l^

C AT E N^
GR^CORUM PATRUM
IN

NOVUM TESTAMENTUM

EDIDIT

J. A. CRAMER, S.T.P.
AUL^ NOVI HOSPITII PRINCIPALIS,
NECNON

HISTORI^ MODERN^ PROFESSOR REGIUS.

TOMUS IV.

IN EPISTOLAM S. PAULI AD ROMANOS.

OXONII,
E TYPOGRAPHEO ACADEMICO.
M.DCCC.XLIV.
A^

7Al
 C A T E NA
IN

SANCTI PAULI

EPISTOLAM AD ROMANOS.

AD FIDEM CODD. MSS.

EDIDIT

J. A. CRAMER, S. T. P.

AULiE NOVI HOSPITII PRINCIPALIS,

NECNON

HISTORIiE MODERN^ PROFESSOR REGIUS.

-^

OXONII,
E TYPOGRAPHEO ACADEMICO.

M.DCCC.XLIV.
 MONITUM LECTORL

CATENAM in D. Pauli Ep. ad Romanos edidi e

Cod. Bodleiano E. II. 20. qui chartaceus est, form. in
4}^. e MS. antiquiore Gaditano, ut videtur, a Jo. Lluydo
An. 1601. descriptus. Hunc olim, ut opinor, Lascaris
quidam, sive Constantinus, sive alius ejus stirpis, secum
in Italiam e Graecia adduxerat. Cujus facti, hoc Epi-
gramma in ultima libri pagina exaratum, fidem facit.

Ada-Kapis aXXobaTirj yalr] evl KdrdeTO, yaCrjv

OVTL \.ir]V ^€LVr]V, CO ^€V€, fJ.€IJ.(f)6fl€V0S.

cvpaTo p.€i\i)(Jiriv' dAA' a\6eTai, eiirep ""Axaiois

HrjbfTi xovv x€V€t, iraTpls kkevOipiov.

t 5I£
(f

o^
aiivf, Ao.Kaiv'', vii' €p.ol 'PaXAov TraTpbs r/ TTpo(f)vyov<Ta

bovXoavvriv TrdTpas, ^Xdev es 'IraAiTjy

p.rJTp(a TT€tOoyi.ivr], os (€v^€ ]xlv dvipL /cAeiv<S.

Tols K(xX K6<Tp.os €r]v TOLS IhiaLs dpeTals.

EAAdSos dAA' okor] KaTepCvav Trpov<^Oa(T€ iioipa,

Tr\Xi TTcp, ovb^ &KTeLp ^yKVov ourc vir]V.

Catena autem haec, quam eximiam esse et multis aliis

hoc nomine praeferendam, quod plerorumque Doctorum
testimonia ex scriptis non editis deprompta sint, judica-
iv MONITUM LECTORI.

vit Chr. Wolfius, (Exercit. in Cat. Patr. Gr. p. 33.) non

integra est ; nam ultra cap. ix. haud procedit. Hiatum
vero e Codice olim Augustano, nunc in Bibl. Regia
Monacensi adservato, supplere institui. Non autem
hic liber omnino partem alteram Catenae, ut suspicaba-
tur Grabius, (ap. Wolf. loc. cit.) refert; diversa enim
esse opera satis patet ex Auctorum Symbolis, hac et
illa prolatis. In Bodl. Cod. Origenes saepissime cita-

tur, rarius autem in Monacensi. Semel tantum in

Bodl. adducitur Chrysostomus, quum alter Cod. ejus

citationibus abundet.
Monacensis autem libri hsec est notitia in Reiser.
Catal. Theolog. p. 9.
" Cod. 23. Catena in Ep. D. Pauli ad Rom. viginti
" et quinque Patrum Gr. vid. Acacii, Athanasii, Ba-
" silii Magni, Caesarii, Chrysostomi, Clementis, Cjrilli,
" DamascenijDidymi, Diodori Charterii^ Dionysii Alex-
" andrini, Dionysii Areopagitae, Euthalii, Gennadii,
" Gregorii Theologi, Isidori, Maximi, Methodii, Nys-
" seni, (Ecumenii, Origenis, Photii, Severiani, Theodo-
" reti, Theophili." Membr.
Incipit a Cap, 7-
Hujus autem Apographus, cum serius ad manus no-
stras pervenerit, id in causa fuit, cur volumen quod
commentariorum seriem in D. Pauli Epistolas ordiri
debuerat, ultimum prodiret.

» Leg. Tarsensis.
 YnoeE2i2
THS npos

'POMAIOIE EniSTOAHS.

* H AE npog VwiJMiovs 'KvtaToXyj iKpte-xet ryjv itpog tov

jLpKXTOv jrapaaKevvjv, fxa.ht<TTa Toli Ik ^v<T€wg XoytafJLoTf e\ey-

'^(SeiaaVf Kai Oia tovto irpoTaTTCTat aWatg aTraaati^ wg tyj irpog

avTovg yeypafj.ij.ivy] Tot/s- ^§>y to, Seta vpofJLVvyjSevTag. TavTTjv evt'

oreAAe/ airo Koptvdov, fxrpto} fj.ev kwpaKwg 'VafLaiovgy aKovcov Se
vept avTooVy Kai eTrnroSav avTovg t^eh. Kai TrpiaTOV ^ev, diro^e-
j^eaSat (pyjat ttjv irtaTtv avTwv, KaTayyekXoft.ewjv opvv iravTa- lo
y(ov. eiretTa a-rjfjiaivet TrokXaKig eavTOv TrpoOefJLevov ekSeh '^ia

Tcv etg avTovg Trodov, Teoog fj^ff ^e^^vvyiaBat. Kai XotTrov ^t^aaKaXtKVjV
Ty]v KTrtaToXrjv irotehat, irep) KA-^aeajg eOvSiv. Kat OTt vj 7reptT0fj.yi

€»« Katpov yjv, Kai vvv ireiravTat. Kat OTt tta tov Xp/<rrou KeXv-
Tai TO irapanTWft.a tov A^afA, Kat yj cKta tov vof*.ov irap^XOe. tvjv 15
^ev ovv KXyjcrtv TaJ» edvwv aKoXoiSag KaTacKevdl^et ovTWf, diro-
cetKvvg iraaiv dvBpwirotg ef>.(f>vTov eivat tov vofKOV, Ka\ Trdvrag
aOtoaKTa) t6 t^ (pvaetf Kat dir avTi^g T^f KTiaeag hvvacrBat ytvw-

iJKetv Tov Qfov.

Ato Kat etKOTOog atTtaTat TrpcoTOv 'EAXiJvaj, ug fjiev tov Seov 20
tpavepaxravTog avToig eK tS>v Troiyjf/.dTOiv Toy Koafj.ov t>/v irep)

eavTov yvaatv Kai Tyjg aihiov ^vvdu.eui avTOVy yjTig eaT^v Aoyog
avTov, ev w Kai '^i 01/, to. TrdvTa TrenoiyjKev, ainovg ^e, fJiVi eyvcu-

Kevat fiev eK Tav KTtaf/.dTCCv eivat Seov tov tovtohv ^yjfniovpyov, to,

* Argumentum hoc et capitum divisionem ex GEcumenio Supple-

vimus.
 5

[ 2 ]

Se TtoiYifJMra Beovof^aavTag, Kai Tij kti(T€1 fxaXkov rj avToo kaTpev-

aavTus. aiTtaTai Se Kai lov^^aiov^;^ wg [xr] (pvXd^avTag tov voixov,

dWa Kai fjidXXov ^ia rvjg napalSdcrecoi tcv vofxov, rov ©eov

aTifxdaavTai. Kai ovT(og dfxcf^orcpa Ta fi.iyiaTa lovQaiovg Kai

'EAA^vaf avyKkeiei Kai cXiy^^ei eiri Tiapavofkia, iva Se/^ij oti 5

oaoi yevof^evoi ol iidvTegf eTricyjg, wg V7rev6vvoi, tov XvTpovfj.evov

^eovTai. T^g ^e ydpnog kou Xvrpooaecog eTTiayjg rrji ^Xov^aioig

ye.vofj.evrig Kai em ra e6v^f eiKorag Ka\ vj KXi^atg yeyove Tsiv

eflvwv. T^f ^e KXvjaeag rm e6vccv y€VOft,evy}g, e| dvdyKrjg iieTtavTat

rj TieptrofJ^, Kat vj ev rw vofJ.a} aKtd. o yap 'A(3pdfi. (pyjatv ovk ev i o

TreptrofJL^, dXXa vpo r-iqg •neptrofx^g ^iKatci}6e]g, fx,eTwvofj.da6Yi fxev

'A^paafJ., OTi itaryjp itoXXwv e6vwv efxeXXev eivat, Kara rvjv ev ry

dKpo^varta Tttartv. €Xaj3e ^e fxera ro tiKatwWfjvat Kai tyiv itept-

TOfn^v ev aapKt, tva avjfj.elov y] roTg Kara adpKa yevvwfLevotg e^

avrov, Ttavaea^at TroTe t^v '7teptrofi.y}v, orav ra e^vyj yevyjrai 1

Teiicva Toy A^paafJ., ap^dfj.eva TtoXirevea^at Kara ryjv itiartv rov

'Aj3paaf/., ev yf
ettKata6yj ore y^v ev dKpo/Svarta. jovrwv yap '/dpiv

fi.eTWV0fj.da6Yi 'AjSpadfi.. avdyKV] ^e eX6ovrwv rav ayjfi.atvofj.eva}v,

7tavaaa6at ro ayjfj.ahov. et fj.ev ovv ra e6vYi avay^d^ovai itept-

Tefj.V€a6at, Ttaverwaav te ro ovofxa rov 'APpaafHf Kai KaX€ta6(o 20

'A^pdfJ.. €1 ^e 'A^padfj. itapa 0eov fj.erwvofJ.da6Y}, ov te^i itepi-

TefJ.veaaat ra efjvY}. aXX ovoe avrovg ert rovg Kara aapKa iov-

tatovg, iva y} ro ovofxa ^e^atov, Kat "TtarY^p e6vwv ttoXXwv KaX^rat.

Kat ydp ov y^etav eyet Xontov rtg it€ptT€fJ.vea6aty dpKovfnevog ryj

Tttaret rov 'AjSpadfj.' ovte ryjg dXXy}g ^e ryjg ev vofJ.(ja aKidg. ov 25

ydp €K rovTWv, dXX eK tttarewg ttKaiovrat rig, Ka^d-Jtep Kat 6

'APpadfn.
TavTa ovrwg KaxaaKevdaag, aTto^eiKvvat TtdXtv ort dXXwg
ovK dv yevotro Xvrpwatg Kai ydptg rov \apaY}X Kat roig edveatv, ei

fkY} Xv6y} y} dpyaia dfk.apTia rov A^dfa, yj etg Ttdvrag yevo^ev»/. 30

^i dXXov ^e Tai;T>;v fo^ ^vvaa6ai e^aXetcpd^vat (pY/a^v, dXA y} ^td

^ptarov Tov ©eov, Ot ov Kat e^ ocpy^g Kardpa yeyovev. ov ydp

tvvarov y}V, dXXov Xvaat ro Ttapdttrwfj.a. eira ypdcpet ort dXXwg
Tovro ov fj.Y} y€VY}Tai, et fj.v] awfj.a cpopeay] Tiog rov Qeov, koi
yevy}Tat av6pw7tog, tva rovro itpoaeveyKag VTtep Ttdvrwv, rovg itdv-^tS
 ^

[ 3 ]

Tflf eXfvBepaai^ onro rov BavaTov. Kai ooairep ^t evof av$pooTrov 17

aixaprta eU tov K0<Tfj.GV ei<7vjX6ev, ovtco^ Kat S/ evog avQpooirov 17

yaptg yevyjTat. Ka\ Xotirov cwf KaXos oiKovofJiOif Tovf fxev lov^^aiovi

TiapafxvQenat' OTt ov "napa^aTai yiveade tov vofxov, eav etg tov

'Kpt(TTOv TTtcTTevayjTe. Tc7g "he a-no twv eOvav Trapeyyva, [xt] eirat-

pecrdat KaTa tov laparjKf dx\a ytvaxTKetv OTt w<; Kkd^og eirt t^v

pi^aVf ovTwg €ir eKCtvovg eveKevTpiaQYiaav. (j.eTa ^e TUvTa irapaivi-

TtKOvg Xoyovg eU toc yi^ri '^^d^ag, TeXetoT ttjv KirtaToX^^v.

B 2
 .

KE^AAAIA
TH2 npos

POMAIOTS EniSTOAHS.

u . EyayyeAixi) SiSaffxat^/a Trep/ ye Toiv e^eo p^a^iTOf Xpi<rTOW,

xa) Twv Iv p^apiTi, xa» tts^i eXTr/Soj xa» TroXiTsiaf irvew-

jxaTix^;.

|6 . rie^i xplareaas rris xuToi eQvooVf toov ow fu\a<7c6vTaiV toL (puvixct.

y . Hep) xpl<rexg TYjg xuto. tow 'Itrpa^X, tow jiiij (pitKoKTO-ovTos ToL

VOfllfMt.

8'. rie^l yTrepo^^f *I<rpa^X, tou Toyp^avovTOf t^j eTrayyeXiaj.

e . Oe^i ^apiTog, 8i* ^j oivQpooTroi fuovov SixaioSvTai, ot5 xaTa yevoj

diaKexpifj,evcosy aWoi xaTa 0eoD §oa"iv WoTlpictis xaT« tov

'A^paOLfJ. TVTTOV.

f. riep) TT^i aiTOxeiiJievris eXw/Sof.

^. He^i eicrayajy^f toS wpoj (TaoTyjplav ^jncov av^pamou 'I)]<ro5

XpiO"TOW, avTi Tow w80"o'vToj If ap^^Jjj yijyevouj 'ASajx.

>j'. riepi T^j 6ipei\0[ji.evYjs l7ri t^ Tr/trTei irpafewj ayaS^j.

fl'. 'E7ravaA>jvI/i5 7ref)i t^j Iv X^f"'*"' ?«'')?•

i'. riepi T^f W7ro vo/iow xaTaxpla-eoos 8ia t^v aiJ.apTiav.

la'. Ilep Twv Iv avdpcoTr/vjj ^wo^ei waflcov, aSwvaTov woiowvtmv t^v

Trpoj vo'j«,ov (Tvfj,<pcovlav.

0. Tlep) otTTO^ocrecos tSov <pva-txoov 7ta&rj[j.aTcav, ha tyis Tpoj to

TTVewjtta <rw/x(pcoyiaj.

ly'. *E7ravaXi)\I/ij Trepi t^j aiTOxeipi,evYis toij ayms 8o'^)jj.

iB'. Ilepi T^j o<peiXojU,ev>j5 ayaTrrjj X^io^tow.

le'. Ilepi ex-TTTCJOcreoos 'lcyparjX tow aizo^Xr^UvTOc, xai xX^<recof ToD

aX»)9owf, ToD 6io-ap,^6evTOf ju,eTa Iflvcov.

if'. "OTe xaTa aincTTlav ^ ex^rTcoo^ij 8id t^c eij ayvoiav xaTah.r\'

rj/ecof, xai tow ju,^ dppio^ovTOS avTolc x>jpwyju,aTOf

i^. Ile^i ToD (TxOTtov xad* ov I0s/3xij5>jo-av, cwrre SewTe^ov eTraveXdgiv

^i^Xtt) ToJv TijU,>)9evTct)V Ifivcov 0-wvap^Se'vTcov 7rio-Tci3v.

i>j'. X\apa'ive<Tic •Kepi apeT^s Tijf Tpoj &eov xa) avflpcoTrowj.

i9'. Ilepi iJ,i[j.rj<Tecos tt^s X^io^tow ave^ixax/aj.

x'. Ilepi XeiToupyias «wtow, t^j Iv avaToXp xai Sw<rsi.

 ESHrH2I2
E12 THN nP02

POMAIOTS EniSTOAHN.

KE<^. A.

"EvayyfKiKTj dibatTKoXia irepi ye tS)v t^oa xdpiros Xpiarov xal rS>v tv \apiTt, c

KoX TTepl f\m8os Ka\ TrokiTtias nvevpMTiiajs.

I nAYA02 8ov\o9 *lr)crov ^piOTOV, Kkrjros 'Atto- ^

oToXos.
Eethpianot. T< trpioTe to koivov t^ioiroieiTai ; cirei^r] voWo)
fjiev Kai d€a(7a/x€voi tov Kvpiov, Kai fxy) Sea^jafjievoi eiria-T€v<7av' lo

Tiavko^ ^e ovpavoQev KaXenai, " '^aovK, SaoyA, ri fX€ ^iWKet^ ;*

"TrpodeTi Oe avT(o ^e Kai vXeov ti irapa tov^ Xoiirovg ^Airoa^Tokovs.

Tovg yap nept YleTpov Kai laKta^ov Kat ladvvrjv 6 Kvpto^ KaXe-
(Tag, Kat fA.a6YiTas eay^i^Kwg, ovk evQvg AnocrToXovi eTroivjo^ev 77

avofxaae. tov ^e YlavXov, OfKOv Kai eKaXecrev, Kat eig airocrToA^v 15

TiapYiyayev.

' A({)a>pLaiJL€uo9 ei? KvayyeXcov Qeov.

AnoAiNAPioT. yieyapiafxevo^; Kat d<pa}piaft.fvog et( rov evay-

yeXta^fxov, wg vofxog a<popiaf/.a Kat acpaipefjia Xeyet to '/oopt^o-

fxevov Twv QvfxaTwv ©eso Kat tepevatv. 20

iipiFENOTS. Acpopi^erat ^e etg EvayyeXtov Qeov, ov ^ia

Tfiv (pvatv eyovaav ti e^aiperov, Kat oaov eirt t^ KaraaKevrj, vTrep

Tag Twv Totovrm (pvaetg' dXXa ota rag irpoeyvooafLevai ft.ev irpo-

repov TrpdJ^eig, varepov Ve yevofj.evag €k rvjg vapaaKev^g Ka) rvjg

Trpoatpeaeayg t^^ aTroaroXtK-ijg. 25

 .

E3HrHEI2 E12 THN nP02 I. 3.

3 Ylepi Tov Ylov avrov rov yevojxevov €K cnrepfiaTos

Aa0i8 KaTa aapKa.
AnoAiNAPiOT. revOjuevof roivvv Kara aapKa ev OfAOicofJLaTt r^f
vjfjierepag yeveaectig viog avBpwnov, Kara to "nvevfi.a Kai Kara t^v

hvvafxiVf Tiof ava^etKvvTai Qeov ev Tyj ^evTepa, yeveaet ryj €K S

vfKpaiVf Trpoi TO Kai rj[Mag OfJiOiovfjLevovq avrco vlovi yeveaQai Qeov'

T^v vtodecriav KOfJiiaaixevovg ev ttJ airoKvTpaaei rov o"a?/AaTO$", »f

avTog 6 AnociTokog e<f>y].

Ktpiaaot. Ovkovv cog etKoveg irpog apyeTvitoVy ovtu Ka) yjfxe^g

01 kaTa 6ea-tv vtot, irpog to (f>v(T(t Te Kat ^vvdfjiei Kai dXyjSSig €k 10

TlaTpog fJt.e[j.apTvpy][Ji.evov eig tovto Kara HvevfLa dytcoa-vvyjg, Kai

eK T^f dvaaTaaewg T-^g ck veKpm. opi^eTat ^e eig viov Ka) KaTa ro

dvQpaTctvoV (ETt ^e xat KaTo, (f)vatv Tiog Qeov Kat ev '^vvdfx.et

fi.apTvpovfKevog *'
KaTa WvevfJ.a dyiajavvifig e^ avaaTdaewg veKpwv.^^

TovTeartv d-noye rov ^vvaaSat KaTapyelv to tov BavdTov KpdTog. 15

5 At' ov i\d^0fiei/ X'"'P''^

aTroarToXrjs
'
'AnoAiNAPiOT. \va Ve ^et^v] oti Kat 'PQ3fji.aioif rwv eQvwv ovTeg
itdvTwv Twv irjv oiKovfjievvjv KaToiKovvrcov^ ^tKaicag avTOv Scj^ovTa^

T^^ aTToaTOAvjg to Ky]pvyfi.a.

'AnoAiNAPioT. Sethpianot. 'Atto dyditrig yap ©eov vj ^kXyi- 20

<r<f, ovK d^tag twv KXyj^evrcoV Ka\ yj T[poa6y]KVj te rov " dytotg^

ov'^ dirXcog elpvjrai' dx\ eiret^v] •noXKot KXv^rot, okiyot te eArXe-

KTOtf ov yap TtdvTeg €7refj.evov tv] KXvjaei' iva fnv] rovg fi.apyapt~

Tag pnrTVj ToTg yoipoig, Kai toc ayta ToHg Kvatv, " dytotg'^ €ipv]K€

^v]\ovoTt' Kat evTevQev vjfj.h v] Tiv^yv] twv dyaBm diidvTm. irdvTag 25

^e rovg Trtarovg dyiovg KaXei.

7 ^dpis vfuv Ka\ elprjVYf.

Sethpianot. KaTa ^e Tovg aipeTtKOvg, et K.vptog ^ptarog,
T[aTY]p 0€ rifJMV KSeog, eaTai Kat LiaTV]p oovXog tov A.piaTov.

otog yap vtog, Totovrog Kai "naT-^p. dXX ovy^ ovTccg Tavra e^xjet. 30
irarv^p yap v]fJMV ei-Trev, 7va ryjv ydptv '^et^v]' l^vptov Se ^lvjaovv,

tva fi.v] fxeya (f>povf]a avieg, wg Kai avTot vtoi Qeov, KaOeXcoat tov
lv]aov TVjv oo^av, v] eavTovg dydycoaiv VTrep tv]v (f>vatv.

Cod. kXIctk;.

1
 I. II. PliMAIOTS EOISTOAHN. 7

j\noAiNAPioT. Qeov KaXovcriv ol l^aipiTwg Kai vvep Touf

aWov^ Trpoa-^KovTei ainw, naXai [xev ol TrpotpvjTaii vvv Oe oi

AvocToXot. ^TjXoT ^e OTt ovk evt evjfapiaTVjaai ©eoj avev ^ptaTov.

'/atpei Ve ayyeXiKri tiaGeaet ')(j>Wfj.evoi, eiTi to KeKpaTvjKevai tvjv

^piarov TTiaTiv ev 'Pwjaij* " %«/'« 7«P ^^ ovpavw yiveTai Kat eTti 5
" evt afj.apTaXoo [ji.eTavoovvTt." Kai av^yaipet tw avvamaToXo}
avTov TleTpWf ToaovTov lay^yaavTt Qta Tyjg yapno^.

9 M.dpTV9 yap p,ov iaTiv 6 Geoy.

AnoAiNAPior. E'i^r] ^e kuTpeiag TioXXa. Kai yap Tipoaev-

ypfxevog Qeia XaTpevet. Kai vvjaTeta yjtafxevo^f Kai Toii Oetotg 10

Xoyiotg TipoaeyjJOVf Kai [xevToi Kat TVjg twv l^evSov 6epa7reia<, eiri'

[xeXovf/.evoi. ^e ye Beiog AiroaToXog XaTpeveiv e<f)y] tw T/c5 tco tov

Qeov irpoacpepwv ToTg eBveatv ^vayyeXtov Kat XaTpevetv ev nvev-

fxaTtf avTt TOVf KaTo. tvjv ^e^of/LevvjV ff.ot yaptv tov WvevfxaTog.

'OpirENOTS. ^ Et/ ^e Koi y^piq ^eXrffxaToq %eov tfKetv trpog 15

Ttva^ waTrep BaAaa/x aTry^et irpog to BaAaA: KaTapaaafxevoi

fxtaQov TOV ^lapavjX' oifxat ^e Kat Tias eQviKog, vj OTras '^
^^ TroTC

T^f Qeoae^etag aXXoTptog, fxrj '^iaKovovfxevos dytoig tcSv XvatTeXwv

Tt avToTg, ov Kat ev QeX-^fxaTi Qeov evotovTat, yiveaSat irpog ovg

yiveTai' ei Kai evo^ovTat iroTe. " eaT; ya-p" (p-i^aiv vj ypacf)!^, 20

'
ev KaKoig evooia avbpog.

II "Im TL ii€Tad(o xapL(T/JLa vplv TTvev/xaTLKOv.

OpirENOTS. 'Q,g ovTog Kai yaptafxaTog fxyf irvevfxaTtKOv,

yiyovfxat OTt dvayKatcog irpoaKetTat. eaTi yap Ttva yaptafxaTa ov

irvevfxaTtKa, ug Kat yafxog. to yap irvevfxaTtKOv, ovk av iroTe 35

efi.Tro^iaat Trpoaevyyj. yj Ve eiri to avTO avvo^og dv^pog Kat yvvat-

Kog, KioXvei. OTt ^e ydptafxa ydfxog, "tfiXoT AiroaToXog (pyjaag,

" BeXoi Trdvrag dvBpairovg elvat ag Kai efxavTOV, dXX eKaaTog t ^tov

^X^' X»/"^!"-* f^ Weof fxev ovTfag, og oe ovTcog.

'AnoAiNAPioT, 'laANNOT, ©EOACPOT. At^^daKet fxev, Tovg ^o

fx-^Tro) ytvwaKOVTag (pwTi^wv. irapaKaXeT Qe, Tovg yjQyj 7re(pci}Tta-

fxevovg eiKppaivoiv tw TVjg ao(f>tag Xoyx, cog avTog Otaipwv (pyjaiv'

*'
ene tttdaKWV ev t^ ^ttaaKaXt(i, eiTe irapaKaXwv ev r^

^ Non pauca hic defecisse videntur : cseterum haec ad evoSaid^ff o/*a*

V. 10. spectant. « 8yj oni. Cod.

 8 EHHFHSIS E12 THN OPOS I. 13.

**
-TrapaKk-^a-ei." 7rapaKa\ovfji.eva}v ^e Pwjaa/wv, Kai avrog^ fpWy
(jvfLiTapaKkyjB-^atTai, koivcovcov rr]<; €K(.ivm napaKX-^a-eag Ota rrjv

dya7rv]v. afj.a §6, a>g ov^e avTog uv vTiep avw tov XP"^^^^^ ''"^» ^*^

Xoyov wcpeXeias. napaKXi^aig yap 6 Xoyog Kat tw XeyovTi.

13 Ov 6eX(o Se vjjids ayvouv dSeX^oi. 5

'AnoAiNAPioT. Kat eTret^r} to KYipvyfxa itoXKaKtg evayyeXtov

irpoofiyopevdev, TtdOovg Ve tovto fxvrifKYjv e^/ei Kat aTavpov Kai

SavdroVf roTg Se /w.^ TreTriaTevKoatVf dTifJLiag etoKei eivat TovTa

fxeaTdf eig Kaipov eTtvfyayev, '*
ov yap cnatayvvofi.at to Eyayye-
" Xtov^^ Kat ra e^vji. 10

16 Ov yap iwaKT-xyvofJLai tov l^vayyeXiov rov Xpt-

CTTOV.

i!\noAiNApioT. Ov ^Xeitoi, (f^rjat, Tr}v (patvofxevrjv aTtfxtaVf

dhXd rrjv eK Tavrrjg (pvofxevrjv evepyeaiav' eK TavTrfg yap Trfv

awTrjptav Tpvyaatv 0/ TTtaTevovreg' tovto ^e Kat itaaiv e<f>r} itpo- 15

Ketadat Kat ^lov^aiotg Kat EXXrjat. irpoTeOrjKe ^e Tav KXX-^vuv

rovg ^lov^atovg, eTiet^r] Kat 6 ^ea-norrjg X.ptarog nparovg rovg

lepovg direaretXe KrfpvKag.

AnoAiNAPioT. E/ ev rrf fxeytarrj rotvvv rwv TroXeaVy cf^rjaty

yXevd^^taBat tel itapd rollg dvorjrotg KrjpvTTOvra rov awTrjptov 20

aTavpov, ov Jtapatri^aofJ.at. et yap 6 yiog rov Seov t>;v ata^^vvrjv

av6 rjfLUV e(3daraa-e rrjv rcu aravpov, Ttag ovk arottov i^fxdg

atayyveaQat ro rov Kvptov ^t Yjfxdg itdBog ;

'AnoAiNAPiOT. Ka\ dv rtg ^;' epyxv ovk etXtKpivovg ovte

^aoTtotov OtKatoavvrjg r^v ttd itiarecog ^wrjv yapt^Ofi.evov rjv, Kat 25

Ttpocp-qrrfg eiprjKev " eK Tttareag eig ittaTtv'" **
et ydp eitiareveref

<f>r]aty
*' MaaeT, eitiaTevere av efxoi.^^

AnoAiNAPioT. Ai§ac7Afe< itoaav dnaXXd^et KaKav ro Eivay-

yeXtov Kat rj ^i avrov itiartc,' Ka\ tte^eXBm rd re ev eSveat Ka]
ev LovOatotg KaKa, fxera ravra itpotm, rov Ttepi rrjg TttaTeag ertt- 30
<l>epet Xoyov' avayKatav yeyevrjaSat rrjv rov X/?i!TTov rtapovaiav
O/OaaKSt»* Kat ovtq} irepi rrjg rwv 'lov^aioov eKirraaeag ^taXeye-
rat. Kai ro reXevTaiov hrdyet rdg irapatveaeig. dp^^^erat Se drto

rov Kara eQv^v Xoyov, Kat (pi^atVf wj' rov ev rrj (pvaet itapa rov
orffxtovpyov ypaipevra vofJLOV d^eSig itape^rjaav.
 I. 19- Pi2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 9

KE^. B.

Ilf^i Kpictas Tjjs Kara i6va>v tS>v ov (f^vkaairovTav to vofufxa.

* A7roKa\v7rT€Tai yap opyrj Qeov air ovpavov.

'AnoAiNAPioT. ^Qii TO rov 0eoy ovo{J.a. n Kai (re^ag eig ra

Tov Qeov fji.€T(iVeyKOVTeg '^i^ixiovpyYjfxaTa' eha Kat epfjii^vevft 07rco<;. $

€1 yap y) opaTT) ktiijk; tov dopaTov iKavr) ^etKvvvai, KaTaXiirovTeg

^e toDto o/ av6p(i}7Toi, toc ^vjixiovpy^fxaTa eQeoTroiYiaav, ev aQiKta

KaTeayov Toy Qeov tvjv dXvjSeiav, d(ft wv '^

^rj yvZvai tov Seov,

itkavYjBevTeg Kat roye elg avToiig vjkov, rj^tKY](7av ttjv yvaaiv Kai

TVjv aXr^Setav, ovk etg Ta Trpoar^KovTa avT-q •^Q^rjaafi.evot' aW lo

eKetvvj aTpeaTog f/.evei, t>?« oiKetav eyovaa ^o^av dKtvqrov.

^9 Alotl to yv(oaTOv tov Qeov (f)av€pov icTTLV iv avTols.

jf\noAiNAPioT. OvK ovaia tovtov r} evepyovaa, (aaicep erepccBt

(f>r]a}v " d(f)6dpr(a, dopdr(i)f fi.ov(jp ao(f>f OeoJ," d\\ at ravT-qg evep-

yetat doparoi ovaat (pvaet, Kat firj^eTroTe ytvop.evat Kara^pavetg, 15

dX\a ^ta Tvjg KTiaeccg ev^eiKvvft.evat.

Ktpiaaot. Ot< (pBaprrjv eypvTaiV t»jv <f)vaiv t£v "^apriyfxevcov

elg yeveaiv, kou KeK\rjfi.evav ev '^ov(o rrjv vTrap^tv, earai ttov

Trdvrccg tovt(ov ^rjfi.tovpyog d(p6apTog Kat at^^tog' ovKovv ovtep.tav

evpvjaovatv dnoXoyiav ev r}fJ.epa Kptaecog. 20

AnoAiNAPioT. Mdraiog dpa rj rov fxr) ovrog, ag ovrog (f^avra-
ata' fAv^evog ovrog "nept tov Seov 6p.otxft.aTog rav irapa rovroig

7rpoaKvvovf».evuiv. eK rrjg ovv d<ppovog eavTWV "hiavotag Kai aKorog

ra7g yl/vyoug eavrav eiteiarjfyayov.

Etsebiot. AoKe7 /acv ovv dirXovaTepov tov itpog EAX>jvaf 25
evtaraabai Xoyov' wg KaQ ev povov ei^og dae(3etag rrjv el^oiXo-

Xarpetav Ttotovp.evog rov eXey^^pv. ov firqv Kat rolg aKpi^earepov

Beoipovatv a Xeyet rovro (patverat 'TrotSov, dXXa ttoXv fnaXXov

•nXarvv^ov rrjv kclt avrccv eTrtTtp.r]atv ag " eXXetTrovvrcov dae/Seiag

ei^og. 30
32 Oi TLV€9 To SLKaLcopLa Tov Qcov iTnyvovT€s.
AnoAiNAPioT. EvTaufla irdXiv ro dvairtov rov Seov, Kai ro

c Leg. Ser. d sic Cod.

 10 ESHrHSIS EI2 THN OPOS II. 7.

VTraiTiov Tov avGpiCTrov, Kat to ^iKaiov TV]i eTit(pepo[j.iV'rji Kptaea^;.

TovTa yap ^paaiVj ovk ayvoovvTeg to toiovtov, oti itapa Qew Kpnyj

KoXd<T€Wi eaTiv a^ia. ^vjXoi ydp etatv ovk dyvoovvTeq to to;outo,

enettav Kpivaai, Kat OavaTca tov$ Ta TotavTa TtotovvTaq [ueTep-

yovTat. OTav ovv Kai ot cf>avXot tyjv tov KaXov yvaaiv ey^oVTes- 5

(paivovTaif Kat y^aixevot ye avTyj, eTret^^av ixrj Ta^ig vjtova7g Trapa-

TpeTTavrai, [xapTvpovcrt Trj Ofj[Kiovpyia tov Qeov OTt KaXrf oitep

Kat ^FjKKXi^cTtaaTVjg eTrtdeccpi^aas (pyjatv' " OTt eiioiriaev Qtog

** Kat avTot
Tov dvBpocnrov ev6v '^, e^vJTrjaav Xoyiafxovg itoXXovg.^^

Twv ^e dvQpWTKav, ot [xev ap^^vjyot irpog to KaKOV, 01 ^e aKoXovdyi- 10

Tai Tov KaKOv. d[A.(j)orepot ^e irovYjpot, Kai 6 KUTdp^ag, Kai

avv^^pafLwv. tou ^e TroieTv to avvevtoKeh yeipov TiBi^ai KaTo, to

Xeyofxevov, " et eSewpetg KXeTiTVjv, avveTpe-)(eg ayTaJ." [J.ev yap

Tioiav, [/.edvwv tc5 Trddei, ^TTaTat TVjg npd^ecog' ^e avvev^oKwv,

(KTOg av Tov -ndBovg, Trovvjpta ')(j)co[Ji.evog, avvTpey^ei tx KaKa' to ovv 15

" ov [/.ovov, dXXa Koi avvevtoKovaiv," eniaTaaewg " ecTTi' TovTovg

[t.evTOi aiTiaTai, (og CKaTepa iiotovvTag.

1 Ato avairoXoyr}T09 €t w avOpcoire, 770,9 6 Kplucov.

i\.noAiNAPior. YJept Qeov ^taXeyo[>.evog, " diro^^aaei," (f)Y,at,

" KaTa TOL epya avTOv^^ Kara to eipvi[t.evov toci rpaXf/.cp^co' 6 Se HcoTVjp 20
Ttept avTov TOVTO Xeyet (f^daKccv,
*'
ToVe dTto^^aaet eKdaTcp KaTa tyjv

" Ttpd^tv avTOvT orav ovv oitep ai[t.oXoyYjTat elvai Qeov, tovto Ttov
(f)atveTat ov, Koivcovia ry^g (pvaecog ^eiKvvrat, Kat aXvjQvjg viorYjg.

7 ToL9 fxev Kaff vtto/iovtjv epyov dyaOov.

Eethpianot. Q.aitep Se davyyvcoarov to e^ epiSetag, ovrcog 25

Kat TO Tov Karepya^ofAevov Ttapa rov epya^o[t.evov. eaTi yap epya-

^eaOat TtaXaiovra, [t^ vtKco[/ievov ^e. to ^e Karepyd^eadat, Tvjg jM,eT

e7tt[i.eAeiag epyaaiag eart rov KaKov.

iilpirENOTS. Opyvj &e eartv eito[A.evog roHg d[t.aprdvovatv

eitt Tt[i.copia. itovog. 6v[xov Ve opi^ovrai opyviv dva6v[>.ico[i.evvjv Kai 30

ototoaivovaav. ovrog Se Bv[i.og epyov eyet to eXeyyetv, YjviKa
av ota rag a^iaprtag itaaywv rtva, vjrot rvjg avvetOvjaecog avrcov

nXvjTTO[i.evY]g, ^ aKoXovBovvrcov eitfTtovcov rtvm tyJ d[f.apTta. aXXa

Kai aXtxpig enerat roHg rotovrotg' ovy^ vitO[A.ovYiv KaT€pya^o[i.evv],
c Sic Cod. d Leg. vid. iiriTa<rfa(.

I
 II. 14- PX2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. H
ov^e €1 Mn^tJTig cov Kav^-fjcrerai, aX\ ei avve^evKTai aTdvo^^ppta.

ovK av ^e T/f i<7T ^voyjapyjQyjt ei 'ireTroiyjKe Tig avrw aito (xotpias

Ti\a.To<; Kap^ia^y Kai YjKourre tov AttoutoXov XeyovTog' " iTXa-

*'
TvvSvjTe Kai vfjieis" crvvdyeiv yap eiwGe Kai cTevovv ttjv ^'^'X/IV

Ta KaKetf wg tov ^idPoXov, ccg ev on^ Kara tov 0(piv e[Ji.(f)(tiXeveiv. 5

10 Ao^a Se Koi rt/xrf kcu elprjvrj.

Sethpianot. EiTTi [xev Tov KaKov, Ti^v KaTdKpt(7tv (apKxeVf ovy^

ciTrAcSf dkk eTTi tZv KaTepya^o[J.ev(i}v' eni Se tov dyaOov t>;v

to^aVy ov [xovov eitt tcov KaTepyai^ofJievcoVf iva ^t' eKaTepcov tov

Qeov TO dya6ov ^ef^^Syj, Kat oti KaraKpivei ovy^ aTiXwg Tovg epya^ i o

^ofxevQvgy aXXa rovg KaTepya^ofxevovg' Kai oti TifJM. Tovg dnXoag

epya^ofxevovg tg dyaSov.

AnoAiNAPioT. KaXag he TrdXiv evTavBa \ov^ai(p Te TTpuTOV

^7^0"/, ^evTep(tig Se KXXyjvi' 01 yap TTXyjaiecxrepov tov ^e(77roToi»

Kat Twv hrtTifj.yj(xe(i}v vnep Tovg dXXovg TifnavTaiy Kai tSiv Ttfxm i^

vnep Tovg dXXovg aiioXavov^xtv.

KE*. r.

Ufpi Kpi<Tf(os TTjs Kara roi 'itrpa^X, tov p.^ (f)v\d<T<TovTos to. vofiina.

^2 0(TOL yap avofjuos rniapTOV.

'AnoAiNAPioT. AiKai(i}(xtv Se ov Trjv TeXeiav, t>jv KaTo, Xpi- 20
<7T0V. Ttept yap eKeiv^g OTav ® (ftyjaiv, " e^ epyujv vofj.ov ov htKatoo-

" 6yi(7eTai iTdda adp^."

14 "Orav yap eOvrj ra fxr] vo/xov e^^ovra (fyvaet.

'AnoAiNAPioT. E< Kai Tyjg dKpodaeaig T-Sjg tov vofxov, cpy^aiVf

diroXeXefJiTat Ta e^vyi, dXX edv Kard rov (pvaiKOv vovv ('rrtreXyj rd 25

rov vofxov ^ovX-^fxaraf vofxov eyet tijv (pvatv.

^vfxixapTvpovar)9 avrav rrjf avvei8r](r€(09.

©EOAaPOT. 'H ^e rovTcov, (f^yjat, ^tdyvooatg rore earat, ore

Kat Tcov Kard vofxov (Stovvroov, evog ovrog rov Kaipov KaB bv '*
ra
*'
vdvTCOv ruv dvQpoiTcav e^erd^et Qeog ^td rov \ptarov, Kard ro 30
'*
EivayyeXtov fxov," iva e^iTry], KaQoog Kat avro Kyipvrrccv ^tareXSsv,

^ Post hav est parvus hiatus in Cod.

c a
 12 EHHrH2;i2 EIS THN OPOS II. 17.

OTt eaTUi Kpiaecog Katpog, Kai ^ti TTtaTfvaavTag K.piaTx tvjv

TifjLxpiav €K<pvy€iv eKiivvjv.

'i^pirENOTs. H Kai ovTcai Kpivei 6 Seo^ Kara to KvayyeXtov

TlavXoVf eTi Kai toov iiapankYjaiav eKetvw, Kat a^tovi; eavTov^

TieiroivjKOTWv, ov^evo:; aKvBpwTTov a\\' e(f> w ya.tpeiv XP"^'

"'^ ^

avTwv eaTi to KvayyeXtov avu tvj tov ©eov Kpi<xei ^taKOVo)

KeyjvjfJLev^.

'AnoAiNAPioT. AvBpcoTTot yap twv (f>avep(ov ^ KaQovTai ^tKacnai

fxovov, Kptatv ^e tcov aTroKeKpvfjifxevoov wg Qeo( iroteTTat. " avBpwnog

" yap" (pvjatv *' oipiTat eig Trpoa-anov, 6 ^e Qeog eig KapOtav." 10

a)<7Te K.piCTov KptvovTOi, Qeov ehai tov KpiTi^v.

17 "Ide crv *lov8ai09 eTropofxd^r).

©EOAflPOT. Ov KaT epctiTVjatv, cog Ttveg vneXa^ov, avayvca(TTeov

TO " the (XV lov^^aloi eTrovo/xa^Tj," aXAa KaTo. ano^pacrtv. iva etTTVj'

fxTj wv akrfiiog Kat ev KpvTtTca lovtahq, aXXa Xeyofxevoi. 15

^' 'O OVV BLbdaKWV €T€pOV.
ZvjTvjaai ')(j}V} 'noaay^q voft.Oi XeyeTai, Kat fxaXiaTa irapa
**
TOJ AwoaToAco, tva fjivj ^o^v) evavTtovaBat eavTw' Tore fuv el

" TteptTefj.veaBe, KptaToq vfxai ov^ev uxpeX^^aet'" Trore Be, ** nepi-

" TOfuvjv oi)(f>€Xe7v eav vofJiov Tig 'irpdaayjj'^ eaTtv ovv vofX,oi KaB eva 20
Tpoirov ipiXov, TO ^caaecog ypdfHfxa, KaBo avjfnatvofxevov etpvjTat to
" el ev vo/xcu ^ ^tKatovaSe, T^g ydptTog e^eTrecxaTe." Kat to **
vo-

" fkog Tiaitaycayoq •yjft.ccv yeyovev eig X^/cttov." eT< Kai KaTo,
*'
"TrvevfKa vofKog Kvptoog ovofxa^ofxevog, KaQo etpvjTat' ftJCTTe /xev

" vofiog ayiog Kat v] evToXvj dyta^^ er/ Kat (pvatKOg^ KaBo eipvj- 25
**
Tat' OTav yap eOvv} Ta fi.vj vofxov eyovTa, (pvaet Ta tov vofxov
**
iroteH,^^ Kai Ta e^vjg. XeyeTai vofkog Kat vj Mwaecog taTcpia, ccg

OTav ev TVi irpog YaXaTag (pcxaKVj **

AeyeTe fA.01 ot tov vofiov dva-
**
ytvaaKovTeg, tov vofiov ovk aKoveTe ; ykypaitTat yap ^A/3paaft.

Ovo vtovg icxye, Kai Ta eqvjg. KaXet de Kat Ta -Trpo^pvjTtKa vofxov, 30

" cyf ev Tw vojtx,cD yeypairTai, ev ^ CTepoyXwaaotg Ka) ev yeiXeatv
'*
eTepotg XaXvfaca tx Xax TOVTCp" ev 'Hcraia. fxvjTroTe Se Kat t^v

e ois
SlC Cod. S hKUKivirOcci Cod. ^ frfpoyXwavvii.
II. 21. Pi2MAIOT2 Eni2T0AHN. 18

\piaTov TTfpi rwv TtpaKrim ditaaKakiav vofxov KaXei, xg orav

<f)aaKVj, " oiTiveg ev vofxx ^iKaiovaSe, rvjg yapirog e^eTrrdaare,^

dvarpeitei Yjfxdg diio rov Mwo-ea»? ypdfXfjiaTog. irepnofjiyjv ovv vjv

avrog <t>yi<^i, vvv ereoav Xeyei itapa Tr,v KaTaTOfx.y}v Kai voft.ov rov

TtvevfiariKOV. hvvarai ^e vZv vofnog voe7a6ai Kai 6 Kara rag (j>v<Ti- $

Kag evvotag. Kara yap ri^v rvjg v^v)^^? /SeXrixatv, o TCvevfKartKOig

Tteptrefxvofnevog, uKfteXelrat Kara rrjv rwv (pavXwv itepiatpeatv. ^<a

^e Tov Ttpdrreiv rov vofxov rd TtpaKrea epyatofj.evog. '^vvarat Sc

rig Kai Kara ro prjrov eKrog avay ooyYjg e^r,yyj(jactBat ro pvjroV

Kat <})rjatv ori itpog rovg dito lovtatwv ^ia\eyoft.evog rovro (f)r,aiv' lo

eyevero yap rolg lov^hatoig ag ^lovtalog, tva lov^atovg Kep^-^av],

TtepiTefichv rov 'Yifj.oBeov Kai Ketpdfxevog Kai KaGatpofnevog Kora

**
vofLov, (eare Kat itpog avrovg Xeyeiv, 7teptT0fj.rj fj.ev yap wcpeXeT,
" edv vofxov 7tpdaay]g," itpog ^e TGy^ e^ eOvav '^taXeyoft.evog, ravTyjv

Kwkvet, fjiy) evavTiovfnevog eavric. 15

^Eitei^yj ^e eipyjrat ev rw itepi Tavr^g Xoyw, too AjSpaatx rovg

e^ eBvwv Tteptrefji.veaSat, ei fJLV} rovg aito aitepfLarog avrov, Kat

roi/g oiKoyeveTg Kat Tcvf dpyvpcov^rovg' OfKotwg ^e Kat ev rw

AeviTtKco Ttep) rwv vliov ^lapayjX e'ipy)rat fxovov. ovk dvdyKr\ §e

Kai rovg Ttpoar\Kvrovg rovrovg TtpoavnaKOveaBai, ettei ovoe ra ttept 20

Tctjv Aevtrwv l^iKwg vevof/io6ery]fLeva, yj ra itept rav tepecov, rj

ra Ttept ryjg yepovaiag TtpoavnaKovetv avrotg Oidaoat Kai erepovg.

orav yap Kat rovg "TtpoayjkvTovg jSovXerat ri OtaTtpdrreaQat,

i^tKwg Kat avrcov fxefXvriTai' oog orav itepi Bvatag (f)rjatv, aju.eAe<

Kat avvearyjKOrog rov KaXovixevov ayiaafxarog npoaecpepov Kat 25

Ttpoarjkvrot. ag Kai itepi rav teKa Xeitpxv rwv KaBapBevtctiv

Kvpiog e(pyi,
" ttopevBevreg ^et^are eavrovg rolg tepevai^'' a(f) wv

^afxapeiryjg elg yjv. co jU.apTvpwv ^ar-^p <f)yjaiv, " ovy^t ot oeKa

*'
eKaSaptaByjaav, 01 Se evvea itov ; ov^ evpeBr\aav vitoarpei\iavTeg

" ^o^av 'hovvai rco Qecio, ei fxr) dXXoyevrjg ovrog^^ et Oe rtg ra 30

aTto ryjg K^ohov dvBvitotaet nepi rm eaBietv ro itdaya ^ovXo-
fxevcov TtpooriXvrcav, ag "^el avrovg TtepirefxveaBai, (prjaofxev, cog ev

evi roTtco BveaBai ro itdaya itpoaera^ev Seog, tovtov Oe lara-

fievov, vvv Ttepirrri yj itepirofxyi roig e^ eBvxv.

 14 EHHrH2I2 EIS THN HPOS II. 26.

26 'Eai/ ovv 7] aKpo^vcTTLa to. BLKaLa>ixaTa tov vo-

/JLOV.

©EOAflPor. TaJ 7ivevfj.aTif ov tw \\yica. ov yap Trtpi toov ev tjJ

yapni KaTopGovvTCcv ^iaXeyeTatf ak\ VTTOTiOcTai ^i oXov Tovg \^(a

Tflc Tov votxov Ttoiovvrai' Kai ^etKvvai KpeiTTovag tcSv cv too vo/x,Oij 5
7iapal3aivovTav' avva^ei ^e 'anavTa KaTaXXyjXwg tw oiKeiw aKOTrcf

TrpoSeciv e%a)v Kai tov tpvaiKov vofxov KXXvjvag ^ei^ai Tcapa^aTagy

Kai ^Yov^aiovg irpog tw (pvaiKoi Kai tov BeToV iva ^ia TrdvTWV
'*
CTYjaf] TO T-fjg yapiTog y^prj^eiv aiiavTag. Xeyei Qe to ev irvev-

" [xaTi" dvTi T6y t^ •npodeaei, (og ev tt] twv ApiSfxav l3tl3X(p (pyjatv 10
*'
Qeog, OTt TtdvTeg ot Tiapo^vvavTeg fxe ovk orpovTat ttjv yi^v' ^e
" iraTg fxov ^dpe^, ort eyevvyjQr, iFvevfxa eTepov ev ayTW, Kai (Ttvj-

**
Kokov6r,ae [xot^'^ Kat ra e^rjg. (f^avepcog Trvevfxa tvjv TrpoQeatv ei-

irav' Kat irpocf^i^T-^g " TrvevfxaTt Tropveiag eirXavrfiriaav. tva etTryj

TtpoOeaiv eayov TiopvtKrjv. '5

'OpirENHS. Ka) Kpivei rj e/c TttaTeoog aKpoj^vaTta. eXey^yjae,

(pi^atv, TO ayjfxeTov fxev fxy] ey^aV ra &e tov arjfxeiov KaTopOaaag

wg fxyj KaTop6a>aavTa' KaiTot ^eov, eitet Kat viteayov, 'tta tov avj-

fxetov fJiaXXov eKetvov to KaTopBcofxa eitt^eiKvvvat.

KEa>. A. 30

Htpi vwfpoxrjs 'laparjX, rov Tvyxavovros Trjs firayyeXias.

I Ti oifv To TrepLcraov tov 'lovSaLov ;

OpirENOTS. To 7ttarev6'^vat rd Xoyta rov Oeov, ovk ev tw

pi^Xia Kat ypdfLfxara Tttarev^yjvat, yapaKrript^eTai' aXX ev ra
rov ev avToTg vovv Kat rd evaTtoKettxeva fxvar-^pia yivioaKea6at. 25

Kara ydp rov vyiyj Xoyov ao(f>og vorjaet Ta dito rov i^tov aro-

fxaTog. eiit Se yetXeat (popeaet eTttyvcafxoavvi^v. rotovrog rjv 'M.wii-

ay^g Kat ot itpo(f)^Tat, ^lov^aTot ovreg Kat Tttar evdevreg rd Xoyta

Tov 0eov, Kat etrtg Ttap avroTg rovroig TtapaitX-^aiog. Kat ot

AitoaroXot oe rov Kvptov yjfxav ^ii^aov ^ptarov etyov to itepiaaovZ^

Tov iovoatov, Kat r^v rrjg Tteptrofxyjg w(f)eXeiav itapd rovg vir

avrcov fxa6ovTag rov 'Kptartaviafxov. '

Eart ^e Kat roTg e^ eSvav
 III. 3- PX2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 15

iroXv TO irepKTcxov Ttapa tdvq Ik irepnofxyji. ait €K€ivav yap y}p6r]

yj /oaaiXeia rov Oeou, iva ^oS^ eflve/ iroiovvTi Tovg Kapnovi avTi^i,

€1 8e TrpwTOi €K€ivoi €7riaT€v$y}<Jav Ta Xoyia T&y Qeov, eiaiv oi Kat

^€VT€pov 7TiaT€v6€VT€i, TO jap TipaTOV Tivog €aTiv, yj TIVXV TTpaTOV.

TiV€i ovv ^evT€pov €7riaT€v6T^aaVf l^eTv laTiv €k tov, " raj iJ.€v <yap 5

'^ia Tov 7rv€Vf/.aTog tt^OTai Xoyoi ao(f)ia$" Kai Ta e^Yji. €i ^e Tig

avyy^eofJievog TavTOv oieTai Ta Xoyia tov Seov ToiV ypa[xfxaai tov

©eov, npoa€')(€T(i} tco XeyovTi xpaXixXy " to. Xoyia K.vpiov, Xoyia
*'
ayva, apyvpiov ireneipaifjievov, hoKifi,iov t^ yYf, K€Ka6apia ft,€vov
*'
e?rTa7rAa<r/<uf." fyw yap ovk oifxai '* Ta ayva Xoyia" elvai to. 10

'*
a:;Ta, Tc5 aTtoKT€ivavTi ypafLfnaTi^^ (oaitep ^e 0/ irpoeipvjfLevoi

lov^atoi TcpxToi eTiiaTev^vjaav Ta Xoyta tov Seov, ofTa? Kai Ttveg

riTiiaTiQaav' aXX ovyj Ttav toiovtxV €tT€ Trpog tov ©eov, e<Te iipog

Ta Xoyta avTov, aiitaTia. ttjv -ntaTtv tov ©eou KaTapyvjaei. noiav

Se TitaTtv Toi) 0€oy ; noTepov vjv Oeoc 7riaT€V€t Ttai Ta Xoyta, vj \c

vjv 01 7riaT€v6€vT€g Ta Xoyta 7itaT€vovat tco ©ea) ; wg " ^Ppaaft.

" eTr/o-Teytre tw Oeco, Kat €Xoyia6v} avTX e/c ^tKatoavvvjv.^' €Ka-
T€pov oifKat Xoyov eyjstv. ft.€fj.v'^a6ai yap tel tov t€ TrtaTevovTa
tco 0ea3, Kat tov 7i€7itaT€Vfj.€vov Ta Xoyta avTov. ft.dXtaTa ev

Kaip'2 TVjg Tav dniaTCov yXevv}^;, vjv "x^Xevd^ovat Tovq 7r€7TiaT€VK0- 20

Tag, Tov fj.v] KaTapy€ia6at tv^v ntaTtv tov ©eow vito Tov Xoyov tS>v

aTTtaTOVVTCOV.

Etsebiot kai Sethpianot. To /xev 7ipwTov, ovx^ iva, (fjviatf

oevTepov ti entvf Kai TpiTov, dXX oti touto npwTov TidvTxv eaTi
KaXwv TrepteKTjKov. tov yap TrtaTevaat To7g tov Qeov Xoyotg ti 25

KpeiTTOv av etvj ;

3 M77 TQ airucTTLa avTa>v rrjv ttuttiv tov Qeov KaTap-

yycry;
!AnoAiNAPioT. 'Ofj.oXoy€ta6(i}, (f>v]at, to tov Seov ^e^aiov kolI

dXv}6€g iravTayov. av6oci}Troi ^e dPejSatot Kai i/^euSerf eXeyyea^oo- 30

crav. tva vikS. Talg evepyeatatg Seog virep tv}v a^iav twv av6pa-

W4>v, Ta Trap eavTov yapil^Ofi.evog. Kai e^ret^av Kptvv}Tai Ttpog itaaav

adpKa KaTa to yeypafj.fj.evov avafj.(pta (By}tv}tov, v} t» iravTa fxev

avTOv Ttapeayi^Kevat Kora tv}v aya6o7V}Ta tvjv eayTov, Kat VTtep

16 EHHFHSIS E12 THN HPOS 111.3^

r-rjv /xvBpanwv a^iaV Tovg ^e avSpcoirovi u.y] Ttapid^^Kivai avra

ra fji.y] i:po(7rjKovTa.

Ktpiaaot. EvTifjiCtiTepoi t£v aWuv oi irpoeyva}(Xfji.(voi, koi

vofAOv Xotj^ovTes TTai^ayayov, Kai vito^jye^Tng eyovri^ eiii ^piarS),

Kai Vifi Kai a.Ti€i\i^(pOT€g Kat TTpoKeKXyjfnevoi rwv aXXoov. €(f)a<7K€ 5

yap 'Earvjpf *'
ovk aTi€(JTakriv el ft.yj Trpog ra iipo^aTa ra attokoi-

" Kora oiKov l<Tpav]X" Kai rwv ^ia TricrTtcog avaae(7co(7ft.€VQ}v airapyri

y€yovoT€(;. ov yap ei Tiveg €K (ppevofSkaPeiag tov TrKjreveiv «ttw-

XeiaSov, TavTfj rot, (pyjatv, <xcf)afA.apri^(T€i€V av rov Kat a\-rfifiq €ivat

0eof. ovKovv 7r€7iQft.(p€ ft.€v c^ ovpavov rov Tlov Ylarrip, ir€irt(TT€v- to

Kaai y€ fxrjv ov Travreg avrca. ap ovv ort yeyovacri rtveg v^ptarat

re Kai aiiKJTOt, ovk €(JTai o 0eof tx\i^dv]g ^ta rovro ; ,a>y yevotro.

" yiv€o6x ^e Seog <xXv]6Y]g, Trag ^e avBpoiTrog yl/evarv^g." avrt rov

vo€ia6(i} T€ Kat X€y€a6ot} Tipog rjfxxv aXr]6r]g. Ka6opt^€a6io ^e (oairep

av6p(i}irov iravrog rov "^evtovg ro KaTr]yopr]fx.a. arpeTrrog ft.€v yap 15

Kat avaXXoiQ}Tog TravreXwg vt 6€ia (pvatg eart. aeaaXevrat ok

Xtav r] avBptoTtov (pvatg, Kat oaov ijKfv €1$ re ro eyyjapovv irag

av^poiTtoq ^evarr^i' Kara^Xet yap eaS ore rrjg dvSpcoTrov ^tavotag

(cg ocft.aprta ro ipev^og, Kat ^ey^erat itcog r] (pvatq Kat rov rotov^e

TVjv voaov. €Ttt te ye rov itdvra^v Kparovvrog 0eoD roioilTOv rt voelv 20

r] Xeyetv ov 6€fx.tg. ovkovv roye ^vvaa6at ita^eh ro i\j€vtog rr^v

av6pco7tov (pvaiv r]yovv ttjv ^tdvotav, dXr]6€g earat ro Karr]yopr,fLa'

'*
ovrco itov (pyjai Kat fxaKdptog Aa/3i&, eyw eiita ev rr] eKard-
" aet fxov, Ttdg dv6pco7tog xpevarvjgj'^ avrog t av yevoiro Xoyog
irept re ©eoi) Kat r]fA.(ov Kat Trept rm aXXcov dirdvTcov, oiov eirt rvfg 25
OtKatoavvr]g, (patrj yap dv rtg Kat ovk e^« Xoyov, ytvea^co OtKaiog

6 @€og, irdg Se dv6pco7rog xpevarr^g.

Sethpianot. Taj^a S av rig dirXovarepov Kat roig irpoKet-

fxevoig otK€toT€pov epfxr]V€va€te rov Xoyov, fxr] Kara airocpaaiv

aXXa Kara vno^eatv €K^€^dfJi.€Vog ro pv]6€v, Trpoa^-^KVi fxtdg avX- 30

Xa(5v]g' ort kolv irdvreg av6pco7rot 7tpo r^g aXi^6eiag aya7tcoat ro
ypevoog, ovtXv rjrrov Qeog dXr]6r]g tiafJ.€V€t Kat ^iKatog, VTtt-

a'/yovfA.€vog oia ©ew TtpoarjKe, Kai itdv ro reXeaSev e^ttreXcov, vjviKa

7tpoarjK€v.
 III. 9- PilMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 17

'QpirENors. To oiiv " yevvjQYjTio" etpvjTai «vtI cvktikqv a>s to

**
€17] TO ovo[Ji.a (Tov evXoyyifJi.€vov ei^ Tovf aiavasJ'*

5 Et Se ^ d8LKLa rjfiayv Qeov BLKaLoavvrjv ovvlottjo-i.

Ktpiaaot. 'H T^f ToiavTfjs tia^oKyjg Ttpocpaaig iVTeiiQev ye-

yevrjTai. fJLCTa tvjv ano BajSvAwvof enavo^ov oi vioi lapai^X /ceXev-S

6evT(g VTTO Kvpov ava^€i[Jiaa6at tov veuv, Kai TrKvjpovv €vy(a.g, Kai

irpoa^ayetv 6vatag, yeyovaat paBvfxoi, 7rpo(f)aat^Ofji.evoi itTw^eiav, Kat

Tvjv ano Tvjs af^aXaatag TaXatTKapiav. TavTvj avfXfjLerpotg eaccippo-

vt^ovTo Tiatteiaii, d<popiatg KapTrav, Kat veTuv ev^eiatg' da^^^dXXov-

Teg Se Ttpog Tai ToiavTag irXvjyag, efxaKdpt^ov fxev Tovg aWoyeveTg, lo

Kai Tovs fJLV) ^ovkevovTag to3 Qeco wg ev ev6vfj.ta ^tdyovTag' Kat

€(f)a(JK0v afxeivovg eavTutv vndpyetv eKetvovg. Kai yovv ecpaTKe

irpog avTOvg }AaXayj.ag 6 vrpotpviTVjg' " efSapvvaTe en eff.e Touf

*'
Xoyovg vfj.av, Xeyet Yivptog, Kai etTraTe, ev Ttvt KaTe\a\vj(jafj.ev
" KaTa (70V ; ciVaTe <f>v]<Tt, fji.dTatog o ^ovXevwv Qea. Kai ri itXeov 15
" OTi e<f>v\d^aft.ev to. <f>v\dyf/.aTa avTov ; Kai ^tOTt €7iop€v6v}fi.€v

**
iKeTat Ttpo 'TtpocwTtov ^vptov TtavTOKpdTopog, Kat vvv vjfj-elg futKa-
" pii^ofx.ev dXKoTptovg ; Kai dvotKo^ofxovvTat itotovvTeg dvofxa ; av-
" Te6v](7av ©ec5 Kai ecwdr^crav. TauTa KaTekdXvjo-av 01 (f>o^ovft.evoi

" TOv ILvptov, eKadTog itpog rov vXvjdiov avTov' Kai itpoaeaye Kv- 20
*' aiTiag, wovto
ptog, Kai ela-^Kov^re.^^ TavTvjg eveKa, (pvjai, t^j-

Ttveg Tovg lov^atovg keyeiv, iiotviawfi.ev to. KaKa, tva eX6v] Ta aya6d.
ev^iKOv Se ft.v]v to Kptfux, eiitwv, v] twv ^lov^atotg €7tt(f>i^ft.t^ovTccv CKei-

va, ^yovv twv Xeyeiv aTtOToXfjLtovTCov, oti itotvjawfj.ev ra KaKdf tva

€X6v] Ta dya6d. 25

KE4>. E.

Hepi xapiTos 8i ^s av6pa»roi fiovov diKaiovvrai, ov Kura yevos BiaKtKpifievws,

aXXa Kara 0eoi) 86aiv IfroTip.ats Kara tov 'A^paap, tvkov.

9 T/ oi)v 7rpo€)(o/xeda ; 01; Trdvrcof.

0EOACPOT. Iva etnvj, aye toivvv fj.eTa rov oiKeioov eXey^ov, 30

Tftjv vjfxeTepwv to fxeye6og Xe^ofxev.

'OpirENOTS. BovAeTa/ jij^Ta avvayayelv wwg aitavTeg 'lov-

^aHoi Ka\ ' EAAv^ve^ vito dfxapTtav yeyovaai. dp^dfxevog dito tov
**
Ka6wg yeypa.TtTat, ovk eaTt %tKaiog ovVe elc, . ovk eartv avviwVf
D
18 EHHrHSIS EI2 THN HPOS III. 9.

" ovK e<7T/v ^yjrav, tov ©eov." oirep avraii Xe^e<nv, ov^^^ €vpofi.€v

Tiov ycypa^ixevov, aXXa vo[j.i^Q[j.ev «tto rov rpiaKaioeKarov Kai rov

'TrevTT^Koarov "hevrepov fxeraTioieiaGai vtto rov AiroaroXov ra pr/ra'

ev fxev yap rS ty tpaXfJioi e'ipy]rai'
'*
K.vpiog eK rov ovpavov B/e-
**
Kvxpev eiti rovg vlovg rwv avOpooTrwv rov /^eTv ei eari avviav rj
5
" eK^rjTiov rov 0€o'v." ev ^e tw v^* " ©eo^ eK rov ovpavov
" oteKvxpev eiit rovg vlovg rwv avOpairav rov l^eTv ei eari avviav r)

" eK^y^rSiv rov Seov." eoiKev oi/v vevovjKevai laohvvafxeh ro *'

rov

tbeiv et eari avviav vj eKgvjrwv rov Kyeov. Kai ro ovk eart

**
OiKatog ovte elg" vof/ii^a yeyovevai e« tou **
ovk eart Tiotav 'XJ^yj-'
10
o^TOT>jTa* ovK eartv ecuf evof. coaTe ryj bvvaft.ei Oti avrov reOet-

Kevatf aira^ fxev ft.eraTtotyjaavra, aTia^ ^e Xe^eai raig avraig y^rf-

*'
adf/.evov, Kat itapaXtTiovra ro ^evrepov eipT^ff.€vov ovk eartv.^^

©EOAflPOT. T'^ fnaprvpta, ovy^ ag 7rpo(pyjrtKS>g etpyifxevy} eyj)y]-

aarOf dXX ax; dpft.o^ovay] roTg d7ro^e^€tyfi.evotg, ra TrepiXyjnrtKwg 15

vept eirraiKorwv Xeyetv avra rov Aal3i^. aairep ovv yjfAeis ayjpi

ry]g oevpo ev ralg eKKXyjaiaartKaTg ^taXe^eat, fiaprvptatg avyK€-

y^yjft.eBaf wg av dp/xo^etv ^vvaft.€vatg d^ro rvjg tiavotag roTg irap

rjfj,S>v Xeyofnevoig. 6 yap tpaXfj.og eKcTvog ov Trepi irdvrm avdpairwv

*'
etpyjrat tco AajSth. Kat ^^Xov e^ wv (pyjatVf ovy^t yvaaovrai 20
" irdvreg 01 €pya^oft.evot rvjv dvofJ.tav ; ot eaOiovreg rov Xaov fj.ov

'*
ev /3pwaei dprov." rtva ^e e^eAAev ovoft.d^€iv otKeTov ©eeo

b Trept Trdvrwv avBpwirwv ware ro ')(€.Tpov eKKXtvavrwv airo^pi^va-

fj.evog ®.

Sethpianot. *'
T/ ovv Kare^^ofJ.ev irepiaaov ;" Trpoyjryjadfj.eQa 25
yap lovhaiovg re koi EAXvjvaf Kat ra e^vjg eXXetirwg eipyjrat.
'

ro yap " rt ovv Kar€')(ofi.€v ireptaaov ;" aKoXovBov yjv eirayayeTv

rrjiV eK Trtarewg ^tKaioavvyjv' irpot^ryjadf/.eOa yap lov^atovg re Kat

KXXrjvag. Trpoyjr-^aaro ^e irwg ; ev tu5
'
KXXyjvag fiev aireXey^at

otacpBetpavrag ryiv (pvatKvjv yvwatv ev otg etpyj, " Qeog yap 30

" avroTg €(pavepwae' ra yap aopara avrov aito Krtaewg KoafKov^
" roTg irotrjfiMat voovff.€va KaBopdrat. Kai ^tort yvwvreg rov
" 0eov, 0^5^ wg 0eov e^o^aaav^ ^ evyaplar-i^aav." 'lov^aiovg Se

7iapa/3€^y]Korag rov vo/aov, ^i wv (pyjatVf " og €V vofxw Kavyaaatj

^ Hiec procul dubio corrupta sunt.
 III. 19- Pi2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 19
*'
Qia TTJg Trapa^daews tov vofxov tov 0€ov d,TtfJid^(tg ;" ^ei^ag Ka\

OTi irap oif fJLCV vj <f>vat$ vjadevyjo-e' irap oU &f> xai vj rftvatf icai

vofxo^f aKoXovBcag t/jv €k tov KvayyeXiov ydptv eia-dyet Kai

(pyjo^tf Tt e-)(pfji.ev vjyi.ellg eK TVjg y^dptTog Ttepiaaov Kat e^aipeTov ;

Tiyv TitaTtv Tr^v ^ta 'Ii7<7ov X/3«7T0y 'htKaioa-vvYig ovaav dvepya- 5

aTtK-^v,

12pirENOT2. ** To ^e log daTrt^av vTto Ta 'xetXri avrwv"

avTaig \e^eat KeTrai rj yjpyjfytg irapa tco pX6^ xpaXfxio' to Se mt
TOVTOig " m TO aTOfxa dpag Kat irtKpiag yefi.ei" eotKe yeyovevat
avo Tov ev t» 'evvaToo \l/a\fJiw ovTCog eiprjfLevov " ob dpag to io
" aTOfjt,a avTov yefj^et Kat •ntKpiag Ka) ^o\ov" eW e^^g tovto
eaTtv' " o^eig oi iro^eg avTcov eKyeat alfjia.^' tovto ^e ^vjT-^aetg
ev ToS 'Ho-aioc, vj ev Taig dXkatg Toiv Ylapotfxtav eK^oaeatVf ev

Ta *'
Tayyvot eKyeat aifux. '
b fji.€Ta daTepiaKm irpoaeTeO^ ev t^
eKtoaet twv e0tofj.yjKovTa. " to Se avvTptfXfj.a kou TaXatitapia ev 15

" Tatg o^ollg avTm^^ "^^^ '^evpo ovk ot^a irov dveyvctiKwg.
H'^'XJP'^

otfxai ^e ev t;v/ tc5v TrpocpvjTaiv yeypa(f)6ai to, " o^ov elp-^vrjg ovk
" eyvccaav." ev ^e "^aXfiLoTg, **
ovk eaTt <f>o^og Seov direvavTi tuv
" o<f)6a\fi.av avTwv." Trkr}6ovg Ve ovtwv dfi.apTrjfj.dTm ov irdvTwg

evoyog eKaaTog eaTt Toig airaatv. dX\ 01 ft.ev, tw ^e TaJ dfJMp' 20

T-^fxaTi, ot Se Toj^e, Kai ovtw Tovg rrdvTag To7g iraatv.

19 Olda/JLev yap otl oora 6 vofxos Xiyei.

£ipirENOT2. T< Kotvov irpog iraaav adpKa to. epya tov M»-
aewg vofxov ; irwg Se Kat Trjg dfJMpTiag eirlyvwatv ^ia tov vofxov
Meoi/Veojf ytveTat ; iroXXm Kat irpo M.(i}aea}g eTreyvcoKOTm to. TSia 25

dfxapTrjfxaTa. Ka/v jotev, (f>rjai, " fnet^m rj aiTia fxov tov d(f>e-

*'
6rjvat fxe." 01 ^e elg AiyvTTTov KaTa(3dvTeg irpog tov ^lwar}(f>

iraTptapyat, Xeyovatv eirt Torf Toy \wari(f> irpog avTovg Xoyoig to

**
ev dfxapTtatg eafxev irept tov ddeX(f>ov rjfxav," Kai to. e^^g. dXXa
'*
Kat etTtep IojjS teiKvvTai "npo 'M.waewg yeyovevat, (fjrjatv el ^e 30
**
Kat dfxapTm eKovattog eKpvrpa Trjv dfxapTiav ft.ov" Kat to. e^rjg.

cocTTe '^oKeT fxot ft.^ tov Maaeag vofxov vvv Xeyea6at tw ^iroaToXw,
aXXa Trepi tov (fjvaiKOV, og Kat yeypairTat ev Toig Ka^iatg twv

^ h avr^ Cod.
D 2
 20 EHHrH2I2 EIS THN OPOS III. 21.

avSpaircov. Tiveg h av eifv 0/ ev tc5 vo[j.oo ; yj irag 6 aviJ.it\yipwaag

Tov Xoyov avbpcoTroi ; ovk eiai yap ev too vOfJLO}, 01 €Tt ^wvTe^

'^(^(epti vofjiov, OTTOioi y]v Kai YlavXog TroTe, TrXvjv ot aytot, ovg

Ttpoeyvo) Kai iipoaptae Kat e^iKaiwae Kat edo^aae, vofxog etat Kat

OVK ev vofxw. ^tOTtep ov (ppay-^aerat avTwv to aTOfxa, ovoe viro- 5

htKOt yev^aovTat tw Qew' ov yap elat adp^. Kat ei ttKatovvTat

**
Se, ovK e^ epycov vo[j.ov, voiJ.og yap, ovk ef epywv voiJ.ov ^tKatQ}-

" d-^acTaif^ avToBev ItKatoi (OV ovtu) Se ^ ^r] vofj.ov entyvwatg

df».apTiaf, wg ^ia laTpiKYjg eitiyvwatg voaov, Kat fj.dXiaTa TVjg

XavOavovaYig Kai avTOv tov voaovvra. Ka\ dXkwg te, oaov eirt tw 10
vofxw Ttfj.wpyiQvivai tov fj.otyevovTa, ej^^v Kai tov <f)ovevovTa KoXa-
*'
^eaSat ^ovXofJ.evw •ndvTwg' to §e Kvptog a(pe7\€ to avofjy}fj.a

*'
(70V," ovKCTt PovXYifj.a Yjv Tov vofxov, dWa ydptg tov o^wKOTog
Tov vofxov. hia TovTo dKpt(3wg ei-nwv to " e^ epywv vofj.ov,
'
ovk

eTtYiyayey itag dv6pwTTog, d\Xa itdaa adp^. ^taOeaei fj.ev yap 15

otKatovaOat "tvvaTOv, OTav tyJ itpoBeaei itpog to tov vofJ.ov p^TtYi

^ovXYjfxa. epyotg Se, ovKeTi ^vvaTOV. t» Se epya aapKog, aitep

dve^YjTat ^'^X^.

21 NvjH Se xco/jfy vojxov SiKaiocrvur} Qeov TrecpavepcoTai.

'QpirENOTS. "^O Xeyet toiovtov eaTiv. ovy^ waitep '^ta vofi,ov 20

ejtiyvwaig dfj.apTtag, ovrw koi <f)avepwatg tiKatoavvYjg Qeov ota

vofJ.ov yiveTat. fj,ti^wv ydp eaTtv yj dtKatoavvYj tov Seov Taiv

<f>vatKwv d(f>opf(.wv, at Ttveg ovk eiatv avTdpKetg itpog to KaTa-

voYjaat ^tKatoavvYiv, oyj^ ditXwg, dkXd tyjv avTOv tov Qeov, ov Ta
^iKatovfxeva Kpifj.aTa dve^epevvYjTd etatv. ^io " vvvt xwptg vofiov 25
" •necpavepwTat yj tov Qeov ^tKatoavvYj^' ^g ^t^^daKaXog eaTtv

XptaTog, ev fj.Yj^evi TtapaXafj.^dvwv eig itapdTaatv T^g tov Qeov

otKatoavvYjg tov t^j- (f)vaewg vofj.ov. efuapTvpeiTo Se avTYj waitep

vito Twv TtpotpYfttKwv koywv e^ 'Ayiov TIvevfj.aTog aivtyfxaTw^wg

eipYjft.evwv, Kat vito tov itpotp^^TOv M.wva€wg vofxov. Kat fA.Yj Bav-^o
fj.day]i, et ^vo aYifj.atvofj.eva tov evog ovofJ-aTOg tov vofkov ev tw
avTw TtapetXyjTtTat Toitw. evp^^aofj.ev yap TavTYjV tyjv avvYjQetav Kat
ev akXaig ypa(f)aig' oiov " ovy^ vfj.elg XeyeTe ort TeTpdfi-Yjvog eaTt,

S Leg. fors. hd.

 III. 21. PX2MAIOT2 EmSTOAHN. «1

*'
Kai Qeptcrixog ep^^^jerai ; eirapaTe Toy$ o(f)6a\[xovs vfxav, Kai
*'
Qeaaaa-Be Tag yjapa^; ori XevKai etaiv iipog Beptafxov vj^i;.*' §/f

yap eKe7 6 Septajxoi ovo[xaa6e)fy Kai to, fxev tov irpoTepov htt tov

acofxaTiKOv a,va<f)epeTaif Kara ^e rov tevrepov eirt tov iTvevfxaTtKOV.

etTrep Qy] o avrog vofxog TtapetAYjTrTat Kara Ttva<;. et fxev yapis S

vofxov ireipavepaTai, ov^^ vao vofnov fxaprvpenat. ei Se vtto vofxov

fxapTvpeiTai^ ov xa»^<? tov vofxov irecpavepuTat.

AnoAiNAPioT. Ov KaTa evavTtwatv t>;v "Trpoi vofxov, akXa

Kara irpoaO-^Kifjv aya6ov Kat ^copeav Qeov' tva fxvjKeTt ev av6p(a-

Trivr) ^tKatoavvvj Kptvoofxe6a t^ iravrag e^eXeyyo[xevfi' aXXa Tyj i o

'^apa Qeov ^tKatoavvy] Teketa6wft.ev. avTtj ^e eaTtv rj tta rrjg

^ptaTov irtaTeac, etg irdvTag tta^aivovaa Toy^' ittaTevovTag, Kat

iraatv hravaTravofxevri.

ToT ATTOT. AvekaPe to irpoetptifxevov, tva vpoad^ ro Aenrov.

eTrei^v] yap etire ^tKatoavvri Qeov irecf^avepcorat, etra rtva irapeve- 15

6v]Kev dvayKaKcg, rovrov rov \oyov dvaXaPoov, ^etKvvat ^ta r^g etg
Tov '^eairoTVjv ^ptarov 'Trtareag ravTvjg airavrag diroXavovrag, eire

lovOaioi eiev, eire KWvjveg, 01 TavT*]g rvyeiv e^^tefxevot. to ydp

etg iravrag rovg lovoatovg Aeyetf eirt Travrag Oe rovi eK rcov

akXcov eOvxv. 20
Ktpiaaot. Oida ort yeypairrat irept rtvoJVf ort ** v]aav ^iKatot
**
afX<porepot 7ropevoft.evoi ev raig evrohaig Kat 'ttKataifxaat rov
A.ptaTOv afxefxirrot. Kat fxaKaptog oe viavAog e<pv], ort Kat
avrog Kara '^tKatoavvv]v ty]V ev vofxco yeyovev dfxefXTrrog. aAA*
ev rovrotg dfxefxirrog ovTro) treTtpaye ra tt wv earat Xafxirpog Kai 25

do^tfxog. Kat yovv avrog ecpv} Trdktv [xaKdptog IlayAof, ag

vf^eho fxev airavTa ra ev vofxw ^v]fxtav, Kat ev tacc aKv^dXotg

KareXoyt^ero. ^v]TOtv] Sf irdXtv to virepeyov TV]g yvwaecog rov
^ptarov. KaraKpivet he irdktv vofxog rovg irapa^aivovrag.
ravrv] rot erepcc^t (pv]atv' **
el yap rvj ^taKovia T^f KaraKpiaecag 30
Oo^ay iroWf fxdkXov ireptaaevet v] ^taKovia t^$ ^iKatoavvv]g

^O^V].

IlketaTV]g Se Qvav]g evrokv^g ev avrS), irdaa vrwg dvdyKV] Ka\

rov aKptjBv] vofxo<pvXaKa '^taTrraietv ev rtat, Kat irapa^drv^v vofxov

Ka6taraa6at' Kat ort (poprtKog dkr]6cag ^tcof/.oXoy^Kaatv evapyccgiS

 22 EHHrHSlS EI2 THN HPOS III. 22.

01 6e(77reaici fxaOrjTai' e^pacTKov yap " vvv ovv ri neipd^eTe tov

" 0eoy, eiTiBeTvai ^vyov hiti tov TpdyyiXov tw» fji.a6viT(0Vf ov

" ovTi 01 itaTepeg vjfjiaVf ovt€ rjfxeig Kjyvdafxev j3aaTa<Tat ; ore

Toivvv "EXA>jv€f fMV ^(Tav v(f> dfLapTtav ag YjyvovjKOTei tov ov]-

fxtovpyov, ^lov^a7ot ^e wg r^f tov vofj.ov 7rapa(3da-€ws evo^^^pt,

5
e^ifiaev dvayKaiw^ Tolq ovatv em TVjg yvji ^ tow ^iKatovvTog
yipta-Tov' ^e^tKatwfji.e6a yap ovk e^ epym twv ev ^tKaioavvvjy av

eiroiYjaaft.ev rjfJ.eHg, aXka KaTa to ttoXv avTOv eXeo^' avTO^ yap •rjv

KaToi TidXai Xeywv "tta (paiv-^i -Tipo^pvjTwv, " eya etf/.t 6 e^aket-
*' aov^ Kat ov fi^ ^idTTei ye 10
(f)(i)V Tag dvofJ.iag fi^vv}a6Yjaof*.atJ"

fLrjv r] 'htKatovaa %dptq eig TidvTag ev laWf 'louSa/ouf t€ (fyyjfJi.i Kai

*'
"EXXTjvaf, OTt Kai rcdvTeg rjf*.apTov Kat vaTepovvTat Trj^ ^o^yii
** av etKOTW^ to
Toy fcJeoy, ooqa \yeov oe vootT /x^tc etoevai

fJ.riTe fj.ri 7r€(f>vKevat 7r\r]fj.fj.eXeiv. KaTorttv te 7idvT(ag t«v T^f

6eoTr]Tog av)(rjfidT(i}v, Tiaaa rj yevi^TV] KTiaiff 7iap(i}Xia6ov yap Kai 15
Twv Ayyekdiv Ttveg, nXriv evtoKi^aev 6 ©eof Kai YlaTrjp dvaKecfta-

\atwaaa6at to, TidvTa ev tco yipiaTw tc5 ^tKatovvTi 0(opeav Trj

ayTou ydptTt. TedevTai yap IXaaT-^ptov '^ta TnaTexg ev tco avTov

atfJ,aTt. eTteiOri yap ^ieTrotrjTai TVjg diidvTo^v ^co^f dvTdXkayfj.a to
ittov alfj.a, aeacoKe tyjv vti ovpavov, tXeoav Te Kat evfj.ev^ KaTeaTTj- 20

aev rjfiLiv tov ev to7s ovpavoig UaTepa Ka\ Qeov.

22 r\' ^ > \ ' ' \o'
yjv yap ecm s>
oLcuarTOAr]. iravTes yap r]/xapTov,

HpirENOTS. AtKatov ^e 7iapa6ea6at tov<; fj.eTa aifi.aTO<; yevo-

fnevQvg KaTa tov vofuov t\aaft.ovg, tv evpe6r\ €k twv napaTt^efJ.ev^av,

Kat cov eaTt avfnfSoXa Ta yeypafi.fj.eva. yeypaitTat toivvv fj.eTa 25

T7JV Tou apy^€pe(ac, 6vaiav ev tc5 hevtTiKWf " eav he ndaa avva-
*'
y(iiyr\ dyvorjari, Kai Xd6ri prifi.a e^ 0(p6aXfj.(i)v Trjc cruva-ycuy^f,

**
Kat Tiotrjacoat fj.tav aTtaaav tZv cvtoAcov K.vpiov. rj ^ dfj.apTta,
'*
yifj.apTov ev avTri Kat Tipoad^et rj avvayaoyrj fj.oayov €k (3oav
" Tiept T^s dfj.apTiai." eha fJ.eT oKiya' " Kat elaoiaei lepevg, ©3°
*'
yjptaTog aTio tov atfjJXTog tov fj.oayov eig ttjv aKrjvrjv tov f^ap-
*'
Tvptov^ Ka/ TidXtv fj.eT oXiya — " Ka) Ttotrjaet^^ <Pwh " to>'

fj.oayov ov Tpoitov evotrjae tov fj.oayov Tr\g afxapTtag oi/TCiJf

S oi Cod. h ^'Cg. Ka\ yvuaO^ avroti ij diA. ^v ^fAafTov, Lcv. iv. 14.
 ;

III. 27- PilMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 23

*'
TTOi-yjfiiJtreTa* avra' Kat €^i\a<TeTai iifpi aviav 6 lepevsy Kai

aqxfjrjaeTai avToig.

liiANNOT. Sethpianot. Qy^a/xoy ^e <priaiv, oti iravref yjcre-

/SvjaaVf aW v](xapTOv to tyj^ ajxapTias koivqv' ov to t^j' aaej^eiag'

^ ov^e v(7Tepov[ji€Vog eyovTi to vaTepovv, ^yjTeT to XetitoV elyov 0/5

iov^^aHoi Tov vofxov. laTepel ^e ayTorf vj ttj^ yapiTog Tekewaii.

25 Eiff evBei^LV TTis 8iKaLoavvr]9 avrov.

Sethpianot. ©EOAXiPHTOT. 'Hveaj^eTO yap ©eof, iva ^ei^yj

TVjv eavTov ^iKaioavvvjv. el yap ime^eXvjkvOeif TtavTug av aveiXev.

el te avYipei, ovk vjv aool^ofxevog. eneiViri te vjveayeTo Kai irpoaTi- 10

Qefxevm tS>v afji.apTV}fj.dTwVf e^et^ev OTt (3ovXofxevoi ov KaTaXkdJ^ai

vof/.ov Twv dft.apTVjfxdTwv, aAAa Kai ^tKataaat, to irpoTepov vjve-

ayero. avyyxpviaag toivvv dfutpTdvetv, ddpoav t>jv oupeaiv eyapt-

aaro. otKatov oe tov ©eoi/ keyofnev vjTot dvTaTio^t^ovTa, vj tvjv

^tKatoavvvjv yapt^ofnevov. ovv eya ^tKatovtJiat, Seov ^iKaioavvvjy 15

eirei^vj ovk e^ efniiov epyaVf aAA* €K t^? tov ^tKatovvTog ydpiTog.

otov avvTOfj.ag tet^ag to. toopa t^( ydptTOi, dvaTpeyet tov vep) tov
vofJLov Aoycv Kat oetKvvatv avTov.

^7 noiJ ovu 77 Kov^aLs ; e^e/cAewr^ry.

OpirENOTS. ^iiretVfi Taca ^ ef epyav direKXetaB^ Ttdaiv 20

avSpuTTOtg Kavyyjatgy ^ta tovto " waf vxpwv eatrrov TaveivcoO-^ae-

** Ta<*" Kav dXvjdevcov Xeyet to **
©eoj- evyaptarav aot, OTt ovk
** wg
etfji.t ot XotTTOt Tav dvOpcoircov," Kat to. e^vjs. ^ta vofxov ^e

TTtaTewg eKKketeTat itdaa Kavyvjatg, oitota vjv vj IlavAov KeyovTog

** ^ efxot Se fMj yevotTo KavyaaQat eir ovtefJi.ia. twv dpeTwv, ^ e» 25
**
fnova Tw aTavpw tov K.vptov vjfnwv I^aov X^^orou."
IlavTcy!,- e^erre f>.ot, ti( htetaeXGwv vofxos tovtov c^ejSaAev
eitet^i^ vofxw 7te<f>vKev KpaTwv XveaOat vofi.og. Ttpog ovg, (f^vjatv,

ov vofxog epywv eitetaeXBwv tov itpoTepov eKvae. KdkkiaTa ydp

eiyev eKetvog, Ka^d ye ToyTO. vdfxog Se itiaTeoog eiretaeX^XvQwg, 30
veptTTOv etKOTwg tovtov a7re(f)V}vev, vtKwavjg tvjv diro tov vofxov twv

epywv. eiret^vj TovTa vjfxwv diro TVjg Oetag virdpyet ydptTog, a avv
TroWw Tw Ttovw "jrpoaytveaQai airo tcSv irpOTepwv ovk v^wvjOviv.

o
» Haec non cohserent. ^ e/>io« Cod. 1 tfyuv Cod.
 24 EHHrHSIS EI2 THN OPOS III. 28.

etei^e ^e ^ta vofxov iriarew^ ***** (xOai iipoi rov

vofxov ag aXkorpiov e.Tti rav oiKeicov ryjv TrpoaYjyopiav aa-Tra^erai.

Ktpiaaot. T/f yap oXw^, vj liri riat Kavy^^ceraiy Ttavrav

ijiyjpeKti^evav Kat eKKeKXetKorwv rvjg evBeiag otov, Kat ovoevog

ovros vavreXwg rov Tiotovvrog yjtriarorrira ; ovkovv " e^eKXeta6i^, 5

(pTjahf y] Kavyyiaig. rovreartv eK(Be(3Xrirat, Kat av^prjrai roirov.

rrjv Ttapeatv rZv irpoyeyovoroiv ait.aprrnj.aro)V TreirXovrrjKafxev eXea

Kat yaptrtf ttKatov^evot tapeav ev Xptarw.

28 Aoyi^ofJLeOa ovu 7ruTT€L SiKaiovaOaL avOpcoTTOU.

©EOAapoT. To Se " Xoyi^OfJieSa^ ovk eirt afxcpt^oXiag Xeyei,io

aXX' avrt rov Xoyiafxw TW irpoa-^Kovri' rjyovfxai rrjg Kara Tttartv

^tKatcoae^S aveii epycov vofxov Ttavra avQpcoirov ^ovXrjQevra fxere-

Xeiv. arjfxetcoreov ^e ug ovy^ aTtXwg eiTte '* ywptg epym vofxov,

aaavet Kat epya^oi[xe6a aperrjg entfxeXovfxevoty ovk avayKri vofxov

rovTo "TTotovvrav, aXX vcp erepov irpog rovro ayofxevcov. \^
'OpirENOTS. Ot; &6 dpKei etg ^tKatoavvrjV rrjg nrtarecog vo-

fxog KaOoXov fxrj^ev epyaaafxevotg rjfxTv, eypfxev ^ei^at rov avarav-

pwQevra Xrjarrjv tcS Irjaov, Kai rrfv ev toJ Kora AovKav dfnaprwXov
yvvatKa rrjv Kofxiaaaav dxd^aarpov fxvpoVf Kat araaav •jrapa

Toiig Jid^ag rov ^li^aov, Kat '^ianpa^afi.evi^v aitep avayeypanrat 20

TreiroirjKevat. e| ov^evog yap epyov, aXX eK rrjg Triareag a(f)eovrat

lavrrjg ai dfxapriat, Kat rjKovae ro " rj Tiiarig aov aeawKe ae.

" iropevov eig elp-^vrjv.^^ ori ^e fxera rrjv eTriyvcoatv d^tKta yevo-

[xevri, dSerei rrjv ydpiv rov ttKatwaavrog, aa<pwg avrog ev roTg

el^f Ttapaarrfaet. eyw ^e oifxat, (f>rjaiv, ori Kat ra 'Trpo rrjg 25

ittarewg epya, Kav SoAfjj eivat ^e^ia, wg fxrj eirotKo^ofxi^Bevra KaXw
^ BefxeXiw rrj Titaret, ov hKaio7 tov itotrjaavra avrd.

31 'H *lov8aL(ov 0eoy jxovov kcll ovk iOvcov ; vojxov ovv

KaTapyovfjL€v Slo. rfjf 7rLaT€cos ;

Ktpiaaot. E^iy rw QeaTteaiw Moxr^ rwv cXav Qeog, " Tipo- 90

*'
(prjrriv avro7g dvaarrjaw eK rwv d^eX(j)wv avrov' Kat XaXrfaei
" avro7g Ka6ori av evretXwfxat avrw. Kat avOpcairog eKe7vog og
**
fxrj aKovarj twv Xdycov, oaa av XaXrfarf Ttpo^prfrrjg eirt rw

1 Bifji,i\ia. Cod.
III. 31. P12MAI0TS EniSTOAHN. 26

" ovofJLUTi fjLOV, eya iKhiKyjad} e^ avTov." 7rc5f ovv ovx^ KXTafxev

vofxov ^ta T^f vicTews tqv irap avTov 'irpoaiefj.cvov ^oyov Kai

•jrpo^^rjTYjg wvofxaaTai tia to avQpwjrivov 6 Ytfj.fJM.vovfiXy o ag ev

To^ei Majcrewf fA.eaiTrjg ©eou Kai avOpuTrcov. Kai iraXiv 6 fJi€v

vofJ.og yjv ev crKiaigf TrXrjv w^ivav opaSai r^f aXvjSeiag TfjV fjiopcfxo- 5
(XIV. ovK avatpeT ^e Toiig Tvvovg vi aXyjBeia, Ka$iaTi^<7i ^e efJ.fpa'

ve<TT€povg,

'OpirENOTS. Tivi ^ia(f)€pet vj eK vifTTewg ^tKaiovfievyj irept"

tofj.rj, T^f ttKatovfj.evqg '^ia TVjg TriaTeag aKpo(BvaTiag ; ov yap

vofJ.i<JTeov cog eTt^p^e Tlavkov Taig TrpoBeaecxt ^iaipopwg KeyjprioSat. 10
olov Kat ev Tr} irpog l^optvBtovg^ " rj •yw/^," <^^a<v, " eK tou avtpog,
**
^e avrip ^ta Trji yvvaiKog.^^ ^okcT ^e fnot oiKCioTepov eivai to

€K Ttvog Toj e| ov, r) irep to ^ia Ttvog tw ^t ov. rj fxev yap yvv-i^

TrpcoTwg e^ avbpog eaTiv ovOeTroTe Ot avopog. ovbe yap 65 aAAov

TTOTe yvvrjf iva yevrjTat ^t av^tpoi. Kat fjAktaTa eTrav aKovr} 15

TOVTcov KaTa Tov A^afJi. Kai t^v Euav, tta to " tovto vvv oaTovv
'*
€K Tm oaTav fi.ovy Kat aap^ €K Ti^g aapKog fi.ovJ'^ ^e av^p

ovte-noTe eK Trjg yvvatKog, aXXa Kat avTog TrpaTOog e| av^^pog a>v,

fxeTa TOVTO ytv€Tat ^ta yvvatKog' aXXa tovto ovKeTt apfj.oi^et eirt

Tov AoafjLf aXX' evi iraviog av^pog fLeT eKelvov. eTre) toivvv ev- 20
yeveaTepov irepiTOft.ri aKpo^vaTiag VTrapyov^ to ^e yiro^eeaTepov
^ aKpo/3vaTia o^evet ^ia Trjg iriaTeoog, tva ^tKatooSrj ovk eXQovaa
'hta T^g irtaTecog. vtaTevaag yap Ttg ep^^^CTat eig Trjv •jreptTOfJ.rjv,

Kat fj.aXtaTa rjv (f>rjatv 6 AiroaToKog ** t^v cv Kpv^£" coare fieX.-

Ttov voetTui TO e| av^^pog, KaQo e| dv^pog to ^ta yvvaiKog. OTt hrt 25

TravTOf fCev dvSpcairov y^jopav eyet tovto, erret vpo tov tta yvvatKOg,

yeyovev e^ dvtpog. eiri Be tou Sojt^/jos" fj.rj yevofxevov e| dv^pog^

ovK eyei TO yeyovevat avTOV ^;a yvvatKog' ^ioirep eKe"!, e-nei to

yeyevr}fj.evov eK Tiqg aapKog, adp^ eariv, rj aap^ avTov /x^ yevo~

fj.evrj ef dvtpog, yeyovev eK yvvaiKog, Ka). ov S;a yvvatKog. 30

©EOAiiPOT. 'Ett/ twv \ovtatcav to " eK TriaTecog" TeSetKeV ag
av e^ovTCtiv fxev Kai eTepag d<popfJ.ag Trpog hKaicoatv, ov '^vvafj.evcov te

avTrfg fj.eT€yetv wA^v eK Trjg iriaTecag. ent Se tc5v 'EXA^vwv **

^ta

Trjg TriaTecag.

JE
 26 EHHrHSIS EIS THN nPOS IV. 3.

'OpirENOTS. ZojTOVjaev '^tari fxvj e/Vev eK 7ii<m(og tiKaiov-

fjievov Yj 7r€piro[J.Yi €<ttiv. Kai ovk afj.(f)i^akXoix.€v (f>y]aiv, et fj.fi

KaTapyelrai €k irKTTCcog 'ttKatovfxevYii^ KaTapyeHrai vofnoi. aXXa

vvv vofMQV €\dPofJiev Tov Isliwaeag, 'tta TYjg TriaTecog ov KaTapyov-
fj.evov. Yj yap TrttTTtg iTTyjat Kat tqv vofxov €k 0eou ovra' irpoOYi-^

Aov Se acxTtep Tt r^f opQ-^g TriaTecog ^afxev. ei ^e Ttg dvTi6^a-€i €K

*'
T^g ^evTepag irpog KoptvQiovg 'ETrtaToXi^g to ei he yj ^iaKovia
" Tov OavaTov ev ypdfj.fj.aaiv evTeTvirfCfj.evYj XtBot^f eyevYjdv} ev
" ^o^yj, coaTe f).rj tvvaaQat aTeviaai Tovg vlovg \apariX etg TO
" irpoacoTrov M.ctiiJaecoif ^ta tvjv ^o^av tov irpoanTrov avTov ttjv 10
**
KaTapyovft.€vvjv" €povfj.€v oti ov TavTov eaTif to vofiog ovv

KarapyeiTatf tov vofJ.ov ovv KaTapyovfJ.€v. ovte yap avTog evepyei

vofj.og Ylavkog to KaTapyetv tov vofiov. et yap Kat KarapyeiTai

viro TYjg v7repl3aXXovaY]g ^o^rjg tov ^ptaTov, " Kvpiog ydp," (j^Yjat,

" Toy aal3/3dTov eaTi" Kat ov ^e^^o^aaTat to ^e^^o^aaft-evov ev tovtw 15

Toi; jw,e^e/ cog npog avyKptatv TY^g ™ virep^aivovaYfg %o^Yiq* fj.ovov

yovv mofj.aae to yipiaTov. to ^e fj)iq fj.€vov KaTapyovf/.evov, eTrei

" 6 vofj.og irai^ayctiyog^ ecag av eXBy] to 7r\Yjpcofj.a tov y^ovov^^

2 Ei yap 'A/Spaa/x i^ epycou eSLKaLcodr).

OpirENOTs. 'Ett/ Tivi eirtaTevaev 'AjBpaafj. tco Sea, ov iravv, 20

aacpcog ttYjy^aaTo ypacf)-^' eotKC ^e 6 'AiroaToXog yj KaSokov avTOV
eK\afij5dvetv TreirtaTevKevat. Kat yap dKYjBcbgj ei fj.ev to KaQoXovy

TrdvTcog Kat to Kara fJ.€pog, ei ^e ent ToTg etpY]fJ.€voig eirtaTevaev

TW ©eoj, ovK aKoXovBet oti KaGoXov entaTevaev. eaTt yap fJ.eTpa

'*
Tov TrtaTeveiv ©ecc' ^to 'AjSpadft. fxev eiriaTevae tco QeWy Kai 25
'*
€\oytady] avTco etg ttKatoavvYjv.^' ovtev ^e TOiowTov yeypairTat,
**
y]vtKa ei^ev Japay]\ t^v
X^^P^ '^^" fi€ydky]Vf a emtY^ae Kvptog
**
Tor? AtyvTTTioig, Kat €(f)0^-^6y] 6 \aog KvpioVf Kai eiriaTevae tco
" Kvpico, Ka\ yicoaY] tco OepdirovTt avTOv.^' ov irpoaKetTat ^e «f
'*
eirt Toi) 'AfSpaaft. to ekoyia^Y] avTSi eig '^iKatoavvY/V." 30
5\noAiNAPioT. TvTruo KaTo, Tov 'A^padfj. eTritetKVvat ty]v iri~

aTiv' ov Tolg ev vofj.co Kctt TreptTOfJ.Y] %^ofj.evYiv ft.ovotg, elg ^Katco-

"• In inarg. yfi. vittppciAKcva-vji;.

IV. 2. PI2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 27

oiVf aXXa Kai roig ev aKpo^vaTia. ^e^iKaiccrai fJih yap Kai

A^paafi, ovK e^ epyctiv. ov^e yap yjv to Kav^^^yjfJLa avTov Xafji.irpov,

aT€ke( oVf Kai Ttapa 0eco fKY\ ^yva/Aevov <paivea6ai' irap a> ^iKai-

ocTvvv] '^coXevovaay Kav)(Vj(Tiv " €%€<v ov ^vvaTai' ak\ €k Tria-Teag rj

^iKaicoaii Tov TraTpog y]fi.wv 'A^padfi.. iraTepa KaTa adpKa avTOV S

Xeyei t£v lapavjXiToiv rav KaTa Tiv€vfji.a Seov yevo fLevcov viav'

ols e^ofJioictidetg ^piaTOg ev t-^ Kora crdpKa yeveaet, e^Ofxotwaetev

avTovf Ttpog eavTov, tta Tvji ev YlvevfxaTt KOTa ydptv yev-

vvjaewg.

Ktpiaaot. yip-i^vai ^e vTToXafjL^dva}, ecpvj Tif, tov itept tov itpo- lo

iidTopoi AjSpaaf/. •noXvTtpayft.ovovvTag Xoyov, eKeho etTieliv. eipi^Tat

vov Ttvt Twv dyicov fiaByjTcHVf ^f^^a twv epytov, tvjv irtcj-Tiv etvai

v€Kpdv' nporTe-ndyet §e TOVTotg to BeXetg te yvavai, co avOpcoTre

K€ve, OTi yj TrtcTTig yjaptg tcov epycov veKpd ecrrtv ; 'A^paafJ^ 6

iiaTyip yjfjicov, ovk e^ epycov e^iKatcoSy}, dveveyKag ^lcraaK tov viov 15

avTOv etit TO BvataaTyjptov ; ap^ ovv dXX-^Xotg TavavTta (paatv

ot TrvevfjLaTO(f>opot ; t/ ovv iipog TovTa (f>afji.€v ; eig yvjpag eXyjXaKOTt

Xoiirov d^oK-^Tcog Xtav hiyiyyeXeTo avToo viov 6 tcov oXcov Seog'

e(f)a(7K€ T€ OTt TVj tS)V aaTpcov avapt8ft.y]Tco irXyjdvi (ptXovetKOvv to

ef avTOv yev^aeTat air€pfj.a. Se enetvep eTifA.a tov vTriayvov- 20

f*.evov TO Trdvra ^vvaaOat KOTopBovv, ^«a tovtov eTrifJiapTvpcov too

0eco oeotKaicoTai irap avTW, Kai yepag evTo^tov TVjg qvtco Qeocpi-

Xovg €KOfJLt^eTO yvcoft.yjg, tcov apyatcov atTtafLaTCOv ttjv afJivyjaTetav.

ttAvjv eTrote^To KOTa Kaipovg yvfxvaaftM tw "^tKatca Seog to eirt ye

Tw laaaK ypyjafi.cp^yjft.a. dXX y]v Kat etr avTca TrtaTOg Kat (ptXo- 25

Beog, cog TVjg irpog Seov aydTrvjg irpoTd^ag ov^ev. irXyjv KaBd (pvjat

Tov SwT^^of fxaSi^Ti^g, yj TriaTtg avvepyel Tolg epyotg' Kat €K

Toiv epycov vj iriaTtg e/Se^aicoOy]. ecpv] te Ttov Kat 6avf/.datog

YiavXog irept tov irpoTrdTopog A^paafi., " TrtaTei irpoaevypjoye tov

'*
laaaK 7retpa^Ofi.evog, Kat tov fi.ovoyev^ irpoae^pepev 6 Tag eTrayye- ^o
" Xtag dva^e^dfjievog' irpog ov eXaXyj^Y], ev ^laadK KXi^6Y]a€Tai aot
" airepfi.a' Xoytadfxevog OTt Kat Ik veKpwv eyeipeiv ^vvaTOg
*'
Seog." ovKovv kov el Xeyot to Tvyjiv e^ epycov ^e^iKatcoadat ^td-

" «X*"* Cod.

£ 2
 28 EHHFHSIS EIS THN HPOS IV. 4.

Tot TO '7rpCi(7ev€yK€Tv rov l<raaK Treipa^ofjiivoVf aXX vjv Kai tovto

avTOi TTiaTecos Tri^ e^paioTaTrig aiiotei^ig evepy/jg,

4 T^ 5e ipya^pfjLev^ 6 fiLaOos ov XoylleTai Kara

'£lpirENOT2. OySev av ^i^^aaiv Qeog t^ yevvrjT^ (pvaeif w? 5

6cf>ei\(>)V '^i^ooaiv^ d\Xa irdvTa ag X^^f*^^

"^xpeTTai. Kai irdvTa ra
evepyeTOv^eva, ovk 6<f)eiXo[Ji.evi^s avTolg evepyeaiag evepyeTeTrat,

aAAa ro (SovXeaSai tov Qeov IZia ydpiTi evepyereTv, ovg av evep-

yeTrj. vvv ovv vofxtaTeov avTO dirXovaTepov Kat KaOoXov eiprjaBaiy

Kai dXXwi KoivoTepov voovfxevov eni toov otaTtatvovv epya^ofievwv, 10

Ka] Tov fxiaSov dir eKttvm Xafk^avovTm, ov KaTa '//"ptv, aXXa

KaTo, 6(f>eiXrift.a, rjyrjTeov ^e avTO '^vvaaQat XeyeaBat, <f)epe etireTv

eiit Twv ig Kdiv epya^oft.evci}V tyjv yrjv Kat TrotovvTOiv epya irovyjpa'

TovTotg yap ag 6(petXofJieva vofi.i^(i}f Kai ccg fxtaBov twv epyai^o-

fjievctiv dno^itoaGat rag KoXdaetg. ^;o Kat ^AiroaToXog 6xp(i}vta 15

[xev Tijg dfxapTtag ecprjaev etvai rov BdvaToV ovKCTt ^e 6\p(i}vta Kai

iairepet 6(j)etXofj.eva aTto %eov rrjv ataviov ^(cirjVy aXXa yapiafka

avTov. (prjat yap, " to ^e ydptafj.a tov 0eoy, ^ou*/ aicoviog, ev

*'
X.ptaTi2 Irjaov t» K.vptw rjfj.(ov^^ ov vofxtaTeov ovv eirt tZv
KpeiTTOVCov epycov XeyeaOat ev too KvayyeXto) ro " co fierp^ fxe- 20
**
TpeiTef dvTtfj.eTprjQ-^aeTai vfxiv.'^ " %dptTt ydp eafj.ev aeacaafxevoi'

**
Ka\ TOVTO ovK c| yjfxm, Seov to ^Hopov, tva (xrjrtg Kavyr]arp:at^

TTpog ^e fxcTpov tc5v rjfxapT-^fxevcov rjfxav ^i^oaQat Tag KoXdaeig

vjToXrjTiTeov.

6 KaOaTrep koll Aa^lS Xeyei tov jJLaKapLajJLOv tov av- 25

OpCOTTOV.
'
0EOAOPOT. @avfxaat(CTaTa Se Ta^- fxapTvptag avveKpovaev, ciri

**
fxev Tiyf TtiaTewg, Kat eXoyia6r) aiiTco eig '^tKatoavvrjvJ'^ eitt te

Tcov epyxv' " Kat ov fxrj Xoytaerat K.vptog dfxapTtav^ eKet yap
rjpeaev rj iTtaTig, ware XoytaBrjvat avTco etg ttKatoavvrpj. eviavQaZ^
'he Ta epya Kat Ttpog to evavTiov peirovTa ov Xoyi^eTat, otov rj toD
&eov (ptXavdp(C7iia twv yeyovoTocv avcorepa (patverat.
Opifenots. yirjKeTt TtpaTTofxevov tov yeipovog, d(peatg eiKog

hvvaTat yeveaOat dvofxtSiv. dyaOov Ve eniTeXovfxevov (og Ta yevofxeva

 .

IV. 9- PfiMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 29

KwXvfxa, yivea^Sai t»v 7rpovjiJ.apTV)fX€vci}v e^a(f)avt^ovTa avTm rrjv

<pv(Ttv, entKaXvnTOVTat ai dixapTtat tcS» irpoayovTUVf ovoe koyt^e-

Tai CTt K.vptog Ttvi tw vjfji.apTyjK€vat.

9 Keyoixev yap otl iXoyLaOrj tco 'A^paafj, rj ttlcttls

eL9 bLKaLoavvqv 5

Sethpianot. WepnofJ^lri e^oOvj ^ta rpeTi aiTtag ravrag. oocm

(jYlfxtiov eivat Tticrem^ kcu toi; ' h^pafj.taiov yevovg eivat ^"i^XartiiOV,

Koi (TVfj.^okov Kai atvtyfjia iToXiretag KaGapSii Kai (xaxf^povo^f oxrre

ovy(^ ag ^tKatocTvv/js rov AjSpadfj. ".

©EOACPOT. E<V ro elvai avrov varepa TrdvTwv rov irKrrevov- lo

rccv Kara ro oiKetov i^ia>fn.a KavravOa etitev w^ ro etg ro etvai

avrovg dvairoXoyrfcovq' Xeyet yap ro avayKatwq ro7g yeyovo(Ttv

e-nofxevov. evrevBev <f)vjai Kotvog ecrrtv dirdvrwv Trarvjpf e-^et^av rrjv

vpog aiirov OfJ.otOTr]Ta r^g Tttfrrewg ^e^wvrai.

'OpirENOTS. AafJ.^dvei §6 fxera rrjv Ik Tnarewg ^iKatW(Tiv 15

(Ty)fxeTov itepirofi.yigy waitepei a<^pay7^a rvyydvov(jav Kat ditoKXi-

vov(Tav ^iKVjv Twv e(T(f)payta-fi.evwv ro fxvarvjptov rwv eK itt(Trewg

^tKatovft.evwv' tv 01 fj.era rvjv •Tria-rtv, CKeTvot €k '^eptrofj.^g T&y

'Af3paa.fJi erepot ovreg rwv €k itiarewg ^iKaiw6^a-ofi.evwv reKvwv

avTov, ^ eig reKva avrov \oyta-6vjaoiJLevwv, erepoi wa-i Xaot itapa 20

Ta5v ev aKpo^varicx. €K Ttia^rewg ^tKatwBvjaofxevwv. vj ^e c(f>paytg

ervjpeTro fj.ev f/.v] Xvoft.evv]f oaov ov^eitw eXvfkvBeta-av 01 eK ntarewg

Koi ev dKpo(3varta' vjviKa ^e v}X6ev 6 Jtpoetpvjfxevog reyQ-^credOai

Xaog Twv ev dKpo^varia, Kat eK itiarewg htKaiovfxevwv, rore vj

(T(f>pay\g Ka\ ro (TVjfxehv €Ke7vo eXvOv], war av XeyOi^vat rw (3ov- 25

Xofxevw r^v (T(f>pay7^a €Keivv]v Xa^eTv, ort eav 7teptT€fxvv]a-6e, Xp;-

arog vfxag ov^ev w(peXv]aet.

ToT ATTOT. Nofxii^w te roi/g dito tcSv e^vwv fxv] eTttarvfaavrag

rvj dKpiPeta r^g ypa(f>v]g, eKre6vjaaa6at ro aitQ rv]g yeveaewg

pv]rov, oi)"^ «$• YlavXog avro edvjKev ev r^ °^PXV' ^^'^^^ y^P ^3®
ovrwg dKpt0v]g €^e6ero ro '^
eitiarevae ^e 'Afipadfx tc5 Oew." ovrw
Se eiKog Kat ev roTg €^v]g yeypa(f>6at ev t-^ Ttpog Pwfxatovg EiTtiaroXy,
**
ori eXoyia6v] v] •jriartg rw 'A^padfx eig ^iKatoavvvjvJ^ vvvi Se eyo-

fxev vjfxeTg 'Af^padfx.

n Deest aliquid.
 30 EHHFHSIS EIS THN HPOS IV. 13.

13 Ov yap Slo. uojJLOv rj eVayyeA/a r<» 'AjSpaa/jL.

'AnoAiNAPioT. Ov vofAov opiaag tvjv tnayyeXiav Seo$ (^wkc

Tco *Al3paafJi. Kai toj airepfJiaTt avTov^ a\Xa 'HKTTei ^iKaiaaag av-

Tov. rj ^e toBuaa tw 'A^paafJ. enayyeXia ^v, <as Ttapa tov Mwo-fcy^-

fjLefji.a6-^Kafxev, yj Xeyovaa,
" aoi ^waco Kai tco (nrepfj.aTi aov Traaav 5
** eizay-
T>;v yYjv TavTVjv." ^io Kai Koaf/.ov KXyjpQvofniag eivai tyjv

yeXtav 6 ' ATroaToXo^ Xeyei' yvig ovaav eirayyeXtav. ev ^e tjJ irpog

KopivQiovg, elg yjfJ-ag Tovg tov 'A^paafj. KaTo. nvevf/ia ^ia^o^xovg,

avacpepcov navTa vjfi.(ov <py]aiv, ** ene Koaft.og, ene eveaTWTa, ene

*'
jOieAAovTa." Kai ^i^Xov TOig toc M-coaeag avayivwaKovaiVf oti ov 10

vofJi.ov TrpoaTayfi.aTa Xa^m A(3paaff., eiri TovTotg ea^/e tvjv

TotavTYjv enayyeXiav. Se ye TlavXog ev ToTg iTpoKeifj.evoig, Kat

T>jv aiTtav aTro^i^ccai, §;' ^v ovK e-ni vofioo tyjv eitayyeXtav e%(aKev

Seog, aXX eTit iiiaTet.

" E^ei^ev OTt avayKaia yj iriaTtgy ort Trpea/SvTepa TreptTOfJ.-rjg, 15

OTt vofi.ov tayvpoTepUf OTt avvtaTvjat vofi.ov. et yap irdvTeg y)fj.ap-

Tov, avayKaia. ei aKpo/SvaTog ccv e^tKaictiBv], Tipea^vTepa. et fJ.ap-

Tvpenai viro tov vofiov, Kat tov vofi.ov taTyjatv, ovk evavTia dXXa
<f)iXyj Kai avfi.ft.a')(og. ^eiKvvat ^e iidXiv Kat eTepcoSev, OTt ovhe

^vvaTOV yjv '^ta voft.ov Tyjv KXyjpovofi,iav Xafieiv. Kat Trapa^aXcdv 20

avTVjv T^ •neptTOfj.yi, Kai Aa/3a)v Tot vtKyjTYjpta, avTeTre^dyet irdXtv

avTVjv Tco vofi.a. tva fj.y]

Ttg Xey^, oti Kai TriaTiv ^vvaTOv ej^e^v,

Kat vofJ.ov Tyjpyjaai ^etKvvatv OTt dfj,yjyavov. ydp eyofj.evog tov

vofnov wg aw^ovTog dTtfid^et Tyjg TiiaTecog tyjv * * * * #

Oto (pyjatf " KeKevcoTat yj TriaTtg'"'^ TovTeaTtv ov yjpeta TVfg KaTo. 25

aapKa acoTyjpiag. ov^e ydp '^vvaTai tvjv ta^^^yv tvjv eavT^g eTittei-

qaaOat. Kat ydp 'lof^arof 'iaag av ^ eiiiot, t/ fJ.ot ydp yjpeia

TTiaTeag ; ovkovv et tovto dXyiOeg, fK.eTa Tvjg niaTecag Kai Ta T^g

eitayyeXtag dvy]pyiTat. itotav %\ eitayyeXtav (f>y]at' to KXy]povofj.ov
avTov etvat tov Koafj.oVf Kat ev avTCO iravTag evXoye7a6at, Kat 30
Ttoog KaTy]pyy]Tat yj hiayyeXia avT>7 (py^atv, ** OTt vofJ.ogy^ Kai Ta

° Hoc Schol. nuUum habet nomen Auct. marg. adpictum. P eMrjj

Cod.
 IV. 15. P12MA10TS EmSTOAHN. 81

^5 *0 yap v6fi09 6pyr)v Karepya^eTou,

AnoAiNAPiOT. E/ §6 opyrjv Karepya^eTaif Kai Trapa/Sda-ei
KaTevQvvovg Ttrjiel^ eySijA.ov OTi Kai KaTapa. Kai Ttfjnopia Kai napa-

j3da-€i '7rdvT€^ vncvSvvot. ovtc Kkyjpovoix,m a^ioif dX\a Toy Qikyjv

Qt^ovai Kat €K^dXkea6at. t/ ovv ytV€Tai \ epy^Tai rj inaTtg, ecpeX-S

KOfJi€vvj TV]v ydpiv. wcTTe T^v eTtayyeXiav epyov e^eXfle2v. ottov yap
yaptg^ (Txyyywpfiatg. oitov Se avy^pricnq^ ov^efJita Kokaaii;' Kokd-
aecos Se avvipvjfxevYig, eTnytvofuevYig tia T^g TttaTewg^ Tt to kcoXvov

KXvjpovouiovg yjfJiag yeveaSai T^g eiiayyeXiag ; ^ta tovto ovv Ik

irtaTeccg <f>r]aiv, iva KaTa ydpiv elg to eivat ^((3aiav tvjv eitay- i o

yeXiav tov ©eoi) itavTi tS> attepfkaTt. hpag oti ov tov vofLov taTrjat

fLOVov rj •tttaTig, dXXa Kat Trjv enayyeXtav tov Qeov ovk acptrjai

oiaTteaeh ; o oe vofxog TovvavTtov Kat Trjv ittaTtv KaTapyel itapa

Katpov Trjpovfxevog, Kat Trjv eTtayyeXiav KcoXvet. ^ta tovto (pr^at

" KaTa ydptv" etg to fnr] KaTaiayyvOrjvai, dXX **

eig to eivai l3e- 15
**
I3atav Trjv eitayyeXtav itavTi tS> ittaTevovTi^

ToT ATTOT. Avo TtOrjatv evTavda ayaOa' OTt Kai Pe^aia ra

ot^Ofxeva, Kai itavTt tc5 aitepfxaTi, Tovg e^ e6vwv avvaydycov, Kat

^etKvvg lov^aiovg eKTOg ovTag, av Ttpog t>;v TtiaTiv (fnXovetKrjaa)-

aiv. eha Otopi^eTai tcS aTtepfxaTi Tovg €K ittaTewg (priai, avva- 20

^rTOJv Trjv rtpog Ta eSvrj avyyevetaV Kat ^etKvvg, OTt ovde ^vvavTat

ff>pov€7v €Tti To5 APpaafL ot fLrj TttaTevovTeg Ofii.otQ}g eKeiva. t^v

Totvvv avyyevetav t^v itpog tov ^iKatov, aKpi^eaTepav rj TttaTtg

eTtotrjae, Kai itXetovoov eKyovcav ditecprive itpoyovov. ^to oi/^e ditXJSig

etTtev A^paafX., aXXa tov itaTpog rjfxSiv Tav tttaTav. 25

OpirENOTs. AavKOcf^avT^Tcog aKoveiv yjprj tov AitoaToXov ev

TOVTOtg Kai avvtevat tov ^ovXr^fxaTog avTov. cpaat ydp Ttveg, et

€v6a ovK eaTt vofxog, oii^e itapd/^aatg ^>yAovOT/. ov^etg ev itapa-

/Sdaei yeyove itpo M.a3aea}g el^evat' et Se fi.r] yeyove Ttg, ovre

^peKTOgf QVTC ovv KaiV, ovTe itdvTeg ot ^ta Tag eavTav dfxapTiag^o
TOv KaTaKXvafxov ita^ovTeg, r] 01 ev Yo^^OfLOtg ev Trapa/^daet yeyo-
vaai. Kat itpoye tovtcov ASa^ Kat rj Kva. XeKTeov ovv rtpog tov-
TQvg OTt 6 Mcoaecog vofxog, ov Trjv ev Kpiaet opyrjv KaTcpyd^eTat,

aXXa Tr]v KaT avTOV Tovg /xev Xi6oXevaTOvg Ttotchv' eTepovg Je

32 EHHrHSIS EIS THN HPOS IV. 15.

€ni itvpog KaraKaiaVf vj knpa vnojSaWwv rifJiapia.. akka Kai

emep ov ovk €<tti vofx.oSf ov^e iiapa^aaig' ore oaa vofj-o? AaAe?,

roHg €v TOJ vofJiw XaXei. opa ^e avToiig Ka\ tov irap avTW nayAoo

voft.ov 7ri(TT€Ci}g ovofJLa^ofnevov &eov opyrjv Karepyd^ea^daty Kai irapa-

Patriv elvat ev6a ecniv rrjc TttCTetog vofnog Kai rov Qeov. 5
^acpug he avrot; ezepov ft.ev elvat voft.ov rov rov 0eou, w /aov«

Kai avrof dvv^terai Kara rov eo"» avdpcoirov. erepov he vofjiov eivai

Tov ev To7g fKeXeciv eavrov avr ktt paTevofj.evov tSo vofi.00 rov voog.

Kat opa fjirj-noTe ovrog ear/v aXi^Swi opyrjv Karepya^l^o^evog. Kai

ov ovK eart vofuog ovTog, eKeT ov^e Trapa(3aaig euTi' Kai ot eK 10

rovrov tov vof/.0Vf ov^aff.S)g etat KkvjpovofLOt. et yap ot eK voft.ov

**
Kkyjpovofioij KeKevarai v} iriartg. iravrt §e toj cnrepft.aTt^ (pyjcrtv,

vjToi T<£ eK Tov vofi.ov, yj ro ck ryjg ntareag avrov, Kat ov fnovov ro

eK Toy vofJ.ov, akk el eyoi itpog ro Ik tov vofnov ro ck ryjg irt-

arecog. et yap fj.y]

ovroog eKka^otfj.ev, earat yj eirayyekta roig c^ '5

lapay]k, Kat roig €k ^erovpag, airep ovk apeaKet.

ToT ATTOT. AvayKa7ov Se, (pyjaiv, e^eraaat (fyaiverat, irwg

aKokovOei ro €K ittarewg Kat ro KaTa yaptv, ro ^e^aiav elvat ryjv

eTtayyekiav. apa yap et vfv Ik vofi.ov, ovy^ oiov re '}jv ^e^atav

rvyyaveiv ryjv eitayyekiav. ttpoay^eg ovv, oiovei ^evaoitotog rig 20

I3a(f>y] ytverat €K itiaTewg itepi t^v \\jv)(y}v, Kai fkaktara ryjg keko-

yiafj.evyjg etg hiKaioavvyjv, onare rv^v ^t avryjg eitayyekiav Kai

ya.ptv tayetv tta ro P aveKTtkvrov avr-l^g, yj afnera^okov ye t>?v

(SijSatOTyjra' yjTig ovk €fj.(patveTai itept t» eK vofJiov epya. aito-

aTp€(f>eiv yovv TtoTe ttKatog a.ito rvfg ^tKatoavvtfg avrov keyerat, 25

Kat Ttoielv o^iKtav. ovk otta te et Kat Ttept ryjg ittarewg yeypa-
Ttrai, ori aTtearpexpe rtg airo rvig iriaTewg aita^ f(.aprvpi^6€ig

iteittarevKevai, Kai '^iKatwQetg ^ta ryjv Ttiariv. eira Kat tyjv fiMp-

rvptav e7tta(f>payt^€t 6 6e7og Aitoarokog ro eipyjfLevov avrw.

ToT ATTOT. "^O ^e keyei rovro eartv waitep Seog, fneptKog ^o
ovK eart yyeog, akka Ttavrwv Ttaryjp, ovrw Kai avrog. Kat itaktv
waitep Qeog Ttaryip eariv, ov Kara tyjv (pvaiKVjv avyyevetav, akka

V
P avfKitMjTOv Cod.
 IV. i8. PilMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 33

Kar oiKeiooaiv TTiaTeccg, ovto} Kai avTog. yj yap vaaKovj Troiei

varepa TravTm rjfxm. hreitri yap ov^ev evofxi^ov eivai ravTi^v tyjv

avyyfvetav, tyjv TrayvTepav eKeivrjv KaTaay^pvTeg, teiKvvcxi TavTvjv

KvpiooTepav, eTri tov Qeov tov \oyov avdyav. Kai fxeTa tovtov

KaKUVo efAxpami, oti Kai afxoi^yjv TYji via-Tectis TavTVjv eXa(3ev, 5

co(TTe av fxf} tovto tJ, Kav TravTCov yj iraTyjp Tav ti^v yy\v oikovvtccv

To KaTevavTi ovKeTi "XJ^paV to yap " KaTevavTi" to Ofxomi eaTi.

ro yap Trapd^o^ov tovto eaTtVf ovg oi/K eiyev eK (pvaecog, tovtov^

airo Tojf Tov Qeov ^(cpeag Xa^elv.

Sethpianot. " KaT€vavT/ ov eviCTevaev" dvri evwiriov irpoa- 10

omov ov eiri(TTev<Te Qeov.
ToT ATTOT. To " KOTevavTi ov eTriCTevae 0eoi)," (feyjaiv, avTt

Tov 0T€ eirtaTevae tco Sew' eTrethyj yap '^taKeyofxevca irap wv eirt-

(jTevae to KaTCvavTi TedetKev. avTt tov ei$ Tpoirov Kat o<7t6 eirt-

(TTtva-ev, 15
OpirENOTS. OTTora (f>i^ai to. TroWa eOvy] yjv, wv redetKev av-
Tov iraTepan Tag eirayyeXiag avroi 'ti^ov? Qeoi' irept yap t«v
Qia t>?v dfxapTiav veveKpxfxevcov, wv yj rpvyji^ veKpd yeyevyjTo ev
acofxaTi ^avTt, otoftdit vvv avTOv Xeyetv " rpvy^yj yap yj dfxaprdvovaa
**
avTV} aTToQaveiTat" Ttva ^e Ta fxyf ovra^ yj 01 earepyifxevot toS 20
ovTog Kat fxy) fxeTeypvTeg avTov, oiJTca KaXovfxevot irpog dvTt^ta-

aToXyjv Twv fxeTeypvTccv tov e/VoWof " eycja eifxt cov." KaXei ^e
ra fxy] ovTa, tva viraKovaaatv avToig yapiayjTai to etvat. aXX
tacog Ttg irpog TavTa epei, ncog 6 AiroaToXog (pyjai fxeb erepa,

e^eAcgaTO vyeog Ta fxyj ovra, iva Ta ovra KaTapyyjayj ; aXX 25

evtyjXov wg eTepov eaTt tovto ay]fxatvofxevov tov ovTog koi fxyj

ovTog, oaov airo Traayjg T^f eKeiae airocpdaecog, ovTeg fxev yap ev-

6aoe ot KaTa crapKa ao(f>dt Kat "hvvaTot Kat evyeveig' fxyj ovTeg ^e

ot aXXcog irapd TovTotg ttaKetfxevot xg irpog ryjv €Keiva)v v7ro\yp\jtv.

T 8 ' O9 irap iKTriBa eV iXTriSL hriaTevcrev, 3°

Sethpianot. Ylap eXiri^a TVjg oiKetag (pvaecog, eXiri^t ri^g

Tov eirayyetXafxevov ovvdfxecog' to ^e " ovTcog eaTat to airepfxa

aov, ov fKovov Too irXyjSei, aXXa xat t^ XafXTrpoTVjTt.

QpirENOT2. Ev To3 KaTttXoyca twv yapiafxdTcov rcov ^t^ofxevcov

F
 M EHHrHSIS EI2 THN HPOS IV. 2 o

KaroL Tyjv avakoyiav ryjg Tnarfccg, KaTV)\€KTai Kai 17 jria-Tig. (pvjat

yap HavXog fxeO' erepa' " aXAco Ttiaiig ev Ta avTa rivey/xaT*.'*

S' avTOi (f^Yiai nai aXXayov' " oti airo Qeov vfji.iv e^/apiaByj, cv

" fjiovov TO eig HLpiaTOV TitaTevetv, aXXa to Kai virep avrov Ttaayeiv.

otfj.at ^e OTt Kai 01 ATroaToXot eXXetiiv] netaBevTeg eivat tvjv eK ^

Tov e(p y^uAv P TiiaTtv, ei Kat eK iriareag ovv 01 KXvjpovofJiot, Kat

yj eTtayyeXia^ iva Kara yaptv^ ov avryf 7] viarig v] irpo r^g

yaptrog Kaff y\v Xeyerat tta rovro eK Titarewg, iva Kara yapiv
yoopig yapiTog vcfjearavat ov tvvarai.

10 EtS' Se TT]V iirayy^Xiav tov Seov. 10

'OpirENOTS. Opa fx-^TTore wg " Al3paaft. Ttap eXttita eii
**. eXir;§i eittarevaevy^ ovt» Kat itavreg o't rrjg Ttiarettxg A/SpaafJi

vtot, Ttap eXiti^a eTt eXvitt itept itdvraiv marevovatv. etre Ttept

avaardaecog veKpwv, etre Ttept rov KX7jpovof*.rjaetv ^aatXitav ovpa-

vav v] PaatXeiav Seov. Tavra yap oaov eitt r-^ dvdpaTtivv] (pvaet 15

vap' eX^ni^a eartv' oaov oe eiti tco ^vvaroi rov Qeov Kat ralg
dxpev^eatv ettayyeXtaig avroVf eit eXTtt^t rav eK rov Tttarevetv
eX^t^ovrcov rvyydvei. Kat eTtentep Tttarevcov eit eXni^i ittarevei,

ttd rovro " fj.evet TtiaTig, eXTttg,^^ d<f) wv yevvaTat Kat ro rpirov

fjiei^ov TOVTCov vj aydttyf. Kat vofJ.i'C,ca aTotyetciiaecag fj^ev eyetv 20

Xoyov TV]v Tttariv' TtpoKOTtvjg Oe, rvjv eX^/Sa, TeXe/OTiyTo^ ^e rvjv

dydTtvjv. crt ^e ov Oia ro y^pag Xeyerat ro awf/ia tov ' A^padfL

veveKpci}ft.evov, ^^Xov earai tw eTitaTv^aavrt riva rpoitov itpoaQefj.evog

'APpadft. eXa/Se yvvaiKa Tovvofj.a yLerrovpav, Kat eieKev avrx

fnerd TV]v reXevrvfV ^dppag, r]rig e^v]aev ervj eKarov etKoattTtrd' 25

•npea^vrepog ^e rvjg "^dppag '^eKaervjg elpiaKerat aacfycicg

A^padft.. ei ovv ^ia tv]v eitayyeXiav, cng (fjaat riveg, enat^oTtoivjae

rov laaaK, itSig ycapig eitayyeXiag fj^era enarov eiKoatenrd erv)

ereKe rovg atto ^erTovpag. coare cv enaivQi Xeyerai v] roiavTTj

veKpcoatg rov rd fJ.eXy] rd htt Ti}f yvjg veKpcaaavrog" ore ydp rtg ^o
itvevfi.aTt rag Ttpd^eig rov aci}f/.aTog 6avaTo7, rore ajSevvvai itdaav

rvjv 7te(f)VKviav dvdTireaQat ev avTca Ttvpcoatv. coare tv]v tov ^laaaK

^ Aliquid credo excidit, dicturus erat de Apostolis a Domino nostra

incrementum fidei petentibus.
 V. I. PnMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. SS

yev€(Tiv fji.y) etvai avo Trvpwcxeag, aXX e^ eirayyeXiaf Seov. a^ioi

yap yeyovaai tt^v tovtov iiriypafpYjvai TraTpidpyov yovei^.

23 OvK iypa(f)r} Se 8l avrov fioifov, oti iXoyicrOr] avrw.

HpirENOTS. NtJv TO V avTov [xovoVf dWa Kai to ^i rjfJi.ai, 5

avTt Tov irept vjfjiSov ov yap iva ' Al3paafL (VTV)(pv 6 M»vcrea)«- irpo-

yevearepog toJ fA,eTayeve(TT€px avTOv ypafJif/.aTt (i}(f)eXyjdvj avrio etf

otKato<TvvYjv' aXKa Kai Ttep\ YjfAav oiovet npoava^jxavovVTog tov Xoyov

TVjv Xoyi(jByi<JofJi.evrjv e/c TttdTewg ttKatoffvvyjv ToTf TrtaTevovaiv evt

Tov eyeipavTa rov Y%.vpiov yjf/.Zv lyjaovv \pt(yTov eK veKpav. Ttpo^ryeg i o

eTiiff.eXedTepov fJii^TroTe fxovog Kat 7ra.<; TttuTevet " eTtt rov eyeipavra
**
lyj<Tovv rov Kvptov yjft.av Ik veKpav^^ (TvveyepQeig ^ptartf' war
av eiTTtiv " Kat cvvyjyetpe Koi (TvveKdBtcrev yffuai ev ro^ig eitovpavtotg

*' ev
X-ptcrrx'" avvy]yep6y] ^e Xp/CTTce 6 <TVfi.fiiop(f>og yevofi.evog TYf

ava<7Taaet avrov' Kai ^ia ro avvanoTeOv^Kevat (tv^Siv avroo' " ei 15

*'
yap avvairoBdvcoff.ev, Kai av^-^aofnev." avvdireBave ^e X^/<7tco, eTre*

Kat X-ptarog airoBavhv r^ dfiaprta aireQavev e<j> aira^' Kai avro^

aTroBaviov Tyj dfji.apTt(X, av^yj X.ptaTx' ^yj he X.ptaToi ev Katvoryjrt

^(oyjg TreptTrarav.

AnoAiNAPioT. Aviaryjat ft.ev rov eavrov vaav Kvptog' ey^- 20

yepKev oe avTOv YlaTrjp eK veKpwv^ coaTrep ra vdvra ^ta tov
^ai^Oif ovro} Kal tovto epyaadfxevog.

5".
KE4>.

' AiKaia^euTey ovif eK TriaTem — elSoTey otl 77 OXiyj/if^^

VTTOfjLOPrjv KaTepyd^eTai.

AnoAiNAPioT. Ay^ctiptarog rov Ylarpog T/o^, rrpoaayoft.evoi

rjfxdi irpoi eavrov, Kat rrj rrtaTet rrjv dytd^ovaav ydptv errt-

vetfA.ag, atrtoi yeyove rov irpoaayByjvat ©€w, avva<peiag airtos

rolq Oiearcoat Karaarag ^td rvjg avrov fjLeatreiag. vpog ft.ev rov^o
IJarepa r^ BeorrjTt avvrif/.fj.evog' iipog §e y^fj.dg Kard rriv dvQpw-
vorrjTa avva(p6etg. ooare oaovg Kara ro dvQp^airtvov irpoadyerat,
F 1
 36 EHHrHSIS EI2 THN nP02 V. i.

Tovrovg KaTo, ro OeTcv Trpoadyd 0ed5. karyjKevai oe 17/x.af elnibv

ejti rvjs Trpoaayovavjs ©coo '^apirog, eTTQiyei r^ Triaret ra Trepi

rrji (Xiritog' tuKvvg rvjv iiiariv, ag ev ryj irpog EjSpaiovs yeypa-

'*
Ttraiy eXTTi^ofxevccv ovaav vnoaraaiv Trpayfxarcov. Kai cf)V}aiv, ori

" Kav^afxeSa lii eXyri^i rYjg ^o^^g rov Qeov" Trpoa^oKciovrei ry^v^

Oeiav eTrafMpievvvaSai ^o^av, vj; rvnog [xev ev MwyV'^, aXi^Seia

^e ev 'Kpiar^' e^etKovia[j.Oi ^e eig yjfJiag. alria Se rvjg rotav-

ryjg a7:o^o6i^aoixevv]g Vjfuv ^o^Y,gy vj itapovaa y^ap^g' coaTiep yap rtq

reyyirviq eiaotKi^o[J.evog eig vjfxag ro Ilvev[Jia ro Ayiov, y^apaKrvj-

pi^et vvv Kat [j.opcpoH itpog o[A.otorr,ra 'Kpiarovy ^i aiioKpvcpm evep- ro

yetZvf fJt-txP^ ''fp *^ et^oTTotvjOev Kat entreXeaBev, ro orav eKXa[t.\pvj

*'
Kara rvjv eirttpdveiav rov Har^pog, vjg ladvvvjg \eyet, a^eXfpot,

" vvv reKva Seov eafnev, Ka) ovttoo ecpavepadvj rt eao(J.e6a' ot^a[xev

" ort eav (pavepaQ^, o[J.otot avrw eao[Jie6a."

MeydXv} Be vj t^<" eXiti^og ^e(3atori^g ruv v]^i^ Kavy(a[j.eva)v w? 15

Ttapovat roHg [j,eXKovai. Kav~/vjatv yap eit aya6ch ^e^atwg vitap-

yovrt ytverat' Kai avrvj vjv vj [j.aKapia Kavyvfatg, vjv Ttpocpi^rvjg

'\epe[t.tag elaviyeHrat' *'

/x*; Kavyda6<ji^^ keywv, " vXovaiog ev

" Tftj 'TtXovrco avrov, dkk ev rovrw Kavyda^ca Kavya[j.evog,

** avvteh Kat ytvaaKetv rov Kvptov," Kat ra e^vjg. Kat ovy ori 20

Ttovot (pvjat Kat 6ktrpetg itdpetat, tta rovro rvjv eitt roig v}^ovatv

dya6oTg Kavyvjatv a[(.(3Kvvo[J.ev, Kat ravrvj fiaXXov ert Kavya[j.e6a

avvatrtov r^g tcSv dyaSav ditoXavaeiog, ei^oreg rvjv rm itovwv

vTto^LOvvjV. '^ta yap 6Xi}pe(t)g vTtoft.ovv] avviararat' 6 ^e vito^j.etvag,

'^OKtfj.og. te '^OKtfj.og Ttapa Seco yevofj.evog, eXiti ^et eyetv ra itapa 25

©eov. ^e ekniaag eig Seov, ovk alayyv6Yjaerat. evtoKet yap ev

Toig eXTti^ovaiv eiti ro eXeog avrov. avvatrta apa rSov eXTtt^o-

[j.ev(ov aya6S)V vj SXtxptg, ytverai o^v)yog eitt rvjv eXTtt^a KaStara-

fj.evvi' da^akvj te t*/v ekTtida heiKvvatv ovaav ent tov viyaTtv\Kora

^fidg Qeov ytvoft.evv]v. rvjg Se dydnvjg reK[t.Yjptov t>jv tov Yivev-i'^

[xarog htopedv' e^€yee ydp ecf> vjfndg rv]v dydiivjv ro at[j.a

eKyeag. e^eyee te Ttpovjyoufnevcog ro Ilvev[Jia 1 evcoKiaeV cog Kat

avrog ^corvjp keyet' " ort itap V[j.Tv [j.evet' Kat avv v)[j.Tv earaiJ"

ft Aliquid deesse videtur,

 V.5. P12i\IAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 87

^ Xptsostomot. T/ eartv " eip^V7]v ej^aj/xev ;'' rtve^ (f)aatv, oji

fjLV] t^ cTaaidi^a[j.€v uaayayeiv. ffxot he ^0Ke7 Tiept jroXiTetag

y)fuv XotTTOv htaXeyeaBat. enet^yj yap iroAXa irept icKJTeaig oia-'

XeyPttg Kai Tvji dia t^v epyccv ^iKatoavvv]^ avTYjV TrpovSvjKev, iva
*'
lAVjTii vofJLiaYj paBvfxiag VTToSeat^ eivat ra Xeyofxeva (pvjatv et- 5
*'-»/3)yv>jv ej^cujaev" TovreaTiv, iJ.vjKeTi diJ.apTa.vwfj.ev, fi.vj ^e irpoi to.

TipoTepa eTTavepyji}fJ.etja tovto yap eari irokefj.ov e^/eiv irpos tov

Seov. Ka\ Tiw^ ^vvaTov (f)Vjaif to fxviKeTt dfnapTdveiv ; TrSos to

TipoTepov eyeveTO ^vvaTOv ; e; yap ToaovTwv ovTeg virevBvvoi, iiav-

T!cv dTtvjKXdyvjfiev ^ia tov Xp/CToy, ttoAXoS fj.aXXov ev olg eafxev, \o

fA.eivat ^t avTOv tvvYiaofj.eBa' ov ydp eaTiv iaov fJ.v) ovaav etp-^vvjv

Xa(3eiv, KOLt ^o6e7aav KaTaayeiv. eiiet^vpiep vj KTVjaig TVjg <pvXa-

Kvjg yaXeiiWTepov. dXX^ Ofj.wg yeyove to yaXenwTepov evKoXov, Kai

e/V '<£pyov e^e^vf ovkovv eaTat Kai to evKoXwTepov vjfxh evKaTop-

BwTov, dv eywfxeOa Kat eKeiva vjfj.h ^vvKOTeg. evTovBa ^e ov to 15

evKoXov atviTTeaBat fj.01

^0Ke7 fxovov, dXXa Kat to evXoyov. ei yap
ai/Tog yj[j.dg Kar-^XXa^e TioXefj.wfj.evovg, evXoyov fxevetv eiii TOig

KaTaXXayeiai, Ka\ TavTY^v dn^ovvat avTW ty^v dft.ot(3vjV, iva fj.r]

^o^vj cKaiovg Kat dyvwfxovag KaTVjXXayevai tw ' HaTpi.

5 "^Otl 7} ayain) tov GeoO iKK€)(yTaL eV Talf KapSlais 20

'AnoAiNAPiOT. *0 ^e Xeyet toiovtov eaTtv. et yap vnep dv-

hpog evapCTOv ovk dv Ttg eXotTO layewg a-noBaveh, evvovjaov tov

teanoTov tvjv dydnviv, otov f*.vj vvep evapeTWV avTog, aXX vnep
dfxapTwXwv Koi lyBpwv (patveTat aTavpwBetg. 25
'OpirENOTS. ''Ottoi; ju,ev daBeveig vj dfxapTwXovg ovofxd^ei, Kai

kavTOv Toig ToiovTotg efJ.TieptXafj.^dvei. onov oe Xeyet aae^eig,

ovKeTt' Koi Tdya eiKOTwg vno tov vofxov wv, b^ vjaBevet ^ia Tvjg

aapKOg, daBevvjg fxev eaTi KOLt dfj.apTwXog^ ov [j.v)v Kai KaTa tvjv

avvYjBeiav TVjg ^iaaToXvjg twv ypa(f)wv, Kai daef^eig XeyovTWV tc«Iv3o

**
vno vofxov dfxapTavovrwv tc5 Qew' Kat yap eav dfxapTavwfxev, aoi
^'
eafxev, ei^oTeg aov to KpdTog'' dae^eig ^e TOTe 01 vofxi^ofxevot eivai

r Desunt plura ut opinor. * In marg. oi/t&i< Qiwpv^KaKTOi.

 5

m EHHrnSIS EI2 THN nPOS V. II.

VTTO Tov vofJiOVf Tvy^dvovaiv' t-nav eyKaTaXtnovreg tov Qeov toJv

vaTepwVf ^YITOvcTi Tovi Beovi twv iBvwv. irpiv ^e iipoaiXBuv yjfxag

9€0<Tej3eia, ayaTrvj ev Yjfxh ov trvveiOTi^Ket' iravTa yap fxakXov yj

©eov dyaiiwfJi.ev. OTe be toiovtcov yjfxcov virap-^^ovTWv, 'KpiaTog VTrep

vjixwv dneOave, tot€ avveaTfj Kai VTTeary} ev yjfxlv yj tov ^eov ayaitri^ 5

•ndvTm TrepiatpeSevTcov tw tov Iyjctov OavaTW a<fi yjfxSiv txv efxiro-

^t^^ovTWV Tij av(7Td<Tei TYjg eig yifxdg tov %eov aydiiy]?. Kara Tav-
TYjV ovv T7JV tf^yriciv tov " avviaiY^civ^ aKovaTeov, avvKJTavTog

Kat vcpiaTdvTog toD Seov ev Yjfx7v tyjv eavTOv ayd-nYjV, tyjv ovhevog

€Tepov Kvptag, Y] avTOv tov Qeov Tvyyavovaav. 10

ToT ATTOT. Ov yap fxovov TY^v dSdvaTQV ^coYjV avafxevofJLfVf ak\a
Kai KaTO. Tov TtapovTa (3iov, ccg npoaotKetctjGevTeg Tca Qeca aefxvv-

vofxeBa To. KaTo, tov ^eaTroTY]v KptoTov Koy 1^0 fxevoi, og fxeaiTvjg

Yjfxav yevofxevog, tyjv etpi^vi^v eirpayfxaTevaaTO.

1 1 Ov fxovov 5e, aXKa koll Kav^cofxevoL iv ra Oew. 1

'Ancntmon. To **
ov /Aovov," Tiepi TV]v twv iipoeipYjfxevaiV tipYf-

Tai diro^ei^iv. Bapaeiv yap ndpeaTt, (fyfjai, Kai TaviY) itepi twv

eipYjfxevoov, ^ KavywfxeOa ev toj Qeco tia lyjaov 'KptaTov. eiai oe

^vvdfLeig xai '^apiafxaTa twv lafxaTCtiv, dg eirtTekovvTeg 01 Ano-

aTokoif TriaTtv tw KYjpvyfxaTi irapef^^ovTO fxeydXYjV' KaXS>g ^e to 20

KavyYjf>.a enrev ey^eiv ev tcS Sew '^ia tov Kvp/ct» Yifxm Itjctou

Kpta-cov. ot /xev yap e^ epycov vofxov Tt KTcnfxevoi, e<p eavTov

ej^etv e'ipY]Tai to Kavyvifxa' 0/ ^e Ik TrtaTecot, lYjaov KpiaTov
^iKatovfxevoi, ev t'2 Sew to Kavyvifxa eyovai' tw ^cDpovfxevco ^ia

\Y]aov yiptaTov Ta irXovaia yaptafxaTa twv tafxaTcav, appajSwv 25

TvyydvovTa T^g fxeXXovaYfg 'yapdg. TrtaTOTrotenat Yjfxdg Kat TVjg

opyY]g pv6Y]aofxevovg ^id tov Kvpiov Yifxwv Ivjaov KpiaTov, Kai

aciiBY]aofxevovg ev tyj ^coy] avTOv. avTO ^e roi^To Kai TYjg irpog tov

Seov KaTaXkayY]g aY]fx€iov eivat ti vnep dfxapTcaXwv airoTeQvr]-

Kevat, ov TrdvTcov, <pY]aiu, avBpcoTtcav aaefBwv TvyyavGVTCov. ov yap ^o

APpaafL, Y] 01 '7rpo<pY]Tai y] 'ndvreg 01 Kara vofxov iroXiTevadfxevot

aaejSeTg. aXXa twv fxev cag dfxapTcaXm, Tcav Ve Kat cag daej3cav'

tva irdg fxev aaePrjg Kat dfxapTcaXog y], ov fXY]v TovvavTiov eTtt nXeiov

fxev Y] dfxapTta' y] Se daejSeta eir eXaTTOv' Kat "htd tovto Kai

V. II, Pi2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. S9

Anoo^ToXo^ ev irpcoTOif etprjKwg ^piarov vTrep dcrelSiiv aTroreQvrj-

Kevai, vuTepov e7rwiop6ov[xevo(; eavTOv, to xaSoXtKOv eirfiTrei. a<Te~

/3cSv ovv (f)y}<Ti Tav cflvwv, ov {j-yjv tq HaBoXiKOv TavTt] triXovrai'

aXk ev Tu> enreh' " eri yap afxapTaXxv ovtxv yijxSiv, 'K.ptcnog

" VTiep Yj^m «Treflave'" to vnep irdvTwv avTOv diroTeBwjKevai ^rj-^S

XovTai aacfiSii- evTavda.

AXX ei Kat TovTO Tig Trapa^e^aiTOf. 0>jc7<, TriOavac eiprjfxevov,

Ttoog ovK av eTTi^YjTriaeuv, Tiva Tponov dfxapTwXog av XeyoiTO

opBxg APeX, Kat vir avTov tov Kvpiov hiKaiog KeKXrjfxevog ;

7] ai) (xeTaTeBetg tov y^ Ittelv BdvaTOv 'Evwj^; ^ ot Xoino] irdv- lo

Teg, ot viro Trjg 6eta<; ypaKprji •^Yi(xaTi(javTeg " av ovk yjv d^iog o
'*
Koafxog ;
'
(pafxev ovv, t»v dfJiapT-^^ft.dTav, to, fxev KaTa ^idvotav

eivai fLQvoV Ta oe Kai elg evepyetav ep^^eTai' tc ydp u.Y)^e fkey^ig

ev$vfi.r]Teci)g Xoytaa7$ai to irovrjpov, Trjv rjfxeTepav Kxag eKire-

<f)evye ^vvafLiv' Ta f>.ev ovv eig evepyetav r^KovTa, t^v TraXatdvi^

vofiLr^ofxev eTrfjearjfxeiauQat ypacfjrjv' Ta ^e fxe^/jiig evOvfxrjae(ag, r]

Kai TYjv YjfLerepav eKcpevyovTa ^tdvotav, d ^yj Kpv(pia mofkaaev o

Aa^t^, ovK Yj^iioaBat wrovoovfxev ev aiTiag fxepet TeBetuBtxt, Kai

oXag avayeypacpSat, Kat taccg ov toc evQvfnrjfiaTa eKptvev o VQff.og,

aXXa Ta a-TTOTeXeafi.aTa, d Kat rjXeyy^ovTO ofxoXoyetv dv&pcoTroi' 20

Kav yap vofxog *'
ovk eiriBvfx-^aeig'^ Xeyei, ov tyjv eiriBvf/.tav, dXXa
TO TavTYjg airoTeXeafxa Kpivei. Kat lacog TavTYj irdvTeg rifxapTov,

tcai vaTepovvtai Trjg ^o^rjg Ttt) Qeov, '^iKatovfxevoi ^copedv Tr] aviov
XdptTi ^id Trjg diroXvTpaaecog Trjg ev ^ptaTW 'it^aov' U)g fxrj fxovov

TOv Ta aToira f))f\ rrpdaaetv Ovvafxtv KeKTrjaBat, dxxd Kat tov fxrj 25
evBvfxeHaOat Ta cf>avXa. ov yap av eireTaaaev Irjaovg, **
eppeSrj,'^

Xeym, **
^0?? dpyatotg' eyw ^e Xeyco vfxh, irdg efx(3Xeiroov

** yvvatKt vpog to eTri6vfi.yjaai avTvjv, rj^rj efxotyet^aev avTYiv ev t^

*'
Kaphia ayTou.'* Kai irtpi (ftovov Kai TrXrjyoov coaavTCog Kat tcov

irapaTrXrjaictiv. 3*^

T»v ovv fxoyOrjpav evBvfxrjaecov KaBapevetv (3ovXofX€vog Tovg eav-

Tov ft.a6rjTdg, ^vvafitv avTotg eveSi^Kev dvaardg €k veKpcov t>;v tov

Ayiov JJvevfxaTog "xdpiv, tov fxr] dvafSatvetv eirt Tag Kap^^iag
avTCOv evBvfiLi^aecov (f)aVTdafxaTa' Kai TavTri kcu virep tcov df/i.ap-
40 ESHrHSIS E12 THN HPOS V. il.

TcyAcSi' aTredavev, iva Kai tov^ toiovtov; Kai Toy? oXtyta TrpoTBfv

€ipyj[j.(vov$ OdvaTOi avTov KaSapevay], TtiaTfivovTag 6<f tov 6ava-

Tov «yToy Kai (k; ti^jv iK veKpav avaiTaiiv. tovto (pavepcoTepov o

'AttoVtoAo? (^•^X.aatv ev t^^ Trpoi E^ecriovg \eycov, " oi avbpeg

" dyaTiaTi rag havTwv yvva^Kag, KaBoig Kai o X.ptarTOi lyyaTnjcrf 5

** 'EKKXvjalav, Kai eavTOV iiape^xKev vnep avT^i, iva avTVjv

T>;v

*'
dytd(TYi, KaBaptaag tw XovTpco tov voaTog ev pi^u.aTt." eha
(SovXofxevog ^iaTd^at Ttg dytavfxog, eTTiXeyei ypd^pwv, " iva irapa-

'*
(TTrjaifi avTOg eavTco eu^o^ovp^rjv EiKKXyja-tav, fxy] ey^ovaav (jitikov,
" ri pvTtta, rj ti tccv TOtovTm' aKk tva yj dyia Kai af/.(i)fx.og'^^ Kat 10

tid TovTo ovtetg KeyeTai TeTeKetwdbat, irpo tov tov K.vptov itaBovTa,

Kai Twv ToiovTcov (TTTiKwv Kai pvTi^cov KaSdpdiov yevea6ai tov ye-

vovg rjfA.av.

KE<I>. Z.

Tlfpl flaayayyrjs tov irpos croiTrjpiav fjpSiv avBpamov Irjcrov XpicrTov avrl tov •
5
Tr«r6vT0s e| apxrjs yrjy^vovs 'ASa/i.

Ktpiaaot. 'O Kvptog yj[xav Ivj^rovg \ptaTog tvjv a^tdyaaTov

dKfjBig Tov Beov Kat OaTpo^ dydTir\(Jtv, %v eig rjixdg eTtehet^aTo,

KaBtaTag evapy^q, Trjg fxeTa crapKOg otKOVofxtag to itepag Kai to

eiTi t£ (XTavpw TcdBog TrapeKOfxt^ev eig dTto^ei^tv, w^e nrj Keycov' 20

**
ovTct) yap rjydirrjaev Qeog tov KOafxov, coaTe tov Tiov avTov
'*
Tov fxovoyev^ etoiKev, iva Tidg TriaTevccv eh avTOv [x,ri diroKKrj-
**
Tat, aKK ej^ij ^covjv a/ft)v;ov." e^ccKe yap Seog aKrjBwg virep rjfxwv

Tov i^iov Tiov. eKKeKvT pwiJ.eBa ^c yjfJi-c^g, aTrvjKKdyfJieBa Bavdrov

Kai dfJiapTiag' ov ydp eKaTepov Ttvog ydptv yeyove adp^ Aoyog, 25

Kai eaKTjvcciaev ev rjfuv' Kai iva tov TYjg aapKog BdvaTOV dvaTKag,

6ptaft.j3evar] fxev apyag Kat e^ovatag' Karapy^arj §e Kat avTOV

Tov TO KpdTog e^ypvTa tov BavdTov, TovTeaTi tov SaTavav, Ka\ dveKrj

fxev TVjv <p6opav, ditoaTrjar] te avv avTvj Kai t^v Ka& rjfx,wv Tvpav-
vvjaaaav afxapTiav, aitpaKTOV Tf ovTCng aitocf^^^vrj Kotitov t^v dp- 30
yatav eKetvrjv apav, vjv vj tov dv6pci)Ttov (pvatg V7teft.etvev ev 'A^a/A,
ctig ev aitapyri tov yevovg, Kai wg ev pi^rj Trf TtpcoTr}.
 V. 13- PiiMAI0T2 Eni2T0AHN. 41

Ylapa^ag yap t*?v evToXyjv 6 'ASajU., irpoa-KiKpovfce tw hrj-

fxiovpyx. TavTfj toi yeyove Kai eTiapaTog Kai SavaTCp KaToyoq. oA,o-

TpoTtag te aiioXwXoTai KaTeXey]<T€ irakiv o tSov oAwv 0€0"5roT>jf.

Kad-^KCTO yap e^ ovpavSrv 6 T/of avieig eyKk-^fxaTo, QiKaiav ev

TTiaTei Tov a(Tt(3Yj, ^eTayaXKevwv wg 0eo$ t^v avBpairov cf)vatv eig 5

a(f)Bapcn.av, Kai avaKOfxi^av eig to aTrap^^g' " Kaiwi yap KTi(7ig

Ta ev XptcTw, OTt Kat piga TeOetTat Katvv]. yeyove oe Kat

^evTepog A^afx' Kai ov)(^ (oairep eKcTvos opy-^g irapaiTiog Kat airo-

cTTpo(p>Yj<; TYjg avioBev ToTg e^ ayTOU yeyovo(Jt' Trpo^evoq ^e fxaWou

Kat ^oT^p TTji "npog ev otKetOTYjTog ^t <xytacrfj.ov tc Kat acpBapaiag, 10

Kat TYjg ev irtcrTei ^tKaio^rvvYjg. TOVTa YjfiTv (70(f>og e^yjyehat

YlavXog ^ia TY}g npoKetfJLevYjg p-^aecog. ovkovv " &><• §i evog avQpo}-
'* **
TTOV," (f^Yjatv, Yj afi.apTia etg tov Koafi.ov eiaYjABe, Kat ^ta, TYfg

**
af/iapTiag 6 BavaTog ^iYjXBev, e(f) w TroivTeg YjfnapTov." eicre^v fiev

yap, (t)g e(f)Yjv, tta t^^^ afuxpTtag BavaTog ev tc5 irpcoTovXdaTCi) Kat 15

ev Tyj Tov yevovg apyY]' etTa oXov e^e^^f KaT&tefi.-^BYj to yevog.

aXXa Kot TYjg afuapTtag evpcTYjg ^paKwv tayvaag ev A^a/x ToTg

TVjg (f)avXoTY}Tog Tpoirotg PaTYjV ^ Yjpyaarat ttjv avBpcjOTrov ttdvotaV

TrdvTeg yap e^eKXivaVf afna yjypetcoBYjaav. eK irpoaamov '^yj ovv

yeyovoTeg Toy Ylavayiov Seov, ^tdToi to €Tttfi.eXS)g eyKeTaBat tyjv 20

dvBpwTiov ttdvotav eiri t« TrovYjpa Ik veoTYjTog, dXoyaTepov tte^cofxev

/3iov. Kat Kaieirtev jaev BdvaTog tayvaag, (ag 7rpo(pT^TY}g (f)Y]atv'

** ^vyYjv avTov, Kat to

eirXdTvve b^e Ka\ ' At^Yjg tyjv ttYivot^e

**
aTOfxa avTov tov fjjti haXtTreTv.^' eTret^vj yap TYjg ev A^a/x ira-

pa^daewg yeyovafkev fi.tfJi.Y}Tatf KaBo irdvTeg Y}fj.apT0Vf TaTg taatg 25

eKeivio VtKatg VTrevevYjyfi.eBa' dXX ov fj.eff.evY}Kev dveTriKovpvjTog

Y} wrovpavov' KaB-^pvjTat yap yj dfLapTta' veirTooKev SaTavaf*

KaT^pyYjTat ^e Kat BdvaTog.

13 "^XP^ y^P ^OfioVf oifiapTLa r)v iv Kocr/xa>.

Ktpiaaot. 'O vofjLog ^ta Mwvaewg, eXeyyog >jv, eog e<^v, T^fS*^

Tftjv TrTaiovTcov daBeveiag, ov XvTtKog dfxapTiag, KaTepyd^eTo Se

fjMXXov opyY}v. Y]v yap avdyKY] Tovg irapa(3aivovTag TaTg ev vo/*.co

^t(t}ptaft.evatg vvo<pepeaBat ^tKatg. ov §e ^y] oXoog irapaPdaeoog Tpo-

8 Sic.

G
42 EHHrHSIS EIS THN nP02 V. 13.

TTOi, eKet iiov TravTcoi kui afxapTia. Kai iiirep eariv afxapria

6avajov Trpo^evosy •nafra weof avdyKV] (TvveppwaQai Xeyeiv avTvj Kai

Tov e^ avTvjg dva^pevTa^ BdvaToV KaSvjpvjfxevyj re TravTcog cvyKaTO.'-

aeiecjBai' Kai old nep l^ia (xvvtioXkvcrQai fJ.y]Tpi. riv ovv a.-)(j>i vofxov

afKapTia^ (pYjaiv^ ev Koi7ft.w KeifJ.evov yap eTi tov vofLov, Kai ra^
TYjg Trapa/Saaewg eyKXrffxaTa Kajd twv TiTaiovTCDV eKpaTVveTO'

dpyovvTog Se >;^v;, TreTtavTai avv avT'2 tov irapaPaiveiv vj ypacpvf.

Tieiiavfxevrig te t^$ dfxapTlag, wg ecpi^v, avff.neTtavaeTai Kai

BdvaTog.

ToT ATTOT. AAA ei TovTO Tiva TpoTtov (paifi Tig aVf KaTeKpd- 10

TTjcre Tav em TYjg yrjg Kai Ttpo vofxov OdvaTog.

ToT ATTOT. E< yap Kai Tiveg ov yeyovaai Taig tov vofxov

itapa^daeaiv evoy^oi, ^idToi to fk-^Ttd) Te6e7a6ai tov vofxov, dXk

VTteovaav Kai avTOi tvjv (l)6opdv eTti toj Oft.oioofii.aTt Trjg Ttapa^d-
aeccg ^A^dft.' Ofxotov ag el Xeyot TV)(pv, eittTpe^^ovTog tov 6avdT0v 15

Ka6 OfLotOTriTa T-yjv ASa^ to ef avTov itdv yevog, waitep (pvTov

7ta6ovTog /3Xa/3og etg pi^av, itdad 7t!og dvdyKV] Tovg e^ avTov

yeyovoTag fxapaivea6at KXZvag' TVTtov ye ^avjv avTOV tov ft.eXXov-

Tog eivat (prjai, TovTeajt HptaTOv' Kanot itapayeyovoTog r^r] Kat

TTJg fxeTa aapKOg olKovofxiav ^taitepdvavTog to fxvaTrjptov' Ttag 20

ovv fkeXXovTa KaXeH ', (pairj Ttg dv tacog' 7tapa6etg yap rjfuv tov

TtpwTOV avdpcoitov, Kai twv jrjg •napa^daecog '^iafxvrjfKOvevaag Kat-

puiv, (tig fxeT avTovg itapeaofxevov Te Kat eayaTOv A^af*. mofxaae
Tov ^ptaTOV' TtpoccptaTo fxev yap ag ev 6eXrjaet t€ Kai Ttpoft.rj6eta

Tov ©eov Kat YlaTpog, acoT^^p t€ kou XvTpmrfg. eTte^pave te Kai- 25

potg lOtotg Kad ovg rjaeXrjaev OvvaaTrjg ovTOt Oe etatv 01 ev

eayaTotg Kat oiov evt ^vaft.aig tov TiapovTog aiuvog. ovkovv Tedet-

Kag etg Tvitov tov TtpaTov ro ^evTepov, fxovovovyj Kat ttaTivv6dveTat

Tov aKpoaft.evov, ag ev VTtoartyft,^ re Kat epwTrjaet Xeycov Ta e^rjg.

Fennaaiot. TavT-^g rjfuv (pyjat Trjg ev tovtco tc3 KoafJico ^cu^f 30

T^g dfxapTeiv Te koi diioBaveiv eitt^^eyofxevrig, Kai "^td tovto Kat

vofi.ov oeofxevrjg etKOTCog Toy TVjv dft.apTiav VTto^etKvvvTog tc Kai

artayopevovTog, vjp^e itpaTog 'A^a/A, «tc TtpcoTog Kat yevofxevog

Kat Ttapavofxvjaag. twv cvv e^ avTOv KaTa ^ta^oyag TtKTOft.evcov,

* Sic fors. leg. avutpvvra.

 i

V. 13- PilMATOTS EniSTOAHN. 43

TravTig d7te6n]<7Kov wg etKCn; tov itpoTraTopog K\v]povofx.ovvT€g T-fjg

(ftvcr^oDg' aWa twv aTioBvY}(7KQVTm tovtccv o/ fxev §/' wv Kai avToi

TrapYjvofjiovv, yjTreiyovTO tco BavaTX' ol t\ ^ia fxovi^v tov Aoa/A t>;v

KaTaKpKTiVy oiov yj Tav vrjiriav fJ.€pig' B/a t&vto vvv fxev (pvjaiv eig

TrdvTag dvQpcoTrovg eia^XBev o BdvaTog, e(p ii irdvTeg vjfjiapTov' avTi 5

Tav TToAXSv Xeyvv Tovg itdvTag (oajrep avTOig " fceTa TOVTa' ** 6/

" yap Tw Tov evog TiapaTnwfLaTi oi iioKXoi aiteQavov, rovg vok"

Xovg dvTi Tm TrdvTWv (pvjo^i' " vvv ^e e^acrikevaev 6 OdvaTog aito

" 'A^a/ix /W-ej^* MoJO-fCtJf, Kai eiti Tovg fjir] dfJ.apT-^aavTag'^^ oi

yap ovTe Ttpd^eag, ovre ^iaKpntK^g "Ttpoatpecrecog ovreg evTOg, itwg lo

av eUv vitevdvvot TtXrifj.fx.eXYifKaT ; ro Ve dy^t vofJLOv dfiapTta yjv ev

KO<TfJiW, TOIOVTOV e<7TtV.

'O fuiKdptog YlavXog aito Tav KaTa \pt(TTOV TtoXXdKtg •rjfxTv

^iaXeyeTat' a>g fneTa Trjv cfyavepaatv tov '^VT^pog, ovKeTi TVjg

TtaXalag KpaTovcTtig aXXa T^f Katvyfg KaTacTaaeajg. ev fxev ovv 15

Tyj TtaXaia (rapKtKOig ovaiv rjft.h Kai vitoKetfJ.evotg ft.a6T^fi.aaiv,

dvayKatav eivat t>;v ^ocr<v tov voff.ov avve^aive Tatg twv Ttf/.(a-

piuv aTteiXalg avaKOTtTovTog vjfnav TVjg <}>v(Texg Tag itpog tvjv

dfiapTtav opfjidg' Katvo^ig Se yevofJ.evoig ev Xp/o-Toj Kat ttKatoig,

TOVTedTt TVjv tia TVjg dfJMpTiag TtaXataxriv enite')(^of>.evotg ovKeTi, 20

*'
TteptTTOg itavTditaatv vofnog eaTt. '^id tovto Xeyei, ttKat^a

*'
vofJiog ov KeiTai' Kat vft.elg ovk ecTTe vito vofi.ovJ'^ dta Totvvv tov
" ayjpi yap vofJ.ov dfxapTta rjv ev Koaf/.w'^ tovto Xeyet, OTi ea)g ov

(pvcrecog r]ff.ev (rapKiKrjg tc Kat '7ta6rjTiK'^g, Kai ^ia tovto wto vofJ.ov

elvai '^(j^rj^ov^Trjg, Trj dfj.apTt(t, KaTeKpaTovfie6a' TtoXiTevofj.evr}g av- 25

TYjg ev tSo KO(Tfj.(ji itavTt' dvatpeBevrog fxevTOi tov vofnov, oia to

TtvevfJ.aTiKovg yevofj.evovg itpog ^iKaKoaiv rjfJ.dg ev \ptaT^ fj.eTeX-

Beh, avvavrjprjTat Kat rj dfxapTia. ov yap eXXoyeiTai Xotvov, ft.r]

ovTog vofj.ov.

'O TOivvv avfXTtag, cog av ev Ke<paXai(ii> Tig entoi, Trjg pi^aeoog Tay-30
Tr]g voy^- oyTOf eaTi. itapeyet itdaiv rjfuv rj KaTa 'KptaTOv 'ydpig,

TO ^e^aKcg avTr\ TteittaTevKOTag Kavxjda^at. Kat ^ia tovto oti

ov^ev diteiKog, dXXa Kai a(f}0^pa ye evXoyov dp^at tovtov vifj.7v

rvjg dBavdrov Kat '^tKaiag ^(ovfg' ov Tpoitov r]p^ev rjfnSiv to rtporepov

^ Leg. €v Tor?.

G 2
 5

44 EHHFHSIS EI2 THN HPOS V. 13.

'A^afx ryjg (pdapT^g re Kai naBriTiK-qi. e/ yap eKeivca TTTaiaavTi

Kai KaraKpiQivTi T^XevTyj, ol /x€t' avTOv e| avTov KeKcivcovyjKafxev

aTravT€$i 01 /Aev, Kai avTO 7rpo(7€(pafJiapTdvovT€g to irapavofxetv' 01

Se aTTO fnovyji KaTa to a-vyyeveg Trjg €k€ivov KoXaaeag' Ttag ovk

dvTippvjTov Tco * Kai TW SecTTroTTj yipioTw kaTa to avOpaiiivov iroXi-S

T€vaa[Ji€viJi Kai KaTopSaaavTi Kai KOixiaaix€va) jtACTa ttjv €K V€Kpm

dvdaiaaiv tvjv dfj.€ivova Xyj^iv. '^id tovto yap, (pyjatv, avTOv

Seog vTrepvxpwaev Toiig €vov[ji.€vovg avTW ^id 7rtaT€cog, Kat Ka-

Ta^iov[X€vovg Tyjg tov Y\v€Vfji.aTog evoiK-^aecog, tov itpooTOv avTOv

lK€tvov lyeipavTog €k V€KpSiV, Kotvuveh avTa t^? aKYjpdTov ^coijj, 10

avTi aapKiKcov ytvofi.€vovg TTvevfnaTtKovg.

'AAA' **
€(3aaiX€va€," cpyjatv, " OdvaTog diro A^df/. f-^XP^
" Mwaeag, Kat ctt; Tovg dfJLapTyjaavTag eiii rco ofj.oto}fxaTt TVjg
f*.yj

'*
TrapajSdaeiog 'A^a/A." «vt/ Toy, Ka6' ov Tpomv napa^e/SyjKOTog
'A^flCjOt, SdvaTog €(3aaiX€va(v, ovtco Kai tZv e| avTOv fx€T avTOV 1

y€voft.€voov, y]fi.apTyjKOTCov t6 Ka] ovy^ y}fi.apTy}KOTav Of*.otcog. to 0€

" fJ-^y^^i Mco(7ea>$-" TavTOV laTt to dy^pt yap vofJ.ov' Mctxreot yap
vvv, ovK tttKthg TO npoaconov tov dvlipog, dXXa to Tipdyff.a (pyjaif

Tov vofJ.ov €K Tou voft.oS€Tov KaXcoV ovTco Kat €V T^ Tipog KopivBtovg

**
€cog dvayivcoaKyjTat Mcocr^j"," TovTeaTtv vofii.og 6 ota Mce»<7ecof 20

^oSeig, og caTi Tvirog tov fxkXXovTog. eTvirovTo oe dpa, (pyjatv, €v

ToHg Ttep) Tov 'A^ajtx, Kat Trpo^teypdcpeTO Ta /AeTcn-f/Ta y€vy]aoft.€va'

TovTa 'tyj Ta KaTa tov Kvpiov yjfj.m lyjaovv ^ptaTOv, (Oei yap
**
'iacog yeveaOai tov fiev itpcioTOV dvdpcoTtov Adafi. etg ^v^^yjv ^aaav,
" Tov ^e eayoTOV 'A^a^, elg itvevf^a ^coonotovv." eTteihyj yovv, 25
'*
ff.€v TtpcoTog dvGpconog ^A^dfn eK yvjg '/oiKOg, ^e ^evTepog
" dv6pco7tog Kvptog e^ ovpavov^^ dvdyKy] " «aTot f/.ev tov yotKOv

- " etvat Tovg yoiKovg' KaTa ^e tov eitovpdvtov Tovg eitovpavtovg.

**
K(xi waTtep €(pop€aafj.€V TYfv eiKOva tov yoiKOv, ovtco ^^Ttov Kai tyjv

**
eiKova TOt) eitovpaviov (popeaofnev." dKoXovScog €K tcov viio^eeaTe- ^o
pcov ava^i^a^Ofj.€voi itpog Ta vitdpyovTa.
AlOAQPOT. WpoetTtaV OTt €711 TVJ dfXapTt(l TOV Ahdft., €711 T^
a7to(paa€t tov Oavdvov Kat ot XotTtoi TtdvTeg yjfi.apTov, 7tiaT0VTai. oti
**
yifxapTov, €K Tov eTtdyetv' OLypi yap vofxov dfxapTKX yjv ev Koafxw."

t Aliquid excidit hic.

V. 13- PilMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 46

fjivj yap vofJ.KTViTe, (priaiv, oti ovk yjv afxapTta €cyf tov vofxov tov
yiujaaiKov. el ^e eveAo-ye/Vo afjiapTta avGpaTToii, rjv yap Kai eve-

XoyfiTo, €iT€i Kai vofxog ojv •nolov ovv vofJLOv efJi(l>aivei ; tov <f)vai-'

KOVf Kad ov KivovfJ.e6a ^iaKpivovTeg to. ^eXTiova Kai to. y^etpova'

nept ov vof/.ov >j^07 ecpYjaev, " OTav yap eOvr) to, fxy) vofj.ov eyovTa 5
(pvaei Ta tov vofj.ov Trof^, ovTa vofnov ft.yj ey^ovTei, eavToig eiat
**
vofxog.^ aXX wg ovtcov, (f^rjatv, afj.apTif}fiidT(ov, Kat efj.itoXnevofj.e-
vcov, e^aatXevaev GdvaTOi d-no A^dfx ^ fJ^eyjit Tr}<; Seaecos toD vofj.ov,

Kat ent TOVi fxri dixapT^^aaVTai fxrj^^e Trapaf^e^rjKOTag evToXrjv

Qeov KaTa tov Aodfn.' «AAa vofii.ov (pvaeccs Ttapa^^apd^avTai;. to 10

te, " Oi eaTt Tv-nog tov jM,eAAovTOf," TovTeaTi Tvirog tov XptaTov 6

A^afn, ov KaTa t*/v dfxapTiav, rj Trjv ttKatoavvrjv, KaTa ydp TavTa

evavTiag eayov, akXa Kara to Ttporjpy^Pat. waiiep yap dito Tot/

Aoafi. oteooOri etg rtavTag QdvaTog, ovTccg dno tov \piaTov ^te-

Oo6r) eig itdvTag rj i^covj. eaTt ^e Tvrtog Ka) Ka& eTepov Koyov. 15

coaitep yap A^afL Ke^fjaXrf rfv Trjg Kvag, KaOo dvrjp, ovtco Kat 6

\ptaTOg Ke(f)aKrj Trjg KKKXrjaiag, KaSo vvfX(ptog avTrjg dvrjyopev-

Tat' (tig Kat ArtoaTokog (f>rjaiv, " dvTi tovtov KaTaXeixpei

" avQpayitog tov itaTepa avTov Kat Trjv fxr^Tepa, Kai itpoaKoXXrjQr}-
" o-€Ta< Ttpog Trjv yvvaiKa avTov' to fxvaTrjptov tovto, fxeya eaTiv' 20
" eych Se Xeyot) eig X.piaTov Kat Trjv KKKXrjatav.^^

©EOAflPOT. Ov^e ydp vofxog ertetaeXOcov, (f>riat, Trjv dfxapTtav

eXvaeV aXX a^y^tg rjv Te vofxog Kat enoXiTeveTO Kai eKparet

Ttapa Toig dvSpcoitoig, eXdfL/Bave Kat Ta t^? df/iapTiag itpoaBriKriv'

ovSev ttpog tovto Trjg tov vofxov Oeaecog avfx^aXea6at ^vvrjOeiarjg 25

afTor^' Kat Ttpog dito^ei^tv toi) rtpoKetfxevov eitdyei, " dfxaoTta te

**
ovK eXXoyenai, txrj ovTog vofLov." ToaovTov ydp artei^x^ev vofxog,

(prjai, rov rrjv dfxapTiav dveXeh, waTe oyS' av yevono dfLapTia, ei

fxrj vofxog etrj. vofxov Se vvv KaXe7 tvjv rjVTiva ^•^itOTe ttdKptaiv'

eiT€ aito (jjvaecag, etTe arto Oeaecog eyyivofxevrjV fnrj yap ovarjg t^^ 30
otaKptaecog ovk dv rtg Xeyotro dfxaprdveiv dfnapTiaV ei ^e to (f)at~

vofxevov KaKOV Kai ^taKekpifj.evov dito tov KaXov fxeTtccv, dXXd tovto
fj.ev, etg av^vfatv tou e(f> c6 Ttdvteg rffxapTov, TedeiKev. e-xpfxevog he

Trjg oiKeiag dKoXovQtag, eitr]yayev, " aAA' e^aaiXevaev OdvaTog

**
dito A^dfx fiieyj>i Mctiaecog Kai en) Tovg fnrj dfxapTVjaavTag ev 2,S
46 EHHrHSIS E12 THN nPOS V. 13.

" Tw ofxoiiOfJiaTi TYj^; Tiapa^ao^tai ^A^^afx' og e<JTi Tviroi tov /a€A-

" XoVTOi"

To fxev ovv *'.Kai €7ri tov^ [xr] dixaoT-^aavTag ev Tta ofxot(0{Ji.aTt

" Trji TTapa^do-eoig A^afx" Toyro keyei, OTi 6 OdvaTog eKpaTVjcrev

aTrdvTWV toov OTTioa^vjTroTe yjfKapTrjKoiav. ov yap eTreiovj ovy^ Ofxoiov 5

'TjV TO TVfi dfxapTiag el^og to re tov A^afx Kai twv Xontav av6pco-
TTOjVy OavdTov yeyovaaiv eKTog 01 Xoinor aXk viiep m vjfJiapTavov

OTraa^-^TTOTe, toD OavaTOV TYfV dTto(f>acTiV e^e^avro irdvTeg. ov yap

TVjg TOida^e dfxapTiag TifLcopia 6 QdvaTog apiaTaif aXXa Trdai^g

dfnapTiag' eaTi ^e ev tx Ttdv dno tov, " ov fnovov ^e dXXd Kai Kav- 10
" ywfxtvoi ev tw Qew ^ia xov K-vpiov yjfjiwv Irjaov X/j/cttov."

ov Xeyet ydp Trjg TOtdate dfxapTiag Tifxwpia QdvaTog coptaTai,

dXXd TrdaYjg dfnapTtag. Xeyei yap OTt ovk eirt tovtw fxovov Kav-

ywfxe6a, OTt tta tov yipiaTov KaTrjXXa^ev Yjfxdg Qeog eavTw,

dXX OTt Kat TidvTa Ot; t» TtaXata eXvae Ka^d. "noia TavTOL ; rjfxap- 15

TvjKOTog ydp tov A^a/x,, Kai fjivjv Kai Bvvjtov ^td tovto yeyovdiog,

vjTe dfxapTta Tidpo^ov eXa^ev eig Toy^ e^^f, Kat BdvaTog TidvTWV
eKpaTei twv avQpwnwv wg eiKog' TiavTwv yap v]f/.apTVjK0Twv, et Kat

fi.vj TiapaTTXvjaiav tco 'A^a/A dfnapTiav, dXX ovv ye OTrcocSoyTroTe,

Twv fxev ovTWy Twv te ovtw' dvdyKvi Kai tov OdvaTOV vjv KpaTCiv ao

e(f> dndvTWV ofxotwg' aXX' ov^e vofxog eitetaeXBwv dveXeh avrviv

eiTi ToJv avSpwiTWv e^vvvjSv]' TovvavTiov ft.ev ovv Kat vj tov dfxapTa-

vetv d(popft.v] evTevQev vjfxh eireyiyveTo' tw fxv]^e oiov tc eivai

dfxdpTV]fj.a KptveaQat vofxwv eKTog' ovtwv ^e twv KaB v]fxdg ev tov-

Totg wg fxv]hefXiav T^i' eiti ro KpenTov fi.eTa^oXv]g v7T0(f)aivea6ai 2 ^

eXTit^a, Xvaiv aTidvTwv 'KpiaTOg eipydaaTo twv Kakwv. oto avv-

TOfxwg eitvfyaye to " og eaTi Tvitog tov fxeXXovTog'" iva etiiv] oti

eyeveTO te Ta KaTa tov A^dfi. TVTiog twv KaTa "KptaTov. eTiet^v]

waitep Qt eKeivov twv yeipovwv v] itdpooog eyeveTo^ outoj Ota tovtov

TV]g Twv KpetTTOvwv diioXavaewg tv]v d(popfJ.v]v e^e^dfxe6a. 30

Akakiot. Ov'/^ dnXwg e'ipv]Ke " Kat eiTi Tovg fxvj df*.apTvjaavTag'"

avTiKpvg ydp evavTiov vjv dXXayov avTW elpvifj.evw' tw

tco *'
iidv-

" Tc^ yap vjf/iapTOv,^^ dXX " eTii Tovg fxvj afxapTV]aavTag eiii tcS

" OfxoiwfxaTi T^«- 7iapal3daewg ^A^dfx'" TOVTeaTi Kat eiii Tovg fxvj

Qta Tov (payeiv diio tov ev tw Ttapa^etaw ^vXov dfxapTWVTag. €^^35

 V. 15- PfiMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 47

TOVTCV Se laas av tk; KaTaaKevdavjf akXa •nepi evoi Kai fxovov

Tov A^cifJ.' ei yap nepi tov koivov avQpwiiov yeypafj.fA.evov tjv to

•aepi Tyjg napajSaaewi ypdfjifjia, ovk av evTavBa eXeyeTo *'

Kai eTti

**
Tovi fj.v} dfi.apTy]aavTag eni tw'
Ofj.oi!/ifj.aTi TVji •napa^daewi
" 'AUfj.r 5
^CTioT. *'
AAA e^aaiXevaev o BdvaTog d-no 'Adatt. f>.i'Xjpt

** McouVecyf." Tpid eaTiv ev TOVTOig Totg iiapa^oXiKwg dXkriXoig

•aapaTeSeiaiv, Ofj.oioTfig t;^, evavTioTVjg^ VTiep^oXvj. KaTa t^v 6ft.oio-

TVjTa evavTiOTvji fj.ev, dfLapTia, avafLdpTVjTov' ey6pa iipog 0eov,

KaTaXXayi^ 'apog Qeov' KaTdKpifj.ai tiKaiwfj.a' aiiwXeia Kai titw- i o

fj.a Kai BdvaTog^ acoTVjpia Kai ^w^ Kai dvdaTaaig. vj fj.\v ovv

evavTtOTVjg ev TOVTOig' vj 6e Ofj.oioTV}g, coairep ^i evog Tolg Tiaaiv

eiiiyeyovev' vj ^e vneplSoXvjf oti eTr/ ft.ev toov '^eipovoiv avveTtpa^av,

ra evt oi iroXXoi eni to fj.eTaayeh avTo7g twv KaKav, eiit ^e tov

afj.eivovcov ovOeig avveirpa^eVf dXXa ft.ovov tov evog ^ptaTov T015

yapiafjjx ^e-yovev. ojaTe ovy^ Oft.oia)g Kai eTriavjg, dXXa Ka^ xmep-
fioXi^v Kat eK Ttepiaaetag v) oft.otOT'^g' TidXtv ^ia tov 'A^dfj. tuv
yetpovcov eiaayBevTm, ovk avvjpeBv] ft,ovov TavTa, OTtep wg evavTtotg
Ofj.otov Kai dvdXoyov, dXXa Kai eTre^oBv} vapa ^ptaTOv to, dfxeivco'

o-nep TVjv vTiep^oXvjV Kat tvjv iiepiaaetav JiaptaTvjatv. 20

15 AAA ovx cos to TrapaTrrcofJLa, ovtco kcu to )(apia/xa.
Ktpiaaot. TeSetKag^ etg tu^ov Toii TipciTepov rov ^evTepov,

fnovovov^t TivvBaveTai tov dKpoct}ft.evov, wg vTioaTtyfj.v} Te Ka). eTiepcti-

TVjaei Xeyav' *'

aXX ov^^ ajf to Tiapd7iT0}fj.a, ovtco Kat to 5^0-
**
ptafj.a. ofx.oiov yap cog Xeyot' KaTaKeKpifi.e$a tco SavdTco did 25

T^f ev Ahdft, TTapa^daecog, oXvjg TVjg dvBpconeiag (ftvaecog tovto

vaOovavjg ev avTco' Kai yap vjv andpyv} tov -yevou^-* dXA ev

KptaTa TidXiv dveBdXXofJ.ev eig l^covjv. Tvnog ^e v}v 'A^dfi. tov

fi.eXXovTog, TovTeaTt KpiaTOv, Tvj tcov <f)6aaavTcov aKaiOTV}Tt tvjv

taofioipovaav vjfj.h etaKOfj.i^ovTog %dptv. dpa ovv, (pv^at, toZto 30

Xeycov, ^tv]ft.dpTV]Ka KaT dXv]6ovg ; e^cy <f>epoft.ai tov etKOTog ;
'*
ovv
" cog TO TiapaTiTCOft.a, ovtco Kat to '^dptafj.a ;" aAA' ia-)(vae fj.ev

Ct evog 6 OdvaTog, drov^aet ^e ^i evog vj l^w^ ; KaiTot Ticog ovy^

"^
Leg. TtfietK&Ji;.
48 EHHrHSIS EIS THN HPOS V. 15.

aXyjOei €Ke7vo eiTreiv; " et yap tco tov evo^ TrapairTfe^xaTi 01 ttoA-

" Ao/ aiie6avov, ttoXKw fxaXXov yj %apiq t6i3 0€6v Kat y] ^apea ev

" '/aptTi T'^ Toi) evO(; avQpayirov Irjcrov X.piaTov, elg tov^ TroAAovf
*'
eTieplaaevcrevr ave^eTai yap vjKtaToi ye (f)tXdv6p(i}7T0(; uv ^y][ji.t~

ovpyog, KaTtQyyaat fxev QdvaTOv tta tov evog, dirpaKTvjo^at he tvjv ^

^i evog avdpaiTTOv ^avjv. virepKetcreTai te yj %dptg Ta e^ opyrjg.

rENNAAioT. Mia fxev ydp (pvjaiv yj dfxapTia t^c KaTaKpiaeag

TtdvTCov atTta, Kat t^v eKetvvjs ^iKVjv 01 Kade^vjg irdvTeg e^eriaav.

V] he %dptg ovK eKftvviv fxovvjv^ dkka Kat Tiokkag dXXag eKetvvjs

PapvTepag eTTtTVj^evdetaas vno tSiv fxeTayevecTTepm dveiXev, ditTai- 10

<7Tcv TtavTeXtag tov Xontov Kai ^tKaiav epyaaafxevvj tvjv (pvatv

V}fX.S>V.

AioAapor. Tovto ^ toKet evavTicoi '^%(tv tco iipoKetfi.evca to

**
€/V TtdvTag dv6pct}7iovi 6 QdvaTog ttv}X6ev'" etirm yap dvcoTepci}

irept itdvTm, vvv ttepi iroXXwv Xeyei. dXXa %pv} ei^evai OTt ^tvjXQe 15

/u,ev e/V TtdvTag QdvaTog, eTtettvf Kat itdvTeg vjfxdpTOfiev. dXXa

^t^X6e TtdvTag fxev tiepevvihv Kat iieipd^coVf KaTe%m Ve ov Tovg

ditX^g dfxapTdvovTag, aXXa Tovg efXTrapafxevovTag Taig eavTcov

dfxapTiatg. OTtep Kat '^ta twv e|% ^YfXci Xeym, oti dfxapTwXoi
KaT€(jTd6v]aav 01 iroXXot. ti m eft.<f>atvei to dfxeTd6eTGv TVjg 20
KaKtag avTm. wcrTe ^t^X6e fiev eig irdvTag 6dvaTog, '^tepevvm,

opm avTovg dfxapTavovTag' e6avdT(ii(Te te ov irdvTag. evtot fiev ow

^tacpopav 6avdT0V cevj6vi(xav Qta TOVTm ^vjXovcr^at' Kat ^ta fxev tov
" irdvTeg" acofxaTtKOv efX(f)atvea6at tov 6dvaTov' ^ia ^e Toy " ttoA-
*'
Ao/" xpv^tKov, «AA' ov^ev Tovrm vvv vj dKoXov6ta tov Xoyov ^etKvv- 25
crtv. ov^e yap S/acrToA^ Ttg ev avTco eaTtv, dXX wf fep' €vog otKOv-

fxeviKov 'irpdyfxaTog ^ie^eiat. (f^tXoTtfxehat fxevTot '^e^i^at, oti

€1 Kat TO TrapdTiTcofxa tov A^aft. KaTeaKevaaev Trovvjpog, ap%riv

eavTW TVjg «•«t dv6pcoirov PaatXetag irpayfxaTevOfxevog, dXXa fxe7-

^ov %dptafxa eirtt-^fxi^aag Kvptog e%apiaaTo. 30

©EOAOPor. Kat ov^e tov TrapairTWfxaTog eitog (f)y]at, ToaovTOV,

oaov TO Tov %aptafxaTog' et yap Kat v] tov evog afxapTia Totg

av6p<moig tov 6avaTov hrr^yayev' dXX ovv ye vj tta tov \piaTov

^ Cod. ToD.
 V. i6. P12MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 49

hapea, fMei^oov Tig Trepi Tovg avBpwTtovg cyeveTo. to yap " oi iroK-

*'
Ao/ «Tre^avov ' «vt/ tov irdvTei \eyei. Travres" yap aiteBavoVy wg

axnog dvcoTepci) (pyjaiV " €/ iidvTag avQpwnovg oivjXBev o QavaTog.

S>yAov Se oti to " Ka) eig Tovg voWovg eirepiaaevev" ofJLOtwg avTi tov

eig TidvTag keyei' koiv/j yap Kat rj t^s avacrTa^rewg yaptg, anav- 5

Twv avKJTafkevdiv Ofji.ota}g.

i^ Kat ovx ws" ^i' ^'^'0$' a/xapTr)aavT09 to dcopTjfia.

Ktpiaaot. AvaTi6vj(xiv axmep tvjv tou irpdyixaTog <f>v(Ttv Kai

TVjv Tov vo^fjfJLaTog Ovvafj.tv eitt to OTt fi.dkt(na •npeitov tS) 0eoo. et

yap S^, (fffjo-tf To e^ evog, yjtoi ^t evog KaTdKpifjux tov AoafJ. 1 o

«jre^oiTvjaev etg itdvTag KaS OfJLOiOTr/Ta tvjv avTov' pt^a yap

vjVf (cg e(f>y}v, tov yevovg itaOovaa tvjv (p6opaVf itwg ovk av

yevotTO Kat Ttt(7Tet itapd^eKTov Kat dyaTtfjTOv tco ©eco to oeh e^

evog ^tKat(afj.aTOg eK TtoXXav 7tapaTtTa)fxdT(tiV ^iKatoixrSat itoXKovg ;

77 01^5^ atpeTOv TO aco^etv fx.dXXov 77 aTtoXXvvat itapa 06«j ; aoaitep 15

TOtvvv KttTa^ehiKaaTat fji.ev 'A^a/x, KaTeKpdTvjae ^e M^coaeoog rj

TVjg dpdg ^vvafLtg vitocpepovaa t^ (pdopa Tovg eTti T-qg yrjg, ovTcog

eTtei^^rjitep "te^^tKaidJTat X.ptaTog 6 ^evTepog 'A^a/x. oOx t'^ vpiOTrj,

I3a^te7rai Ttov itdvTag Kat eig vjfj.dg vj ^iKaKDatg. teQiKataaBai Oe

cf)afj.ev Tov \ptaTOv, ovy^ ag attKov fnev yeyovoTa -noTe, itpoarjKOVTa 20

ye fLrjv e^ eiti^oaewg TVjg elg Ta djxetvfo etg ^iKaiccaiV dXX ort

•JtpaTog T€ Kai fiovog dvGpcovog avTOg evi 'y^;- ovk eitotvjaev dfxap-

Tiav, Qv^e evpeBrj '^oXog ev to(5 aTOfxart avTov.

rENNAAioT. M<a fj.ev ydo, <f)r)atv, dfj.apTta t^^ KaTaKpiaecog

TtdvTuv atTia, Kat tvjv eKetvvig ^ikvjv 01 KaOe^vig itdvTeg e^eTtaav. 25

vj te xdptg ovK eKeivvjv fiiovvjv, dXXa Kai TtoXXag aXXac, eKetvrjg

PapvTepag eTtiTr]^ev6eiaag vao rS>v fjieTayevearepwv aveiXev, aTtrat~

arov TtavTeXxg Kat tiKatav epyaadfxevog rrjv (f)vaiv rifj.av.

AioAapOT. 'AvTi Tov Ttpog ev df>.dpTVjfj.a rov A^dft.. fLeydXrj

yap rjv Kat itoXXr}, Kat ra dfj.apTrjfj.aTa rri (fjtXavQpcoTtta. vrtep- 0,0

l3aivovaa' ortep tt^daKcev evtdyet' " to |W,ev yap Kptfxa ef evog etg
" KaTdKpift.a' TO te ydptafj.a eK TtoXXSov 7tapa7rTcofj.dTCi)V etg otKatco-
" jw,a." fSovXerat yap eineTv, ort ro ft.ev tov Aoafn dfJ.dpTrjfj,a ev

^v, dXX OfJicog ev ov e^ evog dfxapTT^fxar og KareKpive rovg itoXXovg

H
 50 EHHrHSIS EI2 THN HPOS V. 17.

^ia TO fxia-^aaaBai tov Aoa,[x. ro Qe yapia^a rov K.vpiov, ov

Trpog TO ev afxapTfjfx.a €{X€Tp-^6v}, akka. Ttpog ra TtavTm itoXka

ovra' oJCTTe €k ttqXXwv •jrapaTTTafJiaTwv «JraAA.a^av, ^yayev ng

^tKai(i}fji.a' ev yap tovtx Iuti r^g yapiTog ro TrepK^aevfxaf oti ov

fxovov tSiv itapaTiTWfLaTm aTtvfkkayev, aAAa Kat elg diKaioavvrjv S

ey^eipayayr/aev.

0EOACPOT. M.iav TavTf^v aiTiav Keyei ryjg tiacpopag. CKei

fxev ydp (prjcnv^ elg YjfxapTyjK^t;, Kai KaTaKpiBeii ^ia tovto, «V tou^'

e^^i TVjv Ttfxapiav eveySrjvai itapeaKevaae itavTag^ Koivcovovg t^?

aTtocf^aaeeog eayr^Kwg tov SavaTov. vj Se yapi<i ovy Ofxoiwg. ov 10

yap a,Tt evoq (oaitep eiti tov A^afx eig Tovg e^vjg ek/jXvBev. akXa
vokkoov ovTccv Twv Tj^Yj KaTaKeKpifxeviov, avvTOf/iov etg Te Tovg itpo-

Tepov Kat eig Toi/g e^vjg avQpaTtovg Trjg ^apeag eTtot^aaTO tvjv e^a-

vXaaiv. eaTiv ovv fxet^l^wv TtoXKw' f'tnep eKeivo //,ev eKkafxxpe rovg

c^^?* toSto ^e 01» Tov? e^^g fxovov oxpekvjaev, akka yap Kai Tovg 15

"TtpoaeikrjcpoTag ekvae tSov eyKkrjfxaTWV.

17 Ei yap Tw Tov €vos TrapaTTTco/xaTt.

Ktpiaaot. ASpei ^rj rtakiv wg akKifKCOTepav TYjg KaTaKpivov-

avjg apag Karakoyi^eTai Trjv tiKaiovaav yapiv. ov yap S17, (f>r}aty

(fyatr] Ttg av wg i]V etKog KaTiayyaat fxev twv erti Tr^g yrjg tov ti 20
evog 6avaTov, evaQevetag ye fnrjv afxoip^aai tyjv ^oorjV itokkSi yap
fxakkov 01 yapiv ep^ovTef t>;v tta \piaTov Kai t^v T-i^g ^tKatoavvrjg

^apeav eK (f>tkoTifxtag Tr/g avdoQev, anoaeiaovTai fxev tov OavaTOv

T3 KpaTog, avfx^aaikevaovat ^e tc? ^cuoTro/ovvTi Ta ttavTa Xp<o"Tco.

Fennaaiot. Arto^et^ag avTapKoog ro iteptTTOv Trjg yaptTog 25

KaTo. avyKpiatv, eTtiavkXoyt^eTat kotttov Kut KaTaaKeva^ei to

aitov^a^C^ofxevov, Kai (prjatv, " ei yap TCt5 tqv evog itapaTtTWfxaTi

" 6dvaTog efSaatkevae ^ta tov evof," Kat Ta e^rjg. tc5 yap avv-
^eafLw, vvv dvTi tov toivvv eyprjaaTO. ei Totvvv (prjat Kai evog av-

6p^TtQV TtapaTtTWfxaTi Kat ti evog TtapaitTafxaTog 6avaTog epa- 30

aikevaev, dpa ovv Ttokkw fxdkkov 01 to itkeov Trjg eig otKaioavvrju

ydptTog ev toj evi ^ptatco KOfnt^ofxevot, Ka6ag aTtoM^eiKTat, f3aat-

kevaovatv ev d^avdrw ^(orj.

Beoaapot. Et/ fXYfV KaKetVQ <prja), Ttokkriv ^eiKVvai Trjv ^ia-

 V. i8. PX2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 61

tpopav' OTi Iku [xev o BdvaTO^ elcra-^^PeU tyJ tov Aoafi dfxapTiat

Ka) KpaT-^aas 6ir/ tcov dvQpoTtoov, e^e^aTO kvaiv. rj oe ye tvjs

'^(opeag ditoXavaig tia tou Xp<(TTov itpoayeyovvla yi[J.7v, ^i rjv Kai

Tyji dvaaTaaemq Tev^OfJieGa, Ka) ev "^tKaioavvy] ^iaTeXeaofxev dfxap-

Teiv ovK eTti^eyofji.evoii kvaiv ov M^eTat. ttafJievovft.ev yap t^^s

fKekXovayjg ^«^f "ttyjveKSii d-noXavovTeg.

18 "Apa o^v m 8l eVoy TrapaTrTcofiaTOf.

KrpiAAOT. Ylpoaendyei TaTg irpoKetfj.evatg evvotaif Beaite-

atog Ylavkog oiove) to avfi.Ttepaafj.a, koi (fiyjatv,

*'
apa ovv wg 01

" evof TtapaTtTWfj.aTog,^^ Ka) toc elyjg. KaTaKeKpifJ.eBa yap, ag 10

TtpoeTnov ev 'A§a,«, Ka) ag eK pi^g T^g itpaTvjg etg attav ^ie^yj

TO e^ avryjg yevofj.evog c| dpdg Gdvarog. te'^tKat<i}f/.e8a te Kai

dv€pkaaT-^aafj.ev etg ^coyjv, '^tKatcoQevTog vnep yjfJMV tov \ptaTov.

dcpet^^-^aag fiiv yap Tyjg avTca '^oBeiayjg evToA^f itpoTtaTccp, itpo-

KCKpovKe tS) 0ea3 Kat vTtofi.efi.evyjKe to. ck Betag opyyjg. KaTtaXiaBe 15

yap elg cf>6opdv Tore, Kai eiayjkaTO t>;v avQpccvov (pvatv yj dfxapTia'

ovTW Koi dfnapTcokot KaTeaTdSi^aav 01 voX^oif TOVTeartv ot ava

Ttdaav Trjv y^v. «XA' elitoi Ttg dv vat TtapcoXtaQev A^aft, Kat

Tyjg Beiag dXoyiaag evToXyjg, <f>Qopa Kai Oavdrca KaTe^tKa^eTO. eha

itcog dfj.apTCo\ot ^i avTOv KaTeardQyjaav 01 TtoXXoi ; Tt itpog yjfJ.dg 20
TOt exeivov 7tTaiaft.aTa ; itag ^e oXcog 01 ft.YjTtco yeyevyjfievot Kara-
^e^tKdafj.e6a aiiv avTw, Kairot Qeov KeyovTog, " ovk ditoQavovvTat
*'
TtaTepeg vitep TeKvcov, ovTe TeKva VTtep itaTepcov. ^'vyyi yj dfj.ap-
*' av yevotTo
Tavouaa afTi7 ditoQavelTai,^^ Ttg ovv itpog yjfkdg r^^g

ditoKoyiag 6 Tpoitog ; ovkovv xpvyyj fxev yj dfJMprdvovaa avTyj aTto- 25

Bavetrat. dfnapTcokot ^e yeyovafjev ^/a Ty^g TtapaKo^g Tot3 A^aft.

^ta Toiov^e TpoTtov. "TteitoiyjTO fj.ev yap ent a(f)6apata Kat ^coyj, y]v

^e auTM ka\ j3iog dytoTtpeityjg ev tw itapatetacii Tyjg Tpvcp^g'

oXov ^v Ka) '^taitavTog ev SeoTtTiaig vovg, ev ev^ta Se Kat ya-

X-^vyj TO acoft.a, KaTi^peft.ovaYig aTtdayjg aiayjpdg y^^ovyjg' ov yap vjv^o

eKTOTtasv Kivyifi.dTcov Oopv/Sog ev avTu.
EiTtei^y^ Se TteTtTcoKev vcf> dfxapTiav Kat KaTcoXtaOev etg (pQopav,

evTevQev elaetpafj.ov tyjv t% aapKog (f>vatv yj^ovai Te Kat d^a-

dapaiat. dve(f>v Se Kai ev Tolg fj.eXeatv yjfj.cov ayptatvcov vofjog.

H 2
52 EHHrHSIS EIS THN HPOS V. 18.

vevo(TVjKev oiiu 7] (pvaii t^v a,[J.apTiav ^ia TVji TiapaKO-iqg tov evog,

T0VTe<7Tiv A^dfx' ovTtag dfJiapTwXoi KaTeaTaOr/aav 01 tcoKXoi' ovy^

ag TW A^afx av[Ji7[apa(3e^v)K0Teg, ov yap vjaav TrwTrore, aXX ccg

T^g eKeivov (pvaecog ovreg t^^ vtio vofxov Treaovafjg tov TVjg dfxap-

Tiag. ccaTrep toivvv y]ppa>aTrjaev rj dvBpanov (f)vaig ev Aoafx, Qia 5

T>7f TTapaKorjg tyjv tpaopav, eiaebv re ovTCog avTfjv Ta iiauy), ovTOog

dn-^XXuKTai itdXiv ev 'KpiaTW. 'yfyove yap vnYjKoog tw ©ew Kat

IlaTpi, Kat ovK eTToivjaev afxapTtav.

AioACPor. ^K^erdaag Kai 'dtayvfxvdaag tyjv tc 'bid tov Ahafi.

TipoaTpi^eiaav dvOpw-notg l^^^fxiav, Kai tyiv iiapa tov }^vptov ^(opvj- 10

6eiaav evepyeaiav, eirdyet Xoiirov d7ro<paTiKWTepov ^todaKcov, <u;

Tov fxev A^afx KaTeKptve, Kai eOavdrwaev dvOpccTrovg ro -napd-

TrTCOfxa, Tov Se }^vpiov e^cooiroii^ae to ^iKatcofxa. ti ^e tov A^afx

TO Trapd-nTWfxa ; yj irapaKOYf ri tov K.vpiov to ^tKaicnfxa ; tj vira-

KOYf, y]v virrjKovaev tS) WaTpi KaTa to evavOpcon^aai Kat TraBeh 15

VTrep dvOpcoTrcoVy KaOcog ev hepoig 6 AiroaToXog <f>y]at,

" ayJifxaTi
" evpeSetg cog avSpconog, eranetvcoaev eavrov, yevofxevog virYjKoog

" fi-ey(j>i Bavdrovy Oavdrov te axavpov^^ coarf: yj vnaKOYj KadeiXe

TYjv irapaKOYjv, Kat tco ^eXrtarcxi ro yeiptaTov KaTYiycovtaaro.

©EOAflPOT. ApKovvTCog ev roig TrpoKetfxevotg tyjv hta(f)opdv het- 20

^ag rcov Trpayfxdrcov, avXXoyt^erai evravda ro ndv npog ro ^id
" TOVTO coanep ^t' evog avdpcoTrov yj dfxaprta etg rov KOafxov eta^X6e'"

ravra dno^^thovg Kat Xeycov, ort '^e^etKrat ^id rovrcov Yifxh, oircog

Tou A^dfx Kat dfxapTYjaavrog Kat Qavdrov atriov yeyovorog,

'S.ptarog Kat tyjv Xvatv rcov dfxapTYjfxdrwv Yjfxav eyaptaaro, Kai 25

rY]V diraXXayyjv tou Qavdrov ty] rijg avaardaecog eX^rt^t, Ka6 y^v

e^co irdaYjg dfxapriag TroXiTevaofxeOa. rovro yap Xeyei ro dfxap-

rcoXot. ovrujg X.piaTog tyjv dvdaraaiv vjfxh eocopYjaaro, coare ev

dBavdrco rrj <j)vaet KaraardvTag, ndavjg dfxapriag ^tdyetv eXevSe-

povg, ev dKpi(3e7 r^ ttKatoavvri TroXtrevofxevovg. etei^e Se Kav- 30
ravSa ort ro 01 iro^Xo] dvrt rov irdvreg Xeyet' elirm ydp ro " elg

" Travrag avSpconovg, eig diKatcoaiv ^covjg, enYjyayev " dfxaprcoXoi

" KareardSvjaav 01 noXXoi." coare '^vjXov ori 01 TroXXot avri rov 01

'savreg Xeyei, Kai dvcorepoig, KavravSa.

 5

V. 20. PliMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 63

'Akakiot. *^"il<7irep yoip" (fiyi^h

" ^'a "^V^ Trapa^aaecoi t(,v

" evoi afxaprcoXoi KaTeaTaQrjcrav ol ttoAAo/," ov toZto Xeya oti

€vo$ a[JLapTcovTog Kai ol TroXkol afxapTavTeg, Tr;v aiiTyiv '^o^av aTi-/j-

vkyKavTO fx€Ta tcov Tiixwpiav' o^ikov yap, ^oti aiio tov Aoafx apy^-riv

€a"5^fv y} dvdpcoiroTVjgy Kai vndpyjiv Kai afJiapTdvetv. 5

Sethpianot. E/^e^ Tra<; diopi^et KavTavda evt fxev Tvjg d[jt.ap-

Tiag Ka) Trji ^tKaioavvvjg, to " ttoXXoi" Ttdeig' ov yap iravTeg

yifxapTOV 01 Ttpo vo\x.ov, ovh\ ettKatoTrpdyrjaav irdvTei; ev TJj yapiTt'

^''"noXkoi ydp kXtjto), oXlyot ^e e/cAe/CTo<." Itii Ve tov (rcofxaTtKov

BavaTov Kai TVjg aafxaTtK^^g avacTdaecog itdvTeg Kat iravTeg. 10

'ANEnirPA*OT. TovTO evavTtovTat TJj airoaToXtKyj pvjdei t^

XeyovaYj " e/ ydp tw tov evog TrapaTTTco/xaT* ot iroXXot anedavov,

Kat Ta e^yjg. TOvg -noXXovg ovv Tovg irdvTag Xeyet. vj yap ydptg
Kat >} ^wped vj ^td Toy evog Ivjaov 'KptaTov ovk eaTt fjLeptKvj' ojaTe
**
01 TToXXot" dvTt TrdvTMv eiXyj-TTTat' et Se Tig ^ovXoito TCff iroX- 1

Xovg voeXv TebvfiKevat, VTre^aipovfJievav tov Kvay^, Kat tov iiXta,

eig ovg ^/^A5e jaev SdvaTog, Ka9o yeyovaat QvvjTot, ov ft.v}v Kat

KdTeayev avTaV OTt 6 fxev fxeTeTeOv] tov fxvj t^eiv BdvaTov, oie

dveX^^cpOv] ev apfxari JTvptvx, iroato fxdXXov vi etg toc diieipa TTXrjBvf

diToaTaXelaa ydptg tov iTavaydQov 0eou vjfxm '^td Vviaov KpiaTov ; 20

et §e Kat Ttveg ev Tvj irapovata KaTaXvjcftGevTeg tov K.vpiov Ivjaov

X.ptaTOv, fxvj yevaatvTO BavdTov, Kat iTpog Tovg ToiovTovg av etvf

dvTt^taaTeXXofxevov to '*
ot ttoXXoi aTTeBavov" t/ yap to avayKoiov
Tovg TieptXetiTOfxevovg ev tv] Tiapovata. tov l^vptov BavdTov yevaa-
aBat, eha avBig aviaTaaBat' dXXd fxv] evTevBev etg dBavaatav 33

ywpetv. ov yap OTt X.piaTog aiTeBave, TavT'/j Kat iidvTag aTToBa-

vetv avdyKVj. aXX eK tov evavriov, et virep TTdvTwv diTeBavev, ov^etg

axpetXev dTToBvvjaKeiv ovKeTi. tt Be ^id ttjv tpvatv tov TipdyfxaTog

ovTca yiveTat, ot KaTaXafxpavofxevot ev tvj -napovata avTov ov

TeBvvj^ovTat. oq

20 No/xos de TrapeKrrjXOeu, Iva TrXeovaarj to TrapairrcDixa.

Ktpiaaot. AtaXoyieiTat Ttg, <pvjai, KaTa xo etKog eKeHvo ttov,

Kat Xeyet' Tvnog vjv tov fxeXXovTog A^dfi.' Kat (oaiTep ev eKetva

* Leg. dXX' irt.

54 EHHFHSIS E12 THN nP02 V. 20.

KaT€a-Tddy)fji€V dfJiapTCoXo} ^ia rrjv iTapdfSaaiv, ovTcog ev KptaTW

'hehiKamjxdBa ti viraKovji. €^€i toivvv /x^aoXafSovvTog, (pyjaiVf ov-

^evof, TTjv €V X/3/<7Tc5 ^iKaiwaiv To7g liii 7^4 dva(paiv€aBai. eiTa

TTOia yeyovc Tav ^ia Mcoo-ewf vo/xcev co<r e^ dvdyKfjg yj yj>€ia. itpoq

^»; Ta TOiavTa Ttdkiv GeaTrcatoi; YlavXoi (Jlovovov^i nai aviaTarat 5

**
Xcyav vOjtxo? Se irap^iavjXOcVy iva irX^ovdaf] ro napdjtTcofxa'" to

^e " iiap^tayjXB^v" dvTi tov Tiap€ia ^€^Xyik€ fX€Ta^v t^c Te ev

'A^a/x KaTaKpia^wif Kat TVjg ev ^piaTW ^iKaioavvrjs.

K.ai tU dv voono irdXtv tvj^ tov vofxov Ttap^tatpofJ.rjg 17 xp6<a»

aa^fjcjig dKovaet XeyovTog, " iva TiXeovdavj to irapdTtTafj.a^ ti (f)^g 10

co riayAe ; «^5« Kat dfxapTtai 6 vofxog i)v Trpo^evog ; Kat Ti^nXrj-

SvvTat ^/ avTov Ta TtapaTtTWfxaTa ; fj.yi

y€votTO. •yjiy} Totvvv KaT-
evpvvat Tvjg fj.vaTayci)yiag tov Tpoitov. ecpvj Toiyapovv Aa(3th
" OTt vdvT€g €^€KXtvaVf afxa vj^^f^p^tcoBrjaaV ovk rjv itotSiv yjpri-

*'
aTOTrjTa, ovk ^v ecag kvog." ^iecpOdpKaai ydp irdvT€g 01 litt t^c 15
yrjg t>jv o^ov avTwv, /xeTa t>jv ev A^afx 7tapd(3aaiv' TavTrj Tot Kai
€KoXd^ovTO' Kotvrjv fji€v a7tavT€g v7tofJi.€tvavT€g ^ikyjv tov KaTaKXv-
afxov' idiKag Se Kat KaTa Katpovg Kat KaTa yapag t€ Kat 7toX€tg'

€1 ydp Kat vofxog ovk rjv, aXX' ovv Kat e^ €fj.(j)VTCov KivvjfJidTcov

€Ttai^aycoy€7To Ttapd 0eov Ttpog ^'itriatv tcov dyaSav vj dvQpcoitov 20

(f>vatg.

Yl€7tpayoTag ovv dBXicog Toi/g eitt yrjg KaT!^X€€i 0eof, Kat

Trjg Tvpavvovavjg avTovg dfJiapTtag avaXXaTTeiv ev ^iptaTW (piXa-

ydOcog €aK€it€To' dXXd ^ei"^ oorfBri Kat fj.aXa op6cog itoXv, voaovv-

Tag itpoava(f)aiv€a6at Toiig eTr/ T^f 'y^f' tva yjp^tco^eaTdTYjV leyovaa 25

t>jv f/f Tov Koau.ov €ia(3oXrjVf vj ev \piaTco OiKaicoaig opcoTo Xontov'

'^tKatovaBat ydp (f>afj.€V, ov tov vi^vi ^tKaiov, aAX' ei' Ttg caTtv dfj.ap-

Tiatg €voypg. itSjg ovv e^e/ npoavaheiKVvadai Tovg €Tti T^g yvjg Tyjg

ev 'K.piaToo ydptTog ^e^€V)f/.€Vovg ; Ttap€iavjX6€ voft.og, tva TtXeovdavj to

TtaoaitTCOfj.a' TovTcaTiv, tva ev TOtg vito vof/.ov TtoXv (paivotTO T030

•napditTcafJM' fxvj^evog hvjXovoTt ^iKaiova6ai ^vvaft.€vov '^td to Tvjg

<f)va€cog aa6iV€g' VTtoTtiitTOVTCOV te coaitep ditdvTOjv Taig €K Ttapa-

^aaecog atTiatg. TeBeiTai Totvvv vofi.og eXeyyog oid Ttg TVjg

^ Leg. vid. SelV.

 V. ao. PnMAI0T2 Eni2T0AHN. 55

andvTccv acOevaai, iva (paivono to. dvBpwTriva fxov-i^g TVjg Oid

Xpi(7ToD Qepatteiag ^ehci^fji.eva. TavTf} tci (pvjcriVy ** ov 0€ €7rk€~

" ovacrev vj dfxapTia, virepeTTepidaevcrev yj '^^dpti" etei ydp eivai

ToaavTYjv, ag afJietvw (f>aivea6at tov KaTaKptvovfog vofiov.

AioAOPOT. E/ttwv tva TcXeovdayi, ehet^ev oti nat Tipog vofxov ^

•^v TTapdTTTafia, Kai vjheaav TiTaiovTeg avBpa-not. ov fxyjv TidvTa

d eiTTatov eiteytvaaKov ag TtTaiaft.aTa' aXk o vofLog '^oQeti, d-Tre-

yvfjLVCoae Kat e^et^e TtXetova ovtu tj d evofjit^cv' aKpt/Swg ^e etire

'*
TO TrapeiavjXQe," fiLeTa^v ydp TVjg Toi) AddfJi irapaKoyjg , Kai TVjg

Tov '*
'^ajTifjpog eTit^rifi.tag irdpo^ov eig tov ^tov eka/Sev 6 vofiog. ov lo
" 0€ eirXeovaaev r) dfuzpTia, virepeirepiaaevaev vj ydptg^^ aov ovv
kirXeovaaev ^ dfJiapTia ; OTroy o vofjiog. ei ^e irapd ^\ov\aioLg 6

vofJLog, €Ke7 Kat virepeiiepiaaevaev vf '^apig. €K€i6ev yap evay-

yekiaTai Kai AiioaToXoi, Kat ro t^^ awTi^ptag Kecpdkatov 6

\piaTog. 15
4>OTioT. E/Trojv OTi rvTiog ^v 6 A^dfj. rov HpiaTov' rvTiog Se
Oi^XovoTi €K Tov evavTtov' wg ydp eKeivog atriog dvBpaiioig ^ 6avd-
rov, ovTcog 6 ^ptarog airtog avQpcoiiotg dvaardaewg. eiTiav ovv, wg
€(j)yjfji.€v, OTi rinrog y^v A^afi. rov 'Kptarov' eiiet^y} fJLcKXwv avro
KaraaKevd^eiv, ov fJMvov ryjv Qfxoioryjra KaraaKevd^ei Ka) tvtiov, 20
aAAa Kat tvjv ev rm Ti/Troo Kai ofj.otOTyjTi vnepo^^^j^v Kat iiepiaaetav'
rovro yap evteiKvvrai tta rov keyeiv, aAX' ovy^ cog ro TiapdiircofjLa'
Kat -TidXiv, Kai ovy^ cog €vog dfxapr-^aavrog. eiret ovv avvBerov avrce

Trcog yeyove ro eirtyeip-^fxa, avofxoiwryjrd iicog Iv OfJLOioryjTi ^ta-

TiXeKovTi' vvv enavaXafJLfSdverai fjLcv ro avro, KaBapcag Ve Tr,v 2,5

6fJL.otory]ra ^eiKVvat' Kat ovKert TiXeKcov oaov diio rvjg Xe^ecog rtvd

dvofJLOicarr^rog fxdyyfv' eira aacpcog tovto Kat KaBapxg ev^tei^dfxevog,

ori coairep ht evog e^aaiXevaev Bdvarog, noXXa fjLoiXXov ev ^coyj

/3aaiX€va€t Oi evog ^ptarov, eiidyet coanep avfj.Tiapatvovfj.evog,

Kai €ig ro ert aatpearepov Kat avvearaXfjievov avaycov rov Xoyov, 30

Kai (pi^atv " apa ovv cog ^t evog TiapaiiTafJ.arog eig Tidvrag dv-
*'
Bpcjynovg ro KaraKptfj.a^'' Kai rd el^yjg' eira Kat eirei^^ Kat ev

ra vpcoro) Kat avvBerc^ eTiiyeip-^fiLaTi, Kai ev roo ^evrepa) Kai S/a-

y Cod. avOpamog sed marg. yp. ayBpaiitoti.

 56 EHHrHSTS EI2 THN HPOS V. 21.

K€Ka6apfji(va3 Kai €7ravaXy]7rTiKa' Kat €V tw " wcnrfp" avfxnepdafxaTi

» /j/ / \ \ / \ /
eff€V65^a€i/Ti. TtapaTiTafj.aTog /xev Kai ya.piaiJi.aTot; Kai KaTaKpi-
fjiaTOi Kai Owp-fjiJM.TOi Kai '^iKatwfjiaTog Kai ToiovTm fxvi^fjiovtvd'

oaev Kat tyjv apyrjv etAyjcpev eKaTepa tcov evavTiwv rj avaTotyia

avTVj ovteiiu) eTttaYjfj.-^vaTo. vvv aiiTO tovto ^taaacpei Kai aitoKaXv- 5

7rT€<, Kat (pvjatVy OTt Ta fj.ev (k TrapaKorjg eppvf), to, ^e e^ vnaKovjg

Yjvtjyjaev waTe KaTaaKevaaTtKOv av etv) tovto tov eTttyeipYjfj.aTog

Tov KaTaaKevd^ovTOi; tov tvtiov Kat tyiv ofx.otOTVjTaf oiov tcv " ei

" yap Tw Tov evog 7tapaTiTWfj.aTi 6 6dvaT0<;,^' Kat e^^i.

Ov TavTokoyel Totvvv, wg av Ttg oi7j6ety], 6e7o<; AitoaToXog ev 10

TovTotgj aXka aa(f)wg Xtav Kai ^ty]KpiPwfj.euwg dXXyjkov/el Kat

evTaTTet t«v K€<paXaiwv tvjv hvvaft.iv' eaTt ft.ev ovv to ft.ev
" aAX'
" ov)(^ wg TO 7tapaTtTWfj.a,^ Kai e^yjg, ewg tov " e*^ itoX.Xwv TtapaitTW-
**
ft.dTwv etg htKaiwfna." eTtiyetpyift.a fj.ev, wg ecjii^fj.ev, tetKTiKov toxj

Tvitov Kat TiJ^- OfiotOTyjTog' eheiTO ovv aa<j>yjveiag Kat htaKa6dp- ^5

aewg. tovto 7tote7 to ecpe^yig eTttyeipyjfiia, e7tavaXafi./3dvov to 7tpo-

€tpy}fi.evov Kat 'hiaKa6aipov Kai eig to aacpeg d^tayyeXov' dxx' ehet

Kai TovTo Xa^e7v d^twfna, Kat e| v7to6ea€wg 7tpoT€tV€a6at fj.ovov.
•«S\ -.

ovte TOVTO Ttapopa,

~),5f/
aXX
fj.^

waTtep avfj.7tepatvofJ.evog,
/
Kat
N~~,/
tov Xoyov
Tyj

6appwv aXyj6eta, fneTa /Se^atwaewg d7to(f>aiveTat' " dpa ovv oog ht 20

" evog TtapaTtTWfj.aTog^'' Kat Ta e^iy?. ena, €7tet ovv y]v etTtwv ev

ToaovTotg eTttyeip-^ft.aatv ovhaf>.ov 7to6ev eayev dpyyjv to htKaiwfj.a

Kai TO KaTdKptfj.a, oiiQe tovto Ttapopa, dXXd Ti6y]at Xeywv, " waitep
•'
ydp Qtd Tyji ^tapaKo-^g,^' KOt e^^g.

ai Iva. (oaTrep e^aaiXevaev 77 afiapria ev tco OavaTco. ^c

rENNAAioT. n<TT€ (pYjatv avavTtppyjTOv OTt Ka6d7t€p y] dfA.apTia

eauT^f 6avdTW Kat htd tov 6avdTov ^vvaaTetav CKpd-

TY]V

Tnvev, OVTW Kat

"
€v Tco
\f/
%aptg
y]
\>-v~~~
ty]v ev A.ptaTw Totg Ttaat Ttapeyoft.ev'^
'

OtKatwatv, ev dTeXevr-fjTW ^w^ tyjv /SaatXetav dhtddoyov y]^et.

©EOAapoT. Ta? (SaatXevaat ev tw 6avdTW ty]V dfj.apTiav, ovtwg 50

Xeyet' fj.et^ova 7t€pt to dft.apTdveiv p07tv]v 6vY]Tot yeyovoreg eayv]-

KafLev. 7toXXa fnev yap dito Y^ovy]g, TY]g itept t€ (3pwai,v Kai vtoaiv,

Kat Tov e^w6ev KoafKov, Kat fi.vjv Kat Tag twv yvvatKwv eTttfit^iag
eyytveTai Y]fj.7v 7tTaiafj.aTa, e</> eKdaTov tovtwv, ovk €7r< tov
 VI. I. PX2MAI0TS EniSTOAHN. 57

irp€iTOVTo$ Twv 7ioWS)V /(7Ta/w.cvwv, aW £/f a[X€Tpiav CKCp^pofJievwV

TovTa t\ oSavaTw fxev ovk av iroTe eyyevono (f>v(xei' itoia yap

Y^ovfi ; Tii ^e (pikapyvpia eiri Tyjg adavaTOv yjapav e^et (f>vaeci)g ;

eTrei^yj ^e OvyjToi yeyovafxev t€ Kai e<Tfxev Tr]V <f>v(Tiv, acparov

fxev Tiva airo tSiv 7rpoeipyjf*.eviov Tradav tvjv evo-x^Xy^aiv virofxe- 5

fxevofxev, noXKyjv ^e tvjv iiepi to afnapTaveiv ponyjv evTevOev ^eyo-

fieOa. KaKxg ovv e(f)y] ^aciKevcjai ev tw BavaTW ti^v afnapTtaVf

ft.ovovovy) KpaTovaav yjfjLav ^ia Trjg evovcrvji yjfuv evrevBev irep) to

afiapTaveiv poiryjg. wcr-^ep ovv tot€ (f>yi(Tiv, yj afxapTia yjft.U)v eKpd-

Tet (TvvwBovfxevwv eir avTyjv, Kat yrapa yvw fuvjv itoKXaKK;, ovtw Vf] 10

y] Tov Qeov KaQe^et ^ p a (f>tXoTifx'ia, aadXevTov tvjv ^aaiXeiav

iyovaa ev yffxiv, htettav t^*- aiwviov ^wvjg KaTa^twdevre^ ^ta Tyji;

avaaTtxa-iWi ev aXyjBtvyi Kot /Se^aia TVf ^tKatoavvyj ^tdyetv fji,e\-

XofxeVf a.ft.apTeh ovk eTrt^heyofxevoi.

I T/ o^v ipov/JLev ; iiniievoviiev Trj a/jLapTia. 15

rENNAAiOT. Ta vpoXa^ovTa etpYiKwq eirt avaTaaei tov

irept TVjg KaTo. ILptaTOV yaptTOi Xoyov, avveihev eK tovtwv ayTW

TtKTOft.evy]v avTiSeatV Kat TavTVjv avTtSetg, ws airo tov evav-

Ttov T*/v Xvaiv avT^g layypoTaTyjV epyd^eTatf Kai ^yjaiv, " t<

" ovv epovfnev ; eTrifxevovfj.ev t^ afxapTia tva 17 %«/"? nXeovaayj ; 20

" fxy) yevotTO." apa oi/v (f)y)a}v, eK ye wv e(py}v, cy^ ene^afiapTyjTeov

vifuv, Kai TavTYf T^y 'Xpiptv TroiyjTeov nXetova Te Kai fxet^ova. etirep

ovv irpoi TO Twv yjfiiTepwv irXyiBog afxapTYifxaTWV Kai y] TavTyji

av^eTai <f)vaig. eotKe Se fxaXtaTa toDto, tw " (f)aat Ttveg yjfJ.ag Xe-
" yetv, TrotYiawfxev ra KaKa, iva eXSyj to. ayadd." fny} yevotTO (pY/ai' 25

Tcwf wf avoaiov iraVTOg Xoyiafxov tov Xoyov aTryjv^aTO. fxeTa tovto

^e ^^>7 Kai Xoiyiafxolg dvafj.(f)tXeKToti ^ TYfv aTOTriav avTov ^te-

**
Xeyyet, Kai (f)i^atv, otTtveg direBdvofJ.ev TYf dfj.apTia, irwg eTi

" ^yjaofJ.ev ev avTYf ;" towto Xeyetv dv ^yjatv eyotev ot aapKtKot

Te Kcti airtaTot. yjfj.ag fievToi twv TravTairaatv d^vvdTwv eaTtv avBtg ^q

dvafStwvat t^ df>.apTta tov$' aTra^ diroBavovTag avTyj.

AioACPOT. " T/ ovv epovfxev," (pyjaiv, " eirtfj.evovfj.ev t^ dfxap-

** aa^paXwg
Tia, tva yj ydptg TrXeovdayj ; fi.y) yevotTO." eiryiyaye

2 Cod. avefMptXfKTOti,

I
 58 EHHrHSlS EI2 THN HPOS VI. 3.

ro **
fjiv] ykvoiTO'" ov yap 01 KaKoreyyag a[xapTavovTe$ acptaewi
a^ioif aXX' 01 ^ia pa6u[xiav Kai aitpoae^iav tck; Tiapa rov ^ta^o-

Xov (AiOo^^eiai ^e-xo[/.evoi, ovroi e\ee7a6ai '^iKaoi Ttapa rov Seov.

" 0" riveg aireOdvofxev r^ dixaprta,, ttco^ ert ^'^awfA.ev ev avr^ ;

CTTfi^T; PaTTTti^OfJ.evoi 0[Ao\oyovft.ev diioreGvyjKevat tw Kocrfxw^ Kat ^

dirordrrecxQat t-^ dfuaprta Kat rw ^ta^oXa.

KE<>. H.

Ilfpt Tijf 6(l>fiKonevTjs enl Tfj ttiotci irpd^eas dya6rjs.

3 *H dyuoeire otl o(Tol e^airTLcrOrniev ety ^pLcnov

'lr)<Tovv. 10

**
Ktpiaaot. Be^avTiafJieQa fxev ofi,oXoyovfj.eva>g eig ro ovofJia

**
rov Harpog Ka\ rov Ttov Kot rov 'Ayiov Uvevfit.aTOf'^* ei Se S*j

\eyot ag elg Xpiarov li^aovv ^i(3aTtrtafj.eBa^ ovk e^a rov etKorog

epei' fj.dki(jra fj.ev yap ovofKaat re Kat v^oardaeat Kat irpoaw-
•nav ^ta(popa7g ei<; i^^tKvjv ereporyjra ^tear^^^ei nwg YlaTfjp vpog i^
Tiov, Kat irpoi dft.(pw ro Ylvevfj.a. Ylarvip ydp eartv 6 Ylar^pf
Kat oyp^ liog l tog av iraXtv Kara cpvatv eg avrov, Kat ov
'
Har^^p. Ylvevfj.a le i^tKwg ro YlvevfA.a ro Aytov. eiret^r] ^e ev

Ylarpt fj.ev eartv Tiog, ev T/a5 ^e Ylary^p, ovrog ev afX(poh rov

Aytov Y\vevfj.axog ^ta ro rrjg ovaiag ravrov, Kav et ev rtg ovo- 20

fj.davf ^vvdft.et Bewpfifj.drwv rriv rov nravrog ^^Kwaiv eitoffjaaio.

ovKovv Xptarov ovofJ.daag, ovk dfj.vYifj.ovevaet rov Ylarpog y} rov

Ylvevft.arog,

^EiTiet^yj ^e yevofxevog dv6pw'7rog, rov virep r^g dirdvrwv ^wjg

dverXfi Qdvarov 'I>ja«i/f * KeywpvjKev dvayKaiwg fxaKaptog 25

YlavXog eirt ro ort ft.dXtara ry 'TrpoKeiy.evv} f*.vaTaya:yttx. j^e/w-

^ecTaToV e^ei yap ovofJ.aarat * tov jre^TrovQora. ravrvi rot (pi^atv,
**
ort oaot epairriaS^^fi.ev etg Xptarov Iviaovv, eig rov Bdvarov
" afTOu e(3airria6vjfi.ev." 7rpoKara6eft.evoi yap wairep ro eK avvet-
d-^aeag op6vjg dya6ov €7repu>rvjft.a etg Hptarov, koi Triaret irapo^e-^o

^dfxevot, ori Kat dire6avev vvrep vjfxwv Kat erd(f>vi Kat dvejStw, rvjv

" Sic.
VI. 3- PnMAlOTS EniSTOAHN. 59

cuftecnv twv aff.apTi(ov fay^yjKafxiv ^ia tov ayiov /SairTia-fJiajQg,

Kai TV}v T^f dfxapTiai viro[x.evovTei veKpcocriv Kai olov too Si yjfJias

TeQvewTyi ^ avva-noBv^crKOVTeif ^ia to veKpovv toc fJieXrj to, eici r^f

*'
yyjg. o jtiev yap 'KpiaTog t^ dfj.apTia dTieQavev ecf^dira^. o ^e
*'
^-yj Tw 0eco." y^fJ.etg te tov 'laov avToo OdvaTov v710y.evofi1.ev, Kai 5

fj.ovovovyjL (TvvTeGdft.fi.eGa, t^v avTov veKocoaiv irepi^epovTeg ev i^ioig

a-cofiaat' (xvveTd(f>Yjfj.ev Se to5 'KpiaTw. t/ hv] dp evT€v$ev diroKep-

'*
"^aivovTeg, cra(f)VjViei Xeyoov avTOi, iva oocniep vjyepQy] X.piaToc Ik
*'
veKpm ^ia Trjg '^o^vjg tov YlaTpog, ovTOog Ka\ ^fieig ev KaivoTvjTi

" l^WYji TtepiTTaTyja-iofLev.^^ Jo

Ae? yap yjfJLdi cog avvTeGafkft.evovg Kai avvavi(TTaaGai vorj-

Twg. Kai eiirep €<TTi TeBvdvai t^ dfj.apTia to avvSanTeaBai T<e

^piaTw, dvjXov dv e^iVj ^yjTTOvGev ug 0^5^ CTepov ti to avvaviaTaaOai

vooTt av eiKOTwg 7rA»;v OTi to ^v ev ^iKaioavvy]. eyy\yepGai fii.yjv

tiafSelSaiovvTai X.piaTOV tta T^jg ^o^rjg tov YlaTpog, ovy^ wf 15

iayvog eTri^ed' Kai ydp eaTiv avTog 6 tcov tvvdfj.ecov ILvpiog' dXX
OTi Ta vTiep dvOpooTTov (f>vaiv t^ Tvjg dvcoTdTco. (f>vaeci}g ^o^i^ Ttpoa-

aiTTeiv eBog, avTco Te \piaTco Kai To7g avTov. ovkovv Kav eiTi

XeyoiTO KaTopBovv Seog Kai YlaTYjp, ovk el^eKevovft.ev TVjg e(f>

airaaiv evepyeiag avTov tov Tlov. el ydp TidvTa "yeyovev S/ avTov, 20

itwg dv evtoidaeiev Tig ag evyjpyyjKe tid Tlov Kai avTov tov dyiov
acofiaTog tyjv dvaaTaaiv. Kai yovv Tiog evepyov eig tovto ^eiKVvg
*'
eavTOv Toig ^Jovdaioig, e(f>aaKe XvaaTe tov vaov tovt6V, Kai ev

" Tpiaiv y]fj.epaig eyepca avTOv^ dBpei ^>; ovv oncog avTog eyeipeiv

enayyeXXeTai tqv itiov vaov, KaiTOi tov Seov Kai TlaTpog ava- 25
aTy^aai 'keyofj.evov. ettei^ ydp eaTiv avTOg yj ^cooTioiog Qvvafj.ig

Tov Seov Kai YlaTpog, tov itiov e^coo-noiei vaov.

rENNAAioT. laTe TovTO TrdvTcog, <f>y}aiVf wg to ^piaTOv ^diTTi-

afia Tvnov eyfiv avTov, TovTe BavdTov (f>afiev Kai Tvjg dvaaTdaecog.

ot TOivvv TovTo TtiaTet te^dfx.evoi, TipotyjXov ag eTti TaTg eXmatv ^o

avTo TavTatg ei\y)(f)afj.ev'' tva coaTtep vjyepByj X.ptaTog eK veKpm eig

vioBeatav em^o^ov, tovto ydp Xeyei " 'htd TVjg to^vig tov YlaTpog^^
ovTCo Kai v]fj.€Tg tov BavdTov KeKOivcovvjKOTeg aiiTCX) &<a tov ^anTt-^

^ In marg. yp. reOveZTi.

I 2
 60 EHHrHSIS EIS THN nP02 VI. 5.

cr/AaTOf, koivtovoi fjfji.ev r^g aKfipaiov Kai aTraXatctiTov Kai 7ra[/.[JLa-

Kapiag eKeivyjg ^a^c.

©EOAnPOT. H OVK i<7Te, (f>yj<TlV, €K€7vo, OTl TO ^aTtTKTfXa

KOivavovg Ttoiu tov OavaTov tov lLpi<TTOv ; Kat yap (auitep <7vv-

BaTTTeadai '^OKovfxev avTw l3a7rTi^o[/.evoi KaTo. ye tov tvttoV oxTTe 5

TrpoaviKeiv yjfJ.ag, KaBdiiep K.vpiog eK veKpSov avauTag eig CTepav

KaiVYiv Tiva KaTe<TTV) ^(oyjv, ovTUf Kai avTovg ev Kaivyj tivi ^ciivj

KaQecTTavai /xera xo /SaTTTiCTjOta, Xoyi^ofji.evovi a£,iov eTri^eiKvvaBai

Tov (3iov TVjg ^w^f eKeiVYjSf elg ^v tia tov ^ainiafj.aTog yeyevyia6ai

7ii.aTevofj.ev. 10
Sethpianot. To ev KaivoTi^Ti ^(ayjg eaTi^ to Kaivyjg tivo$ Kai

veag evap^aadai ^w^f, tvjv 7raXaiav tvjv ev <xfj.apTiati a7roBefJ.evovg'

Kat yap yj (xvayevvvjatg Katvov Tivog ^iov Kai veov noXiTetav eTtay-

yekkeTai.

5 Et yap aviJL(f)VTOL yeyopa/jLeu rw ofxoLcofxaTL tov Ba- 15

vaTOV avTOv.
Ktpiaaot. yipyjvat, (^yjaiv Beaiteaioi Y\.avXog ' Tovg avvTe-

6af/.fxevovg ^ptaTco Kat avvavaaTVjaeaBai TtpoaOoKav' Kat to fxev

" avfj.(f)VTOi* TO oiovei avfi.f*,op(poi re Kai TavToet^eig vovjTag

VTreft.(j)Vjveiev aV 7iXyiv eKeho TteptaBpeh avayKcuov. TeSetKev vTtep 20

v]fj.(tiv TVjv eavTov ^v^^i^v Kff.fKavovi^X, Kat aiteQave KaTa aapKa.

avvTe6dftf/.e6a ^e awTcS, Tiva hv) TpoTtov vjf^eii ot ^ l3e(3a7rTtafj.evot ;

apa wg dvaTXdvTeg avv avT^ tov T^g aapKog 6dvaTov ; ov f/ievovv.

Ttag ovv apa avfj.(f)VTOi yeyovafnev rco OfJ.ot(i}fi.aTt tov 6avaTOV

avTov ; (f>€pe ^>j «^e/^e, Xeya^fnev' d7te6ave fj.ev yap KaTa aapKa 25
Xp<o'TO«', tva Xvayj tov Koafj.ov tt^v dfi.apTiav. d7to6v^aKOfj.ev oe

v]ft.e7g ov KaTaye tvjv adpKa woflev, aAAa TJj dfnapTta Ka6a ye-

ypavtTat' TovTeaTtv depy"!^ re Kat a7tpaKT0V ev eavToHg a7to(f)ai-

vovTe? T^v dfj.apTiaVi ^ia tov KaTaveKpovv Ta fj.eXvj Ta eTti Tvjg

yvjf' Ttopvetav, dKadapatav, itdBogy e7tt6vfxtav kukyjv Kai tvjv irXe-So

ove^iav.

Y.vfJ.(f)VTOt '^vf ovv yeyovafkev, ovyt Vff fiovov tw Kara (rapKa

6avdT(i Xp/o-Tov, aAAa Kctt tw ofxota>fxaTt tov BavaTOV avTOV.

TovTO S av eivai vooito to VTtep TVjg dfxapTiag d^to^aveh^ Kat ovj^

c Cod. ^(^aimvfjUyov.
 VI. 5- PiiMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 61

vTrep T€ rrjg i^tai' ttoK^qv ye ko,) ^ei. Koi yap eariv afxufAo^ 6

Seo^, Kai TQv ^vvacSai TrXvjfj.iJi.eXetv aTtwTaTd}' aXX' tva wg e<py]v,

vnep Trji tqv KoafjiQv afJLapTias. "b yap a/neOave Tvj afj.apTia, aTre-
** 6avev ecfxxTta^y qvkovv <TVfj.(f>VTOi yeyovaft.ev toj OfJ.Qiafj.aTi. tqv
Qavdrov avTov. e(rofj.eda oe Ttdvrooi avf/.(pvTQi Te Kai TavToei^eTf 5

Kai Tvjg avaaTaaeag avTov. ^i^aofii.e6a yap ev 'KpiaTa' Kai dva-

jSictiaeTai fj.ev vj aap^, ^vjaotj.e6a ^e Kai Ka6 eTepov Tpoitov avTCOf

^TTjv QiKeiav avadevTcg t|^yx>jv, fj.eTaaTOLyeiovfKevQi Te npoi dyiaafj.ov,

Kat etg evKked TiQkiTeiav ev Ayta YlvevfLaTt.

©EOACPOT. ^YjKov Ve dpa KaKeho (pYjatv, ag qvk eveaTi tvtti- io

Ka^ KQtvavriaavTei tco 6avdTo>, y.vj Kat tvj^ dvaaTdaeaq eir avToo

Tv^^erv Tav iipayfj.dTm. KaXag ^e etiie tq **

avfj.<pVTQt,^' Ttepi tc
veKpccaecci Kat ^ctiOTrot^aectis ^taXeyofnevQg' eTtet^v^ Kat tcov (pvTav

i^tov eaTi TO veKpova6ai fi.ev ev Tvj (pvTeia, fj.e6laTaa6at Ve eiri

TO KpeiTTOv kai ev^^o^eTepov iroAAoo. Kai eiKOTcoi diro twv irapovTUV i

^
Ta fj.eXkQVTa entaTcaaaTQ' e7re<B»; yap ^vjKov i^v ci>g YVvevfuiTQg

fxeTei^xov ev tco ^anTtafj.aTt' tqvtq te vn avTccv aa^pag e^^eiKvvTo

Twv 'npayf/.dTcov' KaXwg dno tqv (f)aivQfi.evov Tore to fivj^eTrco ^^Xqv

avTOvg eirtaTcaaaTQ.
AioAapoT. AKpil3wg to avfj.(pvTov Te6etKe' twv yap avfj.ne- 20
(pVTevfxevctiv npeft.vcov eig ravTQ evovrai iiQKXdKtg v] (pvatg Ota t^^

KoXXvjaecog' ovrccg ovv Kai ot yvvjatag paTtriadevTeg etg rov 6ava-

TQV TQv Kpiarov, evQvvrat avrco ^ia rvjg ntaTeag.

npirENOTS. YiXaaag to 0VQfA.a re6eiKe (pvrov rt, eTnardfj.evog

Tov Jvjaovv 6dvarQV (pepov Kapnovg avatperiKQvg r^g dff.aprtai' w 25

(pvrcJo 6 Xoyog yecopyeT ev roTg itapate^afj.evotg rviv ^t^aaKaXtav
rvjv ^ia Kpiarov, Ttotm avrovg avfj.<pvrovg ra Ofj.Qtcafi.aTt rov

6avdrQV eKeivov , ^vvarat vj dv6pcoTttvv] (pvatg dvaXaj3e7v, rov Se

CKeivov 6dvaTQV rov dfnaprtav ft.v] TtQf^aavrog, fj.v]^e yvovrog dfj.ap-

Tiav, aXX a'7to6avovrog eiti tv] Ka6atpeaet, ovyj. T^f ev avra dfJ.ap-20
riag, dXXa rvjg ev vjfuv, ovy^ Qtov re eartv ditoBaveh rtva rav

v]fuitpTVjK0Tcov' " Ttdvreg ^v] v]fj.aprQV Kat varepovvrat TV]g ^o^^vjg rov
" ©€0v, ttKatQVfLevot ^copeav," Kat ra e^v]g.

d Quae sequuntur non satis cohaerent.

 62 EHHrHSIS EIS THN nPOS ¥1.6.

ANflNTMON. Ev akXoig ^e Keyet, *'

avv^yetpe Kai avveKoi-
" 6iaev ev To7g enovpavtoig ev "KptaTw' Kat ei avvyjyepdrjTe tw
^*
•*^
XptarcOf Ta avw ^fjTene.^^ itag ovv evTavOa Xeyei, Kat ryjg
" avaaTaae(i)i; eaoixeOa ;" Trpog tovto XeKTeov OTt ^tTTag ovatxat^ei
TVjV avdaTaatv o AiroaToXog' ^tav [xev t^v ^^17, Ka6 yjv 6 aytog 5

avvaveaTYj 'KpiaTcOf Kai avveyepSetg «yT», Ta avco ^fiTeX' erepav

^e Tyjv OTav eXBri to TeXetov, -Trep) ^g Ka) AavivjX 7rpo(f>yiTev(ov

(pi^ai, " TToXXot Tm KaQevhovTCov ev yvjg ycofxaTt avaaTTjaovTat,

" ovTot eig ^covjv aicoviov, Kat ovtoi etg ovet^ta[j,ov Kat eig aia-
" 50*^"^'' atcovtovJ" Tyjv erepav fxev ovv rav dvaardaecov 01 aytot 10

epovai avveyriyepOai ra yLptarca' Kara te ryjv erepav Kat ava-

arYiaeaBat.

6 TovTo yLV(D(TKOVTes, OTL 6 7raXaL09 rjixoii' avOpamos.

KxPiAAOT. T;f **
iraXatog vjfxwv dvSpcoTrog," nohv Se " ro
" aafJM. ryjg dfxaprtag ro Karapyovfxevov,^^ Kai riva ^yj rpoTtov 15

avveaTavpcoOv) Yiptarca, iioXviipayfKoveh dvayKahv. 'tacog fi.ev ovv

otyjaovrat rtveg dfxapriag etpyjaQat acofia ryiv dito y^g adpKa,

KaBditep ev rd^et ^iKVjg t'^ tov dvBpcoTtov to&eiaav 'ipvy^yj, ^ta ro

Kat Ttpo acofxdrcov vjfi.apTi^Kevat. ^oKei yap a>Se rtat Kat <ppoveiv

Kat Xeyetv. 'KXXyjvcov ^e ovaav ryjv to^av cog ovk dXyjB^ ^icoaoo- 20

fji.e6a. aSifi.a rotvuv dfJLaprtag Kai itaXatov y}f>.cov avSpcoTtov ro aa>fji.a

Xeyet ro dito yy^g e^/ov coaitep eK TraXaioryjrog ryjg ev A^dft. ro Ka-

Ta<pdeipea6at ^eiv' Ka\ KaTa^e^tKdaft,e6a ydp ev eKeivco Kai itparco'

YjppooaryiKog te Ttpog rovrca Kai ro (piX-^^ovov. ej^o/ ydp ovrco Kard

(f)vatv yj adp^ e^ ea(f)vrcov Ktvy}f/.dTCov. 25
Ylag ovv apa avvearavpcorat aito yvjg rco Kptarw ; yeyovev
avdpcoitog ft.ovoyevy]g, Kai adpKa t>jv dito yyjg y)fj.TteayeTo Karap-
pcoarovaav, cog 'e(f>y}v, cog eK TtaXaiOTyjrog ryjg ev A^dfn, rov 6dva-

roV mivovaav ^e coaitep ev eavr^, Kat to e^ efn,(pvTcov Ktvy]ft.dTcov

aKovda6ai Ttpog dfLapTiav' Karyipefj.el fJ.ev ryjg dfj.apTtag vofJ.og 30

ev ryj dyia Kat itavdyvce aapKt rov KptaTov, Kai ovri itov KeKtvy^-

a6ai (pafj.ev ev avrcp rd rm dvSpcoTtivcov itaOm eKToitcorepa' TtXyjv

oaa ryjv Ktv^atv d^id/3Xy]T0v 'e^xjet' ro Ttetvyjv ^e Xeyco Kat ro ^txp^v

Kat To KOTttdv Kai oaa Kat Ttap yjfi.h rvjg (pvaecog vofxog efa»
VI. 6. Pi2MAI0TS Eni2TOAHN. 63

TiTYjpriKev aiTta<;' 0[ji.<t}( e/ Kai [x^ K€KivvjTai tv-^ov ev Xp/aTw

T^g afxapTiag 6 voixoi, liaTOi to Kary}vva(76ai ttj tov oiKOVOfxovv-

T0$ koyov ^vvdfjiei re Kai evepyeia' aAA' ovv orav avTi] KaB
eavT-fjv V) TVjg aapKog ^oKifjid^eTai cpvatgf xav et ev X|3/(7Ta) vooTto

Tvyov, ovy^ erepav ovaav napa ttjv yjfxm evp-^(70fj.ev. avveaTavpa}- $

fxeBa Totvvv avTw aTavpadeiai^i avTOv TVjg aapKog, Kat oiov o\yjv

eyovayig ev eavTjj tvjv (pvatV KaQdvep dfiekei Kai ev Ahafx, ot€

•yeyovev eitdpaToq, oXy] vevoayjKe Tijv dpav rj <pvaig' ovto) yap Kai
avveyyjyepBai XeyofxeQa tco 'KptaToo' avyKaBi^aBai Ve Kat ev Toig
eitovpavtotq' ei yap eaTtv vnep y]f>.dg wg Seog 6 Eifi.fJLavovy)X, «AA lo

ovv eTietTOi yeyove KaO yjfmg wg elg e^ rjfx.m, eyyjyepTai tc Kat

avvehpevei tx ©e» Kal YlaTpL

YiVveaTavpwByi toivvv o iraXatog a,v6pa}7rog' XekvTai yap ^ta t^^'

avaaTdaecog T^g dpy^atag CKeivyjg dpdg yj ^vvafntg' Kar-^pyyjTai Be

Kai TO awfxa TVjg dft,apTiag, Kat ovj^/ ^^ TrdvTCog yj (rdp^, dkXa 15

Tav ev avTYf KtvyjfxdTxv y} eft.(pVTOi dypiOTVjg, Karaaeiaovaa fnev

det Ttpog Ta aiay^to) tov vovv' evteiaa %\ coaitep Tiyjkw Kai rekfiaai

Taig yeui^eaTepatg yj^ovatg. oti ydp ev X.piaTw Kai tovto Karap-

BcoTat TV] avQpwTreKX <l)vaet' nag dv ev^otdaeie Tig Ilavkov Xeyov-
*'
Tog evapycog, to ydp d^vvarov tov vdfJi.ov, ev w yjaBevei ^id t^j- 20
'*
aapKOg, 6 Seog tov eavTov T/ov irefi.xpag ev 6fii.otoof>.aTi aapKog
*'
dfxapTtag, KareKptve tyjv dfJiapTiav ev Tyj aapKt. opdg oiiv oitcog

TO TVjg dfJiapTtag KaTyjpyyjrat a(ofi.a. KaraKeKpiTai yap ev Trj

aapKt TVjg df>.apTtag to Kevrpov, Kat veveKpcorai fnev ev vpcoTO}

\piaTa}' tial3el3y]Ke ^e itap avTov Kai ^< aiiTov Kai etg y]fj.dg iy 25

rENNAAiOT. YlaXaiov avQpcoTTOv, TOV (pBaprov Xeyei Kat irddy]-

ToV cog Ty]g 7taXatoTy]Tog (pBetpovayjg rov coaitep av e-niytvotTO'

dfJ.apTtag le acofjia <f>y)<7t, to fj.y]KeTi fjievov tq dvafj.dpTy]Tov, dXX'

e7tioe')(pfi.evov dfj.apTtav. tovto rotvvv Karapyeirat (f>y](7i, rovreaTt 30

avevepyy]Tov Ttpog tvjv dft.apTiav KaBtararat. ^io Kat ovy^ ditXcog

e<py] KaTapye7a6at to aSifJM, aXXa to aafj.a TYig dfxaprtag, tovto

yap (pBaprov ov vvv, ev^verat acpdapatav' Ka\ 6vy]rov ov vvv, ev^v-
aerai a6avaatav, fteraayji^fi.art^ovTog y]fj.(ov ro acofLa ryjg raTtei-

vcoaecog rov ^eaTtorov Kpiarov, itpog to yevea6at avro avfj.fj.op(pov$$

 64 EHHrHSIS EI2 THN HPOS VI. 8.

Tco (TWfJiaTi rvji ^o^yji avTov. o ya.p airoBavm (pi^rriVf '^e^iKaiccTai

airo T^j" dfxapTias. ri tovto eariv o Xeyei ; tuv ^covtwv TavTYjvi

rrjv ^(tivjv ro Trraietv euTiv. eirei^r] nai rov vofjiov eyjeiv tovtcov

earr To7i TerekevrvjKoai ^e TtpoayjKei tovtcov ovterepov. ovre yap

vofJ.os Tw reSwjKOTi itpoG^tiakeyerai' ircog yap ra ye fXYj^e aKOvovri ; 5
Kai dfxapria rov roiovrov ov ^iOj^Ae?. ra roivvv aTioQavQVTi (pi^a-tv,

Qv^ev Ttpoi T^v djxapTiav koivov' ov^e avrv] irpog eKeivov ej^e* ro

^iKaiov. ov^e yap to5 7rkif]fj.[ji.e\eiv vTrOKeirai rov Xonrov.

0EOACPOT. Aeyei Ka) ro irdQo^ rov Kvpiov e-ni riaiv eyevero,

eii fxei^ova Triariv rav elpvifj.evm, eneihri yap vito ryjv aTtocf^aa-iv 10

yevofxevoi rov BavdroVf irXe^arov oaov eTtippeirearepov irpog ro

dfj.apTdveiv viro T^f BvrjroTyjros eytvofJ.eda, r£ X.ptarw (pvfatv

€aravpQ)fj.evw, wairep airaaa '^fj.cov vj vno rvfv dvi^roTVjTa Keifxevvj

(fjvaig avveaTavpaBvj, eTrei^vj Kat irdaa avrw avvavearvj. Travrcov

avOpcoircov avrw avfj.fj.eraayeh e\7rt^ovrcov r^s avaardaecog. cog 15

evrevQev avvacpavtaBvjvai fxev rvjv irept ro dft.aprdvetv vjfxcov evKo-

Xiav, ^ia rvjg eitt rvjv dQavaaiav rov acofLarog fj.eraardaecoi'

yevvjOvjvat ^e Kat vjfj.dg e^ca Karaarvjvat t^$ tov dfjMprdveiv

dvdyKVjg.

Sethpianot. Ot Kara rov iraXaiov avBpcoirov ^mreg, acofna 20

e-^^^ovatv dfj.apTiag TtpOKetfievov ra diaPoXco etg eTtiPovXdg' ot ^e

Kara rov veov rov K.vpiov vjfncov Ivjaovv \piaTOV, awfxa ^iKato-
avvvjg' eiret^^ Kai fLeXvj tov JLvpiov etatv, ovkovv roi) ^ia/Sokov

rovg dvBpconovg e^epeOi^ovrog dfxapreh, vjTTviBevrog ^td \piaTov,

Kat rco aravpco TrpoaviAcofjeiavig rvjg aapKog rov Aoyov, Ttovvjpog 25

eK^efBXvirat' Kai eXevBepta^ovat vvv ot (3ovXof*.(vot. yap ditoBa-
voiv Kara rov rov ^aTtriaff.aTog Xoyov, rco KOafJ.co aiteBave, Kat
te^tKaicarat Kai ditvjKkaKrai rifj.ci)ptagy rvfg df^apriag ditak-
Xayetg.

1 Et 5e aireOavofiev arvv \pLaTm. 30

rENNAAioT. OvKovv, (f)Vjai, KaBdvtep yiptarog, Kat vj/j.eTg

anoBvvjaKOfLeVf KaBditep ^piarog ^i^aofj.e6a Kai vjfj.e'tg. vpoa-^Kei

ovv etg eKeivov vfxh d(f>opdv' Kat aitep eKehov aita^ aTtoBavovra
rvj afi.apTta, eira avaardvra rco Qew, rcov o^vvdrm eartv avBig
dfToBaveiv, ovrco oeoi dv Ka\ vfxdg Xoytafxw -yjxofxevovg ^tKatordrcaiS
VI. 8. P12MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 65

TOv eavTav tov Xonrov Piov ev Ty] KaTo. 'KpiaTov paQvfAi^eiv ^so^

wg eXTTt^i Tipo^ TavTvjv fji.eTa^el3yjK0Tai ck T^f iipoT^pag.

AlOACPOT. E< jtACV •flV hjVaTOV (f>Yj<Jl TOV 'K.piaTOv Kat ^tg Kai Tpti

dirodaveTv VTiep tcov dfxapTavovTwv, tcrwg dKivOvvov yjv iiit tvjv tra-

katov Tuv dfmpTfjfxdTm 7ra>^ivdpofii^a-at avv^Qetav, ofnotav eyovaiv 5

dei Kat TYjg tptXavQpooTriag e^irt^a. et ^e aira| dnodavav ovk eTt

diioBvyjaKet, ovTd) Kat rjft.eTg crvvTacpevTeg avTta Kat avveyepdevTei,

ovKeTt Tati dfxapTtaig diroOv^aKOfiiev. ov ydp eaTi oevTepov (3a-

TTTtafiM ovre tevrepog Xp/oToD QdvaTog, ^to da(pakeaTepov Oet

l3tovv. " yap diteBave tyi dfxapTta., dneQavev e<f)aira^. TovTeaTtv i o

virep Toiv dfi.apTi(iv tcov dvBptOTttvm' " b Se ^]^, tS) Oeo5 ^]^." tovt-

eaTtv elaaei tyf, are §>; ©eof wV ovT<ag ovv Kat vfJieig TaHg dfxap-

Ttatg veKpa6y]T€' tw Se Sew ^aaaTef ^i' ov ^Te.

Ka/ ovTO) voYiaetgy (oaitep XeyofJLev, eirt tov KaB Yjft.dg avBpv-

TTov, dtieBave ttj aapKtf ^y} ^e Tfi ^vyvi, KaTo. toTtKYiv d-noOtOovTef 15

Tov Koyov, ovTCi) fj.ot voet " tx Sea ^^'" TovTeaTi to etvat Qeog,

ovK eTret^vj Koti to elvai y\nr/yj ovk e^ij, aAXa to afj.ayjaTepov eOyjKe

TO eivat avTOv Seov.

** ^avaTO? avTov
'ripirENOTS. ^ AttoTeTokfJ.Yjix.evwg e7it(f)epet to
" ovK€Tt Kvptevei'" mep eaTi ^va(f)r]f>.oet^eg. ot yap "nkHaTot 20
(ftaatv diToBaveh avTOV' ovto}^ KvpteveaSai ano tov BavaTov, aXXa
Tco CKOVTa Tyjv xpvyYjv avTov TtBeiKevat virep t£v itpo^aTav eauTov,

Yl inrep tc5v (piXwv eavTov' (fivjaiv yap Kat avTOg "^(DTVjp, " ovOetg

" atpei TTjV 4^vy-^v fLov dn efxov, dXk ey(b TtByifxt avTVjv att

*'
efxavTov." fnev ovv Ttg itpog Toina (f^Yjaiv, oti BdvaTog XeyeTai 25

vvv fxeaog Ka\ d^tdcpopog, ov KaTa to KOtvoTepov aneBavev, OTe wg

(pYiaiv YlavXog, " diteBave KaTo. Tag ypafpdg." dXXa Trcag TavTV}

^vv^aeTat avvayopevaai t'^ '^ti^y^aei to " aTreBdvoixev avv \ptaTW,

Kat TO, " yap dneBave t^ dfxapTta, dneBavev e^paTta^ ;" aXX tacog

ToiovTog epe7, wg to, avTo, ovofxaTa TtBi^at '^tTTCog vj ypa^pYf itoTe^o

fjiev eitt t£v acofjiaTiKoov, OTe ^e eitt tov Ttvevfj.aTiKov, ceg Kai itept Ti^g

'EafnapeiTi^og yeypafi.fi.evov, ev c5 to v^cap Kat to ittetv KaTo, tov av-

TOv TOTtov, oTe ft.ev eitt tov a(afj.aTiKov' OTe oe eitt tov TtvevfxartKov

TCTdyBat ^oKei' Kat to vept tov BepiafLOv caaavTcag (pi^ai.

^ Leg. pvOiM^fiv. ^ Leg. oi i^.

K
 66 EHHrH2I2 EI2 THN nPOS VI. 12.

^Yjai Totvvv ov^h $av[j.aa-TOV Kara tovtov tov yapaKTy^pa Kal

Tov AttocttoAov elpvjKfvaif to fjuv

" aiieBavofJ^ev avv \pia-TC0f^

ToiaaovTa, ovK (tti tov KoivoTepov Bavajov' to ^e '*

6avaTog avTov
" ovK CTt Kvptevet, a}( Gavarov vvv toi) fJieaov ovofJ.a^oixivov. eT€-

pog ^e TTapa tovtov Ipu oti BdvaTog evTavOa keyeTat Kvptevwv ^

yipiaTOv, ovK aXKog tj eyQpog aiiTOv, ov TOTtog ° riv to KaToc tgv

lctivav KTjTog TrpocpYjTevofJievov, Kat viro tov fw/3 (pdaKovTog, " aXXa
**
KaTepdaatTO avTrjv fxekXm to fx.eya KvjTog yeip^aaaaBai'^^

Tipog Qv BdvaTOV otevcav^ KaTa tov Katpov tov fxeaov BavdTOV eAe-

yev, ov "^ta tov ft.eaov BdvaTov, dXXa tt eKehov " vvv vj xpvy^"^ fuov 10
" TeTdpaKTat, Kat TiepiXvnoi; eaTtv vj xpvyj^ fiov eag OavdTov." olvet

(sic) ydp aTiyjet eig tvjv '/J^pav avTov ^td Toix; KpaTovft-evovi vv
raj^a ota tovto epetaBat tq **
avTOV, (og elg %&2v BavdTOv KaTYj-
" yayeg fne.^^ Kat eavTOv TrefioivjKev avT^ " vnyjKoog yevofi.evog f-^XP^
*'
BavdTov." ota yap to yeyovevat ev avTw KaTaKptdeig vtt' avTOv, 15
KaTeKptve tyjv afj.apTtav, ovaav ev eKetvco tco OavdTuo. cog dv Ttg

Tiapa^etyfj.aTog eveKev, eXevBepog cov, hovkov kavTOv iiapa^ihcoat rco

aTpaTYiych tc5v Tio\efj.t(av, iva nap avTco yevofii.evog, eXevBepcoay}

Tyj eavTov olKovofj.tKYi mvXta Tovg itoXiTag dno tov vti cKeivco

Ktv^vvov oia Tov eveopa tivi dnoKTehai tov aTpaTYjyov, Kat Tovg 20
VTi avTco TioXefJ.tovg. eKvptevBvj yap tovto tpdaag, cog ovk

atXfJ-dXcoTog dXovg, aXXa (ppovyjfnaTi y^Yiaafj.evog dptaTecag' ovTCog

ovv Kat "KpiaTog eavTOv "Tiape^coKe tyi tovXeia, tva fi.Yj^e)g Bavd-
tov yevYfiat tcov f>.aBYjTevofj.evcov avTov tco Xoyco ^ovXog' ovTcog

yap (pYjaiv yj ypa^pYj, " KaT-^pyvjae tov to Kpd^og eyovTa Tot) 25

'*
BavdTov, TOVTeaTi tov ^ialSoXov," Kat Ta e^^g. Tdya ^e koli

Tsap^cDKev eavTOV tco BavaTcp KvpievBi^aofJ.evov, pvofj.evog Tovg vit

avTov KiKpaTYjfxevovg, Kai avT eKeivcov eavTOv napo^ihovg' tva fKeTa

TovTO KaTaaTpaTYjyyjayj Kat KaTapyyjay] tov BavdTov.

12 M^ ovv ^aaiAeveTco tj afiapria ev rm Outjt^ rjfiwv ^o
crcofJLaTL.

AioAflPOT KAi ©EOAflPiTOT. **

M>; TiaptaTdveTe,^^ «/^jo"'? " Ta
*'
ft.eXy} vfj.m OTiXa d^iKiag tyJ df».apTta," avTt tov, fKYj vfi.eig Kaff
'*
eavTcov ^t^oTe oitXa tco iiovyjpw Kai layyv, dfJ.apTdvovTtg' dfnapTta
d Leg. TVTtOi. .
 5

VI. 12. P12MA10T2 EniSTOAHN. 67

'
**
ya^ v\x.m ov Kvptevaet, ov <yap eare vtco vofAOVy aAX' vno "X/xptv.

Tiota dfJiapTta ov Kvpievaet ; vj npo rov ^a-mtcrfkaro^;, vjVTrep a<f>i-

Yjaiv Y) yo.ptg rov ^picrTov. tovto de o vofxog iroteh ovk vjOvvaTo.

ovK €<7T€ vno vofj.oVf TOv fjLvj ^vvdfL€vov pv(ja<j6ai, dXka fxaWov
Ttfji(opovfjt.evov. 5
Oeoacpot. Aeyet acv, ori rovrm ovrcDg ej^ovTwv, ^iKatov

y}ft.ag fXYj afJ.apTaveiv Kara rov itapovra PioV Kav eri dvvjroi

r^v (f^vatv ovT€f, irXetova ey^rjTe tyjv eirt rovro poitYjV eiieihY) ^e

TO (3acriXevetv eTii r^g dfj.aprtag reSeiKe, KaXoig etire, ro " /x»y

*'
Trapiardvere ra fJieXvj v/a»v." Tiapeardvat ydp roig ^aaiXev- lo

(Tiv edog Toy^ Oopv(f)opovi. fXYj rovvvv (pvjaiv wg (BaaiXttii ty)

dfj.apria. (Tirevhovreg vitYiperetaOat, tiaTtpdrrecxBe d ft.y] ^e7. crTtov-

^daare ^e fj.dXkov eavrovg d(f)optaat ric Qew, Kard rovg eK veKpm

dva/3iaaovTag' oXoi ^/ oXm rd ^taKOctoavvvjg epya rtoteiv eaitov-

haKoreg. 1

Savfjiaai<tiTarov ^e avrov ro waei €k veKpav ^oovrag ^eiKvvvrog

ori ov ro npdyfj.a itap avrwv ditaireT, dwd rvjv Kard ro ^vvarov

fj.ifj.Yiatv' ^(£vTe$' ^aev ydp eK veKpm rore eaovrai, vvvt ^e cog eK

veKpav ^mreg (f>Yjaiv, dvrt rov Kard ro ^vvarov eKeivo fj.tfj.ovfJ.evoi'

Kai KaXwg TtetQwv avrovg /x^ ^e^otKevai tyjv itept to dfj-aprdvetv 20

poTtYiv Kai rai evrevBev Kiv^aetg, ei ra t^? yvwfKYig d^epaia aw-
^otTo, eitdyet, " afkapria yap vfj.m ov Kvptevaei^ eitettY\ yap
atto rav fA.eXXovTCtiv fi.Yj ^eiv avrovg dfj.aprdvetv e^e;|ev, aKoXovOcog
eiiYiyayev, ort KparYiaat vfj.xv KaQoXov tyjv dfj.apriav rm d^vvd-
T»V earai yap Katpog fieXXcov, ev co Ttaarjg dfiapTtag aitYjX- 25

Xayfj.evot itoXtrevaeaBe' coare et vvv ra r^g yvcofXYjg vfxav vyiatvot^,

ditav ei^og dfj.apriag ditoaTpe(f>of/.evcov, Kai aitov^^ rd KaXa itoteTv

eOeXovrcov, ov tel te^oiKevat ty^v ent ro yelpov poTtrjV. Xvjxlierat

ydp taatv rovro itdvrcag ev Katpco roS TtpoaYjKovrt, Kai ov "yjiita rcav

Yjfj-erepcov itpog rovro vovcov. Kat ro fnei^ov, '*

ov yap eare VTto vofj.ov, 30
" dxx! VTto ydptvr roaovrov ydp d(pe^er€ rore Kai rt rotovrov Qt-

^otKCvai, coare ov^e vofj.cov vfuv '^e-^aet rcov vTtc^etKvvvTCov d TtpdTreiv

* Cod. iyiaivfi.

K 2
68 EHHrHSIS E[2 THN nPOS VI. la.

Trpoa-^Kei. xapiTi re Kai (pt>,OTi[Xia tov ^e^wxorof TVji tou Flveu-

[xaTOi diTCiXavcreTai ® oujpeag.

rENNAAioT. ^AvaTpirpag eK tS)v Kara •^pKTxwv t>jv avriGeaiv,

Kai tei^ag ovKeTi tov aixapTaveiv avToig ovoafxwg, ag ovk ovaiv eri

fxeTo. TO /^dTTTia-ixa aapKiKo7g' TavTa Ve [xovrj iiiaTei Teocg ov 5

Treipa KeKT-^fxeOa' ovTe yap d7ra6e7g, ovxe dQdvaTOi Titag yeyovafxeVf

Tov TrpdyfxaTog avTOv KOTa Tiva Xoyov a-noppyjTov tw TVjg Koivvjg

dvaaTdaewg (pvXaTTOfxevov Kaipx, avfx^ovXvjv [xeTptav tc avTo7(

Kat Tv}V ev^^e^j^ofxevriv -npoadyet' ov yap ecf)-/}, [xr, ovv dfxapTdveTe.

TovTo yap (jyvaewg ditaBovg re Kat aQavdTov, aXXa " [xri (3aat-io
" XeveTCO yj d[xapTia ev tco BvyjtS!) vfxm,^ KpdTog eyeTw' [xv] oe

^iKv]v oiKeTCtiv TO TTpoaTaTTOfxevov VTt avTYig ev Toig tou aoofxaTog

vj[x<hv eiitBv[xiatg eri TToteiv KaTo^eyeaQe ^, ^opvcpopovg wanep avTVjv

irpog avvepyetav TVjg d^tKiag to, eavTcov irapeyQfxevot [t.eXvi. aXX

diTocpvyovTeg eKeivvjv, Kat 7[oXe[xiav vfuv eivat Kat eyBpav vjyvjaa-^^

[xevoiy KaTa<pvyeTe irpog Qeov, Kat ag adavaTOvg avTix itpog

^tKaioavvYig Kard ttKatoavvvig KaTOpOcoatv eavTovg evTpentaaTe'

" d[xapTta ydp v[xm ov Kvptevaei, ov yap eare vito vofxov aXX
" VTio ydptvr eyvo) tovtov tov aapKiKov eTot[X(iig e^OfxevoV Kai
TVf '^(dpiTi Ttpog d[xdpTV}[xa ditoy^pviadfxevov aoeiav tovto TOtvvv 20
TtpovTtei^ovog (sic) eavTa, tov vap eKeivov Xoyov avQvTto^pepet Kat
(pvjatv.

OpirENOTS. ^AvaTepw [xev el-nev, " iva ooaitep ej3aatXevaev

" vj d[xapTia ev tco fiavccTco." vvvt ^e ovk elite tovto, aXXa, " [xi^

'*
PaaiXeveTO) vj dfxapTta ev tw Bv^Tcp ^ v[xm craj/xaT/." '^t^daKWV 25

oxi warcep Bpovog Kat (SaatXetov eaTi tvjc, dfxapTtag to Svvjtov v}[Xiov

aS>[xa' TO ydp (ppovvifxa T^f aapKOg eyBpa etg ©eov, Kai itdXiv

TO (ppovvj[xa Tvjg aapKog BdvaTog. dXXd Kai itdvTa Ta d[t.apTV}[xaTa

epya aapKog eaTiv, artep 6 AitoaToXog '*

(pavepd" mofxaaev. ev

avTo7g Ve Td^ag kou Tag aipeaetg, e^t^a^ev OTt Ka\ avTai aapKog $0

etatv epyov anoXvov v}[xdg TteptoTtaafxov' tva [xv} vo[xt^a}[xev Ttva

[xev eivat epya aapKog, Ttvd ^e d{xapTV}[xaTa ov aapKog, v}tqi Se

6 Leg. a,TtoKa,ijatTe. f Cod. Karahx^o^Oat. S Cod 6avdr(f)

sed in marg. yp. Ov^t^.
VI. 12. PI2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. G9

ypvyji^i VI vcv. aXX' eirav Tig ^tjttJ TrcUf kui aip€<TCtg T^f crapKOg

elai KaTet\ey[Jicvai, XeKreov irpog avTOv, ort aip€<xetg ytvovTat avro

Tov vov T^g aapKog, irept ov <f)yjai ttov o WavXo(; " etKyj efn^a-
" Tevewv Kai <f>v(Ttovfi.evog viro tov voo^ TVjg crapKog avTov, Kat ov
*'
KpaTWv TVjv Kecf^aX-^v" Taya %\ Kat oie afxapTavofxev ^aatXev- 5

ov<xr}<; Tyjq dfJiapTiai ev tx Bvvjtw yjfxwv awfxaTi, ov^ev aXXo eafxev,

Yjirep TO SvrjTov au)[j.a Kai aapKeg' " ov fi.fj" yap (priat, " KaTa-
" f».eivv] TO TrvevfJid fxov ev Tor? dvSpooTrotg TOVTOig eU tov aiava ^ta
*'
TO eivat avTOvg adpKag." Kat avTYf ^e v) t/^y^»? eoiKe fJLVj fxevetv,

aXX' yjTot "^ta KaKiav yiveaBai aap^, Pi S' dpeTyjv irvevfxa' ot€ yap lo
KokXaTat T7J iropvyj, yiveTat eU adpKa fi.iav irpog avT-^v' 6 ^e koX-

Xwft.evoi Tw Kvptw, ev Ylvevft.a eaTtv.

ToT ATTOT. Kat yjhyj tovto etpyjKev, " ovto) Kat vfJLeig koyi-
" ^eaOe eavTOvg veKpovg fxev eivat ttJ dfJMpTta, ^avTa? Be to5 0eco,"

oi) fuvfv €' yipiaTW l^aov. Ttve<; ^e tovto irpo; dvTtOiaaToXyjv ^S

X-^oVTa- XeyeaOat eTepcav, ot e^yjaav fxev tw Qew, ov fj.ev ev

^piaTco lyjaov. y^fJ.eHi ^e <f>afj.ev, fj.YiiroTe o^vvaTov eaTt f^v /xev

0ea ev \ptaToi li^aov * * * * eiretirep

*'
eihe TYiv "KptaTOv yifxepav Kat eydpy]'^^ etTe Mwo-^^ e^vjae toj

0€co, ev \ptaTx ^lviaov e^y)aev' " oaTtg ye Kat fket^ova TrXovTov 20

" yiy^aaTO tZv AiyvirTOV Byiaavpwv tov ovetOiafj.ov tov KptaTov'"

dXXd KOi 01 eTitQvfj.yiaavTeg voXXoi Trpo<f)^Tat Kat ttKatot iheh a

eJ^ov 01 ^ AiroaToXot, Kat dKovaat a>v yiKovaav, ovk dv yjXOov etg

Tviv Tcov TOiovTWV eiriBvfj.iav Kat ope^iv, e^cy Tvy^f^dvovTeg tov ev

X.ptaTx 'lyjaov ^jiv tw Sew. 25

Zii^T^aetg Be et 5^»/ (f>daKetv irdvTa tov ^avTa tco 0ec5 ev

HptaTa lyiaov veKpov eivat Tyj dfj.apTta.. irpog tovto XeyoiT av, et

fj.€v (og veKpog tv] dfi.apTia e^vi iroTe t'^ dfux-pTia, edv ^e Ttg viro tov

irdvTa epevvwvTOg Y\vevfi.aToq Kai Ta PdByi tov Seov, <f>ci)Tta6eig evpri

Ttvag ywpig tov e^i^Kevat t^ dfJ.apTia noTe ^avTag toj ©eaj ev Xp^cTTW^o

^[yiaov, d7ro<f>aiveTat, oti ovk et Ttg ^^ tco ©eco ev KptaTx li^aov,

ovToj' yj^yi TrdvTwg veKpog eaTt Tyj dfj.apTia, Kat vaTepov veKpog

yevofLevog avTyj e^yiae tw 0eco ev 'KpiaTx ^lyjaov. eTepog ^e e<?ro;

av, 0T< evSe^^eTa* Kat ^t^of>.€vov tov ^ijv Tiva^ Tci5 0eo5 ev Xjs/<tto5
 70 EEHrH212 EIS THN OPOS VI. 15.

[i^(TQv {xvjOeTTOTi yevofxevovi ev dfxapTia, ov^ev vjttov KaKcivovg

V€Kpovg eivai t^i afxapTia' (oaTrep X^ptg vofxov afxapTia vjv veKpa^

ovK €K Tov TtoTe ^"^v eXGoxKJa eiri to yevecrBai veKpd.

AeiKvuai ^e 6 6eToi AiroaToXog Kai eTepcoBev Tvjg viKVjg ti^v

evKoXiav' " afJiapTia yap yjfA.av" <pv}aiVf " ovk ct/ Kvpievaei,^' 5
" ov yap ecTTe,' <pi^ai, " vtto voft.ov dXX vtto ydpiv^ itpoayeq
evTovQot. TYi aTtoaToXiKYj aKpi(Beia' Tiva TpoTiov to Kvpieveiv Tdaacov
'*
eiri Tov 'EcoTy^pog Kai e<f) vjfjiuv. eiii fi.ev tov Y.wTyjpog, flavarof,"

elneVf *'
avTov ovk eTi Kvpievaei." eni ^e vjfxav, " dfLapTia yap
" vfKWV ov Kvpievaei." oWe yap €7ri tov 'EiaTVjpog eTrpeTre Xeye- 10

a6ai TO dfxapTia avTov ov Kvpievaei, «vtc exf) Vff.(t)v KvpiWTepov rjv

TO 6dvaTog vfLiov ov Kvpuvaet. Kai tva ft.y} TavTOV iiept toiJ Swt^-
pog Kdi yjfjLwv XeyeTat^ cog irapairXYiatwv, fxeTa TovTa aairep aiTiav
TraptaTai tov dfKapTiav vjf/.m fiv} Kvpteveiv, (pYiat to " ov yap eaTe
" VTTO vof*.ov, aXX v7ro ydpiv^ Kaia yap avTOv tov TlavXov, " ij '5
" tvvafJitg T^f dfxapTiag 6 vofiog ecrT/." Kat " vof>.og TrapetayjX^ev, iva

" irXeovdayj to irapdTrTafxa. dXX oirov eirXeovaaev vj dfj^apTta, eKei

*'
VTrepeireptaaevaev yj ydptg ^. ttOTt ovKCTt eaft.ev vno vofi.ov «AA*
" viro ydptvr htKatoo yap voff.og ov Kenat. ov yap ^eeTat Tyjg diro

ypdfj.ft.aTog vofniKVjg ^iOaaKaXiag elg to TVjpeTv Tag evToXdg tov 20

Qeov, ^eohltaKTog m, ag YlavXog ^t^^daKet Xeyav, " irept ^e TVjg

" dydTivjg ov ypeiav 'eyjTe vfnTv ypd(pea6ai, vfneTg ydp 6eoti^aKTOi

" ecTTe etg to dyandv aXXvjXovg.''^ et tivi ovv avfx^recpvKev 6 tov

Qeov vofxog, ag fxv) eTepov f>.ev ^ovXeadat tov vofioV eTepov ^e

eivai TO 6eXi^ft.a tov av6pu}'irov, ToiovTog ovk eaTiv vvro voft.ov 25
aXX^ viro yaptv. ovtco vovjTeov " aXX vj ev tw vofxca [^vptov to 6e-
*'
XYift.a avTov"
15 Ti oivv ; afxapT-qcrofxev, otl ovk icr/xep vtto vofiov,

aAA' mro ^apiv ;

rENNAAioT. Ov yap vft.dg tovto, (f>v]ai, XeXvj6ev, ort irpoa-^o

vjKov vfxTv Toug vfxm avrm ofxoXoyiatg efxfxevetv Kat tovtov oti

^eaTroTijv eavTov roTg epyotg Tig evt^e^etKTat tov ov ToTg (sic)

S Leg. X^yfjiai. h Cod. tztpiitefl<Tatva-a,v xdftv.

 VI. 17. PftMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 71

KeXevafiaa-iv (yvcoKev viiaKoveiv' Kav afA,apTia tovtq, Kav oiKaio-

avvv]. TO yap ^toi dfxapTia^, v) vnaKoyjg iU ^iKaioavvrjv aaatpwg

eiprjfxevov toiovtov eaTiv, vjtoi dfi.apTia( elg vTcaKo^v, v} otKaio-'

avvrji.

©EOAflPOT. TovTo Jovhaioig fxdXiaTa Xeyetv evijv, oti vofAov ^

(pvaig 'hiopt^ei Ti fj.ev vpaTTeiv TtpoavjKet, t/ ^e fj.rj. et ft.ev ovv

€^(0 vofnov Tvyj^dvofxev, ov^ev av KCoXvot to iipoarv^ov aitavTag

TtpdTTetv. el te ecTi Ttg iipaKTewv Ka\ fHA] TOtovTWv ttdKptatg, vtto

vofxov TidXtv eafxeV Kat ayy)fj.a xi/tXov ej^ei Ta Xeyofieva iiap

vfnoov. TavTV}v Toivvv avTtBetg avTco ttjv avTtppvjatv, Xeyet f/.ev "ntig lo

dfxapTtag eKTog eivai itpoa^Kev yju.dg, oy^^ vTto vofLov ovTag' oitwg

te yj T^$- ydpiTog ditoXavatg ovk o^etav yjfuv tov dfJt.apTdvetv

TtapeyeTat' Kai ev6vg fLev eitdyet KaTa to avvrfieg avT^, f/.v]

yevoiTo Tov afLapTdveiV Kat tvjv Ttpoayjyopiav (pevKTyjv eivat yjyov-

fuevog, T^v Se ye Xvatv TYjg dvTtOeaeag ovtcc Ttotenat' ndg avBpw-ie,

Ttog OToo Ttep dv vitaKovetv eXyjTat, (pyjat, OovXov cavTov eKetvov

kaTeaiYjaev elg to iteiOeaQai Te avTco kat toc eKetvca ^oKovvTa

TtpdrTeiv aitavTa. y] Toivvv Tyj dft.apTta TtetQeaSat eXofievot, Ta

eKetvy} ^oKovvTa Ttoieh dvdyKy\v ej^eTe, tov eTttytvofkevov evTev^ev

BdvaTov eK^e^xfift.evoi, yj Tyj '^iKatoavvyj 7tpoaveift.avTag eavTovg, oey]- 20

aet TtdvTwg to TavTrjg 0QvXyjfi.a TtXyjpovv, Ta CKeidev aya6a ttepi-

fi.evovTag.

17 ^api9 5e rw Oew, oti yre SovXol ttj? a/jLapTias.

rENNAAioT. " Xapif," (fyyjai,
" tix 0eco, OTt yjTe dovXot ryjg
" dfi.apTiag," Xdy^eTe, TVjg dft.apTtag dv6eXofj.evot Tyjv ^iKatoavvyjv' 25

Kat TavTyfv dvT eKeivyjg ^eaTtOTyjv ej^e/v KaTa^e^dfi.evoi. yjg Kat tov

TVTtov Trig '^t^^ayyjg itapetXi^fpOTeg Ttpoa^^KaaOe, itpog ov tov Xotitov

^iWTeov vfkh dKpi(3iog.

0EOAOPOT. AvayKatOTaTov /xcv ovv Kat to " ^e toj

X'^/'''!"

" ©eoo*" e^ci ydp dito ev-^^aptaTiag dp^aa&at, tov ye ToaovTav 30

dyaBoov ^oatv itapd Qeov VTtdp^aaav yjft,7v e^yjye7a6at fii.eXXovTa.

KatptwTaTa ^e to '* yap

eig ov Ttape^^oOyjTe Tvitov "hitayyjg.^^ ot

AmaToXot ^teTeXovv dTtavTayov XeyovTeg, OTt XeXvTat t» Tta-

Xata, iteitavTat BdvaTog, eajSeaTat dfJ.apTta' (pycp fJ.ev vaTepov,
 72 EHHFHSIS EI2 THN nPOS VI. 19.

iTTayyiKia Se ^St?. tvttov ^e riva Kai avfxfSoXa TrXrjpovfJiev CKeivcov

eTT/ Toy ^anTtafj.aTOi, ^ia t^j §e^o/x€vi7f 1^1«,?« ev «fTOJ tov Ylvev-

fjMTQi ^apeai' dxntep avayevvafj.evoi KaTa [Jt.i[ji.vjaiv twv eaofxevav

TOT€. TovTo ovv Xeyet' oti yvwfj.yi r^v vjfKeTepav ^i^aaKaXiav
elXeadai ^, ^/ ^f 7Tpoavjyaycf>.ev vfit.ag, Kat fj.ovovovy^i 7iape^aKaft.ev 5
Tco TVTTco Twv fj.eXkovTav tia Tov (3anTlafi.aTog. TovToig Vfj Tiei-

aSevTag, avayKvi avff.(f>ava '^ianpa.TTeaOai, fj.ifi.ovfj.evovg eKeha too

jS/co, eig a tco tvttco KaTeaTVjTe.

rENNAAioT. Elg ToiovTQvg KaTev€veyft.ai Xoyovg, Kai irapa-

heiyf>.aaiv avdpcoTrivcov ey^pi^aau.i^v eflwv toi/ •jrpog apeTVjv aTovov T^f 10
aapKog vfxm fxe KaTavayKaaavTa.
AioACPOT. H^vva/xiyv, (^riai, TeXetOTepov t/ Kai fj.etl^ov enreh,

Kai evepyeaiag VTiep^aXKovavjg a^iov. Key<ti te vfuv ToaovTOv, oaov

yapene, aadeveTg re dvTef t^ aapKt.

1 9 "Q.Girep yap TrapearrjaaTe ra p.€.Xr] vfJLwv 8ovAa Trj 1
5

aKaOapa-La.
rENNAAioT. " Q.anep yap ttapeaTviaaTe^^ <l>ri<^h
" Ta jtteA?;

" vp.m,^^ Kai Ta e^vjg. tov yap KavTavBa avv^eafiov, avTi tov

TOivvv 7iapeiXvj<p€. ^t7 toivvv vft.ag, <f)Vjaiv, (oaitep ev tw TipoaQev

okovg eavTOvg t-JJ avofj.ia irpog epyaatav aKaOapaiag CK^e^ccKetTe 20

iraavjg, ovtco vvv, vf Kat ft.aKKov aiioa^^Qfj.evQvg eKeivdJV TtavTaitaai,

T7JV ttKaiQavvvig aTiQv^aicog dyiOTVjTa fit.eTek6eiv.

AioAflPOT '. ^vjkov jU.ev ovv (pviatv, OTt ToaovTca fxetl^Qva Ttepi

TavTa eyetv iipQavjKe t^v crTrofS^v, oaco Kakiag KpeiTTccv Tpvjaag

TiKeiova vepi to "/elpov eyovavi tvjv poTivjv, fj.vj fj.eya t/ (l>6ey^Qfj.ai 25

fi.v] vnep av$pco7iov. ToaovTO yovv vf/.ag iiept tvjv apeTVjv ep^e/v /Soi»-

Xoft.at, oaov t^vj dfj.apTta TipoaeayvjKaTe.

rENNAAioT. IcTe yap 7IQV Tov yjpovov eKehov, (pvjatv, ev co Trjg

dfi.apTiag eTiiTdyfj.aaiv VTieTaTTeaQe. Tiag vjv vfj.h 7ipdyfj.a kqivov

Tipog Tv^v ^tKatoavvvjv oii^ev. 30

npirENOTs. EiTiei^^ cog TioKKa^^ov (pvjatv, €TVjpvjaafj.€v to Tvjg

OtKaioavvvjg ovofxa, avT< TVjg dpeTVjg eaff oVe TiapaKafx^dveTat,

^ Leg. uMo-Be. i
Cod. S«o3«. ^ Sic. leg. fors. aptTij.
 VI. 21. PilMAIOTS EOISTOAHN. 73

KiKTeOV OTt Kai VVV TOIOVTOV (.(7TI TO X€yO[X€V0V. 0T€ Oovkoi »?T€

T^i afMapTiag, eXevdepot rjTe t^ apeT^. Kai TiapaKoXovBeH tw

yeviKf T^j dixapTiag ovofJiaTt, to yevtKOv tvj^ dpeT^g dtKatoa-wvjv

ev TOVTOig ovoy.d^ea6at. '^o^et ^e i^tKas to etg dyiaa-fxov Xeyetv

irpoTpeTrotxevog eig dyveiav Ka\ KaOapoTfjTa /3iov tov ovvdfji.€vov 5

yfcop^aat'.

21 TiVa odv Kaprirov €L)(€T€ t6t€, €v 0I9 vvv €7ratcrxv-

v€a-0€.

rENNAAioT. l^atTOt vj^eag av eywyc vvv Trvdotfj.viv vfxav viiep

OTOv KaTeaTTevJft-evxg ovTcog t^ dfxapTta tvjv KaXvjv eKeivvjV 10

tovXeiav e^enXyjpovTe, Kat Tig Tvjg TroAX^f TavTvjg evvotag vfxwv

KUpnog. ov <p6opa Kat aKadapaia Kat BavaTog, Kat Ta Tiaavjg

aia^^vvrig avafxecTa ;

0EOAOPOT. KaT epwTVi<Ttv avayvwmeov to, **

Tiva ovv Kdpitov
" ei%fT€ to't6*" eha KaTa aiioKptatv " e</> olg "y" eTiaiayvveaBe.^^ 15

el^ofxev yap to Keptog, (f>Yia], TVjg Trepi eKeTva anov^yis, d Kai

XeyovTm eTepxv aia^^^yveaQe.

'OpirENOTS. E|euTeAi^a)i/ tov KapTcov twv ^ovXwv T^g dfA.ap"

Tiag wg ovtevog d^tov Xoyov (pvjatv. ecf) otg ydp Tig itpoTepov ev

dfJiapTia. Kat dyvoia Treirpayfi.evotg vaTepov eig avvataQvjatv eXBov- 20

T(ov Yifj.apTVjfxevwv otayfvveTat^ TavTa Kapitog av etvj dy^taTog ,

dtcpog etg Ppaatv Kai eig ovBev evtTvi^eTof. Kai yap TeXog tcSv

TOioyTwv epycov ovk dXXo vj Bdvarog eo-T/v, e^^Qpog 'KptaTa tw

eiTTOVTt, " eyu) eifi.t vj ^ooyj." KvptevovTav TOtovTovg Kapirovg evvjvo-

')(OTwv' ev 00 BavdTca ovk eaTtv fxvv}fii.ovev(i}v Qeov. Kat yap itdg 25

ev avTw TeQvvjKe tco ©eoj, Kai ^vj tco OavaTW, (mep ravtov eaTi,
"'.
TO gvjv TTJ avafnapTia

Fennaaiot. Apa ovv, (f)V)at, ToiavTa Kat Ta vvv, vj fxtKpw t£

Ka) tSo TvyovTt tteaTviKOTa, dXX ovyj. tw oXw Kat tw TtavTi.

dXXa^df*.evot yap t^j dfxapTtag Oeov, Kat Ta hoKOvvTa tovtw 30

^taitpdTTeaSat yvovTeg, KapiiovaQe /xev tov dytaafxov to ava-

fj.dpTYjTov' TovTeaTtv, Ik Ve tovtov to ddavaToig vfxiv ^iafLeveiv

TtepieaTai.

1 Leg. axfyt^^o^. ™ Sic.

 74 EHHrHSlS EIS THN HPOS VI. 23.

'HpirENOTS. 'HfxeTepoi Kapirog ei$ ayiaafU)v. ov^ rj[JL€Tfpo(

^e, oy^e KaTa t>jv ^[xeTepav (f)vaiv (pepoov tw tj^v) avvvjaBvjfJievco

avTOv ala^^^vvyjv. oti ^e vjfxeTcpov fxev to KpenTov, ov toiovtov oe

TO yeipovy tr{ko1 ^e Y,my\p Xeycov, " ei to aXkoTpiov eindTev-

" BfjTe, Kai ovK eyeveaOe a^ioi, to vfxeTepov Tig vfxTv ^aaet ;" Kav 5

yap fUj yevwfxeBa a^ioi tov KpeiTTovoc,, cog vjixeTepov avTO t^ <}>va(i

ov \af/.PavofXiv ^ia tvjv aft.apTiav. epel ^e tk evTavQa tov eig

ayiaafxov Kapirov elvai toov ^e^ovkcoft,eviov t» Qew tvjv TravTekyj

aito Tm a^potiaioiv Kaddpevaiv. Kai (pYjaiv 6 ToiovTOi, ToTg fjiev

ev ydf/iw dpfKo^eiv to " ekevfiepxBevreg Ve d-no Tvjg dfj^apTiaSf \o

" e^ovkwBviTe t^ '^iKaioavvvj." toT^ ^e ev dyveia wq fxeT^ov, to

**
vvv\ te ekev6epco6evTeg diro TVji dfj.apTiaq^'' Kai to, e|^f. waTe
Tov fiev ea^^aTov Kapirov avTov e<V dyiaafxov "tia to ^^ovkwahai

TO) %ew. "hetovkwaBai iiokv irpoTepov tvj ^iKaioavv^ fnvj TidvTwg

eyeiv tov Kapitov avTov e^/ei eU dyiaafj.ov ^<a tov KaTO, avyyvw-\S
/X1JV koyov^.

23 Ta yap oyJACOuia Trj? afxapTias OavaTOS.

AioACPOT. 'Oi^wvovvTa^ c/ df/.apTdvov7eg vno t&v oiapokov,

TovTov Tov TpoTTOV TmtpaaKovTeg aw<ppoavvv}v Kai wvovfxevoi aKoka-

aiav, TiwkovvTeg yjpyjaTOTVjTa, Kai avTikaf^l3dvovTe$ cofx.OTV]Ta. 01 20

oiiv ToiovTOi i^iov KTVjfxa caa-nep tyjs dfxapTiag yevof^evoif BavaTCO

eavTovi vndyovai. Ta yap oxpwvia ivj<; dfxapTiag, BdvaTog. vj

Tdya TovTO keyei, oti Ta itapa tov eyBpov o^wvovfxeva OavaTov

•napeKTiKd.

'OpirENOTS. ^akv] Yj ^iacffopd' oxpcoviov ft.ev evr; Tvji dff.ap- 25

Tiag TeTayfxevov yapia fj.aToq te eiti tov Qeov. ovTe yap oxpoovia

aj- o(f)eikoft.eva ^i^coaiv 6 Qeog, dkka ydpiaft.a' ovoe ydpiafxa vj

dft,apTia aAX' o(peikoft.eva oxpavia. to ^e ydpiafKa tov Qeov ovk

CTa^ev ditkwi ^ojt? atavtoi' aTekvjg yap avTvi voeTraif OTe fxvj ev

^piaTW ^lvjaov tw Kv/j/oj vjft.Sov eaTi. ^vjkovTat Se OTt vj dft.apTia^o

Tw /SaatkevofKevw vit avTYjg ti^hctiat tov QdvaToV Kai ovy Qeog

e7ti(f>epei tov eyQpov tov X.ptaTov bdvaTov. " yap Seoi QdvaTOV
" ovK fTfiivjaev," Kai Ta e^^f. eav ^e Ttg 7tpo( tovto dvQwtoiai^ Kai

^ Leg. vid. Myov. sed plura ut vid. corrupta sunt.

 VII. I. PnMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 75

ro " cyw aitoKrevS) Koi l^miroiyjcxa}" Kai " Kvp/o^ Oavaroi Kai
" ^myovei" epovfAfv ori airoKrevei 6 Qeoi ryj afmpna., tva /xera
rovro ^(tiOTioiyicryi rov anoBavovra ttJ afuapria.

KE4>. e.

I 'H ayi/oetre aBeX^oi, yivcoaKOvai yap vofxov AoA©.

Ktpiaaot. Tlavra^^^pv entacpaXef omotpatvet ro vtto vofxov

KeHcBat ^rireh. irporpenei ^e fxaXXov e(piea6at Kat okyj ^tavoia

^ixpyjv T^v ^ia Tiiareag yaptv, rovreartv ttjv ev ^ptcrrSi OtKatw-

oiv. w Kat cvvre6a(p6at ttt(jyypt(xaro rov^ ^e^aTtrtaft.evovg' tva lo

veKpoo6evr€g ryj aixapriaf 0ew ^^ae^av ev ttKatocyvvy}. roiydproi

K(xt ecpaaKe, " [xyj ovv (SaatXeverca yj afj.aprta ev t» 6vyirS) vfxwv

" aafjiart, eh ro viraKOveiv ra7i eTridvfxtatg avrov, /xij^e jraptard-
*'
vere ra ft.ekyi vfAoiv oirXa o^tKtag ryj dfiapria, aXXa TrapaaTyj-
" craTe eayT&fj tc2 0ecS (tiaet eK veKptcv ^(cvrag' Kat ra fj.eXyi 15
*'
vfjiMV oirXa ^iKatoavvi^g rw ©ea" dfi.aprta yap vfj.av ovKeri

Kvptevaet' ov yap eare viro vofxov aXX viro yaptv. afjpei di]

ovv oirajg airocfjoirav eirtrdrret T^f rov vofiov aKtdg, virorpe^^eiv

^e fJidXXov ryjv ev \piaTw ')(dpiv, ttAtjv ovk yjyvoyjaev Trvevfj.a-

ro(f)opoi ort ^y] Trdvrag epovai rtveg, yffovv ^taXoytovvrat, ort ^ty}- 20
fj.apr-fjKaatv dpa ryj<; ev6eiag otov Kai ^ooyjg 01 Trarepeg. myfae
Se avrovi 6 vofj.og ov^ev, Kat <f>pov^a irwi y]Oyj ryjg eKetvxv iroXi-

retag rd avyy}fj.aTa. ei ydp eart rav arotraiv ro viro vof/.ix Ke7a6ai

^yjreiv, Kat vjv ovrog roHg apyatotg ^tov aKoirog, irag ovk dXyj6eg
enreiv oog rov irpeTrovrog tf^ft.apr-^Kaatv ; 25
^Aymi^erat rotvvv 'Kptarog (sic) ej^cev ev eavrWf Kai viro-

irXdrrerai u.ev evcpvHig ro Kat avro7g (3ovXea6ai avvenre7v ro7g

virQ vofKov pe^twKoat. Trepirpeiret ^e TrotKiXcog etg ye ro ^eiv

o^tea6at Katpov KaXovvrog etg irtartv, fxy} Xtav e6eXeiv roTg dpyatotg

%6eaiv efLCpiXoyapeiv. ravT-i^roi^ (pyjatv, " yj dyvoeire d^eX(pot, yiva-^o

" OKOvai ydp vofkov XaXw, ort vofj.og Kvptevei rov av6p6cnrov e(p

° Cod. TaVTOiTT,.
76 ESHrHSIS EI2 THN HPOS VII. i.

**
Qtjdv '^ovov ^^ ;" opo$ ovtos yfviKO^ Kaxa t€ vojtxci; itavroq Kai twv

VTto vofJLOV. aTraai fXiv yap ToTg vito aKi^TrTpa l3aai\€cov ^iopi^ovai

vofxoi TO T( TrpaKTeov Kai to fxyj. laytyovQi Se itapa ye Tolq ^wcr/v

(.Ti. e/ oe ooy tk; tuv vno vofxov TYjg evaoofJLaTOV ^(ovji airakXaT-
TciTO, (Xvvaire^vaaTO t^ ^ojtj Kai tcov vofxwv t^v e^ovaiav. et yap 5
TteitavTai tov TrkyifXfxeAeiv, aTtpaKT-^arei Toy' itavTccq Kai vofxog

en avT^. akvjQes ovv oti Kvpievei tov avBpaitov ecf) oaov xpo-

vov ^yj.

Kai Tii apa eaTiv tov Xoyov aKOitog avayKam eliteh. tvo

KaT avTOv eiaKOf/ii^ei^ yjpriaifji.a. '^fxeTs fj.ev yapf (f)rjaiv, 01 avvre- 10

6aff.fj.evoi \ptaTa ha tov l3a7tTiaf/.aT0i, 01 aitoBavovTeg t^ afxap-

Tia, e^cc yeyovafxev Trig e^ovaiag tov vofxov' fj.eTeaToi')(^etco6i^ft.ev

yap eig ^covjv erepav. 01 ^e ye Ttpo TVjg eitt^vjfxiag ovno} tov ev

\ptaTai voovfxevov QavaTov vTtof/.eivavTe?, e^av eTt Tvj afj.apTta.'

eKparet Vlfi ovv w^ ^wvtccv vofxog, KaQaitep afxeket Kat yvvatKog 15

avvjp. waitep yap vj vTtav^pog yvvvi, ^covTQg fxev ert tov Kora

vofxov avvcoKr^aavTog ^, ovk avev6vvov Ttoienat t^v v(p eTepca avvo^ov

ei ^e hv] Te6vatrj (f^rjatv, e^cy Ke7a6at '^tKrig, Kav ei ekoiTO ^pav

evvofxcog. Kara tov taov oifxat TpoitoVy ol fx-^itca Tvjg afxapTtag rvpt

veKpcoaiv ej^ovTe? ev ^ptara, ^iovTeg ^e coaitep ev avrrj, iteTtpa- 20

yaatv eiKOTCog Kat vito vofxov. Kvptevet yap tov av6pcci7tov e(f> oaov

y^ovov "C^ri' 01 he ye vito yapiv r^r^ yeyovoreg rr^v ev ^ptaTU, ^t

rjg Kat Te6v^Kaat rrj dfxaprta, Kai veveKpavrat r^ capKi, Tovreari

ToHg 7td6eai Trjg aapKog, ei fxi^Kert y^prjft.art^ovatv ccg ^wvreg ev

KoafLw, aKarataTo P TroiorvTO av rrjv f^co vofxov ^corjv. redavdrcov- 25

rai yap, lag e0>;v., ^ta rov acoftarog rov 'Kptarov, Kat aite^avov toj

vofxco, "^tKatovfxevot tta ittarecog.

AioAflPor. E/if TOWTOy KaraaKevd^et ort tay^vovrog fxev rov

vofxov Ttpo \ptaTOv ovK "^v e|ov eTepco avva(f)6rjvat, rovreartv rvj

)^dptTt. Ttavaafkevov ^e tou vofi.ov, Kat rpoitov rtva a7ta6avovTog, 50

e^eart XotTtov avvd7trea6at tv]v ^EiKKXi^aiav rco ovpavtco vvfx<ptco.

Kai yap rov vofJ.ov Ka\ rov X.ptaTOv ev ywpa dvtpog Tt6v]ai.

Tov ft.ev T^g EKKkvjatag, e^tet^rj coaTtep dpyrj yvvatKOg 6 avvjp,

"* Leg. ItOV. n Cod. UKQVfAi^d. ^ Cod. O-UVWKlJO-aVTO? KOTO?.

V Leg. a*caTa*T/aTov.
 VII. 4- PX2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 77

ovTcog *1
^piaroi T^f E/<f/fX>j<r/af . Kai 6 vo[Ji.oi ttotc Tvji avva-
ywyvjg. " o vofJiog" <t>Wh " Kvpievei tov auQpaTrov, e<p oaov y^ovov
'*
f^." Tig ^rj ; vojxos. coairep ^c 7rfp< av^pog xai (xvvoikov aura
^iaXeyeTai Tiepi avTov.

'OpirENOTS. To yivaaKeiv tov vofi.ov irdvTiog otte t>;v ^iacpopav 5

TYjS ev avTco 7ra\aiOTV)TOS tov ypdfHfxaTog Kai Trjg evvTtap-yovafiq

ToTg vorjiJLaaiv avTov KaivoTrjTog tov YlvevfJMTOi. tovto ydp eari

TQ Tekeiw<; yivwaKeiv tov vofj.ov. eTTi<pepei ^e Kai irapd^^eiyft.a,

acpo^pa tS> TTpoKeiff.evoi TrapdWvjXov. vj yap viiavtpog yvvri tco ^wvTi

dvhpi "^eterai vofj.w. edv Se aTToOdvrj 6 av^p, KaT-^pyriTai airo Toy i o

vofj.ov Tov dvtpog. vofj.0? eaTiv 6 dv^p. '^vjXov 8e ori 6 Kard to

ypdf>.fxa. ovTog ydp Kai to diToOvfjaKeiv eTreSe^atTO, ^id to eivai

TTaXaiOTy]^ ypdfLfJ.aTog. to ^e TTaXaiovfnevov Kai yripdaKov eyyvq

d(paviafi.ov. XeyeTai ^e Kai d-^oQv^aKeiVf eiTei /x>j^e Tiapd tois

/SovXofxevois avTOv (pvXdaaeiVf Kai ovro) iipoaipovfi.evois' iv ovtccs 15

e'l1TCi} ^yj^ * * *
4 "Qcrre, dSeXcf^OL fiov, Koi vfiels idauaTcoOrjre r« i^o/iaf

8ia Tov acofiaTos tov HpiorTOv.

'ANEnirPA*oN. AttqKovBov rjv enrelv, coaTe aOe\<f)oi fKOv Kai

vfjLits TotJ vOjtAou TekevT^aavTog ov KpiveaBai * fj.oi'/eia<; dvhpi yevo- 20

jaevo^ eTepw. aXk ovk eliTev ovTcog. dWa iTag ;

*' eBavaTcoQrjTe

" TW vofJ.co'^^ el veKpoi yeyovaTe, ovk eare v-tto vofj.ov. ei yap TeAeu-
T^aavTOf Toy dv^pog, ovk eaTiv virevBvvog rj yvvrj, ttoWw fkdXXov
avTrj TeTeXevTrjKvTa dif^WaKTai tovtov. eioeg TlavXov aocpiav ;

TTOog Tov vofJ.ov etei^e tovto (3ovXoft.evov to dTToaTr^vai avTov Kat 25

yeveaBai dv^pi eTepoo. ov ydp KcoXvei, (prjai, avvievai dv^^pi eTepcp,

TeXevTrjaavTog tou rrpoTepov. iTwg yap, ottov Kai ^xvTog eiiiTpeiTei

(3i(3Xiov dnoaTaaiov Xa(3ovaav ; aXXd tovto ov Ti6rjaiv, OTTep

eyKXrjfxa ^v t«v yvvaiKcov. ei ydp Kai avveyaprfTo, aXX Qfj.cag ovk

rjv atTtag diiriXXayfj.evov. OTav ydp diro tcov dvayKaicov Kai ^o<:/-3°

fxcov ej^i^ Ta vtKrjTrjpta, ov ^rjrei Ta neptTTa. to TOtvvv 6avft.aaTOV

<priaif TouTO eaTtv, OTt avTOg vofj.og diTaXXaTTet tcov eyKXrjfjia-

<1 Cod. oSto?. r Xn marg. ^vir. mox vacuum spatium et X«.

* Leg. KpmaBf.
78 EEHrHSIS EI2 THN HPOS VII. 4.

Tav vixag aTrocTOVTag avTOv. Kai yap Kai avTOg TedvvjKe, koi

y]ixi7g TeBvyjKafxiv. Kai onrkyj tol tyj<; e^ovaia^ dvripYjTai. ^e

ovVe TovToii apKehaif dXXa Kai ro airiov 7rpo(xri6i^a-iv. ov yap

«ttAwc diiyikXdyYjTi (pvjaiv, dWa oia rov Bavdrov rov ^eaitoTiKov.
" €6avarco6Yjre" ydp (pYjcnv, **
toj vojUco ^ia rov (rwixaxog rov 5
*'
X.piarovJ' ovK evrevdfv ^e itporpeTiei fxovov, dXXd Kat eK r^f

VTrepo'^^; rov tevrepov dv^po^. ^io kou htYiyayev, elq ro yevea6ai

vfxai eTepca €k veKpav eyepdevn.

rENNAAioT. ^epe ^17, (pYjCTiv, (Tva-TY}a(t)fi.ev Kai dito tov vcfxov

rovro avTO. ovkovv lare vofxofxa^elg ovTeg tovto ye dKpt/3ai, OTt 10

Toy av6pQ}Ttov Kvptog vofnog f-^Xpt'! ov ^Yf Ka^e^yr^^Kev. yj yovv
vitav^^pos yvvYj ^mri fxev tc5 dv^pt, Ttpoa^e^erai vof/iw. ovkovv

avTcv TteptovTOc; t^ot Ttpog erepov, yj KeKpi^Terat fi.of/aXig' TeXev-

TYjdavTOi te dcpeiTat rov vof^ov, Kat avvotK^^aet /Aev, co j3ovKYjTat'

ro §€ r^g fLOf^^etag eyKkYjfxa ^ta^pev^eTat. dpa ovv d^eXfpoi, rotov- 15

Tov Tt Kat ro Ka6 vfKag. yeyovare fxev yap TttaTevaavTcg reiv

(j-oofxarog rov "Kpiarov. rere\evTYjKo>g Se eKelvog to) vofi.(o itpoi

erepav eK rm veKpm dve(3t(i) ^(oyjv. ovkovv ev ovre? Kai vfi^eT^ ev

avT(jc, rco fxev vofX(a reBvYjKare' KapTtooaere ^ta rvjg dvaaTaaeuig

avrao itapaTtAYjanog Kat vfxetg. 20

©EOAapoT. AetKvvg rav Kard H-ptarov ro Q}(f>e\tft.ov ^, eTtdyei'

*'
tva Kapito^popYjaoifxev tco ©eco." ovk eit airtag ^e keyet ro eivat,

akXa ro eTtOfxevov roo Ttpdyfxart KaTa ro avvYiBeg avTco' /SovAerat

yap eiJteTvf ori ev ravTY] yevofxevot ryj ^co'^, ^tYjveKeTg otaofxev TYJg

ZiKatoavvTig r^ ©eoS rovg Kapitovg, TYjg KaTa vofLov itoKtTeiag 25

aTtYiXkayfxevot. 6avfxaaiwTaTov ^e avTOv ro fXYj etiteTv, edavaToidYire

hid Tov (3aTtr lafxaT og, dkXd dta rov adofxarog rov Kptarov. dp'^
fxev ydp TYJg TtapovaYjg ^(6Yjg A^dfx Ttdatv dv6po3Ttovg eyeveTO'

T^f ^e fxeXXovaYfg 'KpiaTog. coaitep ovv eiti rov ttapovrog ^tov^

TYjv Ttpog Tov A^dfi. KotvoTYjTa TYjg (pvaeoog ^'^(^Ofxev, ovr(tig eiti toD^o
fxeXXovTog, tyiv itpog rov 'Kptarov ofi.otOTYjTa Xafx/3dvoui.ev' CKeT-

6ev rag a^opfxag rvjg dvaardaedog eypvreg. fxepog ovv rov ato-

fxarog XeyofxeBa rov K.vpiov, dre Vifj t^v Ttpog avTOV Kotvoovtav

te^/pfxevot.

^ Cod. u<f)eXvifJi.ov.
 VII. 5- PnMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 79

-yev^c^a/ 7ri<XT€vofA€v, tovto Xe-ye/, oti fxepog yevofxfvoi tov T(i}[/.a-

Toq Tov XjOto-TOy &<« T^s" KaTa t^v avaaTaaiv Koivaviag, TVjg ev

T(o PaiTTia-ixaTif itXfjpovv Tovg Tvnovg rjyovfxeQa. veKpog fxev ei

Tx TrapovTi (3ia \oinov, e^w ^e TVjg vtto tcv vofxov TrokiTeiai KaQe- 5

aTyjKag' ovhefxiav (pepwv eavTX ^tal3oXvjVy ei fxvj Kata TavTOv

•noXirevoio. eitei^ri (f>vaig avTw tq KpaTeiv eiti twv t>jv irapovaav

^ftJVTCyV ^(OYIV.

5 "'Ore fiev yap rffiev Iv ry aapKi, tcl TraOrjfxaTa twv

afiapTicov Ta Sia tov vofiov. ^°

Ktpxaaot. 'ZdpKa fxeVf to aapKiKov ovofxa^et (ppovyjfxa, cog

Ka\ ev eTepoig (f>y]a)vf

" 01 ^e ev aapKi ovTef, Sea apeaai ov

" ^vvavTat." KaiTOi itag ovk d\Yj6eg (ug cvK e^a) yeyovoai To7g

Ttap avTov fLvaTaycoyovfxevoig Ta TOiaOe itapeyyva ; ti de pov-

KeTai 'tvfkovv itoKvTtpayfxoveh dvayKahv. ore toivvv aapKtKag 15

eTtoXtTevofxeQa <l>y}a), koi to yeai^eg ev vffxh eKparei (ppovi^fxa, totc

Kai evyjpyeiTO ev yjfxiv toc T^g aapKog itdOr] ^ta tov vofxov, vpog ro

Kap7to<f>opyjaat tw Bavdr^f). rt ovv ; (f>ati^ rtg av, TtdBy} Tvjg aapKOg

eiaeKOfxiaQyj '^ta Toy vOjaou ; eha itag avTOV eyKXy]ft.aT(ov aitaWa-

^(tifiev ; t/ ovv ttpog tovto (f>afxev ; ov S/a vofxov ra T^f aapKog 20
ev y]fx7v KeKivyjrat 'TtdOyj' TiKrerat Se fxaXXov Kat e| efX(f>vTOv fxev

lyJov^f, Tov §e a<70ev^ KaTaXvii^eTai vovv. Kat tovto yjfxh efx(f>aveg

Ka6iaTy]ai Xeyicv, *'

17 aap^ eTtt6vf(.ei Kara rov itvevfxaTog, ro ^e

*'
Ttvevfxa Kard rv]g aapKogi'^ ravra ^e dXXvfXotg avriKetTat. vvvt

^e TOVTO Ttapelg, dvre^dyeiv ryjv adpKa rw "nvevfxari <f>Y]atv, ^iai$

fxeaov TtBetg ovhev. ovkovv ov ^tdye rov vofxov ra rrjg aapKog ev

y]fx7v Kive7rat TtdBy]' fxdXXov Ve (pvaiKag. Kai Toye napd^o^ov

roig rov vofxov 6eXyjfxaaiv dvravtararai, (cg avrog rtov (fyrfaiv

'0

YlavXog, " ori ro (f>pQvy]fxa t^c aapKog ey6pa eig 0eov. tco yap
vofX(a rov ©eov ovy^ imordaaerai' oi/Se yap "^vvarat. el Oe fxd- ^o
yerai too vofX(e ro (f>povy]txa ryjg aapKog, itag ovk aTtoitXy^Krov

evvoeh tt avrov KiveTa6at itpog evepyeiav ra ovrttig dv^eary]-

OIS
* Cod. (Kuvan;.
80 EHHrHSIS E12 THN HPOS VII. 5.

T/ ovv ; Tlavkos (pyjatv' w^ TeSveaai ryj ajJiapTia ^iaXeye-

Tat ToTg ^ia tov PaTiTiafJiaTog crvvTe6a[XfJievois X.piaTco' Kai Wf

VjtYj TTjv Twv TraQav vcKpaaiv TreirXovTVjKOdiVy ols av vpemi Kai to

e^a> ^etv levai tov vofxov, tidye tov cmfiWdy^ai ita^m Tm %ta

Tov vojxov KaTO^etiKaaixevm. ovkovv cti fxevovTOiv vjfjiccv ev tw 5

(ppovvjiJiaTi TVjg aapKog, 7rd6vj toc ^ia toiI vofxov KaTeipvjfxeva Te Kai

wvofxaafxeva, (^vjaiv, evvjpyeiTO ev v}fi.7v. vjfxev Se Kai vnev6vvot to

TVjvtKd^e TW vofxw, are ^vj Kai ^aa-vji ev vjfxTv Tv^g dfxapTtag' (Tt

vvvi "he KaTYipy^6vifi.ev diio tov vofxov dno6avovTeg ev co KaTetyo-

fxe6a. evoypi ydp vjft.ev tx vofxw, VTCoTt^eiavig vjfxag Tvjg dfxapTtag 10

avTw. el Ve diie^dvofxev ev w KaTetyofxe^a, TovTeaTt Tvj dfxapTia,

avvaTipaKTVjaet ndvTcog avTvj Kat vofKOi' Te6eaTttaTat ydp ^t

avTVjv, tva eXeyyvj Tovg itapa^aivovTag.

Fennaaiot. Tco TVjg aapKog ovoixaTt ^tyag v} 6eta yjivjTai

ypa(f>vj' vvv fxev tvjv (f>vaiv ovTwg avTv}v ovofxd^ovaa, wg to 15

" nvevfxa adpKa Kat oaTea ovk eyet, Ka6wg efxe 6ewpeTTe ej^ovTa,"

Tw 'EwTvjpt irpog Tovg fxa^vjTag nept avTov fxeTa t^v dvdaTaatv

etpvjfxevov' vvv oe ovk avTVjv, dXKa to avTVjg efXTta6eg, wg tovto

avTO TO TtpoKetfxevov. ov yap wg aaapKwv vvv ovtwv ecj^-^ae to " ot€

" vjfiiev ev Tvj aapKt^^ akX wg itpog d6avaatav Kat ditd^uav evio
\piaTW fxeT€Xv)Xv6oTWV. itoXKdKtg yap, Ka6wg vj^v} 7tpoe(f)V]v, dtto

Twv KaTa l^ptaTOv TttaTevofxevwv vjfnTv wg eveaTWTWv TtpoattaXeye-

Tai. Xeyet Totvvv oti t^^ itpoTepag vjfxwv eTt T^g aapKtKVjg ovtwv
^wvjg, Ta ev ToTg vjfxeTepotg Tta6vjfxaTa fxekeat itpog afxapTtav

evvjpyeTro ^td tov vofxov. TOVTeaTtv vti vjfxwv evepyovfxeva, ^td tov 25

vofxov vjfxTv eig dfxapTtav KaTe\oyt^eTo' TtTpwaKOfxevoi ^e vno Tav-

T*?^, dvayKatwg tco 6avdTW Ttapa'7tefX'itofxe6a. Ttpog ydp TOVTotg oi

dWvjkwv KpaTvvofxevotg vj (pvatg vjfxwv e^oyfxaTt^^eto' Tvjg fxev

dfxapTtag layyovavjg "ttd tov vofxov, tou 6avdTov te ^td t^v

dfxapTiav KpaTovvTog' toi) voft.ov Se ToTg 6vv]ToTg t€ Kat ^td tovto 3°

Ttpog dfxapTtav eittppeiteatv, avayKatwg eittKetfxevov. ovkovv ti^v

fxev dfxapTtav Koafxog *

voft.og avveaTVj. vj ^e dfxapTia tov 6dvaTov .

t Sic Cod.
VII. 5- PaMAIOTS Eni2T0AHN. 81

aveyivva. o Se Qavarog t*;v (f>vcrtv e/f afJLapriav evokiaSov ^ta tov

€f/.7raQovi €pyaad[xtvoi, ev %/36/a vofJiwv KaT€<TTVja-€v.

AioAfiPOT. "' Ot€ ydp" <f)vjaiv,

**
^/xev ev Trj (japKi" dvr) tov

€V Tw vofxca' 01 yap ev vo/aoj lyapi^ovTo tvi crapKi' dKpi/Sxg ^e e/Ve

" Ta ^ia Tov voixov" ov to. d-no tov vofxov. ov yap to dy.apTd- 5
ve^v Ttapeoyrev o vofJi.oSf og yc irpoa€Ta^€ fivj dfuapTdvfiv. e/jrev

ofv oia TQv vof/iOVf €V€i^Yi (jvyyojpm Tpv(f>dv €^i^ov Tolg TrdOeai
irpocf^aaiv. ooaTe ovy o r]6t\€ KareaKeva^ev 6 vofj.oi, dX\* o fiir]

vjBekev.

©EOAapoT. H 6eia ypa(f>v) TroTe /u,ev adpKa Xeyei tvjv <f>vaiv lo

avnqVf woTe Oe ov t>;v <f>v(7iv dTtKS)g, dXX dno t^? 6vv]totv}tos

ovTccg avTVjv ovofxd^ei, ai dv ovk€ti '^vvafjievvjv ovtw KaXelaOai, el

Ovj aito6oiTO Tov 6dvaTov. wf OTav keyv) to '*

adp^ Kai aifna ^aai-
" Keiav Oeov KXvipovofj.v}aai ov SyvavTa;." wg av ovKeTi aapKog,
ot/Te ovavjf ovie Qvofjid^€a6ai '^vvaft.evvjs Tvjg e-at tov fj.€kXovTOi \
$
atwvog yeyovviaq d6avdTov. eaTi Se otc Kat to Ttd^og aiiTO adpKa

otoe KaXeTv, wi otov Xeyvj, " og ev Ta7s v]ft.epatg Tvjg aapKOg

**
afTOi;," iva enrvj ev tc3 Kaipco tov itd^ovg, OTe vtpoi avTx
efJiekXe yeveadat tco 6avdTa3. Kai fi.vjv Kat to TtpoaKatpov Kai

evOtdXvTov aitav ot%ev oi/tci; KaXelv, ug ev tv] ttpQg K.optv6iovg el- 20

Ttwv, " a\kd Toc fjLtopd tov Koafxov e^eXe^aTo 6 Qeog, tva KaTat-
"
^X^^V ^°^^ aocf>ovg, Kai Ta aadev^, tva KaTaiayvvvj toc layypd'
" Kat Ta e^ov6evvifj.eva Kai Ta fj.vj ovTa, tva toc ovTa KOTapyvjavi"

eitviyayev, " 'oitcag fj)fj Kavyv}av}Tai itdaa adp^ Ivwittov auT^y*'*

KatToiye ov htacf^opcov ^aaiv fx.vvia6€ig, dxx! tva eHTtvj ooaTe itavTa 25

Ta TtpoaKaipa cf>avvjvat aTova itpog tyjv TVjg evae/Seiag evtiyvaatv.

ovTca Se TOy fuv d6avdTov ^avTog ^avjv, ov^e itoTf ravTV} KaXov-

fxevQV TVf cfxovv}.

"ZapKog he, vot€ fJiev TYfg cpvaecog XeyofJ.evvjg, itOTe te Tvjg

Ttpoaviyoptag, ovk eitt Tvjg cf>vae(t}g Xafj.l3avofj.€vvig, dXX^ eit) avj-^o

fxaaia T^f 6vi^TQTVjTog, v(f> ^v elvai avfj.(B€^'!^Kev v]fj.dg. itoTe Se

Tov TtpoaKatpov vtavTog tvjv vTto tov opov Toy 6avdTov K€ifi.evv]v

KaXetf wg TO " adp^ Kai a'ifj.a fSaaiXeiav Qeov KXvjpovofxvjaai

ov OvvavTat ovToig Xeyei ro, OTe v]ft.ev ev tvj aapKi, avri

ToD OTe '^juev 6vvitoi, ev aapKi Xeycov etvat to eivat 6vT,Tovg. Tovg ^e.
82 EHHraSIS EIS THN nP02 VII. 6.

yap TieTiiaTtvKOTag ^piaT^, Kai tvjv irepi tS>v /xeAAovTwv i.itay-

yeXiav >j§>7 KQfxiaafJL€VQV(f Kai fj^fjv Kai tqv tvttov t^$" ev tw

/3anTiafxaTi yapnoi KaTa^iaBevTag, ovKeTi Xoyi^iTai eivat 6vy)-

Tovi' oOev Kai KoifJi.a>[A€Vovg ev Tyj irpog QeaaakoviK€7<; KaXe7 Tovg

airoBv^aKOVTai' totc toivvv to, to. itaBrjixaTa twv afxapTiav Ta 5
^^a Tov vofKov evepye7v ev To7g fxeXeaiv ^fn.oov, wanep ^idcpopa
TidOy] rco awfxaTi rco rjfxeTepoi avfK^aiveiv Tie(f>vKe, Kav fxfi irdvja

Ttaai fjLfj^e TtdvTOTe eyyiveTat. ovtcc Kai dfx.apTiS)v ^idcpopa TrdSi^

7re(f)VKev y^fx7v evoyXe7v, Kav fjtJrj TrdvTa itapa TtavTOov eTtiTekvjTaif

fxvjte TtdvTOTe. ig yap KaTO. to aafxa, o /xev ^ttov, 6 oe fidXkov lo

ToTg TtdOeai TtepntmTei, ovt(c eni tcijv dft.apTVjfxdTcov, o fxev itXeiova

§e eXdTTOva dfxaprdvei.

'ETre/^Tj Tolvvv vofnoo tivi t» dfxapTvifux.Ta KptveTaiy etTe KaTa

Tvjv <f>vaiKYjv ^tdupiatv, eiTe KaTO, Tai '^e^ofn.evai e^aSev ^iaTo^etgy

TovTO Xeyei, OTt itavTa Tm dfxapTim ra itaBri oaa itept vofna^ 15

Tiv) ^taKpivofneva eyyiveaSat Yjfx7v avff.(3atvei, ojav ti Ttapa ro

(f>atvofxevov vjfxiv, vi '^tvjyopevfxevov KaXov ^taitpaTTwfxeBa, TavTa

Vfi 'TtdvTa Kai etcpdTTeTO itap v]fxav' iva eftvj oti Bvvitoi tvjv (f>vatv

cvTeif Kat Ttepi to dfxapTdvetv TtoXXvjv ^id tqvto tvjv poTtvjv ej^ovTef,

airav ei^og eiteTeXovfxiv dfxapTtag' KaiTOtye ^ta(f>opoig To7g vo- 20

fxotg Ttai^evofxevot wv dite-yeaQat TtpoavjKov vjv v]fxdg Kai ti to

evTevBev yivofxevov eig tq Kapvtocpop^aat tw GavdTW' Xeyei Se OTi

evTevSev ^fxiv eTtea(f>iyyeTo tov BavdTOv v] Ttfxwpta. cog ydp vito

T^i' BvvjTOTVjTog fxei^ova tov dfxapTovetv tvjv evo^^^Xvjatv vnefxevofjievy

ovTCog V) Ttfxapta vito tqv itTaieiv vjft.7v eTtea(f>tyyeTO, Kai 6 vofxog 25

ov^ev yjf>.dg axpeXeiv vj^vvaTo' TovvavTtov ^e Kai dfxapTVjfxdTcov

eyiyveTO 7rpo'^evoj, eitet^-ij Ta7g ^tayopevaeai TavavTta ^ie-npaTTO-

fxeBa.

Nui/t Se KaTqyop-qOrjixdv airo tov vo/jlov airodavovTe^,

iv cp KaTeL^ojJLeOa. 3°

Ktpiaaot. Evoj^o; yap vjfxev tx vofxw, (f>vjaiv, VTtoTiQeiavjg

Vjfxa^ TVji dfxapTtag avTa. el Se aTteOdvofxev *'

fv w KaTefyofxeBa^^
TQVTeaTt Tvj dfxapTta, avvaTtoitpaKTVjaei itdvTag avT^ Kai vofxog'

xeBeaTtiaTat ydp tt avTvjv, iva eXey^^vj Tovg 'napa{3aivovTag. e^ce

VII. 6. PilMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 83

^vj ovv T^g Tov vo{xov 'yjpitaq, ol Trj afJiapTia v€V€Kpwixevoi' yeyova-
fjL€v yap €T€pai' Kai avToo dov\€vacofjL€v ev KaivoTyjri Trvey/xarof,

Kai ov TiaAaiOTyjTi ypafXfjiaTO^.

rENNAAIOr. Nllv (J.€VTOl, <f>7)(riV, aTTO TOV VOfXOV TOV KaT€yOVTOq

ri\jJaq KaTyjpy:^6r]tj.€v, "a(TT€ hovkfV€tv yjfj.ag €V KaivoTi^Ti nv€v[j.aTQg ^

" Kai ov TtakaiQTrjTi ypdfXfj.aTo<;.^^ ^eov ovv ««• dQavdTovi tov komov
Kai Tiv€Vfj.aTiKovg y€y€V'rjf/.€vovg vjft.dg 7rokiT€V€a-dai' dkka f/.v] ag
(pQapTovg €Ti Kai Trakaiovfj.(vovg, Kai vofjia ^ia tovto KaTyjvayKa'

a-fji.€vovg dovk€V€iv. dvTiti€aT€ik€ ^e tw ypdfj.fj.aTt fjilv to irvcu/xa*

Trf TtakatOTYiTi Se ttjv KaivoTyjTa' Kat avToHg Tollg ovQfj.aat fj.€yi- lo

aTy]V ^€tKvvg t»;v twv TrpayuidTfov dta<popdv.

©EOAapoT. Akka irdvTa vvv (f>i^ai fi.€Tal3€l3kv}Tat' tm yap
/3/co TovTO} v€Kpoi y€yQvaft.€v' co Vlfi TvyyavovT€q coan^p vno Tivog
dvdyKYjg KaT^tyofj.^Qa e<V to tx vofnco irokiTeveaSat' o6€v ov^€

€aTt Tig yjfj.iv KOtvavta ^iov Ttpog avTOV tov kofnov' avaKaivia6€v- i
^
T€g ydp Tyj ^vvdfj.€i tqv nvej;/xaTOf, Kai €T€poi /xev dv6 €T€p(ov

yeyovoTeg, fj.€TaaTdvT€g Se (Ig d(p6apTov ^coyjv aTto tov irapovTog

/3iov, ov^€fj.iav dfiiapTYjfj.dTcov Ivoykriatv VTtofj.€vofJ.€V. ovkovv ovq€

voff.(ov ^€0fx€6a Kai ypafXfjidTCov tcSv ^t^aaKovTCOv yjfidg tov KaKov

TTjv aTtoyy\v. TovTa yap Tolg ev Ty\ tov ^tov tovtov itakatoTyjTi 20

Ka6€aT(oot yjprjatfj.a €ivat SvvaTa/, ov ro/V vitQ Toy Trvey/x.aTOf

dvaKatvta6€7ai Kai yeyovaatv *

d(f)6dpT0tg' otg vofj.(ov ovK€Tt y^^ta^

ttd To fi.i^d€ dfj.apTdv€tv Int^^^yjEa^ai. ovtco Kp€iTTOva Ta yjfj.€T€pa

€K€ivcov (pyjai, Kai Ttokkco fJi€i^ova Ta KaTa X.ptaTOV o}(p€k€iav

ej^ovTa T«v VTiQ Tov VQfj.ov 7tat^aycoyovfji€vcov. 25

KE^. I.

UepX TTJs VTTO vofiov Ka.TaKpi(Tf(as dta Trfv ayLapriav.

"Q.are SovXeveiv r}fia9 ev KaiuorrjTL ivvevixaTOS.

'OpirENOTS. To " Aytov rivev^a ae/ effT<v ev KatvoTyjTi, ovre

'itakaiovfj.€vov oiJTe yyjpdaKOV, dkkd fx.dkkov tov €aa yffxwv av6pic-$o

Ttov dvaKaivovfxivov, yjfxipa Kat vjfxepa' Kat rj ttakaiQTrig 0€ tov

t Leg. yiyovo^Tiv.

M a
84 EHHrH2I2 EIS THN OPOS VII. 6.

ypa,fJi.fJLaTOSy ovk t<niv oVe KaivYi ^v, ov^\ itaKaiog ly/Awv avOpaiTOi

Katvo^ TTOTC yjv. oaTif afxa tw vitoTTrjvai Tre^TrakaKOTat, ov 'XJ>ovu>,

Tav Toiccv oe voi^fxaTWV Kat epyav TraXataadvTUV avTov.

Sethpianot. Ov to iTTateiv napiiyev o vofxoi 6 TtpocTaT-

Twv jtAT^ d[ji.apTdvetv' ^ia Se tov avy^^apeiv tv]v Tpvcpyjv ToTi 7ta,6rj- 5

fxacrt. TO ovv fiape^/eiv toi^ TraO-^f/.aa-t Trpocpaatv, ovk •rjv tov cko-

vov Tov vofKov, TO ^6 <TVf/i.^ahov T^g olKovofxtag 'iiv 'hoQ'i^vat tot€'

Acyw Vyj to eaBietv Kat irtveiv evepyeiTo ev Toii fi.eXea-tv vjfjiZv.

KtveiTat yap Kat ev toi<; vvjaTevovatv eTitBvfn.ta. aXX' ovk evepyei-

Tat els TO Kap^JTocpop^aat tw QavaToo. ovtqj ttaKovta BavdTov ye- lo

ypaitTat Mcwa^f, eTrei^^ e^dpei o vofiof. Kat o /xev e/SovAeTO, ov

KaTopSov ^e fi.r] vjOeKe, npoe^evet.

AnoAiNAPiOT. MTy^eJf TawTa aKovav, epea^^^eketTto itpoi tov

AvoaToXov (j^daKwv, wg ei tovto eartv ev tc5 vojaco Ta davaToiJvTa

ttayopevetv, Kat yvaptfj.a 'TOteTv to, (pavXa twv Tipayfi.dTWV Kat 15
Kaka, ouSev /jttov Kat K.vptog, to t6 <f)avXov ev ToTg eavTOV Ao-

yoig Kai to KaXov ^topt^wv, ^o^etev av tvjv tavjv e^epyd^ea6at Tvj

dft.apTia KaTa tc5v ft.v] TreiOoft.evav o^ov. to yap ^td<f>opov fi.eya,

Ka] TtoKv TO fLCTa^v' vofxov fxev ev p-rjfxaat vofLov Ketfxevov, Kai

fjjvltefLtav elg ^tKatoavvvjv 'tvvaf/.tv ev^t^ovTog, aAA' ent tvj irpdJ^et 20

t£v aKOVovTwv to avft.7rav KaTaXetirovTog. tov Ve K.vptov vjfj.Scv

'loycroD HLptaTov, to juiev avfJLirav ev Tvj ^oaet tov IIvet^jtAaTos" T17V

Tc5v v<f)' eavTOv aoiTVjpiav epya^Ofi.evov, Kat oiovet tv}fj.tovpyovvjog

vjfj.ag e^apyvjg, Kat /leTaTrAaTTovTOf Kai pv6fii^ovTog ev tw Tr^v

6etav e^ntirvotav viro^^eyea^at Tovg 'srtaTevovTag, Kat "jrpog avTvjv 25

otKetova6at. Xoyotg te eig irapaiveatv Ke')(j>vift.evov, ht wv evrtTv^eiovg

vjfidg KaTaaKevd^et t» fj.op<f>ovvTi Kai ^taTi6evTi rivey/ixaTi. 01/5^

vjfj.Tv^ avToTg Ta Ka6 vjfxdg eirtTpexpag. v] ydp av KaTeKptvQfi.e6a

"TtdXtv, o^vvaTOvvteg etg to Tret6ea6at' Kat vj TVjg dfi.apTtag yvccatg

Ka6 vjf*.av fj.dXXov vj irap vjfxav eyiveTO' dXXd tc55 Y]vevf/.aTt §0- 3°
"X^^Ta 'jrapaaKevd^wv 'fjfi.dg' dvievTag fxev ctiavjfKepat (sic) 'irpog tov

Koaft.ov avfj.Trd6etav, Kat XvovTag Ta '^eafj.d Ta aapKtKd' eirtTet-

vovTag ^e tv]v irpog to Tlvevfj.a oiKetwatv.

^to Kat vofj.og fJ-h elg Ttfxwpiav o^vg' Ylvevfj.a ^e dve^iKaKOV.

u Cod. vy.Si.

i
 VII. 6. Pi2MAI0TS EniSTOAHN. 85

juev TVjv i^^tav twv dvBpavav KaT0p6<i}<xiv dg ^iKaioavvvjv ^ijTav,

TO ^€ T>jv "Jiap €avTOv yopr^yovv. tovtu) yap €Ti€Tai tov jmv vofjiov

OV KaTOp6oVfJL€VOV TOV 7TpOK€lfJ.€VOV Tlf/.(i}priTlKOV €Trt(p€petV TW TrpOtJ'

TaKTiKa' TovTco yap ^v lyofj.^vov €K€ivov, to ^€ rivcvfM, ^vvafLtv

€yjov (sic) e/f t>;v twv ir€7itaT€VK0Ta)v hiopOoiatVf €i Kat toc TTpxTa 5

€^a(j6€votv}v TT^v irap' avTov "hyjf/.tovpyiav vTto^f^aadai. fJ.rjT€ aiio-

ytvco<TK€iVf fJi.yjT€ KoXa^€tv €v6vff aKKa Tyj vap kavTOv acoTyjpta

(pvXaTTOV Tov av6pot}7rov Ti:at^€vofJ.€vovy wait^p Y\av)^og €<paa-K€

Tco ^aTavSi Jtapa^ooaetv €ig oKfdpov Tvji aapKog, tva to T[V€VfjLa

aa)6yjf to Ylv€VfJ.a Toi/ Kvptov. av€y€Tat yap ay^t TVji HptaTOv 10

Ttapovataii e»f Ti€p av t^s vvv €'ntT€kovft.€V'fig '^rjft.tovpyiag

ff^/<'>7 'XJpovogy Kptaeccg €TrtaTaayjgf vj Tovg a^top6aTovi a7ro6€iTat

TO koiTTOVf <xv€irtTrjQ€tovg €ig tvjv aioovtov ^co^v €vptaKOfx,€vovg.

Aia TOVTO Kat akkayov tpvjatv 6 AitoaTokog " ©eov €hai tov
'*
€V€pyovvTa ev •^fj.Tv Kat to 6€\€tv Kat to €V€py€iv vTicp ttjs eySo-15
" Kiag^ ovyj to avT€^ovatov rjfjiMV TreptKOTrTOi^v, akXa Tyjv irapa,

Seov '^vvafj.iv €tg apcTrjV €^rfyovfJ.€vos. Kai 2wT>?p Ylvevfxa Aytov

€V€<pvar]a€V avaaTag' tta tovto irpoaotK€toov rjfLag' Kat ft.rj^€ fi.€-

pifj.vav OTt \aXrjaofj.tv €K€k€va€v' " ov yap vui€ig €aT€ 01 Aa-

" AoyvTef, «AAa to Ilv€vfjxc tov UaTpog vfxoov to kakovv ev vf/.ivJ'* 20
vj^r) ^e Kat 6 7rpo(priTtKog koyog Trjv veav ^ta^-^Krjv ev t^ ooa€t tov
Ylv€Vfj.aTog 6pt^ofj.€vog k€y€t, ^ctKrjv €^r]yovfj.€vog 7rpog tov ^laparjk

^idk€^tv. " Ka] avTr) avTotg rj Ttap €fj.ov ^ta6i^KYj e/Trev, Kai to
" JJv€Vf)La TO €fj.ov ecTT/v €7rt aotf Kat to, prjfj.aTa a Se&»Afa €ig ro
" aTOf/La aov, ov u.rj €Kkt7rrj €K tov aTOfj.aTog aovy Kat €K tov 25
" a7r€pft.aT0i aov, e/Tre Kvptog aito tov vvv Kai €tg tov aicova."

Kat TavTa /xev hta Toy Haaiov.

Ata he Tov 'l€p€ft.tov Trjv Katvrjv ^ta6r)K-^v €7tayy€kkofJ.€vog

S€og, **
auT>;," (prjatv, " "^ tta^rjKrj ^v ^ta6rj<70fj.ai 7tpog avTOvg €v

" €K€tvatg Taig rjfj.€patg, "^t^^ovg vofiovg fxov ev TaHg Kap^iatg ay-30
" Talv, Kat €7tt ^tavotav avTccv €7ttypdxpco avToiig, Kot ov ^t~
fj.^
'*
od^coatv cKaarog tov 7tkr]aiov avTov, kiyovreg yvcodt tov Kvptov,
** OTi 7tdvT€g €iQ-^aovai fi.€ aTto fntKpov €cog fj.€ydkov avTooVy oti
*'
tk€(og €aofJ.at Taig dfiapTiatg avToiv." t*/v tov \Jv€Vfj.aTO( fv
TovTotg €V€py€tav €ig Kapliag €7rayy€kkdfj.€vog, ^i' rjg Ka) tkaafj.og $^
 86 EHHrH2IS EIS THN OPOS VII. 7.

irapa 0eoy yiv^rai. twv /x,ev t^? afxapriai €K\oyiCfji.(cv tZv Kara
Tov vo[X(tV aviifxivuVf ryji ^e TtvevfnariKrji avel^iKaKiaf rov iXaafxov

eitiywpovG-qg. Kai fxrjv Kai ^ia rov 'E^(ki^\ ^axxfiv Kap^iav Kai-

v/jv Kat Ylvivfiia Katvov fitayyiXXerai, iU t»/v twv i^iwv 6e\vif/.aT(av

€v yjfjitv TtX-^pcoatv. ooare KaKag Kai ev T&r? 7tpoKeifi.€voig Aito-^

(xroXot; rrjv Kara 'KpKrrov ^(crjv 6pt^ofi.evo$, ovk ev yp<i.fKfj.aTi Kai

To T^f afi.apTtag TtapaXveaQai (f>r}(Ti Ka^ rifxav lcryypov. are trj

Tov Ylvevfxarog ovk eig yvw^Tiv xai rrjv ^ia ravTrjg Kar<xKpi(7iv eitt~

trjfxovvTog, «aA' eU avaipecriv fJLCV afKapriag^ '^iKatocrvvrji ^e eve^-

yeiav, ovk avdp(07ttvrjg aXXa BeiKrjg, co^ Kat ev apyri, OiKatoavvrjv 10

Seov ^ia rov evayyeXiov elttev aTtoKaXvTtreaSai.

7 T/ oi)v epoiifxev 5 6 vofios d/juxpTLa ;

Ktpiaaot. AOpei ^rj oit(og ao^pag rovg eiti ra vofxa TrotetTai

Xoyovg. ecftrj fxev yap ori " OTe rjfxev ev rr} aapKi, ra TtaQrjfxara
**
rav afxaprtSov ra tia TOi) vofxov evrjpyeiro ev roTg fxeXeaiv rjft.(0Vj 15
" eU ro Kapito^poprjaat rSo fiavaTcc*" attrjXXaKro av ov^afxHg VTto-

\piag 6 Xoyog. €(f>rj yap av T/5 itpog ravra evOvg, (3pa(3evrr]g ovv

apa Ka) eiarjyrjry^g txfxapriag 6 Xoyog. et yap eartv aXrj6eg cog ev

Yjfxh evepyeTrai ^i avrov ra TtaBrjfxara rrjg aapKog, Ttcog ovk av

vooTto Ka) afxapriag yeveaig ; ri ovv 6 fxvaraycayog ; ^ptfxvg 20

VTravTa, Kai arto^paaKei fxev ort Ttarrjp afxapriag vofxog' airta-

rat t\ fxaXXov t>jv av6pco7tov ^vatv, wg aa6evrj Kai ot avrov ita-

6ovaav ro evaX(ovat ^iKaig. ravrr} roi <f>rjai, rt ovv epovfxev \

vofxog afxapria ; fxri yevotro. aXXa rrjv afxapTiav ovk eyvccv ei fxrj

^ia vo^ov." aXX ori firj eyvco fxaXXov avrrjv. ovkovv ov Ttpo(pa- 25
atg afxaprtag 6 vofxog. Ttapa^eiKriKog Se fxaXXov avr^g rolg ovk

eihoatv aiirrjv. €fX(f)aveii KaBtaragy oyj^ iva fxaBovreg epydaaivro,

erye Kot itptv ettevat, TtavT(og ttov Kat ehp(ov. ov yap rjv diKaiog

Kara t»;v tov xpaXXovrog <f)(ovypf, aXA' iva ro ahiKovv eidoreg, ttpog

ra afxeivco fxeray^copriaeiav. 30
Ka/ fxot ^oKel yevea6ai ri toiovtov Tor? ap-^^aiorepotg "bia rrjg

Mw(7€ft)j' evToA^f. VTtoKeia^u} roo Xoyco TtXaTeTa rig olfxog aitOKO-

fxtt^ovaa Ttot. Kat ^ieppi(f>6cofxev^ ev avry noXXvj ^ia fxeaov yaafxog.

opeopv)(6(o (sic) ^e el loKei kou fio6poi. eira riveg earcoaav 01 ev

^ heg. heppi^dw ixev.

VII. 7. P12MAI0TS EniSTOAHN. 87

vvkt} Koi a-KOToo (3a^i^ovT€i ev avr^, iiepnnaiovTe^ Tf Kai fxaKa

cvyywi Tolq ^ia. ^kkiov K(i[J.€voig' Kai fxrjv Kai j^oBpoig ajSovX-^Twg

eyKa6i€[j.evoi. eyovTog Se ai^e tciJ TtpayfJ.aTog, SaOa Tig Aa^wv, €w

avTalg eaTr)ae Ta7g Tpio^oig e/x<^av^ KaBiaTag Toig oiiai Ta

fjieTa^v, ov^Y iva TtaKiv avTotg TrepniTaiwaiv, akXa iva fnaXXov ^

VTrepcpepQivTO Ka) anaXXdTTOiVTo tov KaKov. apa ovv i^OiKVjae to

(pag, OTi Trape^ei^e to Kvtiovv ; ri fj.akXov eKeho (pafjievy wg itXei-

uT^^v ocYjv avToig evemiei t^v ovrjaiv, dveTeXei ^e Kai da^pake-

GTepovg. aXX' olfJ.ai tovto eaTiv ov^evt twv ovtcov aa-vft.(f)aveg.

oVe TOivvv ovreg dfj.apTCi}Koi, irXeiaToig t6 oaoig eyKKr^fJ.aai 7re- lo

piTiTaiovTegf eyvwKaff.ev ^ta tov voft.ov t^v dfj.apTtav, ouj^ dfLapria

fj.aXkov v6fJ.og vooTt av eiKOTCcg vj KeyotTO, TroKKov ye Kai oe?.

irapa^eKTiKog &e fj.akkov Ty^g dfj.apTtag, ag e(f>y}v.

©EOAOPOT. To ovv vj^eiv Kai ovK eyvcuv, ov -TravTekovg ayvoiac

evjavOa ^yjkwTiKat dkka tovto keyet, OTt dKpi^earepav TVjg (ftv- 15

atK^g '^taKpiaecog e^e^dfi.Yjv yvxaiv ^ia tov vofx.ov.

rENNAAioT. "T17V t€ yap eTrtQvfiiav," (f^yjaiv, "ovk >jSe/v, ei fJ.Y}

*'
vofnog ekeyev, ovk eviBvfJ.-^aeig.'^ ov tovto (f>Yjatv, oti TYjg eirtQvfiLiag

fKOi T^v (pvatv evTeSetKev ovk e^^ovT/ to Trapdyyekfia. y} yap eirt-

6vff.ia T^i" (f>vae(cg. dkk^ OTt ft.Yj ^t^d^avTog fne tov vofnov "^ta t^^ 20

dvayopevaewgt eTrixpoyov t€ Kat (f>avkY]v eTri6vfj.iav vTrdpyeiv ovk

Yj7riaTdfi.Y}v.

AioAflPOT. " 'AAAa T^v dfj.apTiav,*' (f)ria]v,

*'
ovn eyvccv ei

" ft.Y} Ota vofxov." ovK eiTrev, akka ty}V dfiapTtav ovk eiToiY^aa ei

[j,yj ha v6fJ.ov, dkk " ovk eyvwv.^^ coaTe, ov toD voietv, dkkd tov 25
^tayivaaKeiv t*;v dfj.apTtav voft.og aniog. Trai^evTtKog ovv

v6fJ.og fJ.Y} avy^fwpwv Oia t^s" dyvoiag eig tv^v t»v dkoywv efj.-

iriTrTeiv (f>vatv. eKfivo ft.evToi ^Y}TY}Teov Trcag evTav6a eiTrav tt/v

dfj.apTiav ovK Y}^etv, ei fj.Y} ^ta tov vofj.ov, ev CTepotg ^eiKvvatv oti
**
eyoft.ev ev eavToig to ^taKpntKOv, ev oig (f)Y}atv, OTav ydp e6vi^ ^o
'*
Ta fj.Y} vofj.ov eyovTa, (f>vaet Ta tov vofxov itotY}, ovTot v6fiov /xtj

" e^^ovTes", eauTor^ etat vofxog." ^<a tovtcuv TrapiaTY^aiv, OTt Kat

dvev vofnov evY}v avvopdv Ta ^eovTa. koytaTeov ^e ort Kai evY}v,

dkk ov irdvTa. ovTca ye Ka\ vvv eTt evta irap dkkotg e6veatv wg
88 EHHFHSIS EI2 THN OPOS VII. 7.

KaKa. Kai evvofxa iroXtrtvtTai, itap aXXoiq ^e w^ avofj.a Ka} KaKag

fj^ovra €K(3dXX€Tai' ^io hvi ei avayKa7a tov vofj.ov vj ^o<7/f, ^iopi-

^ovaa vjfxiv to. t€ itpaKTka Kai to. /x*/, Kai ^iapOpovaa vjfj.h Kai

(pa>Tit^ov(7a tov tiKaiov t>j« TroXiTeiav.

©EOAiiPOT. kiaBofxivog aiio re tov " to, traByjfj.aTa toov afxap- 5

Ttcov Kai bia tov vofxoVf Kai ano tov ^*vofxog Oe napeiayjXdev iva
" "nXeovaati to TtapdiiT^afxa^^ Kai erepwv nXeiovav cov ev toi^ dva-

Tepoig elp-YjKeiy '^ia(3oAr)v Tiva e7ri(f>vof).evv}v too vofX'j} «f dvatTta (sic)

Kai Troir/TtKw Tav dfxapTYifxdTwv, TpeireTat fxev eirt Ttepl tovtcov

Xoyov. dpyeTat Ve Tvji dvTt^eaeag ovto) Xeyav, " t/ ovv epovfxev ; 10

*'
vofxoi dfxapTta ;" dXX apa (pvjci, fxv} tovto ; dTto toov vjfxeTepm

^etKvvrat pvjfxdTOiVy CTt Virj <pavXog Kat TtotvjTtKog dfnapTiai vo-

fkog ;
" fxvi yevotTO' aXXa t^v dfxapTtav ovk eyvav el ft.vj ^ia
" vofxov.^^ TovvavTiov ovO av eyvcov t^v dfxapTiav, ti ^g eKKXivetv
Ttpoa-^Ket TVjv Ttpd^tv, et fxv] vofxog v^v tyj ^taKptaet tov t€ KaXov 15

Kai Tov yetpovog irat^evav vjfxdg waTe ttoteh Kai wv dtteyeaGat

^6?. ctxTTf vofxog vjfxh Tov fxiaovg TVjg dfxaprtag eyeveTO atrtog'
og VTte^et^e Te avT-i^v, Kai dito^pevyeiv TtpoaeTo^e' Kat aacpearepov

irotSov TO etpvjfnevov envjyaye, " t^v re ydp eTttOvfxtav ovk vj^eiv, et

** 20
fLvj vofxog eXeyev, ovk eTtiBvfx-fjaetg."

IloXAcSv €7tt6vfxe7v vjfxdg Kard rov itapovra /3tov avfxj5el3v]Kev'

ov Ppctifxdrcov Kat Ttofxdrcov Kat yafxtKVjg Kotvmtag fxovov, dXXa

Kai ^o^T^f Kat yj)Vjfxdrccv. m Se t^v eitiBvfxtav evovaav ej^o/xev,

TOVTCOV ovK dv TTOTC etvai rt (pavXov vjyvjadfxeGaf fxvj vofxov ^i-

^daKOVTog yjfxdg, cov eitiBvfxovvTag dite^/eaBai "TtpoavjKet. coavep 25

ovv Kat rov Xoyov eKaarov ditapatr^^rccv rvjv otKetav eKitXvjpovv

evtBvfxtav enetyerai, are ^yj ov^evog avra itpog rovvavriov av&eX-

Kovrog. v(f> ov rtpog fndyvjv t^? otKetag ope^eoog KaTaarYjaerai.

elra litoteiyfxart Keyjpvirat ro7g Ttept rov Atdfx, elg fxei^ova rov

yevofxevov aa^ftvjvetaV vofxog ydp vjv Kat vj itpog eKeivov evroXvj Ttepi 30
roD (pvrov yevofxevvj' Kat avvej3dXXeT0 ra Kar eKe^vov etg avara-
aiv rcov itept toi; vo,aoy Xoycov.

'HpirENors. No/Aov coSe voovfxev ov fxovov rov yicaaeccg rov

KCoXvovra rvjv eittBvfxiav, dXXd Kai rov (pvatKov. eveaitaprai ydp

VII 8. PI2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 8&

'ijfji.iv (pvaiKug vj e7ri6vfji.ia wg TtdBog, Kai 6 inpi TavTVjv vofxog, Kai

€\a(3(:V dcpopfxvjv vj dfAapTia, ov dia Tyjg ypam^g /Aovojf evToX^g,

dXka Kat ^id TVjg (pvaiK^g. Kai o 'A^a/A Se -yj^ex tovto Kai npo

TOV Ma>0"€ft>f VOfLOV.

* A(popfir]v de Xa^ovaa rj afxapTLa 8ta rijs iuToXrjs. S

rENNAAIOT. 'M.Vj ^l^d^aVTOg fi.€ TOV VOfi.0V, (f>y}Tl, ^ld TYjg dita-

yopevaeoog, €'Jrixl^oyov xe Kai (pavXvjv eTTiOvfniav vTidp^xetv ovk i^tti-

crdfx,Yiv. vvvt ^e ^td TVjg kvToXvjg tovto fj.€fji.d6if]Ka. ft.€Tpov<ivfi ydp

fjLOi TavTVjg TVjv €yK€tfji€vv}v €vi6vf/.tav TVj (pvaei, Kat ttjv y^jtvjcriv

avTVjg a(f)€Tov ovk eaavjg, a\X opotg TaKTo7g avTvjv Trepiypa^povcrvjg lo

T€ Kat iiepiXafJL^avovai^g, vj afnapTta Xa^ov<7a ot avTVjg a(popff.vjv,

TOVT€(JTiv tayyog evTTopvjaacra Kai eniKovptag, €iTa ft.€ Tipog aft,€-

Tptav vTToa-KeXtcraaa, evepyov etg dfi.apTtav fxot ndaav eiriQvfJiiav

a'7t€ipv)ft.€vv)v KaTeaTvjae' ro yap " KaretpydaaTO ev efj.ot Tidaav

" eTttBvfjLiav^^ €vo€7to aTtvjyopevfiLevi^v. '5

0EOACPOT. T'7i(j^€tyfi.aTi K€y^viTat To7g Trept tov A^dft., hr€t

K(x.K€7vog irpoK€tfX€vwv €Trt Tov 7rapa^€iaov rwv (pvTcov dhewg dvdv-

Twv ft.€TaXaf/.^dv€tv e^vvaTo, €i fxvj vofiog avTW Ttg Trepi dvo^/vjg

€TV)(^€ ^oOeig. xat ovk yjv dft.dpTVjfj.a to fj.€Td tSjv XotTrwv ^ovXvj-

Qivra KaKftvov (paye7v. eTret^vj ^e evroXvjv e^e^aTo aTtoayea^at tov 20

(pvTov rij^ Ppaaecog, e-niOvft.ta fnev rig ev^v avTW TVjg ft.eTakvppeag

iog etKOg rov KapTrov. €K(i}Xv€to ^e Ofxvg vno t^^ evToXvjg, dft-dp-

Tvjfj.a elvat to (paye^v twv a7rv}yopevf>.eva>v vjyovf/.evog. evTevOev vj

dfLaprta 7rdpo^ov ea^^fe. r^f fnev evroAi^^ eireyovavjg tv}v /SpaaiV

Tov Se A^dfJ. ov Trpog tv^v d^tontaTtav T^g evTOA.i^g jSovkvjdevTog 25

i^eiv, dXXa TrtaTceSevTog jtxev tov eTrt^ovkov To7g Xoyoig, okov te

Ti^g €Trt6vfj.tag tow (paye7v yeyovorog.

Ka/ ov fxovov a(popft.v] TYjg dfj.apTtag evTevQev eyevero, akXa

yap €Tt K(x.Ke7vQ efj.d6ofj.ev, ag ovk d^raTY] Ta7g €7ri6vfj.iaig Ttpoa-

vjKev €7r€a6at vifj.dg. ^oKifkd^ovTeg Se d "^q^vj iroieiv, twv eTepcov 3°

dTreyea^ai' olg ovk efXfjevovTeg, 'hi^kot TrdvTwg eafKev du.apTd-
vovreg. waTe ov KaT eKe7vo fxovov vj dfiapTia t^v Trdpo^ov ea^^e
"^td T^f evToA^c, Ka6o tov (pvrov fj.eT€tkYi(pafj.ev' dkkd ydp Kai
OTt fxv) iraaatg evrea^at Ta7c €7rt6vfJ.iatg d^rkag €VT€v6ev fj.av6d-
vovTeg vjfj.apTdvofJ.ev, toc T^f e7rt6vfj.iag •napd to ^eov Trkvipovv e7re/-35

N
90 EHHrHST2 EI2 THN OPOS VII. 8.

yofMevot. TOVTO yap Xeyei to " KaTeipydaaTo ev €[xoi "naaav eiriBv-

" fxiav" avTi tov TravToq afxapTyjfxaTog amo Tivog eTriBvixiag tikto-

[xevcv^ evTevdev yj apyy} yeyovev vj[MiVf aTe ^v} T^g tiaKpiaeag rag

d<f>op[xag ^e^a[t.€vifjg evTevSev. ovtco Kai ev ToTg avaTepotg to " t>jv

" e-TriOvfiiav ovk vj^etv, el [xvj o vo[xog eXeyev, ovk eTTt^v^xyjcretg. 5

dvTt Tov ovK av vj^etv ag ov ^el ti iroieTv twv ev e7rt6v[xia Ketfxevmy

€t [xvj VQ[xog vjv 6 TovTO ^iopi^cov vjfxTv.

Ka/ yap to " ev e[xot" OTe \eyet, to Kotvov keyetv tcSv av-

Bpamwv koi tov 'A^^d^x eig dTro^et^iv Keyj)V]Tat tcov koivcov. oSev

eitt Tov oiKeiov KaKeTvo Xeyet TtpocrwTtov' ^ta icdvTwv oeTqai (3ov- lo

Xo[xevog OTt dvayKaiag [Kev KaTO. tov itapovTa ^tov vo[xoig iroki-

T€vo[x(6ay v<f> av vj €[X(f>vTog dvaKtveTTai 'htdKpi(Tig' Trai^evo^xevccv

d>v T€ dneyeu^at Kat a iroteTv Trpocr^^Ket' ag t€ Kat to XoytKov ev

Vj[xTv evepyov eivat. yjp^ia t\ T^f [xeWovuvig vj[xTv KaTaaTaaeag, ev

v} yeyovoTeg, t» <paivo[xeva v}[xTv KaXd TOVTa Kat iToivjaat '^vvvjao- »5

[xe6a pa^icog. o6€v TVjg oiKeiag e^/^o^xevog dKokovQtag Kat t6v ^etKvv-

vai, ag ov^ dv Ttg v]v ev vjfxTv ^tdKpiatg TovTe Kakov Kat tov yet-

povog, ov^^e d^xapriag eiriyvooatg, ei [xv] vo[xw TavTa ^tcopicrTO iiap

vifxTv, dkoym %\ hiKVjv to npoaTvyov noteTv anav efxekXofnev,

evdyetf " %(^pU ydp vo^xov, d[xapTia veKpd." ov^ dv evepyvjSetvj, 20

(f^vjcrtVf d[xdpTVj[xa, [xvj vo[xa) ^tcopta^xevoV &<a t< ; oii ovy vj npa^tg

dfidpTVjfxa aTTkag, dXXd to ethoTa wv diieyea^at irpoa-i^Ket, iroteTv

Tt Tiapa Ta eyvaafxeva KaXag eyeiv.

'OpirENOTS. OvK ev YlavXx [xova dXX' ev Trdavj xpvyvj, ot€ vj

d[xapTia v-neaTVj, iidaa e7ri6v[xia KaTeiioXe^xei to yevog. d[xv\yavov 25

ydp av6p<t)7itvv]v xpvyvjv, [xvj dnoTieaeTv nd^eai' Kav e^ entfieXetag

vaTepov oiovet ev dTia6eta yevv\Tat. co^e ^e YiaA)Xog vidaav ent-

6vff.iav Xeyet 7ia6vjTtKVjV Kai dfxapTwXov, vjv vofxog anayopevet,

*'
^thdaKwv TO ovK eTit6vfLYiaetg." v^Ttg eaTtv ope^ig dXoyog yivo-

[xevv] KaTa opfivjv TiXeovd^ovaav napdXoyov, Ka6 v]v cf^tXo^coovfxev ^o

wg dya6ov opeyofxevot, ttAovtco Ka\ ^o^f] Kat yvvai^t Kai TaTg Xot-

TiaTg eTit6vfxtatg, KaTa to t^c dfxapTiag ^ovXvjfLa Tiotovavjg v][xag

€KT€tvea6ai wg ent dya6ov iidv to vcp vjfiSiv ent^vfxovfxevov. <pav-

raaia yap dya6ov vj €iit6vfxia yiveTat.

Sethpianot. Ov KaKog, cprjatv, voft-og, ovte dfxapTia, aXXa 35

VTI. 8. PilMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 91

yv(i)pi^€Tai fX€V TVjv afJiapTtaVf a-nofJTYjaai Se avTi^v ov OiQvvYifxevo^f

(iri^oaeag a(poofj.^v avTyj Tcapeaye. tovto Be "^taTi (f>Yj(ji ; oeiKVV(

T^f afnapTiag to fi.eyeBogf iva avvaTro^ti^y] T^i yapiTog tyjv vnep-

I3o\yjv, ovTOt), (f)Y]a]v, Yfv itTyvpa yj afJiapTia, oti ota tZv avayo-

pevovTCOv fLaXXov eKpaTei Kai TiKeov icryvev' (canep (pXoya apga-5

fxevY^v fLev Kai to Tvyov a^evvvaiv. e^a^pdeiaav S eiri iikeov, Kai

ro aPeaTiKOv v^ap iiXeov anTei. ovTag t^v afLapTiav •ndaYjg tyj^

olKovfi.evYig KpaTYjaaaav Kai TtdvTag e^Trivefj.OfjJvYjv, o vofxog YjXey^ai,

aj3eaai Se qvk layvaev.

AnoAiNAPiOT. ToHg fnev ovk aKovaaai vofiov, (f)vaiKag y} io

rovTov yvaaig eyyiverai, KaBa Kai irporepov e'ipYiKev' " eQvYj ra fXYj

vofiov ej^ovTa, (f)vaei ra rov vofj.ov Tcoiovvra, ypaitrov evoeiKvvadat

'*
To epyov Tov vofxov ev raig eavrm Kaptiatg." to7c, oe vito vofLov

TO Tov voft.ov ypdfLfKa Kai t/jv (f>vaiKi^v evvoiav avaKivet, KarYjypv-

fnevotg vTio rov ^i^aaKdXov, irpog ro Kai avvtevat ro Kakov Kai ro 15

(f)avXov d(f) eavrwv ^vvaaBai.

Xa>/)ty yap vojjlov, a/xapria ueKpd.

Ktpiaaot. E/ yap fi.Yj Keoiro (f>Yjaiv rov r^g (f)avXoTYjTog

rpoirov Kara^iKdl^div vofiog, d^paveg av yevoiro ro KaKOv. KarepeSi-

^erai ydp fj.ovovovyi Tipog layyv 'hid rov vofJ.ov' Kat pa6vfi.OTepov 20

fj.ev rtai ro r-^g r^ovYjg eyKetaerai Kevrpov, eTtirtfi.a)vrog avrx

fkYi^evog. fAOvov ^e ovy] Kai d-naft.^kvverai toI t^^ e^ovaiag TtXdrei
yoYjrevof/ievov. ov ydp oXag ro dvriararovv oii^ev, eKei itov itdvrcog

apyel ro (ptXovetKOV. veKpa rotyapovv yj dfJ.apria, vof>.ov ro

TtpaKreov ^taKpivovrog. e^YjKevat ^e, (pYjatv 6 f>.vaTay(i)yog, ya^ptg 25

vofJ.ov Ttore. eha T^g evroXYjg eXBovaYjg, dvajStoovai fxev tyjv dfj.ap-

Tiav' reOvavat ye fn.Yjv avrov layvpt^erai. Kai ayYifj.aT i^ei fj.ev ev

rovroig e(f) eavrco rov Xoyov. olfx^t te eycoye toiovtov ri fSov-

XeaSat drjXovv avrov. vito ^i^Yjv fi.ev ydp ofj.oXoyovfj.evwg eari Kai

ro ev dyvoia TtXYjfHfieXeTv, yj ro ev ethYjaei vofnuv. ei Qe ^07 rig 30

yeyovev vno vofxov, rY^v e^o) vofJ.ov Ttore ^ta^Yiaag ^co-^v' elra rav

TeOeaittafi.evwv a(peiteh YipYifj.ev(c, yjXw ypa(f)Yj dfJMprtag, Kai ite-

TtrwKev VTto ^iKrjv, rore ^yj rore, raHg eavrov paBvfj.tatg eitt-

arvyvaaag. Kai TYjg dKpifSttag rov vof/.ov fj.ovovovyj. KaraKeKpd-

N 2
9S EEHFHSTS EI2 THN OPOS VII. 8.

^erat X(.ya)v, " eycb ^e e^wv 5(a>^<$' vCjaoy TtorL ekdovavji §e r^f
" tVToX^S yj dfji.apTia e^vjaev. eyw de dTreQavov." el ydp eaTiv
aXvjQws dfx^apTia vcKpa ')(ci>pt( vofxov^ "ncHi; ov inQavov evvoen* ^»0-

iToiuaBai Tponov Tiva ^ia tov vo/xov tvjv dixapTiav, tov Kai efxcpavyj

KaBiaTavTog avTVjVf Kai olov efJiTTVOvv airoTeXovvTOi ; Kanoi Tidkai 5

fxyf eyv(ti(Tft.evyjv^ ei Kai tS) ev yjfiAv. ov yap •^ft.ev ^iKatoi. aaTtep

^e veKpdg ovayjs T-rjq dfj^apTta^;, ^idToi to fnyj eivai tv)^ov tov

Kara^iKa^ovTa vofxov, e^ojpiev yjft.e'is Tyjg dyvoiag Tyjv •jrapaiTi^atv

evdfJiopcpov (sic) ej^ovTe^. '*ov yap ovk eaTi vofxog^ ovVe irapd^aaigy'
KaSd (pyjaiv avTog. ovtoj irapeXQovayjg etg fjieaov T^g evToX^g, 10

dvej3iwfji.ev" xaitep yj dfKapTta, KaTyipyyjSvj ^e BdvaTog^ Ka\ dpa

Kai ^iKyj Tftjv TaTg TtapafBdaeatv vTtoTtntTOVTUv e^ dadeveiag.

Kai t/ to evTev6ev ; TteitpaKTat ti tcov eXTti^og e^» Kai o^okyj-

Tcov ecf) yjfutv. evpyjTai yap yj evTok-^, (pyiaiv, >; OoSeiaa itpog ^(o^v,

avTyj eig oavaTov. waTtep yap KaTaaiveTai Ttag TYjg yjAtaKyjg aKTi- 15

vog TO (pag, Tovg oiaitep dv eiev tyjv ori^iv yjppcoaTyjKOTeg' KaiToi

Tte(f>vKog eivat yAvKv Kai TptTioayjTOV. Kat Kar avTO TtavTsog

eaTt TO d^^tKovv. vooito Se ju.aAAov TVjg txv Tti-novQoTOjv dppcoaTiag

eyKXyjft.a to d^iKe7adai Ttap avTov' Kara tov taov oift.at TpoTtov

Ttpo(j)aatv "bt^^oaBat t^ dfKapTtfXf (pyjat, tvjv evToXyjv, e^r)7taT^aOat Tf 20

§;' avTVjgf KaTaKOfktaByjvat Oe Kat etg Sdvaiov.

^aiv] ti' dv Ttg Kai eTepwg^ OTt tyj ^ a^po^pa (piXei Tatg tov

vof/Lov ^ovXaig det Ttct^g fi.dyeaBat to (ptXoitovov' Kat 01 TVjg <pav-

KoTyjTog TpoTtot Ta7g eittetKeiatg dvaKoitTOft.evot yevtKcoTepov dv-

Te^dyovat' Kat tovovv^ ea6 OTe KaTaXyji^ovTat, Karaarpe^povTeg 2^

eig Ttapd/SaaiVf Kat Taig eK vofAOV TtotvaHg v7to(pepovTeg' KatToi

voft.ov eayyiKOTec, tov 7toXefj.ov tyjV a(popfJ.y]v. Tavryj toi, (p^^o^t^ ao(pog

QiV YlavXog, y]7taTV]a6ai t€ ^id TVjg evToXvjg, Kat Ot avTVjg dito^a-

velv, aTteKTetve yap fKovovovyj, KaTa^yiyovaa itpog avTtaTaatv Tag

ev y^fMV v^ovdg, Ka^dye Tovg itpoetpvjfJLevovg Tpottovg. 30

'I21ACPOT. 'ETre/^^ Tictjg yjepig voft.ov vj dfJiapTia veKpa, vjOeXiq-

aag fj.aBelv, (pvjfJ-t OTt tovto jSovXerat et-neJv YlavXog, oti ovTtco

^ Leg. ave^tw iJL€v.

" Cod. 8«?. y In marg. lo-ws' yp- Kahoi
vovy (sic) sed leg. koi tov voZv.
 5

VII. 8. PX2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 93

yjv yvoipifJiOi. o^ yo.p tovto alviTTiraif oti ovk r^eaav d[j.apTdvovT€i,

evei dkoyaq evpeOeitv KokaaQevTe^ oi irpo tov vofxov. oi [xev yap
vbaTo^f 01 o€ Ttvpog epyov eyevovTo. «Aa oti yjoeerav jtAev, ov^^^

ovTU ^e dKptjSwg. ^io eKoXa^ovTo jtxev, ovy^ ovtw ^e a(f>o^pco<;.

rENNAAiOT. '* Xct)p<f yap vofxov^ (pvjciv, " VI dfxapTia veKpd."

T»;v yap Trpd^iV dfxapTCckov 6 vojxog airayopevoov (Jvvi<JTYjcnv, cog

(dv fx'1] TovTov fxoi TrpoirapvjyyeXKOTog avT^g diioyrjv eTcneTVjOev-

Kwg vitvjp^^^ov avTrjv, ovK av vjv evoyog irXvjixfxeX-^fxaTi. " ov yap ovk
**
ecTT/ vofxog, ov^e TrapdPaaig." ov ydp ekXoyelTai dfxapTia, ft.ri

ovTO^ vofxov. " ey(a he e^cov yjapK; vofxov iroTe. lo eyw vvv avTi \o

ToD dvQpoiTrog Xeyet, Xeyet 8e 'Trept tov 'A^a^. '* eXBovai^g Se t^j-
" evToXvjg, vj dfxapTia dve^i^aev, eyw de direQavov." eft-e yovv tov

dvBpairov eyovTa Trpo toD vofxov to ^v oJ evToA^ •irpoaeXBovaa §/a

TVji TrpoaBev veKpdg dfxapTtai, ava^yjaaavjg, tovto acfyeiXeTO' Kat

evpeBrj fxot vj evToXvj vj elg ^»>?v» «i^tt; etg BdvaTov. Kat ireTrovBd Tt i^

ayeTXtov, Kat ovTccg eXeetvov, Tvj evepyeata ^Xa^etg, Kat roo Trpog

^(tiviv ^oBevTt fxot PovjBvjfKaTt, tovtch to ^vjv diroXeaag. " vj yap

^^dfnapTia d(popf)iVjv Xa/Sovaa ^ia TVjq evToXvjg e^vitrdTVjae fxe, Kat ^i
^*
avTVjg direKTetvev." eyovaa ydp "tid TVjg evToXvjg 7rpo(paatv vj Ka-
rdpaTog dfxapTia, Kat OvvaTCCTepa tS) OTrXce tx efxco yevofxevyf, S/ 20
avTov fxe tovtov TrapaKpovaafxevv] KaTea^pcJ^e. ^teiai fxevTot Trept

T^g dfxapTiag, oog ^coavjg re Kai v(peaTV}KVtag Kat ao(pt^ofi.evv]g tov

dvBpccTTOv, KaTa ro tiJc Qetag eBog ypa(p^g. ovtco yovv Kai tvjv ii-

Kaioavvvjv TrpoacairoTrotwv ft.aKdpiog eladyei Xeycov^ " ^iKatoavvv]

" evcairtov avrov TrpoTropevaeTat" Kat irdXiv HoXofxcbv t»)v ao(ptav. 25

Kat oXcog ev Tolg Beioig Xoytoig iroXv to TotovTov l^tcofxa.

AioAapoT. '*
^XBovavig te" (pr/at, " t^j- evToA^f, vj dfxapria
'
ave^vjaev eyco de aireOavov. et ave^vjae, bv}Xov ort e^vj yrore,

Kat d-noBavovaa dve^Y/ae. irore ovv e^Tj ; OTe eiXvj(pora rov 'Aldfx

evroXvjv Kat e/^ota, t»jv irapd^aatv oXeBptov vprdrviae Kat Karv]- 30

ycovtaaro ^td/3oXog. coaavTOjg Sc OTe Kai rov Kaiv. Kat ydp

avTOg ev yvooaet vjixapre TrapayyeXBetg fxvj (povtvetv rov aBeX(pov,

'^td Tot5 " vjf>.apTegj vjavyaaov." ft.v] ovavjg ovv fxeTOtJ^v, fxv]Te evro-

Xvjg, fxv]Te vofxov, eveKpovvro v^ dfxapTta r^ rcov afxapravovTCOv

94 EHHrHSIS EI2 THN HPOS VII. 8.

oi.yv(a(7ia. ra yap TiK^lara i^yvoovv TTTaiovTe^' ojare ovTe vno tov

avvei^OTog KaTeKpivovTO. ti ovv eK tovtoov ; eXvaneXei [xvj ^ovvai

Tov vofjiov ; aAA e^vjfxiovvTO ol fxeXXovTeg KaTopSovv. aTOTtov Se

Oia Tovg pa6vfxovg Kai (piXvj^ovovg aveAeiv twv (XTiovhaKav Kai eva-

peTwv T7JV rrjg acoTYjpiag VTioueaiv. 5

©EOAflPor. IlaA^v eTTi ro Trapd^eiyfxa yapel elg r^v rov Ttpo-
*'
Keifxevov TTiaTcoaiv, Kai (jyvjaiv, eyw ^e e^cov x^pig vofxov TTOTei'^

Ttepi Tov AoafJL keym. ag av ore evSvg eyevero, e^a vofxov rvyya-
vovrog' Ttpiv yj ^e^aadai icapa rov %eov TVjg d%oyv\g rov (pvrov ro
eTiiTayu.a. oyjKov yap wg eyevero "nporepov' elra ryjv evroXvjv e^e- 'o

^aro varepov. oBev ettdyet,' " eXBovavfg ^e rvjg evToXvjg, vj dfLapria

" ave^viaeVf eya ^e diteSavov' Kai evp($v} fxot v] evroATy vj elg ^oi^v,

" avrvj eig Qavarov.^^ eTtet^Yj ^e, (pvjaiv, 6 Qeog rov itepi rov fpvrov
OeOccKe vofKOV, Kai ^idKptaig eyevero "^vo •npayft.drm, v^ fkev dfxap-
ria TtapetaOva IV eayev' eya ^e ravavrta Ttotvjaag rolg rco Sea 15

^e^oyfnevoic, 6avdr(a KareKpi^Yjv. yeyove re Yjfuv XotTtov Oavdrov

TtapeKTtKOg Ttapa rov Seov redeig vofxog, eTti rx i^vjaat Tteia^ev-

rag avrw. ydp rot fxaKdptog YlavXog ekvjKvde fxev ent rovrotg

aito rov vofxov rovg Koyovg' tel^ai (3ovkoft.evog (og ov (pavXov

avrov vjyeirat, KOivag Oe Xotitov itept r^g rov vofiov (pvaecog ^ia- 20

Xeyerai, ro '^petSj^eg avrov Kai w(peXifi.ov ti^^daKm. o6ev Kai TVjg

Ttpog rov A^dfi. f)Lef».vvjTai evroXvjg. eTtei^vj dp-^^vj vofxov roig dv6pw-

Ttoig eKCivog eyevero. Kai avfiTtXeKcov dfi.(f)orepa KaXag eTtdyei'

" cuare 6 ft.ev vofJLog ayiog, Kai vj evroXvj dytck^ Kai rd e^vjg.

OpirENOTS. Tore ydp Kat yevoir dv itepi t&v rotovrov, ori 25

ovrog ^vi yjeptg vofj.ov. eTti ravrviv yap tvjv Kardaraatv ava^pepm
IlaDAo^ Kai Ttdg dv6pco7tog epei, " eycb ^e e^m yjjiptg vofxov

" TTOTe. eitei itore vjv ycopig vofLov, oitov Ka6cbg avrog (pvjai,

'TtepirofJ.v] OKTavjfxepog, Ik yevovg lapavjX, 'EPpaiog e^ 'E/Bpaim.

cv ydp Ovvarai ro eri dXoyov eyov Kardaraaiv itat^iov ^tjv vito 30

vofJiov. Ttdg yap avdpcoitog e^vy %(opig vofKov nore, ore itat^iov vjv.

Ka' TtavTt av6p(07ico vjX6e Tiore yj evroX"^. itore ^e vj ore avveTtXvi-

p(oae rov Xoyov, Kai vevovjKe rvjv evroXvjv itporarTovaav fj.ev ra

roidoe, ditayopevovaav ^e rd roid^e. dfua ^e toD eX6eiv rvjv evro-
VII. 8. P12MA10TS EniSTOAHN. 95

\rjv Kara tov rrpSiTOV ai/r^f Kaipov, vcptaTaTat 7) KaKta, i^ w$ o

r\av\og o)voixa<7ev, ava^'^ yj afxapTta, Tewg ovaa vcKpa. eTret^rj [xy]

TTecpvKev dva^yiv d[xapTia, Kat 6 eaco dvBpwTTog, '^ta tovto eXBovrjrig

TYig evToA^f, iy fxev diJ.apTia dva^yj, vj Ve '^vyr} dTroBvrjaKei' Kara

To, " y\^vy^ rj dixapTavovaa, avrrj diro6ave7Taiy to ydp " eyw" ent 5

Trjv ^pvy^y Kat eiii tov 'eaa avBpaiiov ava(f)epeTai. [xrj vofJii<Trj<; ^e

vapanXrjatov Tt eyeiv tov OavaTov tov npcoTov irjg d[J.apTtag, too

^evTepco Tavirig BavdTua. ag ydp TioXkrj ttacpopd otc veKpa rj

a[j.apTta yoopig vo[x.ov, Kat OTe veKpa r] dfJLapTtay veKpcoSevTcov toov

jtAfAftJv ToJv ent y^g avo tov Xoyov. ovTcog Kai Trjv KaQ e^dTepa lo
veKDOTrjTa Trjg d[f.apTiag ^oo^g, TioKXri Ttg av etrj Kat ov avyKpt-

TiKrj rj eTepa tt} eTepa ^tacpopa tov ^-^v. ^y^Xov ydp OTt rj veKpd

dfJiapTta ^rj, OTe [xvjttco veKpovTat Ta [xekri Ta eni Trjg yrjg viio

Tov Koyov. irpo oe tov vofxov Kat tov ek6eTv Trjv evToXvjv e^rj, vfKpd

ovaa. 15

AnoAiNAPioT. Noet yovv [t.01, (f>rjai, fxr] reQevTa npwTOv vofxov,

cog vvv ov TtapeaTtv eirtTtfxrjatg. dyvoia yap avevBvvov KoXaaiv ovy^

vnoKetTai. fxera TavTa eiietatovaav Becopet Trjv evToXrjv. evTavQa

KaTe^avtaTUTat KaB rjfLoov rj dfxapTia, npoayevofxevrjg Trjg yvcoaeoog,

Kat [xrjKeTi Trjg ayvoiag Trjv opyrjv dcptaraar^g Trjv eirt ToTg ytvo- 20

[xevoig. OVTOO ^e ^r] fxev rj dfxapTia, "tvvafxtv Kat tayyv XaixfSd-

vovaa. aTroBvrjaKet ^e dvSpooTrog, tyi yvcoaet KaTaoiKa^ofxevog' Kai

irepitaTaTai to ^oooirotovv dyaQov rj tov vofxov irpoaTa^ig, eig Qavar-

Tov Trpocpaatv. rjg yap avev, Trjv dfnapTiav, ovy olov Te afxapTiav

eivat, ov^e KaTo^iKo^etv QavdToo tov dvBpcoirov, ^ta TavTrjg Orjirov 25

Kat TQ Trjg irovriptag eyKKrjfxa, Kai to Trjg KoAaaexg eirtTifxiov

avvtaTaTai.

^cTioT. 'H fxev dfxapTia veKpd' eya ^e ev ^co-^, aTe fxri

evoyXovfxevog ft.rj^e vvTTOfii.evog, fxrj^e veKpovfxevog vir avTrjg. Tri^g

ovv dve^i^aev eKeivrj htd tov vofxov ', Ttva Tpoirov, OTt tov vofxovso

^oQevTog [xakXov eKetvrj irpov eiri6eaiv aapa)^vv6rj, Kat oiov eTrrjped-

aat wpff.rjaev' «tc ^rj Kat aTe(pavova6ai [xeXXovTa tov (pvXd^avTa

T>jv evT&A^v viroXoyt^ofxevri, Kat ^ia toDto [/.dXXov tia(3aaKat-

vovaa. Kat eyca ndXiv yvovg ^<a Tiqg evToXrjg t>jv dfxapTtav, oog ev
 96 EHHrH2I2 E12 THN HPOS VII. 12.

yvaxTfi TrpaTTCOV a cpevyeiv cSf/, fxaWov KaTO. tovtq yjfxapTUvov'

Kai fxakXov avrvjv KaT efxavTov fTT^pmvvov, layvv avTYi ^<a t^$

KaTa yvaaiv aTOTiov npa^tKg eitiyopyp^^v^ Kai olov acrOev^ Kai

V€V€Kpcoft,€VYjv ovcrav eviayvoov Kai ava^oiTrvpwv. rj Se ^yicyatja €fx€

€V€KpW(7€. TTpO ^€ TOV ava^aai €K€IVYIV, lyW €^Ci}V fXaXXoV. TOVTO 5

Oe ^v Ttpo TOv vofxov Kai TVjg €VToXrj(;. coare e/ Kai fuifi vofxog

afxapTia, aXk ovv CKeivov ^oQevTog, KaTo, ^vo Tpoicov^ yj aft.apTia

ave^rjtrev. avTVji tc €K€tvy}$ fkakkov iipog eiiiBecJiv avaKivYjBeicTVjg

Kat ^teyepdeiijrjg, Kai yjfxcov tyj KaTa yvSoo-iv eKTOTia Tipa^et evtcryy-

crdvTCtiv avTyjv' Kat tyjv KaB yjfnav eTriPovXyjv criiv Tiaopyjaia Trapa- 10

(Tyofx.€VYiv. aKX eKeivyj fxev ave^yjaev, eyw de aneoavov.

*'
H yap afxapTia a(f)opfxyjv XaPovcra." avcoTepco etiicov " OTt

" acfiopfxyjv Xa^ovaa yj afxapTia, KaTetpydaaTo ev efxot Tidcrav

" entBvfxtav," enayei oti ov fxovov eTiiBvfxiav iiaaav KaTetpyd-

caTOy aWa Kai edavdTcoae fxe. avTY) yeyovev eig BdvaTov. eha uog 15

eflof avT^ atTtag aiTiaig avvatpeiv, Kat ttjv aKoXovGtav evtetKvvvai

Kat Tav TtpayfxdTcov ev Tolq Xoyotg, dvaTpiy^ei Kat Tt6y]<n itcag

*'
KaTetpyaaaTo Tidaav €7it6vfxtav, '
Kat (pYfaiv, " oti acpopfXYjv \a-
**
0ovaa e^yjTidTyjae fxe." eha d(py)Ke to TtpoppYfBev voeh evTovQa
OTt €K TOVTOv ^c €tpydaaTo T>jv €Ttt6vfxiav, Kai TOVTO dcpetg eTiiavv- 20
*'
dnTet TO T€\o(, Kai aiteKTeivev' iv vj KaTo, avveyetav ei Ttg dva-

Xd^ot ovTcog avTcp etpYjfxevov. " acpopixYjv Xa^ovaa vj dy.apTia

*'
KaT€ipyaaaTo ev efxot iidaav €TTi6ufxiav" tyjv Se eittBvfn.tav

KaT€tpydaaTQ aTtaT-^aaaa' epyaaafxevY/ ^e t>ji/ eTttBvfXtav, aTteKTeive

fx€. eaTtv ovv diidTYj atTta TYjg €7ii6vfxtag. yj ^c evtdvfxia tov 25

6avdT0v. Tyjv he «TraTijv etpydaaTO ^ia. TYjg evTokyjg yj dfxapTta'

tva (pavYf TO VTtep^dXXov TYjg KaKiag avTVJg, ^td tov dyaBov to

KaKtaTOv epya^l^ofxevYjg.

12 Qo"re 6 ^ev vofio^ ayios, koll t] evToXrj ayia kou

SiKaia KOLL ayaOr). 3°

Ktpiaaot. " Aytog vofxog Kat yj 6vroA>j dyta Kat ^iKata

" Kat aya6y]" diio^atvet yap dytovg re Kat ^tKaiovg Kat dya6ovg

Tovg otTtep dv ^vvatVTO (pvXdTTetv avTOv. tva ^>j yevotVTO Ta7g €k

 5

VII. 13- Pi2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 97

'JTapa^aa-eav aiTiaii ()V^a[ji.o9ev dkwataoi. dk\ vjv tovto ttws avf-

(piKTOv. ^^ TrapaTTTafxaTa ydp Tig avv^^xei ;

' KaTa to ytypafXfxevov.
*'
rENNAAioT. ^'"OcTe," <f)i^aiv, [Xfv vofjioi ayiog, Kai vj

*' dnXicg
evToXvj dyia koI '^iKaia Kai dyaS'^." o fi.€v (7vvti(Tfj.og

(VTavOa TrpoaeppfTiTai' vOfKOV ^e Kai IvtoXyjv TavTov afJLcf^oTepag S

wvouiaaev. dyiav fLevToi Tiqv cvtcAvjv e/Vev, o)? T^/jg afAapTiag aita-

yov(Tav, Ka\ tiiaTiixjdv t€ Ka\ dtpopi^ovaav tov KaKOv. oiKaiav Se,

(og fkeTa tov ^iKaiov Tty.S)o-dv Te vnaKovovTag, Kai Kokd^ovaav

TtapaKovovTag. dyahriv ^e ^g '^tiyoxxjdv Te irpog to dyaOov Kat ot

ayaSorrjTa ^oOeicrav Seov. ov toivvv o vofnog afxapTta (pvjatv, lo

0(7ye yvoopi^ei t€ fjt.oi to (pavXov, Kai TVjg tovtov npd^ecog etpyet.

aXKa TovvavTiov, ayiog t€ Kai ^tKaiog Kai dyaSog.

©EOAfiPOT. Tvjg irpog tov 'A^ocja fnefJLVYjTai evToX^?. eTreitvj

apyvf vofKov Tolg avBpcoTroig eKeTvog eyeveTo. Kat avfn-^XeKdiv afx.-

<f)OTepa Xeyei, " waTe o fi.ev vofnog aytog, Kat vj evToXvj dyta Kai Qi- 1

" Kata Kai dyadvj." tva etTrv] OTt dft.(pOTepa Totvvv ayav (0(f)eXift.a.

KaXwg ^e eTii t^c evroXvjg irXeiocrtv ey^pvjaaTo ToTg eiraivotg, «tc

^vj Ka\ TVjg ^o^recog ovk eir' dvayKaioig KaTo. to irpoyetpov Qo^d(Xvig

^e^oaOat, Koi bavdTOv irapeKTtKVjg aTrdat yevofnevvjg. eKdXeae oe

avTV]v dytav ff.ev, (og idg d(f)opff.dg Trapeyovaav TVjg Te tov KaXov 20

Kat Tov KaKov ^iaKptaeiog, Kai to KpeiTTOv airo tov yetpovog a(f>o-

pi^ovaav' ^tKatav Be, cog dvayKaicog fjLeTa to ^e7^ai to KaXov eird-

yovaav tc5 irapafSaTVj tvjv Ttfjicoptav' aXXa Kai aya$vjv, <og KaXcov

"TrapeKTtKVjv, to Te irapeyetv ttjv ^tdyvooaiv, Kat to fxet^ova ireiQo-

fjLevoig vTrtayyeHaQat KaXd. 25

13 To ovv ayaOov efxol yeyove Oavarog.

Ktpiaaot. "'Ay/of fxev vofxog, dyta Ve Kai vj evToXvj Kai

" dycSriP eha irag e(f)aaKe, " Ka) evpeBv} fjiot v} evToXvf vj etg ^covjv

" avTVj eig BdvoTov ;" apa ovv, etire fuot, 'yey&ve to ayaBov oXe-

6pov Trpo^evov ; fnvj yevotTO, (fjvjatv, eiratTicofjiat yap ev TovToig, 30

vjKtaTa fxev tov vofxov, eaTVjKa Se coairep TVjg dfxapTtag KaTVjyopog.

KaTa/3td^eTai ydp ovtco tvjv dvOpconov (pvatv, Kat TVjg ev vjfuv Ota-

voiag KeKpaTVjKev, coaTe avTOv tov eig acoTvjpiav vjfjJiv Kat ^cijtjv 00-

BevTa vofxov, TVfv dytav ovTag Kat dya^v\v €VtoA>jv, flavaTov yeveaOai

o
98 EHHrH2I2 EI2 THN HPOS VII. 13.

irpocpaaiv toi$ vTre^evy[xevot$. TraJf, 7] riva rpoTrov ; ei yap e^^e-

rai f^ev dei To7g 'Trapavofj.ovaiv -^ "^iKif], ^teXvjXdKajXfv ^e npoq tovto

KotTiov dcjQevetag y}[xei(, cog dei Taig TrapalSdaeatv evaXicKecrBaif

evapyeg ritrj Trwf, OTt Kara tovtov tov t^oVov, (ja^av vofAOi,

aytoq t€ Kai ayaQog, vevpd Trojf toKe"! yeveaBai tyj dfJLapTta, Kat 5

otog etg BdvoTOV TOi"? v<l> dfxapTiav. Kat Tdyd ttov (f)Vj(Jtv,
" tva
" yevv)Tat Ka6 VTrepfSoXrjv afiapTwXoi vj dfxapTta ttd T^f evToX^f."

To?f ixev riyvoYiKoai to tw ^eaTroTrj hoKOvv expeTat [xev Trdvjcog to

evaXavat OiKatg. r}VO[xrjKaat ydp, ei Kat [xy] eyva>Kaat. TrXrjv eaTtv

avTOig Kai airoXoytag ovk diitQavog ot[t.ai koyog. npo^aXovvTai 10

ydp KaTa to eiKOg Trjv ayvotav. ToTg ye [nrjv ev vo[i.a to [Ufi et^e-

vai Xeyeiv to 6ekri[La to ^eaitoTtKOv, el Kat [xy] ovet^i^ Trcof, ovkovv

€(f)aiveTo ^tapiovv ripri[).evoti avoatag, ovk ayvotag earat, dXk d-no-

votaq TO KaTr]yopri[i.a, Kat to}; avcDTaTO) Xotnov d(ptXo6eiag. ovTag

dv XeyoiTo " Ka6 vTreppoXr^v afKapTcoXog." a[t.apT(jciXov u.ev vndpyov- 15
Tog Kat Tov 'neT:Xr][t.[xeXr]KOTog (ag ev dyvoia, r^Ktara ye [t.r]v Ka6
VTiepl3oXrjv Xeyo[t.evov t€ Kai ovTog d[JLapT<t)Xov.

rENNAAioT. To ovv ayaSov e[koi, (prjat, yeyove BdvaTog ; [nr]

yevono. dXX rj d[i.apTta. ovk apa, (f)r}at, rov KaKov [xot to dya6ov

aiTtdao[t.at' Trjg ^e d[iapTiag Kparr^yop^, Kat Tavrr^v fjiiaa. Kai 20

vpog TavTr]V ovk av eKCOv elvat aneiaaift.r}v wot€. iva (pav^, <pr]atv,

rj d[J.apTia tid tov dyaBov [j.ot KaTepya^oft.evr] ddvaTov. avTT/ ydp

/SXdxpaad [J.e tco dya6w, ^t avTov [t.ot tovtov Kat Tr]v eavT-i^g (f>v-

atv ^Tig ear) KaTe(f)dvv]' " tva yevi/]Tat," (pr]at, " Ka6 v7rep^oXr]v
" dfLapTCtiXog Kai dfxapTta tta Tr]g evToAiJf ." eXeyyeTat ydp ^td 25

TOv VQft.ov, (j)y]atv, v]XtKOv t€ Kai oaov eartv yj dft.apTta KaKOv. tov

ydp 7iapaKeXevoft.evov avTr]v fxot <pvXdTTea6at Kat ^e^ofi.evov etg

avft.fj.ayiav, vncaKeXtaaad ft.€, ot dndTr^g avTov ft.01 tovtov ene-

aTrjae (povevTrjv.

AioAflPOT. "EXeyyog, (p^^^rrt, Tr]g tov ^ta/SoXov 7iovr]piag 030

vdfxog. dya^Qv te tov voft.ov eiTre. (patveTai ovv novr^pog ^etvog

av Ttovrjpog. OTqy ^td tov ^oBevTog ayaBov BdvaTOV Tolg XafSovai

Tov dya6ov vOfxov npov^evy^aev. ''dft.apTCi}Xog," (pr^atv, " rj dft.apTta.*^

^avepmuTa vvv e^ei^ev oti dfxapTtav tov ttd^oXov eXeye, Kat

 VII. 14- P12MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 99

dfxapTCi)Kov vi/v avrov oovofjiaaev' afiapTco^Oi ydp icriv o a^apTiSiv

TrOlVjTlKO^.

OpirENOTS. E" T/f irpoi Ta €ipY/[ji.eva avQvTiocf^epei XeyaVj

lJ.rptoTe ayiog voiuog yeyovev eig SdvaTov tw avdpaTrcp ;

^'
e^Oovavjg
" yap T^f evToX^i dve^rjaev rj dfxapTia. o ^e avBpaitog aneBavev.^ 5

aKovaere oti ov to dyaBov -ye-y&ve BdvaToc, aAA e^e^ tvjv afxap-

Tiav (pavyjvai vjkiKOv ecTTi KaKOv. OTe ydp eTTihvjfJiei to ayaBov tvj

^v^yj, (fyavepovTai to KaKov. Kat edv Ttg [xeTa tovto afjiapT^,

evpidKeTai tov Bdvarov Troiovaa BavdTOv Ttpo^evoi. Kai 7] afxapTia

oyj^ avkag afj.apTia, dk\d KaB v7rep/3oky^v afj.apT<t>kog avTVj, ^id xo

T^g ayiag evTokv/g Trapeia^vvovaa, Kai tov Bdvarov v]fx7v Karepya-
^off.evvj.

14 0'i8afJL€u yap otl 6 vofxos TrvevfiaTLKos 1<jtlv.

Ktpiaaot. Y\vevfj.aTiKov (pvjai tov vofj.ov, iog diroTekovvTa

Tivevf/.aTiKovg tov^ e7roft.evovg avTw. voeHrai Ve itvevft.aTiKOg, joi^ 15

KaTa (jdpKa ^av, aiiovevevKog &e fj.dkkov ein to Bekeiv eite<7Bai Tvj

*'
Bekvjaei tov YlvevfJiaTog. e^pvj Se Kat 6 fuaKdpiog Aal3i^, vofxog
**
Kvpiov dfJ.<afJ.og, eTriaTp€(f><i}V i\)vydg. vf fj.apTvpia Kvpiov TrtaTi^,

" ao(pi^ovaa v-^Tria' (po^og Kvptov dyvog, '^iafj.evav eig atava atta-

*' ." coaTtep ovv (pvjatv eivat rov vofnov, oibe yap 20
vof afj.cofi.ov afj.(afj.ovg

aTtOTekeh' Trtarvjv oe r^v fxaprvpiav, wg jriarovg avro^paivovaav'

Kai dyvov rov (poPoV eart ydp dyvoTrotog' ovrcog eK^e^vj KdvBdoe

•nvevfj.artKOv etpvjaBat rov voft.ov, cog Tivevfj.ariKovg aTiocpaivovra

rovg enofj.evovg avrco. ei ydp eariv ev aKiaig, akk ovv eyet rvjg

dkvjBeiag rvjv fLopcpcaatv. ri oi/v Ylavkog ; tayvpi^^erai fj.ev ort 25

'nvevfJ.artKog vofxog. atTidrat Be rvjv avBpcoirov (pvatv cog 'jrokv

voaovaav rvjv afj.apriav Kat iretparat 7rkvipo(popetv cog eiretTrep

eari jrvevfj.ariKog 6 vofxog, ravrvj rot fxdktara (poprtKog eari rvj

rov dvBpamov <pvaet. rt ydp eiire fxot (pvjatv ;

" e/ fnev vofj.og eari
" Trvevft.artKogf eyco ^e aapKtKog etfxi'^^ Tovreari ro^ rvig aapKog ^o

(ppovYifkart rvpavvovfj.evog. opag oircog eig oai^v vjfj.7v evavrtori^ra

Beki^fj-drcov riBvjat rd ^vjkovfneva. erepov ydp ro Bekv}f*.a rov nvev-

fKaTog, Kat erepov dv vooTto to rvjg aapKog. dvTiKetvrai yap

' Cod. in marg. ^a-ui t^.

o %
100 EHHPHSIS EI2 THN nPOS VII. 14.

aXXyjXot^, Kat aavfxjSaTov eyovai t^v tU TavTOTVjra avvQpofx-^V

0T€ Toivvv aapKtKog jxh 6 avOptoTro^, rtvev/xaTtKOg ^e 6 vo[xoi, nag

av yivoiTO Kai etg to To7g ovrcwf YjppcaaTrjKoai tvjv aixapTiav ;

fxaXa €[X(f>pov(i}i. e/ yap €aTt aapKtKOiy voyjSetT) av otd ti^ atyjxa-

XcoTog, Kat ev TaJ^€t ttj oiKeTiKrj. 5
rENNAAIOT. EiTTt TlXeOV V7T€paTToXoyOVfX€VOg T€ TOV VQfLOV, Kat

TVji atTtag aitoXvav avTOv, tovto, cf)Yjatv, €TrtaTaft.ai, OTt voftiog

irvevfnaTtKog eaTtV tva ^'iTrvj TcXetog Kat avev^e»;?, Kat dpeTYjv

dn'/]Kpt(3ooft.€VYiv airaiTuv aBavaTotg TipoavjKovaav. aXX €ya Tt

TtdQct) ; 6vyjTV}v Kat (pdapTVjv Kat iroXXoig TtdGeatv vTiOKdfxev/jv Ttept- 10

K€tft.€vog adpKa, €Kt€toft.€vog coa^Ttep €tg TTTatafxaTa ; t/ yap ire-

irpafX€vog viro tyjv afKaprtav ; avTt tou oog 7r€irpaff.€vog X€y€t Kat

TOVTo Se i^tcoft.a ypacf)tKOv to ^tya toD OfxotafKaTtKOv €TiippYjfxaToc

Xeyetv t< tS>v TrpoK€tft.€vm TroXXdKtg. otov €aTt Kat to " Seog
" ^fxwv Ttvp KaTavaXiaKovr €oik€ ^e to '^hovXoi ^Te T^g dft.apTtag'^ 15

€v ToTg " Ttvt viroy^pecog av TreirpaKa vfi.dg, aXX yj Taig dft.apTtatg

'^
Vfxwv €7rpdOYjT€'^^ Kat Tco €V TOig dytotg EtvayyeXtotg €tpY}fX€Vca

*'
Trapd Tov "EooTi^pog Yjftiov. qti 6 Trotwv tyjv dft.apTiav, ^ovXog eaTt
" T^f dfxapTtag.^^ ovrcog ydp chTtg YjTTYjTat, tovtco Kat ^eOovXcoTat.

AiOACPOT. EiiKOTCog XeyeTai irv€Vff.aTiKOg vofxog. (j^vXayP^VTa 20

ydp Ta €v avTW irapayy^XfxaTa itvevfxaTtKOV ktrotet tov avSpcoTrov.

Yj Kai OTi (pYjai KaT €V€py€iav Ylv€VfiaTog 'Ayiov €7ri^€KTtK0vg,

*'
K€Kadapf/^€vovg, t^ tov vofxov Trai^aycoyta. 7t€7rpafL€vog^ vTro ttjv

" dfxapTtav," ovy^ VTro €T€pov Ttvog 7r€7rpafX€vog, aXX avrog v(}>

avTov KaToXtycopiov tcov 7r€7rapYiyy€Xft.€vctiv. 25

OEOAaPOT. To *'7rv€VfLaTtKog^ dvTt Tov wcpeXeTv Kat Trai^eveiv

d ^ei tvvdfLevog tyjv y^/vyYjv. to Se aapntKog dvTt tov BvYjTog, Kai 'htd

TOvTo TroXXYjv Trepi to dfnapTdvetv eyjov po^rvjv. tovtq ydp Xeyet to

" 7r€7rpaft.€vog v7ro tyjv dfxapTiav.^^ eTret^Yjirep yj Trpdatg, '^ovXov Trdv-

Tcog TTOtet Tov TreTrpaixevov vTro tov riyf v^rvjpeatag KabtaTafxevov ^o

dvdyKY]v, cog dv ovtco Kat y^fKcov ttd TYjg BvYjTOTYjTog €ig tyjv tov

aft.apTav€tv eTotfxoTYjTa KaTaardvTcov. (BovXeTai yap eiTreiv OTt

KaXog fx€v vofxog, Trat^evet ydp t)]v t/^y%^v, Ttvd ft-ev dya^rdv,

" Cod. Tctitpa.yfjt.tvoi; et sic iterum posthac.

 VII. 15- Pi2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 101

Tiva ^e a-noarpecpeaQat Ttpoorjiiei, Kai ro Tiavrm irporiixav rav

Beiwv TO ^ovkyjfJia' 0(f)eAog ^e efjioi Tipog ro aTtYjXKayPai rrji; auiap-

riag evrevOev ov yiverai. 6vy)Tog yap cov t>;v (pvriv, Kai TtoXkyjV

^ia rovrov Ttepi ro au.apTa.veiv rrjv evKoXiav Oe^a^aevof, aTtfjX-

Xa^yQai rov Trraieiv ov '^vvaixai. Kav [xvpiaKig a irpoa-^Kei oia rovS

vofjiov TTai^evufJiev tt^w xpvx^-^v.

llpirENOTS. Tt-^TYjfjia avaKVTirei aiio Traa-vjg rvjg TrpQKeifx.evYig

TiepiKOTiyjg, irag ravra Xeywv 6 YlavXog, ov QoKei evavnovadai

roig i^ioig Koyoig, o Xeycov " rifi.Yjg vjyopaaSvjre,^^ Kai *'
^piarog
**
Yjfxag e^Yjyopaae,"" Kai " ^a> ^e, ovKeri eya, ^vj de ev eft-oi Kpi- lo
" o-TOf." e; fn-^ Ttov eiircofjiev ori Ttpoadmoitouag eyei ^ia(f)opovg

TioiOTVjrag TrpoawTrcov, evQa ol (f>avXoi aXXa irpaTTovai -napa xy\v

7ipovjyovfi.evYjv eavrxv itpoQeaiv. 6 Se itapm Xoyog apfio^ei Xe-

yeaOai vito rav fji€fxa9Y}K0rav ra itepi rov vofiov, ori 6eiog eari,

Kai ^XeitovTCOv avrov ra itpoarayfj.ara ori elai KaXa. omev Oe '5

^TTov wg Tteitpafi.evoi vno rY\v af).apTiav Kai aapKiKoi ovreg, Kat

ytvoiaKovai ita>g efJiTttTtrovatv vito rvjv afnaprtav.

'5 ^ '/(^p KaTepyd^OfJiai ov yLV(a(TKa>.

Ktpiaaot. OiovTa< «-aToc to etKog rav df/i.aOeaTep(i}v riveg tcov

'EiXX-^vctiv fxvQov efKTtetovv eBeXeiv avrov ov ovk oi^ OTtcog eKehoi 20

Ttpea^evetv eyvcaKaai, TtXavxvreg re Kai TtXavcofJievoi. eifLapfjievvjv

ydp riva TtXaarovpyovvreg, Kai rv^^vjv Kara ro a(ptai Ookovv' eha

TO Kpareh rcov Ka9 ^fj.ag 7tpa.yfi.aTxv ratg ovk ovaaig avdTirovreg,

Ttapaipovvrat rov dv9pcoTrov rov ort ft.dXtara itpeTtovrog avrw, (f)Y}fji.t

Se rov "y^pvjvat jSiovv eXevdepcog, avetft.evvjv re Kai eOeXovatov eyovra 25

T>;v poTtvjv, rvjv e(f> ortep dv eXoiro rm itpaKrecov. dvdyKvi Se coaTiep

Kat To7g Ttap eKeivcov opotg re Kat \l^Yj(f>oig vitdyovrei, ov fjierptcog

d^iKovat rovg Kard rov^e rov (3iov. et ydp rig toi Kar' avrovg

etti ro ^pdv a ft.v] 9eft.tg, ovk evov avrco, Kav et ^ovXotro, rv)(pv rvjg

etfi.apfj.evYig ro vevfia ^iacpvyeh, ov^' dv oXcoi ^iafi.cou.YjaatTO rtg €v30

(ppovcov, Kav et opcoro TtXYjfj.fj.eXcov. b yap v)v avdyKVj Kai ovy^ eKovra

hpdv, ei dxiaKoiro Tteitpaycog, e^co vtov vdvrcog atriag earat Kat

^tKvjg.

FiTtatveaete S dv t<s ov Xiav efj.(f>pov(og rov e-ntetKVj Kai Koafj.iov.

102 EHHrHSlS EIS THN riPOS VII. 15.

T/ 'ya^ ei yeyove TOiovTOi ovj^ emov, aX\a roii CTepov vtv^acyi

Trapfivriviy^evog elg tovto' (xakkov ^e Kai ajxa^^ov avT^ t>jv

avdyKrjv KaTe^avtaTaayji TVjg TV^^vjg ; ovkovv aitYiyjki fJi.€v itavTe-

Awf TO Ta7<; 'EAA^vwv TepQpeiaig avvaTro^pepiaOai Xeyeiv tov twv

KaKXiGTav elai^yvjT-^v' \\yovv oieaOai TVjg eKeivcov dPe\Tepiag levai 5

KaTOTTiv, Tov Twv 6eiwv Yjfuv (j.v(7TYipio}v yeyovoTa Tafxiav^ ei Xeyoi

Tvypv' " b yap KaTepyd^ofxai ov ytvuiaKoo. ov yap BeXa, tovto

Trpda-acD. «AA' fxiaoOf tovto TroiaJ." ei ydp ^vj Tig okws ttiayypi-

aaiTo, Kai h^ Kai eXoiTo (f>pove7v ug eifxapfx.evvj fxev Kai Tvyvf tv^v

Twv KaB v]fxdg aTrovevefxvjKev e^ovaiav, TrZi ovk dv etKOTCog eipolTO 10

av avTOv eKeho nov Xeyxv' ei aKhvjpaTg Kai ovaavTYjTotg avdyKaig

evetKvifxevot tcSv irpaKTeav vj fi.y^, Kvpioi f«.ev vjfieig ovodfxoSev KaOe-

aT^Kafxev' e'tKOfxev Ve fxdXXov (t)g KpoLTovaiv eTepoig Kai tov KaTa

yvafxvjv etpyofj.e6a' Troog vjf/iTv yeypa(f>ag avTog, " vj dyvoeiTe aoeX-
*'
(poi, ytvcaaKovat yap vofxov KaXa, OTt vofxog Kvpievet tov av- 15
*'
Bpdmov €(f>
oaov ypovov ^tj." Kvptevet ^vj ovv Ttva TpoTTOv twv

^'wvTcov vofxog. aiipaKTvjaet fxev yap apapoT cog ent ToTg TeBvecoaiv.

6pi^€Tai he ovK eKetvotg iioGev, dXXd ToHg 6t< twv ev acofxaTt Tpi-

jSovat (3iov. Kat aTe(f)avot ff.ev eiraivotg tov evtoKifxeh eluiQoTa,

KaTa\pYj(f)i^eTat he tS)v /3ePvjkwv tvjv ^tKVjv. ehd itdig vofxoBeTvig 20

oatog eaTat KpiTvjg KoXd^cov v^fxapTVjKOT ag Tovg etg tovto Treaeh

afSovkYjTcog eK Tvyvjg vfvayKaafxevovg ; fJMkXov te re Kai oXcog tov

vo'ft.ov coptaoTO. Totg ft^ev ydp eyovaiv evr e^ovaiag d dv ^ovXotvTo

hpdv, oatav vOjtx.of opi^^et ttjv ^ikvjv, ei Tiapov evhoKtfxeh Toug

dyaOovpyiaig eiiioovTag tov vovv, avTot Ta alaytca TeT tfxvjKdaiy 25

Kai Tcov dfxetvovm TjAAafavTo Ta '^ta vofxov KaTeyv(»iafxeva.

'YoTg ye fxv^v e7rYjpTVjfji.evov eyovai tov TVjg dvdyKvjg ^vyov, Kai

otTtep dv ToTg KpaTovai ^ok^ Tpeiroff.evoig det, TreptTTOv olixat irov

TO Beaiiiafxa' KaiTot Trws' ovk dXvjdeg etiteh, ag oiih av vjfuv 6

TtdvTa ei^ag tov eK tov vofxov ^vyov eiteTtQet, to avToo toKovv ev^o
fxdXa l3pa(3evovTa Kat TtatdaycoyovvTa Ttpog to avfK(pepov, el ToTg

elfxapfxevotg (3poyotg evetXvjfXfxevovg vjTttaTaTo ; vj ydp CKeivo Xeyov-

Tcov ol ^t evavTtag, cog vjyovj'^ (sic) Kai tovto Seog. ^ e'iTtep opQd

* Cod. aiiTo. Leg. 'Ijyvoei,

VII. 15- PnMAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 103

<f>pov€iv vjpvjfjievoit ^e^iaci a<f)ohpa ro r^f appYjTov ^o^vjt; Karayeai

r^v ajvoiav^. vevofjLoSeriKevai ^e <pa<7if Kai fxyjv Kai rm iiXrjixft.e-

Xovvrccv KaOopta-ai rag ^iKag o[j.oXoyYjaovaiv evapyiii. oioe itov

ndvrwi eXevBepa (ppov^fxaTi ^ia^l^mra rov avSpcoiroVf Kat ponaii

eBeXovaloig ecf) onep av e^ovXero ^tdTreiv la^^^yovra^ TrapaTio^i^ov- 5

roi ovdevo^.

TavrvjTot Kai o QeaTreaiog YlavXoi Kvptevetv ecpf} rov dvdpcoTrov

Tov vofxoVf e(j) oaov -^povov ^yj. ovkovv ovy^ aq rv]^ dvSpwmv ^ta-

voiag TO?f erepccv imoKetfxevoi'; vevfLaai rd roidoe (pvjai' (f)tXoao-

(fteT ^f, Kat T^t; dv&poonov (pvaewi rd ndOYj Treptepya^erat. fnovov ro

Se ov^x) Kou dvopvrret Xenrasg rd eU vovv eaco rav dppci}ary]fji.dTCi}v",

Kal T^4- efJi(f)vrov (f^iXi^^^ovia^ ro acofxa ypd(perat rov voaovvrog eri

rrjv (fnXoaapKtav, eavrca ro TrpoawTrov ev fxaXa TtportBetg. et yap

Ka) earavpctiTai fxev avroi tco Koafxct}, Kai fxi^v o Koafxog avra,

Kai Yjv d^tdyaarog dXyjOax;, dXX vjyeho ao(f)ov, fxyj etq ro otKehv 15

ydpiafxa ^Xenetv, dXXd t^v ovttcc yeyovorcov Kar avrov aaBevetav

vTToBeatv dvajKatav noteTadat tw Xoyca.
"Orav ovv dKovavjg Xeyovroi, " ydp Karepyd^ofxat, ov ytvco-

" aKcOf" evvoet rtvag rm virepdyav*^ dfxapTcoXuv otofxevovg, ort rov

navdptarov dXyjdoog '^ta^aai (3iov' Kat ort r^i ev rw^e rca Koafxw 20

Tpv(f>yj$ Ka\ e^tryjXiag ov^ev av yevotro ro laoararovv. Karafxv-

adrrovrat fiev ydp tt?? eTrteiKeiaq rovg rpoTrovg, evafx^pvvovrat ^e

Kat evanaraXcoat Xiav ra7g a(pm avrav yj^ova7<i. Kai nept avrav

ctfxai nov (f^i^atv TlavXog, '*

ot rd eniyeta (ppovovvreg, wv Qeog

" y] KotXia' Kai yj '^o^a ev r^ aia-j^vvvi avravi' ovrot (paiev av 25

eiKorcoi cog rt rwv dyav eiratvovfkevm 'TrXyjpovvreg ro (f>avXov, "
^^
ydp KaTepyd^ofi.at ov ytvcoaKco. ovkovv aKoverooaav, " eKvyjxpare

*'
0/ fxeOvovres e^ otvov avrav." ovnep yap Tpoirov ot (ptXoTrorai

Kat Kdrotvot iiapaKeKOfXfxevot rcc TrdOet TYjg '^tavotag ro dKpi(3eg,

ovK dv ei^eiev rd a(pia\ '^pccfjieva", Kard rbv rov fxeBvetv Kaipov,r^o

ovrctig ot rvjv (ppeva KaryjppcoaTyjKoreg, eK (ptXoaapKtag Kai rwv

ala^^^iarm yj^ovm, ov^e ort irore ^pcoaiv etoeiev av.

Noay]ft.a oi/v y]fxh dvBpcoirov Kap^tag 6 TlavXog e^y^yeJrat Xeym,

* Leg. vid. dfOiav. ^ Cod. ap-^crf^fAdTuv. '^ Cod. virep ayav.

^ Cod. hpofAfva.
 5

104 EHHrH2I2 EI2 THN HPOS VII. 15.

" yap KaTepya^ofxai ov yivacrKCo" ei ^e ^yj t/^ avj roTi fxev

aito Tov avveioOTOi eXeyyoii TpvcpepcoTepav (oaTiep vneyjov Trjv

kavTov KapbiaV Kai aayaWm fxev oti 7rXy][X[xe\ei' iiX-i^v eTi

7rXeoveKTOVfxevo( Tatg eig dfxapTiav yj^ovalkg^ Kai olov d^ovKYjTUit;

*'
<wv Tipoi TO TrX^^ixfxeXeSi (fxnii^v av elKOTwg. ov yap b fleAoj, tovto 5

" '7ipa(7a(i}, aX\ fXKTw^ tovto ttoico. Wf irocroi TToaaKig TeOavfxd-

Kacn fxev tvjv eyKpaTeiaV Kai ^^ Kai fxeXeTYii Tyjg elg aviYjv

dp^dfi.evoi, TOig TVjg fxvaapdg vj^ovyig veviKTjVTai Kevrpoig, Kai OKXd-

aavTog avToHg tov vov npog to "/elpov evYjpy-^Kaai^ ty^v dfxapTtaV
KaTV}(f)fiag ye fxvjv fjLefjLeaTccvTai' TovTotg dv iipeTiot Kat fndXa 10
eiKOTCog fJLovovov^^t Kai d/SovX-^TCog y]aSevYjKoa-t to (pdvat W/} TtdXiv,

*'
vvvt ^e ovKeTt eyw KaTCpyd^ofxat avTO, dXX vj oiKovaa ev efkot

ij afxapTta.

Fenn AAiOT. ^TtetVf) et-nev to " neTrpafxevog ^ inro tyjv dfxapTiav"

Kat ^td TovTov T»jv fi.ev ev ^d^ei ^eanoiVYjg vneSeTo' eavTOv ^e ev 1

**
^ovXov, Ttpog TOVTO dKoXovBcog eitdyei, b ydp KaTepyd^ofxai ov
" ytvcoaKco" tovto ydp ttiov oikctZv, to Itiag eivat
fjiVj yvwfxvjg

Kvpiovg, dXXd teaitoTiKolg vitYjpeTelaQat itpoaTdyfxaat. ttoXXdKtg

*'
yovv T/ <f>Yiai, ov Ttpoaipovfxevog avTOg ^taTipdTTofxai. to ydp ov
" ytvcoaKCo ov^ OTt ayvocov Xeyet' Ttag yap, ei itpdTTei Ttg tovto 20

avTOV ayvoeiv eyy^copeH. vj oXcog av avTco to toiovtov etg a(f)dXfxa

KaTaXoyt^otTO ev evayyeXtotg tov "E^coTVjpog, " ovk oi^a vf/.dg, diteX-

**
6eTe ait efxov. '
avTt tov KaTepyd^of^at Tt TtoXXdKtg, ovk oUetov-

fxevog, ovoe yatpcov, ovoe v^tofLevog avToa KaTa itpoQeatv' oii^e efxav-

Tov, avvTOfxcog etneTv, vitaKovcov^ aXX' aXXov. Kai OTt tovto ovTcog 2C

ej^e/, <f>Yiai, tvjXov. " oii ydp SeXco, tovto Ttpdaaco, dXX fxiaoo,

" TOVTo Ttoico." TovTeaTtv, d fnev avTog efnavTco SeXco, tovtcov ovoev

tiaitpdTTOfnat. Ttotco Ve Tavavria' Kai d fKiaco, ovk dv efLavrw

{3ovXvjSeivjv 'TtoTe. ^td fxev TotovTcov tov tov HcoTVjpog cKetvov vofxov

Ttapa^atvetv <f)V]at tov cftvaiKov Te Kai TiepteKTtKOV tcov aTtdvTcov' 30

Tov " oaa av SeXvjTe tva Ttoicoatv vfxiv 01 dvSpcoitot, Kai vfxe^ig

" Ttote^Te. ovTog ydp eaTtv vofxog Kat 01 itpocf^vjTat.'^

*^ Cod. tvqfyfifAMat. ^ Cod. neTtpayy.tyoi.

VII. i6. PX2MAIOT2 EmSTOAHN. 105

AiOACPOT. Ovy^ ori TYjv afxapTiaVf oti afiapTia eaTiv ayvoeiv

<f>YI(7iv, aXk avTi Tov "awg avrrjv iToia, xat iia^ VTroPXeirTOfxat ovk

aia-davo[J.at. ohv itokKaKii Kptvag KpaTyjaat 6vfJiOVf y^TTfjQriv efJLav-

Tov. yjiyi fxevrot ei^evat, oti ovy^ eavTov KaTtf/opel^ aKka to Kotvov

Tav av6pa)7r(ov ev eavTw vTtoypacpet. to (poprtKOV eirt erepov Ta^at 5

vapatTovixevog. detKvvai yap ort opeyofJie6a [xev T-ffg apeTvjg, vjtto}-

fjLe6a ^e t^^ ^'^ov^i, oaot vno vofLcv eafj.ev. ov fjLy\v ocxni wo yaptv'

01 Kat €^6) dfj.apTtai ^ta T-rjv yaptv yeyovafJ.ev.

'OpirENOTS. 'Apfio^et to. pvjfj.aTa TavTa \eyetv To7i iiaKat-

<ya<jt Ttpo<; Tag htt6vfj.tai' ^ta &e <xa6evetav XoytafLov iteaoixTt' 10

Kat To?s' Into 6vfi.ov ea6 otc vtK(t}fj.evoti Ka) vvo (fjo^oVf Kat itpaT-

Tov<Tiv a fj.r) 6eXov<7ti Kai a fj.i<TOv<Ttv' otov &€ Kat aito Xoyov
eTtoipaecoi yjTT^^^^evTeg vtKti^afJ.ev eK tov '^OKovvTog etvat aya6ov ov

fnvjv dXy)6ovSf <7vft.(pafi.ev toj vo/aco OTt Ka)Cog, itoiovfj.ev oe to Ka6

VjtoVYjV. 1
5

Ei 5e ov OeXco tovto ttoico, av/KJ^rjfii r« uofjia> otl

AcaAoy.
- rENNAAiOT. E/ Toivvv (prjatv^ **
fj.vj avTog 6eXci}f tovto itoiSa^

tia TovTo Tov vofuov eivat KaXov Ka6ofj.oXoy<Jo. ag ydp eKeivog KaKi-

^cov itpd^etg dttayopevet fkot, tovtwv Kat avTog eycb TtpoKaTeyvccKO, 20

Kav fj.eTtco TOig epyotg avrd,

Ktpiaaot. 'KvtvjCTt TtdXiv TVjg 6ecoptag to aKpt^eg^ TVf tov

<T(i}fj.aTog (pvcTetf Kat tcov evovTcov avrcp (pvatKcov appcoaTVjfiMTCov

TVjv ^vvafntv KaTaaKeitTeTat' at t€ ydp ope^etg at itpog itdv oti

ovv ditoKOfJit^ovaat tcov ita6<av, Kai r^f (ptXvi^ovov ^covjg Ta eyKXvj- 25

fj.aTa itviyviv 'eyovat tv\v adpKa' Kat itpog ye toiJto, vjfndg efJ.iteOoT

Xeycov tov SwT^pof ft.a6v]Tv]gf " Tro^flev itoXefJ.ot ev vfj.h, Kat Tto6ev
" fj.dyat ; ovy^ evTev6ev €k tuv vj^oviov vfKcav rcov aTpaTevojj.eva}V

" ev Tor^ fxeXeaiv y/Awv;"

106 EEHrHSIS EI2 THN OPOS VII. 18.

KE*. lA.

Uepi Tav iv av6pa>TTiv{j (})V(rfi nadav, ddvvaTov iroiovvTav ttjv irpos vofiov

crvp,(f)a>viav.

Ol8a yap oti, ovk ot/cet eV ifio)., TovTeaTLv eV Ty aapKi

ixov, ayadov. 5

©EOAOPOT. Ka/ TQvio [X€v vofji.ov, (pt^o^i, TO ')(j>-^at[Jiov ^eiKvvrai'

a(f> cov ov^evi twv TrpaTTOfxevav ap€(TKofiai. ofxoXoya yap axoTia

elvai, Kav fjLvpiaKii avTo. ^iaTrpaTTtofxaif to itiiiaitexKjBai tovto

VTTO Tov vofLov. (paiveTat oe rj TYjg dfiapTiag iV^ff, ovto) fnov ^ia

Triv OvvjTOTVjTa KpaTov(xa, w^ Kai aKOVTa itoXKaKii eiti t>jv twv 10

aTOTTdJV KaTa(f>ep€a6ai Trpa^iv' Kai to avTO itdXiv' " oita yap oti

" ovK oIkci €v efi.01, TovTeaTiv ev T-q aapKi fLov, to dyaBov' Kai yap
€7tiaTaft.ai, (prjaiv, oti oaov eiii Tyj aapKt, Sv^tojv ^'^(^ovayj tvjv

<f>vaiv, ov^ev twv eli dpeT^^v avvTekovvTtov TtpayBrjvai ovvaTai. yj

f/L€V yap 6vvjT0TV]s Tftiv TiapovTwv €(f>i€a6ai fkovov yifA,ag itapaaKevd- \S

^ei. €K ^e TVjg TTept TovTa a^nrov^vjg dpeTvjv e/V aKpov ovtafj.wg oiov

T€ fJLV) Twv TtapovTwv vTtepopwvTa KpetTTovt XoytafKSi a6avdTC0v

d(f>t€fJievot Ttpayfi.aTm.

To yap OiX^LV TrapaKeiTai fioLf to Se KaTepyd^ecrOaL

TO KaXov ovx €vpLcrK(o. 20

Ktpiaaot. " To yap ^eXetv" (f>vjat,

" TtapaKetTat fxot, to
" ^e KaTepyd^ea6at to Kakov ov," Kat Ta e^vji' etg aitodet^tv tov

KaTYiyop€7a6at tvjv adpKa ^etvwi a^tvovaav ev eavTvjf tvjv d/xap-

Ttav Ttapo^€y(€Tat ao(f>S>g' to 7tapaKeia6at fnev vjfj.h to dya6ov'

fj^in fj)i^v €Tt Ka) TO hvvaa6at ^iaitepatvetv avTO. KaTal3td^€Tat ydp 25

eti afSovXvjTov evTpoitvjv, Kai ov^ €KOVTa tov vovv. ovkovv oaov

i]K€v etg y( TO avTW ^oKovv, vjv dv e^ci} Kat dfj.apTiag. eTtetVfj te

^va^id(pvKTOV v7tOfj.ev€t TtXeove^tav eti^ dv eiKOTwg ovk avTov ^vj

fxdWov aWa t&D "TtXeoveKTOvvTog vj atTta' TavTVj Tot (f^vjaiv' " ei

" ^e ov 6€X(o, eyw tovto •notSo, omeTt eya KaTepyd^ofxat avTO, 30

" «aA V) oiKovaa ev €fj.Qi df/.apTta."

Aia TtdvTCtiv TOVTCov To €v ToT^ evayyeXioK; Xeyet itapd tov

VII. i8. PI2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 107

'*
^ecriroTov Aej^fiev oti to TrvevfMa TtpoBvixov, vj ^e (rap^ aa6evy}$"

TO yap <f>6apT0v t^c capKog Kai (xv[j.7ra6ec TVjg irapavofxias KaTai-

**
TiaTaiy ovK olKHf^ yap (pyjaiv, '*
ev Tyj aapKi fJiov aya6cv.

TovTeaTiv ovK ep^e< to aita&eg ov^e to TeXeiov, Ka\ ai/ev^eef re Kai

avafxapTi^ToV o6ev avTVjv Kai aapKa iioXkaKig afxapTiag Ka\e7fS

Kai aa^ixa afj.apTiai Kat cwfxa oavaTov. aipov[j.ai yovv tw va to
aya6ov, Kai TtapeaKevadfxai irpog tovto KaTO. ylivyviv' eiii oe t«v

oia aapKog epyoov avTO ixeTeh6eTv ovy^ evpiaKco, aXX eairovoaKa

fxev Kai ayavi^ofxat Tioiyjaai to aya6ov. VTcdyofxat Se Ttap avTVjg

•npaTTeiv a fii^ Trpoyjprjfxat. t^v ovv ToiavTyjv irpd^tv etKOTag ovk io

e/x,>jv, dXX aXXoTptav Xoyi^Qfxat.

0EOAI2POT. KTTtfii.evoov 7o7s avTo7g, " ov yap o ^eXco" ^>?o"i,

*'
TTOta dya6ov, «AA' o ov 6eXu} KaKOv tovto itpdaaoo. ei he o ov 6eXco
'*
TovTO TToiu), ovKCTt eyo) KaTepyd^ofxat avTO, dXX vj oiKovaa ev

**
ef/.oi dy.apTtaS^ to yap avTO KdvTav6a Xeyei' oti t-^ j!*ev 1^115^7715

alpovfxat TO KaXov, v^no tov vofxov itat^^evofxevoi a Se?" itoiS) te

ov^ a (SovXofxat itoXXdKtg, aXXa a fxy} ^ovXofxat fLaXXov. /3ov-

Xofxat fnev ydp Ta TOt$ Beiotg vofxoig dKoXov6a. itpaTTW Se

TdvavTta, wv eitiaTafxal Te Kat ^ovXofxat KaXm. ag evTevdev T^f

dfxapTias (paivea6at t^v t<7yyv, ^v KaT efxov ^id t^? 6vY[TQTViToi 20

eiteKTyjaaTo' e'iTtep Vri Kat Ttapd yvafxy]v eitt t^v oiKeiav fxe
'*
Ka6eXKetv ^vvaTat Ttpd^tv. to ydp ovk eyw KaTepyd^l^ofxai^

dvcoTepo) KavTav6a Xeyet tq itapd yvafXYiv, oid itdvTav oe tovt»v

**
«710 Toy oi^afxev ydp oti 6 vofxot; "TtvevfxaTiKog eaTt," /3ovXeTat

eiiteiv, OTt KaXoi fxev vofxog, Ttai^evoov d Oei tvjv ip^X^V Kai tov- 25
Tov ye eveKev acpo^pa •^(^i^atfxog.

Eyw ^e ^id Tyji ^vi^TOTyjTog oe^dfxevog dni^XXd^^^pat tov itTaletv

'hid Tyjg Tov Xoyov %t%aaKaXiaq, ov ^vvafxat. itoXXyjv fuv ydp e-yei

T^v layvv vofnos ev Tyj TYjg y\^vyyj; ^t^aaKaXia. Kai tovtq ^oJAov,

c^ av dKptjSyjs eyKetTat yjfx7v yjTe tov KaXov Kai tov KaKov §/«-30
Kpiatg' ovhe TtttntOTe yovv vito tov TtXyj^ovg tZv dfxapTyifxdTm, to

ei^evat tovto dite^dXofxev. TovvavTiov te xai fxvpia TtTatovreg.

Tov 'yoDv e/^eva/ T^f dfxapTiag tyiv (pavXoTyjTa eKTOg ov yeyova-

fxev. ov fxyjv dcpeXav yjfxm to dfxapTdvetv ^etvvyiTat, TVjg 6vy}T0-

TyjTOf TtoXXyjv tvjv evKoXioa/ y^fxlv epyaaafiLevyjg. dXXd Kav acpodpa 35

P 2
108 EHHrHSIS EIS THN nPOS VII. i8.

^ia Tyjg olK^iag titaaKaKiaq TToWyjv tov tipoayjKOVTO^; (.pyaariTai

TYjv 'hiaOf.aiv^ aKQVT€i Kai «j ovk 'laixev TrokkaKiSf eig tyjv tojv «to-

"ncDV V'jro<f>€pofJi.€9a iTpd^iv.

AioAOPOT. ^AyaQoepyZv o Oelog 'AnoaToXog, c/Vwv aKi^Kt^^aTOi^

eyivfTo Twv fjtMSvjTevofxivav' otov yapiv Kai (K€Kpa^e, " fjii[xy]Tat 5
" fjiov ytveaSe, KaOchg Kayw 'KpiaTovJ'^ Toiyapovv ovk avTov eaTi

Kara KvpiOTyjTa €(f)y]'

" otta ^e qti ovk oik€i ev TJj aapKi fuov
**
TO ayaBoVy^ dW ovhe to " TaXatnapog eycii avSpayTrog, Ttg fne
" pvacTai eK tov aci)f/i.aTog tov OavdTov tovtov. aXXa TavTa kat

oaa TotavTa, ev TrapevBeTcp TrpoawTtca vnoKptvof^evog Xeyet' irpog 10

ekeYXfiv rav (piXaft.apTi^fJi.ovcov. waTrep ^e rovg dvQpccnovg a%o rav

a(f)av Trpd^ecov, aapKtKovg, xpiJ^tKOvg, TTvevfj.artKovg, Kat erepotg

fjivpioig ovofnaat KaXeh ottev y) 6eia ypacpyj, ovtcc ^yj Kat rov ^td-

/SoXov, ov fxovov Y^aravav Kat dvTtKetfj.evov Kat ^tdj3oXov Kai 0(f>iv,

Kat Xeovra KaXeh oi^e, Kat ]ieXiap, dXXa yap Kat adpKa Kat vofi.ov 15

Ka] dfj.apTtav Kat GdvaTOv' Tovrotg yap e^ovXevaafiev S;a ryfg Tta-

paKOYjg, Kat ov tc5 X-ptaTw.

'
Otov ydpiv Xeyet, " ore yffi.tv ev ry^ aapKt" ^yjXwv cog vvvi

ovK ert ovTcov avTwv ev aapKi, Katirep ovrcov ev aapKt' ag ovk apa

rYjv adpKa y]v iieptKeifj.eBa tta^dXXcov, dXXa ryjv Ofj.covvfi.ag avryjv 20

Xeyofxevyjv adpKa. ^g Kat aTTYiXXdyYifxev ^ta ro dnoOaveiv YjfJ.ag ev

'Kptara, ^ta rov avvra^pyjvat avrw ^ta rov ^aTrTiafj.arog. ovrcog

ravTYjg y}Xev6epco6yjft.€V ryjg aapKog. eiit^epet yap Xeycov, " vvvt

*'
^e KaTi^pyrj6Y}fj.€V dico rov vofJ.ov rvig dfi.aprtag, diioBavovreg ev
**
00 Kar€fyoft.€6a, coare ^ovXeveiv y}fi.ag ev KatvoTYirt Tivevfiarog, 25

" Kat ov TraXatOTVjTt ypdfLfiarog." ei6 ovrcog Yjp^aro •ndXtv TYjg

Ka6 v7io6eaiv irpoacoTroTrotiag, ap^afj.€vog aito rov " rt ovv epov-

" fi€v ; vofJ.og dfj.aprta ; ft.Yi yevoiro" ecog rov *' raXaiTTCopog eya
**
avOpcoTTog, rig fi.e pvaerat eK rov acof^arog rov 6avdrov rovrov ;"
aaetarov 6efJ.eXiov npoBefi.evog ev TrpoXoyca T17V eavTov d-noXoytav 30
&t/Ta) XeyaV " Tt ovv ; vofkog aytog, Kat evroXy) dyta Kat ^tKaia
**
Kat dya^Yir evTav6a vofj.ov Xeyet, ov tov dvTtarpaTevoft.evov tS>

vofico Tov voog y}fJ.av, aXXa rov irpoTTapaiveriKov, rov rovg dfj.apTd-

^ Cod. «KTjX/SoTOf.
VII. i8. PflMAI0T2 EniSlTOAHN. 109

vovras KoXoL^ovTa. otov ya.piv Kai avvnl>v}(fna^aTO avTW wi oai(a Kai

^iKaicp Kai aya6a.

EiS' ovTUi vjp^aTo tvikveiv aKoXovOai oU avaTepo) "TrpoeTrreVf

\oyov evyapi(7Tov iipooiixiacra^evoi; ovTwg' " evyapiTTS) tw Sew Oia

" ^lriaov KpiaTov tov Kvpiov rjfnav.''^ €iTa npog KaTaKpiaiv tS)v loi- 5

a^e atpopixa^^oixevav Kat KaKi^ovrav ag nepiKetiJi.eBa aapKaq, Xeyei

*'
eirepmyj^aTtKwg, apa ovv avrog eyo) too [xev vo/ ^ovXevcov vofJLa

" ©eoy, TYJ ^e aapKt vofx(p ajxapTiag." apa Kayco TlavXog fxefxe-

Tpiafxai ^ ; Tiyj f*.ev ^ouAeuwv vo/aoo ©eou, ttvJ ^e vofjiw afxapTtag ;

dpa Tov X.piaTOV Kai tov BeXiap, afxa Kai KaTa to avTO eyw ev lo
efxavTw ; dpa eych o Xeyav " ^cS §e ovKeri eyw, ^y ^e ev efxoi
" Xo/o-TOf," \pevadft,evo; tvjv dfxapTtav ^Soaav eya ev efxavTx ;

dkXoig Trpo^pav^aag, " ovk o'i^aTe oti to, aafxaTa vfxav vaog tov
" ev vfxh 'Ayiov T\vevft.aTog eaTi ;" Kai " ^o^daare tov Qeov ev
^*
Toig fxeXeaiv vff.S)v," avTog eyo) ev tw aafxaTt ovtev eyjDV^S

dyaQov ; aAX' oiiK eaTi TotovTog, ovk eaTi' fxvf yevotTO. TeKvov

yap opyvjg Kat aKevog opyvjg Trpiv, fxera^aXwv tov ipoitov ov tvjv

(pvaiv, eyevero Tifxtov eKXoyvjg aKevog. eiiei ovv Ta TTpoacaTtoTrotvi-

QevTa p-^fiaTa ovTe tco Beaiieaif YlavXw dpf/LO^ei, oure fxvjv navTi

tS) avvTacpevTt X/Sio-Tco ttd tov ^aTrriafxaTog' tiOTi Tvjg ovofxa- 20

^ofxevTig aapKog v^XevdepwBvjaav. ov yap eri KaTaKpt^yjaovTat ot

ToiovTot '^td TVjv Tov 'A^oc/x TTapaKO-^v' ovKeTi (Baatkevei avTav vj

dfxapria' ovy^ BdvaTog "^id T^f dfxaprtag' avveTa<pv]aav yap

T-^ ^w^ Tov "KptaTov, ^id TVjg vitaKovfg TVfV irapaKovjv e^a(paviaav-

Tog, Kai TOJ eKovaioo eavrov GavaTX tov e^ avTVfg eTrtavfxfBavra 25

Yjfxh Sdvarov eKKpovaafxevtp' yeyove yap eKWV vno vofxov rov T^f

TtapaKovig, 'iva v][xdg Toiig vTto vofxov tov t^^ KaraKptaeoog e^ayo-

pdavf. %id TovTO e<pv) " Tidg XeXvTpoofnevog."

" \dptg Se Tco Sew ^id ^Jvjaov Hpiarov tov Kvpiov vjfxSov. to
" ydp a^vvarov rov vofxov, ev co v}a6evei "^id rvjg aapKOg, 6 Qeog ^o
" Tov eauTou Tiov Ttefxipag ev ofxoKOfxaTt aapKOg dfxapriag, KaTe-
" Kpive TVjv dfxapriav ev TVf aapKi.^^ ori Se Tav& ovTcog KaXS>g TeSe-
iopvjTat, eitt(pepet Xeytav de7og AitoaToXog' " ov^ev dpa KaTdKptixa

g Sic Cod. sed leg. [ji.eiJi€i>KTfMi,f.

110 EHHmSIS EI2 THN HPOS VII. i8.

" TCi<V ev Xp/oTw Ivjaov — rjkevSepwcre fxe aiio rov vofxov r^g dfxap-
" Tia^ Kai Tov QavaTov" Kai ra tovtuv e^rji. neiodacti ^^ ^ia

Ppayeav Kat eis avra ra pYjfj.aTa ra KaTa TfpoacoTroTroiTav eiprj-

fxeva Tiaparpe^/ovToog eiTretv, dp^dfxevog diro rov, " d<popfJi^v Se

*'
Xa^ovaa yj dfi.apria, ^id r^g evroXi^g e^viTidryjae fne, Kai ^i 5

" avryjg aneKreive."

To dfxaprlag ovofxa, ovk ovaiav vcffearaaav ^vikoi, dkXa rpo-

•7I0V Kai l3iov rov ^ivjf>.aprrjKevai rtvd rov Kard Xoyov Kat opBag
ej^ovTOf TTpdyfxarog. (oaitep yap yeviKccrarov eariv ovofna yj afxap-

ria, Kard itoXKm Kat dtacpopoov Tipayfxdrm KaTViyopovft.evfj. Trdv i o

Se dfidprr}fj.a ovre Xoyw, ovre vof^io TipoaraKrtKW yiverat' ei yap
Kard vofKov Kai Xoyov eytvero opOov, ovKert dv r]v dfxdprrjfjia

wptafxevov Kai rerayfxevov eyov rov rrjg yeveaewg Xoyov. enet^i^ 6

Belkog AnoaroKog ov^ dTrXag dfJ.apTYjfxarm, aXX dfLaprtag yevt-

KCOTdrrji ey^ovarig (ppovrift.af eyovafig vofJ.ov, tvvafKevy\q ao(f>iaaa6aty 15

acpopfKag iroptaaaBat Tipog ty^v rov KaKOv KaraaKevrjv, fxvrjfj.ovevet,

ovK aXXov rtva yeviKttirdrwg dfxaprtav ovofxa^et, aXX rj avrov rov

Tm dft.aprr]fxdrm ap-^^rjyerrjv Kai Tiarepa htd/3oXov, orov "X/^ptv

Kat (SaaiXeveiv twv dfxapri^fxarm avrov A^ioaroXog anecprjvaro.

" fLrj ovv (3aatXeverci) rj dfKaprta ev rcjo Bvrjrio vfxm aciifxart^ cog 20
yap rovg dvdpcoTiovg a(p rjg eiitrrj^evovat reyyrig KaXovfxev, ovtci>

^rj Kat avrov rov ^tdl3oXov wg Tipwrciog ecpevper^v yevofxevov rrjg

dfxaprtag, dfxapriav KaXel.

EiTiet^hri rotvvv ^id rrjg ^oBeiarjg rx A^dff. d<pQpfxdg noptad-

fxevog ^ia rrjg evToXrjg. eart Se avrr}. *'
ri ort^^ (prjatv, " einev 6 25
" Seog, dito Tiavrog ^vXov rov ev ra Ttapa^^eiacfi, ov (pdyeaOe ^ dv
" «yTot;, ttavoiyB-fjaovrat vfxm ot ocpBaXfLot, Kat eaeade oog Seot,

" ytvcoaKovreg KaXov Kai novrjpov.^' ao(pt^erai ^e avrovg ft.ei^ov,

eTiayyeXia KaraKpvy\>at ttjv dndrrjv, viita^/yenat ro nXeov, tva

rovg rrjg evroXrjg (pvXdKag rm rrjg dper^g /3d6pm rw Oft.oica ^o

avrovg Tirciifxart Karaarpey\>ri. rov yap avQpamov e^oiarprjaag, laa
Qeco eBeXet yeveaBat, rrjg Kara dndrriv ofxtXiag rrjv d(popft.r]V

e-nopi^ero eK rrjg 7iapay(6etarig evroX^g' orov "xdptv HavXog

e<pri, " d(popf>.r]v ^e Xa^ovaa rj dfxaprta ^/a rrjg evroXvjg e^rjvd-

h Hsec mutila sunt, Gen. iii. i. et seq.

VII. i8. Pr2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 111

Ty)<J€ fji,€. iva 6e /x^ ti^v evT0A>;v yj rov TavTVjv bcOiOKOTa Weov,

aiTidaovTai Tiveg, yeiTovi Kai ofj.ocjitopw ej^iJcraTo p^^fxaTi Toid^e

*'
(f>daKa)v' oi^afxev Se ot< 6 vofLog ayiog Kai rj evTokyj dyta Ka\
*'
^iKaia Kai dyaSyj.^^

^Tiei ovv ovh avTrj rj dfii.apTia, TOVTeaTiv o tid^oXo^y <f>v(X€i 5

*'
Kai ovaia afn,apTia ecrTiv, eTTKpepei Xeycov, iva yevrjTai Ka6 VTiep-
'*
^oXriv dfxapTaXoi vj dfi.apTia ^ia Tvj$ evToX^i-." to ydp KaT ov-
ciav Ti ov, TO TrXeov Kai to eXaTTov ovk eTrite^eTai. e<TTi ydp
cirep e<7Tiv, aei tovto ov oirep e<JTiv ovaico^Hog. tco ydp yivofLevw
Kai e7riyivofi.evx t/, erre oXiyov, eiTe Kad vTrep(Bo)^v, eTepdg e<XTi 10

KUT ov<Ttav Tav avTca eTriytvofLevccv' to ydp Trocrov, ovk ov<Tta,

akXa irept tvjv ovcrtav, e<JTtv, ovk ov ovcrta. >] apa Totvvv KaXov-
fjievv] vno tov AirocrToXov dfiapTta, to irXeov e'irtte')(Ofi.evyi df/.ap'

Tvjaetv, tva yevvjTat Ka6 virepfSoXvjv aft.apTa}Xo$ vj afJiapTta, apa

Kat TOv eivat df/.apTta, vj afuxpTta ecT/v, dpyvjv eXajSev, ovk ovaa 15
Kaff vvep(3cXv}v ev dp^^^rf KUTa to vjfnapTriKemt dft.apTccXo$ vj

af/.apTia' ^io ^vj Kai tvjv eiriTaatv tov yeveaSat Ka& vireplSoXvjv

dfiiapTCiiXog vj dfnapTia ^id TVjg evToXvjg. ei Se Xeyoiev Kai irwg av

€11^ dyadv] Kat ^tKaia ; Trw^; Se dyta vj evToA^ Kat vofKOi, oiroTe

Qia ryfg d(f>opfJi^s avTcov dft/xpTCoXog Kaff virep^oXvjv lyeveTO dfxap- 20

TaXog vj afjLapTta ; Trpog TovTa aKOveTcoaav, oti ovKeTt KaTa-
Pxd-TrTeTat vj^vj, Kai vj d<popfi.v) ^/' ^v ^XdirTeTat (pavXvj eaTt Kai

Trowjpd. ov^e yap oti 01 dvotco<; koi dfj.eTpcog evarevt^ovreg tco vjXio)

pXairTovTat rag oxpetg, ^d'*; Kai tov viXtov (pafj.ev irovi^pov. ovo oti

Kaff V7rep(3oXvjv ^td^oXog dfi.apTcoXog yeyove tw evrtyetpriKevat 25

Kard Tov Ttov tov 0eoy, rl^v) Kat tov T/ov toD ©eoy (pavXov Kat

yrovvjpov elvai Xeyofj.ev.

**
Oita Se 0T< ovK oiKet ev efnot, TovreaTiv ev Tr) aapKi fj.ov,
<{ > /1 / M ~ ' V ~ ' A ?>V / >}- ~ \ r/
ayaoov. vvv eig to tov AOafn Trpoacoirov eqvjyetTat. Kat ori

areprjSetg rov 0eov eyeiv ev eavrco dvrt rvjg ovrcog i^cor^g Odvarov 30

KaraXXa^dfnevog. Kai yap Qdvarog ovy Kotvog fj.ovog rcov f>.€Xcov

avrov eKpdrvjaev, dXXa Kat rvjg TrapaKovjg, Kard rvjg ypvyyjg avrov
eta^aXcov. fxaXtara yap Kparcov Odvarog irpo rvjg rov ^ptarov
eTrtov)fj.iag, e^aatXevae, Kard irdvrcov vofiov Ka) aKVjirrpov rvjg eav-
 5

112 EHHrHSIS E12 THN nP02 VII. 18.

Tov PaatXeiai iyjisv ryp TrapaKoyiv. aXX ovk avapypg vj ayevYjxog rj

Tov Qavarov jSaaiXeia. ck yap rm ^wvtcov to TfOvdvai avfxlSaiveif

Kat eK TVji Twv virvjKOav vitaKOYjg to TtapaKova-ai riva. to yap

**
Oekeiv "napaKeirai jxoi' ro Se Karepyd^eaBai ro Kakov ov. yap
" 6eXa> dyaOov, rovro ov Troia, aAX' ja/ac5, rovro Trpdrrco." ei
5
ro Bekeiv (j.ovov ev y^fxh eari, ro ^e Karepyd^eaOat ro 6eXvj6ev

KaXov, ovK eariv ev vjfJiTv, etg fxar-rjv ayaOog Seog rag Ofxoovaiag
eavrov ipv^ag ev roTg aaixaat KarenefJi^pe' ro yap avrw Kat av-
raii (f)iXov ov irpdrrovatv, ovk evepyovaiv, akXd fxovov 6eXovai.

raya oe ovbe avro, aovjAov yap. 10

Ki ^e rovTO dkvj^eg eart, Kard rovg daePeig epS>' apa ovk

y}v, ov^e earat ev I3t03 ro Kakov. ovre rtg irore avro evi^pyyjaev,

iiye Kara avatpeaiv rov Kakov Kai aya6ov eirt Tiavrog av6pcc7rov

€KXafx(3dv(tiaiv, ori " 6eXo) aya6ov, rovro ov noiS), dkX [Jitaa,

** rovTo Trpdrrci)." iro6ev ^e Kat ev tw tojv dv6pa-7rm /3/co dperm ovo- 1

(xara evpe6i^' ei ^e eiatv evepyovvreg ro KaXov, Kav oXiyot eiev ot

ravra ^pciovreg, dp ovy^ 01 Trdvreg (pi^acvaiv, o't^afj.ev ^e ort ovk oiKei

ev yjy.iv aya6ov. ydp yj^eXyjaav dya6ov, rovro ov Trpdrrovatv. et

oe ot ro dya6ov evepyovvreg, ev aapKi vTtdpyovreg rovro evepyov-

atv, Kat 01 rovro fxri Trotovvreg aXXa ro KaKOV, ev aapKt etatv, apa 20

ov rrj aapKt to atrtov rov fnrj ytvea6at ro dya6ov TrepiaTrreov,

aXXa ryj rovrav fj.aXaKo^vy^i(x. ei yap rolg edeXovat ro KaXov

TTotyjaai TrapotKelrat ro KaKOv, Ofiotag ^e Kat To7g e6eXovat kuko-

opyeiv, ov KaXov TrapdKetrat. Trpovoyjaavreg oe Kai irpoBey^Yiaavreg

eirt roaovrov evepyeiag epyovrat, apa ov (f)vaet Kat ovata ra atc- 25

fi.ara yjfnav eart (pavXa. rSiv ydp yrpaKrem yjfxm Trpoyfyelrat ^ovXy\

Kat 6eXy\atg. xpvyyjg ^e ravra (ppovYifxa eyovayjg aure^ovatov, peipat

'^vvafi.evyig yrpog ag PovXerat irpd^eig.

" Nuv/ Ve ovKert eycb Karepyd^oft.at avro, dXX yj oiKovaa ev

" efxot dfj.apTia." direXoyyiaaro %td rovrov rov Xoyiov, ort irep 30
cv (pavXyj Kard (pvatv yj adp^. cv yap yj aap^ yjv TreptKeift.e6a

oiKet ev yjfxh, dxX^ ev rolg irapavofj.otg oikxv ^tdfSoXog. co ydp

Xeya, \piarog oiKeT ev Travri ^tKaiw ro ayaBov epya^ofj.eva}' rov

avrov oifxat rpoiiov oiKetv rov ^idPoXov ev iravrt KaKomtw. ovk

 VII. ai. PX2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 113

cvv 0115^ Vf^^^i eo-jU.6v, Ka6o aapKa ey^ofxev, "Trovrjpoi, aXk yj oiKovaa

ev YjfMV aixapriaf a\kv] tis oixxa Ttapa Trjv (japKa Kai t>jv "^vyriv

tov avdpaTtov' Kat yap ev ^'^'xyj

fJi.aX.iaTa XeyeTai emy^^cpia^l^eiv

^ia^oko^f KaTa to " ela-yjkQev ^aTava^ elg t>jv Kaptiav lov^a"

**
Kat KaTa to ^Avavia, iva ti eTrkYjpcocev '^aTavag ttjv KapOtav 5

aov ; ev oe tco etTtetv ovKert eyw KaTepya^ofxat avTog^ akk

**
iy otKQvaa ev efxoi aixapTia." epyov yap Kat KaTepyov irokv to

fxeaov dtoTt Tov fi.ev epyov itoielTat to KaTepyov^ waTe <j>epe

etTTeiv oiKtaf, y] vrjoi. to Se KotTepyoVy TOVTeart T^f vkYi^ vj itpo-

vapaaKev^. i o
H Totvvv otKovaa ev To7g afxapTavovatv afx.apTia, TOVTeaTiv

SaTavaf, OfKokoyovfxevui ev Tolg koytafxoTg y]f/.av iTpoKaTepyd^eTai

Tov eaoft.evov KaKov T^f /Seaf r^v /<aTacrAfeu»/v, Trjg VTro^e^afnevvj^

avTOv ^pvyrji avfHTrpaTTovavjs avTa Tojf KaKta^' Ka^anep To7g

aiTeipovatv rj Tr^g Brjkeog fxrjTpa irpog to Tekea(f)oprjdy^vat to aira- '

5

pev. Kat eTrettrjTTep e/c T-i^g Kaptiag eKiropevovTat koytafLOi TTOvrjpot

eK Trjg yevvaft.evri<; tov ^tajSoXov avkk-^xpeag, KeKpaye to Seiov

**
koyioVy koytafxovi KaOatpovvTeg, Kat iiav vxpccfua eiTatpofLevov

" Kara t^j yvwaewg tov ©eoy." wanep ToTi avToTg (pikaperotg

^vy(pug TO Ay tov Y\vevf>.a avyKOTitav keyerat, KaTO, to **

itepta- 20
** aoTfpov wdvTCtiV eKoirtaaa, ovk eyw Se, dkk rj xdpig tov ©eov
** avv e^rav pdQvfxog '^vyrj raig
rf efxot. tov ^tajSokov rrpoTpoiraTg
eireaGjjf avvepyov eyet irpog to KaKOv avTOv tov ^id(3okov. avTog
yap Kai tov tvjtov T-fjg eaofxevrjg dfuapTiag irpoKaTrjpydaaTo ev
avTrj. OTOV ydpiv eiprjTat, '*
ovKeTi eyo) KaTepya^cfkat avTO, akk 25
**
rj otKovaa ev efxot dfxaprta.^^

21 KvpUTKQ) apa TOV VOfJiOV TW OeXoVTL i/JXH TTOieLV TO

Kakov, OTL e/xoi to KaKov TrapaKeLTaL.
AOpet §€ irdktv wg aocpoog Ka\ evTeyyag diro^eyerat tov vo-

fxov. ovy^ (og Trjg dfkapTtag to KevTpov dvafLl3kvvetv tayvovTa' ^o

owTe fni^v KaTavcKpovv olov Te tvjv ev rjfxiv dft.apTtaVy dkk cog

evtevTa fxovco too voo Trpt rov avfX(pepovTog yvwatv. ei ydp efxot,

(prjai, TtapaKetTat to KaKOv, wg evotKovv Trj aapKi, KaTaKt^^rikevet

ye fxrjv vofxog avrw yapt^erat ^ tijv errtKovptaV Kat voe7rai avfx^

g Leg. vid. x«/»'^«<''^a«-

 114 EHHrHSIS EI2 THN HPOS VII. a2.

PovXoi^ ov fxyjv €Ti Kai KvTpaiTVj^. ^e7 ^e ^r} "TrdvTxg To7g appcti-

CTovai Tvjv dfxapTiaVf ov tov tiei^evai i^ovov^ oti to, afxeivo} Trpoa-

vjKei "^pav avTovg, dX\a Kai tou ^vvaaSai KaTop6ovv airep av eii

ejoi, Ka) TM vo/Aco toKy]. KaBdiiep dfxeXei Kat Toig eQeXovai evOO'-

Ktfj.eiv ev ft.dyai<;, ovk dnoy^ri iipoq tovto yvfxvrj Kai fnovv] twv S

TaKTiKm ^ e'i^vjaii, dXX ei TipocrvTrdpyoi tovtco Kai to evjQeveg,

elev av ol TOioite fxoXig Xafxvpo) kcci aTToPXeTTTOi. ovkovv ei oiha'

CKei fxev vofxog to ev dyaGo7g evTeyyegf KaT ovteva Se Tpoirov

ToTg irXeoveKTovfxevoig e^iKOVpel tvjv dfxapTiav airovevpav^ KaXog

fxev OTi Ka) ^i^daKaXog' ov fxev eTi Ka) ev lax xdpiTi t^ Qid lo

^piotov KaTaXoyiaSeii^ dv eiKOTagf tow Kai aocpovv layyovTog^ Kai

aXKifxccTepovg vjfxdg aTrocpaivovTog T&iJ KaKov.

rENNAAioT. OvKovv (pi^aiv eK TovTOJV ^eiKVVTai ^ovXofxevog

Kat vofxog avvx^d tco '^epi to KaXov fxov QeXrjfxaTt, e^ wv Kat to

KaKOVj dfX(poTepotg, efi.oiTe KaKetvcOy tuvtov airocpatveTat. 15

AioAapoT. Tx " evptaKO) tov vofxov" Xeiitei to ^vaKaTopdcoTov.

(f)Yjal ydp, OTi e| uiv Kat ^ovXdfxevog ti TiotYiaai KaXov, ov ^wafxat^

dXX^ €7r} TO yetpov TrapaTpeTiofxat, evpiaKO} tov vofxov tvaKaTopQu)-

Tov fxot QeXovTi Ttoieh to KaXov. TrapdKeiTat ydp fxoi Ta eToifXo-^

Tepa Toc KaTa Trpog to Troieiv avTd. ^id ^e tou **

•napaKeiTat^ "het- 20
Kvvatv, ag ovk epya^eg eaTt fxeTievat t*?v KaKiav.

©EOAflPOT. KaToc ^tatpeatv dvayvwaTeov. " evptaKco apa tov

*'
vofxov efxot Tca GeXovTt itoteh to KaXov.^^ eha e^^g, " qti efxoi to

" KaKOv TiapdKetTatr eKaarov ydp avTwv thta TeXeiav Kai aTivjpTi-

afxevvjv eyet t>jv evvotav. to fxev, tco BeXovTt efxot KaTa tv^v ^vyvfv 25

XeyovTog. to ^e, OTt efxot to KaKOV napdKetTat KaTa tvjv adpKa.

Xeyet ydp OTt KaTa fxeu ttjv ^p^y^v, ypvjatfxog 6 vdfxog, Tiat^evctiv

avT^v e(f>tea6ai tov KaXov, dicoaTpe^fteaQat Se to KaKov. tvjv iiepi

TO dfxapTdvetv Ve y^fxwv evKoXtav, ov^afxciog ^vvaTat a<f>eXe7v, vjTig

aTio ivig 6vvjTOTi^Tog eveyeveTo. 30

22 ^wrjSofxai yap tc^ uo/jicp rov Oeov Kara tov «ro)
avOpoiTrov.
Ktpiaaot. 'Of e<f)Viv v]^v}, Sii^a" jaev vovg to eXev6epov, kou

tS)v 'hta^e(3Xv]fxevwv dTiaXXaKTia, Ka\ Tatg dvcDTdTca TtfxaHg aTe-

^ Cod. S/>|/^.
VII. 22. P12MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 115

cpavoi Tov vofjLOv coj- tZv KaXXiaTm elo-Yjyi^T-^v. KaTapid^eTai ^e

tU (KTQTTCvi vj^ovai^ vj TYjg aapKog (pvo-ii, JioXefj.ovvTog t€ Kat

€yKeif/.€Vov Tov vofJi.ov Tr/g afxapTiag. vofA.ov ^e afj.apTia$ €ivai (prjcn

TO €ff.(f)VTov Kivyjft.a, Kai onep av VTidpy€iv oioito Tig, Trjg <l>iKoaap-

Kiag TO TidBog. KaBdii€p dfi.€\€t Kat vofi.ov €(pri voof, t>?v €ig ye to S
aya6ov avTov po7rrjVT€ Kat B^Xriatv,

rENNAAIOT. *' Y.VVri^OfJi.at yOip" 4>V^t» *'

TCO VO/ACC TOy &€0V

KaTa Tov €aco avapcowov, Kat Ta e^^f. tco yap avTi tov
Totvvv KavTovBa ^y^prjaaio. itdvTav yap diro tov " ot^afj.€v oti 6

" vofnog Ttv€Vft.aTtKog caTi '

Trpo€tprjft.€vcov avTw, avvaycoyrjv rj/3ov- i o

k^^Srj irof^aaaGat' tw fi.€V v6fJ.(C toivvv avvrj^ofi.at tov ©foD KaTo.

Tov caci} dvBpsoTTov, 6vofJ.d^€t Tov €v rjfuv vo€poVy Kat yatpca Kai

ykyrfia tovtov Tolg 'napayy^Kfj.aat. (3k€ii(a §e vofJ.ov €T€pov tSov

eavTov f*.€XS)V dvTtirapaTTOfJ.^vov^ tovtco, Kat itpog /Stav cof eat»TOv

aTTocTTraJVTa ft.€, Kai oiov a/j^aAcoToo Ttvt 7rapaK€')(j)r}fj.€vw ft,ot. a 1$

ydp €K€lVOg €TTlTdTT€t, Kat aV €K€7vog C/€aBat fUOl K€\€V€lf OVTOg

aTT^-xjeaQai tovtcov ciravayKd^ct. vofj.ov ^e dfnapTtag ev TO?f fx.€K€-

atv avTov, to ^ovX.rifj.a Kat tov aKoitov Trjg TiaBriTrjg X€y€i aapKog'

€7[€tV^ Kai TiaVTOg t^tOV VOfLOV, TO TOrS" VTt aVTOV Ta aVTCO '^OKOVVTa

irapaK^X^v^aSat. cyco TOtvvv ovy^ co yatpcti voficOf (prjatv, viraKOvo}, 20

dXX c5 /xy; yaipa). ov •npdTTd) yap a ^ovXofJ.at' a %\ fn.r] PovXo-
fj.at TrpdTTCo' Kat ft.dXXov fj.ov tS)V fi.€Xm 6 vofLog tov 6€tov vOfj.ov

KaTaKpaT^I. Kat irpog avTOV ayxvi^0fi.€vog dvTtayjsh ovk dpKii.

TO ft.(v yap TO Kat to irotrjaat, Kat •ndXtv to Kat to ft.ri Tiotrjaat,

^td Tov Betov vofj.ov Tiat^€vofJ.€vog ^yco fj.€Tpovft.€vog vito Tr^v yvaatv 25

T^f dpcT^g. €V€py^aat ^e avT^v KcoXvofi.€Vog vno T-fjg aapKog, itap

avtov l^orjGetag ovk d^tovfxat. aXX twv /xeAcSv /xoi/ vo/xo? a^e-»

Tpatvcov oiyjeTat ft.€Ta itoXefxov Xd(f)vpov KaTaKTCOf/i€vog.

A10A12POT. Tov Kotvov Kat €V TovToig avOpcoTtov ^taypd(f)€t. tov

yap Kotvov avdpcoTtov to avvopdv fj,€v tw vco Ta ^eovTa, ft.rj TtdvTcog ^o

^c KaTOpBovv. Tov ^e €ig \ptaTOv ireTttaT^vKOTogf to aiiv tco vcJj

KaTopQovv "^td Trji tov TIv€Vfi.aTog ItttKovpiag. ^<o Ka\ TtvevfnaTt-

Kog 6 TO^oyTO? KaX^hai. hetKvvat ^e ot< coanep dvTivofJ.o6€T€i Trj

> In niarg. yp, o.vrtvapataTToiAitov,

Q 2
 116 EHHrHSIS EI2 THN HPOS VII. 24.

Tov ©eoi/ vofJioOecria 6 ^id^oXog' olg yap TTpoaeTa^ev 6 ©€0f,

TavavTia TiouiVt 7rei6ei TOVi avBpwiiovi. TrecpvXayfxevcci ^e •ndvu

ev Tolg ^eXe<yiv tivai (pYjai tov TVjg d[j.apTiai vofxoV teiKvvg ag

ovK dpeaKiTai To7g tov aafxaTog TrdOeaiv vj xpv^^vj, ei xai avy-

KuBeXKeTai iioXXdKic, avTco. 5
©EOACPOT. Y,(po'hpa (X€v yap e-Tit To7i tov Qeov vofxois •fjtoiJ.aiy

^iyo"/, TTjv ypvy^rjv, eiiaivav re avTovg, Kai Tiepi tiqXXov Tioiovfxevoiy

dvTmpaTTovaa ^e v] dfxapTia too PovX-^fxaTi T^g ^"X^^' ^'^ T^dv-

Twv oi)$ e/Vfn/ Tftjv fxeXSou fTr/ tijv eavTvjs fxeOeXKei Tipd^iV Kai

KaXwg eiTiev " ev To7g fxeXea-tv" eTiet^rj iioXvTpoTrog vj dfxapTia did 10

TravTWV €7iiTi^^evea6ai (pvaiv e-y^ovaa twv fxeXm, Ta fxev yap oi

o^daXfxav, t» ^e "^td yXaTTVig, Ta. §e eTepag dfxapTdvofxev. OaV"

fxdaai le d^iov evTav6a Toi/g ^iamp-^aavTag, TioTtpov Tpeig v)

Teaaapag vofxovg ^AnoaToXog jSovXeTai XeyetV tYjXYig ovavfg Kai

dvoXvTOV Ty}g ^tavotag. dvTi ydp tov eiVerv t^v dfxapTtav, vofxov «5

etTiev dfxapTiav, ov^ev dXXotOTepov Xeyoiv. Ka^d Tt oe avTO otKeiov

**
Te6etK(iog l^icofna. ovto) koi ev Toig dvcoTepo} Xeyei, ^td vofxov Tit-

" <7T€W5*" Kat fxeTa ^payea te' " ydp vofxog tov nvevfxajog Tyjg

" ^w^f," avT/ Tov etiieTv to nvevfxa TVjg ^ooYjg. eTre/O»? yap aKonog
eaTi vofxov navTog, i^tcog ecf) cKdaTOV to toS vofxov 7ipoaTi6Yiatv 20

ovofxa' iva c/tttj tov aKonov tov TipdyfxaTog, iiept ovnep av Xeyri,

avTO TO Tipdyfxa Kat ov^ eTepov Xeyav.

'OpirENors. 'Ev roig [XYj^^eiKO KpaTVvaai tyjv e^iv eni Ta
^eXTiaTa ^taypdcpet 6 YlavXog tov iiapovTa Xoyov. (oanep Totvvv

aTpaTiuTYjg KpaTYjaag TioXefxicov aty^fxaXcoTovg ayet, ovTCog ev Toig 25

Tipoetprifxevoig npoaconotg eaTiv ev Totg fxeXeatv avTcov vof).os

dvTtaTpaTevofxevog tco vofxc^ tov voog avTCOv, Kat af)QxaXcoTt^cov ty^v

TaXatncopov ^^^v/yjv, Kat dycov eiit tov TYjg dfxapTtag vofxov ev to7(

acofxaTiKoTg fxeXeaiv.

24 TaXaLTTCopos iyco ap0pco7ro9, ris /jl€ pvaeTai €< tov 30

^avaTOV TOVTOV.
rENNAAiOT. OvK e/Vf KaKOg dv6pcoiiog, ov^e -TiovYjpog, aX>^a
" TaXaiTicopog." npoattYiyYiadfxevog ydp Kat ^et^ag avTOV t^ vo3

fxev opcovTa npog to KaXov, vnoavpofxevov ^e vpog to (pavXov tw

 $5

VII. 34. Pi2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. VH

TrdBet Toe T^g aa^KO^y eiKOTWi a>i ekeeivov fj.oi.Kkov TaXanroopov

TipoaYiyooevaiVj ov/^ (ag fJiiavjTOv irovvjpov. oavfx.aciwTaTa oe ecpyj

TO '*
Tig ;" f[x(f)aivctiv '^ia Trji airop-^aecoi to tov iipayfxaTog

tvaKoXov. Tig ovv apa, (^tjo"*, ToaovTog, os /xe t^s" Tvpavvi^og tov

aafxaTog aTiaXKd^fi, vcf) Yjg Tipog dfxapTiav KaBdKKOfxevog dava-

Tovfxat ; aaf^a yap BavaTov, to davaTov TrapatTtov Keyet. €K tov

d-noTeKeafxaTog avTO TipoaetTrtov. viro^et^ag te avTapKag tvjv

dvdyKyjVf kou ^vjKaaag to tov TcpdyfxaTog fxeyeQog, endyei, fxer

evyaptaTiag Kai vfxvov tov evepyeTVjv ti^KZv, " evy^aptaTO) too 0ec5
" fxov ^ta Ifjaov ^pioTOv tov Kvptov rjfxm. tovto Keywv OTt lo

%dpii tS) (f)tKav6pwn(Xi Qew '^ojpYjaafxevo) tijv adavaaiav Yjfxh, Kat

TYjv d(p6apaiav Kai tt^v ditdBetav ^ta t^^ otKovofxtag TYjg KaTa
Tov Kvpio-j Yjfxwv ^lyjaovv "KptaTOv, og fxeyaKoiftuvcfi itpog y]fxag kyj-

pvyfxaTt KeKpaye, " ^euTe 'npog fxe itdvTeg ot KomtmTeg Kai Tie<f)op-

** dvanavaca vfxdg.
TtafKevot, Kdyci) 1

AioAapoT. ^FiTitaYjfxavTeov ug ovy^ ditKag eK tov awfxaTog

TOVTOv, dKK^ eK tov QavdTov tov awfxaTog. ov yap tov aoofxarog

ev-^^eTat pvaByjvat, dKKa tov KaTeyovTog QavdTov to awfxa '^ta TYjg

dfxapTtag.

Eethpianot kai Oeoacpot. Sewp-^aag tw vw tov ^ta rov 20

awfxaTog KaTO, T^g ^pvyvjg ytvofxevov TtoKefxov, Kai Qta tov " tov

dvBpwitov al^y^^fxaKwTt^Ofxevov, KaTacpvyvjv awTYjpiag ^riTel, Kat tov

pvofxevov TteptfBKeiteTai, tva avTO to awfxa tov BavaTOv etg awfxa

^w-^g fxeTaitof^aYi. eha wg evpeBevTog tou pvofxevov, Kat etotfxov

ovTog Ttpog tyjv ydptv TVjg awTYipiag, tyjv itpeTtovaav evyaptaTtav 25

dvaitefXTtet tw 0ec5 tta 'l^fxou ^ptaTo^v, ^t ov avTW Kat to pvaB'^-

vat TQv TtoKefxtov TtpoaeyeveTo. ov Keyei oe ditKwg, ovQe evyeTai

pvaBrjvai rov awfxaTog, dKKa tov KaTaaypvTog to awfxa BavaTOv,

'^td Tvjg dfxapTtag tov Bavd^ov. BeKei ydp to awfxa avTov ^WYjg

eivai awfxa, ov awfxa BavdTov, ovte awfxa dfxapTiag, 30

'OpirENOTS. 'Qf KaKi^wv T7JV dvBpwTtivYjV aaBevetav Trjv ttept-

eKKOvaav Kat iteptaitwaav tov Koytafxov, Kat itpoaKaKovfxevvjv eiti

TO. evavTia, Keyet ro, " raKaiTtwpog eyw dvBpwnog,^^ xat wg ^ta
 ^

118 ESHrHSIS EIS THN OPOS VII. 25.

eiriKovpias Qeiag pvaQeig rov aafxarogi ^'^ ovoixaaSdvrog aafxa-

TOf 6avdrov, ^ia rai TrpoeipvjfJiivai alriag eTrdyei ro, " ev^^apiara
" Tcc 0eco ^ia lyjaov Xpiarov."

25 "Apa yovv avros lyco, tco fieu vo\ SovXevco vofico Oeov,
Trj de aapKL, vojxco afiapTiay. S

Ktpiaaot. 'MaKpog /xev avrix eKTreTroivjrai Xoyog, (Saaavi^ovrt

XeTTTWf CKaara rSiv ev rjfJAVy Kai rvfq TrXeove^iag rovg rpoirovg, ovg

virofxeveiv eQog rrjv dvQpairov ^idvoiav, dvre^dyovrog avrjj rov

KaKOv. ^ua^^^^vpi^ero §e wg daydKKei /xev ea^ ore rm eTrieiKe-

arepwv 6 vovg, ro7g t^^' aapKOg irdBeai rvpavvovfxevog^. dXvei oe 10

atpohpa, Ka\ daOevav alayyverai. roye fxvjv aTro(f>opriaaa6ai rvjv

d^ovkvjrov dfJiapriav, ovtafj.o6ev ej^e/, ^e/vwf KarefXTrtTrrovavjg rvfg

ijoov^g. ravryjroi Kat aaoevet irpog avrtaraatv, ovoev ro trapa-

Trav ^tdye rov vofLov irpog rovro eirtKovpovfxevog. dXvjGevei ^y; ovv

Qeaneatog IlavAof, ei r<a fxev vo)' ^oyAei;e<v tw ©ew tiia^^Qjpt- 15

aatro vofJ.(a, r^ff te aapKt vofJiw dfj.apriag. Kat rovro oifJ.at eartv

oirep e(f)y)'
" to yap QeKeiv irapdKetrat fxot, ro ^e Karepyd^eaQat
" TO AfaXov, oy." irdXat fj.ev ovv, cog ecpyjv, evvjrrfpyev v]fj.7v roye

vjKov elg vovv kou t>jv ev avrw QeXrjaiv, ro ekeaQat rx 6eiw Oov-
Aeve/v vofxoo. Kare^td^ero ^e irpog dfj.aprtav vj aap^, ro otKeiov 20

(oairep dvrtardaa 6eKYifj.a. •i]v ovv apa KardKpifxa ro7g e6eXovai

fxev d-TroTrepaivetv ro dya6ov, ov ft.vjv eri Kat 'tvvafj.evotg ota ro

rvpavve7a6at To7g 7rd6eaiv. «AA ev Xpiar^ Treiravrat ro KocraKpt-

vov, rovreariv v} rav aapKtKav KtVYjfj.drm irXeove^ta.

rENNAAioT. 'Airo^^ovg rS) evepyery] rrjv KaQ-^Kovaav evcpvifj.iav, 2

eyerai rov irpoKetfi.evov' eya rotvvv avrog &eov re ^ovXog, Kat

dfA.aprtag elfxt, Kai fxe '^ta rov '7ra6v]rov r^g aapKog v] dfj.apria

fxepi^erat Trpog 0eov. viro^ei^ag Se Toiv vtto vofJ.ov ro irpog ^tKatco-

atv eXXtTreg, e7rt(f>epet ro TYjg '^dptrog reXeiov, Kat (pvjaiv, " oy^ev

" dpa KardKptfJ.a vvv ro7g h Xptar^ Injo-oy,'' ^at rd e^^?. aAA 3"^

i^oii ydp vvv v] '^td X.ptarov X"-?^^^ ^Wh ''"^^ KaraKpiaeccg ravrv]g

vjfj.dg ^\ev6epooa(' rrpog ydp dtraQYi Kat dQdvarov ^cuvjv ^id rvjg rov

'
Cod. rpa.vyovfA(voi sed in marg. feran yp. rvpavvoviJifVO(.
 VIII. 2. P12MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 119

%v€V[MajQi ^apeat; fji.€6taTd{X€Voty kou oXoi itvevfjiaTtKot ot oAaov

yivofxevotf tvj(; re dfxapTias dnaXkaTTOfxeOaf Kat tov 6avdT0v tov

^i avT^v.
AiOAOPOT. TlapafJi.evet eXeyy^av tov iraXatov avBpcoiTov ty,v

Ttpoi eavTOv eKTioXefj.oo(Jtv, ovk eipYjVevovTOi Tipog tyjv ^vyy^v toi) 5

<7C0jaaT0$-. TavTa ^f ^teXey^^et, \va tyj<; tow 2a)T^^o$- eiriOvjfJ.iai

€Tittei^Yj To, KaTop6a>fJiaTa, Kat tvjv yevofi.evi^v evcoatu t€ Kat etpYjVYjv

tpv/y^i Ka) (jafxaTog '^ta Tyjg tov XovTpov itaktyyevecnag. <jvv/)'

yayev ovv o c/5ovA€to, Ka) vjk6ev €(p' o KaTeaKeva^ev, eiTTWv, " ov^ev

" dpa KaTdKpifxa vvv TOig ev \piaT^ 'Ivjaovi^ aTroQet^as yap OTt lo

0/ vno vofxov ovT€^, aT€ Viri Kora adpKa ^«vref, xjtiq afnapTiav €iat

Kai KaTdKptfjia, enYjyayev, OTt ol vttq ILptaTOv ovTeg, ovk etaiv wto

KaTdKpiff.a, eirei^vj
f/.^
KaTa aapKa TiepfnaTovaiv,
©EOAaPOT. T^ jaev yap y^vyri, </)>jo-/v, aipovfiat to. OoKOVVTa

T» vo/xco Toil 6eov, viro ^e tyjs 5v>jT0T>jT0f eiri t^v dfxapTtav 15

Ka6eXKQfj.at. dkk' dirv]KAdyfiL€6a tovtccv dirdvTccv, Kat Ttfxwpiaq

drrdavji KaTeaTYifjLev eKTOg, 01 ^ia tvj^ eirt tov \piaT0v TrtaTewi

e^(i) yevofnevot tvj^ 6vY,T0TYiT0i Kat tov AcaT avTVjv ^yjV. toT^ yap
6vv]To7s Kat Tvjv eiri to yeHpov poirviv ^eyofievoti, avayKa7o$ vof*.os,

aTreipym tqv yetpovog. <x6avdTQis Se Kat aTpeirTois yeyovoai, TTe-2o

ptTTQs e^ dvdyKYjq Ka^eaTvjKev.

^ 'O yap vofios tov UueviJiaTOf ttJs ^(orJ9 ev X/)toT«

*lrjaov.

Ktpiaaot. ^ AvayKa7ov Se otf^.at irpos aKpi^-^ ^iaad(f)V]atv twv

tv TOVTOtg evvotwv, eKeTvo eiireTv. ccairep ydp dfxapTiag Kai Bava- 25
Tov vofxov TO aapKtKOv ovofxd^et <f>povv]ft.oi, irpos Ttdv ei^^oi (pavXo-

TVjTos diro(f)epov v]fj.ds, ovto) Kai vo/aov ITIvey/AaTOf ^«^f to 6eXv]fKa

TO irvevfi.aTtKov' TOVTeaTi ty]V eis ye to dya6ov tv]s ^iavoias

ioTToyv. aAX **
fiev aireipQrv elg t>jv adpKa, eK TV]g aapKOq 6epia€i
** ^e aTreipav e/V to TlvevfJLa, Ik tov Ilvev/itaTos' deptaei
(p6opav, 30
" ^(tiY,v atctivtov.^ QVKOvv *'
fxev vofnof Tov YlvevfJiMTOS TYis ^a;>5f,"

TovTeart tq 6eXvjfxa tov vov to airo^pepov eig ^»>jv, y]v /xev

ev vjfxiv Kat irdXai' e^ovXevofnev ydp Ta? voi, vofx.(f) Qeov' aXX

rjppaaTvjaev, wf e0>jv, to d^paveg e*V avT/o-Tacriv, Kat TaTs r^f

120 EHHFHSTS E12 THN OPOS VIII. 2.

aapKOi liriGvfxiai^ yjTTtt)fi.€voi KaTfKpmTo tco voit.w, liieiVfi Oe to

voae^v ^ a7ro/3aAwv, eppaxxBif} ^ia \pi(7Tov, KaTeacfypayicixeOa yap

^/ avTov T» 'Ayix YlvevfJiaTt, Kot tv]v e| vipovi ^vvafxiv r]ft.({)i'

e<TfjL€6a. TavTYjToi Kai ke\vTpu>fxt6a' Kai v7Te^evyvvfi.t6a fxev ovKeTi

Tw KaKw, KeKXyjfj.e6a Ve, wf ffj^yjv, elg eXev6epov a^icofA.a. 5

OvKovv " vofios Tov YlvevfiaTOi Tyjg ^diyjs" TovTecrTiv to 6e\y]'-

fjia TOv vov TO vevevKOg elg aya6ovpyiav, Kat etg ^coyjv aTro(f)epov,

OTe Trjv tta l^pi(7T0v 7renkovTY/Ke yapiv, Kat TVjg ap^^aiag aa-devetag

aiTYiWaKTatf Tore roiv e| afj.apTiag aXoy^aag KaKwv, Kai tov t^(

(xapKog KaTevfj.eye6Yiaag vofi.QVf YjXevdepvcre fj.e (pi^crt. Kat ovk io

avTog TTOV itavTwv tyjv eXev6epiav ^t^^ovg' yeyovwg oe fj.akkov Yjfuv

€kev6epiag '/rpo^evog TYjg '^ta "KptaTov. loaTtep Ve Tovg vtto vofxov

ovTag Tov TYjg afiapTiag, iiaaa 7rS>g avdyKY] Kat Tolg tov 6avaTov

KaTa^eaf>.€ia6at ^poyotg, ovtw Tovg e^cc yeyovoTag avTYjg ekevde-

pctifjievovg Te ^ia 'KptaTov, ^ei iidktv e^o) Te eivat 6avdTov, Kat i^

dfj.eivovg opaa6ai (f)6opag, Kat ^yjv ev dytaafi.w.

AioAOPOT. Noft.ov Tov Ilv€Vf*.aTog etTtev, dvTi^taaTekkccv irpog

Tov vofj.ov xov ypdfnfAaTogj dvTt tov vj itapa X.ptaTov xotpig yj

^wo^oiog.

©EOAflPOT. T'^ Toy nveyjM.aTO^ fxeTovata, tyjv avdaTaatv yi- 20

vea6at ' ATTOaTokog (f^Yjat.
" aiteipeTat ya/J," (f>f}<^i,
" awfxa
*'
\pvxiKOv, eyetpeTat aZf/M 7rvevft.aTtK0v" <og dv avTov tot€ Kpa-
TovvTog YjfJidg ev d(f)6apaia, Te Kat «TeAeuTOTijT/. Tlvevfjia ovv

avTO ^cti^g KakeT, wg av xYjg d6avdTov ^a>Yjg •napeKxtKOVy Yjg totc

r€v^ofM€6a. to Toivvv Y]vevfj.d (f)Y]ai, to eir ekTii^i t^$- d6avaaiag 25

"^fiiv he^ofievoVf ov tvjv dnokavaiv y] eiit tov X.piaTOV ictaTtg irape-

ayY]K^i> ^/"'"'j dTc^kka^e fj.e tov Te 6avdT0v Kai T^jg dfj.apTtag.

^ojXov te OTt dito Twv ft.ekkdvTWV Ttotenai r^v dno^et^iv tSov tia

\ptaTov napeaxi^evTcov Yifj-h, OTe ent twv iTpayfj.dTCOv tyjv eK^a-

atv kyjxpeTat. enet Kai yj toS 6avdT0v ekevdepia totc Y]fiiv irpoa- ^o
y€VY]aerat, ovk avtaTafj.evotg fJ.ovov, dkkd [7«/?] Kat a6avdTOV ^caYjg

d^iovfuevotg. TOTe te Kat TYjg dfiapTiag dTrakkaTTOfj.eOa. totc

^ Cod. foatt.
 VIII. 3- PXIMAIOTS Eni2TOAHN. 121

aTpeTTToi yeyovoTfg tyj tov IJvev/AaTOf yapiTi, afJiapTetv ovk eiri-

oeyoixeQa. KaTo. ydp toi tov TiapovTa Piov, irpohrikov wg 6vv]T0t t€

eafxev, Kai viio tijv Tvjg afxapTiai 6«oj^A>j(r*v KeifJLe&a.

KE«i>. IB.

Ilepi aTroSoo-efflr Ta)t> (pvcriKav iTa6i]fxdTtov, 8ia Trjs Trpo? ro rivfufia (TVfi- C

(fxovlas.

3 To yap aSvvarov tov vofiov eV a> ^crOevet 8ia rrjs^

aapKos.
Ktpiaaot. A^idya<7To<: p.(v o ff.vaTayci}yog Kai lcx^xyog ayav
eig 6ecoptag. ihtaTi^g ^e elvai cpvjai to? Ao-yoo* TavTVjToi cpafJiev lo

epv6piwvTe<; ov^ev^ oti t':^ (Tvvd^^Kyj twv TrpoKetfievav Ae^ewv, Xetiret

Tt (3pa-)(v TTpog evTeXrf ^iaad(pvjcrtv. e^et yap eiTrelv, to yap d^vva-

Tov
>
TteTtavTat.
Tov vofnov ev
T
co vjadevet

etTa irpoavneveyKeiv tov itpayfi.aTog

^ia
~~/ T^g (japKOg, XeXvTat
\>/^
tvjv aitoboaiVy
Tvy(ov,

kui
v)

Tov \eXva6ai avvdxl/ai tov Tpoirov, iipoaTt6evTa irdktv, " oydpiS

*'
&eog Tov eavTov T/ov Trefnpag ev 6fji.ot<tifJiaTi aapKOg dfxapTtag,
*'
Kat irepi dfiiapTtaif KaTVjpyvjKe tvjv dfxapTtav ev tvj aapKt^^ Kat
Ta TOvTOti e(f)e^^g ^e^ooKe TVjq tZv Xe^eav avv6v]KVjg, KaTaye tov
evovTu aKt/nov avTw. (p€pe KaTa6pvja(t}fxev TVjg '^td ILptaTov 6epa-
f \ /
Tieiag tov Tponov. 20
IleTrauTai he onag to d^vvaTov tqv vofnov ; Kat irotov av oXwg
TO aovvaTov vooIto tov voft.ov ; XeirTOfiv^ei ydp Xiav 6 6ei^yopog ev

TOVToig. dirote^^eTat toivvv ag acfyeXetv el^OTag tov tc tov Seov

vofjiov, (t)Vifi.i Vfj Tov ev ypdfi.fj.aat, Kai tov ye tov Y\vevft.aTog, Ka6

ov ea-^^vjKatxev to 6eXetv to aya6oV et fuv] TrapaKeoiTo tv/ov to 25

Ovvaa6ai ^pdv avTo. e(f)Vj ydp, OTt " to ydp 6eXetv irapdKetTai
•'
TO ^e KaTepyd^ea6at tq KaXov ov." irXeoveKTovai^g hvjXov
'/..
fj.01,
t
OTi T>7f afnapTtag, Kat tov TVjg
/ \-.~ \/
aapKog vofxov KaTaaT pe(f>ovTOg
/, >
eig

Ta otKeta Kai ovk e/covTa tov vovv. KaTa tov avTOV oifkat Toviovt

Tpoirov vooiT dv eiKOToog to d^vvaTov tov vofxov, TouTe ev ypdfJi-S^

fxaai Kat Qia M«3"ecof, Ka6dnep 'e(pvjv dpTtag. Kai ft.evToi tov

efJ.(f)vTov Kat ev yjfJiiv, Ka& ov " Kai Ta e6vvj Kat toi tov ypaitTOV
" ovK eyjjvra vofnov, (f)vaet iroiovvTa tov vofxov (f)aiv(Taif Kat vofJiog

R
laS EHHrHSIS ET2 THN OPOS VIII. 3.

" elatv eavToTi, ev^eiKvvvTai yap to epyov tov vofjiov ypanTOv ev Tatg
" Kaphiaig avToiv, Ka6a ykypaTtTaiT nohv ^e to ev ajxcpoiv a^vva-

Tcv, (3a<ravi(Tai Kaipog.

'O fxev yap ev ypafj.[xaai vofxog ti^aa-KaXog "^v evKoa-uiiag Kai

Twv apiaTuv eiavjyyjT-^g' de^^iKaictiKe ^e TravTeXag ovteva. oye fxyjv 5

efX(f)VTOi Te Kat ev y}}Mv, bv Kai ovofxa^ei tov HvevixaTog, aiTove-

vevKe /xev elg to ayaSov, vjTTaTai ^e Xiav tov Trpog Ta alay^iio

KakovvTog vofxov. ovkovv to a^vvaTov, TOVTecTTi to aiBevovv, ene "

Tov ev ypa.fjifj.aa IV, eiVe tov efxtpvTov vofxov, ireTravTai dia \pi-

aTov. veveKpitifxev)^g yap Tponov Tiva T^i aapKog, Kat oiov dv^pyj- lo

fxevvjf T^g (V rjfxh r^ovrjg, KaT ovoeva Tpoitov tov WvevfxaTog,

yjToi Tov voog daBevfjaei vofxog' veveKpWTai Se T<va Tpoitov yj ev

yjfxiv dfxapTia, (pepe Xeyvfxev ag evi.

O yap Tov Seov Aoyog, ev ev^oKta tov Qeov Kat YloTpog ev

OfxoKCfxaTi yeyove aapKog dfxapTiag, tva KaTaKpivrj t>;v dfxapTiavi^

ev aapKt, yeyove yap avBpco-nog KaSeig eavTov eig Kevcnatv. Kai

Ofxoei^eg fiev oti Kai 6fxo<pveg T^rf yjfxeTepoig aiOfxaai to avTov,

Ttxg dv evooidaeie Ttg ', ttAvjv t» /xev roiv dXkav dirdvTwv aoofxaTa
adpKeg av keyoiVTo Tyjg dfxapTiag' tid Te to TiepvKevai voaeiv

Twv eKTOTiccv yj^QvSov T>;v yeveaiv. to Se ye aoofxa XptaTov ^atyj 20

Ttg [7«/?] ov/^ afxapTtag eivat adpKa ; fxyj yevoiTo. Ofxotxfxa te

fxdXXou aapKog afxapTtag' TovTeaTi irpoaeotKog fxev Toig yjfxeTe-

potg adofxaatv, ov fxyjv eTt Kat voaeiv et^^og aapKtKyju aKaOapatav.

aytog yap ck fxyjTpag 6eiog eKeivog veoog, Kat oaov fxev yjKev eig

evvotag Te Kat Xoyovg Tovg ev Ty (pvaet, KaTOKv^aeiev av ov^e^g 25

eKeivo efTreiv, (vg eiietTiep vjv aap^, eaj^ev dv ev eavTyj to 'ittov re

Kai efx(pvTov Ktvyjfxa. eVei^vj Se itdaav t»;v KTiatv dytd^wv
Aoyog KaTWKyjaev ev avT-^, KaTaKeKptTat Trjg dfxaprtag ^ "^vvafxtg,

iva Kat eig yjft.dg dta(3aivrj to KaTopddofxevov. fxeTea^/yjKafxev ydp

avTov TtvevfxaTtKag tc Kat acofxaTtKag. OTav yap Kat yjfi.iv evau-30
A/^€Ta/ 'KptaTog, ^td tov Ay lov YlvevuiaTog, Kai ^td T^g fxvaTt-

KYjg evXoytag, tot€ Sv? ttdvTwg Kat ev yjfxiv 6 TVjg dfxapTtag KUTa-
KpiveTai vofxog.

^ Cod. hic et infra elV t6.

VIII. 3- PX2MA10T2 EniSTOAHN. 1«3

AXrjOf^ Qvv OTi TO a^vvaTov tov vofxov, ev a i^adevei oia tvji;

aapKOif 'TreiravTai ^ta 'Kpi<TTOv, KaTaKpivavTog re Kat KaTrjyopvj-

KOTo<i TVjV afxapTiav ev T17 capKi, tva to otKatatxa tov vofxov

iry.vjpaOrj ev Vj[x7v. neTr KYjpaTat yap to ^tKaiWfxa tov vo[/.ov,

TovT€(TTtv Yj ^vvafxi^ tZv TeSeaTTtafxevMV ^ta tov vofKOv' yjyovv to 5

6f\vjua TO ^keitov eiq aptTrjv' tov ev oy/xoiv ovTOi vofxov Kar of^eva
Tponov, a>i e<f)vjv, acrOevovvTOt; eaTi ^ta tov TvpavveiaSat Tai^

efxc^vTotg vjtovali. TCtTtX-^putTai TOtvvv ev vjfAiv to hiKaiwij.a tov

vofkov Tolq ff.^ KaTa crdpKa nepnraTovcri' ^jjv oe f^akXov eOeXovai

TtvevfLaTtKai. 10

rENNAAioT. "^Hv vofnos, (jyi^ci, ttKat(o<7iv vnayopfvwv vjTOvet

^ia T^? vjfieTepai aapKOg ev vjfxh KaTopBxaai, TavTVj^ ev KpiaT'2

Tidpecyev vjff.iv Seo<;. tov yap Ttov irefji^^ag tov eavTOv, adpKa
Tvjv avTVjv ^ft.iv eyf^ovTa, 7ra6v}T^v t€ Kai dfxapTeiv eiri^eypft.evvjv'

Off.oi(i)fLa yap aapKO^ dfkapTiag, Tviv evte^^^ofKevviv afxapT^aat adpKa 15

**
(f>i^atv' wi Kat to ev of/.otafjLaTi avSpwirov yevofx^vog avTt tov yevo-

fxevog dvSpavog. TavTVjv ovv eyovTa tvjv aapKa (pvjatv, Seog rov
eavTov Ttov nefi.y\^ag itept afxapTtag, TOVTeanv e(f> OTe TVfv afxap-

Ttav KaraywviaaaOat, KareKpive TVfv afxapTiav ev Tvj aapKt, KaTe-

hiKaaev avTVjV ev avTvj. dveiracpov avTVjv Kai dvdkwTov vravTeXSig 20

Kat akkwi.
tiacpvXd^ag
TVjv
/»~
\cafLapTiav
aiiTVjv.

ev tvj
Vj

aapKi.
/>\~»avTi
OTt irepi

tov, avafxapTVjTOv
afxapTiag KareKpive
/ -,

TVjg aapKOg
\

ovavjg avTW, Kat ov')^^ VTroKetft.evvjg otd tovto 6avdTa' KareKpive

fxev irepi dft.apTtag tv)v aft.aprtav Seog ev avTVf, wg ovk ev htKi^

Tctf davdrw tvjv tou K^vpiov adpKa TrepiPaXovaav. tid ^e rvjg eK 2^

veKpwv avaardaewq, e^etvvjv fi.eTej3a\f irpog aird^eiav. Kat ovtw

Xoiirov vj Tov vofxov ^tKaiwatg ev vjft.iv KaropSovTat, ^id vriaTewg

vjfxwv evovft.evwv avrw, Kai irvevft.aTtKwv avri aapKiKwv yivoft.evwv.

TotovTOv eaTi Kat to ev ^ AvTto^/eta TVjg Yltai^tag elpvffxevov aiiTW,

OTi " «Tro TravTwv wv ovk y]Bvv^6i^Te ev tw vo/xod Mwaewg htKaiw- 30

av}vai, ev tovtw Kat iriarevwv OiKatovTat.

AioAflPOT. " To ydp d^vvarov tow vOjU.oy ev w vfaSevet ^ta tiJj

*'
aapKog." o^j^ vo'jaof (pi^atv, aovvaTa Trpoaeraaaev, aAX' vf

^ Leg. credo eT«.

K 2
124 EHHrH2I2 EI2 THN HPOS VIII. 3.

(jap^ ovK rjhvvaro 'nXYjpovv rrjv -xov vojxov 'TroXireiav^ ^ia rov efxno-

^i^ovra TcovYipov, bv "tia TYjg kavrov aapKog KareKpive ^piarog.

" Seog, (prjai, rov eavrov Tlov Trefxxpag ev 6[ji.omfJiari a^apKog
" afiapriag." orav jxev a7rol3ke\pvi irpog rrjv tov Kvp/ou adpKa

ATToaroXog, dkfjBwg ovcrav adpKa, e^ div Kai eyewi^dy} Kat averpd<f)y) S

Kai eTToXirevaaro tco (3too, (f>avepac rvjv adpKa Ttpoaayopevet, (og

'* aapKt' Kat

Kai evravQa eirdyet KareKpive rvjv afxaprtav ev ryj

Ttpog TtfJLoQeov ypdtpooVf " Qeog ecpavepooBrj ev aapKi'" orav ^e airo-

l3Xexpr) Ttpog ro rvig aapKog dvafidprvjrov Kat Kadapov Kat oaiov,

6fi.ot(i}fxa avro aapKOg ovofxd^et. ov^ ort Kora rriv (pvatv ^iiyA-io

AaTTCV, dXX ort ofxotov ^v ryj aapKtKy] afxaprta. eTrefxxpev ovv,

^yjatv, Qeog rov Tiov avrov, ovk ev ofxoiwfxart dyyeXov yj rivog

rotavTVjg ^vvdfxewg, dXX ev ofnotcofxart aapKog, tva aapKOg yjrryj-

Oetayjg €Tri rov A^afx, aap^ Karaymiayjrat rov Tiovyjpov eirt tov

J^vptov. dTreardXy] M, (pviatv, 6 "Kvptog hta rvjv eTttKparyjaaaav 15

Twv dvdpccTTCov dfxapTtav. rovro ydp ro " nepi dfxaprtag," avrt

Tov ^td ryjv dfxapriav.

YiapeXKei ^e ro " Kai" iva ro ^tKaKOfxa rov vofxov TTXyjpoidyi,

(pyjaiv ev yjfxh. oiov e^ovXero f/L,ev •nXyjpioaai 'htKatwfxa 6 vofxog,

yjaBevet ^e ^id ro avyywpyjaat avrov avroig rpvcpdv. rt ovv avve-20

Xoopei. ort ovK av napeteySyj, ei fxyj avyKare/Satvev avrav ryj

daOeveia. rt ovv wcpeXrjae avyKara(3ag, et fny] e^tKaiwaev ; ot<

TOv vjvv etg dvatabrja lav dyvotag eKTceaovra aveKaXeaaro. " to<V
" ft.ri Kard adpKa Tteptitarovat" (prjatv, avrt rov Kard rov vofxov.

eiye ydp 6 vofxog napari^prjaeig aapKt^dg' aapKiKOv ^e rjv Kai ro 25

avyyjapriaat Tpv(pdv.

©EOAapoT. O fxev ovv vofxog, ei Kat rvjv ^vyrjv ui(peXe7, <pvj-

atv, dXXd rvf KaropBaaet r^g dpervjg drovav e(patvero' dvrfnpar-

rovavjg avrw r^g BvYiTOrvjTog ; Kat ttoXXvjv rvjg afxaprtag rrjv

evoyX-^atv rjfi.h epya^oft.evr]g. 6 ^e ye Tiog rov Qeov^ ev Tavrvj ^o

yeyovcog rvj (pvaei r^ 6vy]Tvj, Kat afxapriatg VTroKeifxevvj, ovy^ erepov

eveKev, aXX^ v] ware d(peXeh avrvjg rvjv afnaprtav, dveiXe ro eveivat

OOKOvv avrr] Kvpog rvjg df/Laprtag. d(peXwv fxev avrvjg tv]V 6vr]T0-

1 Cod. oin. Seov.

 VIII. 5- PX2MAIOT2 Eni2T0AHN. 125

T»jTa, avvaveXm oe avTyj Kai T^f afxapriaq rriv IvoyXyiaiv. do^

Xonrov rov vofxov rov o-kottov Ka) ro ^ovXvjfJia ev yjimv irXrjpova6at,

Tois anfjKXayixevoig fxev TVjg BwjrorYirog, ev aOavaaia Se KaQe-

craaiv. o yap ovk layyae Tcoielv ev Yjfxiv 6 voixog, ore ert Qvyjrol
rvjv (f>vaiv wfxev, Kairotye TiXeiara itepi rov fxvj ^eiv afxaordveiv 5

OiaXeyofxevog, rovro ^fxh ev ryj r^fjg 6vvjroTr]rog dcpaipeaei •nooa-

eyeveTo. ovOe fniav '" evoyXyjatv afxapriag ovvafxevoig vnofxevetv,

efieto av a-na^ r^v <pvaiv d^dvarot yevofxe6a.

OptrENOTS. MaAAov ro a^vvarov tov vofxov rov rrjg dfxap-

riag Kat rov 6avdrov woe Xeyet. aairep yap vj dpeTYf tVta. <pvaet 10

tayvpa, ovrct) Kat -^ KaKta Kai ra dit avrrjg da6evYj Kat d^vvara.

Kparel yap ov rav tayypZv, dXXa rwv eKXvrm' ov ^ia r^v i^tav
tayyv, aXXa Ota rvjv eKetvm d^pdveiav. T&y roiovrov vofxov r) <f>vai(

aOvvarog eart. ^to Kat evYfpyet ev rri da6evei aapKt. ov rpoirov

KareKptvev Qeog, irefxxi/ag rov eavrov Tiov, ovk ev aapKt dfxap- 15

rtag rotavrrjg, j] 6 ^ovXevav Kard vofxov dfxapriag ^ovXevet, dXX'
ev OfxotfDfxart rotavrrjg aapKog. dtd ^e rovro ovk rjv dfxapria
rj aapq rov Ttov rov Qeov, dXX Ofxot(i)fxa. eTreiitep ovk rjv eK
anepfxaTog avOpog Kai yvvaiKog vnvw avvtXdovarjg. ovkovv 6 Seog
KareOiKaae rr^v dfxapriav yevofxevrjv KaO' vTrepjSoXrjv dfxaprcoXov' 20
Kat Oia TYjg aapKOg eitX-^pa^rj ro rov 6eiov vofxov ^tKaiafxa ev rjfxh,

ore fxri Kara aapKa Tiepinarovfxev. ev rj aapKi evepyei ro d^vvarov

rov vofxov Kat aadeveg, eartv rj KaKta. dXX^ enofxevoi Qeoo Kard
ro Wvevfxa avrov, TTpdrrofxev Tidvra, elg eavrovg Trapa^eyofxevot
rov Tiov Tov Qeov. 25
5 01 de Kara aapKa ovres tol r^? crapKos (j^povovaLv.
Ktpiaaot. ©avaTov jOiev elvat <prjat ro rrjg aapKOg <f>povr,fxa,

Kat fxaXa op6wg. ro Oe ye rov Ylvevfxarog ^or^v Kat elprjvfjv.

6avdrov fxev ydp dXrj6wg rj <f)tXoaapKia irpo^evog' ^ayjg ^e r^g

etg atma Kat rm dvw6ev dya6m ro ^taPtovv eXea6at nvevfxa- 30
TtKag.

rENNAAioT. Q^arrep, <f>rjat, rovg ovrag <p6apTovg, Kat ro

(ppovrifxa <p6aprov eyeiv avdyKrj, ovro) Kai roi/i ovrag d(p6dpTovg *

™ Cod. /*/«.
126 EHHraSIS EI2 THN nP02 VIII. 5-

acjidapTov eiKOi ecniv ej^e/v Kai to (ppov^fxa. eKaTepoov dvdXoyov

TVjg oiKeiag (pvaeoog twv koyior^ov KeKTVjfJievctiv. " to yap <ppovYjixd,"

(pfjoi, " T^j- (xapKog, davaTOf." BdvaTov TovTe(TTi Ttpo^evovv, Kai

**
npos KoXa(Xiv Trapo^wov Qeov. to ^e (f)povi^fxa tov YlvevfJiaTog ^(o")^

" Kai etp-^vvj'" TOVTecTTiv aOavaaiav tcapovfxevov Kai (pikiav ti^v 5

Tipog Qeov.

©EOAfiPOT. ATrevTeDflev Xontov "hia iiXeiovm keyei, oti Tolq

fxev dvvjToTi TO dft.apTdveiv eiieTai TrdvTcog. dBdvaioi 8e yeyovoTeg,

aTtYiXXdyfKe^a tovtov. co(tt€ KaTa TrapaBeaiv (pavy^vat Ta Kara

\ptaTOV TrXeiaTOV virepey^ovTa tov vofxov, entep eKehog /xev a(pe- i o
AeTv TCv BdvaTOV ovk '^'^vvaTO, Kai dvdyKfi ndaa yjv KpaTeh ev

vjfiAV TY}v dfiapTiav' Kai fivpidKig e^rat^eveTO vj ^^vyvj to beov. o

^e ye 'KpiaTOg tov tc GdvaTov d(peT\e, Kai t^v evovaav vjfxTv TVjg

dfxapTiag evoj^ATjcr/v avvaveTXe tw BavdTco. ^p^aTO fxev ovv dito

Tov " tiKaidiBevTeg ovv eK TriaTecog, etpvjvviv eyofxev npog tov Qeov 15
*'
^ta TOv Kvptov vjfiicv \vjaov ^iptaTOv" t«v ^ia rov X.piaTov
TrapaayeBevTcev vjfxTv e^vjyeTaSat to fi.eye9og avv TrokXoTg eTepotq,

TiapaQeaet T^f irpog tov vGfxov '^eT^ag avTwv tyjv virepo'^vjv.

^^iTiethvi ^e etg tyjv twv dvaKVTiTovrcov ^viTVjft.dTcov eTpditYi Xvatv,

ditoXoyviadfxevog vrtep avTcov wg ToTg itpoKeifKevoig M^etKTai v^fxTv 20

aa<peaTepov, Kat "^vj Kai vttep tov dfj.apTiag tioivjtikov Xeyeiv tov

vofxoV e^e<^e fj.ev avTov to ')(j)'^atfi.QV dvayKaicoi. Kat tovto Sc cv

ToTg dpTtcog epfxvjvevQeTai aacpeaTepov le^v]KcoKaf/.ev. •Tidkiv ^e

KaTa TiapaBeaiv tov vofxov Xeycov twv ^ta tov ^piaTov to fxeyeBog,

CTit Tov Tcov 'JipcoTcov ^'jjTij/xaTcyv dvaTpeyet XoyoV Kai to ^eiKvvvat 25

a>g fJLeytaTcov vjfj.Tv ayaBcov X.ptaTog eyeveTo itpo^evog. oviiep

evcKev KavTavBa ^ovXeTat ttd tioXXcov tetKvvvai, oti tyi fj.ev Bvvjto-

TVjTi TO dfxapTdvetv eTteTai. dBdvarot ^e yeyovoTeg, ditvjXXdyfLeSa

TOVTOV. ^to (pYiatv, " 01 yap Kara adpKa ovteg, Ta TVjg aapKog
*'
(ppovovai" Kai Ta e^vjg. tovto Xeyei, oti 01 fxev BvvjTot tyjv (pv 3°
atv, avayKatcog TtXetaTviv tov afxapTavetv tv^v evo^^^^Xvjatv vnofxe-

vovai. t/ ydp av Kai (SovXevaaiTO dBdvaTov cpvatg Bv^tyj ; et oe

Kai Tig eaTtv ev Yjfj.Tv apeivj, ov TVjg aapKog eaTiv avTi^i, dXXa tov
(ppovfjfj.oTog t^s" ^vyyigt eiiei^av dvcoTepa yevi^Tat tcSv 'jiapovTcov.

01 fxevTot Tov Y\vevfJ.arog *;S>j fj.erea^/vjKoreg, Kpelrrova rovrcov^iS

 VIII. 7- PI2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 1«7

(^ovai TOv \oyiafxov, a6dvaToi yeyovoTCi tvjv (f>vatv, Kat iraaYji

TYji aiio Tm yjEipovm IvoykYia-iooi aTrvjKXayixevot. tovto yap Xeyft

TO etpyjvvjv. eTTet^Yj ev toi( avaTcpcis irapa loHi tvjv (f)v<xtv 6vv]Toii

TTcAe/xov tivai €<pv}f j^g dfJiapTtag avTtTrpaTTovavig tw jSovX-^fJuitTi

T-rjg rpv^fji^g. eip-^vYjV evTavBa Xeym to d^paipelaOat TTjg^ dfxapTta<; 5

TYfv evo-)(KYiatv.

7 AioTL TO (f)poi>7]fxa Trjs' aapKOS ^X^P^ ^'-^ Oeou.

rENNAAioT. A.ix-qyavov ydp, (prjatf Tor? tov Seov BekYjft.aa t,

toig ^ta Tov vofxov yvcopti^ofJLevotg yjfju^v, to BeXrjfxa tyj^ aapKog

TtoTe avveXOeiv Kat (piXtav da7rdaaa6at. o fj.ev yap airdSetav lo
eirayyeXXerat, yj ^e eaTt Tra^YjTYj. ov toivvv ov^e Tovg dveyofJ.evovg

Tco 'ppovYjfxaTt TYjg aapKog, Kat fj.eTe^yovTag TYjg (pvaeag TavTYig^

oiov T€ dpeaat Seov. eirt ToaovTov yap avTov QteaTYjKaatv, e(p

oaov etat TavTYjg eyyvg' Kat etatv apeTYjg Troppco ToaovTov, oaov

6vYjTOTYjTog ° d6avaaiag. 15

OpirENOTS. 'A0' cov '^ttdaKei YlavKog, fj.av6dvofJ.ev Ttveg

etat KaTa aapKa' 01 to, T^f aapKog (ppovovvTeg. Kat Ttveg ot

KaTO. Wvevfxa' 01 to, tov Ilvev/AaTos' (ppovovvTeg. Ta oe (ppovY]-

fxaTa Tvjg aapKog eiai, Tiopveia, daekyeia, ei^aKoXaTpeia Kat Ta

Ofj.ota' OTtep avTO tovto 6dvaTog eaTt. Ta Se Toy YlvevfxaTog, 20

dyditYj, yapV, eip-^VYj, fj.aKpo6vfj.ia, Kat toc TOi^TOif aKo^^ov^a'

airep eaTt ^aYj. Kat yi^y} ev lYf ^cw^ e/a<v ot to<ovto/, Kai ev eipYjVYi

ev(ppaivovTat. aKoXov6ov ovv rovg fxev etg tyjv aapKa aTreipovTag,

6ept^eiv <p6opdv. TOff ^e Tlvevfi.aTt i^wvTac,, aTreipeiv etg to Ylvevfxa,

d(p ov eaTi 6eptaat ^cdtjv almtov. irpog Se TovTOif Kat ey6pot etat 25

ToD 0foy ol Tov <ppovYjfj,aTog TYjg aapKog. (ppovovat oe Ta TYjg

aaoKOg Kai oaot ^ovXovTai irXovTeh, ^ eTri6vfj.ovat oo^Yig' Kai 01

KaTa TO ypdfxfna ^avreg \ov^a7oi' Kai tyjv ev (pavepw ireptTOfXYjv

ev aapKt aaKOvvTeg ovTOt t» TYjg aapKog tov vofxov (ppovovatv-

01 "he KaTo. Ylvevfna, 01 ev KpvnTco 'lov^^aTot, 01 tyjv ev Kaptla Kai 30

irveufxaTt ireptTOfxYjv irotovvTeg, riTOt (ppovovat Ta tov Ilvei/|U.aTOs.

Ka/ ev fx\v Tw (ppovYjfxaTt TYjg aapKOg tov vofxov, 6avaT0v Ttg

evpYjaet Kai eydpav tyjv eig Seov. ev ^e too (ppovyjfxaTi tov vO|tAou

" Cod. T^i/. o I-*g- ^^^- SvtiroTr,;.

 128 EHHmSIS EI2 THN HPOS VIII. 9.

ToD YlvfvixaTog, ^coyjv Kai eip-^vvjv. 01 ^e ev t^ crapKi tqv vofxov

ovTeg, S(cJo apeoai ov OvvxvTai' d\X 01 (v tc2 HvevfxaTi tov vofjiov

ovT€g. afJicf)OT€poi yap eirayyfKXofj.eSa tov Maaecoi vofxov. aAA'

€K€7voi fi.€Vf KaTa (rdpKa, vifJL€7$ he KaTo, Ilv€Vf».a. dio CKetvoi aap-
KiKag rjyovvTai Tag (TtayyeKiai, aKoXovdwg tw aapKiKw vofxa' 5

yjft.eHg ^e TTveufxaTiKaif cv nd(jYj evXoyia "nvevfxaTiKyi h Tor? Ittov-

pavioii.

9 Y/jL€Lf 8' ovK icrfe ev (TapKi, aXK ev UvevfxaTi. uirep

YivevfJia 0eoi; o\k€l Iv vplv.

rENNAAIOT TOTTO KAI ©EOAflPHTOT. 'AAA' VfXelq ydp, (f^VJ- lO

aiVf €K SvYjTOTyjTog e<<r dQavamav fi€Taf3€Pi^KaT€' dvTt aapKiKwv

yeyevYjfxevot TrvevfxaTiKot. Kat avavTtppi^Tov toD "Koyov tovtov t>jv

aTioOetgtv ('^(Ciiv. efnep \.\v€vff.a yyeov, (pvjdtv, oiKet ev vft.iv.

TOT€ yap "npog t«5 t^j" vioQeatag yapi<jfxo.Ti Kat €T€pm eitt Qav-

fxaTovpyia yaptafxdTm ditikafBoVf tov Y\.v€VfxaTOi; avTOvg ^td 15

TovTWv Kat Ttepi Twv T€Oic a<pav(ov TTtuTovfxevov. OTt Totvvv, tpyio'1,

•npoi 'nvevfLaTiKVjv fxeTeaTyjae ^coyjv €K t^s" aapKiK^Sf rj tov rivei/-

ft.aT0i KaTOtKovaa ydpi^ vfxaq aTToypcavTiog OrjkoT.

AioAdJPOT. " 'Tft.€is ^e," (f)y}atv" ovk ecTTe ev aapKi, aXA' ev

" IIvefjaaTi'" avT< tov ovk eaTe ev aapKtKa7g eTtiBvfxiatg, akX ev 20

TtvevfxaTt ^Te, " e/Vep Ilvev^a Qeov oiKei ev vfxh." ^teyetpccv

avTovg elg to eypi^yopevai tov vovv, Kai fxyj vTtTtovaBat wg KaTcop-

BcaKOTag, KaTo. '^iaTayfxov e^yjveyKe tov Xoyov eiTtcbv, " etitep nveV|Ua
" 0eov olKelt €V vft.7v.'^ to ydp o(f)pvc!>aat avTOvq Kai (pvataaat,

a)i yj^yj eyovTaq Wvevfxa 6e&v, eTttfSXa^ei^ yjv, Kat t>?v ait ovTy\v %i^

^taKOipat iKavov.

Ei 8e TL9 Ilv€Vp.a \pLaTOV OVK €)(eL, OVTOS OVK eaTLv

avTOV.

rENNAAioT. " E/ Se Tff," ^>ja/, '*

Yivevfxa ^piaTov ovk eyet,

ovTog ovK eaTiv avTov. caaitep 01 eq AOafx tov Mafx etvat 30

XeyofxeBa, T^g (pvaecag avTco KoivcovYjaavTei, evcoaecog etvat XeyovTeg

Tov XpiCTCv, tia T^f Toi) evoq itvevft.aTog Kotvcoviag fxeTovatag ei

o Cod. (iit^Xa.^^<;.
 VIII. 12. PX2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 129

§e 'K.piaroi ev vfxiv, to [mv axfxoi veKpov oia afxapriavy to oe

Trvevfia ^u^ ^ia ^iKaioa^vvr/v. e< toivvv yvjopi^erai l^piaros (pi^aiv,

ev v{x7vf TO Toy n.v€vixaTOi avTov fxtre-^^fiv vfxag, ov rpoirov eaTi

TO aZfxa '^ia t»jv UfxapTiav aOavao-iag afxeroyov, ovtcc^ av BavaTOV

Tioppu} ^/a Trfv ^iKaiocrvvYjv to Trvevfxa. Ylvevfux. ^e to TtvevfxariKOv 5

awfxa Trpoaeinev' eK tov fxeBeKTiKov to fxeToyov KaXeaag, (i)g Kai

ev Toig KvayyeXiotif " to yeyevrjfxevov" (prj&iv, ** eK roi) 11^6^1«,«-

" Tog, rivev/xa."

11 Ei 5e To Ufevfia rov eyeipavros \piaToi> lijaovi/

oIk€l iv V/MU. ^°

rENNAAioT. 'AXXa fx^v ov^e ^e7 itepi tovtov, (prjai, ^iafx-

(fiia!3riTeh, oti Tovg rf^mfxevovg Xaovg yeveaSai tov WvevfxaTog.,

Kai TavTrj KeKoivcovrjKOTag \piaTcCf ey^ofxevov eaTi Koivav/jaai

avTa ^i avTO TovTo Kai T^g eK veKpav eig addvaTov ^oor^v ava-
araaeoig. ^5

©EOAflPOT. WpoeiTtoiv " Ilveyjtxa Xp/crTci/," TtaXiv (f)rjaif

'*
ro
" Ylvevfxa tov eyeipavrog 'KpiaTOv oiKei ev vfxivJ'^ enavayayav aito

Tov ILpiaTOv eiti tov YlaTepa' ovtev erepov rj aa(f>wg hi^^aaKwv oti

eK ToD Tiov Kai TO Ylvevfna ovk aWorpiov Tijg itarpiKrjg 6eoTrjTog

eari' Kai olg fLia rj evepyeia, TOVTOig TtavTcog Kai rj ovaia t» 20

VlaTpi avvafhog. aKoXovBxg fxevroi evoiK-^aavTog WvevfxaTog 'Ayiov

xat Tiyf afxapTiag veKpaOeiarjg, eiteaOai Tolg ayavi^ofxevoig ra

eitaBXa (prjaiv' av itpwTov Ka) fxeyiaTOV rjv vj eK veKpwv ava-

aTaaig.

12 "Apa ovv, a5eA0of, ocpeiXeTOj, eo-fjLev, ov Tjj crapia, tov2^

KaTa adpKa ^v.
Fennaaiot. ' Ayaviadfxevog ^ia ndvToov, Kai hei^ag ovk cti

itpoariKeiv avTovg tw A^a/x, TovTeaTi Tr} TtaQvjTrj Kai vito vofxov

^aJTj, dXX' eivai Xp«TTOv, rovTeari itvevfxaTiKovg Te Kai aKr,-

paTovg, avyKe(f)aXaiovfxevog Ta oia TtXeiovav ev ToTg efXTtpoaOev ^o

elprifxeva, vovOeaiav aa(f)ri re Kai avvrofxov eTti(f>epei Xeym, fxr} .

;)^i5va< Toi' XoiTtov Totg TVjg aapKog eavTovg TtdSeaiv eKOioovai.

^iaTi ; el ydp Kard adpKa ^Te, (priatf fxeXXere aTtoQvYjaKeiv. Trjg

ydp TOtavrrjg ^(oy^g, (f^rjai, (pGcpd tc TeAof eaTiv. el ^e iivevfxaTt

s
 130 EHHrHSIS EIS THN HPOS VIII. 14.

Tfff npa^it^ Tov (7a}[xaTog BavaTovTi, ^-^creadt. f/ fxeyToi^ ^»?^^»

KaTa T^v evovaav vf/.7v tov YlveviJ.aTOi Xo^-piv aTrov^a^oiTe ^^v,

avevepyyjTovg eavTOv^ Ttpog Tai ToiavTag tov aoofxaTos Trpd^eig

hia(f*vXdTTOVT€ff oiaeaOe t>jv dBavaalav.

14 "Oa-OL yap Tli/evfxaTL Geov ayovraL^ ovtol eio-lu vlols

Qeov.
rENNAAioT. Oi yap TlvevfAaTi ©eov /cvl^epvafxevoi, TouTcaTiv
01 nvevfi.aTiKoi Kai ov xpvy^iKoiy eavToTg <t>g dkvjBxi to eivai viot

Qeov l3epaiovaiv. €<f)y]

Sc tovto Ttpoi dvTi^^iaaTO^^v Tav vno tov

vOfXQV ')(j)i^fji.aTiadvTa}v viwv Qeov, Kai avTuv ^td tvjv ag npog Tovg 10
Aotnovg dvdpcoTrovg e^atpeTOV tov Seov KVj^efjiovtav itepi avTovg.
" ekakyiaag yap ev opdaei to7$ vtoii aov," (fyvjai' Kat " eyw etva
*'
0eo/ eaTe, Kai vioi vipiaTov iidvTeg." ax; irpoi tovtovc ovv dvTt-
^iatpav Tovg KaTo, \ptaT0v, e(f)Vj,
" ovtoi eiaiv vioi ©eoiJ."

0EOAOPOT. A^Xov oiiv OTt ot ToiovTot TYjv fjMKapiav ^ctiVjv irapa 15

TCf eauTwv TiaTpi ^vjaovTat.

^S Ov yap kkd^eTe Trvevfxa SovXeia^ TraXLV els (po^ov,

aAA' i\a^€T€ Ylvev/JLa vloOeaia^.

AioAOPOT. Tov vo/xov " iivevfi.a tovkeia<;" elne, Kai ^ovXovg

Tovi VTto Tov vo[J.ov. TO yap eiiiTdTTeaQai vtto tou vofiov, Kat TVjg 20
eiriTayYji dfxek-^aavTaff Ttfxwptav diietkvjdeiaav (f)0peia8ai, dou-

keiagV av}fj.e'iov eaTi. to ^e entTpaTTvjvat •naTepa tov Seov ditoKa-

Xeh, ^td Tv^v Tov jS/ov KaSapoTVjTa, vioSeaiag ek7ttda<; eitayyeXke-

Tat. eJVe ^e tovkeiag e^oBvj Ttvevfxa, eit dft.(f>oTepcov eaTi KaTa to

avfj.<pepov Kai dpft.o^ov etg CKdTepov tov Xaov evepyeiaav KaTa tvjv 25
afx.<poTepm a^tav.

©EOAflPOT. To *'
itdktv," a; npog to " ^ovkeiag" diietwKev.
dvayvcaareov ovv ovTOig' " ov ydp ekd^eTe 7ivevfj.a'" eha '^iaaTVj-

aavTa eitayayeh yjpvj, " "^ovkeiag Tidkiv elg (f>o{3ov.^^ Tiept ydp
Tav ev vofxcp keyet' nat ev t^ npog VakdTag, oti fxta /xev opovg r^o

S;va etg dovketav yevvSiaa dovkovg Tovg ev vofxo), Ttapadeaei tS>v

ToD fxekkovTog almog Kakiov. enetovj ovTot ft.ev vtio TtpoaTdyfkaTa

P Cod. BovXe/av,
Vlll. 15. P^MAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 131

oi/T€f, y) vapa/BamvTes eTifxcopovvTOf yj (f)v\a.TTOVTeg (TraivovvTO.

OTrep ovv txv ^qvKwv '{'^tov eivai <7V[xPel3T^K€v. (KeTvot §e "xapiTt

Tov OiairoTOv rcSv fjieXXovToov ayaQSov KOfJit^ofJi.(vot tyjv diroKavcnv,

fiv^(fj.tav €Ti fi.eTaPoXYjv vcpopmTat. oirep ovv vTtdp^/et Toig T(Kvot$

(K Twv nocTepcov eSo^. wairep yap (v Tyj Tipog TtfxoBeov K(y(i' *' ov S
**
yap (Xd^(T( TTvevft.a ^e/Ae/af^'" ovp^ ag ovTog ^etXtag Trvevff.ay

ak\ avTi Tov TovTa (fLiroteiv to 7rv(vfi.a (f>v(7tv ovk ej^e/. oi/TCtfj'

•*
(VTav6a, ov yap (kdlB(T( 7tv(vfi.a ^ovkdag itdktv (ig cf)ol3ov'

dvTt Tov T\v(vft.aTog fj.(T«Tyj^KaT(, ovy^ iva irdkiv tmo oovketav

•:^T€ Kai (f)Opov KaTa Tovg ev voft.(X), TavTa yap (K(7vat Totg irav- 10

TeA^ Tov Ylv(vfi.aTog '^(^afj.lvotg tyiv ydpiv ovy^ olov t(' kd0(T(^
\Jv(vfji.a vtoi/g (pyal^ofxevov ©eov. o(9ev Kakdv* TraT(pa tov Q(0v
irpoayofJ.eBa.

Avjkov yap oti KaTo. t^v tov Kvpiov irapa^oaiv tvjv " IlaTep
*'
vfxxv (V Toig ovpavo7g" (Kdkovv IlaTe^a tov 0fov, ot tov 15

/3airTi<Tft.aTog rj^tafKvoi. Kakag Se to *' d^^a •3raT>?p," (Tr^t^yj

Txv vTjTricov ^dtov (<jTt TO dPl3a Kak(7v Tovg 7raT(pag. vyjirtoi ^e

(Tt KaTOL Tov TrapovTa l3iov Yjcrav, 01 '^ta tov ^airTtdfxaTog Yj^to}-

fji(voi T^g vtoTYjTog, TYjv T(k(iav Kat dkYiQYj (irt tov fKkkovTog
Trpo(T^OKmT(g aiwvog. to ovv d^^a TraTYjp T(detK(, to fj.ev, (tg 20
ft.-^vu(Ttv TYjg Trpoa^oKcafxkwjg TekdOTYjTog' to Se, (Jvfi.^oXov TYjg

irapov(7Yjg KaTa(XTd(7(wg, ev yj vYjirictiv '^tKYjv, ovy^ okoTekag TYfg

fj.eT0V(7iag tS)v ayaQHv KOft.iadfiievot^ ty)v aTrokavcrtv, Yrept(fL(vov to

iroT( avTo7g Trpoa((7(a6at KaK(7va Ta7g vvv cirayy^ktatg aKokovOwg.

Sethpianot. Kviot ^\ ** wveD/xa dovk(tag" tov irovYjpov (f>a- 25

(7iv, dkk^ ovK e(7Ti. Tov yap vofjiov coSe irv(vfi.a ^ovkdag k(y(t,
Kai ^ovkovg Tovg viro vofi.ov. ho (og TifJiwpovfxevot (i eTTTa/crav

((po^ovuTo. 07r(p ^ovketag ecj-Ti (7Yifx(7ov. to t( (iriTpaTri^vat Tra-

T(pa Tov 0eov Kake7v tid to tov (3tov Ka9apov, vtoOeatag ekTrtdag

(7rayy(kkeTat. to Se «vto Ttvevfxa eaTtv (tt afx.cf)OT(pm twv kaSiv 30

(vepyyjaav to t^j "^ovXdag Kat vto6(aiag KaTa to avft,(f)(pov Kat

dpfko^iov KaTa t>jv dfJ.(f)OT(pav a^tav.

<l Cod. livXetac.

" Leg. aXX' iXd^tTe sed pliira desunt.
s Cod. KaXtT. * Cod. Koi^ricrciiAfvoi.

S 2
 132 EHHrHSIS EI2 THN OPOS VIII. i6.

i6 AvTO To Ylvev/JLa (TVjiiiafyrvpei r^ wvev/jLaTi rjixwv.

AioAflPOT. E^f/|e tta tovtov, oti kui t^v i/'U%^v TrveD/xa

\iyei, orav •>} irvevf/.aTiKVj. Kat to yapiafxa tov YlvtvfJiaroc;

rivevjtxa. TOVTo ovv eaTiv o <f)vjaiv aXkay^ov. " to yap ri irpoa-

" €v^o[J.€6a ovK o\ ^afxev avTO to WvevfKa (VTvy/avei virep Yjfxwv 5

" (jTevayfkolq akaX^^Tois'^^ Kai tovto Se ^e^Tai epfxi^veiag. eaTi ^e

ToiovTov yapiafii.a itpoaevyyjg rj e7r< twv AtocttoAwv. eTteio'/} irok-

XaKig KaTa Ta fur} avfA(f>epovTa atTovfxev. tia tovto aviaTaft.evog

Tti €Trt Twv ATToaToXcov, TO '^aptaf/.a tyj^ itpoaevy^g ^')^'* f^*

Tov Xaov Ta avfi.(pepovTa tov Qeov vjTetf oTevayft.olg aXaXrfcoig lo

5^a»/x€V0f, iva Ttpog evXa^etav Kat <f)ol3ov TrdvTag eXKvaff. Kat

*'
TovTO eariv o (j>rjatv dXXayov, eKaaTog vfxav rpaXfKOv ej^e/*

" iTpoaevyriV ej^e^" ovkovv Kat tov xpdXXeiv ydptafia rjv, Kai tov

TipoaevyeaBat ydptaft.a riv. avfXf/.apTvpeH ^e tS) itvevfxaTi rjfi.m,

htetVf} virep oXov tov Xaov nvevft.aTt npoarjvyeTO o eyav to yd- 15

ptafka. •npoaevyofxevog ^c to " IlaTep rifj.av ev Toig ovpavolg''

eXeye. ^ta tovto (f^i/jat, avft.fji.apTvpelt to nveyjUa Trjg iipoaevy^g

Tco Ttvevfxart rjfxiav, eyofi.ev tta tov (3aTtTiaff.aTog, " OTt eafiev
" TeACva ©eoD." Kpd^et yap to 7tvevfi.a, TovTeaTi to ydptafxa to

TYjg Ttpoaevy^g, " dPfSa TtdTrjp.

'
20
©EOAflPor. AyTO To rivevaa to Ay tov avfXfj.apTvpei tw
'Ttvevft.aTt rjfLav, oti Ttvevf/iaTtKwg ^tdyofkeV 010 Kai eafiev T€Kva

Seov. eav ovv avfi.Ttdaycoft.ev tco X.ptaTw, TOVTeaTtv eav Ta avra

Ttdayetv aiprjaoofieSa, aitep \ptaTog rrfv aXrjdetav itpea^evm

eiraOev eKCCv' edv ^iu}KOfJ.€Voi Kaprepafxev, Kai oaa Oft.ota itdayafj.ev 25

vnep €vae/3eiag, avvto^aaBY,aoft.eBa avrWf ev rio yeveaBat reKva

Qeov Ka\ avyKXi^povof/ioi Xptarov. rig te rj KXi^povofnta -TtpoeiprjTat

OTtiaw, ev6a Xoyog rjv Ttept Toi), " et yap 01 €k vofxov KXrjpovofioi,

KeK€V'j>Tai r} ittarig.
 VIII. 17- PX2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 188

KE4». ir.

*Eiravdkri^lns irepl rijs diroKfiHfvrjs tois ayiois do^s.

17 EfTre/) avfX7rdaxo/J.€i/, Iva kcu. cTvvBo^aorOaifiev.

Ktpiaaot. K.aTopBoinat fjiev ow * * * * to ayaOov.

ttAt^v eir) [xeydXois iKiilai ro7i dyioig 6 irovoi Kai rm vnep vovv 5

Ka) Xoyov yj ixeOe^ig. 01 yap roov ev) yrig virepopavre^;, a^iot

Kat rwv avararco yepcoV Kai ot TrpoTTovYjKore^ ev avopeia Kat vno-

fxovYj, fjLeXXovai (jre<pdvav ditoXavetv ev davyKptrotg vnepoycu^.

fketoveKreirat ydp etg dperrjv irovo^ rwv fjt.era ravra rifxav.

'^o^av ^e keyet rav dyiav, eitelirep eKXdfJi\povatv ot ttKaioi Kard 10

Kaipovg a>g ^A/of, ev rtf/.yj ku) ^o^ri Kat d(p$apaia yeyovoreq^ ev

rco fxera^XYjQy^vat avrSiv ro (rSofiia, KaOwg fxerefjLopf^oiBri Hptaros

ev rS) opet.

rENNAAioT. 'Ev ToIV Ttpo oKtyov rvj^ avre^erdaecDg axldfnevo^

rYji irpog rd 'Trakatd, Kai ^ta rYjg TrapaXXYjXa Qeaeug avrav^ ro 15

vTrepeyov yvccpiaag T^f ^aptros etra iva fj.Yj Oia ro jw.eyec/of to<^

fxa6Y}raii dfx<f)tPdKotro, ntcxracrdfxevoi avro rjj rov Aytov llvev-

fjiaroi fxerovata, fxereiatv eiri TrapdKKYjcnv aKoXovBcag, Kai irpo-

rpeiret fHYj^^ev dKivhvvov inrep rm rotovrm dTro^iopdcrKetv. crcpohpa

'XPYjaiff.Yjg Ka\ dvayKaiaq avTW tyj^; Trept rovrccv ovuYig OtOacxKa- 20

kiag' aKkcog re Kai iroXKm iroKefxm ev ratg dpyaig rov kyj-

pvyfxarog eirtcpepofxevwv rolg fxa6Y)ra7g. '/jpYi roivvv, (pYjcri, t^c ^td

Xp<o"Tov ^o^yjg opeyofuevovg, Ofxoicog avra irpog rovg virep avTYjg

eviaTaadat iretpacTfj.ovg. y] ydp rm 7ra6Y)fi.drm Koivmia, Kat TYjg

dvrt^ocreoog Koivmiav epyda-erai. eyw 'yovv (pYjcrtv, evBvfxovfxevog, 25

Ka\ Trdoag dvrtTrapaTideig Tag eiri rov irapovrog 6Kixpeig aimog,

rolg eirYiyyeKft.evoig YjfJuv dyaBrTig ev 'KpiaTW, fxtKpdg Kai ro fxritev

ovaag evptoKco.
©EOAiiPOT. To " Koyi^ofnat" avrt rov Koytaixca rw irpoaYjKovri

ireTreta fj.at rovro ovrcDg eyetv, wc ro " Koyi^oixe6a ovv Tricjrei Oi- 30
" Katova6ai dvdpco-rrov ycoptg epym vofxov.
 134 EHHrHSlS EIS THN OPOS VIII. 19.

^9 'H yap anroKapahoKLa rrj^ KTLorecof Trjv d7roKaXv\l/LV

Tcou VLCOP Tov Oeov aTreKdexeTai.

Ktpiaaot. ATTOKapa^oKia fxev etrr/v, v} eXTcig Kai yj T^g tcSv

TrpayfJidTav €Kl3daeag TrpoatoKia re Kai eTrni^pyjati. eK^^eyjETai

ye fj.fjv vj KTKTi^ T>jv diioKdXvxpiv tc5v TeKvm tov ©eoy, ovk avTYj 5

Tiov TidvTwg eihv7a to eaofxevov tov Qeov. •nwg yo-p^ f\ ''^oSev ; aW

OTi Ta7g aiToppyjToig oiKOVoixiatg tov irdvTa f/.eTapv6(xt^ovTog etg to

aixeivov OeoD, Trpog tovto vj^ei to TeXog. /xeTa-^XaTTofJievcov yap

cixniep eli ^o^av e^ aTtfxiag, Ka) ck (f)dopag eig d(})6ap(xiav twv

Tov QecZ TeKvaVf TovTeaTi Tav tvjv ev^OKtfxov KaTopBwKOTm ^ooyiV ' o

Kai avToi 'Jiov ndvTCog yj KTtatg fj.tBapfj.ofjBYja-eTai Tipog to afxeivov.

Kat Tipoaye tovto yjfj.dg BeaTieatog YleTpog evooid^etv ovk ea,

efJicev, OTi Kaivovg ovpavovg Kat Kaivvjv yYjV Kat Ta* eiiayyeXfJ.aTa

avTov 7ipoa^OKSof/.ev.

rENNAAioT. TofXOyTOV €(7T/, <^>jO"i, T^J' €'V "yifJ^dg aTioKa- 15

Xv(f>Bv]aofj.evYig ^o^yjg to Tieptov, <ag Kot t^v dnoKapa^oKiav T^f

KTtaewg, TOVTeaTt tyjv diKaBev avTVjg Tipoa^toKiav ^ijAvjv VTidpy^eiv,

OTi TYjv dnoKdXvxpiv eK^e^j^eTat tccv viccv tov &eov, ^td to Tecog
TYjv ^ci}y]v Yjfj.Zv KeKpvcpBai aiiv tw 'K.ptaTW ev tx 0ea5. to fievTot

avfj.Tiav voYjfj.a, toiovtov eaTiv. elaBafJ.ev noXkdKtg ot avBpcanot 20

jw,€Ta Tag TaJv Tipayfj,dT(av eK^daetg, cag aa(f>^ Taig fj.vYjfj.atg ava-

Xafj./3dvetv to, iipoaBev Yjfxiv daa(f)Yj. otov Tt Xeyco' iiecfyctipaTai Ttg

dyaBov t/ TteiiotiqKwg, yj iidXtv KaKOv. evBvg TtapiovTeg (f)afxev,

dXXd Kat noppcoBiv ovTog ToiovTog cev KaTe(f>aiveTo, Kat e^etKvv

Tw ayYjiJ.aTt. Kat eycb fxev avTOv ck T^cr^e T^g priaewg oaTtg yjv, 25
avTtKa fxdXa KaTefxaBov. koi oXcog TotavTd Ttva iipog tyjv iiapov-

aav Tipd^iv twv 'naXatxv Xafx^dvovTeg avfx^oXa, ^efSatovfxev eav-

Toig eK Tav TipoTepav t» ^evTepa. toiovtov t/ (pyjat Kat 6 Kvay-
yeXtaTYjg iiept tSov fxaBYjTcvv tov Kvpiov, OTt ov avvteaav fxev Ta

nept avTOV oiKovofxovfxeva iipoTepov' OTe te dveaTYj eK Tm veKpcov,^o

TOTe eyvcoaav OTt TavTa yjv ctt avTCp yeypafxfxeva' Kai eiitaTevaav

TYj ypa(f>^, Kat tw Xoycp co einev Xviaovg. KavTavBa toivvv

fxaKaptog YlavXog "nvevfxaTtKYj ydptTt TYjg oiKovofxtag Tyjg ev

'KpiaT^ TYjv yvcofXYjv TiapetXvjcpcog, Kat yvovg OTt dvcoBev ^e^^oKTo

* Leg. KCX.Ta. TflS.
VIII. 19- P12MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 135

T^ Sew, Kai OTi e^fAe^ftTo 17/xaf irpo KaTa^oXyj? ko<7^ov, titdaK^i

ra Tclig Trpoa^ev a-TToppyjTa. keyei yap ori ainyj^ Trji KTiaiwg rj

TOtovTOTponog oiaaKevvj TtpoKVjpvTT^ to vvv ire</»jvof evayyeXtov^

Kat Oi^Xv] Kai aa^^-fji eaTi tyjv dTTOKdXvxpiv twv vim tov Oeow
'TTfpifji.evovaa. eire/ ixrj^e fUiTaiag ovtwj eKTiae itdvTag Tovg vtovg 5
Tav avQpwirvv.

AioACPOT. Ev ToaavTY] (pyjaiv eaiaQai yjfxai tcov dya6<ov

Ooopea tov Qeov, ccaTe yj ekiiig Kat yj Ttpoa^OKia Tyjg KTiaetog €K^e-

yeTat TftJv vtav Tov ©eoD T>yv aitoKdXv^tV oiov t^v KeKpvfjt.fj.evyiv

avTwv fMaKaptori^Ta, fJLiKpov varepov aTioKaX.v<p6y]aofxevyjv. virovoiav ^o

Sc Tor^ TToXXoTg di^aat ra yeypafi.fi.eva ag efJL^^v^^^og eartv yj opa-

fi.evq KTiatg, Kai XoyiK-^v rtva ej^e/v ata^yjatv 6 Koafj.og. ei ydp

avarevd^et Kat avvco^ivet, Kat r^^v dvoKdXvxptv direK^^ey^erat, '^yjXov

OTi, (f>y)aif Kat avvataddveTat, Kat Xoytaftos KtveJrai. ovy^ ovra) ^e

ej^er aXXd rag e^pearyjKViag avra7g tvvdfj.etg, rdg rayeiaag -napd '5
©eoy S;e7re/v ry\v Krtatv Kard r-i^v rov ^y]fj.iovpyov (^ovXyjatv Kard
TO yeypafLfxevov, " OTe ^tefxept^ev v^piarog e6vy], ag eavetpev
'*
viovg A^dfi, earrjaev opta e6vav Kard dpi6ft.ov dyyeXav 0eou."
*'
ovT(a Oe Kai eTit rov, ei^AoyerTC tiivypg Kai Kavfia'" koi irdXtv
" 5(aAa^a Kai %<wv" Kat rd Ofxota, Tatg e^fjeari^Kviatg eirt rovrwv 20
Ovvdfxeat Xeyeadat vot^reov. ov ydp dvata6yjrotg vXatg irapaKe-
Xeverai aiveh rov 0eov. aaiiep ydp, " ndaa y] y^ irpoaKvvyiaaToo
" aoi, Kai xpaXdrwadv aoi^ Kat (aaTiep " Kvptog e^aaiXevaev
*'
ayaXXtaa6ci) yj yyC Toyj eict Ty^g yyfg dv^pairovg Xeyet' Kat
'* irev^Yjaei otvogf Kat irev^-^aet dfXTreXog" rovg ecpearyjKOTag Xeyei 25

yeapyovg' ovrco Kat vvv ryjv KTiatv Xeyet rdg '^vvdfj.etg Ta, e<pe-

aryjKViag Ta7g arpvyotg vXaig, Kat avrdg KTtardg ovaag. coairep

aroXtafxog dvopog, Kat yeXcog ohovrcov, Ka) /S^aa Tro^oi- dvayye^Kel

Ta Ttept avrov.

Oeoacpot. KapaooAcerv Xeyerai ro eXTtt^eiv' dTtOKapa^oKetv 30

TO aireXyrt^etv. toivvv Xeyet rotovrov eariv. ev aafxa t»;v avfL-
naaav Kriatv eitoti^aev Qeog. o6ev Ka) Koafxog Xeyerat itdvra,
eire opara, eire aopara' wg ev ry] Ttpog Kopiv6tovg 'ETr^aToA'^

(pi^atv, " 0T< 6earpov eyevyj6yifj.ev nx Koafj.co Kai 'AyyeXotg Kai dv-
136 EHHFHSIS EI2 THN OPOS VIII. 19.

" BpdoTrciii." enii^Y] toivvv ^iaffxipd iiq eanv ev avTo7(, to tu fxev

eivai opaTa, t« ^€ dopaTa' jSovAo/xevof eig €v to. TidvTa avv^cpdat,

TreTTOiyjKe tov avBpanov. e^ opaTov /xev <7vyKeiu,evov tov a(i)[j.aTo$,

Ka) avyyevovq Tvj (paivofxev:^ KTtaei. eK y^g yap avyKeiTai Kai

depoi Kai v^aTog Kai Ttvpoi' dopdTOV ^e TV)g i^f^^f, Kai oiKeiai S

ToTf dopdToig. Kai ^^ TrenoivjKev avTOV, (oaTrep ti (piXiag eveyypov

T0^(; Tiaai. yjpyiaifxa fxev yap avToo ra <paivo(xevay djg avTyj t^

iretpa fxavOdvofxev. ((f>eaTaai he avToi^; al voi^Tat (pvaeig, -npog to

yjfxTv wcpeXifi.ov aina Kivovaai. Kat tovtov fxdpTvg AiroaToXog,

nept T^j evavTtag Keym '^vvdft.ewg, " KaTa tov apyovTa T^g e^ov- ' o
" aiag tov depog, tov vvv evepyovvTog ev Tolg vic^ig TVjg dTteiOetag"

wg eivai ^vjXov vjfxiv, OTt npo TVjg napa^daeag elg fovg ecpeaTooTag

Tvj Tov aepog Ktv^aet 6 ttd^okog avveTeXet. Kat fxvjv Kat ToTg

irpog ^i^aaKaXiav TVjg evae^etag etg vjfxeTepav axpekeiav VTrvjpe-

Teia6at avvvjBeg avTov, wg Kat AnoaToKog cftvjatv,

'*
ovyj. itdvTeg 15
'*
eiai KeiTOvpyiKa itvevfxaTa, eig %iaKoviav ditoaTeXKofxeva %ta
'*
Tovg fxeWovTag KXvjpovofieiv accTvjptav ;"

EvTfilfiev Totvvv dopaTOi (pvaeig etg oiKeia TiBevTat to. Kaff

vjfxdg ev(ppatvofxevat. ei Vif) irpog to KpeiiTov penetv vjfxdg avfx-

^aivei. Kat tovto v]fxdg Kvptog ^t^daKet keycov, " em ev) dixap- 20
*'
TwAco fxeTavoovvTi Kai dyyeXovg yatpetv ev ovpavoigT ^vfkov %\

OTt Kat kvTrvjV avToig Trpo^evei Ta KaO vjfxdg evrt to yeipov ^taKei-

fxeva. ov^e yap dv ev^ppatvoiVTO vjfiSov d(f)iaTafi.evu}V Tvjg t«v «tc-

TTwv Trpd^ewg, et fi.vj Kai XvTrvjv avTaig eKtvei to fLeveiv vjfxdg eV
eKeivwv. ovTW S^ yvwfxvig eyovaat irept vjft.dg, wg «Te Viri oiKeiov 25

^wov Kat avyyeveg avTaig, vjvtKa yeyovwg 6 A^dfx, ehe^aTo tov

Qeov TO eirtTayfxa, Ofxov KaKeivo aKovaag, wg Trapa/Sag diroOavei-

Tat, eaKOirovv v^VTtva apa Ta KaT avTOv rvjv eK^aaiv X-^ipeTai'

Kat eire^Yi irapa/Sdg SvvjTOg eyeveTo ^id t^? diro^pdaewg, eywpi^eio

Te wg eiKOg vj ^vyy^ tov awfxaTog, Kat ft,vjyavvj9eig '^id tov 3°

dvBpwirov avvoeafLog TVjg KTiaeoog ^iekvTo.

TovTW Tco Tpoirw eaKvBpwTra^ov ai voYjTai (pvaetg ent Toig

ytyvofxevotg, Trept Vjfxdg Te ovk eiypv otKetwg, wg dv TotovTwv yeyo-

VOTWV aiTiovg KaKwv. wg ^e toD yjpovov vrpoiovTog, 01 KaOe^vjg
VIII. 19- Pi2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 137

MGpconoi ixei^ovooi (Tri lo x^^ip^'^ iipo^aivovTig €vea(f)iyyov eavToi^

Tov BavaTOv tvjv airocppaaiv' irdvTa fj.€v ra Ka6 yj[J.Si$ aiieyivx-

<jKov' [xei^ov ^e KaO y}ft.S)v dve^e^^fovro to fuHooi. o6ev ovoe "TtpdT-

Teiv VTrep YjfxoiV e^ovkovTO ti Xonrov, tovto jtxev, «f dXXoTpiovg

eavTciv d7ro(XTp€(f)OfM€voi, tovto ^e icg eyBpovg tov ©ecu fxvaaTTO- 5

fAevoi.

T/ ovv eiti TovToi^ eyevcTo ; ecpi^aev avToii o Kvpioi, cog tioiyi-

aei TYjV Kaff rjfidg "^iopQcaaiv^ dvaaT-^aag t€ y]ft.di Kai aQavaTovg

epyaadfnevoi, a>( fxr/KeTi ^e^oikevai*' /AojSe^/av ndXiv ft.eTa^okyiv

Kai ^idkv<Tiv Tov Koivov crvvMafi.ov t^c KTiaecog. TavTVjv oe^dfi.€voi lo

T*;v VTcoay^eaiv yjvBvfxovv f/iaSovTeg cog yj 6eia %dpig twv yjfji^v

€irTaiafji.evwv TtoiYiaerai tyjv ^iopSccaiVf Kai (f)i\0TifLia TtavTa Yjfuv

dTio^waetf av Yjfj.eHg eavTovg ^id fLoyPYjpiav dneaTepYjaafj.ev Tpo-

mv. Koi fAfvei fi.ev 6 KaQoXov avv'^eaft.oi ^idXvaiv ovtefKiav eTiiOe-

yofj.€vog Tov Koiiiov. ftevei ^e dppvjKTOg Kai tyJ KTiaei npog eavTY^v 15

Yj (j)ikia. evT€v^6v Kai TipdTTei aTiavTa vnep y}fJ.S}V ovk ookvovv.

KaiToiy^ €v Totg yetpoaiv €^€Ta^oft.ev<ov t'^ twv fj.€k\ovT(ov eXvi^i,

^id TVjv Tov Qeov enayyekiav KpaTOvfnevoi. tovto ovv keyei, oti

Yj KTiaig Toye ecf) YjfJ.h noXXdKig toc Ka6 vjft.dg aTieXinaaaay

TavTYjv dneKteyeTai Tm dndvTwv ^iop6(oaiVf tyjv TipoaooKiav t«v 20

fLeXXovTcov, OTi dvaaTYiaoft.e6a iidvTf.g eig to eivai a6avaT0i. tyjv

ydp dnoKdXtflpiv tcov viav tov Qeov, Xeyei TYfv avaaTaaiv' Ka6o-

Xov tvjv vio6eaiav t>jv d6avaaiav KaXcov. eneioy) viiov elvai vofJ.ii^ei

Qeov TO d6avdTovg elvai. o6€v Kai 6 Aa/3/S Xeyei, " eyco eina
'*
6eot eaTe, Kat vlot inpiaTov TidvTeg'" vfJieTg Se cog av6p!07iot ano- 25

6vf)aKeTe. cog av ovk eyovTog Xoyov to ano^vYiaKeiv Tovg viovg tov

©eou yj)Y)fJ.aTtaavTag.

Eethpot'^ 'Antioxeias. YlpoaaiioTiotelTat ty^v KTtaiv KYjpv^

TYjg dXy}6eiag, TiapaaTYiaat l3ovXofi.evog to tov TipayfuiTog fxeye^og,

Kai (f)Yjatv ditoKapo^oKHv avTYjV, TovTeoTt a(f>oop(og TipoaooKav tyjv ^o

TYjg dvaaTdaeag v]ff.epav, i^Tig eaTtv yj anoKaXvxl/ig twv vtav tov

Seov, Kat Yj Twv ^tKaiwv (pavepaatg. Kapa^oKta yap vj €7itT€TafJ.€VYj

* Cod. ScSoxeva». " Cod. J^evyjptavoZ.

 138 EHHrH2I2 EI2 THN nPOS VIII. 20.

TCtiv eXiri^oixevwv eniTYjpyjaii e'ipy]Tai. a>g tov TrpocrOoKavTa [xovov-

ouj^/ Kai eTTiKXiveiv tvjv Ke(f)aXvjv Kai Tovg 0(p6aXfjL0vg evTeiveiv,

ag TtapavTiKa itelv fj^eXkm tq 7rpo(J^oKovfjt.evov.

'AnoAiNAPioT. Ilao-a, (f^vja^v, vjfJiag vj ktIok; dvafxevei, Kai tov

Kaipov OTTOTe eTii t^s TtpoavjKovayjg vjfxTv "^o^vjg o<p0vj(TOfJie6a •JioQe7. 5

(i)g fxvpev eivai Xaft.TipOTepov riyf Ttpog v]fJ.ag e(TOfJitvYjg evoo^iag.

aKokovQov Ve vioTg Qeov t^v ktkjiv e-ne^yBai KTVjfj.a oixxav Qeov.

ekevBepoo yap to 'hovKov (XKoXovSei, Kai via to KTV]fX(x ^ia tvjv

evyeveiav viroTeTaKTai. Kai v) Tipog tov iiaTepa otKei(i}(Xig TOig

vloTg vnoTaTTei to ^ovXov. ^^Xov ^e oti KaTo. yapiv eyovTeg to io

vioi eivat Qeov, ^ta tvjv tov nvevfj.aTog, aig TipoetpvjKe, fj.eTov(Tiav,

KaTa xdpiv eyofxev to vjyefj.oviKOV ev rij KTKrei tv] oo^v] tov aXv]-

6ov( Ttov '^e^dfj.evot. cocrTe fxvj eivai Trapd ^o^av to tv]v TO(TavTV]v

Kat ToiavTVjv ktkjiv dvQpcoTroig vnoTeTdyQat, fxtKpoTg ev t^ KTtaei

(paivofxevotg. '5

20 T77 yap fiaTaLOTrjTi tJ ktlctls vireTayrj.

KrpiAAOT. MaTaiOTvjra evOa^e (pvjTt Tovg ^(iovTag ev fkaTato-

TV]Ttf TovTecTTtv Iv (j)povv]fj.nT t (TapKtKW' nepi wv dv XeyotTO Kai

fxdXa eiKOT(i)g, " dvOpcoTiog fxaTatOTV]Tt (t)fxoi(>}Qv]," Kai fxv]v Kat oti

TiapacTvve^XvjBv] ToTg KTV^vecrtv loTg dvov]TOig Kai oifxotaOv] avToTg. 20

fxaTaiOTV]g yap aXv]BS>g twv TotovTOJv ^tog. Tovrotg v] KTiaii

vnoTdaaeTat, Kat ovTt itov TidvTOog eKOvaa itoTe. TtSog ^e ^v] dpa
Kat TovTO (pafxev ; oi^e fxev yap oXwg twv KaS^ v]fxdg v] ataOviTV] tc

Kat opwfxevY] KTtaig. ov ydp eaTt XoytKV]. dxX ei Kat Ttg ^oti^ tq

dvvaaOai ti voeTv avTviVf ovk dv Y]veayeTO, (f>v]ai, Tvjg ovT(i)g ataypdg 25

tovXetag, oiit dv vjBeXv^aev viiOTeTdyPai tc Kut VTivjpeTeTv ToTg en
ov^evi Tav dvayKaiiov v]yovv dyaBav ^iafSiovv eXofxevoig. dXX^ en
eXntOtf (f>Y]at, twv aaoSv^aofKevcov Kat iSov KaTa Katpovg dytoov tc Kat

eKXeKToov vttoTeTaKTai t€, (log vno^evyvvvTog avTV]v tov Seov, Kat

olov TYjpovvTog etg eXevBepiav tyjv viioye ToTg dytotg Kai ToTg aya- 30
Tiooatv avTOV. iva ^v] fiovoig vnvjpeTeT^ ToTg avTov TeKVOtg Kai TaTg
Twv e^etXeyfxevcov TiapalSaiaeTO^ ypeiaig' aX.vei fxev yap fxovovovyi

Kat a^ivovaa Kat dXyvvofxevv]' Kat eiirep v]v fiivTvj to Kai et^evat t/

* Leg. credo vTirjpeTiTv. y Leg. vid. itapa^^cicatro.

 VIII. 21. P12MAI0TS EniSTOAHN. 139

OvvaaOai twv Ka^ oy^a? TTpayikaTav^ Tct^a ttou Ka\ avotfxio^ovaa.

ttXvjv roii; Q^ioig iiKovcra vevfxaTi, Kapa^oK€i rpOTiov riva rrjv ano-
KaXv\piv, wg ecpyjv, rm vlav rov 0€oy.

rENNAAioT. ^araiorifjra Xeyei rov pevarov rovrov Kai (pQap-

rov /3iov Yj[X(iov. ezet rtvog '/aptv, (pt^atv, ovrui itpoi ryjv VTfrjpea tav $

rxv (pSaprav aicaaa avvereivero' jot»; eTr' eXitthi Kai TTpoa^oKiaig

rotavratg Troietv avr'^, rov &eov rovro vofxoQer^^aavrog ', ro oe

" ov)(^ eKovcya" iipoawTioiioiyjaag ecpvj. ttoXv Se rovro irapa rij

OeoTtvevarci) ypa(f)Yj ro thtaiix.a' Xeyw ro Kat (f>mag Kat yjQvj roTg

ayl/vyj/ig TreptrtOevai. 'jiGitep afxeXet Kav ttj rerdprr} rav Ba(7<-io

Ae<c5v, " oLTtecrretXe yap,^^ (pyjatVf *'

lcovag ^aaiXevg lapayjk itpog

" Afxeatav /Saatkea 'lovSa, keywv, 6 aKav o ev rco AtPdvo} dite-

" areiXe Ttpog rvjv Kehpov rrjv ev tc2 At^dvw Xeym, ^og rvjv Qvya-
" Tf^a aov TctJ viS) [xov etg yvvatKa." aXXa Kut ev roTg KpiraTg,

ladafji 6 Tehemog rov Kat 'lepo^oaff. vlog, e/Ve, (priaif itpog av^pag 15

^tKtfxm, " e^eitopevByj ra ^vXa rov yjptaat e(j> eavra ^aatXea'

" Kai eiTtov ryj eXaia, (3aaiXevaov e(p y]fxdg." Kai oXcag avditXeasg

wg e(pi^v rm roiovrm yj GeTa ypacprj. ro oiiv " ov)(^ eKovaa" Kara

TOVTO Kai ATtoaroXog ecpyjae ro ibtxfxa. yj Kai ota rovg Ayye-
Xovg rv^fov, tva diio rov Kpetrrovog wg itept itdayjg avrvfg 5} to 20

Xeyofxevov.

©EOAflPOT. AfneXet, (pyjaiv, ov^ev ert TtoteTv vTtep y}f*.m 01

AyyeXoi ave)(pfx.evoi, oid ryfv eitayyeXiav ravryjv etXavro Ttdvra

TtoteTv. KaiTOiye itept rd fxdraia yjfxm dayoXovf/.evwv, rovro Kard

T^y rov Qeov eitayyeXtav aiteK^^eypfxevot, ro Ttdvra aTtaXXayyjvai 25

(pQopdg, Kat fLerapoXm Kat rpoiiy^g. enet^dv Kai yjf/.eTg d^tioQevreg

ryji dvaardaewg, dOdvarot rrj rov 0eou ^vvdfKei ytvofi.eQa.

21 Otl Kcd avTT] 77 KTUTLS eXevOepcoOrjaeTaL airo Trjs

dovXeias rrjs (j)0opas.

Tennaaiot. Ave^yerai fxevrotye vvv (pyjatv, ag Kai avr-i^ rvjg 30

vjfnerepag eXevSepiag avvaTtoXavovaa. itavaerai yap rvjviKavra
Xotitov dovXevovaa t')} (pBopa. rovreariv ovre vjulTv ert (pdaproTg

ovatv e^vTtvjper-^aerat, tafxev ydp oav) vvv vj rm aroiyetm Kriatg

aXXotcoatv vcpiararat Kai (pBopdv. Kat fj.vjv Kat rovg A-yyeAov^
T 2
140 EHHFHSIS EIS THN HPOS VIII. ai.

OTi ixYjTtw (pv(rei to aTpeiTTov e^/pvaiv entaTafxeSa' ovk «tto tcov

eKireTrTCOKOTCov [aovov, Kai dia tovto TTeaovTav e^ ovpavov^ aKXa

Kai acp m IlavAof e^vj irepi avTwv w$ evOe^^^^ofxevcov to dfJiapTeiv'
*'
'*
Kav yap rjfxei^,^' (t>'y]0''i, Kav AyjeXog e^ ovpavov evayyeXi^e-
'

" Tai Vfxa^ Trap b evyjyyektrrafxeSa vfxh^ avaQefxa ecTTa.

'

AioAflPor. Tijf vXatovg (pvueco^ ^e^ovkc>}ft.€vri^ tw Ttovripcio, Kai

eirt^ovXevofi.evfig vtt avTov noXXa.Ktg KaTa Gvyyapticriv ©eoi),

cooTC Kai Xtfxovg Kai Xoifxovg kai vocxovs Kat TioXefXovg Kat aX^ag
(jyGopai VTT avTov KaTaaKevd^eadai. Kai yap otKOi twv evoiKOvvTcov
aa-el3ciog ^tayovTcov, ey^etv yjiopav tov "TiovYjpov, cog tOicov KaTeTrt(3ai- lo

vetv' Kai eict Tyj avTcov KaKcoaet ra itept avTovg (JTOf^eta KaKovv.

m yevofxevcov, ai Tayeiaat ent tyj evTa^ia TVjg KTiaecog ovvdfxetg

aTevd^ovat Kat x^ivovai, Kat tyjv eXev6eptav rov avdpcoTrov Qiafxe-

vovatv. co Ka) y] KTiatg avveXevOepcoOetaa, TTjg tov ^ia(3oXov e^ov-

aiag dTraXXayvjaeTai. to ovv Taig XoytKaig '^vvdft.eat avfx^aivov, 15

TOVTO T'^ arpv^^^co neptTeOeiKev vXvj, cog Kai vvv <pafxev, vj oiKia

Bopv^enat, yj itoXig dyavaKTeH, yj ywpa opyi^eTat' eK toov dtotKov-

fxevcov Kai TteptTioXovfxevcov tottcov, Tovg ototKovvTag Kat iieptTto-

XovvTag iioXXdKtg arjfnaivovTeg.

Ka/ KaQ^ eTepov ^e Xoyov yj KTiatg eK^ey^eTat eXev9epco6y^vat 20

«TTO TVjg ^ovXetag TYjg (f)6opdg. eiiet ttj Toy hia/SoXov KaTaaKevrj

aKovaa TipoaKvvetTat vno twv avv^ovXcov avTYjg. eae(3da6Yiaav ydp

KOt eXdrpevaav t'^ KTtaet itapa tov KTtaavTa, coaTe TYjg ^eanoTt-

KYjg aKovatcog diioXavovaa Ttfx^g, (3dpecog (pepet to ytvofxevov, Kat

whtvet Kat ay6eTat tipog tyjv tcov av6pco-Jicov fxaTaiav TipoaKvvYjatv, 25

Kat e'3it6vf/.eT TYjg tovtcov aTiaXXayYjg, (pYjat Se OTt ot/^e e^ oipxV^

eKOvaa oi/Se avTOff.oXYjaaaa iipog tov ^td(3oXov vneTdyYj avTco.

dXX^ VTieTdyYi avyycop-^aavTog tov Qeov' Kat vveTdyY) en eXitttt

fjLeXXovaYj. Tiota ; TavTYj, oti Kat avTYj yj KTiatg eXev6epco6riaeTat.

TioTe ^e eXev6epcio6YjaeTat ', eig tov Katpov TY^g eXev6eptag tcov Si-30

Katcov' ^io etKOTCog " rj Kapa^oKta TYjg KTtaecog, t^v aTioKdXvxpiv

" T60V TeKvcov Tov Seov aTteK^^eyeTat.*^

0EOAOPOT. AnaXXdTToVTat ydp, (pYjat, TOTe Kat avTo\ tov

vTiYipeTela^at (p6optft.atoig itpdyfxaatv, eTtethdv rifxeHg d6dvaT0t

 .

VIII. 23- PliMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 141

yivafxe&a' Kai ra itavia anaXKayrj tov Tpeirecdat' eTiei /xrj^e

f(7T< Tov Xomov TO avvavayKa^ov avTovg Ttpog t-tjv tovtccv vnvjpe-

T€7a6ai Kivyjaiv.

22 OiBa^ev yap otl TToucra rj ktIcis avo^Teva^ei koll avv-

Co8lV€L a^L TOV vvv. 5

rENNAAiOT. rvapifjiog eaTiv aitaaiy (pvjaiVf rj (pvaig TVjg

KTiaewg avvTaXatTTcopovfxevrj Tewj Vf^iVf Kat oiov ^^ KoreTcetyovaa

Kai TrpoevTpeTTi^ofJievv] irpog tv^v Kotwjv avayevvvjatv.

©EOACPOT. K.a\ag ovk etite aTevd^et Kat whivetf dWa

" avaTevd^ei Kai avvco^ivet." eiret^v] Kat to **
Tiaaa ^ KTiatg" 6v-io

TavQa TtpoaeQvjKev. dv(o " vj KTiaig" eipvjKwg fAOVOv. (3ovkiTat §€

etTteTv OTt avfxcpiovaig eittteiKWTat tovto itaaa vj KTiatg' iva Ka\

TO Ttapa Ttdavjg to avTO yivea^at oixoioog, itai^evav} TOVTOvg tv]V

Ttpog anavTag Kotvaviav aipetaQat tv} tSov XvTtY,pS)v KapTepta, itag

^e Ttdaav e<pvj tovto vTtofxevetv tvjv KTtaiv', Tag fxev aopdTovg ag 15

ciKOg, aT€ ^vj KoytKag Kai tS>v yivofj.evwv ey^pvaag tvjv ataOvjaiV

Tag te opaTag, Tyj Kotvcovia tov itpdyfjMTog,

23 Ov fxovov Se, dXXa Ka), avTol ttjv aTrapyTjv ttjv irvev-

fxaTos e^ovTes, kcll rjfjL€L9 avToi iv iavTOL^ o-T€vd^OfX€V

Ktpiaaot. Ae^eTa* Ttpoq aTto^et^iv toov eipvjf/i.evav ro ev vjfuv 20

yiveaQai TtecpvKog. avTot yap vjfneTg, (pvjatv, ot tvjv aitap-^fvjv tov

Ylvevfi.aTOi e^x^ovTeg, aTevd^ofj.ev (3apovfj.evot, vioBeatav dneK^e^xp-

fxevot TVjv aitoXvTpaatv tov aoofJMTog vjfLwv. aXvjSeg yap OTt (pOap-

Tov a(afj.a /3apvvet i^u)^»?v, Kai (BptSei to ye^x^eg OKVjVog^ vovv

ttoXvcppovTt^a. yeyovoTog ^e aita^ ev vjfi.h Toy YlvevfkaTogf Kat 25

fj.eTaaTOf/eiovvTog vjfndg eig e(peatv apeTvjg, avTe^dyet ooaitep vj

(piXoaapKia i^oToig^ fieXeatv vjfuiuv eyKaTaaKvjy^^ag vofnoi^ det Ka~

Ta(f)evy6ov elg eKTOitovg vj^ovag^ aTtvjvoog dvTavtaTaTai. TavTi^oi

aTevd^ofJ.ev tvjv tov aafiLaTog vjfkm dTtoXvTpoaaiv. eaeaBat Se

Ttpoa^^oKoo^ To aoofxa itvevfj.aTiKOV, TovTeaTtv aTto^e^XvjKog e/V 30

aTtav (ppovT^fua to aapKtKov Kai^ 'yea^ef, Kat TVjg duiapTiag to

^-
Leg. olovf). y Leg. (rK?)vo?. ^ Fors. ko,) to^. * Leg. yo<TOi.
^ L6g. irpo<rioKSfA.fv. Cod. vv^.
*^
142 EHHrH2I2 EI2 THN nP02 VIII. 23.

K€VTpciv. TOVTO ilvai (f)a{xkv TO aa^a to WtviJ.aTiKOv. ei 0€ T-fji

vioBeaias vj %«/"? t"^" tov awfjiaTOi yj/xxv aitoXvTpaaiv ej^e/, fj.-^oe

riveg ok<c$ avKocftavTetTcoaav tyjv avaaraa-iv' fxrjTe [xyjv eig tovto

rjKovTm aaefSetag, wg aito^XriTOv fxev 7roie7a6ai ttjv adpKa Kai

a(f)avTta$YjaeTat Xeyetv etg anav avTVjv Tteaovaav ei$ y^ijv. avTa-5
vtaTaaBat Se (tianep eTepov r/ irvevfxaTtKOv, layyov (f>v][xt Kat

depx^eg ^'
voovai ydo cu^e to irvevfxartKGv avTOt.

rENNAAioT. Tt Tiept TTJi KTiaedo^ TavTa Xeycc ; (priatv' aK\

vjfxeig avToi to Ke(f)dXaiov TYjg ^vjfxtovpyiag' Kat ^t ovg Kat fi.e&

wv rd TrdvTa dvaKaivt^eTai, de^eyfxevot tyjv tov YlvevfiaTog aTrap-^v, 10

ToaovTOV Tm fxeXKovTav eiKyjcpafxev itoQov, coare aa'^dKKof>.ev Ttpog

Trjv fxeKKyiatv, Kat padtciig ovy^ vno(\>epofxev Tf\v dva^oKvjv' dKKa

KOfxiaaaBat to Ttdv tj^i^ yKfyofkeBa. Koci tvjv viodeatav ^rjKcov, tvjv

aTfoKvTpcoatVf (f>Yjai, tov aci>fxaTog rjfxav eTttOvfXovfxev, TovTeartv aito-

KvOy^vat to rjfneTepov aafxa (p6opdg Kai dfxapTiag Kai BavdTOv TtoTe. 15

eTtet^^rjTtep ev ToTg dvaTepotg f/.ev ag r^rj Trjg BvrjTOTrjTog tvjv evya-

ptaTtav aveKpayeVf evTav6a TtaKtv ccg ovTtco tovtov TeTvyriKcog, aKK
ert Tvyeiv e(pt(fi.evog TtpoaTidrjat' " Trj ydp eKTtiht eaci}6rjLxev' "ev

eKitiatv eTt, (f>r]ai, Ta Trjg acoTrjpiag rjf^uiv.

AiOAfiPOT. Ov fLovov, (f>riatv, rj KTtatg aTevd^et Kai a^tvet 20

Trjv eKevSepiav '^td tov Y\vevfJ.aTog dTteK^eyofnevrjv, dKKa Kat

rjfJ.eTg, KatToi rj^rj Tag dTtapyag tov WvevfxaTog eiKrj(pOTeg, Ka\

Ttetpaa6evTeg avTov Trjg evepyeatag. ei Kai ft.rj^e7tci} to TeKetov Trjg

VTtoayeaecog eiKrj^pafxev. eaTtv rj vto6eata 'htd rrjg rov acafxarog

airoXvTpcoaeoig. 25
AiOAflPOT. Ovteitci) ydp, (prjat, Trji; avaaTaaecag Tervy^Kafxev'
dKKa ^e^dfxevot rrjv vitdayeatv ralg eKittai xpvyaycoyovfi,e6a.

Fennaaiot. " 'Ev eATT/^/," (prjatv, " eart Ta rrjg accrrjpiag

rjfLiov.

©eoacpot. Y^carriptav KaKe7 rrjv TtavTeKrj t<5v KaKccu dnaKKa-^o

yr^v' rjTig avroHg eitt tov fxeKKovrog aiwvog TtpoaytveaSat efi.eKKe.

ravTa rotvvv, (prjat, fSe/Satctig eKTtt^eiv ort Ttpoaearai r}f/i.tv, eni rov

TtapovTog etKrj(Pafxev /3tov.

' Cod. «pSSe< in marg. lo-ai? yp. atpuhfi;.

 VIII. 26. PX2MA10T2 EniSTOAHN. 143

24 EATrfy Se ^XeTrofieur] ovk eaTiv iXiris.

©EOAflPOT. E< i^ev <yap aTrfXavofxev rj^vi twv npoa^oKaf/ievxv,
(pi^criVf vii oipiv eK€iTO TrdvTcos tvjv yjiJ.eTepav. Trepi de tiov (paivo-

[xevcov eXTii^eiv ov^^afxag e^eofJieSa. eTrei^rj ^e eXjri^ofjiev Trept avTwv

oog ov (patvofnevcoVf etKOTxg, avar^Kt] aitaoav t>jv eK/3a<7iv avTav 5
TtepifxevovTaiy vnofJieveiv airav oti av Kai na6e7v vnep eKetvcov

^eot.

OpirENOTS. Av$ ov ev akXoig evpoft.fv' dvri tov "b yap ^ke-

" TTf;" fKeja 8e TiotelL eknt^av eig fi.y} ^kenofj.evov' Kai tt eKe7vo

TO TeTaaOat tov vovv avTov npog avTO, ndv OTtnoTovv vnofnevoov. 10

26 'QcravTcos koll to Uvev/xa crvvavTLXaii^dveTaL.

Ktpiaaot. "Y.Tevayfx.o^g dkaXvjToig evTvyy^dvet vnep ^fncov" to

yjfLwv ^i^XovoTt nvevfua' aTevd^0fi.ev ydp eaB ot6, Tag npog tov
Seov tKeTeiag noieiadat anov^d^ovTeg' ovkovv ev 'Aytco T]vevft.aTi

Kat TOVTO fi.avBavofi.ev. ao<pov ydp eaTt KaBdnep Kat eig. eTret^r} 15

§e (fyfjat, to " x/ npoaev^oft.eBa KaBo ^eT ovk o't^afii.ev" eKeivo

^y]TVjacoft.ev. Kanot TOTtva^elt^ Tpoirov 'npoaeit^eaBat Sf?, npone-

TratOevfieBa napd ^ptaTov XeyovTog evapyag' **
ovTcog ovv vff.etg
" npoaev)^eaBe, IlaTejO yjfKav ev Toig ovpavoig, dytaaBrjTO) to

" ovofjid aovy eXBeTco vj ^aaiKeta aov, yevvjBi^TCo to Be\v]ff.d aov, 20

** (og
ev ovpavoi Kai e-ni Tvjg yvjg^^ Kai caa TovTotg eaTtv ecpe^yjg.

OTe Totvvv eyvcoKafiev KaB ov av npenot Tponov noteiaBat Tag iKe-

Tetagy Tig dv yevotTO Xoyog tcov anoaToXiKciov ypafj.ft.aTiov, vj onot-

irep av ^KeirotTO ^ta TVjg tov HavKov (pcovvjg ; (f)afj.ev ovv OTt

npoaev^ofieBdi, ft.ev tvjv toov dyaBcav 'i^vjTovvTeg aiTVjaiVf Kat Trpoye 25

Tav akXcov Ta eig ^o^av Qeov, Kai Ta ti wv av yevotTO (3icovat re

*'
opBoog, Kai TVjv evtoKtfj.ov dXi^Bcog KaTopBcoaat ^coi^v. tv]v de dnap-
*'
5(;>}v Tov YJvevfJiaTog ey^ovTeg Kat avTot aTevd^ofkev ev eavToligf
" vtoBeaiav dneKteypfj.evoi, tvjv dnoXvTpcoatv tov acof/.aTog.'' Kat
'*
cog ev ye tovtco tco fJicp^i to t< npoaev^ofj.eBa, KaB b Se^ ov/f30

otdaft,ev. et yap ocpBaXfxog ovk eioe, Kat ovg ovk vjKovae, Kat
" ent Kapdtav dvBpoonov ovk dvePvj, d vjToifj.aaev Seog Toig dya-
*'
"naat afTOv," t/ npoatovTeg alTVjaoft.ev ; vj nag av e^eivjfj.a ^ Ka)

" Leg. S^. b Sic Cod. fors. 6<8e<Sj,ut>' « /ca* oi Te9.

144 EHHFHSIS EIS THN HPOS VIII. 26.

Te6ea.[x€6a' fxaXKov ^e Kai to. eiteKeiva vov, kui TaHg avSpoovoov

Kaptiai? ovK eyvcaafxeva ; iroia S av yevono Kai vj tov adOfxaTOi

airoXvTpcca-K; ; ^ r/f 6 ixeTaiiXaaixog ; avaaToiyeiovTai Ve orcwg

eU a(f)dap<7iav Kai ^o^av^ avTog av ei^eiYj Kai fxovog tovtcov

Texvy)TYig. 5

"Kfj^y) ^e Tiov Ttpog Tivag tov SwT^po? fxaOriTrjgf KaO Qel

irpoaev^/ecrQai fxri elhoTag, aiTe^Te Kai ov Xaix^dveTe, ^ioti KaKag

aiTe7cr6f, iva ev Taig vj^ovaig vfxav ^aTrav^avjTe. ovkovv itpeiiei av

Ka) fxdXa eiKOTCog To7g w^e '^iaKeif/.evotg eiTieTv to " ti irpoaev^o-

" fxe6a Ka& teT ovk o'i^afxev.^' dXaXvjToig hri ovv CTevaymlg 10
anovfxev ev nvevfxaTi, a Kai oti fxev ecnat TtettiaTevKafxev' Tiva

&€ TpoitoVf dyvoovf/iev TravTeXSig. yj aev (f)vatg vjfniovy (pvjcnv, ecniv

da^evYjg, Kai to Kaff avTvjv dpvovfxevv] tq av6ig avafLwaecr6ai' Ta

te eTtrjyyeXfxeva fLeydXa re Kai 6e7a Kai olov fxvj^evi " •^copy}6Yjvai

^vvdfxeva, /xtjS' oXag eiti dv6pxTtov Kapdiav dvel3v} itoTe. aXX Ofxag 15

Ttpog TtldTiv TOVTCtiV Tav TVjXiKovrcov ov fiiKpav eittKovpiav aito Tov

YlvevfiaTog e^/ofxev. ravTa yap Kai aiT-^aeag KpeiTTova, Kai itepi

m ovK 'icTfxev ov^e OTtoog ev^aa6ai y^vf. iva etTtv] Ta Kai vjtep vovv

dv6pcc7tivov Kai vitep evy^v Tavia vjfniv vj ^e^ofxevi^ tov Yl.vevf/i.aTog

ydpig dTtoppvjTCog elcxitpdTTeTai' Kat otocoaiv vj ditapyvf 6appe7v 20

7tep\ Tov Ttavrog. cocritep yap 01 eni tcov ydfxcov appaPcioveg, olg

dXX-^Xotg 01 yafxovvreg '^i'^coaiv, eyyvcovrai rd fxerd ravrd, Kai

itpo(f>epOfLevoi rdg ecf) olg ^e^ovrai avv^vjKag e-ni itepag ay6v]vai

KaTavayKdt,ovaiv' ovrcog olfxai Kai vj aitapyvj rov Wvevfxarog,

TOVTeari to fxepiKOv tov Ylvevfxarog ydpiafxa, evriv appafSoov 25

T^g KXvipovofxiag vjfi.cov, t>jv ert] Kaipov '^o6v]aofLevvjV Ka6oXov "xdpiv

v)fx7v (3e^aio7. ^eov ovv dpa, rovg vnep avrvjg Ttovovg fxvj aitocpev-

yeiv. TO ^c evrvy^^dveiv fxeTa<f>opiKciog eiitev dito rov Kai rifxm rag

yeipag Ta7g itpog aXXv^Xovg evrvy^iaig avvea6ai.

©EOAOPOT. "EyvjfxaTtafxog eari Kard ro avvv)6eg rvf 6eta 30

ypa(f>v] TO eipv]fxevoVy cog erepov (paivea6at toS Ttpoyeipcf, fxdXXov v]

^ovXerai Xeyeiv. Xeyet fxev yap oti vjfxe7g ov^e Ttpoa^oKav eKe7va

Kurdye rviv T^f (f)vaecog aKoXov6iav hvvdfie6af dXX^ vj Toy Ylvev-

^ Cod. oT /xjjSevof.
VIII. 26. PI2MAIOT2 Eni^TOAHN. 145

fjLaTos %«/?<?> >]i TYjv aiTapyyiv (vravBa eiX-^cpafjLev, avafji.(f>i^o\cog

yjfMV iyyvarai t^v /xeToya/av eKeivav ea-^^^vjfJidTtae ^e ovTag. a

irpo<T^OKiOfj.ev, TavTa Kat alTOvf/.ev naoa Qeov. a ^e fni^ OvvaTOv

ekitKTat \al3eTv, TovTa ov'^ av aiT^a-at ttotc dvaayoift.eSa. to owv

jtc^ ^vvaaOat Trpoa^oKav eKeha, to fnvj ettevat Kaff o ^e? Ttpoaev- 5

^aaOai itept avTxv eKaXeTev. eTret^vj, ag ecpvjv, TavTa oyS' av

aiTvjaetev Te a fiLVj^evt Xoyw ^vvaTat Trpoa^oKav. to ^e Tvj tou

TlvevfLaTog ^vvdfLet ndvTcog avToig avTa TiepteaeaOat eXiri^etv, to

Ylvevfxa evTvy^dvetv e^pvj. eTret^^vj yap dpyvj' (sic) noXkdKii
Xafi.pdvoft.ev eKeiva a fj.vitafKS>g eavTolg •nepfnotvjaai hvvdfj.e6a, lo

evertdiq Oe avToig Kai to ntaTevetv irepl fneXXovTOiv vj en] tov

irapovTOi l3tov tov Ylvevfj.aTog ^oatg' avTO (pi^at to Ylvevfj.a ev-
Tvyyavet virep vifj.av. iva etirrf oti tovto vjfj.h eKeivcov atTtov^ o

(oairep ev appa(3u3vog To^ei KaTot tov TrapovTa /S/ov vjfi.h ^o&ev,

avayKatvjg Kat irept Toy TeXetov irtaTevetv votei. oOev tva fi.vj 15
vofxiavjg irept ivyvjg Xeyetv avTOv dXvjBwg, enviyaye, " <JTevayfj.o7g

" aXaXvfTotg, iva enrfl oti aTroppvjTX Tpo-nw eKetva ecpeXKexat. to

yap eirt Talg fj.eXXovaaig eirayyeXtatg Ka^d ye tov irapovTa l3tov

oeOofJ.evov vjfi.iv trapeyjtTat irdvTODg vjfi.iv eKeiva. Kat to " aTevay-

" ft.oig" te aKoXovBag tw ayyifj.aTtafj.Si wg eirt ivyvjg e^pvj. eiret- 20
ovj TTcog fj.eTa aTevayfiLwv ev-/pfj.evot, aKoveadai vofJ-i^ovTat fj.aXXov.

wg av avvTovwTepov irctovfj.evot rag ^evfaeig. ovtco Kai dvcoTepco

Trept TVjg KTtaecog ecpv} to arevd^etv Kai irept '^ft.Sov, OTt aTevd^c-

fiev aTevayfj.ov diravTayov ttjv irpoa^oKiav eKeivcov KaXeavjg' coaTiep

ovv KavTovBa ecpvj to Ilvev^a /ACTa aTevayfi.cov evTvy^dvetv. cog 25

av irapeyov vjfj.iv eKeiva Ka\ irpoa^oKav a rtov TrapaaKeva^ovrcov

T^v eK^aatv otKov ^ (sic). coaavTCog ^e Kat ro Uvevfxa (ppovTiaet

•jTov. ei he dfi.eXelg, dfj.eXvjBvjay}.

ToT ATTOT. TouTo ovv AidKovog TrXvjpoT, TovTa XtTavevcov.

OpirENOTS. TovTeo-Tiv av nXvipoT Ta TVjg vjfxeTepag dadeveiag 30

avTtXafj.Pavofj.evov avTvjr,. afxa Sc fxavBdvofJ.ev OTt traatv dvBpcoirivv)

(f)vaig tta tovtcov ^e^i^XcoTat.

OIS

ToT ATTOT. Ey ^etae^api6fi.'^T0vg^ to TlvevfiLa dvTtXafxPdveTat

•5 CEcumenii ut vid. est notula. ^ Fort. leg. ev Seijcreo-* Svo-efaptd/AijTOK.

D
 146 EHHrHSIS EI2 THN HPOS VIII. 27.

rvj daBevfia y][xS>v. ovk ikairov te Kai ev rw n^o^Ti.vyf.a^ai vjfJia^,

eirav ^iaPaiv<o[xev ware 7tpo(revy(.(yQai. rore yap ri 7ipo(Tev^w[xe6a

Ka6 ^cT ovK el^ore^, avrikaix^avofxevov tov Wvevfxaroi rrjq ev

vjfjiiv daSeveiaif ^<a r^v diio rovrov (SoYjQeiav, irpo^yev^^ofxe^a itvev-

fxari' eir e(peiro[xevov avroo Povjdovvri rov vov, Trpo^Tev^Ofxe^a Kai 5

rai vo'i. (.Kkemfig ^e yj evyyi rov fxvj iipoaev^oixevov dfx(porepoii'

(c^ ^^kov eK rov, " eav yX(a(j(7aig kakw, ro itvevfxd. fxov irpodev-

yerai' ^e vovg fxov aKapTTog eariv." iva oiiv fxvj aKapiTog f)

vovi, " irpoGev^Ofxai," <pvi(Ti, " rw itvevfxari, Trpocrev^Off.ai Kai

./.

TCO VOl. 10
I

27 'O Se ipevvcou ras Kap8ia9, oiSe tl to (ppourjiJLa tov

7rv€VfxaT09, oTt KaTa Qeou evTvy^^aveL inrep 'Aylcov.

rENNAAiOT. OvK dyvoiav dkka rvjv aKpi^v) rov ©eov yvSxriv

Twv Ka& ^fnag ^td rvji; " epevvm^ eavjfxave ke^eui. eTretKv) Ka)

vjfxeHi epevvvji ravra Kai nkeiovog d^iovfxev ^vjr-^^reai, a^^ep av 15

dKpif3S)$ fKaOeh ^ovkviQeii^fxev. rovr(a irpocreoiKe KdKeho " ro

" YlvevfKa TidvTa epevva, Kat ra f3d$T^ rov 0(oi;*" Kai ro Trapa

roo Tipotpviry] "^ocpovKX, " ev t^ eKeivvj >\eyei vj e^epevv^crcc

'^f-^p'^

" r^v \epov(Takvjfx fxera kvyyov. '

0eof oiv (pvjatv, aa^pwg ra

Tidvja rwv dv6p(t}7i(ov ei^oig, ov Se tcv aKOZOV rov Tivevft.arog vjfxSiV 20

dyvoelt, dkk^ ov^ev ori Kard rov avrov ^ovkvjfxa f(p 06 oe^wKev

avro' rovro ydp eari ro " Kara Qeov, Tipos avrov Tioietrai rvjv

evrev^iv. coare Tfj^eTv rovg oh "npog ae rvjv okoKkv}pov r^g dyto-

rvjTog. rovreartv ore avroig oia rvjg dvaardaeoog eig d6dvarov Kai

dTia6v\ Kat Tiavrekhg dvoke6pov fxeraarvjvat ^covjv. ei^ibg ^e rovro, 25

fKVi Tikvjpwavj rvjv ^cupedv.

©EOAflPOT. E,vrav6a (3ovkerai emeiv, ori ravra vjfxiv Tiapa-

aye^viaerat vno rov Ylvevfxarog, yvwfxvj Seov' og eTiei^vj vj/3ovk-^6v}

rvjv dnapy^vjv vjfxdg rov Ylvevfxarog eirt rov Trapovrog K0fxtaaa6ai

Plov, dvayKaicog iiape^ei KaKfiva, wv eir ekirt^i ravrvjv eKOfxt- $0

adfneBa. eirei Se ea-)(vifxdriaev (og eirt ev^^vjg ro hid r^g evrav6a

dTrapyy^g rov rivevjOiaTCf, avayKatcog vjfxag TrpoahoKav Kai ra

fxekkovra, dvayKataig envjyayev, ori Kai 6 Qeog e/^wf ro (3ovkvjfxa

TQv nvev|W.aTOf, Kai ori Kara yvcofKVjv avrov rag atrvjaeig Tioiei-
 VIII. 28. PHMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 147

Ta/, (TTivevei T7J TtpotTivyyi. KaAag Oe Kai to vTrep ayicov, iva enryj

Tcov Trpoi TovTo acpapiafAevccVy Kai joieTeaj^vj/fOTajv ^^^ tov Ilvez;-

fiaTog. IvTvyyaveiv t\ tq YlveviAa to yapKJix.a Xeyei to etii

Tov irapovTog yjfuv ^fhofxevov j3iov. Kai anapyriv tov IIvey/xaTos-

ov TV}i vno(TTa<jeaq avTov Ka^Kel, aXka Tvjg totc yjfxTv eii itavTekyi 5
®
fj.eTOV(Jiav tS>v aya^m 7rpoahoK(i}f>.evr]i ^oBrjdeaOai •^apnog. oti

fxevTOi avvrjQes Tyj 6tia ypacpyj ayYifj.aTi^eiv Tag Ta oe aito twv

Ttapa TO) fi.aKaplw Aaj3i^ avveyjag to, ToiavTa Xeyeiv eiaoBe

" yvo(pov tj^ovTa Tovi itotag" Kai oaa KaT eKeivo ro

,

(pyjaiv.
/ >IN\ \~ viro

ovoe yap tov itapovTog

/ (•/
,/
aitavTa Keyetv ein Kaipov.
»\ «.>5,\
fJiepog

ev de lo

TW Ky , Ttpog T€ Tag iivkag (pavyjv a')(yjf/.aTt'^etv wg av avoty6y\vai

o^eiXovaagy Kai itap avTcov aTtoKptatv. tovtcov yap ovoev jtxev, wg

etpvfraif voeiadai ^vvarat. erepa Se T<va €0"t/ Ta air avrav efi.(pai-

vofneva. eya fuevTot TeOeiKa Koi toDto, loaTe txyj^eva Katvov ti

vof/.i^etv keyeaSat ttap ^fx,oiv to KaTa ayyjfj.aTiaft.ov etpyjaOat TCC15

AwoctoXco Ta TtpoKeifxeva.

28 OiSa/iev Se otl tol9 ayaivwaL tov O^ov Trdvra avvep-

ycL etff dyaOov toIs KaTa Trpodecriv kXtjtols ovctlv.

Ktpiaaot. " Yivvepye7 fxev aitavTa irpog to ayaOov To7g aya-

'*
Ttwat Seov, Toig KaTo. TtpoOeatv KKyjToTg ovai." " KaTa itpoOeatv" 20

0€ apa Tvjv Ttvm ; t/ ^' av vooIto to " KaTa TtpoQeatv ;" o^«oDv
TO " AfaTa TtpoOeaiv' eiy) av to KaTa l3ovXy)atv ; KeKkyivrat §>? ovv

01 irept m \oyog, Kara ^ovkyjaiv Ttvm, iroTepov Stj tov KeKkyj-

KOTog, yj Kat avTm tSov KeKkyjfi.evm ; ovkovv anaaa f>.ev ecpeatg

Jtpog tiKatoavvqv y)fJ.ag aTtocpepovaa, yevotT av rjfjiiv itapa tov 25

Oeou Ka\ Ylarpog ; €^17 yap itov, ^ptarog, " ovteig hvvaTat
" ekBeh Ttpog fj.e, eav fiy] 6 YlaTyjp 6 Jrefj.xpag fj.e, ekKvav} avTov."

irky]v ev ye TOVTOtg ovk av Ttg afj.apTot Toy irpeirovTog keya , wg

KkyjTot yeyovaai Ttveg Kara TrpoSeaiv, t^v t€ tov KeKkffKOTog Kat

Tyjv eavrZv. 30
rENNAAiOT. Akka fxyjv Kai TOVTO yjfJ.h (pyjat irov, irdvrcog

dvof/Lokoyi^Tai OTt Seog ovk eyvo} KaTukenreiv Tovg dyairmTag

avTOV, akka ndvra avTotg to, nept avTo7g avfi.(3aivovTa yiverat ^

« Quae seq. pessime depravata sunt, f Leg. Xtyuv. B Leg. ytve(T9ai.

U 2
 148 EHHrHSIS EI2 THN nP02 VIII. 29.

•napaaKevd^ei npog dyaQov, are Kai Kara t>jv ayaOvjv avToiv irpO'

Qeaiv TTpoaKeKXrjfJievovg ^ avTovi' evTevQev fxevTOi fcai tyjv aito-

Koyiav Tojf virep T^f Xov^aim dTto^oXri<; Tjp^aTO TrpoKaTaaKev-

d^eiv.

©EOAflPOT. Oii ^e7 Oavfxd^eiv, <f>i^aiv, el TOiavTa fxev totc S

vpoa^oKiOfJLev vjfuv dyaOa nepieaeaQai, ev dvi^KeaTOig Oe ayav

KaKoig KaTa to napov evpiaKOfieaa. itavvye eiOOTai wg Oia TravTCOv

evepyeTCiv S e^of too Qew tov^' ayaTrZvTai avTOV. a(f>6ovov avToig

Twv dyaSoov tv}v yopriylav itapeyofkevo^;. coaTe Kat d-no twv qqkovv-

Tcyv eivai XvTryjpcov, ft.et^ovas avTo7i rovi aicovtovs Ttpo^eveiaSai 10

fxtaBovi. KaXwi Se toSto o'i^afkeVf eTtetVif} a(f)o^pa afj.oKoyyiff.evov

e(f>if] vpayfiM, "navTog ovtivqs qvv Ttdvvye avvQTjaofxevov, oti to<V

dyaircoatv avTOv dya9cov Trpo^evog ytveTat Seog' oitovye Kat •nXvjff.-

fxeXovvTCOV dveyeTat, yjXtovTe dvaTokrjv Kat veTcov yropviytav avTolg

'^apt^Ofx.evog. eha Ka) dno^^ei^ewv oitep e(f>ifjv •Jr/aToy/x.evos', " T015' 15

**
KaTa itpoBeatv KKvjToig ovat'" tovtwv yap y)^v} Kat itdkat Seog
TVjv Ttep) avTwv itpodeatv, oid Tig eaTat. o6ev avTOvg Kat eKaKeaev

eitt Toi TYjg otKeiag d^icog Ttfxyjaat itpoatpeaeag.

^flTior. " To/V KaTo. TtpoOeatv KKyjTOtg ovat'" TovTeaTt To7g

KUTa yva3ft,i^v, KaTa itpoBeatv d^tci)6e7at TYjg Kh^aewg. 30

29 "^Otl ovs irpoeyvio, kol TrpocopLcre (Tvp.fxop(povs rrjs

elKovos Tov Ylov avTov, els to eivaL avTOV TrpcoTOTOKOV

iv TroAAot? d8e\(f)oiy.

rENNAAioT. Hpoaptae ^e tovto, (pyja), Kai fxeTc^coKe t^? vio-

deaiag Ka) aKKotg. ov tov Tiov TavTyjToi ^yjfxtaaag' eyei yap 25

ovTCog eKehog t»;v KaTo. itdvTCOv vTtepoyyjv, Kat TtXeoveKTet Totg

TtpcoTOTOKOtg Tcov aoeX(f)Zv.

3° Ouff Se irpompLcre, tovtovs koll CKaXeae. Kai ovs €/ca-

Aeo-e, TovTovs kol ehLKaicaaev' ovs Se iSLKaicoae, tovtovs

Ka), iSo^oLorev. 30

Ktpiaaot. Eivd(f)opft.ov Tvjg dittaTiag to y^pyifxa TtotelaBai Ttvag

TO ditetKog ov^ev, e^ dfxa6iag avvYipitaafxevovg, Kat XeyovTag, ei ovg

f Cod. TifovKwKvifMyoi. B Cod. fvtfy€T(7.

VIII. 30. PX2MA10Y2 EmSTOAHN. 149

aiiTOg irpoeyvci) Kara ^podeaiv Kai vpoaipeav, cvtoi KeKkvjvTatf

vpog rjixai ovtev tov^ oxma) Tii.TiicmvKOTai' ov yap toi K€kXv]~

fi,ida' ovT€ fJLVjv Ttpocopta-fxeSa. itpog ovg epovfxeVf oti o votwv toi/?

yafji.ovg tc5 vlw avTov, Toiig /xfv oiKeTag aneaTtiXe (xvvayeipat

Tovg KeK\vjfji.evovg' oi ^e ovk rjGeXov eXGe7v. eia^XSov ^e fxeT eKei-S

vovg 01 K\y)Tot kot tVtav TrpoQecriV TreTtX-^aTat ^e ovTwg 6 vvfxcpaov

Tc5v avaKeifKevm. ov^ ovv d<p avTOig edeXovctv eXOeTv efi.iroowv

opaTai Ketfxevxv. a^iKe7 §e ovleva to avfXTrav yj Ttpoyvoiatg. ovt€

fjjyjv ovivvjai Ttvag eni^^i^aaKOVTCov, ei

fj.y)
Kai avTOi TrpoeyvccaOvj-

aav, 01 Taig aitetOiaig e^v^piKOTeg tov KeKXitjKOTa Qeov. akka lo

Kou KeKkrjVTat fxev, Koi eta-iTeTiyj^vjKaat Ttveg etg tov yoifJLOV. vXifjV

(iv yeyovaatv CKXeKTo), ov^e ^e^tKaiwvTat, ov^e eQo^dadyjaav. Ota

-noiav ahiav ; oti fxy} TtpeiTovaav ^ To7g ydfxoig ^fX(f)tevvvvTo

aToXyjv dXXwaTe kou avTOV evplaKOfxev tov Kvpiov v}ft.av Iviaovv

'X.piaTOV dvacpavlov eipyjKOTa, " ^evTC Trpog /xf TrdvTeg ot KOirtwvTeg 15

" Ka) ire^popTiafxevot, Kayw dvairavaw vfxdg.^* i^ov yj^y] avfxirav-

Tag cKdXet irpog eavTOV. dfxoipyfaetev S' av ovheig TVjg «r/ ra

KeKXyjaOai '^(dptTog' ev ydp tw irdvTag entelv, airoirefxirTOV TroteT-

Tat iravTeXwg ovteva' ovg ei^wg iroppwBev, (pyiaiv, oirolot Tiveg

eaovTai, dcpwpiaev eig to twv fxeXXovTWV fxeTaayeh dyaBwv, TOu-20

Tovg Kai eKdXeaev, waTe ^id TVfg hr avTOV triaTewg airoXavaat

^iKaiwatv ', dtxapTeiv ovk eTtt^e^/ofxevotg tot6* y) te ye ^o^a ev

d<p$apaia. t6 Kat dGavaata yeyovoai KaSd-Tta^. aitavTa fxevTot

Tavra dite^wKe 'itpog to, " oHlafxev ^e OTt to?? dyattwat tov Qeov
" TtdvTa avvepyet elg dyaOov," ^i^^d^at ^ovXofxevog, wg ov tteptopwv^ 25

avTOvg Oeof ev TaXg Ttapovaaig e^eTd^eaOat 7tote7 avfX(f)opa7g,

Ttwg ydp, oye hti ToaovTwv dyaSwv artoXavaiv KaXeaag avTovg.

Kai

KaTa
ToyTow^
\\>/ TVjv
vvv,

airoppyjTov
dXXd
f~/ irdXat

eavTOv
Kai

irpoyvwaiv
irpoirdXai,
> '
yprtaraTO
e^OTeirep
f~/
oiroioi
avTOvg
Ttveg

eaovTai, Ka\ irpo tov yeveaSat. ethwg ydp avwOev ToiovTovg eao-^o

fxevovg ™ avToi/g, dvdXoya t'^ nepi avTwv ^taSeaei TtoppwSev avTo7g

yjvTpeTtt^ev dyaSd. itwg oiiv avTovg itepitte^v oiov tc, Kai itpo tov

^ Cod. vpeicov. i
Cod. tiKaiua-n;. ^ Cod. ui ami itepiopu.

1 Leg. toZto ov *Z*. ™ Cod. €i:ojA(vov<i sed in marg. eVo^evov^.

 160 EHHrHSIE EIS THN nP02 VIII. 31.

yeveaOai TYjg Ttpoaipiaewg avTwv ra^; a[xoil5ag evTptTriaavTa, Kai

eir/ TovTovi avTovg Ka\eaavTa, (caTe ^ta Tvjg eii avTOv TTicrTeag
Tftjv TTpoa^oKWfxevcov ayaSav.

3 ^ T/ ovi^ ipovfjLeu irpos ravra ; et 6 Qeos virep t^/jlwv,

TLS Kaff rjpiav ; os ye rov ISiov Yiov ovk icpeicraTO. 5

rENNAAior. Qeov Toivvv, (pyjaiv, ovTog vnep yj^av, v]fji.eig aWov

riva Tccv Tidvrwv 0o/3^fl^a-Oj«,e0a ; Kai rov <^<ov T/ov ovrag virep

^[xav '^i^ovg d(f>ei^icg, ovrog eig '^[xag nepi rm vTroXonrm af/,iKpo-

XoyfjaeTai ; ovk eari itdvra Oeviepa 0€o5 rvjg dyditrig avrov

T^f -nepi vjfxag ; evKaipov tovtx vvv en lay^eiv' ori evravOa rov 10

Tlov Trapa rov Tlvevfi.arog virep y]fi.wv icapo^etoaBai " \eyuv 6

HavXog, ev ri] •apog Kcpea-iovg, avrov Trap eavrov Xeyei rov Tlov
*' *'
Tovro TrevoivjKevai. ^ptarog, yap," (pfiaiv, YjydTtYjaev vjfxag,

" Kat itape^aKev eavrov virep yjfnuv.*^ ri ^i^daKcov yjfiLag erepov

yj ev etvai Y\vevff.art Kai Tiw Tvjg dvBpcoTiov acoryjptag ro Pov-i^

Xyjft.a ;

AioACPor. Aet^ag dtd rcov Ttpd^ecov oit avvepyei itdvra yjfuv

elg dyaBov ttd t^v toD ©eou 'itept yjfj.dg dydTty\v, ovf evpe Kard
itpoQeatv KXyjrovg, ro fxeya reKfkyiptov ryjg aydity\g rov ©eov,
htdyei, b eit^ei^aTo ev tw tov ft.ovoyevovg /x^ (peiaaadaf el Kat 20

fj?q
Odvarog KareKvptevae rov '^caryjpog, eitei Kat ctt avrS) Kvpici)

Tco Behat " t^v ^^y/l^ avrov Kai itdXtv Xa(3eiv avryjv, aXX Ofjicog

aKOTtYireov ort \piarog eavrov roig dvBpctiTiivotg vTrejSaXe yrdBeat'

Tiyv Te ihtav rov YYarpog eKTrXyjpciov /SovXyjaiv. irdvra ovv virep

yjft.a>v Qeov olKovofLovvrog, rtg eft.7io^iaet ; rtg ovrog layvpog, 25

(oare rag eig yjfnag rov Qeov dcopeag ^iaKcoXvaai. eiKorcog ydp
TOtJ Ttov ^t yjfxdg fXYj (petadfxevog, Kat rd dXXa irdvra vnep yjfxcjiv

oiKovofA.y)aet, Kai rav aXXcov irpoBYjaet tyjv ydptv.

KrpiAAor. Tolg ayaBoepyeh yipY\fi.evovg, itdvra avvepyei, ©eov

virepaaTrt^ovrog. yap rov Kara (pvaiv yj^pet^i^Kcbg Tiov, iva aaai^ 30
Ktv^vvevovrag, Kat aTtaXXd^vj Kivtvvcov, yrchg ovyi Kat avv avTco rd

Trdvra YjfJAV yapielran ;

n Cod. nrapaZehuaOai. o Cod. O^vat.

 5

VIII. 33- Pi2MAIOT2 EniSTOAHN. 151

33 TtV iyKaXecrei Kara eKKeKTWv GeoO ; ©eoy 6 dLKaicov.

tU 6 KaraKpivaiv j

rENNAAioT. ^yKaXovvTm TOiyapovv ot PovXo[JL€vot Kai KaTVj-

yopovvTcov rjii,ag' ov yap layvouatv yjfjAV aixvveaGat to TtapaTiav

T^g &€ov \p7](f>ov, fj.e6 vjfjicov T€ Kat vTrep yjfj-av t€T ayij.€V)qg' (3ov- $
XeTat eiTreTv OTt [Mvj^evt ^vvaTOV TavTa vjfj.av acjxKeaBai, a TcpoXa-

/3(i)v vjfxh @€0g eyaptaaTO. ovt€ ovv eKXe^afnevov vjfj.ag tqv ©foD

eirt Tvj Twv fj,€XkovT(i:v anoXavcrei avaTpanvjvat vno Ttvog tvjv enXo-
yvjv vjf/iav ^vvaTOV. ovt€ iiapeyovToq vjft.Tv to, Trpocr^oKiOfxeva' Kat

TTpoye TravTav tvjv a\vj6tvvjv eKetvvjv ^tKataatv ev vj KaTaaTV]ao- lo

f)i.€$a, afj.apTeh ovk eTri^ey^Of^evot, TOre ecnat Tig 6 fj.€Ta(3o\'t^v

Twv Ka6 vjfnag Troivjaat tvvdft.evog ; axxTe oi) irpoavjKe ^e^tevat Tovg

OtiOKovTag. d<peXea6at ydp ra dya6d irap v]ft.wv '^vvavTat ov^a-

fJ-S)g, a-nep em tov fieXKovTog vjft.iv aiccvog npoaeaea^at €kTrt^ofj.€V.

Oio eiire " tv^v eKkoyvjv Ka) t^v ^tKaiojatv." ttd fxev TVji CKXoyvjg 1

TO Trpog TovTo evrev^ev vj^vj d(f)(opia6at. a-^fxaivwv Oe Ota TVji

otKaiioaectig ro eivat avTcov ev diroXavaei. to t€ ^tKaiooatv to

dfiapTtav fj.vj eirtMy^ea^ai KaXav. avTvj ydp dkvi6vii tiKaicoatg.

diro o\ TOvTov To ^e/Satov toov '^t^oft.evctiv vjft,h avjf/iaivcov. 01 P ydp

dfKaprdvovTeg ev To7g tttofi.evoti fj.evovfj.ev dei. o6€v ov^e avaTpa- 20

irvjvat viro Ttvog avTO '^vvarov eivai ecpvj.

'^pirENOTS. AoKeT fxoi tovto dvacpepeadat ent rov ^idl3o\ov,

ovra KaTYiyopov Kat toov eKXeKrm oig eyKaXeaet. ov^etg ydp

eartv, ov. ekeTvog fi.v] KaTV]yopv]ar], Kat c6 ovk eyKaXeav], ei fKV]

fxovov {v]aov, " bc dfxaprtav ovk evotvjaev' ov^e evpe^v] ^oXog ev to) 25

" aTOfxaTt avTov'''^ Kai ^td tovto Xeycov, " vvv epyerat dpywv tov
" Koafi.ov TovTOVf Kcti ev efxot ovk eyet oiitev." tta tovto ovv eKeT-
vog e^evTeXi<!^€Tai, eyKaXm Kat Kard eKXeKTav Qeov. tou ydp
Qeov ^tKaiovvTog, rtg KaTaKpivat ^vvaTat ; Kav Karvjyopog (pepvj

etg fkeaov Ta dTrv]XtfXft.€va ecf oig KaT€Kpi6v]aav, et fxv] airetXtirTO. 30

eOtKatcaae ^e avrovg, cog v€<p€Xv]v dTraXetxpag tocc dvofi.tag auTwv,

Kat XevKdvag rovg Trporepov v]fxapTV]KOTag dog yj.ova,

^piaro^ 6 aTToOavoov, fidXXov Se koll eyepOeis.

Fennaaiot. Wpog tv]v aTTO^et^iv av6ig tS>v Trpoetpvjfnevcov j^oj-

P Leg. vid. (,11.

162 EHHFHSIS EI2 THN HPOS VIII. 33.

petf KOii (f)f](yt,

" X/)/(JTOf aTtoBavaiv, [AaWov Sc Kai eyepOfig,^*

Kai TCt e^yjs. ov yap cos Tives wvjQYjo-av [AeWovaav avTippY)<Tiv

avTW •napa riviav TavTVjv avSvnocpepeaGat diakvuv tovt6 eTrvjya-

•yev, ena (U.>jSe v7re<pveTo [xyj^afxoQev eK twi/ 'Trpoetpyjfxevav avT^

TotavTVj Ttg evdTaatg' Ttep eTti tuv «AAcov evpofxev dvTtBeaewv. 5
Ttg yap av tovto viieXa^e Ttpog tov YlavXov, to OTt toi) Qeov Kat
YlaTpog ^tKatovvTog yjfxagf 6 'K.piaTOi 6 Xiog ovk edaei ; ov^e etg

S^woy* ov TOivvv ov^e 6 ^ATtoaToXog itpog ovk dvStaTdfxevov avTa

Xoyov efxeWev eiKyj ttayavi^eaBat Kat aKtoixayeiv. ittaTovaSat

[xevTOt Kat ^e^atoiiv TtXeov tov Qeov t>jv (f>t\av6pctiittav, w<; itpoe- 10

(pafxev, yjv avTcp koi a(f)0^pa ye dvayKahv. ^ta tovto toTs vpoeipvj'
** dvtoQavm, [xakkov Se Kat eyepOetf,
fuevoig htvfyaye, X.ptaTOs

og Kai eaTiv ev be^ta. tov Kieov. 0$ Kai evTvy^avet vitep yjixm.

[ui yap evt i ri Sc? ae, (f>v]a}, rov kontov ; [xvj yap vitet^eaOai

fj.era^oXvjV. eyet reXog' ro itpdyft.a Ttpog itepag eK^e^vjKev. ov^^ev 15

€vSer Ttpog T^v awTVjpiav y)[ii.av. reQvvjKe KptaTog^ [xdkXov Ve Ka\

eyyiyeprai, Kat TertfxvjTat ra Ttpara itapa 0ea5' Kat tvjv ydpiv
avTOg eKl3t(3d^ei tvjv eig V3[i.dg. TOVTeariv avra tc3 TtpdypLari

S^Xof eartv wg eavrov vjfndg 7tpoaKaXov[X€vog, Kai vj aTtap^/vj ro

Ttdv aitoX^^rperat' Kat rvj Ke^paXrj ro Xotitov dnotoOviaerat awfua. 20

rvjv yap vitep v][jt.av 'nXvjpwaag otKovo[xiav, Kai vxpaBetg, eX^et Ka)

Vjfxdg oig eavrov Kard t\v oiKeiav vitoayeatv. " OTav yap," <pvja]v,

" v\pa)6w, Tore Ttdvrag eXKvao) itpog efxavTOv." eayvifi.dTtae Se

KavravBa ro Ttpdyfxa ^td t^j " evrvy/dvei^ Xe^eag, vtpog TtXvjpo-

(poptav vjfxm. KaSd Kat itpo ^pa^^eag ev Toig itept Toy IIveJ/AaTOf 25
e^a^aev.

AnoAiNAPior. KeXvKe, (pvjatv, vj eKXoyvj rd eyKX-^fxara, Ka)

rvjv KaraKpiatv Ttpoav^pvjKev vj ^tKatcoaig. aare ovre vofxog Kara-
otKa^m, ovre dp^yovreg rov aimog rovrov KaTey^ovreg v(f> dfxap-
Tiav rov avdpuTtov, Kat ^id rvjg dfxapriag eiti ^ovXeiav Bavdrov 30
KaQeXKovreg, ta-^vpoi KaQ vjfxm ert yevvjaovTat' dXXd itavaerat

fxev TO Tov vofxov (f)ol3epov, ydptrt 'Kptarov vtKCOfxevov. e^aaSevei

Oe vj rm dpyovrm rov atmog rovrov itovvjpia, ttj dyaOorvjTt tov hi

yjfxdg acpaytaaQevTog, Kat eKovaiwg eavrov eK^e^wKorog evhoKia

Tov ©fou Kat riaT^oj-, et Kat eitvjXGev dvdaTaatg rov Odvarov ^^
 VIII. 35. PaMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 153

aTcoKpvTtrovca' Kai ovKeri TeGvfcoTa opxfxiv X/j/o-tov, «AAa ^xvTa

Kat avvtopevo^Ta to) IlaTp, Kai iiTrep avBpiiiav npea-^evovTa
KaTa TO avdpctmivov, Ka6o Kai itpoi avBpairovq avvrjcpQyj^ to. ^ie-

atSiTa avvanTcov,

Sethpianot. Aia tovtcdv tyjv aixcTpov tov \pi(7Tov ^etKvvaiv i

aya^TTyjv^vjv ej^e/ irept vjfJiag. ovk rjpKeaOi^ yap rco aTtoGaveh virepvjfxSiv.

Kat oyjAov OTt Tavra evTvy^^avei, avep Kat vjviKa avvrjv av&pcoTroi^

Kara adpKa' vjTet yap tqv YlaTepa Xeyav, " iva omv eyw elfxtf

" Kat avTot cuaiv.' itept tovtov evTvyyavei 6 Swt^jS, ovtc ^e ca$

ayvoovvTa tov TlaTepa to. koB rjfxa^ ^t^da-Kei evTvyydvcov, ovTe i o

cof fxrj /3ov\ofJi.evov' a yap /SovXeTat 6 TlaTy^p, (3ovkeTai Kai o

Tio;. TO ovv ^ovXeTai rj 7rpea(3eia Kai rj evTvyja, tyiv fxeXXovaav

aaejBetav Ha(3eXXtov •npoeKKOTtTet 6 Xoyog' ^i^daKoov, wg el Ka\

ft.ta eaTi t^^ Tptd^og rj ovata, «AA' ovy^i futa viroaTaati. ^<a

yap Trji evTev^ecog eTepoi o atTav, Kat eTepcs o atTovfxevos ^eiKvv- 15

Tat. ovK aTOTtov yap tov fj.ev Ttov atTeiv, tov 8e UaTepa yo.pt-

^eaOat. OTtcog av dpfji.o^ovaa ToJ^tg eit dfJi(f>OTepcov tc5v itpoaccTtcov

(pvKaTTrjTat. vj ovk aTOTtov rjv et^OTa tov IlaTpof t^v yvcofLrjv

<f>6av€tv Tov Ttov Tov YlaTpog t>jv '^cnpeav, Kat vcpapitd^ovra ^i^ovat
Trjv yaptv. ovtco yovv Kat itdvTa fj.ev dta tov Ttov e^rjft.tovpy^Bi^, 20
(3ovkriati t\ Tov IlaTpOf, iva ^tdXov to aKoXovSov Kat itpeTtov kir

afL(f)OTepci)V Tchv Ttpoacc-itctiv (pvXdTTrjTai. ^i^daKCi oi/v rjfnai Xoyo^

Trjv Ttept Tov IlaTpog Kat Ttov davyyvTov Td^tv. eav ^e Kat tov ev

aapKt HptaTOv Xoytarj aiTovvTa, itoXXci) aoi fj.dXXov (pavehat

Xoyo( ivavvovTOTepo;. 25

KE4>. lA.

Hepl T^s 6(}ifi\ofjLepTis dydin)s Xpurra,

S5 Tis^ 'qiMcis \(opLau anro ttJs aytm-qs tov \pio-TOV.

rENNAAior. Av^rjaai to itept rjfj.di (ptXTpov Tot/ Seov, Kai

Trjv rjfj.eiepav Xonrov evyvcofi.oavvr)v, ^v itepi tqv ToaovTov vjfJ-dq -iq

evepyeTrfv eyetv yj>eciiv, tte^epyeTat Xeycav, cuj ov^ev tu>v ev dv-

X
 154 EHHFHSIS EI2 THN OPOS VIII. 37.

BpoiTTOii ovTCDV ^eivav jyji els X.pi(7T0v ayaTrrji iTpoa^Kev •yjfJi.as

€Tri(7Tav,

ToT ATTOT. Tavra TtpodpY,Tai rcc itpo^pYiTfi Aa/Si^ ntpi r^f

virep Tov vofjiov tc5v MaKKal3ai(tiv evcxTacrewf. Tt yap to 6av[xa-
JTOV, (f)7jaiVf €pya(70[x€6a^ ttjv ia-)^v Totg Ttpea^vTepoii evvoiav €tii~
5
'^eiKvvfxevoi Titpi tov Qeov ; oU ovk icri^v aXka Kai ^oAXoS fji.et^o(ra

KeK0(Tfx-^fjLe6a '/a.ptv' Kat eiieityi T^f oiKeiag 'yvw/xT^^ e^eiiie t>jv

7rpo6eciVf iva furi ^o^ij KaT aXa^oveiai expea6aij Ta^^faq etiriyayt

TO el^f.

37 *AAA' eV TOVTO19 TTaxTLV v7repvLKa>iiev 8ia tov dyawrj- 10

(TavT09 rjfidf.

rENNAAioT. E^^Ojtxfv fxevTot^ <^>jo"/, TO ToyTOJV KaTo, Tteptovcrtav

KpaTeTv, ovK «</>" fauTcSv, «AXa Qta tov ayaTT^^cavTog v}fA,ai.

©EOAflPOT. AetKvvg OTt fJiVj^e tvjv ^apvTfjTa Seb^eva/ irpo^y^Ket

Twv eTiayofJ.evoiv KaKav, etKOTOog ev^yayev, " «AA ev TovTOig ira- 15

" (Ttv VTiepviKafKev 'bta tov ayaitYiQaVTOi vjfxag." itap avTOV yap

YifKiV Kat TO %OKOvv etvat l3apv Tav 6\f^e(ov eTriKOvcpi^eTat. ave-

TtaKT^rjTOV TYi Ttap avTov cvvepyeta twv XvTiYjpm epya^ofLevov tvjv

Ttetpav.

OpirENOT2. N/A^a jW,ev fxeTa afX(f>Yjpia-Tov ayavog tov^ ev 20

ToIV aycovi^OfJievois irept viKYjg 7ieptyivofJ.evog tov avTay<i)Vi(XTOV.

vTiepviKa ^e firj^e ttjv apyy^v eTTtTpexpag (XTYjvat irpog avTOV tc5

fvavTiOVfJiev(a. TOtovTog TlavXog Kat ot t)]v ofj.oiav ayTcw Ttapa-

(TKevYjv itpog Tovg 7tetpa(Tfj.ovg avetXYjcpoTeg, to 6Xi(3ov KaTaita-

TOVVTef Kat eVTpV(f>0OVT€g TUi (TTeVOyOHpoVVTt, Kat TO '^tSoKOV TYJ 2C
vTtofJ.ovYi ^iccKOVTeg' Kat tov XifJ.ov tta t^v ovpavtov Tpo(py]v yeXSav-

Tef* Kat TYjv yvfj.voTVjTa ev ov^^evt Tt6efj.evoi, ^i ^v evtebvvTat

XptaTOV, Kat Tov Kivtvvov (Oi ov KivhvvevovTeg KaTaitaTovvTeg, koi

Tvjv fi.ayaipav, S<a tov ^avTa tov ©eoiJ Xoyov, ovh\v yoKeitov

epyacraa6at avTOvg Ttei^ofJ.evoi. go

Sethpianot. AafiTtpug ^et^ag tyjv tov Seov vep) yjfnag ^id-
6e(Jiv, Kat TYjv Tov Ttov avTov ayaitYiv, aKokov^ag ^ttdaKet, otovg

Xotvov eivat ^el irtpt tov evepyeTyjv Tovg evyvafnovag. uaTe /AijSe

TCtJv Travf (pojSepxv Ovvaa6ai ^taaTi^aat Yjfxag tov XptaTOv.

 VIII. 38. PnMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 155

38 Tl€7r€t(riiaL yap ori ovre Odvaros, ovre ^corj.

rKNNAAioT. Qavarov jaev ovv TrdvTa Xeyei ra yaXena' eTreiOyj

tSv roiovTwv TToivTWV Te\oi 6 QdvaTO^. ^wi^v Se irdvTa ra rpvcf^yjXa

re Kai dya^d' e7re;^r? rm Toiovrav itdvTm reXoi vaXiv euriv »7

^o)^. \yyeXovg ^e Kai dpyag Kai ^vvdfxeig, ras dopdrovg ovatag 5

ai rolg ^iaipopoig rovroig ovof/.aai KaraXXyjXag alg viir,peTOvv-'

rai yjieiaig TipocrayopevovTai. AyyeXoi [xev irapa ro e^ayyeX-

Xeiv roTg dvQpooTTOig ra ck Seov, dpy^at Se, Ttapa ro apyeiv,

% 'TToXecoVf ^ e6viov oXag olg ecf^earaai. ^vvdfxeig oe, irapa ro

^vvarag ^e^^rjfji.iovpyeTcTQai •npog vnYjpeaiav 0eov. " evXoyehej 10

yap <^>jcr/, " rov KvptoVy irdvreg 01 AyyeAoi avroVf ^vvaTOt 'iayyi^

** Ttoiovvreg rov Xoyov auTOu." eveo-Tftjra ^e, avfxnavra irepiXYi-

•KrtKwg ra iiapovTa' fxeXXovra §e, Ofnotag Tidvra rov irpoaooKO}-

fjLfva' vtpi^fxd re Kat PdSog, vnepovpdvid re Kat vitoyPovta' npoa-

e6y]K€ ^e Kai touto, ovre rtg Kitatg erepaf ^etKVvg ryjg irept Qeovi^
dydityig avrov t^v virepiSoX-^v' Kat ort ravryjg "xdptv €Toif*.og

_ €ctt/v ro7g re ovai Kat ro7g ovk ovai ttafxd^/eaGai. ^ta fxevTot toi)

**
ovTf fi.eXXovra" ^^Aov TreTtoiyjKev dKpi^ag, ort ov ^id ri (ptXei

rov 0eov, ov^e dfKoi^m eXitttt rtvm, dXX avro rovro arepym
ro (ptXeTv rov 0eov, Ka) Ka& avro Kpivm avro Tteptaitov^aarov. 20

ov^ev ovv rm TtpoaTtYiptBfLyifxevm, (pyjatv^ ditoaryiaet t^? €tg 0eov

dydityig y^fxag, eveKe ryjg dcpdrov vept yjfAag avrov ^'^(eaeag, y^v

tta Tot; Kvpiov yjf/.m 'I^croy '^ptarov Ttoir,adft.evog eve^ei^aTo.

'QpirENOTS. Opa ei fiyj evXoycog ro fkev **

Tteitetafn.atf^* ort

ov ^vvarat y}f/.dg yjoptaat. rd ^e rtva era^ev eitt rm ft.ei^ovm yj 25

Kard dv6pa}7tov itetpaafi.m. ro ^e '*

rig yjfxdg yapiaet" e^evreXt-

^m Tovg dv6pci)7tivovg eitt rm eXarrovm yvfx.vaaim ryfg avdpojTttvyjg

tpvy^g' Kat edv v7tepvtKiifi.ev ^e rd Ttporepa Kat avflpwTr/va, ov

ycaptg avfkitvotag Kat evepyetag Kpetrrovog avrov 7tept€aofJ.e6a. "^to

KaXag 6 TlavXog 7tpoae6y}Ke ro *'

"^id rov dya^tyjaavrog yjfxdg." 30

Ttpoayeg §e ei 6dvaTog fiev ^taXaiei ^ovXofxevog ycaptaat dito r^g

aya7tr\g rov %eov ryig ev 'Kpiarw lyjaov, ovy Kotvog Ttept ov

'*
dvcoTepci} e'tpyjTat, ro evfAcev aov 6avaTovfxe6a oXi^v ryjv vjfxepav,^^

dXX eyPpog X.ptaTov Kai eayarog KaTapyyi6y]aofxevog. ^ovX-fj-

X 2
156 EHHrHSIS EI2 THN OPOS VIII. 38.

aerai fxev yap ovtos yjupiaai, (pepe eiTreiv YlavXoV ov ^vv^creTai

oe Kai KaTapyovfxevoi vTto tov ev avTco X.piaTov. ^wri Oe, ov^i

Tco 6ava.TU) tovtq) evavTia. to. yap aXXvjkoii evavTia ov TrecpvKev

ev Kai TOVTO /SovXeaGaif aWa vj KaB ^i» ^ri Tig t^ dff.apTia Kai
ToHi ei ^eaiv avTy}<; Kat t<» \pev^ei. el ^e Kai Ka6 eKa<TTOv ei^oi 5
'*
ufxapTia e(TTi Tig, tpavX')^ ^coyi eTTiaTyjdeig 8<a to KoeiTTOv to
*'
ekeo^ (Tov vTiep ^cDaf*" avTfi yap /SovX^^aeTai fxev ywpiaai tov
ev TJi aydiTYj tov 0eoy ev 'KpiaTW \vjaov. ov ^vvaTai ^e, KaTapyov-
fxevi^, Trv} /A€v viio tov SavdTov Ka6 ov aTroBv^aicei Tig tyi dfJiapTia'

•nyj te vjto tyji; ^ayjg ^ ft.ev Tif KeKpvitTat avv tSo X.piaToo ev to) 10

06W. Kat AyyeXoi Se j3ovXovTat yjff.ai yjcptaai TYjg dydTitiq tou

©eoi) T^f ev ^ptaTio Irjaov, •nepi cov XeXeKTai To7i ef eva)vvf/.(0Vf

" VTrdyeTe eig to nvp to aiuiviov, to ^Totf/.aaft.evov tco ^ia/SoXca

Kai TOts AyyeXotg. to de out€ ot.pyai eTri to, ovk eaTiv rjfntv

** Yj
irdXyi ""po*" «']«•'* '^*' adpKa, dXka Trpog Tag dpyag^ Kat t» 15

e|^c dvacpepeTat' Kai eig to " OTav KaTapyvjavj Trdaav ct.p^^v Kai
" ndaav e^ovatav Kai ^^vyafi.iv." e^^g tovto eaTi " ra evecrTftJTa'"

TttiJTa te e^TTiaKeypai et ^vvaTai dvacpepeadai dri rovg KoafxoKpa-

Topag Tov aKOTOvg tovtov, Kat ovy^t e-ni Tiva eveaT^Ta av6pco7rtva.

AXXog S av Xeyoi to. eveaTOOTa dvacpepeaBai eiri Ta ^Keno- 30

ju.eva Kai TTpoaKaipa. /xeTa tovto ei'^ci)ft.ev Tiva " Ta fi.eWovTa*

Kai eiTt Trpog tov fj.eX\oVTa y[£ovov TraXataovTa tco ATioaToXca ri^g

cv Tco /3/03 TovTco napent^y]fi.iag cof Trpog Ta7g eveaTVjKvtaig avToo

TYjg ypa(f)Yig TYjg FjTrtaToXy^g yjfAepatg, yj Ta fi.eTa tov eveaTYjKOTa

alma Kai jU,eTa t>jv e^ohov ev6ect)g aTratTYjaoiji.eva, OTe apy^cav tov%^
KoafKov TovTov, Kal Ttveg vtt avTW tvvdfxeig (SovX-^aovTat fi.ev

KpaTeiv Tov eK^y}ft.YjaavTog, ov ^vvrjaovTai oe eTri tSov irpoaveiXyjcpo-

Tcov T^v dydTTYjv Tov ©eoD ev "KpiaT^ l-t^aov. e^^g Oe avTco eaTi

ro ovTe 0vvafJ.eigy onep eotKev etvat etbovg Ttvog tcov eqca ovyjtov

awfKaTog XoytKcov. fHYjnoTe ^e yj tov av6pcoTrov xpiJ^x/} eTii^ovXeveTat, 30

VTTO fxev vxl/cofj^aTog, KaTo. " ev ToiV eirovpavtotg TrvevfxaTiKa Ty}g

" TrovYjpiag." vno ^e ^dBovg^ KaTo. to. KaTay6ovia, aiv ovteTepov

Tov ev TY} dydny} Toy 0eov onXiadfj.evov ya)pia6y}vat avT^g eaaet.

E< Be Kot irapd tv}v l3Xcnof>.evi^v oXyp TavTY]v KTiatv eartv

IX. i. PaMAIOTS EniSTOAHN. 157

erepa KTiaig^ Tyj (pvaei fx,€v /3Ae7r5/x€V>j, vvv Se ov^€vu op<ofi,€vrj,

^YjT-^aeig ei ^vvuTat eV €K€ivy)v avacfyepecrSai ro " ovre KTiutg

'*
CTfpa ovvi^aeTai vjixaf yjeptaat aiio r^f dyany]? tov Qeov."

KE*. lE.

n.(p\ (KTTTixrtas 'l(rpa^\ tov dTro^\r)6(VTOt, Koi «cX^crfax tov dXrjBovs tov 5
(\a-ax6(VTQs fKTa (BvS>v.

*AXi]0eiav Xeyco eV l^piarw, ov •^evSofJLai' avyLjxap-

Tvpov(Trj9 /JLOi rrjy avveLhrjcrew^ /jlov.

Ktpiaaot. AttoXcktov fj.€v tTioieiTO Seo^ ev ap^yaX^; tov

lapoYjX' Kat ^Yj Kai TrpcoTOTOKov avTOV dinKdXei. dWa ytyovaatv 10

aXd^oveg Kai v^piaTai, Kat to CTt tovtwv (ireKetva KvpioKTOvot'
ravTVjToi QtaXccXaart. yeyovaat yap dvoTiefjjnroi Kat e^epptfji.ff.e-

vot, Kai Tifjg irpog Qeov otKetorvjTog eig aicav uXtaSyjKOTeif reO-

itvrat KaroTTiv eBvcaV Trecp-^vaat ^e Kat Tvjg rav irarepcov eXTridog

aXkoTpiot. eTret^rj ^e fxaKdptoi riayAof, rm Betwv evayyeXim 15

reBetrat Xetrovpyoi^ Kat ^ieKrjpvrre rolli eBveai rov lyiaovv^ avoore

Kat Kdrco rovg e^ aifiMTog 'lapay^k dvoTreirrwKevat Xeyuv' Kai

rovg ev aKoro} vore Kat rSiv baifjiovim BepaTtevrag KXvjrovg yeve-

aBat Kara Trpo&eatv Kat irpoyvaatv Seov ^ttayvpi^ofLevog, tva /x^

riveg otcovrat^ twi/ afjLadearepctiv fj.ovovov)(^t Keif*.evotg Kat evdX- 20

XeaQat roTs eK yevovg avrov Kai ireaovatv eTtifj.et^ia,v^ dvayKatav

*'
Ttotelrat ttjv aiioXoytav^ Kat (pyjatv, aXyjBetav Xeycc ev HptarcOf
" ov xpev^ofi.ai" Kat ra e^^g' dXXa rolg fiev etg rovro aKaiorv}-

Tos rpoTTQV eKire(f>otTy]Koaiv ccg rvjg eig Seov aydirvjg a7roXta6eTv,

aKXvipdg re rag eirt rovro Xoivov dvarXvjvai ^tKag, eTrtarvyvd- 25

aetev dv rtg, Kat ro eK (ptXaXXvjXtag avroTg eTttard^at ^dKpvov,

etvj av ov irepa Xoyov, ft.dXXov oe rvjg dyaTiVfg rv\v itXvipcaatv eyei.

ro ye 'hv\ Kat vitep avrcov avdQefj.a BeXetv etvat ^ptarov, fnerpxv

eiteKeiva rSiv dydTivjg Xotiiov. ov yap dv tXotro rtg, etirep eariv ev

KaXcp (ppevogj rvig erepeav evcKa acarvjpiag itpoa^Kpovetv 0eo3* Kat 30

•noteTaBai fj.ev irapov^ev rvjv eavrov ^co-^V erepotg ye fjivjv ro "yjpvjfLa

1 Cod. o\ovtai.
 S

168 EBHrHSIS EI2 THN nPOS IX. i.

eveivat eXeiv. t/ ovv apa, ^vjo"/, r^f lov^aiav caTrjpiag dvTa\-

Xayixu Tviv eavTov TrpoTiSeig ; ovkovv vrnp^oXiKOi^ 6 Xoyog' Kai

ayaTtyji diro^d^iv ej^e/ tvj<: TjAewTaTiyf . **

evxpixi^v yap" (pvjatv,

*'
dvdOeixa eivai avTO(; eyw dTco tov 'KpiaTOv virep Tav d^eX(pav ^

*'
fxov, Tuv a-vyyivuv [xov." Ofxoiov yap «$• einep \eyoi. ei Ttpoa-

KeKpovKOTOf efKOv Tco \pi<TTW, lapavjX avaaa^eTatf eiXofXYjV av

avTOg eyw, 6 Kai toTs ev irtaTei ^e^tKaiwfxevoii e<7rwv, **

ov yap
** tovtov
eKpivd Tt elhevat ev vfUVf ei [xy] Ivjaovv Xp<o"TOv, Kat
** *'
diio
eaTavpcofxevov'" 6 Ttaai ^taKYjpvTTCOVy Tig yjfxag ytoptaei

*' T^f dydnyjg tov XpicrTov, 6\i\pig ^ aTevo-xcopia, ^ ^tcoyfxog, ^io

" Xifxoif yj yvfxvoTy](f y\ Ktvovvoit yj fxa^^^aipa ; to oyTO) beivov vito-

aTYivat KaKOVf Kat eig virep ndvTCOv yjaptaat iipog oXeBpov. tovto oe

yjv aayy\vevovToq fxev Tovq Xovtatovq e\q evTreiSiaVy dnoKpovofxevov Qe

Tag Twv davveTwv avKO^avTtag. coovto yap tZv ^lov^^atav Ttveg^ oiov

dvoTrXyjKTov yeyovOTa tov Beaiteatov YlavKoVy Tolg Ota Mwaewf 15

dvTtcpepeaBat voft.otg. TavTVjTot Toig TiiaTevaaatv entaTeXket Xe-

yooV " erre yap e^eaTyjfnev Sew, ehe acocppovovfxev vfLiv'" ovkovv

€Xotft.y]v av eycoye, Kat fxdXa iipoBvfXcog (pyjaiv, iva Tovg e^ aifxa-

Tog dvaacoa-atfxtf dvdBefxa eivat dno Y^ptaTov. TipoaeTrdyei ^e

coairep Tyjg eit avTolig kvTiyjg tyjv atTiav, ovk avtKavcog eyovaav 20
dno(paivcov etg ye to hvvaaOat TOtavTVjv avT^ ttjv "htdBeatv evep-

yd^eaOai. tua fxyjTt ^okoiyi (TKXyjpov Te Kat dTiyiyeg ei7re7v Tijg

eTepcov ^co^g avTaWayfxa t^v eavTov ^copovfji.evog. TrpaTov fxev ydp

'*
fpYiatv 'lapat^XiTatf avTwv yj vto6ea-ta Kai yj ^o^a' Kat al htaS^
Kai Kat yj vofxo6eaia Kat yj KaTpeta Kai ai eirayyeXtai. e\ avTav 25
6e TO Kara aapKa, Kat avTOg Ji.piaTog. aAA et fxev Tiveg

Yiaav TovTcov ov irdXai ^teyvcoKOTcov tov (pvaeiTe Kai dkrfiag ovTa

0eov, et fxyf vofxog avTOig ^ta Mcovaecog yeyove fBpalBevTYig, ri^g

etg avrov otKeiOTyjTogf et fxri TYjg twv dytcov TraTepcov e^e(pvaav

pt^yjg, Kat T^f eKetvcov evKXeiag Te6eivTat KXyipovofxoi. et fx^ irpaj-^o

Tot Tovg TYig eig Qeov XaTpeiag fxefxeXyiT^Kaatv eXni^ag, fxeTptco-

Tepav av Tig tyiv ev avTo7g eirof^aavTo Xvn-^v. eitet^yi ^e avTcav

o'i TtaTepeg Kat toc dXXa, fxovov ^e oyj^/ xai e^ ovptag^ avTo7g tcov

"
Cod. intp^oXiKuf, * Cod. i^ovpici(.
IX. I. PaMAIOTS Eni2T0AHN. 169

"apay^arm lOVTcov e/f a^OKVjrov eKTreTTTciiKaai TeXog, Kai dirjfxap-

TviKaai TTjg eXm^og' ttoJj ov Trav^e/vov d\y]6£i to toTs dOXioif

<Tvfxl3e(3i^Kog ;

rENNAAiOT. Tovioaag ovTco ^ia TrdvTwv avTOvg eig to itiuTev-

ovTag Tf KvayyeXiw (SelSaictig, TrdvTag doKvwg Tovg virep tovtov 5

•neipaafxoiig KaTa^e^^^eadat, ^ovkeTai Trpog evaTuaiv dvOvno^pepO"

fj.evYiv avT^ Kai fjidXa veaviKV]v dTTOKpiveaSat. e^net^v] yap ev Toijf

•7rpoXa(3ovct tov vofxov eKJBaXlov, tyjv ydptv •noKvTpoiroig Kai fj,d-

Xtcnd ye «tt avTov tov voff.ov avveaTrjae' Kai dXvjSciig viovg Seov
Tovg TavTvjg ecpvjaev etvat, ovg Kat ndXat TtpoethoTa KeKkvjKevai lo

vvv Tov Qeov' eyvu} tov lov^^ahv evBvg tovtov dvTtaTV]aofJievov, Kai

TV]v TioXvBpvXXi^Tov avToTg eKetvv]v avTtdeatv avrco npoKa\ovft.evov.

e<paaKov yap lov^^atcov ot To7g AvoaToXotg Kat too KV]pvyfj.aTi

7ioXefj.ovvTeg, tvoh e^ dvdyKV]g virdpyetv to eTepoV i^ xpev^^eg to

evayyeXtov, vj tqv Qeov xpevaTyjv. ei fxev yap a KVfpvTTeTe, <f>vja]v, 15

etatv aXv]6Y], xpev^^v^g 6 Seog, Tag oiKeiag irpog Tovg TraTepag vjfj.S)V

Trept vjfLoov viroayeaetg Toig epyotg e^apvv]adfj.evog. e7rv]yyet\aTo

jLtcv yap TOJ AjSpaaft,, etg to aTrepft.a to avTov TiapaTrefj.xpeiv Tag

evkoyiag. vvvt ^e dv6 vjfxcov, dKaddprovg koi dkXo<f)v\ovg dv6pw-
Trovg Ta e6vv] irpoa^e^eKrat. ei TOtvvv vj tSov eirayyeXtwv eKetvcov 20
CKpaatg eaTtv cog (f>aT€ to Vfj.eTepov KVfpvyfJ-a, irpohvjXov tog expev-

aTat Tovg iraTepag vjfnav 6 Qeog. ei 8e ovy^ oatov irept Qeov tovto
etireh, vfi.(ig apa Kat irap vft.S)V Xoyog xpev^^^g. tovtov itpog

Tovg AiroaToXovg tov Xoyov avveyag irapa/^aXXofievot, irpayfj.d-

T»v ov fj.tKpcav avTo^ig atTtoi Kai 6opvj3ctiV KaBtaTavTo. tia yap TVjg 35

TotavTVfg irtdavoXoytag avToov e^aTraTciovTeg Tag Kap^htag rwv d^d-

Koov, Tourous' Te a(pv]povvTO t^j- aooTV]piag, Kat ^tooyfi.ovg ToTg 'Atto-

aToXotg a<popvjTovg eirr^yetpov.

TavTf^v Totvvv avToov Kat vvv 6 ayiog YlavXog tv]v dvTtppv]atv

povXerat ^taXvaat, Kai '^ei^at tov t6 toD EvayyeXiov Xoyov aXijfl^, 30

Kai Tov Qeov ov \pevadfi.evov. fieXXoov ^e tovto KUTaaKevd^etv, etg

avTovg eKeivovg TrpoTpexpat ^ovXeTat tv]v Karv^yoplav, Kai Tv]v diro-

^oXy]v avTooVy ovTe tov Qeov xpevaTi^v, ovtc to KvayyeXtov ^te-

Xeyyetv, aXXa tv]v eKeivoov avToov vrovvjptav t€ Ka) rrpog tov ©eov
160 EEHrHSIS EI2 THN HPOS IX. r.

avKTTiav. iva ovv tovtq noiav fA,v) ^oKoii^ Troieh avro (fnXoveiKia^
rm Kai fjiiaei tw irpof avToiif, aXXa to ovTcof aXriBiiac; ej(e/v ro

vpayfxaf TipotiopBovTai rov Xoyov Kai to fxeXXcv av9v(f)0p(Ji.(iv eg

avTov Kai 7rpoi(7Taaaai tco aKpoaTf] TTpoiofxevo^ apy^Tai ovTa^.

" aXvjSeiav Xeyco ev X.picrTQ}, ov }pev^oft.at,^^ Kai Ta e^^f. avd9efxa 5

70 d(f>a}picrf/Levov eariv, ene ^e eir dyaBS) olov ©eco, e/re eiri

KaKW, olcv dvQ Qeov. tovto ^e ck tov viroKetfxevov yva)pi^erai.

" ev^Of/.fiv yap avrog eyw dvdOefxa etvat aico rov ^piarov virep rSov

" d^e\(f>av fxov, rwv avyyevthv fjiov'^ Kat ra e^yjg. AteXSwv ev roU
Tcpo TovTCtiv T^f €V Xp<(7Tco Tov Qeov ydpiTog Titjv v^ep^oXi^v, Kai lo

T^v vnep avT^f eavrov TrpoOvfJLtav Kot evaraaiv, vvv fxefKvyirai rm

TrpoTepcov, ore Ka6 VTiepPoXvjv e^itoKe rrjv eKKXyjatav toD Oeou Kai

eTTopGvjaev avrrjv' TreptaaoTepcog ^vjXcoTVjg vndpytav toIv •JTarptKm

avTov napaooaecov' Kai (ftvjatv, ort avrog ovroi eya, o vvv erotfJ.og

(ov vnep rov ^vayyeXtov Kat Tiav oriovv vnofi.ehai, ovrcog eK rvjg 15
evavrtaf yvcofi.yjg avrov ro npoaSev TroXefniog vjv, (oare av^^^eTv ro

aTiYjXXoTptcoadat Qeov, Kat Kotvaviav eivat fXYj^ertvaovv Trpog avrov.

Qvrco ^e, (pyjai, ^teKeifxvjv, irpog rvjv Kara aap^d fxov twv \ovoatoov
avyyevetav d(f>opav, Kai vofxt^cov eTretnep lapavjXTTat rvy/dvovaiv

ovroi, xpev^es eivai ro K-^pvyfxa raig Geiatg irept avrm evavrtov- 20

fxevov vTroay^^eaeat. Kard yovv fxev rov vofxov Kat TrpoatefJ.evov ^tya
rovTQV Tovg eBvtKOvg, aircoBcvfj.evov te rovrovg wv vj vioBeata, rovr-

eartv Qtirep vjaav 01 eKXeKToi' kou ovg ev^o^ovg ^td tcSv Trepi

avrovs aet BavfKdrfov eTroiYjaev Qeog' Kat oirtveg vir^pyov tcSv

tiaQi^Koiv 01 ^/a^oj^o/' Ka) oig voft.Q6eTVjaai Seog Karvj^icoae' kou 25

oig eK TravTcov rvjv avrw irpoa^i^Kovaav Xarpeiav Troteiv e(f)avepcoaev.

ovg irepiel^/ov at viroay^eaetg, Kat cov ot irarepeg, 01 irdvv (piXoi

©eoiJ. Kat ro fj.eyiarov irdvrcov, " e^ m ^piarog ro Kard adpKO,

*' wv Seog, evXoyrjTOg
eirt irdvrcov eig rovg aicovag. df/.-^v."

Ylporepov fxev ovv, ovrco tteKetfxvjv' vvvt ^e rt KXvjSvjvat ^id T^f^o

ydptrog KaTO^tcoSetg, Kat yvovg dXi^Bwg eivat rovro eKe7vo ro Trapd

©eot) frpog Toy^ narepag eTrdyyeXfxa, KarkyvwKa fxev ent roig

* Cod. (JMvtKitqi sed in marg. yp. ^^kavetKt^.

IX. I. PX2MAIOT2 EmSTOAHN. 161

irpoadev (fxavTov, kvTrrj ^e a^pop-^TX Ka\ o^vvq (yvviyofxai^ OiapKyj

Xoyil^oixevQg vnep Tivm tivi ^i6j«,ap^o/xvjv. Kai TrSig Xp^oTov fxev

yjapi^eiv Kai aWoTptovv eaTrov^a^ov efJiavTov' npoiTtfj.av oe tvjv

KaTa adpKa itpog Tovg ^Xov^atovg vjiraTvifjLevo^ otKetooaiv. o$€v

eTretOvj to Xeyoinevov ovk evirapd^eKTov ov, ^TriaTaTO tc5 aKpoaTyj^^

^td T6 TO Tvji f/.eTa^oXr}i vireplSdWov, Kai OTt yvafji.v]i vjv Kat

irpoatpeaeai doodTOv, irpo^taTetveTat fjJrj Xeyeiv rpivOvj, Kai eTrift.ap-

TvpeTai Tov X.oiaTov, ag irap eavTov Kat T^g avTov avvepyetas

Tav koyav avTov to dXvjBevetv eyovTm. avfj.fj.apTvpel ^e fkov,

(f>v}<Tt, Kai V] avveihvjati, ^id TVjg 7rvevfj.aTtKVjg ydptTog, etg tovtoio

(f>6a(TavTog yvoifj.viq. (pvjaag fj.evToi to " evyofxvjv avTog eya ava~
" 6efii.a eivai diro tov 'KptoTov, vnep txv d^e\(f)av fuov, twv (jvy-
'*
yevthv fj.ov^^ irporxe^viKe to " KaTa (rdpKa'" ^td tovto Ovo yev-

vvfdeti vjft.a)v oidev vj 6eia ypa^pvf' fxiav fxev tv]v 6vv}tvjv, vjv Kai

aapKiKvjv ovof/.d^et. ^evTepav ^e tyjv eK veKpm avaaTacreojg, tvjv '5

*'
dBdvaTov, vjv Kai irvevfJ.aTtKVjv eivai ^r,aiv' oi ovk e^ a<jU.aTa)v,"

" yap," (f)Y]aiv, *^ov^e eK 6eXvjfj.aT0i aapKog, ov^^e eK 6eXvjfj.aTog dv-

" 'bpog, «AA' Ik Qeov eyevvvj6r,aav." Qeog fxev ovv rjfj.m ev €KaTep(x,

'*
yevv^aet ^vjfKtovpyog. **
av eirXaadg fJie," <f>vjat, Kai edvjKag eir

**
ejtAe T^v %€'/'« cof ." OfJ.(»>g dvdpoiTrwv fxev vtovg KaXeT Tovf Tiy? 20
irpoTepag yevv^aeag' Qeov ^e Tovg Tvjg oevTepag. 6eXi^aag TOtvvv

hiroaToXog tovto e[JL(f>^vai, OTt fnvj Kotvctivovatv avTa KaTa ri^v

deiav avyyevetav vjirtaTVjKOTeg yiptarw, Kat TJj Kar avrov vvv

dva(f>avetavj yevvvjaet, 7rpoae6riKe ro " Kara adpKa'" avrvj ft.ev ovv

vj TVjg irpoeKreBeiavjg iriarewg aKpt^vjg epfnvjveta' KtaXvet Oe ovOev 25

** eart
Kai T^v do^daav erepotg €iTre7v. e(f>aaav rotvvv rc, Xviri^ fj.ot

**
fneydXv} Ka) dtidXeiTrrog otvvri rr} Kap^ta" rov HavXov etTreTv,

ov '^tori e^ifa^e r^v eKKXvjaiav rov Qeov, Kai rivyero ava6efj.a

elvai dito Kptarov, dXX^ virep TVjg dno^oX^i^g rav lovOaioov rav

avyyevm avrov Kard adpKa. virep m Kai avro rovro evyeaOai 30

TO dvd6eft.a eivat diro rov \ptaTov. eya oe vtpog rovro, rovro fj.ev,

ov (f>vjfJ.t, ort ov irepi evearaavjg, dXXd irept 7rapeXvjXv6vtag yvoofj.t^g

Xoyog avTw. evyofjiVjv -yoyv eiirev, ovk evyofnai. TroXv yap r-t^g

rm yjpovm evaXXayrfg ro d^td^popov irapa t>j ypa(py. eKeivo Oe

Xeyw, ort qvk rjv eiKog VlavXoy rov virep Trjg etg 'Kpiarov a^aw^Jf 35

Y
162 EHHr. EI2 THN nPOS PaMAIOTS EH. IX. i.

TradeTv iravia "TipoBvfxwg KaraO€')(0[j.evov wg evTtXovg •npayfj.ajog

tia rovg ^lov^^alovg Kararf^poveTv tov 'S.picTToVf Kai t^^ l^iag 'irpog

Tov 'KpiaTov oiK(iw<T€a}g, ovTOjg tfxTtpoaGev tyjv lon^a/wv a-coTvjpiav

'TTOteTadat, wf Kai (vyeaBai to aTtioyja^ai Xpiarov. aXX avro

TOVTo (pyiai) T>jv rav lov^^aiav crcoTVjpiav rjOvj KaTaBvfxiav oixxav S

'X.piaTWf Kai ^ia tovto tov oiKeiov KaXov to (piXov 'KpiaTw Trpoe-

TifJLa. Kakwg ovkovv Kai t>jv i^iav a^WTYjpiav ovaav XpcrTo? (f)iXy]v

vptiaTaTO tyjTtovBev ov yap eaTiv aXXcog enie7v. ei toivvv eSepa-

"^eve TavTfi •TTapa^vve, Kai '^api^o^evog fKaXXov eXvTrvj. ro aw-

^ea6ai yap, aXXccv airoXXvfxevav, vjKiaTa 'K.piaTw irpoacpiXec, lo

«AA' eneTreiaTOf (pr^ai, Xpiarov avTOv aTro^eypixevov Tvjg ToiavTVjg

irpoSeaeag fxvj dvaTroXeiv' Kai ^ia tovto vivyero dvd6e[xa eivai diro

Toi) "K-piaTOv. dxXa tovto tqv irpoTepov papvTepov, enrep dafxevi-

^eiv "^ia TVjv eig 'K.piaTOV evvotav vireKpiveTO Tifxcopiav, vjv ovtafxvtg

cvfx.^vjaoft.evviv Trpov^ei. OappZv yap to fOri iraBeh, eipmeia rvjv 15

evvoiav ^ia roy roiovrov 'ndBovg cnXdrreTo.

AioAapoT. AvayKaiwg ra napeTrovri^ opKco 'Tria^Tovrai rov

Xoyov. Trpoetirwv yap ort ovk eart rt ^vv^aerai avrov yapiaat

rvjg dydirvjg rov KptaTov, eirdyet ori fxovog rvjg avyyeveiag avrov

vjrrarat. (f)i^ah oiv ort VTrep rav lov^aicov vj^ecog av Kai 20

Kai
^,\ 'tpvyvjv TrpovjKaTo.
/ cr»
tva cov
/
eKTreTrrccKaat,
\5\/.
ra avra iraXtv
acofux,
>
ava~

KaXeactivrat TrtarevaavTeg eig 'Kptarov. rt yap rav KaXcov ovk

'louSa/cov ^v, e(f) oig vvv ra eflv^ a-efxvvverat ; ^ vioOeaia, vj to^a,

ai tiaBvjKai, at hrayyeXiai, vj Xarpeta, 01 6eo(f>iXeTi •narepeg' Kai

TO fxeyiaTOV, c| wv 6 Kpta-rog, ro Kara adpKa. e\ avrav, (f^vjatv, 25

Kptarog. %eog te ov fxovccv avrwv, aXXa Kotvvj eirt Trdvrccv eart

Qeog. rovrccv ovv irdvrwv eKireTrrcoKaatv lov^haTot' aXX tva ravra

avaKTviawvTai, (f)V}aiv, v^ewg av dvdBefxa virep avrwv eyevof/.t^v ano
rov Kptarov. to ^e dvd6efxa rov dXXorptov ^vjXoT. evret ro ava-

Tffiev rcy dvare^evrog dXXorptov. dvayKatwg ^e oavjv ej^e* Trept ^o

avrovg otdBeatv "^eiKVvatv. tva fJ.v)Tig rovg Kar avrwv eXeyyovg
npog aireyPetav Xeyea6ai virofSdXXot^.
Kflwtt

^ Leg. iiphovTi. X Hic desinit Codex Bodl.

 $

SUPPLEMENTUM
E CODICE MONACENSI.

7 Tt oi)v ipovfjL€V 6 vofxos a/iapria ; fi-q yevoLTO' dWa

TTjv ajxapTiav ovk eyvcov, el firj 8ia vofiov.

ToT Xptsostomot. 'AvTiOeaiv irdXiv avaKVTTTOV^rav kv€i'

enetoyj yap elnev " Iv KaivoTVjTi Ttvevfx.aTQq Ka\ ov TtaXaiorriTi

" ypafj.{xaTog,*^ eTt-rjyaye^ " t/ ovv epovixev' 6 vo(J.oi afxapTia ;"
Kat yap irpog tovtov yjv elpfiKwg^ oti Ta iiadrifj.aTa tZv ay.apTiS>v
" Ota Tov vofiov evyjpyeiTO ev To7g ft.e\eatv fjfxZv' Kat dft.apTia
" vfi.'2v ov Kvpievcrei' ov yap eaTe vno dx\ vno
vofiov, ydptv'^ lo
Katf " ov yap ovk eoTt vofkog^ ov%\ TTapd(3a(Ttg'" Kai^ " 6 vofkog
" 06 TrapetTvjXdev, iva irXeovdafi to TtapdiiTOOfj.a.^* Ka\ *'
o vofLog
*'
opyffv KaTepyd^erai.^^ enei ovv rayra anavTa eOOKet OtapoXvjv

(pepetv ro) vofLcOf ag ttopBovfi.evog t>;v 6* tovtoov vnovotav, Tt$Yjat

Tifjv avTtdeatVf Kat (pyjot, " /x.7; yevotTO'" -npo Trfg KaTaoKevyjg \$
aTiYiyopevae tov aKpoaTvjv oiKetovfj.evog, Kat tov <TKavtaXt^ofj.evov

depairevuv' Xotirov yap aKovaag Kat VTrep riqg ^taOeaeag avTov

TrXyjpocpoprfietgy ^i^Ter jU,fT avTov to ^okovv etvat aTropoV Kat ojJj^

VTroTrTevet rov Xeyovra' ^io Kat tt^v dvTtSeatVf itpoaXa^wv eKeTvov

TeQetKeV ov yap eiire' Tt ovv et7rotfi.t dv ; dXXd " Tt ovv epovff.ev ;" 20
wg ^ovX^g Kat yvafj.fjg TrpoKetu.evy]g' Kai eKKXrjatag KotvYji avy-
KeKpoTy]fx.evy]i' Kat ov irap avrov^ dXXd irapd TYjg twv eipYifxevctiv

aKoXovQiag, Kat TYjg txv irpayf/.dT^cv dXyiSeiagj TYjg dvTtSeaecog

(f)avetcrY]g.

Ot/ ft.ev yap ro ypdft,ft.a diroKTtTvat ^vvaTat, ovheig dvTepeX, 25

(f)y}at. Kat OTt to Trvevfj.a ^woTro/e?', Kat tovto tvfXov. Kat ovheig

dv (jitXovetKi^aeiev. ei Totvvv TovTa <aft.oXoyyjft.eva, Tt dv enroifj.ev

Y a
164 SUPPLEMENTUM VII. 7.

Trep/ rov vofxov ; on afxapria ;

[xvj yevoiTo' Xvaov ovv tyjv airo-

piav. didfi TTcoj fji($ cavToy tov dvTi^iKov KXTrjcri, Kai to tov

dt^daKovTog d^icofxa XajScov tTr) tyiv Kvaiv ep^^^^Tai ; Tig ovv yj

Xvaig ; dfxaprta f/.lv ovk eaTi cfyvjai' " Trjv ^e dfLapTiav ovK
" eyvav, €1 fav] B/a vs/xoy." opa ao(f)iag eTrnaaiv. OTiep ydp ovk 5

eaTiv vofLog, e^ dvTtOeaeccg TedtiKev, iva dvaipuiv tovto, Kai TavTYj

')(^api^Ofi.evoi; Ta lov^aic», icetarj to ekarTOv avTOv KaTa^e^aaSat.

t/ eaTi To e\aTTOv ;
" OTt ttjv dfxapTiav ovk eyvav, el fL^ ^ia

VOfXOV.

ToT 0EOAOPHTOT. YloXkd ydo ftpYjKwg dvwTepco, Tov vofxQv 10

KadaTfTOfneva, Kai Ttooopchv ag "TrvevfxaTtKVjg ydpiTog Yj^tcofxevog, OTi

tS)v aipeTiKav Tiveg elg KaTYjyopiav TavTa TY)g Ttakatdg XYjxpovTai

diaO-^kyjg, Kai vofxtovatv dXkov Ttvog etvai 0eov tov vofxov tov

•naXaiov, avayKaiwg Kai Tag avTtOeaetg TtSvjat' Kat enKpepet Tag

Xvaeig. Kai •npSoTov fxev, /3\da(pi^fA.ov edei^e tyjv epcjOTYjatv, tov '5

dTiayopevTtKOv Xoyov TeSetKOog' " /x^ yevotro." eha ^t^daKet TOt>

vofLov TO y^pYjatfKoV ov fiovov ydp (f)r/aiv ovk eaTtv vofxog dfxap-

Tiag tt^aKTiKog' dXXd Kat to evavTiov, dfxapTtag KaTYfyopog' ov

ydp dv eyvctiv, t/ to kukov, ei fXYj voy.og e^t^a^ev.

Sethpianot. Ovk eiTtev ovk f7rotY]aa' aXX " ovk eyvcav.^ 20

ioaTe ov Tov itotelv, dXXd tov ^taytvooaKetv tyjv dfxapTiav, 6 vofnog

atTtog' "JTai^evTtKog ovv vofiog' fXY) avyywpm "^ta tyj( ayvoiag

eig TYjv tS>v aXoy-jov eKTnnTetv (pvatV eKe7vo fnevTOt ^rjTi^Teov, t£c
evTav6a eiTrcbv, " tyjv dft.apTiav ovk yj^eiv, et fjiYj ^ia vofii.ov," ev

eTepotg ^etKvvatv, oti eyofxev ev eavTo^ig tg ^taKpiTtKOv, ev oig 25

(pYjai' " OTav yap e6vYj Ta fLYj vofj.ov eyovTa, (fyvaet Ta toD vofxov
" "noirj'" TtapiaTYjai ydp ^ia tovtcov OTt Kat dvev vofxov evrfv avvo-

pdv Ta OeovTa. XiKTeov Ve OTt ei Kat evYjv, dXX ov TidvTa' ovtco

ye Kat vvv eTt evia Ttap aXXotg e6veatv cog KaXd Kai evvofxa noXi-

TeveTat' nap aXXoig Oe uig dvofxa Kat KaKag eyovTa eK(3dXXeTai' ^o

^to Oy] dvayKata tov vofLov yj ^oatg' ^topi^ovaa vju.7v Ta Te

TTpaKTea Kai Ta fji^' Kat ^iap6povaa Kai (pcori^ovaa tov ttKaiov

TYjV TToXtTetav.

Ktpiaaot. A6pei iv] oirctig ao(f)Sog Tovg eV) tco vofico TtoteiTat

Xoyovg. e(f>r) fxa yap, OTt " oVc rffKev cv tyj aapKi, toc TraSiJjtAaTa 35
VII. 7- E COD. MONACENSI. 165

" Twv afJMprtav To, ^<a tov vofxov (vi^pyeiTo (v Toii fJieXeatv vjixcov'

aTT-^XXaKTO S' av ov^aixSii vTTcipiag 6 Xoyog' «pyj yap av t/j irpof

TOVTa fv6vs' (3pa(3€VTyjg ovv apa Ka) eiarjyrjTyji Tijg dfxapTiag 6

vofxog. €1 ydp eaTiv aAvjfle,' «j evepyeirat ^i avTov ev yjiuv Ta

irad-^fiaTa T^f aapKog, irag ovk av vooito Kai dfxapTtag yeveatg ; 5

t/ ovv 6 fj.v(XTaywyog ; ^ptfxvg aTiavToi' Kat diio^pdaKei /xev, oti

ov naTVjp dfj.apTiag 6 voixog' aiTtaTat Ve tyjv dvQpwTiov <f>v(Tiv ug

daSevYi fxdXXov, Kai S/ avTOv TraOovaav to evaXavat 'htKaig. TavTVj

Tot (pYjaiv. " Tt ovv epovfi.ev ; 6 vofxog dfxapTia ; fxr, yevoiTo. aXXa
**
TYjv dfxapTiav ovk eyvxv, ei fxyj ^ta vofxov." opa Totvvv OTt ovk lo

eine t^v dixapTtav ovk etypv et fxv} '^ta vofxov aXX OTt fxvj eyvwv

fxdXXov avTyjv' oiiKovv ov npocpaaig dfxapTta; 6 vofxog' TrapaoeiKTi-

KOg te fxdXXov avTvig. ToTg ovk et^OTtv avTvjv efxcpavr) KaBtaTag'

ovy tva fxaBovTeg epydaotVTo' e"i ye Kat nptv ei^evat ndvTag nov

Kot e^pctiv. " ov ydp yjv ^Uatog ov^^e eig" KUTa ty^v toD y^^dXXovTog j^

(pcov^v. dXX' tva to dttKovv eltoTeg, npog Ta dfxetvu) fxeTay^w-

p-^aetav.

Kai fxot ^oKei yeveaOai Tt TotovTov ToTg dpyaioTepotg S<a tov

^aaewg evToXrjg. vTTOKetaBco tw Xoyu) nXaTeTa Ttg otixog' anoKO-

fxi^ovad Ttoi' Kat ^tepptcpBo} fxev ev avTyj TroXXyj Qia fxeaov yep- 20

fxdg' opwpvyBm Ve ei 'boKeT Kai (3o6poi. ehd nveg eaTwaav ot ev

vvKTt Kat aKOTO} ^a^i^ovTeg ev avTy^' ireptnTaiovTeg Te Kat fxaXa

avxyHog ToTg ^ia fxeaov Ketfxevotg' Kai fxyjv ^oBpotg a(3ovXyjTa}g

eyKaBtefxevot. eyovTog ^e coSe rov npdyfxaTog. ^a^a Ttg Aa/3a)v,

(TT avTaTg eaTi^ae TaTg Tpto^otg' efxcpaviq KaBtaTag ToTg tovat Ta 25
fxeTa^v' ov)(^ tva ndXtv avToTg TreptTTTatuatVf aXX iva anaXXaT-
TotvTO Tov KaKov. dp ovv Yj^iKyjae to (pag, OTt napedtt^e to Xv-

novv ; Y} fxdXXov eKeTvo (pafxev xg nXeiaTY^v oay(v avToTg evenoiet

T^v ovYjaiv ; dne^eXet te Kai da^paXearepovg ; aXX oTfxai tovto

eaTiv ov^evt tcSv ovt<ov davfxcpaveg. ot€ TOivyv ovTef dfxapTwXot' 3°

nXeiaTOtg Te oaoig lyKXyjfxaat neptnTatovTeg, eyvtOKafxev Qta tov

vofxov TYjV dfxapTtav. ov^ dfxapTia fxdXXov vofxog vooTt dv

eiKOTwg vj XeyotTQ' noXXov ye Kai SeT. napaoeiKTiKog Qe fxdXXov

T^f dfxapTiag, ag e<pYjv.

 166 SUPPLEMENTUM VII. 8.

4>CTiOT. OvK etTie Jf, t/ ovv vojxog a7rc5av€v, r] KaTfjpyrjTai ;

TOVTo yap efBovXero' a\\ onep /ix^ Se a:;T^ eWf/. ri ovv (f>y)aiv,

*'
vofxoi afxapria ;" §/o eTrayei, " /*>; yevono'" ocfxa KaKeivof (sic)

Aea/vcyv «-at Ta at/Toy ouk avaipav. ov yap el /x^ c<rT/v afJiapTia,

vj^rj Kai ovK txTreQavev, ^ ov KaT-^pyr]Tat' OTrep avrog Kai e^eiKvv 5

Kat e(3ov\eTo.

Tr)v T€ yap imOvfxiai' ovk ySeiif, cl fxr) 6 uofio^ ovk

S i7n$Vfxr]a€Ls ekeyev d(J)opjxrji/ 8e Ka^ovaa t) dfxapTia

Sia Trj^ evToArjS) KaTeipyaaaTO ev efxol irdxrav eTriOv-
°
fxiav. '

TOT XpTSOSTOMOT. *Opag OTtag KaTO. fXtKpOV OV^/l fXOVOV KaT-t}'

yopov Tov vofxov tetKvvat r^? dfxapTia^f aXX' yjpefxa Kat Kara-
<7Keva(TTiK0v ; ov fxv}v irapa ttjv atTiav t>jv az;Tov, aAAa iiapa TVfV

rav dyvoifxovm 'lov^aiwv, aTrofpaivei tovto avfxPatvov' Kai yap

Kat Mav/j^a/wv eajiov^aKev efx(ppd^at to. cTTO^/xaTa, tojv KaTr^yo- 15

povvT<i)v Toy vofnov' 'hto mriyayev' " dcpopfLTjv Se ka^ovaa rj

** avTrjv dir-^Wa^ev eyKkri-

dfxapTia tia rvji evToX^^'." eiheg itoiig

fxaTm ; oy dfKapTta (j)r]<Ti, oyj^ vofxog rjv^rjae tojv eiiiQvfxiav. Kat

rovvavTiov ointep efSovXeTO vofxog 'yeyoveV o^^ep aaSeveiag rjv, ov

vovrjpiag' otov ydp Tivog entQvfxwfxev, eha KU}\vcofi.e6a, aiptTat 20

fxaWov T^i entQvfXtag rj (f^Xo^. aKK ov Tiapd tov vofxov touto*

aiiTog fLev ydp eaTTov^a^ev wf tc dnayayeiv' rj ^e dfJLapTia^ tout-

eartVf rj paQvfxta rj cry], Kat r] yvafxrj rj Trovrjpa, tco KaK^ Tipog to

evavTtov ey^prffraTo. aXK ov tov tarpov to eyKkrjfxa' dWa rov

dppwcTTOvvTcg' Tw (papfLaKO} KaKwg -^(jnfcrafi.evov. ov ydp ^td toDto 25

etoQr] vofxog^ tva avdxpv] Tr]v e7r<fly/A<av, dXK iva alSeav]. rovvav-

riov Se e^e(3r]. aXK ovk eKeivov, aXX r]fi.u)v rj KaTvjyopia' ov^e

ydp et rtg rw TtvperTovri Kat ^v^^oTtoa tag aKaipag eTrtQvfxovvrt'

fxY] Tcapaayoiv eft.(prjprfirjvai rrjg ckedpiag ravrrjg rj^ov^g av^^^aete

rr]V eittBvfKiav, lyKaXotr av ^tKaiag. rov ydp larpov^ ro Kmkvaat ^o

rjv fxovov, ro Ve dnoayeaQai, rov KafxvovTOi. ri ydp el rj dfi.apria

e^ afTou rr(v a^popfkiqv eXaj^ev ; e^ dyaQm yap eTTtTayfxdrm tioX-

Xot rm TTovrjpm rrjv eavrm Trovrjpiav av^ovatv. evrei Kai hd(3o-
VII. 8. E COD. MONACENSI. 167

A&f ct/TO) rov lovtay aTrcoXecrtv' eii (piXoyjiyjfjiaTiav e/x/SaAwv, koi

KXeirretv ra rav irevyjTav Trof^aaf, aAA' ov to TTKJTevQ^vai to

yX(i}Ci(70KOf/.ov avTOVy rovro eipydaaroy aAA y) rvj^ yva>fjt.v)^ itovifj-

pia. Kai Yj Efa Ve rcv A^aft. d-no rov ^vXov irapaaKevdaacTa

(f>ayeiVj e^e^aXev aTio rov Trapo^eiaov. aAA' ov^e eKe) ro Mvhpov 5

aiTiov. el Kai ti avrov rj d(f)opfxr] yeyovev.

E/ fle Kai <x(poopoTepov Ke^^^pvjrai rw Xoyoj tco TTept rov vofi,ov,

ft.Yi Oavfi.daYii' Tipog yap ro KareTtelyov o WoijvXoq laraTat. ovk

a(j)ietg fKev ovhe ro7g dXkfjig vnoTtrevovcrt ra Xeyofieva, Xa(3rjv

iiapaayeh. TioXXrjV ^e iJTtovVfjv 7rotovfi.evogy ro napov ItopBcoaat, lo

fLrj roivw yvfKvd e^era^e ra evravQa Xeyofxeva, dXXa Kat rrjv VTto-

Qecrtv TtpoartQet ti' r^v ravra etiteh Ttpoadyerat' Kat rrjv fixiviav

Xoyt^ov rrjv lov^atK-^V Kai rrjv evrovov avrwv (f)tXovetKtav' y]v

KaraXvaai aitevtaiv, ^oKeT itoXvg KaTa rov vofi.ov TtveTv ovy^ tva

eKeivov ^taPdX.Xr}f dXX tva tovtcov eKXvcrr] rov rovov. et ydp 15

eyKXrjfJia rov vofLov ro ^t avrov rrjv dfkapriav d(f)opfi^v Xa^eh^y

evpeSyja-erat Kat ev rrj Kaiv^ rovro <7Vfi.j3aivov, Kai yap Kai ev rrj

Katvri vofuoi fj.vpioi' Kat Ttept 7toXX£ fi.et^ovcov Ttpayfi.drci)v. Kat

rovTo ihot rtg av eK^ahov KaKeT' ovk eitt r^g e-JttQvfjt.iag fLovoV

dXX e-Tt) Ttdcyjg ditXag KaKiag' " et yap fxr] rjXQoVf'^ i^fjo^h
*'
f(ai 20
*'
eXdXiqaa avroTg, dfi.aprtav ovk eiy^ovT ovkovv evrev^ev r] dfiap'

ria rriv vitoOeaiv eXa^e, Kot rj fjiei^cov KoXaatg. Kat TtdXtv itepi

r^g ydpirog YlavXog ^iaXeyofnevogy (f)r]atv. " Ttoao) ^oKeTre yet-

" povog d^icoQ^aerat rtfJi.(>}piag, rov Ttov rov Seov Karaitarr]-
" aag ;" ovkovv Ka\ rj '/etpwv rtfj.wpta t*jv d(f)opfxy]v evrevSev eyet 25
aTto rr]g fj.ei^ovog evepyeatag. Kai rovg '
KXXi^vag oe Otd rovro

(pyjatv dva7toXoyr]Tovg elvai. ort Kai Xoyw rtfLrfievreg., Kat rrjg

KTiaecog Karaft.a6ovTeg ro KdXXog, Kai d-t avrrjg Ovvdfxevot itpog

rov dv]fJi.tovpyov yetpaycayrjO^vaif rrj ao(f)ia, rov Qeov qvk etg ^eov

eyj)r]aavTo. 30
Opdg Ttavrayov roTg itovf]poTg rag d(f>opfj.ag rov fiet^ovcog ko-

Xd^eaSai dtto twv dyaSiav ytvofievag •npayfj.drwv ; aAA ov ^^Ttov

* Cod. >.a.3riv, sed in mar^. Xa$(7v a. m. rec.

 o
5

168 SUPPLEMENTUM VII. 8.

^ia TOVTO KaTvjyop^^aoixev Tav evepyfcriav tov 0eoi/. aXKa TavTag

fX€v GavfxaaofMsSa fxei^ovag' Kai fxeTa TavTa, tt^v ^e yviofxrjv twv

€/f TavavTia toT^ ayadoig Keyjififxevwv^ tia^akovfi.ev' tovto toivvv

Kai eTTi Tov vofLov Ttoi(afxev. aXXa tovto fxev pd^tov Kai evKaXov.
'*
TO ^e aTiopoVf €Ke7vo ecTi. Tra^ <pv}(7iv tvjv eTridvfnav ovk vj^eiv, 5
" ei fXYj 6 vofxog ekeyev, ovk e7ridvf>.vj<xei(;." ei yap ovk vj^ei tyjv

eTTiGvfKiav Tipiv Yj Aa^eh tov vofxov o avQpcoTTo^f iroSev o KUTa-

KXvQfxo^ ye^yoi/e ; "noBev to, Y^otofKa eve-npyjBYj ; ti ovv (f^r^ai ; t^v

eTtneTafxevyiv e7nBvf),iav' tia tovto ovk elite KaTeipyd<jaTo ev eixoi

eiriBvfxiaVf dXXa *'

Tracxav e7n6vu.iav" to a^(po^pov evTavOa atviT- i

TO/x.evof.

WEOAaPHTOT. ri TO, ovK TjOeiv Kai ovK eyvm^ ov T^^g

TiavTeXovg dyvotag evTavBa ^/jXctiTtKd' dkXd tovto \eyet, oti

aKpt(5e<7Tepav T^g (f)vatKy^g ^iaKpiaea^g ehe^dfxvjv yvoiaiv ^id tov

vofXoV vj ie irpoaSvjKV] tov " d(f}opfii.Yjv XafSovaa yj dfiapTia ^id 1

" f-^i evToXvjg Trdaav eiri6vfi.tav ev eft.ot KaTetpyaaaTO^^ tetKvvat

Tov vofxov Trfg KaTYjyoptag eKevSepov. eTrei^vj ydp etirev ort yiv^yjQr)

Ta df/LapTVjfxaTa t^ Seaei tov vofxov, tva ^a^ Ttg VTroXdj3y] tov

vofxov atTtov yeytvyiaSat, dvayKaicog VTro^etKvvat tov TpoiroV oti

npo(f>aatv ^tafKd-)(y]g yj dfiapTta ty/v vofxoSeaiav Xa/Sovaaf tov da6e- 20

veaTepov KaTeTponaaaTO Xoyiafiov.
j
Fennaaiot. MeTpovaYjg ydp fxot t^j evToXYjg ti^v eyKetfKevvjv

eTrtSvf/iiav tyi <j)vaei' Kai tyjv y^pyjatv avTYjg dcpeTov ovk eioaYjg,

aX\ opoig TaKToig avTYjv Treptypacpovayjg t€ Kat TreptXafx^avov-

»/5/
cvfg,

<<7^i/o$-
vj dfxapTta

evTropvjaaaa
ka^ovaa
\>
TavTvj
/
dt avTvjg
~/
Kat eTrtKovpiag, etTa f^e Trpog afxeTpiav viro-
d<f)opft.v]Vf
\ r
T0VTeaTtV2i
/<
aKektaaaa, evepyov etg dfxapTiav fnot irdaav eTrtOvfLtav aireipi^fxe-

VYjv KaTeaTYjae. tw yap " KaTeipydaaTO ev efxot Trdaav emSv-

" fxtav^^ evSe?, to, dTrY]yopevfi.evv]v.

ToT Xptsostomot. Kai ti tov voff.ov to Kep^^og, el to TrdSog %o

vjv^rjae (pv]atv ; ovVev, akXd Kat iroXv to (3XdPog. dXX^ ov tov

vofxov TO eyKXvjfxa. dXXa Tvjg paSvf^tag tocv li^afi.evcov. yj ydo

dfxapTta avTO KoretpydaaTO. aXXd tid toD vofKov. dXX' ov tovto
T&y vofxov anovod^ovTog, aXXa Kat ro evavTiov. layvpoiepa ovv
VII. 8. E COD. MONACENSI. 169

yeyove^ (pvjo-iv, yj afxapTia ; Ka} a-(f)odpa' aW ov Se tovtq

eyKKy}f/.a tqv vofxov TraKiv, aXka Tyjg eKeivasv ayvcjoixoavwj^.

Eethpianot. E/ Se /SovXeiy afxapTtav w^e vot^a-ov, tov %ia^Q-

Kov. coaTrep yap tov HwT^pa ^wvjv 07 ypacpy} KaXei, Kai ^iKatoav-

vT^v, Ta) ^oj^f Kai "^tKatoavvrig aiTtov eivai' qvtw Kat ry/v havTiav 5
Ovvafj.iv Ik Tvjf oiKeia^ evepyeiag, TioTe /Aev, aft.apTiav, irore Be

xi^evhog Kai aOavaTov^ KaXel. ovT(i> Ka) ev tq7<; e^vj^ eiTiwv " vj

" dfJiapTta dve^vjae,^^ tov ^id{3okov KakeT. Xontov ovv ^ia t^^
evToX^g df/yopfivjv tid^oXoc; eka^ev. oti to. iiapayyeKfiMTa tov
vofjLov wj vKvjv Tiva tvj; eavTov Teyyvji •notviadfi.evog' elg to evav- 10

T/6V xaTg evToXaT^, TiepieTpeTre tov dvBpaTtov. laTeov fxevToi oti h

eavTov 6 AitoaToXog to koivov triXol.

Ktpiaaot. Ka< TO Tvji ^fneTepag (pvaewg d^paveg iiapetadyei.

OTi ^o6eig 6 vofJ.og eig ovvjatv, eite^ovkevaev d^oK-^TCog. ag koi Toig

TOv 0(f)BaXfx.ov aaBevovai tov rjkiov to (pug. OTav ovv kfyvj, d(f>op- 15

fJLVjv Taig eTTiBvfxtatg Tpoitov Tiva tvjv fvroA^v yeyev^aOai, fj.vj^etg

KaTVjyopeTv avTOV oteaQco tou vofAov' akka KaTaKeKpayevai fkdkkov

Tyjg ev vjfuv daSevetag. avB av eyjtvjv dvaKOTtTeaBai ^ia Toy vofxov,

Qta TovTCtiv etg Ta '/eipca TtapaTpvvofxevovg. vj ydp dvBpuiTtov ^id-

voia TO (f)tkoKaivov aei vpog eitiBvfj.iag voael. Kai f$.ev itotSiv Tag 20
eittBvfxiag, »$• 0eAe/ f^, dvevo^^^^kvjTog av. Se dvaKOTtTm avTag,
dypicoTepav eta^e^^^^eTai tvjv tcSv itaBchv e(po^ov. Kai twv fxev itpo-

Xeipcov ov^etg eitiBvfxeT' wv Se KcvkveTai Tig eTtiBvfxeT. oBev tou

vofXQV KcakvaavTog to BkditTov, yeyovev dtpopfxv} Tolg daBeveaTe-

poig, Tov Ttkeov avTov eTtiBvfxeh. 25

©EOAOPOT MoNAXOT. Ta^^a Se Kai eig Ta KaTa rov Pi^dfJ.

ctig ev VTto^^etyfxaTog koya entoi rtg dva(f)epeaBai to itpoKetfxevov.

eTtei KdKeivog itpoKeifi.evccv avTco, (fjvTcav d^eag ditdvTcev fxerakafx-

I3dvetv vj^vvaTo, el f/.v} vofxog avTa itepi ditoyvjg ervye "^oBeig. Kai

ovK v]v dfxdpTVjfxa, to fxeTa twv koiirm, KaKeivov (payeTv. eTtei^vj^o

^e evTokvjv e^e^aTo ditoayfeaBat tov (f)VTQv TVjg /Spctiaecog, eittBvfxia

fxev Ttg ev^v ayrd? TVjg fxeTakvj\peci}g cog etKog tou Kapitov. eKcakveTo

^ Leg. flavaTov.

z
170 SUPPLEMENTUM VII. 8.

Se V710 T^f evToX^s. afxdpTV}fj.a dvai to (f>ayuv rav anaycipev^ev-

TieVf vjyovfjLevoi. evTev&ev yj afxapTia napo^ov eaye. TVji fnev cvto-
Xyji; e7re-)(ovavjg tvjv ISpaaiv' tov ^e A^afn ov irpog Trjv a^ioni-

CTiav avTTjg ^ovXfiBevTog t^eiv, dWa tov eTn^ovkov TTiaraQevTO';

To7$ Xoyoig, Kai oKov TYjg eiiiSvfi.iag Toy (f)ayeiv yeyovoTog. Kat 5

ov fxovov acpopfjiy} rrjg e7riOvft.iag evTevOev eytveTo' dkXa KdKe7vo

efKaGofKev' ug ofj^ dirdaatg Ta7g eTitBvft.taig irpocy^Kev eneaOai

vjfj-dg. ^oKiuid^ovTag Se d ')(^pri 'iroieTVf twv eTepav aTie^^eaBat' otg

ovK efJ.fJ.evovTeg, ^^Ao/ ndvTag eafxev dfj.apTdvovTeg. coaT6 ov KaT

eKeho fxovov yj dfnapTta t^v ndpotov ccrj^e ^ia t^^ €VToX^f, KaBo lo

TOu (JJVTOV fJ.€T€tXi^(l)etft,ev. aXXa yap Kai oti fj.y}

iraaatg eneaBai

TaHg eTTtOvff.iaig fxaSovTeg, vjfj.dpTOfj.ev diidaag irapa to oeov ttXyi-

*'
povv eTtetyofj.evoi. tovto Tap Xeyet, tc, KaretpydaaTO ev efxot

" Tida-av e7rt6vfi.tav." dvTt Toy TravTOj dft.apTrift.aTog ano Tivog

€7itBvfj.tag TtKTOfKevov, evrevQev vj dpyvj yeyovev ^fj.iv. «tc S^ "^Vi^o

^taKpiaecog rdg d(f)opfi.di he^aft.evoig evTevSev' ovtw Kat ev Toig

dvoDTepotg' tw, " rvjv e7n6vft.iav ovk rj^etVj et

fj.y}
6 voft-og eXeyev
*'
ovK €71 t6vft.'^aeii" avTt tov, ovk dv vj^eiv ei fj.vj o vofi.og vjv 6

rovTO ^iopt^uv, ag ov hei Tt iroieTv tcov ev €7it6vft.ta K€tfi.evm. Kat

yap To *'
ev efi.oi^' ore Xeyet, to Kotvov Xeyet rav avdpco^rcov' Kat 20

ToTi Tov A^a/x etg d^rodei^iv Ke^^^jpvjTai tsJv KOtvwv.

Xft)/ots' yap vo/jLOV a/iapTLa veKpa.

Xpt202t6mot. Tot^Teo-T<v, ovy^ ovTco yvct}pifj.og. vj^eaav fj.€V

ydp Kat ot Trpo tov vofj.oVy ort vjfj.dpTavov. dKpt^earepov Se €fj.a6ov

fj.€Ta Tvjv Tov voft.ov ^oatv. ^id TOVTO Kat ft.€t^ovog vjaav KaTviyo- 25

ptag v7r€v6vvot. ovOe ydp vjv laov, (pvatv e^^etv KaTr]yopov. Kat

/xeTa Tr]g <pva€Ct)g Kai tov voft.ov (pavepag ^iayopevovTa airavTa.

fsiACPOT. OvKovv TovTo atviTTtTai' OTt ovK i^^eaav dfj.apTd-

vovTeg. €7Tei aXoycog evpe^eTev dv KoXaa6evTeg, 01 irpo tov voftLov'

ot fj.€V yap, voaTog, 01 he, Trvpog epyov eyevovTo' dXX^ OTt 'jy^ecrav^o

^ev, ov^f^ ovTO) ^e dKpt^cog. ^to eKoXd^ovTo ft.ev, ovj^ ovtco ^e

a^po^pSig.

Ktpiaaot. H Kat d^rXwg' ei fj.vj KeotTo, (prjatVj 6 tSov Tvjg

(pavXoTVjTog rpowcov KaTVjyopwv vofj.og, d^paveg dv yevotTO to KaKOv,

 VII. 12. E COD. MONACENSI. 171

KaTepeOi^erat yap fx.(/vovovyj. vpof ?o"5^vv, ^ta tov vofxov. Kai padv-

[xoTepov /xev Tiat to t^^ vj^ov-iji eyKeiaeTat KevTpov, eitiTifj.SiVTog

avTcov fjiVj^evoi. fx.ovovovy\ Ka) airafji(3XvveTai tw t^« e^ovcriag

•nXaTet yoYjTevofLevov' ov yap oXcag to ovTtaTaTOvv ov^ev, eKe7 iiov

TravTOJc apyel Kat to <f>iXovetKov. veKpa Toiyapovv yj afLapTta, vofnov 5

TO irpaKTeov fni^ OtayopevovTo^.

©EOAflPHTOT. Kai fJiyj OVTOi TOV TO TTpaKTeoV VTIO^etKVVOVTOg.

Kai TO ov TipaKTeov aTiayopevovTog, ovk eyet yjapav vj afi.apTia.

Sethpianot. Oti fKri Ve ^vvaTai KaTaKpivai tov ev ayvoia

yjfxapTi^KOTa. o ^e vofxog toSt)^, koi Se/^a^ t^v afiapTtav, tvvafi.tv lo

oeoaKe t^ aixapTia' tovto §6, ov rov vofx.ov KaTfffopia' aXXa T^f

TCDv fj.ri (pvXaTTOvTccv avTOv oXiyapiag eXeyyoi aaitep oe yjiopig

vofjiov afj.apTta veKpa, ovto) Kat (pvXaTTOfLevov tov vofJiov, tj afi.ap-

Tia veKpa.

rENNAAioT. T^v yap Tipa^tv vofjiog aTiayopevwv^ afxdpTooXov ^5

(Tvvta-Tifjaiv' wg eav ju.*j tovtov ft,ot npoTiapvjyyeXKOTOs tvjv avT^g

aTioyvjv, eiiiTeTrj^evKcbg viiyjpyov avTvjv, ovk av vjv evoypg irXvjfji-

f).eXvjft.aTt' " ov yap ovk CTt voft.og, ovhe napd^aaig'^ ov yap

eXXoyehat dfnapTia, fjiVj ovTog vofJiov. to oi/v " Xft>/«f vofjiov vj

" dfLapTta veKpd'" dvTt tci^, ovk av evepyvjOeiy], (f^yjo-t, du.dp- 20

TVjfKa, ft.v] voft.(c ^tci}pt<jft.evov' ^ia ti ; OTt ovy rj Tipa^tg dfi.dpTV]ft.a

aTiXciog. dXXa to et^OTa ojv §6? aneyecrBai, iiotetv ti itapa Ta

eyvcc(7fiieva KaXcog eyetv.

9 'Eyw Se e^cov xoipi9 vofxov Trore' iXOovarjs^ Se T7J9

io€UtoXt]9, rj fxev aixapria dve^rjaev, iyco Se aTreOavoV Kalt^

evpeOrj fJLoi rj ivToXr) rj ety ^(orjv, avTrj elf OavaTov.
iiT^ yap apapTia d^opp.r]v Xa^ovaa Sia r^? ivToXrjf,

i2i^rpr(iTr]ae fxe kcll 8l avTrjs direKTeLvev . coaTe 6 fxev

V0fX09 ayL09, Kal r) ivToXrj ayLa kolI ^LKaLa /cat dyaOrj,

Ktpiaaot. 'E^7j«-€va/ jaev (f>vjatv 6 fxvdTaycoyog, yaptg vofjiov ^o

?r6T€' e<Ta t^^- evToA^f eXOovarjg, dva(3twvat fJLev rrfv dfJiapTtav

reOvdvat ye fjiVjv eaviov tiiayvpt^eTo' Kat ayrjfi.aTi^et fnev ev

rovToig e(f) eavrw rov Xoyov. oifxai te eyccye toiovtov ti j3ov-

z 2
172 SUPPLEMENTUM VII. la.

\iV€Gdai ^rjKovv avTOv. vtto ^iki^v fjiev yap Ofj.oKoyovfj.ivoof €(tti

Kai TO (V ayvota TrXvjfXfxeXe^v. faTai ^e oti (fiopTiKWTepa Torf

ei^oaiv yj Kokaaiqy ire^TrkYjpocjiopi^Ktv o "Emrjp Xeycov' " o el^ug to

" 6eXv]fxa Tov Kvpiov avTov, Kai fxvj Troivjdai, ^apvjaeTat TroXkdg.

" Se ft,y] e<'Sct)f, Kai ju.ij irotvjaaiy ^apvjo-eTai oKiyag." ovkovv, afiiei- 5

vov 6fxo\oyovft.ev(cg to ev ayvoia 7rk-/][XfxeX€iv, vj to ev el^vjaei

voam.
E/ Ve ^vj T/f -ye^yovev vtto vofxoV tvjv e|a> vofxov iroTe ^ia^^^aaf

^wvjv' eha twv TeQeaTricrfxevuv d(f)ei^e7v ^pvjfxevog, vjXco ypa<f)V]v

dfxapTiai, Kai veiTTaKev viro ^iKVfV tot€ Viq Tore TaHg eavTov 'o

paGvfxiaii eTTiaTvyvdaag r^f dKpi(3eiag tov vofxov, fxovovovj^^t Kai

'*
KaTaKeKpd^eTat Xeyav, eya ^e e^wv yjapig vofxov ircTe. eXBovav^g

6e TV\q evToKv]q, V] afxapTia avegvjaev eyw Ce aireaavov ei yap

**
eaTiv dXy]6ccg df/.apTia veKpd %(»}ptg vofxov," irag ov TriBavov

^mTrotelaQai Tpoirov Tivd 'htd tov vofxov t^v dfxapTiav, evvoeiV «5

ToD Kai €fX(f)avv] KaSiaTaVTog avTV]v, Kat oiov, efXTrvovv eniTeXovv-

Tog ',
Kanoi vrdXat fxvj eyvaafxevi^v, et Kat vjv. ovy^ ^i"''^'»
Of 7«)"

T^jotev ^iKaioi. ooarrep ^e veKpdg o'vav]g TVjg dfxapTiag' '^td toi to

fxv] eivat Tvyov tov KaTa^tKa^ovTa vofxov, e^Wfxev v]fxeTg, TV]g

dyvoiag ty]v jrapaiTV]aiv evdcpopfxov e^/pvTeg. " ov yap ovk eaTt 20

" vofxog, ovSe irapd^aatg," KaQd (pvjat avTog. ovtcc Trape\6ovav]i

TYjg evToXv]g elg fxeaov, dve^ica fxev wairep v] dfxapTta' KaTepe6ia6v]

^c 6 BdvaTog' Ka) dpd Kai '^ikv] tS)V Talg 7rapa(3daeaiv virofrt-

TTTOvTajv e^ daBevetag' Kat Tt to €VTev6ev ; TreirpaKTat Tt twv

eXirihog e^o) Kai o^ok-^tcov €(p vjfxh' evpvjTat ydp, (pv]at, v] ev- 25

ToA^ V] do6e7aa irpog ^wv]v avTV] etg BdvaTov. caairep yap KaTa-
aiV€Tai TTCcg t^s" v]KtaKYjg dKThog to (f)S)g Toiig oiirep dv eiev tv]v

o\l/iv v]ppcoaTV]KOTeg, Kat toi 7re(f)VK0g elvai yXvKv Kai TptTtoBy]-

Tov. Kat ovK avTO TrdvTCog eaTi to dotKovv' vooIto ^e fxdWov TVjg

Twv 'TreirovBoTcav dppcoaTiag €yKXv]fia, to aOiKe7a6ai vrap avTov' 30

KaTa Tov taov oifxai Tpoirov 7rpo(paatv Oeooa6at t^ dfxapTta (f^vjat

T*;v cvToA^^v. e^YiiraTVfaBai tc S<' avTVjg' KaTaKOfXtadvjvat t€ Kat

€tg 6dvaTov. (f^aiv] H" dv Ttg Kai erepag, oti ^v] a(f>o^pa (f)iXe7 Ta7g

Tov vofxov ^ovkaig aei Trcag fxdyea^at to (f)ikv]^ovoV Kat 01 TVjg

VII. 12. E COD. MONACENSI. 173

(pavXorrixog rpoTroi raig eTrieiKeiaig dvaKoirTOfxevoi, yevviKOiTepov

avTe^ayovcri' Kai tov vovv eoB ot€ KaraX-i^i^ovTaiy KaTa<TTpe(f)ov-

Teg eig Trapapacriv, Kai raig eK vofJLOV iroivaig VTrotpepovTeg. Kai

Toi vofxov eayriKOTeg tov TCoXeixov tijv acf)opfJi.'^v. TavTVj toi (f>i^ai

<jO(pog (wv r\avXog, yjTraTyja-Qai re ^ia rvji evToX^g, Kai 0* avTVJg 5

aTToOaveiv. aiieKTeive yap fxovovovy^i KaraS-^yovaa itpog avTiaTa<Jiv

Tag ev yjfuv TjSovaf, KaTa ye Tovg irpoeipvjfxevovg Tponovg.

Xptsoztomot. Ka) opa irag ^eT^ai aTtov^hal^ei Kai acf) wv

ovK eTroiTjae Pap-^aavra tov vofKOv ttjv avOpcinrivrjv cpvaiv' OTe yap
ywpig vofKov e^ccv (pi^a], ^vjXa^Yj irpo Maxreoj?, ovy ovtco Karebi- io

Ka^ofn.fjv' " eXBovarjg ^e rrjg evToXvjg, vj dfJiapTia dve^vjaeV eyw ^e

'*
direBavovr tovto toKil /xev elvai KaTi^yopla Toy vofxov. ei Oe

Tig dKpi(3wg e^eTaaeie, Kai eyKWfjLiov avTov (fjavelTai ov. ov yap

fj.Yj ovaav vTreaTrjaaTo' aXka KpvTTTOfxevvjV et>eti;ev oirep Kai eirai-

vog eaTi tov vof>.ov' ei ye irpo tovtou fx,ev avtTraia dvjrwg y]ft.ap-i^

TavoV tovtov Se eXBovTog, el Kai /x»j^ev eTepov eKapTrwaaro, tovto

^'
yovv dKpijBag efxaBov oti ^fxapToV oirep ovk av eivj fxiKpov eig

KaKiag d-TraXXay^v. el le fXYj dir-fiXXdy/iaav T^f KaKiag, ovTev

TovTO irpog tov TidvTa virep tovtov iroiyjaavTa vofxov. aXX vj Trdaa

KaTvjyopia TVjg eKeivav yvafxr^g ear}, irap eXirita irdaav oia(f)Ga- 20

peiay\g' ov yap KaTa Xoyov viv to yivofxevov to Oia tojv w(peAovv-

Tftjv (3xdirTea6ai. ^io Ka) eXeyev " evpeQvj fxoi vj evToXv} vj etg

" ^cDvjv,eU SdvaTov." ovk eiire yeyove BdvaTog' ovoe ereKe

avTvi

SdvaTov, dXX^ " evpeQv]." to Katvov Kai Trapdoo^ov t^? aTOiriag

ovTdog epfxvivev^av. Kat to irdv eig t>jv eKeivm TreptTpeTrm Ke(f)a- 25

Ai^v. «v ydp Tov aKoirov avT^i eSeA^jf tteh, elg ^ojtjv viye (f)vjatv.

Ka) 'hid TovTo e^oBvj. et ^e Gdvarog evrevQev e^€/3>j, t&jv Xa(3ovTCi>v

TV]v €VToX>jv TO eyKXvjfxa, ov T^g eiri TVfV ^oovjv ayovavjg. aa<pe-

(TTepov Te TovTO Ka) ttd tcov e^vjg eh-^Xcoaev eiTrm, " 17 yap dfxap-
**
Tta d(f)opfxy^v Xa^ovaa B;a TVjg evroXvjg, e^vjirdTVjae fxe, Kat Ot 30
**
avTVjg d^JreKTetvev" el^eg irag iravTayov TVjg dfxapTiag eyeTat.
** aare
Tov vofxov diraXXaTTm KaTfiyoptag ; Oto Kat eirvjyayev,

**
fxev vofxog dyiog' ko) vj evroXy] dyia Kat tiKaia Kat ayaBvf.

c Leg. T^«.
174 SUPPLEMENTUM VII. 12.

Oeoaaphtot. TeQetKe yoiiv to, " evpeSY)''" iva ^ei^rj, aX-

Xov /xey tov tov vofjiov crKOTtov, a.>^Xo Ve to hia ttjv dfJiapTiav

cv[J.I3d^.

Sethpianot. E/ ^e dve^vjaev ^ dfxapTia, ^rjXovoTi e^>7 woTf,

Kai d-no^avovoa dve^vjae' ttotc ovv e^vj ; ore et\y]<pOTa tv]v evTo-S

Xvjv Tov A^aja, Kal el^OTa ttjv 7rapd(3aatv oXeQptag^ vjndTYjo-e Kat

KaTVjycoviaaTO 6 '^id^okog. fj^fj ova^jf ovv fji.eTa^v fxyj re evTokvjg

fj.v} t€ co^ e^ipi^Tat vofxov, eveKpovTO v) dfxapTta t^ twv dfxapTavov-

Tcov dyvaxjta' Ta yap TrXe/aTa yjyvoovv itavTeg. ti ovv ck tovtcov ;

eXvaiTeXei f*.vj '^ovvat tqv vofxov ; dW e^vifxtovvTo 01 fxekXovTeg 10

KaTopBovv' aTOTTOv 8e ^ta Tovg paBvfKovi; Kai (piXvj^ovovg dfxeXeiv

Tov Xoyov TVjs accTvjpiagf Kai tv)v viroSeatv twv aTrov^atav Kai

evapeTm.
Basiaeiot. AvvaTov fxevTOt to, " eXBovavjc; TVjg evTokvjg. vj

**
fXfv dfxaprta dve^vjaev, eyoi Ve «Trefiavov," Kat dXXcag eKXaPetv. 15
«t; yap eitt TVjg irpcoTi^g vjKiKtag ovTej 01 avBpcDTioi, ovTe ev KaKia

eafxev, ovt€ ev apeTvj' aven tteKTog yap vj vjXtKta TVjg e^ecag €Ka-
Tepag. eTrei^av Se Xoyog vjfxSiv avfxiiXfjpcDQvj^ TOTe ytveTat to

yeypafifxevoV " eXBovarjg ^e TVjg evToXijg, vj dfxapTia ave^vjoeV

'*
eyw Se dTreOavov'^^ eirayyeXXovat ydp Xoyiafxot frovvjpoi eK tcov 20

irabm TVjg aapKOg^ Tatg xi^v^aig vjfxccv evTiKTOfxevot. tco ovti yap
eySovaa vj evToXvj. TOVTeaTiv vj ^tdyvcoaig tSov KaXm' eav fxvj

KaTaKpa.TVjavj tov yetpovoc, Xoyiafxov. dXXa '^vyywpvj^vi vno tZv

TraOm e^av^pa7io^ia6^vai tov Xoytafxov, dve^i^ae fxov vj dfxapTta,

dire6ave ^e 6 vovg veKpog yevofxevog Totg Trapa^TrTcofi.aatv. 25

npiTENOTS. A^rag Totyapovv dvBpcoirog ei^v] yjaptg vofxov TroTf,

OTC irat^tov vjv' OTe ovk vjv eTTntfxyjaig. dyvota ydp KoXdaei ovy^
VTroKetTai' Kai iravTt avBpcairw vjXOe 7tot€ vj evToXv]. iroTe, vj ot€

aveirXvjpcoae tov Xoyov, Kai vevorjKe tvjv evToXvjv itpoaTdTTOvaav

fxev ra Toidoe' dirayopevovaav ^e Ta 70/a^e ; «laa ^e tco eXQeiv ^o

TVjv evToXvjv, Kara tov rrpcoTOV avTVjg Kaipov vtptaTaTai vj KaKta.
vj cog UavXog <pvjaiv, ava^yj vj dfxapTia, Tecog ovaa veKpd. eiret

06 fxvj irecpvKev dfxapTia dfxa ^vjv Ka) eaco dv9pco7rog, ^id tovto

eXOovayjg TVjg evToXvjg, vj fxev dfxapTta dva^vj, vj ^e ^pvyjt^ diioGv^-

aKei. KaTa to, " 'i\>vy^'^ dfxapTdvovaa, avrvj Kat aTroQaveiTat'" T035
VII. 13. E COD. MONACENSI. 175

yap " e-yw, eTi tov eo"» avdpayTrov Kai cni ryjv ^t/y(vjv avacpeperai.

vepiiaraTai toivvv to ^(dottoiov ayaBov rj tov vofxcv TrpoaToJ^ii,

fti QavaTov irpocpaaiv' rjg yap avev, tvjv afxapTiav ov^ olov re

afxapTiav eivai, ov^e KaTo^iKa^eiv BavdTo: tov dvOpwirov. ^ia Tav"

TY]^ ^T^ irov Kai TO TVjg novrjpiag eyKXyjfXM Kat to t^^ KoXdcTewg 5

eirtTtixiov avvtaraTat.

©EOACPOT MoNAXOT. Tivei §e TO, •*

eya e^cov ywp^i vofxov
" TTOTe,'' Kat Tot e^rjiy Ttepi toi) A^^afx Xeyeiv (paat tov ATioaTO-

\ov' wi OTe ev6vi eyevero, e^w vofxov Tvy^dvovioq' irptv vj ^e^a-

c6at irapa tov Oeou T^f airo^yy}^ rov (f>vTov ro eiriTayfxa. '^yjXoh \o

ydp Wi eyevero TrpwroV eira rvjv evToAr^y eoe^aTO vaTcpoV o9ev

eirdyei, " ekdovavjg ^e ryjg evToXyji,^' Kai rd e^^f . e7re<S»? ^e, (pyjat^

Qeog rov Trept rov cf>vTov ^e'Scu/f6 vofxov, Kat ^iaKptatg eyevero

^vo Trpayfxdrwv, yj dfxapria irapelatvatv fVj^ev. eyw te TavavTia

irotyjaag ro^ig roo Qew ^e^oyfxevotg, 6avdToo KaTeKpt6^v. ek-^Xv^e 15

&€, (pyjatv YlavKog, eirt rovTOvg diro rov vofxov rovg Xoyovg'

tetKVvq wg ov (pavXov yjyeTrat avTOv. Kotvwg te nept rvjg rov vofxov

(pvaewg ^taXeyeTat' ro j(j>etS>^eg avrov ^ttdaKwv. o6ev Kat Tyjg

irpoq rov A^a/x fxefxvyjTat evroAYjg' eTrei^y) dpyy) vofxcv rotc dv6pcc-

voig eKeivog eyevero. Kat avfXTrkeKwv dfxcpoTepa, KaXxag eirdyet, 20

" ware 6 fxev vofxog aytog^ Kat yj evToXyj dytaJ'

©EOACPHTOT. 'Atto yovv Tov Kard Tov A^a/A irapa^eiyfxaTog

(^avepov iroiei ro ywpiq vofxov fxrf ywpav eyetv t>jv dfxapjtaV

ydp 'Ahdfx irpo r^g -Trapa^daeag, ovk elye tov davdrov ro deog.

Tov ^e Qeov tvjv irept tu>v ^ev^^pwv evrokyjv re6etKOTog, ev6vg fxev2^

irpoaeX-^Xv^e ttd rov ocpecog htd/3o\og ryj yvvatKi, Kat To7g aira-

TYikoig eKetvotg eyp^^aaTo Xoyotg. ^ekeaa^eiaa ^e eKeivyj' Kat tov

Kapirov ryjv wpav 6eaaafxevyj, yjTTyj6ri fxev ryjg lyJov^f, irape^'^ Qe

T^v evToXyjV e^e^aio ^e avv tw A^dfx irap avriKa tov opov ryjg

reXevryjc, eKotvwvyjae yap KaKehog TYjg (Spwaewg. 30

rENNAAioT. '
0(7T€ ^'yw, dv6pwTrog keyet vvV keyei Oe Trept

*'
rov Addfi.' ro ^e e^wv ywptg vofxov,' vovjaov Kat ovrwg. efxe rov

dv6pw3rov eyovra Trpo rov vofxov ro ^jv, yj evTokyj irpoaek^ovaa Oia

*'
T^f npoa6ev veKpdg d[xapriag dva^yjadayig^ tovto acpetXero' Kai
" evpedyj fxoi yj evToKyj yj etg ^«>?v, avryi eig ^ocvaTOV." Kai neirovOe^S
176 SUPPLEMENTUM VII. 12.

T/ c^k-rXiov Kai ovr(t)q ekeeivov, t^ evepyea-ta (3Xa^ei^' Kai tw

Tipog ^airiv ^odevrt (xot poyjGYjiJiaTt, tovtx to ^v aTroXeaag. " 17

**
yap af^apTta a(popiMVjv Ka^ovaa,^^ Kai toc e^^s' (^(ovaa yap
"^ia T^s" IvToXyji 7rpo<pa(Tiv v) KaTapaToq a^apTta, Kat ^vvaTCOTcpa
TW onXo} Tic efxiXi yevofxevv], ^ia tovtov fxe avTOv TTapaKpovaafxevr} 5
KaTea(f)a^€' ^ietai fxevToi Ttepi T^f afAapTiaf, cog ^ooavjg tc Kai

vcpeaTYjKvtag Kai ao<pt^oft.evy]g tov avSpcoTTOv' KaTa to tyjs Betag

eSog ypa<pyjg. ovrui yovv Kat ^iKatoavvyjv Tipoa^aTioTiotm 6 fj.aKa~

piog elaayet Aa/3i^, " ^tKatoavvyj evaoirtov avTov npoaTtopevaeTai,"

Xeywv' Kat iraXtv 6 ^o>^Of*.m t>;v aocptav. Kai oXug ev To7g 6etotg 10

Xoyiotg TToXv to TotovTov i^tcofxa.

AI2API0T. Aaa OTiep eiTiov TO, eyta he e§»v "Xfoptg vofiov

*'
TroTe," ov Ttept avTov tov YiavXov XyjiTTeov. ov yap TipovTryipye

tov vof«.ov TlavXog, ea-^aTog Trdvrcov rwv rov vofxov (potTyjTwv. ov^

av TidXiv 'x^coptg tovtov vore 'fjv yj fyeveTo* Kat yap ro evayyeXiov 15

KyjpvTTCov, rag vofAtKag fkapTvpiag itavTi Trapart&i^aiv' dXX^ eK

Trpoacoirov rov A^afx diroOvpoft.evog ravra cpyjatv, *' eyco ^e e^cov
" 'Xjopig vof/iov TTOTe." aacpearepov te cog eK irpoawTrov rov 'A^a/A

airo^vpofAevog ravTa cpi^at XevKaivcov ro voyjfKa' ovk eri vofLov «AA'

evToA>;v (pdaKcov ri^v ^oOeiaav rco 'Adaft. ^yjXovort' eXOovayjg §e r-i^g 20

cvToA^f, coaavei ^o6eiayjg, y; du.aprta ave^yjae (pyjat' eycb he dire-

6avov T^ ^<a TVjg irapaKoyjg eKTrrcoaei rijg ft.aKaptag ^coyjg.

©EOAiiPHTOT. Atto tyj rS>v Kara rov AVaft. •trtarcoadfi.evog rov

irept Tov ^oiaaiKOv vofLOv Xoyov, avfxTrepatvcov eirdyei' " ware

" vofKog ayiog Kat yj evroXy] ayta^ Kat ttKaia Kat dyaS^^J^ 25

vofiov Xeycov, rov M.a}aaiKOv' evroXyjv ^e, t>7v tco 'A^a/x, ^e^of/.evrjV.

ov ydptv, Kai trXetoatv avTVjv eraivtcoae are^pdvotg' wg trXeiovg

irapa TroXXav ^e^^ofJ^^vyjv Karyjyopiag. 01 yap pa6vfj.ia av^covreg,

Kai rov oeairoTov Qeov Karyjyopovaiv wg reBetKorog ryjv evroX-^v.

tt fxev yap yjyvoet (paat ro yevyjaofxevov, Trag Qeog Trpoyivco-^o

f/.yj

aKcov ra f/.eXXovTa ; ei oe irpoopm tijv TrapdjSaatv, reBeiKe ryjv

evroXyjv, avrog 7^5 Trapa^daecog airiog. ehet Te avrovg avvtdeh,

cog tdiov XoytKCov yj rm KaXm Ka) rm fxyj rotovrm ttdKpiaig'
"Trcog roivvv evyjv rovg ToiavTVjv eyiovrag (pvaiv, XjMp^g vofJLOv ttoXi-

revea6at ',
^td ri tovto re6eiKe rvjv evToA^ Qeog ; Hva Ka) t»?V35
VII. 12. E COD. MONACENSI. 177

oiKeiav (pvaiv eTtiyivaaKr], Kat tov vofj,o6eTvjv dtifxaivY}. «jti Oe

i^eiv Kat Tov vofji.oSeTov tvjv (pi\avQpa}TTtav kiav evyepvj, Kai ov

^vaKaTopSuTOv ^e^u)KOTO$ vofxov. Travrwv yap eteowKei twv (ftVToiv

TTjv aTTokavaiv' evoi; ^e (xovov eKeKoikvKei tvjv f*.eTdXr,\piv' ov <p6o-

vaJv avT^ TVjv e^ovaiav ^ra^ecp^vj/cwf ' aXAa Tvji OovXeiag avTOv $

eKTrai^evav tov^ opovg' Kai evvovv eivai Ttepi tov TrenoiyjKOTa

^iddcrKttiv, Kai d<popft.r]v eig yvfKvaaiav itapeyav \ to3 XoyiKa' ei

he TV}v cvToA^v fxrj (pvXd^ag, vito tov opov tov QavdTOv /caTecrT>7, ov

KaTviyopta tovto tov TeSetKOTog, dXXd tov 7tapa(3e^vjKOTog.

Xptsostomot. AAAa TavTa fuev Kat ci Ttepi TVjg ev toj itapa- lo

'^etaoa evToA^^ Kai tov (pvaiKov vofLov to pvjTOv eKKafji^dvovTeg.

i^ufnev ^f, 00$ ov acpo^pa tvjg aKpt^eiag e^^ovTa*' TtavTayov ydp

(JKOTtog Toj navActJ, tov Mco<7ai'«-ov itoAjaat vofLov' Ttpog Ve eKei-

vovg, ov^eva Xoyov eyet. Kat fxdXa etKOTCOi' tovtov yap ot lov-

'^aToi ^e^oiKOTeg Kai (pptTTovTeg, e(ptXovetKovv tvj ydptTt' T^vSei^

«VToA^v Tvjv ev tS) 7tapa^et(7w, ov^e vofi.ov itoTe (patveTai KaXeaag^
ovTe IlauAof outc dXXog ovteU. iva te Kat dit avTav Tciiv eipt^-

fKevwv TOVTO aa(peaTepov yevvjTai, eite^eXSajfJ.ev toIV py]6eiai' f/.tKpa

avcoTepco tov Xoyov avayayovTeg. itepi ydp itoXiTetag avTolg aKpt-

Povg ^iaXeyQetg^ eitvfyayev' " vj dyvoeire dheX(poi, OTt o voft.og 20
** Kai
Tou dvOpwTtov Kvptevei, e(f> oaov ypovov ^^ ; coo-t6 vfLeig

" eOavaTwSi^Te tco vofKW." ovkovv ei itept tou (pvaiKov TovTa

etpvjTat, evpe6v]aoft.e6a fnvj eyovTeg voft.ov (pvaiKoV et oe tovto

dXvj6egf t(ov dXoycov eafji.ev dvovjTOTepoi. dXX ovk eaTt TavTa

ovK eari' itept ydp tov ev tw itapa^etaco ovOe (ptXovetKeTv avay- 25

Kalov. tva fuf\ iteptTTOv dvo^e^iifj.e6a itovov itpog toc o}fi.oXoyvi-

**
fiieva dito^^vof/.evot' itag ovv (pvjaif t>jv dfxapTtav ovk eyvcov,

" ei fJi.v] hia vofnov ;" ov tvjv Ka6oXov Xeycov ayvotaV dXXd tvjv

dKpt^eaTepav yvaaiv ei ydp itepi tov (pvaiKOv tovto etpvjTUt,

Ttcag av to e^vjg eyoi Xoyov ; " eycb," ydp (pvjat, ** e^cuv ycopig vofii.ov 3o
TTOTe ouTe yap AOafi. ovre aXXog avOpcovog ovoe eig ovbe-

•noTe (paiveTat ycopig vofnov ^vjaag (pvatKov' Ofj.ov le yap avTOv

eitXaTTev 6 Seog, Kai eKeivov evTt6ei tov vou.ov avToo. avvoiKov

vofi.ov aa^paX-Si TtapaKa6iaTdg tvj (pvaei Ttdav]. yjapig Ve tovtcov,

A a
178 SUPPLEMENTUM VII. 12.

ovtaixov (paivcTat tov cpvaiKOV vofxov evToXrjv KaXeaag' tovtov ^e

Kat evToXvjv dyiav Kat ^tKatav KaKei' Kat voimov Trvev^aTtKov

^e <f)vaiKOi, ovK dno TtvivixaTog vifJiTv e^odi^. Kai yap (3dp(3apot

Kai EAA.7jv6f, Kat Trdvreg rov vofxov tovtov ey^ovaiv 01 avQpctinoi'

oSev ^^Aov, OTi Ttep) rov ^(tiaaiKov dvuo Kai Kdrw Kat Travrayov ^
^taKeyerai.
'*
4>flTioT. E/^ ^evrepov Se e<f)yj rOf XafSovaa r} dfxaprta
" d(f)opixyiv "^td r^i evroKvjgJ'^ rd avrd •aoiKiXw^ KaraaKevd^av'

Kai etKOTCDs' ixeydXy]v yap efye to^av vofuog. teiKvvatv ovv avrov

fjLVj^ev o}(f)eXovvTa, d\?C eK Tieptardaeai Kat PKdipavra' tva 10

eimapd^eKroi yevvjratj Kvjpvaauv ro d(f)eivat fxev avrov irpo^pa-

fjieiv ^e TV} irtarei \piarov.

Aaaos ^e, dvwrepo) eiiroiv, " d(f)opfi.v]v Xa^ovaa vj dft.apria 'btd
**
T^f evroKvj^; Karetpydaaro ev eft.oi irdaav eirt^vfkiavy^ eirdyet ori

ov fjiovov eTrtQvfxtav irdaav Karetpydaaro' d\Xd Kai eBavdr^aae fie. 15

avrvj fxoi yevofievvj ets BdvaroV eira wg eQog avrco atTtag atrtaig
(TvvetpeiVj Kai tvjv dKoKovQiav evtetKvvvat rcov TrpayfkdTwv ev roTg

Koyoiif dvarpeyet Kai rt6v}at Trwi Karetpydaaro irdaav eTrtQvfktav.

Kat (f)Vjat brt " d(popfi.v]v Ka^ovaa, e^vfrrdrYiae fii.e." eha d(ftvjKe ro

Trpopprfiev voeh evravBa' ort, eK rovrov he eipydaaro' rt eipydaaro; 20

TVjv eTrtOvfj.iaV Kat rovro a(f>etf, eirtavvdTrret ro reko^;. " Kat dire-

" Kreivev'^'' iv vj Kara avviyetav, et rtg avakdfSot ovrcog avTw etpvj-

fLevov.
**
d(f>opfi.v]v Xa^ovaa vj dfiapria Kareipyaaaro ev eft-ot ndaav
" eTnBvfKiav.^^ tv]V ^e eiriQvfj.iav Karetpydaaro, dirarv]aaaa, rovr-

eart leXedaaaa' epyaaaft.evv] ^e tv]v e7rt6vf*.iav, direKTetve fj.e. 25

eartv ovv vj dTrdrr/ atria rvjg e7ri6vft.tag. vj Se eirtOvfj.ta, rov Bavd-

rov' rvjv ^e dirdTYiv elpydaaro ^td r^s evToKv]^ v] dfiaprta' tva

(pav^ ro vireplSdKXov tvj^ KaKtag avrv]q' ^ia rov dyaSov ro Kd-

Ktarov epya^ofi.evv]g.

rENNAAioT. **'D,CTTe fxev vofxog, dytoi' Kai v]. evroXv] ttKaia^o

Kat ayaSv]. '*
o f>.fv" avv^^eafxoc,, dnXSog evravBa Trapepptirrat.
vofxov oe Kai evrokvjv, ro avTO ei ^ovXet elire. dyiav fxevrot tv]v

evroXvjV etpv]Kev, ccg T^g dfxaprtag dirdyovaav, Kat "^iiaTwaav Kai

a(f)opt^ovaav rov kukov' ^tKaiav ^e, wg fxerd rov ^iKaiov rtfxaaav

VII. 12. E COD. MONACENSI. 179

T€ VTtaKoiovTa^y Kot KoXd^ov(7av TtapaKovovTai. dya&riv §e, «$•

oty]yovaav t\ itpog to dyaGioVf Ka\ ^/ dyaBoTYjTa ^odeiaav Qeov'

Kat KaXcou TrapcKTiKyjVf rco Tf vapey^etv tvjv ^ tdyvuaiVf Kai tw

[xei^ova TreiQofxevcti VTTtayyeiaSat KaTaaTaatv.
Ktpiaaot. Ki7rot(; S av tov voixov dyiov Kat tvjv evToXrjv dyiav $
Kai ^tKaiav Kat dyaB-^v Kai OTt dTrotpaivet dyiovi Kat ^tKatov^

Tovg, otirep av eXotVTo (pvXdTTetv avTOv' Kat airaXXdaaei tZv Ik

7rapa(3aae(0f eyKXYjfJidTav.

Xptsostomot. E/ yap Kat aKdBapToi yeyovaaiv lovtahi

fxeTa Tov vofxoVy Kat d^tKoi Kai irXeoveKTat' ov Korapyel tovto io

Tov vofxov TVjv dpeT-^v' coairep tov Stov ttjv iiiaTiv ovk dvatpetf yj

airtaTta avTav.

OpirENOTS. K.dvTav6a ^e Ttg vofxov tov (pvatKOv d-ne^coKev.

ovTO) XeyxV a^ ei Kai " yj dfxapTta d(f>opfxv]v Xa^ovaa ^ta Trjg

" evToX^g e^vjTrdTvjae,^^ Kat ^td tovto direKTetvev, ov^ev yjttov tviv 15
aXvjBeiav fxokoy vjtcoV Kat tov eyyeypafxixevov Trj Kap^ia viro tov
Qeov vofxov wg aytov diro^eKTeov. Kat t^v evToXvjv ag dyaGivjv koi

e^ ayaOov Qeov eiraiveTeov.

©EOAflPHTOT. AAAof Se vofxov fxev tov ^coaaiKOv eiirev evTo-

Kviv oe TVjv Tw Aoafx OeOofxevvjv. vjv dylav fxev npoavjyooevaev, as 20

TO heov ^t^d^aaav ^iKaiav ^e, cof op6'2( toi<; Trapa^dratt; tv^v

rp^l^pov eireveyKovaav. aya^vfv ^e, a>f ^co^v ToTf (pvXdTTOvatv evTpe-

Tri^ovaav.

<J>flTioT. Su Oe dirkag 'hvvaaat aytov tov vofxov elireh' qti

e0f XftTTev «TTO aKaBapaiag Tovg <f>vXdTTovTag avToV ^iKaiov, OTt »5

Tous- fxev KaTopBovvTag, vjfxetlSeTo ^wpeais' Toig Se irapa^aivov-
atv, eireTtQet Tag Ttfxujptag. dyaOhv, OTt ovy^ vj^ofxevog Taig Ttfxa-

ptaig v) opyvf yjixfxevog eKoAa^eV dxxd TVjg avTm eveKev aa-

TVjpiag' Kai ert OTt fxiKpd KaTopBovat fxeyaXa e'/api^eTo' Kai
dfxapTdvovTag irepteTTre' Kat ov KaT d^iav t(Jov TrKvjfXfxeXvjfxdTCCv ^o
eKoXa^eV avTOg Oe TOVTa irapo^pafxm ck tovtwv avfXTrepaivet

aytov Kai ^iKatov Kat dyaQov eivai tov vofxov ^ tvjv evToXvjv. e^

evog fxeVf OTt e^ida^e fxe tvjv dfxapTiaV Ka\ eireTa^e (pvyeTv avT-^v.
eg eTepov de, ot; KVjOOft.fvoi Kat (ppovTt^av tovto eTroivjaev. aytog
A a a
 180 SUPPLEMENTUM VII. 13.

ovv, OTi e^i^a^c, kui erreTa^e <f>vye7v airo t^<; aKaQap^ia^. ^iKaioi,
OTt ^tod^ag ovtco, ttjv Tifjiwpiav Tovg dixapTdvovTag aTraiTei' dya-
6og oe, OTi Kai ^co-^v fjiot irpovoovfKevog TavTa eTreTeXet.

13 To ovv ayaOov iv e/JLol yeyove 6avaT09 ;

/x^ yevoiro'

aAA rj dfjLapTLa, tva (Pavfj dfxapTLa, Sid tov dyaOov fioLS

KaTepya^OfievTj OavaTOV. Iva yevrjTaL KaO^ v7repj3oX.7jv

dfxapT(aXo9 r] dfiapTLa dLa tyjs evToXrjs.

Ktpiaaot. Ayiog fxev vofxogy ayia ^e Kat 07 evToKvj, Kai

dyaSv]' eha ?ra5f e(f)aaKe' ** Kai evpfSvj fx.oi yj evToXYj 17 eig ^'-^yjv,

*'
avTy} eig 6avaTov ; apa ovv etite fxot yeyovev YjfJiiv to ayadov 10

okeBpov Tcpo^evov ; ft.yi yevotTo (f)Yjat. eiratT iwft.at yap ev TOVTOtg

rjKiaTa fiev tov vofnov' ecrTV]Ka Se wa-irep TVjg dfKapTiag KaTrfyopog'

KaTa^iaC^eTat yap oyTw t\v dvSpu^^ov <pvcrtv, Kat T^g ev vjfuv

ttavotag KeKpdTVjKeV lccTTe avTOV tov eig (rccTYjpiav •yjfnTv Kat ^wvjv

OoSevTa v6f/.ov, t^v dyiav ovTwg Kat dyaQvjv evTo\vjV, SavaTov yeve- 15

aBat npo^paatv ToTg VTio^evyvvvat. "nag vj Tiva TpoTtov; ei yap

ei^eTat fxev det ToTg itapavofKova-tv vj "^iKVj' '^teXvjXdKafi.ev ^e Tipog

TovTo daQevetag ^fxeig Xoiitov ag dei TaTg Ttapa^daeaiv evaXiaKe-

aSat, evapyeg ^^19 Ttag, oti KaTa toStov tov Tpoitov 6 aa^cov vofxog,

6 ayiog Te Kat dyaOog, vevpov vSig ^oKei yeveaSat TVf dfxapTta, Kat 20
**
o^og elg Bdvarov To7g v(f> dfJiapTiav. Kai Tdy^a itov (f)Vjatv, tva
**
yevvjTat Ka& vitepfSoXvjv dfxapTOjXog vj dfj.apTia "^ia TVjg evTO-
" Aojf." Torf p.ev yap vjyvovjKoat to t» ^eaTtOTVj ^okqvv, expeTat

fjLev TtdvTCog to evaXavat dtKatc,' vpoft.v}Kaat ydp, et Kat fnv] eyvcc-

Kaat' TtX^v eaTt Ttg ainolg Kat ditoXoytag ovk aittOavog olft.at 25
Xoyog' Ttpo^aXovvTat yap KaTa to etKog tvjv ayvotav. Tolg ye ft.vjv

ev vofi.cc TO fKV] ei^evat Xeyeiv to BeXv]fj.a to deaTtoTiKov, etKaiov

vj^^v] Ttwg' ovKovv et Ttg (ftaivotTo tia^tovv y]pY]fj.evog dvoatcog, ovk

dyvotag eaTat dXX^ ditovoiag to KaTVfyop-^fxa' Kai T^g avcoTdTco

XotTtov a(f)iXoQeiag. oi/Tcof dv XeyotTO KaS vnepPoXvjv dfxapTcoXog ^o
Yj afLapTia. afj.apTCt}Xov fi.ev ydp vitdpyovTog, Kai tov TteitXvjft.-

lJi.eXv}KOTog ev ayvota' vjKiaTd Te fx^v Ka6' vvep^oXvjv Xeyofxevov

T€ Kat QVTog afiapTcoXov.

VII. 13- E COD. MONACENSI. 181

©EOAflPHTOT. A<a Toivvv Tdv oiyaOov, TOVTiaxi tqv vofXov Kai

T^f €VTo\^f, OeiKWTai (xoi yj aft.apTia, d[xapTia '^'

TOVTecrTi, KaKvj

Kai Ttovvjpd. Kat ttcos ^eiKVVTai ; KaTepya^ofMevvj ddvaTov. diro yap

Tov KapiTov yivci}(TKCi} To ^ev^^pov. Kai tov BdvoTov ^keTiwVf tvjv

TOVTOV fxvjTepa fniaio. tovtcov ^e ftoi 6 voft.oi ^i^do-KaXog. ov T0/-5

vvv vofxog KaKO^, TavTU hi^^daKccv, dXk' 7} dft.apTia Tipo^evovaa

Tov 6avaTov. iroieH oe t^v dfnapTiav, TVjg vjfneTepai irpoaipeaecag vj

€ir/ To "X^eTpov poTrvi. et yap Kat vj (f)vaig tyiv dfLapTiav vno^eiKVV-

atv, aXX ovv ye vofji.og dKpil3eaTepov yjfxa^ e^ita^e t^? Trovvjpiag
**
avTyii Tviv vTrep^oXvjV to ^e 7va yevvjTai Kaff vitep^oXvjv dfxap- 10
" TwXog vj afxapTta^ eXXi7[S}<; KeiTat' itpoavTiaKoveTat ^e, <f>avepd'

ovTco yap Kat ev to?V efji.it poaBev eipvjKafx.ev, " aAA' vj dfxapTta, 'iva

** tpav^ dfLapTta,^^ TOVTeoTtv, tva yevv]Tat Ita tvjs evToXy^g (pavepd'

OTt Ka6 VTtep(3oXvjv dfxapTCoXog vitdpyet vj dfxapTia' dvTt tov,

TtOVVjpd. I c

rENNAAioT. OvK dpa ToD KaKov fxot TO dya6ov aiTtdaofxat'

T^f Ve dfxapTtag KaTVjyopS}, kou TavTvjv fJLtaa>. Koi itpog TavTY/v
ovK av eKcov aTtetaaifLvjv itoTe. tva cf>avy], <f>v]ai, dft.apTta, ^ta Toi!

aya6ov fiot KaTepyai^ofxevvj 6dvaTov' avTVj yap j3Xd\paad fxe tco

aya6x, ot avTov fxot tovtov, Kai tv^v eavTVj<; (f)vatv vjTtg eaT< 20
KaTe(f)dvvj. eXeyyeTai yap ^ta tov vofJ.ov, vjXikov KaKOv Kai oaov
eaTtv vf afxapTta' tov yap TtapaKeXevoft.evov avTvjv ft.ot (pvXdTTe-
a6at Kai ^e^ofnevov eig avf>.fi.ayjav, vTtoaKeXiaaad fj.e S/ ditdTvii,
avTov fj.ot TovTov eneaTi^ae (f)ovevTV]v.

$i2TioT. To fii.eye6og te v]6eXv]ae ^ei^ai Tvjg dfiapTtag' Kat 25

eTteioi^ TavTV]i eig KaKiav ft.ei^ov ovk v]v evpeiv' 8/ avT^g TavTvjg
ev^etKVVfievog to fj.eye6og (pvjaiv' " tva (pavvj dfnapTia'" TovTeaTtv
iva eKKaXv(f)6vj avTvjg Ttdg T^g KaKiag itXovTog, Kat vj la^^vg

avTvjg V] ev avT^^. oiov iv OTtep eaTtv oA>j cog oXvj yevi^Tat eK(f>avvjg.

eiri fj.ev yap tcov aXXcov vTtep(3oXv]v Tiva 6eXovTeg itapaaTvjaat, 30

^vvdfj.e6a dXXo Tt evtcpepetv t» ^taavpcoff.evoo v(f) vjixav' oiov ft.ia-

pog v]v eiri ToaovTov Kaiv' oti Kat d^eX(f)OKTovog eyeveTO' Kat

Qeov TrpcoTog expevaaTO. Kai TtdXiv, ovhe fxeTa tv]v tcov TepaaTicov

^ Leg. df/.afraiKo^.
182 SUPPLEMENTUM VII. 13.

eiTi^ei^iv irapeKXvjSi^ ^apatb aTtoXxxjai rovg lapariXirag. iva <pav^

avrov ro oofxov ryjg yvafj.fjg Kai 6toiJLt(7e$' Kat iiri rm aWcov

oixotwg. eari yap evpe^v rt y/ipov rav VTTOKetfxevQiVf ov fxeraa-^^ov-

reg 01 Trov/ipevop.evot rag Kar eKelvo Trpoayjyopiag e7r<^ep^ovTa<.

eTTt Se ryjg afxapnag, eiret ravrrjg ag ecfiYjfxev ovk eart "xeTpov 5

evpeh' avrYjg ecp eavr^g Karyjyopyjae. TttKpwg ai^a Kat "^ptfxeag

rov oyKOV avr^g, Kat ro rvpavviKOv afx.a Ka) avv7repP\yjrov ev^ei-

Kvv[xevog. eiret Se a<T(pa\earepov iiwg e^o^ev eip^adai r'^ ravro-

Koyla. rov ovofxarog' naktv ^e f/.era\af/./3avoixeuov rov ovofiarog.

e<pYi yap itapmvfxttig " af/LaprwXog ^ aft.aprtaJ'^ y} ryjg Opift,vTyjrog 10

ev^^et^tg e^e\vero. Ttapovofxal^et /xev Kat ov rekeiag a(pt(xrarat rov

ovoft.arog. ev co Se eKXeXvcrBat etoKet' rovov eirayei rjj TrpoaSyjKYf

rov " KaB vTrepl^oXYjv'^^ Kai ovrag eirt ro aacpearepov afxa Kat

evrovov, Kat rov '^ptfxeug efx^pavrtKOv fxeraXa^av rov koyov (pvjatv'

" iva yevyjrat KaS v7repl3o}^v txfxaprakog yj afkapriar 15

XprsosTOMOT. \va '^etySri (f>i^ai oaov KaKOV yj dfjtaprta' yj

paSvfnog irpoaipeatg' yj eirt ro xeTpov poTryj. Kat avryj Se yj irpaJ^tg^

Kat Yj '^ie(p6apfJievY] yvxft.y]. rovro yap (xirdvrm atrtov rav KaKuv.

av^et te avryjv, ^etKvvg ryjg rov Qeov yaptrog t>jv vTrepjBokyjv.

Kat ^t^^daKwv otov KaKov ro rav avBpaTrm «TnyXAa^e yevog. 20

Koi ^ta rm KwXvovrm yjv^avro. ^t m ^e avr^g KaryjyopeTj

^etKVvat nixKtv fxet^l^ovoog rov vofnov ryjv aperyjv. ovte yap fJ.tKpov

yjvl^yjae, ^ei^ag oaov yj afj.aprta KaKOV. Kat irdvra rov lov avr^g

eig fj.eaov irpoaBetg. rovro yap eSi^Awaev elTtm' *'

tva yevYjrai
*'
Ka6 VTreplSoAYjv afKaproiXQg vj afLapria '^ia r^g evrokYjg." rovr- 25
ecTTiv tva (pavYi YjKtKov KaKOV rjXtKog oXe6pog yj afiapria' rovro Se
^ta ryjg evroXyjg e^ety6Yj' Ik rovrm, Kat ryjv VTrepoyyjv ^eiKvvat

ryig yaptrog trpog rov voft.ov, ryjv v7repoyy]v, ov ryjv fndynfjv. fJLY]

yap rovTO t^rjg oti y^eipovg eyevovro ot te^oif*.evoi. (xXX^ eKeTvo

aKonet' ort ov fxovov etg eniTaatv tyjv KaKtav ayayeTv ovk YjdeXev ^o
vofxog, aXXa Kai ttjv Trpovitdpyovaav eKKo^^at eairov^a^eV et he

ovK la^^vae, are<pdvov fxev eKeTvov aTio rY\g yvcofii^g' TrpoaKvvei te

ft.et^ova)g t»jv rov 'Kpiarov '^vvafj.tv, y] trotKiXov ovra KaKOv Kat

" A m. rec. 8»« tZv Icitikuv <f)apiAa,KCi>v x^^p'^^ fylvero Koi.

 VII. 13- E COD. MONACENSI. 183

oiaKaraywvKjTov, y^cpavio-e re Ka} Trpoppt^ov €KT([Jiovaa aveaTraaev,

aixapTiav 6e orav aKovavjg, fjiyj '^vvaixiv riva evvTroaraTOV vofxicrvji'

aXXa Tvjv irpS^iv rvjv irovYipav €7Tiyivofxevy}v re Kal dTroyivofxivyjV

dei. Kai ovre itpo rov yeve<x6ai ovaav, Kai fxeTO. to yeveaSai
TidXiv a(f)avi^o(xevrjv. ^ia yap tovto Ka\ vofxog eho9y}. vofxog ^e^
ovoeTcore eir dvaipeuei tSov (pvaiKav ^i^orai, d\)C evt ^iopOaaei
T^? Kara Ttpoaipeaiv iiovYipai Ttpd^eag.

©EOAflPOT MoNAXor. 'AXAa <f)epe koi avQis nep). rcov eipyj-

fxevwv ^te^ekSafxev evKpivearepoV wg rivog elnovrog Kara dvriQe-

aiv. rovro ayaOov o Oavdrov KaTearv] fxovov alrioV dyaQov Se lo
ovoevog \ fxvj yevono, (pi^ai. dvri tov, oyp^ ovrccg e^ei' ov Bavdrov

fxev aiTiov eyevero' dyaOov Se itapeayev ovHev' dKha Kai rivoq e^

avrov aireXavaafxev aya6ov. vj dfxapria <f>y]at, tva (pavyj dfxapria'

Oia Tov dya6ov fxoi Karepya^ofxevy] Sdvarov. el yeyovw^ o ^A^afx

KaTeKei(j>6yi fxy^^eva vofxov te^dfxevoi, ovhev av ^iyjXXarTev dXoyov. 15

oiaKpiaiv fiev ovhefxiav e^/oov KaXov re Kai yeipovog. Tiav Se to

irpoarv^^pv wg ervye '^ia-npaTrofxevog. ovre ovv dft.dpTy]fxa eivai

TO Ttoiyjaai rt ro7s 6eioig vofxoig VTievavriov y^iriararo, ovre f/^v

aya6ov ro TroieTv oaa eKeivoig dKokov6a. TioSev yap koi et^evai

TOVTO irpoa^Ke, vofxov qvk eiki^cpori ; ovkovv y) 'toatg ryjg evroXyjg^ kou 20
oiaKpiaiv avTw rov re Kakov Kai rov yeipovog iiapeaye.v. vitaKoyig

re yap e^ovaia Kai TrapaKovjg avrw TrpovKeiro, Ttpog peitetv

e^ovkero. Kai eyvwpiaev avrco ri fxev dfxdpTVjfxaj ri ^e diKaio-

avvvj. KaXov fxev eivai ro 7t€ia6^vai To7g vofioig yvapi^ovaa'

afxaprvjfxa t\, ro itoie7v rt rovrcov dkKorpiov. Kai enei^^v] itape^vj 25

TO 6eiov eitirayfxa' elra ttjv vitep rovrov Tifkcopiav ete^aro, fxet-

^ov Kaia TV]g dfxapnag ro fi7aog eKrvjaaro' itdXat fxev Xoyji
7taioev6etg, ag vj dfxaprta 6avdTov 'TtapeKTiKV]. varepov ^e eTti ratv

epyaVy rv]g dfxapriag eyvwKcbg rvjv (pavXorv^ra' Kat yap caco '^ia

rv]v 7tapaj3aatv vito rtfxcopiav KareaTV], Toaovrca fxtaetv rvjv dfxap- 30

Tiav, cog airiav avrx rwv KaKcov TtapeaKevd^ero. ro ovv **
v] dfxaprta
*'
iva (pavYj dfxapriai" dvrt rov, coare (pavYjvai tv]v dfxapriav, oitep

eari' ri ^e rovro ; avro rovro dfxapria. iv eiiiv] KaKOv. 7to6ev Se

TOVTQ e(f>dvv] ; S<a rov dya6ov' iv etitv] ttd T^f evroXvjg. Ka\ ojtxg
 184 SUPPLEMENTUM VII. 14.

€(f)dvv]' KaT€pya^ofji.(vv) OdvarciV. d(p m Oavdrov yivirai •npo^evog,

cvve^dkixo ovv fxoi to aya6ov' iv eiTrvj yj evToATj, jrpog to yvavat

TYjV dfJiapTtav, hrt ^>j KaKov. (oaTe Kat fXKreiv avTVjv ^ia tovto.

dyaGov dpa vj evToXv], TVji tiaKpiueoog Kai tov itpog tvjv dfxapTiav
**
fxiaovg TV)V atTiav yjfi.7v Trapaay^^of/.evv]. to yap tva' ovk ent 5

aiTiag, dXka ro eTrofJievov avvvjSooi Keyet. d-no^oreov ^c ro " ttd

*'
Tov dyaQov fxot^ Kard rvpt evvotav, rSi " yj dfxapria tva (pav^
" dfJiapria'^^ ov tco e^^g, tS, " KaTepya^ofxevvi Bdvarov." Keyet

ydp ort ^ia rov dyaSov, rovrevTi rvjg evrokvjg, Kard^vikog fxot v]

dfj.apTta eyevero, vjXikov eari KaKOV, (Hg Kat Sdvarov aTtorekeh 10

Kard Twv eirtrxi^evovTOiiv avTVjV.

14 Otda/JLev yap oti 6 pofji09 irvevfxaTLKOs ecmp' iyco Se

crapKiK09 el/ju, ireTrpapLevos viro ttjv d/j.apTiav.

Xptsostomot. ETTet^vj etTcev, ort fKeydXa yeyove KaKa. Kat

V) dfxapria '^vvarcorepa Karearv], t^j' evroXvjg eTiiXa^ofkevY]. Ka\ 15

Tovvavrtcv oviiep eaitovha^l^ev vofxog e^el3v]' Kai etg ttoAAtjv tov

aKpoaTV]v eve(3a\eu airopiav Keyet Kat rov XoytafKOv Xonrov KaS

ov ravra yeyove' Trporepov diiaXXd^ag rov vofxov rv]g "novv^pag

VTTOrptag' tva yap ff.vj aKovxv, ort ^id rvjg evroX^g vj dfJ.apTia

a(f)opfiv]v eXa^e' Kat ori eXQovavig avTV]g, v] dfxapria e^v]ae' Kat 20

OTt ^i avTYjg e^vjTrdrvjae Kai dneKreive ^, rlv vofxov rm KaKwv

rovrcov airiov vofntavj rtg eivat' nporepov ry]v vnep avrov riOv^atv
aitoXoytav, fxera TtoXXvfg rvjg itepiovatag' ov fxovov Karvfyopiag

avrov aitaXXarroiv, aXXa Kai eyKCOfXiov avrw TtXeKOJV fxeytarov'

Kat TQvro, ov^ xg avrog "xapi^ofxevog Ti6v]aiv, dXX (og Kotvv]v ela- 25

(fyepctiv i^^^oV ** o'i^aixev 7«/?," (pi^on, " ori vofxog TtvevfxariKog

" ec7T/v." (og dv et eXeyev, ori cofxoXoyvjfxevov rovro Kai ^^Xov
eariv' ort itvevfxartKog eart. roaovrov aite^/ei dfxapriag airtog
etvat . opag oitwg ov Karvjyoptag avrov dTtaXXdrret fxovov, dXXd
Kat eTtaivei fxe6 vitep^oXvfg aTtdav^g. itvevfxartKOv yap e/Vwv, 30

otoaaKaXov avrov deiKVvaiv dperv)g ovra, Kai KaKiag itoXefxtov.

^ In niarg. a ni. rec. IV oSv tc^. ^ In marg. a m. rec. kou\ rwv

ytytvvjiJitvccv KaKtiv viieij6vvo^.

I
VII. 14. E COD. MONACENSI. 185

rovTo yap ianv eivai innv(j.aTiKOV' to, iravTwv airaynv afxapTrj-

fAaTccv' oirep ovv Kai 6 vofxo^ eiroiei, 0o/3a;v, vovflcTwv, KoXa^wv,

hiopdovfxcvog' Ta wcp) apeTvji avfxjSovXevav airavTa.

0EOAflPHTOT. '^H irvevfJiaTtKog vo[xo<;f ori 9€ia> eypa(f>r) itvev-

fjMTi. Taurvjg yap fxeriyoov TVjg yapncq^ </»?<'') Maja^f, tov vo^ov 5

Qvveypay\jev.

KrpiAAOT. '^H Kou wg TivevfxartKovi awoTtXaJv, Toyj' iteiQo-

fxevovg avToo' voeTrai ^e ntvevfxariKO^, o fxvj Kara aapKa ^wv, akk

efrofxevog rvj deX-^aet rov Uvevfxarog afxa}fxvjT(Oi.

Fennaaiot. ^Eirt irkeov ovv rov vofxov virepavokoyovfxevcg, lo

4>vjai' **
eiriarafxat ori o vofxog TrvevfxaTiKOi ecriv^ iva etirvj

reXetog Ka\ avev^e>?f, Ka) aperi^v a-nvjKpi(3a}fxewiv a-nairZv, aBa-

varoig TrpoavJKovaaV aXA.' eya ri 7ra$a3 ; 6vv}r^v koi (pOaprvjv, Kai

TToXXoTg irdOeatv vTroKeifxevvjv irepiKeifxevoi aapKa.

Ktpiaaot. Ka< aapKiKog cdv* cog tw r^g aapKog (fipovvjfxaTi 15

Tvpavvovfxevog' erepov ovrog rov (ppowjixarog rvjg aapKOg, Kai a\-

\ov Tou wevfxarog. airep avriKetrat aWvjKoig' ei yap Kat vofxog

•nvfVfxariKog eart' rovreart ra rov irvevfxarog ^ovkerat' Kat ra

avfx(pepovTa ^vjrei rvj tp^^' «^^' ^7^^ ^^i "^^^ aapKOg eTriQvfxiag

ttwKm, aapKiKog elfxt. ovK eiire le VfxeTg ot rx voixa} yjx^fxevoi 20

Kat irapa^aivovr fg. tva fxv) rpayyv Kai etrayffi] irotvjav) rov Xoyov.

aAX' eyu (pvjai, ra eKeivwv, e(f> eavrov ayvjfxari^wv. Kai e(f>e^^g

^e ouTco TToiei' ro rpayy Kai a^po^^pov eKXvccv r^ "nepi avrov ayvj-

fxarokoyKx.

Xpt202t6mot. *H to, eyo) (pviat, rov ev tw vofxoo Kat vpo to5»S

vofxov iroktrevofxevov avdpxnov vTroypa(p(av vvv.

©eoacphtot. Ka/ oAwf, tov irpo rvjg yapirog avBpwTrov eiaa-

y(tiv, TToXtopKovfxevov viro rav iraGSoV aapKtKOv yap KaXeT rov

'*
fxv^enrw rvjg TrvevfxartKVjg eirtKovptag rervyvjKOTa' ro Se Treirpa-

" fxevog viro rviv afxapriav^^ S/a rrjg npo^pvjrtK^g vovjaofxev 5^^- 3°

aewg. " /^oy," (pvjat, '*

Tarj- afxaprtatg vfxav eTrpafiijTe''* rovro

Kai evTOvQa (pvjat' vivTOfxoXv)aa irpog rv]v afxaprtav' Kai efxavrov

avrrj ireTrpaKa' eK^te^Ofxevog coaTtep eig irratafxara.

Fennaaiot. To yap " ireirpafxfvog'^ avri rov ag TreTtpafxevog

Bb
186 SUPPLEMENTUM VII. 14.

Xeyfi. Kai tqvto ^e Itiwfxa ypa(f)iKov' to S/p^« tov o}xoi'j)^aTiKov

€TTippr/[xaTo^, Xeyav t/ twv iTpoKeifXfvxv TroXXaKig. oiov ecrTi Kat

TO, " 0eof v}fj.(!)v iTvp KnTavaXta-Kov.^* eotKe he to, " ^ovXot •rjTe

" T^i aixapTiaq, '

ev To7g ijXTipoaBev eiprjfXivov, Kat t£ Tiapa tw
7rpo(pi^TYi, *'
Tivt vno)(j3€<i}g cov, TreiTpaKa vft.ag. akX vj, Talg dft.ap- 5
" Tiati vfxav €7Tpd6rjTe.^^ Kai too ev tois evayyeXiotg Xeyoft.eva},

" TTOtoov TYjv dfKapTtav tovXog eaTt TYjg dfxapT tag'^' ovTO>g yap,
co Tig YiTTYjTai, TOVTw Kat '^e^ovXwTai.

XpTsosTdMOT. " '^apKtKog etfit," <l>Wi " TTeirpauevog vno

" TYjv dfLapTtav.*^ fxeTa yap tov QavaTov, Kat txv TTaOcov eTTeiir- 10

YjXBtv o-)(Xog. OTe yap Ovyjtov eyeveTo to o-iJ/xa* e^e^aTO Kai e-TTi-

Bvf/Liav avayKatcog Xoittov, Kai opyrjv, Kai Xvttyjv, Kai Ta aXXa

TtdvTa' d TToXXYjg eteno <piXoao(piag, iva ft.Yj TTXYifKfxvpavTa Iv

Y}fxh, KaTaTToVTidY] Tov Xoyicrfxov etg tov TYjg df>.apTiag (3v6ov.

avTa fxev yap ovk r^v dfxaoTia' y] Oe dfxeTpia avTWv fHYj yaXtvov- 15

fxevYj, TOVTO eipyd^eTo' o'ioi>, tv wg eiTi TTapa^etyfiaTog, ev avTwv

fkeTayeipKrdfxevog etiTCi:, yj eTit6vfx.ta dfxapTia fxev ovk eaTtv' CTav

te eig dfxeTpiav eKTTecrj' ei(JOO t«v tov ydfxov vofkoiv ovk eOeXovaa

fxevetv, dXXd Kai aXXoTpiaig e7Tt7TYj^Z(7a yvvai^i, to tc Xoittov

fxof^eia yiveTai. aXX ov napa ty^v eTTi6vft.iav, aXXa Trapa ty^v 20

Ta:;T»7, TTXeove^iav. Kai OKOiTet cxo^piav YlavXov' eyKccfxtdcxag yao

Tov vofxov, eiTt Tov dvctiTepcti yjiovov e.^pafi.ev evBecog' tva het^Yj iiTwg

Kai TOTe TO yevog ^ieKeno to vjfieTepoV Kai YjviKa tov vofxov eXa-

(3eVf diTocp^^vYj TYjg ydpiTog avayKaiav oixxav tijv Trapovaiav. oiTep

TTavTayov KaTaoKevdaat eanovhaKe. to yap " iTeTTpafxevog vtto 25

" T7JV dfxapTiav^ OTav Xeyrj, ov TTepi twv ev tw vojtxw Xeyet fxovcov,

dXXd Kai Twv TTOO tov vofxov j3ej3ici}K0Tiov, Kai tuiv e^apyrjg yevo-

fxemv dv6p:i}TTccv.

OpirENOTS. ZdYjTi^fxa Kat avaKviTTei aTio TTaaYjg TVjg iTpoKet-

fievYjg TTepiKOTTYjg. TTwg TavTa Xeycov riavAof, ov ^oKeT evavTtov-^'^

a6ai Tolg i^toig oh Xoyotg, ev Xeyet, " Yiyopda^Yjxe TifXYjg.
'
Kai
" X/3«7T0f rjfxdg e^Yjyopaae." Kat " ^a ^e ovKeTt eya, ^y] Se ev

" eu.ot Xp;c7T0s." et fxyj ttov ei-nojfxev, OTt TTpoa-aiTTOTTOtiag ej^e/

^ia(popovg Xoyog. Kai ava-^rifKaTi^ovTat at TiepiKOTTai npog Tag

^tacpopovg 7ToiOTv]Tag tcov ^rpoawiTwv. yovv TTapcov Xoyog apfxc^et 35

 VII. i6. E COD. MONACENSI. 187

Xeyeadai vno rav [xefJLaSi^KOTCov [X(V ra tov vofxov, oti Qeto^ eorr
Kat
'?'
(SXeTTOVTCtiv