l^aovg eig t^v
raig eopraig etg

lovoatav
TroXiv
rrjv

Kat ra
dvirj,

e^rjg,

QeiKvvatu ort

rrfv

ware

ev fjiiaotg

avroTg irportBevat

ra

'^oyfj.ara,

25

Kai

diro

rav

6avfji.dTa}v

axpeXetav, fuera te ro XvBrjfvat
eiretorj

rag

eoprag, evt rov

lopoav^v 'ripxero

oe evravaa 'ttoXXoi avveroirovg,

rpeyov,

rovg %\

TroXvoyXovvrag

dei

KareXdfj.^ave

ovk

eirt^^etKvvfj.evog

ovSe

<f>iXoTtfj.ovfj.evog,

dXXa

trXetoai rrjv irap

eavTov

Trapeyetv w(peXetav aTrov^d^oiv.

30

Ki ^e Kai Xeyet

FivayyeXtar^ijg evTav6a, ort e^dvrt^ev, ovy^
(fyyjaiv,

wg avrov ^airTi^ovrog rovro

aAAa

ro rwv fxa6rjTwv epyov

^ tiippSv Cod.

E e

210
e/f

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
K.ai

III. 25.

Tov ti^a<JKaXov avvjyayev.

yap iipoim

07ja/v, ori 'I^crovs'

ovK e/SaTTTi^ev,
TovTO
(f>v]a-iv,

«AA

01

[xaOYjTa) avTOv' o6ev ^rjXovori [t;?] evTovOa
fxovoi.

OTi
;

avToi e^dnTi^ov

Tivos ^e eveKev avTog
**

ovK ePaiTTi^e
*'

TrpoXalSwv

lcodvvv^g

e/Vev,

avrog

vfjiag

^aTiTieTTOiovv

aei ev YlvevfxaTi 'Ayioo," YIvtvf/.a ^e ovTra ^v ^e^a^Koog.
fJiaSifjTa],

$

Qe TovTO ot
picc^ei

^ovXofuevoi tioXXov^ iipotTayayeh Tyj crcaTV^

^i^aaKaXia.
tcov

Tivos ^e eveKev
eTravcraTO

[xaQvjTwv

tov 'K.piaTov /3a7rT<^ovT»v, ovk

ladvvrjg

tovto %oiwv,

dXXa

^iay.efLevr]Ke
*' tjv

Kai avTog
Iwdvvyjf 10

PaTiTi^av'

Kai ydp
ev

(f)if]a-iv

EvayyeA/o-r»;?,

^e Kai

"

/SaTTTi^oov

Alvwv"

k. t. e.

Kat

(J-^xpi TVji eig ro

^eufxaT^^piov
vjv

KaTaKXeiaeag tovto

enoiei.

To yap emeh " ovwa

/3e(3Xy]-

f*.evog eig tvjv (pvXaKVjv

\.coavvvj$,

OvjXovvtos etXTi^ oti ecog totc
eoog

ovK eTiavdaTo ^anrii^wv.

Tivog ovv eveKev

TOTe e^dyrTi^ev

;

tva Tovs eavTov fi.a6rjTag ei$ nXetova ^^Xov dvaydyyj, Kat (ptXovet- 15

KWTepovi epydavjTat'

fxvptdKtg

/3oS>v,

Kat

tcov

Tcpwretoov

det
ei

too

yiptaTSi 'napayjtipoov, ovk eiretcrev avTovg avToo 7rpo(7^pay.eiv,
fxrfj

KOt

TovTO

eiiotet,

ttoXXw f*.dXXov dv

eTtoiYiae.

A.ia tovto
Tro^iov 6

^e Kai
{oodvvrjg

yipt(7T0g TOre

fxdXtaTa vjp^aTo KrjpvTTetv, ore ck
^e OTt Kat
'^ta

eyeveTo.

01 /xev

tovto a-vy/ooprfGy^vat

tvjv

TcXevTVjv 20
tvjv

Iwavvoy Tayj.QTv\v avToov yeveaOai, ooaTe itdaav tov 7rXi^6ovs
^td^eatv
Tepoov
eTTt

tov X.ptaTOv fx.eTeX6eh, Kai f^vjKeTt Ta7g toov df^(f)o-

avTOvg (7'^t^ea6ai yvwfi.aig.
^e Tig e^erd^ot t/ TrAeov e/j^e to tcSv f/.a6vjTS)V tov "KpiaTov
loodvvov,

E<

^diiTt^TfKa Tov
Tvjg

epovfxev, OTt

ovMv.
vjv,

eKdrepa yap
Kat atTia fxia

Ofxotoog
afJi(f)o-

25

eK Tov YlvevfKaTog ydptTog aft-otpa
vjv

Tepwg

Tov /3a7rTt^eiv, to tw "KptaTa itpoaayetv Tovg ^airci-

^ofkevovg.

25

T/

avjfAaivei

vj

yevou.evv} ^-^TVjatg eK toov
;

fii.a6i^TCC>v

lcodvvov irpog

Ttva lov^ocrov irepi Ka6aptafj.ov
Tjv

t>jv ^vjXoTVTTiav

avToov efi.(paivet,

30

e/p(^ov

aei Tcpog Tovg tov KptaTov ft.a6v]Tag Trpog avTOV Te tov
cog

KptGTOV,
"KpiaTov
OTt

Tov

Tiap

avTwv /3a7TTtafLaTog
tovto yap

TrAeov

Tt

twv TOy

ft.a6v}Twv ey^ovTog'
toc

irpog tov ^hv^a7ov ^teXeyovTo.
**

ydp TOVTO eaTi,

e|^f ^i^Xoi.
c
Z-riKovv oTi y}v

HA^ov ydp,"

(f>v}at,

"

iTpog

Cod.

5

III. 25.

mANNHN

EYArrEAION.
Kat ra e?^?.
o^
-^v

211
[xtra
o-ov,
co

"

Tov Iwavinjv Kat Xeyovai, pappi,

TOVT€<TTtVy Oi To^tv uy(.

fxaO^TOv, aitory^^tdag
tov, ov <tv
to,

^antTt'C,(.t.

"

<tv

" fXi^pTvpriKaif*
€iroivj(Ta$

avTt

ejSaTT/aaf, ov
<Tot

(tv

Xa\i.itpov

Kou Trepi^XiTtTOV,

avTo,

ToAjaa.

Ov

tovto &e

ixovov

mvTO

TrapaKvt^eiv tov ^i^d<TKaXoVf TOVTeaTt tov ^aitTKTT^v^ 5
*'

aAAa
**

kou to avTOv Trapev^oKtfJieiadat KonroV
irpos

TravTff

yap epyov(pojovjaat

Tai

avTOV."

fleAcov

^e

Tewf

KaTaitXyj^at
17

Kat

avTovf, Kat ^ft^at OTt ouj^ eTepw?

aAA

Ta?
'*

0eaj iroKefxovatv,

avTco TroXffx.ovvTe^, diroKptQetg direv avToHg,

ov hvvarat avBp<ciroi

"

XafxfSdvetv

d(f>

eauTOv oy^ev,"
17

/cax

Ta

ef^s".

10
S>jAouv-

To
ToV

^e,

**

eav
ri

fjir]

Se^Oj«,evov afTco

dvaSev" ovbev ocAAo

ecTTiv'^,

OTt Kat

dtvvdroii eiTf)(€ipovatf Kai 6eofJ.dyot TrdXtv

evptaKOVTat. evTevGev avTov^ Kat Trapafj.vBenat vjpefxa, ^eiKVv^f oti

ovK dvGpcairog
^e,
<f)i^<TiVf

dWa

0eoV eaTtv
e'/pfj.ev,

Trapev^oKtfj.m

y)fJ.dg,

Kat

vjfxeT^

ov^ev o^KoBev

dx\d

Trdvra eK tov Qeov.

E/

1

Se Xafj-irpoTepa to. OavfiM^eiv
'X.p^i

eKeivov,

Kat irdvTeg vpog avrov epyovTat, ov

TotavTa ydp Ta QeTa.
Kat

To

§e,

" awTo*

vfi.e7$ fxot

" fkapTvpetTe,
efj.vjg

Ta

ec,-r]q,

d>jAoi

OTt et

oXwg eyeaOe,

(pyjat, t-^s

fj.apTvpiag, Kai dXvjOi^ TavTVjv -rjyeTaOe, fi.d6eTe OTt ^td
efne

Tav20

rriv

fjAXtaTa ovk
ei
fj.v]

eKeivov, aAA' eKeivov
yj

efj.ov

irpoTtfJMv y^vf.

Kat ydp

•npoarjXBev
vvfK(f)ia)

vvfj.(f)y],

TovTeaTt

Xaog, yjyovv

yj

^KKKXvjata, Tco

'KpiaToo, tot6 av yjXyvjaa, vvv §e tovtou

yevofxevov, cof (f>iXog

X^P^

yaipoov ^ia to eK t^?

(f)<avy]<;

tov

vvfj.(piov

T^v

vvfiL(f>y]v

eyrtyvmat

avrov.
tc5 Oeo3.

ovt» yap

y]

KKKXi^ata ^td

t^j"

^i^aaKaXiag dpfJ.o^eTat

25
dirXMg redetKev,

Ka/ TO "
OTt

eaTy]K<i)g'^ §e,

ov'/^

dXXd

^etKvvi

Ta avTov
yjvvaTat,

ireTravTat, Kat
<f)y]at,

OTt avTOv Xotirov eardvat ypy].

Kai

ydp

Trap

efxov to epyov,

yeveadat e^ei'

y(j)y]

roivvv

Ta

yjfj.eTepa

eXaTTOvaQat, av^etv ^e Ta €K€tvov.
Tou l3a7rTiafj.aTog vvfX(f>eveTat 30
y]

Ammcniot nPEZBTTEPOT. A/a
\ptaT0s
yj

T*?v

EiKKXy]aiav dvayevvyjOeTaaV

^e

av^vyta avTyj

irvevfxaTtKy]

^ta tov ^i^^aaKaXtKov Xoyov avvdirTet 0ea5* irapvvfx(f)iq

Oevoi eaTt
rj

Kat dyvf] Kai

^ta t^v t»v toyfxaTav opQoTy]Ta,

avTV] Kai yvvvj eaTt tov \ptaTOV, cog
^
SljXoUv TOVTf<TTlV

ayaBag yevvSiaa

irpd^etg,

Cod.

£62

212
cvK
a(f>

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
eauT^f,

III. S^vjs

«AXa

^ia t&v aaTreipovTog
eivai

a

avr^ HpiaTov,

ovteti Ta5v yevvyjTav ^vvaTai

vv[x(f)iog) eirentep

TrpwTOTVTTwg^

ov^eU
'

avTCtiv

eaTi ^OT^p dyaQav.
vvfj.(f>'/]

Ilaaa

ovv XoytKVj (f>vaii

Ayye-

AoJV Te Kat

dvQpamm
eaT^v
6

ei(Xiv.
vj

Ny]tx0/of
vvfJi^av
avvd(f>eia,
avvvjg.

XpiaTog Ka)

'EKKki^aia
ev6a yiveTat

vvfj.(f>v},
vj

Kai

oS

TOTtog
eTrei^^v]

Tov ^aiTTiafxaTO?,

iivevfj.aTiKvi
ev(f>po~

ndvTa

(f>ai^pa Kai '/apdg avdfxeaTa Kai

T/ ydp

fxaKapidoTepov

tov

Ka9apia6vjvai

dfxapTiwv

Kai

KoXkviBvjvai 0ec3, /ca/

koivwvov yeveaBai Beiag ^vaecog ^id TVjg tov
;

'Ayiov Ilvevf).aTog

ft.eTovaias

rayTa ydp

o

dppafSaV
o vvfX(f>iog

Ta

^e lo

TeXeiwTepa

ev toj

/xeAAom, ore vdKiv elaeXQm

eiaayei

avv avTca Tag TrapGevovg xpv^^dg,
IlavTcyv Trpog

tov ^li^aovv dTnovrm, eXvjXvBa yap fxapTvp^aat

avTw,

'iva

TtdvTeg TriaTevaaaiv

avT^

^i

efiov.

OvTC
€a)a(popov 6

\ptaTog av^ei, outc

^ladvvi^g cAaTTOvTa/,

aAAa

OiKvjviS

ladvvvjg vtto tov vo^jtoS v]Xiov aKeiteTai.
eirl

31

'O 'KpiaTog wg &eog
&er fxevetv ev otg elfxi.

TtKehv av^ei ^avepovfxevog'

efxe

^e

T/

aYifxatvei oirep etnev,

"

avooBev epyoOoqvfg

"

fxevog

eTrdvo}

irdvTm C(7t/;" t^v vitep^dXXovaav
oti
ov^^evog

avTov

vTtepoyvjv, Kat

^en-a/ TroTC,

dXk dpKm

eaTiv eavTco. 20

TavTa
Kai

Be

iiep)

tov XpiaTOv eXeye.
(f>i^aiv,

To

fxr^e eK T^f
eTtiyeia

7^? ovTa

XaXovvTa eavTOV
eiTtev

ovy

OTi ^e

e(pSeyyeTo, Ota

TovTo

eavTOV Ik TVjg yvjg Xake7v,

dwd

Ttpog tvjv

tov HptaTOv

tt^^aaKaXiav 7iapa(3dXXm eavTOV, evTeXvi Kai Taiteiva Kai fxiKpa

TovTa eXoyt^eTO.

25
Tvjg

" 'O av

€K TVjg yvjg ck TVjg yvjg eaTt, Kai eK
(f>viatv,

yv\g XaXei.

OvK

laofxeTpcDg evepy^aet,

etg to ^vvaadai itetBetv
fxev

yvjyewig
eitt

Toj hti
yv]g,

TtdvTag ovti ©eoj.
fxovvi

AaXvjaei

ydp ag dvSpamog

Tyjg

Kai ev

avfx/SovXov KetaeTai

Tct^e;.

'FiTtdvco

TtdvTm eaTi twv

TteTtoivifuevm,
€^i^pv}iJi.evog

ovy wg

ev Ttdavi

AcaTa-30

pt6ft.ovfxevog,

dW

ug itdvTm

Kai To7g itdat QeoitpeTtag
6 TVjg

enoyovfxevog
eK7t€(f>vK0ig, Tvjv

dvu6ev

epypfj.evog,
€(f>

TOVTeaTiv
(ftvaiKtag

avcoSev pt^vjg
€V(f>viav,

TtaTpuav

eavTW

aTtoaoi^m

TO €Ttdva

vdvTm

vitdpyetv ofj.okoyovfj.evwg KeKTVjaeTat'
^ npuTOJVTia

vjv

ydp

^17

Cod.

III. 35Kou
"Trep

mANNHN
axr/j,

EYArrEAION.

213

afjiyf^avaVf [xyj

wavTWf to^ovtov
o

opacrQat rov Tlov, oiroioi
'AvOpcoiit-

av

vootro, Kai

Kara r^v a^tav
t>jv

yevv^aai avrov.

vctirepov

\a\€i

^ta

aapKa'

rri

yap

(f>v(rei

Travreketof wv,

irdvra

d(f>

eavrov otoev.
Eirei

OpirENOTS.
fxaprvpovaag
^ei, ov^etf
Ttepi

yap

6 epevvav

ra^ ypa(f)af evpiaKet airai $
dof

^ptaroVf ovk vjpewow ^e avrag 'lov^aiot

rav dve^erdcrrcog ralg ypacpaTg evrvyyavovrm

eXdfJ.-

/3ave rrjv Tiepi
etneiv,

avrov fjiaprvpiav,

fi.ovov

Kat Ttavrog rov Kat

'^vvafx.evov

"

ov

eypaxpe M.(i)vavjs ev too

vofi.ai

ot 7rpo(f>^rat

evp-^Kaa(f>pa-

"

/Aev lojcoyv"

Xafx^dvovrog
6

t»?v irept

avrov fj.aprvpiav Kat

lo

yt^ovrog

"

ort

Qeog
riov

dXfjByjg

eart^^ irpoaeTrayyetXdfji.evoi
ev

ro

EvayyeXtov
Ttov avrov.

^ta

"Trpo^f^yjriov

ypa(pa7g

dytaig

iiept

rov

AMMaNioT.
c(f)paytda.

'Avrt

rov

eTrXvjpo^f^op-^Srjf

Kat

e)(ei

aTro^et^tv Kat

15

'ATreardXQat keyerat

Xiog diro rov Tlarpogf
11«^*;^
fj^cov

vj

^ta rvjv evrov Tiov ovk

aapKov TrapovaiaVj

yj

ort

ev eavrSi

€Kpv\p(v, «AA' e^eXMfx^pev avrov eK rvjg idiag (f>vaewg,

wg eK
ei

(jxarog

dttavyaafJM,.

'E^eA^Ayfle

yap

Tiog eig lYtav vTrap^tv,

Kai ev

avroo

Kara

(f>vatv eartv.

20
oiiv

i^noAiNAPioT.

'Eiret

ra

eKetvov (f>6eyyerai,

re irtarevm,
^e

re dirtarcov, eKetva Kat ntarevet Kat dirtaret.

To

"

ea(f>pd-

ytaev

avri rov ebetqe.
ro,

34

T/ eart
evravQa
evepyetav
rrjv

"

ov

yap €K

fxerpov ^ilwatv
•^ft.eig

Seog ro

;"

TIveyjtAa

evepyetccv

Xeyet'

fxev

ovv, (f>v]ai,

fierpx rviv 25

rov Uvevfxarog e\d^ofj.ev, avrog ^e oi^ ovrwg,

dXXa

dyierpyirov eyet Kai oXoKXyjpov itaaav t^v evepyetav.

Xmmcniot.

'Clg Tryjyy)

wv tow UvevfJMrog ^t^^aatv avrog t^v

evepyetav, Xeyet rov YIvevfJMrog, ^v 0/ dvSpwirot fj.erpu} Xafj.pdvovatv.

Avrog yap

oXoKXyjpov
f/.y]v

eyet
f/.epovg

irdaav.

oXov e/et ro nveyjU.a3o

Ttog ovattatwg, ov avro
^i^coatv,
01

eK

ag

Krtafj.a.

Ato Kat avrog
J/'

§e aytot

^ta Ueaiag irotovat rov \ptarov

ayTftJv eTrtyopvjyyjaai

ro Y\vevfJ.a.

35
"

E/Vftjv
cv
rfi

te

ort

**

ITaT^p dyaira. rov Tiov, Kat irdvra

^e^d^Kev

X^'P^ avrov," ug vept dvBpuyirov "^eiKvvrat ^taXeyofj.evov35

214

EPMHNEIA
eiri

EIS

TO KATA

III. 36.

Tivog Bavixaa-Tov, o6ev
eiTreiv
**

to TaTreivoTepov ayei tov Xoyov, ev ra)
^e Tcoiei evitapa^covjv

TidvTa Se^w/cev ev

t^ %c'P^ awToS'" tovto

^€KTOV KaTaTKeva!^m tov Xoyov.
Tov
elf Tov Tlov

Kha

^e Kai aiwviov e^/eiv

TTiaTevQVTa

^iafxapTvpeTai'

tov oe

aTreiOovvTa 5

avTco eKTTiTTTeiv avTYjg, Ka\ t>;v opyriv tov

©eov

fxeveiv ei: avTOV.

i\MMflNIOT nPESBTTEPOT.

ToTe

TtXfjpOVTai

TOVTO, 0T€

KaTa

Tov TYjg '^evTepag Trapovaiag Kaipov, itav yovv

avTW

KaiXTTTei atto-

(SaXovTav

tjv

eyovai KaKiav. %e1pa a^e

t5^v ^vva[J.iv

KaXe7, ^v

e^xjei

vtog (f)vaiKS)s Kai ov fxeTaXyjTTTii^.

36
*'

Ktpiaaot.
yap
^cofxev

Zcor) fxev

yap KaTo,

cf)vaiv

fJiovoyev)]^,

"

ev

avTw 10

Kal KivovfxeSa Kai

eo-jU-ev"

elaoiKi^eTai ^e TtavTwg

Tjfxwv

T^s TTiaTewg, kou KaToiKel %ia

tw

^kylov YlvevfxaTO^.
^wvjv, Ttepi

O

oe

aireiQwv

tw T/«, ovk
(f^vjai,
**

oxpeTai

tvjv

twv ayiwv

^g Kai

^paXfnw^^og

Tig

eaTiv avGpwno?

BeXwv
(f^yjai
vj

^wyjv,

ayaiiwv

"

yjfxepav

l^eiv

ayad-^v ;^

Kai

6

YlavXoi ^e

Trpo^

TOVf TJJ15

KaKia veveKpwfxevovg'

"«TreflaveTe yap, Kai

^w^ vfxwv KCKpvyj

" "

TTTai

ev

Tw ©ew avv tw HpiaTW. OTav
TOT€ Ka)

'KpiaTO^ ^avepwBrf,

^wri vfxwv,

v[xe7s cf^avepwS-^aeaQe ev ^o^tj."

ovk

ehe

^e,

fxevet,

avTOV, aXX^ eii avTOV, ^eiKvi/g oti ov^eTroTe avTOv airoaTyi'Iva

aeTai'

yap

fxy)

vofXiayj

ti^ GavaTOV eivat irpoi Katpov to

ovk 20

oxpeTai ^WTjv, aXX^ tva TitaTevaYf OTt ^tyjveKwg eaTtv ei^ tvjv

KoXa-

atv

TovTO TeBetKe, tia tovtwv avTov twv pyjfxaTWV w6wv irpog tov
fxovov,

\ptaTOV, ovK avTOv$ ^e
XtKy^v

aXXa

Kat iravTag' Kai yap KaSofxev

eTrotyfaaTO t>jv irapatveaiv.

avTOg

KptaTog ovk e^a-

TTTi^eVf 01

Be aTrayyeXXovTeg ^ovXofxevot ^teyeipat Tovg aKovovTag 25

eU

(fySovov

tovto aTr-^yyeXXov, avTog ^e aveywpei, ov tetXiag yaptv,
aiiTwv
fi.ev

aX?C eKKOTTTWV
(f>Bovov'

tyjv

fSaaKavtav

Kat

TrapafxvBovfxevog
eiTtayeiv,

tov

'hvvaTog

yap

yjv,

Kat eireXGovTag

aXX ovk
aapKog

yj(3ovXeTo

avveywg tovto

iroteh,

waTe

f/^ airtaTeiaBat t^$"

Tyjv oiKOvofxiav.

KE$.

E.

Ilfpi TT)s 2afiap€iTi8os.

4

"ClaTrep
(f)y}a]v

epyov

avTOV

irotovfxevov

TYfV

T^f HafxapetTt^oi
ItepyeaOat
"^ta

ooov,

EvayyeXtaTyjs to " eht Se

«iJtov

T^f

IV. 4.

IX2ANNHN ETArrEAION.

215

" ^afxapeiag'" tovto ^e eymTOy wo-re TraTav
aitoXoyiav'

(KKOTrrjvai ^lov^aicov
tcHv

OTav yap

aTTvjXavvov,

tot€

TVjg

eSvHv

Tjxrero

AMMflNlOT nPESBTTEPOT.
Ya[JiapeTTaif ^io

'

OfJiOpOl

YjaaV

TOJV

loV^aiCCV

01

Kai ano r^f vyjy^g

(ttivov

tov

laKal3.

A^iov ^
6 roTrof

Se ei7re7v Kat iroBev ot YafxapeTTat avveaTyjaav

Kat
tvjv

yap

«yrof «Traf
€\aj3e
;

Ytaimpeta
*:opos
'f«'

eKaXeno.

TloQev

ovv

Trpoavjyoptav
Kcti oi

Ho(Aop TO

ekeyeTo aiio roy KTfiaafj.evov, KaGaTtep
'y

Haaiocf <f>Wh "

Kecj^aKri

Hofj.opo3V

E(f)paift.'"

aXk

otKQvvTe^ ov Tiaf/.apeiTat
«•^oiovTOf

aXk

laparjXiTat

eKeyovTO.

K.povov

Se lo

vpoaeKpovaav

raJ 0eaj, Kat

j3aat\evaavTos ^aKe^ avekTroXXac,

Bav QeXyacpaXaaaap

iioXeti

re

eiAe

Kat

eireSeTO
f/t.ev

too

HXa,
Tov

Kat (popov eTrotrjaev VTroTeXeHi.

AXX
tovto
ert

ovto^ to
itpog

itp^-

ei^ev,

vaTepov
KaTe(f)vye

^e

aiteaTyj

t^? apyYji, Kat
eyvta
6

t^v twv
Kat 15

AiQtOTTCtiV

avft.fi.a'/^iav.

Aaavptog,

entaTpaTevaag Kai dveXav avTov^, qvk
a(f>iy]at
fiiev

to eOvog eKeT

ft.evetv

^ta

tvjv

TYjg

dnoaTaaecog

viro^^i^iav,

aXXa TovTovg Tovg
Se
edvyj

eig

Ba/3i;A«va rp/aye

Kat M^^oyf,
ev
t'»}

eKe76ev

bta(f)0-

pm

TOTtav

ayaym
Tyjv

KaTtnKtaev
apyr^v
eivat,

Y.aft.apeta.,

wcTe

Xotnov
tottov.

aa^aXyj avTco

twv

otKetcav

ej^ovTwv tov
tvjv

20

TovTCov ^e ytvofievccv, fSovXofxevog
ft.tv,

Seog

'^eT^at

avTOv ^vva^ta
dfj.ap-

OTt

ov

^i

daOevetav e^e^coKev ^lov^aiovg,

dXXa

Tiag,

eiia(f>iviai

XeovTag ToTg

(3apl3dpotg, otTtveg
too l3aaiXeT,

eXvft.aivovTO
vefii.Ttet
Ofi.cag

to

eOvog anav.

AityfyyeXyi ovv

TUVTa

Kai

lepea
ovOe 25

Ttva Tov Ttapo^aaovTa avToTg tov tov Qeov
ovTcag el

vofLov,

dXX

oXoKXrjpov Tvjg dae^eiag d-TteaTyjaav,
TtpoTovTog

dXX

e^ y)fx.taetag.

^povov ^e

twv

ft.ev ei^ooXcov dTte-Tty^riaav,

eae^ovTO Oe tov
ot

Seov, Kat t»v itpayfj.aTcav ev TOVTOtg
^aTot XotTtov ^YjXoTVTtcag ttpog
y
.

qvtoov,

evaveXSovTeg
itpog

lov-

Kat TtoXefiiovg, Kat aito tov opovg 2jau.apeiTag avTovg eKaXovv, 30 Kat ov fj.tKpa evTevSev
ypa(f>aTg itdaatg
yjv

/

\J\~J/

avTOvg

ei-^^ov,
-r,

enTe
/

>V»/.

aXXo(f>vXovg

itpog

avTovg
Tot

yj

(f)tXovetKta.
fj.ova

ovoe TaTg
^e')(pfJ.evot,

eKeyjpyjVTo,

dXXa

^cavaecag

T»v aAAcuv vpo^f^yprm ovteva

eTtotovvTO Xeyov,

F,(f>tXoveiKovv fnev-

Tot etg Trjv evyeveiav elacaSeTv eavTOvg tyiv
fj.ovvTo
eitt

XovtaiKYiv, Kat e(f)tXoTt-

Tca

A(3paafi,, Kai

vpoyovov avTOv a7teypa(f>ovTo, aTe 35

216
aito Tiyf

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
rm

IV. 4.

JLaKoaiaq ovra' Kai rov laKwp 6e Trarepa eKaAovv, are
01

eKCtvov ovra aiioyovov.

%\

Yov^aloi

ra

/xev

ttavTm

eGviKav,

Kou TovTOv^ e^^eXvaaovTOi o6ev Kai tw Kvpiao 'I^<roD ovei^i^ovTCi
eXeyov,

"

'LafJLapeni^g
els

ei

o-y*"

Kai avToq §e to<V [t-a^rfralq ovtods
fxy]

eKeXeve Xeym, "
[(TTopiag
6

itoXiv

HafxapeiTav
[/.ovov

c/o-eA^Te." ov TYjg 5
laK0}j3

te

eveKev tou Tonov

aveixv^^aev Yji/.ag tov
'heH^ai
eiti

EivayyeXicTTyjif

akka

Kai

vnep tqv

t^v

airojBoXriv
-Trpoyovcov
''A

t^v

lov^^aiKrjV TrdXai yeyevr](jt.evv]v.

Kai yap

twv

avTwv
irpo-

Tovg TOTiovg avTwv avT avToov KaTe^ryov eKemi.
TtaTopeg avTwv

yap

01

eayov ovK ovTa awTwv, TauTa ^ia

tvjv

ade^eiav lo

ovTa az/TWV, aTrcoAecrav ovtoi.

T/vof ovv
TOTtov

eveKev

aKpiPoXoye^Tai

^vayyeXiaTrjg

itepi
e^-rjg
;

tov
iva

Xeym, "

epy(eTai et$ itoXtv 'Eafji.apetai,^^ Kat to.
TTjg

OTav aKovacofiiev

yvvaiKog Xeyovarig,
Taurvjv,"

"

laKUi^

TtaTVjp

rjfJiwv

" e^aKev
eKeivog

y^fxiv

t^v

itriyriv

^^

^evtaQcafj.ev'

yap

TOitog 15

^v ev6a

vitep

Tvjg

Aivag

01

itep)

tov Aey")' Kat 2u/Aewv
<povov.

dyavaKTOvvxeg tov yaKeitov CKeivov etpydaavTO
KeKOTttaKwg
evTovcog,

E/ttojv te

eK

Trjg

obotitoptag,

ede/^ev

oti

ovTwg

epaoi^ev

wg Kat
rjfJiag

KOTttacxai, ofSe

yap

vito^vytotg e/fej^^To* ttavTayov
[ji.v}

Ttathevwv
1
ettt

to avTOvpyov Kat ditepiTTov, Kat
avTi
eit

ttoXXwv ^e7a6at. 20

6e

ovTwg

tov

ccg

aitKwg Kat wg eTV^e, Kat oti
eKd6v]T0,
vjv

ovk
Kat

6povov,

dk\

e^d<pQvg

dvattavm to
'^ft.epa ft.eav].

(j(afJL.a,

Ttapa

Ttqv itr]yr\v
e/TTCtJv,

avaxpv^fcov avTO'

yap

tovtq yap
te
fj^ovov,
eitt

eS^Aa)(7€v

"

copa

v]v

waei

eKTV].^^

ov to

evttTtovov
fi.ovov

dkXa

Kat TO aTV^pov evTev6ev ^etKVVTat, eK

ToiJ

avTOv

25

T^j- ohov KaTaXet(p6r}vat.
v]ft.eXv]fi.evov,

M.av6dvu)fi.ev ^e Kai to

itept

Tag Tpocpag

ck tov diteX^eh Tovg fj.a6v]Tag avTOv eig to ayopdaat

apTOvg,

OTtoig

Kat

vjf/.eHg

Ttattev6(hfj.ev
fj)q

KpaTeTv yaaTpog Kat KoraiteptaTtov^aaTOV Tr]v TavTi^g

fppoveh ^tacpopccv eteafj.dTm, Kat
eivat vofj.t^eiv XetTOvpytav.

30

Xp^

^e

Kat TOVTo aKOTtvjaat, oti ev

w Kaipw aitavTeg apiarofj.vj

TtoiovvTat, ovTot

Tag Tpocpag

v]yopa^Qv' Kat tva

Ttg avaiayyvTwv

Xeyv], OTi

TtpoaTaaawv

f/.^

eig itoXtv 'Eafi.apeiTav etatevat,

SaavTW
to 35

fj.apetTatg ^taXeyeTat, "^ta tovto
eit).

EvayyeXtaTi^g
TOitov

<j>v]atv,

OTt

Toy ToVoy

Ka6e^pa

'tta

tov

yeyovev,

ov

fj.v]v

'^id

IV. 12.
(jvvTvy(ih
T^yj

mANNHN

ETArrEAION.

217

yvvaiKi, Kai irepi tvjs yvvaiKOif oti Oia to avTKyjdai

v^xp

e^rjkSe, •napayevofxevov ^e to yvvaiov

ovK e%/5^v Xonrov airfa-

aaadai, ovTd) iioXT^v (f)iXo^aBiav eni^etKvvfxevov' ^io Kai evXoyov
aiTiav eiadyei r^f irpo^ avTOV ^taXe^eai'
^i\po$.
**

aiTei

yap v^ap ^ia to
(f>Yjai

YloOev ^e avTOV ^lovtatov voixiaaaa eivai
(XV

Trpog

avTOV
ica^g
vjv

5

TTOoi

'loy^arof

cov,"
pQs»;

Kai Ta
^e

e^yjg

',

aixo

tov

(jyj]\t.aTog

Koi TVjg tiaXe^ecog.

aKo^n^a^ai, iriog

^ie^rKefx.iJ.evov

to
ov

yvvaioV

ei

yap
oti

e^ei (pvXd^aaBaif tov K.vpiov etei, ovk eKeivrjV

yap
'^ahi

eiirev

'Zay.apeTTai

lovbaioig

ov

avyy^ZvTai, akXa
y)

lov-

^afiapeiTag ov TrpoaievTat, dXX

0[jt.(i}s

yvvyi

ovhe

ovTCog 10

eatyyjaev, aAA'

»? oieTai tiopBovTai to
irpoTepov

fxyj

KaTa

vofxov ytvofxevov.

'O ^e "KpiaTOg
fxyj

^et^ag avTYiv d^tav ovaav aKovaai Kai
(ffyjat

irapo^pQyjvat,
yj^etg t>;v

Tore eavTOV eKKaXvTrTet, Kai

Trpog

avTYjv'

"

el

^wpeav tov Seov" Kat Ta

e^yjg'

Kat yap efxeXXev

evOecog fJui6ovaa oaTtg eaTtv,

waKoveaBai Kat
airoKpiveTai

irpoae^etv
*'

avTw,

^to 15

Kat
**

eJrietKfag

irpog

Tavra

Xeyovaa'

^vpte, ovTe

avTXi^fxa ej^eif," Kat
TVjg

Ta

e^yji.

KtTrovaa Se, " Ky^/e,"eSe/^ev ori
aTreaTi^,

evBexg

Taneivyjg

virovotag
fxev

TroXXyjv

avTw

tvjv

Ttfnyjv

airovetfxaaa'
Trrevev eKeivyj,

Kat

aXXwg

^piarog eXeyev, aXXwg
v^^cop

^e

vnw-

"

irodev

^X^tg ro

ro ^cov" Xeyovaa.

Y\po(5dX~ 20

Xerat Se Trarepa rov
evyevetav, Kat ort

laKufS, eig t»/v
ec,

lov^aiKyjV eiaa}$ovaa eavryjv
(pi^at,

avrog

avrov

eirtev,

Kat

ra

eg^^^g.

be

Xeyei toiovtov eartv' ort ov ^nv^aTj ^ovvat erepov rovrov (SeXrioVf
ei fkvj Ti

ye rov

\aK(io(3 [xet^ova

ofxoXoyeig eivat aavrov.

ovrcog ck

Trpwryjg diroKpiaeag e^ei^aro voyjfxa fieya Kai tnpYjXov.

ae

12

Tivog eveKev
yjfxtav

eKetvyjg

etirovayjg,

"

fxyj

av

fxet^cov ei
etf/.t',

rov Trarpog
tva
fxyj

laKcop,

avrog ovk

etirev avrrj, vat

fnetgm

ooqy]

KOfxirdl^etv, ryjg

diro^et^ecog fxyi^etria

(paivofxevi^g'

^;'

av ^e Xeyei,
rov

rovro
ittvoiv
'*

KaraaKevd^ei'
Otxyi^aei

Ik
og

tovtov

fxev
irtyi

yap,

<f>y]ai,

v^arog

iraXtv

av

eK rov vOarog, ov eyco oaad)
^e

^o

avTco, ov

fxyj ^txpyjarj eig

rov aixva."
\aKwl3,
ort

Xeyet toiovtov eariv.

Ei
ov 6

Oavfxdl^etg,
Trivcov

(priai,

tov

e^ccKe

rovro ro v^xp, ef

irdXtv ^txp-^aet, ttoAAw fxdXXov Bavfxdaai yjpri rov iroXv
v^^cop^^ (f)i^atv, '*

rovTOV PeXriov v^cop Trapeyovra " Kat yap ro

"

eyoi

^coaco

avrf, yev^aerat

ev

avrx

Tryjyyi

vtaroi dXXofxevov

e/f

35

Ff

218
^iorjv

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
alaviov" tovxo Se
eiite

IV. i6.
tvjv

tov KaBap^ov tov e^ avrov Kai
tv}v

TroAX^y Traparpvyyjv ev^eiKVvfxevov
fxevai<;

eyytvofxevyjv

Talg viro^^eyoyj

avTOv ^iavoiaii.

ttoXv

oiv

avveTcoTepa tov NiKO^-^fXov Kai

yvvri

avTTj (pavetaa kui

av^^peioTepa, evOeag eTTiaTevae
i/^&jp*"

(pyjci,

" Kvpie,

Bo?

[MOi
ttcc^;

TovTO TO

eKehog yap fxvpiav toiovtwv 5
;

aKovm
aXXa

eXeye,

^vvaTat TovTa yeveaBai
y^^iropei,

avTfj ^e

oyp^

ovTCc^y

TO [xev irpwTov
ev

vaTepov ^e ov^e fxeTa KaTaaKevrjg,
tov
Xoyov,
eirt

aXX
"

aTTocpdaeai

Ta^ei

'^e^afxevri

ttjv

Xvjxpiv

evGecag eneiyeTat.
ft.v]

npoeTifj.fiae

ye avrov toD laKco^, etTrovaa " iva
tovto ydp,
(fti^o^i,

^iipa, /xvj^e epyofxat ev6d^e dvTXeiv,'^

yivO' lo

[xevov, ovKCTt ^eofxai TavTvjg tvjs Trvjy^g.
1

6

EiTre ^e avTyj,

" vnaye,

(pavrjaov tov dvtpa

aov" ^id to

eTriKeT-

a6at avTyjv tov Xa(3e7v, aaavet evtetKWfxevog, OTt KaKehov
vyj(xat

'heH Kotvcn-

TovTOOv av

av

7io6ei<;.

eKetvyj ^e (XTtev^hovaa

Xa^eh, dfxa

oe Kat

KpvTTTOvaa TO Tov TrpdyfxaTog
Tog ^e ^td

ala-y^pov, (f)yjaiv,

^^dvtpa ovk e%w*" av- 15
eavTOv,

7rpo(f>yjietag Xotitov diroKaXvTiTcav Trjv ^vvafxiv tvjv

dfK^OTepa fxeTa aKpt^etag Xeyei' Tovg Te yap iipoTepovg
Koci

i^pt6fA.y]af,

Tov vovv KpvTTTOfxevov '^Xey^ev.
a(f)eiaa e(pvyev,

ovk e^vayepave ^e

eKeivrj

TovTa

aKovaaaa, ovte

aXXa 6avfi.aaaaa fxaXXov

Kai Ttpoa-

KapTepyjaaaa irXeov, Xeyei, " Kvpie, Beoopa ori

7rpo(f)yjTy]g ei

av," 20
fxoi,

dno

TroXXrjg

(f)tXoao(f)iag'
irept

to Se

** ^ecopS)'^

dvTi tov, (patvet

eiirev, o6ev

Kat

toyfxdrcav ev6ecog avTOv epccToi, ov Trepi (3tcoTtept y^pyjfxdTcov,

TiKccv, oy^e irept
'*

awfxaTog vyteiag, ov^e
(f)i^atv,

aXXa

Tt

;

01

iraTepeg
Trepl

yjfucliv,"

"

ev

tw

opei

TovTcp TrpoaeKvvyjaav"
eKcT, (f)aai, tov

Tovg

tov

h^paafx Xeyovaa, Kat yap
**

viovz^

avTOV dvyjvoyevai,
**

Kai vfieTg Xeyere, oti ev 'lepoaoXvfxoig eaTtv
irpoaKvveh." iheg irag vxpi^XoTepa
T-fj

Toirog ev6a
;

'/^pyj

^tavoia

yeyove

yj

ydp

//.^

vTrep

tov aKvXXea6ai ^td to

'^iil/eiv

itpo fxiKpov

fxepifxvchaa, vitep ^oyft.dTCov epcoTO, Xoitrov, 010 Kai
fXYi

'Kptarog tovto
iroXv

Xvaag to

^yjTi^ff.a,

ov

yap

-^v

aviw

ireptaTrovtaaTOV,

^o

[xeya avTy\
vat^X

toyfxa dtreKaXvipev, oirep ovSe N/z^o^^^/xco ovVe Nafia(f>yjai

eyvccpiae'

yap, " TrtaTevaov
avryj fxev

fxot

yvvai,

oti

epyerat

copa,

Kai

Ta

egrjg.

yap eaTrovbagev

evrifxorepa oei!;at

rd avr^g twv
epuryjaiv,

lovhaiKav, avrog Se ov irpog ravT^^v vnyjvryjae Tyjv
^e
Tftlv

dfx^porepcov

Toirav

rd irpea^eTa dveXm, S;a-35

IV. ai.
viarifjfftv

laANNHN ETArrEAlON.
avT^i
tvjv

219

^vyyjVf

^eiKvvg oti ovt€

lovoaioi ovt€ avToi

f-^ovai Tt irpos TO

fxeWov

^copeia6ai' irX^v Kai ovtco tov^
vfjieii

lov^aiov^

acfxvoTepovg

diiecf^t^vev

emm, "
oi

'^poaKvve^Te

o

ovk oi^aTe,

Kai Ta

e^Yjs.

n<5f Se ovK yj^eaav

Y^ayi.apehai b TrpoaeKvvovv

;

7re[j.\l/avT€s

5

aTT-i^yyeiXav, OTt o tov TOitov
7iep\

Qeog avTovg XvixaiveTai, ov^h vXeov
ei^cti\a}v

avTOv KaTO. tovto twv

(f)avTa^o[Jt.evoi, ^io

Kai

eite-

fx.€tvav

Kai ^aifxovta BepoTrevovTeg Kai avTOV.

lov^aioi ^e TavTyjg

y](jav diifiXKayix.evoi rvjg vTtovoiag^

Kai TYjg otKOvixev/jg yj^eaav avTOV
yjpy)

Seov ovTa, Kat
lov^atav avTav

et

fj^,vj

TidvTeg.
irpog

Ov

^e 6avfJ.d^eiv

OTt

fi.eTa

lo

apt6ft.e7'

yap

tt^v

vnovoiav TYjg

yvvatKog

^taXeyeTat wg
redetKe.

TtpocjjYiTVjg,

ag lov^aiog'

^io Kai to

"

Ttpo(TKvvovfj.ev^

21
Yj

T/

cr>jjU.a/vcDV, (fjYjatv,

"

oti

yj

aooTt^pia Ik

Tav lov^aim eaTiv

;^^

OTi TYi

oiKovft.evY}

To,

dyaSa

eKe76ev yeyove.
tyjv

To yap
dpyYiv

ei^evat 15

Seov Kai KaraytyvooaKetv
Tot

ei^aXcov, eKeiBev

€%€;,

Kat

dXXa

TtdvTa Ooyfj.aTa'
et

Kat itap
fj^lf}

vftufv

^e

(f)i^atv

avTO tovto to
tyiv

T^^ TtpoaKvv^aetag,

Kai

opOcog.
yj

Aito yovv twv lovhatm
yj

ap^^v eXa^e.

acoTYjptav

ovv

TovTa,

ttjv

avTov Ttapovatav

KaXeif fiaXXov he ovk dv Ttg dfi.dpToi, dfi.(f>OT€pa TovTa acoTY}piav 20

KaXav,

'Ammoniot nPESBTTEPor.
T/ov,
Yj

Atd

to e| avTcov €aapKaa6at tov

OTi eq

eKeivav Yjp^avTo etoevat tov eva Seovy eK tov vofxov

Kat TWV

TtpO(f>YlTWV.

lipirENOTs.
*'

OTav

dKovayjg

oti

"

€k tc5v

lovSa/wv
eipY]f>.eva.

yj

acoTY]-

25

pia eaTtv" Ttepi tov Tavra XeyovTog ocKove
Yj

Ta

Avt og
Aal3t^

ydp

Tcov

e6vwv

ttpoa^^oKta,

yevofj.€vog

Ik aTiepfLarog

KaTa adpKa. ro
TouTo
rpoTtce
^YjXot,

^e
ei

'*

epy^erai

copa

Kat

vvv

eart" Ka) Ta e^^f,
co

OTt

Kat 7tXeov€KTovfj.€v vfj.m,

yvvatf 4>^at,

rw

TYjg

itpoaKvvfjaecog, irA^v

dXXd

Kat ovTog
dfj.ei(f)6YiaeTat
etti

rpottog reXog
fkovov,

e^et

Xoivov.

Ov yap ra
ra
vito

twv

roTtcov

dXXa

Kat ra Toy rpoitov TYjg Xarpeiag, Kat ravTa Kat ofj^
cog

6vpatg e^peari^Ke,

rm
^e

7tpo(f>YjTcov

eipYjf/.eva

itapeKTaatv j^ovou
T.aft.ap€iTatg

X-^xpovrai.

E/7ra>v

"

aA^jfi/vouf,"

avve^efSaXe

F f 2

220
^hv^aiovi'
e*

EPMHNEIA E12 TO KATA
yap Kai iKnviov
a^iivov<; ovToi,

IV. 25.
[xeWovTwv

aWa t«v
iiavTi

eXaTTOvg ttoAAw, Kai tocovtov oaov aArjBeiag TOitog.

AMMflNioT.

O/

aXyjBeis

irf/oaKvvi^Tai

ev

tottoi)

Trpocxa-

jovci Tw Qeio Tag TcveviKaTiKai
ce(3eia.

OvaiaSy

eaTiv apeTVj Kai Beo5

Uepi

^e TYjg 'EiKKXvjaiag Xeyei, oti

vj

aXvjByjg TrpocKvvvjo-ig Kat
iraTVjpf (pyjai, ^yjTet

Seao Trpenovaa avTvj eaTi'

"

ToiovTOvg
[jl^

yap
tottw

" Tovg TTpoaKvvovvTag avTw" Tovg
XaTpeiav,
cog vfxeTg 01

iiepiKKeiovTag tyjv

^aff.apeiTai, Kai Tovg tov

Qeov
Kai

ev TrvevfxaTi

Oepairevovragf KaSag Kai

TlavXGg
itpo

(pvjatv,

"

cc

XaTpeva

ev 10

"

TcS

TTvevfJLaTi fjiovj"^

'H yap

tovtov Tiapa To7g
yjv.

lovOaioig

yiyvQf/.evv} TrpoaKvvyjaig

avyKaTa^aaeag

Kinwv, "
eaTt
<Joofj.a,

irvevfxa 6 ©foj*," to aaci>f/.aTov Keyet.
cf^yja),

E/

Totvvv ovk
Oet,

Kat

tvjv

XaTpeiav avTov ToiavTy]v eivat

Kat
'^S

^ia Tov ev

YjfjJiv

aacofxaTov itpoacpepeaBai, TovTeaTt ^ta T^g rp^V^j
tyjXoi, OTt

^ia

Ty}g

tov vov KaBapoTYjTog, tovto yap

"

Tovg iipoaKv-

"
25

vovvTag avTOv ev Ttvevfj.aTi Kat aXyjBeia ^ei TtpoaKvvetv."
Tlo6ev Y^afj.apetTaig to Ttpoa^hoKav t^v Toy

^ptaTov itapovatav

;

TOVTO yap SiyAov eK tov
*'

tvjv

yvvalKa

elitelv

itpog tov Xp/crTOv/'

epyeTat

^Aeaatag
^e^afuevot

XeyofLevog
vofLOV,

'K.ptaTog,"
tcov

Kat

to,

e^vjg'

tov 20

MajvVeftjf
Tcov,

aii

avTwv

M.coiJaecog

ypaft^fnditof^acofi.ev

Kai yap ev

ap-^

tov T/ov aTteKaXvipe'

to yap "
itpog
6

"

avQpcoTtov

KaT

eiKova

Kat

ofj.i(oatv

'^ft.eTepav"

tov

0eov

eipyjTai——Kat tco APpaaf/. ev

Tri

aKi^vyj

ovTog

ijv

'^taXeyofxevog,

Kat

6

laKcbj3

Ttept

avTov
eciig

7tpo(f>i^Tevcov

eXeyev,

"

ovk eKXeixpet 25

apycov
McyyV^i",

eq

lovOa,
*'

av

eXOYj
yjft.iv

aitOKetTat.

Kat
6

avTog

de

<f>y}ai,

7tpo(f)y]Ty]g

avaaTVjaet

K.vptog

Seog eK

" Twv

d^eX(f>cov

vfJLcov,

cog efi.e,

avTOv dmvaeaBe'" Kat noXXa eTepa

TotavTa eaTi
ovv
(fyyjaiv
yj

tvjv

itapovatav avTov dvaKVjpvTTovTa.
itpog

Aia tovto
6 XeyofJievog

yvvrj

avTOv, " epyeTat M.eaaiag

30

" XptaTog,"" Kat Ta
<f>y}atv,

e^^g.

AvTog

^e

Xontov eKKaXvitTcov eavTOv

"

e-yco etf*.i

XaXSov
eiitev,

aot"

oitep

av

et

Ttapa tvjv dpy^v
Xyjpeiv.

fjJrj

^yjTyjadayj
fj.tKpov

t^ yvvatKt
eitt

eto^ev av

avT^

Nvv

^e

KaTa

avTvjv

t>jv

ft.v^fjiy]v

dyaywv, evKaipcog eavTOV diteKa-

IV. 28.
Xvxpe^ Kai Totg
€/

mANNHN
[xh lov^aion;
eTrfibv}

ETArrEAION.
"
elve vj^h

221

crvveyjHi keyovat,

u

av

XpKTTO^y

ovOfv TO
^e

[xauetv rjpaTOiv tovto, ovk «Tre-

KolvaTO avTOt^
eiTre

aa(f>S)if TavTrj

dia to evyvwfxoveiTTepav eivai,
^ia-

cpavepas'

Kat yap e^ ateKaaTOV Kat omXyjg yvafAVji Kat Kat tyjkov eK Tav fX€Ta TavTa'
eiii

vota^ e(f)9eyyeTo'

Kai yap aKov-$

craaa eiriaTevaei Kat akXovg

tovto eaayvjvevae, Kai TiavTaypv
Kai to iiiaTOV.
aTr-^VTVjaav

ryji yvvaiKog eaTiv t^eiv Kai to

rjKpil3a)(xevov

27

'ATrapTiaOeiayjg T^g

'^ttaaKaXia^ evKaipcog
[xeTa yvvaiKog

Kat

01

IxaOvjToi, Kai e6av[xa^ov OTt

eXdket.

Tt edavovro} Ttept-

fxa^ov

i

TO aTV<poVy ro fxeO VTiep^oXrjg raireivov, ori
oiV

\o

^XeTtrog

^vc/p^ero

fxera

roaavrrji

raneivo(f)poavvrig

yvvaiKi

^iaXeyea6ai Treviyjpa Kat Y,af/iapeiTi^i'
ovK
rjpwrrjaav
rrjv

«AA

Ofmg eKTikayevTeg
rrjv

atrtav'

ovrcog

rjaav

Treiiat^evfxevoi

tkv
ei
1

fxa6riTav rd^tv rrjpeh'

ovrag avrov e^ehoiKeiaav Kai
Trapprjata^ofxevot,
olov

'^'^ovvro.

^e

dkXay^ov

(patvovrai
rco

orav

6

laavvrjg

5

eirnriTtrei
fjiei^ctiv,

avrov

arri^et,

orav avrco Trpoatevreg

keyovai rtg

Kat orav vioi Ze^e^aiov Kakovatv, iva elg eK he^iav, Kai

eig f| evcovvfxcev

avrov Ka6iar], dkk eKeiva wg

elg

avrovg

dvrj-

Kovra dvdyKrp eiyov e^erd^etv' evrav6a ^e ovhev avroig
TO yivofxevov.

^ie(f>epe

20
avry] dv^(f>6r}f
irokiv,
t>jv

28

H
vtpiav

"he

yvvrj ovrcag vtto tcov etpr]ft.evcav

wg Kat

rriv

d(f>e7vat,

Kat

^pafj.eHv

eig

r^v

Kai

irdvra

^yjfxov

ekKvaai

Trpog rov

\piaTOV' Kat Kara

oiKeiav tvvafxiv'

oirep

eiroiyjaav 01

Airoarokoi, Kai avryj
iiokiv

ireTrotyjKev, ovy^

eva

y;

^vo Ka-

kovaa, dkka

okoKkyjpov,

" ^evre" ^ocoaa "

Kat

i^ere 25

"

dvdpcoTrov, og

etTre fxoi

irdvra oaa eiroii^aa."

Av6pct}irov ^e

avrov

KakeT, avverwg Kai rovro irotovaa Kai avyKara^artKcbg^ Kat ov'baft.wg

eiryjayvv^yj rov
r]v

etrre^v,

"

og etire fxoi irdvra
Trpo^f^-^rrjv

oaa

'

eTrotvjaa'

KaiToiye

etTreiv

erepcog, ^evre, 't^ere
'nvpi^ irpog ^'^X'^ ^^^^

"^pocf^yjrevovTa'
ryj yyj

akk orav

Trvpco^-^

ov^ev rcov ev

A0/-30

TTOV opa, ov Trpog ^o^av, ov irpog atayyvr^v.

To
T^f
riqg

^e,

"

/w.^T/

ovrog eariv
fxovov

\ptaTog

;

ehe

^ovkofxevyi ovk eK

i^^tag

d7ro(f>daecog

irapeiadyetv avrov^
Koivuvovg,

dkkd

Kat avTOvg

y\>yj(f)ov

Tavry]g
koyov.

iroivjaai

fxdkkov

evirapd^eKTOv

enotet rov

'HpwTwv

Se ol fj.a6v]Tat rov

XptaroVf rovreart 35

222
TiapiKaXovv'
*'

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
rovro yap ^^Ao/
rrj

IV. 31.
(fioivy

eyyapio) avrwv

Xeyovreg
<f>i-

pa{3l3t, (f^dye" ovk

eK TrpoTrerovi yvaiMYj^,
'^iQaa-KaXov, Kai
rvjg

aX\

eK itoXXyjg

Xoaropyiag npog rov

yap e^Xenov avrov
'

KeK[j.y]-

Kora

vTio ryjg

otomopiag Kai
oirep
;

(pXoyog

r^g

eTtiKeiixevyig.
vjv

31

Ti

ayjfxaivei

einev avroig,

"

eyai (Spwa-iv e^^a? (payeTv,

5

"

vfx.eis

ovK otbare

oetKvvg

otav

entbvfji.tav

e^/et irepi ry}g yjfJ^e-

repag

aoiryjptag'
^e,

ravr-^v
tt

yap " ^pwatv" eKaXeaev, ovk eK rov

Trpoyetpov

dXka

aivtyft.drwv
efii.(3aXoov

rd

fj.ev

aTroKaXvTrrei, coaTrep

Kat rovro, tva etg aiioptav
TTOvcog ^yjTeiv

rov dKpoarn^v TrapaaKevdayj entt>?v avv^Gyj Kare^^^ovreg,

to Xeyofkevov, avrot Be t^v a;^w

10

«yTco

jW,ev

iievaiv
fii.yj

ovk eroXfxyiaav iipoaayayeh' Ttpog aXXrjXovg Se
hio

eXeyov
pov

"

rtg yjveyKev avroo (payeiv ;"
€fi.ov

Kat avrog aa(f)eareeartv, tva
TrotS)

avroig diTeKdXvxpe Xeyav, "

^pafj,a

ro

"
'*

BeXyjfj.a
vfj,etg

rov

Ylarpog
ort

//,01»,"

OTcep

epf*.Yjvev(tiv

en-^yayev, " ofj^

Xeyere
e^Yjg.
'

rerpdfj-yivov eariv, Kat

6epiaft.og

epyerat^^ 15

Kat ra

Ktpiaaot.
ryjptav

OXog fuv

e| oXov irpog t»?v tojv KeKXyjfxeviov aco~
'Ke

avvretverat, itotenat

Xoyov ov^eva t^c rov awfxarog
'btd

rpo(f)^g, Kairot KeKfLi^Kwg e^ o^otnopiag, tva ndXtv

rovrov rovg
ff.ev

ev

ra7g CKKX^^aiatg

a^fteX^^^arj

^t^aaKdXovg, Kai Kafxdrov
itept

Trav-

20

rog dvaTretavj ireptopav, Kpetrrova ^e ryjg

ro

a(iofJ.a

(f>povri^og

T^v

€711

ro7g aw^ofnevotg iiotetaBat aTiovtyiv.
'Q.g

'Ammiqniot.
fxaGy]rdg

li^aaKdXovg r^g
ry^g

olKovfxevy^g

^i^daKet
6€Xyfft.a

rovg rov
roov

iiportfxav
€7ii6vfxe7

oiaa^yjTiorovv
rpocf)^g,

(Spaaecog

ro

Qeov. wg
dv6pCti7IClOV.

rtg

ovroo

Kayw r^g

awrt^piag

25

'AnoAiNAPioT.
e^ey(^ero,

AyjXovatv ori rdg ^taKOVtag rSov
oov

7ipo(f)€povroov

Katrot ^vvarog

rpe(f>eiv
i]g

Kat

fxv]

rpe(f)ea6at.

evepyeaia

ydp

[xeyiaryj ro rpe(f)etv

Hptarov,

ovk

e(f)6ov€i

roTg ^ovXofxevoig,

tio Kat ro7g fxa^YiraHg ro taov era^ev.

30

Ktpiaaot. \71eardX6at
Ka) riaT^o?
Y}

Se ^Yjat, ^^Aov Se OTi ^ra^a tou

©eou
e/c

Kard rov

r^^g evav6pc»7i-^ae(jog rponov,

^ wg Aoyog

Toy yevvYiaavrog vov, TipoKvTinov rtva Kat

7ief/.7iofxevog.

Kat

fxer

^ (fioiyoi

Cod.

IV. 39oXiya

mANNHN
^oiyapovv vTrapywv
TO
epyov avroVf
o

ETArrEAION.

223
deA>7/xa,

tlog ro ayaBov tov Ylarpoi
Tolq

TekiioX

a-ooTfjpiav

via-Tevovaiv

eii

avTOv
irpog

ava^€iKvvfX€vog. %«<^/'«f /^f" xai Oepiaixov to TiXyjBog twv
VTro^o^xyjv

iTol^v

Tov KfipvyixaTo?
yj

ovofjid^ei'

o(f)6akfxovg Se

evTavSa Xlyei, ^

TGff T^f ^iavoiag
Ttkyjdoi

Tovg tov aafxajot;'
epy^Ofi.evov'

Kai yap eapuv Xoittov to 5

Tav ^afJiapeiTav

tvjv ^e Tijg iipoaipeaecag avT<ov

erotixoTaTa Tag yjnpaq

toc^ \evKaivo\Levaq cpvjaiv.

wavep yap

01

aaTayyeq

eiteitav

XevKavSaai

Trpog

afurjTOv

eiaiv eToifxoi'
*'

ovto)

Kai ovTOi Trpog awTfipiav Yjaav TrapeaKevaafxevoi.
<f>y]ai,
*'

O

6ep/^a)v,"

fuiaSov kafK^avei Kai avvayei Kap-nov eig ^ayiv aiaviov,

ivaio

" Kai
eaTtv.

aveipm
0<

ofJLov

xatpi^ Kai 6 Oepi^av." "^O ^e keyet toiovtov
(f)yjaiVf

Tipo^p^Taif

eaTretpav Kat ovk
yjOovyjg,

eOeptaaV
yjfJ-Tv

ov

fj.^v

Ota TovTo aTreaTepyjvTat T^g

aXXa avv

yatpovatv^

et

Kat
To7g

ft.y]

avv

yjfj.h

Gept^ovai'
ev

tovto Se ov avfj.^aivet ev Totg aiaQr^irvevfJJXTtKo^ig.

yevea6at,

aXX

To7g

Eav yap
6eptaaiy

ev To7g 15

ata6yiTo7g

avfj.^fi

erepov

airelpat

Kat

eTepov

ovy

OfLov

•yatpovatv, aXX' 0/ 6epi^ovTeg'
01

evTavda ^e ovy ovTCog,
yatpovat.
**

dXXa

Kat

aitetpavTeg Ofj.oiag
Ttpog Tovg

To7g afxwat

'Yivog eve/cev, (f>y]atv

6 'KptaTog
**

AnoaToXovg,
;'

oareaTetXa vfxdg 6ept^etVf

oi/y^

vft.e7g

KeKOirtaKaTe
eig

tva

orav

avTovg

aTroaTeXXyj,

fxy]

20

6opv^yj6iaatv wg
viOTepov

7tpayfj.a

entTiovov
^to

7ieft.7tofj.evot'

tq yap

eTttTto-

TO Twv TtpocpyjTwv
01 Trpo^pT^Tai, **

yjv'

(pyjaiv,

aXXot KeKOTttaKaat"
eiaeXy]-

TovTeariVf
*'

Kat

vfj.e7g etg

tov koitov avTwv

A^flaTe."

i^MMflNioT.
eXaXy]6y],
yyjivtav
7tefJ.7i(a

'Of
Vfj.ag

efjiov

ovTog

Toi)

aTTopoVf Kat

^ia

7rpo(f)y]Tiav

25

6eptaat.

ot fj.a6r]Tat

Kat Tovg

EXXvjvag twv

Kat Tovg Jov^aiovg toov aapKtKccv tov vofxou XaTpetwv d^toea-t
ttjv

TCfLVOvaif Kat etg tvjv aXo) a7tOTt6evTat,

KKKXyjatav, OTtov

aTayvg

Tpt{3ofievog yiverai a^Togy
6eptafi.og,

^m^totiav Tovg 7ttaT0vg.
y]

O

7tvevfJ.aTtK0g

eartv

deoaefSyjg

epyaata, T^jyv^o
ej^e/, cv

fxev d7to6eatv

Kat tov d7to6yjaavptafj.ov

ev

ovpavo7g

oe

tw

fxeXXovTt aixvt ditoXavatv dreXevTyjToV
T^ff avTaTTo^otrewf.

ovTog ydp

eaTtv

Katpog

39

** 'E/if T-iqg

TtoXecog ^e eKetvvjg TtoXXot
eTtei^^y]

eTttarevaav eig avTOv twv

" ^afxapetTwv,"

avveoopiov OTt

ovk av vitep tov yaptaaa6ai 35

224

EPMHNEIA E12 TO KATA
e^eTrofXTrevcre
(3iov.

IV. 42.

erepw tov eavT'^^
*'

KixapTvpei

yap Xeyovaa,
'^ii^veKioi
6<7rcov,

OTt eiTce {xoi TidvTa

oaa

eTroivjo-a.^^

Aio Kai e(3ov\ovTO

KaTeyetv avTOv.
hri
**

Tovto yap
[xe7vai

FivayyekiaTrjg

e^^Awcrev
^e toSto

yjpccTCOv

amov

iiap ayTO<V."
yjfxepag

AuTOf

/xev

ovk
odev 5

eTteiaBfj

'Troivjaai'

tvo

^e [xovov

efxeive Tiap

avTOK,

"

Kai TroXAco TrKeiovg eTriaTevcrav eig avTOv ^ia tov Koyov avTOv,^
aif][xe7ov

Kanrep
[xevoi,

ov^^ev

/Sovref ^.

lov^^aToi ^e Kai

BavfxaTa Beaadov

Kai

Totg 7rpo(f)V]Taig

avvTpacftevTeg,

ov

[xovov

KaTelyov

avTOVy

aXXa

Kai airrjXavvov.
'Eafxape^Tai aiTOv<ri
etaiv

AMMaNior nPESBTTEPOT.
[xelvai Tipog avTOvg, OTi

tov "KpiaTOv^o
01
**

riveg

aXXoytvei^;^ Kai

avyyeveig
l%Gpoi rov

avTov ro Kara adpKa

lov^^aioi

e^ia)Kov

avrov, ort

avapaiTTov 01 oiKiaKoi avrov.

Tor Xptsostomot.
yap
evoyjaav
TYjg

Ttjv "i^t^daKovaav vTrepi^KOvriaav'

evBeccg

ort

rriv

oiKov[t.ev'/jv

eTrtaiidaaaBat e[xeXXov, ori

eni

'

5

^iopSaaet
aTTOKXetetv

Koivvjg

^X6e acori^piagy ort ovk
itpovoiav,

ev ^lovlaiotg [xeXXet

avrov

rvjv

dXXa TiavTayov
dXXa

aireipetv

rov

XoyoV dXX^ ovy
oavvifjv

lov^aio; ovroog,
^tKatoavvrj rov

^yjrovvreg rvjv i^iav ^iKat-

ari^aat,

rr\

Seov ov% VTrerdyyjaav.
YicarYjpa 01

42

Oyj^ aTrXaig ^e KaXovaiv avrov
Toy Koafxov,
'yajO

Y.aixapenat,

aXXa 20
jotev

cog

t^vjv

dXi^Oivrjv

aooTVjptav

iiapeyovTa.

'HASov
Trept

TtoXXot

awaai Kai AyyeXot Kat
**

Trpotpy^rat,

dXXa

avrov
tyjv

[xovov Xeyovatv,
irpwrjv "

ot; dXyjQivog llwrvjp ovrog earivJ'^

Aio kui

avrovg
eTTi

^t^daKovaav

vTrep^KOvrtaav

varepov,

(ptXort-

[xov(xevot

ro [xet^ovwg 6av[i.d^etv

avrov, evovjaav

yap ev6eag 25
'Earvjpa

€« Tc5v pvj^xdrcov

avrov uv e^t^aaKev avrovg, rov

ovroog

avTOv

eivat,

Kai ovy eva raov itoXXm.
ot
',

Tivog ^e eveKev ov Xeyovaiv ^[xTv

¥>vayyeXiarai ra 6avOTTCcg [xd6oo[xev, ori

[xaara pvj[xara r^g '^t^^aaKaXiag aurov rav [xeydXoov naparpeyovatV

iroXXa

eK te rov reXovg rcov Trpayfxdrcov ^o

tva ^[[xeHg avro) avvopSo[xev rvjv rovroov ^vva[t.tv.

e

»8oT€«

Cod.

^

icdp^y

Cod.

IV. 46.

laANNHN ETArrEAION.

225

KE$.
Hfpl Tov

r.

/SaortXtxov.

42
**

Aia

Ti i^CTa TO eiTT^Tv tov

KvayyeXKXTriv oti
o

aTr^Afiev

f.ii

t^v

roA/Xa/av, 'npoaeOi^Kev qti " avro? yap
OT/ vpo<pi]TV]g €v TTj /d/a TraTpioi
Tifx-i^v

'K.piaTog

efxapTvpyjaev

ovk

^^XJ^i *

eauOr} ovk S

et( Ti^v KaTTdpvaovfj.
Tvjv

an^XSeVjakX
fxvj

eig

t^v TaXiXaiaVy KaKeidev ei^
[x.ev

Kava.
€(Jieive,

Iva yap

e^eToia-v}

ti^ ^ia ti iiapa

tois avTOv
tvjv

ovK

Ttapa Se Tolq "^aikapenaiq

\[t.eive, Ti6v]<rt

aiTiav

Xeyav
fxr]

OTt ov irpoaeT-xov

avT^,

Aia tovto yap ovk

aTirjXQev, tva.

fxeT^ov avToXg to Kpifxa yev/]Tai.

lo
oiKovo[xia$ Xoyov ^i^AcSv

YlaTpi^a ^e eavTov Kake7, tov
ovv

ty]<;

t/

ov^

opZfxeVf

<t>r]ai,

Kai Ttapa Tolg

lov^aiois

noWovq

Bavfxa-

^o/xevouf,

fxaXtaTa

fxev

ovk airo t«v cirav^^ovTcyv Ta TOiavTa ^et
ev

^py](pi^ea6at.

E/

Se

T/ve$"
vj

t^ avTcUv TtfxavTat
avvvjBeta

TraTpi^t, "ttoWco
iroietv

fxaXXov
etoiSev.

ev Tyj

aXXoTpta'

yap

evKaTa^ppov^ovs

15

AMMaNioT. Ov^x w?
TioXtTm
cov
T-Jj

t;/x^S' avTtiiotovfxevog e^v]X6ev,

aAXa t£v
Tifxr]

(pet^ofxevog'

OTt

yap eapav avTOv,

eQvfxovvto'

bf ev

Qeia eaapKwQ')^, Kat tov aTifxoTaTov vireaTV] QavaTov ^ta tv]v

yjfxwv aooTV^piav.

20
7rpo(pr]Tr]v

O^e

eafToy KaXeT tov

tov tmo Mcyyaecof TrpoavaeKX-^Sv],
iTpo(j>-i^Tat

Kr]pv)(PevTa, b? Kat 7tpo(f)r]Tr]g olKovofxtKag

avTog wv

6

tov

HvevfxaTog
fxefxw]Tat
01

%opyjrfoq
tcSv

cuf

0eof,

S/

ov

eTtpo^^Tevov.
^ei^v]

^e

raA.<Aa;cuv

aTro^e^af/.eva}v

avTOv, tva

OTt

KaKt^OfLevot
ju,ev

ovToi

fxdXiaTa Trpoaepxpfxevot avTa evpiaKOVTat. 25
Tt

'O

yap eXeyev, " eK Na^apeT ^vvaTai
OTt eK TV]g

dyaOov

eivat ;"

oXAof Se "
ttov

TaXiXatag
kou

Ttpo^pr^Tv^g

ovk ey^ye/JTOi,"
eig

aAA

Kat

HafxapeTTat

TaXiXaTot TttaTevovaiv

atayyw{v

\ovtatm' evpe6r]aav ^e Ka)
EACervoi
JU.CV

TaXtXaim
a

01

^afxapeTTat (BeXTtovg.
pr]fxdT<av avTOV,

yap dno twv T^g yvvatKOg e^e^avTO
eiroty^aev.

30

ovTot Be eccpaKOTeg, (pvjat, to, ay]fxeTa

46

T/vof
Xeyoiv,

eveKev

dvafxtfxwfa Ket

tov

BavfxaTog

KvayyeXtarvfg

"

OTTov €wo/>;<7e

to v^cop otvov ;" t«v "EafxapetTwv to iyKw-

226
[xiov

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
av^y}(Tai
(3ov\ofji.€voi'
01

IV. 48.
aito

/xev

yap Ta\i\aioi Kai
yevofxevctiv

tZv

«v

'lepoaoXvfJioif Kat

aizo

rav €K€i

c/ifxeim

avTOV

e^e-

^avTO,

01

^e YafxapeiTai oyj^ ovTccSf
yjtoi

aXka

airo

^i^aaKaXia^

[xovy^s.

^aaiXiKov oe KaXeT,
yovTa,
fkev ovv
rj

wg eK tov yevovg tov ^aatXiKov VTrdp-

d^tafxaTi dpyvj^; eTepov, ovTa Ka\ovfji.evov eyovTa. Ttve^ 5
too MaTfla/co* tet-

eKehov avTOv eivai vofxt^ovat tov itapa
cov

KVVTat ^e eTepoi

iiap

eKelvov,

ovk dvo tov d^twf/i.aTos
fnev

fxovov,

dXKa

Kat dno

T^i

TTtaTeoo^.
f/.evetv'

eKemg

yap

(3ovXofi.evov

tov

'K.ptaTov eXOeiv, d^toT

ovTog te etg t^v otKtav ekKei' Ka^e Kai KaTeitetyet'

KeTvog
fJiev

ft.ev

<pv]atv,

qvk

eifxi aJ^tog, oiiTog

KaKcT 10

airo

tov opovg KaTa^ag etg

KaTrepvaovfj. etatet, vvv ^e

awo

T^g "Eaf^apeiag, Kat ovk
vov
fj.ev

etg KaTrepvaovf/.,

aX\

etg

Kava* KdKet'TTvpeTw.

Traig TtapaXvaet
eiirev
fj.Yj

KaTetyeTO,
ort

o

^e ToyTov vlog
fn'^

48 Uepi Ttvm
"
/^>jTe, ov

\ptaTog, "

eav

avjfj.eTa

Kat TepaTa

"TTtaTevaviTe ;"

avTog yap
t^s*

fiaatXtKog ov (paive-i^

Tat eK TTtaTecog uvtZv, TOVTO
(pviatv,
Yj

aXX

vj

TtoXeag
cog

avTov KaQaTtTOfiievog

Kai TovTov avrov, ovy Kai yap Kat to

oXoKXvjpov TavTVjv,

dXXa

fj.eptKy]V KeKryjfxevov.

eiTteiv

avTOv,

"

Kvpte, Kardefj.(j>at-

"

PrjOt Ttptv aTtoSaveTv tov viov fnov,^^ tyjv aaBevetav
ct)f

avrov

vet,

fXYi

TttaTevovrog avTov, oti

et

Kat avft.^Yi avTOV aTtoSaveh, 20
^e

tvvarog eaTtv dvaar^aat avrov.
"KptaTov, ev
cvv TYjv
OTt
*'

eari
Tot/

Kat

a>g

ovk ei^OTog toD

Ttotoig

Ta r^g voaov
tyjv

Ttat^tov

eaTt.

Aia

TavTvjv

evTcX^ Ttiartv Kat

itoXXyjv enei^iv, iva ^et^Y)

avTw,

Kat dttm Qepaitevet,

(pyjat itpog

avToV "

Ttopevov,

viog aov

^yj*" oQev

eK tovtov tov nat^og ovy yjttov, Kat tyjv avTov ttd- 25

votav daSevovaav idaaTO.

^AMMiiNioT.
$aXfj.ovg

Tepag eari to itapa
lyeTpat

<j>vatv, otov

to dvoT^ai to ovk
e^co

0(j>-

TV(f)Xwv, Kat

veKpoV

aYjfxeTov Se

T^g

(pvaecog ov, oitep eartv tdaaaSat dppaaTOV.

^i

'Aif^vTYjaav ^e avrcp 01

TtaT^eg avTov,

Ta

TYjg vytetag

tov vtovZ'^

avTOv dnayyeXXovreg,
ov

ha

tq

eKitXayvjvat

avrovg to

yevofj.evov'

yap ditXMg

ovte wg

eTUj^^ev, dTtYjXXdyYj Tvjg
fJ.Yj

aadevetag to itaieivai

^iov,

dXX

dOpoov,
ri^g

wg (patveaQai
evepyeiag

(pvaecog

dKoXovBto.v

to

6avfJ.a,

dXXa

rov 'KptaTov.
t-I^v

MaOcov Se

"Ttap

avTcov

tKeTvog tvjv tapav, XotTtov rtpog

irtartv reXetcog ^teKvxpev.

Op^g 35

V.

2.

lilANNHN ETArrEAION.
ov-x^

827
6 X/3/<rT0f*

OTi T0T6 €7r/<rT6V(T€v, OTe 0/ 7ra7^€S CiVov,
oint

ore

tvjv

^idvoiav vvv hkeyyjov avTov

[Jie6

^^

TrpoYjXBeVy ilg iriaTiv
rjv

c0€A^e
oi

KeTai.

Upo yap
Kai

tov

(ryifxelov

ov (jtpo^pa
ovtev

'neiriffTevKWif ei

Kai

r]X6€

•napeKakeaeVf

6av[/.acnov'

eiw6a(Ti

yap

iraTepe^ vno TioXXYji (f>iXiaq ov [xovov olc 6appovaiv laTpotg irpo^xi-S
evaif

aKka Kai oh

y-^ 6appov(Xi 'biaXeyea^ai^ [xyj^ev

oAwf vapaXi-

veiv l3ovko[xevot.

Ammcniot nPESBTTEPOT.
yap layvei niaTig, avvepyov Kai
**

FIpo

[iiai

eTridTevaeVf

ev

^e

Tr[

e|^f Kai epyx YjKova-ev, oti ye-yovev

o €7r/o"Teycrev eae<r6ai'

iroXX^a

TeXeidiTVjv
yj

eyovaa tov Qeov.

lo

EiriaTevae §e Kai avTO^f Kai

oiKia avTov oA^," ^ia to
ovto^;

fJLa6eiv

avTovg irapa tov teavOTOv avTav, oti
rov itai^ogy ovnep
eiirev

^v o Kaipog

TYJg vyieiag

avrS

6

^ptarog, eK rovrov

XafSovreg (XTro^ei^iv r^g ^vvd^xeiag avTOv.

54

^^X
Tc5v

«''^*'^ ^f

''0

"

^evrepov" 7rpoae6y[Kev, dXX* eri ro 6av[i.a 15
arj^j.eiov

Y.a[xapeiTm^ ^eiKvvg ori Kai ^evrepov

yevo[uevov ovte

Trpog TO vrpog eKeivcov e(p6aaav

twv ov^e ev

avj^xetcov

eapaKorwv.

KE^.
TLepX Tov
Xj;' frr}

Z.
r!}

()(OVTOs iv

a<T6fvtiq.

1

Mera ravra
Yloia eopryj
eopraig

rju

ioprrj

tcov 'Iov8aLcov, kcu avi^r} 6 20

'Irjcrovf €L9 'lepoaoXv/JLa.
;

e/xo/ "^oKel r-^g irevTi^Koaryig.

avve^^^jag

Oe ev ralg
[/.er

eirtyoiptd^l^et

ryj

iroXei,

tovtq

jotev,

tva

to^ri

avrav
[t.d-

eoprd^eiVf rovro Se tva ro TrX^dog entandai^rat

ro a^oXov'

Xtara yap
awteaav.

ev

ratg eopraTg ravratg

01

d(f>eXearepov

^taKet[t.evoi

25

%

"EoTt Be eV
KoXv/JL^rjOpa.

Tols 'lepoa-oXvfioif

eTTt

ry Trpo^aTLKrj

AMMaNioT nPESBTTEPOT.
ra eyKara avrav
eirXvvovro eKei.

TipofSaTiK-i^

eKaXeiro,

ort

eKei

awfjyero ra Trpo^ara ra [xeXXovra a(pd^ea6at

eig ryjv eopri^Vf Kai

30

Beoacpot.

Tlept rS>v irevre

arowv ovrwg

oi[xatf [Ji.era

rag

ev

KVKXoi reaaapag, [xeayjv etyev erepav. T/f te 6 ivjg aadeveiag rpoTTog

Gg

a

228
oXtos ;
iroTov

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
^fx.Tv

V.

4.

fi.v(Trvjpm alvlrr€.Tai

;

ov

yap air^ag Kai eiK^
rrpo^iaypd(f>eif

avayiypa^Trraif
fxvj

aWa

ra ixiXXovra

[JivaTvjpta

aare

TO

cr(f)o^pa

•napo^o^ov dTrpo^T^OKfjTov yevofJievov Xvfj.-^vaaBai ry r^f
'E7re< ovv ^jaeAAe

itttrreoog lvvd<xei.

pdnrKTfxa tidoaOaif

ttoAXvjv

^vvafniv ey^ov, Kai ^copeav ff.eytaryjv to dfJiaprtag KaBalpov, Kai dvrt 5

veKpov ^aivra
TrpooTOV
fjiev

TrotSov,

KaBditep ev eiKovi irpo^ooyypacfiei ravra'

Kai

^thorat v^a>p, Ka6aipov acofi.dra}V KYjXt^^a Kai fKoXv(XfJ.ovg

ovK ovrag,
XeTTpav,
v^^arog
(Te(ag,

aXXa

'^oKovvrag

eivat, oiov

rovg dico Ki^^etag, rovg airo
koi TroXXa dv rtg
Tavryjg
eveKev
rv}g
'i^ot

Tovg

diio

rotovrm
TVjg

erepcoVy

^t

yeyovora
irA^v

eirt

TraXatag'

7rpo(j)d-Jo

4 oXiya
6

—" AyyeXog

dXXa

Trpog

ro Kareireiyov Kai

icoft.evov vovv.

Kai

fxer

yap

KaTa(3aivcov erdpa^rae ro ySo)^," Kat larptfudScoaiv 01
"Ttdvra

Krjv evertSet tvvafxtVf tva

lov^aiotf ort tioXXSi fnaXXov
voa-^ff.ara
rvjg

Twv AyyeXoov ^ecmOTyjg

ra

i/^y^^f
rciov

idca-

crQai "^vvarat.
<f)vatgf
7}

"Q^aTrep evravSa ov'^ aTrXcog larat
Tiavrog

vodrctiv

^^5

yap dv ^ta
evepyeta, ovrco
rvjv

rovro
vjfi.iv

eytvero,
ov'/^

aXX

eirt

t^ tov
epyd-

AyyeXov
^erat,

Kat

e(f>

aTrXoog ro vocop

dXX orav

rov Ilvevfi.aTog

'^e^vjrat
vj

ydptv, rore ndvra
KcoXvfna to5

ra

dfj.apTVjfj.ara

Xvet.

aXXa rore
eyivero,

f/.ev

daSeveta
Kvptog

(3ovXofJ.evca

BepaTrevSvjvat

vvv
6

Se

cKaarog

eari 20
rcov

irpoaeXSeTv.

ov

yap AyyeXog eariv
6

rapdaacov,
ovk

dXX

'AyyeXcov ^eayrorvig,
*'

ro

Trav

epya^of/ievog.

eartv elirehf

dvQpcnirov

ovk eyco'" ovk eartv eiireh

"

ev
vj

00

epyofj.at KareXOeTv,

" aXXog
V]

irpo efJ.ov

Kara^atvei" dXXa Kav
ov^^e
vj

oiKovfj.evy]

iraaa

eXSvjf
ofj.oia

ydptg ovK dvaXiaKerai,
Kai

evepyeta ^airavarat,
rovrov.

dXX

25

fj.evet

rotavrv], ota Kat

vrpo

dXXd

rt tviirore Trdvrag
"^Xae
;

a(f>etg

ivjaovg eirt rov

rpiaKovra oktco

eTVj

eyovra

1

;

Qat

Kai epcora,
irapeXKov

"

OeXetg

vyivjg

yeveaSat ;" oyj^ tva
tov rotovrov
rvjv

fJ.d6v],

rovro ydp

vjv,

dXX' tva

^t^^d^vj

Kaprepiav.

5

^MMflNioT nPESBTTEPOT. 'O^e
afJ.aTog
fJ.vaTVjptov,

7rpo^teypd(f)eTo ro rov (3a7rrt-3o
dfj.apr-qfj.drcov

ev

w

irav

eitog

eQepaTrevero.
eKirXvjKrog

" Ev
vj

ravratg KareKetro

irXvjSog iroXv^'
ervj

Koi

toc

e^v)g.

Kaprepta tou irapaXvT tKov'

rpiaKOVTaoKTco

ety^e,

Kat KaB
ev^-

eKaarov evtavrov diraXXayvjaeaQat rov
^peverOf Kai ovk d^piaraTO'
el

voa-fjfj.arog irpoatoKciov

yap rd

fj^

TrapeXBovra,

Ta yovv 3^

V.

8.

mANNHN
yjv

ETArrEAION.
aXk

229
ofJMi ovk

lnkKXovra ovy^ iKava

avTOv aTrayayiiv rov tottov,

aveireafv ov^e aircyvaj.

Ktpiaaot.
V€ia T^f Tov

Tvvos Kai
{(xpayjX
€is

y]

TtoXvy^oviog tou irapaXvrtKov acOi-

^piaTOV airKJTiag' aaOev^aa yap Kai
Ttg

7rapa\v6Yi<T€Tai,
Tryj,

ak\ ecTa/

avTW iiapa tov
eitt

'Lcor^po^ eTrtaKO-^

Kou vyiaaO-^aeTat Kat avTOS

rri

KoXvix/S^^Opa ^i

viraKO^i

Triareas.

'AnoAiNAPioT.

To

rpiaKoarov Kai

oy^^oov
yjdvi

cto? Toy Ketfx^vov
ori

TtapaXvTov avjfxaivei
Kai reaaapdKOvra

KoXdaecoi yjpovov

av[J.ir\y]pov[xevoVf

ery} o

kaog

lirt

T^f

epyjfxtag

^iKa? e^eTtae, Kat lo

reaaapdKovra
vo[J.og

yj^xepag

eireayev

o

KaraKXva[ji.Oif Kat vXyjyaTs Se o
o

reaaapdKovra rovg d(j.apTdvovrag eKoka^ev.

roivvv Kvptog

VTrore[j.vo[kevog ro TrXyjpeg

r^g KoXdaeag, eret rptaKoarS) oy^ox 6epa-

vevet Tov dppaarov, coaTrep Kat rag vo[J.iKag KoXdaetg vTrere[j.vero
"^ta ryjg

ydpirog, eyyvg toS Koa[j.tKOv y^ovov

TreirXyjpco^j.evou.

15

Ammcniot nPESBTTEPOT.
T^ivog eveKev rovg

Ovy^ wg dyvocav epcora, dXXa ^ia-

vtarcov avrov etg e7ri6v[iiav rov 6epaTrev6vjvat.

dXKovg irdvrag d<petg

e-rrt

rovrov yiX6ev 6 "Kpiarog
iva [nddyjf rovro

Kai

epcorSif

"

ei

6eXet vytyjg yevea6at ;"
tva
yj[J.dg '^i^d^y} ryiv

ovy

yap
ypyj

irapeXKov

yjv^

aXX

rovrov Kapreptav.

Ato
vai

20

aKoiryjaai,

[j.e6

oayjg

eirtetKeiag

dvoKpiverat Xeycov^
egvjg

"

Kvpte,

avbpcoTrov Oe

ovk eyu,

Kat ra

It rovrcov rcov py][JMTCov

eXeeivorepov yevoir

dv; ri rav irpayixdrcov ireptTra6earepov, otav
oii^^e

Kaphiav avvrerptfj.[xevyjv eKeKr^t^ro,
avveyo[J.evogf

inro ryjg

[xaKpag da6eveiag
iroXXovg
dKovo[J.ev 2^

e(p6ey^aro
dTrai^evreov
ttjv

rt

l3xda<pyi[j.ov,

ola

Xeyovrag

ra>v

Kai draXatyrapctiv ev neptardaeaiv' ov

Karyipdaaro avrov

y][j.epav,
y]v

aXXa

irpdcog

aTroKpiverat, Katrot
^epairevetv €[j.eXXev,

ye

[t.y]

el^cog

rtg irore
[t.ovov tacog

epcoraVf ovff

ort

aXX

y]

rovTO

irpoae^^OKy^ae

ro yj)y]at[j.evaetv avrco rov
'^o

'K.ptarov ro e[t.^aXeh eig ro v^cop'

Kat ^td tovtcov avrov eirtaird-

aaa6at rav

py)[j.drcov

ov /3ovXerai.
;

Ovk

elirev ^e*

avrw

Kptarog

6eXetg ae 6epaTrevaco

tva

[t.y]

^o'^7j

KO[J.Trd^etv.

8

KeXevei Se ayTOv apai ro KXtvi^tov, jrtarci)aaa6at l3ovXo[xevog
ro yevo[xevov 6av[i.a, Kat
[xyjteva
'

vo[xiaat

(pavraatav avro eivat.

€7r€«8ij

Cod.

230
OvSe yap av

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
ei fxri pej3ai(i}$

V. 12.

Kot acpodpa avToo avHvayv]

Ta

/xcA>j,

Tvjv kXivvjv (pepfiv vj^vvaTO.

OvK

airaiTei ^e avTOv irpo T^f /acrecof "Jtkxtiv, (oairep

(tii

akXwv

TivS>v, OTi ov^eTTftj

avTOv eapaKei

ai^fxeTov

eTepov Tre^noiyjKOTa, aAX'

ovoe oaTis
•^po

>jv

yjoei

Kai yap Kai
jtxeTa

eKemvg

ovg anvjTei

"TTiaTiv,

ov 5

Twv BavfxaTm, aXKa
aTTVjTei.

to i^eiv avTov$ BavfJiara

TreTroiv]-

KOTa

""Hpe
vjKovae

^e TO

eavTov

Kpd/3j3aT0Vf Kai

itepieiidTei, eTreiVy]
[xvjtev

a/xa

maTevaag'

vjyepBvj

yevofxevog vyiyjgi

oKwg aTtiaTOV
10

evvovjaag.

AnoAiNAPior.
aal3(3dTa},
TVjg

Ovk

eiTrav ^ia

ti

TavTa eKekeve ytveaSai

ev

dXXa

^ia ti TOvTa eTvoivjaev ev

aaPPaTca

;

oy^

VTiep

Trapa^daewg tvayepamvTeg, dXXa

rvj acnTi^pia tv] Ttap

avTov

(j)BovovvTeg.

Y^ai toi ye oaov etg avBpwtrivov epyov, tovto fxaXXov

epyov

v]v,

OTtep eTroivjaev

irapdXvTog'

eKeho ^e Xoyog Kai

pvjfia.

15

yjpvi ^e Bavfxdaai Kai t>jv

^6Ta TauTa

itiaTiv avTov, Kat tvjv irpog

rovg

lov^aiovg Tiappvjaiav, 7r£f

eTTtKetf>.evm

avra Ka\ XeyovrwVf

" ovK
avTog

e^eart

aot

apat rov Kpd^j^arov

aov ^ta ro adjSParov,*'

ft-era Tiappvjatag rv]V

dvatayyvTOV einaTOfxi^wv yXtoTrav, rov

evepyeTVjv eK^^pvTre Xeywv,
**

"

Tiof^aag fxe vytvj, avrog

fiot etitev,

20

aj3ov

Tov KpdfSParov aov," fnovovov^t Xeyav, Xv^peHre Kat irapaaTro

itatere, KeXevovreg tc3

fiaKpdg ovto) Kat '/aXeiiv^g aitaXXditpoaraaaovTt, Kat roi ye
et7te7v, oiov ort 01^5^ ckoov
et

^avTt

jtxe

voaov

fLv]

TteiQeaBat

KaKovpTtotco,

yeh dXX

e(3ovXeTo,

evvjv

Kat erepag
ei

tovto

erepov KeXevaavrog'

^e

eyKXvifux.

tovto, kat
vj^et

ditortBefxai 25

T^v KXtvv]v, Kat Bepaiteiav ^e
CfTO)
'^aKVOft.evovg
eiit

eKpvi\^ev

dv

Kat yap

aa<pwf
eitt

ovy^
TV]g

rv]

rov

aaf^^drov Xvaei, wg

rv]

dppwariag ^iopdwaet.

12

Ttvog eveKev ovk

eiTtov

avra, rtg eartv

itoivjaag

ae vyt^,

dXX

*'

etTtav aoi, dpov rov

Kpd(3^aT0v aov ;" aTro TtoXXv^g KaKOvp-^o
^oKovaav itapdf^aatv eig fxeaov
fnev, iva

yiag' dva

yap Kai Kdra

t>jv

v]yov.

AvTog
V]

Sc rovrov ydptv e^evevae' jtpwrov

ditovTog avrov

fxaprvptd dvvnoitrog yevv^rat'
v]v

yap

ata6v]atv Xa^oiv r^g vytetag,

d^tOTttarog

rvjg

evepyeatag

fxdprvg.

E7re<Ta tva

fxv]

itXeov

rovrwv TtapaaKevdav] rov Ovfxov eKKav]vat' oloc ydp, Kat

oxptg ftiOVV]3S

V. 14.
TOt;

I12ANNHN ETArrEAION.
ov fxiKpov toT^
aiptvj(ytv

231
evievai (rvtv6^pa.

^ta<f>SQVOv[Jt.evov

jSaaKamvtnv

Aia

TOVTO avayjap4i<Tai;
Ttap

avro koB kavjo to (pyov aywvt'

vi^faQai
6avfji.aTt.

avToli.

E-y/icaAouvTef

yap t€Us

fxapTvpovtxt

tw

14

T/ ^ai
Kat Ta
voai^ft.a,

[xavQavofXfv ck tov,
;

" J^Se

vytvj^ ykyovaq, fxyjKeTt

dfxdpTave" 5
avBpwirca to

e^yji

IlpwTov

fxevy OTt e| dfJiapTtxv eTe^/Pfj

tw

hevTepov Se OTt dXrjOyjs 6 t^? yefvvyj^ Xoyog, Kat to fnaKpav
diieipov tyjV Ttft.a}piav.

eivat Kai

Tlov yap vvv utrtv
Ko\d^oft.ai
;

ot

Ae-yovTef,

OTi (V wpa. fLta enopvevcaf Kai
oi/TOf

a6dvaTa

t^ov

yap Kat

ovK ev TO<TovTois vifJMpTev CTeatVf ev qcok; e^oAa^ero,

dXk

10

okoKXvjpov 'yovv dv6pQ}Trov ^tov aj^eBov dv^Xaaev ev too fi-^Kei T^f
Ttfuwpiag.

Ov^e yap
twv

ev

XP^^-"?

"^^

dfj.apT-rjft.aTa

KpiveTat,

aAA*

ev auT'^ T'^ (pvaet

iieTiXyjft.fj.eXrifj.evftiv.

MeTa

toDto KaKeho

fi.av6dvoft.ev, oti kolv

yaXeTiyiv

'^afj.ev

virep

Tav

TrpoTepav dfi.apTy]-

fLaTxv

T^v

^iKrjVf

eha

Torf

avToTg veptveaa}fi.ev,

yaXeitaTepa 15
T'^ Ttft.aeirt

voXX^

•7retaofj.e6a jrdXiv,

Kat fuxXa etKOTCOi' 6 yap

ft.y]^e

pta yevQfxevo; PeXTioov, ag avatadi^Tog Kat KaTa(ppovr\Ty)<;, ^ova ayeTat

fi.ei-

KoXaaT-^pta.
;

Kai

tivo;

eveKev,

(pyjcrt,

fxyj

Ttdvre;

ovTOO KoXa^l^ovTai

Kai yap TtoXXov; opafxev Tojy (fjavXaov evacafjLaKat
7roXXyj<;

ToSvTaj

Kai

<7(f)ptyS}VTagj

airoXavovTa;

evyjfjiepiag.
fj.ei^(,vog

20

aAAa

to

fj.yjOev

avTOVi evTavSa

Tta6e'iv, e(f>o^tov

yiyvejat

T^f eKeT Ttft.<jopia;. Kai tovtq ^rjXav

IlayAoj' eAeye
(7vv toj

"

KptvQfxevot te

"

VTTO

Kvpiov

itathevofj.e^a, iva

fiyj

KO(Tfx<a KaTaKpt6(0fJiev'^^

Tot fjiev

yap evTav6a vov6eata;, Ta
;

8e eKei TtfJLooptag ea-Tt.
;

Tt

ovv

TtdvTa

ra

vo(Ty)fx.aTa

ef dfi.apTyjft.dTav

qv Ttdvra

ju,ev,

25

aAAa Ta
Kca
ev

uAe<ova.

TtyveTat

fxev

yap ^ta
Ttva

dfj.apTyjfxdTwv, wa-itep

Tarj'

Ba<r/Ae^a/f
^t
otei

opxfxev

itotaXyia

KaTacrye6evTa.
<f>y]<Ttv

yiveToi
** rj

^c

Kat
(Tot

ev^oKtfi.i^<7tVy

oo<7irep
rj

tw
iva

Iw/3

©eof,

aAAojf

KeyprjfJuxviKevat,

ttKatog dva(pavyj; ;"

)^vta oe Kat

aito

paOvu.ta; ytveTat.

Kai yap Kai yaarptfxapyta ^o

Kat

fji.e6rj

ra TO<ayTa TtKTOvat

vourjfJLaTa.
<f>a(Ttv

T/V6f Tov itapdXvTQV TovTOV ^tafidXXovTeg,
Hpt<7T0v
yevrjae(T6at
Trjv

avTOV tov
ttjv

KaT-tf^opov,
aitetXrjv
ev

Kat

ttd

tovto

dKrjKoevat

TtapayyeXiav Kat
yap,
(f>yj(Tt,

eKetvyjv,

Ovk

eaTt te ovto};. Ka)

" evpKTKei avTov

tm

tepw o

lyjcrov;," oitep fj.eyt<TTrjg

35

mANNHN
evAapeiag
Tpv(f)^ Kai
ayjfxeiov

ETArrEAION.
yap
aveyapvjaev
ev tco lepw

V. 17.
oiKaOe,
S^ojye,

eaTtv'

ovoe

ovbe

aveaei

e^wKev eavTOv,
wofJieveiv

aXA

Kai toi

ye roaavTVjv
veaGai eiK^.

fji,e\Xwv

e(po^ov,

Kai napa iravTm eXav-

a\\

ofSev tovtccv eneiaev avTOV aTroaTyjvai tov lepov'

Kat fxeTa to '^iaXeyBrjvai toIV ^lov^aloig
ov^ev ToiovTOV Yjvi^aTO,
[xovoV
opSifJLev

evpm avTOv

^Jyjaov^,

5

aXKa

iipog

to [xeXXov avTOV aa<paXt^eTai
avTyjg [xevovTa evyvccfJLoavvi^i,
[xot,

^e a^TOv Kai
OTt

eiti Tvjg

Ov yap
vm,

eiitev

avTO^ eaTtv

6

emm

apov tov Kpdj^PaTOv
laTpov avTOv
efjicpat-

aov, onep eKcTvoi eyKXyifxa eTrotovvTO,
(pyiatv,

dXXa
fxe

"

Irjaovg

eaTiv

Tcotrjaag

vyty}^

E/c

tovtovio

(BovXo[j.evog

Tovg dXXovg Trpoi tov ^piaTOv e<peXKvaaa6ai.
ypj,

Ov

yap

ovTW^" dvataByiTog

wg

fji.€Ta

Toaavryjv evepyeatav Kai ira"^iavotq.

patveatv TtapavTo. irpo^ovvat rov evepyeryjv, Kat KaKovpyfa
eiTTe7v, OTt ** ^lyjaov^

eartv

Ttotrjaag avrov vyi^'"

dXX

ovrog fxev

evyvwfxovi aKOTtio
yervjv ori

tovto eXeyev.
eitoiet ev
**

Oi

^e

lov^aioi e^iwKov tov evep- 15

ravra
(fyyjatv,

aa^^arw.
[xov eug dprt epyd^erat,

17

A<a t/

UaT^p

Kayw epyd-

"

^ofxai ;" TO

ofxortfxov

ro itpog rov Ylarepa ^eH^ai ^ovXofxevog.
dtio

"Afxa te Kai
dvQpdiTta}

dvayayeh avrovg SeXav

r^g y^g, tva

ff.y]Keri (og
(j>y]aiv,

Ttpoaer^aiv, ccAA' «f ©eaj Kat vofxoOeryj, Kat aaitep, rov ©eov
>

20

ditoXvere
r/

eyKXyjfxdrm

e^' oif Kai

ore ^iaTtpdrrerai,

\

/

ovTco

Kat
^e

efxe.

E/

rtg

eTttBvfxeH rov

rpoitov

fxa6eiv,

Ka$
ttjv

bv

epyd^erai

Tlaryjp, opdra

t^v

oiKOVfxevyiv

aitaaav Kat

ravryig itpovoiav'

Ka) ^Xtov dvareXXovra Koi

aeXyjvvjV

Tpey^vaav, Kat ityiyag Kat 25

Ttorafxovg Kat verovg, Kai (pvaewg ^pofxov rov ev roHg aTtepfxaai,

rov ev ro7g aoofxaai rolg Yifxerepotg Kai roig
Ttdvra, S/

rm

aXoywv, ra aXXa

m
ol

rote ro
^e
t'^

itdv

avyKporeirat, aittp Kat ev
avveyofxevoi

aa^^arw
avrov

ytverai.

itov^pia

fxdXXov

e^vjTovv
e^yjg.

ditoKrelvat,

"

ort ov fxovov eXve ro

adjSParov," Kat ra

30

OvK
dXXd
Xoyotg

elitev

Xeywv, ov ydp av ro7g p-^fxaaiv e^etKvv
ro^ig

fxovotg,

TtVKVorepov ev
e/j^ov

ttpdyfxaaiv.

T/ ^^

itore

;

OTt roHq fxev
ri^v

eittaKyptreiv,

Kat dXa^oveiav eyKaXeiv,
eTti

Oe

rav

Ttpayfxdrm opmreg^ dXyfQeiav eK/Satvovaav, Kat
^ opSv T€

rm epym

Cod.

V.22.
avaKif}pvTTOfJLevv]v

lilANNHN ETArrEAION.
tvjv
SyvajU,/v,

233
vj^wavro Xonrov.
(ftaa-iv,

ov^ev a.vTenre7v

aAX'
OTt

01 [xyj /SovXofxevoi

[xeT

evyvoofxoavvyi?
i<Jov

TavTa teyeaQai
Weco,

ov^

ApiaTog

eitoiei

eavTOV
ava:8ev

tod

aXK

oi

iovbaioi
eOia^KOV
y]

TovTo

vTrwTTTevov.
01
;

oi/Kovv
yj

ra
;

elprjixeva

eTieX6(i}f/.ev.

auTOv

lovoaioi,

ovk eOia)Kov

Kai

Oia tovto eOiooKov,

Oi ^

fTepov Tt
cAt/cv
;

Koi TovTO <7vvo[xoXoyeiTai' eXve to a-al3{3aTov

vj

ovk

ov^e vpo^ tovto eyei^ Tt avTeticeh.
Yj

riaTepa

i^^iov

ekeye

TOv Seov

ovK eXeye

;

Kai tovto aXrjQeg'
tcrov

ovkovv Kat
irote^v

Ta e^^g t»
©eoo,

T^? auT^f aKoXovBta^ eyeTat, Kat to
T^i auT^f yvwfXYjg
airocffaatg
o
"rjv.

eavTOV

lo
iroteTv
a<f>

To

^e

**

ov

^vvaTat

TiOi
t'x

eauTou ovOev," touto
aXXoTptov, ov^ev

arjfiaivet,

OTt

ov^ev evavTtov

YlaTpt,

ou^ev

^evov, Kat

TovTo Se t^v Ttpo^ tov YlaTepa ^eiKvvaiv laoTffra Kat
yvccfnvjg,

TO OLTrapaXXaKTOV Kat to uaavei «tto fxta^
^vvafxeag
av,
yivofxevov.

e^ovatag, Kat

AriXoT Se touto Kat
mtyjy

t'o

eirayofxevov,

" a yap 15
irotei,

q>y)aiv,

llaTi^p

TavTa Kat
Kat eK
tSov

Tt0( Ofxotwg
fxeTa

oSev Kat eK tccv avaOev

eipYift.ev<i}v,
rj

TavTa

Ae^flev-

twv, ^eiKVVTat Tvji taoTifjTOi

aTro^et^tg.

20

1

*

eaTi TO

Kat fxet^ova toi/twv Oet^et avTa> epya, tva vfxetg
eirei^rj

"

6avfxd^rjTe ;"

tov TrapdXvtov eacpty^e, fxeXXet Se veKpov 20
ei

eyetpeiv.

Aia tovto

^rjaiv,

Oavfxd^eTe, ort irapaXvTOV vytrj

ireTroirjKa, fi.ei^ova TOVTCtiv o^^eade.

TairetvoTepov
fxavtav

te

ai/To

eiire,

TOvreaTt to " ^ei^e^," tva t^v
ort
'

avTav irapafxvB^arjTat'

yap

ov

Kvptcog

to

"

^e/^ei"
<^ijo-iv,

Ke^xjirjTat,

Ta
~."

e^rjg

^i^Xo7.

*'

Q.avep

yap
6

HaTy^p,"

25

"
ce

eyetpei
^a'o7ro<ei

Tovg veKpovg Kat ^aoTroieT, ovtco Kat
to

V

^^

"^

jtxev

yap

li

"
ccajrep

fT-r^''"~^' HaTrjp
eyetpet

Tiog ovg OeXet
Trjg OvvafLecog

^eiKvvat T^v dirapaXXa^tav, lo Se
taoTi^Ta.

"

ovg fleAe/," T^g e^ovatag t^v

22

E7re/^>; Se

evepyeTOVfxevot
*'

01

dvBpayirot

ov^

ovTCog aiaSdvovTat,

30

Ota TovTO eirdyei, ort

t^v Kpiatv irdaav te^aKe tx T/oI," iva
Ttfxy^v

Kav

(pojSog

e/f

tijv

tov

Tiov avTovg

eirtaTrdarjTai.

Tcaaav

Oe

c/ttcdv

touto eOr\Xcaaev, ort Kat tov KoXa^etv Kat tou
ctsg

Ttfxav eaTt

Kvptog airavTag,

av

eaeXr].

cvaTrep oe

to

*

eOcoKe
e^cDKe

"

^ccirjv,"

eyevvrjaev

aviov

^avTa eaTtv,

ovTca

Kat to

"

35

H

ll

234

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
eyevv^crev, e/A^a/ve;.

V. 24.
aKov-

" KpKTiv" Kpnyiv avTOv
ovT€$ OTi aniov eyjei tov

"ha yap

fji,^

HaTepa, TrapaWayyjv ovaia^

vo[xto-<t}fji.eVf

Kai

Ti\i.riq

ekaTTCtiaiVf ^ia tovto avTog

epy^eTai vjixag Kplvwv

t^v

ia-OTy}Ta
e^^Qtiv

evTevBev Trpog

tov

YlaTepa ^eiKvvg.
to.

'O yap e^ovaiav

Kai KoXa^eiv Kai Tifxav ag pov\eTai,

avTa

'^vvaTai

tco5

YJaTpi'

TQVTOV he '/apiv ovTca

cf)6eyyeTat,

^ta

to aTtapo^eKTOV
p^fxaai'

yeveaSai rov Xoyov, Kai To7g v\prjXo7g
TOVTO
eiTreiv,

irpoo^^oTroiyjaat

^ta

avafxtyvvai TavTa

eKeivotg,

KaKeiva TOVTOtg, olov eK tov
Kaych
epyd^of/iat'"
'^ia

"
TO

itaT^p fxov
Ofi.OTtfj.ov.

epya^eTat,
YiBeh.fiaav

e^e/|ev

eK
ot

TOVTOv

avTOv

tovto

dTTOKTeivat

10

Jov^aiot'
TiBvjatv,

irdXiv Tyj Xe^et fiev KaOvcpivjat, to, vo-^fnaTa te

Ta avTa

oyTW Xeyuv, " ov ^vvaTat
eirt

viog iroteTv

d(f)

eavTOv of^ev."

E/Va

Ttdktv

Ta

vrprjXa dvdyei

tov XoyoV

" a yap av eKeivog
liaXiv
eiti

TToty],

(pYjat,

TavTa Kai
yap 11«^»;^
fiei^ova
loaTiep

vtog Ofxotag irotet.

tq

TairetvoTepov,

"

ayaitS, tov Ttov, Kat TtdvTa
tei^et

^eiKvv- 15
eir}

" atv avT^, Kat
TO vxprjXoTepov,

tovtccv

avTw."

E/t»

TrdXiv

"

yap

6 YlaTvjp eyeipet

Tovg veKpovg Kai ^woOfKov

"
*'

TTOteT,

ovTw Kat

Ttog."
Kptvet
eTii

E/Va to Tanetvov
ov^eva,

Kat vxpvjXov,

ofSe

yap

ITaT^p

*'

^aKe

To3 T/oS."

E/Va

to vrp^^XoTepov,

dXXa iraaav t^v Kptatv §e" tva TtdvTeg Tifxxat 20
I^ov
ttoig

" Tov T/ov, KaBag TtfLwat tov HaTepa."
TtotKtXXet,
"ht

tov

Xoyov

vrpvjKav avTOv

Kat Taitetvm

vcftatvcov, (isaTe

Kat To7g

TOTe yeveaGai evitapddeKTOV, Kat To7g fxeTa TavTU
/3^vai, dito

fi.yj^ev

/3Aa-

Twv

vxpyjXccv

Kat twv eTepccv

tvjv

TtpoarjKovaav Xafipdyj

vovTeg evvotav.
Trj
TtfKyj
Toi)

AetKvvg ovv OJt avfj.TteTtXeKTat
riaT^Of,
(pyjaiv, **
f^vj TtfJ.av

TifJ.yj

tov Ttov, 25
TtfJ.S.

tov Tiov ov
6
fnv]

tov

" TiaTepa
f/.ri

tov TtefxxpavTa ayTOV," oyj^ ditXag

t//x»v,

dXX

Tiy.av ovTcog ag TtpoeiTtov, (pvjat, TOVTeart wg tov IlaTe^a.
ft.v]

24

JJpog ^e TO

eKSvjptaS^vat Tovg

Jov^aiovg, /SovXofjievog aitaoti
**

pd^eKTOv
ovatv
01

Ttot-^aat tov Xoyov,

eK tov

fj.aSe7v

tw IlaTp;
aKovav
e^^g.

TttaTev- ;^o

avTov aKovovTeg, ettv^yaye Xeyoiv,
tcc iteft.xpavTi

fj.ov

Tovg

Xoyovg Kai TttaTevcov
'^e^du.evot

/xe," Kat

Ta

Tovto yap
evKoXooTepov

fieTa

TtpoBvfj.iag,

kou Ta

Xotita

efj.eXXov

^ey(eaBat.

To

§e

"

elg

Kpiatv ovk

epp^eTa/,"

TOVjeaTtv,

ov

KoXd^eTat' 3S

V.

2 7.

lilANNHN ETArrEAION.
(f>it}a)f

235
J»^!'

QavaTov §€,
eKCivrjv.

ov toiovtov,

aXKa

tov atwvioVf (Danep Kai

25

"ha
Kai
Iva
*'

te

[xyj

^o^yj

KOfxiTo? eivai

to Tipayfxa Kai Ty(^of, -napkyei
oti epyeTai copa

Trjv
fji.y)

Oia twv epyoiv a-noQeiqiv, Ae-ywv,

ena

fxaKpov viioTiTivaafAev y£OVov,

" Kai

vvv eaTiv, ot€ 01 veKpoi 5

aKov70VTai T^f (pmrig tow viov tov avQpamov Kai ^•^aovTat.'^
<f>i/]<TiVf

vvv,

efxov

hiaTpij3ovTo^ fxeS

vfiMV,

tovto yev^aeTai irpoi
^e

TO

fxy]

^iaTriaTeveiv vfi.ag Trepi

tovtoV

Tovto

eXeye vept wv

efxeXXe veKpav aviaToiv, olov tov vtov TTjg 'X.vpag Kai tov Aa^dpov.

E/Va Kat
**

Xoyi<xfi.ov eTrdyet

twv

€tpyjft,evcov

diro^etKTiKov.

**

£l<T7rep

10

ydp,
vi'j}

(f^yjaiVf 6 TraTyjp ej^ei ^w>jv

€V

eavTw, ovTCBf e^coKe Kai

tco

"

^aiyjv

eyetv ev eavToj.
**

T>jv
fxovov

^e Tov

e^a)/fe"

Xe^tv evTavOa
eivat, tov Oe

TeBeiKev
1 tov,

eiti

to

^et^at

TOJ

Tov

jtxev

liaTepa

Ta

Oe

aXXa

itavTa
15

TO taov Kat ditapdXXaKTOv efx^aivet itpoq tov YlaTepa.

27

T/vof eveKev dvdrxTaatv
XeycoVf
^^

Kat

Kptatv avw

Kat

KdTto

<XTpe<f)et

Kai e^ovaiav e^coKev

avTW Kai

Kptaiv irote^v" OTt

TovTa

[xdXtaTa itdvTWV eaTtv, a Kai enayayea^at %vvaTat tov

dKpooLTyjy.

'O yap

"TFetaBeis oti

Kai avaaT^aeTai, Kat avTW ^waet, TovTeaTt

Tw

X.ptaToi, Kai evOvvag

tZv

ireirXyift.fLeXyifi.evwv, et

Kat

ft.yi^ev

eTe- ao

pov ei^e arifiehv, tovto fxovov KaTo^e^dfxevo^, irpoa^paft.eTTat trdvTCOi
avToo, yifxepov
Xjorj
it

KaTaaKevd^av eavTW to

"^iKaaTyjptov.

atv,

^e f/.ev YlavXos 6 ^afxoaaTevf ovtu <f>rif\ f/ > ~ / ' ~ / ' / .»> /1 >\ ^' aXX ebcoKev avTcp Kptatv Ttoietv, OTt vtog av&pcoTrov eaTtv
ytvcaaKetv, oTt 6
ir<s

ov^efxiav aKoXovOiav ey^et.
dvBpctiTioq

Ov yap
Tyj<;

^ta tovto eXa/Se Kpiatv, OTt 25

eaTtv,

dXX

eTtetVfj

dppyjTov

ovaiag

eKeivyjf

eaTtv

vioq, "^ta TovTO eaTt
**

Kat

KptTyjg'

ovtcd toivvv dvayvcoaTeov,
^¥titetVfi

'*'0t/
eto-

vios dvBpccTTOv

eaTi,

fxyj

Bavfxa^eTe tovto."

yap

Ket Tolg opwat TtpoiaTaaOat to <f>atvofj,evov, Kai itXeov ovtev evofxt^ov etvat,
avSpcoTiov

dXXa

xpiXov

avOpanov,
yj

to,

he

Xeyofxeva fxet^ov

yj

KaTo,

30

i^v, fji.dXXov

Se fxeT^ov

KaToc AyyeXov, Kat
'*

Qeov

fxovov,

TavTrjv

Xvctiv t*jv

dvTiQeatv eitrjyaye,
**

/a*j

BavfiM^eTe."

Evtei^y] ^e elnev dvcoTepce,
*'

oVi

aKovm fMv

tovs Xoyovq Kat
fxri

itiaTevciov

tc5

TtefLXpavTi

fxe,

ov

KpiveTat" tva

vofxiawfxev,

OTt TovTo fxovov

dpKeT

Ttpof

awTviptav, itpoaTeBetKe Kai to. eK

TOU35

H h

2

236
)S;ov,
eiTTWVf

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
"
kui €K7ropev(TOVTai
01

V.30.
7ro/i;o"avT6f,

ra ayaBa

Kai

ra

elrji.

'AMMflNioT nPESBTTEPor.
aaaaif
ei
f/.7]

'

0(rT€ ovK apKii

yj

Tii(jri<;

[xovrj

Kai epya T/f

ej^e/

aya9d.

Ai

a/x^oTepcyv, rov re (po^ov Kai T^f ri[XYi^f TrporpeTterai e/f $

(Tcorvjpiav rov avBpcoTiov.

T/

arnxatvei ro,

"

ov ^vvaixai eyo} mieiv
eq>yi gevov,

air

efxavrov ovbev

;

ro aTrapaXAaKrov, ori ovbev

ovoev

irapif)X\ayf/.evov,

ov^e

^^ ^ovkerai
Kptva" rovro

Ylarvjp,

"nap

e/x.ov

yi-

verai.

30

To

^e

**

^aflwf dKOVoD,

^vjXoT ov ^t^aaKaXiaVf
Kpivct},

akXa 10

TO T^f i^iy^ov

^crov, a)(Tavei

eAeyev, oi^tw

(o^ravei

avroi
fxev

Yiar^p
TrpeirSos,

Kptvcov efq.

ETre/^^ ^e ev to/V e[X7rpo(T6ev,
^iyjXeyPrj,

ra

6eo-

ra

^e dv^pooirtvcog

irdXiv
yj

wg

av^pcoiroi

Kara-

(XKevd^ei
**

ra avrd, KOi

^vjdtv,

"

vj

Kpiaii

efx^ tiKata

eariv, ori

ov ^yjroi ro 6eXy]f».a ro efxov" Kai

rd

e^^i.

'O

/xev

yap

^eXcov, 15

<f>y](Ti,

ra eavrov

crryjCTat,

Kxccg

av

v7ioTrrev6etyj,

axnrep

<f)6etpoov

ev

rovrca ro ViKatov.

'O te

fu]

rd eavrov
;

aKoirtav,

riva dv

e^/oi

7rpo(f>a(7tv

rov

fi.y]

rd ttKata Ta

i\/y](f)t^e(j6at

A;a

touto ovv,
i"r

eTrethyj

TW TlaTp;
yofxevotg.

dvart6yjfji.i

yiyvof/ieva, 7rei(j6y]re

to/V

c/*oy

^f-

20
**

31
*'

To

^e

eav eyw fuaprvpu) irepi

efuavrov,

y]

fjt.aprvpta

fnov ovk

etjrtv aXy]6y](;,"
rrep}

t/

ay]fi.atvet

;

Kat ydp iroXXa^^^ov (patverai fiap"^afnapeiri^i
erepco6i
'^iaXeyof/.evog,

rvp-^(7ag

eavrov, olov

ry]

Kat

rS

rv(pXco, Kai

roTg

Jov^aioig,

Kat

iroXXa^j^pv

rovro
;

iroiel.

^Av ovv diravra ravra i^ev^^, rig ^f^Tv acori^ptag eXirtg
T*;v dXy]6etav
vj

Tro6ev te 25

evpy]aofi.ev,

orav avrr]

v]

aXyj6eta Xeyv], ori ovk eariv

fxaprvpta fiov dXy]6-^g.

Ov

rovro Se ^oAcer ro evavrtcofna eivai

fj.ovov,

dXXd

Kat erepov ovk eXarrov rovrov.
irepi efi.avrov,
iroiov
v]

n^oiwv yap

<f>i^at,

" Kav
YioTov
co-T<

eyu} ft.aprvp(a

fkaprvpta fnov aXy}6v]$ eari.
vofj.iacofKev
01

ovv

^e^ofLe6a,
;

^e

eivai

y^jev^og

;

T/ 0VV30

TO

eipy]ft.evov

efxeXXov avrco Xeyeiv
v]

lov^^aTot,

eav av f-ap-

rvpyjg irepi aeavrov,

fxaprvpta aov ovk eariv dXy]6y]g.

Aid

rovro

ovv irpoXa^wv rovro elirev, coaavet

eXeyeV

lacog epeTre /xo/, ort aot
ev

ov

irtarevofi.ev, ov^heig

ydp
Trpog

eavruj ft,aprvpcov d^tOTriarog eartv
rv]v

avdpconoig.

Ov

rotvvv

d^tav

t>;v

avrov,

aXXa

irpog rv]v^$

V. 35-

mANNHN

ETArrEAION.
TovTa.

237
/xev Acyij,

vTTOvoiav TTjv €K€ivwv e(f)6€yy€To

Ka/ orav

"

17

" fxapTvpta
Kai
TVjv

fxov ovk eaTtv aX>j6>jf ," t^v

yva}fi.riV

iXiyyei t^v eKeivwv,
eaeaSai, ^€iKvvg

[xeXXovaav avTco Ttap
OTi

€K€ivcov avTiB^oiv
iXTroppyjTa

avToT^,
Ae^yTj,

o/^f

Ta

eKeivcov
vj

t^^

"^iavoiag.
avT-l^v

OTav

&€

QTi

akYiByi^;

€aTiv

fxapTvpia avTov,

^eiKvvai tov 5
€^€i voixi^eiv
vir

"npdyfJiaTog t^v (pvatVf oti

wg Qeov d^ioiriaTOV avTOv

rpeis Tiapayetv fxapTvpiag tcSv XeyofL^vav'
ytvoft.€va,

Ta epya Ta
lccavvov

avTov
Trpo-

Tov liaTpog
eAccTTcy t>jv

ttjv fiLapTvptaVf
toi)

to

KVjpvyfna,
**

T€pav

TVjv

ladvvov TiQYjat

Xeym,

dXXog €aTiv
v}

"

6 fi.apTvpm n€pt

Ifxov,

Kai oi^a OTt dXfiQvjg laTtv
OTt
OTiep irpO
t^jjv

fxapTvpia 10

" aVTOv"
**

^CtKVVi

Kai

€VT€v6€V,

TOVTOV €<Vev,
€a:€/vwv

"

rj

fiapTvpia fiQv OVK €aTiv
€ir€t irSog
jtxTj

aATjfivj^"," irpos

e/Vev vno;

votav

aA>j6^ eivat fLapTvpeH tvjv tov lcnavvov fxapTvpiav
€i

Iva ^e
f*.€vos;
**

Xlytoat, t/ ovv

Kat €K€ivq$ efnapTvpyjai aot '^api^o**

Kat TavTfjv ave^Ae t^v virovotav e/Vwv,
Trpog ^lcDdvvvjv, Kai
fi.€fJUipTvpi^K€
TYj

vfncTg

direaTdX-i^
ovk av he

KaT€

dXyjS^ia,^^

dir€aT€iXaT€f

(priaiv, ei ft.^ d^toTrtaTov vjyelaSe.

34
**

To

^e

"

eycb ov Trapa dv6p6CTrov tyjv fxapTvptav

XafnPdvco,
/xev

aXXa
<f>YifA.t,

TavTa

X€yco, tva

vfk^lg

o-cofi^Te,"

ToyTO eaTiv, eyw

OVK

€&€0jtx,7jv

T^f

Toi^Tou

fj.apTvptag,

@€og

cov,

TYjg

dvdpcoTrtvYjg.

20

KTr€t^Yj

^e

fndXXov

avTco

Trpoaety^Te,

vjirep a>g

lfi.01,

Kai

TrdvTccv

d^tQTtiaTOT€pov
fj.€T€, €fj.o]

vjy€7aQe, Ka)

eKtiv^ /xev,

tt^o^ijttj
'^ta

irpoae^pd-

&€ QavfxaTOvpyovvTt ovK

€7rtaT€vaaT€,

tovtov vfxag

avafj.ifj.vvjaKca

TVfi fJMpTvpiag €K€tvvjg, Kai irdvTa iroiw (oaTC vfJMg

aceBvjvai.

25
§c Katofxevov Kat (paivovra avTOV enre "^ta to
fi.vj

Ai^vov
e)(€iv

otKoSev

TO
Sc

<f>cog,
**

dXXa

diro TVjg tov Ylv€Vfi.aTog ydptTog,

ZS

To

vfj.elg

vjSeX-^aaTe

dyaXXtaa6v]vat irpog copav
fj.€v

toS (f)C0Tt

afTov,

dijAoi ot;

a;reOe$avTO
€i-)(ov,

Trpog copav

Ta

etpi^fxeva,

Kat

op6^v irept avTOv Kptatv
airovOi^v,

TOVTeaTi TrpoaKatpov Kat a^e/Satov ^o
Iijo"oiJv

Kt ydp

€Tr€fJ.€tvav,

Tayicog dv avTovg irpog tov

e^^etpaycoyvjaev.

E/Va
y(ov,
**

T*jv

€K
^e

TcSi/

ihicov

epycov fiapTvpiav
fj.€t^ova

^etKVvg, hrvffaye Aclojoevvov,

eyli

ej^a)

t^v fj.apTvpiav

Ta epya d

238
" e^uKe
fxoi

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
TlaTyjp
iva
7rciiS>f

V. ^9-

avTa

fJLapTvpeT ori o

UaTyjp

fxe

"

ane<XTei\ev."

KvravQa rov TiapaXvBevTog
irpog

Kai

avopSwQevrog

dvefxvyjaev.

Et; ^e Kai

t^v KaTTjyopiav t^c tov aa(3PaTov

Xvaeag eviQTaTai.
elvai^ OTi

'ETre/^^

yap eXeyov

"niag

tvvaTai ano 0eoD

ro ad/3l3arov ov

rvjpeT,

^id rovro

(f)V](7iVy

" d

eOccKe

ft.Qi

5

"

YlaTYjp.^^

Aeyet ^e konrov Ka) r^v rov Tlarpog fLaprvptav,
avrog
ecrriv
cf^ccvy^v

"

ort

nefJL^pag fxe YlarYjp,
;

fx,efxapTvpYjKe nepi efxov."
o

Uov

^e fx,efxaprvpyjKev

" ovrog
^6

Tiog fxov

6

ayaTrvjTog, avrov
JTairore, ovre

" dKovere."

To

"

ovre

avrov aKYiKoare
elg

" ei^og avrov ewpdKare,^^
evdyoov

(pyjcrh,

(f)tXoao(pov
<pcovyj

avrovg ^oyfxa lo

Kard

fxtKpov,

^eiKVvg

ort

ovre

itept

©eou

e(7Tiv,

ouTe
fxyj

e/So<r,

«AAa

dvoorepog

ayyjfxdrcov eart.
6

Touto ^e

e/7rev,

iva

keycoai, KOfxird^etg,

M.xvae7 XekdXyjKev
yj[xeig

Seog

fxovcti'

waitep

ovv
**

Kai eXeyov, ort

"

ot^^afxev,

ort

'M.covaet XeXdXi^Kev 6

Seog' rovrov ^e ovk oitafxev
ori ovre

iroSev

eart."

Ata

rovro ravrd 15

(fyyjatv, ffiL(f>aivcov
<f)y]at,
e(f>
Q)

(pcovyj irept

©eov, ouTe el^og. Kat rt Xeyw,

ort (pcovyjv

avrov ovk aKyjKoare, ovre eihog ecopdKare, ov^e
e(f>
ch

fxdXtara avyeHre, Kai
Ttpdyfxari, ort

fxdXtara Ttdvreg eare TrenXyj-

po(f)opy]fi.evot

rd itpoaTdyfxara avrov e^e^aa6e, ov^e
E/ ydp Kat

rovro vfxh 'hvvarov etiteh.

Qeog avrd ^terd^aro, 20
fxy)

dXX

ofxcog

Ttap

vfxh ovk eartv, enet^yj

itiarevere
ev

fxot.

Atd

yap rovro ovre rov Xoyov avrov eyere fxevovra
aitearetXev eKehog, tovtco vfxeHg ov Ttiarevere.
Kdrco Xeyet
yj

vfxh, ort ov
avca

E; yap
^e

Kai
iti-

ypa(f>y], ort

efxot

^e^ itpoaeyetv, vfxeig

ov

arevere

ft.ot,

ev^yjXov

ori

Kat

Xoyog avrov aTtearyj

d(f)

vfxav.

25

Aia
eTre;

ri ovK eiitev, dvaytyvcoaKere,

dXX "

epevvdre rdg ypa(pdg ;"
ryjg eitt-

ra

Ttepi

avrov Xeyofxeva

ev

avratg TtoXXv}g ederro

ardaecog' avveaKtaaro

yap

avcoSev

avfX(f)epovTag rolg rore.

Atd
rco

rovro ^taaKditTeiv avrolg fxerd dKptPeiag KeXevet, iva rd ev

^dOet Keifxeva

'hvvYjBaatv

evpeh.


ori
vfxeig

3y

yJVK

etTte

he

ort

e^^^ere,

aXX

boKeire

ev

avraig

gcoyjv atcovtov e^xeiv,

oetKvvg, ori

ovOe cKetOev eKapitovvTO fxeya
aoo^eaOat
fxovvjg

rt

Kat

yevvalov dito ryjg dvayvcoaecog
fxyj

itpoa^o-

Kcovreg, ittarecog

itpoaovayjg.

ToDto yap avjfxatvet Kat ro eita-

V.43yofJLCVOv

mANNHN
"
^cuijv
ju,^

ETArrEAION.
itepi

239
xai ov fieXere

eK€7vai ei<Tiv al [xapTvpova-at

efxoVf

€Aaeiv 'apog ^e, zva

aiwviov eyyjTe.

CjIkotci}^

apa eXeye

TO

*'

^o/cerre"

S/a to

/SovkeaQai avToii^ 'netQeaOai,
ETrei^^
avefxvi^aev

«aV
Trjg

eTr/

[xovrj TYj

avayvaaet

av^^eiv.
tyj<;

ai/Tovg

tou

litidvvov

[xapTvptag, Kat
avTocv

tov Qeov, Kat twv epyoov avTov ^ta ^
eiKOi ^e
vjv

T^v

a-ctiTvjpiav

Kat [xovoV
'hta

TroXXovi vTcoirTevetv,
OTt
**

OTi ^o^i^i epwv

TavTa eXeye'

tovto

<f>y)atVf

^o^av itapa
vj

"

dvQpcoTTov

ov

Xa[t.^dv(i}y^ TovTeaTiv, ov teo[xai,

ovk eaTtv

e/x>)

TotavTT], w(7Te ^e7a6ai t^j "Trapa dv9pa}7rav ^o^yjg.
9

oe

eyvoiKa u/xa^, OTt tvjv ayairvjv tov K^eov ovk
oti ov
Ot

^'^(eTe,

lo

eiire, oeiKvvg,

ayairr^v Kieov avTOV

eOtcoKov,

Kav

6VTa)i

eKeivoi irpoe<f>aai^ovTo.

'Opoii OTt avca Kat KdTco ^ta tovto Xeyet direaTdXSat, Kat irapa

Tou YlaTpog

elXy)(f>evat,

Kat ov^ev ^vvaaBat
dyvu}[/.oavv'rjg.

Troteiv

d(p

eavTOv, tva

itaaav eKKOXpvj 7rpo(f)aatv

15
eAOyj

43
"

liept
i^tw,

Tivog

Aeyet,

oti

"

eav
Trep)

aXXog
tov

ev to)

ovo[xaTi

too

eKehov X^xpeaSe ;"

hvTtyjiiaTov oaTtg
6

eavTOv

[xeXXet diro^etKvvvat, OTt
**

avTog eaTtv
ijXSov,

Qeog.

ToDto ydp eaTtv,
jtxe."

ev To3 ovo[xaTt tov

riaTpof

Kat ov ^ej^ea^e
v[xag T>yv tov

Tovto

§€ av[t.(3atvei V[xiv ^ta to

[xyj

^vjTetv

Seov to^av, 20
XeyeTe

aAAa

[xdXXov

t»;v

Trapd

dXX-^Xm Xa[x^dvovTOg.
^i

^tiret oe

Mwi/Ver

irtaTeveiv,

^eiKvv[xt
Mcoiicrer.

wv KaT

e[xov

ToXfxaTe, OTt [xdKaTVfyo-

XtaTa dirtaTehe tw
** **

A<o Kat " eKehog eaTtv
eti

p^v v[xm

Trpog tov

HaTepa,

ov

v[xeTg vjXvtKaTe.
e^rjg.

Ki yap

entaTeveTe Mavtjer, eirtaTeveTe av e/xo^," Kai Ta

Uwg
(fii^aiv,

25

^e Mccjva^f 7rep<

afToy eypaxpev dKovao[/.ev.

Kdv

Ttg eXQvj

ayi[xe7a irotihv, Kat irpog tov

Qeov dym, Kat TrpoXeym Ta [xeXXovTa

[xeTa aXv]6etag, viraKovaeTe
ovv

avTW

[xeTo. rrdavjg airov^^g'

\ptaTog

TavTa

TreTrotvjKev.

ToT ArioT Ktpiaaot.
dvo[xiag viov,
'*

'EvTeufiev

otfnat

avveig, Kat
IoySa/c<Jv

[xaKd-2,0

ptog riavAoj" aXviSeg Tt (pi^at, irept

te tcDv

Kat tov TVjg

dv&

m

t>jv dydirvjv TVjg
•ne^xxl^ei

dXvjOeiag ovk e^ei^av etg to

"
**

aaOvjvat avTovg, tta tovto

aiiToTg 6

Qeog evepyeiav irXdot

Wjgf etg to irtaTevaat avTovg tcU y\jevhet, tva KptdSoatv airavTeg
fxv)

**

TTtaTevaavTeg

tyi dXv)6eta, aAA' ev^oK-^aavTeg Tvj dttKt(tr

35

240

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA

V. 43.

'Ammcniot nPESBTTEPOT. E/ Koi

oidev OTi ov TreiGovTaty «AA'

wf Seog TO iavTov voieif eXeyy^cov Kai vovOeTwv.
Trjv

Avt ^^(^picrTog
cKeivw ni-

Tov

IBiov

^o^av

eirayyekXeTatf Kai

^ta

tovto

aT€veT€.

Eya
ev

fjt,€v,

<f)y}aiVf evet'^'^ irep vfji.ag Trpoi;
vff.iv

tov Seov avaywy oiihev 5

TOJ

/5/0?

TrepijSXeTTTOV
\eyofJievcov
TVjv t»;v

eTrayyeXAojaevof, airocf^evyeTe
eiiei^-^-wep

twv
ev
tyjv

•nap
Too

€fji.ov

^t^aaKaXiaV cKemg ^e

(3i(o

TOVTco
Toli;

iTaaav eavTov ^o^av eiri^etKVVTaif TroXX^v
aveaiv t6
^of>jf

evTavda

en

avTOV TrtaTevovatv,
eTriGvfj.ta

Kat
67r

oapocpopiav

eTrayyeXXofiievo^y

t^$

Trapovavjg

avTOv

avv- 10

^pafxeiade.

'AnoAiNAPioT.
ttavotav
fj.Yjatv

Aeyei

Trjg

aTriaTiag Trjv atTtav, eXey^^wv tZv

Ta

K€KpvfKfj.eva'

apy/jVTeg fiev
"he

yap

tvjv

airo

Xawv evhoKtTifLyjv

fj.eTa^taK0VTeg, Xaot

ttiv

irapa To7g apyovat
€fJ.€'

ayattjvi^

TroovTeg,

a<f>iaTaa6e Ti^g TrtaTewg Tyjg eig
vft.Tv,

01 fj.€V

iva

fnyj

"^o^av eXaTTwSeliev tyjv ev
Tif».y}v

vfxelig

Te

tva

fxri

tyjv irap

eKetvotg

airo^dXotTe.

KE4>. H.
Hepi tS>v
eiKog
airo

apTCiv Koi tS)v

l^6va>v.

^Etiretty)

"^jv

twv Xoycov tovtwv TeyBrivai

(pBovov Kai

20

fiyttov

ToHg 'lovtaiotg, KaTairpavvcov avToiig

Kvptog ^ta T^g ava-

ywpyjaewg, " «Tr^A^e Trepav T^f 6aXdaayjg t^j TaXtXatag t^j T/ySe'*

ptd^og'" yjKoXovOyjaav ^e
eiroiet
yjv.

avTw

o^y^Xot

TroXXoi, dewpovvTeg

Ta

avifj.eia

a

eirt

t&Jv

ao-^evoiivTWV, OTrep ov acpo^pa
tvjv

d(f)iXoao(f)ov

'yvw-

fi.y]g

E^e< yap avTovg fuaXXov ^ta

^i^aaKaXtav tovto 25
Tol^g

Trot^aat.

Ta

yap

ayjfi.€ia <f)y]atv 6

AiroaToXog

dirtaTOig, aXX^

ovK eKehog
** **

^'^(Xog

Trapa
(f>i^ai,

tw MaT^aico

TotovTog,
tyj

aXXa

irwg

;

e^eTrAi^TTovTo" yap,

"

irdvTeg

eirt

^t^ayyi avTOv, OTt

eoiOaaKev avTOvg, wg eqovatav eywv.

'Aaaos.

T^^

Xtfj.vyjg

(f)i^atv,

eGog

yap

Tyj

ypa(f)^,

<f)y)at,

Ta3o
vj

Twv v^dTWV avaTr}ft.aTa
Tojv Toirwv

6dXaaaav KaXeiv.
tvjv

H

fj.€Td^aatg Kai

evaXXayyj iKavwg
pa6vfj.0T€pwv ^i

tov TrXrjBovg e^oKtfLa^e irpoatpeatv.
eni xa>pag fxevovTwv
01

Twv ydp

okvov

airov^aio-

VI.

5.
rjKQXovSGVv

mANNHN
avT'2

ETArrEAION.
t^v
epi^fxov

241
rav
yiyvofJLivoov

repoi

Koi

c/f

eK

ciqixtim rag
opoi
yjft.ag

r\/vya.i;

oc^yjfxepat

(3e^aiov[xevoi.
ayjfx.ehVf

'AvvjXQe ^e

eU

ro

vvv

^ia TO fxeXXov yiveaBai

afxa ^e Kai

nai^evcov

(pevyeiv rovg ev ftearx Sopv/Sovg.
Yj

')(^p-^crif/.ov

yap

Tipog (ptXo-

<xo(f)iav

rjdvy^ta.

5

Ka/ yap

ore yj^ovXero fuvcrrtKOV ri rolg fxaSrjraTg 'Trapa^ovvaif

€/V opog avetcrtv.

©EOAflPOT MoM*OTE2TIA2.
r}fi.ag

^AvV]\deV

eii

TO

OpO^y

^l^dvKCOV
Qei

ori

rov fj.dXt<jra Se'2 Trpoatovra

"Trdarjg

aTtYjXXd^yPat

rapa^^^rjgf

Kat Katpov Kat roTrov Qopv^ov KaQapov tiVjreh.

lo
yiptaros
fx.ov,

Ktpiaaot.
Kara ro

Otc yap rav

*lepo(ToXvfj.(cv eKTrecpotri^Kev 6

ev Trpocj^-^ratg etprift.evoVf

" eyKaraXeXotira

rov oikov

"

d(f>yjKa rrjv KXrjpovofi.iav

fxov" Kai rolg aXXoyevecrtv eavrov eyadvetat de
eig

pt^ero,

rdre

irokvg

oyXog aKoXovSei.
diiQ
rr,g

opog

avrog^
15

rovrecrrtv,

vxpovrat

y^f,

eig

rov vnep rjfxdg
yj

ef/.(3atvci}V

ovpavov, tva irdvrag eXKvarj irpog eavrov'
eig opoc
avQpcoTtov

irdXiv erepag, KaBdirep
a>g

dva^e^y]Kwg

rriv SeoTrpeiryi

riff.-fjv

re Kat to^av' ov yap

artfji.d^ofii.ev

Kara

rov

la-payjX,
y]ft.e7g.

dXX

a>g

&eoy

Kai

^wryjpa Kat Kvpiov npoaKvvovfi.ev

OvK
KaKeiBev

dvi^XOe
etg

^e

eig ro

Ilao-j^a vvv,
i^pefi.a

dXX

eig

t>jv

TaXtXaiav, 20
vofLov,

Kairepvaovfi.,

Xotnov

vneKXvav rov

d(popfi.yjV Xafjij3dv(cv diio t^s'

lov^aiK^g

Tiovyjpiag.

To

^e

dvaPXe^pag
fxerd

roTg

o(p6aXf>.oig

tetKvvaiv

ort

ovtenore
ri

d-aXag eKdGrjro
Ttpog avrovg, Kat

rwv

fxaQrirm,

dXX

dKpi^oXoyovfxevog

entarpecpcav avrovg Trpog eavrov, b fxdXtcra rrjv 25

Kri^efxoviav

avrov ev^eiKVvrat, Kat ro raitetvov Kat cvyKara(3art-

nov ro irpog eKeivovg, avveKadyjvro yap avr co.

5

O/
epctirav

jue»

aXXot KvayyeXiarai rovg fxaSi^rdg (paaiv npoaeXQovrag
f>.yj

Kat TtapaKaXeTv, ware
§€
(j>y]at

diroXvaai rovg oyXovg vyjareig.
irapd

Ovrog

rov ^iXtinrov
elvai

epooryjS^vat
dXrjBrj,

rov
eni

^piarov. 30
rav avrav rwv
fxaByj-

^OKeT ovv

fxoi

dfxcporepa

dXX ovk

yevofxeva Katpwv.
rSiv

Kpara

^e rov ^iXfmtov, eTretVr} r^et

roiig

fxdXiara ^eofxevovg irXetovog ^t^ctaKaXiag.

Ovrog ydp

eartv

fxero.
yjfxivJ'^

ravra

Xeycov,

"

^ei^ov

yjfxTv

rov Y]arepa aov, Kat
epv6fxtae,

" dpKeT

Atd rovro

dvadev avrov
I
i

Kai

ei

fxev^S

242
omXiog TO
^e

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
crv](xe7oy

VI. lo.
to Gavfxa' vwi
iva

eyevero, ovk av to(tovtov

€(f)dvy]

7rpoT€pov avTOV

avayKa^ei oixoXoyYjcai

tvjv

aTraviv,

aKpi-

jSeaTepov KaTaf/.a6v} tqv [xeWovTog yiveaQai davfxaTog to [A€ye6og'

imwg

T-fig

eKTrXYj^eag yevofxevi^g, t^v

fxvYjfxi^v

twv ofxoXoyrj^evTm

ftv]

^vvYjOy]
'*

XoiTTOv

€KJ3aXeiv.

Aia tovto

(pfja^i,

"

TtoQev

ayopdaofxev 5

dpTovg iva (pdyaaiv ovtoi ;"

T/ eaTi
aeaOai
;

ireipd^wv

;

apa

a>g

dyvom

to fkeXKov ait avTov

pvjSi^-

ovtafxag,

dXX

dvdpcoTrivccg

tovto

e^ipviTat, iva toKifx.wTepov

avTOV diiepydarfiai.
Tvj

A;a

tovto Kai
evaiiofxeivag

KvayyeXiaTvjg, iva
vnoTiTevav]
vj^ei

fx.yi

daBeveia

t^^

Xe^ecog
(pvjaiv,

ti

itept

tov 10

pvjfLaTog

aTOTTOV,
TTO)

" avTog yap
dve/3Y]

ti

ef>.eXXe

Ttoieiv."

'TxpvjXoTepov
Ttav

Tov

^tXmnov
yap
eig

6

Avdpeag, ov
tu)v

fKVjv

etg to

e(p6aaev'

olfxai

avTOv eXvjXv6evai

7rpocf>v}TWV

Ta

BavfnaTa, Ka) itwg
ttXv^v

^lStXiaaahg eTroir/ae to eni twv dpToov
^iXiinrco

av]fii.€ioVf

ofLoicog

Tca

eXeyyeTai

/xTj^ev

fxeya

(f)avTaa6eig, 15

/xTj^e eTrd^tov ti
**

tov ^i^aaKdXov (ppov^aag, ^/ av eTivjyayev,
eig

" dXXa
fxev

TauTa

T<

eaTiv

Toaovrovg ;"

evofnt^e

yap

oti

diio

eXaTTOVTCcv eXdTTovTa, dTto Se nXetovccv itXetova '^fxeXXe itoieh
6avfi.aTovpycov, OTtep ovk
v]v.

Ov yap

vXv]g e^eiVo Tvjg vTioKeifievvfg,

aXX' waTe

fxv]

to^at tv]v KTiaiv dXXoTptav elvai T^f ayTot; aocpiag, 20

avTY] TV] KTiaei /cej^p^jTa/ Ttpog tv]v v7to6eatv tccv KTiafAaTCOv.

10

Ojg €Totff.ov

Kai

itapeaKevaafxevrjg
01

TY]g

Tpa7te^v]g

eKeXevaev

avTOg

ev6ecog

dvaiteaelv'

^e

t>jv
e7tt

dpyv^v ditiaTv^aavTeg fxeTa tov
•yppTov,

7tpo6vfn.tag

KaTeKXivav
v]v

tov oyXov

(naTe avTOvg

"htaTtavaat'

yap

6

Katpog T^g Ttoag, eapog XotTtov ovTog'
Tlapovactiv

eyyvg 25

yap

v]v,

(pv]ai,

to Tlaaya.
dpt6ft.ei,

he yvvatKcov

avv TeKvotg,

fxovovg
Xov6cov.
ev

TOvg avhpag

Taig KaTO. tov

vofxov avvY]6etatg

aKo-

ToDto yap Kai

M.covayjg e7toiY]aev ev dpt6f/,oig' Ttfxiov

yap

/StfiXco

Qeov

Ttav

oaov dv^pa^^eg Kai

veavtKOV

evyaptaTei ^e

Xaj3cbv

Tovg dpTovg,
tco ©ece,

letKvvg OTt Tovg Tpo(pr]g dpyofxevovg

evya- ^o

ptaTeiv dei

Kat OTt oyXog

v]v

TtoXvg

Ttapuv, Kat eypv^v

avTOvg

7teta6Y]vai, OTt
Ttoiei

KaTa

yvcofiv]v

Qeov TtapeyeveTo.

Ata tovto
S'

0T€ fxev fxovog
€7ti

av^fxeHa, ov^ev

toiovtov e^tt^teiKvvTat' otav

TtoXXm TOVTQ
v7tovoiav, OTt

7toteT,

^ia Tvjg evyaptaTtag tovto

Ttoiet, dvatpcov

TV]v

ovK avTt6eog Ttg eaTiv, ov^e evavTiog

too

yeyev-

VI. 13.
vrjKOTi.

IfiANNHN ETAITEAION.
AetKvva-i
e/c

243
rroieiy

he

oti

ovk acxOeveia tovto
TroteTv.

aXka

trvy-

KaTa^a,<7€t,

tou ra fxet^ova av6evTeta

i^MMONioT nPESBTTEPOT.
avTWy Ka\
viav,
fXYj

Ai^daKet ^ia Tov

(Tvjfjietov

BappeTv

aQvfxetv ev <7t evo-)(ccpia, riTOt ft^ ^eiktav Trpoq (f)t\o^e-

«AAa

Ttpoi itav

dya^ov eToifxovg
fx)]

eivat.

$
eivat,

A<a
hi^d^y]

TovTo evy^apt^XTel, tva
y]fj.dg

^o^yj

dvTtQeog
-jrXvjv

Kat

tva

ev

to)

eaQietv
ecog

ev-^^apio-Teiv,

Kai wg dvOpcaTTog

evyaptaTei, tva XdSrf

tov irdBovg tov apyovTa tov vvv atavog.

©EOAapoT MoM*OTE2TiA2.
evnpodftiittag

TovTQ
tvjv

fi^iqv

Xeyei, het^ag eig tc
itoffjaatTBat

avToig
eKeTvo ^e

KeXevaat

tS)v

KXaafi.dT<i)V

lo

crvXXoy^V

olKovofj.ovfi.evog, oirep
eitt

ef avTov Ttap-^KoXovBet

Tov 7tpdyfi.aTog, to

itXeov
vj

ditoXavovTag juaAXov tov yeyovo^od-l^vai

Tog

fJLefJivrj(x6at

6avfj.aTog,

Kat oxTTe

Kat eig eTepovg to

yeyevfjfj.evov.

KcpatveTO ydp Kat to ^axptXeg Trjg ydptTog ev too

'«Xyfiei Trig Tteptaaetag,

Kat oti itdvTa KaTa to ^okovv avToo ^ta- 15

itpdTTeTai.

Svve^^wp^jjo-e &e iteptrTevaai

ToaavTa KXdafJ.aTa,

ov hi

eTtioet^iv, aitaye,

dXX

axxTe

f/.vj

(pavTaatav vofi.ta6^vat to itpdyft.a.
'K.piaTOg ^ta tccv
Tr]g
rj

AMMi2NiOT.
apTccv

Tpe(p€t

Tovg ittoTovg

irevTe

Tav KpiBtvm,

OTtep

voenai

•*]

TtayvTepa
oitep eo^T/v

itevTaTevyov
'^t^ayrf

OtQaaKaXta, Kai htd twv ^vo lyjSvwv,

ditaX^

20

tov evayyeXtKOv Kat ditoaToXiKov Krjpvyfj.aTog.

13

OvK
eitettr]

edooKe

&e ToTg oyXotg

/3aaTd^eiv,

dXXa

ToTg fXM6rfraTg,

fxdXiaTa TOVTovg

Ttai^^evaai

e^ovXeTO, Tovg

fxeXXovTag

€(xea6at

^itaaKdXovg

Trjg oiKovft.evr)g.

To

fxev

ydp

7tXrj6og ov^ev

fxeya efneXXe KapTtwaaa6at
exeAa^ovTO, Kat r]Tovv
efxeXXov Kep^aivetv.
fxevov ov

eK tov

6avfj.aTog.

Kai ydp evdecag 25

eTepov 6avft.a.

Ovroi Se ov Ta TvyovTa

Hv

^e Kat tSi 'lov^a^ KaTdKpifxa to ytvoKO(f>tvov.

to Tvyov, /3aaTd^ovTi tov
oi)

Xp»; ^e

TO

itXrj^og 6avfiid^etv

twv yeyovoTOov KXaafxdTm Ik

t£v
OTi

apTftJV

fxovov,

dXXd

Kai t^v dKpt^etav tov TteptaaevaavTog, 30
fJut6r]Ticv

ouTe TtXeov, ovTe eXaTTov, dxx' iaapi6fLovg t£v

Tovg

KOiptvovg Twv Xettl/dvav eitoir^ae iteptaaev^vat.

E>6avuiaaav Sc

01

oyXot

vt/v

tovto

to

arifxeTov

Si'

imepjSoXyjv

yaaTpifxapyiag' fxvpta etpydaaTo tovtov 6avfxaatwTepa, Koi ou'

'Iov8a/j)

Cod.

I i

2

244
^afAov

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
€Tn(TTevaav'
y]

VI. 13.
oti

ovtod

6avfJi.d(TavTes
c/c

icifj!.o\6yr)a-av,

cvTog

ecTTiv aXYjOag

npoipriTYig.

^e tovtov h^Xov oti irpoip^^Trjv Tiva

TrpoaeooKovv
**

e^atpeTov'

Kai yap

tw

/SaTrTiaTvj ^ia
tvjv Tyjg

tovto eXeye,

av

ei

Trpo^pyjTyjg."

Kti

^e

Kai ^ia

yaaTptfxapylag
tcept

avTwv
Ty]q

r^podTTaQeiav, ovk

eTi vofxov eK^iKovaiv^

ovk 6t; avTolg

^

Tov aa/3l3dT0v 7rapa(3daeQ}g fxeXet,
Kat
irpocpyjTy^i
"^id
y]v

dXXa T^g yaaTpog
avToU
Kai

ai/roig

efJLTrXyiaSeiayjgf

irap

^aatXetag
KoafJLt-

a^tog.

^e

^ptaTog

tovto (pevyet, Tratteviov

yjf*.as Twi/

kSov KaTacfypoveiv d^iQ)ft.dToov.

KE$.
Hepl Tov iv

e.
irepmaTov.

10

6a\d(T(TT}

Ttvog '/dptv
fxovog, Kat
fieVf

a(f)tyjat

Tovg fi.aBy)Tdg Kat dvepyeTat eiq ro opog
ctt}

irdXtv (paiveTat

t^s"

SaXdaavjg ^a^i^av
y)

;

'FiKe7vo

"httdaKitiv

avTOvg, iroaov eariv

aTroXeixptg,

kcu tov iroOov

epya^of/.evog

fJt.et^ova.

Tovto

^e, tvjv

avrov

'bvvafxtv ev'^etKvvfj.evog.

15

'£lg te oipia

eyevero, KaTe^yjaav eig t^v

GdXaaaav

01

fKaSyjTat,

Kai fxey^pt fuv

t%

y]fi.epag 7repieft.evov

avTOv^ ri^eiv Trpoa^oKwvTeg
f*.yj

vpog avTovg.

Vevofxev^g ^e eairepag., ovk rivetyovTO
epciog,

^rjTeiv

tov

^t^^daKaXoVf roaovTog avTovg KaTeHy^ev
KevTovfLevot, ej3i^aav
etg to
TrXoiov.

Kai diro tov TroOou

Ov ydp
dXXd

dTrXwg

Eivayye-'
$epf/.r)v

20

XtaTrjg

Kat

tov

Katpov e^rjXwaeVf
r)

^td tovtov Tr}V

avTwv

dydirr^v efKcJyatvcoVf OTt ovTe

eairepa avTovg Kareayev.

Ktpiaaot kata ANArizrHN. E< ^apv
Tcij vor)T(£i,

to ev

cr/coTO)

yeveaOat

Ka)

ei

yaXeirov to ev BaXdaar) TrtKpa twv r^^^ovm KaTatov
Tr)g

TrviyeaBaif

Trpoa^e^oofneOa

lr)aovv.
etg

ToDto

yap

rjfxdg

Kat 25

Ktv^^vvm diraXXd^et
tSov
eir)
elpr]fj.ev(ov

Kat

SdvaTov dfj.apTtag' 6 ^e Tvirog
0(p6r)aeTat.
r)^et
^r)

ev

ToTg yeyovoaiv
**

ovv irdvTwg

Tovg ft.a6y)Tdgi
fj.ev

eyoo

eifJLt,

f>.y)

(f)o(3e7a6e.^^ elaofi.e6a

^td tovtov
viro-

(ppovrffxa
fj.ovr)

e%f/v ev iretpaafxolg evToXfxov Te Kat veavtKov'

te Key^y]a6at avvTOvo} Tr) elg l^ptaTOVf eXirtha (3el3aiovf/Levovg
tt^v ent tco irdvTCog

30

eig ev6apatav
rjfidg 01

^taaa^-^aeaBaif Kav iroXXot Ttveg
eiriTrfpet

eK tov Tretpd^eadat ireptKVKXaat (po^ot.
ev

yap

oirctig

ovK ev6vg diroTrXevaccatv, ovOe
aKd(f)ei

dpyrj tccv Ktvhvvav Tolg ev t(o
ovTcoat ircag ev f*.eaotg roTg

^piaTog

eirt^patveTai.

AAX' OTav

VI. 22.

WIANNHN ETArrEAION.
totc S^ Kat a^oK-^TCOi
(po^ov, kiv^^vvov
(7ii(f)aiv€Tai

245
'KpiaTO^,

Kv[jLa<Ttv €vpi(TKa>[Ji.i6a,

Ka) irepta-TeXKfi
Kou

/x€v tov

Se

airaXXa^ei Ttavro^,

«TrovvjT/ ^e KaTop6a)(70fJi.ev to.

XvaiTeXrj TtapovTog avTov.

20

'ETrecTT^

^e

avToHg

'/eifjia^oixevotg Ae-ycyv,
Ty\v

"

eyu)

(ifJii,

fjirj

(po-

"

(3€7(j6(,^^

kou fJieTa tov pYjftMTog Kai
"^i^vyyji;,

^(i\tav e^e'/3aXev dno 5

T^g

(K(ivjov

Kat fneTa T^g (pcowjg yaXi^wj y(yov(v'

ovk

(V({3y] h(

(U

TO TrXoToVy to 6avfi.a fj.di^ov (pydaa(76at ^ovXofX(vog,
Ate(3i^(xav
fjL(v

Kot

T>?y

6fOTy}Ta avToHg (KKaXvrpat yvfx.voT(pov.

ovv TTjv (pv6pa.v
TtoXv

6dXaaaav Kat
(VTOvda.
oi/Tog

lov^aToi, Ma»o-ea)f yfyovfj.(vov,
fJL(v

dXXa
'hovXog
fJL(V,

TQ

fJ.(aov

'O
^e €i^(

yap

(vypfJ.evog

Kat

(ng

lo

TidvTa
VOTOV

(tpyd^(TO,

fJ.(T

(^ovatag

dirday]g'
(Tti

KaKei

TOT(

TtvcuaavTog,

TO v^(op,

coo-Te

^yjpag voiyjaai

Ttap(X6(Tv.
(Ttt

FiVTavda h(
<f>va€oi}g

fi.(i^ov
yj

to 6avfxa eytveTo.
ovTcog

Mevovaa yap

Tyjg

oiK(tag

6dXaaaa,
t^

(cfxpe tov 'heaitOTypj
6 Ttept-

htt Twv vcoTCOv, fjLapTvpovaa (Ketvri

pYjaet

t^ Xeyovav}, "

i$

" TtaTwv

(Ttt

T^f 6aXdaayig
^e to
TrAorov

cog (iti
(Ttt

eSa^oyf."
(y(V(TO, tovto §>jAor, ov

To

(v6(ctig

Tvjg yyjg

fxovov aa(f>aXyj avTolg
oyX(ji

aXXa

Kat (^ovptojv itap^lye tov itXovv' tc?
(itt

Se

ovK (it(^(i^(V kavTOv
yj

Tyjg

6aXdaai^g it(pt7taT0vvTa.
y]v.

MeT^ov yap

KOTa t^v

(Ketvcov

da6(vetav to aYifxdLov

20
oyXog

22

^Kpt^kaTepov ^e

¥ivayy(XtaTyig Ae-ye/,

"

T-i}

(itavptov 6

"
"
yjv

(aTyjKcog 7t(pav Tyjg ^aXdaayjg, (i^(v OTt itXotdptov

aXXo ovK
ti^d^ai.

(K(t," Kat
;

Ta

(^yjg,

(T(pov

t;

^ovXofJL(vog

rjfJLag

Yiohv TovTO
li^aovg

OTi Kat To7g oy^Xotg

d
to

Kat

fj.y}

(pav(pcog, '(^coKe

yovv
Kai 25

Xav6avovTQ}g

vitovo^aai

y(y(vy}fi.(vov

eaTtv,

ei

aAAo
TO

TtXotapiov
TYjg

ovk

yjv,

ovTe ToTg fiLa6i^Ta7g avvav(/3y], (vpe6^vai
oti
T>yv

Ttipav

6aXdaay)g, itpohyjXov
OfJLCog

6dXaaaav

it^^evcov

TtapeykveTo'

aXX

fJLeTa

Toaoirtov

6avfJ.a,

aiteX^ovTeg itpoi

avTOV ovK y]pcoTy]aav vcog
<7yjfJL(iov,

^te/^yj,

ovhe (^-^Tyjaav fLa6(7v to ToaovTOV

aXXa

Tt (fjaat

;

itcog a>^e

itapaykyovev

;

ovT(ag
6

yjv

(vSpav- 30

aTog
01

yj

opfxyj

avTm.

Ot yap X(yovT(g, ovTog (aTtv

Ttpo(pyjTyjg,

aTtov^d^ovT(g dpitdaat

Kat itotyjaat (3aatX(a, (vpovT(g avTOV,

oz/Sev TOiouTov

PovXevovTai,

dXXa

to 6avfj.a €KJ3aXovT(g ht(^-^Tovv
'^to

vdXiv

Tpa7t(^y]g ditoXava^tv, otag Kat itpoTepov'

Kai ovet^t^ovfj.€

Tai Ttapa tov 'lyjaov,

"

dfj.^v, dfj.yjv,

Xiyco

vfjJiv,

^y]T(tT(

oyj^

35

246
**

EPMHNEIA EI2 TO KATA
e^^ere
cr>j|U,e?a"

VI. a;.
e/7re,

OTi

Kai ra.

k^rjg.

Touto

Se

^iop6aaai

avToiig /3ov\o(X€vo(f afxa ^e Kai ^ia to eKKaXvxpai

Ta

tyj^ diavolag

avTav, e<V TriaTiv ayaye7v [xei^ovaf ug oti Qeo^ eaTiv.
YloieH te tovto fJieTa <pei^ovi' ov

yap

e/Vev,

a>

Xaifxapyot Kat

yaaTpo^
Ti67]aiv

^ovXoi,

a\Xa

TrpoaYjveaTepov' dio
*'
jjiy]

Kai ^ioaaKaXiav 'npo- 5

"

epya^ea6ef^ Xeycav,

ty}v

jSpaaiv tyjv a7rok\v[xevv)v^

Kat Ta

e^yj^.

Ktpiaaot.
ye<j6at
hia^yjv,

Ai'^a(TK0fxe6a

ha

toiJtwv,

[xvj

(piXoKOfXTias

eitei-

aXXa

fxovotg

opaa6at

6eXetv

TOig

T^f 6eoTYjTog
entTe- 10

ocpSaXfioigf aTToyvfxvovayjg to,

Kpvma, Kat to

XeXrj6oTas

XeaSev eig efxcpaveaTaTyjv ayovar^g KaTaXeixptv.

37

T;

^T^Xo^ To

**

€pyd^ea6e

ft,y]

tvjv

PpSoatv tvjv diroXXvfiLevTjv
Tpocp-i^g,

;*'

ft,ri^etg vf>.av

eaTCt}

Xoyoq TavTr^q T^f

coaTe ^ta Trjv avTVjV

fxeptfxvav Kai K0TtTea6at,
Tyjv (ppovTt^a Tt6ea6e.

dXXa

iiept

(Keivyjg Tyjg itvevfxaTiK^g oXyjv

AXX

eTrei^-^

Tiveg tuv ^ovXofxevu>v

apyagi^

Tpe(pea6at, dTioKey^prjVTat tovtoo tcb
TiTOVTog

Aoyoo ag TrjV epyaaiav ckkoitpog

Tov

Ivjaov,

dvayKaHov Kat

avTovg
eivat'

etTte7v,

oti

ov

TouTO

ecTiV

aivtTTOfxevog,

aaTC apyovg

Kai

yap tovto

fxaXiaTa aitoXXvfxevrj jopaaig eaTt, itdaav yap KaKiav e^/^a|ev
rj

apyta,
Tyjv

aXX
TVjg

(oaTe

epya^ea6ai

Kat

fxeTo^ttovai.

ToyTo ydp 20

eyet

/SaaiXetag eitayyeXiav Trjg fxeXXovarjg.
7to6ev

Ei ^e ovk
;

epyd^eTai Ttg,
TovTo
Xoyov,
Ttpog
ev

av yevoiTO di^ovai
eitet^ri

to5

ovk

ej^^ovT/

E/Ve ^e
eitoiovvTO

eKeivovg,

j^g

fjiev

itiaTeiog

ovteva
t^^v

Se fxovov

e^ovXovTO, yaaTpi^ea6at'

TOiavTrjv

ovv

Tpo(j)riv (3pu)atv dTtoXXvfxevrjv

e^dXeaev.
Tvj

25
Xeyet,

Ylag

ovv, (f>yjaiv,

Ivjaovg

Mdp6a
"

"

fxeptfxvag kou

" "

6opvl3d^etg itept itoXXd, evog Se eaTt yjieia,
6yiv fxept

Map/a

^e t^«

dya-

da e^eAe^aTO," Kat itdXtv,

fX'^

fxeptfnv^ai^Te," (prja)v,

"

etg Trjv avpiov ;"
fj.y)

T<

oiiv

av

('irtotfxev

ttpog

TavTa
fii.y]

;

ot; to

fxrj

fkepifxvav, ov to
Tor^-

epyd^eadat eaTtv,
TovTeaTi,

dXXd

to

7tpoar]Xwa6at 30

{3titiTiKo7g

Ttpdyfxaat'

fxr}

Ttoteiade

(ppovTi^a, vitep
fxr]^ev fxeptfxvav,

Tvjg eig avptov

ava-navaeag. e^eaTi he epyal^ofxevov
fxeptfxva

ov

yap TavTOv

Kat

epyaaia.

Kat to npog M.dp6av 8e

etprffxevov, ov

Ttepi

epyov eaTt Kat epyaaiag,
fxrj

dXXd

Ttept

tov ^eh

Katpov ei^evat, Kai

tov Tr]g aKpodaeag Ttpog toc aapKiKa dva-3S

VI. 27Xktkciv.

mANNHN
Ov
aKpodaei.
M.€Qi(TTYjai

ETArrEAION.
ravTa

247
eXe-yev,

roivvv e/f apyiav avTrjv 6/x./3aAAcov

akXa

Trpoai^kSiv Tyj

AnoAiNAPioT.
Tpo(f>v)Vf

{xvj •^epi

tvjv (f>$eipofX€vy}v eiTToeTaBai
i\/v/j^v.

dWa

Trjv eig aicova
vj

[xevovaaVf virig rpetpei
yjv

Avryj

^e ^v

y]

Triarig

^miroiog^ KaB

e^Qfxoiovvrai

•Trpog rvjv

adpKa^

Tou KvpioVf
.

rvjv vTto

ToD Yiaipog

ecr(f>payiafji.evriv

r^

Oeia ovvd[j.et.

Ammcniot.

T»;v vo>jt^v Kat KoytK^v Kai TtvevfxartKr/V.
eig ro

AvrYf

yap (TVfJi^dXXerat
yjv vj

aTrokavaat
irpo^evei.

vjfAag

rwv fMXXovrcov ayaQSiv,

eig 'Kpiarov

marig

Trjv

fKvartKYiv

fneTdXeixlfiv

Xeyet t^v dyid^ovaav ^y%ijv Kai lo

aafxay avvavaitXe^ag
2"/

rw

BeoirpeireT ro dvQpairivov.
6

Ti eari

**

toutov yap o Tlarvjp ea^ppdytaev

Seog

;"

rovrea-

rtVf dire^et^e ^ia rvig

avrov fnaprvptag' e^ei^e
irpog

fj.ev

yap Kai avrog

eavrov.

'Eire/^^

^e

iov^^aiovg

tteXeyerOf t>;v rov

Warpog
TO15

fxaprvptav etg fxeaov vjyayev,
Xeyofnevov.
^caaetv tyjv

tva

fxt}

TrdXtv avrovg Trpoar^

Kat yap fkeya
^otrjv rvjv

irept

eavrov

ecpdey^aro,

etTrav

avrog

atwviov.
v)

Ktpiaaot. To ea(f)payta6at
Karaacppayt^erat yap

ro Keyj)iaBat eBiKwg
fj.efJiOp(j>'.orat

redeiKe.
(ftvaiKwg

yj^toft.evog^ viyovv ori

npog rov Harepa'

Oft.oiov

yap uaei eXeyev, wg ovk d^vvarvjaw 20
Kat
rpv(f>i^v

fipaatv vfMv eiri^ovvat Tvp fxevovaav, Kat etg ^oo^v re
dva(f)epovaav.
ei

yap Kat

opafnai

KaOdirep elg e^

vftMV, av6pa)7rog

^vjXovort ft.eTa aapKog,

dXX

e-)(oia6r}v

Kai KaTea(f>payia6vjv irapa
Ofii.otQrv)ra, rvjv

rov Qeov Kai Ylarpogy etg dirapdXXaKrov

wg

irpog

avrov

voovfi.evr]v,

^vjXoVQrt

r^jg

Kara

Trav

oriovv
ev
oo^v]

efi.(f>epetag,

ov 2$

Kara rovg
taoard6ft.x
eo"T/

rvjg

aapKog yapaKrvjpagy dXX
Ka)
ev

6eoTrpeTrei
eTrtrvipvjreov
oeoTrpeirvj

Kai
Se

^vvdfxet,

e^ovaia ^aatXtKVf.

Tov vtov rov avdpairov

eTrf)(opvjyvjaeti>, etirwv

ra ^

Kai

Karea(f>payia6ai Trpoi etKOva tov 0eou Kat Ylarpog'
fjLeptaft.ov

ovk dve^^^erai
e/c

rov ^iarefi.vovrog

rvjg

Kara

dX-^deiav
opt^etv

vtorvjrog, rov

30

irapBevov vaov,

dXX

eva

irdXtv

eavrov

re

Kat

voeTadai

(SovXerat.

i^MMCNioT riPESBTTEPOT. Tov
ey^iaev 'Aytx Ylvevfxart,
ri^v

a|3Tov

ea<ppdyiaev,

eariv,

adpKa rov Kvptov
£<< •ndvia.

rvjv avBpaTrtvvjv, ov

Fors.

248
TVjv GeoTYjTa.
Trjv

EPMHNEIA EIS TO KATA
Yldvra yap ay^e^ov xa t^s ciKovofxiag

VI. 29.
ovofjt-aTa irepi

crdpKa e.iXfptTai.
yjToi

Tovto

eiVev,

>;

OTi fj.€[J.op(l)coTai (pva-iKws "npog
01 y^piOfnevoi.

Tov YlaTepaf

iy£iae' KaTaacppayi^cvTai yap
iva €pya^afJi.eoa

Lo de
€Ke7vQif

t;

7roiu>{jt.ev

Ta epya tov
Kai

Kyeov

emov
e^^f. 5

ov^

(caT€

ft.a6eh

Kai

Trpd^ai^

^eiKVuai

YlaXiv yap avTOV

eTri ttjv TVjg

Tpocp^g ekKovai yopf\yiav.

29

'O Se X.piaTOg

vTre^ei^ev avTo7g oiiep e^yiTfiaav,

"

tovto eaTi

"

TO epyov Tov 0eov, iva 'TrtaTevavjTe eig ov diieaTeiXev eKetvog."
Se

OvTOt

KaBditep Ttves dvaiadYjTotf
cog ov^^evog yevof>.evov,

CTt

tov

ar^ft.eiov
**

ev

yepaiv

ovTog avTolg, Kai
TTote^ig
;

ovTCcg eXeyov,

Tt avjft.eiov 10

iva itwfxev koi 7itaTevawf/.€v aoi Tt

epya^nj*" ovTcog vjaav

iteTToopcofKevot.

Ammoniot nPESBTTEPOT. E/
BvjaofJievovg,

Kat

vj^^et

eKetvovg fxyjVev wcf^eXvj-

dkXa

'tia

to KotvcocpeXeg TVjg
Trotei

^i^a-^^Yjg OTieKpiBiq' ovy^ 6 6ekv]f/.a,

Ta7g aKtaig ^ovXevcov tov vofKOV
eig Tov

to tov Seov

dXX

6 15

^ptaTOv TrtaTevxv.
fJLev

Seov
^e
eivai

epyov evTovQa XeyeTat

to avvjKov eig Qeov.
eir

ToiJto

(f)V]aiv

Kvptog, tv]v itiaTtv tv^v
Teketov'

avTOv, epyov avTVjv
av6pco7rivcov

airo^paivcov tepov Te Kat

Kai avev tcov

epycov,

eiKOTCog ^tKaio7 t€ Kai dytd^et,
TVjg yl^vyvjg,

«Te

tvjv

KakktaTVjv evepyeiav eyov 20

ovk dpytav Ttva Kat anpa^tav.

©EOAapoT.

ToyTO

(pvjatv
Trept

Kvpiog, avvetg OTt vkeiaTov avTcov

VTrepfSaivet tvjv aKorjv
TTvevfj.aTtKvi

tou fLvaTvjptov koyog. tovto yap
Tvj

vj

Tpocfy^.

ovk ev6vg ovv eTrtTpey^et

dtvjy^aei,

dkk
^ 25

Q^a Key^pvjTat

TTpeTrovavj iipog tov koyov.

H

yap

iitaTtg, (f)Vjatv,

eig e/Ae o^og vfMv

eaTat irpog

tvjv

tcov

konrav KaTavovjaiv t€ Kai
vrpog t< tcov keyofnevcov

%ttaaKaktav.
dfj.(f)tj3dkketv,

(yuTe

ydp irtaTevovTag eveaTt
fj.v]

ovT€

TTtaTevovTag de^aa6at

Tt

tcov

keyofievcov

^vvaTOV, ft.€ydkcov ovtcov, Kat nokv tv]v vfj.eTepav
aKOY]V.

vitep(3atvovTcov

30
elitov

qi

T/vof eveKev

"
;

ot

itaTepeg

vjff.cov

ecpayov to fuavva ev Tvj

"

epY]fJ.cio^^

Kat Ta e^^g

voft.i^ovTeg

avTOV ^id tovtov epe^t^etv,

coaTe ToiovTov Ttotv^aat
KiKcag.
'

avjf/ieiov, oiiep

avTovg

6p€xl/ai

vj^vvaTo

aap-

OTt ydp tovto eaTi
fxvv]fj.ovevaat

^vjkov eK tov fxr^evog eTepov tcov itpo'