-
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT
OF
NORTH CAROLINA SOUTHERN DIVISION No. 7:14-CV-180-BR ELVIS WILLIAMS and VONNIE WILLIAMS, Plaintiffs,
v
VERDICT MURPHY-BROWN LLC, Defendant.
1
Did the defendant substantially and unreasonably interfere with the plaintiffs use and enjoyment
o
his or her property? Elvis Williams Answer:
e
>
Vonnie Williams Answer:
e~
2
What amount
o
damages,
i
any,
is
the plaintiff entitled to recover from the defendant? Elvis Williams Vonnie Williams Answer: $
Q
:5f YJ
·
0
Answer:$
(o0 W·
3
Is the defendant liable to the plaintiff for punitive damages? Elvis Williams Answer:
/es
Vonnie Williams Answer:
(e,s
Case 7:14-cv-00182-BR Document 279 Filed 06/29/18 Page 1 of 2
4.
What
amount
of
punitive damages,
if
any, does the
jury in
its discretion award to the plaintiff?
~lv s
Williams
Answer:$
f46::460C/JO
C 2::5
fi;f,1/,M
/, ?
t::;/V\
o
/;2.,611/i/// )/1)
Answer:
$
L
J...J.J
u <.
~~~
/ 7
V
ont )
e
Williams
REDACTEDVERSlON:
PursuanHo
he ·e~So\/er:r:unentActand
th~
·
edeta1· ru1es;
theunred~ttecfversion<of
this·e1ocumemth~s:beenfih~d uhdersea1
F orepersq.fl
0~;{29;Jg
Date
I
I
2
Case 7:14-cv-00182-BR Document 279 Filed 06/29/18 Page 2 of 2