You are on page 1of 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

Ludwig von Mises Institute of Canada
Tu Ne Cede Malis
Search here...

Home LvMIC Daily About Blog Learn Events TASC Media Donate
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 1 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism
Tuesday, June 19th, 2012 by James E. Miller posted in Capitalism, Economics, Regulation, Socialism.
Tweet 4 Share 57 Like 0

The word “privatization” is a loaded term these days. Unions and big government worshippers scoff at the idea of any public services being in the hands of ruthless, greedy capitalists. The left has the distorted view that people in the private sector are driven primarily by their desire to cut costs and throw workers out on the street. To them, government workers are angles sent from heaven to do God’s work like picking up the neighborhood trash or
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 2 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

maintaining a public pool filled with the bodily discharges of kids whose derelict parents decided to drop off and go shopping for a few hours. On the right, conservatives who supposedly hold high regard for market forces and Ronald Reagan’s classic declaration “government is the problem,” typically have a favorable view of privatization schemes. Given that government creates no wealth and only consumes capital, privatization of services would seem like an obvious choice; especially for cash strapped states and municipalities. The rational behind privatizing public service is that the private sector is almost always more efficient in operation than bureaucracies unconcerned with earning a return on investment. Even leftists will grudgingly acknowledge the super quality markets tend to produce to a point. So if common sense dictates allowing businesses with a vested financial interest in their own success to pick up the slack in delivering public services, why should free marketers be wary of such ventures? There are just so happens to be two different forms of privatization. The first type is genuine privatization; that is the political class and bureaucrats completely removing their hands of any dealings with the offering of a service. Supporters of the free market should applaud this type of privatization as it means entrepreneurs and investors can freely enter into the industries the government has just vacated. As long as consumers demand the service in question, the opportunity will exist for businessmen to devise new and profitable ways in ensuring its
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 3 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

delivering. The other type of privatization shouldn’t be so appealing. That’s because it isn’t true privatization but a deceptive form of political patronage. These rackets are commonly known as “public-private partnerships” and tend to garner bipartisan support due to the crooked dealings which are almost always their sole impetus. According to the National Council for Public-Private Partnerships, PPPs are a contractual agreement between a public agency (federal, state or local) and a private sector entity. Through this agreement, the skills and assets of each sector (public and private) are shared in delivering a service or facility for the use of the general public. In addition to the sharing of resources, each party shares in the risks and rewards potential in the delivery of the service and/or facility. In other words, PPPs result in the government still maintaining the final say over the delivering of the service. Taxpayers now have the noose of being forced to guarantee an “acceptable rate of return over the term of the partnership” to the contracted company around their neck. Even though public-private partnerships are championed as cutting age methods to modernize the state, underhanded bribes on the taxpayer dime go back at least a century. Perhaps the biggest, most powerful public-private partnership around is the
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 4 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

Federal Reserve System. The New York branch of the Fed, which has been given a monopoly on the supply of what has become the world’s reserve currency, is still technically a private entity that just so happens to have the guns of the state defending its open market operations. Today, public-private partnerships are still offered as a way to mask ever-intrusive government. Recently Senator Rand Paul introduced a measure in the U.S. Congress to “privatize” the crotch fondles in the TSA. “Privatize” is put in quotations because the bill would “require that the mostly federalized program be turned over to private screeners and allow airports — with Department of Homeland Security approval — to select companies to handle the work” according to Politico. Private screeners would still be under the guidelines of the Department of Homeland Security and be paid with tax dollars even though they would be employed by a non-government firm. Ironically, Rand’s father, Texas Congressman Ron Paul, pointed out the flaw in his son’s proposal last July when he wrote: What we need is real privatization of security, but not phony privatization with the same TSA screeners in private security firm uniforms still operating under the “guidance” of the federal government. Real security will be achieved when the airlines are once again in charge of protecting their property and their passengers. President Barack Obama has proposed public private partnerships numerous times during his time in office; namely in childhood education and infrastructure development. Last year
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 5 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

when Obama pushed for an infrastructure bank to pool together capital already swindled from taxpayers to form a quasi-banking institution which would take out loans in order to pay for the rebuilding “roads, bridges, and ports and broadband lines and smart grids,” both the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and AFLCIO were in favor of it. Along with the banksters who stood to make a hefty profit by charging above-market fees to finance such deals, the support of the CC and AFL-CIO should be a nobrainer considering unions and construction companies would most likely be paid to do the “shovel-ready” legwork. It was a PPP even the left could get behind since a portion of the funds went to their supporters. Public-private partnership schemes haven’t been limited to just America lately. In Canada, the province of Ontario has recently considered granting a private company, Teranet Inc., the rights to operate its online service which delivers such things as birth certificates and driver license renewals. According to the World Bank, many European and Central Asian countries are opting for public private partnerships after tax receipts plunged in the wake of the financial crisis. PPPs are still popular among various governments for precisely one reason. There is actually another, more accurate term for public-private partnerships. It’s called fascism; plain and simple. Private business may act as an administrator but the state still pulls the reigns. From a political perspective, public-private partnerships are quite ingenious. Politicians remain in control while convincing voters they believe in the efficiency of a robust private sector. And when issues arise over the performance of a
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 6 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

service, whatever private firm granted the monopolistic privilege of delivery can be treated like a scapegoat despite having to operate within government established guidelines. The state escapes criticism as the public ignorantly clamors for more protection from those evil hearted businessmen. To the ruling establishment, public-private partnerships are “heads I win, tails you lose.” What the non-exploitive supporters of public-private partnerships tend to forget is that it isn’t just the administration of the service in supposedly private hands that adds to its betterment. Why the market function so well is that it is driven by competition from businesses that don’t rely on assistance from the band of thieves who occupy the offices of the state. Government assistance gives some businesses an upper hand on competitors which can lead to diminishing innovation. Why compete when Uncle Sam has your back to ensure a decent rate of profit? Then there are government grants of monopoly which give the chosen company absolutely zero incentive to cut costs. All of the advantages of private ownership become effectively nullified in public-private partnerships to the detriment of the taxpayer. In our world of unceasing centralization of power, lawmakers are finding more deceptive ways to mask their lust for dominance. Public-private partnerships are the embodiment of what Mussolini dubbed “corporatism;” that is the “merger of state and corporate power.” Under corporatism, the ruling class is able to expand unbeknownst to the Boobus Americanus and its equivalent in other countries. The Average Joe still has his
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 7 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

wallet forcefully stripped of its contents but now the state’s cronies get to partake in the plunder. Meanwhile the same big businessmen who benefit from government privilege still maintain their praise for free markets while working with politicians to forcefully subdue their competition. Murray Rothbard was quick to recognize why such parasites of men are dangerous for the blurring of the line between public and private when he wrote: What’s needed is a corporate spokesman who embraces the government-business partnership with enthusiasm and joy – a kind of Big-Businessman-as-Philosopher. When such a champion emerges, Mr. and Ms. America, keep a sharp eye on your wallets – you are about to be fleeced. Distinguishing between genuine privatization and outright fascism is the only way to make sense of the state’s manipulation of words and their meaning. James E. Miller holds a BS in public administration with a minor in business from Shippensburg University, PA. He is the Editor in Chief at the Ludwig von Mises Institute of Canada and a current contributor to his hometown newspaper, the Middletown Press and Journal. Tags: fascism, Privatization, public private partnerships

Comments
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/

Login

Seite 8 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

There are no comments posted yet. Be the first one!

Post a new comment
Enter text right here!

Comment as a Guest, or login:
facebook

Name
Displayed next to your comments.

Email
Not displayed publicly.

Website (optional)
If you have a website, link to it here.

Subscribe to None

Submit Comment

Donate

We need your support! Donate Now
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 9 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

LvMIC Daily Newsletter

Email *

Email...

Submit

LvMIC Weekly Newsletter

Email *

Email...

Submit
Like Tweet 4 Recommend this on Google Sebastian Kwame Braun and 2,079 others like this.

Author Spotlight

James E. MillerMore posts by the Author »James E. Miller holds a BS in public administration with
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 10 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

a minor in business from Shippensburg University, PA. He is the Editor in Chief at the Ludwig von Mises Institute of Canada and a current contributor to his hometown newspaper, the Middletown Press and Journal.Read Full Website: http://millergd.blogspot.com/
Latest Comments
The last comments for

Can the State Produce Wealth? Ross Can the state produce wealth? It sure can; a wealth of useless paper monopoly money... with heavy ac...
» 4 hours ago

rwe2late Myopic and mistaken article. First, the article posits the absurd notion that a public school teacher...
» 15 hours ago The last comments for

Austrian AV Club - Kinsella and the Corporation on Trial TokyoTom Thanks for conducting and posting this interview, Redmond. However, Stephan overstates his position,...
» 19 hours ago The last comments for

Can the State Produce Wealth? Jbm ATMs do put people out of work in the short term. Obama's comment was simply that people need to...
» 21 hours ago

Comments by IntenseDebate

http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/

Seite 11 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

Ludwig von Mises Institute of Canada on
Facebook Like 2,080 people like Ludwig von Mises Institute of Canada.

Ramiro

Olivier

Suvarṇāruṇa Richard

Alain

Michel

Garret

Chris

Facebook social plugin

Latest Blog Posts

0 Comments NRP: Narcoleptic Raiders of the Public Cops. We are told that their job is to “serve an ... 8 hours ago

0 Comments Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 12 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

The word “privatization” is a loaded term these da ... 1 day ago 1 Comments Is Canada Suffering from Dutch Disease? From the Winnipeg Free Press: Resource-rich provinces ... 2 days ago

3 Comments Can the State Produce Wealth? In his latest speaking gaffe, President Obama once aga ... 3 days ago

http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/

Seite 13 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

1 Comments Does America Face an Election Between Two Moderates? This weekend the runoff election will be held in Egypt ... 5 days ago

Categories
Banking Capitalism Civil Liberties Economics Education Environment Epistemology Events Foreign Policy Health Care History Intellectual Property Law Lifestyle
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 14 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

Methodology Music Philosophy Politics Politique Regulation Socialism Trade Uncategorized War on Drugs

Archives
June 2012 May 2012 April 2012 March 2012 February 2012 January 2012 December 2011 November 2011 October 2011 September 2011 August 2011 July 2011 June 2011 May 2011 April 2011 March 2011
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 15 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

February 2011 January 2011 December 2010

Links
Acting Man Capitalism Institute Cliff Küle's Notes Freedomain Radio LewRockwell.com Liberal Studies Michael Geist Mises Academy Mises Wiki Mises.org Stephan Kinsella The Freeman Online Walter Block
The Quotable Mises

Ludwig von Mises: "Under capitalism everybody is the architect of his own fortune." - Bureaucracy

http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/

Seite 16 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

contact@mises.ca 181 Vine Ave, Toronto, Ontario, M6P 1V9 416 624 8848

Home LvMIC Daily About Blog Learn
http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/ Seite 17 von 18

Public-Private Partnership: Another Phrase for Fascism

21.06.12 11:39

Events TASC Media Donate Ludwig von Mises Institute of Canada Copyright 2012. All Rights Reserved. contact@mises.ca Log in

http://www.mises.ca/posts/blog/public-private-partnerships-another-phrase-for-fascism/

Seite 18 von 18