EXHIBIT 9
6:14-cv-00187-RAW Document 246-9 Filed in ED/OK on 06/30/14 Page 1 of 6
From:
Date:
May 20, 2014 at 9:55:29 AM PDT
To:
Subject:
NAFC Court Case
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
6:14-cv-00187-RAW Document 246-9 Filed in ED/OK on 06/30/14 Page 2 of 6
&=695 &/ 769" 6" -6 7,.;(/0 9- 56 ;",;&", E6" 57, 5,-51 =95 4 E,.5 (5 6)) 57&5 7, >&- -(<;.D)6(/0 [\@ 56 69" 0"69;# 45 59"/- 695 57&5 &.<6-5 &.. 57, 39,-F6/- &/) &/->,"- 57&5 7, >,/56'," >,", &.-6 6/ 57, 5,-5# 4 &-N,) +,/5 (E 57(- >&- .,0(F<&5, &/) 7, ",&--9",) <, 57&5 /656/.D >&- (5 .,0(F<&5, =95 57&5 4 T=,8&9-, 6E >6"N(/0 I] 769"- )&D-1 ] )&D- & >,,N E6"?&"86/6/J 7&) 06/, -6 E&" &=6', <D 769".D <(/(<9<- &- 57,", 56 =, /6 ;"6=.,<# ^J
@ E,> >,,N- .&5," <D-,.E &/) -,',"&. 6E <D ,<;.6D,,- ",8,(',) 8,"FG8&F6/- 57"6907 57,?@AB &- BB%B_-# `J
@ 869;., D,&"- .&5,"1 +,/5 86/5&85,) 9- &0&(/ &/) -&() 57&5 7, >69.) =, &=., 56 0,5 9-)(R,",/5 8,"FG8&F6/- E6" !&-5,"- (/ B69/-,.(/0- E6" 576-, >76 7&) !&-5,"- ),0",,-1 &- >,..&- B@%B1 &/) & B,"FG,) 4/5,"',/F6/ C;,8(&.(-5# 4 =,.(,', 7(- >(E, S,> 695 57(- F<,# O7,",>&- /6 5,-F/0 &5 57(- F<,1 6/.D ;&;,">6"N 56 G.. 695# @0&(/ 57(- >&- E6" & E,,# a&5," >,",8,(',) /,> 8,"FG8&F6/-1 =95 57,-, >,", ",0(-5,",) >(57 +,/5_- 86<;&/D1 57, b(5& Q"69;# @5 57(- F<, 4 ",&.(c,) 57&5 57, B@%B >&-/_5 57, d",&._ B@%B 57&5 ,K(-5- (/ 57, >6".)1 =95 +,/5_-d<&), 9;_ 8,"FG8&F6/# @- & ;&"5 6E 57(- 0"69;1 +,/5 &0",,) 56 8,"FED b7(. +,..,D &/) C7&"6/+9=&8N( >(57 57, ?@AB# Z, -5&5,) .&5," 57&5 57,D >,", 8,"FG,)1 57&5 >, 869.) -5&5, 57&5 57,D>,",# 45 59"/- 6951 (/ ",5"6-;,851 57&5 57,D /,'," >,",# ]J
C(/8, 57&5 F<,1 &;;"6K(<&5,.D U D,&"- &061 >, -56;;,) ",E,""(/0 56 ?&"86/6/1 =95 86/F/9,)56 )6 (/5,"',/F6/- E6" & '&"(,5D 6E 57,< /&F6/>(),# LJ
@;;"6K(<&5,.D P D,&"- &061 >, (/E6"<,) 57,< 57&5 >, >69.) /6 .6/0," &88,;5 (/5,"',/F6/",E,""&.- 9/.,-- 57,D =,8&<, 76/,-5 &=695 a *6/ Z9==&") &/) C8(,/56.60D# O7(- >&- <,5 >(577&"-7 8"(F8(-< &/) ,--,/F&..D 566N 9- 6e8(&..D 695 6E >6"N(/0 >(57 ?&"86/6/ &- /6 6/,>69.) ",E," 56 9- 9/.,-- >, f(/5,/F6/&..D )()/_5 <,/F6/ a# *6/ Z9==&") &/) .,5 57,?&"86/6/ -5&R 7&/)., 57&5g# MJ
@"69/) 57(- -&<, F<, 4 86/5&85,) ?@AB &/) &-N,) &=695 T.,0(F<&5,1 &.576907 4 )()/_5 -&D57(- 56 57,<J 5,-F/0 8,/5,"- -6 57&5 4 869.) 0,5 T>7&5 4 =,.(,',) 56 =, &957,/F8J 8,"FG8&F6/&- & BB%B# @h," 5,-F/01 4 ",8,(',) & BB%B 8,"FG8&F6/ (/ 57, <&(.# iJ
@=695 I] <6/57- &061 4 =,8&<, ;9=.(8 (/ -;,&N(/0 695 &0&(/-5 ?&"86/6/1 &/) 7&', =,86<,&/ &)'68&5, 56 7,.; 657,"- >76 7&', =,,/ 7&"<,)# IXJ
4/ ",0&")- 56 57, ,K;(",) .(-F/0- 6/ 69" >,=-(5,1 4 7&', /6 ,K89-,# O7(- 7&-/_5 =,,/ <,&/5 56fE"&9)9.,/5.D ;"6<65, 8,"FG8&F6/-1 ,K;(",) 6" 657,">(-,g1 -(<;.D &/ 6',"-(075 57&5 4 7&',/_5",.&D,) 87&/0,- 56 69" 695-(), >,=-(5, ),',.6;,"-:86<;&/(,- (/ 39(5, -6<, F<,# A6",K&<;.,1 b7(. +,..D 7&-/_5 >6"N,) E6" 9- (/ 6'," & D,&"# j,/ V7(k&N," 7&-/_5 >6"N,) E6" 9- (/6'," & D,&" &- >,..# C7&"6/ +9=&8N( (- & 86/5"&856"# !D -5&R ;&0,- -(<;.D &", /65 &889"&5,1 &-4 7&', ] 86/5"&85,) (/5,"',/F6/(-5- 57&5 &", /65 .(-5,) 6/ <D -(5,1 U 6E >76< &", .(8,/-,)8.(/(8(&/-1 &/657," 6E >7(87 7&- & B@%@B T",&. 6/,J &/) & j*4# ?6/, 6E 57,< &", 6/ <D -(5,1&/) -769.):>69.) =, &- .(8,/-,) 8.(/(8(&/- ,--,/F&..D d5"9<;_ 8,"FG8&F6/- (/ 5,"<- 6E 39&.(G8&F6/-1 (/ <&/D 8&-,-# !D ="657," +,'(/1 >76 7&- /,'," >6"N,) E6" ?&"86/6/ /6"=,,/ & 8.(,/51 .,5 7(- .&;-, &/) /,'," ",/,>,) (5# @0&(/1 4 7&',/_5 87&/0,) 57, -(5, &/) 5&N,E9.. ",-;6/-(=(.(5D# 4_< /65 -9", 57, -5&59- 6E <D BB%B# 4- (5 ,K;(",)1 &8F',1 -9-;,/),)l 4)6/_5 N/6># V, &.-6 )6/_5 &/) 7&',/_5 (/ D,&"- ",E,"",) 56 ?&"86/6/ /6" &", >, (/ 86..9-(6/
6:14-cv-00187-RAW Document 246-9 Filed in ED/OK on 06/30/14 Page 3 of 6