1 The Campaign for Commercial Free Childhood (CCFC) and Center for Digital Democracy (CDD), by their counsel the Institute for Public Representation, supplement their
Request for Investigation of Google’s YouTube Kids app (YTK) filed April 7, 2015
(April 2015 RFI). This supplement provides additional information
regarding the children’s media
marketplace and YTK that shows the urgent need for FTC action. It also describes changes that Google made to YTK and shows that none of the changes alter our prior conclusions that YTK targets children with deceptive and unfair advertisements, that Google markets YTK to parents in a deceptive manner
, and that sponsored videos shown on YTK violate the FTC’s Endorsement
Guides. We ask that the FTC consider this Supplement in conjunction with the
Request for
Investigation of Violations by Members of the Children’s Food
and Beverage Advertising Initiative of Pledges Not to Advertise Products to Children that Do Not Meet Uniform Nutrition Criteria
(CFBAI RFI), which we are also filing today. That filing provides many examples of commercials and promotional videos for food products available on YTK that violate the CBFAI
pledges, violate YTK’s own Ad Policy, and are unfair and deceptive to children. Thus, we a
sk the FTC to broaden its investigation of Google (now part of Alphabet) to include its relationships with multichannel video programmers (MCNs); food, beverage and toy companies; its major
YouTube advertising and “unboxing” video partners
; and companies that specialize in
“influencer” and product placement marketing on YouTube.
We also ask that the FTC promptly complete its investigation and take action to stop these deceptive and unfair marketing practices.
I.
Background
It has been known since the early 1970s that young children have difficulty distinguishing between programming and commercials on television and do not understand that the purpose of commercials is to promote the sale of a product. Research has clearly established that most children experience difficulty discriminating between programs and commercials until