State
o 
f 
ew
ersey
CHRIS 
CHRISTIE
OFh ICE 
OF 
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
cJO N
J. 
HOFFM N
Governor
DEPARTMENT
OF
L W 
AND
PUBLIC SAFETY
Acting 
Attorney
General
KIM
GU D GNO
`LrJ
MARI~T
TREET
THOM S 
CALCAGNI
Lt.
Governor
P
ox 112
First Assistant
TRErrTON, 
NJ
8625-0112
Attorney 
General
October 21 
2 
13
 -~
~
Mark Neary
-
~
~
`
lerkU
r
~i
SupremeCourt 
of New 
rs y~~
+.a
T
 
`~
 7
R.J. Hughes Justice Complex
 
P.O. Box970
25 
Market Street
r ~--~
 
Trenton 
New
Jersey 08625-0970Re:Garden State Equality 
et
al.
v. 
PaulaDow 
et 
al.
Supreme Court Docket 
No.
A-21-13Appellate Division Docket No. 
A-0521-13
Law Division Docket No. 
Mer-L-1729-11
Dismissal 
of 
Appeal pursuant
to
R. 2:8-2Dear Mr. Neary:Please accept this letter
as 
a
withdrawal of the
appeal
in
the
-above referenced
matter
pursuant 
to Rule 2:8-2.
matter.Thank 
you
for your assistance and 
courtesies in this
Respectfully 
submitte
ohn J. offmanActing Attorney
General of
New 
Jersey
c: 
Joseph Orlando Clerk 
of
the 
Appellate Division
All counsel
HUGHES 
us riCE
COivrnLEx 
TELEPHONE:
609) 599-6868 
FAx: 609) 92-0690
New
ersey
Is
An
qual 
Opportunity aployer
Printed
on 
Recycled
Paper 
~ad 
Recyclable
 
JOHN J. HOFFMANACTING ATTORNEY GENERAL 
OF 
NEW 
JERSEY Attorney for Defendants
~~
`~
~~ 
~
R.J. Hughes Justice
Complex
P.O. 
Box 112 
25 
Market Street 
;~
r
 
~~ 
/.~ 
~
4~~
Trenton 
New 
Jersey 08625-0112 
~ 
S~
CURT
By: 
Robert 
Lougy 
_'.~'S
~~ 
r 
~
Assistant 
Attorney 
General609-599-6868
SUPREME COURT 
OF 
NEW 
JERSEY
DOCKET 
NO. A-21-13GARDEN STATE EQUALITY; DANIELWEISS; JOHN GRANT;MARSHASHAPIRO;LOUISE WALPIN;MAUREENKILIAN;CINDYMENEGHIN;SARAH KILLIANMENEGHIN;
ERIC 
BRADSHAW;KARENNICHOLSONMCFADDEN;MARCYENICHOLSONMCFADDEN;KASEYNICHOLSONMCFADDEN;MAYANICHOLSONMCFADDEN;THOMASDAVIDSON;KEITH HEIMANN;MARIEHEIMANNDAVIDSON; andGRACEHEIMANN DAVIDSON 
Respondents 
v.
PAULA 
DOW 
in 
her 
officialcapacity as Attorney Generalof 
New Jersey; 
JENNIFER 
VELEZ
in her official capacity as
Commissioner of
the New JerseyDepartment of Human Services;
and 
MARY E 
O 
OVdD
in herofficial 
capacity 
asCommissioner of 
the 
New Jersey
Department 
of 
Health andSenior 
Services 
Appellants.
CIVIL ACTION
ON 
DIRECT CERTIFICATION 
FROM
THE 
SUPERIOR COURT 
OF 
NEWJERSEY LAW DIVISION
MERCER
COUNTY
Sat Below: 
Hon. 
Mary 
C.Jacobson A.J.S.C.
DOCKET 
NO. L-1729-11CERTIFICATION 
OF SERVICE
 
I, 
ROBERT LOUGY, of 
full 
age, hereby certify:
1. am 
an 
Assistant Attorney General employed by 
the
Department
of 
Law and Public Safety, Division of Law. 
I 
am
assigned to represent Appellants 
in 
the above-captioned 
matter.2. 
On 
October 21, 
2013, 
caused 
to 
be
delivered 
byovernight delivery the letter from Acting Attorney 
General John
J. Hoffman to the Clerks of the Supreme Court and 
the Appellate
Division of the Superior Court of New Jersey informing 
them of
State Defendants dismissal of the appeal pursuant to R. 2:8-2
in 
the above-captioned matter 
to:
Lawrence S. Lustberg, Esq.Gibbons P.C.One 
Gateway 
CenterNewark, New Jersey 07102-5310Attorney 
for
PlaintiffsHayley Gorenberg, Esq.Lambda 
Legal
120 Wall Street19th Floor
New 
York, 
New 
York 1005-3919Attorney 
for 
PlaintiffsRonald 
K. 
Chen, Esq.Rutgers Constitutional Litigation ClinicCenter 
for 
Law 
Justice
123 Washington StreetNewark, New Jersey 07102Attorney 
for 
Amici 
Curiae
Edward 
Barocas, Esq.
ACLU of New JerseyP.O. 
Box 32159
Newark, New Jersey 07102
Attorney for
 
Amici 
Curiae
2
View on Scribd