Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

15 views

Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

- Quintessential Nature of the Fine-Structure Constant
- Gamma Ray Spectroscopy Lab Report
- Prime Matter- The Explanation for Atoms- Neal Adams
- Serway College Physics 8th Edition
- Electric Pickle.pdf
- Electro Magnetic Waves
- anderson 2003 0536
- ON THE GENERALIZATION OF EINSTEIN’S IDEA OF THE PHOTOELECTRIC WORK FUNCTION: EXAMPLE FROM SCANDINAVIAN CLIMATE DATA
- Homework2
- (www.entrance-exam.net)-AIEEE Sample Paper 2
- nature02939 Monoenergetic beams of relativistic electrons from intense laser–plasma interactions
- Ruggero Maria Santilli- Fundamental Neutrino Experiments
- David W. Thomson III and Jim D. Bourassa- A New Foundation for Physics
- 93 NMC Milkling Slugs DJR or GAM
- obj4
- K_capture
- Quantum Pigeon
- Lecture Plan - Applied Physics 2
- Appendix II.3

You are on page 1of 4

1007/s10773-007-9414-2

H.E. Puthoff

Abstract In 1953 Casimir proposed a semiclassical model for the electron based on the concept that net inward radiation pressure from the electromagnetic vacuum uctuation elds (as in the Casimir effect, generally) might play the role of Poincare stresses, compensating outward coulomb pressure to yield a stable conguration at small dimensions. Given that in scattering experiments the electron appears point-like, critical to the success of the proposed model is demonstration that the self-energy corresponding to the divergent coulomb eld does not contribute to the electron mass. Here we develop a self-consistent, vacuum-uctuation-based model that satises this requirement and thereby resolves the issue of what would otherwise appear to be an incompatibility between a point-like electron and nite mass. Keywords Casimir effect Semiclassical electron Vacuum energy Vacuum uctuation elds Renormalization

1 Introduction In his paper Introductory Remarks on Quantum Electrodynamics [3], H.B.G. Casimir, fresh from his investigation of the vacuum-uctuation-driven attractive force between conducting plates (the Casimir force), proposed a semiclassical model of the electron in the spirit of Lorentzs theory of the electron [6]. Though such modeling is out of favor in terms of providing a realistic description of the quantum electron, nonetheless the potential for insights to emerge from such modeling remains seductive. Along these lines Casimir suggested two models, the second of which has received little attention but is the subject of this short note. Casimir suggested that a dense shell-like distribution of charge might partially (as in the Casimir Effect, generally), or even wholly, suppress vacuum elds in the interior of the shell

H.E. Puthoff ( ) Institute for Advanced Studies at Austin, 11855 Research Blvd., Austin, TX 78759, USA e-mail: puthoff@earthtech.org

3006

(Shell Models I and II, respectively). This could result in net inward radiation pressure from the EM (electromagnetic) vacuum uctuation elds (playing the role of Poincare stresses) counteracting outwardly-directed coulomb forces to yield a stable conguration at small dimensions. From the modern viewpoint, for such semiclassical modeling to provide useful insight, a key issue to be resolved is that although in scattering experiments the electron appears to be pointlike and structureless, the self-energy corresponding to the (divergent) coulomb eld does not appear to contribute to the electron mass. In QED renormalization theory this is handled by adding an innite negative mass term to cancel the innite positive coulomb term. Though such renormalization can be carried out in QED in an unambiguous and invariant way, from the standpoint of a semiclassical model it appears sufciently ad hoc as to merit a search for an alternative.

2 Casimir Shell Model I In Casimirs Shell Model I, interior EM vacuum uctuation elds associated with the discrete vacuum states permitted by boundary conditions are assumed to exist (as in the standard modeling of the Casimir Effect). For this model a charge e is assumed to be homogeneously distributed on the surface of a conducting shell of vanishing radius a, whose tendency to expand by coulomb repulsion is checked by a net inwardly-directed vacuum uctuation radiation pressure due to the pressure imbalance between interior and exterior vacuum modes. Unfortunately for the model, detailed analyses showed that for this case the Casimir pressure was (surprisingly) outwardly-directed, augmenting rather than offsetting the coulomb pressure, thereby falsifying the Casimir Poincare stress hypothesis for this case [1, 2, 4, 7].

3 Casmir Shell Model II For Casimirs Shell Model II, which we now discuss, the charge density is taken to be sufciently dense in a vanishing-radius shell so as to result in the total absence of interior vacuum uctuation elds as a singularity is approached. The modeling for this case proceeds as follows: 1. Consider charge e to be homogeneously distributed on a spherical shell of (vanishing) radius a 0. 2. Under this assumption, the electric eld E, given by E= e , 40 r 2 (1)

a0 a

ucoul dV = lim

a0 a

1 e2 0 E 2 dV = lim a0 80 a 2

= lim

a0

c , 2a

(2)

where is the ne structure constant, = e2 /40 c 1/137.036. 3. With regard to the vacuum uctuation electromagnetic elds, the spectral energy density given by ()d = 3 d 2 2 c3 (3)

3007

uvac = lim

3 4 d = lim , 2 c3 8 2 c3 2

(4)

where constitutes an upper limit cutoff frequency that asymptotically approaches innity. For Shell Model II in which an absence of interior vacuum uctuation energy is assumed, the vacuum energy decit inside the sphere is given by Wvac = uvac V = lim 4 4 3 4a3 a = lim . 2 c3 3 ,a0 8 6c3 (5)

,a0

From (2) and (5) we therefore obtain for the coulomb and vacuum energy contributions to the shell model W = Wcoul + Wvac = lim c 2a lim 4a3 . 6c3 (6)

a0

,a0

4. We now require that the outwardly-directed coulomb pressure, given by Pcoul = ucoul = lim c , 8a 4 (7)

a0

be balanced by the inwardly-directed vacuum radiation pressure [5] 1 4 Pvac = uvac = lim . 3 24 2 c3 Pressures (7) and (8) result in a (stable) balance at radius a = ab given by ab = lim (3)1/4 c 0. (9) (8)

5. Under this pressure-balance condition, the shell model energy (6) then reduces to W = Wcoul + Wvac = lim c 2ab lim c 2ab 0, (10)

ab 0

ab 0

and thus a corollary vacuum energy decit serves to cancel the positive self-energy of the divergent coulomb eld. Unlike previous attempts to develop such a model [8], the approach followed here does not force a specic (incorrect) value for the ne structure constant, .

4 Discussion and Conclusions Thus, for Casimirs Shell Model II, the net contribution to the self-energy of the pointparticle electron by the coulomb and vacuum elds vanishes. We are therefore led to conclude that, under the set of assumptions applicable to Casimirs Shell Model II, an inwardlydirected, divergent, electromagnetic vacuum uctuation radiation pressure stably balances the outwardly-directed, divergent coulomb pressure. Furthermore, it does so in such a manner that, even in the limiting case of the point particle electron, no contribution to the self

3008

energy of the electron results from the divergent coulomb eld. Thus a key requirement for the semiclassical electron model is met. As a result, to the degree that this result of the semiclassical analysis carries over to QED renormalization, it would appear that the additive innite negative mass in the QED approach nds its source in a negative vacuum energy contribution as proposed in the Casimir model. The effect of the high-energy-density vacuum uctuation elds at the fundamental particle level is thereby claried, dening a renormalization process compatible with a nite particle mass.

Acknowledgement The author wishes to express appreciation to Michael Ibison for stimulating discussion and useful input during the development of this effort.

References

1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Balian, R., Duplantier, B.: Ann. Phys. (N.Y.) 112, 165 (1978) Boyer, T.H.: Phys. Rev. 174, 1764 (1968) Casimir, H.B.G.: Physica XIX, 846 (1953) Davies, B.J.: J. Math. Phys. 13, 1324 (1972) DeWitt, B.: In: Sarlemijn, A., Sparnaay, J. (eds.) Physics in the Making. North-Holland, Amsterdam (1989) 6. Lorentz, H.A.: The Theory of Electrons, 2nd edn. Dover, New York (1952) 7. Milton, K.A., De Raad, L.L., Jr., Schwinger, J.: Ann. Phys. (N.Y.) 115, 388 (1978) 8. Milton, K.A.: Ann. Phys. (N.Y.) 127, 49 (1980)

- Quintessential Nature of the Fine-Structure ConstantUploaded byMichael A. Sherbon
- Gamma Ray Spectroscopy Lab ReportUploaded byLizelleNiit
- Prime Matter- The Explanation for Atoms- Neal AdamsUploaded byJared Bond
- Serway College Physics 8th EditionUploaded byedlover9000
- Electric Pickle.pdfUploaded byJhoanna Castro
- Electro Magnetic WavesUploaded byUriahs Victor
- anderson 2003 0536Uploaded byParticle Beam Physics Lab
- Uploaded byluisdaniel
- ON THE GENERALIZATION OF EINSTEIN’S IDEA OF THE PHOTOELECTRIC WORK FUNCTION: EXAMPLE FROM SCANDINAVIAN CLIMATE DATAUploaded byVj Laxmanan
- Homework2Uploaded byIsaac Bailey
- (www.entrance-exam.net)-AIEEE Sample Paper 2Uploaded bysunayanachauhan
- nature02939 Monoenergetic beams of relativistic electrons from intense laser–plasma interactionsUploaded byface121
- Ruggero Maria Santilli- Fundamental Neutrino ExperimentsUploaded by939392
- David W. Thomson III and Jim D. Bourassa- A New Foundation for PhysicsUploaded byKunma050
- 93 NMC Milkling Slugs DJR or GAMUploaded byManash Mudoi
- obj4Uploaded byVarsha Dange
- K_captureUploaded byvinayakbhat82
- Quantum PigeonUploaded byarrupe2
- Lecture Plan - Applied Physics 2Uploaded byAlexisdundee
- Appendix II.3Uploaded byJonnathan Sanchez Palomino
- Perturbation theoryUploaded byTeka Kam
- Environmental Remediation of Thiophene Solution by Photocatalytic Oxidation Using NiO_AgInS2 NanoparticlesUploaded bynguyendangninh
- Quantum Mechanics FinalUploaded byarnold
- 10.1063@1.4995510.pdfUploaded byManendra Chaudhry
- FM200 Filling SystemUploaded byal boshia
- EVO SEM SOPUploaded byAswr
- Atomic-Physics.pdfUploaded byJitendra Karn Rajput
- X RAYSUploaded byMihir Laddha
- FUNDAMENTALS OF ELECTRICITY.pptxUploaded byHersal fae Gerardo
- Gk Physics DrdoUploaded byMohan Bukya

- Can the ZPE Vacum Be Engineered for FTL Spaceflight Applications Hal PuthoffUploaded byBen
- Journal of Scientific Exploration- Volume 21, Number 1Uploaded byRtpom
- Scott R. Little- Null Tests of Breakthrough Energy ClaimsUploaded byRtpom
- Michael Ibison- Gravity emerging from direct-action EM in a toy universe of electrons and positronsUploaded byRtpom
- Michael Ibison- The reaction-free trajectories of a classical point chargeUploaded byRtpom
- Michael Ibison- On the Conformal Forms of the Robertson-Walker MetricUploaded byRtpom
- Michael Ibison- Response to Halton Arp's Comments and Tom Van Flandern's Published Position on the Reality of the Electromagnetic and Gravitational PotentialsUploaded byRtpom
- Glen A. Robertson, P.A. Murad and Eric Davis- New frontiers in space propulsion sciencesUploaded byRtpom
- Scott R. Little, George A. Luce and Marissa E. Little- MOAC- A High Accuracy Calorimeter for Cold Fusion StudiesUploaded byRtpom
- E. W. Davis and H. E. Puthoff- Experimental Concepts for Generating Negative Energy in the LaboratoryUploaded byRtpom
- Takaaki Musha- Explanation of dynamical Biefeld-Brown Effect from the standpoint of ZPF fieldUploaded byRtpom
- Darryl J. Leiter and Stanley L. Robertson- Einstein Revisited: Gravitation in Curved Spacetime Without Event HorizonsUploaded byRtpom
- Progress in Physics 2009: Volume 1Uploaded byRtpom
- Adam Getchell- Traversable Lorentzian Wormholes: An OverviewUploaded byRtpom
- Marc G. Millis- NASA Breakthrough Propulsion Physics ProgramUploaded byRtpom
- Balthasar Indermuehle- Space – The Final FrontierUploaded byRtpom
- Claes R Cramer- Photon propagation in a stationary warp drive space-timeUploaded byRtpom
- Carlos Calvet- The Background Field Theory (Virtual Particles and Fields of Force)Uploaded byRtpom
- H. E. Puthoff et al- Engineering the Zero-Point Field and Polarizable Vacuum For Interstellar FlightUploaded byRtpom
- Marc G. Millis- The Challenge to Create the Space DriveUploaded byRtpom
- Musha Takaaki- Possible Existance of Tachyon Field Cancellation of ZPF Induced Gravitational Field in Empty SpaceUploaded byRtpom
- Alan C. Holt, Eric W. Davis and Hal Puthoff- Space Testing of Electromagnetically Sensitive Materials for Breakthrough Propulsion PhysicsUploaded byRtpom
- Eric W. Davis- Interstellar Travel by Means of Wormhole Induction Propulsion (WHIP)Uploaded byRtpom
- Eric W. Davis- Wormhole-Stargates: Tunneling Through The Cosmic NeighborhoodUploaded byRtpom
- Necmi Bugdayci- Scalar Waves in Spacetimes with Closed Timelike CurvesUploaded byRtpom
- F. Schein and P.C. Aichelburg- Traversable Wormholes in Geometries of Charged ShellsUploaded byRtpom
- Arun K. Pati, Indranil Chakrabarty and Pankaj Agrawal- Purification of Mixed State with Closed Timelike Curve is not PossibleUploaded byRtpom
- S. Nojiri et al- Can primordial wormholes be induced by GUTs at the early Universe?Uploaded byRtpom
- Matt Visser- The reliability horizon for semi-classical quantum gravity: Metric fluctuations are often more important than back-reactionUploaded byRtpom

- The Continuous Spectrum and the Peaks of XUploaded byaman
- Subatomic ParticleUploaded byjamessonian
- [Aharonov, Y.; Susskind, L.] Observability of the Sign Change of Spinors Under 2π RotationsUploaded bylev76
- Polchinski-firewall paradox.pdfUploaded byAalok Gangopadhyay
- Aram Bah RozUploaded byPshtiwan Balabarz
- Modern Theory of Critical Phenomena (Westview Press, 2000)(ISBN 0738203017), Shang-Keng MaUploaded bySidiq M Khidzir
- Problem Set 1Uploaded bydarklordsauron
- Aufbau PrincipleUploaded byPraveen Kumar
- Huping Hu & Maoxin Wu, Follow-up on CERN's OPERA Neutrino ResultsUploaded byAnonymous 0U9j6BLllB
- Atomic Structure (Grade 10) TestUploaded bys
- Selected Solutions, Griffiths QM, Chapter 1Uploaded byKenny Stephens
- Electrostatics With ExamplesUploaded byNunna Baskar
- Quantum RevelationsUploaded byMarihHolas
- Chapter 3 Practice Test Answers 4u1Uploaded byhelloblarg
- 05 FeynmanUploaded byfadumo97
- Matti Pitkanen- Bio-Systems as Self-Organizing Quantum SystemsUploaded byJoaokaa
- Molecular OrbitalUploaded byMichael Martin
- Briefings-on-nuclear-technology-in-India----PK-Iyengar-Retd-Chairman-AEC-May-2009Uploaded bykalyan974696
- LRT.pdfUploaded bylili
- 4. Quantum Mechanics Quantum_Mechanics_NET-JRF June 2011-Dec 2014Uploaded bysaratharackal
- 3rd long test.docUploaded byEunice Viclar Correa
- inside_atom_mc_review_answers.docUploaded byRomeo Acero-Abuhan
- NotesUploaded byZiying Fang
- Matric Std10 5 ChemistryUploaded byDheena Thayalan
- Postulates of Quantum MechanicsUploaded byBenjaminLloyd
- Quantum ComputersUploaded bydeepti169
- third open quantum meetingUploaded byapi-196256157
- EL ARTE DE NAVEGAR - Pedro de Medina - 1545 - Manuela Ribadeneira expo 2012 1.pdfUploaded byLuis Lancelle Fine Art
- 1.Introduction of Particle PhysicUploaded bysyazwan
- Fall CourseUploaded byMaci Costa

## Much more than documents.

Discover everything Scribd has to offer, including books and audiobooks from major publishers.

Cancel anytime.