A project of the National Coalition Against Censorship
CO SPONSORED BY
American Booksellers for Free Expression
Comic Book Legal Defense Fund
Association of American Publishers
"#$%&'%( )*+ ,*-. /0& 1#2%3 455056786 9:;%(086%8<%86 =#<3 >056(0?6 @:'20? 9?A##25 B-B =#<3 4$%8:% =#<3+ CD E,F-F >%7( G(H 1#2%3+ C% 7(% 7 ?#72060#8 #I 206%(7(3+ 7(60560? 78< %<:?760#872 #(J780K760#85 <%<0?76%< 6# ;(#ɠJ I(%% %L;(%550#8 78< I0JA608J 6A% 5:;;(%550#8 #I I(%% 5;%%?AH C% #II%( 5:;;#(6 78< J:0<78?% 6# %<:?76#(5 08 ;(#6%?608J 6A% (0JA6 #I 56:<%865 6# (%7< I(%%23H 45 <05?:55%< 276%( 08 6A05 2%66%(+ M% #;;#5% 6A% ?A722%8J% 6A76 7 ;7(%86 A75 I02%< 08 78 %II#(6 6# (%&#$%
! #$% #&' ($) #* +&&% ,&- $ +.-/
I(#& 6A% =#<3 N0JA 9?A##2 20'(7(3H C% 725# M(06% 6# 5:JJ%56 0&;(#$%&%865 6# 3#:( ;#20?0%5 I#( (%$0%M08J '##O5 20O%
! #$% #&' ($) #* +&&% ,&- $ +.-/
H C% '%20%$% 6A%(% 7(% 6M# M735 08 MA0?A 6A% ;(#?%55 6# (%$0%M 6A05 '##O ?78 '%66%( 0&;2%&%86 6A% ;A02#5#;A3 #:6208%< 08 3#:( P#7(< #I Q<:?760#8 @#20?3 RS T
0*$-).)1 2*3&4-5*3 $)% 6$7*-.$/38
+ 78< @#20?3 RSU T
0.9-$-' 6$7*-.$/3 :*/*57.&) $)% !%&;7.&)
VH
!"#$%& () #)*+,,)-. %/0% 1+2 #)3"$) 1+2# 4)0#-"-5 #)$+2#*)$ *+,640"-%$ 6+4"*1 %+ )-$2#) %/0% 7+,640"-% 7+,,"%%)) .)*"$"+-$ 0#) 80$). 6#",0#"41 +- 6).05+5"*04 6#"-*"64)$ 0-. %/) 6#+9)$$"+-04 ):6)#%"$) +9 ).2*0%"+- 0-. ,)."0 $6)*"04"$%$;
R8 065 ;(%5%86 I#(&+ @#20?3 WQ= T
<49/.5 =**%9$5> &- (&?;/$.)73 !9&47 0*$-).)1 2*3&4-5*3
V ;27?%5 6A% %L;%(6 X:<J&%86 #I %<:?76#(5 76 7 <057<$7867J% '3 J0$08J 7 J(%76%( 8:&'%( #I =#&&066%% 5%765 6# Y;7(%865Z;76(#85H[ =:((%8623+ @#20?3 WQ= 722#M5 6A(%% %<:?76#(5 78< I0$% ;7(%865Z;76(#85 6# 5%($% #8 6A% =#&&066%%+ 78< %567'205A%5 6A76 I0$% ?#&&066%% &%&'%(5 ?#85606:6% 7 \:#(:&H C06A 6A05 ?#&;#5060#8+ 6A% ;7(%86Z;76(#8 &%&'%(5 ?#:2< $#6% 6# (%$05% 78 %860(% ?#:(5% ?:((0?:2:& #$%( 6A% #'X%?60#85 #I 722 6A(%% %<:?76#(5H /A% 2#5%(5 A%(% M#:2< '% 6A% 56:<%865 MA#5% %<:?760#8 M#:2< ;#6%8607223 '% J(7$%23 0&;70(%<H R8 7<<060#8 6# 0&;(#$08J 6A% '7278?% '%6M%%8 %<:?76#(5 78< ;7(%865Z;76(#85 6A76 ?#85606:6% 6A% =#&;270865 =#&&066%%+ 06 05 725# %55%86072 6A76 20'(7(0785 5%($% #8 6A% =#&&066%%H @#20?3 RSU #8
0.9-$-' 6$7*-.$/3 :*/*57.&) $)% !%&;7.&)
5;%?0I0?7223 675O5 6A% 5?A##2 20'(7(3 &%<07 ?%86%( M06A Y%8(0?A]08J^ 78< 5:;;#(6]08J^ 6A% %<:?760#872 ;(#J(7&5 #I 6A% 5?A##2[ 78< Y;(#$0<]08J^ 7 M0<% (78J% #I &76%(0725 #8 722 2%$%25 #I <0II0?:263+ M06A <0$%(5063 #I 7;;%72+ 78< 6A% ;(%5%86760#8 #I <0II%(%86 ;#0865 #I $0%MH[ U0'(7(0785 _ MA# %L%(?05% 6A%0( ;(#I%550#872 X:<J&%86 08 5%2%?608J '##O5 I#( 6A% A0JA 5?A##2 20'(7(3 _ 5A#:2< '% ?#85:26%< 08 (%`%$72:7608J 6A#5% '##O5 MA%8 7 ?A722%8J% #??:(5H U0'(7(078 (%;(%5%86760#8 08 6A% =#&&066%% M#:2< 725# 755056 08 7?A0%$08J Y7
?#&;(%A%850$% ?#22%?60#8 7;;(#;(076% I#( 6A% :5%(5 #I 6A% 20'(7(3[ 78< %85:(% 6A76 Y;(08?0;2% ]05 ;27?%<^ 7'#$% ;%(5#872 #;080#8 78< (%75#8 7'#$% ;(%X:<0?%+[ '#6A J#725 #I @#20?3 RSUH
<)*+-.&
() 2#5) 1+2 %+ "-*42.) %/) 4"%)#0#1 0-. ).2*0%"+-04 ,)#"%$ +9 0 */044)-5). %"%4) 0$ 0 90*%+# %+ 8) *0#)92441 *+-$".)#). "- %/) 7+,640"-% 7+,,"%%))=$ .)*"$"+->,0?"-5 6#+*)$$;
"#6 #823 ?#:2< 6A% ?:((%86 J:0<%208%5 I#( 6A% ?#&;#5060#8 #I 6A% =#&;27086 =#&&066%% :8<%(&08% 6A% 7?A0%$%&%86 #I %<:?760#872 #'X%?60$%5 %567'205A%< 08 3#:( #M8 ;#20?0%5+ 6A%3 ?#:2< 725# 0&;70( 56:<%865a M%22`%567'205A%< (0JA6 6# 7??%55 0<%75 ;:(5:786 6# 6A% 10(56 4&%8<&%86H /A% 9:;(%&% =#:(6 A75 %567'205A%< 6A76 ;:'20? 5?A##2 #II0?0725a <05?(%60#8 (%J7(<08J 6A% (%&#$72 #I
/.9-$-'
'##O5 05 ;7(60?:27(23 20&06%< 6# %85:(% 6A% ;(#6%?60#8 #I 56:<%865a 10(56 4&%8<&%86 (0JA6 6# 7??%55 08I#(&760#8 '%?7:5% Y56:<%865 &:56 72M735 (%&708 I(%% 6# 08\:0(%+ 6# 56:<3+ 78< 6# %$72:76%+ 6# J708 8%M &76:(063 78< :8<%(5678<08J [ 78< Y6A% 5?A##2 20'(7(3 05 6A% ;(08?0;72 2#?:5 #I 5:?A I(%%<#&H[
#&$-% &, @%45$7.&) AB <.5&
+ Fb. cH9H Eb)+ EdE`dB T-BE,VT;2:(72063 #;080#8VH R8 6A% 57&% ?75%+ 6A% =#:(6 725# ?7:60#8%<+ Y]2^#?72 5?A##2 '#7(<5 &73 8#6 (%&#$% '##O5 I(#& 20'(7(3 5A%2$%5 50&;23 '%?7:5% 6A%3 <0520O% 6A% 0<%75 ?#86708%< 08 6A#5% '##O5 78< 5%%O '3 6A%0( (%&#$72 6# e;(%5?(0'% MA76 5A722 '% #(6A#<#L 08 ;#2060?5+ 8760#87205&+ (%20J0#8+ #( #6A%( &766%(5 #I #;080#8Ha
C #&$-% &, @%45$7.&) AB <.5&
+ Fb. cH9H Eb)+ E., T-BE,VT;2:(72063 #;080#8VH /A:5+
%/) #),+304 +9 8++?$ 9#+, 6284"* $*/++4 4"8#0#")$ %+ $266#)$$ ".)0$ "$ 0 3"+40%"+- +9 %/) !"#$% @,)-.,)-%;
/7837 U%% 96#8%a5
! #$% #&' ($) #* +&&% ,&- $ +.-/
05 7 ?(060?7223 7??270&%< '##O 6A76 67O%5 #8 <0II0?:26 ?A722%8J%5 &783 3#:8J (%7<%(5 I7?% 08 A0JA 5?A##2H P%?7:5% #I 065 (%5#878?% M06A 6%%8 (%7<%(5+ 6A% '##O 05 #8 7 8:&'%( #I <05608J:05A%< 206%(7(3 20565+ 08?2:<08J 6A% 4&%(0?78 U0'(7(3 455#?0760#8 ,**. f:0?O @0?O5 I#( g%2:?6786 D#:8J 4<:26 g%7<%(5+ 9?A##2 U0'(7(3 S#:(872 P##O #I 6A% G#86A+ "%M D#(O @:'20? U0'(7(3 P##O I#( 6A% /%%8 4J%+ /%L75 /735A75 9676% g%7<08J U056+ G7(3278< h(%76 P##O5 I#( /%%85 ,**d+ W%86:?O3 P2:%J(755 4M7(< G756%( U056+ 7J #6A%(5H
:5D&&/ 0.9-$-' E&4-)$/
;(705%< 96#8%a5 Y(%720560? 78< I(78Oi<%5?(0;60#85 #I 6A% 6%%85 78< 6A%0( 5%L:72063H[
#&&>/.37
+ 6A% (%8#M8%< 4U4`5:;;#(6%< 206%(7(3 (%$0%M I#( 20'(7(0785+ 7J(%%5 6A76 Y96#8%a5 8#$%2 08 $%(5%+ &#(% ;#%60? ;(#5% 6A78 ;#%6(3+ ;7?O5 7 56%7&3+ %<#872 M722#;i[ 56(%5508J 6A76 Y6A% 2%55#85 2%7(8%< A%(%+ A#M%$%(+ 7(% 0&;#(6786H[ R8 <%?0<08J MA%6A%( 6# O%%;
! #$% #&' ($) #* +&&% ,&- $ +.-/
08 6A% =#<3 N0JA 9?A##2 U0'(7(3+ 6A% =#&;27086 =#&&066%% 5A#:2< 725# ?#850<%( 6A% $72:% 6A05 6062% M#:2< '(08J 6# 6A#5% MA# ?A##5% 6# (%7< 06H U06%(76:(% A#2<5 7 :80\:% ;27?% 08 A%2;08J 3#:8J ;%#;2% ?#;% M06A 6A% ?A722%8J%5 #I J(#M08J :; 78< '##O5 20O%
! #$% #&' ($) #* +&&% ,&- $ +.-/
?78 ;(#$0<% 7 57I% 5;7?% 6# %L;2#(% 6A#5% ?A722%8J%5 78< <%$%2#; %&;76A3 I#( #6A%(5 I7?08J 50&027( ;(#'2%&5H G783 3#:8J (%7<%(5 A7$% M(066%8 6# /7837 U%% 96#8% 6# %L;(%55 6A% $72:7'2% 2%55#85 A%( '##O 0&;7(6%< 78< 6A% 0&;7?6 06 &7<% #8 6A%0( 20$%5H j8% 5:?A 3#:8J (%7<%( M(#6%k lR 6A08O 6A76 783 J0(2 ?#:2<+ 78< ;(#'7'23 M022 J%6 5#&% O08< #I M7(808J #:6 #I 6A05 '##OHHH
%/) 8++? "$ 0,0A"-5 0-. "$ 0 5#)0% %)0*/)# 9+# %/+$) 5"#4$ B2$% *+,"-5 "-%+ %/) $%05) +9 4"9) (/)#) %/)1 (0-% %+ 8) "- 0 #)40%"+-$/"6;;;"% $/+($ 2$ %/0% 5"#49#")-.$ 0#) 0 6+()# %/0% 1+2 $/+24. -)3)# $2##)-.)#;
l
/M# #6A%( (%7<%(5 M(#6%k lR A7< 7 '7< '#3I(0%8<HHHR I%26 A:&02076%< 78< '(#O% T
3.5
V+ 20O% R M75 7 ;0%?% #I 6(75A 5#&%#8% ?#:2< ;0?O :; 78< 6A(#M 7M73HHHR M05A R ?#:2< <# MA76 S#50% <0<Hl l
C+2# 8++? #0"$)$ 0- ",6+#%0-% "$$2) 0,+-5 %))-05) 5"#4$;
f:06% I(78O23+ #:( X:<J&%86 05 6%((0'2%+ 78< R 6A08O 3#: J0$% :5 78 %L?%22%86 (%&08<%(+ 6A76 6A08O08J 6A08J5 6A(#:JA ?78 5%($% :5 &:?A '%66%( 6A78 50&;23 I#22#M08J 0&;:25%5Hl CA02% 8#6 %$%(3 '##O 05 (0JA6 I#( %$%(3 (%7<%(+ 6A% (#2% #I 5?A##2 20'(7(0%5 05 6# 722#M 56:<%865 78< ;7(%865 6# &7O% ?A#0?%5 7??#(<08J 6# 6A%0( #M8 086%(%565+ %L;%(0%8?%5+ 78< I7&023 $72:%5H N#M%$%(+ 8# ;7(%86+ 56:<%86 #( ?#&&:8063 &%&'%( &73 0&;#5% 6A%0( $0%M5+ $72:%5 78< 086%(%565 #8 #6A%(5 '3 (%56(0?608J 78 %860(% ?#&&:8063a5 7??%55 6# ;7(60?:27( '##O5H
D) $%#+-541 2#5) 1+2 %+ ?))6
" #$% #&' ($) #* +&&% ,&- $ +.-/
"- %/) 7+.1 E"5/ <*/++4 4"8#0#1 $+ %/0% 044 $%2.)-%$ (/+ ("$/ %+ #)0. "% ,01 .+ $+;
C% 7(% (%7<3 6# #II%( 783 A%2; M% ?78 ;(#$0<% 08 &7O08J ;#20?3 ?A78J%5 6A76 M022 56(%8J6A%8 6A% ;(#6%?60#85 I#( 6A% 10(56 4&%8<&%86 (0JA65 #I 56:<%865 08 =#<3H @2%75% <# 8#6 A%50676% 6# ?#867?6 :5H 908?%(%23+ =A(05 10878+ QL%?:60$% >0(%?6#( =A7(2%5 P(#M856%08+ QL%?:60$% >0(%?6#( "760#872 =#72060#8 4J70856 =%85#(5A0; =#&0? P##O U%J72 >%I%85% 1:8< G0220% >7$05+ 9%80#( >%$%2#;%( >78 =:22%8+ 96(76%J0? >%$%2#;&%86 jII0?%( "760#872 =#:8?02 #I /%7?A%(5 #I Q8J205A 4&%(0?78 P##O5%22%(5 1#:8<760#8 I#( 1(%% QL;(%550#8 9#I07 =756022#+ 967II 466#(8%3 G7(3 g75%8'%(J%(+ QL%?:60$% >0(%?6#( 455#?0760#8 #I 4&%(0?78 @:'205A%(5 4:6A#(5 h:02< U08 j20$%(+ QL%?:60$% >0(%?6#( S7&%5 U7g:%+ >0(%?6#( 9#?0%63 #I =A02<(%8a5 P##O5 C(06%(5 78< R22:56(76#(5 /A% 1(%%<#& 6# g%7< 1#:8<760#8