You are on page 1of 63

NRD-SER-101-03

101 6

100 10 1
22
UT 3 23
1
3 24 UT 2
4 2.5mm

3
16 0550 S/D
0SG-XE-109 0SG-XE-105
0SG-XE-105

0.29g

107

101 5 18
7
0.29g

()

(SCC)

() 7
113

2.5mm
120

107

ii


........................................................................................................... i
..............................................................................01
........................................................................................... .. 01
...................................................................................... 02
...................................................................................... 06
...................................................................................... 07

.............................................................. 09
............................................................................................. 09
...................................................................................... 13
() .................................................... 13
() ....................................................................... 26
() ....................................................................... 28
...................................................................................... 31
...................................................................................... 32

........................................... 35

............................................................................................. 35
()0.29g ................................................................. 35
()0.29g ................................................................. 36
() ............................................................... 37
() ................................................................... 37
...................................................................................... 38
()0.29g ................................................................. 38
3

()0.29g ................................................................. 40
() ............................................................... 42
() ................................................................... 44
...................................................................................... 46
...................................................................................... 48

..........................................................

50 ............................................................................................. 50
() ....................................................................... 50
() ....................................................................... 51
() ........................................................................... 52
() ....................................................................... 55
...................................................................................... 56
() ....................................................................... 57
() ....................................................................... 62
() ........................................................................... 75
() ....................................................................... 77
..................................................................................... 79
...................................................................................... 80

.......................................................................

83 ............................................................................................ . 83
() ............................................................................... 83
() ............................................................................... 83
4

() ............................................................................... 84
...................................................................................... 88
() ............................................................................... 88
() ............................................................................... 89
() ............................................................................... 90
...................................................................................... 120
...................................................................................... 121

......................................................................................... 124

...................................................................................... 124
.............................................................................. 127

.............................................................................. 12

21 EOC-21 100 10
24
VT-3
1 A15 8
119 UT

()
100 12 14 10012005001
EOC-21 (RPV Support
Skirt Anchor Bolts)

JCO

EOC-22 (UT)


101 3 23 EOC-22
UT

357 A2 18.2
NonConformance Disposition NCD 10132


101 3 24 119
1

2 ( C6D14)4
(

B10B13C9D11) 2.5mm6

3
16 0550 S/D
0SG-XE-109 0SG-XE-105
0SG-XE-105 0.29g

101 4 3 4 6 4 25 5 14

14185124

14

107

3 4

(SCC)
3

(101 3 16 )

0SG-XE-105 0.29g

4 11 4 27 7
()
() 120

7 120 UT

18

101 5 18 10105006821
7
0.29g

( ) 7
4 11 B10
B13C6C9D11 D14 6 4

17 4 27
3

A2 3 7




1

()
7
113
2.5 mm

113

2

()
7 (
preload) preload 120 ( 7
)


3

() 0.29g
101 3 16

0.29g
( )
0.2g
0.2
4


0.29g

8

0.29g
0.29g
4

()
101 3 16

0.29g

EOC-22
( 708.3.4)
/ ( 59 )
( 732.6-IST)
( 612.3.7) ( 575)
( 295)


5

()


5


157


(SCC)


6

()
EOC-22 7
120 UT

UT


7

()()
()

0.29g
6

()0.29g

()0.29g ()
()
7

()
()()()

()()
() ()
()()

2
1.

AI-4A
-4
A-2

2.
A-3AIV-2

1.
7 101 5 7
2.
7

101 5
3.
101 5
4.
0.29g
101 6 5
5.
101 5
6.
- 101 5 7
7.
Rev.4 101 6 5

/
A2
101 3 24 C6
101 4 5
D14 4 101 4 12

2-1 1 2

1(
EPRI NP-5769 Table 4-1, 1973 Haddam Neck SG Support
Embedment Anchor Bolts high preload & Moisture
Environment (SCC, stress corrosion cracking))
(SCC)
(
)

1 67 5 29
68 1 5 7

(SCC)
10

()

()

(A2C6D14 )

2-2A2 2

(B10B13
C9D11 ) Phased Array 3

B13C9D11 B10
B10
(crack
initiation stage)(crack propagation stage)
:

11

2-3

(SCC)

12

2-4

()
2-5 2-6A2 (Front
view)
2-7A2 (Dimples)
()

(Pickling)
SEM 2-8(
(A)(B)(C)(D)) SEM
(Crack propagation)(Dimples)
/

13

2-9 2-10 C6 SEM A2 SEM


2-13 D14 SEM
2-15 B10

2-5A2 6

2-6A2 2-5 6

14

2-7A2 6

2-8A2 SEM
6

2-9C6 SEM 7

15

2-10C6 I1 a~h SEM

16

2-11D14 (*) 8

2-12D14 8

2-13D14 2-12 SEM


8

17

2-14B10 I1I2 I3
9

18

2-15B10 2-14 (a) I1(b) I2(c) I3


9
10
2

(SCC)

1.

-17A-7-15A-8A-2
AEC-4AIV-3

3 4

0 180

5 31 -15

19

0 180

GEH analysis to date based on design basis loading with


Kuosheng specific values there is no indication of extra loading
in the 0 or 180 location. However GE continues to review with
GEH Systems experts and specialist to evaluate if any other
possible reasons for extra loading at
these locations. At this time there are no possible reasons for
extra loading at 0 or 180 locations.
4 (30 115 217 295 )

0
180

2. SRV S/D
I-2
-12-42
-1-43

-44-45-46
20

(Crack Initiation)
(Crack propagation)

2~3mm ( 3 )(
)
(

21

)(
)

(SCC)A2
A2 C6
C6
D14
5
/
Dimples( 1 )

SEM
(micro-dimples) SEM-EDX
(
10~20 m) SEM (microdimples)
K
( Threshold region)

/
Dimples Striations
(striation spacing)

stage I R-ratio mean stress

22

I-2
()
()
SRV
S/D

3.
TAF (ISO 17025 )-50

TAF (
0115) ISO/IEC 17025:2005
(01.01)(M101)(M102)
(M103)
(TAF ) TAF
in-house method

LECO NIST
SRM
5 31

ISO9001:2008
ISO9001

23


(LECO) ISO
9556 ISO 4935
(NIST SRM)

17025

4. ()
-11 SEM
-41
(clear cut)/

()
()
(strain rate) 10E-5~10E-3>10E-2
<10E-6()
()
(yielding) (dislocations)(slip)
( dimples)

(cleavage)
/ (intergranular cracking)

24

SEM (Crack propagation)

(Dimples)/
13




5. 100
-14

1
1

UT
14

thermal circumferential moment of circumference


based on mean diameter of RPV skirt ( thermal moment)
thermal radial shear of circumference based on mean diameter
of RPV skirt(
radial shear)

moment shear

thermal moment
25

6 ( 1 )(free body)

26

thermal moment

radial shear RPV skirt


(JCO)

thermal moment
radial shear
( )

6.
-18



7. A2 18.2 I-11
-13 indications
I-12:
A2 (18.2 )

skirt flange/
mounting plate ()

( )
+++
()

(fixed end)
27

(in place alignment)


skirt
flange mounting plate


(vertical upward)
(thermal moment) SSE LOCA

()()

()
GALL Rev. 2
RPV anchor bolt ASME Class 1
150ksi

(NUREG-1801 Rev2) 12

1. I-67
AI-2A-3AEC-1AEC-3:

30
A2C6D14

28

PT 4
4 B10

3 (B13C9D11)
B10 AEC-1

B10

(SCC)
Phased Array 3
B10 B10

(SCC)
29



SCC

()

3
ASTM A-540 Gr. B23

4
30

6~9 ASME Sec II


Part A,SA-540/SA-540M ( 11)
B23 Class 1 (Dia.to 3 inches, included)HB 321~ 415

1. I-9
-6
(
450C) A2

31

2. A2 C6 0.46%
0.37~0.44%
() CMTR
-21
C6 ([C])( 3 ):
1 : 0.4595/0.4742/0.4564/0.4544 [C]mean=
0.4611% 2 : 0.4280/0.4297/0.4296/
[C]mean=
0.4291% 3 : 0.4494/0.4321/0.4432/
[C]mean=
0.4416% Avg. [C] = 0.4439%
ASTM A540 [C] variation : 0.02%

3. 61236 61765
A2 C6

53
61236 61765
-36
3 (A2C6D14) 2 (B10
C9) 61236 2 (B13D11)
61236

113

32

33

(SCC) SCC

560 kips
(ASME)
2.5mm

18

() ()
()
()

(SCC)

()

() K
( Threshold region)
34

35

SEM (Crack propagation)


(Dimples)/

()

()

() 17025

()
Strain gauge

1.Degradation and Failure of Bolting in Nuclear


Volumes 1

Power Plants,

and 2, EPRI NP-5769, Electric Power Research Institute, Palo


Alto, CA, April 1988.
2.
36

- 101 5 7

37

3.
-
101 5 7
4.
-
101 5 7
5.
- RPV
Phased Array
101 5
6.
-
A2 101 5
7
7.
-
C6 101 5
7
8.
-
D14
101 5
6
9.
-
B10
101 5
6
10.

38

101 5 9
11. ASME Sec II Part A, Specification for Alloy-Steel Bolting
Materials for
Special Application, SA-540/SA-540M, pp969-981, 1998.
12. Generic Aging Lessons Learned (GALL)

Report Final Report

(NUREG-1801, Revision 2), December 2010.


13. RJ Morrissey et. al., Frequency and stress ratio effects in
high cycle fatigue of Ti-6Al-4V, Intel. J. Fatigue, 21,
pp679~685, 1999
14.
-
Rev5 101 6 4

39

101 03 16 05:50

XE-105 0.29g


0.29g 0.29g

() 0.29g
0.29g 101 03 16
8
0.04 g 0.29 g

2
0.29g

0.2g 0.2

40

41

0.29g

() 0.29g

Faulted

condition(SSE+LOCA) ( 1083kips )

0.29g(<SSE+LOCA)
8.29 Hz
(-8
1) OBE 0.57 gSSE 0.93
g( -94 OBE 0.16gSSE 0.37g)

OBE SSE
0.29 g 0.57 g
(OBE) 0.93 g (SSE)
3
0.29 g
22
1. 708.3.4
5
2. / 59
19 29 RWCU
11 6
3. 732.6-IST
7
42

4. 612.3.7
8
5. 575 9
6. 295
10

0.29g
LOCA:Loss of Coolant AccidentOBE:Operating Basis Earthquake
SSE:
Safe Shutdown Earthquake
()

(
) 0.01g

()

3( 921 /8Hz
/25 Hz )
full scale (10V) 2g
(full scale)
()
8 3-1

11
43

/
/

(/ 1 )

(30 )

(/ 1 )

(290 )

(115 ) (/
1 )

(217 )
(/ 1 )

3-1: 8 11

() 0.29g
1. 0180
IV-12
IV-11
0180
30217
115 290
44

8 8

0.16g 0.015g

IV-11 5 31

()
(1)() (2)
(3)

8
(8
)
/ 8
/
/
0.16g 0.015g

(1) 8 2

45

(2) (

() 0.29g
1. S/D mode
-22-23-24 0.29g

reactor internal

-47

SRV
245
Mode Switch startup
shutdown Mode Switch

96 9 29 21:53 21:56 601.12

Mode Switch
Mode Switch
99 10 07 05:53 Mode
Switch Shutdown 601.12
15:17 Mode Switch Shutdown
13:33 601.2.1APRM SET DOWN
601.1.3
(WRNM) Mode Switch
46

Refuel Mode
Switch Shutdown

47

101 4 14 22:23
HCU
XE-105
101 4 14
0.04g()
0.04~0.06g
101 4 14 8

30
101 3 16 230

101 3 16 0.29g

(1)
4.2/4.3 Faulted condition(SSE+LOCA)(
1083kips )
0.29g(<SSE+ LOCA)

(2) 8.29 Hz
-8-47
OBE 0.57 gSSE 0.93
g( -94 OBE 0.16gSSE
0.37g)
OBE SSE
0.29 g
0.57 g (OBE) 0.93 g (SSE)

48

-22 1991/12/29

1991/12/29

()
1. XE-105 0.29 g
-9-14-47IV-5
IV-6IV-7A-4AEC-8

(
) 0.01g

(
) 5 15

101 2 2

101 3 16
0.29g

0.2g 0.2
49


0.29g

2. -16IV-10
IV-8

98 10 20
( 3 -)
(921331 ) 100 4
30 (XE-105)
0.01~0.03g 98 10 20
()

(
) 0.01g


21 (99 10 )
(

50

)5
17
5 15
IV-8IV-10 5 31

rigid

()
1. sensor I-6-8
(real-time) -17
IV-13
AI-6
4 13 8 4 14

(real-time)

0.16g 0.015g

( 8 )


51

52