Select a country Subscribe



search New Scientist


Log in

My New Scientist

Home News In-Depth Articles Blogs Opinion TV Galleries Topic Guides Last Word Subscribe Dating LIFE PHYSICS&MATH SCIENCE IN SOCIETY

Look for Science Jobs

Home | Life | News

It's black and white: TV influences your dreams
10:52 17 October 2008 by David Robson For similar stories, visit the The Human Brain Topic Guide

The moment when Dorothy passes out in monochrome Kansas and awakes in Technicolor Oz may have been more significant than you'd ever imagined. A new study reveals that children exposed to black-and-white film and TV are more likely to dream in greyscale throughout their life. Opinions have been divided on the colour of dreams for almost a century. Studies from 1915 through to the 1950s suggested that the vast majority of dreams are in black and white. But the tides turned in the 60s, and later results suggested that up to 83% of dreams contain some colour. Since this period also marked the transition between black-and-white film and TV and widespread Technicolor, an obvious explanation was that the media had been priming the subjects' dreams, but differences between the studies prevented the researchers from drawing any firm conclusions. Whereas the later studies asked subjects to complete dream diaries as soon as they awoke, the earlier research used questionnaires completed in the middle of the day, so the subjects may have simply forgotten colour elements to their dreams and assumed they were greyscale.

This week's issue

21 January 2012

Enlarge image

Different generations
To lay the debate to rest, Eva Murzyn from the University of Dundee, UK, has incorporated both methods into one study. She first asked 60 subjects - half of whom were under 25 and half of whom were over 55 - to answer a questionnaire on the colour of their dreams and their childhood exposure to film and TV. The subjects then recorded different aspects of their dreams in a diary every morning. Murzyn found there was no significant difference between results drawn from the questionnaires and the dream diaries - suggesting that the previous studies were comparable. She then analysed her own data to find out whether an early exposure to black-and-white TV could still have a lasting effect on her subjects dreams, 40 years later.

For exclusive news and expert analysis, subscribe to New Scientist. Gain full online access Current issue content Content of past issues


Latest news

Grouse have signature drumming styles
16:00 20 January 2012

Imprinted minds
Only 4.4% of the under-25s' dreams were black and white. The over-55s who'd had access to colour TV and film during their childhood also reported a very low proportion of just 7.3%. But the over-55s who had only had access to black-and-white media reported dreaming in black and white roughly a quarter of the time. "There could be a critical period in our childhood when watching films has a big impact on the way dreams are formed," she says. Even though they would have spent only a few hours a day watching TV or films, their attention and emotional engagement would have been heightened during this time, leaving a deeper imprint on their mind. However, Murzyn concedes it's still impossible to verify whether the dreams are actually in black-and-white, or whether media exposure somehow alters the way the mind reconstructs the dreams once we wake.

Male ruffed grouse are the first animals known to make unique non-vocal sounds

'Human beings are learning machines,' says philosopher
12:00 20 January 2012

Prevailing wisdom holds that we are born with an innate understanding of the world. No, argues Jesse Prinz: we learn a lot of it for ourselves

Zoologger: Gecko's amputated tail has life of its own
16:43 19 January 2012

Faced with a predator, the

Journal reference: Consciousness and Cognition (DOI: 10.1016/j.concog.2008.09.002) body The Human Brain - With one hundred billion nerve cells, the complexity is mind-boggling. Learn more in our cutting edge special report.

leopard gecko can jettison its tail – we explain how it keeps moving without a

Why scarab beetles dance on a ball of dung
21:00 18 January 2012



Whatever ancient Egyptians might have said, scarab beetles dance to the sun not to worship it but to roll their dung ball in a straight line see all related stories

If you would like to reuse any content from New Scientist, either in print or online, please contact the syndication department first for permission. New Scientist does not own rights to photos, but there are a variety of licensing options available for use of articles and graphics we own the copyright to.


Latest news

New cracks found on Airbus A380 jets

Have your say
Only subscribers may leave comments on this article. Please log in. email: password: Remember me   g c d e f Log in Only personal subscribers may leave comments on this article Subscribe now to comment.

21:55 20 January 2012

Urgent inspections have been ordered for the Airbus A380 double-decker jumbo jet after two types of cracks were found in wing components

Bird flu researchers stand down for 60 days
21:18 20 January 2012

The world's top flu virologists have agreed to temporarily stop work on experiments that could cause the H5N1 virus to spread more easily

Today on New Scientist: 20 January 2012
18:04 20 January 2012

read all 34 comments

Comments 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

All today's stories on, including: the first subliming planet and the drumming styles of grouse

In Future
Fri Oct 17 12:46:07 BST 2008 by Helgar

Speed limit for birds could mean better UAVs
17:30 20 January 2012

Does this mean with the future advent of 3d tv people will dream in 3d.

login and reply

report this comment

A mathematical model suggests that birds or unmanned aerial vehicles will always crash when flying at certain speeds in a built-up environment see all latest news

In Future
Sun Oct 19 12:50:17 BST 2008 by Peter M

Most read
Don't people already dream in 3D? Perhaps as a product of playing 3D games in my later childhood, I experience and recall all of my dreams in 3D (and colour). The same goes for my memories and thought processes in general, where applicable; if I've visited a location, I can revisit in in my mind and view it from different angles, zoom in, zoom out and move around as though it was a 3D model in a computer, and when I think about things, whether it's the forces at work in a glacier or the best way to stack some boxes, I work with 3D models of the problem in my head. There's also an internal physics model at work, so I can mentally 'feel' the weight and strength of an object in one of these 3D scenes and gauge the force required to move it or damage it. It's not as rigorous as a CAD package and I couldn't design a suspension bridge in my head, but it gives me a feel for the physical world that some other people seem to lack.

Most commented

Into the mind of a Neanderthal Astrophile: How to spot a dark-matter galaxy Disrupted body clock may prime you for schizophrenia Death-defying time crystal could outlast the universe Did the US accidentally zap PhobosGrunt?

Most read

Most commented

US education advocates tackle climate change sceptics Costs of killing Iran's nuclear scientists Why should we stop online piracy? Into the mind of a Neanderthal

login and reply view thread

report this comment

In Future
Sun Oct 19 15:01:42 BST 2008 by Igal

Outsider physicists and the oh-mygod particle

In the future we'll probably dream in HD.

login and reply report this comment

New Scientist is on Twitter In Future
Mon Oct 20 18:54:44 BST 2008 by Eva Murzyn

Get the latest from New Scientist: sign up to our Twitter feed

Most dreams are in 3D and HD - unless someone spends their life looking at highly pixellated 2D games or grahics. The 3D quality of dreams is visible from their spatial layout, though, rather than the exact visual details - if you can walk around a table in a dream, it is generated in 3D.

Editorial Team Leader/ Medical Writer - South East

login and reply

report this comment

Global CMC Regulatory Affairs Manager - Switzerland Head of Regulatory Affairs Global Regulatory Affairs - Senior Associate Regulatory Team Manager Head of Regulatory Affairs

view thread

Wizard Of Oz
Fri Oct 17 13:10:30 BST 2008 by Blanche

This movie is highly overated. I can't believe that a so-called serious website would devote an entire article to it. Please Newscientist! do the right thing and stop creating articles like this.

Regulatory Affairs Manager - Labelling

login and reply

report this comment

Wizard Of Oz
Fri Oct 17 15:30:18 BST 2008 by Bob L

The article is nothing to do with the movie, which is of passing relevance and so gets a brief mention.

login and reply view thread

report this comment

Tv: An Influence?
Fri Oct 17 13:26:06 BST 2008 by Matthew

I can't understand how TV could have such an effect. Surely in terms of exposure time, we get much more 'colour' visual stimuli from the world we see than any from the TV?

login and reply

report this comment

Tv: An Influence?
Fri Oct 17 17:44:28 BST 2008 by Jeremy

We do, but dreams are different. When we dream, reality-checking is suspended and the mind is connecting various memory inputs as they bounce around. It's like a keyboard input to your computer: if you input random electrical signals to the wire the computer will interpret it as letters, although the words they form usually don't make sense. Perhaps when we watch TV, reality reality checking is also suspended (it helps) and it is these TV images and themes that are not verified by reality that get bounced around more when we sleep and dream. Emotional content also seems to get bounced around in dreams more than factual things. Again, this is content that carries an element of guesswork where conclusions can't be verified by reality.

login and reply view thread

report this comment

Tv: An Influence?
Fri Oct 17 21:09:33 BST 2008 by Martin Dodds

Of course, the article states Ã¢â ¬Ë the over-55s reported dreaming in black and white roughly a quarter of the timeâ ⠬⠢, thus, roughly three quarters of the time they experienced colour-dreams. Tv had an 'influence' !!

login and reply

report this comment

view thread read all 34 comments Comments 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

All comments should respect the New Scientist House Rules. If you think a particular comment breaks these rules then please use the "Report" link in that comment to report it to us. If you are having a technical problem posting a comment, please contact technical support.

Back to top

search New Scientist



About us
New Scientist Syndication Recruitment Advertising Staff at New Scientist Advertise RBI Jobs

User Help
Contact Us FAQ / Help Disclaimer Ts & Cs Cookies Privacy Policy

Subscribe Renew Gift subscription My account Back issues Customer Service

Site Map Browse all articles Magazine archive NewScientistJobs The LastWord RSS Feeds Online Store Android App Mobile site home

Science Jobs
Biology Jobs Chemistry Jobs Clinical Jobs Sales Jobs Earth & Environment Jobs Engineering Jobs Maths & IT Jobs Graduate Jobs

© Copyright Reed Business Information Ltd.

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful

Master Your Semester with Scribd & The New York Times

Special offer for students: Only $4.99/month.

Master Your Semester with a Special Offer from Scribd & The New York Times

Cancel anytime.