Professional Documents
Culture Documents
October 2004
710010-R
Copyright 2005 McKinsey & Company. Confidential. Not for further reproduction or distribution.
Context:
Would Indias infrastructure be sufficient to sustain Road, rail, telecom, and power infrastructure meet basic
rapid industrialization? needs and are being expanded and modernized
Would Indias infrastructure be sufficient to sustain Road, rail, telecom, and power infrastructure meet basic
rapid industrialization? needs and are being expanded and modernized
Arunachal Pradesh
Rajasthan
Languages
Main towns (Population in millions, 2001 census)
Mumbai (Bombay) - 11.9 Delhi - 9.8 Kolkata (Calcutta) - 4.6 Bangalore - 4.3 Chennai (Madras) - 4.2 Hyderabad - 3.5
Gujarat
Madhya Pradesh
Assam Nagaland Meghalaya Bihar Manipur Tripura Jhark- West hand Bengal Misoram Chattisgarh Orissa
Maharashtra
Political structure
Andhra Pradesh Karnataka
13 officially recognized languages; over 1,700 dialects Hindi national language; English widespread as a second language
Form of state
Hindu (82%) Muslim (12.1%) Christian (2.3%) Sikh (1.9%) Buddhist (0.8%) Jain (0.4%)
Head of State
The Executive
Currency
Bicameral National The Rajya Sabha, or upper Legislature house, has 245 members The Lok Sabha, or lower house, has 545 members
4
8 12 20
10 18 25
Rest of world
63
28 24 32
0-15
23
China
India
63.6
India
60
58 15 27
India
50 22 28
China
5
China
72.2
China
86
Services
Sources: EIU; CIA World Fact Book; Asian Demographics Report; U.S. Census
Himachal Pradesh Punjab Uttaranchal Haryana Arunachal Pradesh Sikkim Rajasthan Uttar Pradesh Bihar Gujarat Assam Meghalaya Manipur Tripura Mizoram Nagaland
Madhya Pradesh
Chattisgarh Orissa
Wealthy states
Maharashtra
Population, 2003: 530mn % of Indias population, 2003: 49.7% Area: 1,494 (000 sq. km) Primary drivers: manufacturing, services GDP/capita ($) CAGR**
612 267 386 720 80-90 90-00 3.8% 4.7%
Laggards
Andhra Pradesh Karnataka
Population, 2003: 536 million % of Indias population, 2003: 50.3% Area: 1,661 (000 sq. km) Primary economy drivers: agriculture GDP/capita ($) CAGR
264 312 328 80-90 90-00 3.4% 1.7% 189
Kerala
Tamil Nadu
Would Indias infrastructure be sufficient to sustain Road, rail, telecom, and power infrastructure meet basic
rapid industrialization? needs and are being expanded and modernized
INDIA HAS SEEN STRONG, ROBUST GROWTH OVER THE LAST 20 YEARS
Real GDP growth* $ Billions 5.4% 3.0%
118 159 473
5.7%
558
5.8%
279
4.2%
60
3.2%
86
1960 434
1970 548
1980 687
1990 850
2000 1,016
2003 1,066
4.0% 0.7%
216 231
523
3.6%
0.8%
199
328
1950
* Base year = 2002 Sources: WEFA-WMM; team analysis
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
2003
8
GROWTH HAS BEEN SPURRED BY THE POSITIVE DIRECTION AND TRACK RECORD OF REFORMS DURING THE PAST 20 YEARS
Green Revolution Further and restrictions nationalisation 1969 1973 Balance of payment crisis in 1991 1991 Liberalization (faster reforms) 1991 to 2000 Narasimha Rao D. Gowda I.K. Gujral Second phase of Continued reform liberalization kickstarted 2000-2004
Tentative liberalization
Era
1953
1984
2004-
Lal Bahadur Indira Gandhi Indira Gandhi Shastri Morarji Desai Rajiv Gandhi Indira Gandhi Charan Singh V.P. Singh Chandra Shekhar Liberalization Increased Acknowledgment of of agriculture; emphasis on Unprofitability of governmentprivate sector the public sector controlled competitiveness Stifling effect industrial of controls growth Entry barriers Nationalisation Significant lowered for restrictions on of many sectors foreign Banks/ exchange insurance through Foreign Core Exchange sectors Regulation Act Controls on Capital market expansion of large business controls houses
Pace of reforms increased due to pressure from World Bank and IMF
Continued and increased commitment for economic reforms in the country Deregulation in strategic sector such as telecom, petroleum, and power Increased emphasis on disinvestment Rationalization of tariff structure Introduction of value-added tax
Policy
Soviet-style central planning Focus on heavy industry Passive public-sector ownership Virtually closed to international trade
Overhaul of Trade policy Industrial policy Financial sector Tax system Public sector
1 2
Product reservation for small-scale industry (SSI) Tax and excise duties
VAT of 13% for agriculturerelated products and 17% for others Corporate tax rate is 33%
Effective regulatory framework and strong regulatory bodies in telecom and power
Independent regulatory
bodies set up for most utilities (e.g., telecom and power) and financial services (e.g., securities and insurance)
The licenses/quasilicensing requirements exist in sectors such as cars, textiles,and electronic gambling machines
Import duties range from Average range of import Average range of import 15% to 40% (basic) 0% to 30% duty is 0% to 20% duties from 0% to 30% Customs duty for Duty for commodities: Steel Duty for commodities: Steel Duty for commodities: commodities: Steel (10%), (4%), Al(6%), Cu(6%) (0%), Al (0%), Cu(5%) Steel (1%-12%), Al (1.5%Al (10%), Cu (15%) 7%), Cu (1%-8%) Almost complete
deregulation: 100% FDI allowed in most sectors, with few restrictions (e.g., insurance, telecom, retail)
Foreign ownership
* Central Value Added Tax Sources: MGI (McKinsey Global Institute) report; press search; PwC; E&Y; team analysis
10
Computerization of land
records in some states Removal of Urban Land Ceiling Act
Most of the land is privately Russian government owns All domestic land is state
Property taxes, stamp Stamp duty rate ranges The assessment of Property tax rate is Property taxes are charged duties, and property tax is both on established by regions but on historical cost or current from 5% to 14.7% surcharges cannot exceed 2.2% rental Property taxes are charged market value and historical cost on historical cost rather Property tax based on book Stamp duty range from than market value value 0.5 to 4 Tenancy laws
Tenancy laws favor tenants Tenancy laws favor tenants Tenancy laws favor tenants Tenancy laws favor tenants
and it is difficult for owners to reclaim property in case of disputes and it is difficult for owners to reclaim property in case of disputes and it is difficult for owners to reclaim property in case of disputes and it is difficult for owners to reclaim property in case of disputes
10
Government equity
disinvested in PSUs like VSNL*,BALCO**,IBP, CMC, ITDC ~$2.3 earned from disinvestments
Government divested
entities in sectors like utilities and telecom (199294: $8.6bn and 1995-02: $78.6bn)
Private ownership
introduced to more than 130,000 companies but state still accounts for 50% of GDP. Main sectors are utilities, telecom.
Government divested
entities in PSUs, but government still shareholder
11
Labor laws
Two-thirds of employees in Employment termination need government approval any Brazilian company only allowed on grounds for employee retrenchment must be Brazilian provided in Labor Code. Removal of restrictions on Notice period is 30 days Notice period is 2 weeks using contract labor in SEZs*** Private participation in
infrastructure permitted (e.g., ports and airports)
Employment termination
allowed on grounds in Labor Code Notice period is 30 days
12
Infrastructure
Government trying to
approve the PPP (PublicPrivate Partnership) law to expand the level of private investment in infrastructure
A large part of
infrastructure belongs to government, but last 2-3 years private companies (especially metals and oil & gas) have started investing in ports and roads
Private participation in
construction; operation and sharing of partnership of infrastructure, such as subway, bridges, ports operation are permitted
* ** *** Sources:
Videsh Sanchar Nigam, Limited Bharat Aluminium Company Special Economic Zones MGI (McKinsey Global Institute) report; press search; PwC; E&Y; team analysis
11
Would Indias infrastructure be sufficient to sustain Road, rail, telecom, and power infrastructure meet basic
rapid industrialization? needs and are being expanded and modernized
Savings rate, 2003 China Russia South Korea Japan Taiwan India Germany U.K. U.S.
13% 11% 26% 24% 24% 22% 33% 33% 43%
13
10.3 9.3
ICOR measures
6.9
6.8
6.7
the efficiency of the economy in using capital resources Defined as the units of incremental capital required to generate one additional unit of output The higher the ICOR, lower the efficiency
Brazil
Mexico
Chile
U.S.
Hong Kong
Malaysia Korea
China
India
* Average share of fixed investment in GDP during the previous four years, divided by average growth rate of real GDP in previous four years = ICOR Sources: EIU; team analysis
14
53.0
57.0
4.0
1993
2003
1993
2003
6.0
35
1.0
45
1993
2003
1995
2003
15
30.1
29.8
China Korea
India
Japan
U.S.
India
Brazil
49.5
68.8
36.1 23.0 19.0 9.1 5.8 2.0
57.2
47.0
Brazil
India
Japan
India
China Mexico
16
Would Indias infrastructure be sufficient to sustain Road, rail, telecom, and power infrastructure meet basic
rapid industrialization? needs and are being expanded and modernized
Indias real GDP* growth $ Billions CAGR = 5.4% 558 129 429
1998
2003
Growth in 5 years
18
Increasing earnings
GDP/capita*, $
1995
1999
2003
2003
300 200
+
3 Reducing incentive to save
4 Availability of consumer
100 0 95 97 99 01 03 05 07 09
CAGR 36%
26 17
Consumer spending per capita comparison, CAGR (2003-2010) U.S. U.K. 3.7% 7.5% 0.8% China 7.7%
10
12
Japan
* 2002 terms ** Includes car finance, housing finance, personal loans, credit cards, two-wheeler credit, commercial vehicle credit, and consumer durable financing Sources: WEFA-WMM; CMIE; CSO; EIU; SSKI report; team analysis
19
1 20
1 26
38 33 41
Lower-middle income ($1,400-$2,000) Low income (< $1,400)
6%
10%
41 27 18 20
1995-96
5%
2%
10 13
2001-02
-5% -5%
-9% -7%
8
2006-07E
* Annual Income at PPP levels (PPP = purchasing power parity); average size of a household is 5.8 people Source: NCAER
20
AS A RESULT, INDIAS CONSUMER MARKETS ARE GROWING FAST AND ALREADY RANK AMONG THE WORLDS LARGEST
TV sales Million units
4.5
EXAMPLE
Key manufacturers
11.5 8.0
2000
2003
Samsung Sony LG Philips Toshiba Panasonic Nokia Ericsson Motorola Siemens Alcatel Bajaj Hero Honda TVS Yamaha Kinetic Motor Co.
21
16
2000
2003
2000
Source: Press search
2003
Would Indias infrastructure be sufficient to sustain Road, rail, telecom, and power infrastructure meet basic
rapid industrialization? needs and are being expanded and modernized
116
40
6.6
6.8
2.9
3.0
8.9
94
31 17
5.3 10.7 10.2 3.3 4.9
27
66
15
13 23
44 32 Construction Electricity, gas Manufacturing Mining & quarrying 4.9 9.0 9.9 5.8 4.0
17 5
8 46 29
69 61
12 4 15 2 1980
19 4
1985
6
1990
8
1995
8
2000
9
2003
15.7
10.4
5.6
-0.7
4.2
23
59.9
26.1
17.5
37.4 6.8 22.6 4.6
8.4%
7.5%
18.0
1990 1995 2000 2003
24
LABOR PRODUCTIVITY IS INCREASING AND THERE IS POTENTIAL FOR FURTHER IMPROVEMENT WITH REMOVAL OF BARRIERS
Labor productivity has improved Real GDP per worker*, $ CAGR 3.3% Potential to improve is high
Reform in the automotive industry has led to significant growth in productivity
1,477 1,312
100
1,118 966
CAGR in percent (1990-2003) 1992-93 Labor productivity growth comparison 1999-00
7.3
1990
1995
2000
2003
U.K. U.S.
* Base year = 2002 Sources: EIU; Global Insight; WEFA-WMM; economic survey of India; interviews; SIAM; annual reports; team analysis
Japan
25
23.0 19.0
Graduates
2,200
8.7
Engineers
295
0.5
China
0.6
India
0.7
1.0
2.1
U.S. Germany
M.B.A.s
60
* Unskilled/semiskilled labor Sources: EIU; Manpower Profile of India; Human Resource Development Ministry
26
18%
19%
898 70% 90
193 67% 94
55 67% 90
85 67% 95
27
* Economically active population is aged 15-64 years ** Official statistics; however, a lot of underemployment in India Sources: U.S. Census Bureau; WEFA-WMM; EIU; ILO
BACKUP
6.4
30
28
Aircraft
Others
63.8
1 2 Inorganic chemicals 2 15 Jewellery 2 3 Optical instruments 3 7 7 Edible oils Organic Chemicals Nuclear reactors, boilers Electrical machinery & equipment
Exports Percent 100% = $54.7 bn Jewellery
Exports Percent
20
Others
17
Non-knitted 6 apparel
Others 45
UAE
5 Hong Kong
UK Germany 3 China Japan Singapore Belgium
4 3 3
Italy
Mineral fuels, 5 oils, etc. 4 Knitted Fish & crustaceans 4 apparel Cotton 4 Organic Chemicals 4 3 3 3 3 3 Iron and steel Pharmaceuticals Parts of nuclear reactors,boilers Electrical machinery & equipment Cereals
43
28
Would Indias infrastructure be sufficient to sustain Road, rail, telecom, and power infrastructure meet basic
rapid industrialization? needs and are being expanded and modernized
4.6
3%
6.2
4%
8.2
5%
14.6
10%
17.7
15%
20.6
6.0
4.7
25%
Roads and other transport**
10.2
14.0
45%
46%
41%
32%
5.0
3.0
12%
Railways
10% 9% 6%
3.3
1.6
38%
40%
44%
50%
7.7
4.3
1970
Infrastructure investment as % of GDP
1975
4.6
1980
5.2
1985
5.2
1990
5.2
1995
4.9
2000
4.4
3.9
* Infrastructure investment is the gross capital formation in the specified sectors; Base year = 2002 ** Includes ports, civil aviation, and inland waterways Sources: CMIE; Global Insight; World Bank
30
HIGHWAYS
1,539
660
U.K.
Sources: Planning commission; NHAI; CIA World Fact Book; CMIE Infrastructure Report - 2003
31
HIGHWAYS
Mumbai-Pune Expressway
State/district roads
32
RAILWAYS
70 32
21
21 8 7 5 4
Korea U.S.
Sources: Planning commission; Indian Railways; India Infrastructure Report 2003; CIA World Fact Book
33
RAILWAYS
Calcutta metro
34
POWER
India China Malaysia + Taiwan Korea Thailand x Egypt Japan UK Germany U.S. Brazil Indonesia
14,000 12,000 10,000 8,000 6,000 4,000 2,000 0 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 40,000
real GDP/capita in 2002 $ Intensity curve for emerging economies high power intensity Very high energyintensive new emerging economies (China, India) y = 1.0945x-41.0 R2 = 0.91 y = 0.4858x-3.9 R2 = 0.93
y = 0.0099x1.33 R2 = 0.86
Strong correlation between per capita GDP and power consumption The later an economy develops, the more power hungry it is, as a result of technology advancements (relatively more applications that consume power used) Given Indias current level of development, it is expected that India will continue to follow the very high power intensity curve in the medium term (e.g., up to 2025)
35
BACKUP
392
269
133 89
20.3
5 2.7
Western region
North West South East Northeast
Southern region
Northern region
Eastern region
Energy gap driven by Inadequate generation capacity Inadequate transmission capacity, leaving even available generation unevacuated Inefficient and inadequate distribution capacity with high T&D losses (50%)
37
* Year-round average difference between unconstrained energy requirement and energy supply ** Peak period average difference between unconstrained energy requirement and energy supply Sources: Analyst reports; Ministry of Power
841
530
capacity in India is still relatively smaller than China. China is adding the power capacity in one year that India is adding in 5-6 years Planned power generation capacity addition annually is double what was added on average over the past 5 years The governments achievement of planned targets has risen to 80% as observed in the past two years. Its not yet clear if this will be maintained or fall back to ~50% (as seen in previous plans)
1996-97 2001-02 2006-07 End of VIIIth Plan End of IXth Plan End of Xth Plan
*Demand estimation in Services-led growth scenario GDP growth 5.5% CAGR (03-10) **Last five-year average of 65% capacity addition target achievement assumed Sources: Ministry of Power; CMIE; Central Electricity Authority; Global Insight; team analysis
38
GOVERNMENT HAS DELIVERED ON CAPACITY EXPANSION PLANS IN THE RECENT PAST AND IS LIKELY TO CONTINUE DOING SO POWER
Track record of target achievement
4,891
Hydel
1378
3,441 3,420
4,086
2,927
641 228
2590
Thermal
134 1362
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
39
INTERESTINGLY, POWER SHORTAGES IN THE PAST HAVE NOT PREVENTED ECONOMIC GROWTH, AS THE INDUSTRY HAS WORKED AROUND THE POWER ISSUE
Relation between Power shortage** and GDP growth Real GDP growth*
POWER
12%
40
49.4
1.7
74.4
41.5
Fixed line
41.2 33.6
U.S.
Brazil
China
India
Cellular
6.4
13.0
March 02
March 03
March 04
Korea
U.S.
Germany Brazil
China
India
Sources: TRAI EIU; ITU; Pyramid Research; Ministry of Information Industry (China)
41
Would Indias infrastructure be sufficient to sustain Road, rail, telecom, and power infrastructure meet basic
rapid industrialization? needs and are being expanded and modernized
INDIA HAS SHOWN GROWTH IN THE LAST 20 YEARS DESPITE SOME POOR MONSOONS
DROUGHT YEARS
Real GDP growth Percent
12
Years of poor GDP growth monsoon
10
1982 8
GDP growth
1983 1985
6 Average 5.7% 4
2002
0 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003
* Base year = 2002 Sources: WEFA-WMM; Ministry of Agriculture; Center of Studies in Resource Engineering (IIT-Bombay); team analysis
43
Would Indias infrastructure be sufficient to sustain Road, rail, telecom, and power infrastructure meet basic
rapid industrialization? needs and are being expanded and modernized
INDIA HAS SHOWN STRONG, ROBUST GROWTH OVER THE LAST 20 YEARS
Real GDP growth* $ Billions 5.4% 3.0%
118 159 473
5.7%
558
5.8%
279
4.2%
60
3.2%
86
1960 434
1970 548
1980 687
1990 850
2000 1,016
2003 1,066
4.0% 0.7%
216 231
523
3.6%
0.8%
199
328
1950
* Base year = 2002 Sources: WEFA-WMM; team analysis
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
2003
45
GOING FORWARD, GOVERNMENT POLICY IS THE KEY VARIABLE AS IMPLEMENTATION OF ECONOMIC REFORMS WOULD FURTHER UNLOCK INDIAS GROWTH POTENTIAL
MGI study on India Indias growth potential from reforms GDP CAGR Small-scale reservations FDI restrictions India Poor regulation 5.5 (Status quo) High import duties Unequal taxes
Product market barriers
2.3
Government ownership Other barriers: Labor market Roads & ports infrastructure India (complete reforms)
0.7
0.3
10.1
46
CAGR %, 03-10
13,589 4,592 2,244 2,217 1,905 1,670 1,368 930 863 824 811 797 774 725
2025F $ Billions
CAGR %, 10-25
20,718 5,926 5,598 2,879 2,730 2,740 1,834 1,908 1,834 1,568 1,420 1,354 1,205 1,138
U.S. Japan Germany U.K. France China Italy Canada Spain Mexico
India
3.4 1.7 1.7 7.4 2.5 2.2 2.0 3.1 6.4 3.6 5.5 2.5 4.8 5.8
2.9 1.7 6.4 1.7 8.0 2.5 2.2 5.9 2.0 4.4 4.1 2.5 3.4 2.4
U.K. France
India2
Italy Mexico
India3
Mexico
India2
Spain
India3
S. Korea
* Base year = 2002 India 1: High growth at ~8% p.a. India 2: Status- quo growth at ~6% p.a. India 3: Stagnated growth at ~4.5% p.a. Sources:WEFA-WMM; team analysis
47
2003
Status- quo growth: GDP grows at ~6% 4.1%
523
2010
4.9%
2025
36,890
1,416 691
32,046
2003
Stagnated growth: GDP grows at ~4.5% 3.4%
523
2010
3.2
659
2025
24,103
1,054 10,183
2003
Population
2010
1,174
1.4%
2025
1,347
0.9%
1,032 2,128 2,558 3,960
Million CAGR
1,066
U.S.
48
THE SERVICE SECTOR WILL REMAIN THE KEY GROWTH DRIVER IN THE MID AND LONGER TERM
Real GDP* $ Billions, percent 100% = 159 279 473 558 811 1,908
13.2
Agriculture
32.5
31.7
26.2
23.6
Agriculture, hunting, forestry, fishing Mining & quarrying Manufacturing Electricity, gas, and water Construction Wholesale & retail trade, restaurants & hotels Transportation & communications
3.0
4.9
5.5
1.7 1.2 9.3 2.2 10.4 2.8 8.4 15.3 8.0 17.3 12.5 10.5 8.6 14.0 5.2 20.9 3.1 6.6 13.0
Industry
21.6 21.8
6.8
6.8
Services
9.2
Finance, insurance, and real estate Community, social, and personal services
5.3
4.5
1980
1990
2000
2003
2010
2025 49