You are on page 1of 269
Figure  . “Let Your True Voice Be Heard.” AT&T advertising brochure.

Figure . “Let Your True Voice Be Heard.” AT&T advertising brochure.

Index

abstraction/particularity. See particularity/abstraction activism: arts, , ; capitalism and, , ; Christian, , ; gay and lesbian, ; NEA, , n; queer, , n. See also NEA controversy; social movements Adorno, Theodor: and Max Horkheimer, xx–xxi, , , n, n anity vs. identity, xxvi–xxix Agamben, Giorgio, xxix–xxx agency, , , , , , . See also collective action AIDS, xii, , , n, nAIDS Show, The, xiii, , nAlthusser, Louis,  altruism, , . See also philanthropy; volunteerism American Family Association (AFA), ; activities of, , , , n; NEA controversy and, , , n; Tupelo, Mississippi, and, , , ; Allen Wildmon, , ; Donald Wildmon, , ,  Amin, Ash: and K. Robins,  analogies: among cultures, nations, economies, , , , , n; between global/local, ,

; between political/cultural repre- sentation, ; between production/ representation, ; between sexuality/race, , , ; between sexuality/religion, , , n, n, n; between subject of consciousness/subject of labor-power, . See also binary oppositions analogy: compared to binarisms, xxxv, , , n; complicity and, xxiv–xxv, xxxiii, , , , , n; denitions, , ; equivalence and, xxi, xxviii, xxxii, xxxv, , , , n. See also binary oppositions Anderson, Benedict, xix,  Anzaldúa, Gloria, xxii; and Cherríe Moraga, xxii Appadurai, Arjun, xx, , n, n, nArato, Andrew: and Jean Cohen, n Arendt, Hannah, xix–xx, xxx, , n arts, the: communal value of, ,  ; NEA Four, n, n; politics and, . See also NEA; Theatre Rhinoceros arts organizations: advocacy, , , , , , n, n; artist-based, , , n; authenticity, xx, . See also NEA; NEA controversy

220

Index

AT&T, , ,  authenticity: the arts and, xx, ; communitarianism, xx, n; of community, xiii, xxii–xxiv, , , , ; Enlightenment and, ; identity and, xxiii–xxiv; nationalism, xx, ; of organiza- tions, , , , n; professionalism and, ; Theatre Rhinoceros and, 

Badgett, Lee: and Nancy Cunningham, , n Balibar, Etienne, xviii, xix Barber, Benjamin R., n, nBarnet, Richard J.: and John Cavanagh,  Bataille, Georges,  Baudrillard, Jean, , , , n, n Baugniet, Lanny, x, xi, xii Bell, Daniel, , , n Bender, Thomas, , , nBenhabib, Seyla, n Berlant, Laura: and Elizabeth Freeman, , n Berman, Russell,  Bhabha, Homi, , n, nbinary opposition: compared to analogy, xxxv, , , n; complicity and, xxiv–xxv, xxxiii, , ; critique of, xxv; in NEA contro- versy, , , , , ; poststructuralism and, xxv, xxvi; social hierarchy and, ,  binary oppositions: community/ capital, , , , , ; community/society, xx–xxi, , ; domination/exploitation, ix, , , , ; economy/culture, , , , , , , , ; Enlightenment/nationalist, , , , ; gay/Christian, xxxv, , n; global/local, , , , , ; homo/hetero, xv– xvi, ; materiality/discourse, ; modernity/fundamentalism, , , , ; production/

performance, ; progress/decline, , , ; public/private, xxi– xxii, , , , , , , ; spatial/temporal, , , , , , n; urban/rural, xxvii, , ; value/values, xxxiv, , , , , , n. See also analogies; particularity/ abstraction; particularity/ universality Bourdieu, Pierre, , ,  Bramen, Carrie Tirado,  Brecht, Bertolt,  Brenner, Neil,  Brown, Wendy, nButler, Judith: analogy and, xxviii, , ; on consumerism, ; on Laclau, ; performativity, , n, n, n; speech act theory, , , n; subjectivity, xxvii

Calhoun, Craig, ncapital: body as, ; circulation of, xxxii, , , , , , , , , ; cultural, ; family and, ; nance, , n, n; formation of, , ; primitive accumulation of, ; social, , ,  capitalism: “Asian” crony, ; civil society and, ; community and, xxxii–xxxiii, , , , ; critique of, xxxi–xxxiii, , , , n; diversity and, , , , ; diversity of, ; emanci- pation and, , , , ; Enlightenment and, ; Fordist, ; gender and, , , ; gift-exchange, , ; globalization, , ; heterogeneity, ; identity, , , ; industrializa- tion, , ; kinship, , , , , ; nation-state, ; nongovernmental organizations and, , ; nonprot organizations and, , , ; performativity of, xxxi–xxxvi; post- Fordist, , , n;

Index

221

capitalism (continued): Romantic anti-, ; sexuality and, , , ; subjectivity, , , , , ; supplementarity of community with, viii, xxxii–xxxiii, , , , , ,  Carlston, Erin,  Carnegie, Andrew, , ,  Carroll, Thomas F., , n, n Cavanagh, John: and Richard J. Barnet,  Chasin, Alexandra, n Chatterjee, Partha, xx Chaves, Mark,  Christianity: arts advocacy and, , ; in contemporary politics, , n; identity, ; niche markets, , ; sexuality and, xxxv, , , n, n Christian organizations: activism of, , , , n; American Family Association (AFA), , , , , n, n; colonization through, ; pluralism and, n. See also Christian Right, the; faith-based organizations Christian Right, the, , , n, n churches, , , . See also faith- based organizations civil rights discourse, , , , . See also rights discourse civil society, xxxiv–xxxv, , , , , , n Clark, John,  class: bourgeoisie/proletariat, , , , , , ; formation, , , , ; identity, xxiii–xxiv, ; lumpenproleteriat, ; nation and, ; nongovernmental organizations and, , n; revolutionary proletariat, ; rights discourse, ; Theatre Rhinoceros voices on, xiii, , ,  Clemens, Elisabeth S.: and Walter W. Powell,  Coats, Dan: and Rick Santorum, 

Coman, Robert,  Cohen, Jean: and Andrew Arato, n collective action: agency and, , , , , , , ; of artists, , ; based on dierence, xxvi– xxviii; emancipatory, xxiv, xxix–xxxi, , , , , ; identity-based, xvii, xxii–xxiii, xxiv, , , , , ; kinship, , ; nongovernmental organiza- tions and, , , , ; resistance, xxx–xxxi, , , . See also activism; social movements colonialism, xx, , ,  commodity, , , , , ,  communalism: ethnicity, ; kinship, , , ; Marx on, ; as multiculturalism, ; production/ consumption and, viii–ix, ; society vs., , n. See also local, the Communism, , , , , , , ,  communitarianism, viii–ix, xx, , n, n communities: ethnic, xvii–xviii, , , , , , , ; gender-based, xvii–iv, xx, xxii–xxvi, , , n; political, xxvii, ; race based, xvii–xix, , , ; religious, , , n; sexual, xvi, xvii–xviii, ,  community: debt and, , , , , , ; denitions, vii– ix, xvii–xix, xxiv, xxix, ; discourse of, viii–ix, xviii–xxxi, , , , , ; feminist critiques of, xviii, xxvii–xxxi; fetishization of, xxxiv, , ; idealization of, xxiv, xxix–xxx, , , , ; nonprot, ; poststructural critiques of, xxv, xxvii– xxx; Romantic discourse of, xix–xx, xxxi, , , n, n; society vs., xx–xxi, , ; supplementarity of capital with, xviii, xxii–xxxiii, , , , , , , 

222

Index

community-based organizations, ,  consumerism, ,  consumption, , , , , , , n. See also niche markets Cooney, Michael, , ncorporations: AT&T, , , ; diver- sity within, , , , ; Federal Express, ; General Motors, , ; industrialization, , ; kinship structures, , , ; subject formation through, ; worker loyalty,  cultural pluralism. See pluralism cultural studies, viii, , , , n Cunningham, Nancy: and Lee Badgett, , n

debt: community and, , , , , , ; crisis, , , n, n; gift-exchange, ; microcredit, , n, n; Partners for Fragile Families, , ; Theatre Rhinoceros and, , , . See also gift- exchange Delphy, Christine,  D’Emilio, John,  Derrida, Jacques: binary oppositions, xxv; on The Gift (Mauss), , ; politics of memory, ; supplemen- tarity, development: capitalism, ; critiques of, ; discourse of, , ; globalization, , , , , ; industrialization, ; microcredit and, ; nongovern- mental organizations and, , , n, n, n, n, n; sustainability, ; within Theatre Rhinoceros, ; third wave of, n; women, ,  dialectics, , , , , ,  Dionne, E. J., ,  Dirlick, Arif, , n discourse: class formation through, ; materiality binary, , 

discourse of: community, viii–ix, xxviii–xxxi, , , , , ; development, , ; Enlight- enment, xix–xxi, xxxi, , , , , ; globalization, , , , ; global/ localization, , , , , , , ; nationalism, xx– xxi, , , ,  diversity: of capitalism, , ; corporate support of, , , ; the local and, , , n; managing, , , , , n; Theatre Rhinoceros and, xiv, xv, xvii–xviii, xxiii–xxiv, , , , , . See also multi- culturalism; pluralism Dixon, Ken,  domination. See exploitation Dorado, Sylvia,  Douglas, Mary, ,  Durkheim, Emile,

Edwards, Michael David: and David Hulme, ,  Edwards, Michael W.: and Bob Foley, , , n, nEhrenhalt, Alan, Elson, Diane, n Engels, Frederic, xix, ,  Enlightenment, the, xix–xxi, , , , ,  Escobar, Arturo,  essentialism, xx, xxiv, xxvii, xxxii, , , n Estes, Alan, x,  ethnicity: analogies and, , , , , , , , n; commu- nity and, , , , , , ; niche markets, , ; plural- ism, , ; primordialist theory of, n. See also diversity; race Etzioni, Amitai, , Ewen, Stuart, n Ewig, Christina, , , nexploitation: consumption and, , ; denitions, , ; domination and, ix, , , , 

Index

223

Fabian, Johannes,  faith-based organizations: American Family Association (AFA), , , , , n, n; Christian organizations, n; Christian Right, n, n, n, n; churches, , , ; fundamen- talist, ; missionary organiza- tions, ; Traditional Values Coalition, n. See also values family, , , ,  family values: gays and lesbians, ; in modernity, ; and NEA controversy, , , n, n; niche marketing, ; Partners for Fragile Families, , ; worker loyalty vs.,  Fanon, Frantz, xx Federal Express,  Feldman, Shelley, ,  feminist: activism, xxii; analyses of productive labor, , , ; articulations of community, xxx; critique of identity politics, viii, xiv, xxii–xxvi, xxviii; critique of liberalism, xxi–xxii, n, n; critique of nationalism, xx–xxii; and gay historians, ; Marxism, ; poststructuralism, viii, xxvi, xxxi, n; self-critique, xix, xxii, xxiv– xxv, n; studies vs. gay/lesbian studies, , ; theories of dierence vs. identity, xxi, xxvi, xxvii, xxix; theories of globalization, , n; theories of sex as productive labor,  Fernando, Jude L.: and Alan W. Heston, , , n fetishization: commodity, , , ; of community, xxxiv, , ; denitions, ; of family,  Fleck, John, n. See also NEA controversy exibility, nexible accumulation/specialization:

denitions, , n; Fordism, , ; globalization, ; kinship, , , , ; niche

markets, , , , , , , , n; post-Fordism, , , n; production/ consumption,  Foley, Michael W.: and Bob Edwards, , , n, nFord Foundation, ,  Fordism: consumption, , n; corporations, ; in creation of NEA, ; crisis of, , ; discourse of community, , ; kinship, , ; nationalism, ; nonprots and, ; transition to, , n. See also post-Fordism for-prot organizations. See corporations Foucault, Michel, vii, xxv, ,  Frankfurt School, , , , , ,  Fraser, Nancy, xxi, n Freeman, Elizabeth: and Laura Berlant, , n Fukuyama, Francis, ,  fundamentalism, , , , . See also Christian Right; modernity

Gamson, Joshua, n gays and lesbians: AIDS, xii–xiii, , , n, n, n; capitalism, , , ; Christian binary with, xxxv, , n; as community, , , , , , , , , , ; corporations and, , , , ; gift-exchange, , ; identity formation of, , , , , , ; kinship, , , ; as niche market, , , , , , n; philanthropy of, ; productive labor of, , n; vs. queer, xviii; race and, xiv–xv, xvii–xviii, xxiii, xxii–xxiii, , , , ; sexual activity of, , ; volun- teerism, , n. See also kinship; NEA; sexuality; Theatre Rhinoceros Gellner, Ernest, , n, n

224

Index

gender: class and, , , ; communitarianism, xx; family values, ; in gay/lesbian studies, ; industrialization, ; issues at Theatre Rhinoceros, xiv, xvi, xvii; performative construction of, , , n General Motors, ,  Gibson-Graham, J. K., ,  gift-exchange: community and, xxxv, , ; debt vs., ; denitions, ; emancipation and, , ; nonprots and, xxxv, ; supplementarity of economic ex- change with, ; Theatre Rhinoceros and, , . See also debt globalization: colonization, ; community and, , ; cultural studies of, ; development and, , , , , ; discourse of, , , , ; feminism, n; global/ local rescaling, ; industrializa- tion, ; kinship, , , , ; localization discourse, , , , , ; nation- state and, ; nonprot complicity with, ; resistance to, ; Romantic discourse of commu- nity vs., ; social formations in, ; spatial/temporal narratives of, ; structured by analogies, xxxv. See also development; modernization Goldsmith, Edward: and Jerry Mander,



Gordon, Avery,  Grameen Bank,  Gramsci, Antonio, xxvii, ,  Grewal, Inderpal, , n Grønbjerg, Kirsten A., nGuha, Ranajit, xx

Habermas, Jürgen, xix, xxi–xxii, , , n, n, n, n Hall, Peter Dobkin, , , , n Hall, Stuart,  Hansmann, Henry, 

Haraway, Donna, xxvi, , n Harding, Susan, ,  Harvey, David: body as capital, ; corporate kinship, ; exible accumulation, n, n, n; Fordism/post-Fordism, , n; on globalization, , , n; identity commodication, ; performativity, ; pluralism and space, , , , n; value/ use value,  Hauser Center for Nonprot Organizations, , , n hegemony: agency and, ; denitions, xxvii–xviii; heterogeneity and, ; nonprots and, , , n; subject construction, , , , n Heston, Alan W.: and Jude L. Fernando, , , n Holsclaw, Doug, xii, xiii,  homosex of,  hooks, bell, xxii Horkheimer, Max: and Theodor Adorno, xx–xxi, , , n, n Hudock, Ann C., , n Hughes, Holly, n. See also NEA controversy Hulme, David: and Michael David Edwards, ,  human rights. See rights discourse Hunter, James Davidson, 

identity: anity vs., xxvi–xxix, n, n; arts and, , ; authenticity of, xxiii–xxiv; capitalism and, , ; Christian, , , , n, n, n; class, , , , ; commodication of, , ; corporations, ; dierence vs., xxi–xxii, xxvi–xxix; formations based on, xxxiii, , n, n; gender, , n; performativity of, xxv–xxvi, , , , n, n; post- structural criticism of, xx–xxiii, xxv– xxvi; production of, , , ;

Index

225

identity (continued): queer vs. gay, xvii; racial, xxii, xviii–xix, , n; sexual, xv–xvi, xvii–xviii, , , , , n, n, n identity politics, xxii–xxv, xxvi–xviii, , ,  individualism, , , , , , ,  individuation, ,  industrialization, , , 

Jakobsen, Janet, , , n Jameson, Fredric, 

Kazanjian, David, xix,  Keane, John, , n, n Keeping Things Whole (poem), , n kinship: capitalism, , , , , ; community, , , , , ; corporations, , , ; ctive, ; Fordism, , ; gays and lesbians, , , ; General Motors and, ; globalization, , , , , ; liberalism, , ; localization, , ; Marx on, , ; the nation, , , ; premodern, ; production, , ; race, ; social hierarchies, , , , ; the state,  Klein, Christina,  Kushner, Tony, 

labor: consumptive, , ; corpora- tions, ; industrialization, , ; mobility of, , ; nonprot, ; productive, , , , , ; reproductive, , , , , , , n; unproductive, , , n; women’s, xx, , , , , , n labor theory of value, , , ,  Lacan, Jacques, , , , n, n Laclau, Ernesto, ; and Chantal Moue, xxvii–xxviii, , , , n

Lasch, Christopher, , Lee, Martyn J., n, n lesbians: in lesbian workplace, ; in Theatre Rhinoceros, xvi, xvii–xviii, . See also gays and lesbians; women Levine, Daniel,  liberalism: denitions, , n; feminist critiques of, xxi–xxii, n, n; pluralism, , , , ; public/private, xix–xxii, , n, n; subjectivity, ,  Liepetz, Alain,  Lloyd, David: and Lisa Lowe, , nlocal, the, , , , n, n, n localization, , , ,  Lorde, Audre, xxii Lowe, Lisa: and David Lloyd, , nLukenbill, Grant,  Lyotard, Jean-François, xxv

MacDonald, Laura, 

Mander, Jerry: and Edward Goldsmith,

 Mapplethorpe, Robert, n, n. See also NEA controversy maquiladoras, Mexican, 

Marcuse, Herbert,  Martin, Biddy: and Chandra Mohanty,

xxvi

Marx, Karl: Capital (vol. ), , , , ,

, , , ; Capital (vol. ), , ; civil society, ; class formation, , , , , ; “Critique of the Gotha Program,” ; development of community, ; dialectics, , ; discourse, , ; Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, ; Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte, , ; exploitation, , ; fetishism, ; German Ideology, , ; Grundrisse, , , ; kinship, , ; Manifesto of the Communist Party, , ; materiality, , ; “On the Jewish Question,” , xxi; particu- larity/abstraction in, , ;

226

Index

Marx, Karl (continued): rights discourse, ; sexuality, ; social constructionism, ; value, , , , ,  Marxism: feminist, ; orthodox, , ; post-, , , n; poststructuralist, , nmateriality, ,  Mauss, Marcel, Mayer, Margit,  Meadwell, Hudson, n Memmi, Albert, xx methodology, viii, ix–x, xxxiii–xxxvi, , , nmicrocredit, , n, n

Miller, Tim, n. See also NEA controversy Minko, Debra, n modernity, viii, xxxi–xxxii, , , , , , , n, nmodernization, , ,  Mohanty, Chandra: and Biddy Martin,

corporations, , ; critiques of, xix–xxii, n; discourse of, , , ; Enlightenment and, , , ; kinship, , ; modernity, , , , , ; multiculturalism and, ; in NEA controversy, , , , , , ; non- governmental organizations and, n; pluralism, xix, , , ; public/private, xxi–xxiv, ; race,  nation-state: diversity, xix–xx, , ; globalization, , , , ; history of, ; nonprot organizations and, , , ; particularity/abstraction, , ; rights discourse,  NEA (National Endowment for the Arts): Fordism in creation of, ; funding practices of, , , ; history of, . See also NEA

  • xxvi controversy NEA controversy: American Family Association, , , n; arts

Moore, Michael, 

Moraga, Cherríe: and Gloria Anzaldúa,

  • xxii advocacy in, , , n; arts organizations and, , n; Christian organizations, , , , , n; Christians and, , , , n; com- munity and, , , ; Congressional response to, , , n, n; Enlighten- ment/nationalist binary, , , , ; funding, , , , , , n, n, n; gay/Christian binary, ; gays and lesbians, xii, , , , , , n, n; history of, n, n; nation-state, , ; NEA Four, n, n; People for the American Way, , , , n; pluralism, ; public/ private, , ; rights discourse, , ; space/temporality in, , . See also activism; faith-based organizations; nonprot organizations

Moue, Chantal, xx–xxi, xxvi, xxvii– xxviii, n, n; and Ernesto Laclau, xxvii–xxviii, , , , n Moynihan, Daniel P., , ,  multiculturalism, xxiii–xxiv, xv–xviii, , , . See also diversity; pluralism

Nancy, Jean-Luc, xxix–xxx nation, the: as community, xx, , ; as culture, , , , , , n, n; diversity, ; kinship, , , ; rights discourse, , , , , ; as unit of economic activity, , , , , n National Endowment for the Arts. See NEA National Gay and Lesbian Task Force (NGLTF),  nationalism: authenticity, xx,