JWG ORAL ARGUMENT Presented to the Supreme Court of Virgnia May 24, 2011 ** They say it is a Fool who

represents themselves - I had no choice ** So I hope you look at this Fool as someone with a lot of courage **. I am very nervous, honored and grateful to be here ** It says alot about our great country the United States of America. And about the State of Virginia ** When asked for the elevator speech of this situation I refer to a soccer game Each side has equal players - an equal chance to win This soccer field doesn't look like that This case never had that fair playing ground On one side you have : Judge. Klock Haddock Kemler. Dawkins McGrath Fortkort Brown

Said 7 Circuit Court Judges

Ilona - Her law firm Ben DiMuro - past president of the VSB His law firm DiMuroGinsburg David Grenadier His attorney Michael Wieser Commonwealths Attorney Randy Sengal VSB - Edward Davis JIRK - Donald Curry ** I then went to my state Representatives - Patsy Ticer - set it up so I met with Martha Kent - Martha sat listened to my situation - Then explained to me - She had walked in my shoes - understood my situation - she was the x-wife of a Judge - I needed to drop this - and move on as I had no Rights . The appearance of justice, as well as justice itself, is critical to the Commonwealth of Virginia. This is particularly important when a pro se plaintiff like me litigates against an

experienced attorney/defendant like Ms. Ilona Ely Freedman Grenadier Heckman and David Grenadier, her stepson, whose father and Ilonas husband was a judge of the Circuit Court. . To ensure the appearance of justice, as well as justice, Va. Code 17.1.105(B) requires the Chief Justice of this Court to appoint an out of Circuit judge when all judges of the Circuit Court are recused (or were required to recuse themselves). The avoids the appearance that judges who are recused (or are required to be recused) hand select their replacements. . When I filed my suit in 2007, the judges of the Circuit Court were Donald Haddock, Lisa Kemler, and John Kloch. . On or about September 22, 2007, Diane Fisk, the Court administrator, informed me that all three judges had recused themselves, i.e. (1) Judge Kemler was a close friend of and grew up with David; (2) Judge Haddock was a personal friend of Ilona; and (3) Judge Kloch had a personal relationship with Ilona and her late husband. Judge Kloch formally recused himself in September 2007. . At no time thereafter did the Chief Justice appoint an out of Circuit judge. This is a clear violation of the law and should result in all subsequent proceedings being vacated and this Chief Justice appointing an out of Circuit Judge to begin the case anew. It does not matter that my case was dismissed by an out of Circuit judge because his appointment was improper and in violation of the law. . I am a ** Mom with 2 beautiful girls - Abigail is a senor, Kappa at Ole Miss - Madeline is going to be a sophomore, Kappa at University of Texas and plans on going to law school there - - I was their Girl Scott leaders -- Room Mother -- Sports Mom ** this court gave me sole custody of the girls in 2000 ** I am an entrepreneur ** I finished 2 years of college - due to personal reasons didn't finish ** I am far from perfect nor do I expect perfection from others **this situation has taken a horrid toll on my personal life - family life - professional life and the lives of my children I am not an attorney. I did not learn of this provision of the law until June 2010.

** In fact I was told the complete opposite by the Circuit Court of Alexandria - That the only way The Cheif Justice choose a Judge was if they "the Circuit Court " couldn't find a Judge I filed a motion to vacate the dismissal of my case in July, 2010. Incredibly, Judge Kloch, who had recused himself in September, 2007 and then retired from the bench, reappeared. He denied my motion on August 11, 2010 and then recused himself again

and immediately vacated his decision on August 12, 2010. **October 13, 2010 Judge Dawkins refused to recluse himself & denied my motion when by all appearance he had recused himself in 2008 - as he was appointed in April of 2008 and sworn in June of 2008 . These are the facts that I know. I did my best to represent myself. The judges of the Circuit Court are appointed to know and follow the law. Judges must avoid the appearance of impropriety at all times especially to avoid appearing that Judges favored defendants whose deceased husband and father, respectively, had been a member of the Circuit Court by improperly selecting their replacements. . I do not wish to criticize the motives of the Circuit Court Judges, my opponents, the administrator, or the out of Circuit judges involved. I dont have to do so. A clear violation of law occurred. I ask this Court to correct it. **As this law was designed to protect the people from behind close door descisions ** Improperly hand selected Judges ** I ask this court to "Draw the line" to protect the Public ** That the Cheif Justice please choose a Judge to hear my case Again I am honored and grateful for your time Do you have any questions for me? Thank you