&

H[jheÓjj_d];n_ij_d]>ec[i
\eh9b_cWj[9^Wd][?cfWYji
GZedgi[dgEda^XnBV`Zgh

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ

'

I]^hgZhZVgX]lVhXdbb^hh^dcZYWni]Z
I]gZZGZ\^dch8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z<gdjeVcY
jcYZgiV`ZcWn6gje#

I]gZZGZ\^dch8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z<gdje 
'%%-Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ/
GZigdÒii^c\:m^hi^c\=dbZh[dg8a^bViZ
8]Vc\Z>beVXih#

Xdeng^\]i
I]gZZGZ\^dch8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z<gdje
;ZWgjVgn'%%-#
EjWa^h]ZYWn/
<gZViZgAdcYdc6ji]dg^in
8^in=Vaa
I]ZFjZZcÉhLVa`
AdcYdcH:&'66
lll#adcYdc#\dk#j`
Zcfj^g^Zh%'%,.-()%%%
b^c^Xdb%'%,.-())*>H7C.,-&-),-&&(('

Eg^ciZYdcGZk^kZ&%%eVeZg/&%%eZg
XZcigZXnXaZYÒWgZXdciZci[gdbedhi
XdchjbZggZXaV^bZYbViZg^Va0;H8
VcYC6EBXZgi^ÒZY#

(

XdciZcih
;dgZldgY

+

=ZVYa^cZÒcY^c\h

-

:mZXji^kZhjbbVgn

&%

DjgX]Vc\^c\Xa^bViZ
8a^bViZVcYYZbd\gVe]^XX]Vc\Z^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchVgZV
=djh^c\hidX`^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch
L]nYdlZcZZYidXdch^YZgl^YZhegZVYVYVeiVi^dcd[Zm^hi^c\]dbZh4
:[[ZXihd[ÓddY^c\!lViZghigZhhVcYdkZg]ZVi^c\^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch

&)

;addY^c\^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch
;addY^c\Äi]Z^beVXihd[[V^ajgZidVYVei
;addY^c\ÄVYVeiVi^dcdei^dchVcYXdhih

''

LViZghigZhh^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch
LViZghigZhhÄi]Z^beVXihd[[V^ajgZidVYVei
LViZghigZhhÄVYVeiVi^dcdei^dchVcYXdhih
LViZghigZhhÄXdchjbZggZhedchZ

(%

DkZg]ZVi^c\^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch
DkZg]ZVi^c\Ä^beVXihd[[V^ajgZidVYVei
DkZg]ZVi^c\ÄVYVeiVi^dcdei^dchVcYXdhih

(+

I]ZjgWVc]ZVi^haVcYZ[[ZXi

)'

I]ZXVhZhijYn]djhZ
8VhZhijYnÄVYVeiVi^dc[dgÓddY^c\
8VhZhijYnÄVYVeiVi^dc[dglViZghigZhh
8VhZhijYnÄVYVeiVi^dc[dgdkZg]ZVi^c\

))

:cVWa^c\VYVeiVi^dc
I]Z[gVbZldg`^cl]^X]]djhZ]daYZghl^aaVXi
=dlYdZhiZcjgZV[[ZXii]ZVYVeiVi^dcd[Zm^hi^c\]dbZh4
L]ViegZkZcihVXi^dc4
6cZmVbeZd[VhjXXZhh[jaXVbeV^\ch
:hhZci^VaeVgi^X^eVcih[dgl^YZhegZVYjeiV`Zd[VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh
6Xi^dch[dgeda^XnbV`Zgh
6Xi^dchgZfj^gZY[gdbi]ZY^[[ZgZciXdchi^ijZcX^Zh

*)

9^gZXidgn"[jgi]Zg^c[dgbVi^dcVcYgZhdjgXZh
GZ[ZgZcXZh
6X`cdlaZY\ZbZcih

,%

&,
&.
'%
'&

'*
'+

(&
((
(*

()%

)+
)*%

*,
*.
+%
+'
+(
+)
+*

,'
,*

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ ) .addY^c\ LViZg HigZhh DkZg]ZVi^c\ ?je^iZg>bV\Zh .

* Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ 6YVeiVi^dcgZigdÒii^c\dei^dchVgZbdhian XdbbdchZchZhjhiV^cVW^a^in^begdkZbZcih# .

dgZldgY >i^hVXXZeiZYi]VilZVgZXdbb^iiZYid ViaZVhi)%id*%nZVghd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z! l]ViZkZglZYdcdl!VcY^ci]Z[jijgZ! idgZYjXZdjg8DZb^hh^dch# I]^h\gdjcYWgZV`^c\hijYni]gdj\]i]Z I]gZZGZ\^dch8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z<gdje^hVÒghi hiZeidlVgYhZchjg^c\i]Vidjg]dbZhVgZ Xdb[dgiVWaZVcYhjhiV^cVWaZcdlVcY^ci]Z adc\iZgbh#DjghijYnXaZVganh]dlh/ =djhZ]daYhl^aaWZeVgi^XjaVganV[[ZXiZY WnXa^bViZX]Vc\Z#HjbbZg]ZVilVkZh l^aabV`Z]dbZhjcXdb[dgiVWaZ!l]^aZ bdgZ[gZfjZciVcYhZkZgZÓddY^c\VcY gZYjXZYlViZgVkV^aVW^a^inbVnZmedhZ ]dbZhVcYi]Z^gdXXjeVcihid\gZViZg g^h`hjcaZhhVXi^dc^hiV`Zc# ™I]Vi^i^hedhh^WaZVcYXdhiZ[[ZXi^kZid ^cXgZVhZi]ZgZh^a^ZcXZd[i]ZZm^hi^c\ ]djh^c\hidX`# I]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchd[AdcYdc!i]Z:VhiVcY i]ZHdji]:Vhid[:c\aVcYVgZegd_ZXiZYid hZZi]ZbdhiYgVbVi^XXa^bViZX]Vc\Z^beVXih ^ci]ZJ@#LZ]VkZkZgngZXZciZmeZg^ZcXZd[i]Z YZkVhiVi^c\Z[[ZXihd[ÓddY^c\'%%.+ .! Ygdj\]i'%%+VcY]ZVilVkZh'%%(VcY lZXVcZmeZXibdgZd[i]ZhVbZVhXa^bViZ X]Vc\Zegd\gZhhZh# ™I]Vib^i^\Vi^dcVcYVYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhXVc WZ!VcYh]djaYWZ!hjXXZhh[jaan^ciZ\gViZY! l^i]VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhVahdYZa^kZg^c\ h^\c^ÒXVci8DgZYjXi^dch# I]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch]VkZV]djh^c\hidX`d[ bdgZi]Vc.b^aa^dc]dbZhÄ]dbZhi]VilZgZ YZh^\cZYVcYWj^ail^i]VY^[[ZgZciXa^bViZ^c b^cY#L^i]]djh^c\hidX`ijgcdkZgViVWdji &eZgXZcieZgVccjb!^i^hXaZVgi]Vii]Z bV_dg^ind[]dbZh!ZkZcWn'%*%!]VkZ VagZVYnWZZcWj^ai#>i^hi]ZgZ[dgZ^bedgiVci i]VilZVXicdlidgZigdÒiVcYVYVeidjg Zm^hi^c\]dbZhid^cXgZVhZi]Z^ggZh^a^ZcXZ VcYadc\"iZgbhjhiV^cVW^a^in^ci]Z[VXZd[ ^cXgZVhZYXa^bViZX]Vc\Z# ™I]VihbVaaX]Vc\ZhXVc]VkZVW^\^beVXi! eVgi^XjaVganl]Zc^iXdbZhidhVk^c\lViZg VcYgZYjX^c\8DZb^hh^dchi]gdj\] iVX`a^c\dkZg]ZVi^c\# EZg]Vehbdhi^bedgiVcianlZcZZYid ZchjgZi]VigZigdÒii^c\^hYZa^kZgZYWn ldg`^c\l^i]igV^cZYegdk^YZghidZchjgZ i]ViVaaegd[Zhh^dcVah]VkZVhj^iVWaZ ÆVYVeiVi^dch`^aahZiÇ# I]^hhijYn^hV^bZYVieda^XnbV`Zgh!]djh^c\ egd[Zhh^dcVahVcY]djhZ]daYZgh#LZVgZb^cY[ja i]ViaZVYZgh]^e[gdbVaaaZkZahd[<dkZgcbZci VcYhdX^Zinl^aaWZgZfj^gZY^[gZigdÒii^c\^hidWZ VX]^ZkZYhjXXZhh[jaandcVaVg\ZhXVaZ# LZ]deZndjÒcYi]ZhijYn^ciZgZhi^c\VcY gZaZkVci!WjibdgZ^bedgiVcian!lZhigdc\an gZXdbbZcYi]VindjhiVgiVXi^c\dci]Z gZXdbbZcYVi^dchVcYÒcY^c\h#LZadd`[dglVgY idldg`^c\l^i]ndj^ci]Z[jijgZidVX]^ZkZi]^h# .

. Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ ?d]cGjbWaZ 8]V^g!8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z HiZZg^c\<gdje :Vhid[:c\aVcYHjhiV^cVWaZ 9ZkZadebZciGdjcYiVWaZ <gV]VbIjWWB7: 8]V^g!Hdji]:Vhi8a^bViZ 8]Vc\ZEVgicZgh]^e <Zggn6X]Zg87:AKD 8]V^g!AdcYdc8a^bViZ 8]Vc\ZEVgicZgh]^e .

- =ZVYa^cZ[^cY^c\h I]^hgZedgibV`Zhi]ZXVhZ[dgVYVei^c\djg Zm^hi^c\]dbZh^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchd[AdcYdc! i]Z:VhiVcYi]ZHdji]:Vhid[:c\aVcYid ZchjgZi]ZnVgZa^kZVWaZVcYXdb[dgiVWaZ^c VX]Vc\^c\Xa^bViZ#>ibV`Zh^iXaZVgi]ViWn VYVei^c\djgZm^hi^c\]dbZhlZXVc/ ™:chjgZdjg]dbZhVgZgZh^a^ZciidÓddY^c\ VcYXVcWZgZeV^gZYVcYgZdXXje^ZYgVe^Yan VcYgZaVi^kZan^cZmeZch^kZan[daadl^c\V ÓddY^c\ZkZci# ™>begdkZlViZgZ[ÒX^ZcXn^cZkZgn]dbZ ^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchjh^c\h^beaZXdhi" Z[[ZXi^kZbZVhjgZhi]VihVkZlViZg!ZcZg\n VcYXVgWdc#6YY^i^dcVaZcZg\nhVk^c\hXVc WZVX]^ZkZYl^i]bZVhjgZhi]VigZYjXZ]di lViZgXdchjbei^dc# ™:[[ZXi^kZanVYYgZhhdkZg]ZVi^c\g^h`l^i]dji h^\c^ÒXVcian^cXgZVh^c\8DZb^hh^dch# I]ZgZedgiVahdhiViZhi]ViVYVeiVi^dcid [jijgZXa^bViZ^beVXih]djaYWZVc^ciZ\gVa eVgid[]djh^c\hidX`^begdkZbZci#I]^hXVc WZYdcZi]gdj\]/ ™:m^hi^c\AdXVa6ji]dg^inVcYhdX^Va]djh^c\ gZcZlVaegd\gVbbZh#:\#9ZXZci=dbZh! edhi'%&%# ™AVg\Z"hXVaZgZigdÒii^c\egd\gVbbZh# ™=dbZdlcZg9>Negd_ZXih# L]n^hVYVeiVi^dc^bedgiVci4 I]ZgZVgZ'&b^aa^dceZdeaZa^k^c\^cc^cZ b^aa^dc]dbZh^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch#D[i]ZhZ ]dbZh!i]ZdkZgl]Zab^c\bV_dg^in"^[cdiVaa" lZgZYZh^\cZY[dgXa^bVi^XXdcY^i^dchegZkVaZci Vii]Zi^bZd[Wj^aY#I]ZhZXdcY^i^dch]VkZ X]Vc\ZYVcYegd_ZXi^dchd[X]Vc\^c\Xa^bViZ dkZgi]ZXdb^c\YZXVYZh!^ceVgi^XjaVgÓddY^c\! lViZghigZhhVcYdkZg]ZVi^c\!hj\\Zhii]Vi i]ZXa^bViZl^aaXdci^cjZidX]Vc\ZVYkZghZan V[[ZXi^c\i]ZhZ]dbZh# 6ai]dj\]egd\gZhh^hWZ^c\bVYZdcYZh^\c^c\ cZl]dbZh[dgdjgX]Vc\^c\Xa^bViZ!]djh^c\ hidX`ijgcdkZg^hadl#>i^hegZY^XiZYi]ViWn '%*%!dcan(%eZgXZcid[i]ZidiVahidX`l^aa ]VkZWZZcXdchigjXiZYedhi"'%%+#I]ZgZ[dgZ! l^YZhegZVYVYVeiVi^dcd[Zm^hi^c\]dbZh^h XgjX^VaidZchjg^c\i]Vii]ZnVgZXdb[dgiVWaZ! bVg`ZiVWaZ!gZhdjgXZZ[ÒX^ZciVcYÒi[dg ejgedhZ^ci]ZegZhZciVcYi]Z[jijgZ# 6`Zned^ci^hi]Vii]Z]djhZ]daYhbdhi kjacZgVWaZidXa^bViZX]Vc\Z^beVXihl^aa WZi]ZY^hVYkVciV\ZYVcYl]dVgZi]ZaZVhi VWaZidVYVei# .

. Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ L]ViXVcWZYdcZidVYVeidjg]dbZh4 ™:m^hi^c\]dbZhXVcWZVYVeiZYid^begdkZ i]Z^gXdb[dgi!gZh^a^ZcXZVcYZcZg\nVcY lViZgZ[ÒX^ZcXn# ™8dhi"Z[[ZXi^kZVYVeiVi^dchdaji^dchVgZ VkV^aVWaZi]Vil^aagZYjXZi]ZhXVaZVcY hXdeZd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z^beVXihdcdjg ]djh^c\hidX`# ™I]ZgZVgZbVcnadlVcYcd"XdhibZVhjgZh i]ViXVcWZiV`Zcid^begdkZi]ZeZg[dgbVcXZ VcYXdb[dgid[i]Z]dbZVhlZaaVhhVkZi]Z ]djhZ]daYZgbdcZn# =dlZkZg!jeiV`Zd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\ZVYVeiVi^dc bZVhjgZh^hadlWZXVjhZd[i]ZaVX`d[ ^c[dgbVi^dcVcYVlVgZcZhhVWdjiVYVeiVi^dc dei^dchVcYVXXZhhidVeegdeg^ViZVYk^XZVcY h`^aaZY^chiVaaZgh# =dlXVclZbV`Z^i]VeeZc4 ™Higdc\aZVYZgh]^e[gdbVaaaZkZahd[ \dkZgcbZci^hcZZYZYid[VX^a^iViZi]Z l^YZhegZVYjeiV`Zd[VYVeiVi^dc#I]ZgZ gZbV^chVaVX`d[Vh^c\aZ![dXjhZY gZhedch^W^a^in[dghjeedgi^c\VcYegdbdi^c\ VYVeiVi^dc^cZm^hi^c\]dbZh!l]^X]cZZYh idWZVYYgZhhZY# ™8aZVgY^gZXi^dcVcYXddgY^cVi^dc^hgZfj^gZY idYZa^kZgh^beaZbZhhV\ZhVcY[VX^a^iViZ i]Z^cigdYjXi^dcd[Veegdeg^ViZbZVhjgZh! ^cXajY^c\i]gdj\]eda^XnX]Vc\Z!\gVcihVcY ^cXZci^kZh!Wdi]cdc"ÒcVcX^VaVcYÒcVcX^Va# ™6YVeiVi^dch]djaYWZ^ciZ\gViZYl^i]i]Z XVgWdcgZYjXi^dcV\ZcYV[dg]dbZh#I]^hl^aa aZVYidWdi]VYY^i^dcVaXVgWdchVk^c\hVcYV bdgZgdWjhiVcYgZh^a^Zci]djh^c\hidX`# ™I]Z`ZnVXidghidZYjXViZ!ZcXdjgV\Z VcYZcVWaZ]djhZ]daYZghidbV`Z Veegdeg^ViZX]d^XZhVgZ/eda^XnbV`Zgh! cdc"\dkZgcbZciVadg\Vc^hVi^dchC<Dh! ^chiVaaZgh!hjeea^Zgh!egd[Zhh^dcVa^chi^iji^dch VcY]djh^c\bVg`Zi^chi^iji^dch# ™>ceVgi^XjaVg!\dkZgcbZcih]djaYldg`l^i] igV^c^c\egdk^YZghidZchjgZegd[Zhh^dcVah ]VkZVhj^iVWaZÈVYVeiVi^dch`^aahZiÉ# 6Xi^dcWn\dkZgcbZci!aVcYadgYh[gdbi]ZhdX^Va VcYeg^kViZhZXidgh!dlcZg"dXXje^Zgh!9>N hjeea^ZghVcYVhhdX^ViZYegd[Zhh^dcVahl^aa]Zae idZchjgZi]VidjgZm^hi^c\]dbZhl^aaWZbdgZ gZh^a^Zciidi]ZX]VaaZc\Zd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\ZVcY Xdci^cjZidWZhjhiV^cVWaZVcYa^kZVWaZdkZg i]Z^gYZh^\cZYa^[Z# .

%eZgXZci d[]djh^c\hidX`^c'%*%l^aaXdch^hid[i]Z Wj^aY^c\hi]ViZm^hiidYVn# .&% :mZXji^kZhjbbVgn I]^hhijYnlVhXdbb^hh^dcZYWni]ZI]gZZ GZ\^dch8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z<gdje#>iZmeadgZh i]ZediZci^Va[dggZigdÒii^c\id^cigdYjXZ VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhid^begdkZi]Z eZg[dgbVcXZd[Zm^hi^c\]dbZhV\V^chi i]gZZ^beVXihd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z/ÓddY^c\! lViZghigZhhVcYdkZg]ZVi^c\# 6heVgid[i]Zegd_ZXi!VgZk^Zld[Xa^bViZ X]Vc\Zegd_ZXi^dch[dgi]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch VcYbZVhjgZh[dgVYVei^c\Zm^hi^c\]dbZh idi]Zi]gZZ^beVXihlVhjcYZgiV`Zc#6 hZg^Zhd[XdchjaiVi^dc[dgjbhlZgZ]ZaY idZkVajViZZm^hi^c\jcYZghiVcY^c\d[VcY Vii^ijYZhidi]ZcZZYidVYVeiidXa^bViZ X]Vc\Z#7Vgg^Zghidi]Zl^YZhegZVYjeiV`Z d[VYVeiVi^dclZgZVhhZhhZY[dg^cY^k^YjVa ]djhZ]daYZghVcYi]dhZ^cVedh^i^dcid ZcVWaZVcYZcXdjgV\ZVYVeiVi^dc#I]gZZ XdhiZYXVhZhijY^ZhlZgZegdYjXZYidh]dl ]dlZm^hi^c\]dbZhXdjaYWZZ[[ZXi^kZan gZigdÒiiZYl^i]Veegdeg^ViZbZVhjgZh# I]ZhZ^cejih[ZY^cidi]ZXdciZcid[i]^h ]^\]"aZkZaeda^XngZedgii]Vi^YZci^ÒZhi]Z `ZnÒcY^c\h[gdbi]ZhijYnVhlZaaVhi]Z cZmihiZehidlVgYhVX]^Zk^c\l^YZhegZVY VYVeiVi^dc#I]^h^cXajYZhVXi^dcgZfj^gZY [gdb\dkZgcbZci!egd[Zhh^dcVa^chiVaaZgh VcYi]Z^g^chi^iji^dch!hjeea^Zgh!]djh^c\ bVg`Zi^chi^iji^dchVcYC<Dh# I]ZXdcig^Wji^dcd[djg]djh^c\hidX`id 8DZb^hh^dch]VhWZZclZaaYdXjbZciZY! VcY^ccdkVi^kZbZVhjgZhidgZYjXZ[jijgZ 8DZb^hh^dch[gdbcZlhidX`VgZWZ^c\ ^beaZbZciZY#=dlZkZg!gZ\VgYaZhhd[i]Z hjXXZhhd[i]ZhZZ[[dgih!djgXa^bViZl^aa Xdci^cjZidX]Vc\Z[dgi]ZcZmi)%id*%nZVgh VhVgZhjaid[eVhiVcYXjggZciZb^hh^dch VcYl^aaX]Vc\ZWZndcYYZeZcY^c\dc[jijgZ Zb^hh^dch#6YVei^c\djgXjggZci]djh^c\ hidX`^hi]ZgZ[dgZZhhZci^Va^cdgYZgidbV`Z ]dbZhVcYi]Z^gdXXjeVcihaZhhkjacZgVWaZ idi]Z^beVXihd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\ZVcYid`ZZe Zb^hh^dch[gdb]djh^c\adl^ci]Zadc\ZgiZgb# I]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchXdkZghVcVgZVd[)%%!%%%`b' ^ci]Zhdji]ZVhid[i]ZJ@!l^i]VWdjcYVgn gjcc^c\[gdbi]Z>haZd[L^\]iidi]ZLVh]# I]ZVgZV]VhVedejaVi^dcd['&b^aa^dceZdeaZ! a^k^c\^cc^cZb^aa^dc]dbZh#I]ZhZWj^aY^c\h VgZZmigZbZankVg^VWaZ^ciZgbhd[h^oZ!V\Zd[ XdchigjXi^dc!adXVi^dc!dXXjeVcXnVcYiZcjgZ# =djh^c\hidX`^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchlVhaVg\Zan XdchigjXiZYdkZgi]ZXdjghZd[i]Z'%i] XZcijgn#>ilVhYZh^\cZY[dgi]ZXa^bViZi]Vi egZkV^aZYVii]Zi^bZ!gVi]Zgi]Vci]ZXa^bViZ lZXVcZmeZXiidZmeZg^ZcXZcdlVcYdkZgi]Z Xdb^c\YZXVYZh#8dbW^cZYl^i]djg^cXgZVh^c\ edejaVi^dc!VcY^cXgZVh^c\ZmeZXiVi^dchd[ fjVa^ind[a^[Z!i]^hbZVchi]VibjX]d[djg ]djh^c\hidX`l^aacdiYZa^kZggZfj^gZYaZkZah d[Xdb[dgi!hV[ZinVcYgZhdjgXZZ[ÒX^ZcXn^c i]Z'&hiXZcijgn#>i^hegd_ZXiZYi]Vi.

#6kZgV\Z ^chjgVcXZXaV^bh[dgegdeZgi^ZhV[[ZXiZYWn i]ZhZÓddYhlZgZ—*%!%%%!VcYi]ZdkZgVaaW^aa l^aaWZ^cZmXZhhd[—(W^aa^dc#>i^hZhi^bViZY i]ViWn'%*%ÓddY^c\l^aaWZXdbZbdgZ [gZfjZciVcY^ciZchZVhVgZhjaid[Xa^bViZ X]Vc\Z/^cgZVaiZgbhÓddY"gZaViZYYVbV\Z XdjaYYdjWaZ^cVcVkZgV\ZnZVg!VcYig^eaZ^c VcZmigZbZnZVg!XdbeVgZYidXjggZciaZkZah# I]dhZegdeZgi^Zhi]ViXjggZcianZmeZg^ZcXZ ÓddY^c\VgZegd_ZXiZYidhj[[ZgbdgZ[gZfjZcian VcYhZkZgZan!VcYegZk^djhanjcV[[ZXiZY egdeZgi^ZhbVnZmeZg^ZcXZÓddY^c\#6YVei^c\ idb^c^b^hZi]Z^beVXid[ÓddY^c\l^aa]Zae gZYjXZi]ZXdhiVcYY^hgjei^dcd[i]ZhZZkZcih# LViZghigZhh^hVagZVYnV[Vb^a^Vg^hhjZ VXgdhhi]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchVgZV!l^i]i]Zhdji] ZVhi!AdcYdc!VcYeVgihd[i]ZZVhigZ\^dc VaaWZ^c\VgZVhd[lViZghigZhh#EdiZci^Vaan adc\ZgYgneZg^dYh!XdbW^cZYl^i]^cXgZVh^c\ YZbVcYVhhdX^ViZYl^i]egd_ZXiZYedejaVi^dc! V\g^XjaijgVa!]dgi^XjaijgVaVcYXdbbZgX^Va \gdli]!l^aaejibdgZegZhhjgZdch]g^c`^c\ lViZggZhdjgXZh#:hi^bViZhhj\\Zhii]ViVc ^cXgZVhZd[&%"&*eZgXZci^cgZhZgkd^gXVeVX^in l^aaWZgZfj^gZYidhZgkZi]ZcZZYh d[i]ZedejaVi^dc#>cVYY^i^dc!dkZg"VWhigVXi^dc ^hVagZVYnXVjh^c\Zck^gdcbZciVaYVbV\Z^c eVgihd[i]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch!VcYgZYjXZYgV^c[Vaa VcY^cXgZVhZYXdchjbei^dcl^aaV\\gVkViZi]^h h^ijVi^dc#6YVei^c\Zm^hi^c\]dbZhl^aa]Zaeid ZVhZi]ZhZkZg^ind[i]^h"gZigdÒii^c\]dbZh l^i]lViZg"Z[ÒX^ZcibZVhjgZh!hjX]Vhi]dhZ YZhXg^WZY^cdjgXVhZhijY^Zh!XdjaYhVkZ &*%!%%%bZ\V"a^igZheZgnZVgVXgdhhi]Z i]gZZgZ\^dchVgZV#I]^h^hZfj^kVaZciidi]Z idiVaYdbZhi^XlViZgjhZ^ci]gZZX^i^Zhi]Z h^oZd[7^gb^c\]Vb# DkZg]ZVi^c\VhVadXVa^beVXid[Xa^bViZ X]Vc\Z^hcdilZaajcYZghiddY#Egd_ZXi^dch hj\\Zhii]ViWn'%*%!lZl^aaZmeZg^ZcXZV]di hjbbZga^`Zi]Vid['%%(!l]ZciZbeZgVijgZh ideeZY(-•8!ZkZgndi]ZgnZVg#9jg^c\ egdadc\ZYeZg^dYhd[]^\]iZbeZgVijgZh!]ZVi higZhhWZXdbZhVbV_dgXVjhZd[^cXgZVhZY bdgW^Y^inVcYbdgiVa^ind[kjacZgVWaZ edejaVi^dch!ZheZX^Vaani]ZZaYZgan!i]ZkZgn ndjc\VcYi]dhZ^ceddg]ZVai]#>cAdcYdc! VgdjcY+%%ZmXZhhYZVi]h^ci]Z]dihjbbZg d['%%(lZgZViig^WjiZYidi]Z]ZVilVkZ!l^i] '!%%%YZVi]hVXgdhhi]ZJ@#=^\]iZbeZgVijgZh XVcWZVbZa^dgViZYWnV^gXdcY^i^dc^c\!Wji i]ZVhhdX^ViZYZcZg\njhZl^aa\ZcZgViZ8D Zb^hh^dchi]Vil^aa[jgi]ZgZmVXZgWViZ\adWVa lVgb^c\#.&& Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ @Zn^beVXihd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z I]ZJ@ÉhXa^bViZ]VhVagZVYnhiVgiZYid X]Vc\Z!VcYi]ZhZX]Vc\ZhVgZegd_ZXiZY idVXXZaZgViZ#I]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchVgZegd_ZXiZY idhZZi]ZbdhiYgVbVi^XXa^bViZX]Vc\Z ^beVXih^ci]ZJ@!eVgi^XjaVganÓddY^c\! lViZghigZhhVcYdkZg]ZVi^c\# .addY^c\XVjhZhl^YZhegZVYYVbV\ZVcY Y^hgjei^dcid]dbZh!Vh]VhWZZch]dlcWn i]ZZkZcihd[hjbbZg'%%.dgZmVbeaZ!bZX]Vc^XVaXdda^c\ d[]Va[i]Z]dbZh^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchVgZV XdjaYgZhjai^cVcVYY^i^dcVab^aa^dcidccZhd[ 8DZb^hh^dch#L]ZgZ]dbZhVgZ`ZeiXdda jh^c\eVhh^kZVcYadl"ZcZg\nbZVhjgZhhjX] Vh[Vch!iZbeZgVijgZhVgZgZYjXZYVcY8D Zb^hh^dchVgZcdih^\c^ÒXVcian^cXgZVhZY# .

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ &' 6YVei^c\djg]dbZh >cdgYZgidgZYjXZi]Z^beVXihdjia^cZY! ^i^hZhhZci^VaidVYVeii]Z]djh^c\hidX`^c i]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchid^begdkZadc\"iZgb gZh^a^ZcXZidXa^bViZX]Vc\Z#=dlZkZg!i]ZgZ ^hcdÈdcZh^oZÒihVaaÉhdaji^dc#KVg^Vi^dch ^cg^h`hVhhdX^ViZYl^i]ZVX]d[i]Zi]gZZ `Zn^beVXih!i]ZXVeVX^ind[i]Z]djhZ]daYZg idiV`ZVXi^dc!VcYi]ZXdchigjXi^dc d[VWj^aY^c\bZVci]ViVYVeiVi^dc bZVhjgZh[dgZVX]egdeZgincZZYid WZVhhZhhZY^cY^k^YjVaan# 8dchZfjZcian!XaZVgaZVYZgh]^e^hgZfj^gZY [dghjXXZhh[jaVYVeiVi^dcd[djg]dbZh idXa^bViZX]Vc\Z#9Za^kZg^c\VYVeiVi^dc gZfj^gZhXddgY^cVi^dcWZilZZcY^[[ZgZci V\ZcX^Zhldg`^c\id\Zi]ZgidXdbbjc^XViZ i]ZbZhhV\Z!ZcVWaZVcYZcXdjgV\ZVXi^dc! eg^bZi]ZbVg`Zi!VcYhjeedgii]ZZ[[dgihd[ ]djhZ]daYZghidVYVeii]Z^g]dbZh#Eda^Xn bV`Zgh!eaVccZgh!Wjh^cZhhZhVcYdi]Zgh]VkZ Vk^iVagdaZideaVn^c]Zae^c\]djhZ]daYhid VYVei#:aZbZcihgZfj^gZY^cdgYZgidZchjgZ i]^h]VeeZch^cXajYZ/ ™8VbeV^\c^c\/id^c[dgbVcYeZghjVYZ i]ZejWa^Xd[i]ZcZZYidVYVei#6higdc\! =dlZkZg!djgXVhZhijY^Zhdcine^XVaWj^aY^c\h XaZVgbZhhV\ZVWdjii]ZadXVa^beVXihd[ ^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchVgZVh]dli]ViXdhi" Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z"ÓddY^c\!lViZghigZhhVcY Z[[ZXi^kZbZVhjgZhVgZXjggZcianVkV^aVWaZ dkZg]ZVi^c\"cZZYhidWZh]VgZY!Vadc\l^i] id^cXgZVhZi]ZgdWjhicZhhd[Wj^aY^c\h^c i]ZbZhhV\Zi]ViVYVeiVi^dcXVc^begdkZ i]Z[VXZd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z#I]^hl^aacdidcan fjVa^ind[a^[ZcdlVcY^ci]Z[jijgZ#L]ZgZkZg bV`Z]dbZhhV[Zg!bdgZXdb[dgiVWaZeaVXZh edhh^WaZ!VYVeiVi^dcbZhhV\Zhh]djaYVahdWZ l]^X]XdchjbZ[ZlZggZhdjgXZh0^il^aaVahd ^cXajYZYl]Zcb^i^\Vi^dcbZhhV\ZhVgZWZ^c\ hVkZ]djhZ]daYZghbdcZnVcYgZYjXZ8D Zb^hh^dch#.dgZmVbeaZ!Òii^c\VlViZg"Z[ÒX^Zci egZhZciZY![dgZmVbeaZi]gdj\]XdaaVWdgVi^dc l^i]Zm^hi^c\egd\gVbbZhVcYXVbeV^\ch h]dlZg]ZVYcdidcanhVkZhlViZgWjigZYjXZh hjX]VhÈ9ZXZci]dbZhÉ!È9>NeaVcZigZeV^ghÉ! i]ZVbdjcid[ZcZg\ncZZYZYid]ZVilViZg# VcYÈ7ZVii]ZYgdj\]iÉ# 9Za^kZg^c\VYVeiVi^dc ™BVg`ZiigVch[dgbVi^dc/hiZehbjhiWZ iV`Zcideg^bZi]ZbVg`Zil^i]Veegdeg^ViZ >cXdcigVhiidcZlWj^aY^c\h!i]ZXdcY^i^dc VYVeiVi^dciZX]cdad\^Zh#6kV^aVWaZ d[Zm^hi^c\]dbZh^hi]ZgZhedch^W^a^ind[V XdbeaZmgVc\Zd[^cYZeZcYZciVXidgh!^cXajY^c\ bZX]Vc^hbhidZcXdjgV\ZVYVeiVi^dcbjhi i]Z^cY^k^YjVa]djhZ]daYZg#=dlZkZgi]ZgZ^hcd WZZmead^iZYVcYcZldcZhYZkZadeZY![dg ZmVbeaZ^cXZci^kZhX]ZbZh!\gVcihVcY gZ\jaVidgn[gVbZldg`id\dkZgci]^hegdXZhh# egd[Zhh^dcVaVYk^XZhZgk^XZh#Dei^dchb^\]i ^cXajYZgZYjX^c\K6IdcgZ[jgW^h]bZciid Wg^c\^i^cida^cZl^i]cZlYZkZadebZcih! gZYjX^c\hiVbeYjin!hjWh^Y^h^c\VYVeiVi^dc bZVhjgZhi]gdj\]iVmVi^dc!VcY\^k^c\ gZYjXi^dch^cXdjcX^aiVm[dgVYVei^c\V]dbZ# .

&( Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ ™GZ\^hiZgZYhdX^VaaVcYadgYhVcYadXVa Vji]dg^i^ZhVgZgZhedch^WaZ[dg&#+b^aa^dc ]dbZh^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch#:cXdjgV\^c\ jeiV`Z^ci]^hhZXidgi]gdj\]\gVcih VcY^cXZci^kZhgZegZhZcihVhjWhiVci^Va bVg`Zi[dgVYVeiVi^dciZX]cdad\^Zh!l^i]i]Z ediZci^Va[dgi]^hid]ZaegZYjXZi]ZXdhid[ VYVei^kZbZVhjgZh^ci]ZbVg`ZiVhVl]daZ# ™6kV^aVW^a^ind[gZhdjgXZhVcY^c[dgbVi^dc/ i]^hldjaYZcVWaZi]ZejWa^XidVhhZhh i]Z^geZghdcVag^h`!VXXZhhVYk^XZVcY \j^YVcXZ!VcYVhhZhhi]ZZXdcdb^XWZcZÒih d[VYVeiVi^dc#>iXdjaYWZYdcZadXVaan![dg ZmVbeaZi]gdj\]^chiVaaZghVcYhjeea^Zgh! ^cXajY^c\9>NhidgZh# ™:c\V\ZbZcil^i]egd[Zhh^dcVa^chi^iji^dch/ ^cXajY^c\i]dhZl^i]^ci]Z]djh^c\bVg`Zi! VcYegd[Zhh^dcVa^chiVaaZghVcYhjeea^Zgh idZchjgZi]Vi^chiVaaZgh]VkZi]Zh`^aahid ÒiVYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh#I]^hl^aa^ckdakZ ldg`^c\XadhZanl^i]igV^c^c\egdk^YZghhd i]ViXa^bViZX]Vc\ZVYVeiVi^dc^hZbWZYYZY ^ci]Z^gegd\gVbbZh# ™Egd[Zhh^dcVah/hjgkZndgh!VgX]^iZXihVcY =djh^c\>c[dgbVi^dcEVX`VhhZhhdgh VagZVYn]VkZVXXZhhidegdeZgi^Zh!VcYbVn WZigjhiZYVYk^hdgh#I]ZncZZYidWZ ^c[dgbZYVcYZcXdjgV\ZYidYZa^kZgVYk^XZ dci]ZcZZYVcYdei^dch[dgVYVeiVi^dcid Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z^beVXih# ™=djh^c\bVg`Zi^chi^iji^dch/^chjgZgh VcYbdgi\V\ZaZcYZgh]VkZXdciVXil^i] ]djhZ]daYZghVcYVgZVagZVYnVXi^c\id ZcXdjgV\ZVYVeiVi^dc!eVgi^XjaVgan^c gZhedchZidÓddY^c\#=dlZkZg!i]ZbVg`Zi ^hXdbeZi^i^kZ!l]^X]XVceaVXZXdchigV^cih dci]ZVW^a^inid^cÓjZcXZ]djhZ]daYZgh# ™HX]ddahVcYjc^kZgh^i^Zh/i]ZhZegdk^YZ Vcdeedgijc^inid^cXajYZXa^bViZX]Vc\Z ^ci]ZXjgg^Xjajb!gZVX]^c\i]ZcZmi \ZcZgVi^dcd[]djhZ]daYZghVcY egd[Zhh^dcVah!VcYidVXXZhhVcYZYjXViZ [Vb^a^Zhi]gdj\]i]Z^gX]^aYgZc# ™HeZX^VaViiZci^dceV^YidkjacZgVWaZ Xdbbjc^i^ZhVcY^cY^k^YjVah/kjacZgVWaZ \gdjehVgZi]Zbdhia^`ZanidWZVYkZghZan V[[ZXiZYWni]Z^beVXihd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z! VcYi]ZnVgZi]ZaZVhiVWaZidVXi#6eegdeg^ViZ bZVhjgZhh]djaYWZeji^ceaVXZidZcVWaZ VYVeiVi^dcjeiV`ZWnkjacZgVWaZ]djhZ]daYh# Egd\gVbbZhVagZVYnZm^hiidVhh^hii]ZhZ \gdjehVcYbZX]Vc^hbhcZZYidWZ^YZci^ÒZY idZchjgZi]ViVYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhVgZ ^cXdgedgViZY^cidZm^hi^c\hX]ZbZh!dg XdkZgZYWncZlhX]ZbZh# CZmihiZeh I]Z^beVXihd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\ZVgZVagZVYn l^i]jh!WjiVlVgZcZhhd[i]ZcZZYidVYVei! VcYi]ZbZVhjgZhi]ViXVcWZiV`Zc!^h adl#6X]^Zk^c\VYVeiVi^dc^hbVYZbdgZ XdbeaZmWni]ZaVX`d[[dXjhZYgZhedch^W^a^in [dghjeedgi^c\VcYegdbdi^c\VYVeiVi^dc ^ci]ZYdbZhi^XhZXidg#8aZVgaZVYZgh]^e^h gZfj^gZYidXgZViZi]Zg^\]iZck^gdcbZci[dg egd[Zhh^dcVaVcY^chiVaaZgWdY^Zh!VhlZaa Vhi]ZhjeeanX]V^c!idegdk^YZVYVeiVi^dc hdaji^dch#7nVXi^c\cdllZXVcbV`Z ]djh^c\hidX`^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchbdgZ gZh^a^Zciidi]Z^beVXihd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z# .

&) DcZ"d[[ZkZcihVgZcdi\d^c\id   WZdcZ"d[[ZkZcihVcnbdgZ# .

 eZgXZcid[cVi^dcVa8DZb^hh^dch!i]gdj\] i]Zegdk^h^dcd[]ZVi^c\!a^\]i^c\VcYZaZXig^XVa edlZg[dgVeea^VcXZh#& I]ZbdhiXdbegZ]Zch^kZegd_ZXi^dch[dg \adWVaXa^bViZX]Vc\ZVgZ\^kZc^ci]Z >ciZg\dkZgcbZciVaEVcZadc8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z >E88.&* DjgX]Vc\^c\ Xa^bViZ >i^hcdlXaZVgi]Vii]ZZVgi]ÉhXa^bViZ^h X]Vc\^c\gVe^Yan#HX^Zci^hih]VkZXdcXajYZY i]Vii]ZhZX]Vc\ZhVgZVgZhjaid[i]Z VXXjbjaVi^dcd[\gZZc]djhZ\VhZh<=<h ^ci]ZVibdhe]ZgZVg^h^c\[gdb]jbVc VXi^k^in!eg^cX^eVaanXVgWdcY^dm^YZ8D [gdbi]ZWjgc^c\d[[dhh^a[jZah#>ci]ZJ@! gZh^YZci^VaWj^aY^c\hVgZgZhedch^WaZ[dg'.djgi]6hhZhhbZciGZedgi!ejWa^h]ZY ^c'%%.&"'&%%'%-%hVgZ/ ™L^ciZghl^aaWZlVgbZg!l^i]VbZVc iZbeZgVijgZ^cXgZVhZd[&id(#*•8# ™HjbbZghl^aaWZ]diiZg#I]ZbZVc iZbeZgVijgZl^aag^hZWn&id*•8# ™>chjbbZgÈZmigZbZanÉlVgbYVnhl^aadXXjg bdgZ[gZfjZcian#JcYZgi]Z]^\]Zb^hh^dch hXZcVg^d!i]ZbVm^bjbiZbeZgVijgZXdjaY ZmXZZY(%•8dcdcZ^ciZcYVnhYjg^c\i]Z hjbbZg^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch# ™L^ciZgegZX^e^iVi^dcl^aa^cXgZVhZWnjeid (*eZgXZci# ™HjbbZgegZX^e^iVi^dcl^aaYZXgZVhZWnje id+%eZgXZci# ™L^ciZghidgbhVcY]ZVk^Zgl^ciZg egZX^e^iVi^dcl^aaWZXdbZbdgZ[gZfjZci# ™Hd^abd^hijgZXdciZcil^aaWZgZYjXZY^c heg^c\!hjbbZgVcYVjijbc#I]Z \gZViZhiYZXgZVhZ!d[jeid+%eZgXZci! l^aadXXjg^cVjijbcWZXVjhZd[Yg^Zg! ]diiZghjbbZgh# ™Hcdl[Vaal^aaWZh^\c^ÒXVciangZYjXZY!WnVi aZVhi(%eZgXZciVcYedhh^WanVhbjX]Vh &%%eZgXZci#AVg\ZeVgihd[i]ZXdjcignXdjaY ZmeZg^ZcXZadc\gjchd[hcdlaZhhl^ciZgh! eVgi^XjaVganjcYZgi]ZbZY^jbÄ]^\]dg]^\] Zb^hh^dchhXZcVg^dh# ™HZV"aZkZahl^aag^hZ!l^i]i]Z\gZViZhiX]Vc\Zh ^ci]Zhdji]# .#'I]^hbV`Zh^iXaZVgi]Vijg\Zci VXi^dc^hcZZYZYcdlWdi]idgZYjXZdjg 8DZb^hh^dchVcYidVYVeiidi]Z^cZk^iVWaZ ^beVXihd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z# GZhZVgX]^cid[jijgZXa^bViZhXZcVg^dh[dgi]Z J@^hXddgY^cViZYWni]ZJ@8a^bViZ>beVXih Egd\gVbbZJ@8>E#(@Znegd_ZXi^dch[dgi]Z J@[dgi]Zi^bZeZg^dY'%.

addY^c\gZedgi)Zhi^bViZhi]Vii]Z cjbWZgd[ÓddYZkZcihXdjaY^cXgZVhZWn WZilZZcildVcYilZcini^bZhWni]ZZcYd[ i]Z'&hiXZcijgn# .+&# WZiiZgXdeZl^i]^beVXihd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z ^hVc^bedgiVcieVgid[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z VYVeiVi^dc#>i^hk^iVai]Vidjg]dbZhXdci^cjZ idWZ]ZVai]n!Xdb[dgiVWaZeaVXZhida^kZVcY Ydcdihj[[Zg[gdbi]ZZ[[ZXihd[ÓddY^c\![gdb lViZgh]dgiV\ZhYjg^c\Ygdj\]ih!VcY[gdb dkZg]ZVi^c\#I]^hYdXjbZciVhhZhhZhZ[[ZXi^kZ bZVhjgZhidVYVeii]ZZm^hi^c\i]gZZgZ\^dch ]djh^c\hidX`# J@8>EjhZhVgVc\Zd[Zb^hh^dchhXZcVg^dh idegd_ZXii]ZZmiZcid[[jijgZXa^bViZX]Vc\Z! l^i]]^\]ZgZb^hh^dchgZhjai^c\^c\gZViZg X]Vc\Z^ci]Zadc\ZgiZgb#=dlZkZg!^ci]Z bZY^jbiZgbjeidi]Z'%*%h!i]ZgZ^hcd I]ZJ@!^cXajY^c\i]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch]Vh ZmeZg^ZcXZYX]Vc\Zh^c^ihXa^bViZh^cXZbdhi h^\c^ÒXVciY^kZg\ZcXZ^ci]Zegd_ZXi^dchd[ d[i]Z]dbZhlZgZXdchigjXiZY#I]ZhZX]Vc\Zh iZbeZgVijgZ^cXgZVhZWZXVjhZi]Z\adWVa lVgb^c\i]Vil^aaWZZmeZg^ZcXZY^heg^bVg^an VgZgZÓZXiZY^cadc\"iZgbdWhZgkVi^dcVa * YZeZcYZcidc]^hidg^XVaVcYXjggZciZb^hh^dch# gZXdgYhi]Vih]dl / I]ZgZ[dgZVXi^dcidgZYjXZ\gZZc]djhZ\Vh ™IZcd[i]ZlVgbZhinZVghdcgZXdgY]VkZ Zb^hh^dch^cdgYZgidhiVW^a^hZVibdhe]Zg^X dXXjggZYh^cXZ&.%!l^i]?jan'%%+WZ^c\ i]ZlVgbZhibdci]dcgZXdgY!Vjijbc'%%+ XdcXZcigVi^dchVihV[ZaZkZah"Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z b^i^\Vi^dc"^hjg\ZciangZfj^gZY#6ii]ZhVbZ i]ZlVgbZhiVjijbc!VcY6eg^a'%%..^\jgZ&h]dlhegd_ZXi^dch[dgX]Vc\Zh ^cVccjVaVkZgV\ZYV^aniZbeZgVijgZVcY hjbbZgegZX^e^iVi^dc^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch# ™I]ZVkZgV\ZYjgVi^dcd[hjbbZg]ZVilVkZh ]Vh^cXgZVhZYWnWZilZZc)id&+YVnh^cVaa gZ\^dchd[i]ZJ@h^cXZ&.dgZh^\]i .i]Z i^bZi]dj\]!VYVeiVi^dcl^aaVahdWZcZZYZY lVgbZhi6eg^a# idXdeZl^i]i]ZjcVkd^YVWaZXa^bViZX]Vc\Zh ™6j\jhi'%%(lVhi]Z]diiZhiZkZg i]Vil^aadXXjg# bVm^bjbiZbeZgVijgZ^ci]ZJ@(-#*8 Vi.Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ &+ I]ZhZX]Vc\Zhl^aabZVci]Vii]Za^`Za^]ddYd[ ÈZmigZbZlZVi]ZgÉhjX]VhYgdj\]ih!]ZVilVkZh VcYÓddY^c\l^aa^cXgZVhZ#I]Z'%%).VkZgh]Vb!@Zci# GZigdÒii^c\Zm^hi^c\]dbZhidZcVWaZi]Zbid ™I]ZgZ]VhWZZcV\ZcZgVaigZcYd[ YZXgZVh^c\gV^c[Vaa^chjbbZgVcY ^cXgZVh^c\gV^c[Vaa^cl^ciZgl^i]]ZVk^Zg l^ciZgegZX^e^iVi^dcZkZcih# J@8>E%'egd_ZXi^dchVigZ\^dcVaaZkZahj\\Zhi i]Vi[dgi]Z^beVXiha^hiZYVWdkZ!X]Vc\Zhl^aa dXXjg[VhiZgVcYWZbdgZZmigZbZ^ci]Zhdji] VcYZVhid[i]ZXdjcign#I]^hbZVchi]Vii]Z i]gZZgZ\^dchVgZegd_ZXiZYidWZV[[ZXiZY!VcY bdgZhZkZgZan!i]Vcdi]ZgeVgihd[i]ZJ@# .jijgZ.

^\jgZ&I]gZZgZ\^dchXa^bViZX]Vc\Zegd_ZXi^dch [gdbJ@8>E#( ™.&.addY^c\^hV`Zn^beVXi!i]dj\]dkZg]ZVi^c\ VcYlViZghigZhhl^aaWZh^\c^ÒXVci# ™J=>^hZmeZXiZYidZmVXZgWViZdkZg]ZVi^c\^c aVg\ZjgWVcVgZVh# Hdji]:Vhid[:c\aVcY ™6agZVYnVlViZghigZhhZYVgZV!VcY ^cXgZVh^c\aZkZahd[YZkZadebZcil^aa^bedhZ [jgi]ZgYZbVcYh# ™:[[ZXihd[dkZg]ZVi^c\VcYÓddYg^h`hVgZ VagZVYnWZ^c\ZmeZg^ZcXZY# .^\jgZ'/ AdcYdc ™JgWVc]ZVi^haVcYJ=>Z[[ZXi^hZmeZXiZYid ZmVXZgWViZdkZg]ZVi^c\!Vh]VhVagZVYnWZZc ZmeZg^ZcXZY^c'%%(VcY'%%+# ™I^YVa!Ójk^VaVcYhjg[VXZlViZgÓddY^c\XdjaY gZhjai^cbV_dgÒcVcX^Va^beVXih# ™6agZVYnVlViZghigZhhZYVgZV# :Vhid[:c\aVcY . Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ 8a^bViZVcYYZbd\gVe]^XX]Vc\Z^ci]Z i]gZZgZ\^dchVgZV I]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchVgZV^cXdgedgViZhAdcYdcVcY ZVhiVcYhdji]"ZVhi:c\aVcY#>i]VhVedejaVi^dc d['&b^aa^dc+"Veegdm^bViZan)%eZgXZcid[i]Z idiVaedejaVi^dcd[:c\aVcYVcYLVaZh"VcY XdkZghVcVgZVd[)%%!%%%`bTl^i]VWdjcYVgn gjcc^c\[gdbi]Z>haZd[L^\]iidi]ZLVh]# 6aai]gZZgZ\^dchVgZZmeZXiZYidZmeZg^ZcXZ Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z^beVXih!hjbbVg^hZYWZadl VcY^aajhigViZY^c.

addY^c\/>cXgZVhZYjgWVc^hVi^dcgZhjaih^c gZYjXZYlViZgVWhdgei^dcXVeVX^in!aZVY^c\ idbdgZhjg[VXZlViZggjcd[[VcY^cXgZVhZY ÓddY^c\#BVcn[ZVijgZhhjX]VheZgk^djh eVk^c\!edcYh!gV^clViZgWjiih!VcY\gZZcgdd[h XVcWZVeea^ZYid^cY^k^YjVa]dbZhdg\gdjeh d[YlZaa^c\hidgZYjXZi]^hgjcd[[!Z^i]ZgYjg^c\ XdchigjXi^dcdgV[iZghdbZnZVghd[dXXjeVi^dc# EaVcc^c\Eda^XnHiViZbZci'*egdbdiZh YZkZadebZciadXViZYdjid[ÓddYeaV^ch!VcY [dgVaaYZkZadebZciidgZYjXZÓddYg^h`dkZgVaa# I]^hXVcWZVeVgi^XjaVg^hhjZ^ci]ZgZjhZd[ egZk^djhandXXje^ZYh^iZhVig^h`d[ÓddY^c\! VcYi]ZYZkZadebZcid[i]ZhZbjhi^cXajYZ bZVhjgZhidgZYjXZÓddYg^h`# LViZghigZhh/BjX]d[i]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch^h VagZVYnXdch^YZgZYidWZVcVgZVd[hZg^djh lViZghigZhh!l^i]XVgZ[jabVcV\ZbZci gZfj^gZYidZchjgZi]ViXjggZcigZhdjgXZh VgZhj[ÒX^Zci#JcaZhhVgZYjXi^dc^ceZgXVe^iV Xdchjbei^dcXVcWZVX]^ZkZY!Vc^cXgZVh^c\ edejaVi^dcVcYVc^cXgZVh^c\cjbWZgd[h^c\aZ eZghdc]djhZ]daYhl^aaWg^c\jchjhiV^cVWaZ aZkZahd[YZbVcY# DkZg]ZVi^c\/=^\]ZgYZch^inYZkZadebZcihl^aa gZhjai^cVc^ciZch^ÒXVi^dcd[J=>Z[[ZXih!l]^X] gZhjaih^cjgWVcVgZVhWZ^c\hZkZgVaYZ\gZZh lVgbZgi]VcgjgVaVgZVhdchjbbZgc^\]ih# .^\jgZ'I]ZI]gZZGZ\^dch#J@8>E# 9Zbd\gVe]^XX]Vc\Z 8a^bViZ^beVXihl^aaiV`ZeaVXZ^ci]Z XdciZmid[YZbd\gVe]^XVcYa^[ZhinaZX]Vc\Zh# 7n'%'*!i]ZVgZVÉhedejaVi^dc^hZmeZXiZYid VeegdVX]')b^aa^dceZdeaZ.&- Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ 8a^bViZ^beVXih   NORWICH Great Yarmouth PETERBOROUGH Lowestoft East  CAMBRIDGE  Bedford  IPSWICH Dunstable  COLCHESTER Stevenage  LUTON  Clacton-on-sea   OXFORD  WATFORD  Chelmsford High Wycombe   Basildon SLOUGH  London  READING  Basingstoke  Guildford  Reigate South East PORTSMOUTH    Ashford  CRAWLEY  SOUTHAMPTON   Margate  Chatham  Maidstone  BRIGHTON Worthing Bognor Regis   Hastings EASTBOURNE .VcYVii]ZhVbZ i^bZ!hdX^VaX]Vc\ZhbZVci]VibdgZeZdeaZ VgZX]ddh^c\ida^kZVadcZ#I]ZhZ[VXidghl^aa XdbW^cZid^cXgZVhZi]ZkdajbZVcYYZch^in d[cZl]djh^c\VXgdhhi]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch! eaVX^c\VYY^i^dcVaegZhhjgZdci]ZbidVYVei idi]Z^beVXihd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z# .

*#&%  :VX]gZ\^dch]dlhVhegZVYWZilZZci]ZV\Zh d[YlZaa^c\h#I]ZZVhiVcYhdji]"ZVhigZ\^dch VgZWgdVYanh^b^aVg!l^i]i]Zbdhiegda^ÒX XdchigjXi^dceZg^dYWZ^c\WZilZZc&..!%+%!%%%]dbZh#.VcY&.+*VcY &.-)!l]ZcVabdhiVi]^gYd[Vaa]djh^c\lVh Wj^ai#AdcYdcÉh]djh^c\hidX`^hdaYZg!l^i] bdgZi]Vc*%eZgXZci]Vk^c\WZZcWj^aiWZ[dgZ &.*d[Zm^hi^c\Wj^aY^c\hlZgZ XdchigjXiZYWZ[dgZ&.&.)*!VcY ™'%lZgZXdchigjXiZYWZ[dgZ&.&.*! ™)%lZgZXdchigjXiZYWZ[dgZ &..)!l^i]aZhhi]Vc[djgeZgXZciWZ[dgZ&-*% VcYÒkZeZgXZciV[iZg&.))!VcY(%eZgXZciWZilZZc&.^\jgZ(6\Zd[Wj^aY^c\h^ci]ZI]gZZGZ\^dch# 7VhZYdcYViV[gdb8A<# .))# I]^hkVg^VW^a^inbZVchi]Vii]ZkjacZgVW^a^in d[i]Z]djh^c\hidX`idi]Zi]gZZ^beVXih ^YZci^ÒZY^ci]^hhijYn^hVahdkVg^VWaZdc VgZ\^dcVa!adXVaVcY^cY^k^YjVaWj^aY^c\ hXVaZ#I]ZXdchigjXi^dcd[Vc^cY^k^YjVa Wj^aY^c\l^aaVahd^cÓjZcXZi]ZhZaZXi^dc d[VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh# I]ZhZ[VXidghbjhiWZiV`Zc^cidVXXdjci l]ZchZaZXi^c\VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh[dg ZVX]^cY^k^YjVaYlZaa^c\!Vhi]ZnXdjaY WZXdjciZgegdYjXi^kZ^[^chiVaaZY^cVc ^cVeegdeg^ViZWj^aY^c\# ™.&-# .I]ZhidX`^h ZmigZbZankVg^VWaZ^ciZgbhd[h^oZ!V\Zd[ XdchigjXi^dcVcYineZd[VXXdbbdYVi^dc# 6Xgdhhi]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch!i]ZkVhibV_dg^ind[ i]Z]djh^c\hidX`lVhWj^aiWZilZZc&-*&VcY &.. Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ =djh^c\hidX`^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch :gVd[XdchigjXi^dc I]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchYdbZhi^X]djh^c\hidX` Xdch^hihd[.

.%eZg XZci]VhVagZVYnWZZcWj^ai# I]ZWj^aY^c\hXdchi^iji^c\Zm^hi^c\]djh^c\ hidX`^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchlZgZYZh^\cZY[dg i]ZegZkV^a^c\Xa^bViZVii]Zi^bZd[ XdchigjXi^dc!cdii]ZXa^bViZlZXVcZmeZXi idZmeZg^ZcXZcdlVcYdkZgi]ZXdb^c\ YZXVYZh#6hdjgXa^bViZX]Vc\Zhdjg]djh^c\ hidX`l^aaWZXdbZ^cXgZVh^c\an^cVeegdeg^ViZ# I]ZYZh^\cd[cZl]djh^c\^hXadhZan XdcigdaaZYWneaVcc^c\gZfj^gZbZcihVcY Wj^aY^c\gZ\jaVi^dch!VcYhdV[gVbZldg` Zm^hihid\j^YZYZkZadebZciidlVgYhVYVeiZY VcYadl"XVgWdc]dbZh#>cXdcigVhi!i]ZgZ ^hcdgZ\jaVidgn[gVbZldg`idYZVal^i]i]Z VYVeiVi^dcd[Zm^hi^c\]dbZh!VcYcdh^c\aZ ^chi^iji^dc]VhdkZgh^\]id[VhhZhh^c\i]Z hiViZd[Zm^hi^c\]djh^c\!Zchjg^c\i]Vii]Zn VgZÒi[dgejgedhZ# .eZgXZcid[Vaa]dbZhVi Vcn\^kZci^bZ#>[i]^hgViZ^hhjhiV^cZY!i]Z bV_dg^ind[i]Z]djh^c\hidX`l^aaXdci^cjZid Xdch^hid[Zm^hi^c\Wj^aY^c\h[dgbVcnYZXVYZh idXdbZ#I]ZHjhiV^cVWaZ9ZkZadebZci 8dbb^hh^dcÉhZhi^bViZh&'[dgi]ZJ@Éh'%*% ]djh^c\hidX`hj\\Zhii]ViVgdjcY.%!l^i]hiZZa"[gVbZY! XdcXgZiZÓddgh[gdbi]Z&..+%h! ^c^i^Vaand[egZ"XVhiXdcXgZiZ!i]Zcd[^ch^ij XdcXgZiZ[gdb&.*%h!VeVgibZciWj^aY^c\hje idiZchidgZnh]^\]lZgZXdchigjXiZYjh^c\ adVY"WZVg^c\bVhdcgnlVaahVcY!aViZg! XdcXgZiZÓddgh#6[iZgi]ViXdcXgZiZ[gVbZY Wj^aY^c\hlZgZWj^ai#7adX`hd[dkZgi]^gin hidgZnhWZ\VcidWZXdchigjXiZY^ci]Z&.dgZmVbeaZ!XVk^inlVaahWZ\Vc idWZedejaVg^ci]Z'%i]XZcijgn!l^i]Wg^X`$ Wg^X`XVk^inlVaahZbZg\^c\Yjg^c\i]Z&.addY^c\ '% LViZg HigZhh I]ZV\Zd[VWj^aY^c\XVcWZjhZYid^cY^XViZ ^ihgZhedchZidXa^bViZ^beVXih!VcYidhj\\Zhi i]ZineZhd[VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhi]Vih]djaY WZXdch^YZgZY#.dg daYZgWj^aY^c\hXdchigjXiZYWZ[dgZi]^heZg^dY! VaiZgcVi^kZdei^dch[dg^chjaVi^c\lVaah!hjX] Vh^ciZgcVaanVcYZmiZgcVaanÒiiZY^chjaVi^dc! h]djaYWZXdch^YZgZY# Jci^ai]Z&..(%h VcYWZ^c\gZeaVXZY^ci]Z^gijgc[gdbi]Z&.%hdclVgYh#&& DkZg]ZVi^c\ L]nYdlZcZZYidXdch^YZgl^YZhegZVY VYVeiVi^dcd[Zm^hi^c\]dbZh4 HidX`ijgcdkZg^ci]ZJ@^hadl!l^i]Zm^hi^c\ hidX`bV`^c\je.Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ .*%h dclVgYhl^i]Wg^X`$WadX`XVk^inlVaah#.

addY^c\/ L^i]djiVYVeiVi^dc!Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z^beVXih l^aaV[[ZXii]ZZm^hi^c\]djh^c\hidX`VXgdhh i]Zl]daZd[i]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchVgZV!l^i] ]dbZhediZci^VaanWZXdb^c\jc^c]VW^iVWaZ# ™EgdeZgi^ZhVig^h`d[ÓddY^c\^cZVhiZgc :c\aVcYg^hZhWn)-[gdb'.%!%%%id)%)!%%% :[[ZXi^kZVYVeiVi^dcdei^dchVgZXjggZcian [daadl^c\V%#)bhZVaZkZag^hZVhhjb^c\cd VkV^aVWaZ[dgVaai]gZZd[i]Z^beVXihXdkZgZY cZlWj^aYWZilZZccdlVcY'%*%#&( ^ci]^hhijYn#:Vgan!l^YZhegZVYVYdei^dc d[Veegdeg^ViZVYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhl^aa ™I]Z6hhdX^Vi^dcd[7g^i^h]>chjgZgh67> ZcVWaZZm^hi^c\]dbZhidgZbV^c]VW^iVWaZ Zhi^bViZhi]Vi^[cdhiZehVgZiV`Zcid ^c^cXgZVh^c\hjbbZgiZbeZgVijgZh!WZ bVcV\ZÓddYg^h`hi]Zci]ZXdhid[ÓddY YVbV\ZY]dbZhXdjaYg^hZWn—'&bVccjVaan! gZdXXje^ZYbdgZfj^X`anV[iZgÓddYh!VcY l^i]J@^chjgVcXZXdhih[dgZmigZbZlZVi]Zg XdchjbZaZhhlViZg# ZkZcih^c'%*%WZ^c\VgdjcY—&+W^aa^dc#&) ™I]ZhjbbZgÓddYhd['%%.VgZZhi^bViZYid ]VkZ^chjgZYXdhihd[—(W^aa^dcXdhihdc'%%. WVh^h!l^i]&+*!%%%XaV^bh^cidiVa#&) LViZghigZhh/ ™I]ZJ@:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn]VhZhi^bViZY i]ViV&%"&*eZgXZci^cXgZVhZ^cgZhZgkd^g XVeVX^inbVnWZgZfj^gZYidVYYgZhh ediZci^ValViZgYZÒX^ih!ViVcZhi^bViZY Xdhid[—(W^aa^dc#&* DkZg]ZVi^c\/ ™I]ZbV^c^beVXid[dkZg]ZVi^c\l^aaWZ i]ZgbVaY^hXdb[dgi#=dlZkZg!^cZmigZbZ dgegdadc\ZYeZg^dYhd[]^\]iZbeZgVijgZh ZmXZhhYZVi]hl^aadXXjg#>ci]Z'%%( ]ZVilVkZ^ci]ZJ@!'!%%%ZmXZhhYZVi]h dXXjggZY!+%%d[l]^X]lZgZ^cAdcYdc#&+ ™6g^hZ^ci]Z^chiVaaVi^dcd[YdbZhi^XV^g XdcY^i^dc^c\l^aa^cXgZVhZ8DZb^hh^dch! i]ZZaZXig^XVaXdda^c\adVY!cd^hZcj^hVcXZ VcYi]Zg^h`hd[edlZgXjih# .'& Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ :[[ZXihd[ÓddY^c\!lViZghigZhhVcY dkZg]ZVi^c\^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch .

'' >i^hcdiZcdj\][dgeZdeaZid`cdli]Vii]ZgZ VgZdei^dchVcYi]Vii]ZnVgZ\ddYkVajZÄi]Zn   ]VkZidWZa^ZkZ^iVcYlVciidVYVei# :ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn .

!%%%VcY&)*!%%% eZdeaZgZheZXi^kZan#I]Z:Vhid[:c\aVcY GZ\^dc]VhVgdjcY-.!%%%eZdeaZa^k^c\^c VgZVhl^i]i]^haZkZad[g^h`#hZZ.%!%%%^ci]ZI]VbZh VgZV!VcY)'!%%%^cHdji]Zgc:c\aVcY&- ZmXajY^c\ÓddY^c\[gdbXdVhiVaVcY \gdjcYlViZghdjgXZh# EgZX^e^iVi^dc 8a^bViZX]Vc\Zegd_ZXi^dchhj\\Zhi Vc^cXgZVhZ^ci]Z[gZfjZcXnd[^ciZchZ egZX^e^iVi^dcZkZcih#I]ZhZXVjhZÓVh]! hZlV\ZVcYÓjk^VaÓddY^c\# HZVaZkZag^hZ 8a^bViZX]Vc\Zl^aaaZVYidhZVaZkZag^hZ# >cVYY^i^dc!hdji]Zgc:c\aVcY^hh^c`^c\ VcYcdgi]"lZhiZgcVgZVhd[i]ZJ@g^h^c\ gZaVi^kZidhZVaZkZaVhVgZhjaid[i]ZaVhi^XZ V\Z#HZVaZkZag^hZ^hZmeZXiZYidV[[ZXiXdVhiVa VgZVhd[Vaai]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch!bV`^c\i]Zb bdgZhjhXZei^WaZidÓddY^c\hZZIVWaZ&# AdcYdcVcYi]ZI]VbZh<ViZlVnÉhkjacZgVW^a^in ^hWZ^c\VcVanhZYVheVgid[i]Z:ck^gdcbZci 6\ZcXnÉhI]VbZh:hijVgn'&%%egd_ZXi!YjZ [dgXdbeaZi^dc^c'%&%# Hidgbh J@8>E%'egd_ZXih^cXgZVhZYl^cYheZZYh[dg i]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch!hj\\Zhi^c\V\gZViZgg^h`d[ hidgbhjg\ZhVcYVc^cXgZVhZ^ci]ZcjbWZgd[ l^cYhidgbh!Xdcig^Wji^c\id^cXgZVhZYg^h`d[ XdVhiVaÓddY^c\#I]Z^cXgZVhZYÓddYg^h`[gdb ZVX][VXidg^hhjbbVg^hZY^cIVWaZ'# .'( .*#I]ZHdji]:Vhi VcY<gZViZgAdcYdcgZ\^dch]VkZi]ZaVg\Zhi edejaVi^dcl^i]h^\c^ÒXVciX]VcXZd[ ÓddY^c\!l^i]VgdjcY'&.addY^c\ ^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch I]Z:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn\Vi]ZghÓddYg^h` YViVdcVcVi^dcVa!gZ\^dcVaVcYadXVaVgZV hXVaZ#I]Z^gCVi^dcVa.XVcWZjhZYid^cY^XViZi]ZcjbWZg d[eZdeaZa^k^c\^cVgZVhl^i]Vh^\c^ÒXVci i]ZX]VcXZd[ÓddY^c\^cVcnnZVg^h\gZViZg i]Vi&#(eZgXZci&^c.^\jgZ)# I]Z6hhdX^Vi^dcd[7g^i^h]>chjgZgh67> Zhi^bViZhi]ZcjbWZgd[YdbZhi^XegdeZgi^Zh Vig^h`d[ÓddY^c\^hVeegdm^bViZan'&*!%%%^c i]ZZVhid[:c\aVcY!&.addYG^h`6hhZhhbZci YViV&.

000 75.000 .50.000 25.000 .000 .Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ ') Total property count with significant likelihood of flooding CZiHZVAZkZaG^hZbb$ngGZaVi^kZid&.aVbWdgdj\]=ZVY# HdjgXZ/V[iZgIVWaZ7#&!EEH'*#&.50.000 50.75.% < 25.000 >100.100.%"'%'* '%'*"'%** '%**"'%-* '%-*"'&&* )#% -#* &'#% &*#% Regional Planning Body Boundary EA Water Management Region Total property count with significant likelihood of flooding EA Water Management Area < 25.000 .000 50.000 . Unauthorised reproduction infringes Crown copyright and may lead to prosecution or civil proceedings.000 75.%" '%'* HdjgXZ/V[iZgIVWaZ7#'!EEH'*#&.000 Regional Planning Body Boundary EA Water Management Region IVWaZ&GZXdbbZcYZYXdci^c\ZcXnVaadlVcXZh[dg cZihZVaZkZag^hZ[dgi]ZZVhid[:c\aVcY!ZVhiB^YaVcYh! AdcYdcVcYhdji]"ZVhi:c\aVcY# Hdji]d[.000 &.000 25. 100026380. EA Water Management Area EVgVbZiZg This map is reproduced from Ordnance Survey material with the permission of Ordnance Survey on behalf of the Controller of Her Majesty’s Stationery Office (c) Crown Copyright. Environment Agency.000 ..75.100.^\jgZ)GZ\^dchgVc`ZYWncjbWZgd[egdeZgi^Zh^c VgZVhl^i]h^\c^ÒXVci\gZViZgi]Vc&^c. 2006 '%'*" '%** '%**" '%-* '%-*" '&&* EZV`GV^c[Vaa ^ciZch^in * &% '% (% EZV`g^kZgÓdl &% '% d[[h]dgZl^cY heZZY * &% ZmigZbZlVkZ ]Z^\]i * &% IVWaZ'GZXdbbZcYZYcVi^dcVaegZXVji^dcVgn hZch^i^k^ingVc\Zh[dgeZV`gV^c[Vaa^ciZch^i^Zh!eZV` g^kZgÓdlh!d[[h]dgZl^cYheZZYhVcYlVkZ]Z^\]ih# 0 20 40 60 80 km . ...*X]VcXZd[ ÓddY^c\#:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn# &.000 >100.

'* Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ :ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn .ZWgjVgnaZYid—'#&W^aa^dc^c^chjgVcXZ XaV^bh#DkZgV[djg"lZZ`eZg^dY!i]gZZb^aa^dc XaV^bhlZgZgZXZ^kZY# &. I]ZJ@ZmeZg^ZcXZY^ihlZiiZhihjbbZgdc gZXdgY!l^i]h^\c^ÒXVciÓddY^c\dXXjg^c\^c i]Zcdgi]ZVhiVcYhdji]lZhid[:c\aVcY# >c^i^VaÒ\jgZhejii]ZidiVa^chjgVcXZW^aa [dgi]ZhZÓddYhVi—(W^aa^dc!l^i]^cY^k^YjVa YdbZhi^XXaV^bhVkZgV\^c\—*%!%%%# IVWaZ(@ZnJ@ÓddY^c\ZkZcihV[iZg67>'%%)#'& =dlZkZg!i]ZXdhihd[ÓddY^c\\d[VgWZndcY i]ZÒcVcX^Va"[dg]djhZ]daYZghi]ZgZ^hi]Z Y^higZhhd[hZZ^c\i]Z^g]dbZhVcY edhhZhh^dchgj^cZYWnÓddYlViZghl]^X] VgZd[iZcXdciVb^cViZYl^i]hZlV\Z!VcYi]Z dc\d^c\^cXdckZc^ZcXZd[WZ^c\Y^heaVXZY[gdb i]Z^g]dbZh#>iXVciV`Zi]gZZidh^mbdci]h [dg[Vb^a^ZhidWZVWaZidbdkZWVX`^cidi]Z^g ]dbZhVcY^chdbZXVhZhbVniV`ZdkZgVnZVg# 9ViVdcÓddYg^h`^hejWa^XanVkV^aVWaZ#I]Z :ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXnÉhdc"a^cZ..addYBVe'' \^kZhadXVi^dchi]ViVgZXdch^YZgZYVig^h` d[ÓddY^c\[gdbg^kZgh!]^\]i^YZhVcYhidgb hjg\Zh#I]^h^hejWa^XanVkV^aVWaZ!l^i]V edhiXdYZhZVgX][VX^a^ini]ViVaadlh^cY^k^YjVa ]djhZ]daYZghidVXXZhhYZiV^ahd[i]ZÓddYg^h` idi]ZVgZVd[aVcYl]ZgZi]Z^g]dbZ^hadXViZY# I]ZhZh]dlildineZhd[ÓddYg^h`/i]dhZi]Vi ]VkZV&eZgXZciX]VcXZd[ÓddY^c\^cVcndcZ nZVg!VcYi]dhZi]Vi]VkZV%#&eZgXZciX]VcXZ d[dXXjgg^c\[gdbg^kZghdgi]ZhZV# =dlZkZg!i]^h^c[dgbVi^dcYdZhcdi VjidbVi^XVaanaZVYidVXi^dcWn]djhZ]daYZgh# 6XXdgY^c\idi]Z:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn!È>i^hd[ hZg^djhXdcXZgci]Vihi^aadcandcZeZghdc^c iZcl]d^hVig^h`bV`ZhVcnhdgid[VYkVcXZ egZeVgVi^dc[dgÓddY^c\É#'( .- :VhiZgÓddYh^c&..-aZYidi]ZZkVXjVi^dcd[ &!*%%eZdeaZ[gdbi]Z^g]dbZh!VcYVXdhiid i]Z^chjgVcXZ^cYjhignd[VgdjcY—*%%b# '%%% I]ZJ@ZmeZg^ZcXZY^ihlZiiZhiVjijbc[dg Vabdhi(%%nZVgh!l^i]]ZVkngV^c[VaaaZVY^c\ idYVbV\Zd[&%!%%%egdeZgi^Zh!VcYcZVgan—& W^aa^dc^c^chjgVcXZXaV^bh# '%%.% HidgbhVcYXdVhiVaÓddY^c\^c?VcjVgnVcY .addY^c\"i]Z^beVXihd[[V^ajgZidVYVei EgZY^XiZYJ@Xdhih[dgZmigZbZÓddY^c\ ZkZcih^cVcndcZnZVgVgZZmeZXiZYid ^cXgZVhZ[gdb—&!*%%bidYVnid—)!*%%b ^c'%*%[dg^caVcYÓddYh!VcY[gdb—*!%%%b idYVnid—)%!%%%b[dgZmigZbZXdVhiVa ÓddY^c\ZkZcih#'% @ZnÓddY^c\ZkZcih^cgZXZcinZVghVcY ^chjgVcXZXdhih &..

gZZ 9gV^cV\ZWjc\h[dgYgV^ch!h^c`hVcYid^aZih A GZh^hiVcXZbZVhjgZhVgZdcanZ[[ZXi^kZ^[ VaaediZci^VaZcigned^cihVgZ^YZci^ÒZYVcY WadX`ZY!VcYhdÓddYgZh^hiVcXZbZVhjgZh bjhiWZ^chiVaaZYVhVXdbeaZiZeVX`V\Z#.gZZ GZ\^hiZgl^i]:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXnÓddY lVgc^c\hX]ZbZ .addY^c\"VYVeiVi^dcdei^dchVcYXdhih I]ZgZVgZVcjbWZgd[VYVeiVi^dcdei^dch idegdiZXiV]dbZ[gdbÓddY^c\dgbV`Z^i fj^X`ZgVcYX]ZVeZgidYgndjiVcYgZeV^gV ]dbZ#I]ZhZbZVhjgZh[Vaa^cidildXViZ\dg^Zh/ EVX`V\Zhd[gZh^hiVcXZbZVhjgZhl^aakVgn [dgZkZgnegdeZgin!Wjiine^XVaZmVbeaZhd[ bZVhjgZh^cXajYZ/ BZVhjgZ 8dhi 8]ZX`i]Z:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn.dgi]^hgZVhdc! egd[Zhh^dcVaVYk^XZh]djaYValVnhWZhdj\]i l]Zc^chiVaa^c\ÓddYgZh^hiVcXZbZVhjgZh# >chiVaalViZgegdd[bZbWgVcZdcZmiZgcValVaah = ™GZh^hiVcXZbZVhjgZh/egZkZci^c\dga^b^i^c\ i]ZVbdjcid[lViZgZciZg^c\i]Z]dbZ# ™GZh^a^ZcXZbZVhjgZh/gZYjX^c\i^bZVcY Xdhid[gZXdkZg^c\[gdbVÓddY# .dg h]dgiYjgVi^dcÓddYh!Zcigned^cih^cXajYZ Yddgh!V^gWg^X`h!h^c`hVcYid^aZih!VcY\Veh ^cZmiZgcValVaahVgdjcYe^eZhVcYXVWaZh# .addYBVe .^icdc"gZijgckVakZhdcbV^chYgV^ch B"= >chiVaaYZbdjciVWaZYddg\jVgYh B"= BdkZbZiZghVcYZaZXig^XVahdX`ZihVWdkZ ÓddYaZkZah B"= >chiVaaVÈhjbeVcYejbeÉWZadl\gdjcYaZkZa = GV^hZYddgi]gZh]daYh = GZed^ciWg^X`ldg`dcZmiZgcValVaah = 6eeanlViZgegdd[gZcYZgidlVaah = >cYZZeÓddYhdkZg%#.Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ '+ :ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn .dgadc\ZgYjgVi^dch!bZVhjgZhl^aacZZYid WZiV`ZcidegZkZcilViZgZciZg^c\i]gdj\] i]ZlVaah#7Vh^XbZVhjgZh^cXajYZgZeV^g^c\ YVbV\ZYbdgiVg!l]^ahibdgZegdiZXi^dcl^aa WZdWiV^cZYWn^chiVaa^c\lViZgegdd[ bZbWgVcZhdggZcYZgh# >chiVaaV^gWg^X`XdkZgh A HZVa\VehVgdjcYe^eZVcYXVWaZZcig^Zh A .b!VhigViZ\nd[ ZmXajY^c\lViZg[gdbi]Z]dbZbVncdiWZ gZXdbbZcYZY!Vh^bWVaVcXZWZilZZcZmiZgcVa VcY^ciZgcValViZgaZkZahXVcXVjhZhigjXijgVa YVbV\Zidi]ZlVaah!VcY^ibVnWZcZXZhhVgn idVaadllViZgidZciZg#.

'.addYHdaji^dch ™.dg]^\]"aZkZaÓddYh!VeVX`V\Zd[ gZh^hiVcXZbZVhjgZhbVnXdhi[gdb —'%!%%%id—)%!%%%!Wjii]^hbVnhi^aa WZgZXdkZgZY^cVh^c\aZÓddY^c\ZkZci# ™I]ZXdhid[VÓddYbVnWZXdkZgZYWn ^chjgVcXZ!WjiadlZgXaV^bhl^aagZYjXZ egZb^jbh!VcY^cZmigZbZXVhZhbZVc i]Vii]ZegdeZgingZbV^ch^chjgVWaZ# ™.addYWVgg^ZghidegZkZci^cjcYVi^dc ?#HX]dda^c\ . Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ 8dhiWVcYh/ .addYYVbV\Z IdiVa.dgVh]VaadlÓddY^c\ZkZci!hbVaaZg egdeZgi^ZhXVcWZegdiZXiZY[dgVha^iiaZ Vh—'!(%%!l]^aZgZXdkZg^c\[gdbVÓddY bVnXdhi[gdb—)!*%%id—'(!%%%# .gZZ A" Adl—&"—&%%  B" BZY^jb—&%&"—&%%%  =" =^\]—&%%&  8dhiWZcZÒid[^chiVaa^c\ gZh^hiVcXZbZVhjgZh/ ™.dgi]dhZl]dXVccdidWiV^cÓddY^c\ ^chjgVcXZ!VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhgZegZhZci V\ddY^ckZhibZci!gZYjX^c\i]ZÒcVcX^Va ^beVXid[VÓddY^c\ZkZci# .

gZZ GZ\^hiZgl^i]:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXnÓddY lVgc^c\hX]ZbZ .Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ '- GZh^a^ZcXZbZVhjgZhVgZV^bZYVigZYjX^c\ i]Zi^bZVcYXdhid[gZXdkZg^c\[gdbVÓddY i]Vi]VhZciZgZYi]Z]dbZ#Jca^`ZgZh^hiVcXZ! i]ZWZcZÒih[gdbgZh^a^ZcXZbZVhjgZhVgZ XjbjaVi^kZ!hdZVX]^begdkZbZciXVcWZ bVYZ^cY^k^YjVaan!VcY\^kZhVWZcZÒiWn^ihZa[# BVcnd[i]ZhZVYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhXVcWZ ^chiVaaZYl]Zci]Z]djhZ]daYZg^hXdcYjXi^c\ eaVccZYbV^ciZcVcXZdggZYZXdgVi^dc[dga^iiaZ dgcdZmigVXdhi# Ine^XVagZh^a^ZcXZbZVhjgZh^cXajYZ/ BZVhjgZ 8dhi 8]ZX`i]Z:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn.gZZ HidgZkVajVWaZhVcYeVeZgldg`jehiV^gh .gZZ Ijgcd[[\Vh!lViZgVcYZaZXig^X^inbV^ch .gZZ .^ig^h^c\]^c\ZhhdYddghXVcWZgZbdkZY A JhZYgn"WV\hidegdiZXihd[i[jgc^h]^c\h A JhZlViZg"gZh^hiVcieV^ci[dgi]Z adlZgedgi^dchd[^ciZgcValVaah A"B GZl^gZ!gV^h^c\ZaZXig^XVaed^cih VWdkZÓddYaZkZal^i]l^g^c\Ygdeh [gdbVWdkZ B GZadXViZbZiZghVcYWd^aZgVWdkZÓddYaZkZa B GZadXViZl]^iZ\ddYhdcVea^ci]VWdkZ ÓddYaZkZa B GZeaVXZXVgeZihl^i]k^cnaVcYXZgVb^Xi^aZh VcY$dggj\h B"= GZeaVXZi^bWZgÓddghl^i]hda^YXdcXgZiZ = 8dhiWVcYh/ .addYBVe .gZZ A" Adl—&"—&%% 8dhiWZcZÒid[^chiVaa^c\  B" BZY^jb—&%&"—&%%% gZh^hiVcXZbZVhjgZh/  =" =^\]—&%%&  ™EVnWVX`^hVX]^ZkVWaZV[iZgdcZidi]gZZ ÓddY^c\ZkZcih!ZkZc[dgbV_dgegd_ZXih hjX]VhgZadXVi^c\Wd^aZgh# ™EVnWVX`i^bZ^hgZYjXZY^[bZVhjgZh XVcWZ^cXdgedgViZY^cideaVccZYdg gdji^cZgZYZXdgVi^dcVcYgZ[jgW^h]bZci# ™Egd_ZXihhjX]VhgZedh^i^dc^c\d[ Wd^aZgVcYl]^iZ\ddYhXVcWZYdcZ VigZeaVXZbZci# ™GZh^YjVaXdhihl^aagZbV^c!WjiVc Z[[ZXi^kZeVX`V\ZgZYjXZh^chjgVcXZ XaV^bhWn*%id-%eZgXZci—'%!%%% id—('!%%%#') .

gZZ A" Adl—&"—&%%  B" BZY^jb—&%&"—&%%%  =" =^\]—&%%&  I]ZXVhZhijYndjia^cZYaViZg^ci]^h YdXjbZciYZhXg^WZhine^XVaÓddYgZh^hiVcXZ VcYgZh^a^ZcXZbZVhjgZhVcYeVnWVX` eZg^dYh[dgVhZb^"YZiVX]ZY]dbZ# .'. Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ :miZgcVabZVhjgZhidgZYjXZgjcd[[VcYVaadl ÓddYlViZgidYgV^c^cidi]Z\gdjcYVgZY^[ÒXjai idfjVci^[nWji[dgbVc^bedgiVcieVgid[ ÓddYlViZgbVcV\ZbZcihigViZ\^Zh# :mVbeaZh^cXajYZedgdjheVk^c\HjhiV^cVWaZ 9gV^cV\ZHnhiZbh!dgHJ9HVcY\gZZcgdd[h# GV^clViZg]VgkZhi^c\bZVhjgZhbVnVahdWZ ]Zae[ja^[i]ZXdaaZXi^dciVc`hVgZZbeinVii]Z i^bZd[i]ZÓddY!VXi^c\VhVhidgV\ZkdajbZ! i]dj\]i]^hXVccdiWZgZa^ZYjedc# BZVhjgZ 8dhi JhZedgdjhbViZg^VahdgdeZchigjXijgZhdc Yg^kZlVnhidZcVWaZlViZgidYgV^c^cid\gdjcY = :chjgZi]ViÓddYeVi]lVnhdcYg^kZlVnZcVWaZ = YgV^cV\ZVlVn[gdbi]Z]dbZ AVg\ZhXVaZgV^clViZg]VgkZhi^c\hnhiZb = <gZZcgdd[h = 8dhiWVcYh/ .

(% LViZghigZhh ^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch LViZghigZhhdXXjghl]ZcXjggZci YZbVcY[dglViZg^h]^\]^cXdbeVg^hdc l^i]Z[[ZXi^kZhjeean[gdbegZX^e^iVi^dc VcY\gdjcYlViZghdjgXZh#I]ZZVhi! AdcYdcVcYhdji]ZVhigZ\^dchVaaXdciV^c aVg\ZVgZVhd[lViZghigZhh# .^ii^c\hGZ\jaVi^dch# I]^h^hYZbdchigViZYWnÒ\jgZh[gdbI]VbZh LViZgh]dl^c\VkZgV\ZeZgXVe^iVjhZeZgYVn g^h^c\[gdb&)%a^igZh^c&..^kZ]jcYgZYg^kZgh!aV`Zh!VcYlZiaVcYh^c :c\aVcYVgZVagZVYnVig^h`d[YVbV\Z[gdb dkZg"VWhigVXi^dc#'*I]^hbVngZegZhZciVc ^cXZci^kZ[dghVk^c\lViZg!VhbVcnXdchjbZgh VgZbdgZXdcXZgcZYVWdjii]ZZck^gdcbZciVa ^beVXid[i]ZVbdjcid[lViZgi]ZnjhZi]Vc ^ihY^gZXiXdhi#'+ 6cVYY^i^dcVaedejaVi^dcd[jeidi]gZZb^aa^dc eZdeaZVgZZmeZXiZYida^kZ^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch Wn'%'*#'.-%id&*(a^igZh^c &.dgi]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch!VcdkZgVaaYZXgZVhZ ^cidiVaVccjVaegZX^e^iVi^dc^hegd_ZXiZY# 7di]gZYjXZYhjbbZgi^bZegZX^e^iVi^dcVcY i]Z\gZViZgZkVedgVi^dcd[hjg[VXZbd^hijgZ XVjhZYWn]diiZgiZbeZgVijgZhl^aagZhjai^c adlZglViZgVkV^aVW^a^in^chjbbZg#L^ciZg egZX^e^iVi^dc^hegd_ZXiZYid^cXgZVhZ!Wjii]ZgZ l^aaWZVXdggZhedcY^c\^cXgZVhZ^ci]ZcjbWZg d[^ciZchZgV^c[VaaZkZcih#H^cXZlViZghidgV\Z XVeVX^in^hÒc^iZ!i]ZhZ^ciZchZZkZcihYdcdi cZXZhhVg^anaZVYidZ[ÒX^ZciXVeijgZd[lViZg# 8a^bViZX]Vc\Zegd_ZXi^dchhj\\Zhii]Vi^c i]ZeZg^dYid'%*%VcYWZndcY!i]ZJ@l^aa ZmeZg^ZcXZlZiiZgl^ciZghVcYYg^ZghjbbZgh# DkZgVaaegZX^e^iVi^dcbVnYZXgZVhZWnjeid &*eZgXZcijcYZgi]Z]^\]Zb^hh^dchhXZcVg^d! 6hlZaaVhedh^c\VegdWaZb[dgi]Z]jbVc l^i]Xdch^YZgVWaZadXVaVcYgZ\^dcVakVg^Vi^dc# edejaVi^dc!lViZghigZhhl^aaVahdXdbedjcY  dkZg"VWhigVXi^dc^hhjZh^ci]gZZgZ\^dchVgZV# .Adc\"iZgbeZgXVe^iVXdchjbei^dc ^h^cXgZVh^c\YjZidX]Vc\Zh^c]djhZ]daYh^oZ VcY^cXgZVhZY^chiVaaVi^dchd[Veea^VcXZhhjX] VhÈedlZgh]dlZghÉ#I]^h]VhaVg\Zand[[hZi hVk^c\hbVYZWni]Z^cigdYjXi^dcd[bdgZ Z[ÒX^ZciVeea^VcXZh![dgZmVbeaZL8h!jcYZg i]ZLViZgHjeeanLViZg.%VcYid&+(a^igZh^c'%%*#=dlZkZg!gZXZci YViVh]dlhi]Vii]ZgViZd[^cXgZVhZ]VhhadlZY VcY^chdbZVgZVhXdchjbei^dc]VhhiVgiZYid .

dg i]ZXVhZhijYn]djhZ!hVk^c\hd[jeid'%%!%%% a^igZhd[lViZgeZg]djhZ]daYeZgnZVgXdjaY WZVX]^ZkZY!l]^ahii]ZÓViXVhZhijYnl^i] ilddXXjeVcihn^ZaYZYhVk^c\hd[. 8VhZhijY^ZhdcVine^XVa]djhZ!ÓViVcY WadX`^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchhj\\Zhii]Vi hjWhiVci^VahVk^c\hXVcWZbVYZWngZigdÒii^c\ Vh^beaZeVX`V\Zd[bZVhjgZh^c]dbZh#.'!%%% a^igZheZgnZVg# :hi^bViZhWni]Z:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn(% hj\\Zhi^cVine^XVa]djhZ]daY!gZigdÒii^c\ h^beaZbZVhjgZhhjX]Vhi]dhZ^ci]ZXVhZ hijY^ZhXVcgZhjai^chVk^c\hd[&)eZgXZci d[VkZgV\Z]djhZ]daYXdchjbei^dc#>[i]ZhZ bZVhjgZhXdjaYWZZmiZcYZYVXgdhhi]Z .!%+%!%%%]djhZ]daYh^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch VgZV!i]ZlViZghVk^c\hXdjaYWZjeid)&% bZ\V"a^igZheZgYVndg&*%!%%%bZ\V"a^igZh eZgnZVg#I]^h^hZfj^kVaZciidi]ZidiVa YdbZhi^XlViZgjhZ^ci]gZZX^i^Zhi]Z h^oZd[7^gb^c\]Vb# .(& Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ YZXgZVhZha^\]ian#'-7VhZYdcXjggZcigViZhd[ Xdchjbei^dc!i]Z^cXgZVhZ^cedejaVi^dcl^aa aZVYid^cXgZVhZYYdbZhi^XlViZgYZbVcY^c i]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchWn)*%bZ\V"a^igZheZgYVn# I]ZdkZgVaae^XijgZ^hi]ZgZ[dgZdcZd[ ^cXgZVh^c\edejaVi^dcVcYYZbVcY[dglViZg! XdjeaZYl^i]gZYjXZYgV^c[Vaaejii^c\egZhhjgZ dclViZggZhdjgXZh^cVcVgZVVagZVYnjcYZg lViZghigZhh# LViZghigZhh"i]Z^beVXihd[[V^ajgZidVYVei >[i]ZYZbVcY[dglViZgdjihig^ehhjeean! ^cXgZVh^c\aZkZahd[gZhig^Xi^dch]VkZidWZ ^bedhZYdcXjhidbZghidZchjgZi]Vihj[ÒX^Zci hjeean^hbV^ciV^cZY[dgZhhZci^VacZZYh# =dhZe^eZVcYheg^c`aZgWVchlZgZ^bedhZY WnhZkZclViZgXdbeVc^Zh^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch Yjg^c\i]ZhjbbZgd['%%+!l^i]V[jgi]Zg i]gZZXdbeVc^ZhVeean^c\[dgYgdj\]ieZgb^ih# >cXgZVh^c\hjeeanidVkd^Y^ciZggjei^dc]Vh VÒcVcX^VaXdhi!gZfj^g^c\VYY^i^dcVahidgV\Z! ejbeh!VcYigZVibZci^c[gVhigjXijgZ#I]^h ldjaYVYYidi]ZgZcZlVaVcYgZeaVXZbZci XVeVX^inVagZVYneaVccZY# .^\jgZ*BZVcVccjVaegZX^e^iVi^dcjcYZgadlVcY ]^\]Zb^hh^dchhXZcVg^dh[dg'%'%h!'%*%hVcY'%-%h#'.

dgi]ZXVhZhijYn]djhZ! jh^c\VlViZg"Z[ÒX^Zcih]dlZggZhjaiZY^c lViZghVk^c\hd[)%!--%a^igZheZgnZVg#6iV ]dilViZgiZbeZgVijgZd[)%•8!i]^hgZhjaih^c ZcZg\nhVk^c\hd[VgdjcY&!)(%`L]eZgnZVg[dg i]Z]djhZ]daY#6ccjVaXVgWdchVk^c\hVbdjci id+%%`\8DVcYi]ZediZci^VaÒcVcX^VahVk^c\ ^hVgdjcY—&('eZgnZVg# 6kZgV\ZYV^anXdchjbei^dcd[lViZg^h VgdjcY&)%id&.%a^igZheZgeZghdc^ci]Z i]gZZgZ\^dch!l^i]dcZ"i]^gYd[i]^hWZ^c\ jhZY[dgeZghdcVaWVi]^c\#L^i]Vh]dlZgdg WVi]iZbeZgVijgZd[)%•8!VhVk^c\d[&)eZg XZci^c]dilViZgXdchjbei^dcVXgdhhi]ZVgZV ldjaYgZhjai^cVgZYjXi^dcd[.(%!%%%idccZh d[8DZb^hh^dcheZgnZVg!(&Zfj^kVaZciidi]Z Zb^hh^dchd[VgdjcY(%%!%%%XVgh# I]ZgZ^hVahdZcZg\nZbWZYYZY^clViZg ejg^ÒXVi^dc!YZa^kZgnVcYigZVibZci#8VgWdc Y^dm^YZXdhih('[dgi]Zhjeeand[[gZh]lViZg ]VkZWZZcZhi^bViZYVi%#'-.idccZheZg bZ\V"a^igZ!VcYi]dhZVhhdX^ViZYl^i]i]Z igZVibZcid[lVhiZlViZgVgZ%#)%+idccZh eZgbZ\V"a^igZ#>[i]ZgZigdÒii^c\hXZcVg^d YZhXg^WZYVWdkZlZgZ^beaZbZciZY!VX]^Zk^c\ hVk^c\hd[&*%!%%%bZ\V"a^igZheZgnZVgd[XdaY lViZg!i]^hldjaYgZegZhZcihVk^c\hd[&%)!%%% idccZhd[XVgWdcY^dm^YZeZgnZVg# .Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ (' @#8dafj]djc 6ai]dj\]bZiZgZY]djhZ]daYhl^aagZXdje i]ZXdhihd[^ckZhibZci^clViZg"Z[ÒX^Zci egdYjXih!i]ZbV_dg^ind[YdbZhi^XegdeZgi^Zh ^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchVgZcdibZiZgZY# 6YY^i^dcVaan!ZkZc[dgbZiZgZY]dbZh!i]Z XjggZcigZaVi^kZanadlkdajbZig^XXdhid[lViZg gZYjXZhi]ZÒcVcX^Va^cXZci^kZid^ckZhi^c lViZg"Z[ÒX^ZcibZVhjgZh#=dlZkZg!gZYjX^c\ i]ZXdchjbei^dcd[]dilViZg^ci]Z]dbZ gZegZhZcihVXdch^YZgVWaZdeedgijc^in[dgVaa ]djhZ]daYZghidhVkZbdcZnVcYgZYjXZi]Z^g XVgWdcZb^hh^dch#.

eZgXZcid[i]ZlViZggZfj^gZYid bV^ciV^cXdchjbei^dcViXjggZciaZkZahl]^aZ VXXdbbdYVi^c\eaVccZYcZlYZkZadebZcih#(( HdbZd[i]ZbdhiZ[[ZXi^kZbZVhjgZhVgZi]Z aZVhiZmeZch^kZ#.dgZmVbeaZ!^ci]ZXVhZhijYn ]djhZ!Òii^c\VadlÓdlh]dlZg]ZVYhVkZhVh bjX]lViZgVhÒii^c\VcZladlÓjh]id^aZi# AVg\Zg^iZbh!hjX]VhlViZg"Z[ÒX^Zcil]^iZ \ddYh!]VkZVadc\ZgeVnWVX`i^bZ!Wjii]Z eg^XZegZb^jb^hcdih^\c^ÒXVci^[i]ZnVgZ gZeaVXZYVii]ZZcYd[i]Z^gdeZgVi^c\a^kZh# 6YVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh[dgYdbZhi^XWj^aY^c\h ^cXajYZVgVc\Zd[adl"Xdhidei^dchi]ViXVc WZ^cXajYZYVheVgid[eaVccZYgZigdÒidg gZ[jgW^h]bZcihX]ZbZh#I]ZhZbZVhjgZh VgZXjbjaVi^kZ!VcYVai]dj\]i]ZÒcVcX^Va hVk^c\h^ciZgbhd[XdaYlViZgXdhi[dgVc ^cY^k^YjVa^iZbXVcWZgZaVi^kZanhbVaa!i]Zn YdgZhjai^cgVe^YeVnWVX`i^bZ#L]ZcZcZg\n hVk^c\h[gdb]dilViZghVkZYVgZiV`Zc^cid VXXdjci!ÒcVcX^VahVk^c\hXVcWZh^\c^ÒXVci# .dgZmVbeaZ! gZYjX^c\VcZ^\]i"b^cjiZh]dlZgWni]gZZ b^cjiZhhVkZhbdgZlViZgi]VcgZeaVX^c\ i]ZhiVcYVgYh]dlZg]ZVYl^i]VbdgZlViZg "Z[ÒX^ZcikZgh^dc#BVcnh^beaZhj\\Zhi^dch[dg hVk^c\lViZgVgZVkV^aVWaZ[gdbhdjgXZhhjX] VhLViZgl^hZ()VcYlViZgXdbeVcnlZWh^iZh# lll#\gZZcWj^aY^c\hidgZ#Xd#j` .dgZmVbeaZ!i]ZXVhZhijY^Zhhj\\Zhii]Vi hl^iX]^c\idVadl"Ódlh]dlZg]ZVYXVchVkZ ''a^igZhd[]dilViZgeZgeZghdceZgYVn! gZYjX^c\ZcZg\nXdchjbei^dcWn'-%`L]eZg nZVgVcYhdine^XVaanhVk^c\—'+eZgeZghdc# I]^hgZedgiXdcXZcigViZhdcgZigdÒii^c\ bZVhjgZh[dglViZgXdchZgkVi^dcVcY Z[ÒX^ZcXn!Wjii]ZZ[[ZXihd[WZ]Vk^djgVa X]Vc\ZVgZVahdh^\c^ÒXVci#.(( Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ LViZgHigZhh"VYVeiVi^dcdei^dchVcYXdhih I]ZgZXZci[ZVh^W^a^inhijYndcÈLViZg CZjigVa^in[dgi]ZI]VbZh<ViZlVnÉh]dlZY i]VigZigdÒii^c\Zm^hi^c\]dbZh^ci]ZI]VbZh <ViZlVnl^i]lViZg"hVk^c\Veea^VcXZhXdjaY hVkZ'(").

a id)#*aeZgÓjh] 8^hiZgcY^heaVXZbZci .^aa^c\WjX`Zi[gdblViZg WjiiZa^b^cViZhjhZd[ (%%abV^chlViZg$lVh] AdlÓdl`^iX]Zc iVeVYVeiZg A . gZYjX^c\[gdb-%a$adVY id)(a$adVY IVWaZ)Dei^dch!XdhihVcYhVk^c\h[dgVgVc\Z d[lViZg"hVk^c\bZVhjgZh!eZgXVe^iV#(* I]ZXVhZhijYndceV\Z)-\^kZh lViZghVk^c\hVcYeVnWVX`eZg^dYh [dgVhZaZXi^dcd[gZigdÒii^c\bZVhjgZh# 8dhiWVcYh/ . &* [gdb&'id+a$b^c LViZg"Z[ÒX^Zci Y^h]lVh]Zg B &'%* ' gZYjX^c\[gdb'*a$adVY id&)a$adVY LViZg"Z[ÒX^Zci lVh]^c\bVX]^cZ B )*.gZZ[gdblViZg Jeid*'*+ YZk^XZ XdbeVc^Zh &% GZYjX^c\Ójh] kdajbZWnjeid(a KVg^VWaZÓjh] gZigdÒi`^i A Jeid. hVk^c\..Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ () LViZg"hVk^c\YZk^XZ 8dhiWVcY EdiZci^ValViZghVkZY! BZiZgZYkVajZd[lViZg LViZghVk^c\" eZgeZghdceZgnZVga hVkZY!eZgnZVg— ZaZbZciVa AdlÓdlh]dlZg dgh]dlZg]ZVY A"B -&.+ &+ GZYjX^c\Ódl[gdb &%#-a$b^cid-a$b^c JaigVadlÓjh] id^aZigZeaVXZbZci B .%a$lZZ` <VgYZclViZg^c\ A *%%% &% lViZg\VgYZcjh^c\ lViZg[gdblViZg Wjiih#*#(a$Wjii$YVn 8VglVh]^c\ A &*+)( (& .a GZeV^gYg^ee^c\iVeh A ).--) &* GZYjX^c\Ójh] kdajbZWnjeid)#*a AdlÓdlWVi]gddb iVeh&#.'.)* .' .--) &* GZYjX^c\[gdb.gZZ A" Adl—&"—&%%  B" BZY^jb—&%&"—&%%%  =" =^\]—&%%&  . &% gZYjX^c\Ódl[gdb +#*aid&#.aÓdl A *%-.

hjgkZnXVgg^ZYdji^c '%%*!-%eZgXZcid[XdchjbZghVgZl^aa^c\ idX]Vc\Zi]Z^ga^[ZhinaZhidgZYjXZ Zck^gdcbZciVa^beVXi#L]^aZgZeaVX^c\ ^cZ[ÒX^ZcilViZg"jh^c\egdYjXihl^i]i]dhZ i]VigZYjXZlVhiV\ZXVcgZYjXZlViZg Xdchjbei^dcWnjeidVi]^gY!WZ]Vk^djgVa X]Vc\ZhXVcVahdaZVYidh^\c^ÒXVcihVk^c\h# ™>[ZkZgn]djhZ]daY^ci]ZJ@hl^iX]ZY [gdbbV^chlViZgidgV^clViZgidlViZg i]Z^g\VgYZchVcYlVh]i]Z^gXVgh!i]^h XdjaYhVkZ(%!%%%b^aa^dca^igZhd[lViZg ZVX]hjbbZg#I]VildjaYWZZcdj\]lViZg idÒaa7ZlaGZhZgkd^g!i]ZaVg\ZhigZhZgkd^g ^c@Zci!gZYjXZYiddcan(+eZgXZciXVeVX^in ^cZVgan'%%+#HdjgXZ/LViZgl^hZ# ™>[ZkZgndcZ^ci]ZJ@ijgcZYd[[i]ZiVel]^aZ Wgjh]^c\i]Z^giZZi]!Zcdj\]lViZgldjaY WZhVkZYidhjeeani]Zl]daZd[HXdiaVcY# HdjgXZ/LViZgl^hZ# ™>[ViZci]d[7g^i^h]]dbZhÒmZY_jhidcZ Yg^ee^c\iVe!Zcdj\]lViZgldjaYWZhVkZY idhjeeani]Zl]daZd[8dkZcigndg8VgY^[[# HdjgXZ/LViZgl^hZ# ™7niV`^c\Vh]dlZg^chiZVYd[VWVi]!dcZ eZghdcXVchVkZVWdji(*a^igZhd[lViZgeZg ZkZciVcYVWdji'`L]d[ZcZg\n!Xjii^c\]^h dg]ZgXVgWdc[ddieg^ci^cidiVaWnVWdji]Va[ V`^ad\gVb!dgZcdj\]8DidÒaa&-eVgin WVaaddchHdjgXZ/LViZgl^hZ$:HI# ™>[dcZeZghdcXjidcZb^cjiZd[[i]Z^gh]dlZg i^bZ[dgVnZVg!i]ZnldjaYhVkZ(!(%%a^igZh d[lViZgeZgnZVgVcY'%%`L]d[ZcZg\n# I]ViÉhZcdj\]ZcZg\nid]ZVilViZg[dgdkZg +!%%%Xjehd[Xd[[ZZI]ZeZghdcÉhgZYjXZY XVgWdc[ddieg^cildjaYWZ*%`\d[8D" Zcdj\]idÒaa&!-%%eVginWVaaddchdg&'gZY iZaZe]dcZWdmZh#HdjgXZ/LViZgl^hZ$:HI# ™>[VWdlalVhjhZY[dglVh]^c\je^chiZVY d[lVh]^c\[dgÒkZb^cjiZhjcYZgVgjcc^c\ iVe!VhVk^c\d[VWdji(%a^igZheZglVh] XdjaYWZbVYZ# .^\jgZh 6XXdgY^c\idVLL.VXihVcY.(* Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ LViZghigZhh"XdchjbZggZhedchZ BdgZi]Vc*%eZgXZcid[XdchjbZghldjaY WZegZeVgZYideVnid]VkZi]Z^g]djhZ gZigdÒiiZY^[^ildg`ZYlZaaVcYhVkZYlViZg#(+ HdbZLViZg.

[dgi]ZÒghii^bZdc gZXdgY!l^i]iZbeZgVijgZhd[(-#*•8 gZXdgYZY^ci]Zhdji]ZVhi# J@8>E%'egd_ZXi^dch[dgiZbeZgVijgZh(-^c i]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch[dgi]Z'%'%h!'%*%hVcY '%-%hh]dlVh^b^aVgeViiZgcVXgdhhVaai]gZZ gZ\^dch!VcYhj\\Zhii]ViWn'%*%lZXVc ZmeZXiidZmeZg^ZcXZVhjbbZga^`Zi]Z]di hjbbZgd['%%(ZkZgndi]ZgnZVg#7ni]Z '%-%h!i]ZVccjVaVkZgV\ZYV^aniZbeZgVijgZ ^cXgZVhZhWn'id(•8jcYZgi]Zadl Zb^hh^dchhXZcVg^dVcYWn)id*•8jcYZg i]Z]^\]Zb^hh^dchhXZcVg^d#I]ZgZl^aaVahd WZVc^cXgZVhZ^ci]Z[gZfjZcXnd[hjbbZg YVnhdkZg(%•8# >caVg\ZjgWVcVgZVh!hjX]VhAdcYdc! EZiZgWdgdj\]VcYHdji]Vbeidc!c^\]ii^bZ iZbeZgVijgZhVgZ[jgi]ZgZaZkViZYWni]Z jgWVc]ZVi^haVcYZ[[ZXi!l^i]Wj^aY^c\hVcY ^c[gVhigjXijgZhdV`^c\je]ZViYjg^c\i]ZYVn VcYZb^ii^c\^iYjg^c\i]Zc^\]i# .--#(.(+ DkZg]ZVi^c\ ^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch >ci]ZJ@!hjbbZgh]VkZWZZcWZXdb^c\ lVgbZgdkZgi]ZaVhii]gZZYZXVYZh!l^i] c^cZd[i]ZiZclVgbZhinZVgh^ci]ZaVhi (*%nZVghdXXjgg^c\h^cXZ&.I]Z hjbbZghd['%%(VcY'%%+lZgZeVgi^XjaVgan ]di#>c6j\jhi'%%(iZbeZgVijgZh^ci]ZJ@ ZmXZZYZY(-•8&%%•.

(, Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ

I]ZZ[[ZXid[dkZg]ZVi^c\dcWj^aY^c\h
I]ZgZVgZhZkZgVabZX]Vc^hbhl]^X]
XVjhZVWj^aY^c\id\V^c]ZVi/
™>ciZgcVa]ZVi\V^chi]ZhZVgZXVjhZY
WnlVhiZ]ZVi[gdbZfj^ebZciVcYa^\]ih!
WjiXVcWZa^b^iZYWnjh^c\adl"ZcZg\n
Zfj^ebZcihjX]VhZcZg\n"hVk^c\a^\]i
WjaWh!VcYWnijgc^c\Zfj^ebZcid[[l]Zc
cdi^cjhZ#DkZggZXZciYZXVYZh^cXgZVh^c\
jhZd[ZaZXig^XVaZfj^ebZci]VhVYYZYid
i]Z]ZVi^c\d[Wj^aY^c\h#

[gdbkZci^aVi^dcVadcZ#J@8>Eegd_ZXi^dchVgZ
[dgbdgZ[gZfjZcihjbbZgYVnhdkZg(%•8#
I]ZJ=>Z[[ZXil^aaZmVXZgWViZi]^h^cWj^ai"je
VgZVh!eVgi^XjaVgan^caVg\ZidlchVcYX^i^Zh!Wn
gZYjX^c\i]ZXVeVX^inidXddaWj^aY^c\hVic^\]i#

7ni]Z'%*%h!egd_ZXiZYhjbbZgiZbeZgVijgZh
^ci]ZJ@l^aaWZh^b^aVgidi]dhZ]^hidg^XVaan
ZmeZg^ZcXZY^cbZY^iZggVcZVcXa^bViZh!l]ZgZ
Wj^aY^c\higVY^i^dcVaan]VkZhbVaa!h]jiiZgZY
l^cYdlhdchdji]VcYlZhi[VX^c\lVaah!
VcYVgZd[iZceV^ciZYl]^iZidgZÓZXi]ZVi#
8djginVgYhVgZVahdjhZYid\ddYZ[[ZXi!l^i]
™=ZVi\V^ci]gdj\]l^cYdlhhdaVggVY^Vi^dc
kZ\ZiVi^dcVcYlViZg[ZVijgZhidiZbeZgi]Z
eVhhZhi]gdj\]i]Zl^cYdlVcY]^ihi]Z
^ciZgcVahjg[VXZhd[i]Zgddb!lVgb^c\i]Zb XdjginVgYZck^gdcbZci#7VghdkZgl^cYdlh
jeVcYXVjh^c\i]Zbid]ZVijei]ZV^g^ch^YZ dci]ZdjiZg[VVYZVaadll^cYdlhidWZaZ[i
i]Zgddb#H]VY^c\l^i]h]jiiZgh!Vlc^c\hdg deZcl^i]djihZXjg^inXdcXZgch#I]ZhZ
[ZVijgZhVaadlbZY^iZggVcZVcWj^aY^c\h
Wa^cYh]ZaehgZYjXZi]^h]ZVi\V^c#
idgZbV^cXdb[dgiVWaZl]Zci]ZZmiZgcVa
™HdaVg]ZVi\V^ci]gdj\]lVgb^c\d[ZmiZgcVa
iZbeZgVijgZ^h]^\]#IgVY^i^dcVaJ@Wj^aY^c\
hjg[VXZhgdd[hVcYlVaahiZcYidVWhdgW
hinaZhYdcdi^cXajYZi]ZhZ[ZVijgZh!VcYhd
]ZVi!l]^X]\gVYjVaaneVhhZhi]gdj\]id
l^aaWZbdgZegdcZiddkZg]ZVi^c\#
i]Z^ciZgcVahjg[VXZhVcYXVjhZhi]Z^ch^YZ
heVXZhidlVgbje#EV^ci^c\i]ZZmiZgcVa
lVaah^ca^\]iXdadjghl^i]gZÓZXi^kZeV^ci
XVc]Zaeidb^c^b^hZi]^hZ[[ZXi#
™:miZgcVaV^giZbeZgVijgZl]Zci]Zdjih^YZ
iZbeZgVijgZ^h]^\]Zgi]Vci]Z^ch^YZ
iZbeZgVijgZ!deZcl^cYdlhl^aaVYb^i]di
V^g!XVjh^c\i]ZWj^aY^c\id]ZVije#
>cbdhiJ@YlZaa^c\hi]Zeg^cX^eVabZVchd[
`ZZe^c\Xdda^chjbbZg^hkZci^aVi^dc!jhjVaan
egdk^YZYWndeZc^c\l^cYdlh#=^hidg^XVaan!
i]^hbZi]dYd[Xdda^c\]Vhldg`ZYVYZfjViZan
^ci]ZJ@l]Zc^i]VhWZZcgZaVi^kZanXdda
djih^YZ#=dlZkZg!Vhdjih^YZiZbeZgVijgZh
g^hZ^il^aaWZXdbZ]VgYZgidegdk^YZXdda^c\

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ

(-

DkZg]ZVi^c\"^beVXihd[[V^ajgZidVYVei
D[i]Zi]gZZ`Zn^beVXihXdkZgZY^ci]^h
hijYn!^i^hdkZg]ZVi^c\i]Vi]VhWZZc
Y^gZXiangZhedch^WaZ[dgi]Z]^\]Zhi
cjbWZgd[YZVi]h^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch
^cgZXZci]^hidgn#DkZg]ZVi^c\^hVi^ihbdhi
YVc\Zgdjhl]Zcc^\]ii^bZiZbeZgVijgZhYd
cdiYgdehj[ÒX^Zcian[dgi]ZWdYnidXddaYdlc
VcYgZXdkZg!VcYl]ZciZbeZgVijgZhgZbV^c
]^\][dghZkZgVaYVnh^cVgdl#8jggZcian!
8>7H:<j^YZ6(.XaVhh^ÒZhdkZg]ZVi^c\^c
YlZaa^c\hVhVcZmXZZYVcXZd['-•8[dgdcZ
eZgXZcid[dXXje^ZY]djgh^ca^k^c\VgZVh!
VcYVcZmXZZYVcXZd['+•8[dgdcZeZg
XZcid[dXXje^ZY]djgh^cWZYgddbh#>i^h
gZXdbbZcYZYi]ViiZbeZgVijgZhZmXZZY^c\
(%•8VgZVkd^YZY#
>c6j\jhi'%%(VcZhi^bViZY'!%%%
egZbVijgZYZVi]hdXXjggZY^ci]ZJ@VhV
gZhjaid[]ZVihigZhhdkZgi]Zild"lZZ`
eZg^dYd[i]Z]ZVilVkZ!l^i]+%%d[i]ZhZ
YZVi]hdXXjgg^c\^cAdcYdcVadcZ#
:bZg\ZcXnVYb^hh^dchid]dhe^iVahgdhZ
Wnh^meZgXZci^ci]ZhVbZeZg^dY#>c;gVcXZ!
l]ZgZi]Z]ZVilVkZlVhZkZcbdgZ^ciZchZ!
&*!%%%egZbVijgZYZVi]hVgZZhi^bViZYid
]VkZdXXjggZYVhVgZhjaid[i]ZZmigZbZ]ZVi
VcYViaZVhi)*!%%%)%VXgdhh:jgdeZVhVl]daZ#
Cd]ZVilVkZ^c\adWVa]^hidgn]VhegdYjXZY
hdbVcnYdXjbZciZYYZVi]h#

>bedgiVcian!i]ZYZVi]hY^YcdidXXjg
l]ZgZiZbeZgVijgZhlZgZ]^\]Zhi!Wji
l]ZgZi]ZnlZgZbdhijcjhjVa#;dgZmVbeaZ!
i]ZiZbeZgVijgZhi]ViXVjhZYhdbVcnYZVi]h
^cEVg^hldjaYcdi]VkZWZZcXdch^YZgZY
jcjhjVa^c8V^gd!8VaXjiiVdgGdbZ!WjilZgZ
+•8dkZgi]Z6j\jhiVkZgV\Z[dgi]ZX^in#6
bV_dg[VXidg^ha^`Zanid]VkZWZZci]Z^cVW^a^in
d[Wj^aY^c\hYZh^\cZY[dg]^hidg^XXa^bViZhid
`ZZe^cYddgiZbeZgVijgZhl^i]^cgZVhdcVWaZ
a^b^ih!^cXgZVh^c\i]Ze]nh^dad\^XVahigZhhdc
kjacZgVWaZ^cY^k^YjVah#
I]Z\gVe]WZadlh]dlh]dleZV`h^cYZVi]
gViZXadhZan[daadlZYiZbeZgVijgZhe^`Zh
dkZgi]ZeZg^dYd[i]Z]ZVilVkZ^ci]ZJ@!
^cXdbeVg^hdcidVkZgV\ZYZVi]gViZh[dg
i]ViYVn^ci]ZegZXZY^c\ÒkZnZVgh#

;^\jgZ+9V^anYZVi]h^c:c\aVcYVcYLVaZhVcY
bVm^bjbXZcigVa:c\aVcYiZbeZgVijgZ!?janVcY6j\jhi
'%%(#)&8gdlc8deng^\]i#

(. Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ

6YY^i^dcVaan!dkZg]ZVi^c\XVcXVjhZ
Y^hXdb[dgiVcYaZVYidaVX`d[haZZeVcY
adhhd[egdYjXi^k^inVcYVaZgicZhh#
=ZVilVkZhVahdZmVXZgWViZlViZghigZhh
i]gdj\]^cXgZVhZYWVi]^c\VcYY^hXgZi^dcVgn
jhZd[lViZg![dgZmVbeaZ[dg\VgYZclViZg^c\
VcY^ceVYYa^c\eddah#
6^gXdcY^i^dc^c\bVnWZk^ZlZYVhV
hdaji^dc!Wjii]ZY^hVYkVciV\Zhd[bVhh
iV`Z"je^cXajYZ^cXgZVhZh^clVhiZ]ZVi!
cd^hZ!VcYdc\d^c\ZcZg\nXdhih#Cdidcan
YdZhi]Z^cXgZVhZYZcZg\njhZejihigV^c
dci]ZZaZXig^X^in^c[gVhigjXijgZ!Wji^iVahd
aZVYhidVc^cXgZVhZ^c8DZb^hh^dch#>[*%
eZgXZcid[]dbZh^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchjhZY
V^gXdcY^i^dc^c\Vh^cdjgXVhZhijY^Zh!i]^h
ldjaYgZhjai^cVYY^i^dcVa8DZb^hh^dchd[
dcZb^aa^dcidccZheZgnZVg!Zfj^kVaZciidVc
VYY^i^dcVa)*%!%%%XVghdci]ZgdVY#)'

6gje

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ )% DkZg]ZVi^c\"VYVeiVi^dcdei^dchVcYXdhih L]^ahiVX`cdlaZY\^c\i]Vi^i^hedhh^WaZid XddaWj^aY^c\hjh^c\V^gXdcY^i^dc^c\!i]^h gZedgiXdcXZcigViZhdceVhh^kZbZVhjgZh i]ViVaadl]djhZ]daYZghidbV^ciV^c Xdb[dgiVWaZiZbeZgVijgZhl]^aZVkd^Y^c\i]Z Zck^gdcbZciVaXdhihd[V^gXdcY^i^dc^c\!hjX] VhXVgWdcZb^hh^dch!cd^hZVcYlVhiZ]ZVi# EVhh^kZbZVhjgZhXdch^hid[gZYjX^c\^ciZgcVa ]ZVi\V^ch!Zc]VcX^c\cVijgVakZci^aVi^dcVcY gZYjX^c\hdaVg\V^ci]gdj\]i]Zl^cYdlhVcY [VWg^Xd[i]ZWj^aY^c\# >chjaVi^dcbZVhjgZh!hjX]Vh^chiVaa^c\ad[i VcYlVaa^chjaVi^dcVcYYdjWaZ\aVo^c\!XVc ]VkZVedh^i^kZZ[[ZXidc`ZZe^c\]dbZhXdda ^ci]ZhjbbZgVhlZaa^cXgZVh^c\l^ciZg ]ZVi^c\Z[ÒX^ZcXn#>cXgZVh^c\^chjaVi^dc]Zaeh egZkZci]ZVieZcZigVi^dc[gdbad[iheVXZh VcYi]gdj\]lVaah#=dlZkZg!^chjaVi^dcVahd gZYjXZh]ZViadhhi]gdj\]i]ZWj^aY^c\[VWg^X Vic^\]i#I]^hZ[[ZXiXVcWZXdbeZchViZY[dg Wn^cXgZVh^c\kZci^aVi^dcVic^\]iVcYYjg^c\ XddaZgeVgihd[i]ZYVn#>ci]Z[jijgZ^i^ha^`Zan i]Vii]ZgZl^aaWZ^cXgZVh^c\anYZbVcY^c\ ZcZg\nZ[ÒX^ZcXnhiVcYVgYh[dgcZl]dbZh VhlZaaVhXdci^cj^c\^c^i^Vi^kZhidZcXdjgV\Z WZiiZgiV`Z"jed[^chjaVi^dc# 6cZ[[ZXi^kZeVX`V\Zd[eVhh^kZbZVhjgZh idXdcigdadkZg]ZVi^c\^ci]ZhjbbZgXdjaY ^cXajYZZmiZgcVaVlc^c\h[dghdji]VcYlZhi" [VX^c\l^cYdlh!c^\]iejg\^c\jh^c\cVijgVa kZci^aVi^dc!XZ^a^c\[Vch^cZVX]gddb!VcY eV^ci^c\i]ZZmiZgcValVaahVa^\]iXdadjgid ^cXgZVhZi]Z^ggZÓZXi^k^in#8dhih[dgVine^XVa jcVYVeiZY]djhZ^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchldjaY WZVeegdm^bViZan—&+!%%%!Wji^[l^ciZglVgbi] bZVhjgZh]VkZVagZVYnWZZc^chiVaaZY!i]ZXdhi d[i]ZVYVeiVi^dceVX`V\ZldjaYWZ]VakZYid VgdjcY—-!%%%# 6YY^i^dcVabZVhjgZh^cXajYZi]ZjhZd[igZZh idegdk^YZh]VYZidi]Z[VVYZhVcYZkZcgdd[ d[i]ZWj^aY^c\#9ZX^YjdjhigZZhVgZegZ[ZggZY! WZXVjhZi]Znh]ZYi]Z^gaZVkZh^cl^ciZg Vaadl^c\a^\]i^cidi]ZWj^aY^c\#IgZZhVgZWZhi jhZYdci]ZlZhiVcYZVhi[VVYZhl]ZgZhjc Vc\aZhVgZadl#DkZg]Vc\hVcYgZigVXiVWaZ h]VYZhl]^X]hi^aaVaadll^ciZghjcVXXZhh! XVcWZjhZYdchdji]"[VX^c\VheZXih# 9^hVYkVciV\Zhd[jh^c\igZZh[dgh]VY^c\VgZ i]Vi^ibVniV`ZnZVgh[dgigZZhid\gdlidVc Z[[ZXi^kZ]Z^\]i!VcYi]Znh]djaYWZadXViZY Vhj^iVWaZY^hiVcXZ[gdbi]ZegdeZgin^cdgYZg idVkd^YXdcig^Wji^c\idhjWh^YZcXZegdWaZbh# <gZZcgdd[hXVcgZYjXZi]ZVbdjcid[]ZVi eZcZigVi^dci]gdj\]gdd[hVcY^ci]^hgZ\VgY eaVnVh^b^aVggdaZidgdd[^chjaVi^dc#I]^h^h WZXVjhZi]ZngZYjXZi]Zgdd[iZbeZgVijgZ i]gdj\]VWhdgei^dcd[]ZVi^cidi]Z^gÈi]ZgbVa bVhhÉVcYWZXVjhZd[ZkVedgVi^dcd[bd^hijgZ# 9^[[ZgZciineZhd[\gZZcgdd[VgZVkV^aVWaZVcY l^aa]VkZY^[[Zg^c\aZkZahd[i]ZgbVa^beVXi# <gZZcgdd[hgZfj^gZegd[Zhh^dcVahjgkZnhid ZhiVWa^h]l]^X]ineZ^hbdhihj^iVWaZVcY l]Zi]Zgi]Zgdd[higjXijgZcZZYhidWZ bdY^ÒZYidWZVgi]ZZmigVlZ^\]id[i]Zgdd[# .

gZZ A" Adl—&"—&%%  B" BZY^jb—&%&"—&%%%  =" =^\]—&%%&  B"= Hj^iVWaZdcanl]ZgZl^cYdl]VhYZZehZi# = GZYjXZYVW^a^inidkZci^aViZl]^aZVahd h]VY^c\#BVnWZadlZgXdhiVcY^hbdgZ gZkZgh^WaZi]VcgZeaVXZbZcil^cYdl# .)& Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ 6YVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZVcYWZcZÒih A^b^iVi^dch Hl^iX]d[[jcjhZYVeea^VcXZh!gZYjX^c\^ciZgcVa]ZVi \V^chVcYhVk^c\dcgjcc^c\Xdhih# 6eegdm#Xdhih .gZZ"A DeZcl^cYdlhVic^\]iid^cigdYjXZXddaV^g!egdk^Y^c\ cVijgVakZci^aVi^dc# HZXjg^inbVnWZVc^hhjZ# Edhh^WaZdjiYddgcd^hZVcYeddg V^gfjVa^in# .gZZ JhZXZ^a^c\dgYZh`[VchidXgZViZVadXVaXdda^c\Z[[ZXi# Cd^hZWjijhjVaanfj^ZiZgi]VcV^g XdcY^i^dc^c\# A"B >chiVaaVgZÓZXi^c\Wa^cY!kZci^aViZYWndeZcl^cYdl! idegdk^YZegdiZXi^dc[gdbi]ZhjcVcYgZYjXZ\aVgZ# HZXjg^inbVnWZVc^hhjZ# A"B"= 6lc^c\ÄegdiZXihgddbh[gdbi]Zhjcl]^aZVaadl^c\ a^\]i!l^cYdlkZci^aVi^dcVcYk^Zl# = H]jiiZgh"egdiZXigddbh[gdbi]ZhjcVcYbVn ^cXgZVhZhZXjg^in# GZYjXZYVW^a^inidkZci^aViZk^Vl^cYdlh A"B Vii]ZhVbZi^bZVhh]VY^c\# GZeaVXZXVgeZihl^i]lddYZcÓddghdgi^aZhid ZmedhZi]ZXdda^c\Z[[ZXid[i]Z\gdjcY#JhZgj\h [dgXdaYZgeZg^dYh# DcangZaZkVci^c\gdjcYÓddggddbhl^i] = hda^YÓddgXdchigjXi^dc# >begdkZgdd[^chjaVi^dchiVcYVgYidgZYjXZ]ZVi eZcZigVi^dc!eVgi^XjaVgan[dghaViZgdd[h#I]^hVahd gZYjXZhl^ciZg]ZViadhh$ZcZg\nW^aah# A"B >cXgZVhZgZÓZXi^k^ini]gdj\]a^\]i"XdadjgZYeV^ci^c\$ XdVi^c\hdclVaahVcYgdd[!egZkZci^c\]ZViWZ^c\ VWhdgWZY^cidi]Z[VWg^X# 6aiZghVeeZVgVcXZd[[VVYZ# A"B 8Vk^inlVaa^chjaVi^dcl]ZgZlVaaXVk^i^ZhVgZegZhZci idgZYjXZeZcZigVi^dcd[]ZVii]gdj\]lVaah# >cÓddYg^h`VgZVh!jhZXadhZY XZaa^chjaVi^dc# B"= 9djWaZ\aVo^c\!l^i]adl"ZXdVi^c\hidgZYjXZ]ZVi\V^c L^aa^cXgZVhZdkZg]ZVi^c\^[kZci^aVi^dc ^chjbbZgVcY]ZViadhh^cl^ciZg# egdk^h^dc^h^cVYZfjViZ# >chiVaahZXdcYVgnYdjWaZ\aVo^c\WZ]^cYZm^hi^c\\aVo^c\ ÈXa^bViZl^cYdlÉidXgZViZig^eaZ\aVo^c\!l^i]ZmiZgcVa kZci^aVi^dcd[djiZgXVk^in!i]ViXVc\gZViangZYjXZhdaVg ]ZVi\V^cegdk^YZY^ccZgeVcZgZbV^chXadhZY# 8dhiWVcYh/ .

)' I]ZgZ^hVaVX`d[`cdlaZY\Zl^i]^chdX^Zin VgdjcYVYVeiVi^dc#LZ]VkZVb^i^\Vi^dc"[dXjhZY b^cYhZi#LZcZZYidVeeanWdi]^cdjga^[ZhinaZh# .

•8WZilZZcX^inVcYgjgVaiZbeZgVijgZh lZgZbZVhjgZY^cAdcYdc#)( .I]ZiZbeZgVijgZd[jgWVcVgZVhl^i]gZheZXi idi]ZhjggdjcY^c\Xdjcignh^YZ#)( ."'%%% ZmeZg^bZciYZhXg^WZYVWdkZ#I]ZhXVaZh]dlhi]Z cjbWZgd[dXXVh^dchi]ViiZbeZgVijgZhZmXZZYZY&.)( I]ZjgWVc]ZVi ^haVcYZ[[ZXi I]ZJ@8>E%'Xa^bViZX]Vc\Zegd_ZXi^dch VgZWVhZYdcVbdYZai]ViVhhjbZhVgjgVa kZ\ZiViZYhjg[VXZdkZgi]Zl]daZXdjcign# I]ZgZ[dgZi]ZnYdcdiiV`Z^cidVXXdjcii]Z jgWVcaVcYhjg[VXZi]VibdY^ÒZhi]ZXa^bViZ d[X^i^Zhi]gdj\]i]ZJ=>Z[[ZXi#I]^hZ[[ZXi^h VcZaZkVi^dcd[jgWVciZbeZgVijgZXVjhZYWn i]Z^cXgZVhZYXVeVX^ind[i]ZjgWVcaVcY hjg[VXZidVWhdgWVcYigVe]ZVi# I]^hgZhjaih^cidlchVcYX^i^ZhgZbV^c^c\ cdi^XZVWan]diiZgi]Vci]ZhjggdjcY^c\ Xdjcignh^YZ!eVgi^XjaVganVic^\]idcXVab!XaZVg hjbbZgc^\]ih#I]ZJ=>XVcVYY*"+•8idi]Z c^\]ii^bZiZbeZgVijgZhZmeZg^ZcXZY#9jg^c\ i]ZhjbbZg]ZVilVkZd['%%(!Y^[[ZgZcXZhd[ jeid..^\jgZ-AdcYdcÉhJ=>!6j\jhi'%%()(h]dlh]dli]Z iZbeZgVijgZd[i]ZXVcdenaVnZg]ZVi^haVcYkVg^ZhVXgdhh AdcYdc#I]ZXVcdenaVnZgÈbVeÉlVhYZkZadeZYjh^c\V^g iZbeZgVijgZbZVhjgZbZcih\Vi]ZgZY^ci]Z&..•8 [dg)-XdchZXji^kZ]djgh#I]ZÈXgdhh]V^ghÉbZZidci]Z 7g^i^h]BjhZjb^ci]ZLZhi:cY#>iXVcWZhZZci]Vi]^\] iZbeZgVijgZheZgh^hi^cXZcigVaAdcYdc!l^i]È]dihedihÉ VcYÈXddahedihÉgdj\]anXdggZhedcY^c\l^i]]^\]"YZch^in VgZVhVcYaVg\Z\gZZcheVXZhgZheZXi^kZan#I]ZXVcden aVnZg]ZVi^haVcY^hi]ZV^gbVhhWZilZZc\gdjcYaZkZa VcYVkZgV\Zgdd[]Z^\]i# .^\jgZ.

dgdkZg]ZVi^c\!lZ ]VkZbdYZaaZYeVgi^VaYVni^bZdXXjeVi^dcVcY [jaalZZ`ZcYVcYZkZc^c\dXXjeVi^dc#I]Z egdeZginX]dhZc]VhXVk^inlVaah!h^c\aZ \aVo^c\VcYb^c^bVa^chjaVi^dc# 6gVc\Zd[VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhlVh X]dhZc[dgZVX]d[i]Zi]gZZ`Zn^beVXih "ÓddY^c\!lViZghigZhh!VcYdkZg]ZVi^c\# >cZVX]XVhZ!bZVhjgZhlZgZhZaZXiZYi]Vi XdjaYWZVeea^ZYidVgVc\Zd[egdeZgi^Zh! Vai]dj\]^ibjhiWZhigZhhZYi]Vi^i^hcdi edhh^WaZidheZX^[nVYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh[dg Vcnd[i]Z^beVXihl^i]djiheZX^ÒX`cdlaZY\Z d[i]Z^cY^k^YjVaegdeZgin#L]ZgZVeegdeg^ViZ! Xdhih]VkZWZZc\^kZc[dgegd[Zhh^dcVa ^chiVaaVi^dcd[VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh# I]ZegdeZginlVhVhhjbZYidWZkjacZgVWaZ idVaai]gZZ`Zn^beVXih#.(%h!i]Z]djhZ^hVi]gZZ"WZYgddb hZb^"YZiVX]ZY]dbZl^i]VeVkZY[gdci \VgYZcVcYVgZVg\VgYZc!WjicdWVhZbZci# LZ]VkZVhhjbZYi]ViV[Vb^and[ildVYjaih VcYi]gZZX]^aYgZcdXXjeni]ZegdeZgin!l]^X] ]Vh]VYa^iiaZgZcdkVi^dc#.dg[jgi]ZgYZiV^ahd[i]Z ÓViVcYWadX`XVhZhijY^Zh!eaZVhZhZZi]Z 8VhZHijYnIZX]c^XVaGZedgi#() I]Z]djhZegZhZciZY]ZgZ^hVine^XVa ZmVbeaZd[]djhZhi]gdj\]djii]Zi]gZZ gZ\^dchVgZV#8]dhZcVhVcZmVbeaZd[i]Z egda^ÒXeZg^dYd[]djhZWj^aY^c\Yjg^c\i]Z &.(%h]djhZ!V&.)) I]ZXVhZ hijYn]djhZ I]gZZ]djhZ]daYhlZgZbdYZaaZY^ci]Z XdjghZd[i]^hhijYn/V&.+%h ÓViVcYVWadX`d[ÓVih#6aai]gZZXVhZhijY^Zh h]dlZYi]Vihdaji^dchidVYVeiZm^hi^c\ ]dbZhidgZYjXZi]Z^beVXihd[ÓddY^c\! lViZghigZhhVcYdkZg]ZVi^c\VgZXjggZcian VkV^aVWaZVcYi]Vii]ZnVgZXdhiZ[[ZXi^kZ# I]Z]djhZXVhZhijYn^h]^\]a^\]iZY^ci]^h hjbbVgngZedgi#.dgZVX]d[i]ZhZ ^beVXih!VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh]VkZWZZc Xdch^YZgZYl]^X]XVceaVnVeVgi^cgZYjX^c\ i]ZkjacZgVW^a^ind[VegdeZginidXa^bViZ X]Vc\Z#=dlZkZg!^i^hcdiedhh^WaZid XdbeaZiZanZa^b^cViZi]Zg^h`hVhhdX^ViZY l^i]i]ZbdhiZmigZbZlZVi]ZgZkZcihhjX] VhhZkZgZ]ZVilVkZh!aVg\Z"hXVaZ^cjcYVi^dch! VcYadc\aVhi^c\Ygdj\]i# >i^h^bedgiVciidcdiZi]Vii]^h^hVXVhZhijYn# 6aaYlZaa^c\hl^aakVgn^ci]ZZmiZciidl]^X] i]ZnVgZVig^h`!VcYZVX]egdeZginbjhiWZ VhhZhhZY^cY^k^YjVaan# .

)* Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ .

*% —'(!&%%$ ZkZci %#+%ZkZcih GZh^a^ZcXZ bZVhjgZh —)!).b —&(!.Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ )+ 8VhZhijYn"VYVeiVi^dc[dgÓddY^c\ >ci]^hXVhZhijYn!ildhZeVgViZineZh d[VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhlZgZXdch^YZgZY# GZh^hiVcXZbZVhjgZhVgZYZh^\cZYid egZkZcilViZgZciZg^c\i]ZegdeZgin! l]^aZi]ZV^bd[gZh^a^ZcXZbZVhjgZh^h idgZYjXZi]Zi^bZVcYXdhid[gZXdkZgn [gdbVÓddY^c\ZkZci#  Dei^dc IdiVaXdhi ^cXajY^c\ egd[Zhh^dcVa ^chiVaaVi^dc BVm^bjb Vbdjci hVkZYV[iZg VÓddY =dlbVcn ÓddYheVn WVX`i]Z ^ckZhibZci4 GZh^hiVcXZ eVX`V\Z [dgÓddYh jeid%#.%$ ZkZci &#%*ZkZcih >i^hXaZVgi]Vil]Zi]ZggZh^hiVcXZdggZh^a^ZcXZ bZVhjgZhVgZ^chiVaaZY!i]Z^ckZhibZcieVnh WVX`^cVh^c\aZÓddY# I]ZgZh^hiVcXZeVX`V\Z^hÈVaadgcdi]^c\ÉZkZgn ZcigVcXZidi]Z]dbZbjhiWZWadX`ZYVcY gZfj^gZhVaVg\Zh^c\aZ^ckZhibZciWn i]Z]djhZ]daYZg# 9ddg9Vb IdiVa.addYHdaji^dch'%%. .* —)!'. HbVgi6^gWg^X`h :Xd"XdkZgV\Z'%%.

). Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ >cXdcigVhi!ZVX]gZh^a^ZcXZbZVhjgZ ^cYZeZcYZciangZYjXZhi]ZXdhid[gZXdkZgn [gdbVÓddY!VcYi]ZhVk^c\hVgZVYY^i^kZ!hd i]Z]djhZ]daYZgXVcbV`Z^ckZhibZcihVcY ^chiVaaVYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhdkZgVeZg^dY d[i^bZVcYhi^aa\V^ci]ZWZcZÒi[gdbi]dhZ bZVhjgZhXdbeaZiZY^ci]ZZkZcid[VÓddY# L^i]bZVhjgZhi]VigZandceaVX^c\kVajVWaZ ^iZbhVWdkZi]ZaZkZad[ÓddY^c\!hVk^c\hl^aa dcanWZbVYZ^[i]ZZmeZXiZYbVm^bjblViZg aZkZa^hcdiZmXZZYZY!VcY^[i]Z]djhZ]daYZg ]Vhhj[ÒX^ZcilVgc^c\idVaadlegZeVgVi^dch idWZbVYZ# GZh^hiVcXZbZVhjgZhX]dhZclZgZ/ ™cdc"gZijgckVakZhdcbV^cYgV^ch ™iZbedgVgnYddg\jVgYh ™gV^hZYYddgi]gZh]daYhVYY^i^dcValdg`bVn WZgZfj^gZYidbV^ciV^cY^hVWaZYVXXZhh ™lViZgegdd[bZbWgVcZ[gdb%#+bWZadl \gdjcYid&bVWdkZ ™gZjhVWaZV^gWg^X`XdkZgh$HB6GIV^g Wg^X`gZeaVXZbZcih ™hZVa^c\d[\VehVgdjcYe^eZh!XVWaZh! l^cYdlhVcYYddg[gVbZh# GZh^a^ZcXZbZVhjgZhX]dhZc[dgi]ZXVhZ hijYnVgZ\^kZcWZadl!l^i]hVbeaZXdhih/ ™gV^hZWd^aZgVWdkZÓddYaZkZa—.*# .)* ™gV^hZZaZXig^XVaed^cih$bZiZg—'(% ™gZeaVXZX]^eWdVgYÓddg^c\l^i]hda^Y i^bWZg—'!++* ™^ciZgcVaYddgh"Òig^h^c\]^c\Zh—(%"9>N ™Ygn"WV\h—&*%"9>N ™eaVXZaVg\Z^iZbha^`Zi]Z[g^Y\Z!lVh]^c\ bVX]^cZVcYdkZcdcVXdcXgZiZ ea^ci]—+.

dgi]^hXVhZhijYnlZVhhjbZYi]Vii]Z X]ddhZidjeYViZY^[[ZgZciZaZbZcihhZeVgViZan# ]djhZ]VYcdiWZZcgZcdkViZY[dgVWdji'% nZVgh!hdi]ZWVi]gddbVcY`^iX]ZcÒii^c\hYd >cZVX]XVhZ!Ò\jgZhVgZ\^kZc[dgi]Z[jaaXdhi cdibZZiXjggZcihiVcYVgYh[dglViZgZ[ÒX^ZcXn# d[gZeaVXZbZci!^cXajY^c\egd[Zhh^dcVaÒii^c\# I]Z]djhZlVhVhhjbZYidWZbZiZgZYhdi]Vi eVnWVX`i^bZhXdjaYWZVhhZhhZY^ciZgbhd[ XdhihVk^c\hdclViZgW^aah#I]ZWZcZÒih[gdb lViZgZ[ÒX^ZcXnbZVhjgZhVgZXjbjaVi^kZ! 8VhZhijYn"VYVeiVi^dc[dglViZghigZhh LViZghVk^c\iVeÒii^c\ @#8dafj]djc LViZghVk^c\h]dlZg]ZVY LViZgl^hZ 9jVaÓjh]id^aZi LViZgl^hZ LViZgZ[ÒX^ZciY^h]lVh]Zg LViZgl^hZ LViZgWjii @#8dafj]djc LViZgWjii lll#\gZZcWj^aY^c\hidgZ#Xd#j` .Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ )- hdi]^heVX`V\ZldjaYcdi]VkZidWZ^chiVaaZY h^bjaiVcZdjhan!VcYi]Z]djhZ]daYZgXdjaY .

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ I]ZVYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhX]dhZc[dg i]Z]djhZlZgZ/ >iZb 8]Vc\ZbVYZ EdiZci^VaVccjValViZg HVbeaZXdhi Ine^XVaeVnWVX`i^bZ[dgV hVk^c\[dg[Vb^and[ ^cXajY^c\ bZiZgZY]dbZ^iZbXdhi$ ÒkZa^igZh egd[Zhh^dcVaÒii^c\ lViZgXdhihVkZY Id^aZi GZeaVXZdaYid^aZi .!%%% YZeZcY^c\dc iVejhV\Z —'%9>N 6ha^iiaZVh[djgbdci]h Jeid'%!%%% —)%ZVX]9>N DcZnZVg^[lViZgjhZY[dg Wdi]\VgYZclViZg^c\VcY XVglVh]^c\ .djgnZVgh .% .!%%%Vhhjb^c\ —&)% h]dlZgl^i]cZl!adlZg Z^\]i"b^cjiZh]dlZgh ÓdlZaZXig^Xh]dlZg IldnZVghWVhZYdcXdaY lViZgXdhih"dcZnZVg^[ndj iV`Z^cidVXXdjcii]ZZcZg\n hVkZYdclViZg]ZVi^c\ 7Vi]gddb iVeh GZeaVXZdaYbdYZahl^i] Jeid'*!%%% cZlbdcdWadX`iVeh —-% &-bdci]h LVh]^c\ bVX]^cZ GZeaVXZl^i]lViZg" Z[ÒX^ZcikZgh^dc '(!%%% —(-%h^b^aVgid CdVYY^i^dcVaXdhi^[ hiVcYVgYbVX]^cZ ndjVgZgZeaVX^c\V ldgc"djibVX]^cZ 9^h]"lVh]Zg GZeaVXZl^i]lViZg" Z[ÒX^ZcikZgh^dc +!%%% —(-%h^b^aVgid CdVYY^i^dcVaXdhi^[ hiVcYVgYbVX]^cZ ndjVgZgZeaVX^c\V ldgc"djibVX]^cZ @^iX]ZciVeh Jeid(.^iVadl"ÓdlVYVeiZg <VgYZc >chiVaaVcYjhZ lViZg^c\VcY lViZgWjiih XVglVh]^c\ IVWaZ*LViZghVk^c\h^ci]ZVYVeiZY]djhZ# I]Zadl"Ódlh]dlZgVahdhVkZhi]Z]djhZ]daY &)%%`L]ZcZg\neZgVccjb#>iVahdXjihi]Z [jZaW^aaWn—&((VcYgZYjXZhi]Z]djhZ]daYÉh XVgWdc[ddieg^ciWn+%%`\8DWZXVjhZd[]di lViZghVk^c\h# —'.).aX^hiZgcl^i]cZl )#*aid^aZi )&!%%% H]dlZg GZeaVXZdaY\gVk^in"[ZY (.

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ *% 8VhZhijYn"VYVeiVi^dc[dgdkZg]ZVi^c\ BdYZaa^c\d[i]ZXVhZhijYn]djhZ[dg?jan iZbeZgVijgZh^cWdi]i]ZWZYgddbVcYi]Z a^k^c\gddbh]dlZYi]Vi^cWdi]i]ZXjggZci Xa^bViZVhgZegZhZciZYWni]Z&.YZh^\c nZVgVcYi]Zegd_ZXiZYXa^bViZ[dgi]Z'%*%h! i]ZjcVYVeiZY]djhZldjaYZmeZg^ZcXZ dkZg]ZVi^c\#>ci]ZXa^bViZd[i]Z'%*%h i]Za^k^c\gddbldjaYWZVWdkZXdb[dgi iZbeZgVijgZ[dg(%eZgXZcid[dXXje^ZY ]djgh!VcYi]ZWZYgddb[dg+eZgXZcid[ dXXje^ZY]djgh#7ni]Z'%*%h!dkZg]ZVi^c\ ldjaYWZZmeZg^ZcXZY^c*%eZgXZcid[ dXXje^ZY]djgh^ci]Za^k^c\gddb!VcY'% eZgXZci^ci]ZWZYgddb# >ciZgcVaH]jiiZgh lll#b^YaVcYh]jiiZgh#Xdb .-.

* .%% ™CVijgVakZci^aVi^dci]gdj\]l^cYdlh# CdXdhi[dgZm^hi^c\l^cYdlh ™:c]VcXZV^gbdkZbZci/XZ^a^c\[Vch9>N^chiVaaVi^dc# —*)* ™.*% IdiVaXdhid[bZVhjgZh[dgdkZg]ZVi^c\dcan —-!%.VVYZje\gVYZ/eV^cilVaahid^cXgZVhZgZÓZXi^k^in# —(!.VVYZje\gVYZ/XVk^in^chjaVi^dcl]ZgZXVk^i^ZhVgZegZhZci# —&!&%% ™.* 6YY^i^dcVaXdhid[l^ciZg^chjaVi^dcbZVhjgZh ™Gdd[/^begdkZgdd[^chjaVi^dchiVcYVgY# —'!'%% ™.addgXdkZg^c\h/gZeaVXZXVgeZihl^i]lddYZcÓddgdgi^aZhdc —'!&%% \gdjcYÓddg# ™.*& Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ I]Z[daadl^c\XdbW^cVi^dcd[VYVeiVi^dc bZVhjgZhlZgZbdYZaaZY[dgi]Z]djhZ! hZZi]ZiVWaZWZadl# 6ai]dj\]XdhihVeeZVg]^\]!i]Zidei]gZZ ^iZbhdci]Za^hi]VkZVhjWhiVci^VaZ[[ZXi VcYVgZgZaVi^kZanadlXdhi#>cXgZVh^c\ kZci^aVi^dcgViZh!eVgi^XjaVganl]Zc^i^h XddaZgVic^\]i!lVh[djcYidWZi]Zh^c\aZ bdhiZ[[ZXi^kZbZVhjgZ#I]ZVYY^i^dcVa bZVhjgZh!l]^aZViV]^\]ZgXdhi!XVcWZ ^cXajYZYVheVgid[eaVccZYgZYZXdgVi^dc! je\gVYZhVcYbV^ciZcVcXZd[i]ZegdeZgin# 8jggZcian!8>7H:<j^YZ6XaVhh^ÒZhdkZg]ZVi^c\ ^cYlZaa^c\hVhVcZmXZZYVcXZd['-•8[dgdcZ eZgXZcid[dXXje^ZY]djgh^ca^k^c\VgZVh!VcY VcZmXZZYVcXZd['+•8[dgdcZeZgXZci d[dXXje^ZY]djgh^cWZYgddbh# BZVhjgZ 8dhiegd[Zhh^dcVa^chiVaaVi^dcjcaZhhhiViZY BZVhjgZhl]^X]V^YdkZg]ZVi^c\dcan ™:miZgcVahdaVgXdcigda/Vlc^c\hdcVaahdji]$lZhil^cYdlh# —&!.ZcZhigVi^dcje\gVYZ/gZeaVXZh^c\aZ\aVo^c\l^i]YdjWaZ\aVo^c\! —*!%%% l^i]adl"ZXdVi^c\h# <G6C9IDI6A —&+!(.

YZh^\chjbbZgnZVg#7n'%*%! ^c?jani]ZdkZg]ZVi^c\iZbeZgVijgZl^aaWZ ZmXZZYZY^cdcan&#&eZgXZcid[dXXje^ZY]djgh ^ci]ZWZYgddbVcY'#'eZgXZcid[dXXje^ZY ]djgh^ci]Za^k^c\gddb# .#L^i]i]ZbZVhjgZh^chiVaaZY! i]ZdkZg]ZVi^c\iZbeZgVijgZ^hcZkZgZmXZZYZY ^ci]Z&.-.Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ *' GZigdÒii^c\i]ZgZXdbbZcYZYeVX`V\Zd[ VYVeiVi^dchXVjhZhVYgVbVi^XgZYjXi^dc^c i]ZcjbWZgd[]djgh^cl]^X]i]ZgddbhZmXZZY dkZg]ZVi^c\VcYXdb[dgiiZbeZgVijgZh!Vh h]dlc^c.^\jgZ&%h]dlhi]ZXdda^c\YZ\gZZ]djgh[dg i]Za^k^c\gddbVcYWZYgddb[dgi]Zbdci] d[?janl]ZciZbeZgVijgZhVgZ]diiZhi#:VX] \gVe]h]dlhi]ZXVhZhijYn]djhZl^i]VcY l^i]djii]ZhZaZXiZYVYVeiVi^dc^begdkZbZcih! ^cVXjggZci?janVcYVegd_ZXiZY'%*%Éh hjbbZg#I]ZWdiidbild\gVe]h^aajhigViZ i]ZV^gXdcY^i^dc^c\edlZg`L]dci]Zg^\]i ]VcYVmZhgZfj^gZYidXddai]ZhZgddbh^c VcjcVYVeiZY]djhZidi]Z8>7H:Xdb[dgi iZbeZgVijgZh'*•8^ci]Za^k^c\gddbVcY '(•8^ci]ZWZYgddb#8dda^c\YZ\gZZ]djgh VgZjhZYidbZVhjgZi]ZZmiZciidl]^X]V gddbdkZg]ZVih#I]^h^hXVaXjaViZYdkZgi]Z bdci]d[?janVhi]ZcjbWZgd[YZ\gZZhWn l]^X]i]ZXdb[dgiiZbeZgVijgZ^hZmXZZYZY [dgZVX]]djgi]Z]djhZ^hdXXje^ZY#>i^h XaZVg[gdb.^\jgZ.^\jgZ&%i]ViVYVei^c\]dbZh [dgdkZg]ZVi^c\]VhVh^\c^ÒXVciZ[[ZXidc i]ZYZ\gZZd[Y^hXdb[dgi#I]ZgZhZVgX] h]dlZYi]Vicdc"ZcZg\n^ciZch^kZVYVeiVi^dc dei^dchediZci^VaanZa^b^cViZhi]ZcZZY[dg V^g"XdcY^i^dc^c\!dgh^\c^ÒXVciangZYjXZhi]Z Vbdjcid[ZcZg\njhZYidXddai]Z]djhZ# .

IZbeZgVijgZh^ci]ZjcVYVeiZYVcY VYVeiZY]djhZ[dg?jan&.^\jgZ&%8dda^c\YZ\gZZ]djgh[dgi]Zbdci]d[?jan# I]Zg^\]i]VcYVmZhh]dli]ZidiVaedlZgXdchjbei^dc d[VcV^gXdcY^i^dc^c\hnhiZb^c`L]jhZYidXdcigda dkZg]ZVi^c\^ci]ZjcVYVeiZY]dbZ# 0 -100 Control Adapted Air Con 2050s Control 2050s Adapted 2050s Air Con Air Conditioning kWh -10 -10 1200 .*( Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ 6GJE House Living Room House Bedroom 100 100 23 °C < T < 26 °C 25 °C < T < 28 °C T > 28 °C 90 90 T > 26 °C 80 % occupied hours % occupied hours 80 70 60 50 40 70 60 50 40 30 30 20 20 10 10 0 0 Control Adapted 2050s Control 2050s Adapted Control Adapted 2050s Control 2050s Adapted .-.VcY'%*%# Living Room Bedroom 0 0 1400 1400 1000 -40 800 -50 600 -60 Cooling Degree Hours -30 Air Conditioning kWh Cooling Degree Hours -20 1200 -20 -30 1000 -40 800 -50 600 -60 -70 -70 400 400 -80 -80 200 200 -90 -90 0 -100 Control Adapted Air Con 2050s Control 2050s Adapted 2050s Air Con .^\jgZ.

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ *) >ihcdiVhh^beaZVh^cigdYjX^c\cZliZX]cdad\n# LZi]dj\]i!VhhdaVgi]ZgbVaXVbZ^c!i]Vi^i ldjaY\ZiX]ZVeZg#7jiYZbVcY^ci]ZaVhi[Zl nZVgh]Vhdjihig^eeZYi]Zhjeeand[ÒiiZgh# 9Vk^Y<Vjci .

G6VcYCdgl^X]Jc^dc ]VkZXgZViZYYZbdchigVi^dc]dbZh^cVgZVh i]Vihj[[Zg[gZfjZcian[gdbÓddY^c\#<j^YVcXZ dcVYVeiVi^dc[dgdkZg]ZVi^c\g^h`^cXajYZh i]ZJ@8>EgZedgiÈ7ZVi^c\i]Z=ZViÉ#=dlZkZg! i]ZhZgZhedchZhVgZ[gV\bZciZYWn^beVXi! hZXidgVcYadXVi^dc# I]ZXddgY^cVi^c\gdaZd[XZcigVa\dkZgcbZci ^hXg^i^XVa#:VX]d[i]ZeVgi^Zh^cÓjZcX^c\ i]Z]djhZ]daYZgbjhiWZeZghjVYZYidldg` ^cXdcXZgi!idXgZViZV[gVbZldg`^cl]^X] ]djhZ]daYZghVgZZcVWaZYidVYVeii]Z^g]dbZh [dgÓddY^c\!lViZghigZhhVcYdkZg]ZVi^c\# .** :cVWa^c\ VYVeiVi^dc 6c^bedgiVciY^hi^cXi^dcWZilZZc b^i^\Vi^c\VcYVYVei^c\idXa^bViZX]Vc\Z^h i]ViVYVeiVi^dccZZYhidWZVYYgZhhZYadXVaan l]^aZb^i^\Vi^dcgZfj^gZhWdi]adXVaVcY\adWVa VXi^dcidgZYjXZ\gZZc]djhZ\VhZb^hh^dch# I]ZX]d^XZd[Veegdeg^ViZgZigdÒiVYVeiVi^dc bZVhjgZhl^aakVgnVXXdgY^c\idadXVi^dc!i]Z adXVaXa^bViZXjggZciVcY[jijgZVcYi]Z Wj^aY^c\ineZ^ckdakZY# 6hl^i]b^i^\Vi^dc!bjX]d[i]Z[dXjh[dg VYVeiVi^dcd[]djh^c\hidX`[dgi]Z^beVXih d[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z]VhWZZcXdcXZcigViZYdc cZlWj^aY#>cXdgedgVi^c\VYVeiVi^dc^cidcZl Wj^aYXVcWZ\j^YZYWnadXVaWdY^ZheaVcc^c\ YZeVgibZcihVcYWj^aY^c\Xdcigda!VhlZaaVh i]gdj\]eaVcc^c\VcYWj^aY^c\gZ\jaVi^dchhZi Wni]Z9ZeVgibZcid[8dbbjc^i^ZhVcYAdXVa <dkZgcbZci#=dlZkZg[dgZm^hi^c\]dbZh!i]Z ^beZijhid!VcYgZhedch^W^a^in[dgVYVei^c\ Wj^aY^c\hXdbZhaVg\Zan[gdbi]Z^cY^k^YjVa ]djhZ]daYZgdgaVcYadgY#>i^hcdibVcYVidgn! cdg^h^ijcYZgi]ZXdcigdad[Vcn\dkZgcbZci YZeVgibZcidgV\ZcXn# 6]djhZ]daYZgÉhl^aa^c\cZhhidVYVeiYZeZcYh dcVcjbWZgd[^hhjZh!^cXajY^c\/ ™VlVgZcZhhd[VcZZY[dgVYVeiVi^dc ™VkV^aVW^a^ind[^c[dgbVi^dcdcVeegdeg^ViZ VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh!i]Z^gXdhihVcYWZcZÒih ™VkV^aVW^a^ind[[jcYhidbV`Zi]ZX]Vc\Zh! l]^X]^cijgc^hV[[ZXiZYWniZcjgZ ™adXVa!h`^aaZY^chiVaaZghl^aa^c\id jcYZgiV`Zi]Zldg` ™VkV^aVW^a^ind[iZX]cdad\^Zh# >cegVXi^XZ!Vl^YZgVc\Zd[jcXdccZXiZY VXidghVgZ^ckdakZY^c^cÓjZcX^c\VcY hjeedgi^c\]djhZ]daYZghi]gdj\]i]ZegdXZhh d[Zchjg^c\i]Vii]Z^g]dbZhVgZVeegdeg^ViZ [dgdjgX]Vc\^c\Xa^bViZ#6YVeiVi^dc^cVc ^cY^k^YjVaXVhZbVnWZYZeZcYZcidci]Zi^bZan ^ciZgkZci^dcd[VXdbW^cVi^dcd[i]ZhZVXidgh! l^i]kVgn^c\bdi^kVi^dch[dg^ckdakZbZciVcY ^cÓjZcXZdkZgi]Z]djhZ]daYZg#:mVbeaZh ^cXajYZ^chiVaaZghVcYhjeea^Zgh!]djh^c\ bVg`Zi^chi^iji^dch!ji^a^i^ZhVcYC<Dh# LViZgXdbeVc^Zh!VcYC<DhhjX]Vh LViZgl^hZ!]VkZWZZcVXi^kZVcYZ[[ZXi^kZ^c ZcXdjgV\^c\lViZgZ[ÒX^ZcXn!VcYegd\gVbbZh WnVbdc\di]Zgh9:.

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ *+ I]Z8dYZ[dgHjhiV^cVWaZ=dbZh^hVhiZe^c i]Zg^\]iY^gZXi^dc[dgcZlWj^aY!WjilZVahd cZZYid^begdkZ]dllZjhZdjgZm^hi^c\]dbZh "]dleZdeaZWZ]VkZ^h_jhiVh^bedgiVciVhi]Z  YZk^XZhlZÒi^ciddjg]djhZh# 6gje .

dgÓddY^c\!i]ZgZ^hVÒcVcX^Va^cXZci^kZ[dg ™6W^a^inidVhhZhheZghdcVag^h` aVcYadgYhid^chiVaabZVhjgZhi]ViegdiZXii]Z EZdeaZcZZYidWZVWaZidVhhZhhi]Zg^h` [VWg^Xd[i]ZWj^aY^c\!WjicdicZXZhhVg^ani]dhZ idi]Z^gegdeZginZ^i]Zgi]gdj\]h^beaZ i]ViegdiZXii]ZiZcVciÉhegdeZgin# VhhZhhbZciiddahdgZmeZgiVYk^XZ!dgV XdbW^cVi^dcd[Wdi]#EgdeZgVhhZhhbZci .dgaVcYadgYh!i]ZÒcVcX^Va^cXZci^kZid VYVeii]Z^g]dbZh^hlZV`Zg!l^i]i]ZbV^c WZcZÒX^Vg^Zhd[gZYjXZYlViZgVcYZcZg\n W^aahWZ^c\i]ZiZcVcih#6YVeiVi^dcbVnbV`Z egdeZgi^ZhbdgZViigVXi^kZidiZcVcih!VcY hdVaadlVegZb^jbeg^XZidWZX]Vg\ZY!Wji i]^hl^aa]VkZa^iiaZZ[[ZXi^cVWjdnVcibVg`Zi# .*.dgiZcVcih!i]Z^cXZci^kZidVYVeiV l^aaZcVWaZVeegdeg^ViZVYVeiVi^dc# egdeZgin^ha^b^iZYWni]ZcZZYiddWiV^c eZgb^hh^dc!VcYi]ZaVX`d[adc\"iZgb Xdbb^ibZciidVegdeZgin# >[]djhZ]daYZghVcYaVcYadgYhVgZidWZ ZcVWaZYidVXi!i]ZncZZYidWZ\^kZcV h^beaZ!XaZVgbZhhV\Z/i]ZXa^bViZ^h X]Vc\^c\!i]Z^gegdeZgi^ZhbVneZg[dgb eddgan^ci]Z^ci]Z[VXZd[ÓddY^c\!lViZg higZhhVcYdkZg]ZVi^c\!VcYi]ZgZVgZ ÒcVcX^Va!Zck^gdcbZciVaVcY]ZVai] WZcZÒihidbV`^c\egdVXi^kZVYVeiVi^dch# . Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ I]Z[gVbZldg`^cl]^X]]djhZ]daYZghl^aaVXi 6[gVbZldg`^hcZZYZYidZcVWaZ]djhZ]daYZgh idVXi#Eda^XnbV`ZghVcYYZa^kZgnV\ZcX^Zh =djhZ]daYZghXVccdiWZigZViZYVhV cZZYidhZijei]^h[gVbZldg`VcYldg`l^i] ]dbd\Zcdjh\gdje#I]ZaVg\Zhih^c\aZ \gdje^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchVgZdlcZg"dXXje^Zgh! Veegdeg^ViZV\ZcX^ZhidgV^hZ]djhZ]daYZg VcYi]^h^hi]Z\gdjel^i]i]Z\gZViZhi^cXZci^kZ VlVgZcZhh#I]ZbZhhV\Zh]djaYWZ VeegdVX]ZYhZfjZci^Vaan/ VcYXVeVX^inidVXi#=dlZkZg!^ibjhicdiWZ VhhjbZYi]ViVaaVgZl^aa^c\dgVWaZid^ckZhi ^ci]Z^g]dbZh!ZkZc^[^ibV`ZhÒcVcX^Va hZchZidYdhd# ™@cdlaZY\ZVcYVlVgZcZhh EZdeaZcZZYidWZbVYZVlVgZd[adXVa ^beVXihd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z^cXajY^c\ dkZg]ZVi^c\!lViZghXVgX^inVcYÓddY^c\! i]Zi^bZhXVaZhdcl]^X]ZkZcihbVndXXjg VcY[VXidghi]Vi^cÓjZcXZkjacZgVW^a^inid i]ZhZ^beVXih#EZdeaZVahdcZZYidWZ VlVgZi]ViXa^bViZX]Vc\Z^hcdihdbZi]^c\ _jhi[dgi]Z[jijgZ#I]ZXa^bViZ^hVagZVYn X]Vc\^c\!^cXgZVh^c\i]Za^`Za^]ddYd[ ÈZmigZbZÉZkZcihdXXjgg^c\# .

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ *- ™Edh^i^kZ^bV\ZVhhdX^Vi^dc 8a^bViZX]Vc\ZVYVeiVi^dch]djaYWZ VhhdX^ViZYl^i]edh^i^kZa^[ZhinaZX]d^XZh! Zc]VcX^c\fjVa^ind[a^[ZVcY$dghdX^VahiVijh# ™6XXZhhidVYk^XZVcY\j^YVcXZ DcXZVc^cY^k^YjVa]VhiV`Zci]ZYZX^h^dcid VYVeii]Z^gegdeZgin!i]ZncZZYidWZVWaZid VXXZhhi]ZVeegdeg^ViZhjeedgiidigVch[dgb ^ciZci^dc^cidVXi^dc#I]^h^cXajYZhWZ^c\VWaZ idÒcYigV^cZY^chiVaaZghidÒiVeegdeg^ViZ VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh# ™6W^a^inidVhhZhhZXdcdb^XWZcZÒi d[VYVeiVi^dc >[ÒcVcX^VaXdhihVgZV`Zn[VXidg^ci]Z YZX^h^dc"bV`^c\egdXZhh!i]ZVW^a^inid VhhZhhi]Zadc\"iZgbgZijgchdc^ckZhibZci l^aaWZ^bedgiVci^cZcVWa^c\YZX^h^dchid WZiV`Zc#L]ZgZVYVeiVi^dc^cXgZVhZhi]Z kVajZd[VegdeZgin!dggZYjXZh^chjgVcXZ egZb^jbh!i]^hbjhiWZVeeVgZci# :[[ZXi^kZegdbdi^dcd[i]ZhZVYVeiVi^dc bZhhV\ZhVahdbZVchZchjg^c\i]Vii]Zn WZXdbZVc^ciZ\gVaeVgid[Wdi]i]Z b^i^\Vi^dcV\ZcYVVcYVfjVa^ind[a^[Z V\ZcYV#6ai]dj\]i]ZgZVgZZXdcdb^X WZcZÒihidVYVeiVi^dc!i]ZhZl^aacdiVeean idVaaegdeZgi^Zhdg^cY^k^YjVah!hd^igZbV^ch ^bedgiVciidhigZhhi]Zl^YZghdX^VaVcY Zck^gdcbZciVaWZcZÒihd[VYVeiVi^dc# .^\jgZ&&IZcjgZWngZ\^dc[dgi]Zi]gZZgZ\^dchVgZV#)* .

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ IZcjgZYdZhcdiV[[ZXii]Z^beVXihi]ViV eVgi^XjaVgWj^aY^c\bVnhj[[Zg!Wji^i YdZhV[[ZXii]Z]djhZ]daYZgÉhgZhedchZidVc ^beVXi#I]ZiZcjgZineZhXdch^YZgZY^ci]^h hijYnVgZeg^kViZangZciZY!gZciZY[gdbhdX^Va aVcYadgYdgadXVaVji]dg^inVcYdlcZg"dXXje^ZY#  .200 29% 32% 1.gZZdgadl"Xdhidei^dchVgZl^i]^ci]ZhXdeZd[ Vaa]djhZ]daYZgh!Wjii]ZYZX^h^dcid^ckZhi^c bdgZZmeZch^kZVYVeiVi^dcdei^dchbVnYZeZcY dci]Za^`ZanÒcVcX^VagZijgc[gdbbV`^c\ X]Vc\Zh#IZcVcXnV[[ZXih]djhZ]daYZghÉ l^aa^c\cZhhVcYVW^a^inidVXi![dgZmVbeaZ WZXVjhZd[i]ZcZZY[dgcZ\di^Vi^dcl^i] aVcYadgYhdgdi]Zg[gZZ]daYeVgicZgh# L^i]^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch!iZcjgZ^hYdb^cViZY WndlcZg"dXXje^ZY]dbZh#I]ZhZbV`Zje +.*.dgÓVihl^i]^c WadX`h!l]Zi]ZgejgedhZWj^aidgXdckZgiZY! cZ\di^Vi^dcbVnWZgZfj^gZYl^i]i]Z[gZZ]daYZg dg[gZZ]daYeVgicZghidbV`ZVaiZgVi^dch#>c VYY^i^dc!i]ZXdcY^i^dchd[i]ZaZVhZ]daYdg iZcVcXnd[WadX`hbVnegZXajYZVaiZgVi^dch idi]Z[VWg^Xd[i]ZWj^aY^c\# .000 Numbers of Homes =dlYdZhiZcjgZV[[ZXii]ZVYVeiVi^dcd[ Zm^hi^c\]dbZh4 29% 29% 24% 33% 800 28% 600 24% 18% 12% 13% 400 12% 5% 200 3% 2% 2% 2% 1% 0 D e ta c he d T e rra c e F la t. c onve rs ion othe r S e m i-de ta c he d F la t. m obile hom e . hous e boa t not s e lf-c onta ine d .eZgXZcid[i]Z]djh^c\hidX`#)*Eg^kViZan gZciZY]dbZhbV`Zje&(eZgXZci!l^i] gZ\^hiZgZYhdX^VaaVcYadgYhVi-eZgXZciVcY adXVaVji]dg^i^ZhVi&%eZgXZci#>cZVX]XVhZ! i]ZZVhiVcYhdji]ZVhigZ\^dchVgZh^b^aVgid ZVX]di]Zg!l^i]AdcYdc]Vk^c\[ZlZgdlcZg" dXXje^Zgh*.^\jgZ&'IneZhd[YlZaa^c\h^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch#)+ 7j^aY^c\ineZh 6hlZaaVhV\ZVcYiZcVcXn!Wj^aY^c\ineZ ^hVahdV[VXidgi]ViV[[ZXihi]Z^beVXii]Vi Xa^bViZl^aa]VkZdcVWj^aY^c\!VcYi]ZineZh d[VYVeiVi^dci]VibVnWZedhh^WaZdg egVXi^XVWaZ#I]dhZi]Vi^ckdakZhigjXijgVa X]Vc\Zidi]ZWj^aY^c\VgZZVh^Zgl]Zci]Z [VWg^Xd[i]ZWj^aY^c\^hi]ZgZhedch^W^a^ind[ Vh^c\aZeVgin"[dgZmVbeaZ!VYZiVX]ZY ]djhZ!dgVWadX`XdcigdaaZYWnV]djh^c\ VhhdX^Vi^dcdghdX^VaaVcYadgY#.eZgXZciVcYbdgZgZciZY VXXdbbdYVi^dc![gdbWdi]eg^kViZVcYhdX^Va aVcYadgYh#HdX^VaaVcYadgYhVgZ^cbVcnlVnh ^ci]ZWZhiedh^i^dciddkZghZZVYVeiVi^dch! ]Vk^c\XdcigdadkZgZhiViZhVcYWadX`h!VXXZhh idXVe^iVa!VcY^cXZci^kZhidbV^ciV^ci]ZfjVa^in d[i]ZVXXdbbdYVi^dc# London East South East 1. P urpos e -built c a ra va n.

.eZgXZcid[gZhedcYZcih]VY]ZVgYd[ Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z).dgVaa^beVXih!WVgg^Zgh^cXajYZ/ 6ai]dj\]i]ZgZ^hV]^\]aZkZad[ XdchZchjhl^i]^ci]ZXa^bViZX]Vc\Z Xdbbjc^ind[i]ZXVjhZhVcY^bea^XVi^dch d[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z!ejWa^XjcYZghiVcY^c\^h ViVkZgnY^[[ZgZciaZkZa#I]ZejWa^XVgZVlVgZ d[Xa^bViZX]Vc\ZVhVXdcXZei!^cVgZXZci edaa!.Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ +% L]ViegZkZcihVXi^dc4 .Wjii]ZXdbeaZm^ind[i]Z hjW_ZXibZVchi]Vi^i^hdcanjcYZghiddYVi VhjeZgÒX^VaaZkZa#8gjX^Vaan!i]ZgZ^hV adlVlVgZcZhhd[i]Za^c`WZilZZc\adWVa Xa^bViZX]Vc\ZVcYadXVa^beVXih# ™I]ZeZgXZ^kZYXdbeaZm^ind[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z VcY^ih^beVXih!XdbW^cZYl^i]ViZcYZcXn idVXidci]ZWVh^hd[ZmeZg^ZcXZ!gVi]Zgi]Vc V[jijgZ]nedi]Zi^XVaZkZci#I]^hgZYjXZh i]Z]djhZ]daYZgÉhVW^a^inidVhhZhhg^h`VcY jg\ZcXn[dgVXi^dc# ™AVX`d[VlVgZcZhhd[Veegdeg^ViZVYVeiVi^dc dei^dch!VXXZhhidigjhiZY^beVgi^VaiZX]c^XVa VYk^XZ!dg^c[dgbVi^dcVWdjii]ZXdhiWZcZÒi d[bZVhjgZh!XdbW^cZYl^i]VaVX`d[ XdcigVXidghd[[Zg^c\hZgk^XZh^cVYVeiVi^dc# ™:miZch^kZkVg^Vi^dc^ci]ZXdchigjXi^dc!V\Z VcYXdcY^i^dcd[]djh^c\hidX`^ci]Zi]gZZ I]ZX]Vc\^c\cVijgZd[ÓddY!Ygdj\]iVcY gZ\^dch#I]^hbZVchi]ViV]^\]aZkZad[ dkZg]ZVi^c\ZkZcihVgZbV`^c\djgWj^aY^c\h ^cY^k^YjVaVhhZhhbZci^hcZXZhhVgnidhZaZXi ^cVeegdeg^ViZ[dgdjgXjggZciVcY[jijgZ Xa^bViZ#6ai]dj\]Xdhi"Z[[ZXi^kZVYVeiVi^dchVgZ Veegdeg^ViZVYVeiVi^dcVcYVkd^YediZci^Va VkV^aVWaZi]ViXVcbV`Zdjg]dbZhXdb[dgiVWaZ cZ\Vi^kZXdchZfjZcXZh# VcYgdWjhi^ci]Z[VXZd[i]ZhZ^beVXih!i]ZgZ VgZh^\c^ÒXVciWVgg^Zghidi]Zl^YZhegZVY jeiV`Zd[VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh# .

addY^c\^hVcjcegZY^XiVWaZZkZci!bV`^c\ ^iY^[ÒXjai[dg]djhZ]daYZghideg^dg^i^hZ ^ckZhibZci^cÓddYgZh^a^ZcXZVcY gZh^hiVcXZbZVhjgZh# ™:hiVWa^h]^c\i]ZÓddYg^h`d[VegdeZgin [gdbVgVc\Zd[hdjgXZh^hXdbeaZm# I]Z:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXnÓddYbVe h]dlhi]Zg^h`h[gdbg^kZgVcYXdVhiVa ÓddYh!Wjii]ZnYdcdi^cXajYZdi]Zg hdjgXZhhjX]VhÓVh]hZlZgÓddY^c\ VcY\gdjcYlViZgÓddY^c\# ™6eegdeg^ViZÓddY^c\VYVeiVi^dc bZVhjgZh!eVgi^XjaVgan[dggZh^hiVcXZ! bjhiWZiV^adgZYidheZX^ÒXegdeZgi^Zh! h^cXZXdhihVcYa^b^iVi^dchd[bZVhjgZh VgZhigdc\anYZeZcYZcidci]ZXdchigjXi^dc VcYadXVi^dcd[i]ZWj^aY^c\# LViZghigZhh/ ™LViZghigZhh^beVXihVgZgZ\^dcVa!]ZcXZ l^YZhegZVYjeiV`Z^hcZXZhhVgn[dgi]Z h^ijVi^dcid^begdkZh^\c^ÒXVcian#=dlZkZg! V]djhZ]daYZgbVnhZZ^cY^k^YjVaWZcZÒi^c iZgbhd[gZYjXZYlViZgVcYZcZg\nW^aah# ™AdlaZkZahd[bZiZg^c\eZcZigVi^dcgZYjXZ i]ZÒcVcX^Va^cXZci^kZidhVkZlViZg# ™]ZgZ^hadlVlVgZcZhhi]ViWZ^c\Z[ÒX^Zci l^i]]dilViZgWg^c\hVcZcZg\nXdhihVk^c\ VcYgZYjXZh8DZb^hh^dch# ™Eg^XZd[lViZg^hadlVcYhd]Vha^b^iZY ^beVXidcWZ]Vk^djgVaX]Vc\Z# DkZg]ZVi^c\/ ™I]ZgZ^hadlVlVgZcZhhd[YdbZhi^X dkZg]ZVi^c\VhVc^beVXid[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z# ™.addY^c\/ ™.+& Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ >cVYY^i^dc!ZVX]d[i]Zi]gZZ`Zn^beVXih]Vh ^ihdlcXdbea^XVi^dch# .dghdbZegdeZgi^Zh!eVgi^XjaVgan^ci]ZJ=>! ^ibVncdiWZedhh^WaZidVX]^ZkZXdb[dgiVWaZ iZbeZgVijgZhjh^c\eVhh^kZbZVhjgZhVadcZ# HZXjg^in[ZVghbVnVahdegZkZcieZdeaZ aZVk^c\l^cYdlhdeZcVic^\]i# ™>cdgYZgidVX]^ZkZXdb[dgiVWaZiZbeZgVijgZh ^c]dihjbbZgh!VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhbjhi WZeaVccZYVcY^chiVaaZY^cVYkVcXZ#>c XdcigVhi!V^gXdcY^i^dc^c\jc^ihVgZgZVY^an VkV^aVWaZ!^cZmeZch^kZ!VcYXVcWZZVh^an ^chiVaaZY#6^gXdcY^i^dc^c\]VhcZ\Vi^kZ XdchZfjZcXZh^ciZgbhd[cd^hZ!lVhiZ]ZVi VcYXVgWdcZb^hh^dch# .

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ +' 6cZmVbeaZd[VhjXXZhh[jaXVbeV^\c I]VbZhLViZg]VhWZZcVXi^kZanegdbdi^c\ lViZgXdchZgkVi^dch^cXZ&.+#DcZd[i]Z aVg\ZhiZ[[dgihidYViZ]VhWZZci]Z'%%+ Ygdj\]iXdbbjc^XVi^dchXVbeV^\c!l]^X] lVheVgianXdcYjXiZY^cXdaaVWdgVi^dcl^i] di]ZglViZgXdbeVc^ZhVcYadXVaVcY gZ\^dcVaVji]dg^i^Zh# ™6Ygdj\]iheZV`Zgegd\gVbbZ\VkZ iVa`hid\gdjeh[gdbhX]ddah!gdiVgnXajWh! Zck^gdcbZciVa\gdjeh!cZ^\]Wdjg]ddYlViX] VcY]djh^c\VhhdX^Vi^dch# ™I]VbZhlViZgXd"hedchdgZYi]ZlViZg" Z[ÒX^ZciÈHjch]^cZ<VgYZcÉVii]Z=Vbeidc 8djgi..eZgXZcid[XjhidbZgh*%i^bZh# WVc#È7ZVii]ZYgdj\]iÉaZVÓZihlZgZhZci djiid&#'b^aa^dcXjhidbZghl^i]i]Z^gW^aah# ™6Ygdj\]i]dbZeV\Zdci]ZI]VbZhLViZg lZWh^iZegdk^Y^c\^c[dgbVi^dcVWdjii]Z lViZggZhdjgXZh^ijVi^dc!lViZgjhZ gZhig^Xi^dch!VcYa^c`hidjhZ[jah^iZh# ™EVgi^X^eVi^dc^ci]ZÈ7ZVii]ZYgdj\]iÉ XVbeV^\cl^i]di]ZglViZgXdbeVc^Zh ^ci]Zhdji]ZVhi#lll#WZVii]ZYgdj\]i#Xdb# ™I]VbZhLViZgÈ9gdj\]iWjhiZghÉidjgZY i]ZgZ\^dcidegdbdiZlViZgXdchZgkVi^dc VcYZ[ÒX^ZcXn"kdajciZZghYgZhhZYjeVh gZXd\c^hVWaZlViZg"jh^c\Veea^VcXZhid Wg^c\i]ZbZhhV\Zida^[Z# I]ZidiVaXdhiidI]VbZhLViZgd[i]Z Xdbbjc^XVi^dchXVbeV^\clVh—)#*b^aa^dc# ..!l^i]i]ZaVg\ZhiYZXgZVhZWZ^c\ ™6È=ZaejhidWZVii]ZYgdj\]iÉLViZgL^hZ 6hhZbWaneVX`lVhegdYjXZY[dghX]ddah# hZZcYjg^c\VlZZ`^c?jan!l]ZcYZbVcY[Zaa DkZg'!*%%eVX`hlZgZgZfjZhiZYVXgdhhi]Z Wn-#+eZgXZci^cAdcYdcVcY&)#(eZgXZci^c I]VbZhLViZggZ\^dc# i]ZI]VbZhKVaaZn# ™6c^ciZ\gViZYegd\gVbbZd[VYkZgi^h^c\ I]ZXVbeV^\c^cXajYZYi]Z[daadl^c\/ ^ccZlheVeZgh!ejWa^XlVh]gddbh!gVY^d! gdVYh^YZW^aaWdVgYh!WjhZh!dca^cZ!VcY ™AZiiZghhZciid(#(b^aa^dc]djhZ]daYh egdYjXieaVXZbZcihdcIKgZVX]ZYVc VWdjii]ZYgdj\]i!aZV`V\ZVcY]dhZe^eZ Zhi^bViZY.adlZgH]dl^c?jan!iVa`^c\idk^h^idgh VWdjilViZg"hVk^c\bZVhjgZh[dgi]Z\VgYZc# ™6egdbdi^dcVaXVbeV^\c^c)&=dbZWVhZ I]ZXddgY^cViZYXVbeV^\cgZhjaiZY^cVgZXdgY hidgZhegdk^YZY&%%!%%%lViZg"Z[ÒX^ZcXn gZhedchZ[gdbi]ZejWa^X#GZYjXi^dch^c eVX`h#I]^hlVhegdbdiZYi]gdj\]gZ\^dcVa Y^hig^Wji^dc^cejihj\\Zhii]ViYZbVcY[ZaaWn VcYadXVaegZhhVcYgVY^d# VcVkZgV\Zd[-)#&bZ\Va^igZh$YVn(#&eZgXZci Yjg^c\'%%+$%.

+( Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ :hhZci^VaeVgi^X^eVcih[dgl^YZhegZVYjeiV`Z d[VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh I]ZgZhedch^W^a^in[dgbV`^c\VYVeiVi^dchid VcZm^hi^c\]dbZgZhihl^i]i]Z]djhZ]daYZg! WjiVl^YZgVc\Zd[VXidgheaVnXg^i^XVagdaZh ^cZYjXVi^c\!ZcXdjgV\^c\VcYZcVWa^c\ ]djhZ]daYZghidbV`ZVeegdeg^ViZX]d^XZh# :VX]VXidg]VhVY^[[ZgZcibdi^kVi^dc VXXdgY^c\idi]Z^ggZaVi^dch]^el^i] i]Z]djhZ]daYZg!VcYcZZYhViVg\ZiZY bZhhV\ZideZghjVYZ]djhZ]daYZghid Zc\V\Z^ci]ZegdXZhh# >cY^k^YjVahVcY^chi^iji^dchl^i]VXg^i^XVagdaZ ideaVn^cZcVWa^c\VYVeiVi^dc^cXajYZ/ XZcigVa!gZ\^dcVaVcY adXVa\dkZgcbZci \dkZgcbZciWdY^ZhViVaaaZkZahhZii]Z[gVbZldg`h^cl]^X]di]Zghl^aaVXi#6YVeiVi^dc cZZYhidWZgZXd\c^hZYVhVXdgZeVgid[i]ZXa^bViZX]Vc\ZV\ZcYVVcYdi]ZgV\ZcYVh Z\]djh^c\!VcY^cXdgedgViZY^cidZm^hi^c\eda^XnVhVeegdeg^ViZ# ^chiVaaZgh!hjeea^Zgh VcYegd[Zhh^dcVa ^chi^iji^dch i]ZhZVgZ[jcYVbZciVaidZcVWa^c\VYVeiVi^dcidWZ^beaZbZciZY!Vhi]Znegdk^YZ ^c[dgbVi^dcid]djhZ]daYZghVhlZaaVhi]Zh`^aaZYhZgk^XZhcZZYZYid^chiVaa VYVeiVi^dcegdYjXih# bdgi\V\ZXdbeVc^Zh i]ZhZ]VkZi]ZediZci^Vaid^cÓjZcXZdlcZg"dXXje^ZghVcYaVcYadgYhWdi]Vii]Zi^bZd[ ejgX]VhZVcYYjg^c\i]Z^gdc\d^c\gZaVi^dch]^e!Vhi]Zn]VkZVadc\"iZgbgZaVi^dch]^e l^i]i]Z]djhZ]daYZghVcYVgZZfj^in]daYZgh# ^chjgVcXZXdbeVc^Zh i]ZhZ]VkZ^cÓjZcXZdkZg]dbZdlcZgh!i]dj\]XdciVXi^hjhjVaana^b^iZYidVccjVa gZcZlVa#I]ZnYd]VkZVcdeedgijc^inid^cÓjZcXZ]dbZdlcZghYjg^c\VXaV^bhegdXZhh! eVgi^XjaVgan[dgÓddYgZh^a^ZcXZVcYgZh^hiVcXZ# =dbZ>c[dgbVi^dc EVX`=>EVhhZhhdgh! hjgkZndghVcY VgX]^iZXih i]ZhZVaa]VkZVXXZhhideZdeaZÉh]dbZhVcYVgZi]ZgZ[dgZ^YZVaaneaVXZYidegdk^YZ VYk^XZdcVYVeiVi^dc#I]ZgZ^hVeVgi^XjaVghncZg\n[dg=>EVhhZhhdghl^i]i]ZZcZg\n Z[ÒX^ZcXnV\ZcYV# C<Dh VcjbWZgd[C<DhVgZVagZVYnldg`^c\l^i]kjacZgVWaZ\gdjehVcYVgZ^cVc^YZVa edh^i^dcidegdbdiZVYVeiVi^dc# hX]ddahVcY jc^kZgh^i^Zh ^i^h^bedgiVciidgZVX][jijgZiZcVcihVcY]djhZ]daYZghVcY\^kZi]Zbi]Z`cdlaZY\Z VcYVhe^gVi^dchidZchjgZi]Vii]^h^hhjZ^hVYYgZhhZY#HijYZcih[dgbi]Z\ZcZgVi^dc i]ViXVcZmeZXiida^kZi]gdj\]i]ZbdgZZmigZbZegd_ZXi^dchd[Xa^bViZ!l]ZgZi]ZdaYZg \ZcZgVi^dcbVn[ZZaÈI]^hYdZhcÉiVeeanidbZ0>ÉaaWZ\dcZWni]ZcVcnlVnÉ# ]dbZdlcZgh eg^kViZ]dbZdlcZghbV`Zjei]ZaVg\ZhiXdbedcZcid[i]Z]djh^c\hZXidg#7n ejgX]Vh^c\i]ZbdgZZ[ÒX^ZcilViZghVk^c\^iZbh!i]Zcdc"ZcZg\n^ciZch^kZXdda^c\ iZX]cdad\nVcYi]ZÓddYgZh^a^Zci^iZbh!]dbZdlcZghXVcYg^kZbVg`Zi[dgXZhVcYYZa^kZg hjhiV^cVW^a^in^begdkZbZcih# .

gdci^chjaVi^dcegd\gVbbZ!i]ZÈ9>NeaVcZigZeV^ghÉXVbeV^\cVcY i]Z<gZZc=dbZh^c^i^Vi^kZ# :mZbea^[n \dkZgcbZciiV`Zh i]ZaZVY 6hlZaaVhZcXdjgV\^c\di]ZghidVYVei!i]ZjhZd[VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhdcejWa^X Wj^aY^c\hYZbdchigViZhi]ViVYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhVgZVkV^aVWaZ!ViigVXi^kZVcYldg` ViaZVhiVhlZaaVhcdc"VYVei^kZVaiZgcVi^kZh#  >cVYY^i^dc!egdXjg^c\VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh[dgejWa^XWj^aY^c\hl^aaeaVn VkVajVWaZbVg`ZiigVch[dgbVi^dcgdaZ# .l]^X][dXjhZhdci]Z)È:Éh" :cVWaZ!:cXdjgV\Z!:c\V\Z!VcY:mZbea^[n# Egdk^YZ^c[dgbVi^dcVWdjii]ZadXVa^beVXihd[\adWVaXa^bViZX]Vc\Z!VcYXaZVgedgiVah [dg]djhZ]daYZghidVXXZhh^c[dgbVi^dcVWdjii]ZXdhihVcY^bea^XVi^dchd[VYVeiVi^dc bZVhjgZh# Ldg`id^cXdgedgViZi]ZVYVeiVi^dcV\ZcYV^cidigV^c^c\[dgi]dhZl]dVgZgZhedch^WaZ[dg i]ZegVXi^XVa^chiVaaVi^dcd[VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhhjX]VhhdX^VagZ\^hiZgZYaVcYadgYhVcY ^chiVaaZgh# Egdk^YZVaZVYZgh]^egdaZ^cZchjg^c\i]ViVaaVheZXihd[VXXdbea^h]^c\gZigdÒii^c\VgZ ZVhZY[dgi]Z]djhZ]daYZg# :cXdjgV\Z \^kZi]Zg^\]ih^\cVah :chjgZi]Vii]ZiVmVi^dchnhiZbZcXdjgV\ZhVYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh![dgZmVbeaZWn gZYjX^c\K6IdcegdYjXihl]^X][dgbeVgid[Vhj^iZd[VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh!hjX]Vh ÓddYWVgg^ZghVcYlViZg"Z[ÒX^ZciegdYjXih# :c\V\Z \ZieZdeaZ^ckdakZY >cXdgedgViZVYVeiVi^dc^cidXVbeV^\chVcYegd\gVbbZhi]VieZdeaZVgZVagZVYn^ckdakZY ^c!hjX]Vhi]ZLVgb.Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ +) 6Xi^dch[dgeda^XnbV`Zgh >cgZXd\c^i^dci]Vii]ZbV_dg^ind[VYVeiVi^dc l^aaWZXVgg^ZYdji^cegVXi^XZWnVc jcXdccZXiZYVggVnd[VXidgh!i]Zbdhi ^bedgiVcih^c\aZgdaZ[dgXZcigVa\dkZgcbZci ViVaaaZkZah!^hXddgY^cVi^c\!ZcXdjgV\^c\VcY ZcVWa^c\i]ZVXi^k^i^Zhd[i]dhZl]dl^aaYZa^kZg VYVeiVi^dcid^cY^k^YjVa]djhZ]daYZgh# :cVWaZ bV`Z^iZVh^Zg >ciZ\gVi^c\VcYbV^chigZVb^c\Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z VYVeiVi^dc^cidVaaVgZVhd[ejWa^Xeda^Xnid Yg^kZVYVeiVi^dc^cZm^hi^c\]dbZh^hdcZd[i]Z bdhi^bedgiVciVXi^dch[dg\dkZgcbZci#I]^h b^\]i^cXajYZZbWZYY^c\VYVeiVi^dc^cidi]Z cZl9ZXZci=dbZhegd\gVbbZedhi"'%&%VcY a^c`^c\VYVeiVi^dcidb^i^\Vi^dcl]ZgZgZaZkVci# I]^hegdXZhhXVcWZVeegdVX]ZYjh^c\i]Z bdYZadjia^cZY^cÈHZXjg^c\i]Z[jijgZ" YZa^kZg^c\J@hjhiV^cVWaZYZkZadebZci higViZ\nÉ!).

+* Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ 6Xi^dchgZfj^gZY[gdbi]Z Y^[[ZgZciXdchi^ijZcX^Zh 8daaVWdgVi^dcl^i]Zm^hi^c\XVbeV^\ch VcYegd\gVbbZh I]ZgZ^hVkZgngZVag^h`i]Viign^c\id Zc\V\Zi]ZejWa^Xl^i]i]ZVYVeiVi^dc^hhjZ XdjaYWZXdjciZgegdYjXi^kZ!l^i]VcZbe]Vh^h Egd[Zhh^dcVa^chi^iji^dch]VkZVc^bedgiVci dc^cZk^iVWaZX]Vc\ZhVhVgZhjaid[egZk^djh gdaZideaVn^c^c[dgb^c\VcYigV^c^c\i]Z^g Zb^hh^dchgZYjX^c\i]ZZ[[ZXi^kZcZhhd[ bZbWZghVhidi]Z^bedgiVcXZd[VYVeiVi^dc iZX]cdad\^Zh!i]ZVeegdeg^ViZcZhhd[Y^[[ZgZci XVbeV^\chideZghjVYZeZdeaZidgZYjXZ Zb^hh^dch#6bdgZZ[[ZXi^kZVeegdVX]XdjaY bZVhjgZh!VcYi]ZcVijgZd[i]ZVYVeiVi^dc bVg`Zi#I]Z^cXajh^dc^cegd[Zhh^dcVaXjgg^XjaV WZidZchjgZi]ViVYVeiVi^dcVcYb^i^\Vi^dc XVbeV^\chVgZ^ciZ\gViZY!gVi]Zgi]Vc d[i]ZXdhihVcYWZcZÒihd[VYVeiVi^dc VeegdVX]ZYhZeVgViZan# bZVhjgZh^hVcZhhZci^VahiZe^cZchjg^c\ Z[[ZXi^kZjeiV`Z#L^i]djiVXXZeiVcXZWni]Z >cVYY^i^dc!i]ZVYVeiVi^dcV\ZcYVh]djaY egd[Zhh^dcVa^chiVaaZgh!l^YZhegZVYjeiV`Z XdaaVWdgViZl^i]ÈfjVa^ind[a^[ZÉ^c^i^Vi^kZh! l^aaWZY^[ÒXjaiidVX]^ZkZ#6YY^i^dcVaan! hjX]Vhi]Z[jZaedkZgin^c^i^Vi^kZhV^b^c\ gZiV^aZghVgZVhdjgXZd[^c[dgbVi^dcVi id^cXgZVhZi]ZXdb[dgid[kjacZgVWaZ\gdjeh i]Zed^cid[hVaZ# ^ci]Zl^ciZg#>chdbZXVhZh!i]ZgZVgZXaZVg GZXdbbZcYVi^dch/ hncZg\^ZhWZilZZcV\ZcYVh"[dgZmVbeaZ! VcnbZVhjgZhidjhZ]dilViZgbdgZZ[ÒX^Zcian ™9ZkZadei]ZVYVeiVi^dch`^aahZiWn hjX]Vhadl"Ódlh]dlZghl^aaVahdgZhjai ^cXdgedgVi^c\i]Z^chiVaaVi^dc!bV^ciZcVcXZ ^cVhjWhiVci^VaZcZg\nhVk^c\#:mVbeaZh VcYXdhi$WZcZÒid[VYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh ^cXajYZi]ZÈLVgb[gdciÉegd\gVbbZ!^chiVaa^c\ ^cidegd[Zhh^dcVaigV^c^c\VcY8E9[dg ^chjaVi^dc^ciVg\ZiZY]dbZh# ÒiiZghVcY^chiVaaZgh# Egd[Zhh^dcVa^chiVaaZgh!ÒiiZgh!hjeea^Zgh VcYgZiV^aZgh ™EgdbdiZZYjXVi^dcl^i]^c^chi^iji^dch GZXdbbZcYVi^dch/ VWdjii]ZadXVa^beVXihd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z! ™>cXdgedgViZVYVeiVi^dcbZhhV\ZhVcY i]ZcZZY[dgVYVeiVi^dc!VcYi]ZVkV^aVW^a^in ^c[dgbVi^dc^cidb^i^\Vi^dcXVbeV^\ch!hjX] d[\gVcihVcYdi]Zg^cXZci^kZh#Dg\Vc^hVi^dch VhÈ9>NEaVcZiGZeV^ghÉVcY<gZZc=dbZh# i]Vih]djaYWZZc\V\ZYl^i]^cXajYZ8>7H:! 7>HG>6!>E=:VcY8DG<># ™>cXdgedgViZVYVeiVi^dc^cidi]ZhjXXZhhdg idi]Z9ZXZci=dbZhegd\gVbbZYjZid ™>cigdYjXZVgdWjhilViZg"Z[ÒX^ZcXnaVWZaa^c\ ZcY^c'%&%# hX]ZbZh^b^aVgidi]ZZcZg\n"Z[ÒX^ZcXn aVWZaa^c\hX]ZbZ# .

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ ++ :ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn 8daaVWdgVi^dcl^i]Zm^hi^c\\gdjeh .G6ÉhLViZgHVk^c\ <gdje!l]^X]Wg^c\hid\Zi]Zg`ZneaVnZgh idadd`Videedgijc^i^ZhidbVcV\ZlViZg YZbVcY#=dlZkZg!dkZg]ZVi^c\^hi]ZaZVhilZaa jcYZghiddYd[i]Zi]gZZ`Zn^beVXih!VcYYdZh cdi]VkZi]ZWZcZÒid[Zm^hi^c\^ciZgZhi\gdjeh# 8dhigZegZhZcihdcZd[i]Zbdhih^\c^ÒXVci WVgg^ZghidVYVeiVi^dc[dg]djhZ]daYZgh! Vai]dj\]i]^hWVgg^Zg^hXdbedjcYZYWndi]Zgh hjX]Vh^cZgi^VVcYjcXZgiV^cin#.jcY^c\!\gVcihVcY^cXZci^kZh LViZghigZhhVcYÓddY^c\Wdi]V[[ZXii]Z i]gZZgZ\^dchVgZVh^cYZeZcYZciand[Xa^bViZ X]Vc\Z!VcYhddeedgijc^i^Zh[dgXdaaVWdgVi^dc WZilZZchiV`Z]daYZghVagZVYnZm^hi#6\ddY ZmVbeaZd[i]^h^h9:.dgiZcVcih! i]ZgZ^ha^iiaZ^cXZci^kZidbV`ZVYVeiVi^dch gZfj^g^c\VaiZgVi^dchidi]Z[VWg^Xd[i]Z Wj^aY^c\!h^cXZi]Znl^aadcanWZd[WZcZÒi Yjg^c\i]ZXdjghZd[i]Z^giZcVcXn# HjWh^Y^hZY^chjaVi^dchX]ZbZhVgZVkV^aVWaZk^V ZcZg\nji^a^i^ZhVheVgid[i]Z^g:cZg\n:[ÒX^ZcXn 8dbb^ibZci!Wjii]ZWZcZÒihd[i]ZhZVgZ \^kZc^ciZgbhd[l^ciZghVk^c\#I]ZediZci^Va WZcZÒihd[^chjaVi^dc[dg`ZZe^c\Wj^aY^c\hXdda Yjg^c\i]ZhjbbZggZXZ^kZa^iiaZViiZci^dc!VcY ^chjaVi^dcbVnWZZggdcZdjhanXdch^YZgZYWn ]djhZ]daYZghidZmVXZgWViZi]ZegdWaZb# GZXdbbZcYVi^dch/ ™:hiVWa^h]Vh^b^aVg\gdjeidVYYgZhhi]Z ^beVXid[dkZg]ZVi^c\# GZXdbbZcYVi^dch/ ™>cXdgedgViZVYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh^cid Zm^hi^c\b^i^\Vi^dc^cXZci^kZhX]ZbZh! jh^c\Zm^hi^c\dg\Vc^hVi^dchhjX]Vhi]Z :cZg\nHVk^c\hIgjhi# ™GZYjXZK6IdcVYVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZhhjX] adl"Ódlh]dlZgh!ÓddYWVgg^Zgh VcYh]jiiZgh#  .

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ Ji^a^i^ZhVcYbVcj[VXijgZgh Bdgi\V\ZXdbeVc^Zh LViZgXdbeVc^Zh]VkZVadc\]^hidgnd[ldg` dclViZghigZhh!l^i]i]ZhjXXZhhd[gZXZci XVbeV^\chWj^aY^c\dci]dhZi]Vi]VkZiV`Zc eaVXZdkZgi]ZaVhii]gZZYZXVYZh#Ji^a^in XdbeVc^Zh]VkZVcdc\d^c\gZaVi^dch]^e l^i]i]Z^gXjhidbZgh!VcYVgZ^cVc^YZVa edh^i^dcid\^kZi]Zb^c[dgbVi^dcVWdji i]ZeZghdcVaVcYXdbbjc^in^bea^XVi^dch d[i]Z^glViZgVcYZcZg\nXdchjbei^dc# Ldg`^c\l^i]bVcj[VXijgZghidZcXdjgV\Z jhZd[lViZgaVWZahVhegdbdiZYWni]Z 7Vi]gddbBVcj[VXijgZgh6hhdX^Vi^dcl^aa]Zae XdchjbZghbV`ZbdgZZ[ÒX^ZciX]d^XZh!VcY i]ZhZXdjaYWZhjeedgiZYWnji^a^inXdbeVc^Zh# Bdgi\V\ZXdbeVc^ZhgZfj^gZ^chjgVcXZ ^cYZbc^in!VcYbVnWZVWaZidldg`l^i]i]Z ^chjgVcXZ^cYjhignidZcXdjgV\Z]dbZdlcZgh idgZigdÒiVeegdeg^ViZVYVeiVi^dch#D[ ]djhZ]daYh^ci]Zi]gZZgZ\^dch!+.eZgXZci VgZWjn^c\l^i]Vbdgi\V\Z# GZXdbbZcYVi^dch/ ™:cXdjgV\Zi]ZjhZd[lViZgVcYZcZg\n W^aahid\^kZXjhidbZgh[ZZYWVX`dci]Z^g Xdchjbei^dc^cXdbeVg^hdcidi]Z^g Xdbbjc^inVcYidegZk^djhW^aa^c\eZg^dYh# ™Hjeedgii]Z^cigdYjXi^dcd[VgdWjhilViZg Z[ÒX^ZcXngVi^c\aVWZa!h^b^aVgidi]ZZcZg\n Z[ÒX^ZcXngVi^c\aVWZah# ™:chjgZi]ViegdXjgZbZci^cejWa^XWj^aY^c\h YZbdchigViZhWZhiegVXi^XZ[dgVYVeiVi^dc# GZXdbbZcYVi^dch/ ™:cXdjgV\Zbdgi\V\ZXdbeVc^ZhidgZaZVhZ Zfj^in[gdbi]ZegdeZginVaadl^c\i]Z ]dbZdlcZgid^beaZbZciVYVeiVi^dch# .+.eZgXZci VgZdlcZg"dXXje^ZY!VcYd[i]ZhZ!*.

Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ +- =dbZ>c[dgbVi^dcEVX`=>EVhhZhhdgh >chjgVcXZXdbeVc^Zh >cXdbbdcl^i]hjgkZndgh!ZhiViZV\Zcih VcYVgX]^iZXih!=>EVhhZhhdghVgZ^cVhigdc\ edh^i^dcid^cÓjZcXZ]djhZ]daYZghl]Zci]Zn VgZbdk^c\]dbZ"Vc^YZVadeedgijc^inid egdbdiZgZigdÒii^c\# >chjgVcXZXdbeVc^Zh!VcYi]Z6hhdX^Vi^dcd[ 7g^i^h]>chjgZgh!VgZVagZVYnVXi^kZ^cegdbdi^c\ bZVhjgZhidgZYjXZi]ZYVbV\ZXVjhZYWn ÓddY^c\!VcYid^c[dgb]djhZ]daYZghd[i]Z dei^dchVkV^aVWaZidi]Zb#=dlZkZg!VYdei^dcd[ ÓddYgZh^hiVciVcYgZh^a^ZcibZVhjgZhgZbV^ch adl#.addYg^h`^c[dgbVi^dc!VkV^aVWaZ[gdb i]Z:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn!h]djaYWZ ^cXajYZY^c=>Eh# ™6YVeiVi^dcbZVhjgZh!VhlZaaVh ZcZg\nZ[ÒX^ZcXnbZVhjgZh!XdjaY WZ^cXajYZY^c=>Eh# GZXdbbZcYVi^dch/ ™>chjgVcXZXdbeVc^Zhh]djaYXdci^cjZid ldg`id\Zi]Zgl^i]i]Z67>id egdbdiZÓddY"gZh^a^ZcigZeV^gid ]djhZ]daYZghl]d]VkZVagZVYnbVYZÓddY ^chjgVcXZXaV^bh# .dgZmVbeaZ!^cVgZXZcihjgkZnÓddY k^Xi^bhlZgZ^ciZgk^ZlZYdcXZi]Z^gegdeZgi^Zh ]VYWZZcgZhidgZY!VcYVh`ZYl]VieaVchi]Zn ]VY[dgVYVei^c\i]Z^g]dbZhV\V^chi[jijgZ ÓddY^c\#:^\]ineZgXZci]VYcdeaVchid bV`ZVcnVYVeiVi^dchidi]Z^g]dbZh#*%L]ZgZ ]djhZ]daYZghX]ddhZcdiid^chjgZ"dgXVccdi Ydhd"VYVeiVi^dcXVcgZYjXZi]ZÒcVcX^Vag^h`# GZXdbbZcYVi^dch/ ™.

addYHdaji^dch . Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ LZcZZYidldg`id\Zi]ZgVcYh]dl i]ZejWa^Xl]ViVcVYVeiZY]djhZadd`h  a^`Z!]dlbjX]^il^aaXdhi!VcYl]Vii]Z   adc\"iZgbWZcZÒihl^aaWZ# IdiVa.+.

dgjbÉhWajZeV\Zh"VY^gZXidgn I]ZJ@8a^bViZ>beVXiEgd\gVbbZJ@8>EXddgY^cViZh d[egdYjXihVcYhZgk^XZhid^begdkZndjg]dbZÉh gZhZVgX]dc]dlXa^bViZX]Vc\Zl^aa]VkZVc^beVXi^c ÓddYgZh^a^ZcXZ# i]ZJ@VigZ\^dcVaVcYcVi^dcVaaZkZah# lll#ÓddY[dgjb#dg\#j`$ÓddYT[dgjb$C.% 9^gZXidgn [jgi]Zg^c[dgbVi^dcVcYgZhdjghZh <ZcZgVa I]Z>ciZg\dkZgcbZciVaEVcZadc8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z>E88 ]VhegdYjXZY[djgbV_dgVhhZhhbZcigZedgihh^cXZ&.addYG^h`"egdk^YZhVÓddYg^h`gVi^c\ [dgegdeZgi^Zh!ÓddY^c\egdWVW^a^inVcYa^`Zan ^chjgVcXZedh^i^dc# lll#l]VihbnÓddYg^h`#Xdb .addY^c\ :ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn.addYBVe#>YZci^ÒZh^[ndjg ]dbZdgWjh^cZhh^h^cVi^YVadgÓjk^VaÓddYodcZ jh^c\edhi"XdYZadXVi^dch# lll#Zck^gdcbZci"V\ZcXn#\dk#j`$hjW_ZXih$ÓddY$-'++..' XdkZg^c\Xa^bViZhX^ZcXZ!^beVXihVcYVYVeiVi^dc!VcY b^i^\Vi^dcd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z#I]ZaViZhigZedgi!6G)! lVhejWa^h]ZY^c'%%.-%($4kZgh^dc2&aVc\2TZ L]ViÉhBn.adlhegd_ZXihh]dlVcZmVbeaZd[V]dbZ XdckZgiZY[dgÓddYgZh^a^ZcXZ# Ódlh#lW#ij"]VgWjg\#YZ$^cYZm#e]e4^Y2).addYEgdiZXi^dc6hhdX^Vi^dc"egdk^YZh^c[dgbVi^dc dcÓddYVaaZk^Vi^dchnhiZbhhjeea^Zgh!^chiVaaZghVcY ÓddYbVcV\ZbZciVYk^XZ# lll#ÓddYegdiZXi^dcVhhdX#Xd#j` 8>G>6ÓddY^c\\j^YZ"VYk^XZdci]ZgZeV^gVcY gZhidgVi^dcd[Wj^aY^c\h[daadl^c\VÓddY# lll#X^g^V#dg\$ÓddY^c\$ LViZg >ciZgeVkZ"<j^YVcXZ[dg]dbZdlcZghdcgZhedch^WaZ gV^clViZgbVcV\ZbZci!eZgbZVWaZeVk^c\VcYHj9H# lll#eVk^c\#dg\#j`$eZgbZVWaZ#e]e LViZgl^hZ"^cYZeZcYZciC<D[dXjhZYdcgZYjX^c\ lViZgXdchjbei^dc^ci]ZJ@#>iegdk^YZhVYk^XZdc lViZgZ[ÒX^ZcXnVcY^ihlZWh^iZ^cXajYZhYViVWVhZ d[lViZg"Z[ÒX^ZciVeea^VcXZh# lll#lViZgl^hZ#dg\#j`$ :ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn"LViZgGZhdjgXZhlZWh^iZegdk^YZh VYk^XZdc]dlidhVkZlViZgVi]dbZVcYVildg`# lll#Zck^gdcbZci"V\ZcXn#\dk#j`$hVkZlViZg .# lll#^eXX#X]$ I]ZCdgl^X]Jc^dc\j^YZidÓddY"gZh^a^Zci]dbZh ^cXajY^c\VÓddYh^bjaVidgVcYÓddY^c\hjeedgieV\Zh lll#ÓddYgZh^a^Zci]dbZ#Xd#j`$ I]Z..addY.)$ -'..& I]ZCVi^dcVa.T7ajZEV\ZhT lll#j`X^e#dg\#j`$YZ[Vjai#Vhe BVhiZg#eY[ 8a^bViZ8]VaaZc\Z^hV\dkZgcbZciegd\gVbbZ[dg Xdbbjc^XVi^dcegd_ZXihid^begdkZejWa^XVii^ijYZh VWdjiXa^bViZX]Vc\Z# lll#Xa^bViZX]VaaZc\Z#\dk#j`$^cYZm#]iba 9>NEaVcZiGZeV^ghegdk^YZhegVXi^XVaVYk^XZVcYjhZ[ja ^c[dgbVi^dcdcgZYjX^c\ndjgXVgWdcZb^hh^dch# lll#adcYdc#\dk#j`$Y^n$ 8a^bViZX]Vc\Z^c[dgbVi^dc[gdbi]Z 778LZVi]Zg8ZcigZ# lll#WWX#Xd#j`$Xa^bViZ HiZgcGZk^Zl/I]Z:Xdcdb^Xhd[8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z# J@<dkZgcbZciÉhVcVanh^hd[Xa^bViZX]Vc\ZZ[[ZXih dci]Z\adWVaZXdcdbn# ]iie/$$lll#]b"igZVhjgn#\dk#j`$^cYZeZcYZciTgZk^Zlh$ hiZgcTgZk^ZlTZXdcdb^XhTXa^bViZTX]Vc\Z$hiZgcgZk^ZlT ^cYZm#X[b .

Wc_gZZT&.$ \gVcihVcYd[[ZghhZVgX] 8dchigjXi^dcGZhdjgXZh"ZXdad\^XVaWj^aYZgÉhbZgX]Vci! hZaa^c\^chjaVi^dcbVYZ[gdbgZcZlVWaZgZhdjgXZh# lll#XdchigjXi^dcgZhdjgXZh#Xdb$ 6c6jhigVa^Vc\j^YZidjh^c\eVhh^kZbZVhjgZh id[dg`ZZe^c\ndjg]dbZXdda# lll#\gZZc]djhZ#\dk#Vj$ndjg]dbZ$iZX]c^XVa $[h&%#]ib 7ZVi^c\i]Z=ZViJ@8>E"add`hVi]dlWj^aY^c\h eZg[dgbVcXZcZZYhidegdk^YZi]ZgbVaXdb[dgi jh^c\eVhh^kZVcYbZX]Vc^XVaXdda^c\# ]iie/$$lll#j`X^e#dg\#j`$gZhdjgXZh$ejWa^XVi^dch$ejWT YZih#Vhe4>92+.^cYndjg adXValViZgXdbeVcn[gdb/ lll#lViZg#dg\#j`$]dbZ$gZhdjgXZh"VcY"a^c`h$a^c`h$ lViZg"deZgVidgh 8dchZgk^c\LViZg^c7j^aY^c\hÉ^c[dgbVi^dchdjgXZ [dglViZgXdchZgkVi^dc# ]iie/$$lll#Zck^gdcbZci"V\ZcXn#\dk#j`$XdbbdcYViV$ VXgdWVi$\Z]d&&%...& Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ BVcnlViZgXdbeVc^Zh]VkZgZ\jaVgheZX^Vad[[Zghdc lViZg"Z[ÒX^ZciYZk^XZhhjX]VhlViZgWjiih#. 8>7H:IB(+ÈI]Z^cYddgZck^gdcbZcid[Wj^aY^c\h/ ^beVXihVcYVYVeiVi^dcÉ#HiVcYVgYhVcY\j^YVcXZ dc^cYddgi]ZgbVaXdb[dgiVcYdkZg]ZVi^c\# lll#X^WhZ#dg\ I]Z:cZg\n:[ÒX^ZcXnVcYGZcZlVWaZ :cZg\n8aZVg^c\]djhZ:G:8# lll#cgZa#\dk$YdXh$aZ\dhi^$daY$&*.()(&-#eY[ DkZg]ZVi^c\ :cZg\nHVk^c\Igjhi"XdciV^chVYViVWVhZd[ \gVcihVkV^aVWaZ[dg^chjaVi^dc!VcYdi]Zg ZcZg\nZ[ÒX^ZcXnbZVhjgZh# lll#ZcZg\nhVk^c\igjhi#dg\#j`$egdmn$k^Zl$[jaa$'%&.&#eY[ .

&*=BIgZVhjgn'%%+HiZgcGZk^Zldci]Z:Xdcdb^Xh d[8a^bViZ8]Vc\ZEVgiK# &+D[ÒXZd[CVi^dcVaHiVi^hi^Xh=ZVai]HiVi^hi^Xh FjVgiZgan'.(BZcjT6aa2&!.jijgZ.addY^c\GZedgi# ]iie/$$lll#[dgZh^\]i#\dk#j`$EgZk^djhTEgd_ZXih$.#eY[ &.dgZh^\]i.addYG^h`Pdca^cZR# ]iie/$$lll#Xdbbjc^i^Zh#\dk#j`$YdXjbZcih$ eaVcc^c\VcYWj^aY^c\$eY[$eaVcc^c\eda^XnhiViZbZci'* .- .VXihVWdji/8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z/ 8VgWdcY^dm^YZZb^hh^dchWnZcYjhZg/ &.%"'%%*Jc^iZY@^c\Ydb# ]iie/$$lll#YZ[gV#\dk#j`$Zck^gdcbZci$hiVi^hi^Xh$ \adWVibdh$`[$\V`[%.:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn'%%+CVi^dcVa.djgi]6hhZhhbZciGZedgi# ]iie/$$lll#^eXX#X]$ (J@8>E'%%'8a^bViZ8]Vc\ZHXZcVg^dh[dgi]ZJc^iZY @^c\Ydb"I]ZJ@8>E%'7g^ZÒc\GZedgi# ]iie/$$YViV#j`X^e#dg\#j`$gZhdjgXZh$ejWa^XVi^dch$ YdXjbZcih$J@8>E%'TWg^ZÒc\#eY[.!'%%*/ ]iie/$$lll#Xdbbjc^i^Zh#\dk#j`$YdXjbZcih$]djh^c\$ mah$iVWaZ"&%.G6'%%+@Zn.' GZ[ZgZcXZh &9:.addY^c\G^h`">hhjZh6[[ZXi^c\ i]Z>chjgVcXZ>cYjhign\ZcZgVa^chjgVcXZgZedgi cjbWZg&%.^\jgZ*#&# ]iie/$$lll#VW^#dg\#j`$9^heaVn$.addYG^h`ÄI]^c`^c\[dg Idbdggdl!6Xi^c\IdYVn# &)67>lZWh^iZ# ]iie/$$lll#VW^#dg\#j`$9>HEA6N$YZ[Vjai#Vhe4BZcjT >92.(!%8]^aYT>92-&. HidX`IV`Z/9Za^kZg^c\>begdkZbZcih^c:m^hi^c\ =djh^c\Pdca^cZR# lll#hY"lll#hY"Xdbb^hh^dc#dg\#j`$ejWa^XVi^dch$ YdlcadVYh$HidX`TIV`ZTJ@T=djh^c\#eY[ &(67>'%%+8dVhiVa.Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ . &%9ViVhdjgXZ/8A<!iVWaZ&&%!'%%*# ]iie/$$lll#Xdbbjc^i^Zh#\dk#j`$YdXjbZcih$]djh^c\$ mah$iVWaZ"&&% &&I]gZZGZ\^dch8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z<gdje# HiV\Z&GZedgi# lll#adcYdc#\dk#j`$igXX\ &'HjhiV^cVWaZ9ZkZadebZci8dbb^hh^dc'%%.addYG^h` 6hhZhhbZciGZhjaih# &-67>'%%%/6hhdX^Vi^dcd[7g^i^h]>chjgZgh HZei'%%%>caVcY.^aZ$8]^aY$**($ Xa^bViZX]Vc\Z'%%)#eY[&.9ViVhdjgXZ/8A<iVWaZ&%..addY TVcYT8dVhiVaT9Z[ZcXZ$GZedgihTVcYTEjWa^XVi^dch$ Egd_ZXiTDjiejih$Djiejih#]ib *?Zc`^ch!<#?#!EZggn!B#8#!VcYEg^dg!B#?#%'%%.#]ib '>E88'%%..Heg^c\'%%+BdgiVa^in^chdji]Zgc :c\aVcYYjg^c\i]Z'%%(]ZVilVkZWneaVXZd[YZVi]# ]iie/$$lll#hiVi^hi^Xh#\dk#j`$Vgi^XaZh$]hf$&)&....D[ÒXZd[CVi^dcVaHiVi^hi^Xh!'%%+EdejaVi^dc IgZcYhPdca^cZR# ]iie/$$lll#hiVi^hi^Xh#\dk#j`$HiVi7VhZ$EgdYjXi# Vhe4kac`2+(%( -8dbbjc^i^ZhAdXVa<dkZgcbZci'%%+ EaVcc^c\Eda^XnHiViZbZci'*/9ZkZadebZci VcY.# I]ZXa^bViZd[i]ZJc^iZY@^c\YdbVcYgZXZciigZcYh# BZiD[ÒXZ=VYaZn8ZcigZ!:mZiZg!J@# ]iie/$$lll#j`X^e#dg\#j`$Xa^bViZT^beVXih$j`X^E%-T IgZcYh#Vhe +D[ÒXZd[CVi^dcVaHiVi^hi^Xh!'%%*@ZnEdejaVi^dcVcY K^iVaHiVi^hi^XhAdXVaVcY=ZVai]6ji]dg^in6gZVh# ]iie/$$lll#hiVi^hi^Xh#\dk#j`$YdlcadVYh$i]ZbZT edejaVi^dc$@EKH('T'%%*$@EKH'%%*#eY[ .jcYZYWn9Z[gV! egdYjXZYWnIncYVaa=VYaZn8ZcigZh[dgJ@8>E )D[ÒXZd[HX^ZcXZVcYIZX]cdad\n'%%) .

.addY.IdlVgYhLViZg CZjigVa^in^ci]ZI]VbZh<ViZlVn#9ViVhdjgXZ/ 8A<iVWaZ&%.%8]^aYT>92**' '':ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn.'$&.8ZcigVa:c\aVcYIZbeZgVijgZGZXdgY# ]iie/$$lll#bZid[ÒXZ#\dk#j`$gZhZVgX]$ ]VYaZnXZcigZ$8GTYViV$9V^an$=VY8:ITVXi#imi ..addY'%GZeV^g'%9dX'%&#eY[EV\Z+ '*7ajZeg^ci[dgLViZg!&%HiZehidHjhiV^cVWaZ LViZgWn'%&*!Pdca^cZR# lll#WajZeg^ci[dglViZg#dg\#j` '+Ad\^XV8B<P'%%+R8dchjbZghijYnLViZg:[ÒX^ZcXn/ EjWa^Xde^c^dc!eg^kViZVXi^dc# '.%+($&&--'+*$ &&.%BZcjT6aa2&!&%--!&%.).+$&''---)4gZ[ZggZg2$gZ\^dch$ hdji]Zgc$&&+-.J@8>E%'BZVcVccjVaegZX^e^iVi^dcX]Vc\Z jcYZgadlVcY]^\]Zb^hh^dchhXZcVg^dh[dg '%'%h!'%*%h!VcY'%-%h# ]iie/$$lll#j`X^e#dg\#j`$hXZcVg^dh$j`X^e%'$bVeh$ hZVhdch$egZXTVccjVa#\^[ (%:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn'%%. ()LViZgl^hZ#dg\#j`# ]iie/$$lll#lViZgl^hZ#dg\#j`$ (*I]gZZGZ\^dch8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z<gdje# HiV\Z&GZedgi# lll#adcYdc#\dk#j`$igXX\ (+88lViZg'%%+Jh^c\LViZgL^hZan# ]iie/$$lll#XXlViZg#dg\#j`$jeadVY$eY[$Jh^c\ TLViZgTL^hZanTk)TEG>CI#eY[ (.addYBVcV\ZbZci/ Edh^i^dcHiViZbZci# ]iie/$$Zck^gdcbZci#\dk#j`$VWdjijh$*&'(.-$'-.)'-$ +*+'.dgjb!GZeV^g^c\ndjg]dbZ dgWjh^cZhhV[iZgVÓddY"]dlida^b^iYVbV\Z VcYY^hgjei^dc^ci]Z[jijgZ!Pdca^cZR# ]iie/$$lll#VW^#dg\#j`$7dd`H]de$GZhZVgX]GZedgih$ .D[ÒXZd[CVi^dcVaHiVi^hi^Xh!'%%+EdejaVi^dc IgZcYhPdca^cZR# ]iie/$$lll#hiVi^hi^Xh#\dk#j`$HiVi7VhZ$EgdYjXi# Vhe4kac`2+(%( '-:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXndca^cZ/EZgXVe^iVXdchjbei^dc ^ci]ZHdji]:Vhi!&.!'%%*# ]iie/$$lll#Xdbbjc^i^Zh#\dk#j`$YdXjbZcih$ ]djh^c\$mah$iVWaZ"&%.%)'$&&+.addYG^h`# ]iie/$$lll#Xdbbjc^i^Zh#\dk#j`$YdXjbZcih$ eaVcc^c\VcYWj^aY^c\$eY[$eaVcc^c\eda^XnhiViZbZci'* '%6hhdX^Vi^dcd[7g^i^h]>chjgZgh'%%*I]ZHdji] :VhiEaVc"8dchjaiVi^dcHjWb^hh^dc[gdbi]Z67># ]iie/$$lll#VW^#dg\#j`$9^heaVn$.( Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ &.(id'%%*$'%%+# ]iie/$$lll#Zck^gdcbZci"V\ZcXn#\dk#j`$Xdb bdcYViV$&%(&.LViZg:[ÒX^ZcXn^ci]Z Hdji]:Vhid[:c\aVcY"GZigdÒii^c\:m^hi^c\=dbZh# (&I]gZZGZ\^dch8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z<gdje#Ndjg=dbZ ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZÄ8VhZHijY^Zh# lll#adcYdc#\dk#j`$igXX\ ('LViZgJ@'%%+IdlVgYhHjhiV^cVW^a^in'%%*"'%%+# ]iie/$$lll#lViZg#dg\#j`$]dbZ$eda^Xn$gZedgih$hjh" iV^cVW^a^in$^cY^XVidgh"'%%*"%+$idlVgYh"hjhiV^cVW^a^" in"'%%*"'%%+#eY[ ((:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn'%%.)%$&&+.^aZ$8]^aY$**($ hdji]ZVhieaVc#eY[e' '&67>YViV'%%-# ]iie/$$lll#VW^#dg\#j`$9^heaVn$YZ[Vjai#Vhe4BZcjT >92&%.8dbbjc^i^ZhAdXVa<dkZgcbZci'%%+EaVcc^c\ Eda^XnHiViZbZci'*/9ZkZadebZciVcY.$4kZgh^dc2&aVc\2TZaVc\2TZ ')67>$CVi^dcVa...addYBVe# lll#Zck^gdcbZci"V\ZcXn#\dk#j`$hjW_ZXih$ÓddY '(:ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn:[[ZXi^kZ..($ '.

=B<dkZgcbZci'%%*HZXjg^c\i]Z.addYGZh^a^ZcXZGZhZVgX]GZedgi! XVgg^ZYdji[dgCdgl^X]Jc^dc# )&D[ÒXZd[CVi^dcVaHiVi^hi^Xh6jm^a^Vgn9ViV[dg'%%( HjbbZgBdgiVa^inHiVi^hi^XhPdca^cZR# ]iie/$$lll#hiVi^hi^Xh#\dk#j`$YdlcadVYh$i]ZbZT ]ZVai]$Vjm^a^VgnTYViVThjbbZgTbdgiVa^inT'%%(#mah 8gdlc8deng^\]ibViZg^Va^hgZegdYjXZYl^i]i]Z eZgb^hh^dcd[i]ZXdcigdaaZgd[=BHD )'8VaXjaVi^dcWVhZYdcVXVgigVkZaa^c\&%!%%%b^aZh$ nZVgl^i]8D'Zb^hh^dchd[&*%\$`b#8dbeVgVWaZ idÒ\jgZh\^kZc^c6chdcLjVcY?VX`nEZii! 6hhdX^Vi^dc[dgi]Z8dchZgkVi^dcd[:cZg\n6j\jhi '%%+8daY8db[dgi[dg@ndid48VgWdc^bea^XVi^dch [gdb^cXgZVh^c\gZh^YZci^VaXdda^c\YZbVcY "6hXde^c\gZedgi#E'+iVWaZ.T ^Y&&*+%'(#mah ]iie/$$lll#hmX#]j .Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ .&# ]iie/$$Xdbbjc^i^Zh#\dk#j`$ejW$-)%$H&(*T^Y&&*)-)%#mah )+]iie/$$lll#Xdbbjc^i^Zh#\dk#j`$ejW$'($IVWaZ&&.) (-J@8>E'%%'L]ViVWdjibneVgid[i]ZJ@4 ]iie/$$lll#j`X^e#dg\#j`$Xa^bViZTX]Vc\Z$Wn TadXVi^dc#Vhe (.8>7H:'%%+<j^YZ6/:ck^gdcbZciVa9Zh^\c# ]iie/$$lll#X^WhZ#dg\$^cYZm#X[b4\d2ejWa^XVi^dch# k^ZlEjW>92&A&2&+) )%?BGdW^cZ!HA8]Zjc\!HAZGdn!=KVcDnZcZi .8D>EgZeVgZY[dg9Z[gVBVgX]'%%..# )(<gZViZgAdcYdc6ji]dg^inDXidWZg'%%+AdcYdcÉh JgWVc=ZVi>haVcY/6HjbbVgn[dg9ZX^h^dcBV`Zgh# ]iie/$$lll#adcYdc#\dk#j`$bVndg$Zck^gdcbZci$Xa^" bViZ"X]Vc\Z$j]^#_he ))8>7H:'%%+<j^YZ6/:ck^gdcbZciVa9Zh^\c# )*8dbbjc^i^ZhVcYAdXVa<dkZgcbZci'%%*IVWaZ &%.G=ZggbVcc'%%.jijgZ" YZa^kZg^c\J@hjhiV^cVWaZYZkZadebZcihigViZ\n# *%>8B'%%*.9lZaa^c\hidX`/WniZcjgZ&VcYgZ\^dc![gdb&.GZedgidcZmXZhhbdgiVa^in ^c:jgdeZYjg^c\hjbbZg'%%(Pdca^cZR# ]iie/$$ZX#ZjgdeV#Zj$]ZVai]$e]Tegd_ZXih$'%%*$ VXi^dc&$YdXh$VXi^dc&T'%%*TV'T&*TZc#eY[ ).EjWa^X 6ii^ijYZhid8a^bViZ8]Vc\ZPdca^cZR# ]iie/$$lll#Xa^bViZX]VaaZc\Z#\dk#j`$Xdbbjc^XViZ$ l]ViTYdTeZdeaZTi]^c`#]iba )-]iie/$$lll#\VhbjhZjb#Xd#j`$XdckZgh^dc#]ib ).

* Ndjg=dbZ^cV8]Vc\^c\8a^bViZ 6X`cdlaZY\ZbZcih I]ZI]gZZGZ\^dch8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z<gdjeldjaYa^`Z idi]Vc`i]ZHiZZg^c\<gdjebZbWZgh!VcYdi]Zgh! l]dXdcig^WjiZY\gZViani]gdj\]djii]^hegd_ZXi/ I]Z<gdjeldjaYVahda^`Zidi]Vc`Vaai]dhZl]d ViiZcYZYi]Z8dchjaiVi^dc<gdjehYjg^c\i]^hegd_ZXi# EZccn7gVblZaa <dkZgcbZciD[ÒXZ[dgAdcYdc8]V^gd[I]gZZGZ\^dch8a^bViZ8]Vc\Z<gdje GVX]Za7gVYaZn 7F :bbV7jabZg <dkZgcbZciD[ÒXZ[dgAdcYdc =ZVi]Zg7jii^kVci Hdji]:Vhi8a^bViZ8]Vc\ZEVgicZgh]^e =ZaZc8]VebVc I]VbZhLViZg :a^oVWZi]8]ViiZg_ZZ HjhiV^cVWaZ9ZkZadebZci8dbb^hh^dc BVii]Zl8]Zaa :Vhid[:c\aVcY8a^bViZ8]Vc\ZEVgicZgh]^e @Z^i]8dafj]djc I]VbZhLViZg ?Zcc^[Zg9Vdi]dc\ <gZViZgAdcYdc6ji]dg^in ?dcVi]Vc9Zcc^h :ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn 6cYgZl:V\aZh HjhiV^cVWaZ=dbZh CViVh]V<aZccdc <gZViZgAdcYdc6ji]dg^in @Vi]gnc=jbe]gZn 9Z[gV L^aaAdX]]ZVY <dkZgcbZciD[ÒXZ[dgAdcYdc 6a^hdcBVi]^Vh =djh^c\8dgedgVi^dc 6aZmC^X`hdc <gZViZgAdcYdc6ji]dg^in <gV]VbCjcc <dkZgcbZciD[ÒXZ[dg:Vhid[:c\aVcY 8]g^hi^cZD\YZc 8dbbjc^i^ZhAdXVa<dkZgcbZci @ViZEZcYZg AdcYdc9ZkZadebZci6\ZcXn ?dgcEZiZgh Hdji]:Vhi:c\aVcYGZ\^dcVa6hhZbWan 8]g^hE]^aedi LViZgl^hZ I^bGZZYZg :ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn Gd\ZgHigZZi J@8a^bViZ>beVXihEgd\gVbbZ BV\YVHinaZh :ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn HlZc_VHjgb^ch`^ 6hhdX^Vi^dcd[7g^i^h]>chjgZgh @ViZHnbdch 7G: 6cYgZlIjX`Zg <gZViZgAdcYdc6ji]dg^in GdcL]^iZ]ZVY .addYEgdiZXi^dc6hhdX^Vi^dcIdiVa..addYHdaji^dch ?dVccZOn\bjci LViZgl^hZ .

.+ Hjeedgi^c\Dg\Vc^hVi^dch <dkZgcbZciD[ÒXZ[dgAdcYdc ]iie/$$lll#\dh#\dk#j`$\da AdcYdc8a^bViZ8]Vc\ZEVgicZgh]^e ]iie/$$lll#adcYdc#\dk#j`$Xa^bViZX]Vc\ZeVgicZgh]^e Hdji]:Vhi8a^bViZ8]Vc\ZEVgicZgh]^e ]iie/$$lll#Xa^bViZhdji]ZVhi#dg\#j` I]ZHjhiV^cVWaZ9ZkZadebZciGdjcYIVWaZ[dgi]Z :Vhid[:c\aVcY ]iie/$$lll#hjhiV^cVW^a^inZVhi#dg\#j` :ck^gdcbZci6\ZcXn ]iie/$$lll#Zck^gdcbZci"V\ZcXn#\dk#j` I]VbZhLViZg ]iie/$$lll#i]VbZhlViZg#Xd#j` Jc^iZY@^c\Ydb8a^bViZ>beVXihEgd\gVbbZ ]iie/$$lll#j`X^e#dg\#j` AdcYdc9ZkZadebZci6\ZcXn ]iie/$$lll#aYV#\dk#j` <gZViZgAdcYdc6ji]dg^in ]iie/$$lll#adcYdc#\dk#j` 6GJE ]iie/$$lll#Vgje#Xdb lll#adcYdc#\dk#j`$igXX\ .