!
"#$%&' )%*%&) '$)%+$,% ,-"+% .&)%&+# '$)%+$,% -/ %&0*) *")%$# '$1$)$-# 2345 -6674839: +35;7<<7 =>9?: @ ,<3>47 2AB7B: C79D4E FAGG839: @ )D7H7 '739: *<>5>3 27I<A5J: @ *<39 K7L7B;3B79: )5ADD 27I<A5J: @ C47? 134974: MLIE NA9?: CL><> K>A9I>: @ M3BA9 C4779 39I #>43<> 239I3EO3<3: @ ,3B7 #AP QQQQQQQQQQ A9 R7;3<G AG D;78B7<H7B 39I 3<< @ AD;74B B>8><34<E B>DL3D7I: @ @
!"#$%&$''()
@ HBP @ @ ,<3BB *5D>A9 S3D;: $95P: %O>DD74: $95P: *66<7: $95P: @ /357RAAJ: $95P: K7<L?3: $95P P: @ T7<6U $95P: KL4R9: $95P: $9BD3?438: $95P: @ /AL4BVL347 N3RB: $95P: CAO3<<3 $95A46A43D7I: @ /AAIB6ADD>9?: $95P: F>6BD74: $95P: N>9J7I$9 @ ,A46A43D>A9: +AH>A 2AR><7 -E: W76DAN3R "= @ ML4E %4>3< '7839I7I N>8>D7I 3J3 W76DAN3R: ,;><<>9?A NDIP: @ &<75D4A9>5 *4DB $95P: 39I =>J $9D7435D>H7: $95P: @ @
+,',%-#%&(.
@
!
"#$%&$''(
)
+
,$-$%#"
.
"#((
#
.&$+%
.
+/!"#$%&
“Don't take things that aren't yours.”
-
Robert Fulghum,
All I Really Need To Know I Learned In Kindergarten
Case 1:12-cv-00219-SS Document 1 Filed 03/12/12 Page 1 of 152
1:12-cv-00219
X
S<3>9D>GGB: A9 R7;3<G AG D;78B7<H7B 39I 3<< AD;74B B>8><34<E B>DL3D7I: 3<<7?7 3B GA<<AOBY
%
#&0,1 +' &21
#
.&$+%
!P 2><<>A9B AG O>47<7BB 8AR><7 I7H>57 AO974B 9AO J776 D;7>4 64>H3D7 3II47BB RAAJBZ<>BDB AG ;L9I47IB A4 7H79 D;ALB39IB AG 674BA93< 39I 64AG7BB>A93< 5A9D35DBZA9 D;7>4 8AR><7 O>47<7BB I7H>57BP %;7B7 <>BDB: O;>5; >95<LI7 5A9D35D 9387B: 6;A97 9L8R74B: 6;EB>53< 39I 7[83>< 3II47BB7B: \AR D>D<7B: R>4D;I3EB: 39I AD;74 B>8><34 674BA93< >9GA483D>A9 383BB7I AH74 D;7 AO974B] <>G7D>87B: 347 BA87 AG D;7 8ABD 674BA93< I3D3 D;3D AO974B 5344E A9 D;7>4 O>47<7BB 8AR><7 I7H>57BP
!
XP %;7 I7G79I39DBZB7H743< AG D;7 OA4<I]B <34?7BD 39I 8ABD >9G<L79D>3< D75;9A<A?E 39I BA5>3< 97DOA4J>9? 5A8639>7BZ;3H7 L9GA4DL93D7<E 83I7: I>BD4>RLD7I 39I BA<I 8AR><7 BAGDO347 366<>53D>A9B ^_*66B`a D;3D: A957 >9BD3<<7I A9 3 O>47<7BB 8AR><7 I7H>57: BL4476D>D>ALB<E ;34H7BD: L6<A3I 39I ><<7?3<<E BD73< D;7 AO974]B 3II47BB RAAJ I3D3 O>D;ALD D;7 AO974]B J9AO<7I?7 A4 5A9B79DP *B 47H73<7I >9 3 47579D #
&.
T
-+=
%
$2&)
476A4D:
_%;7 3II47BB RAAJ >9 B834D6;A97B [[ O;747 BA87 AG D;7 LB74]B 8ABD 674BA93< I3D3 >B 5344>7IZ >B G477 GA4 366 I7H7<A674B DA D3J7 3D O><<: AGD79 O>D;ALD D;7 6;A97 AO974]B J9AO<7I?7P P P P ,A8639>7B D;3D 83J7 839E AG D;7 8ABD 6A6L<34 B834D6;A97 366B GA4 *66<7 39I *9I4A>I I7H>57B Z %O>DD74: /AL4BVL347 39I
"
/,,
#>5A<7 S74AD; 39I #>5J K><DA9:
012$", 344( 5#6, +#&# 7$&819& !,:;$(($1%
: #
&.
T
-+=
%
$2&)
^A9<>97 7IP 3D OOOP9ED>87BP5A8 39I ;DD6YbbR>DBPR<A?BP9ED>87BP5A8bXc!XbcXb!db?AA?<7[39I[8AR><7[366B[D3J7[I3D3[
RAAJB[O>D;ALD[6748>BB>A9b /7RP !d: Xc!Xa ^786;3B>B 3II7Ia ^_%;7
!""#$%% '(() *+ %,!#-./(+$%
e>Bf O;747 BA87 AG D;7
0%$#1% ,(%- .$#%(+!2 "!-!
>B 5344>7I`aP
Case 1:12-cv-00219-SS Document 1 Filed 03/12/12 Page 2 of 152
g
$9BD3?438 38A9? D;78 Z 4ALD>97<E ?3D;74 D;7 >9GA483D>A9 >9 674BA93< 3II47BB RAAJB A9 D;7 6;A97 39I >9 BA87 53B7B BDA47 >D A9 D;7>4 AO9 5A86LD74BP h h h .;><7 *66<7 B3EB >D 64A;>R>DB 39I 47\75DB 39E 366 D;3D 5A<<75DB A4 D439B8>DB LB74B] 674BA93< I3D3 O>D;ALD D;7>4 6748>BB>A9: D;3D ;3B 9AD BDA667I BA87 AG D;7 8ABD 6A6L<34 366<>53D>A9B GA4 D;7 >S;A97: >S3I 39I >SAI Z <>J7 T7<6: CAO3<<3: F>6BD74 39I /AAIB6ADD>9? Z G4A8 D3J>9? LB74B] 5A9D35DB 39I D439B8>DD>9? >D O>D;ALD D;7>4 J9AO<7I?7P`
X
gP N>D743<<E R><<>A9B AG 5A9D35DB G4A8 D;7 3II47BB RAAJB AG D79B AG 8><<>A9B AG L9BLB675D>9? O>47<7BB 8AR><7 I7H>57 AO974B ;3H7 9AO R779 3557BB7I 39I BDA<79P %;7 BL4476D>D>ALB I3D3 L6<A3IBZA55L44>9? AH74 RAD; 57<<L<34 97DOA4JB 39I A679: 6LR<>5 O>47<7BB 3557BB 9AI7B >9 ;A87B: 5AGG77 B;A6B: 47BD3L439DB: R34B: BDA47B 39I RLB>97BB7B 3<< 354ABB D;7 93D>A9Z;3H7: VL>D7 <>D743<<E: DL497I D;7 3II47BB RAAJ AO974B] O>47<7BB 8AR><7 I7H>57B >9DA 8AR><7 43I>A R735A9B R4A3I53BD>9? 39I 6LR<>5<E 7i6AB>9? D;7 L9BLB675D>9? I7H>57 AO974]B 3II47BB RAAJ I3D3 DA D;7 OA4<IP jP %;>B 5<3BB 35D>A9 <3OBL>D B77JB DA ;3<D 39I 647H79D D;7B7 L95A9B5>A93R<7: ><<7?3< 6435D>57B: DA 839I3D7 G>i7B DA D;7B7 8AR><7 I7H>57B 39I *66B DA 647H79D D;7B7 >9H3B>A9B AG LB74B] 64>H35E 39I D;7 L93LD;A4>k7I 3557BB 39IbA4 D439BG74 AG L97954E6D7I 3II47BB RAAJ I3D3: DA 47VL>47 D;3D 3<< O4A9?GL<<E[ARD3>97I I3D3 R7 67483979D<E 6L4?7I: DA >86AB7 5A9BD4L5D>H7 D4LBDB AH74 D;7 3BBA5>3D7I R797G>DB D;7B7 I7G79I39DB O4A9?GL<<E 39I L9\LBD<E 473<>k7I G4A8 D;7 BDA<79 I3D3: 39I DA 475AH74 I383?7B GA4 D;7 ;348 BLGG747I RE D;7 S<3>9D>GGB 39I 8><<>A9B AG AD;74 L9BLB675D>9? O>47<7BB 8AR><7 I7H>57 AO974B O;AB7 I3D3 ;3B R779 BDA<79 39I O;AB7 64>H35E ;3B R779 B7H747<E 5A864A8>B7IP
2
See id.
Case 1:12-cv-00219-SS Document 1 Filed 03/12/12 Page 3 of 152