Scribd

! # !

!"#$%& ($)$%( &#($*#+$ +,!*$ (,!$-%*" &#($*#+$ ,. "%/ 0,*1

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!$ %&'()*+ ,)&-+./ 012 %&'()*+ ,)&-+./ .*+-'3 45367 %8091:9;;<7 !0=091<:! (.>)/ '?@))4)7 +&.3/%.&)3*A #7 BB* 2CDC0 '?@))4) >)6-. E&'5%7 &* >.FG)BB7 012 .3+H'3A -.+&'%'5B'/7 6I;I1201:<J K K K K K K K K K K K K K K *9L98 .M:9N1 3NJ OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

+,234)#"$ )"& &%2)"& .,* 5!*0 $*#)4

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

#6

3)*$#%(

#J

%8091:9;; %UN]IM: ,IU9:0< 9< 0 1N1!<:NMQ MNUWNU0:9N1 NU=019VI2 T12IU :SI 80R< N; :SI *NXXN1RI08:S N; ,9U=91907 R9:S 0 WU91M9W08 W80MI N; DT<91I<< 91 >0X0UN1IMQ7 3IR ANUQJ -: 9< UI=9<:IUI2 91 3IR ANUQ 0< 0 ;NUI9=1 1N:!;NU!WUN;9: MNUWNU0:9N1J

Case 7:23-cv-04533 Document 1 Filed 05/31/23 Page 1 of 37

! _ ! _J

%8091:9;; %UN]IM: ,IU9:0< .M:9N1 4T12 9< 0 1N1!<:NMQ MNUWNU0:9N1 NU=019VI2 T12IU :SI 80R< N; :SI *NXXN1RI08:S N; ,9U=91907 R9:S 0 WU91M9W08 W80MI N; DT<91I<< 91 >0X0UN1IMQ7 3IR ANUQJ -: 9< UI=9<:IUI2 91 3IR ANUQ 0< 0 ;NUI9=1 1N:!;NU!WUN;9: MNUWNU0:9N1J `J

6I;I1201: (0XI< '?@II;I 9< 0 10:TU08 WIU<N1 012 0 M9:9VI1 N; :SI /:0:I N; 3IR ANUQJ '?@II;I 9< 0 UI<92I1: N; GI<:MSI<:IU *NT1:^7 3IR ANUQJ aJ

6I;I1201: +U01<W0UI1M^ #7 BB* 2CDC0 '?@II;I >I290 EUNTW 9< 0 6I80R0UI B9X9:I2 B90D989:^ *NXW01^ R9:S 0 WU91M9W08 W80MI N; DT<91I<< 91 >0X0UN1IMQ7 3IR ANUQJ -:< <N8I Q1NR1 XIXDIU 9< '?@II;IJ bJ

6I;I1201: &* >0$RI88 9< 0 10:TU08 WIU<N1 012 0 M9:9VI1 N; :SI /:0:I N; .U9VN10J cJ

6I;I1201: .1:SN1^ -0:UNWNT8N< 9< 0 10:TU08 WIU<N1 012 0 M9:9VI1 N; :SI /:0:I N; >9MS9=01J

##6

5!*#(&#+$#," )"& 7%"!%

dJ

+S9< *NTU: S0< <TD]IM: X0::IU ]TU9<29M:9N1 NLIU :S9< 0M:9N1 WTU<T01: :N _e 5J/J*J f #``# 012 #e 5J/J*J f #e`cYM\ 0< :S9< 9< 01 0M:9N1 ;NU7

!"#$% '(!'

7 X9<0WWUNWU90:9N1 N; 0 :U02I <IMUI: 012 9<7 :SIUI;NUI7 0 ;I2IU08 gTI<:9N1 T12IU #e 5J/J*J f #e`c7

$# )$*+

+SI *NTU: S0< <TWW8IXI1:08 ]TU9<29M:9N1 NLIU :SI <:0:I 80R M809X< WTU<T01: :N _e 5J/*J f #`cdJ eJ

+S9< *NTU: S0< WIU<N108 ]TU9<29M:9N1 NLIU '?@II;I 012 '>E DIM0T<I :SI^ UI<92I 917 2N DT<91I<< 917 012 0UI M9:9VI1< N; :SI /:0:I N; 3IR ANUQ7 012 :SI MNTU:< :SIUIN; S0LI ]TU9<29M:9N1 NLIU S9X WIU *%B& f `h#J '?@II;I N:SIUR9<I MN1<I1:I2 :N :SI ]TU9<29M:9N1 N; :S9< *NTU: WTU<T01: :N %0U0=U0WS _eYP\ N; S9< .:!G988 )XW8N^XI1: .=UIIXI1: N; (T1I __7 _h#h7 0< 0XI12I2 N1 NU 0DNT: /IW:IXDIU _h7 _h__ YZ)XW8N^XI1: .=UIIXI1:[ NU Z).[\7 0 :UTI 012 MNUUIM: MNW^ N; RS9MS 0WWI0U< 0: )$S9D9: .7 0< UI20M:I27 0::0MSI2 SIUI:N 012 91MNUWNU0:I2 SIUI91 D^ UI;IUI1MIJ -0:UNWNT8N< MN1<I1:I2 :N :SI ]TU9<29M:9N1 N; :S9< *NTU: WTU<T01: :N %0U0=U0WS _b N; S9< .:!G988 )XW8N^XI1: .=UIIXI1: N; (T1I c7 _h__7 0< 0XI12I2 N1 NU 0DNT: /IW:IXDIU a7 _h__


! ` ! YZ-0:UNWNT8N< .=UIIXI1:[\ 0 :UTI 012 MNUUIM: MNW^ N; RS9MS 0WWI0U< 0: )$S9D9: P7 0< UI20M:I27 0::0MSI2 SIUI:N 012 91MNUWNU0:I2 SIUI91 D^ UI;IUI1MIJ >0$RI88 MN1<I1:I2 :N :SI ]TU9<29M:9N1 N; :S9< *NTU: WTU<T01: :N %0U0=U0WS _d N; S9< .:!G988 )XW8N^XI1: .=UIIXI1: N; 3NLIXDIU #7 _h_#7 YZ>0$RI88 .=UIIXI1:[\ 0 :UTI 012 MNUUIM: MNW^ N; RS9MS 0WWI0U< 0: )$S9D9: *7 0< UI20M:I27 0::0MSI2 SIUI:N 012 91MNUWNU0:I2 SIUI91 D^ UI;IUI1MIJ iJ

,I1TI 9< WUNWIU 91 :S9< 69<:U9M: WTU<T01: :N _e 5J/J*J f #`i#YD\Y#\ j Y_\ 0< '?@II;I 012 '>E UI<92I 91 :S9< 69<:U9M: 012 0 <TD<:01:908 W0U: N; :SI ILI1:< 012 NX9<<9N1< =9L91= U9<I :N :SI M809X< U09<I2 SIUI91 NMMTUUI2 91 :S9< 69<:U9M:J '?@II;I N:SIUR9<I MN1<I1:I2 :N LI1TI 91 :S9< *NTU: WTU<T01: :N %0U0=U0WS _eYP\ N; :SI )XW8N^XI1: .=UIIXI1:J /9X980U8^7 -0:UNWNT8N< 012 >0$RI88 MN1<I1:I2 :N LI1TI 91 :S9< *NTU: WTU<T01: :N W0U0=U0WS< _b 012 _d N; :SI9U UI<WIM:9LI 0=UIIXI1:<J #hJ

%TU<T01: :N %0U0=U0WS _`YP\ N; :SI )XW8N^XI1: .=UIIXI1:7 %UN]IM: ,IU9:0< X0^ WUNMII2 91 :S9< *NTU:7 012 9< I$IXW: ;UNX 0UD9:U0:9N17 0< :S9< 9< 01 0M:9N1 :N <IIQ WUI89X910U^ 012 ;9108 91]T1M:9LI UI89I; :N I1;NUMI :SI UI<:U9M:9N1< 012 ND89=0:9N1< N; :SI )XW8N^XI1: .=UIIXI1: 012 :N UI<:U091 0M:T08 DUI0MS N; :SN<I UI<:U9M:< 012 ND89=0:9N1<7 012 9: X0^7 :SIUI;NUI7 WTU<TI 91 :S9< *NTU: Z01^ 012 088 0229:9N108 UIXI29I< 0L0980D8I 0: 80R7[ 1N:R9:S<:01291= :SI 0UD9:U0:9N1 WUNL9<9N1< N; :SI )XW8N^XI1: .=UIIXI1:J +SI X0:IU9088^ 92I1:9M08 WUNL9<9N1 0WWI0U< 0: %0U0=U0WS< _b 012 _i N; :SI -0:UNWNT8N< .=UIIXI1: 012 >0$RI88 .=UIIXI1:7 UI<WIM:9LI8^J

###6

.)+$( 8#7#"8 *#(% $, +,234)#"$

##J

%UN]IM: ,IU9:0< 012 %UN]IM: ,IU9:0< .M:9N1 4T12 0UI bh#YM\Y`\ 012 bh#YM\Ya\7 UI<WIM:9LI8^7 1N: ;NU WUN;9: MNUWNU0:9N1< ;NUXI2 T12IU ,9U=9190 80R R9:S SI02gT0U:IU< 91 GI<:MSI<:IU *NT1:^7 3IR ANUQJ
