You are on page 1of 26

Shareholder Value and Corporate Governance

Sarbesh Mishra,
Research Scholar, University of Delhi.

Chapter Objectives

Review the implications of financial theory for the corporate finance policies. Emphasise the need for a linkage between the financial policies and strategic management. Explain the implications of sustainable growth model. Focus on the shareholder value creation. Develop a framework for the shareholder value analysis. Discuss the concept of economic value added (EVA) and market value added (MVA).
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 2

Financial Goals and Strategy

Two important tasks of the financial manager are:

allocation of funds (viz. investment decision) and generation of funds (viz. financial decision).

The theory of finance makes two crucial assumptions to provide guidance to the financial manager in making these decisions.

The objective of the firm is to maximise the wealth of shareholders. Capital markets are efficient.
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 3

Financial Goals and Strategy

The corporate finance theory implies that:

Owners have the primary interest in the firm, and therefore, the main objective of the firm should be to maximise owners (shareholders) wealth. The current value of the share is the measure of the shareholders wealth. The firm should accept only those investments which generate positive net present values (NPVs) and thus, increase the current value of the firms share. NPVs of the individual projects simply add; therefore, the firms diversification policy does not create any extra value. Hence it is not desirable from investors point of view. The firms capital structure and dividend decisions lose their significance as they are solely guided by efficient capital markets and management has no control over them.
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 4

Financial Goals and Strategy

Strategic management considers all markets, including product, labour and capital, as imperfect and changing. Strategies are developed to manage the business firm in uncertain and imperfect market conditions and environment. It is an important management task to analyse changing market conditions and environment to make forecasts, and plan generation and allocation of resources. There are many other influential constituents such as lenders, employees, customers, suppliers, competitors, government and society. Management develops goals and strategies which are consistent with the interests of these constituents and integrates their actions. Contrary to the wealth maximising focus in the finance theory, strategic management is multi-dimensional; it optimises a vector of objectives for attaining the firms legitimation. Thus, the focus of strategic management is on growth, profitability and flow of funds rather than on the maximisation of the market value of share. This focus helps management to create enough corporate wealth to achieve market dominance and the ultimate I. M. of the firm. successful survival Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed.,

Sustainable Growth

Financial goals are the quantitative expressions of a companys mission and strategy, and are set by its long-term planning system as a trade-off among conflicting and competing interests. In practice, the financial goals system boils down to the management of flow of funds. The objectives of growth and return can assume different priorities during the life cycle of a company. In operational terms, the financial goals of a company may be expressed as four key variables:

Target sales growth Target return on investment (net assets) Target dividend payout and Target debt-equity (capital structure)
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 6

Features of Financial Goals

In a study of twelve large American corporations, Donaldson has identified several characteristics of a companys financial goals system.

Companies are not always governed by the maximum profit criterion. Financial priorities change according to the changes in the economic and competitive environment. Competition sets the constraints within which a company can attain its goals. Managing a companys financial goals system is a continuous process of balancing different priorities in a manner that the demand for and supply of funds is reconciled. A change in any goal cannot be effected without considering the effect on other goals. Financial goals are changeable and unstable, and therefore, managers find it difficult to understand and accept the financial goals system.
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 7

Sustainable Growth

Corporate managers in India consider the following four financial goals as the most important: Ensuring fund availability Maximising growth Operating profit before interest and taxes Return on investment

I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas.

Shareholder Value Creation

The value of a firm is the market value of its assets which is reflected in the capital markets through the market values of equity and debt.
Shareholder value = Market value of the firm Market value of debt

I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas.

Methods of Shareholder Value

The first method, called the Free Cash Flow Method, uses the weighted average cost of debt and equity (WACC) to discount free cash flows. FCF PBIT (1 T ) DEP ONCI NWC CAPEX When the value of a firm or a business over a planning horizon is calculated, then an estimate of the terminal cash flows or value (TV) will also be made:
Economic value = PV of net operating cash flows (NOCF) + PV of terminal value

FCF do not include financing (leverage) effect, and therefore, they are unlevered or ungeared cash flows. The weighted average cost of capital (WACC) includes after-tax cost of debt. Hence the financing I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., effect is incorporated in WACC rather than cash 10 Vikas. flows.

Methods of Shareholder Value

Second method calculates the economic value of a firm or business in to two parts: Value of a levered firm = Value of unlevered firm + Value of interest tax shield Steps Estimate the firms unlevered cash flows and terminal value. Determine the unlevered cost of capital (ku). Discount the unlevered cash flows and the terminal value by the unlevered cost of capital. Calculate the present value of the interest tax shield discounting at the cost of debt. Add these two values to obtain the levered firms total value. Subtract the value of debt from the total value to obtain the value of the firms shares. Divide the value of shares by the number of shares to obtain the economic value per share.
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 11

Methods of Shareholder Value

The third method for determining the shareholder economic value is to calculate the value of equity by discounting cash flows available to shareholders by the cost of equity.
Equity cash flows FCF + INT(1 T )

I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas.


Market Value Added

In terms of market and book values of shareholder investment, shareholder value creation (SVC) may be defined as the excess of market value over book value. SVC is also referred to as the market value added (MVA): Market value added = Market value invested capital (capital employed)
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas.


Market-to-Book Value (M/B)

An alternative measure of shareholder value creation: Market value of equity = Market value of the firm Market value of debt The market-to-book value (M/B) analysis implies the following:

Value creation If M/B > 1, the firm is creating value of shareholders. Value maintenance If M/B = 1, the firm is not creating value of shareholders. Value destruction If M/B < 1, the firm is destroying value of shareholders.
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 14

Market-to-Book Value (M/B)

We obtain M/B equation as follows:

M ROE g = B ke g

The following are the determinants of the M/B ratio:

Economic profitability or spread Growth Investment period

I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas.


Accounting Measures of Performance

Accounting measures, like earnings or return on investment, however, have several problems:

They are based on arbitrary assumptions and policies and have scope for easy manipulability. Profits can be affected by changing depreciation methods, inventory valuations methods or allocating costs as revenue or capital expenditures without any change in true profitability. They could motivate managers to take short-term decisions at the cost of long-term profitability of the company. Managers could reduce R&D expenditure or expenditure of building the staff capability to bolster short-term profitability. This would happen more in those companies where the compensations of managers are based on short-term earnings.
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 16

Accounting Measures of Performance

They do not reflect true profitability of the firm. Earnings are not cash flows. No distinction is made for the timing of earnings. Thus, earnings measures ignore time value of money and risk. The most serious problem with accounting measures is that they might destroy shareholders wealth. A manager can increase earnings by undertaking investment projects that have positive returns but negative net present value. In other words, these projects earn returns less than the cost of capital. They would increase earnings but destroy shareholders wealth. Shareholders are not interested in growth in earnings rather they would like their wealth to increase through positive NPV I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., projects. 17 Vikas.

Economic Value Added (EVA)

Economic value added PAT Charges for equity PAT Cost of equity Equity capital

Economic value added is a measure which goes beyond the rate of return and considers the cost of capital also. Economic value added, economic profit or residual income is defined as net earnings (PAT) in excess of the charges (cost) for shareholders invested capital (equity):

The firm is said to have earned economic return (ER) if its return on equity (ROE) exceeds the cost Economic return = ROE COE of equity (COE):
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 18


EVA can be calculated for divisions and even projects. EVA is a measure that gauges performance over a period of time rather than at a point of time. EVA is a flow variable and depends on the ongoing and future operations of the firm or divisions. MVA, on the other hand, is a stock variable. EVA is not bound by the Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP). As we discuss below, appropriate adjustment are made to calculate EVA. This removes arbitrariness and scope for manipulations that is quite common in the accounting-based measures. EVA is a measure of the firms economic profit. Hence, it influences Management, 9th related to the firms and is ed., I. M. Pandey, Financial 19 Vikas. value.

EVA Adjustments

Impaired or Non-performing Assets Research and Development Deferred Tax Provisions LIFO Valuation of Inventory Goodwill Leases Restructuring charges
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 20

Evaluation of M/B and EVA

Both M/B and EVA approaches focus on economic profitability rather than on accounting profitability. Both the approaches are an improvement over the traditional accounting measures of performance. But both do suffer from the limitation that they are partially based on accounting numbers.
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 21

Value Drivers

Drivers of EVA or Value based on the Discounted Cash Flow Approach:

Revenue enhancement Cost reduction Asset utilisation Cost of capital reduction

I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas.


Corporate Governance

Corporate governance implies that the company would manage its affairs with diligence, transparency, responsibility and accountability, and would maximise shareholder wealth. Companies are needed to at least have policies and practices in conformity with the requirements stipulated under Clause 49 of the Listing Agreement. Board of Directors The Board of Directors should be composed of Executive and Non-Executive Directors meeting the requirement of the Code of Corporate Governance.
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 23

Corporate Governance

Audit Committee The appointment of the Audit Committee is mandatory, and its a very powerful instrument of ensuring good governance in the financial matters Shareholders/Investors Grievance Committee As a part of corporate governance, companies should form a Shareholders/Investors Grievance Committee under the Chairmanship of a non-executive independent director.
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 24

Corporate Governance

Remuneration Committee The company may appoint a Remuneration Committee to decide the remuneration and other perks etc. of the CEO and other senior management officials as the Companies Act and other relevant provisions. Management Analysis Management is required to make full disclosure of all material information to investors.
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 25

Corporate Governance

Communication The quarterly, half-yearly and annual financial results of the Company must be sent to the Stock Exchanges immediately after they have been taken on record by the Board. Auditors Certificate on Corporate Governance The external auditors are required to give a certificate on the compliance of corporate governance requirements.
I. M. Pandey, Financial Management, 9th ed., Vikas. 26