ABCEFGHIJK LMNOPQR STUABCDEFGHIJK LMNOPQR STU
HCAL 185/2016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF THEHONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGIONCOURT OF FIRST INSTANCE
CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST NO 185 OF 2016 _______________ BETWEENCHIEF EXECUTIVE OF THE HONG KONG 1
s
A!!"#$%&S'ECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGIONSECRETAR( FOR )USTICE2
&*
A!!"#$%&%&*THE 'RESIDENT OF THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCILR+s!,&*+&%&*SIXTUS LEUNG CHUNG HANG1
s
I&+-+s+* '%-.(AU WAI CHING2
&*
I&+-+s+* '%-. _______________ AND
ABCEFGHIJK LMNOPQR STUABCDEFGHIJK LMNOPQR STU
HCM' 281/2016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF THEHONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGIONCOURT OF FIRST INSTANCE
MISCELLANEOUS 'ROCEEDINGS NO 281 OF 2016 _______________ BETWEENTHE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OF THE HKSAR1
s
'"%#&# SECRETAR( FOR )USTICE2
&*
'"%#&# %&*(AU WAI CHING1
s
D++&*%&SIXTUS LEUNG CHUNG HANG2
&*
D++&*%&'RESIDENT OF THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL
-*
D++&*%& _______________ 3+%-* ,4+3+-B+,-+ H,& A7 ) #& C,7-D%+ , H+%-#&4 N,+9:+- 2016D%+ , )7*49+& 15 N,+9:+- 2016) U D G M E N T
ABCEFGHIJK LMNOPQR STUABCDEFGHIJK LMNOPQR STU
A.INTRODUCTION
1A 9+9:+- , 3+ L+4#s"%#+ C,7&$#" ;L+4C,< #s
constitutionally mandated
7&*+- A-#$"+ 10= ;BL10=< , 3+ B%s#$ L%>;BL<? 7!,& %ss79#&4 ,#$+? , %@+ %& ,%3 , s>+%- , 7!3,"* 3+ BL%&* , s>+%- %""+4#%&$+ , 3+ H,&4 K,&4 S!+$#%" A*9#&#s-%#+ R+4#,&, 3+ '+,!"+s R+!7:"#$ , C3#&%2F,- 3+ !7-!,s+ , BL10=? % L+4C, 9+9:+- #s -+7#-+*7&*+- s+$#,& 1 , 3+ O%3s %&* D+$"%-%#,&s O-*#&%&$+ C%! 11;ODO< , %@+ 3+ L+4#s"%#+ C,7&$#" O%3 ;L+4C, O%3<
#& 3+,-9
as prescribed
7&*+- s+$#,& 16* %&* S$3+*7"+ 2 3+-+, '%- IV, S$3+*7"+ 2 !-+s$-#:+s 3+ ,-9 , 3+ L+4C, O%3 %s ,"",>s
;THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL OATHI s>+%- 3%? :+#&4 % 9+9:+- , 3+ L+4#s"%#+ C,7&$#" ,
the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People’s Republic of China
, I will
uphold the Basic Law of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People’s Republicof China bear allegiance to the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People’s Republic of China
%&*s+-+ 3+ H,&4 K,&4 S!+$#%" A*9#&#s-%#+ R+4#,&$,&s$#+&#,7s".? *7#7"".? #& 7"" %$$,-*%&$+ >#3 3+ "%>?3,&+s". %&* >#3 #&+4-#.&%9+ , !+-s,& 9%@#&4 3+ ,%3<
emphasis
%**+*
S+$#,& 21 , 3+ ODO 7-3+- !-,#*+s 3% # % L+4C,9+9:+- ;
declines or neglects
< , %@+ 3+ L+4C, O%3 ;
when reuested
<, *, s,? 3+ ;
shall
< 9+%&#&4 3+ 97s %$%+ 3+ ,#$+ # 3+ 3%s %"-+%*.+&+-+* ,& #? ,- 3+ ;
shall
< :+ *#s7%"##+* -,9 +&+-#&4 ,& 3+ ,#$+ # 3+ 3%s &,